Sammatitarka Prakaranam Part 1

Author(s): Siddhasen Divakarsuri, Kirtiyashsuri
Publisher: Sanmarg Prakashan
Catalog link: https://jainqq.org/explore/002563/1

Page #1
W saMgatitarkaprakaraNam bhAga-1 prAcInavibhAgaH granthakarttAraH zrutakevali-mahAdArzanikaziromaNipUjyAcArya zrIsiddhasenadivAkarasUrIzvarAH mUlaTIkAkArAH tarkapaJcAnanapUjyAcArya zrImadabhayadevasUrIzvarAH anye TIkAkArAH samarthazAstrakAraziromaNipUjyAcArya zrIharibhadrasUrIzvarAH pUjyamahAmahopAdhyAyazrIyazovijayagaNivarAH tadanyamahApuruSAzca sampAdakA: pravanacanaprabhAvakapUjyapAdAcAryazrImadvijayakIrtiyazasUrIzvarAH

Page #2
pU.A.zrIvijayarAmacandrasUrismRti-saMskRta-prAkRtagranthamAlA - kramAGka-25 saMmatitarkaprakaraNam bhAga-1 [ prAcInavibhAgaH ] [ pUrvAcAryaviracitavRttisamanvitam ] -: granthakartAraH :zrutakevali-mahAdArzanikaziromaNi-duSSamAnizAdivAkarakalpa pUjyAcAryazrIsiddhasenadivAkarasUrIzvarAH ___-: mUlaTIkAkArAH :tarkapaJcAnanapUjyAcAryazrImadabhayadevasUrIzvarA: _____-: anye TIkAkArAH :samarthazAstrakAraziromaNipUjyAcAryazrIharibhadrasUrIzvarAH pUjyamahAmahopAdhyAyazrIyazovijayagaNivarA: tadanyamahApuruSAzca -: sampAdakAH :tapAgacchAdhipatipUjyapAdAcAryazrImadvijayarAmacandrasUrIzvarANAM paTTaprabhAvakavardhamAnataponidhipUjyapAdAcAryazrImadvijayaguNayazasUrIzvarANAM caraNacaJcarIkAH pravacanaprabhAvakapUjyapAdAcAryazrImadvijayakIrtiyazasUrIzvarAH For Preate & Personas Use Only

Page #3
granthanAma : saMmatitarkaprakaraNam granthakartAraH : zrutakevalipUjyAcAryazrIsiddhasenadivAkarasUrIzvarAH mUlaTIkAkArAH : tarkapaJcAnanapUjyAcAryazrImadabhayadevasUrIzvarAH anye TIkAkArAH : samarthazAstrakAraziromaNipUjyAcAryazrIharibhadrasUrIzvarAH pUjyamahAmahopAdhyAyazrIyazovijayagaNivarA: anyamahApuruSAzca pArzvaprabhATIkAkArAH pU.A.zrImadvijayakIrtiyazasUrIzvarAH gurjarabhASAbhAvAnuvAdakArA: : pU.A.zrImadvijayakIrtiyazasUrIzvarAH sampAdakAH prakAzakam AvRttiH : pU.A. zrImadvijayakIrtiyazasUrIzvarAH : sanmArgaprakAzanam, ahamadAbAda. : prathamA- vi.saM. 2066, vi.saM. 2536, I.saM. 2009 pratayaH 700 mUlyam : rUpyakANi 125/ ISBN - 978-81-87163-58-9 | sUcanam | jJAnanidhivyayena mudrito'yaM grantho'to sampUrNa mUlyaM tatkSetre dattvaiva gRhasthaiH svAmitvamasya karaNIyaM suyogyaM vA zulkaM (nakaro) dattvaiSa paThanIyaH / - sanmArgaprakAzanam

Page #4
jainazAsana ziratAja vyAkhyAnavAcaspati dIkSAyugapravartaka - pa.pU. AcAryadeva zrImad vijaya rAmacaMdrasUrIzvarajI mahArAjA i n International 2010_02

Page #5
2010_02

Page #6
| Cii vardhamAnataponidhi pU.A.zrI vijaya guNayazasUrIzvarajI mahAzAjA A tejasvI tavArIkho ? saMsArI nAma : gagaladAsa voherA mAtA-pitA : saMjIbena svarUpacaMda voherA vatana : zrI bhorolatIrtha karmabhUmiH amadAvAda dharmapatnIH a.sau. jIvIbahena Adhabodha : pU.A.zrI.vijaya siddhisUrIzvarajI (bApajI) mahArAjA gudevA : pU.A.zrI vijaya rAmacaMdrasUrIzvarajI mahArAjA ziSya-praziSyo : 33, nizrAvartI zramaNoH 41 janma vi.saM. 1980 vaizAkha vada 3 bhorola tIrtha dIkSA vi.saM. 2023 poSa suda 14 murabADa tIrtha vaDI dIkSA vi.saM. 2023 mahA vada 10 muMbaI-lAlabAga gaNi vi.saM. 2050 kArataka suda 11 surata paMnyAsa vi.saM. 205ra vaizAkha suda 9 bhorola tIrtha upAdhyAya vi.saM. 205ra vaizAkha suda 9 bhorola tIrtha AcArya vi.saM. 205ra vaizAkha suda 7 bhorola tIrtha kALadharma vi.saM. 2065 Aso vada 4 muMbaI-lAlabAga Jain Education agnisaMskAra 10 02 vi.saM. 2065 For Private Aso vada pakuv muMbaI-vAlakezvara www.ain an org

Page #7
2010_02

Page #8
praHIRArIyA jainazAsana ziratAja , saMgha sanmArga darzaka, tapAgacchAdhirAja pUjyapAda AcAryadeva zrImad vijaya rAmacaMdrasUrIzvarajI mahArAjAe ATha-ATha dAyakA sudhI pravacana gaMgAnuM vaheNa vahevaDAvI bhAratabharanA bhavyone jinAjJA-marmanuM mahApradAna karyuM hatuM. tenA mULamAM teozrImade AjIvana karelI AgamAdi zrutanI apramatta upAsanA hatI. teozrImadanI Rtasiddhi ane zrutaviniyoganI hArdika anumodanAnA bIjarUpa teozrImanI puNyasmRtine avismaraNIya banAvavA kAje amoe teozrImadUnA maMtratulya nAma sAthe saMkaLAyela 'pU. A. zrI. vijaya rAmacaMdrasUrismRti saMskRta-prAkRta graMthamALA' prakAzita karavAno zubha nirNaya karyo hato. teozrImadnA paTTAlaMkAra, AjIvanagurucaraNasevI, suvizAla gacchAdhirAja pU.A.zrI vijaya mahodayasUrIzvarajI mahArAjAnA AzIrvAdathI A zreNImAM amo ThIka-ThIka AgaLa vadhI zakyA hatA. vardhamAna taponidhi pU.A.zrI vijaya guNayazasUrIzvarajI mahArAjanI chatrachAyA ane teozrInA ziSyapravara pravacana-prabhAvaka pU.A. zrI vijaya kIrtiyazasUrIzvarajI mahArAjAnA zAstrIya mArgadarzanane pAmI vividha zruta-sevI munivaro Adi dvArA taiyAra karAyela vividha viSayanA pratAkAra temaja pustakAkAra aneka graMtho chapAyA bAda A ja zreNInA 25mA puSpa tarIke "saMmatitarkaprakaraNam bhAga-1' graMtharatnanuM prakAzana karatAM amane savizeSa AnaMdanI anubhUti thaI rahI che. parama yogIzvarazrI arihaMtaprabhu ane temanA AjJAzAsananA vartatA pratyeka sUri-vAcaka-sAdhuvaMdanA anugraha temaja zAsanadevonI zubha sahAyathI samyagdarzanane nirmaLa karanArA AvA vadhune vadhu dArzanika graMthonA prakAzanamAM ame nimittarUpa banIe evI bhAvanA bhAvavA sAthe sahu koI adhikArI banI AvA zrutaratnonA abhyasana dvArA paramAtmA zrI arihaMta devonA yogasAmrAjyanA svAmI banI zAzvata sukharUpa mokSane pAme e ja zubhakAmanA. - sabhA prakAzana Jain Edth International 2016 | mI .

Page #9
lAbhArthI - -- -- saMbhA) prakAzIta dvArA Ayojita pUjyapAda AcArya zrI vijaya rAmacaMdrasUri-mRti-saMskRta-prAkRta graMthamALAnA 2pamA puSparUpe prakAzita thatA pUrvAcArya maharSikRta vRttiothI suzobhita zrutakevali pUjyapAda, hA AcAryavarya zrI siddhasenadivAkarasUri mahArAjA racita saMmatitaoprazvara 2, zeTha zrI kasturacaMda mUvAjI sahaparivAra sthApita zrI mahAvIrasvAmI jaina zvetAMbara mUrtipUjaka daherAsara, (khetavADI jaina saMgha), 9mI khetavADI, muMbaInA jJAnavidhinA sadupayoga dvArA prakAzita thayo che. - jenI paNa amo hArdika anumodanA karIe chIe ane bhaviSyamAM paNa teonA hAthe uttarottara uttama kakSAnI zrutabhakti thatI rahe evI zubhakAmanA karIe chIe. janmA pradAna Person

Page #10
jeonA sAdhanApUta puNya prabhAve A graMtharatnanuM sarjana-saMpAdana thayuM teonA parama pavitra karakamaLomAM zraddhAsabhara hRdaye samarpaNam 9 mArI ati nAnI vayathI ja jeozrIe mane zrI namaskAra mahAmaMtranuM zravaNa karAvyuM. 9 jarAka samajaNo thayo eTale "saMsAra kevo ? khAro-khAro', ane mokSa kevo ? mITho-mITho' samajAvyo. * cAra varSanI uMmare AyaMbila karato karyo; pUjA, pratikramaNa, A sAmAyika, pAThazALAno vyasanI banAvyo. je vacanasiddha pU.A.zrI vijaya siddhisUrIzvarajI (bApajI) mahArAjAnA khoLAmAM mAruM samarpaNa karyuM. * 'ApaNe dIkSA ja levAnI che tevA saMskAra daDhamULa karyA. * pU. bApajI mahArAjAno kALadharma thatAM teozrImadbhA AdarzonA sAcA vArasadAra vyAkhyAnavAcaspati pU.A.zrI vijaya rAmacaMdrasUrIzvarajI mahArAjAno mane bheTo karAvI Apyo. - janmathI aMtima samaya sudhI... mA karatAM ya vadhu vAtsalya ApyuM, bApa tarIke kaDaka anuzAsana karyuM, guru tarIke gurunAM kartavyo adA karavAmAM kyAreya pAchI pAnI na karI potAnA svArthonuM visarjana karI mane parama gurudevanI sevAmAM joDyo.. 86 varSanI jaipha vaye paNa TaTTAra besI, aneka rogonI sAme jhIMka jhIlI japa-yoga, svAdhyAya yoga ane parama samAdhimAM jhIlatA rahI jeoe mAruM ane mArA ziSyapraziSyAdi gaNanuM akhaMDa yogakSema karyuM che, te svanAmadhanya, AjIvanagurucaraNasevI, niHspRhamUrti, vIzasthAnakatapaprabhAvaka, vardhamAnataponidhi pUjyapAda AcAryadeva zrImad vijaya guNayazasUrIzvarajI mahArAjAnA pAvana karakamaLomAM saMmatitarka bhAga-1 graMtharatnanuM samarpaNa karI dhanya banuM chuM. - vijaya kIrtiyazasUri 201002 For Private elinary org

Page #11
guru AvA jagatamAM nahi maLe re gauravavaMtA gurudeva pUjya AcAryadeva zrImad vijaya guNayazasUrIzvarajI mahArAjA ! jaina zAsana ziratAja, dIkSAyuga pravartaka, tapAgacchAdhirAja, bhAvAcArya bhagavaMta zrImad vijaya rAmacaMdrasUrIzvarajI mahArAjAnA teozrIjI paramavinayI ziSyaratna hatA. vardhamAna taponidhi eonuM mukhya birUda hatuM; paraMtu vardhamAna birUdAvalIthI navAjIe to paNa alpokita thAya evA vardhamAna guNagaNothI bharapUra eonuM jIvana hatuM, te pUjyapAda AcAryadeva zrImad vijaya guNayazasUrIzvarajI mahArAjA hatA. gujarAtanA vAyavya khUNe tharAdanI pAse AveluM bhorola tIrtha emanuM vatana hatuM. vAva, tharAda, sAMcora jevI aitihAsika nagarIothI gherAyeluM A tIrtha eka jamAnAmAM pippalapura pattana agara pippalAnaka nAme mahAnagara hatuM. pAsenuM DhImA tIrtha evuM upanagara hatuM. seMkaDo koTipati zreSThio atre vasatA. aneka jinamaMdirothI nagarI bharI bharI hatI. kALanI thapATa vAgatAM badhuM vera-vikhera thayuM. aneka pratimAjI bhUmimAM birAjI devagaNathI pUjAtA rahyA. vi.saM. 1961mAM bhorola bhUminA bhAgyavidhAtA bhagavAna zrI neminAtha prabhu svayaMbhU pragaTatAM bhUminAM bhAgya palaTAyAM. kramasara unnati thavA lAgI. saMghe suMdara jinAlaya banAvI prabhune padharAvatAM bhAvonI vRddhi thatAM ghara-gharamAM prazasta dravyanI paNa vRddhi thavA lAgI. vi.saM. 1980mAM pAlItANAnA zrI AdIzvaradAdAnI pratiSThAnA zubha dine eTale ja vai.va. 6nA sejIbAInI kUkhathI nAnakaDA bALakano janma thayo. pitA svarUpacaMdane vadhAmaNA maLatAM AnaMda thayo. bALakane navakAra saMbhaLAvAyo. dAdA zrI nemanAthanA darzana-pUjana karAvAyAM. be eka varSa pitAnuM vAtsalya meLavyA bAda pitA jyAre devalokanI vATe saMcarI gayA tyAre bALaka gagaladAsa te ghaTanAne samajI paNa zakatuM na hatuM. kAkA gamAnacaMde jALavI moTA karyA. dharmanA saMskAra ApyA. e kAkA comAsI pratikramaNa karIne AvyA bAda kALotarA sarpe DaMkha mAratAM namaskAra mahAmaMtranA smaraNapUrvaka svargavAsI banyA hatA. 2010_02

Page #12
gurudevanuM jIvana caritra gagaladAsanuM prAthamika zikSaNa bhorola tIrthamAM thayuM. yuvAna thayA bAda temaNe amadAvAda AvavAnuM nakkI karyuM. bhorolanI bhUmi ane bhagavAna zrI nemanAthanI bhakti choDavI na hatI. paNa vyavahArika javAbadArIone pUrI karavA mATe bIjo IlAja na dekhAtAM bhagavAnane bheTI prayANa karyuM. rAjanagaramAM AvI bhADAnI jagyA lIdhI. vyAya-nItithI dhaMdho karyo. kApaDanI pherI ane lArI karI. AgaLa jatAM potAnI dukAna paNa karI. prAmANikatA ane dilanI cophakhAIthI vepArIonA temaja grAhakonA mAnItA banyA. A gALAmAM paramAtmAnA darzana-pUjA, guruvaMdana-pUjana-pravacana zravaNa vagere AcAro jALavI rAkhyA. upAzraye-upAzraye phare. dareka sAdhu bhagavaMtonAM pravacano sAMbhaLe. ghare bolAvI vahorAve. aMgata paricaya karI bhaktino lAbha le. paNa emanI parIkSaka dRSTi sAdhu tatvane gotatI rahe. rAjanagaranA aneka upAzrayomAM pharI vaLyA bAda vidyAzALe birAjamAna pU.A.zrI vijaya siddhisUrIzvarajI mahArAjAmAM emanuM mana TharyuM. Adarza sAdhutA ahIM dekhANI. emaNe manomana samarpaNa karI dIdhuM. have pratyeka bAbatamAM teo gurvAjJA meLavI pravartavA lAgyA. A arasAmAM rAmapurAnA hakamacaMda kevalacaMda voharAnA zIlavatI-rUpavatI kanyA jIvIbena joDe emanAM lagna levANAM. dAMpatya jIvana zarU thayuM. gagalabhAInuM mana saMsAra tarapha ochuM ane saMyama tarapha vadhu hatuM. zrAvaka jIvanane zobhAve tevA upadhAnAdi tapo karyA. rAtribhojana, abhakSyabhakSaNa jevAM pApone to kyArano dezavaTo ApI dIdhelo. ekavAra nagarazeThanA vaDe pU.A.zrI vijaya labdhisUrIzvarajI mahArAjAnI nizrAmAM pU.A.zrI vijaya rAmacaMdrasUrijI mahArAjAnuM pravacana sAMbhaLI mAMhalyo jAgI UThyo. jIvananI dizA nakkI karI lIdhI. vi.saM. 2006mAM pAlItANA cAturmAsa karyuM. rahyA hatA AgamamaMdiramAM paNa tyAMnA mahAtmAnI saMmatithI pU.A.zrI vijaya premasUrIzvarajI mahArAjAnI nizrAmAM pU.A.zrI vijaya rAmacaMdrasUrijI mahArAjAnAM thatAM pravacano sAMbhaLavA roja narazInAthA dharmazALAe jatA. A pravacanoe vairAgyane jvalaMta banAvI dIdho. manomana ghaNA nirNayo laI lIdhA. savizeSa tapa dharmamAM joDAI gayA. vi.saM. 2008mAM putra kAMtilAlano janma thayo. janma bAda navakAranI bheTa ApI. putra samajaNo thayo. tyArathI mA putramohathI enuM ahita na karI de enI kALajI rAkhI, sAthe ne sAthe rAkhatA, tapa karAvatA. tapa paLAya enuM dhyAna rAkhatA. pU.A.zrI siddhisUrijI (bApajI) mahArAjA sAthe putranuM paNa bhAvanAtmaka joDANa karI ApyuM. Adarza jIvana ghaDavaiyA banI putramAM uccattara vidyAonuM AdhAna karyuM. 2010_02

Page #13
gurudevanuM jIvana caritra mana have saMyama mATe thanaganatuM hatuM. svajana-parivAranI rajA mAMgI. samajavA koI taiyAra na hatuM. khUba virodha UThyo. gagalabhAIe paNa virodhane khALavA ugratara tapa, tyAga ane abhigraho karavA mAMDyo. 12-12 varSa sudhI mULathI ghIno tyAga karyo. vardhamAna tapanI oLIno pAyo nAMkhyo. uparA uparI oLIo karavA lAgyA. mAtra eka-be dravyanI oLIo karI. pAraNe chaThThuM ane enA pAraNe bhAta-pANI ke roTalI-pANInA AyaMbilo. varSo sudhI A krama cAlyo. cha vigaIo sadaMtara mULathI baMdha karI. ene ya 6-6 varSo vItyAM. svajanoe dAda na ApI. have aMtima taiyArI rUpe putrane skUla choDAvI. gurudeva pAse vihAramAM mUkyo. dhaMdhAnI javAbadArI potAnA pitarAI bhAI-bhatrIjAne soMpI ane vi.saM. 2023nI sAlamAM poSa mahine e amadAvAdathI bhAgI nIkaLyA. aneka kalyANa mitrono sAtha-sahakAra maLyo. muMbaI-murabADa AvyA. pU.gurudeva vihAra karIne tyAM AvI cUkyA hatA. putra kAMtine to pahelethI ja tyAM mokalI Apyo hato. pAMca divasano maMgala mahotsava thayo. kalyANa mitra parivAroe svajanono rola evo bhajavyo ke prAya: koIne khyAla na Avyo ke A gupta dIkSA che. po.su. 13nA pU. gurudevanI dIkSAtithi ujavAI ane po.su. 14nA e ja gurudeve pitAputrane dIkSAnAM dAna karyA. potAnA ziSya-praziSyarUpe pU.mu. zrI guNayazavijayajI mahArAja ane pU.mu. zrI kIrtiyazavijayajI mahArAja nAma rakhAyAM. hitazikSA ApI. ApelA nAmono paramArtha samajAvyo. baMne pitA-putra guru-ziSya munivare guruzIkhane nakhazIkha avatAravAno nirNaya karyo. have baMne pU. gurudevanI sevAmAM joDAI gayA. parivArano moTo virodha guru prabhAve vilAI gayo. rAjIkhuzIthI bhUlezvara lAlabAga, muMbaI khAte vaDIdIkSA thaI. pitAmuni savizeSa tapamAM ane putramuni adhyayanamAM lAgI gayAM. baMnee sva-sva kSetre kAThuM kADhyuM. pU.mu. zrI guNayazavijayajI mahArAje je rIte putra muninuM bALapaNathI saMskaraNa kareluM e pU. gurudevathI chAnuM na hatuM. te kaLA joI emaNe potAnI pAse jANavA-rahevA AvatA mumukSuone temane soMpavA mAMDyA. mAtra eka ja varSanA paryAyamAM A javAbadArI maLI, je temaNe sAMgopAMga nIbhAvI guruno vizvAsa sArthaka karyo. pU. gurudeva khUba saMtRpta thayA. A ja rIte prAraMbhika varSomAM pU. gurudevanI atyaMtara mAMDalImAM rahI eozrInI tamAma sevA-vaiyAvacca Adino bhAra pitAmunizrInA vRSabha skaMdho para mUkAyo. e paNa emaNe sAMgopAMga pAra pADyo. vaiyAvacca sahelI nathI. emAM ya AvA TocanI kakSAnA gurudevanI vaiyAvacca karavI hoya to tana-mananI ghaNI sajjatA joIe. pU. munizrIe e sajjatA keLavI ane pU. gurudevane temaja gacchane apAra saMtoSa Apyo. A guNanA kAraNe emano jhaDapI AtmavikAsa thayo. tapa-japamAM to agrima hatA. have AdhyAtmika pariNatio, 2010_02

Page #14
gurudevanuM jIvana caritra svarUpAnusaMdhAna, saMyamarati, mokSanI tAlAvelI AdimAM teo agresara banyA. AvI guNAvalI teomAM sahaja rIte Atmastha banI. 9 emaNe saMskRtano ya abhyAsa karyo. aneka mumukSuo ane munivarone bhaNAvatAM-bhaNAvatAM jAte ya bhaNavAno puruSArtha karatA. pariNAme saMskRta buko thayA bAda aDhaLaka graMtho temaNe vAMcI lIdhAM. pU. gurudeva jIvyA tyAM sudhI emano paDachAyo banIne jIvyA. 24 varSa sudhI akhaMDa gurukuLavAsa sevI apAra nirjarA karI. vi.saM. 2047mAM aSADha vada 14nA pU. gurudevanA paramasamAdhimaya kALadharmathI teo bhAMgI paDyA hatA. guNAnuvAda sabhAmAM raDI paDyA hatA. guruviraha khamavo emanA mATe AsAna na hatuM. emaNe tapasvI samrATa pU.A.zrI rAjatilakasUrijI mahArAja ane potAnA vaDIla gurubaMdhu gacchAdhipati pU.A.zrI.vijaya mahodayasUrijI mahArAjAnuM sAMnidhya jALavI manane manAvyuM. pU. gurudevanA virahamAM pU. gurudevanA pravacana pustakonuM AlaMbana laI manane vALyuM. anekavAra ekanuM eka pustaka vAMcyuM. emane jANe potAnA khovAyelA gurudeva e pustakonA pAne maLI gayA. emano rojano krama banI gayo. prakAzanuM paheluM kiraNa Ave ke hAthamAM pravacana pustakanI sthApanA thatI ane sAMjanA aMtima kiraNe e pustaka bAju para mukAtuM. pU. gurudevane emaNe jeTalAM vAMcyA haze teTalAM zAyada koIe nahi vAMcyA hoya ! pU. gurudeve zAsananA anekAneka kAryonI javAbadArI putramuni para nAMkhelI. pU.mu. zrI kIrtiyazavijayajI mahArAja have rojidAM pravacano paNa karatA; pU. gurudevanI atyaMtara parSadAmAM birAjI zAsananA kAryomAM masalata paNa karatA, saMmelananA virodhanI sabhAomAM pU. gurudeve hukamanA pattArUpe emane pravacano karavAnI javAbadArI soMpelI. pU.mu.zrI guNayazavijayajI mahArAja putramuninuM rakhopuM hatA. emanuM jatana karatA. avasare emanA kAmo pAra pADIne paNa emane zAsana sevA mATe nizrcita rAkhatA. pU. gurudevanI kRpA gaMgA banIne A beya pitA-putra munivaro para avirata vahetI hatI. emanI yogyatA joI suratamAM vi.saM. 2050nI sAlamAM samudAyanA vaDIla tapasvIsamrAT pU.A.zrI vijaya rAjatilakasUrIzvarajI mahArAjA tathA gacchAdhipati pU.A.zrI vijaya mahodayasUrIzvarajI mahArAjAe emane gaNipadathI alaMkRta karyA. pU. bApajI mahArAjAnA bhAvavArasadAra baMne sAdhako pU. bApajI mahArAjAnI jema ja suratamAM gaNipade ArUDha thayA. gurubhaktoe tyAre jinabhaktino mahAmahotsava karyo hato. baMne pitA-putranA zAstrIya mArgadarzanathI emanA sAMsArika vatana zrI bhorolatIrthanA zrIsaMghe pU. gurudevanA AziSa ane vAsakSepa meLavIne tIrthanA jinAlayano bhavyAtibhavya uddhAra karyo. covIza jinAlaya banyuM. enI pratiSThA paNa pU. gurudeve ApelA saMketAnusAra vi.saM. 2052mAM nakkI thaI. 2010_02

Page #15
10 gurudevanuM jIvana caritra A mahotsave vaDIloe baMne gaNivarone paMnyAsapadathI alaMkRta karavAno nirNaya karelo. paraMtu emanI paramAtma bhakti, gurubhakti ane samudAya bhaktimAMthI sarjAyela puNya acAnaka vAyaro palaTAtAM paMnyAsapada uparAMta pAThaka ane sUripada lakSmIthI teone alaMkRta karavAno nirNaya karAyo. vai.su. nA paMnyAsa ane pAThaka padavI thaI ane zrI nemanAthadAdA gAdIe beThA tyAre vai.sa. 7nA sumuhUrte hajAronI medanI ane lAkhkho rUpiyAnI uchAmaNIonA mAholamAM baMne pitA-putro sUripadathI zobhAyamAna banyA. vaDIloe hitazikSA ApI ke pU. gurudevanA samudAyanA gauravane vadhAranArA banajo ! 'tahatti' kahIne svIkRta karAyelAM e hitavacanone jIvanabhara AbAda nIbhAvyAM. sva jIvanamAM jIvI jANyAM. vi.saM. 2051nI sAlathI vardhamAna taponidhi sUridevazrIjInI nizrAmAM putrasUrijInA svataMtra cAturmAso thavA lAgyAM. amadAvAda-surata-muMbaI ane pAlItANAmAM cAturmAso thayAM. zeSakALamAM cheka giranArajIthI laI rAjasthAnanA nAkoDAjI sudhI ane mahArASTramAM pUnA-nAsikanA paTTAmAM ya vicaraNa karyuM. chellI zakti pahoMcI tyAM sudhI teo cAlatA rahyA. zarIre sAtha ApavAno baMdha karatAM DolIno sahAro levo paDyo. paNa emano tapa, tyAga, svAdhyAya, japa ane AvanAra hara koIne saMsAra tyAga karI saMyamI banI javAnI ja ekamAtra hitazikSAnuM dAna AmAM koI phera na paDyo. vAtsalyanA teo mahAsAgara hatA. anuzAsanamAM teo avvala hatA. koInI ya nAnakaDI ya bhUla calAvatA nahi. nAnakaDA ya guNane biradAvyA vinA rahetA nahi. emanAmAM emanA pU. gurudevano vAraso pratiphaLa banIne avataryo hato. jayaNA emane varelI hatI. upayoga emano atyaMta tAjo hato. najara chellA divasa sudhI sateja hatI. pAMce Indriyo akabaMdha ane prazasta banelI hatI. pramAda emaNe karyo nahi ane pramAdane emaNe gAMDyo paNa nahi. emanuM dhAreluM hitakara kArya e karIne ja rahetA. mAtra 16 varSa jeTalA jAhera jIvanamAM emanA hAthe 100 jeTalA puNyAtmA dIkSita banyA. bIjA 100 jeTalA emanI preraNAthI vairAgI banI anyatra dIkSita banyA haze ! 70 jeTalA gRhamaMdironI pAvana pratiSThA emaNe karI. emanA parivAramAMthI 26 puNyAtmAonI dIkSA thaI, gAma-pathakamAMthI 33 puNyAtmAo saMsArane alavidA karI cAlI nIkaLyA. dasa jeTalA to cha-rI pAlaka saMgho nIkaLyA, jenA dvArA aDhaLaka zAsana prabhAvanA thaI hatI. 12 zikharabaddha jinAlayonI teozrInI varada haste aMjana-pratiSThAo thaI. sAte kSetramAM emanA upadezathI karoDonuM dravya vaparAyuM. moTI moTI uchAmaNIomAM emanI pradhAna nizrA rahetI. zrI bhorolatIrtha temaja smRtimaMdira aMjana pratiSThAnI uchAmaNI, sametazikharajI taleTI tIrtha, lAlabAga bhUlezvara jinAlaya aMjana pratiSThAnA caDAvA vagere emAMnAM AMkhe uDIne vaLage evA keTalAka dAkhalA che. 2010 02

Page #16
gurudevanuM jIvana caritra jIrAvalA tIrthanA navatara punaruddhArano saMketa teozrInI tapa-japathI pavitra nizrAmAM ja prApta thayelo. nAkoDA tIrthe dazakAomAM pahelI vahelI caitrI oLImAM paNa teozrIe nizrAdAna kareluM. bhUkaMpa ke relanA prasaMge anukaMpA-jIvadayAmAM paNa karoDo rUpiyA teo zrImadgI pAvana nizrAmAM vaparAyA hatA. emanA kalyANa mitrone e roja yAda karatA. emane mArge lAvavA, saMyamapaMthe caDAvavA khUba prayatnazIla rahetA. e mATe patro paNa lakhatA. saMsArIone saMsAra kIcaDamAMthI bahAra kADhavA teo satata puruSArtharatA hatA. pratyakSa preraNA, patra dvArA hitopadeza karavAmAM e na thAkatA. emanI nizrAmAM ATha to upadhAna thayAM. Azare 5000 puNyAtmAoe upadhAna ArAdhyAM. karoDonI pratyeka sthaLe Avaka thaI. hastagiri tIrtha mATe teozrInA upadezathI karoDo rUpiyA apAyA hatA. tyAM bIjA gaDhe covIza jina-gaNadhara pagalAMnI mahAkAya covIza derIonA nirmANa-aMjanapratiSThAmAM paNa teozrInI nizrA-mArgadarzana maLyAM hatAM. potAnA prANapyArA pU. gurudevanI 17 jeTalI pratimAonI emaNe pratiSThA karAvI hatI. emano prabhuprema, gurubhaktino umaLako, jayaNAnuM lakSya, jvalaMta vairAgya, nakhazIkha cAritrapAlana, nirmalatara zraddhA ane karaNAbhilASa, aMtima vayamAM paNa tapano pracaMDa puruSArtha, savi jIva karuM dIkSArasInI utkaTa bhAvanA ane tadanusArI prayatna vagere vagere guNonI yAdI eTalI moTI che ke e eka eka guNane varNavavA mATe ya pAnAnAM pAnAM ochAM paDe. jIvanamAM anekavAra siddhitapa, zreNitapa ane varSItapa jevA mahAtapo karyA, apramattapaNe mAsakSamaNa, vIzasthAnaka jevA tapo ArAdhyAM to soLa-daza-aneka aThThAIo, viziSTa abhigrahapUrvaka vardhamAna tapanI 100 + 23 oLIo ArAdhI ane tapAvalImAM batAvelAM nAnAmoTA aneka tapone karIne e sAcA arthamAM vardhamAna taponidhi banyA hatA. chelluM comAsuM teozrIe muMbaI-lAlabAga (bhUlezvara)mAM kareluM. ahIM bALadIkSA-siddhAMtanI surakSA ane atrenA jinAlayanI pratiSThA mATe eonuM Agamana thayuM hatuM. bALadIkSAnI surakSAnuM mahAna kArya teozrInA AlaMbane khUba ja zreSThatama rIte saMpanna thayuM hatuM. pratiSThA mATenI uchAmaNIo paNa AkAzane AMbavArI banI. have thoDo ja samaya bAkI hato tyAM emaNe jIvananI bAjI sameTavAno prAraMbha karI dIdho hato. aMtima cAturmAsa daramyAna emanuM svAthya kathaLeluM hatuM. chatAM ya emaNe emano nitya ArAdhanA krama choDyo na hato. atyaMta upayogapUrvaka badhI ja ArAdhanAmAM teo otaprota rahyA. roja devavaMdana, upakArI guru bhagavaMtanI chabI AgaLa bRhad guruvaMdana, navasmaraNAdi stotronuM vAMcana, sUrimaMtra, gaNividyAnI samArAdhanA, gurudata aneka maMtrapadonuM pArAyaNa-dhyAna, AzritonuM satata yogakSema, darzana karavA AvatA zrAvaka-zrAvikA vargane eka mAtra dharmalAbhanA AzIrvAdanuM dAna, dIkSA levA mATe yogya 2010_02

Page #17
12 gurudevanuM jIvana caritra jaNAyelA zrAvaka-zrAvikAone hitazikSA ane preraNA karatA patronuM lekhana, putra sUrideva para zAsananA kAryo aMge vidha-vidha sUcano, potAnI samatA ane samAdhi akabaMdha rahe evuM adbhuta Ayojana, samAdhi prabaLa sahAyaka evuM potAnA gurudevanAM pravacanonuM niyamita kalAko sudhInuM vAMcana, enA upayogI aMzonI noMdha karI putra sUrivarane prakAzanArthe bhalAmaNa, tapasvI munivaronI upabRhaNA ane kALajI, dUra sudUra rahelA sAdhvI saMghanA yogakSemanI bhalAmaNa jevAM aDhaLaka Atma hitakara kAryomAM teo kartavyaniSTha banyA rahyA. cikitsako AvatA to cikitsA karavA detA. paraMtu cikitsakane kahetA ke, mArI samAdhi mATe sahayoga ApuM chuM, tame mArI dravya cikitsA karo cho, huM tamArI bhAva cikitsA karavA IcchuM chuM. tame tamArI lADa kyAre mArA hAthamAM Apo cho ? ahIM kyAre Avo cho ?" A emanI karuNA hatI. karuNAnI saritA vahetI vahetI have khaLakhaLa gaMgA banI have mahAsAgaramAM bhaLavA adhIrI thaI rahI hatI. aMtima divasa paNa AvI gayo. Aje paNa sUrijIe rAtre aDhI vAgyAthI pAMca vAgyAno nitya jApa pUrNa karyo. prAbhAtika smaraNo gaNyAM. prabhujI padhAryA to UbhA thaI vinaya karyo. prabhujIne pradakSiNA ApI. UbhAM UbhAM devavaMdana karyuM. khamAsamaNAM pUMjIne pramArjIne ja ApyAM. samyagdarzana pustakano svAdhyAya karyo. vyAkhyAnamAM javAnI bhAvanA vyakta karI. putra sUrijIne vyAkhyAnamAM jatAM ane vyAkhyAna karIne AvyA bAda be hAtha mAthe mUkIne AzIrvAda ApyA. hita vacano lakhI ApyAM. bAra, sADI bAra sudhI 'samyagdarzana' vAMcatA rahyA. pachI acAnaka svAgye vaLAMka lIdho. prezara vadhyuM. putrasUrideva tarata AvI gayA. paristhitine jANIne upacAra karAyA. upacAra kAragata na nIvaDatAM samAdhimAM sahAyaka padonuM zravaNa karAvAyuM. potAnA pU. gurudeva je arihaMta pada sAthe anusaMdhAna sAdhI muktinI dizAmAM prayANa karI gayA hatA. te ja arihaMta pada sAthe anusaMdhAna sAdhyuM. 'arihaMte saraNe pavanjAmi' nA nAdamAM ekatAna banyA. vacce vacce zrI zaMkhezvara pArzvanAtha prabhu ane zrI neminAtha prabhunI pratikRtinAM darzana karatAM palako namAvI darzana-vaMdana karyA. 'gurudeva ! Apa jAgRta cho ? jIvanabhara karelI ArAdhanAne sArthaka karavAno have avasara AvI gayo che vagere prazto pUchAtAM potAnA hAthanA AMgaLAthI ajapAjapa cAlu hovAnuM sUcana karyuM. pATIyAthI pavana nAMkhavAno prayatna thatAM be vAra sUcanA karI virAdhanA thatI aTakAvI. khUba ja samatAbharyA citte, sahaja samAdhimAM lIna thaIne bapore 3-20nA samaye teo kALadharmane pAmyA. Aso vada 4 guruvArano e divasa hato. putra-ziSya sUrijIno eka hAtha emanA mastaka para hato ane bIjo hAtha gurudevanA hAthamAM hato. eozrInA kALadharmanA samAcAre saunA hadayanA dhabakArA cakAyo. AghAtano pAra na 2010_02

Page #18
gurudevanuM jIvana caritra rahyo. caturvidha zrIsaMgha moTI saMkhyAmAM nirdhAmaNA karAvavA hAjara hato. e saue aMtima ArAdhanA najaronajara nIhALI hatI. DaoN. zekharabhAInA kahevA mujaba emanI DaoNkTarI lAIphamAM AvuM sahaja mRtyu koInuM ya joyuM na hatuM. eonA puNyadehane vAsakSepAdi aMtima vidhi karIne putrasUrijIe saMghane soMpyo. snAnAdi saMskAra thayA. zreSTha pUjA-upacAra karAyA. saMghanA darzana-pUjanArthe vyAkhyAna haoNlamAM padharAvAyA. saMghe lAIna baMdha AvIne pUjA karI. Aso vada 5+6 zukravAre agni saMskAranA caDAvA bolAvAyA. minITomAM ja traNa karoDa jeTalI Avaka thaI. jIvanabhara taddana ni:spRha sUrivaranA nicceSTa dehanA caraNe upakRta lokoe dhananA DhagalA karI dIdhA. dasa vAge aMtima yAtrA prAraMbhAI. nava zikharI jarIyana pAlakhImAM birAjelo deha bANagaMgA pahoMcyo. dhAnerAnA caMpAbena jayaMtilAla ajabANI temaja bhorolatIrthanA zAMtilAla harilAla mahetA parivAre agni saMskAra Apyo. pUjyapAdano puNyadeha paMcatvamAM vilIna thayo. pAchaLa devavaMdana ane guNAnuvAda thayA. bIjA divase lAlabAga saMghamAM bhavyatama guNAnuvAda sabhA thaI e prasaMge aSTAhnikA mahotsavanA lAbho meLavavA uchAmaNIo bolAI. daseka miniTamAM ja AThe divaso apAI gayA. pUjyonI nizrAmAM kA.su. 14 thI aSTAhnikA mahotsava ujavAyo. roje roja pUjyazrI ane anya munivaroe guNAnuvAda karyA.zrAvaka saMghanA movaDIoe paNa pUjyazrIno upakAra varNavyo. kalAko sudhI guNAnuvAda thavA chatAM koI uThatuM na hatuM. sAMbhaLyA ja karIe tema saune thatuM. pUjyazrInA sadbhuta guNagaNonI anumodanArthe aneka gAmo-zaheromAM bhavyAtibhavya mahotsavo thayA; haju paNa navanavA mahotsavonA Ayojano saMghajano vicArI rahyA che. pUjyazrInA jIvanane aMjalI ApavA mATeno zubha prayatna saue karavA yogya che ane e prayatna che potAnA haiyAmAM dIkSA jIvananI prIti pragaTAvavI. pote dIkSA levA prayatnazIla banavuM ane potAnA parivArajanone paNa e prIti-prayatnanA paMthe calAvavuM." pUjyapAdanA parama preraka jIvanane bhAvabharI aMjalI, teozrImadbhA paramagurudevazrIjInA pagalepagale cAlI teozrIe jIvana ujALyuM. jatAM potAno bhavya vAraso potAnA paTTAlaMkAra pravacana prabhAvaka pU.A.zrI vijaya kIrtiyazasUrIzvarajI mahArAjAne soMpIne gayA. have teozrInA AlaMbane ApaNe saue ArAdhanA karavAnI che. 2010_02

Page #19
saMpAdakIya bhadaM micchAdasaNasamUhamaiyassa amayasArassa / jiNavayaNassa bhagavao saMviggasuhAhigammassa / / kalyANa thAo ! Avo AzIrvAda, AvI eka zubhabhAvanA saMmatitarkaprakaraNa graMthanA racayitA bhAvI rahyA che. A zubhabhAvanA konA mATenI che ? jene mATe A kalyANanAM vacano dvArA AzIrvacano uccArI rahyA che tenuM svarUpa zuM che ? te vAta ApaNe ahIM karavI che. zAstrakAra bhagavaMta ahIM zrI jinavacanane uddezIne AzIrvacano uccArI rahyA che. A gAthAmAM te jinavacananA cAra vizeSaNo mUkelAM che. 1-jinavacana mithyAdarzanonA samUhamaya che, 2-jinavacana amRtatulya mokSane pamADe che, 3-jinavacana aneka prakAranI labdhine utpanna karAvavA mATe aizvaryAnuM che, ane 4-jinavacana saMvigna jIvo dvArA ja sukhe karIne jANI zakAya tevuM che. A cAre prakAranA vizeSaNathI viziSTa evA jinavacananuM kalyANa thAo. A prakAranuM AzIrvacana zAstrakAra paramarSine zA mATe kahevuM paDyuM haze ? te jANavA mATe ApaNe jainazAsananA saMpUrNa bhUtakALane AMkha sAme lAvavo paDaze. jaina darzananI sarvoparitA : A avasarpiNInA trIjA ArAnA aMte bhagavAna zrI RSabhadeva paramAtmAnA nirvANagamana pachI lagabhaga eka koDAkoDI sAgaropama pramANa cotho Aro pUro thayo tyAM sudhImAM ghaNI badhI ghaTanAo ghaTI hatI. jyAre bhagavAna zrI RSabhadeva paramAtmAe sarva jIvone saMsAra sAgaramAM DUbatA bacAvavAnI bhAvanAthI yathAvasthita vastutattvanI prarUpaNA dvArA mokSamArga svarUpa zrI jinazAsananI sthApanA karI hatI tyAre jayavaMtA jainazAsana sivAya koIpaNa dharma vidyamAna na hato. rAjAo, rAjaputro, maMtrIo, senApatio, sAmaMta rAjAo, zreSThIo, zreSThIputro, strIo, bALako vagere asaMkhya sAdhako A jainazAsananI ane temAM batAvela tattvarUpa jainadarzananI ArAdhanA karI muktipadane pAmyA hatA. anya darzanonI utpatti : paramAtmAe sthApelA zAsanamAM marIci nAme aNagAra thayA. je paramAtmAnA pautra tathA bharata cakravartInA putra hatA. dIkSA lIdhA bAda keTalAka kALe saMyamajIvananA saMpUrNa AcAra na pALI zakavAnA kAraNe ane dIkSA choDIne gRhastha dharma aMgIkAra karavAmAM lajjA vagere bAdhaka banavAne kAraNe vacalA mArga tarIke temaNe tridaMDika vezane dhAraNa karyo hato. A tridaDika vezane dhAraNa karavA chatAM teo samajavA AvanAra darekane paramAtmAe prarUpela yathArtha dharma ja samajAvatA ane paramAtmAnA caraNomAM ja dIkSA apAvatA. paraMtu ekavAra mAMdagI AvI, asaMyamI hovAthI koI sAdhu pANI vagere temane ApatA nathI, tethI eka ziSyanI IcchA utpanna thaI. tyAre kapila nAmano avivekI ziSya maLyo ane tenA dvArA A 2010 02

Page #20
saMpAdakIya tridaMDika vezanI paraMparA cAlI ke je sAMkhyadarzana tarIke bahAra AvyuM. bharata mahArAjAe banAvela ArSa vedo zrI suvidhinAtha prabhu ane zrI zItalanAtha prabhunA samayagALAmAM nAza pAmyA, paNa te pachI rasaRddhi-zAtA lolupI gRhastha brAhmaNoe potAnI lAlasAne poSavA mATe navA veda banAvyA. jenA AdhAre vaidika, mImAMsAdi darzanonI utpatti thaI. jemaNe samagra bharata kSetramAM potAnA matanA phelAvA mATe bharacaka prayatno karyA hatA. A rIte anekAneka mato, pAkhaMDo, dharmo, darzana ane saMpradAyo phUlyA-phAlyA. tIrthakaronI samavasaraNa parSadAnuM varNana sAMbhaLIe tyAre 393 pAkhaMDIo roja paramAtmAnA samavasaraNamAM AvIne besatA ane potAnA matane puSTa karanArAM vacano grahaNa karI potAnA matono phelAvo karatA evuM jANavA maLe che. A uparAMta prabhuvIranA samakAlIna gautamabuddha thayA ke jeo zrI jinavacananA RjusUtra nayanA AdhAre anya nayono apalApa karIne potAnuM darzana calAvanAra banyA emanuM darzana bauddha dharma tarIke khyAtine pAmyuM. advaitavAdI uttaramImAMsA darzana mAtra saMgrahanayane grahaNa karIne anyAyono apalApa karI potAnuM darzana calAvanAra thayuM. A rIte niyativAda, satkAryavAda, asatkAryavAda, nityavAda, anityavAda, jJAnavAda, karmavAda vagere seMkaDo mato prabhuvIranI hAjarImAM vidyamAna hatA ke je mato zrI jinazAsananA sakalana sApekSa pramANavacananA eka-eka aMzane ekAMtaSTithI pakaDI anya nayo ane vacanono apalApa karIne pravaryA hatA. mithyAdarzanonA samUharUpa jainadarzana kaI rIte ? syAdvAda e jainazAsanano maulika siddhAMta che. A syAdvAda siddhAMtane anekAMtavAda-vibhajyavAdasApekSavAda tarIke paNa oLakhAvavAmAM Ave che. te tathya jaNAvavA zAstrakAre "micchAviMsamUdamaya = mithyAdarzanonA samUhamaya zrI jinavacana che" - ema kahyuM che. jeTalAM paNa darzana che, temanI pAse potAnI koI maulikatA nathI; jyAre zrI jinavacana sarvathA maulika che. A ja zrI jinavacanamAMthI eka eka nayano Azraya laIne te te darzanonI utpatti thayelI che. "te te darzano koI eka ja nayane ekAMte svIkRta kare che ane anya sarva nayono apalApa kare che mATe ja te anya darzano khoTAM che. paNa jo te darzano anya nayono apalApa na kare ane anya-anya nayone paNa sApekSabhAve svIkAre to te sAcAM paNa banI zake che" tethI "jo te ja dareka nayono samUha karavAmAM Ave arthAt dareka nayone paraspara sApekSasusaMvAdI banAvavAmAM Ave to te pramANarUpa eTale samyagdarzanarUpa bane che mATe ja "syAvAda svarUpa zrI jinavacana te mithyAdarzananA samUharUpa bane che.' evuM ahIM Apezika rIte zAstrakAre varNavyuM che. nayonI nirapekSatA tathA sApekSatAnuM pariNAma : prastuta graMthamAM graMthakArazrIe te vAtane siddha karavA mATe kyAMya kasara choDI nathI. dareke dareka tarko ane pramANo dvArA DaMkAnI coTe eka ja vAta siddha karavAno prayatna karyo che ke, jainazAsane prarUpelA syAdvAda siddhAMtanA eka aMzano amalApa paNa mithyAdarzanamAM pariName che. jo mULa nayo paraspara sApekSa bane to 2010 02

Page #21
saMpAdakIya ja te naya samyaktva rUpa banI zake che. mULanayonI jema uttaranayomAM paNa A ja sthiti che. jo te nayone paraspara nirapekSa mAno to saMsArasthiti-lokasthiti paNa ghaTatI nathI ke sukha-du:kha paNa ghaTatAM nathI, saMsAranA kAraNabhUta karmo paNa ghaTatAM nathI ke te karmono baMdha-sthiti-svabhAva vagere paNa ghaTI zakatA nathI. mATe anekAMta siddhAMtathI sApekSapaNe ja dareka nayane svIkAravAmAM samyaktva che, anyathA mithyAtva che. A ja vAto pratyeka padyamAM tArkika zailIthI jaNAvavAmAM AvI che, je graMthanuM adhyayana karatAM jANI zakAya tema che. graMthakAra maharSi ane guNagarimA : AvA mahAn graMtharatnanA racayitA che zrutakevalI, vAdivRSabha, mahAtArkika, stutikAra bhagavaMta zrI siddhasena divAkarasUrijI mahArAjA. hA, samartha zAstrakAra ziromaNi sUripuraMdara pU.A.zrI haribhadrasUrijI mahArAjAe teo mATe "zrutakevalI' vizeSaNa vAparyuM che. teozrIe A granthanI racanA prAkRtapadyomAM karI che. bhASA atyaMta mIThI ane saraLa hovA chatAM arthathI atyaMta gaMbhIra ane prauDha che. A mahApuruSanuM jIvana Alekhana aneka graMtharatnomAM pUrvanA mahApuruSoe karela che. jemAM mukhyatve pU.A.zrI bhadrezvarasUrIzvarajI racita kathAvalI, pU.A.zrI prabhAcaMdrasUrIzvarajI racita prabhAvaka caritra, pU.A.zrI merUtuMgasUrIzvarajI racita prabaMdhaciMtAmaNi, pU.A.zrI rAjazekharasUrIzvarajI kRta caturvizatiprabaMdha, prabaMdhakoza, pU.mu.zrI zubhazIlagaNi racita vikramacaritra tathA pU. upAdhyAya zrI dharmasAgaragaNi racita paTTAvalI vagere graMtho prakhyAta che ane te te graMthone AdhAre ane anya mAhitI vaDe vartamAnamAM prakAzita thatA aneka graMthomAM paNa sAmAnyathI, vizeSathI, aitihAsika mAhitIpUrvaka graMthakArazrIjInuM jIvana AlekhAyuM che. saMmatitarka graMthanI paNa je je AvRttio atyAra sudhI bahAra paDI che temAM paNa prastAvanAmAM pU.A.zrI darzanasUrIzvarajI ma.sA., mu. zrI jayasuMdara vi.ma.sA. (hAla AcAryazrI), 5. sukhalAla, paM. dhIrUbhAI vageree paNa graMthakArazrIjInA jIvanapaTane prakAzita karavA sArI mahenata karI che. mATe A prakAzanamAM graMthakArazrIjInA jIvanakavanane na AlekhatAM te te graMtho jovAnI jijJAsuone sUcanA karavAmAM Ave che. graMthakArazrI prakAMDa paMDita hatA to sAthosAtha ativiziSTa kavitvazaktine paNa dharAvatA hatA. teozrI tarkasamrATa hatA to bhaktahRdaya kavi paNa hatA. teozrI sarvazAstronA pAraMgAmI hatA tema samarthavAdI paNa hatA. ItihAsavidonA mate te vakhatanA AgamayugamAM tarkapradhAna vivaraNazailI dvArA graMthonI racanA karanArA zvetAMbara ke digaMbara paraMparAmAM teo prathama AcArya hatA. temanA ghaNA graMtho kadamAM nAnA dekhAtA hovA chatAM arthathI atigaMbhIra che. graMthakArazrIjInI guNagarimAnuM gAna karatAM keTalAye mahApuruSoe potAnA graMthomAM temanA mATe je vizeSaNo vAparyA che, te vAMcatAM paNa te te mahApuruSonA hRdayamAM graMthakArazrIjInI jJAna garimA pratye kevo ahobhAva hato te jaNAyA vinA rahetuM nathI. samarthazAstrakAra ziromaNi pU A zrI haribhadrasUrIzvarajI mahArAjA paMcavastukagraMthamAM jaNAvI rahyA che ke, 2010_02

Page #22
saMpAdakIya 17 "Na ya No sahAvaNAo suakevaliNA jao bhaNiyaM / / 1047 / / AyariyasiddhaseNeNa sammaIe paiTThiajaseNaM / tUsaMsivivArappattano tavaSevi aa2048aa" syAdvAdaratnAkaramAM pU.AcArya zrI vAdidevasUri mahArAjA pharamAvI rahyA che ke, "zrI siddhasena-haribhadrapramukhAH prasiddhAH, te sUrayo mapi bhavantu kRtaprasAdAH / yeSAM vimRzya satataM vividhAn nibandhAna, zAstraM cikIrSati tanupratibho'pi mAdRk / / " siddhahemazabdAnuzAsanamAM kalikAlasarvajJazrI jaNAvI rahyA che ke, "manu siddhasenaM vaya: " tathA anyayogavyavacchedArnAizikAmAM lakhyuM che ke, "kva siddhasenastutayo mahArthA azikSitAlApakalA kva caiSA / tathApi yUthAdhipateH pathasthaH skhaladgatistasya zizurna zocyaH / / " pUjya AcArya zrI pradyumnasUrijI mahArAjA pharamAve che ke, "tamaHstomaM sa hantu zrIsiddhasenadivAkaraH / yasyo sthitaM pUrvasUriva yAvidhiH " AgaLa vadhIne pU. nyAyAcArya nyAyavizArada mahAmahopAdhyAya zrI yazovijayajI mahArAjAe graMthakArazrIjIne uddezIne "madaviIi ", "samayaparamArthaniH ", "mA ", "pravaranopaniSaddedI", "vAnivesara" jevAM aneka vizeSaNo potAnA bhinna bhinna graMthomAM ullekhyAM che. graMthakArazrIe dehano tyAga karyo che e ema sUcavato "putti vidyota: sARtti kSathe " A ardhazloka jyAre saMbhaLAvavAmAM Avyo tyAre graMthakArazrInAM saMsArI pakSe bahena evA pU. sAdhvIjI zrI siddhazrIjInA mukhamAMthI bAkIno ardhazloka sahaja rIte sarI paDyo ke, nUnamartato vAlI, siddhaseno vivAra: " graMthakArazrIjInuM sAhitya sarjana : graMthakArazrIjInuM zruta sarjana joIe to teozrIe batrIsa-batrIsI nAme eka graMtha banAvyo hato. temAMthI ekavIza batrIsIo Aje paNa upalabdha che. jo prabhAvakacaritrAnusAra nyAyAvatAra granthane paNa tenI aMtargata laIe to bAvIza batrIzIo Aje upalabdha thAya che. A ekavIza batrIzI ane nyAyAvatAra sUtra uparAMta kalyANa maMdira stotra tathA saMmatitarka graMtha maLI teonA banAvelA kula covIza graMtho vartamAnamAM upalabdha che. 2010_02

Page #23
18 ekavIza batrIsIomAM mukhyatve pa2mAtmAnA guNo, atizayo, 5ramAtmAno upadeza, jaina darzananuM svarUpa, anya darzanonuM svarUpa, vAda, kathA vagere viSayone sAMkaLavAmAM AvyA che. nyAyAvatArasUtramAM mukhyatve jainadarzananA nyAyane tarkavAdane jaNAvavAmAM Avyo che. sAthosAtha pramANonI carcA, parArthanumAnanuM svarUpa vagerenuM paNa vizada varNana ka2vAmAM AvyuM che. kalyANamaMdirastotrathI to sahu koI paricita ja che ke je stotrarUpa stavanA dvArA graMthakArazrIjIe avaMtidezamAM mahAdevanA liMgamAMthI bhagavAna zrI pArzvanAtha prabhunA biMbane pragaTa karyuM hatuM. je avaMti pArzvanAtha tarIke prasiddhane pAmyuM. A prasaMga dvArA teozrIe saMvat pravartaka vikamAditya rAjAne pratibodha pamADyo hato. kyAMka A kArya batrIzInI stavanA dvArA saMpanna thayAnuM paNa ullekhAyuM che. A uparAMta saMmatitarka graMtha ke jenI viSayavastu ApaNe AgaLa vistArathI joIzuM. A dareka graMthanuM jo UMDANathI avalokana ka2vAmAM Ave to e vAta spaSTa thayA vagara nahi rahe ke graMthakA2zrIjInA graMtho saMskRtamAM hoya ke prAkRtamAM hoya, Agamika hoya ke dArzanika hoya e dareka zAkhA upara teozrIjInI asAdhAraNa pakkaDa hatI. grantharacanA evI pravAhabaddha cAle che ke vAMcanArane kyAMya aTakavAnuM mana na thAya. joke e cokkasa che ke teozrIjInA graMthonuM vAMcana sAmAnya abhyAsI mATe zakya nathI. kAraNa ke, bhASAnA bodhathI sUtrano padArtha khyAla Ave, paNa vAkyArthamahAvAkyArtha-aidaMparyArtha samajavo kaThIna bane che. mATe ja graMthakArazrI tathA temanA graMthonI lokapriyatA hovA chatAM temanA graMthonuM sAtatyapUrNa abhyasana abhyAsuvargamAM jovA maLatuM nathI. A rIte arthanI duruhatA, gaMbhIratA ane vizALatA hovAne kAraNe ja be graMthone choDI daIe to anya eka paNa graMtha upara TIkAo racAyelI paNa jovA maLatI nathI. Ama chatAM graMthakArazrInA je graMthano sauthI vadhu upayoga thato hoya, je graMtha upara sauthI vadhu TIkAo jovA maLatI hoya to te ekamAtra graMtha che; 'saMmatitarkaprakaraNa.' saMmatitarkaprakaraNa : graMtha mahattA : saMpAdakIya jayavaMtA zrIjainazAsananI dvAdazAMgIne sADA nava pUrvanA dhA2ka yugapradhAna pU.A.zrI AryarakSitasUrIzvarajI mahArAjAe cAra anuyogamAM vibhAjana karelI che. 1-dravyAnuyoga, 2-gaNitAnuyoga, 3-kathAnuyoga ane 4-caraNakaraNAnuyoga. A cAre anuyogamAM dravyAnuyoga pradhAnabhAvane bhajanAra che. caraNakaraNAnuyoga paNa dravyAnuyogane AlaMbane Take che. gItArthatA, bhAvasamyaktva, prarUpaNA mATenuM adhikArIpaNuM vagere dravyAnuyoganA jJAna vagara saMbhavI zakatuM nathI. A dravyAnuyoganA viSaya tarIke nayapramANa-nikSepA-saptabhaMgI-svaparadarzanano bodha-AtmavAda-karmavAda-Sadravya vagerene jaNAvavAmAM AvyA che. dravyAnuyoganA A viSayonuM varNana karatAM granthomAM tathA darzana prabhAvaka zAstromAM pradhAna sthAnane pAmanAra granthonuM varNana karatAM zrI AcArAMgasUtranI TIkAmAM TIkAkAra paramarSi pU. AcArya zrI zIlAMkasUrijI mahArAje lakhyuM che ke, "dravyAnuyogaH pUrvAni sammAvijI / " "varzanapramAvaorvA samAvimiH / " 2010_02

Page #24
saMpAdakIya 19 darzana prabhAvaka zAstromAM saMmatisUtrane mokharAnuM sthAna ApatAM cUrNikAra maharSi pU.A.zrI jinadAsagaNijI mahattare nizIthasUtranI cUrNinA prathama uddezAmAM jaNAvyuM che ke, "daMsaNaNANappabhAvagANi satthANi siddhiviNicchiya-saMmatimAdi geNhato asaMtharemANe jaM akappiaM paDisevati jayaNAto, tattha so suhI apAyacchittI bhavatItyarthaH / " bhAvArtha : siddhivinizcaya, saMmatisUtra vagere darzana-jJAna prabhAvaka zAstrone bhaNato sAdhu kAraNavaza jo yatanAthI akalpita vastunuM sevana kare to paNa te zuddha ja che, tene prAyazcitta lAgu paDatuM nathI. "daMsaNappabhAvagANa satthANaM sammadiyAdisuttaNANe ya jo visArado NissaMkiyasutatthotti vuttaM bhavati so ya uttimaTThapaDivano, so ya jattha khitte Thio tatthaMtarA vA verajjaM mA taM suttatthaM vocchijjaMtu tti, ao taggahaNaTThayA pakappaMti verajjaviruddhasaMkamaNaM kaauN|" bhAvArtha : zrI saMmatisUtra vagere darzana prabhAvaka zAstrorUpa zrutajJAnamAM je vizArada hoya, ni:zaktipaNe sUtra ane arthane dhAraNa karanAra hoya ane jo tevA sAdhue anazana svIkArela hoya to te sAdhu je kSetramAM rahyA hoya athavA te kSetramAM virodhI rAjya hoya to paNa sUtrano artha viccheda thavo joIe nahi. tethI te sUtrArthanA grahaNa mATe virodhI rAjyamAM javuM paNa kalpa che. nyAyAcArya-nyAyavizArada-mahAmahopAdhyAya zrI yazovijayajI mahArAjA gujarAtI bhASAmAM svaracita dravya-guNa-paryAyanA rAsa"mAM dravyAnuyoganA pradhAna graMtha tarIke saMmatitarka graMthane jaNAvatAM kahe che ke, "saMmati-tattvAratha mukha graMtha, moTo je pravacana nigraMtha" tathA dravyAnuyogamAM tanmaya sAdhune AdhAkarma vagere doSo paNa lAgatA nathI evuM jaNAvatAM kahe che ke, "e yogi jo lAgaI raMga, AdhAkarmAdika nahi bhaMga; paMcakalpa bhASyaI Imi bhaNi7, sadguru pAsa IsyuM meM suNiI." darzana prabhAvaka zAstronA adhyayana mATenA apavAdamArgane jaNAvatAM bhASyakAra bhagavaMta pUjyapAda zrI saMghadAsagaNi kSamAzramaNa paMcakalpabhASya nAmanA chedagraMthamAM tathA tenI cUrNi karatAM cUrNikAra bhagavaMta jaNAve che ke, "daMsaNa pabhAvagAti ahavA NANaM ahijjamANaM tu / attaTThaparaTThA vA jahalaMbha geNha paNahANI / / 1165 / / cUrNi : daMsaNapabhAvagANi vA satthANi / anuogaM vA darisaNapabhAvakaM / te giNhamANo jassa vA pAse 2010 02

Page #25
20 giues, tesiM vA aTThAe gacchaMto, addhANe uggamAi jaM paDisevai AhArAi asuddhaM nANAhigame vA nANamadhijjaMto nArNAnimittaM vA gacchaMto, vAyaNAriassa vA jahA sikkhApayaMmi to suddho / tattha jaM paDisevai taM na saddahai / / " saMpAdakIya samarthazAstrakAra ziromaNi pUjya A. zrIharibhadrasUrIzvarajI mahArAjA, vAdivetAla pUjya AcArya zrIzAMtisUrIzvarajI mahArAjA, navAMgI vRttikAra pUjya AcArya zrIabhayadevasUrIzvarajI mahArAjA, kalikAlasarvajJa pUjya AcArya zrIhemacandrasUrIzvarajI mahArAjA, tarkapaMcAnana pUjya AcArya zrIabhayadevasUrIzvarajI mahArAjA, nyAyAcArya-nyAyavizArada-pUjyamahAmahopAdhyAya zrIyazovijayajI mahArAjA jevA aneka mahApuruSo potAnA viziSTa graMthomAM A graMthagAthAone sanmAnabhera sthAna ApyuM che. eTaluM ja nahi, paNa ghaNA kharA mahApuruSoe potAnA viziSTa kSayopazamapUrvaka tenA padArthonI spaSTatA-vivecanA paNa karI che. amane je je graMthomAM saMmatigAthAno ullekha jovA maLyo te te graMthonI noMdha pariziSTa-1mAM jaNAvela che. saMkSepamAM kahIe to naya-pramANa-anekAMtavAdanI spaSTatA karatA sauthI prAcIna ane sauthI zreSTha graMtha tarIke A graMthane oLakhAvavo paDe. A uparAMta digaMbara sAhityamAM paNa SakhaMDAgamanI dhavalATIkA, harivaMzapurANa, padmapurANa, paMcAstikAya vagere graMthomAM saMmatitarka graMthanI gAthAonuM bahumAnapUrvaka uddharaNa ka2vAmAM AvyuM che. jenA AdhAre digaMbara paraMparAmAM paNa A graMthane kevA Adara-sanmAnathI svIkArAyo che teno khyAla AvI zake che. saMmatitarka prakaraNa : nAma : A graMthanA nAma mATe vidvAnomAM thoDo vivAda utpanna thayela che. graMthanuM nAma sammati, sanmati ke satitao ? A viSayanI spaSTatA karatAM vyAkhyAnavAcaspati, kavikulakirITa - 52mapUjya jainAcArya zrImadvijaya labdhisUrIzvarajI mahArAjAe svasaMkalita 'sammatitattvasopAna' graMthanI prastAvanAmAM lakhyuM che ke, " Xxxx idameva ca tatra tatra grantheSu sammatiriti sammatitarka iti ca vyavahriyate, samIcInA matiryasmAt sa sammatiH, samyaG manyate'vabuddhyate prAmANyasarvajJatvanayapramANAdisvarUpANi yasmAt sa sammatiriti vA, samyaGmananaM sammatistatpUrvakastaka hi yatreti sammatitarka iti vA vyutpattiH, taka hi mithyAdRzAM prAmANyAdiviSayo nayAbhAsamUlakaH, tannirAso'tra pramANamUlatakaiH kriyata iti sammatitarka ityanvarthaM nAma, idameva ca nAmAsya mUlasya granthaMkartturabhipretamiti maulaviSayAnurodhAt prAcInalikhitamUlapatrAnurodhAd vyavahArAcca vijJAyate / _2010_02

Page #26
saMpAdakIya etena mUlasya sanmatirbhitameva nAma digambaraparamparAyAM mahAvIrasya vAcakatvena sanmatizabdadarzanAttatsiddhAntapratipAdakatvenAsya mUlasya tena saha sambandhapradarzanaucityAt, zleSeNa zreSThamatimattvasyApi pradarzanaucityAt, sammatizabdavyavahArastu sanmatizabdasya mahAvIravAcakatvenAgrahaNAd bhramamUlaka eveti matamapAstam, mahAvIreNaiva pratipAditasiddhAntapratipAdakatvenAbhyupetatve bhavajinAnAM jinAnAM zAsanaM siddhaM pratipAdya tadvyAkhyAtRpratipAditArthAvadhAraNasAmarthyasampAdakatvaM nijaprakaraNasyAbhidhAya tIrthakaravacanasaGgrahavizeSapratipAdakadravyArthika-paryAyArthikanayAdivyAvarNanasya bhadraM jinavacanasya bhagavata ityupasaMharaNasya ca mUlakArakRtasya cArutA'nirvAhAt, sAmAnyatayoktehetumantareNa mahAvIravizeSArthaparyavasAyitvavyAvarNanasyAnaucityAt / satsu bahuSu mahAvIraparyAyazabdeSu paramparAntaraprasiddhazabdopAdAne prayojanamantareNa mUlakRdabhiprAyakalpanAyA nirmUlatvAt, sammai iti prAkRtAbhidhAnasya gArvANavANyAM sanmatItyeva cchAyA na tu sammatItyatra niyAmakAbhAvAt, sammatizabdasyoktarItyA sArthakatve baadhkaabhaavaanyc|" A kAraNomImAMsA jotAM prastuta graMthanuM nAma sammati (saMmati) ke sammatitarka (saMmatitarka) mAnavuM e ja ucita jaNAya che, paNa sanmati nAma ucita jaNAtuM nathI. saMmatitarka prakaraNa : graMtha pramANa : A graMthane traNa kAMDamAM vaheMcavAmAM Avyo che. prathama kAMDamAM 54 gAthA, bIjA kAMDamAM 43 gAthA tathA trIjA kAMDamAM 69 gAthA che. A rIte AryAvRMdamAM banela kula 136 gAthA pramANa A graMtha che. keTalIka hastalikhita pratomAM trIjA kAMDamAM nIce jaNAvelI eka gAthA vadhu maLe che. jemAM kahyuM che ke, jeNa viNA logassa vavahAro savvahA na NivvaDai / tassa bhuvaNekkaguruNo Namo'NegaMtavAyassa / / bhAvArtha : je (anekAMtavAda)nA abhAvamAM sarva prakAre loko vyavahAra saMbhavI zakato nathI, tevA traNe bhuvananA advitIya guru samAna anekAMtavAdane namaskAra thAo. joke A gAthA upara eka paNa hastalikhita pratamAM tarkapaMcAnanazrIjInI TIkA upalabdha thaI nathI, mATe A gAthAne prakSipta gAthA tarIke svIkAravAmAM AvI che. saMmatitarka prakaraNa - upalabdha-anupalabdha TIkAo : AnI spaSTatA mATe vartamAnamAM chellA varSomAM sAla mujaba prakAzita saMmatitarka graMthanI AvRttionI noMdha ame pariziSTamAM ApI che. te uparAMta "jaina saMskRta sAhityano ItihAsa" pustakanA trIjA khaMDamAM A aMgenI je vigato maLI che te nIce mujaba che. 2010_02

Page #27
saMpAdakIya "sammaIpatharaNanI TIkAo : (1) svopajJa vivaraNa - pU.A.zrI siddhasena divAkarasUrijIe 196 padyamAM sammaIpayaraNa racyuM che. e traNa kAMDamAM vibhakta che. A pAIe kRtinuM mahattva jotAM ema bhAse che ke teo zrImade jAte AnA upara saMskRtamAM vivaraNa racyuM haze. A pUrve pro. loyamene svopajJa vivaraNa hovAnI saMbhAvanA karI che. (2) mallavAdI racita TIkA - "vAdimukhya" pU.A.zrI mallavAdIsUrijIe sammaIpayaraNa upara saMskRtamAM TIkA racI hatI ema pU.A.zrI haribhadrasUrijI kRta anekAntajayapatAkAnI svopajJa vyAkhyA (khaMDa 1, pR. 58 ne 116) jotAM jaNAya che. pU.upA. zrI yazovijayagaNie aSTasahastrInI TIkAmAM pU. zrI mallavAdIsUrijIno sammaIpayaraNanA TIkAkAra tarIke ullekha karyo che. vizeSamAM pU.A. zrI malavAdIsUrijIe A TIkAmAM koTizaH bhaMgo darzAvyA che ema paNa emaNe kahyuM che. bUTi mAM A TIkAnuM parimANa 790 zlokanuM noMdhAyuM che. A TIkAnI hAthapothI hajI sudhI to koI sthaLethI maLI AvI nathI eTale vizeSa tapAsa thavI ghaTe. ema lAge che ke pU.upAzrI yazovijayagaNie to A TIkA joI hatI. e jo lupta hoya to sammaIpayaraNanA abhyAsa mATenuM eka uttama sAdhana ApaNe gumAvyuM che ema kahevAya. (3) sumatikRtaTIkA - pU.A.zrI haribhadrasUrijIe zAntarakSitano ullekha karyo che. A zAntarakSita bauddha graMthakAra che. emaNe tattvasaMgraha racyo che. AmAM "syAdvAdaparIkSA" (kArikA 1262 I.) ane "bahirarthaparIkSA" (kArikA 1980 I.)mAM sumatinuM khaMDana karyuM che. A digaMbara sumatie sammaIpayaraNa upara TIkA racI che e vAta zrI vAdirAjasUrikRta pArzvanAtha caritranA prAraMbha uparathI ane zravaNa belgolAnI malliSaNa prazasti uparathI jANI zakAya che. A sumatinuM bIjuM nAma sanmati paNa che. emaNe racelI TIkAnI koI hAthapothI maLatI hoya ema jaNAtuM nathI. (4) tattvabodhavidhAyinI kiMvA vAdamahArNava - pU.A.zrI pradyumnasUrijInA ziSya tarkapaMcAnanI pU.A.zrI abhayadevasUrijIe 25000 zloka jevaDI ane potAnA samaya sudhInI vividha dArzanika carcAone rajU karanArI tattvabodhavidhAyinI nAmanI ane vAdamahArNava tarIke prakhyAti pAmelI vivRti racI che. sammaIpayaraNanA prathama kAMDanI 40mI gAthAnI vivRtti (pR. 447)mAM emaNe kahyuM che ke e Adya be bhaMgonA traNa traNa prakAra, tRtIya ane caturthanA dasa dasa ane pAMcamA vagerenA 130 prakAro che te pU.A.zrI malavAdIsUrijIe darzAvyA che. vaLI e pU.A.zrI mallavAdIsUrijIe kahyuM che ke e 1423 prakAro ddhi. Adi saMyoganI kalpanA karatAM karoDa thAya che. sammaIpayaraNanA trIjA kAMDanI kamI gAthAnI vivRttimAM (pR. 754mAM) mUrtine AbharaNo vaDe bhUSita karavI ke nahi e bAbatanI carcA kare che. A mahAkAya vivRtinI prazastimAM pU.A.zrI abhayadevasUrijIe kahyuM che ke A rIte ka paM. sukhalAla saMpAdita saMmatitarkaprakaraNa bhAga 1 thI 5 2010_02

Page #28
saMpAdakIya (sammaIpayaraNanAM) keTalAMka sUtronI vyAkhyA vaDe je puSkaLa puNya meM upArjana karyuM che tenA vaDe bhavya jIvono saMsArano bhaya dUra thaI teo jJAnagarbhita, nirmaLa ane AnaMdapUrNa evA abhayadeva (?) arthAt mokSane pAmo. Ama jo ke ahIM keTalAMka sUtro" ema kahyuM che. chatAM emaNe vyAkhyA karatI veLA eke padyane ke enA mukhya aMzane choDI dIdhela nathI. sammaIpayaraNano sAMgopAMga abhyAsa karanAre vAdamahArNavanuM parizIlana karavuM joIe. paraMtu A mahAsAgaramAM praveza karavo e kaMI sAdhAraNa vAta nathI. Ane lakSamAM rAkhIne jainaratna, vyAkhyAna vAcaspati, pUjya jainAcArya zrI vijayalabdhisUrijIe sammatitattvasopAnanI yojanA karI che. (5) nyAyAcAryakRta TIkA - nyAyAcArya pU.maho zrI yazovijayagaNie samaIpayaraNanuM AkaMTha pAna karyuM che. emaNe potAnI vividha kRtione A amUlya kRtimAMthI avataraNo ApI enuM mUlya vadhAryuM che. vizeSamAM e avataraNo upara pote vivaraNa paNa racyuM che. keTalIka vAra to e svataMtra che kema ke e vAdamahArNavane anusaratuM nathI. kaI kaI kRtimAM samaIpayaraNanI gAthAo Ave che e bAbata uparyukta saMskaraNamAM pAMcamA bhAgamAM trIjA pariziSTarUpe rajU thaI che eTale have te te sthaLo tema ja tyAra pachI prakAzita keTalIka kRtio joI phakta saMkalanA ja karavAnI bAkI rahe che. e thatAM ApaNane A mahattvapUrNa kRti upara pU.upAzrI yazovijayagaNi jevA pratibhAzALIne hAthe racAyelI laghu TIkA meLavavAno lAbha thaze. (3) ajJAtakartRka TIkA - sammaIpayaraNa upara koIkanI TIkA hovAno ullekha ji. 2 ko. (vi. 1, pR. 423)mAM che." saMmatitarka prakaraNa : viSaya : mahAvAdi-zrutakevali pUjya AcArya zrI siddhasenadivAkarasUrIzvarajI mahArAjA racita aneka graMthomAM zreSTha graMtha tarIke saMmatitarka graMthane ja sthAna ApavuM ghaTe. A graMthamAM viSayonI vyApakatA, jaina zAsananA mULabhUta padArthonI spaSTatA, arthanI gaMbhIratA, anekAMtavAdanI sudaDha sthApanA, anubhavanA paripAkarUpa vacano vagere A graMthamAM savizeSa jovA maLe che. pUrve jaNAvyA mujaba prastuta graMtha traNa kAMDamAM vibhakta che. traNe kAMDanA sAmAnya viSayone anusarIne tenI oLakha ApavI hoya to prathama kAMDane nayakAMDa, dvitIya kAMDane upayogakAMDa athavA jJAnakAMDa tathA tRtIya kAMDane zeyakAMDa tarIke oLakhAvI zakAya. graMthakArazrIe prathama nayakAMDanA prAraMbhamAM ja jinazAsananA asAdhAraNa guNonI stavanA dvArA maMgalAcaraNa karyA bAda pratijJA karI che ke, "AgamanA padArthone samajavAmAM maMda buddhivALA jIvo zAstranA paramArthanA vistArane prakAzita karanArA mahApuruSonI sevA karavA prerAIne AgamanA hArdane pAmI zake te rIte arthane kahIza." dravyAnuyoganA mahAna graMtharatnanA prAraMbhamAM ja A svarUpanI pratijJA 2010 02

Page #29
A saMpAdakIya dvArA "gacchamAM ja rahevuM, gurunizrAe vasavuM, guru bhagavaMtanI sevA-bhakti-vinaya-vaiyAvacca karavI, tenA dvArA jJAnane pAtra banI jJAna meLavavuM vagere bAbatono abhuta dizAnirdeza karavAmAM Avyo che. te pachI dravyAstikana ane paryAyAstikanayanuM svarUpa varNavI, tenA ja bheda svarUpa anya sarve nayo che te vAtanI spaSTatA karI che. naigamanayano, saMgrahanaya ane vyavahAranayamAM samAveza karI saMgraha vagere cha nayone ja svIkAranAra graMthakArazrI chae nayone dravyAtikanaya ane paryAyAstikanayamAM vibhAjita karyA che. tyAra bAda paraspara nirapekSa evA dravyAstikanaya ane paryAyAstikanaya miththArUpa che, tenI spaSTatA karIne baMne nayono sAdhAraNa viSaya, vivekSAthI ja nayano bheda, eka nayane mAnya viSaya bIjA naya mATe amAnya, paraspara nirapekSa baMne nayone mAnya vastunuM bhinna bhinna svarUpa, paraspara nirapekSa dravya ane paryAyano abhAva jaNAvI dravyanuM lakSaNa, baMne nayo sunaya svarUpa ke durnaya svarUpa thavAnuM kAraNa vagere bAbato tarkapradhAna zailIthI spaSTa karI che. ATaluM varNana karyA bAda mukhya nayonA viSayane ja anya nayo spaSTa karatA hovAthI je rIte nirapekSa mukhya nayo dUSita bane che te ja rIte anyanayo paNa dUSita bane che. A rIte mukhya nayo hoya ke tenA AdhAra para rahelA anya nayo hoya, paNa jo te nirapekSa hoya - anya nayanI mAnyatAnuM khaMDana karI pravartatA hoya to te nayomAM saMsArasthiti, sukha-du:khano saMbaMdha, karmabaMdha, karmasthiti ke karmathI mokSa vagere kAMIpaNa ghaTI zakatuM nathI; te vAta sacoTa rIte jaNAvavAmAM AvI che. ATalI spaSTatA bAda sarvanayo mithyArUpa ke samyakarUpa kyAre bane ? - te vAta ratnAvalInA dRSTAMtathI jaNAvavAmAM AvI che. sAthosAtha dRSTAMtanuM zuM mahattva che ? tenAthI lAbha zuM ? te jaNAvI kArya-kAraNa aMge nirapekSapaNe pravartatA satkAryavAd, asatkAryavAda ane kArya-kAraNanI abhinnatA mAnanAra advaitavAdanI mithyA mAnyatAonuM khaMDana karI syAdvAda-sApekSatA dvArA ja teno samanvaya thaI zake che te vAta spaSTa karI che. tyAra bAda dravyAstikanaya ane paryAyAstikanayanA viSayarUpa kramika abheda ane bhedanuM varNana karI dravyane eka ke aneka kaI apekSAe kahevAya te mATe dravyanA vyaMjana-paryAyo ane artha-paryAyonuM dRSTAMta dvArA spaSTIkaraNa karI dravyane ekAMte eka ke aneka mAnavAmAM AvatA doSo jaNAvyA che. ATaluM varNana karyA bAda syAdvAdanI pIThikA svarUpa saptabhaMgInuM pratipAdana karI, vyaMjana-paryAya ane artha-paryAyamAM keTakeTalA bhaMga saMbhave che, tenuM nirUpaNa karyuM che. te pachI mAtra paryAyanayanI ke mAtra dravyAstikanayanI dezanAmAM apUrNatA jaNAvI keTalAMka dRSTAMtono sahAro laI dezanAnuM autsargika ane ApavAdika svarUpa varNavI dharmopadezakone uttama mArgadarzana pUruM pADIne prathama kAMDanI pUrNAhuti karI che. A rIte prathama kAMDamAM dravyAstikanaya ane paryAyAstikanayanI mukhya dharI upara ArohaNa karI viSayanuM nirUpaNa karavAmAM AvyuM che ane mukhya nayo hoya ke tenA bheda svarUpa anya nayo hoya, paNa jyAM sudhI te nayonuM anekAMtavAdathI-syAdvAdathI-sApekSavAdathI nirUpaNa karavAmAM AvatuM nathI tyAM sudhI te nayo samyapaNAne - sunayapaNAne pAmI zakatA nathI, te vAta atyaMta-sacoTa ane spaSTapaNe jaNAvI che. 2010_02

Page #30
saMpAdakIya 25 upayoga kAMDa ke jJAnakAMDa svarUpa dvitIyakAMDano prAraMbha karatAM prathama gAthAmAM dravyAstikanayanA viSayarUpa darzananuM (sAmAnyabodhanuM) tathA paryAyAstikanayanA viSayarUpa jJAnanuM (vizeSabodhanuM) svarUpa spaSTa karyuM che. A darzana ane jJAna baMne paraspara sApekSa che, tema jaNAvI upayogavAdanI carcAno prAraMbha karyo che. matabheda vagaranA chadmasthanA upayoganuM nirUpaNa karI, matabhedavALA kevalInA upayogamAM pracalita traNa vAdo jaNAvyA che. 1-pU.A.zrI jinabhadragaNi kSamAzramaNano kramavAda, 2-pU.A.zrI mallavAdisUrijI mahArAjAno sahavAda ane 3-svamAnya abhedavAda. te paikI sau prathama gAthA 4 thI 8 mAM sahavAdipakSa dvArA kramavAdipakSanuM anumAna, Agama ane tarka dvArA khaMDana karavAmAM AvyuM che tyAra bAda gAthA 9 thI 14mAM bhinna bhinna tarko dvArA sahavAdanuM khaMDana karI abhedopayogavAdanuM sthApana karavAmAM AvyuM che. pharI kramavAdinA praznane upasthita karIne teno uttara ApI tarkasiddha je artha che te mujaba ja sUtranI vyAkhyA karavAthI Agama virodha paNa nahi Ave tema spaSTa rIte jaNAvyuM che. A rIte abheda upayoga siddha thavA chatAM kevalajJAnathI kevaladarzananA bhinna ullekhanuM kAraNa zuM? tenuM samAdhAna ApIne amedavArane siddha karyo che. tyAra bAda ekadezI mata mujaba darzana ane jJAnanA svarUpamAM AvatA doSo jaNAvI cakSudarzana ane acakSudarzana zabdano artha jaNAvyo che. A rIte karela "darzana' zabdanI vyAkhyA mujaba mana:paryAyajJAnamAM darzana mAnavAnI ApattinuM nirAkaraNa, zrutajJAnamAM 'darzana' zabdano asaMbhava, avadhijJAna tathA kevalajJAnamAM 'darzana' zabdanI ghaTamAnatA karI niSkarSa jaNAvyo che ke, "eka ja kevalopayoga baMne svarUpe che" A ja svasiddhAMta che ane anya "kramika utpatti" ke "sahavAda' e parasiddhAMta che. A rIte kevalInA upayoga aMgenA vAdanI spaSTatA karI "zraddhA" arthamAM vaparAtA samyagdarzana zabdane paNa spaSTa karI tene samyajJAna svarUpe ja svIkAryo che. tyArabAda "kevalajJAna sAdi-anaMta che" A sUtranuM spaSTIkaraNa karI jIva ane jJAnarUpa jIvanA paryAyo paraspara bhinna che evA ekAMtapakSanuM dRSTAMtapUrvaka khaMDana karI "dravya e paryAyothI ekAMte bhinna nathI" A vAtanuM spaSTIkaraNa karyuM che ane chelle AtmadravyanuM svAbhAvika ane vaibhAvika paryAyo vaDe ekapaNA - anekapaNAnuM varNana karI anekAMtavAdanI sthApanA karIne A kAMDanuM paNa samApana karavAmAM AvyuM che. zeyarUpa trIjA kAMDanI zarUAtamAM ja sAmAnya ane vizeSa paraspara sApekSa ja che ane te baMnene nirapekSapaNe rajU karavAthI zuM prApta thAya tenI spaSTatA karI che. tyArabAda AptavacananuM svarUpa rajU karAyuM che. te pachI koIpaNa paryAyane ekAMte mAnavAmAM Apatti Ave che mATe anekAMtathI ja koIpaNa paryAyane svIkAra karavo joIe te jaNAvI dravya ane guNa vacce ekAMte bheda mAnanAra pUrvapakSanuM ekAMte abheda mAnanAra pakSa dvArA khaMDana karAvI tenuM paNa khaMDana tarkabaddha rIte karavAmAM AvyuM che. tyAra bAda ekAMte bheda tathA ekAMte abheda mAnavA saMbaMdhI prastuta carcAno upasaMhAra karatAM jaNAvyuM che ke, jaina 2010_02

Page #31
26 zAsanamAM ekAMte bheda ke ekAMte abheda mAnya ja nathI. mAtra ziSyanI buddhinA vikAsa mATe ja A vAta rajUAta karavAmAM AvI che. tyAra bAda paramAtmAnA vacanamAM anekAMta siddhAMtanI vyApakatA jaNAvatAM kahyuM che ke, "kharekhara, anekAMta siddhAMta paNa anekAMtathI ja samajAya che." tyArabAda gatiyukta dravya, guNaniSpanna nAmo tathA kuMbha-jIvanAM draSTAMto vaDe anekAMta siddhAMtanuM atyaMta saraLa bhASAmAM spaSTIkaraNa karyuM che. te pachI dravyanA utpAda tathA nAzanuM peTA bhedo dvArA svarUpa varNana, utpAda-nAza ane sthitino kALabhedathI bhedAbheda, eka ja samayamAM utpAda vagere traNanuM dRSTAMta vaDe spaSTIkaraNa, vibhAgathI utpanna thanArA utpAdane nahi mAnanAra vaizeSikamatanuM khaMDana, vibhAgathI thanArA utpAdanuM svarUpa, utpAda-vinAza ane sthitinI samAnatA vagere padArtho 2jU karyA che. tyArabAda hetuvAda ane ahetuvAda (zraddhAvAda) rUpa AgamavAdanuM nirUpaNa karyuM che. siddhAMtanI prarUpaNAmAM kuzaLatA kyAre pragaTe ?, parizuddha ane aparizuddha nayavAdanuM svarUpa ane anya darzanonuM pramANa varNavI sAMkhyadarzana-bauddhadarzana ane vaizeSika darzananI utpatti yA nayane AbhArI che tenI spaSTatA karI te kema khoTA che, tenA kA2Na svarUpa nirapekSatAnuM varNana karyuM che. te pachI kALa vagere kAraNo, nAsti vagere cha mato ane asti vagere cha mato ekAMtadRSTine kAraNe kaI rIte mithyA bane che tenI spaSTatA karI temAM samyakUpaNuM kyAre Ave te mATe anekAMtanI-sApekSatAnI ja mahattA batAvavAmAM AvI che. AgaLa vadhIne anekAMtavAdanuM mahatva jaNAvatAM kahyuM ke, "jo vAdI vAdamAM anekAMtavAdano sahAro na le to te kyAreya jItI zakato nathI ane jo te anekAMtavAdane sahAro le to tene jItavo azakya che." A rIte vAdamAM paNa anekAMtavAdanI ja mahattA darzAvI prarUpaNAmAM paNa tenI mahattA sUcavI che. saMpAdakIya prarUpaNAmAM vivekanI, anekAMtasiddhAMtanA jJAnanI ane sUtra sAthe arthajJAnanI mahattA jaNAvI zAstraparyAlocana upara atyaMta bhAra mUkayo che. AgaLa vadhIne cAritranA sArane pAmavA mATe paNa svapara siddhAMtanA paryAlocananI keTalI mahattA che, te varNavI aMte mAtra jJAnathI ke mAtra kriyAthI mokSa maLavo zakya nathI. paNa "jJAnayiAmyAM mokSaH" jaNAvI chellI gAthAmAM cAra cAra vizeSaNo vaDe zrI jinavacananI kalyANa kAmanA karavAmAM AvI che. A rIte anekAMtavAdanI mahattA, utpAda vibhAganuM svarUpa, dharmavAdanuM svarUpa, anya darzanonI utpattimAM kAraNabhUta nayo, ekAMtadRSTinuM mithyApaNuM, vAdamAM tathA prarUpaNAmAM anekAMtanI AvazyakatA savizeSa varNavI trIjA kAMDanI samApti karavAmAM AvI che. Ama traNe kAMDamAM mukhya anekAMta siddhAMtanI vyApakatA ja savizeSa jovA maLe che. TIkAkAra maharSi-tarkapaMcAnana pUjya AcArya zrI abhayadevasUrIzvarajI mahArAjA TIkAkArazrI caMdrakulIya caMdragacchanA pUjya AcArya zrIpradyumnasUrijI mahArAjAnA ziSya hatA. zrI uttarAdhyayanasUtranI pAIya TIkAnA kartA vAdivetAla pU.A.zrIzAMtisUrijI mahArAjA tarkapaMcAnanazrIjIne . 2010_02

Page #32
saMpAdakIya potAnA pramANa zAstranA gururUpe bahumAnapUrvaka jaNAve che. tarkapaMcAnanazrIjInuM jIvanacaritra anya koI graMthomAM jovA maLela nathI. mAtra nIce jaNAvela graMthonI prazastimAM teozrIjInuM zrIsaMmatisUtranI 25000 zloka pramANa vAdamahArNava TIkAnA kartA svarUpe bahumAnapUrvaka nAmoccAraNa karAyuM che. zrI siddhasenasUrikRta pravacanasAroddhAravRtti zrI mANikayacaMdrasUrikRta pArzvanAthacaritra zrI prabhAcaMdrasUrikRta prabhAvaka caritra vAdivetAla zrI zAMtisUrikRta uttarAdhyayana sUtra pAIyaTIkA TIkAkArazrIjInA anya koI graMtho hovAnuM vizeSa jANavA maLyuM nathI. prazastio vagere dvArA ItihAsane jotAM temanA vidyAziSyo ane dIkSita ziSyono parivAra ghaNo moTo ane vizALa phalakamAM vaheMcAyelo haze, tevuM anumAna karI zakAya che. prastuta prakAzananI AvazyakatA : jainadarzananA mULabhUta anekAMtasiddhAMtanuM sacoTa rIte spaSTa nirUpaNa karatA ane jaina dArzanika graMthomAM sarvocca kakSAnA A graMthanuM adhyayana ane adhyApana sakala zrI jainasaMghamAM ati alpa pramANamAM jovA maLe che. A mahAna graMtharatnanA adhyayana ane adhyApana kSetrathI zrI jaina saMgha aLago rahe te ApaNI khoTa gaNAya. A khoTanuM mukhya kAraNa jovA jaIe to darekanA haiyAmAM zrI saMmatitarka graMthanI bahu agharA dArzanika graMtha tarIkenI ja chApa jovA maLe che. jeNe darzana zAstrono abhyAsa karavo hoya teNe A graMtha vAMcavo. AvI ja vicAraNA savizeSa jovA maLe che. paNa A graMtha mukhyatAe anekAMta siddhAMtanuM prarUpaNa kare che te vAta khyAla bahAra rahI jAya che. vaLI, A graMtha uparanI prAcIna takavaMcAnanazrIjInI 'tattvabodhavidhAyinI' arthAt "vAdamahArNava TIkA upalabdha che. paNa tenuM kada, bhASA, dArzanika carcA vagerenI kaThinatAne kAraNe moTA bhAganA abhyAsu A TIkA sAme AMkha uMcI karI jovAnuM paNa vicArI zakatA nathI. te pachI pU.A. zrI darzanasUrijI ma.sA. dvArA "saMmatitarkamahArNavAvatArikA' nAmanI TIkA racavAmAM AvI hatI. je TIkAmAM dArzanika carcAone sAruM evuM sthAna ApavAmAM AvyuM che ane te pachI vyAkhyAnavAcaspati, kalikulakIriTa pU.A. zrI labdhisUrIzvarajI mahArAjAe saMmatitattvasopAna graMthanuM saMpAdana karyuM hatuM. jemAM temaNe tarkapacAnanazrIjInI mukhya TIkAne ja nAnA-nAnA praznottara paddhatimAM DhALI pUrvapakSa tathA uttarapakSa samajavo saraLa paDe tevI mahenata karI che. paNa baMne TIkAmAM anekAMtasiddhAMtanI spaSTatAnI sAthosAtha dArzanika carcAone paNa pUratuM sthAna ApeluM hovAthI vartamAnakALamAM dArzanika bodhanI ruci vinAnA jIvo tenAthI dUra ja rahevAnuM pasaMda kare che. A be TIkA uparAMta, paM. sukhalAle gujarAtI bhASAmAM gAthArtha ane 2010_02

Page #33
28 sAmAnya bhAvArtha sAthenA pustakanuM saMpAdana karela che, paNa te arthabodha mATe eTaluM paryApta na jaNAyuM. tethI varSo pUrve saMmatitarka graMthanuM viziSTa saMpAdana karavAnI meM bhAvelI bhAvanA prabaLa banI hatI. varSo pUrve A aMgenuM je kAMI sAhitya ane saMzodhanAdinI sAmagrI ekatrita karI hatI paNa anya kAryavyastatA vaza kArya thaI zakyuM na hatuM. chelle varSa pahelAM paM. dhIrUbhAIe paNa saMmatitarka graMtha vAMcavA abhyAsuo prerAya te mATe zakya saraLa bhASAmAM - potAnI zailIthI gujarAtI bhASAmAM vivecana taiyA2 karyuM hatuM, je temaNe mane jovA mATe mokalAvyuM hatuM ane te vakhate gAthArtha - padArthamAM jarUrI pheraphAro temane sUcavyA hatA. prAyaH mujaba sudhA2o ka2vAno temaNe prayatna paNa karyo hato. temanA dvArA karAyeluM e vivecana tapAsatI vakhate varSo pUrve sevelI bhAvanA prabaLa banatAM kArya zarU karyuM. jemAM mAtra mULabhUta gAthAone sa2La-saMskRta bhASAmAM samajAve tevI akSaragamanikA TIkA banAvIne mUkavAnuM paNa nakkI karyuM. je sAdhakoe mAtra maMDanAtmaka anekAMta siddhAMta samajavo hoya, nyAyazailIthI je ajANa hoya, viziSTa dArzanika bodhanI jemanI ruci na hoya, saMkSepamAM gAthArtha-padArtha jeNe jANavA hoya - temanA mATe A navatara pArzvaprabhA TIkAgraMtha upakAraka banaze tevI AzA rAkhuM chuM. graMtha saMpAdana paddhati : saMpAdakIya prastuta prakAzanamAM ame graMthane be bhAgamAM 2jU karyo che. prathama bhAgamAM tarkapaMcAnanazrIjInI TIkAnA maryAdita bhAgano samAveza karyo che. 25000 zloka pramANa tarka paMcAnanazrIjInI TIkAmAM gAthAnA pratyeka padono arthabodha karAvI, tad viSayaka vAda utthita ka2vAmAM Avyo che ane te vAdanI samApti bAda anya padono arthabodha karAvyo che. jethI mAtra gAthAnA padono arthabodha ka2vAnI bhAvanAvALAne durAnvaya thAya che mATe tarkapaMcAnanazrIjInI TIkAmAMthI ja mAtra mULagAthAnA padonA bhAvane spaSTa karatI paMktiono saMgraha ka2I mULasparzI TIkA jevuM svarUpa A bhAgamAM taiyAra karyuM che. A saMkalanamAM eka paNa pada-vAkya vagere potIkuM ume2vAmAM AvyuM nathI. tarkapaMcAnanazrIjInA zabdono ja saMpUrNatayA upayoga karAyo che. AnI sAthe ja anya je paNa graMthomAM saMmatitarkagraMthanI gAthAonuM uddharaNa maLyuM che, te sarve sthAnono ahIM saMgraha karAyo che. te te graMthomAM mukhyatayA saghaLe sthAne te te gAthAnA artha ane padArthane paNa spaSTa karela che. to kyAMka mAtra dizAnirdeza tarIke sAkSIpATha tarIke paNa upayoga thayo che. te te graMthakArazrIo jyAM jyAM saMmatino AdhAra laI te gAthAnA padArthone kholyA che te sarvano ahIM saMgraha karyo che. tevA saMgrahamAM AgamanI TIkAo, samarthazAstrakAraziromaNi pU. AcArya zrI haribhadrasUrIzvarajI mahArAjAnA graMtho tathA TIkAo, kalikAlasarvajJa pUjya AcArya zrIhemacaMdrasUrIzvarajI mahArAjAnI TIkAo, vAdivetAla pUjya AcAryazrI zAMtisUrIzvarajI mahArAjAnI TIkAo, nyAyAcArya-nyAyavizArada pUjya mahAmahopAdhyAya zrIyazovijayajI mahArAjAnA graMtho tathA TIkAo, digaMbara saMpradAyanA graMtho vageremAMthI uddharaNa karI ame teno samAveza karAyo che. savizeSa jovA jaIe to mahAmahopAdhyAyazrIjInA graMthomAM vizeSa A graMtha-gAthAno upayoga . 2010_02

Page #34
saMpAdakIya thayelo jovA maLe che. temAM jJAnabiMdu jevA keTalAka graMtho to A graMthanA AdhAre ja racelA jovA maLe che. to vaLI, anekAMta vyavasthApakaraNa, zAstravArtA-samuccaya uparanI syAdvAda kalpalatA TIkA vageremAM paNa A graMthano savizeSa AdhAra lIdho hoya tevuM jovA maLe che. zakya te sarveno atre samAveza karavAno prayatna karyo che. A saMgraha mATe ame paM. sukhalAla saMpAdita saMmatitarka graMthanA pAMcamA bhAgamAM Apela pariziSTano tathA pU.A.zrI darzanasUrijI ma. saMpAdita saMmatitaka mahArNavAvatArikA graMthamAM ApelI noMdhano paNa upayoga karyo che. te uparAMta anya ghaNA sthAnomAMthI A graMthagAthAnI TIkA tathA uddharaNo ame meLavyAM che te sarvenI noMdha karI teno ame pariziSTa-1 svarUpe prathama bhAgamAM ullekha karyo che. A sivAya paNa jo koIne koI graMthamAM A graMthanuM koIpaNa uddharaNa maLe to amane cokkasapaNe jaNAvavA vinaMtI, jethI punaH prakAzana vakhate teno upayoga karI zakAya. A uparAMta prathama bhAgamAM je je gAthAonA zabdomAM anya graMthomAM Apela uddharaNa sAthe pheraphAra jaNAyo che te te pheraphArano pAThAMtara svarUpe TippaNamAM ullekha karela che. A rIte mAtra pUrvocAryonA zabdo dvArA ja saMmatitarka graMthanI gAthAono arthabodha karAvato hovAthI amoe prathama bhAganI prAcIna vibhAga tarIke oLakhANa ApI che. bIjA bhAgamAM saMskRta pArthaprabhA TIkA tathA gujarAtI bhASAMtarano samAveza karyo che. te paikI prathama pArthaprabhA TIkA rajU karavAmAM AvI che. jemAM prAcIna je je TIkAo prApta thaI che, tene AdhAre tathA zakya prayatna tenA karatAM paNa vadhu saraLa zabdo dvArA saraLatAthI arthabodha thAya tenuM khAsa dhyAna rAkhyuM che ane tyAra bAda DhuM tAtparyam | vagere kahI gAthAno bhAvArtha saMskRta-sugama bhASAmAM rajU karyo che. jethI AgaLa pAchaLanI gAthAnA anusaMdhAnapUrvaka gAthAno zuM bhAva che te alpa prayatna samajI zakAze. tyAra bAda bIjA naMbare gujarAtI bhASAMtara vagere che. jemAM gAthAnI chAyA-anvayArtha-gAthArtha ane tAtparyArtha ApavAmAM Avela che. bhASAMtaramAM je gAthAo anusaMdhAnavALI jaNAI temAM paraspara gAthAnA joDANapUrvaka arthasaMkalanA karavI yogya jaNAvAthI te gAthAono gAthArtha tathA tAtparyArtha eka sAthe ApavAmAM Avela che. A bhAgamAM saMskRta pArthaprabhA TIkA tathA bhASAMtara baMne ekasAthe ApavAmAM Avela che. jethI jijJAsuonI baMne prakAranI jijJAsA eka sAthe saMtoSI zakAze. A sarva vibhAgone khyAlamAM rAkhI bIjA bhAganI amoe arvAcInavibhAga svarUpe oLakhANa ApI che. A graMthanA mupha saMzodhanAdimAM vidvAna munirAja zrI vairAgyarati vi. ma., vidvAna munirAja zrI saMyamakIrti vi.ma., viduSI sA. zrI prazamitAzrIjI ma., viduSI sA. zrI caMdanabALAzrIjI ma.vageree karela sahAya A prasaMge bhUlAya tema nathI ane teoe jaNAvela sUcanono zakya samAveza karavAno prayatna karyo che. vizeSa mArA ziSya vartuLa ane emAMya munirAja zrI maMgaLayazavijayajIe savizeSapaNe je rIte A graMthanA saMkalana-saMpAdana kAryamAM - prapho jovA vageremAM je jahemata karI che te atyaMta anumodanIya che. 2010 02

Page #35
30 Aja rIte pUrvAcArya racita vibhinna graMthonA saMzodhana-saMpAdana vageremAM jIvanano amUlya samaya phALavI te te graMthomAM jaNAvela AcAra-vicAra-pariNati dvArA potAno AtmavikAsa sAdhe e ja eka bhAvanA bhAvuM chuM. saMpAdakIya mane paNa A graMthanA adhyayana, saMzodhana, saMpAdana ane navatara2canAnI puNyapaLomAM apAra prasannatAnI je anubhUtio thaI che tene zabdadeha Apavo asaMbhava che. A prasaMge syAdvAda siddhAMtanA prakAzakomAM ziromaNi tIrthaMkara 52mAtmAo, zrI gaNadhara bhagavaMto, cauda Adi pUrvadhara bhagavaMto, viziSTa zrutadhara sUri-vAcaka munivaro, saMmatitarka mahAgranthanA racayitA zrutakevalI pU.A.zrI siddhasenadivAkarasUrIzvarajI mahArAjA, vAdamahArNava TIkAnA raciyatA tarkapaMcAnana pU.A.zrI abhayadevasUrIzvarajI mahArAjA, suvihita ziromaNi pU.A.zrI haribhadrasUrIzvarajI mahArAjA, saMmatitarka graMthanuM 'atha'thI 'Iti' sudhi Acamana karanArA mArA parokSa gurudeva nyAyAcArya-nyAya vizArada-pUjya mahAmahopAdhyAya zrI yazovijayajI gaNivara Adi mahApuruSonA caraNomAM koTikoTi vaMdanA saha smaraNapathamAM saMsthApita karuM chuM. to vaLI, mane samyagdarzanano ekaDo ghuMTADI jagatanA vAstavika svarUpano yathArthabodha karAvanArA, saMgha sanmArga darzaka, anekAMtabhAsa timirataraNI, dIkSAyuga pravartaka, pravaragItArtha, vyAkhyAna vAcaspati, tapAgacchAdhirAja pUjyapAda AcAryadeveza zrImad vijaya rAmacaMdrasUrIzvarajI mahArAjAnAM pAvana caraNomAM zraddhA sumana samarpita karuM che. mArA jIvananA pratyeka satkAryomAM teozrInI anugrahadhArA niraMtara varasI rahI che, evo anubhava meM satata karyo che ane karI rahyo chuM. teo zrImadnI paramakRpAthI A mahatkArya alpAvadhimAM pUrNa thayuM chuM. vizasthAnakatapaprabhAvaka, vardhamAnataponidhi, pravara tapasvI, satata tapa-japa-svAdhyAyamagna, Azritajana kalyANakAMkSI, saune suvizuddha saMyamI banAvI zivasukhanA svAmI banAvuM evI bhavyabhAvanAmAM dinarAta tallIna evA mA2A 52matA2ka gurudeva pUjyapAda AcAryadevazrImad vijaya guNayazasUrIzvarajI mahArAjAnuM pAvana smaraNa mArA AtmAnA pratyeka pradezone pulakIta kahe che. kAraNa ke, mArA samagra jIvananA ghaDataranI jema A saMpAdana-navIna racanAnuM kArya paNa teozrIjInA pratyakSa sAMnidhyamAM ja saMpanna thayuM che. A mahAna graMthanA bhAvone jANavA prakAzavA e atizaya kaThIna hovA chatAM 'zume yathAzakti yatanIyam' e nyAye sva-52nA kalyANa mATe tathA nyAyazailIthI ajANa, dArzanika carcAnI rucino abhAva hoya chatAM jaina zAsananA maulika anekAMta siddhAMta-naya-pramANa vagere padArtho jANAvAnI tIvra jhaMkhanAvALA sAdhako A graMthanA abhyAsa dvArA jIvananA pratyeka vyavahAromAM anekAMta siddhAMtano upayoga karI jIvanane paramAtmAnI AjJAmaya banAve tevA ekamAtra AzayathI A graMthanuM saMpAdana-racanA-kArya karavAmAM AvyuM che. 2010_02

Page #36
saMpAdakIya nirmaLabhAve zakti anusAre karAyela A zubha yatnamAM jyAM kyAMya paNa vItarAga paramAtmAnA vacanathI ke graMthakAra, vRttikAra maharSinA AzayathI viparIta AlekhAyuM hoya to te aMge nirmaLa bhAvane varelA adhikRta vidvAno dhyAna dorI upakRta kare tevI vinaMtI karuM chuM. temanA dvArA jo koI tevI kSati batAvAze to sAbhAra teno svIkAra karI AgaLanI AvRttimAM ane zakya hoya tyAM sudhI cAlu AvRttimAM paNa tvarita teno sudhA2o ka2vAmAM Avaze. saMgha sthavira pU.A.zrI vijaya siddhisUrIzvarajI (bApajI) mahArAjAnI 50mI svargArohaNatithidina, zeTha zrI motIzA lAlabAga jaina saMgha, bhUlezvara, muMbaI. vi.saM. 2065, bhAdaravA vada 14 2010_02 saMghasanmArgadarzaka, samatvayoganA svAmI, vyAkhyAnavAcaspati, tapAgacchAdhirAja pUjyapAda AcAryadeveza 31 zrImad vijaya rAmacaMdrasUrIzvarajI mahArAjAnA ziSyottama vizasthAnaka tapaprabhAvaka vardhamAnataponidhi AjIvana gurucaraNasevI pUjyapAda AcAryadeveza zrImad vijaya guNayazasUrIzvarajI mahArAjAno caraNasevaka AcArya vijaya kIrtiyazasUri.

