Jainagama viruddha Murtipooja

Author(s): Ratanlal Doshi
Publisher: Akhil Bharatiya Sudharm Jain Sanskruti Rakshak Sangh
Catalog link: https://jainqq.org/explore/002998/1

Page #1
* * * * ******** ***** *** jainAgama viruddha mUrtipUjA lekhakaratanalAla DozI, sailAnA prakAzaka zrI akhila bhAratIya sudharma jaina saMskRti rakSaka saMgha, jodhapura zAkhA- neharU geTa bAhara, byAvara : (01462) 251216, 257666 ************** **********************

Page #2
sudharma jaina saMskRti rakSaka saMgha sAhitya ratnamAlA kA 110 vAM ratna jainAgama viruddha mUrtipUjA lekhaka ratanalAla DozI, sailAnA prakAzaka zrI akhila bhAratIya sudharma jaina saMskRti rakSaka saMgha, jodhapura zAkhA - neharU geTa bAhara, byAvara (rAja.) : (01463) 251216, 257666

Page #3
noTaH sabhI prasaMgoM kA nyAya kSetra byAvara hI hogaa| dravya sahAyaka udAramanA zrImAn seTha vallabhacandajI sA. DAgA, jodhapura prApti sthAna 1. zrI a. bhA. sudharma jaina saMskRti rakSaka saMgha, siTI pulisa, jodhapura 2. zAkhA-a. bhA. sudharma jaina saMskRti rakSaka saMgha, neharU geTa bAhara, byAvara 3. mahArASTra zAkhA-mANake kaMpAuMDa, dUsarI maMjila AMbeDakara putale ke bAjU meM, manamAr3a (nAsika) 25251 |4. zrI jazavantabhAI zAha eduna bilDiMga pahalI dhobI talAvalena . po0 baoN0 naM0 2217, bambaI-2 5. zrImAn hastImala jI kizanalAlajI jaina 67 bAlAjI peTha, jalagAMva |6. zrI eca. Ara. DozI jI-36 bastI nAranaula ajamerI geTa, dillI-6 7. zrI azokajI esa. chAjer3a, 121 mahAvIra klaoNtha mArkeTa, ahamadAbAda 8. zrI sudharma sevA samiti bhagavAn mahAvIra mArga, bulaDANA 6. zrI zrutajJAna svAdhyAya samiti sAMgAnerI geTa, bhIlavAr3A 10. zrI sudharma jaina ArAdhanA bhavana 24 grIna pArka kaoNlonI sAutha tukogaMja, indaura 11. zrI vidyA prakAzana mandira, TrAMsaporTa nagara, meraTha (u. pra.) 12. zrI amaracandajI chAjer3a, 233 vAla Teksa ror3a, cainnaI ka 535775 mUlya : 15-00 prathama AvRtti vIra saMvat 2528 5000 vikrama saMvat 2058 navambara 2002 | madraka-svastika prinTarsa prema bhavana hAthI bhATA, ajamera | -

Page #4
nivedana jahAM jIva rakSA yahI parIkSA dharma vahI jaaniye| jahA~ hota hiMsA, nahIM hai saMzaya, adharma vahI phicaanie|| jaina dharma ahiMsA pradhAna hai| isakA sAra ukta dohe meM de diyA gayA hai| dharma kI pahicAna evaM parIkSA kA eka mAtra bero mITara jIva rakSA hai| jahA~ bhagavAn dvArA prarUpita SaTkAya rUpa jIvoM kI rakSA hotI ho to vahA~ binA kisI nanUnaca ke svIkAra kara lenA cAhiye ki dharma hai| isake viparIta jahA~ SaTkAya rUpa jIvoM meM se kisI bhI kAya kI hiMsA hotI ho athavA inakI hiMsA meM dharma honA svIkAra kiyA jAtA ho vahA~ binA kisI saMzaya ke adharma mAnanA caahiye| ataeva ekendriya se lekara paMcendriya taka kisI bhI jIva kI hiMsA nahIM karanI caahiye| isake lie svayaM tIrthaMkara prabhu apanI dezanA rUpa AgamavANI meM nirUpita karate hue pharamAte haiM - . "se bemi je ya aIyA je ya paDuppaNNA je ya AgamissA arahaMtA bhagavaMto te savve evamAikkhaMti evaM bhAsaMti evaM paNNaveMti evaM parUviMti-savve pANA savve bhUyA savve jIvA savve sattA Na haMtavvA Na ajAveyavvA Na parighetavvA Na pariyAveyavvA Na uddaveyavvA, esa dhamme suddhe Niie sAsae samicca loyaM kheyaNNehiM paveie, taMjahA-uTThiesu vA aNuTThiesu vA uvaTThiesu vA aNuvaTThiesu vA uvarayadaMDesu vA aNuvarayadaMDesu vA sovahiesu vA aNuvahiesu vA saMjogaraesu vA asaMjogaraesu vA, taccaM ceyaM tahA ceyaM assiM ceyaM pvucci||126||" (AcArAMga sUtra) . bhAvArtha - gata kAla meM ananta tIrthaMkara ho cuke haiM aura

Page #5
[4] ******************** bhaviSyat kAla meM ananta tIrthaMkara hoMge tathA vartamAna kAla meM pAMca mahAvideha kSetra meM 20 tIrthaMkara vidyamAna haiM una saba kA yahI pharamAna hai ki ekendriya se lekara paMcendriya taka kisI bhI prANI kI hiMsA na karanI cAhie, unheM zArIrika yA mAnasika kaSTa na denA cAhie tathA unake prANoM kA nAza nahIM karanA caahie| yaha ahiMsA dharma nitya hai, zAzvata hai| saMsAra sAgara meM DUbate hue prANiyoM para anukampA karake unake uddhAra ke lie tIrthaMkara bhagavAn ne yaha ahiMsAtmaka dharma pharamAyA hai / bhagavAn ne jagat jIvoM ke kalyANArtha jo dharmopadeza diyA hai, vaha sarvathA satya hai| vastu kA jaisA svarUpa hai vaisA hI bhagavAn ne pharamAyA haiM, usameM kiJcinmAtra bhI anyathA nahIM hai| isa prakAra padArtha kA yathArtha varNana isa jaina darzana meM hI pAyA jAtA hai, anya darzanoM meM nahIM kyoMki unameM pUrvApara viruddha bAteM pAI jAtI haiN| prazna hotA hai ki ukta pATha meM to bhagavAn ne ekendriya se lekara paMcendriya taka kisI bhI jIva kI hiMsA nahIM karane kA kahA hai / para yahA~ yaha kahA - batalAyA ki dharma ke nAma para bhI hiMsA nahIM karanI caahiye| bhagavAn (dharma) ke nAma para hiMsA karane para to mahAn lAbha (phala) hotA hai| isake samAdhAna ke lie prabhu isI AcArAMga sUtra meM pharamAte haiM / "imassa ceva jIviyassa parivaMdaNamANaNapUyaNAe jAimaraNamoyaNAe dukkhapaDighAyahe" arthAt prabhu ne apane kevalajJAna meM dekhakara pharamAyA hai ki jIvahiMsA (ArambhasamAraMbha) cAhe isa jIvana ko nIroga ciraMjIvI banAne ke lie parivaMdanA - prazaMsA ke lie, mAna pUjA pratiSThA ke lie, yAvat janma maraNa se chUTane duHkhoM kA nAza (anta) karane ke lie yAnI dharma ke nAma para hI kyoM na kI jAya ? vaha hiMsA "taM se ahiyAe, taM se

Page #6
[5] ******************************************* abohie" usa jIva ke lie ahitakara tathA bodhi(samyaktva guNa) kA nAza karane vAlI hotI hai| hA~ to hiMsA (Arambha samArambha) cAhe kisI bhI nAma para kyoM na kiyA jAya vaha hiMsA adharma hai, saMsAra paramparA ko bar3hAne vAlI hai aura yadi vaha hiMsA dharma ke nAma para athavA usameM dharma mAna kara kI jAya taba to vaha bahuta hI jyAdA ahitakara hai| AgamakAra pharamAte haiM ki aise jIvoM ko bhaviSya meM dharma kI prApti honA bhI durlabha ho jAtA hai| itanA hI nahIM praznavyAkaraNa sUtra ke prathama adhyayana meM dharma ke nAma para bhagavAn ke nAma para hiMsA karane vAle ko "maMdabuddhI" vizeSaNa dekara use hInamati, viveka-vikala, mithyAdRSTi hitAhita dharma-adharma aura puNya pApa ke jJAna se rahita kahA hai| "madabuddhi' ke sAtha use "dRDhamUDhA' atyanta mUrkha aura dAruNamaI-kaThoramati vAlA bhI batalAyA hai| maMdabuddhi vAle kevala ve hI nahIM jo par3he likhe nahIM hoM, jinheM bolane-likhane kA khyAla na hoM, balki jo apane samAna prANa rakhane vAle jIvoM kI hiMsA karate hoM, hiMsAkArI upadeza dete hoM, hiMsA meM dharma kI prarUpaNA karate hoM, logoM ko hisaMka pravRttiyoM meM jor3ate hoM, aise sabhI logoM ko prabhu ne maMdabuddhi kahA hai| jar3apUjA, mUrti pUjA meM ekendriya se lekara paMcendriya taka ke jIvoM kI hiMsA hotI hai| ataeva mUrti pUjA prabhu mahAvIra ke ahiMsA vrata ko dUSita karane vAlI hone se ise "jinAjJA viruddha" kahA hai| isake alAvA jaina dharma meM ahiMsA ke sAtha guNoM ko pramukhatA dI gaI hai, guNa hone para hI vyakti vizeSa vaMdanIya pUjanIya mAnA gayA hai| kahA bhI hai ki-"jaina dharma meM guNa lAre pUjA, nirguNA ne pUje vaha dharma hai dujaa"|

Page #7
[6] ********************************************** jaba taka kisI bhI vyakti meM guNa vidyamAna hai taba taka vaha vaMdanIya pUjanIya mAnA jAtA hai| yaha bAta sAmAnya sAdhu sAdhvI taka hI sImita nahIM balki tIrtha ke saMsthApaka tIrthaMkara bhagavantoM para bhI lAgU hotI hai| jaba tIrthaMkara prabhu kA janma hotA hai, taba indrAdi devoM ke dvArA kiye gae janmotsava se mAlUma ho jAtA hai ki jinakA indroM ne janmotsava kiyA, ve tIrthaMkara prabhu saMsAra kA kalyANa kara isI bhava meM mokSa pdhaareNge| itanA saba kucha jAnate hue bhI jaba taka tIrthaMkara mahArAja gRhasthAvasthA meM rahate haiM, taba taka koI bhI vratI zrAvaka yA sAdhu unheM tIrthaMkara rUpa meM vaMdana-namaskAra nahIM karate aura jaba tIrthaMkara prabhu kA nirvANa ho jAtA hai, taba deha rUpa zarIra ke loka meM rahate hue bhI tIrthaMkara prabhu kA viraha ho jAtA hai, unake zava ko deva agni saMskArita kara dete haiN| kyoMki vaMdanIya pUjanIya jo guNa AtmA thI vaha to gamana kara gii| sampUrNa jaina samAja ke sarvamAnya namaskAra sUtra meM pAMcoM pada guNa niSpanna hai, koI bhI aisA pada nahIM jisameM guNa nahIM ho aura usa pada ko vaMdana kiyA gayA ho pahalA evaM dUsarA pada to sarvajJatA ko lie hue haiM, ataeva ve to guNoM ke bhaMDAra haiM hI para zeSa ke tIna padoM ke lie bhI batA diyA gayA hai ki AcArya ke chattIsa, upAdhyAya ke paccIsa evaM sAdhu ke sattAvIsa guNa hoM to hI ve usa pada ke yogya evaM vaMdanIya pUjanIya haiM, anyathA nhiiN| AgamoM meM pAMca prakAra ke asAdhu kuzIlie batalAe gae haiM yAnI jo sAdhu ke veza meM hote hue bhI guNoM se sAdhutA ke guNoM se rahita haiM, ve vaMdanIya pUjanIya to dUra balki prabhu ne to unase saMsarga rakhane kA bhI niSedha kiyA hai| isase kucha Age cale, prabhu ke zAsana

Page #8
[7] ***************** meM sAta vi hue, ve prabhu dvArA nirdezita sabhI niyamoM kA pAlana karane vAle the / mAtra eka niyama meM unakA prabhu se matabheda huA, yAnI. ve jJAna aura cAritra se sampanna hote hue bhI kisI eka bAta kI amAnyatA ke kAraNa ve saMgha se bahiSkRta hue| jamAlI jo bhagavAn kA saMsArI jaMvAI evaM bhANeja thA, kintu jinavANI viruddha prarUpaNA se vaha bhI saMgha se bAhara kara diyA gayA / pIche hA~ to jaina dharma meM kisI kA lihAja nahIM hai, yahA~ to guNoM ke pUjA hai / yadi jar3a pUjA kA mahattva hotA to tIrthaMkara prabhu ke zava ko masAlAdi bharakara maMdira meM surakSita rakhA jA sakatA thA, jaisA ki anya dezoM meM zavoM meM masAlA bhara kara rakkhA jAtA hai / kyoMki pASANa mUrti se zava ThIka hI thA, jisameM aba cAhe guNa na rahe hoM, para pUrva meM to unameM guNa the hii| jabaki pASANa mUrtti meM na koI pahale aura na hI bAda meM koI guNa hai? vastutaH guNoM kI ArAdhanA evaM guNI kI sevA bhakti karane se hI unake guNa AtmA meM prakaTa hote haiN| jar3a pUjA, mUrtti pUjA meM aise koI guNa dRSTi gocara nahIM hote, jinakI pUjA arcanA karane se jIva ke andara AdhyAtmika guNoM kA kucha vikAsa hotA ho| ataeva jar3a pUjA, mUrti pUjA guNoM kI apekSA se bhI jinAgama viparIta hai| jIva rakSA, guNa pUjA ke sAtha jaina darzana kI tIsarI kasauTI hai Agama maanytaa| yaha to sarva vidita hai ki tIrthaMkara prabhu cAra ghAtI karmoM kA kSaya hone para vANI kI vAgaraNA karate haiM, unakI prathama dezanA meM hI caturvidha saMgha kI sthApanA evaM gaNadhara bhagavantoM dvArA prabhu kI vANI ko Agama rUpa meM gUMthita kara diyA jAtA hai| vaha Agama

Page #9
[8] rUpa vANI vartamAna meM battIsa AgamoM ke rUpa meM hamAre samakSa upalabdha hai, jise sampUrNa zvetAmbara samAja mAnya karatA hai| ina AgamoM meM anyAnya viSayoM ke alAvA caturvidha saMgha ke pratyeka ghaTaka (sAdhusAdhvI, zrAvaka-zrAvikA ) ke dharmArAdhanA ke lie vidhi vidhAnoM kA savistAra ullekha kiyA gayA hai / kintu sampUrNa battIsa AgamoM meM bindu mAtra kahIM para bhI mUrti pUjA karane yA mUrti ke darzana karane kI AjJA nahIM dI hai| na hI kisI zramaNa mahAtmA yA zrAvaka mahodaya ke cAritra varNana meM yaha bAta milatI hai ki unhoMne prabhu kI mUrti ke darzana yA pUjA kI ho, saMgha nikAla kara yAtrA kI ho, mandiroM kA nirmANa karavAyA ho, pratiSThA mahotsava Adi karavAyeM ho yAnI isa prakAra kI kisI bhI kriyA kA ullekha na Agama meM hai, na hI prAcIna kathAnakoM meM hai| AgamoM meM jahAM bhI zrAvakoM kI dharmArAdhanA kA varNana hai, vahA~ zrAvaka ke vrata grahaNa karane, pratimAoM kI ArAdhanA karane, apanI pauSadhazAlA meM dayA, pauSadha saMvara kriyA karane kA to ullekha hai, para kahIM para bhI aisA varNana nahIM milatA ki amukaamuka bhagavAn ke zrAvaka ne itane maMdira banavAye, jirNoddhAra karavAyA, mUrti pUjA kI, unake darzana Adi kie hoN| isI prakAra bhagavAn ke sAdhuvarga dvArA maMdiroM ke nirmANa, unake jirNodvAra, pratiSThA mahotsava Adi karavAne kA varNana evaM saMgha Adi nikalavAne kA kahIM ullekha nahIM hai, jabaki sAdhu evaM zrAvaka varga ke sAdhanA vidhi ke lie sUtra ke sUtra bhare hue haiM, jinameM unake choTI se choTI sAdhanA kA spaSTa ullekha kiyA gayA hai| yadi mUrtti pUjA jainAgama sammata hotI to jisa taraha anya sAdhanA vidhi kA varNana AgamoM meM hai usI prakAra **********

Page #10
[9] ***************** mUrti pUjA isake darzana Adi kA varNana bhI jainAgamoM meM avazya miltaa| ataeva 'mUrtipUjA', 'jIvarakSA', 'guNavattA' evaM 'Agamika vidhi-vidhAnoM' Adi kisI bhI dRSTi se 'jinAgama sammata' nahIM hai| hamAre kitaneka mUrttipUjaka baMdhu evaM inake mAnya guru varga mUrtipUjA ko jinAjJAnusAra batalAne kI koziza karate haiM, isake lie Agama kI duhAI bhI dete haiM, kintu yaha mAtra bhrama jAla hai| mUrtipUjaka samAja jina-jina muddoM ke AdhAra se mUrtti pUjA ko jinAjJAnusAra batalAte haiM, unameM kitanI satyatA hai, Agama pAThoM ko kisa prakAra tor3a maror3a kara unakA artha kiyA hai, ina saba bAtoM kA samAdhAna AgamapAThoM kA saMdarbha dekara sacoTa isa pustaka meM kiyA gayA hai| zrI jJAnasundara jI ma. ( jo marudhara kezarI kahalAte ) pahale sthAnakavAsI paramparA meM dIkSita hue, sthAnakavAsI samAja se ve bahiSkRta kie jAne para, ve mUrtipUjaka samAja meM jA mile aura vahA~ jAkara Apane vahA~ " mUrtti pUjA kA prAcIna itihAsa" nAmaka pustaka likhI, jisameM Apane Agama ke kucha khoTe uddharaNa dekara mUrti pUjA ko jinAgama sammata batAne kA prayAsa kiyaa| Apake die gae uddharaNa kitane bebuniyAdI, ayathArtha evaM Agama viruddha hai, una saba kA uttara (samAdhAna) zrImAn ratanalAla jI DozI, sailAnA ne isa pustaka meM vistAra se kiyA hai| AdaraNIya ratanalAla jI sA. DozI apane samaya ke prakANDa vidvAn evaM carcAvAdI rahe, Apake nAma se hI mUrti pUjaka samAja ke sAdhu-sAdhvI ghabarAte the / Apane " mUrti pUjA kA prAcIna itihAsa" meM carcita mukhya - mukhya sabhI muddoM kA jinake bala bUte para mUrttipUjaka samAja mUrtti pUjA ko AgamAnusAra honA karAra dete haiN| unakA Agama pramANoM se ----

Page #11
[10] ** ****** sacoTa khaNDana kara prabhu mahAvIra dvArA prarUpita zuddha nirdoSa, dharma kI sthApanA kI hai| isa pustaka kA prakAzana vikrama saMvat 1666 meM yAnI lagabhaga 60 varSa pUrva huA thaa| usa samaya carcAvAdI yuga thA mUrttipUjaka samAja evaM sthAnakavAsI samAja ke AcAryoM ke bIca carcA hotI rahatI thI aura carcA meM hamezA mUrttipUjaka samAja ko mAta khAnI pdd'tii| kyoMki ve ise jinAgama sammata siddha karane meM hamezA viphala rhe| yadyapi vartamAna carcAvAdI yuga to nahIM hai, para sthAnakavAsI samAja meM jJAna kA abhAva hone evaM kuguruoM dvArA dharma kA sahI svarUpa nahIM samajha ne ke kAraNa jina zAsana se bhaTakaneM kI sthiti banI huI hai| aisI viSama sthiti meM isa prakAra ke sAhitya kA prakAzana Avazyaka samajhA gayA, tAki samAja jinazAsana ke sahI svarUpa ko samajha kara isa ke zraddhAlu baneM tathA jinezvara bhagavAn dvArA upadezita sAdhanA mArga kA anusaraNa kara mokSa mArga ke pathika baneM / isI bhAvanA ko lekara isa pustaka kA prakAzana saMgha dvArA kiyA jA rahA hai| isa pustaka ke sAtha anya tIna pustakoM (lokAzAha mata samarthana, mukhavastrikA siddhi evaM vidyut (bijalI) bAdara teUkAya hai) ke prakAzana ke bAre meM dharma priya udAramanA zrAvaka ratna zrImAn vallabhacandajI sA. DAgA, jodhapura nivAsI ke sAmane carcA kI to Apako atyadhika prasannatA huI / Apane cAroM pustakoM ke prakAzana kA sampUrNa kharca apanI ora se dene kI bhAvanA vyakta kii| maiMne Apase nivedana kiyA ki phrI pustakeM dene meM pustaka kI upayogitA samApta ho jAtI hai tathA usakA durupayoga hotA hai| ataeva ina cAroM pustakoM kA dRr3hadharmI priyadharmI udAramanA

Page #12
zrAvaka ratna zrImAn vallabhacandajI sA. DAgA, jodhapura ke artha sahayoga se arddha mUlya meM prakAzana kiyA jA rahA hai| AdaraNIya DAgA sAhaba kI udAratA ke lie samAja pUrNa rUpeNa paricita hai| Apa saMgha kI pravRttiyoM ke lie hamezA udAratA se sahayoga pradAna karane ke tatpara rahate haiM / sAhitya prakAzana meM sahayoga pradAna karane meM ApakI bhAvanA utkRSTa rahatI hai| saMgha evaM pAThaka gaNa Apake isa sahayoga ke lie bahuta-bahuta AbhArI hai| Apa cirAyu rahe aura saMgha aura samAja ko ApakA sahayoga prApta hotA rahe / [11] prastuta pustaka ke punaH prakAzana meM hamArA eka mAtra lakSya hai ki jinavANI rasika caturvidha saMgha ke sadasya jinavANI ke zuddha svarUpa ko samajheM evaM sthAnakavAsI samAja meM bar3ha rahI vikRtiyoM ke kAraNa logoM kI zraddhA jo DAMvADola ho rahI hai vaha sthira bane ! bAvajUda isa prakAzana se kisI bhI mahAnubhAva ke hRdaya ko yadi koI Thesa pahu~ce to usake lie maiM hRdaya se kSamA cAhatA hU~ / saiddhAntika mAnyatA ke alAvA merA kisI vyakti vizeSa ke prati koI vaira virodha nahIM hai| mittI me savvabhUesu, veraM majjhaM Na keNa // yaha durlabha pustaka bar3e hI lambe antarAla ke pazcAt punaH prakAzita kI jA rahI hai / ataeva pAThaka baMdhuoM se nivedana hai ki ve ise dharohara ke rUpa meM apane pAsa rakheM aura samaya-samaya para isakA vAcana kara apanI zraddhA ko dRr3ha kre| isI zubha bhAvanA ke sAtha ! byAvara (rAja.) dinAMka 1-11-2002 saMgha sevaka nemIcanda bAMThiyA a. bhA. su. jaina saM. ra. saMgha, jodhapura

Page #13
[12] dhanyavAda! pahale se thoka grAhaka hokara mere isa samAjopayogI kArya meM sahAyaka hone vAle mahAnubhAvoM kA hArdika svAgata karatA huA unakI zubha nAmAvalI Adarza ke lie upasthita karatA huuN| prati zubhanAma 100 zrImAn seTha vardhamAnajI sAhaba pitaliyA, rtlaam| 100 zrImAn seTha bhairodAnajI jeThamala jI seThiyA biikaaner| 100 zrImAn seTha gulAbacandajI pAnAcandajI mehatA, raajkott| 100 zrImAn seTha dalIcandajI U~kAralAlajI rAMkA, sailaanaa| 5.0 zrImAn seTha ratanalAlajI sAhaba nAhara, brelii| 25 zrImAn seTha somacandajI tulasIdAsa jI, rtlaam| ina mahAnubhAvoM ke vacana prApta hone para pustaka prakAza meM AI, ataeva isa pustaka se jo bhI samAja hita hogA, usakA adhikAMza zreya ukta mahAnubhAvoM ko hai| zrImAn munivarya sadAnandI choTAlAla jI mahArAja sAhaba ne apane samaya aura zakti kA bhoga dekara isa pustaka para mananIya bhUmikA likhI hai, ataeva yaha lekhaka munirAja zrI kA hArdika upakAra mAnatA hai| isa pustaka meM jina-jina granthakAroM aura lekhakoM ke granthoM tathA samAcAra patroM kI sahAyatA lI gaI hai, unakA upakAra mAne binA kaise raha sakatA hU~, yadi kAgajoM kA duSkAla nahIM hotA to sabakA pRthak-pRthak paricaya detA, jisase eka bahuta bar3I sUcI bana jaatii| kintu isa nikRSTa samaya meM mAtra samuccaya AbhAra mAnakara hI santoSa karanA par3atA hai| ___ - lekhaka

Page #14
__ [13] udbodhana mitra jJAnasundara jI! Apake mUrti pUjA ke prAcIna itihAsa ke uttara meM pahale 'mukha vastrikA siddhi' peza kI gii| aba jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA' prathama bhAga bheMTa karatA huuN| ApakI donoM pustakoM kA samucita khaMDana karane meM pratyeka viSaya ke lagabhaga 7 grantha aura prakAzita ho sakate haiN| yadi samaya sAdhana evaM paristhiti kI anUkUlatA rahI to kramazaH eka-eka cIja Apake sAmane rakhatA rhuuNgaa| vAstava meM Apane ina do pustakoM kA prakAzana kara jaina samAja kA mahAna apakAra kiyA hai aura sthAnakavAsI samAja ke mahAna upakAroM kA isa taraha ulTA badalA cukA kara kRtajJa (?) siddha hue Apake mithyA zraddhAna aura bhrama pUrNa pracAra kA avarodha karane ke lie yaha kRti samAja ke caraNoM meM samarpaNa karatA hU~ aura eka prati Apake pAsa bhejakara isase yatheSTa lAbha uThAne kA Agraha karatA huuN| Apako cAhiye ki apane hRdaya evaM mastiSka para barpha rakha kara ThaMDe dila aura dimAga se ise par3heM aura pariNAma se sUcita kreN| yadi isa viSaya meM Apa mujhe kucha pUlanA cAheMge to maiM yathA saMbhava anya kAryoM ko rokakara pahale Apako uttara dene kA prayatna kruuNgaa| zubhecchuka lekhaka

Page #15
| bhUmikA sahu koI samaje evI eka bAta e che ke jagatanA prANI mAtra pachI te manuSya hoya ke itara hoya, manuSya mAM paNa bAla, yuvAna, vRddha, strI, ke puruSa, jJAnI ke ajJAnI, sadhana ke nirdhana game te hoya paNa sahu koI bAhya ke Abhyantara zAnti ne icche che ane pota potAnI samaja zakti mujaba dareka yathA zakya zAnti melavavAne banato prayatna kare ch| keTalA eka no prayatna samajaNa pUrvaka no hoya che, keTalAeka no ogha saMjJAvAlo hoya che, jyAre keTalAeka no ajJAnatA vAlo ane keTalAeka no durAgraha mizrita samajaNa vAlo hoya ch| ema judA judA prakAre zAnti mATe prayatna karanArA o pota potAnA prayatna mAM masta hoya che, temAM samajaNa pUrvaka prayatna karanAra jarUra zAnti melavI zake che, andha zraddhA vAlA paNa amuka aMze zAnti prApta karI zake che, paNa ekAnta ajJAnatA vAlA ke durAgraha mizrita prayatna karanArAo pote sAcI zAnti melavI zakatA nathI, eTaluMja nahiM paNa bIjA anekane azAntinA nimitta rUpa bane che, kAraNa ke evAone zAnti melavavAnuM sAdhana jar3a hoya che pudgalika hoya che, ane jar3a vastu ne zAnti zuM?ke azAnti zuM? caitanya ne zAnti caitanya pAsethIja malI zake paNa jar3a pAse thI AdhyAtmika zAnti naja malI zake e saheje samajI zakAya tema che, AMbAnI goTalI mAMthIja AMbo melavI zakAya, sabIja juvAra mAMthIja juvAra prApta karI zakAya, paNa patthara nI AMbAnI goTalI banAvIne ke pattharanA juvAra nA dANA banAvIne sArAmAM sArI karAla jamIna mAM vAvavAmAM Ave ane upara varSAda vagere manamAnatA pUratA pramANa mAM sAdhano no upayoga thAya to paNa e mAMthI-AMbAnA nAmamAtra bIjamAMthI AMbo ke juvAra vagere kAMI paNa naja melavI zakAya, eTaluMja nahiM paNa e

Page #16
[15] ***** jar3a bIja sAme game tevI prabala prArthanA ke bhAvanA paNa saphala thatI nathI kAraNa ke e AMbAnI goTalI ke juvAra ne mAtra nAma Apela che, athavA to tenI mithyA sthApanA karela che, jethI te phala dAyaka banatI nathI, kAraNa te vastu mAM no mUla guNa hoto nathI eTale udyama karanAra no varSo no udyama hoya to paNa te zUnya pariNAmaja nivar3e che, e sanAtana satya che| e anAdi satya ne vikRta svarUpamA abudhone samajAvavA game tevA vidvattApUrNa yuktioM ke kuyuktioM vAlA zAstroM racavAmAM Ave ke arhat kathita zAstroM nA viparItArtha karavAmAM Ave paNa athI abIja vastu sabIja koI paNakAle naja banA zake / eja rIte ekAnta jJAna, darzana, cAritra ane tapa vaDe karIne temAM paNa khAsa karIne jJAnadarzana je ananta zaktimAna AtmAnA mUla guNa che, te guNone karmoe AvarI lIdhela hovAthI je azAnti anubhavAya che te azAnti dUra karavAne ananta jJAnI e batAvela cAritra ane tapa eja parama sAdhana che| e parama sAdhana dvArA sAdhanA karavAne badale mUrti Adi jar3a padArtha mAM arihaMtoM nI kalpanA karI tenI sanmukha besI e jar3a sAdhana dvArA (tenI mArphata ) Atma sAdhanA karI zAzvata zAMti melavavAnI AzA rAkhavI te keTale aMze nyAya saMgata che, te taTastha vRtti thI vicAra nArA vicArakoM saheje samajI zake tema che| jaina siddhAntoM mAM AtmaguNa- jJAna darzanAdinA AvaraNo dUra karavAne cAritra ane tapa sivAya anya koI paNa sAdhana kahelaja nathI / zramaNopAsaka zrAvaka nI jyAM jyAM dinacaryA siddhAntoM mAM batAvela che tyAM deza viratI cAritra ane nAnAvidha tapanIja vidhi batAvela che koI paNa ThekANe pratimAjI nuM pUjana arcana ke te sambandhI vidhi vidhAna kyA batAvela nathI /

Page #17
[16] zrI ThANAMgajI sUtranA cothe ThANe zramaNopAsaka ne mATe cAra vizAmA batAvela che temAM sAmAnya vrata, paccakkhANa, sAmAyika, pauSadha Adi ane saMyama vigere kahela che paNa kyAMya pratimAM vaMdana-pUjana vizrAntinuM sthAna kahela nathI temaja trIje ThANe traNa kAraNe karI devane pazcAttApa-kheda-thavAnuM kahela che temAM (1) chatI anukUlatAe jJAnAbhyAsa na karyo (2) zrAvaka paNuM zuddha na pAlyuM ane (3) saMyamI paNuM zuddha na pAlyuM, e traNa kAraNe devane kheda thavAna kahela che, paNa kyAMya pahAr3a parvatanI yAtrA na karI ke pratimAdinuM pUjana na karyu tenA mATe kheda thavAnuM zrI vItarAga deve kahela nathI, kAraNa ke AtmakalyANasAdhanArAo mATe e vastu e pravRttinI jarApaNa jarUra jJAnIoo svIkArI nathI, temaja pratimA pUjana e niravadya kriyA nathI paNa sAvadha kriyA che, eTale te kriyA sambandhI sarvavirati to kAMI paNa Adeza ke AjJA to zuM paNa upadeza paNa naja karIzake, eTaluMja nahiM paNa deza vistI zrAvako paNa pauSadhAdi vrata mAM hoya tyAre paNa pratimA pUjananI AjJA ke sUcanA na karI zake, je kriyA AtmAnA AvaraNo dUra karI zake tevI niravadya ke je saMsAra ne chedanAra hoya tenIja AjJA upadeza ke sUcanA karI zake, paNa je kriyA saMsAra vadhAranAra hoya teno Adeza vratadhArI zrAvaka paNa najakarI zake, evAta mUrti pUjaka bandhuo paNa svIkAre che| jaina dharma prakAza pustakaM 52 aMka 5 me pRSTa 185 mAM praznottara vibhAga mAM eka praznakAre prazna ko che ke - - "ApaNA ghara derAzara nI pratimAnI pUjA karI na hoya ne bhalAmaNa karavI paNa rahI gaI hoya to bIjA koI ne pUjA karavAno Adeza pauSadhamAM karI zakAya?

Page #18
[17] uttara mAM kahe che ke - "pauSadhakaryA agAu gharadarAzara mAM pUjA karavI joie athavA to bIja karavAnI bhalAmaNa karavI joie, pauSadha lIdhA pachI bhalAmaNa thaizake nahIM / " jyAre pauSadha vAlA ne jenuM vrata samaya puratuMja che ane te paNa pUrNa navakoTinA paccakkhANa vAluM nathI chatAM enAthI pUjananI bhalAmaNa paNa thaI zake nahiM, to sarva virati ane te paNa jAvajIva nA cAritravAlA thI pratimAdi pUjana vagere nI bhalAmaNa thaI zakeja nahiM e to dekhItIja vAta che| zrI ThANAMgajI sUtranAM pAMcameM ThANe trIje uddeze dharma nAM pAMca avalambana-pAMca AdhAra - kahela che te " dhammesuNaM caramANassa paca nissATTANA paNNattA taMjahA 1 chakkAyA 2 gaNo 3 rAyA 4 gAhAvaI 5 sarIraM arthAt chaH kAya, gaNa, rAjA, gAthApati ane zarIra e pAMca avalambana kahyA, paNa dharma ke je AtmAno guNa athavA Atma mala dUra karavAnuM pavitra sAdhana e dharmanA AdhAra rUpe pratimAjI ke koI paNa sthAvara tIrtha batAvela nathI, e upara thI paNa siddha thAya che ke dharmakAryaAtmakalyANa nA mATe mUrti pUjA - mUrtinI kyAMya paNa jarUriyAta zrI jinezvara deve svIkArela nathI / zAzvatI pratimA zAzvatI pratimA ane tepaNa zrI jinezvaradevanI pratimA zAzvata hoi zakeja kevI rIte? je vastu anAdi ananta hoya teja zAzvata, to jinezvara devanI pratimA hoya to koI paNa kAle te jinezvara deva thayA hovA joie, eTale omanI Adi thaI, ane e jinezvaradeva nA zarIra no

Page #19
[18] ********************************************* anta paNa hoyaja, eTale e anAdi ananta naja khevaay| ane anAdi anantaja hoya te jinezvara devanI pratimA na hoya, e sarva mAnya satya ch| valI stUpa, khAI, prakAra, koTa vagere zAzvata hoi zakatA nathI enA mATe zrI jinezvara deva poteja evI sthUla vastu ne rahevAno kAla saMkhyAto kAla kahe che, jyAre zAzvata vastu anantakAla sudhI nI hovI joie, eTale je vastu-padArtha ne mATe kAlanI maryAdA hoya te azAzvata, ane amaryAdita kAlanI je vastu te zAzvata, enA mATe zrI jinezvara deva zrI vardhamAna prabhu poteja zrI bhagavatIjI sUtra nA 8 mAM zataka nA 6 mAM uddezA mAM kathe che ke - "sekittaM samuccaya baMdhe? samuccaya baMdhe jaeNaM agaDa, taDAga, nadI, daha, vAvI, pukkhariNI guMjAliyANaM, sarANaM, sarapaMtiyANa, bilapaMtiyANaM, devakUla, sabhA, pavvaya, thUbha, khAiyANaM, parihANaM, pAgAraTTAlaga cariyadAra, gopura, toraNANaM, pAsAyavara saraNaleNa AvaNANaM siMghADaga, tiga, caukka caccara caummuha mahApaha mAiNaM chuhA cickikha lasilA samuccaeNaM baMdhe samupajai jahaNNeNaM aMto muhattaM ukkoseNaM saMkhejakAla se taM samuccaya bNdhe|" artha - have samuccaya baMdha kone kahe che te kahe che, he gautama! kUvA, talAva, nadI, draha, vAvar3I, puSkaraNIvAva, guMjAlI, pAlabaMdha, talAva, talAvanI paMktio, devAlaya, rAjAdikanI sabhA "stUpa" khAI, prakAra, koTa, aTAlI, kAMgarA, dvAra, nagaranA dvAra, toraNa gRha, saraNaleNa, siMghADA nA AkAra nA sthAna, trika, cauka, ghaNA mArgavAluM sthAnacauka-rAjamArga vagere ne samuccaya baMdha kahe che, ane tenA sthiti jaghanya anantara muhUrtanI ane utkRSTI saMkhyAtA kaalnii| ___

Page #20
[19] ********************************************** A uparathI spaSTa samajAzeke devAlaya stUpa vagerenI sthiti saMkhyAtA kAlanI che, ane zAzvata che te koI paNa vyakti vizeSa nathI, mAtra nAma game te hoya tethI kAMI te amukaja hoya ema mAnI zakAya nhiiN| vastutaH zAzvata pratimA e jinezvara devanI pratimA nathI, mAtra jinezvara devanA nAmane malatA nAma che, ane malatA nAma thI jinezvara deva mAnI levAe keTale aMze susaMgata che te vAMcakoja vicArI le| atyAre ghaNAnA nAma mahAvIra hoya che ethI tene vardhamAna mahAvIra mAnIne koI deva temanI sevAmAM Avato nathI, ke vardhamAna nAmanA sAdhune koI prabhu tarIke vAMdatA pUjatA nathI ghaNA rAmacandra nAmanA mANaso mahenata majurI karIne AjIvikA calAve che, paNa nAma mAtra thI te baladeva tarIke pUjAtA nathI, gujarAtI mAM eka duho che ke - "nAma mAtrane sAMbhalI, mohAtA nahIM koy| kanaka nAma dhatura muM, hema kaDA navi hoy||" arthAt - kanaka eTale sonU-suvarNa kharaM ane kanaka eTale dhaturo paNa kharo, kanaka nAme dhaturo levAthI kAMI tenA AbhUSaNoM thor3Akaja banI zake che? nAmanI sAthe tenAmAM te guNa hovo joiye, guNa pUjanIya che nAma nahiM, ghaNIe gaMgA, sarasvatI, godAvarI nAme baheno gaMdhAtI ane gobarI hoya che, e jana samAja thI kyA ajANyuM che? eTale vardhamAnAdi nAma uparathI te pratimA jinezvara nI hovAnuM mAnI levu e matamoha nuM pariNAma hoya tema kema na mAnI zakAya* *A sambandhI paMDita becaradAsajI e lakhela zrI rAyapaseNiya sUtra no gujarAtI anuvAda mAM mAro lakhela upodghAta vaaNco|

Page #21
[20] ********************************************** sUryAbha deva no dAkhalo mUrti pUjA siddha karavA mATe sUryAbha devano dAkhalo bahuvAra ane mukhyatAe apAya che paNa te keTalo avAstavika che teno Aja pustakamAM zrIyuta dosIe bahuja sArI rIte ane spaSTatA thI samajAvela che, eTale e sambandhI vadhu to kAMi lakhavA jevU yogya jaNAtuM nathI chatAM ebAbata paratve jarA vicAra karatAM eka prazna thAya che ke vartamAna sUryAbhadeva paradezI rAjA no jIva che, ane paradezI rAjAe potAnI pAchalI avasthA mAM zrAvaka paNuM-zramaNopAsaka paNuM pAlelaM, tethIte marIne sUryAbhadeva thayA pachI paNa te deva paNAmAM samyaktvI -jainadharmI rahyA che, eTale teNe karela paramparAgata rUr3hi anusAra pratimA pUjanane jinezvara devanI pratimA TharAvAya che, ane namutthuNaM nA pAThano ullekha karAvAya che, parantu sUryAbha deva to dareka kAle hoyaja, ane te sUryAbha devanI jagyA ane nAma kadAca enee hoya, sthAna paratve no nAma kAyama hoya che-parantu devanA AyuSyanI to amuka sthiti hoya che, te sthiti pUrNa thatAM te deva AyuSya pUrNa karI sva karmAnusAra koI paNa gatimAM jAya che, pachI thI eja jagyAe bIjo koI jIva AvIne utpanna thAya che, ane tepaNa sthAna paratvenA nAma thI sUryAbhadeva kahevAya che, e nAma thI olakhAya che, ane te sUryAbha-dareka sUryAbha deva samyaktvI -jainadharmI hoya che-hoyaja-evo koI cokkasa siddhAnta nathIM, tethI sUryAbhadeva mithyAtvI paNa hoya, ane e mithyAtvIdeva paNa paramparAgata rUr3hine anusarI pratimA pUjana jarUra kareja, tyAre paNa zuM te mithyAtvIdeva jinezvara devanI pratimA mAnIne jinezvaradeva pratyenA bhaktibhAva zraddhA thI pUjana karatA haze? ane namotthuNaM no pATha paNa kahetA haze? ane kadAca namotthuNaM no pATha paNa rUr3hi

Page #22
[21] **** ***** anusAra bolavAno niyama hoyato te pATha bolatI vakhate te zraddhA samyaktva pUrvaka te bolatA haze ? nA, nA tema kadIpaNa banavA sambhava nathI, naja bane, eTale e siddha thAya che ke sUryAbhadeva je pratimA pUjana karela che te dharma ke AtmakalyANa nI bhAvanA thI nahi paNa rUr3higata praNAlikA nA bandhana thI, ane tevI kriyA samyaktvI ke mithyAtvI bane kare temAM jarA mahattA nathI, devasthAna mAM devalokAdi mAM zAzvata pratimA hoya che, ane tenuM pUjana te sthAne utpanna thayela devo kare che paNa tethI ema nathI samajavAna ke te dareka pratimA jinezvara devanIja hoya che ane tenA pUjaka devo badhAya samyaktvIja hoya che, kAraNa ke sAmAnya deva hoya ke indrAdi deva hoya te samyaktvI hoya che ane mithyAtvI paNa hoya che, indrAdi devo samyaktvIja hoya amuka jagyAnA deva samyaktvIja hoya, evo cokkasa siddhAnta niyama nathI, dareka jIva dareka sthAne utpanna thayela che, zrI jIvAbhigamajI sUtra mAM cAra prakAranI jIvanI paDivattI mAM vItarAga deva pharamAve che ke " sodhamIsANe suNaM bhaMte kappesu savvepANA savvebhUyA savvejIvA savvesattA puDhavIkAiyatAe jAva vaNasaikAiyatAe devattAe devIttAe AsaNasayaNa jAva bhaMDamata vagaraNatAe uvanna puvvA ? haMtA goyamA asai aduvA aNaMtakhutto savvesu kappesu evaM ceva navaraM no cevaNaM devIttAe jAva gevijavA aNuttarovavAie suvievaM no cevaNaM devattAe devItAe setaM devA / " artha - sudharmA izAna devaloka ne viSe aho bhag2avaMta, sarvaprANI, sarvabhUta, sarvajIva, sarvasatva pRthvIkAya paNe yAvat vanaspati kAya paNe, devatA paNe, devAMganA paNe, siMhAsana, zayyA, jyAna, bhaNDa, upakaraNa paNe atItakAle upanA che? hA~ gautama vAramvAra nizcaya anantI

Page #23
[22] ***************************************** anantIvAra ema sarvadevaloka madhye upanyA che, paNa devAMganA paNe sarva ThekANe nathI upanyA, kAraNa ke bIjA deva loka sudhIja devAMganA che, te uparanAM devaloka mAM devAMganA nathI, te mATe temaja pAMca anuttara vimAne paNa pRthvIkAyAdi paNe anaMtI vAra upanA che paNa devapaNe ke devAMganA paNe utpanna thayA nathI, kAraNa ke devAMganA tyA~ che nahIM, ane deva sarva ekAvatArI che mATe devapaNe saMsArI sarvajIva utpanna thayA nthii|" ___A pATha parathI spaSTa thAya che ke mAtra pAMca anuttara vimAna nA deva ane trIjA devaloka thI devIpaNe utpanna thavA sivAya sarva jagyAe sarva padapara sarva jIvo utpanna thai zake che, eTale bhavya hoya ke abhavya hoya, samyaktvI hoya ke mithyAtvI hoya game te hoya te utpanna thAya, ane je jagyAe je utpanna thAya te sthAna paratve je kAI kriyA pravRtti karavAnI hoya te karavIja par3e, pachIte zraddhA thI kare ke rUDhi praNAlikA ne vazavartI ne kare, paNa karavIja joie emA zaMkA nthii| - zrI bhagavatI jI sUtranA 12 mA~ zataka nA 7 mAM uddezA mAM paNa eja vAta karI che ke - bhagavAn zrI gautama svAmInA pUchaye thake zrI vIra prabhue kahela che ke bIjA devaloka pachI devI paNe ane pA~ca anuttara vimAnanA devapaNe jIva utpanna thayo nathI, te sivAya dareka jIva dareka sthale karma sahita AtmA dareka sthiti mAM utpanna thayela che. eTale indro ane devo bhavya hoya ke abhavya hoya, samyaktvI hoya ke mithyAtvI paNa hoya paNa te sarve jItAcAra mujaba pUrvagata rUr3hi anusAra pratimAdinI pUjA kare, ethI siddha thAya che ke pratimA e jinezvara devanI na hoya, ane pUjanArA badhAe samyaktvI paNa na hoya, lokAntika devonuM paNa emaja ch| arthAt sUryAbha deve pUjela pratimA jinezvara devanIja pratimA hatI evaM che nahIM

Page #24
[23] temaja eNe dharma bhAvanA thI ke Atma kalyANa nI bhAvanA thI pratimA pUjana karyu nathI paNa rUr3hi anusAra karavI joI lI kriyA tarIke e kriyA karI che| ane ema to rAjyAbhiSeka ke evA koI khAsa prasaMge vartamAna kAle paNe hindU rAjAoM ne muslima kriyAne ke muslima rAjAne hindU dharma kriyA ne mAna Apaq par3e che eTaluMja nahiM paNa koI koI kriyA jAte paNa karavI par3e ch| paNa ethI koI ema nathI mAnatu ke hindU rAjA muslima dharma pratye zraddhA rAkhe che ke muslima rAjA hindu dharma pratyeka zraddhA rAkhe che. rAjadharma tarIke je vakhate je khAsa pravRtti rUr3hi anusAra karavI joie te kare, tethI kAMI vizeSatA nthii| ____ A sUryAbhadeva sambandhI ane teNe karela pratimA pUjana saMbandhI vizeSa vigata jANavAnI icchAvAlAe paM0 zrI becaradAsa jI dosI kRta zrI rAyapaseNIya sUtrano gujarAtI anuvAda ane temAM lakhela Aja lekhaka no upodghAta jijJAsuvRtti vAlAe ekavAra jarUra vAMcavo, jemA ghaNI jAtanA khulAsA thayela che, temaja A pustaka nA pR0 36 thI zuru thatuM zAzvatI pratimA ane sUryAbhadeva nuM prakaraNa bahuja zAMtithI ane taTastha vRtti thI vAMcaq ke jethA zrIyuta ratanalAla dozIe karela sapramANa zAstrokta ane buddhi gamya khulAsA thI satya zu che te spaSTa smjaashe| dAr3hA pUjana mUrti pUjAne siddha karavAne mATe mUrti pUjaka bandhuo zrI tIrthakara deva paramapada pAme tyAre pachI temanA sthUla dehano agni-saMskAra thayApachI indrAdi devo te dehanI rAkhane kSIra samudramA padharAve che, ana temanI dAr3hAo ne pote lAI jaIne pUjya vastu tarIke rAkhe che A Upara thI pratimA pUjako mUrti pUjAnI siddhi thayela mAne che ane kahe che ke jo ___

Page #25
[24] ****** dAr3hA pUjanIka che to te jinezvara devanI pratimA pUjanIka kema na hoya ? AvA prakAranI dalIla karI sAmAnya prajA janane mUrti pUjA sAcI che ema ThasAvavA prayatna kare che paNa e vAta barAbara nathI ane to zrI dozIe bahuja spaSTatA thI samajAvela che, vizeSamAM vicArie to enA mATe ve bAvato vicAra vAnI rahe che / **** (1) e dAr3hAo jinezvaradeva tarIke vaMdanIya zarIranIja hatI eTale rAgavaza manuSyo pUjanIya puruSanI - potAnI vastunI kadAca mahattA kare to banavA joga che, ane te paNa dharma dRSTie nahiM, paNa ekAnta rAganI dRSTieja / jyAre pratimA zrI jinezvaradevanI nathI, prati mUrti eto kAlpanika che ane te kAlpanika vastune dharma dRSTie pUjavA vAMdavA thI kalyANa thAya eto koI paNa vicAravanta manuSya kabUlanaja kare / (2) dAdAnI pUjA kulAcAra vaMza paramparAgata rivAja mujaba paNa karAya che| kAraNa ke je deva samyaktvI na hoya te paNa dAdAnuM pUjana praNAlikA ne vazavarti paNe kare che, eTale mithyAtvI devapaNa e dAdAnuM pUjana kareche, eTale te jinezvaradeva pratyenA bhaktibhAva ke zraddhA thI nahiM paNa vyavahAra sAcavavA artheja sivAya kAMI nahiM / e Upara thI saheje samajhI zakAya che ke dAr3hAnI pUjana thI pratimA pUjananI vAtane jarAe puSTi malatI thI, kAraNa ke rAgAdine vazavarti koI paNa manuSya ke deva potAnA priya jananI koI paNa mahattA jAlaveja, e eka sAmAnya bAta che| zrI bhagavatIjI sUtramAM zrI jamAlinA adhikAre pATha che ke - " jamAlissa khattiyakumArassa pareNaM jatteNaM cauraGgala vajje nikkhamaNayayoge agga kesekappar3a taeNaM sA jamAlissa khattiya kumArassa mAyA haMsalakkhaNeNaM paDasADaeNaM agga kese paDicchar3a agga ke se paDi cchittA surabhiNAgaMdhodaeNaM pakkhAlei

Page #26
[25] ********************************************* surabhiNAgaMdhodaeNaM pakkhAlittA aggehivarehiM gaMdhehiMmallehiM acceti 2 suddhavattheNaM baMdhittA rayaNa karaMDaMgasi pakkhivati 2 hAravAridhArA siMduvAra chinna muttAvalippagAsAI suyaviyoga dUsahAI asui viNimuyamANi 2 evaM vyaasii|" "esaNaM amhaM jamAlissa khattiya kumArassa bahusu tihisuya pavvANIsuya ussavesuya jannesuya chaNesuya appacchime darisaNe bhavissati tikaTTa osisaga mUle tthveti|" ___artha - jamAli kSatriya kumAranA niSkramaNa yogya agra kezo cAra AMgala mukIne kApe che, tyArapachI jamAli kSatriya kumAranI mAtA haMsanA jevA zveta paTa sATaka thI te agra kezone grahaNa kare che, grahaNa karIne te kezo ne sugaMdhI gaMdhodaka thI dhue che, dhoine uttama ane pradhAna gaMdha tathA mAlA vaDe pUje che, pUjIne zuddha vastra vaDe bAMdhe che, bAMdhIne ratnA karaMDiyA mAM mUke che, tyArapachI jamAli kSatriya kumAranI mAtA hIra pANInI dhArA siMduvAra nA puSpo ane tuTI gayelI motInI mAlA jevA putranA viyoga thI AMsu pADatI A pramANe bolI ke "A kezo amArA mATe ghaNI tithio, utsavo, yajJo, ane mahotsavo mAM jamAli kumAranA vAraMvAra darzana rUpa thaze" ema dhArIne tene ozikA nA mUlamAM mUke che| rAgane vazathaI mAtA putranA kezo no pUjana kare to pachI zrI jinezvara devanI dAr3hAneM koI paNa pUjana kare to tethI koI pratimA pUjana siddha thatuM nathI, arthAt dAr3hA pUjana e pratimA pUjana nI pratitI nthii| devANaM AsAyaNAe "devANaM AsAyaNAe" zabda no AdhAra laI mUrti pUjA siddha karavAno prayatna bAlakanI ramata jevoja che ke bIjuM kAMI? sAmAnya rIte

Page #27
[26] ****** ******* sAmAnya buddhi vAlo manuSya paNa saheje samajI zake tema che ke koinu paNa kharAba karavuM nahiM eno artha e nathI thato ke tenuM pUjana karavuM ? jJAnIo ane Atma kalyANa ne icchanArAo pApio no paNa anAdara na karavAnuM vAraMvAra samajAve che tenI avagaNanA - tenuM apamAna ke teno tiraskAra na karavAnuM pokArI pokArI ne kahe che, paNa enA sAme ema kahetA nathI ke pApione page lAgoM ke tenuM pUjana arcana karo, tene vaMdanAdi karo ema kadI kahetAja nathI, ane kahe paNa nahiMja eka vastunA anAdara na karo eTale teno Adara karo ema naja hoya, anAdara karavA thI, lAbha nathI tema je vastu AdaraNIya nathI teno Adara naja karavo paNa upekSA vRttija rAkhavI, "devANaM AsAyaNAe" no A hetu che, ane te barAbara che| koI nuM kharAba na karavuM eno artha e nathI thato ke tenI pUjA karavI / manuSya lokamAM vizeSe karIne khAsa karIne vyaMtara devano nivAsa che, ane deva jAti mAM e halakI jAtinAM che, enA saMsarga mAM manuSyo ne haravakhata AvavuM par3e che, kAraNa ke e vyaMtara devo jyAM jyAM rakhaDatA hoya che, koI sthala, koI mandira, koI paNa mUrti vagere ke jene thor3A yA jhAjhA manuSyo athavA sthUla svArtha ne vaza paDelA manuSyo e sthala athavA mUrti vagere ne pUjatA hoya tevA koI paNa sthale te vyaMtaradeva ghusI gayela hoya, kAraNa ke te mAna pUjA nA bahuja abhilASI hoya che e potAnI abhilASA ne tRpta karavA mATe AvA sthalo ne potAnA nivAsa sthAna banAve che, e rIte potAnI pUjA thatI pote mAne che evA sthalonA AzAtanA karavAthI vyaMtarAdi devoke je halakA svabhAva nA che, te devone duHkha thAya, potAnu apamAna thayuM mAne ane ethI e ajANatA paNa AzAtanA karanArane duHkha Ape, ane tethI cAritra dharmamAM dhakko lAge mATe prabhu zrIe pharamAvyuM ke devonI AzAtanA karavI nahiM, paNa

Page #28
[27] ********* ethI pratimAnuM pUjana karavAnu kaI rIte siddha thAya che? zuM jinezvara deva ke je vartamAna kAle bharata kSetra mAM dehadhArI nathI, paNa je je tIrthaMkara devanuM smaraNa thAya che te sarva siddha thayela che, te prabhu temanI pratimAnI andara AvI virAjatA haze ? ke jethI devanI AzAtanA karavAthI jema hAthAya tema tIrthaMkara devanI pratimA pUjavA thI kalyANa thAya? siddha paramAtmA azarIrI che, teo zAzvata che eTale tyAMthI pote AvatA nathI, tameja temanA pratinidhi tarIke koIne mokalatA nathI ke je pratimAjI mAM AvI vAso karI tene pUjanAranuM te kAMI paNa hita karIzake ke karmakSaya mAM madadagAra thaI zake ? aphINa ke somala khAvAthI mANasa marI jAya che, paNa aphINa na khAvAthI ke pUjA-bhakti karavAthI manuSyane amaratva prApta tuM nathI, evAta to sAmAnya buddhi no manuSya paNa samajI zake tema che, TuMkA mAM devANaM AsAyaNAe no pratipAdana karI pratimA pUjana siddha karavA prayatna karavo vyartha prayatna che, ema samajAya che| 20 prakAre tIrthaMkara nAma karma hara koI prakAre abudha janone pratimAjI nA pUjananuM ThasAvavAnuja jyAM mAnasa che tyAM potAnI dalIla ke purAvo vAstavika che ke kema? te paNa bhUlI javAya che, eno pratyakSa purAvo 20 prakAre tIrthaMkara nAmakarma upArjana mAM arihaMtAdi 7 nA arihaMta, siddha pravacana ( tIrthaMkara deva kathita zAstro nu bahumAna paNu) guru, sthavira bahu sUtrI, ane tapasvI, e sAtanA guNagrAma-stuti karatAM temAM jo tadAkAra vRtti thAya to aneka prakAranA karmanI vargaNAo karmanA daliyAone uDADI mukI tIrthaMkara padavInA adhikArI banI zakAya che, ane e bAta to sahu koI samajI

Page #29
[28] zake mache, kAraNa ke stuti karavAthI jenI stuti thAya che te pote ApaNa ne stuti karanArane kAMI paNa ApatA nathI / koI pramANa patra ke adhikAra stuti karanArane jenI stuti thAya che te ApI zakatA nathI / U~ca nIca paNuM, sukha duHkha siddha padake narakamAM nArakIpaNuM e koI nA ApyA apAtA nathI, eto jevo jeno puruSArtha tevuM tene pariNAma | zrI vItarAga prabhu pote paNa eja kahe che ke "appA kattA vikattAya duhANa ya suhANa ya" arthAt sukha duHkhanA karttA ane karma bhoktA AtmA poteja che, anya koI nathI / mATeja pharIeja adhyayanamAM prabhue kahyuM ke "appA mittamamittaM ca dupaTThiyaM supaTThiyaM" potAno mitra ane zatru AtmA poteja che, anya koI nahiM / jo tIrthaMkara prabhu pote koI ne deva nArakI banAvI zakatA hota to zreNika rAjA zrI kRSNa vAsudeva ane eka anekane narkanA duHkho bhogavavA par3ataja nahiM, eTale sukha duHkha e svaupArjita vastu che, sthiti che parantu je dhyeya je jenA guNAnuvAda thAya che, te dhyAtA nA Adarza rUpe hoya che ane Adarzane pahuMcavA mATe teno smaraNa nirantara joiyeja, mATe guNagrAma stutinI mahattA dareka dharmanA paMthA AcArya devo ane avatArI AtmAoe gAI che ane te barAbara che, parantu te stuti te guNAnuvAda dehanA nAmanA ke jar3a vastunA nahiM paNa caitanyanA kAraNa ke ananta jJAna darzanano dhAraka siddha svarUpI ane zAzvata guNa no dhAraka AtmA che, nahiM ke deha athavA jar3amUrti / jar3a to nAzavaMta ane tyAjya vastu che, tenI upayogitA to temAM ananta guNa dhAraka AtmA hoya tyAM sudhIja pachI jarAe nahiM / jo jar3a vastu pUjanIya vaMdanIya hoyato zrI tIrthaMkara deva nA sthUla udArika deha mAMthI AtmA parama pade pahoMcyA pachI te zarIrane devo potAnI zakti vaDe tene hajAro varasa sudhI jAlavI rAkhata, ane tenI pUjA arcanA karata, paNa

Page #30
[29] jar3a vastu pUjanIya na hovAthIja zrI jinezvara devanA zarIrane agnine AdhIna kare che, athavA agni saMskAra karI tenI rAkhane kSIra samudra mAM padharAvI de che| A Upara thI spaSTa thAya che ke guNagrAma karavAnA che te caitanyanA, ane vaMdanIya pUjanIya che te paNa caitanya jar3a nahiM, eTale tIrthaMkara nAma karmanI upArjanA tIrthaMkara deva tarIke rahelA AtmAnA nahiM tenA zarIranA, ke tenI mUrtinA, guNagrAma karavAne vyavahAra mAM paNa "amuka ghara ghaNuM khAnadAna che" emaje vakhANAya che te ghara eTale patthara IMTa ke cUnA mATI thI baneluM te nahiM paNa e gharamA rahenAra manuSyo sad cAritravAna - uttama nIti vAlA hoya tethIjae ghara vakhANAya che, manuSya thI gharanI mahattA che kAMI gharathI manuSyanI kImata nathI, arthAt tIrthaMkara nAma karmanuM nimitta tIrthaMkara devanAguNa grAmache, nahiM ke tIrthaMkara devanI banAvaTI mUrti / jyAM mUrti pUjA ghusAr3avAnI vRttivAluM mAnasa che tyAM potAnuM kathana potAno purAvo keTalo vAstavika che, keTale aMze sapramANa che teno kAMI paNa vicAra karyA binA mAtra jema AvyuM tema kahI ke lakhI nAkhe che eto ghaNI utAvala che / bali karma karma mAM mUrti pUjA kaI rIte samANI ? teno koI vicAra ke hetu binA mAtra balikarma eTale prabhUnI mUrtinI pUjA, balikarma mAtra jaina kareche evaM to kAMI che nahiM, samyaktvI yoya ke mithyAtvI hoya, paNa jyAM snAnanI - deha zuddhinI kriyA hoya tyAM balikarma hoyaja / tIrthaMkara deva nA vyAkhyAnamAM jatI vakhate balikarma hoya ane vezyA ne tyAM jatI vakhate paNa balikarma hoya, rAja kacerI mAM jatI vakhate paNa hoya ane

Page #31
[30] ******************* **************** yuddha mAM jatI vakhate paNa hoya ema jyA jyAM snAna che tyAM balikarma hoyaja, eTale dareka ThekANe jinezvara devanI pratimAjInI pUjA na hoya eto saheje samajI zakAya ema che, chatAM balikarma eTale pratimA pUjana kathA zAstra nA AdhAre samajAvavA mAM Ave che, pUjaka bhAio samajAvaze? zrI jJAtAjI sUtranA prathama adhyayana mAM pATha che ke - "tatteNaM sumiNapAThagA seNiyassaranno koDaMbiya purisehiM saddAviyA samANA haTTha tuTThA jAva hiyayA NhAyA kayabalikammA jAva paaycchittaa|" arthAt - tyAra pachI te svapnapAThako zreNika rAjanA koTumbika nA bolAvyAthI haSTa tuSTa yAvat Anandita hRdaya vAlA thayA, nhAyA balikarma karyu yAvat kautuka maGgala prAyazcitta karyu arthAt pAchalI avasthA ttaalii| eja adhyayana mAM meghakumAra dIkSA levA taiyAra thayA tyAre hajAmane bolAve che, te hajAma paNa snAna balikarma karIne Ave che ema dareka ThekANe snAnanI sAthe balikarma kahela che, eTale snAna hoya tyAM balikarma hoyaja, ane te bakilarma pAThanI pAchala "pAyacchittA" pATha paNa hoyaja, ethI balikarma eTale snAnanI vizeSa zuddhinI kriyA-zarIranA pratyeka aGgopAMganI kAlajI pUrvakanI zuddhi keTalAka snAna kare che tyAre mAtra zarIra para pANI Dhole, paNa pratyeka aGgopAMganI zuddhi tarapha bedarakAra rahe to bhaviSya mAM snAna karavA chatAM rahelI azuddhinA kAraNe ghaNA rogo utpanna thAya che, ane jo vidhi pUrvaka snAna thAyato ghaNA rogo utpanna thatA aTakI jAya che e azuddhi TAlavA mATenI khAsa kAlajI eja balikarma, kAraNa ke enA pachIno je pATha "pAyacchittA"

Page #32
[31] *** **** te sUcave che ke snAna ane balikarma karIne pAchalI eTale snAna karyA palAnI je je zArIrika azuddhi-doSa hatA te sarva ne dUra karyA / have jo balikarma no artha deva pUjA karavAmAM Ave to te devapUjAno azuddhimAM samAveza thAya che, kAraNa ke balikarma karavuM e azuddhi zArIrika azuddhi TAlavAnuM snAna sAdhenuM eka kArya che, eTale e paNa tyAjya che ane jo deva pUjA tyAjya hoya to pachI tenI mahattA kAMI chejanahiM arthAt balikarma no artha zarIra zuddhinI kAlajI pUrvakanI eka kriyA sivAya zuM hoi zake ? dharma prANa loMkAzAhanA vaMzajo dharmaprANa lokAzAhanA vaMzaja koI yatie mUrtipUjAnI mahattA gAI hoya ke mUrtipUjA karI hoya ethI mUrti pUjA jo siddha thatI hoya to vartamAna kAle koI koI zvetAmbara mUrtipUjaka sAdhujI relamA musAphirI kare che eTaluMja nahiM, paNa relamA musApharI karavAnuM te pratipAdana kare che, dariyA mArge jAvAmA sTImaramA bese che ane tema besavuM e dharma viruddha nathI paNa dharma pracAranuM eka kalyANa kAraka aGga che ema parUpe che, eTale have rela vihArI sAdhujI ne Adarza mAnI tenuM anukaraNa sarva AcAryoM ane sarva sAdhujI ane sAdhvIjIe jarUra karavuMja joie ne? ane jo relve musApharI karavAmAM Ave to gRhastho paranoM ghaNo Arthika bojo ocho thAya tema che eTale jaina sAdhu ne varjita evA relavihAra ne mAnanArAo nuM anukaraNa sAdhu sAdhvIjI kare to mukhyatAe be lAbha to thAya tema che / (1) koI zarIra nA kAraNe ke vRddhAvasthA ne kAraNe lAMbo vihAra karI zakatA nathI teone DolI mAM bezI ne manuSya kAMdhA para car3hInemanuSyoM ne takalIpha ApIne je gAmo gAma vihAra karavo par3e che ane ene

Page #33
[32] **************************************** aMge bhaktoM ne saikar3oM athavA hajAroM nA je kharca karavA par3e che temAM teone ghaNI rAhata male ane kharcI ghaNoja ocho thaI jaay| (2) bIjo lAbha sAdhu sAdhvIjI sAthe bojo upAr3anAra gAmogAma thI je mANaso-majuro levA par3e che ane te majuro nuM kharca je keTalAka nAnA gAmoM ne te ghaNuja bhAre par3e che te paNa ochu thaI jAya ane gAmar3A vAlA ne te kharca mAM thI ghaNI rAhata mle| eTale rela vihAra karanAra ne Adarza mAnIne have suvihita kahevAtA satpuruSoM paNa relve vihAra nI zuruAta karI devI joie paNa hu~ dhAruM chu tyAM sudhI suvihita AcAryoM-saMtoM relve vihAra karanAra ke aivA sAdhu dharma thI viruddha AcaraNa AcaranAra nA kAryanI koI paNa anumodanAe karatA nathI, temaja dharmaprANa loMkAzAha nA koI vaMzaja loMkAzAha nI zuddha dharma praNAlikA thI viruddha ane azuddha AcaraNa Acareke viparIta parUpaNA kare tethI teno purAvo sajjanoM to naja aape| ane tenA purAvA thI potAnA koI mAnyatA siddha karavA mAMge to tenA mATe vicAravaMto to jarUra hAsya ja kre| eTale pratimAjI nA pUjana nI sAbitI artha lokAzAha nA koI zraddhAbhraSTa ziSya no purAvo Apavo eto narI bAla ceSThAja che| AloyaNA AloyaNA eto aMtaHkaraNa no pazcAttApa ch| sAcI AlocanA eto anaMta janmAMtaro nA pApane bAlanAra prabala agni ch| e pazcAttApae AlocanA koI thI karAvI zakAtI nathI, A jagata mAM koI evI sattA nathI koI evI zakti nathI ke koI nA pApa no nAza karAvI shke| pApa karma nA nAza - amogha zastra to e ekaja che| sAMcA dila no

Page #34
[33] ******************************************** pazcAtApa-aMtaHkaraNa nI AlocanA mATe zrImAn "kalApI" svaruMja kahe che ke - "hA? pastAvo vipula jharaj, svarga thI utaryu ch| pApI temAM DubakI daI ne, puNyazAlI bane ch| aho! kevU smaraNa madhuraM, pApa, e dhare ch| mAphI pAmyuM kudarata kane, ema mAnI gale che| / rAjyo thI ke julamavatI ke, daNDa thI nA bane ch| te pastAvo sahaja vahatA, kArya sAdhI zake che| huM pastAyo prabhu! praNayI e mAphI ApI mane ch| hu~ pastAyo muja hRdaya nI, pUrNa mAphI malI che|" Avo parama pavitra pazcAttApa e paramAtmA-ananta jJAnI paramAtmAnI sAkSIe hoI zake, ke jeo pazcAttApa nA zuddha svarUpane yathArtha rUpe samajI zake evA-sarvajJa prabhunI hAjarI nA abhAve kadAca koI vartamAna kAle jeo zAstrajJa hoya, hRdayanA udAra ane sarala hoya, jeo zAstrAnusAra vartana karanAra hoya tevAnI sAkSIe AloyaNA karavAnI hoya, ane temanA abhAve koI samabhAvo udAracitta saMghanI sAkSIe AloyaNA thaI shke| parantu je jar3a padArtha che, jene mana saMkalpa vikalpa jevI vastupaNa nathI, jenejJAna darzana paNa nathI tenI sAkSI hoija zu zake? sAkSIne potAne potAnuM jJAna bhAna nathI tevA khare khara jar3a padArthanI sAkSIe AloyaNA naja hoI shke| koI paNa jainAgama mAM pratimA jInI sAkSI AloyaNA mATe kahI hoya tevU jANavAmAM nthii| jainettara samAja ke jar3apUjA mAM ghaNA vakhata thayA mAnato Aveche te samAja mAM paNa koI gunhegAra ne gunhA nI kabUlAta karAvavI hoya tyAre temanA pUjya devanI mUrti samakSa lAvIne sogana khavarAve che, paNa te vakhate paNa te jJAtinA

Page #35
[34] ** AgevAna paTeliyAo ke evA koI jarUra hAjara hoyaja che, ane temanI sAkSI sogana khAvAnuM kAma thAya te / parantu koI paNa dunhegArane pratimAjI pAse ekalo mokalIne gunhAnA sambandhamAM sogana khAvAnuM kahevAmAM AvatuM nathI, to pachI jyAM ekAnta AtmabhAvanA che, jyAM jJAna darzananIja mukhya mahattA che tevAone jar3a pratimA pAse jaine enA sAkSIe AloyaNA karavAnuM koI sAmAnya buddhi vAloe kabUla na kare to pachI jJAnI devato mI AjJA kareja kema? arthAt naja kare / nathIja karI 1 A sambandhI zrIyut dosIe je je yukti yukta javAba ApyA che te jarUra samaju vicAraka ne to mAnya thAya temacha, bIjAne mATe to kahevA jevuMja zuM rahe che jene zAstrakAro ekAnta adharmI kahIne olakhAvela che tevA paradezI rAjAe je pApa karma no kSaya karyo ane AtmAne karma thI halavo banAvyo te jJAnI samakSa antaHkaraNa nA sAMcA pazcAttApa thii| koI paNa pratimAnI sAkSIe nathI arthAt jar3a sAkSIe sAkSIja nathI, paNa kharekhara Atma vaMcanAja che / pratimAnI prAcInatA pratimAnI prAcInatA kahI batAvIne te pUjanIya che ema kahevuM eto bholA bAlako ne bharamAvI unmArga gAmI banAvA jevuM che kAraNa ke pratimAjInI prAcInata e koI mahatvanI bAbata nathI, kAraNa ke ghaNI tyAjya vastu paNa pratimAjI thIe ananta kAlanI prAcIna che / pApa Azrava bandha vagere ghaNA prAcIna che / somalAdi viSa jherae paNa bahuka lanA junA che, evI aneka vastuo anAdi kAlanI prAcIna che paNa tethI te grAhya che, vandanIya pUjanIya che, ema koI paNa DAhyo manuSya naja khe| ane vastu svarUpe prAcIna hoyake na hoya paNa prAcIna karI batAvavuM -

Page #36
[35] hoyato te sahelAI thI thaI zake che, vihAra daramyAna ameM zatruMjA, giranAra, amadAbAda, khaMbhAta, saMkhezvara, pATaNa, AbU, delavAr3A, acalagar3ha, serIzA, pAnasara, vagere sthale mhArI samaja zakti mujaba ghaNA derAsarajI ane derAsaramAM rahela pratimAjI dhyAna pUrvaka joyela che to pratimAjI o vikrama saMvat 12 nA saikA pahelAnI pratimA kyAMya jovA mAM nathI Avela, mAtra ekaja pratimA saMkhezvarajI nA tIrtha dhAmamA saMvat 11 nA saikAnI che, te sivAya bIje kyAMya 12 nA saikA pahelAnI pratimAjI mhArA jovAmA nathI Avela chatA~ dalIla khAtara pratimAnI prAcInatA kabUla karAya to te thI vaMdanIya pUjanIya che ema koI rIte sAbita thatuM nathI, thAyaja nahiM mATe prAcInatA kahIne bholA lokone bharamAvavA e koI rIte buddhimAna manuSya nuM kAma nathI / sArAMza zrIyut ratanalAla dozIe bahu vizAla vAMcana, manana ane adhyayana pachIja yukti yukta sapramANa dalIlo thI zrImAn munivarya zrI jJAnasundarajI ne je jabAba ApyA che te temaNe pote ane anya vicAraka vA~cako e taTastha ane zAnta vRtti thI banne pustako sAthe rAkhIne vA~cavA, anehuM dhAruM chaM tyA~ sudhI taTastha vRtti thI vA~canArane A pustaka jarUra AdaraNIya a vastu svarUpa samajAvanAra ane sanmArga nA sAcA bhomiyA jevuMja jaNAze, emA~ zaGkA nathI / - AtmakalyANanI sAdhanA koI paMNa jar3a vastu pachIte sthUla padArtha rUpe hoke sthUla kriyA rUpe hoya tenAthI thatI nathI kAraNa ke te sAdhana pote kA~I koI nuM kalyANa ke akalyANa karatuM nathI paNa se sAdhana no sadupayoga ke durupogaja kalyANa akalyANa no nimitta bane

Page #37
[36] ***************************************** che, paNa tethI te nimitta ne valago rahI bIjAne paNa eja nimitta ne svIkAravAno Agraha karavo ane te na svIkAre eTale tene gAlo devIke apavAda karavo te koI no paNa dharma nathI paNa e dharma bhraSTatA ch| ___karakaMDu RSine balada ne joine vairAgya thayo tethI teo bIjAne ema na kahI zake ke sarva koIe balada rAkhI tenI vRddhAvasthA joine vairAgyavIna thq| zrI mallinAtha prabhunA pUrva bhavanA chaH mitra rAjAo mallinAtha prabhunI pratimAnI gaMdha thI kaTAlyA ane te vakhate malli prabhue upadeza Apyo tethI chaH rAjAone strI zarIra ane viSayabhogano anityatA, asthiratA, ane aniSTatA samajANI ethI zrI mallinAtha prabhue potAnI dezanA mA~ kyA~ya na kahyu ke dareka vairAgyavAna strIe potAne ghare potAnI pratimUrti jevI eka mUrti banAvIne temA annanA koliyA nAkhI tene saDAvI ga~dhAvIne puruSone vairAgya pamADavo, ema kadI baneja nahiM, ane vairAgya, nimitta sthUla ane jar3a e vaMdanIya pUjanIya na hoy| athavA je sAdhana dvArA Atma sAdhanA karAtI hoya, thatI hoya, e sAdhana to anAzakti paNe upayoga karIne tene tyAgI devUja par3e, jo tenApara saheja paNa mUrchA bhAva Ave to teto parigraha gaNAya, ane parigraha eTalerAga, ane rAga hoya tyAM dveSa hoyaja, ane rAgadveSa eja karmanA bIja e bIjane bAlyA sivAya AtmakalyANa kadI na saMbhave, eto sarvakoI samajI zake tema che, to pachI sthUla jar3a sAdhanane valagI rahI e sAdhana Upara mamatvabhAva rAkhIne potAne azAnti rAga dveSano vadhAro karavo, ane anyane azAnti karAvavI e vuddhajana no kAma nthii| Atma kalyANa nu sthUla jar3a paNa ati nikaTanuM parama sAdhana zarIra che, tenApara paNa mUrchA bhAva na rAkhavAnuM zrI vItarAga deva ane sarva mahApuruSo pokArI 2 ne kahe che, ane te eTale sudhIke e sthUla zarIrane koI niMde ke

Page #38
[37] vaMde, koI tenu pUjana kare ke prahAra kare te sarvamAM samabhAva rAkhI mamatva bhAvathI rahita thaI ne Atma sAdhanA karavI, evo parama puruSa zrI vItarAga devano upadeza che, to pachI zAstramAM jenI pUjA arcanAno ullekha sarakho e na hoya tevI jar3a mUrti - pratimAjInI parANe pUjA karAvI ane te nimitta rAgadveSa vadhArIne AtmakalyANa karAvavAno dhakhAro karavo te keTalo satvahIna che? te vAMcaka varga ne samajAvavuM par3e tema nathI / potAnI samajaNa zakti mujaba potAne je kalyANa kAraka lAgatuM hoya tene pramANika paNete svIkAre ke satkAre temAM bIjA koIne bAMdho hoI zakeja nahiM, paNa potAnI mAnyatA anya sarva koIe svIkAravIja joi evo durAgraha karanArane mATe eTaluMja kahI zakAya kete zrI vItarAganA mArgane vItarAgadevanI dharmane thor3e aMzepaNa samajyAjanathI, ane ethIe vadhu kharAba te eche ke potAnI mAnyatA thI itara mAnyatA vAlAne dveSa buddhi thI niMdavA, tenA sadguNane paNa durguNa nA rUpamAM citaravA, aneka prakAranA avarNavAdI bolavA, eto harakoIne mATe kharekhara pAmaratAja che, eTaluMja nahiM paNa sAmAne kaSAyAdi utpanna karAvI pote anaMta saMsArI banavAnI sAthe anyane paNa e cakrAvA mAM ghasar3e che| vastu svarUpe ema hovuM joie ke potAnI mAnyatA thI viruddha mAnyatA vAlAne zAnti thI samajAvavA upadezavA ane ema karIne potAnA sahadharmI banAvavA, e prayatna avagaNanA karavA lAyaka nathI, parantu potAnI mAnyatA sAmI vyakti na svIkAre to tenI upekSA karavI, paNa tenI avagaNanA ke tenApara krodhAdi karIne AtmaghAtato naja karavo joie / jo viruddha vicAra dharAvanAra pratye upekSA vRttithI jovAyato paraspara bhale sambandha sneha kadAca na vadhe paNa paraspara baira to naja thAya, paNa viruddha vicAra mAnyatAvAlA ne zAstranA nAme jo vagovavA mAM Ave to

Page #39
[38] ************ pachI sAmAM kAMI badhAe vItarAga avasthAne pAmelA hotA nathI, enepaNa thor3e ghaNe aMze rAga dveSato hoyaja, cheja, ane e rAgadveSano agnibhArelA agnine A matAgrahIe phUMka mArI ne pradipta karyo, pachI pradipta thala agnine turtamAM ThAravA mAM ne Ave to lAkhonuM nukasAna karI bese che, e sthitinA gunhegAra prathamanI mamatvI vyaktija ke samUhaja hoyache / gujarAtImAM kahevata che ke " bolavu na hatuM paNa moMDA mAM AMgalI nAkhIne bolAve tyAre zuM karavuM" arthAt potAnI mAnyatA thI judI rIte AcaraNa rAkhanAra ne "yena kena prakAreNa " niMdavA tene juThA pAkhaMDI kahI vagovavA no dhandho laI besanArAo sAmAne parANe bolavAnI pharaja pAr3e che ane zrImAn munivarya zrI jJAnasuMdarajI e paNa kAMika evuMja karyu che " mUrti pUjAkA prAcIna itihAsa" nAmanI pustikA munizrI lakhI paNa te jo maMDanAtmaka lakhI hotato sthAnakavAsI - amUrtipUjaka nA koI paNa pustaka sambandhI kAMI kahevAnuM hoyaja nahiM / paNa pratimAjI no itihAsa lakhatA sthAnakavAsI samAjane bhAMDavA kAma karyu tyAre zrI ratanalAla dozIne A pustaka lakhavAnI jarUra par3I, ana te jarUriyAta pUravA mATe nivRtti parAyaNa ane dharma pracAra karavA mATe tyAgI jIvana gujAranAra sAdhu-dharma guruonuM mukhya karttavya hatuM, ane che, te kArya gRhasthAzramanI aneka pravRttithI viMTAela zrI ratanalAla dozIe karyu che, te samAja Upara mahAn upakAra karyo che, ane jo amUrtipUjaka ( sthAnakavAsI) samAjamAM kAMI paNa kRtajJatA hoyato zrI ratanalAla dozIno samAje upakAra mAnavo joie, vadhu nahiM to chevaTa A pustakanI hajAro nakalo dhanavAnoe kharIda karIne gAmme gAma to zuM paNa gharoghara bheMTa ApavI joie, mhArI A yAcanA dhaniko sAMbhalaze ? svIkAra ze? ane thor3e aMze paNa sArthaka karaze ?

Page #40
zrI ratanalAla dozInuM baholuM vAMcana, ghaNo abhyAsa vagere jotAM A pustakanI bhUmikA lakhavA mATe koI vadhu samartha vadhu vidvAn ane zAstrajJane A kAma soMpavu joituM hatuM parantu temanI icchA mhArI pAsethI AsevA levAnI thaI, ane tenA mATe temano Agraha thayo, eTale AyatkiMcita sevA samAja caraNe dharuMchu ane te paNa mhArA hamezanA sahAyaka vinayamUrti munivarya zrI lakSmIcandrajI mahArAjanI parama sahAya thIja / [39] mhArI pharI pharI sarva koIne bhalAmaNa - vinaMti che ke jeo thor3e aMze paNa hiMdI bhASA vAMcI samajI - zakatA hoya temaNe A pustaka jarUra vAMcavuM / zrI ratanalAla dozInA AvA zubha prayatnamAM vadhu saphalatA male tevuM icchI A bhUmikA lakhavAmAM je kAMI jinAjJA viruddha lakhAyuM hoya te sarva ne mATe zrI arihaMta, zrI gurudeva, zrI saMghanI ane AtmAnI sAkSIe mithyAme duSkRtam / - vihAra sthala jAmanagara beDI baMdara zrI digvijayasiMhajI solTa varkasa (sthAnakavAsI jaina, liMbaDI saMpradAya) vi0 saMvat 1968 vIra saM0 2468 nA prathama jeTha vada 13 guruvAra li0 sadAnaMdI jaina muni choTAlAlajI

Page #41
viSayAnukramaNikA prakaraNa viSaya 1. praveza 2. dharma mArga 3. prAraMbha meM hI patha bhraSTa 4. vizva vyApakatA kI mithyA yukti 5. kyA sadAcAra Adi ke lie mUrti pUjA Avazyaka hai ? 6. sAkSAt aura mUrti meM antara 7. mithyA prazaMsA 8. zAzvatI pratimAeM aura sUryAbha deva (1) devaloka kI pratimAeM tIrthaMkara pratimA nahIM hai (a) mUrtiyoM kA zAzvata pana (A) aruNa netra (i) vastra paridhAna (I) pUjana vidhi zarIra varNa meM bhinnatA pratimA parivAra nAma nizcitatA (2) sUryAbha sAkSI kI anupAdeyatA (3) mUrti pUjA aura jinAjJA 6. dAr3hA pUjana 10. bharatezvara ke mUrti nirmANa kI asatyatA

Page #42
***** [41] prakaraNa viSaya 11. zreNika aura mUrti pUjA 12. campA nagarI aura arihaMta caitya 13. pUyaNa vattiyaM 14. camarendra auraM mUrti kA zaraNa 15. devANaM AsAyaNAe 16. Ananda zramaNopAsaka 17. aMbar3a parivrAjaka aura mUrti pUjA 18. tuMgikA ke zramaNopAsaka 16. cAraNa muni aura mUrti pUjA 20. draupadI aura mUrti pUjA samakitasAra kA pATha zrI0 harSacandrajI ma. ke nAma se jhUThA pracAra 21. kathAoM ke udAharaNa 22. loMkA gacchIya yati 23. sthApanAcArya kA mithyA aDaMgA 24. vyavahAra sUtra kA samabhAvita caitya 25. paTTAvalI ke nAma se prapaMca 26. svarNa gulikA se mUrti kA mithyA sambandha 27. sthApanA satya meM samajha phera 28. DaoN0 haramana jekobI kA aTala abhiprAya 26. stUpa nirmANa kA kAraNa ********** pRSTha 67 73 to 62 66 101 121 126 138 144 154 158 156 166 166 176 181 184 186 162 168

Page #43
[42] pRSTha . ja ma 0 244 prakaraNa viSaya 30. bhakti yA apamAna 31. sAdhumArgI jaina mUrti pUjaka nahIM haiM 32. vikRti kA sahArA 33. mUrtiyoM kI prAcInatA se dharma kA sambandha mUrti nirmANa kA kAraNa mUrtiyoM ke sabhI lekha sacce nahIM haiM prAcIna hone mAtra se upAdeya nahIM AgamoM ke sAmane isakA koI mUlya nahIM 34. kyA jaina sAdhu aisA upadeza de sakate haiM? 35. caitya zabda ke artha 36. battIsa sUtroM ke nAma se gappa 37. kyA TIkA Adi bhI mUla kI taraha mAnanIya hai? 38. mUrti pUjA viSayaka granthoM kI aprAmANikatA 36. mUrti pUjA viruddha pramANa saMgraha jainAgama. viruddha mUrti pUjA na tIna meM na teraha meM mUrti pUjaka mAnya pramANoM se mUrti pUjA kA virodha ajaina vidvAn aura mUrti pUjA 40. upasaMhAra kA saMhAra 41. niSkarSa 42. pariziSTa 43. upayogI padya 264

Page #44
mUlya saMgha ke prakAzana 5. nAma 1. aMgapaviTThasuttANi bhAga 1 2. aMgapaviTThasuttANi bhAga 2 3. aMgapaviTThasuttANi bhAga 3 4. aMgapaviThThasuttANi saMyukta 5.anaMgapaviTThasattANi bhAga 1 6. anaMgapaviTThasuttANi bhAga 2 7. anaMgapaviTThasuttANi saMyukta 8. aMtagaDadasA sUtra 9. anuttarovavAiya sUtra 10. AcArAMga sUtra bhAga 1 11. AcArAMga sUtra bhAga 2 12. AyAro 13. Avazyaka sUtra (sArtha) 14. uttarajjhayaNANi (guTakA) 15. uttarAdhyayana sUtra . 16. upAsaka dazAMga sUtra 17. uvavAiya sutta 18. dasaveyAliya suttaM (guTakA) 19. dazavaikAlika sUtra 20. NaMdI sutaM 21. nandI sUtra 22. praznavyAkaraNa sUtra 23-29. bhagavatI sUtra bhAga 1-7 30-31. sthAnAGga sUtra bhAga 1-2 32. samavAyAMga sUtra 33. sukhavipAka sUtra 34. sUyagaDo 35. sUyagaDAMga sUtra bhAga 1 36. sUyagaDAMga sUtra bhAga 2 37. mokSa mArga grantha bhAga 1 38.mokSa mArga grantha bhAga 2 39-41.tIrthaMkaracaritra bhA0 1,2,3 42. tIrthaMkara pada pApti ke upAya 43. samyaktva vimarza 44. Atma sAdhanA saMgraha 45. Atma zuddhi kA mUla tattvatrayI 46. nava tattvoM kA svarUpa .47. sAmaNNa savidhammo 48. agAra-dharma 49-51. samartha samAdhAna bhAga 1,2,3 52. tatva-pRcchA 53. tetalI-putra 54. zivira vyAkhyAna 55. jaina svAdhyAya mAlA 56. svAdhyAya sudhA 57. AnupUrvI 58. bhaktAmara stotra "... ...MOVo 000000000000000 0000000000000000000 m . morrrrrrrrror 50.50.55055500 40.00000000000000 R0000000000000000 ors500 0900901 000000000 0000000000 aprApya .

Page #45
jaina stuti maMgala prabhAtikA siddha stuti saMsAra taraNikA AlocanA paMcaka vinayacanda caubIsI bhavanAzinI bhAvanA stavana taraMgiNI sudharma stavana saMgraha bhAga 1 sudharma stavana saMgraha bhAga 2 sudharma caritra saMgraha sAmAyika sUtra sArtha sAmAyika sUtra pratikramaNa sUtra jaina siddhAnta paricaya jaina siddhAnta pravezikA jaina siddhAnta prathamA jaina siddhAnta kovida jaina siddhAnta pravINa 102 bola kA bAsaThiyA tIrthaMkaroM kA lekhA jIva-dhar3A laghu-daNDaka mahA-daNDaka tetIsa bola guNasthAna svarUpa gati - Agati karma-prakRti samiti-gupti samakita ke 67 bola 25 bola nava-tattva jaina siddhAnta thoka saMgraha bhAga 1 jaina siddhAnta thoka saMgraha bhAga 2 jaina siddhAnta thoka saMgraha bhAga 3 jaina siddhAnta thoka saMgraha saMyukta patravaNA sUtra ke thokar3e bhAga 1 pannavaNA sUtra ke thokar3e bhAga 2 patravaNA sUtra ke thokar3e bhAga 3 Saarth Saamaayik Sootra sAmAyika saMskAra bodha prajJApanA sUtra bhAga 1 prajJApanA sUtra bhAga 2 . prajJApanA sUtra bhAga 3 prajJApanA sUtra bhAga 4 caucheyasuttAI jIvAjIvAbhigama sUtra bhAga 1 lokAzAha mata samarthana jinAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA mukha vastrikA siddhi vidyut ( bijalI ) sacitta teUkAya hai 6-00 aprApya 3-00 7-00 200 1-00 2-00 5-00 22-00 15-00 10-00 1-00 4-00 3-00 3-00 4-00 4-00 3-00 4-00 0-50 1-00 2-00 2-00 1-00 2-00 2-00 1-00 2-00 2-00 2-00 3-00 7-00 10-00 10-00 10-00 15-00 8-00 10-00 6-00 10-00 7-00 40-00 40-00 40-00 40-00 15-00 35-00 10-00 15-00 3-00 3-00

Page #46
// NamotthuNaM samaNassa bhagavao mahAvIrassa // jainAgama ciruddha mUrti pUjA praveza jaina dharma nivRtti pradhAna dharma hai / nivRtti kA artha hai -alaga rahanA, AtmA se bhinna bAhya padArthoM (pudgaloM) se virakta rahanA nivRtti mArga hai| aura pudgaloM meM Asakta rahanA hai - pravRtti mArga / jaba taka prANI pudgala se apanA sambandha nahIM chor3atA aura ghara, hATa, havelI, dhana, dhAnya, strI, parivAra, vastra, AbhUSaNa tathA vAhana Adi meM lipta rahakara pravRtti kI ora hI bar3hatA jAtA hai, taba taka usako AtmazAMti prApta honA asambhava evaM azakya hI hai| jyoM-jyoM AtmA kI pudgala zakti ghaTatI jAyagI, tyoM-tyoM utthAna hotA jAyagA, kyoMki pudgala prema hI AtmA ko bhArI banAkara bhavabhramaNa ke cakkara meM DAlatA hai| isIlie jainAgamoM meM nivRtti ko hI pradhAnatA dI gaI hai| jaina samAja ke sAdhu-mahAtmA isa siddhAMta ke pratyakSa pramANa haiM, isI uddezya se unheM nirgratha vizeSaNa se sambodhana kiyA gayA hai| yadi yahA~ koI zaGkA kare ki jaba pudgala tyAga hI dharma hai taba phira sUtroM meM sAdhuoM ke liye AhAra, pAnI, vastra, pAtra Adi ke upayoga karane kA vidhAna kyoM kiyA gayA ? isakA samAdhAna yaha hai ki - AtmA zarIra ke AdhAra se rahatA hai, zarIra dvArA hI AtmA ne karma bandhana kiye haiM aura karma bandha ke phala svarUpa hI yaha zarIra prApta huA hai| jaba taka AtmA karma bandhana se mukta na ho jAya taba

Page #47
praveza taka azarIrI (siddha) nahIM ho sakatA (bhale hI eka zarIra ko chor3akara dUsare meM calA jAya) ataeva azarIrI hone ke liye AtmA ko isa zarIra meM rahakara hI Atma-kalyANa karanA hotA hai| jaba zarIra meM rahakara hI Atma-sAdhanA hotI hai taba deha ko TikAye rakhane kI bhI AvazyakatA hai| deha Tike rahane para hI jJAna, darzana, cAritra aura tapa kI vizeSa ArAdhanA kara karma bandhana se AtmA halkA hotA huA Urdhva gamana karatA hai| aisI avasthA meM zarIra ko TikAne ke liye khAna, pAna aura vastrAdi kI AvazyakatA bhI anivArya hai| isIlie AtmakalyANa aura paropakArArtha AvazyakatA ke anusAra nirmamatva buddhi se sAdhuoM ke bhojana pAna aura vastrAdi se zarIra nirvAha karane kA AgamoM meM vidhAna hai| Agama ke abhyAsI isa bAta ko acchI taraha jAnate haiN| isake sivAya dharmopakaraNa meM rajoharaNa mukhavastrikA Adi bhI cAritrArAdhana-AtmotthAna-meM mukhya sAdhana hai| jinake sadupayoga se sAdhaka mahAtmA choTe-choTe jantuoM kI rakSA karate hue apanI saMyama yAtrA meM prayatnazIla rahate haiN| pramArjana karane ke liye rajoharaNa aura niravadya (nirdoSa) bhASA bolane ke lie mukhavastrikA kA honA paramAvazyaka hai| jisase prathama to ahiMsA mahAvrata kA pUrNatayA pAlana hotA hai, dUsarA saMsAra ko mUka bhASA meM apane viziSTa siddhAMtoM kA paricaya dekara dharmAbhimukha karane kI bhAvanA aura tIsarA jinAjJA kI ArAdhanA hotI hai| isa taraha kaI prakAra ke lAbha hote haiN| ataeva dharmopakaraNa kI bhI AvazyakatA anivArya aura Agama sammata hai| ____ yadyapi sAdhaka mahAnubhAva AhAra, vastra, pAtrAdi kA upayoga kara zarIra rakSA karate haiM tathApi nirmamatva buddhi (Asakti rahita)

Page #48
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA ******************************************** hone se pudgaloM se virakta hI kahe jAte haiN| aise mahAtmA yaha dhyAna meM rakhate haiM ki jisa prakAra rogI manuSya svAsthya lAbha karane ke lie apriya va kaTu auSadhi kA upayoga karatA hai, kintu svAsthya lAbha kara lene para auSadhi kI tarapha dekhatA bhI nhiiN| ThIka isI prakAra sAdhaka mahAtmA bhI karma bandha rUpa roga se mukta hone aura jJAnAdi ratnatraya kI ArAdhanA ke lie auSadhi kI taraha AhArAdi bAhya vastuoM kA sevana karate haiM aura bhAvanA rakhate haiM ki vaha dina kaba AyagA ki maiM AhArAdi bAhya vastuoM ke tyAga pUrvaka isa zarIra ko zava kI taraha DAla dUMgA aura Atma dhyAna meM lIna hotA huA kalyANa sAdha lU~gA, tathA apanI AtmA ko ina pudgaloM se ekadama bhinna kara zuddha, svaccha, nirmala evaM svatantra banA luuNgaa| ___isake sivAya dhAtrI-mAtA (dhAya) kA udAharaNa bhI isa bAta ko spaSTa karatA hai| jisa prakAra dhAtrI-mAtA (dhAya) dUsare ke putra ko khilAtI pilAtI huI putra kI taraha pAlana karatI hai aura mana meM jAnatI hai ki yaha putra merA nahIM hai| mujhe AjIvikA ke lie hI aisA karanA par3atA hai| isI prakAra mahAtmA puruSa bhI AhAra, pAnI aura vastrAdi se zarIra kI rakSA karate haiN| phira bhI ve jAnate haiM ki hamArI AhArAdi dvArA zarIra rakSA kevala tana ko TikAkara jJAnAdi ratnatraya kI vizeSa ArAdhanA ke lie hI hai| hamArA mukhya dhyeya to AtmotthAna hI hai, khAna pAna Adi nhiiN| ataeva siddha huA ki Avazyaka AhAra Adi kA sevana bhI nirmama buddhi se karanA yogya hai| isa prakAra Asakti rahita sevana karane vAle ko pudgala se alipta kahane meM koI atizayokti nahIM hai, arthAt aise mahAtmA ko pudgala se bhinna kahanA hI ucita hai| isalie ukta zaGkA ko sthAna hI nahIM hai|

Page #49
praveza ******Jing ********************************* yadi koI mahAnubhAva tarka kareM ki jisa prakAra cAritra nirvAha aura Atma kalyANa meM vastra, pAtra aura dharmopakaraNa kI AvazyakatA hai usI prakAra nivRtti mArga vAle ko Atma-kalyANa meM "mUrti" bhI sarvaprathama Avazyaka hai| isakA niSedha kyoM kiyA jAtA hai? isakA samAdhAna hai ki mUrti pUjA kI Atma-kalyANa meM koI AvazyakatA nahIM hai| zAstroM meM upakaraNoM kA jo vidhAna kiyA gayA hai vaha Avazyaka aura anivArya hone se hI upAdeya hai tathA ina upakaraNoM kI gaNanA bhI kI gaI hai| kintu aise dhArmika upakaraNoM meM sarvajJa maharSiyoM ne mUrti kA to nAma bhI nirdeza nahIM kiyaa| ina upakaraNoM ko ucita sAdhana samajhakara hI grahaNa karate haiN| inameM mamatva buddhi nahIM rahatI, kintu mUrti to sAdhya kI taraha mAnI jAtI hai aura isake dvArA Asakti adhika bar3hatI hai| upakaraNoM ko kama karane tathA samaya para tyAgane kI bhAvanA rahatI hai, parantu mUrti ko to apanAye rakhane kI hI buddhi rahatI hai * upakaraNoM ke upayoga meM hiMsA nahIM hotI, parantu mUrti kI pUjA meM trasa tathA sthAvara jIvoM kI hiMsA * upakaraNoM se mUrti kI sAmyatA ho nahIM sakatI kyoMki zAstroM meM - 1. rajoharaNa mukhavastrikA ko jaina liMga meM mAnakara atyaMta upayogI batAyA hai| yahAM taka ki jina kalpI aura kevalI taka ke yaha liGga rahatA hai| "svaliGgasiddha" kA svarUpa jAnane vAle isa viSaya meM zaGkA hI nahIM kara sakate, kintu mUrti rUpa upakaraNa ke lie to Agama eka dama mauna hai| 2. rajoharaNa mukhavastrikA ke sivAya vastra pAtra Adi upadhi ke lie tyAga kI bhAvanA hokara samaya para tyAga bhI kiyA jAtA hai| jisake lie uttarAdhyayana sUtra ke 26 veM adhyAya meM upadhi tyAga kA phala bhI batAyA gayA hai| yadyapi mUrti koI upakaraNa nahIM hai, tathApi upakaraNoM ke sAtha samAnatA karane para to mUrti bhI upakaraNa kI taraha tyAgane yogya (upakaraNa) mAnI jAnI caahie|

Page #50
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA *********** ********* hotI hai| upakaraNoM kA upayoga prabhu kI AjJAnusAra hai, kintu mUrti pUjA Apta AjJA rahita aura hiMsA yukta hone se prabhu AjJA kI virodhinI hai| upakaraNoM ke lie kisI prakAra kI lar3AI nahIM hotI, kintu mUrti ke lie aise-aise jhagar3e hue, jisameM samAja chinna bhinna ho gye| lAkhoM karor3oM kA pAnI huA, aura ho rahA hai| yahA~ taka ki kezariyA tIrtha meM to pUjaka mahAnubhAvoM ne apane hI bhAiyoM ke prANa haraNa kara liye / upakaraNoM ke upayoga se indriyoM kA viSaya poSaNa nahIM hotA, kintu mUrtti pUjA se pAMcoM indriyoM kA spaSTa viSaya poSaNa hotA hai / gAna, tAna, vAdiMtra, dIparAzi, nRtya, sugandhita puSpa, phala, itra, kezara, naivedya, snAna, mardana Adi kAryoM meM pAMcoM indriyoM kA viSaya poSaNa khullama-khullA hotA hai / yadi spaSTa kahA jAya to jisa jainadharma kA siddhAnta pudgala tyAga hai, mUrti - pUjA se ulTA pudgalAsakta - pudgaloM meM masta rahanA pratIta hotA hai| jo zrRGgAra sAmagrI vilAsa bhavanoM tathA nATyazAlAoM meM hotI hai, prAyaH usI prakAra kI sAmagrI Aja mUrti ke mahAlayoM-mandiroM meM pAI jAtI hai| aise sthAnoM meM gayA huA manuSya pudgaloM meM masta hokara hI lauTatA hai| koI-koI to kAma vAsanA meM gote lagAte pAye jAte haiM / samAcAra patroM meM mandiroM ko vyabhicAra ke aDDe kaha kara pukArA jAtA hai| dakSiNa kI devadAsI prathA to sarva prasiddha hai| jaina mandiroM meM bhI kAma 3. jinakalpI ke rajoharaNa aura mukhavastrikA ye do hI upakaraNa mAne gaye haiM phira inake lie mUrti kahAM gaI ? 4. jisa prakAra rajoharaNa mukhavastrikA sadA sAtha rakkhe jAte haiN| rajoharaNa adhika dUra rakhane para prAyazcitta yogya hai / isa prakAra mUrti to sadaiva sAtha nahIM rhtii| aisI dazA meM dharmopakaraNoM se isakI samAnatA kaise ho sakatI hai? Tan

Page #51
or praveza varddhaka sAmagrI tathA rasIle gAna, tAna nRtyAdi kriyAoM ke prabhAva se aura strI puruSoM, yuvaka, yuvatiyoM ke samparka se vikAra vardhaka bhAvanAoM kA utpanna honA svAbhAvika hai| abhI thor3e dinoM kI khabara hai ki pAlItAne meM....vijaya nAmaka sAdhu.....nAmaka kacchI vidhavA ko lekara palAyana kara gyaa| aisI eka nahIM aneka ghaTanAeM ghaTa cukI, aura ghaTatI jA rahI hai| yaha saba prabhAva pudgalAsakti kA hai jo ki mandiroM aura mUrtiyoM kA sahArA pAkara phaila cukI hai| ataeva mUrtipUjA AtmakalyANa meM anAvazyaka evaM ahitakara siddha hotI hai| pudgaloM ke phande meM pha~sAne vAlI ThaharatI hai| Atma kalyANa ke icchuka ko isakI tanika bhI AvazyakatA nahIM hai| jaba pudgala tyAga hI dharma hai| pudgaloM kI AvazyakatAoM ko ghaTAnA hI kalyANa kI ora agrasara honA hai| to phira mandira mUrti ke dvArA pudgaloM kI vizeSa vRddhi kara usameM Asakti kI pracUratA ko dharma kaise kahA jAya? jaina dharma lokottara dharma hai| isameM vyakti pUjA kI apekSA guNa pUjA ko adhika mahattva diyA gayA hai| guNoM ke astitva se guNI kI pUjA hotI hai| nirguNI yA durguNI tathA dravya liMgI ko vandana karane kA vidhAna jaina dharma kA nahIM hai| jo bhI vyakti pUjA bAhya dRSTi se dikhAI detI hai, usake lie samajhadAroM ko yaha dhyAna meM rakhanA cAhie ki yaha vyakti pUjA nahIM, kintu vyakti ke bhItara vidyamAna mahAn vyaktitva-arthAt guNoM-kI hI pUjA hai| kyoMki jaba taka pUjA pAne vAle vyakti meM uttama guNoM kA honA pAyA jAtA hai taba taka hI vaha pUjanIya hotA hai| kintu jaba upAsaka ko yaha mAlUma ho jAya ki jise hama apanA Adarza-guru mAna kara vandanA namaskArAdi karate haiM,

Page #52
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA unameM gurutva ke guNa to hai hI nahIM, kevala veSabhUSA se hI ve hameM dhokhA de rahe haiN| to zIghra hI unakA bahiSkAra aura nirAdara kara diyA jAtA hai| jainAgamoM ke abhyAsI yaha jAnate haiM ki jaba taka jamAlI, gozAlA Adi meM zuddha zraddhA thI, taba taka hI ve jainiyoM ke lie vandanIya - pUjanIya the / kintu jaba ve zraddhA bhraSTa hue aura isakI khabara jainiyoM ko lagI taba zIghra hI vandanA namaskAra baMda kara bahiSkAra bola diyaa| yaha guNa - pUjakatA kA jvalanta udAharaNa hai / tIrthaMkara prabhu kA janma hotA hai, taba indrAdi devoM se kiye gaye janmotsava se yaha mAlUma ho jAtA hai ki jinakA indroM ne janmotsava kiyA aise tIrthaMkara prabhu saMsAra kA kalyANa kara isI janma meM mokSa pdhaareNge| itanA jAnate hue bhI jaba taka tIrthaMkara mahArAja gRhasthAvasthA meM rahate haiM taba taka koI bhI vratI zrAvaka yA sAdhu unheM tIrthaMkara rUpa se vandanA namaskAra tathA sevA - bhakti nahIM karatA aura jaba tIrthaMkara prabhu kA nirvANa ho jAtA hai taba - deha - zarIra ke yahA~ rahate hue bhI jaina saMsAra meM tIrthaMkara viraha kA mahAn zoka chA jAtA hai aura unake zava ko jalAkara naSTa kara diyA jAtA hai| kyoMki vaMdanIya pUjanIya jo guNI AtmA thI, vaha to gamana kara gyii| isase spaSTa hai ki jaina samAja jar3a pUjaka yA vyakti pUjaka nahIM, varan guNa pUjaka hI hai / yadi vyakti pUjA yA jar3a zarIra kI pUjA hI mukhya hotI to tIrthaMkara ke gRhasthAvasthA meM rahate hue yA nirvANa ke pazcAt unakA zava bhI vandanIya, pUjanIya mAnA jAtA aura mUrtti ke sthAna meM vaha zava hI mandiroM meM surakSita rakhA jaataa| jaise kI kaI dezoM meM masAle bharakara zava rakhe jAte haiN| Aja bhI saMsAra meM aneka dharmoM ke dharma guruoM - netAoM ke dehotsarga pazcAt unake zarIra ko apanI

Page #53
praveza ************Zhu Xue Li Li Li Li Li An Qiu Shi Xue Jia Xin Ci Ci Xue Zhu An Ke Jia **Ben Xue apanI mAnyatAnusAra jalA diyA jAtA, athavA bhUmi meM gAr3a diyA jAtA, yA pAnI meM bahA diyA jAtA hai| isase bhI yahI siddha hotA hai ki yadi vyakti kI mUrti (AkRti) pUjanA hI dharma hotA to unake zarIra ko jisameM ki rahakara ve pUjya hue the, kyoM naSTa kiyA jAtA? pASANa kI mUrti se to zava ThIka hI hai, kyoMki pahale usameM guNa vidyamAna the| ataeva siddha huA ki mUrti pUjA AtmakalyANa meM anAvazyaka hai| AdaraNIya kevala guNa hI haiN| guNa ke dhAraka mahAn sarvajJa puruSa hI hamAre deva haiN| sAdhutva sambandhI uttama guNoM ke dhAraka mahAtmA hI hamAre guru haiN| vItarAga prabhu ne hamAre liye jo kalyANakArI mArga batAyA hai, usakA anusaraNa karanA hI hamArA dharma hai aura aise deva kI bhakti aura bahumAna pUrvaka AjJA pAlana karanA hI saccI deva pUjA hai aura yahI kalyANakArI mArga hai| svayaM mUrti pUjaka zrI vijayAnanda sUrijI "jainatattvAdarza' pR0 416 meM likhate haiM ki - "ihA~ sarva jo bhAva pUjA hai so jinAjJA kA pAlanA hai|" __ataeva jinAjJA pAlana rUpa prabhu pUjA hI mokSa dAyinI hai, mUrti-pUjA nhiiN| mUrti-pUjA to ulTI pudgaloM kI abhivRddhi aura Asakti bar3hAkara bhava bhramaNa karAne vAlI heya (tyAgane yogya) vastu hai| - vizvabhara ke SaT nitya dravyoM meM pAMca dravya arUpI aura eka pudgala nAmaka dravya rUpI hai| yadyapi chahoM dravyoM meM pradhAnatA jIva dravya kI hai, tathApi arUpI halkA aura UrdhvagAmI isa pradhAna jIva dravya ko jar3a aura pudgala ne apanI ora AkarSita kara, usa para apanA prabhAva jamAkara use bhArI aura patana kI ora bar3hane vAlA banA diyA hai| isa taraha pradhAna aura ananta zaktizAlI hote hue bhI yaha

Page #54
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA ******************************** ** AtmapadArtha jar3a-pudgala ke AdhIna hokara paratantratA meM bhI Ananda mAnatA hai| isIlie ananta jJAnI, sarvadarzI, vItarAga prabhu ne samasta jIvoM ke kalyANa kI kAmanA se prerita hokara pudgala tyAga rUpa dharma kA upadeza kiyA hai| aura aisA hI upadeza karane kA apanI vaMza paramparA meM hone vAle anagAra bhagavantoM ko Adeza diyA hai| ... saMsAra meM jIvoM kI prakRti pudgaloM kI ora adhika rahI hai| adhikAMza loga pravRtti mArga meM hI Ananda mAnakara apanA janma vyartha vyaya kara rahe haiN| jisake lie khedajJa mahAtmAoM ko duHkha honA svAbhAvika hI hai| kintu isase adhika duHkha kI bAta to yaha hai ki nivRtti pradhAna aise parama pavitra jaina dharma kI mithyA oTa lekara kitane hI loga bhole manuSyoM ko pravRtti mArga kI ora bar3hAkara sva-para ahita kara rahe haiN| aise bhrama jAla meM koI bhadra bandhu na par3a jAya isIliye yaha udyama kiyA jA rahA hai| isa pustaka meM hama zrI jJAnasundarajI (jo marudhara kezarI kahalAte haiM) ke prakAzita "mUrti-pUjA kA prAcIna itihAsa' nAmaka pustaka para vicAra kara unake phailAye hue bhrama (Atma-kalyANa meM bAdhaka mata) kA unmUlana kreNge| yadyapi satya bAta ko svIkAra karanA sujJatA kA karttavya hai, kintu zrI jJAnasundarajI ne satya ko hRdaya meM sthApana kara kArya kiyA ho, aisA mAlUma nahIM hotaa| isa pothe ke andara sundara bandhu ne kaI sthAnoM para sAdhumArgiyoM kI niMdA karake majAka ur3AI hai| kaI bAteM nirarthaka likha mArI hai, kaI kutarka bhI kiye haiN| hama una saba bAtoM kA uttara denA nirarthaka samajhakara vizeSa aura Avazyaka viSayoM ko cunakara usI para vicAra kreNge| yadi viSaya cunane meM kisI viSaya para hamArA dhyAna na bhI jAya to sujJa pAThaka

Page #55
10 dharma-mArga ************************************** hamase patra dvArA puuchleN| hama yathAzakti samAdhAna karane kA prayatna kreNge| hama apane pAThaka mahodayoM se vizeSarUpa se yaha bhI nivedana karate haiM ki ve isa pustaka ko kama se kama eka bAra atha se iti taka, dhyAna pUrvaka pddh'eN| (2) dharma-mArga jaina samAja kA yaha sarvamAnya siddhAnta hai ki jainAgamoM kI racanA ghAtIkarma ko kSaya karake ananta jJAna darzana ko prApta karane vAle sarvajJa vItarAga aura tIrtha ke nAyaka pUrNa evaM Apta prabhu ke viziSTa jJAna meM se huI hai| aise pUrNa aura vItarAga prabhu kI AjJA vizva ke samasta prANiyoM ke lie ekAnta kalyANakArI hotI hai| jaba taka manuSya jJAnAvaraNIya karma kA sarvathA unmUlana nahIM kara sakatA taba taka vaha apUrNa hI hai| aise apUrNa mAnavoM ke lie AtmakalyANa kA yahI mArga hai ki ve sarvajJa AjJAoM kA pAlana kara usI mArga se apanI apanI unnatti saadhe| jainAgamoM meM sabase prathama sthAna AMcArAMga sUtra ko prApta hai| isameM eka sthala para likhA hai ki - 'ANAemAmagaMdhamma, esa uttaravAde, ihamANavANaM, viyaahite|' (AcArAMga zru0 1 adhyayana 6 uddezaka 2) arthAt - AjJA se mere dharma ko pAlana kre| yaha pUrvokta kathana manuSyoM ke liye utkRSTavAda kahA gayA hai| "aNANAeegesovaTThANe ANAeege niruvaTThANe evaM te mA hou eyaM kusalassa dNsnnN|"

Page #56
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 11 ****************************************** guru kahate haiM ki he ziSya! jina-AjJA se bAhara kI karaNI meM udyama aura jina AjJA meM Alasya, yaha tujhe na honA cAhie aisA tIrthaMkara kA abhiprAya hai| (AcArAMga a0 5 uddezaka 6 sUtra prArambha) ___ isa prakAra jinAgamoM meM vizva kalyANa kI kAmanA vAle gaNadhara mahArAja ne sarvajJa, sarvadarzI, vItarAga prabhu kI AjJA pAlana karane kA Adeza kiyA hai| prabhu AjJA kA pAlana kara ananta jIva siddha buddha ho cuke haiN| bhaviSya meM jinAjJA pAlana kara ananta jIva bhava bhramaNa kA nAzakara nitya aura zAzvata sukhoM ko prApta kreNge| zrI sundara mitra bhI hamArI isa bAta ko svIkAra karate hue apane "mejharanAme' meM likhate haiM ki - dharma AjJA vItarAganI, AjJA lopI ho kare gaNI dharma AcArAMgapahelA aGgamAM, nahIM jANyoho? teNe dharma no marma|| 10 // (DhAla 13 pR0 45) (2) "sUtra sUyagaDAMga mAM kayuM, AjJA bAhara ho? baMdhu Ala pNpaal|" (DhAla 25 pR0 76) (3) "jina ANA virAdhatAMrule ananta sNsaar| ANA ArAdhI je huA, zivaramaNI bhrtaar"||1|| (DhAla 30 kA dohA pR068) (4) "dharma che te vItarAganI AjJA mAMche ane AjJA thI nyUnAdhika karavU te to adharmaja ch|" (DhAla 22 ke tAtparya meM pR0 69) ukta cAra avataraNa svayaM sundara mitra ke mejharanAme ke haiN| isake sivAya zrI vijayAnanda sUrijI ne samyaktva zalyoddhAra ke 37 veM

Page #57
dharma- mArga ****** prakaraNa meM AjJA pAlana hI dharma hai isa viSaya meM eka pUrNa prakaraNa likhA hai| 12 jinAgamAdi ukta pramANoM se yaha spaSTa siddha ho gayA ki jisa kArya ke karane kI prabhu AjJA hai vaha dharma hai / aura jisake liye AjJA nahIM, vaha kArya karanA, athavA AjJA ke viruddha kRtya karanA adharma hai| tIrthaMkara prabhu ne kaisA dharma batalAyA ? ekAnta hitakArI, sukhakArI evaM mokSakArI dharma kA svarUpa kyA hai ? isa sambandha meM batAyA hai| " se bemi jeya atItA, jeya paDuppannA, jeya AgamissA arahaMtA bhagavaMto te savvevi evamAikravaMti evabhAsaMti evaM paNNaviMti evaM paruveMti - savvepANA, savvebhUyA, savvejIvA, savvesattA, Na haMtavvA, Na ajjAveyavvA Na parighetavvA Na parittAveyavvA Na kilAmeyavvA, Na udyaveyavvA, esa dhamme suddhe, Nitie, sAsae sameccaloyaM kheyannehiM pavetite taMjahA - uTThiesu vA aNuTTiesa vA uvarayadaMDesu vA aNuvarayadaMDesu vA, sovahiesu vA aNovahiesa vA, saMjogaraesu vA, asaMjogaraesu vA taccaceyaM tahAceyaM, assiMceyaM " pavuccaI / " (AcA0 zru 1 a0 4 u0 1) tAtparya - sudharma svAmI kahate haiM ki aho jaMbu ! bhUtakAla meM jo anaMta tIrthaMkara huve haiM, vartamAna meM jo haiM, aura jo bhaviSya meM hoMge ve saba arihaMta bhagavAn aisA kahate haiM, aisA batalAte haiM ki kisI prANI, bhUta, jIva, satva ko mAranA tAr3anA va ghAta karanA na cAhie,

Page #58
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 13 ****************************************** yAvat unako jIvatva se rahita na karanA cAhiye, yahI dharmazuddha hai, zAzvata hai, aisA khedajJa zrI mahAvIra prabhu ne kahA hai| jo pramAda meM par3e haiM, yA pramAda rahita haiM, jo tyAgI nahIM hue haiM, yA tyAgI ho cuke haiM, ityAdi saba jIvoM ke liye yaha prabhu bhASita dharma yathAtathya hai| ___ prabhu ne sAdhu zrAvaka ke lie jo sAdhanA batAI, vaha bhI prabhu ke upadeza se hI suniye, yathA - "tamevadhammaMduvihaM AikkhaMtitaMjahA-agAradhamma aNagAra dhammaM ca, aNagAradhammo tAva iha khalu savvato savvatAe muMDe bhavittA agArAo aNagAriyaM pavvayaI savvAo pANAivAyAo veramaNaM, savvAo musAvAyAo veramaNaM, savvAo adiNNAdANAo veramaNaM, savvAo mehuNAo veramaNaM, savvAo pariggahAo veramaNaM, savvAo rAibhoyaNAo veramaNaM ayamAuso! aNagAra sAmAie dhamme paNNatte eyassa dhammassa sikkhAe uvahie NiggaMthe vA NiggaMthI vA viharamANe ANAe ArAhae bhavaMti agAradhammaMduvAlasavihaM AikkhaitaMjahA-paMca aNuvvayAI tiNNi guNavayAI cattAri sikkhAvayAI paJca aNuvvayAitaMjahA-thUlAopANAivAyAoveramaNaM, thUlAo musAvAyAo veramAthUlAo adiNNAdANAo veramaNaM, sadArasaMtose, icchA parimANe, tiNNi guNavvayAiM taMjahA - aNatthadaMDa veramaNaM, disivvayaM, uvabhogaparibhogaparimANaM, cattArisikkhAvayAitaMjahAsAmAiyaM, desAvagAsiyaM, posahovavAse, atihisaM

Page #59
14 ** dharma-mArga **** vibhAge, apacchimA maraNaMtiyA saMlehaNA jUsaNArAhaNA, ayamAuso ! agArasAmAie dhamme paNNatte eyassa dhammassa sikaravAe uvaTThie samaNovAsae samaNovAsiA vA viharamANe ANAe ArAhae bhavati / uvavAI sUtra dharma dezanAdhikAra sU0 34 tAtparya yaha hai ki - jo sAdhu sAdhvI pA~ca mahAvrata aura rAtri bhojana tyAgavrata kA pAlana karate haiM aura jo zrAvaka pA~ca aNuvrata tIna guNavrata, cAra zikSAvrata kA pAlana karate haiM aura anta samaya meM zalya rahita hokara ArAdhanA pUrvaka samAdhi maraNa karate haiM ve AjJA ke ArAdhaka hote haiM / isake sivAya sUtrakRtAGga sUtra zru0 2 a0 2 meM bhI agAra aura anagAra dharma kA varNana spaSTatA ke sAtha kiyA gayA hai aura bhI sUtroM meM aneka sthaloM para dharmArAdhana kI vidhi batalAI gaI hai| zramaNa varga ke liye to rAtri - dina ke 24 ghaMToM meM jo-jo Avazyaka kriyAyeM karanI Avazyaka haiM jaise ki bhojana, pAna, gamanAgamana, bhikSAcarI, zayana, pariSThApana, bolanA, calanA, vastra pahinanA, pAtrAdi kitane va kaise rakhanA Adi kriyAoM kI vidhi spaSTa samajhA kara batalAI hai| isI prakAra aneka mahAtmAoM ke caritra varNana bhI AgamoM meM aneka sthAnoM para Aye haiN| unameM unake dharmArAdhana sambandhI vistRta vivecana milate haiM, kintu kisI bhI sthAna para aisA ullekha nahIM milatA ki jisase mUrti pUjA ke siddhAnta ko kucha bhI sahArA mila ske| vidhivAda meM farai bhI sthAna para mUrtti pUjA karane yA mUrtti ke darzana karane kI AjJA nahIM dI gii| na hI kisI zramaNa mahAtmA yA zrAvaka mahodaya ke caritra varNana meM yaha bAta AI ki unhoMne prabhu mUrti ke darzana yA pUjA kI ho|

Page #60
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 15 ********************************************* saMgha nikAla kara yAtrA karane yA mandira banavAne tathA pratiSThA karavAne Adi mUrti sambandhI kisI bhI kriyA kI na to kahIM AjJA hI hai aura na kisI dhArmika puruSa ke dharmArAdhana ke caritra varNana meM ullekha hI hai| mUrti-pUjA meM dharma mAnane kI zraddhA kA kisI bhI sUtra meM kisI bhI taraha ullekha nahIM hai| bilakula nahIM hai, biMdu visarga taka nahIM hai| hamAre kitane hI mUrti-pUjaka bandhu mUrti-pUjA ko jinAjJA ke anusAra kahate haiM aura isake lie Agama pramANa kI duhAI dete haiN| zrImAn jJAnasundarajI ne bhI apane "mUrti-pUjA ke prAcIna itihAsa' nAmaka pustaka meM aisA prayatna kiyA hai, kintu yaha eka bhrama-jAla hI hai| zrImAn sundarajI ne apane sAre pothe meM eka bhI pramANa aisA nahIM diyA jo mUrti-pUjA meM dhArmika zraddhA ko puSTa kre| hAtha kaMgana ko ArasI kyA? pAThaka svayaM usa pustaka se nirNaya kara sakate haiM, sundarajI ne isa viSaya meM jahA~-jahA~ zAstroM ke nAma se bhrama phailAyA hai, usa para vicAra hama isI grantha meM kara rahe haiM, kintu maiM saMkSipta meM dRr3hatA pUrvaka kaha sakatA hU~ ki - jinAgamoM meM mUrti-pUjA karane kI kisI bhI jagaha AjJA nahIM hai, na sundarajI bhI aisA siddha kara sake haiN| jaba mUla meM hI yaha vastu nahIM hai, to phira suMdara mitra lAveM kahA~ se? hA~, vyartha ke kutarka khar3e karake bhadra janatA ko ve bhrama meM avazya DAla sakate haiN| eka sAdhAraNa par3hA likhA aura samajhadAra manuSya mUrti-pUjaka vidvAn se yaha prazna karale ki - mahAnubhAva! jarA yaha to batalAiye ki jahA~ AcAra dharma kI vidhi batalAne vAle sUtra ke sUtra bhare par3e haiN| jinameM choTI choTI bAtoM ke lie spaSTatA pUrvaka AjJA dI gaI hai, unameM kisI eka bhI jagaha mUrti yA mandira banavAne athavA darzana,

Page #61
prArambha meM hI patha bhraSTa ******************* ********************* pUjana, karane kI AjJA dI hai? sAdhu sAdhviyoM ke samUha ke sAtha saMgha nikAlakara Arambha samArambha karate hue tIrtha yAtrA jAne aura isa prakAra mauja ur3Ane kI vItarAga prabhu ne AjJA dI hai kyA? aise prazna kA uttara praznakAra ko yA to mauna se milegA yA krodha se ? agara uttaradAtA ne kutarkoM kA rAstA pakar3a liyA to vaha itanI bar3I-bar3I chalAMge mAregA ki jisase satya rUpI sundara mArga se haTakara mithyArUpI gaharI khAr3I meM jA giregaa| ___isI prakAra zrI jJAnasundarajI ne bhI kutarka karane meM kamI nahIM kii| aisI-aisI vyartha kI bAteM likha mArI haiM ki jinake kAraNa sundara mitra kI yogyatA spaSTa ho jAtI hai, itanA hI nahIM balki bhASA, jJAna aura vidvattA na hote hue bhI sAdhumArgI samAja ke muniyoM aura sudhArakoM ko mUrkha yA ajJa kahane taka kI dhRSTatA kara DAlI hai| apanI mUrkhatA aura dveSa buddhi se prerita hokara nindA karane evaM ha~sI ur3Ane meM bhI sundara mitra ne pakkI vIratA dikhAI hai| ___ sundara mitra kI sundara dalIloM kA paricaya to pAThakoM ko agale prakaraNa se hI mila jaaygaa| pAThaka mahodaya dhyAna pUrvaka avalokana kreN| prArambha meM hI patha-bhraSTa jisa kArya kA prArambha hI doSa yukta ho usakA anta bhI aniSTakArI mAnA jAtA hai| jo vyakti lambA saphara karane kI icchA se prasthAna kare aura prArambha meM hI viparIta mArga kA anusaraNa karane laga jAya to usakA pravAsa saphalatA pUrvaka honA asambhava samajhA jAtA hai| samajhadAra loga prathama dRSTipAta meM hI kArya ke pariNAma ko

Page #62
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 17 Zu Zu Zu Zu Zu Zu Zu Zu *********Ben Ben *****Zu Zu Zu Lai Lai Lai Lai Lai Zu Zu Zu Zu Zu Zu Zu Zu Ben Ben Ci samajha lete haiN| jaba hama zrI jJAnasundarajI ke "mUrti-pUjA ke prAcIna itihAsa" ke prArambha ko hI dekhate haiM, tabhI yaha spaSTa kahanA par3atA hai ki - sundara mitra prArambha meM hI patha-bhraSTa ho gye| Apa viSaya praveza karate hue pR0 1 meM likhate haiM ki - "jainAgamoM meM SaT dravya zAzvata batAe haiM jisameM pA~cadravya amUrta aura eka dravya mUrta haixxx jaba mUrtadravya (pudgala) anAdi haito mUrti-pUjAanAdimAnane meM sandeha hI kyA ho sakatA hai?". ___ sundara mitra kI ukta dalIla kitanI thothI aura mithyA hai, yaha nimna vicAra se spaSTa ho jAtA hai| 1. sundara mitra ne jisa mUrta dravya ko anAdi batAyA hai yaha vahI isa pustaka ke prArambha meM prazaMsita huA "pudgala" dravya hai| yadi pudgala pUjA meM hI dharma hai taba to saMsArI jIva pudgala pUjaka hI haiN| dhana, dhAnya, kuTumba, parivAra, Adi pudgala kI upAsanA sabhI karate haiN| isalie sundara hisAba se to sabhI dharmI hoMge? aura jo mahAtmA (sarvajJa se lekara sAdhu paryaMta) tathA Agama zAstra pudgala se vimukha hone kA upadeza karate haiM, ve adharmI tathA adharma pracAraka tthhreNge| 2. pudgala ke anAdi hone se mUrti-pUjA bhI anAdi mAnalI jAya to phira suMdarajI ko kyA adhikAra hai ki ve jainiyoM kI mUrtipUjA ko hI anAdi mAnakara anya ziva, kRSNa, rAma, buddha Adi kI mUrti-pUjA kI sAdi kaheM? aura jainiyoM kI mUrti-pUjA meM dharma aura anya kI sAtvika mUrti-pUjA meM adharma kaheM? kyoMki pudgala dravya to sabake liye samAna hai|

Page #63
18 prArambha meM hI patha bhraSTa ********************************************** 3. karma bandha bhI pudgala dravya hI hai, jo ki jaina dRSTi se heya vastu hai, suMdarajI ke siddhAMta se to yaha bhI upAdeya hokara pUjanIya honA cAhie? ___4. dhana, dhAnya, strI, parivAra, vastra, AbhUSaNa, jUte, talavAra, bandUka Adi pudgaloM ko bhI pUjanA cAhie? 5. pudgala ke anAdi hone se hI mUrti-pUjA bhI anAdi aura upAdeya hai to phira pudgaloM se hI pudgala kI pUjA karanA kaise ucita " kahA jA sakatA hai ? pUjane yogya mUrti bhI pudgala aura usakI pUjA kI sAmagrI arthAt puSpa, phala, dhUpa, cA~vala, kezara, candana aura paisA Adi bhI pudgala, to pudgaloM se pudgala kI pUjA karanA kyA buddhimattA kA kArya hai? paudgalika pana to saba meM hai, phira eka pUjya aura dUsare usakI pUjA kI saamgrii| yaha kalpanA kyoM? jabaki akhila jaina samAja pudgala rUpI mUrta dravya se amUrta AtmA kA piNDa chur3Ane kA prabala upadeza de rahA hai| jina jina AtmAoM ne pudgala ko sarvathA chor3a diyA hai ve hI "siddhigai nAmadheyaM ThANaM saMpattANaM" hue haiM, aura bhaviSya meM bhI aise hI mahAtmA mukta ho skeNge| yaha mAnyatA samasta jaina zAsana kI hai| aisI dazA meM mUrti-pUjA ke moha aura sAdhumArgI samAja para ke apane dveSa rUpa mada meM masta hokara pudgala kI anAditA se hI mUrti-pUjA kI anAditA aura upAdeyatA siddha karane vAle sundara bandhu kaba sadmArga ke pathika hoMge? . eka jaina sAdhu aura Upara se vidvattA kA dama bharane vAle hI jaba mata moha meM masta hokara pudgala pUjA meM dharma batalAne, pudgala ke sammukha janatA kI pravRtti karane kI ceSTA kareM aura sAtha hI pudgaloM se

Page #64
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA 16 ** virakta hone kA upadeza karane vAloM kI nindA kare to yaha vAstava meM ajJAna IrSA kA hI prAbalya hai| isa prakAra dharma viruddha yukti lagAkara vAstava meM sundara mitra prArambha meM hI patha bhraSTa hue haiN| - jaina sAdhuoM kA karttavya patha svayaM pudgala se vimukha honA aura dUsaroM ko bhI karanA hai / kintu sundara mitra apane grantha ke prArambha meM hI apanI mUrti pUjA kI upAdeyatA pudgala dravya ke mUrtta aura anAdi - hone se batAkara paraspara tulanA kara rahe haiN| isa prakAra pudgalAnusArIpana ko protsAhana denA spaSTa patha bhraSTatA hai| (4) vizva vyApakatA kI mithyA yukti sundara mitra pR0 2 meM dUsarI kuyukti lagAte hue likhate haiM ki " mUrtti pUjA kA siddhAMta vizva vyApaka hai, yaha kisI bhI samaya vizva se pRthak nahIM ho sakatA +++ mUrti ko nahIM mAnanA eka prakAra se prakRti kA khUna karanA hai / " ukta vAkya sundara mitra ne kisI taraMga meM Akara likhe pratIta hote haiN| yadyapi ukta siddhAMta bhI pudgala pUjA kI taraha ni:sAra hai, kintu phira bhI sundara mitra ke liye isa para bhI dUsarI taraha se vicAra karate haiN| jabaki sundara kathanAnusAra mUrti pUjA kA siddhAMta svayaM vizva vyApaka aura nitya hai, taba usI ke liye inheM itanA parizrama karane kI AvazyakatA hI kyoM huI? aura sAdhumArgI samAja ko mUrtti pUjA

Page #65
20 ****** ***** ke virodhI kahane kI buddhi hI kyoM paidA huI? isase to yahI spaSTa huA ki mUrtti pUjA kA siddhAMta vizva vyApaka nahIM hai / vizva vyApakatA kI mithyA yukti *********** (1) sAdhumArgI jaina, Arya samAja, islAma, sikkha, IsAI, kabIra Adi samAjeM mUrti pUjA kI mAnyatA nahIM rakhatI haiN| unheM jabaradastI mUrtti pUjaka likha DAlanA kyA haTha buddhi nahIM hai? yadyapi samaya ke prabhAva se vikRti prAyaH sabameM A gaI hai, jo ki pravRtti mArga kA dharma hai| tathApi una una samAjoM ke mUla siddhAMta to mUrtipUjA ko nahIM mAnane ke hI haiN| yadi Apa pIche se ghusI huI kisI vikRti ko dekhakara prasanna hote hoM to yaha ApakI bhUla hai / kintu hA~, Apa bhI to vikRti ke upAsaka tathA pracAraka haiM na? kyoMki mUrti-pUjA. jainadharma kA mUla siddhAnta (maulika saMskRti) nahIM, kintu samaya pAkara ghusA huA vikAra hI hai| (2) kisI pravRtti ke vizva vyApaka hone se hI vaha AdaraNIya nahIM ho jAtI, jaise ki - mithyAtva, avrata, asaMyama Adi vizvavyApaka haiM - vizva ke kaune-kaune meM phaile hue haiM / pravRtti mArga kA anusaraNa karane vAlA bahuta bar3A samUha hai| yadi vizva vyApakatA hI ke kAraNa kisI viSaya kI upAdeyatA svIkAra karate haiM to Apake lie mithyAtva, avrata, kaSAya Adi bhI karaNIya ho jAyeMge? mitravara! vizva vyApakatA kI duhAI dekara kahIM aisA nahIM karane laga jAnA, nahIM to ulaTe lene ke dene par3a jAya~ge / - (3) viSaya sevana vizva vyApaka hai| deva, manuSya, pazu, pakSI Adi sabhI viSaya meM lubdha rahate haiN| kevala manuSyoM meM hI a~gulI para ginI jAya itanI saMkhyA aise mahAtmAoM kI hogI jo viSaya sevana chor3akara brahmacarya vrata kA pAlana karate hoM / siddha huA ki viSaya

Page #66
* jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ***************************************** 21 ********** sevana vizva vyApaka hai| kintu sundara siddhAntAnusAra vizva vyApakatA ke nAte yaha bhI upAdeya samajhanA cAhie ? yahA~ to sundara mitra bhItara se nahIM to (?) Upara se to jarUra kaheMge ki nahIM, yaha to vizva vyApaka hote hue bhI anupAdeya - heya - hI hai / phira vizva vyApakatA kI jhUThI duhAI dekara mUrti pUjA kaise siddha kara sakate haiM? mahAzaya ! Apa svayaM Age calakara kyA likhate haiM, kyA isakA bhI Apako bhAna hai ? dekhiye Apane hI isI pothe ke pR0 286 meM likhA hai ki - " jana saMkhyA adhika hone se hI kisI mata kI satyatA nahIM kahI jAtI hai| yadi aisA hI hai to musalamAna dharma ko bhI Apako satya mAnanA par3egA, kyoMki usako tIsa karor3a manuSya mAnate haiN| " kahiye mitra ! Apa hI ke lekha se Apa hI ke siddhAnta kA cakanAcUra ho gayA na? aura vizva vyApakatA kI mithyA oTa se mUrtti pUjA kI upAdeyatA dhUla meM mila gaI na ? kahanA nahIM hogA ki yadyapi sundara mitra ne mUrti - pUjA ke vizva vyApaka hone kI jhUThI bAta likhI hai, tathApi inhIM kI dUsarI dalIla se ye svayaM asatya bhASI Thahara cuke / Azcarya to yaha hai ki aisI lacara dalIloM para se hI sundara mitra kahate haiM ki "mUrti ko nahIM mAnanA prakRti kA khUna karanA hai" samajha meM nahIM AtA ki sundara mitra ne ye vAkya kisa Azaya se likheM haiN| vaise to jaina mAtra prakRti kA khUna karanA hI cAhegA hama bhI yahI cAhate haiM ki zIghra hI jar3a prakRti kA khUna ( nAza) kara - "vihayarayamalA" bana jAveM / binA ATha karma kI vividha prakRtiyoM

Page #67
22 kyA sadAcAra Adi ke lie mUrti pUjA Avazyaka hai ******************************************** kA khUna kiye koI bhI mukti nahIM pA sktaa| siddha prabhu bhI prakRti kA khUna karake hI zAzvata sukha pA sake haiN| phira hama prakRti kA khUna kara ananta sukhI baneM, yaha to ThIka aura mana bhAvanI bAta hai| kintu sundara Azaya kucha aura hI dikhAI detA hai| ve mUrti-pUjA ko nahIM mAnanA sva-para ahita karanA kahate hoMge? jo ki mithyA hai, jisakA vivecana Age yathA sthAna kiyA jaaygaa| yahA~ to hama itanA hI kaheMge ki-jo mUrti-pUjA ke pracAraka haiM, ve kalyANa aura mokSa ke sundara mArga kA khUna karane vAle-bAdhaka haiM, yaha niHsandeha hai| ___ eka dRSTi se sundara zabda sAdhumArgiyoM para lAgU hI nahIM hote kyoMki sundara siddhAnta mUrti nahIM mAnanA hI prakRti kA khUna karanA batA rahe haiN| aura hamArI samAja to mUrti ko mUrti mAnatI hai| isalie hamAre viSaya meM ye zabda likhanA bilakula vyartha ho jAtA hai| kyA sadAcAra Adi ke liye mUrti pUjA Avazyaka hai? ___ zrI sundarajI pR0 3 para likhate haiM ki - "saMsAra meM sadAcAra, zAMti, sukha aura samRddhi kA mUla kAraNa kevala mUrti-pUjA hI hai|" hada ho gaI? andha vizvAsa ke pravartaka mahodaya ne kamAla kara diyA??? sarAsara jhUTha likhate hue tanika bhI saMkoca nahIM kiyaa| jisa mUrti-pUjA ke pIche kevala jaina samAja ke hI lAkhoM rupaye svAhA ho cuke, mAnava hatyA kA niMdanIya kArya kezariyA tIrtha meM huaa| zithilAcAra aura pAkhaNDa kA daura daurA huaa| sadaiva mUrti ke

Page #68
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA ********************************************** darzana karane aura tatsambandhI pracAra karane vAle kitane hI sAdhu loga prabhu kathita cAritra dharma se gire hue dikhAI dete haiM aura samAcAra patroM meM jinake lajjA janaka samAcAra chapate haiM taba sundarajI ke kathana kI asatyatA meM sandeha hI kyA hai? ____ aneka mUrti-pUjaka bandhu sadaiva mUrti-pUjA karate hue bhI naitika AcAra se gire hue pAye jAte haiM jo aneka prakAra kI Adhi vyAdhi se azAMta aura duHkhI dikhAI dete haiN| kitane hI loga Arthika sthiti ke gira jAne ke kAraNa bar3I kaThinAI se apanI AjIvikA calAte haiN| phira sundarajI ke ukta zabdoM kA mUlya hI kyA rahatA hai? . yadi sundarajI ke kathanAnusAra mUrti-pUjA hI sadAcAra, zAMti sukha aura samRddhi kA kAraNa hai to phira maiM unase pUchatA hU~ ki mahAnubhAva mUrti-pUjaka sAdhu jo ki sadaiva mUrti ke darzana-pUjA karate haiM aura mUrti-pUjA kA yathAzakti pracAra bhI karate haiM unameM Apasa meM hI DaMDemAra kyoM calatI hai? mUrti ke darzana karane vAle sAdhu gRhasthoM ke bacce kyoM ur3Ate haiM? una para rAjya saMsthA kI ora se vAraMTa kyoM jArI hote haiM? UMjhA (gujarAta) meM lakSmaNa vijaya* nAmaka sAdhu para julAI 1938 ko nyAyAdhIza ne do mahIne kA kArAvAsa yA 500) rupaye daMDa kyoM kiyA? yadi ina sabhI praznoM kA uttara hamase liyA jAya to kevala yahI hai ki ye loga kevala mUrti ke cakkara meM par3akara sadAcAra-sAdhu AcAra-ko bhUla gaye haiN| "zatrujaya mahAtmya' nAmaka graMtha meM likhA hai ki "jisane hatyA, corI, paradAra-sevana Adi duSkarma kiye hoM to isa pahAr3a para Akara eka upavAsa kara mUrti-pUjA karane se pApoM kA piMDa chuTa jAtA * vartamAna AcArya vijaya lakSmaNasUrijI - - ____

Page #69
24 kyA sadAcAra Adi ke lie mUrtti pUjA Avazyaka hai ************** na hai aura likhA hai ki tapa japAdi karane kI koI AvazyakatA nahIM, pApa se Darane kI hI jarUrata hai, kevala zatruMjaya kA smaraNa kiyA ki sabhI pApa naSTa ho jAte haiM / jisane kevala bahurUpiye kI taraha sAdhu veSa pahina liyA hai aise veSadhArI ko bhI zatruMjaya parvata para gautama gaNadhara ke samAna samajho aura usakA gautama pAtra miSThAnna se pUrNa bharado" ityAdi / ************** aise hI andhavizvAsa aura pAkhaNDa pravarttaka granthoM kI svAdhyAya kara, aura sundarajI jaise guruoM ke mukha se aisI bAteM suna kara becAre bhole loga bhrama meM par3a jAte haiM / socate hoMge ki aba sadAcAra Adi kA kAma hI kyA hai? zatruMjaya kA smaraNa yA vahA~ jAkara pUjA kI ki basa saba pApoM kA nAza ho jAyagA / isa taraha mUrtti pUjA ke khoTe cakkara meM par3akara bhadra loga sadAcAra aura zAMti se hAtha dho baiThate haiN| aura vyartha ke Asrava sevana Adi pApoM se apanI AtmA ko bhArI banA lete haiN| ataeva siddha huA ki mUrti-pUjA ke pIche hI andhavizvAsa meM par3akara loga sadAcAra zAnti aura sukha se vaMcita rahate haiM / ataH mUrtti pUjA sadAcAra zAnti aura sukha kI ghAtaka hokara duHkha aura patana kA kAraNa siddha hotI hai| yadi sAdhAraNa taura para vicAra kiyA jAya to jitanI hatyAyeM bhAratavarSa meM mUrtti pUjA kI Ar3a meM huI, aura hotI haiM, utanI dUsarI taraha se nahIM / viSaya vikAra ke poSaNa meM bhI kabhI-kabhI kahIM-kahIM mUrttiyoM ke sthAna hI kAraNa rUpa bana gye| mandiroM aura mUrtiyoM kI zrRMgAra sAmagrI - bahumUlya AbhUSaNa Adi sampatti hI gire hue logoM ko lubhA kara corI jaise niMdanIya kArya taka karane kI preraNA karatI hai| samAcAra patroM ke pAThakoM se yaha bAta gupta nahIM hai ki mandiroM meM

Page #70
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 25 Zu Zu *****Ke Jia Duo Duo Xue Duo Duo Xue ****Zi Zi Zi ********Zi Duo Duo Duo Duo *** coriyA~ hokara kitanI hAni hotI hai| cora dhAtu kI mUrti ko hI uThA le jAte haiN| ataeva sundarajI kA kathana niHsaMdeha mithyA haiN| misTara jJAnasundarajI! Apane apane ukta zabdoM meM "kevala" aura "hI'' do zabda lagAkara apanI bAta ko khUba dRr3ha kiyA ki basa "saMsAra bhara meM yadi sadAcAra, zAMti, sukha aura samRddhi kA mUla kAraNa yadi koI hai to eka mAtra mUrti-pUjA, anya kucha nhiiN| (ha~sI AtI hai suMdarajI kI bAlabuddhi pr| Apa mUrti ke raGga meM aise raGga gaye ki jisake kAraNa anya sabhI kalyANakArI mArgoM para tAlA hI Thoka diyaa| binA pramANa yA yukti ke aise mithyA atizayokti bhare vAkya likha DAlanA sacamuca bAla ceSTA hI hai| yadi suMdarajI mUrti-pUjA kI bhayaGkaratA para vicAra karate to unheM spaSTa dikhAI detA ki mAnava jAti ko dharma ke nAma para pAkhaMDa aura andhavizvAsa meM Dhakelane ke mukhya kAraNoM meM mUrti-pUjA bhI hai vaha bhI sabameM bar3hakara hai| sAdhutA kI ghAtaka aura caityavAda Adi se zithilatA kI varddhaka bhI yahI siddha huI hai| mUrti-pUjA ke saMskAroM ne hI jaina mandiroM meM anya bhairavAdi kI mUrtiyoM ko sthAna diyA hai| aura isI ke sahAre anya adharmI * loga jaina samAja ko luTate haiN| rAjya + kI ora se bhI jaina samAja cUsI jA rahI hai| ApasI xx . * kezariyA tIrtha meM paMDe loga jaina samAja kA paisA har3apa kara lete haiN| + pAlitAnA sTeTa prativarSa 60000) rUpaye zatruJjaya pahAr3a ke kara ke vasUla karatI hai, AbU pahAr3a para bhI Teksa diye binA mUrti taka pahuMcanA muzkila ho jAtA hai| _xx digambara zvetAmbara ke ApasI jhagar3oM meM lAkhoM kA pAnI huA,, aura ho rahA hai|

Page #71
- sAkSAt aura mUrti meM antara ********************************************** jhagar3e aura kalaha kaMkAza bhI isI ke kAraNa hotA hai| vyartha x ke kharce bhI yahI karavAtI hai| isalie yadi AtmakalyANa ke icchuka sadAcAra zAnti aura samRddhi cAhate haiM to unheM mUrti-pUjA se sarvathA dUra rahanA caahiye| vAstava meM mUrti-pUjA sadAcAra zAnti sukha evaM samRddhi kI nAzaka hI siddha huI hai| suMdara baMdhu ko ulTA kathana karate kucha satya kA bhI dhyAna rakhanA caahiye| sAkSAt aura mUrti meM antara zrI sundarajI Age (pR0 4 meM) likhate haiM ki - "Apa apane mana-mandira meM nirAkAra Izvara kI kalpanA kareMge to vaha kalpanA bhI sAkArahI hogii|jaise ki tIrthaMkara aSTa mahA pratihAra vibhUSita kevalajJAnAdi saMyukta samavasaraNa meM virAjakaradezanA derahe haiM ityaadi| aba Apa svayaM sociye ki-mandira yA mUrti mAnane vAle Apa kI isa kalpanA se vizeSa kyA karate haiM?" sundara mitra kI ukta vAk chalanA se becAre bhole loga to bhrama meM par3a jAte haiM, kintu jinameM thor3I bhI vicAra zakti hai vaha avazya isake bheda ko acchI taraha nApa sakate haiN| Azcarya to yaha hai ki khuda suMdarajI itane varSa sAdhumArgI samAja meM rahakara bhI hamAre siddhAMta se anabhijJa rhe| kyoMki sAkAra nirAkAra - pratiSThA, saMgha nikAlanA, Adi kAryoM meM lAkhoM rupaye vyartha barabAda hote haiN|

Page #72
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 27 *****Shi *Lao ***********Jing Zhuan Jia Xue Hui Xue Li ***************Xue Xue kA jhagar3A to hai hI nhiiN| hama bhI sAkAra tIrthaMkara prabhu ko Izvara mAnate haiN| phira vyartha kAgaja kAlA karake suMdarajI ne kyA lAbha uThAyA? - suMdara buddhi kA eka camatkAra aura dekhiye - Apa apane ukta lekha meM sAkAra tIrthaMkara ko hI nirAkAra mAnate haiM isIse Apa nirAkAra kI carcA karate-karate sAkAra meM A pdd'e| isake sivAya suMdara mitra sthApanA aura bhAva kA svarUpa bhI kadAcit nahIM jAnate hoMge? isIse aisI vyartha kI yukti lagA baitthe| kyoMki sthApanA, miTTI, kASTa, pASANa, dhAtu, kAgaja aura aise hI . anya padArthoM se banAI jAtI hai, kintu kalpanA kisI vastu se nahIM banAI jaatii| sAkSAt tIrthaMkara prabhu bhAva svarUpa haiN| usI taraha sAkSAt kI kalpanA-vicAra-yA bhAvanA bhI bhAva svarUpa hI hai| sthApanA nahIM, kyoMki isakA sambandha bhAva se haiN| jisakA bhAvoM se sambandha ho vaha sthApanA nahIM ho sktii| yahA~ bhAvoM se vicAra karane vAlA vyakti apane bhAvoM meM tIrthaMkara ke bhAvoM-guNoM kA cintana karatA huA bhAva-ArAdhanA karatA hai| aisI sarala bAta ko bhI tor3amaror3akara ulTI paddhati se janatA ko dikhAnA eka prakAra se dhokhA denA hai| _ vicAra karo ki kisI vyakti ne zrI suMdarajI ko dekhe haiM aura usakA unameM anurAga bhI hai| kAlAntara meM suMdarajI kI anupasthiti meM jaba vaha suMdarajI ko yAda karegA taba usakI dRSTi meM inakI AkRti dikhAI degI to kyA vaha AkRti mAtra sthApanA nikSepa meM hogI? __maiMne apane guruvarya ko dharmopadeza dete hue dekhe the, aba jaba kabhI mujhe unakA smaraNa hotA hai, taba merI A~khoM meM vaha saumya vadana

Page #73
28 sAkSAt aura mUrtti meM antara ***************************************** ****************** mahAtmA dharmopadeza dete hue dikhAI dete haiN| yaha spaSTa rUpa se bhAva svarUpa hai| yadi koI kahe ki dekhI huI vastu to saralatA se smaraNa kI jA sakatI hai kintu binA dekhI vastu kI kalpanA karanA asambhava hotA hai isalie usakI sthApanA honA Avazyaka hai to yaha kathana bhI ThIka nahIM, kyoMki jisa prakAra binA dekhe hI kalpanA ke AdhAra para mUrttiyeM banAI gaI haiM ( kyoMki tIrthaMkaroM kA phoTU khIMcakara usase mUrttiyeM banAI gaI hoM, yaha bAta to hai hI nahIM) usI prakAra zAstroM se tIrthaMkaroM ke deha aura guNoM kA varNana jAnakara usakA ciMtana kiyA jA sakatA hai| isa prakAra bhAvoM se kiyA huA ciMtana bhI bhAva deva kI bhakti meM hI sammilita hai| isaliye sAkSAt bhAva nikSepa prabhu kI kalpanA kara stuti karanA bhI bhAva svarUpa hI hai| aise sarala aura bhAva pradarzaka viSaya ko sthApanA meM ghasITa le jAnA kadApi ucita nahIM kahA jA sakatA / zrImAn sundarajI kahate haiM ki "tuma kalpanA karate ho, hama mUrti banAkara pUjate haiN| isameM adhika kyA huA ?" dayA AtI hai isa bAla ceSTA para, Apa itanA bhI nahIM samajha sake ki bhAvoM dvArA bhakti aura sthApanA - mUrtti pUjana meM AkAza pAtAla kA sA antara hai| eka hai zuddha prakAza, to dUsarA hai gAr3ha andhakAra / eka meM niravadya bhakti hokara AtmA halkI hotI hai, to dUsare meM vyartha hI prANiyoM kI hiMsA va pUjya kI AjJA bhaGga rUpa apamAna hokara AtmA bhArI hotI hai| bhAvarUpI bhakti meM kisI bhI bAhya vastu kI apekSA nahIM rahatI, zuddha tana-mana se kI jAtI hai, taba mUrtti pUjA meM agaNita trasa aura sthAvara jIvoM kI hatyA, vyartha kA dravya vyaya aura mithyA pAkhaMDa rahatA hai / -

Page #74
26 jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA. ******************Ben *** ******************** __sundara mitra yadi Apa hamase adhika nahIM karate haiM to batalAiye, yaha mUrti banavAnA, mandira cunavAnA, pratiSThA karavAnA, saMgha nikAlakara yAtrA karanA Adi kriyAyeM Apa kyoM karate, karavAte haiM? kyA ye kriyAyeM hamase Apa adhika nahIM karate haiM? yadi ApakI dRSTi meM hamArI bhAva rUpa bhakti aura ApakI sthApanA bhakti eka hI hai to phira yahI kariye, jisase kisI prakAra kA jhagar3A bhI nahIM rahe, na vyartha kA dharma ke nAma para pApa ho, na jaina samAja kI zakti IMTa cUnA aura pattharoM meM barabAda ho! na zraddhA dUSita rahe aura sabhI jaina samAja prabhu AjJA pAlaka bneN| sundara mitra ne bholoM ko cakkara meM DAlane ke liye amAvasyA aura pUrNimA kI taraha jar3a bhakti aura zuddha caitanya bhakti ko eka samAna batA diyA, kintu janatA jAnatI hai ki isame kitanA antara hai ? jabaki mUrtiyoM aura mandiroM ke kAraNa jaina samAja meM bhArI kalaha macA huA hai| digambara zvetAmbaroM ke lAkhoM rupaye inake haka aura adhikAra ke lie svAhA ho cuke aura ho rahe haiN| zvetAmbara mUrti pUjaka loga sAdhumArgI samAja para isI ke kAraNa hamale karake prabhu patha ko Thesa pahu~cAte rahate haiN| inhIM mandiroM aura mUrtiyoM ke kAraNa vilAsitA vikArI bhAva aura corI jaise niMdya kArya bar3hate haiN| aisI hAnikara paddhati ko kisI bhI prakAra kI hAni se sarvathA rahita Atmabala pradAtA kahanA aura bhAva dvArA bhakti se samAnatA batalAnA kitanA andhera hai? kyA yaha sarAsara dina dahAr3e janatA kI A~khoM meM dhUla jhoMkanA nahIM haiM? spaSTa hai ki bhAva dvArA bhakti karane ko mUrtipUjA ke samAna batalAnA sarAsara jhUTha haiN|

Page #75
30 **** mithyA prazaMsA (7) mithyA prazaMsA zrI0 sundarajI pustaka ke prathama prakaraNa ke anta meM pR0 116 meM mUrtti pUjA kI mithyA mahimA gAte haiM ki - " mUrti pUjakoM ne saMsAra kA jitanA upakAra kiyA hai utanA hI mUrti virodhakoM ne saMsAra kA apakAra kiyA hai / " 7 vAha ! kyA kahanA ! apane Apa miyA~ miTTha bananA ise hI to kahate haiM / vAstava meM jisa prakAra binA lagAma kA ghor3A unmArga gamana karatA hai, ThIka usI prakAra binA vicAre pramANa zUnya bolane aura likhane vAle bhI unmArga- mithyA mArga pakar3a lete haiM / sundara mitra ! saca pUchA jAya to jitanA patana mUrti-pUjA ke dvArA mUrti pUjakoM ne kiyA, utanA zAyada hI kisI anya kAraNa se kisI ne kiyA ho ? 1. jitanA dhana Aja taka mandira mUrtti nirmANa karane meM, mUrtiyoM ke bahumUlya AbhUSaNa banavAne meM, mandira mUrtti ke liye jhagar3e lar3ane meM, saMgha nikAlakara yAtrA karane meM aura pahAr3oM ke kara bharane meM vyartha kharca huA hai, utanA zAyada hI kisI anya kAryoM meM kharca huA ho / yadi yahI dhana bacA rahatA to usase sArA bhAratavarSa zikSita ho sakatA, bekArI kA nAma bhI nahIM raha sakatA aura isa dhana ke bahuta se hisse ko mahamUda gajanavI jaise AkramaNakArI lUTa khasoTakara bhArata ko nirbala banAkara svayaM sabala na ho skte| ataeva bhArata kI Arthika sthiti ke girane meM mUrtti pUjA aura isake pravarttaka tathA bhakta bhI pradhAna kAraNa haiN|

Page #76
31 jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA ******************************************* 2. mUrti-pUjA hI ke kAraNa devadAsI jaisI bhayaGkara prathA kA prAdurbhAva huaa| isa prathA kA kucha asara jainiyoM para bhI huA, aura yahA~ taka ki jainiyoM ke bar3e AcArya kahe jAne vAle govindAcArya * tathA hemacandrAcArya ne mandiroM meM nartakiyoM-vezyAoM kA nAca krvaayaa| vartamAna meM bhI kahIM kahIM mandiroM meM dainiyoM kI kanyAoM ko nacAkara ise bhakti kA rUpa diyA jAtA hai| vikrama saM0 1963 meM zrImAn vidyAvijayajI ne bhI karAMcI meM aisA kiyA thA, aisA samAcAra patra se mAlUma huA thaa| isa prakAra mUrti-pUjakoM ne dharma kI oTa lekara kyA-kyA DhaGga racA, yaha spaSTa dikhAI detA hai| surile vAdiMtra aura gAna tAna ke sAtha nRtya karavAkara mUrti-pUjaka mahAnubhAvoM ne viSaya vikAra kA poSaNa hI kiyA hai| 3. mandiroM aura mUrtiyoM ke adhikAra ke liye mUrti-pUjakoM ne mAnava hatyA bhI karavAI jisakA jvalaMta udAharaNa kezariyA tIrtha kA hatyAkAMDa hai| _____4. mandiroM aura mUrtiyoM kI Ar3a meM prativarSa hajAroM prANI talavAra ke ghATa utAre jAte haiN| aura jainiyoM meM bhI asaMkhya trasa tathA sthAvara jIvoM kI hiMsA pratidina pratyeka sthAna meM hotI hai| isa hiMsA ko bhI dharma kA kAraNa mAnakara mUrti-pUjaka jainiyoM ne samyaktva ko dUSita kiyA hai| 5. mUrti-pUjA hI ke kAraNa jaina muniyoM meM cAritra sambandhI zithilatA phailI yahA~ taka ki ugravihArI muni bhI maThAdhIza banakara vaibhavazAlI bana baitthe| isa vikAra ko naSTa karane ke lie hI dharmaprANa lokAzAha ko krAMti macAnI pdd'ii| Aja bhI bahuta se sAdhu apanA * dekho 'prabhAvaka' caritra tathA kumArapAla critr|

Page #77
zAzvatI pratimAeM aura sUryAbhadeva ************Kong ********* ** zramaNa karttavya-cAritra-dharma bhUlakara mUrti-pUjA ke kAraNa Arambha aura Asrava varddhaka upadeza dekara Apta AjJA kA ulaMghana karate haiM, jisake katipaya namUne Age diye jaayeNge| ina mandiroM aura mUrtiyoM ke kAraNa kaI prakAra ke anartha hue haiN| mandiroM aura mUrtiyoM meM rahe hue dhana vaibhava ke kAraNa anArya logoM ne bhArata para car3hAI karake deza ko barabAda kara diyA, achUtoM kI pazuoM se bhI badatara dazA kara DAlI, isI kAraNa se digambaroM meM apane ko ucca samajhane vAle loga dassoM ko achUta samajhakara mandiroM meM nahIM Ane dete haiN| andhavizvAsa aura pAkhaNDa pracAra meM mUrti-pUjA hI agrasthAna rakhatI hai| ataeva saMsAra kA jitanA apakAra mUrtipUjakoM ne kiyA, utanA dUsaroM ne nhiiN| aura jina sudhAraka netAoM ne mUrti-pUjA kI bhayaMkaratA dekhakara isakA bahiSkAra kiyA, unhoMne vAstava meM saMsAra kA upakAra kiyA hai, saMsAra ko bar3I bhArI hAni se bacAne kA prayatna kiyA hai| aisA karake unhoMne dharma ke nAma se phaile hue pAkhaNDa kA nAza kara dharma sevA deza sevA aura saMsAra sevA kA mahAn lAbha prApta kiyA hai| aise spaSTa hAni lAbha ke kAraNoM ko ulTA batAne vAle sundara mitra kaise satya vaktA haiM? yaha pAThaka svayaM smjhleN| (8) zAzvatI pratimAe~ aura sUryAbhadeva sUtroM meM devaloka kI jina pratimAoM kA varNana hai, unake zarIroM kA bhI varNana hai, ve zAzvatI pratimAe~ haiM, rAjyAbhiSeka prasaGga para devatA unakI pUjA karate haiM, yaha pUjA paddhati bhI paramparAnusAra hotI hai| isa viSaya kA vizeSa varNana urdhvaloka sambandhI "rAyapaseNaiya

Page #78
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA Duo Duo Duo Duo Duo Duo Duo Duo Duo Duo Duo Duo Duo Duo Duo Duo Duo Zi ***Mai Mai Mai Ben Lai Ping An Ben Lai Lai Lai Lai Lai Lai Li Li Li Li *Ben sUtra" aura tircha loka sambandhI "jIvAbhigama' sUtra meM milatA hai, jo bhAI sAmAnya buddhi vAle yA guru gama binA ina prakaraNoM ko dekhatA hai vaha prAyaH bhrama meM par3a jAtA hai, tathA mUrti-pUjaka loga bhI aise prakaraNoM ko lekara janatA meM bhrama phailAyA karate haiN| zrI jJAnasundarajI ne apane "mUrti-pUjA ke prAcIna itihAsa ke prakaraNa 3 meM zAzvatI mUrtiyoM kA varNana kara sUryAbhadeva kI mUrti-pUjA kA pramANa diyA hai" aura isa prakAra mUrti-pUjA meM dharma hone aura mUrti-pUjA bhagavadAjJA yukta hone para jora diyA hai, kintu jo loga samajhadAra haiM jinhoMne guruoM ke samIpa sUtroM kA svAdhyAya kara unakI vAstavikatA ko samajha liyA hai? ve kabhI bhI inake cakkara meM nahIM Ate, yahA~ hama isI viSaya meM kucha vicAra karate haiN| . zrI jJAnasuMdarajI ke kathana meM vicAraNIya kevala tIna bAte haiN| 1. devaloka sthita pratimAyeM tIrthaMkaroM kI hai| 2. sUryAbhadeva ne mUrti pUjA kI, isalie sabhI ko karanA caahiye| 3. mUrtipUjA jinAjJA yukta dharmakaraNI hai| khAsa kara ina tIna bAtoM para hI matabheda hai, yahA~ hama ina tInoM viSayoM para pRthak 2 vicAra karate haiN| (1) devaloka kI pratimAeM tIrthaMkara pratimA nahIM hai devaloka kI pratimAyeM kevala "jina pratimAyeM" kahalAne se hI tIrthaMkara pratimAyeM nahIM ho sakatI, kyoMki jina zabda ke aneka artha haiN| AcAryoM aura granthakAroM ne itane artha to mAnya kiye haiN| (1) (hindI vizvakoSa pR0 306 aSTama bhAga) ___

Page #79
34 . zAzvatI pratimAeM aura sUryAbhadeva ******************* ************************ jina- (saM0 pu0) ji-nk-| 1 jinendr| ye arhat, tIrthaMkara, sarvajJa, jinezvara, vItarAga, Apta Adi nAma se prasiddha haiN| "tIrthaMkara" dekho| 2 buddh| 3 vissnnu| 4 sUrya (tri0) 5 jitvara, jItane vaalaa| jina- (a0 pu0) musalamAna bhUta "jinda'' dekho| (2) (abhidhAna rAjendra koSa pR0 1456 caturtha bhAga) jina- pu0| jayati-nirAkAroti rAga dveSAdirUpA narAtIniti jinH| kevalini, vize0 / jinmaH sAmAnya kevalinaH / prajJA0 1 pd| rAga dveSAdi zatru jetAro jinA bhavastha kevlinH| paa0| caturdazapUrviNo jinAzca kevalinaH cturdshpuurvinnshc| utta0 5 a0 / gacchA nirgatasAdhuvizeSe c| sthA0 3 ThA0 / RSabhAdike caturviMzati saMkhyA ke tIrthaMkare c| sUtra0 1 zru0 6 a0| jinklpikec| "akkhobbho hoi jinacieNo" jinaH zrutAvadhimanaH paryAya kevala jJAna vanto jina kalpikAzca taizcIrNaH Acarito jina ciirnnH| paJcA0 4 viva0 / "jinavara vasahassavaddhamANassa" rAgAdijayAjinAH avadhimanaH-paryavopazAntamohAH kSINamohAH teSAM madhyevarAH pradhAnAH sAmAnya kevalinaH / saMthA0 / "jiNANaM jaavyaannN|" "jino'rhad buddha viSNuSu" (hemacandrAcArya anekArtha saMgraha 2-378) arhanto (tIrthakaro) pi jinazcaiva, jinaH sAmAnya kevlii| kaMdarpo'pi jinazcaiva, jino nArAyaNo hriH| (haimI nAma mAlA)

Page #80
35 jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA ************* ** ********* * * ***** sarvajJaH sugato buddho dharmarAja stathAgataH / samantabhadro bhagavAnmArajilloka jijinaH / (amarakoza) isake sivAya nAma, sthApanA, dravya, bhAva-bheda se bhI jina cAra prakAra ke haiN| kozakAra bhI zabdoM ke vahI artha dete haiM jinakA prayoga hotA ho, yA huA ho, binA prayoga kiye hue artha ko ve dete hI nhiiN| sAhitya meM 'jina' zabda ko 'arhat' 'kevalI' ke sivAya 'buddha' 'viSNu' (yA nArAyaNa) kaMdarpa Adi arthoM meM bhI liyA hai ataH koSakAroM ne bhI ve artha kiye haiN| isalie jina zabda kA artha kevala tIrthaMkara hI mAnanA ucita nahIM, kisI bhI zabda kA artha prakaraNa ke bhAvoM ke anukUla kiyA jAe to anartha nahIM hotA, nahIM to mahAn anartha ho jAtA hai| prastuta viSaya meM ve jina pratimAyeM tIrthaMkara pratimA nahIM mAnI jAtI, kyoMki - (a) ve zAzvata haiN| (A) unake netroM meM lAla rekhAyeM haiN| (i) unheM vastra dhAraNa karAye gaye haiN| (I) pUjana vidhi sarAgI deva jaisI hai| (u) zarIra varNana ulTA hai| (U) AsapAsa kI mUrtiyeM bhI sAdhu sAdhvI kI nahIM haiN| (e) nirdhArita cAra hI nAma diye haiN| ukta kAraNoM para vistRta vicAra kiyA jAtA hai -

Page #81
zAzvatI pratimAeM aura sUryAbhadeva ********************************************** (a) mUrtiyoM kA zAzvata pana ananta caubIsI bIta gaI, Aja taka jitane bhI tIrthakara hue haiM, una sabakA janma huA aura nirvANa bhI huA, bhaviSya meM bhI isI prakAra hogA, lAkhoM pUrvo taka vidyamAna rahane para bhI janma aura nirvANa hotA hI hai, Aja taka koI zAzvata nahIM rhaa| zAzvata vastu sadA, sarvadA vidyamAna rahatI hai, usakI na to utpatti hotI hai aura na naash| tIrthaMkara to amuka nAma se janma lete haiM, va nirvANa ko bhI prApta hote haiM, ataeva ve zAzvata nahIM ho skte| jaba tIrthaMkara nAma rUpa se zAzvata nahIM hote, taba unakI mUrti kaise zAzvata ho sakatI hai? siddha huA ki devaloka kI cAra nAmavAlI mUrtiye zAzvata hone se ve tIrthaMkara kI nahIM hai| (A) aruNa-netra A~khoM kI raktatA yA lAla rekhAyeM sarAgiyoM ke hotI hai, kyoMki ye saMsArI hokara kAma-krodha yukta hote haiM, yaha to sabhI jAnate haiM ki krodhI kI A~kheM lAla hotI hai, idhara "rAyapaseNaiya' aura "jIvAbhigama" donoM sUtroM meM "aMto lohiyakkhapaDisegAo" kahA hai jisakA artha "lohitAkSa (lAlaraGga kI) ratnamaya A~khoM kI rekhAyeM haiM" aisA hotA hai aura vItarAgI tIrthaMkara prabhu ke zveta netra hote haiM, kyoMki ve nirvIkArI haiM, uvavAI aura rAyapaseNaiya ina donoM sUtroM meM tIrthaMkara prabhu mahAvIra ke zarIra kA varNana hai, jisameM unakI A~khoM ke viSaya meM koyAsiya dhavala pattalacche' arthAt unakI "vikasita zveta kamala ke samAna zveta aura patalI A~kheM" likhA hai| isa prakAra netra sambandhI viruddhatA hArdika bhAvoM kI viruddhatA prakaTa karatI hai,

Page #82
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA isaliye "aruNa netra' arthAt lAlarekhAyukta sarAga bhAva ko batAne vAlI ye pratimAyeM tIrthaMkara kI pratimA nahIM mAnI jA sktii| (i) vastra-paridhAna jainAgamoM meM tIrthaMkara ko vastra rahita batalAyA hai aura sabhI jainI yaha mAnate haiM ki tIrthaMkara vastra dhAraNa nahIM krte| hA~, dIkSita hote samaya indra prabhu ke kandhe para eka devadUSya vastra rakhatA hai| jo vaisA hI par3A rahatA hai, prabhu use samhAla kara pahinate nahIM, yA gira jAne para uThAte bhI nahIM, isa prakAra sabhI tIrthaMkaroM ke vastra rahita rahane kA kalpa hai| jaba tIrthaMkara prabhu vastra pahinate hI nahIM, nagna hI rahate haiM, aura vastra pahinane vAle tIrthaMkara nahIM mAne jAte, taba vastra pahinane vAlI mUrti tIrthaMkara kI kisa taraha mAnI jA sakatI hai| sUtra "rAyapaseNaiya" aura "jIvAbhigama' meM spaSTa ullekha hai ki - "devadUsajuyalAI niyaMseI" arthAt "deva dUSya vastra pahinAye" phira aisI pratimA tIrthaMkara kI kaise ho sakatI hai? isake samAdhAna meM "sundara" mitra kahate haiM ki - "pratimA ko vastra pahinAye nahIM, kintu car3hAye haiN| aura sAtha hI sva0 pUjya zrI amolakaRSijI mahArAja para AkSepa bhI kara baiThe haiM, dekhiye sundara mitra kA lekha - "sUtra meM vastra car3hAnA likhA hai para RSijI ne vastra pahinAye likha diyA hai para yaha likhate samaya itanA hI vicAra nahIM kiyA ki gozIrSacandana kA lepana kara vastra kaise pahinAye? aisA to eka vivekazUnya manuSya bhI nahIM karate haiM to ve mahAvivekI deva kyoM kreNge| vAstava meM vastra car3hAye arthAt arpaNa kiye| jaise Aja bhI pUjA . meM vastra arpaNa kiyA jAtA hai jisako aGga luhane kahate haiN|" (pR0 56 kA phuTa noTa)

Page #83
38 zAzvatI pratimAeM aura sUryAbhadeva *********************An ********************** isa prakAra sundara mitra ne binA vicAre manameM jo AyA so likha DAlA hai kintu vAstava meM yaha ajJAnatA pradarzana hI hai, kyoMki sUtra meM spaSTa rUpa se gozIrSa candana kA lepa karane ke bAda hI vastra pahinAnA likhA hai, sundara mitra "niyaMseI" zabda kA artha car3hAnA karate haiM para svayaM TIkAkAra zrI malayagiri ne isa zabda kA artha "paridhApayati" karake paridhAna karavAnA-pahinAnA-kiyA hai aura inhIM mUrtipUjaka samAja ke labdha pratiSTha vidvAn paM0 becaradAsajI bhASAMtara karate hue ukta viSaya meM likhate haiM ki - "deva dUSya yugala paherAvyAM" (rAyapaseNaiya sutta no sAra pR0 63) basa, ho gayA nirNaya? yadi aura bhI adhika spaSTIkaraNa cAhie to lIjiye, hama yaha siddha karate haiM ki gozIrSa candana kA lepa karane ke bAda vastra pahinAnA hI zAstra sammata hai, dekhiye - 1. isI rAyapaseNaiya sutta meM sUryAbhadeva ke vastra paridhAnAdhikAra meM nimna mUla pATha hai - "taeNaM tassa sUriyAbhassa devassa sAmANiya parisovavannaMgA alaMkAriya bhaMDaM uvaTThaveMti, taeNaM se sUriyAbhedeva tappaDhamayAe pamhalasUmAlAe surabhIe gaMdhakAsAIegAyAiMlUhetilUhittA saraseNaMgosIsa caMdaNeNaM gAyAiMaNuliMpatiaNuliMpittAnAsAnIsAsa vAyabojjhaM cakkhuharaM vanna pharisajuttaM hayalAlApelavAtiregaM dhavalaM kaNagakhaciyanti kammaM AgAsa phAliya samappabhaM divvaM devadUsa juyalaM niyaMseti'

Page #84
36 jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA ********************************************* ___ ukta mUla pATha kA bhASAntara paM0 becaradAsajI pR0 61 meM isa prakAra karate haiM - "pachI tenA sAmAnika sabhya devoe tenI samakSa tyAM badhI alaGkAra sAmagrI upasthita karI, pahelA to nhAelo hovAthI teNe sukomala aGga lUchaNA dvArA potAnAM aGgoM lUchayAM, tenA upara sarasa gozIrSa candana no lepa ko ane tyArabAda ekaja phUMke ur3I zake tevu ghor3A nI lAla jevU narama, sundara varNa ane sparzavAluM ane jene cher3e sonuM jar3elu che tevU sphaTika jevU ujalu dholuM devadUSya yugala teNe pheryu|' ___isake sivAya 1 AcArAMga sUtra meM bhagavAn mahAvIra svAmI ke dIkSA utsava ke varNana meM, 2-3 zrI jaMbudvIpa prajJapti sUtra meM cakravartI bharatezvara mahArAja ke snAna vastraparidhAnAdhikAra aura prathama jinezvara ke nirvANAdhikAra meM, 4 uvavAI sUtra ke samrAT koNika ke snAna ke bAda vastra pahinane ke varNana meM aura 5 jJAtA dharmakathA a0 1 meM, ityAdi aneka sthAnoM para yahI varNana hai ki gozIrSa candana kA lepa karane ke bAda vastra pahine, aura vastra pahinane meM "niyaMseti" zabda hI AyA hai| kyA aba bhI sundarajI kI ajJatA meM kucha sandeha hai? sundara mitra! dekhiye mUrti ko vastra pahinAnA Apake zrI vijayAnanda sUrijI bhI svIkAra karate haiM yathA - "jisa samaya dropadI ne jina pratimA kI pUjA karI tisa samaya meM jina pratimA ko vastra pahirAne kA rivAja thA so hama manjUra karate (hindI samyaktva zalyoddhAra pR0 100) kahiye, mahAtman! aba to Apake mana kI murAda miTTI meM milI? jarA pahile hI vicAra se kAma liyA hotA to sujJa janatA meM ApakI mUrkhatA to jAhira nahIM hotI? haiM

Page #85
40 zAzvatI pratimAeM aura sUryAbhadeva ************* ***** *** . sundara mitra ! gozIrSa candana kA lepa zarIra ko zAMti pahu~cAne va zItala rakhane ke kAraNa kiyA jAtA thA, yaha koI ubaTana nahIM thA jise dhokara sApha karane kI jarUrata par3e yadi itanA bhI jJAna Apa meM hotA to ApakA "jJAnasundara" nAma nirarthaka siddha nahIM hotA / mahadAzcarya to isa bAta kA hai ki zrI jJAnasundarajI to phira bhI mAtR bhASA ke zuddha jJAna se rahita haiM isalie apanI ajJatA ke kAraNa inase koI manakalpita anartha bhI ho jAya, para AgamoddhAraka, AcArya deva kahAne vAle zrI sAgarAnandasUrijI ne bhI apane vAjiMtra siddha cakra pAkSika varSa 7 aMka 6 meM sUryAbha kI mUrti pUjA kA varNana karate hue isa zabda kA artha vastra car3hAnA likhA hai, aura yahI AcArya * isa zabda kA jaMbudvIpa prajJapti aura AcArAMga ke pATha dete hue pahinAnA artha karate haiM, kyA, pakSAndhatA kI bhI koI sImA hai? yadi "niyaMseti" kA artha car3hAnA hI ho to ina logoM ko yaha bhI mAnanA cAhiye ki svayaM sUryAbha ne aura bhagavAn mahAvIra va bharatezvara koNika Adi ne bhI vastra nahIM pahine para apane pairoM meM car3hA liye ? jabaki inhIM ke mAnya TIkAkAra mUrti ko vastra pahinAnA svIkAra karate haiM taba ye Aja kala ke mahAn AcArya (?) pakSapAta ke cakkara meM par3akara isa prakAra anartha karane laga jAya~, yaha kitanI hAsyajanaka bAta hai ? isa prakAra spaSTa siddha ho gayA ki sUryAbha ne mUrti ko vastra pahinAye the aura tIrthaMkara vastra nahIM pahanate, ataeva yaha pratimA tIrthaMkara kI nahIM hai|

Page #86
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 41 (I) pUjana-vidhi ___ tIrthaMkara prabhu pUrNa tyAgI mahApuruSa haiM, ve sacitta to ThIka para anAvazyaka acitta vastu ko bhI nahIM chUte, unakI pUjA mana vacana aura zarIra se hI hotI hai, yadi koI unheM acitta pAnI se snAna karAnA cAhe, akSata car3hAveM, dravya bheMTa kareM, AbhUSaNa pahinAne kA prayatna kare to ve kabhI bhI svIkAra nahIM krte| yadi koI anajAna hone se isa prakAra kI bhakti karanA cAhe to ve use rokate haiN| prabhu svayaM isa prakAra kI pUjA svIkAra nahIM karate the aura una jagadupakArI prabhu ne apane sAdhu sAdhviyoM ko kisI bhI prakAra kI sacitta vastu ke chUne ko manA kiyA hai| yadi susAdhuoM se anajAna apane meM aisA ho jAya to mAlUma hone para ve prAyazcitta lekara zuddha hote haiM, jaba zarIradhArI aura sAkSAt prabhu hI isa prakAra kI pUjA ko svIkAra nahIM karate, to unakI mUrti ko to aisI pUjA kI jarUrata hI kyA? yadi zarIradhArI sAdhu jaGgala meM hoM aura pyAsa ke mAre unake prANa sukha rahe hoM, taba bhI ve prANa denA svIkAra kara leMge para pAsa ke sacitta pAnI se bhare hue jalAzaya se pAnI nahIM leMge, aisI hAlata meM acetana-jar3a-aisI tIrthaMkara mUrti ke lie to aisI pUjA ucita ho kaise ho? aura sUryAbha ne to sarAgI devoM kI mUrti kI taraha jala, phUla, akSata, dhUpa Adi se Arambha varddhaka pUjA kI hai, ataeva ye mUrtiyeM tIrthaMkara kI nahIM honI caahiye| yadi Apa vartamAna kI tIrthaMkara mUrti kI pUjA kA udAharaNa dekara una mUrtiyoM ko tIrthaMkara mUrtiye kaheM, to yaha bhI ThIka nahIM, kyoMki yaha to Apane zAyada isI kathAnaka kA anukaraNa kiyA hai| kyoMki Apa apanI pUjA paddhati meM inhIM kA pramANa dete haiM, isaliye ApakA kathana anucita aura hamArI yukti nyAya saGgata hai|

Page #87
42 zAzvatI pratimAeM aura sUryAbhadeva zarIra varNana meM bhinnatA vizvopakArI mahAn AtmAoM ke zarIra kA varNana zikha-nakha arthAt mastaka se lekara pairoM taka krama se hotA hai aura anya manuSyoM kA varNana "nakha-zikha' arthAt pairoM se lagAkara mastaka taka ulTe krama se hotA hai| bhagavAn mahAvIra ke zarIra kA varNana "uvavAI" aura "rAyapraseNI" sUtra meM "zikha-nakha" se haiM, kintu ina pratimAoM kA varNana "nakha-zikha' se hai, isalie ye pratimAyeM tIrthaMkara kI pratimA nahIM mAnI jaatiiN| pratimA-parivAra tIrthaMkara prabhu ke gaNadhara, pUrvadhara, labdhidhara Adi hajAroM sAdhu aura sAdhviyoM kA parivAra hotA hai kintu nAga, bhUta, yakSAdikoM kA nahIM, aura ina pratimAoM ke parivAra meM (pAsa meM) do do nAga bhUta aura yakSa pratimAyeM haiM, isalie bhI ye pratimAyeM tIrthaMkara kI nahIM siddha hotiiN| yadi yahA~ yaha kahA jAya ki ina pratimAoM ke sAmane jo nAga bhUtAdi kI pratimA haiM vaha sevA meM karabaddha khar3I haiM isase ina jina pratimAoM kA mahattva hai to yaha bhI anucita hai kyoMki tIrthaMkara prabhu kI sevA meM nAga bhUtAdi to kyA vaimAnika devoM ke bar3e-bar3e indra bhI khar3e rahate haiM, taba ina mAmUlI (sAdhAraNa se sAdhAraNa) devoM kA mahattva hI kyA? aura so bhI sUryAbha vimAna meM, svayaM sUryAbha se bhI ve nAga bhUtAdi deva halkI koTi ke haiM, to vahA~ inakA mahattva kucha bhI nahIM hai| vahA~ to bar3e-bar3e indroM kI pratimA honI cAhiye thI ataeva siddha huA ki ve jinapratimAe~ tIrthaMkara pratimAyeM nahIM haiN|

Page #88
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA nAma-nizcitatA tIrthaMkaroM ke lie yaha koI niyama nahIM ki inake amuka amuka nAma hI honA cAhiye, ye kisI bhI nAma se ho sakate haiN| hA~ ye mahApuruSa haiM isaliye inake nAma guNa niSpanna to hote haiN| idhara devaloka meM jahA~ bhI pratimAyeM haiM ve sabhI cAra nAmoM kI hI haiM, jahA~ 108 pratimAyeM haiM ve bhI sirpha ina cAra nAmoM kI hI haiN| isase bhI yahI siddha hotA hai ki ye pratimAyeM tIrthaMkara kI nahIM hai, kyoMki tIrthaMkara to 24 hote haiM aura sabhI bhinna-bhinna nAma ke, phira yahA~ cAra hI nAma kI mUrtiyeM kyoM ? aura ye nAma bhI zAzvata kyoM? isake uttara meM jJAnasundarajI pR0 47 meM likhate haiM ki - "ye cAra nAma zAzvata haiM, hara eka caubIsI meM ina cAra nAma ke tIrthaMkara hote hI haiM isIlie devaloka meM ina cAra nAma kI hI pratimAyeM haiM / " inakI ukta tarka bhI managar3hata hI pratIta hotI hai, kyoMki isake lie Apane koI pramANa nahIM diyA na Aja taka kahIM kisI Agama meM aisA pramANa dekhane meM hI AyA hai, ataeva pramANa zUnya bAta kA mUlya hI kyA ? dUsarA jaba hama samavAyAMga sUtra meM bhaviSyat utsarpiNI kAla meM hone vAle tIrthaMkara kI pUrI nAmAvalI dekhate haiM taba usameM to ina ( RSabha varddhamAna, candrAnana, vArisena) cAra nAmoM meM se eka bhI nAma nahIM hai phira inakI tarka ke mithyA hone meM kyA nyUnatA hai ? maiM sundara mitra se pUchatA hU~ ki yadi kisI caubIsI meM 20 - 22 yA 23 tIrthaMkara ho cuke hoM aura unameM ukta cAroM nAma meM se eka bhI nahIM hue hoM aura 24 veM tIrthaMkara avatAra lekara gRhastha vAsa meM ho unakA nAma ina cAra nAmoM se bhinna ho to kyA nAma bhinnatA ke kAraNa hI ve tIrthaMkara hone se vaMcita raha jAya~ge ? nahIM 43