Page #37
saMmatitarkaprakaraNam - bhAga-1, anukramaNikA |kAMDa-1) gAthA viSaya 5tra | V 9 P ) S 32 , 38 1 jaina zAsananI stavanArUpa maMgalAcaraNa 2 graMtha racanAno uddeza 3 mukhya be nayo-dravyAstikanaya ane paryAyAstikana, bAkInA nayo tenA bheda svarUpa che. ja dravyAstikanayanA bhedo - saMgraha ane vyavahAra 5 paryAyAstikanayanA bhedo-RjusUtra vagere cAra navo 6 nikSepAomAM nayonI vyApakatA 7 mukhya nayo nirapekSa hoya to miththArUpa che. 8 baMne nayono sAdhAraNa viSaya arthAt jJAnanI anekAMtatA 9 vivakSAthI ja nayono bheda 10 anya nayano viSaya anya naya mATe aviSayabhUta 11 paraspara nirapekSa baMne nayone mAnya vastunuM bhinna bhinna svarUpa 12 paraspara nirapekSa dravya ane paryAyano abhAva jaNAvavApUrvaka dravyanuM lakSaNa 13 utpAda vagere traNe lakSaNa bane kyAre ? 14 baMne nayo anekAMta svarUpa banavAmAM kAraNa 15 nirapekSa evA sarvanayo durnaya thavAnuM kAraNa 16 mULanayone dUSita karavAthI anyanayo paNa dUSita thavAnuM kAraNa 17 nirapekSa evA koIpaNa eka nayamAM saMsAra na ghaTavAnuM kAraNa 18 nirapekSa evA koIpaNa eka nayamAM sukha duHkhano saMbaMdha na ghaTavAnuM kAraNa 19 nirapekSa evA koIpaNa eka nayamAM karmabaMdha-sthiti na ghaTavAnuM kAraNa 20 karmabaMdhanA abhAve saMsAra-mokSa na ghaTI zake 21 sarvanaya samyaktvanA kAraNe kyAre bane ? 22 ratnonA dRSTAMtathI nirapekSa no samyaka banatAM nathI tenuM kathana 23 ratnonA dRSTAMtathI nirapekSa naya samyaku banatAM nathI tenuM kathana 24 ratnAvalInA dRSTAMtathI sApekSa no samyak bane che tenuM kathana 25 ratnAvalInA dRSTAMtathI sApekSa naya samyaka bane che tenuM kathana 39 40 40 41 41 42, 43 44 47 47 48 48 2010_02

Page #38
anukramaNikA gAthA patra paO pa1 pa3 pa7 paNa = 0 ) 0 ne ) 9 je te ) 67 viSaya (kAMDa-1) 26 dRSTAMtanA guNo 27 kArya-kAraNa aMge pracalita anya darzananI mithyA mAnyatAonuM khaMDana 28 potAnAthI anya nayanuM khaMDana karanArA nayo mithyA svarUpa 29 baMne mULa nayonI viSayamaryAdA 30 paryAyAstika nayanA viSaya svarUpa bhedanuM vizeSa varNana 31 eka dravya aneka thavAnuM kAraNa 32 vyaMjanaparyAya ane arthaparyAyanuM dRSTAMta 33 dravyane ekAMte eka athavA aneka mAnavAmAM AvatA doSo 34 vyaMjanaparyAya ane arthaparyAyano viSaya tathA upasaMhAra 35 anekAMta vastumAM ekAMtatvanuM kathana vakatAnI ajJAnatAne sUcavanAra 36 saptabhaMgInA prathama 3 bhaMga 37 saptabhaMgIno cotho bhaMga saptabhaMgIno pAMcamo bhaMga 39 saptabhaMgIno chaThTho bhaMga 40 saptabhaMgIno sAtamo bhaMga 41 vyaMjanaparyAyamAM ane arthaparyAyamAM saptabhaMgInuM svarUpa 4ra mAtra paryAyanayanI dezanAmAM pUrNatAno abhAva 43 mAtra dravyAstikanayanI dezanAnuM svarUpa 44 nirapekSa dravyAstikanayamAM pUrNatAno abhAva 45 puruSarUpa dRSTAMtamAM bhedabheda saMbaMdhanuM kathana 46 dRSTAMta-dASTratikabhAva 47 pANI ane dUdhanA dRSTAMtathI jIva ane karmanA avibhAganuM kathana 48 jIvana ane karmane Azrita jJAnAdi tathA rUpAdinuM paNa avibhAganuM kathana 49 jIva ane pudgalanA ekamekapaNAthI thatA zAstrIya vyavahAro 50 jaina zAsanamAM bAhya ane atyaMtaranA vibhAganI spaSTatA 51 dravyAstikanaya ane paryAyAstikanayanI prarUpaNA para nirapekSa evA dravyAstikanaya ane paryAyAstikanayanI prarUpaNAnuM phaLa 53 jaina zAsananI autsargika prarUpaNAnuM svarUpa pa4 jaina zAsananI apavAdika prarUpaNAnuM svarUpa (n < Ta ( (c) 9 0 - 9 2010 02

Page #39
anukramaNikA | kAMDa-2) gAthA viSaya 5tra 97 - - 100 104 105 1 darzana ane jJAnanuM svarUpa 2 darzanamAM vizeSa sApekSa sAmAnyabodha ane jJAnamAM sAmAnya sApekSa vizeSabodha 3 sahavAda pakSanuM sthApana : chabasthanA jJAna ane darzana bhinnakAlIna, kevalInA jJAna ane darzana samakAlIna 4 kramavAdipakSa ane sahavAdIe karela tenuM khaMDana : kramavAda = kevalImAM jJAna ane darzana kramika sahavAda = 1-kramavAdI tIrthakaranI AzAtanAthI DaratA nathI. Agama sUtranuM arthaghaTana, samai - tunyam 5 ra-anumAnathI khaMDana kevalajJAnAvaraNIyanA nAzathI kevalajJAnanI jema kevaladarzanAvaraNIyanA nAzathI te ja kALe kevaladarzananI utpatti 6 3 - anumAnathI khaMDana : matijJAnAvaraNIya vagerenA nAzathI matijJAna vagere jema bhinna na ghaTe tema kevaladarzanano paNa bhinna asaMbhava. 7 4 - AgamathI khaMDana : kevalajJAna sAdi - anaMta che. jJAna ane darzanane kramika mAnatAM jJAnanI hAjarImAM darzana ane darzananI hAjarImAM jJAna na saMbhavatAM baMne sAdi-sAMta mAnavA paDaze. 8 5 - tarkathI khaMDana : kramika mAnazo to bemAMthI pahelI utpatti konI ? sahavAdi pakSanuM arthaghaTana tathA ekopayogavAdI graMthakAra dvArA tenuM khaMDana 9 sahavAdi = baMnenI utpatti eka ja samaye siddhAMti = 1-eka ja samaye be upayogano asaMbhava 10 2 - dareka samaye sarvajJa - sarvadarzI mAnavA paDe athavA dareka samaye sarvajJa-sarvadarzI nathI, evuM mAnavuM paDe. 11 3 - jJAna bhakta che ane darzana avyakta che, kevalIne vyakta-avyaktano bheda kaI rIte ghaTe ? 106 108 108 110 111 2010_02

Page #40
35 anukramaNikA patra 112 113 114 115 116 118 119 gAthA viSaya (kAMDa-2) 12 4 - kramavAdImate eka samaye jJAtadaSTa bole che te ghaTatuM nathI, sahavAdImate eka samaye aSTajJAta bolaze athavA ajJAtadaSTa bolaze tevuM mAnavuM paDaze. 13 5 - ajJAtavastu daSTa thaI ane adRSTavastu jJAta thaI. to pachI sarvajJapaNuM kaI rIte ghaTe ? 14 6 - baMne anaMta hovA chatAM jJAnathI darzana alpa ghaTaze. 15 kramavAdi = upayoga kramika hovA chatAM zaktithI jema cAra jJAnI kahevAya, tema kevalajJAna-kevaladarzana ghaTe. siddhAMti = jema kevalI paMcajJAnI na ghaTe, tema bhedathI jJAnavAna darzanavAnuM paNa na ghaTe. - 16-17 cAra jJAnanA daSTAMtanuM spaSTIkaraNa : cAre jJAnano viSaya parimita hovAthI temAM kramika upayoga ghaTe. paNa kevalajJAna-darzanano viSaya aparimita hovAthI kramika upayoga na ghaTe. 18 siddhAMti = artha mujaba ja sUtranI vyAkhyA karavAthI Agamavirodha nahi ghaTe. 19 kevalajJAnathI kevaladarzananA bhinna ullekhanuM kAraNa : 1-mana:paryAyajJAnamAM mAtra vizeSano bodha che. jyAre kevala upayogamAM sAmAnya ane vizeSa ubhayano bodha che. 20 2- AgamamAM darzananA cAra bheda kahyA che. 21-22 ekadezImata mujaba darzana-zAnanuM svarUpa: jema matijJAnamAM avagraha mAtrane darzana ane vizeSitabodhane jJAna kahevAya, tema kevalajJAna-darzanamAM taphAvata samajavo. darzanapUrvaka jJAna che. paNa jJAnapUrvaka darzana nathI, mATe be vacce kathaMcit bheda che. 23-24 ekadezImatamAM AvatA doSo : zAstramAM jJAnanA ATha bheda che. jyAre darzananA cAra bheda che. zAstramAM zrotradarzana - zrotajJAna AvA bhedanI prasiddhi nathI. cakSudarzana ane cAkSuSajJAna bhedanI zAstramAM prasiddhi 25 cakSudarzana ane acakSudarzana zabdano artha : aspaSTa - aviSayabhUta padArthano bodha te darzana 1ra0 121 121 1 24 125 2010_02

Page #41
36 gAthA viSaya (kAMDa-2) 26 pUrvapakSa = A vyAkhyA mujaba manaHparyAyajJAnane paNa darzana kahevAnI Apatti Avaze. siddhAMti = mana:paryAyajJAnano viSaya manodravya che. ghaTa vagere dravya nathI. jJAna e ja darzana svarUpe che. 27 28 zrutajJAnamAM pratyakSabodhano abhAva hovAthI 'darzana' zabda na saMbhave. 30 29 avadhijJAnamAM pratyakSa bodha hovAthI 'darzana' zabda saMbhave. kevalajJAnamAM paNa pratyakSa bodha hovAthI 'darzana' zabda saMbhave. 31 niSkarSarUpe svasiddhAMta ane parasiddhAMtanuM spaSTIkaraNa. svasiddhAMta = eka ja kevalopayoga baMne svarUpe che. parasiddhAMta kevalajJAna ane kevaladarzana kramika utpanna thAya che. 3333 33 'samyagdarzana' zabdanuM spaSTIkaraNa 32 zraddhA arthamAM vaparAto 'samyagdarzana' zabda samyajJAna svarUpa ja che. samyajJAna ane samyagdarzana baMne arthathI ekarUpa ja ghaTe che. 'kevalajJAna sAdi-anaMta che' A sUtranuM spaSTIkaraNa H - 34 pUrvapakSa = kevalajJAna Adi-anaMta hovAthI teno nAza ghaTI zake nahi. 35 siddhAMti = 1-siddhi pAmatAM samaye kevalI bhagavaMtanA saMghayaNa vagere nAza pAmatAM hovAthI tenAthI abhinna kevalIparyAya paNa nAza pAme che. (kevalajJAnano nAza) 2-siddhapaNAnI utpatti sAthe kevalI paryAya paNa utpanna thAya che. = 36 (kevalajJAnanI utpatti) 3 - sattArUpe kevalIparyAya sAdi-anaMta che. (kevalajJAnanuM dhruvapaNuM) jIva ane tenA jJAnAdi paryAyo bhinna hovAnI zaMkAnuM spaSTIkaraNa 37 pUrvapakSa = jIva anAdi anaMta che ane kevalajJAna sAdi anaMta che, mATe jIva kevalajJAnarUpa kaI rIte ghaTe 38 pUrvapakSa = tethI jIva bhinna che ane tenA jJAnAdi paryAyo paNa bhinna che. 39 siddhAMti = ekAMtapakSanuM khaMDanapUrvamAM thaI cUkyuM che have dRSTAMta kahevAze. 40-41 dRSTAMta vaDe padArthanuM spaSTIkaraNa 42 dravya e paryAyathI ekAMte bhinna nathI 43 Atma dravyanuM svAbhAvika ane vaibhAvika paryAyo vaDe ekapaNA-anekapaNAnuM varNana . 2010_02 anukramaNikA patra 126 127 128 128 129 132 133 134 137 137 138 138 138 139 139 140 141

Page #42
anukramaNikA kAMDa-3 | gAthA viSaya patra 143 144 145 146 146 148 149 150 153 154 154 155 1 paraspara joDAyelA sAmAnya ane vizeSanuM varNana 2 sAmAnya ane vizeSanuM nirapekSapaNe rajU karavAnuM phaLa 3 AptavacananuM svarUpa 4 dravya je svarUpe pariNata thayuM che tenuM varNana 5 padArthanuM astitva tathA nAstitvamAM niyAmaka tattva 6 ekAMte vartamAnaparyAya mAnatAM AvatI ApattinuM nirAkaraNa 7 eka puruSamAM bhedabhedanI vyavasthA dravya ane guNa vacce ekAMte bheda mAnanAra pUrvapakSanuM khaMDana 8 pUrvapakSa = dravya ane guNa vacce ekAMte bheda che | uttarapakSa = guNa zabdanA viSayamAM parIkSA karavA yogya che. 10 guNAstika nayanuM akathana 11 paryAyo guNathI judA nathI 12 paryAya ane guNanI vyAkhyAmAM samAnatA 13 pUrvapakSa=AgamamAM guNArthika naya paNa upadezAmela che. 14 uttarapakSa=AgamamAM karela guNa zabdanuM spaSTIkaraNa 15 dRSTAMta vaDe guNa zabdanuM spaSTIkaraNa dravya ane guNa vacce ekAMte abheda mAnanArA pakSanuM khaMDana 16 pUrvapakSa=dravya-guNano ekAMte abheda 17 pUrvapakSa=dRSTAMtapUrvaka ekAMta abhedanuM spaSTIkaraNa 18 pUrvapakSa=dRSTAMta-dASTratikabhAva 19 siddhAMtapakSa-saMbaMdhathI pitA vagere baeNvahAra ghaTe paNa nAnA-moTAno vyavahAra kaI rIte ghaTe ? 20 pUrvapakSa=vizeSa saMbaMdhathI te paNa ghaTaze. 21 siddhAMtapakSa=vizeSa saMbaMdhathI vizeSa pariNAmanI aghaTamAnatA 22 dravyamAM thatI viSamatAnuM kAraNa 23 ekAMta bhedavAdIe rajU karela dravya-guNanuM bIjuM lakSaNa ane tenA bhedavAdanI samAlocanA 156 157 157 158 158 158 160 161 0 161 162 0 163 2010_02

Page #43
anukramaNikA | | " patra 164 165 166 137 171 174 176 177 178 180 34 182 184 186 gAthA viSaya (kAMDa-3). 24 ekAMta bhedavAdIe rajU karela dravya-guNanuM bIjuM lakSaNa ane tenA bhedavAdanI samAlocanA 25 ekAMta bheda tathA ekAMta abheda saMbaMdhI prastuta carcAnuM prayojana 26 zrI jinopadezamAM ekAMta bhedavAda tathA ekAMta amedavAdano abhAva anekAMta siddhAMta paNa anekAMtathI ja samajAya 28 anekAMtanI vyApakatA 29 anekAMtane vyApaka jaNAvanAra gatiyukta dravyanuM dRSTAMta 30 anekAMtane vyApaka jaNAvanArA guNaniSpanna nAmonuM dRSTAMta anekAMtane vyApaka jaNAvanAra kuMbha ane jIvanuM dRSTAMta dravyanA utpAdanuM svarUpa 33 svAbhAvika utpAdanuM svarUpa dravyanA nAzanuM svarUpa 35 utpAda-nAza-sthitino kALabhedathI bhedAbheda 36 eka ja samayamAM utpAda vagere traNanuM dRSTAMta vaDe spaSTIkaraNa eka ja dravya traNe kALanA viSayathI viziSTa 38 vibhAgaja utpAdane nahi mAnanAra vaizeSikamatanI rajUAta vibhAgathI thanArA utpAdanuM svarUpa 40 eka dravyanA vibhAgathI aneka dravyanI utpatti 41 utpAda-vinAza-sthitinI samAnatA 42 dravyanA utpAdanA prakAro 43 hetuvAda ane ahetuvAdarUpa dharmAvAda 44 hetuvAdarUpa dharmAvAdanuM svarUpa 45 ' siddhAMtanI prarUpaNAmAM kuzaLatA kyAre ? 46 parizuddha ane aparizuddha nayavAdanuM svarUpa 47 jeTalAM vacana mArgo teTalAM paradarzano 48 sAMkhyadarzana ane bauddhadarzananA AdhArabhUta nayo 49 vaizeSikamatanA zAstro mithyA hovAnA kAraNo 50 nirapekSa nayane Azrita matomAM mithyAtvano avinAbhAva 51 sApekSa tathA nirapekSanayonuM phaLa 187 39 19) 191 192 193 194 195 198 198 202 203 206 207 210 210 2010_02

Page #44
39 anukramaNikA 5tra 211 213 218 220 gAthA viSaya (kAMDa-3) para ghaTa dRSTAMta vaDe spaSTIkaraNa pa3 kALa vagere kAraNonuM mithyApaNuM ane samyaphapaNuM 54 nAsti vagere cha matonuM mithyApaNuM pa5 masti vagere cha matonuM mithyApaNuM paka anekAMtadRSTinA abhAve vAdamAM AvatA doSo 57 nayomAM sApekSatA tathA nirapekSatAnuM phaLa pa8 vAdamAM anekAMtavAdIne jItavo azakya vAdamAM kuzaLatAnA kAraNo 60 syAdvAda prarUpaNAno mArga 61 viveka vagarano Agamabodha ajJatAno sUcaka che 62 viveka vagaranA AgamabodhanuM phaLa 63 siddhAMta prarUpaNAnA adhikArInA lakSaNo 64 arthanuM jJAna nayavAdathI ja thAya upa sUtrajJAtAe arthaprAptimAM prayatna karavo zAstraparyAlocana vagaranA bAhya ADaMbaramAM AvatA doSo sva-para siddhAMtanI vicAraNA vagara cAritranA sAranI aprApti 68 mAtra jJAna ke mAtra kriyAthI mokSano abhAva 69 jinavacananI kalyANa kAmanA 221 222 223 224 224 225 225 226 227 227 228 230 235 236 2010_02

Page #45
2010_02 saMmatitarkaprakaraNam bhAga-1 [ prAcInavibhAgaH ] [ pUrvAcAryaviracitavRttisamanvitam ] sUcanam mudraNavyavasthAdoSena 'zca' sthAne 'pTA' abhavat / tena granthamadhye yatra yatra 'pTA' dRzyate tatra tatra 'zca' paThanIyaH /

Page #46
rAjagacchIya-tarkapaJcAnana-zrImadabhayadevasUrinirmitatattvabodhavidhAyinyAkhyAyAH vyAkhyAyAH mUlagAthAsparzivyAkhyAMzasahitaM katipayamUlagAthAnAM ca vibhinnagrantheSu tattadgranthakAraiH kAritAbhirvRttibhiryuktaM mahAdArzanikaziromaNivikramAdityAdinRpatipratibodhakazrIsiddhasenadivAkararacitaM saMmatitarka-prakaraNam / prathamaH kANDaH / sphuradvAgaMzuvidhvastamohAndhatamasodayam | vardhamAnArkamabhyarcya yate sammativRttaye / / 1 / / prajJAvadbhiryadyapi sammatiTIkAH kRtAH subahvAH / tAbhyastathA'pi na mahAnupakAraH svalpabuddhInAm / / 2 / / zemuSyunmeSalavaM teSAmAdhAtumAzrito yatnaH / mandamatinA mayA'pyeSa nAtra saMpatsyate viphala: / / 3 / / 'iha ca zArIra-mAnasAnekaduHkhadAridropadravavidrutAnAM nirupamA'natizayAnantazivasukhAnanyasamA'vandhyakAraNasamyagjJAna-darzana-cAritrAtmakaparamaratnatrayajighRkSayA atigambhIrajinavacanamahodadhimavatarItukAmAnAM tadavataraNopAyamaviduSAM bhavyasattvAnAM taddarzanena teSAM mahAnupakAraH pravarttatAm, tatpUrvakapTAtmopakAraH' iti manvAna AcAryo duSSamA'rasamAzyAmAsamayodbhUtasamastajanatAhArdasaMtamasavidhvaMsakatvenAvAptayathArthAbhidhAnaH siddhasenadivAkarastadupAyabhUtasammatyAkhyaprakaraNakaraNe pravarttamAnaH "ziSTAH kvacidabhISTe vastuni pravarttamAnA abhISTadevatAvizeSastavavidhAnapurassaraM pravarttante" iti tatsamayaparipAlanaparastadvidhAnodbhUtaprakRSTazubhabhAvAnalpajvaladanalanirdagdhapracuratarakliSTakarmAvirbhUtaviziSTapariNatiprabhavAM prastutaprakaraNaparisamAptiM cA''kalayan 'arhatAmapyarhattA zAsanapUrvikA, pUjitapUjakapTA lokaH, vinayamUlapTA svargA-'pavargAdisukhasumanaHsamUhAnandAmRtarasodagrasvarUpaprAptisvabhAvaphalapradAnapratyalo dharmakalpadrumaH' iti pradarzanaparairbhuvanagurubhirapyavAptAmalakevalajJAnasaMpadbhistIrthakRdbhiH zAsanArthAbhivyaktikaraNasamaye vihitastavatvAt 'zAsana ___JainEducation International 2010_02

Page #47
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-1 matizayataH stavArham' iti niSTiAnvan 'asAdhAraNaguNotkIrtanasvarUpa eva ca pAramArthikastavaH' iti ca saMpradhArya zAsanasyAbhISTadevatAvizeSasya pradhAnabhUtasiddhatva-kusamayavizAsitvA'rhatpraNItatvAdiguNaprakAzanadvAreNa stavAbhidhAyikAM gAthAmAha siddhaM siddhatthANaM ThANamaNovamasuhaM uvagayANaM / kusamayavisAsaNaM sAsaNaM jiNANaM bhavajiNANaM / / 1 / / ___ asyApTA samudAyArtha etatpAtanikayaiva prakAzita;, avayavArthastu prakAzyate-zAsyante jIvAdayaH padArthA yathAvasthitatvena aneneti zAsana dvAdazAGgam, taJca siddhaM pratiSThitamniSTiAtaprAmANyamiti yAvat-svamahimnaiva, nAtaH prakaraNAt pratiSThApyam / [S.T.P. 1] zabdasamutthasya tu abhidheyaviSayajJAnasya yadi prAmANyamabhyupagamyate tadA apauruSeyatvasyAsambhavAd guNavatpuruSapraNItastadutpAdakaH zabdo'bhyupagantavyaH, atha tatpraNItatvaM nAbhyupagamyate tadA tatsamutthajJAnasya prAmANyamapi na syAdityabhiprAyavAnAcAryaH prAha-jinAnAm rAga-dveSamohalakSaNAn zatrUn jitavanta iti jinAsteSAM zAsanaM tadabhyupagantavyamiti prasaGgasAdhanam / [S.T.P. 29] athApi syAt-svaviSayAvisaMvAdivacanavizeSasya tadviSayAvisaMvAdijJAnapUrvakatvamAtrameva bhavatA prasAdhitam, na caitAvatA'nantArthasAkSAtkArijJAnavAn sarvajJaH siddhimAsAdayati, sakalasUkSmAdipadArthasArthasAkSAtkArijJAnavizeSapUrvakatve hi vacanavizeSasya siddhe tajjJAnavataH sarvajJatvasiddhiH syAt / na ca tathAbhUtajJAnapUrvakatvaM vacanavizeSasya siddham, anumAnAdijJAnAdapi svaviSayAvisaMvAdivacanavizeSasya saMbhavAt; na ca tathAbhUtajJAnavAn sarvajJo bhavadbhirabhyupagamyata ityetad hRdi kRtvA''ha sUriH kusamayavisAsaNaM iti / samyak-pramANAntarAvisaMvAditvena-Iyante paricchidyante iti samayAH-naSTa-muSTi-cintA-lAbhA'lAbha-sukhA'sukhajIvita-maraNa-graho-parAgamantrauSadhazaktyAdayaH padArthAH-teSAM vividhama-anyapadArthakAraNatvena kAryatvena cAnekaprakAram-zAsanaM pratipAdakaM yataH zAsanaM kuH pRthvI tasyA iva / ___ ayamabhiprAyaH-jJatva-prameyatvAderanekaprakArasya pratipAditanyAyena sarvajJasattvapratipAdakasya hetoH sadbhAve'pi tatkRtatvena zAsanaprAmANyapratipAdanArthaM sarvajJo'bhyupagamyate; tasya cAnyato * S.T.P = sanmatitarka prakaraNam, prakA. gujarAta vidyApITha, pAMca bhAga / 2010_02 .

Page #48
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-1 hetoH pratipAdane'pi tadAgamapraNetRtvaM hetvantarAt punaH pratipAdanIyaM syAditi hetvantaramutsRjya pratipAdanagauravaparihArArthaM vacanavizeSalakSaNa eva hetustatsadbhAvAvedaka upanyasanIyaH, sa cAnena gAthAsUtrAvayavena sUcitaH / ata eva saMskRtya hetuH karttavyaH / tathAhi-yo yadviSayA'visaMvAdyaliGgAnupadezAnanvayavyatirekapUrvako vacanavizeSaH sa tatsAkSAtkArijJAnavizeSaprabhavaH, yathA'smadAdipravartitaH pRthvIkAThinyAdiviSayastathAbhUto vacanavizeSaH, naSTa-muSTivizeSAdiviSayAvisaMvAdyaliGgAnupadezAnanvayavyatirekapUrvakavacanavizeSaSTAAyaM zAsanalakSaNo'rtha iti / [S.T.P. 65] svAsAdhyAvinAbhUtaSTA hetuH sAdhyadharmiNyupadarzayitavyo vAdakathAyAmityabhiprAyavatA AcAryeNa gAthAsUtrAvayavena tathAbhUtahetupradarzanaM kRtamiti / tathAhi-samayavizAsanam ityanena gAthAsUtrAvayavavacanena svasAdhyavyAptasya hetoH sAdhyadharmiNyupasaMhAraH sUcitaH [S.T.P.67] pratibandhaprasAdhakaM cAsya hetoH prAgeva dRSTAntadharmiNi pramANaM pradarzitamityabhiprAyavataiva AcAryeNApi kusamayavisAsaNaM iti sUtre kuH ityanena dRSTAntasUcanaM vihitam, na ca pakSavacanAdyupakSepaH sUcitaH / nanu bhavatvasmAddhetoryathoktaprakAreNa sarvajJamAtrasiddhirna punastadvizeSasiddhiH / tathAhi-yathA naSTa-muSTyAdiviSayavacanavizeSasya arhatsarvajJapraNItatvaM vacanavizeSatvAt sidhyati tathA buddhAdisarvajJapUrvakatvamapi tata eva setsyatIti kutastadvizeSasiddhiH ? na ca naSTamuSTyAdipratipAdako vacanavizeSo'rhacchAsana eveti vaktuM yuktam, buddhazAsanAdiSvapi tasyopalambhAt ityAzajhyAha sUriH siddhatthANaM iti / asyAyamabhiprAyaHpratyakSA'numAnAdipramANaviSayatvena pratipAditAH zAsanena ye te tadviSayatvenaiva tairnipTiAtA iti siddhAH, te ca 'aryante' iti arthA ucyante, teSAM zAsanaM pratipAdakama arhatsarvajJazAsanameva na buddhAdizAsanam / ato vacanavizeSatvalakSaNasya hetosteSvasiddhatvAt kutasteSAmapi sarvajJatvaM yena vizeSasarvajJatvasiddhirna syAt ? yathA cAgamAntareNa pratyakSAdiviSayatvena pratipAditAnAmarthAnAM tadviSayatvaM na saMbhavati tathA'traiva yathAsthAnaM pratipAdayiSyate / ___ 2010_02

Page #49
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-1 athavA siddhArthAnAm ityanena hetusaMsUcanaM vihitamAcAryeNa-siddhAH pramANAntarasaMvAdato niSTiAtAH, ye'rthA naSTa-muSTyAdayaH, teSAM zAsanaM pratipAdakaM yato dvAdazAGgaM pravacanamato jinAnAM kAryatvena saMbandhi; tenAyaM prayogArthaH sUcitaH-prayogaTA-pramANAntarasaMvAdiyathoktanaSTamuSTyAdi-sUkSmAntaritadUrArthapratipAdakatvAnyathA'nupapatterjinapraNItaM zAsanam / [S.T.P.68] kusamayavizAsanam iti ca atra vyAkhyAne buddhAdizAsanAnAmasarvajJapraNItatvapratipAdakatvena vyAkhyeyam / tathAhi-kutsitAH pramANabAdhitaikAntasvarUpArthapratipAdakatvena, samayAH kapilAdipraNItasiddhAntAsteSAm "santi paJca mahabbhUyA" (sUtrakR. pra. zru., pra. a., pra. u., gA. 7) ityAdivacanasaMdarbhaNa dRSTeSTaviSaye virodhAdhudbhAvakatvena vizAsanam vidhvaMsakaM yataH ato dvAdazAGgameva jinAnAM zAsanamiti bhavatyato vizeSaNAt sarvajJavizeSasiddhiriti sthitametajjinazAsanaM dvAdazAGgaM tattvAdeva siddhaM niSTiAtaprAmANyamiti / [IzvarasvarUpavAdaH ] atra IzvarakRtajagadvAdinaH prAhuH-yuktamuktam 'sarvajJapraNItaM zAsanam, tatpraNItatvAJca tat pramANam' iti / idaM tvayuktam 'rAga-dveSAdikAn zatrUn jitavanta iti jinAH' / sAmAnyayogina evezvaravyatirikta etallakSaNayoginaH na punaH zAsanAdisarvajagatsraSTA IzvaraH / tathA ca pataJjali: "kleza-karma-vipAkA''zayairaparAmRSTaH puruSavizeSa IzvaraH" (yogada. pA. 1, sU. 24) iti / anena sUtreNa rAgAdilakSaNaklezazatrurahitatvaM sahajamIzvarasya pratipAditam, na punarvipakSabhAvanAdyabhyAsavyApArAt klezAdikSayastatra yena 'rAgAdIn svavyApAreNa jitavantaH' iti vacaH sArthakaM tadviSayatvena syAt / tathA cAnyairapyuktam "jJAnamapratighaM yasya aizvaryaM ca jagatpateH / vairAgyaM caiva dharmazca saha siddhaM catuSTayam" / / [ ] ityAzaGkyAha bhavajiNANaM iti, bhavanti nAraka-tiryag-narA'maraparyAyatvenotpadyante prANino'sminniti bhavaH saMsAraH, taddhetutvAda rAgAdayo'tra 'bhava'zabdenopacArAd vivakSitAH,taM jitavanta iti jinAH / upacArAzrayaNe ca prayojanam-na hyavikalakAraNe rAgAdau adhvaste tatkAryasya saMsArasya jayaH zakyo vidhAtumiti pratipAdanam / bhavakAraNabhUtarAgAdijaye copAyaH ___ 2010_02

Page #50
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-1 pratipAditaH prAk; tadupAyena ca vipakSarAgAdijayadvAreNa tatkAryabhUtasya bhavasya jayaH saMbhavati nAnyatheti / na hyupAyavyatirekeNopeyasiddhiH; anyathopeyasya nirhetukatvena deza-kAlasvabhAvapratiniyamo na syAditi sarvaprANinAmIzvaratvam, na vA kasyacit syAt / pratipAditapTAAyamarthaH "nityaM sattvamasattvaM vA'hetoranyAnapekSaNAt / apekSAto hi bhAvAnAM kAdAcitkatvasaMbhavaH" / / [ ] ityAdinA granthena dharmakIrttinA / tanna rAgAdiklezavigamaH svabhAvata evezvarasyeti yuktam / [S.T.P.69] nanu yadi teSAM bhavanibandhanarAgAdijetRtvaM tadA zAsanapraNetRtvAnupapattiH, tajjayAnantaramevApavargaprApteH zarIrAbhAve vaktRtvAsaMbhavAt / atha rAgAdikSayAnantaraM nApavargaprAptistarhi rAgAdijayo na bhavakSayalakSaNApavargaprAptikAraNam, na hi yasmin satyapi yanna bhavati tat tadavikalakAraNaM vyavasthApayituM zakyama, yavabIjamiva zAlyakurasya / atha niravazeSarAgAdyajayAd apavargaprApteH prAgeva tatpraNetRtvAdadoSaH, nanvevaM tacchAsanasya rAgalezA55zliSTapuruSapraNItatvena naikAntikaM prAmANyam, kapilAdipuruSapraNItasyeva ityAzajhyAha sUriHThANamaNovamasuhamuvagayANaM iti / asyAbhiprAyaH-yadyapi sarvajJatApratibandhighAtikarmacatuSTayakSayAvirbhUtakevalajJAnasampado jinAstathApi bhavopagrAhizarIranibandhanasya karmaNaH sadbhAvAdalpasthitikasya na zarIrAdyabhAvAt zAsanapraNetRtvAnupapattiH, nApi rAgAdilezasadbhAvAt tatpraNItAgamasyA'prAmANyam, viparyAsaheto_tikarmaNo'tyantakSayAt / na ca karmakSayAdaparasyApravRttinimittatvama, bhavopagrAhiNo'dyApi sAmastyenAkSayAt tatkSaye cApavargasyAnantarabhAvitvAt karmakSayasyaivApavargaprAptAvavikalakAraNatvAditi / avayavArthastu-tiSThanti sakalakarmakSayAvAptAnantajJAnasukharUpAdhyAsitAH zuddhAtmAno'sminniti sthAnaM lokAgralakSaNaM viziSTakSetram, na vidyate upamA svAbhAvikAtyantikatvena sakalavyAbAdhArahitatvena ca sarvasukhAtizAyitvAd yasya tat sukhamAnandarUpaM yasmiMstat tathA, tat 'upa' iti kAlasAmIpyena gatAnAM prAptAnAm, yadvA 'upa' ityupasargaH prakarSe'pyupalabhyate, yathA "upoDharAgeNa" [ ] iti / tena 2010_02

Page #51
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-2 sthAnamanupamasukhaM prakarSaNa gatAnAmiti / "parArthe prayujyamAnAH zabdA vatimantareNApi tamarthaM gamayanti" [ ] iti nyAyAdanubhUyamAnatIrthakRnnAmakarmalezasadbhAve'pi tad gatA iva gatA ityuktAstena zAsanapraNetRtvaM tasyAmavasthAyAM teSAmupapannameva / / yadvA "muktAH sarvatra tiSThanti vyomavat tApavarjitAH" [ ] ityetasya durnayasya nirAsArthamAha sUriH- ThANamaNovamasuhamuvagayANaM atra ca sthAnamanupamasukham-prakarSaNa apunarAvRttyA gatAnAm-upagatAnAmiti vyAkhyeyam / athavA "buddhyAdInAM navAnAM vizeSaguNAnAmAtyantikaH kSaya Atmano muktiH" [ ] iti matavyavacchedArthamAcAryeNa- ThANamaNovamasuhamuvagayANaM iti sUtramupanyastam / asya cAyamarthaH-sthitiH sthAnaM svarUpaprAptistad anupamasukham 'upa' iti sakalakarmakSayAnantaramavyavadhAnena gatAnAM prAptAnAm-zailezyavasthAcaramasamayopAdeyabhUtamanantasukhasvabhAvamAtmanaH kathaJcidananyabhUtaM svarUpaM prAptAnAmiti yAvat / [S.T.P. 133] tat sthitametat 'anupamasukhAdisvabhAvAmAtmanaH kathaJcidavyatiriktAM sthitimupagatAnAm' iti / / 1 / / [S.T.P. 166] evamiSTadevatAnamaskArakaraNadhvastaprakaraNaparisamAptivivandhakRtkliSTakarmAntarAyaH sUrirjinapraNItatvena zAsanasya prakaraNamantareNApi svataH siddhatvAt tadabhidheyasya niSprayojanatAmAzaGkamAnaH samayaparamattha ityAdigAthAsUtreNa prakaraNAbhidheyaprayojanamAha samayaparamatthavittharavihADajaNapajjuvAsaNasayano / AgamamalArahiyao jaha hoi tamatthamunesuM / / 2 / / tadeva cAsyA gAthAyAH samudAyArthaH / taJca zrotRpravRttyarthaM prayojanasya pratipattimantareNa prekSAvatAM pravRttyanupapatteH anabhihitaprayojanasya zAstrasya prekSApUrvakAribhiH kAkadantaparIkSAderivAnAzrayaNIyatvAt / ataH prayojanapradarzanena teSAM pravarttanAya zAstrasyAdau vAkyaM tatpratipAdanaparamupAdeyam / taduktam 2010_02

Page #52
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-2 "sarvasyaiva hi zAstrasya karmaNo vA'pi kasyacit / yAvat prayojanaM noktaM tAvat tat kena gRhyate" / / [zlo. vA. sU. 1 zlo. 12] punarapyuktam "anirdiSTaphalaM sarvaM na prekSApUrvakAribhiH / zAstramAdriyate tena vAcyamagre prayojanam" / / [ ] "zAstrasya tu phale dRSTe tatprAptyAzAvazIkRtAH / prekSAvantaH pravarttante tena vAcyaM prayojanam" / / [ ] "yAvat prayojanenAsya sambandho nAbhidhIyate / asambaddhapralApitvAd bhavet tAvadasaGgatiH" / / [zlo. vA. sU. 1 zlo. 20] "tasmAd vyAkhyAGgamicchadbhiH sahetussaprayojanaH / zAstrAvatArasambandho vAcyo nAnyastu niSphalaH" / / [zlo. vA. sU. 1 zlo. 25] ityAdi / [S.T.P. 169] atra ca AgamamalArahRdaya ityanuvAdena samayaparamArthavistaravihATajanaparyupAsanasako yathA bhavati tamarthamunneSye iti vidhiparA padaghaTanA karttavyA / [S.T.P. 172] padArthastu malamiva ArA prAjanakavibhAgo yasyAsau malAro gaurgalI Agame tadvat kuNThaM hRdayaM yasya-tadarthapratipattyasAmarthyAt-asau tathA mandadhIH, samyagIyante paricchidyante'nenArthA iti samaya AgamaH tasya paramo'kalpitaSTAAsAvarthaH samayaparamArthaH tasya vistaro racanAvizeSaH zabdArthayopTA bhede'pi pAramArthikasambandhapratipAdanAyA'bhedavivakSayA 'prathane vAvazabde' (pANi0 3, 3, 33) iti ghaJ na kRtaH- tasya vihATa iti dIpyamAnAn zrotRbuddhau prakAzamAnAnan dIpayati prakAzayatIti vihATapTAsau janapTA caturdazapUrvavidAdilokastasya paryupAsanama-kAraNe kAryopacArAt sevAjanitatadvyAkhyAnaM tatra saha karNAbhyAM varttata iti sakarNastad ___ 2010_02

Page #53
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-3 vyAkhyAtArthAvadhAraNasamarthaH yathA iti yena prakAreNa bhavati taM tathAbhUtamarthamunneSye lezataH pratipAdayiSye / [S.T.P. 173] zeSastvatra pUrvapakSagranthaH pratipadamuccArya na prativihitaH granthagauravabhayAd digmAtrapradarzanaparatvAcca prayAsasya / iti sthitametat-samayaparamatthavitthara iti / / 2 / / [S.T.P.270] [ dravyAstikanayanirUpaNam ] / [1 sadadvaitapratipAdakaH zuddhadravyAstikanayaH ] atra ca kuNThadhiyo'pyantevAsino yogitApratipAdanArthaH prakaraNArambhaH pratipAditaH, sA ca viziSTasAmAnya-vizeSAtmakatadupAyabhUtArthapratipAdanamantareNAtaH prakaraNAnna sampadyata iti prakaraNAbhidheyaM yogitopAyabhUtamartham titthayaravayaNasaMgaha-visesapatthAramUlavAgaraNI / davvaDhio ya' pajjavaNao ya sesA viyappA siM / / 3 / / ityanayA gAthayA nirdizati / asyASTA samudAyArthaH pAtanikayaiva pratipAditaH / avayavArthastu-taranti saMsArArNavaM yena tat tIrtham-dvAdazAGgam tadAdhAro vA saGghaH-tat kurvanti utpadyamAnamutpAdayanti tatsvAbhAvyAt tIrthakaranAmakarmodayAd veti "hetvAdyarthe Tac" [ ] tIrthakarANAM vacanam-AcArAdi arthatastasya tadupadiSTatvAt-tasya saGgrahavizeSau dravya-paryAyau sAmAnya-vizeSazabdavAcyAvabhidheyau tayoH prastAraH-prastIryate yena nayarAzinA saGgrahAdikena sa prastArastasya saMgraha-vyavahAraprastArasya mUlavyAkaraNI AdyavaktA jJAtA vA dravyAstikaH-drutirbhavanaM dravyam-satteti yAvat tatra 'asti' iti matirasya dravyAstikaH "saha supA" (a. 2, pA0 1, sU04 pANi. vyA0 pR0 160 a0 649) ityatra 'supA saha' iti yogavibhAgAt mayUravyaMsakAditvAd vA dravya-AstikazabdayoH samAsaH, dravyameva vA'rtho'syeti dravyArthikaH dravye vA sthito dravyasthitaH / pari samantAta avanama avaH-paryavo vizeSastajjJAtA vaktA vA, nayanaM nayo nItiH paryavanayaH atra chandobhaGgabhayAt 'paryAyAstikaH' iti vaktavye 'paryavanayaH' ityuktam / [S.T.P.271] 1. vi (uttarA. pAiaTIkA) ___ 2010_02

Page #54
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-3 tenAtrApi paryAya eva 'asti' iti matirasyeti dravyAstikavat vyutpattirdraSTavyA; sa ca vizeSaprastArasya-RjusUtrazabdAdeH-Adyo vaktA / nanu ca 'mUlavyAkaraNI' ityasya dravyAstikaparyAyanayAvabhidheyAviti dvitvAd dvivacanena bhAvyam, na; pratyekaM vAkyaparisamApteH, ata eva cakAradvayaM sUtre nirdiSTam / zeSAstu naigamAdayo vikalpA bhedAH anayordravyArthikaparyAyArthikayoH / siM iti prAkRtazailyA / "bahuvayaNeNa duvayaNaM" [ ] iti dvivacanasthAne bahuvacanam / tathAhi-parasparaviviktasAmAnya-vizeSaviSayatvAd dravyArthika-paryAyArthikAveva nayau, na ca tRtIyaM prakArAntaramasti yadviSayo'nyastAbhyAM vyatirikto nayaH syAt / tRtIyaviSayasya cAsambhavo bhedAbhedavinirmuktasya bhAvasvabhAvasyAparasyAnupapatteH / tAbhyAmanya ekastadvAnartho'stIti cet, na; svabhAvAntarAbhAvAt prakRtavikalpAnativRttestatsvabhAvAtikrame vA khapuSpasadRzatvaprasakteH / tAbhyAM tadvato'rthAntarasya sarvathA sambandhapratipAdanopAyAsambhavAta samavAyasya tairasambandhe tadvyapadezAnupapatteH, samavAyAntarakalpanAyAmanavasthAprasakteH vizeSaNavizeSyasambandhakalpanAyAmapyaparAparatatkalpanAprasakterna sambandhasiddhiH / tataH sthitametad na kiJcinnayadvayabahirbhAvi bhAvasvabhAvAntaravikalpanAvalambi prarUpaNAntaramiti / kevalaM tayoreva zuddhyazuddhibhyAmanekadhA vastusvabhAvanirUpaNavikalpAbhidhAnavRttayo vyavatiSThante / / tatra zuddho dravyAstiko nayaH saMgrahanayAbhimataviSayaprarUDhakaH / tathA ca saMgrahanayAbhiprAyaH sarvamekaM sat, avizeSAt / [S.T.P.272] azuddhastu dravyArthiko vyavahAranayamatArthAvalambI ekAntanityacetanA'cetanavastudvayapratipAdakasAGkhayadarzanAzritaH / [S.T.P.280] atra paryAyAstika RjusUtra-zabda-samabhirUDha-vambhUtanayapratyayarAzimUlavyAkaraNI zuddhA'zuddhatayA vyavasthitaH paryAyalakSaNaviSayavyavasthApanaparo dravyAstikanayAbhipretavastuvyavasthApanayuktiM pratikSipati / [S.T.P. 285] azuddhadravyAstikasAGkhyamatapratikSepakastu paryAyAstikaH prAha-yaduktaM kApilai: 'pradhAnAdeva mahadAdikAryavizeSAH pravarttante' iti / [S.T.P.296] 2010_02

Page #55
10 - nayopadeze : evaM sAmAnyalakSaNaM vivicya tadvibhAgamAha ayaM saMkSepato dravya-paryAyArthatayA dvidhA / dravyArthikamate dravyaM tattvaM neSTamataH param / / 12 / / nayAmRta0-ayamiti-ayaM sAmAnyalakSaNalakSito nayaH saGkSepataH avAntarabhedAparigraheNa, dravyaparyAyArthatayA dravyArthikaH paryAyArthikaSToti dvidhA dviprakAraH, tIrthaMkaravacanasaGgraha-vizeSaprastAramUlatvenetthameva mUlanayavibhajanAt, tadAha vAdI [sammatau ] - saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA- 3 "titthayaravayaNasaMgaha-visesapatthAramUlavAgaraNI / davvaTThio a pajjavaNao a sesA vigappA siM / / " (1/3) ti tatrAdau dravyArthikamatamAha - dravyArthikasya mate dravyaM tattvaM paramArthasat; ataH dravyAt pRthag bhinnaM vikalpasiddhaM guNa-paryAyasvarUpaM tattvaM neSTam, saMvRtisato'pi tasya paramArthato'sattvAditi bhAvaH / / 12 / / tataH kim ? ityAha -: tattvArthAdhigamasUtre : mahAmahopAdhyAyazrIyazovijayajIkRtavivaraNam (adhyAya - 1, sUtra 35) kiMca saptatattvavibhAge prayojanabheda ukta eva, navanayavibhAge ca na kaSTizatprayojanabhedaH / kiM tu tIrthaMkaravacanasaMgrahavizeSaNa (vizeSa) prayojanAbhyAmAdito dvayoreva nirUpaNaM vidheyam / tadbhedajijJAsAyAM ca sapta nirUpaNIyA iti vibhaktavibhAgo'yamekapraghaTTena / navAnAM maulabhedAnAmabhidhAnaM tu bAlizavilasitam / tadidamabhipretyAha mahAvAdI siddhasenaH [sammatau ] 2010_02 "titthayaravayaNasaMgaha-visesapatthAramUlavAgaraNI / davvaTThio ya pajjavaNayo ya sesA vigappA siM / / 1 / 3 / / " ti... / / 35 / / -: vizeSAvazyakabhASye :maladhAragacchIyapU.A.hemacandrasUrIkRtaTIkA

Page #56
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-3 eyANa samoyAro davaTThiya-pajjavaTThiyadugammi / sesesu ya saMbhavao tANaM ca paropparaM kajjo / / 3587 / / eteSAM ca saMgrahAdinayAnAM dravyArthika-paryAyArthikanayadvaye samavatAro'ntarbhAvaH kAryaH / uktaM ca[sammatau] "titthayaravayaNasaMgaha-visesapatthAramUlavAyaraNI / davvaDhio ya pajjavanao ya sesA viyappA siM / / 1/3 / / tathA, teSAmeva saMgrahAdinayAnAM zeSeSu niSTAyanaya-vyavahAra-jJAna-kriyAdinayeSu pUrvokteSu vA saptasu nayazateSu samavatAro vidheyaH / tathA 'tANaM ca' tti teSAmeva saMgrahAdinayAnAM parasparaM saMbhavato yathAsaMbhavaM samavatAraH kAryaH / tadyathA-RjusUtraH paryAyAdivAditvasAmyAt zabdanaye samavatarati, zabdanayo'pi bhAvAdyabhyupagamasAmyAt samabhirUDhe, so'pi pratizabdamanyAnyArthavAcitvAdinaivambhUte / evamanyathApi yathAsaMbhavaM parasparameSAmantarbhAvo vAcya iti / / 3587 / / -: uttarAdhyayanasUtre : pAiaTIkA-adhyayana-1 niyuktigAthA 30 te hi tIrthavidhau sarve, mAtRkAkhyaM padatrayam / utpattivigamadhrauvyakhyApakaM sampracakSate / / 5 / / utpattivigamAvatra, mataM paryAyavAdinaH / dravyArthikasya tu dhrauvyaM, mAtRkAkhyapadatraye / / 6 / / tataSTA-dravyatvamanvayitvena, mRdo yadvad ghaTAdiSu / tadvadevAnvayitvena, nAmasthApanayorapi / / 7 / / anvayitvaM tu sarvatra, saGketAnnAmra ucyate / sthApanAyApTA tadrUpakriyAto buddhito'pi vA / / 8 / / tannAmasthApanAdravyanikSepairanuvartitaH / dravyArthikanayo bhAvanikSepAditaraH punaH / / 9 / / tathA ca mahAmatiH [sammatau] - "titthayaravayaNasaMgaha-visesapatthAramUlavAgaraNI / davvaDhio vi' pajjavaNao ya sesA viyappA siM / / 10 / / " / / 1/3 / / tathA "nAmaM ThavaNA davie tti esa davvaTThiyassa nikkhevo / bhAvo u pajjavaTThiassa parUvaNA esa paramattho / / 11 / / " / / 1/6 / / / 1. ya (saMmati.) 2010_02

Page #57
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-3 (nayalakSaNAni) (saMgraha-naigamanayasvarUpam) atra ca naigama-saMgraha-vyavahAralakSaNAstrayo nayAH zuddhyazuddhibhyAM dravyAstikamatamAzritAH RjusUtra-zabda-samabhirUDha-evambhUtAstu zuddhitAratamyataH paryAyanayabhedAH / tathAhi-saMgrahamataM tAvat pradarzitameva, yeSAM tu matena naigamanayasya sadbhAvastaistasya svarUpamevaM varNitamarAzyantaropalabdhaM nityatvamanityatvaM ca nayatIti nigamavyavasthAbhyupagamaparo naigamanayaH / nigamo hi nityA'nitya-sadasat-kRtaka(kA')kRtakasvarUpeSu bhAveSvapAstasAGkaryasvabhAvaH sarvathaiva dharmadharmibhedena sampadyata iti / sa punarnaigamo'nekadhA vyavasthitaH pratipattrabhiprAyavazAnnayavazAnnayavyavasthAnAta / pratipattArapTA nAnAbhiprAyAH / yataH kecidAhuH-"puruSa evedaM sarvam" [zvetAzvata. u. a. 3, 15] ityAdi, yadAzrityoktam "UrdhvamUlamadhaHzAkhamazvatthaM prAhuravyayam / chandAMsi yasya parNAni yastaM veda sa vedavit" [gItA a. 15 zlo. 1] puruSo'pyekatva-nAnAtvabhedAt kaipTiAdabhyupagato dvedhA, nAnAtve'pi tasya kartRtvA'kartRtvabhedo'parairAzritaH, kartRtve'pi sarvagatetarabhedaH, asarvagatatve'pi zarIravyAptyavyAptibhyAM bhedaH, avyApitve'pi mUrtetaravikalpAd bheda eva / aparaistu pradhAnakAraNikaM jagad abhyupagatam, tatrApi sezvara-nirIzvarabhedAd bhedAbhyupagamaH / anyaistu paramANuprabhavatvamabhyupagataM jagataH, tatrApi sezvara-nirIzvarabhedAd bhedo'bhyupagataH, sezvarapakSe'pi svakRtakarmasApekSa-tvA'napekSatvAbhyAM tadavastha eva bhedAbhyupagamaH / kaipTiAt svabhAva-kAla-yadRcchAdivAdAH samAzritAH, teSvapi sApekSatvA'napekSatvAbhyupagamAd bhedavyavasthA abhyupagataiva / tathA, kAraNaM nityam, kAryamanityamityapi dvaitaM kaipTiAdabhyupagatam, tatrApi kAryaM svarUpaM niyamena tyajati na vetyayamapi bhedAbhyupagamaH / evaM mUtaireva mUrttamArabhyate, mUttaimUrttam, mUtairamUrttamityAdyanekadyA pratipattrabhiprAyato'nekadhA nigamanAnnaigamo'nekabhedaH / [ vyavahAranayasvarUpam ] vyavahAranayastu-apAstasamastabhedane(me)kamabhyupagacchato'dhyakSIkRtabhedanibandhanavyavahAra 2010_02

Page #58
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-3 virodhaprasakteH-kAraka-jJApakabhede(da)parikalpanAnurodhena vyavahAramAcara(mAraca)yan pravartate iti kAraNasyApi na sarvadA nityatvam kAryasyApi na sarvadA nityatvam kAryasyApi naikAntataH prakSaya iti / tatapTA na kadAcidanIdRzaM jagaditi pravRtto'yaM vyavahAro na kenApi pravartyate anyathA pravartakAnavasthAprasaktiH / tato na vyavahArazUnyaM jagat / na ca pramANAviSayIkRtaH pakSo'bhyupagantuM yuktaH adRSTaparikalpanAprasakteH, dRSTAnurodhena hyadRSTamapi vastu kalpayituM yuktam anyathA kalpanAsambhavAditi saMgraha-naigamA'bhyupagatavastuvivekAlokapratItapathAnusAreNa pratipattigauravaparihAreNa pramANa-prameya-pramitipratipAdanaM vyavahAraprasiddhyarthaM parIkSakaiH samAzritamiti vyavahAranayAbhiprAyaH / tataH sthitaM naigama-saMgraha-vyavahArANAM dravyAstikanayaprabhedatvam / viSayabhedapTauSAM pratipAditaH "zuddhaM dravyaM samAzritya saMgrahastadazuddhitaH / naigama-vyavahArau stAM zeSAH paryAyamAzritAH" / / [ taduktam "anyadeva hi sAmAnyamabhinnajJAnakAraNam / vizeSo'pyanya eveti manyate nigamo nayaH" / / [ "sadrUpatAnatikrAnta-svasvabhAvamidaM jagat / sattArUpatayA sarva saMgRNhan saMgraho mataH" / / [ ] "vyavahArastu tAmeva prativastuvyavasthitAm / tathaiva dRzyamAnatvAt vyavahArayati dehinaH" / / [ ] iti / [ RjusUtranayasvarUpam ] paryAyanayabhedAH RjusUtrAdayaH "tatrarjusUtranItiH syAt shuddhpryaaysNshritaaH(taa)| nazvarasyaiva bhAvasya bhAvA (vAt) sthitiviyogataH" / / [ ] 2010_02

Page #59
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-3 deza-kAlAntarasambaddhasvabhAvarahitaM vastutattvaM sAmpratikam ekasvabhAvam akuTilam Rju sUtrayatIti RjusUtraH / na hi ekasvabhAvasya nAnAdik-kAlasambandhitvasvabhAvamanekatvaM yuktam ekasyAnekatvavirodhAt / na hi svarUpabhedAdanyo vastubhedaH svarUpasyaiva vastutvopapatteH / tathAhi-vidyamAne'pi svarUpe kimaparamabhinnaM vastu yad rUpanAnAtve'pyekaM syAditi ? yad vasturUpaM yena svabhAvenopalabhyate tat tena sarvAtmanA vinazyati na punaH kSaNAntarasaMsparzIti kSaNikam, kSaNAntarasambandhe tatkSaNAkArasya kSaNAntarAkAravizeSAprasaGgAt ato jAtasya yadi dvitIyakSaNasambandhaH prathamakSaNasvabhAvaM nApanayati tadA kalpAntarAvasthAnasambandho'pi tannApanayet, svabhAvabhede vA kathaM na vastubhedaH anyathA sarvatra sarvadA bhedAbhAvaprasaktiH ? akSaNikasya krama-yogapadyAbhyAmarthakriyAnupapatterasattvam, sahakAryupaDhaukitAtizayamanaGgIkurvatastadapekSA'yogAdakSepeNa kAryakAriNaH sarvakAryamekadaiva vidadhyAditi na kramakartRtvam, na vA kadAcanApi svakAryamutpAdayet nirapekSasya niratizayatvAt nahi nirapekSasya kadAcit karaNamakaraNaM vA virodhAt, tatkRtamukA(mupakA)raM svabhAvabhUtamaGgIkurvataH kSaNikatvameva / vyatiriktatve vA sambandhAsiddhiH, aparopakArakalpane'navasthAprasaktiH / yugapadapi na nityasya kAryakAritvam dvitIye'pi kSaNe tatsvabhAvAt tatastadutpattitaH tatkramaprasakteH / kramA'kramavyatiriktaprakArAntarAbhAvAJca na nityasya sattvam arthakriyAkAritvalakSaNatvAt tasya / pradhvaMsasya ca nirhetukatvena svabhAvato bhAvAt svarasabhaGgurA eva sarve bhAvAH iti paryAyAzritarjusUtrAbhiprAyaH / taduktam "atItAnAgatAkArakAlasaMsparzavarjitam / vartamAnatayA sarvamRjusUtreNa sUtryate" / / [ ] pramANa-prameyanibandhanaM yadyapi zabdA'rthI sAmAnyena bhavataH tathApi sAkSAt paramparayA vA pramANasya kAraNameva svAkArArpakaviSayaH, "nAnukRtAnvayavyatirekaM kAraNam nAka(ka)raNaM viSayaH" [ ] tathA "arthena ghaTayatyenAM nahi muktArtharUpatAm / tasmAt prameyAdhigateH pramANaM meyarUpatA" / / [ ] 2010_02

Page #60
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 1, gAthA - 3 7 ityAdi vacanAt tadAkArAnuvidhAyinI tadadhyavasAyena ca tatrAvisaMvAdAt saMvit pramANatvena gIyate / adhyakSadhISTathA'zabdamarthamAtmanyAdhatte anyathA arthadarzanapratyutiprasaGgAt / na hyakSagocare'rthe zabdAH santi tadAtmAno vA yena tasmin pratibhAsamAne'pi niyamena pratibhAseranniti kathaM tatsaMsRSTAH (STA) adhyakSadhIrbhavet ? kiJca vastusannidhAne'pi tannAmAnusmRtiM vinA tadArthasyAnupalabdhAviSyamANAyAmarthasannidhirakSadRgjananaM pratyasamartha iti abhidhAnasmRtAdu (?) pakSINazaktitvAnna kadAcanApIndriyabuddhiM janayet sannidhAnAvizeSAt / yadi cAyaM bhavatAM nirbandhaH-svAbhidhAnavizeSaNApekSameva cakSurAdipratipatti(?) svArthamavagamayati tadA'staMgateya-mindriyaprabhavA'rthAdhigatiH tannAmasmRtyAderasambhavAt / tathAdi-yatrArthe prAk zabdapratipattirabhUt punastadarthavIkSaNe tatsaGketitazabdasmRtirbhavediti yuktiyuktam anyathA atiprasaGgaH syAt na ced anabhilApamarthaM pratipattA pazyati tadA tatra dRSTamabhilApamapi na smaret asmaraMSTA zabdavizeSaM na tatra yojayet ayojayaMSTA na tena viziSTamarthaM pratyetItyAyAtamAndhyamazeSasya jagataH / tataH svAbhidhAnarahitasya viSayasya viSayiNaM cakSurAdipratyayaM prati svata evopayogitvaM siddhaM na tu tadabhidhAnAnAM tadarthasambandharahitAnAM pAramparyeNApi sAmarthyAsambhavAt / ityarthanayA vyavasthitAH / [ zabdanayasvarUpam ] zabdanayAstu manyante - kAraNasyApi viSayasya pratipattiM prati naiva prameyatvaM yuktaM yAvadadhyavasAyo na bhavet so'pyadhyavasAyavikalpaSTot tadabhidhAnasmRti (tiM) vinA notpattuM yuktaH iti sarvavyavahAreSu zabdasambandhaH pradhAnaM nibandhanam / pratyakSasyApi tatkRtAdhyavasAyalakSaNavikalasya bahirantarvA pratikSaNapariNAmapratipattAviva pramANatAnupapatteH avisaMvAdalakSaNatvAt pramANAnAm, pratikSaNapariNAmagrahaNe'pi tasya prAmANyAbhyupagame pramANAntarapravRttau yatnAntaraM kriyamANamapArthakaM syAt / tataH pramANavyavasthAnibandhanaM tannAmasmRtivyavasAyayojanamarthaprAdhAnyamapahastayatIti zabda eva sarvatra pramANAdivyavahAre pradhAnaM kAraNamiti sthitam / zabdanayaSTA RjusUtrAbhimataparyAyAt zuddhataraM paryAyaM svaviSayatvena vyavasthApayati / tathAhi'taTaH' 'taTI' 'taTam' iti viruddhaliGgalakSaNadharmAkrAntaM bhinnameva vastu, nahi tatkRtaM dharmabhedamananubhavatastatsambandho yuktaH taddharmabhede vA svayaM dharmI kathaM na bhidyate ? yathA hi kSaNikaM vastu 2010_02 15

Page #61
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 1, gAthA - 3 atItA'nAgatAbhyAM kSaNAbhyAM na sambandhamanubhavatyevaM gotvAdi kalpanAsAmAnyavizeSasvarUpaparasparaviruddhastrItvAdyanyatamadharmasambaddhaM nAnyadharmI (rmi) sambaddhamanubhavati (?) viruddhadharmAdhyAsasya bhedalakSaNatvAt, tathApyabhede 'na kiJcid bhinnaM jagadasti' iti bhedavyavahAra evotsIdet / tathA, ekasminnudakaparamANau ' Apa:' iti bahutvasaGkhyAyA nirdezo'nupapannaH na hyekatvasaGkhyAsamAdhyAsitaM tadeva tadviruddhabahutvasaGkhyopetaM bhavatItyekasaGkhyayaiva tannirdeSTavyam / kAlabhedAd vastubhedaH RjusUtreNApyabhyupagata eveti 'agniSTomayAjI putro'sya janitA' ityayuktameva vacaH atItA'nAgatayoH sambandhAbhAvAt / tathA, anyakArakayuktaM yat tadeva aparakArakasambandha (ndhaM) nAnubhavatIti adhikaraNaM ced grAmaH adhikaraNazabdavAci(karaNavAci) vibhaktivAcya eva na karmAbhidhAnavibhaktyabhidheyo yukta iti 'grAmamadhizete' iti prayogo'nupapannaH / tathA, puruSabhede'pi naikAntad (kaM tad) vastu iti 'ehi manye rathena yAsyasi nahi yAsyasi yAtaste pitA' iti ca prayogo na yuktaH api tu 'ehi manyase yathAhaM rathena yAsyAmi' ityanenaiva parabhAvenaitannirdeSTavyam / evamupagrahaNabhedepi 'viramati' iti na yuktaH AtmArthatAyAM hi 'viramate' ityasyaiva prayogasaGgateH / na caivaM lokazAstra-vyavahAravilopa iti vaktavyam, , sarvatraiva nayamate tadvilopasya samAnatvAditi yathArthazabdanAt zabdanayo vyavasthitaH / | taduktam 16 "virodhiliGga-saGkhyAdibhedAt bhinnasvabhAvatAm / tasyaiva manyamAno'yaM zabdaH pratyavatiSThate" [ [ samabhirUDhanayasvarUpam ] ekasaMjJAsamabhirohaNAt samabhirUDhastvAha-yathA hi viruddhaliGgAdiyogAd bhidyate vastu tathA saMjJAbhedAdapi / tathAhi-saMjJAbhedaH prayojanavazAt saGketakartRbhirvidhIyate na vyasanitayA anyathA anavasthAprasakteH tato yAvanto vastunaH svAbhidhAyakAH zabdAstAvanto'rthabhedAH pratyarthaM zabdanivezAt naikasyArthasyAnekenAbhidhAnaM yuktamiti 'ghaTaH ''kuTaH''kumbhaH' iti vacanabhedAd bhinna evArthaH, kriyAzabdatvAd vA sarvazabdAnAM sarve'pyanvarthA eva vAcakAH tato 'ghaTate' 'kuTati' 'kau bhAti' iti ca kriyAlakSaNanimittabhedAt naimittikenApyarthena bhinnena bhAvyamiti 'ghaTaH ' 2010_02 ]

Page #62
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 1. gAthA - 3 ityukte kutaH 'kuTa:' iti pratipattiH tena tadarthasyAnabhihitatvAt ? yathA vA 'pAvaka 'zabdo - kteranyaiva pAvakazaktiranvayavyatirekAbhyAM lokataH prasiddhA tathA ghaTana-kuTanAdizaktInAmapi bhedaH pratIyata eveti nAnArthavAcina eva paryAyadhvanayaH naikamarthamabhinivezanta iti samabhirUDhaH / uktaM ca "tathAvidhasya tasyApi vastunaH kSaNavRttinaH / brUte samabhirUDhastu saMjJAbhedena bhinnatAm" / / [ evaMbhUtanayasvarUpam ] zabdAmidheyakriyApariNativelAyAmeva ' tad vastu' iti bhUta evaMbhUtaH prAha-yathA saMjJAbhedAd bhedavad vastu tathA kriyAbhedAdapi, sA ca kriyA taddhettrI yadaiva tAmAvizati tadaiva tannimittaM tattadvyapadezamAsAdayati nAnyadetyatiprasaGgAt / tathAhi--yadA 'ghaTate' tadaivAsau 'ghaTa:' na punaH 'ghaTitavAn''ghaTiSyate' vA 'ghaTaH' iti vyapadeSTuM yuktaH sarvavastUnAM ghaTatApattiprasaGgAt / api ca, ceSTAsamaya eva cakSurAdivyApArasamudbhUtazabdAnuviddhapratyayamAskandanti ceSTAvantaH padArthAH yathAvasthitArthapratibhAsa eva ca vastUnAM vyavasthApako nAnyatAbhUtaH anyathA aceSTAvato'pi ceSTAvattayA zabdAnuviddhe'dhyakSapratyaye pratibhAsyatya ( bhAsa itya) bhyupagame tatpratyayasya nirviSayatayA bhrAntasyApi vastuvyavasthApakatve sarvaH pratyayaH sarvasyArthasya vyavasthApakaH syAdityatiprasaGgaH / tanna ghaTanasamayAt prAk paSTazAd vA 'ghaTaH ' tadvyapadezamAsAdayatItyevaMbhUtanayamatam / uktaM ca "ekasyApi dhvanervAcyaM tadA tannopapadyate / kriyAbhedena bhinnatvAdevaMbhUto'bhimanyate" / / [ tat sthitametat RjusUtrAdayaH paryAyAstikasya vikalpA iti / asyASTA gAthAyAH sarvameva zAstraM vivaraNam / / 3 / / [S.T.P. 310 to 314] 2010_02 ] iti / 17

Page #63
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-4 [ dravyAstikaikaprakRtikayoH saMgraha-vyavahArayoH zuddhAzuddhatayA bhedanirUpaNam ] 'davvaDhio ya pajjavaNao ya' ityAdipaSTAATTaikadezasya vivaraNAya Aha sUriH davvaTThiyanayapayaDI suddhA saMgahaparUvaNAvisao / paDirUve puNa vayaNathanicchao tassa vavahAro / / 4 / / iti gAthAsUtram / ata ca saMgrahanayapratyayaH zuddho dravyAstikaH vyavahAranayapratyayastvazuddha iti tAtparyArthaH / avayavArthastu dravyAstikanayasya vyAvarNitasvarUpasya prakRtiH svabhAvaH zuddhA ityasaGkIrNA vizeSAsaMsparzavatI saMgrahasya abhedagrAhinayasya prarUpaNA-prarUpyate'nayeti kRtvA-upavarNanA padasaMhatistasyA viSayo'bhidheyaH / viSayApakAreNa viSayiNo vRttasya viSayavyavasthApakatvAdupacAreNa viSayeNa viSayiprakathanametat anyathA kaH prastAvaH zuddhadravyAstike'bhidhAtuM prakrAnte saMgrahaprarUpaNAviSayAbhidhAnasya ? [S.T.P.315] vyavahArasya vizeSamizritasattAviSayakatvasAdhanam | tAmevA'zuddhaM (ddhAM) paDirUvaM puNa ityAdigAthApaSTAArTena darzayatyAcAryaH-pratirUpaM pratibimbaM pratinidhiriti yAvat / vizeSeNa ghaTAdinA dravyeNa saGkIrNA sattA, punariti prakRtiM smarayati / tenAyamarthaH-vizeSeNa saMkIrNA sattA prakRtiH svabhAvaH vacanArthaniSTAyaH iti heyopAdeyopekSaNIyavastuviSayanivRtti-pravRttyupekSAlakSaNavyavahArasaMpAdanArthamucyata iti vacanam, tasya'ghaTaH' iti vibhaktarUpatayA 'asti' ityavibhaktAtmatayA pratIyamAno vyavahArakSamaH-arthastasya niSTAyaH nirgataH pRthagbhUtaH cayaH paricchedaH tasya iti dravyAstikasya vyavahAraH iti lokaprasiddhavyavahArapravarttanaparaH nayaH / so'bhimanyate yadi hi heyopAdeyopekSaNIyasvarUpAH parasparato vibhinnasvabhAvAH sadrUpatayA zabdaprabhave saMvedane bhAvAH pratibhAnti tato nivRttipravRttyupekSAlakSaNo vyavahArastadviSayakapravRttimAsAdayati nAnyathA; na caikAntataH sanmAtrA'viziSTeSu bhAveSu saMgrahAbhimateSu pRthak svarUpatayA paricchedo'bAdhitarUpo vyavahAranibandhanaM 2010_02

Page #64
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-5 saMbhavatIti / tathAhi-yadyadyAkA(yat yadAkA)ranirapekSatayA svagrAhiNi jJAne pratibhAsamAdhatte tat tathaiva 'sat' iti vyavahartavyam, yathA pratiniyataMSTA sattAdirUpam, ghaTAdyAkAranirapekSaM ca paTAdikaM svAvabhAsini jJAne svarUpaM sannivezayatIti svabhAvo hetuH / ghaTAdinirapekSatvaM ca paTAdeH ghaTAdyabhAve'pi bhAvAt avabhAsamAnAJca(sanAJca) siddham / yadvA pratizabdo vIpsAyAm rUpazabdaSTA vastunyatra pravarttate / tenAyamarthaH-rUpaM rUpaM prati'yAM vastu vastu prati yo vacanArthaniSTAyastasya prakRtiH svabhAvaH sa vyavahAra iti / tathAhi - pratirUpameva vacanArthaniSTAyo vyavahAraheturna punarastitvamAtraniSTAyaH, yataH 'asti' ityukte'pi zrotA zaGkAmupagacchan lakSyate ataH 'kimasti' ityAzaGkAyAm 'dravyam' ityucyate, tadapi 'kim ? pRthivI, sApi kA ? vRkSaH, so'pi kaH ? cUtaH' tatrApyarthitve yAvat 'puSpitaH' 'phalitaH' ityAdi tAvannipTiAnoti yAvad vyavahArasiddhiriti / vyavahAro hi nAnArUpatayA sattAM vyavasthApayati tathaiva saMvyavahArasaMbhavAt / ato vyavaharatIti vyavahAra ityanvarthasaMjJAM bibhrat azuddhA dravyAstikapravRtirbhavati / / 4 / / [S.T.P.316] [ paryAyAstikaikaprakRtikAnAm RjusUtrAdInAM zuddhAzuddhabhAvena vibhajanam ] vizeSaprastArasya paryAyanayo mUlavyAkaraNI, zabdAdayaSTA zeSAH paryAyanayabhedA iti prAguktam tatsamarthanArtham mUlaNimeNaM pajavaNayassa ujusuyavayaNavicchedo / tassa u saddAIA sAhapasAhA suhumabheyA / / 5 / / iti gAthAsUtram / asya tAtparyArthaH-paryAyanayasya prakRtirAdyA RjusUtraH sa tvazuddhA, zabdaH zuddhA, zuddhatarA samabhirUDhaH, atyantataH zuddhA tvevaMbhUta iti / avayavArthastu-mUlamAdiH NimeNaM AdhAraH paryAyo vizeSaH tasya naya upapattibalAt paricchedaH tasya, Rju-vartamAnasamayaM vastu svarUpAvasthitatvAt tadeva-sUtrayati paricchinatti 1- mUlanimANaM (ane. vya.) / 2-saddavikappA (dvAda.naya.) / 3-mUlanirmANaM mUlAdhAraH (ane. vya.) / 2010 02

Page #65
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-5 nAtItA'nAgatam tasyA'sattvena kuTilatvAt tasya vacanama-padaM vAkyaM vA tasya vicchedo'ntaH -sImeti yAvat / 'RjusUtravacanasya' iti karmaNi SaSThI , tena 'RjusUtrasya evamayamartho nAnyathA' iti prarUpayato vacanaM vicchidyamAnaM yat tat mUlanimenam atra gRhyate / [S.T.P. 317] tadevaM pratyakSataH anumAnatapTA kSaNikatvavyavasthiteH sthitameva tad mUlAdhAraH paryAyanayasya RjusUtravacanaviccheda iti / tasya RjusUtrataroH tuH avadhAraNArthaH, tena tasyaiva na dravyAstikasya zabdAdayaH zabdAdarthaM gamayantaH zabdanayatvena pratItAH zabdasamabhirUdvaivaMbhUtAstrayo nayAH zAkhAprazAkhA iva sthUlasUkSmatara(lasUkSmasUkSmatara) darzitvAt sUkSmo bhedo vizeSo yeSAM te tathA / yathA hi taroH sthUlAH zAkhAH, sUkSmAstatpazAkhAH, pratizAkhAati (zAkhApTA) sUkSmatarAH evam RjusUtrataroH sthUla-sUkSma-sUkSmatarAH zAkhA-prazAkhA-pratizAkhArUpA azuddha-zuddha-zuddhataraparyAyAstikarUpAH zabda-samabhirUDhai-vaMbhUtAstrayo nayA draSTavyAH / tathAhiRjusUtrAbhyupagataM kSaNamAtravRtti vastu liGgAdibhedAd bhinnaM zabdo vRkSAcchAkhAmiva sUkSmamabhimanyate ekasaMjJaM samabhirUDhaH zabdAbhimataM vastu saMjJAbhedAdapi bhidyamAnaM zAkhAtaH prazAkhAmiva sUkSmataramadhyavasyati, tadeva samabhirUDhAbhimataM vastu zabdapratipAdyakriyAsamAvezasamaya eva sthiti(?)bhUta evaMbhUtaH kriyAbhedAd bhinnaM prazAkhAtaH pratizAkhAmiva sUkSmatamamadhigacchatyevaM bAhyArthAbhyupagamaparaH zabda-samabhirUDhevaMbhUtabhedavAnavagantavyaH / / [S.T.P.349] -: anekAntavyavasthAyAm : RjusUtranayasvarUpavarNane patra. 54 ayaM carjusUtranayaH paryAyanayatarormUlam, zabdAdInAmetacchAkhArUpatvAt, taduktaM sammatI "mUlanimANaM pajavaNayassa ujjusuavayaNavicchedo / / tassa u saddAIyA, sAhapasAhA suhumabheyA ||1/5 / / " asyArthaH-mUlanirmANaM mUlAdhAraH, paryAyanayasya RjusUtravacanavicchedo lakSaNayA pratikSaNavivecanena vicchidyamAnavacanaphalIbhUtaRjusUtrAkhyo nayabodhaH, tasya RjusUtrataroH, turavadhAraNArthaH, tena tasyaiva na dravyArthikasya, zabdAdayaH zabdaprAdhAnyenArthopasarjanatvena pratItijanakAH zabdasamabhirUdvaivambhUtAkhyAstrayo nayAH, zAkhAprazAkhA iva sthUlasUkSmataradarzitvAt sUkSmo bhedo yeSAM te tathA, yathA hi taroH sthUlAH zAkhAH 1- mUlaNimeNaM (saMmati.) / 2- mUlamAdiH NimeNaM AdhAraH (saMmati.) / 2010_02

Page #66
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-5 sUkSmAstatprazAkhA atisUkSmasUkSmatarAstatpratizAkhAH, evaM RjusUtrataroH sthUlasUkSmasUkSmatarazAkhAprazAkhApratizAkhArUpA azuddhazuddhazuddhatarAH zabdasamabhirUdvaivambhUtAkhyAstrayo nayA draSTavyAH / tathA hi RjusUtrAbhyupagataM kSaNamAtrAvasthitivastu liGgAdibhedAdbhinnaM zabdo vRkSAcchAkhAmiva sUkSmamabhimanyate, samabhirUDhaH zabdAbhimataM vastu saJjJAbhedAdapi bhidyamAnaM zAkhAtaH prazAkhAmiva sUkSmataramadhyavasyati, tadeva samabhirUDhAbhimataM vastu evambhUtaH kriyAbhedAdbhinnaM prazAkhAtaH pratizAkhAmiva sUkSmatamamadhigacchatIti / etacca RjusUtrapadavyutpattinimittaM pratyutpannagrAhitvaM paryAyanayatvamAtraparyavasannamabhipretya draSTavyam / yadvA vizeSaNabhedAprayuktaRjusUtraviSayapratiyogikabhedAnAdhArapratItiviSayakatvamiha zabdAdInAmRjusUtrabhedatvaM paribhASyate, na hyevaM vyavahArasya saGgrahabhedatvaM prasajyate, vizeSaNabhedAprayuktasAmAnyalakSaNasaGgrahaviSayapratiyogikabhedAdhAravizeSaviSayatvAttasya / zabdabhinnatve sati pratyutpanagrAhitvaM lakSaNamabhipretya tu na zabdAdInAmRjusUtrabhedatvam, anyathA nayavibhAjakopAdhivyApyavibhAjakopAdhimattvena nayaprabhedatvApatteH-"satta mUlaNayA paNNattA" iti sUtravyAkopaprasaGgAt, na cAnyathA'pi nayavibhAjakopAdhirUpadravyArthikatvaparyAyArthikatvavyApyasaGgrahatvaRjusUtratvAdikamAdAya saGgraharjusUtrAdInAM nayaprabhedatvaM durnivAram, dravyArthikatvaparyAyArthikatvayoH prakRtavibhAgaprayojakavibhAjakopAdhitvAbhAvena tadadoSAditi smartavyam, ata eva nava nayA-dravyArthikaH-1 paryAyArthiko-2 naigamaH-3 saGgraho-4 vyavahAra-5 RjusUtraH-7 zabda:-7 samabhirUDha-8 evambhUtapTo-9 tyekavibhAgakaraNalampaTadikpaTakapaTamapAstamApabhrAMzikaprabandhe'smAbhiH / evaM hi dravyArthikatvaparyAyArthikatvAbhyAM sAmAnyato nayavibhAgaM kRtvA saGgraharjusUtrAdInAM dravyArthikaparyAyArthikabhedAnAmevAnupadamupadarzanena vibhaktavibhAgaH kRtaH syAt, natvekavibhAgaH, saGgraharjusUtrAdyantarbhAvazIlayordravyArthikaparyAyArthikayoH pRthagvibhAgasya kartumazakyatvAt, anyathA'rpitAnarpitabhedadvayAdhikyenaikAdazadhApi kiM na nayavibhAgo devAnAMpriyasyAbhimataH syAt ?, na ca paJca nayA ityeka AdezaH saptetyanya itivatsapta nayA ityekaH Adezo navetyanya ityasmadabhipretamiti sAmpratam, bhinnaviSayANAM zabdAdInAM trayANAM zabdatvenaikyaM svAtantryaM cAbhipretya paJcasaptAdezabhedadvayasambhave'pi prakRte viSayabhedAbhAvena tadasambhavAt, na ca saptadhA navadhA ca tattvavibhAgavannayavibhAgo'pi tathA nAnupapanna iti vaktuM yuktam, tatra kevalaniHzreyasopayogyabhyudayasaMvalitatadupayogibodhalakSaNaprayojanabhedena vibhAgadvaividhyasambhave'pi prakRte prayojanabhedAbhAvenAnuyogadvArasthAnAGgatattvArthamahAzAstrAdyabhihitaM saptadhAnayavibhAgamullaGghya navadhA tatkaraNasya sUtrAzAtanAkalaGkitatvAditi dig / ayaM ca sarvo'pi RjusUtravacanavistAro bAhyArthAbhyupagamaparo draSTavyaH / ___ 2010_02

Page #67
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-6 yadvA Rju bAhyApekSayA grAhakasaMvittibhedavikalamavibhAgaM buddhisvarUpamakuTilaM sUtrayatIti RjusUtraH zuddhapayAryAstikaH, yadvA sarvadharmavirahazUnyatetyabhyupagamaparaH zuddhataraparyAyAstikAvalambI RjusUtro vyavasthitaH, athavA sautrAntikavaibhASikau bAhyArthamAzritau yathAkramamRjusUtrazabdau, vaibhASikeNa nityAnityazabdavAcyasya pudgalasyAbhyupagamAcchabdanaye tasyAnupradezaH / bAhyArthapratikSepeNa vijJAnamAtrAbhyupagamaparaH samabhirUDho yogAcAraH / ekAnekadharmavikalatayA vijJAnamAtrasyApyabhAva ityevamabhyupagamapara evambhUto mAdhyamika iti sammativRttau vyavasthitam, tatpUrvapakSasamAdhAnAdikamapi tata evAvaseyam, vistarabhayAnneha vilikhyate, navInatarkaspRhayAlubhiSTAAtrArthe matkRtasyAdvAdakalpalatA parizIlanIyA / RjusUtranayavicAraH sampUrNaH / / -: dvAdazAranayacakre : Araka 9 evameva ceti yadapi lakSaNakAreNa zabdanayalakSaNamuktam-nAma-sthApanA-dravyavAcyeSTAkaraNAd bhAvayuktavAcI zabda: [ ] iti, bhAvaH paryAyo niyamo guNo vA, tadyuktavAcI tadyuktamarthaM brUte iti zabdanayamataM tadapi evaM yujyate yadavaktavyamiti paryavaNamAtramAha, sAmAnyavizeSaikatvAnyatvAnekAtmakasya vastuno vAcA vaktumazakyatvAt / zabdanayadezatvAt paryavAstika eSaH, [sammatau] "tassa tu saddavikappA sAha-pasAhA suhumabhedA" (1/5) iti vacanAcchabdanaye'ntarbhUtaH / [ nayavanikSepANAmapi yathAsvaM dravyArthika-paryAyArthikarUpatayA vibhajanam ] nayAnuyogadvAravat zeSAnuyogadvAreSvapi dravyArthika-paryAyArthiko mUlavyAkaraNinAviti darzayannanayorvyApakatAm nAma ThavaNA davie tti esa davvaTThiyassa nikkhevo / bhAvo u pajavaTThiassa parUvaNA esa paramattho / / 6 / / ityanayA gAthayA darzayatyAcAryaH / athavA vastunibandhanAdhyavasAyanimittavyavahAramUlakAraNatAmanayoH pratipAdya adhunA 1- saddAIA (saMmati.) / 2- a (syA. kalpa.) / 3- pajjavaTThiyaparUvaNA (dvAda. naya,, syA. kalpa.) / 2010_02

Page #68
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-6 adhyAropitA'nadhyAropitanAma-sthApanA-dravya-bhAvanibandhanavyavahAranibandhanatAmanayoreva pratipAdayannAhAcAryaH-nAmaM ThavaNA ityAdi / asyApTA samudAyArthaH nAma sthApanA dravyam iti eSa dravyArthikasya nikSepaH / bhAvastu paryAyArthikanirUpaNAyA nikSepa iti eSa paramArthaH / [1 nAmanikSepaH ] [ nAma vyAkhyAya tatra saMketavidhi-tadviSayayoH prarUpaNam ] tatra yasya kasyacid vastuno vyavahArArthamabhidhAnaM nimittasavyapekSam anapekSaM vA yat saGketyate tannAma / saGketakaraNaM tu kvacid abhedena yathA 'ayaM ghaTaH' iti, kvacid bhedena yathA 'asya cAyaM ghaTazabdo vAcakaH' iti bhedena / etacca samAnAsamAnAkAraMpariNatyAtmake'pi vastuni samAnAkArapratipAdanAyaiva niyojyate tasyAnugatatvena tatra saMketakaraNasaukaryAt / asamAnapariNateSvananugamAt AnantyAJca na tatra saGketaH kartuM zakyaH / zabdavyApArAJca vastugatasadRzapariNatereva pratibhAsanAt sa eva zabdArtho yaH zAbdyAM pratItau pratibhAtIti nA'sadRzapariNAmo'tyantavilakSaNastasyArtha iti vastusthitiH / [S.T.P. 379) __ [2 sthApanAnikSepaH] [ sthApanAM vyAkhyAya mukhya-pratinidhyorbhedAbhedapakSadvaye'pi tasyA dravyArthikanikSeparUpatva-vyavasthApanam ] saGketAbhidhAnasyArthasya pratikRtikalpanA sthApaneti yad vastu sadbhUtAkAreNa sthApyata iti NijantAt karmaNi Su(yu)pratyayaH / sApi dravyArthikasya nikSepaH mukhya-pratinidhivibhAgAbhAvAt sadavizeSAt sarvasya mukhyArthakriyAkaraNAt anyathopayAcitAdestato'siddhiprasakteH tannimittadravyAdiviniyogavyavahArAbhAvaprasakteSTA mukhyapadArtharUpatvAt sthApanAyA dravyArthatvAt / athavA adhyavasAyoparacitameva sthApanAyAstadekatvam, na punarvAstavam anyathA mukhyapratinidhivibhAgAbhAvaprasaktestadrUpopalakSakatvAbhAvaprasakteSTA / nAbhede upalakSyopalakSakabhAva upapannaH / nApi bhinnadezakAlacetanA'cetanamuktAdivibhAgo nyAyAnugato bhavediti sarvatra 2010_02

Page #69
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 1, gAthA - 6 sadbhAvAsadbhAvarUpatayA pravarttamAnatvAt dravyadharmasadbhAvAdekatvAdhyavasAyakRtameva tasyA dravyArthatvamiti dravyArthikanikSepaH sthApanA / 24 [ 3 dravyanikSepaH ] [ dravyaM vyAkhyAya tatra dravyArthikanikSepatvabhAvanam ] dravati atItA'nAgataparyAyAnadhikaraNatvena avicalitarUpaM sa (sat) gacchatIti dravyam tacca bhUtabhAviparyAyakAraNatvAt cetanamacetanaM vA anupacaritameva dravyArthikanikSepaH [S. T.P.387] [ dravyanikSepaviSayasya dravyasya AgamoktarItyA svarUpavarNanam ] dravyaM ca anubhUtaparyAyam anubhaviSyatparyAyaM caikameva tena 'anubhUtaparyAya 'zabdena tat kadAcidabhidhIyate kadAcicca 'anubhaviSyatparyAya' zabdena yathA atItaghRtasambandho ghaTo 'ghRtaghaTaH' ityabhidhIyate bhaviSyattatsambandho'pi tathaivAbhidhAnagocaracArI / zuddhatara- paryAyAstikena ca nirAkArasya jJAnasyArthagrAhakatvAsambhavAt sAkAraM jJAnamabhyupagatam, tatsaMvedanameva cArthasaMvedanaM jJAnAnubhavavyatirekeNAparasyArthAnubhavasyAbhAvAt ghaTopayoga eva ghaTastanmatena / tatparyAyeNa atItena pariNatam-pariNaMsyad vA dravyaM tacchabdavAcyaM dravyArthikamatena vyavasthitaM pUrvavat / ata eva ghaTAdyarthAbhijJastatra ca anupayukto 'dravyam' iti pratipAdito dravyArthikanikSepaSTA / dravyamAgame anekadhA pratipAditam iha tu yuktisaMsparzamAtrameva pradarzyate tadarthatvAt prayAsasya / [ 4 bhAvanikSepaH ] [ bhAvaM vyAkhyAya tatra paryAyArthikatvakathanam ] bhavati-vivakSitavarttamAnasamayaparyAyarUpeNa utpadyate iti bhAvaH, " vibhASA grahaH " ( 3-1143 siddhAntakau0 aM0 2905) ityatra sUtre kaiSTiAd "bhavateSTA" iti No'pISyate / athavA bhUtirbhAvo vajra-kirITAdidhAraNavarttamAnaparyAyeNendrAdirUpatayA vastuno bhavanam, tadgrahaNaparyAyeNa vA jJAnasya bhavanam / yathA cAyaM paryAyArthikaprarUpaNA tathA pradarzita eva prAk na punarucyate / eSa eva nayanikSepAnuyogapratipAditaH ubhayanayapravibhAgaH paramArthaH paramaM hRdayamAgamasyaitadavyatiriktaviSayatvAt sarvanayavAdAnAm, na hi zAstraparamahRdayanayadvaya 2010_02

Page #70
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-6 vyatiriktaH kaSTiAnnayo vidyate sAmAnyavizeSasvarUpaviSayadvayavyatiriktaviSayAntarAbhAda: d viSayiNo'pyaparasya nayAntarasyAbhAva iti prAk pratipAditamiti / / 6 / / [S.T.P.406] ___- zAstravArtAsamuccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAM stabaka 7, gAthA.17 nanu tathApi "NAmAitiyaM davvaviyassa bhAvo a pajjavaNayassa" [vi. A. bhA. 75] iti maGgalAdhikAre'bhidhAya, upoddhAte "bhAvaM ciya saddaNayA sesA icchaMti savvaNikkheve" [vi. A. bhA. 2847] iti vadatAM bhASyakRtAM ko'bhiprAyaH ? iti cet ? ayamabhiprAyaH - pUrva zuddhacaraNopayogarUpabhAvamaGgalAdhikArasaMbandhAd naigamAdinA jalAharaNAdirUpabhAvaghaTAbhyupagame'pi ghaTopayogarUpabhAvaghaTAnabhyupagamAt tathoktiH, pRthaganikSepAcca na pratyayasyAbhidhAnatulyatA / agre tu vyavasthAdhikArAd vizeSoktiH, iti 'dravyArthikasya nAmAditrayam' ityatra nAvadhAraNam, 'paryavanayasya bhAvaH' ityatra cAvadhAraNam, ityanena svAtantryeNa nAmAditrayaviSayatvameva dravyArthikasyetyabhipretya nayAntareNa vA pUrvaM tathoktiH / ata evoktaM tattvArthavRttau-"atra cAdyA nAmAdayastrayo vikalpA dravyArthikasya, tathA tathA sarvArthatvAt, pApTAtyaH paryAyanayasya, tathApariNativijJAnAbhyAm" iti / ata eva ca "nAma ThavaNA davie tti esa davyaTThiyassa Nikkhevo / __ bhAvo a pajavaTThi aparUvaNA esa paramattho / / " [1/6] iti sammatigAthAyAm / athavA, vastunibandhanAdhyavasAyanimittavyavahAramUlakAraNatAmanayoH pratipAdyAdhunA'dhyAropitA-'nadhyAropitanAma-sthApanA-dravya-bhAvanibandhanavyavahAranibandhanatAmanayoreva pratipAdayannAhAcArya:-iti dvitIyAvataraNikA / iti dRDhataraM sudhIbhirvibhAvanIyam / ityevaM buddhanikSepo mauDhyakSepodyataH sudhIH / tathA tathA prayuJjIta yathA saMdhA na bAdhate / / iti / / 17 / / -: dvAdazAranayacakre : Araka-8 ___ evaM caitadityAdhuktArthopanayaH / tatra zabdanayasya etaddarzanam-yathArthAbhidhAnameva nyAyyam / lakSaNaM 1- u (saMmati.) / 2-pajjavaTThiassa parUvaNA (saMmati.) / 2010_02

Page #71
26 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-6 ca yathArthAbhidhAnaM zabdaH [tattvArthabhA0 1/35] / tathA nAma-sthApanA-dravya-bhinnaliGgAdivAcyeTAkaraNAdbhAvayuktavAcI zabdaH [ ] iti ca lakSaNAntaram / tatra vibhAgena dravyadravyArthavAcyaM pUrvanayeSUktamiSTaM na karotIti naigamAdigocaramanenApi vyAvartitameva zabdanayena / vyavahAragocaranAmadravyArthavAcyamapISTaM na karotItyadhunA vyAvartitam / RjusUtrasyArthaparyAyasya gocaraM ca bhinnaliGgAdivAcyamiSTaM na karotIti yathA vacanAdi sAdhu iti manyamAnaH zabdanayaH pravartate yuktyA ca yathA tasya mataM zabdasya tathA prakArAntaM pradarzitam / tathAcAryasiddhasenA'pyAha [sammatau] - "nAmaM ThavaNA davie tti esa davaTThiyassa Nikkhevo / bhAvo u pajjavaTThiyaparUvaNA esa paramattho / / " [1/6] tti / -: vizeSAvazyakabhASye : svopajJaTIkAyAm, gAthA. 75 NAmAitiyaM davvaTThiyassa bhAvo ya pajjavaNayassa / saMgahavavahArA paDhamagassa sesA ya itarassa / / 75 / / NAmAditi0 gAhA / atra ca nAma-sthApanA-dravyanikSepatrayaM dravyAstikasyaivAbhimatama, na paryAyAstikasya, tadarthazUnyatvAt / paryAyAstikasya tu bhAva eva / dravyAstikanayAvalambinau saMgrahavyavahArau, RjusUtrAdayastu paryAyanayamatAnusAriNa AcAryasiddhasenAbhiprAyAt; anyathA hi sUtre'bhihitam"ujjusutassa ege aNuvayutte Agamato egaM davvAvassayaM, pudhattaM Necchati' (anu0 14) iti, atassa dravyamicchan kathaM bhAvamAtragrAhiNaM paryAyanayamAlambati ? / / 75 / / - vizeSAvazyakabhASye : pU. koTyAcAryakRtaTIkAyAm, gAthA. 75 idAnImayaM nAmAdikSepaH sAmAnyato vizeSataSTA nayaiH parimRgyate iti, ata Aha nAmAitiyaM davvaTThiyassa bhAvo ya pajjavanayassa / saMgahavavahArA paDhamagassa sesA ya iyarassa / / 75 / / 'nAmAi' ityAdi, tatra nAmAdinikSepatrayaM dravyAstikasya matam, tadarthazUnyatvAt tasya cAbhAvAva1-pajjavaTThiassa parUvaNA (saMmati.) / 2010_02

Page #72
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa -1, gAthA- 7 lambitvAd dravyAstikatvAd, 'bhAvo ya pajjavaNayassa' maptaM tadarthAzUnyatvAd, tathA saMgrahavyavahArau dvAvapi 'paDhamagassa'tti prathamanayamatAvalambinau, zeSAstu-RjusUtrAdayaH, itarasya dvitIyasya matamAlambata iti vAkyazeSaH, etaccAcAryasiddhasenAbhiprAyeNa ucyate, na sUtrAbhiprAyeNa, tathAhi sUtre'bhihitam"ujjusuyassa ege aNuvautte [ egaM davvaM ] AgamaMto egaM davvAvassayaM, puhattaM necchai" ityato'sau dravyamicchan kathaM bhAvamAtragrAhiNaM paryAyanayamAlambate iti gAthArthaH / / 75 / / [ dravya-paryAyayoranyonyavyAptijJaptaye nirapekSanayAzritavacasAmasatyatvakathanam ] etadapi nayadvayaM zAstrasya paramahRdayam ' dravyaM paryAyAzUnyam, paryAyASTA dravyAvirahiNaH' ityevaMbhUtArthapratipAdanaparam, nAnyathetyetasyArthasya pradarzanArthamAha pajjavaNissAmaNNaM vayaNaM davvaTThiyassa 'asthi'ti / avaseso vayaNavihI pajjavabhayaNA sapavikkho / / 7 / / parasparanirapekSasya nayadvayasya pratyekamevaM vacanavidhiH- dravyAstikasya ananuSaktavizeSaM vacanam 'asti'ityetAvanmAtram, paryAyAstikasya tvaparAmRSTasattAsvabhAvaM 'dravyam' 'pRthivI' 'ghaTaH' 'zuklaH' ityAdyAzritaparyAyam / parasparanirapekSaM cobhayanayavaco'sadeva, vacanArthA - sattvAt / vacanamasadarthamiti tadarthasyApyasattvamAveditaM bhavatIti samudAyArthaH / 27 avayavArthastu-paryAyanayena saha niHsAmAnyam asAdhAraNaM vacanaM dravyAstikasya asti iti etat, bhedavAdyabhyupagatasya vizeSasya sattArUpatAnupravezAt / etacca vaco nirviSayam, nirvizeSatvAt, viyatkusumAbhidhAnavat "nirvizeSaM hi sAmAnyaM bhavecchazaviSANavat" (zlo0 vA0 AkRti0 zlo0 10) iti prasAdhitatvAnnAvyAptirhetoH / asiddhiH parAbhyupagamAdeva parihRtA / tanna ekAntabhAvanApravRttasya dravyAstikanayasya paramArthatA / paryAyAstikasyApyevaMpravRttasya na seti paSTArthena pratipAdayati- avazeSa iti zeSaH sa copayuktAdanyaH vacanavidhiH vacanabhedaH sattAvikalavizeSapratipAdakaH paryAyeSu sattAvyatirikteSvasatsu bhajanAt sattAyA AropaNAt sapratipakSaH iti sataH pratipakSaH - virodhI asan bhavati / tathAhi paryAyapratipAdako vacanavidhiravastuviSayaH, niHsAmAnyatvAt, khapuSpavat / bhAvanA tu dravyArthikavacanaviparyayeNa prayogasya kAryA / 2010_02

Page #73
28 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-8 athavA "arthAbhidhAnapratyayAstulyanAmadheyAH"[ ] iti artha-pratyayoH svarUpamabhidhAya abhidhAnasya dravyAstika-paryAyAstikasvarUpasya tadabhidhAyakasya vA pratipAdanArthamAhapajjavaNissAmaNNaM ityAdi / paryAyAniSkrAntam-tadvikalam-sAmAnyaM saGgrahasvarUpaM yasmin vacane tat paryAyanissAmAnyaM vacanam / kiM punastat ? ityAha-asti iti, tacca dravyArthikasya svarUpam pratipAdakaM vA / yadvA paryAyaH RjusUtranayaviSayAd anyo dravyatvAdivizeSaH, sa eva ca niSTiAtaM sAmAnyaM yasmiMstat paryAyanissAmAnyaM vacanam / dravyatvAdisAmAnyavizeSAbhidhAyIti yAvat / taJca azuddhadravyArthikasambandhi tatpratipAdakatvena tatsvarUpatvena vA / avazeSo vacanavidhiH varNapaddhatiH sapratipakSaH asya vacanasya paryAyArthikanayarUpaH tatpratipAdako vA paryAyasevanAt; anyathA kathamavazeSavacanavidhiH syAt yadi vizeSaM nAzrayet ? / / 7 / / [S.T.P.407] [ dravya-paryAyayoranyonyasammizratvasUcanAya jJAnAnekAntavarNanam ] evaM tAvad dravyArthika-paryAyArthikabhedena bhedamanubhavatAM nayAnAM svarUpaM pratipAdya anekAntabhAvabhAvanayaivaiSAM satyatA nAnyathetyetatpratipAdanArthaM jJAnAnekAntameva tAvadAha pajjavaNayavokvaMtaM vatthu davaTThiyassa vayaNijjaM / jAva daviovaogo apacchimaviyappa-nivvayaNo / / 8 / / dravyAstikasya vaktavyam-paricchedyo viSayaH, niSTAyakartR vacanaM nirvacanam, vikalpaSTA nirvacanaM ca vikalpa-nirvacanam, na vidyate papTiAmaM yasmin vikalpanirvacane tat-tathA-tathAvidhaM tada yasya dravyopayogasyAsau apaSTiAmavikalpanirvacanaH saGgrahAvasAna iti yAvata tataH paraM vikalpa-vacanA'pravRtteH / yAvad apaSTiAmavikalpanirvacano dravyopayogaH pravarttate tAvad dravyArthikasya viSayo vastu, taJca paryAyAkrAntameva; anyathA jJAnA'rthayorapratipatterasattvaprasaktiH / na hi paryAyA'nAkrAntasattAmAtrasadbhAvagrAhakaM pratyakSam anumAnaM vA pramANamasti, dravyAdiparyAyAkrAntasyaiva sarvadA sattArUpasya tAbhyAmavagateH / 1-vattavvaM (ane. vya., jJAnabi.) / 2010_02

Page #74
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 1, gAthA-8 yadvA yad vastu sUkSmataratamAdibuddhinA paryAyanayena sthUlarUpatyAgenottarottarasUkSmarUpAzrayaNAd vyutkrAntam gRhItvA tyaktam, yathA kimidaM mRtsAmAnyaM ghaTAdibhirvinA pratipattiviSayo yAvat zuklatamarUpasvarUpo'ntyo vizeSaH etad dravyArthikasya vastu viSayaH yato yAvad apaSTimavikalpanirvacano'ntyo vizeSastAvad dravyopayogaH dravyajJAnaM pravartate; na hi dravyAdayo vizeSAntAH sadAdipratyayA viziSTaikAntavyAvRttabuddhigrAhyatayA pratIyante, na ca tathA'pratIyamAnAstathAbhyupagamArhAH atiprasaGgAt / / 8 / / [S.T.P.408] -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM vyavahAranayasvarUpavarNane, patra - 28 nanu sAmAnyavizeSAtmake vastuni vizeSaM gRhNatA vyavahAreNa sAmAnyamapi sambhRtasAmagra grAhyameva, sUkSmasUkSmataraparyAyanayatyaktasyArthasya dravyArthikaviSayatvAt / taduktaM sammatIpajjavaNayavukkataM vatyuM davvadviyassa vattavyaM / jAva daviovaogo, apacchimaviyappanivvayaNo / / 1-8 / / "tti atra na vidyete paSTiAme vikalpanirvacane savikalpakadhIvyavahAralakSaNe yatra sa tathA saGgrahAvasAna iti yAvat, tataH paraM vikalpavacanApravRtteH, IdRzo yAvad dravyopayogaH pravartate tAvad dravyArthikasya vacanIyaM vastu, taca paryAyanayena vi vizeSeNa, udUrdhvam, krAntameva viSayIkRtameva paryAyAnAkrAntasattAyAM mAnAbhAvAdityeko'rthaH / -- yadvA yadvastu sUkSmasUkSmatarasUkSmatamAdibuddhinA paryAyanayena sthUlarUpaM tyajatA vyutkrAntaM gRhItvA muktaM kimidaM mRtsAmAnyaM yaSTaTAdivizeSAnyabuddhiviSayIbhavedityevamAkAreNa yAvacchuklarUpatamo'ntyo vizeSastAvattatsarvaM dravyArthikasya vacanIyam I yato yAvadapaSTimavikalpanirvacano'ntyo vizeSastAvaddravyopayogaH pravartata iti dvitIyo'rthaH / / 1- vayaNijjaM [saMmati, nayo . ] 29 -: nayopadeze : gAthA 15 "pajJjavaNayavukkaMtaM vatyuM davvaTThi assa vayaNijjaM / jAva daviovaogo apacchimavikappa - NivvayaNo" / / [sammatau - 1/8 ] tti 2010_02