Page #89
zAzvatI pratimAeM aura sUryAbhadeva ******** kadApi nahIM / yahA~ nAma dhAma kI koI bAdhA nahIM hai, yaha to kevala mUrti mati mahAnubhAvoM kA matamoha hI hai / ataeva vimAnavAsI devoM meM aura tirche loka meM jahA~ bhI jina pratimAyeM haiM ve sabhI jagaha adhika saMkhyA meM hote hue bhI kevala nirdhArita cAroM nAma kI hone ke kAraNa tIrthaMkara kI nahIM hai, jabaki bhaviSyat utsarpiNI kAla meM hone vAle 24 tIrthaMkaroM kI nAmAvalI meM inameM se eka kA bhI nAma nahIM hai taba sundarajI kI tarka Thahara hI kaise sakatI hai ? itane vizada vicAra se yaha spaSTa ho gayA ki devaloka sthita pratimAyeM tIrthaMkara pratimA nahIM hai / 44 (2) sUryAbha sAkSI kI anupAdeyatA sundara baMdhu ne mUrti pUjA meM dharma aura ise Agama AjJA yukta ThaharAne ke lie sUryAbha kI sAkSI dekara apanI kamajorI hI prakaTa kI hai, kyoMki sUryAbha deva kA yaha kArya koI dhArmika kArya nahIM kintu vimAna sambandhI saMsAra vyavahAra kA kArya hai| saMsAra meM rahA huA samyagdRSTi jIva sAMsArika vyavahAra kA bhI pAlana karatA hai sAdhAraNa manuSya hI nahIM para gRhasthAvasthA meM rahe tIrthaMkara prabhu bhI apane mAtA pitA ko namaskAra karate haiM, cakravartI pana meM cakraratnAdi kI pUjA aura anya Avazyaka vyavahAroM kA yathA samaya pAlana karate haiM, (sAdhu avasthA meM nahIM) isI prakAra sUryAbhadeva bhI devapane meM utpanna hone para vahA~ ke vimAnagata paramparAnusAra cale Aye AcAra kA pAlana kiyaa| isameM dharma mAnane kI koI bAta hI nahIM hai / jisa prakAra vartamAna samaya meM dezI rAjyoM ke nareza dazahare ke avasara para DhAla, talavAra, bandUka, topa, ghaNTA, nakkArA, nizAna

Page #90
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA *Shui Shui ga Shui Bing Shui ************* ******** (dhvajA) hAthI, ghor3A aura mukhyadvAra Adi kI pUjA karate haiN| vyApArI loga divAlI ke avasara para kalama, davAta, bahI, supArI ke banAye hue gaNeza aura dravya Adi kI pUjA karate haiM, usI prakAra sUryAbha deva ne bhI apane rAjyAbhiSeka ke samaya una pratimAoM aura nAga, bhUta, yakSa pratimAoM tathA dvAra, toraNa, nAgadantA, bAvar3I Adi aneka vastuoM kI pUjA kI hai, isI se spaSTa ho jAtA hai ki yaha kriyA dhArmika nahIM hai| yadi sUryAbha ke isa kRtya ko dhArmika mAnA jAya to bahuta sI bAdhAyeM utpanna hotI haiM, jisameM mukhya yaha hai ki yadi mUrti pUjA meM dharma hai to batAiye dvAra, zAkhA, toraNa, nAgadantA, aura bAvar3I Adi kI pUjA meM bhI Apako dharma mAnanA cAhiye bhUta nAgAdi kI mUrtiyoM kI pUjA ko bhI dharma meM sammilita karanA cAhie, aura to aura isa prakAra mAnane para dharma kA mahattva kucha bhI nahIM rahegA, balki saMsAra ke bhairava, bhavAnI, pIra, bhUta yakSAdi kI mUrtiyoM kA pUjanA bhI dharma mAnA jaaygaa| isa prakAra itanA andhera khAtA calegA ki mithyAtva aura samyaktva meM kucha bhI bheda nahIM rhegaa| .. ___yadi yaha kahA jAya ki sUryAbha deva ne jaise mUrti kI pUjA kI hai, vaise anya vastuoM kI pUjA nahIM kI, ataeva anya mUrtiyoM aura vastuoM kI pUjA meM dharma nahIM mAnA jA sakatA to yaha bhI ThIka nahIM, kyoMki sUryAbha ne aura vastuoM kI bhI pAnI, puSpa, puSpamAlAyeM aura dhUpa se pUjA kI hai, isa bAta ko Apake TIkAkAra bhI svIkAra karate haiM, dekhiye - "caityavRkSasya dvAra vadarcanikAM karoti xxx pUrvasya mukhamaNDapasya dakSiNa dvAre pazcimastambha paMttayottara pUrvadvAreSu krameNoktarUpAM pUjA vidhaay|"

Page #91
46 zAzvatI pratimAeM aura sUryAbhadeva ************************************** isa prakAra sabhI vastuoM kI pUjA kI jAnA siddha hai| yadi Apa use pUjA nahIM mAne to batAiye, sUryAbha ko una vastuoM ko pAnI kI dhArA dene, candana se arcane, phUla car3hAne, mAlAyeM pahinAne aura dhUpa dene kI kyA jarUrata thI? kahanA nahIM hogA ki yaha saba pUjA hI thI, ataeva ina vastuoM kI pUjA meM bhI Apako dharma mAnanA caahiye| ___mahAnubhAva! sUryAbha kI yaha saba kriyAyeM rAjyAbhiSeka ke samaya vahA~ kI paramparAnusAra jIta-vyavahAra ko adA karane kI thI isase dharma mAna lenA yA dhArmikatA kA raGga car3hAnA kisI prakAra ucita nahIM hai| ... zrI jJAnasundarajI ne sUryAbha kI isa pratimA pUjana ko dhArmika karaNI batAne ke lie kucha yuktiyeM dI haiN| yahA~ hama saMkSipta meM ve yuktiyA~ bhI batA dete haiN| 1. ve pratimAyeM padmAsana se dhyAnastha haiM isalie tIrthaMkara - pratimAyeM haiN| 2. sUryAbha ne "namutthuNaM" ke pATha se unakI stuti kI ataeva ye mUrtiyeM tIrthaMkara kI thii| 3. isa pUjA kA phala zAstrakAra ne sAkSAt tIrthaMkara vandana saMyama pAlana ke phala ke barAbara hita, sukha yAvat mokSa taka kahA hai| 4. jItAcAra kI karaNI meM bhagavAn ne AjJA dI hai| 5. sUryAbha samyagdRSTi aura bhavya hai, ataeva usakI mUrti pUjA upAdeya hai| ukta pA~coM yuktiyoM para nimna vicAra kiyA jAtA hai|

Page #92
.47 jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA **** *************************Xue Xue ** 1. sundara mitra ne likhA hai ki "ve mUrtiyeM padmAsana se dhyAna lagAkara baiThI hai ataeva aisI pratimAyeM sivAya tIrthaMkara ke anya kI nahIM ho sktii|" isa viSaya meM hamArA samAdhAna yaha hai ki sUtra meM kahIM bhI nahIM likhA ki "ve mUrtiye dhyAnastha kAyotsarga mudrA se baiThI hai, sUtra meM to sirpha paryaGkAsana se baiThane kA hI varNana hai, phira binA kisI AdhAra ke sundara mitrajI ne "dhyAna lagAkara baiThI' aisA kaise likha mArA? dUsarI bAta yaha hai ki Aja bhI ajaina mUrtiyeM paryaGkAsana se baiThI huI kaI sthAnoM para milatI hai, vaiSNavoM ke kaI mandiroM ke Upara paryaGkAsana se unake RSiyoM kI mUrtiye baiThI dikhAI detI hai, itanA hI nahIM ajamera ke myujiyama meM to eka prAcIna buddha mUrti paryaGkAsana se aura vaha bhI kAyotsarga mudrA se baiThI huI hai| phira sundarajI kevala paryaMGkAsana zabda se hI use arhat mUrti mAna le, aura apanI ora se use dhyAna lagAkara baiThI huI (pR0 46) batA deM, yaha pratyakSa mata moha nahIM to kyA hai? 2. dUsarI yukti "namutthuNaM' viSayaka hai, isa viSaya meM yaha samAdhAna hai ki sUryAbha ne mUrti kI namutthuNaM se stuti nahIM kii| pratimA kI stuti to usane 108 gAthAoM dvArA hI kI, aura phira usa sthAna se 7-8 pAMva pIche haTakara namutthuNaM kahA, dekhiye vaha mUla pATha : "aTThasaya visuddhaganthajuttehiM atthajuttehiM apuNaruttehiM mahAvittehiM saMthuNai saMthuNittA sattaTThapayAI paccosakkai paccosakkittA" aadi| spaSTa huA ki sUryAbha ne mUrti kI 108 gAthAoM se stuti kI aura phira vahA~ se pIche haTakara bAda meM "namutthuNaM' kahA, isase yaha

Page #93
48 zAzvatI pratimAeM aura sUryAbhadeva ********************************************* samajhanA sarala hai ki "namutthuNaM'' mUrti ko nahIM para siddhoM ko hai| dUsarI bAta-"namutthuNaM' jo kahA vaha siddhoM kI stuti ke liye kahA*, usake antima vAkya meM bhI yahI bAta hai ki "siddhigainAma dheyaM ThANaM saMpattANaM" isaliye yaha stuti siddhagati prApta siddhoM kI hI kI gii| aura NamutthuNaM jo hai vaha bhAva tIrthaMkaroM kI stuti kA bhI pATha hai, pramANa meM inake mUrti-pUjaka lekhakoM ke mantavya dekhiye "bhAva jinezvara nI stuti mATe kahevAtA zakrastava mAM yoga mudrA raakhvii|" (zrI sAgarAnanda sUrijI-siddha-cakra varSa 7 aGka 4 tA0 21-11-38) "pracalita zakrastava paryanta nA pAThano viSaya vividha vizeSaNo thI vibhUSita evI bhAva arihaMta prabhunI stuti che'. ane enA pachI nI gAthA dravya arihaMta ane bhAva arihaMta nI vaMdanA rUpa ch|" (pro0 hIrAlAla rasikadAsa kApar3iyA, "jaina satya prakAza" varSa 2 aGka 12 pR0 600 kA namutthuNaM ne aGge zIrSaka lekha) ataeva siddha ho gayA ki "namutthuNaM jinezvara kI stuti hai, aura sUryAbha deva ne isase siddha prabhu-bhAva jinezvara-kI hI stuti kI hai, sthApanA-mUrti kI nhiiN| 3. tIsarI yukti meM sundara mitra ne likhA hai ki sUryAbha kI mUrtipUjA ko zAstrakAra ne hitakArI, sukhakArI, kalyANakArI aura mokSakArI honA batAI hai| isameM sundaramitrajI bhole bhAiyoM kI A~khoM meM dhUla DAlane kA prayatna karate hue likhate haiM ki - "sUryAbha ke ina praznoM ke uttara meM zAstrakAra pharamAte haiM ki'- (pR0 61) * namutthuNaM ko zakrastava bhI kahate haiN| tional

Page #94
46 jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA *******Zhong Zhong Zhong Zhong Zhong Zhong Zhong Zhong Zhong Zhong ***************************** basa isI meM ina mahAnubhAva kI cAlAkI hai| isa eka lAina meM ina mahAtmA ne "zAstrakAra" yaha zabda ajJoM kI A~khoM aura hRdaya paTa para dhUla DAlane ke kuvicAra se rakkhA hai, kyoMki sUryAbha kA uttara zAstrakAra ne nahIM, balki usI kI sAmAnya pariSad ke devoM ne diyA hai| sundara sAhaba kI isa caturAI (?) kA mukhya kAraNa yahI hai ki yaha phala devoM ke mukha se nahIM hokara zAstrakAra ke hI mukha se honA batAyA jAyagA, to phira kisI ko kucha kahane kI jagaha hI nahIM rhegii| hAM, sundarajI! sAdhu kahAkara bhI kuTilatA se bAja nahIM aaye| isake sivAya sundara mitra ne isa kuTilatA ko janatA ke hRdaya meM ThIka taraha se jamA dene ke uddezya se eka koSTaka banAkara mUrti-pUjA, tIrthaMkara vandana aura saMyama pAlana tInoM kA eka samAna phala honA zAstra sammata batAyA hai| yahA~ hama inake isa kucakra kA chedana karane ke liye usI prakAra kA zAstra sammata eka koSTaka banAkara janatA ke sAmane rakhate haiM mUla kI tIrthaMkara vaMdana phala | saMyama pAlana phala dhana rakSA phala | mUrti-pUjA phala eyeNaM pecca bhaveya |hiyaM, suhaM, khamaM, | pacchA purAe / hiyAe, suhAe, NisseyasaM aNu | vi hiyAe suhAe khemAe, NisseyasAe | gAmiyaM khemAe nisse- | khamAe nisseaNugAmiyattAe yasAe aNugA- | yasAe aannugaabhvissii| miyattAe bhavi- mittayAe bhvissii| ssti|

Page #95
50 zAzvatI pratimAeM aura sUryAbhadeva ***************************************** anuvAda isa bhava aura para- |hita kartA, sukha | pIche aura pahile pahale va pIche .. bhava meM hita kartA, | kartA, kSema kartA, | hita kArI, hitakArI sukhakArI sukha kartA, kSema kalyANa kartA, | sukhakArI, kSema-| kSemakArI kartA, kalyANa mokSakartA sAtha | kArI, kalyANa- kalyANakArI va kartA, mokSa kartA, | Ane vAlA hotA | kArI mokSakArI | sAtha Ane aura sAtha Ane | hai| (AcArAMga | sAtha Ane vAlA hotA vAlA hogaa| jana | a08 Apta kathita) vAlA hotA hai| | hai| (rAyapraseNI samUha se kahA huA bhagavatI za.2-1/ deva vacana aura sUtrakAra se skandaka vacana | Apta AjJA sammata dvArA dhanalobhI | rahita) (utta0 a026) kI bhaavnaa|) pAThaka sundarajI ke diye hue koSTaka aura hamAre isa koSTaka ko milAkara dekheMge to isameM rahA huA bheda spaSTa mAlUma ho skegaa| hamAre ukta koSTaka se pAThaka sahaja hI meM samajha jAya~ge ki prabhuvandana aura cAritra pAlana kA phala hita-sukha kSema aura mokSakara svayaM sarvajJa prabhu ne batalAyA aura zAstrakAroM ne sUtra rUpa grahaNa kiyA kintu jisa prakAra dhana rakSA kA phala sUtrakAra kI ora se nahIM para dhanalobhI-dravyAsakta-prANI kI svataMtra mAnyatA batAI hai| usI prakAra mUrti pUjA kA phala bhI sUtrakAra kI ora se nahIM hokara sAmAnya pariSad ke devoM kA hai| so bhI ihalaukika zAMti ke liye na ki pAralaukika AtmakalyANArtha! jisa prakAra vartamAna samaya meM janmotsava, vivAhotsava, yA videza gamana ke samaya kitane hI dezoM meM bhAvi zAMti ke liye-nirvighna kArya pUrNa rone kI bhAvanA se-deva pUjA kI

Page #96
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 51 ****************************Xue Xue ************ jAtI hai| vyApArI vyApAra prAraMbha karate samaya zubha muhUrta dekhakara bhAvi lAbha kI AzA se sAMsArika devoM ko manAte haiN| usI prakAra sUryAbha ne bhI apanI utpatti ke bAda apanI AdhInatA meM rahe hue deva, devI, vimAna Adi para niSkaNTaka adhikAra banAye rakhane va jIvana lIlA ko sukhapUrvaka calAne Adi kI bhAvanA se pUrva paramparAgata AcAra ke anusAra kriyA kI, usI ke lie prazna kiye aura usI ke use hita-sukha Adi zabdoM meM uttara mile yaha bilakula sahaja hai| devoM ne jo bhI hita sukhAdi phala batAye haiM ve kevala sAMsArika dRSTi se hI haiM, na ki dhArmika vicAra se| aise sIdhe va sarala prakaraNa ko jabaradastI apanI mAnyatA kI yukti meM ghasITanA kevala pakSapAta pUrNa hRdaya kA kAma hai| yadi sujJa pAThaka dhyAna pUrvaka isa viSaya ke mUla pATha ko dekheMge to unheM mAlUma hogA ki mUla pATha se hI isakA samAdhAna ho sakatA hai| dhana rakSA aura mUrti-pUjA ke phala meM pahale va pIche hita-sukhakara Adi jitane kalyANakara zabda Aye haiM aura prabhu vaMdana viSaya meM peccaparabhava-bhAvI janma-meM sukhakara hitakara zabda Aye haiM, isI (pacchA aura peccA) arthAt "pIche aura parabhava' zabda se hI yaha viSaya spaSTa ho jAtA hai| dhana rakSA aura mUrti pUjA phala ke lie "pacchA" zabda hai, isase matalaba Aja se pIche isI janma taka se hai, arthAt dhanarakSA se Aja se janma paryanta hita sukha arthAt Ananda milatA hai, usI prakAra mUrti pUjA se bhI Aja se pIche iha janma paryaMta hita sukha arthAt nirvighna rUpa Ananda mila sakatA hai| aura tIrthaMkara vaMdana se to "peccA" arthAt parabhava meM bhI Ananda milatA hai| parabhava meM Ananda tabhI milegA jaba AtmA ne kalyANakArI kRtya kiye hoN| basa ___

Page #97
52 zAzvatI pratimAeM aura sUryAbhadeva ***************** *** ********** spaSTa hai ki jisa prakAra tIrthaMkara vaMdana aura cAritra pAlana kA phala parabhava meM kalyANakArI hai usI prakAra dhana rakSA yA mUrti pUjA kA phala nahIM / yadyapi sujJa janoM ke lie hamArA itanA samajhAnA hI paryApta hai phira bhI sundarajI kI caturAI ko cUra-cUra karane ke lie yahAM inhIM ke abhimata kucha pramANa de diye jAte haiM jisase kisI ko kucha zaGkA karane kI jagaha hI na rhe| sundara mitra ne mUrti pUjA aura cAritra kA phala bilakula samAna hI batAyA hai, kintu sundara saMmata ( mUrti pUjaka) granthakAra hI inake ukta kathana se sarvathA virodhI haiM, dekhiye nimna pramANa - " davvathao bhAvathao, davvathao bahuguNatti buddhi siA / aniuNa maivayaNamiNaM, chajjIvahiaM jiNA viMti // 162 // chajjIvakAya saMjamu davvathae so virujjhaI kasiNo / to kasiNa saMjama viU pupphAiM na icchati // 163 // artha - dravyastava aura bhAvastava yadi aisA kahA jAya ki dravya stava bahuta guNavAlA hai to yaha kathana buddhi kI anipuNatA ( buddhimaMdatA ) hI jAhira karatA hai, kyoMki tIrthaMkara mahArAja chaha kAya jIvoM ke hita ko kahate haiM aura chaha kAya jIvoM kI rakSA dravyastava meM sampUrNa ruddha hotI hai, isalie sampUrNa saMyama ke jAnakAra muni puSpAdi ko nahIM cAhate / / 162-163 / / (Avazyaka hAribhadrIya caturviMzatistava) yahA~ AcArya zrI haribhadrasUri ne dravyastava mUrtti pUjA ko saMyama virodhinI batAkara aisI prarUpaNA karane vAle ko maMda buddhi kahA hai 'aura dekhiye -

Page #98
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 53 Li ************ ***********Ben Ben Lai Shui Shui ******* lAkhamAM aMze paNa nathI AvatuM ane tethI tevI pUjA Adi ne chor3I ne paNa bhAva dharma rUpI cAritra aGgIkAra karavAmAM aavech|" (zrI0 sAgarAnanda sUrijI-dIkSAnuM suMdara svarUpa pR0 147) isake sivAya mahAnizIthakAra ne bhI mUrti pUjA kA niSedha kara cAritra pAlana para jora diyA hai yahA~ taka kahA hai ki - cAritravAn sAdhu mandira para pA~va bhI nahIM de| aba itane puSTa pramANoM para se sundara mitra se pUchate haiM ki - mahAtman! kyA aba bhI ApakA ajJAna dUra nahIM huA? kyA aba bhI Apa mUrti pUjA aura cAritra pAlana ko eka hI koTi meM rakkheMge? jabaki svayaM mUrti pUjaka AcArya cAritrapAlana ke sAmane mUrti pUjA ko ekadama tuccha ginate haiM taba Apa hI batAiye ki ApakA kathana satya yA Apake vidvAn AcAryoM kA? yadi ApakI mAnyatAnusAra jo phala mUrti pUjA kA hai vahI saMyama pAlana kA ho to phira sarva tyAgI hokara sAdhu banane kI AvazyakatA hI kyA hai? spaSTa huA ki mUrti pUjA kA phala mokSa nahIM hai, na aisA zAstrakAra kA hI kathana hai, hA~ yaha suMdara hRdayI suMdarajI kI cAlAkI yukta prapaJca jAla to avazya hai| suMdara bandhu yadi isI hiyAe suhAe Adi pATha para TIkAkAra kA mata bhI dekha lete to zAyada isa prakAra kA sAhasa nahIM karate, isa pATha ke viSaya meM TIkAkAra spaSTa likhate haiM ki - "iha prAktano granthaH prAyo'pUrvaH bhUyAnapi ca pustakeSu vAcanA bhedastato mA'bhUt ziSyANAM sammoha iti kvApi sugamo'pi yathAvasthita vAcanAkrama pradarzanArtha likhitH|" ___ isI viSaya meM bhASAMtarakAra paM0 becaradAsajI dosI pR0 88 ke phuTanoTa 87 meM likhate haiM ki -

Page #99
zAzvatI pratimAeM aura sUryAbhadeva *************** * ************* * ___ "TIkAkAra lakhe che ke "Asthale pustakoM mAM ghaNoya vAcanA bheda-pATha bheda che ane temAno keTaloka to prAya: apUrva che, te thI ziSyoM ne sanmoha to thavAno paNa e nathAe te mATe ahiM eka sugama pATha ame Apelo che' mArI samaja mAM phera na hoya to je hakIkata ne AzrI ne jaina samAja mAM moTo matabheda pravarte che te hakIkata ne lagato A pATha bheda lAge che, A pATha bheda bAbata khUba vicArI ne tatva zodha thAya toja jaina samAja mAM zAMti pravarte e dhyAna mA rAkhavAnuM che|" mitra! samajha gaye TIkAkAra ke Azaya ko? ve kahate haiM ki yahAM (hiyAe suhAe Adi pATha meM) pATha bheda bahuta haiM, jisase ziSyoM ko sandeha hogA, isalie yahAM hama sugama pATha rakhate haiM, aura Apa hI kI mUrti pUjaka samAja ke vidvAn bhASAMtarakAra paM0 becaradAsajI isI para se kahate haiM ki jaina samAja meM bhArI matabheda cala rahA hai| jisa pATha ko hI Apake TIkAkAra mahArAja sandeha janya batA rahe haiM usI para ApakA uchala kUda macAnA aura vaha bhI ekadama unmArga kI ora yaha kahA~ taka ucita hai? vijJa pAThaka samajha gaye hoMge ki sundara mitra kI yukti kevala bholI janatA ko bhrama meM phaMsAne kI prapaJca jAla mAtra hai| 4. sundara mitra ne eka yukti yaha bhI peza kI hai ki "jaba Apa sUryAbha kI mUrti pUjA ko jItAcAra kahate haiM to jItAcAra ke lie to bhagavAn ne svayaM sUryAbha ko AjJA dI haiM, isa hetu se mUrti pUjA meM prabhu AjJA pAlana rUpa dharma hai hI" isake samAdhAna meM hamArA kathana hai ki - jaba sUryAbha prabhu mahAvIra kI sevA meM upasthita hokara apanA nAma, gotra sunAkara vandana namaskAra karatA hai| inake uttara meM prabhu pharamAte haiM ki he sUryAbha! yaha tumhArA purAnA jItAcAra hai yAvat

Page #100
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 55 ***************************************** bhavanapatyAdi ke deva arihaMto ko vandana namaskAra kara apane nAma gotra sunAte haiM Adi, isameM prabhu ne kevala vandana namaskAra aura nAma gotra sunAne ko jItAcAra kahA hai aura isI kI AjJA pradAna kI hai, na ki mUrti pUjA rUpa sAMsArika jItAcAra kii| jItAcAra bhI do prakAra ke hote haiM, 1. sAMsArika aura 2. dhArmika sUryAbha kA mUrti pUjA rUpI jItAcAra sAMsArika haiM, isameM prabhu kI AjJA hai hI nahIM, yadi isameM bhI Apa prabhu AjJA mAneMge to prabhu AjJA aura dharma adharma meM kucha bhI antara nahIM rahegA, kyoMki sUryAbha ne to jItAcArAnusAra nAga bhUtAdi kI pratimA, bAvar3I, nAgadantA dvAra aura dhvajA Adi kI bhI jala, phUla, candana aura dhUpa se pUjA kI hai phira yaha bhI dhArmika jItAcAra meM mAnA jaaygaa| ataeva sAMsArika jItAcAra ko dhArmikatA kA rUpa denA aura vandana namaskAra tathA nAma gotra uccAraNa rUpa dhArmika jItAcAra kI anumati meM ise ghasITa lenA zuddha hRdayI sujJoM kA kArya nahIM hai| zrI suMdarajI mUrti moha meM itane masta ho gaye ki satyAsatya kA bhAna hI gaMvA baiThe, Apa pR0 56 meM likhate haiM ki - "jina pratimA kI dravya bhAva pUjA kara sUryAbha bhagavAn mahAvIra deva ko vandana karane ko jAtA hai|" sundarajI kA matalaba hai ki - mUrti pUjA ke sAtha hI sUryAbha prabhu vaMdana ko jAtA hai kintu yaha kathana bilakula mithyA hai| pUjA to janme bAda hI kI thI aura vandana namaskAra to usake bAda kAlAMtara meM kiyA, isase usakA kyA sambandha? aura sUtra meM vandana namaskAra kA varNana to pahale AyA, aura pUjA kA bahuta Age bar3ha kara AyA hai, phira eka se dUsare kA sambandha hI kyA? kyA isameM bhI koI sundara rahasya hai?

Page #101
zAzvatI pratimAeM aura sUryAbhadeva *************************************** 5. sundara mitra ne eka yukti yaha dI hai, ki "sUryAbha deva samyagdRSTi aura bhavya hai aura samyagdRSTi anya deva ko pUjate nahIM isalie usakI mUrti pUjA upAdeya hai" yaha kathana bhI binA soce samajhe haiM kyoMki sAMsArika vyavahAra pAlane se dhArmikatA meM koI bAdhA nahIM hai, saMsAra meM rahA huA samyaktva ko zuddha rakha sakatA hai, jabaki Apake kalikAla sarvajJa zrI hemacandrAcArya sAdhu dazA meM rahe hue bhI ziva-zaMkara-jaise ajaina deva kI mUrti kI stuti kara sakeM, avirati devoM kA smaraNa-dhyAna aura ArAdhana kara sakeM, rAtri ko sthAna chor3akara bAhara jAkara deva deviyoM ko bali de sakeM, sAdhu sAdhvI dina meM do do bAra avirati devoM kI stuti kara sakeM, to gRhastha samyaktvI kisI vizeSa paristhiti meM saMsAra vyavahAra ke adA karane ke lie mithyAtvI devoM kA laukika artha pUjanAdi kare to isameM samyaktva ko kyA bAdhA hai? aura devaloka meM sabhI deva to samyaktvI hai hI nahIM, jaise yahA~ kaI mata ke manuSya rahate haiM vaise devaloka meM bhI kaI mata ke deva rahate haiM, aura svarga meM pratimAyeM to kevala ye cAra prakAra kI hI haiM jise sabhI devatA pUjate hoMge, isase bhI yahI siddha hotA hai ki ina pratimAoM kA pUjanA dhArmika dRSTi se nahIM hai, dhArmika dRSTi se ho to phira mithyA dRSTi deva unheM kyoM pUjane lageM? isalie sUryAbha kA yaha kRtya laukika uddezya se hai, aura laukika Avazyaka vyavahAroM kA pAlana karatA huA bhI zuddha zraddhA vAlA gRhastha apanI samyaktva ko nirmala rakha sakatA hai| ataeva yaha yukti bhI kuyukti hI siddha huii| isa prakAra sUryAbha deva kA udAharaNa janatA ke sAmane rakhakara unheM mUrti pUjA meM phaMsAnA ThIka nahIM hai| mUrti pUjA dharma va AtmakalyANa

Page #102
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA **: kA aGga nahIM hai, na isake lie prAmANika sUtroM meM prabhu AjJA hai phira khAlI kathAoM kI oTa lekara manamAne Azaya jor3akara vitaMDAvAda phailAnA sujJajanoM aura AtmArthiyoM kA kArya nahIM hai| sUryAbha sAkSI ke lie mUrti pUjaka samAja ke zrI hukumamunijI bhI Apase asahamata haiM, dekhiye "je loko surIAbha deva no tathA dhrupadI (draupadI, le0) pramukhanoM adhikAra dekhADIye chIyeM parantu te karaNImAM vicAra ghaNo che zAmATe ke bije devatA pramukha ghaNA deve, pUjA devapaNe upanyA te vakhata karI che, paNa tene bhagavAne samakiti kahayA nathI, te to mithyAtvI che, ane te deva navA upane eTale sarve pujA kare evaM sUtra jotAM mAluma par3e che, parantu kaMi samakitI mithyAtvI no niyama rahyo nathI, tema kaMi pharIthI pUjA karavAno adhikAra koI ne che nahiM / " 57 (adhyAtma prakaraNa antargata tattvasAroddhAra pR0 410 ) isake sivAya mUrti pUjaka pratibhA sampanna vidvAn paM0 becaradAsajI dozI, apane " rAyapaseNaiya sutta" pravezaka ke pR0 21 lakhate haiM "huM samajuM chaM tyAM sudhI A sUtra no svAdhyAya karanAre rAjA paesI citta zuddhIkaraNa ne ja dhyAna mAM rAkhavAnuM che, e sivAya dharma ne nAme hair vadhe rIte e sUtra no upayoga karavo ghaTita lAgato nathI / " mUrti pUjaka samAja ke eka prasiddha vidvAn kA bhI jaba yaha mata hai aura ve bhI rAjA pradezI ke Atma kalyANa ko hI lakSita karane kA kahate haiM, jisakA Azaya bilakula spaSTa hai ki - jisa prakAra pradezI rAjA ne dhArmika jIvana meM praveza kara vrata, niyama, tapa, svAdhyAya, kSamA, anAsakti Adi dvArA Atma kalyANa kiyA aura pUrva ke nivir3a

Page #103
zAI 58 zAzvatI pratimAeM aura sUryAbhadeva **Li Xiao Rong ***************Li Li Li ***An *****Xue Ju ** karma vRndoM kA chedana kara ekA bhavatArI huA, usI prakAra sabako karanA cAhiye kintu sundara mitra mUrti ke cakkara meM par3akara kucha aura hI matalaba nikAlate haiM, dekhiye - ___"ahA! ahA!! narabhava meM pradezI rAjA kI dRr3ha zraddhA aura aTUTa kssmaa| bAda pradezI rAjA kA jIva devaloka meM sUryAbhadevapane utpanna hotA hai aura utpanna hote hI kaisI bhAvanA? mujhe pahale kyA karanA cAhie? pIche kyA karanA caahiye|" Adi ... sundarajI sUryAbha deva kI isa bhAvanA ke udbhava hone ke kAraNa dharma batAkara usase mUrti pUjA meM dharma batalAnA cAhate haiM, kintu sundara mitrajI ko yaha mAlUma nahIM hai ki - tatkAla ke utpanna hue sUryAbha ne apanI sthiti ke yogya kArya karane kA mArga DhUMDhane ko yaha vicAra kiyA hai, vAstava meM nUtana paristhiti utpanna hone para sabhI loga yahI socate haiM ki hameM yahA~ kyA karanA cAhiye? pahale va pIche hameM kyA hitakArI, sukhakArI hogA? isI taraha sUryAbha ne bhI janma lete - sajJAna hote, yaha vicAra kiyA ki mujhe yahA~ pahale kyA karanA cAhiye, aura pIche kyA? pahale va pIche kyA hitakara sukhakara hogA? isa prakAra kI paristhiti meM mArga nikAlane ke vicAroM ko bhI sundara mitra dharma kA pariNAma batA kara, devatAoM ke kahane se paramparAnusAra kI huI pUjA ko dharma manavAne kA prayatna karate haiM yahI to mahadAzcarya hai? kyA sundarajI? Apa yaha batalAne kA kaSTa svIkAreMge ki pradezI rAjA ne apane dhArmika jIvana meM kabhI mUrti pUjA kI thI yA kabhI mUrti ke darzana bhI kiye the? Apa kyA Apake anekoM vidvAn AcArya bhI nhii| batA sakate, kyoMki jaba mUla meM hI nahIM to lAveM kahA~ se ? jaba sUryAbha

Page #104
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ******** ke pUrva bhava pradezI rAjA ke janma meM kI huI dharma karaNI ( ki jisake prabhAva se mahAn pApoM kA nAza kara sUryAbhadeva pane utpanna huA hai) meM mUrti pUjA kA nAma hI nahIM hai, taba usakA vicAra vo sUryAbha pane utpanna hone para kyoM karane lagA ? yadi eka isI viSaya para ThaMDe hRdaya se vicAra kiyA jAya to sahaja hI meM yaha mAlUma ho sakegA ki sUryAbha ke ina vicAroM se dhArmikatA kA koI sambandha nahIM, para nUtana paristhiti meM apane yogya Avazyaka kArya kSetra DhUMDhane kI bhAvanA hai| pUrva bhava kI dharma karaNI meM mUrti pUjA ko nAma mAtra bhI sthAna nahIM hone se usako usake saMskAra bhI nahIM hai| ataeva sUryAbha ke isa kRtya ko Apa hI ke zrI hukumamunijI ke mantavyAnusAra laukika kRtya mAnakara mithyA haTha ko chor3a denA cAhiye / ubhaya mAnya AgamoM meM mUrtti pUjA kI kahIM bhI prabhu AjJA nahIM hai, na kisI prAmANika zrAvaka yA sAdhu ke jIvana itihAsa meM aisA ullekha hai, phira khAlI kathAoM kI aura vaha bhI mithyA oTa lene meM lAbha hI kyA hai? (3) mUrti-pUjA aura jinAjJA ukta prakAra se sUryAbha sambandhI sabhI yukti va tarkoM para vicAra karane ke pazcAt hama yaha bhI spaSTa kara denA cAhate haiM ki yadi thor3I dera ke lie hamAre sundara mitra ke kathanAnusAra devaloka sthita pratimAoM ko tIrthaMkara pratimAyeM bhI mAnaleM taba bhI kisI prakAra kI bAdhA nahIM hai, kyoMki yaha to akhila jaina samAja kI mAnyatA hai ki anya kalAoM kI taraha citrakalA bhI anAdi hai aura citrakAra apanI yA anya kI icchita vastu kA citra banA sakatA hai, isI taraha tIrthaMkara prabhu kI bhI mUrti banAlI jA sakatI 56 ****

Page #105
60 dAr3hA-pUjana *Ke Lai Shui Ben Zhong ****Ben Zi Ben **Li Li ***Ben Ben Ben Ben Lai Hu Hu Hu Hu Hu Ben Ben Ben Zu Zu Zu Zu Zu Zu Zhong hai, tIrthaMkara prabhu ke sevaka-bhakta-ananyarAgI to deva aura indra taka hote haiM isalie unakI mUrti to ve sundara se sundara aura U~ce se U~ce . padArtha kI banA sakate haiM, jaba citra kalA anAdi hai aura tIrthaMkara ke rAgI devendra jaise bhI hote haiM taba yadi rAgI vyakti apane priya zraddheya | aura pUjya kI rAgabhAva meM Akara mUrti banavAle to isameM kaunasI bar3I bAta hai? para yaha yAda rahe ki isa prakAra kI banavAI huI mUrti aura usakI pUjA dharma meM zumAra nahIM ho sakatI, na kathAoM ke pramANa bhii| vivAdagrasta viSaya meM upAdeya hote haiN| aise sthAna para to Apta AjJA rUpa vidhi vidhAna hI kArya sAdhaka hote haiM, yadi kisI mUrti pUjaka bandhu meM himmata ho to ubhaya mAnya mUla AgamoM ke vaise pramANa prastuta kareM, anyathA mUrti pUjA meM dharma hai tathA yaha jainAgama sammata hai aisA kahanA kevala unmatta pralApa ke samAna hI tthhregaa| dAr3hA-pUjana zrI jJAnasundarajI ne tIsare prakaraNa pR0 51 meM tIrthaMkara kI dAr3hoM kA ullekha kara unakI pUjana meM AtmakalyANa batAyA, aura isa taraha mUrti pUjA meM dharma manavAne kA prayatna kiyA hai| kintu yaha prayAsa bhole bandhuoM ko bhrama meM DAlane ke samAna hI hai| kyoMki asthi-pUjA jaina samAja ko mAnya hI nahIM hai| ___ aura jo indrAdi deva tIrthaMkara kI dAr3hA lete haiM tathA vaMdanAdi karate haiM, ve AtmakalyANArtha nahIM, na unake isa kRtya ko zAstrakAra ne AtmakalyANakArI mAnA hai| zAstrakAra ne to sUtra meM devatAoM kI bhAvanA kA nirdeza mAtra kiyA hai, jaise ki

Page #106
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA ********************************************** "kei jiNabhattIe, kei jIameaMtikaTTa, kei dhammAtikaTTa gennhti|" (jambUdvIpa prajJapti bAbU patra 145) isameM spaSTa batAyA hai ki kitane hI deva jina bhakti se, kitane hI paramparAgata AcAra se aura kitane hI dharma jAnakara grahaNa karate haiM, yaha bAta Apane bhI hamAre sAmane pR0 52 meM rakkhI hai, kintu isake Azaya kA eka aMza pakar3akara Apane anartha kara DAlA, Apane jItAcAra, bhakti bhAva, aura dharmabhAva, ina tInoM kA Azaya bhinna 2 nahIM batAyA, yahI ApakI khUbI hai| jabaki samuce devoM meM eka hissA bhakti-rAga vAlA, dUsarA jItAcAra mAnane vAlA, aura tIsarA dharma mAnane vAlA hai taba do hisse kI upekSA kara eka hI ko pakar3akara prapaJca calAnA kahA~ kI buddhimAnI hai? sundara mitra! jaba devoM ke bhI dAr3hA lene meM bhinna bhinna vicAra haiM taba Apa usameM ekAnta dharma hI kaise batalAte haiM ? vAstava meM dAr3hA pUjA se dharma kA koI sambandha nahIM hai, dharma nAyaka-tIrthaMkara deva kI dAr3hA hone mAtra se ve jar3a dAr3hAe~ pUjanIya vandanIya nahIM ho sakatIM, isalie jina devoM ne una dAr3hAoM ko dharma samajhakara grahaNa kiyA ho yA jo dharma mAnakara vandate pUjate hoM, unakI mAnyatA ThIka nahIM pAI jaatii| vAstava meM yaha bhI rAga kA hI aviveka hai| kyoMki yadi haDDiyoM ke grahaNa karane yA vandane pUjane meM AtmakalyANa rahA hotA to prabhu ke anekoM gaNadhara, pUrvadhara, zrutadhara, sAdhu sAdhviyeM aura lAkhoM zrAvaka zrAvikAyeM bhI prabhu kI asthiyeM lekara vandanA, stuti, pUjAAdi karate yA unhIM haDDiyoM ke sthApanA tIrthaMkara (Apake sthApanAcArya kI taraha) banAkara rakhate jabaki kisI bhI sAdhu yA sAdhvI yA zrAvaka zrAvikA ne asthi pUjA meM dharma nahIM mAnA na gaNadharoM ne hI dharma mAnane

Page #107
62 dAr3hA-pUjana kA Adeza kiyA, to ye mUrti bhakta mahAnubhAva haDDI pUjA meM dharma batAkara kyoM bhrama phailAte haiM? Azcarya nahIM ki aise hI pracAra se jaina gRhasthoM meM bhI mare hue kI haDDiyeM tIrtha ke jalAzaya meM DAlane kA rivAja calA ho? jabaki gRhastha apane mAtA-pitA kI haDDiyoM ko samhAla kara acche bhAjana meM rakkhe aura unheM kAlAntara meM gaGgA Adi nadI meM DAla kara apane karttavya kA pAlana honA samajhe, unheM to hama mithyA kriyA karane vAle kaheM aura hama khuda haDDiyoM kI pUjA meM dharma honA mAne yaha kahA~ kA nyAya hai? sundara mitra yadi dIrgha dRSTi se sUtrAzaya para vicAra karate, yA sadguru ke samIpa samajhate to spaSTa mAlUma hotA ki - ye kriyAyeM mukhyataH jItAcAra aura rAgabhAva se hI kI jAtI hai, jaise ki 1. tIrthaMkara prabhu kA nirvANa jAnakara indrAdi devatA manuSya loka meM Ate haiM aura tIrthaMkara ke zava ko dekhakara "vimaNe NirANaMde aMsupuNNa-NayaNe" arthAt zoka yukta, Ananda rahita aura azru pUrNa netra vAle hote haiN| yaha spaSTa ArtadhyAna-jo ki iSTa viyoga se hotA hai aura rAgabhAva kA dyotaka hai| sArAMza yaha ki indrAdi devoM kA yaha zoka karanA rAgabhAva meM-bhakti ke atireka meM saMmilita hai| 2. isake bAda indra ne prabhu ke zava ko snAna karAyA, zarIra ko candana se arcita kiyaa| isase bhI dharma kA koI sambandha nhiiN| hA~ rAga aura pUjya puruSa ke zava kA bahumAna (laukika vyavahAra se utkRSTatA pUrvaka karane) kA hI uddezya hai| 3. isake bAda svayaM saudharmendra prabhu ko vastra aura alaMkAra pahinAtA hai| aura bhavanapatyAdi anya deva gaNadharAdi sAdhuoM ko vastra aura AbhUSaNa pahinAte haiM, batalAiye yaha kaunasI dharma karaNI hai? jo

Page #108
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ************************* prabhu dIkSita hone ke dina se nirvANa paryanta vastra nahIM pahinate hoM, unheM nirvANa pazcAt vastra pahinAve aura vizeSa meM AbhUSaNa bhI, kyA aisI bhakti ucita hai ? ise zuddha bhakti kaheM yA bhakti kA atireka arthAt rAga raMjita bhakti ? 63 ****** basa isI rAgabhAva kA hI pariNAma hai, ArttadhyAna karanA, zava ko snAnAdi karAkara vastrAbhUSaNa pahinAnA aura isI kA phala hai asthi pUjA / vAstava meM indrAdi deva jItAcAra aura prabhu ke prati ananya rAga se hI ye kriyAyeM karate haiM kintu AtmakalyANa rUpa dharma ke nimitta nahIM, isake lie bhI pramANa dekhiye - jaba saudharmendra ko avadhijJAna se yaha mAlUma hotA hai ki tIrthaMkara kA nirvANa ho gayA taba vaha vicAra karatA hai ki - "taM jIameaM tIapaccuppaNNamaNAgayANaM sakkANaM deviMdANaM devarAiNaM titthagarANaM pariNivvANa mahimaM karittae / " ukta sUtra pATha kI vRtti karate hue vRttikAra likhate haiM ki"tat tasmAdhetoH jItaMkalpaH AcAra etadvakSyamANavarttate atItapratyutpannAnAgatAnAM atIta varttamAnA'nAgatAnAM zakrANA mAsanavizeSAdhiSTAtRNAM devAnAMmadhye indrANAM paramaizvarya yuktANAM deveSurAjJAM kAntyAdiguNairadhikaM rAjamAnAnAM tIrthakarANAM parinirvANa mahimAM kartuM / " (jambUdvIpa prajJapti bAbU 0 patra 138) yahAM zakrendra kevala paraMparAgata cale Ate hue jItAcAra ko jAnakara hI nirvANa kriyAdi karane kI taiyArI karatA hai jo bilakula hai / hamArA bhI yahI kahanA hai ki dAr3hA pUjanAdi kriyA laukika

Page #109
64 dAr3hA-pUjana ******************************************Quan Shu (sAMsArika) vyavahAra kI hai| lokottara (AtmakalyANa kI) nhiiN| aura jo devatA dharma samajha kara dAr3heM le jAte hoM to vaise dharma bhI to kaI (grAma dharma, dezadharma, kuladharma Adi) bhedoM meM vibhakta haiM ataeva ise Atma kalyANakArI dharma nahIM smjheN| yadi devoM ne isa kriyA meM AtmakalyANakArI dharma mAnA ho to yaha mithyA hai aura devoM meM sabhI zuddha zraddhAvAle to hote hI nahIM jaise manuSya loka meM dharma ko adharma, adharma ko dharma, laukika ko lokottara aura lokottara ko laukika mAnane vAle hote haiM, vaise devaloka meM deva bhI hote haiN| jaise manuSyoM meM kitane hI bhole bhAI vyAvahArika kriyAoM meM bhI dharma mAnane laga jAte haiM, vaise devaloka meM ke deva bhI tIrthaMkaroM kI dAr3hAyeM pUjane meM dharma mAnate hoM to koI Azcarya nahIM, kyoMki vRttikAra to yahA~ taka likhate haiM ki devatA cakravartI kI haDDiyeM bhI le jAte haiM dekhiye - __ "AstAM trijadArAdhyAnAM tIrthakRtAM yoga-bhRccakravarti nAmapi devAH sakthi grahaNaM kurvNtiiti|" ___(jambUdvIpa pra0 bAbu0 patra 145) kahiye yaha bhI koI dharma hai? kahA~ taka batAU~, TIkAkAra ne to yahA~ taka batA diyA ki citA kI rAkha taka ko vidyAdharAdi manuSya le jAte haiM, batAiye yaha bhI koI dharma hai yA dharmAndhatA? kyA ise bhakti kA atireka nahIM kaha sakate? avazya yaha andha bhakti hI hai| yadi devoM kI sabhI karaNI Apake lie upAdeya hai to Apako cAhie ki cakravartI kI bhI mUrti banAkara pUjeM tathA apane guru kI haDDI rAkha Adi lAkara usI taraha pUjate rheN| jisa prakAra sUtroM meM aneka sthAnoM para yaha varNana AyA hai ki dIkSita hone vAloM ke mAtA pitAdi dIkSA samaya meM dIkSitoM ke

Page #110
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA ***************************Shui *************** bAla (keza) acche vastra meM lekara unheM yatna se rakhate the| tathA unheM Adara ke sAtha rakhakara samaya-samaya para dekhate aura una putrAdi ko yAda karate the yaha unake moha kI prabalatA thii| usI prakAra yahAM bhI bhakti kA atireka hai ve keza rakhate the, ye dAr3hAyeM yA asthiyeM rakhate haiN| ve putra ke rAga se aisA karate the, ye prabhu kI bhakti se aisA karate haiN| yadyapi antara donoM meM bar3A bhArI hai, tathApi upAdeya to eka bhI nahIM hai| . sundara mitra! jinendra ke prati saccI bhakti jise ho vaha to una dharmAvatAroM kI AjJA kA pAlana karanA hI apanA mukhya kartavya smjhegaa| aisI bhakti hI use kalyANakArI hogii| jainatva isI meM hai dAr3hA pUjana meM nhiiN| jo dharma guNa pUjA ko agrasthAna detA ho, jisameM vyakti pUjA kI apekSA ucca vyaktitva hI upAdeya mAnA ho, kyA vaha dharma kabhI vyakti kI haDDI aura rAkha kI pUjA ko mahattva degA? kadApi nhiiN| __bandhuvara! yadi haDDI pUjA jainoM ko upAdeya hotI to Aja sArI jaina samAja asthi pUjaka ho jAtI, kyoMki jainI ke lie jaise deva pUjya haiM vaise guru bhI pUjya haiN| isa taraha guru kI haDDiyeM bhI pUjA pA liyA krtii| kintu guNa pUjakoM ke lie vaha prathA upAdeya nahIM hone se hI samAja meM nahIM clii| anta meM Apase yahI kahanA hai ki mUrti ke cakkara meM par3a kara jar3a pUjA ko protsAhana mata do aura jJeya viSaya ko upAdeya mata bnaao| anyathA ApakA yaha mata moha bhava bhramaNa kA kAraNa bana jaaygaa| guNa pUjakoM ko jar3a pUjaka banAne kA prayatna karanA yaha sarAsara mithyAtva hai|

Page #111
66 bharatezvara ke mUrtti nirmANa kI asatyatA ************** *************** (10) bharatezvara ke mUrti nirmANa kI asatyatA 67 meM likhA hai ki sundara mitra ne pR0 " zrI bharata cakravartI ne aSTApada parvata para caubIsa tIrthaMkaroM ke caubIsa maMdira banAkara tIrthaMkaroM ke zarIra varNa cihna yukta mUrtiyA~ una maMdiroM meM sthApanA kI, sagara cakravartI ke putroM ne unakI rakSA kI, samrATa rAvaNa maMdodarI ne vahAM jAkara bhakti kI, gaNadhara gautama svAmI ne usa mahAn tIrtha kI yAtrA kI, aisA ullekha jaina zAstroM Aja bhI vidyamAna hai|' "" - sundara mitra kA ukta kathana bhI kevala aupanyAsika DhaGga ke kahAnI granthoM ke AdhAra para hI hai| kyoMki cakravartI mahArAjA bharatezvara kA varNana jambUdvIpa prajJapti meM upalabdha hai, jisameM unake snAna, maMjana, vastrAdi paridhAna, digvijaya tathA zIza mahala meM kevalajJAna prApta karane Adi kA to vistRta kathana hai, kintu mandira ke lie eka zabda bhI nahIM hai| aisI hAlata meM kathA granthoM kA yaha mUrti pUjA kA pramANa paurANika gapor3A hI pAyA jAtA hai| aise hI sagara, rAvaNa aura gautama svAmI ke kathana kA hAla hai aise varNanoM ko kevala andha zraddhAlu bhakta hI aitihAsika kaha sakate haiN| vicArazIla sajjana to aisI bAtoM se inake pakSa ko kabhI upAdeya nahIM kaha sktaa| isase adhika aura kyA kaheM ? hAM isa jagaha mUrti pUjaka zrI lAbhavijayajI kA eka prazna sundara mitra ke sAmane rakha dete haiM -

Page #112
************ haiM? . deM? jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ********************************** "27-bharatacakrI ne aSTApada pai biMba bharAye, kauna siddhAMta meM . sthAnakavAsI hamase prazna karate haiM so batAiye kyA uttara ( stavanAvalI pR0 128 kA prazna 27 vAM) dekheM sundara mitra zrI lAbhavijayajI ke prazna kA kyA uttara dete haiM ? 67 (19) zreNika aura mUrtti - pUjA zrI jJAnasuMdarajI ne pR0 127 meM likhA hai ki - " paTTAvalI meM spaSTa likhA hai ki kaliMga se rAjA naMda jaina mUrti ko magadha meM le gayA, vaha mUrti magadhadeza mahArAjA zreNika ne sthApita kI thI.... mahArAjA zreNika pratidina 108 suvarNa yava (akSata) banavAkara tIrthaMkaroM kI mUrti ke sAmane svAstika karate the..... mahArAjA zreNika ne isa apUrva bhakti se hI tIrthaMkara nAma karmopArjana kiyA..... yaha kArya Atma-kalyANa evaM dharma kArya sAdhana kA eka khAsa aGga thA, isaliye bhagavAn mahAvIra ne use na to manA kiyA na kisI anyatra sthAna para isa kArya sAdhana kA virodha kiyA, ataH yaha samajhanA koI kaThina kArya nahIM ki bhagavAn mahAvIra bhI isa kalyANakArI kArya meM sahamata the| sundara mitra jisa paTTAvalI kA udAharaNa dekara zreNika ko mUrti pUjaka ThaharAte haiM, vaha zAyada mUrti pUjakoM meM hI Adara pAtra aura prAcIna mAnI jAtI hogI ? kintu maiM inase pUchatA hU~ ki kyA ApakI yaha paTTAvalI sUtroM se bhI prAcIna aura adhika pramANika hai ? nahIM, kadApi nhiiN| sUtroM ke sAmane isakA mUlya phUTI kaur3I kA bhI nahIM / aura sUtroM meM jahA~-jahA~ zreNika, usakI rAniyoM, aura putroM kA varNana

Page #113
68 zreNika aura mUrti pUjA **Gong Jia Lai Xue Xue Hui Y=*****Jiao ******Li Li ************* milatA hai vahA~-vahA~ usake prabhu vaMdane, praznAdi pUchane, amArI paDaha phirAne Adi kA ullekha to spaSTAkSaroM meM milatA hai, usakI rAniyoM ke dIkSA kA varNana, putroM kA tyAgI honA, koNika kI prabhu bhakti, aura yuddha Adi kA varNana to pracuratA meM milatA hai, kintu kisI bhI varNana meM maMdira banavAne yA mUrti pUjA karane kA nAma nizAna bhI nahIM miltaa| aisI sUrata meM sundara pramANa asatya pramANita hone meM zaGkA hI kyA ho sakatI hai? isase sivAya zreNika ko hamezA 108 svarNa jau se mUrti pUjA karane vAlA likhanA bhI mUrti pUjaka granthakAroM kA paurANika satya (jhUTha) se kama nahIM hai| yadi ina logoM kI bAta para thor3AsA vicAra kiyA jAya to yaha hAsya janaka hI siddha hoMgI, kyoMki - eka tarapha to ye loga mahAnizItha meM aisA phala vidhAna karate haiM ki mUrti pUjA karane vAlA bArahaveM svarga meM jAtA hai| idhara zreNika ko nitya 108 svarNa yava se pUjane vAlA batAte haiM, isa hisAba se to zreNika ko svarga meM hI jAnA cAhiye, jabaki mAmUlI phUloM aura cAvaloM se pUjane vAlA bhI bArahaveM svarga meM pahuMca sakatA hai to sone ke yava se pUjane vAlA kama se kama prathama svarga meM to jAnA cAhie? kintu jaba hama inhIM logoM ke granthoM ko dekhate haiM to ye mahAnubhAva samrATa zreNika ko narakagAmI batAte haiN| kahiye mUrti pUjA kA kaisA phala milA? yaha ulaTa phera kaisA? * mUrti pUjaka granthakAra yaha likhate haiM ki - jaba prabhu mahAvIra ne zreNika ko bhaviSya meM narakagAmI hone vAlA kahA, taba vaha kheda prakaTa karatA huA prabhu se naraka nivAraNa kA upAya pUchane lgaa| prabhu ne uttara meM cAra upAya batalAye yathA ___

Page #114
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ************* 66 ****** 1. tU eka bhI navakArasI tapa karale / 2. terI kapilA nAma kI dAsI apane hAthoM se muni ko dAna de| 3. kAla saurika kasAI eka dina ke lie bhI hiMsA banda kara de / 4. pUrNiyA zrAvaka kI eka sAmAyika bhI tU kharIda le / isa prakAra naraka nivAraNa ke cAra upAya prabhu ne batAye (jo ki usase hone asambhava the ) aba yahAM yaha vicAra hotA hai ki yadi mUrti pUjA bhI naraka nivAraNa aura svarga pradAna karane kA kAraNa hotI, isameM Atma kalyANa hotA to kyA prabhu zreNika ko yaha upAya nahIM batAte ? kyA prabhu isa upAya ko bhUla gaye the ? svarga nahIM to punaH mAnava bhava hI sahI, yadi itanA bhI lAbha mUrti pUjA se hotA to prabhu avazya batAte ki jisase zreNika kA kucha to bhalA hotA / vaha to prabhu kA ananya bhakta thA, phira use aisA upAya kyoM nahIM batAyA ? vAstava meM samrATa zreNika sAmAyika yA choTA sA pratyAkhyAna karane ke lie sarvathA ayogya the ve mana para kAbU nahIM kara sakate the, unase vrata niyama ke bandhana meM rahate nahIM banatA thA, isI se unakA nivir3a pApa karma chedita nahIM ho skaa| jaba ve Atma-kalyANa kI karaNI ke ayogya the taba AtmakalyANa kI sAdhana kahI jAne vAlI ApakI mUrti pUjA se unakA uddhAra kyoM nahIM huA? Apa to unheM 108 svarNa jase pUjane vAlA mAnate haiM, phira unakA naraka kyoM na rukA ? isake sivAya sundara mitra kahate haiM ki - "jina svarNa jau ko kukkuTa khA gayA thA aura jinake kAraNa sonI ne metArya muni ko mahAn ********* * jabaki jJAnasundarajI mUrti pUjA meM dAna, zIla, tapa aura bhAvarUpa cAroM taraha kA dharma mAnate haiN| (mU0 pU0 prA0 i0 pR0 264 )

Page #115
70 zreNika aura mUrti pUjA ****************************************** kaSTa diyA thA, ve svarNa jau rAjA zreNika ne isI mUrti pUjA ke lie banAye the| yaha kuyukti bhI sundara mahAtmA ne vicitra lagAI, zAyada svarNa jau aura kisI kAma meM hI nahIM Ate hoMge? Aja bhI aise kaI AbhUSaNa dekhe jAte haiM ki jinameM yugala jau jur3e hue pAye jAte haiN| phira bhI yaha kathA mUrti pUjaka granthakAroM kI hI banAI huI hai| kisI prAmANika sUtra kI to hai hI nahIM aura hamAre sAdhumArgI mahAtmA bhI zAyada isI ko lekara kucha kathA karate hoM, yA caupAI meM gAte hoM, jinakA kI ullekha sundara mitra ne kiyA hai| phira bhI sundara mitra kI yaha to kevala kalpanA hI hai ki ve vahI jau the jo zreNika ke pUjA karane ke lie banAye gaye the| ataeva isameM bhI koI sAra nahIM hai| Age sundarajI kahate haiM ki-"isI (mUrti pUjA) se zreNika ne tIrthaMkara nAma karma kA upArjana kiyaa|" yaha bhI kevala manamAnI kalpanA hai kyoMki mUrti pUjA se tIrthaMkara nAma karma kA bandha honA kisI bhI jagaha nahIM likhA hai| hA~ sUtrollikhita arhan bhakti, zAsana (pravacana) prabhAvanA, amArI paDaha, zuddha zraddhAna Adi kArya zreNika ke mahAn puNyazAlI the ki jisase tIrthaMkara nAma karma kA bandha honA sarvathA sambhava hai| aisI dazA meM aise kAryoM kI upekSA kara jabaradastI mUrti ko ar3A denA satyapriya mahAnubhAvoM kA kArya nahIM hai| svayaM mUrti pUjaka samAja ke AgamoddhAraka AcArya zrI sAgarAnanda sUrijI apane "siddhacakra' pAkSika varSa 7 aGka 4 tA0 21-1138 ke "tIrtha yAtrA saMgha yAtrA' zIrSaka lekha ke pR0 62 prathama kAlama meM likhate haiM ki - "kRSNa mahArAja ane zreNika mahArAja ke jeo eka nokArasI

Page #116
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA ************************ sarakhA paccakkhANa ne karavA paNa bhAgyazAlI thaiza kyA hotA tepaNa AvatI cauvIsI mAM je jinezvara nI padavI thI alaMkRta thaze te sarva prabhAva zAsana nI prabhAvanA noja che / " isameM zAsana prabhAvanA se tIrthaMkara gotra pAnA svIkAra kiyA gayA hai jo ki yajJa yAga rUpa hiMsAtmaka samaya meM jainadharma ke ahiMsA siddhAnta kI amArI pravartana se bhArI prabhAvanA karanA hai| yaha prabhAvanA kisI bhI taraha kama nahIM hai, Aja bhI paryuSaNa parvAdhirAja tathA mahAvIra jayaMtI Adi parvoM para kaI zaharoM meM tathA dezI rAjyoM meM palatiyeM (agate) rakhavAkara amArI pravartana dvArA zAsana prabhAvanA kI jAtI hai| basa zreNika mahArAjA kI sUtrollikhita ahiMsA pravartana rUpa zAsana prabhAvanA hI yadi tIrthaMkara gotra kA adhika kAraNa hai to isameM koI Azcarya kI bAta nahIM hai, kintu mUrti pUjA to zAsana prabhAvanA kA kAraNa nahIM, apitu yaha andha zraddhA evaM pAkhaNDa prabhAvanA kA kAraNa hokara prabhu virodhinI bhakti hone se zAsana kI avalehanA karAne vAlI hai, isalie ApakA mUrti pUjA se tIrthaMkara gotra upArjana karane kA kathana bhI satya se sarvathA dUra hai / sundarajI kahate haiM ki bhagavAn ne isa kArya kA virodha nahIM kiyA, isalie yaha pAyA jAtA hai ki bhagavAn mahAvIra mUrti pUjA se sahamata the" jabaki yaha kathana hI jhUTha hai, taba yaha prazna hI kahA~ raha gayA ki bhagavAn isakA virodha kareM ? yadi koI vyakti niyama viruddha kArya hI nahIM kareM, to use usake vRddhajana kyoM ToMkane lage ? basa isI taraha samajha lo ki jaba zreNika mUrti pUjaka hI nahIM, to phira bhagavAn mUrti pUjA se use rokeM kisa prakAra ? 71

Page #117
72 zreNika aura mUrti pUjA ************Ben Zi Li Li Li Li Li Li Li Li Li Li ***Li ***Zu Zu Zu Zhong __isake alAvA bhagavAn ko mUrti pUjA se sahamata batAnA yA bhI pakSa vyAmoha hI hai, kyoMki bhagavAn ke aise koI bhI zabda nahIM, jo mUrti pUjA kA samarthana karate hoN| ulTA prabhu ne to dharma ke lie sthAvara prANiyoM taka kI hiMsA ko Atma ke lie ahitakArI kahA hai| aura mUrti pUjA meM trasa, sthAvara kI hiMsA pratyakSa siddha hai isalie yaha kArya prabhu AjJA se viruddha to avazya hai| sundara mitra ne binA kisI pramANa ke prabhu ko mUrti pUjA se sahamata batA diyA, yaha eka Azcaryajanaka bAta hai, itanA hI nahIM, sundara bhAI ne to yahAM taka likha DAlA hai ki - "mahAvIra mUrti pUjA ke virodhI nahIM para kaTTara samarthaka the|" (jaina dhvaja tA0 17-8-37 varSa 4 aM0 20 pR0 5). ___ bAta yaha huI ki-zrI rAmakRSNa mAthura ema. e. ne "bhArata varSa kA itihAsa" nAmaka eka pustaka likhI, jo Ananda pustakamAlA kAnapura se prakAzita huI hai| yaha pustaka sarakArI skUloM meM bhI par3hAI jAtI hai| isameM jainadharma ke sambandha meM likhate hue lekhaka ne likhA hai ki - "mahAvIra mUrti pUjA ke virodhI the" basa, isI ke uttara meM zrI jJAnasundarajI mahArAja ne "jainadharma ke viSaya meM janatA kA bhrama' zIrSaka lekha meM binA kisI AdhAra ke ukta zabda likha DAle haiM, jo ki unmatta pralApa se kama nahIM hai| yoM to kala se dayA dAna ke virodhI bhI yadi kaha deM ki bhagavAn mahAvIra dayA dAna ke kaTTara virodhI the, to aise bAla vacanoM kA prabhAva hI kyA ho sakatA hai? basa isI taraha sundara mitra ke ukta zabda jaina mAnyatA ke viruddha hone se nirarthaka bakavAda hai| Azcarya to yaha hai ki eka tarapha inhIM mUrti pUjaka mahAnubhAvoM ke mahA mAnya upAdhyAya zrImad yazovijayajI hamArI

Page #118
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA ****Ben Xue Xue Zhu Jiao Xue Qiu Xue Xue ****Li *********An ********Nian ****Kong ** mAnyatA kA khaNDana karate hue "pratimA zataka" ke 20 veM zloka meM likhate haiM ki - sAvadhaM vyavahAratopi bhagavAn sAkSAt kilaanaadisht| balyAdi pratimArcanAdi guNakRt maunena sNmnyte|| artha - zrI varddhamAna svAmI balidAna ane pratimArcana vigere vyavahAra thI sAvadha che tethI tene sAkSAt Adeza nahIM karatA te guNakArI che, ema mauna dhAraNa karI pravartAva ch| (pR0 37) isa taraha pratimA pUjana bhagavAn mahAvIra kathita nahIM honA svIkAra karate haiM, aura dUsarI tarapha sAhasI sundarajI mahArAja binA hI kisI pramANa ke bhagavAn ko mUrti pUjA ke samarthaka likha rahe haiN| yaha sarAsara mithyAvAda, mata moha meM masta hRdaya kA hai| ataeva adhika udyoga kI AvazyakatA nhiiN| pAThaka svayaM samajha leN| (12) campA nagarI aura arihanta caitya ___ misTara jJAna sundarajI ne apanI pustaka "mUrti pUjA kA prAcIna itihAsa' ke cauthe prakaraNa pR0 69 meM likhA hai ki - "jahA~ jainoM kI bastI ho vahA~ Atma-kalyANa kA sAdhana, jaina mandira mUrtiyoM kA honA svAbhAvika hai| jainAgamoM meM nagaroM kA varNana kiyA vahA~ bhI isa bAta ko acchI taraha se batalAyA hai ki nagaroM ke muhalle-muhalle meM arihaMtoM ke mandira haiM, hama yahA~ para zrI utpAtika sUtra meM campA nagarI ke varNana meM Aye hue arihaMtoM ke maMdiroM kA ullekha kara dete haiN|"

Page #119
74 campAnagarI aura arihanta caitya ********************************** **Jing *** phira pR0 70 meM pATha aura loMkAgacchIya amRtacandra sUri kRta TabbArtha diyA hai, jo akSarazaH uddhRta kiyA jAtA hai| "AyAravaMta ceiyA juvai viviha saNNiviTTha bahulA arihanta ceiya jaNavaesaMNivaTTha bhulaa|" (itipAThAMtara) TabbArtha jiNa nagarIi AkAravaMta-sundAkAra caityaprAsAda deharA chaai| vaizyAnA vividha nAnA prakAra saMnivaTTha pADA chei bahulA kahatAM ghaNAM tINa nagarI chaI, arihantanA caitya prAsAda deharA ghaNA chaI (paatthaantr)|" ukta pATha aura TabbArtha para se yaha nahIM mAlUma hotA ki isameM kitanA aMza pATha kA hai, ora kitanA pAThAntara kaa| isa para se to yahI jAnA jAtA hai ki sArA avataraNa hI pAThAntara kA ho| parantu khoja karane para yaha patA lagA ki isa pATha meM se kevala "arihaMta ceiya jaNavai visaNNiviTTha bahule" itanA aMza pAThAntara kA hai, sabhI nhiiN| isa jagaha yaha jijJAsA bhI paidA hotI hai ki isa prakAra pATha aura pAThAntara ke bheda ko haTAkara donoM ko zAmila kara dene kI karatUta kisane kI? kyA amRtacandrajI ne, yA sundara mitra ne? isakA samAdhAna hamAre pAsa nahIM kyoMki amRtacandrAcArya vAlI prati hamAre sAmane nahIM hai| isalie hama isa viSaya meM donoM meM se kisI eka ko doSI nahIM ThaharA skte| phira bhI itanA to avazya kaheMge ki isameM sundara mitra kI karatUta bhI kama nahIM hai, kyoMki yadi sundarajI ne amRtacandrajI vAlI prati se yaha pATha likhA hai, taba inheM yaha to socanA cAhie thA ki isa pATha meM pAThAntara kA aMza kitanA hai? yadi isa para se pUrI chAnabIna kara kAma kiyA jAtA to yaha ghoTAlA to nahIM hotA? sambhava hai sundara mitra

Page #120
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA 75 ****** ********* ********* **** ne jAna bUjhakara bhole bandhuoM ko bhrama meM DAlane ke lie yaha cAla calI ho ? astu, aba hama yahA~ mUrti pUjakoM kI prasiddha Agama prakAzinI saMsthA Agamodaya samiti dvArA prakAzita prati ke anusAra paM0 bhUrAlAla kAlIdAsa dvArA prakAzita uvavAI sUtra kA mUla pATha yahAM uddhRta karate haiN| "AyAravaMta ceiyajuvaI viviha saNNiviTThabahulA ukkoDiyAgAya gaMThibheya" Adi / - (pRSTha 2) isa prati meM mUla pATha ke sAtha sundara mitra kA diyA huA pAThAntara hai hI nhiiN| sirpha TIkA meM TIkAkAra ne isa sUtra kI vyAkhyA karane ke sAtha pAThAntara honA batAyA hai, jo nimna prakAra hai - pAThAntaraM " "AkAravanti - sundarAkArANi AkAracitrANi vAyAni caityAni-devatAyatanAni yuvatInAM ca - taruNInAM paNyataruNI nAmiti hRdayaM, yAni vividhAni sanniviSTAni - sannivezanAni pATakAstAni bahulAni bahUni yasyAM sA tathA 'arihanta ceIyajaNavaIvisaNNiviTThabahule' ti ( pR03) isa prakAra pAThAntara ko mUla pATha meM nahIM milAkara alaga TIkA meM hI rakhA hai, mUla pATha kI TIkA aura TabbArtha se yaha sAbita nahIM hotA ki yaha varNana "jaina mandiroM" kA hai, kyoMki " AkAra vaMta caitya" kA artha donoM ne sundara AkAra vAle devAyatana hI kiyA hai aura devAyatana to pahale bhI nAga, bhUta, yakSa, vaizramaNAdi aneka prakAra hote the / isake sivAya " AkAravaMta caitya" ina do zabdoM se nATya bhUmi, sabhA bhavana ( TAuna haoNla) Adi kaI artha ho sakate haiM, zAyada isI zaGkA se TIkAkAra mahArAja ne sundara devAyatana artha karake chor3a diyA kintu isake bAda sAtha vAle pATha para dRSTi DAlane para to aura bhI

Page #121
campAnagarI aura arihanta caitya ********************************* Azcarya hotA hai, kyoMki sundarAkAra caityoM ke sAtha yaha "juvaIviviha saNNiviTThabahulA" pATha kaisA? TIkAkAra mahArAja ne isakA artha, kiyA ki - "yuvatInAM ca taruNInAM paNyataruNInAmiti hRdayaM, yAni vividhAni sanniviSTAni sannivezanAni pATakAstAni bahulAni bahu ni yasyA saa|" arthAt-yuvatI vezyAoM ke adhikatA se hai nivAsa sthAna jahA~ para, sundara mandiroM ke sAtha vaizyAoM ke nivAsa sthAna kA kyA sambandha?. mAlUma hotA hai ki ye AkAravaMta caitya, maMdira nahIM, para yA to koI nATyazAlA, gAnazAlA Adi hoM, yA phira sArvajanika ArAma sthAna- bagIce ( gArDana) hoM, yA phira sabhA sthAna Adi hoM, ki jahA~ nATaka dekhane, gAnA sunane, yA Tahalane ko janatA vizeSa rUpa se AtI ho aura isIlie aise sthAnoM ke samIpa (logoM kA adhika AvAgamana, vaha bhI Amoda pramoda ke lie hotA ho) vezyAoM ne apane nivAsa banAye hoM jisase rasika logoM kA dhyAna saralatA se apanI ora khIMcA jA ske| isake sivAya usa jamAne meM caityoM meM gAna, vAdana, nRtya, nATaka, kaI prakAra ke khela tamAze bhI hote the, jisakA varNana isI uvavAI ke pUrNabhadra caitya ke sambandha meM likhA huA hai tathA mUrti pUjaka samAja ke prasiddha vidvAn paM0 becaradAsajI apane " rAyapaseNaiya sutta no sAra" pR0 7 ke caitya varNana meM TippaNa naM0 16 meM likhate haiM ki - 16 caityanuM A varNana jotAM te bhAre gammatanuM sthAna paNa hoya ema lAge che, keTalIka kathAoM mAM caitya ne 'jugArIono akhAr3o' 'yuvAna yuvatIonAM mIlananuM sthAna' 'abhisArikAonuM saMketasthAna' e rIte varNavelu' che, te uparyukta varNana jotAM bandha vese evaM che / yadyapi yaha varNana zahara ke bAhara ke caitya kA hai, tathApi zahara ke bhItara ke caitya meM bhI aise kArya prAthamika koTike yA sudhare hue DhaGga ke 76

Page #122
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA 77 **** hote hoM to koI Azcarya nhiiN| saMbhava hai ki ye AkAravaMta caitya aura pUrNa bhadra caitya milate julate hI hoN| isa prakAra AkAravaMta caitya kI vyAkhyA na to TIkAkAra ne spaSTa kI, na TabbAkAra ne hii| mAlUma hotA hai isa campA varNana se hI mUrti pUjaka mahAnubhAvoM ke hRdaya ko AghAta pahu~cA ho, kyoMki jaba campA jaisI jaina purI kA zAstrakAra varNana kare aura usameM jaina mandiroM kA nAma taka bhI nahIM ho, yaha kitanI vicAraNIya bAta hai ? basa, isI ko lekara zAyada " arihaMta ceiya" ityAdi pATha kI sRSTi hokara pAThAntara ke bahAne pustakoM meM pahu~cAyA gayA ho, jisakA spaSTa yahI Azaya hai ki kisI taraha maMdira mUrti janatA ke gale meM DAla denA / pAThakoM ko hamAre kathana para avizvAsa nahIM ho, isake lie eka aura pramANa bhI yahA~ detA hU~ / mUrti pUjaka samAja ke sAkSara paM0 becaradAsajI dozI ne " rAyapaseNaiya sutta" kA saMzodhana aura anuvAda karake prakAzita kiyA hai, usake prathama sUtra meM " Amala kampA" nagarI kA varNana karate hue koSTaka meM aupapAtika sUtra kA vaha pATha bhI diyA hai jisameM " AkAravaMta caitya" kA pUrA varNana hai, kintu isa pATha meM ApakA pAThAntara vAlA pATha to hai hI nahIM tathA isI 'rAyapaseNaiya sutta' kI TIkA karate hue TIkAkAra malaya giri AcArya ne yAvat zabda se aupapAtika sUtra ke pATha kI TIkA dI hai, usameM bhI kathita arihaMta caitya vAlA pAThAntara nahIM dikhAI detA / ataeva spaSTa mAlUma hotA hai ki isa pAThAntara kA janma - campA varNana meM Arhat maMdiroM kA nAma nahIM hone ke kAraNa hI huA hai|

Page #123
campAnagarI aura arihanta caitya ********* hameM Azcarya to sundara mitra kI sundara buddhi para hotA hai ki ve mUla pATha ke " AkAravaMta caitya" kA hI artha jina mandira karate haiM, dekhiye 78 ******* " uvavAI sUtra meM ceiyA - caitya kA artha jJAna na karake yakSa kA maMdira kiyA hai to vAstava meM jaina maMdira thA / " ( pR0 66) mAlUma nahIM hotA ki sundarajI ne kisa AdhAra se yahA~ jaina maMdira artha kiyA, jabaki Apake TIkAkAra aura TabbAkAra hI isa viSaya meM mauna pakar3a rahe haiM, taba Apa aisA haTha kyoM pakar3a rahe haiM, kyA maMdira mUrti ke moha ke kAraNa hI na? isake sivAya sundara mitra zrI amRtacandrajI ke guNagAna aura sva. pUjya zrI amolakaRSi jI mahArAja sAhaba kI niMdA karate pR0 70 se likhate haiM ki - "lokAgacchAcArya - amRtacandra sUri 'arihaMta ceiyA' pATha mUla meM likhakara use pAThAntara batalAte haiM yaha ApakA bhava bhIrU panA hai ki sUtra meM thA jaisA likha diyA, taba RSi jI ne mUla pATha se usa pATha ko nikAla kara phuTa noTa meM rakha diyA / " jaisA sundara mitra ! Apane pAThAntara ko pATha meM milA dene vAle amRtacandrajI kI to prazaMsA kara dI, kyoMki unakA prayatna Apake mana bhAtA huA thA, kintu Apa yaha batAiye ki Apa hI ke ye Agamodaya samiti ke AgamoddhAraka aura paM0 bhurAlAlajI, paM0 becaradAsajI, jinhoMne Apake priya isa pAThAntara ko mUla pATha meM eka tilabhara bhI sthAna kyoM nahIM diyA? aura TIkAkAra ne isakA nirdeza TIkA karate hue hI kyoM kiyA ? isase bhI spaSTa ho jAtA hai ki yaha vastu mUla ke sAtha rahane kI nahIM hai / isalie itane pramANoM se yaha pAThAntara phuTanoTa meM

Page #124
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 76 rakhakara pUjyapAda amolakaRSi jI mahArAja ne koI anucita kArya nahIM kiyaa| hA~, zrI amRtacandajI to mUla meM pAThAntara ko milAne vAle hone se doSI avazya haiN| Apa bhale hI unakI prazaMsA kareM, unhoMne to aisA prayatna kiyA ki jisase pATha aura pAThAntara kA patA hI nahIM cala sake, isalie nyAya dRSTi se yaha dhokhe bAjI hai aura aisI dhokhe bAjI kI prazaMsA karane vAle bhI...... ___maiM Upara batA cukA hU~ ki uvavAI sUtra meM sundarAkAra caitya ke sAtha yuvatI vezyAoM ke nivAsa kA bhI varNana AtA hai, jo mUrti pUjaka vidvAnoM ko bahuta khaTakatA hai| isI kA eka pramANa yahA~ pAThakoM ke sAmane rakhatA huuN| mUrti pUjaka samAja kI "AkSepa nivAriNI samiti" kI ora se prakAzita hone vAlI "jaina satya prakAza" nAmaka mAsika patrikA meM zrI darzanavijaya jI ne sthA0 samAja ke khilApha eka lekha mAlA prakAzita kI thI, jisakA nAma thA "jaina maMdira" isa lekha mAlA meM prathama varSa ke tIsare aGka pR0 76 meM Apane uvavAI sUtra kA pATha nimna prakAra se diyA hai| "AyAravaMta ceiya viviha sanniviTTha bahulA" isa mUla pATha meM se mahAmanA zrI darzanavijaya jI mahArAja "juvaI" zabda ko bilakula har3apa kara gaye, kyoMki yaha yuvatI artha ko batAne vAlA hai aura isakA tAtparya "vezyAoM" ke nivAsoM se hai, aisA TIkAkAra kA mantavya hai| aisA zabda aura vaha bhI mahAtmA darzanavijaya jI ke mata se jina maMdiroM ke sAtha, bhalA ise ve kaise sahana kara sakate haiM? caTa se nikAla kara alaga pheMka diyA ___

Page #125
80 pUyaNavattiya ******************** ****************** aura nirbhaya bana gye| yaha hai ina mahAnubhAvoM ko mUrtimati karatUtoM kA jvalaMta pramANa * ina mandiroM aura mUrtiyoM ke phaMde meM pha~sakara ina logoM ne mUla kI kaisI dazA bigAr3I hai, yaha ukta pramANa ke dekhane para spaSTa ho jAtA hai| aba pAThaka hI soceM ki kyA isa prakAra dhokhebAjI calAne se inakI jar3a pUjA pramANita ho jAyagI? haragija nhiiN| kadApi nhiiN| na isa taraha pATha prakSepa se hI pAkhaNDa cala sakatA hai| (13) pUyaNavattiyaM zrImAn suMdarajI ne cauthe prakaraNa ke pR071 meM likhA hai ki - "bhagavAn mahAvIra kI maujUdagI meM Apake bhakta loga ApakI puSpAdi se pUjAkara Atma-kalyANa karate the aura isa viSaya kA zAstra meM ullekha bhI milatA hai jarA dhyAna lagAkara dekhiye - appegaiyA vaMdaNavattiyaM, appegaiyA puuynnvttiyN| (uvavAI sUtra) isa prakAra uvavAI sUtra kA nAma lekara zrI jJAnasundarajI bhagavAn mahAvIra-jo ki sacitta vastu ko chUte bhI nahIM the, kA puSpoM se pUjA karane kA kahate haiM aura pramANa meM uvavAI sUtra kA ukta pATha bar3e sAhasa * kevala darzana vijayajI meM hI nahIM balki AcArya zrI vijayalabdhi sUrijI ne bhI "jaina satya prakAza' varSa 1 aMka 7 pR0 208 meM "saMtabAlanI vicAraNA" lekha meM isa pATha meM se "juvaI" zabda nikAla kara apanI sAhukArI (taskaravRtti) kA paricaya diyA hai| yaha hai ina logoM kI saiddhAMtika satyatA, matamoha meM par3akara saiddhAMtika coriyAM kara DAlanA to ina logoM ke bAyeM hAtha kA khela ho gayA hai|

Page #126
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA se peza karate haiM / kintu yaha prayAsa bhI binA soce samajhe kiyA gayA hai, yadyapi 'vaMdaNavattiyaM' kA artha vaMdanA karanA aura 'pUyaNavattiyaM' kA artha pUjA karanA hotA hai / tathApi pUjA karanA isa zabda mAtra se yaha tAtparya nahIM nikalA ki "phUloM se hI pUjA kI jAtI ho' isake lie sundara mitra ko jaina sAdhuoM kA karttavya dhyAna meM rakhate hue "prazna vyAkaraNa" prathama saMvaradvAra meM dayA ke 60 nAma meM ke "pUjA" vizeSaNa ko dhyAna se samajhanA caahie| yadi sarva prathama suMdara jI yahI socate ki jaina tIrthaMkara sacitta ho yA acitta kintu bAhya vastuoM kI pUjA grahaNa nahIM krte| (hA~ unake upayoga meM Ane vAlI vastueM jaise AhAra, pAnI Adi to grahaNa karate haiM / kintu kevala pUjA nimitta hI car3hAI jAne vAlI vastu grahaNa nahIM karate ) taba sacitta vastu to grahaNa kareM hI kaise ? dUsarA "prazna vyAkaraNa" meM dayA ko pUjA ke nAma se pukArA hai aura phUloM se pUjane meM phUloM ke jIvoM kI hiMsA hotI hai arthAt dayA nahIM rhtii| jaba dayA hI nahIM rahatI to phira jaina sUtrAnusAra vaha pUjA hI kaise kahI jA sake? spaSTa huA ki phUloM se pUjA karane kA kathana jaina dRSTi se bAhara hai / uvavAI sUtra ke ukta zabda kA Azaya bhAva-pUjA-mAnasika bhakti se haiM / prazna vyAkaraNa meM "pUjA" zabda kI TIkA karate hue mUrti-pUjaka abhayadeva sUrijI likhate haiM ki - " pUyA - pUjA ( pavitrA) athavA bhAvato devatAyA arcanam / " 81 **** jaba inhIM ke TIkAkAra mahodaya pUjA kA artha 'bhAva se devatA kA arcana' karanA batalAte haiM, taba sundara mitra pUjA zabda mAtra se phUloM ko kyoM tur3avAte haiM? isa prakAra to isI zabda se Apa jala, candana, kezara, dhUpa, dIpa, akSata aura dravya Adi vartamAna kI samasta pUjA

Page #127
pUyaNavattiyaM Li An Qiu Zi Zhong Li *****Zhong Kong Xue Hui Xue Zhu Zi *********Cha ************Kong Zhong sAmagrI le sakate haiM? kintu aisA karanA anartha paramparA khar3I karanA hai| vAstava meM yahI ThIka hai ki na to svayaM vItarAga prabhu mahAvIra puSpAdi se kI huI pUjA ko svIkAra karate the, na svayaM ke upayoga ke lie sacitta vastu chUte the| itanA hI nahIM apane zramaNa vaMzajoM ko bhI prabhu ne sacitta vastu chUne kI manAI kara dI, jo Aja paryanta calI AtI hai| jaba svayaM vIra prabhu sacitta vastu kA sparza hI nahIM karate, taba unakI bhakti karane vAle prabhu ko mAnyatA aura AjJA ke viruddha sacitta phUloM se una kI pUjA kara hI kaise sakate haiM? pAThaka svayaM soca leN| sundara mitra ne 'appegaiyA' Adi pATha dekara 'loMkAgaccha' ke nAma dhAraka mUrti-pUjaka yatiyoM kA kiyA huA phUloM se pUjane kA artha peza kiyA hai, kintu yaha artha kevala manaH kalpita hai| yatiyoM ne aisA artha karake jaina mAnyatA aura Agama kI avahelanA kI hai| cAlU viSaya meM sundara mitra ne pRSTha 72 meM likhA hai ki - "zrImAn RSijI ko pUchA jAya ki "vaMdaNavattiyaM" kA artha to Apane vandanA, stuti kara diyA, jisako Apa bhAva pUjA mAnate ho| phira "pUyaNavattiyA' kA kyA artha hotA hai? yadi Apa bhAva pUjA hI kahoge to Apake anuvAda meM punarukti doSa AvegA" aadi| vAstava meM sundarajI meM ajJatA pUrI taraha se chAI huI hai| abhI to sundara mitra dravya bhAva kA bheda hI nahIM samajha sake haiN| kyoMki dravya pUjA use hI kahate haiM jo bAhya rUpa se ho jaise - zarIra se jhukakara namana karanA, kacana se stuti karanA, ye dravya pUjA hai aura mana se prabhu ke caraNoM meM apane ko arpita kara denA, bahumAna karanA, prabhu kI ananta jJAnAdi zakti para vizvAsa rakhanA aura AjJAoM ko hRdaya meM sthApana karanA hai mAnasika bhakti-bhAva-pUjA kintu bhAva zabda jo ki mAnasa

Page #128
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA 83 ****************** ***** kA dUsarA nAma hai, nahIM samajhane vAle suMdarajI zarIra aura vANI ko hI mAnasa-bhAva kA rUpa dete haiM / aura apanI ajJatA dUsaroM ke zira lAdate haiM ? Azcarya hai ki vidvAn (?) sundarajI kisa bala para AkSepa karane ko taiyAra hue haiN| mahAtman! bhAvayukta bhakti namaskAra rUpI dravya bhakti se pRthak hai / dekhiye isI uvavAI sUtra kA koNika vaMdana adhikAra jisameM svayaM sUtrakAra ne bhakti ke tInoM bheda pRthak 2 isa prakAra batAye haiM - "tivihAe pajjuvAsaNAe pajjuvAsai taMjahA kAiyAe vAiyAe mANasiyAe, kAiyAe tAva saMkui aggahatthapAda sussUsamANe NamaMsamANe abhimuhe viNaNaM paMjaliuDe pajjuvAsai, vAiyAe jaM jaM bhagavaM vAgarei evameaM bhaMte! tahameyaM bhaMte! avitahameyaM bhaMte! asaMdihameaM bhaMte! icchiamea bhaMte! paDicchiameaM bhaMte! icchiyapaDicchiyameaM bhaMte! se jaheyaM tubbhe vadahaM apaDikUlamANe pajjuvAsati, mANasiyAe mahayA saMvegaM jaNaittA tivvadhammANurAgaratto pajjuvAsai / " sUtra 32 kahiye sundarajI! samrATa koNika jo ki zrI vIra prabhu kA ananya bhakta thA, usane bhI prabhu kI phUloM se bhakti nahIM kI, kevala mana, vANI aura zarIra se hI bhakti kI / bhakti ke tInoM prakAra sUtrakAra ne spaSTa batalA diye, inameM ApakI priya aisI puSpoM se pUjA to hai hI nahIM / kahiye phira ApakA phUlAdi se pUjane kA siddhAMta kahA~ gAyaba ho gayA ? jo kaNika rAjA bhagavAn para apanI ananya bhakti ke kAraNa sadaiva prabhu ke samAcAra ma~gavAyA karatA thA, isI kAma ke lie usane kucha sevaka bhI rakha chor3e the / bhagavAn ke samAcAra sunakara vaha atyanta

Page #129
pUyaNavattiyaM prasanna hotA thA / isa prasannatA meM vaha samAcAra dene vAle ko bhArI pAritoSika detA thA / aise paramopAsaka rAjendra bhI prabhu ko do kor3I ke (binA kImata ke - khuda ke bagIce ke ) phUla bhI nahIM car3hA sakA / kyA isa bhakti ko vaha nahIM jAnatA thA ? yA Apa jaise gautamAvatAra rAjA kI salAha dene vAle vahA~ nahIM the? phira kyA kAraNa hai ki koNika ne phUloM se prabhu pUjA nahIM kI? sundara mitra ! itanA hI nahIM samrATa koNika jaba prabhu vaMdana ko apane sthAna se dhUmadhAma pUrvaka nikalA thA, taba usake pAsa phUla jarUra the, kintu samavasaraNa ke nikaTa Ate hI usane phUloM ko dUra kara diyA, dekhiye vahA~ kA sUtra pATha " sacittANaM davvANaM viusaraNayAe" 84 TIkA * "puSpAdisacetanadravya tyAgena" kahiye mitra ! aba to spaSTa huA ? kyA aba bhI ApakA va lokAgacchiya mUrttipUjaka yatijI kA anartha Tika sakatA hai? sundarajI! Apa yaha nahIM samajha leM ki kevala koNika ne hI phUloM se pUjA nahIM kI, kintu jainAgamoM meM aneka rAjA, mahArAjA seTha senApati Adi ke prabhu vaMdana aura bhakti karane ke aneka varNana Aye haiN| una saba meM yahI batalAyA hai ki-unhoMne prabhu kA Agamana sunakara prasannatA prakaTa kI, zIghratA se snAna maMjanAdi kiye, vastrAbhUSaNa se susajjita hue, phUla mAlAe~ pahinI aura prabhu vaMdana ko gaye / vandana, namaskAra kiyA, vANI zravaNa kI yathA zakti vrata pratyAkhyAna kiye| jina vacanoM meM aTala zraddhA kii| dharma ke raGga meM acchI taraha raMga gye| kintu kisI eka ne bhI prabhu kI phUloM se yA acitta cAvaloM se hI pUjA kI ho aisA anekoM kathAnakoM meM se kisI eka meM bhI nahIM miltaa|

Page #130
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA ******************************************** isake sivAya mere vicAra se sundarajI ke samAna sArI mUrtipUjaka samAja ke vidvAnoM kI mAnyatA bhI nahIM hogii| kyoMki aise hI prakaraNa para vicAra karate hue zrI vijayAnanda sUri "samyaktva zalyoddhAra" pR0 103 meM likhate haiM ki - "bhagavAn bhAva tIrthaMkara the, isa vAste tinakI vaMdanA stuti vagairaha hI hotI hai aura tinake samIpa satarAM prakArI pUjA meM se vAjiMtra pUjA, gIta pUjA tathA nRtya pUjA vagairaha bhI hotI hai cAmara hote haiM ityAdi jitane prakAra kI bhakti bhAva tIrthaMkara kI karanI ucita hai utanI hI hotI hai, aura jina pratimA sthApanA tIrthaMkara hai, isa vAste tinakI satarAM prakAra Adi pUjA hotI hai|" ukta maMtavya se yaha spaSTa ho jAtA hai ki bhAva tIrthaMkaroM kI pUjA phUloM se nahIM ho sktii| jaba mUrti pUjaka vidvAn bhI isa bAta meM abhI eka mata nahIM hai, aura yaha bAta jaina siddhAnta kI virodhinI bhI hai| aisI hAlata meM mUrti ke moha meM masta bane hue sundara mitra binA soce samajhe apanA hI haTha phailAte raheM to isa ke lie dUsarA upAya hI kyA hai? sundara mitra! jarA kAnoM ke parde kholakara suno| jaina zraddhAna meM vAstavika pUjA vahI mAnI gaI hai ki jisake dvArA AtmA halkI hokara Urdhvagamana kI ora agrasara ho, jisameM lAbha hI lAbha ho, kisI bhI para prANa ko kiJcit bhI duHkhadAyI na ho| aisI hI pUjA jaina zAsana ko mAnya hai| aisI pUjA paddhati ko svIkAra karane vAle hI zuddha zraddhAvAn haiN| isake viparIta jo para prANoM ko lUTakara prabhu pUjA karane kA kahate haiM - mAnate haiM ve vAstava meM jaina siddhAnta kA ghora virodha karane ke sAtha apane ArAdhya pUjya kI AjJAoM ko ThukarAte haiN| vyartha meM para prANoM ko lUTakara apanI AtmA ko bhArI banAte haiM aura aise hiMsAkArI kRtyoM meM

Page #131
pUyaNavattiyaM prabhu-pUjA mAnakara zuddha zraddhA se vaMcita rahate haiM aise loga prabhu bhakta nahIM, para kapUta kI taraha prabhu kA apamAna karane vAle haiN| 86 mAnyavara sundarajI ! prabhu kI saccI pUjA phUloM se pUjane meM nahIM, kintu unakI AjJA pAlana karane meM hai / jarA AMkheM khola kara apanI hI samAja ke vidvAnoM ke nimna vAkya par3hiye - "ihA~ sarva jo bhAva pUjA hai so jinAjJA kA pAlanA hai| " (vijayAnanda sUri racita jaina tattvAdarza pR0 416 ) "pUjA eTale teonI AjJA nuM pAlana / " ( zrI haribhadrasUri, jaina darzana pR0 41) jaba jinAjJA pAlana rUpa hI pUjA mAnI gaI taba aisI pUjA meM phUla, phala, pAnI, agni Adi kI hatyA ko sthAna hI kahA~ rahA? ataeva spaSTa huA ki jo loga sacitta vastuoM kA upayoga kara pUjA karate haiM, karavAte haiM, ve prabhu pUjaka nahIM kintu prabhu ke apamAna karttA haiN| zrImAn sundarajI ne isa bAta ko puSTa karane ke lie samavasaraNa kI puSpa vRSTi kA udAharaNa diyA hai| kintu yadi zrI sundarajI abhiniveza ko chor3akara zAnta citta se vicAra karate to " rAyapaseNaiya " sUtra se isakA acchA spaSTIkaraNa ho sakatA thaa| vahA~ spaSTa batAyA gayA hai ki devatAoM ne apanI vaikriya labdhi dvArA puSpoM ke bAdala banAye aura usI bAdala meM se vaikriya se kiye hue phUloM kI varSA kii| yadi vahA~ ke jalaja sthalaja zabda se hI bhrama huA ho to yaha bhI vyartha hai kyoMki yaha jalaja sthalaja zabda upamA meM liyA gayA hai| jaise ve phUla kaise the to jaise jala sthala meM utpanna hue phUla haiM vaise / jisa prakAra " zakrastava " meM " purisasIhANaM purisavarapuMDarIANaM purisavara gaMdhahatthINaM" ye pATha upamA darzaka hai, usI prakAra ukta ujala sthalaja zabda bhI hai| isI - ***

Page #132
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 87 ******************************************* prakAra "rAyapaseNaiya" ke mUla pATha meM vaikriya samuddhAta kara puSpa varSA karane ke prasaMga se phUloM ko tor3akara pUjane kA kahanA mithyA hI hai| yadi ve phUla jala sthalotpanna hote to vaikriya se vikurvaNA karane kA nahIM kaha kara janmAbhiSeka Adi prasaGgoM meM batAye anusAra "sAharaNa' karane kA hI ullekha hotaa| ___ samavasaraNa ke phUloM kI sacittatA ke viSaya meM to svayaM mUrtipUjaka vidvAn hI abhI eka mata nahIM haiN| kucha loga una puSpoM ko sacitta hI mAnate haiM, kintu bahuta se vidvAn unheM acitta bhI mAnakara sacitta mAnane vAloM se pUchate haiM ki yadi sabhI phUla sacitta mAnoge to hajAroM sAdhu sAdhvI samavasaraNa meM the| unako to samavasaraNa meM paira rakhanA hI muzkila ho jaaygaa| isalie samavasaraNa meM donoM taraha ke phUla mAnane caahie| isa prakAra matAntara hai jisakA varNana "pravacana sAroddhAra" meM kiyA gayA hai tathA "sena prazna' ke ullAsa 3 praznottara 38 meM bhI sacitta aura acitta donoM taraha ke phUla mAne haiN| paM0 becaradAsajI dosI ne "rAyapaseNaiya sutta" kI TippaNa meM isa viSaya ke kucha matAntara dekara sacitta mAnane vAle mata ko satya samajhAne ke lie yajJa kI hiMsA kA udAraNa dekara eka kaTAkSa pheMkA hai| ataeva jaba mUrti pUjaka samAja ke vidvAn hI abhI ekamata se samavasaraNa ke phUloM ko sacitta mAnane ko taiyAra nahIM hai| taba Apa hameM kisa muMha se sacitta phUla batAte haiM? jo ki sUtra Azaya se sarvathA viparIta hai| Apake pUrvAcAryoM ne jo una puSpoM ko acitta ke sAtha sacitta bhI batAyA hai usakA vizeSa kAraNa mUrti pUjA se gaThabandhana hone kA hI ho sakatA hai| isalie donoM taraha kI bAteM karate haiM kintu vAstava meM sUtra dekhate to patA lagatA ki samavasaraNa meM vaikriya se banAkara hI puSpa barasAye gaye the

Page #133
88 pRyaNavattiyaM ******************************************* aura vaikriya ke pudgala acitta hone se hiMsA hotI nahIM tathA ye puSpa varSA bhI kisI vizeSa prasaMga para hI hotI hai, sadaiva nhiiN| isake sivAya ye barasAye hue puSpa prabhu para girate hoM yaha bhI pramANita nahIM hotaa| prabhu para to azoka vRkSa kI gaharI chAyA rahatI thI, jisase Upara se girane vAle puSpa nIce baiThe hue prabhu para nahIM A sakate the| Azcarya to isa bAta kA hotA hai ki jo jaina zramaNa kisI bhI prANI kA kisI bhI karaNa yoga se ahita nahIM cAhate aura apane ko hiMsA ke sarvathA-naukoTi se tyAgI honA batalAte haiM ve hI yadi ina mUka jIvoM ke jAnI duzmana bana hatyA karane kA galA phAr3akara upadeza deM aura usameM dharma batAveM to pAnI ko Aga aura amRta ko viSa kahane meM atizayokti hI kyA hai? apane manaH kalpita pAkhaNDa ko janatA ke gale mar3hane meM ye loga akaraNIya kRtya bhI kara DAlate haiN| pAThakoM kI vizeSa jAnakArI ke lie mUrtipUjaka AcArya vijayAnaMda surikRta "samyaktva zalyoddhAra" kA eka avataraNa yahAM de diyA jAtA hai, Apa mUrtipUjA meM puSpoM ko hotI huI hiMsA ko bhI dayA kA jAmA pahinAte haiM, jarA dhyAna pUrvaka par3hiye - . "puSpa pUjA se to una zrAvakoM ne una puSpoM kI dayA pAlI hai vicAroM ki mAlI phUloM kI caMgare lekara becane ko baiThA hai| itane meM koI zrAvaka A nikale aura vicAre ki puSpoM ko vezyA le jAvegI to apanI zayyA meM bichAkara Upara zayana karegI aura usameM kitanIka kI kadarthanA bhI hogI koI vyasanI le jAvegA to phUla ke gucche gajare banAkara sUMghegA, hAra banAkara gale meM DAlegA yA mardana karegA koI dhanI gRhasthI le jAve to vo bhI unakA yatheccha bhoga karegA aura striyoM ke zira meM gUMthe jAveMge to itra ke vyApArI le jAveMge to phulela vagairaha

Page #134
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA banAne meM usakI bahuta viDaMbanA kareMge ityAdi aneka viDaMbanA kI saMbhAvanA ko dUra karane ke lie aura arihaMta kI bhakti rUpa zuddha bhAvanA ke nimitta vaha puSpa zrAvaka kharIda kara ke jina pratimA ko car3hAve to usase arihaMta deva kI bhakti hotI hai aura phUloM kI bhI dayA palatI hai, hiMsA kyA huI ? (samyaktva zalyodvAra pR0 180 ) isa prakAra bhogiyoM kI oTa lekara ye jogI loga phUloM ke prANoM ke duzmana banate haiN| vijayAnaMda sUri kI tarka bhI ajaba prakAra kI hai / ve bhole bhAiyoM ko yoM samajhAnA cAhate haiM ki hamAre zrAvakoM ne mAlI se phUla kharIda kara unakI dayA kara lI aura bhogI loga tAkate hI raha gaye | vAha mahAtman! acchA jhAMsA diyA? Apake bhagavAn ko phUla car3ha jAne se bhogI logoM ko phUla hI nahIM mileMge ? kyA maiM Apase yaha pUcha sakatA hUM ki Apa mAlI se phUla kharIda karavA kara adhika hiMsA to nahIM karavA rahe haiM? kyoMki isase to mAlI kA rojagAra adhika calegA aura vo adhika phUla paidA karake becegA / vaha Apake bhaktoM ko bhI degA aura bhogiyoM ko bhI degaa| isa taraha Apa to kadAcit dugunI hatyA karavAne vAle mAne jaaoge| becAre phUloM para to Dabala Apatti A gii| mahAnubhAva! vAstava meM Apake hRdaya meM phUloM ke jIvoM ke prati dayA ke bhAva the to ApakA karttavya thA ki Apa bhogiyoM ko samajhA kara unase phUloM kI rakSA karate aura isI se unakI rakSA ho sakatI thI / kintu Apane to rakSA ke bahAne ulTI mAra calA dI, yahA~ to rakSaka so hI bhakSaka vAlI kahAvata ghaTita hotI hai| kyA mahAtman ? jarA yaha bhI to batalA dIjiye ki nimna AjJAyeM 86

Page #135
pUyaNavattiyaM ******************** **************** ** Apane apane "jainatattvAdarza' grantha meM pradAna kI haiM, kyA ye bhI dayA se prerita hokara kI haiM? jaise ki - "patra, bela, phUla pramukha kI racanA karanI xxx zatapatra, sahasra patra, jAi, ketakI, campAdika vizeSa phUloM karI mAlA mukuTa seharA phUla gharAdi kI racanA kre|" . (pR0 405) . "phUla ghara kadaligharAdi mahA pUjA kre|" (pR0 473) "sundara-aGgI, patra-bhaMgI, sarvAMgAbharaNa, puSpagRha, kadalIgRha, pUtalI pANI ke yaMtrAdi kI racanA kre|" (pR0 474) yahA~ kucha prazna karane kI icchA hotI hai, ataH nimna prazna mUrti pUjaka vidvAnoM kI sevA meM peza kiye jAte haiN| yathA - (1) kyA mAlI se kharIde hue phUloM se dayA hotI hai, vaise vRkSa, latA se tor3akara car3hAne meM bhI dayA hotI hai? (2) Apake mandiroM ke samIpa tathA dUra phUlavArI rahatI hai| jisameM se phUla tor3akara pUjA ke kAma meM liye jAte haiM, to kyA isameM bhI dayA hI hotI hai? (3) Apake kalpa sUtra meM eka kathA AI hai, usameM likhA hai ki eka nagarI meM bauddha matAnuyAyI rAjA ne jainiyoM ko pUjA ke lie phUla nahIM lene diye| jisase daza pUrvadhara zrI vajrasvAmI AkAza mArga se anya dezoM meM pahu~ce aura vahA~ se lAkhoM phUla tur3avA kara le Aye to kyA yaha bhI dayA kA hI kArya huA? isameM hiMsA to nahIM huI ? ___(4) jisa prakAra phUloM se pUjane meM Apane dayA batalAI, usI prakAra jala, phala, dhUpa, dIpa Adi se pUjane meM bhI dayA hai kyA?kyoMkijala nhAne, dhone aura gudA taka dhone ke kAma meM AtA hai| phala ko bhI loga kATakUTakara khAte haiM, kIr3e bhI sar3A dete haiN| agni para koI khAnA .