Page #75
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 1, gAthA - 9 na vidyate paSTiAme vikalpa - nirvacane savikalpadhIrvyavahAralakSaNo yatra sa tathA saGgrahAvasAna i yAvat, tataH paraM vikalpa - vacanApravRtteH, IdRzo yAvad dravyopayogo prarvatate tAvad dravyArthikasya vacanIyaM vastu, tacca paryAyanayena vi vizeSaNa, ut Urdhvam, krAntameva viSayIkRtameva paryAyAnAkrAntasattAyAM mAnAbhAvAdityeko'rthaH / 30 yadvA yad vastu sUkSmatara - sUkSmatamAdibuddhinA paryAyanayena sthUlarUpaM tyajatA ( uttaratra sUkSmarUpAzrayaNAt) vyutkrAntaM gRhItvA muktam, yathA 'kimidaM mRtsAmAnyaM yat ghaTAdivizeSAnuparaktatA viSayIbhaved' ityevamAkAreNa yAvacchuklarUpatamo'ntyo vizeSastAvat tat sarvaM dravyArthikasya vacanIyatA, yAvadapaSTimavikalpanirvacano yo'ntyaH vizeSastAvad dravyopayogaH pravartata iti dvitIyo'rthaH / / -: jJAnabindu: :"pajavaNayavuktaM vatyuM davvaTTiyassa vattavyaM / } java daviovaogo apacchimaviyappa-nivvayaNo / / " [ sammatau - 1 / 8 ] iti / paryAyanayena vyutkrAntaM gRhItvA vicAreNa muktaM vastu dravyArthikasya vaktavyam / yathA 'ghaTo dravyam' ityatra ghaTatvaviziSTasya paricchinnasya dravyatvaviziSTenA'paricchinnena saha bhedAnvayA'sambhava iti mRdeva dravyamiti dravyArthikapravRttistatrApi sUkSmekSikAyAmaparAparadravyArthikapravRttiH yAvaddravyopayogaH / na vidyete paSTime uttare vikalpanirvacane savikalpakadhIvyavahArau yatra sa tathA, zuddhasaGgrahAvasAna iti yAvat / tataH paraM vikalpavacanA'pravRtteH ityetasyAH arthaH / [ vastugatyA dvayAtmaka eva tattve nayadvayaviSayavivekasya vivakSAdhInatvAbhidhAnam ] tadevaM na sattA vizeSavirahiNI, nApi vizeSAH sattAvikalA iti pradaryopasaMharannAhadavvaTTiTThao tti tamhA natthi Nao niyama suddhajAIo / Na ya pajjavaTTio NAma koi bhayaNAya' u visesa / / 9 / / tasmAd dravyArthikaH iti nayaH zuddhajAtIyo vizeSavinirmukto nAsti niyamena ityavadhAraNArthaH, viSayAbhAvena viSayiNo'pyabhAvAt / na ca paryAyArthiko'pi kaTizannayaH 'nAma' iti prasiddhArthaH-niyamena zuddhasvarUpaH sambhavati, sAmAnyavikalAtyantavyAvRttavizeSaviSayA 1- vayaNijjaM (saMmati.) 2 - bhayaNAi (ane.vya., syA. kalpa.) / 2010_02

Page #76
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-9 bhAvena viSayiNo'pyabhAvAt / yadi viSayAbhAvAd imau nayau na staH yaduktam 'tIrthakaravacanasaGgraha'-ityAdi tad virudhyata ityAha-bhayaNAya u viseso bhajanAyAstu vivakSAyA eva vizeSaH-'idaM dravyam ayaM paryAyaH' ityayaM bhedaH tathA tadbhedAd viSayiNo'pi tathaiva bheda ityabhiprAyaH / bhajanA ca-sAmAnyavizeSAtmake vastutattve upasarjanIkRtavizeSaM yad anvayirUpaM tad 'dravyam' iti vivakSyate yadA tadA dravyArthikaviSayaH, tadA tUpasarjanIkRtAnvayirUpaM tasyaiva vastuno yad asAdhAraNaM rUpaM tad vivakSyate tadA paryAyanayaviSayastad bhavatIti / / 9 / / [S.T.P.408] -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : vyavahAranayasvarUpavarNane, patra-28 - ata eva dravyaparyAyaviSayatAbhyAM taditarAviSayatayA vA na zuddhajAtIyadravyArthikaparyAyArthikabhAvavyavasthA, kintUpasarjanIkRtAnyArtha-pradhAnakRtasvArthaviSayatayAnekAntAnupravezAdeva / taduktaM [sammatau] - "davvaTThiotti tamhA, Natthi Nao Niyama suddhajAIo / . Na ya pajjavaDio NAma, koi bhayaNAi'u viseso / / 1/9 / / " bhajanA upasarjanapradhAnabhAvAvagAhanA / / -: nayopadeze : gAthA-15 ata eva dravya-paryAyaviSayatayA taditarAviSayatayA vA na zuddhajAtIyadravyArthikavyavasthA, kintUpasarjanIkRtAnyArtha-pradhAnIkRtasvArthaviSayatayA, taduktam [sammatau] - "davvaDhio tti tamhA Natthi Nayo niyama suddhajAIo / Na ya pajjavaTThio NAma koi bhayaNAya u viseso " / / 1/9 / / tti bhajanA- upasarjana-pradhAnabhAvAvagAhanA / Aha-sAmAnyasaGgrahe'pi zuddhadravyArthekAntiko na 1-bhayaNAya (saMmati.) ___ 2010_02

Page #77
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-10 syAditi cet ? na syAdeva, paryAyanayavicArAnavatAradazAyAmeva tasya zuddhatvavyavasthiteH, tadavatAre tu pUrvapravRttadravyArthikAprAmANyaniSTAyena tadarthAbhAvasyaiva niSTAyAt / -: zAstravArtAsamuccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAm, stabaka 7, gAthA-10 ata eva dravyAstikAdeH pratyekamitthaMrUpatayA sattvam, anitthaMrUpatayA cA'sattvaM paribhASitam [sammatau] "davvaTThiu tti tamhA Natthi Nao Niyama suddhajAtIo / na ya pajjavaDhio NAma koi bhayaNAi'u viseso / / 1/9 / / " iti / [ane ?]na hi viSayabhedakRto'nayorbhedaH, dvayAtmakasyaiva prAtisvikarUpeNa dvAbhyAM grahAt, kintu bhajanayA vivakSAbhedakRtapratibhAsabhedAdityuttarArdhatAtparyam / _ [ vivakSAkRtasya nayadvayaviSayavivekasya vizadIkaraNam ] evaMrUpabhajanAkRtameva bhedaM darzayitumAha davvaTThiyavattavvaM avatthu NiyameNa pajjavaNayassa / taha pajjavavatthu avatthumeva dabaTThiyanayassa / / 10 / / paryAyAstikasya dravyAstikAbhidheyamastitvam avastveva bhedarUpApannatvAt dravyAstikasyApi paryAyAstikAbhyupagatA bhedA avasturUpA eva bhavanti, sattArUpApannatvAt / ato bhajanAmantareNaikatra sattAyAH aparatra ca bhedAnAM naSTatvAd 'idaM dravyam ete ca paryAyAH' iti nAsti bhedaH / na ca pratibhAsamAnayordravya-paryAyayoH kathaM paryAyAstika-dravyAstikAbhyAM pratikSepaH iti vaktavyam, yataH pratibhAso'pratibhAsasya bAdhako na tu mithyAtvasya; mithyArUpasyApi pratibhAsanAta / tathAhi paryAyAstikaH prAha-na mayA dravyapratibhAso niSidhyate-tasyAnubhUyamAnatvAt-kintu vizeSavyatirekeNa dravyasyApratibhAsanAd avyatireke tu vyaktisvarUpavat tasyAnanvayAd ubhayarUpatAyApTaukatra virodhAt gatyantarAbhAvAt dravyapratibhAsastatra mithyaiva / vizeSapratibhAsastvanyathA, bAdhakAbhAvAt yataH pratikSaNaM vastuno nivRtte zotpAdau paryAyalakSaNaM na sthitiH / dravyArthikastu bhajanotthApitasvarUpaH prAha-asmAkamapyayamevA 1-bhayaNAya (saMmati.) / 2-hoi pajjAe (ane.vya., nayo., syA. kalpa.) 2010_02

Page #78
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 1, gAthA - 10 bhyupagamaH-na vizeSapratibhAsapratikSepaH kintu tasya bhedAbhedobhayavikalpairbAdhyamAnatvAd mithyArUpataiva abhedapratibhAsastu anutpAdavyayalakSaNasya dravyasya - tadviSayasya sarvadA'vasthiterabAdhyamAnatvAt-satya iti / / 10 / / [S. T.P. 409] -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM vyavahAranayasvarUpavarNane, patra- 28 tathA (yA) ca kathaM vastugatyA sAmAnyaviSayasya vyavahArasya tadabhAvA'rthaM yatna iti cet, na hi sArvajanIno nayAntarArthapratibhAso nayAntareNa bAdhyate kintu tadaprAmANyaM viSayIkriyata iti jJAnaprAmANyasaMzayAdarthasaMzaya iva tadaprAmANyaniSTAyAttadarthAbhAvaniSTAya iti sAmAnyanayAprAmANyaniSTAyaprayuktatadabhAvaniSTAyatvameva tadabhAvArthayatnaparatvamiti na ko'pi doSaH / tadidamuktaM mahAvAdinA [sammatau] - "davvaTThiyavattavyaM, avatthu niyameNa hoi pajjA / / taha pajjavavatthu avatthumeva davvaTThiyaNayassa / / 1/10 / / " avastu-itaranayaprAdhAnyopasthitijanitatannayAprAmANyaniSTAyakRtA'vastutvaniSTAyaviSayaH, tathA caitadabhyuccayArthamuktam [sammatau ] - - "uppajyaMti cayaMti a, bhAvA NiyameNa paJjavaNayassa / davvaTThiyassa savvaM, sayA aNuppaNNamaviNa / / 1/11 / / " taduktam [sammatau]-- -: 2010_02 : nayopadeze gAthA - 15 : 33 "davvaTThiavattavyaM avatthu niyameNa hoi pajjAe / taha pajjavavatthu avatthameva davvaTThi anayassa" / / 1/10 / / avastu -- itaranayaprAdhAnyopasthitijanitanayAprAmANyaniSTAyakRtAvastutvaniSTAyaviSayaH, tasmAt 1- pajjavaNayassa (saMmati ) / 2- viyaMti ( saMmati ) /

Page #79
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-11 paryAyavinirmuktaprakAratAkasya paryAyaniSThopasarjanatvAkhyaviSayatAkasya vA dravyArthikasya tattarkopanItasvArthavicAradazAyAmeva zuddhatvam, paryAyanayArthAntarabhAvAkAGkSAyAM cAzuddhatvamiti vivekaH / / 15 / / -: zAstravArtAsamuccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAm, stabaka 7, gAthA-11 tasmAt paryAyArthika utpAda-vyayapratibhAse satyatvamavagacchati, dhrauvyapratibhAse tvasatyatvam, na tu tatpratibhAsameva pratikSipati, anubhUyamAnatadviSayatA'tadviSayatAkatvasya vyavasthApayitumazakyatvAt / na khalu sahasreNApi bAdhakaiH 'idaM rajatam' iti pratIte raGgatvAvalambanatvaM vyavasthApayituM zakyate / dravyAstiko'pi dhrauvyapratibhAse satyatvamavagacchati, utpAda-vyayapratibhAse tvasatyatvam / taduktam [sammatau] "davaTThiyavattavyaM avatthu niyameNa hoi pajAe / taha pajjavavatthu avatthumeva davvaTTiyaNayassa / / 1/10 / / uppajaMti cayaMti a bhAvA niameNa pajavanayassa / davvaTThiyassa savvaM sayA aNuppannamaviNahU~ / / 1/11 / / " iti / ayaM ca svaviSayapakSapAto'yuktaH, ubhayapratibhAsaprAmANyasya tulyayogakSematvAdityuktam / tataSTA tryAtmakaM vastu pramANataH paryavasitamiti / / 11 / / [ nirapekSayadvayamekameva vastu yathA yathA manyate tathA vibhajya varNanam ] kalpanAvyavasthApitaparyAyAstika-dravyAstikayorevaMlakSaNapradarzitasvarUpayomithyArUpatApratipattiH sukarA bhaviSyatItyAha uppajjaMti viyaMti ya bhAvA niyameNa pajjavaNayassa / davvaTThiyassa savvaM sayA aNuppannamaviNaTuM / / 11 / / utpadyante prAgabhUtvA bhavanti vizeSeNa niranvayarUpatayA gacchanti nAzamanubhavanti bhAvAH padArthAH niyamena ityavadhAraNe paryAyanayasya matena pratikSaNamutpAda-vinAzasvabhAvA eva bhAvAH paryAyanayasyAbhimatAH / dravyArthikasya sarvaM vastu sadA anutpannamavinaSTama AkAlaM 1-pajjavaNayassa (saMmati.) / 2-viyaMti (saMmati.) | 3-cayaMti (syA. kalpa.) _ 2010_02

Page #80
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-11 sthitisvabhAvameveti matam / etacca nayadvayasyAbhimataM vastu prAk pratipAditamiti na punarucyate / / 11 || [S.T.P. 409] -: vizeSAvazyakabhASye : maladhAragacchIyapU.A.hemacandrasUrIkRtaTIkA atha vakSyamANaniyuktigAthAyAH prastAvanAmAhadavvaM guNo tti bhaiyaM sAmaiyaM savvanayamayAdhAraM / taM dabva-pajjavadviyanayamayamaMgIkareUNaM / / 2642 / / iha sAmAyikaM sarvanayamatAdhAraM sarvanayavicAraviSaya ityarthaH, tatastanmatena bhAjyaM bhajanIyaM dravyaM guNo vA bhavati / tatastad dravyArthika-paryAyAstikanayadvayamatamaGgIkRtya vicAryate / iti gAthApaJcakArthaH / / 2642 / / kathaM vicAryate ? ityAha jIvo guNapaDivanno nayassa davvaTThiyassa sAmaiyaM / so ceva pajjavaTThiyanayassa jIvassa esa guNo / / 2643 / / jIva AtmA guNaiH pratipanna AzritaH, dravyamevArtho yasya na tu paryAyAH sa dravyArthikastasya dravyArthikasya nayasya matena sAmAyikam / idamuktaM bhavati- guNAH khalvaupacArikatvAdasanta eva, dravyavyatirekeNa teSAmanupalambhAt / tatapTA nyagbhUtaguNagrAmo jIva eva mukhyavRtyA sAmAyikaM na tu paryAyA iti dravyArthikanayo manyate / Aha- nanu rUpAdayo guNA yadi na santi, tarhi kathaM lokasya dravye tatpratipattiH ? / ucyate- bhrAntaiveyam, / citre nimnonnatapratipattivat / ityasya nayasyAbhiprAyaH / sa eva sAmAyikAdiguNaH paryAyArthikanayasya paramArthato'sti, na tu jIvadravyam, yasmAjjIvasyaiSa guNaH, jIva iti tatpuruSo'yam, sa cottarapadapradhAnaH, yathA tailasya dhArA tailadhAreti, na cAtra dhArAtiriktaM kimapi tailamasti / evaM jJAnAdiguNAtiriktaM jIvadravyamapi nAstIti paryAyArthikanayAbhiprAyaH / iti niyuktigAthArthaH / / 2643 / / atra bhASyam icchai jaM davvanao davvaM taJcamuvayArao ya guNe / sAmaiyaguNavisiTTho to jIvo tassa sAmaiyaM / / 2644 / / ___ 2010_02

Page #81
36 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-12 pajAo ciya vatthu tacaM davvaM ca taduvayArAo / pajavanayassa jamhA sAmaiyaM teNa pajjAo / / 2645 / / vyAkhyA- yad yasmAd dravyArthikanayastathyaM satyaM dravyamevecchati, guNAMstUpacArata eva manyate na tu satyAn; tatastasmAt sAmAyikaguNaviziSTa upasarjanIbhUtasAmAyikAdiguNo mukhyatayA jIva eva tasya dravyArthikanayasya sAmAyikamiti / yasmAt paryAyArthikanayasya matena paryAya eva tathyaM nirupacaritaM vastu, dravyaM punasteSveva pUrvAparIbhUtaparyAyeSUpacArato vyavahriyate, na tu paramArthatastadasti, teSu paryAyeSUpacArastadupacArastasmAditi samAsaH / tena tasmAt kAraNAt paryAya evAsya mukhyatayA sAmAyikam, na jIvadravyamiti / / 2644 - 2645 / / [anyonyamuktayordravya-paryAyayo stitvoktipUrvakamutpAda-vyaya-dhrauvyANAM dravyalakSaNatvena varNanam ] parasparanirapekSaM cobhayanayapradarzitaM vastu pramANAbhAvato na sambhavatItyAha davvaM pajjavaviuyaM davvaviuttA ya pajjavA Natthi / uppAya-TThii-bhaMgA haMdi daviyalakkhaNaM eyaM / / 12 / / dravyaM paryAyaviyuktaM nAsti mRtpiNDa-sthAsa-koza-kuzUlAdyanugatamRtsAmAnyapratIteH / dravyavirahitASTA paryAyA na santi anugataikAkAramRtsAmAnyAnuviddhatayA mRtpiNDa-sthAsa-kozakuzUlAdInAM vizeSANAM pratipatteH / ato dravyArthikAbhimataM vastu paryAyAkrAntameva na tadviviktam paryAyAbhimatamapi dravyArthAnuSaktaM na tadvikalam, parasparaviviktayoH kadAcidapyapratibhAsanAt / kiMbhUtaM punardravyamastItyAha-utpAda-sthiti-bhaGgA yathAvyAvarNitasvarUpAH parasparAvinirbhAgavartinaH, handi ityupapradarzane; dravyalakSaNaM dravyAstitvavyavasthApako dharmaH etad dRzyatAm, yataH pUrvottaraparyAyaparityAgopAdAnAtmakaikAnvayapratipattistathAbhUtadravyasattvaM pratipAdayatItyutpAdavyaya-dhrauvyalakSaNaM vastvabhyupagantavyam / etaJca tritayaM parasparAnuviddham, anyatamAbhAve taditarayorapyabhAvAt / [S.T.P.410] 2010_02

Page #82
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-12 37 -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : vyavahAranayasvarUpavarNane, patra-29 nanvevaM saGgrahavyavahArayoravadhAraNAMze dvayorapi mithyAtvaM syAt sAmAnyavizeSAnyatarAbhAvavadvizeSyatvAbhAvavatyanyatarasmi~stadabhAvavadvizeSyakatvAvagAhitvAditi cet, syAdeva, utpAdasthitibhaGgAH samuditA hi dravyalakSaNam, na tu pratyekam, ekaikavinirmokeNa dravyApratIteriti pratyekalakSaNa-grAhiNau dravyArthikaparyAyArthiko mUlanayAviha hi mithyAdRSTI, na cAsti tRtIyaH kaSTiAnnaya iti, dvayormUlanayayoreva yadi parasparAtyAgarUpavizeSeNa bhajyamAnayoreva samyaktvahetutA, na tu nirapekSagrAhiNoH, tadA kaiva pratyAzA nirapekSagrAhiNAM mUlanayArthaprajJApanAmAtravyApRtAnAM viziSTAMzAdhigamamAtreNa bhedabhAjAmuttaranayAnAM prAmANye iti / yadvAdI [sammatau] - "davyaM pajjavavijuyaM, davvavijuttA ya pajavA Natthi / uppAyaTThiibhaMgA, haMdi daviyalakkhaNaM eyaM / / ee puNa saMgahao, pADikkamalakkhaNaM duvejhaMpi / tamhA micchaTThiI, patteyaM dovi mUlaNayA / / Na ya taio atthi Nao, Na ya sammataM Na tesu paDipuNNaM / jeNa duve egaMtA, vibhajamANA aNegaMto / / jaha ee taha aNNe, patteaM duNNayA NayA savve / haMdi hu mUlaNayANaM, paNNavaNe vAvaDA tevi / / savvaNayasamUhammi vi, Natthi Nao ubhayavAyapaNNavao / mUlanayANa u ANaM, patteyaM visesiyaM biMti / / " [1/12 taH 16] -: nayopadeze : gAthA-17 idaM ca zuddhaparyAyAstikanayamatam, tadavAntarabhedAstu yAvadapaSTiAmavikalpanirvacanaM dravyArthikAvAntarabhedavat nyAyasiddhA nAnAvidhA abhyupagantavyAH / athaivaM paSTiAmavikalpanirvacanatayA mAdhyamikadarzanapravartaka evambhUta eva zuddhaparyAyArthikaH syAt, iSyate ca sUtro'pi zuddhaparyAyArthika iti kathamiyaM vyavastheti cet ? kSaNikaviSayatAvyApakaparyAyaviSayatAzAlI zuddhaparyAyArthika iti ___ 2010_02

Page #83
38 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-12 paribhASAzrayaNAditi gRhANa / nanvevaM zuddhadravyArthikaparyAyArthikayoritaretaraviSayapratikSepakatvena samuditadravyalakSaNAgrAhitvena mithyAdRSTitvamavAntaratadbhedAnAM ca vaiparItyena samyagdRSTitvaM syAditi yathAzrutazuddhAzuddhavivekAnupapattiriti cet ? idamitthameva jAtyA zuddhAzuddhatvaikAntasya vAdinaiva pratikSiptatvAt, yo nayopayogaH svArthe itaranayArthasaMyojanAyAM vyApiparti tasya tAvatyA'pekSayA samyagdRSTitvasya, yathAzrutArthapravAhapravRttasya tathopayogavaikalyena mithyAdRSTitvasya ca sampradAyasiddhatvAt, taduktam [sammatau] - "davvaM pajjavaviuaMdavvavijuttA ya pajjavA Natthi / uppAya-TThii-bhaMgA haMdi davialakkhaNaM eyaM / / ee puNa saMgahao pADikkamalakkhaNaM duviNhaM pi / tamhA micchaddiTThi patteyaM do vi mUlanayA / / Na ya taio atthi Nao na ya sammattaM na tesu paDipannaM / jeNa duve egantA vibhajjamANA aNeganto / / jaha ee taha anne patteyaM dunnayA nayA savve / haMdi hu mUlanayANaM pannavaNe vAvaDA te vi / / savvaNayasamUhammi vi Natthi Nao ubhayavAyapaNNavao / mUlanayANa u ANaM patteyaM visesi biMti / / " [1/12 taH 16] tti -: AcArAGganiryuktau: gAthA-170 TIkA tadevaM bhedAbhedopapattibhirvyAkulitamatiH ziSyaH pRcchati-ubhayathA'pi doSApattidarzanAtkathaM gRhNImaH ? AcArya Aha-ata eva bhedAbhedo'stu, tatrAbhedapakSe dravyaM guNo bhedapakSe tu bhAvo guNa iti, tathAhi-guNaguNinoH paryAyaparyAyiNoH sAmAnyavizeSayoravayavAvayavinorbhedAbhedavyavasthAnenaivAtmabhAvasadbhAvAt, Aha hi [sammatau] - davvaM pajjavavijuyaM davvaviuttA ya pajavA Natthi / uppAyaTThiibhaMgA haMdi daviyalakkhaNaM eyaM / / 1/12 / / 2010_02

Page #84
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-13 -: zAstravArtAsamuccaye :- . syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAm, stabaka 7, gAthA 3 etadupapattereva sthalAntaramAha payovrato na dadhyatti na payo'tti dadhivrataH / agorasavato nobhe tasmAttattvaM trayAtmakam / / 3 / / payovrataH kSIrabhojanavrataH, na dadhyatti na dadhi bhuGkte / yadi ca danaH payasa ekAntA'bhedaH syAt tadA tasya dadhi bhuJjato'pi na vratabhaGgaH syAt / tathA, dadhivrataH dadhibhojanavrataH, na payaH dugdham atti / payaso dadhna ekAntA'bhede ca bhuJjato na dadhibhojanavratabhaGgaH syAt / tato dadhipayasoH kathaJcidbhedaH / tathA agorasavataH AranAlAdibhojanavrataH, ubhe dugdhadadhinI nAtti iti gorasabhAvena dvayorabhedaH, anyathA kRtagorasapapratyAkhyAnasya dugdhAdyekaikabhojane'pi na vratabhaGgaH syAditi / tasmAt dravyaparyAyobhayAtmakatvAt trayAtmakam utpAda-vyaya-dhrauvyA'pRthagbhUtaM vastu / tathA ca samayaparamArthavedinaH [sammatau] - davvaM pajavaviuaM davvaviuttA ya pajavA Natthi / uppAya-TThii-bhaGgA haMdi ! daviyalakkhaNaM eyaM / / 1/12 / / iti / [svatantrANAmutpAda-vyaya-dhrauvyANAM dravyalakSaNatvAbhAvAt pratyekaM nayadvayasya mithyAtvakathanam] ete ca parasparasavyapekSA dravyalakSaNam na svatantrA iti pradarzanAyAha ee puNa saMgahao pADikkamalakkhaNaM duveNhaM pi / tamhA micchaddiTThI patteyaM do vi mUlaNayA / / 13 / / ette utpAdAdayaH saGgrahataH zibikodvAhipuruSA iva parasparasvarUpopAdAnenaiva lakSaNam / pratyekaM ekakA utpAdAdayo dvayorapi dravyAstika-paryAyAstikayoH alakSaNam uktavat tathAbhUtaviSayAbhAve tadgrAhakayorapi tathAbhUtayorabhAvAt utpAdAdInAM ca parasparaviviktarUpANAmasambhavAt / tasmAtanmithyAdRSTi eva pratyekaM parasparaviviktau dvAvapi etau dravyArthika-paryAyArthikasvarUpau mUlanayau samastanayarAzikAraNabhUtau / / 13 / / [S.T.P.415] _ 2010_02

Page #85
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-14-15 [ubhayArabdhatRtIyanayAbhAve'pi dvayoreva nayayoranyonyasavyapekSayossamyaktvapratipAdanam] syAdetat bhavatu parasparanirapekSayomithyAtvam, ubhayanayArabdhastvekaH samyagdRSTibhaviSyatItyAha Na ya taio atthi Nao Na ya sammattaM Na tesu paDipuNNaM / jeNa duve egantA vibhajjamANA aNeganto / / 14 / / na ca tRtIyaH parasparasApekSobhayagrAhI asti nayaH kaSTiAt tathAbhUtArthasyAnekAntAtmakatvAt tadgrAhiNaH pratyayasya nayAtmakatvAnupapatteH / na ca samyaktvaM na tayoH pratipUrNa pratiSedhadvayena prakRtArthAvagateH / azeSaM hi prAmANyaM sApekSaM gRhyamANayoranayorevaMviSayayorvyavasthitaM yena dvAvapi ekAntarUpatayA vyavasthitau mithyAtvanibandhanam tatparityAgenA'nvaya-vyatireko vizeSaNa parasparAtyAgarUpeNa bhajyamAnau gRhyamANAvanekAnto bhavatIti samyaktvahetutvametayoriti / / 14 / / [S.T.P.416] __ . [ nirapekSagrAhitce mUlanayavaduttaranayAnAmapi mithyAtvavarNanam ] evaM sApekSadvayagrAhiNo nayatvAnupapattestRtIyanayAbhAvaH pradarzitaH, nirapekSagrAhiNAM tu mithyAtvaM darzayitumAha jaha ee taha aNNe patteyaM duNNayA NayA savve / haMdi hu mUlaNayANaM paNNavaNe vAvaDA te vi / / 15 / / yathA etau nirapekSadvayagrAhiNau mUlanayau mithyAdRSTI tathA ubhayavAdarUpeNa vyavasthitAnAmapi parasparanirapekSatvasya mithyAtvanibandhanasya tulyatvAt pratyekam itarAnapekSA anye'pi durnayAH na ca prakRtanayadvayavyatiriktanayAntarArabdhAtvAdubhayavAdasya nayAnAmapi vaicitryAdanyatrAropayitumazakyatvAt tadrUpasyAnye samyakpratyayA bhaviSyantIti vaktavyam, yataH haMdi ityevaM gRhyatAM huH iti hetau mUlanayadvayaparicchinnavastunyeva vyApRtAste'pi tadviSayavyatiriktaviSayAntarAbhAvAt sarvanayavAdAnAM ca sAmAnyavizeSobhayaikAntaviSayatvAt / tanna nayAntarasadbhAvaH yataH tadArabdhobhayavAde nayAntaraM bhavet / / 15 / / [S.T.P.416] _ 2010_02

Page #86
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-16-17 ____41 [ saGgrahAdInAM mUlanayagrAhyagrAhitvAnnobhayavAdaprajJApakatvamiti pradarzanam ] nanu saGgrahAdinayasadbhAvAt kathaM tadvyatiriktanayAntarAbhAva; ? satyam, santi saGgrahAdayaH kintu tadviSayavyatiriktaviSayAntarAbhAvatastadvitayaviSayAste'pi tadrUSaNenaiva dUSitAH yato na mUlacchede tacchAkhAstadavasthAH saMbhavantItyAha savvaNayasamUhammi vi Natthi Nao ubhayavAyapaNNavao / mUlaNayANa u ANaM patteyaM visesiyaM biMti / / 16 / / saMgrahAdisakalanayasamUhe'pi nAsti kaSTiAd naya ubhayavAdaprarUpakaH yataH mUlanayAbhyAmeva yat pratijJAtaM vastu tadeva Azritya pratyekarUpAH saMgrahAdayaH pUrvapUrvanayAdhigatAMzaviziSTamaMzAntaramadhigacchantIti na viSayAntaragocarAH / ato vyavasthitam parasparAtyAgapravRttasAmAnyavizeSaviSayasaGgrahAdyAtmakanayadvayAdhigamyAtmakatvAt vastvapyubhayAtmakam / / 16 / / [S.T.P. 416] [ nityAnityaikAntapakSadvaye'pyAtmani saMsArasukha-duHkhAderanupapattipradarzanam ] na kevalaM bAhyaghaTAdivastu ubhayAtmakaM tathAvidhapramANagrAhyatvAt kintvAntaramapi harSa-zokabhaya-karuNaudAsInyAdyanekAkAravivarttAtmakaikacetanAsvarUpaM tadAtmakaharSAdyanekavikArAnekAtmakaM ca svasaMvedanAdhyakSapratItam, tasya bhedAbhedaikAntaikarUpatAbhyupagame dRSTA'dRSTaviSayasukhaduHkhasAdhanasvIkAra-tyAgArthapravRtti-nivRttisvarUpasakalavyavahArocchedaprasaktiriti pratipAdayitumAha Na ya davaTThiyapakkhe saMsAro Neva pajjavaNayassa / sAsayaviyattivAyI jamhA uccheavAIA / / 17 / / dravyArthika-paryAyArthikanayadvayAbhimate vastuni na saMsAraH sambhavati, zAzvatavyakti pratikSaNAnyatvekAntAtmakacaitanyagrAhakaviSayIkRtatvAt pAvakajJAnaviSayIkRte udakavat / tathAhi-saMsAraH saMsRtiH sA caikAntanityasya pUrvAvasthA'parityAge sati na sambhavati tatparityAge naiva-gateH bhAvAntarApattervA-saMsRteH sambhavAt / nApyucchede utpattyanantara 2010_02

Page #87
42 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-18 niranvayadhvaMsalakSaNe saMsRtiH sambhavati gateH bhAvAntarApattervA kathaJcida anvayirUpamantareNa ayogAt / athaikasya pUrvA'parazarIrAbhyAM viyoga-yogau saMsAraH asAvapi sadA avikAriNi na sambhavati, nityasya pUrvA'parazarIrAbhyAM viyoga-yogAnupapatteH / niranvayakSaNadhvaMsino'pyekAdhikaraNatvAsambhavAt na tallakSaNaH saMsAraH / na ca amUrtasyAtmanaH asarvagataikamano'bhiSvaktazarIreNa viziSTaviyoga-yogau saMsAraH manaso'kartRtvena zarIrasambandhasyAnupapatteH / yo hyadRSTasya vidhAtA sa tannivartitazarIreNa saha sambadhyate, na caivaM manaH, na ca manasaH zarIrasambandhe'pi tatkRtasukha-duHkhopabhoktRtvam Atmani tasyAbhyugamAt tadarthaM ca zarIrasambandho'bhyupagamyata iti tatsambandhaparikalpanaM manaso vyartham, manasi sukhaduHkhopabhoktRtvAbhyupagame vA AtmakalpanAvaiyarthyam manasa AtmatvasiddheH / / 17 / / [S.T.P.417] tathA - suha-dukkhasampaogo Na jujjae NiJcavAyapakkhammi / egaMtuccheyammi ya suha-dukkhaviyappaNamajuttaM / / 18 / / sukhena abAdhAsvarUpeNa, duHkhena bAdhanAlakSaNena, samprayogaH sambandhaH na yujyate na ghaTate Atmano nityavAdapakSe dravyAstikAbhyupagame sukhasvabhAvasya avicalitarUpatvAt sadA sukharUpataiva AtmanaH na duHkhasamprayogaH duHkhasvabhAvatve tadrUpataiva tattvAdeva / ekAntocchede ca paryAyAstikapakSe sukha-duHkhasamprayogo na yujyata iti sambandhaH / tathA pakSadvaye'pi sukhArtham duHkhaviyogArthaM ca viziSTaM kalpanaM yatanam-'kalpateH' atra yatanArthatvAt-ayuktam aghaTamAnakam sukha-duHkhopAdAnatyAgArthaprayatnasyApyayuktatvamuktanyAyAt / "saMsarati nirupabhogaM bhAvairadhivAsitaM liGgam / " [ sAGkhyayakA0 40 ] iti sAGkhyamatamapi nirastam nyAyasya sarvaikAntasAdhAraNatvAt / / 18 / / [S.T.P. 417] dazavaikAlikaniyuktau gAthA-60 suhadukkhasaMpaogo na vijaI nizcavAyapakhaMmi / egaMtuccheaMmi a suhadukkhavigappaNamajuttaM / / 60 / / ___ 1-vijjaI (daza. niryu.) / 2-jujjae (saMmati.) / 2010_02

Page #88
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-19-20 sukhaduHkhasaMprayogaH samyak saMgato vA prayogaH saMprayogaH akalpita ityarthaH na vidyate nAsti na ghaTata ityarthaH, kva ? nityavAdapakSe nityavAdAbhyupagame saMprayogo na vidyate, kalpitastu bhavatyeva, yathA''hurnityavAdinaH- "prakRtyupadhAnataH puruSasya sukhaduHkhe staH, sphaTike raktatAdivad buddhipratibimbAdvA'nye" iti, kalpitatvaM cAsya Atmanastattvata eva tathApariNatimantareNa sukhAdyabhAvAd upadhAnasannidhAvapyandhopale raktatAdivat, tadabhyupagame cAbhyupagamakSatiH, buddhipratibimbapakSe'pyavicalitasyAtmanaH sadaivaikasvabhAvatvAt sadaivaikarUpapratibimbApatteH, svabhAvabhedAbhyupagame cAnityatvaprasaGga iti / mA bhUdanityaikAntagraha ityata Aha- * ekAntena sarvathA ut prAbalyena chedo vinAzaH ekAntocchedaH-niranvayo nAza ityarthaH, asmiMSTA kim ? sukhaduHkhayorvikalpanaM sukhaduHkhavikalpanam, ayuktam aghaTamAnakam, ayamatra bhAvArtha:- ekAntocchede'pi sukhAdyanubhavitustatkSaNa eva sarvAthocchedAdahetukatvAttaduttarakSaNasyotpattirapi na yujyate, kutaH punastadvikalpanamiti gAthArthaH / / [ ekAntapakSe cAtmani karmaNo bandha-sthitikAraNAnupapattiprakaTanam ] ekAntapakSe Atmasukha-duHkhopabhoga-nirvarttakazarIrasambandhahetvadRSTotpAdakanimittAnAmapyasambhavaM darzayannAha kammaM joganimittaM bajjhai bandha-1 dha-TThiI kasAyavasA / apariNaucchiNNesu ya baMdhaTThiikAraNaM Natthi / / 19 / / 43 karma adRSTam, yoganimittaM mano-vAkkAyavyApAranimittam, badhyate AdIyate, badhyata iti bandhaH adRSTameva tasya sthitiH kAlAntaraphaladAtRtvena AtmanyavasthAnam sA kaSAyavazAt krodhAdisAmarthyAt etadubhayamapi ekAntavAdyabhyupagate AtmacaitanyalakSaNe bhAve apariNate utsanne ca bandhasthitikAraNaM nAsti / / 19 / / [S. T.P. 418] [ ekAntavAde bandhA'bhAvena tanmUlakasaMsAranivRttyAderanupapattiprakAzanam ) kiJca, ekAntavAdinAM saMsAranivRttitatsukhamuktiprAptyarthA pravRttiSTAsaGgatetyAhabaMdhammi apUrante saMsArabhaoghadaMsaNaM mojjhaM / bandhaM va viNA mokkhasuhapatthaNA Natthi mokkho ya / / 20 / / bandhe vA'sati saMsAro janma maraNAdiprabandhastatra tatkAraNe vA mithyAtvAdAvupacArAt 2010_02

Page #89
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-21 tacchabdavAcye bhayogho bhItiprAcuryaM tasya darzanam 'sarvaM caturgatiparyaTanaM duHkhAtmakam' iti paryAlocanaM mauDhyaM mUDhatA anupapadyamAnasaMsAraduHkhaughaviSayatvAt mithyAjJAnaM vandhyAsutajanitabAdhAgocarabhItiviSayaparyAlocanavat mithyAjJAnapUrvikA ca pravRttirvisaMvAdinyeva, bandhena vinA saMsAranivRtti-tatsukhaprArthanA ca na bhavatyeva tathA mokSaSTAnupapannaH niraparAdhapuruSavat abaddhasya mokSAsambhavAt, bandhAbhAvaSTA yoga-kaSAyayoH prakRti-sthiti-anubhAga-pradezAtmakabandhahetvorekAntapakSe viruddhatvAt / na caikarUpatvAt brahmaNo bandhAdyabhAvapreraNA na doSAya, cetanA'cetanAdibhedarUpatayA jagataH pratipatteH / na ca bhedapratipattimithyA avidyAnirmitatvAditi vaktavyama avidyAyAH pratipattijananavirodhAta, avirodhe vidyArUpatAprAptedvaitaprAptiriti / prativihitapTAdvaitavAda iti na punaH pratanyate / / 20 || [S.T.P. 419) [ sarveSAmapi nayAnAmanyo'nyA'nizritatve mithyAtvam anyonyanizritve punaH samyaktvamiti pratipAdanam ] / tadevamekAntAbhyupagame bandhahetvAdyanupapatteraihikA''muSmikasarvavyavahAravilopaH ityekAntavyavasthApakAH sarve'pi mithyAdRSTayo nayAH anyonyaviSayA'parityAgavRttayastu ta eva samyaktvaM pratipadyanta ityupasaMharannAha tamhA savve vi NayA 'micchAdiTThI sapakkhapaDibaddhA / aNNoNNaNissiA uNa havaMti sammattasabbhAvA / / 21 / / yasmAd ekAntanityA'nityavastvabhyupagamo bandhAdikAraNayoga-kaSAyAbhyupagamabAdhitaH tadabhyupagamo'pi nityAdyekAntAbhyupagamapratihataH ityevaMbhUtapUrvottarAbhyupagamasvarUpAH tasmAd mithyAdRSTayaH sarve'pi nayAH svapakSapratibaddhAH sva AtmIyaH pakSaH abhyupagamastena pratibaddhAH pratihatA yatastata iti / nayajJAnAnAM ca mithyAtve tadviSayasya tadabhidhAnasya ca mithyAtvameva / tenaivaM prayoga:-mithyA sarvanayavAdAH, svapakSeNaiva pratihatatvAt cauravAkyavat / atha teSAM pratyeka mithyAtve bandhAdyanupapattau samyaktvAnupapattiH sarvetretyAha-anyonyanizritAH parasparA 1-evaM (tatvA. vivaraNa, tatvA. siddha. TIkA, AcA. TIkA) 12. micchaddiTThI (ane. vya., syA. kalpa., tatvA vivrnn)| 3-sapakhapaDivannA (ane.vya., tatvA. vivaraNa) | 4-te caiva sammattaM (AcA.TIkA) / 2010_02

Page #90
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-21 45 parityAgena vyavasthitAH punar iti ta eva samyaktvasya yathAvasthitavastupratyayasya sadbhAvA bhavantIti na bandhAdyanupapattiH / / 21 / / [S.T.P. 419] -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : vyavahAranayasvarUpavarNane, patra 29 nanvevaM sarve'pi nayavAdA mithyA, svapakSeNaiva pratihatatvAJcauravAkyavad' ityanumAnAtsarveSAmeva nayAnAM mithyAdRSTitve tatsamudAye'pi samyaktvaM na syAditi cet, na anyonyanizritatvena samudAye samyaktvasambhavAt / Aha ca [sammatau] - "tamhA savve vi NayA, 'micchaddiTThI sNpkkhpddivnnaa| aNNuNNaNissiyA puNa, havaMti sammattasabbhAvA / / 1/21 / / " samyaktvasya yathAvasthitapratyayasya, bhAvayantIti bhAvAH, santo bhAvAH sadbhAvAH avandhyakAraNAnItyarthaH / jJAnAtmakanayapakSe samyaktvasadbhAvAH samyaktvasvabhAvA iti vArthaH / pratyekaM mithyAvadhAraNAnAmanyanizritasamudAyepi kathaM samyaktvam, svagocarAparityAgena tatrApi teSAM viSayAntarApravRtteriti cet / atra sammativRttikRtaH / pratyekamapyapekSitetarAMzasvaviSayagrAhakatayaiva santo nayAstadvyatiriktarUpatayA tvasanta iti satAM satsamudAye samyaktve na kaSTiAddoSaH / nanvitaretaraviSayAparityAgavRttInAM kathaM jJAnAnAM samudAyaH sambhavati ? yena tatra samyaktvamabhyupagamyeta, anuktopAlambha eSaH / hyekadAnekajJAnotpAdatasteSAM samudAyo vivakSitaH, api tvaparityaktetararUpaviSayAdhyavasAya eva samudAyaH, anyonyanizritA ityanenApyayamevArthaH pratipAditaH / na hi dravyArthika-paryAyArthikAbhyAmatyantapRthagbhUtAbhyAmaGgulidvayasaMyogavadubhayavAdo'paraH prArabdhaH ityAhuH / -: zAstravArtAsamuccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAm, stabaka-7, gAthA-10 nanu yadyevaM dravyAstika-paryAyAstikayordvayorapi pratyekaM mithyAtvaM tadA sikatAsamudAye tailavat tatsamudAye'pi samyaktvAbhAvAt kathaM "pramANa-nayairadhigamaH" [ta0 sU01-6] iti cet ? satyam, na hyatra dalapracayalakSaNaH samudAya ucyate, paryAyasyA'dalatvAt, itaretaraviSayA'parityAgavRttInAM jJAnAnAM samudAyAbhAvAt, kvacit kramikatatsamudAyasyA'vyApakatvAJca; kintvitaranayaviSayIkRtarUpA'1-micchAdiTThI (saMmati.) / 2-sapakkhapaDibaddhA (saMmati.) 2010_02

Page #91
46 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-21 vyavacchedakatvam, tadeva cAnyonyanizritatvaM gIyate / idameva ca pravRttinimittIkRtya tatra samyaktvapadaM pravartate / tadidamuktam [sammatau] - "tamhA savve vi NayA 'micchaTThiI sapakkhapaDibaddhA / aNNoNNaNissiA uNa havaMti sammattasabbhAvA / / 1/21 / / " iti / -: tattvArthAdhigamasUtre :mahAmahopAdhyAyazrIyazovijayajIkRtavivaraNe, adhyAya-1, sUtra-6 atha pramANanayayorjJAnAtmakatvAtsAmAnyavizeSAtmakavastupariccheditvAJca kaH prativizeSa iti cet, atra TIkAkRtaH sarvanayAMzAvalambijJAnaM pramANam / anekadharmAtmake vastunyekadharmAvadhAraNaM ca nayaH / sa ca mithyA, dvayorekatvabuddhivat / yadAha evaM savve vi NayA, 'micchaTThiI sapakkhapaDivannAtti / ' apare tvAhuH- parasparApekSA naigamAdayo nayAH, taiH parasparApaikSairyad jJAnaM samastavastusvarUpAlambanaM janyate tadanavagatavastuparicchedAbhyupAyatvAt pramANam, ye punarbhegamAdayo nirapekSAH paraspareNa, te nayAbhAsA iti / atra prathamapakSe sarveSAM dharmANAM sarvAvacchedena dharmiNi na paryAptiH, kintu pratyekamityanantadharmAtmake'pyekadharmAvadhAraNasya dvayorekatvabuddhivannAprAmANyam / dvitIyapakSe ca sakalanayaghaTitasaptabhaGgyAtmamahAvAkyaikadezasya nayatvasiddhAvapyudAsInatayA'saGgraha iti saptadharmAtmakatvabodhakatAparyAptyadhikaraNaM vAkyaM pramANam, tadekadezabodhakatAparyAptyadhikaraNaM taditarAdUSakaM nayaH, taditaradUSakaM tu durnaya ityayameva lakSaNavibhAgo yuktaH / / - tattvArthAdhigamasUtre :___ pU. siddhasenagaNikRtaTIkAyAm, adhyAya-1, sUtra-7 nanu ca pramANamapi sAmAnyavizeSAtmakavastuparicchedyeva, nayA api caivaMvidhaviSayopanipAnita eveti nAsti kaSTiAd vizeSaH, jJAnAtmakatvAddhi nayA na bhedenopAdeyAH pramANAditi, asatyA eva nayA iti [cedato] heyatayA nyAyyamupAdAnamityetadapi na, yato vakSyati- "na vipratipattayo'rthAdhyavasAyA" iti [1-35] tathA "niyayavayaNijasavvA" [sammatau-1/28] ityAdi / ucyate-pramANanayAnAmayaM bhedaH, 1-micchAdiTThI (saMmati.) / 2-tamhA (saMmati.) / 3-sapakkhapaDibaddhA (saMmati.) / 2010_02

Page #92
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-22-23 xia pramANaM samastavastusvarUpaparicchedAtmakaM matyAdi nayAstu ekAMzAvalambina ityato bhinnaviSayatA, pratyakSaparokSavat / etaduktaM bhavati-sarvanayAMzAvalambi jJAnaM pramANam, yat tu jJAnamanekadharmAtmakaM sadvastu ekadharmAvadhAraNenAvacchinattyevamAtmakamevaitaditi tannayA iti kathyante, ataSTA pramANaM samyagjJAnam, nayAstu mithyAjJAnam, yata Aha- "evaM savvevi nayA micchAdiTThI [sammatau-1/21] / " ityAdi / -: AcArAGgasUtre :pU.A. zIlAGkAcAryakRtaTIkAyAm, a. 1, u. 7, sU. 61 tadevaM sarve'pi nayAH parasparanirapekSA mithyAtvarUpatayA na samyagbhAvamanubhavanti, samuditAstu yathAvasthitArthapratipAdanena samyaktvaM bhavanti, yata uktam [sammatau] - "evaM savvevi NayA micchAdiTThI sapakkhapaDibaddhA / aNNoNNaNissiyA puNa havaMta te ceva sammattaM / / 1/21 / / " tasmAdubhayaM parasparasApekSaM mokSaprAptaye alam, na pratyekaM jJAnaM caraNaM ceti, nirdoSaH khalveSa pakSa iti vyavasthitam / [ pratyekaM nayeSu mithyAtve'pi samuditeSu samyaktvasya ratnAvalIdRSTAntena samarthanam ] na ca samudAyAbhAve nayA eva parasparavyAvRttasvarUpA iti na kvacit samyaktvam, nayapramANAtmakaikacaitanyapratipatteH ratnAvalIvat ityetadAha- [S.T.P.420] 'yadvA yat pratyekaM nayeSu na samyaktvam tat teSAM samudAye'pi na bhavati, yathA sikatAsu pratyekamabhavat tailaM tAsAM samudAye'pi na bhavati' ityatra hetoranaikAntikatApratipAdanArthamAha jaha'NeyalakkhaNa. ityAdi jaha'NeyalakkhaNaguNA veruliyAI maNI visaMjuttA / rayaNAvalivavaesaM na lahaMti mahagghamullA vi / / 22 / / taha NiyayavAyasuviNicchiyA vi aNNoNNapakkhaNiravekkhA / sammaiMsaNasadaM savve vi NayA Na pAveMti / / 23 / / 1-tamhA (saMmati.) | 2-sammattasabbhAvA (saMmati.) / 2010_02

Page #93
48 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-24-25 jaha puNa te ceva maNI jahA guNavisesabhAgapaDibaddhA / 'rayaNAvali'tti bhaNNai jahaMti pADikkasaNNAu / / 24 / / taha savve NayavAyA jahANurUvaviNiuttavattavvA / sammaiMsaNasadaM lahanti Na visesasaNNAo / / 25 / / yathA anekaprakArA viSavighAtahetutvAdIni lakSaNAni nIlatvAdayaSTA guNA yeSAM te vaiDUryAdayo maNayaH pRthagbhUtA ratnAvalIvyapadezaM na labhante mahArghamUlyA api / / 22 / / tathA pramANAvasthAyAm itarasavyapekSasvaviSayaparicchedakAle vA svaviSayaparicchedakatvena suniSTiAtA api anyonyapakSanirapekSAH 'pramANam' ityAkhyAM sarve'pi nayA na prApnuvanti nije ca itaranirapekSasAmAnyAdivAde suviniSTiAtA hetupradarzanakuzalA anyonyapakSanirapekSatvAt samyagdarzanazabdaM 'sunayAH' ityevaMrUpaM sarve'pi saGgrahAdayo nayA na prApnuvanti / / 23 / / yadA punasta eva maNayo yathA guNavizeSaparipATyA pratibaddhAH 'ratnAvali' iti AkhyAmAsAdayanti pratyekAbhidhAnAni ca tyajanti ratnAnuviddhatayA ratnAvalyAstadanuviddhatayA ca ratnAnAM pratIteH 'ratnAvalI' iti tatra vyapadezaH na punaH pratyekAbhidhAnam / / 24 / / tathA sarve nayavAdA yathAnurUpaviniyuktavaktavyA iti yathA iti vIpsArthe anu iti sAdRzye rUpam iti svabhAve tenAnurUpamityavyayIbhAvaH punaryathAzabdena sa eva "yathA'sAdRzye" (pANi0 a0 2 pA0 1 sU0 7 siddhAntakau0 aM0 661 pR0 163) ityanena / yad yadanurUpaM tatra viniyuktaM vaktavyam upacArAt tadvAcakaH zabdo yeSAM te tathA yathAnurUpadravyadhrauvyAdiSu pramANAtmakatvena vyavasthitAH samyagdarzanazabdaM 'pramANam' ityAkhyAM labhante na vizeSasaMjJAH pRthagbhUtAbhidhAnAni ekAnekAtmakatvena caitanyapratipatteranyathA cApratipatteriti / nanu nayapramANAtmakacaitanyasyAdhyakSasiddhatvena 'ratnAvali' iti dRSTAntopAdAnaM vyartham, na; adhyakSasiddhamapyanekAntamanabhyupagacchantaM prati vyavahArasAdhanAya dRSTAntopAdAnasya sAphalyAt / pravartitaSTA tenApi tatrAnaikAntavyavahAraH / / 25 / / [S.T.P. 421] 2010_02

Page #94
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-24-25 -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : vyavahAranayasvarUpavarNane, patra-29 atredaM manAgmImAMsAmahe-nanu viziSTaikAdhyavasAyasya samudAyArthatve dvitvaviziSTAvagrahAdijanitaghaTapaTobhayasamUhAlambanavatsakalanayArthasamUhAvambanamekaM pramANajJAnaM prApnoti, taJcAyuktam, kramikanayavAkyaiH samUhAlambanaikapramANajJAnajananAyogAt, sakalanayArthavAcakasya ca vAkyasyApyekasya saptabhaGgyA niSetsyamAnatvAt, na ca pareSAmavayavavAkyArthajJAnajanyanyAyavAkyArthajJAnavadasmAkamapi kramikanayavAkyArthajJAnajanyamahAvAkyArthajJAnarUpapramANAtmakaikAdhyavasAyopapattiriti vAcyam / nyAyavAkyasthale'pi pratItyasamutpAdenaikaikajanitakhaNDavAkyArthajJAnasamudAyasyaiva mahAvAkyArthajJAnatvenAsmAbhirabhyupagamAt, zabalAdhyavasAyAnyathAnupapattyA paramatasyAyuktatvAt, anyathAGgulidvayasaMyogasthAnIyobhayavAdArambhaprasaGgAcca / kiM ceyaM kalpanA ratnAvalIdRSTAntena nayapramANAtmakaikacaitanyopapAdakasammativacanaviruddhatvAdevAnupAdeyA / evaM hi tat [sammatau] - "jaha'NegalakkhaNaguNA, veruliyAI maNI visaMjuttA / rayaNAvalivavaesa, Na lahaMti mahagghamullAvi / / 1/22 / / " yathAnekaprakArA viSaghAtahetutvAdIni lakSaNAni nIlatvAdayaSTA guNA yeSAM te vaiDUryAdayo maNayaH pRthagbhUtA ratnAvalIvyapadezaM na labhante mahArthamUlyA api / "taha NiyayavAyasuviNicchiyA vi aNNuNNapakkhaNiravekkhA / sammaiMsaNasaI, savve vi NayA Na pAviti / / 1-23 / / " tathA pramANAvasthAyAmitarasavyapekSasvaviSayaparicchedakAle vA svaviSayaparicchedakatvena suviniSTiAtA apyanyonyanirapekSAH pramANamityAkhyAM sarve'pi nayA na prApnuvanti, nije vA (ca itara) nirapekSasAmAnyAdivAde suviniSTiAtA api hetupradarzanakuzalA api, anyonyapakSanirapekSatvAtsamyagdarzanazabdaM sunayA ityevaM rUpaM sarve'pi saGgrahAdayo nayA na prApnuvanti / / "jaha puNa te ceva maNI, jahAguNavisesabhAgapaDibaddhA / rayaNAvalitti bhaNNai, jaheMti pADekkasaNNAo / / 1/24 / / " 2010_02

Page #95
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa -1, gAthA - 26 yathA punasta eva maNayo yathAguNavizeSaparipATyA pratibaddhA ratnAvalIti bhaNyante, pratyekAbhidhAnAni ca tyajanti ratnAnuviddhatayA ratnAvalyAstadanuviddhatayA ca ratnAnAM pratIteH, ratnIyasannivezavizeSasya tadviziSTaratnAnAM vA ratnAvalIzabdavAcyatvAdviziSTAnAmaviziSTavAcakazabdAvAcyatvAdviziSTAviziSTayoH kathaJcidbhedasya prAtItikatvAt / 50 " taha savve NayavAyA, jahANurUvaviNauttavattavvA / sammadaMsaNasa, lahaMti Na visesasaNNAo / / 1/25 / / " tathA sarve navAdA yathAnurUpaviniyuktavaktavyAH, yatheti vIpsArthe, yad yadanurUpaM tatra tatra viniyuktaM vaktavyamupacArAttadvAcakaH zabdo yeSAM te tathA, samyagdarzanaM pramANamityAkhyAM labhante, na vizeSasaMjJAH pRthagbhUtAbhidhAnAni, ajahadvRttyaikopayogatvaviziSTasAkAGkSasakalanayavAkyajanitanayajJAnAnAM tAdRzanayajJAnIyA'jahadvRttyaikopayogasya vA pramANazabdavAcyatvAdviziSTanayAtmakasyApi pramANacaitanyasya zuddhanayazabdavAcyatvAt nanvagrahAdicatuSTayAtmakamatijJAnopayogavatsAkAGkSasakalanayavAkyajanitanayapramANAtmakacaitanyasyAdhyakSasiddhatvAttatra ratnAvalIdRSTAntopAdAnaM vyarthamiti cet, na, ekAnekAtmakopayoge svasaMvedanasiddhe'pi vAdivipratipattijasaMzayanirAsena niSTAyadADhayarthaM tadupAdanAt / [ dRSTAntopanyAsaprayojakAnAM tadguNAnAM parigaNanam ] dRSTAntaguNapratipAdanAyAhaloiyaparicchayasuho nicchayavayaNapaDivattimaggo ya / aha paNNavaNAvisautti teNa vIsatthamuvaNIo / / 26 / / vyutpattivikala-tadyuktaprANisamUhasukhagrAhyatvam majanakatvaM ca atha ityavadhAraNArthaH anantadharmAtmakavastuprarUpakavAkyaviSayatvaM dRSTAntasyaiva / etaiH kAraNaiH zaGkAvyavacchedena ayamupadarzita iti gAthAtAtparyArthaH / ekAnekAtmakabhAvaviSayavaco'vaga na cAvalyavasthAyAH prAg uttarakAlaM ca ratnAnAM pRthagupalambhAt iha ca sarvadA tathopalambhAbhAvAd viSamamudAharaNamiti vaktavyam, AvalyavasthAyA udAharaNatvenopanyAsAt / na ca dRSTAntadAntikayoH sarvathA sAmyam tatra tadbhAvAnupapatteH / / 26 / / [S. T.P. 422] 2010_02

Page #96
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-27 .. -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : - vyavahAranayasvarUpavarNane, patra-30 "loiyaparicchayasuho, NicchayavayaNapaDivattimaggo ya / aha paNNavaNAvisao tti, teNa vIsatthamuvaNIo / / 1/26 / / " [sammatau] laukikaparIkSakANAM vyutpattivikalatadyuktaprANinAM sukhaH sukhapratipattyupAyaH, niSTAyavacanasyaikAnekAtmakaniSTAyavAkyasya pratipattimArgaH prAmANyapradarzakaH, athetyavadhAraNe, prajJApanAviSayaH prakRtanidarzanavAkyaviSayo ratnAvalIdRSTAnta iti, tena kAraNena, vizvastaM niHzaGka yathA jJAyate tathA, jJApayitumiti zeSaH, upanIta upadarzitaH / na cAvalyavasthAtaH prAguttarakAle ca ratnAnAM niyatopalambhAtpramANAvasthAyApTA prAguttarakAlaM nayAnAM tadabhAvAdudAharaNavaiSamyamiti vAcyam / pramANasyaikAnekAtmakopapattimAtrArthamAvalyavasthodAharaNopAdAnAt, sarvathAsAmye dRSTAntadAAntikabhAvAnupapatteH / ratnAdikAraNeSvAvalyAdikAryaM sadeveti sAGkhyaH, teSAmevAnena rUpeNa vyavasthitatvAttadavyatiriktaM vikAramAtraM kAryaM pariNamata eveti sAGkhyavizeSaH / na khalu kAryaM kAraNe prAgutpattervidyate, na vA kAraNaM kAryarUpeNa pariNamate, kintu tatra pRthagbhUtameva kAryaM sAmagrIta utpadyate iti vaizeSikAdayaH / na kAryaM kAraNaM vAsti dravyamAtrameva tattvamityapare / / - [dRSTAntasya sAdhyasamatAM vadatAmekAntavAdinAM nirAsAya paJcAnAM tadabhiprAyANAM nirdezaH] (1) "ratnAdikAraNeSvAvalyAdikAryaM sadeva" [ ] iti sAGkhyaH / (2) "teSAmevAnena rUpeNa vyavasthitatvAt tadavyatiriktaM vikAramAtraM kAryaM ta eva" [ ] iti sAGkhyavizeSa eva / (3-4) "na kAryaM kAraNe vidyate iti tebhyastat pRthagbhUtam nahi kAraNameva kAryarUpeNa vyavatiSThate pariNamate vA" [ ] iti vaizeSikAdayaH / (5) "na ca kAryam kAraNaM vAsti dravyamAtrameva tattvam" [ ] ityaparaH / evaMbhUtAbhiprAyavanta ekAntavAdino dRSTAntasya sAdhyasamatAM manyante tAn pratyAha iharA samUhasiddho pariNAmakao vva jo jahiM attho / te taM ca Na taM taM ceva va tti niyameNa micchattaM / / 27 / / 1-va (ane. vya.) / 2-ceva tti (ane. vya.) / ___ 2010_02

Page #97
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 1, gAthA - 27 itarathA uktaprakArAdanyathA samUhe ratnAnAM siddho niSpannaH pariNAmakRto vA maNyAdiSvAvalyAdiH kSIrAdiSu dadhyAdirvA yo yatra arthaH te maNyAdaya AvalyAdi kAryaM kSIraM vA dadhyAdikam tatra tatsadbhAvAt tasya tatpariNAmarUpatvAt / 'samUhasiddha : ' ' pariNAmakRtA vA ' iti dvayorupAdAnaM laukikavyavahArApekSayA / paramArthatastu paramANusamUhapariNAmAtmakatvAt sarva eva samUhakRtaH pariNAmakRto veti na bhedaH / [S.T.P. 423] 52 kSaNikavad ekAntAkSaNikeSvapyarthakriyAlakSaNaM sattvaM pUrvopadarzitanyAyena vyAvRttam sattAsambandhalakSaNasya ca sattvasyAtivyAptittvA'sambhavAdidoSaduSTatvAt asattvamityekAntA'kSaNikA apyasanto bhAvA ityutpAda - vyaya - dhrauvyalakSaNameva bhAvAnAM sattvamabhyupagantavyamiti naikAntataH kAraNeSu kAryamasaditi na tat iti pakSo mithyAtvamiti sthitam / brahmAdvaitavAdasyApi prAgeva pratiSedhaH kRta iti tadeva vA iti ayamapi pakSo mithyAtvam / tataH kAraNe pariNAmini vA kAryam pariNAmo vA sadeva tAveva tAvasadeva vA tat tatreti na kAraNameva kAryam pariNAmI vA pariNAmaH / na kAryam nApi kAraNam api tu dravyamAtraM tattvamiti tadeva veti niyamena ekAntAbhyupagame sarva evaite mithyAvAdA uktanyAyena niyamena mithyAtvam ityabhidhAnAt kathaJcidabhyupagame samyagvAdA aivete ityuktaM bhavati yata utpAda-vyaya- dhrauvyAtmakatve vastunaH sthite tad vastu tattadapekSayA kAryam akAryaM ca, kAraNam akAraNaM ca, kAraNe kAryaM sacca asaca kAraNaM kAryakAle vinAzavat avinAzavaJca tathaiva pratIteranyathA cA'pratIteH / / 27 / / [S. T.P. 429] -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM :vyavahAranayasvarUpavarNane, patra 30 iti nAnAvidhAbhiprAyavadekAntavAdimate dRSTAntasya sAdhyasamatetyata Aha [sammatau ] " iharA samUhasiddho, pariNAmakaovva jo jahiM attho / taM taM taM - tti niyameNa micchataM / / 1/27 / / " Na -- itarathoktaprakArAnabhyupagame, samUhasiddho ratnAvalyAdiH pariNAmakRto vA kSIrAdiSu dadhyAdiryaH, 1- ca (saMmati.) / 2- ceva va tti ( saMmati ) / 2010_02

Page #98
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-28 yatrArthaH sarvasyaiva paramANusamUhapariNAmobhayakRtatve'pi vikalpAbhidhAnaM laukikavyavahArApekSayA, te ratnAdayaH, tadevAvalyAdikameva, taddadhyAdikaM na tadeva na kSIrAdikameveti, niyamena mithyAtvam, satkAryavAde kAraNavyApAravaiphalyaprasaGgAt, asatkAryavAde ca kSIrAdikameva dadhyAditvena pariNatamiti vyavahAravilopaprasaGgAt, sadasatkAryAbhyupagame ca tiryakpracayenaivordhvatApracayenApi sAmUhikavyavahArakSamakAryasambhavAdAtmadravyAnusyUtanayapramANAtmakacaitanyamapratyUhamiti bhAvaH / [ sve sve'ze satyAnAmapi nayAnAM parAMzavicAlane mithyAtvAt samayajJaH sApekSAvadhAraNaM karotIti varNanam ] ata ekAntarUpasya vastuno'bhAvAt sarve'pi nayAH svaviSayaparicchedasamarthA api itaranayaviSayavyavacchedena svaviSaye vartamAnA mithyAtvaM pratipadyanta ityupasaMharannAha NiyayavayaNijjasaJcA sabbanayA paraviyAlaNe mohA / / te uNa Na diTThasamao vibhayai sacce va alie vA / / 28 / / nijakavacanIye svAMze paricchedye satyAH samyagjJAnarUpAH sarva eva nayAH saMgrahAdayaH paravicAlane paraviSayotkhanane mohAH muhyantIti mohA mithyApratyayAH paraviSayasyApi satyatvenonmUlayitumazakyatvAt tadabhAve svaviSayasyApyavyavasthiteH tataSTA paraviSayasyAbhAve svaviSayasyApyasattvAt tatpratyayasya mithyAtvameva tadvyatiriktagrAhakapramANasya cAbhAvAt tasmAt tAneva nayAn punaH zabdasyAvadhAraNArthatvAt na iti pratiSedho vibhajanakriyAyAH dRSTaH samayaH siddhAntavAcyamanekAntAtmakaM vastutattvaM yena puMsA sa tathA sa na vibhajate satyetaratayAsvetaraviSayamavadhArayamANo'pi tathA tAn na vibhajate api tvitaranayaviSayasavyapekSameva svanayAbhipretaM viSayaM satyamevAvadhArayatIti yAvat / 'grAhyasatyAsatyAbhyAM grAhakasatyAsatye' ityevamabhidhAnam taca dRSTA'nekAntatattvasya vibhajanam 'syAdastyeva dravyArthataH' ityevaMrUpam / / 28 / / [S.T.P.429] 1-adiTThasamao (guru. vini., dvAda. naya.) | _ 2010_02

Page #99
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-28 -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : vyavahAranayasvarUpavarNane, patra 30 etadevAha [sammatau] - NiyayavayaNijasA, savvaNayA paraviyAlaNe mohA / te puNa Na diTThasamao, vibhayai sace va alie vA / / 1/28 / / nijakavacanIye svAMze paricchedye, satyAH samyagjJAnarUpAH, sarva eva nayAH saGgrahAdayaH, paravicAlane paraviSayotkhanane, muhyantIti mohA mithyApratyayAH, paraviSayasyApi satyatvenonmUlayitumazakyatvAt, tadabhAve svaviSayasyApyavyavasthiteH, tasmAttAneva nayAn, punaH zabdasyAvadhAraNArthatvAd, dRSTasamayo nirNItAnekAntatattvaH, satyAnvA'lIkAnvA na vibhajate, api tu pramANAvasthAyAM sApekSatayA syAdastyeva dravyArthata ityAdirItyA nayaviSayaM vibhajetetyarthaH / tasmAnnayapramANAtmakamekarUpamevAtmasvarUpaM vyavasthitam / --: zAstravArtAsamuccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAm stabaka-7 gAthA 10 tadidamuktam [sammatau] - "NiyayavayaNijjasaJcA savvaNayA paraviAlaNe mohA / te uNa Na diTThasamao vibhayai saJce va alie vA / / " 1/28 / / asyArthaH-nijakavacanIye svaviSaye paricchedye satyAH samyagjJAnarUpAH sarva eva nayAH saGgrahAdayaH, tadvati tadavagAhitvAt / paravicAlane paraviSayotkhanane mohA muhyantIti mohA asamarthAH, paraviSayasyApi satyatvenonmUlayitumazakyatvAt, tadabhAve svaviSayasyApyavyavasthiteH, mitho nAntarIyakatvAt / ataH paraviSayasyAbhAve svaviSayasyApyasattvAt tatpratyayasya mithyAtvamevetyavadhArayana dRSTasamayo jJAtAnekAntaH punastAn nayAn na vibhajate satyAnalIkAn vA, kintvitaranayaviSayasavyapekSatayA 'astyeva dravyArthataH' ityevaM bhajanayA svanayAbhipretamarthaM satyamevAvadhArayati, yad tatra yadapekSayAsti tasya tatra tadapekSayA grAhakatvenaiva nayaprAmANyAt / 2010_02

Page #100
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-28 . -: gurutattvavinizcaye : ullAsa-1 yadapyuktaM "zuddhaSTA niSTAyanayaH" iti sa evAzrayaNIya iti tatrAha suddhataM puNa doNha vi, NiyavattavvANugANamavisiTuM / saTTANe baliANaM, jaM bhaNiyaM saMmaIi imaM / / 44 / / suddhataM puNatti / zuddhatvaM punaH dvayorapi niSTAyavyavahArayoH nijavaktavyAnugayoH svAbhimatatattvAnusAriNoH svasthAne svaviSaye balikayoH itarApratikSepyayoraviziSTam, "savve vi hoMti suddhA, Natthi asuddho Nao u saTThANe / " iti vyavahArabhASyavacanenetarApekSayA'zuddhasyApi svApekSayA zuddhatvAt, dIrghatvahasvatvayoriva zuddhatvAzuddhatvayoravyavasthitatvAt, yad bhaNitaM sammatAvetanmahAmatinA / / 44 / / NiyayavayaNijjasaJcA, savvaNayA paraviAlaNe mohA / te puNa adiTThasamao, vibhayai saJce va alie vA / / 45 / / .. _ 'Niyaya'ti / nijakavacanIye satyA arthapratipAdakatvAt sarve nayA naigamAdayaH parasya nayasya vicAraNe pareNa nayena vicAlane- svArthasya parityAjane vA 'moghA' viphalA asatyA iti yAvat, anyArthApratipAdakatvAdanyanayapratibandhena svArthApratipAdakatvAdvA / tAn nayAn punaH adRSTasamayaH' ajJAtasiddhAntaparamArthaH vibhajate ekAntena niSTiAnoti satyAn alIkAn vA syAt / satyatvA satyatvapratipAdane tu dRSTasamayataiveti bhAvaH / / 45 / / / ___-: nayopadeza: :svArthaniSTAyakatvarUpaM nayaprAmANyasaMzayena viSayasaMzayAt niSTAyasyAniSTAyapariNatyA na kathaJcidityatrApi nayAnAmanekAnta eveti zikSayati svArthe satyA parainA asatyA nikhilA nayAH / viduSAM tatra naikAnta iti dRSTaM hi sammatau / / 10 / / nayAmRta0-svArtha iti / svArthe svaviSaye, satyAH niSTAAyakAH, paraiH nayaiH nUnA aprAmANyAH zaGkAviSayIkRtAH, asatyAH aniSTAAyakAH, nikhilA nayAH naigamAdayaH, viduSAM siddhAntavyutpannAnAm, 1-Na diTThasamao (saMmati.) / 2010_02

Page #101
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-28 tatra nayaprAmANyA'prAmANyayoH, naikAntaH, vaktuM yukta iti zeSaH, iti dRSTaM parIkSitam, hi sammatau, abhiyuktavacanasaMvAdapradarzanametat, tadvacanaM ca "NiyayavayaNijasaJcA, savvaNayA paraviAlaNe mohA / te puNa Na diTThasamayo vibhayai saJce ya alIe vA / / 1/28 / / " tti / -: dvAdazAranayacakre : Araka-1 sa eva vyavahAranayAzrayAllaukiko brUte - ko hi vAdAnAmiti ekAntavAdAnAm antaM kartuM zakruyAt- ucchedaM zakruyAt kartumiti / kiM kAraNam ? na hi sAGkhyAbhihitAH sat kAraNe kAryam, asadakaraNAdupAdAnagrahaNAt sarvasambhavAbhAvAt / zaktasya zakyakaraNAt kAraNabhAvAJca sat kAryam / / [sAGkhyakA0 9] ityevamAdayo hetavaH, na vA vaizeSikoktAH kriyAguNavyapadezAbhAvAdasat [vai0 sU0 9 / 1 / 1] ityAdayaH, 'kSaNikA ghaTAdayaH pratyayAyattajanmatvAt' ityAdayo vA bauddhoktAH paraspareNocchettuM zakyante, abhiyuktabuddhyutkarSaparamparAyA adRSTaniSThatvAt / etasminnarthe jJApakamAha-Aha ceti, nAhameva svamanISikayA bravImi, kiM tarhi ? anye'pyevaM bruvate / NiyayavayaNijasaJcA savvaNayA paraviyAlaNe mohA / te puNa adiTThasamayo vibhajai saJce va alie vA / / [sammatau 1 / 28] svaviSayasatyatvAdevAvicAlyA iti taJcAlane moghAH / teSAmanekAntasthitisvattvAnavabodhAta 'satyameva, asatyameva vA' ityadRSTasamayastAn vibhajate ityAcAryasiddhasenaH / -: nyAyakhaNDakhAghe (mahAvIrastave) : _ vibhAga-3, gAthA-40 nanvevamanyavyAvRttyapratyAyakatvAniHsvarUpatvaM nayasya prAptam, tatrAha-nayasya hi nijaM svarUpaM tATasthyamaudAsInyameva, kasmAt svArtheSu vicitreSu svaviSayeSu, ayogavirahasyAyogavyavacchedasya, pratipattimAtrAt, tadidamabhipretyoktaM bhagavatA sammatikRtA, 1-Na diTThasamao (sNmti.)| 2010_02 .

Page #102
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-29-30 57 "NiyayavayaNijjasaJcA savvaNayA paraviAlaNe mohatti" evaM ca naiyAyikAdinayAH svArthAyogavyavacchedapratipAdanamAtreNa tUSNIntiSThantu, na tu nayAntarakhaNDanAyApi pragalbhantAm, tattarkavicAraprahAropanipAte kenAntarA hastAdAnAdityuktaM bhavati / / 40 / / [ sarvasyApi vastuno'bhedarUpeNa dravyArthikaparicchedyasyaiva bhedarUpeNa punaH paryAyArthikaparicchedyatvAbhidhAnam ] ato naya-pramANAtmakaikarUpatAvyavasthitamAtmasvarUpam anugatavyAvRttAtmakam utsargApavAdarUpagrAhyagrAhakAtmakatvAd vyavatiSThata ityarthapradarzanAyAha dabaTThiyavattavvaM savvaM sabveNa NiJcamaviyappaM / Araddho ya vibhAgo pajjavavattavvamaggo ya / / 29 / / yat kiJcid dravyArthikasya saMgrahAdeH sadAdirUpeNa vyavasthitaM vastu vaktavyaM paricchedyaM tat sarvaM sarveNa prakAreNa nityaM sarvakAlam avikalpaM nirbhedam, sarvasya sadasadvizeSAtmakatvAt tacca bhedena sampRktamiti darzayitumAha-ArabdhaSTA vibhAgaH sa evAvibhAgaH sattArUpo yo dravyAdinA''kAreNa, prastutaSTA bhedaH cazabdasya prakrAntA'vibhAgAnukarSaNArthatvAt paryAyavaktavyamArgapTA paryAyAstikasya yad vaktavyaM vizeSaH tasya mArgaH panthA jAtaH-paryAyArthikaparicchedyasvabhAvo vizeSaH sampanna iti yAvat / / 29 / / [S.T.P.429] [zabdArthagatatvena paryAyasya dvaividhyaM pradarzya tasya dvividhasyApi punarbhedAbhedarUpeNa vivecanam] evaM bhedAbhedarUpaM vastUpadarzya bhedasya paryAyArthikaviSayasya dvaividhyamAha so uNa samAsao ciya vaMjaNaNiao ya atthaNiao ya / atthagao ya abhiNNo bhaiyavvo vaMjaNaviyappo / / 30 / / sa punarvibhAgaH samAsataH saMkSepato vyaJjananiyataH zabdanayanibandhanaH arthaniyataSTA arthanayanibandhanaSTA / tatra arthagatastu vibhAgaH abhinnaH saGgraha-vyavahAra-RjusUtrArthapradhAnanayaviSayo'rthaparyAyo'bhinnaH asadadravyAtItAnAgatavyavacchinnAbhinnArthaparyAyarUpatvAt tadviSayA nayA api 'arthagato vibhAgo'bhinnaH' ityucyate / bhAjyo vyaJjanavikalpa iti / vikalpitaH 2010_02

Page #103
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 1, gAthA - 31 zabdaparyAyo bhinnaH abhinnaSTAnekAbhidhAna ekaH ekAbhidhAnaSTaukaH iti kRtvA, samAnaliGgasaGkhyAkAlAdiranekazabdo 'ghaTaH''kuTaH''kumbhaH' ityAdika ekArtha iti zabdanayaH / samabhirUDhastu bhinnAbhidheyau ghaTa- kuTazabdau bhinnapravRttinimittatvAt, rUpa- rasAdizabdavat ityekArtha ekazabda iti manyate / evaMbhUtastu ceSTAsamaya eva ghaTo 'ghaTa' zabdavAcyaH anyathA'tiprasaGgAt / tadevam abhinno'rtho vAcyo'syetyabhinnArtho ghaTazabda iti manyate / / 30 / / [S.T.P. 430] [ ekasyaiva vastunastraikAlikAnantazabdArthaparyAyazAlitayA'nantapramANatvena sarvAtmakatvAkhyAnam ] yat tadanyato vibhaktena svarUpeNaikamanekaM ca vastUktam tad anantapramANamityAkhyAtumAhaegadaviyammi je atthapajjayA vayaNapajjayA va tIyANAgayabhUyA tAvaiyaM taM havai davvaM / / 31 / / 58 ekasmin jIvAdidravye arthaparyAyA arthagrAhakAH saMgraha-vyavahAra-RjusUtrAkhyAH tadgrAhyA vA arthabhedAH vacanaparyAyAH zabdanayAH zabda-samabhirUDha - evaMbhUtAH tatparicchedyA vastvaMzA vA te ca atItAnAgatavarttamAnarUpatayA sarvadA vivarttante vivRttAH vivarttiSyanta iti teSAmAnantyAd vastvapi tAvat pramANaM bhavati / tathAhi - anantakAlena sarveNa vastunA sarvAvasthAnAM parasparAnugamenA''sAditatvAt avasthAtuSTAvasthAnAM kathaJcidananyatvAt ghaTAdivastu paTapuruSAdirUpeNApi kathaJcid vivRttamiti sarvaM sarvAtmakaM kathaJciditi sthitam / dazyate caikaM pudgaladravyaM atItA-'nAgata-varttamAnadravya-guNa-karma-sAmAnya- vizeSapariNAmAtmakaM yugapat krameNApi tat tathAbhUtameva / ekAntA'sata utpAdAyogAt sataSTA niranvayavinAzAsambhavAditi pratipAditatvAt / / 31 / / [S.T.P.430] -: AcArAGgasUtre : uddeza- 4 pU. A. zIlAGkAcAryajIkRtaTIkAyAm adhyayana-3, je egaM jAi se savvaM jANai, je savvaM jANai se egaM jANai (sU0 122 ) 1- ekadaviyassa (AcA. TIkA) 1 2010_02

Page #104
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-31 yaH kaSTiAdavizeSitaH ekaM paramANvAdi dravyaM paSTAAtpuraskRtaparyAyaM vA jAnAti parichinnatti sa sarvaM svaparaparyAyaM jAnAti, atItAnAgataparyAyidravyaparijJAnasya samastavastuparicchedAvinAbhAvitvAda, idameva hetuhetumadbhAvena lagayitumAha-je savvamityAdi, yaH sarvaM saMsArodaravivaravarti vastu jAnAti sa ekaM ghaTAdi vastu jAnAti, tasyaivAtItAnAgataparyAyabhedaistattatsvabhAvApattyA'nAdyanantakAlatayA samastavastusvabhAvagamanAditi, taduktam [sammatau] - "egadaviyassa je atthapajavA vayaNapajavA vAvi / tIyANAgayabhUyA tAvaiyaM taM havai davvaM / / 1/31 / / " -: dvAdazAranayacakre : Araka-1 tadyathA-ekaparamANuvarNa-gandha-rasa-sparzapariNAmaiH saprabhedaiH svAbhAvikaiH puraskRtaiH papTAtkRtaipTA vyaNukAdibhiH sAMyogikairmahAskandhaparyantairvaisrasikaiH prAyogikaipTA kArmaNazarIrA-dibhirabhisambadhyate / yathoktam [sammatau] - ekkadaviyammi je atthapajjayA vayaNapajjayA vA vi| tItANAgatabhUtA tAvaiaM taM havai davvaM / / [1/31] -: nayopadeze : gAthA-3 ekavastugrahe tadgatasva-paraparyAyakukSipravezena sarveSAmeva grahAt, anuvRtti-vyAvRttisaMbandhaparyAlocane tAvat pramANasyaiva vastuno'nubhavAt / tadAha mahAvAdI sammatau - egadaviammi je atthapajavA vayaNapajavA vA vi / tIyA'NAgayabhUA, tAvaiyaM taM havai davvaM" / / 1/31 / / iti / 1-ekadaviyammi (saMmati.) / 2010_02

Page #105
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa -1, gAthA - 32-33 [vyaJjanArthaparyAyabhAvanayA puruSasya bhedAbhedAtmakatvasamarthanena vastumAtrasyA'nekAntarUpatvasUcanam ] 60 evaM tAvad bAhyAbhyantarabhedena dvividhasyApi vastuno'nekAntAtmakatvaM pratipAdya tatpratipAdanavAkyanayAnAmapi tathAvidhameva svarUpam, nAnyAdRgbhUtamastIti pratipAdayannAhapurisamma purisasaddo jammAI maraNakAlapajjanto / tassa u bAlAIyA pajjavajoyA bahuviyappA / / 32 / / athavA artha-vyaJjanaparyAyaiH zakti-vyaktirUpairanantairanugato'rthaH savikalpo nirvikalpaSTA pratyakSato'vagataH, idAnIM puruSadRSTAntadvAreNa vyaJjanaparyAyaM tadavikalpakatvanibandhanam arthaparyAyaM ca tatsavikalpatvanimittamAha-purisammi ityAdinA sUtreNa atItAnAgatavarttamAnAnantArtha-vyaJjanaparyAyAtmake puruSavastuni 'puruSa' iti zabdo yasyAsau puruSazabdaH tadvAcyo'rtho janmAdirmaraNaparyanto'bhinna ityarthaH ' puruSaH' ityabhinnAbhidhAnapratyayavyavahArapravRtteH tasyaiva bAlAdayaH paryAyayogAH pariNatisambandhA bahuvikalpA anekabhedAH pratikSaNasUkSmapariNAmAntarbhUtA bhavanti tatraiva tathAvyatirekajJAnotpatteH evaM ca 'syAdekaH' ityavikalpaH 'syAdanekaH' iti savikalpaH siddhaH, anyathA'bhyupagame tadabhAva evaiti vipakSe 'atthi 'tti NivviyappaM' ityanantaragAthayA bAdhAM darzayiSyati / dvitIyapAtanikA''yAtagAthArthastu-puruSavastuni puruSadhvanirvyaJjanaparyAyaH zeSo bAlAdidharmakalApo'rthaparyAya iti gAthAsamudAyArthaH / [S.T.P.431] [ puruSasya bhedAbhedaikAntAbhyupagame abhAvarUpatApattyA dUSaNam ] yathA puruSastathA sarvaM vastvekam anekaM vA sarvasya tathaivopalabdheH anyathAbhyupagame ekAntarUpamapi tanna bhavediti darzayannAha asthi ti NivviyappaM purisaM jo bhaNai purisakAlammi / so bAlAi viyappaM na lahai tullaM va pAvejjA ||33|| 2010_02

Page #106
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-34 61 iti / asti iti evaM nirvikalpaM niSkrAntAzeSabhedasvarUpaM puruSam ekarUpaM puruSadravyaM yo bravIti puruSakAle puruSotpattikSaNa eva asau bAlAdibhedaM na labhate bAlAdibhedarUpatayA nAsau svayameva vyavasthitiM prApnuyAt / nApi tadrUpatayA aparamasau pazyet / evaM cAbhedarUpameva tat puruSavastu prasajyeta / tulyaM vA prApnuyAt tadapyabhedarUpaM bAlAditulyatAmeva abhAvarUpatayA prApnuyAt bhedA'pratItAvabhedasyApyapratIterabhAva iti bhAvaH / yadvA asti iti evaM nirvikalpam niSTiAto vikalpo bhedo yasmin puruSadravye tad nirvikalpaM bhedarUpaM puruSaM tatsvarUpalAbhakAle bhaNati asau bAlAdivikalpaM na labheta tulyam iti dravyatulyatAmevAsau prApnuyAt / atrApi pUrvavat tadagrahe tadagrahAd bhedarUpatAyA apyabhAva iti bhAvaH / na caivamevAstviti vaktavyam, sarvavyavahArocchedaprasakteriti bhedAbhedarUpameva vastva stu / / 33 | | [S.T.P. 440] [ puruSe zabdArtha-paryAyAbhyAM bhedAbhedarUpatvasya vyavasthApanam ] asyaivopasaMhArArthamAha vaMjaNapajjAyassa u puriso 'puriso' tti NiJcamaviyappo / bAlAiviyappaM puNa pAsai se atthapajjAo / / 34 / / zabdaparyAyeNA'vikalpaH puruSaH bAlAdinA tvarthaparyAyeNa savikalpaH siddha iti gAthAtAtparyArthaH / "vyaJjayati vyanakti vA'rthAniti vyaJjanam zabdaH na punaH zabdanayastasya RjusUtrArthanayaviSayatvAd" iti kecit-tasya paryAyaH A janmano maraNAntaM yAvadabhinnasvarUpapuruSadravyapratipAdakatvam, tadvazena tatpratipAdyaM vastusvarUpamatra grAhyam upacArAdevaM ca dvitayamapyetat puruSaH 'puruSaH' iti abhedarUpatayA na bhidyate-vyaJjanaparyAyamatena puruSavastu sadA avikalpam bhedaM na pratipadyata iti yAvat / bAlAdivikalpaM bAlAdibhedaM punastasyaiva pazyati arthaparyAyaH RjusUtrAdyarthanayaH / atrApi viSayiNA viSayaH RjusUtrAdyarthanayaviSayaH abhinne _ 2010_02

Page #107
dara saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-34-35 puruSarUpe bhedasvarUpo nirdiSTaH upacArAt / evaM cAbhinnaM puruSavastu bhedaM pratipadyata iti yAvat / / 34 / / [S.T.P.441] -: nayopadeze : gAthA-5 ata eva savicAraNayA sAmAnyadRSTyA ca sarvaM nirvikalpakaM vizeSadRSTyA ca sarvaM savikalpakamityanekAntaH puruSadRSTAntena saMmatau pratipAditaH / tathAhi "vaMjaNapajjAyassa u puriso 'puriso'tti nizcamaviappo / bAlAivigappaM puNa pAsai se atthapajjAo / / 1/34 / / vyaJjayati vyanakti cArthAniti vyaJjanaM zabdaH, na punaH zabdanayaH, tasya sUtrasamAnaparyAyaviSayatvAt, tasya paryAyaH vAcyatA tadgrAhakanayena puruSaH, puruSa iti puruSatvaprakArakajJAnaviSaya iti, nityam A janmano maraNAntaM yAvad, avikalpaH puruSatvAtiriktAprakArakajJAnaviSayaH, idamupalakSaNaM dravyatvavastutvAdinA'pyavikalpatvasya, zuddhadravyopayoge tu padadvayasya nirdharmakatvalakSaNayA zuddhadharmiviSayakabhAnaviSayatvamevAvikalpatvaM draSTavyam, se tasya puruSasya, arthaparyAyaH RjusUtrAdyarthagrAhakanayaH, punarbAlAdivikalpaM bAlAdibhedaM pazyati / / 34 / / [ vastuno'nekAntAtmakatve'pyekAntarUpatvaM vadato'pramANatvakhyApanam ] evaM nirvikalpa-savikalpasvarUpe pratipAdye puruSAdivastuni tadviparyayeNa tad vastu pratipAdayan vastusvarUpAnavabodha svAtmani khyApayatIti darzanArthamAha saviyappa-NibbiyappaM iya purisaM jo bhaNejja aviyapaM / saviyappameva vA NicchaeNa Na sa nicchio samae / / 35 / / savikalpanirvikalpaM syAtkArapadalAJchitaM puruSadravyaM yaH pratipAdakaH tad vastu brUyAt avikalpameva savikalpameva vA niSTAyena ityavadhAraNena sa yathAvasthitavastupratipAdane prastute anyathAbhUtaM vastutattvaM pratipAdayan na niSTiAta iti niSTAyo niSTiAtam tad asyAstIti niSTiAtaH'arzaAditvAt ac samaye paramArthena vastustattvasya paricchetteti yAvat / tathAhi ___ 2010_02

Page #108
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-35 pramANaparicchinnaM tathaivAvisaMvAdi vastu pratipAdayan vastunaH pratipAdaka ityucyate / na ca tathAbhUtaM vastu kenacit kadAcit pratipannam prApyate vA yena tathAbhUtaM tadvacastatra pramANaM bhavet tathAbhUtavacanAbhidhAtA vA tajjJAnaM vA pramANatayA loke vyapadezamAsAdayet / / 35 / / [S.T.P.441] -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : saGgrahanayasvarUpavarNane, patra 26 so'yaM devadatta iti vAkye lakSaNAbhyupagame bIjAbhAvAta, tattedantAviziSTayorbhedAbhedasya sArvajanInatvena virodhAbhAvAt, na hi pratyakSasiddhe'rthe virodho nAma, anyathA citrarUpacitrajJAnAdAvapi nAnArUpasamAvezabAdhenAkhaNDAMzalakSaNAsvIkArApatteH / pratItibalAttatrapyakhaNDAMze lakSaNA svIkriyata eveti cet, tarhi dravyanayadRSTyA'khaNDapratibhAsavatparyAyanayadRSTyA sakhaNDapratibhAso'pi sArvajanIno na hyavayavavyatirikto'vayavI kapTiAdanubhUyate ityakhaNDavAcakapadasya sakhaNDAMza eva kiM na lakSaNA svIkriyate ?, na hyekA pratItiH svagRhakuTumbinI anyA ca paragRhakuTumbinIti tvadicchAmAtraM prAmANikairanurotsyate, ubhayapratItyanurodhe cobhayAtmakameva vastu jinezvaraziSyIbhUya vibhAvyatAm / tadidamabhipretyoktaM bhagavatA sammatikRtA "saviyappa-NibbiyappaM, iya purisaM jo bhaNeja aviyappaM / saviyappameva vA NicchaeNa Na sa Nicchio samae / / 1/35 / / " sakhaNDAkArapratItiviSayatvaM savikalpatvama, akhaNDAkArapratItiviSayatvaM ca nirvikalpatvam, tataH pramANamArgeNa sakhaNDAkhaNDobhayarUpatvameva vastuno vyavasthitam, itthaM cAkhaNDaikarUpaM brahma pratipAdayan vedo niSTAyanayamevAlambata iti vicAraNIyam / - nayopadeze : gAthA-5 saviappa-NivviappaM iya purisaM jo bhaNeja aviappaM / saviappameva vA NicchaeNa Na sa Nicchio samaye ||smmtau-1/35 / / savikalpaM nirvikalpaM syAtkArAGkitaM tadubhayapadaghaTitamahAvAkyabodharUpapuruSadravyasya yo bhaNed avikalpameva savikalpameva vA, niSTAyena ekAntena samaye paramArthe, na niSTiAtaH niSTAyo niSTiAtaM 2010_02

Page #109
64 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-35 tadasyAstIti niSTiAtaH, arzaAditvAdacpratyayaH, na tadarthe ityarthaH, durnayAbhinivezAd nayatvAd vA saMpUrNAnekAntavastusvarUpAparicchedAditi rahasyam / / 35 / / -: jJAnabinduH :savikalpAvikalpayoranekAntasya samarthanam"tattvamasi" (chAndo. 6/8/7) ityAdAvapi AtmanastattadanyadravyaparyAyoparAgAsambhavavicArazatapravRttAveva zuddhadravyaviSayaM nirvikalpakamiti zuddhadRSTau ghaTajJAnAd brahmajJAnasya ko bhedaH / ekatra sadadvaitamaparatra jJAnAdvaitaM viSaya ityetAvati bhede tvauttarakAlikaM savikalpakameva sAkSIti savikalpakA'vikalpakatvayorapyanekAnta eva zreyAn / taduktam [sammatau] - "saviappa-NivviappaM iya purisaM jo bhaNeja aviappaM / saviappameva vA NicchaeNa Na sa Nicchio samae / / " 1/35 / / iti / na ca nirvikalpako dravyopayogo'vagraha eveti tatra vicArasahakRtamanojanyatvAnupapattiH, vicArasya IhAtmakatvena IhAjanyasya vyuparatAkAGkSasya tasya naipTAyikApAyarUpasyaiva abhyupagamAt, apAye nAmajAtyAdiyojanAniyamastu zuddhadravyAdezarUpazrutanizritAtirikta eveti vibhAvanIyaM svasamayaniSNAtaiH / -: aSTasahastrItAtparyavivaraNe : pariccheda-1 kANDa-3 yadi ca zuddhabrahmaNi nirvikalpakaviSayatvameva tattvamasItyAdivAkyAdapi jahadajahallakSaNayAkhaNDabrahmaNyeva padavRttigraheNa nirvikalpakazAbdabodhopapattiriti vibhAvyate tadA dravyArthAdezAt sarvatra vizeSavinirmokeNa nirvikalpakapadazaktigrahasambhavAt sarvasyaiva nirvikalpakaikavedyattvamastviti nirvikalpasavikalpakatayApi padArthAnAmanekAnta eva zreyAn / taduktaM puruSadravyamAzritya sammatI - saviyappa-NivviappaM, iyaM purisaM jo bhaNejja aviappaM / saviappameva vA NicchaeNa Na sa Nicchio samae / / 1 / / tti (1/35) ___ tathA ca sarvapramANAnAM nirvikalpakAdezAdvidhAtRtvaM savikalpakAdezAcca niSeddhatvamiti tulyau vidhiniSedhAviti mantavyam, adhikametattattvaM nayAmRtataraGgiNyAM pratipAditamasmAbhiriti tata evAdhimantavyam / 2010_02

Page #110
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-36 ___ [ saptabhaGgIsvarUpavicAraNA ] parasparAkrAntabhedAbhedAtmakasya vastunaH kathaJcit sadasattvamabhidhAya tathA tadabhidhAyakasya vacasaH puruSasyApi tadabhidhAnadvAreNa samyagmithyAvAditvaM pratipAdya adhunA bhAvAbhAvaviSayaM tatraivaikAntAnekAntAtmakamaMzaM pratipAdayato vivakSayA sunaya-durnaya-pramANarUpatAM tatpratipAdakaM vaco yathA anubhavati tathA prapaJcataH pratipAdayitumAha yadvA yathaiva tad vastu vyavasthitaM tathaiva vacanAt pratipAdayato vaktunipuNatvaM bhavati anyathA sAGkhya-bauddha-kaNabhujAmiva abhinna-bhinna-parasparanirapekSobhayavastusvarUpAbhidhAyinAm arhanmatAnusAriNAmapi 'syAdasti' ityAdisaptavikalparUpatAmanApannavacanaM vaktRNAM syAtkArapadA'lAJchitavastudharma pratipAdayatAmanipuNatA bhavediti prapaJcataH saptavikalpotthAnanimittamupadarzayituM gAthAsamUhamAha atyaMtarabhUehi ya Niyaehi ya dohi samayamAIhiM / vayaNavisesAIyaM dabbamavattavvayaM paDai / / 36 / / asyAstAtparyArthaH-arthAntarabhUtaH paTAdiH nijo ghaTaH tAbhyAM nijArthAntarabhUtAbhyAM sadasattvaM ghaTavastunaH prathama-dvitIyabhaGganimittaM pradhAna-guNabhAvena bhavatIti prathama-dvitIyau bhaGgo 1-2 / yadA tu dvAbhyAmapi yugapat tad vastu abhidhAtumabhISTaM bhavati tadA avaktavyabhaGgakanimittam, tathAbhUtasya vastuno'bhAvAt pratipAdakavacanAtItatvAt tRtIyabhaGgasadbhAvaH vacanasya vA tathAbhUtasyAbhAvAd avaktavyaM vastu 3 / / 36 / / [S.T.P.442] -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : saptabhaGgasvarUpavarNane patra-69 tadidamabhipretyoktaM sammatau "atyaMtarabhUehi ya, Niyaehi ya dohi samayamAIhiM / vayaNavisesAIaM davvamavvattavvayaM paDai / / 1/36 / / " 1-samayamAi8 (syA. kalpa.) / 2010_02

Page #111
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 1, gAthA - 36 asyArthaH- arthAntarabhUtairnijakaiSTA paryAyaiH krameNa syAt san syAdasanniti dvau bhaGgau bhavata iti zeSaH / dvAbhyAM cAdibhyAM prAguktAbhyAM prakArAbhyAm, samakaM yugapadvivakSitamiti zeSaH, dravyaM vacanavizeSAtItaM sattathAvidhavacanavAcyatA'nApannaM sad, avaktavyakaM patati tRtIyabhaGgaviSayatAmAskandatIti / atra ca nijArthAntaraparyAyairanekAntopajIvinaigamavyavahAravizuddhatAratamyopadarzakavasatidRSTAntanItyA yathAkramasaGkucadbhiH krameNa yugapaJcAdiSTairUpadarziteSu SoDazasvavaktavyavikalpeSu madhye ekAdazasu trayo'pi bhaGgAH sambhavanti, dvAdazAdiSu paJcasu sa svatantraikAnte nayArpitaistaiH pratyekaM samudAye ca sarvathA'vaktavyatvabhaGga evottiSThate, sa ca bAdhitaH san kathaJcidavaktavyatve paryavasyati, tasya kathaJcittvaM ca bhaGgadvayAdhInam, itthaM ca trayANAM bhaGgAnAM kramAbhidhAnameva sampradAyasiddhamiti / -: zAstravArttAsamuccaye : 66 syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAm stabaka- 7, gAthA 23 yadi vA, rUpAdayaH pararUpam, matubarthaH svarUpam, rUpAdyAtmakaikAkArAvabhAsapratyayaviSayavyatirekeNApararUpasambandhyanavagatervizeSyAbhAvAd na rUpAdimAn ghaTa ityavAcyaH / na caikAkArapratibhAsagrAhyavyatirekeNApararUpAdipratibhAsaH, iti vizeSaNAbhAvAdapyavAcyaH / anekAnte tu kathaJcit tathA / athavA, bAhyaH pararUpam, upayogastu svaM rUpam, tAbhyAmAdiSTo'vaktavyaH, tathAhi-ya upayogaH sa ghaTa ityuktau upayogamAtrameva ghaTa iti sarvopayogasya ghaTatvaprasaktiH, iti prativAcyaH / yo ghaTaH sa upayoga ityuktAvupayogasyArthatvaprasakterupayogAbhAve ghaTasyApyabhAva iti kathaM nAvAcyaH ? I tadidamuktam [sammatau] - 1 "" atyaMtarabhUehi ya Niyaehi a dohi samayamAi / vayaNavisesAIyaM davvamavattavvayaM paDai || 1 / 36 / / " iti / -: aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNe : pariccheda 1, kANDa 16 kathaJcidarpitayoH-svapararUpAbhyAM vivakSitayoH, tathApratipattisadbhAvAcca tAdRzayostayorekAdhikaraNatvadhIsadbhAvAcca, na ca dRSTe'nupapannaM nAma, bhinnasvabhAvayorapyekatvaM dRSTAntena prasiddhenopadarzayati 1- samayamAIhiM (saMmati ) / 2010_02

Page #112
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-37 zAbdetaretyAdi / spaSTAspaSTaviSayatayA bhinnasvabhAvatvena siddhayoH pratyakSazAbdabodhayoryathaika- . viSayatvamekadravyAzrayatvaM cAviruddha tathA sattvAsattvayorekAzrayatvamapIti yugapadAdiSTAbhyAM tadbhedAdAnekabheda ityete trayo niravayavadravyaviSayatvAt sakalAdezarUpAH sadasattvasadavaktavyatvAdayaSTAtvArastu caramAH sAvayavadravyaviSayatvAdvikalAdezarUpAH, dezabhedaM vinaikatra tu krameNApi sadasattvavivakSA sampradAyaviruddhatvAnnodetIti na niravayavadravyaviSayatvameSAmityasmadabhimatoktameva yuktamiti mantavyam / tadetadrahasyaM svasamayavyutpattirasikamanovinodAya sammatigAthAbhireva vyutpAdayAmaH atyaMtarabhUehiM Niyaehi ya dohiM samayamAIhiM / vayaNavisesAIyaM davvamavattavvayaM paDai / / [1/36] arthAntarabhUtaH paTAdiH nijo ghaTAdiH tAbhyAM dvAbhyAM sadasattvaM ghaTavastunaH prathama-dvitIyabhaGganimittaM pradhAnaguNabhAvena bhavatIti sopaskAraM vyAkhyeyam / 'samayamAihiM' ityanantaraM turgamyaH, dvAbhyAmiti cAnuvarttate, samakamAdirAdAnaM yayostAbhyAM sahArpitAbhyAM tu dvAbhyAmityarthaH / vacanavizeSAtItaM vacanasya vizeSaH zaktistamatItamatikrAntaM sat tathAvidhavAcakAviSayIbhUtamiti yAvat / dravyaM ghaTAdi, avyaktavyam, patati azaktibhArAdvaktavyatAzikhare sthAtuM na zaknotItyarthaH / avyaktavyatAM vA patatIti vyAkhyeyam, tathAhi-dvayordharmayoH prAdhAnyena guNabhAvena vA pratipAdane na kiJcidvacaH samartham / [ caturthabhaGganirUpaNam ] evaM niravayavavAkyasvarUpaM bhaGgakatrayaM pratipAdya sAvayavavAkyarUpacaturthabhaGgakaM pratipAdayitumAha aha deso sabbhAve deso'sabbhAvapajjave Niyao / taM daviyamatthi Natthi ya AesavisesiyaM jamhA / / 37 / / atha iti yadA dezo vastuno'vayavaH sadbhAve'stitve niyataH 'sannevAyam' ityevaM niSTiAtaH aparapTA dezo'sadbhAvaparyAye-nAstitva eva-niyataH- asannevAyam' ityavagataH avayavebhyo'vayavinaH kathaJcidabhedAd avayavadharmestasyApi tathAvyapadezaH yathA 'kuNTho devadattaH' iti / tato'vayavasattvAsattvAbhyAmavayavI api sadasan sambhavati / tataH tad dravyamasti ca nAsti _ 2010_02

Page #113
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-37 ceti bhavatyubhayapradhAnAvayavabhAgena vizeSitaM yasmAt / tathAhi-yada avayavena viziSTadharmeNa Adizyate tad asti ca nAsti ca bhavati / tathA, svadravya-kSetra-kAla-bhAvairvibhakto ghaTaH svadravyAdirUpeNAsti paradravyAdirUpeNa ca sa eva nAsti / tathA ca puruSAdi vastu vivakSitaparyAyeNa bAlAdinA pariNataM kumArAdinA cApariNatamityAdiSTamiti yojyam-4 / / 37 / / [S.T.P.446] -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : saptamabhaGgasvarUpavarNane, patra-70 Aha ca [sammatau] - "aha deso sabbhAve, deso'sabbhAvapajjave Niyao / taM daviyamatthi Natthi ya, AesavisesiyaM jamhA / / 1/37 / / " asyArthaH- yadA dezo vastuno'vayavaH sadbhAve'stitve niyataH sannevAyamityevaM niSTiAtaH, aparaSTA dezo'sadbhAvaparyAye nAstitva eva niyato'sannevAyamityavagataH, avayavebhyo'vayavinaH kathaJcidabhedAdavayavadharmestasyApi tathA vyapadezo, yathA 'kuNTho devadatta iti' tato'vayavasattvAsattvAbhyAmavayavyapi sadasan sambhavati, tatastadravyasti ca nAsti ceti bhavati, Adezena ubhayapradhAnAvayavabhAgena vizeSitaM yasmAt / tathAhi, yadavayavena viziSTadharmeNa Adizyate tadasti ca nAsti ca bhavati, tathA svadravyakSetrakAlabhAvairvibhakto hi ghaTo'sti paradravyAdirUpeNa ca sa nAstIti / Adyayorapi bhaGgayoH svadravyaparadravyAbhyAM vibhajyata eva ghaTa iti tatsamudAyAtko'sya vizeSa iti cet, na, tatrAstitvanAstitvAvacchedakadvArA vibhAge'pyavayavadvArA vibhAgAbhAvAt, atra tu taddvArA vibhAgena vizeSAt / tadvArA vibhAgakaraNa eva kiM bIjamiti cet ? sAvayavaniravayavAtmakavastunastathAprati pattijanakasAvayavaniravayavatvazabalaikasvarUpavAkyatvena prAmANyarakSArthamiti dik / / 2010_02

Page #114
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 1, gAthA - 37 -: aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNe pariccheda- 1, kANDa 16 bhaGgAH SoDaza yogatarkavadime bhUyo vicArakSamAH, sAkalyena ca tairniyamyata idaM bhaGgatrayaM vastuni | tenaitAn sudhiyo vadanti sakalAdezAn vivakSAvazA dezasthAMTAturaH parAMstu vikalAdezAnnidezAd guroH / / 1 / / ( zArdUla0) etadanyatareNaiva saptabhaGgyaikyamiSyate / zabdasAmyena naikatvaM tattvataH SoDazaiva tAH / / 2 / / hArthe koTizo bhaGgA nirdiSTA mallavAdinA / mUlasammatiTIkAyAmidaM diGmAtradarzanam / / 3 / / eta eva saptabhaGgAH syAtpadalAJchanavirahiNo'vadhAraNaikasvabhAvA viSayAbhAvAddurnayA bhavanti / dharmAntaropAdAnapratiSedhAkaraNAt, svArthamAtrapratipAdanaparAH syAtpadamahimnA vivakSitaikadharmAvadhAraNaparA vA sunayA iti vibhAgaH / -- evaM niravayavavAkyAtmakaM bhaGgatrayaM pratipAdya sAvayavavAkyarUpaM caturthaM bhaGgaM pratipAdayitumAha [sammatau] aha deso sabbhAve deso'sabbhAvapajjave Niyao / taM daviyamatthi Natthi ya AesavisesiyaM jamhA / / 2 / / [1 / 37] 2010_02 69 atheti yadA dezo vastuno'vayavo dharmo vA, sadbhAve'stitve, niyato vivakSitaH, dezAparo'sadbhAve nAstitve tadA tad dravyamasti ca nAsti ceti dezAbhedadvAreNa vAcyam / akSipANigatakANakuNTatvayogAt kANakuNTa iva devadattaH, tadAha yasmAttad dravyamAdezavizeSitam ubhayasvAzrayasamavAyitvarUpaparamparAsambandhAvacchinnadharmadvayaprakAratAnirUpitaikavizeSyatAkaupAdAnikabodhecchAviSayIkRtamiti yAvat / yathAzrute ghaTapadasya dezaparasyAvRttyAH prakAratAdvayanirUpitavizeSyatAdvayazAlina eva bodhasya jananAdaupAdAnikabodha- paryantamanudhAvanam, evamagre'pi pradhAnAvayavAbhedenArpitaM bodhyam / -

Page #115
70 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-38 [ paJcamabhaGgapradarzanam ] pUrvabhaGgakapradarzitanyAyena paJcamabhaGgakapradarzanAyAha sabbhAve AiTTho deso deso ya ubhayahA jassa / taM atthi avattavvaM ca hoi davi viyappavasA / / 38 / / sadbhAve'stitve yasya ghaTAderdharmiNo dezo dharma AdiSTo'vaktavyAnuviddhasvabhAve anyathA tadasattvAt / na hyaparadharmApravibhaktatAmantareNa vivakSitadharmAstitvamasya sambhavati kharaviSANAderiva / tasyaivAparo deza ubhayathA astitvanAstitvaprakArAbhyAmekadaiva vivakSito'stitvAnuviddha evAvaktavyasvabhAvaH anyathA tadasattvaprasakteH na hyastitvAbhAve ubhayAvibhaktA zazazRGgAderiva tasya sambhavinI, prathama-tRtIyakevalabhaGgavyudAsastathAvivakSAvazAdatra kRto draSTavyaH / tatra prathama-tRtIyayorbhaGgakayoH parasparAvizeSaNabhUtayoH pratipAdyenAdhigantumiSTatvAt, pratipAdakenApi tathaiva vivakSitatvAt, atra tu tadviparyayAt anantadharmAtmakasya dharmiNaH pratipAdyAnurodhena tathAbhUtadharmAkrAntatvena vaktumiSTatvAt tad dravyamasti ca avaktavyaM ca bhavati taddharmavikalpanavazAta dharmayostathApariNatayostathAvyapadeze dharmyapi tadvAreNa tathaiva vyapadizyate 5 / / 38 / / [S.T.P. 447] ___ -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : saptabhaGgasvarUpavarNane, patra-70 ekasya dezasya sattvenA'parasya ca yugapadubhayathAdeze dvitIyo vikalAdezaH / Aha ca [sammatau] "sabbhAve AiTTho, deso deso ya ubhayahA jassa / taM atthi avattavvaM ca hoi daviyaM viappavasA / / 1/38 / / " asyArthaH-sadbhAve'stitve, yasya ghaTAderdharmiNaH, dezo dharmaH AdiSTo'vaktavyAnuviddhaH, svabhAve, anyathA tadasattvAt, na hyaparadharmA'pravibhaktatAmantareNa vivakSitadharmAstitvamasya sambhavati, kharaviSANAderiva, tasyaivAparo deza ubhayathAstitvanAstitvaprakArAbhyAmekadaiva vivakSito'stitvAnuviddha evAvaktavyasvabhAve, anyathA tadasattvaprasakteH, na hyastitvAbhAve ubhayAvibhaktatA zazazRGgAderiva tasya 2010_02

Page #116
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-38 sambhavinI, prathamatRtIyakevalabhaGgavyudAsastathAvivakSAvazAdatra . kRto'tra draSTavyaH, tatra prathamatRtIyayorbhaGgayoH parasparAvizeSaNIbhUtayoH pratipAdyenAdhigantumiSTatvAt, pratipAdakenApi tathaiva vivakSitatvAd, atra tu tadviparyayAdanantadharmAtmakasya dharmiNaH pratipAdyanurodhena tathAbhUtadharmAkrAntatvena vaktumiSTatvAttadravyamasti cAvaktavyaM ca bhavati, taddharmavikalpavazAddharmayostathApariNatayostathA vyapadeze dharmyapi taddvAreNa tathaiva hi vyapadizyate / atredamavadheyam - parasparavizeSaNIbhUtayorastitvAvaktavyatvayoratra na vivakSA, caitro raktadaNDavAnitivat syAdastyavaktavyaSTA ghaTa ityato'stitvaviziSTA'vaktavyatvavAn ghaTa ityabodhAt, kintu cakArabalAd 'ekatra dvayam' iti nyAyena videze daNDI kuNDalI cetyatra caitre daNDakuNDalayoriva prakRte ghaTe'stitvA'vaktavyatvayoH parasparA'vizeSaNIbhUtayoreva bhAnAt / ekatra dvayabhAne dvayoH sAmAnAdhikaraNyena vaiziSTyamapyautsargikaM bhAsata iti cet, tarhi sambhUyabhaGgadvayajanitabodhe'pi tadbhAnamAvazyakamiti kastato vizeSaH / vastuto militAbhyAM prathamatRtIyAbhyAmastitvaviziSTe ghaTe'vaktavyavaiziSTyajJAnaM sukaram, dvitIyamilanasyApi 'adhikaM praviSTe na tu taddhAniH' iti nyAyenAduSTatvAt, prakRte tu 'ekatra dvayam' iti nyAyenApi na bAdho deze'sattvasya deze'vaktavyatvasya ca vivakSaNAditi viparIto vizeSaH, parasparavizeSaNIbhUtayorekavAkyena bodhyatvaprakArakatAtparyaviSayatayA tu vizeSo na bhaGgAntaranimittaM phalAvizeSAt, anyathA vizeSaNavizeSyabhAva kAmacArasyApi tathAtvaprasaGgAt, tathApi dezavizeSitaparasparavizeSaNavizeSyabhAvenAtra vizeSo draSTavyaH, prakRte'styavaktavyapadayordezAstitvaviziSTadezAvaktavyatvaviziSTayoreva tAtparyAnupapattyA lakSaNAsvIkArAt, tayopTA tAdAtmyena vaiziSTyabAdhasyaitadbhaGgaphalatvAt, ayameva parasparAnuvedhArtho'pi draSTavyaH, caturthabhaGge'pyubhayapradhAnAvayavabhAgenaiva vizeSopadezAdatrAgre'pi tasyaiva vizeSasyA'viziSTatvAditi dig / / -: zAstravArtAsamuccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAm stabaka-7, gAthA-23 yadA ca dezo'stitve'vaktavyatvAnuviddhasvabhAva Adizyate, aparapTA dezo'stitvanAstitvAbhyAmekadaiva vivakSito'stitvAnuviddha evAvaktavyatvasvabhAve, tadA paJcamabhaGgapravRttiH, prathamatRtIyakevalabhaGgavyudAso'tra vivakSAbhedakRto draSTavyaH, prathama-tRtIyayoH parasparAnuparaktayoH pratipAdyenAdhigantumiSTatvAt, pratipAdakenApi tathaiva vivakSitatvAt, atra tu tadviparyatAt, anantadharmAtmakasya dharmiNaH pratipAdyanurodhena tathAbhUtadharmAkrAntatvena vaktumiSTatvAt / tadidamAha [sammatau] _ 2010_02

Page #117
72 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-39 "sabbhAve AiTTho deso deso a ubhayahA jss| taM atthi avattavvaM ca hoi daviyaM viappavasA / / 1/38 / / " -: aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNe : __ pariccheda 1, kANDa 16 uktanyAyena paJcamabhaGgapradarzanAyAha[sammatau] - sabbhAve AiTTho deso deso ya ubhayahA jassa / taM atthi avattavvaM ca hoi daviyaM viappavasA / / 1/38 / / sadbhAve astitve yasya ghaTAderdharmiNo deza AdiSTo dezaSTApara ubhayathA'stitvanAstitvaprakArAbhyAmekadaiva vivakSitaH tad dravyaM asti cAvaktavyaM ca bhavati, vikalpavazAd uktobhayadharmAkrAntadezadvAreNa dharmiNo vivakSAvazAt, tena prathamatRtIyabhaGgasaMyogenAnyathAsiddhivyudAsaH, kevaladharmavivakSAyA dezAvizeSitadravya eva sambhavAt, dezadvArA dravye ubhayadharmavivakSAyA eva yuktatvAditi bodhyam / [ SaSTabhaGgapradarzanam ] SaSThabhaGgakaM darzayitumAha AiTTho'sabbhAve deso deso ya ubhayahA jassa / taM Natthi avattavvaM ca hoi daviyaM viyappavasA / / 39 / / yasya vastuno dezo'sattve niSTiAtaH 'asannevAyam' ityavaktavyAnuviddhaH aparapTAsadanuviddha ubhayathA 'sannasaMpTA' ityevaM yugapanniSTiAtastadA tad dravyaM nAsti ca avaktavyaM ca bhavati vikalpavazAt tadvyapadezyAvayavavazAt dravyamapi tadvyapadezamAsAdayati / kevaladvitIyatRtIyabhaGgakavyudAsena SaSThabhaGgaH pradarzitaH 6 / / 39 / / [S.T.P.447] -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : saptabhaGgasvarUpavarNane, patra-71 deze'sattvasya deze ca yugapadubhayorvivakSaNe SaSThaH, Aha ca [sammatau] - 2010_02

Page #118
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-39 AiTTho'sabbhAve, deso deso ya ubhayahA jassa / taM Natthi avattavvaM ca hoi daviyaM viyappavasA / / 1/39 / / asyArthaH yasya vastuno dezo'sattve AdiSTo'sannevAyamiti avaktavyatAnuviddho vivakSito'paraTAsadanuviddhaH, ubhayathA sadasattvAbhyAmAdiSTastadA tad dravyaM nAsti cAvaktavyaM ca bhavati vikalpavazAt, tadvyapadezyAvayavAbhedopacArAt dravyasyApi tadvyapadezAsAdanAt, dezAnuparaktadvitIyatRtIyabhaGgavyudAsenAyaM SaSTho bhaGgaH pravartate / / -: zAstravArtAsamuccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAm, stabaka-7, gA. 23 yadA ca vastuno deza eko'sattve'vaktavyatvAnuviddhe niSTiAtaH aparaSTAsattvAnuviddho yugapadubhayathA vivakSitastadA tathAvyapadezyAvayavavazAdavayavini SaSThabhaGgapravRttiH, kevaladvitIyatRtIyabhaGgavyudAsaH, prAgvat pratipAdyajijJAsAvazAt / tadidamAha [sammatau] - "AiTTho'sabbhAve deso deso ya ubhayahA jassa / taM Natthi avattavyaM ca hoi daviaM viappavasA / / " 1/39 / / -: aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNe : pariccheda-1, kANDa-16 SaSThaM bhaGga darzayitumAha [sammatau] - AiTTho sabbhAve deso, deso ya ubhayahA jassa / taM Natthi avattavyaM ca hoi daviyaM viappavasA / / [1/39] yasya vastuno deza eko'sattve niyato'paraSTA sattvAsattvAbhyAM yugapad AdiSTaH tad dravyaM tathA vikalpavazAnnAsti cAvaktavyaM ca bhavati, kevaladvitIyatRtIyabhaGgavyudAsaH prAgvadbhAvyaH / 2010_02

Page #119
74 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-40 [ saptamabhaGgaprakAzanam ] saptamapradarzanAyAha sabbhAvA'sabbhAve deso deso ya ubhayahA jassa / taM asthi Natthi 'avattavvayaM ca daviyaM viyappavasA / / 40 / / yasya dezino dezo'vayavaH dezo dharmo vA sadbhAvaniyato niSTiAtaH aparastu asadbhAve asattve tRtIyastu ubhayathA ityevaM dezAnAM sadasadavaktavyavyapadezAt tad api dravyamasti ca nAsti cAvaktavyaM ca bhavati vikalpavazAt tathAbhUtavizeSaNAdhyAsitasya dravyasyAnena pratipAdanAdaparabhaGgavyudAsaH / ete ca paraspararUpApekSayA saptabhaGgyAtmakAH pratyekaM svArthaM pratipAdayanti nAnyatheti pratyekaM tatsamudAyo vA saptabhaGgAtmakaH pratipAdyamapi tathAbhUtaM darzayatIti vyavasthitam / 7 / atra cAdyabhaGgakastridhA, dvitIyo'pi tridhaiva, tRtIyo dazadhA, caturtho'pi dazadhaiva, paJcamAdayastu triMzadadhikazataparimANAH pratyekaM zrImanmallavAdiprabhRtibhirdarzitAH / punaSTA SaDviMzatyadhikacaturdazazataparimANAsta eva dvayAdisaMyogakalpanayA koTIzo bhavantItyabhihitaM taireva / atra tu granthavistarabhayAt tathA na pradarzitAstata evAvadhAryAH / athAnantadharmAtmake vastuni tatpratipAdakavacanasya saptadhA kalpane aSTamavacanavikalpaparikalpanamapi kiM na kriyata iti na vaktavyam tatparikalpananimittAbhAvAt / tathAhi-na tAvat sAvayavAtmakamanyonyanimittakaM tat parikalpayituM yuktam, caturthAdivacanavikalpeSu tasyAntarbhAvaprasakteH / nApi niravayavAtmakamanyonyanimittakaM tat parikalpanAmarhati prathamAdiSvantarbhAvaprasakteH / na ca gatyantaramastIti nASTamabhaGgaparikalpanA yuktA / kiJca, asau krameNa vA taddharmadvayaM pratipAdayet, yaugapadyena vA ? prathamapakSe guNapradhAnabhAvena tatpratipAdane prathamadvitIyayorantarbhAvaH pradhAnabhAvena tatpratipAdane caturthe / yaugapadyena tatpratipAdane tRtIye, bhaGgakasaMyogakalpanayA bhaGgAntarakalpanAyAM prathamadvitIyabhaGgakasaMyoge caturthabhaGgaka eva prasajyate, prathamatRtIyasaMyogAt paJcamaprasaktiH , dvitIya-tRtIyasaMyogAta SaSThaprasaktiH , prathamadvitIya1-avattavvaM (assttshsrii.)| 2010_02

Page #120
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-40 tRtIyasaMyogAt saptamaH, prathamacaturthAdisaMyogakalpanAyAM punaruktadoSaH / tasmAnna kathaJcidaSTamabhaGgasambhava ityuktanyAyAt vastupratipAdane saptavidha eva vacanamArgaH / / 40 / / [S.T.P.447] -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : saptabhaGgasvarUpavarNane, patra-70 deze'stitvasya deze nAstitvasya deze ca yugapadubhayorvivakSAyAM saptamaH / Aha ca [sammatau] - "sabbhAvAsabbhAve, deso deso ya ubhayahA jassa / taM atthi Natthi avattavvayaM ca daviyaM viappavasA / / 1/40 / / " asyArthaH-yasya dezino dezo'vayavo dezo dharmo vA, sadbhAve sattve niyato'parastvasadbhAve'sattve, tRtIyastUbhayathAtyevaM dezAnAM sadasadavaktavyavyapadezAttadapi dravyamasti ca nAsti cAvaktavyaM ca bhavati vikalpavazAt, tathAbhUtavizeSaNAdhyAsitasya dravyasyAnena pratipAdanAdaparabhaGgavyudAsaH / ete ca paraspararUpApekSayA saptabhaGgayAtmakAH pratyekaM svArthaM pratipAdayanti nAnyatheti pratyekaM tatsamudAyo vA saptabhaGgAtmakaH pratipAdyamapi tathAbhUtaM darzayatIti sampradAyavido vadanti / tatra jijJAsitasaptadharmAtmakatApratipAdakatvaparyAptyadhikaraNamahAvAkyatvarUpasaptabhaGgItvaM samudAya eva niruktapratipAdakatvAdhikaraNavAkyatvarUpaM ca tatpratyekamapIti vivekaH / ata eva syAtpadalAJchanavivakSitadharmAvadhArakatvena svArthamAtrapratipAdanapravaNatvena ca dvidhA sunayatvamudAharanti, AdyaM saptabha GgyAtmakamahAvAkyaikavAkyatApannavAkye, antyaM codAsIne dharmAntaropAdAnapratiSedhAkAriNi, itthaM ca syAdastItyAdi pramANam, astyevetyAdi durnayaH, astItyAdikaH sunayaH, na tu sa vyavahArAGgam, syAdastyevetyAdistu sunaya eva vyavahArakAraNam, svaparAnuvRttavyAvRttavastuviSayapravartakavAkyasya vyavahArakAraNatvAditi granthakRto vivecayanti / atra saptabhaGgyAmAdyabhaGgakastridhA, dvitIyo'pi tridhA, tRtIyo dazadhA, caturthopi dazadhaiva, paJcamAdayastu triMzadadhikazataparimANAH pratyekaM zrImanmallavAdiprabhRtibhirdarzitAH / --: zAstravArtAsamuccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAm stabaka-7 gA. 23 yadA ca vastuno deza ekaH sattve niyataH dvitIyaSTAA'sattve, tRtIyastUbhayathA'bhidhitsitastadA tathAbhUtavizeSaNAdhyAsitasyAnenaiva prakAreNa pratipAdanAdIdRze'rthe'parabhaGgaviSayA'prasarAt saptamabhaGgapravRttiH / tadidamAha [sammatau] 2010_02

Page #121
76 "sabbhAvAsabbhAve deso deso a ubhayahA jassa / taM atthi Natthi avattavvayaM ca daviaM viappavasA / / 1/40" / / iti / -: aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNe : pariccheda 1, kANDa - 16 saptamaM pradarzayati [sammatau] - saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 1, gAthA - 41 sabbhAvAsa bhAve deso, deso ya ubhayahA jassa / taM atthi Natthi 'avattavvaM ca hoi daviyaM viappavasA [1/40] yasya deza ekaH sadbhAve aparo asadbhAve anyaSTA ubhayathA niyatastad dravyaM tathAvikalpavazAdasti nAstyavaktavyaM ca bhavati, viziSTavivakSayA kevalabhaGgatrayavyudAsaH / na cAtrASTamavacanavikalpaparikalpanApi sambhavadavatArA, tannimittAbhAvAt, sAvayavAtmakasya niravayavAtmakasya tannimittasya caturthAdiSu prathamAdiSu cAntarbhAvAt, gatyantarasya cAsattvAt / na cAvaktavyatvavadvaktavyatvenASTamena bhavitavyam, sapratipakSamaulabhaGgajijJAsAmUlajijJAsAviSayatvenAvaktavyatvAzrayaNe'pi tadviparyayeNa vaktavyatvAnAzrayaNAt, ata evAvaktavyatvasaptabhaGgyAmapi maulabhaGgadvayotthApitAkAGkSAviSayasyAvaktavyatvasyAnyasyaiva tRtIyabhaGge pravezAnna nyUnatvamiti vadanti tena vyavasthitaH saptavidho vacanamArgaH / [ saptAnAM bhaGgAnAmarthanaye zabdanaye ca yathAsaMbhavaM vibhajanam ] anyonyAparityAgavyavasthitasvarUpavAkyanayAnAM zuddhayazuddhivibhAgena saMgrahAdivyapadezamAsAdayatAM dravyArthikaparyAyArthikanayAveva mUlAdhAra iti pradarzanArthamAha evaM sattaviyo vayaNapaho hoi atthapajjAe / vaMjaNapajjAe uNa saviyappo Nivviyappo ya / / 41 / / evaM ityanantaroktaprakAreNa saptavikalpaH saptabhedaH vacanamArgo vacanapathaH bhavatyarthaparyAye arthanaye saMgraha-vyavahAra-RjusUtralakSaNe saptApyanantaroktA bhaGgakA bhavanti / tatra prathamaH saMgrahe 1- avattavvayaM ( saMmati ) / 2010_02

Page #122
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-41 sAmAnyagrAhiNi, 'nAsti' ityayaM tu vyavahAre vizeSagrAhiNi, RjusUtre tRtIyaH, caturthaH saMgrahavyavahArayoH, paJcamaH saMgraha - RjusUtrayoH, SaSTho vyavahAra - RjusUtrayoH, saptamaH saMgraha-vyavahAraRjusUtreSu / vyaJjanaparyAye zabdanaye savikalpaH prathame paryAyazabdavAcyatAvikalpasadbhAve'pyarthasyaikatvAt / dvitIya-tRtIyayornirvikalpaH dravyArthAt sAmAnyalakSaNAnnirgataparyAyAbhidhAyakatvAt samabhirUDhasya paryAyabhedabhinnArthatvAt evaMbhUtasyApi vivakSitakriyAkAlArthatvAt liGgasaMjJA-kriyAbhedena bhinnasyaikazabdAvAcyatvAt / zabdAdiSu tRtIyaH, prathama-dvitIyasaMyoge caturthaH teSveva cAnabhidheyasaMyoge paJcama-SaSTha-saptamA vacanamArgA bhavanti / athavA pradarzitasvarUpA saptabhaGgI saMgraha - vyavahAra - RjusUtreSvevArthanayeSu bhavatItyAha-evaM sattaviyappo ityAdigAthAm / asyAstAtparyArthaH 77 arthanaya eva sapta bhaGgAH, zabdAdiSu tu triSu nayeSu prathama dvitIyAveva bhaGgau / yo hyarthamAzritya vaktRsthaH saMgraha-vyavahAra-RjusUtrAkhyaH pratyayaH prAdurbhavati so'rthanayaH arthavazena tadutpatteH arthaM pradhAnatayAsau vyavasthApayatIti kRtvA, zabdaM tu svaprabhavamupasarjanatayA vyavasthApayati tatprayogasya parArthatvAt / yastu zrotari tacchabdazravaNAdudgacchati zabda-samabhirUDha-evaMbhUtAkhyaH pratyayastasya zabdaH pradhAnam, tadvazena tadutpatteH arthastUpasarjanam, tadutpattAvanimittatvAt sa zabdanaya ucyate / tatra ca vacanamArgaH savikalpa nirvikalpatayA dvividhaH - savikalpaM sAmAnyam, nirvikalpaH paryAyaH tadabhidhAnAd vacanamapi tathA vyapadizyate / tatra zabda- samabhirUDhau saMjJAkriyAbhede'pyabhinnamarthaM pratipAdayata iti tadabhiprAyeNa savikalpo vacanamArgaH prathamabhaGgakarUpaH / evaMbhUtastu kriyAbhedAd bhinnamevArthaM tatkSaNe pratipAdayatIti nirvikalpo dvitIyabhaGgakarUpastadvacanamArgaH / avaktavyabhaGgakastu vyaJjananaye na sambhavatyeva yataH zrotrabhiprAyo vyaJjananayaH sa ca zabdazravaNAdarthaM pratipadyate na zabdAzravaNAt avaktavyaM tu zabdAbhAvaviSaya iti nAvaktavyabhaGgakaH vyaJjanaparyAye sambhavatItyabhiprAyavatA vyaJjanaparyAye tu savikalpa-nirvikalpau prathamadvitIyAveva bhaGgAvabhihitAvAcAryeNa tuzabdasya gAthAyAmevakArArthatvAt / / 41 / / [S.T.P. 448] -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : saptabhaGgasvarUpavarNane, patra - 72 2010_02

Page #123
78 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa -1, gAthA - 41 atraivaM nayavibhAgamupadizanti zrIsiddhasenadivAkarapAdAH [sammatau ] " evaM sattaviyappo vayaNapaho hoi atthapajjAe / vaMjaNapajjA puNa, saviyappo Nivviyappo ya / / 1/41 / / " asyArthaH evamanantaroktaprakAreNa saptavikalpaH saptabhedaH, vacanapatho bhavatyarthaparyAye'rthanaye saGgrahavyavahArarjusUtralakSaNe, saptApyanantaroktA bhaGgakA bhavanti / tatra prathamo bhaGgaH saGgrahe sAmAnyagrAhiNI, nAstItyayaM tu vyavahAre vizeSagrAhiNi, RjusUtre tRtIyaH, caturthaH saGgrahavyavahArayoH, paJcamaH saGgraharjusUtrayoH SaSTho vyavahArarjusUtrayoH, saptamaH saGgrahavyavahArarjusUtreSviti vibhAgaH / / atra yaddharmaprakArakaH saGgrahAkhyo bodhaH prathamabhaGgaphalatvenAbhimatastaddharmAbhAvaprakArako vyavahArAkhyabodha dvitIyabhaGgaphalatvenaiSTavyaH tena syAd ghaTaH syAnnIlaghaTa ityAdisAmAnyavizeSasaGgrahavyavahArAbhyAM na saptabhaGgIpravRttirityavadheyam / / atha tRtIyabhaGgasya RjusUtranimittatAyAM kiM bIjaM yugapatsattvAsattvAbhyAmAdiSTaM hi saGgrahavyavahArAvapyavaktavyameva brUtaH, saGgrahavyavahArau yugapadubhayathA''dizata eva, neti cet, RjusUtro'pi kathaM tathA''diSTuM pragalbhatAm, madhyamakSaNarUpAyAH sattAyAstenApyabhyupagamAt / saGgrahAbhimatayAvatsajAtIyavizeSAnuvRttasAmAnyAnabhyupagamAdRjusUtreNAvaktavyatvabhaGga utthApyata iti cet, so'yaM pratyekAvaktavyatvakRto'vaktavyatvabhaGgaH, tadutthApane ca saGgrahopi samarthaH, RjusUtrAbhimatamadhyamakSaNarUpasattAnabhyugantrA tenApi tadutthApanasya sukaratvAditi cet, atredamAbhAti-saGgrahavyavahArau yugapannobhayathAdeSTuM pragalbhete, svAnabhimatAMzAdeze'niSTasAdhanatvapratisandhAnAt, RjusUtrasya tu vartamAnaparyAyamAtragrAhiNastiryagUrdhvatAspadAdhArAMzAnyatararUpasAmAnyAnyApoharUpavizeSau ca sAMvRtAveveti tadapekSayA yugapadubhayathA''hAryatadAdezasambhavAdavaktavyabhaGgotthAnamanAbAdham, na caivamapi tajjanitabodhasya prasaGgarUpatvAdviparyayaparyavasane saGgrahavyavahArAnyatarasAmrAjyamiti vAcyam, viSayAbAdhe kUTaliGgajAnumiteriva prakRtabhaGgajabodhasya pramAtvena viparyayaparyavasAnakadarthanAnavakAzAd / adhikaM bahuzrutA vidanti / vyaJjanaparyAye zabdanaye punaH savikalpaH prathame paryAyazabdavAcyatAvikalpasadbhAve'pyarthasyaikatvAt, dvitIyatRtIyayornirvikalpakaSTA, dravyArthAtsAmAnyalakSaNAnnirgatasya paryAyarUpasya vikalpasyAbhidhAyakatvAttayoH, samabhirUDhasya paryAyabhedabhinnArthatvAt evambhUtasyApi vivakSitakriyAkAlArthatvAt, 2010_02

Page #124
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-41 tathA ca ghaTo nAma ghaTavAcakayAvacchabdavAcyaH zabdanaye'styeva, samabhirUdaivambhUtayostyeiveti dvau bhanau labhyete, liGgasaMjJAkriyAbhedena bhinnasyaikazabdAvAcyatvAcchabdAdiSu tRtIyaH, prathamadvitIyasaMyoge caturthaH, teSveva cAnabhidheyasaMyoge paJcamaSaSThasaptamA vacanamArgA bhavanti / athavA'nyathAsyAH vyAkhyAtAtparyam, arthanaya eva sapta bhaGgAH / -: nayopadeze : gAthA-6 atra saptabhaGgyAmitthaM nayavibhAgamupadizanti zrIsiddhasenadivAkarapAdAH [sammatau] - "evaM sattaviappo vayaNapaho hoi atthapajjAe / vaMjaNapajjAe puNa saviappo Nivviappo a|| 1/41 / / " evam anantaroktaprakAreNa, saptavikalpaH saptabhedaH, vacanapatho bhavati, arthaparyAye arthanaye saGgrahavyavahArarjusUtralakSaNe, tatra prathamo bhaGgaH saGgrahe sAmAnyagrAhiNi dvitIyastu 'nAsti' ityayaM vyavahAre vizeSagrAhiNi, RjusUtre tRtIyaH, caturthaH saGgraha-vyavahArayoH, paJcamaH saGgraharjusUtrayoH, SaSTho vyavahArarnusUtrayoH, saptamaH saGgraha-vyavahArarnusUtreSviti / prayogaSTautepTAturtha-tRtIyayorvyatyayeneSyata iti na tRtIye RjusUtrayojanAnupapattiH / atra yaddharmaprakArakaH saGgrahAkhyo bodhaH prathamabhaGgaphalatvenAbhimatastaddharmA'bhAvaprakArako vyavahArAkhyo bodha eva dvitIyabhaGgaphalatvenaiSTavyaH, tena 'syAd ghaTaH' 'syAnIlaghaTaH' ityAdi sAmAnya-vizeSasaGgraha-vyavahArAbhyAM na saptabhaGgIpravRttiH, navaikavacanabahuvacanAdinA bhaGgAntaravRddhirityavadheyam / __ atha tRtIyabhaGgasyarjusUtranimittakatAyAM kiM vIjam ? yugapatsattvA'sattvAbhyAmAdiSTaM hi saGgrahavyavahArAvapyavaktavyameva brUtaH, saGgraha-vyavahArau yugapadubhayathA''dizata eva neti ced ? RjusUtro'pi kathaM tathA''deSTuM pragalbhatAm ? madhyamakSaNarUpAyAH sattAyAstenApyupagamAt, saGgrahAbhimatayAvadvyaktyanuvRttasAmAnyAnabhyupagamAdRjusUtreNA'vaktavyatvabhaGgo na sthApyata iti cet ? so'yaM pratyekAvakta-vyatvakRto'vaktavyatvabhaGgaH, tadutthApane ca saGgraho'pi samarthaH RjusUtrAbhimatamadhyamakSaNarUpa-sattAnabhyupagantrA tenApi tadutthApanasya sukaratvAditi cet ? 2010_02

Page #125
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-41 atredamAbhAti-saGgraha-vyavahArau yugapatrobhayathA''deSTuM pragalbhete svAnabhimatAMzAdeze'niSTasAdhanatvapratisandhAnAt, RjusUtrasya tu vartamAnaparyAyamAtragrAhiNastiryagUlatAdhArAMzAnyatararUpaM sAmAnyam anyApoharUpo vizeSaSToti dvAvapi saMvRtAveveti tadapekSayA yugapadubhayathAhAryatadAdezasambhavAdavaktavyabhaGgotthAnamanAbAdham / na caivamapi tajjanitabodhasya prasaGgarUpatvAd viparyayaparyavasAne saGgraha-vyavahArAnyatarasAmrAjyamiti vAcyam, viSayAbAdhe kUTaliGgajAnumitiriva prakRtabhaGgajabodhasya pramAtvena viparyayaparyavasAnakadarthanAnavakAzAt / vyaJjanaparyAye zabdanaye punaH savikalpaH prathame paryAyazabdavAcyatAvikalpasadbhAvAdarthasyaikatvAJca, dvitIya-tRtIyayonirvikalpaSTA dravyArthAt sAmAnyalakSaNAnirgatasya paryAyarUpasya vikalpasyAbhidhAyakatvAt tayoH, tathA ca ghaTo nAma ghaTavAcakayAvacchabdavAcyaH zabdanaye'styeva, samabhirUdvaivaMbhUtayostyeiveti dvau bhaGgo labhyete / liGga-saMjJA-kriyAbhedena bhinnasyaikazabdAvAcyatvAcchabdAdiSu tRtIyaH / prathama-dvitIya-saMyoge caturthaH, teSveva cAnabhidheyasaMyoge paJcama-SaSTha-saptamavacanamArgAH sambhavanti / athavA zabdanaye paryAyAntarasahiSNau savikalpo vacanamArgaH, tadasahiSNau tu nirvikalpa iti dvAveva bhaGgo avaktavyabhaGgastu vyaJjananaye na sambhavatyeva, zrotari zabdoparaktArthabodhanasyaiva tatprayojanatvAt, avaktavyabodhanasya ca tannaye sampradAyaviruddhatvena tathAbubodhayiSAyA evAsambhavAdityadhikamasmatkRtAnekAntavyavasthAyAm / tadevaM pratiparyAyaM saptaprakArabodhajanakatAparyAptimad vAkyaM pramANavAkyamiti lakSaNaM siddham / itthaJca tadantarbhUtasya taSTahibhUtasya vA'nyatarabhaGgasya pradeza-paramANudRSTAntena nayavAkyatvamevetyarthato labhyate / itarapratikSepI tu nayo nayAbhAso durnayo vetyucyate / malayagiricaraNAstu- "nayo durnayaH sunayaToti digambarI vyavasthA, na tvasmAkaM nayadurnayayorA'vizeSAt, syAcchabdena vivakSitadharmoparAgeNa kAlAdibhirabhedavRttyA'bhedopacArAd vA'nantadharmAtmakavastupratipAdane pramANavAkyasyaiva vyavasthiteH, ata eva syAcchabdalAJchitatayaiva sarvatra sAdhUnAM bhASAvinayo vihitaH, avadhAraNI bhASA ca niSiddhA, tasyA nayarUpatvAt, nayAnAM ca sarveSAM mithyAdRSTitvAt, tathA cAnusmaranti- "savve NayA micchAvAyiNo" [ ] tti, na ca, saptabhaGgAtmakaM pramANavAkyam, ekabhaGgAtmakaM ca nayavAkyamityapi niyantuM zakyam, sapta bhaGgAH saptavidhajijJAsopAdhinimittatvAt, na ca tAsAM sArvatrikatvam, ko jIvaH ? iti pro lakSaNamAtrajijJAsayA 'syAjjJAnAdilakSaNo jIvaH' iti pramANavAkyarUpasyottarasya siddhAntasiddhatvAt, syAtpadasya cAtrA'nantadharmAtmakatvadyotakatvena prAmANyAGgatvam, dyotakatvaM cAtraupasampadAnakI zaktirlakSaNA 2010_02

Page #126
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 1, gAthA - 41 vetyanyadetat, tatra ca zrutapadapratipAdyadharmAMze laukikI viSayatA syAtpadadyotyA, anantadharmAtmakatvAMze ca lokottareti vizeSaH" ityabhisandadhate, tanmatamanurUdhya pramANalakSaNAntaraM samuccinoti - ca- punaH, yad vAkyam, ekadharmagaM pratiniyataikadharmapratipipAdayiSayA prayuktam, [ aparollekhi] syAtpadAdapare ye'nantA dharmAstAMllikhatItyevaMzIlaM vAkyam, tadapi pramANavAkyaM vyavartavyamityarthaH / ayaM sa samuccayo mayApi sampradAyamatamiti kRtvA samunnItaH, vastuto nayadurnayavibhAgo na daigambara eva, hemasUribhirapi "sadeva sat syAt saditi tridhArtho mIyeta durnIti-naya-pramANaiH" [anyayogavya0 lo. 28] ityAdi vibhajyAbhidhAnAt Akare nayatadAbhAsAnAM vyakterbodhitatvAcca / avadhAraNI ca bhASA ekAntavAdAtmakaiva niSiddhA, na tu nayarUpA'pi, tasyAH pramANaparikaratvena tatrAvadhAraNItvasya niSTAyakatvarUpabhASAlakSaNAnvayenaiva siddhAntasiddhatvAt, ata eva nirAkAGkSA'nAsannAdisthale zabdasamAnAkAramAnasasvIkAre kimaparAddhaM zAbdabodheneti paryanuyoge mAnasasya saMzayA''kArasyApi sambhavAd niSTAyakarUpazAbdabodhAnupapattereva yoktikairnirAkRtaH / na ca, bhASAmAtrasyAvadhAraNItve'pyArAdhakatva-virAdhakatva-tadubhayA-'nubhayaiH satyAdibhedacatuSTayopadezAnnayabhASAyA dezArAdhakatvena tRtIyabhaGga eva nikSepAt sAdhUnAmanAdaraNIyatvamityapi yuktam, caturdhA vibhAgasya dravya-bhAvabhASAyAmevopadezAt, tatra ca paribhaNitamizrabhASAbhedadazakAnantarbhAvAdeva nayabhASAyAM doSAbhAvAt, zrutabhAvabhASAyASTA tRtIyabhASAyAmevAnadhikRtatvAt, cAritrabhAvabhASAyAmAdyantayorbhASayoradhikRtatve'pyAyuktatayA catasRNAmapi bhASaNe ArAdhakatvAvirodhasya prajJApanAdAvuktatvAt / kiJca, pratItyasatyAlakSaNamatra sphuTameva kiM nonnIyate ? na ca saptabhaGgAtmaka vAkyasyaiva pratItyasatyAtvam, apekSAtmakabodhajanakavAkyatvasyaiva tallakSaNatvAt, anyathaikatrApekSayA hasva-dIrghAdi laukikavacanasyAlakSyatvApatteH / na ca satyA sarvatrA'laukikyeva lakSyA, janapadasatyAdibhedAnupasaGgrahApatteH / -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : zabdAditrayanayasvarUpavarNane, patra - 57 atredamAbhAti yadyapi sammatI " evaM sattaviappo, vayaNapaho hoi atthapajjAe / vaMjaNapajjAe puNa, saviyappo Nivviyappo ya / / 1-41 / / " tti / 2010_02 81

Page #127
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-41 gAthayA'rthaparyAyAzritA saptabhaGgI saGgrahavyavahArarjusUtrairvyaJjanaparyAyAzritA ca zabdasamabhirUDhavambhUtaiH sUcitA, tathApyetatprakAradvayAbhidhAnamarthavyaJjanasAdhAraNaparyAyasAmAnyAzritasaptabhaGgyA apyupalakSaNam, sA ca svaparaparyAyANAM kramayugapadvivakSAvazAnnayadvayenA'zuddhazuddhazuddhataraparyAyavivakSayA ca nayatrayeNApi sambhavatIti RjusUtrazabdaprayuktasaptabhaGgyA dvitIyAdinA vyavahArarjusUtrazabdaprayuktAyAM ca tasyAM tRtIyAdinA bhaGgenarjusUtrAcchabdasya vizeSitatarArthatvaM yuktam, na caivaM RjusUtrakRtasattApekSayA'sattAgrAhiNo vyavahArasyApi tato vizeSitatarArthatvaprasaGgadUSaNAnuddhAraH, sampradAyAviruddhabhaGgaviSayIbhUtenArthena vizeSitataratvasyAbhidhitsitatvAt, sampradAyapTottarottarabhaGgapravRttAvuttarottaranayAvalambanenaiva dRSTo nAnyatheti na kaSTiAddoSa iti vibhAvanIyaM sudhIbhiH / / -: dravyaguNaparyAyano rAsa : DhAla-4, gAthA-13 maho to bha. degnj cha "sakalanayArthapratipAdakatAtparyAdadhikaraNavAkyaM pramANavAkyam" meM lakSaNa leInaMI, tehave ThAme-syAtkAralAMchita sakalanayArtha-samUhAlaMbana ekabhaMgaI paNi niSedha nathA.TheTiM-vyaM4 napAna bhiM-2 mA 59 arthasiddhi sammati naviSa 5 / 76 tathA ca tadgAthA evaM sattaviappo, vayaNapaho hoi atthapajAe / vaMjaNapajAe puNa, saviappo Nivviappo ya / / 1 / / ehano artha_evaM pUrvokta prakAraI, saptavikalpa saptaprakAra vacanapaMtha-saptabhaMgIrUpavacanamArga te-arthaparyAya-astitva-nAstitvAdikanaI viSaI hoI, vyaMjanaparyAya je ghaTakuMbhATizabdavAcyatA, tana viSa-savikalpaH-viSi35 nirvikalpaH niSedha35: a 2 4 win 8. 5|bhvtvyaahi mAno, bhATiM-tavya viSaya to virodha thA. athavA-savikalpaH za-samami3Dhanayamata, Ana-nirvikalpaH avamabhUtanayamata , bha. 2. na .. marthanaya prathama 4. to vyaM4 napAya bhAna nahI, te bhA25- nayanI i pravRtti nathI. aghiI anekAntavyavasthAthI nij 2010_02

Page #128
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-41 tadevamekatra viSaye pratisvamanekanayavipratipattisthale syAtkAralAJchitatAvannayArthaprakArakasamUhAlambanabodhajanaka eka eva bhaGga eSTavyaH, vyaJjanaparyAyasthale bhaGgadvayavad / yadi ca-sarvatra saptabhaGgIniyama eva AzvAsaH tadA-cAlanIyanyAyena tAvannayArthaniSedhabodhako dvitIyo'pi bhaGgaH, tanmUlakApTAAnye'pi tAvatkoTikAH paJcabhaGgApTA kalpanIyAH, itthameva nirAkAGkSasakalabhaGganirvAhAd iti yuktaM pazyAmaH / e vicAra sAdvAdapaMDitaI sUkSma buddhi cittamAMhi dhAravo. 13 -: aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNe : pariccheda-1, kANDa-16 atra nayavibhAgapradarzanArthamAha [sammatau] - evaM sattaviappo vayaNapaho hoi atthapajjAe / vaMjaNapajjAe puNa saviappo Nivviappo ya / / [1/41] evaM-uktaprakAreNa saptavikalpaH saptabhedo vacanapathaH arthaparyAye-arthanaye saGgrahavyavahArarjusUtralakSaNe bhavati / tatra prathamaH saGgrahe sAmAnyagrAhiNi, dvitIyo vyavahAre vizeSagrAhiNi, tRtIyapakSa RjusUtre sUkSmavartamAnakSaNagrAhiNi, ekadobhayArpaNAyA vartamAnakSaNaniyatatvAt, caturthaH saGgrahavyavahArayoH, paJcamaH saGgraharjusUtrayoH, SaSTho vyavahArarjusUtrayoH, saptamaH saGgrahavyavahArarjusUtreSu / vyaJjanaparyAye viSayilakSaNayA zabdanaye savikalpaH sAmpratAkhyabhede, paryAyazabdavAcyatAvikalpasadbhAvAt, nirvikalpaH samabhirudvaivaMbhUtayoH paryAyakriyAbhedabhinnArthatvAt tayoH / tathA ca syAdasti syAnnAstItyatra ghaTapadena yAvadghaTavAcakapadAvAcyatvAvacchinno dharmyupAdeyaH, tasya phalataH prathamazabdabhede sattvam, dvitIyatRtIyayoSTAAsattvamiti bhedadvayaM siddhyati / saviappaNibviyappaM [1/35] ityAdisiddhasavikalpakatvanirvikalpakatvabhaGgadvayopAdAne prakRtasaptabhaGgImupakramya dharmAntarasaptabhaGgIsAdhane'rthAntararUpanigrahasthAnaprasaGgAdityasmAkamanekAntavyavasthAdau manISonmeSaH / 2010_02

Page #129
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-42-43 __ [ kevalaparyAyArthikanayasya matamupadarya tasyApUrNatvAbhidhAnam ] idAnIM paraspararUpAparityAgapravRttasaMgrahAdinayaprAdurbhUtatathAvidhA eva vAkyanayAstathAvidhArthapratipAdakA ityetat pratipAdya anyathAbhyupagame teSAmapyadhyakSavirodhato'bhAva evetyetadupadarzanAya kevalAnAM teSAM tAvanmatamupanyasyati jaha daviyamappiyaM taM taheva asthi tti pajjavaNayassa / Na ya sa samayapanavaNA pajjavaNayamettapaDipuNNA / / 42 / / yathA vartamAnakAlasambandhitayA yad dravyamarpitaM pratipAdayitumabhISTaM tat tathaivAsti nAnyathA-anutpanna-vinaSTatayA bhAvi-bhUtayoravidyamAnatvenApratipatteH apratIyamAnayoSTA pratipAdayitumazakteratiprasaGgAd vartamAnasambandhina eva tasya pratIteH iti paryAyArthikanayavAkyasyAbhiprAyaH / etad anekAntavAdI dUSayitumAha - na iti pratiSedhe, sa iti tathAvidho vAkyanayaH parAmRzyate samaya iti samyaga Iyate paricchidyata iti samayo'rthastasya prajJApanA prarUpaNA paryAyanayamAne dravyanayanirapekSe paryAyanaye pratipUrNA puSkalA sampadyate / na sa vAkyanayaH samyagarthapratyAyanAM pUrayatIti yAvat paryAyanayasya sAvadhAraNaikAntapratipAdana-rUpasyAdhyakSabAdhanAt tapTAdhAM cAgrataH pratipAdayiSyati / / 42 / / [S.T.P.449] [ kevaladravyArthikanayamatasya pradarzanam ] dravyArthikavAkyanaye'pyayameva nyAya iti tadabhiprAyaM tAvadAha paDipuNNajobvaNaguNo jaha lajjai bAlabhAvacarieNa / kuNai ya guNapaNihANaM aNAgayasuhovahANatthaM / / 43 / / prAptayauvanaguNaH puruSo lajjate bAlabhAvasaMvRttAtmIyAnuSThAnasmaraNAt 'pUrvamahamapyaspRzyasaMsparzAdivyavahAramanuSThitavAn' yathA ityudAharaNArtho gAthAyAmupanyastaH yathaiva tato'tItavarttamAnayorekatvamavasIyate / karoti ca guNeSu utsAhAdiSu praNidhAnamaikAgryam anAgataM yat sukhaM tasyopadhAnaM prAptistasyai tadartham 'mayaitasmAt sukhasAdhanAt sukhamAptavyam' iti / yatapTauvamato'nAgata-vartamAnayoraikyam / / 43 / / [S.T.P.449] 2010_02

Page #130
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-44 -: zAstravArtAsamaccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAm, stabaka-7 na cApyabheda evetyAha yuvaiva na ca vRddho'pi nAnyArthaM ceSTanaM ca tat / anvayAdimayaM vastu tadabhAvo'nyathA bhavet / / 30 / / na ca yuvaiva vRddho'pi sarvathA vRddhaparyAyApanna eva, 'idAnImayaM yuvA na vRddhaH' iti pratIteH / na ca tatkAle tatra yUni tatsaMtAnIyavRddhabheda eva, yato'nyArthaM saMtAnAntaravRddhavat na ca ceSTanaM kAyavyApArarUpam / tat tasmAt, vastu anvayAdimayam, AdinA vyatirekagrahAdanvaya-vyatirekazabalam, anyathA tadabhAvaH adhikRtavastvabhAvo bhavet, sarvathA'satsadbhAvavirodhAt / tadidamuktaM sammatikRtA paDipunnajovvaNaguNo jaha lajjai bAlabhAvacarieNa / kuNai ya guNapaNihANaM aNAgayasuhovahANatthaM / / 1/43 / / Na ya hoi jovvaNattho bAlo anno vi lajjai na teNa / Na vi a aNAgayatagguNapasAhaNaM jujai vibhatte / / 1/44 / / iti / [ kevaladravyArthikanayamatasyApyapUrNatvamiti pradarzanena vastuno bhedAbhedarUpatvasUcanam ] atrApi mate yathAvasthitavastusvarUpaprarUpaNA na pratipUryata iti sUtrAntareNa darzayati__Na ya hoi jovvaNattho bAlo aNNo vi lajjai Na teNa / Na vi ya aNAgayavayaguNapasAhaNaM jujjai vibhatte / / 44 / / na ca bhavati yauvanasthaH puruSo bAlaH api tvanya eva anyo'pi na lajjate bAlacaritena puruSAntaravat tenAnanyaH / nApyanAgatavRddhAvasthAyAM sukhaprasAdhanArthamutsAhastasya yujyate atyantAbhede / etadevAha-vibhakta iti vibhaktirbhedaH / akAraprazleSAd avibhakte bhedAbhAve'vicalitasvarUpatayA tatprasAdhakaguNayatnAsambhavAt / tasmAnnA'bhedamAtraM tattvam kathaJcidredavyavahRtipratibhAsabAdhitatvAt / nApi bhedamAtram ekatvavyavahArapratipattinirAkRtatvAditi bhedAbhedAtmakaMtattvamabhyupagantavyam anyathA sakalavyavahArocchedaprasaktiH / / 44 / / [S.T.P.450] 1-aNAgayavayaguNa0 (saMmati.) / 2-aNAgayatagguNa0 (syA. kalpa.) / ___ 2010_02

Page #131
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa -1, gAthA- 45-46 [ puruSadRSTAnte bhedAbhedAtmakatvapariNatirbAhyapratyakSeNa siddheti pradarzanam ] evamabhedabhedAtmakasya puruSatattvasya yathA atItAnAgatadoSaguNanindAbhyupagamAbhyAM sambandhaH tathaiva bhedAbhedAtmakasya tasya sambandhAdibhiryoga iti dRSTAntadAntikopasaMhArArthamAhajAi-kula- rUva-lakkhaNa- saNNA - saMbaMdhao ahigayassa / bAlAibhAvadiTThavigayassa jaha tassa saMbaMdhI / / 45 / / 86 jAtiH puruSatvAdikA, kulaM pratiniyatapuruSajanyatvam, rUpaM cakSurgrAhyatvalakSaNam, lakSaNaM tilakAdi sukhAdisUcakam, saMjJA pratiniyatazabdAbhidheyatvam, ebhiryaH sambandhastadAtmapariNAmaH tatastamAzritya adhigatasya jJAnasya (jJAtasya) tadAtmakatvenAbhinnAvabhAsaviSayasya yadvA sambandho janyajanakabhAvaH ebhiradhigatasya tatsvabhAvasyaikAtmakasyeti yAvat bAlAdibhAvairdRSTairvigatasya tairutpAdavigamAtmakasya tathA bhedapratItestasya yathA tasya sambandho bhedAbhedapariNatirUpo bhedAbhedAtmakatvapratipatterbAhyAdhyakSaH / / 45 / / [S.T.P.450] [ AdhyAtmikapratyakSato'pi tatra dRSTAnte yathA bhedAbhedAtmakatvasiddhistathA dAntike jIve'pi tadyojanam ] AdhyAtmikAdhyakSato'pi tathApratItestathArUpaM tad vastviti pratipAdayannAha dRSTAntadAntikopasaMhAradvAreNa tehiM atItANAgayadosaguNadugaMchaNa'bbhuvagamehiM / taha baMdha - mokkha - suha - dukkhapatthaNA hoi jIvassa ||46 || tAbhyAmatItAnAgatadoSa- guNajugupsA -'bhyupagamAbhyAM yathA bhedAbhedAtmakasya puruSatvasya siddhiH tathA dArSTAntike'pi ' taha baMdha - mokkha- suha- dukkhapatthaNA hoi jIvassa' iti tathA bandha-mokSa- sukha-duHkhaprArthanA tatsAdhanopAdAnaparityAgadvAreNa bhedAbhedAtmakasyaiva jIvadravyasya bhavati bAlAdyAtmakapuruSadravyavat / na ca jIvasya pUrvottarabhavAnubhaviturabhAvAt bandha-mokSabhAvAbhAvaH utpAda-vyaya- dhrauvyAtmakasya tasyAnAdyanantasya prasAdhitatvAt / / 46 / / [S.T.P.451] 2010_02

Page #132
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 1, gAthA- 47 etadevAha [ jala- dugdhadRSTAntena jIva- karmaNoravibhAgakathanam ] aNNoNANugANaM 'imaM va taM va' tti vibhayaNamajuttaM / jaha duddha - pANiyANaM jAvaMta visesapajjAyA / / 47 / / anyonyAnugatayoH parasparAnupraviSTayoH Atma-karmaNoH 'idaM vA tad vA' iti 'idaM karma ayamAtmA' iti yad vibhajanaM pRthakkaraNaM tad ayuktam aghaTamAnakam, pramANAbhAvena karttumazakyatvAt / yathA dugdha-pAnIyayoH parasparapradezAnupraviSTayoH / kiMpariNAmo'yamavibhAgo jIvakarmapradezayoH ? ityAha- yAvanto vizeSaparyAyAstAvAn / ataH paramavastutvaprasakteH antyavizeSaparyantatvAt sarvavizeSANAm ' antya' iti vizeSaNAnyathAnupapatteH / / 47 / / [S.T.P. 452] -: zAstravArttAsamuccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAm, stabaka- 3, gAthA- 42 87 iyaM ca dehasparzAdisaMvittiSTA anyonyavyAptijA guDazuNThIdravyayoriva zarIrA''tmanorjAtyantaratApattiprabhavA, pratipratikaM tadanubhavAt, ekAbhAve'pyabhAvAcca / yuktaM caitat, avibhAgadarzanAt, naratvAderekaniSThatve'tiprasaGgAt, vyAsajyavRttitve ca parasyApasiddhAntaH, vyAsajyavRttijAtyanabhyupagamAt, ekAzrayatvAnubhavavirodhAt, zarIrA'pratyakSe'pyandhakAre naratvapratItyanupapatteSTA / tadidamAha bhagavAn sammatikAraH 2010_02 gANaM imaM va taM vatti vibhayaNamajuttaM / jaha duddha-pANiyANaM jAvaMta visesapajjAyA / / [1/47] / / anyonyAnugatayorAtma-karmaNordugdha-pAnIyayoriva yAvanto vizeSapayAryAstAvatsu idaM vA tad vA iti' vibhajanamayuktam, pramANAbhAvAt / -: dvAdazAranayacakre : Araka-8 paramArthatastu vAdaparamezvaravAda evAyam / kasmAt ? ekaikadravyAnantaparyAyatvAdasmanmatameva, ahaM

Page #133
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-48 hi tvayaiva saha virudhye na vAdaparamezvareNa / tena ca saha ko virodhaH ? tasya hi matam-ekaikaM dravyamanantaparyAyam, sApekSanirapekSASTA pariNAmAH paryAyAH zaktaya ityucyante, dravyANi cAnyonyAnugatazaktitvAt sarvazaktIni / yathAha [sammatau] - aNNoNNANugatANaM imaM va taM va tti vibhayaNamayuttaM / jadha duddha-pANiyANaM jAvaMta visesapajAyA / / [1/47] -: dravyaguNaparyAyano rAsa : DhAla-13, gAthA-10 e bhAvi saMmati bhaNiuM re, anugata artha asesa. jala-paya jima navi vibhajiI re, yAvata aMtya vizeso re. 218 catu20 meM mAvi-se abhiprAya, sammati aMthamaifB 36 , 4-anuta-satyaMta saMbaddha, mazeSa dii-sava, artha, 48:5ya:bhi-bhAra:nIra: pari, vimAna - pRtha: 27 nahI. Beitis aMtya vizeSa-zuddha purAta: 94: sakSa- vimA. yathA-218 "audArikAdivargaNAniSpannAccharIrAderzAnadhanAsaMkhyeyapradeza AtmA bhinnaH" iti / atra gAthA aNNoNNANugayANaM imaM va taM va' tti vibhayaNamajuttaM / jaha duddha-pANiyANaM jAvaMta visesapajAyA / / 1/47 iti / / 218. [jIva-karmaNoranyonyAnupravezena tadAzritajJAnAdi-rUpAdInAmapi parasparAnupravezavarNanam] jIva-karmaNoranyonyAnupraveze tadAzritAnAmanyonyAnupraveza ityAha rUAipajjavA je dehe jIvadaviyammi suddhammi / te aNNoNNANugayA paNNavaNijjA bhavatthammi / / 4 / / rUpa-rasa-gandha-sparzAdayo ye paryAyA dehAzritA jIvadravye vizuddhasvarUpe ca ye jJAnAdayaste'nyonyAnugatA jIve rUpAdayo dehe jJAnAdaya iti prarUpaNIyA bhavasthe saMsAriNi akAraprazleSAd vA asaMsAriNi / na ca saMsArAvasthAyAM dehAtmanoranyonyAnubandhAt rUpAdibhistadvyapadezaH muktyavasthAyAM tu tadabhAvAt nAsau yukta iti vaktavyam, tadavasthAyAmapi 2010_02

Page #134
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-48-49 dehAdyAzritarUpAdigrahaNapariNatajJAna-darzanaparyAyadvAreNAtmanastathAvidhatvAt tathAvyapadezasambhavAt AtmapudgalayopTA rUpAdi-jJAnAdInAmanyonyAnupravezAt kathaJcid ekatvam anekatvaM ca, mUrttatvam amUrttatvaM cAvyatirekAt siddhamiti / / 48 / / [S.T.P.453] -: zAstravArtAsamuccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAm stabaka-3, gA. 42 evaM tarhi jJAnAdayo'pi dehe syuH, deharUpAdayo'pyAtmanIti cet ? iSTApattiH / tadAha [sammatau] rUvAipajavA je dehe jIvadaviyammi suddhammi / te aNNoNNANugayA paNNavaNijjA bhavatthammi / / 1/48 / / iti / 'gauro'haM jAnAmi' ityAdidhiyastathaivopapatteH, rUpAdi-jJAnAdInAmanyo'nyAnupravezena kathaJcidekatvA-'nekatva-mUrtatvAdisamAvezAt / ata eva daNDAtmAdInAmekatvamanekatvaM ca sthAnAGge vyavasthitam / tadAha [sammatau] - "evaM ege AyA, ege daMDe a hoi kiriyA ya / karaNaviseseNa ya tivihajogasiddhI va aviruddhA / / 1/49 / / [ parasparAnupravezAdAtma-pudgalayoH kathaJcidekatvasyAnekatvasya copapAdanam ] etadevAha evaM "ege AyA ege daMDe ya hoi kiriyA ya" / karaNaviseseNa ya tivihajogasiddhI vi aviruddhA / / 49 / / evaM ityanantaroditaprakAreNa mano-vAk-kAyadravyANAmAtmanyanupravezAt Atmaiva na tadvyatiriktAsta iti tRtIyAGkasthAne "ege AyA" (sthAnA0 sU0 2 pR0 10) iti prathamasUtrapratipAditaH siddhaH eka AtmA eko daNDa eka kriyeti bhavati mano-vAk-kAyeSu daNDakriyAzabdau pratyekamabhisambandhanIyau karaNavizeSeNa ca mano-vAk-kAyasvarUpeNAtmanyanupravezAvAptatrividhayogasvarUpatvAt trividhayogasiddhirapi AtmanaH aviruddhaiveti ekasya 1-vi (saMmati.) / 2-va (syA. kalpa.) / 2010_02

Page #135
90 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-49-50 satastasya trividhayogAtmakatvAt anekAntarUpatA vyavasthitaiva / na cAnyonyAnupravezAt ekAtmakatve bAhyAbhyantaravibhAgAbhAva iti antarharSaviSAdAdyanekavivarttAtmakamekaM caitanyam, bahirbAla-kumAra-yauvanAdyanekAvasthaikAtmakamekaM zarIramadhyakSataH saMvedyata ityasya virodhaH bAhyAbhyantaravibhAgAbhAve'pi nimittAntarataH tadvyapadezasambhavAt / / 49 / / [S.T.P.453] [ Atma-pudgalayorvastuto bAhyAbhyantaravibhAgAbhAve'pyabhyantaravyapadezasya manonimittakatvena samarthanam ] | etadevAha Na ya bAhirao bhAvo abbhaMtarao ya asthi samayammi / NoiMdiyaM puNa paDDaJca hoi abbhaMtaraviseso / / 5 / / Atma-pudgalayoranyonyAnupravezAt uktaprakAreNa arhatpraNItazAsane na bAhyo bhAvaH abhyantaro vA saMbhavati mUrttAmUrtarUpAditayA'nekAntAtmakatvAt saMsArodayavartinaH sakalavastunaH / abhyantaraH iti vyapadezastu noindriyaM manaH pratItya tasyAtmapariNatirUpasya parApratyakSatvAt zarIra-vAcoriva / [S.T.P.453] - zAstravArtAsamuccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAm stabaka-3 gAthA-42 nanvevamantaharSa-viSAdAdyanekavivartAtmakamekaM caitanyam, bahirbAla-kumAra-yauvanAdyanekAvasthAtmakamekaM zarIramadhyakSataH saMvedyata ityasya virodhaH, bAhyA-'bhyantaravibhAgAbhAvAditi cet ? satyam, AtmabhinnatvAbhyAM tadvyapadezAd / tadAha [sammatau] - Na ya bAhirao bhAvo abhaMtarao a atthi samayammi / NoiMdiyaM puNa paDuzca hoi abbhaMtaraviseso / / [1/50] sarvasyaiva mUrtA'mUrttAdirUpatayA'nekAntAtmakatvAt 'ayaM bAhyaH, ayaM cAbhyantaraH' iti samaye na vAstavo vibhAgaH / abhyantara iti vyapadezastu noindriyaM manaH pratItya, tasyA''tmapariNatirUpasya parA'pratyakSatvAt, zarIra-vAcoriva / na ca tadvadeva tasya parapratyakSatvApattiH, indriyajJAnasyA _ 2010_02

Page #136
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-51 zeSapadArthasvarUpagrAhakatvA'yogAt / evaM ca syAdvAdoktireva yuktA na tu parasparanirapekSanayoktirvinA / zrotRdhIparikarmaNAnimittam, vastuno'nekAntAtmakatvAt / tadAha [sammatau] - davvaTThiyassa AyA baMdhai kammaM phalaM ca veei / biiyassa bhAvamettaM Na kuNai Na ya koi veei / / [1/51] davvaTThiyassa jo ceva kuNai so ceva veyae niyamA / aNNo karei aNNo paribhuMjai pajjavaNayassa / / [1/52] je vayaNijjaviappA saMjujaMtesu hoti eesu / / sA sasamayapaNNavaNA titthayarAsAyaNA aNNA / / [1/53] purisajjAyaM tu paDuca jANao paNNavija aNNayaraM / parikammaNAnimittaM dAehI so visesaMpi / / [1/54] tasmAd dehAtmano'nyonyavyAptijaiva dehasparzAdisaMvittiriti siddham / iti hetoH, bandhAdi saGgataM yuktam, kAryAnyathAnupapatteH / / 42 / / [ nirapekSayordravyAstika-paryAyAstikayormatena yathA yathA karmabandhastatphalaprarUpaNA bhavati tathopavarNanam ] asya ca mithyAtvAdipariNativazopAttapudagalAGgAGgibhAvalakSaNo bandhaH tadvazopanatasukhaduHkhAdyanubhavasvarUpapTA bhogaH anekAntAtmakatve satyupapadyate anyathA tayorayoga iti pratipAdanArthamAha-davvaTThiyassa ityAdi / athavA parasparasApekSadravyAstika-paryAyAstikayoH prarUpaNA pradarzitanyAyena sambhavinI, nirapekSayoH kathaM sA ? ityAha - davvaTThiyassa AyA baMdhai kammaM phalaM ca veei / bIyassa bhAvamettaM Na kuNai Na ya koi veei / / 51 / / dravyAstikasyeyaM prarUpaNA-AtmA ekaH sthAyI karma jJAnAdivibandhakaM banAti svIkaroti tasya karmaNaH phalaM ca kAryarUpaM vedayate bhuGkte Atmaiva / dvitIyasya tu paryAyArthikasyeyaM 2010_02

Page #137
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-52-53 prarUpaNA-naivAtmA sthAyyasti kintu bhAvamAtraM vijJAnamAtramiti na karoti na ca kaSTiAd vedayate utpattikSaNAnantaradhvaMsinaH kartRtvA'nubhavitRtvAyogAt / / 51 / / [S.T.P.455] tatheyamapi tayostathAbhUtayoH prarUpaNetyAha davaTThiyassa jo ceva kuNai so ceva veyae NiyamA / aNNo karei aNNo paribhuMjai pajjavaNayassa / / 52 / / ya eva karoti sa eva vedayate nityatvAt dravyAstikasyaitanmatam / anyaH karotyanyaSTA bhuGkte kSaNikatvAt paryAyanayasya / nanu pUrvagAthoktameva punarabhidadhatA piSTapeSaNamAcAryeNa kRtaM bhavet, na; utpattisamanantaradhvastena karaNam bhogo vA sambhavIti prAk pratipAditam iha tu utpattikSaNa eva karttA tadanantarakSaNaSTA bhokteti na punaruktatA / uktaM ca paraiH-"bhUtiryeSAM kriyA saiva kArakaM saiva vocyate" [ ] iti / / 52 / / [S.L.P.455] [ sApekSanayadvayAzritAnAmeva kathaMcitpadAGkitAnAM vacasAM svasamayaprarUpaNAtvaM nAnyeSAmityabhidhAnam ] iyamasaMyuktayoranayoH svasamayaprarUpaNA na bhavati yA tu svasamayaprarUpaNA tAmAha je vayaNijjaviyappA saMjujjaMtesu honti eesu / sA sasamayapaNNavaNA 'titthayarA''sAyaNA aNNA / / 53 / / ye vacanIyasyAbhidheyasya vikalpAstatpratipAdakA abhidhAnabhedAH saMyujyamAnayoranyonyasambaddhayorbhavantyanayordravyAstika-paryAyAstikavAkyanayayoH / te ca-'kathaJcinnitya AtmA kathaJcidamUrtaH' ityevamAdayaH / sA eSA svasamayasyeti tadarthasya prajJApanA nidarzanA anyA tu nirapekSayoranayoreva nayayoryA prarUpaNA sA tIrthakarasyAsAdanA'dhikSepaH / "egamegeNaM jIvassa eese aNaMtehiM NANAvaraNijjapoggalehiM AveDhiyapaveDhie" [ ] iti tIrthakRdvacane pramANopapanne satyapi 1-siddhantavirAhaNA (nayo.) | 2010_02

Page #138
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-53 93 "nAmUrtaM mUrttatAmeti mUrtaM nAyAtyamUrttatAm / . dravyaM kAlatraye'pItthaM cyavate nAtmarUpataH" / / [ ] iti / tIrthakRnmatamevaitannayavAdanirapekSamiti kaiSTiAt pratipAdayadbhistasyAdhikSepapradAnAt / / 53 / |S.T.P.456] -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : saptabhaGgasvarUpavarNane, patra-15 ete ca nayAH pratyakSAdisthale'jahadvRttyaikopayogarUpatayA sApekSAH pramANatAmAskandanti, zabdasthale ca sAkAGkSakhaNDavAkyajasaptabhaGgyAtmakamahAvAkyarUpAH pramANam, na nirapekSAH, taduktaM sammatau je vayaNijjaviyappA, saMjujaMtesu hoti eesu / sA sasamayapaNNavaNA, tittharA''sAyaNA aNNA / / 1/53 / / ye vacanIyasyAbhidheyasya vikalpAstatpratipAdakA abhidhAnabhedAH, saMyujyamAnayoranyonyasambaddhayorbhavanti, anayordravyAstikaparyAyAstikanayavAkyayoH, te ca 'kathaJcinnitya AtmA' 'kathaJcidanitya' ityevamAdayaH / saiSA, svasamayasya tattvArthasya, prajJApanA nidarzanA, anyA nirapekSanayaprarUpaNA tIrthakarasyAzAtanA adhikSepaH, tatprarUpaNottIrNatvAt / - nayopadeza: :kutastarhi vaizeSikadarzanamutpannaM kathaM vA tanna samyagityAkAGkSAyAmAha dvAbhyAM nayAbhyAmunnItamapi zAstraM kaNAzinA / __ anyo'nyanirapekSatvAnmithyAtvaM svamatAgrahAt / / 118 / / nayAmRta0-dvAbhyAmiti / dvAbhyAM sAmAnya-vizeSagrAhibhyAM saGgraha-vyavahArAbhyAM nayAbhyAm, unnItaM pRthag vyavasthApitamapi, kaNAzinA kaNAdamuninA, zAstram, anyo'nyanirapekSatvAt parasparadvayAvalambanameva zAstrasya samyaktvaprayojakam, kintu yathAsthAne tadviniyogaH sa ca svaprayuktabhaGgaviviktadravya-paryAyobhayAvagAhitvAt, svamatAgrahAt svakalpanAbhinivezAt, mithyAtvam, nahi nayadvayetarayAvadbhaGgAnAM syAdvAdalAJchitAnAM parasparasAkAGkSANAM tAtparyaviSayatayA sampadyate, ekatarasyApyatAtparya siddhAntavirAdhanayA aparihArAt, tadAha [sammatau] - _ 2010_02

Page #139
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA-54 "je vayaNijjaviappA saMjujjantesu honti eesu / sA sasamayapannavaNA 'siddhantavirAhaNA aNNA / / " 1/53 / / [ syAdvAdazaH adhikArivizeSa sati nirapekSanayadvayAzritAnyapi vAMsi prayuJjAno na doSabhAgiti prathanam ] parasparanirapekSayoranayoH prajJApanA tIrthakarAsAdanA ityasyApavAdamAha purisajjAyaM tu paDuca jANao paNNavejja aNNayaraM / parikammaNANimittaM dAehI so visesaM pi / / 54 / / puruSajAtaM pratipannadravyaparyAyAntarasvarUpam zrotAraM vA pratItya Azritya jJakaH syAdvAdavit prajJApayet AcakSIta anyatarat paryAyam dravyaM vA-abhyupetaparyAyAya dravyameva, aGgIkRtadravyAya ca paryAyameva kathayet / kimityekameva kathayet ? parikarmanimittaM buddhisaMskArArtham / parikarmitamataye darzayiSyatyasau syAdvAdAbhijJaH vizeSamapi dravya-paryAyayoH parasparAvi nirbhAgarUpamekAMzaviSayavijJAnasyAnyathA viparyayarUpatAprasaktiH syAt taditarAbhAve tadviSayasyApyabhAvAt / / 54 / / iti tattvabodhavidhAyinyAM sammatiTIkAyAM prathamakANDam / / [S.T.P.456] -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : saptabhaGgasvarUpavarNane, patra-65 utsargataH syAdvAdadezanAyA eva tIrthakareNa vihitatvAd' 'vibhajavAyaM ca viyAgarijjA' ityAdyAgamavacanopalambhAt / puruSavizeSamapekSyApavAdatastvekanayadezanAyAmapi na doSaH, tadAha sammatau purisajjAyaM tu paDuJca jANao pannaveja annayaraM / parikammaNANimittaM, ThAehi so visesaM pi / / 1/54 / / puruSajAtaM pratipannadravyaparyAyAnyatarasvarUpaM zrotAraM pratItya Azritya, jJakaH syAdvAdavid, prajJApayedanyataradajJAtaM parikarmanimittama, ajJAtAMzasaMskArapATavArtham, tataH parikarmitamataye 1-titthayarAsAyaNA (saMmati.) / 2-ThAehi (ane. vya.) / 3-dAehI (saMmati.) / 2010_02

Page #140
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-1, gAthA- 54 sthApayiSyatyasau syAdvAdavizeSamapi parasparA'vinirbhAgarUpam, tataSToyamekanayadezanApi bhAvataH syAdvAdadezanaiveti phalitam / / taduktaM vAdinaiva [sammatau ] " purisajjAyaM tu pahuca jANao paNNavijja annayaraM / parikammaNAnimittaM dAAhehI so visesaM pi" / / 1 / 54 / / tti, nayopadeze gAthA - 6 pramANavAkyamapi hyanekAntarucizAlinaM puruSavizeSamadhikRtyaiva prayujyate, tadanayordvayorapi kAraNikatve prApte svasvakAle utsargikatvameva nyAyasiddham, vipratisiddhakAraNavidhisthale tathAvyutpatteH, tasmAt 'syAjjJAnAdilakSaNo jIvaH' ityapi sunayavAkyameva ekabhaGgarUpatvAt, pramANavAkyatA tatrApyutthApyAkAGkSAkrameNa bhaGgaSaTkasaMyojanayaiva / uktasUtra eva prativacane prAha -: upadezahasyam : iha vibhajjavAo ANatto Na ya niruddhapatthAro / eyaM kahamaviruddhaM, bhannai soAramahigicca / / 99 / / nanviha-'saMkijjayA' ityAdisUtre, vibhajyavAdaH syAdvAdaH AjJaptaH sarvatra bhASitumanujJAtaH, tathA niruddhaprastAraH-stokArthavistaraSTA nAnujJAtaH, etaddvayaM kathamaviruddham ? syAdvAdaprakAzane vistarAvazyaMbhAvAt ? bhaNyate - pratyuttaraM vidhIyate; zrotAraM zrotRvizeSaM adhikRtyAviruddhametat nikhilanayacaturaM prapaJcitajJaM pratipattAramuddizya vistareNa syAdvAdapratipAdanAt, ekataranayapriyaM ca tamuddizya syAdvAdapratipattiyogyatAmAdhAtuM stokapratipAdanAttadAnImapi syAdvAdapratipAdanayogyatAyA anapAyAt, tathA cAha sammatikAra: purisajjAyaM tu paDuca jANao pannavejja aNNayaraM / parikammaNANimittaM dAhehI so visesaMpi / / 1 / 54 / / 2010_02 95 evaM zrotRbhedena syAdvAdapratipAdane bhajanApi bhavet tatparijJAnaM vinA tu samyaktvamapi na vyavatiSThata iti / "

Page #141
saMmatitarkagranthe * kva siddhasenastutayo mahArthA azikSitAlApakalA kva caiSA / / tathApi yUthAdhipateH pathasthaH skhaladgatistasya zizurna zocyaH / / - anyayogavyavacchedadvAtriMzikA / / NRS * zrI siddhasena-haribhadrapramukhAH prasiddhAH, te sUrayo mayi bhavantu kRtaprasAdAH / yeSAM vimRzya satataM vividhAn nibandhAn; zAstraM cikIrSati tanupratibho'pi mAdRk / / - syAdvAdaratnAkare, vAdidevasUrimahArAjA / / * tamaHstomaM sa hantu zrIsiddhasenadivAkaraH / yasyodaye sthitaM mukairUlUkairiva vAdibhiH / / - A. pradyumnasUrimahArAjA / / * dravyAnuyogaH pUrvANi sammatyAdikazca / - AcArAMgasUtraTIkA, pR. 1 / / *darzanaprabhAvakairvA sammatyAdibhiH / nijAma - AcArAMgasUtraTIkA, pR. 249 / / / 2010_02 |

Page #142
rAjagacchIya-tarkapaJcAnana- zrImadabhayadevasUrinirmita tattvabodhavidhAyinyAkhyAyAH vyAkhyAyAH mUlagAthAsparzivyAkhyAMzasahitaM katipayamUlagAthAnAM ca vibhinnagrantheSu tattadgranthakAraiH kAritAbhirvRttibhiryuktaM mahAdArzanikaziromaNivikramAdityAdinRpatipratibodhaka zrIsiddhasenadivAkararacitaM saMmatitarka-prakaraNam / dvitIyakANDaH / [ 1 upayoganirUpaNam ] [ vyastayordarzana- jJAnayoH lakSaNamabhidhAya dravyAstika-paryAyAstikAbhyAM tayoH svabhAvasya vibhajya varNanam ] evamarthAbhidhAnarUpajJeyasya sAmAnya - vizeSarUpatayA dvayAtmakatvaM pratipAdya 'ye vacanIyavikalpAH saMyujyamAnayoranayornayayorbhavanti sA svasamayaprajJApanA'nyathA tu sA tIrthakRdAsAdanA ' iti yaduktam tadeva prapaJcayitum 'upayogo'pi parasparasavyapekSasAmAnya-vizeSagrahaNapravRttadarzanajJAnasvarUpadvayAtmakaH pramANam, darzana-jJAnaikAntarUpastvapramANam' iti darzayituM prakaraNa - mArabhamANo dravyArthika-paryAyArthikAbhimatapratyekadarzana-jJAnasvarUpapratipAdikAM gAthAmAhAcAryaHjaM sAmaNNaggahaNaM daMsaNameyaM visesiyaM NANaM / doha vi NayANa eso pADekkaM atthapajjAo / / 1 / / dravyAstikasya sAmAnyameva vastu tadeva gRhyate aneneti grahaNaM darzanametad ucyate, paryAyAstikasya tu vizeSa eva vastu sa eva gRhyate yena tat jJAnam abhidhIyate grahaNam vizeSitam iti vizeSagrahaNamityabhiprAyaH / dvayorapi anayornayayoreSa pratyekamarthaparyAyaH artha viSayaM paryeti avagacchati yaH so'rthaparyAyaH IdRgbhUtArthagrAhakatvamityarthaH / [ upayogasya sAkArAnAkArate spaSTayitvA tayoH prAmANyA'prAmANyakathaMtAbhidhAnam ] upayogasya cAnAkAra-sAkArate sAmAnya-vizeSagrAhakate eva tatra tatrAbhidhIyete / avidyamAna AkAraH bhedo grAhyasya asyetyanAkAraM darzanamucyate / saha AkArairgrAhyabhedairvarttate yad grAhakaM tat 2010_02

Page #143
98 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-2 sAkAraM jJAnamityucyate / nirAkAra-sAkAropayogau tUpasarjanIkRtataditarAkArau svaviSayAvabhAsakatvena pravartamAno pramANam na tu nirastetarAkArau, tathAbhUtavasturUpaviSayAbhAvena nirviSayatayA pramANatvAnupapatteritarAMzavikalaikAMzarUpopayogasattAnupapatteSTA / tenaikAntavAdyabhyupagamaH 'bodhamAtraM pramANam sAkAro bodho'nadhigatArthAdhigantRtvaviziSTaH sa eva jJAtRvyApAro'rthadRSTatAkhyaphalAnumeyaH saMvedanAkhyaphalAnumeyo vA anadhigatArthAdhigantA indriyAdisaMpAdyaH avyabhicArAdivizeSaNaviziSTArthopalabdhijanikA sAmagrI tadekadezo vA bodharUpo'bodharUpo vA sAdhakatamatvAt pramANam' ityAdirUpo'yuktaH / / 1 || [S.T.P.458] [ darzanaviSayIbhUtasya prameyasya na vizeSAkAreNa zUnyatvam na vA jJAnaviSayIbhUtasya sAmAnyAkAreNa iti nirUpaNam ] sAmAnyavizeSAtmake ca pramANaprameyarUpe vastutattve vyavasthite dravyAstikasyAlocanamAtraM vizeSAkAratyAgi darzanaM yat tat satyam, itarasya tu vizeSAkAraM sAmAnyAkArarahitaM yad jJAnaM tadeva pAramArthikamabhipretam 'pratyekameSo'rthaparyAyaH' iti vacanAt / pramANaM tu dravyaparyAyau darzanajJAnasvarUpAvanyonyAvinirbhAgavartinAviti darzayannAha davvaDhio vi hoUNa daMsaNe pajjavaTThio hoi / uvasamiyAIbhAvaM paDuJca NANe u vivarIyaM / / 2 / / asyAstAtparyArthaH-darzane'pi vizeSAMzo na nivRttaH nApi jJAne sAmAnyAMza iti / dravyAstiko'pi iti AtmA dravyArtharUpaH sa bhUtvA darzane sAmAnyAtmake sa hyAtmA cetanAlokamAtrasvabhAvo bhUtvA tadaiva paryAyAstiko vizeSAkAro'pi bhavati / yadA hi vizeSarUpatayA''tmA saMpadyate tadA sAmAnyasvabhAvamaparityajanneva vizeSAkArapTA vizeSAvagamasvabhAvaM jJAnaM darzane sAmAnyaparyAlocane pravRtto'pyupAttajJAnAkAraH, na hi viziSTena rUpeNa vinA sAmAnyaM saMbhavati / etadevAha-aupazamikAdibhAvaM pratItya iti aupazamika-kSAyikakSAyopazamikAdIn bhAvAn apekSya vizeSarUpatvena jJAnasvabhAvAd vaiparItyaM sAmAnyarUpatAM pratipadyate vizeSarUpaH san sa eva sAmAnyarUpo'pi bhavati, na hyasti sAmAnyaM vizeSavikalaM vastutvAt zibakAdivikalamRttvavat vizeSA vA sAmAnyavikalA na santi asAmAnyatvAd mRttvarahitazibakAdivat / / 2 / / [S.T.P.596] ___ 2010_02

Page #144
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-3 [ upayogasvAbhAvyAdeva chAdmasthikayoni-darzanayoH kramavartitvam, na punaH kevaligatayostayoH sahavartitvAd iti pratipAdanam ] atra ca sAmAnyavizeSAtmake prameyavastuni tadgrAhi pramANamapi darzanajJAnarUpaM tathApi cchadmasthopayogasvAbhAvyAt kadAcid jJAnopasarjano darzanopayogaH kadAcittu darzanopasarjano jJAnopayoga iti krameNa darzanajJAnopayogI, kSAyike tu jJAnadarzane yugapadvartinI iti darzayannAha sUriH maNapajjavaNANaMto NANassa ya darisaNassa ya viseso / kevalaNANaM puNa daMsaNaM ti NANaM ti ya samANaM / / 3 / / manaHparyAyajJAnamantaH paryavasAnaM yasya vizleSasya sa tathokto jJAnasya ca darzanasya ca vizleSaH pRthagbhAvo matyAdiSu caturSu jJAnadarzanopayogau krameNa bhavata iti yAvat / tathAhicakSuracakSuravadhijJAnAni cakSuracakSuravadhidarzanebhyaH pRthakkAlAni chadmasthopayogAtmakajJAnatvAt zruta-manaHparyAyajJAnavat / vAkyArthavizeSaviSayaM zrutajJAnam, manodravyavizeSAlambanaM ca manaHparyAyajJAnam etaddvayamapi adarzanasvabhAvaM matyavadhijJAnadarzanopayogAd bhinnakAlaM siddham / kevalajJAnaM punaH kevalAkhyo bodho darzanamiti vA jJAnamiti vA yat kevalaM tat samAnaM samAnakAlaM dvayamapi yugapadeveti bhAvaH / tathAhi-ekakAlau kevaligatajJAnadarzanopayogI tathAbhUtApratihatAvirbhUtatatsvabhAvatvAt tathAbhUtAdityaprakAzatApAviva yadaiva kevalI jAnAti tadaiva pazyatIti sUrerabhiprAyaH / / 3 / / [S.T.P. 596] ___- jJAnabinduH :chAdmasthikajJAnadarzanayoreva kramavartitvametaJca tattvaM sayuktikaM sammatigAthAbhireva pradarzayAmaH / "maNapajjavanANaMto nANassa ya darisaNassa ya viseso / kevalanANaM puNa daMsaNaM ti nANaM ti ya samANaM / / " [2/3] yugapadupayogadvayAbhyupagamavAdo'yam-manaHparyAyajJAnamantaH paryavasAnaM yasya sa tathA, jJAnasya darzanasya ca vi leSaH pRthagbhAva iti sAdhyam / atra ca chadmasthopayogatvaM heturdraSTavyaH / tathA ca prayogaH 2010_02

Page #145
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA - 4 1 cakSuracakSuravadhijJAnAni cakSuracakSuravadhidarzanebhyaH pRthakkAlAni, chadmasthopayogAtmakajJAnatvAt, zrutamanaHparyAyajJAnavat | vAkyArthaviSaye zrutajJAne, manodravyavizeSAlambane manaHparyAyajJAne cA'darzanasvabhAve matyavadhijAddarzanopayogAd bhinnakAlatvaM prasiddhameveti TIkAkRtaH darzanatrayapRthakkAlatvasya kutrApi ekasminnasisAdhayiSitatvAt, svadarzanapRthakkAlatvasya ca sisAdhayiSitasya uktadRSTAntayorabhAvAt sAvaraNatvaM hetuH, vyatirekI ca prayogaH, tajjanyatvaM vA hetu:, yadyajjanyaM tattataH pRthakkAlamiti sAmAnyavyAptau yathA daNDAt ghaTa iti ca dRSTAnta iti tu yuktam / kevalajJAnaM punardarzanaM darzanopayoga iti vA jJAnaM jJAnopayoga iti vA samAnam, tulyakAlaM tulyakAlInopayogadvayAtmakamityarthaH / prayogaSTA - kevalino jJAnadarzanopayogAvekakAlInau, yugapadAvirbhUtasvabhAvatvAt, yAvevaM tAvevam, yathA raveH prakAzatApau / [kevalajJAna-darzanayoH sahabhAvitve vipratipadyamAnAnAM keSAMcinmatasya sAdhikSepaM nirdeza: ] ayaM cAgamavirodhIti keSAMcinmatamupadarzayannAha 100 keI bhAMti "jaiyA jANai taiyA Na pAsai jiNoti / suttamavalaMbamANA titthayarAsAyaNA'bhIrU ||4 // kecit bruvate " yadA jAnAti tadA na pazyati jinaH" iti / sUtram - " kevalI NaM bhaMte ! imaM rayaNappabhaM puDhaviM AyArehiM pamANehiM heUhiM saMThANehiM parivArehiM jaM samayaM jANai no taM samayaM pAsai ? haMtA goyamA ! kevalI NaM" [ ] ityAdikam-avalambamAnAH / asya ca sUtrasya kilAyamarthaH kevalI sampUrNabodhaH 'NaM' iti prazno'bhyupagamasUcakaH / 'bhante !' iti bhagavan ! imAM ratnaprabhAmanvarthAbhidhAnAM pRthvImAkAraiH samanimnonnatAdibhiH pramANairdairghyAdibhiH hetubhiranantAnantapradezikaiH skandhaiH saMsthAnaiH parimaNDalAdibhiH parivAraiH ghanodadhivalayAdibhiH 'jaM samayaM No taM samayaM' iti ca " kAlAdhvanoratyantasaMyoge " [pA0 2-35] iti dvitIyA adhikaraNasaptamIvAdhikA tena yaM samayaM jAnAti yadA jAnAtItyarthaH 'No taM samayaM pazyatIti na tadA pazyatIti bhAvaH / vizeSopayogaH sAmAnyopayogAntaritaH sAmAnyopayogaSTA vizeSopayogAntaritastatsvAbhAvyAditi praznArthaH / uttaraM punaH 'haMtA goyamA !' ityAdikaM praznAnumodakam 'haMtA' ityabhimatasyAmantraNam 'gautama' iti gotrAmantraNam 2010_02

Page #146
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-4 101 praznAnumodanArthaM punastadeva sUtramucAraNIyam hetupraznasya cAtra sUtre uttaram-"sAkAre se NANe aNAgAre daMsaNe" [ ] sAkAraM vizeSAvalambi asya kevalino jJAnaM bhavati anAkAramatikrAntavizeSaM sAmAnyAlambi darzanam / na cAnekapratyayotpattirekadA nirAvaraNasyApi tatsvAbhAvyAt na hi cakSurjJAnakAle zrotrajJAnotpattirUpalabhyate / na cAvRtatvAt tadA tadanutpattiH svasamaye'pyanutpattiprasaGgAt / tato yugapadanekapratyayAnutpattau svabhAva eva kAraNam nAvaraNasadbhAvaH / sannihite'pi ca dvyAtmake viSaye vizeSAMzameva gRhNan kevalI tatraiva sAmarthyAt sarvajJa iti vyapadizyate sarvavizeSajJatvAt sarvasAmAnyadarzitvAJca sarvadarzI / yaccaivaM vyAkhyAyAmakiJcijjJatvaM kevilano hoDhadAnaM ceti dUSaNam, tanna; yato yadi tat kevalaM jJAnameva bhaved darzanameva vA tataH syAdakiJjijjJatA na caivam AladAnamapi na saMbhavati 'yaM samayaM' ityAdhuktavyAkhyAyAH sampradAyAvicchedato'pavyAkhyAnatvAyogAt / na ca duHsampradAyo'yam tadanyavyAkhyAtRRNAmavisaMvAdAt "jaM samayaM ca NaM samaNe bhagavaM mahAvIre" [ ] ityAdAvapyAgame asakRdu-cAryamANasyAsya zabdasyaitadarthatvena siddhatvAt / tato durvyAkhyaiSA-yaiH samakaM yatsamakamiti bhavataiva hoDhadAnaM kRtam / [ kevalopayogadvayasya kramabhAvitvaM pratiSedhya tatsahabhAvitvaparatayA Agamasya __vyAkhyAnam ] ete ca vyAkhyAtArastIrthakarAsAdanAyA abhIravastIrthakaramAsAdayanto na bibhyatIti yAvat / sA ca 'na kiJcijjAnAti tIrthakRdityadhikSepaH' 'anyathokte tIrthakRtaivamuktam' ityAladAnam / tathAhi-yadi viSayaH sAmAnyavizeSAtmakastadA viSayi kevalaM vizeSAtmakaM vA bhavet sAmAnyAtmakaM vA ? yadi vizeSAtmakamiti pakSastadA niHsAmAnyavizeSagrAhitvAt teSAM ca tadvikalAnAmabhAvAt nirviSayatayA tadavabhAsino jJAnasyAbhAva ityakiJcijjJaH sarvajJastato bhavet / atha sAmAnyAtmakam evamapi vizeSavikalasAmAnyarUpaviSayAbhAvato nirviSayasya darzanasyApyabhAvAnna kiJcit kevalI pazyet / athAyugapad jJAnadarzane tasyAbhyupagamyete tathApi yadA jAnAti na tadA pazyati, yadA ca pazyati na tadA jAnAtItyekarUpAbhAve anyatarasyApyabhAvAt pUrvavadakiJcijjJo'kiJciddarzI ca syAt / ubhayarUpe vA vastunyanyatarasyaiva grAhakatvAt kevalopayogo viparyasto vA bhavet / tathAhi-yad ubhayarUpe vastuni sAmAnyasyaiva 2010_02

Page #147
102 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-4 grAhakaM tadviparyastam yathA sAMkhyajJAnam tathA ca sAmAnyagrAhi kevaladarzanamiti tathA, yad vizeSAvabhAsyeva tathAbhUte vastuni tadapi viparyastam yathA sugatajJAnam tathA ca kevalajJAnamiti / yathA ca sAmAnyavizeSAtmakaM vastu tathA pratipAditamanekadhA / hoDhadAnamapi sUtrasyAnyathAvyAkhyAnAdupapannam / tathAhi-na pUrvapradarzitastatrArthaH kintvayamkevalI imAM ratnaprabhAM pRthivIM yairAkArAdibhiH samakaM tulyaM jAnAti na tairAkArAdibhistulyaM pazyatIti kimevaM grAhyam ? 'evam' ityanumodanA / tato hetau pRSTe sati tatprativacanaM bhinnAlambanapradarzakaM tat-jJAnaM sAkAraM bhavati yato darzanaM punaranAkAramityato bhinnAlambanAvetau pratyayAviti / idaM codAharaNamAtraM pradarzitam / evaM ca sUtrArthavyasthitau pUrvArthakathanamAla dAnameva / 'jaM samayaM' ityatra 'ja' zabde 'am' bhAvaH prAkRtalakSaNAt NIyA lovamabhUyA ANIyA do vi biMdu-dubbhAvA / / atthaM vahati taM ciya jo ciya siM puvvaniviTTho / / [ ] abhUta eva bindurihAnItaH / yathA 'yatkRtasukRte' iti "jaMkayasukayaM" [ ] iti lokaprayoge / / 4 / / [S.T.P. 606] __ -: jJAnabinduH :kevalajJAnadarzanayoH kramavAdasya khaNDanamayamabhiprAya AgamavirodhIti keSAJcinmatam, tAnadhikSipannAha keI bhaNaMti "jaiyA jANai taiyA Na pAsai jiNo" tti / suttamavalaMbamANA titthayarAsAyaNA'bhIrU / / [2/4] kecijjinabhadrAnuyAyino bhaNanti-'yadA jAnAti tadA na pazyati jinaH' iti / sUtram "kevalI NaM bhaMte imaM rayaNappabhaM puDhaviM AyArehiM pamANehiM heUhiM saMThANehiM parivArehiM jaM samayaM jANai No taM samayaM pAsai ? haMtA goyamA ! kevalI NaM...' (prajJApanA, pada 30, sU. 314) ityAdikamavalambamAnAH / asya ca sUtrasya kilAyamarthasteSAmabhimataH kevalI=sampUrNabodhaH / Namiti vAkyAlaGkAre / bhaMte iti bhagavan ! imAM ratnaprabhAmanvarthAbhidhAnAM pRthvImAkAraiH samanimnonnatAdibhiH, pramANairdeAdibhiH, hetubhiH 2010_02

Page #148
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-4 102 anantAnantapradezikaiH skandhaiH, saMsthAnaiH parimaNDalAdibhiH, parivArairghanodadhivalayAdibhiH / 'jaM samayaM No taM samayamiti' ca "kAlAdhvanoratyantasaMyoge" (pA.2 / 3 / 5) iti dvitIyA saptamIbAdhikA, tena yadA jAnAti na tadA pazyati iti bhAvaH / vizeSopayogaH sAmAnyopayogAntaritaH, sAmAnyopayogaSTA vizeSopayogAntaritaH, tatsvAbhAvyAditi praznArthaH / uttaraM punaH haMtA goyametyAdikaM praznAnumodakam / gautameti gotreNAmaMtraNam, praznAnumodanArthaM punastadeva sUtramuccAraNIyam / hetupraznasya cAtra sUtre uttaram-"sAgAre se nANe havai aNAgAre se daMsaNe" (prajJApanA, pada 30, sU. 314) iti / sAkAraM vizeSAvalambi asya kevalino jJAnaM bhavati, anAkAramatikrAntavizeSaM sAmAnyAvalambi darzanam / na cAnekapratyayotpattirekadA nirAvaraNasyApi, tatsvAbhAvyAt / na ca cakSurjJAnakAle zrotrajJAnotpattirupalabhyate / na ca AvRtatvAttadA tadanutpattiH, svasamaye'pi anutpattiprasaGgAt / na ca aNunA manasA yadA yadindriyasaMyogastadA tajjJAnamiti kramaH paravAdyabhimato'pi yuktimAn, sarvAGgINasukhopalambhAdhupapattaye manovargaNApudgalAnAM zarIravyApakatvakalpanAt, suSuptau jJAnAnutpattaye tvaGmanoyogasya jJAnasAmAnye hetutvena rAsanakAle tvAca-rAsanobhayotpattivAraNasya itthamapyasambhavAJca / tato yugapadanekapratyayAnutpattau svabhAva eva kAraNaM nAnyat / sannihite'pi ca dvayAtmake viSaye sarvavizeSAneva kevalajJAnaM gRhNAti, sarvasAmAnyAni ca kevaladarzanamiti svabhAva evAnayoriti / ete ca vyAkhyAtArastIrthakarAzAtanAyA abhIravaH tIrthakaramAzAtayanto na bibhyatIti yAvat / evaM hi niHsAmAnyasya nirvizeSasya vA vastuno'bhAvena na kiJcijjAnAti kevalI na kiJcitpazyati ityadhikSepasyaiva paryavasAnAt / na ca anyataramukhyopasarjanaviSayatAmapekSyobhayagrAhitve'pi upayogakramA'virodhaH, mukhyopasarjanabhAvena ubhayagrahaNasya kSayopazamavizeSaprayojyatvAt, kevalajJAne chadmasthajJAnIyayAvadviSayatopagame avagrahAdisaGkIrNarUpaprasaGgAt / uktasUtrasya tu na bhavadukta evArthaH kintu ayaM- kevalImAM ratnaprabhAM pRthivIM yairAkArAdibhiH samakaM tulyaM jAnAti na tairAkArAdibhistulyaM pazyatIti kimevaM grAhyam ? (hantA) evamityanumodanA / tato hetau pRSTe sati tatprativacanaM bhinnAlambanapradarzakaM tajjJAnaM sAkAraM bhavati yato darzanaM punaranAkAramityato bhinnAlambanAvetau pratyayAviti pratyapAdIti TIkAkRtaH / atra yadyapi 'jaM samayaM' ityatra 'jaM' iti ambhAvaH prAkRtalakSaNAt, yatkRtamityatra 'jaMkayaM' iti prayogasya loke'pi darzanAditi vaktuM zakyate, tathApi tRtIyAntapadavAcyairAkArAdibhiH luptatRtIyAntasamAsasthayatpadArthasya samakapadArthasya ca anyUnAnatiriktadharmaviziSTasya ratnaprabhAyAM bhinnaliGgatvAdananvaya iti 'yat samakam' ityAdi kriyAvizeSaNatvena 2010_02

Page #149
104 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-5 vyAkhyeyam / ratnaprabhAkarmakAkArAdinirUpitayAvadanyUnAnatiriktaviSayatAkajJAnavAn na tAdRzatAvadanyUnAnatiriktaviSayatAkadarzanavAn kevalIti phalito'rthaH / yadi tAdRzasya viziSTadarzanasya niSedhyasyA'prasiddherna taniSedhaH "asato Natthi Niseho" (vizeSA. gA. 1574) ityAdivacanAditi sUkSmamIkSyate, tadA kriyApradhAnamAkhyAtamiti vaiyAkaraNanayAzrayaNena ratnaprabhAkarmakAkArAdinirUpitayAvadanyUnAnatiriktaviSayatAkaM jJAnaM na tAdRzaM kevalikartRkaM darzanamityeva bodhaH sarvanayAtmake bhagavatpravacane yathopapannAnyataranayagrahaNe doSA'bhAvAditi tu vayamAlocayAmaH / [ Agamena kevalajJAna-darzanayoryogapadyamabhidhAya anumAnayuktyA punastatpratipAdanam ] AgamenAbhidhAya yogapadyaM jJAna-darzanayoranumAnenA'pi tayostad darzayitumAha kevalaNANAvaraNakkhayajAyaM kevalaM jahA NANaM / taha daMsaNaM pi jujjai NiyaAvaraNakkhayassaMte / / 5 / / kevalajJAnAvaraNakSaye yathotpannaM vizeSAvabodhasvabhAvaM jJAnaM tathA tadaiva darzanAvaraNakSaye sati sAmAnyaparicchedasvabhAvaM darzanamapyutpadyatAm na hyavikalakAraNe sati kAryAnutpattiryuktA tasyAtatkAryatAprasakteritaratrApyavizeSato'nutpattiprasakteSTA / jJAnakAle darzanasyApi saMbhavaH tadutpattau kAraNasadbhAvAd yugapadutpattyavikalakAraNaghaTapaTayugapadutpattivat / nanu ca hetau satyapi zrutAdyAvaraNakSayopazame zrutAdyanutpadyamAnamapi kadAcit dRSTamityanaikAntiko hetuH, na; zrutAdau kSINAvaraNatvasya hetorabhAvAt-zrutAdeH kSINopazAntAvaraNatvAt / bhinnAvaraNatvAdeva ca zrutAvadhivannaikatvamekAntato jJAnadarzanayorekadobhayAbhyupagamavAdenaiva / / 5 / / -: jJAnabinduH :hetuyaugapadyAdapi balena upayogayogapadyamApatati ityAha "kevalanANAvaraNakkhayajAyaM kevalaM jahA nANaM / taha daMsaNaM pi jujai NiyaAvaraNakkhayassaMte / / " [2/5] spaSTA, navaraM nijAvaraNakSayasyAnta iti darzanAvaraNakSayasyAnantarakSaNa ityarthaH / na ca ekadobhayAvaraNakSaye'pi svabhAvahetuka eva upayogakrama ityuktamapi sAmpratam, evaM sati svabhAvenaiva sarvatra nirvAhe kAraNAntarocchedaprasaGgAt, kAryotpattisvabhAvasya kAraNeneva tatkramasvabhAvasya tatkrameNaiva nirvAhyatvAJca / ___ 2010_02

Page #150
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-6 105 ___ etena sarvavyaktiviSayakatvasarvajAtiviSayakatvayoH pRthagevAvaraNakSayakAryatAvacchedakatvAdarthatastadavacchinnopayogadvayasiddhiH ityapi apAstam / tatsiddhAvapi tatkramA'siddherAvaraNadvayakSayakAryayoH samaprAdhAnyena arthagateraprasarAJca / na ca 'matizrutajJAnAvaraNayoH ekadA kSayopazame'pi yathA tadupayogakramastathA jJAnadarzanAvaraNayoryugapatkSaye'pi kevalinyupayogakramaH syAt' iti zaGkanIyam, tatra zrutopayoge matijJAnasya hetutvena, zAbdAdau pratyakSAdisAmagryAH pratibandhakatvena ca tatsambhavAt; atra tu kSINAvaraNatvena parasparakAryakAraNabhAvapratibandhakabhAvAdyabhAvena vizeSAt / [ sarvajJe chAdmasthikakramopayogAbhAvAt tadRSTAntenaiva tatra kevalajJAnAdanyadA kevaladarzanAbhAvapratipAdanam ] yajjAtIye yo dRSTastajjAtIya evAsAvanyatrApyabhyupagamArho na jAtyantare dhUmavat pAvaketarabhAvAbhAvayoH anyathAnumAnAdivyavahAravilopaprasaGgAdityAha bhaNNai khINAvaraNe jaha maiNANaM jiNe Na saMbhavai / taha khINAvaraNijje visesao daMsaNaM natthi / / 6 / / yathA kSINAvaraNe mati-zrutA'vadhi-manaHparyAyajJAnAni jine na saMbhavantItyabhyupagamyate tathA tatraiva kSINAvaraNIye vizleSato jJAnopayogAdanyadA darzanaM na saMbhavatItyabhyupagantavyam kramopayogasya matyAdyAtmakatvAt tadabhAve tadabhAvAt / / 6 / / -: jJAnabinduH :etadevAha "bhaNNai khINAvaraNe, jaha mainANaM jiNe Na saMbhavai / taha khINAvaraNijje visesao daMsaNaM Natthi / / (2/6) bhaNyate niSTiAtyocyate, kSINAvaraNe jine yathA matijJAnaM matyAdijJAnaM avagrahAdicatuSTayarUpaM vA jJAnaM na sambhavati, tathA kSINAvaraNIye vi leSato jJAnopayogakAlAnyakAle darzanaM nAsti, kramopayogatvasya matyAdyAtmakatvavyApyatvAt sAmAnyavizeSobhayAlambanakramopayogatvasya ca avagrahAdyAtmakatvavyApyatvAta, kevalayoH kramopayogatve tattvApattirityApAdanaparo'yaM granthaH / pramANaM tu kevaladarzanaM kevalajJAnatulyakAlotpattikam, tadekakAlInasAmagrIkatvAt, tAdRzakAryAntaravat, ityuktatarkAnugRhItamanumAnameveti draSTavyam / 2010_02

Page #151
106 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-7 [ kramavAdimate'numAnavirodhavadAgamavirodho'pyApatatIti pradarzanam ] na kevalaM kramavAdino'numAnavirodhaH Agamavirodho'pItyAha suttammi ceva sAI apajjavasiyaM ti kevalaM vuttaM / suttAsAyaNabhIrUhi taM ca daTThavvayaM hoi / / 7 / / sAdyaparyavasAne kevalajJAnadarzane kramopayoge tu dvitIyasamaye tayoH paryavasAnamiti kuto'paryavasitatA ? tena kramopayogavAdibhiH sUtrAsAdanAbhIrubhiH "kevalaNANe NaM bhaMte !" [ ] ityAdi Agame sAdyaparyavasAnatAbhidhAnaM kevalajJAnasya kevaladarzanasya ca draSTavyaM paryAlocanIyaM bhavati / sUtrAsAdanA cAtra sarvajJAdhikSepadvAreNa draSTavyA acetanasya vacanasyAdhikSepAyogAt / na ca dravyApekSayA'paryavasitatvam dravyaviSayapraznottarAzruteH / atha bhavato'pi kathaM tayoraparyavasAnatA paryAyANAmutpAdavigamAtmakatvAt ? na ca dravyApekSayaitaditi vAcyam asmatpakSe'pyasya samAnatvAt / tadviSayapraznaprativacanAbhAvAnneti cet tarhi bhavato'pi dravyApekSayA'paryavasAnakathanamayuktam, asadetat; tayoryugapad rUparasayorivotpAdAbhyupagamAnna Rjutva-vakratAvat / evamapi saparyavasAnateti cet, na; kathaMcit kevalidravyAdavyatirekatastayoraparyavasitatvAt / na ca kramaikAnte'pyevaM bhaviSyatyanekAntavirodhAt / na cAtrApi tathAbhAvastathAbhUtAtmakaikakevalidravyAbhyupagamAt rUparasAtmakaikadravyavad akramarUpatve ca dravyasya tadAtmakatvena tayorapyakrama eva / na ca tayostadrUpatayA tathAbhAvo na svarUpatastathAtve'nekAntarUpatAvirodhAnnirAvaraNasyAkramasya kramarUpatvavirodhAJca tasyAvaraNakRtatvAt / kiJca, yadi sarvathA krameNaiva tayorutpattiranekAntavirodhaH / atha kathaJcit tadA yugapadutpattipakSo'pyabhyupagataH / na ca dvitIye kSaNe tayorabhAve aparyavasitatA chAdmasthikajJAnasyeva yuktA / punarutpAdAdaparyavasitatve paryAyasyApyaparyavasitatAprasaktiH / dravyArthatayA tattve dvitIyakSaNe'pi tayoH sadbhAvo'nyathA dravyArthatvAyogAt / / 7 / / 2010_02