Page #136
61 jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA ****************************************** pakAtA hai to koI AmiSa pakAtA hai| isa prakAra sabhI jIvoM kI viDaMbanA hotI hai| isalie jisa prakAra phUloM kI dayA batAI, usI prakAra ina jIvoM kI bhI dayA honI cAhie? (5) patra, bela, kadalI phavvArA Adi se mahA pUjA karane meM bhI dayA hotI hogI kyA? zrI vijayAnaMdajI to aba saMsAra meM nahIM rhe| isalie mere prazna kA uttara unake vaMzaja yA zrI jJAnasundarajI ko hI denA caahie| aba to guruoM kI kRpA se vaidika logoM kI bhI coMca khula jaaygii| pahale jainI loga unake prANI yajJa ko heya dRSTi se dekha kara una para AkSepa karate the| para aba yadi yaha phUloM kA hAla unheM mAlUma huA to ve bhI tapAka se kaha deMge ki jisa prakAra Apa phUloM ko bhogiyoM kI viDaMbanA se bacAkara bhagavad bhakti meM lagAkara dayA karate haiM usI prakAra hama bhI pazuoM ko anya mlecchoM ke peTa meM par3ane se bacAkara yajJa meM homa kara unheM svarga meM bhejanA cAhate haiM jise una para dayA hotI hai| pakSAndhatA kyA nahIM karAtI? abhiniveza meM chake hue loga viSa ko bhI amRta kahate nahIM ddrte| astu, eka tarapha to puSpA se pUjanA puSpoM kI dayA honA kahI gaI, aba dUsarA siddhAnta zrI vijayAnaMda sUrijI kA aura dekhiye - "sacitta vastu arthAt jIvavAlI vastu phUla, phala, bIja, gucchA patra, kaMda, mUlAdika tathA bakarA gAya sUarAdi inako tor3e, chede, bhede, kATe so jIva adata kahiye, kyoMki phUlAdika jIvoM ne apane zarIra ke chedane bhedane kI AjJA nahIM dinI hai jo tuma hamako chedo bhedo isa vAste isakA nAma jIva adatta hai|" (jaina tattvAdarza pR0 327) ___

Page #137
12 camarendra aura mUrti kA zaraNa ******************************************* pAThaka mahodaya! dekha liyA Apane? donoM bAtoM meM kitanA antara hai? donoM siddhAnta eka hI mahAtmA ke haiN| eka meM hiMsA kArI vidhAna to dUsare meM usakA nissedh| kaisA paraspara virodha? vAstava meM pakSa vyAmoha cAhe so karA letA hai| ___ hamAre itane prayAsa se pAThaka samajha gaye hoMge ki jaina siddhAnta sacitta aura sAvadya pUjA kA kadApi pratipAdana nahIM krtaa| zrI sundarajI aura vijayAnaMdajI ne jo bhI hiMsAkArI bAteM likhI hai vo kevala kapola kalpanA hI hai| jabaki prabhu AjJA meM hI dharma mAnA jAtA hai aura zrI sundarajI ne bhI "mejharanAme' meM isa bAta ko svIkAra kI hai| taba prabhu AjJA rUpa pramANa kyoM nahIM peza kiye jAte? kyoM vyartha hI artha kA anartha kiyA jAtA hai? (14) camarendra aura mUrti kA zaraNa zrI jJAnasundarajI ne cauthe prakaraNa ke pR0 73 meM likhA hai ki - "camarendra Urdhva loka meM jAtA hai taba arihaMta arihaMta kI pratimA aura bhavitAtmA anagAra kA zaraNA lekara hI jAtA hai" aadi| isakA uttara yaha hai ki - zrI madbhagavatI sUtra za0 3 meM camarendra ke Urdhva loka meM jAne kA kathana hai vahA~ yaha batAyA gayA hai ki jaba camarendra prathama svarga meM gayA taba nimna zaraNA lekara gayA, yathA - taMseyaM khalu me samaNaM bhagavaM mahAvIraM nIsAe sakkaM deviMda devarAyaM sayameva accAsAittae.......sUtra 27 /

Page #138
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA arthAt - camarendra vicAra karatA hai ki mujhe zramaNa bhagavaMta mahAvIra svAmI kI nezrAya lekara zakrendra kI attyAzAtanA karane jAnA hI zreyaskara hai| isake bAda jaba zakrendra ke bhaya se saudharma devaloka se bhAgakara camarendra punaH lauTA to zrI vIra prabhu jo usa samaya chadyasthAvasthA meM the, unhIM kI zaraNa meM AyA aura usake pIche zakrendra kA vajra bhI aura usake pIche zakrendra apane pheMke hue vajra ko yaha jAnakara punaH khIMcane ko daur3e ki - taM mahAdukkhaM khalu tahArUvANaM arahaMtANaM bhagavaMtANaM 6.3 **** aNagArANaya accAsAyaNAe / sUtra 31 arthAt - mere isa kArya (vajra pheMkane) se tathA rUpa ke arihaMta bhagavaMta aura anagAra kI atyAzAtanA hogI, yaha bar3e duHkha kA viSaya hai| pAThaka dekheMge ki - ina tInoM bAtoM meM mUrti kA koI sambandha hI nahIM hai| na to camarendra ne saudharma devaloka meM jAte samaya mUrti kI zaraNa lI, na AyA taba mUrti ke zaraNa meM aura na zakrendra ne mUrti kI AzAtanA mAnI, camarendra ne jAte samaya chadmastha arihaMta mahAvIra prabhu kI hI zaraNa lI thI, AyA bhI unhIM kI zaraNa meM aura zakrendra ne attyAzAtanA bhI arihaMta bhagavaMta aura aNagAra mahArAja kI hI mAnI / phira mUrti kA aDaGgA kyoM batAyA jAtA hai? yadi inatInoM sthaloM para zAMta citta se vicAra kiyA jAya to yaha bAta sahaja hI samajha meM A sakatI hai ki isameM mUrti kA aDaGgA lagAne vAle kevala haThAgrahI hI haiN| isake sivAya ye loga isake pUrva kA eka pATha yaha peza karate haiM ki - NaNattha arihaMte vA, "arihaMta ceiyANi vA " aNagAre vA bhAviyappaNo /

Page #139
64 camarendra aura mUrti kA zaraNa ***************************************** aura isakA artha karate haiM ki - isake sivAya arihaMta, arihata pratimA, bhavitAtmA anngaar| isa prakAra "arihaMta caitya' zabda lekara usakA artha arhanmUrti karake mUrti kI pUjA karanA Agama sammata batalAte haiM, yaha prayAsa inakA sarvathA viphala hI hai kayoMki yahA~ arhan-caitya kA mUrti artha karanA asaMgata hai| camarendra prabhu mahAvIra kI zaraNa grahaNa karake hI saudharma kalpa gayA thA aura bhayabhIta hone para AyA bhI unhIM prabhu kI zaraNa meM, isake sivAya zakrendra ne bhI arihaMta, bhagavaMta aura anagAra basa ina hI kI atyAzAtanA mAnI hai| isa viSaya meM yahA~ sarala buddhi se yaha samajhanA cAhie ki - . eka to usa samaya isa bhAratavarSa meM koI sAkSAt bhAva arihaMta the hI nhiiN| prabhu mahAvIra bhI chadmasthAvasthA meM dravya tIrthakara the isalie arihaMta jo ki bhAva nikSepa hai unakI anupasthiti meM dravya arihaMta kI zaraNa lI gaI isalie yaha "arihaMta ceiyANi vA" adhika pada. lagAne kI AvazyakatA huii| dUsarA jaba chadmastha tIrthaMkara (arihaMta) kI hI zaraNa lekara gayA aura punaH vApisa unhIM ke zaraNa meM AyA to phira chadmastha arihaMta kI zaraNa bhI to pRthak batalAnA Avazyaka hai na? basa isI uddezya se yaha arihaMta caitya zabda chadmastha arihaMtoM kI zaraNa batalAne ke lie rakhA gayA hai| kintu mUrti kI zaraNa kahanA mithyA hai, yadi mUrti kI zaraNa hI camarendra ko iSTa hotI to vaha usI saudharma devaloka kI zAzvatI mUrti jo ki usake atyanta nikaTa thI, chor3akara aura apanI jAnako jokhima meM DAlakara manuSya loka jaise atyanta dUra sthAna para prabhu mahAvIra ke Azraya meM kyoM jAtA?

Page #140
ha5 jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA ********************************************** isase hamAre mUrtimati mitra kahate haiM ki - mUrti kI zaraNa kyoM jAya jisakI zaraNa lekara gayA ho usI kI zaraNa jAnA caahie| kintu inakA yaha kathana bhI ayogya hai kyoMki jaba koI vyakti vikaTa paristhiti meM phaMsA ho to vaha apanI zAnti aura rakSA ke lie sabase sarala, sahaja aura atyanta nikaTa Azraya ko hI DhUMDhatA hai| yadyapi usakA uddezya apane ghara yA anya kisI ucca Azraya sthAna para pahu~cane kA hotA hai, tathApi jaba vaha jAnatA hai ki vipatti kA pahAr3a sira para maMDarA rahA hai aura kucha kSaNoM meM apane pUrva lakSya ko chor3akara apane atyanta hI nikaTa ke kisI nirApada Azraya ko DhUMr3hatA hai| vicAra karo ki - eka manuSya nadI ke usa pAra jAnA cAhatA hai| vaha nadI ke usa pAra pahu~cane ke lie prasthAna bhI kara cukA hai| usakA dhyeya mAtra hai usa pAra phuNcnaa| kintu yadi vaha nadI pAra karate karate thaka jAtA hai, zvAsa phUla jAtA hai, bhujAyeM aiMTha jAtI haiM taba apanI jAna bacAne ke lie pAsa hI ke kisI Alambana ko DhU~r3hatA hai, usa samaya vaha kinAre kA lakSya chor3akara pAsa hI ke kisI TIle patthara yA per3a A de kA sahArA khoja kara usI kA Azraya legA, jaba usakI thakAna dUra hogI taba vaha Age bddh'egaa| ataeva sarala buddhi se samajhiye ki yadi camarendra ko mUrti kI zaraNa lenI iSTa hotI to ve apanI khataranAka paristhiti meM atyanta nikaTa sthAna vAlI mUrti ko chor3akara itanI dUra kadApi nahIM aataa| ataeva mUrti kI zaraNa kahanA ThIka nahIM hai| are bhAI! mUrti svayaM apanA hI rakSaNa nahIM kara sakatI, jisase becArI ko tAle meM banda rahanA par3atA hai, bhakta loga mUrti kI rakSA ke lie sazastra paharedAra rakhate haiM, itanA hote hue bhI coriyA~ ho hI jAtI

Page #141
66 camarendra aura mUrti kA zaraNa ******************************************* haiN| bhalA aisI mUrti jo apanA hI rakSaNa Apa na kara sake aura dUsaroM ke Azraya meM rahe, vaha kyA kisI ke lie zaraNa bhUta ho sakatIhai? kadApi nhiiN| spaSTa siddha huA ki mUrti kI zaraNa batalAnA ekadama mithyA hai| zakrendra ne jaba yaha socA ki - saudharma svarga meM camarendra arihaMta aura anagAra mahArAja ke nezrAya binA nahIM A sakatA hai taba unheM vicAra huA ki - taM mahAdukkhaM khalu tahArUvANaM, arahaMtANaM, bhagavaMtANaM aNagArANa ya accaasaaynnaae| ____yahA~ zakrendra ne arihaMta, bhagavaMta aura anagAra mahArAja kI atyAzAtanA hI mAnI hai| isameM arhata caitya zabda nahIM hone se sundarajI ne socA ki isase hamAre mUrtimata ko bAdhA pahu~catI hai aura isa pATha se kahIM hamAre mUrti pUjaka kucha zaGkA nahIM uThA leM, isalie sundara mitra ne yaha kahakara jAla phailAyA hai ki - "arihaMta kI AzAtanA meM hI arihaMta mUrti kI AzAtanA kA samAveza hai|" ___ yaha sundara cAla bhI vicitra hai| yadi arihaMta zabda meM mUrti kA samAveza ho jAtA hai to sundara mitra arihanta caitya zabda ke lie kyoM vyartha kA kutarka karate haiM? kintu nahIM, sundarajI jahA~ arihaMta caitya hogA vahAM to arihaMta zabda meM mUrti honA nahIM mAnakara arihaMta caitya zabda se mUrti artha mAneMge aura jahA~ nahIM hogA arihaMta zabda meM hI mUrti mAnakara kevala usI zabda se mUrti kI vandanA, pUjA bhI mAna leNge| yaha pratyakSa pakSa vyAmoha hai, sundarajI ko atyAzAtanA ke sthAna para arihaMta caitya nahIM hone se arihaMta zabda hI se mUrti kI AzAtanA mAnakara apanA kAma calA lenA pdd'aa| kintu sundara bandhu ko yaha bhI mAlUma nahIM hai ki Agama meM teMtIsa prakAra kI AzAtanA batalAI hai, usameM bhI

Page #142
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 67 ****Ben *****************Zi ********Zi Zhong Li *******Zu * arihaMta, siddha, AcArya, upAdhyAya, sAdhu, sAdhvI, zrAvaka, zrAvikA, deva, devI, yAvat sarvaprANa, bhUta, jIva sattva taka kI AzAtanA mAnI hai, ina teMtIsa boloM se ekendriya prANa bhUtAdi kI bhI AzAtanA mAnI, kintu isameM bhI mUrti kI to koI bhI AzAtanA nahIM batalAI, phira sundara mitra kA kathana mithyA hone meM kyA kasara hai? __sundara mitra! saMsArI jIvoM ke zaraNa bhUta jina cAra padoM kA nirdeza kiyA gayA hai usameM sArI jaina samAja eka mata hai, kyA usameM bhI ApakI mUrti ko sthAna hai? nahIM, kadApi nahIM dekhiye| cattArisaraNaMpavajjAmi-arihaMtAsaraNaMpavajjAmi, siddhA saraNaM pavajjAmi, sAhu saraNaM pavajjAmi, kevali paNNattaM dhamma saraNaM pvjjaami| isa sarva mAnya aura saMsAra rata jIvoM ke zaraNabhUta siddhAnta meM bhI mUrti ko sthAna nahIM hai| ataeva sundarajI kA prayatna viphala hI hai| sundarajI ne chadmastha arihaMta ko sAdhu pada meM batAkara bhavitAtmA anagAra meM unakA samAveza honA likhA aura arihaMta caitya ko mUrti ke lie surakSita rakha liyA, yaha vyartha kI khIMcatAna hai| inheM samajha lenA cAhie ki chadmastha arihaMta ko arihaMta caitya zabda se pRthak batalAne kA khAsa kAraNa yaha hai ki camarendra inhIM chadmastha arihaMta kA zaraNa lekara saudharma svarga gayA thA aura AyA bhI inhIM kI zaraNa meN| yahA~ chadmastha arihaMta prabhu mahAvIra hI mukhya evaM AzrayabhUta puruSa haiM, ataeva inase vizeSa sambandha hone ke kAraNa yaha pada adhika lagAyA gayA hai, kintu sUtra rahasya se anabhijJa sundarajI ko yaha bAta mAlUma kaise ho? zrI sundarajI! jisa prakAra vaiyAvRtyAdhikAra meM sUtrakAra ne AcArya, upAdhyAya, sthavira, tapasvI, rugNa, bAla Adi ko mAtra sAdhu pada meM hI

Page #143
camarendra aura mUrtti kA zaraNa nahIM ginAkara pRthak pRthak ginAyA hai isakA bhI khAsa kAraNa yahI hai ki vaiyAvRtya ke pAtroM kA spaSTa jJAna ho jAya, isI prakAra Azraya dAtA chadyastha arihaMta ke lie ukta zabda pRthak rakhanA svAbhAvika haiN| isake sivAya yadi sundara kathanAnusAra ukta zabda kA mUrti artha mAna bhI leM to bhI koI bAdhA nahIM hai kyoMki jisa prakAra pahale dezI rAjyoM meM dharma sthAnoM kI itanI maryAdA thI ki vahA~ pahu~cane vAlA aparAdhI jaba taka vahA~ rahatA giraphtAra nahIM kiyA jAtA, athavA jaise kisI eka mahAtmA ke do bhakta haiM, yadi donoM ke Apasa meM takarAra ho gaI ho aura unameM se kisI ne vahA~ mahAtmA ke nAmakI duhAI (zapatha) de dI, ho to vahA~ bhI jhagar3A Age bar3hane se rukanA saMbhava hai / hamAre isa prAMta meM eka aisA DAkU thA ki yadi use koI "mAmA" kaha de to phira vaha usakoM lUTatA nahIM thA / isa taraha mAtra nAma yA makAna se bhI asara honA pAyA jAtA hai, jisa rAjA ke rAjya meM rahate hoM usakI duhAI dene se bhI pahale bahuta bacAva ho jAtA thA / isa taraha nAma mAtra hI mAne usake lie asara kAraka ho sakatA hai to isa taraha mUrti ho to bhI koI Azcarya nahIM, kintu isameM Atmika kalyANa mAnanA to sacamuca vicAra zUnyatA hai * aura aise pramANa denA hI anucita haiN| AzA hai sundarajI isa para gaharA vicAra kara apane pakar3e hue haTha ko chodd'eNge| 68 * arihaMta caitya zabda ke lie yahA~ yaha bhI saMdeha hotA hai ki jisa prakAra upAsaka - dazAMga, uvavAI kA aMbar3AdhikAra tathA campA varNana meM gar3abar3I huI hai aura pATha prakSipta hue haiM, usI taraha yahA~ bhI to aisA nahIM huAho ? kyoMki cAroM sthaloM meM zabda eka samAna hI haiN| tIna sthaloM kI cAlAkiyeM to pakar3alI gaI kintu yadi zodhaka vidvAn khoja kareMge to saMbhava hai isa sthala ke viSaya meM bhI kucha patA lage /

Page #144
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 66 (15) devANaM-AsAyaNAe mi0 jJAnasundarajI ne apane pothe ke pR0 75 meM likhA hai ki - Apa khuda bhairava vagairaha kI mUrti ko pUTha dekara nahIM baiThate ho Apake saba sAdhu sAdhvI pratidina do vakta pratikramaNa karate samaya kahate haiM ki - "devANaM AsAyaNAe, devINaM AsAyaNAeM" isako jarA soco evaM samajho ki una deva devI kI pASANamaya mUrtiyoM kI AzAtanA kI ho to micchAmi dukkaDaM svayaM Apako denA par3atA hai, jaba mUrti kI AzAtanA kA itanA bar3A pApa hai to usakI bhakti kA puNya honA to svataH siddha hai isameM savAla hI kyA ho sakatA hai ? misTara sundarajI kA ukta kathana bhI vicAra zUnyatA kA hai| kyoMki "devANaM AsAyaNAe, devINaM AsAyaNAe" kA tAtparya devI-devatA kI pASANamaya mUrti se nahIM hai| sUtra meM 33 prakAra kI AzAtanAoM kA varNana hai, usameM arihaMta se lekara sAdhu-sAdhvI, zrAvaka-zrAvikA, ihaloka, paraloka, dharma, deva, manuSya yukta loka, kAla, sUtra, sUtradAtA, sarvaprANI, bhUta, jIva, sattva inakI bhI AzAtanA batAI gaI hai to kyA sundara hisAba se sabhI AzAtanAoM kA matalaba mUrti se hI hai? sundarajI! kutarkoM se bAz2a Ao, ye AzAtanAeM mUrti se kucha bhI sambandha nahIM rakhatI, "na devANaM AsAyaNAe" kA tAtparya hI mUrti AzAtanA kA hai| kyoM becAre bhole bhoMduoM ko bhrama meM DAlate ho? "devANaM AsAyaNAeM" kA matalaba devatAoM kA astitva nahIM svIkAra ne se yA unake avarNavAda bolane se hI hai, kintu mUrti se nhiiN| "ThANAGga sUtra meM bhI durlabha bodhi hone ke pAMca

Page #145
100 devANaM-AsAyaNAe ***************** ******************** kAraNoM meM samyagdRSTi devatAoM kA avarNavAda bolane ko durlabha bodhi kahA hai kintu mUrti kI AzAtanA to vahA~ bhI nahIM kahI, phira sundara kathana ke thothepana meM kyA kasara hai? aura vaise to cAhe koI bhI kyoM na ho, niMdA yA AzAtanA to kisI kI bhI nahIM karanA caahie| niMdA burI hai, ise sabhI burI kahate haiM, kintu yaha bhI dhyAna meM rakhanA cAhie ki vastu sthiti kA satya evaM spaSTa nirdeza karanA niMdA nahIM hai| mithyA ko mithyA aura jhUTha ko jhUTha kahanA niMdA nahIM para satya kI rakSA hai| pApa ko pApa kahane vAlA niMdaka nahIM hokara dharma kI rakSA aura dharma kA pAlana karane vAlA kahA jAtA hai| ataeva ApakA tarka vyartha hI ThaharatA hai| jabaki - prazaMsA aura vaMdana namaskAra sadguNa hai to kyA bhairavabhavAnI, caNDI-maNDI Adi ko Apa vaMdana namaskAra kareMge? unakI prazaMsA kareMge? ajaina, bAbA, jogI, sanyAsI, fakIra Adi kI prazaMsA aura vandana namaskAra kareMge kyA vaise hI vezyA, zikArI, juArI, kuttA, siMha zUkara Adi ko bhI vaMdanAdi kareMge kyA? nahIM, vahA~ Apa svayaM aisA karanA asvIkAra kreNge| isI prakAra jarA sarala buddhi se yaha bhI samajhiye ki - yadyapi niMdA nahIM karanA sarva mAnya siddhAnta hai, tathApi prazaMsA to hara kisI kI nahIM kI jA sakatI, usI prakAra jaise ko taisA kahanA koI niMdA yA burAI nahIM hai| jJAna sundara jI! kitane hI mUrtimati aise bhI kutarka karate haiM ki"tumhAre pitA ke citra ko namaskAra karo agara namaskAra nahIM karo to pairoM tale roMdau" yaha kathana bhI ajJatA kA hai| hamArA to yaha siddhAnta hai ki hamAre pUjya pitA zrI hamAre pUjya haiN| unakA citra nahIM, kintu maiM Apake kutarka ke khaNDana meM Apa hI se pUchatA hU~ ki - Apa kisI anya

Page #146
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 101 ****************************************** dharmAnuyAyI sujJa ko kaheM ki bhAI! tumhAre dharma ke viparIta zraddhAna vAle amuka puruSa ko vaMdanA namaskAra kro| jaba vaha "nA" kahe to phira kaho ki - tuma use nahIM mAnate ho to jUte mAro, phira dekhiye vaha Apako kyA javAba degA? yahI ki mahAzaya! Apa bhI acche nikale, bhalA maiM vandanA kyoM karane lagA aura jUte bhI kyoM mArane lagA? yaha kahA~ kI buddhimAnI hai? ataeva aisA kutarka karane vAloM ko yaha dhyAna meM rakhanA cAhie ki - jinako Adara nahIM diyA jAtA, unakA apamAna bhI nahIM kiyA jAtA, guNa niSpanna vastu ko hI yathocita Adara diyA jAnA caahie| hama bhI mUrti ko vaMdana namaskAra nahIM karate haiM, usI prakAra apamAna bhI nahIM karate haiM kintu vastu svarUpa kA varNana karate jaise ko taisA avazya kahate haiN| isameM mAna apamAna kI koI bAta nahIM hai, vastu ke satya svarUpa ko prakaTa karanA satyAgraha evaM dharma rakSA hai| isa siddhAnta ko acchI taraha samajha kara dveSa buddhi ko chor3a denA caahie| (16) Ananda-zramaNopAsaka zrI jJAnasundara jI ne cauthe prakaraNa ke pR0 78 se Ananda zramaNopAsaka viSayaka kalama calAte hue likhA hai ki - "AnaMda zrAvaka ne mandira banavA kara mUrtiyeM sthApita kI thI aura mUrti pUjA karatA thA aisA upAsaka dazAMga ke "arihaMta ceiyAI" zabda se aura samavAyAMga sUtra se pramANita hotI hai| ___mitra jJAnasundarajI ke isa prakAra ke lekha se pAyA jAtA hai ki - ye jar3a pUjA ke raMga meM pUre raMge hue haiM, isI se jahA~ eka bUMda taka nahIM ho vahA~ mahAsAgara dikhAne jaisI vyartha ceSTA karate haiN| kyoMki upAsaka

Page #147
102 AnaMda-zramaNopAsaka dazAMga sUtra ke AnandAdhikAra meM to ThIka para sAre sUtra meM kahIM bhI kisI zrAvaka ke mUrti pUjane kA nAma nizAna taka nahIM hai| phira sundara mitra kyoM vyartha meM AkAza pAtAla eka kara rahe haiM? AnaMda zrAvaka ne mandira banAye yA mUrti pUjA kI yA saMgha nikAla kara yAtrA kI, aisA kathana sUtra meM to aNumAtra bhI nahIM hai| isa viSaya meM mUrti pUjaka loga jo kucha bhI kahate haiM, kalpanA kahAnI mAtra hai| mUrti-pUjA ke samarthaka zrI jJAnasundarajI ne AnaMda zramaNopAsaka ko mUrti-pUjaka ThaharAne ke lie AnaMda kI tyAga pratijJA kA avataraNa diyA hai, yahA~ hama usa sthala kA prAcIna prati ke AdhAra se zuddha pATha dete haiN| 'No khalu me bhaMte! kappai ajjappabhiI aNNautthira vA, aNNautthiya devayANi vA, aNNautthiya pariggahiyANi "ceiyAiM" vaMdittae vA NamaMsittae vA, puvviMalANatteNaM Alavittae vA, saMlavittae vA, tesiM asaNaM vA, pANaM vA, khAimaM vA, sAimaM vA, dAuM vA aNuppadAuM vaa||' ___ yaha AnaMdAdhikAra kA zuddha pATha prAcIna prati ke anusAra hai isameM AnaMda zrAvaka ne tyAga koTi kI pratijJA karate hue kahA hai ki - he prabho! Aja pIche mujhe anyayUthika (jaina ke sivAya anya matAvalambI) ko anyayUthika deva ko aura anyayUthika ke grahaNa kiye hue sAdhuoM ko vaMdana namaskAra karanA, unake bolAne ke pahile hI bolanA, bArambAra bolanA, azanAdi denA, bArambAra denA nahIM kalpatA hai| isa sUtra meM mUrti pUjane yA nahIM pUjane kA nAma bhI nahIM hai, kintu mUrti-pUjaka bandhuoM ke pUrvaja AnaMda ke sAre adhyayana meM mUrti kA nAma ____

Page #148
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ********** bhI nahIM dekhakara apanI mUrti-pUjA rUpI kahI jAne vAlI dharma karaNI ko pramANa zUnya samajhane lage, taba una logoM ne isa pATha meM eka zabda aura apanI ora se bar3hA diyA, jahA~ prAcIna prati meM " aNNa utthiya pariggahiyANi ceiyAI" vAkya hai vahA~ " aNNa utthiya pariggahiyANi "arihaMta" ceiyAiM pATha banA diyA arthAt isa sAre vAkya meM "arihaMta" zabda adhika prakSipta kara diyA aura artha karane lage ki . 103 - " anyatIrthiyoM ke grahaNa kiye hue arihaMta caitya arthAt "jina pratimA" ise AnaMda ko vandanAdi karanA nahIM kalpe / " isa viSaya meM thor3AsA vicAra kiyA jAtA hai| Aja jitanI bhI prAcIna aura prAcIna se prAcIna pratiyeM upAsaka dazAMga kI milatI haiM, unameM yaha bar3hAyA huA (arihaMta) zabda hai hI nahIM, mere jAnane meM AyA hai ki jaisalamera ke prAcIna zAstra bhaMDAra meM upAsakadazAMga kI tAr3a patra para likhI huI eka prati hai yaha bahuta prAcIna hai isameM bhI " arihaMta" zabda nahIM hai 1. eziyATika sosAyaTI kalakattA se prakAzita upAsaka dazAMga sUtra meM to "arihaMta ceiyAiM" ye donoM zabda nahIM hai / isa viSaya meM isa sUtra ke anuvAdaka mahodaya pro0 e. epha. ruDolpha hornala sAhaba ne eka noTa likhakara yaha batAyA hai ki - prAcIna pratiyoM meM "arihaMta" zabda nahIM hai aura "ceiyANi" zabda yadyapi prAcIna pustakoM meM hai tathApi yaha zabda bhI TIkA se lekara mUla meM milAyA huA pAyA jAtA hai| 2. zve0 mUrti pUjaka samAja ke samartha vidvAn paM0 becaradAsajI dosI ne "bhagavAn mahAvIra nA daza upAsako" nAmaka grantha gujarAtI bhASA meM likhA hai (jo upAsaka dazAMga kA anuvAda hai) usameM

Page #149
104 AnaMda-zramaNopAsaka AnaMdAdhikAra ke isa pATha kA artha pR0 14 meM isI eziyATika sosAyaTI kI prati ke anusAra isa prakAra diyA hai| "Aja thI anya tIrthIko ne anya tIrthika devatAoM ne anya tIrtha ke svIkArelAne, vandana ane namana karavUmane kalpe nhiiN|" 3. svayaM suMdara mitra ne bhI apane mUrti-pUjA ke prAcIna itihAsa ke cauthe prakaraNa pR0 80 meM yahI pATha diyA hai usameM bhI yaha "arihaMta' zabda nahIM hai| isake sivAya pR0 81 meM yaha likhakara ki "arihaMta zabda ke lie kaI pratiyoM meM hone para bhI Apa inakAra karate ho|" svIkAra kiyA hai ki "arihaMta zabda kaI pratiyoM meM nahIM bhI hai|" yadi sabhI aura prAcIna pratiyoM meM "arihaMta" zabda hotA to sundara mitra "kaI pratiyoM meM hone para" aisA kadApi nahIM likhte| ____ ataeva siddha huA ki - AnaMda pratijJA meM "arihaMta" zabda mUrti pUjakoM ne adhika bar3hA diyA hai aura isakA mukhya Azaya mUrtipUjA ko AnaMda prakaraNa meM milAne kA hI hai kintu hamAre pUjaka bandhuoM kI yaha karAmAta bhI yahA~ vyartha hI siddha huii| inake isa prakSipta zabda se bhI inakA abhiSTa siddha nahIM ho sakA aura isa "arihaMta" zabda ke hote hue bhI artha to prakaraNa saGgata "sAdhu" hI anukUla huaa| kyoMki- .. . isa pratijJA se Ananda kA yaha Azaya hai ki maiM anya tIrthika anya tIrthikadeva aura anya tIrthikoM ke grahaNa kiye hue sAdhuoM ko vandanA namaskAra AhAra, jala, khAdima, svAdima nahIM dUMgA, vArambAra bhI nahIM duuNgaa| bulAne se pahale bolUMgA bhI nahIM Adi Adi yaha viSaya svayaM apanI zakti se yaha batA rahA hai ki yaha pratijJA manuSya se sambandha rakhane vAlI hai| alApa saMlApa manuSya se hI hotA hai, AhArAdi bhI

Page #150
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ********************************** 105. ********** manuSya ko diyA jAtA hai| mUrti se to ina bAtoM kA sambandha hI nahIM hai| hA~ yadi isameM dhUpa, dIpa, naivedya, patra, phala-phUla, jala, akSatAdi car3hAne kI bAta hotI, AratI utArane kI pratijJA hotI, darzana-pUjana kA kahA gayA hotA taba to vicAra ko kucha avakAza bhI hotA, kintu sUtra meM to spaSTa manuSyoM ke khAne pIne kI Avazyaka vastuoM aura bhakti kA ullekha kiyA gayA hai, phira aise sthala para prakaraNAnukUla " sAdhu" artha nahIM karake mUrti artha karane vAle kisa prakAra sujJa kahe jA sakate haiM? sundara mitra ne aise uttara para yaha bhI kutarka kI hai ki "jo sAdhu jaina se bhraSTa hokara anya tIrthI bana gayA hai vaha to anya tIrthI meM ginA jA cukA hai phira use pRthak batAne kI kyA AvazyakatA hai?" isa viSaya meM sundarajI ko samajhAyA jAtA hai ki sAdhu do prakAra ke hote haiM, eka to gRhasthAvasthA se sAdhu avasthA meM Ate haiM, dUsare kisI samAja ke sAdhuoM meM se nikala kara kisI dUsare samAja ke sAdhuoM meM mila jAte haiM / yahA~ inakI bhinnatA batAne kA kAraNa bhI hai / vaha yaha hai ki - jo gRhasthAvasthA se anya samAja ke sAdhu bana haiM ve to svAbhAvika taura se apanA kAma karate rahate haiM jaina samAja kA unase adhika paricaya nahIM hotA, ataeva unake pAsa svabhAva se hI AnA-jAnA nahIM hotA hai / kintu jo jaina sAdhutva se bhraSTa hokara anya samAja meM mila jAtA hai usakA sAdhAraNa jaina gRhastha samudAya se paricaya bhI adhika rahatA hai / usa paricayAdhikya ke kAraNa koI jaina gRhastha usake pAsa jAya to vo svayaM gRhastha ke pAsa Akara paricaya bar3hA kara apanA mithyA jAla phailAve to usase bacane ke lie yaha bhinna aura svataMtra sthAna (vAkya) rakhA gayA hai aura isakA honA bhI

Page #151
106 AnaMda-zramaNopAsaka ******************************************** Avazyaka hai, kyoMki aise bhAge hue loga pUrva samAja ke lie adhika hAni kAraka haiN| yaha to sabhI jAnate haiM ki sAdhumArgI samAja ke lie hAnikAraka jitane anya mUrti pUjaka nahIM utane yaha bhAge hue AtmArAmajI burerAyajI Apa khuda aura pIche ke kAnhajI tathA bhraSTa paMcaka Adi haiN| ina logoM ne apanA pUrva paricaya kA jAla phailAkara aura una logoM meM ghusa-ghusa kara bahutoM ko zraddhA bhraSTa kara diyA hai| Apa bhI saM0 1965 ke cAturmAsa meM byAvara meM isa kUTa nIti kA anusaraNa kara cuke haiN| basa isI kAraNa se anya tIrthI ke grahaNa kiye hue se paraheja rakhane kI AnaMda ne pratijJA lI thI aura usa samaya usakI AvazyakatA bhI thI, kyoMki usa samaya jamAlI gozAlaka ne apanI-apanI khIcar3I alaga pakAnA prArambha kara diyA thaa| unameM jitane bhI sAdhu sAdhvI Adi the prAyaH jaina sAdhu saMsthA meM se gaye hue the, isalie unase paricaya nahIM bar3hAkara unase ghRNA karanA bhI samAja rakSakoM kA mukhya karttavya thA, jisakA jvalaMta pramANa sakaDAla putra zrAvaka kA gozAlaka ke prati anAdara bhAva hai| isalie usane gauzAlaka ko apane ghara cale Ane para bhI mAna nahIM diyaa| yaha anya tIrthI ko yA usameM mila jAne vAloM ko Adara Adi nahIM dene kA pratyakSa pramANa hai| ataeva aisI zaGkA ko tanika bhI sthAnaM nahIM hai| hamAre mUrti-pUjaka bhAI "arihaMta ceiyAiM" se jina pratimA artha karake yaha kahate haiM ki "AnaMda ko anya tIrthakoM kI grahaNa kI huI jina mUrti ko vandanAdi nahIM kalpatA hai|" kintu yaha kathana bhI asatya aura yukti se zUnya hai, kyoMki jina mUrti kisI ke grahaNa kara lene mAtra se apUjya yA avandanIya nahIM ho jAtI, na mUrti ke hI rUpa meM parivartana hotA hai cAhe, jaina usakI pUjA kare yA ajaina kintu isase

Page #152
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 107 ******Li Li **Li ********Li Li Li Li Li Li ***Ben ***Kong ********* usameM kisI prakAra kI bhinnatA nahIM hotii| hA~ sAdhu to anya ke grahaNa kara lene se avandanIya ho sakatA hai, kyoMki jaina mAtra ke lie guru pada meM paMca mahAvratAdi mUla aura uttaraguNa yukta muni hI vandanIya pUjanIya hai aura anya tIrthI ke grahaNa kara lene se (anya samAja meM mila jAne se) sAdhu meM ye guNa nahIM rahate haiM, ve jaina dRSTi se zuddha samyaktva se bhI rahita ho jAtA hai| ataeva avandanIya avazya hai, kintu mUrti ke lie to yaha bAdhA hai hI nahIM mUrti to jahA~ hogI vahA~ eka hI rUpa meM hogI phira anya ke grahaNa kara lene mAtra se mUrti achUta kyoM aura kaise ho sakatI hai? jisa prakAra tIrthaMkara prabhu aura anagAra mahAtmA anya sAmAjikoM ke vandana namana karane para bhI jaina ke lie vandanIya paryupAsanIya rahate haiM, usI prakAra mUrti bhI Apa ke hisAba se rahanI caahie| ___ sAdhu ke anya samAja meM mila jAne para usako zraddhA jainadharma aura siddhAMtoM para nahIM rahatI, vaha jainattva ko hI heya samajhatA hai, isalie jainiyoM ke lie to vaha avazya avaMdanIya hai| kintu mUrti to jainiyoM ke adhikAra meM hone para bhI jar3a hai aura anya ke adhikAra meM jAne para bhI jar3a hI rahatI hai ? jina mUrti ko yadi anya tIrthI grahaNa kara le aura use apanA deva mAnakara vande pUje to yaha to mUrti-pUjakoM ke lie prasannatA kI bAta honI cAhie? kyoMki ve loga jainiyoM ke deva ko mUrti pUjakara mUrti-pUjakoM ke hisAba se jinopAsaka hote haiM ataeva isameM mUrti kI apUjyatA kI bAdhA kyoM honI cAhie? . ___kitane hI mUrti-pUjaka loga yahA~ yaha tarka karate haiM ki - "jisa prakAra sama sUtra mithyA dRSTi ke hAtha meM jAne se viSama ho jAte haiM usI prakAra jina mUrti bhI anya ke adhikAra meM jAne se avaMdanIya ho jAtI haiN|" kintu yaha kathana bhI ajJatA kA hai, kyoMki sUtra

Page #153
108 AnaMda-zramaNopAsaka ********* ************************** (pustaka rUpa) svayaM anya tIrthI ke hAtha meM jAne se viSama nahIM bana jAte, sUtra to sama hI haiM aura sama hI rahate haiM, kintu sama-viSamatA to pAThaka kI yogyatA para nirbhara hai| pAThaka yadi viSama mati (mithyAdRSTi) hogA to vaha sama sUtra kA artha bhI ulTA viSama kara DAlegA aura pAThaka samadRSTi hogA to satya artha karegA ataeva sUtra kI sama viSamatA pAThaka kI yogyatA kI apekSA rakhatI hai, kintu isakA yaha artha nahIM ki sUtra svayaM viSama bana jaay| jaise ki koI sUtra sama sUtra hai aura vo viSama dRSTi vAle ke hAtha meM hai to usa viSama dRSTi vAle ke lie usake viparIta artha lagAne ke kAraNa viSama ho sakatA hai kintu vahI sUtra usI samaya kisI samadRSTi sujJa ke hAtha meM jAyagA to vaha usakA sama artha hI karegA ataeva siddha huA ki sUtra to sama hI hai viSama nahIM, kintu sama viSama to pAThaka kI buddhi kA pariNAma hI hai| mithyAdRSTi yA viSama mati ke hAtha meM jAne mAtra se sUtra amAnya nahIM ho jAte yadi aisA hI ho to Apake lie Aja prAyaH sabhI sUtra amAnya aura viSama hone cAhie kyoMki Aja jitane bhI mudrita sUtra haiM, ve prAyaH ajainoM ke hAtha se mudraNa hote haiM ajaina loga hI uThAkara gAr3iyeM bharakara presa se lAte haiM anekoM pustakAlayoM meM sUtra sAhitya haiM vo ajainoM ke hAtha meM bhI jAtA hai| anekoM hastalikhita sUtra ajainoM kI lekhanI se likhe gaye haiN| Aja pracalita bhASAoM meM sUtroM kA anuvAda hokara saikar3oM ajainoM ke hAtha meM pahuMca cuke haiN| isalie sarala buddhi se yaha samajho ki sUtra svayaM viSama nahIM haiM, kintu sama viSama kA matalaba pAThakoM kI yogyatA se hI hai| - Apa eka auSadha ko dekhiye, yadi samajhadAra vaidya usa auSadha ko kisI rogI ke upayukta samajha kara use ucita anupAna ke sAtha

Page #154
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 106 *************************************** degA to vaha lAbhakArI hogI kintu usI auSadha ko koI anAr3I U~Ta-vaidya binA marja samajhe hI kisI rogI ko de DAlegA to vahI auSadha lAbha ke badale hAni kAraka hogI isameM auSadha kA koI doSa nahIM hai, yadi doSa hai to usa mUrkha vaidya kA hai, jo na roga ko samajhatA hai na auSadha ke guNa doSa ko, basa isI prakAra sUtroM ke viSaya meM bhI samajhiye isameM bhI doSa sUtra kA nahIM kintu pAThaka kI yogyatA kA hI hai| ataeva ApakI kutarka havA ho gaI, kevala ajaina yA viSama dRSTi ke hAtha meM jAne yA usake par3ha lene mAtra se hI sUtra amAnya nahIM hote ve punaH hamAre pAsa A jAne se hama usakA svAdhyAya karate haiM, usI prakAra mUrti bhI anya ke adhikAra meM jAne mAtra se yA anya tIrthI ke pUja lene se hI apUjya nahIM ho jaatii| yadi aisA hI hai to Apake madhya bhArata meM makSI ke pArzvanAtha kI mUrti bhI avandanIya apUjanIya honI cAhie kyoMki usa para digambaroM kA bhI adhikAra hai, ve bhI apanI vidhi se vaMdate pUjate haiM aura ve to vandate pUjate samaya zvetAmbaroM kI kI huI pUjA ko hI utAra pheMkate haiM, mUrti ke netra nikAla lene ke bAda hI pUjate haiM, isalie Apake hisAba se to vo mUrti bhI avandanIya honI cAhie? isI taraha mevAr3a prAnta kI kezariyAjI kI mUrti bhI Apake lie amAnya honI cAhie, kyoMki use bhI ajaina aura bhIla loga taka apanA deva mAnakara pUjate haiM, bhIla loga usa mUrti ko kezArayAnAtha yA riSabhadeva kI mUrti nahIM kahakara kAliyA bAbA kI mUrti kahate haiM aura mAnate pUjate haiM, paNDe loga jo vaiSNava haiM unhoMne usa mUrti ko apanA deva honA batAkara usa para apanA adhikAra jamAkara Apake adhikAra se inakAra kiyA hai| ataeva use bhI Apako nahIM vaMdanA pUjanA caahie|

Page #155
110 AnaMda-zramaNopAsaka ********************* ********************* vAstava meM bAta to yaha hai ki jisa prakAra sUtra kisI ajaina ke par3ha lene mAtra se jainiyoM ke lie amAnya nahIM ho jAte, usI prakAra mUrti bhI kisI ke adhikAra meM jAne yA kisI ke vandane pUjane mAtra se avandanIya nahIM ho sktii| isalie sarala buddhi se yaha samajho ki AnaMda zramaNopAsaka kI pratijJA mUrti viSayaka nahIM kintu sAdhu viSayaka hai| mUrti pUjaka loga jina mUrti ko deva pada meM mAnate haiM, svayaM sundara mitra ne bhI yaha svIkAra kiyA hai ki - 1. arihaMtoM ke caitya (maMdira mUrti) ko AzAtanA karanA arihaMtoM kI hI AzAtanA hai| (pR076) 2. arihaMtoM kI mUrti arihaMta pada meM aura siddhoM kI siddha pada (pR0 263) 3. mUrti arihaMta aura siddhoM ke zaraNA meM hai| (pR0 263) 4. jo arihaMtoM kI mUrti kI AzAtanA hai vaha hI arihaMtoM kI AzAtanA hai| (pR0 263) ataeva siddha huA ki - mUrti pUjaka mUrti ko deva pada meM mAnate haiM aura nya yUthika deva jaba avandanIya hue to usake sAtha unakI mAnya mUrti bhI avandanIya huI yaha svataH siddha hai, isake lie pRthak sthAna rokane kI AvazyakatA nhiiN| pRthak sthAna jo rakhA gayA hai vaha anya yUthika parigRhita sAdhu ke lie hI hai| jisakA mukhya kAraNa pahale batalA diyA hai| sundara jI kI yogyatA cAlU prakaraNa meM suMdara mitra ne svayaM ajJa hote hue bhI svargavAsI AgamoddhAraka zAMta svabhAva parama pUjya zrI amolaka RSi jI mahArAja para anucita hamale kiye haiN| hama yaha nahIM kahate ki pUjya zrI ke

Page #156
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ****************** anuvAda meM azuddhi nahIM hai, kintu hamArA yahA~ yaha kahanA hai ki - yahA~ suMdarajI ne jo azuddhi batAI hai usameM suMdara mitra kI hI mUrkhatA hai| suMdara mitra pRSTha 81 meM likhate haiM ki - "RSijI ko pUchA jAya ki Apane anuvAda meM jainake bhraSTAcArI sAdhu likhA hai usameM sAdhu to zAyada Apa 'ceiANi vA' kA artha kara diyA hogA, parantu jaina yaha kisa zabda kA artha kiyA hai? aura Age Apa sAdhu ke sAtha bhraSTAcArI zabda jor3a diyA hai yaha kisa mUla pATha kA anuvAda hai kyoMki Apake mUla pATha meM to yaha donoM (jaina aura bhraSTAcArI) haiM hI nahIM phira Apane yaha kalpanA kara utsUtra bhASitva kA vajra pApa zira para kyoM uThAyA?" Adi 111 isa prakAra ajJatA pradarzita kara sundarajI apanI yogyatA batA rahe haiM, kintu yadi zAMta buddhi se vicAra kiyA jAya to jo artha zAstroddhAraka maharSi ne kiyA hai, yaha yogya hI hai, kyoMki mUla pATha meM " aNNautthiya pariggahiyANi ceiyAI" zabda AyA hai| jisakA zabdArtha hotA hai"anya tIrthI ke grahaNa kiye hue sAdhu" kevala isI zabdArtha para se yaha vizeSaNa acchI taraha se laga sakate haiM, jaise ki "anya yUthika - jaina ke sivAya anya tIrthI, parigRhita - grahaNa kiye hue, caitya sAdhu" jina anya tIrthIkoM ne jaina ke sAdhu ko grahaNa kara liyA hai vo jaina ke hisAba se to bhraSTa sAdhu hI huA, ataeva bhraSTAcArI vizeSaNa ucita hI hai| dUsarA yahAM paramArtha bhI jaina ke sAdhuoM ko hI grahaNa karane kA hai, anya ko nahIM, kyoMki anya samAja ke sAdhuoM kA to samAveza prathama vAkya meM hI ho gyaa| ataeva jo bhI vizeSaNa isa viSaya meM diye gaye haiM ve ucita hI hai aura yadi Apako mAnyatAnusAra yahA~ arihaMta zabda mAna bhI liyA jAya to bhI koI hAni nahIM hai, -

Page #157
112 AnaMda-zramaNopAsaka ***************************************** isakA bhI ukta artha hI hotA hai, kintu yaha zabda nahIM hone para bhI yaha artha spaSTa ho jAtA hai phira isa zabda kI AvazyakatA hI kyA? ataeva kutarka karanA chor3akara satya artha ko mAnya karane kI sarala buddhi ko sthAna diijie| Age calakara Apa phira mUrkhatA pUrNa bAta likhate haiM - __"arihaMta aura jaina eka hai yA bhinna 2 haiM? yadi Apako pratimA hI nahIM mAnanA hai to phira arihaMta kA sAdhu kahane meM kyA harja thA xxx para itanI akala Ave kahA~ se?" aklamaMda sundarajI! mUrkhatA kA pradarzana to svayaM kara rahe haiM, eka baccA taka jAnatA hai ki arihaMta aura jaina eka nahIM, kintu bhinna haiN| eka hai upAsya to dUsarA hai upAsaka, arihaMta haiM deva to jaina hai una deva kA upAsaka, isa sIdhI aura sarala bAta ko bhI nahIM samajhane vAle sundarajI kI sundara buddhi kI balihArI hai, kyA yaha mUrkhatA kA pratyakSa tANDava nahIM hai? hA~ arihaMta aura jina ko eka likhate taba to koI bAta nahIM thI, para vidvatA kA mithyA ghamaNDa kara anya kI niMdA karane meM nipuNa sundara mitra ke kaluSita hRdaya meM to kAlI vastu bharI hai, suMdarajI ke isa suMdara (?) pothe meM aisI to kaI anartha kAraka azaddha vastue~ haiM koI pRSTha aisA nahIM nikalegA ki jo zuddha ho, kahIM zabda hI azuddha to kahIM prayoga azuddha, pAyA jAtA hai ki pothe kI asala prati meM to anaginata kI azuddhiyAM hogI, kintu anya ajaina yA jaina paribhASA se anabhijJa kisI se kucha zuddhi avazya karAI hai to bhI yaha to avazya hai ki bhASA kA prayoga ekadama azuddha hai, jo kisI bhI hiMdI ke sAdhAraNa jJAtA se chupA huA nahIM hai|

Page #158
jaisA jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 113 * ******************************************** jabaki-AnandAdhikAra aura sAre upAsaka dazAMga meM bhI mUrtipUjA kA nAma nizAna taka nahIM hai, taba sundarajI ko apane mithyA pakSa ko puSTa karane ke lie nimna do kutarka uThAne par3e haiM, jo pRSTha 78, 76 se pAye jAte haiM, tadyathA - 1. sUtra saMkSipta kara diye gye| 2. samavAyAMga meM upAsaka dazAMga kI noMdha meM zrAvakoM ke mUrti pUjA kA kathana hai| yaha do kutarka suMdarajI ne uThAe haiM, kintu pAThakoM ko yaha dhyAna meM rakhanA cAhie ki yaha donoM kutarka suMdarajI ke nijI nahIM hai, kintu vijayAnanda sUri ke "samyaktva zalyoddhAra pR0 85" ke haiM, vijayAnaMda sUri ne yaha to svIkAra kara liyA hai ki-upAsaka dazAMga sUtra meM mUrtipUjA kA pATha nahIM hai kintu suMdarajI to unase bhI bar3hakara kutarkI haiM dekhiye, vijayAnaMda jI kA spaSTa kathana - "yadyapi upAsaka dAMga meM yaha pATha nahIM hai kyoMki pUrvAcAryoM ne sUtroM ko saMkSipta kara diyA hai tApi samavAyAMga meM yaha bAta pratyakSa hai|" isase bhI siddha huA ki upAsaka dazAMga sUtra meM mUrti pUjA kA pATha nahIM hai| aba Ananda zramaNopAsaka kI kAlpanika (AdaraNIya) pratijJA ko bhI dekhie - "kappaI me samaNe NiggaMthe phAsuesaNijjeNaM asaNapANakhAimasAimeNaM vatthapaDiggaha kaMbala pAda pucchaNeNaM pIDhaphalagasijjA saMthAreNaM osaha bhesajjeNaM paDilAbhemANe vihritte|" arthAt Ananda zrAvaka pratijJA karatA hai ki "mujhe zramaNa nigraMtha ko prAsUka eSaNika AhArAdi pratilAbhate hue vicaranA kalpatA hai|"

Page #159
114 AnaMda-zramaNopAsaka **************************************** AzA hai ki aba to suMdarajI Ananda zrAvaka ko mUrti-pUjaka mAnane kI dhRSTatA nahIM kreNge| aba suMdara mitra ne aura vijayAnanda jI ne kiye do kutarkoM para vicAra karate haiN| sUtra saMkSipta hone kI kuyukti sundara mitra aura vijayAnaMdajI ne upAsakadazAMga meM zrAvakoM ke mUrti pUjana kA kathana na hone meM sUtroM kA saMkSipta honA batalAyA hai, yadyapi sUtra saMkSipta hone kI bAta ThIka hai, tathApi aise viSaya meM sUtroM ke saMkSipta hone kA aDaMgA lagAnA anucita hai| kyoMki - sAre upAsakadazAMga meM Ananda zrAvaka kA prathama adhyayana hI aisA hai ki jisane sAre sUtra ke tRtIyAMza pRSTha roka lie haiM, zeSa do bhAga meM nau zrAvakoM kA varNana hai| AnandAdhikAra meM usakI Rddhi, dhana, kSetra, vAstu, dAsa-dAsI, pazu aura parivAra kA kathana savistAra hai AnaMda ne kisa prakAra prabhu darzana dharmopadeza zravaNa aura vratagrahaNa kiye, aticAra TAle, pauSadha zAlA meM gayA, ekAdaza pratijJA kA pAlana kiyA, avadhijJAna utpanna honA, gautamasvAmI kA AnaMda se sammilana honA, samvAda honA, AnaMda kA prazna karanA, gautama svAmI ko zaGkA honA, prabhu kA zaGkA nivAraNa karanA, gautama svAmI kA Ananda se kSamA yAcanA, Ananda kA svarga gamana karanA Adi bAtoM kA jisameM ThIka ThIka pratipAdana kiyA gayA ho, yahAM taka ki - AnaMda ko pAnI kaisA pInA, ghI evaM cAMvala kaise khAnA, vastra kaise pahinanA, AbhUSaNa kaunakauna se pahinanA, daMtadhAvana kisa vastu se karanA Adi bAteM spaSTa batAI gaI ho, vahA~ kevala mUrti sthApita karane yA mandira banavAne yA pUjA

Page #160
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 115 * ***************************************** karane kA kathana nahIM hone mAtra se hI sUtra ke saMkucita hone kI mithyA DIMga mAranA, sarAsara haThadharmI pana hI hai| ... yadi AnaMda mandira nirmANa karavAtA yA mUrti sthApita karatA yA darzana pUjana karatA, yA kabhI saMgha nikAlakara yAtrA karatA to gaNadhara mahArAjA avazya isakI bhI noMdha lete? vistRta rUpa se nahIM to thor3e se zabdoM meM hI sahI, para kucha na kucha varNana to avazya milatA? Azcarya kI bAta hai ki jo (mUrti-pUjA) paddhati dharma kA mukhya aMga mAnI jAtI ho aura usake lie Adarza dharmAtmA upAsakoM ke jIvana vistAra meM bindu visarga taka nahIM mile yaha kyA thor3e vicAra kI bAta hai? isase to spaSTa siddha hotA hai ki usa samaya mUrti pUjA meM dharma mAnane kI jaina zraddhA nahIM thii| na ve zrAvaka vayaM hI mUrti pUjA meM dharma mAnate the| yadi unakI zraddhA sundarajI ke matAnusAra hotI to ve Adarza zrAvaka avazya aisI kriyAeM karate aura unakI jIvanI meM isakI noMdha bhI avazya hotI? : yaha haragija nahIM ho sakatA ki mAmUlI bAtoM kA sUtrakAra varNana kare aura Avazyaka bAta ko chor3a de| ataeva sUtra saMkucita hone kI kuyukti bhI anucita hai| isake atirikta saMkucita kA artha hai vistRta ke vistAra ko ghaTAkara thor3A kara denA,jo vastu daza yA bIsa zabdoM meM batAI gaI ho use eka yA do zabdoM meM hI batAkara saMkSipta kara denaa| kintu saMkucita ke mAne kisI vastu ko hI ur3A denA nahIM hotA, saMkucita yA saMkSipta meM to vastu kA sadbhAva avazya rahatA hai| isa hisAba se bhI yadi vistRta rUpa se nahIM to saMkSipta rUpa se mUrti pUjA kA varNana do cAra vAkyoM meM to avazya honA cAhie thA, kintu jaba mUrti

Page #161
116 AnaMda- zramaNopAsaka ******** pUjA ke lie sUtra ko pUrva se lekara pazcima taka TaTola liyA jAya to eka zabda to dUra eka akSara bhI nahIM milegaa| yaha sthiti spaSTa batA rahI hai ki upAsaka dazAMga meM mUrti pUjA kA nAma nizAna bhI nahIM haiN| isalie sundara bandhu ko cAhie ki Apa saMkucita kara dene kI kuyukti ko chor3akara basa yahI kaha dIjiye ki sUtrakAra yA saMkalana karttA ne mUrti pUjA ke pATha ko hI "chor3a diyA" yahI zabda Apake lie ThIka hai / kyoMki saMkucita zabda to vastu ke sadbhAva ko sthAna detA hai ataeva Apako cAhie ki Apa saMkucita zabda ko nikAla kara "chor3a diyA" zabda lagA dIjiye aura isameM hAni hI kyA hai, yaha to Apake ghara kI rIti hI hai| Apake vijayAnaMda sUrijI ne bhI samyaktva zalyoddhAra meM aisA kiyA hai jarA vaha bhI dekha lIjiye - " sUtra meM pAMDavoM ne saMthArA karA yaha adhikAra hai aura uddhAra karAyA yaha adhikAra nahIM hai" isase yaha samajhanA ki " itanI bAta sUtrakAra ne kamatI varNana karI hai / " (hindI samyaktva zalyoddhAra caturthAvRtti pR0 157) basa sundara mitra Apa bhI yaha kaha dIjiye ki - AnaMda ke mUrti pUjA kI bAta sUtrakAra ne kamatI varNana kI hai, yA chor3a dI hai kintu AnaMda ne mUrti pUjA to kI thii| mahAzaya ! isa prakAra ke mithyA prayatna hI Apako va Apake sUriyoM ko abhinivezI ghoSita karate haiM / jitane viSaya samavAyAMga meM upAsaka dazAMga kI noMdha lete hue batAe haiM ve sabhI viSaya upAsaka dazAMga meM maujUda haiM, hA~ pahale vistRta rUpa se hoMge, va aba saMkSipta rUpa se hai kintu haiM sabhI viSaya / ataeva ukta kuyukti eka dama mithyA hai|

Page #162
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 117 ********************************************** samavAyAMga ke nAma se bhrama Age cala kara Apane va vijayAnaMdajI ne samavAyAMga sUtra meM AnaMda zrAvaka ke mUrti pUjA kA hAla honA batalAyA hai| yaha bhI mithyA ceSTA hai kyoMki samavAyAMga meM kahIM bhI aisA ullekha nahIM hai, jisa bAta para Apa apanA AdhAra samajhate aura samajhAte haiM vahI bAta (vahI mUla pATha jo Apane diyA hai) likhakara ApakA bhrama jAla kA chedana kiyA jAtA hai| dekhiye - ___ "se kiM taM uvAsagadasAo? uvAsagadasAsuNaM, uvAsayANaM, nagarAiM, ujjANAI, ceiyAI, vaNakhaMDA, rAyANo, ammApiyaro, samosaraNAiM, dhammAyariyA, dhammakahAo, ihaloiya, paraloiya, iDDi visesA, uvAsayANaM, sIlavvaya, veramaNaM guNa, paccakkhANa, posahovavAsa paDi vajjiyAo, sUyapariggahA, tavovahANAiM, paDimAo uvasaggA, saMlehaNAo, bhattapaccakkhANAI, pAvogamaNAI, devalogagamaNAI, sukula paccAyA, puNo bohi lAbho, aMtakiriyAo, aaghvijjti|" artha - upAsaka dazAMga meM kyA hai? upAsaka dazAMga meM upAsakoM ke nagara, udyAna, caitya, vanakhaNDa, rAjA, mAtA, pitA, samavasaraNa, dharmAcArya, dharmakathA, ihalaukika, pAralaukika, Rddhi vizeSa kA kathana hai aura upAsakoM ke zIlavrata, veramaNavrata, guNavrata, pratyAkhyAna, pauSadhopavAsa vrata, sUtra grahaNa tapopadhAna, upAsaka pratimA, saMlleSaNA, bhakta pratyAkhyAna, pAdopagamana karanA, devaloka gamana, ucca kula meM janma, punaH bodhilAbha, antakriyA karanA yaha varNana kiyA gayA hai|

Page #163
118 AnaMda-zramaNopAsaka ************************************** suMdara mitra! isa noMdha meM to kahIM bhI mUrti pUjane maMdira banavAne Adi kA nAma nizAna taka nahIM hai phira Apa vyartha kA jhaMjhaTa kyoM macAte haiM? kyA Apa isa varNana ke "ceiyAI" zabda para to Apatti nahIM kara rahe haiM? isI para to Apa logoM ne bala diyA hai| kintu ApakA yaha prayatna bhI viphala hai, kyoMki isI zabda ke Age pIche kA sambandha dekhane para koI bhI sujJa isa zabda kA artha zrAvakoM ke jina mandira nahIM karegA, isa zabda ke sAtha hI yaha varNana hai ki - "ngraannNujjaannaaiNceiyaaivnnkhNddaaraayaanno|" arthAt - "upAsakoM ke rahane ke nagara, udyAna, vyaMtarAyatana, vanakhaMDa rAjA" isakA yaha matalaba nahIM ki ve nagara, udyAna, vyaMtarAyatana, vanakhaMDa rAjA Adi una upAsakoM ke khuda ke svataMtra the kintu isakA yaha tAtparya hai ki upAsaka dazAMga meM jo upAsaka jahA~ rahate the vahA~ ke nagara, udyAna, vyaMtarAyatana, vanakhaMDa rAjA Adi kA varNana hai| yadi sundara hisAba se caitya zabda kA artha jina mandira ho aura vo caitya upAsakoM ke khuda ke banAye hue mAne jAya to phira sundara bandhu ko nagara, udyAna, vanakhaMDa, rAjA, dharmAcArya dharmakathA Adi bhI upAsakoM ke khuda ke banAye hue mAnane cAhie? kintu aisA mAnanA hI anucita hai vizeSa tAtparya to vahA~ hai jo Upara batAyA gayA hai, vizeSa spaSTatA ke lie AnandAdhikAra kA nimna pATha dekhiye - ___"vANiye gAme nAmaM nayare hotthA vnnnno| tassa vANiyagAmassa nayarassa bahiyA uttara puratthime disIbhAe "duipalAsae naamNceie|" tatthaM vANiyagAme nayare jiyasattu rAyA hotthA vnnnno| tattha NaM vANiyagAme ANaMde nAma gAhAvai aDDhe jAva apribhuue|"

Page #164
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 116 ***************************************** arthAt - vANijya grAma nAmaka nagara thA, varNana yogya usa vANijya grAma nagara ke pUrvottara dizA bhAga meM dutipalAsa nAmaka caitya (vyaMtarAyatana) thaa| usa vANijya grAma nagara meM jitazatru nAmaka rAjA rAjya karatA thA varNana yogya, usa vANijya grAma meM Ananda nAmaka gAthApati rahatA thA vaha samRddha yAvat aparAbhavita thaa| jo noMdha samavAyAMga meM nagara Adi ke viSaya meM AI hai vaha isI viSaya kI hai, isameM caitya kA nAma "dutipalAsa' kahA hai| yaha dutipalAsa nAmaka caitya koI jinamandira yA mUrti nahIM kintu vyaMtarAyatana hI hai, aise nagarI ke varNana ke sAtha Aye hue caityoM kA artha TIkAkAra abhayadeva sUri ne bhI yahI kiyA hai| dekhiye - _ "ceieti-citarlepyAdi cayanasya bhAvaH karmaveti caityaM saMjJA zabdatvAd deva bimbam tadAzrayatvAt tad gRhamapi caityaM tacceha "vyaMtarAyatanam" natu bhagavatA mrhtaaytnm|" isI prakAra samavAyAMga sUtra meM jJAtA dharmakathA sUtra kI noMdha ke caitya zabda kA bhI TIkAkAra ne isI prakAra vyaMtarAyatana artha kiyA hai| dekhiye.. caityN-vyNtraaytnN| Agamodaya samiti patra 108 sUtra 141 / yahI artha upAsaka dazAMga ke caitya zabda kA bhI hai, kyoMki ekasA sambandha hone se TIkAkAra ne Age aise zabdoM kI TIkA nahIM kI, phira vijayAnandajI aura sundara mitra kyoM mithyA aDaMgA lagAte haiM? kyA sundara mitra Apa TIkAkAra se bhI adhika Age bar3hakara anartha to nahIM kara rahe haiM? batalAiye Apa jhUThe yA Apake TIkAkAra ? mahAzaya! anartha karate lajAiye, kucha parabhava kA bhI bhaya rakhiye yadi usa samaya jina mandira-tIrthaMkara maMdira hote to prabhu unameM hI Thaharate, unheM chor3akara

Page #165
120 AnaMda-zramaNopAsaka ***************** ****************** yakSAyatana-vyaMtarAyatana meM nahIM Thaharate, kisI bhI prAmANika sUtra meM yaha nahIM likhA hai ki kabhI prabhu tIrthaMkara mandira meM utare hoM, Thahare hoM, phira ApakA yaha anartha kaise mAnya ho sakatA hai? aura Apake hI TIkAkAra mahArAja ne to aise caitya zabda kA artha vyaMtarAyatana hI kiyA hai aura vizeSa meM arhat mandira hone kA niSedha hI kara diyA hai| kyA aba bhI ApakI bolatI banda nahIM hogI? aura dekhiye sundara mitra ! jisa prakAra upAsaka dazAMga kI noMdha meM "ceiyAI" zabda AyA hai, usI prakAra yahI zabda antakRta dazAMga anuttaropapAtikadazAMga kI noMdha meM bhI AyA hai| ina sUtroM meM sAdhuoM kAhI varNana hai, to kyA Apake sundara hisAba se sAdhuoM ke mandira yA sAdhuoM ke banAye jaina mandira artha hogA? kadApi nahIM / phira Age bar3hiye, vipAka sUtra kI noMdha lete hue duHkhavipAka ke viSaya meM bhI yahI batAyA gayA hai ki - "duha vivAgANaM NagarAiM ujjANAiM "ceiyAI" / " arthAt - duHkhAnta vipAkoM ke nagara, udyAna, caitya the / kahiye mitra! kyA una dukhAnta vipAka - anAryoM mlecchoM ke bhI jaina - Arhat mandira the, yA unhoMne bhI tIrthaMkara mandira banavAye the ? kyoMki pATha to sabhI jagaha isI taraha eka samAna hai, phira yahA~ Apa anAryoM ke Arhat mandira kyoM nahIM mAnate haiM? kintu haTha bhI to koI cIja haiN| yahA~ to Apa jina mandira nahIM mAnaMge, aura una Adarza zramaNopAsakoM ko jabaradastI mUrti pUjaka siddha karane ke lie vahA~ apanI icchA se hI anartha Thoka deMge, yaha sarAsara abhiniveza mithyAtva hai| hamAre itane kathana se ApakI samavAyAMga kI oTa to girakara cUra cUra ho gaI, aba hama ApakI lacara dalIla se upAsaka dazAMga ke

Page #166
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 121 ********Ci ***********Ban ******************** "arihaMta ceiyAI" pATha meM ke prakSipta arihaMta zabda kA bhI rahasyodghATana karate haiM dekhiye - yadi mUrti pUjakoM va Apake matAnusAra upAsaka dazAMga sUtra ke AnandAdhikAra meM "arihaMta ceiyAiM" zabhda hI hotA to ye loga ise chor3akara khAlI "ceiyAI" ke lie samavAyAMga kI ora nahIM lapakate? jo ki kevala nagarI ke varNana ke sAtha AyA hai??? ataeva siddha huA ki upAsaka dazAMga kA "arihaMta" zabda "kSepaka" hI hai| upAsaka dazAMga meM jahA~ nagarI ke varNana ke sAtha caitya zabda AyA hai vahA~ saba jagaha vyaMtarAyatana artha ko hI batAtA hai, dekhiye - "punnnnbhddeceie|kotttthggceie|gunnsileceie|" Adi ina sabhI caityoM se Apa kisI prakAra bhI jaina mandira yA tIrthaMkara mUrti artha nahIM kara skte| ataeva nivedana hai ki kRpA kara anartha karanA chor3a kara aura utsUtra bhASaNa kA prAyazcitta lekara AtmA ko bhArI pApa se bcaaiye| ve Adarza zramaNopAsaka kabhI bhI mUrti pUjaka nahIM the, na Apa yA Apake koI vidvAn unheM mUrti pUjaka siddha kara sakate haiN| (17) aMbaDa parivrAjaka aura mUrtipUjA ___ aupapAtika sUtra ke 40 veM sUtra meM ambar3a parivrAjaka kA caritra varNana kiyA gayA hai| usameM bhI Ananda zramaNopAsaka kI taraha lagabhaga milatA julatA eka pATha hai, jisako lekara hamAre mUrti pUjara bandhu zrI jJAnasundarajI ambaDa ko mUrti pUjaka ThaharAne kA prayatna karate haiN| ___ pAThakoM ko yaha smaraNa rakhanA cAhiye ki zrImad jambU svAmI ke

Page #167
122 aMbaDa parivrAjaka aura mUrti pUjA *******Li Li Li Li ****Li Li Li Li Li Li Li Li Li ***An An An An An An An **** nirvANa ke kucha varSoM ke bAda hI zithilAcAra ne jaina zramaNa samAja meM zanaiH zanaiH praveza karanA prArambha kara diyA, hote hote yahA~ taka sthiti bigar3I ki adhikAMza loga nAma ke sAdhu aura guNa se gRhasthoM se bhI kitanI hI bAtoM meM gaye gujare ho gaye, phira bhI susAdhuoM kA (jo ki bilakula svalpa saMkhyA meM raha gaye the) maMda-maMda pracAra jArI thA, jisase zithilAcArI logoM ko bhaya banA rahatA thaa| jaba ve kisI navIna paddhati ko zuru karate to unake mana meM yaha zaGkA uThA karatI ki kahIM bhakta loga suvihita sAdhuoM se hamArI pola nahIM jAnale, isaliye jahA~ taka ho sakA ve loga suvihita muniyoM kA una bhaktoM ko saMsarga hI nahIM hone dete, phira bhI ye loga pUrNa rUpeNa nirbhaya nahIM ho sake, kyoMki inheM AgamoM kA bhI bhaya thA, kabhI kisI ne pUcha liyA ki mahArAja Apa amUka prakAra kA AcaraNa karate haiM yaha kisa zAstrAnusAra hai? to isake liye bhI inheM taiyArI karanI thii| basa isI svArtha poSaNa ke liye AgamoM meM bhI hera phera aura nUtana prakSepa zuru huA, isa prakAra AgamoM kI asaliyata bigAr3ane meM svArtha pipAsu mahAnubhAvoM ne kucha bhI kamI nahIM kii| basa phira kyA thA, tIrthaMkara prabhu ke AgamoM kI sAkSI batAkara bhAgyazAlI bhadra bhaktoM se manacAhI kriyAyeM karavAI jAne lgiiN| isa prakAra kaI zatAbdiyoM ke lambe samaya taka hamArA Agama sAhitya zithilAcAriyoM ke kabje meM rahA, aura jaba dharma prANa loMkAzAha ne kriyoddhAra kara samAja kI sar3Ana ko dUra kiyA aura anAcAra varddhaka mUrti pUjA ko jainAgama viruddha ghoSita kiyA, taba lagabhaga 30-40 varSa bAda mUrti pUjaka vijayAdAna sUri ke hRdaya meM khalabalI maca gaI, inhoMne Agama zuddhi ke bahAne apanA pakSa majabUta karane ke lie aneka prakAra se kaI bAra pATha parivartana kiye| zrImAn lokAzAha ke svarga

Page #168
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ********************** gamana ke thor3e varSoM bAda phira se zithilAcAra ne jora pakar3A aura isI puNya pavitra AtmA ke vaMzajoM meM se kucha loga alaga nikalakara usI Dharre meM phira se phaMsa gye| jina mandira mUrtiyoM kA zrImAn lokAzAha ne AgamAdhAra se bahiSkAra kiyA thA, unhIM mandira mUrtiyoM kA usI yuga pradhAna ke vaMzaja apanI zithilatA aura svArtha poSaNa ke lie Adara karane lge| usa samaya zrImAn lokAzAha kA jo bhI kucha Agama sAhitya hogA vo bhI unhIM ke hAtha meM calA jAnA svAbhAvika hai / isa prakAra bahuta bar3e lambe samaya se sAhitya sAmagrI mUrti pUjaka aura zithilAcAra vAloM ke hAtha meM rhii| kriyoddhAra ke bAda hamAre sAdhumArgI jaina samAja ke pAsa jo bhI sAhitya sAmagrI Ane lagI vo unhIM logoM ke pAsa se / ataeva aisI sAmagrI se hI kAma calAnA pdd'aa| kucha varSoM se sAhitya kSetra meM bhI janatA kI ruci bar3hI, kaI anveSakoM ne prAcIna pratiyoM kI zodha kara zuddha saMskaraNa prakAzita kiye jisase bahuta samaya se ghusI huI kaI bhrAntiyAM dUra huii| jisa prakAra Ananda zramaNopAsaka ke adhikAra meM " arihaMta " zabda kA adhika bar3hAyA jAnAM siddha ho gayA, aura usa viSayaka bhrAnti dUra ho gaI, isI taraha isa aMbaDa adhikAra meM bhI kucha golamAla huA ho to Azcarya nahIM, kyoMki donoM kA yaha prakaraNa isa viSaya meM milatA julatA hai, aupapAtika sUtra kA ambar3a viSayaka pATha samyaktva zalyoddhAra pR0 85 meM zrI vijayAnanda sUri ne nimna prakAra se diyA hai - "aMbaDassa parivAyagassa nokappara aNNautthie vA, aNNautthiya devayANi vA aNNautthiya pariggahiyAiM arihaMta ceiyAI vaMdittae vA namasittae vA NaNaNattha arihaMte vA arihaMta ceiANi vA / " 123

Page #169
aMbaDa parivrAjaka aura mUrti pUjA aura AgamoddhAraka svargIya pUjya zrI amolakaRSijI mahArAja sAhaba ne bhI apane anuvAdita uvavAI sUtra pR0 163 meM aisA hI pATha diyA hai, kintu jaba hama Agamodaya samiti se prakAzita isI sUtra ke patra 67 ke dUsare pRSTha paM0 4 se isI pAThako dekhate haiM to hamArI isa pATha " viSayaka ukta zaGkA vAstavika mAlUma detI haiN| dekhiye vaha pATha 66 'ammaDassa No kappai aNNautthiyA vA aNNautthiya devayANi vA aNNautthiya pariggahiyANi vA ceiyAiM vaMdittaevA, NamaMsittae vA, jAva pajjuvAsittae vA NaNNattha arihaMte vA arihaMta ceiyAI vA / " isa pATha meM aura Upara batAye hue donoM pAThoM meM eka mahatvapUrNa antara hai, samyaktva zalyoddhAra aura haidarAbAda se prakAzita uvavAI meM ambar3a kI akalpanIya aura kalpanIya donoM pratijJAoM meM donoM sthAnoM para "arihaMta ceiyAI" pATha hai kintu Agamodaya samiti kI prati meM kevala eka hI sthAna para " arihaMta ceiyAiM" pATha hai, aura eka meM Ananda pATha kI taraha kevala "ceiyAiM" zabda hI hai| 124 ************ isI prakAra vikrama saM0 1664 meM sUrata se prakAzita uvavAI sUtra meM bhI pATha hai| isa para se spaSTa ho gayA ki ambar3a sambandhI ukta pATha meM kevala eka sthala para hI " arihaMta ceiyAI" pATha hai, donoM jagaha nahIM, sva0 pUjya zrI amolaka RSijI mahArAja sAhaba ne zAyada aisI hI prati kA anusaraNa kiyA, jo zuddha nahIM ho / astu, hamAre vicAra se yaha pATha aura bhI zodha khoja mAMgatA hai, kyoMki aba taka pUrI zodha nahIM ho sakI hai| jaba pUrI pUrI zodha hogI taba na

Page #170
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 125 ******************************************* jAne kitane hI gula khileNge| phira bhI uvavAI sUtra kA yaha pATha mUrti pUjA ko to sthAna detA hI nahIM hai, kyoMki ambaDa zramaNopAsaka ne isa pATha meM yahI pratijJA kI hai ki - "mujhe anyayUthika, anyayUthika deva, aura anyayUthika parigrahIta caitya ko vandanA namaskArAdi karanA nahIM kalpatA hai, kintu arihaMta aura arihaMta caitya ko vandanAdi karanA kalpatA hai" isameM akalpanIya niSedha pratijJA meM 1 anya yUthika 2 anyayUthika deva 3 anyayUthika parigrahIta caitya ko vandanAdi karanA chor3A hai so Ananda zrAvaka ke samAdhAna kI taraha sarvathA ucita hai, aura isa caitya kA artha sAdhu hI prakaraNa saGgata hai| (dekho Ananda prakaraNa) aura kalpanIya (AdaraNIya) pratijJA meM kevala do pada vaMdanIya rakkheM:- 1 arihaMta 2 arihaMta caitya, yahA~ arihaMta caitya kA artha sAdhu hI upayukta hai, kyoMki yadi yahA~ mUrti artha kiyA jAya to sabase bar3A prazna yaha hotA hai ki-kyA ambar3a ke lie arihaMta ke sivAya gautamAdi gaNadhara pUrvadhara aura labdhidhara Adi sAdhu sAdhvI vandanIya pUjanIya nahIM the? avazya the, kyoMki prabhu ne ambar3a ko zramaNopAsaka kahA hai, jo zramaNopAsaka hokara zramaNavarga kI sevA bhakti nahIM kare vaha zramaNopAsaka hI kaisA? yadi pakSapAta vaza Apa "arihaMta caitya" kA artha mUrti karo to basa ambar3a ke lie kevala arihanta aura unakI pASANamaya pratimA hI vandanIya rahI, gaNadhara aura sAdhu sAdhvI nahIM aura isa prakAra vaha zramaNopAsaka hI nahIM rhaa| ataeva kutarka aura anartha karanA chor3a dIjiye, aura ambar3a ko pASANa mUrti ke bajAya prabhu ke jIte jAgate caitya (smAraka) sAdhu bhagavantoM ko vandanA namaskAra karane vAlA mAnakara use mUrti upAsaka kI apekSA zAstrAnusAra zramaNopAsaka hI rahane diijiye| yahA~ hama prakaraNocita eka do prazna kara lenA bhI ucita samajhate haiM ___

Page #171
126 tuMgikA ke zramaNopAsaka ****************************************** (1) sundara mitra ne pR0 76 meM arihaMta zaraNa zabda meM hI arihanta mUrti mAnalI, aura Age calakara eka sthala para tIrthaMkara gotra ke 20 boloM meM prathama bola arihanta pada ArAdhana meM hI unakI mUrti ko bhI sammilita kara liyA, taba hama inheM kahate haiM ki - bhagavan! yahA~ bhI yahI cAla caliye n| jisase arihanta pada meM hI Apa apane santoSa ke liye unakI mUrti bhI mAnalo, isase dUsarA arhan caitya pada sAdhuoM ke lie svatantra raha jAya, isa taraha ApakA bhI hisAba ThIka baiTha jAya, yAne ambar3a jinopAsaka ke sAtha mUrti upAsaka bhI ho sake, aura zramaNopAsaka bhii| isase unakI zramaNopAsakatA to nahIM mArI jAya, kaho utarI gale? (2) kyoM bhagavan! khAlI "caitya' zabda ho usakA artha bhI jinamUrti aura "arihanta caitya" ho usakA bhI artha jinamUrti, yaha gar3abar3AdhyAya kaisA? kucha spaSTa to honA cAhie? yadi arihanta caitya se hI jinamUrti artha hotA ho to binA arihanta ke jahA~ sirpha "caitya" zabda hI ho vahA~ to yaha aDaMgA nahIM lagAnA cAhie? kahiye hai mnjuur| mahAnubhAva! jaba taka hArdika saralatA nahIM lAoge taba taka AtmakalyANa kadApi nahIM hone kaa| yAda rakhiye ApakA yaha "marudhara kesarI' pana kahIM saMsAra meM rulAne vAlA nahIM bana jaay| (18) tuMgikA ke zramaNopAsaka zrImad bhagavatI sUtra za0 2 u0 5 meM tuMgiyA nagarI ke zramaNopAsakoM kA varNana hai| jisakA saMkSipta sAra yaha hai ki eka bAra tuMgiyA nagarI meM bhagavAn pArzvanAtha ke ziSya sthavira bhagavAn 500