Page #152
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-7 107 -: jJAnabinduH :na kevalaM kramavAdino'numAnavirodhaH api tvAgamavirodho'pItyAha "sattaMmi ceva 'sAI-apajjavasiyaM' ti kevalaM vuttaM / suttAsAyaNabhIruhiM taM ca daTThavvayaM hoi / / " [2/7] sAdyaparyavasite kevalajJAnadarzane sUtre prokte kramopayoge tu dvitIyasamaye tayoH paryavasAnamiti kuto'paryavasitatA ? / tena sUtrAzAtanAbhIrubhiH kramopayogavAdibhistadapi draSTavyam / co'pyarthaH / na kevalaM kevalI NaM bhaMte imaM rayaNappabhaM puDhaviM' ityAdhuktasUtrayathAzrutArthAnupapattimAtramiti bhAvaH / na ca dravyApekSayA'paryavasitatvam, dravya viSayapra nottarAzruteH / na ca "arpitAnarpitasiddheH" (tatvArtha, sUtra-5/31) iti tattvArthasUtrAnurodhena dravyArpaNayA'zrutayorapi tayoH kalpanaM yuktam anyathA paryAyANAmutpAdavigamAtmakatvAt bhavato'pi kathaM tayoraparyavasAnatA ? iti paryanuyojyam ; yaddharmAvacchinne kramikatvaprasiddhiH, taddharmAvacchinne aparyavasitatvAnvayasya nirAkAGkSatvAd anyathA Rjutva-vakratve aparyavasite iti prayogasyApi prasaGgAt / mama tu rUparasAtmakaikadravyavadakramabhAvibhinnopAdhikotpAdavigamAtmakatve'pi kevalidravyAdavyatirekatastayoraparyavasitatvaM nAnupapannam / atha paryAyatvAvacchedakadharmavinirmokeNa zuddhadravyArthAdezapravRtteH kramaikAnte'pi kevalayoraparyavasitatatvamupapatsyate, ata eva paryAyadravyayorAdiSTadravyaparyAyatvaM siddhAnte gIyate tattadavacchedakavinirmokasya vivakSAdhInatvAditi cet ? kimayamuktadharmavinirmokastattatpadArthatAvacchedakaviziSTayoH abhedAnvayAnupapattyA zuddhadravyalakSaNayA, uta uktadharmasya vizeSaNatvaparityAgena upalakSaNatvamAtravivakSayA ? / Adye Adyapada eva lakSaNAyAM 'zuddhadravyaM zuddhAtmadravyaM vA aparyavasitam' ityeva bodhaH syAt / sAditvasyApi tatra anvayapraveze tu kevalidravyaM sAdyaparyavasitam' ityAkAraka eva / ubhayapadalakSaNAyAM tu zuddhadravyaviSayako nirvikalpaka eva bodha iti 'kevalajJAnadarzane sAdyaparyavasite' iti bodhasya kathamapi anupapattiH / antye ya kevalatvopalakSitAtmadravyamAtragrahaNe tatra sAditvAnvayAnupapattiH kevaliparyAyagrahaNe ca navavidhopacAramadhye paryAye paryAyopacAra evAzrayaNIyaH syAditi samIcInaM dravyArthAdezasamarthanam / niyatopalakSyAvacchedakarUpAbhAve'pi saMmugdhopalakSyaviSayakatAdRzabodhasvIkAre ca 'paryAyo'paryavasitaH' ityAderapi prasaktiH / dravyArthatayA kevalajJAnakevaladarzanayoH aparyavasitatvAbhyupagame dvitIyakSaNe'pi tayoH sadbhAvaprasaktiH anyathA dravyArthatvAyogAt / 2010_02

Page #153
108 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-8-9 [ sopasaMhAramAgamavirodhasya spaSTIkaraNam ] tadevaM kramAbhyupagame tayorAgamavirodha ityupasaMharannAha saMtammi kevale daMsaNammi NANassa saMbhavo Natthi / kevalaNANammi ya daMsaNassa tamhA saNihaNAI / / 8 / / kramotpAde sati kevaladarzane na tadA jJAnasya saMbhavastathA kevalajJAne na darzanasya tasmAt sanidhane kevalajJAnadarzane / / 8 / / ___ -: jJAnabinduH :tadevaM kramAbhyupagame tayorAgamavirodha ityupasaMharannAha "saMtaMmi kevale daMsaNammi nANassa saMbhavo Natthi / kevalanANammi ya daMsaNassa tamhA anihaNAiM / / " [2/8] svarUpato dvayoH kramikatve'nyatarakAle'nyatarAbhAvaprasaGgaH, tathA ca uktavakSyamANadUSaNagaNopanipAtaH, tasmAt dvAvapyupayogau kevalinaH svarUpato'nidhanAvityarthaH / / [prakaraNakAreNa kramopayogadvayavAdinam sahopayogadvayavAdinaM ca paryanuyujya svapakSasyopanyAsaH] atra prakaraNakAraH kramopayogavAdinaM tadubhayapradhAnAkramopayogavAdinaM ca paryanuyujya svapakSaM darzayitumAha daMsaNaNANAvaraNakkhae samANammi kassa puvvaaraM / hojja samaM uppAo haMdi due Natthi uvaogA / / 9 / / sAmAnyavizeSaparicchedakAvaraNApagame samAne kasya prathamataramutpAdo bhavet anyatarasyotpAde taditarasyApyutpAdaH syAt na cedanyatarasyApi na syAdavizeSAt ityubhayorapyabhAvaprasaktiH / akramopayogavAdinaH kathamiti cet samam ekakAlam utpAdastayorbhavet satyakramakAraNe kAryasyApyakramasya bhAvAdityakramau dvAvupayogau / atraikopayogavAdyAha-'haMdi duve Natthi uvaogA' iti dvAvapyupayogau naikadeti jJAyatAm sAmAnyavizeSaparicchedAtmakatvAt kevalasyeti / / 9 / / 1-anihaNAI (jJAnabindu) 12-sanihaNAI (saMmati.) / 3-samaM uppAo (saMmati.) / ___ 2010_02

Page #154
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA- 9 -: jJAnabindu: : itthaM granthakRdakramopayogadvayAbhyupagamena kramopayogavAdinaM paryanuyujya svapakSaM darzayitumAha "daMsaNanANAvaraNakkhae samANammi kassa puvvayaro / 2 hojja va samaoppAo, haMdi duve Natthi uvaogA / / " [2 / 9] sAmAnyavizeSaparicchedAvaraNApagame kasya prathamataramutpAdo bhavet ? anyatarotpAde taditarasyApyutpAdaprasaGgAt, anyatarasAmagryA anyatarapratibandhakatve ca ubhayorapyabhAvaprasaGgAt / " savvAo laddhIo sAgArovaogovauttassa" iti vacanaprAmANyAt prathamaM kevalajJAnasya paSThAt kevaladarzanasyotpAda iti cet ? na, etadvacanasya labdhiyaugapadya eva sAkSitvAt, upayogakramAkramayoraudAsInyAt yogapadyenApi nirvAhe'rthAddarzane'nantarotpattyasiddheH, ekakSaNotpattikakevalajJAnayorekakSaNanyUnAdhikAyuSkayoH kevalinoH kramikopayogadvayadhArAyA nirvAhayitumazakyatvAcca / 109 atha jJAnopayogasAmAnye darzanopayogatvena hetuteti nirvikalpakasamAdhirUpachadmasthakAlInadarzanAt prathamaM kevalajJAnotpattiH, kevaladarzane kevalajJAnatvena viziSya hetutvAcca dvitIyakSaNe kevaladarzanotpattiH, tataSTA kramikasAmagrIdvayasampattyA kramikopayogadvayadhArAnirvAha iti ekakSaNanyUnAdhikAyuSkayostvekakSaNe kevalajJAnotpattyasvIkAra eva gatiriti cet ? na, "daMsaNapuvvaM nANaM" ( sanmati 2 / 22 ) ityAdinA tathAhetutvasya pramANAbhAvena nirasanIyatvAt, utpannasya kevalajJAnasya kSAyikabhAvatvena nAzA'yogAcya / na ca muktisamaye kSAyikacAritranAzavadupapattiH, kSAyikatve'pi tasya yogasthairyanimittakatvena nimittanAzanAzyatvAt, kevalajJAnasya cA'naimittakatvAd utpatau jJaptau cAvaraNakSayAtiriktanimittAnapekSAtvenaiva tasya svatantrapramANatvavyavasthiteH, anyathA 'sApekSamasamartham' itinyAyAttatrA'prAmANyaprasaGgAt / etena kevaladarzanasAmagrItvena svasyaiva svanAzakatvamiti kevalajJAnakSaNikatvam, ityapi apAstam anaimittike kSaNikatvA'yogAt, anyathA tatkSaNa eva tatkSaNavRttikArye nAzaka iti sarvatraiva sUkSmarjusUtranayasAmrAjyasya durnivAratvAditi kimatipallavitena ? nanviyamanupapattiH kramopayogapakSa evetyakramau dvAvupayogau stAmityAzaGkate mallavAdI - " bhavedvA samayamekakAlamutpAdastayoH" iti / tatraikopayogavAdI granthakRt siddhAntayati 'handi ' jJAyatAM dvAvupayogI naikadeti, sAmAnyavizeSaparicchedAtmakatvAt kevalajJAnasya yadeva jJAnaM tadeva darzanamityatraiva nirbhara: ubhayahetusamAje samUhAlambanotpAdasyaiva anyatra dRSTatvAt nAtra aparidRSTakalpanAkleza iti bhAvaH / 2-va samaoppAo (jJAnabindu) 2010_02

Page #155
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-10 [ kevalajJAna-darzanayorabhedapakSa eva sarvajJatva-sarvadarzitvopapattiriti prakaTanam ] yadeva jJAnaM tadeva darzanamityasminneva vAde sarvajJatAsaMbhava ityAha jai savvaM sAyAraM jANai ekkasamaeNa savvaNNU / jujjai sayAvi evaM ahavA savvaM Na yANAi / / 10 / / yadi AkArAtmakaM vastu bhavanaM bhavanAtmakaM vA AkArAtmakaM sAmAnyavizeSayoravinirbhAgavRttitvAta sarvaM sAkAraM jAnastadAtmakaM sAmAnyaM tadaiva pazyati tat pazyan vA tadavyatiriktaM vizeSaM tadaiva jAnAti ubhayAtmakavastvavabodhaikarUpatvAt sarvajJopayogasya sadA sarvajJatvaM sarvadarzitvaM ca tasya sarvakAlaM yujyate pratikSaNamubhayAtmakaikarUpatvAt tasya / athavA sarvaM sAmAnyaM sAkAraM vA vastu na pazyati na jAnAti ca tathAbhUtayostayorasattvAt jAtyandhavat AkAzavadvA / athavA sarvaM na jAnAtyekadezopayogavRttitvAd matijJAnivat / yugapat krameNa caikAntabhinnopayogadvayavAdimate na sarvajJatA sarvadarzitA cetyAzaya AcAryasya / [ kramA'kramA'bhedapakSatrayagrAhiNa AcAryAn nAmagrahaM nirdizya taiH svasvapakSapoSakatayA vyAkhyAtAnAM sUtrANAM saMsUcanam] atra ca jinabhadragaNikSamAzramaNapUjyAnAmayugapadbhAvyupayogadvayamabhimatam / mallavAdinastu yugapadbhAvi taddvayamiti / siddhAntavAkyAnyapi "sAgAramaNAgAraM lakkhaNameyaM tu siddhANaM" (prajJApa0 dvitI0 pa0 sU0 54 gA0 160) / tathA "kevalaNANuvauttA jANaMti" (prajJApa0 dvitI0 pa0 sU0 54 gA0 161) ityAdIni yugapadupayogavAdinA svamatasaMvAdakatvena vyAkhyA tAni / kramopayogavAdinA tu "savvAo laddhIo" [ vizeSAva0bhA0 gA0 3089] ityAdIni svamatasaMvAdakatvena / prakaraNakAropi svamatasaMvAdakAnyetAnyanyAni ca vyAkhyAtavAn / / 10 / / -: jJAnabinduH :asminneva vAde kevalinaH sarvajJatAsambhava ityAha "jai savvaM sAyAraM jANai ekasamaeNa savvaNNU / jujai sayAvi evaM ahavA savvaM na jANAi / / " [2/10] 2010_02

Page #156
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-11 yadi sarvaM sAmAnyavizeSAtmakaM jagat sAkAraM tattajAtivyaktivRttidharmaviziSTam, sAkAramiti kriyAvizeSaNaM vA niravacchinnatattajjAtiprakAratAnirUpitatattadvyaktivizeSyatAsahitaM parasparaM yAvadravyaparyAyanirUpitaviSayatAsahitaM vA yathA syAt tathetyarthaH / jAnAtyekasamayena sarvajJaH 'pazyati ca' iti zeSaH, tadA sadApi sarvakAlaM yujyate, evaM sarvajJatvaM sarvadarzitvaM cetyarthaH athavA ityetadvaiparItye sarvaM na jAnAti sarvaM na jAnIyAdekadezopayogavartitvAd matijJAnivadityarthaH tathA ca kevalajJAnameva kevaladarzanamiti sthitam / [ sAkArAnAkAropayogayorekAntikabhedAsaMbhavapradarzanena anekAntasya samarthanam ] sAkArAnAkAropayogayo:kAntato bheda iti darzayannAha sUriH parisuddhaM sAyAraM aviyattaM daMsaNaM aNAyAraM / Na ya khINAvaraNijje jujjai suviyattamaviyattaM / / 11 / / jJAnasya hi vyaktatA rUpaM darzanasya punaravyaktatA na ca kSINAvaraNe arhati vyaktatAvyaktate yujyate / tataH sAmAnyavizeSajJeyasaMsparzI ubhayaikasvabhAva evAyaM kevalipratyayaH / na ca grAhyadvitvAd grAhakadvitvamiti tatra saMbhAvanA yuktA kevalajJAnasya grAhyAnantyenAntatApatteH / anyonyAnuviddhagrAhyAMzadvayabhedAd grAhakasya tathAtvakalpane ekatvAnatikramAnna doSa iti / sUrerayamabhiprAyaH-na caikasvabhAvasya pratyayasya zItoSNasparzavat parasparavibhinnasvabhAvadvayavirodho darzanasparzanazaktidvayAtmakaikadevadattavat svabhAvadvayAtmakaikapratyayasya kevalinyavirodhAt anekAntavAdasya pramANopapannatvAt / / 11 / / ___-: jJAnabinduH :avyaktatvAdapi pRthagdarzanaM kevalini na sambhavatItyAha- "parisuddhaM sAyAraM aviattaM daMsaNaM aNAyAraM / Na ya khINAvaraNijje jujai suviyattamaviyataM / / " [2/11] jJAnasya hi vyaktatA rUpam darzanasya punaravyaktatA / na ca kSINAvaraNe'rhati vyaktatA'vyaktate yujyete, tataH sAmAnyavizeSajJeyasaMsparmyubhayaikasvabhAva evAyaM kevalipratyayaH / na ca grAhyadvitvAd grAhakadvitvamiti sambhAvanApi yuktA, kevalajJAnasya grAhyAnantyenAntatApatteH / viSayabhedakRto na 2010_02

Page #157
112 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-12 jJAnabheda ityabhyupagame tu darzanapArthakye kA pratyAzA ? AvaraNadvayakSayAdubhayaikasvabhAvasyaiva kAryasya sambhavAt / na ca ekasvabhAvapratyayasya zItoSNasparzavat parasparavibhinnasvabhAvadvayavirodhaH, darzanasparzanazaktidvayAtmakaikadevadattavatsvabhAvadvayAtmakaikapratyayasya kevalinyavirodhAt / jJAnatvadarzanadharmAbhyAM jJAnadarzanayorbhedaH, na tu dharmibhedeneti paramArthaH / ata eva tadAvaraNabhede'pi syAdvAda eva / taduktaM stutau granthakRtaiva "cakSurdarzanavijJAnaM paramANvauSNyaraukSyavat / tadAvaraNamapyekaM na vA kAryavizeSataH / / " [niSTAya0 dvA0 8] iti / / paramANAvuSNarukSasparzadvayasamAvezavaJcAkSuSe jJAnatvadarzanatvayoH samAveza ityarthaH / itthaM ca cAkSuSajJAnadarzanAvarakarmApi paramArthata ekam, kAryavizeSata upAdhibhedato vA naikamiti siddham / evamavadhikevalasthale'pi draSTavyam / tadAha "cakSurvadviSayA'khyAtiravadhijJAnakevale / zeSavRttivizeSAttu te mate jJAnadarzane / / " [dvA. 10/30] iti / "cakSurvaJcAkSuSavadviSayA'khyAtiH spRSTajJAnAbhAvaH aspRSTajJAne iti yAvat, bhAvAbhAvarUpe vastuni abhAvatvAbhidhAnamapi dossaanaavhm| zeSA vRttayaH spRSTajJAnAni tAbhyo vizeSo'spRSTatAvizeSaNa vakSyamANarItyA'spRSTA'viSayavRttitvavyaGgyena, tasmAtte avadhikevale jJAnapadena darzanapadena ca vAcye ityetadarthaH / [ kramAkramopayodvayapakSe zAstrasiddhaM jJAta-dRSTabhASitvaM bhagavato na ghaTate ityabhidhAnam ] kramAkramopayogadvayAbhyupagame tu bhagavata idamApannamiti darzayati addiSTuM aNNAyaM ca kevalI eva bhAsai sayA vi / egasamayammi haMdI vayaNaviyappo na saMbhavai / / 12 / / adRSTameva jJAtaM jAtyandhahastiparijJAnavat ajJAtameva ca dRSTamalAtacakradarzanavat / sarvakAlameva kevalI bhASata ityetadApannamakramopayogapakSe / kramavalupayogapakSe tu ekasmin samaye jAnAti yat tadeva bhASate jJAtaM na ca dRSTam samayAntare tu yadA pazyati tadApi dRSTaM bhASate na jJAtam, bodhAnurUpyeNa vAcaH pravartanAt / bodhasya caikAMzAvalambitvAdakramopayogapakSe, 2010_02

Page #158
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-13 113 / kramopayogapakSe tu tattvAd bhinnasamayatvAJca tata ekasmin samaye jJAtaM dRSTaM ca bhASata ityeSa vacanavizeSo bhavadarzane na saMbhavatIti gRhyatAm / / 12 / / ___-: jJAnabindu: :kramA'kramopayogadvayapakSe bhagavato yadApadyate tadAha "aghiTuM aNNAyaM ca kevalI eva bhAsai sayA vi / . egasamayammi haMdI vayaNavigappo Na saMbhavai / / " [2/12] iti / AdyapakSe jJAnakAle'dRSTam, darzanakAle cAjJAtam, dvitIyapakSe ca sAmAnyAMze'jJAtaM vizeSAMze cA'dRSTam, evamuktaprakAreNa kevalI sadA bhASate tataH 'ekasmin samaye' jJAtaM dRSTaM ca bhagavAn bhASate' ityeSa vacanasya vikalpo vizeSo bhavaddarzane na sambhavatIti gRhyatAm / na cAnyatarakAle'nyataropalakSaNAt upasarjanatayA viSayAntaragrahaNAd uktavacanavikalpopapattiH, evaM sati bhrAntacchadmasthe'pi tathAprayogaprasaGgAt / yadA kadAcit zRGgagrAhikayA jJAnadarzanaviSayasyaiva padArthasya tabuddhAvanupravezAditi smartavyam / [kramAkramapakSadvaye bhagavataH ajJAtadarzitayA adRSTajJAyitayA ca sarvajJatvAsaMbhavapradarzanam] tathA ca sarvajJatvaM na saMbhavatItyAha aNNAyaM pAsaMto addiTuM ca arahA viyANaMto / kiM jANai kiM pAsai kaha savvaNNu tti vA hoi / / 13 / / ajJAtaM pazyannadRSTaM ca jAnAnaH kiM jAnAti kiM vA pazyati na kiJcidapIti bhAvaH / kathaM vA tasya sarvajJatA bhavet ? / / 13 / / -: jJAnabinduH :tathA ca sarvajJatvaM na sambhavatItyAha "aNNAyaM pAsaMto addiTuM ca arahA viyANaMto / kiM jANai kiM pAsai kaha savvaNNu tti vA hoi / / " [2/13] ajJAtaM pazyana adRSTaM ca jAnAnaH kiM jAnAti kiM vA pazyati ? / na kiJcidityarthaH / kathaM vA tasya sarvajJatA bhavet ? / na kathamapItyarthaH / 2010_02

Page #159
114 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-14 [ AgamasiddhasamasaMkhyakaviSayAvagAhitvayuktyA kevalajJAnadarzanayorabhedasamarthanam ] jJAnadarzanayorekasaMkhyatvAdapyekatvamityAha kevalaNANamaNaMtaM jaheva taha daMsaNaM pi paNNattaM / sAgAraggahaNA hi ya NiyamaparittaM aNAgAraM / / 14 / / atra tAtparyArthaH-yadyekatvaM jJAna-darzanayorna syAt tato'lpaviSayatvAd darzanamanantaM na syAditi "aNante kevalaNANe aNaMte kevaladaMsaNe" [ ] ityAgamavirodhaH prasajyeta / darzanasya hi jJAnAd bhede sAkAragrahaNAdanantavizeSavartijJAnAdanAkAraM sAmAnyamAtrAvalambi kevaladarzanaM yato niyamenaikAntenaiva parItamalpaM bhavatIti kuto viSayabhedAdanantatA? __ yugapadupayogadvayavAdI anantaM darzanaM prajJaptamityasyAM pratijJAyAM 'sAkAraggahaNAhi ya Niyama'parittaM' ityakAraprazleSAt sAkAre vizeSe gataM yat sAmAnyaM tasya yad grahaNaM darzanaM tasya niyamo'vazyaMbhAvastenAparItamaparimANamiti sAkAragatagrahaNaniyamenAparItatvAditi hetumabhidhatte / yaJcAparItaM tadanantaM yathA kevalajJAnam aparItatA ca darzanasya dravya-guNa-karmAdeH sAkArasya ca sakalasya dravyatva-guNatva-karmatvAdinA svasAmAnyena tAvatparimANenAzUnyatvAta sAmAnyavikalasya paryAyasyAsaMbhavAt / vizeSatAdAtmyavyavasthitasAmAnyasya darzanaviSayasyAnantyena darzanasyAparItatvaM nAsiddhamiti bhavati tasyAnantyasiddhiriti vyavasthitaH / / 14 / / -: jJAnabinduH :samasaMkhyakaviSayakatvenApi kevalayoraikyamjJAnadarzanayorviSayavidhayaikasaMkhyAzAlitvAdapi ekatvamityAha "kevalanANamaNaMtaM jaheva taha daMsaNaM pi paNNattaM / sAgAraggahaNAhi ya NiyamaparittaM anAgAraM / / " [2/14] yadyekatvaM jJAnadarzanayorna syAt tadA'lpaviSayatvAddarzanamanantaM syAditi "aNaMte kevalanANe aNaMte kevaladaMsaNe" ityAgamavirodhaH prasajyeta / darzanasya hi jJAnAd bhede sAkAragrahaNAdanantavizeSavarti* jJAnAdanAkAraM sAmAnyamAtrAvalambi kevaladarzanaM yato niyamena ekAntenaiva parItamalpaM bhavatIti kuto _ 2010_02

Page #160
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-15 115 viSayAbhAvAdanantatA ? na ca 'ubhayostulyaviSayatvA'vizeSe'pi mukhyopasarjanabhAvakRto vizeSaH' iti vAcyam, vizeSaNavizeSyabhAvena tattannayajanitavaijJAnikasambandhAvacchinnaviSayatayA vA tatra kAmacArAt / ApekSikasya ca tasyAsmadAdibuddhAvevAdhirohAt / etaJca nirUpitatattvam 'jaM jaM je bhAve' (Ava0 282) ityAdiniyuktigAthAyA nayabhedena vyAkhyAdvaye anekAntavyavasthAyAm asmAbhiH / akramopayogadvayavAdI tu prakRtagAthAyAM sAkAre yad grahaNaM darzanaM tasya niyamo avazyaMbhAvo yAvanto vizeSAstAvantyakhaNDasakhaNDopAdhirUpANi jAtirUpANi vA sAmAnyAnIti hetostenA'parItaM anantamityakArapra leSeNa vyAcaSTe / [ abhedavAdyuktasya kevale aparyavasitvAdidoSasya kramavAdinA samuddharaNam tasya ca punarabhedavAdinA pratisamAdhAnam ] kramavAdidarzane jJAnadarzanayoraparyavasitatvAdikaM nopapadyata iti yat preritamekatvavAdinA tatparihArArthamAha bhaNNai jaha cauNANI jujjai NiyamA taheva evaM pi / bhaNNai Na paMcaNANI jaheva arahA taheyaM pi / / 15 / / yathA kramopayogapravRtto'pi matyAdicatarjJAnI aparyavasitacaturjJAna utpadyamAnatajjJAnasarvadopalabdhiko vyaktabodho jJAtadRSTabhASI jJAtA draSTA saMjJeyavartI cAvazyameva yujyate tacchaktisamanvayAt tathaitadapi ekatvavAdinA yadaparyavasitAdi kevalini preryate tad yujyata eva / atraikatvavAdinA pratisamAdhAnaM bhaNyate yathaivArhanna paJcajJAnI bhavati tathaitadapi kramavAdinA yaducyate bhedato jJAnavAn darzanavAniti ca tadapi na bhavatIti sUtrakRto'bhiprAyaH / / 15 / / [S.T.P. 610] -- jJAnabindu: :kramavAde jJAnadarzanayoraparyavasitatvAdikaM nopapadyata iti yaduktaM tatrAkSepamuTTaGkaya samAdhatte "bhaNNai jaha caunANI jujai NiyamA taheva eyaM pi / bhaNNai Na paMcanANI jaheva arahA taheyaM pi / " [2/15] bhaNyate AkSipyate yathA kramopayogapravRtto'pi matyAdicaturjJAnI tacchaktisamanvayAdaparya 2010_02

Page #161
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-16 vasitacaturjJAno jJAtadRSTabhASI jJAtA dRSTA ca niyamena yujyate; tathaitadapi ekatvavAdinA yadaparyavasitatvAdi kramopayoge kevalini preryate tadapi sArvadikakevalajJAnadarzanazaktisamanvayAt upapadyata ityarthaH / bhaNyate atrottaraM dIyate yathaivAhanna paJcajJAnI tathaivetadapi kamavAdinA yaducyate bhedato jJAnavAn darzanavAMpTA tadapi, na bhavatItyarthaH / matyAdyAvaraNakSaye'pi ekadezagrAhiNo matijJAnAderiva darzanAvaraNakSaye'pi tAdRzadarzanasya kevalini bhedenAnupapatteriti bhAvaH / iyAMstu vizeSaH yadabhedenApi kevalajJAne darzanasaMjJA siddhAntasammatA, na tu matijJAnAdisaMjJeti, tatra hetU anvarthopapattyanupapattI eva draSTavye / ayaM ca prauDhivAdaH / vastutaH kramavAde yadA jAnAti tadA pazyati ityAderanupapattireva, AzrayatvasyaivAkhyAtArthatvAt / labdheratadarthatve tu ghaTA'darzanavelAyAmapi 'ghaTaM pazyati' iti prayogaprasaGgAt, ghaTadarzanalabdheH tadAnImapi vidyamAnatvAt / 'cakSuSmAn sarvaM pazyati na tvandhaH' ityAdau tvagatyA labdheryogyatAyA vAkhyAtArthatvamabhyupagamyata eva, na tu sarvatrApyayaM nyAyaH atiprasaGgAt / na ca siddhAnte vinA nikSepavizeSamaprasiddhArthe padavRttiravadhAryate / SaTSaSTisAgaropamasthitikatvAdikamapi matijJAnAderlabdhyapekSayaiveti durvacam, ekasyA eva kSayopazamarUpalabdhestAvatkAlamanavasthAnAt, dravyAdyapekSayA vicitrAparAparakSayopazamasantAnasyaiva pravRttyupagamAt / kintu ekajIvAvacchedena ajJAnAtiriktavirodhisAmagryasamavahitaSaTSaSTisAgaropamakSaNatvavyApyasvajAtIyotpattikatve sati tadadhikakSaNAnutpattikasvasajAtIyatvarUpaM tat pAribhASikameva vaktavyam, evamanyadapyUhyam / [ matyAdijJAnacatuSkarUpe dRSTAnte yatra yatropayoge viSayabhedastatra tatrAsarvArthatvamiti vyApterbhAvanam ] krameNa yugapadvA parasparanirapekSasvaviSayaparyavasitajJAnadarzanopayogau kevalinyasarvArthatvAnmatyAdijJAnacatuSTayavanna sta iti dRSTAntabhAvanAyAha paNNavaNijjA bhAvA samattasuyaNANadasaNAvisao / ohimaNapajjavANa u aNNoNNavilakkhaNA visao / / 16 / / matizrutayorasarvaparyAyasarvadravyaviSayatayA'bhinnArthatve zrutasyAsarvArthagrahaNAtmakabhAvanayA matirapi tathA bhAvitaiveti zrutajJAnasyaiva gAthAyAmasarvArthatvabhAvanA pradarzitA / prajJApanIyAH zabdAbhilApyA bhAvA dravyAdayaH samastazrutajJAnasya dvAdazAGgavAkyAtmakasya darzanAyA 1-ya (jnyaanbindu)|. 2010_02

Page #162
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-16 117 darzanaprayojikAyAstadvAkyopajAtAyA buddheviSaya Alambanam materapi ta eva zabdAnabhidheyA viSayaH zabdaparikarmaNAnapekSasya jJAnasya yathoktabhAvaviSayasya matitvAt / avadhimanaHparyAyayoH punaranyonyavilakSaNA bhAvA viSayaH avadheH pudgalAH manaHparyAyajJAnasya manyamAnAni dravyamanAMsi viSayaH iti asarvArthAnyetAni matyAdijJAnAni parasparavilakSaNaviSayANi ca ata eva bhinnopayogarUpANi / / 16 / / [S.T.P.616] ____ -jJAnabinduH :krameNa yugapadvA parasparanirapekSasvaviSayaparyavasitajJAnadarzanopayogI kevalinyasarvArthatvAd matyAdijJAnacatuSTayavanna sta iti dRSTAntabhAvanApUrvamAha "paNNavaNijjA bhAvA samattasuanANadaMsaNAvisao / ohimaNapajjavANa ya aNNoNNavilakkhaNA visao / / tamhA caubvibhAgo jujjai Na u nANasaNa jiNANaM / sayalamaNAvaraNamaNaMtamakkhayaM kevalaM jamhA / / " [2/16, 17] prajJApanIyAH zabdAbhilApyA bhAvA dravyAdayaH samastazrutajJAnasya dvAdazAGgavAkyAtmakasya darzanAyAH darzanaprayojikAyAstadupajAtAyA buddheH viSayaH Alambanam, materapi ta eva zabdAvasitA viSayA draSTavyAH, zabdaparikarmaNAhitakSayopazamajanitasya jJAnasya yathoktabhAvaviSayasya matitvAt matizrutayorasarvaparyAyasarvadravyaviSayatayA tulyArthatvapratipAdanAJca, avadhimanaHparyAyayoH punaranyonyavilakSaNA bhAvA viSayaH avadhe rupidravyamAtram, manaHparyAyasya ca manyamAnAni dravyamanAsItyasarvArthAnyetAni / tasmAt caturNAM matyAdInAM vibhAgo yujyate tattatkSayopazamapratyayabhedAt, na tu jinAnAM jJAnadarzanayoH / 'nANadaMsaNa tti' avibhaktiko nirdezaH sUtratvAt / kutaH punaretadityAha-yasmAt kevalaM sakalaM paripUrNam / tadapi kutaH ? yato'nAvaraNama, na hi anAvRtamasakalaviSayaM bhavati / na ca pradIpena vyabhicAraH yato'nantam anantArthagrahaNapravRttam / tadapi kutaH ? / yato'kSayam, kSayo hi virodhisajAtIyena guNena syAt, tadabhAve tasyA'kSayatvam, tataSTA anantatvamanavadyamiti bhAvaH / tasmAt akramopayogadvayAtmaka eka eva kevalopayogaH / tatraikatvaM vyaktyA, dvayAtmakatvaM ca nRsiMhatvavadAMzikajAtyantararUpatvamityeke / mASe snigdhoSNatvavadvyApyavRttijAtidvayarUpatvamityapare / kevalatvamAvaraNakSayAt, jJAnatvaM jAtivizeSaH, darzanatvaM ca viSayatAvizeSaH doSakSayajanyatAvacchedakaM iti tu vayam / 2-u (saMmati.) / 3-NANadaMsaNajiNANaM (saMmati.) 2010_02

Page #163
118 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-17 [ matyAdivaidhahNa kevalopayogasya asarvArthatvAbhAvena . viSayabhedAbhAvAdakramopayogadvayAtmakaikarUpatvasAdhanam ] evamasakalArthatvaM bhinnopayogapakSe dRSTAntasamarthanadvAreNa pradopasaMhAradvAreNAkramopayogadvayAtmakamekaM kevalamanyathA sakalArthatA tasyAnupapanneti darzayitumAha tamhA caubvibhAgo jujjai.Na u NANadaMsaNajiNANaM / sayalamaNAvaraNamaNaMtamakkhayaM kevalaM jamhA / / 17 / / yasmAt kevalaM sakalaM sakalaviSayaM tasmAnna tu naiva jJAnadarzanapradhAnAnAM nirmUlitAzeSaghAtikarmaNAM jinAnAM chadmasthAvasthopalabdhatattadAvaraNakSayopazamakAraNabhedaprabhavamatyAdicaturjJAneSviva jJAnadarzanayoH pRthak kramAkramavibhAgo yujyate / kutaH punaH sakalaviSayatvaM bhagavati kevalasyAnAvaraNatvAt na hyanAvRtamasakalaviSayaM bhavati / na ca pradIpAdinA vyabhicAro'nantatvAt anantatvaM ca dravyaparyAyAtmakAnantArthagrahaNapravRttotpAdavyayadhrauvyAtmakopayogavRttatvenAkSayatvAt / yathA ca sakalapadArthaviSayaM sarvajJajJAna tathA prAk pradarzitam / tato'kramopayogadvayAtmakamekamiti sthitam na cAkramopayogadvayAtmakatve kathaM tasya kevala vyapadeza iti kramAkramabhinnopayogavAdinA preryam indriyAlokamanovyApAranirapekSanirAvaraNAtmasattAmAtranibandhanatathAvidhArthaviSayapratibhAsasya tathAvidhavyapadezaviSayatvAt / advaitaikAntAtmakaM tu tanna bhavati sAmAnyavizeSobhayAnubhayavikalpacatuSTaye'pi doSAnatikramAt / tathAhi- na tAvat sAmAnyarUpatayA tadadvayaM sAmAnyasya vizeSanibandhanatvAt tadabhAve tasyApyabhAvAt, nApi vizeSamAtratvAt tadadvayam avayavAvayavivikalpadvayAnatikramAt, na tAvat tadavayavarUpam avayavyabhAve tadapekSAvayavarUpatA'saMbhavAt, na cAvayavirUpam avayavAbhAve tadrUpasyAsaMbhavAt, na ca tadvayAtiriktavizeSarUpam asadavizeSaprasaGgAt, na caikAntavyAvRttobhayarUpam ubhayadoSAnatikramAt, na cAnubhayasvabhAvam asattvaprasakteH, na ca grAhyagrAhakavinirmuktA'dvayasvarUpam tathAbhUtasyAtmanaH kadAcidapyananubhavAt suSuptAvasthAyAmapi na grAhyagrAhakasvarUpavikalamadvayaM jJAnamanubhUyate / / 17 / / 1-NANadaMsaNa jiNANaM (jJAnabindra) / 2010_02

Page #164
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-18 [ abhinnopayogavAdinA svapakSe samApatata AgamavirodhasyArthagatyA vyAkhyAntaramAzritya pariharaNam ] jJAnadarzanopayogadvayAtmakaikakevalopayogavAdI svapakSe AgamavirodhaM pariharannAha paravattavvayapakkhAavisiTThA tesu tesu suttesu / atthagaIa u tesiM viyaMjaNaM jANao kuNai / / 18 / / parairvezeSikAdibhiryAni vaktavyAni pratipAdyAni teSAM pakSA abhyupagamAH "yugapad jJAnAnutpattiH" [ ] "nAgRhItavizeSaNA vizeSye buddhiH" [ ] ityAdayaH tairaviziSTA abhinnA bhagavanmukhAmbhojanirgateSu teSu teSu sUtreSu "jaM samayaM pAsai No taM samayaM jANai" [ ] ityAdiSu abhyupagamAH pratibhAsante / na ca te tathaiva vyAkhyeyAH pramANabAdhanAt / tasmAt arthagatyaiva sAmarthyenaiva teSAM vyaktiM sakalavastuvyApyanekAntAtmakaikakevalAvabodhaprabhavadvAdazAGgakazrutaskandhAvirodhena vyAkhyAM jJako jJAtA karoti / zrutAvadhimanaHparyAyakevalI trividho "jaM samayaM pAsai no taM samayaM jANai" / [ ] na tvevaM kevalakevalI tasyAsarvajJatAprApteriti sUrerabhiprAyaH / / 18 / / -: jJAnabinduH :abhedapakSe AgamavirodhaparihAraH nanu-"bhavaduktapakSe 'kevalI NaM' ityAdi sUtre jaM 'samaya' ityAdau yatsamakamityAdyartho na sarvasvarasasiddhaH, tAdRzaprayogAntare tathAvivaraNabhAvAt tathA nANadaMsaNaTThayAe duve ahaM' (bhaga0 18/ 10) ityAdyAgamavirodho'pi, yaddharmaviziSTaviSayAvacchedena bhedanayArpaNaM taddharmaviziSTApekSayaiva dvitvAde: sAkAGkSatvAt, anyathA'tiprasaGgAt- ityAzakya yuktisiddhaH sUtrArtho grAhyasteSAM svasamayaparasamayAdiviSayabhedena vicitratvAt ityabhiprAyavAnAha 3"paravattavvayapakkhA avisuddhA tesu tesu atthesu / atthagaIa u tesiM viaMjaNaM jANao kuNai / / " [2/18] pareSAM vaizeSikAdInAM yAni vaktavyAni teSAM pakSA avizuddhAH teSu teSvartheSu sUtre tannayapari- . karmaNAdihetornibaddhAH / arthagatyaiva sAmarthya naiva teSAmarthAnAM vyakti sarvapravAdamUladvAdazAGgA'virodhena 1-paravattavyayapakkhA avisuddhA (jJAnabindu) / 2-atthesu (jJAnabindu) / 3-paravattavvayapakkhAavisiTThA (saMmati.) 4-suttesu (saMmati.) 2010_02

Page #165
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-19 jJako jJAtA karoti / tathA ca 'jaM samayaM' ityAderyathAzrutArthe kevalI zrutAvadhimanaHparyAyakevalyanyataro grAhyaH paramAvadhikAdhovadhikacchadmasthAtiriktaviSaye snAtakAdiviSaye vA tAdRzasUtrapravRttau tatra paratIrthikavaktavyatApratibaddhatvaM vAcyam, evamanyatrApIti dik / - [akramopayogadvayAtmakamekaM cet kevalaM kimiti manaHparyAyavadAgame tasya jJAnamAtratayA na kathanam kimiti ca jJAna-darzanarUpatayA dvaividhyena varNanamiti codye marmopTATanam ] yadyakramopayogadvayAtmakamekaM kevalaM kimiti manaHparyAyajJAnavat tad jJAnatvenaiva na nirdiSTam? tasmAt "kevalanANe kevaladasaNe" [ ] iti bhedena sUtranirdezAt krameNa yugapadvA bhinnamupayogadvayaM kevalAvabodharUpamityAzaGkayAha jeNa maNovisayagayANa dasaNaM Natthi davvajAyANa / to maNapajjavaNANaM NiyamA NANaM tu NiddiSTuM / / 19 / / yato manaHparyAyajJAnaviSayagatAnAM paramanodravyavizeSANAM vizeSarUpatayA bAhyasya cintyamAnasya ghaTAderliGgino gamakatopapatteH darzanaM sAmAnyarUpaM nAsti dravyarUpANAM cintyamAnAlambanaparamanodravyagatAnAM cintyAvizeSANAM vizeSarUpatayA bAhyArthagamakatvAta tadgrAhi manaHparyAyajJAnaM vizeSAkAratvAd jJAnameva grAhyadarzanAbhAvAd grAhake'pi tadabhAvastato manaHparyAyAkhyo bodho niyamAd jJAnamevAgame nirdiSTo na tu darzanam / kevalaM tu sAmAnyavizeSopayogaikarUpatvAt kevalaM jJAnaM kevalaM darzanaM cetyAgame nirdiSTam / / 19 / / __ -: jJAnabinduH :'kevalanANe kevaladaMsaNe' ityAdi bhedena sUtranirdezasyaikArthikaparataivetyabhiprAyeNa upakramate "jeNa maNovisayagayANa daMsaNaM Natthi davyajAdANaM / to maNapajjavanANaM niyamA nANaM tu NiddiTuM" [2/19] yato manaHparyAyajJAnaviSayagatAnAM tadviSayasamUhAnapraviSTAnAM paramanodravyavizeSANAM bAhyacintyamAnArthagamakataupayikavizeSarUpasyaiva sadbhAvAt darzanaM sAmAnyarUpaM nAsti, tasmAt, manaHparyAyajJAnaM jJAnamevA''game nirdiSTam, grAhyasAmAnyAbhAve mukhyatayA tadgrahaNonmukhadarzanAbhAvAt / kevalaM tu sAmAnyavizeSobhayopayogarUpatvAt ubhayarUpaikameveti bhAvaH / ___ 2010_02

Page #166
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 2, gAthA - 20-21 [ ekatve'pi kevalasya jJAna - darzanobhayarUpatayA zAstre pAThAt tasya kathaMcidanekarUpatvAbhyupagamanam ] tathA punarapyekarUpAnuviddhAmanekarUpatAM darzayannAha cakkhu acakkhuavAhikevalANa samayammi daMsaNaviappA / paripaDhiyA kevalaNANadaMsaNA teNa te aNNA / / 20 / / cakSuracakSuravadhikevalAnAM svasamaye darzanavikalpA bhedAH paripaThitAstena darzanamadhye pAThAd darzanamapi kevalam jJAnamadhye pAThAd jJAnamapi ato bhinne eva kevalajJAnadarzane na cAtyantaM tayorbheda eva kevalAntarbhUtatvena tayorabhedAt na caivamabhedAdadvaitameva sUtrayuktivirodhAt tatparicchedakasvabhAvatayA kathaMcidekatve'pi tathA tadvyapadezAt / / 20 / / -: sualdog: nirdezabhedenaiva kathaJcittayoranaikyaM nAnyathA -- sUtre ubhayarUpatvena paripaThitatvAdapyubhayarUpaM kevalaM na tu kramayogAdityAha "cakkhu acakkhu avadhikevalANa samayammi daMsaNaviappA | paripaThiA kevalanANadaMsaNA teNa viya aNNA" [2/20] 121 spaSTA / cakSurAdijJAnavadeva kevalaM jJAnamadhye pAThAt jJAnamapi, darzanamadhye pAThAcca darzanamapIti paribhASAmAtrametaditi granthakRtastAtparyam / [ ekadezinA matyupayogaM dRSTAntIkRtya ekasyApi kevalopayogasya dvirUpatvasamarthanam ] etadeva dRSTAntadvAreNAha daMsaNamoggahamettaM 'ghaDo' tti NivvaNNaNA havai NANaM / jaha ettha kevalANa vi visesaNaM ettiyaM ceva / / 21 / / 2010_02 avagrahamAtraM matirUpe bodhe darzanam 'idam' 'tat' ityavyapadezyam 'ghaTaH' iti niSTAyena varNanA niSTAyAtmikA matijJAnaM yatheha tathehApIti dAntikaM yojayati 'jaha ettha' ityAdinA 1-viya (jJAnabindu) / 2- te ( saMmati ) /

Page #167
122 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-22 kevalayorapyetAvanmAtreNaiva vizeSaH ekAntabhedAbhedapakSe tatsvabhAvayoH pUrvoktadoSaprasaGgAd ajahadvRttyaikarUpayorevAbhinibodhikarUpayostattadrUpatayA tathAvyapadezasamAsAdanAt kathaMcidekAnekAtmakatvopapatte daikAnte tayorapyabhAvApatteH / / 21 / / - jJAnabinduH :matijJAnAdeH krama iva kevalasyA'krame'pi sAmAnyavizeSA'jahadvRttyekopayogarUpatayA jJAnadarzanatvamityekadezimatamupanyasyati "daMsaNamuggahamettaM 'ghaDo'tti nivvannaNA havai nANaM / jaha ittha kevalANa vi visesaNaM ittiyaM ceva / / " [2/21] avagrahamAnaM matirUpe bodhe darzanam, idaM tadityavyapadezyam, ghaTa iti niSTAyena varNanA tadAkArAbhilApa iti yAvat, kAraNe kAryopacArAJca ghaTAkArAbhilApajanakaM ghaTe matijJAnamityarthaH / yathA'traivaM tathA kevalayorapyetAvanmAtreNa vizeSaH / ekameva kevalaM sAmAnyAMze darzanaM vizeSAMze ca jJAnamityarthaH / __[ punarapyekadezinA kramikabhedaM dUSayituM zAstrIyayuktyA jJAna-darzanayoH kathaMcidanyatvavyavasthApanam ] itaSTA kathaJcid bheda: daMsaNapuThvaM NANaM NANaNimittaM tu daMsaNaM Natthi / teNa suviNicchiyAmo daMsaNaNANANa aNNattaM / / 22 / / darzanapUrvaM jJAnam, jJAnanimittaM tu darzanaM nAstItyuktaM yataH sAmAnyamupalabhya paSTAAd vizeSamupalabhate na viparyayeNetyevaM chadmasthAvasthAyAM hetuhetumadbhAvakramaH / tenApyavagacchAmaH kathaJcit tayorbheda iti / ayaM ca kSayopazamanibandhanaH kramaH kevalini ca tadabhAvAdakrama ityuktam / / 22 / / 1-daMsaNanANA Na (jJAnabindu) / 2010_02

Page #168
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-22 ___-: jJAnabinduH :ekadezyeva kramikabhedapakSaM dUSayati "daMsaNapuvvaM nANaM, nANanimittaM tu daMsaNaM Natthi / teNa suviNicchiyAmo daMsaNanANA Na aNNattaM / / " [2/22] darzanapUrvaM jJAnamiti chadmasthopayogadazAyAM prasiddham / sAmAnyamupalabhya hi paTAt sarvo vizeSamupalabhata iti, jJAnanimittaM tu darzanaM nAsti kutrApi tathA'prasiddheH / tena suviniSTiAnumaH dasaNanANA iti darzanajJAne nA'nyatvaM na kramApAditabhedaM kevalini bhajata' iti zeSaH / kramAbhyupagame hi kevalini niyamAjjJAnottaraM darzanaM vAcyam, sarvAsAM labdhInAM sAkAropayogaprApyatvena pUrvaM jJAnotpattyupagamaucityAt / tathA ca jJAnahetukameva kevalini darzanamabhyupagantavyam, taJcAtyantA'darzanavyAhatamiti bhAvaH / yattu kSayopazamanibandhanakramasya kevalinyabhAve'pi pUrvaM kramadarzanAtta.jAtIyatayA jJAnadarzanayoranyatvamiti TIkAkRvyAkhyAnam, tat svabhAvabhedatAtparyeNa sambhavadapi darzane jJAnanimittatvaniSedhAnatiprayojanatayA kathaM zobhata iti vicAraNIyam / ___ nanu yathA pareSAM kalpitaH kramo varNaniSTho buddhivizeSajanakatAvacchedako'smAkaM ca bhinnAbhinnaparyAyavizeSarUpaH, tathA kevalijJAnadarzananiSThastAdRzaH krama evAvaraNakSayajanyatAvacchedakaH syAditi noktAnupapattiriti cet ? na, kramavatprayatnaprayojyasya suvacatve'pyakramikAvaraNakSayaprayojyasya kevalyupayogakramasya durvacatvAdananyagatyA'kramikAdapyAvaraNadvayakSayAt kramavadupayogotpattyabhyupagame ca tannAzakAraNAbhAvAdavikalakAraNAttAdRzopayogAntaradhArAyA avicchedAJca "jugavaM do Natthi uvaogA" (Ava0 979) iti vacanAnupapatiH / na ca 'jJAnasya darzanamevArthAntarapariNAmalakSaNo dhvaMsa ityupayogA'yogapadyam' sAmpratam, sAdhanantaparyAyavizeSarUpadhvaMsasyaivAvasthitivirodhitvAdarthAntarapariNAmalakSaNadhvaMsasyA'tathAtvAt anyathA tattatsaMyogavibhAgAdimAtreNAnubhUyamAnaghaTAvasthityucchedApatteH / na ca 'jugavaM do Natthi uvaogA' ityasyopayogayoryugapadutpattiniSedha eva tAtparyam, na tu yugapadavasthAne'pItyupayogadvayadhArANAM nAzakAraNAbhAvena sahAvasthAne'pi na doSa iti sAmpratam, akramavAdinApyevaM kramAvacchinnopayogadvayayaugapadyaniSedhaparatvasya vaktuM zakyatvAt, sUtrA'saMkocasvArasyAdare yadeva jJAnaM tadeva darzanamityasmaduktasyaiva yuktatvAditi dik / 2-daMsaNaNANANa (saMmati.) 2010_02 - For Private &Personal use Only

Page #169
124 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-23-24 [ ekadezIye avagrahamAtramatijJAnasya darzanatvAbhyupagame samApatato doSasyAbhidhAnaM tatsamarthanaM ca ] yaduktam 'avagrahamAtraM matijJAnaM darzanam' ityAdi tadayuktam ativyApterityAha jai oggahamettaM daMsaNaM ti maNNasi visesiaMNANaM / maiNANameva daMsaNamevaM sai hoi niSphaNNaM / / 23 / / evaM sesiMdiyadaMsaNammi niyameNa hoi Na ya juttaM / aha tattha NANamettaM gheppai cakkhummi vi taheva / / 24 / / yadi matyavabodhe avagrahamAnaM darzanaM vizeSitaM jJAnamiti manyase matijJAnameva darzanamityevaM sati prAptam na caitad yuktam / "sa dvividho'STacaturbhedaH" (tattvArtha0 a0 2 sU0 9) iti sUtravirodhAt / / 23 / / evaM zeSendriyadarzaneSvapyavagraha eva darzanamityabhyupagamena matijJAnameva taditi / na ca tad yuktaM pUrvoktadoSAnativRtteH / atha teSu zrotAdiSvindriyeSu darzanamapi bhavat tad jJAnameva, mAtrazabdasya darzanavyavacchedakatvAt / ata eva tatra 'zrotrajJAnam' ityAdivyapadeza upalabhyate 'zrotradarzanam' 'ghrANadarzanam' ityAdivyapadezastu nAgame kvacit prasiddhastarhi cakSuSyapi tathaiva gRhyatAM cakSurjJAnam' iti na tu 'cakSurdarzanam' iti / atha tatra darzanam itaratrApi tathaiva gRhyatAm / jJAnadarzanayorupalambharUpatve avizeSaprasaGgastayoriti cet evametadrUpatayA svabhAvabhedAt tu bheda iti / / 24 / / -: jJAnabinduH :matijJAnamevAvagrahAtmanA darzanam, apAyAtmanA ca jJAnamiti yaduktaM dRSTAntAvaSTambhArthamekadezinA taddUSayannAha "jai uggahamittaM daMsaNaM ti maNNasi visesiyA nANaM / mainANameva daMsaNamevaM sai hoi niSphaNNaM / / " [2/23] 1-visesiyA (jJAnabindu)12-visesiaM (sNmti.)| 2010_02

Page #170
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 2, gAthA - 25 yadi matirevAvagraharUpA darzanam vizeSitA jJAnamiti manyase tadA matijJAnameva darzanamityevaM sati prAptam / na caitadyuktam, "sa dvividho'STacaturbhedaH " (tattvArtha0 2 / 9) iti sUtravirodhAt, matijJAnasyASTAviMzatibhedoktivirodhAcca / " evaM sesindiyadaMsaNammi NiyameNa hoi Na ya juttaM / aha tattha nANamittaM gheppai cakkhummi vi taheva / / " [2 / 24 ] evaM zeSendriyadarzaneSvapyavagraha eva darzanamityabhyupagamena matijJAnameva taditi syAt, tacca na yuktam, pUrvoktadoSAnativRtteH / atha teSu zrotrAdiSvindriyeSu darzanamapi bhavajjJAnameva gRhyate, mAtrazabdasya darzanavyavacchedakatvAt, tadvyavacchedaSTA tathAvyavahArAbhAvAt, zrotrajJAnaM ghrANajJAnamityAdivyapadeza eva hi tatropalabhyate, na tu zrotradarzanaM ghrANadarzanamityAdivyapadezaH kvacidAgame prasiddhaH, tarhi cakSuSyapi tathaiva gRhyatAM cakSurjJAnamiti na tu cakSurdarzanamiti / atha tatra darzanam, itaratrA'pi tathaiva gRhyatAM yuktestulyatvAt / [ jJAna eva cakSuracakSurdarzanapravAdasamarthanAya darzanapadasya arthAbhidhAnam ] nanvavagrahasya matibhedatvAd mateSTA jJAnarUpatvAd avagraharUpasya darzanasyAbhAva eva bhavet ucyate NA apuTThe avisae ya atthammi daMsaNaM hoi / mottUNa liMgao jaM aNAgayAIyavisaesu / / 25 / / aspRSTe'rtharUpe cakSuSA ya udeti pratyayaH sa cakSurdarzanaM jJAnameva sat indriyANAmaviSaye ca paramANvAdau arthe manasA jJAnameva sad acakSurdarzanam, muktvA meghonnatirUpAlliGgAd bhaviSyadvRSTau nadIpUrAd voparyatItavRSTau vA liGgiviSayaM yad jJAnaM tasyAspRSTAviSayArthasyApyadarzanatvAt / / 25 / / -: jJAnabinduH kathaM tarhi zAstre cakSurdarzanAdipravAda ityata Aha --- " nANamapuTThe avisae a atthammi daMsaNaM hoi / muttUNa liGgao jaM aNAgayAIyavisaesu / / " [2/25] 2010_02 125

Page #171
126 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-26 aspRSTe'rthe cakSuSA ya udeti pratyayaH sa jJAnameva sat cakSurdarzanamityucyate, indriyANAmaviSaye ca paramANvAdAvarthe manasA ca udeti pratyayaH sa jJAnameva sadacakSurdarzanamityucyate / anumityAdirUpe manojanyajJAne'tiprasaGgamAzaGkyAha-anAgatAtItaviSayeSu yalliGgato jJAnamudeti 'ayaM kAla AsannabhaviSyadRSTikastathAvidhameghonnatimattvAt, ayaM pradeza AsannavRSTameghaH puravizeSavattvAt' ityAdi-rUpaM tanmuktvA / idamupalakSaNaM bhAvanAjanyajJAnAtiriktaparokSajJAnamAtrasya tasyA'spRSTAviSayArthasyA'pi darzanatvenA'vyavahArAt / [ aspRSTAviSayAvagAhitve'pi na manaHparyAyabodhasya darzanatvaprasaGga iti sayuktikaM pratipAdanam ] yadyaspRSTA'viSayArthajJAnaM darzanamabhidhIyate tataH maNapajjavaNANaM daMsaNaM ti teNeha hoi Na ya juttaM / bhaNNai NANaM NoiMdiyammi Na ghaDAdao jamhA / / 26 / / etena lakSaNena manaHparyAyajJAnamapi darzanaM prAptaM parakIyamanogatAnAM ghaTAdInAmAlambyAnAM tatrAsattvenAspRSTe'viSaye ca ghaTAdAvarthe tasya bhAvAt na caitad yuktam Agame tasya darzanatvenApAThAt / bhaNyate atrottaram NoiMdiyammi manovargaNAkhye manovizeSe pravartamAnaM manaHparyAyabodharUpaM jJAnameva na darzanaM yasmAdaspRSTA ghaTAdayo nAsya viSayo liGgAnumeyatvAt teSAm / tathA cAgamaH "jANai bajjhe'NumANAo" (vizeSA0 bhA0 gA0 814) / nanu ca parakIyamanogatArthAkAravikalpasyobhayarUpatvAt kimiti tadgrAhiNo manaHparyAyAvabodhasya na darzanarUpatA ? na, manovikalpasya bAhyArthacintanarUpasya vikalpAtmakatvena jJAnarUpatvAt tagrAhiNo manaHparyAyajJAnasyApi tadrUpataiva ghaTAdestu tatra parokSataiveti darzanasyAbhAva eva manovikalpAkArasyobhayarUpatve'pi chAdmasthikopayogasya paripUrNavastugrAhakatvAsaMbhavAJca na manaHparyAyajJAne darzanopayogasaMbhavaH / / 26 / / ____ 2010_02

Page #172
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-27 / 127 -: jJAnabinduH :yadyaspRSTAviSayArthajJAnaM darzanamabhimataM tarhi manaHparyAyajJAne'tiprasaGga ityAzaGkya samAdhatte "maNapajjavanANaM daMsaNaM ti teNeha hoi Na ya juttam / bhannai nANaM Noindiyammi Na ghaDAdao jmhaa||" [2/26] etena lakSaNena manaHparyAyajJAnamapi darzanaM prAptam, parakIyamanogatAnAM ghaTAdInAmAlambyAnAM tatrA'sattvenA'spRSTe'viSaye ca ghaTAdAvarthe tasyabhAvAt / na caitadyuktam, Agame tasya darzanatvenA'pAThAt / bhaNyate'trottaram-noindriye manovargaNAkhye manovizeSe pravartamAnaM manaHparyAyabodharUpaM jJAnameva na darzanam, yasmAdaspRSTA ghaTAdayo 'nA'sya viSaya' iti zeSaH, nityaM teSAM liGgAnumeyatvAt / tathAcA''gamaH "jANai bajjhe'NumANAo" (vizeSA. gA.814) tti / manovargaNAstu parAtmagatA api svAzrayAtmaspRSTajAtIyA eveti tadaMze'pi darzanatvaprasaGgaH / parakIyamanogatA'rthAkAravikalpa evA'sya grAhyastasya cobhayarUpatve'pi chAdmasthikopayogasyA'paripUrNArthagrAhitvAnna manaHparyAyajJAne darzanasambhava ityapyAhuH / [ aspRSTAviSayAvagAhi jJAnameva darzanam na tataH pRthagiti pratipAdanam ] kiJca, maisuyaNANaNimitto chaumatthe hoi atthauvalaMbho / egayarammi vi tesiM Na daMsaNaM daMsaNaM katto ? / / 27 / / matizrutajJAnanimittazchadmasthAnAmarthopalambha ukta Agame / tayorekatarasminnapi na darzanaM saMbhavati na tAvadavagraho darzanaM tasya jJAnAtmakatvAt tataH kuto darzanam ? nAstItyarthaH / aspRSTe'viSaye cArthe jJAnameva darzanaM nAnyaditi prasaktam / / 27 / / -: jJAnabinduH :kiJca "maisuanANaNimitto chaumatthe hoi atthauvalambho / egayarammi vi tesiM Na daMsaNaM dasaNaM katto / " [2/27] matizrutajJAnanimittazchadmasthAnAmarthopalambha ukta Agame / tayorekatarasminnapi na darzanaM sambhavati / na cA'vagraho darzanam, tasya jJAnAtmakatvAt / tataH kuto darzanam ? nAstItyarthaH / / 2010_02

Page #173
128 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-28-29 [ aspRSTArthAvagAhitve'pi zrutajJAnasya darzanatvAbhAvapratipAdanam ] nanu zrutamaspRSTe viSaye kimiti darzanaM na bhavet ? ityAha jaM paJcakkhaggahaNaM Na inti suyaNANasammiyA atthA / tamhA daMsaNasaddo Na hoi sayale vi suyaNANe / / 28 / / yasmAt zrutajJAnapramitAH padArthA upayuktAdhyayanaviSayAstathAbhUtArthavAcakatvAt zrutazabdasya pratyakSaM na gRhyante ato na zrutaM cakSurdarzanasaMjJam mAnasamacakSurdarzanaM zrutaM bhaviSyatItyetadapi nAsti avagrahasya matitvena pUrvameva darzanatayA nirastatvAt / / 28 / / . - -: jJAnabinduH :nanu zrutamaspRSTe'rthe kimiti darzanaM na bhavet ? tatrAha "jaM paJcakkhaggahaNaM Na inti suanANasammiyA atthA / tamhA saNasahotama Na hoi sayale vi suanANe / / " [2/28] __ yasmAcchrutajJAnapramitA arthAH pratyakSagrahaNaM na yAnti akSajasyaiva vyavahArataH pratyakSatvAt, tasmAt sakale'pi zrutajJAne darzanazabdo na bhavati / tathA ca vyaJjanAvagrahAviSayArthapratyakSatvameva darzanatvamiti paryavasannam / pratyakSapadAdeva zrutajJAnavadanumityAdeAvRttau parokSabhinnatve satIti vizeSaNaM na deyam, 'muttUNa liGgao jaM' ityuktasyApyatraiva tAtparyaM draSTavyam / itthaM cA'cakSurdarzanamityatra naJaH paryudAsArthakatvAdacakSurdarzanapadena mAnasadarzanameva grAhyam, aprApyakAritvena manasa eva cakSuHsadRzatvAnna ghrANadarzanAdIti sarvamupapadyate / [ avadhijJAna evaM pravRttinimittavazena darzanazabdasyApi labdhAvakAzatvasamarthanam ] nanvevamavadhidarzanasyApyabhAvaH syAdityAha jaM appuTThA bhAvA ohiNNANassa hoMti paJcakkhA / tamhA ohiNNANe saNasaddo vi uvautto / / 29 / / yasmAdaspRSTA bhAvA aNvAdayo'vadhijJAnasya pratyakSA bhavanti cakSurdarzanasyeva rUpasAmAnyam tatastatraiva darzanazabdo'pyupayuktaH / / 29 / / 2010_02

Page #174
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-30 129 ___-: jJAnabinduH :tathA ca 'avadhidarzanamapi kathaM saGgacchate ? tasya vyaJjanAvagrahAviSayArthagrAhitve'pi vyavahArataH pratyakSatvAbhAvAt - iti zaGkAyAH pratyakSapadasya vyavahAranizcayasAdhAraNapratyakSArthatvAt, avadhijJAnasya ca naipTAyikapratyakSatvA'vyAhateH parihAramabhiprAyannAha "jaM appuTThA bhAvA ohiNNANassa honti paJcakkhA / tamhA ohiNNANe daMsaNasaddo vi uvautto / / " [2/29] spaSTA / upayuktaH labdhanimittAvakAzaH / [ siddhAntinA ekasyaiva kevalopayogasya jJAnadarzanopayogadvayarUpatvavyAvarNanam ] kevalAvabodhastu jJAnadarzanopayogadvayAtmako jJAnameva san darzanamapyucyata ityAha jaM appuDhe bhAve jANai pAsai ya kevalI NiyamA / tamhA taM NANaM daMsaNaM ca avisesao siddhaM / / 30 / / yato'spRSTAn bhAvAnniyamenAvazyaMtayA kevalI cakSuSmAniva puraHsthitaM cakSuSA pazyati jAnAti cobhayaprAdhAnyena / tasmAt tat kevalAvabodhasvarUpaM jJAnamapyucyate darzanamapyavizeSata ubhayAbhidhAnanimittasyAvizeSAt na punarjJAnameva sadavizeSato'bhedato darzanamiti siddham / yato na jJAnamAtrameva tat nApi darzanamAtraM kevalam nApyubhayAkramarUpaM parasparaviviktam nApi kramasvabhAvam api tu jJAnadarzanAtmakamekaM pramANamanyathoktavat tadabhAvaprasaGgAt / . [sUryabhiprAyeNa jJAnapaJcaka-darzanacatuSkayoH svarUpavibhajanam] chadmasthAvasthAyAM tu pramANaprameyayoH sAmAnyavizeSAtmakatve'pyanapagatAvaraNasyAtmano darzanopayogasamaye jJAnopayogasyAsambhavAd aprApyakArinayana-manaHprabhavArthAvagrahAdimatijJAnopayogaprAktanI avasthA aspa(spR)STAvabhAsigrAhyagrAhakatvapariNatyavasthA vyavasthitAtmaprabodharUpA cakSuracakSurdarzanavyapadezamAsAdayati / dravyabhAvendriyAlokamatijJAnAvaraNakarmakSayopazamAdisAmagrIprabhavarUpAdiviSayagrahaNapariNatipTAtmano'vagrahAdirUpA matijJAnazabdavAcyatAma nute / 2010_02

Page #175
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA - 30 zrutajJAnAvaraNakarmakSayopazamavAkyazravaNAdisAmagrIvizeSanimittaprAdurbhUto vAkyArthagrahaNapariNatisvabhAvo vAkyazravaNAnimitto vA AtmanaH zrutajJAnamiti zabdAbhidheyatAmApnoti / 130 rUpidravyagrahaNapariNativizeSastu jIvasya bhavaguNapratyayAvadhijJAnAvaraNakarmakSayopazamaprAdurbhUto locanAdibAhyanimittanirapekSaH avadhijJAnamiti vyapadizyate tajjJaiH avadhidarzanAvaraNakarmakSayopazamaprAdurbhUtastu sa eva taddravyasAmAnyaparyAlocanasvabhAvo'vadhidarzanavyapadezabhavati / bhAg ardhatRtIyadvIpasamudrAntarvartisakalamanovikalpagrahaNapariNatirmanaHparyAyajJAnAvaraNakarmakSayopazamAdiviziSTasAmagrIsamutpAditA cakSurAdikaraNanirapekSasyAtmanaH manaHparyAyajJAnamiti vadanti vidvAMsaH / chAdmasthikopayogaM cAtmA svapradezAvaraNakSayopazamadvAreNa pratipadyate na tvanantajJeyajJAnasvabhAvasyAtmana etadeva khaNDazaH pratipattilakSaNaM pAramArthikaM rUpaM sAmAnyavizeSAtmakavastuvistaravyApi yugapatparicchedasvabhAvadvayAtmakaikakevalAvabodhatAttvikarUpatvAt tasya / tacca tasya svarUpaM kevalajJAnadarzanAvaraNakarmakSayAvirbhUtaM karaNakramavyavadhAnAtivartisakalalokAlokaviSayatrikAlasvabhAvapariNAmabhedAnantapadArthayugapatsAmAnyavizeSasAkSAtkaraNapravRttaM kevalajJAnaM kevaladarzanamiti ca vyapadizyate / tena 'avagraharUpa Abhinibodho darzanam sa eva cehAdirUpo vizeSagrAhako jJAnaM tadvyatiriktasyAparasya grAhakasyAbhAvAt tasyaivaikasya tathAgrahaNAt tathAvyapadezAdutphaNaviphaNAvasthAsarppadravyavat tatastayoravasthayoravyatirekAt tasya ca tadrUpatvAdeka evAbhinibodho darzanaM matijJAnaM cAbhidhIyata iti sUtrakRto'bhiprAyaH' iti yat kaiSTid vyAkhyAtaM tadasaGgataM lakSyate AgamavirodhAt yuktivirodhAcca / na hyekAntato'bhede pUrvamavagraho darzanaM paSTAd IhAdikaM jJAnaM tayoSTA tatrAntarbhAva iti zakyamabhidhAtum kathaMcidbhedanibandhanatvAdasya AtmarUpatayA tu tayorabhedo'bhyupagamyata eva / na caikasyaiva matijJAnasyobhayamadhyapAtAdubhayavyapadezaH avagrahasya darzanatve 'avagrahAdidhAraNAparyantaM matijJAnam' ityasya vyAhateH tasya vA'darzanatve 'avagrahamAtraM darzanam' ityasya virodhAt AgamavirodhaSTA tadvyatirekeNa darzanAnabhyupagame tadabhyupagame vA'STAviMzatibheda 2010_02

Page #176
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA - 30 matijJAnavyatiriktadarzanAbhyupagamAt kuto jJAnameva darzanaM chadmasthAvasthAyAm ? kevalyavasthAyAM tu kSINAvaraNasyA''tmano nityopayuktatvAt sadaiva darzanAvasthA vartamAnapariNatervastuno'vagamarUpAyAH prAk tathAbhUtAnavabodharUpatvAsaMbhavAt tathAbhUtajJAnavikalAvasthAsaMbhave vA prAgitarapuruSAvizeSaprasaGgAt / tato yugapajjJAnadarzanopayogadvayAtmakaikopayogarUpaH kevalAvabodho'bhyupagantavya iti sUrerabhiprAyaH / / 30 / / jJAnabinduH - kevalajJAne'pIdaM lakSaNamavyAhatamityAha -- "jaM appuTThe bhAve jANai pAsai ya kevalI niyamA / tamhA taM nANaM daMsaNaM ca avisesao siddhaM / / " [2/30] 131 yato'spRSTAn bhAvAnniyamenA'vazyatayA kevalI cakSuSmAniva puraHsthitaM jAnAti pazyati cobhayaprAdhAnyena tasmAttatkevalajJAnaM darzanaM cAvizeSataH ubhayAbhidhAnanimittasyAvizeSAt siddham / manaHpraryAyajJAnasya tu vyaJjanAvagrahA' viSayArthakapratyakSatve'pi bAhyaviSaye vyabhicAreNa svagrAhyatAvacchedakAvacchedena pratyakSatvAnna darzanatvamiti niSkarSaH / atra yaTTIkAkRtA - pramANaprameyayoH sAmAnyavizeSAtmakatve'pyapanItAvaraNe yugapadubhayasvabhAvo bodhaH, chadmasthA'vasthAyAM tvanapagatAvaraNatvena darzanopayogasamaye jJAnopayogAbhAvAdaprApyakArinayanamanaH prabhavA'rthAvagrahAdimatijJAnopayogaprAkkAle cakSuracakSurdarzane avadhijJAnopayogaprAkkAle cAvadhidarzanamAvirbhavati' iti vyAkhyAtaM tadardhajaratIyanyAyamanuharati, prAcInapraNayamAtrAnurodhe zrotrAdijJAnAd prAgapi darzanA'bhyupagamasyA'varjanIyatvAt, vyaJjanAvagrahArthAvagrahAntarAle darzanAnupalambhAt, tadanirdezAcca, asaGkhyeyasAmayikavyaJjanAvagrahAntyakSaNe " tAhe hunti kare " ( nandI0 sU0 35) ityAgamenArthAvagrahotpattereva bhaNanAt, vyaJjanAvagrahaprAkkAle darzanaparikalpanasya cAtyantA'nucitatvAt / tathA sati tasyendriyArthasannikarSAdapi nikRSTatvenAnupayogatvaprasaGgAcca / prApyakArIndriyajajJAnasthale darzanAnupagame cAnyatrApi bhinnatatkalpane na kiJcitpramANam, 'nANamapuTTe' ityAdinA jJAnAdabhedenaiva darzanasvabhAvapratipAdanAt 'cakSurvadviSayAkhyAtiH' ityAdistutigranthaikavAkyatayA'pi tathaiva svArasyAcca / chadmasthajJAnopayoge darzanopayogatvena hetutve tu cakSuSyeva darzanaM nAnyatreti kathaM zraddheyam ? tasmAcchrIsiddhasenopajJanavyamate na kutrA'pi jJAnAddarzanasya kAlabhedaH / kintu svagrAhyatAvacchedakAvacchedena vyaJjanAvagrahA'viSayIkRtArthapratyakSatvameva darzanamiti phalitam / 2010_02

Page #177
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-31 yadi ca cAkSuSAdAvapi jJAnasAmagrIsAmarthyagrAhyavartamAnakAlAdyaMze mitimAtrAdyaMze ca na darzanatvavyavahArastadA viSayatAvizeSa eva darzanatvam / sa ca kacidaMze yogyatAvizeSajanyatA'vacchedakaH, kvaciJca bhAvanAvizeSajanyatA'vacchedakaH, kevale ca sarvAMze AvaraNakSayajanyatA'vacchedaka iti pratipattavyam / na ca 'arthenaiva dhiyAM vizeSa iti (nyA0ku0 4-4) nyAyAdarthA'vizeSa jJAne viSayatAvizeSA'siddhiH' iti zaGkanIyam, arthe'pi jJAnAnurUpasvabhAvaparikalpanAt, arthA'vizeSe'pi paraiH samUhAlambanAdviziSTajJAnasya vyAvRttaye prakAritAvizeSasyA'bhyupagamAJca / na hi tasya tatra bhAsamAnavaiziSTyapratiyogitAjJAnatvameva viziSTyajJAnatvaM vaktuM zakyam, daNDapuruSasaMyogA iti samUhAlambane'tiprasaGgAt / na ca bhAsamAnaM yadvaiziSTyapratiyogitvaM (tannirUpakajJAnatvameva tathA, 'daNDapuruSasaMyogapratiyogitvAnuyogitvAnI'ti jJAne daNDaviziSTajJAnatvApatteH / na ca svarUpato bhAsamAnamityAdhuktAvapi nistAraH, pratiyogitvAderatiriktatve prakAritatvAderjJAnaniSThasya kalpanAyA eva laghutvAt / anatireke tu daNDadaNDatvAnirvikalpake'pi daNDAdiviziSTajJAnatvApatteH / etena svarUpato bhAsamAnena vaiziSTyena garbhitalakSaNamapyapAstam, saMyuktasamavAyAdeH sambandhatve svarUpata ityasya durvacatvAJca / tasmAt parAbhyupagataprakAritAvizeSavadAkAravizeSaH syAdvAdamudrayA'rthAnuruddhastadananuruddho vA jJAne darzanazabdavyapadezaheturanAvilastatsamaya evA'rthajJAnayoravinigamenA''kArAkAribhAvasvabhAvAvirbhAvAdityeSa punarasmAkaM manISonmeSaH / [ eka eka kevalopayogo vyAtmaka iti svasiddhAntaH samayAntarotpAdavacanaM tu paratIrthikamatakathanamiti vibhajanam ] dvayAtmaka eka eva kevalAvabodha iti darzayannAha sAI apajjavasiyaM ti do vi te sasamayao havai evaM / paratitthiyavattavvaM ca egasamayaMtaruppAo / / 31 / / dve api te jJAnadarzane yadi yugapad na nAnA bhavatastadA svasamayaH svasiddhAntaH "sAdyaparyavasite' iti ghaTate yastvekasamayAntarotpAdastayoH 'yadA jAnAti tadA na pazyati' ityevamabhidhIyate sa paratIrthikazAstraM nArhadvacanama nayAbhiprAyeNa pravRttatvAditi sUrerabhiprAyaH / / 31 / / 2010_02

Page #178
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-32 133 -: jJAnabinduH :tasmAd dvyAtmaka eka eva kevalAvabodha iti phalitaM svamatamupadarzayati "sAI apajjavasiyaM ti do vi te sasamayaM havai evaM / paratitthiyavattavyaM ca egasamayaMtaruppAo / / " [2/31] sAdyaparyavasitaM kevalamiti hetojhai api jJAnadarzane te ubhayazabdavAcyaM taditi yAvat / ayaM ca svasamayaH svasiddhAntaH / yastvekasamayAntarotpAdastayorbhaNyate tatparatIrthikazAstram, nArhadvacanam, nayA'bhiprAyeNa pravRttatvAditi bhAvaH / [ evaMbhUtatattvazraddhAnarUpasya samyagdarzanasya samyagjJAnarUpatvameva iti varNanam ] evaMbhUtaM vastutattvaM zraddadhAnaH samyagjJAnavAneva puruSaH samyagdRSTirityAha evaM jiNapaNNatte saddahamANassa bhAvao bhAve / purisassAbhiNibohe saNasaddo havai jutto / / 32 / / evamanantaroktavidhinA jinaprajJaptAna bhAvAn zraddadhAnasya puruSasya yadAbhinibodhikaM jJAnaM tadeva samyagdarzanam viziSTAvabodharUpAyA ruceH samyagdarzanazabdavAcyatvAditi bhAvaH / / 32 / / -: jJAnabindu: :evambhUtavastutattvazraddhAnarUpaM samyagdarzanamapi samyagjJAnavizeSa eva / samyagdarzanatvasyA'pi samyagjJAnatvavyApyajAtivizeSarUpatvAt, viSayatAvizeSarUpatvAdvetyAha "evaM jiNapaNNatte saddahamANassa bhAvao bhAve / purisassAbhiNibohe daMsaNasaddo havai jutto / / " [2/32] jinaprajJaptabhAvaviSayaM samUhAlambanaM rucirUpaM jJAnaM mukhyaM samyagdarzanam, tadvAsanopanItArthaviSayaM ghaTAdijJAnamapi bhAktaM taditi tAtparyArthaH / -: tattvArthAdhigamasUtre : mahAmaho.yazovijayajIkRtavivaraNe a.1, sU.1 atredamavadheyam, na hyapAyamAtre rucitvaM vaktuM zakyaM ghaTAdyapAye tadananubhavAt, kintu jIvAjIvAdi 2010_02

Page #179
134 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-33 samUhAlambanajJAnavizeSa eva, ata eva zraddhAtvaM jJAnatvavyApyo jAtivizeSa iti pare'pi vadanti, tadavacchinne ca darzanAvaraNakSayopazamAnAmekazaktimattvAdinA hetutvamiti jJAnAvaraNavizeSa eva darzanAvaraNam, pRthagvibhAgAdiprakriyA tu govRSanyAyAt, tadidamabhipretyoktaM sammatau "evaM jiNapaNNate, saddahamANassa bhAvao bhAve / purisassAbhiNibohe, daMsaNasaddo havai jutto / / 1 / / tti" zraddadhataH samUhAlambanatayA'vagRhNato bhAvato rucirUpatayA / tathA ca pUrvadvayalAbhe bhajanIyamuttaramiti keyaM vAco yuktiH, dvitIyalAbhe prathamasyApi bhajanIyatvAvakAzAt / yadi ca mukhyaM samyagdarzanaM rucirUpoktajJAnavizeSa eva, bhAktaM cAnekAntAgamavAsanopanItasarvAnaikAntyAvagAhighaTAdyapAyo'pIti tadubhayasAmAnyaM sagRhyate tadA bhavati samyagjJAnena samaM sAmanaiyatyam / [ samyagjJAne darzanatvasya niyatatayA darzane samyagjJAnatvasya vikalpanIyatayA samyagdarzanaM viziSTajJAnarUpameva iti phalitAbhidhAnam ] nanu yadi samyagjJAne samyagdarzanaM niyamena darzane'pi samyagjJAnaM kimiti na syAt ? na, ekAntarucAvapi samyagjJAnaprasakterityAha sammaNNANe NiyameNa daMsaNaM daMsaNe u bhayaNijjaM / sammaNNANaM ca imaM ti atthao hoi uvavaNNaM / / 33 / / samyagjJAne niyamena samyagdarzanaM darzane punarbhajanIyaM vikalpanIyaM samyagjJAnam ekAntarucau na saMbhavati anekAntarucau tu samyagdarzane samasti / yatapTauvamataH samyagjJAnaM cedaM samyagdarzanaM ca viziSTarucisvabhAvamavabodharUpamarthataH sAmarthyAdupapannaM bhavati / / 33 / / -: jJAnabinduH :nanu samyagjJAne samyagdarzananiyamavaddarzane'pi samyagjJAnaniyamaH kathaM na syAt, ityatrAha "sammannANe NiyameNa daMsaNaM, daMsaNe u bhayaNijaM / sammannANaM ca imaM ti atthao hoi uvavaNNaM / / " [2/33] samyagjJAne niyamena samyagdarzanam, darzane punarbhajanIyaM vikalpanIyam, samyagjJAnaM ekAntarucau na 2010_02

Page #180
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA- 33 sambhavati, anekAntarucau tu samastIti / ataH samyagjJAnaM cedaM samyagdarzanaM cetyarthataH sAmarthyAdekamevopapannaM bhavati / tathA ca samyaktvamiva darzanaM jJAnavizeSarUpameveti nirvyUDham / prAcAM vAcAM vimukhaviSayonmeSa sUkSmekSikAyAm, ye'raNyAnIbhayamadhigatA navyamArgA'nabhijJAH / teSAmeSA samayavaNijAM sanmatigranthagAthA; vizvAsAya svanayavipraNiprAjyavANijyavIthI / / 1 / / bhedagrAhivyavahatinayaM saMzrito mallavAdI, pUjyAH prAyaH karaNaphalayoH sImni zuddharjusUtram / bhedocchedonmukhamadhigataH saGgrahaM siddhasena - stasmAdete na khalu viSamAH sUripakSAstrayo'pi / / 2 / / citsAmAnyaM puruSapadabhAkkevAkhye vizeSe, tadrUpeNa sphuTamabhihitaM sAdhanantaM yadeva / sUkSmairaMzaiH kramavadidamapyucyamAnaM na duSTam; tatsUrINAmiyamabhimatA mukhyagauNavyavasthA / / 3 / / tamo'pagamacijjanuH kSaNabhidAnidAnodbhavAH, zrutA bahutarAH zrute yavivAdapakSA yathA / tathA ka iva vismayo bhavatu sUripakSatraye; pradhAnapadavI dhiyAM kva na davIyasI dRzyate / / 4 / / prasahya sadasattvayorna hi virodhanirNAyakam vizeSaNavizeSyayorapi niyAmakaM yatra na / guNA'guNavibhedato matirapekSayA syAtpadAt; kimatra bhajanorjite svasamaye na saGgacchate ! / / 5 / / pramANanayasaGgatA svasamaye'pyanekAntadhI-, 1 rnayasmayataTasthatollasadupAdhikirmIritA / kadAcana na bAdhate sugurusampradAyakramam; samaJjasapadaM vadantyurudhiyo hi saddarzanam ||6 / / 2010_02 135

Page #181
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-33 rahasyaM jAnante kimapi na nayAnAM hatadhiyo, virodhaM bhASante vividhabudhapakSe bata khalAH / amI candrA''dityaprakRtivikRtivyatyayagiraH; nirAtaGkA kutrA'pyahaha na guNAnveSaNaparAH / / 7 / / syAdvAdasya jJAnabindoramandAnmandAradroH ko phalAsvAdagarvaH, drAkSAsAkSAtkArapIyUSadhArAdArAdInAM ko vilAsapTA ramyaH / / 8 / / -: tattvArthAdhigamasUtre : mahAmaho.yazovijayajIkRtavivaraNe a.1, sU.1 tadidamAhasammannANe NiyameNa daMsaNaM daMsaNe u bhaiavvaM / sammannANaM ca imaM, ti atthao hoi uvavannaM / / 1 / / darzane tu bhaktavyam, iti, ekAntarucau na bhavatyanekAntarucau tu bhavatyeveti, avizeSitadarzanena saha bhajanoktAvapi samyakpadavizeSaNe, neyamityAzayenAha-'idaM samyagdRSTipratyakSaM samyagjJAnaM cazabdAt samyagdarzanamityarthata upapannam' arthApattisiddhamityartha iti / idaM punaranyadavadheyam / evaM sati cAritramapi jJAnavizeSa eva, viSayapratibhAsAtmajJAnatattvasaMvedaneSu buddhijJAnA'sammoheSu ca tRtIyasya tatsthAne'bhiSecanIyatvAt, tadAvaraNasya ca cAritramohatvena pRthagabhidhAnaM prAgvadeva, jJAnaikazeSe vinigamakaM cAtmaguNAnAmAtmano jJasvAbhAvyameva / tadidamuktam "AtmAnamAtmanA vetti, mohatyAgAdyadAtmani / tadeva tasya cAritram, tajjJAnaM tacca darzanam / / 1 / / " tathA ca uttaralAbhe pUrvadvayanaiyatyaM svarUpato na tu bhedagarbhatayeti dig / [ sUtroktaM sAdyaparyavasitatvaM zabdazaH spRzatAM keSAMcidAcAryANAM garviSThatayA samyagvAditvAbhAvapratipAdanam ] atra sAdyaparyavasitaM kevalajJAnaM sUtre pradarzitam anumAnaM ca tathAbhUtasya tasya pratipAdakaM saMbhavati / tathAhi-ghAtikarmacatuSTayaprakSayAvirbhUtatvAt kevalaM sAdi na ca tathotpannasya paSTAttasyAvaraNamasti ato'nantamiti na punarutpadyate vinAzapUrvakatvAdutpAdasya na hi 2010_02

Page #182
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-34-35 137 ghaTasyAvinAze kapAlAnAmutpAdo dRSTa ityanutpAdavyayAtmakaM kevalamityabhyupagamavato nirAkartumAha kevalaNANaM sAI apajjavasiyaM ti dAiyaM sutte / tettiyamittottUNA kei visesaM Na icchaMti / / 34 / / kevalajJAnaM sAdyaparyavasitamiti darzitaM sUtre ityetAvanmAtreNa garvitAH kecana vizeSa paryAyaM paryavasitatvasvabhAvaM vidyamAnamapi necchanti te na ca samyagvAdinaH / / 34 / / . [ siddhAntinA kevalasya paryavasitatvapradarzanam ] yataH - je saMghayaNAIyA bhavatthakevalivisesapajjAyA / te sijjhamANasamaye Na hoMti vigayaM tao hoi / / 35 / / ye vajraRSabhanArAcasaMhananAdayo bhavasthasya kevalinaH AtmapudgalapradezayoranyonyAnuvedhAd vyavasthiteH vizeSaparyAyAste sidhyatsamaye'pagacchanti tadapagame tadavyatiriktasya kevalajJAnasyApyAtmadravyadvAreNa vigamAt anyathA'vasthAturavasthAnAmAtyantikabhedaprasakteH kevalajJAnaM tato vigataM bhavatIti sUtrakRto'bhiprAyaH / / 35 / / -: dravyaguerAparyAyano rAsa : a.c, u.14 eNaI bhAvaI bhAsiuM sammati mAMhi e bhAva re. saMghayaNAdika bhavabhAvathI, sIjhaMtAM kevala jAI re. 147 jina bh-525||mthii sarva dravyana sikSAyoga samarthiI . me 4 abhiprAya-sammati graMthamAMDiM me bhAvabhASiuM je-"je saMghayaNAdika bhavabhAvathI sIjhatAM mokSasamayai kevalajJAna jAI-bhavasthakevalajJAna paryAyaI nAza thAI, e artha te siddhapaNai-siddha kevalajJAnapaNaI UpajaI, tehaja-kevalajJAnabhAva chaI-dhruva chaI. e mokSagamana-samayache je vyayaH utpatiH huA, tatpariNatasiddhadravyAnugamathI zivamAMbhokssmaaBi 3. lakSaL 5. gAthe _ 2010_02

Page #183
138 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 2, gAthA - 36-37-38 je saMghayaNAIA, bhavatthakevalivisesapajjAyA / sijjhamANasamae, Na hoMti vigayaM tao hoi ||2 / 35 / / siddhattaNeNa ya puNo uppaNNo esa atthapajjAo / kevalabhAvaM tu paDucca kevalaM dAiaM sutte / / 2 / 36 / / bhAva senA "kevalanANe duvihe paNNatte - bhavatthakevalanANe ya siddhakevalanANe ya" hatyAhi sUtri upadeza chaI 147. [ sidhyatsamaye kevalasya vinAzavad utpAdasyApi pradarzanam aparyavasitatvaviSayakasUtrokterapekSAvizeSeNa samarthanaM ca ] vinAzavat kevalajJAnasyotpAdo'pi sidhyatsamaya ityAha siddhattaNeNa ya puNo uppaNNo esa atthapajjAo / kevalabhAvaM tu paDu kevalaM dAiyaM sute / 36 / / siddhatvenAzeSakarmavigamarUpeNa punaH pUrvavadutpanna eSa kevalajJAnAkhyo'rthaparyAya utpAdavigamadhrauvyAtmakatvAd vastunaH anyathA vastutvahAneH / yat tvaparyavasitatvaM sUtre kevalasya darzitaM tat tasya kevalabhAvaM sattAmAtramAzritya kathaMcidAtmAvyatiriktatvAt tasya AtmaSTA dravyarUpatayA nityatvAt / / 36 / / [ svarUpa lakSaNAbhyAM jIva- kevalayorbhede satyapi kathaM tayorekatvamityasyAH keSAMcidAzaGkAyA ullekhaH ] nanu kevalajJAnasyAtmarUpatAmAzritya tasyotpAdavinAzAbhyAM kevalasya tau bhavataH na cAtmanaH kevalarUpateti kutastaddvAreNa tasya tAvityAha jIvo aNAiNihaNo kevalaNANaM tu sAiyamaNaMtaM / ia thorammi visese kaha jIvo kevalaM hoi / / 37 / / tamhA aNNo jIvo aNNe NANAipajjavA tassa / uvasamiyAIlakkhaNavisesao kei icchanti / / 38 / / 2010_02

Page #184
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-39-40 139 . jIvo'nAdinidhanaH kevalajJAnaM tu sAdyaparyavasitamiti sthUre viruddhadharmAdhyAsalakSaNe vizeSe chAyAtapavadatyantabhedAt kathaM jIvaH kevalaM bhavet ? jIvasyaiva tAvat kevalarUpatA asaMgatA dUrataH saMhananAderiti bhAvaH / / 37 / / tasmAd viruddhadharmAdhyAsato'nyo jIvo jJAnAdiparyAyebhyaH anye ca tato jJAnAdiparyAyA lakSaNabhedAJca tayorbhedaH / tathAhi - jJAna-darzanayoH kSAyikaH kSAyopazamiko vA bhAvo lakSaNam jIvasya tu pAriNAmikAdi vo lakSaNamiti kecit vyAkhyAtAraH pratipannAH / / 38 / / [ prAguktAmAzaGkAM nirasitumupakramaH ] etanniSedhAyAha aha puNa puvvapayutto attho egaMtapakkhapaDisehe / / taha vi uyAharaNamiNaM ti heupaDijoaNaM vocchaM / / 39 / / yadyapyayaM pUrvameva dravyaparyAyayorbhedAbhedaikAntapakSapratiSedhalakSaNo'rthaH prayukto yojitaH 'uppAya-TThii-bhaMgA' [pra0 kA0 gA0 12] ityAdinA anekAntavyavasthApanAt tathApi kevalajJAne anekAntAtmakaikarUpaprasAdhakasya hetoH sAdhyenAnugamapradarzakapramANaviSayamudAharaNamidamuttaragAthayA vakSye / / 39 / / [ anekAntAtmakaikarUpatvena sAdhyena sattvasya hetorvyAptiM prasAdhayituM dRSTAntopanyAsaH ] tadevAha jaha koi sadvivariso tIsaivariso NarAhivo jAo / ubhayattha jAyasaddo varisavibhAgaM visesei / / 40 / / yathA kaSTiAt puruSaH SaSTivarSaH sarvAyuSkamAzritya triMzadvarSaH sannarAdhipo jAta ubhayatra manuSye rAjani ca jAtazabdo'yaM prayukto varSavibhAgamevAsya darzayati / SaSTivarSAyuSkasya puruSasAmAnyasya narAdhipaparyAyo'yaM jAtaH abhedAdhyAsitabhedAtmakatvAt paryAyasya narAdhipaparyAyAtmakatvena cAyaM puruSaH punarjAto bhedAnuSaktAbhedAtmakatvAt sAmAnyasya ekAntabhede'bhede vA tayorabhAvaprasaGgAnnirAzrayasya paryAyaprAdurbhAvasya tadvikalasya vA 2010_02

Page #185
140 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-41-42 sAmAnyasyAsaMbhavAt saMzayavirodhavaiyadhikaraNyA'navasthobhayadoSAdInAmanekAntavAde ca prAgeva nirastatvAt / / 40 / / [ dRSTAntagRhItavyApteH sattvahetordAAntike kevale upanayanam ] dRSTAntaM prasAdhya dAAntikayojanAyAha evaM jIvaddavvaM aNAiNihaNamavisesiyaM jamhA / rAyasariso u kevalipajjAo tassa sa viseso // 41 / / evamanantaroktadRSTAntavajjIvadravyamanAdinidhanamavizeSitabhavyajIvarUpaM sAmAnyaM yato rAjatvaparyAyasadRzaH kevalitvaparyAyastasya tathAbhUtajIvadravyasya vizeSastasmAt tena rUpeNa. jIvadravyasAmAnyasyApi kathaMcidutpatteH sAmAnyamapyutpannaM prAktanarUpasya vigamAt sAmAnyamapi tadabhinnaM kathaMcid vigataM pUrvottarapiNDaghaTaparyAyaparityAgopAdAnapravRttaikamRdravyavat kevalarUpatayA jIvarUpatayA vA anAdinidhanatvAnnityaM dravyamabhyupagantavyam pratikSaNabhAviparyAyAnusyUtasya ca mRdravyasyAdhyakSato'nubhUtena dRSTAntAsiddhistasmAt kevalaM kathaMcit sAdi kathaMcidanAdi kathaMcit saparyavasAnaM kathaMcidaparyavasAnaM sattvAdAtmavaditi sthitam / / 41 / / [ jIva-tatparyAyagataM prAmANikaM vyavahAramAzritya dravyaparyAyayorekAntabhedanirAkaraNam ] na dravyaM paryAyebhyo bhinnamevetyAha jIvo aNAinihaNo 'jIva' tti ya Niyamao Na vattavyo / jaM purisAuyajIvo devAuyajIviyavisiTTho // 42 // jIvo'nAdinidhano 'jIva' eva vizeSavikala iti niyamato na vaktavyam / yataH puruSAyuSkajIvo devAyuSkajIvAd viziSTo jIva eva iti tvabhede puruSajIva ityAdibhedo na bhavet kevalasya sAmAnyasya vizeSapratyayAbhidhAnAnibandhanatvAnninimittasyApi vizeSapratyayAbhidhAnasya saMbhave sAmAnyapratyayAbhidhAnasyApi nirnimittasyaiva bhAvAt tannibandhanasAmAnyAbhyupagamo'pyuyuktaH syAditi sarvAbhAvaH / na ca vizeSapratyayasya bAdhArahitasyApi mithyAtvamitaratrApi tatprasakteriti pratipAdanAt / / 42 / / 2010_02

Page #186
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-2, gAthA-43 141 [ Atmadravyasya svAbhAvikairvebhAvikaipTA paryAyaiH kathaMcidekAnekatvapradarzanam ] kevalajJAnasya kathaMcidAtmA'vyatirekAdAtmano vA kevalajJAnAvyatirekAt kathaJcidekatvaM tayorityAha saMkhejjamasaMkhejjaM aNaMtakappaM ca kevalaM NANaM / taha rAgadosamohA aNNe vi ya jIvapajjAyA / / 43 / / Atmana ekatvAta kathaJcita tadavyatiriktaM kevalamapyekama kevalasya vA jJAnadarzanarUpatayA dvirUpatvAt tadavyatirikta AtmA'pi dvirUpaH asaMkhyeyapradezAtmakatvAdAtmanaH kevalamapyasaMkhyeyam anantArthaviSayatayA kevalasyAnantatvAdAtmA'pyanantaH / evaM rAgadveSamohA anye'pi jIvaparyAyAzchadmasthAvasthAbhAvinaH saMkhyeyA'saMkhyeyAnantaprakArA AlambyabhedAt tadAtmakatvAt saMsAryAtmA'pi tadvat tathaiva syAt / somilabrAhmaNapraznaprativacane cAgame etadarthapratipAdakaM ca sUtram-"ege bhavaM duve bhavaM" ityAdi "jAva aNegabhUyabhAvabhavie bhavaM" iti prazne uttaraM-"somilA ! ege vi ahaM jAva aNegabhUyabhAvabhavie ya ahaM / se keNaTeNaM bhaMte ! evaM vuJcai ? ege vi ahaM" ityAdyuttarahetuprazne hetupratipAdanam / "somilA ! davvaTThayAe ege ahaM, NANadaMsaNaTThayAe duve ahaM" [bhagavatI0 za0 18 u0 10 sU0 647] ityAdi prakRtArthasaMvAdi siddham | rAgAdInAM caikAdyanantabhedatvamAtmaparyAyatvAt yo hyAtmaparyAyaH sa ekAdyanantabhedo yathA kevalAvabodhastathA ca rAgAdaya iti sthityutpattinirodhAtmakatvamarhatyapi siddhamiti yat pareNoktama - "anekAntAtmakatvAbhAve'pi kevalini sattvAta yat sat tat sarvamanekAntAtmakamiti pratipAdakasya zAsanasyAvyApakatvAt kusamayavizAsitvaM tasyAsiddham" [ ] iti tat pratyuktaM draSTavyam / / 43 / / iti tattvabodhavidhAyinyAM sammatiTIkAyAM dvitIyaM kANDam / 2010_02

Page #187
142 THA HE * anusiddhasenaM kavayaH / - kalikAlasarvajJazrIhemacandrasUrimahArAjA / / * bhaNNai egateNaM amhANaM kammavAya No iTTho / Na ya No sahAvavAo suakevaliNA jao bhaNiaM / / 1047 / / AyariyasiddhaseNeNa sammaIe paiTTi ajaseNaM / dUsamaNisAdivAgarakappattaNao tadakkheNaM / / 1048 / / paJcavastau, pU.A.zrIharibhadrasUrimahArAjA tathA ca mahAmatiH xxx hA - uttarAdhyayanasUtre, vAdivetAlazAMtisUrimahArAjA / / E 2010_02

Page #188
rAjagacchIya-tarkapaJcAnana-zrImadabhayadevasUrinirmitatattvabodhavidhAyinyAkhyAyAH vyAkhyAyAH mUlagAthAsparzivyAkhyAMzasahitaM katipayamUlagAthAnAM ca vibhinnagrantheSu tattadgranthakAraiH kAritAbhirvRttibhiryuktaM mahAdArzanikaziromaNivikramAdityAdinRpatipratibodhakazrIsiddhasenadivAkararacitaM saMmatitarka-prakaraNam / tRtIyakANDaH / [ sAmAnyavizeSayoranyonyAnuviddhasvarUpatvapradarzanam ] evaM darzana-jJAnAtmanoH parasparavinirbhAgarUpatAM pratipAdya idAnIM sAmAnya-vizeSayoranyonyAnuviddhaM svarUpamupadarzayannAha sAmaNNammi viseso visesapakkhe ya vayaNaviNiveso / davvapariNAmamaNNaM dAei tayaM ca Niyamei / / 1 / / sAmAnye 'asti' ityetasmin, vizeSo dravyamityayam; tathA vizeSapakSe ca ghaTAdau, 'asti' ityetasya vacanasya nAma-nAmavatorabhedAt sattAsAmAnyasya, vinivezaH pradarzanam, dravyapariNatimanyAM sattAkhyasya dravyasya pRthivyAkhyAM pariNatimanyAM sattArUpAparityAgenaiva vRttAM darzayati vizeSAbhAve sAmAnyasyApyanyathAbhAvaprasakteH-yad yadAtmakaM tat tadabhAve na bhavati, ghaTAdyanyatamavizeSAbhAve mRdvad vizeSAtmakaM ca sAmAnyamiti tadabhAve tasyApyabhAvaH / tathA, takaM ca vizeSam, dvitIyapakSe sAmAnyAtmani niyamayati vizeSaH sAmAnyAtmaka eva tadabhAve tasyApyabhAvaprasaGgAd yataH sAmAnyAtmakasya vizeSasya sAmAnyAbhAve, ghaTAderiva mRdabhAve, na bhAvo yuktaH / / 1 / / [ sAmAnya-vizeSayorekAntabhedaM vadato doSApattiprakaTanam ] na ca vizeSAd vyatiriktaM sAmAnyamekAntataH, tasmAd vA vizeSA niyamato bhinnAH, ityabhyupagantavyam adhyakSAdipramANavirodhAd ityAha 2010_02

Page #189
144 etaNivvisesaM eyaMtavisesiyaM ca vayamANo / davvassa pajjave, pajjavAhi daviyaM Niyattei ||2|| saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 3, gAthA- 2 ekAntena nirgatA vizeSA yasmAt sAmAnyAt tad vizeSavikalaM sAmAnyaM vadan dravyasya paryAyAn RjutvAdIn nivartayati Rju-vakratAparyAyAtmikAGgulyAdidravyasya adhyakSAdipramANapratIyamAnasya vinivRttiprasakteradhyakSAdipramANabAdhApattiH / tathA, ekAntavizeSaM sAmAnyarahitaM vadan paryAyebhyo vizeSebhyo dravyaM nivartayati, evaM cAGgulyAdidravyA'vyatiriktaRjuvakratAdivizeSasya pratyakSAdyavagatasya nivRttiprasaktiH / na cA'bAdhitapramANaviSayIkRtasya tathAbhUtasya tasya nivRttiryuktA, sarvabhAvanivRttiprasakteH anyabhAvAbhyupagamasyApi tannibandhanatvAt tatpratItasyApyabhAve sarvavyavahArAbhAva iti pratipAditam / atrAha-'sAmaNNammi' ityAdikANDaM nA''rabdhavyam uktArthatvAt, yato na tAvadanena vastu anekAntAtmakaM pratipAdyate ' egadaviyammi' [ pra0 kA 0 gA0 31] ityAdinA 'iharA samUhasiddha'[pra0 kA0 gA0 27] ityAdinA ca tasya pratipAditatvAt / tathA, 'uppAya-TThii-bhaMgA haMdi daviyalakkhaNaM eyaM' [pra0 kA0 gA0 12] ityanena lakSaNadvAreNa sarvasya sataH anekAntAtmakatvaM pradarzitameva / atha pramANaviSayavAkyanirUpaNArthamidaM prastUyate, tadapi na samyak ; 'saviyappaNivviyappaM' [pra0 kA0 gA0 35] ityAdinA tasyApi nirUpitatvAd vAkyasya ca vastutvAt tannirUpaNe tasyApi nirUpitatvAnna tannirUpaNArthamapyetadapunaruktam, evametat; kintu prameyaprAdhAnyena tadgrAhakasya pramANasyApi nirUpaNamityetatpradarzanadvAreNa tatpratipAdakavAkyAvatAraH prAg vihitaH, iha tvavidyamAnaprameyasya pramANasya pramANatvAsaMbhavAt pramANanirUpaNadvAreNa prameyanirUpaNamiti pradarzanadvAreNa tadvAkyAvatAra ityadoSaH / yadvA anekAntapakSoktadoSaparihAro'nekadhA vyavasthApyata iti na kaSTiAd doSaH 'sAmaNNammi' ityAdi sUtrasaMdarbhaviracane / / 2 / / 2010_02

Page #190
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-3 145 [ AptavacanasyAnekAntAtmakavastubodhakatvena svarUpakathanam ] sAmAnya-vizeSAnekAntAtmakavastupratipAdakaM vacanamAptasya, itaraditarasyetyetadeva darzayannAha pacappannaM bhAvaM vigaya-bhavissehiM jaM samaNNei / eyaM paDuJcavayaNaM davvaMtaraNissiyaM jaM ca / / 3 / / pratyutpannaM bhAvaM-vastuno vartamAnapariNAmam vigata-bhaviSyadbhyAM paryAyAbhyAM yat samAnarUpatayA nayati pratipAdayati vacaH tat pratItyavacanaM samIkSitArthavacanaM sarvajJavacanamityarthaH, anyaJcAnAptavacanam / [S.T.P.628] paramANvArambhakadravyAt kAryadravyaM dvyaNukAdi dravyAntaraM vaizeSikAbhiprAyatastena niHsRtaM saMbaddhaM kAraNaM paramANvAdi yat pratipAdayati tadapi pratItyavacanam / athavA ekadravyAdanyad dravyaM dravyAntaraM tasmin niHsRtaM saMbaddhaM yat tadapi pratItyavacanam / yathA-dIrghataraM madhyamikAGgulidravyamapekSya hasvataramaGguSThakadravyamiti vacaH / hrasva-dIrghAdikastu svadharma eva dravyAntaravizeSAbhivyaGgyaH piteva putrAdinA / __ yadvA gotvasadRzapariNatiyuktAcchAbaleyadravyAt tatsadRzapariNatiyuktaM bAhuleyAdi dravyAntaraM tasmin niHzritaM saMbaddhaM vAcakatvena 'gauH' iti yad vacanaM tadapi pratItyavacanam / na punaH kevalatiryaksAmAnya-vizeSa-tadvadubhayAdipratipAdakam asadbhUtArthapratipAdakatvAd unmattavAkyavat [S.T.P. 629] / / 3 / / ___-zAstravArtAsamuccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAM sta.1 gA.49 atra kAryasya sattvaM pUrvottarakAlayoH / paryAyArthikanayAnusAriNaH paryAyadvAreNaivAdizanti, dravyasya niSpannatvenA'dalatvAt / dravyArthikanayAnusAriNastu tena rUpeNa dravyasyAnutpannatvAd dravyadvAraivAdizanti / tadidamubhayAbhiprAyeNoktaM sammatau"paJcappannaM bhAvaM vigayabhavissehiM jaM sammaNNei, eyaM paDucavayaNaM" / [3/3] iti / 2010 02

Page #191
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 3, gAthA- 4-5 [ Aptavacane samupatiSThamAnAyA ekAntapakSAzritAyA AzaGkAyA anekAntapakSAzrayaNena nirAkaraNam ] nanu pratyutpannaparyAyasya svakAlavadatItA'nAgatakAlayoH sattve atItA'nAgatakAlayorvartamAnakAlatApatteH anyathA tadrUpatayA tayostatsattvAsaMbhavAt-traikAlyAyogAt tasya tadviziSTatAnupapattestathAbhUtArthapratipAdakaM vacanamapratItyavacanamevetyAzaGkyA''ha davvaM jahA pariNayaM taheva asthi tti tammi samayammi / viga - bhavissehi u pajjaehiM bhayaNA vibhayaNA vA / / 4 / / 146 dravyaM cetanAcetanam, yathA tadAkArArthagrahaNarUpatayA ghaTAdirUpatayA vA pariNataM vartamAnasamaye tathaiva asti / vigata- bhaviSyadbhistu paryAyerbhajanA kathaMcit taistasyaikatvam, vibhajanA vigatabhajanA nAnAtvaM kathaMcit, 'vA' zabdasya kathaMcidarthatvAt / tataH pratyutpannaparyAyasya vigata - bhaviSyadbhayAM na sarvathaikatvamiti kathaM tatpratipAdakavacanasyApratItyavacanateti bhAvaH / / 4 / / [ saMbhavadbhiH paryAyairghaTAdervastunaH astitva - nAstitvaprarUpaNam ] nanu ghaTAderarthasya kaiH paryAyairastitvam anastitvaM vA ? ityAhaparapajjavehiM 'asarisagamehiM NiyameNa Nicamavi natthi / sarisehiM pi vaMjaNao atthi Na puNa'tthapajjAe / / 5 / / vartamAnaparyAyavyatiriktabhUta-bhaviSyatparyAyAH paraparyAyAstairvisadRzagamairvijAtIyajJAnagrAyairniyamena niSTAyena nityaM sarvadA nAsti tad dravyam, tairapi tadA tasya sadbhAve avasthAsaMkIrNatAprasakteH / sadRzaistu vyaJjanataH sAmAnyadharmaiH sat - dravya-pRthivItvAdibhiH vizeSAtmakaipTA zabdapratipAdyairasti, sAmAnya - vizeSAtmakasya zabdavAcyatvAt / sAmAnyamAtrasya tadvAcyatve zabdAdapravRttiprasakterarthakriyAsamarthasya tenAnuktatvAt sAmAnyamAtrasya ca taduktasyArthakriyA'nirvartakatvAt, vizeSamantareNa sAmAnyasyAsaMbhavAt sAmAnyapratipAdanadvAreNa lakSaNayA 1 visarisagamehiM (ane.vya.) 2010_02

Page #192
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-5 147 vizeSapratipAdanamapi zabdAnna saMbhavati, kramapratipatterasaMvedanAt; vizeSANAM tvAnantyAt saMketAsaMbhavataH zabdAvAcyatvam / parasparavyAvRttasAmAnya-vizeSayorapyavAcyatvam ubhayadoSaprasaGgAt / tata ubhayAtmakaM vastu guNa-pradhAnabhAvena zabdenAbhidhIyata iti sadRzairvyaJjanato'stItyupapannam / na punarnaiva arthaparyAyaiH RjusUtrAbhimatArthaparyAyeNa tad asti, anyonyavyAvRttavastusvalakSaNagrAhakatvAt tasya / ayaM cArthaH pUrvasUtra eva pradarzita ityanyathA gAthAsUtraM vyAkhyeyama-anyavastugatAH paryAyA visadRzasadRzatayA dviprakArAH, tatra visadRzairvivakSito ghaTAdi vAsti / sadRzaistu kaipTiAduktavadasti, kaipTiAnneti tAtparyArthaH / / 5 / / -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa.74 tataH sadRzavyaJjanaparyAyaireva sarvamasti na tvanyairityayamanekAnta eva vyavasthitaH, tadidamuktaM[sammatau] "parapajjavehiM 'visari-sagamehiM NiyameNa NiJcamavi Natthi / / sarisehi vi vaMjaNao, atthi Na puNa atthapajAe / / 3/5 / / " visadRzagamairvijAtIyajJAnagrAdyaiH / -: aSTasahasItAtparyavivaraNe : pari. 1, kA. 15 tattvatastu sAmAnyadRSTyA sarve nirapekSA vizeSadRSTyA ca sarve sApekSA iti vyApako'nekAnta eva vijayate, vyaJjanaparyAyaiH sadRzAnAmapyarthaparyAyairvesadRzyasya zAstrasiddhatvAt / tadAha pravacanopaniSadvedI mahAvAdI siddhasenaH-[sammatau] parapajjavehiM asarisagamehiM Niyameva Niccamavi Natthi / sarisehiM pi vaMjaNao atthi Na puNatthapajjAe / / 1 / / iti, [3/5] 1 asarisagamehiM (saMmati.) ___JainEducation International 2010_02

Page #193
148 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-6 [ vartamAnaparyAye'pi dravyasyAnekAntAtmakatvasamarthanam ] nanu pratyutpannaparyAyeNa bhAvasyAstitvaniyame ekAntavAdApattirityAzaGkyAha pacuppaNNammi vi pajjayammi bhayaNAgaI paDai davvaM / jaM egaguNAIyA aNaMtakappA gama[guNa visesA / / 6 / / vartamAne'pi pariNAme sva-pararUpatayA sadasadAtmarUpatAm, adho-madhyorkhAdirUpeNa ca bhedA'bhedAtmakatAM ca bhajanAgatimAsAdayati dravyam, yata ekaguNakRSNatvAdayo'nantaprakArAstatra guNavizeSAsteSAM ca madhye kenacid guNavizeSeNa yuktaM tat / tathAhi-kRSNaM dravyaM tadravyAntareNa tulyam adhikam UnaM vA bhavet prakArAntarAbhAvAt, prathamapakSe sarvathA tulyatve tadekatvApattiH; uttarapakSayoH saMkhyeyAdibhAgaguNavRddhi-hAnibhyAM SaTsthAnakapratipattiravazyaMbhAvinI / syAdetat pudgaladravyasya tAdRgbhUtAparapudgaladravyApekSayA anekAntarUpatA yuktA, pratyutpanne tvAtmadravyaparyAye kathamanekAntarUpatA ? na, AtmaparyAyasyApi jJAnAdestattadgrAhyArthApekSayA'nekAntarUpatA pudgalavanna virudhyate / tathA dravya-kaSAya-yogopayoga-jJAna-darzana-cAritravIryaprabhedAtmakatvAdAtmanaH pudgalavadanekAntarUpatA ArSe pratipAditaiva"kaivihe NaM bhaMte ! AyA paNNatte ? goyamA ! aTThavihe / taM jahA-davie AyA" [bhagavatIsU0 zata0 12, u0 10] ityAdau / / 6 / / -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa. 74 nanvevamapi pratyutpannaparyAyeNAstitvaniyame'pyekAntavAdApattiriti cet, atrAhu:- [sammatau] "paccuppaNNaMmi vi pajayaMmi bhayaNAgaiM paDai davvaM / jaM egaguNAIyA, aNaMtakappA gama [guNa] visesA / / 3/6 / / " "pratyutpanne'pi vartamAne'pi, paryAye, svapararUpatayA sadasadAtmikAM madhyorkhAdirUpeNa ca bhedAbhedAtmikAM bhajanAgatiM vikalpapaddhati, patatyAsAdayati, dravyaM, yadyasmAtkAraNAd, ekaguNakRSNatvAdayo'nantakalpA anantaprakArAstatra guNavizeSAH, teSAM ca madhye kenacideva guNavizeSeNa yuktaM 2010_02

Page #194
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-7 tat, tathAhi, kRSNaM dravyaM tad dravyAntareNa tulyamadhikamUnaM vA bhavet, prakArAntarAbhAvAt, prathamapakSe sarvathAtulyatve tadekatvApattiH, tathA ca nIlanIlatarAdipratItibAdhaH, uttarapakSayoH saGkhyeyAdibhAgaguNavRddhihAniyAM SaTsthAnakapratipattiravazyambhAvinIti pratyutpannaparyAyeNApi bhajanA'bAdhitaiva / / -: nyAyakhaNDakhAdye (mahAvIrastave ) :vibhAga-3, gA-43 yathA ca nAnAjAtisamAvezanibandhanaSTizatravyavahArastathA nAnAparyAyasamAvezanibandhano'pi, bhedadRSTyA tathAnubhavAt, SaDguNahAnivRddhiparyAyANAM svakAraNAyAtatvAcca taduktam - [sammattau ] "pacuppaNNaMmi vi pajjayaMmi bhayaNAga paDai davvaM / jaM egaguNAIA aNaMtakappA gamavisesatti" [3/6] tasmAdIdRzi sUkSme'rthe mano'nivezayataH ziromaNeH prajJAparAdha eva bhUyAniti kimatra brUmaH / / 43 / / [ Atmano'nekAntAtmakatvasya buddhigamyatayA pradarzanam ] itaSTAnekAntAtmakatA AtmanaH pratipattavyetyAha kovaM uppAyaMto puriso jIvassa kArao hoi / tatto vibhayavvo parammi sayameva bhaiyavvo / / 7 / / 149 kopapariNatimupanayan puruSo jIvasya parabhavaprAdurbhAve nirvartako bhavati, tannimittasya karmaNa upAdAnAt / kopapariNAmamApadyamAnaSTA puruSastataH parabhavajIvAd vibhajanIyo bhinno vyavasthApanIyaH, kArya-kAraNayormRtpiNDa-ghaTavat kathaMcid bhedAt; anyathA kArya-kAraNabhAvAbhAvaprasaGgAt / na cAsau tato bhinna eva parasmin bhave svayameva puruSo bhajanIyaH AtmarUpatayA abhedena vyavasthApyata iti bhAvaH ghaTAdyAkArapariNatamRddravyavat kathaMcidabhinna ityanekAntaH / yadvA kopapariNatimanyasmin jIve utpAdayan puruSaH kArako bhavati / tato'sau kopakArakatvena vibhajanIyaH kopapariNatiyogye jIve kArakaH, anyatrAkAraka iti / / 7 / / 2010_02

Page #195
150 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-8 -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa. 75 prakArAntareNApyAtmano'nekAntarUpatAmupapAdayati sammatikAraH "kovaM uppAyanto puriso jIvassa kArao hoi / tatto vibhaiyavvo, paraMmi sayameva bhaiyavyo / / 3/7 / / " kopaM kopapariNatim, utpAdayan puruSaH, jIvasya parabhavaprAdurbhAvapariNativiziSTasya, kArako nirvartako bhavati, tannimittikarmaNa upAdAnAt, kopapariNAmamApadyamAnaSTA puruSaH, tataH parabhavajIvAd, vibhajanIyo bhinno vyavasthApanIyaH, kAryakAraNayormutpiNDaghaTavatkathaJcidbhedAt, anyathA kAryakAraNabhAvAbhAvaprasaGgAt / 'vItarAgajanmAdarzana' nyAyenaikatvena siddhasya jIvasya kathaM bhavabhedena bheda iti cet ?, mRdravyatayaikatvena siddhasya mRtpiNDaghaTabhAvAbhyAmapi kathaM bhedo, na hi mRtpiNDaghaTabhAvAbhyAM mRda iva devamanujabhAvAbhyAM jIvasya vailakSaNyamaprAmANikamiti vibhAvanIyam / na cAsau tato bhinna eva, yataH, parasminbhave, svayameva puruSo, bhajanIya AtmarUpatayA'bhedena vyavasthApanIyo, ghaTAdyAkArapariNatamRdrvyavadityanekAntaH / yadvA kopapariNatimanyasmin jIve utpAdayan puruSaH kArako bhavati, tato'sau kopakArakatvena vibhajanIyaH kopapariNatiyogye jIve kArako'nyatrAkAraka iti / / __ [ dravya-guNayoH kathaMcidabhedamanicchatAM keSAMcit tayorbhedaviSayA''zaGkA ] dravyaM guNAdibhyo'nanyat te'pi dravyAdananya evetyetadanekAntamamRSyamANA AhuH rUva-rasa-gaMdha-phAsA asamANaggahaNa-lakkhaNA jamhA / tamhA davvANugayA guNa tti te kei icchaMti / / 8 / / rUpa-rasa-gandha-sparzAH asamAnagrahaNa-lakSaNA yasmAt tato dravyAzritA guNA iti kecana vaizeSikAdyAH, svayUthyA vA siddhAntAnabhijJA abhyupagacchanti / tathAhi-guNA dravyAd bhinnAH, bhinnapramANagrAhyatvAt, bhinnalakSaNatvAJca; stambhAt kumbhavat / na cAsiddhau hetU, dravyasya 'yamahamadrAkSaM tameva spRzAmi' ityanusaMdhAnAdhyakSagrAhyatvAta rUpAdInAM ca pratiniyatendriyaprabhavapratyayAvaseyatvAt 'dArzanaM spArzanaM ca dravyam' ityAdyabhidhAnAdasamAnagrahaNatA dravya-guNayoH siddhA / tathA, vibhinnalakSaNatvamapi- "kriyAvad guNavat samavAyikAraNaM dravyam" [vaizeSikada0 2010_02

Page #196
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-8 151 3 1-1-15] "dravyAzrayyaguNavAn saMyogavibhAgeSvakAraNamanapekSaH" [vaizeSikada0 1-1-16] iti / vacanAt siddham / / 8 / / -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa.75 atha dravyaguNAnAM bhedA'bhedAnekAntamamRSyamANAnAM matamutthApayati "rUvarasagaMdhaphAsA, asamANaggahaNalakkhaNA jamhA / tamhA davvANugayA, guNa tti te kei icchaMti / / 3/8 / / " rUparasagandhasparzA asamAnagrahaNalakSaNA yasmAttato dravyAzritA guNAstadbhinnA eveti, kecana vaizeSikAdyAH svayUthyA vA siddhAntA'nabhijJA abhyupagacchanti / tathA hi guNA dravyAdbhinnA bhinnapramANagrAhyatvAdbhivalakSaNatvAJca, stambhAtkumbhavat / na cAsiddhau hetU, dravyasya 'yamahamadrAkSaM tameva spRzAmi' ityanusandhAnAd vyakSagrAhyatvAd, rUpAdInAM ca pratiniyatendriyaprabhavapratyayAvaseyatvAd, 'dArzanaM spArzanaM ca dravyam' ityAdyabhidhAnAdasamAnagrahaNatA dravyaguNayoH siddhA / tathA vibhinnalakSaNatvamapi "kriyAvadguNavatsamavAyikAraNaM vA dravyam" "dravyAzrayA nirguNA guNA" ityAdivacanAtsiddham / -: zAstravArtAsamuccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAM sta.7 gA.31 uktameva spaSTayannAha anvayo vyatirekapTA dravyaparyAyasaMjJitau / anyonyavyAptito bhedAbhedavRttyaiva vastu tau / / 31 / / anvayo vyatirekapTotyetAvaMzI dravya-paryAyasaMjJitau-'dravyaM' 'paryAya'Toti dravya-paryAyapadavAcyau / etena 'dravyaM, guNAH, paryAyApTA' iti vibhAgaH keSAJcidanabhijJasvayUthyAnAM parayUthyAnAM vA nirastaH, vibhinnanayagrAhyAbhyAM dravyaparyAyatvAbhyAmeva vibhAgAt / yadi ca guNo'pyatiriktaH syAt tadA tadgrahArthaM dravyArthika-paryAyArthikavad guNArthikanayamapi bhagavAnupAdekSyat, na caivamasti, rUpa-rasa-gandhasparzAnAmarhatA teSu teSu sUtreSu "vaNNapajjavehiM0" ityAdinA paryAyasaMjJayaiva niyamanAt / 'guNa eva tatra paryAyazabdenokta' iti cet ? nanvevaM guNaparyAyazabdayorekArthatve'pi paryAyazabdenaiva bhagavato dezanA, iti na guNazabdena paryAyasya tadatiriktasya vA guNasya vibhAgaucityam / "ekaguNakAla: 2010_02

Page #197
152 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-8 dazaguNakAla:" ityAdau guNazabdenApi bhagavato dezanA'styeva iti cet ? astyeva saMkhyAnazAstradharmavAcakaguNazabdena, na tu guNArthikanayapratipAdanAbhiprAyeNa / yena ca rUpeNa vibhinnamUlavyAkaraNi(NI)nayagrAhyatA tenaiva rUpeNa vibhAgaH, anyathAvibhAgasya saMpradAyaviruddhatvAt / ata eva "guNaparyAyavad dravyam" iti sUtre guNa-paryAyapadAbhyAM yugapada-'yugapadbhAviparyAyavizeSopAdAne'pi na traividhyena sAmAnyavibhAga iti tattvam / tadidamAhuH- [sammatau] rUva-rasa-gaMgha-phAsA asamANaggahaNalakkhaNA jamhA / tamhA davvANugayA guNa tti te kei icchaMti / 8 / / dUre tA aNNattaM guNasadde ceva tAva pAricchaM / kiM pajavAhio hoja pajjave ceva guNasaNNA / / 9 / / do puNa nayA bhagavayA davvaTThia-pajjavadviA NiayA / etto a guNavisese guNaTThiaNao vi jujaMto / / 10 / / jaM ca puNa arahayA tesu tesu suttesu goamAINaM / / pajjavasaNNA 'NiamA vAgariA teNa pajjAyA / / 11 / / parigamaNaM pajjAo aNegakaraNaM guNa tti tullaTThA / tahavi na guNa tti bhaNNai pajjavaNayadesaNA jamhA / / 12 / / jaMpaMti atthi samae egaguNo dasaguNo aNaMtaguNo / rUvAIpariNAmo bhannai tamhA guNavisaso / / 13 / / guNasaddamantareNa vi taM tu pajjavavisesasaMkhANaM / sijjhai, NavaraM saMkhANasatthadhammo 'taiguNo' tti / / 14 / / jaha dasasu dasaguNammi ya egammi dasattaNaM samaM ceva / ahiammi vi guNasadde taheva evaM pi daTTavvaM / / 15 / / [3/8 taH 15] iti / 1.NiyayA (saMmati.) 2010_02

Page #198
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 3, gAthA - 9 [ dravya - guNayorekAntabhedAzaGkAM nirAkartuM guNazabdasyArthaparIkSA ] etatparihArAyAha dUre tA aNNattaM guNasadde ceva tAva pAricchaM / kiM pajjavAhio hojja pajjave caiva guNasaNNA / / 9 / / dUre tAvad guNa-guNinorekAntenAnyatvam - asaMbhAvanIyamiti yAvat-guNAtmakadravyapratyayabAdhitatvAd ekAntaguNaguNibhedasya / na ca samavAyanimitto'yamabhedapratyayaH, tasya niSiddhatvAt / na caikatvapratyayasya prAgupanyastAnumAnabAdhA, ekatvapratyayAdhyakSabAdhitakarmanirdezAnantaraprayuktatvenaikazAkhAprabhavatvAnumAnasyeva tasya kAlAtyayApadiSTatvAt / tato guNaguNinorekAntAnyatvasyAsaMbhavAt guNazabde eva tAvat pArIkSyamasti kiM paryAyAdadhike guNazabdaH ? uta paryAya eva prayukta iti ? abhiprAyaSTA na paryAyAdanyo guNaH, paryAyaSTA kathaMciddravyAtmaka iti vikalpaH kRtaH / / 9 / / -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM :anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa. 75 etanmataM parijihIrSurAha " dUre tA aNNattaM, guNasadde ceva tAva pAricchaM / kiM pajjavAhie hojja, pajjave vA vi guNasaNNA / / 3-9 / / " dUre tAvad guNaguNinorekAntenAnyatvam, asambhAvanIyamiti yAvat, guNAtmakadravyapratyayabAdhitatvAdekAntena guNaguNibhedasya / na ca samavAyanimitto'yamabhedapratyayaH, tatra pramANAbhAvAt, na caikatvapratyayasya prAguktAnumAnabAdhA, ekatvapratyayAdhyakSabAdhitakarmanirdezAnantaraM prayuktvenaikazAkhAprabhavatvAnumAnasyeva tasya kAlAtyayApadiSTatvAt, tato guNaguNinorekAntAnyatvasyAsambhavAd, guNazabda eva tAvatpArIkSyamasti, kiM paryAyAdadhike guNasaMjJA guNazabdaH pravartate kiM vA paryAya eva bhavet, paryAyAnanyatve kathaJcid dravyAtmakatvamevetyabhiprAyaH / 1. vA vi (ane. vya.) 2. ceva ( saMmati ) / 153 2010_02

Page #199
154 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-10-11 [ guNasya paryAyAd bhede tRtIyasya guNArthikanayasyApi vacanIyatvaprasaJjanam ] yadi paryAyAdanyo guNaH syAt paryAyArthikavad guNArthiko'pi nayo vacanIyaH syAdityAha do uNa NayA bhagavayA davvaTThiya-pajjavaTThiyA niyayA / etto ya guNavisese guNaTThiyaNao vi jujjaMto / / 10 / / dvAveva mUlanayau bhagavatA dravyArthika-paryAyArthiko niyamito, tatrAtaH paryAyAdadhike guNavizeSa grAhye sati tadgrAhakaguNAstikanayo'pi niyamituM yujyamAnakaH syAd anyathA avyApakatvaM nayAnAM bhaved arhato vA tadaparijJAnaM prasajyeta / / 10 / / -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa. 75 yadi ca paryAyAdanyo guNaH syAttadA paryAyArthikavad guNArtho'pi nayaH syAdityaniSTApattimAha "do u NayA bhagavayA, davvaTThiyapajjavaTThiyA niyayA / etto ya guNavisese, guNaTThiyaNao vi jujaMto / / 3/10 / / " dvAveva mUlanayau, bhagavatA dravyArthikaparyAyArthiko niyamitAvitaH paryAyAdadhike, guNavizeSe grAhye sati, tadgrAhako guNAstikanayo'pi niyamituM yujyamAnakaH syAd, anyathA'vyApakatvaM nayAnAM bhavet / / [ tRtIyasya guNArthikanayasya bhagavadanuktatvopapAdanam ] na ca bhagavatA'sAvukta ityAha jaM ca puNa arihayA tesu tesu suttesu goyamAINaM / pajjavasaNNA 'NiyayA vAgariyA teNa pajjAyA / / 11 / / yataH punarbhagavatA tasmiMstasmin sUtre "vaNNapajjavehiM, gaMdhapajjavehiM" [bhagavatI sU0 zata0 14, u0 4 sU0 513] ityAdinA paryAyasaMjJA niyamitA varNAdiSu gautamAdibhyaH vyAkRtA-stataH paryAyA eva varNAdayo na guNA ityabhiprAyaH / / 11 / / 1.NiamA (syA. kalpa.) / 2010_02

Page #200
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-12 155 -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa. 75 na ca bhagavatA'sAvukta ityAha jaM ca puNa arahayA, tesu tesu suttesu goyamAINaM / pajjavasaNNA NiyayA, vAgariyA teNa pajjAyA / / 3/11 / / yat punarbhagavatA tasmi~stasminsUtre 'vaNNapajjavehiM' ityAdinA, paryAyasaMjJA niyamitA varNAdiSu, gautamAdibhyo vyAkRtA, tataH paryAyA eva varNAdayo na guNA ityabhiprAyaH / / [ tulyArthatvAd AgamAJca paryAyazabdena guNasyaivAbhidhAnamiti kathanam ] atha tatra guNa eva paryAyazabdenoktaH tulyArthatvAt AgamAJca"ya eva paryAyaH sa eva guNaH" [ ] ityAdikAt / etadevAha parigamaNaM pajjAo aNegakaraNaM guNa tti tullatthA / taha vi Na 'guNa'tti bhaNNai pajjavaNayadesaNA jamhA / / 12 / / pari samantAt sahabhAvibhiH kramabhAvibhiSTA bhedairvastunaH pariNatasya gamanaM paricchedo yaH sa paryAyo viSaya-viSayiNorabhedAt; anekarUpatayA vastunaH karaNaM-karoterjJAnArthatvAt-jJAnamviSaya-viSayiNorabhedAdeva-guNaH iti tulyArthI guNa-paryAyazabdau, tathApi na 'guNArthikaH' ityabhihitastIrthakRtA paryAyanayadvAreNaiva dezanA yasmAt kRtA bhagavateti / / 12 / / -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa. 75 atha tatra guNa eva paryAyazabdenoktaH kiM na syAdityAdizaGkAyAmAha___ "parigamaNaM pajjAo, aNegakaraNaM guNa tti tullatthA / taha vi Na guNatti bhaNNai, pajavaNayadesaNA jamhA / / 3/12 / / pari samantAtsahabhAvibhiH kramabhAvibhiSTA bhedairvastunaH pariNatasya gamanaM paricchedo yaH sa paryAyo vipayavipayiNorabhedAdanekarUpatayA vastunaH karaNaM 'karoterjJAnArthatvAt' jJAnam, viSayaviSayiNora 2010_02

Page #201
156 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-13 bhedAdeva guNo 'guNyate pRthakkriyate'nena' iti dhAtvarthAnusArAd, iti vyutpattinimittamapekSya, tulyArthI guNaparyAyazabdau, tathApi guNA iti paryAyA na bhaNyante, paryAyavizeSavAcakasya guNazabdasya paryAyasAmAnyoktAvapravRtteH, na ca guNazabdasya paryAyasAmAnya eva zaktiH kalpanIyA, yasmAt paryAyanayadvAreNaiva bhagavatA dezanA kRtA, na tu guNArthikanayadvArA, ato vyutpattinimittataulye'pi guNaparyAyazabdayoH sAmAnyavizeSabhAvApannapravRttinimittabhedAnna paryAyatvamiti / [ bhagavato guNadvAreNApi dezanAdarzanAnna guNAbhAva iti pUrvapakSaH ] guNadvAreNApi dezanAyAM bhagavataH pravRttirupalabhyate iti na guNAbhAva ityAha jaMpanti asthi samaye egaguNo dasaguNo aNaMtaguNo / 'rUvAI pariNAmo bhaNNai tamhA guNaviseso / / 13 / / jalpanti dravya-guNAnyatvavAdinaH-vidyate eva siddhAnte "egaguNakAlae duguNakAlae" [bhagavatIsU0 zata0 5, u0 7 sU0 217] ityAdi rUpAdau vyapadezastasmAd rUpAdirguNavizeSa evetyasti guNArthiko nayaH upadiSTapTA bhagavateti / / 13 / / -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa. 76 nanu paryAyazabda: kramabhAvidharmavAcaka eva, guNazabdaSTA sahabhAvidharmavAcaka eva, tathA ca guNaH paryAyebhyo'tiricyante paryAyAtiriktaguNAbhidhAnAnyathAnupapattyA ca guNArthikanayo'pi bhagavatA'rthAdupadiSTa evetyAzaGkate "jaMpaMti atthi samae, egaguNo dasaguNo aNaMtaguNo / ruvAiyapariNAmo, bhaNNai tamhA guNaviseso / / 3-13 / / " jalpanti dravyaguNAnyatvavAdino, asti vidyata eva, siddhAnte 'egaguNakAlae duguNakAlae' ityAdiH rUpAdau vyapadezaH, tasmAdrUpAdipariNAmo guNavizeSa evetyasti guNArthiko'pi naya upadiSTapTA bhagavateti / 1. rUvAiyapari0 (ane. vya.) / 2. rUvAI pari0 (saMmati.) / 2010_02

Page #202
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-14-15 157 [ uktasya pUrvapakSasya siddhAntavAdinA nirAkaraNam ] atrAha siddhAntavAdI guNasaddamaMtareNAvi taM tu pajjavavisesasaMkhANaM / sijjhai NavaraM saMkhANasatthadhammo 'taiguNo'tti / / 14 / / rUpAdyabhidhAyiguNazabdavyatirekeNApi 'ekaguNakAlaH' ityAdikaM paryAyavizeSasaMkhyAvAcakaM vacaH sidhyati na punarguNAstikanayapratipAdakatvena, yataH saMkhyAnaM gaNitazAstradharmaH'ayaM tAvadruNa iti etAvatA'dhiko nyUno vA bhAvaH' iti gaNitazAstradharmatvAdasyetyarthaH / / 14 / / -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa.76 atrAha siddhAntavAdI "guNasaddamantareNAvi taM tu pajavavisesasaMkhANaM / sijjhai NavaraM saMkhANasatthadhammo na u guNo tti / / 3/14 / / " tattu prAguktaM vacanam, guNazabdamantareNApi rUpAdyabhidhAyakaguNazabdaM vinApi, paryAyavizeSasaMkhyAnaM paryAyavizeSasaMkhyAvAcakam, sidhyati, na tcatiriktaguNaguNArthikanayapratipAdanaparam, tatra guNazabdasyatAvatA'dhiko nyUno vA bhAva iti gaNitazAstradharmavacanatvAditi bhAvaH / / [ siddhAntinA svoktasyArthasya dRDhIkaraNam ] dRSTAntadvAreNAmumevArthaM dRDhIkartumAha jaha dasasu dasaguNammi ya egammi dasattaNaM samaM ceva / ahiyammi vi guNasadde taheva evaM pi daTThavvaM / / 15 / / yathA dazasu dravyeSu, ekasmin vA dravye dazaguNite dazazabdAtireke'pi dazatvaM samameva tathaiva etadapi na bhidyate-'paramANurekaguNakRSNAdiH' iti / ekAdizabdAdhikye guNa 1.na u guNo tti (ane. vya.) / 2. taiguNo tti (saMmati.) | 2010_02

Page #203
158 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-16-17-18 paryAyazabdayorbhedo vastu punastayostulyamiti bhAvaH / na ca guNAnAM paryAyatve vAcakamukhyasUtram "guNa-paryAyavad dravyam" (tattvArtha0 a0 5, sU0 37) iti virudhyate, yugapadayugapadbhAviparyAyavizeSapratipAdanArthatvAt tasya / na caivamapi matuSprayogAd dravyavibhinnaparyAyasiddhiH, nityayoge'tra matubvidhAnAt dravya-paryAyayostAdAtmyAt sadA'vinirbhAgavartitvAt anyathA pramANavAdhopapatteH / saMjJA-saMkhyA-svalakSaNA'rthakriyAbhedAd vA kathaMcit tayorabhede'pi bhedasiddherna matuvanupapattiH / / 15 / / -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa.76 dRSTAntadvAreNAmumarthaM dRDhIkartumAha "jaha dasasu dasaguNami ya, egami dasattaNaM samaM ceva / ahiyaMmi vi guNasadde, taheva evaM pi daTThavvaM / / 3/15 / / " yathA dazasu dravyeSu, ekasmin vA dravye dazaguNite guNazabdAtireke'pi, dazatvaM samameva tathaivaitadapi na bhidyate paramANurekaguNakRSNAdirityekAdizabdAdhikaguNazabdenApi tadadhikArthApratipAdanAditi draSTavyam / [ bhedasya nirAsenAbhedasya phalitatve'pyekAntinA tasya dADhAya sopanayamudAharaNam ] evaM dravya-paryAyayorbhedaikAntapratiSedhe abhedaikAntavAdyAha eyaMtapakkhavAo jo uNa davva-guNa-jAibheyammi / aha pubbapaDikkuTTho uAharaNamittameyaM tu / / 16 / / piu-putta-Nattu-bhavvaya-bhAUNaM egapurisasaMbaMdho / Na ya so egassa piya tti sesayANaM pitA hoi / / 17 / / jaha saMbandhavisiTTho so puriso purisabhAvaNiraisao / taha davamiMdiyagayaM rUvAivisesaNaM lahai / / 18 / / 1. bhANijja (ane. vya.) / 2010_02

Page #204
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-16-17-18 159 ekAntavyatiriktAbhyupagamavAdo yaH punarravya-guNa-kriyAbhedeSu sa yadyapi pUrvameva pratikSiptaH bhedaikAntagrAhakapramANAbhAvAt abhedagrAhakasya ca 'sarvamekaM sadavizeSAta vizeSa vA viyatkusumavadasattvaprasaGgAd' iti pradarzitatvAt / tathApi tatsvarUpe dADhyotpAdanArthamudAharaNamAtramabhidhIyatepitR-putra-naptR-bhAgneya-bhrAtRbhirya ekasya puruSasya saMbandhastenAsAveka eva pitrAdivyapadezamAsAdayati / na cAsAvekasya pitA putrasaMvandhataH-iti zeSANAmapi pitA bhavati / yathA pradarzitasaMbandhaviziSTaH pitrAdivyapadezamAzrityAsau puruSarUpatayA niratizayo'pi san tathA dravyamapi ghrANa-rasana-cakSus-tvaka-zrotrasaMbandhamavApya rUpa-rasa-gandha-sparzazabdavyapadezamAtraM labhate dravyasvarUpeNAviziSTamapi nahi zakrendrAdizabdabhedAda gIrvANanAthasyeva rUpAdizabdabhedAd vastubhedo yuktastadA dravyAdvaitaikAntasthiteH kathaMcida bhedAbhedavAdo dravya-guNayormithyAvAda iti / / 16 / / 17 / / 18 / / -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa.82 Aha ca mahAmatiH "piuputtaNattubhANijabhAUNaM egapurisasaMbandho / Na ya so egassa piya tti sesayANaM piyA hoi / / 3/17 / / " jaha sambandhavisiTTho, so puriso purisabhAvaNiraisao / taha davvamiMdiyagayaM, rUvAivisesaNaM lahai / / 3/18 / / "pitRputranaptRbhAgineyabhrAtRbhirya ekasya puruSasya sambandhaH tenAsAveka eva pitrAdivyapadezamAsAdayati, na cAsAvekasya pitA putraH saMvRtta iti zeSANAmapi pitA bhavati, yathA pradarzitasambandhaviziSTaH pitrAdivyapadezamAzrityAsau puruSarUpatayA niratizayo'pi saMstathA dravyamapi ghrANarasanacakSustvakzrotrasambandhamavApya gandharasarUpasparzazabdavyapadezamAtraM labhate dravyasvarUpeNAviziSTamapi, na hi zakendrAdizabdabhedAdgIrvANanAthasyeva rUpAdizabdabhedAdvastubhedo yuktaH, na caivaM pitrAdivad ghaTAderapi sAvadhikatvaprasaGgaH, pitrAdivyavahArasyeva rUpAdivyavahArasya sAvadhikatve'pi ___ 2010_02

Page #205
. 160 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-19 vastuno'tathAtvAt / na cakSurgrAhyatAviziSTadravyasya rUpAditve grAhyatAyAH zaktirUpAyAH atIndriyatvena rUpAdyatIndriyatApattiH, vizeSaNApratyakSatve'pi vizeSyavidhayA tatpratyakSatvasambhavAcchaktibhedAcca na cAkSuSAdijJAnasaGkara iti dig / / [kathaMcid bhedAbhedaM mithyA vadato'bhedekAntapakSasya nirAkaraNam ] asya nirAkaraNAyAha hojjAhi duguNamahuraM aNaMtaguNakAlayaM tu jaM davvaM / Na u Daharao mahallo vA hoi saMbaMdhao puriso / / 19 / / yadi nAma AmrAdidravyameva rasanasaMbandhAd 'rasaH' iti vyapadezamAtramAsAdayet dviguNamadhuraM rasataH kuto bhavet tathA nayanasaMbandhAd yadi nAma 'kRSNam' iti bhaved anantaguNakRSNaM tat kutaH syAd vaiSamyabhedAvagaternayanAdisaMbandhamAtrAdasaMbhavAt / tathA, putrAdisaMbandhadvAreNa pitrAdireva puruSo bhaved na tvalpo mahAn veti yuktaH / vizeSapratipatterupacaritatve mithyAtve vA sAmAnyapratipattAvapi tathAprasakteriti bhAvaH / / 19 / / / -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : ___ anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa.82 nanvevaM dravyAdvaitaikAntasiddheH kathaJcidbhedAbhedavAdo dravyaguNayoraghaTamAnaH syAditi cet, na, rUpAdInAM guNabhedena vyavahAropapattAvapi dravyAvizeSe'pi tadvizeSadarzanena bhedasyApi sambhavAt, Aha ca "hojAhi duguNamahuraM, aNaMtaguNakAlayaM tu jaM davvaM / Na u Daharao mahallo, vva hoi sambandhao puriso / / 3/19 / / " yadi nAmAmlAdidravyameva rasanasambandhAdrasa iti vyapadezamAtramAsAdayet, dviguNamadhuraM rasanato kuto bhaveta, tathA nayanasambandhAdyadi nAma kRSNamiti bhavedanantaguNakRSNaM tatkutaH syAt, vaiSamyabhedAvagatenayanAdisambandhamAtrAdasambhavAt, tathA putrAdisambandhadvAreNa pitrAdireva puruSo bhavenna tvalpo mahAnveti yuktaH, vizeSapratipatterupacaritatve mithyAtve vA sAmAnyapratipattAvapi tathA prasakteriti bhAvaH / / 2010_02

Page #206
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-20-21 161 [ abhedaikAntavAdina AzaGkA ] atrAhAbhedaikAntavAdI bhaNNai saMbaMdhavasA jai saMbaMdhittaNaM aNumayaM te / NaNu saMbaMdhavisese saMbaMdhivisesaNaM siddhaM / / 20 / / saMbandhasAmAnyavazAd yadi saMbandhitvasAmAnyam anumataM tava nanu saMbandhavizeSadvAreNa tathaiva saMbandhivizeSo'pi kiM nAbhyupagamyate ? / / 20 / / -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa.82 atrAhaikAntA'bhedavAdI "bhaNNai sambandhavasA, jai sambandhittaNaM anumayaM te / naNu sambandhavisese, sambandhivisesaNaM siddhaM / / 3/20 / / " sambandhasAmAnyavazAdhadi sambandhitvasAmAnyamanumataM tava, nanu sambandhavizeSadvAreNa sambandhivizeSo'pi kiM nAbhyupagamyate ? / / [ siddhAntavAdinA''zaGkAnirasanam ] - siddhAntavAdyAha jujjai saMbaMdhavasA saMbaMdhivisesaNaM Na uNa eyaM / NayaNAivisesagao rUvAivisesapariNAmo / / 21 / / saMbandhavizeSavazAd yujyate saMbandhivizeSaH yathA daNDAdisaMbandhivizeSajanitasaMbandhavizeSasamAsAditasaMbandhivizeSo'vagataH / dravyAdvaitavAdinastu na saMbandhivizeSaH nApi saMbandhavizeSaH saMgacchata iti kuto rasanAdivizeSasaMbandhajanito rasAdivizeSapariNAmaH ? / / 21 / / ___ 2010_02

Page #207
162 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-22 -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM :anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa.82 siddhAntavAdyAha jujai sambandhavasA, sambandhivisesaNaM Na uNa eyaM / naya(rasa)NAi visesakao, rUvA(rasA)i visesapariNAmo / / 3/21 / / " sambandhavizeSAd yujyate sambandhivizeSo, yathA daNDAdisambandhavizeSajanitasambandhavizeSasamAsAditapuruSAdisambandhivizeSo'vagataH, dravyAdvaitavAdinastu na sambandhivizeSo nApi sambandhavizeSaH saGgacchata iti kuto rasanAdivizeSasambandhajanito rasAdivizeSapariNAmaH ? / / [ anekAntavAde ananta-dviguNAdivaiSamyapariNatiH kathaM ghaTate ityAzaGkA tannirAsaSTA ] nanvanekAntavAdino'pi rUpa-rasAderananta-dviguNAdivaiSamyapariNatiH kathamupapannA ? ityAha bhaNNai visamapariNayaM kaha eyaM hohii tti uvaNIyaM / taM hoi paraNimittaM Na va tti ettha'tthi egaMto / / 22 / / zItoSNasparzavadekatraikadA virodhAd bhaNyate 'ekatra AmraphalAdau viSamapariNatiH kathaM bhavati' iti pareNa prerite upanItaM pradarzitamAptena-tad bhavati paranimittam dravya-kSetra-kAlabhAvAnAM sahakAriNAM vaicitryAt kAryamapi vaicitryamAsAdayati-tad AmrAdi vastu viSamarUpatayA paranimittaM bhavati, na vA 'paranimittameva' ityatrApyekAnto'sti, svarUpasyApi kathaMcinnimittatvAt / tanna dravyAdvaitaikAntaH saMbhavI / / 22 / / -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa.83 nanvanekAntavAdino'pi rUparasAderanantaguNadviguNAdivaiSamyapariNatiH kathamupapannetyAzaGkAyAmAha "bhaNNai visamapariNayaM(I) kaha eyaM hohii tti uvaNIyaM / taM hoi paraNimittaM, Na va tti patthittha egaMto / / 3/22 / / " 1. Natthittha (ane. vya.) / 2. ettha'tthi (saMmati.) / 2010_02

Page #208
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-23 163 zItoSNasparzavadekatraikadA virodhAdbhaNyate ekatrAmraphalAdau viSamapariNatiH kathaM bhavatIti pareNa prerite, upanItaM pradarzitamAptena tadvaiSamyaM bhavati paranimittaM dravyakSetrakAlabhAvAnAM sahakAriNAM vaicitryAttadAmrAdivastu viSamarUpatayA pariNamatIti vaiSamyaM paranimittamityarthaH, na ca paranimittamevetyatrApyekAnto'sti, svarUpasyApi tatra kathaJcinnimittatvAd, anyathA dviguNarasAdInAM dezaniyamAnupapatteH, virodhaSTA kAlabhedena vA nirasanIyaH, na caikatraiva pradeze dviguNarasAditve ekaguNarasAdidvayasamAvezAdvirodhaH sambhAvanIyaH, ekaikaguNApekSayA dviguNaparyAyavato rasasya pratyekAtiriktatvenAvirodhAt, ata eva parApekSayA SaTsthAnapatitatvamapyaviruddham, ApekSikadharmayoIsvatvadIrghatvayoriva virodhAsiddheriti dig / tanna dravyAdvaitaikAntaH sambhavI / / [ prAguktasya lakSaNasya bAdhAd bhedaikAntavAdinA dravya-guNayorlakSaNAntarAbhidhAnam abhedaikAntavAdinA ca vikalpya taddUSaNam ] dravya-guNayorbhedaikAntavAdinA prAk pradarzitatallakSaNasyaikatvapratipattyadhyakSabAdhitatvAd lakSaNAntaraM vaktavyam tadAha davvassa ThiI jamma-vigamA ya guNalakkhaNaM ti vattavvaM / evaM sai kevaliNo jujjai taM No u daviyassa / / 23 / / dravyasya lakSaNaM sthitiH, janma-vigamI lakSaNaM guNAnAm, evaM sati kevalino yujyata etallakSaNam-tatra kila kevalAtmanA sthite eva cetanAcetanarUpA anye arthA jJeyabhAvenotpadyante, ajJeyarUpatayA ca nazyanti / na tu dravyasyANvAderlakSaNamidaM yujyate, na hi aNau rUpAdayo jAyante atyantabhinnatvAt gavyazvAdivat / athavA kevalino'pi sakalajJeyagrAhiNo naitallakSaNaM yujyate / na cApi dravyasya acetanasya, guNa-guNinoratyantabhede asattvApateH asatopTA kharaviSANAderiva lakSaNAsaMbhavAditi / / 23 / / -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : ___ anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa.83 atha dravyaguNayorbhedaikAntavAdino dravyaguNalakSaNAnupapattimudbhAvayanti "davvassa ThiI jammavigamA ya guNalakkhaNaM ti vattavvaM / evaM sai kevaliNo, jujai taM No u daviyassa / / 3/23 / / " ___ 2010_02

Page #209
164 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-24 dravyasya lakSaNaM sthitiH, janmavigamI lakSaNaM guNAnAmevaM sati kevalino yujyata etallakSaNam, tatra kila kevalAtmanA sthita eva cetanAcetanArUpA anye'rthA jJeyabhAvenotpadyante, ajJeyarUpatayA ca nazyanti, na tu dravyasyANvAderlakSaNamidaM yujyate, na hyaNau rUpAdayo jAyante atyantabhinnatvAd gavyazvAdivat, athavA kevalino'pi sakalajJeyagrAhiNo naitallakSaNaM yujyate, na cApi dravyasyAcetanasya, guNaguNinoratyantabhede'sattvApatterasatopTA kharaviSANAderiva lakSaNAsambhavAditi dravyArthAntarabhUtaguNavAdinaH / davvatthaMtarabhUyA muttA'muttA ya te guNA hojja / jai muttA paramANU Natthi amuttesu aggahaNaM / / 24 / / dravyArthAntarabhUtaguNavAdino dravyAdarthAntarabhUtaguNA mUrtAH, amUrtA vA bhaveyuH ? yadi mUrtAH paramANavo na tarhi paramANavo na bhavanti, mUrtimadrUpAdyAdhAratvAt anekaprAdezikaskandhadravyavat / athAmUrtAH, agrahaNaM teSAm amUrtatvAt AkAzavat / tato dravya-guNayoH kathaMcid bhedAbhedAvabhyupagamanIyau anyathoktadoSaprasakteH / tathAhi-dravya-guNayoH kathaMcid bhedaH yathAkramamekAnekapratyayAvaseyatvAta, kathaMcidabhedo'pi rUpAdyAtmanA dravyasvarUpasya rUpAdInAM ca dravyAtmakatayA pratIteH; anyathA tadabhAvApatteH / / 24 / / -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa.83 atrottaram "davvatthaMtarabhUyA, muttAmuttA ya(va) te guNA hojjA / jai muttA paramANU, Natthi amuttesu aggahaNaM / / 3/24 / / " dravyArthAntarabhUtA guNA mUrtA amUrtA vA bhaveyuH, yadi mUrtA na tarhi paramANavo bhavanti, mUrtimadrUpAdyAdhAratvAd, aneka prAdezikaskandhavat, athAmUrtAH, agrahaNaM teSAM amUrttatvAdAkAzavat / tato dravyaguNayoH kathaJcidbhedAbhedAvabhyupagamanIyau, anyathA pratItivirodhAt / tathAhi-dravyaguNayoryathAkramamekAnekapratyayAvaseyatvAtkathaJcidbhedaH pratIyate, kathaJcidabhedo'pi rUpAdyAtmanA dravyasvarUpasya rUpAdInAM ca dravyAtmakatayA pratIteH, anyathA tadabhAvApatteH, etaJca vivakSAmAtreNocyate'nyathA jAtyantarAtmake vastuni bhedAbhedAdanyatarakathAyA evAsambhavAt, na hi citraM vastu nIlapItAdyanyataratayA kathyate carcyate vA, ekatarajijJAsayA kevalaM tathA pratIyata iti / 2010_02

Page #210
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-25 [ prastutaprapaJcasya ziSyabuddhivezadyamAtraprayojanakatvakathanam ] tataH sIsamaIvipphAraNamettattho'yaM kao samullAvo / iharA kahAmuhaM ceva Natthi evaM sasamayammi / / 25 / / ziSyabuddhivikAzanamAtrArtho'yaM kRtaH prabandhaH, itarathA kathaivaiSA nAsti svasiddhAnte 'kimete guNA guNino bhinnAH, Ahosvid abhinnAH' iti, anekAntAtmakatvAt sakalavastunaH / / 25 / / -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa.83 etadAha "sIsamaIviSphAraNamettatthoyaM kao samullAvo / iharA kahAmuhaM ceva, Natthi evaM sasamayammi / / 3/25 / / " ziSyabuddhivikAsanamAtrArtho'yaM kRtaH prabandhaH, itarathA kathaivaiSA nAsti svasiddhAnte, kimete guNA guNino bhinnA AhosvidabhinnA ? iti, 'anekAntAtmakatvAtsakalavastunaH / -: nayopadeze : gA. 6 nanu tathApyutsargato'nAdaraNIyatvAdeva naya-durnayabhASayoravizeSaH, tathA coktaM vAdinA- [sammatau] "sIsamaiviSphAraNamettattho'yaM kao samullAvo / iharA kahAmuhaM ceva Natthi evaM sasamayaMmi" / / 3/25 / / iti cet, na-ziSyamativiSphArakatvaM hi nayavAkyasya pramANAtmakamahAvAkyajanyazAbdabodhajanakAvAntaravAkyArthajJAnajanakatvam, tadanukUlAkAGkSotthApakatvaM vA, tena tasyAdaraNIyatvasyaiva siddheH / 1. eyaM (nayo., tattvA. yazo.kRtaviva.) / 2010_02

Page #211
166 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-26 -: tattvArthAdhigamasUtre : mahAmaho.yazovijayajIkRtavivaraNe a.1, sU.35 utsargato hi pAramezvarapravacanapariNatabuddhInAM syAdvAdAbhidhAnamevocitaM paripUrNavastupratipAdakatvAt, tadvyutpattyarthitayA tu ziSyANAmaMzagrAhiSu nayavAdeSvapyapavAdataH pravRttirucitaiva / "azuddha vartmani sthitvA, tataH zuddhaM samIhata" ityAdinyAyAditi bhAvaH / tadidamAha-sammatau mahAvAdI "sIsamaIviSphAraNametatthoyaM kao samullAvo / iharA kahAmuhaM ceva, Natthi evaM sasamayaMmi / / 3/25 / / " iti / / [ vastutve kathaMcid bhedAbhedAtmake vyavasthite'pi tadanyathAvAdinAM mithyAdRSTitvakathanam ] evaMrUpe ca vastutattve anyathArUpaM tat pratipAdayanto mithyAvAdino bhavantItyAha Na vi asthi aNNavAdo Na vi tavvAo jiNovaesammi / taM ceva ya maNNaMtA avamaNNaMtA Na yANaMti / / 26 / / naivAsti anyavAdo guNa-guNinoH, nApyananyavAdo jinopadeze dvAdazAGge pravacane sarvatra kathaMcidityAzrayaNAt / tadeva anyadeveti vA manyamAnAH mananIyameva avamanyamAnA vAdino'bhyupagataviSayAvajJAvidhAyitvAd ajJA bhavanti abhyupagamanIyavastvastitvapratipAdakopAyanimittAparijJAnAd mRSAvAdivaditi tAtparyArthaH / tato'nekAntavAda eva vyavasthitaH / / 26 / / -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa.83 evaMrUpe ca vastutattve'nyathArUpaM tatpratipAdayanto mithyAvAdino bhavantItyAha ___ "Na vi atthi aNNavAo, Na vi tavyAo jiNovaesammi / taM ceva ya maNNaMtA avamaNNaMtA Na yANaMti / / 3/26 / / " naivAstyanyavAdo guNaguNino pyananyavAdo jinopadeze dvAdazAGge pravacane, sarvatra kathaJcidityA 2. evaM (saMmati.) / ___JainEducation International 2010_02

Page #212
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 3, gAthA - 27 zrayaNAt, tadevAnyadeveti vA manyamAnA mananIyamevAvamanyamAnA vAdino'bhyupagataviSayAvajJAvidhAyitvAdajJA bhavanti, abhyupagamanIyavastvastitvapratipAdakopAyanimittAparijJAnAnmRSAvAdivaditi tAtparyArthaH / tato'nekAntavAda eva vyavasthitaH / / [ anekAntasya vyApakatAM pradarzayitumanekAnte'pyanekAntAbhyupagamanam ] nanu 'sarvatrAnekAntaH' iti niyame anekAnte'pyanekAntAd ekAntaprasaktiH / atha nAnekAnte anekAntavAdastarhi avyApako'nekAntavAda ityatrAha bhayaNA vihu bhaiyavvA jaha bhayaNA bhayai savvadavvAiM / evaM bhayaNA niyamo vi hoi samayAviroheNa / / 27 / / yathA bhajanA anekAnto bhajate sarvavastUni tadatatsvabhAvatayA jJApayati tathA bhajanA'pi anekAnto'pi bhajanIyaH anekAnto'pyanekAnta ityarthaH-naya- pramANApekSayA 'ekAntathA'nekAntaSTA' ityevaM jJApanIyaH / evaM ca bhajanA'nekAntaH saMbhavati, niyamaSTA ekAntaSTA siddhAntasya " rayaNappabhA siA sAsayA siyA'sAsayA" [ jIvAjIvAbhi0 pratipa0 3 u0 1 sU0 78 ] ityevamanekAntapratipAdakasya " davvaTTayAe sAsayA, pajjavaTTayAe asAsayA" ] ityevaM caikAntAbhidhAyakAvirodhena / [ 167 na caivamavyApako'nekAntavAdaH, 'syAt 'padasaMsUcitAnekAntagarbhasyaikAntasya tattvAt anekAntasyApi 'syAt'kAralAJchanaikAntagarbhasya anekAntasvabhAvatvAt / na cAnavasthA, anyanirapekSasvasvarUpata eva tathAtvopapatteH yadvA svarUpata evAnekAntasyaikAntapratiSedhenAnekAntarUpatvAt 'syAdekAntaH' 'syAdanekAntaH' iti kathaM nAnekAnte'nekAnto'pi / anekAntAtmakavastuvyavasthApakasya tadvyavasthApakatvaM svayamanekAntAtmakatvamantareNA'nekAntasyA'nupapannamiti na tatrA'vyApakatvAdidoSa ityasakRdAveditameva / / 27 / / 1. 0 yAvirAhaNayA (ane. vya., syA. kalpa., guru vini., upa. raha . ) / 2010_02

Page #213
168 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-27 -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa.83 nanu sarvatrA'nekAnta iti niyame'nekAnte'pyanekAntAdekAntaprasariktiriti cet, atra vadanti "bhayaNA vi hu bhaiyavvA, jaha bhayaNA bhayai savvadavvAiM / evaM bhayaNANiyamo vi, hoi samayAvirAhaNayA' / / 3/27 / / " "yathA bhajanA'nekAnto bhajate sarvavastUni tadetatsvabhAvatayA jJApayati, tathA bhajanApyanekAnto'pi, bhajanIyA anekAnto'pyanekAnta itISTamasmAkaM iti nayapramANApekSayaikAntaSTAnekAntapTotyevamasau jJApanIyaH, tathAhi nityAnityAdizabalaikasvarUpe vastuni nityatvAnityatvAvAdhekataradharmAvacchedanaikataradharmAtmakatvamubhayAvacchedena vobhayAtmakatvaM tathA nityAnityatvAdisaptadharmAtmakatvapratipAdakatatparyAptyadhikaraNe'nekAntamahAvAkye'pi sakalanayavAkyAvacchedenoktarUpamanekAntAtmakatvaM pratyekanayavAkyAvacchedena caikAntAtmakatvaM na durvacamiti bhAvaH / etadevAha evamuktarItyA, bhajanA'nekAntaH sambhavati, niyamaSTaukAntapTA, samayasya siddhAntasya-"rayaNappabhA siya sAsayA siya asAsayA" - ityevamanekAntapratipAdakasya-"davvaTThayAe sAsayA pajjavaTThayAe asAsayA" -- ityevaM caikAntabhidhAyakasyAvirodhena / na caivamavyApako'nekAntavAdaH, syAtpadasaMsUcitAnekAntagarbhasyaivaikAntasvabhAvatvAdanekAntasyApi syAtkAralAJchanaikAntagarbhasyAnekAntasvabhAvatvAt / na cAnavasthA dezakAtAbhyAmavayavAvayavirUpasya vastuna iva syAdvAdasyApyekAntAnekAntAtmakasyaiva pramANAdeva pratIteH, bhinnaikAntA'nekAntAvalambane'pyasyA jJaptivirodhitvAbhAvAtsvasAmagrImahimnA tAdRzasyaivotpattermitho'napekSaNAdutpattivirodhitAyA api vaktumazakyatvAt, na cotpattijJaptyanyatarApratibandhikApyanavasthA dUSaNam, yattArkikAH-"mUlakSayakarI prAhuranavasthAM hi dUSaNam / " iti, na cedevaM tadA prameyatve prameyatvAdyupagame'pyanavasthAdoSo durnivAraH syAt, yadvA yathA naiyAyikAdInAM 'ghaTAbhAvo'tirikta eva, tadabhAvaSTA ghaTa eva, tRtIyAbhAvaSTAdya eva, caturthapTA dvitIya eva' ityAdirItyA nAnavasthA tathA'smAkaM anekAntaH1, anekAntAnekAnta ekAntaH2, tadanekAnta Adya eva, tadanekAntapTA dvitIya eveti tRtIyacaturthAdyanekAntAnAmAdyadvitIyayoreva paryavasAnAtkA'navasthA nAma / ekAntaniyAmakasvaparUpayoranavasthAnAdekAntagarbhAnekAntasya parijJAtumazakyatvAjjhaptipratibandhikaiveyamanavastheti kaSTiAt, tanna, itthamapi 'guDazuNThI' nyAyenAnavacchinnAnekAnte doSAbhAvAt / sAvacchinnAnekAntavAde'pi sUkSmAvacchedakajijJAsoparama evAnekAntaprayogAntaraparizramoparame'navasthAnavakAzAditi dig / / 1. vyAviroheNa (saMmati.) / 2010_02

Page #214
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-27 169 -: zAstravArtAsamuccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAM sta.7, gA. 2 na ca zokAdikaM nirhetukamiti vaktuM yuktam, nityaM sattvasyA'sattvasya vA prasaGgAt / na ca yuSmAkamapi tatra ghaTamukuTobhayArthinA yugapacchokapramodotpAda iti vAcyam, ekatrobhayArthipravRttyayogAt / ekatra deze tatpravRttau cobhayasya kathaJcitpratyekAtirekeNa doSAbhAvAt, yena rUpeNa yatrecchA tena rUpeNa tannAzo-tpAda-sthitijJAnAnAmeva zoka-pramoda-mAdhyasthyahetutvAt, anekAntasyApyanekAntAnuvidvaikAntagarbhatvAt / taduktam "bhayaNA vi hu bhaiyavvA jaha bhayaNA bhayai savvadavvAiM / evaM bhayaNA niyamo vi hoi samayAvirAhaNayA / / " 3/27 / / iti / -: gurutattvavinizcaye : u. 1 gA. 52 tathA ca siddhavyAkhyAtA nyAyAvatAravivRtau syAdastyeva jIva iti pramANavAkyamupanyastavAn, tathA ca tadgato granthaH "yadA tu pramANavyApAramavikalaM parAmRzya pratipAdayitumabhiprayanti tadAGgIkRtaguNapradhAnabhAvAzeSadharmasUcakakathaJcitparyAyasyAcchabdavibhUSitayA sAvadhAraNayA ca vAcA syAdastyeva jIva ityAdikayA darzayanti / ato'yaM syAcchabdasaMsUcitAbhyantarIbhUtAnantadharmakasya sAkSAdupanyastajIvazabdakriyAbhyAM pradhAnIkRtAtmabhAvasyAvadhAraNavyavacchinnatadasambhavasya vastunaH saMdarzakatvAtsakalAdeza ityucyate, pramANapratipannasampUrNArthakathanamiti yAvadityAdi / " tasmAdasmaduktaiva pramANanayavyavasthA samIcInA, yathA yo nAma nayo nayAntarasApekSaH sa paramArthataH syAtpadaprayogamabhilaSan sampUrNa vastu gRhNAtIti pramANe'ntarbhAvanIyaH / nayAntaranirapekSastu nayo durnayaH, sa ca niyamAnmithyAdRSTireva, sampUrNavastugrAhakatvAbhAvAditi / " atredamavadheyam-yo nAma nayo nayAntarApekSastasya pramANAntarbhAva vyavahAranayaH pramANaM syAt, tasya tapaHsaMyamapravacanagrAhakatvena saMyamagrAhiniSTAyaviSayaviSayakatvena tatsApekSatvAt / zabdanayAnAM ca nikSepacatuSTayAnabhyupagantRRNAM bhAvAbhyupagantRzabdanayaviSayaviSayakatvena tatsApekSatvAtpramANatvApattiH / nayAntaravAkyasaMyogena sApekSatve ca grAhye syAtpadaprayogeNa sapratipakSanayadvayaviSayAvacche 1. vyAvirohaNa (saMmati.) / 2010_02

Page #215
170 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-27 dakasyaiva lAbhAta, tenAnantadharmakatvAparAmarzaH, na cedevaM tadA'nekAnte samyagekAntapravezAnupapattiravacchedakabhedaM vinA sapratipakSaviSayasamAvezasya durvacatvAt, iSyate cAyam, yadAha mahAmatiH - "bhayaNA vi hu bhaiyavvA jaha bhayaNA bhayai savvadavvAiM / evaM bhayaNAniyamo vi hoi samayAvirAhaNayA / / 3/27 / / iti" / / -: upadezarahasye : gAthA 101 "aitehiM dohiM ThANehiM vavahAro Na vijjai / etehiM dohiM ThANehiM aNAyAraM tu jANae / / 3 / / 'sarvaM nityamevAnityameva vA' etAbhyAM dvAbhyAM sthAnAbhyAmabhyupagamyamAnAbhyAmanayorvA pakSayorvyavahAro lokasyaihikAmuSmikayoH kAryayoH pravRttinivRttilakSaNayorna vidyate / ekAntanityatve ghaTAdyarthaM kumbhakArAdermokSAdyarthaM tapasviprabhRtInAM ca pravRttyanupapatteH, ekAntA'nityatve'pi lokAnAmanAgatabhogArthaM dhanadhAnyAdisaMgrahArthaM mumukSUNAM ca mokSArthaM pravRttyanupapattereva, nityAnityatvayoH pratiniyatAzrayatvavAde'pyekatra mRdAdau sthAsakuzUlaghaTAdhanekakAryArthapravRtteranupapatterekasyAnekapariNAmitvavirodhAt, ata etayoH sthAnayorekAntatvenAzrIyamANayoranAcAraM maunIndrAgamabAhyatvarUpaM jAnIyAt / 'tu'zabdo vizeSaNArthaH, 'kathaJcinnityAnitye vastuni vyavahAro yujyate' ityetadvizinaSTi, ekAMzamAdAya nayavyavahArasyobhayamAdAya ca pramANavyavahArasyopapatteH / na caivamapi syAnnityameva syAdanityameveti ca prAptam, tatrApyevakArArthAvadhAraNabalAd yenAkAreNa nityatvaM tena nityatvamevetyekAntatvApattiriti zaGkanIyam, anityatvAsaMvalitasya nityatvavyavacchedasyAprasiddheH, tatsaMvalitasya ca tasya sattve kiJcidapekSayA ekAntasaMvalitAnekAntAnapAyAt, tathA cAha sammatikAraH "bhayaNAvi hu bhaiyavvA jaha mayaNA bhayai savvadavvAI / evaM bhayaNAniyamo vi hoi samayAvirAhaNayA / / " (3-27) 1. nyAviroheNa (saMmati.) / 2010_02

Page #216
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-28 171 [ SaD jIvanikAyAstadaghAte ca dharma ityatrApyanekAntavyavasthApanam ] nanvanekAntasya vyApakatve 'SaD jIvanikAyAH' 'tadaghAte vA dharmaH' ityatrApyanekAnta eva syAdityAzaGkayA''ha NiyameNa saddahaMto chakkAe bhAvao na saddahai / haMdI apajjavesu vi saddahaNA hoi avibhattA / / 28 / / niyamenA'vadhAraNena 'SaDevaite jIvAH kAyApTA' ityevaM zraddadhAnaH SaTkAyAn bhAvataH paramArthato na zraddhatte jIvarAzyapekSayA teSAmekatvAt kAyAnAmapi pudgalatayaikatvAt jIvapudgalapradezAnAM parasparAvinirbhAgavRttitvAJca jIvapradezAnAM syAd ajIvatvam pratyeka prAdhAnyavivakSayA syAd anikAyatvam sUtravihitanyAyena pravRttasyA'pramattasya 'hiMsA'pyahiMsA' iti 'tapTAte syAdadharmaH' iti / na bhAvasamyagdRSTirasau syAt, dravyasamyagdRSTistu syAt 'bhagavataivamuktam' iti jinavacanarucisvabhAvatvAt / tato'paryAyeSvapi na vidyante arcimurmurAdayo vivakSitaparyAyA yeSu pudgaleSu teSvapi avibhaktazraddhAnaM yat tadapi bhAvata eva bhavet'arciSmAnayaM bhAvo bhUto bhAvI vA' iti / tannA'vyApako'nekAntavAdaH / / 28 / / -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa.84 nanvanekAntasya vyApakatve 'SaDjIvanikAyAstaSTAte cAdharma' ityatrApyanekAntaH syAditi cet, atrAhu: "NiyameNa saddahaMto chakkAe bhAvao Na saddahai / haMdI apajjavesu vi, saddahaNA hoi avibhattA / / 3/28 / / " niyamenAvadhAraNena SaDevaite jIvAH kAyApTotyevaM zraddadhAnaH SaTkAyAnbhAvataH paramArthato na zraddhatte, jIvarAzyapekSayA teSAmekatvAtkAyAnAmapi pudgalatayaikatvAt, jIvapudgalapradezAnAM parasparA'vinirbhAgavRttitvAjjIvapradezAnAM syAdajIvatvam, pratyekaM prAdhAnyavivakSayA syAdanikAyatvaM sUtravihitanyAyena pravRttasyApramattasya na hiMseti, taSTAte'pi syAdadharma iti na bhAvasamyagdRSTirasau, dravyasamyagdRSTistu syAdevAnyadarzanAsadgrahanivRttyA jinavacanarucisvabhAvasya saMkSepasamyaktvalakSaNa-tvAt, tathA ca pArama) [uttarA0a028] 2010_02

Page #217
172 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-28 "aNabhiggahiyakudiTThI, saMkhevaruitti hoi NAyavyo / avisArao pavayaNe, aNabhiggahio ya sesesu" / / 26 / / tti / tato'paryAyeSvapi na vidyante'cimurmurAdayo vivakSitaparyAyA yeSu pudgaleSu teSvapyavibhaktazraddhAnaM yattadapi bhAvata eva bhavedarciSmAnayaM bhAvo bhUto bhAvI veti, na hi bhUtabhAviparyAyoparaktavAkyaM dravyataH satyaM bhavati, savizeSeNa' iti nyAyAd bhUtabhAviparyAyadhvaMsaprAgabhAvAvagAhitvAt, tatra dravyataH satyatvamiti cet, na tathApi dharmAze dravyato'vibhaktasyApi dharmyaMze vibhaktasya pratyayasya bhAvata eva sambhavAt, tannAtrApyavyApako'nekAntavAdaH / / vastuto niyamena SaT kAyAn zraddadhadbhAvato na samyagdRSTirityatraiva heturayam, handi yataH aparyAyeSu ekAdiprakArarahiteSu SaTsu kAyeSu zraddhA'vibhaktA bhavati syAdvAdajJAnaparisamApyAkAGkSAparipUrtyA'vizrAntA bhavati "egavihaduvihativihA"-ityAdiprarUpaNayaiva tadvizrAntisambhavAdityayamartho'nubhavasammukhIna iti dhyeyam / -: aSTasahasItAtparyavivaraNe : pari. 6, kA. 77-78 tadAha sammatau mahAvAdI niyameNa saddahaMto chakkAe bhAvao Na saddahai / haMdI apajjavesu vi saddahaNA hoi avibhattA / / [3/28] asyA arthaH-niyamena SaDevetyavadhAraNena SaTakAyAn zraddadhadapi bhAvato na zraddhatte, prakRtadharmaghaTitasaptabhaGgaparyAptaprakAratAkabodhAdijanitasamUhAlambanarucereva prakRtadharmabhAvazraddhApadArthatvAt, tadAha-aparyAyeSu bhaGgAntarasaMvalanarahiteSu dharmeSu, apebhinnakramatvAt zraddhA'pyavibhaktA'sampUrNA bhavati, dravyazraddhAparyavasannA bhavatIti yAvat / ayamasmAkaM manISonmeSaH / anye tvevamuttarArddha vyAcakSate- handi yato'paryayeSvavivakSitaparyAyeSu pudgaleSvapi zraddhA'vibhaktA ekarUpA bhavatIti, tathA ca pUrvottarAddhAbhyAM jIvapudgalayoH sAmAnyata ekarUpatvopadarzanAttadubhayaghaTitanikAyaSaTkaikAntabAdhAttacchraddhAnasya dravyasamyaktvarUpatvameva jinavacanAbhinivezadazAyAm, svAbhinivezadazAyAM tu zuddhAtmasvarUpabAdhanena tanmAtravizrAntAntaraGgaratnatrayabAdhanAnmithyAtvarUpatvameveti tadabhiprAyamapya 2010_02

Page #218
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-28 173 viruddhamevAkalayAmaH / tadevaM vistArAjJArucibhedena hetuvAdAhetuvAdayorvyApakatvaM vyavasthitam, AharaNataddezatadoSopanyAsAdihetuvistarastu matkRtopadezAmRtataraGgiNIto bodhyaH, yathA tadvyApakatve niHzaGkaM cetaH syAdityuparamyate / vyavahAratastu hetubahulatvAt prAyo dRSTivAdAkhya Agamo hetuvAdaH, taditarapTAAhetuvAda ucyate, tadapekSayA'yaM prajJApakavibhAgaH sammatisiddhaH jo heuvAyapakkhammi heuo Agame ya Agamio / so sasamayapaNNavao siddhaMtavirAhago aNNo ||1||tti [3/45] anyasya virAdhakatvaM ca pratipAdakavacasyanAsthAdidoSotpAdanAditi bodhyam / / 78 / / -: zAstravArtAsamuccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAM sta.7, gA.30 na caivamanekAnte 'SaDeva jIvanikAyAH' iti zraddhAnavatAM samyaktvabhaGgaH, vibhAgavAkyAd nyUnatA'lAbhe'nekAntavyAghAtAd mithyAtvApatteriti vAcyam; bhAvatasteSAmanekAntaparijJAnazUnyAnAmasamyagdaSTitvAdeva, jIvarAzyapekSayA teSAM kAyAnAmapi pudgalatayA jIva-pudgalapradezAnAM ca parasparA'vinirbhAgavRttitayaikatvasyA'zraddhAnAt / dravyata eva ca 'bhagavataivamuktam' iti jinavacanarucisvabhAvatvena samyagdRSTitvAt / taduktam NiameNa saddahato chakkAe bhAvao Na saddahai / haMdI apajavesu vi saddahaNA hoi avibhattA / / 3/28 / / iti / -: adhyAtmasAre : SaSThe vairAgyabhedAdhikAre ekAntena hi SaTkAya-zraddhAne'pi na zuddhatA / sampUrNaparyayAlAbhAd, yanna yAthAtmyaniSTAyaH / / 22 / / 2010_02

Page #219
174 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-29 [ gatimatyapi dravye apekSAvizeSeNa gatyagatI pradAnekAntasya vyApakatvopapAdanam ] nanvanekAntasya vyApakatve 'gacchati tiSThati' ityatrA'pyanekAntaH syAt, tathAbhyupagame ca tayorabhAvaprasaktirityetadevA''ha gaipariNayaM gaI ceva kei NiyameNa daviyamicchaMti / taM pi ya uDDagaIyaM tahA gaI anahA agaI / / 29 / / _ 'gatikriyApariNAmavad dravyaM gatimadeva' iti kecid manyante, tadapi gatikriyApariNataM jIvadravyaM sarvato gamanA'yogAd UrdhvAdipratiniyatadiggatikaM tairvAdibhirabhyupagantavyam; evaM ca tat tathA pratiniyatadiggamanenaiva gatimat; anyathA'pi gatimat syAt tadA'bhipretadezaprAptivad anabhipretadezaprAptirapi tasya bhavedityanupalabhyamAnayugapadviruddhobhayadezaprAptiprasakteratrApyanekAnto nA'vyApakaH / abhipretagatireva tatrA'nabhipretA'gatiriti cet, na; anabhipretagatyabhAvAbhAve pratiniyatagatibhAva eva na bhavet tatsadbhAve vA tadavastho'nekAntaH / / 29 / / anekAntavyavasthAyAM anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa.85 nanvanekAntasya vyApakatve gacchati tiSThatItyatrApyanekAntaH syAditi cet, syAdevetyAha "gaipariNayaM gaI ceva, kei NiyameNa daviyamicchaMti / taM pi ya uDDagaI, tahA gaI aNNahA agaI / / 3/29 / / " gatikriyApariNataM dravyaM gatimadeveti kecinmanyante, tadapi gatikriyApariNataM jIvadravyaM sarvato gamanAyogAdUrdhvAdipratiniyatadiggatikaM tairvAdibhirabhyupagantavyam, evaM ca tattathApratiniyatadiggamanena gatimadanyathA cA'gatimadeva, anyathApi yadi gatimatsyAt tadA'bhipretadezaprAptivadanabhipretadezaprAptirapi tasya bhavedityanupalabhyamAnayugapadviruddhobhayadezaprAptiprasaktirityatrApyanekAnto nAvyApakaH, abhipretagatireva tatrAnabhipretAgatiriti cet, na anabhipretagatyabhAvAbhAve pratiniyatagatibhAvasyaivAbhAvAt, tatsadbhAve ca tadavastho'nekAntaH / nanu gatimadevetyekAntena gatisAmAnyavati gatisAmAnyAbhAvo niSidhyate sa ca gativizeSAbhAvena nApodyate, nahi vizeSAbhAva eva sAmAnyabhAva iti ko'yamanekAnta iti cet, na, gatisAmAnyavatyapi gativizeSAbhAvena bhAvAbhAvobhayarUpatAsamAvezAdevAnekAntasAmrAjyAt / na ca vizeSAbhAvebhyaH sAmAnyabhAvo'pi sarvathAtiriktaH, kintu 2010_02

Page #220
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-29 yAvadvizeSAbhAvAdhikaraNAvacchedenAtirikto yatkiJcidvizeSAbhAvAdhikaraNAvacchedena cAnatirikta iti gatisAmAnyavati vizeSarUpeNa tatsAmAnyAbhAvo'pi na durlabhaH / gatimati gatitvAvacchinnapratiyogitAkAbhAvaniSedhAnnaikAntavyAghAta iti cet, na, sAmAnyarUpeNa vizeSAbhAvamAdAyetthamapi vaktumazakyatvAt, gatitvAvacchinnagatisAmAnyaniSThapratiyogitAkAbhAvena saha gatisAmAnyavirodhaikAnta eveti cet, na, sAmAnyAvacchinnapratiyogitAkatvasyAdhikaraNavizeSAvacchedenaiva sambhavAt, tattadadhikaraNAntarbhAvena virodhAvirodhayorapyanekAntasyaiva sAmrAjyAt / yadi ca sAmAnyAvacchinnapratiyogitAko'bhAvo'tirikta eva tadA dravyavizeSa rUpaM na tu dravyasAmAnya iti pratItyA sAmAnyAvacchinnAdhikaraNatAko'pyabhAvo'tirikto'bhyupagantavyaH, tasmAdabhAvasya sAmAnyAdhikaraNakatvasya sAmAnyapratiyogitAkatvasya svataH sAmAnyavizeSabhAvasya cAnekAntakroDIkRtatvAdbhAvAbhAvayorvirodhAvirodhAvapi tAdRzAvevetyabhiprAyAt / etena 'bhAvAbhAvasAmAnyayoreva virodhakalpanAdbhedAbhedAdyanekAntasamAvezo'prAmANikaH' ityapAstam, virodhasyApi vizeSavizrAntatvena yathAnubhavaM guNaguNyAdibhedAbhedAdyavirodhakalpana eva lAghavAdityadhika matkRtanayarahasye / -: zAstravArtAsamuccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAM sta.7, gA.30 evaM 'gacchati-tiSThati' ityAdau, 'dahanAd dahanaH-pacanAt pacanaH' ityAdau, 'jIvadravyamajIvadravyaM' cetyAdAvapyanvayavyatirekavyAptirbhAvanIyA, gatisthityAdipariNatasyApyUrdhvagatibhUtalasthitityAdyapekSayaiva gati-sthitimattvAt, anyathA'bhipretadezaprApti-sthitivadanabhipretadezaprAptisthityorapi prasaGgAt, tathAsvabhAvasattve kAraNAbhAvasyA'prayojakatvAt, kAraNasamAjena tathAsvabhAvasyaivAkSepAt anyathA'tiprasaGgAt / dahanAderapi dAhAdipariNAmayogyApekSayaiva dahanAditvAta, anyathA cA'tathAtvAta, adahanasyApyudakAdidravyasya svayamadahanatve'pi pRthivyAdyadahanavyAvRttatayA kathaJcidatathAtvAt, samayAvirodhena bhajanApravRtteH, jIvA'jIvayorapi kumbhAdyapekSayA jIvApekSayA cA'tathAtvAt, anyathA sarvasya sarvAtmakatApatteH / tadidamAha gaipariNayaM gaI ceva kei NiameNa daviamicchaMti / taM pi a uDDagaiaMtahA gaI aNNahA agaI / / 3/29 / / guNaNivvattiasaNNA evaM dahaNAdao vi daTThavvA / jaM tu jahA paDisiddhaM davyamadavvaM tahA hoi / / 3/30 / / 2010_02

Page #221
176 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-30 kumbho Na jIvadavi jIvo vi Na hoi kuMbhadaviaM ti / tamhA do vi adaviaM aNNoNNavisesiA huMti / / 3/31 / / iti / --: nyAyakhaNDakhAghe (mahAvIrastave) : vibhAga-1, gA. 16 tathA zAbdabodhasyApi nayabhedena vyutpattisaGkocAdupapatteH, yogyatAjJAnasyApi sambandhavizeSaniyantritasya sambhavAt / tadayaM sAmAnyarUpeNa vizeSAbhAva eva prasaktaH sa ca pratiyogitAvacchedAkAvacchinnasattvasyAbhAvavirodhitvAdanupapanna iti cet / na / virodhasya sambandhavizeSaniyantritatvenoktottaratvAt, tadayaM nimittabhedAdvizeSapratiyogikatvena sAmAnyarUpeNa vizeSAbhAvo vocyatAM sAmAnyarUpeNa pratiyogyullekhAdviziSTasambandhena sAmAnyAbhAvo veti syAdvAdinAM na kimapi durvacam / anenaivAbhiprAyeNAha-gandhahastI sammatI "gaipariNayaM gaI ceva, kei NiyameNa daviyamicchanti / ___ taM pi ya uDDhagaIaMtahA gaI aNNahA agaI" / / 3/29 / / tti| kuto'pi nimittAt yad yadekAntena paraiH svIkriyate nimittabhedAvatAreNa tattannirAkRtya syAdvAdaviSayasamuJcayamaryAdAyAM neyam, gatimattvAderiva guNavattvAderapyekAntadravyalakSaNatvAyogAditi etattAtparyam / / [ dahanAdAvapekSAvizeSeNAdahanatvAdikaM nirUpyAnekAntasya vyApakatvasamarthanam ] syAdetat 'dahanAd dahanaH, pavanAt pavanaH' ityatrApyanekAnte dahanAdAvadahanAdeviruddharUpasya saMbhavAt svarUpAbhAvaH syAdityatrAha guNaNivvattiyasaNNA evaM dahaNAdao vi daTThavvA / jaM tu jahA paDisiddhaM davvamadavvaM tahA hoi / / 30 / / guNena dahanAdinA nirvartitotpAditA saMjJA'bhidhAnaM yeSAM te'pi dahana-pavanAdaya evamevA'nekAntAtmakA draSTavyAH / tathAhi-dAhyapariNAmayogyaM tRNAdikaM dahatIti dahanaH tadapariNatisvabhAvaM svAtmAkAzA'prApta-vajrA'NvAdikaM na dahatIti / tena yad dravyaM yathA dahanarUpatayA pratiSiddhaM tad adravyamadahanAdirUpam tathA bhajanAprakAreNa syAd dahanaH syAnneti bhavati tato nA'vyApI anekAntaH / 2010_02 -

Page #222
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-30-31 177 tathA, 'adahanaH' ityatrApyanekAntaH / tathAhi-yad udakadravyaM yathA dahanarUpeNa pratiSiddhaMdahano na bhavatIti 'adahanaH' iti tadapi na sarvathA adahanadravyaM bhavati, pRthivyAderadahanarUpAd vyAvRttatvAt anyathA dahanavyatiriktabhUtaikatvaprasaGga ityanekAnta eva adahanavyAvRttasya tadravyatvAt / / 30 / / -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa.85 syAdetad, dahanAddahanaH pacanAtpacana ityatrApyanekAnte dahanAdAvadahanAdiviruddharUpasya sambhavAt svarUpAbhAvaprasaGgastatrAha "guNanivvattiyasaNNA, evaM dahaNAdao vi daTThavA / jaMtu jahA paDisiddhaM, davvamadavvaM tahA hoi / / 3/30 / / " guNena dahanAdinA nirvartitA utpAditA saMjJA yeSAM te'pi dahanapacanAdayaH, evamevAnekAntAtmakA draSTavyAH, tathA hi dAhapariNAmayogyaM tRNAdikaM dahatIti dahanaH, tadapariNatisvabhAvaM tvAtmAkAzAprAptavajrANvAdikaM na dahatItyadahanaH, tena yad dravyaM yathA dahanarUpatayA pratiSiddham, tadadravyamadahanAdikam, tathA bhajanAprakAreNa syAddahanaH syAneti bhavati, tato nAvyApya'nekAntaH / tathA'dahana ityatrA-pyanekAntaH, tathAhi yadudakadravyaM dahanarUpeNa pratiSiddhaM dahano na bhavatItyadahana iti bhavati tadapi na sarvathA'dahanadravyaM bhavati, pRthivyAderadahanarUpAd vyAvRttatvAt, anyathA dahanavyatiriktabhUtaikatvaprasaGga ityanekAnta eva, dahanavyAvRttasya tadatadravyatvAt / [ sarvasyApi vastunaH pratiniyatasvarUpAnyathAnupapattyA svarUpAstitva pararUpanAstitvAbhyupagamenAnekAntAtmakatvapradarzanam ] nanvevaM tadatavyatvAd jIvadravyamajIvadravyam ajIvadravyaM ca jIvadravyaM syAdityAzaGkayA''ha. kuMbho Na jIvadaviyaM jIvo vi Na hoi kuMbhadaviyaM ti / tamhA do vi adaviyaM aNNoNNavisesiyA hoti / / 31 / / kumbho jIvadravyaM na bhavatIti jIvo'pi na bhavati ghaTadravyam / tasmAd dvAvapi adravyamanyonyavizeSitau parasparAbhAvAtmakau / 2010_02

Page #223
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa 3, gAthA- 31-32 yato'yamabhiprAyaH-jIvadravyaM kumbhAderajIvadravyAd vyAvRttam avyAvRttaM vA ? prathamapakSe svarUpApekSayA jIvo jIvadravyam, kumbhAdyajIvadravyApekSayA tu na jIvadravyamityubhayarUpatvAdanekAnta eva / dvitIyavikalpe tu sarvasya sarvAtmakatApatteH pratiniyatarUpAbhAvatastayorabhAvaH kharaviSANavat tataH sarvamanekAntAtmakam - anyathA pratiniyatarUpatA'nupapatteH-iti vyavasthitam / / 31 / / 178 -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa. 86 nanvevaM tadatadddravyatvAjjIvadravyamajIvadravyam ajIvadravyaM ca jIvadravyaM syAt ityAzaGkAyAmAha - "kuMbho Na jIvadaviyaM jIvo vi Na hoi kuMbhadaviyaM ti / tamhA do vi adaviyaM aNNoNNavisesiyA hoMti / / 3/31 / / " "kumbho jIvadravyam na bhavati, jIvo'pi na bhavati, ghaTadravyaM, tasmAd dvAvapyadravyamanyonyavizeSitau parasparAbhAvAtmakau / yato'yamabhiprAyaH jIvadravyaM kumbhAderajIvadravyAd, vyAvRttamavyAvRttaM vA, prathamapakSe svarUpApekSayA jIvo jIvadravyaM kumbhAdyajIvadravyApekSayA tu na jIvadravyamityubhayarUpatvAdanekAnta eva / dvitIyavikalpe tu sarvasya sarvAtmakatvApatteH, pratiniyatarUpAbhAvatastayorabhAvaH kharaviSANavat, tataH sarvamanekAntAtmakam, anyathA pratiniyatarUpatAnupapatteriti vyavasthitam / [ utpAdaparyAyasya prayoga - visrasAjanyatvena dvaividhyakathanam ] atra prAguktam-'pratyutpannaM paryAyaM vigatabhaviSyadbhyAM yat samAnayati vacanaM tat pratItyavacanam' iti, tatra vacanAdiko'pi paryAyaH, sa cA'prayatnAnantarIyako vacanavizeSalakSaNo ghaTAdikastu prayatnAnantarIyaka iti kecit saMpratipannAstannirAkaraNAya 'yad yato'nvayavyatirekAbhyAM pratIyate tat tata evA'bhyupagantavyam anyathA kAryakAraNabhAvAbhAvaprasaktiH' ityAha upAo duviyappo paogajaNio ya vIsasA ceva / tattha u paogajaNio samudayavAyo aparisuddho ||32|| dvibheda utpAdaH-puruSetarakArakavyApArajanyatayA adhyakSAnumAnAbhyAM tathA tasya pratIteH / 2010_02

Page #224
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-32 179 puruSavyApArAnvayavyatirekAnuvidhAyitve'pi zabdavizeSasya tadajanyatve ghaTAderapi tadajanyatAprasaktervizeSAbhAvAt pratyabhijJAnAdeSTA vizeSasya prAgeva nirastatvAt tatra prayogeNa yo janita utpAdaH-mUrtimadravyArabdhAvayavakRtatvAt-sa samudAyavAdaH, tathAbhUtA''rabdhasya samudAyAtmakatvAt / tata evA'sAvaparizuddhaH, sAvayavAtmakasya tacchabdavAcyatvena abhipretatvAt / / 32 / / -: zAstravArtAsamuccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAM sta.7, gA.1 atrotpAdaH 'utpannamidam' iti dhIsAkSiko dharmaH / sa dvividhaH-1. prayogajanitaH, 2. visrasAjanitaSTA / puruSavyApArajanita AdyaH, sa ca mUrtimadravyArabdhAvayavakRtatvAd samudayavAdaH, tata eva cAsAvaparizuddha iti gIyate / taduktam "uppAo daviyappo paogajaNio a vIsasA ceva / tattha ya paogajaNio samudayavAo aparisuddho / / 3/32 / / " iti atrA'parizuddhatvaM svAzrayayAvadavayavotpAdApekSayA pUrNasvabhAvatvam / na hyapUrNAvayavo ghaTa utpadyamAnaH kAtnye'notpanna iti vyavahriyata iti / nanu ca prayogajanya utpAdaH, ghaTAdereva prayatnajanyatvAt, utpAdasya tvAdyakSaNasaMbandharUpasyA'tathAtvAditi cet ? na, 'mudgarapAtAd naSTo ghaTaH' iti vyapadezAd nAze mudgarapAtajanyatvavat 'puruSavyApArAdutpanno ghaTaH' iti vyavahArAdutpAde'pi puruSavyApArajanyatvasyAvazyakatvAt, vivicyAnanubhUyamAnatvenotpAdApalApe ca nAzasyApyapalApaprasaGgAt, utpatterAdyakSaNasaMbandhenAnyathAsiddhau nAzasyApi caramakSaNasaMbandhanAze'nyayAsiddheH suvacatvAt, anyatra tadAdhAratApratyayasyAtpattyAdhAratApratyayasyevAvacchedakatvenopapatteH / 'ghaTapratiyogikatvena nAzo vilakSaNa evAnubhUyata' iti cet ? tathotpAdo'pIti tulyam / kiJca, evamAdyakSaNe 'AdyakSaNasaMbandhavAn ghaTaH' itivat 'AdyakSaNa utpanno ghaTaH' iti prayogo na sUpapadaH syAditi na kiJcidetat / ____ 2010_02

Page #225
180 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 3, gAthA- 33 -: dravyaguNaparyAyano rAsa : DhA. 8. 18 havaI-utpAdanA bheda kahaI chaI-- dvividha--prayogaja vIsasA, utpAda prathama avizuddha re. te niyamaI samudayavAdano, yatanaIM saMyogaja siddha re. 152. jina0 dvividha-utpAH 2. prA cha; kheDa :- prayoga, jIbhe-vIsasA - hatAM svabhAva nita philoutpAdaH te vyavahArano che, te mATaIM-avizuddha kahiIM. te nirdhAra--samudayavAdano tathA yatanaIM karI avayavasaMyoga siddha ahi. atra sammatigAthA upAo duviappo, paogajaNio a vIsasA ceva / tattha ya paogajaNio, samudayavAo aparisuddho / / 3 / 32 / / -: aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNe pari. 1, kA. 11 nanu evamutpAdAditrayasya kAraNAnapekSatve ghaTotpAdAdyarthe daNDagrahaNAdau pravRttirna syAditi AzaGkAyAM Aha-tadvizeSa eveti itthaM cotpAdasya prAyogikavaizrasikabhedena dvividhatvAd dvitIye hetvanapekSAyAmapi prathame tadapekSAdhrauvyAnna pravRttyuccheda iti bhAvaH / etaccotpAdadvaividhyaM 2010_02 : "uppAo duviappo paogajaNio a vIsasA ca" [3/32] ityAdigranthena bhagavatA sammatikAreNApi bhaNitamiti nAsmatsampradAyapratikUleyaM kalpaneti bodhyam / evaM sati kAlAdihetupaJcakasAmagryAH kAryotpattimAtraniyatatvabhaGgenApasiddhAntabhIstu gauNamukhyabhAvena tadabhaGgad vAraNIyA, uktadvaividhyasya prayogavizrasAprAdhAnyenaiva vyavasthiteriti dig / [ visrasAjanyasyApyutpAdasya dvaividhyavarNanam ] visrasAjanito'pyutpAdo dvividha ityAha sAbhAvio va samudayakao vva egattio vva hojjAhi / AgAsAIANaM tinhaM parapaca o'NiyamA / / 33 / / svAbhAvikaSTA dvividha utpAdaH - ekaH samudayakRtaH prAkpratipAditAvayavArabdho ghaTAdivat /

Page #226
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA- 33 aparaSTIkatviko'nutpAditA'mUrtimaddravyAvayavArabdha AkAzAdivat / AkAzAdInAM ca dravyANAmavagAhakAdighaTAdiparadravyanimitto'vagAhanAdikriyotpAdo'niyamAd trayANAM anekAntAd bhavet, avagAhaka- gantR-sthAtRdravyasannidhAnato'mbara-dharmA'dharmeSvavagAhana-gatisthitikriyotpattinimittabhAvotpattirityabhiprAyaH / evaM mUrtimadamUrtimadavayavadravyadvayotpAdyA'vagAha-gati-sthitInAM yathoktaprakAreNa tatrotpatteH avagAha-gati-sthitisvabhAvasya ca viziSTakAryatvAd viziSTakAraNapUrvakatvasiddhestatkAraNe AkAzAdisaMjJAH samayanibandhanAH siddhAH / / 33 / / -: zAstravArttAsamuccaye :syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAM sta. 7, gA. 1 sa ca dvividhaH - samudayajanitaH aikatvikaSTA / tatra mUrtimaddravyAvayavArabdhaH samudayajanitaH itaraSTaukatvikaH / Adyo'bhrAdInAmutpAdaH ghaTAdInAmapyaprathamatayA viziSTanAzasya viziSTotpAdaniyatatvAt / na hi mUrtAvayavasaMyogakRtatvaM samudayajanitatvam, vibhAgakRtaparamANvAdyutpAde'vyApteH, kintu mUrtAvayavaniyatatvam / tacca tadavasthAvayavasyApyavasthAvizeSAt saMbhavIti / dvitIyastu gaganadharmA-'dharmAstikAyAnAmavagAhaka-gantR-sthAtRdravyasaMnidhAnato'vagAhana-gati-sthitikriyotpatteraniyamena syAtparapratyayaH, mUrtimadamUrtimadavayavadravyadvayotpAdyatvAd avagAhanAdInAM syAdaikatvikaH syAda-naikatvikaSToti bhAvaH / taduktam "sAbhAviovi samudayakau vva egattiu vva hojjAhi / AgAsAIANaM tihaM parapacao'NiyamA / / 3/33 / / " , -: 2010_02 dravyaguNaparyAyano rAsa : DhA. 8 gA. 20 saha46 thAI, te-vIsasA, samuhayaH kheDatva prakAra 2. samuhayaH ayetana aMdhano, vasI sathittaH bhIsa: niradhAra re 143. vina je-sahajaI-yatana vinA utpAda thAI, te vizvasAutpAda kahiIM. te viDaH uktaM ca 181 eka samudayajanita, bIjo

Page #227
182 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-34 "sAhAvio vi samudayakao vva egattio'ttha hojAhi" / / 3/33 / / samudayajanita vizvasAutpAda, teacetanaskaMdha abhrAdikano. tathA-sacittaH mizra zarIra: varNAdikano nirdhAra-jANavo. 153 Dhal.c, u.27 parapratyaya dharmAdikaNo, niyamaI bhASio utpAda re. nijapratyaya paNa teha ja kaho, jANI aMtaranayavAda re. 159. jina) dharmAstikAyAdikano utpAda, te niyamaI parapratyaya, svopaSTasmagatyAdipariNatajIva pudgalAnimittaja bhASio. ubhayajanita te-ekajanita paNi hoI, te mArTi-tehanaI nijapratyaya paNi kaho. aMta2nayA:-nizyaya: vyavahAra. 150na, meM artha. "AgAsAIANaM tihaM prpnyco'nniymaa|| 3/33 / / " e sammatigAthA madhye sAkAra prazleSaI bIjo artha vRttikAraI kahio chaI, te anusarInaI likhyo 77. 157. [ utpAdavad vigamasyApi dvaividhyavarNanam ] utpAdavad vigamo'pi tathAvidha evetyAha vigamassa vi esa vihI samudayajaNiyammi so u duviyappo / samudayavibhAgamettaM atyaMtarabhAvagamaNaM ca / / 34 / / vigamasyApyeSa eva dvirUpo bhedaH-svAbhAvikaH prayogajanitapToti tadvayAtiriktasya vastuno'bhAvAta pUrvAvasthAvigamavyatirekeNottarAvasthotpattyanupapatteH na hi bIjAdInAmavinAze'GkurAdikAryaprAdurbhAvo dRSTaH / na cA'vagAha-gati-sthityAdhAratvaM tadanAdhAratvasvabhAvaprAktanAvasthAdhvaMsamantareNa saMbhavati tatra samudayajanite yo vinAzaH sa ubhayatrApi dvividhaHekaH samudayavibhAgamAtraprakAro vinAzaH yathA paTAdeH kAryasya tatkAraNapRthakkaraNe tantuvibhAgamAtram, dvitIyaprakArastvarthAntarabhAvagamanaM vinAzo yathA mRtpiNDasya ghaTArthAntarabhAvanotpAdo vinAzaH / na cArthAntararUpavinAzavinAze mRtpiNDaprAdurbhAvaprasaktiriti vaktavyama, pUrvottara kAlAvasthayorasaMkIrNatvAt-atItataratvena prAktanAvasthAyA utpatteH atItasya ca vartamAnatA'yogAt-tayoH svasvabhAvAparityAgatastathAniyatatvAt tuccharUpasya hyabhAvasyA'bhAvaH syAdapi tadabhAvarUpaH, na tu vastvantarAdupajAyamAnaM vastvantaramatItarAvasthArUpaM bhavitumarhati 1. vA (syA. kalpa., dravya. rAsa) / 2010_02

Page #228
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-34 183 tara-tamapratyayArthavyavahArAbhAvaprasakteH / pratipAditaM ca kasyacid rUpasya nivRttyA rUpAntaragamanaM vastunaH prAgiti na punarabhidhIyate / / 34 / / -: zAstravArtAsamuccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAM sta.7, gA.1 ___ vyayo'pi svAbhAvikaH prayogajanitapToti dvividhaH / taddvayAtiriktasya vastuno'bhAvAt, pUrvAvasthAvigamavyatirekeNottarAvasthotpattyanupapatteH / na hi bIjAdInAmavinAze'GkurAdikAryaprAdurbhAvo dRSTaH / na cAvagAha-gati-sthityAdhAratvaM tadanAdhAratvasvabhAvaprAktanAvasthAdhvaMsamantareNa saMbhavatIti / tatra samudayajanita ubhayatrApi dvividhaH-samudayavibhAgarUpa ekaH, yathA paTAdeH kAryasya tantvAdikAraNapRthakkaraNam / anyaSTArthAntarabhAvagamanalakSaNaH, yathA mRtpiNDasya ghaTArthAntarabhAvaH / nAzatvaM cAsyAjanakatvasvabhAvA'parityAge janakatvA'yogAt / na caivaM ghaTavinAze mRtpiNDaprAdu rbhAvaprasaktiH, pUrvottarAvasthayoH svabhAvato'saMkIrNatvAt vastvantararUpe vastvantararUpasyApAdayitumazakyatvAt / aikatvikanAzaSTaukatvikotpAdavad vainasikabheda eveti / taduktam-- "vigamassa vi esa vihI samudayajaNiammi so u duviappo / samudayavibhAgamettaM atyaMtarabhAvagamaNaM vA / / " [3/34] / iti / -: dravyaguparyAyano rAsa : Dhal. 4, u. 27 aNunaI chaI yadyapi khaMdhatA. rUpAMtara aNu saMbaMdha re. saMyoga-vibhAgAdika thakI, to paNi e bheda prabaMdha re. 159. jina) yadyapi-aNunai aNusaMbaMdhai khaMdhatA chaI, te rUpAMtara pariNAma ja chache, to paNi saMyogavibhAgAdikarUpaI dravyavinAza-dvaividhyanuM ja, e upalakSaNa jANavuM. je mATaI-dravyotpAdavibhAgaI ja jima-paryAyotpAdavibhAga, tima-dravyanAzavibhAgaI ja paryAyanAza vibhAga hoI. te samudaya vibhAga anaI-arthAtaragamanaH e 2 prakAra ThaharAI. pahalo-saMtuparyata paTanAzaH bIjo ghaTotpatti mRtiMDAdinAzaH jANavo.159 uktaM ca sammatau "vigamassa vi esa vihI samudayajaNiammi so u duviappo / samudayavibhAgamittaM atyaMtarabhAvagamaNaM vA / / " 3/34 iti / 1. ca (saMmati.) / 2010_02

Page #229
184 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-35 [ utpAda-vinAza-dhrauvyANAM bhinnAbhinnakAlatvasyArthAntarAnarthAntaratvasya cAbhidhAnam ] na cotpAda-vinAzayoraikAntikatadrUpatA'bhyupagame anekAntavAdavyAghAtaH, kathaMcit tayostadrUpatA'bhyupagamAt, tadAha tiNNi vi uppAyAI abhiNNakAlA ya bhiNNakAlA ya / atyaMtaraM aNatthaMtaraM ca daviyAhi NAyavvA / / 35 / / trayo'pyutpAda-vigama-sthitisvabhAvAH parasparato'nyakAlAH yato na paTAderutpAdasamaya eva vinAzaH tasyAnutpattiprasakteH / nA'pi tadvinAzasamaye tasyaivotpattiH avinAzApatteH / na ca tatprAdurbhAvasamaya eva tatsthitiH tadrUpeNaivAvasthitasyAnavasthAprasaktitaH prAdurbhAvA'yogAt / na ca ghaTarUpamRtsthitikAle tasyA vinAzaH tadrUpeNAvasthitasya vinAzAnupapatteH / na ca ghaTavinAzaviziSTamRtkAle tasyA evotpAdo dRSTaH / nA'pi tadutpAdaviziSTamRtsamaye tasyA eva dhvaMso'nutpattiprasaGgata eva yuktaH / tatastrayANAmapi bhinnakAlatvAt tad dravyamarthAntaraM nAnAsvabhAvam na hyanyonyavyatiriktakAlotpAda-vigama-dhrauvyA'vyatiriktamekasvarUpaM dravyamupapadyate tasya tebhyo bhedaprasakteH / na ca tad bhinnamevAstu tattritayavikalasya tasya tathA'nupalabdhito'sattvAt / na caikasya dravyasyAbhAvAdanekAntAbhAvaprasaktiH yato'bhinnakAlASTotpAdAdayaH / nahi kuzUlavinAzaghaTotpAdayobhinnakAlatA; anyathA vinAzAt kAryotpattiH syAt ghaTAdhutaraparyAyAnutpattAvapi prAktanaparyAyadhvaMsaprasaktiSTA syAt / pUrvottaraparyAya-vinAzotpAdakriyAyA nirAdhArAyA ayogAt tadAdhArabhUtadravyasthitirapi tadA'bhyupagantavyA / na ca kriyAphalameva kriyAdhAraH tasya prAgasattvAt; sattve vA kriyAvaiphalyAt / tatastrayANAmabhinnakAlatvAt tadavyatiriktaM dravyamabhinnaM na nAnA / na ca ghaTotpAdavinAzApekSayA bhinnakAlatayA'rthAntaratvam kusUla-ghaTavinAzotpAdApekSayA abhinnakAlatvenAnarthAntaratvAdekAnta iti vaktavyam, dravyasya pUrvAvasthAyAM bhinnA'bhinnatayA pratIyamAnasyottarAvasthAyAmapi bhinnA'bhinnatayA tasyaiva pratIteranekAntA'vyAhateH / na cA'bAdhitA'dhyakSAdipratipattiviSayasya tasya virodhAdhudbhAvanaM yuktisaMgatam sarvapramANa-prameyavyavahAravilopaprasaGgAt / ata eva arthAntaramanantaraM cotpAdAdayo dravyAt, tadvA tebhyastatheti ___JainEducation International 2010_02

Page #230
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-35 185 pratijJeyam dravyAt tathAbhUtatadgrAhakatvapariNatAdAtmalakSaNAt pramANAdityapi vyAkhyeyam nahi tathAbhUtapramANapravRttistathAbhUtArthamantareNopapannA dhUma iva dhUmadhvajamantareNa, saMvedyate ca tathA bhUtagrAhya-grAhakarUpatayA anekAntAtmakaM svasaMvedanataH pramANamiti na tadapalApaH kartuM zakyaH; anyathA'tiprasaGgAt / yadvA dezAdiviprakRSTA utpatti-vinAza-sthitisvabhAvA bhinnAbhinnakAlA arthAntarAnAntararUpAH, dravyatvAt-dravyAvyatiriktatvAdityarthaH-anyathotpAdAdInAmabhAvaprasakteH / tebhyo vA dravyamarthAntarAnarthAntaram, dravyatvAt / pratijJArthaikadezatA ca heto zaGkanIyA dravyavizeSe sAdhye dravyasAmAnyasya hetutvenopanyAsAt / / 35 / / ___-: zAstravArtAsamuccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAM sta.1, gA.75 na tathAbhAvinaM hetumantareNopajAyate / kiJcinnazyati caikAntAd yathAha vyAsamaharSiH / / 75 / / tathAbhAvinaM-kAryarUpatayA bhavanazIlaM, hetuM vinA kamapi na jAyate, tatpariNAmakRtadravyAvasthAvizeSarUpatvAt tatpariNAmotpAdasya / na caikAntAd-dravyapRthagbhAvena kiJcid nazyati, tatpariNAmottaradravyAvasthArUpatvAt tadvinAzasya / na caivaM dravyameva syAt na tUtpAdavinAzau, kathaJcid bhinnatvasyApISTatvAt / tadidamuktaM sammatau tiNNi vi uppAyAI abhinnakAlA ya bhinnakAlA ya / atyaMtaraM aNatyaMtaraM ca daviyAhi NAyavvA / / 3/35 / / atraikapratiyoginirUpitatvena tadviziSTadravyanirUpitatvena votpAdasthitivigamAnAM bhinnakAlatA, yathA ghaTotpAdasamaye ghaTaviziSTamRdutpAdasamaye vA na tadvinAzaH, anutpattiprasakteH / nApi tadvinAzasamaye tadutpattiH, avinAzaprasakteH / na ca tatprAdurbhAvasamaya eva tatsthiti, tadrUpeNAvasthitasyAnavasthAprasaktyA prAdurbhAvA'yogAt / ato dravyAdarthAntarabhUtAste, anekarUpANAmekadravyarUpatvAyogAt / bhinnapratiyoginirUpitatvena tadviziSTadravyanirUpitatvena vA'bhinnakAlatA, yathA kuzUlatadviziSTamRnnAzaghaTatadviziSTamRdutpAdamRtsthitInAm / ata aikarUpyeNa dravyAdanAntarabhUtatvam, iti sampradAyaH / 2010_02