Page #172
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ***************** zramaNa parivAra sahita padhAre jaba tuMgiyA ke zrAvakoM ne ye samAcAra sune to harSita hue, aura valikarma Adi karake sthavira bhagavanta kI sevA meM upasthita hue / sevA bhakti ke pazcAt saMyama tapa Adi viSaya meM prazna pUche, sthavira bhagavantoM ne samAdhAna kiyA, zrI gautamasvAmIjI ne isa viSayaka prabhu mahAvIra se praznottara kiye| 127 ****** isa varNana meM una zrAvakavargoM ke lie yaha likhA hai ki ve sthavira bhagavan kI sevA meM upasthita hue jaba pahale snAna " balikarma" kiyA aura vastrA'laGkAra paridhAna kara phira ghara se nikleN| ukta prakaraNa meM snAna ke sAtha jo "balikarma" zabda AyA hai usI ko lekara hamAre mUrti pUjaka bandhu una zramaNopAsakoM ko mUrti pUjaka batA rahe haiM aura zrI jJAnasundarajI ne bhI apane mUrti pUjA ke itihAsa ke cauthe prakaraNa pR0 86 meM likhA hai ki - " Atma kalyANa kI abhilASA rakhane vAle ve zrAvaka khAsa tIrthaMkaroM kI mUrti kI hI pUjA karate the itanA hI kyoM para zrAvakoM ke to aise aTala niyama bhI hote haiM ki ve binA tIrthaMkaroM kI pUjA kiye mu~ha meM anna jala taka nahIM lete haiN| isa prakAra manamAnI lekhanI calAkara bholI janatA ko bhrama meM phaMsAne kA prayatna kiyA hai| bar3e Azcarya kI bAta hai ki jahA~ eka bUMda pAnI nahIM ho vahA~ mahAsAgara hone kA niSphala jhAMsA (dhokhA ) dete ina mahAnubhAvoM ko kucha bhI saMkoca nahIM hotA, pAThakoM ko sAvadhAna hokara socanA cAhie ki-balikarma zabda jo ki snAna zabda ke sAtha hI AyA hai, aura jo snAna kI vistRta vidhi ko saMkSipta meM batAne vAlA hai| kevala isI se tIrthaMkara mUrti kI pUjA karanA kaise siddha ho sakatA hai? pAThakoM

Page #173
128 tuMgakA ke zramaNopAsaka ************************************** ko samajhane meM saralatA ho isa kAraNa isI zabda viSayaka ubhaya mAnya AgamoM ke kucha pramANa uddhRta kiye jAte haiM, yathA (1) jJAtAdharma kathAMga sUtra a0 2 meM dhanya sArthavAha kI patnI subhadrA santAna prApti ke lie nAga deva kI pUjA karane ko puSpa, gaMdha, mAlA aura alaGkArAdi pUjA sAmagrI lekara apane ghara se nikalI, aura rAjagRhI nagarI ke madhya meM hotI huI puSkaraNI bAvar3I para AI, bAvar3I para Akara pUjana sAmagrI ko vahIM kinAre para rakha diyA phira pAnI meM utara kara jala maJjana kiyA, snAna " valikarma" kiyaa| bAda meM pAnI se gIlI sAr3I sahita nikalI aura pUjA ke liye kamala aura patra grahaNa kara bAhara aaii| vahA~ se pUjana sAmagrI jo vaha ghara se lAI thI uThAkara nAga ghara meM gaI aura nAgadeva kI pUjA kI / ukta prakaraNa para dIrgha dRSTi DAlane se sahaja hI mAlUma ho sakegA ki balikarma artha- deva pUjA nahIM hai| yadi aisA hI hotA to bhadrA puSkariNI meM praveza karane ke pUrva pUjA sAmagrI bAhara rakhakara puSkariNI meM kyoM jAtI aura jalakrIr3A karate hue binA pUjana sAmagrI ke kisa prakAra kara sakatI ? yahA~ yaha spaSTa ho jAtA hai ki balikarma snAna vizeSa hI hai / bhadrA ne pUjana sAmagrI bAhara rakhakara bAvar3I meM jAkara snAna balikarma kiyA aura bAda meM bhIge vastra sahita puSpa patra tor3e phira rakhI huI pUjana sAmagrI lekara nAga ghara meM gaI aura pUjA kii| yahA~ eka bAlaka bhI samajha sakatA hai ki pUjana aura balikarma paraspara eka nahIM para bhinna bhinna haiM / jaina AgamoM meM jahA~ snAna kA kathana hai vahA~ bahutasI jagaha "hAyA kayabalikammA" ye zabda sAtha hI Aye haiM, ataeva isa prakAra Aye hue balikarma kA matalaba snAna kI vistRta vidhi ko saMkSipta batAnA hI hai yaha pramANa spaSTa kara detA hai ki pUjA aura balikarma bhinna vastu hai / -

Page #174
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ************************ ( 2 ) isI jJAtA dharmakathA sUtra ke 8 veM adhyayana meM bhagavatI mallikumArI ke viSaya meM likhA ki ve snAna kara yAvat bahuta khojI ke sAtha kuMbharAjA ke samIpa AI yahA~ bhI yAvat zabda se balikarma kA bhI grahaNa hotA hai| jisakA artha mUrti pUjA kisI bhI sUrata meM nahIM ho sakatA, kyoMki arhan prabhu gRhasthAvasthA meM rahane para bhI na to kisI deva ko namaskAra karate haiM aura na kisI mUrti kI pUjA hI karate haiN| ataeva isakA mUrti pUjA artha asatya hI tthhraa| (3) uktaH sUtra ke 16 veM adhyayana meM dropadI ke viSaya meM bhI aisA hI pATha hai aura sAtha hI yaha likhA ki dropadI majjana ghara meM gaI vahA~ snAnAdi kara vastra pahine, phira vahA~ se jinaghara gaI aura mUrti pUjA kii| yahA~ dropadI ne snAna balikarma pahile va mUrti pUjA bAda meM kii| isa para se bhI bilakula spaSTa ho gayA ki snAnagRha (gusalakhAne) meM dropadI ne snAna vizeSa hI kiyA thA, mUrti pUjA nhiiN| kyoMki snAnagRha koI mandira yA mUrti kA sthAna to thA hI nahIM aura dropadI ne to snAna balikarma karane ke bAda vastra pahine aura phira vahAM se pUjA karane gaI / 126 ***** zrI sundarajI dropadI ke viSaya meM yaha yukti lagAte haiM ki yahA~ " kayabalikammA" se matalaba - "gharaderAsara kI pUjA karane se hai" para yaha kathana bhI mithyA hai kyoMki yahA~ "ghara derAsara" kA to koI jikra hI nahIM hai| kyA mUrti pUjaka loga gusalakhAne meM hI "ghara derAsara" rakhate haiM? kyoMki dropadI ne majjana ghara meM praveza karane ke bAda snAna balikarma kiyA aura vastra pahine phira bAda meM majjana ghara se niklii| isase to inake hisAba se gusalakhAne meM hI mandira honA cAhie? kyA kutarkoM kA bhI kucha ThikAnA hai? (4) rAyapaseNaiya suta meM kezIzramaNa munirAja ne pradezI rAjA

Page #175
tuMgakA ke zramaNopAsaka ****************************************************** ko kahA ki "jaba tU snAna balikarma karake deva pUjane ko jAve" yahA~ snAna aura balikarma ke bAda deva pUjana batalAyA isase bhI spaSTa huA ki balikarma devapUjA nahIM hai, devapUjA isase bhinna hai ataeva siddha huA ki snAna zabda ke sAtha AyA huA balikarma zabda snAna ke vistAra ko hI batAne vAlA hai| 130 (5) isI sUtra meM Age calakara kezIkumAra zramaNa ne pradezI ko vana jIvI * logoM kA dRSTAnta diyA, usameM batAyA ki ve loga vana meM kaSTa lene gaye, vahA~ bar3I aTavIM meM unhoMne snAna balikarma kiyaa| yadi yahA~ bhI devapUjA kaho to isa para se yaha prazna hotA hai ki jaMgala meM unhoMne kisa kI pUjA kI ? vahA~ kisI mandira mUrti kA honA to saMbhava hI nhiiN| kyoMki yaha eka bar3I aTavI hai, ataeva kayabalikammA kara artha yahA~ bhI snAna vizeSa hI hai| (6) dazAzrutaskandha sUtra kI dazavIM dazA meM yaha ullekha hai ki jaba zreNika rAjA aura cillaNa devI ke rUpa saundarya ko sAdhusAdhviyoM ne dekhA to ina donoM ke aizvarya vaibhava aura sukhopabhoga ke prati unakA dhyAna AkarSita huA ve apane mana meM usake sukhopabhoga kA smaraNa isa prakAra karane lage. - 'Azcarya hai ki zreNika rAjA atyanta aizvarya sampanna hokara sampUrNa sukhoM kA anubhava karane vAlA hai aura snAna balikarma kautuka maGgala aura prAyazcita kara saba taraha ke AbhUSaNoM se bhUSita ho cillaNAdevI ke sAtha sarvottama kAma bhogoM ko bhogatA huA vicaratA hai / hamane aisA devoM meM bhI nahIM dekhA / yadi hamAre tapa saMyama kA phala ho to hameM bhI bhaviSya meM aise uttama bhoga prApta ho / " * vana kI lakar3iyoM ko beMcakara AjIvikA karane vAle /

Page #176
- jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 131 ***************************************** ukta ullekha meM kevala sukhopabhoga sambandhI hI varNana hai isameM dharma vyavahAra yA AcArAdi viSayoM ko kicit bhI sthAna nahIM kintu yahA~ bhI snAna ke sAtha "balikarma" zabda AyA hai, isa para se eka sAdhAraNa se sAdhAraNa buddhi vAlA bhI samajha sakatA hai ki isa viSaya meM deva pUjA artha karane vAle kevala matamohI hI haiN| kyoMki snAna balikarma kara vastrAlaGkAra se vibhUSita ho rAnI ke sAtha bhoga bhogane meM deva pUjA kA sambandha hI kyA? yahAM deva pUjA to eka mUrkha bhI nahIM maantaa| (7) isI prakAra vipAka sUtra ke dUsare adhyayana meM rAjA ke snAna balikarma karane ke bAda vezyAgamana karane ke lie jAne kA ullekha hai aura a0 4 meM suseNa pradhAna kA bhI aisA hI ullekha hai, ina sthaloM para vicAra karane se bhI ina mUrti pUjaka bandhuoM kA kiyA anartha prakaTa ho jAtA hai, inheM itanA bhI bhAna nahIM ki- deva-pUjA aura vezyA-gamana meM kyA sambandha? snAna vizeSa to sarvathA ucita hai, kyoMki snAna to svabhAva se hI kAmoddIpaka hai| ___isa prakAra ukta pramANoM para vicAra karate marudhara kezarI mahAnubhAva kI havAI dIvAra ekadama TUTa jAtI hai| sundara mitra svayaM jAnate hoMge ki jahA~ snAna kA vistRta varNana hai vahA~ to isa kayabalikammA (balikarma) zabda ko sthAna hI nahIM milA hai| jisake lie aupapAtika sUtra meM samrATa koNika kA vistRta snAnAdhikAra aura jambUdvIpa prajJapti meM cakravartI mahArAjA bharatezvara kA snAna varNana, jaina janatA meM prasiddha hai aura jahA~ snAna ko saMkSipta meM hI batAyA hai vahIM prAyaH snAna balikarma kahA hai, phira pakSapAta meM par3akara kyoM anartha karate haiM? jabaki inake TIkAkAra bhI inhIM tuMgiyA ke zramaNopAsakoM ke "balikarma' ko balikarmayai 'svagRha devatAnAM' kahakara gRhadeva kI pUjA karanA batAte

Page #177
tuMgikA, ke zramaNopAsaka ********************************************** 132 - %D " HTETTE TRY haiN| jisakA matalaba gRha sambandhI sAMsArika deva se hai, na ki tIrthaMkara kI mUrti vAle ghara derAsara se| isa viSaya meM eka do pramANa bhI lIjiye (1) mUrti pU0 muni vIraputra zrI AnandasAgarajI ne sva anudita vipAka sUtra pR0 300 meM 'kayabalikamma' kA artha nimna prakAra se likhate haiM - "gRha sambandhI deva pUjana kI" (2) bhagavatI sUtra ke isI varNana meM balikarma kA artha bhASAMtarakAra y. pUjaka dina SHROONLOD jAna radAsa prakAra se gotra'devI neM pUjana karI" (khaMDa 1 pR0 276) (3) aura isI khaMDa ke pIche diye hue koSa ke pR0 361 kaoNlameM 2 meM balikarma zabda kA artha "gRha-gotra devI - pUjana" kiyA hai!(4) isake alAvA svayaM suMdara mitra (Apa) ne hI apane isa pothe ke 86 veM pR meM tuMgiyA ke zramaNopAsakoM ke viSaya meM bhargavI kA pATha dekara usakA TabbArthaH diyA, usameM bhI balikarma kA artha "ApaNA gharanA devatA ne kIdhA balikarma jeNe likhA hai| jaba mUrti pUjaka mata se hI baMlikarma artha-gRha (sAMsArika) deva kI pUjA hotA hai taba sundara bandhu ise tIrthaMkara kI mUrti pUjA meM kyoM ghasITate haiM? kyA mUrti moha ke prabala asara se hI? sundara mitra yahA~ eka yukti lagAte haiM ki - "tuMgiyA nagarI ke zrAvaka apane dharma meM itane dRr3ha zraddhA vAle the ki kisI Apatti kAla meM bhI kisI deva dAnava kA smaraNa na ko arthAt sahAyatA nahIM icche, isa hAlata meM yaha kahanA kahA~ taka ThIka hai ki binA, kisI Aphata aura apane pUjyAcArya deva ke vandana samaya tuMgiyA nagarI ke zrAvakoM ne kula devI kI pUjA kI arthAt yaha kahanA sarAsara anyAya evaM asaMgata hai|" Tag:

Page #178
*** jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA .133 ***** *********** zrI sundarajI kI yaha yukti bhI anucita hai, kyoMki sUtra meM jo 'asaheja devAsura nAga" Adi pATha kahA hai, usakA to yaha matalaba hai ki ve nirgrantha pravacana meM pakke Astika the, unheM dharma se DigAne ko devadAnavAdi bhI samartha T ye nahIM the, a aura na kisI kI sahAyatA cAhate the, tathA karma pariNAma ko mAnane vAle the| isa pATha se sAMsArika vyavahAra ko adA karane meM koI bAdhA nahIM haiM aise zramaNopAsaka bhI gRhasthAvasthA meM rahane ke kAraNa pUrva paramparAnusAra sAMsArika devoM kI pUjA kare yaha svAbhAvika bAta hai| isase inakI samyaktva ko kisI prakAra kI bAdhA nahIM hotI dRr3ha samyakttrI Avazyaka saMsAra vyavahAra adA karate hue bhI apanI samyaktva ko surakSita rakha sakate haiN| kucha pramANa bhI lIjiye - (1) bharata cakravartI mahArAjA ne dRr3ha samyaktvI hote hue bhI cakraratna, guphA, dvAra Adi kI pUjA kii| aura devoM kI ArAdhanA kirane ke lie tapa kiyaa| (2) zAMti, kuMthu, araha, ina tInoM tIrthaMkaroM ne cakravatIpana meM bharata kI taraha paristhiti ke anusAra cakraratnAdi kI pUjA kii| (3) araka zramaNopAsaka ne nAvA kI pUjA kI, aura bali bhI cddh'aaii| (4) abhayakumAra ne dhAriNI devI kA dohana pUrNa karane (laukika kAryArtha) telA kiyaa| (5) kRSNa vAsudeva ne bhI apane choTe bhAI kI utpatti ke lie tapazcaryA kara devArAdhana kiyaa| ye pramANa to gRhastha samyaktvI zrAvakoM ke haiM, kintu mUrti pUjaka sAdhu to mUrti ke kAraNa zithila hokara sAdhu dharma ke viparIta avirati devoM kA smaraNa, dhyAna, stuti, namaskArAdi karate haiM, dekhiye -

Page #179
134 ********* siddha kii| tuMgakA ke zramaNopAsaka (6) zrI hemacandrAcArya ne - (ka) padminI rAnI ko nagna khar3I rakhakara usake sAmane vidyA (yogazAstra prastAvanA) **** (kha) ziva-zaMGkara kI stuti kI / (pra0 ca0 ) (ga) rAtri ko upAzraya se nikala kara zahara ke bAhara gaye aura deva deviyoM ko bala bAkula car3hAye / (pra0 ca0 ) (7) jinadatta sUri Adi aneka AcAryoM ne devArAdhana kara camatkAra btaaye| (8) vartamAna ke caturtha stuti mAnane vAle sabhI sAdhu sadaiva pratikramaNa meM donoM samaya avirati devoM kI stuti kara sAhAyya mA~gate haiN| jaba mUrti pUjaka sAdhu hI munidharma ke viparIta deva sAhAyya kI prArthanA karate haiM taba gRhastha kare usameM bAdhA hI kyA ho sakatI hai ? hama to kevala yahI kahate haiM ki kisI taraha kI sahAyatA mAMge binA bhI sAMsArika Avazyaka vyavahAra ko adA karane ke liye samyaktvI zrAvaka gRhadeva kI pUjA kare to usameM usakI samyaktva ko koI bAdhA nahIM hai, aura isa prakAra yadi Apake TIkAkAra aura anya vidvAnoM ke matAnusAra una zrAvakoM ko sAMsArika gRha devatA kI pUjA karane vAle bhI mAne jAye to bhI Apako to nirAza hI honA par3atA hai, kyoMki ApakI tIrthaMkara mUrti ko pUjane kA to vahA~ kiJcit mAtra bhI AdhAra nahIM hai, phira kutarkI banakara utsUtra prarUpaNA karake kyoM AtmA ko bhArI banAyA jA rahA hai? kyA parabhava se ekadama nirbhaya ho gaye ? sundara mitra ! jo bhI Apake vidvAnoM ne balikarma kA artha gRhadeva pUjA kiyA hai, kintu yaha artha bhI sabhI jagaha saMgata nahIM ho sakatA,

Page #180
135 jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA Zu *************Hao **************************** kyoMki aise kaI prakaraNa haiM, jahA~ snAna vizeSa artha hI hotA hai, jo hama pahale likha cuke haiM, saMkSepa meM phira bhI dekhiye - (1) bhadrA sArthavAhI ne pahale jalAzaya meM jala krIr3A kI, snAna balikarma kiyA, phira pUjana sAmagrI lekara pUjA kI, ataeva devapUjA aura balikarma bhinna bhinna huaa| (2) tIrthaMkara kisI kI bhI mUrti nahIM pUjate aura bhagavatI mallikumArI ne balikarma kiyA, ataeva yaha bhI snAna vizeSa hI hai| (3) draupadI ne prathama snAnagRha meM snAna balikarma kiyA, bAda meM vahA~ se nikala kara deva pUjA karane gaI, yahA~ donoM kI paraspara bhinnatA Apake mata ko bAdhaka hai| (4) kezI zramaNa ne prathama snAna balikarma, aura bAda meM deva pUjana ke liye jAne kA kahA, yaha spaSTa Apako viphala manoratha ThaharAtA hai| ___ (5) vanajIvI logoM ne bhArI jaGgala meM snAna balikarma kiyA, aise araNya meM mandira mUrti ke abhAva se ApakA artha asaMgata ThaharatA hai| (6) sukhopabhoga ke varNana meM jahA~ ki deva pUjA kI kiJcita bhI AvazyakatA nahIM, isa zabda kA prayoga huA, yaha pratyakSa Apako haThavAdI batalAtA hai| (7) vezyAgamana ke pahale snAna balikarma to saMgata ho sakatA hai para deva pUjA to nAma mAtra ko bhI nhiiN| ataeva yahA~ bhI balikarma kA artha snAna vizeSa hI smjho| (8) isake sivAya kaI sthAnoM para snAnagRha (gusalakhAne) meM praveza kara snAna balikarma karane, aura phira vastra pahinakara bAhara nikalane kA varNana milatA hai| isase bhI yahI siddha hotA hai ki balikarma artha

Page #181
136 tuMgikA ke zramaNopAsaka ******************************Li ***Ke Lai Ping Ping Ping Ping Ping Ping deva pUjA nahIM kyoMki balikarma snAnagRha meM kiyA jAtA hai jahA~ ki deva mUrti yA mandira kA koI sambandha nhiiN| - isa prakAra balikarma artha se gotra devatA ke pUjana kA artha bhI asaMgata ThaharatA hai| Apa hI ke samAja ke vidvAn paM0 becaradAsajI dozI kI jinhoMne pahale bhagavatI sUtra meM yahI artha kiyA hai ve bhI abhI isa artha meM sandeha karate haiM, dekhiye unake hAla hI ke (saM0 1964 ke) anuvAdita aura zuddha kiye hue "rAyapaseNaiya sutta no sAra" pR0 26 kA phuTa noTa naM056 - "koI gRhastha jJAnI pAse dharma sAMbhalavA jAya ke rAja darabAra mAM jAya tyAre "balikarma' karIne jAya-evA aneka ullekhoM jaina AgamoM mAM vidyamAna che, paNa e balikarma zuM che? te sambandhI spaSTa mAhitI malatI na thI, "pota potAnA gRhadevo pAse bali caDAvavI-nivedya dhara-bheMTa dharavI" evo balikarma no artha TIkAkAre Apelo che, AmAM "gRha devatA" koNa ane teno zuM svarUpa-e prazna ubho rahe ch|' isa prakAra gRha devatA kI pUjA karane kA artha svayaM Apake vidvAnoM ko hI zaGkAspada hai, taba aisI sUrata meM aura hamAre Upara batAye hue pramANoM se Apake kutarka kA unmUlana hokara mUrti pUjA kI saiddhAntika kamajorI spaSTa hone meM khAmI hI kyA hai? - cAlU prakaraNa meM sundara mitra kI eka yukti para thor3A sA vicAra kara lenA Avazyaka samajhatA huuN| Apane isI prakaraNa ke 87 veM pRSTha meM likhA ki - "snAna ke bAda pIThI (tela ATA mizrita mAliza) karI xxx kyA koI samajhadAra vyakti snAna karane ke bAda mAliza karate hoMge? kadApi nhiiN|" . jo hamAre vicAra se bhI yaha yukti kucha upAdeya mAlUma huI, kintu

Page #182
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 137 .. ..... vizeSa vicAra karane para yaha bhI pAyA gayA ki zAyada samaya samaya kI bhinna bhinna pravRttiyA~ ho, kisI samaya kisI vastu kA upayoga pahale hotA ho, aura kisI samaya pIche, Aja bhI bahuta se aise haiM jo snAna ke bAda zira meM tela DAlakara malate haiM, aura bahuta se snAna ke pUrva hii| isa taraha vicAra kara hI rahe the ki hamArI dRSTi zrI dazAzrutaskandha ke eka pATha para par3IM, jisase hamArI dhAraNA majabUta huI, dekhiye vaha pATha "savvAo kasAya-daMta kaTu-pahANa-maddaNavilevaNa" Adi (dazA 6) yahA~ prathama snAna aura phira mardana aura bAda meM vilepana batalAyA hai, isa sUtra pATha se to sandeha hI nahIM rahatA aura hamArI dhAraNA ko hI puSTi milatI hai ki pUrvakAla meM isa prakAra kI bhI prathA thI, zAyada isake par3ha lene se sundara mitra kI zaGkA bhI dUra ho jAyagI? hamArA sundara mitra se yahI kahanA hai ki - bhAI! bilakula "kezarI' (?) hI mata bana baittho| mithyA prapaJcoM dvArA jAla phailAkara bhoMdU bher3iyoM meM kezarI kahalAnA koI bar3I bAta nahIM hai, Apa to kyA Apake saikar3oM vidvAnoM kI bhI zakti nahIM, jo mUrti pUjA ko dharmakRtya aura Agama AjJA yukta siddha kara sake isa prakAra kathAoM aura zabdoM kI mithyA oTa lene se samajhadAroM ke sAmane ApakA pAkhaNDa kisI bhI taraha Thahara nahIM sktaa| are, jisa kriyA ko dharma kA mukhya aGga kahA jAya, jo varddhamAna bhASita batAI jAya, usake liye usI ke pracAraka varddhamAna AjJA kA eka zabda bhI nahIM batAkara idhara udhara hAtha paira paTakeM, yaha kitanA nirbalatA aura nirlajjatApUrNa haThadharmitA haiN| kyA aba bhI sundara mitra sIdhe mArga para AyeMge?

Page #183
138 cAraNa muni aura mUrtti pUjA ***************************** (19) cAraNa muni aura mUrtti pUjA *********** bhagavatI sUtra za0 20 u06 meM bhagavAn zrI vIra prabhu se zrI gautama svAmIjI prazna karate haiM ki "jaMghAcAraNa, vidyAcAraNa muniyoM kI tiryaggati kI zakti kitanI hai ?" usake uttara meM prabhu ne pharamAyA hai ki " vidyAcaraNa muni eka utpAta meM mAnuSottara parvata para samavasaraNa kare aura vahA~ caitya vaMdana karake dUsare utpAt meM nandIzvaradvIpa meM samavasaraNa kare, vahA~ caitya vaMdana kara svasthAna Ave aura caitya vaMdana kare / " Adi isa varNana meM se zrI jJAnasundara jI caitya vandana zabda ko pakar3a karamUrti - pUjA siddha karanA cAhate haiM aura likhate haiM ki - " yAtrArtha cAraNa muni gaye hoM aura anya bhavyoM ke yAtrA karane ke bhAvoM meM vRddhi ho, isa garaja se zAstrakAroM ne isakA varNana kiyA ho to yaha hai bhI yathArtha kAraNa zakti ke hote hue tIrthayAtrA karanA kyA sAdhu aura kyA zrAvaka saba kA yaha prathama karttavya hai / isI uddezya ko lakSa meM rakhakara asaMkhya bhAvukoM ne bar3e-bar3e saMgha nikAla kara yAtrA kI hai / " Adi ( pR015) prathama to yaha bAta hI mithyA hai ki- "koI cAraNa muni yAtrArtha gaye hoM" kyoMki sUtra meM to kevala zakti kA paricaya batAyA hai, yaha nahIM likhA ki koI muni vahA~ mUrti pUjA karane yA vaMdanA namaskAra karane gayA ho / ulTA sUtra meM to isa prakAra apanI zakti kA upayoga karane (labdhi phor3ane ) gale ko AjJA bhaMjaka kahA hai, para yadi koI sunI huI ko dekhane kI icchA se AjJA viruddha bhI zakti kA durupayoga karake

Page #184
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ************** jAve aura binA AlocanA pratikramaNa ke kAla kara jAve to use bhagavad AjJA kA virodhI batalAyA hai| jaba bhagavatI ke isa prakaraNa se hI aisI pravRtti ke lie niSedhAtmaka dhvani nikalatI hai taba sundara mitra kA ukta kathana to sApha jhUTha hI ThaharatA hai ki - " anya bhavyoM ke bhAvoM meM vRddhi ho aura ve yAtrA karane jAyaM, isa garaja se zAstrakAra ne vaha varNana kiyA" aise sIdhe sAdhe prakaraNa ko hI ulTA batAne lage, unheM kisa prakAra samadRSTi mAnA jAya? mahAnubhAva sUtra meM Aye hue "ceiyAI vaMdaI" kA bhAvArtha bhagavad stuti se he, mUrti vaMdana se nahIM, caitya vaMdana bhI stuti kA dUsarA artha hai| dekhiye 136 ******* "jekara mUrti na mile to pUrva dizA kI taraha mukha karake vartamAna tIrthaMkaroM kA caitya vaMdana kare / " (vijayAnaMda sUri li0 jainatattvAdarza pR0 301 ) isa prakAra bhAva tIrthaMkaroM ke parokSa vaMdana ko bhI caityavaMdana kahA hai aura bhagavatI sUtra ke ukta prakaraNa kA bhI yahI Azaya hai| jisa prakAra mUrti pUjaka sAdhu upAzraya meM rahe hue prAtaH sAyaM donoM samaya pratikramaNa meM caitya vaMdana karate haiM vaha bhI binA mUrti ke parokSa vaMdana hI hotA hai isI prakAra ukta prakaraNa ke lie bhI aisA mAna lenA nyAya saMgata hogA / hamArI isa yukti se mU0 pU0 AgamoddhAraka zrI sAgarAnaMda sUrijI bhI sahamata hote hue apane "siddhacakra" varSa 7 aGka 2 tA0 23-10-38 ke pR0 36 ke "sAgara samAdhAna" zIrSaka se likhate haiM ki - "jaMghAcAraNa Adi munioM paNa naMdana Adi mAM namutthuNaM Adi thI bhAva jina AdinA vaMdano kare che / / "

Page #185
140 NOTE mAna AramAtta pajA BALLAH . . . ...- ATE kahiye aba to utarI gele? yadyapi Age calakara inhIM sUrijI ne mUrti vaMdane ko bhI likhA hai aura yahA~ bhI Adi zabda rakhakara apanI guMjAisa rakhalI hai tathApi hamArI yukti ko puSTa karane meM ukta mantavya paryApta haiN| isake sivAya Apane bhI pR0 102 meM nimna prakAra se likhA hai ki - "zAyada RSijI jJAnI ke guNAnuvAda ko caitya vaMdana hI samajhate hI kyoMki caityaM vadana meM bhI unhIM jJAnI tIrthaMkaroM ke guNAnuvAda hI Ate haiM to yaha to ThIka bhI hai, vidyAcAraNa, jaMghAcAraNa munivaroM ne naMdana vana, pANDaka vana, nandIzvara, rucaka, mAnuSottara aura svasthAna (jahA~ se gaye the) ke mandiroM meM jAkara caitya vaMdana (jJAnI tIrthaMkaroM kA guNAnuvAda) kiyA thA, isameM hamArA matabheda bhI nahIM hai|" pAThaka samajha gaye hoMge ki tIrthaMkara stuti kI caityaM vandana sundara mitra ne bhI mAnA hai, jo ki hamArI yukti kA pUrNa rUpa se Adara hai| ukta avataraNa maiM sundara mitra ne jo yaha likhA ki "mandiroM meM jAkara" . ....... . ya n : ... yAtanA yaha li mitra kAma kyAki mUla meM kahIM bhI aise zabda nahIM hai ki "cAraNa muni mandiroM meM jAkara caitya vaMdana kareM" aMtaevaM aisI kapola kalpanoM para adhika likhane kI AvazyakatA hI nhiiN| ___ isake sivAyaM mAnuSottara parvata aura rucaka parvata para to zAzvatI mUrtiye bhI nahIM haiM aisI sUrata meM mUrtiyoM ko vaMdane ko jAne kI ApakI dalIla Thahara hI kaise sakatI hai? aura jahA~ zAzvatI mUrtiye haiM, ve devoM ke AdhIna hokara unhIM ke pUjanIya haiM, kyoMki ve unhIM se sambandha rakhatI haiM, arthAt unhIM ke vaMza paramparA se pujAtI huI devamUrtiyeM haiM, tIrthaMkara pratimA nhiiN| (adhika spaSTatA ke lie sUryAbha prakaraNa dekhoM) sayret - ....--. - . . .

Page #186
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ataeva yaha bAta bhI asaMgata huI, hamAre vicAra se vahA~ jAne kA mukhya kArama naMdanavanAdi kI saira karane kA hI ho sakatA hai kyoMki yaha bhI eka chadmasthatA kI palaTatI huI caMcala vicAradhArA kA pariNAma hai, jaba koI muni jahA~ jAkara vana kI saira kara vizrAma lete hoM, taba yaha socanA svAbhAvika hai ki vAstava meM jJAniyoM ne ina sthAnoM kI jo racanA batAI hai vaha yathAtathya hai| isa prakAra sarvajJa ke prati vizeSa zraddhA honA aura isase vahA~ stuti kA bhI honA saMbhava hai| isa prakAra isa prakaraNa kA bhAva pAyA jAtA hai jo ki aisA karane vAloM ko AjJA bhaMjaka batAne vAle sUtra se sphuTa ho jAtA hai| yadi koI yahA~ yaha yukti de ki vaha AlocanA mArga doSa-nivRtti kI hai, to yaha bhI ThIka nahIM kyoMki sUtra meM spaSTa " tassa ThANassa aNAloiya" kahA hai, jisakA artha " usa sthAna kI AlocanA nahIM karane se hai, na ki mArga-doSanivRtti se / ataeva siddha huA ki yaha kriyA hI AjJA viruddha hai| isake sivAya isI prakaraNa para se Apa yaha likha baiThe haiM ki - zakti hote hue tIrthayAtrA karanA kyA sAdhu aura kyA zrAvaka sabaikA yaha parama kartavya hai| isI uddezya ko lakSa meM rakha kara asaMkhya bhAvukoM ne bar3e-bar3e saMgha nikAla kara yAtrA kI hai| ( pR0 65) hA~ calAte jAIye, khUba car3hA car3hA kara bhole bhAvukoM ko pahAr3oM meM bhaTakAiye, isI meM guru logoM kI pau bAraha hai, manamAne mAla ur3AnA isI meM milatA hai| mahArAja! aisI dharma karaNI to bhagavAn mahAvIra bhI DR. My - nahIM batA sake, kintu mitra sundrjii| yahA~ to Apa cAraNa muniyoM ke sahAre se yAtrA karanA aura saMgha nikAla kara nAyaka banane kA phala nikAla rahe haiM, para mejharanAme" meM Apane yaha kyA likha diyA 141 31 ********

Page #187
cAraNa muni aura mUrti pUjA ***** pAchaladIdhuM thApa // 21 // "te vakhate saMgha nahIM kahyo, pAsatthAe ho? (mejhara nAmA DhAla 23) kahiye mitra ? yaha kyA mAjarA hai? eka sthAna para to Apa ( pR0 65 meM) saMgha nikAla kara yAtrA karane kI preraNA karate haiM ise pavitra kArya batAkara isameM lAbha honA bhI likhate haiM aura mejharanAmeM meM svayaM Apa hI saMgha nikAlane kI pravRtti ko nUtana aura zithilAcAriyoM kI calI huI batAte haiM, yaha kyA bAta hai ? kyA yahIM mUrti kI sthApanA karate-karate mattamoha meM masta to nahIM ho gaye ki jisase apanI pUrva bAta kA dhyAna hI na rahA? vAstava meM pakSapAta manuSya ke jJAna kA lopa kara detA hai| 142 Age calakara isI 65 veM pRSTha para sthAnAMga sUtra kA udAharaNa dekara yaha likhate haiM ki - " isa pATha meM jina pratimAoM kA nAma RSabha, varddhamAna, candrAnana aura vAriseNa jo tIrthaMkaroM ke zAzvata nAma haiM unhIM tIrthaMkaroM kI mUrtiyA~ batalAI haiM jinake nAma kI mAlA evaM jApa hamAre sthAnakavAsI bhAI hamezA karate haiM unhIM kI mUrtiyoM ko vandana namaskAra karane meM ve loga zaramAte haiM yahI to eka Azcarya kI bAta hai arthAt ajJAna kI bAta hai|" sundara mitra ne yahA~ bhI khUba prapaJca racA hai kyoMki inakA yaha likhanA ekadama jhUTha hai ki - sthAnakavAsI devaloka sthita mUrtiyoM ke nAma kI mAlA phirAte haiM yadyapi sundara mitra yaha jAnate haiM ki sthAnakavAsI samAja ina zAzvatI pratimAoM ko tIrthaMkara kI honA nahIM mAnatA, aura na tIrthaMkara kI mUrti ke nAma kI mAlA hI phirAI jAtI hai phira bhI isa prakAra inakA likhanA, mAyAyukta mithyA hokara janatA ko bhramajAla meM phaMsAne ke duSTa abhiprAya se ota prota hai|

Page #188
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA sundara mitra ! zarama to Apa logoM ko AnI cAhiye, jo mokSa prApta tIrthaMkaroM ko bhI sacitta jala, phala, phUlAdi car3hAne aura mUrti ke Age mAthA ragar3avAne kI mUrkhatA pradarzita karate haiN| hameM zaramAne kI AvazyakatA hI kyA? hamato aisI lajjAjanaka kriyA se sarvathA dUra hI rahate haiM / *** 143 isake sivAya Apane dvIpasAgara pannati kA uddharaNa dekara sAtha hI yaha bhI samAdhAna kara diyA ki ThANAMga sUtra meM isakA ullekha haiM, aura isa viSaya meM yaha bhI likhA hai ki Apa apane pUrvaja lokAgaccha ke yatiyoM se prazna kreN|" Adi mahAnubhAva! Apako sthAnAMga sUtra kA pramANa dene kA kaSTa uThAne kI AvazyakatA nahIM aura na isa pramANa se Apa hameM dvIpasAgara pannati ko mAnane kA Agraha hI kara sakate haiM kyoMki yadyapi sUtrollikhita sabhI zAstra hameM mAnya haiM, tathApi hama isalie ina sUtroM ko sampUrNa rUpa se pramANita nahIM mAnate haiM ki inameM samaya ke phera se aniSTa parivartana bahuta huA hai, ye zAstra jaise pahale the, vaise isa samaya nahIM rahe, isa viSaya meM Age calakara eka svatantra prakaraNa se hama vizeSa rUpa se smjhaaveNge| Apa hara jagaha loMkAgacchIya mUrti pUjaka yatiyoM ke arthoM ko pramANa meM dete haiM tathA unheM hamAre pUrvaja batAte haiM yaha ApakI pUrI sajjanatA hai jabaki hama yaha siddha kara cuke aura sabhI jAnate haiM i vartamAna loMkAgacchIya yati zrImAn lokAzAha ke vaMzaja nahIM para usa dharmavIra ke siddhAnta se ekadama bahiSkRta haiN| kyoMki usa puNyAtmA kI zraddhA mUrti pUjA meM bilakula nahIM thI, aura ye loga mUrti pUjaka haiN| phira aise logoM kA (jo Apake hI samAna haiM) sahArA lenA aura zuddha sAdhumArgI kriyApAtra muniyoM ko unake vaMzaja batAnA, dina dahAr3e DAkA DAlane ke samAna hai| duniyA jAnatI hai ki sthA0 samAja ke

Page #189
144 draupadI aura mUrti pUjA .. susAdhuoM kI barAbarI ke gRhastha jaise yati to kyA para ApakI samAja ke sAdhu bhI nahIM kara sakate, phira ApakI yaha sajjanatA (?) eka rAjapUtra ko DAkU ke vaMzaja kahane ke barAbara hai| Apake isa sajjanatA pUrNa vyavahAra ke lie Apako bArabAra dhanyavAda (?) hai| ..... sundara mitra! mUrtimoha meM masta hokara mAyAcAra kA sevana mata kro| ye mUrtiye Apako hargija tArane vAlI nahIM haiN| yadi AtmakalyANa priya hai to isa mAyA ko hRdaya se nikAlakara samabhAva pUrvaka saMyama pAlana kro| anyathA parabhava meM pazcAttApa karanA pdd'egaa| (20) draupadI aura mUrti-pUjA zrI jJAnasundarajI ne cauthe prakaraNa ke pR0 103 se satI draupadI ko arhat pratimA pUjane vAlI batAkara hameM bhI mUrti pUjA karane kI preraNA sAtha hI satya ko dabAne kI koziza bhI kii| kintu janatA kI jAnakArI ke liye hama draupadI kA pUrva sambandha saMkSepa meM batAkara bAda meM vastu sthiti ko spaSTa kreNge| isa kAraNa "zrI jJAtAdharma kathAMga sUtra ke 16 veM adhyayana meM vistAra pUrvaka kathana hai ki - "dharmaruci nAma ke tapodhanI mahAtmA ko mAsika tapazcaryA ke pAraNe ke dina nAga zrI nAma kI brAhmaNI ne kaTu tumbikA ke halAhala samAna AhAra bhiraayaa| jisake sevana se una mahAn tapodhanI ko dAruNa vedanA hokara unake prANa pakheru ur3a gye| tapasvI hatyA ke kAraNa nAgazrI ke pati ne use ghara se nikAla diyaa| nAgazrI bhikhAriNI huI aura azubha karmodaya se bhayaMkara rogiNI banakara mRtyu pAkara naska meM mii| laraka sambandhI mahAn vedanA ko bhogatI huI aura

Page #190
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA anekoM bhava karatI huI, bhaTakatI bhaTakatI manuSya bhava ko prApta huI / vahA~ sukumAlikA nAmakI bAlikA ke nAma se pahicAnI jAne lagI, duHkha se duHkhI ho cAritra grahaNa kiyA, kucha hI samaya bAda cAritra se patita hokara zithilAcAriNI bnii| guruNI ne sukumAlikA AryA ko apane se pRthak kara diyaa| isa prakAra cAritra virAdhanA karatI huI eka bAra eka vezyA ko pAMca puruSoM ke sAtha krIr3A karate dekhakara yaha nidAna kiyA ki "yadi merI karaNI kA phala ho to maiM bhI isI prakAra pA~ca pati ke sAtha vipula bhoga bhogatI huI vicarU~" / isa prakAra nidAna kara binA AlocanA prAyazcitta liye virAdhikA ho mRtyu prApta kara svarga meM gii| vahA~ se draupadI pane utpanna huI / yauvanAvasthA ke prApta hone para usake liye svayaMvara racA gyaa| usa samaya snAnAdi se nivRtta hokara jina ghara gaI, vahA~ jina pratimA kI pUjA kara svayaMvara maNDapa meM gii| nidAna ke prabhAva se aura sabhI rAjA mahArAjAoM ko chor3akara pANDava putra ke gale meM varamAlA DAlakara pA~coM bhAiyoM kI patnI bnii| isa prakAra draupadI kA saMkSipta kathAnaka hai| isameM "kevala jina pratimA kI pUjA kI" itanA mAtra hone para binA hI kucha soca vicAra kiye ye loga mUrti pUjA siddha karane cale haiM isa viSaya meM ina bhAiyoM kI ora se sAmane AtI huI nimna bAtoM para vicAra karanA hai| 1. draupadI zrAvikA thI / 2. draupadI kI pUjI huI pratimA tIrthaMkara kI thI / 3. draupadI ne namutthuNaM se stuti kI thI / khAsakara ukta tIna yuktiyA~ hamAre sAmane prastuta kI jAtI haiM, aura hamase draupadI kI jaise pUjA karane kA anurodha kiyA jAtA hai aba hama tInoM yuktiyoM para krama se vicAra karate haiM. - 145 ***

Page #191
146 draupadI aura mUrti pUjA . ... kyA draupadI vivAha ke samaya zrAvikA thI? draupadI ke sukumAlikA AryikA bhava ke nidAna aura usase hone | vAle phala vipAka para yadi sUkSma dRSTi DAlI jAya to mAlUma hogA ki draupadI vivAha ke pUrva zrAvikA hone ke yogya nahIM thI, kyoMki vaha pUrva bhava meM bhoga lAlasA kI itanI icchuka huI thI ki usane kor3I ke lie ratna beca dene kI taraha bhoga kAmanA kI pUrti ke liye cAritra rUpI dhana kI kamAI ko kho DAlA thA aura usI kAmanA se marakara devaloka meM gaI, punaH manuSyabhava pAkara draupadI pane utpanna huI yahA~ usakA nidAna (pUrva kAmanA) pUrNa hone kA thaa| jaina Agama ke jAnakAra bhalIbhAMti samajhate haiM ki - nidAna vAle jIva kA jaba taka nidAna pUrNa nahIM ho jAya (phala nahIM mila jAya) taba taka vaha samyaktva se vaMcita-jainadharma se dUra-hI rahatA hai, hA~ yadi maMdarasa kA nidAna ho taba to vaha phala prApta hone ke bAda dharma ke sammukha ho sakatA hai, para binA phala prApti ke to sammukha nahIM ho sktaa| idhara vivAha ke samaya bhI draupadI ke viSaya meM zAstrakAra likhate haiM ki "puvvakaya niyANeNa coijamANi' arthAt pUrva kRta nidAna se prerita huI ataeva vivAha ho jAne ke pUrva hI draupadI ko zrAvikA kahane vAle jaina Agama se anabhijJa hI kahe jA sakate haiN| isake sivAya samakitasAra ke racayitA zrImad jyeSThamallajI mahArAja sAhaba apane isI grantha meM likhate haiM ki "ogha niyukti sUtra kI AcArya zrI gaMdha hastikRta TIkA meM draupadI ko eka saMtAna prApti ke bAda samyaktva prApta honA batAyA hai" isase bhI yahI siddha hotA hai ki

Page #192
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ******************** ********** vivAha ke pazcAt jaba draupadI kA pUrvakRta nidAna pUrNa ho jAtA hai, taba vaha jinopAsikA hone ke yogya banatI hai| vivAha ke pUrva draupadI kI mAnasika sthiti vyakti ke jIvana vRttAnta se hI usakI yogyatA kA patA laga jAtA hai| draupadI ke sukumAlikA bhava ke nidAna aura draupadI ke bhava meM usakI pUrti para vicAra karane se hI yaha spaSTa mAlUma ho jAtA hai ki draupadI kI mAnasika sthiti vivAha ke pUrva dharma ke sammukha hone yogya nahIM thii| sajJAna - yauvana avasthA meM praveza karate hI pUrva saMskAra ke udaya se vaha vipula sukha bhoga kI abhilASiNI huI ho, yaha bilakula svAbhAvika hai aura usI ke phala svarUpa eka sAtha vaha pA~ca pati kI patnI banI, basa isI bAta kA vicAra karane vAlA draupadI ko kaumArya jIvana meM hI zrAvikA mAnane kI bhUla nahIM kara sakatA / aura sociye puruSa ke adhika patniyoM kA honA to AgamoM se bhI mAlUma ho sakatA hai, para kisI ne kisI bhI prAmANika Agama meM yaha par3hA ki kisI zrAvikA ne eka sAtha eka se adhika pati banAye hoM ? to isakA uttara nakArAtmaka hI hogaa| ataeva draupadI kA eka sAtha pA~ca patiyoM kA varaNa karanA hI spaSTa batA rahA hai ki vaha bhoga * lAlasA ko bahuta samaya se aura adhika pramANa se cAhane vAlI honI cAhiye / isa prakAra pakSapAta rahita ThaMDe mastiSka se vicAra kiyA jAya to yahI tathya nikalegA ki - draupadI ke pUrva saMskAra hI aise the ki jisake kAraNa vaha sajJAna hote hI vipula evaM vistIrNa bhogoM ko prApta karane kI icchuka huI / aisI sthiti meM vivAha ke pUrva sAdhAraNa taura para bhI dharma ke sammukha honA kaThina hai, taba nidAna rUpa karma se AcchAdita - 147 -

Page #193
draupadI aura mUrtti pUjA huI AtmA ke lie to kahanA hI kyA ? spaSTa huA ki vivAha ke pUrva draupadI jinopAsikA hone ke yogya nahIM thI / (2) 148 kyA draupadI ne tIrthaMkara pratimA kI pUjA kI thI ? jaba yaha spaSTa ho cukA ki - pANigrahaNa ke samaya draupadI samyaktva se rahita thI, taba yaha samajhanA ekadama sahaja ho gayA ki usakI pUjI huI mUrti bhI tIrthaMkara kI mUrti nahIM thii| kyoMki tIrthaMkara ko deva mAnakara to samyaktvI hI vandate pUjate haiM, taba prazna yaha upasthita hotA hai ki - draupadI kI pUjI huI mUrti ko "jina pratimA " sUtra meM hI batAyA hai, phira isa jina pratimA ko tIrthaMkara kI pratimA nahIM mAnA jAya to kisakI mAnI jAya? isake samAdhAna meM kahA jAtA hai ki - 'jina' zabda ke kaI artha hote haiM, jinameM se kucha hama sUryAbha prakaraNa meM de cuke haiM, vahA~ zrI hemacandrAcArya ke hemI nAma mAlA kA eka yaha bhI artha hai ki "kaMdarpopi jinozcaiva" arthAt kaMdarpa- kAmadevako bhI jina kahate haiM aura yaha artha isa prakaraNa meM bilakula upayukta hai kyoMki draupadI ko nidAna prabhAva se kAmadeva hI adhika rucatA thA vaise kAmadeva ko bhI jina kahA jAya to yaha bhI eka dRSTi se yogya hI hai kyoMki isakI upAsanA karane vAle ananta jIva haiM, ananta prANiyoM para isakA adhipatya hai| yahA~ taka ki pazu pakSI se lekara manuSya aura deva taka isake vazIbhUta haiM bar3e bar3e RSi muni bhI isake jhapeTe ko sahana karane meM azakta Thahare, adhika jAne dIjiye / svayaM mUrti pUjA ke prAcIna itihAsa ke lekhaka zrI jJAnasundarajI (Apa) bhI isake prabhAva meM aise pha~se ki bahuta se sadgRhasthoM ko bhI mAta kara diyA jisake lie

Page #194
146 ... jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA ********************Xue Chan Xue Xue Zhu Xue ************** aneka ghaTanAoM meM se kevala eka "prema ke jharane' vAlI ghaTanA to suprasiddha hai| basa isI ke jhapeTe meM draupadI bhI A cukI thI, so bhI isa bhava se hI nahIM, kintu para bhava se, aisI dazA meM pUrva saMskAroM ke udaya se draupadI isa jina (kAma) deva kI mUrti kI pUjA kare to yaha sarvathA sambhava hai isalie eka prAcIna pramANa bhI dekha liijiye| vijaya gaccha ke zrI guNasAgara sUri ne vikrama samvat 1672 meM "DhAla sAgara" nAma ke eka kAvya grantha kI racanA kI, usake khaMDa 6 DhAla 115 ke dohe meM draupadI ke pUjanIya ArAdhya deva kA khulAsA isa prakAra hai - "kari pUjA "kAmadevanI" bhAMkhe drupadI naar| deva dayA karI mujhane bhalo dejo bhrthaar||8||" ukta dohe se hamAre kathana kI acchI taraha se puSTi ho gaI, yaha mantavya vAstava meM prakaraNa ke anusAra hai, yadi yahA~ yaha artha na mAnA jAya to batAiye aisA kaunasA sthala hai jahA~ zrI hemacandrAcArya kA jina zabda kA kAmadeva artha upayukta ho sake? . isa viSaya meM sundara mitra ne eka tarka yaha bhI uThAyA hai ki kAmadeva to anaMga hai, phira anaMga (aGga rahita) kI mUrti kaise banAI jA sake? yaha zaGkA ThIka hai, para yadi saMsAra vyavahAra para jarA dRSTi DAlI jAya to yaha zaGkA bhI nahIM rahane pAtI, Apa yaha to jAnate haiM ki siddha arUpI hai phira bhI mUrti pUjaka unakI bhI mUrti banAte haiN| jainI loga jinavANI ko sarasvatI kahate haiM, phira bhI Apake mUrti pUjaka loga sarasvatI kI bhI mUrti banAte dekhe gaye haiM, isI prakAra kAmadeva kI bhI mUrti bane to sandeha nahIM, ajI sandeha kisa bAta kA? satya hI hai, icchA ho to eka pramANa bhI lIjiye - ww

Page #195
150 draupadI aura mUrti pUjA ***Jing *****Kong ****Ben Kong ************** ******** mathurA ke myujiyama meM kaMkAlI TIle se nikalI huI prAcIna mUrtiyoM meM kAmadeva kI bhI eka mUrti hai| isake viSaya meM "mathurA ke saMgrahAlaya meM" nAmaka paricaya pustikA ke citra paricaya pR0 15 paM0 1 se citra naM0 20 ke paricaya meM likhA hai ki - "20 bhagavAn kAmadeva yA kusumAyudha kI miTTI kI mUrti (naM0 2661) puSpa mAlyAbharaNoM se alaMkRta puSpita bhUmi meM khar3e hue kAmadeva ke dAhine hAtha meM paMcabANa aura bAMye meM kodaNDa hai|" basa aba Apako aura kyA cAhie? vizvAsa na ho to svayaM padhArakara darzana kara aaiye| ApakI zaGkA dUra ho jAyagI aura Apa bhI zAyada draupadI ke viSaya meM apane vicAra badalakara usakI pUjA ko tIrthaMkara pUjA nahIM maaneNge| lagna prasaMga meM mUrti pUjA kA kAraNa sundara bandhu ne isI pustaka ke mUrti pUjA viSayaka praznottara pR0 271 meM likhA hai ki - "lagna jaise raGga rAga ke samaya bhI apane iSTa ko nahIM bhUlI to dUsare dinoM ke lie to kahanA hI kyA thaa| dharmI puruSoM kI parIkSA aise samaya hI hotI hai|" Adi ... isa prakAra draupadI ke lagna prasaMga kI pUjA ko dharma bhAvanA yukta batalAte haiM kintu inheM jarA vicAra karanA cAhiye ki - eka to draupadI nidAna karmavAlI thI dUsare nidAna karma ke kAraNa prabala bhoga icchA vAlI thI, aura aisI lambe samaya kI icchita kAmanA ke pUrNa hone kA samaya bhI usI dina kA thA, aisI hAlata meM bhalA kauna vicAraka draupadI ko usa samaya dharma bhAvanA vAlI kaha sakegA? saMyoga aura saMskAra hI

Page #196
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 151 ****************************************** use usa samaya bhoga bhAvanA vAlI siddha kara rahe haiM, aura isI ke calate draupadI ne bhAvI akhaMDa saubhAgya aura pracuratA se bhoga sAmagrI milane kI kAmanA se hI pUjA kI hai, tathA aisI kAmanA kAmadeva jaise se hI kI jA sakatI hai, dharmadeva se nhiiN| ataeva siddha huA ki draupadI kI pUjI huI mUrti tIrthaMkara kI nahIM thii| vivAha prasaMga ke samaya kAmadeva kI sthApanA va pUjA pahale pracuratA se hotI thii| eka pramANa mUrti pUjaka zrI vardhamAna sUri ke saM0 1468 ke race hue AcAra dinakara kA dekhiye - "para samaye gaNapati kandarpa sthaapnN| gaNapati kandarpa sthApanaM sugamaM lokprsiddhN|" (vibhAga 1 vivAha vidhi patra 33) draupadI vivAha ke pUrva parasamaya-ajaina thii| aura para samaya meM vivAhotsava para kandarpa pUjA pahale bahutAyata se sarvatra hotI thI yaha isa pramANa se siddha ho gyaa| itanA hI nahIM pratiSThA jaise dhArmika kahe jAne vAle kRtya meM bhI kaMdarpAdi ko yAda kiyA gayA hai| dekho AcAra dinakara vibhAga 2 pratiSThA vidhi| isake sivAya jarA loka vyavahAra ko bhI dekhiye - . mAlavA, mevAr3a, mAravAr3a Adi prAntoM meM yaha rivAja hai ki vivAhotsava ke prArambha se hI ajaina aura mithyAdRSTi aise devoM kI pUjA vara aura vadhU donoM ora se kI jAtI hai, mAlave prAnta meM vivAha ke prArambha meM hI kumhAra ke ghara mahilAe~ dhUmadhAma se jAtI hai aura usake cAka (baratana banAne ke cakra) kI pUjA karatI haiM ukarar3I (kUr3e karkaTa kA Dhera) Adi kI pUjA vara vadhU se karAI jAtI hai| gajAnana ke citra

Page #197
152 draupadI aura mUrti pUjA **************************************Y ke sammukha vara vadhU ko biThA kara pANigrahaNa vidhi karAI jAtI hai, varavadhU ko grAma devatA bhairava bhavAnI, caMDI, zItalA, hanumAna, nAga, bhUta Adi kI pUjA vandanAdi karanI par3atI hai| aura isa prakAra jaina mandiroM meM bhI jAte haiM, ina sabakA pradhAna kAraNa dAmpatya jIvana sukhamaya evaM vRddhimaya hone kI bhAvanA hI hai, anya nhiiN| ApakI jaina vivAha paddhati se tIrthaMkara mUrti sthApana kara usakI pUjA karake vivAha kiyA jAya, to bhI isameM dharma kA koI khAsa sambandha nhiiN| yaha saba sAMsArika kArya hai, kyoMki ina pUjAoM meM yAcanA mukhyataH sAMsArika sukhoM kI hotI hai| jaisA ki AcAra dinakarakAra ne jaina vivAha vidhi meM vidhAna kiyA hai| aisI kriyAyeM mUrti pUjA meM dharma nahIM mAnane vAle vara vadhU bhI pracalita rUr3hi ke kAraNa karate haiM, aisI kriyAyeM vartamAna meM hI hotI hai, aisA nahIM smjheN| balki pUrvakAla meM bhI prakArAntara se kisI na kisI rUpa meM hotI thii| gajasukumAra ke pANigrahaNa ke liye saumila havana ke lie jaGgala meM lakar3I lene gayA thA aura bhI Agamollikhita kathAnaka vivAha ke samaya havana hone kI rUr3hi ko batA rahe haiM aura AcAra dinakarakAra kandarpAdi pUjA kA ullekha karate haiN| ina sabakA dharma se koI khAsa sambandha nahIM hai, ye saba saMsAra kAmanA se otaprota haiM, Apa svayaM aise prasaMga ko rAgaraGga kA samaya batA rahe haiM, bhalA aise samaya aura vaha bhI draupadI jaisI nidAna karmavAlI arthAt pradhAna bhoga prApti kI kAmanA vAlI yuvatI ke lie dharma bhAvanA kA honA kaise mAnA jA sakatA? jabaki usI samaya pUjA ke bAda ke pATha meM hI draupadI kI mAnasika avasthA ko batAne vAlA sUtra pATha draupadI ko "puvvakaya niyANeNaM coIjamANi' batAkara use bhoga kAmanA vAlI ghoSita kara rahA hai, taba ApakI yukti Thahara hI kaise sakatI hai? siddha huA ki draupadI kI

Page #198
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ********************************************* pUjA se dharma kA koI sambandha nahIM thA aura isa prakAra draupadI kI pUjI huI mUrti bhI tIrthaMkara kI nahIM thI / (3) kyA draupadI ne namutthu se stuti kI thI? draupadI ko zrAvikA aura usakI pUjI huI mUrti ko tIrthaMkara pratimA siddha karane ke lie zrImAn sundarajI ne eka dalIla yaha bhI peza kI ki "draupadI ne usa mUrti kI namutthuNaM ke pATha se stuti kI, aisA jJAtA sUtra ke mUla pATha meM spaSTa likhA hai| isase draupadI kA zrAvikA aura pratimA kA arhan pratimA honA svataH siddha hai|" isake samAdhAna meM kahA jAtA hai ki - 153 mahAzaya ! yaha to Apa bhI isI pustaka ke pR0 25 meM svIkAra kara cuke haiM ki hamArI vistIrNa sAhitya sAmagrI kAlabala se AkramaNakAriyoM dvArA bahuta kucha naSTa ho gaI isake bAda Apako yaha bhI samajhAyA jAtA hai ki jo bhI sAhitya bacakara rahA thA vaha samaya kI viSamatA ke kAraNa zithilAcArI, caityavAsI yA caityavAdI yatiyoM ke adhikAra meM rahA, vaha samaya suvihitoM ke lie to itanA nikRSTa thA ki kitane hI zaharoM aura gAMvoM meM ye yati loga una cAritra pAtra saMyatoM ko Ane hI nahIM dete the, yadi koI bhUlA bhaTakA sAdhu udhara A jAtA to bhArI zahara meM bhI unheM Thaharane ke lie sthAna hI nahIM milatA / yati loga unheM bahuta taMga karate, isa viSaya meM eka do pramANa bhI dekhiye (1) Avakhate pATaNa mAM caityavAsiyoM nuM prAbalya hatuM te eTalA sudhI ke temanI saMmati sivAya suvihita sAdhu pATaNa mAM rahI na hotA ( prabhAvaka caritra paryAlocanA pR0 85) sakatA / -

Page #199
154 draupadI aura mUrti pUjA ******************************************* (2) zrIpattana (pATaNa) mAM caityavAsI AcAryoM suvihita sAdhuoM ne tyAM rahevA na detAM vighna kare che| (prabhAvaka caritra bhASAMtara pR0 256) isa prakAra yati logoM ne suvihitoM para bhArI julma kiyA thA, itanA hI nahIM inake julma se Agama sAhitya bhI vaMcita nahIM raha ske| isameM bhI una logoM ne icchita parivartana kara diyA, Apa svayaM apane "mejharanAme" kI 22 vIM DhAla meM likhate haiM ki - "ajita zAMti nA aMta mAM, gAthA ho? milAvI saath| gA0 15 maMditu sUtra siddha daMDake, jayavIyarAya ho gAthA dIdhI bhel| gA0 17 pratyakSapATha siddhAMta mAM, te lopI ho? mAne kalpita / gA0 25 isa prakAra sUtroM meM bhI kaI prakAra kA parivartana kara DAlA hai phira bhI kucha kucha yati loga zithila hote hue bhI AgamoM ko jaise ke taise rakhane ke vicAra vAle bhI the| unake pAsa jo pratiyeM rahIM ve to zAyada zuddha raha sakI hoM, para svArthI aura matamohI ke pAsa vAlI pratiyoM meM avazya gar3abar3a huI hai, prastuta viSaya meM jJAtA dharmakathAMga ke draupadI sambandhI namutthuNaM Adi pATha bhI kAla bala se mUla meM jA virAjA hai, Aja vartamAna samaya meM bhI jJAtA sUtra kI prAcIna pratiyeM upalabdha hai, jinameM ki namutthuNaM Adi pATha bilakula nahIM hai| yaha bAta kevala hama hI kahate haiM aisA nahIM samajheM, kintu svayaM Apa hI ke mUrti pUjaka TIkAkAra zrI abhayadeva sUri draupadI sambandhI pUjA ke pATha kI TIkA karate hue likhate haiM ki - "jiNa paDimANaM accaNaM kareiti" ekasyAM vAcanAyA metAvadeva dRzyate "vAcanAntaretu" Adi dekha liyA sundarajI? Apa hI ke TIkAkAra mahAzaya kevala bAraha akSara vAle pATha ko hI mUla meM sthAna dekara bAkI ke lie

Page #200
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA 155 vAcanAntara meM honA likhakara TIkA hI meM rakhate haiM, mUla meM nahIM aura prAcIna pratiyeM bhI yahI batAtI haiM ki ina bAraha akSaroM ke sivAya mUla pATha meM namutthuNaM yA sUryAbha sAkSI Adi kucha bhI nahIM hai phira mUrti pUjA ke raMga meM raMge hue mahAnubhAvoM ke prakSipta kiye hue adhika pATha ko pramANa meM dekara apanA mata dUsaroM para lAdanA yaha kahA~ kA nyAya hai? vAstava meM dekhA jAya to loMkAgacchIya yatiyoM ne aura Agamodaya samiti ke AgamoddhAraka ne draupadI viSayaka namutthuNaM Adi adhika pATha mUla meM bar3hAkara Agama kI asaliyata ko bigAr3ane ke alAvA apane hI TIkAkAra ke maMtavya kA virodha kiyA hai / sundara mitra ! hamArI samAja ne namutthuNaM Adi pATha nikAlA nahIM, para mUrti pUjakoM ne hI mUla sUtra meM adhika bar3hA diyA hai ataeva ApakA tarka itane mAtra se TUTa gyaa| isake sivAya Apane isa viSaya meM hamArI ora ke zrI majyeSTamallajI mahArAja aura zrI harSacandajI mahArAja kI pustakoM kA pramANa dekara NamotthuNaM Adi pATha kI asaliyata siddha karane kA prayatna kiyA hai, aba usa para vicAra karate haiM - samakita sAra kA pATha hama pahale batA cuke haiM ki hamArA sAhitya bar3e lambe samaya se mUrtipUjaka yatiyoM ke hAtha meM rahA aura zrImAn lokAzAha ne jaba mUrti pUjakoM ko vIradharma rahita ghoSita kiyA taba AgamoM meM bhI mUrti pUjakoM ko pheraphAra karane kI AvazyakatA dikhAI dI aura parivartana kara bhI DAlA / isake bAda suvihita - susAdhuoM kI vRddhi kA samaya AyA, jisa nikRSTa kAla meM ye mahAnubhAva nAma mAtra ke thor3e se raha gaye the / ye 1

Page #201
156 draupadI aura mUrti pUjA ***Ding *Ben *************Kong ***********Nian *****Ben Ben Zhong phira samaya kI anukUlatA se adhika parivAra vAle hote gaye aura jaina zAsana kA (zramaNa saMgha kA) sRSTi meM prabhAva bar3hAte gye| aise samaya AvazyakatA par3ane para jaisI Agama pratiyeM inheM milI, unhIM se kAma calAte gye| pAThaka bhUle nahIM hoMge ki aisI pratiyoM meM adhikatA unhIM yatiyoM ke hathakaMDoM se dUSita huI pratiyoM kI thI, basa unhIM para vizvAsa rakhakara kArya calAnA pdd'aa| zrI majyeSThamallajI mahArAja ne samakitasAra meM bhI aisI hI kisI dUSita prati kA upayoga kiyA haiM kyoMki prAcIna pratiyoM aura TIkA se yaha to siddha ho gayA ki mUla pATha meM namutthuNaM Adi adhika pATha nahIM hai| eka taTastha mUrti pUjaka bhI prAcIna pratiyoM aura TIkA ke dekhane para yahI nirNaya degA ki-vAstava meM namutthuNaM Adi pATha pIche se bhUla meM milAyA gayA hai phira yaha mAnane meM zaGkA hI kyA hai ki majyeSThamalajI mahArAja ne kisI dUSita prati kA hI upayoga kiyA ho? mitra sundarajI! ApakA samAdhAna to samakitasAra kA dUsarA bhAga hI kara detA hai Apa jarA A~kha kholakara nimna avataraNa ko par3hiye - "pUjA karavA gaI te ThekANA no pATha eka ghaNI muddata nI lakhAelI jJAtAjI nA mUla pATha mAM to nIce lakhavA mujaba che - "jiNa paDimANaM accaNaM karei kareittA" "e pATha sivAya mUla mAM namotthuNaM yA caityavaMdana yA pradakSiNA yA tikkhutto ityAdika sUriyAbha devanI bhalAmaNano kiMcita pATha nathI, kAraNa ke dillI zahara mAM udayacandajI jati che temanI pAse chaso varasa nuM jJAtA sUtra lakhAeluM che temaja kanaiyAlAlajI gRhastha pAse ghaNA varaso Upara lakhAelI junI jJAtA che, te be sUtro no pATha paraspara malato che, eTaluMja nahIM paNa te sUtro tyAMja hAjara che, mATe AkAMkSA vAlA

Page #202
157 jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA Li ********** ********************Ben **** oe joi levaM, tyAra pachI nI lakhAvaTa mAM AvelI thor3A varasoM nI jJAtAjI nI prato mAM AvaDo phera thayo che, to temAM thayelo pheraphAra kalpita saMbhave che|" (samakitasAra bhAga 2 pR0 38) aura dekhiye - "valI A ThekANe kahevAnu je jJAtAjI nI navI prato mAM vAcanAMtare draupadI nA adhikAre namotthuNaM no pATha jovA mAM Ave che, parantu zrI bharuca zahera nA bhaMDAra mAM tADapatra Upara lakhelI jJAtAjI savA ATha se varasanI che te madhye paNa kayabalikammA nA praznottara mAM lakhyA pramANe pATha che, mATe junA pustako nA AdhAra thI mAlama par3e che ke vizeSaNa pATha che te kalpanAkarI nAkhyo jaNAya ch|" (samakitasAra bhAga 2 pR0 51) ukta samakitasAra bhAga 2 ke ullekha se yaha spaSTa ho gayA ki prathama bhAga meM zrI majyeSThamallajI mahArAja ne jo pATha diyA hai, vaha prakSipta pAThavAlI jJAtA se hI diyA hai aura bAda meM anveSaNa se jo prAcIna pratiyeM unheM milI haiM, usa para se una mahAnubhAva ne dUsare bhAga meM isakA spaSTIkaraNa kara diyA hai, isase to zrI majmeSThamallajI mahArAja ke zuddha evaM satyamAnasa kA paricaya milatA hai una mahAtmA ne prathama jaisA dekhA vaisA hI likha diyA, usameM apanI ora se kucha bhI nyUnAdhika nahIM kiyA aura jaba bAda meM unheM mAlUma huA ki pahale jo pATha diyA hai vaha ThIka nahIM hai, to satya mAlUma hone para pUrva ke pATha kA nirAkaraNa kara diyaa| sundara bandhu! vAstava meM prAcIna pratiyoM meM "namutthuNaM' Adi adhika pATha nahIM hai| maiMne svayaM dillI meM lAlA mannUlAlajI agravAla ke pAsa jJAtA sUtra kI prAcIna prati dekhI, jo bahuta jIrNa thI, usameM ApakA batAyA huA adhika pATha hai hI nahIM aura yaha vahI prati hai

Page #203
158 draupadI aura mUrti pUjA **Hui ********Ben ***************Ben Qiu Xue Li **Ben Shu Zhong jisakA ullekha samakitasAra bhAga-2 meM kiyA gayA hai| isake sivAya kizanagar3ha (rAjapUtAne) meM bhI eka prAcIna prati hai usameM bhI namutthuNa Adi varddhita pATha nahIM hai| isa para se Apako samajha lenA cAhie ki samakitasAra prathama bhAga meM diyA huA pATha azuddha hai| isa para se ApakA abhiSTa siddha nahIM ho sktaa| zrImAn harSacandrajI ma. ke nAma se jhUThA pracAra isake sivAya Apane zrImAn harSacandrajI mahArAja likhita "zrImad rAjacandra vicAra nirIkSaNa" nAmaka pustaka kA kucha avataraNa dekara draupadI viSayaka namutthuNaM pATha siddha karanA cAhA hai, yaha bhI ApakA prapaMca mAtra hai kyoMki zrImAn harSacandrajI mahArAja ne to vahA~ draupadI kI mUrti pUjA ko dharma mAnane kA spaSTa rUpa se khaNDana kiyA hai tathA usI pRSTha meM kucha hI Age bar3hakara yaha spaSTa rUpa se likhA hai ki - "paNa e jagyAe jJAtA sUtra mAM draupadI nA adhikAre hAlanI keTalI pratioM mAM thor3o pATha prakSepa thayo hoya ema keTalIka junI pratioM mAM jotAM mAlUma par3e ch|" (zrImad rAjacandra vicAra nirIkSaNa pR0 16) ___kahiye mitra! ho gayA Apake prapaMca kA khaNDana? isa prakAra kisI eka aMza ko pakar3a kara mithyA pracAra karanA kyA sAdhuoM kA kArya hai? Apane bhI janatA ko cakkara meM DAlane kA mArga to acchA pakar3A, para jaba koI anveSaka khojakara vicAra pUrvaka nirNaya kare, taba ApakI cAlAkI prakaTa hote dera nahIM lgtii| isa prakAra draupadI ke kathAnaka kI oTa lekara mUrti pUjA ko dharma kRtya batAnA aura ise Agama pramANa kaha kara bholI bhAlI janatA ko bhrama meM DAlanA AtmArthI puruSoM kA kArya nahIM hai| ___

Page #204
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 156 ***************************************** jabaki svayaM mUrti pUjaka TIkAkAra isI draupadI ke kathAnaka para vicAra kara likhate haiM ki - "naca caritAnuvAda vacanAni vidhi niSedha sAdhakAni bhvNti|" taba ApakA kathAnakoM kI oTa lekara usase AcAra vidhAna batAnA, so bhI manaHkalpita yuktiyoM se, yaha kahA~ taka ThIka hai? kathAoM kI oTa ke viSaya meM yahA~ hama itanA hI likhakara agale svataMtra prakaraNa se sapramANa vizeSa vicAra kareMge, kintu sundara mitra ko apane hI TIkAkAra mahAtmA ke ukta zabdoM para vicAra kara apanA haThavAda chor3a denA cAhie, isI meM bhalAI hai| (21) kathAoM ke udAharaNa hamAre mUrti pUjaka baMdhu apanI mAnyatA ko Agamokta evaM mahAvIra prarUpita siddha karane ke lie hamAre sAmane kathAoM ke udAharaNa peza kiyA karate haiN| jahA~ jisa kisI mUrti pUjaka se isa viSaya meM pramANa mA~gA jAtA hai taba turanta ye loga garva pUrvaka sUryAbha vijayadeva aura draupadI Adi ke kathAnakoM ko peza karate haiM aura mana meM yaha samajhate haiM ki hamane pramANa pUrvaka mUrti pUjA kI siddhi kara dii| isI taraha caitya yA balikarma zabda para bhI ye loga uchala kUda macAte haiM, hamAre pratipakSI misTara jJAnasundara jI ne garva pUrvaka aise hI pramANa diye haiN| yadyapi sundara bandhu ne kathAoM ke pramANa diye, phira bhI binA khiMcatAna va artha kA anartha kiye| ye mahAnubhAva apanA manoratha pUrNa nahIM kara ske| kahIM zabdoM kA artha manaHkalpita kiyA to kahIM bhAva hI ulTA btaayaa| ___

Page #205
160 kathAoM ke udAharaNa ********************Ben *******Ben Ben Xue Zhong **** vaMza paramparA se cale Ate hue jItAcAra ke kAraNa yA bhAvI bhoga, jIvana ke sukhamaya hone ke lie, kiye gaye kRtyoM ko binA kisI puSTa pramANa ke dhArmika kRtya batA diyA, aise hI caitya aura balikarma zabda mAtra se yA prakSipta pAThoM se bhole bhaktoM ko bhrama meM DAlane kA prayatna kiyA, kintu aisA eka bhI pramANa nahIM diyA ki jisa meM Agamokta AcAra vidhAna kA ullekha ho yA sarvajJa prarUpita ho| isa prakAra ke udyoga se sujJa pAThaka to zIghra samajha jAte haiM ki yahA~ pramANa ke nAma para zUnya hI hai| jo kRtya dharma kA mukhya aMga mAnA jAtA ho, jo mahAvIra prarUpita kahA jAtA ho, jise sundarajI yA anya mahAn AcArya mokSa kA pramukha mArga kahate hoM aura usI ke lie Agama pramANa meM vidhi vAkya ke nAma para eka akSara bhI nahIM milA, yaha mata mohiyoM ke lie kitanI lajA kI bAta hai? sundara mitra! kathAoM ke pAtra svataMtra hote haiM, unakI paristhiti, unake vicAra Adi sabhI svataMtra hote haiM, ve apanI sthiti yogyatA javAbadArI Adi ko lakSya meM rakhakara jo bhI kArya kareM, vaha sabake lie upAdeya nahIM hotA na aise udAharaNoM se koI siddhAnta hI bana sakatA hai, kaI bahujana mAnya uttama puruSoM ke jIvana meM bhI kabhI kabhI aisI ghaTanAyeM ho jAtI haiM ki unake anuyAyI bhI usakA anukaraNa nahIM karate, udAharaNa ke taura para dekhiye - (1) zrI rAmacandra jI mAyA mRga ke pIche daur3e aura bhrama meM par3akara sItAjI ko chor3akara vana meM cale gye| idhara sItAjI ko rAvaNa le Ur3A, isa para nItikAra kahate haiM ki - "nanirmitA kena na dRSTa pUrvA, na zruyate hemamayI kurNgii| tathApitRSNaraghunandanasya, vinAzakAle viparIta buddhiH|

Page #206
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 161 *******************Jing ********************* arthAt - sone kI mRgI kisI ne banAI nahIM, dekhI nahIM, sunI nahIM, to bhI tRSNAvaza zrI rAmacandra jI use lene ko daur3e, yaha vinAza ke samaya buddhi kI viparItatA hI hai| zrI rAmacandrajI maryAdA puruSottama aura Adarza puruSa mAne jAte haiM unhoMne mAyAvI mRga ke pIche daur3ane kI bhUla kI, kyA unakA udAharaNa lekara sabhI ko aisI bhUla karanI cAhiye? - (2) caritAnuyoga (kathAoM) kA pramANa dene vAle sundara mahAzaya ke pUrvaja prabhAvika AcAryoM meM se AcArya vappabhaTTI U~TanI para savAra hue, sUrAcArya hAthI para car3ha baiThe, govindAcArya ne mandiroM meM vezyAoM kA nAca karavAyA aura bhI kaI prabhAvika AcArya isa koTi ke hue (prabhAvika caritra) inake udAharaNa se sundara bandhu ko bhI vAhanArUr3ha honA cAhie aura mandiroM meM vezyAoM ko nacAkara dharma prabhAvanA bar3hAne ke sAtha-sAtha una vezyAoM kA bhI uddhAra (svarga, mokSa, pradAna) karanA caahie| (3) sUryAbha aura vijaya deva ne bhUta, nAga, yakSAdi kI mUrtiyeM puujii| dvAra, zAkhA, toraNa, vApikA, nAgadantA aura dhvajA Adi kI bhI pUjA kI to mUrti pUjakoM ko bhI aisI kriyAyeM karanI cAhie aura usameM bhI dharma mAnanA cAhie? .. (4) draupadI ne pAMca pati eka sAtha kiye, phira bhI satI kahalAI isakA udAharaNa lekara Aja koI yuvatI do yA tIna pati hI karale aura apane ko satI siddha karane ke lie isI SaSTamAMga ke draupadI varNana kI sAkSI Apake sAmane peza kare to Apa svayaM kathAoM ke anukaraNa karane vAle hone se usa yuvatI ke sAmane kisa prakAra bola sakate ho? ___ adhika kahA~ taka likhA jAya, samajhadAra to saMketa mAtra meM samajha jAte haiN| phira bhI sundarajI mahAtmA kI sundara jAla kA chedana

Page #207
162 kathAoM ke udAharaNa ***** **************************** karane ke lie inhIM (mUrti pUjaka) ke mAnya kucha prAcIna aura arvAcIna pramANa diye jAte haiM - (1) naca caritAnuvAda vacanAni vidhi niSedha sAdhakAni bhavaMti anyathA sUrikAbhAdi deva vaktavya tAyAM bahUnAM zastrAdi vastUnAmarcanaM shruuyte| (jJAtA sUtra kI TIkA-Agamodaya samiti patra 211) (2) caritAnuvAdarUpaM pravartakaM nivartakaM ca na bhavatIti / ___ (sena prazna Agamodaya samiti patra 8) (3) "Arya rakSitAcArye temAM caraNakaraNAnuyogaja vyAkhyA mAM karttavya paNe kahela che temAM zeSa traNa anuyogo che paNa tene vyAkhyA kartavya paNe nathI khii|" (vizeSAvazyaka bhASAMtara Agamo0 sa0 bhA0 2 pR0 231) (4) caritAnuvAda eTale zuM? bhUlavU joituM nathI ke caritAnuvAda e vidhivAda na thI, caritAnuvAda ane vidhivAda mAM AkAza pAtAla nuM antara che, amuka mANase amuka kAma karyu eTale ApaNe te karavuja joie athavA ApaNe te karI zakIe ema mAnanArA ke kahenArAoM kharekhara saiddhAMtika AjJAoM nuM mahAn apamAna kare ch| (zrI vidyAvijayajI li. samaya ne olakho bhAga 1 pR0 215) (5) zrI zAMtivijayajI "sAMjha vartamAna' dainika patra ke tA0 11-7-26 ke aMka meM "bambaI jaina saMgha meM cAlU carcA' zIrSaka lekha ke peregrApha da meM likhate haiM ki - "caritAnuvAda sarvavyApI nahIM, vidhivAda sarva vyApI kahA aura vidhivAda balavAna hai| zAstrArtha ke bakhata vidhivAda kA sabUta denA pdd'egaa| (celeMjonI pokalatA pR07) (6) yahI zAntivijaya jI "risAlA majahaba DhuMDhiye' pR0 10 meM likhate haiM ki - ___

Page #208
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 163 **************** ********************* ___ "dUsare jaMbusvAmI vagerA zakhsoM kA jo bayAna pharamAyA yaha caritAnuvAda kI bAta hai, caritAnuvAda usakA nAma hai ki jisa taraha eka zakhsa ne apanI jiMdagI taira kii ho, vidhivAda usakA nAma hai ki jo 2 hukma tIrthaMkara kA hai usako maMjUra karanA, vidhivAda Ama phirake para kAyama hotA hai, caritAnuvAda eka zakhsa para hotA hai|" .. (7) Apake sampradAya ke prasiddha vidvAn paM0 becaradAsajI kA mata bhI dekhiye - ___"jo vyaktio nA AcaraNo upara thIja AcAro nuM vidhAna darzAvAtuM hoya to pachI AcAranA ke vidhinA granthoM ne judA racavAnIzI jarUra che? kathAnuyoga thIja badhA vidhi vidhAno tAravIzakAtA hoya to caraNa karaNAnuyoga no vadhAro karavo vyartha jevo che, sArA ke narasAM AcaraNo karanArAnI kathAoM uparathI jo te te AcAro nuM vaMdhAraNa baMdhAtu hota to nIti nA granthoM ke kAyadA granthonI jarUra zAmATe par3e? . mAruM to ema mAnavu che ke jyAre AcAra nA grantho judAja racavAmAM AvyA che-Ave che ane temAM pratyeka nAnA moTA AcAronuM vidhAna karavA mAM AvyuM che-Ave che, te chatAM temAMje vidhAno no gaMdha paNa na jaNAto hoya te vidhAna nA samarthana mATe ApaNe kathAoM nA oThAMlaie ke koI nA udAharaNo ApIe te bAbata ne hu~ tamastaraNa sivAya bIjA zabda thI kahI zakato nthii|" (jaina sAhitya mAM vikAra thavAthI thayelI hAni pR0 127) mitra jJAnasuMdarajI! ukta sAta pramANa to Apa hI kI mUrti pUjaka samAja ke diye haiM aba eka pramANa digambara sampradAya kA bhI dekhiye, paM0 parameSThIdAsajI nyAyatIrtha likhate haiM ki -

Page #209
kathAoM ke udAharaNa "prathamAnuyoga kA kathA rUpa kathana AjJA nahIM mAnI jA sakatI kAraNa ki jisane jaisA kiyA vaisA hI kathA meM likhA jA sakatA hai| (carcAsAgara samIkSA pR0 201 ) uparokta prabala evaM akATya pramANoM se yaha bhalI bhAMti siddha ha gayA ki caritAnuvAda ( kathAoM) ke pramANa vidhivAda meM kisI kAma ke nahIM, phira aisI hAlata meM ki jahA~ matabheda ho vahAM to sivAya vidhivAda ke anya kathAoM Adi ke pramANa dene vAle vidvAnoM ke sanmukha parAjaya ko hI prApta hote haiN| 164 sundara mitra ! hama to phira bhI Apako itanA bhI kahate haiM ki yadi Apa kathAoM ke pramANa deveM to bhI aise pramANa deveM ki jo vidhivAda sammata ho| jisake lie vidhivAda kA prabala sahArA ho / jo AcAra vidhAna meM kisI prakAra kI bAdhA nahIM pahu~cAtA ho yadi aisA pramANa ho yA Apake pramANoM meM vidhivAda kA kucha bhI sahArA ho to Apa prasannatA pUrvaka peza kIjiye, kintu binA vidhivAda kI sahAyatA ke cAritramArga meM bAdhaka aisI mUrti pUjA kisI bhI taraha upAdeya nahIM ho sktii| mitravara! jaba Apa svayaM hI apane mejharanAme kI 25 vIM DhAla meM isa prakAra likhate haiM ki - - " sUtra sUyaMgaDAMga mAM kahyu, AjJA bAhara ho ? badhuM Ala papAla ||6 // " aura isI "mejharanAme " kI 23 vIM DhAla ke tAtparya meM sApha likha diyA ki "dharma che te vItarAganI AjJA mAM che, ane AjJA thI nyUnAdhika karavuM te to adharmaja che|" -

Page #210
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 165 *************************************** sundarajI! phira AjJA se ekadama rahita aisI mUrti pUjA ke lie kyoM vyartha ke prapaMca karate ho? Apane to apane isI pothe ke pR0 156 meM yahA~ taka prapaMca kara DAlA ki - "anyathA kevala kahane mAtra se ki - hA~, mUrti pUjA pUjA prAcIna to hai para......isa thothI ukti se koI bhI kAma nahIM cala sktaa|" .. kyoM mitra! phira yaha prapaMca jAla kyoM? satya kahiye, Apane isa bindu aGkita rikta sthAna meM kyA rahasya chipA rakhA hai? kyA maiM isa rikta sthAna kI pUrti kara dUM? lIjiye, Apane jo rahasya chupA rakhA hai vaha maiM hI prakaTa kiye detA huuN| mere vicAra se Apane isa rikta sthAna meM "prabhu AjJA nahIM hai" yahI vAkya chupA rakhA hai, isake sivAya aura ho hI kyA sakatA hai? kyoMki hamArI ora se Apa logoM ke mithyA tarkoM para Apase prabhu AjJA rUpa pramANa mAMgA jAtA hai aura aisA pramANa Apake pAsa hai hI nhiiN| isIlie Apako prapaMcI bananA par3A, kintu sundarajI Apa ekabAra kyA hajAra bAra bhI prapaMca kareM, to bhI Apase yA Apake mUrtipUjaka AcAryoM se mUrti pUjA kI Agama AjJA kabhI bhI siddha nahIM ho sktii| hA~ isa prapaMca jAla se bhole bhaktoM ko to bhrama meM DAla sakate haiM aura isa prakAra Apa va Apake bhakta bhava bhramaNa ko to avazya bar3hA sakate haiN| bar3e Azcarya kI bAta hai ki eka tarapha to Apa svayaM AjJA yukta kriyA meM hI dharma mAnate haiM aura AjJA se bAhara kI karaNI ko sarvathA vyartha batAte haiM, kintu dUsarI ora mUrti pUjA ke cakkara meM par3akara AjJA dharma ko thothI yukti batAte haiN| kyA ApakA aisA kahanA apane hI vacanoM se (sva vacana virodha rUpa dUSaNa se) dUSita nahIM hai?