Page #231
186 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-36 -: nyAyakhaNDakhAdye (mahAvIrastave) : vibhAga-4, gA-3 evaM vyavahAranayAbhimate dIrgha grahotpattikAle'bhinnakAlAnAM tadutpattinAzasthitInAM pratyeka kAlatrayasparzivilakSaNayogena saptaviMzatirbhaGgAH, bhinnakAlAnAM ca kAlatrayayogena saptaviMzatestridhA guNane ekAzItibhaGgA utpadyante / na caite kalpanAmAtranirmitavapuSo, nipuNaM nirUpaNe prajJAvadbhiH sarveSAmevAkalanAt / tadidamuktaM sammatau mahAvAdinA "tiNNi vi uppAyAI abhiNNakAlA ya bhiNNakAlA ya / atyantaraM aNatthataraM ca daviyAu NAyavvA / / 3/35 / / " iti / itthaM vivecana eva hi vartamAnapAkakriyAkAle'pi kiJcitpakvaM kiJcit pacyate kiJcit pakSyate ityAdayo niyatavyavahArAH pravarttante, prasthakanyAyena bahubhedanaigamAzrayaNAt tataH pUrvamapi, na cAdyakRtiprAgabhAvaM caramakRtidhvaMsaM cAdAyAnAgatAtItatvavyavahAraikAntopapAdanaM zreyaH / / __[ uktasyArthasya pratyakSasiddhenodAharaNenopodvalanam ] atraivArthe pratyakSapratItamudAharaNamAha jo AuMcaNakAlo so ceva pasAriyassa vi Na jutto / tesiM puNa paDivattI-vigame kAlaMtaraM Natthi / / 36 / / ya AkuJcanakAlo'GgulyAdevyasya sa eva tatprasAraNasya na yukto bhinnakAlatayA AkuJcanaprasAraNayoH pratItestayorbhedaH, anyathA tayoH svarUpAbhAvApatterityuktam tattatparyAyAbhinnasyAGgulyAdidravyasyApi tathAvidhatvAt tadapi bhinnamabhyupagantavyam anyathA tadanupalambhAd abhinnaM ca tadavasthayostasyaiva pratyabhijJAyamAnatvAt / tayoH punarutpAda-vinAzayoH-pratipattiSTA prAdurbhAvaH, vigamaSTA vipattiH-pratipatti-vigamaM tatra kAlAntaraM bhinnakAlatvamaGgulidravyasya ca nAsti / pUrvaparyAyavinAzottaraparyAyotpattyaGgulidravyAvasthitInAmabhinnakAlatA abhinnarUpatA ca pratIyate ekasyaiva dravyasya tathAvivartAtmakasyAdhyakSataH pratIteH / / athavA 'kAlAntaraM nAsti' ityatra 'a'kAraprazleSAd naJapTopAdAnAt pratiSedhadvayena prakRtArthagateH kAlAntaraM kAlabheda utpAdAdevyasya cAstIti kathaMcid bheda ityarthaH-kathaMcid 2010_02

Page #232
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-37 187 bhedenA'pi pratipatteH / tenotpatti-vinAza-sthitInAM paraspararUpaparityAgA'parityAgapravRtta- . pratyekatryAtmakaikarUpatve'pi na vartamAnaparyAyAtmakasyaivA'tItA'nAgatakAlayoH sattvam vastunastryAtmakatvAbhyupagamAt / atItA'nAgatakAlayorapi tadrUpeNa sattve utpAdavinAzayorabhAvena kathaM tryAtmakatvaM tasya bhavet dravyasyotpatti-vinAzanimittatvAdatItAditAyAH anyathA vartamAnavat tadabhAvAt ? na ca tatparyAyasyA'tItA'nAgatakAlayorabhAve kathaM nityatvamiti vAcyam, kathaMcit tasyAbhyupagamAt parityaktopAditsyamAnapUrvottaraparyAyasyAnyAnyaveSaparityAgopAdAnaikanaTapuruSavad dravyasya vivartAtmakatvAt / sarvathA nityatve pUrvottaravyapadezAbhAvaprasakteH / sarvathA'nityatve'pyubhayatraikapratibhAsavyapadezAdivyavahArAbhAvaSTA syAt / na caikAnekatvapratibhAso mithyA / tato yadeva vinaSTaM zibakarUpatayA tadevotpannaM mRdravyaM ghaTAdirUpatayA avasthitaM ca mRttveneti tryAtmakaM tat sarvadA dravyamiti vyavasthitam / / 36 / / [ utpAdAditrayaM pratyekaM tryAtmakavat traikAlikamapyasti iti vadata eva yathArthavaktRtvAbhidhAnam ] yathotpAda-vyaya-sthitInAM pratyekamekaikaM rUpaM tryAtmakaM tathA bhUta-vartamAna-bhaviSyadbhirapyekaikaM rUpaM trikAlatAmAsAdayatItyetadevAha uppajjamANakAlaM uppaNNaM ti vigayaM vigacchaMtaM / daviyaM paNNavayaMto tikAlavisayaM visesei / / 37 / / utpadyamAnasamaye eva kiJcit paTadravyaM tAvadutpannam-yadyekatantupravezakriyAsamaye tad dravyaM tena rUpeNa notpannaM tarjuttaratrApi tannotpannamityatyantAnutpattiprasaktistasya syAt / na cotpannAMzena tenaiva punastadutpadyate tAvanmAtrapaTAdidravyotpattiprasakteruttarottarakriyAkSaNasya tAvanmAtraphalotpAdane eva prakSayAd aparasya phalAntarasyA'nutpattiprasakteH / yadi ca vidyamAnA ekatantupravezakriyA na phalotpAdikA, vinaSTA sutarAM na bhavet asattvAt anutpattyavasthAvat na hyanutpannavinaSTayorasattve kaSTiAda vizeSaH / tataH prathamakriyAkSaNaH kenacida rUpeNa dravyamutpAdayati, dvitIyastvasau tadeva aMzAntareNotpAdayati anyathA kiyAkSaNAntarasya vaiphalyaprasakteH / ekenAMzenotpannaM sad uttarakriyAkSaNAlAMzena yadyapUrvamapUrvaM tad utpadyeta tadotpannaM bhaved ___ 2010_02

Page #233
188 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-37 nAnyatheti prathamatantupravezAdArabhyAntyatantusaMyogAvadhiM yAvad utpadyamAnaM prabandhena tadrUpatayotpannam, abhipretaniSThArUpatayA cotpatsyata ityutpadyamAnam utpannamutpatsyamAnaM ca bhavati, evamutpannamapi utpadyamAnamutpatsyamAnaM ca bhavati, tathotpatsyamAnamapi utpadyamAnamutpannaM cetyekaikamutpannAdikAlatrayeNa yathA traikAlyaM pratipadyate tathA vigacchadAdikAlatrayeNApyutpAdAdirekastraikAlyaM pratipadyate / tathAhi-yathA yad yadaivotpadyate tat tadaivotpannam utpatsyate ca / yad yadaivotpannaM tat tadaiva utpadyate utpatsyate ca / yad yadaivotpatsyate tat tadaivotpadyate utpannaM ca / tathA, tadeva tadaiva yadutpadyate tat tadaiva vigataM vigacchad vigamiSyaJca / tathA, yadeva yadaivotpannaM tadeva tadaiva vigataM vigacchad vigamiSyaJca / tathA, yadeva yadaivotpatsyate tadeva tadaiva vigataM vigacchad vigamiSyaJca / evaM vigamo'pi trikAla utpAdAdinA darzanIyaH, tathA sthityA'pi trikAla eva saprapaJcaH pradarzanIyaH / evaM sthitirapi utpAda-vinAzAbhyAM saprapaJcAbhyAmekaikAbhyAM trikAlA pradarzanIyeti dravyamanyonyAtmakatathAbhUtakAlatrayAtmakotpAda-vinAza-sthityAtmakaM prajJApayaMstrikAlaviSayaprAdurbhavaddharmAdhAratayA tad vizinaSTi / anena prakAreNa trikAlaviSayaM dravyarUpaM pratipAditaM bhavati; anyathA dravyasyAbhAvAt tadvacanasya mithyAtvaprasaktiriti bhAvaH / / 37 / / -: vyAkhyAprajJaptau :pU.A. abhayadevasUrikRtaTIkAyAm, za. 1, u. 1, sU. 8 etatsUtrasaMvAdisiddhasenAcAryo'pyAha "uppajjamANakAlaM uppaNNaM ti vigayaM vigacchaMtaM / daviyaM paNNavayaMto tikAlavisayaM visesei / / 1 / / " iti, 'utpadyamAnakAla'mityanenAdyasamayAdArabhyotpattyantasamayaM yAvadutpadyamAnatvasyeSTatvAdvarttamAnabhaviSyatkAlaviSayaM dravyamuktam, utpannamityanena tvatItakAlaviSayam, evaM vigataM vigacchadityanenApIti, tatapTotpadyamAnAdi prajJApayan sa bhagavAn dravyaM vizeSayati, katham ?, trikAlaviSayaM yathA bhavatIti saMvAdagAthArthaH / 2010_02

Page #234
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-37 189 -: nayopadeze : gA. 32 "kajjamANe kaDe" [ ] tti bhagavadvacanaM tUtpAdAdInAmekadharmisaMsargitayA traikAlyaviSayatvena pramANArthakatayA vyAkhyeyam, tathAhi-AdyatantupravezakriyAsamaye paTaTravyaM yadi tena rUpeNa notpannaM tardRttaratrApi notpannamityantA(nte'pya)nutpannaM syAt, utpannAMzenaiva cotpattau phalAntarAbhAvaprasaGgaH, ityAdita eva prabandhenotpadyamAnaM tadrUpatayotpannamabhipretarUpatayA cotpatsyate, evamutpannamapyutpadyamAnamutpatsyamAnaM ca, tathotpatsyamAnamapyutpadyamAnamutpannaM ca, ityekaikaM traikAlyaM pratipadyate, evaM vigacchadAdikAlatrayeNApyutpadyamAnAdirekaikatraikAlyaM pratipadyate, yadaivotpadyamAnaM tadaiva vigataM vigacchad vigamiSyaJcetyAdirItyA, (evaM vigamo'pi trikAla utpAdAdinA darzanIyaH sammativRttitaH), evaM sthityA'pi trikAla eva saprapaJcakam, evaM sthitirapyutpAda-vinAzAbhyAM saprapaJcAbhyAM trikAlasparzinI pradarzanIyeti sarvairebhiH dharmaiH trikAlasparzibhiravinAbhUtaM dravyaM pratipAdayad vAkyaM pramANameveti, tadidamAha sammatikAraH "uppajjamANakAlaM uppannaM ti vigayaM vigacchaMtaM / daviyaM paNNavayaMto tikAlavisayaM visesei" / / 3/37 / / --: dravyaguparyAyano zaza: a. c, ou. jo tujha utpatti viziSTano, vyavahAra nAzano ISTa re. to vyavahAri utpatti Adaro, je pahilAM achati viziSTa re. 145. jina) jo-utpattidhArArUpa nAzanaI viSaI bhUtAdikapratyaya na kahi , anaiM- dhAtuno artha nAzaH nai utpattiH sa 2 24, tadutpattiAtrayano manvaya saMbhavato . mahatai-nazyatsamaya "naSTaH" me prayoga na hoI; je mArTi-te kAlaI nAzotpattinuM atItatva nathI. Ima samarthana nAzavyavahAranuM jo karo cho, to vyavahArai-utpattikSaNa-saMbaMdhamAtra kaho.tihA-prAgabhAvadhvaMsanA kAlatrayathI kAlatrayano anvaya samarthana karo. anaiM-jo ima vicArasyo-"ghaTanaiM vartamAnatvAdikai jima paTavartamAnatvAdi vyavahAra na hoi, ghaTadharma vartamAnatvAdikaI ghaTavartamAnatvAdi vyavahAra na hoI, tima-nAzotpatti vartamAnatAdikaiM nAzavartamAnatAdivyavahAra na hoi. to-kriyAniSThApariNAmarUpavartamAnatvaH ___ Jain Education-international 2010_02

Page #235
190 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-38 - satAtatva: -"nazyati, naSTa: utpadyate, utpannaH" meM vista-vyava32samarthana 421. ata eva yAva-niSThAva-yogapaviqals "utpadyamAnamutpannam, vigacchad vigatam" me saiddhAnti prayoga saMbhava. 52mata--"idAnIM dhvasto ghaTaH" meM, mAghakSa vyavahA2 sarvathA na gha20. mahamA24nayame saMbhava. atra sammatiH uppajjamANakAlaM, uppaNNaM ti vigayaM vigacchaMtaM / daviyaM paNNavayaMto, tikAlavisayaM visesei / / 3/37 / / [ vibhAgajanyamutpAdamanicchatAM keSAMcid utpAdArthAnabhijJatvakhyApanam ] nanvantaragamanalakSaNasya vinAzasyAsaMbhavAt vibhAgajasya cotpAdasya; tadvayAbhAve sthiterapyabhAvAt tat traikAlyaM dUrotsAritameveti manyamAnAn vAdinaH prati tadabhyupagamapradarzanapUrvakamAha davvaMtarasaMjogAhi keci daviyassa beMti uppAyaM / uppAyatthA'kusalA vibhAgajAyaM Na icchaMti / / 38 / / samAnajAtIyadravyAntarAdeva samavAyikAraNAt tatsaMyogAsamavAyikAraNa-nimittakAraNAdisavyapekSAd avayavi kAryadravyaM bhinnaM kAraNadravyebhya utpadyata iti dravyasyotpAdaM kecana bruvate / te cotpAdArthAnabhijJA vibhAgajAtaM necchanti / / 38 / / -: zAstravArtAsamuccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAM sta.1, gA.75 nanvevaM 'paramANurnityaH' iti vyavahAro'pi bhrAntaH syAt, paramANoH paramANubhAvena nAzasyApyabhyupagamAt, ata evAvayava-vibhAgottaraM tathotpAdapratipAdanAt, taduktam- [sammatau] davvaMtarasaMjogAhi keI daviyasya benti uppAyaM / uppAyatthA'kusalA vibhAgajAyaM Na icchaMti / / 3/38 / / aNu-duaNuehiM dabve Araddhe tiaNuaM ti vavaeso / tatto a puNa vibhatto aNutti jAo aNU hoi / / 3/39 / / iti / 2010_02

Page #236
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-39 191 yuktaM caitat, prAk paramANutAsattve sthUlakAryAbhAvaprasaGgAd iti cet ? na, vyAvahArikanityatAlakSaNe samudayavibhAgarUpasyaiva vyayasya pravezyatvAditi / -: dravyaguerAparyAyano rAsa : DhA. 4, 5. 21 saMyoga vinA ekatvano, te dravyavibhAgaI siddha re. jima-baMdha vibhAgaI aNupaNuM, valI karma vibhAgaI siddha re. 154. jina) saMyogavinA je vizrasAutpAda: te ekatvika jANavo. te dravyavibhAgaI siddha kahatAM utpanna jANavo. jima DhipradezAdika-skaMdha-vibhAgaI aNuMpaNuM kahetA-paramANu dravyano utpAda, tathA-karma- vibhAgai siddhaparyAyano utpAda "avayavasaMyogaI ja dravyanI utpatti hoI, paNi-vibhAgai na hoI." ehavuM je-naiyAyikAdika kahe chaI tehanaI ekatvatAdi vibhAgai khaMDapaTotpati kima ghaTache ? pratibaMdhakAbhAvasahita avasthitAvayavasaMyoganaI hetutA kalpatAM mahAgaurava hoI, te mATi-kihAMIka saMyogaH kihAMIka vibhAgaH dravyotpAdaka mAnavo. tivArai-vibhAgaja paramANutpAda paNi arthasiddha thayo. e satimardi sUciuM 77. taduktam- [sammatau] davvaMtarasaMjogAhi keI daviyasya biMti uppAyaM / uppAyatthA'kusalA vibhAgajAyaM Na icchaMti / / 3/38 / / / aNu-duaNuehi davve Araddhe "tiaNuaM" ti vavaeso / tatto a puNa vibhatto "aNu" tti jAo aNU hoi / / 3/39 / / [prativAdisaMmatotpAdaprakriyAkathanapUrvakaM siddhAntasamatasya vibhAgajanyotpAdasya samarthanam] kutaH punarvibhAgajotpAdAnabhyupagamavAdina utpAdArthAnabhijJAH ? yataH aNu duaNuehiM dabve Araddhe 'tiaNuyaM' ti vavaeso / tatto ya puNa vibhatto aNu tti jAo aNU hoi / / 39 / / dvAbhyAM paramANubhyAM kAryadravye Arabdhe aNuH' iti vyapadezaH paramANudvayArabdhasya vyaNukasyANuparimANatvAt / tribhi_NukaipTAturbhirvA''rabdhe tryaNukam' iti vyapadezaH; anyathotpattAvupalabdhinimittasya mahattvasyAbhAvaprasakteH / 2010_02

Page #237
192 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-39-40 yadi ca paramANavaH svarUpAparityAgataH kAryadravyamArabhante svAtmano'vyatiriktaM tadA kAryadravyAnutpattiprasaktiH / na hi kAryadravye paramANusvarUpAparityAge sthUlatvasya sadbhAvastasya tadabhAvAtmakatvAt / tasmAt paramANurUpatAparityAgena mRdravyaM sthUlakAryasvarUpamAsAdayatIti tadrUpatAparityAgena ca punarapi paramANurUpatAmanubhavatIti valayavat pudgaladravyapariNaterAdiranto vA na vidyate iti na kAryadravyaM kAraNebhyo bhinnam / na cArthAntarabhAvagamanaM vinAzo'yukta iti tadrUpaparityAgopAdAnAtmakasthitisvabhAvasya dravyasya traikAlyaM nAnupapannam / yathA ca ekasaMkhyAsaMyoga-mahattvA'paratvAdiparyAyaiH paramANUnAmutpatteH kAryarUpAH paramANavastathA bahutvasaMkhyAvibhAgA'lpaparimANa-paratvAtmakatvena prAdurbhAvAt paramANavaH kAryadravyavat tathotpannApTAAbhyupagantavyAH, kAraNAnvayavyatirekAnuvidhAnopalambhasya kAryatAvyavasthAnibandhanasyAtrApi sadbhAvAditi ayamarthaH 'tatto ya' ityAdinA gAthApapTArdhena pradarzitaH / tasmAd ekaparimANAd dravyAd vibhaktaH vibhAgAtmakatvenotpannaH aNuriti aNurjAto bhavati etadavasthAyAH prAk tadasattvAt; sattve vA idAnImiva prAgapi sthUlarUpakAryAbhAvaprasaGgAt idAnIM vA tadrUpatA tadrUpAvizeSAt prAktanAvasthAyAmiva syAt / evaM caturvidhakAryadravyAbhyupagamo'saMgataH / / 39 / / [ prativAdimatamAkSipya pratibandItayA sveSTasya vibhAgajanyotpAdasya samarthanam ] prastutamevAkSepadvAreNopasaMharatyAcAryaH-- bahuyANa egasadde jai saMjogAhi hoi uppAo / NaNu egavibhAgammi vi jujjai bahuyANa uppAo / / 40 / / dvyaNukAdInAM sati saMyoge yadyekasya tryaNukAdeH kAryadravyasyotpAdo bhavati-anyathaikAbhidhAnapratyayavyavahArAyogAt nahi bahuSu 'eko ghaTa utpannaH' ityAdivyavahAro yuktaH-'nanu' ityakSamAyAm / ekasya kAryadravyasya vinAze'pi yujyata eva bahUnAM samAnajAtIyAnAM tatkAryadravyavinAzAtmakAnAM prabhUtatayA vibhaktAtmanAmutpAda iti / tathAhi-ghaTavinAzAd bahUni kapAlAni utpannAnItyanekAbhidhAnapratyayavyavahAro yuktaH; anyathA tadasaMbhavAt / tataH pratyekaM tryAtmakAstrikAlApTotpAdAdayo vyavasthitA ityanantaparyAyAtmakamekaM dravyam / / 40 / / 2010_02

Page #238
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-41 193 -: zAstravArtAsamuccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAM sta.7, gA. 13 evaM ca 'pRthivyAdayaSTAtvAraH paramANurUpA nityA eva, kAryarUpAstvanityAH' iti teSAM prakriyApi nirastA, paramANUnAmapi kAryAbhinnatayA'rthAntarabhAvagamanarUpasya nAzasya, vibhAgajAtasya cotpAdasya samarthanAt / yathA hi bahUnAmekazabdavyapadezanidAnaM samudayajanita utpAdaH, tathaikasya bahuzabdavyapadezanidAnaM vibhAgajAto'pi sa kiM nAbhyupeyaH ? / vyavaharanti hi bhagne ghaTe 'bahUni kapAlAnyutpannAni' iti / evaM paramANUnAmapyekanAze yukto bahutvenotpAdaH / tadAhuH- [sammatau] bahuANa egasadde jaha saMjogAhi hoi uppAo / naNu egavibhAgammi vi jujai bahuANa uppAo / / [3/40] iti / [ekasminnapi samaye pratyekaM dravyamanantaparyAyAtmakaM prAguktarItyA sidhyati ityabhidhAnam] nanvanante kAle bhavatvanantaparyAyAtmakamekaM dravyam, ekasamaye tu kathaM tat tadAtmakamavasIyate ? pradarzitadizA tadAtmakaM tadavasIyata ityAha egasamayammi egadaviyassa bahuyA vi hoMti uppAyA / uppAyasamA vigamA ThiI u ussaggao NiyamA / / 41 / / ekasmin samaye ekadravyasya bahava utpAdA bhavanti, utpAdasamAnasaMkhyA vigamA api tasyaiva tadaivotpadyante vinAzamantareNotpAdasyAsaMbhavAt nahi pUrvaparyAyAvinAze uttaraparyAyaH prAdurbhavitumarhati; prAdurbhAve vA sarvasya sarvakAryatAprasaktiH, tadakAryatvaM vA kAryAntarasyeva syAt / sthitirapi sAmAnyarUpatayA tathaiva niyatA sthitirahitasyotpAdasyAbhAvAt bhAve vA zazazRGgAderapyutpattiprasaGgAt / / 41 / / - dravyaguerAparyAyano rAsa : al., u. 18 nijaparaparyAyaI ekadA, bahu saMbaMdhaI bahu rU5 re. utpatti nAzaH Ima saMbhavaI, niyamaI tihAM dhovya svarUpa re. 151 jina) 2010_02

Page #239
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 3, gAthA-42 hama-niSThaparyAya - vaH puchgala nahaM, tathA-paraparyAyAM-khADAzaH dharmAstiDAyaH adharmAstiDAyaH khe traNa dravyanaiM, ekakAlaI ghaNaI saMbaMdhaIM bahuprakAra-utpattiH nAzaH saMbhavaIM jeTalA-svaH 52H paryAya, teTalA-utpattiH nAzaH hoI. tevatI- tihAM- dhrauvyasva3pa telAM niradhAra cha. puurvaaprpryaayaanugtAdhArAMza tAvanmAtra hoI, te vatI. atra sammatigAthA 194 egasamayammi egadaviyassa bahuA vi hoMti uppAyA / uppAyasamA vigamA, ThiI u ussaggao NiyamA / / 3 / 41 / / [ ekasmin dravye ekasamaye'nantadharmAtmakatvasya dRSTAntena sAdhanam ] etadeva dRSTAntadvAreNa samarthayannAha kAya-maNa-vayaNa - kiriyA - ruvAi gaIvisesao vAva / saMjoyabheyao jANaNA ya daviyassa uppAo / / 42 / / yadaivAnantAnantapradezikAhArAbhAvapariNatapudgalopayogopajAtarasa-rudhirAdipariNata vazAvirbhUtaziro'GgulyAdyaGgopAGgabhAvapariNatasthUrasUkSmasUkSmatarAdibhedabhinnAvayavAtmakasya kAyasyotpattistadaivAnantAnantaparamANupacitamanovargaNApariNatipratilabhyamanautpAdo'pi tadaiva vacanasyApi kAyotkRSTataravargaNotpattipratilabdhavRttirutpAdaH, tadaiva ca kAyA''tmanoranyonyAnupravezAd viSamIkRtA'saMkhyAtAtmapradeze kAyakriyotpattiH, tadaiva ca rUpAdInAmapi pratikSaNotpattivinazvarANAmutpattiH, tadaiva ca mithyAtvA'virati -pramAda- kaSAyAdipariNatisamutpAditakarmabandhanimittA''gAmigativizeSANAmapyutpattiH, tadaiva cotsRjyamAnopAdIyamAnAnantAnantaparamANvApAditatatpramANasaMyoga-vibhAgAnAmutpattiH / yadvA yadaiva zarIrAderdravyasyotpattistadaiva trailokyAntargatasamastadravyaiH saha sAkSAt pAraMparyeNa vA saMbandhAnAmutpattiH sarvadravyavyAptivyavasthitAkAza-dharmAdharmAdidravyasaMbandhAt, tadaiva ca bhAvisvaparyAya-parajJAnaviSayatvAdInAM cotpAdanazaktinAmapyutpAdaH ziro-grIvA-caJcu-netrapicchodara-caraNAdyanekAvayavAntarbhAvakamayUrANDakarasazaktInAmiva; anyathA tatra teSAmuttarakAlamapyanutpattiprasaGgAt / utpAda-vinAza-sthityAtmakASTA pratikSaNaM bhAvAH zItoSNasaMparkA 2010_02

Page #240
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-42-43 195 divazAdavAntarasUkSmatara-tamAdibhedena tathaiva sva-parApekSayA yugapata krameNa copalabdheH / na ca taratamAdibhedena nava-purANatayA krameNopalabdhiH pratikSaNaM tathotpattimantareNa saMbhavati / na cAsmadAdyadhyakSaM niravazeSadharmAtmakavastugrAhakaM yenAnantadharmANAmekadA vastunyapratipatterabhAva ityucyeta anumAnataH pratikSaNamanantadharmAtmakasya tasya pradarzitanyAyena pratipatteH / sakalatrailokyavyAvRttasya ca vastuno'dhyakSeNa grahaNe-tadvyAvRttInAM paramArthikataddharmarUpatayA anyathA tasya tadvyAvRttatA'yogAt-kathaM nAnantadharmANAM vastunyadhyakSeNa grahaNam ? ||42 / / [ Agamasya hetuvAdAhetuvAdAbhyAM dvaividhyena vibhajanam ] idAnIM viditanayatvAd viziSTaprajJaH ziSyo vigRhya kathanayogyaH saMpanna iti tasya vigrahakathanopadezamAhaduviho ityAdi / athavA pratyakSa-parokSarUpaH saMkSepato dvividha upayoga AtmanaH / tatra pratyakSopayogastrividhaH avadhi-manaHparyAya-kevalabhedena / tatra kevalopayogaH sakalaviSayaH prAka pratipAditaH / avadhimanaHparyAyopayogastvasakalaviSayo'smadAdibhirAgamagamyaH / parokSopayogastu mati-zrutarUpo dvividhaH / tatrAkSa-liGgaprabhavamatyupayogasya svarUpamAveditam / zrutopayogasya tvAcAryastaddhetubhUtahetvahetuvAdabhedabhinnAgamapratipAdanadvAreNa svarUpamAha duviho dhammAvAo aheuvAo ya heuvAo ya / tattha u aheuvAo bhaviyA'bhaviyAdao bhAvA / / 43 / / vastudharmANAmastitvAdInAmAsamantAd vAdastatpratipAdaka AgamaH ahetu-hetuvAdabhedena dvaividhyaM pratipadyate / pramANAntarAnavagatavastupratipAdaka AMgamo'hetuvAdaH / tadviparItastvasau hetuvAdaH-hinoti gamayatyarthamiti hetustatparicchinno'rtho'pi hetuH, taM vadati ya Agama; sa hetuvAdaH / yastu vastusvarUpapratipAdakatve'pi tadviparIto'sAvahetuvAdo dRSTivAdAt prAyeNAnyaH / tatra tvahetuvAdo bhavyAbhavyasvarUpapratipAdaka AgamaH tadvibhAgapratipAdane'dhyakSAdeH pramANAntarasyApravRtteH-nahi 'ayaM bhavyaH, ayaM tvabhavyaH' ityatrAgamamantareNa pramANAntarapravRttisaMbhavo'smadAdyapekSayA / / 2010_02

Page #241
196 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-43 nanu 'tadvibhAgapratipAdakaM vaco yathArtham arhadvavacanatvAt anekAntAtmakavastupratipAdakavacovat' ityanumAnAt tadvibhAgapratipattau kathaM na tasyAnumAnaviSayatA ? na; evamapyAgamAdeva tadvibhAgapratipatteH-tadvyatirekeNa pramANAntarasya tatpratipattinibandhanasyAbhAvAt / arhadAgamasya ca pradhAnArthasaMvAdanibandhanatpraNItatvaniSTAye'numAnato'tIndriyArthaviSaye prAmANyaM niSTIyata ityabhyupagamyata eva / AgamanirapekSasya tu pramANAntarasyAsmadAdestatra pravRttirna vidyata ityetAvatA'hetuvAdatvametadviSayAgamasyocyata iti / / 43 / / ___-: aSTasahaskhItAtparyavivaraNe : pari. 6, kA. 77-78 syAt sarvaM hetutaH siddhamityAdi, nanu kathametat kAtsyena hetusiddhatvAdyabhidhAnaM ghaTate ? hetusiddhAgamasiddhAnAmarthAnAmavAntaravibhAgenaiva vyavasthitatvAt, tadAha sammatikAraH duviho dhammAvAo aheuvAo a heuvAo a / tattha u aheuvAo bhaviyAbhaviAdao bhAvA / / 3/43 / / asyA arthaH-dharmANAmastitvAdInAmAsamantAdvAdastatpratipAdaka Agamo'hetuvAdo hetuvAdaSToti dvidhA, tatra pramANAntarAnavagatArthapratipAdaka Agamo'hetuvAdaH, tadviparIto hetuvAdo / hetorhetuparicchinnasya vAdo hetuvAda iti vyutpatteH / tatra tvahetuvAdo bhavyAbhavyatvAdayo bhAvAH, viSayAdhyavasAnena viSayyabhidhAnametat bhavyAbhavyatvAdipratipAdaka Agama ityarthaH / na hyayaM bhavyo'bhavyo vetyatrAsmadAdInAM pramANaM pravarttate, na ca tadvibhAgapratipAdakaM vacanaM yathArtham arhadvacanatvAdityanumAnapravRttervyAghAtaH, vacanavibhAgAvacchedakatvena tatpravRttAvapi svAtantryeNa tadapravRtteH, tathA ca bhavyAbhavyatvAdayo'hetuvAdasiddhAH, anye ca hetuvAdasiddhA iti vyAptyA prakRtasaptabhaGgI na yukteti cet, maivam, syAcchabdamaryAdayaiva sarvAnupapattinirAsAt, ahetuvAdasiddhasyApyarthasya tattaddharmiNi tatpratipAditaliGgena hetuvAdatvavyavasthiteH, taduktaM sammatAveva bhavio sammaiMsaNa-nANa-carittapaDivattisaMpunno / NiyamA dukkhaMtakaDo tti lakkhaNaM heuvAyassa / / 3/44 / / prayogaTAyama-bhavyo'yaM samyagdarzanajJAnacAritrapratipattisampUrNatvAta sampratipannapuruSavaditi, kiM bahunA ? ahetuvAdasiddhe'pyarthe tato'nekAntAtmakatvasAdhikA nirAkAGkSatAtparyArthapratipattiparyantApTA 2010_02

Page #242
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-44 197 yA upapattayastA hetuvAdasiddhatvamupapAdayanti, zrutamAtreNa jJAtasyAjJAtaprAyatvAt, tApTAopapattayaH zrutopayogAnanyatvAnna zrutatvavyAhantrya ityAdhupapAditaM jJAnabindau asmAbhiH / ata eva padArthapratipattyAgamAt niSTiAtamapyarthaM sisAdhayiSAdhInapakSatayA'numinvate'numAnarasikAH, mananasAdhyazraddhAvizeSasyetthamevopapatteH, ata eva niyamataH SaTkAyazraddhAne'pi jinavanacarucimattvAd dravyataH samyagdRSTitvam, na tu bhAvato, bhAvasamyagdarzanasya sakalanayaviSayavivecanasAdhyatvAdekavidhadvividhAdiparyAyAparicchede tadanupapatteriti vadanti / -: zAstravArtAsamuccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAM sta.2, gA.25 sarvatra darzanaM yasya tadvAkyAt kiM na sAdhanam ? sAdhanaM tad bhavatyevamAgamAttu na bhidyate / / 25 / / atha yasya sarvatra-sarvakSetreSu, darzanaM duHkhabAhulyajJAnam, tadvAkyAd duHkhabAhulyaM jJAtvA sAdhanam-uktaprasaGgasAdhanam, kiM na bhaveda, ApAdyavyatireke niSTAyasAmrAjyAd ?, iti cet, tat sAdhanaM bhavatyeva, tu-punaH, evam-uktaprakAreNa, AgamAd na bhidyate, zrutAnusArimateH zrutAntarbhUtatvAt / ata eva bhavyAbhavyAdibhAvAnAM pUrvam "tattha ya aheuvAo bhaviyA'bhaviyAdao bhAvA" iti gAthApratIkenA'hetuvAdaviSayatvamuktvApi "bhavio sammaiMsaNa-nANa caritta-paDivattisampaNNo / __NiyamA dukkhaMtakaDo tti lakkhaNaM heuvAyassa / / 3/44 / / " iti gAthAnantaramAgamopagRhItahetupravRttyA hetuvAdaviSayatvamuktaM bhagavatA sammatikRtA, ityavadheyam / / 25 / / [Agamoktasya vastuno hetudvArA vAstavikatvasAdhanameva hetuvAdasya lakSaNamiti sUcanam] vacanavyApAra kevalamapekSyAyaM kramaH / yadA tu jJAna-darzana-cAritratritaye yathAvadanuSThAnapravaNaH tadvikalapTA puruSaH pratIyate tadA anumAnagamyo'pi tadvibhAgo bhavati, yathA-bhavyaH abhavyo vA'yaM puruSaH, samyagjJAnAdiparipUrNA'paripUrNatvAbhyAm, lokaprasiddhabhavyA'bhavyapuruSavat / ahetu 2010_02

Page #243
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 3, gAthA- 44-45 vAdAgamAvagate vA dharmiNi bhavyA'bhavyasvarUpe tadvi ( tadavi) parItanirNayaphalo hetuvAda: pravartate / yo'yamAgame bhavyAdirabhihitaH sa tathaiva yathoktahetusadbhAvAt ityAha , 198 bhavio sammaddaMsaNa - NANa- carittapaDivattisaMpanno / NiyamA dukkhaMtakaDo tti lakkhaNaM heDavAyassa / / 44 / / bhavyo'yam, samyagdarzana- jJAna-cAritrapratipattisaMpUrNatvAt uktapuruSavat / tatparipUrNatvAdeva niyamAt saMsAraduHkhAntaM kariSyati karmavyAdherAtyantikaM vinAzamanubhaviSyati, tannibandhanamithyAtvAdipratipakSAbhyAsasAtmIbhAvAt, vyAdhinidAnapratikUlAcaraNapravRttatathAvidhAturavat / yaH punarna tatpratipakSAbhyAsasAtmyavAn nAsau duHkhAntakRd bhaviSyati tannidAnAnuSThAnapravRttatathAvidhAturavat iti hetuvAdasya lakSaNam / hetuvAdaSTA prAyo dRSTivAdastasya dravyAnuyogatvAt, "samyagdarzana - jJAna - cAritrANi mokSamArgaH" [ tattvArthasU0 1-1] ityAderanumAnAdigamyasyArthasya tatra pratipAdanAt / yathA cAtrAnumAnAdigamyatA tathA gandhahastiprabhRtibhirvikrAntamiti neha pradarzyate granthavistarabhayAt / / 44 / / [ jIvAditattvaM kathaM pratipAdayan siddhAntasya ArAdhakaH kathaM vA pratipAdayan tasya virAdhaka ityabhidhAnam ] "jIvA'jIvA''zrava-bandha-saMvara- nirjarA-mokSAstattvam" [tattvArthasU0 1-4] ityubhayavAdAgamapratipAdyAn bhAvAMstathaivA'saMkIrNarUpAn pratipAdayan saiddhAntikaH puruSaH itarastu tadvirAdhaka ityAha jo heuvAyapakkhammi heuo Agame ya Agamio / so sasamayapaNNavao siddhaMtavirAhao anno / / 45 / / yo hetuvAdAgamaviSayamarthaM hetuvAdAgamena, tadviparItAgamaviSayaM cArthamAgamamAtreNa pradarzayati vaktA sa svasiddhAntasya dvAdazAGgasya pratipAdanakuzalaH, anyathA pratipAdayaMSTA tadarthasya pratipAdayitumazakyatvAt tatpratipAdake vacasyanAsthAdidoSamutpAdayan-siddhAntavirAdhako bhavati sarvajJapraNItAgamasya nissAratApradarzanAt tatpratyanIko bhavatIti yAvat / 2010_02

Page #244
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-45 tathAhi-pRthivyAdermanuSyaparyantasya SaDvidhajIvanikAyasya jIvatvamAgamena anumAnAdinA ca / pramANena siddhaM tathaiva pratipAdayan svasamayaprajJApakaH, anyathA tadvirAdhakaH / yataH pravyaktacetane trasanikAye caitanyalakSaNaM jIvatvaM svasaMvedanAdhyakSataH svAtmani pratIyate, paratra tvapareNAnumAnataH / vanaspatiparyanteSu pRthivyAdiSu sthAvareSu anumAnatapTautanyapratipattiH / tathAhivanaspatayaSTotanAH, vRkSAyurvedAbhihitapratiniyatakAlAyuSkaviziSTauSadhaprayogasaMpAditavRddhihAni-kSata-bhagnasaMrohaNa-pratiniyatavRddhiSaDbhAvavikArotpAdanAzAvasthAniyataviziSTazarIrasnigdhatva-rUkSatva-viziSTadauhRda-bAlakumAra-vRddhAvasthA pratiniyataviziSTarasavIryavipAka pratiniyatapradezAhAragrahaNAdimattvAnyathAnupapatteH, viziSTastrIzarIravat ityAdyanumAnaM bhASyakRtprabhRtibhirvistarataH pratipAditaM tacaitanyaprasAdakamityanumAnatasteSAM caitanyamAnaM sidhyati / sAdhAraNa pratyekazarIratvAdikastu bhedaH"gUDhasira-saMdhi-pavvaM samabhaMgamahIragaM ca chiNNaruhaM / sAhAraNaM sarIraM tabvivarIyaM ca patteyaM / / " [jIvavicA0 gA0 12] ityAdyAgamapratipAdya eva / jIvalakSaNavyatiriktalakSaNAstvajIvA dharmA'dharmA''kAza-kAla-pudgalabhedena paJcavidhAH / tatra pudgalAstikAyavyatiriktAnAM svato mUrtimadrvyasambandhamantareNAtmadravyavadamUrtatvAd anumAnapratyayAvaseyatA / tathAhi-gati-sthityavagAhalakSaNaM pudgalAstikAyAdikAryaM viziSTakAraNaprabhavam, viziSTakAryatvAt, zAlyakurAdikAryavat, yaSTAAsau kAraNavizeSaH sa dharmA'dharmA''kAzalakSaNo yathAsaMkhyamavaseyaH / kAlastu viziSTaparAparapratyayAdiliGgAnumeyaH / pudgalastikAyastu pratyakSA'numAnalakSaNapramANadvayagamyaH / yasteSAM dharmAdInAmasaMkhyeyapradezAtmakatvAdiko vizeSastatpradezAnAM ca sUkSma-sUkSmataratvAdiko vibhAgaH sa "kAlo ya hoi suhumo" [ ] ityAdyAgamapratipAdya eva, nAgamanirapekSayukyavaseyaH / evamAzravAdiSvapi tattveSu yuktayA''gamagamyeSu yuktigamyamaMzaM yuktita eva, AgamagamyaM tu kevalAgamata eva pratipAdayan svasamayaprajJApakaH, itarastu tadvirAdhaka iti prajJApakalakSaNamavagantavyam / / 45 / / ___ 2010_02

Page #245
200 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 3, gAthA- 45 -: paJcavastu prakaraNam : aha vakkhANeavvaM jahA jahA tassa avagamo hoi / Agami amAgameNaM, juttIgammaM tuM juttIe / / 991 / / atha vyAkhyAnayitavyaM kimapi zrutaM, kathamityAha- yathA yathA zrotuH avagamo bhavati, parijJetyarthaH, tatrApi sthitimAha-AgamikaM vastu Agamena, yathA 'svarge'psarasaH, uttarAH kurava' ityAdi, yuktigamyaM punaryuktyaiva yathA dehamAtrapariNAmyAtmetyAdIti gAthArthaH / / 991 / kimityetadevamityAha tathA jamhA u dohavi ihaM bhaNiaM pannavagakahaNabhAvANaM / lakkhaNamaNaghamaIhiM, puvvAyariehiM Agamao / / 992 / / yasmAt dvayorapi atra pravacane bhaNitaM prajJApakakathanabhAvayoH, padArthayorityarthaH, lakSaNaM svarUpaM, kairityAha- anaghamatibhiH avadAtabuddhibhiH pUrvAcAryaiH, kuta ityAha- AgamAt, na tu svamanISikayaiveti gAthArthaH / / 992 / / kiMbhUtaM tadityAha jo uvAyakkhammi heuo Agame a Agamio / so samayapaNNavao, siddhaMtavirAhao anno / / 993 / / yo hetuvAdapakSe yuktigamye vastuni hetuko hetunA carati, Agame cAgamiko, na tatrApi matimohanIM yuktimAha, sa evaMbhUtaH svasamayaprajJApako bhagavadanumataH, siddhAntavirAdhako'nyaH, tallAghavApAdanAditi gAthArthaH / / 993 / / Ago attho, ANAe ceva so kaheyavvo / diTThati diTTaMtA, kahaNavihi virAhaNA iharA / / 994 / / AjJAgrAhyo'rthaH AgamagrAhyaH AjJayaivAsau kathayitavyaH, AgamenaivetyarthaH dAntiko dRSTAntAd dRSTAntena, kathanavidhireSa sUtrArthe, virAdhanetarathA kathanasyeti gAthArtha: / / 994 / / 2010_02

Page #246
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-45 201 -: upadezarahasyam :jo heuvAyapakkhaMmi heuo Agame ya Agamio / so sasamayapaNNavao siddhaMtavirAhago aNNo / / 151 / / [3/45 samma0] yaH kaSTiAddhetuvAdapakSe jIvakarmAdau yuktimArgasahe vastuni hetuko yuktipraNayanapravINaH, Agame ca devalokapRthvIsaMkhyAdAvarthe AgamamAtragamye AgamikaH AgamamAtraprajJApanApravINaH sa svasamayaprajJApaka ucyate / vyavacchedyamAha-siddhAntavirAdhako jinavacanAnuyogavinAzakaH anyaH prAguktavizeSaNavikala: sAdhuH / tathAhi yuktimArgasaheSvapyAgamagamyatvameva puraskurvatA tena nAstikAdipraNItakuyuktinirAkaraNAbhAvAnna zrotRNAM dRDhA pratItiH kartuM pAryate, AgamagamyeSu tu yuktipathAtIteSu yuktimuTuMkayannasaMpAditaniyatArthapratItirviphalArambhatvena svayameva vailakSyaM bhajate, zrotuSTAnAdeyavacano bhavatIti na viparItavyavahAriNA tena samyasiddhAnta ArAdhito bhavati / / 151 / / ___-: tattvArthazlokavArtike : __ a. 1 zraddhAnusAriNo'pi hyAgamAdeva pravartayituM zakyA, na yathA kathaMcit pravacanopadiSTatattve zraddhAmanusaratAM zraddhAnusAritvAdanyAdRzAmatimUDhamanaskatvAt tattvArthazravaNe'nadhikRtatvAdativiparyastavat teSAM tadanurUpopadezayogyatvAt siddhamAtRkopadezayogyadArakavat / prekSAvantaH punarAgamAdanumAnAcca pravartamAnAstattvaM labhante, na kevalAdanumAnAtpratyakSAditasteSAmapravRttiprasaMgAt / nApi kevalAdAgamAdeva viruddhArthamatebhyopi pravartamAnAnAM prekSAvattvaprasakteH / taduktam - "siddhaM ceddhetutaH sarvaM na pratyakSAdito gatiH / siddhaM cedAgamAtsarvaM viruddhArthamatAnyapi / / " iti / tasmAdApte vaktari saMpradAyAvyavacchedena niSTiAte tadvAkyAtpravartanamAgamAdeva / vaktaryanApte tu yattadvAkyAtpravartanaM tadanumAnAditi vibhAgaH sAdhIyAn / tadapyuktam"vaktaryanApte yaddhetoH sAdhyaM taddhetusAdhitam / Apte vaktari tadvAkyAtsAdhyamAgamasAdhitam / / " na caivaM pramANasaMplavavAdivirodhaH, kvacidubhAbhyAmAgamAnumAnAbhyAM pravartanasyeSTatvAt / pravacanasyAhetuhetumadAtmakatvAt / svasamayaprajJApakatvasya tatparijJAnanibandhanatvAdaparijJAtAhetuvAdAgamasya siddhAMtavirodhakatvAt / tathA cAbhyadhAyi - [sammatau] 2010_02

Page #247
202 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-46 "jo heduvAdapakhammi heduo Agamammi aagmo| so sasamayapaNNavao siddhaMtavirAhao aNNoti / / 3/45 / / " tatrAgamamUlamidamAdivAkyaM parAparagurupravAhamAdhyAya pravacanasya pravartakaM tattvArtha lokavArtikaM pravakSyAmIti vacanasyAgamapUrvakAgamArthatvAt / -: AcArAgasUtra : pU.A.zrI zIlAGkAcAryajIkRtaTIkAyAm a. 2, u. 6 syAdetat-kathaM tarhi dharmakathA kAryetyucyate-'ko'yaM' ityAdi, yo hi vazyendriyo viSayaviSaparAGmukhaH saMsArodvignamanA vairAgyAkRSyamANahRdayo dharmaM pRcchati, tenAcAryAdinA dharmakathikenAsau paryAlocanIyaH-ko'yaM puruSo ? mithyAdRSTiruta bhadrakaH, kena vA''zayenAyaM pRcchati, kaM ca devatAvizeSaM nataH, kimanena darzanamAzritamityevamAlocya yathAyogyamuttarakAlaM kathanIyam, etaduktaM bhavati-dharmakathAvidhijJo hyAtmanA paripUrNaH zrotAramAlocayati dravyata:-kSetrataH kimidaM kSetraM taJcanikairbhAgavatairanyairvA tajjAtIyaiH pArzvasthAdibhirvotsargarucibhirvA bhAvitam, kAlato duSSamAdikaM kAlaM durlabhadravyakAlaM vA, bhAvato'raktadviSTamadhyasthabhAvApannamevaM paryAlocya yathA yathA'sau budhyate tathA tathA dharmakathA kAryA, evamasau dharmakathAyogyaH, aparasya tvadhikAra eva nAstIti, uktaM ca- [sammatau] "jo heuvAyapakkhaMmi heuo Agamammi Agamio / so sasamayapaNNavao siddhaMtavirAhao aNNo / / 3/45 / / " [hetusAdhyamarthaM hetoreva itaraM cAgamata eva sAdhayato nayavAdaH zuddho nAnyasya iti kathanam] yo hetusAdhyamarthaM hetunA sAdhayati AgamasiddhaM ca Agamena, tasya nayavAdaH parizuddhaH nAnyasyetyetadevA''ha-parisuddha' ityAdi / yadvA vastudharmapratipAdako'hetu-hetuvAdaprabheda Agamo vAkya-nayarUpaH parizuddhatarabhedena dvirUpatAM pratipadyate ityAha parisuddho nayavAo AgamamettatthasAhao hoi / so ceva duNNigiNNo doNNi vi pakkhe vidhammei / / 46 / / pari samantAt zuddho nayavAdaH yadA vivakSitA'vivakSitAnantarUpAtmakavastupratipAdakaM 2010_02 :

Page #248
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-46-47 203 nayavAkyaM pravartate 'syAnnityam' ityAdikaM tadA bhavati, pramANaparizuddhAgamArthamAtrasya nyUnAdhikavyavacchedena pratipAdanAt adhikasyA'saMbhavena nyUnasya ca nayAnAmasarvArthatvaprasaGgato'rthasya parizuddhAgamaviSayatvAyogAt / sa eva nayavAdaH itararUpanirapekSaikarUpapratipAdakatvena yadA dunikSiptaH pramANaviruddhArthapratipAdakatvenA'vatAritastadA dvitIyadharmanirapekSasya pratipAdyadharmasyA'pyabhAvato'pratipAdanAd aparizuddho bhavati, pramANaviruddhasya tathA tadarthasya vyavasthAyitumazakyatvAt / / 46 / / [ aparizuddhanayavAdarUpaparasamayAnAM saMkhyAnam ] aparizuddhapTA nayavAdaH parasamayaH sa kiyadbhedo bhavati ? ityAha jAvaiyA vayaNapahA tAvaiyA ceva hoMti NayavAyA / jAvaiyA NayavAyA tAvaiyA ceva parasamayA / / 47 / / anekAntAtmakasya vastuna ekadezasya yad anyanirapekSasyA'vadhAraNam aparizuddho nayaH, tAvanmAtrArthasya vAcakAnAM zabdAnAM yAvanto mArgAH hetavo nayAH tAvanta eva bhavanti nayavAdAstatpratipAdakAH zabdAH / yAvanto nayavAdAstAvanta eva parasamayA bhavanti svecchAprakalpitavikalpanibandhanatvAt parasamayAnAM parimitirna vidyate / nanu yadyaparimitAH parasamayAH kathaM tannibandhanabhUtAnAM nayAnAM saMkhyAniyamaH "naigama-saMgraha-vyavahArarjusUtra-zabdasamabhirUDhaivaMbhUtA nayAH" [tattvArtha, sU0 1-33] iti zrUyate ? na; sthUlatastacchuteH, avAntarabhedena tu teSAmaparimitatvameva svakalpanAzilpighaTitavikalpanAmaniyatatvAt tadutthapravAdAnAmapi tatsaMkhyAparimANatvAt / / 47 / / -: zAstravArtAsamuccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAM sta.7, gA.66 na ceyamatantrasiddhetyAha matijJAnavikalpatvAnna cAniSTiriyaM yataH / etapTalAttataH siddhaM nityAnityAdi vastu naH / / 66 / / ___ 2010_02

Page #249
204 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-47 yato matijJAnavikalpatvAd na ceyamaniSTiH pratyabhijJAGgIkAro nApasiddhAnta ityarthaH, vAsanAdhAraNAphalatvena tadupagamAt, tata etaSTalAt pratyabhijJAnyathAnupapatteH naH asmAkaM nityAnityAdi vastu siddham, AdinA sadasadAdigrahaH / tadevaM siddho vastuyAthAtmyaparicchedapravaNaH syAdvAdaH / etadekadezAlambanA eva parasparanirapekSAH pravartante'parimitAH parasamayAH / taduktam jAvaiA vayaNapahA tAvaiA ceva huMti NayavAyA / jAvaiA NayavAyA tAvaiA ceva parasamayA / / [3/47] / / iti / asyArthaH-yAvanto vacanapathAH vaktRvikalpahetavo'dhyavasAyavizeSAH, tAvanto nayavAdAH tajjanitavaktRvikalpAH zabdAtmakAH, sAmAnyato naigamAdisaptabhedopagrahe'pi prativyakti tadAnantyAt / yAvantaSTA nayavAdAstAvanta eva parasamayAH, nirapekSavaktRvikalpamAtrakalpitatvAt teSAm / / ___ -: vizeSAvazyakabhASyam :athavA, kimanena stokabhedadarzanena ?, utkRSTato'saMkhyAtA api nayA bhavanti / te'pi cApizabdAd draSTavyA iti darzayannAha jAvanto vayaNapahA tAvanto vA nayA visaddAo / te ceva ya parasamayA sammattaM samudiyA savve / / 2265 / / vA athavA, yAvanto vacanapathA vacanamArgA vacanaprakArAste'pIhApizabdAta saMgRhItAH / ya eva ca nayAsta eva ca sAvadhAraNAH sarve'pi parasamayAstIrthikasiddhAntAH, samuditAstu niravadhAraNAH syAcchabdalAJchitAH sarve'pi nayAH samyaktvaM jinazAsanabhAvaM pratipadyanta ityarthaH / Aha ca stutikAraH udadhAviva sarvasindhavaH samudIrNAstvayi nAtha ! dRSTayaH / na ca tAsu bhavAn pradRzyate pravibhaktAsu saritsviodadhiH / / iti / / 2265 / / -: SaDdarzanasamuccaye : guNaratnasUrIkRtavRttau kA. 1, gA. 1 nanvatra sarvadarzanavAcyo'thoM vaktuM prakAntaH, sa ca saMkhyAtikrAntaH, tatkathaM svalpIyasAnena prastutazAstreNa so'bhidhAtuM zakyaH, jainAdanyadarzanAnAM parasamayAparanAmadheyAnAmasaMkhyAtatvAt / taduktaM sanmatisUtre zrIsiddhasenadivAkareNa _ 2010_02

Page #250
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-47 205 "jAvaiyA vayaNapahA tAvaiyA ceva huMti nayavAyA / jAvaiyA nayavAyA tAvaiyA ceva parasamayA / / 3/47 / / " vyAkhyA-anantadharmAtmakasya vastuno ya ekadezo'nyadezanirapekSastasya yadavadhAraNaM so'parizuddho nayaH / sa eva ca vacanamArga ucyate / evaM cAnantadharmAtmakasya sarvasya vastuna ekadezAnAmitarAMzanirapekSANAM yAvanto'vadhAraNaprakArAH saMbhavanti tAvanto nayA aparizuddhA bhavanti / te ca vacanamArgA ityucyate / tato'yaM gAthArthaH-sarvasmin vastuni yAvanto yAvatsaMkhyA vacanapathA vacanAnAmanyonyaikadezavAcakAnAM zabdAnAM mArgA avadhAraNaprakArA hetavo nayA bhavanti tAvanta eva bhavanti nayavAdAH, nayAnAM tattadekadezAvadhAraNaprakArANAM vAdAH pratipAdakAH zabdaprakArAH / yAvanto nayavAdA ekaikAMzAvadhAraNavAcakazabvaprakArAH tAvanta eva parasamayAH paradarzanAni bhavanti, svecchAprakalpitavikalpanibandhanatvAtparasamayAnAm, vikalpAnAM cAsaMkhyatvAt / ayaM bhAvaH-yAvanto jane tattadaparAparavastvekadezAnAmavadhAraNapratipAdakAH zabdaprakArA bhaveyustAvanta eva parasamayA bhavanti / tatasteSAmaparimitatvameva, svakalpanAzilpighaTitavikalpAnAmaniyatatvAt tadutthapravAdAnAmapi tatsaMkhyAparimANatvAditi / tadevaM gaNanAtigAH parasamayA bhavanti / / -: syAdvAdamaJjarITIkAyAm : gA.28 atha durnayanayapramANasvarUpaM kiJcinirUpyate / tatrApi prathamaM nayasvarUpam / tadanadhigame durnayasvarUpasya duSparijJAnatvAt / atra ca AcAryeNa prathamaM durnayanirdezo yathottaraM prAdhAnyAvavodhanArthaH kRtaH / tatra pramANapratipannArthekadezaparAmarzI nayaH / anantadharmAdhyAsitaM vastu svAbhitaikadharmaviziSTaM nayati prApayati saMvedanakoTimArohayati iti nayaH / pramANapravRtteruttarakAlabhAvI parAmarza ityarthaH / nayApTAAnantAH, anantadharmatvAt vastunaH tadekadharmaparyavasitAnAM vakturabhiprAyANAM ca nayatvAt / tathA ca vRddhAH- "jAvaiA vayaNapahA tAvaiyA ceva hu~ti nayavAyA" iti / 2010_02

Page #251
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 3, gAthA- 48 ] [ kaM kaM nayamAzritya kaskaH samayaH prasthita iti praznasya vyAkaraNam nanu kaM nayamAzritya kaH parasamayaH pravRttaH ? ko vA kasya viSayaH ? ityAhajaM kAvilaM darisaNaM eyaM davvaTThiyassa vattavvaM / suddhoaNataNaassa u parisuddho pajjavaviappo / / 48 / / 206 yat kApilaM darzanaM sAMkhyamatam etad dravyAstikanayasya vaktavyam - tadviSayaviSayam tadutthApitaM ceti bhAvaH- :- zauddhodanestu parizuddhaH paryAyavizeSa eva vaktavyaH-parizuddhaparyAyAstikanayavizeSaviSayaM tadutthApitaM ca saugatamatamityabhiprAyaH / mithyAsvarUpanayaprabhavatvAd anayormithyAtvaM prAk pradarzitameva / / 48 / / -: zAstravArttAsamuccaye syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAM sta. 7, gA. 66 yAvantaSTA nayavAdAstAvanta eva parasamayAH, nirapekSavaktRvikalpamAtrakalpitatvAt teSAm / tathAhi-kApilaM darzanaM nirapekSadravyArthikanayavikalpaprasUtam, bauddhadarzanaM ca nirapekSazuddhaparyAyAstikanayavikalpajanitam, dvAbhyAmapi ca parasparanirapekSAbhyAM dravyArthika-paryAyArthikAbhyAM praNItamaulUkyadarzanam / tadAha - [ sammatau ] kAvilaM darisaNaM eyaM davvaTThi assa vattavvaM / suddho aNataNayassa u parisuddho pajjavaviappo / / 3/48 / / dohi vi Naehi NIaM satthamulUeNa taha vi micchataM / savisayappahANattaNeNa annunnaNiravekkhaM / / 3/49 / / -- evamaupaniSadadarzanAdInAmapi saMgrahanayAdeH prAdurbhUtirbhAvanIyA / 1. NiravekkhA ( saMmati ) / 2010_02

Page #252
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-49 207 [ dravyAstika-paryAyAstikobhayAzritasyApi vaizeSikasamayasya kathaM mithyAtvamiti praznasya prativacanam ] | nanu bhavatu parasparanirapekSaikaikanayAvalambinoH sAGkhya-saugatamatayomithyAtvam, kaNabhugmatasya tu dravyArthika-paryAyArthikanayadvayAvalambinaH kathaM mithyAtvam ? ityatrAha dohi vi Naehi NIaM satthamulUeNa taha vi micchattaM / jaM savisaappahANattaNeNa aNNoNNaniravekkhA' / / 49 / / dvAbhyAmapi dravyArthika-paryAyArthikanayAbhyAM praNItaM zAstram ulUkena vaizeSikazAstrapraNetrA, dravya-guNAdeH padArthaSaTkasya nityAnityaikAntarUpasya tatra pratipAdanAt / [ kaNAdoktaSaTpadA vyavasthAyA upanyAsaH ] tathAhi-dravya-guNa-karma-sAmAnya-vizeSa-samavAyAkhyAH SaDeva padArthAH, nyUnA'dhikapratipAdakapramANAbhAve parasparaviviktasvarUpaSaTpadArthavyavasthApakapramANaviSayatvAt, ubhayAbhimataghaTAdiSaTpadArthavat / tatra pRthivyap-tejo-vAyvAkAza-kAla-digAtma-manAMsi navaiva dravyANi / 'pRthivI ApaH tejo vAyuH' ityetat catuHsaMkhyaM nityA'nityabhedAd dviprakAraM dravyam; tatra paramANurUpaM nityam "sadakAraNavannityam" [vaizeSikada0 4-1-1] iti vacanAt, tadArabdhaM tu TyaNukAdi kAryadravyamanityam / AkAzAdikaM tu nityameva, anutpattimattvAt / eSAM ca dravyatvAbhisaMbandhAd dravyarUpatA, dravyatvAbhisaMbandhaSTA dravyatvasAmAnyopalakSitasamavAyaH, tatsamavetaM vA sAmAnyam, etaccetaravyavacchedakameSAM lakSaNam / tathAhi-pRthivyAdIni manaHparyantAni itarebhyo bhidyante 'dravyANi' iti vA vyavahartavyAni dravyatvAbhisaMbandhAt, yAni tu naivam na ca tAni dravyatvAbhisaMbandhavanti, yathA guNAdivastUni, iti kevalavyatirekihetubalAt, pRthivyAdIni dravyANi guNAdibhyo vyAvRttarUpANi siddhAni / pRthivyAdInAmapi bhedavatAM pRthivItvAbhisaMbandhAdikaM lakSaNamitarebhyo bhedavyavahAre tacchabdavAcyatve vA sAdhye kevalavyatirekirUpaM draSTavyam / abhedavatAM tvAkAza-kAla-digdavyANAmanAdisiddhatacchandavAcyatA draSTavyA / navaiva caitAni dravyANi, nyUnAdhikatvapratipAdakapramANAbhAve 1.NikhekkhaM (syA. kalpa.) / 2010_02

Page #253
208 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-49 parasparavyAvRttanavalakSaNayogitvAt, ubhayAbhimatanavaghaTAdivat / evaM rUpAdayaSTAturviMzatiguNAH / utkSepaNAdIni paJca karmANi / parA'parabhedabhinnaM dvividhaM sAmAnyamanugatajJAnakAraNam / nityadravyavRttayo'ntyA vizeSA atyantavyAvRttabuddhihetavaH / ayutasiddhAnAmAdhAryA''dhArabhUtAnAm 'iha' itipratyayaheturyaH saMbandhaH sa samavAya eko vyApakapTA / atra ca padArthaSaTke dravyANi guNASTA kecinnityA eva, kecit tvanityA eva / karma anityameva / sAmAnya-vizeSasamavAyAstu nityA eveti padArthavyavasthA / tatapTautat zAstraM tathApi mithyAtvam, tatpradarzitapadArthaSaTkasya pramANabAdhitatvAt / [S.T.P.657] tadevamulUkapratipAditazAstrasya mithyAtvam tadabhihitapadArthAnAmapramANatvAt pramANabAdhitatvAJca / AcAryastu etat sarvaM hRdi kRtvA tanmithyAtvA'vinAbhUtaM pratipAditasakalanyAyavyApakam 'jaM savisaya' ityAdinA gAthApaSTArthena hetumAha-yasmAt svaviSayapradhAnatAvyavasthitA'nyonyanirapekSobhayanayAzritaM tat anyonyanirapekSanayAzritatvasya mithyAtvAdinA'vinAbhUtatvAt / / 49 / / [S.T.P.704] -: vizeSAvazyakabhASyam :evaM sAmAnya-vizeSeSu prarUpiteSu paraH prAha naNu davya-pajjavaTThiyanayAvalaMbi tti negamo ceva / sammaTThiI sAhu vva kIsa micchattabheo'yaM ? / / 2193 / / Aha- nanveyaM sati yat sAmAnyaM tad dravyam, vizeSAstu paryAyAH, tato dravya-paryAyAstikanayadvayamatAvalambitvAt samyagadRSTirevAyaM naigamanayaH, jainasAdhuvat / na hi jainasAdhavo'pi dravya-paryAyobhayarUpAd vastuno'nyat kiJcidicchanti / tat kimityasau mithyAtvabhedaH ? iti / / 2193 / / jaM sAmanavisese parotparaM vatthuo ya so bhinne / mannai aJcaMtamao micchaviTThI kaNAdo vva / / 2194 / / dohiM vi naehiM nIyaM satthamulUeNa taha vi micchattaM / jaM savisayappahANattaNeNa annonnaniravekkhA / / 2195 / / yad yasmAt sAmAnya-vizeSau naigamanayaH parasparamatyantabhinnau manyate, vastuno'pyAdhArabhUtAd dravya 2010_02

Page #254
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-49 209 guNa-karma-paramANurUpAdatyantabhinnau sa tAvicchati; jainasAdhavastu parasparaM svAdhArAJca kathaJcideva tau bhinnAvicchanti; ato mithyAdRSTirevA'yam, kaNAdavaditi; tathAhi-dvAbhyAmapi dravya-paryAstikanayAbhyAM sarvamapi nijaM zAstraM nItaM samarthitamulUkena tathApi tad mithyAtvameva, yad yasmAt svasvaviSayaprAdhAnyAbhyupagamenolUkabhimatau dravya-paryAyAstikanayAvanyonya-nirapekSau, jainAbhyupagatau punastau parasparasApekSau, syAcchabdalAJchitatvAditi / / 2194 / / 2195 / / -: pramANamImAMsA : sU. 30 tatra 'dravyaparyAya'grahaNena dravyaikAntaparyAyaikAntavAdiparikalpitaviSayavyudAsaH / 'Atma'grahaNena cAtyantavyatiriktadravyaparyAyavAdikANAdayogAbhyupagataviSayanirAsaH / yacchrIsiddhasenaH "dohiM vi naehiM nIyaM satthamulUee taha vi micchattaM / jaM savisayappahANattaNeNa annonnaniravikkhA" / / 3/49 / / tti / / 30 / / -: dravyaguNaparyAyano rAsa : DhA. 5, gA. 6 eha vizeSAvazyakaI sammatimAM paNi dhAro re. chama nayathI savi saMbhavaI, meh-amehu5yaa| 3. 70. yAna0. meDa artha vizeSAvazyakaI tathA sammatimAhI 76 ma-dhAro dohi vi Nayahi NIaM, satthamulUeNa taha vi micchataM / jaM savisayappahANattaNeNa aNNuNNaniravekkhA / / 2195 / / svArthagrAhI itarAMzApratikSepI sunayaH, iti sunayalakSaNam / svArthagrAhI itarAMzapratikSepI durnayaH, iti durnayalakSaNam / ma-nayI-nayaviyArathI, me: mama: prAya vyavahAra saMbhava. tathA-naya-saMtavizeSathI: grAhakavRttivizeSarUpa upacAra paNi saMbhavaI. te mATaI-bhedaH abhedaH te mukhyapaNaI pratyekanayaviSayaH mukhyamukhyapaNaI ubhanayaviSayaH upacAra-te mukhyavRttinI pari nayaparikara paNi viSaya nahIM. e samo mArga zvetAmbarapramANa-zAstrasiddha jANavo. 30 _ 2010_02

Page #255
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 3, gAthA - 50-51 [ anyonyanirapekSanayAzritAnAM vAdAnAM mithyAtvarAhityAbhAvapratipAdanam ] anyonyanirapekSanayAzritasya mithyAtvA'vinAbhUtatvameva darzayannAha je saMtavAyadose sakkolUyA bhAMti saMkhANaM / saMkhA ya asavvAe tesiM savve vi te sacA / / 50 / / 210 yAn ekAntasadvAdapakSe dravyAstikAbhyupagatapadArthAbhyupagame zAkyaulUkyA doSAn vadanti sAGkhyAnAM kriyA-guNavyapadezopalabdhyAdiprasaGgAdilakSaNAn te sarve'pi teSAM satyA ityevaM saMbandhaH kAryaH / te ca doSAH evaM satyAH syuH yadyanyanirapekSanayAbhyupagatapadArthapratipAdakaM tat zAstra mithyA syAt nAnyathA prAgapi kAryAvasthAta ekAntena tatsattvanibandhanatvAt teSAm anyathA kathaMcit sattve anekAntavAdApatterdoSAbhAva eva syAt / sAGkhyA api asatkAryavAdadoSAn asadakaraNAdIn yAn vadanti te sarve teSAM satyA eva ekAntA'sati kAraNavyApArAsaMbhavAt anyathA zazazRGgAderapi kAraNavyApArAdutpattiH syAt / [S.T.P.705] tasmAd dravyAstika-paryAyAstikAbhyAM kevalAbhyAM sahitAbhyAmanyonyanirapekSAbhyAM vyavasthApitaM vastu asatyamiti tatpratipAdakaM zAstraM sarvaM mithyeti vyavasthitam ||50 | | [S.T.P. 709] [ anvaya-vyatirekAbhyAM nirapekSanayadvaye mithyAjJAnarUpatvasya dRDhIkaraNam ] amumevArthamanvaya-vyatirekAbhyAM dRDhIkartumAha te u bhayaNovaNIyA sammahaMsaNamaNuttaraM hoMti / jaM bhavadukkhavimokkhaM do vi na pUreMti pADikkaM / / 51 / / tau dravya-paryAyAstikanayau bhajanayA parasparasvabhAvA'vinAbhUtatayA upanIto sadasadrUpaikAntavyavacchedena tadAtmakaikakAryakAraNAdivastupratipAdakatvena upayojitau yadA bhavatastadA samyagdarzanamanuttaraM nAsti asmAd anyad uttaraM pradhAnaM yasmiMstat tathAbhUtaM bhavataH parasparAvinirbhAgavartidravyaparyAyAtmakaikavastutattvaviSayarucyAtmakA'bAdhitA'vabodhasvabhAvatvAt / yadA tu anyonyanirapekSadravya-paryAyapratipAdanatvena upanItau bhavato na tadA samyaktvaM pratipadyete yasmAt saMsArabhAvijanmAdiduH khavimokSamAtyantikaM vizleSaM dvAvapi tau pratyekaM na vidhattaH 2010_02

Page #256
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-51-52 211 mithyAjJAnAt samyakkriyAnaGtayA AtyantikabhavopadravAnnivRttyasiddheH tadviparyayakAraNatvAt taJcAsakRt prAk pratipAditamiti na punaH pratanyate / tataH kAraNAt kAryaM kathaMcid anyat kathaMcidananyat ata eva tadatadrUpatayA 'saJca asaJca' iti / / 51 / / [ kArya-kAraNayorbhedAbhedarUpatvadarzanenAnekAntarUpatvopapAdanam ] amumeva arthamupasaMhAradvAreNa upadarzayannAha natthi puDhavIvisiTTho 'ghaDo'tti jaM teNa jujjai aNaNNo / jaM puNa ghaDo'tti puvvaM Na Asi puDhavI tao aNNo / / 52 / / nAsti sadravyamRtpRthivItvAdibhyo vizliSTo bhinno ghaTaH sadAdivyatiriktasvabhAvatayA tasyAnupalambhAt / kiJca, yadi sattvAdayo dharmA ghaTAd ekAntato bhinnAH so'pi vA tebhyo bhinnaH syAt tadA na ghaTasya sadAditvaM syAt svato'sadAderanyadharmayoge'pi zazazRGgAderiva tathAtvAyogAt sadAderapi ghaTAdyAkArAd atyantabhede nirAkAratayA atyantAbhAvasyeva upalambhaviSayatvAyogAd jJeyatva-prameyatvAdidharmANAmapi sadAdidharmebhyo bhede asattvam sadAdestu tebhyo bhede ajJeyatvAd asattvameva "upalambhaH sattA" [ ] iti vacanAt / tataH sadAdirUpatayA upalabhyamAnatvAd ghaTasya tebhyo'bhinnarUpatA'bhyupagantavyA prameyavyavasthiteH pramANanibandhanatvAt / yat punaH pRthubunodarAdyAkAratayA pUrva sadAdirna AsIt tato'sau anyastebhyo ghaTarUpatayA prAk sadAderanupalambhAt prAgapi tadrUpasya sadAdau sattve anupalambhAyogAt dRzyA'nupalambhasya ca abhAvAvyabhicAritvAt tadatadrUpatAyAM ca virodhAbhAvAt pratIyamAnAyAM tadayogAt abAdhitapratyayasya ca mithyAtvAsaMbhavAd bAdhAvirahasya ca prAgeva upapAditatvAt / / 52 / / -: vizeSavazyakabhASyam :Aha - yadyaikatvavad bhede 'pi kArya-kAraNayostulya upAlambhaH, tarhi kathaM nAma lokaprasiddhastantupaTAdInAM kArya-kAraNabhAvaH sidhyati ? iti bhavanta eva kathayantu, ityAha jaM kajja-kAraNAiM pajjAyA vatthuNo jao te ya / anne'Nanne ya mayA to kAraNa-kajjabhayaNeyaM / / 2103 / / 2010_02

Page #257
212 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-52 yad yasmAd ghaTa-mRtpiNDAdilakSaNe kArya-kAraNe vastunaH pRthvivyAde: paryAyau vartete, tau ca ghaTamRtpiNDalakSaNau pRthvIparyAyau parasparaM yato yasmAdanyAvananyau ca matau / tatra saMkhyA-saMjJA-lakSaNAdibhedAdanyatvam, mRdAdirUpatayA sattva-prameyatvAdibhiSTAnanyatvam / tasmAt kArya-kAraNayoriyamanyA'nanyatvalakSaNA bhajanA draSTavyA / tatapTA kathaJcit tayoH parasparaM bhede, kathaJcittvabhede kArya-kAraNabhAva iti bhAvArthaH / / 2103 / / etadevAha natthi puDhavIvisiTTho ghaDo tti jaM teNa jujjai aNanno / jaM puNa ghaDo tti puvvaM na Asi puDhavI tao anno / / 2104 / / pRthivyA mRttikAyA viziSTo vyatirikto tanmayo ghaTo nAsti na dRzyate yad yasmAt, tena tasmAd yujyate'nanyo mRttikAto'bhinnaH / yat punaH 'ghaTaH' iti vyaktena rUpeNa pUrvaM ghaTaniSpatteH prAg nAsId nAbhUt kintu pRthivI mRttikaivAsIt, anyathA sarvathaikatve pRthivIkAle'pi ghaTo dRzyateti bhAvaH, tatastasmAjjJAyate- pRthivIto'nyo ghaTa iti / evaM yathA mRd-ghaTayoranyA-'nanyatvameva, evaM sarvatra kArya-kAraNayostad bhAvanIyamiti / / 2104 / / 'jaha taMtavo nimittaM paDassa vemAdao tahA tesiM / jaM ceTTAinimittaM to te paDayassa nemittaM / / 2105 / / yathA tantavaH paTasya nimittaM kAraNaM tathA tenaiva prakAreNa yasmAt teSAM tantUnAmAtAna-vitAnAdiceSTAyA nimittaM vemAdayastato nimittasyedaM naimittikaM kAraNaM paTasya bhavatIti / / 2106 / / __-: dazavaikAlikasUtre : pU.A.zrI haribhadrasUrIkRtaTIkAyAm a. 1 atrAha-'dharmo maGgalamutkRSTa'mityAdau dharmagrahaNe sati ahiMsAsaMyamatapograhaNamayuktam, tasyA hiMsAsaMyamataporUpatvAvyabhicArAditi, ucyate, na, ahiMsAdInAM dharmakAraNatvAddharmasya ca kAryatvAtkAryakAraNayopTA kathaJcidbhedAt, kathaMcidbhedaSTA tasya dravyaparyAyobhayarUpatvAt, uktaM ca "Natthi puDhavIvisiTTho ghaDotti jaM teNa jujjai aNaNNo / jaM puNa ghaDutti puvvaM nAsI puDhavIi to anno" / / 1 / / ityAdi, gamyAdidharmavyavacchedena tatsvarUpajJApanArthaM vA'hiMsAdigrahaNamaduSTamityalaM vistareNa / / ___ 2010_02

Page #258
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-53 213 __ [ sadAyekAntavat kAlAyekAnte'pi mithyAtvakhyApanam ] sadAyekAntavAdavat kAlAdyekAntavAde'pi mithyAtvameva ityAha kAlo sahAva-NiyaI pubbakayaM purisakAraNegaMtA / micchattaM te 'ceva samAsao hoMti sammattaM // 53 // kAla-svabhAva-niyati-pUrvakRta-puruSakAraNarUpA ekAntAH sarve'pi ekakA mithyAtvam ta eva samuditAH parasparA'jahadvRttayaH samyaktvarUpatAM pratipadyante iti tAtparyArthaH / tanna kAlAdyekAntAH pramANataH saMbhavantIti tadvAdo mithyAvAda iti sthitam / ta eva anyonyasavyapekSA nityAdyekAntavyapohena ekAnekasvabhAvAH kAryanirvartanapaTavaH pramANaviSayatayA paramArthasanta iti tatpratipAdakasya zAstrasyApi samyaktvamiti tadvAdaH samyagvAdatayA vyavasthitaH / / 53 / / -: paJcavastukaprakaraNam :bhaNNaI egaMteNaM, amhANaM kammavAya no iTTho / Na ya so sahAvavAo, suakevaliNA jao bhaNiaM / / 1047 / / 'bhaNyate 'tra' 'naikAntenAsmAkaM' -jainAnAM 'karmavAda eveSTaH na ca na svabhAvavAda' iSTaH, zrutakevalinA yato bhaNitaM' vakSyamANamiti gAthArthaH / / 1047 / / AyariyasiddhaseNeNa sammaIe paiTThiajaseNaM / dUsamaNisAdivAgarakappattaNao tadakkheNaM / / 1048 / / 'AcAryasiddhasenena sammatyAM' bhaNitaM vakSyamANam, sammatyAM vA 'pratiSThitayazasA' tena, tathA 'duSSamAnizAdivAkarakalpatvAt' kAraNAt 'tadAkhyena' divAkaranAmneti gAthArthaH / / 1048 / / yad bhaNitaM tadAha kAlo sahAva-niaI, puvakayaM purisakAraNegaMtA / micchattaM te ceva u, samAsao hoMti sammattaM / / 1049 / / [3/53samma.] 1. ceva u (paJcavastu, upadezapada, nayopadeza, syA. kalpa., sUtra. TIkA) / 2. ceva (saMmati.) / _ 2010_02

Page #259
214 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-53 kAlaH svabhAvo niyatiH pUrvakRtaM puruSakAraNaM ekAntA ete kAlAdaya eva kAraNaM vizvasyetyevambhUtAH mithyAtvam, ta eva samAsato bhavanti samyaktvam, sarva eva samuditAH santaH phalajanakatveneti gAthArthaH / / 1049 / / -: upadezapada: :nanu kathamitthaM anekakAraNA buddhirjAtA ityAzakya sarvameva kAryamanekakAlAdikAraNajanyamiti darzayannAha kAlo sahAva-niyaI puvvakayaM purisakAraNegaMtA / micchattaM te ceva u samAsao hoMti sammattaM / / 164 / / [3/53 samma.] kAlasvabhAvaniyatipUrvakRtapuruSakAraNarUpA ekAntAH sarve'pyekakA mithyAtvaM tata eva samuditAH parasparAtyajadvRttayaH samyaktvarUpatAM pratipadyante / iti gAthAtAtparyArthaH / / tatra kAla eva ekAntena jagataH kAraNamiti kAlavAdinaH prAhuH / tathAhi - sarvasya zItoSNavarSavanaspatipuruSAderjagataH prabhavasthitivinAzeSu grahoparAgayutiyuddhodayAstamayagamanAgamanAdau ca kAla: kAraNam, tamantareNa sarvasyAsyAnyakAraNatvAbhimatabhAvasadbhAve'pyabhAvAt / taduktaM "kAla: pacati bhUtAni kAlaH saMharate prajAH / kAla: supteSu jAgarti kAlo hi duratikramaH / / 1 / / " asadetat, tatkAlasadbhAve'pi vRSTyAdeH kadAcidadarzanAt / na ca tadabhavanamapi tadvizeSakRtameva, nityaikarUpatayA tasya vizeSAbhAvAt / vizeSe vA tajjananAjananasvabhAvatayA tasya nityatvavyatikramAt,- svabhAvabhedAd bhedasiddheH / na ca vAyumaNDalAdikRto varSAdirvizeSaH, tasyApyahetukatayA bhAvAt / na ca kAla eva tasya hetuH, itaretarAzrayadoSaprasakteH-sati kAlabhede varSAdibhedahetorgrahamaNDalAderbhedaH, tadbhadAJca kAlabheda iti parisphuTamitaretarAzrayatvam / anyataH kAraNAd varSAbhide'bhyupagamyamAne na kAla evaikaH kAraNaM bhavedityabhyupagamavirodhaH, kAlasya ca kutaSTiAd bhedAbhyupagame'nityatvamityuktam / tatra ca prabhavasthitinAzeSu yadyaparaH kAlaH kAraNam, tadA tatrApi sa eva paryanuyoga ityanavasthAnAd na varSAdikAryotpattiH syAt / na caikasya kAraNatvaM yuktam, kramayogapadyAbhyAM tadvirodhAt / tanna kAla evaikaH kAraNaM jagataH / / 1 / / 1. ceva (saMmati.) / 2010_02

Page #260
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-53 215 __ apare tu svabhAvata eva bhAvA jAyanta iti varNayanti / atra yadi svabhAvakAraNA bhAvA iti teSAmabhyupagamaH, tadA svAtmani kriyAvirodho doSaH / nAtyutpannAnAM teSAM svabhAvaH samasti / utpannAnAM tu svabhAvasaMgatAvapi prAksvabhAvA'bhAve'pyutpatternirvRttatvAd na svabhAvastatra kAraNaM bhavet / athavA kAraNamantareNa bhAvA bhavanti svaparakAraNanimittijanmanirapekSatayA sarvahetunirAzaMsasvabhAvA bhAvA iti zabdArthaH / tarhi pratyakSavirodho doSaH / tathA hi-adhyakSAnupalambhAbhyAmanvayavyatirekato bIjAdikaM tatkAraNatvena niSTiAtameva / yasya hi yasmin satyeva bhAvaH, yasya ca vikArAd yasya vikAraH, tattasya kAraNatvamucyate / ucchUnAdiviziSTAvasthAprAptaM ca bIjaM kaNTakAditaikSNyAderanvayavyatirekavadadhyakSAnupalambhAbhyAM kAraNatayA niSTiAtamiti na svabhAvaikAntavAdo'pi jyAyAn / / 2 / / sarvasya vastunastathA tathA niyatarUpeNa bhavanAd niyatireva kAraNamiti kecit / taduktam - "prAptavyo niyatibalAzrayeNa yo'rthaH so'vazyaM bhavati nRNAM zubho'zubho vA / bhUtAnAM mahati kRte'pi hi prayatne nAbhAvyaM bhavati nA bhAvino'sti nAzaH / / 1 / / " asadetat, zAstropadezavaiyarthyaprasakteH, tadupadezamantareNApyartheSu niyatikRtabuddherniyatyaiva bhAvAt / dRSTAdRSTaphalazAstrapratipAditazubhAzubhakriyAphalaniyamAbhAvaSTA syAt / iti kevalaniyativAdo'pi na zreyAn / / 3 / / janmAntaropAttamiSTAniSTaphaladaM karma sarvajagadvaicitryakAraNamiti karmavAdinaH / tathA cAhuH "yathA yathA pUrvakRtasya karmaNaH phalaM nidhAnasthamivAvatiSThate / tathA tathA tatpratipAdanodyatA pradIpahasteva matiH pravarttate / / 1 / / " asadetat, kulAlAderghaTAdikAraNatvenAdhyakSataH pratIyamAnasya parihAreNAparAdRSTakAraNaprakalpanayA'navasthAprasaGgataH kvacidapi kAraNapratiniyamAnupapatteH / na ca svatantraM karma jagadvaicitryakAraNamupapadyate, tasya karbadhInatvAt / na caikasvabhAvAt tato jagadvaicitryamupapattimat, kAraNavaicitryamantareNa kAryavaicitryAyogAt / anekasvabhAvatve ca karmaNo nAmamAtranibandhanaiva vipratipattiH, puruSa-kAla svabhAvAderapi jagadvaicitryakAraNatvenArthato'bhyupagamAt / iti karmaikAntavAdo'pi na vicArasahaH / / 4 / / anye tu varNayanti; puruSa evaikaH sakalalokasthitisargapralayahetuH pralaye'pyaluptajJAnAtizayaH / tathA coktam - 2010_02

Page #261
216 "UrNanAbha ivAMzUnAM candrakAnta ivAmbhasAM / prarohANAmiva plakSaH sa hetuH sarvajanmanAm / / 1 / / " iti / saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 3, gAthA- 53 etadapi na ghaTate, yataH prekSApUrvakAriNAM pravRttiH prayojanavattayA vyAptA, ataH kiM prayojanamuddizyAyaM jagatkaraNe pravarttate ? nezvarAdipreraNAt, asvAtantryaprasakteH, na parAnugrahArtham, anukampayA duHkhitasattvanirvarttanAnupapatteH / na tatkarmaprakSayArtham, duHkhitasattvanirmANe pravRttestatkarmaNo'pi tatkRtatvena tatprakSayArthaM tannirmANapravRttAvaprekSApUrvakAritApatteH / iti naitadvAdo'pi viduSAM manomodAvahaH / / 5 / / ato na kAlAdyekAntAH pramANataH sambhavantIti tadvAdo mithyAvAda iti / ta evAnyo'nyasavyapekSAnityAdyekAntavyapohenaikAnekasvabhAvakAryanirvarttanapaTavaH pramANaviSayatayA paramArthasanta iti tadvAdaH samyagvAda iti sthitam / / 164 / / -: nayopadeze : gA. 124 tathA ca sakalanayadRSTyA muddrapaMktayAdidRSTAntena siddhAntasiddhA paJcakAraNI sarvatra saGgatimaGgati, tatpakSasya sarvanayamatvena samyagrUpatvAt, ekakAraNaparizeSapakSasya ca durnayatvena mithyArUpatvAt, tadAhurAcAryAH- [sammatau ] "kAlo sahAva NiyaI puvvakayaM purisakAraNegantA / micchataM te ceva 'u samAsao hunti sammattaM / / 3 / 53 / / " -: zAstravArttAsamuccaye :syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAM sta. 7, gA. 52 atra prasaGgAd vArttAntaramAha kAlAdInAM ca kartRtvaM manyante'nye pravAdinaH / kevalAnAM tadanye tu mithaH sAmagrayapekSayA / / 52 / / anye pravAdinaH ekAntavAdinaH, kAlAdInAm, AdinA svabhAvAdigrahaH, kevalAnAM parakRptaheturahitAnAm, kartRtvam asAdhAraNatvena hetutvam, manyante / tadanye tu anekAntavAdinaH sAmagryapekSayA sAmagrIpraviSTatvena, mithaH parasparam, sahakArilakSaNaM kartRtvaM 'manyante' iti prAktanAnuSaGgaH / idamevA'bhihitaM sammatikAreNa 1. ceva ( saMmati ) / 2010_02

Page #262
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-53 217 "kAlo sahAva-Niyai puvvakayaM purisakAraNegaMtA / micchataM te ceva u samAsao huM ti sammattaM / / 150 / / iti / / 52 / / -: sUtrakRtAGgasUtraTIkAyAm : a. 12 nanu ca kathaM kAlAdInAM pratyekaM nirapekSANAM mithyAtvasvabhAvatve sati samuditAnAM samyaktvasadbhAvaH ?, na hi yatpratyekaM nAsti tatsamudAye'pi bhavitumarhati, sikatAtailavat, naitadasti, pratyekaM padmarAgAdimaNiSvavidyamAnApi ratnAvalI samudAye bhavantI dRSTA, na ca dRSTe'nupapannaM nAmeti yatkiJcidetat, tathA coktam "kAlo sahAva NiyaI puvvakayaM purisa kAraNegaMtA / micchattaM te ceva u samAsao hoti saMmattaM / / 3/53 / / savvevi ya kAlAI iha samudAyeNa sAhagA bhaNiyA / jujaMti ya emeva ya sammaM savvassa kajjassa / / 2 / / na hi kAlAdIhiMto kevalaehiM tu jAyae kiMci / iha muggaraMdhaNAdivi tA savve samuditA heU / / 3 / / jaha NegalakkhaNaguNA veruliyAdI maNI visaMjuttA / rayaNAvalivavaesaM Na lahaMti mahagghamullAvi / / 4 / / taha NiyayavAdasuviNicchiyAvi aNNoNNapakkhaniravekkhA / sammaiMsaNasadaM savve'vi NayA Na pAviti / / 1/23 / / jaha puNa te ceva maNI jahA guNavisesabhAgapaDibaddhA / rayaNAvalitti bhaNNai cayaMti pADikkasaNNAo / / 1/24 / / taha savve NayavAyA jahANurUvaviNiuttavattavvA / sammaiMsaNasaI labhaMti Na visesasaNNAo / / 1/25 / / tamhA micchaTThiI savvevi NayA sapakkhapaDibaddhA / aNNoNNanissiyA puNa havaMti sammattasabbhAvA / / 1/21 / / " 1. ceva (saMmati.) 2010_02

Page #263
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 3, gAthA - 54 [ AtmanyekAntarUpasya nAstitvAdivAdaSaTkasya mithyArUpatvakathanam ] yathaite kAlAdyekAntA mithyAtvamanubhavanti syAdvAdopagrahAt tu ta eva samyaktvaM pratipadyante tathA AtmA'pi ekAntanityA'nityatvAdidharmAdhyAsito mithyAtvam anekAntarUpatayA tu abhyupagamyamAnaH samyaktvaM pratipadyata ityAha 218 Natthi Na No Na kuNai kayaM Na veei Natthi NivvANaM / Natthi ya mokkhovAo chammicchattassa ThANAI / / 54 / / nAsti AtmA ekAntata iti bRhaspatimatAnusArI / asti AtmA kintu pratikSaNavizarArutayA cittasaMtaterna nitya iti bauddhAH / asti AtmA nityo bhoktA na tu karoti iti sAMkhyAH ta eva prAhuH kartA asau na bhoktA prakRtivat karturbhoktRtvAnupapatteH / yadvA yena kRtaM karma nAsau tad bhukte kSaNikatvAd cittasaMtateH iti bauddhAH kSaNikatvAt cittasaMtateH kRtaM na vedayate iti bauddha eva Aha / kartA bhoktA ca AtmA kintu na mucyate'sau cetanatvAt abhavyavat-rAgAdInAmAtmasvarUpA'vyatirekAt tadakSaye teSAmapi akSayAt iti yAjJikaH nirhetuka evAsau mucyate tatsvabhAvatAvyatirekeNa aparasya tatra upAyasya abhAvAt ii maNDalI prAha / etAni SaD mithyAtvasya sthAnAni SaNNAmapyeSAM pakSANAM mithyAtvAdhAratayA vyavasthiteH / tathAhi - etAni nAstitvAdivizeSaNAni sAdhyadharmivizeSaNatayA upAdIyamAnAni kiM pratipakSavyudAsena upAdIyante, Ahosvit kathaMcit tatsaMgraheNa iti kalpanAdvayam / prathamapakSe adhyakSavirodhaH svasaMvedanAdhyakSataSTautanyasya AtmarUpasya pratIteH kathaMcit tasya pariNAmanityatApratIteSTA zarIrAdivyApArataH kartRtvopalabdheSTA svavyApAranirvirtitabhaktasUpAdibhoktRsaMvedanAcca pudgalakSaNavilakSaNatayA rAgAdiviviktatayA ca zamasukharasAvasthAyAM kathaMcit tasya upalabdheTA svotkarSataratamAdibhAvato rAgAdyapacayataratamabhAvavidhAyisamyagjJAnadarzanAderupalambhAcca / anumAnato'pi virodhaH tathAbhUtajJAnakAryAnyathAnupapattitaH caitanyalakSaNasya AtmanaH siddhiH ghaTAdivad rUpAdiguNataH jJAnasvarUpaguNopalambhAt kathaMcit tadabhinnasya AtmalakSaNasya guNinaH siddhiriti kathaM nAnumAnavirodhaH ? itaradharmanirapekSa 2010_02

Page #264
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-54 219 dharmalakSaNasya vizeSaNasya tadAdhArabhUtasya ca vizeSyasya aprasiddheH aprasiddhavizeSaNavizeSyobhayadoSairduSTapTA pakSaH / 'AtmA' iti vacanena tatsattAbhidhAnam 'nAsti' ityanena ca tatpratiSedhAbhidhAnamiti padayoH pratijJAvAkye vyAghAtaH lokavirodhaSTA tathAbhUtavizeSaNaviziSTatayA dharmiNo lokena vyavahriyamANatvAt svavacanavirodhaSTA tatpratipAdakavacanasya itaradharmasApekSatayA pravRtteH / heturapi itaranirapekSaikadharmarUpo'siddhaH tathAbhUtasya tasya kvacid anupalabdheH sarvatra tadviparIta eva bhAvAd viruddhaSTA / dRSTAntapTA sAdhyasAdhanadharmavikala: tathAbhUtasAdhyasAdhanadharmAdhikaraNatayA kasyacid dharmiNaH aprasiddheH / tanna prathamaH pakSaH / nApi dvitIyaH svAbhyupagamavirodhaprasaGgAt sAdhanavaiphalyApatteSTA tathAbhUtasya anekAntarUpatayA asmAbhirapyabhyupagamAt / tasmAd vyavasthitametad ekAntarUpatayA SaDapi etAni mithyAtvasya sthAnAni / / 54 / / -: dharmaparIkSA :nanvabhavyAnAmantastattvazUnyAnAmanAbhogaH sArvadiko bhavatu, AbhigrahikaM tu kathaM syAd ? iti bhrAntasyAzaGkAmapAkartumAbhigrahikabhedAnupadarzayati Natthi Na NiJco Na kuNai kayaM Na veNai Natthi NivvANaM / Natthi ya mokkhovAo Abhiggahiassa cha viappA / / 9 / / . Nitthitti / nAstyevAtmA, na nitya AtmA, na kartA, kRtaM na vedayati, nAsti nirvANama, nAsti mokSopAya ityAbhigrahikasya cArvAkAdidarzanapravartakasya parapakSanirAkaraNapravRttadravyAnuyogasArasammatyAdi granthaprasiddhAH SaDvikalpAH, te ca sadA nAstikyamayAnAmabhavyAnAM vyaktA eveti kasteSAmAbhigrahikasattve saMzaya iti bhAvaH / -: guratattvavinizcaye : u. 4, gA. 2 dasacaudasavihabajjhabbhaMtaragaMthA u je muNI mukkA / te NiggaMthA tesiM, paMcaNha parUvaNaM vucchaM / / 2 / / mithyAtvaM-nAsti 1 na nityaH 2 na karoti 3 kRtaM na vedayati 4 nAsti nirvANaM 5 nAsti nirvANopAyaH 6 iti SaDbhiH sthAnaistattvArthAzraddhAnam, yadAha sammatikAraH "Natthi Na Nio Na kuNai, kayaM Na veei Natthi NevvANaM / Natthi ya mokkhovAo, cha mmicchattassa ThANAiM / / 1 / / " 2010_02

Page #265
220 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-55 [ AtmanyekAntarUpasyAstitvAdivAdaSaTkasya mithyArUpatvakathanam ] na kevalaM 'nAsti' ityAdiSaNmithyAtvasthAnAni tadviparyayeNApi ekAntavAde tathaiva tAnIti darzayannAha atthi aviNAsadhammI karei veei asthi NivvANaM / atthi ya mokkhovAo chammicchattassa ThANAiM / / 55 / / 'Asti AtmA' iti pakSaH pUraNAdervAdinaH / 'sa ca avinAzadharmI' ityeSA pratijJA kapilamatAnusAriNaH / 'kartR-bhoktRsvabhAvo'sau' iti mataM jaimineH / 'tathAbhUta evAsau jaDasvarUpaH' iti akSapAdakaNabhugmatAnusAriNaH / 'asti nirvANam' 'asti ca mokSopAyaH' ityAmananti nAstika-yAjJikavyatiriktAH pASaNDinaH / ete ca abhyupagamA ekAntAbhyupagamatvAd mithyAsthAnAni, eSvapi pUrvavad vikalpadvaye'pi taddoSAnatikrAnteH ekAntena tadastitvAderadhyakSA'numAnAbhyAmapratIteH tathAbhyupagame ca svAstitvenevAnyabhAvAstitvena tasya bhAvAt sarvabhAvasaMkIrNatAprasakteH svasvarUpA'vyavasthiteH khapuSpavad asattvameva syAt ityAdidUSaNamasakRt pratipAditam / hetu-dRSTAntadoSASTA pUrvavad atrApi vAcyAH / caturthapAdaM tu gAthAyAH kecid anyathA paThanti-"chassammattassa ThANAI" ti / atra tu pAThe itaradharmA'jahadvRttyA pravartamAnA ete SaT pakSAH samyaktvasya AdhAratAM pratipadyante iti vyAkhyeyam / na ca syAdasti AtmA' 'syAnnityaH' ityAdipratijJAvAkyam adhyakSAdinA pramANena bAdhyate sva-parabhAvAbhAvobhayAtmakabhAvAvabhAsakAdhyakSAdipramANavyatirekeNa anyathAbhUtasya adhyakSAderapratIteH tena anumAnA'bhyupagama-svavacana-lokavyavahAravirodho'pi na pratijJAyAH adhyakSAdipramANAvaseye sadasattAtmake vastuni kasyacid virodhasyAsaMbhavAt / na cAprasiddhavizeSaNaH pakSaH laukika-parIkSakaistathAbhUtavizeSaNasyAvipratipattyA sarvatra pratIteH anyathA vizeSaNavyavahArasya ucchedaprasaGgAt anyathAbhUtasya tasya kacidapi asaMbhavAt tathAbhUtavizeSaNAtmakasya dharmiNaH sarvatra pratIte prasiddhavizeSyatAdoSaH / nApi aprasiddhobhayatA dUSaNam tathAbhUtadvayavyatirekeNAnyasyAsattvataH pramANAviSayatvAt / heturapi nA'prasiddhaH tatra tasya sattvapratIteH, vipakSe sattvAsaMbhavAd nApi viruddhaH anaikAntikatA'pi ata evAyuktA / 2010_02

Page #266
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-55-56 221 dRSTAntadoSA api sAdhyAdivikalatvAdayo nAtra saMbhavinaH asiddhatvAdidoSavatyeva sAdhane teSAM bhAvAt / na ca anumAnataH anekAntAtmakaM vastu tadvAdibhiH pratIyate adhyakSasiddhatvAt yastu pratipanne'pi tatastasmin vipratipadyate taM prati tatprasiddhenaiva nyAyena anumAnopanyAsena vipratipattinirAkaraNamAtrameva vidhIyate iti na aprasiddhavizeSaNatvAderdoSasyAvakAzaH / pratipakSapariNAmaparabhAgAdInAM tu uttaravikArA'rvAgbhAgadarzanAnyathAnupapattyA anumAne na adhyakSAdibAdhA asmadAdyadhyakSasya sarvAtmanA vastugrahaNA'sAmarthyAt sphaTikAdau ca arvAgbhAgaparabhAgayoradhyakSata evaikadA pratipatteH / na ca sthairyagrAhyadhyakSaM pratikSaNapariNAmAnumAnena virudhyate asya tadanugrAhakatvAt kathaMcit pratikSaNapariNAmasya tatpratItasyaiva anumAnato'pi niSTAyAt / / 55 / / [ekAntavAdinaH sAdharmyaNa vA vaidhahNa vaikAntadharmayuktadharmisAdhanAzaktatvAbhidhAnam] anekAntavyavacchedena ekAntAvadhAritadharmAdhikaraNatvena dharmiNaM sAdhayannekAntavAdI na sAdharmyataH sAdhayituM prabhuH nApi vaidharmyataH iti pratipAdayannAha sAhammau vva atthaM sAhejja paro vihammao vA vi / aNNoNNaM paDikuTThA doNNavi ee asavvAyA / / 56 / / samAnastulyaH sAdhyasAmAnyAnvitaH sAdhanadharmo yasya asau sadharmA sAdharmyadRSTAntApekSayA sAdhyadharmI tasya bhAvaH sAdharmyam tato vA artha sAdhyadharmAdhikaraNatayA dharmiNaM sAdhayet paraH anvayihetupradarzanAt sAdhyadharmiNi vivakSitaM sAdhyaM yadi vaizeSikAdiH sAdhayet tadA tatputratvAderapi gamakatvaM syAt, anvayamAtrasya tatrApi bhAvAt / atha vaidhAd vigatastathAbhUtaH sAdhanadharmo yasmAd asau vidharmA tasya bhAvo vaidharmyam tato vA vyatirekiNo hetoH prakRtaM sAdhyaM sAdhayed ubhAbhyAM vA 'vA'zabdasya samuccayArthatvAt-tathApi tatputratvAdereva gamakatvaprasaktiH zyAmatvAbhAve tatputratvAderanyatra gaurapuruSe'bhAvAd ubhAbhyAmapi tatsAdhane ata eva sAdhyasiddhiprasaktiH syAt / [S.T.P. 719] 1. do vi a (syA. kalpa.) / 2010_02

Page #267
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA - 56-57 kiJca, ekAntavAdyupanyastahetoH kiM sAmAnyaM sAdhyam, Ahosvid vizeSaH uta ubhayaM parasparaviviktam, utasvid anubhayamiti vikalpAH / tatra na tAvat sAmAnyam kevalasya tasya asaMbhavAt arthakriyAkAritvavikalatvAcca / nApi vizeSaH tasya ananuyAyitvena sAdhayitumazakyatvAt / nApi ubhayam ubhayadoSAnativRtteH / nApi anubhayam tasya asato hetvavyApakatvena sAdhyatvAyogAt / etadeva Aha gAthApaSTArthena - anyonyapratikruSTau pratikSiptau dvAvapi etau sAmAnya- vizeSaikAntau asadvAdAviti / itara vinirmuktasya ekasya zazazRGgAderiva sAdhayitumazakyatvAt / / 56 / / [S.T.P. 725] 222 -: zAstravArttAsamuccaye : : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAM sta. 7, gA. 24 kiJca, paraH sAdhyaM sAdhayan na tAvat sAmAnyaM sAdhayet, kevalasya tasyA'saMbhavAt / nApi vizeSam, tasyAnanuyAyitvena sAdhayitumazakyatvAt / na ca sAmAnyoparAgeNa vizeSasyApyanuyAyitvam, samavAyaniSedhena taduparAgA'siddheH 'parvato jAtimadvAn' ityAdAvatiprasaGgAcca / nApyubhayam, ubhayadoSA'nativRtteH / nApyanubhayam, tasyA'sattvAt ityAdyUhyam / tadidamuktam- [sammatau] "sAhammao vva atthaM sAhijja paro vihammao vA vi / annonnaM paDikuTTA do va a ee asavvAyA " / / 3 / 56 / / iti / [ parasparabhinnaM sAmAnya-vizeSayoH svarUpamanUdya tasya nirAkaraNam ] sAmAnya-vizeSayoH svarUpaM parasparaviviktamanUdya nirAkurvan AhadavvaTThiyavattavvaM sAmaNNaM pajjavassa ya viseso / ee samovaNIA vibhajjavAyaM viseseMti / / 57 / / dravyAstikasya vaktavyaM vAcyam vizeSanirapekSaM sAmAnyamAtram, paryAyAstikasya punaH anusyUtAkAravivikto vizeSa eva vAcyaH etau ca sAmAnyavizeSau anyonyanirapekSau ekaikarUpatayA parasparaprAdhAnyena vA ekatra upanItau pradarzitau vibhajyavAdam anekAntavAdaM satyavAdasvarUpam atizayAte asatyarUpatayA tatastau atizayaM labhete iti yAvat-vizeSe sAdhye 1. doNNavi (saMmati ) / 2010_02

Page #268
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-57-58 223 anugamAbhAvataH, sAmAnye sAdhye siddhasAdhanatayA sAdhanavaiphalyataH, pradhAnobhayarUpe sAdhye ubhayadoSApattitaH, anubhayarUpe sAdhye ubhayAbhAvataH sAdhyatvAyogAt / tasmAd vivAdAspadIbhUtasAmAnyavizeSobhayAtmakasAdhyadharmAdhArasAdhyadharmiNi anyonyAnuviddhasAdharmyavaidharmyasvabhAvadvayAtmakaikahetupradarzanato naikAntavAdapakSoktadoSAvakAzaH saMbhavI, ata eva gAthApaTAArdhena-etau sAmAnya-vizeSau samupanItau parasparasavyapekSatayA 'syAt'padaprayogato dharmiNi avasthApitau vibhajyavAdam ekAntavAdam vizeSayato nirAkurutaH evameva tayorAtmalAbhAt anyathA anumAnaviSayasya uktanyAyataH asattvAt ityapi darzayati / / 57 / / -: zAstravArtAsamuccaye : syAdvAdakalpalatATIkAyAM sta.7, gA.24 anekAnte tu na sAdhyasiddhiranupapannA, kathaJcid vahnimattAyAH sAdhyatvena 'parvato dravyavAn' ityAdAvanatiprasaGgAt, vahnimattAyA dravyavattAsAmAnyakroDIkRtatve'pi kathaJcidatirekAt, vivAdAspadIbhUtasAmAnya-vizeSobhayAtmakasAdhyadharmAdhArasAdhyadharmisiddheSTA; anyathA 'parvatasAmAnyaM vahnimattayA'numinomi' 'imaM parvataM vahnimattayA'numinomi' ityAdi vibhajyAdhyavasAyAkArAnupapatteH, itaratra saMzayA'nivRttiprasaGgAJca / ityanyatra vistaraH / tadidamAha - [sammatau] "davvaTThiavattavyaM sAmaNNaM pajavassa ya viseso / ee samovaNIyA vibhajavAyaM visesaMti / / 3/57 / / iti / tadevaM 'syAdvAdino na kvacidapi niSTAyo yujyate' iti pUrvapakSiNoktaM nirAkRtam / / 24 / / _[ anekAntarUpatayA vastu sAdhayato vAdino'jeyatvAbhidhAnam ] yatra anumAnaviSayatayA abhyupagamyamAne sAdhye dUSaNavAdinaH avakAza eva na bhavati tadeva sAdhyaM hetuviSayatayA abhyupagantavyamiti darzayannAha heuvisaovaNIyaM jaha vayaNijjaM paro niyattei / jai taM tahA purillo dAiMto keNa jivvaMto / / 58 / / hetuviSayatayA upanItam upadarzitaM sAdhyadharmilakSaNaM vastu pUrvapakSavAdinA 'anityaH zabdaH' ityevaM yathA vacanIyaM paro dUSaNavAdI nivartayati siddhasAdhyatA'nanugamadoSAdhupanyAsena 2010_02