Page #211
166 loMkA-gacchIya yati *******************Xue Xue ********************* AzA hai ki aba Age para Apa aisI harakatoM se bAja Akara niMdakapana se vaMcita rheNge| pAThakagaNa! dekha liyA Apane tamAzA? yahI marudhara kezarI (zrI jJAnasuMdara jI) eka tarapha to AjJA meM hI dharma aura AjJA se bAhara adharma mAnate haiM aura dUsarI tarapha sthAnaka vAsiyoM ke Upara apane dveSa ke kAraNa tathA mUrti pUjA pakSa ke pakSapAtI hone ke kAraNa usI prabhu AjJA ke lie thothe banate haiM, jabaki inhIM mahAnubhAva ke pakSakAra kathAnakoM kI oTa lene ko mithyA prapaMca prakaTa kara AjJA rUpI pramANa ko hI puSTa pramANa mAnate haiM, taba sundara bAbA kI baukhalAhaTa kA mUlya hI kyA hai? ataeva khulamakhullA yaha siddha ho gayA ki matabheda aura AcAra vidhAna ke mAmaloM meM kathAoM kI oTa lene vAle janatA ko unmArga kI ora dhakelane aura dveSa phailAne vAle bhayaGkara jantu haiN| (rara) lokA-gacchIya yati zrI jJAnasundarajI ne kaI sthAnoM para yaha prazna kiyA hai ki - "Apa pUrvaja loMkAzAha ke gaccha ke yatiyoM kA kiyA huA artha Apa nahIM mAnate ho taba Apa loMkAzAha ke anuyAyI kaise ho sakate ho?" - isake sivAya sthAnakavAsI samAja ko loMkA-gacchIya mUrti pUjaka yatiyoM ke lie hue arthoM kA pramANa mAnane kA Agraha bhI hara sthAna para kiyA gayA hai, isa viSaya meM hamArA sundara mitra se yahI kahanA hai ki - mahAnubhAva! ApakI yaha mAyA jAla bhole bhAiyoM yA nirakSara

Page #212
167 jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA *************************************** bAiyoM meM bhale phaila jAya kintu jo sAkSara haiM jo vicAra va buddhi se kAma lete haiM, unake Age ApakA sAre prayatna niSphala hI jAte haiN| Apako yaha to mAlUma hI hogA ki - zrImAn lokAzAha mUrti pUjA ke kaTTara virodhI the, mUrti pUjA ke viruddha unhoMne prabala pracAra kiyA thA, yaha bAta Apa acchI taraha jAnate aura likhate haiN| ApakA mUrtipUjaka samAja bhI yaha svIkAra karatA hai, hamArI bhI yaha mAnyatA hai ki patanonmukhI jaina samAja jo ki apane zithilAcArI, svArthI, aguvAoM kI karatUtoM ke kAraNa rasAtala ko jA rahA thA, taba isa puNya bhUmi para dharma prANa lokAzAha kA prAdurbhAva huaa| usa puNyAtmA ne jaba jaina siddhAntoM kA avalokana kara manana kiyA to unheM yaha spaSTa mAlUma huA ki vartamAna meM ina kahe jAne vAle jaina sAdhuoM meM sAdhutva kA to nAma hI nahIM hai kintu yaha dala adhikAMza meM parama pavitra jaina dharma ke sat siddhAntoM kA ghAtaka, prabhu AjJA bhaMjaka, zithilAcArI, svArtha pIpAsu aura dharma ke nAma se jhUThA pAkhaNDa calAne vAloM kA hai mUrti pUjA jisake lie Agama AjJA kA aNu mAtra bhI sahArA nahIM hai, use apanA svArtha pUrti kA prabala sAdhana hone se kevala isI meM dharma batA rahe haiM, isake dvArA janatA ko andhavizvAsa meM DAlakara apanA ullU sIdhA karate haiM aura dharma ke vizeSa tattva jo ki Atma-kalyANa ke mukhya sAdhana haiM unheM svArthavaza dabA baiThe haiN| jainAgamoM ke manana se usa vIraputra ko jaba samAja kI vartamAna dazA kA bhAna huA taba usa parama krAntikAra-dharma sudhAraka, dharmaprANa loMkAzAha ne siMha garjanA kara sarva prathama dharma ghAtaka, pAkhaMDavardhaka, andhavizvAsa kI jananI, zithilAcAra kI poSaka aisI mUrti pUjA ke viruddha AvAja utthaaii| bhadra aura sujJa janatA ne usa bulanda AvAja ko sunA, pAkhaNDa kI divAleM hila uThI

Page #213
lokA-gacchIya yati aura bhUkampa kI taraha kampita hokara bahuta sI dharAzAyI ho gii| baca khucI bhI apanA bhaviSya andhakAramaya dekhane lagI, usI dharmavIra ke svarga gamana ke pazcAt usI ke vaMzaja punaH zithilAcAra meM phaMsa kara bAda meM mUrti pUjaka ho gaye haiN| bhalA ve aba zrImAn lokAzAha ke vaMzaja kaise ho sakate haiM? Apa hI sociye ki kahA~ to usa mahAn AtmA kA mUrtipUjA virodha aura kahAM unake vaMzaja kahe jAne vAle loMkA gacchIya yatiyoM kA mUrtipUjA svIkAra ? kyA aba bhI ve zrImAn dharma sudhAraka loMkAzAha ke anuyAyI banane kA dAvA kara sakate haiM? kadApi nahIM / 168 ******* sociye ? eka sadguNI seTha ke do putra hI seTha kA vyavahAra ucca aura Adarza ho, kAlAntara meM seTha kA svargavAsa ho jAne para eka putra to apane pUjya pitA ke Adarza ko sammukha rakhakara tadanusAra vyavahAra kare, va dUsarA apane pitA ke Adarza ko ThukarAkara unake nAma ko kalaGkita karane vAle virodhI kArya kare, divAlA nikAla de to, Apa hI batAiye ki ina do meM kauna suputra kahalAne yogya hai ? prathama putra hI na ? kahane kI AvazyakatA nahIM ki dUsarA putra kuputra aura kulakalaGka hai| basa isI taraha jarA sarala buddhi se yaha samajhiye ki jina yatiyoM ne zrImAn dharmakrAMtikAra lokAzAha kI AjJA ke viruddha, mAnyatA ke viruddha zithila banakara mUrtipUjA ko svIkAra kiyA hai, ve vAstava meM ukta dAnta ke dUsare kuputra kI zreNi ke haiM aura Aja bhI kitane hI lokAgaccha ke yati aise bhI haiM jo mUrti pUjA nahIM karate haiM, ve to alabattA prathama zreNi ke suputra kI taraha zrImAn lokAzAha ke anuyAyI aura vaMzaja kahe jA sakate haiN| jo loga svayaM mUrtipUjaka haiM ve apane mantavya kI siddhi liye

Page #214
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 166 ***************************************** apane hI samAna mUrtipUjakoM ke kiye hue anarthoM ko hamAre sAmane peza kare, yaha kahA~ taka ucita haiM? sundara mitra ko socanA cAhiye ki Akhira loMkAgaccha ke yati (jo mUrti pUjA karate haiM) bhI to mUrti pUjaka haiM, phira unake kiye viparIta arthoM ko sAmane lAte Apako zaramAnA cAhie, ve kadApi zrI lokAzAha ke anuyAyI nahIM hai| (23) sthApanAcArya kA misyA aMDagA zrI jJAnasundarajI pR0 108 meM sthApanAcArya rakhane kI AvazyakatA batalAte hue likhate haiM ki - ___ "pratikramaNa sAmAyikAdi dharma kriyA karane ke samaya sthApanAcArya kI bhI paramAvazyakatA hai, yadi sthApanA na ho to kriyA karane vAlA Adeza kisakA le? isake sivAya sthApanAcArya ke lie Apa zAstrIya pramANa peza karate haiM vaha bhI dekhiye - / "duvAlasAvatte kitikamme pa0 taM0 duuNayaM jahAjAyaM, kitikammaM bAra sAvayaM causiraM tigutta cAdupavesaM eg nikkhmnnN|" ___ sundara mitra ne ukta pATha sthApanA rakhane kI siddhi meM peza kiyA hai, kintu ukta pATha meM eka bhI akSaraM aisA nahIM jo sthApanA kA nAma bhI batAtA ho, phira sundara jI ke mithyA prapaMca meM sAra kyA nikalA? suMdara mitra ne ukta pATha ke nIce loMkA-gacchIya yatiyoM kI ora se kiyA huA TabbArtha diyA usameM binA hI mUla ke "gurunI thApanA For Private &.Personal.Use Only

Page #215
170 sthApanAcArya kA mithyA aMDagA ********************************************** kIje' likhA hai aura anta meM yaha bhI likhA hai ki "eha samavAyAMga vRtti no bhAva" kintu yaha artha bilakula nirmUla hai, isase mUla kA koI sambandha nahIM hai, na vRttikAra ne hI sthApanA kA ullekha kiyA hai, dekho samavAyAMga ke ukta pATha kI zrI abhayadevasUrikRta vRtti kA avataraNa - "duvAlasAvatte kiikamme" tti dvAdazAvarta kRtikarma-vandanakaprajJaptaM, dvAdazAvarttatAmevAsyAnuvadan zeSAMzcataddharmAnabhidhitsuHrUpakamAha-'duoNae' tyAdi, avanatikhanatam-uttamAna pradhAnaM praNamanamityarthaH, dve avanteyasmiMstadadvayavanataM,tatraikaMyadA prathamameva icchAmi khamAsamaNo! vaMdiuM jAvaNijjAe nisIhiyAe' tti amidhAyAva grahAnujJApanAyAvana matIti, dvitIyaM punaryadA'vagrahAnujJApanAyaivAvanamatIti, yathAjAtaMzramaNatvabhavanalakSaNaMjanmAzrityayoniniSkramaNalakSaNaM ca, tatra rajoharaNa mukhavastrikA colapaTTamAtrayA zramaNo jAno racitakarapuTastuyonyA nimrata evaMbhUta eva vandate tadavyatirekAdvA yathA jAtaM bhaNyate, kRtikarma-vaMdana 'bArasAvayaM' ti dvAdazAvarttA:-sUtrAbhidhAnagarbhAH kAyavyApAra vizeSAH yatijanaprAsaddhAH yasmistada dvAdazAvarta tathA 'causiraM' ti catvAri zirAMsi yasiMmastaccatuH ziraH prathama praviSTasya kSAmaNAkAle ziSyAcArya zirodvaya punarapi niSkramya praviSTasya dvayameveti bhAvanA tathA 'tiguttaM' ti tisRbhirguptibhiguptaH

Page #216
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ************ pAThAntarepi tisRbhiH (zraddhAbhiH) gupti bhareveti tathA 'dupavesaM' ti dvau pravezo yasmiMstad dvipravezaM tattva prathamo'vagrahamanujJApya pravizato dvitIyaH punarnirgatya pravizata iti 'eganikkhamaNaM' ti ekaM niSkramaNamavagrahAdAvazyikyA nirgacchataH, dvitIyavelAyAM hyavagrahAnna nirgacchati, pAdapatita evaM sUtra samApayatoti / " ( Agamodaya samiti patra 23 ) isa vRtti meM bhI sthApanA kA nAma nizAna taka nahIM hai phira samajha meM nahIM AtA ki mUrtipUjaka loMkA - gacchIya yatiyoM ne kisa AdhAra sthApanA kA ullekha kara DAlA? 171 vRtti aura isI TabbArtha ke bAda ke kathana se to sApha-sApha guru ko vaMdana karanA hI siddha hotA hai, dekhiye sundarajI ke diye hue pramANa kA avataraNa pR0 106 se - " guru na page vaMdaNA kIje, 'ahokAyaM kAya' e pATha kahI vihuvAlA thai 12 bArA Avarta yathA cosaro 4 bevalA guru ne page mastaka namAr3iye | Adi - isa prakAra khullama-khulA guru vandana svIkAra kiyA gayA hai| itanA hote hue bhI sundara mitra anartha kA sahArA lekara sthApanAcArya manavAne kA durAgraha karate haiM yaha kahAM taka ucita hai ? hama spaSTa aura sAhasapUrvaka kahate haiM ki jinAgamoM meM kisI bhI sthAna para sthApanAcArya rakhane kA vidhAna nahIM hai, na sthApanA se Adeza lene kA hI ullekha hai, yahI nahIM cauthe pAMcaveM aura chaThe guNasthAna vartiyoM ke caritAnuvAda meM bhI yaha bAta nahIM hai| dekhiye nimna pramANa (1) jaba zakrendra ko prabhu ke "kevalya kalyANa" Adi kA -

Page #217
172 sthApanAcArya kA mithyA aDagA ******************************************** avadhijJAna dvArA mAlUma hotA hai taba vaha siMhAsana chor3atA hai aura sAta ATha kadama IzAna koNa kI taraha Age bar3hakara bhUmi para baiThatA hai, bAda meM mastaka jhukAkara vandanA-stuti karatA hai, kintu vahA~ bhI sthApanA kA ullekha nahIM hai| isake sivAya vahA~ eka bAta yaha bhI spaSTa ho jAtI hai ki aise dhArmika kAryoM ke samaya meM zakrendra mUrtiyoM ke pAsa jAkara vandanAdi nahIM karatA kintu sabhA sthAna ke samIpa hI stuti karatA hai, isase yaha spaSTa ho gayA ki una mUrtiyoM aura unakI pUjA se dharma kA kucha bhI sambandha nahIM hai| (2) upAsaka dazAMga, bhagavatI, jJAtA rAyaprasenI Adi sUtroM meM zrAvakoM kI dharmakaraNI kA kathana hai, usameM batAyA gayA ki ve pauSadhazAlA meM jAkara pratikramaNa, pauSadha, upavAsAdi tapa, saMleSaNA Adi kriyAyeM karate, kintu kisI ko bhI sthApanA kI AvazyakatA par3I ho yA kisI ne rakhI ho, yaha nAma mAtra ullekha bhI nahIM hai| yahI nahIM aMtakRtadazAMga meM sudarzana zreSThi kA itihAsa batAyA gayA hai, jo prabhu vandana ko zahara ke bAhara jAtA hai aura rAste meM use arjuna se upasarga hotA hai, vaha vahIM AlocanA pratikramaNa kara sAgArI anazana kara letA hai, kintu vahA~ bhI sthApanA kI AvazyakatA nahIM huii| (3) bhagavatI, jJAtA, aMtakRtadazA, anuttaropapAtikadazA, vipAka Adi sUtroM meM sAdhuoM kI dharmakaraNI aura anazana Adi kA ullekha hai vahA~ bhI binA sthApanA ke unakA kAma huA, balki nirarthaka aisI sthApanA kI unheM AvazyakatA hI nahIM huI, yahAM taka ki unake kAla kara jAne para sAtha vAle sahAyaka muni unake bhaMDa upakaraNa lekara prabhu ke pAsa Aye, aisA ullekha to milatA hai kintu unameM bhI sthApanAcArya kA to nAma mAtra bhI nahIM hai| ___

Page #218
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 173 Lai Lai Lai Lai Lai Lai Lai ***Ke Lai Lai Lai Lai Lai Lai Lai Lai Lai Lai Lai Lai Lai Lai Lai Lai Lai Lai Lai Lai Lai An Ben Ben Ci Jiao Ben Ci ukta tIna prakAra ke pramANoM meM sAre AgamoM ke aitihAsika mahAtmAoM aura zrAddhavoM ke itihAsa kA sAra A gayA, jisameM saiMkar3oM itihAsa sAkSI haiM, kintu kisI eka meM bhI sthApanA kA ullekha nahIM hai, ataeva siddha huA ki sthApanAcArya kA aDaGgA mUrtimati mahAnubhAvoM kI anokhI sUjha kA hI phala hai| sundara mitra pUchate haiM ki "sthApanA nahIM hone para sAmAyika pratikramaNAdi meM Adeza kisakA le" isake uttara meM kahA jAtA hai ki jaba taka guru Adi jyeSTha upasthita hoM taba taka to unhIM kI AjJA lI jAtI hai aura unakI anupasthiti meM zAstrAnusAra kriyA karane meM prabhu kI AjJA cAhI jAtI hai, jaise ki "anazana sthala para jAkara aneka muniyoM ne aura sudarzana Adi zrAvakoM ne kahA hai ki - namaskAra ho arihanta bhagavanta ko, namaskAra ho dharmAcArya ko, Apa yahA~ nahIM ho, kintu jahA~ ho vahA~ se saba jAnate dekhate ho, maiM ApakI AjJA se amuka vrata yA kriyA karatA hU~" Adi aise pramANa bahuta se sUtroM meM maujUda haiM basa isI mAphika hama bhI karate haiN| hameM sthApanA kI koI AvazyakatA nahIM, hama sthApanA ko nirarthaka samajhate haiM balki hamArI to yaha mAnyatA hai ki - jo sthApanAcArya ko rakhakara unase AjJA mAMgate haiM ve choTe baccoM ke samAna haiM, jo patthara ke gola mola gaNeza biThAkara unase lar3a mAMgate haiN| kyA sundara jI yaha samajhAne kI kRpA kareMge ki inake jar3a sthApanAcArya kisa taraha Adeza dete haiM? caitanyadhArI manuSya to Adeza de sakatA hai, para jar3a se Adeza to jar3opAsaka hI pA sakate hoMge? sundara mitra! Apa aura Apake anya mUrtipUjaka sAdhuoM ne sthApanAcArya kA vyartha sahArA lekara sAkSAt AcAryoM kI bhI upekSA kara

Page #219
174 sthApanAcArya kA mithyA aMDagA *Xue Jia ***************************Li *******Ben **Ben Ping dI, isase khinna hokara Apa hI kI mUrti pUjaka samAja ke AcArya sAgarAnaMda sUrijI 'tapa ane udyApana' nAma kI pustaka meM likhate haiM ki "AcArya bhagavaMto nI ArAdhanA temanI mUrti dvArAe jaNAvI nathI, valI e vAta paNa dhyAnamA rAkhavAnI che ke AcArya mahArAja nI hayAti mAM aMze paNa temanI bhakti bahumAna veyAvacca ane zuzrUSA nahiM karavA vAlA chatAM 'marI ghor3I nuM bahumUla thAya' tenI mAphaka amuka kAla karI gayela AcArya nA temanI pratimAdi sthApanA dvArAe AcArya sthApanA nA bhakta banI vartamAna bhAvAcAryanI bhakti thI benasIba rahI temAM pote magarubI mAnechexxx valI e vAta paNa dhyAna mAM rAkhavAnI che ke jema vartamAna kAla mAM bhAva AcArya, upAdhyAya padasthoM ke potAnA baDIlo vidyamAna chatAM ane teone te te pada ne lAyaka guNavAlA che ema mAnavA chattA sAdhu sAdhvI nA samudAyoM mAM bhinna-bhinna sthApanAcArya rAkhavAnI pravRtti hovA thI ratnAdhika aTale potA thI pahelI bar3I dIkSA vAlA, guru mahArAjA padasthoM ke AcAryAdiko nI samakSa koI paNa Avazyaka pratilekhanAdi nitya kriyA karavAnuM paNa karttavya che ema mAnavA taiyAra thatuM nathI, ane te te prati dina kriyAoM sAkSAt bhAvAcAryAdi pAse na karatAM mAtra sthApanAcArya pAse karI sAdhu sAdhvI jevA uttama jIvo paNa potAne kRtArtha mAnavA taiyAra thAya che tevI avidhinA anumodana karanArA zAstrakAro bane nahIM ane sthApanAcArya Adi dvArAe bhAvAcAryAdika pAse thatI bhAvabhInI kriyAno bheda thaI jAya nahi mATe paNA zAstrakAre AcArya padanI ArAdhanA temanI pratimA dvArAe na jaNAvI hoya te svAbhAvika ch|" (pR0 237) sundara bandhu! dekhaliyA? Apake isa sthApanAcArya ne kaisI sthiti utpanna kara dI? zrI sAgarAnaMda sUrijI ne ThIka hI kahA hai ki- sthApanAcArya

Page #220
175 jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA *******************************Lai ***Duo Ci ke pIche par3a kara logoM ne sAkSAt AcAryoM kI bhakti se upekSA akhtiyAra kara lii| maiM to Apako yahI salAha dUMgA ki Apa isa pacar3e ko haTA dIjiye, isakI tanika bhI AvazyakatA nahIM hai, kyoMki choToM kA kAma bar3oM kI AjJA se cala sakatA hai aura bar3oM kA kAma prabhu AjJA se phira, sthApanA ke aDaMge kI AvazyakatA hI kyA? isake sivAya Apane yaha bhI likha DAlA ki - bhArata kSetra meM zAsana sImaMdhara svAmI kA nahIM, para bhagavAn mahAvIra svAmI ke paTTadhara saudharma gaNadhara kA hai unakI sthApanA avazya honI caahie| tIrthaMkara sImaMdhara ke ora bhagavAn mahAvIra ke AcAra vyavahAra kriyA meM kaI prakAra kA antara hai" aadi| isa viSaya meM saMkSepa meM yahI kahanA hai ki - jaba Apa sudharmA svAmI kA zAsana mAnate haiM to phira jambU svAmI kA kyoM nahIM mAnate? unake bAda prabhavasvAmI aise hote 2 vartamAna AcArya taka cale Aiye zAsanakartA vidyamAna mileMge phira sthApanA kI AvazyakatA hI nahIM rhegii| isake sivAya Apane sImaMdhara svAmI kI AjJA lene meM jo etarAja kiyA hai, yaha bhI vyartha hai kyoMki prathama to hameM isameM koI Agraha nahIM hai jaisI jisakI mAnyatA ho kareM parantu hameM Azcarya to ApakI dveSa parAyaNatA para hai ki Apa hamase to sImandhara svAmI kI AjJA lene para etarAja karate haiM aura khuda lambe caur3e huMDI, peMTha, parapeTha aura mejharanAme likhakara sImandhara svAmI ke pAsa bhArata kI zikAyata bhejate haiM batAiye aba Apa kisa muMha se javAba deMge? jabaki Apa sImandhara svAmI ko yahA~ ke zAsana kartA nahIM mAnate haiM to yahA~ ke zAsana kI zikAyata unake pAsa bhejanA kyA mUrkhatA nahIM hai? vAstava meM Apake hRdaya meM sthAnakavAsiyoM ke lie halAhala bharA huA hai, hamArI

Page #221
176 vyavahAra sUtra kA samabhAvita caitya *************Qiu ******Li ******************** koI bhI bAta Apako acchI nahIM lagatI, isI se Apa dila khola kara manamAnA likha rahe haiM? isake sivAya anta meM Apane yaha bhI likhA hai ki "tuma kalpanA karate ho, phira sAkSAt sthApanA mAnane meM haTa karanA to durAgraha hI hai" isake uttara meM Apako mAlUma ho ki bhAvoM dvArA kalpanA kevala zarIra yA AkRti kI hI nahIM hotI, kintu sAkSAt guNavAn-bhAva yukta ke vyaktitva kI hI hotI hai, jo ki sarvathA ucita hai kintu mUrti se to basa jo vastu sAmane dikhAI detI hai vo hI bhAvoM meM AtI hai, sthApanAcArya dekhane para basa thor3IsI vastra veSTita golamAla AkRti sAmane A jAtI hai, jisase basa yahI dikhAI detI hai anya kucha nahIM, ataeva kalpanA dvArA guNI ke guNa kA ciMtana yA smaraNa karanA atyanta upayogI hai, isakI upekSAkara sthApanA kA aDaMgA lagAnA matAndhoM kA kArya hai| Azcarya hai ki logoM ne AtmotthAnakArI guNoM kA cintana manana aura AcaraNa nahIM karake ekAnta haTha meM par3akara sthApanA ko vyartha gale bAMdha rakhI hai, jo ki kataI anAvazyaka aura vyartha kI upAdhi hai| acchA ho yadi ye loga isa vyartha kI upAdhi parigraha se apanA piMDa chur3A kara Atmika zakti ko hI bddh'aaveN| (24) vyavahAra sUtra kA samabhAvita caitya zrImAn jJAnasundarajI ne pR0 114 meM vyavahAra sUtra se mUrti siddha karane ke lie nimna pATha uddhRta kiyA hai - "jatthaya samabhAviyAiMceiyAiMpAsejjA kappaI se tassaMtie aaloittaavaa|"

Page #222
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ******** ************** ukta pATha kA bhAva batAte hue likhate haiM ki kisI sAdhu ke doSa lagA ho aura AcAryAdi gItArtha kA abhAva ho to vaha sAdhu suvihita pratiSThita jina pratimA ke pAsa AlocanA kara sakatA hai|" - 177 isa viSaya meM pAThakoM ko saralatA ke lie ukta pATha ke pUrvApara sambandha kA bhAva batalAte haiM - ******** vyavahAra sUtra ke prathamoddezaka ke AlocanAdhikAra meM yaha batAyA gayA hai ki yadi kisI sAdhu ko kucha doSa lagA ho to usakI AlocanA ke lie apane AcArya upAdhyAya ke samIpa jAkara AlocanAdi kre| yadi AcArya upAdhyAya dUra hoM to saMbhogika, bahusUtrI, ugravihArI sAdhu ke samIpa jAkara AlocanA kare, yadi inakA bhI yoga nahIM mile to asaMbhogika, sAdharmika bahusUtrI sAdhu ke samIpa jAkara AlocanA kare, yadi inakA bhI yoga nahIM mile to saMyama se girA huA bahusUtrI zramaNopAsaka ho usake pAsa AlocanA kare, yadi isakA bhI abhAva ho to "samabhAvita caitya" ke samIpa jAkara AlocanA kare, samabhAvita caitya ke abhAva meM grAma ke bAhira jAkara IzAna koNa kI taraha muMha kara donoM hAtha jor3akara apanA doSa kahe aura arihaMta siddha ke samIpa AlocanA kara prAyazcita le / " yaha prakaraNa kA sAra hai isameM AlocanA kA eka sthAna sambhAviyAI ceiyAI (samabhAva vAlA caitya) bhI hai jisakA artha sundara mitra "suvihita pratiSThita jina pratimA" karate haiM, jo ki mUla zabdoM se bilakula viparIta hai| yadi sundara mitra hArdika suMdaratA pUrvaka vicAra karate yA isa sUtra ke TIkAkAra kI vyAkhyA ko hI par3ha lete to inheM isa prakAra kI kutarka karane kA maukA hI nahIM miltaa| dekhiye

Page #223
178. vyavahAra sUtra kA samabhAvita caitya ******************************************** sundara jI Apa hI ke TIkAkAra isa samabhAvita caitya kI kyA vyAkhyA karate haiN| "yatraiva samyag bhAvitAni jinavacana vAsitAntaH karaNAni daivatAni pazyati tatra gatvA teSAmanti ke aalocyet|" arthAt - jahA~ samyag bhAvita-jina vacanoM se otaprota hai antaHkaraNa (hRdaya) jisakA aise devatA ke pAsa jAkara AlocanA kre| ukta vyAkhyA ke viparIta sundara bandhu apanI sundara buddhi se "samabhAvita" zabda kA hI artha karate haiM "suvihita pratiSThita' samajha meM nahIM AtA ki sundaramitra ne aisA apUrva(?) artha kisa prakAra kara DAlA? samabhAva zabda kA artha suvihita aura sAtha hI pratiSThita aisA vilakSaNa artha karake kyA sundara mahAnubhAva ne utsUtra prarUpaNA nahIM kI hai? avazya pUrNa rUpa se utsUtra prarUpaNA, sAmAnya janatA ko dhokhA dene kI duSTa niyata se kI hai| yadi sundara mitra TIkAkAra kI vyAkhyA ke bAda ke artha para se aisA kahate haiM to yaha bhI anucita haiM kyoMki TIkAkAra ne ukta vyAkhyA karane ke bAda apanI marjI se yaha bhI vidhAna kara diyA ki yadi aisA samyaktva bhAvita hRdaya vAlA deva nahIM mile to "jina pratimA ke sAmane AlocanA kare' samajha meM nahIM AtA ki TIkAkAra mahArAja ne yaha vidhAna kisa AdhAra se kiyA? mUla sUtra meM to yaha bAta aura yaha adhika vidhAna hai hI nahIM, phira binA hI mUla ke mUrti ke pIche par3akara manamAnA vidhAna ThIka biThAne vAle mahAnubhAvoM ko kyA kahA jAya? yadi spaSTa rUpa se kahane diyA jAya to yaha bhI utsUtra prarUpaNA hI hai| itanA hote hu bhI sundara jI kI dveSa buddhi to alaga hI apanA raMga jamA

Page #224
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ********************************** rahI hai ye to kevala " samabhAvita caitya" kA hI artha "suvihita pratiSThita jina pratimA" karate haiM kyA pakSapAta kI bhI koI hada hai ? kitane hI pakSapAtI baMdhu " samabhAvita caitya" kA artha " samabhAvayukta jina pratimA" karate haiM, kintu yaha artha anucita hai, kyoMki yadi aisA hai to phira yaha bhI mAnanA par3egA ki mUrti ke bhI bhAva (hRdaya) hotA hai aura jinamUrti samabhAva ke sivAya kyA mithyAbhAva vAlI bhI hotI hai ? vAstava meM yahA~ caitya zada kA artha kisI bhI hAlata meM mUrti nahIM ho sakatA, kyoMki isake sAtha " samyag bhAvita " vizeSaNa hai jo ki zarIra aura AtmA vAle sajIva manuSyAdi se hI sambandha rakhatA hai aura mUrti to jar3a hotI hai, usake haDDI, mAMsa, rakta, carma Adi hote hI nahIM, na mana tathA hRdaya hI hotA hai, phira mUrti meM samyag bhAva kaise ho sakatA hai? aura "samabhAva vAlI jina pratimA" artha mAnane vAle ko hama pUcha sakate haiM ki - yadi ApakI mUrtiyeM antaHkaraNa vAlI haiM to jaina samAja meM nahIM, mUrti pUjaka samAja meM itane bakher3e kyoM hote haiM? phUTa aura kalaha kA nagna tANDava kyoM macatA hai ? mAmUlI bAtoM ke lie Apasa meM hI jUte mAra aura DaMDe mAra calakara davAkhAnoM para tabAhI kyoM DAlI jAtI hai? ye antaHkaraNa vAlI inakI mUrtiyeM, kyoM nahIM samAdhAna kara detI ? kyoM samvatsarI ke eka dina Age pIche ke jhagar3e meM khUna kharAbiyAM macavAtI hai? yadi ye mUrtiyeM jinako ye loga antaHkaraNa vAlI mAnate haiM aura bhakti pUrvaka pUjate haiM, pahale se hI AjJA jAhira kara deM, to ina ke izAre mAtra se sabhI jhagar3e dUra ho sakate haiM / ataeva spaSTa huA ki ina bandhuoM ne aisA artha kevala mUrti ke pakSa meM par3a kara sAdhumArgI samAja se jhagar3ane lie hI kiyA hai| 176 ***

Page #225
180 vyavahAra sUtra kA samabhAvita caitya ******************************************* aba pAThaka jarA niyuktikAra mahArAja kI bhI isa sUtra para kI vyAkhyA dekheM, Apa likhate haiM ki - "koraMTagaM jahA bhAviyaTThamaM pucchiuNa vA annN| amati arihaMta siddhe jANaMto suddho jA cev|| arthAt - bhRgukaccha ke koraMTa nAmaka udyAna meM zrImunisuvrata svAmI ne aneka bAra samavasaraNa kiyA thA, vahA~ tIrthaMkara aura gaNadharoM ne aneka sAdhuoM ko aneka prakAra ke prAyazcitta diye the, usa prAyazcitta dAna ko vahA~ ke devatA ne dekhA thA, isalie koraMTa udyAna meM jAkara "samyaktva se vAsita hai aMtaHkaraNa jinakA aise devatAoM" kI ArAdhanA ke lie telA karake yathocita Adara kare, jisase vaha devatA yathA yogya prAyazcitta de detA hai, kadAcit vaha devatA cava gayA ho aura vahA~ para dUsare deva utpanna hue hoM to unhoMne to tIrthaMkaroM ko dekhA nahIM, aura prAyazcitta vidhi sunI nahIM, kintu tele ke prabhAva se ve devatA mahAvideha meM jAkara tIrthaMkaroM se pUchakara prAyazcitta dete haiM?" . niyuktikAra ke ukta kathana aura vyAkhyA para se hama hamAre suMdara hRdayI sundara mitra se pUchate haiM kiM-kyA aba bhI Apa apanA mithyA haTha nahIM chor3eMge ? kahiye, ApakA "suvihita pratiSThita jina pratimA" artha kahA~ havA ho gayA? ye Apake hI niyuktikAra aura TIkAkAra to ApakI hI bolatI banda kara rahe haiM? kyA aba bhI Apa mUrti pUjA kA mithyA haTha nahIM chor3eMge? . sujJa pAThako! isa jagaha TIkAkAra aura niyuktikAra meM bhI matabheda hai, TIkAkAra mahArAja to samyaktva yukta antaHkaraNa vAle deva ke abhAva meM apanI icchA se hI mUrti ke pAsa bheja rahe haiM aura niyuktikAra mUrti ke liye mauna sAdha rahe haiN|

Page #226
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA .. 181 *********Duo Duo Ben ***********Ben *Ben ***Leng ********* yadi mUla sUtra para hI vicAra kiyA jAya to spaSTa pAyA jAtA hai ki sUtrakAra ko mandira mUrti kataI mAnya nahIM hai, na usa samaya mandira aura mUrtiyoM kA pUjanA pUjAnA dharma mAnA jAtA thA, tabhI to samyaktva bhAvita caitya ke abhAva meM sUtrakAra kisI jina mandira yA mUrti ke sAmane nahIM bhejakara grAma se bAhara jaMgala meM jAkara arihaMta siddhoM kI sAkSI se AlocanA karane kI AjJA de rahe haiN| yadi mandira mUrti kI mAnyatA unheM iSTa hotI to ve jarUra isI vidhAna ke sthAna para mandira mUrtiyoM ke hI sAmane AlocanAdi karane kA vidhAna krte| isa sthiti para se bhI spaSTa ho jAtA hai ki mUrti pUjA meM dharma mAnane kI zraddhA kA sUtrakAra ke samaya janma bhI nahIM huA thA, ye loga vyartha kI dhAMdhalabAjI macAkara sAmAnya janatA ko bhrama meM DAlate haiN| (25) - paTAvalI ke nAma se prapaJca sundara mitra ne pR0 126 ke phuTanoTa meM zrImAn maNilAlajI mahArAja racita "prabhuvIra paTTAvalI" pR0 131 kA pUrvApara saMbaMdha rahita uddharaNa dekara mUrti pUjA siddha karane kA prayatna kiyA hai, kintu yaha karatUta bhI satya ko chupAne vAlI hai, yahA~ hama pAThakoM kI saralatA ke liye usa sthAna kA saMkSipta paricaya de dete haiN| zrImadbhadrabAhu svAmI ke svarga gamana pazcAt jaina saMgha ko viSama paristhiti kA sAmanA karanA par3A, suvihita sAdhuoM kA samAgama durlabha ho gayA, samAja meM kleza bar3hane lagA, aise samaya meM rAjA loga jo jaina dharmI the ve bhI itara dharmAvalambI hone lage, sAmAnya varga bhI jainettaroM kI ora AkarSita hone lagA, usa samaya kucha AcAryoM ne vicArA ki - (yahA~ se avikala avataraNa diyA jAtA hai) yathA -

Page #227
paTTAvalI ke nAma se prapaMca ***************************************** "rAjAoM ane gRhasthoM jainetara samAja mAM jAya che enuM khAsa kAraNa teonAM iSTa devanI mUrti nuM AkarSaNa che, dharma guruoM hAjara hoya ke na hoya paNa prabhunAM darzana karIe, tenuM pUjana-arcana karIe topaNa AtmakalyANa sAdhI zakAya che" AprakAra nI bhAvanA nA yoge rAjAo vagere jainadharma tajI daI itara paMthamAM jAya che, mATe teone dharmAMtara karatA aTakAvavA mATe ApaNe paNa zrI jinezvara deva nI pratimAnuM avalambana batAvIe to jarUra ghaNA manuSyoM dharmAMtara karatAM aTake, valI siddhAMtoM mAM paNa " sthApanA nikSepa" kahela che, to zrI jinezvara devanI pratimA ne sthApana karavAmAM koI jAta no pratibaMdha naDato nathI, ane e pratimAne avalambana tarIke mAnavAthI bAla jIvoM ne dharma bhraSTa thatAM bacAvI zakAze, Ama zubha hetue temaNe mUrttipUjAnI pravRtti zaru karI dIdhI / jema eka nAnA bAlaka ne tenA vaMDIle potAnI sagavaDa khAtara ke bAlakanA AnaMda me khAtara amuka jAtanA ramakaDAM ramavAne ApyA hoya, ane tenAthI bAlaka ramatuM hoya, tevAmAM e ramakaDAM tarIkenI koI eka vastunI tenAM vaDIlone jarUra paDe tyAre jo emane ema e ramakaDuM bAlaka pAse thI chInavI levAmAM Ave to te bAlaka raDavA lAge ane kajiyo kare, tema na thavA pAme eTalA khAtara eka ramakaDuM levA mATe bAlakane bIjuM ramakaDuM ApavuM paDe che, eTale navA ramakaDAM nI lAlace prathamanuM ramakaDuM hAtha mAMthI bAlaka mUkI de che, eja rIte bAla jIvo ne anya darzanIonI mUrti - pratimA pratye thatI zraddhA aTakAvavA mATe "suvihita AcAryoe zrI jinezvara devanI pratimAnu avalambana batAvyuM, ane tenuM je pariNAma melavavA AcAryoe dhAryuhatuM te pariNAma keTaleka aMze AvyuM paNa kharaM, arthAt jinezvara devanI pratimAnI sthApanA ane tenI * ina bar3e akSaroM ke bIca kA bhAga lekara hI sundara mitra ne prapaJca racA hai| 182 ********

Page #228
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ************* pravRtti thI ghaNA jaino jainetara thatA aTakyA, ane tema karavA mAM e AcAryoe jaina samAja Upara mahAn upakAra karyo che, ema kahevA mAM jarA atizayokti nathI" 183 *** dharmonnati ane dharma rakSaNa nI prabala lAgaNI nA Aveza mAM AcAryoe pratimAnI - jinezvara devanI mUrtinI sthApanA karI, paNa tenuM bhAvi kevuM Avaze? teno te vakhate temaNe jarAe vicAra na karyo, temaja siddhAMtanI - zrI vItarAga devanI AjJAno paNa zAnta citte vicAra na karyo / " (jaina dharma no prAcIna saMkSipta itihAsa ane prabhuvIra paTTAvalI pR0 130) pAThaka bandhuo ! ukta avataraNa para se Apa samajha gaye hoMge ki sundarajI ne pUrvApara sambandha ko chor3a diyA aura thor3e se aMza ko pakar3a kara kaisA bhrama phailAyA? ukta avataraNa meM mUrti pUjA ko eka bhulAve meM DAlane kA sAdhana mAtra batAyA hai aura bAda meM yaha spaSTa kaha diyA ki aisA karane meM una AcAryoM ne bhaviSya kI bhayaMkaratA kA vicAra nahIM kiyA, na Agama - vItarAga kI AjJA kA hI dhyAna rkkhaa| vAstava meM vikRti kA bIja sUkSma hote hue bhI bhayaGkara hai, bhale hI sthUla dRSTi se usakI bhayaGkaratA tatkAla meM na dikhAI de, kintu vahI sUkSma bIjaM jaba vizAla rUpa dhAraNa karatA hai taba usakI bhayaGkaratA mUrtimAn hokara sarvanAzakArI bana jAtI hai| sundara mitra ! muni zrI maNilAlajI mahArAja ne mUrti pUjA kI jo bhayaGkaratA aura zAstra viruddhatA dikhAI, kyA vaha ApakI dRSTi meM nahIM AI? Apake avataraNa ke akSaroM ke pUrva ke zabda hI jaba mUrti ko khilaunA mAtra batA rahe haiM aura bAda ke zabda usakI bhAvI bhayaGkaratA tathA zAstra viruddhatA ghoSita kara rahe haiM, taba Apa ko gehU~ chor3akara *

Page #229
184 svarNa gulikA se mUrti kA mithyA sambandha ****Hu Hu Hu Zu Zu Zu **Zu Zu Zu Zhong Zi *Ben Ben Xue Li Ben Ci An An *****Ben Xing Zu Zu Ben Ben Shi kevala kaGkara hI saMgraha karane ke samAna yaha anucita karatUta kyoM sUjhI? kyA bholI aura anabhijJa janatA ko bhrama meM DAlane ke liye to nahIM? vAstava meM yaha nirA prapaJca hI hai, anya kucha nhiiN| - bandhuvara! aisA karane se Apa sujJa janatA meM upahAsa ke pAtra Thaharate haiM, aura ApakA pakSa bhI manaHkalpita dikhAI detA hai| AzA hai ki bhaviSya meM Apa aisI vRtti se apane ko bacAye rkheNge| (26) svarNa gulikA se mUrti kA mithyA sambandha sundara mitra ne pR0 130 se 131 taka svarNa gulikA kI eka kathA dekara vaha batAyA hai ki caNDa pradyotana rAjA svarNa gulikA ke sAtha mahAvIra bhagavAn kI eka mUrti bhI ur3Akara le gayA thA jisake lie yuddha huA thA, aura isI para se pR0 132 meM yaha bhI likha diyA ki zrI amolakaRSijI ne praznavyAkaraNa kA anuvAda karate mUrti kA sambandha chor3a diyA, yaha RSijI kI taskara vRtti hai| aadi| sundara mitra ne ukta kathA kisI prAmANika aura ubhaya mAnya Agama se nahIM dI, kintu apane hI mUrti pUjaka pUrvAcAryoM ke race hue granthoM aura TIkA ke AdhAra se dI hai, aura isI para se Apa svargIya pUjya pAda amolakaRSijI mahArAja sAhaba para barasa par3e haiM, kintu yaha inakI duSTa vRtti hI haiN| prazna vyAkaraNa sUtra ke abrahma nAsaka caturtha Amrava dvAra meM abrahmacarya (vyabhicAra) kI kAmanA ko lekara striyoM ke lie bar3e 2 yuddha hue haiM, aisA batAkara kucha striyoM ke nAmollekha kiye haiM, unameM

Page #230
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ************* svarNa gulikA kA bhI eka nAma hai| mUla pATha meM isa viSaya meM kevala " suvaNNa guliyAe" nAma mAtra hI AyA hai, isake sivAya isa viSaya meM kucha bhI nahIM hai / itane mAtra se mUrti pUjaka mahAnubhAvoM ne manamAnI kathA gar3ha DAlI hai aura vRttikAra ne ukta " suvaNNa guliyAe" zabda kI vyAkhyA meM yahA~ taka likha DAlA ki caNDapradyotana svarNa gulikA ke sAtha mahAvIra prabhu kI gozIrSa candana kI eka mUrti bhI le bhAgA, samajha meM nahIM AtA ki TIkAkAra ne yahA~ mUrti kA kathana kisa mUla ke AdhAra se kiyA ? kyA ise mUla kI vRtti kaheM, yA apane mata kI vRtti ? mUla kI vRtti racate samaya mUla se sarvathA dUra, mUla ke kisI bhI aGga ke lie anupayogI aise aMza rakhane kA kyA kAraNa? pAThaka svayaM soca sakate haiM ki prakaraNa kA Azaya kevala kAmavAsanA se prerita hue manuSyoM kA (striyoM ke lie yuddha karane vAloM kA) varNana karane kA hai, yadi prakaraNa ke Azaya ko dhyAna meM rakhakara yahI batAyA gayA hotA to phira bhI cala jAtA, kintu prakaraNa se bilakula dUra - sarvathA dUra - aisI apanI mAnI huI mUrti pUjA ke liye bhI jahA~ cAheM vahA~ jabaradastI sthAna banA lenA, vicAraka janatA meM kabhI Adara yogya nahIM ginA jAtA aura phira sundara mitra to vicitra mahApuruSa Thahare, jaise unmAdI manuSya ko Upara se bhaGga yA madirA pilAdI jAya to phira usake kArya kucha ajIba DhaGga ke hI hote haiM, usI prakAra eka to sundara mitra pahale 185 ***** hI sAdhumArgI samAja ke pUrNa dveSI, aura dUsare mUrti mata meM masta, tisa para unheM aise TIkAkAra mahAnubhAvoM ke varNana rUpa...... . pilAyA jAya to. phira inakA dimAga sAtaveM AsamAna para car3he yaha svAbhAvika hI hai| isI dveSa aura mUrti moha meM masta hokara sundara bandhu ne kathA aura TIkA kI mAdakatA car3hAlI, basa phira kyA kahanA, lage aMTa saMTa hAMkane /

Page #231
186 svarNa gulikA se mUrti kA mithyA sambandha Bi Xue Xue Zhu Xue Zi Ben ***Jing ***Ben Kong **Yu *****Ben ************Li Yong Qiu . svarNa gulikA ko kyoM le gayA? kaise le gayA? kisake sAtha le gayA? Adi praznAvalI pUjyapAda amolakaRSijI mahArAja ko sambodhana kara kara ddaalii| yadi isa praznAvalI meM sundara mitra yaha bhI prazna kara DAlate ki "dina ko le gayA yA rAta ko? ghor3e para biThA kara le gayA yA gadhe para? yA zira para uThAkara le gayA?" to kyA bar3I bAta thI, sundara mitra! isakA uttara to kalpanA dvArA kAma calAne meM kuzala aise mUrti pUjaka granthakAra hI de sakate haiM, dUsare nahIM, phira Age unmAda meM masta hokara yahA~ taka likha DAlA ki - .. - "isa bhagavAn mahAvIra kI mUrti ke samarthaka pATha ko kyoM chor3a diyaa| zAyada inake pUrvajoM se kramazaH calI AtI huI vRtti kA hI anukaraNa kara Apane isa satya ko chipAyA ho to Azcarya nahIM .....aisI taskara vRtti karane se kyA phAyadA ho sakatA hai|" sundara mitra! kauna mUrkha kahatA hai ki pATha chupAyA gayA, yA chor3a diyA? kyA Apa hoza meM hokara likha rahe haiM, yA matamoha ke naze meM masta hokara? vAstava meM aisA likhane vAlA zuddha hRdaya nahIM ho sakatA, kyoMki pATha meM to mahAvIra prabhu kI to kyA kisI bhI prabhu kI mUrti kA nAma nizAna bhI nahIM hai, jo kisI bhI anveSaka se chipI huI hai, hA~ TIkA meM to jarUra hai, para TIkA ko pATha kahakara batAnA to dina dahAr3e A~khoM meM dhUla jhoMkanA hai| sundara mitra mUlAzaya viruddha TIkAoM aura granthoM kA sahArA lekara Apake pUrvajoM ne aneka prANiyoM ko bhrama meM DAlA hai aura Apa bhI DAla rahe haiM, Apa meM yaha vRtti paramparA se calI A rahI hai, ataeva taskaravRtti ThagAI yA dhokhebAjI Apa hI logoM ke palle meM ina mandiroM aura mUrtiyoM ke calate bandhI hai, jo hama sthAnasthAna para batA rahe haiN| ___

Page #232
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA **************** ******** isake sivAya Apane prazna vyAkaraNa kA nAma dekara likhA hai ki " zrI RSijI ne vItabhaya pATaNa ke rAjA udAI kI svarNa gulikA dAsI ko ujjainI nagarI kA rAjA caNDa pradyotana le gayA itanA uddharaNa to de diyA" yaha TIkA ke AdhAra se hI para mUrti le jAne kI bAta chor3a dI vA itanI bAta binA mUla ke kyoM likhI ? ityAdi isake samAdhAna meM hamArA kahanA hai ki - prakaraNa abrahmacarya kA hai aura isa viSaya kI kathA Apa logoM kI ora se racI huI hai hI sAtha hI TIkA meM bhI ullekha hai, isI para se rAjAoM aura nagaroM ke nAma dekara saMkSepa meM hAla batA diyA, jo ki sUtrAzaya ko abAdhita hokara prakaraNa saMgata hai, kintu prakaraNa viruddha aisI kalpita bAta to Apa hI logoM ke mAnane kI hai Apake sivAya niSpakSa vicAraka to aisA aDaMgoM ko kadApi satya nahIM mAna sktaa| mahAnubhAva! aise eka hI nahIM, anekoM jagaha para Apa logoM ke pUrvajoM ne apanI caturAI aura vidvatA kA durupayoga kara vyartha ke aDaMge lagAye haiM | ApakA jitanA kathA sAhitya hai sabhI mandiroM aura mUrtiyoM ke raMga meM raMgA huA hai| zAyada hI aisA koI kathAnaka hogA jisameM mandiroM aura mUrtiyoM kA sambandha nahIM milAyA ho, yahAM taka ki sUtroM meM Aye hue kitane hI kathAnakoM meM mUla meM nahIM hone para bhI manamAne mandiroM aura mUrtiyoM ko caturAI pUrvaka sthAna de diyA gayA haiM, isI kA yaha pariNAma hai ki hajAroM loga isake cakkara meM Akara apanI gAr3hI kamAI ke paise ko kisI ucca kArya meM nahIM lagA kara IMTa, cUnA aura patthara meM DAlakara usase apanI mukti honA mAnate haiN| 187 sundara mitra ! zrImadbhagavatI sUtra za0 13 u0 6 meM vItabhaya nagara ke zrI udAyI rAjA aura prabhAvatI rAnI kA cAritra mUla pATha meM spaSTa rUpa se batAyA gayA hai jisameM yaha likhA hai ki -

Page #233
188 svarNa gulikA se mUrti kA mithyA sambandha ******************************************* "zrI udAyana rAjA eka samaya pauSadhazAlA meM dharmadhyAna meM samaya vyatIta kara rahe the, unake mana meM yaha bhAvanA huI ki - yadi zramaNa bhagavaMta vIra prabhu yahA~ padhAre to maiM unake pAsa vrata aMgIkAra karU~, prabhu rAjA ke manogata bhAva jAnakara campA se vItabhaya nagara padhAre rAjA ne dharmopadeza zravaNa kara apane putra ko rAjakIya jhaMjhaToM se bacAne aura AtmotthAna ke abhimukha karane ke vicAra se bhANeja kezIkumAra ko rAjya dekara dIkSA grahaNa kara Atma-kalyANa kiyaa|" zrImadbhagavatI sUtra meM basa itanA hI kathAnaka haiM, kintu kathAkAra mahAtmAoM ne inake viSaya kI kitanI hI anahonI ghaTanAyeM apanI kathAoM meM bhara dI, jisameM jahA~ dekho vahA~ mUrti to hai hI gIzIrSacandana kI mUrti kA vicitra prakAra se AnA aura rAnI kA mUrti ko peTI meM se nikAlanA, rAnI kA mUrti ke sAmane nAcanA aura rAjA kA bAjA bajAnA, rAnI kA nAcate hue mastaka rahita zarIra rAjA ko najara AnA, rAnI kA nAca bhaMga honA, eka dAsI kI hatyA, rAnI kA dIkSita honA, taba taka rAjA kA ajaina rahanA, phira pratimA ke sAtha dAsI kA ur3AyA jAnA, badale meM eka dUsarI mUrti kapila kevalI (nAcane vAle-tri0 za0 pu0 ca0) dvArA pratiSThita rakha denA, rAjAoM kA yuddha, mUrti kA camatkAra, nagarI bhaMga kA bhaviSya Adi kitanI hI bAteM kathA meM bhara dI gaI haiM, isameM bhI jahA~ dekho vahA~ mUrti hI mUrti, yaha spaSTa batA rahA hai ki kathAkAroM ne mUrti ke moha meM alamasta hokara kaI kalpanA zAstra raca DAle haiN| yahA~ taka ki aisA karate hue kahIM-kahIM to.sUtroM kI bhI upekSA kara baiThe, jaise ki sUtra meM to udAyI ko zramaNopAsaka batAyA hai aura binA kisI vizeSa prayatna ke apanI icchA se hI prabhu ke padhArane kI bhAvanA rakhane vAlA batAkara prabhu ke eka hI upadeza se dIkSita hone vAlA batalAyA hai,

Page #234
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ************* 186 ** **** taba kathAkAra udayana ko kaThinatA se aura prabhAvatI deva dvArA kitanI hI vAra pratibodha hone para dharma ke abhimukha hone kA likha rahe haiM / sUtrakAra prabhAvatI kI dIkSA ke lie mauna pakar3a rahe haiM, taba kathAkAra use mUrti ke sAmane nAcane aura vaha bhI mUrti moha meM itanI masta ki bhAna hI bhUla jAne vAlI tathA aniSTa sUcana se saMyama ke abhimukha hone vAlI aura saMyama lete-lete mUrti pUjA ke lie vastra meM pheraphAra dikhAI dene se eka dAsI ko yamapura pahuMcAne vAlI likha diyA hai| samajha meM nahIM AtA ki aise aupanyAsika DhaMga ke kathAnakoM para se hI sundara mitra kyoM bhAna bhUla hokara sAdhumArga samAja ke duzmana ho rahe haiN| hama to yahI cAheMge ki sundara hRdaya meM anantAnubandhI kI cANDAla caukar3I baiThI ho to vaha apanA sthAna haTA zIghra le, jisase inakI AtmA kA bhalA ho / (27) sthApanA satya meM samajha phera kitane hI mUrti pUjaka jAnate hue bhI bhole logoM meM yaha bhrama phailAte haiM ki dekho ThANA aura prajJApanA sUtra meM " sthApanA satya" kaha kara mUrti pUjA kI satyatA svIkAra kI hai aura isI prakAra jJAnasundarajI ne bhI bhrama phailAyA hai, kintu ina logoM kA yaha prayatna satya se dUra hai, isa viSaya meM vizeSa spaSTatA ke lie hama sAre mUla pATha yahA~ de dete haiM "dasavihe sacce pa0 taM0 jaNavaya, sammaya, ThavaNA, nAme, rUve, paDucca - sacceya, vavahAra, bhAva, joge, dasame ovamma sacceya / " (ThANAMga sUtra ThA0 10 )

Page #235
160 **** sthApanA satya meM samajha phera ***** athavA - "jaNavaya sacce, samudita sacce, ThavaNA sacce, nAma sacce, rUva sacce, paDUcca sacce, vavahAra sacce, bhAva sacce, joga sacce, uvamma sacce / " (pannavaNA sUtra kA 11 vAM bhASApada) arthAt - daza prakAra kA satya kahA, yathA - 1. janapada satya 2. saMmata satya 3. sthApanA satya 4 6. pratItya satya 7. vyavahAra satya 8 10 aura upamA satya / . isa prakAra daza prakAra ke satya meM tIsarA nambara sthApanA satya kA hai, jisakA tAtparya yaha hai ki sthApanA ko bhI satya mAnanA arthAtsthApanA ko sthApanA mAnanA, isakA niSedha nahIM karanA, kintu isakA yaha matalaba nahIM ki sthApanA ko usakI sImA yA upayogitA se sivAya mahattva dekara usake sAtha sAkSAt sA vyayahAra krnaa| jisa prakAra rupaye paise ke citra ko na to sAkSAt rupayA yA paisA mAnanA aura na use rupaye Adi kI sthApanA mAnane se inkAra karanA, jambudvIpa ke nakze ko nakzA mAnanA satya hai, kintu use hI jambudvIpa mAna lenA sImollaMghana kara jAne se satya ke bajAya mithyA ho jAtA hai| hAthI ghor3e ke miTTI ke bane hue khilaunoM ko hAthI ghor3e kI sthApanA mAnanA satya hai, para sAkSAt mAnanA mithyA hai, rAjA yA samrATa ke citra ko citra mAnanA satya hai, para citra ko hI sAkSAt mAnanA aura usake sAmane bheMTa Adi rakhanA mithyA hai| yahI sthApanA satya kA paramArtha hai / ise hama avazya mAnate haiM, kintu jo loga sthApanA ko sImAtIta mAna dete. haiM, ve satya ko chor3akara mithyA pravRtti karane vAle hote haiM, yadi sAMsArika vyavahAroM meM bhI dekhA jAya to sthApanA kA yahI upayoga nAma satya 5 rUpa satya bhAva satya 6. yoga satya

Page #236
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 191 hotA huA dikhAI degaa| choTe se lekara bar3e vidyAlayoM meM bhaugolika nakze mAtra dikhAne ke lie hI rakkhe hue mileMge, aneka prakAra ke citra mAtra dekhane ke lie hI rakhe jAyeMge, ajAyabagharoM meM aneka prakAra ke citra aura mUrtiyeM rakkhI huI mileMgI vo bhI kevala dekhane ke lie hI na ki usakI hada ko chor3akara adhika-sImAtIta-vyavahAra karane ke lie| aisI sUrata meM sthApanA satya kI oTa lekara usase mUrti pUjA karane kA pramANa mAna lenA satya ko jhUTha aura dina ko rAta kahane ke samAna hai| jabaki nAma satya ko guNa se na milAkara kevala nAma hI ko mAnA jAtA hai, taba sthApanA satya ko adhika mahattva dene kA kyA matalaba hai? svayaM TIkAkAra bhI kula vRddhi ke guNa se rahita aise kula varddhana nAma ko bhI nAma satya kahate haiM aura rUpa satya meM kisI bhAMDa ne sAdhu kA veza pahana liyA ho to use kevala rUpa mAtra se hI satya kahate haiM (isase adhika guNa Adi se nahIM) dekho TIkAkAra kA mt| "nAmataHsatyA nAma satyA yathA kulamavarddhayannapi kulavarddhana iti, tathA rUpataH satyA rUpa satyAyathA daMbhato gRhIta pravrajita rUpaH prjaajitiiymiti|" (prajJApanA sUtra bAbU0 patra 372) isI prakAra vyavahAra satya kA bhI smjheN| isa viSaya meM bhI TIkAkAra ne udAharaNa diyA hai ki - jaise ki parvata para ke ghAsa Adi ke jalane para parvata jalane aura bhAjana meM se pAnI Tapakate bhAjana Tapakane kA kahanA loka vyavahAra se satya hai, vaise hI yoga satya meM daMDa ke yoga se daNDI, chatra ke yoga se chatrI kahanA yoga satya hai| tAlAba ko samudra kI upamA denA aupamya satya hai| ina sabakA matalaba sImA meM raha kara mAnane se hai aura vahIM taka mAne to satya hai anyathA adhika mAnane para mithyA ho jAtA hai| yadi kulavRddhi ke guNa se rahita vyakti ke kula

Page #237
192 DaoN0 haramana jekobI kA aTala abhiprAya ********Li Hong ********************************** varddhana nAma mAtra se use kulavRddhikara mAnA jAya to vahI satya mithyA ho jAyegA, dravya veSadhArI ko hI sAdhu mAna lene para yaha bhI mithyA ho jaayegaa| tAlAba ko hI samudra mAnane se yaha bhI jhUTha ho jaaygaa| isI taraha sthApanA ko hI sAkSAt mAnane yA sAkSAt ke samAna vaMdanA namaskAra aura pUjAdi karane se sthApanA satya nahIM raha kara mithyA ho jAtA hai| isalie sundara mitra ko pakSapAta chor3akara zuddha hRdaya se vicAra kara satya ko grahaNa karanA cAhie aura yaha spaSTa svIkAra karanA cAhie ki sthApanA satya kI oTa mUrti pUjA ke anukUla nahIM, kintu pratikUla hokara utsUtra prarUpaNA ke samAna hai| (28) DaoN. haramana jekobI kA aTala abhiprAya ___ mUrti pUjA ke prAcIna itihAsa pR0 146 meM DaoN. haramana jekobI ke mUrti pUjA viSayaka diye hue ajamera ke abhiprAya kA khaNDana karate hue zrI jJAnasundara jI likhate haiM ki - DaoN0 haramana sAhaba kA AkharI abhiprAya hai ki - "jaina AgamoM meM mUrti pUjA kA vidhAna hai" kintu sundara mitra kA yaha kathana bhI ThIka nahIM hai| vAstavikatA to yaha hai ki DaoN0 haramana jekobI sAhaba ko ajamera ke samasta (tInoM phirakoM ke) jaina gRhasthoM ne eka sabhA karake mAna patra diyA tathA sAtha hI jaina divAkara kI padavI bhI pradAna kI, usa samaya DaoN0 sAhaba ne apane bhASaNa meM yaha bhI kahA thA ki - "aMgopAMga meM kisI bhI jagaha mUrti pUjA kA vidhAna nahIM hai" DaoN0 mahodaya ke ina zabdoM ne mUrtipUjakoM meM halacala mcaadii| isI samaya jodhapura meM zrI dharmavijayajI jaina sAhitya

Page #238
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 163 ********************** *********** sammelana karA rahe the vahA~ ukta DaoN0 mahodaya ko bhI AmaMtraNa diyA gayA thaa| DaoN0 sAhaba jodhapura pahuMce, ApakA svAgata dhUmadhAma se huaa| Apako zrI dharmavijayajI se milAyA, zrI dharmavijayajI ne ApakI khUba prazaMsA kI aura ajamera ke diye hue bhASaNa se Apane apanA va sArI mUrti pUjaka samAja kA apamAna honA batAyA aura sAtha hI sUryAbha tathA draupadI ke mUrti pUjana kA havAlA dekara jainAgamoM meM mUrti pUjA kA ullekha honA batAyA, bAda meM apanA ajamera kA abhiprAya badalane ke lie nivedana kiyaa| DaoNkTara mahodaya yadyapi yaha jAnate the ki inakI dalIleM nissAra haiM, tathApi inake Adara satkAra se aura inheM bhI khUza rakhane ke vicAra se yaha kaha diyA ki jainAgamoM meM mUrti pUjA kA vidhAna hai| basa phira kyA thA? mIra mAra liyA aura isI para zrI jJAnasundarajI phUla rahe haiM, kintu isameM inake phUlane kI bAta nahIM hai| kyoMki jaba ina logoM ne DaoNkTara sAhaba ko ukta abhiprAya jAhira kiyA, taba sthAnakavAsI jaina saMsAra kA isakA patA lagA, usa samaya paMjAba ke sahadharmI bandhuoM kA eka DepuTezana DaoNkTara sAhaba kI sevA meM gyaa| jisakA mukhya kAraNa AcArAMga sUtra ke bhASAMtara ke bhramajanaka artha kA spaSTIkaraNa karane kA thA, isa DepuTezana meM jaina saMsAra ke prasiddha tattvajJa svargIya zrI vAr3IlAla motIlAla zAha bhI sammilita hue the, usa samaya DaoNkTara sAhaba ke mUrti pUjA sambandhI jodhapura ke abhiprAya ke sambandha meM DaoNkTara sAhaba se khulAsA mAMgA, jisakA uttara jo DaoNkTara sAhaba ne diyA vaha usI samaya ke "jaina hitecchu varSa 16 aMka 3-4 mArca aprela san 1914 ke pR0 276 meM" paMjAba sthA0 jaina saMgha nu DepyuTezana zIrSaka lekha ke pR0 280 meM gujarAtI bhASA meM nimna prakAra se chapA hai -

Page #239
DaoN0 haramana jekobI kA aTala abhiprAya *************** "mUrti pUjA nA pAThavAlA amUka granthoM mhane batAvavAmAM AvyA hatA, parantu teTalA parathI tIrthaMkaroMe mUrti pUjA upadezyAnI bAta huM hajI mAnI zakyo na thI / " 164 yaha DaoNkTara mahodaya kA AkhirI maMtavya hai, jo ki aTala aura sarvathA satya hai| kyA aba bhI jodhapura vAlA mantavya kucha artha rakhatA hai ? nahIM, isake sivAya svayaM sundara mitra ne bhI apanI isa pustaka pR0 147 paMkti 13 meM yaha svIkAra kiyA hai ki - "agara Apane sUtra pahale dekhe bhI the to vizeSa kara AcAra sambandhI hI / " isa para se bhI yaha to spaSTa ho gayA ki DaoNkTara mahodaya ne AcAra sambandhI sUtroM meM mUrti pUjA kA vidhAna nahIM dekhA, isI para se unhoMne apane bhASaNa meM kahA ki aMgopAMgoM meM mUrti pUjA kA vidhAna nahIM hai, isa abhiprAya ko sundara mitra bhI sacce hRdaya kA abhiprAya batAte hue likhate haiM ki : - "yaha unake nikhAlasa aura pakSapAta rahita hRdaya kI bAta hai / " ( pR0 148 paM0 1) isalie AcAra granthoM ke abhyAsa aura pakSapAta rahita nikhAli tathA svaccha hRdaya kA mUrti pUjA viSayaka vaha abhiprAya ( ki mU0 pU0 kA vidhAna aMgopAMgoM meM nahIM hai) hI satya aura AdaraNIya ho sakatA hai aura isI para se kahA jAtA hai ki mUrti pUjA kA vidhAna sUtroM meM nahIM haiN| kintu sundara bandhu phirakI khAne meM bhI bar3e hoziyAra haiM, nikhAlisa hRdaya kI pakSapAta rahita bAta batA kara Age pR0 148 paM0 2 meM Apa apanA bacAva karane ke lie kahate haiM ki - "unhoMne yaha to nahIM kahA ki jainAgamoM meM mUrti pUjA hai hI nahIM / "

Page #240
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA 165 ***** ********** maiM ina marudhara mahArathI sundara mitra se pUchatA hUM ki jaba mUrti pUjA AcAra vidhAna ke sUtroM meM nahIM to kyA anAcAra ke sUtroM meM hai ? yadi Apa DaoNkTara sAhaba ke isa abhiprAya ko satya aura svaccha hRdaya kA mAnakara mUrti pUjA AcAra pratipAdaka sUtroM meM nahIM hone kA svIkAra karate haiM to maiM Apase yaha bhI pUchatA hU~ ki yadi ApakI mAnya mUrti pUjA AcAra vidhAna meM nahIM hokara anya kisI kathA Adi ke granthoM meM ho to usakA mUlya hI kyA hai? kathAnakoM meM to hiMsA, jhUTha, corI, vyabhicAra, yuddha Adi viSayaka ullekha bhI hai to kyA AcAra vidhAna nahIM hone para bhI Apa kathAoM Adi meM hone se inheM mAnya kara leMge ? sundara bandhu ? aba bhI kyA huA? Apa meM yA Apake vijaya dharmasUrijI ke vaMzajoM meM mUrti pUjA Atma-kalyANa upAdeya aura prabhu vIra kI AjJA yukta siddha karane kI zakti ho to zIghra hI vaise pramANa jAhira kariye jisase sArA bakher3A miTa jAya / sundarajI likhate haiM ki "AcArya mahArAja ne DaoNkTara sAhaba ko bhagavatI, jJAtA, upAsaka dazAMga, prazna vyAkaraNa, uvavAI, rAja praseNI, jIvAbhigama Adi aneka zAstroM meM mUrti pUjA viSayaka pATha batAye ? DaoNkTara sAhaba ko bar3A hI Azcarya huA tathA satya hRdaya meM mUrtti pUjA ko saharSa svIkAra kiyA / " bar3e Azcarya kA viSaya haiM ki - pahale to DaoNkTara sAhaba binA yaha abhiprAya de rahe haiM - "aMgoM aura upAMgoM meM koI khulAsA jikra mUrti pUjA kA nahIM hai|" aura idhara sundara mitra ginA rahe haiM ki ye sUtra bhI aMgopAMga meM ke hI haiM, phira pahale anumati dete samaya to sUtroM meM mUrti pUjA kA jikra nahIM thA aura bAda meM A gayA, isakA khAsa kAraNa hameM to yahI mAlUma huA hai ki DaoNkTara sAhaba eka to AbhAra meM

Page #241
166 **** DaoN. haramana jekobI kA aTala abhiprAya ***** hue the aura phira vAtAvaraNa hI sArA mUrti pUjA ke pakSa kA thA / tIsarA inheM aprasanna bhalA ve kyoM karane lage? basa inhIM kAraNoM se DaoNkTara mahodaya ne apanA abhiprAya badalA, kintu inakA khAsa hArdika abhiprAya to vahI thA, jo pahale de cuke the aura jisakI puSTi bAda meM bhI unhoMne paMjAba ke sthAnakavAsI jaina saMgha ke DepuTezana aura zrI vAr3IlAla motIlAla zAha ke sammukha kI, isalie DaoNkTara mahodaya kA mUrti pUjA ke viruddha jo abhiprAya hai vaha satya aura aTala hai| sundara mitra ! itanA hI nahIM DaoNkTara mahodaya ne hinda ke bAhara jarmana se bhI aisA hI abhiprAya diyA hai, jahA~ ki sthAnakavAsI samAja kA eka baccA bhI unakI dRSTi ke sAmane nahIM thA / svargIya sAkSara zrImAn kezarIcandajI sAhaba bhaMDArI devAsa nivAsI ne apanI aMgrejI pustaka "noTsa ona dhI sthAnakavAsI jaina" DaoNkTara sAhaba kI sevA meM bhejI thI, jisake uttara meM DaoNkTara sAhaba neM zrI bhaMDArI jI ko eka patra diyA thA usameM bhI unhoMne yaha svIkAra kiyA hai ki mUrti pUjA jainadharma kA mUla tattva nahIM haiM, dekhiye unakA patra | ( prabhuvIra paTTAvalI pR0 133 se) Dear Sir, Your kind letter of 9th instand the copy of the "Notes on the Sthanakwasi jains" Reached me here for away from Bombay. I have read the booklet with great interest and shall give notice of it in my report on Jainism which appears every second year in the archive for history of religiona German Journal being away from my book. I cannot inter into details of the subjects but if I

Page #242
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 167 am not greatly mistaken I have somewhere expressed my opinion that worship in temples is not an original element of jain religion, but has been introduced in order to meet the devotional requirements of the deity. the practice of idol worship seems to be pretty old, though not as old as the composition of the Siddhanta. It seems to have been substituted for the worship of Yakshas and other popular deities and demons which seems to have obtained at the time of Mahavira among the people at large a kind of religons sect which formed no part of the jain creed though it was to Ireated by the early Church looked at from this point of view, the worship of the Tirthankars is clearly an improvement Since a purer object of adoration was substituted for one of little or no moral dignity though originally (and I think even now) worship was not and is not theoretically considered as a means of attaining Nirvrati. I should like the obtain more accurate knowledge abut the history of your sect which are the agamas you do acknowledge? have you any old shastras in Sanskrit or magdhi which teach the tenets of the Sthanakwashis? Caniget a Pattawali of your Yatis ? Dated 29-8-1911. Yours sincerely (Sd.) H Jacobi..

Page #243
168 stUpa nirmANa kA kAraNa ************************: isa patra meM DaoNkTara sAhaba ne spaSTa likhA hai ki - "devAlayo mUrti kI pUjA yaha jaina dharma kA mUla tattva nahIM hai kintu devI devatAo kI bhakti kI AvazyakatA ko pUrI karane ke lie yaha prathA calAI gaI haiM, mUrti pUjA kI prathA bahuta purAnI hai kintu sUtroM ke jitanI prAcIna nahIM hai| mahAvIra ke samaya meM eka taraha kA dhArmika paMtha ki jo jaina tattva se kucha bhI sambandha nahIM rakhatA thA, vo deva mandiroM ko mAnatA thA, usa paMtha ke lokoM meM adhika pracAra pAI huI yakSa aura dUsare loka mAnya devI devatA aura maile devatAoM ko pUjA ke badale yaha mUrti pUjA prArambha huI aisA pAyA jAtA hai|" Adi isa para se bhI yahI siddha hotA hai ki - DaoNkTara sAhaba kA mata mUrti pUjA meM jainatva mAnane kA hargija nahIM hai aura mUrti pUjA ke viruddha unakA jo abhiprAya hai vahI satya aura aTala hai| " (29) stUpa nirmANa kA kAraNa zrI jJAnasundarajI ne AgamoM meM stUpa sambandhI Aye hue ullekhoM bhI mUrti pUjA siddha karane kI ceSTA kI haiM aura aisA hI prayatna do cAra varSa pahale zrI nyAyavijayajI ne bhI kiyA thA, kintu yaha bhI prayatna vastu sthiti ko na samajha kara hI janatA ko bhUlAve meM DAlane kA hai, vastutaH stUpa nirmANa kA kAraNa mahApuruSoM kA smAraka rakhane kA hI hai| jisa sthAna para kisI aitihAsika mahA puruSa ke zava ko jalAyA gayA ho usa sthAna para kucha smAraka banA diyA jAya use stUpa kahate haiM / jaba tIrthaMkara mahArAja kA nirvANa hotA thA taba unake zava kI *****

Page #244
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA . 196 ******************************************* dAha kriyA ke sthAna para unake zraddhAlu bhakta stUpa banavA dete the, isa viSaya kA varNana zrI jambudvIpa prajJapti sUtra meM AyA hai, vahA~ likhA hai ki jaba prathama tIrthaMkara zrI RSabhadeva jI kA nirvANa huA taba indrAdi devoM ne manuSya loka meM Akara viziSTa prakAra se dAha kriyA kI, tatpazcAt indra devoM ko AjJA detA hai ki - "taraNaM sakke deviMde devarAyA bahave bhavaNavai jAva vemANie deve jahAriaMevaM vayAsI, khippAmeva bho devANuppiA! savvarayaNAmae mahae mahAlae tau ceiathUbhekarei, egabhagavau titthagarassa ciigAe, egaM gaNadhara ciigAe egaM avasesANaM aNagArANaM ciigAe taeNaM te bahave jAva kreti|" isa mUla pATha kA yaha artha hai ki - jaba zakra devendra devarAja una bahuta se bhavanapati yAvat vaimAnika devoM se aisA kahate haiM ki aho devatAoM ke pyAre! zIghra hI sarva prakAra ke ratnoM se bar3e aura vizAla aise tIna caitya-stUpa nirmANa karo, eka tIrthaMkara bhagavAn ke citA sthAna para, eka gaNadhara kI citA sthAna para aura eka bAkI ke sAdhuoM kI citA ke sthAna pr| usI prakAra una saba devatAoM ne kiyaa| ukta Agama pramANa se pAThaka sahaja hI samajha sakeMge ki ye caitya stUpa mahApuruSoM ke dAhasthAna para yAdagAra yA usa sthAna para aura kisI prakAra kI calane phirane Adi kI kriyA nahIM ho sake, isa kAraNa se bane haiN| isa kriyA meM do hetu hI mukhyataH hote haiM, eka to una mahApuruSoM kI hajAroM varSoM taka yAdagAra rahatI hai, dUsarA una mAnanIya pUjanIya mahAtmAoM kI dAhabhUmi para koI paira Adi nahIM lagA sake yA malamUtrAdi na kara ske| basa aise hI kAraNoM ko lekara ye caitya stUpa zraddhAvAn

Page #245
200 stUpa nirmANa kA kAraNa *********************** ****** bhaktoM kI tarapha se bane haiN| yaha prathA hajAroM hI nahIM lAkhoM varSoM se calI A rahI hai| hA~ isa kriyA meM samayAnusAra parivartana to bahuta huA aura bhaviSya meM hotA rahegA, kintu mUla uddezya yahI thA / yaha bAta dUsarI hai ki saikar3oM varSoM se isakA mUla uddezya badala kara dhArmikatA meM pariNita ho gayA, ise kahate haiM vikRti aura aisI vikRti sAmAnya janatA se AsAnI se cala sakatI hai / jaise ki - kisI eka samAjaM yA sampradAya ke mAnya mahApuruSa ke dehotsarga ke sthAna para unake anuyAyI kisI prakAra kA smAraka banAte haiM, to usase bhinna samAja vAle bhI aise avasaroM para pahale ke smAraka se kucha adhika vizeSatA vAlA smAraka taiyAra karate haiN| yahI nahIM para jaba do bhinna sampradAyoM meM Apasa meM saMgharSa ho uThatA hai taba donoM ke mana meM eka dUsare kA apamAna karane ke vicAra paidA hote haiM aura unameM se kucha ugra vicAra vAle aise bhI hote haiM jo virodhI sampradAya ke mAnya smAraka ko naSTa kara DAlane kA yatna karate haiM (islAma yuga meM hindU mandiroM kA bhaMga isa bAta kA spaSTa udAharaNa hai) jaba eka sampradAya vAloM ko yaha bhaya hotA hai ki kahIM hamAre mAnanIya mahApuruSa kA smAraka hamAre virodhI naSTa kara deMge to ve isake lie usa smAraka para pahare Adi kA prabandha karate haiM, isa prakAra rakSA kI dRSTi se vahA~ manuSyoM ke rahane kI AvazyakatA hotI hai, hote hote ve hI smAraka mandira mUrti kA rUpa le lete haiM aura rakSaka loga pujArI Adi bana jAte haiM tathA sAmAjika loga usakI pUjA Adi meM dharma mAnane laga jAte haiM, yadi merA anumAna ThIka hai to maiM kaha sakatA hU~ ki - ye pUjAdi ke varaghor3e, rathayAtrA, mUrtiyoM ke julUsa Adi kA janma bhI prAyaH virodhiyoM ko aura unakI samAja ko nIcA dikhAne aura apanI mahattA batAne ke uddezya se huA ho|

Page #246
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA 201 ******************************** ************ yaha smAraka nirmANa kevala jainiyoM meM hI hai, aisA koI nahIM samajhe / yaha prathA lagabhaga sabhI samAjoM meM aura prAyaH saMsAra bhara meM hai / bhAratavarSa meM bhI bar3e-bar3e zaharoM meM aneka zAsakoM, janamAnya adhikAriyoM, zrImantoM, deza netAoM aura jana sevakoM ke smAraka vartamAna kAla meM maujUda haiM, , jo hajAroM ke kharce se aura ucca kalA ko lekara bane haiN| isake sivAya smAraka bhI kaI prakAra ke bane aura bana rahe haiM, jaise - yuddha meM vijaya pAne para vijayastambha vijaya kA smAraka, kisI jAtIya mahAsabhA ke virATa adhivezana para-adhivezana smAraka, tapa kA smAraka, (harijanoM ke lie mahAtmAjI ne pUnA meM upavAsa kiye the, tapa pUrti ke dina smAraka vRkSa lagAyA gayA thA) dAnavIroM kA smAraka ( aneka saMsthAoM meM taila citra rakhe jAte haiM) jayantI smAraka ( vArSikotsava manAnA) Adi aneka prakAra ke smAraka haiM, kintu kucha anya zraddhAlu janatA ke sivAya sabhI jagaha ye smAraka, smAraka rUpa hI rahe haiN| ukta vastu sthiti para vicAra karane para hamAre pAThaka yaha samajha gaye hoMge ki mahApuruSoM ke caitya- stUpa andhabhakti ke lie nahIM bane, na pUjA pAne ke lie bane, kintu smaraNArtha yA sthAna kI pavitratA banAne rakhane ke lie hI bane haiN| lekina samaya pAkara ye smAraka pUje jAne lge| svArtha pipAsuoM ne bhI isameM khUba hAtha baTAyA, jisakI bhayaMkaratA yahA~ taka phailI ki ye caityAlaya bhogAlaya kI barAbarI karane lage! yahA~ taka ki vezyA kA nRtya bhI dharma ke nAma para ina dharma mandiroM meM hone lagA ( prabhAvaka caritra ) / vAstava meM ina caityoM aura stUpoM se AtmakalyANakArI dharma kA koI sambandha nahIM hai| jainAgamoM meM to ina caityoM, stUpoM aura devAlayoM ke banAne meM Arambha samAraMbha (pApa) mAnA hai| prazna vyAkaraNa sUtra isakA sAkSI hai, usameM hiMsA janaka kAryoM meM isa taraha ke zabda haiN|

Page #247
202 stUpa nirmANa kA kAraNa ******************************************** ... "citi vetiya khAtiya ArAma vihAra thUma, pAgAra.......AyaNa cetiya devkul|" Adi isa prakAra hiMsA janaka kAryoM meM stUpa, caitya, devAyatana kA bhI samAveza hai, inake banAne meM bhI hiMsA hotI hai, dhArmika dRSTi se to hiMsA ko pApakArI tathA kaSTaprada hI mAnA jAyagA, laukika vyavahAra se bhale hI ise apanAyA jAya, kintu jo zramaNa ahiMsAdi mahAvratadhArI haiM ve to kisI bhI taraha inake banavAne yA inheM pUjane pUjavAne kA upadeza nahIM de sakate, na isa kriyA meM dharma kA honA hI kaha sakate haiN| kintu bar3A Azcarya hai ki kitane hI sAdhu nAmadhArI loga zramaNadharma ke viruddha mandira mUrtiyeM banavAne kA upadeza aura Adeza dete haiM, pUjA karane va karavAne kA Agraha kara Asrava vRddhi karate hue usameM dharma honA mAnate haiN| yaha amRta meM viSa aura pAnI meM Aga ke samAna nahIM to kyA hai? ___ jabaki AcArAMga sUtra dharmArtha sthAvara jIvoM kI bhI hatyAkarane vAle ko vaha hatyA ahitakArI batAte haiM aura eka anya sthAna para dharma ke lie hiMsA karane vAle kA pApI zramaNa ke kuvizeSaNa se paricaya karAte haiM, taba jaina zramaNa kA nAma rakhakara bhI aisI hiMsA ko jAnabUjhakara karavAne vAloM ke lie kevala dayA lAne ke sivAya aura kyA kiyA jAya? sundara mitra! caitya yA stUpa pUjA meM Atma kalyANa nahIM hai, yaha to sirpha laukika pravRtti hai, isakI pUjA meM Atma-kalyANa rUpa dharma mAna lenA apanI buddhi kA divAlA pITanA hai, yadi Apako ina stUpoM aura caityoM kA vizeSa hAla jAnanA hai to Apa apanI hI mUrti pUjaka samAja ke labdha pratiSTha vidvAn paM0 becaradAsa jI dozI likhita "jaina sAhitya mAM vikAra thavAthI thayelI hAnI' nAmaka pustaka par3heM, usameM spaSTa batAyA gayA hai ki mUla meM ye caitya stUpAdi pUjA kI vastu nahIM

Page #248
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 203 **************************************** thI, kintu samaya pAkara vikRti ne paira pasArA aura ye pUjya bana gye| isake sivAya banArasa se prakAzita hone vAlI nAgarI pracAriNI patrikA meM paM0 candradhara zarmA kA "devakula' viSayaka lekha kA nimna avataraNa par3hiye, ApakA saMzaya dUra hokara satya vastu dikhAI degaa| "deva pUjA kA pitR pUjA se bar3A sambandha hai| deva pUjA pitR pUjA se hI calA hai, mandira ke lie sabase purAnA nAma caitya hai, jisakA artha cittA (dAha sthAna) para banAyA huA smAraka hai| zatapatha brAhmaNa meM ullekha hai ki zarIra ko bhasma karake dhAtuoM meM hiraNya kA Tukar3A milAkara una para stUpa kA cayana (cunanA) kiyA jAtA thaa| buddha ke zarIra-dhAtuoM ke vibhAga tathA una para sthAna-sthAna para stUpa banane kI kathA prasiddha hI hai! bauddhoM tathA jainoM ke stUpa aura caitya pahale smAraka cihna the phira pUjya ho gye|" __ sundara bandhu! vAstava meM Apa logoM ne aura Apake pUrvajoM ne smAraka cihnoM ko hI pUjya banA diyA hai, jo ki anucita hai ataeva aba bhI Apako sarala buddhi se samajha kara haTha ko chor3a denA caahie| (30) bhakti yA apamAna sAdhumArgI samAja para pUrI kRpA rakhane vAle zrI jJAnasundara jI mahArAja ne pR0 176 meM mUrti kI pAnI aura puSpoM se pUjA karane meM kucha asabhya apa zabdoM ke bAda eka yukti prastuta kI hai jo nimna prakAra se haiN| jaise kisI manuSya ke ghara eka paropakArI puruSa calA jAveM aura ghara vAle ko usa puruSa se bhaviSya meM mahAn lAbha hone kI AzA ho jAve to vaha gharapati apanI zakti, sampatti aura adhikAra ke sadbhAva

Page #249
bhakti yA apamAna ******************* meM hokara usa paropakArI puruSa kI sevA aura svAgata hI kregaa| Apa hI batalAiye ki Apake mana meM aise paropakArI puruSa ke dekhate hI kyA pUjyabhAva paidA na hogA? kyA Apa unakI apanI zakti ke anusAra puSpAdi se pUjA nahIM kareMge? yadi hA~, to phira usa parama prabhu ke viSaya meM hI ye nirmUla zaMkAyeM kyoM kI jAtI haiM? 204 sundara mitra zAyada yaha bhUle hue haiM ki Adara satkAra yA pUjA AdaraNIya pUjya ke anukUla rucikara vastuoM se hotI hai pratikUla aura tyAjya padArthoM se nahIM, yadi koI manuSya apane yahA~ Aye hue Adara pAtra sajjana ke svAgata karane meM unake pratikUla ghRNita vastueM kAma meM legA to isase vaha Agata sajjana prasanna nahIM hokara ulTA nArAja ho jAyagA, jaise ki zrI hemacandrAcArya ne RSabhacaritra meM likhA hai ki jaba prathama jinezvara zrI AdinAtha svAmI bhikSAcarI ke lie nikalate taba kitane hI bhAvuka unakI AvazyakatA ke padArthoM kI anukUlatA ko na samajha kara unake sAmane hIre, javAhirAta, hAthI, ghor3e, kumArikAyeM aura puSpamAlAyeM Adi pratikUla anAvazyaka aura tyAgI huI vastueM lAte gaye, jinheM prabhu svIkAra nahIM karate the * anta meM zreyAMsakumAra ke dvArA diyA huA acitta ikSu rasa, jo ki prabhu keM anukUla thA, grahaNa kiyA gayA / isI se yaha samajha lenA cAhie ki pUjA pUjya ke anukUla aura upayogI vastuoM se hI karanI cAhie, usI pUjA ko pUjya svIkAra karate haiM, vahI pUjA pUjA hai| isake viparIta pUjya kI ruci ke pratikUla sAmagrI se kI huI pUjA vAstava meM pUjA nahIM, apamAna hai / 'dekho triSaSThizalAkA puruSa caritra parva 1 sarga 3 |

Page #250
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 205 ******************************************* __ aura dekhiye - zrI anAthI muni ko samrAT zreNika ne bhoga kA nimaMtraNa diyA, dhana daulata aura sundariyoM se unheM samRddha kara ucca prakAra se sevA karane kI prArthanA kii| kintu isa viparIta sevA ko zrI anAthI muni ne svIkAra nahIM kiyA aura anta meM pUjya kI yogyatA aura ruci ke pratikUla bhoga vilAsa kI prArthanA karane ke phala svarUpa zreNika ko pUjya se kSamA yAcanA karake pachatAvA karanA pdd'aa| isake atirikta Apake udAharaNa ke uttara meM nimna udAharaNa aura lIjiye - eka rAjapUta jo sadaiva madirApAna aura mAMsa bhakSaNa karatA hai, usake ghara yadi koI sAtvika prakRti kA jaina yA brAhmaNa calA jAya to vaha usa atithi ke sAmane usakI ruci ke anukUla sAtvika vastueM hI rakhegA, balki jaba taka Agata atithi usake yahA~ rahegA taba taka vaha svayaM bhI apeya aura akhAdya vastu se dUra rahegA, taba hI usakA satkAra una mehamAnoM ke anukUla hokara svIkArya hogaa| kintu isase viparIta yadi vaha rAjapUta una brahmadeva ke sAmane madirA kI pyAlI rakhakara pIne kI prArthanA kare aura akhAdya vastu dikhAkara nivedana kare ki - mahAtman! pAvana kIjiye, aisI dazA meM usa kSatriya kI prArthanA usa dvijavarya ke lie svIkArya hogI kyA? usa rAjapUta ke aise vyavahAra ko vaha brAhmaNa kyA samajhegA? Adara yA apamAna? sundara mitra! Apa apane ko hI lIjiye, jaba Apa bhikSA ke lie kisI zraddhAlu bhakta ke yahAM padhAreM, taba vaha bhakta Apase snAna karane kA Agraha kare aura phira kucha phala-anAra, saMtare, seva, aMgUra, kakar3I, kharabUjA, tarabUja, pAna ke bIr3e, ilAyacI Adi rakhe, itra se bhara kara itradAnI hAjira kare, gAdI bichAkara pATalA rakha de aura phira Apase hAtha jor3akara prArthanA kare ki bhagavan! birAjiye, pAvana

Page #251
206 bhakti yA apamAna ******************************************* kiijiye| batAiye mahAtman? Apa ise bhakti samajheMge? bhale hI ApakA mana macala jAya aura muMha meM pAnI A jAya, para Upara se to nA nA kahakara khisakane lgeNge| yadi bhakta anajAna huA to samajhAyeMge ki hama tyAgI haiM, hamArI bhakti isa prakAra nahIM hotI, hama aisI vastuoM ko svIkAra nahIM karate Adi kintu yadi Apako yaha mAlUma ho jAya ki bhakta ne jAna bUjhakara hamArI ruci ke viruddha vastuyeM hamAre sAmane rakhI haiM, taba to Apa use apanA dveSI yA virodhI hI samajheMge aura usake kRtya ko apamAna hI smjheNge| uparokta udAharaNa se jarA sarala buddhi se yaha samajho ki tIrthaMkara prabhu sarva sampatti ke tyAgI, SaTkAya jIvoM ke rakSaka, dayA kA prakhara pracAra kara jo sacitta pAnI, puSpa, bIja, harI, phala, dhUpa Adi ko chUte hI nhiiN| apane zramaNa putroM ko bhI ina vastuoM ko chUne se rokate haiN| inakA chUnA mahAvratiyoM ke lie niSiddha ThaharAte haiN| unhIM mahA dayAlu sarvopari ahiMsaka prabhuoM ke nAma se unakI mUrti para una niSiddha vastuoM ko car3hAkara usameM Apa prabhu pUjA honA mAnate haiN| yaha sarAsara andhera khAtA nahIM to kyA hai? vAstava meM ApakI yaha kahI jAne vAlI pUjA, prabhu pUjA nahIM, para prabhu kA apamAna hai| ___mahAzaya! puSpAdi se pUjA gRhasthoM kI yA laukika devoM kI hotI hai kyoMki ve isake bhogI aura cAhane vAle haiN| kintu lokottara tIrthaMkara prabhuoM yA unake anagAra bhagavantoM kI nahIM, prabhu kI pUjA to vizuddha tana mana se unakI AjJA pAlane se hI hotI hai aura zramaNa bhagavantoM ko unake anukUla acitta AhArAdi dene se hotI hai| isase viruddha karane ko pUjA nahIM kintu apamAna kahate haiM isalie hamArA kathana nirmUla aura yukti rahita nahIM, kintu maulika aura yuktiyukta hai|

Page #252
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 207 ********************Xue Xue Hui Xue *****************Duo Ci isakA Adara karane se hI AtmA kA bhalA ho skegaa| anyathA ApakA aura sAtha-sAtha Apake vacanoM para vizvAsa rakhakara trasa tathA sthAvara jIvoM kI pUjA ke nAma para hatyA karane vAle andha zraddhAlu bhaktoM kA ekAnta ahita to avazyabhAvI hai hii| (31) sAdhumArgI jaina mUrti pUjaka nahIM hai sthAnakavAsI samAja ko bhI mUrti pUjaka ThaharAne ke irAde se zrI jJAnasundara jI ne apanI pustaka meM kaI citra sAdhumArgI samAja ke sAdhuoM ke dekara pR0 174 meM yaha likhA haiM ki - "sAdhumArgI loga apane sAdhuoM ke citra rakhate haiM samAdhiyeM tathA caraNa pAdukAyeM banavAkara unakI pUjya bhAva se pUjA karate haiM" aadi| ukta kathana avicArakapana kA hai kyoMki jahA~-jahA~ sAdhuoM kI samAdhiyeM Adi banI huI hai, ve una pUjya puruSoM ke dAhasthAna para rAgI anuyAyioM dvArA smAraka rUpa meM banI huI hai| saMsAra meM yaha Ama rivAja hai ki jisa samAja yA mata ke pravartaka (netA) kA dehAvasAna ho jAya taba unake mAnane vAle unake zava kI antima kriyA bar3e dhUmadhAma se karate haiN| usa sthAna para kucha smAraka bhI banAte haiM, isI prakAra sAMsArika vyavahAra ke calate sAdhumArgI samAja ke loga bhI apane mAnya mahAtmA ke dehAvasAna para samAdhi Adi banAveM to yaha bhI akSamya nahIM hai| hA~ inakI vandanA, pUjA, satkAra Adi jarUra andha zraddhA yukta hai aura yaha bhI prAyaH par3osiyoM kI dekhA dekhI hotA haiN| jaise gA~va meM kisI eka AdamI ko haijA, plega yA caicaka Adi kI saMkrAmaka bImArI ho jAtI hai to vaha dhIre-dhIre sAre gA~va meM phaila jAtI

Page #253
208 sAdhumArgI jaina mUrtipUjaka nahIM hai ********************************************** hai| isI prakAra mUrti pUjakoM tathA andha zraddhAluoM ke saMsarga doSa se sAdhAraNa janatA jo dhArmika jJAna se anabhijJa hai aura kevala kula paramparA se sAdhumArgI samAja meM hai, unake dvArA aisI samAdhiyeM Adi pUje jAyaM to itane mAtra se sAdhumArgI samAja mUrtipUjaka nahIM bana sktii| isake sivAya sAdhuoM ke citra ke viSaya meM hamArA yahI kahanA hai ki jo bhI ye citra paricaya mAtra ke lie hai, vandane pUjane ke lie nahIM aura paricaya taka citroM kI hada mAnanA ucita hai, to bhI citroM kA sAdhAraNa loga durupayoga nahIM karale tathA citroM ke banAne se hiMsA aura AtmazlAghA honA Adi aneka doSoM ko jAnakara hamArI samAja ke sAdhu mahAtmAoM ne apane bRhad sammelana meM eka prastAva dvArA isa prathA kA niSedha kara diyA hai| isa para se sundara jI ko samajha lenA cAhiye ki - hamArI samAja citra darzana Adi kI pakSapAtI nahIM hai, kintu hameM to sundara mitra kI mithyAbhASitA para Azcarya hotA hai, ve hamArI samAja ke siddhAntoM ko jAnate hue bhI mUrti ke pakSa meM par3akara nimna prakAra likhate haiM ki - paramezvara kI mUrti nahIM pAnane vAlA sthAnaka samAja apane mRta sAdhu sAdhviyoM kI kisa prakAra pUjA karatA hai?........ "paramezvara kI mUrti ko nahIM mAnane vAlA samAja apane guru kI mUrti kI kisa prakAra pUjA karate haiM?"......pUjyoM kI mUrtiyoM ko bhakta apane svaccha makAnoM meM rakha prAtaH samaya darzana kara tathA dhUpa ukhevakRta kRtya baneM" aadi| isa prakAra sundara mitra ne sArI sthA0 samAja ko hI mUrti pUjaka batA diyaa| kintu inheM pakSapAta ko chor3akara vicAra karanA cAhie ki katipaya sAdhAraNa janatA ke isa prakAra citrAdi ko rakhane kA samAdhi banavAne mAtra se sArI sAdhumArgI samAja mUrtipUjaka nahIM bana sakatI, na

Page #254
206 jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA **Jing ************************************** sAdhumArgI samAja kI mAnyatA hI mUrti pUjane kI hai, yaha to eka prakAra kA vikAra hai jo mUrti pUjakoM ke ati saMsarga se yA dekhA dekhI se ho gayA hai| ise eka-dezI vikAra jarUra kaha sakate haiM, kintu sarva dezI siddhAnta nhiiN| na koI sAdhumArgI samAja kA sujJa zrAvaka kisI citra yA mUrti Adi ko guru Adi mAnakara pUjatA hai, na aisI jar3a pUjA meM dharma samajhatA hai| phira sAmAnya janatA ke kisI aMza meM vikAra hone mAtra se sArI samAja ko yA usake siddhAntoM ko hI vaisA batAnA janatA ko dhokhA denA hai| ____ Apako acchI taraha dhyAna meM rakhanA cAhie ki sAdhumArgI samAja tathA isake siddhAnta kisI bhI citra yA mUrti ko vaMdana yA pUjAdi karane meM dharma nahIM mAnate haiM, na aisI prarUpaNA karate haiM, balki aisI mAnyatA rakhate haiM "ki jo loga mUrti pUjA meM dharma mAnakara trasa tathA sthAvara jIvoM kI vyartha hiMsA karate haiM ve anasamajha aura dhArmika tatvoM se anabhijJa haiM, yaha unakA ajJAna hai|" (32) vikRti kA sahArA ucca saMskRti kA mUla rUpa meM adhika samaya taka rahanA mahAn kaThina hai jaba taka usake pracArakoM meM jJAna bala, caritra bala, tatparatA evaM kuzalatA rahatI hai, vAtAvaraNa anukUla rahatA hai, taba taka hI usakI maulikatA kAyama rahatI hai| kintu jahA~ thor3I sI bhI zithilatA aura paristhiti kI viSamatA AI ki vikRti ne jora lagAyA, bar3hate-bar3hate mUla saMskRti ko dabAkara vikRti svayaM maulikatA dhAraNa kara baiThatI hai| amUrti-pUjaka samAjoM meM bhI mUrti pUjA isI vikRti kI dena hai aura

Page #255
vikRti kA sahArA ************************************ ***** pradhAna kAraNa hai mUrtipUjaka bandhu kA saMsarga doSa / hindusthAna ke sabhI samAjoM meM sujJa evaM susaMskAra sampanna loga thor3e hI mileMge, adhika janatA ajJatA ke calate saMsarga doSa evaM aMdhavizvAsa ke cakkara meM A jAtI hai apane mata ke prati anurAga rakhate hue bhI andhavizvAsa ke kAraNa pratikUla AcaraNa sAmAnya janatA meM pAyA jAyagA / saMsAra meM prAyaH sabhI loga duHkha kA anubhava karate hai, koI dhana kA, to koI kuTumba kA, koI zArIrika duHkha kA, to koI Apatti Adi ke bhaya kA, isa prakAra kisI na kisI rUpa meM duHkha kA anubhava sabhI karate hai| jo duHkhI hai, duHkha kA anubhava karate haiM ve sukha prApta karane kA yatna bhI kreNge| kintu ajJAnatAvaza sarpa mUsaka nyAya se ulTA prayatna bhI kara baiThate haiN| jaise ki - 210 kitanI hI hindU lalanAyeM santAna prApti ke lie pIra paigambaroM kA Azraya lene daur3atI haiM, daragAhoM aura tAjiyoM ko pUjatI haiM aura pariNAma meM unheM eka naye hI duHkha kA zikAra bananA par3atA hai| kitane hI artha saMkaTa grasta jaina bhAI dhana yA jana ke kAraNa bhairava, bhavAnI, kAlI cAmuMDA Adi deva deviyoM kI zaraNa meM jAkara ulTI hAni uThAkara adhika duHkhI hote haiN| yaha saba prayatna dhArmika siddhAnta ke viruddha hote hue bhI saMsAra tApa se zAnti pAne ke lie sAdhAraNa loga karate haiM, isakA mukhya kAraNa ajJAna janita bahama hai| AcArya zrI caturasena zAstrI likhate haiM ki - "aMdha vizvAsa aura kusaMskAroM ne hI karor3oM hinduoM ko mUrti 'ke kukarma meM phAMsa rakhA hai / " ( " dharma ke nAma para " pR046) pUjA

Page #256
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 211 ******************************************* - isake alAvA matamoha meM par3a kara sArAsAra kA vicAra kiye binA bhI kitane hI loga pravRtti karane laga jAte haiM, unakA uddezya anya samAja ke ADambara ko dekhakara apane mata meM bhI usase bar3ha car3hakara ADambara kara janatA ko AkarSita karane (lubhAne) kA hotA hai| pariNAma svarUpa ve vikRti ko apanA kara saiddhAntika avahelanA kara baiThate haiN| ___ mUrti pUjA ke viSaya meM bhI yahI huaa| adhika dUra jAne kI jarUrata nahIM, Apa Arya samAja ko hI dekhiye, jo mUrti pUjA kI virodhI hai, phira bhI anya samAjoM ke ADambara kA anukaraNa kara apane Adya saMsthApaka svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatI ke citra kA julUsa nikAlate sune gaye haiN| vAstava meM mUrti pUjA Arya samAja kA koI siddhAnta nahIM hai, kintu sakAraNa ghusI huI vikRti hI hai| basa isI prakAra anya samAja ke lie bhI smjheN| krizciyana samAja meM krAsa aura mUrti kA Adara kaba se hone lagA? kyA yaha samAja mUrtipUjaka haiM? isake siddhAnta mUrti pUjA kA samarthana karate haiM? isakA uttara yadi bAibala se liyA jAya to nakArAtmaka hI milegA, maiMne kucha dina pUrva hindI bAibala ko dekhA, usameM mUrti pUjA ke virodha meM nimna ullekha milate haiN| dekhiye - . / "maiM terA paramezvara yahovA * hU~ jo tujhe dAsatva ke ghara se arthAt mizra deza se nikAla lAyA huuN||" mujhe chor3a dUsaroM ko Izvara karake na maannaa| tU apane lie koI mUrti khodakara na bnaanaa| na kisI kI * bAibala kI mAnyatAnusAra Izvara kA naam|

Page #257
212 vikRti kA sahArA ******************************************Zhong pratimA banAnA, jo AkAza meM vA pRthvI para vA pRthvI ke jala meM hai| unako daNDavata na karanA na unakI upAsanA krnaa| kyoMki maiM terA paramezvara yahovA jalana rakhane hArA Izvara huuN|" (hindI bAibala nirgamana a0 20 tathA vyavasthA vivaraNa a05) tathA "tU mUrateM nahIM banA lenA aura na koI khudI huI mUrti va lATa khar3I kara lenA aura na apane deza meM daNDavat karane ke lie nakkAsIdAra patthara sthApana karanA, kyoMki maiM tumhArA paramezvara yahovA huuN|" (hindI bAibala laivya vyavasthA a0 26) aura bhI dekhiye - "srApita ho vaha manuSya jo koI mUrti kArIgara se khudavAkara vA DhalavAkara nirAle sthAna sthApe, kyoMki yaha yahovA ko ghinaunA lagatA hai|" (hindI bAibala vyavasthA vivaraNa a0 27) isa prakAra krizciyana samAja ke mAnya siddhAnta mUrti pUjA ke virodha meM hI haiM, phira bhI bAda meM vikRti ke kAraNa kisI rUpa meM yadi mUrti pUjA usameM sthAna pA gaI hai to yaha usa samAja kA mAnya siddhAnta nahIM kahA jA sktaa| kyoMki yaha to eka prakAra kA vikAra hai| isI prakAra islAma samAja ke mAnya "kurAna' meM bhI mUrti pUjA ke virodha meM ullekha hai, eka bAra maiMne hindI kurAna zarIpha par3hate-par3hate nimna vAkya usameM dekhe the| he pAlanakartA! isa zahara ( makkA) ko zAMti kI jagaha bana aura mujhako aura merI santAna ko mUrti pUjA se bacA, he pAlana kartA ina mUrtiyoM ne bahutere logoM ko bhaTakAyA hai|" (hindI kurAna pArA 13 sUre ibrAhIma Ayata 35-36)

Page #258
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA isa prakAra islAma ke mUla siddhAnta bhI mUrti pUjA ke pratikUla hai, maiMne eka maulavI sAhaba se tAjiye banAne kI prathA ke sambandha meM bAtacIta kI, to unhoMne kahA ki yaha prathA bAdazAha taimUra ke jamAne se prArambha huI hai| kurAna zarIpha meM isakA kahIM bhI ullekha nahIM hai| isa para se bhI yaha spaSTa ho jAtA hai ki aisI pravRtti mArga kI preraka prathAeM kisI kAraNa se yA saMsarga se prArambha hokara zIghra hI vRddhiMgata ho jAtI hai| pahale prArambha meM inakA rUpa bahuta hI sUkSma rahatA hai, kintu samaya pAkara vahI bhayAnaka ho jAtI hai| mUrti pUjA kI paddhati ajJAniyoM ke lie AkarSaka hai| ve bAhyADambara se mohita hokara use cAhane laga jAte haiM, nahAnA, dhonA, puSpa cunanA, sugaMdhita dhUpa, itra Adi kI mahaka netroM ko lubhAne vAlI sajAI, karNa ke lie madhura rAga, sAtha hI vAdiMtra nAda, phira ajJAnI, dharma tattva se rahita bhole loga yA phira indriyoM ke dAsa sukha zIliye, pudgalAnaMda meM masta hokara ina AkarSaka pudgaloM ke kendra rUpa mandiroM aura mUrtiyoM kI aura jhukeM to Azcarya hI kyA? yaha vastu hI aisI hai ki jise rAgabhAva kI prabalatA vAle adhika cAhate haiN| 213 *** do cAra varSa pahale kI bAta hai, eka bAra paryuSaNa parvAdhirAja ke dinoM meM maiMne apane jyeSTha putra ( jo usa samaya lagabhaga 8 varSa kA thA ) ko kahA ki calo sthAnaka meM pratikramaNa karane caleM / usane kahA ki sthAnaka meM kyA rakhA hai, vahA~ to andherA hai, Apa loga vahA~ aMdhere meM baiThakara muMha se kucha bolA kareMge, mujhe vahA~ acchA nahIM lagatA, maiM to mandira meM jAUMgA, vahA~ acchI rozanI hai, rojAnA mUrti ko acchIacchI naI-naI pozAkeM pahinAI jAtI haiN| hAramoniyama tabale Adi bajate haiM, loga nAcate kUdate haiM, isa prakAra vahA~ bar3A acchA jalasA

Page #259
214 'vikRti kA sahArA *************************************** rahatA hai, maiM to vahIM jaauuNgaa| pAThaka samajha gaye hoMge ki yaha pudgalAnaMdI panA (jo ki jIva ke sAtha anAdi se lagA huA hai) logoM ko mUrti pUjA kI taraha barabasa AkarSita karatA hai| isameM adhika pracAra kI bhI jarUrata nahIM pdd'tii| eka baccA to kyA para bar3e-bar3e vidvAn bhI sukhazIliyApana ke calate apanI svArtha pUrti ke lie ise apanA lete haiM, hA~ jAhira meM ve loga apanI zithilatA ko prakaTa nahIM karate, kintu vAstava meM mukhya prabhAva pudgala lubdhatA kA hI hai jo unake bAda ke jIvana se caritArtha hotA hai| . isa prakAra saMsAra kI sAdhAraNa janatA apane ajJAna ke kAraNa vahema, matamoha, pudgalAsakti (ADambara priyatA) Adi ke kAraNa apane mAnya siddhAnta ke viruddha AcaraNa bhI karane laga jAtI hai, kintu itane mAtra se vaha siddhAnta bAdhita nahIM ho jAtA, na isa vikRti kI oTa se koI apanA pAkhaNDa kisI ke sira lAda sakatA hai| ____ zrImAn jJAnasundara jI ne pAMcaveM prakaraNa meM bholI janatA ko bhrama meM DAlane ke lie muslima, IsAI, pArasI, sikkha, Arya samAja tathA sAdhumArgI jaina samAja ko hI (vikRti kI oTa lekara) mUrti pUjaka batA diye / vAstava meM sundara mitra kA yaha samajha phera hI hai, inheM dhyAna meM rakhanA cAhie ki jisa prakAra krizciyana, islAma, Arya samAja Adi ke mUla siddhAnta mUrti pUjA ke anukUla nahIM hai, usI prakAra jaina samAja bhI mUrti pUjA ko mAnane vAlI nahIM hai, kintu jisa prakAra haraeka dharma samAjoM meM vikRti huI hai, usI prakAra jaina samAja meM bhI huI hai aura vikRti ke anya aneka prakAroM meM isa mUrti pUjA ko bhI mukhya sthAna hai| .