Page #269
224 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-58-59-60 ekAntavacanIyasya taditaradharmAnanuSaktasya anekadoSaduSTatayA nivartayituM zakyatvAt / yadi tat tathA dvitIyadharmAkrAntaM syAt' zabdayojanena purillaH pUrvapakSavAdI adarzayiSyata tato'sau naika kenacid ajeSyata / jitapTAsau tathAbhUtasya sAdhyadharmiNo'pradarzanAt pradarzitasya ca ekAntarUpasya asattvAt tatpradarzako'satyavAditayA nigrahArha iti / / 58 / / [ ekAntAniSTiAtarUpAbhyAM vastu vadato lokakaparIkSakAgrAhyAvacanatvakathanam ] etadeva darzayannAha eyantA'sabbhUyaM sabbhUyamaNicchiyaM ca vayamANo / loiya-paricchiyANaM vayaNijjapahe paDai vAdI / / 59 / / AstAM tAvad ekAntena asadbhUtam asatyam, sadbhUtamapi aniSTiAtaM vadan vAdI laukikAnAm parIkSakANAM ca vacanIyamArga patati / / 59 / / [ nirdoSabhAvaprarUpaNAyA mArgaprakAzanam ] sa eva ca sanmArgaH iti upasaMharannAha davvaM khittaM kAlaM bhAvaM pajjAya-desa-saMjoge / bhedaM ca paDuJca samA bhAvANaM paNNavaNapajjA / / 60 / / dravya-kSetra-kAla-bhAva-paryAya-deza-saMyogAn bhedaM cetyaSTau bhAvAn Azritya vastuno bhede sati samA sarvavastuviSayAyAH prajJApanAyAH syAdvAdarUpAyAH paryA panthA mArga iti yAvat / tatra dravyaM pRthivyAdi, kSetraM svArambhakAvayavasvarUpaM tadAzrayaM vA AkAzam, kAlaM yugapadayugapaJcirakSiprapratyayaliGgalakSaNaM vartanAtmakaM vA nava-purANAdilakSaNam, bhAvaM mUlAGkurAdilakSaNam, paryAyaM rUpAdisvabhAvam, dezaM mUlAGkurapatrakANDAdikramabhAvivibhAgam, saMyogaM bhUmyAdipratyekasamudAyaM dravya-paryAyalakSaNam, bhedaM pratikSaNavivartAtmakaM vA jIvAjIvAdibhAvAnAM pratItya samAnatayA tadatadAtmakatvena prajJApanA nirUpaNA yA sA satpatha iti na hi tadatadAtmakaikadravyatvAdibhedAbhAve kharaviSANAderjIvAdidravyasya vizeSaH yato na dravya-kSetra-kAla-bhAvaparyAya-deza-saMyoga-bhedarahitaM vastu kenacit pratyakSAdyanyatamapramANena avagantuM zakyam / / 60 / / 2010_02

Page #270
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-61-62 225 [ vivecanavikalAmAgamasya pratipattimAzrayatAM tattvAnabhijJatvakhyApanam ] ye tu avivecitAgamapratipattimAtramAzrayante te anavagataparamArthA eva iti pratipAdayannAha pADekkanayapahagayaM suttaM suttaharasaddasaMtuTThA / / avikoviyasAmatthA jahAgamavibhattapaDivattI // 61 / / pratyekanayamArgagataM sUtram-"kSaNikAH sarvasaMskArAH vijJAnamAtramevedaM bho jinaputrAH / yad idaM traidhAtukam" [ ] iti, "grAhyagrAhakobhayazUnyaM tattvam" iti, "nityamekamaNDavyApi niSkriyam" [ ] ityAdi, "sadakAraNavad nityam" [vaizeSikada0 4-1-1] iti, "AtmA re zrotavyo jJAtavyo mantavyo nididhyAsitavyaH" [bRhadA0 u0 2-4-5] ityAdi, "sattA-dravyatvasaMbandhAt sadravyaM vastu" [ ] iti, "paralokino'bhAvAt paralokAbhAvaH" [ ] "codanAlakSaNo'rtho dharmaH" [mImAMsAda0 1-1-2] iti, "dharmAdharmakSayaMkarI dIkSA" [ ] ityAdikamadhItya sUtradharA vayam' iti zabdamAtrasaMtuSTA garvavantaH avikovidasAmarthyAH avikovidam ajJaM sAmarthya yeSAM te tathA'viditasUtravyApAraviSayA iti yAvat / kimityevaM te ? ityAha- yathAzrutameva avibhaktA avivekena pratipattireSAmiti kRtvA sUtrAbhiprAyavyatiriktaviSayavipratipattitvAt itarajanavad ajJA ityabhiprAyaH / athavA svayUthyA eva ekanayadarzanena katicit sUtrANi adhItya kecit 'sUtradharA vayam' iti garvitA yathAvasthitAnyanayasavyapekSasUtrArthAparijJAnAd aviditAtmavidvatsvarUpA iti gAthAbhiprAyaH / / 61 / / [ nirapekSakanayapravRttAnAM doSodbhAvanam ] atha eSAmekanayadarzanena pravRttAnAM yo doSastamudbhAvayitumAha sammaiMsaNamiNamo sayalasamattavayaNijjaNiddosaM / attukkosaviNaTThA salAhamANA viNAseMti / / 62 / / samyagdarzanametat parasparaviSayA'parityAgapravRttAnekanayAtmakam taJca 'syAnnityaH' ityAdi sakaladharmaparisamAptavacanIyatayA nirdoSam, ekanayavAdinastvaviSaye sUtravyavasthApanena AtmotkarSeNa vinaSTAH syAdvAdAbhigamaM prati anAdriyamANA 'vayaM sUtradharAH' ityAtmAnaM zlAghamAnAH samyagdarzanaM vinAzayanti tadAtmani na vyavasthApayantIti yAvat / / 62 / / 2010_02

Page #271
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-63 [ na zAsanabhaktimAtreNa nApyAMzikajJAnamAtreNAnekAntaprarUpaNAkuzala iti kathanam ] atha na te AgamapratyanIkAH tadbhaktatvAt taddezaparijJAnavantaSToti kathaM tad vinAzayantIti ? atrAha 226 hu sAsaNabhattIttaeNa siddhaMtajANao hoi / Na vijANao vi NiyamA paNNavaNANicchio NAmaM / / 63 // na ca zAsanabhaktimAtreNaiva siddhAntajJAtA bhavati na ca tadajJAnavAn bhAvasamyaktvavAn bhavati ajJAtasya arthasya viziSTaruciviSayatvAnupapattestadbhaktimAtreNa zraddhAnusAritayA dravyasamyaktvam / mArgAnusAryavabodhamAtrAnuSaktarucisvabhAvaM tu sadapi na bhAvasamyaktvasAdhyaphalanirvartakam bhAvasamyaktvanimittatvenaiva tasya dravyasamyaktvarUpatvopapatteH / na ca jIvAditattvaikadezajJAtA'pi niyamato'nekAntAtmakavastusvarUpaprajJApanAyAM niSTizato bhavati ekadezajJAnavataH sakaladharmAtmakavastujJAnavikalatayA samyak tatprarUpaNA'saMbhavAt / tathAhisarvajJo yathAvasthitaikadezajJo jIvAdisakalatattvajJatA tu AgamavidaH sAmAnyarUpatayA abhidhIyate "mati zrutayornibandho dravyeSvasarvaparyAyeSu " [ tattvArtha0 1 27] iti vacanAt / [S.T.P. 732] tadevamekAntavAdiprakalpitasya pramANa- prameyAdeH sarvasya aghaTamAnatvAt tacchAsanaM dRSTavat adRSTArthe'pi visaMvAditvAd apramANam / tatpratipakSabhUtaM ca yathoktajIvAditattvaprakAzakaM sarvatra dRSTArthe avyabhicAritvAt adRSTArthe'pi sahetuke heyopAdeyasvarUpe bandha-mokSalakSaNe vastutattve pramANamiti sthitam / ataH pUrvAparaikavAkyatayA sakalAnantadharmAtmakajIvAditattvapratipAdakasUtrasaMdarbhasya naya- pramANadvAreNa pravRttasya tAtparyArthajJAtA siddhAntajJAtA na punaraparihRtavirodhatadekadezajJAtA / na caikadezajJaH syAdvAdaprarUpaNAyAH samyak samartha iti vyavasthitam / / 63 / / [S.T.P. 745] 2010_02

Page #272
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 3, gAthA - 64-65 [ arthavazAt sUtrasya niSpattirna tu nirapekSasUtramAtreNArthasyeti kathanam ] sUtrasya sUcanArthatvAt arthavazAt tasya niSpattiH na punaH sUtramAtreNaiva anyanirapekSeNa arthaniSpattiH ityAha suttaM atthanimeNaM na suttametteNa atthapaDivattI / atthagaI uNa NayavAyagahaNalINA durabhigammA / / 64 / / anekArtharAzisUcanAt sUte vA asmAd artharAziH zete vA asmin arthasamUhaH zrUyate vA asmAd aneko'rtha iti niruktavazAt sUtram / aryata iti arthaH sAkSAt tasyAbhidheyaH gamyaSTA sAmarthyAt tasya sthAnameva sUtram yathArthaM sUtrArthavyavasthApanAt sUtrAntaranirapekSasya tasya arthavyavasthApane pramANAntarabAdhayA tadarthasya tatsUtrasya unmattakavAkyavat asUtratvApatteH / ata eva niryuktyAdyapekSatvAt sUtrArthasya na sUtramAtreNaiva arthasya paurvAparyeNa aviruddhasya pratipattiH ayathArthatayA'pi avivRtasya tasya zruteH / arthasya tu yathAvyavasthitasya gatiH pratipattiH punardravyArtha-paryAyArthalakSaNanayavAdAveva gahanaM vipinam tatra lInA tathA ca duradhigamyA duravabodhA sakalanayasammatArthasya pratipAdakaM sUtram - " jIvo aNAiNihaNo" [ ] ityAdivAkyavad na pramANArthasUcakaM syAt pravRttAni ca nayavAdena sUtrANi / tathA ca AgamaH " Natthi eNa vihUNaM suttaM attho ya jiNamae kiJci / Asajja u soAraM gae NaavisArao bUA " / / [ adhItasUtrasyArthasaMpAdane prayatnAbhAve zAsanaviDambakatvakathanam ] [Avazyakani0 uvagghAyani0 gA0 38 ] iti / / 64 / / yata evam anekAntAtmakArthapratipAdakatvena sUtraM vyAkhyeyam tamhA ahigayasutteNa atthasaMpAyaNammi jaiyavvaM / AyariyadhIrahatthA haMdi mahANaM vilaMbenti / / 65 / / 227 2010_02 tasmAt iti pUrvoktArthapratyavamarzArthaH adhigatam adhItam azeSaM sUtraM yena asau tathA adhItatkAlavyAvahArikAzeSasiddhAntena iti yAvat arthasaMpAdane tadviSayapramANa-naya

Page #273
228 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-65-66 svarUpAvadhAraNe yatitavyam / adhItya sUtraM zrotavyam zrutvA nayasarvasaMvAdaviniSTAyaparizuddha bhAvanIyam anyathA AcAryA dhIrahastA azikSitazAstrArthA anabhyastakarmA'pi karmaNi dhRSTatayA vyApriyate yeSAM hastaste dhIrahastA AcAryApTA te azikSitadhRSTApTA iti yAvat haMdi gRhyatAm te tAdRzA mahAjJAm AptazAsanaM vigopayanti viDambayanti iti yAvat ||S.T.P.746] evamanyadapi AgamabAhyaM svamanISikayA paraparikalpitamAgama-yuktipradarzanena pratiSeddhavyam nyAyadizaH pradarzitatvAt / tadevam anadhItA'zrutayathAvadaparibhAvitAgamatAtparyA digvAsasa iva AptAjJAM vigopayantIti vyavasthitam / / 65 / / [S.T.P.755] [bahuzrutatvAdidarpAt tAtparyAparijJAnAcAniSTiAtazAstrArthasya siddhAntapratyanIkatvakathanam] yata evaM tataH jaha jaha bahussuo saMmao ya sissagaNasaMparivuDo ya / aviNicchio ya samae taha taha siddhatapaDiNIo / / 66 / / yathA yathA bahuzrutaH samyagaparibhAvitArthAnekazAstrazravaNamAtrataH tathAvidhA'parA'viditazAstrAbhiprAyajanasaMmataSTA zAstrajJatvena ata eva zrutavizeSAnabhijJaiH ziSyagaNeH samaMtAt parivRtaSTA aviniSTiAtaSTA samaye tathAvidhaparivAradAt samayaparyAlocane'nAdRtatvAt tathA tathA siddhAntapratyanIkaH yathAvasthitavastusvarUpaprakAzakArhadAgamapratipakSaH nissAraprarUpaNayA anyAgamebhyo'pi bhagavadAgamamadhaH karotIti yAvat / / 66 / / -: paJcavastukaprakaraNam :jaha jaha bahussuo sammao ya sIsagaNasaMparivuDo a / aviNicchio ya samae, taha taha siddhaMtapaDiNIo / / 947 / / yathA yathA bahuzrutaH zravaNamAtreNa sammataSTA tathAvidhalokasya ziSyagaNasamparivRtaSTA kimityAhabahumUDhaparivArapTA, amUDhAnAM tathAvidhaparigrahaNAd, aviniSTiAtaTA ajJAtatattvaSTA samaye siddhAnte tathA tathA 'sau vastusthityA siddhAntapratyanIkaH siddhAntavinAzakaH, tallAghavApAdanAditi gAthArthaH / / 947 / / 2010_02

Page #274
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-66 229 -: upadezamAlA : heyopAdeyATIkA adhunA gauravadvAraM vyAcikhyAsustAvad gauravavataH svarUpamAha - jaha jaha bahussuo sammao ya sIsagaNasaMparivuDo ya / aviNicchio ya samae, taha taha siddhaMtapaDiNIo / / 322 / / jaha jaha bahussuo0 gAhA / yathA yathA bahuzrutaH zravaNamAtreNa, sammatapTA tathAvidhalokasya, ziSyagaNasaMparivRtapTA bahumUDhaparivArapTA, mUDhAnAM tathAvidhaparigrahaNAd, aviniSTiAtaTAjJAtatattvaSTA samaye siddhAnte, jJAtatattvasya RddhirasasAtagauraveSu pratibandhAbhAvAt, tadvataH paramArthato jJAnazUnyatvAt, tathA tathA'sau vastusthityA siddhAntapratyanIkaH siddhAntavinAzakastallAghavApAdanAditi / / 322 / / -: upadezarahasya :jaha jaha bahussuo saMmao a sIsagaNasaMparivuDo a / aviNicchio a samae taha taha siddhaMtapaDiNIo / / 153 / / [3/66 samma0] yathA yathA bahuzrutaH paripaThitabahAgamaH, saMmataSTA bahumataH saMsArAbhinandinAM gatAnugatikapravAhapatitAnAM tadanuvartinAM cAnyeSAM bAhyADambaradarzanamAtroditavismayAnAM mugdhamatInAM ca, ca punaH ziSyagaNairvineyavRndaiH saMparivRtaH samantAt parivRtaH, aviniSTiAtaH samyagapariNataSTA pravacane, aidamparyAjJAnAdviratyabahvAJca yathAsthitasiddhAntasya viparyAsApAdAnAt, ato nedRzagurvAzrayaNaM yuktaM kintUktaguNavadagurvAzrayaNameva zreya iti bhAvaH / / 153 / / -: gurutattvavinizcaye : u. 2, gA. 76 jaha jaha bahussuo saMmao a sIsagaNasaMparivuDo a / aviNicchio a samae, taha taha siddhaMtapaDiNIo / / 76 / / 'jaha jaha'tti / yathA yathA bahuzrutaH zrutapallavagrAhitayA bahuzrutatvakhyAtimAn, ata eva sammataH bahujanAdRtaH ziSyagaNasaMparivRtaSTA aviniSTiAtaH sAkalyena tAtparyAgrAhI ca samaye siddhAnte tathA tathA siddhAntapratyanIko vRthA''DambareNa bahUnAM mithyAtvotpAdakatvAcchivabhUtyAdivat / / 76 / / 2010_02

Page #275
230 [ kriyApradhAnAnAM jJAnayogamasAdhayatAM kriyAphalAnubhavAbhAvakathanam ] tasmAt zAstramadhItya tadarthAvadhAraNaM vidheyam avadhRtaSTA tadartho naya-pramANAbhiprAyato yathAvat paribhAvanIyaH anyathA tatphalaparijJAnavikalatAprasaktirityAha saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA- 67 I caraNa-karaNappahANA sasamaya-parasamayamukkavAvArA caraNa- karaNassa sAraM NicchayasuddhaM Na yANaMti / / 67 / / caraNaM zramaNadharmaH " 'vaya-samaNadhamma-saMjama veyAvaccaM ca baMbhaguttIo / NANaitiyaM tava-kohaNiggahAI caraNameyaM / / [ oghani0 gA0 2] iti vacanAt / vratAni hiMsAviramaNAdIni paJca, zramaNadharmaH kSAntyAdirdazaghA, saMyamaH paJcAsravaviramaNAdiH saptadazabhedaH, vaiyAvRttyaM dazadhA AcAryArAdhanAdi, brahmaguptayo nava vasatyAdayaH, jJAnAditritayaM jJAna - darzana - cAritrANi, tapo dvAdazadhA anazanAdi, krodhAdikaSAyaSoDazakasya nigrahaSTA iti aSTadhA caraNam / karaNaM piNDavizuddhyAdiH "piMDavisohI samiI bhAvaNa-paDimAi - iMdiyaniroho / paDilehaNa-guttIo abhiggahA ceva karaNaM tu" / / [oghani0 gA0 3] iti vacanAt / tatra piNDavizuddhiH trikoTiparizuddhirAhArasya "saMsaTTamasaMsaTThA udghaDa taha appaleviyA ceva / uggahiyA paggahiyA ujjhiyahammAya sattamiyA" / / iti saptadhA vA, samitiH IryAsamityAdiH paJcadhA, bhAvanA anityatvAdikA dvAdaza, pratimA mAsAdikA dvAdaza bhikSUNAm darzanAdikA ekAdaza upAsakAnAm, indriyanirodhaH cakSurAdikaraNapaJcakasaMyamaH pratilekhanaM mukhavastrikAdyupakaraNapratyupekSaNamanekavidham, guptiH mano-vAkkAyasaMvaraNalakSaNA tridhA, abhigrahA vasatipramArjanAdayo'nekavidhAH- etayoSTAraNa-karaNayoH pradhAnAstadanuSThAnatatparAH svasamaya-parasamayamuktavyApArAH ayaM svasamayaH anekAntAtmakavastuprarUpaNAt ayaM ca parasamayaH kevalanayAbhiprAyapratipAdanAt ityetasmin parijJAne'nAdRtA 2010_02

Page #276
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-67 231 anekAntAtmakavastutattvaM yathAvat anavabuddhyamAnAH taditaravyavacchedena iti yAvat / caraNakaraNayoH sAraM phalam niSTAyazuddhaM niSTAyaTA tat zuddhaM ca jJAna-darzanopayogAtmakaM niSkalaGkam na jAnanti na anubhavanti jJAna-darzana-cAritrAtmakakAraNAprabhavatvAt tasya kAraNAbhAve ca kAryasya asaMbhavAt anyathA tasya nirhetukatvApatteH caraNa-karaNayopTA cAritrAtmakatvAt dravya-paryAyAtmakajIvA-ditattvAvagamasvabhAvarucyabhAve'bhAvAt / athavA caraNa-karaNayoH sAraM niSTAyena zuddhaM samyagdarzanaM te na jAnanti na hi yathAvasthitavastutattvAvabodhamantareNa taciH na ca svasamaya-parasamayatAtparyArthAnavagame tadavabodhaH boTikAderiva saMbhavI / atha jIvAdidravyArtha-paryAyArthAparijJAne'pi yad arhadbhiruktaM tadeva ekaM satyamityetAvataiva samyagdarzanasadbhAvaH "maNNai tameva saJcaM NissaMkaM jaM jiNehiM pannattaM" [ ] ityAdyAgamaprAmANyAt, na; svasamayaparasamayaparamArthAnAbhijJairnirAvaraNajJAna-darzanAtmakajinasvarUpA'jJAnavadbhistadabhihitabhAvAnAM sAmAnyarUpatayA'pi anyavyavacchedena satyasvarUpatvena jJAtumazakyatvAt; nanvevamAgamavirodhaH sAmAyikamAtrapadavido mASatuSAderyathoktacAritriNastatra muktipratipAdanAt sakalazAstrArthajJatAvikalavratasya vratAdyAcaraNanairarthakyApattiSTA tatsAdhyaphalAnavApteH na ca yathopavarNitacaraNa-karaNasamyagdarzanavaiphalyai bhavataH jJAnAditritayasyApi tatra pAThAt / na, ye yathoditacaraNa-karaNaprarUpaNAsevanadvAreNa pradhAnAd AcAryAt svasamayaparasamayamuktavyApArA na bhavantIti naJo'tra saMbandhAt-te caraNa-karaNasya sAraM niSTAyazuddhaM jAnantyeva gurvAjJayA pravRtteH caraNaguNasthitasya sAdhoH sarvanayavizuddhatayA abhyupagamAt "taM savvaNayavisuddhaM jaM caraNaguNaTThio sAhU" [Avazyaka ni0 sAmAiani0 gAthA 102] ityAdyAgamaprAmANyAt agItArthasya tu svatantracaraNa-karaNapravRtteH vratAdyanuSThAnasya vaiphalyamabhyupagamyata eva"gIyattho ya vihAro bIo gIyatthamIsao bhaNio / " [ ] ityAdyAgamaprAmANyAt / / 67 / / 2010_02

Page #277
232 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-67 -: anekAntavyavasthAyAM : anekAntavAdasvarUpavarNane pa.86 "anekAntavyavasthitizraddhaiva bhAvataH samyaktvam" tadvikalAnAmutkRSTacAritrAnuSThAnasyApi tathAvidhaphalAbhAvAt, taduktaM vAdigajakesariNA zrIsiddhasenadivAkaraNa "caraNakaraNappahANA, sasamayaparasamayamukkavAvArA / caraNakaraNassa sAraM, NicchayasuddhaM Na yANaMti / / 3-67 / / " caraNaM zramaNadharmaH "vayasamaNadhammasaMjama-veyAvaJcaM ca baMbhaguttIo / nANAitiyaM tavakohaNiggahAI caraNameyaM / / 1 / / " iti vacanAt / vratAni hiMsAviramaNAdIni paJca, zramaNadharmaH kSAntyAdirdazadhA, saMyamaH paJcAzravaviramaNAdiH saptadezabhedaH, vaiyAvRttyaM dazadhA''cAryArAdhanAdi, brahmaguptayo nava vasatyAdayaH, jJAnAditritayaM jJAnadarzanacAritrANi, tapo dvAdazadhA'nazanAdi, krodhAdikaSAyaSoDazakasya nigrahapTotyaSTadhA caraNam / / karaNaM piNDavizuddhyAdi "piMDavisohI samiI, bhAvaNapaDimA ya iMdiyaniroho / paDilehaNaguttIo, abhiggahA ceva karaNaM tu / / 1 / / " iti vacanAt / tatra piNDavizuddhistrikoTiparizuddhirAhArasya, samitirIryAsamityAdiH paJcadhA, bhAvanA anityatvAdikA dvAdaza, pratimA mAsAdikA dvAdaza bhikSUNAm, darzanAdikA ekAdazopAsakAnAm, indriyanirodhaSTAkSurAdikaraNapaJcakasaMyamaH, pratilekhanaM mukhavatrikAdhupakaraNapratyupekSaNamanekavidham, guptirmanovAkAyasaMvaralakSaNA tridhA, abhigrahA vasatipramArjanAdayo'nekavidhAH / etayopTAraNakaraNayoH pradhAnAstadanuSThAnatatparAH, svasamayaparasamayamuktavyApArAH ayaM svasamayo'nekAntAtmakavastusvarUpaprarUpaNAd, ayaM ca parasamayaH kevalanayAbhiprAyapratipAdanAdityetasmin parijJAne'nAdRtAH, anekAntAtmakavastutattvaM yathAvadanavabudhyamAnAstaditaravyavacchedeneti yAvat, caraNakaraNayoH sAraM phalam, niSTAyazuddhaM niSTAyaTA tacchuddhaM ca jJAnadarzanopayogAtmakam, niSkalaGkaM na jAnanti nAnubhavanti, jJAnadarzanacAritrAtmakakAraNaprabhavatvAttasya, kAraNA'bhAve ca kAryasyAsambhavAt, anyathA tasya nirhetukatvApatteH, karaNacaraNayopTA cAritrAtmakatvAt, dravyaparyAyAtmakajIvAditattvAvagamasvabhAvarucyabhAve'bhAvAt, athavA caraNakaraNayoH sAraM nipTAyena zuddhaM samyagdarzanaM te na jAnanti, na hi _ 2010_02

Page #278
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-67 233 yathAvasthitavastutattvAvabodhamantareNa tadruciH, na ca svasamayaparasamayatAtparyArthAnavagame tadavabodho boTikAderiva sambhavI / -: upadezarahasyam :vibhajyavAdamevAbhiSTauti eso pavayaNasAro savvaM iccatthameva gaNipiDagaM / eaMmi aviNNAe vihalaM caraNaM jao bhaNiyaM / / 102 / / eSaH vibhajyavAdaH pravacanasAraH, etapTodhanenaiva pravacanasya phalavattvAt / "ege AyA" [sthAnAMga 1-1] ityAderapi tantraparikarmitamatyA ekatvAnekatvAdisaptabhaGgIparikarmitabodhasyaivotpatteH, ekanayAvadhAraNe mithyAdRSTivacanA'vizeSaprasaGgAt / na kevalaM pravacanakAryamevAyaM api tu tatkAraNamapItyAha-sarvaM niravazeSam ityarthakameva upadiSTavibhajyavAdArthakameva, gaNipiTakaM dvAdazAGgIrUpam, arthaM hi bhagavAnupadizati sUtraM ca tato gaNadharA grananti, sa ca tripadIrUpaH syAdvAdamUrtiriti siddhaM gaNipiTakasya syAdvAdahetukatvam, yata evaM tataH etasminnavijJAte aparicchinne viphalam asAraM caraNaM cAritram, syAdvAdarucirUpasamyagdarzanazuddhizUnyatvAt / yato bhaNitaM sammatau [3-67] zrIsiddhasenadivAkarapAdaiH / / 102 / / caraNakaraNapappahANA sasamayaparasamayamukkavAvArA / caraNakaraNassa sAraM NicchayasuddhaM Na yANaMti / / 103 / / [3/67] caraNaM "vayasamaNadhamme"tyAdigAthoktasaptatibhedam, karaNamapi "piMDavisohIsamiI"tyAdigAthoktasaptatibhedam, tAbhyAM pradhAnAstatra nairantaryAdaravanta ityarthaH, svasamayaparasamayayormukto'nAdRto vyApAraH syAdvAdaparikarmitadhiyA vivecanAtmA yaiste tathA 'caraNakaraNAnuSThAnenaiva kRtArthA vayam, kimasmAkaM tarkakarkazena vAdarasikaramaNIyena syAdvAdena prayojanami'tyevaM jJAnAbhyAsAd vyAvRttA ityarthaH, caraNakaraNasya caraNakaraNAnuSThAnasya sAraM svajanyaphalotkarSAGgam, niSTAyazuddhaM paramArthadRSTyA'vadAtaM na tu bAhyakriyAvallokadRSTyaivApAtato ramaNIyamityarthaH, na jAnanti na vicArayanti, tadAvaraNakarmadoSAt / evaM ca teSAmalpaphalameva caraNakaraNAnuSThAnamityarthaH / / 103 / / ____ 2010_02

Page #279
234 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-67 -: paJcAstikAyasaGgrahe : gA. 172 atha ye tu kevalavyavahArAvalambinaste khalu bhinnasAdhyasAdhanabhAvAvalokanenA'navarataM nitarAM khidyamAnA muhurmuhurdharmAdizraddhAnarUpAdhyavasAyAnusyUtacetasaH prabhUtazrutasaMskArAdhiropitavicitravikalpajAlakalmASitacaitanyavRttayaH, samastayativRttasamudAyarUpatapaHpravRttirUpakarmakANDoDDamarAcalitAH, kadAcitkiJcidrocamAnAH, kadAcit kiJcidvikalpayantaH, kadAcitkiJcidAcarantaH, darzanAcaraNAya kadAcitprazAmyantaH, kadAcitsaMvijamAnAH, kadAcidanukampamAnAH, kadAcidAstikyamudvahantaH, zaGkAkAGkSAvicikitsAmUDhadRSTitAnAM vyutthApananirodhAya nityabaddhaparikarAH, upabRMhaNasthitikaraNavAtsalyaprabhAvanAM bhAvayamAnA vAraMvAramabhivardhitotsAhA, jJAnAcaraNAya svAdhyAyakAlamavalokayanto, bahudhA vinayaM prapaJcayantaH, pravihitadurdharopadhAnAH, suSThu bahumAnamAtanvanto, nihnavApattiM nitarAM nivArayanto'rthavyaJjanatadubhayazuddhau nitAntasAvadhAnA;, cAritrAcaraNAya hiMsAnRtasteyAbrahmaparigrahasamastaviratirUpeSu paJcamahAvrateSu tanniSThavRttayaH, samyagyoganigrahalakSaNAsu guptiSu nitAntaM gRhItodyogA, IryAbhASaiSaNAdAnanikSepotsargarUpAsu samitiSvatyantanivezitaprayatnAH, tapaAcaraNAyAnazanAvamaudaryavRttiparisaMkhyAnarasaparityAgaviviktazayyAsanakAyaklezeSvabhIkSNamutsahamAnAH, prAyaSTiAttavinayavaiyAvRttyavyutsargasvAdhyAyadhyAnaparikarAMkuzitasvAntA, vIryAcaraNAya karmakANDe sarvazaktyA vyApriyamANAH, karmacetanApradhAnatvAddUranivAritA'zubhakarmapravRttayo'pi samupAttazubhakarmapravRttayaH, sakala kriyAkANDambarottIrNadarzanajJAnacAritraikyapariNatirUpAM jJAnacetanAM manAgapyasaMbhAvayantaH, prabhUtapuNyabhAramantharitacittavRttayaH, sUralokAdiklezaprAptiparamparayA suciraM saMsArasAgare bhramantIti / uktaJca[sammatau] "caraNakaraNappahANA sasamayaparamatthamukkavAvArA / caraNakaraNassa sAraM NicchayasuddhaM Na jANaMti" / / 3/67 / / -: dravyaguNaparyAyano rAsa DhA. 1, . 2 :"vinA dravya-anuyoga-viyA2 y29|-424aano nahIM o sA2." sammati graMthe bhASirDa IsyuM, te to budha-jana-manamAM vasyuM. 2 "dravya-anuyogaviyA vin| 19 22||sittrii-429sittriino sAra 15 na." meDaj -sammati aMthana viSa 36, te to dha4nanamanamADa vasalaM, pa!i mAyaSTinAyitamA na sa yathA ___ 2010_02

Page #280
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-68 235 caraNakaraNappahANA, ssmyprsmymukkvaavaaraa| caraNakaraNassa sAraM, NicchayasuddhaM na jANaMti / / 3/67 / / -: dravyaguNaparyAyano rasa : DhA. 4, gA. 14 saptabhaMga e daDha abhyAsI, je paramAratha dekhAI re. jasa karati jagi vAdhaI tehanI, jaIna bhAva tasa lekhaI re. 54. mRtadharmaI mana daDha karI rAkho, jima zivasukhaphala cAkho re. e-kahiyA je saptabhaMga, te daDha abhyAsa-sakalAdezaH vikalAdeza na saptabhaMgaH pramANasaptabhaMgaH ItyAdi bhedaI ghaNo abhyAsa karI, je paramArtha dekhaI-jIvAjIvAdi paramArtha rahasya samajAI, tehanI yaza kIrti vAdhaI "je mATaI syAdvAdaparijJa naI ja jainanaI tarkavAdano yaza chaI anaI jainabhAva paNi tehano ja lekhaI; je mArTi nizcayathI samyakatva syAdvAdaparijJAneM ja chaI." 54. uktaM ca sammatau caraNakaraNappahANA, sasamayaparasamayamukkavAvArA / caraNakaraNassa sAraM, NicchayasuddhaM Na yANaMti / / 3/67 / / e cothaI DhAlaI bhedabheda dekhADyo, anaI saptabhaMgInuM sthApana kariuM. [ jJAnakriyayoranyataravaikalye mokSaphalavandhyatvakathanam ] atra ca samyagdarzanasya samyagjJAnAdabhedAdajJAna-kriyayoranyataravikalayo zeSakarmakSayalakSaNaphalanirvartakatvaM saMbhavatIti pratipAdayannAha NANaM kiriyArahiyaM kiriyAmettaM ca do vi egaMtA / asamatthA dAeuM jamma-maraNadukkha mA bhAI / / 6 / / jJAyate yathAvad jIvAjIvAditattvamaneneti jJAnam kriyata iti kriyA yathoktAnuSThAnam tayA rahitam 'janma-maraNa-duHkhebhyo mA bhaiSIH' iti darzayituM dAtuM vA asamartham na hi jJAnamAtreNaiva puruSo bhayebhyo mucyate kriyArahitatvAt dRSTapradIpanakapalAyanamArgapaguvat / kriyAmAtraM vA jJAnarahitam na 'tebhyo mA bhaiSIH' iti darzayitum dAtuM vA samartham-na hi kriyAmAtrAt puruSo 2010_02

Page #281
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa - 3, gAthA - 68-69 bhayebhyo mucyate sajjJAnavikalatvAt pradIpanakabhayaprapalAyamAnAndhavat / tathA cAgamaH " hayaM NANaM kiyAhINaM hayA aNNANao kiyA / pAsaMto paMgulo DaDDo dhAvamANo ya aMdhao" / / [Avazyakani0 paDhamAva0 gA0 22] 236 ubhayasadbhAvastu 'tebhyo mA bhaiSIH' iti darzayituM samarthaH / tathAhi - samyagjJAna-kriyAvAn bhayebhyo mucyate ubhayasaMyogavattvAt pradIpanakabhayAndhaskandhArUDhapaGguvat / uktaM ca "saMjogasiddhIe phalaM vayaMti" [Avazyakani0 paDhamAva0 gA0 23] ityAdi / tasmAt samyagjJAnAditritayanayasamUhAd muktiH nayasamUhaviSayaM ca samyagjJAnam zraddhAnaM ca tadviSayaM samyagdarzanam tatpUrvaM ca azeSapApakriyAnivRttilakSaNaM cAritram-pradhAnopasarjanabhAvena mukhyavRttyA vA-tat tritayapradarzakaM ca vAkyamAgamo nAnyaH ekAntapratipAdakasya asadarthatvena visaMvAdakatayA tasya prAdhAnyAnupapatteH jinavacanasya tu tadviparyayeNa dRSTavad adRSTArthe'pi prAmANyasaMgateH / / 68 / / [ anekAntamayatvena jinavacanasya stavanaM pAryantikamaGgalavidhAnaM ca ] tasya tathAbhUtasya stutipratipAdanAya maGgalArthatvAt prakaraNaparisamAptau gAthAsUtramAha bhaddaM micchAdaMsaNasamUhamaiyassa amayasArassa / jiNavayaNassa bhagavao saMviggasuhAhigammassa / / 69 / / bhadraM kalyANam jinavacanasya astu iti saMbandha: mithyAdarzanasamUhamayasya; nanu yad mithyAdarzanasamUhamayaM tat kathaM samyagrUpatAmAsAdayati ? na hi viSakaNikAsamUhamayasya amRtarUpatApattiH prasiddhA, na; parasparanirapekSasaMgrahAdinayarUpApannasAMkhyAdimithyAdarzanAnAM parasparasavyapekSatAsamAsAditAnekAntarUpANAM viSakaNikAsamUhavizeSamayasya amRtasaMdohasyeva samyaktvApatteH / dRzyate hi viSAdayo'pi bhAvAH parasparasaMyogavizeSasamAsAditapariNatyantarA agadarUpatAmAtmasAtkurvANAH madhvAjyaprabhRtayastu viziSTasaMyogAvAptadravyAntarasvabhAvA mRtiprAptinimittaviSayarUpatAmAsAdayantaH / na ca adhyakSaprasiddhArthasya paryanuyogaviSayatA anyathA 2010_02

Page #282
saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-69 237 agnyAderapi dAhyadahanazaktyAdiparyanuyogopapatteH / ata eva nirapekSA naigamAdayo durnayAH sApekSAstu sunayA ucyante / abhihitArthasaMvAdi cedaM vAdivRSabhastutikRtsiddhasenAcAryavacanam "nayAstava syAtpadalAJchanA ime rasopaviddhA iva lohadhAtavaH / bhavantyabhipretaphalA yatastato bhavantamAryAH praNatA hitaiSiNaH" [ ] iti / athavA sAMkhyAdyekAntavAdidarzanasamUhamayaikasya cUrNanasvabhAvasya mithyAdRSTipuruSasamUhavighaTanasamarthasya vA yadvA mithyAdarzanasamUhA naigamAdayaH-ekaikasya naigamAdernayasya zatavidhatvAt "ekkeko vi sayaviho" [Avazyaka ni0 uvagghAyani0 gA0 36] ityAdyAgamaprAmANyAt-avayavA yasya tad mithyAdarzanasamUhamayam jinavacanasya naigamAdayaH sApekSAH sapta avayavAsteSAmapi ekaikaH zatadhA vyavasthitaH ityabhiprAyaH / [S.T.P.757] atha prativAdI api asAdhanAGgasya sAdhanAGgatvena upAdAnAt svapakSasiddhimakurvan mithyAbhinivezI nigRhyate iti cet, na; ubhayornigrahaprApterityuktatvAt / tasmAd "asAdhanAGgavacanamadoSodbhAvanaM dvayoH / nigrahasthAnamanyaddhi na yuktamiti neSyate" / [ ] ityAdivAdanyAyalakSaNamekAntavAdinAM sarvamasaMgatamuktanyAyAt sarvasya caikAntasAdhanAGgatvAt tasya asattvena sAdhayitumazakyatvAt anekAntasya ca nirdoSatvena tatra doSodbhAvanasya adoSodbhAvanarUpatvAt doSAnudbhAvanasya ca nirdoSe parAjayAnadhikaraNatvAt tadudbhAvanasyaiva tatra nigrahArhatvAt ityalaM piSTapeSaNena iti vyavasthitam mithyAdarzanasamUhamayatvaM mayikatvaM vA / na vidyate mRtaM maraNaM yasmin asau amRto mokSaH taM sArayati gamayati prApayatIti vA tasya avandhyamokSakAraNatvAt mokSapratipAdakatvAJca / 'amayasAyassa' vA iti pAThe amRtavat svAdyate iti amRtasvAdam amRtatulyamiti yAvat / tathA rAgAdyazeSazatrujetRpuruSavizeSairucyata iti jinavacanam tasya anena viziSTapuruSapraNItatvanibandhanaM prAmANyaM nigamayati / kSIrAzravAdyanekalabdhyAdyaizvaryAdimato bhagavata ityanenApi vizeSaNena tasya aihikasaMpadvizeSajanakatvamAha / saMvignaiH saMsArabhayodvegAvirbhUtamokSAbhilASaiH apakRSyamANarAga-dveSA'haMkArakAluSyaiH 'idameva jinavacanaM tattvam' 2010_02

Page #283
238 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe, kANDa-3, gAthA-69 ityevaM sukhena avagamyate yat tat saMvignasukhAbhigamyam / etenApi viziSTabuddhyAtizayasaMvitsamanvitayativRSaniSevyatvamasya pratipAdayati / evaMvidhaguNAdhyAsitasya jinavacanasya sAmAyikAdibindusAraparyantazrutAmbhodheH kalyANamastu iti prakaraNasamAptau antyamaGgala saMpAdanArthaM viziSTAM stutimAha / ___ iti tattvabodhavidhAyinyAM sanmatiTIkAyAM tRtIyaM kANDaM samAptam / iti katipayasUtravyAkhyayA yad mayA''ptaM kuzalamatulamasmAt sanmate vyasAthaiH / bhavabhayamabhibhUya prApyatAM jJAnagarbha vimalamabhayadevasthAnamAnandasAram / / puSyadvAgdAnavAdidviradaghanaghaTAkuNThadhIkumbhapIThapradhvaMsodbhUtamuktAphalavizadayazorAzibhiryasya tUrNam / gantuM digdantidantacchalanihitapadaM vyomaparyantabhAgAn svalpabrahmANDabhANDodaranibiDabharotpiNDitaiH saMpratasthe / / pradyumnasUreH ziSyeNa tattvabodhavidhAyinI / tasyaiSA'bhayadevena sanmatervivRtiH kRtA / / aGkato granthapramANam 25000 / / pravAdimadamardanaprakaTasanmativyAjato nivezitajagattrayasphuritasAndrakIrtidrumaH / samastajagatItale guNavatAM ziraHzekharo jayatyatulavAgabhayadevasUriH prabhu / / [S.T.P.761] 2010_02

Page #284
pariziSTAni SATTA NRESENA 2010_02

Page #285
T sphuranti vAdikhadyotAH sAmprataM dakSiNApathe / nUnamastaMgato vAdI siddhaseno divAkaraH / / mahAmahopAdhyAya zrIyazovijayavAcakAnAM zabdeSu tadidamabhipretyAha mahAvAdI siddhasenaH / tathA ca samayaparamArthavedinaH bhagavatA sammatikRtaH..... zrI siddhasenadivAkarapAdAH pravacanopaniSadvedI mahAvAdI siddhasenaH vAdigajakesariNA zrIsiddhasenadivAkareNa 2010_02 - - siddha zrI sAdhvI / / siddhatva tatvArthavivaraNe / / syAdvAdakalpalatAyAm / / nyAyakhaNDakhAdye / - anekAntavyavasthAyAm / / aSTasahastrItAtparyavivaraNe / / anekAntavyavasthAyAm / /

Page #286
saMmatigAthA granthanAma 1/3 1/4 prathamaM pariziSTam saMmatitarkagAthAsamuddhRtAnAM granthAnAM sUciH svarUpam / uddhRtagranthe sthAnam | nayopadezaH avataraNikA | gA. 12 tattvArthAdhigama sUtre, mahAmaho. yazovijayajIkRtavivaraNam a-1, sU. 35 vizeSAvazyakabhASyam uddharaNa |gA. 3587 uttarAdhyayanasUtre pAiaTIkA uddharaNa adhya-1, niryu-30 vizeSAvazyakabhASye koTyAcAryakRtaTIkA uddharaNa |gA. 4330 dharmaparIkSA uddharaNa |gA. 24 nayopadezaH uddharaNa gA. 110 anekAntavyavasthA / TIkA patra-54 dvAdazAranayacakram uddharaNa A-9, patra-763 dvAdazAranayacakram uddharaNa A-8, patra-737 pratimAzatakam gA. 30 pratimAzatakam uddharaNa |gA. 95 zAstravArtAsamuccaye, syAdvAdakalpalatATIkA avataraNikA sta. 7, gA. 17 dvAdazAranayacakram avataraNikA A-8, patra-596 vizeSAvazyakabhASyam (svopajJa) padArthasAmya |gA. 75 vizeSAvazyakabhASyam (koTyAcArya TIkA) padArthasAmya |gA. 75 anekAntavyavasthA TIkA patra. 28 nayopadezaH TIkA gA. 15 jJAnabinduH TIkA tattvArthAdhigamasUtre, mahAmaho. yazovijayajIkRtavivaraNam uddharaNa a. 1, sU. 35 nyAyakhaNDakhAdyaH (mahAvIrastavaH) uddharaNa vi. 2, gA. 30 aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNam avataraNikA pari. 1, kA. 3 aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNam uddharaNa pari. 2, kA. 34 2010_02

Page #287
242 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe saMmatigAthA granthanAma 1/9 1/10 1/10, 11 1/11 1/12-16 1/12 svarUpam | uddhRtagranthe sthAnam | anekAntavyavasthA avataraNikA patra-28 nayopadezaH | avataraNikA gA. 15 zAstravArtAsamuccaye, syAdvAdakalpalatATIkA uddharaNa sta. 7, gA. 10 nayopadezaH uddharaNa gA. 83 tattvArthAdhigamasUtre, mahAmaho. yazovijayajIkRtavivaraNam uddharaNa a. 1, sU. 35 nayopadezaH TIkA |gA. 15 anekAntavyavasthA avataraNikA patra-28 zAstravArtAsamuccaye, svAdvAdakalpalatATIkA avataraNikA | sta. 7, gA. 11 / vizeSAvazyakabhASyam padArthasAmya | gA. 2642 taH 2645 anekAntavyavasthA avataraNikA patra-29, nayopadezaH avataraNikA | gA. 17 AcArAGgasUtre A. zIlAGkAcAryajIkRtaTIkA avataraNikA niyu. 170 zAstravArtAsamuJcaye, svAdvAdakalpalatATIkA avataraNikA | sta. 7, gA. 3 dikpaTacorAzIbola uddharaNa |gA. 82 dazavaikAlikasUtre, A. haribhadrasUrIjIkRtaTIkA | TIkA niryu. 60 anekAntavyavasthA TIkA patra-29 zAstravArtAsamuccaye, svAdvAdakalpalatATIkA avataraNikA | sta. 7, gA. 10 tattvArthAdhigamasUtre, mahAmaho. yazovijayajIkRtaTIkA avataraNikA | a. 1, sU. 6 tattvArthAdhigamasUtre, A. siddhasenagaNikRtaTIkA | uddharaNa a. 1, sU. 9 AcArAGgasUtre, A. zIlAGkAcAryajIkRtaTIkA avataraNikA a. 1, u. 7, sU. 61 niSTAyavyavahAragarbhitazrIsIndharasvAmistavana / uddharaNa DhA. 1, gA. 6 sUtrakRtAGgasUtre, A. zIlAGkAcAryajIkRta TIkA uddharaNa zru.1,a.12,ni. 121 anekAntavyavasthA TIkA | patra-29 anekAntavyavasthA TIkA | patra-29 anekAntavyavasthA patra-30 anekAntavyavasthA TIkA patra-30 anekAntavyavasthA TIkA patra-30 1/14 1/18 1/21 1/21-25 1/22 1/23 1/24 1/25 1/26 TIkA 2010_02

Page #288
prathamaM pariziSTam 243 saMmatigAthA 1/27 1/28 svarUpam | uddhRtagranthe sthAnam | TIkA | patra-30 TIkA | patra-30 TIkA sta. 7, gA. 10 TIkA | u. 1, gA. 45 avataraNikA gA. 10 avataraNikA | A. 1 avataraNikA | vi. 3, gA. 40 uddharaNa pari. 10, kA. 103 uddharaNa a. 1, sU. 6 1/31 granthanAma anekAntavyavasthA anekAntavyavasthA zAstravArtAsamuccaye, svAdvAdakalpalatATIkA gurutattvaviniSTAyaH nayopadezaH dvAdazAranayacakram nyAyakhaNDakhAdyaH, (mahAvIrastava) aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNam tattvArthAdhigamasUtre, mahAmaho. yazovijayajI kRtavivaraNam dikpaTacorAzIbola tattvArthAdhigamasUtre, A. siddhasenagaNikRtaTIkA dharmaparIkSA AcArAGgasUtre, A. zIlAGkAcAryajIkRtaTIkA dvAdazAranayacakram nayopadezaH nayopadezaH nayopadezaH anekAntavyavasthA nayopadezaH jJAnabinduH aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNam aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNam anekAntavyavasthA zAstravArtAsamuJcaye, syAdvAdakalpalatATIkA aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNam anekAntavyavasthA aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNam |gA. 3 1/33 1/34 1/35 uddharaNa gA. 79 uddharaNa | a. 1, sU. 6 uddharaNa gA.8 uddharaNa zru.1,a.3,u.4,sU. 122 uddharaNa A. 1 avataraNikA | gA. 3 uddharaNa TIkA | gA. 5 TIkA patra-26 | gA. 5 avataraNikA avataraNikA pari. 1, kA. 3 uddharaNa pari. 1, kA. 16 TIkA | patra-69 avataraNikA | sta. 7, gA. 2 TIkA | pari. 1, kA. 16 | patra-70 TIkA pari. 1, kA. 16 TIkA 1/36 1/37 TIkA 2010_02

Page #289
244 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe TIkA TIkA TIkA saMmatigAthA granthanAma 1/38 anekAntavyavasthA zAstravArtAsamuccaye, svAdvAdakalpalatATIkA aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNam anekAntavyavasthA zAstravArtAsamuccaye, syAdvAdakalpalatATIkA aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNam 1/40 anekAntavyavasthA zAstravArtAsamuccaye, syAdvAdakalpalatATIkA aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNam 1/41 anekAntavyavasthA nayopadezaH anekAntavyavasthA dravyaguNaparyAyano rAsa aSTasahastrItAtparyavivaraNam prameyamAlA 1/43, 44 | zAstravArtAsamuccaye, svAdvAdakalpalatATIkA 1/47 zAstravArtAsamuccaye, syAdvAdakalpalatA TIkA dvAdazAranayacakram dravyaguNaparyAyano rAsa vizeSAvazyakabhASye, koTyAcAryakRtaTIkA aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNam |1/48, 49 zAstravArtAsamuccaye, syAdvAdakalpalatATIkA 1/50, 54 zAstravArtAsamuccaye syAdvAdakalpalatATIkA 1/53 anekAntavyavasthA nayopadezaH anekAntavyavasthA nayopadezaH upadezarahasyaH jJAnabinduH svarUpam / uddhRtagranthe sthAnam TIkA patra-70 avataraNikA sta. 7, gA. 23 TIkA pari. 1, kA. 16 TIkA | patra-71 | avataraNikA | sta. 7 gA. 23 TIkA | pari-1, kA. 16 | patra-70 avataraNikA | sta. 7, gA. 23 | pari. 1, kA. 16 TIkA | patra-72 | gA. 6 arthaghaTana | patra-57 TIkA DhA. 4, gA. 13 TIkA pari. 1, kA. 16 uddharaNa / | 10, pRthivI prakaraNe avataraNikA | sta. 7, gA. 30 avataraNikA | sta. 3, gA. 42 uddharaNa A. 8 uddharaNa | DhA. 13, gA. 10 uddharaNa gA. 45 uddharaNa | pari. 1, kA. 4 uddharaNa sta. 3, gA. 42 avataraNikA sta. 3, gA. 42 TIkA patra-15 avataraNikA | gA. 118 TIkA | patra 65 gA. 6 avataraNikA | gA. 99 TIkA 1/54 TIkA 2/3 2010_02

Page #290
prathamaM pariziSTam saMmatigAthA svarUpam | uddhRtagranthe sthAnam uddharaNa | viM. 18, gA. 2 2/3 2/4 2/5 TIkA TIkA TIkA TIkA 2/6 2/7 2/8 TIkA TIkA TIkA TIkA TIkA TIkA 2/9 2/10 2/11 2/12 2/13 2/14 2/15 2/16, 17 2/18 2/19 2/20 2/21 2/22 2/23 2/24 2/25 2/26 2/27 2/28 2/29 2/30 2/31 granthanAma viMzatirviMzikA jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabinduH jJAnabindu: TIkA TIkA TIkA TIkA TIkA TIkA TIkA TIkA TIkA TIkA TIkA TIkA TIkA TIkA TIkA TIkA TIkA 2010_02

Page #291
246 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe |saMmatigAthA 2/32 svarUpam | uddhRtagranthe sthAnam | TIkA TIkA a. 1, sU. 1 | avataraNikA | pari. 1, kA. 1 TIkA 2/33 2/35 2/35,36 3/3 3/5 3/6 granthanAma jJAnabinduH tattvArthAdhigamasUtre, mahAmaho. yazovijayajIkRtavivaraNam aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNam jJAnabinduH tattvArthadhigamasUtre, mahAmaho. yazovijayajIkRtavivaraNam aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNam dravyaguNaparyAyano rAsa zAstravArtAsamuJcaye, syAdvAdakalpalatATIkA anekAntavyavasthA aSTasahastrItAtparyavivaraNam anekAntavyavasthA nyAyakhaNDakhAdyaH (mahAvIrastava) anekAntavyavasthA anekAntavyavasthA zAstravArtAsamuccaye, syAdvAdakalpalatATIkA anekAntavyavasthA anekAntavyavasthA anekAntavyavasthA anekAntavyavasthA anekAntavyavasthA anekAntavyavasthA anekAntavyavasthA anekAntavyavasthA anekAntavyavasthA anekAntavyavasthA anekAntavyavasthA 3/8 3/8-15 TIkA a.1, sU.1 . uddharaNa pari. 1, kA. 4 uddharaNa | DhA. 9, gA. 14 avataraNikA | sta. 1, gA. 40 uddharaNa | patra-74 avataraNikA | pari. 1, kA. 15 TIkA | patra-74 avataraNikA | vi. 3, gA. 43 TIkA | patra-75 TIkA patra-75 avataraNikA| sta.7, gA.3 TIkA patra-75 TIkA patra-75 patra-75 TIkA patra-75 uddharaNa patra-76 patra-76 patra-76 patra-82 TIkA patra-82 TIkA patra-82 3/9 3/10 TIkA 3/11 3/12 TIkA TIkA TIkA 3/13 3/14 3/15 3/17, 18 3/19 3/20 TIkA 2010_02

Page #292
prathamaM pariziSTam 247 granthanAma saMmatigAthA 3/21 3/22 3/23 3/24 3/25 svarUpam | uddhRtagranthe sthAnam TIkA patra-82 TIkA | patra-83 TIkA patra-83 TIkA patra-83 TIkA | patra-83 avataraNikA | gA. 6 TIkA 3/26 3/27 anekAntavyavasthA anekAntavyavasthA anekAntavyavasthA anekAntavyavasthA anekAntavyavasthA nayopadezaH tattvArthAdhigamasUtre, mahAmaho. yazovijayajIkRtavivaraNam nyAyakhaNDakhAdyaH (mahAvIrastava) anekAntavyavasthA anekAntavyavasthA zAstravArtAsamuccaye, syAdvAdakalpalatATIkA gurutattvaviniSTAyaH upadezarahasyaH dharmaparIkSA anekAntavyavasthA zAstravArtAsamuccaye, syAdvAdakalpalatATIkA pratimAzatakaTIkA pratimAzatakaTIkA aSTasahastrItAtparyavivaraNam anekAntavyavasthA zAstravArtAsamuJcaye, syAdvAdakalpalatATIkA nyAyakhaNDakhAdyaH (mahAvItastava) anekAntavyavasthA anekAntavyavasthA zAstravArtAsamuJcaye, syAdvAdakalpalatATIkA dravyaguNaparyAyano rAsa aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNam 3/28 TIkA avataraNikA a. 1, sU. 35 uddharaNa |vi. 3, gA. 42 patra-83 TIkA patra-83 avataraNikA | sta. 7, gA. 2 avataraNikA | u. 1, gA. 52 avataraNikA | gA. 101 uddharaNa gA. 81 | patra-84 avataraNikA sta. 7, gA. 30 uddharaNa | gA. 15 uddharaNa gA. 92 TIkA pari. 6, kA. 77-78/ TIkA patra-85 avataraNikA |sta. 7, gA. 30 avataraNikA | vi. 1, gA. 16 TIkA patra-85 TIkA patra-86 avataraNikA | sta. 7, gA. 1 uddharaNa DhA. 9, gA. 19 avataraNikA | pari 1, kA. 11 3/29 3/30 3/31 3/32 2010_02

Page #293
248 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe saMmatigAthA 3/33 3/34 svarUpam / uddhRtagranthe sthAnam | avataraNikA sta. 7, gA. 1 uddharaNa | DhA. 9, gA. 20 uddharaNa | DhA. 9, gA. 23 avataraNikA | sta. 7, gA. 1 uddharaNa avataraNikA sta. 1, gA. 75 avataraNikA | vi. 4, gA. 3 . avataraNikA | gA. 32 uddharaNa DhA. 9, gA. 12 3/35 3/37 3/38,39 granthanAma zAstravArtAsamuccaye, syAdvAdakalpalatATIkA dravyaguNaparyAyano rAsa dravyaguNaparyAyano rAsa zAstravArtAsamuJcaye, syAdvAdakalpalatATIkA dravyaguNaparyAyano rAsa zAstravArtAsamuJcaye, syAdvadakalpalatATIkA nyAyakhaNDakhAdyaH (mahAvIrastava) nayopadezaH dravyaguNaparyAyano rAsa tattvArthAdhigamasUtre, mahAmaho. yazevijayajIkRtavivaraNam vyAkhyAprajJaptiH zAstravArtAsamuccaye, syAdvAdakalpalatATIkA dravyaguNaparyAyano rAsa zAstravArtAsamuJcaye, syAdvAdakalpalatATIkA aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNam dravyaguNaparyAyano rAsa aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNam zAstravArtAsamuccaye, syAdvAdakalpalatATIkA upadezarahasyaH paJcavastuH tattvArtha lokavArttikaH AcArAGgasUtre, A. zIlAGkAcAryajI kRtaTIkA aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNam dvAdazAranayacakram yatilakSaNasamuccayaH zAstravArtAsamuccaye, syAdvAdakalpalatATIkA vizeSAvazyakabhASyam 3/40 3/41 uddharaNa a. 1, sU. 10 TIkA za. 1, u. 1, sU. 8 avataraNikA | sta. 1, gA. 75 uddharaNa DhA. 9, gA. 2 avataraNikA | sta. 7, gA. 1 uddharaNa pari. 1, kA. 11 uddharaNa |DhA. 9, gA.1 | pari. 6, kA. 7770 avataraNikA | sta. 2, gA. 2 TIkA gA. 151 TIkA gA. 9 avataraNikA | a. 1 3/43, 44 3/45 uddharaNa a. 2, u.6 avataraNikA | pari. 6, kA. 77 78/ uddharaNa A. 8 uddharaNa | gA. 176 TIkA sta.7, gA. 66 TIkA |gA. 2265 3/47 2010_02

Page #294
prathamaM pariziSTam 249 | saMmatigAthA 3/48,49 3/49 granthanAma svarUpam | uddhRtagranthe sthAnam | SaDdarzana samuJcaye, A. guNaratnasUrikRtaTIkA TIkA kA. 1, gA. 1 zrAddhajItakalpe, A.dharmaghoSasUrikRtaTIkA TIkA gA. 57 vRttI syAdvAdamaJjarI TIkA avataraNikA | gA. 28 sthAnAGgasUtre, A. abhayadevasUrikRtaTIkA uddharaNa sthA. 7, u. 3, sU. 552 uttarAdhyayanasUtre, pAiaTIkA uddharaNa a. 1 dvAdazAranayacakram uddharaNa A. 1 dharmaparIkSA uddharaNa | gA. 24 zAstravArtAsamuccaye, syAdvAdakalpalatATIkA avataraNikA | sta. 7, gA. 66 dharmaparIkSA uddharaNa | gA. 24 vizeSAvazyakabhASyam TIkA | gA. 2195 Avazyakaniyuktau, hAribhadrIyaTIkA uddharaNa |gA. 755 pramANamImAMsA uddharaNa | sU. 30 dravyaguNaparyAyano rAsa uddharaNa DhA. 5, gA. 6 sthAnAGgasUtre, A. abhayadevasUrikRtaTIkA uddharaNa sthA.7,u.3,sU. 552 vItarAgastotre, A. prabhAnandasUrikRtadurgaprakAzaTIkA uddharaNa |pra. 8, gA. 12 siddhiviniSTAyaTIkA uddharaNa pra. 6, gA. 21 vizeSAvazyakabhASyam TIkA |gA. 2104 dazavaikAlikasUtre, A. haribhadrasUrikRtaTIkA uddharaNa a. 1 vizeSAvazyakabhASye, A. koTyAcAryakRtaTIkA uddharaNa | gA. 45 paJcavastukaprakaraNam TIkA | gA. 1049 upadezapadaH TIkA | gA. 164 nayopadezaH avataraNikA | gA. 124 zAstravArtAsamuccaye, syAdvAdakalpalatATIkA avataraNikA | sta. 7, gA. pa2 sUtrakRtAGgasUtre, A. zIlAGkAcAryakRtaTIkA | avataraNikA | a. 12 mArgaparizuddhiH uddharaNa |gA. 167 viMzatirviMzikA uddharaNa |viM. 4, gA. 14 uttarAdhyayanasUtre, pAiaTIkA uddharaNa niryu. 71 vRttau 3/50 3/52 3/53 2010_02

Page #295
250 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe 3/54 3/63 TIkA saMmatigAthA granthanAma dharmaparIkSA gurutattvaviniSTAyaH uttarAdhyayana sUtre, pAiaTIkA sUtrakRtAGgasUtre, cUrNI sUtrakRtAGgasUtre, cUrNI 3/56 zAstravArtAsamuJcaye, syAdvAdakalpalatATIkA 3/57 zAstravArtAsamuJcaye, syAdvAdakalpalatATIkA 3/58 dvAdazAranayacakram pratimAzatakavRttiH 3/66 upadezarahasyaH paJcavastukaprakaraNam upadezamAlAyAM, heyopAdeyATIkA gurutattvaviniSTAyaH mArgaparizuddhiH yatilakSaNasamuccayaH 350 gAthArnu stavana sthAnAGgasUtre, A. abhayadevasUrikRtaTIkA sthAnAGgasUtre, A. abhayadevasUrikRtaTIkA dharmasaMgrahaH anekAntavyavasthA upadezarahasyaH paJcAstikAyasaMgrahaTIkA dravyaguNaparyAyano rAsa dravyaguNaparyAyano rAsa mArgaparizuddhiH pratimAzatakaTIkA samyaktvaSaTsthAnasvarUpanI copAi sammativRtti aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNam | sammativRtti| aSTasahasrItAtparyavivaraNam svarUpam uddhRtagranthe sthAnam | TIkA gA.9 uddharaNa u.4, gA. 2 uddharaNa niryu. 241 uddharaNa | gAthA-534 uddharaNa sUtra-631-34 avataraNikA sta. 1, gA. 27 avataraNikA | sta.7, gA. 24 uddharaNa A. 7 uddharaNa gA.61 TIkA gA. 153 gA. 947 TIkA gA. 322 TIkA | u. 2, gA. 76 uddharaNa | gA.133 uddharaNa gA. 72 uddharaNa DhA. 7, gA.13 uddharaNa sthA.4,u.3,gA. 327 uddharaNa sthA.6,u.3,sU.496 uddharaNa | adhi. 3, gA. 130 TIkA patra-86 gA.103 avataraNikA | gA. 172 uddharaNa | DhA. 1, gA. 2 uddharaNa DhA. 4, gA. 14 uddharaNa gA. 294 uddharaNa | gA.15 uddharaNa DhAla-cAla (antima) uddharaNa pari. 1, kA. 16 uddharaNa pari.1, kA. 14 3/67 TIkA _ 2010_02

Page #296
dvitIyaM pariziSTam saMmatitarkaprakaraNe tarkapaJcAnanazrImadabhayadevasUrikRtaTIkAgatAni viziSTazabdAni zabdaH vyAkhyA acakSudarzanam indriyANAmaviSaye paramANvAdau arthe manasA jJAnameva sad acakSurdarzanam / 2/25 anAkAram sAmAnyagrAhakam, avidyamAna AkAraH bhedo grAhyasya asya iti anAkAraM darzanamucyate / 2/1 aniyamaH anekAntaH / 3/33 anutpannamavinaSTam AkAlaM sthitisvabhAvam / 1/11 anupamasukham na vidyate upamA svAbhAvikAtyantikatvena sakalavyAbAdhArahitatvena ca sarvasukhAtizAyitvAd yasya tat sukhamAnandarUpaM yasmiMstat anupamasukham / 1/1 anyonyanizritAH parasparAparityAgena vyavasthitAH / 1/21 / arthaH aryata iti arthaH sAkSAttasyA'bhidheyo gamyaSTA sAmarthyAt / 3/64 arthagatyA vyaktim sakalavastuvyApyanekAntAtmakaikakevalAvabodhaprabhavadvAdazAGgakazrutaskandhA virodhena vyAkhyAm / 2/18 arthanayaH yo hyarthamAzritya vaktRsthaH saMgraha-vyavahAra-RjusUtrAkhyaH pratyayaH prAdurbhavati so'rthanayaH, arthavazena tadutpatteH arthaM pradhAnatayAsau vyavasthApayatIti kRtvA / 1/38 arthaniyataH arthanayanibandhanaH / 1/30 arthaparyAyAH arthagrAhakAH saMgraha-vyavahAra-RjusUtrAkhyAH tagrAhyA vA arthabhedAH / 1/31 arthaparyAyaH arthaM viSayaM paryeti avagacchati yaH so'rthaparyAyaH IdRgbhUtArthagrAhakatvamityarthaH / 2/1 arthasampAdanaH tadviSayapramANa-nayasvarUpAvadhAraNam / 3/65 arthAntaram nAnAsvabhAvam / 3/35 arpitam pratipAdayitumabhISTam / 1/42 amRtaH na vidyate mRtaM maraNaM yasmin asau amRtaH mokSaH / 3/69 asadbhUtam asatyam / 3/59 avaktavyam tathAbhUtasya vastuno'bhAvAt pratipAdakavacanAtItatvAt, vacanasya vA tathAbhUtasyAbhAvAd avaktavyam / 1/36 2010_02

Page #297
252 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe zabda: vyAkhyA ahetuvAdAgamaH pramANAntarAnavagatavastupratipAdaka Agamo'hetuvAda: / 3/43 AgamamalArahRdayaH / malamiva ArA prAjanakavibhAgo yasyAsau malAro gaurgalI, Agame tadvat kuNThaM hRdayaM yasya-tadarthapratipattyasAmarthyAt - asau tathA mandadhIH / 1/2 ucchedaH utpattyanantaraniranvayadhvaMsalakSaNaH / 1/17 upagatAnAm 'upa' iti kAlasAmIpyena gatAnAM prAptAnAm, yadvA prakarSeNa gatAnAm, yadvA prakarSeNa apunarAvRttyA gatAnAm, yadvA 'upa' iti sakalakarmakSayAnantaramavyavadhAnena gatAnAM prAptAnAm - zailezyavasthAcaramasamayopAdeyabhUtamanantasukhasvabhAvamAtmanaH kathaJcidananyabhUtaM svarUpa prAptAnAmiti yAvat / 1/1 RjusUtraH deza-kAlAntarasambaddhasvabhAvarahitaM vastutattvaM sAmpratikam ekasvabhAvam akuTilam Rju sUtrayatIti RjusUtraH / 1/3 RjusUtravacanam Rju-varttamAnasamayaM vastu svarUpAvasthitatvAt tadeva sUtrayati paricchinatti nAtIta'nAgatam, tasyA'sattvena kuTilatvAt tasya vacanam - padaM - vAkyaM vA / 1/5 karma adRSTam / 1/19 kAlam yugapadayugapaJcirakSiprapratyayaliGgalakSaNaM vartanAtmakaM vA nava-purANAdilakSaNam / 3/60 kulam pratiniyatapuruSajanyatvam / 1/45 kusamayavizAsanam kutsitAH pramANabAdhitaikAntasvarUpArthapratipAdakatvena, samayAH kapilAdipraNItasiddhAntAH teSAm dRSTeSTaviSaye virodhAdyudbhAvakatvena vizAsanaM vidhvaMsakam / 1/1 kriyA kriyate iti kriyA yathoktAnuSThAnam / 3/68 kSetrama svArambhakAvayavasvarUpam tadAzrayaM vA''kAzam / 3/60 guNaH anekarUpatayA vastunaH karaNaM karoterjJAnArthatvAt jJAnam viSayaviSayiNorabhedAdeva guNaH / 3/12 cakSudarzanam aspRSTe'rtharUpe cakSuSA ya udeti pratyayaH sa cakSurdarzanaM jJAnameva sat / 2/25 jAtiH puruSatvAdikA / 1/45 jinAH rAgadveSamohalakSaNAn zatrUn jitavanta iti jinAH / 1/1 jinopadezaH dvAdazAGgapravacanaH / 3/26 _ 2010_02

Page #298
dvitIyaM pariziSTam 253 zabda: jJAnam jJAnam jJAnam tIrthakaraH darzanam darzanam duHkham dRSTasamayaH dezaH dravyAstikaH dravyanikSepaH vyAkhyA paryAyAstikasya vizeSa eva vastu sa eva gRhyate yena tat jJAnam / 2/1 vizeSAvabodhasvabhAvam / 2/5 jJAyate yathAvad jIvAditattvamaneneti jJAnam / 3/68 taranti saMsArArNavaM yena tat tIrtham - dvAdazAGgam tadAdhAro vA saGghaH tat kurvanti utpadyamAnamutpAdayanti tatsvAbhAvyAt tIrthakaranAmakarmodayAd veti tIrthaMkaraH / 1/3 dravyAstikasya sAmAnyameva vastu tadeva gRhyate aneneti grahaNaM darzanam / 2/1 sAmAnyaparicchedasvabhAvam / 2/5 bAdhanAlakSaNam / 1/18 dRSTaH samayaH siddhAntavAcyamanekAntAtmakaM vastutattvaM yena puMsA saH / 1/28 vastuno'vayavaH / 1/37 drutirbhavanaM dravyam - satteti yAvat - tatra 'asti' iti matirasya dravyAstikaH, dravyameva vA'rtho'syeti dravyArthikaH dravye vA sthito dravyasthitaH / 1/3 dravati atItA'nAgataparyAyAnadhikaraNatvena avicalitarUpaM sat gacchatIti dravyam, taJca bhUtabhAviparyAyakAraNatvAt cetanamacetanaM vA anupacaritameva dravyArthikanikSepaH / 1/6 dravyAstitvavyavasthApako dharmaH / 1/12 vastudharmANAmastitvAdInAm A - samantAd vAdaH tatpratipAdakaH AgamaH / 3/43 azikSitazAstrArthA anabhyastakarmApi karmaNi dhRSTatayA vyApriyate yeSAM hastaste dhIrahastA / 3/65 yasya kasyacid vastuno vyavahArArthamabhidhAnaM nimittasavyapekSam anapekSaM vA yat saGketyate tannAm / 1/6 niSTAyakartR vacanam / 1/8 paryAyaH / 1/41 niSTiAto vikalpo bhedo yasmin tad / 1/33 nirgataH pRthagbhUtaH cayaH paricchedaH niSTAyaH / 1/4 niSTAyo niSTiAtam tad asyAstIti niSTiAtaH, paramArthena vastusattvasya paricchetteti yAvat / 1/35 dravyalakSaNam dharmAvAdaH dhIrahastA nAma nirvacanam nirvikalpaH nirvikalpam niSTAyaH niSTiAtaH _ 2010_02

Page #299
254 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe zabdaH niHsAmAnyam naigamanayaH paraparyAyAH paramArthaH paravicAlanam parIkSakaH paryavanayaH paryAyayogAH paryAyAH paryAyAstikaH vyAkhyA asAdhAraNam, athavA niSkrAntam tadvikalam - sAmAnyaM saGagrahasvarUpaM yasmin tata, athavA niSTiAtaM sAmAnyaM yasmiMstat / 1/7 rAzyantaropalabdhaM nityatvamanityatvaM ca nayatIti nigamavyavasthAbhyupagamaparo naigamanayaH / 1/3 varttamAnaparyAyavyatiriktabhUtabhaviSyatparyAyAH paraparyAyAH / 3/5 paramo'kalpitaSTAsAvarthaH paramArthaH / 1/2 paraviSayotkhananam / 1/28 vyutpattiyuktaH / 1/26 pari samantAt avanam avaH-paryavo vizeSaH tajjJAtA vaktA vA, nayanaM nayaH nItiH / 1/3 pariNatisambandhAH / 1/32 pari samantAt sahabhAvibhiH kramabhAvibhiSTA bhedairvastunaH pariNatasya gamanaM paricchedo yaH sa paryAyaH / 3/12 | paryAya eva 'asti' iti matirasyeti paryAyAstikaH, paryAyameva vA'rtho'syeti paryAyArthikaH, paryAya vA sthito paryAyasthitaH / 1/3 zabdAbhilApyAH / 2/16 pramANaparicchinnaM tathaivAvisaMvAdi vastu pratipAdayan vastunaH pratipAdaka ityucyate / 1/35 pratibimbaM pratinidhiriti yAvat / 1/4 samIkSitArthavacanaM sarvajJavacanamityarthaH / 3/3 parasparaviviktaH / 1/13 itarAnapekSaH / 1/15 prarUpyate'nayeti kRtvA-upavarNanA padasaMhatistasyA viSayo'bhidheyaH / 1/4 vivakSA / 1/9 taistasyaikatvam / 3/4 anekAntaH / 3/27 paraspara svabhAvA'vinAbhUtatA / 3/51 bhavanti nAraka-tiryag-narA'maraparyAyatvenotpadyante prANino'sminniti / bhavaH saMsAraH, taddhetutvAd rAgAdayo'tra 'bhava' zabdenopacArAd vivakSitAH / 1/1 prajJApanIyAH pratipAdakaH pratirUpam pratItyavacanam pratyekam pratyekam prarUpaNAviSayaH bhajanA bhajanA bhajanA bhajanA bhavaH 2010_02

Page #300
dvitIyaM pariziSTam zabda: bhAvaH bhAvaH bhAvAH mahAjJA mohAH mUlanayau mUlavyAkaraNI rUpam lakSaNam laukikaH vaktavyam vacanam vikalpanam vikalpAH vigacchanti vicchedaH vibhajanam vibhajanA vibhajyamAnau vibhajyavAdam vizAsanam vizleSaH viSayam vihATajanaH 2010_02 vyAkhyA paramArthaH / 3/28 bhavati-vivakSitavarttamAnasamayaparyAyarUpeNa utpadyate iti bhAvaH athavA bhUtirbhAvaH vajra-kirITAdidhAraNavarttamAnaparyAyeNendrAdirUpatayA vastuno bhavanam | 1/6 padArthAH | 1/11 AptazAsanam / 3 / 65 muhyantIti mohA mithyApratyayAH / 1/28 samastanayarAzikAraNabhUtau / 1 / 13 AdyavaktA jJAtA vA / 1/3 cakSurgrAhyatvalakSaNam / 1/45 tilakAdi - sukhAdi sUcakam | 1/45 vyutpattivikalaH / 1/26 paricchedyo viSayaH | 1/8 255 - heyopAdeyopekSaNIyavastuviSayanivRtti-pravRttyupekSAlakSaNavyavahArasaMpAdanArthamucyata iti vacanam / 1/4 viziSTaM kalpanaM yatanam - 'kalpateH' atra yatanArthatvAt / 1/18 bhedAH | 1/3 vizeSeNa niranvayarUpatayA gacchanti nAzamanubhavanti / 1/11 antaH sImeti yAvat | 1/5 pRthakkaraNam / 1/47 vigatabhajanA nAnAtvam / 3/4 vizeSeNa parasparAtyAgarUpeNa bhajyamAnau gRhyamANau / 1/14 anekAntavAdaM satyavAdasvarUpam / 3 / 57 ekAntavAdam / 3/57 vividham pratipAdakam / 1/1 pRthagbhAvaH / 2/3 Alambanam / 2/16 vihATa iti dIpyamAnAm zrotRbuddhau prakAzamAnAnarthAn dIpayati prakAzayatIti vihATaSTazAsI janaSTA caturdazapUrvavidAdilokaH / 1/2 anyapadArthakAraNatvena kAryatvena cAnekaprakAram-zAsanam

Page #301
256 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe vyA zabda: vyAkhyA vyaJjananiyataH zabdanayanibandhanaH / 1/30 vyaJjanaparyAyAH zabda-samabhirUDha-evaMbhUtAH tatparicchedyA vastvaMzA vA / 1/31 vyaJjanam vyaJjayati vyanakti vA'rthAniti vyaJjanam - zabda: / 1/34 vyavahAranayaH lokaprasiddhavyavahArapravarttanaparanayaH / 1/4 vyutkrAntam gRhItvA tyaktam / 1/8 zabdanayaH zabdanayAstu manyante - kAraNasyApi viSayasya pratipattiM prati naiva prameyatvaM yuktaM yAvadadhyavasAyo na bhaved so'pyadhyavasAyikalpapTot tadabhidhAnasmRtiM vinA notpattuM yuktaH iti sarvavyavahAreSu zabdasambandhaH pradhAnaM nibandhanam / 1/3 zabdAdayaH zabdAdarthaM gamayantaH zabdanayatvena pratItAH zabdasamabhirUDhaivaMbhUtAstrayo nayAH / 1/5 zAsanam dvAdazAGgam / 1/1 saMjJA pratiniyatazabdAbhidheyatvam / 1/45 saMvignaH saMsArabhayodvegAvirbhUtamokSAbhilASo'pakRSyarAga-dveSA'haGkArakAluSyaH / 3/69 saMsAraH janma-maraNAdiprabandhaH / 1/20 saGgrahavizeSau dravya-paryAyau sAmAnya-vizeSazabdavAcyAvabhidheyau / 1/3 satyAH samyagjJAnarUpAH / 1/28 sapratipakSaH . sataH pratipakSaH virodhI asan / 1/7 samam ekakAlam / 2/9 samayaH arhatpraNItazAsanam / 1/50 samayaH samyag Iyate paricchidyate iti samayo'rthaH / 1/42 samayAH samyak - pramANAntarAvisaMvAdatvena Iyante paricchidyante iti samayAH naSTa muSTi cintA-lAbhA'lAbha-sukhA'sukhajIvita-maraNa-graho-parAgamantrI-SadhazaktyAdayaH padArthAH / 1/1 samastazrutajJAnadarzanA dvAdazAGgavAkyAtmakasya darzanA, darzanaprayojikAyAstadvAkyopajAtA buddhiH / 2/16 samyaktvam yathAvasthitavastupratyayaH / 1/21 samyagdarzanazabdam 'sunayAH' ityevaMrUpam / 1/23 'pramANam' ityAkhyAm / 1/25 samyagdarzanam viziSTAvabodharUpAyA ruceH samyagdarzanazabdavAcyatvAt / 2/32 savikalpam sAmAnyam / 1/41 viAza 2010_02

Page #302
dvitIyaM pariziSTam 257 vyAkhyA siddham zabdaH sAkAram vizeSagrAhakam, saha AkArairgrAhyabhedairvarttate yad grAhakaM tat sAkAraM jJAnamityucyate / 2/1 pratiSThitam - niSTiAtaprAmANyamiti yAvat svamahimnaiva nAtaH prakaraNAt pratiSThASyam / 1/1 siddhAH pramANAntarasaMvAdato niSTiAtAH / 1/1 siddhArthAH pratyakSA'numAnAdipramANaviSayatvena pratipAditAH zAsanena ye te tadviSayatvenaiva tairniSTiAtA iti siddhAH, te ca aryante iti arthA ucyante / 1/1 sukham abAdhAsvarUpam / 1/18 sUtram anekArtharAzisUcanAt sUte vA'smAdartharAziH zete vA'sminnarthasamUhaH zrUyate vA'smAdaneko'rtha iti niruktavazAt sUtram / 3/64 sthAnam tiSThanti sakalakarmakSayAvAptAnantajJAnasukharUpAdhyAsitAH zuddhAtmAno'sminniti sthAnaM lokAgralakSaNaM viziSTakSetram / 1/1 sthApanA saGketAbhidhAnasthArthasya pratikRtikalpanA sthApaneti yad vastu sadbhUtAkAreNa sthApyata iti NijantAt karmaNi 'yu'pratyayaH / 1/6 sthitiH kAlAntaraphaladAtRtvena AtmanyavasthAnam / 1/19 svapakSapratibaddhAH __ sva AtmIyaH pakSaH abhyupagamastena pratibaddhAH pratihatAH / 1/21 hetuvAdAgamaH hinoti gamayati arthamiti hetuH, tatparicchinno'rtho'pi hetuH, taM vadati ya AgamaH sa hetuvAdaH / 3/43 prAyodRSTivAdastasya dravyAnuyogatvAt / 3/44 2010_02

Page #303
aNu duaNuehiM aNNAyaM pAsaMto aNNo karei aNNo aNNoNNaM paDikuTThA aNNoNNaNissiA uNa aNNoNNANugayANaM 'imaM va attukkosaviNaTThA atyaMtaraM aNatthaM atyaMtarabhUehi ya atthagaIa u tesiM atthagaI uNa asthamao ya abhiNNo atthi aviNAsadhammI asthi tti NibviyappaM asthi ya mokkhovAo addiTTa aNNAyaM ca apariNaucchiNNesu ya avaseso vayaNavihI avikoviyasAmatthA aviNicchio ya samae asamatthA dAeuM aha tattha NANamettaM aha deso sabbhAve aha paNNavaNAvisau aha puNa puvvapayutto aha pubbapaDikkuTTo ahiyammi vi guNasadde AiTTho'sabbhAve deso AgamamalArahiyao tRtIyaM pariziSTam saMmatitarkaprakaraNagAthAnAM prathama-tRtIyacaraNayoH akArAdikramaH kA./gA./ca. 3/39/1 | AgAsAIANaM 2/13/1 | AyariyadhIrahatthA 1/52/3 | Araddho ya vibhAgo 3/56/3 ia thorammi 1/21/3 |iharA kahAmuhaM ceva 1/47/1 | iharA samUhasiddho 3/62/3 uppajjati viyaMti 3/35/3 | uppajjamANakAlaM 1/36/1 | uppAo duviyappo 2/18/3 uppAya-TThii-bhaMgA 3/64/3 | uppAyatthA'kusalA 1/30/3 | uppAyasamA vigamA 3/55/1 ubhayattha jAyasaddo 1/33/1 | uvasamiyAIbhAvaM paDuJca 3/55/3 | uvasamiyAIlakkhaNA 2/12/1 | ee puNa saMgahao 1/19/3 | ee samovaNIA 1/7/3 egaMtaNivvisesaM 3/61/3 | egaMtA'sabbhUyaM 3/66/3 |egaMtuccheyammi ya 3/68/3 | egadaviyammi je egayarammi vi tesiM 2/24/3 | egasamayammi 1/37/1 egasamayammi haMdI 1/26/3 etto ya guNavisese 2/39/1 eyaMtapakkhavAo eyaM paDucavayaNaM 3/15/3 evaM "ege AyA ege 1/39/1 evaM jiNapaNNatte 1/2/3 |evaM jIvaddavvaM kA./gA./ca. 3/33/3 3/65/3 1/29/3 2/37/3 3/25/3 1/27/1 1/11/1 3/37/1 3/32/1 1/12/3 3/38/3 3/41/3 2/40/3 2/2/3 2/38/3 1/13/1 3/57/3 3/2/1 3/59/1 1/18/3 1/31/1 2/27/3 3/41/1 2/12/3 3/10/3 3/16/1 3/3/3 1/49/1 2/32/1 2/41/1 3/16/3 2010 02

Page #304
tRtIyaM pariziSTam 259 evaM bhayaNA evaM sai kevaliNo evaM sattaviyappo evaM sesiMdiyadasaNammi ohimaNapajjavANa u kammaM joganimittaM karaNaviseseNa ya kAya-maNa-vayaNa kAlo sahAva kiM jANai kiM kiM pajjavAhio kuMbho Na jIvadaviyaM kuNai ya guNapaNihANaM kusamayavisAsaNaM keI bhaNaMti "jaiyA kevalaNANaM puNa daMsaNaM kevalaNANaM sAI kevalaNANamaNaMtaM jaheva kevalaNANammi ya kevalaNANAvaraNakkhayajAyaM kevalabhAvaM tu kovaM uppAyaMto gaipariNayaM gaI ceva guNaNivvattiyasaNNA guNasaddamaMtareNAvi cakkhuacakkhuavahi caraNa-karaNappahANA caraNa-karaNassa jaM appuTThA bhAvA jaM appuDhe bhAve jaM egaguNAIyA jaMkAvilaM jaM ca puNa arihayA jaMtu jahA kA./gA./ca. 3/27/3 |jaM paJcakkhaggahaNaM Na 3/23/3 jaMpanti asthi 1/41/1 jaM puNaghaDo'tti 2/24/1 | jaM purisAuyajIvo 2/16/3 jaM bhavadukkhavimokkhaM 1/19/1 jaM savisaappahANa 1/49/3 |jaM sAmaNNaggahaNaM 3/42/1 jai oggahamettaM 3/53/1 | jai taM tahA 2/13/3 jai muttA paramANU 3/9/3 jai savvaM sAyAraM 3/31/1 |jaha ee taha 1/43/3 |jaha ettha kevalANa 1/1/3 |jaha koi saTivariso 2/4/1 jaha jaha bahussuo 2/3/3 jaha'NeyalakkhaNaguNA / 2/34/1 jaha daviyamappiyaM 2/14/1 |jaha dasasu dasaguNammi 2/8/3 jaha duddha-pANiyANaM 2/5/1 |jaha puNa te ceva 2/36/3 |jaha saMbandhavisiTro 3/7/1 jAi-kula-rUva-lakkhaNa 3/29/1 jAvaiyA NayavAyA 3/30/1 jAvaiyA vayaNapahA 3/14/1 | jAva daviovaogo 2/20/1 jiNavayaNassa bhagavao 3/67/1 jIvo aNAiNihaNo 3/67/3 jIvo aNAinihaNo 2/29/1 jujjai saMbaMdhavasA 2/30/1 | jujjai sayAvi evaM 3/6/3 jeNa duve egantA 3/48/1 jeNa maNovisayagayANa . 3/11/1 je vayaNijjaviyappA 3/30/3 |je saMghayaNAIyA kA./gA./ca. 2/28/1 3/13/1 3/52/3 2/42/3 3/51/3 3/49/3 2/1/1 2/23/1 3/58/3 3/24/3 2/10/1 1/15/1 2/21/3 2/40/1 3/66/1 1/22/1 1/42/1 3/15/1 1/47/3 1/24/1 3/18/1 1/45/1 3/47/3 3/47/1 1/8/3 3/69/3 2/37/1 2/42/1 3/21/1 2/10/3 1/14/3 2/19/1 1/53/1 2/35/1 2010_02

Page #305
260 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe je saMtavAyadose jo AuMcaNakAlo jo heuvAyapakkhammi Na u Daharao NaNu egavibhAgammi NaNu saMbaMdhavisese Natthi Na NiJco Nasthi ya mokkho Na ya khINAvaraNijje NayaNAivisesagao Na ya taio Na ya davvaTThiyapakkhe Na ya pajjavaTThio Na ya bAhirao bhAvo Na ya sa samayapatravaNA Na ya so egassa Na ya hoi jovvaNattho Na vi asthi Na vijANao vi Na vi ya aNAgaya Na hu sAsaNabhattImattaeNa NANaM apuDhe avisae NANaM kiriyArahiyaM NiyamA dukkhaMtakaDo NiyameNa saddahaMto NiyayavayaNijjasaJcA NoiMdiyaM puNa paDucca taM asthi avattavvaM taM asthi Natthi taM ceva ya taM Natthi avattavvaM taM daviyamasthi Natthi taM pi ya uDDagaIyaM - taM hoi paraNimittaM kA./gA./ca. 3/50/1 | tatto ya puNa 3/36/1 tatto vibhaeyavvo 3/45/1 | tattha u aheuvAo 3/19/3 tattha u paogajaNio 3/40/3 tamhA aNNo jIvo 3/20/3 tamhA ahigayasutteNa 3/54/1 tamhA ohiNNANe 3/54/3 tamhA cauvibhAgo 2/11/3 tamhA taM NANaM 3/21/3 tamhA daMsaNasaddo Na 1/14/1 tamhA davvANugayA 1/17/1 tamhA do vi 1/9/3 | tamhA micchaddiTThI 1/50/1. tamhA savve vi 1/42/3 | tassa u bAlAIyA 3/17/3 |tassa u saddAiA 1/44/1 taha khINAvaraNijje 3/26/1 taha NiyayavAyasuviNicchiyA 3/63/3 taha daMsaNaM pi 1/44/3 taha davvamiMdiyagayaM 3/63/1 taha pajjavavatthu 2/25/1 taha baMdha-mokkha-suha 3/68/1 taha rAgadosamohA 3/44/3 | taha vi uyAharaNamiNaM 3/28/1 taha vi Na guNa 1/28/1 taha savve NayavAyA 1/50/3 | tiNNi vi uppAyAI 1/38/3 |titthayaravayaNasaMgaha 1/40/3 tIyANAgayabhUyA tAvaiyaM 3/26/3 | te aNNoNNANugayA 1/39/3 | te uNa Na diTThasamao 1/37/3 | te u bhayaNovaNIyA 3/29/3 | teNa suviNicchiyAmo 3/22/3 | te taM ca Na taM kA./gA./ca. 3/39/3 3/7/3 3/43/3 3/32/3 2/38/1 3/65/1 2/29/3 2/17/1 2/30/3 2/28/3 3/38/3 3/31/3 1/13/3 1/21/1 1/32/3 1/5/3 2/6/3 1/23/1 2/5/3 3/18/3 1/10/3 1/46/3 2/43/3 2/39/3 3/12/3 1/25/1 3/35/1 1/3/1 1/31/3 1/48/3 1/28/3 3/51/1 2/22/3 1/27/3 2010_02

Page #306
tRtIyaM pariziSTam tettiyamittottUNA kA./gA./ca. 3/6/1 3/3/1 1/8/1 tesiM puNa te sijjhamANasamaye tehiM atItANAgayadosa to maNapajjavaNANaM daMsaNaNANAvaraNakkhae daMsaNapuvvaM NANaM daMsaNamoggahamettaM ghaDo' daviyaM paNNavayaMto davvaM khittaM kAlaM davvaM jahA pariNayaM davvaMtarasaMjogAhi davvaM pajjavaviuyaM davvaDhio a pajjava davvaDhio tti tamhA davvaDhio vi hoUNa davvaTThiyanayapayaDI davvaTThiyavattavvaM avatthu davvadviyavattavvaM savvaM davvaviyavattavvaM sAmaNNaM davvaTThiyassa AyA davaTThiyassa jo ceva davvaTThiyassa savvaM davvatthaMtarabhUyA muttA davvapariNAmamaNNaM davvassa ThiI davvassa pajjave duviho dhammAvAo dUre tA aNNattaM do uNa NayA doNha vi NayANaM dohi vi Naehi natthi puDhavIvisiTTho nAmaMThavaNA davie kA./gA./ca. 2/34/3 | pacuppaNNammi vi 3/36/3 | pacuppannaM bhAvaM 2/35/3 | pajjavaNayavokkaMtaM 1/46/1 pajjavaNissAmaNNaM 2/19/3 | pajjavasaNNA NiyayA 2/9/1 | paDipuNNajovvaNaguNo jaha 2/22/1 paDirUve puNa vayaNa 2/21/1 |paNNavaNijjA bhAvA 3/37/3 paratitthiyavattavvaM 3/60/1 | parapajjavehiM asarisa 3/4/1 | paravattavvayapakkhAavisiTThA 3/38/1 | parikammaNANimittaM 1/12/1 parigamaNaM pajjAo 1/3/3 | paripaDhiyA kevalaNANa 1/9/1 parisuddhaM sAyAraM 2/2/1 | parisuddho nayavAo 1/4/1 pADekkanayapahagayaM 1/10/1 | piu-putta-Nattu-bhavvaya 1/29/1 | purisajjAyaM tu paDucca 3/57/1 | purisammi purisasaddo 1/51/1 | purisassAbhiNibohe 1/52/1 | baMdhaM va viNA 1/11/3 baMdhammi apUrante 3/24/1 bahuyANa egasadde | bAlAibhAvadiTThavigayassa 3/23/1 bAlAiviyappaM puNa 3/32/3 bIyassa bhAvamettaM Na 3/43/1 bhaNNai khINAvaraNe jaha 3/9/1 bhaNNai jaha cauNANI 3/10/1 bhaNNai Na paMcaNANI 2/1/3 bhaNNai NANaM 3/49/1 bhaNNai visamapariNayaM 3/52/1 bhaNNai saMbaMdhavasA 1/6/1 | bhaI micchAdasaNa 3/11/3 1/43/1 1/4/3 2/16/1 2/31/3 3/5/1 2/18/1 1/54/3 3/12/1 2/20/3 2/11/1 3/46/1 3/61/1 3/17/1 1/54/1 1/32/1 2/32/3 1/20/3 1/20/1 3/40/1 1/45/3 1/34/3 1/51/3 2/6/1 2/15/1 2/15/3 2/26/3 3/22/1 3/20/1 3/69/1 3/1/3 2010_02

Page #307
262 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe kA./gA./ca. bhayaNA vi hu bhavio sammaiMsaNa bhAvo u pajjava bhedaM ca paDucca maiNANameva daMsaNamevaM maisuyaNANaNimitto maNapajjavaNANato NANassa maNapajjavaNANaM daMsaNaM micchattaM te ceva mUlaNayANa u ANaM mUlaNimaNaM pajjava mottUNa liMgao rayaNAvali'tti bhaNNai rayaNAvalivavaesaM na rAyasariso u rUAipajjavA je rUva-rasa-gaMdha-phAsA rUvAI pariNAmo loiyaparicchayasuho loiya-paricchiyANaM vaMjaNapajjAe uNa vaMjaNapajjAyassa u puriso vayaNavisesAIyaM vigamassa vi esa vigaya-bhavissehiM u saMkhA ya asavvAe saMkhejjamasaMkhejja saMjoyabheyao jANaNA saMtammi kevale sabbhAvA'sabbhAve deso sabbhAve AiTTho deso samayaparamatthavittharavihADa samudayavibhAgamettaM sammaNNANaM ca imaM kA./gA./ca. 3/27/1 sammaNNANe NiyameNa 3/44/1 / sammaiMsaNamiNamo 1/6/3 sammaiMsaNasadaM lahanti 3/60/3 sammaiMsaNasadaM savve 2/23/3 sayalamaNAvaraNamaNaMta 2/27/1 sarisehiM pi vaMjaNao 2/3/1 |saviyappa-NibbiyappaM iya 2/26/1 |saviyappameva vA NicchaeNa 3/53/3 | savvaNayasamUhammi vi. 1/16/3 sAI apajjavasiyaM 1/5/1 sAgAraggahaNA hi ya 2/25/3 sAbhAvio vi sAmaNNammi viseso 1/24/3 sAsayaviyattivAyI 1/22/3 sA sasamayapaNNavaNA 2/41/3 sAhammau vva atthaM 1/48/1 sijjhai NavaraM 3/8/1 siddha siddhatthANaM 3/13/3 | siddhattaNeNa ya puNo 1/26/1 sIsamaIvipphAraNa 3/59/3 suttaM atthanimeNaM 1/41/3 suttamavalaMbamANA 1/34/1 suttammi ceva sAI 1/36/3 suttAsAyaNabhIrUhiM 3/34/1 suddhoaNataNaassa u 3/4/3 suha-dukkhasampaogo 3/50/3 | so uNa samAsao cciya 2/43/1 so ceva duNNigiNNo 3/42/3 |so bAlAiviyappaM na 2/8/1 |so sasamayapaNNavao 1/40/1 | haMdI apajjavesa vi 1/38/1 | haMdi hu mUlaNayANaM | heuvisaovaNIyaM jaha 3/34/3 | hojja samaM uppAo 2/33/3 hojjAhi duguNamahuraM 2/33/1 3/62/1 1/25/3 1/23/3 2/17/3 3/5/3 1/35/1 1/35/3 1/16/1 2/31/1 2/14/3 3/33/1 3/1/1 1/17/3 1/53/3 3/56/1 3/14/3 1/1/1 2/36/1 3/25/1 3/64/1 2/4/3 2/7/1 3/48/3 1/18/1 1/30/1 3/46/3 1/33/3 3/45/3 3/28/3 1/15/3 3/58/1 2/9/3 3/19/1 1/2/1 2010_02

Page #308
caturthaM pariziSTam samupayuktAni grantharatnAni katA / vIkAkAra granthanAma 350 gAthAnuM stavana | yazovijayajI adhyAtmamataparIkSA | yazovijayajI adhyAtmasAra yazovijayajI anuyogadvArasUtra AryarakSitasUrijI anekAntavyavasthA yazovijayajI aSTasahasrItAtparya | yazovijayajI aspRzadgativAda yazovijayajI AcArAGgasUtra dhAmIjI uttarAdhyayanasUtra sudharmAsvAmIjI upadezapada haribhadrasUrijI upadezarahasya yazovijayajI gurutattvaviniSTAya yazovijayajI jainatarkabhASA yazovijayajI jJAnabindu yazovijayajI tattvArtha lokavArttika | umAsvAtijI tattvArthasUtra umAsvAtijI tattvArthasUtra umAsvAtijI dazavaikAlikasUtra zayyaMbhavasUrijI dikpaTacorAzIbola | yazovijayajI dravyaguNaparyAyano rAsa| yazovijayajI dvAdazAranayacakra mallavAdikSamAzramaNa dharmaparIkSA yazovijayajI dharmasaMgraha mAnavijayajI dharmasaMgrahaNI haribhadrasUrijI nayopadeza yazovijayajI paJcavastu haribhadrasUrijI TIkAkAra / prakAzaka | yazovijayajI yazovijayajI gItArtha gaMgA sanmArga prakAzana haribhadrasUrijI yazovijayajI jainagrantha prasAraka sabhA yazovijayajI pravacana prakAzana yazovijayajI zIlAGkAcAryajI motIlAla banArasIdAsa zAntisUrijI devacanda lAlabhAI municandrasUrijI muktikamala jaina mohanamAlA | yazovijayajI aMdherI gujarAtI jaina saMgha yazovijayajI jaina sAhitya vikAsa maNDala yazovijayajI divyadarzana TrasTa yazovijayajI andherI gujarAtI jaina saMgha vidyAnandasvAmi gAMdhInAthoraMga jaina granthamAlA siddhasena gaNi zrIpAlanagara jaina zve. Tra. yazovijayajI gulAbacanda devacanda haribhadrasUrijI anekAnta prakAzana yazovijayajI yazovijayajI paM. zAtilAla kezavalAla siMhasUri gaNi kSamA. | jaina AtmAnanda sabhA yazovijayajI aMdherI gujarAtI jaina saMgha mAnavijayajI jinazAsana A. Tra. yazovijayajI haribhadrasUrijI vijaya lAvaNyasUri jJAnamaMdira arihanta ArAdhaka TrasTa ___ 2010_02

Page #309
264 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe granthanAma kartA TIkAkAra prakAzaka paJcAstikAyaTIkA | kundakundAcArya amRtacandrAcArya | digaMbara jaina svA. maM. Tra. pratimAzataka yazovijayajI yazovijayajI pramANamImAMsA hemacandrasUrijI hemacandrasUrijI sarasvatI pustaka bhaMDAra prameyamAlA yazovijayajI yazovijayajI mahAvIrastava yazovijayajI yazovijayajI tArAcanda motIcanda mArgaparizuddhi yazovijayajI yazovijayajI yatilakSaNasamuJcaya | yazovijayajI yazovijayajI arihanta ArAdhaka TrasTa viMzativiMzikA haribhadrasUrijI yazovijayajI anekAnta prakAzana vizeSAvazyakabhASya | jinabhadragaNi kSamA. hemacandrasUrijI yazovijaya jaina granthamAlA | vizeSAvazyakabhASya jinabhadragaNi kSamA. jinabhadragaNi kSamA. vizeSAvazyakabhASya jinabhadragaNi kSamA. koTyAcAryajI vyAkhyAprajJapti sudharmAsvAmIjI abhayadevasUrijI devacanda lAlabhAI zAstravArtAsamuJcaya haribhadrasUrijI yazovijayajI divyadarzana TrasTa SaDdarzanasamuJcaya / haribhadrasUrijI guNaratnasUrijI bhAratIya jJAnapITha saMmatiprakaraNa siddhasenadivAkarasUrijI | paM. sukhalAla gujarAta vidyApITha (bhASAMtara) paM. becaradAsa saMmatiprakaraNa siddhasenadivAkarasUrijI | abhayadevasUrijI | jainadharma prasAraNa TrasTa (bhASAMtara) anu. paM. dhIrubhAI saMmatiprakaraNa siddhasenadivAkarasUrijI | abhayadevasUrijI / | divyadarzana TrasTa (hindI anuvAda) anu.mu.jayasuMdaravi. saMmatitarkaprakaraNa | siddhasenadivAkarasUrijI | abhayadevasUrijI | gujarAta purAtattva mandira saMmatitarkamahArNavA- | siddhasenadivAkarasUrijI | darzanasUrijI jainamArga prabhAvaka sabhA vatArikA samyaktvaSaTsthAna- | yazovijayajI | yazovijayajI svarUpanI copAI siddhiviniSTAyaTIkA | akalaGkadeva anantavIrya | bhAratIya jJAnapITha sUtrakRtAGgasUtra sudharmAsvAmIjI zIlAGkAcAryajI | motIlAla banArasIdAsa sthAnAGgasUtra sudharmAsvAmIjI abhayadevasUrijI | motIlAla banArasIdAsa syAdvAdamaJjarI mallisenasUrijI hemacandrasUrijI paramazruta prabhAvaka maNDala 2010_02

Page #310
paJcamaM pariziSTam -: saMmatitarka - mudrita tathA anupalabdha sAhitya : saMmatyAkhyaprakaraNa tattvabodhavidhAyinI TIkA (apUrNa) kartA : pU.A. siddhasenadivAkarasUri ma. TIkAkAra : pU.A.abhayadevasUri ma. prakAzaka : zrI jaina yazovijayajI pAThazALA (vArANasI) prakAzana : vi.saM. 1966 saMmatitarkaprakaraNa tattvabodhavidhAyinI TIkA bhAga 1 thI 5 kartA : pU.A siddhasena divAkara sUri ma. TIkAkAra : pU.A. abhayadevasUri ma. saMpAdaka : 5. sukhalAla ane paM. becaradAsa prakAzaka : gujarAta purAtattva maMdira graMthAvalI prakAzana : vi.saM. 1980 saMmatitarkaprakaraNa tattvabodhavidhAyinI TIkA prathama khaMDa kartA : pU.A. siddhasenaMdivAkarasUri ma. TIkAkAra : pU.A. abhayadevasUri ma. saMpAdaka : pU. muni zrI zivAnaMdavijayajI ma. prakAzaka : jaina graMtha prakAzaka sabhA (amadAvAda) prakAzana : vi.saM. 1996 saMmatitattvasopAna tattvabodhavidhAyinI TIkA kartA : pU.A.siddhasena divAkara sUri ma. TIkAkAra : pU.A.abhayadevasUri ma. saMkalanakAra: pU.A.zrImadvijaya labdhisUrIzvarajI ma. prakAzaka : zrI labdhisUrI jaina graMthamALA prakAzana : vi.saM. 2002 2010_02

Page #311
266 saMmatitarkaprakaraNe saMmatitarkaprakaraNa kartA : pU.A. siddhasenadivAkarasUri ma. anuvAda : 5. sukhalAla ane paM. becaradAsa prakAzaka : gujarAta vidyApITha prakAzana : bIjI AvRtti vi.saM. 2008 saMmatitarkamahArNavAvatArikA kartA : pU.A. siddhasenadivAkarasUri ma. TIkAkAra : pU.A. zrI darzanasUri ma. prakAzaka : jaina mArga prabhAvaka sabhA (madrAsa) prakAzana : vi.saM. 2013 saMmatitarkaprakaraNa (khaMDa-1) tattvabodhavidhAyinI TIkA (hindI anuvAda) kartA : pU.A. siddhasena divAkarasUri. ma. TIkAkAra : pU.A. abhayadevasUri ma. anuvAdaka : pU. mu. jayazekhara vi. (hAla AcArya) prakAzaka : zeTha motIzA lAlabAga jaina TrasTa prakAzana : vi.saM. 2040 saMmatitarkaprakaraNa (khaMDa-2) tattvabodhavidhAcinI TIkA (hindI anuvAda) kartA : pU.A. siddhasena divAkarasUri ma. TIkAkAra : pU.A. abhayadevasUri ma. anuvAdaka : pU. mu. jayazekhara vi. (hAla AcArya) prakAzaka : zeTha motIzA lAlabAga jaina cerITIjha prakAzana : vi.saM. 2040 2010_02

Page #312
paJcamaM pariziSTam ra67 saMmatitarkaprakaraNa (khaMDa-pa) tatvabodhavidhAyinI TIkA (hindI anuvAda) kartA : pU.A. siddhasena divAkarasUri ma. TIkAkAra : pU.A.abhayadevasUri ma. prakAzaka : divyadarzana TrasTa prakAzana : vi.saM. 205ra anuvAdaka : pU. mu. jayazekhara vi. (hAla AcArya) saMmatiprakaraNa kartA : pU.A. siddhasenadivAkarasUri ma. anuvAdaka : 5. dhIrajalAla DAhyAlAla mahetA prakAzaka : jaina dharma prasAraNa TrasTa (surata) prakAzana : vi.saM. 2074 saMmatitarkaprakaraNa kartA : pU.A. siddhasena divAkarasUri ma. TIkAkAra : pU. malavAdI kSamAzramaNa ullekha : "anekAMtavAda" graMthamAM A. haribhadrasUrIzvarajI ma. (A TIkA upalabdha nathI) saMmatitarkaprakaraNa - vivaraNa ullekhaH digaMbara paraMparAnA vAdirAjanA pArzvanAtha caritramAM (A vivaraNa upalabdha nathI.) samatitarkaprakaraNa TIkA : ajJAtakartaka ullekha : bRhaddIpanikAmAM (A saMbaMdhI vizeSa jANakArI upalabdha nathI.) 2010_02

Page #313
2010_02

Page #314
pU.A.zrIvijayarAmacandrasUrismRtisaMskRtaprAkRtagranthamAlAkramAGka 25 AMMARRIAN MIOWIN imAM prAzana ISBN-978-81-87163-58-9 dain Education International 2010 www.jainelibrary arg