Page #260
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ********* ********************* ************ sundara mitra ! mUrti pUjA meM dharma mAnane kA siddhAnta zvetAmbara jaina samAja kA hai hI nahIM, yaha to kAla bala se sAMsArika bhUta nAgAdi devoM kI yA bauddhAdi mata kI dekhAdekhI se sthAna pAI huI vikRti hI hai / isa vikRti ko Apako haTAnA caahiye| binA vikRti nikale dharma rUpa zarIra svastha ho hI nahIM sakatA, yaha khUba socaleM / (33) mUrtiyoM kI prAcInatA se dharma kA sambandha zrI jJAnasundara jI ne pAMcaveM prakaraNa meM mUrtiyoM ke prAcIna hone kA ullekha kara tathA kucha citra dekara yaha siddha karanA cAhA hai ki mUrtipUjA tathA isameM Atma-kalyANa rUpa dharma mAnane kA rivAja bahuta purAnA hai, isalie mUrti pUjA upAdeya hai kintu yaha vicAra bhI vicArazIlatA se rahita hai kyoMki - 215 (1) mUrtiyoM kI sthApanA prArambha meM kevala yAdagAra (smAraka) rakhane kI bhAvanA se huI, pUjA ke lie nahIM / (2) mUrtiyoM ke sabhI lekha sacce nahIM, na kevala anumAna se hI koI siddhAnta aTala ho sakatA hai| prAcIna hone mAtra se hI upAdeya nahIM / (3) (4) sarva mAnya Agama pramANoM ke sAmane isakA koI mUlya nahIM / ina kAraNoM se hI vicArazIla sajjana mUrti pUjA kI upAdeyatA svIkAra nahIM karate haiM, jarA vistAra se lIjiye -

Page #261
216 mUrtiyoM kI prAcInatA se dharma kA sambandha (1) mUrti nirmANa kA kAraNa hama "stUpa nirmANa aura usakA kAraNa' nAmaka prakaraNa meM yaha dikhA cuke haiM ki - sarva prathama duniyA meM mahAtmAoM ke nirvANa pazcAt unake dAha sthAna para "yAdagirI' ke lie smAraka banane lage, vahI smAraka kalA ke vikAsa ke sAtha-sAtha apanA AkAra prakAra bhI badalane lage, yAne eka se eka bar3ha car3hakara sundara aura AkarSaka hone lage aura isa prakAra cauMtarA, deharI, pAdukA kA rUpa dhAraNa karate-karate mUrti rUpa meM bhI pariNita hogaye, so bhI yahA~ taka ki pahale to ye mUrtiyeM dharma nAyakoM ke smAraka ke lie banI, kintu bAda meM rAjA, mahArAjA, adhikArI, netA Adi kI bhI banane lgii| isa prakAra kalA ke vikAsa ke sAtha-sAtha smArakoM kI durdazA bhI bar3hane lagI aura vaha bhI sImA chodd'kr| jaise vartamAna samaya meM sarva tyAgI-tyAga ke saMsAra bhara meM eka mAtra mukhya Adarza-tIrthaMkara prabhu kI mUrtiyoM ko koTa, peMTa, jAkaTa, nakaTAI, kAlara, ghar3I * lAkhoM rupaye ke jevara pahinAnA zurU kara diyA, yaha saba bhaktoM ne apanI icchA se, pariNAma kA vicAra kiye binA mana mAnA raMga car3hA diyaa| yaha saba kharAbI lakSya bhraSTatA ko lekara huii| yadi mAnava samAja apane maulika dhyeya para kAyama rahatA to Aja yaha durdazA nahIM hotii| jaba se manuSyoM ne smArakoM kI pUjA kI, vastu aura unake pUjane meM apanA kalyANa honA mAnA hai taba hI se ve lakSya bhraSTa hokara saiddhAntika viruddhatA ko bhI upAdeya mAnane laga gaye haiN| isake sivAya sAMsArika manuSyoM meM rAga dveSa kI pariNatI to hai hii| icchita para rAga karanA yaha sarvAnubhava siddha bAta hai| idhara tIrthaMkara ___ * dekho zrI vidyAvijayajI kRta samaya ne olakho bhA0 1 pR0 215 /

Page #262
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 217 ***********Xue Xue ***************************** prabhu jagadvaMdya trailokyAdhipati the, unako manuSya hI nahIM devendra taka zraddhA kI dRSTi se dekhate the| zrI gautama svAmI jaise bhI prabhu ke prati rAgabhAva rakhate the to sAmAnya janatA rakhe, usameM zaMkA hI kyA ho sakatI hai? basa isI rAgabhAva ke atireka se hI smAraka, haDDI pUjA, yA mUrti nirmANa ho jAya to yaha bilakula svAbhAvika bAta hai aura yaha Aja hI kyoM lAkhoM karoMr3oM varSoM kI ho to bhI hameM koI harja nhiiN| kyoMki citrakalA bhI anAdi hai, isase citroM yA mUrtiyoM kA bhI anAditva ho sakatA hai tathA citra prAyaH usI kA liyA jAtA hai ki jo citra lene vAle yA likhAne vAle ko priya ho, tadanusAra tIrthaMkara ke prati atyadhika rAga vAle hokara logoM ne yadi rAgabhAva ke kAraNa unakI mUrtiyeM bana vAlI ho to usase dharma kA kyA sambandha? cAhe vaha kitanI hI prAcIna kyoM na ho| hamArA abhiprAya to kevala yahI hai ki mUrti pUjA meM dharma mAnane kI zraddhA jaina dharma kI tathA Atma-puruSoM kI nahIM hai| ataeva mUrtiyoM ke prAcIna hone se usakI pUjA usameM Atma-kalyANa mAnane kI zraddhA purAnI nahIM hai| hA~ smAraka rakhane kI rIti purAnI avazya hai aura usI ke calate samaya ke phera se ye mUrtiyeM bnii|| yadi mUrtiyoM ke prAcIna hone mAtra se mUrti pUjA meM dharma honA mAnA jAya to jinamUrtiyoM se bhI prAcIna mUrtiyeM yakSoM kI sunI jAtI hai, mathurA meM kAmadeva kI bhI eka mUrti purAnI nikalI hai, to kyA inake bhI pUjane meM dharma hai? kucha bhI nhiiN| basa isI prakAra yaha bhI samajho ki mUrtiyeM prAcIna hone mAtra se inakI pUjA karane meM dharma nahIM ho sktaa| mUrti pUjA pudgalAsakti ko bar3hAkara saMsAramArga kI ora khIMcane vAlI hai| jisakA udAharaNa Aja taka kA vikAra spaSTa batA rahA hai, Ajataka ke smAraka ke itihAsa se yaha spaSTa ho gayA hai ki manuSyoM ne inako pudgalAsakti ke

Page #263
218 mUrtiyoM kI prAcInatA se dharma kA sambandha **Li Li Li Li Li Li ****************Lai ****Li Xue Xue Hui Xue Jia Lai *** kAraNa jaisA cAhA vaisA banA DAlA hai, kintu hai yaha smAraka kA eka prakAra hI, anya kucha nahIM, hama pahale "stUpa nirmANa" nAmaka prakaraNa meM paM0 candradhara zarmA ke aitihAsika ullekha se yaha siddha kara Aye haiM ki - jaina samAja meM pahale stUpa smAraka rUpa meM the, bAda meM pUjya hue aura yahI mata paM0 becaradAsa jI kA hai, isalie mUrti nirmANa ke kAraNa meM aba vizeSa UhApoha karane kI AvazyakatA hI nahIM rhii| (2) ___ mUrtiyoM ke sabhI lekha sacce nahIM haiM sundara mitra kahate haiM ki amuka mUrti itanI prAcIna hai usa para prAcIna saMvat likhA haiM, Adi kintu mUrti para prAcIna saMvat likhe hone mAtra se vaha prAcIna nahIM ho sakatI kyoMki caityavAda aura caityavAsa ke jamAne meM svArthI loga apanA ullu sIdhA karane ke lie kaI prakAra kI cAlAkiyeM karate the yahA~ taka ki aneka kalpita grantha sarvajJa ke nAma se gar3ha DAle jAte the, parvatoM ke mana mAne mithyA mAhAtmya banAkara prabhu ke mukha se apanI tArIpha karavAI jAtI thI, amAvasyA kI pUrNimA, vaha bhI kevala apanA camatkAra dikhAne ke lie batAte the| vahA~ mUrtiyoM para manamAnA saMvat lagAyA jAya to kauna roka sakatA hai? isa mUrti prAcInatA ke viSaya meM saMghapaTTakakAra ne eka sthala para yaha bhI likhA hai ki svArthI loga bhole logoM ko yaha kaha kara Thagate the ki dekho yaha mUrti prAcIna hai, tumhAre pUrvaja unheM pUjate the, tuma bhI inakI pUjA Adi kro| basa bhole bhakta jaldI se cakkara meM A jAte the, adhika dUra jAne kI jarUrata nahIM, isa bIsavIM zatAbdI ke hI kucha namUne jo mere jAnane meM Aye haiM dekhiye -

Page #264
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 216 ******************************* *********** (1) vikrama saMvat 1946 meM bambaI meM eka yati mahAzaya ne eka SaDayaMtra racakara janatA meM yaha bAta phailAdI ki - "bAlakezvara ke samudra taTapara eka jina pratimA gar3hI huI hai aisA mujhe svapna AyA hai" basa bholI bhAvuka janatA ne yativarya kI bAta para vizvAsa kara liyA, gAje, bAje se yativarya ko lekara julUsa vAlakezvara taTa para AyA, yati mahArAja ne sthAna dikhAyA, mUrti khodakara nikAlI gaI, zraddhAlu jaina janatA ne bhI zIghratA se siddha zilA meM pahu~cane ke lie mUrti ke sAmane dhana ke Dhera karanA zurU kara diyA, bAhara ke bhaktoM ko bhI isa amUlya aura durlabha avasara kA lAbha lene ke lie AmaMtraNa patra pahu~cAye gye| guru mahArAja tIna cAra dina meM hI mAlAmAla ho gye| kintu pAkhaNDa kaba taka chupA raha sakatA hai? kisI dUra deza ne jAMca kara yati jI ke pAkhaNDa kI pola khola dI, basa yatijI kA dUsare dina kA sUrya bhI na jAne kisa sthAna para udita huA? (jaina bhAvanagara tA0 6-11-38 pR0 1032 "mATuMgAmAM camatkArI pratimAH eka pAkhaNDa' zIrSaka para se) . (2) do varSa pUrva muMDArA (mAravAr3a-sTezana phAlanA B. B.CI. Rly.) meM vahA~ ke RSabhadeva jI ke mandira meM kherA maMDapa banane kA kArya zurU huA, usa prasaMga para "panyAsa pravara himmatavijayajI mahArAja" vahIM para the| isa viSaya meM bhAvanagara ke mUrti pUjaka jaina patra ke tA0 19-6-37 ke aMka pR0 876 meM nimna zIrSaka -- camatkArika ghaTanA "paMcamakAla meM sAkSAt deva milApa va vArtAlApa" se eka lekha chapavAyA thA usameM yaha likhA thA ki -

Page #265
220 mUrtiyoM kI prAcInatA se dharma kA sambandha ******************************************************** " jyeSTha zu0 6 guruvAra ko madhyarAtri ko panyAsajI mahArAja laghuzaMkA nivAraNArtha jAgRta hue, bAdhA nivAraNa ke bAda unake sAmane eka lambe zarIra vAlA zveta vastra dhArI puruSa upasthita hokara kahane lagA ki - "mujhe bhI kAma batAo" taba mahArAja sAhaba ne usakA atyAgraha dekhakara kahA ki - "yaha patthara par3e, jo patthara ke ghar3e hue ATha pAye (thaMbhe) mandira ke bAhara par3e the, vajana bahota bhArI kama se kama 12 mana baMgAlI vajana meM hogaa| jisako kama se kama 8 - 10 AdamI muzkila se uThA skeN| basa itanA sunate hI ukta puruSa ne caTa maMdira ke dvAra ko jhapaTa se khola kara eka-eka pAye ko uThAkara AThoM hI pAyoM ko vyavasthAsara rakha diye, phira vaha puruSa gAyaba ho gyaa| subaha hote hI yaha ghaTanA sAre gAMva meM phaila gaI Adi / ukta samAcAroM ke prakAzita hone para zraddhAlu bhaktoM para isakA kyA asara huA hogA? yaha pAThaka svayaM soca leM, jabaki rAste ke kisI siMdUra lage hue patthara ko hamArI bholI bhAlI hindu aura jaina janatA devatA mAnakara natamastaka hone ko ekadama taiyAra ho jAtI hai, rAha calate DhoMgI aura pAkhaNDI ko bhI pahu~ce hue mahAtmA mAnakara Adara karane laga jAtI hai, taba bhalA jaina mahAtmA aura ve bhI mAmUlI nahIM kintu "panyAsa pravara" phira vizvAsa kyoM na kare ? mahAtmAjI kI prazaMsA aneka kaNThoM se hone laga gaI hogI ? mahAtmAjI panyAsa pravara "cauthe Are kI vAnagI" kA vizeSaNa pA gaye hoMge ? kintu burA ho ina bhaNDA phor3ane vAloM kA, jo SaDyaMtrakAriyoM kI AzAoM para ekadama pAnI phirA dete haiM? isI jaina patra meM kucha dina bAda eka zIrSaka dikhAI diyA ki - -

Page #266
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 221 **************************************** dhatiMgo se sAvadhAna raho "svargIya anuyogAcArya panyAsIjI zrI hitavijayajI mahArAja kA paTTadhara ziSya ratna panyAsajI himmatavijayajI mahArAja kA dhtiNg|" aise ThagoM se baco isa lekha meM yaha batAyA gayA thA ki - camatkAra kI bAta bilakula jhUTha hai, rAta ke samaya nIma ke jhAr3a ke nIce saMketa pUrvaka kucha majadUroM ko ikaTThA kara rakhA thA, unhIM se yaha patthara rakhavAyA, majadUrI ke eka rupaye ke badale dasa rupaye diye gye| yaha daza guNA cArja isa bAta ko gupta rakhane ke lie hI diyA gayA hai| anta meM lekhaka ne yaha bhI likhA ki - "agara Apa aba bhI isa kI satyatA pramANita nahIM kareMge to ApakA nAma dhatiMga vijaya rakhA jaaygaa|" (dekho jaina tA0 5-12-37 pR0 1116) aba tIsarI ghaTanA suniye (3) tA0 23-10-38 ko mATuMgA (bambaI) meM yaha khabara jora se phailI kI zA0 bhavAnajI bhAramala ke ghara gata rAtri ko eka deva vimAna AyA, usameM se eka deva ne pArzvanAtha jI kI eka mUrti lAkara ghara ke eka kamare meM rakha dI aura ukta gRhastha kI putra vadhU ne yaha sArI ghaTanA svapna meM dekhI, jAgRta hone para kamare meM jAkara dekhA to mUrti dikhAI dii| "mumbaI samAcAra" jaise bambaI ke prasiddha dainika patra meM bhI yaha khabara sthAna pA gaI, zraddhAlu logoM ke jhuMDa ke jhuMDa darzanArtha Ane lage aura bheTeM bhI car3hane lgii| kintu 'janma bhUmi' nAmaka bambaI ke dainika patra tA0 26-10-38 meM isakA bhaNDAphor3a bhI ho gyaa| isa

Page #267
222 mUrtiyoM kI prAcInatA se dharma kA sambandha ****************************************** patra ke mukha pRSTha para hI bar3e-bar3e akSaroM meM isako SaDyaMtra batAkara yaha rahasya prakaTa huA ki yaha mUrti tA0 21-10-38 ko pIMjarApola kI galI vAle jagannAtha lakSmInArAyana mUrti vAle se rupaye tIsa meM kharIdI gaI aura vyApArI kI bahiyoM ke jamA kharca ke do citra bhI sAtha hI prakAzita hue| isameM yaha bhI batAyA gayA ki jisa strI ne yaha pAkhaNDa phailAyA vaha svayaM pratimA lene gaI thI tathA usI strI ne eka mandira ke naukara se mUrti ke lie netra kharIdane kA sthAna pUchA thA, usake pAsa usa samaya vaha mUrti bhI thii| isake dUsare yA tIsare dina hI yaha aphavAha phailii| isake bAda tA0 27-10-38 ke janma bhUmi denika ke agralekha (sampAdakIya lekha) meM yaha bhI batAyA gayA ki - "yaha kArya akelI bIsa varSa kI lIlAbAI nAmaka strI kA nahIM hokara kisI cAlAka vyakti kA isameM hAtha honA pAyA jAtA hai, phira yaha bhI zaMkA kI gaI ki usa samaya bambaI meM virAjate hue mU0 pU0 AcArya zrI premasUrijI ne usa mUrti ko alaukika jAhira kara isa pAkhaNDa kA samarthana kyoM kiyA? AcArya zrI ke samarthana se hajAroM jaina aura jainetaroM ko hAni huI Adi tathA mU0 pU0 samAja ke prasiddha patra jaina (bhAvanagara) ke tA0 6-11-38 pR0 1032 para isa viSaya meM eka lekha prakAzita huA hai usameM yahA~ taka likhA ki - "sUri zrI (premasUrijI) nA utAvalA ane mUrkhatA bharyA abhiprAya thI ema paNa mAnavAne kAraNa male che ke evA koI sUrio ke sAdhuo no A vyavasthita pAkhaNDa mAM hAtha na hoya enI zI khaatrii| dhAro ke sAdhuo ane sUrio no to pAkhaNDa nIpajAvavAM ane nIbhAvavA no eka prakAra no vyavasAya che? paNa ApaNA dharma ghelar3A "rAva sAhebo ane rAva bahAduro' nI duraMdezI kyAM paravArI gaI htii|" ___

Page #268
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA 223 ** itanA hI nahIM mUrti pUjaka patroM meM sUrijI se isa viSaya meM kaI prazna bhI kiye gaye aura kucha dinoM taka isa prakaraNa kI carcA bhI rahI / cAhe kucha bhI ho, kintu isa viSaya meM pahale se hI sUrijI kA hAtha rahA ho, aisA mAnane ko pratyeka vicAraka taiyAra hoMge, isameM zaMkA ko sthAna hI nahIM hai| cauthA udAharaNa aura dekhiye - (4) ajamera ke myujiyama meM eka pASANa khaNDa hai, jisake viSaya meM zrImAna rAva bahAdura paM0 gaurIzaMkarajI hIrAcandajI ojhA ne likhA hai ki isa pASANa khaNDa para ke lekha para se jJAta hotA hai ki yaha vIra saMvat 84 meM likhA gyaa| isake sivAya ojhA jI ne yaha nahIM likhA ki - yaha lekha kisI mUrti kA hai yA mandira kA, sirpha zilAlekha hone kA hI svIkAra kiyA hai| kintu sAdhumArgI samAja kA virodha karate hue mUrti pUjaka mahAtmA darzana vijaya jI 'jaina satya prakAza' mAsika varSa 1 aMka 10 mAha aprela pR0 330 meM isI pASANa khaNDa ko jina pratimA batA kara likhate haiM ki - "ajamera nI myujiyama mAM vI0 ni0 saM0 84 mAM banela jina pratimA che / " yaha bilakula jhUTha hai| sthAnakavAsI samAja ke bhole logoM ko dhokhA dene ke liye hI isa pASANa khaNDa ko jina mUrti kahA hai / maiMne svayaM ajamera myujiyama ke isa patthara ko dekhA hai, yaha patthara lagabhaga 12-13 IMca lambA aura e- 10 IMca caur3A tathA cAra IMca ke lagabhaga moTA hai| isa patthara se yaha pAyA jAtA hai ki yaha mUrti kA nahIM hai kyoMki aise patthara kI mUrti prAyaH nahIM banatI, mere anumAna se yaha patthara kisI ghara kA zilAlekha hI hai, patthara meM kisI mUrti kI AkRti

Page #269
224 mUrtiyoM kI prAcInatA se dharma kA sambandha ****************************************** nAma mAtra ko bhI nahIM hai| na lekha meM mUrti kA ullekha hI hai, phira zrI darzana vijayajI kI yaha dhokhebAjI sivAya pakSapAta ke aura kisa kAraNa se ho sakatI hai? niHsandeha yaha cAlabAjI jana sAdhAraNa ko bhrama meM DAlane ke lie hI kI gaI hai| jabaki mUrti pUjaka samAja ke lekhaka isa pASANa khaNDa ko mUrti nahIM kahakara pASANa khaNDa hI mAnate haiM, tathA sandeha prakaTa karate hue likhate haiM ki - "sambhava che ke hAMsapura ke je prAcIna kAla mAM harSapura nAmarnu moTuM nagara hatuM ane jyAMthI harSapura gaccha no prAdurbhAva thayo che, te sthAnanA jinAlaya mAM no zilAlekha hoya?" (jaina satyaprakAza varSa 4 aGka 1-2 paryuSaNa parva vizeSAMka pR0 18) isa prakAra jaba inhIM ke zrI jJAnavijayajI mahArAja hI sandeha karate haiM, taba hamArA anumAna satya hone meM kyA kasara hai? hama yaha bhI kahate haiM ki zaGkAkAra ne isa zilAlekha ko jinAlaya kA hI hone kI zaGkA kyoM kI? kisI bhI makAna kA yaha lekha ho sakatA hai, kintu isa para se to yaha spaSTa ho gayA ki - zrI darzana vijayajI kI yaha karatUta ekadama adhama koTi kI hai| (5) inhIM mahAtmA ne jaina satya prakAza varSa 2 aGka 4-5 (mahAvIra nirvANa aMka) mathurA ke kaMkAlI TIle kI tIna pratimAoM kA paricaya karAte hue unheM bhagavAn mahAvIra kI AmalakI krIr3A meM deva dvArA parIkSA hone kI hakIkata batAne vAlI pratimAyeM honA batAyA hai| kintu inhIM ke matAnuyAyI zrI sArAbhAI maNIlAla navAba ne isI jaina satya prakAza varSa 4 aMka 1-2 (paryuSaNa parva vizeSAMka) ke "prAcIna jaina sthApatyo' zIrSaka lekha meM inake isa kathana ko yukti

Page #270
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 225 *************Xue Jiao Xue *******Li ********Lai * evaM pramANa sahita asatya ThaharAyA hai| jinheM adhika jAnanA hai ve donoM lekha par3hakara samajhaleM, yahA~ vistAra bhaya se itanA hI saMketa karate haiN| ukta pA~ca pramANa (jo ki likhate samaya lekhaka ko yAda Aye) hamArI isa bAta ko puSTa karate haiM ki jisa prakAra svArtha tathA prazaMsA icchuka aura pAkhaNDa pravartana kI bhAvanA vAloM ne dhokhA dehI karane meM kucha bhI kamI nahIM kI, usI prakAra mUrtiyoM ko prAcIna batAne ke lie kucha varSoM (zatAbdiyoM) pUrva ke lekha khudavAkara unheM yathA sthAna rakha diyA ho, yA bhUmi meM gAr3ha diyA ho to kyA bar3I bAta hai? daza, pandraha saiMkar3oM meM eka do saiMkar3e cala bhI sakate haiN| jaise ki - vartamAna meM isI bhAratavarSa kI nyAyAlayoM meM lena dena kI nAliza (dAvA) karane kI samaya-sImA (muddata) prAyaH tIna varSa kI hai| isa nirdhArita samaya ke andara hI yadi lenadAra dAvA karade to vaha svIkRta hotA hai, kintu isa samaya se eka dina bhI adhika nikala jAne para lenadAra nyAyAlaya meM dAvA karane kA adhikArI nahIM rhtaa| usakA saba rupayA DUba jAtA hai, itanA hone para bhI kaI mAmale aise bhI hote haiM ki jisameM kisI kAraNa yA gaphalata se dAvedAra niyamita samaya ko cUka jAtA hai, aura samaya nikalane para phira khAte kI tArIkha mAha yA san ke aGkoM meM caturAI se hera phera karake dAvA kara detA hai| yadyapi aise kaI mAmaloM kA nyAyAdhIzoM dvArA bhaMDA phor3a huA hai, tathApi yaha to nahIM kahA jA sakatA ki aise sabhI mAmale pakar3e gaye hoM, ho sakatA hai ki aise mAmaloM meM bhI prativAdI yA nyAyAdhIzoM kI asAvadhAnI se aise SaDyantra nahIM pakar3e jA sake hoM? ___ jaba tIna varSa jaisI muddata ke lekhoM kA hera phera bhI nahIM pakar3A jA sake, to saikar3oM varSoM kI purAnI karatUta Age calakara satya kA

Page #271
226 mUrtiyoM kI prAcInatA se dharma kA sambandha ********Xue Ben Chan **** ********* ************** svAMga pahina le, isameM Azcarya hI kyA ho sakatA hai? isake sivAya anveSaka bhI aise sarvajJa to nahIM ki asaliyata ko yathA tathya jAna leM! Akhira ve bhI to anumAna se hI kAma lete haiN| jAlI dastAvejoM ke bhI kaI mAmale nyAyAlayoM meM Ate haiM, anya kI bAta chodd'iye| kucha varSoM pUrva jaba zvetAmbara mUrti pUjaka bandhuoM ke va digambara bhAiyoM ke, tIrthoM ke pahAr3oM ko lekara adhikAra viSayaka mukaddameM hAikorToM meM cale the, usa samaya zvetAmbara mUrti pUjaka kI ora se kucha bAdazAhI pharamAna pramANa rUpa meM peza kiye the kintu vizeSa jA~ca par3atAla se ve pharamAna banAvaTI hI tthhre| nyAyAdhIza ne unheM ekadama kRtrima ghoSita kara diyaa| (kezariyA tIrtha hatyAkANDa pR0 135-138) pratimAoM para jAlI lekha khudavAne kI kAryavAhiyA~ honA bhI asaMbhava nhiiN| nimna pramANa dekhiye - jaina satya prakAza meM mUrtiyoM para ke ATha lekhoM kI AlocanA karate hue muni zrI kalyANavijayajI (jo svayaM mUrti pUjaka vidvAn haiM) likhate haiM ki - "yadi ye lekha pASANa mUrtiyoM para khude hue haiM taba to yaha mAna lene meM koI Apatti nahIM hai ki lekha "jAlI' hai| kyoMki taba taka mUrtiyoM ke masUraka para lekha khudavAne kA rivAja nahIM calA thA yaha rivAja vikrama kI pandrahavIM sadI se pracalita huA hai|" yadi lekha dhAtu kI mUrtiyoM para athavA pASANa kI mUrtiyoM ke siMhAsanoM para khude hue hoM taba bhI inake "jAlI' hone meM kucha bhI sandeha nahIM hai| hamAre isa nirNaya kI satyatA nIce ke vivaraNa se pramANita hogii| (jaina satya prakAza varSa 5 aMka 8)

Page #272
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 227 ********************************************* isa prakAra apane pakSa ko prabala banAne ke liye pakSakAra anahonI bhI kara baiThate haiN| isaliye mUrtiyoM ke zilAlekhoM aura unakI prAcInatA kI duhAI sunakara yA par3hakara hI hameM vizvAsa nahIM kara lenA cAhiye, jaba taka pUrNa anveSaNa nahIM ho jAya taba taka ye vastueM ekadama vizvAsa kara lene ke yogya nahIM hai| zrI jJAnasundarajI ne bhI mathurA ke myujiyama kI mUrtiyoM ko bahuta hI prAcIna hone para jora diyA hai kintu isa myujiyama kI paricaya pustikA ko dekhane se patA calatA hai kikuSANa kAla (IsvI prArambha se tIsarI zatAbdI taka) se pahale kahIM bhI Aja taka buddha kI mUrti nahIM milI (dekho pR0 3)........kaniSTha ke rAjya kAla (IsvI san 78 se 102 taka) meM to buddha aura bodhisatva mUrtiyoM kI bAr3ha A gaI sAtha hI jainoM ke caubIsa tIrthaMkaroM kI mUrtiyA~ bhI bahutAyata se banane lgiiN| (dekho pR0 3-4) Adi tathA svayaM sundara mitra ne bhI "jaina jAti kA saMgaThana kaise ho" nAmaka eka lekha meM mahAjanoM kA itihAsa batAte hue likhA ki - "usa jamAne meM jainAcAryoM kI bhI yaha paddhati thI ki jahA~ naye jaina banAye vahA~ jaina mandira, vidyAlAya aura jJAna bhaMDAra sthApita karavA dete, kyoMki mandira mUrtiyoM Adi dharma pracAra meM maukhya kAraNa the, phira bhI usa samaya vAdI prativAdiyoM kA khaMDana maMDana aura AkramaNa aura dharma parivartana kA bhI jora thA, isalie mandira mUrtiyoM kI vizeSAvazyaktA thii| (jaina patra bhAvanagara tA0 15-3-36 pR0 261) isa para se bhI yaha paddhati adhika prAcIna nahIM pAI jAtI, phira bhI yaha viSaya bahuta khoja karane bAda vicAra karane kA hai| jisase naye purAne kA patA lage, kintu bahuta prAcIna SaDyantroM kA patA lagAnA to ekadama asambhava hI hai, phira bhI yadi inheM prAcIna mAna liyA jAya to

Page #273
228 mUrtiyoM kI prAcInatA se dharma kA sambandha ******* ********* ****** bhI AtmakalyANa rUpa dharma se isakA kucha bhI sambandha nahIM ho sakatA, yaha mAtra smAraka vastu hI kahI jA sakatI hai / 3 prAcIna hone mAtra se upAdeya nahIM phira bhI yadi zrI jJAnasundarajI mUrtiyoM ke prAcIna hone mAtra se inheM pUjane yA isameM dharma mAnane kI duhAI deM to yaha bhI buddhi gamya nahIM ho sakatA, kyoMki mithyAtva, hiMsA, jhUTha, corI, maithuna, lobha, moha, dveSa, krodha, ahaMkAra, mAyA Adi durguNa hajAroM lAkhoM varSa ke hI nahIM kintu anAdi kAla ke haiN| isalie mAtra prAcInatA ko hI pakar3akara mAnane kA Agraha karane vAle ko to ina dUSaNoM ko bhI upAdeya mAnanA cAhie? yadi aisA ho to saMsAra meM pApa nAma kA koI zabda nahIM honA cAhiye / sundara mitra ! roga purAnA hotA hai, aura upacAra bhI purAnA, kintu samayApekSA roga purAnA kahA jAkara upacAra nayA kahA jAtA hai| durguNa purAne aura usake pratikAra meM sadguNa prAcIna hote hue bhI usa yuga meM nayA hI dikhAI detA hai| jaise ki - jahA~ hatyA, lUTa Adi anartha adhika mAtrA meM aura bahuta samaya se calate hoM, vahA~ inako haTAkara ahiMsA, rakSA Adi se zAMti phailAnA samayApekSA nUtana hI kahA jAtA hai, kyoMki isa samaya ke manuSyoM ko isa sukhada sthiti kA anubhava isa janma meM pahale nahIM huA, isalie ve ise nayA hI kahate haiM / ( para vAstava meM ye guNa bhI prAcIna hI hai) kintu vivekI aura sujJa janatA kevala heya upAdeya ko hI dekhatI hai naye purAne ko nahIM / ekAnta purAne kA Adara kara naye kA anAdara karane vAlA rAjapraznIya sUtra ke nyAyAnusAra loha

Page #274
226 jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA ****************************************** vaNika kI koTi kA hokara anta meM pazcAttApa karane vAlA hotA hai vaha loha vaNika bhI apane kucha samaya pahale ke grahaNa kiye hue loha ko hI purAnA mAnakara aura svarNa ratnAdi ko lohApekSA nUtana mAnakara heya samajhatA rhaa| usane yaha socane kA kaSTa nahIM uThAyA ki vastuyeM donoM prAcIna anAdikAla kI hai, kevala mere grahaNa karane mAtra se eka pahale kI yA dUsarI pIche kI nahIM ho sktii| mujhe to vastu kA mUlya yA guNa doSa dekhanA cAhie, yadi itanA vicAra bhI usa loha vaNika ko hotA vo vaha duHkhI nahIM hotaa| ThIka isI taraha ye loga apanI mUrti pUjA kI prAcInatA batAkara use upAdeya kahate haiM, aura jinAgama sammata zuddhAcAra pAlane vAloM ko nUtana kahakara heya batAte haiM, kintu inheM samajhanA cAhiye ki bhale hI hamArI dRSTi se yaha samAja adhika prAcIna nahIM dikhAI de, kintu isakI mAnyatA, zraddhA prarUpanA upadeza Adi bhagavAn mahAvIra ke AjJAnusAra hai| isalie yaha prAcIna hai| hama apanI dRSTi se hI dekhakara guNoM kI upekSA aura avaguNoM kA Adara kara rahe haiM yahI hamArI bhUla hai| yadi itanI bhI inako samajha A jAya to yaha Asrava varddhaka mUrti pUjA inakA pIchA jaldI se chor3a de| ye svayaM jAnate haiM ki jaisA upadeza Adeza aura AcAra vyavahAra vicAra Adi sAdhumArgI samAja ke sAdhuoM kA hai vaisA hI bhUtakAla ke (tIrthaMkara kAla ke) muniyoM kA thA, jisake lie varddhamAna prabhu ke pravacana sAkSI haiM, kintu phira bhI pudgalAnandI hokara vyartha nindA kara AtmA ko bhArI karate haiM, yahI kheda kI bAta hai| jabaki tIrthaMkara bhagavAn mahAvIra ke batAye hue AcAra vidhAna meM mUrti pUjA kA nAma nizAna bhI nahIM hai, aura zuddha, jJAna darzana cAritra

Page #275
230 mUrtiyoM kI prAcInatA se dharma kA sambandha ********** kA pAlana kara AtmotthAna karane kA aneka sthAnoM para spaSTa ullekha hai, va isI anusAra sAdhumArgI samAja ke susAdhu apanI zraddhA prarUpaNA aura yathAzakti sparzanA rakhate haiM, taba inheM arvAcIna kahakara inakI upekSA yA nindA karanA, samajhadAroM ke lie kahA~ taka ucita hai? zramaNa saMgha ke ekadama vikRta aura patanonmukhI ho jAne se, aura usakA kAraNa mUrtivAda rUpI viSa ke hone se zrImAn dharma sudhAraka lokAzAha ko krAnti macAkara kriyoddhAra karanA pdd'aa| jo usa vakta janatA ko pUrvokta udAharaNoM se nayA honA pAyA jAya to koI Azcarya nhiiN| para samajhadAroM ko to socanA cAhiye ki isameM nUtana pana kyA hai ? kucha bhI nahIM, vahIM vIra bhagavAn ke mukhya siddhAnta / phira naye purAnepanakA ga~vArU prazna hI kyoM uThAyA jAya? vaise to vartamAna mUrti pUjaka zramaNa saMgha bhI prAyaH vikramIya sattarahavIM zatAbdI ke (lokAzAha ke bAda) vRddha kAla meM satyavijayagaNI dvArA caityavAsa kA vizeSa bhraSTAcAra se saMskArita kiyA huA nUtana hI haiN| ApakI isa yukti para se to yaha bhI koTi kA hI honA caahie| ' ataeva kevala prAcIna hone se hI koI upAdeya nahIM ho sakatA / 4 AgamoM ke sAmane isakA koI mUlya nahIM samasta jaina samAja zAstroM ko pramANa mAnatA hai aura unameM batAI vidhi ke anusAra apanA AcaraNa banAne kI bhAvanA rakhatA hai tathA jo zAstra nirdiSTa niyamoM kA bhalI prakAra se pAlana kare use Adara kI dRSTi se dekhatA hai, yadyapi digambara aura zvetAmbara samAja ke zAstroM meM paryAya anaikya hai, kintu sabhI apanI-apanI samAja ke

Page #276
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 231 **********************************Xue Xue zAstroM ko to pramANa bhUta mAnate hI haiN| zvetAmbara jaina samAja ke bar3ebar3e do phirakoM (sAdhumArgI aura mUrti pUjaka) meM mUla 32 sUtroM meM to ekasI mAnyatA hai, kintu mUrtipUjaka sampradAya meM isake sivAya aura bhI sUtra grantha aura ina para kiye hue bhASya, TIkA, niyukti Adi ko bhI pramANa rUpa svIkAra kiyA gayA hai| jo samAja zAstroM ko pramANa rUpa meM svIkAra karatA hai, usake sAmane vaise pramANa nahIM dekara vyartha khIMcatAna karanA nyAya saMgata nahIM hai| ___ zvetAmbara mUrti pUjaka loga sAdhumArgiyoM ke sAmane Agama pramANa nahIM rakhakara mUrtiyoM kI prAcInatA ko batAkara isase Atma-kalyANArtha mUrti pUjA karane kA siddha karanA cAhe, yaha kahA~ taka ThIka hai? hA~ yadi ina mUrtiyoM ko prAcIna smAraka yA zilpakalA kA namUnA hI kaheM taba to koI hAni nahIM, kintu inako hI pUjane pUjAne kI anAvazyaka kriyAyeM kara usameM hI dharma mAnanA aura manavAnA yaha Agama viruddha aura haThadharmI hI hai| 1. jabaki vartamAna samaya meM AcAra vidhAna ko spaSTatayA batAne vAle sarvajJa praNIta aura gaNadharAdi se nirmita, sUtra ke sUtra maujUda haiM, jisameM Atma-kalyANa kA anupama mArga dikhAyA gayA hai unameM mUrti pUjA ke lie eka akSara bhI nahIM hai, taba mUrti pUjA meM dharma kahane vAle kahA~ taka sacce haiM? kisa bala para mUrti pUjA mahAvIra bhASita kahI jAtI hai? 2. jabaki caritAnuyoga (jIvana caritra vibhAga) meM saikar3oM muni mahAtmAoM kI jIvanacaryA batAI gaI hai| vaise hI aneka Adarza zramaNopAsakoM ke jIvana itihAsa likhe hue haiM, una sabameM se kisI eka meM bhI mUrti pUjane, mandira banavAne, yAtrArtha saMgha nikAlane Adi viSayaka bindu visarga taka nahIM hai, phira yaha kaise kahA jAtA hai ki mUrti pUjA se anekoM kA kalyANa huA? ise Agama sammata kahane vAle kyA utsUtra bhASI nahIM hai|

Page #277
232 mUrtiyoM kI prAcInatA se dharma kA sambandha Xue Xue Hui Li Li Li Li Li Li Li Jia Xue Hui Li Li Li Li Li Rong Cheng Xin Xin Xue Zi Qiu Xue Xue Hui Xue Xue Shi Zhi Wan Quan Xin Ben Guan Dong Jun Rong Chan yadi vicAra pUrvaka dekhA jAya to mUrti pUjA meM dharma mAnanA Agama Azaya se viruddha aura Atma-kalyANa ke lie bAdhaka hai| kitane hI loga mandira aura mUrtiyoM ke kalA kauzala kA varNana kara, Adarza evaM ucca kalA batAkara, inakI pUjA karanA ThaharAte haiM kintu mumukSuoM ko dhyAna meM rakhanA cAhie ki yaha saba pravRtti (kalA kI uccatA) sAMsArika hai| jaise vidyAcArya aura kalAcArya ko AgamoM meM sAMsArika pakSa ke batAye aura sAMsArika rIti se hI unako sevA karane kA ullekha hai, kintu dharmAcArya ko dharmapakSa meM ginakara unakI sevA dharmiyoM (mahAtmAoM) kI sevA ke samAna batAI hai, vaise hI kalA kI uccatA bhI dhArmika uccatA se (Atma-kalyANa rUpa dharma se) bhinna hai| svayaM mU0 pU0 itihAsajJa zrImAn jinavijayajI "prAcIna jaina lekha saMgraha" bhAga 1 ke upodghAta pR0 38 meM likhate haiM ki - "mUrti pUjA mAnavIke na mAnavI e eka judI bAbata che ane teno sambandha tattvajJAna nI sAthe vizeSa che, parantu amuka samaya pahalA jainomAM mUrti pUjA hatI ke na hatI, e aitihAsika praznuM to nirAkaraNa A lekha thI ekadama thaI jAya ch|".... (jaina satya prakAza varSa 1 a0 10 pR0 333 jina mandira zIrSaka lekha se) tathA paM0 becaradAsajI "jaina sAhitya mAM vikAra thavAthI thayelI hAni" pR0 117 meM likhate haiM ki - "ApaNA pUrvajoe caityo ne pUjavA mATe nahIM, paNa tene maranAra mahApuruSoM nI yAdagirI rAkhavA mATe banAvyAM hatAM, parantu pAchala thI tenI pUjA zaru thaI hatI ane te Aja sudhI paNa cAle che|" paM0 candradhara zarmA likhate haiM ki -

Page #278
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA "bauddhoM tathA jainoM ke stUpa aura caitya pahale smAraka cihna the, phira pUjya ho gaye (nAgarI pracAriNI patrikA) 1 isa lekha se spaSTa hotA hai ki prAcIna mUrtiyeM itihAsa batAne meM sahAyaka ho sakatI hai, kintu isase tattvajJAna kA koI sambandha nahIM hai aura hamArA vivAda tattvajJAna viSayaka hI hai / ataeva isameM mUrtiyoM kI prAcInatA kA kucha bhI asara nahIM ho sakatA / kintu mahadAzcarya hai ki sundarajI ne tattvajJAna ke prazna ko to ekadama ur3A diyA, Apa mUrti kI prAcInatA batAte hue pR0 156 meM likhate haiM ki 'anyathA kevala kahane mAtra se ki hA~ ? mUrti pUjA prAcIna to hai para. . isa thothI ukti se koI bhI kAma nahIM cala sktaa|" isa lekha meM Apa mUrtiyoM kI prAcInatA se hI Atma-kalyANa kA sambandha mAnakara tattvajJAna yA Agama pramANa ko thothI yukti batalAte haiN| maiM sundara bandhu se sAnunaya pUchatA hU~ ki Apane isa biMdu aMkita rikta sthAna meM kyA chupAyA ? kyA maiM use pUrNa kara dU~? mere vicAra se Apane lajAte hue isa rikta sthAna meM yahI bhAva chupAye haiM ki - " dharma se isakA koI sambandha nahIM" yA isake liye " Agama AjJA nahIM " basa aisA hI bhAva Apane chupAyA hai, jo ki atyanta mahattva kA hai, jise zrImAn jinavijayajI ne bhI svIkAra kiyA hai, itanA hI nahIM khuda sundara mitra hI apane 'mejharanAmeM' meM likhate haiM ki "dharma AjJA vItarAganI, AjJA lopI ho kare gaNI dharma | AcAraMga pahalA aMga mAM, nahIM jANyo ho? teNe dharma no marma 10 (DhAla 13 dvitIyAvRtti pR045) sUtrasUyagaDAMga mAM ka AjJAbAhara ho ? badhuM Ala paMpAla // 6 // (DhAla 25 pR0 76 ) ********* 66 - 233

Page #279
234 kyA jaina sAdhu aisA upadeza de sakate haiM? "dharma che te vItarAganI AjJAmA che ane AjJA thI nyUnAdhika karavU te to adharmaja ch|" (DhAla 22 vIM ke tAtparya meM pR0 66) mitravara! apane ukta lekha kA to vicAra karo? hama isase adhika aura kyA kahate haiM? hama bhI yahI kahate haiM ki mUrti pUjA vItarAga AjJA se rahita hai, isalie anupAdeya hai phira AjJArUpa pramANa mAMgane para use thothI yukti batAnA kyA pakSavyAmoha nahIM hai? avazya hai, yahA~ ApakA "vadato vyAghAtaH" siddha hotA hai| vAstava meM mUrtiyoM kI prAcInatA se dharma kA koI sambandha nahIM hai, na isake lie Agama AjJA hI hai, yadi prAcIna mUrtiyoM kI upayogitA mAnI jAya to kevala smAraka yA kalA kI dRSTi se hI , para dharma ke sAtha isakA sambandha jor3anA adharma samarthana hai| ora hai utsUtra prarUpaNA rUpa mahAn pApa, isa bhayaMkara pApa se vaMcita rahakara AgamAnusAra Atma-kalyANa sAdhanA meM aura isI kA pracAra karane meM jIvana bitAnA hI sacce sAdhaka kA kArya hai| (34) kyA jaina sAdhu aisA upadeza de sakate haiM? jaina muniyoM kA upadeza sarva prANa, bhUta, jIva, sattva ko zAMti dene vAlA hotA hai| AtmazAMti evaM kalyANakArI upadeza jaina mahAtmAoM kA hotA hai, unakI vANI se kisI sthAvara prANI ko bhI kaSTa nahIM ho sakatA, ye pRthvI se lagAkara sabhI jIva kAya kI dayA ke pracAraka hote haiN| bhagavAn mahAvIra svAmI ne ina mahantoM ko aisI hI upadeza dene kI AjJA dI hai, jaise ki -

Page #280
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA ******* "daya logassa jANittA pAdINaM paDINaM dAhINaM udINaM Aisave vibhaye kiTTe vedavI // 2 // se udviesa vA, aNuTTiesa vA, sussUsamANesu vA, pavedae, saMti, viraMti, uvasayaM, NivvANaMsoyaM, ajjaviyaM, maddaviyaM lAghaviyaM aNaivattiya // 3 // " savvesiM pANANaM savvesi bhUyANaM, savvesi jIvANaM, savvesi sattANaM aNuvIi bhikkhU dhammamAikravejjA || 811 235 ****** aNuvIi dhammamAikravamANe No attANaM AsAijjA jo para AsAijjA No annANaM pANAiM bhUyAiM jIvAiM sattAI AsAdejjA se ANAsAdara ANAsAdamANe vajjhamANANaM pANANaM bhUyANaM jIvANa sattANaM jahA se dIve asaMdINe evaM se bhavati saraNaM mahAmuNI // 5 // " arthAt - sAdhu loga meM rahe hue jIvoM ko jAnakara aura gRhastha tathA sAdhudharma kA vibhAga kara dharma samajhAve / sAdhu ko tathA gRhastha ko dayA, virati, upazama, nirvANa, pavitratA, Arjava, mArdava, lAghava Adi samajhA kara dharma kahe tathA sarva prANa bhUta jIva satva kA vicAra kara upakAra buddhi se dharma khe| pUrvApara ke vicAra yukta dharma kahate hue muni sva tathA para AtmA kA hita karake sabake lie dvIpa ke samAna AdhAra evaM zaraNabhUta hote haiN| ( AcArAMga zru0 1. a0 6 ) sebhikkhu mAnne annayaraM disaM aNudisaM vA paDivanne dhammaM Aikve vibhae kiTTe uvaTThiesu vA aNuvaTThiesu vA, sussUsamANesu pavedie sativiraMti uvasamaM nivvANaM ?

Page #281
236 kyA jaina sAdhu aisA upadeza de sakate haiM? *********Xue Fa Xue *************************Ci *** soyaviyaM, ajjaviyaM, madaviyaM, lAghaviya, aNativAtiyaM, savvesiM pANANaM savvesiM bhUtANaM jAva sattANaM aNuvAI kiTThie dhmm||3|| ___arthAt - ugravihArI evaM udyamI sAdhu dharmopadeza karate hue dharmaphala bhinna-bhinna kahe, dharma kI kIrti kare, zAMti virati, upazama, nirvANa, pavitratA, Arjava, mArdava, lAghava ahiMsA Adi kA vicAra pUrvaka sarva prANiyoM kA hitakArI dharma khe| (sUyagaDAMga zru0 2 a0 1) itanA hI nahIM svayaM svayaM prabhu ne bhI saMsAra rata jIvoM ke kalyANa ke lie tathA rakSA aura dayA ke lie hI dharmopadeza kiyA, isIlie pravacana prarUpaNA kI, praznavyAkaraNa sUtra uttarArddha ke prathama adhyayana meM khulAsA ullekha hai ki - "savva jagajIva rakkhaNadayaTThayAe pAvayaNaM bhagavayA sukhiyN|" arthAt - jagata ke sabhI jIvoM kI rakSA aura dayA ke lie bhagavAn ne pravacana khaa| - jo bhagavAn kA pravacana aura AjJA hai usI anusAra muni mahAtmAoM kA bhI pravacana-upadeza honA caahiye| mahAtmAoM ke upadeza se kisI prANI kI vyartha hiMsA ho, Arambha samArambha bar3he nirarthaka aura ulTe mArga meM dravya nAza ho, to phira mahAtmAoM aura saMsArI AtmAoM meM bheda hI kyA? kintu pAThakoM ko Azcarya hogA ki isa mandira mUrti ke cakkara meM par3akara kitane hI jaina sAdhu aura jainAcArya kahalAne vAle, apane uttaradAyitva evaM adhikAra ko bhUlakara jora zora se Arambha samArambha evaM kleza bar3hAne vAle AdezAtmaka vAkya bolate haiM, vo bhI sImA chodd'kr| jinako sunane se zramaNa dharma ke sacce

Page #282
m * * jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA *******Xue Xue *************************Xue Li ***** upAsaka ko kheda hue binA nahIM rhtaa| isa mUrti aura mandira ke pakSa meM par3akara ye loga kaisI bhASA bolane laga gaye haiM, isakA thor3AsA namUnA dekhiye - 1. mandira bnaao| 2. acche kArIgaroM se mUrti bnvaao| 3. amuka pahAr3a kA rAstA khudavA kara ThIka kro| amuka tIrtha sthAna para dharmazAlA bnvaao| mUrti kA pratiSThA mahotsava dhUmadhAma se kro| varSa meM eka bAra avazya yAtrA kro| bar3e ADambara se saMgha nikaalo| 8. sAdhuoM kA nagara praveza khUba dhUmadhAma se kraao| hai. saMgha ke sAtha gAr3I, ghor3e, moTareM, sipAhI, astra zastrAdi rkho| 10. kele kA per3a kaTAkara usake khambhe banAkara sajAI kro| 11. phUloM ko tor3akara unase baMgalA banAo, unheM bindhakara mUrti ke lie AbhUSaNAdi banAo, phUla cddh'aao| 12. mUrti ko sacitta jala se snAna kraao| 13. dIpamAlA se mandira kI zobhA bddh'aao| 14. mUrti kI AratI aura svapnoM kA nIlAma bolakara dravya saMgraha kro| 15. mUrti ko mUlyavAna gahane phinaao| 16. amuka dIvAla ko tor3akara vahA~ ujAladAna bnaao| 17. mukaddameM lar3akara pratipakSI ko hraao| 18. amuka naukara ko nikAla do|

Page #283
238 kyA jaina sAdhu aisA upadeza de sakate haiM? 16. amuka vyakti sAdhuoM kI TIkA karatA hai, use saMgha se bAhara nikAla do| 20. mUrti nahIM pUjane vAlA yadi mandira meM A jAya to khUna se mandira ko dhooge taba zuddhi hogI / (AgamodvArakajI ) 21. trikAla pUjA karo / 22. dhUpa jalAo, vaha bhI AkAza maNDala meM bAdala chA jAya aisA / 23. vAdiMtra bajAo / amuka tabale ko ThIka mar3havAo / 24. nRtya karo / 25. svAmI vAtsalya kA jImaNa karo / kahA~ taka ginAveM, aise aneka prakAra ke upadeza hI nahIM Adeza diye jAte haiM / ukta nAmAvalI to kevala mUrti sambandhI hI hai| yadi anya AcAra viSayaka namUne rakhe jAya to pAThakoM ke roMgaTe khar3e ho jAya~ ? kintu viSayAntara ke bhaya se yahA~ kevala thor3IsI bAteM batAI gaI hai / pAThaka yaha nahIM samajheM ki ukta bAteM maiM apanI tarapha se hI kaha rahA hU~, kintu yesI bAteM satya haiN| jinase ina sAdhuoM kA vizeSa paricaya rahatA hai yA jo inalogoM ke sAmAjika samAcAra-patra tathA pustakeM dekhate haiM, ve isa viSaya meM anubhavI hoMge, phira bhI pAThakoM kI vizeSa saMtuSTi ke lie kucha prayatna karatA huuN| mUrti pUjaka samAja ke sAdhuoM kA eka sammelana ahamadAbAda meM huA thA, isakI kAryavAhI yadyapi gupta rakhI jAtI thI tathApi kisI prakAra se eka dina ke samAcAra dUsare dina janatA meM pahu~ca hI jAte the| sammelana kI kAryavAhI samApta hone para kucha samaya bAda isa viSaya meM eka pustaka "rAja nagara sAdhu sammelana" nAma se prakAzita

Page #284
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 236 ********* ************************** huI usake 193 veM pRSTha para 26 veM dina kI kAryavAhI kA vivaraNa karate hue likhA hai ki - "e zramaNo potAnA mUla hetu ne bhUlI gayA, saMvara ane nirjarAnA pATho par3havAnA sthale dhIme dhIme AzravanA dvAra paNa temaNe khullA karyAM ane aneka jAtanA kalaho bhayaMkara bakher3AoM ane saMsArIo ne paNa zaramAve tevA Arambha samArambha mAM vyagra thavA lAgyA, ane Aje to sArAsAranI tulanA rUpa upadeza bhUlI char3e coka teo Adeza maya zailI no upadeza karI rahyo che, phalANA tuM Amakara? mandiro baMdhAvo? mUrtio padharAvo? puSpa candana thI pUjA karo? upAzrayo baMdhAvo, svAmI bhAiyo ne jamADo? virodhiono pheja karo? heMDabola bAjI thI temane thakavI nAkho? maMDalo kAr3ho? moTaro dor3Avo? vagere A badhA upadeza jaina zailI mujaba nthii|" ___ mUrti-pUjaka zrI jayavijayajI mahArAja "sadbodha saMgraha" pR0 67 meM likhate haiM ki - "kaMcana kAminI nA saMga thI paNa pApa mAnanAra jainasAdhuo vItarAga devanA nAme lAkho rupayA ekaThA karavAmAM eka AMgI bhAMgI nAkhIne bIjI ghar3AvavAmAM, kuMDala, mugaTa, hAra, vigere dAgInA ghar3AvavA mAM jaina prajA nirdhana banatI jAya che chatAM gAmIgAma bhIkha mAMgI eka bIjA nI dekhAdekhIe khAsa paisA ugharAvI derAsaroM caNAvavA mAM dAru mAMsa khAnAra kArIgaroM ne raMgIna kAma mAM lAkhoM rupayA apAvavAmAM hajAroM dIvA battI ughArI salagatI rAkhI muMbaI nI dIvAlI no citAra karavAmAM komala phUloM ne kAtarI sIvIne nirdayatA karavA mAM gyAsa tela tathA bijalI nA dIvA balavA mAM, carabI vAlI mINavattIo salagAvavA mAM, vezyAnA tathA trAgalAnA chokarAone paisA ApI bhADutI bhakti karAvI nAca karAvavA

Page #285
240 kyA jaina sAdhu aisA upadeza de sakate haiM? ********************************************* mAM, kUvA khodAvavA mAM tathA bAga bagIcA karAvavA mAM upadeza Ape vA dharma batAve e kharekhara dIlagIrInI bAta che|" svayaM jJAna suMdara jI apane "mejharanAme' meM likhate haiM ki - "racanAkarAve pahADanI, ubhA ho?rahe pote aap| amuko lAMbo paholo karo, ajJAnI ho? rahe seve bahu paap| su05 baMdhAve upAsarA, karAve ho?. jIrNoddhAra / gRhastha jema ubhA rahe, parabhava no ho? nahIM Dara lgaar| su0 6 pauSadhazAlA upAsarA, nizaMka ho? diye aadesh| ahIM caukI AliuMkaro? ahIM bAMcazeho? vyAkhyAna hamezAsu07 amukI bArI meDo karo, bhaMDAriyuM ho? karo pustaka kaaj| ochA jIvana kAraNe, AjJA mukI ho? nahIM Ave laaj| su0 8 aNumAtra pRthvI kAyamAM, jalabiMdue ho? kahyA jIva asNkhy| trasa thAvara haNAvatAM, lajjA chor3I ho? huvA niHshNk| su0 6 svAdhyAya dhyAna dharyu khuMTIe ubhA bhaNAve ho! pUjA nA paatth| sAvadha nirvidha nahIM gaNe, ANA lopI ho? karI mananA tthaatth| su0 13 caityavAsI pahelA koI nahIM, bhaNAI ho? koI pUjA saadh| Agama pATha dIse nahIM, pAsatthAe ho? muko mryaad| su0 14 sAdhu gAve rAgathI, jema jema vAge ho? mRdaMga taal| dravyastava jeNe seviyo, dravyaliMgI ho? bhAve kahyA baal| su0 15 amuko karo amuko karo, lAvo muko ho? valI bole em| caityavAsI banI rahyo svA? ho? sAdhu bole kem| su0 16

Page #286
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 241 ********************************************* pratiSThA avidhi kare, aMjanazalAkA ho? kare Arambha ghor| kalpita grantha banAvIne, sAhu thor3A ho? malyA bahu cor| su0 16 (DhAla 12) uThe pAchalI rAtanA, saMgha cAle ho? phare gAmo gaam| sAdhu sAdhvI rAte cAlatAM, niMdA ho? hove ThAmo tthaam| su0 15 unuM pANI kare rAtanA, ghar3A bharI ho? bAiyoM rahe laar| tehaja pANI vApare, yAtrA nAme ho? saMyama jAve haar| su0 16 maryAdA munivara tajI, saMgha taNI ho? kare koshiish| UMco dharyo AcArane, zuM lakhuM ho? jANo jgdiish| su06 nAma leve yAtrA taNo, sAthe rAkhe hoya gAr3I ne maal| dAla bATI ne cUramA, ahI thI ho? lAgyo majhAno taal| su0 10 sAdhavI ho sAthe rahe vidhavA ho? rahe dshbiis| sAdhu kAraNa tambu rahe, tambu kAraNa ho? gAr3I ne uuNtt| jIva haNAya cha kAyanA, pUche thI ho? valI bole jhuutt| su0 13 (DhAla 23) pAThaka bandhuo! aba to spaSTa ho gayA ki - mUrti pUjaka mahAtmA loga mandiroM aura mUrtiyoM ke pakSa meM par3a kara apane sAdhutva ko bhI bhUla gaye haiN| aura suniye - ____zrImAn jJAnasundara jI mahArAja jo ki mUrti pUjaka samAja meM itihAsa premI kahalAte haiM, Apane sAdhumArgI samAja kI niMdA kara sAdhAraNa janatA ko bhrama meM DAlane ke lie jo mUrti pUjA kA prAcIna itihAsa nAmaka kalpita grantha nirmANa kiyA hai| (jisakA ki yaha uttara grantha hai) usake pR0136-137 tathA 361-362 meM Apane zrI kezI

Page #287
kyA jaina sAdhu aisA upadeza de sakate haiM? zramaNa nirgrantha kI aura gaNadhara sudharma svAmI Adi ko mUrti pUjaka sAdhu honA batAyA hai tathA mUrtiyoM ke pratiSThA karAne kA ullekha kiyA hai, kintu inakI yaha bAta kevala kapolakalpita yA kisI mUrti pUjA managaDhanta purANa kI hI hai, kyoMki prathama to isameM koI vizvasanIya pramANa nhiiN| dUsare ve mahAn cAritra sampanna the, isalie ve aise heya kArya ko karate hI nhiiN| tIsarA usa samaya mUrti pUjA kI hI mAnyatA siddha nahIM hotI, isalie sundara prayatna bholoM ko bhulAve meM DAlane ke lie hI hai, phira bhI hama sundarajI ke lekha se hI yahA~ isa bAta para vicAra kreNge| sundara mitra apane "mejharanAmeM" meM likhate haiM ki - 242 "aMjana salAkA, pratiSThA, upadhAna, rAtri rozanI karavI zrAvakoe derAsaramAM nAcakUda, dAMDIyA ramavA, strIyoe garavA gAvA, gADA ne gADA mATI maMgAvo pahAr3a racAvavA saMgha sAthe sAdhu sAdhvio rAtri divasa mAM sAtheja cAlavuM ane gADA uMTa sAthe rAkhavA...... . te AgamavAdI paMca mahAvrata dhArI muni mataMgajo nI kriyA na thI, parantu nigamavAdI caityavAsI zithilAcArI sukhazilayAo nIja kriyA che|" ( bhUmikAntargata traNa nanAmA lekhakoM ne uttara pR0 38 ) punaH mejharanAme kI tIsarI DhAla meM likhate haiM ki "kalpita kriyA banAvIne, sAvadya ho kara upadeza / aMjanazalAkA pratiSThA viSe, saMyama ho na rAkhyo leza // 6 // kAvya banAvyA pUjA taNI, sAvadha ho na ANe shNk| " (pU0 13) Age 29 vIM DhAla meM likhA hai ki " rozanI kare rAtanA, mandira mAM ho leve bhaktinuM nAma / aNagaNatA trasa jIvanA, prANa jAye ho? juo vANikanA kAma // 22 // - -

Page #288
243 ********************************************** jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA ANA nahIM Agama taNI caityavAsI ho? nacAvyA nAca / indriya poSaNa kAraNe, nahIM kare ho? gADariyA jaaNc||23|| (pR0 63) sundara mitra! jisa aMjanazalAkA pratiSThA ko Apa zAstra viruddha evaM bhraSTAcAriyoM kA kArya batA rahe haiM, kyA aise (pratiSThA, mUrti pUjAdi ke) kAma ve mahAn cAritravAn gaNadhara mahArAja Adi kara sakate haiM? kahiye! Apa unheM kyA mAneMge? yadi mUrti pUjA ke itihAsa ke ullekhAnusAra Apa unheM mUrti pUjaka aura pratiSThA karane vAle mAneMge, to ve Apake mejharanAme ke anusAra AjJA virodhaka evaM bhraSTAcArI ThahareMge aura una mahAtmAoM ko bhraSTAcArI kahane vAlA to bhraSTAcArI hI ho sakatA hai| basa siddha huA ki Apa apane hI lekha se jhUThe haiM tathA pakSapAta ke naze meM masta haiM, sAtha hI yaha bhI pramANita ho cukA ki mUrti pUjaka sAdhuoM kI ukta kriyAyeM tathA upadeza jainadharma-zramaNadharma se sarvathA viruddha hai, balki yaha kahanA bhI adhika upayogI hotA ki jo kArya caityavAsI karate the ve prAyaH Ajakala Apake mUrti pUjaka mahAtmA loga karane laga gaye haiM, ataeva ye bhI usI zreNI ke haiM, maiM hI nahIM Apa khuda bhI to vartamAna mUrti pUjaka sAdhuoM ko caityavAsI jaise mAnate haiM? kyA bhUla gaye? dekhiye Apane mejharanAme kI 26 vIM DhAla kI 22-23 gAthA meM isa bAta ko svIkAra kiyA hai ki pUjA bhaNAnA, pratiSThAdi karanA yaha caityavAsiyoM kA kArya hai aura isake pUrva 11 vIM DhAla meM likhate haiM ki - "Aveja raste cAlatAM yatiyoM ho? thayA phjiit| satya vijaya badhuM choDI yuM to paNa ho?have A cAlI rIta // 8 // (pR0 36)

Page #289
244 caitya zabda ke artha ******************************************** pravRtti caityavAsI taNI, satya vijaya ho? badhI dIdhI chodd'| yatiye malI sarukarI, hajI sudhI ho? nahIM sake todd'||30|| . (DhAla 23 pR0 77) sundara mitra! satya hai abhI bhI caityavAsI jaise DhaMga maujUda haiM, itanA hI nahIM dina para dina bar3hate jA rahe haiM aura isakA khAsa kAraNa hai kevala "mUrti puujaa"| jaba taka isake cakkara se Apa loga nahIM nikaleMge taba taka zuddha sAdhutva kA AnA asaMbhava hai| kyoMki mUrti pUjakoM meM jitanA zaithilya aura Arambha samArambha cala rahA hai, vo saba isI kI badaulata hai, sAdhutva ke ekadama viparIta upadeza aura yatiyoM jaisA AcAra vicAra saba isIkA pariNAma hai, jaina sAdhu aisA upadeza kadApi nahIM de skte| na aisA kathana jaina sAdhu kA ho sakatA hai| (35) caitya zabda ke artha jaina AgamoM meM aneka sthAnoM para caitya zabda kA prayoga milatA hai aura vizeSakara jahA~ grAma yA nagara Adi kA varNana hogA vahA~ yaha caitya zabda prAyaH pAyA hI jaaygaa| smAraka vizeSa meM bhI yaha zabda upayogI huA hai| isa prakAra caitya zabda kaI sthAnoM para aneka arthoM meM vyavahRta huA hai*| aise anekArthI zabda kA kitane hI mUrti pUjaka loga, mandira mUrti ke haTha ke kAraNa anya arthoM kA lopa kara kevala do tathA tIna artha hI karate haiM, pAThaka dekheM ki mUrti pUjaka samAja ke yugAvatAra aura yuga pradhAna kahe jAne vAle zrI vijayAnaMdasUri ne isa caitya zabda kA pakSapAta ke vaza hokara kisa prakAra artha kiyA hai, yathA - * caitya zabda ke vizeSa arthoM ke lie dekheM - saMgha dvArA prakAzita "lokAzAha mata samarthana" (pR0 40-42)

Page #290
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 245 ********************************************* "jina mandira aura jina pratimA ko "caitya' kahA hai aura cotare bandha vRkSa kA nAma caitya kahA hai inake uparAMta aura kisI vastu kA nAma caitya nahIM kahA hai|" (samyaktva zalyoddhAra pR0 175) isa prakAra zrI vijayAnaMda sUrijI caitya zabda ke AcArya hemacandrajI ke koSa ke AdhAra se tIna hI artha kara Age ke lie bilakula inkAra karate haiM ki "inake uparAMta aura kisI vastu kA nAma caitya nahIM kahA hai'' kintu pAThaka, jarA eka pannA aura palaTakara pR0 177 ko dekheM, vahA~ ye yugAvatAra mahApuruSa eka artha aura svIkAra karate haiN| "jisa vana meM yakSAdika kA mandira hotAhai, usI bana ko sUtroM meM caitya kahA hai|" pAThaka vRnda! dekha liyA? jahA~ inkAra aura svIkAra sAtha hI sAtha calate haiM vahA~ aura kyA cAhie? ___ isa prakAra caitya zabda para mUrti pUjaka mahAzayoM kI pUrI kRpA dRSTi rahI hai, yahA~ hama eka avataraNa aura ukta vijayAnaMda sUrijI ke ziSya ratna "janAba phaijamAna, magjaneilma, jaina zvetAmbara, dharmopadeSTA, vidyAsAgara, nyAyaratna, (itanI lambI pUMcha vAle) zrI zAMtivijayajI kI pustaka "jaina mata patAkA" pR0 74 paM0 8 se dete haiM, pAThaka dhyAna se pddh'eN| ___ "caitya zabda ke mAine-jina mandira aura jina mUrti ye do hote haiM, isase jyAdA nhiiN|" dekhaliye hathakaMDe! kyoM na ho, jabaki guru "kalikAla * sarvajJa samAna" hai, taba cale kama kyoM hoM? ve bhI vidyA ke sAgara Thahare, phira hathakaMDebAjI meM nyUnatA hI kyoM rakheM? * hindI samyaktva zalyodvAra caturthAvRtti ke mukha pRSTha para zrI vijayAnaMda sUrijI ko "kalikAla sarvajJa samAna likhA hai" isa vartamAna samaya meM ka. sa. kauna hai? mAlUma nahIM ho skaa| zAyada nirvANabAda banate hoNge| le0....

Page #291
246 caitya zabda ke artha ********************************************** pAThaka vRnda! aba jarA ukta do yA tIna arthoM se bhinna anya artha inhIM ke mUrti pUjaka granthakAroM kI ora ke dekhiye - 1. kalpa sUtra (khemavijayajI gaNivAlA) pR0 60 paM0 6 meM "veyAvattassa ceiyassa' likhA hai aura isakA artha "vyaMtara, mandira" kiyA hai| 2. bhagavatI sUtra ke TIkAkAra zrI abhayadeva sUri nimna artha karate haiN| "ceie" ti citerlepyAdicayanasya bhAvaH karmaveti caityaMsaMjJAzabdatvAdevabimbamtadAzrayatvAttadgRhamapi caityamtacceivyaMtarAyatanam, natubhagavatAmarhatAyatanam" (yahA~ vyaMtarAyatana artha kara arhat pratimA kA niSedha kiyA hai|) 3. ThANAMga sUtra ThA0 3 u0 1 kI TIkA meN| caityamiva jinAdi pratimeva caityaM "zramaNaM" (isa sthAna para caitya zabda kA artha sAdhu kiyA hai|) 4. rAyapaseNaiya sutta meM - "caityaM su prazasta mano hetutvAta" (isa sthAna para svayaM prabhu ko hI suprazasta mana ke hetu caitya zabda se kahA hai) 5. anekArtha koSa meM zrI hemacandrAcArya likhate haiM - "cityaM mRtaka caityesyAt(mRtaka caitya) / 6. zrI haribhadra sUrijI "lalitavistarA'' meM nimna artha karate haiN|

Page #292
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 247 "cittam-anta-karaNam tassa bhAvaH karma vA caityaM bhvti|" (yahA~ citta ke bhAva karma (jJAna) ko caitya kahA) 7. sthAnAMga kI TIkA meM - "cittam AhlAdayati tat caityaM" (jisase citta ko prasannatA ho vo caitya) 8. uvavAI sUtra meM pUrNabhadra yakSa ke adhikAra meM yakSa kI yogyatA batAte hue nimna artha kiyA hai| "caityaM iSTa devatA pratimA" (isa sthala para arhata pratimA ke sivAya yakSa pratimA ko iSTa devatA pratimA caitya zabda se kahA hai) 6. bRhadkalpa bhASya ke chaThe uddeze meM - 'AhA AdhAya kamme' gAthA kI vyAkhyA meM zrI kSemakIrti sUri ne "caityoddezikasyasAdhUna uddezyakRtasyAdi'' likhakara sAdhu artha kiyA hai| 10. anuttaropapAtikadazA aura vipAka-sUtra kA hindI anuvAda karane vAle vIra putra zrI AnaMdasAgara jI ne aneka sthAnoM para caitya zabda kA artha "upavana' kiyA hai jise bagIcA bhI kahate haiN| 11. kAlaloka prakAza bhA0 3 meM - tIrthaMkara ko jisa vRkSa ke nIce kevala jJAna utpanna huA usa vRkSa ko sUtra meM caitya vRkSa kahA hai, usa caitya vRkSa ko "jJAnotpatti vRkSAH' likhakara caitya artha "jJAna" mAnya kiyA hai| 12. zatrujaya mAhAtmya bhASAntara (jaina dharma prasAraka sabhA) pR0 46 meM - "udyAna nI aMdara eka aMbAdevI nuM caitya htuN|" (isameM ambikA mandira ko bhI caitya kahA hai|)

Page #293
248 caitya zabda ke artha **************Ci *******************Duo Ci Qiu Qiu Qiu 13. mUrti maNDana praznottara pR0 282 meM prazna vyAkaraNa sUtra ke prathama AsravadvAra ke caitya zabda para lekhaka vyAkhyA karate haiM "konA caitya to ke kasAI, bAgharI, mAchalA pakar3anAra mahAkura karmonA karanAra ityAdika ghaNA mleccha jAti te sarve yavana loka devala, pratimA ne vAste jIvo ne haNe te Asrava dvAra ch|" / .........te ThekANe Azrava dvAramAM to mleccho nA caitya "masido" ne gaNavela ch| (14) mUrti pUjaka samAja ke pratibhAzAlI vidvAna paM0 becaradAsajI dosI ne "jaina sAhitya mAM vikAra thavAthI thayelI hAnI" nAmaka pustaka ke "caityavAda' zIrSaka staMbha se isa zabda kA artha mukhyataH "smAraka cihna' kara ke mUrti aura mandira artha ko prAcIna nahIM mAnakara nUtana hI mAnA hai| isa prakAra mUrti pUjaka samAja ke vidvAn bhI caitya zabda ke bhinna-bhinna artha karate haiN| inhIM logoM ke kie hue bhinna arthoM se hI pAThaka samajha sakate haiM ki - jo mahAnubhAva mUrti pUjA ke dharma virodhI pakSa ko janatA ke gale mar3hane aura sAdhumArgI samAja kI niMdA karane ke lie, haTha pUrvaka do yA tIna hI artha mAnakara bAkI ke lie inkAra kI Ar3a Thoka dete haiM, ve kitane pakSapAtI hoMge? aba jarA ubhaya mAnya AgamoM ke bhinna-bhinna artha bhI dekhiye - 1. AcArAMga sUtra meM - "rukkhaM vA ceiya kaDaM thUbhaM vA ceiya karDa' (vyaMtara yukta vRkSa yA stUpa) 2. bhagavatI, uvavAI, upAsaka dazAMgAdi sUtroM meM -

Page #294
assena.246 . jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 246 *************Ben Lai Xue ************************* "guNasIlae ceiye, puNNabhadde ceiye" aadi| (vyaMtarAyatana) 3. bhagavatI, uttarAdhyayana, rAyapaseNI Adi meM "pupphavatIe ceiye, maMDI kucchaMsI ceiye" aMbasAlavaNe nAmaM ceiye" Adi (upavana-bAga) 4. uttarAdhyayana meM - "ceiyevacche" ceiyammi mnnorme| (vRkSa vizeSa) 5. prazna vyAkaraNa meM - "maDaya ceiyesuvA" (dAhasthAna para banAyA huA smAraka) 6. jJAtA dharma kathAMga meM - "sigdhaM, caNDaM, cavalaM, turiyaM, ceiyaM" (gati vizeSa) 7. AcArAMga meM - "AgArihiM aNAgArAiM ceiyAiM bhavaMti" . (banavAnA cunavAnA) 8. ThANAMga, bhagavatI, upAsaka dazAMga, uvavAI Adi meM - 'ceiyANi" (sAdhu) 6. samavAyAMga-praznavyAkaraNa meM - "ceiya" (jJAna) 10. jIvAbhigama, rAjapraznIya Adi meM"ceiya thUbhANaM, ceiya khaMbhe" (smAraka cihna, smAraka staMbha) ..

Page #295
250 caitya zabda ke artha ******************************************** isa prakAra AgamoM meM bhI yaha caitya zabda aneka arthoM meM prayukta huA hai| aba jarA anya matAvalambI vidvAnoM ke kie hue artha bhI dekhiye - 1. zabda soma mahAnidhi koSa meM "grAmAdiprasiddha mahAvRkSe, devAvAse janAnAm sabhAsthatarau buddha bhede Ayatane, citAcinhe, janasabhAyAM, yajJasthAne, janAnAm vizrAmasthAne, devasthAne ca" 2. hiMdI zabdArtha pArijAta meM "devAyatana, masajida, girjA, citA, gAMva kA pUjya vRkSa makAna, yajJazAlA, bilI vRkSa, bauddhasanyAsI, bauddhoM kA mtth|" 3. bhagavata purANa skandha 3 a0 27 meM - ahaMkArastatorudrazcittaM "caitya" stto'bhvt| (AtmA artha meM) 4. banArasa kI nAgarI pracAriNI patrikA meM - "deva pUjA kA pitR pUjA se bar3A sambandha hai| deva pUjA pitR pUjA se hI calI hai| mandira ke lie sabase purAnA nAma caitya hai, jisakA artha citA (dAha sthAna) para banA huA "smAraka' hai|" / 5. saMsAra prasiddha aMgrejI vizvakoSa "insAiklopIDiyA oNpha rilIjiyana eNDa ethiksa' jilda 3 pR0 335 meN| isa caitya zabda kA lambA caur3A artha kiyA gayA hai| jisakA saMkSipta matalaba citA sambandhI smAraka cihna se hI hai| isa prakAra aneka anya darzanI granthoM meM bhI caitya zabda milatA hai, para koI bhI granthakAra hamAre mUrti pUjaka mahAtmAoM kI taraha manamAne artha nahIM krte|

Page #296
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 251 **** ********Li *******Xue Li Ben Xue Xue Xue ******* yadi vartamAna koSakAroM yA granthakAroM meM se kisI ne bhI caitya zabda kA artha jaina mandira bhI kiyA ho to usakA mukhya kAraNa yaha hai ki hamAre mUrti-pUjaka bandhuoM ne eka lambe samaya se isa zabda ko mandira-mUrti ke lie rUr3ha banA liyA aura granthoM meM bhI isa prakAra kA prayoga kiyA tathA zrI hemacandrAcArya ne bhI apane koSa meM isa zabda kA artha jina mandira, jina mUrti kiyA, isIse vartamAna rUr3hi ko dekhakara koI koSakAra yA granthakAra isa zabda kA jinamandira yA jina mUrti artha kare to isameM koI Azcarya kI bAta nahIM hai, kintu isase yaha nahIM mAnA jA sakatA ki AgamoM meM caitya zabda se arhan mandira yA arhat pratimA kA ullekha kiyA gayA ho| mitra jJAnasundara jI! aba Apa hI kahiye ki - zrI hemacandrAcArya aura vijayAnaMda sUri Adi ne caitya zabda ke kevala do tIna hI artha karake kyA zabda zAstra aura AgamoM kI virAdhanA nahIM kI? Azcarya to isa bAta kA hai ki Apa hI ke mahAmAnya TIkAkAra aura granthakAra jaba caitya zabda ke kaI artha karate haiM, taba Apake zrI vijayAnaMdajI anya arthoM ke lie kevala zUnya hI ThoMka deM, yaha kitanI utsUtra prarUpaNA hai? vAstava meM caitya zabda kA artha jina maMdira aura jina mUrti hI karake mUrti pUjakoM ne jar3a pUjA dvArA mAnava samAja kA patana aura zithilAcAra kA poSaNa hI kiyA hai, mitravara! jarA apanI hI samAja ke pratibhAzAlI vidvAn paM0 becaradAsajI ke isa viSayaka nimna udgAra to par3ha liijiye| "te viSe mAre eTaluMja kahevAnuM ke pracalita devAlaya ke mUrti e kAMI caitya zabda no pradhAna artha ke mUla artha nathI, eTaluMja nahIM paNa e banne arthoM taddana pachInA ane rur3hinA karelA ch|' (jaina sAhitya mAM vikAra thavAthI thayelI hAnI pR0 122) ___

Page #297
252 caitya zabda ke artha kahiye mitra ? Apa hI kI ora se ukta pramANa se Apa logoM ke kiye hue ukta mandira, mUrti artha asatya - manaH : kalpita siddha hue yA nhiiN| mitravara ? caitya zabda anekArthavAcI hai, AgamakAroM aura granthakAroM ne isa zabda ke prakaraNAnukUla bhinna-bhinna artha kiye haiM, jo hama Upara dikhA cuke haiM, phira ApakA bhI nimna haTha pUrNa vAkya kisa ginatI meM ThaharatA hai ki - hai|" " caitya kA artha mandira, mUrti stUpa aura pAdukA hI hotA ( pR0 101 ) isa haTha yukta asatya lekha ke kAraNa hama Apako pUrvokta pramANoM se yadi haThI kaheM to Apa burA to nahIM mAneMge? taba jabaki hamArI ora se prakaraNanukUla artha kiye jAte haiM, sundara mitra hameM bhI do hI artha (jJAna aura sAdhu) mAnane vAle kahakara hamArI niMdA karate haiM, kintu yaha inakI kevala dveSa parAyaNatA hI hai, kyoMki hamArI ora se yaha Agraha kabhI nahIM rahA ki caitya zabda ke kevala do hI artha hote haiN| hama to yahI kahate haiM ki isa zabda ke prakaraNAnukUla kaI artha hote haiN| jaba hama isa zabda ke aneka artha mAnate haiM taba Apa hamAre sAmane anya artha rakheM to usase lAbha hI " kyA hai? yaha to vyartha vyApAra rahA aura sAtha hI dveSaparAyaNatA kA paricaya | isake bAda Apane Age cala kara do cAra pramANa mUrti pUjaka granthakAroM aura loMkAgacchIya yatiyoM ke diye haiM, kintu yaha parizrama bhI ApakA vyartha hai, kyoMki yaha to hama bhI mAnate haiM ki isa zabda kA mandira mUrti artha mUrti pUjA ke anuyAyiyoM aura samarthakoM ne kiyA

Page #298
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 053 ******Nian *************************Xin Song ***** hai, hama hI kyA Apa hI kA samAja ke vidvAn aisA kahate haiM, dekhiye- "jaina sAhitya mAM vikAra thavAthI thayelI haani|" ___anta meM Apane pro0 haoNrnala sAhaba ke nAma se eka pramANa peza kiyA hai kintu yahA~ to Apane DaMke kI coTa se apanI ajJatA jAhira kara dI, kyoMki Apake isa pramANa meM to yahI batAyA hai ki - "isa nAmavAlI jagaha meM bagIcA yA udyAna kA samAveza hotA hai| usI ke andara eka mandira hotA hai aura sAtha meM kaI eka koThariyAM hotI haiM jinameM sAdhuoM kA nivAsa hotA hai isake uparAnta kahIM-kahIM stUpa yA samAdhistaMbha bhI hotA hai, usa samagra sthAna ko caitya ke nAma se ThIka hI vibhUSita kiyA jAtA hai|" __yaha pramANa to aupapAtika sUtra ke pUrNa bhadra caitya ke varNana se milatA julatA hai, isameM hamArI aura se kaba bAdhA upasthita huI? phira isa pramANa ke dene se lAbha hI kyA huA? mitravara! vyartha udyoga to eka mUrkha bhI nahIM karatA phira Apane isa pramANa ko peza karake kyoM vyartha kaSTa uThAyA? kyA isa pramANa se ApakA abhISTa siddha ho gayA? isameM to jina mandira yA jina mUrti kA nAma nizAna bhI nahIM hai, yaha to vyaMtarAyatana artha ko hI puSTa karatA hai, phira khAlI pramANa saMkhyA bar3hA kara "hamane itane pramANa diye' isa taraha bhole bhaktoM ko kyA bharamAte ho? sundara mitra ne caitya zabda kA artha jJAna aura sAdhu hone kA khaMDana karake kucha anupayogI tarka bhI kara DAle haiM, isalie isa viSaya meM prApta pramANa dekara phira inake tarkoM para vicAra kreNge| arihaMta caitya (yA caitya) zabda kA arihaMta sambandhI smAraka vizeSa artha hamAre mUrti pUjaka bhAI bhI mAnate haiM, kintu kitane hI

Page #299
254 caitya zabda ke artha loga kevala arhat pratimA hI artha karate haiM, aise mahAnubhAvoM se kahanA hai ki bandhu? arihaMta kA smAraka unakI jar3a pratimA ko mAnane ke banisbata unhIM ke vaMzaja, unhI ke anuyAyI, unhIM prabhu ke AjJArAdhaka jIte jAgate unake zAsana ko dedIpyamAna karane vAle zramaNa bhagavantoM ko kyoM nahIM mAnate?ye to arhatpada prApti rUpa prazasta bhAra ko vahana karane vAle-Arhata se arhata hone ke puruSArthI, anyako bhI arhat banAne meM mukhya sahAyaka evaM dharma ke mUrtimAna svarUpa haiN| inheM arhat caitya nahIM mAnakara jar3a mUrti kA hI Agraha karanA kahAM taka ucita hai? Apake saMtoSa ke liye nimna mUrti pUjaka mAnya pramANa diye jAte haiN| 1. caityaM "zramaNaM' (zrI abhayadevasUri, ThANAMga TIkA) 2. "caityoddezikasya-sAdhUna uddezyakRtasyAdi' (kSema kIrti sUri-vRhadakalpa bhASya u0 6 ke "AhAAdhAya kamme' gAthA kI vyAkhyA meM) 3. buddhaM jaM bohato, appANaM beiyAiM aNNaM c| paMca mahavvaya suddhaM NANamayajANa cediharaM||8|| ceiyaM baMdhaM mokkhaM dukkhaM sukkhaM ca appayaM tsy| ceiharo jiNa magge, chakkAya hiyaM bhnniyN||6|| (digambara sampradAya ke zrI kundakundAcArya racita SaTpAhuDa) 4. ajaina koSa "zabdArtha pArijAta" ke "bauddha saMnyAsI' artha para dhyAna diijiye| jisa taraha bauddha sAhitya meM caitya bauddha bhikSu haiM, usI taraha jaina sAhitya meM jaina sAdhu caitya ho sakate haiM, jisake lie ukta pramANa spaSTa hai| isa prakAra caitya zabda kA artha prakaraNAnukUla sAdhu bhI ho ___

Page #300
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 255 ********************************************** sakatA hai aura jJAna bhii| yadyapi sAdhu artha siddha hone mAtra se jJAna artha bhI siddha ho jAtA hai, tathApi ukta pramANoM meM se tIsarA pramANa to spaSTa jJAna artha ko hI batA rahA hai| phira bhI eka pramANa jJAna artha ke liye aura bhI liijiye| caubIsa tIrthaMkaroM ko jisa vRkSa ke nIce kevalajJAna utpanna huA usa vRkSa ko samavAyAMga sUtra meM "caityavRkSa'' kahA hai aura inhIM caitya vRkSoM ko "loka prakAza' nAmaka grantha ke kartA mU0 pU0 zrI vinayavijayajI ne "kAla-loka prakAza'' meM - "jJAnotpattivRkSAH" likhA hai| isake siyAya zrI haribhadra sUri ne "cittaM antaHkaraNaM tasya bhAvaHkarmavA caityaM bhavati'' kahakara ukta artha ko puSTa kiyA hai, ataeva jarA satya ko hRdaya meM sthAna dekara vicAra kiijiye| ___Age calakara Apa yaha pUchate haiM ki - "jJAna ko jJAna aura sAdhu ko sAdhu hI kahA jAtA hai caitya nhiiN|" isake samAdhAna meM Apako samajhAyA jAtA hai ki - bhagavan! Apa bhI maMdira ko mandira jinAlaya, deharA yA derAsara aura mUrti ko mUrti, pratimA, biMba Adi kahate haiM, so yahI kahiye, caitya kyoM kahate haiM? yadi Apa isa prakAra apanA haTha chor3a deM to phira yaha jhaMjhaTa hI nahIM rahe aura utsUtra bhASaNa se bhI vaMcita raha skeN| mahAtman! sUtroM meM jisa prakAra sAdhuoM ke sAdhu zramaNa, bhikSu, muni, saMyati, aNagAra Adi nAma haiM vaise caitya bhI eka nAma hai, jo ki ukta pramANoM se siddha haiM, aise hI jJAna ke viSaya meM smjheN| kisI zabda kA eka hI paryAya meM adhika bAra prayoga yaha pracalita artha kI adhikA vyApakatA se sambandha rakhatA hai aura isI se aneka artha hote hue bhI kisI eka artha meM adhika aura dUsare meM svalpa upayoga hotA hai, kintu svalpa upayoga hone mAtra se yaha nahIM samajhanA cAhie ki yaha artha ho

Page #301
256 battIsa sUtroM ke nAma se gappa *****************Li Li Li Li Li ******************* hI nahIM sakatA hai| jaise ki - tIrthaMkara prabhu isI nAma se adhika vikhyAta haiM, para "buddha" nAma se nahIM phira bhI samavAyAMga 34 meM bhagavAn ke 34 atizayoM ke varNana meM "buddhAtizaya' kahA hai, to kyA isa zabda para se hI ina 34 atizayoM ko tIrthaMkara atizaya nahIM mAnakara 'buddhadeva' ke atizaya mAneMge? nahIM, sarvathA nhiiN| basa isI taraha samajho ki caitya zabda kA jJAna tathA sAdhu zabda se svalpa upayoga hone para bhI ye artha bhI hote haiN| ___ mitravara! Azcarya to isa bAta kA hai ki jisa mUrti pUjA ko Apa dharma kA mukhya aMga aura avazya karaNIya mAnate haiM, usake lie sarva mAnya vidhi nahIM batAkara na Agamokta AjJA pramANa meM rakhakara khAlI zabdoM kI khIMcatAna kareM yaha kahA~ taka ThIka hai? samajhadAroM ke samakSa Apako lajjita honA par3egA, ApakI samAja ke vidvAn paM0 becaradAsajI hI kahate haiM ki - AcAra vidhi kA nirdeza zabdoM yAkathAoM kI oTa se nahIM hotA balki spaSTa vidhi rUpa se hotA hai, jisake lie AjJA nahIM, vaha vidhi hI kyA? ataeva samajhiye aura apane mithyA haTha ko chor3a diijiye| (36) battIsa sUtroM ke nAma se gappa misTara jJAnasundara jI gapaur3e mArane meM to bar3e hoziyAra haiM, samajhate hoMge ki saMsAra meM sabhI mUrkha aura andhe hI hoNge| Apa apane pothe ke cauthe prakaraNa ke pR0 110 meM nimna pratijJA karate haiM ki - __ "aba hama sthAnakamArgI samAja ke mAne hue 32 sUtroM ke andara mUrti pUjA viSayaka sUtroM meM pATha hai usakA saMkSipta meM digdarzana karavA dete haiN|"

Page #302
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA 257 ukta pratijJA meM sundara bandhu battIsa sUtroM ke pATha se mUrti pUjA siddha karane kA ikarAra karate haiM, kintu pAThaka jaba isa pratijJA ke bAda ke jitane bhI pramANa dekheMge, ve saba ulTe hI najara AyeMge / pratijJA meM Apa sUtroM ke pATha dikhAne kA likhate haiM aura prArambha hI meM niyukti kA pramANa dekara apanI pratijJA kI samApti bhI kara dete haiM, yaha sundara cAlAkI kA jvalaMta pramANa hai / aba inake sabhI saMkSipta pramANoM kI chAnabIna bhI thor3e hI meM dekhiye ** 1. AcArAMga sUtra se mUrti pUjA siddha karane ke lie Apane niyukti kA pramANa diyA hai, kintu yaha bhI mithyA hai, prathama to yaha kathana mUla pATha ke kisI bhI zabda se sambandha nahIM rkhtaa| jabaki yaha niyukti AcArAMga sUtra kI kahI jAtI hai, taba isa meM jo bhI kathana ho vaha AcArAMga ke Azaya se yukta hI honA cAhiye ? jaba AcArAMga meM mUrti yA tIrthaM Adi kA nAma bhI nahIM, taba niyukti meM yaha saba kahA~ se A gayA? kahanA nahIM hogA ki yaha saba karAmAteM mUrtimati mahAnubhAvoM kI hI hai, kisI mana cale mahAnubhAva ne caturdaza pUrvadhara zrI bhadrabAhu svAmI ke nAma se janatA meM phailAne ke lie yaha kAryavAhI kI hI to koI Azcarya nahIM hai aura sUtra pATha jo ki sthAnakavAsI samAjakA mAnya hai, usakA pramANa dene kI pratijJA karane vAle sundara sAhaba kisa muMha se hameM niyukti dikhAte haiM? hA~ yadi sUtra meM saMkSipta rUpa se bhI isa viSaya kA ullekha hotA aura usakA vistAra niyukti meM kiyA gayA hotA, taba to phira bhI vicAra kA avakAza thA, kintu sUtra meM nAmamAtra bhI nahIM - saMketamAtra bhI nahIM, taba usI sUtra kI kahI jAne vAlI niyukti meM aisA ullekha kahAM se A gayA ? ataeva sundara bandhu kA yaha prayAsa sarvathA vyartha hai /

Page #303
258 battIsa sUtroM ke nAma se gappa ******************Nong Xue Zhu Zi Xue ***Xue ************ 2. yahI dazA sUtra kRtAMga kI TIkA kI hai, yaha bhI binA sUtra / kI vRtti hai, ataeva yahA~ bhI sundara bandhu pratijJA bhaMjaka hI tthhre| 3-4. ThANAMga, samavAyAMga meM mUrti pUjA karane kI kahIM bhI AjJA nhiiN| ataeva yaha prayAsa bhI vyartha hai, yadi ThANAMga meM zAzvatI pratimAoM ke ullekha kA kahA jAya to yaha bhI ThIka nahIM, kyoMki ve mUrtiyeM tIrthaMkaroM kI honA saMbhava nhiiN| (vizeSa ke liye dekho sUryAbha prakaraNa) / 5-6-7. bhagavatI, jJAtA, upAsakadazAMga ke viSaya meM pahale pRthak-pRthak prakaraNa dvArA vivecana kara Aye haiM, dekho tuMgikA ke zrAvako, draupadI aura AnaMda prkrnn| 8-6. aMtakRddazAMga aura anuttaropapAtika dazAMga sUtra meM sundara mitra ne "bahulA arihaMta ceiyA" pATha honA batAyA yaha bilakula .. ThaMDe prahara kI gappa hI hai| 10. prazna vyAkaraNa ke "ceiya?" zabda para se Apa artha karate haiM ki "kisI bhI caitya mandira kI AzAtanA hotI ho to jaise bane vaise usako dUra kare yA kraave|" kintu yaha artha ThIka nahIM hai, prazna vyAkaraNa sUtra meM yaha zabda nimna pATha ke sAtha AyA hai| ___ "ahe kerisae puNAI ArAhae vayamiNaM? je se uvahibhattapANasaMgahaNaMdANakusale-accaMta, bAla, duvvala, gilANa, vuDDamAsa khamaNapavatti, Ayariya, uvajjhAe, seha, sAhammiya, tavassI, kula, gaNa, saMpa, peiyaTe nijjaraTTI veyAvaccaM aNissiyaMdasaviya bhuvihNkreti|" (pra0 zru0 2 a0 3)

Page #304
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA 256 ********************* ************** yahA~ yaha prazna kiyA gayA hai ki kaise sAdhu isa vrata ko ArAdhana kara sakate haiM? isake uttara meM yaha batAyA gayA hai ki jo vastrAdi aura bhojana pAnI lene dene meM kuzala ho ve atyanta bAla, durbala, rogI, vRddha aise mAsakhamaNa karane vAle AcArya, upAdhyAya, navadIkSita, sAdharmika, tapasvI, kulagaNa, saMgha, ina daza prakAra yA bahu prakAra ke vyaktiyoM kI vaiyAvacca arthAt sevA (sahAyatA) jJAna ke lie nirjarA kA arthI sAdhu karatA hai| isameM spaSTa batAyA gayA hai ki bAla yAvat saMgha kI vaiyAvRtya (sevA) upadhi ( vastra pAtrAdi) aura AhArAdi dvArA kare, aba yadi sundara mitra "ceiyaTThe " kA artha mandira mUrti kareM to yahA~ yaha prazna upasthita hotA hai ki - kyA mUrti mandira kI sevA AhAra, pAnI, auSadhi Adi se kare ? kyoMki sUtra meM to sabhI kI sevA AhArAdi se karane kA batAyA hai aura mUrti ko to AhAra, pAnI, vastra, pAtra Adi kI AvazyakatA nahIM hotI, vaha to jar3a hai, phira usakA yahA~ kisa prakAra grahaNa ho sakatA hai ? vAstava meM isa sUtra kA uddezya vratadhArI manuSya samAja sAdhuvizeSa kI sevA se hI hai aura isI se isameM yogyatAnusAra pRthaka-pRthaka nAma ginAye haiM tathA AhAra, pAnI, vastra, pAtrAdi kI AvazyakatA bhI zramaNavaryoM ko hI hotI hai ataeva spaSTa ho gayA ki yaha sUtra kisI bhI hAlata meM mUrti yA mandira kI AzAtanA ko dUra karavAne kI hAsyAspada bAta ko nahIM batAtA / jabaki vRttikAra zrI abhayadeva sUri vaiyAvacca kA svarUpa batAte hue likhate haiM ki - " annAdikAnAM vidhinA sampAdanam arthAt vidhi pUrvaka AhAra pAnI pahu~cAnA, phira yaha AhAra pAnI mandira mUrti ko kisa taraha pahu~cAnA yA AhAra pAnI se kisa prakAra AzAtanA miTAnA ? ataeva sundara artha asaMgata tathA matamoha yukta hone se upekSaNIya hai|

Page #305
260 battIsa sUtroM ke nAma se gappa ***** ** *********** *** ****** **** isake sivAya tRtIya aGka zrI sthAnAMga sUtra ke dazaveM sthAna aura bhagavatI sUtra meM daza prakAra kI vaiyAvRtya nimna prakAra se batAI hai, yathA - "dasavihe veyAvacce pa0 taM0 Ayariya veyAvacce, uvajjhAyaveyAvacce, there veyAvacce, tavassiveyAvacce, gilANaveyAvacce, sehaveyAvacce, kulaveyAvacce, gaNaveyAvacce, saMghaveyAvacce, saahmmiveyaavcce|" ___ tathA zrI umAsvati racita tatvArtha sUtra a0 6 sUtra 24 meM bhI vaiyAvRtya kA kathana isa prakAra kiyA gayA hai - "AcAryopAdhyAyatapasvizaikSa glAnagaNakula-saMghasAdhumanojJAnAm // " yaha daza vizeSaNa sAdhuoM ke hI haiN| . isa daza boloM meM-mandira vaiyAvacce yA mUrti vaiyAvacce kA to nAma hI nahIM hai| inameM bhI vahI nAma batAye gaye haiM, isase bhI yahI pariNAma nikalatA hai ki sUtrakAra ko mandira mUrti kI vaiyAvRtya iSTa nahIM anyathA spaSTAkSaroM meM yaha vidhAna bhI avazya hotaa| Azcarya to isa bAta kA haiM ki mUrtiyoM ke mithyA moha meM par3a kara sundara mitra aise thothe bacAva ko Age rakhate hue zabdoM aura bhAvoM kI khIMcatAna karate haiN| kyA isI bala para sUtra pATha ke pramANa dikhAne kI pratijJA kI hai? kahanA nahIM hogA ki sundara mitra ekadama pratijJA bhaMjaka Thahara cuke haiN| 11. vipAka sUtra zrutaskandha 2 ke dazoM adhyayanoM ke zrAvakoM aura zrAvikAoM ne mUrti pUjA kI, sundarajI kA aisA kathana ekAnta mithyA hai| zAyada sundara mitra satya likhane kI zapatha karake kalama calAne baiThe hoM? isa prakAra mithyA prapaMca karate hue bhI sAdhu kahalAnA yaha mahadAzcarya hai| ___

Page #306
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 261 Xue Xue Hui Xue Zhu Zi ************************************ 12. uvavAI 13. rAyapaseNaiya aura 14. jIvAbhigama ina tInoM sUtroM ke viSaya meM aMbar3a zrAvaka aura sUryAbha prakaraNa meM vistRta vicAra kiyA gayA hai| 15. pannavaNA sUtra ke bhASA pada meM jo 'ThavaNA saccA' likhA hai usakA matalaba mUrti pUjA se nahIM, kintu sthApanA ko sthApanA mAnane se hai aura sthApanA kaI prakAra kI aura kisI bhI vastu kI ho sakatI hai, isameM mUrti pUjA karane kA nAma nizAna bhI nahIM hai, yaha pramANa to use dikhAnA cAhie jo sthApanA (mUrti) ko hI (mUrti bhI) nahIM mAnate hoN| athavA sundaramitra ko hI isase bodha lenA cAhie ki jaba taka hama sthApanA ko sthApanA kI sImA meM rahakara nahIM mAneMge taba taka sthApanA satya ke mAnane vAle nahIM hokara sImollaMghana karane se isa sUtra ke utthApaka hoNge| dUsarA jaba sthApanA satya kA bhAva satya ke samAna hI Adara kareMge to donoM meM bheda hI kyA rahA? ataeva inheM sthApanA ko kevala sthApanA taka hI mAnanA cAhie, pUjAdi se bhAva taka nahIM le jAnA caahiye| yaha to ulTA satya ke bajAya asatya karanA hai| ataeva yaha pramANa bhI Apako viphala manoratha siddha karatA hai| adhika ke lie "sthApanA satya meM samajha phera" nAmaka prakaraNa dekho| 16. jambudvIpa prajJapti 17. candra prajJapti 18. aura sUryaprajJapti kA nAma lenA bhI ThANAMga sUtra kI taraha nirupayogI hai| 19. niriyAvalikA sUtra meM kAlI Adi rAniyoM kA mUrti pUjA karanA Adi batalAnA bhI dina dahAr3e A~khoM meM dhUla DAlane ke samAna hai| isI taraha 20. kappavaDaMsiyA 21. pupphiyA 22. pupphacUliyA aura 23. vanhidazA kA nAma lekara unameM mUrti pUjA batalAnA ekAnta

Page #307
262 battIsa sUtroM ke nAma se gappa **********Nian *************************Lao ****** gapor3a zAstriyoM kA kAma hai, mAlUma hotA hai sundara mitra bar3e sAhasI haiM tabhI dila khola kara gappeM ur3A rahe haiN| 24. dazavaikAlika sUtra kI cUlikA aura 25. uttarAdhyayana kI TIkA kA pramANa bhI kalpita kahAnI ke samAna amAnya hai jo ki sundara jI ke pakSa ko spaSTa nirbala batA rahe haiN| 26. anuyogadvAra sUtra ke nikSepAdhikAra kA nAma lekara suMdara mitra likhate haiM ki "sthApanA nikSepa meM tIrthaMkaroM kI va AcArya kI sthApanA karane kA vistRta ullekha hai|" sundara jI kA yaha likhanA bhI bhole bhoMduoM ko camakA dene ke samAna dhokhebAjI se bharapUra hai| yahI bAta (27) naMdI sUtra ke nAma kI hai| 28. vyavahAra sUtra ke pramANa viSayaka svataMtra prakaraNa dekho| 26. bRhadkalpa 30. nizItha ke bhASya cUrNi kA pramANa denA bhI gur3a mAMgane vAle ko gobara dikhAne vAle mUrkharAja ke sadRzya hai| 31. dazA zrutaskandha meM rAjagRhI ke varNana meM bahuta se mandiroM kA astitva batalAnA bhI sarvathA mithyA hai| 32. Avazyaka sUtra meM "arihaMta ceiyANi" Adi pATha ke hone kA likhanA hamAre sAmane bilakula vyartha hai, kyoMki yaha pATha mUrtimati mahAnubhAvoM ke hI Avazyaka meM hai, ina logoM kA Avazyaka' bhI ajIba DhaMga kA hai, jisako yahA~ likhakara viSayAMtara karanA nahIM cAhate, kintu itanA avazya kaheMge ki zrI madanuyogadvAra sUtra meM jo Avazyaka kA svarUpa batAyA haiM usameM "arihaMta ceiyANi" Adi kalpita pATha kA leza bhI nahIM hai aura na caitya vaMdana kA hI nAma hai, yaha saba karAmAta isa mandira mUrti ke kAraNa hI huI hai| sundara mitra ko hamAre sAmane aise phUTI kaur3I se bhI gaye bIte pramANa hamAre mAnya sUtra pAThoM ke nAma se rakhate hue lajjita honA caahiye|

Page #308
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 263 ****************************************** sundara mitra pratijJA to karate haiM "sthAnakavAsI samAja ke mAnya 32 sUtroM ke pATha se mUrti pUjA siddha karane kI, aura pramANa de rahe haiM, apane hI AkAoM ke kalpanA kahAniyoM se ota prota aise sUtra viruddha sAhitya ke, yA anartha kara athavA gapor3e mArakara apanA ullu sIdhA karanA cAhate haiN| kintu inheM mithyA prayatna meM samAja ke dravya ko nAzakara mithyAtva aura phUTa phailAte hue jarA parabhava se bhI DaranA caahiye| __ bar3e Azcarya kI bAta hai ki jisa vastu kA ekadama abhAva hai, usakA sadbhAva pramANita karane kA mithyA prapaJca karane meM loga bhI sahAyaka ho jAte haiM, aura apane dravya tathA sAmAjika zAnti kA nAzakara asat ko sat ThaharAne kI ceSTA karate haiM, yahA~ hama sundara mitra ko adhika kucha nahIM kahate (kyoMki jinheM abhAva meM bhI sadbhAva dIkhatA ho unheM kyA kahanA?) vicAraka pAThakoM se nivedana karate haiM ki ve sundara mitra ke batAye hue AgamoM aura pramANoM ke prAmANikatA kI jA~ca kareM jisase satya vastu ko samajhane meM saralatA ho| yadi koI bhAI itanA bhI nahIM kara sake to mUrti pUjaka samAja ke pratibhAzAlI vidvAn paM0 becaradAsajI ke isa viSaya meM nimna hRdayodgAra hI par3hakara nirNaya krleN| "huM himmata pUrvaka kahI zakuM chauM ke meM sAdhuoM tema zrAvakoM mATe deva darzana ke deva pUjana nuM vidhAna koI aMga sUtroM mAM joyuM nathIvAcyu nathI, eTaluMja nahiM paNa bhagavatI vigere sUtroM mAM keTalAka zrAvakoMnI kathAoM Ave che temA teonI caryAnI paNa noMdha che parantu temAM eka paNa zabda evo jaNAto na thI ke je upara thI ApaNe ApaNI ubhI karelI deva pUjananI ane tadAzrita deva dravyanI mAnyatA ne TakAvI

Page #309
264 kyA TIkA Adi bhI mUla kI taraha mAnanIya hai? Leng Kong Kong ***********************************Duo Duo Duo Duo shkiie| huM ApaNI samAjanA dhuraMdharo ne namratA pUrvaka vinatI karuM chu ke teo mane te viSenuM eka paNa pramANa vA prAcIna vidhAna-vidhi vAkya batAvaze to huM teono ghaNoja RNI thish|" (jaina sAhitya mAM vikAra thavAthI thayelI hAnI pR0 127) pAThaka samajha gaye hoMge ki eka mUrti pUjaka vidvAn ke ukta vAkya akSarazaH satya hokara sundara mitra ke prayatna ko mithyA siddha karane meM pUrNa paryApta haiN| spaSTa siddha huA ki battIsa sUtroM ke pATha se mUrti pUjA kA vidhAna batAne kI pratijJA karane vAle pUrNa rUpa se pratijJA bhaMjaka evaM mithyA pakSa ke poSaka pramANita hue| (37) kyA TIkA Adi bhI mUla kI taraha mAnanIya hai? sundara mitra dUsare prakaraNa pR0 23 meM kalpanA taraGga meM bahate hue likhate haiM jisakA bhAva yaha hai ki TIkA mAnane meM pahale matabheda thA hI nahIM, na kisI ne TIkA Adi ke viruddha eka zabda bhI uccAraNa kiyA, tathA TIkA bhI mUla Agama kI taraha mAnya hai, Adi isa viSaya meM sarva prathama yahI kahanA hai ki sundara mitra ne ukta bAteM kevala sAdhumArgiyoM se virodha batAne ke liye hI likhI haiM, anyathA itihAsa premI aura itihAsavettA kahe jAne vAle sundara bandhu ko kyA yaha mAlUma nahIM hai ki zrI abhayadevAcArya jinhoMne navAMgIvRtti banAI, unake jIvana kAla meM hI isa vRtti kA virodha huA thA? yadi sundara mitra ke itihAsa jJAna meM yaha bAta nahIM AI ho to maiM sundara samAja ke mAnya pramANa ko hI yahA~ de detA huuN|

Page #310
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 265 ************************************* "AcArya mahArAja ne duSTa rakta doSa lAgu paDayo, te bakhate IrSyAlu loko kahevA lAgyA ke - utsUtra nA kathana thI kupita thayelA zAsana devoe e vRttikAra ne koDha utpanna karyo che|" (prabhAvaka caritra-abhayadeva prabandha pR0 260) kahiye sundarajI! aba to ApakI kalpanA korI kapola kalpita hI ThaharI na? aura sAtha hI mithyA bhI siddha huI na? aura dekhiye svayaM zrI abhayadevasUri ThANAMga sUtra kI vRtti pUrNa karate hue likhate haiM ki - "satsampradAyahInatvAt sduuhsyviyogtH| sarvasva para zAstrANA madRSTe rmmRteshcme|| 1 // vAcanAnAmanekatvAta pustkaanaamshuddhitH| sUtrANAmatigAmbhIryAnmata bhedaacckutrcit|| 2 // kSUNAni saMbhavantIha kevalaM suvivekibhiH| siddhAntAnugatoyo'rthaH so'smAd grAhyo na cetrH||3|| (Agamodaya samiti patra 527) A~kheM mUMdakara likhA huA sabhI satya mAnane vAle sundara mitra ko apane TIkAkAra ke ukta udgAroM ko dhyAna se par3hanA cAhiye, ve svayaM likhate haiM ki "skhalanA ho jAnA saMbhava hai, isaliye siddhAntAnukUla artha ko hI grahaNa karanA caahiye|" aisI sUrata meM zrI sundara mitra TIkAoM ko akSarazaH mAnane kA haTha kareM yaha kevala andha zraddhA hI nahIM to kyA hai? sundarajI! Apake mUrti pUjaka vidvAn hI TIkA bhASyAdi ke havAle ko pramANarUpa nahIM mAnate haiM, jarA AMkheM kholakara nimna udAharaNa dekhiye -

Page #311
266 kyA TIkA Adi bhI mUla kI taraha mAnanIya hai? ********************************************** "prakaraNa granthoM nI apekSA vRtti tethI cUrNi ane te thI bhASya emaja niyukti, aMtamA sUtrane sauthIM balavAna pramANa mAne che.....ahiyAM jovU joiye ke sUtrokta rIti no Adara karavA mATe bahu AcAryoM nA vacano tarapha kAiMka khyAla karavAmAM Avato nthii|" (rAjendra sUryodaya pR0 18 pra0 traNathUi samasta saMgha) punaH ukta pustaka ke 52 veM pRSTha para likhA hai ki - "panyAsajI rUpa vijayajI nu kahevU che ke sUtra nI apekSAe TIkA cUrNi no mata hamane mAnya nthii|" sundara mitra! aba eka do pramANa ApakI samAja ke bRhad sAdhu sammelana meM AcAryoM ke bIca zAstrArtha huA usake bhI liijiye| (yaha zAstrArtha dIkSA viSayaka thA) - "Avakhate sAgarAnandasUrijI e dharma-bindu nuM bhASAMtara vijayavallabha sUri ne ApyuM, AgranthanA mUla pAThamAM bar3I dIkSA zabda nahIM hovA chatAM bhASAMtara mAM dRSTigocara thayo ane te thI zrI vijayavallabha sUrijI e jaNAvyu ke kyoM cakkara meM DAla rahe ho? mUla sUtra lAie" pachI mUla sUtra maMgAvyuM to emAM kyAMya bar3I dIkSA no pATha jaNAyo nhiiN|" (rAjanagara sAdhu sammelana pR0 146) sundara mitra! bhASAMtara jo ki anuvAda mAtra hai usameM bhI aise ghoTAle ho jAte haiM, aura unheM bhI Apake AcArya nahIM mAnakara mUla hI kA pramANa svIkAra karate haiM taba TIkAoM kI to bAta hI kyA hai? aura dekhiye - ___ isI sammelana meM bAla dIkSA ke samarthana meM zrI sAgarAnanda sUrijI ne dharma bindu ke bhASAMtara kA pramANa diyA isa para se AcArya samrAT zrI vijayanemisUrijI ne kahA ki - ___

Page #312
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 267 "bhASAMtara upara thI nirNaya na thAya, mUla pATha kaaddh'o|" (rAjanagara sAdhu sammelana pR0 146) - sundara mitra! ApakI samAja ke ye AcArya samrATa mUla ke bhASAnuvAda ko hI jaba pramANa rUpa se svIkAra nahIM karate taba Apa hamAre sAmane mUla kI vyAkhyA kahI jAne vAlI TIkA vaha bhI binA kisI mUla ke (jo ki mUla rahita hone se TIkAkAra kA svatantra mata hai) pramANa mAnane kA haTha kyoM karate haiM? sundara bandhu! TIkAkAra jaba kisI vastu kI vyAkhyA karate haiM taba kitane hI sthAnoM para mUla ke Azaya ko bhUlakara (seMkar3oM varSa pUrva kI paristhiti kI upekSA kara) apane samaya aura AsapAsa ke vAtAvaraNa ko dhyAna meM rakhakara bhI kabhI 2 saiMkar3oM varSa pUrva ke Azaya kI vyAkhyA karane laga jAte haiN| isake sivAya vyAkhyA meM vyAkhyAkAra kA svatantra maMtavya bhI rahatA hai, basa isI kA yaha pariNAma hai ki TIkAoM meM aneka sthAnoM para skhalanAx huI hai, zrI abhayadevAcArya (vyAkhyAkAra) mahArAja bhI to caurAsI caityoM ke mAlika zrI vardhamAna sUri ke praziSya the, aura unakA samaya bhI mUrtivAda kI yuvAvasthA kA thaa| taba aise samaya meM vyAkhyAkAra mahArAja ne apanI paristhiti ke anukUla vyAkhyA karadI ho, isameM sandeha hI kyA hai? sundara mitra jarA pakSapAta ko dUra haTAkara soco, dUsare vidvAnoM ke kathana para vicAra karo, bilakula ahaM sarvasva mata bno| dekho Apa hI kI samAja ke pratiSThata vidvAn paM0 becaradAsajI ApakI ina TIkAoM ke viSaya meM kyA udgAra nikAlate haiN| x dekho - lokAzAha mata smrthn|

Page #313
268 kyA TIkA Adi bhI mUla kI taraha mAnanIya hai? ******Xue Xue Hui Xue Xue ****************Liu Zi Zi Zi Zu Zu ** ___"mAruM mAnavaM che ke koi paNa TIkAkAre mUlanA Azayane mUlanA samayanA vAtAvaraNa ne dhyAnamAM laine spaSTa karavo joie, ArIte TIkAkAranAro hoya toja kharo TIkAkAra hoi zake che, parantu mUlano artha karatI vakhate maulika samaya nA vAtAvaraNa no khyAla na karatA jo ApaNe paristhiti neja anusarie to te mUla nI TIkA nathI paNa mUla nuM mUsala karavA jevU che hu~ sUtroM nI TIkAo sArI rIte joi gayo chu parantu temAM mane ghaNe ThekANe mUla nuM mUsala karavA jevU lAgyuM che, ane te thI mane ghaNuM duHkha thayuM che, A sambandhe ahiM vizeSa lakhavu aprastuta che, to paNa samaya Avye "sUtro ane TIkAo'' e viSe huM vigatavAra hevAla ApavAnuM mAruM karttavya cUkIza nahIM, to paNa Agala jaNAvelA zrI zIlAMka sUrie karelA AcArAMga nA keTalAka pAThoM nA avalA arthoM upara thI ane A caitya zabdanA artha upara thI Apasau koi joi zakyA hazo ke TIkAkAroM e arthoM karavAmAM potAnA samaya neja sAmo rAkhI keTaluM badhuM jokhama kheDayuM che| huM A bAbata ne paNa svIkAra karUM chu ke jo maherabAna TIkAkAra mahAzayoMe mUla no artha mUlanA samaya pramANeja karyoM hota to jaina zAsana mAM vartamAna mAM je matAMtaroM jovA mAM Ave che te ghaNA ochA hota, ane dharma ne nAme Aq amAsarnu aMdhAruM ghaNuM orcha vyApata" (pR0 123) .......je vAta aMgo nAM mUla pAThoM mAM nathI, te vAta tenA upAMgo mAM, niyuktio mAM, bhASyamAM cUrNiomAM, avacUrNio mAM, ane TIkAo mAM zIrIte hoi zake? upAMgo, niyukti o bhASyoM, cUrNio, avacUrNio, ane TIkAo ebadhA grantho eTalA mATeja lakhAya che-lakhAyA che ke koi prakAre mUlanI vastu spaSTa thAya, nahiM ke mUlamAM rahelI koI jAtanI apUrNatA ne te grantho pUrI kre|" (pR0 131) (jaina sAhitya mAM vikAra thavAthI thayelI hAnI)

Page #314
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 266 **************************************** mitravara! vivAdagrasta viSayoM kI carcA ho vahA~ ina TIkAoM (mUlAzaya rahita kI gaI vyAkhyAoM) kA pramANa kucha bhI mahattva nahIM rakhatA, jisakA kAraNa Upara batA diyA gayA hai| ataeva TIkA Adi ko mAnane na mAnane para vyartha kI carcA uThAnA tathA TIkA Adi ko akSaraza: satya mAnane yA manavAne kA haTha karanA andha vizvAsI alpajJoM kA kAma hai| sujJa loga mUlasparzI TIkAoM yA niyuktyAdi ko avazya mAnate haiM kintu TIkAoM ko mUla kI taraha akSarazaH satya yA mAnya kabhI svIkAra nahIM krte| (38) mUrti pUjA viSayaka granthoM kI aprAmANikatA gata prakaraNa meM hamane TIkA Adi ke pramANoM para vicAra kiyA, yahA~ mUrti pUjA ke samarthaka granthoM ko prAmANikatA ke viSaya meM kucha prayatna karate haiM, kyoMki sundara mitra ne isI dUsare prakaraNa pR0 23 meM yaha likhA hai ki - "AgamoM ke atirikta jainAcAryoM ne anya aneka viSayoM para paryApta saMkhyA meM granthoM kI racanA kI hai, yaha racanAkArya bhI svamati se nahIM, apitu jainAgamoM ke AdhAra para hI kiyA gayA hai| jisa taraha kisI vizAla bhavana ke TUTane para samajhadAra manuSya usakI sAmagrI se anya aneka choTe bar3e makAna banA DAlate haiM usI taraha jaba hamArA dRSTivAdAGga rUpI vizAla bhavana TUTane lagA taba usakA masAlA lekara tAtkAlika AcAryoM ne aneka choTe bar3e grantha banAne meM apanI buddhimattA kA paricaya diyA.....unhoMne vidhi vidhAnAdi ke granthoM kI bhI racanA

Page #315
270 mUrti pUjA viSayaka granthoM kI aprAmANikatA ****Kong ***Li Zong Xue Xue **Ben Ben Kong Gong An Xue Xue Hui Xue Xue Jia An An An An An An An An An An An An An kara DAlI........aisI sthiti meM mahAvIra ke putra hone kA dama bharane vAlA eka samudAya usa sAhitya meM bhI aneka prakAra kI truTiyoM ke svapna dekha rahA hai, yaha kitane duHkha aura kheda kI bAta hai|" Adi - isa prakAra sundara mitra mUlAgamoM se ekadama viparIta jAne vAle granthoM kI bhI bhUri-bhUri prazaMsA kara unheM Agama sammata tathA dRSTivAda ke aMza batA rahe haiM, sAtha hI aise aprAmANika granthoM ko nahIM mAnane vAlI samAja para kheda prakaTa kara rahe haiM, kintu yaha saba prayAsa gobara ko gur3a mAnane ke samAna hAsyAspada hai| aisA hI kapola kalpita kathana caityavAsI bhI karate the, ve kahate the ki caityavAsa kA samarthana AcAryoM ne dRSTivAda aMga ke AdhAra se granthoM meM kiyA hai| ve grantha bhI una mahAtmAoM (?) ne kapola kalpita banA liye the, jinakA khaMDana jinavallabha sUri ne saMghapaTTaka meM kiyA thA, saMghapaTTaka kI prastAvanA ke cauthe pRSTha meM likhA hai ki - "A arasA mAM caityavAsa ne siddha karavA mATe AgamanA pratipakSa tarIke nigamanA nAma tale upaniSadAM nA grantho gupta rIte racavAmAM AvyA ane teo dRSTivAda nAmanA bAramA aMganA trUTelA kaDakA che ema lokone samajAvavA mAM aavyu|' sujJa pAThaka vRnda! jisa prakAra kapola kalpita grantha caityavAsiyoM ne taiyAra kiye the aura unheM dRSTivAda kA aMza batAyA thA, usI prakAra sundara mitra bhI Agama virodhI aura hiMsA pravartaka vidhAnoM se bhare hue kapola kalpita granthoM ko dRSTivAda kA hissA kaha kara mAnane kA Agraha karate haiN| kintu yaha dhyAna meM rakhanA cAhiye ki jainAgamoM meM kahIM bhI AraMbhavarddhaka tathA trasa sthAvara jIvoM kI hiMsA karane karavAne aura vaisA upadeza dene kA vidhAna hI nahIM hai, na kisI vyartha kriyA ko

Page #316
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA. 271 *******************************Xue Xue Li *** hI sthAna diyA gayA hai, aisI sUrata meM trasa sthAvara jIvoM kA jisameM pracuratA se dhamAmAna ho, jo saMvara kA virodha kara Azrava ko apanAne vAlI ho, jisameM Atma-kalyANa kA kucha bhI aMza nahIM ho, aisI vyartha aura nirupayogI kriyA kA pracura vidhAna karane vAle grantha kisa prakAra Agama ke aMza yA Agama sammata kahe jA sakate haiM? kadApi nhiiN| dina aura rAta, prakAza aura andhakAra kA jisa prakAra samanvaya nahIM ho sakatA, usI prakAra AgamoM se aise granthoM kA samanvaya nahIM ho sktaa| ina banAvaTI granthoM meM kitanI hI anarthakara aura dharma viparIta bAteM likhI haiM, yahA~ hama mUrti pUjA viSayaka (sambandha hone se) Agama virodhI granthoM ke kucha avataraNa dete haiN| __ zrI sAgarAnaMda sUrijI ne apane siddhacakra pAkSika meM tIrtha yAtrA, saMgha yAtrA nAmaka eka lekha mAlA prakAzita kI hai, jisameM ve devendrasUri ke grantha kA pramANa dekara nimna prakAra se likhate haiM - "zAstrakAra eTalA sudhI kahe che ke dhUpo eTalI badhI gaMdha vAlA hoya ke jANe gaMdha nIja vATa hoya nahiM tevA lAge arthAt AvA sugaMdhavAlA dhUponuM jo dahana thatuM hoya te gandha mAtra bhagavAnanI Agalaja nahiM, ekalA gabhArAmAM nahiM, parantu AkhA maMdira nI andara je dhUpanA dahana thI thayelI sugandha hoya te vyApta hovI joie keTaleka sthAne to dhUpanA dahana nI zAstrakAro eTalo badhI tIvratA jaNAve che ke zrI jinezvara bhagavAnanA mandira mAM karAtA dhUpa dahana nA dhUmADA nI zikhAne aMge mayUro ne varasAda no vahema par3e ane tethI kokArava karavA lAgI jaay|" (siddha cakra varSa 7 aMka 7 pR0157) ___"sArA sArA varNavAlA ane sArA sArA gandhavAlA dravyonI aMdara utkRSTatA hovAne lIdhe je phUlo varNa gandha ne lIdhe upamA devAlAyaka

Page #317
272 mUrti pUjA viSayaka granthoM kI aprAmANikatA *************************************** thAyache tevAM puSpo thIja bhagavAna jinezvara mahArAja nuM pUjana karavU joie.....te phUlo paroyelAM hoya, guMthelA hoya, vITelAM hoya, mAMhoMmAheM nAlavaDe joDelA hoya, ityAdika aneka prakAranA puSpoe karIne bhagavAn nuM pUjana krvuu|" (siddhacakra varSa 7 aM0 5 pR0 116) - "AratI ane maGgala dIvAnI vakhate nATaka karavU joie|" - (siddhacakra varSa 7 aM06 pR0 202) aba jarA zrAddha vidhi grantha ke bhI kucha vAkya par3hiye - "zAMti ne arthe ghI, gola sahita dIvo karavo, zAMti tathA puSTi ne arthe agni mAM lavaNa nAkhavU sAruM che, khaMDita sAMdhelu, phATekheM, rAtuM tathA bihAmaNuM evaM vastra paherIne kareluM dAna, pUjA tapasyA, homa, Avazyaka pramukha anuSThAna sarva niSphala cha / " (zrAddha vidhi pR0 153) "bhagavAn Agala maGgala dIvA sahita AratI no udyota karavo, tenIpAse zagaDI mUkavI, temAM lavaNa ane jala nAkhavA....be dizAe UMcI ane akhaMDa kalaza jalanI dhArA devii|" (zrAddhavidhi pR0 157) "devAdhideva nI Agala kapUra no dIvo prajvalita karIne azvamedhanuM puNya paameN| (zrAddhavidhi pR0 157) . (azvamegha-ghor3e ko agni meM homanA aura isameM bhI puNya kyA yaha mAnyatA jaina dharmAnuyAyI kI ho sakatI hai? nahIM, para mUrti pUjakoM kI to hotI hogI?) "bhagavAn nAM candana thI potAnA kapAlAdika mAM tilaka na karavU, bhagavAn nA jala thI hAtha paNa dhovAya nhiiN| (zrAddhavidhi pR0 206) kalikAla sarvajJa samAna (samyaktva zalyodvAra ke mata se) zrI vijayAnaMda sUri nimna laukika zloka ko pramANa meM dekara samarthana karate haiM, vo zloka yaha hai - ___

Page #318
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ************** 'dhUpo dahati pApAni, dIpo mRtyurvinAzakaH / naivedyaM vipulaM rAjyaM, siddhidAtrI pradakSiNA / " (jaina tattvAdarza pR0 408 ) tathA jo puruSa snAna karake kare jisakA snAna bhI acchA hai| bhagavAn kI tathA sAdhu kI pUjA ( jaina tattvAdarza pR0 400 ) ( acchA hai ? vAha re jaina zramaNAcArya ? aura sAdhukI pUjA snAna karake kaise kare ? kyA, jala, phUla, dhUpa, candanAdi se ?) isake sivAya kadali ke per3a ko kaTAkara usake khaMbhe banavAnA usase baMgalA taiyAra karavAnA, phUloM kA ghara banAnA Adi kaI taraha ke vidhAna mUrti pUjA ke uddezya se kiye gaye haiM / (dekho - lokAzAha mata samarthana) yahA~ adhika nahIM likhakara aba kucha namUne zatruMjaya pahAr3a kI manaH kalpita mahimA ke dikhAye jAte haiN| - " zakrendre zrI kalikAcArya mahArAjanI Agala kahyuM hatuM ke zrI mahAvideha kSetramAM paNa samyagdRSTi jIvoM A zrI zatruMjaya nuM smaraNa kare che| " ( jaina satya prakAza varSa 3 aM0 10 - 11 me - jUna lekhaka zrI vijayapadma sUrijI ma0 pR0 366 ) " 'zrI nemInAtha prabhu nA kahevA pramANe kRSNa vAsudeva ahIM rahIne ATha upavAsa karI kapardi yakSano ArAdhanA karI, je thI yakSAdhirAje parvata nI guphAnI adara rahelI zakrendra thI pUjAyelI traNa 'pratimAo batAvI te guptarAkhI, saMbhalAya che ke hAla paNa te sthale zakrendra ghaNIvAra Ave che|" (jaina satya prakAza varSa 3 aM0 10 - 11 me - jUna lekhaka zrI vijayapadma sUrijI ma0 pR0 371) ( taba to pAlItAnA sTeTa ko aba parvata se hAtha dhonA par3egA 273

Page #319
274 mUrti pUjA viSayaka granthoM kI aprAmANikatA *********************Yu ***********************Zhong kyoMki zakrendra yahA~-zatrujaya parvata para AtA hai vaha ise rAjya ke adhikAra meM kaba rahane degA? pahale bhI varSoM ke lage hue tAle zakrendra ne hI to khulAye the? hA~ para kala mojIrAma bhAI kahate the ki ye sAle cora to zakrendra se bhI bar3hakara nikale, jo zatrujaya ke mandiroM meM se mUrtiyoM-nahIM, nahIM, bhagavAnoM kI bahumUlya rala jar3ita A~kheM hI nikAla le gye| bhAvanagara kA mUrti pUjaka "jaina" patra (agasta 1936) likhatA thA ki abhI taka coroM kA patA bhI nahIM lgaa| ina dinoM meM zAyada zakrendra kA daurA zatrujaya para nahIM huA hogA? kyA kisI DhU~Dhaka devane to indra ko nahIM bahakA diyA? sUrivaryoM ko isake lie zIghra sAvadhAna hokara prayatna karanA caahie|) ukta parvatarAja ke viSaya meM AgamoddhAraka AcArya deva zrI sAgarAnaMda sUrijI ke bhI siddhAta dekha lIjiye - "zrI siddhAcala girIrAja Upara mandira ane mUrtio hajAro ane lAkhonI saMkhyA mAM che, chatAMe girirAja nIja stuti girirAja dvArA karavAmAM Ave che te vivekio ne ochu vicAravA lAyaka na thI'....."bhAva tIrthaMkara karatAM paNa siddhAcala rUpI kSetra no prabhAva bhagavAnanA zrI mukhe keTalo badho mahattara gavAyo che.......A siddhAcala rUpI kSetra eTaluM badhuM prabhAvazAlI che ke AtmA ne pavitra thavAnA kAraNa bhUta je vIrya ullAso te chaNe chaNe poteja utpanna kare che.......khuda sthApanA tIrthaMkara eTale bhagavAn nI pratimA thI tozu parantu khuda bhAva arihanta ke je kevalI avasthA mAM rahelA tIrthaMkara mahArAjA hoya che temanA karatA paNa A girirAja atyanta prabhAvazAlI che, A vAta hareka jainAe dhyAna mAM levA jevI che|" __(siddhacakra varSa 6 aM0 10-11 mArca 1938 ke jinezvara mahArAjanI mUrti karatA girirAja nI adhikatA kema? zIrSaka se

Page #320
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 275 Chan Xue Xue Hui Xue Xue Hui Xue Zhu Xue Li *********Mi ******Zu Zu ***Li *** * (sUrivaryoM ko aba sAkSAt tIrthaMkaroM kI bhI AvazyakatA nahIM, unakI saba AvazyakatA parvata (jo sTeTa kA kaidI hai) pUrI kara detA hai|) ___ aba pAThaka jarA zatrujaya mahAtmya (bhASAMtara) ke bhI kucha namUne pahAr3a aura nadI kI prazaMsA ke dekha leM, yahA~ hama apanI bhASA meM pRSTAMka sahita bhAva mAtra deMge kyoMki isakI samAlocanA ke lie to eka svataMtra grantha caahie| dekhaye aura Apa svayaM vicAra kIjiye - 1. "he bhavyo! japa, tapa, dAna Adi kyoM karate ho? eka bAra puMDarIka giri kI chAyA kA bhI sparza kara lo, basa anya kucha bhI karane kI AvazyakatA nhiiN|" (pR0 2) 2. "prANiyoM kA bhayaGkara pApa parvata ke smaraNa se nAza ho jAtA hai|" (pR02) 3. "pandarA karma bhUmi meM zatrujaya samAna koI tIrtha nhiiN|" / (pR0 21) 4. "prabhu mahAvIra kahate haiM ki-isa tIrtharAja ko namaskAra / (pR0 22) 5. "samyaktva grahaNa kiyA huA bhI yadi isa tIrtha ko nahIM pUje to usakA saba kucha mithyA hai|" (pR0 23) 6. "jaba taka guru mukha se "zatrujaya' aisA nAma nahIM sunA taba taka hI hatyAdi pApa garjana karate haiM phira kucha nhiiN|" (pR0 25) 7. "bhagavAn mahAvIra kahate haiM ki he indra! jo pramAdI haiM unheM pApa se kucha bhI bhaya nahIM khAnA cAhie, sirpha eka bAra siddhagiri kI kathA suna lenA caahie|" (pR0 25) 8. "veSadhArI-dravyaliMgI-sAdhu ko bhI gautama kI taraha mAnakara ho|"

Page #321
mUrti pUjA viSayaka granthoM kI aprAmANikatA "" bhakti karanA cAhie, usakI kriyA Adi kucha bhI nahIM dekhanA kyoMki AkRti hI vandana yogya hai / ' ( pR0 26, 66-70) 6. parvata Upara ke hiMsaka prANI bhI tIsare bhava meM siddha hote haiM / 276 10. zIla pAlane se to zAyada siddha nahIM bhI zaila (parvata) kI sevA se to avazya siddhi ho ajitanAtha bhagavAn kA pharamAna hai| ( pR0268) 11. "AkAza meM ur3ane vAle pakSI ko chAyA bhI isa parvata ko sparza kara le to ve pakSI durgati prApta nahIM krte|" (pR0 337) 12. " zatrujaMyA nadI meM snAna karane vAle ke sabhI pApa naSTa ho jAte haiN| " ( pR0 66) 13. zatrujaMyA nadI ko kevala jJAnI nAma ke prathama tIrthaMkara ke snAna ke lie IzAna indra ne prakaTa kiyA / " ( pR0 161) 14. "rAyaNa vRkSa zAzvata hai / " ( pR0 30 ) "phira UgegA " ( pR0 513) 15. "kuNDa hI mukti detA hai, aura koI nahIM / " ( pR0 205) 16. " sUryakuNDa kA jala hatyAdi doSoM kA nAza karane vAlA ( pR0 66) 17. jo puruSa isa tIrtha kI yAtrA, pUjA Adi karatA hai vaha apane gotra sahita svarga meM pUjA jAtA hai| aura jo yahA~ Aye hue yAtriyoM ko bAMdhe yA dravya haraNa kare, to vaha pApa samUha se parivAra sahita narka meM par3atA hai / " pR0 25) (parivAra aura gotra sahita kyA, grAma sahita likhA hotA to bhI kama thA ? ) hai / " 18. prathama tIrthaMkara kahate haiM ki "zrI saMgha, arihaMta ke liye ( pR0 163) ho, kintu isa jAtI hai| aisA

Page #322
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA bhI vaMdanIya aura pUjanIya hai, isalie isakA jo pati (saMghapati) ho, vaha to lokottara sthiti vAlA hI hotA hai / ' ( pR0 171) ( arihaMta saMgha ko pUjate haiM, taba to saMghapati bhI arihaMta ke liye vizeSa rUpa se pUjanIya hai arthAt arihanta se bhI utkRSTa sthiti vAlA hai, taba vartamAna meM nikalane vAle saMghoM ke saMghapatiyoM ko AcArya, sUrivarya Adi bhI uTha baiThakara namaskAra kara pUjA kare isameM to Azcarya hI kyA? sthAnakavAsiyoM! yaha devadurlabha avasara tumheM tumhAre lakSmInandanoM ke bhAgya meM hI nahIM hai, jarA mUrti pUjaka samAja mAkubhAI Adi saMghapatiyoM ko to dekho ? ve isa paMcamakAla meM bhI arihaMtoM ke pUjya bana gaye ? kyA tumheM aisA sastA saudA nahIM cAhiye ? ) 16. " he girirAja ! tArI yAtrA no lAbha levA mATe cAlatA saMgha ratha, ghor3A, U~Ta, vagere nA paganI raja jeonA zarIre lAge temanA nivir3a pApo jarUra nAza pAme che / " 277 ( AcArya vijayapadma sUrijI jaina satya prakAza varSa 3 aMka 12) ( aura inake pairoM meM Akara marane vAle choTe jIva to usI vakta mukti pA jAte hoMge ? ) " saMbhalAya che ke hAla paNa te sthale ( zatrujaMya para ) zakrendra ghaNIvAra Ave che|" (le0 ukta jaina satya prakAza varSa 3 aMka 11) saMbhalAya kyA, sUrijI khuda jAkara vahA~ Asana lagAkara baiTha * aura mahA kavi RSabhadAsa jI ke kumArapAla rAjA nA rAsanuM rahasya meM likhA ki tIrthaMkara siddha ko namaskAra karate haiM aise siddha bhagavAn ko bhI jo puruSa saMghavI pada prApta karake tIrtha yAtrA kA lAbha letA hai " tenA guNa hamezA bahuja game che" (pR0 266) korI gappa? siddha bhagavAn ko aura 'game che' vAha ?

Page #323
278 mUrti pUjA viSayaka granthoM kI aprAmANikatA ********************************************* jAya, to unheM zakrendra ke darzana ho sakeMge aura parvata kara ke sATha hajAra se mAphI milane ke sAtha hI pAlItAnA rAjya bhI zakrendra kI kRpA se sUrijI.......nahIM nahIM AnaMdajI kalyANajI kI per3hI ko mila jAyagA? aisA maukA hAtha se nahIM jAne denA caahiye| yadi do cAra mahIne prayatna karanA par3e to karanA caahie| itanA bar3A lAbha uThAne meM kucha dina zakrendra kI rAha dekhanI par3e to kyA bar3I bAta hai? zAyada zakrendra do cAra mahIne vilamba se Ave? yadi eka sUri se itane dina eka jagaha nahIM ThaharA jAya to kucha sUrivaroM ko milakara apanI suvidhAnusAra samaya nirdhArita kara paharA Thoka denA caahie| sujJa pAThakavRnda! dekhalI mUrti pUjA ke samarthaka granthoM kI hAlata? kyA aise gapor3a zAstra bhI Agama sammata ho sakate haiM? kyA dRSTivAdAMga aise hI pAkhaNDoM se bharA thA? vAstava meM saMghapaTTaka kI prastAvanA ke lekhAnusAra yaha saba bAteM sAvadyAcAryoM ne manaHkalpita gar3ha DAlI hai aura apane pAkhaNDa ko jaina mAnya karAne ke lie aise granthoM ko dRSTivAda kA aMza batA diyA hai| hamAre sundara mitra bhI usI taraha aise granthoM ko bhI Agama sammata aura dRSTivAda kA aMza batAkara manavAne kI ceSTA kara rahe haiN| sundara mitra! aise granthoM ko hama nahIM mAnate haiM isase Apa ko duHkha hotA hai aura isIlie Apa hameM vIra vaMzaja nahIM mAnate haiM, bhale hI Apa ajJAna vaza apanA haTha na chor3eM, kintu hama to spaSTa kahate haiM ki jo loga aise pAkhaNDa purANoM ko Agama kI taraha mAnate haiM ve samyak zraddhAna se bahuta dUra haiM kyoMki ye grantha AgamoM se viparIta aura saMsAravarddhaka hai, aise granthoM ko aprAmANika ghoSita kara mUla AgamoM

Page #324
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA *********** 276 ****** para aTala zraddhA rakhane vAle hI sacce vIra vaMzaja haiM aura jo loga gapor3oM ko bhI Agama samAna mAnate haiM, unheM arhanvANI batAte haiM, ve vAstava meM zrI vIra pitA ke kula kalaMka rUpI kapUta haiM, unake aise karttavyoM se zAsana hitaiSiyoM ko kSobha honA svAbhAvika hI hai| ataeva mUrti pUjA ke pratipAdaka, samarthaka aura vidhidarzaka grantha AgamavANI se viparIta hone se upekSA karane ke hI yogya hai| (39) mUrti pUjA ke viruddha pramANa-saMgraha zrI jJAnasundara jI ne pR0 126 meM likhA hai ki "bhagavAn mahAvIra ne mUrti pUjA kA virodha kahIM bhI nahIM kiyA isalie yaha samajhanA cAhiye ki bhagavAn mahAvIra bhI isa kalyANakArI kArya meM sahamata the|" - tathA mUrti pUjaka patra "jaina dhvaja" tA0 17- 8-36 pR0 5 para bhI Apa likhate haiM ki 'mahAvIra mUrti pUjA ke kaTTara virodhI nahIM para kaTTara samarthaka the|' isa prakAra mana se modaka banAne vAle to cAhe so mAna le, unheM pramANita to karanA hI nahIM hai, vahA~ to hAthI ke dAMta sirpha dikhAne ke hI haiN| sundara mitra ko yaha nahIM sUjhA ki bhagavAn mahAvIra ke samaya mUrti-pUjA meM dharma mAnane kI zraddhA jaina samAja meM thI hI nahIM / phira usakA maMDana yA khaMDana ho bhI kaise ? bhagavAn mahAvIra ke samaya jitane matamatAMtara the unameM se bahutoM ke viSaya meM AgamoM meM ullekha milatA hai, zrI gautama svAmIjI ne anya tIrthikoM kI mAmUlI bAtoM kI bhI

Page #325
mUrti pUjA ke viruddha pramANa saMgraha **************************************** pRcchA kara samAdhAna kiyA / isa sthiti para se yaha spaSTa ho jAtA hai ki caturthakAla meM mUrti pUjA meM dharma mAnane vAlA jaina samAja thA hI nahIM, itanA hI nahIM, ajaina samudAya meM bhI mUrti pUjA meM dharma mAnane kI rIti nahIM thI, anyathA usakA bhI kisI na kisI rUpa meM ullekha hotA, sUtroM ke abhyAsa se isa bAta kA to patA lagatA hai ki usa samaya logoM meM sAMsArika bhAvanA ko lekara mUrti pUjA pracalita thI, ve bhUta, nAga, yakSa Adi kI mUrtiyeM pUjate the, koI dhana ke lie, koI putrakalatrAdi ke lie, koI zArIrika sukha yA saubhAgya ke lie athavA rUr3hi vaza isa prakAra kI pUjA hotI thI kintu dharma-AtmakalyANa ke lie bhI koI mUrti pUjA karatA ho, aisA kahIM bhI ullekha nahIM hai| isI se spaSTa ho jAtA hai ki mUrti pUjA meM dharma mAnane kI paddhati paMcamakAla (bhagavAn kevalI ke pazcAt ) kI hI hai aura isI se sarvajJa kAla ke siddhAMtoM meM isakA nAma mAtra bhI ullekha nahIM hai / 280 yadi maMDana nahIM hote hue bhI khaMDana nahIM milane mAtra se hI kisI rIti ko svIkArya samajhA jAya to vaise jaina samAja meM hI kaI matabheda thor3e hI samaya se ( bhagavAn ke bAda) cala rahe haiM, kitane hI prakAra kI nUtana mAnyatAyeM haiM, jisakA spaSTa khaMDana sUtroM meM kahIM bhI nahIM hai, to phira ve bhI vIra sammata mAnI jAyeMgI? nhiiN| phira bhI hama sundara samAdhAna ke lie mUrti pUjA ke khaMDana meM kucha pramANa nimna tIna vibhAga se dete haiM 1. jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA / 2. mUrti-pUjaka saMpradAya ke granthoM se mUrti pUjA kA khaMDana / 3. ajaina vidvAnoM ke abhiprAya / ina tInoM viSayoM para pRthak-pRthak sapramANa vivecana pAThakoM ke saMmukha rakhate haiN| .

Page #326
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 281 (1) jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA jaina dharma lokottara dharma hai, isameM guNa pUjA ko hI mukhyatA dI gaI hai, vyakti pUjA ko nhiiN| jaba taka tIrthaMkara prabhu gRhasthAvasthA meM rahate haiM, taba taka unheM eka sAmAnya sAdhu jaisA mAna bhI koI sAdhu yA zrAvaka nahIM dete aura jaba dIkSita hokara chadmasthAvasthA meM rahate haiM taba taka ve eka sAdhu kI hI koTi meM gine jAte haiN| tIrthaMkara yA kevalI tarIke nahIM tathA jaba unakA nirvANa ho jAtA hai taba unake bhautika zarIra ko agni meM jalAkara bhasma kara diyA jAtA hai| bhautika zarIra (zava) kI maujUdagI meM hI tIrthaMkara viraha mAnakara zoka chA jAtA hai| usa zarIra ko sAdhu sAdhvI yA gaNadharAdi vandanA namaskArAdi nahIM karate, isase spaSTa ho gayA ki jaina samAja vyakti pUjaka nahIM, para vyakti ke mahAn vyaktitva (guNa) kA hI pUjaka hai| hA~, vyaktitva ke sAtha vyakti kI pUjA to hotI hai, kyoMki vyaktitva vyakti meM hI rahatA hai bhinna nahIM, kintu vyaktitva ke abhAva meM vyakti pUjA nahIM hotI jaise ki - koI sAdhu varSoM taka saMyama pAle aura phira karmavaza saMyama se gira jAya to jaina samAja use taba taka hI pUjanIya mAnegA jaba taka ki usameM saMyama ke guNa haiM aura jaba use yaha mAlUma huA ki vaha to kevala vezadhArI hI hai to zIghra hI usakA bahiSkAra kara degaa| basa isIse siddha ho jAtA hai ki - jaina samAja guNa pUjaka hai, AkRti yA zarIra kA pUjaka nhiiN| jaba sAkSAt zarIra ko bhI pUjanIya nahIM mAnA jAtA taba usako mUrti yA citra ko to Adara diyA hI kaise jA

Page #327
282 mUrti pUjA ke viruddha pramANa saMgraha ****************Zhi ********************Li Hong Yu sake? isa para se eka baccA bhI samajha sakatA hai ki guNa pUjaka jaina samAja mUrti pUjA kA kisI bhI sUrata meM Adara karane vAlA nahIM hai| basa itane mAtra se yaha samajha lenA bilakula sahaja hai ki "mUrti pUjA jaina mAnyatA ke viruddha hai|" na tIna meM, na teraha meM - hama Upara dikhA cuke haiM ki - bhagavAn mahAvIra aura gautama Adi gaNadharoM ke samaya mUrti pUjA meM dharma mAnane kI jainiyoM meM zraddhA hI nahIM thI, isIlie gaNadhara racita AgamoM meM isa viSaya kA kahIM bhI ullekha nahIM miltaa| aba sundara mitra kI vizeSa saMtuSTi ke lie yahA~ AgamoM se mUrti pUjA kA khaMDana siddha kara dikhAte haiN| pAThakoM ko dhyAna meM rakhanA cAhie ki khaMDana-virodha "pratikAra" se bhI hotA hai aura "upekSA' se bhii| yahA~ hama aMtima zailI se mUrti pUjA kA khaMDana siddha karane kA prayatna karate haiM yathA - (1) ajainoM meM tIrthayAtrA karane kA rivAja bhagavAn mahAvIra ke samaya thA, bhagavatI aura pupphiyA sUtra meM somila ke prazna ke uttara meM likhA hai ki - "svayaM vIra prabhu ne somila ko kahA ki hamAre mata meM jJAna, darzana, cAritra Adi se AtmavikAsa karanA hI yAtrA hai| aisA hI uttara thAvaccA anagAra ne zukaparivrAjaka ko diyaa| aisA jJAtA dharma kathA sUtra meM ullekha hai, kintu mUrtipUjakoM ke mAne hue tIrtha aura unakI yAtrA kA nAma taka nahIM liyaa| isa se yaha spaSTa ho jAtA hai ki tIrthoM ke pahAr3a aura tadAzrita rahe hue mandira mUrti ko mAnane yA inakI yAtrA karane kI rIti jaina samAja meM thI hI nhiiN| isI se isakA ullekha nahIM karake Atmika guNoM ke vikAsa karane ko hI jainadharma meM yAtrA honA btaayaa| isa prakAra mUrti pUjaka bandhuoM ke

Page #328
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 283 ******************************************** mAne hue mandira mUrti aura unakI yAtrA kA jainadharma meM sthAna hI nahIM honA siddha hotA hai tathA yAtrA ke prazna meM bhI zrI mahAvIra kA mUrti pUjaka bhAiyoM ke tIrthoM kA nAma taka nahIM lenA, yaha spaSTa khaMDana hai| (2) prazna vyAkaraNa ke prathama Asrava dvAra meM devAlaya-mandira mUrti, stUpa, caitya Adi ke banavAne ko hiMsAkArI kRtya aura usakA aniSTa phala batAyA, yaha bhI spaSTa khaMDana hai| (3) AcArAMga sUtra meM dharma ke lie pRthvI Adi chaha kAyA kI hiMsA karane meM pApa batA kara usakA phala ahitakArI batAyA hai aura mUrti nirmANa se lagAkara pratiSThA, pUjA Adi sabhI hiMsAkArI kArya hai, ukta sUtrAnusAra isakA phala bhI vahI honA cAhie, yaha bhI spaSTa khaMDana hI samajhanA caahie| (4) ThANAMga sUtra ke tIsare sthAna meM likhA hai ki saMsAra bhara meM sthAvara tIrtha tIna haiM, tadyathA - 1. mAgadha, 2. varadAma, 3. prabhAsa jinheM cakravartI apane adhikAra meM rakhate haiM, ina tInoM tIrthoM ke sivAya zatrujaya, giranAra, AbU, sammedazikhara Adi kisI bhI tIrtha kA nAmollekha nahIM kiyA, ataeva ye bhI AgamAnusAra tIrtha nahIM kahe jA skte| jaba tIrthoM kI gaNanA ke samaya bhI inakI upekSA kI gaI to yaha khaNDana hI huaa| ___ (5) dazavaikAlika sUtra meM parama maMgalakArI dharma meM ahiMsA, saMyama aura tapa ko hI sthAna hai, mUrti pUjA ko nhiiN| (6) zramaNa varga ke paMca mahAvrata rAtri bhojana tyAga mahAvratoM kI 25 bhAvanAyeM, ubhayakAla Avazyaka karane, samiti-gupti Adi viSayaka vidhAna vistRta rUpa meM upalabdha hai, kintu kisI bhI vidhAna meM mandira mUrti ke darzana karane, yAtrArtha jAne, tadviSayaka upadeza dene Adi ___

Page #329
284 mUrti pUjA ke viruddha pramANa saMgraha ********************** ******************* viSayoM meM eka akSara mAtra bhI nahIM miltaa| yaha upekSA bhI mUrti pUjA kI mAnyatA Agama viruddha siddha karane meM prabala zakti vAlI hai| (7) sUtrakRtAMga, dazAzrutaskandha, ThANAMga Adi AgamoM meM zrAvaka dharma kA vivecana hai, jisameM pAMca aNuvrata, tIna guNavrata, cAra zikSAvrata, gyAraha pratijJA (pratimA) Adi kA ullekha hai, kintu mUrti pUjA ke lie sabhI sUtroM ne ekadama cuppI sAdhI hai, yaha upekSA bhI hamAre mUrti pUjaka bhAiyoM kI zraddhA kA virodha karatI hai| (8) uvavAI sUtra meM bhagavAn mahAvIra kI AtmakalyANakArI dezanA likhI hai, jisameM muniyoM ke mahAvrata aura zrAvakoM ke aNuvratAdi dvAdazavrata Adi kA pRthak-pRthak nirUpaNa kiyA gayA hai, kintu isa ekAnta hitakArI dharmopadeza meM bhI prabhu ne mUrti ko yAda nahIM kiyaa| isase spaSTa ho jAtA hai ki prabhu mahAvIra ko mUrti pUjA meM dharma mAnanA iSTa nahIM thA, na usa samaya isa mAnyatA kA astitva hI thaa| ___(6) mokSamArga ke mukhya cAra aMga - jJAna, darzana, cAritra aura tapa, ina cAroM meM mUrti ke liye aNumAtra bhI sthAna nhiiN| (10) sthAnAMga sUtra meM zrAvaka ke tIna manoratha batAye haiM, tadyathA - 1 Arambha parigraha ko tyAgane kI bhAvanA 2 zramaNadharma svIkAra karane kI aura 3 paMDita maraNa kii| ina tInoM bhAvanAoM meM mUrti banavAne yA pUjane athavA saMgha nikAlane Adi kI bhAvanA kA nAma hI nahIM hai| isase bhI mUrti pUjA anupAdeya ThaharatI hai| (11) isI sUtra ke cauthe sthAna (u0 3) meM bhAra vahana karane vAloM ke lie cAra vizrAma sthAna likhe haiM, jisameM tIsarA vizrAma sthAna nAgakumAra suvarNakumAra ke devAlaya kA honA to batAyA, para arhan mandira kA yahA~ nAma hI nahIM likhA, itanA hI nahIM isa vizrAma

Page #330
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ********************** 285 sthAna ke udAharaNa ko gRhasthadharma para ghaTAyA aura zrAvakoM ke lie cAra prakAra ke vizrAma sthAna batAye yathA 1 sAmAyika 2 dezAvakAsika 3 pauSadha aura 4 pratyAkhyAna / ina cAra prakAra ke vizrAMti rUpa dharma sthAnoM meM maMdira mUrti ko vizrAma sthAna nahIM btaayaa| jabaki udAharaNa meM nAgakumArAdi ke mandira kA ullekha hai| ataeva spaSTa siddha hai ki mandira mUrti gRhastha dharma se bahiSkRta hI hai| isIse dRSTAMta ke mandira ko dAnta rUpa gRhasthadharma ke nirUpaNa se sarvathA bahiSkRta rakhA gayA / (12) pA~caveM sthAna meM dharmiyoM ke lie pAMca avalambana meM 1 SaTkAya 2 gaccha 3 rAjA 4 gAthApati aura 5 zarIra avalaMbana batAye, kintu mandira mUrti nahIM / (13) dasa prakAra ke zramaNadharma meM mUrti pUjA ko tila bhara bhI sthAna nahIM hai / - (14) dasa prakAra kI samAdhi meM bhI mUrti ke darzana nahIM hote / (15) dasa prakAra kI vaiyAvRtya meM mUrti kI vaiyAvRtya kA nAma taka nahIM hai / (16) tetIsa prakAra kI AzAtanAoM meM mUrti yA mandira kI AzAtanA svIkAra nahIM kI gaI, yahA~ bhI mUrti bahiSkRta hI ThaharI / (17) uttarAdhyayana sUtra meM AtmotthAna rUpa 73 kriyAoM kA phala nirdeza kiyA gayA hai| usameM mUrti pUjA ke phala kA nAma taka nahIM hai| isa para se bhI yaha bahiSkRta hI ThaharI hai| (18) hajAroM muni mahAtmAoM ke caritroM meM se kisI eka meM bhI mandira mUrti kA ullekha nahIM hai / ataeva siddha huA ki AtmakalyANa meM isakI tanika bhI AvazyakatA nahIM hai|

Page #331
286 *** mUrtti pUjA ke viruddha pramANa saMgraha *********************** - **** (16) vaise hI AnandAdi zramaNopAsakoM ke anekoM caritroM itihAsoM ke vistRta ullekhoM para se yaha pAyA jAtA hai ki unheM bhI mUrti kI AvazyakatA nahIM huI aura binA mUrti ke hI unhoMne AtmakalyANa saadhaa| aisI sUrata meM yaha spaSTa hai ki AtmakalyANa rUpI dharma se mUrti pUjA kA koI vAstA nahIM hai| ( 20 ) uttarAdhyayana sUtra meM samyaktva aura usake lakSaNa kA digdarzana karAyA gayA, kintu usameM bhI mUrti yA mandira se samyaktva prApta honA nahIM batAyA / ataeva siddha huA ki mUrti pUjA se dharma kA sarvathA sambandha nahIM hai / (21) saMsAra meM sarvottama mAMgalika, uttama aura zaraNabhUta kevala cAra sthAna haiM - 1 arihaMta 2 siddha 3 sAdhu aura 4 dharma / isameM mUrti ke zaraNa ko svIkAra nahIM kiyA gyaa| (22) sAdhuoM ke saMyama pAlana meM sahAyaka upakaraNoM meM mUrti yA sthApanAcArya nAmaka koI upakaraNa nahIM hai, isase bhI yaha asvIkArya ThaharatI hai| (23) namaskAra mantra ke pAMca padoM meM mUrti ko aNumAtra bhI sthAna nahIM hai| (24) bhagavatI Adi sUtroM meM bhagavAn mahAvIra svAmI aura gautama gaNadhara ke hajAroM praznottara likhe haiM unameM aisA eka bhI prazna nahIM ki jisameM mUrti pUjA meM dharma mAnane vAloM ke pakSa ko kucha bhI sahArA mila ske| (25) cheda sUtroM meM anekoM bAtoM kA prAyazcitta vidhAna milatA hai, kintu mUrti ke darzana nahIM karane Adi kA prAyazcitta kisI sthAna para nahIM / ataeva ise heya mAnanA asaMgata nahIM /

Page #332
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 287 ********************************************* ukta paccIsa bAtoM meM dharma ke sabhI viSaya A gaye haiM, inameM se kisI eka meM bhI mUrti pUjA ko aNumAtra bhI sthAna nahIM hai| phira mUrti pUjA ko Agama sammata aura prabhu mahAvIra ko usake samarthaka kahane vAle kahA~ taka sacce haiM? ___ pAThaka samajha gaye hoMge ki jainAgamoM se mUrti pUjA kA sambandha "na tIna meM na teraha meM' vAlI kahAvata ke anusAra hI hai| _ aba hama mUrti pUjaka samAja ke mAnya granthoM ke pramANa pAThakoM ke sAmane peza kareMge jisase tattva nirNaya meM suvidhA ho ske| mUrti pUjaka mAnya pramANoM se mUrti pUjA kA virodha yadyapi mUrti pUjaka samAja ke granthakAroM ne mUrti pUjA ke vidhAna aura samarthana meM grantha ke grantha bhara DAle haiN| kathA granthoM meM bhI isakI bharamAra karadI hai, kintu phira bhI kisI kisI vidvAn ne kabhI kabhI nUrti pUjA kI nirarthakatA dekhakara dabI jabAna se bhI virodha to kiyA hai| jisake khAsa khAsa pramANa yahA~ diye jAte haiM, pAThaka dhyAna pUrvaka pddh'eN| (1) mahAnizItha * sUtra ke kuzIla nAmaka adhyayana meM isa prakAra kA ullekha hai ki - * isa mahAnizItha sUtra kA nAma nandIsUtra meM hai ataeva yaha samasta zvetAmbara jaina samAja kA mAnya honA caahie| kintu caityavAda ke samaya isa sUtra meM bhI parivartana kara diyA gyaa| isa zAstra meM kucha Agama virodhI aMza bhI dhusa gyaa| isIlie sthAnakavAsI samAja vartamAna meM mahAnizItha ko sampUrNa rUpa se mAnya nahIM krtii| svayaM mahAnizItha sUtra se hI yaha bAta siddha hotI hai tathA mUrtipUjaka kA0--se prakAzita jaina sAhitya no saMkSipta itihAsa pR0 76 meM likhA hai ki - ___

Page #333
288 mUrti pUjA ke viruddha pramANa sagraha **********************Xue Xue ************* "dravyastava jina pUjA AraMbhika hai aura bhAvastava-bhAvapUjA anAraMbhika hai| bhale hI meru parvata samAna svarNa prAsAda banavAye jAyeM yA pratimA banAI jAya athavA dhvajA, daMDa, toraNa, kalaza, ghaMTA Adi lagAye jAya~, kintu yaha kriyA bhAvastava-munivrata-ke anaMtaveM bhAga meM bhI nahIM A sktii| xxxxx jina mandira jina pratimA pramukha AraMbhika kAryoM meM bhAvastava vAle muni ko khar3A bhI nahIM rahanA cAhiye, yadi khar3e raheM to ananta saMsArI bneN| xxxxx jisane samabhAva se kalyANa ke liye dIkSA lI aura bAda meM munivrata ko chor3akara na to sAdhu meM va na zrAvaka meM, aisA ubhaya bhraSTa nAmadhArI sAdhu kahe ki maiM to tIrthaMkara bhagavAn kI pratimA kI jala, candana, akSata, dhUpa, dIpa, phala, naivedya Adi se pUjA karake tIrtha kI sthApanA 1. "102 chaThu cheda sUtra 6 mahAnizItha AmUla naSTa thayu hatu ane teno uddhAra haribhadra sUrie ko hto|" 2. zrIyuta agaracandajI nAhaTA "jaina Agama sAhitya" nAmaka lekha meM likhate haiM ki "mahAnizItha ke uddhAra kartAoM meM 8 nAma Ate haiM ve samakAlIna nahIM, taba unhoMne milakara kaise uddhAra kiyA? jaina satyaprakAza va0 4 a0 1-2 pR0 (173) / isa sUtra meM eka sthala para mUrti pUjA kA phala vidhAna bhI kiyA gayA hai, isa prakAra paraspara virodhI bAta se bhI yaha pAyA jAtA hai ki yaha parivartana (phala vidhAna) caityavAda ke yuvAvasthA meM hI huA ho tathA aura bhI azAstrIya viSaya (deva dravyAdi) ke praviSTa ho jAne se sAdhumArgI samAja ise prAmANika nahIM mAnatI, hA~ mUrti pUjaka samAja meM to yaha zAstra mAnanIya hai| kintu mUrtipUjaka samAja (tathA Agamodaya sa0) ne ise chapAyA kyoM nahIM? kyA mUrti pUjA ke viruddha ullekha hone se hii|

Page #334
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA hai ************************ kara rahA hU~ to aisA kahane vAlA bhraSTa zramaNa kahA jAtA hai, kyoMki vaha ananta kAla taka caturgati rUpa saMsAra meM paribhramaNa karegA / " isake bAda pAMcaveM adhyayana meM likhA hai ki 286 "jina pUjA meM lAbha hai, aisI prarUpaNA jo koI adhikatA se kare tathA isa prakAra svayaM yA dUsare bhadra lokoM se phala, phUloM kA Arambha kareM aura karAveM, to ina sabako samyaktva bodha durlabha ho jAtA hai / (2) vivAha cUliyA sUtra ke pAhur3e 6 uddeze 8 meM nimna pATha "jai NaM bhaMte jiNa paDimANaM vaMdamANe accamANe, sUyadhammaM caritta dhammaM labhejjA ? goyamA ! No aNaTTe saTTe se keNaNaM bhaMte evaM vuccaI ? goyamA ! puDhavIkAyaM hiMsai jAva tasakAyaM hiMsai / " arthAt - zrI gautamasvAmIjI prazna karate haiM ki - jina pratimA kI vandanA, arcanA karane se kyA zruta cAritra dharma kI prApti hotI hai? bhagavAn uttara dete haiM, nahIM / punaH prazna hotA hai, kyoM nahIM ? prabhu pharamAte haiM ki - pRthivI kAyA se lekara trasa kAyA taka kI isameM hiMsA hotI hai isaliye / yadyapi ukta mUla pATha se praznottara mahAvIra prabhu aura gautama gaNadhara ke bIca honA pAyA jAtA hai| aura yaha sUtra hai AcArya praNIta, phira isameM aisA sambandha kyoM rakkhA gayA ? isa viSaya meM yahI samAdhAna hai ki - jisa samaya janatA mUrti pUjA meM hI apanA kalyANa mAnakara sImAtIta ajJAna dazA meM pahu~ca cukI thI usa samaya kisI

Page #335
260 mUrti pUjA ke viruddha-pramANa saMgraha ****************** *********************** suhRda AcArya ne janatA kA ajJAna sarvajJa bhagavAn mahAvIra aura gautama gaNadhara ke nAma se isa sUtra racanA dvArA dUra karane ke irAde se aisA kiyA ho to Azcarya nhiiN| kyoMki janatA AcAryAdi ke vacanoM kI apekSA tIrthaMkara vacanoM para adhika vizvAsa vAlI hotI hai| dUsarA yaha eka prakAra kI racanA zailI bhI hai| kaI AcArya racita granthoM meM isI prakAra ke praznottaroM kA DhAMcA dikhAI detA hai, isa bIsavIM zatAbdI ke gautamapRcchAdi grantha jinhoMne dekhe hoM ve isa bAta ko saralatA se samajha sakate haiM, isI prakAra vivAha cUliyA ke racayitA ne bhI zAyada isI zailI kA anukaraNa kiyA ho? kucha bhI ho, para yaha to satya hai ki yaha praznottara tIrthaMkara aura gaNadhara ke bIca ke to nahIM hai, kyoMki usa samaya isa prathA kA janma hI nahIM huA thA, to praznottara kI utpatti hI kaise ho? itanA hote hue bhI yaha grantha mUrti pUjaka samAja kA mAnya hone se ukta ullekha se mUrti pUjA kA virodha to spaSTa ho jAtA hai, zAyada isIliye zrI Agamodaya samiti ne ise chapavAne kI kRpA nahIM kI ho? . (3) vyavahAra sUtra kI cUlikA meM zrImadbhadrabAhu svAmI zrI candragupta rAjA ke pAMcaveM svapna kA phala batAte hue kahate haiM ki - "paMcamae duvAlasa phaNiM saMjutto kaNha ahi diTTho tassaphalaM duvAlasavAsa parimANe dukkAlo bhavissaI tattha kAliya sUyappamuhANi suttANi vocchijjisaMti "ceiya ThavAvei davvahAriNo muNiNo bhavissaMti, lobheNa mAlA rohaNa devala uvahANa ujjamaNa jiNabiMba paiTThAvaNavihiM pagAsissaMti, avihe paMthe paDisaI tattha je keI sAhu

Page #336
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 261 ****Li **Jing *****Jing **** *****Li ****** sAhuNi sAvaya sAviyAo vihi magge buhisaMti tesaM bahuNaM hilaNANaM, jiMdaNANaM, khisaNANaM, garahiNANaM bhvissi|" - arthAt - pAMcaveM svapna meM jo tumane bAraha phaNoM vAle kAle nAga ko dekhA hai, usakA phala yaha hai ki - bhaviSya meM bAraha varSa kA duSkAla par3egA, usameM kAlika Adi sUtra viccheda jaayNge| sAdhu dravya rakhane vAle hoMge, caitya sthApanA kareMge, lobha ke vaza hokara mUrti ke gale meM mAlA ropaNa kreNge| mandira udyApana ujAmaNA kraaveNge| jinabiMba sthApanA kareMge vidhimArga se skhalita hokara avidhimArga meM pdd'eNge| tathA jo sAdhu sAdhvI zrAvaka aura zrAvikA usa samaya vidhimArga meM pravartane vAle hoMge, unakI niMdA apamAna apazabdAdi se vizeSa rUpa se kreNge| (4) saMbodhaprakaraNa meM zrI haribhadra sUri likhate haiM ki - "saMnihi mahAkammaM jala phala kusumAi savva scitt| ceiya maThAivAsaM pUyAraMbhAI niccvaasittN| devAi davvabhogaM jiNahara zAlAi krnnNc|" arthAt - caityavAda se caityavAsa kA sambandha dikhAte hue kahate haiM ki - prathama to pUjA ke liye sacitta jala phala, phUla Adi kA Arambha karanA zurU huA, phira devAdi ke nAma se dravya saMcaya devadravya bhakSaNa, jina mandirAdi banAnA prArambha huA, aura phira caitya meM vAsa karanA claa| (5) sandeha dolAvali meM likhA hai ki - "gaDarIpavAhau je ei nayara dIsaI bahu jaNehiM, jiNaggahakAravaNAi so dhammo suttaviruddho adhammoya"

Page #337
262 *********************************Kong ******* arthAt - jinaghara-mandira-karavAnA yaha dharma sUtra viruddha adharma hote hue bhI bahuta loka karate haiN| vAstava meM loka samUha bher3iyA pravAha kI taraha andhAnukaraNa karane vAlA hI adhika hotA hai| (6) saMghapaTTaka meM zrI jinavallabha sUri likhate haiM ki - "AkRSTuM mugdhamInAn baDizapizitavabdiMbamAdI jainN| tannAmnA ramyarUpAnapavarakamaThAn sveSTasiddhayai vidhaapy|| yAtrA snAtrAdyupAyairnamasitaka nizAjAgarAdyai cchalaizca / zraddhAlu majainecchalita iva shrvcytehaajno'ym|| 21 // " arthAt - jisa prakAra rasendriya mugdha machaliyoM ko pha~sAne ke lie badhika loga mAMsa ko kAMTe meM lagAte haiM, usI prakAra dravya liMgI loga nAmadhArI zraddhAlu jainoM ko mAMsavat jinabiMba dikhAkara aura svargAdi phala siddhi kahakara yAtrA snAna Adi upAyoM se tathA nizAjAgaraNAdi chala se Thagate haiN| yaha mahadAzcarya hai| (7) Avazyaka hAribhadrIyavRtti meM ullekha hai ki - davvathao bhAvathao, davvathao bahuguNatti buddhi miaa| aniuNamaivayaNamiNaM, chjjiivhiaNjinnaabiNti|| 162|| chajjIvakAya saMjamu, davvathaeso virujjhaI ksinno| to kasiNa saMjama viu, pupphAIaM na icchNti|| 163 // artha - dravyastava aura bhAvastava, yadi yaha kahA jAya ki dravyastava bahuta guNa vAlA hai to yaha buddhi kI anipuNatA hai kyoMki zrI tIrthaMkara mahArAja chaha kAya jIvoM ke hita ko kahate haiM, aura chaha kAya jIvoM kI rakSA rUpa saMyama meM dravyastava sampUrNa virodhI hai isaliye saMyama ko jAnakara muni puSpAdi ko nahIM cAhate haiN| (8) isI Avazyaka kI 1106 vIM gAthA meM nAma, sthApanA

Page #338
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 263 ********************************************* aura dravya aise tIna bheda ke sAdhu ko avaMdanIya batAkara samiti, gupti Adi bhAvaguNa yukta sAdhu ko hI vaMdanIya svIkAra kiyA hai, isase bhI nAma, sthApanA aura dravya arihaMta avaMdanIya Thahara kara kevala jJAnAdi bhAvaguNa yukta arihaMta hI vaMdanIya siddha hote haiN| (8) zrAddhavidhi nAmaka grantha meM zrAvaka kA svarUpa batAte hue likhA hai ki - "nAmAI caubheo saDDo, bhAveNai iccha ahigaaro| tiviho abhAva saDo, saNa-vaya-uttara gunnehiN|| 4 // " __arthAt - zrAvaka ke 1 nAma 2 sthApanA 3 dravya aura 4 bhAva yaha cAra bheda haiM, inameM se tIna bheda ko chor3akara bhAva zrAvaka hI icchanIya hai bhAva zrAvaka tIna taraha ke hote haiM, jaise - 1 darzana zrAvaka 2 vratadhArI zrAvaka aura 3 uttara guNa vAlA shraavk| isa para vyAkhyA karate hue "zrAddhavidhi" pR0 81 meM likhA hai ki "kevala nAmadhArI, citrAmaNanI athavA jemAM gAyonAM lakSaNa nathI, te gAya jema potAnuM kAma karI zakatI nathI, tema 1 nAma 2 sthApanA ane 3 dravya zrAvaka paNa potAnuM iSTa dharmakArya karI zakato nathI, mATe ahi bhAva zrAvaka noja adhikAra jaannvo|" kahane kI AvazyakatA nahIM ki isI taraha sthApanA-mUrtijina bhI nirarthaka hai| (10) hAribhadrIya Avazyaka gAthA 1138 meM rUpaka mudrA se eka caubhaMgI vaMdanIya avaMdanIya para ghaTAI hai, usakA bhAva zrI sAgarAnanda sUrijI ke zabdoM meM nimna prakAra se hai - "eka to cAMdIno kaTako, jo ke cokkhI cAMdI no che, chatA tenI Upara rupIAnI mahora chApa na hoya tene rupIyo kahevAya nahIM,

Page #339
294 mUrti pUjA ke viruddha pramANa saMgraha ************************************** * ane te calaNa tarIke upayoga mAM AvI zake nahi, bIjo rupIAnI chApa trAMbAnA kaTakA upara hoya to paNa te trAMbAno kaTako rupIA tarIke cAlI zake nahi, trIjo trAMbAnA kaTakA upara paisAnI chApa hoya to te rupIo naja gaNAya, ane cautho bhAgoja evoja cheke jemAM cAMdI cokkhI ane chApa paNa rupIAnI sAMcI hoya tenoja duniyA mAM rupIA tarIke vyavahAra thaI zake ane calaNa mAM caale|" . (dIkSAnuM sundara svarUpa pR0 17) jisa prakAra cAMdI kA mudrAyukta sikkA hI rupayA mAnA jAtA hai, usI prakAra kevala jJAnAdi guNa yukta arihaMta yA tIrthaMkara hI vandanIya ho sakate haiM, kintu tAMbe ke Tukar3e para rupaye kI chApa vAle dUsare bhaMga kI taraha mUrti vandanIya nahIM ho sktii| ukta udAharaNa sarvathA upayukta hai| (11) AcArya vijayAnanda sUrijI ajJAna timira bhAskara pR0 296 meM likhate haiM ki - "kitanIka kriyA ko je Agama meM nahiM kathana karI hai, tina ko karate haiM, aura je Agama meM niSedha nahi karI hai ciraMtana jano ne AcaraNa karI hai tinako avidhi kahakara niSedha karate haiM aura kahate haiM yaha kriyAyoM dharmI janA ko karaNe yogya nahi hai kina kina kriyAyoM viSe "caitya kRtyeSu snAtra biMba pratimA krnnaadi|" arthAt - kitane hI loga aise haiM jo caitya karavAne, biMba pratimA banavAne, snAtra pUjAdi karane kI kriyAoM ko avidhi kahakara niSedha karate haiM, kyoMki AgamoM meM inakA kathana nahIM hai| parantu pUrva puruSoM ne isakA AcaraNa kiyA hai aura Agama meM inakA niSedha bhI nahIM hai| ___

Page #340
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 265 *Jing ****Zhong Zi ******************************** ukta avataraNa meM sApha batAyA gayA hai ki caitya kRtya, mUrti pUjAdi Agama sammata nahIM, para pUrva puruSoM dvArA Acarita hai| (12) AgamoddhAraka zrI sAgarAnanda sUrijI dIkSAnuM suMdara svarUpa pR0 147 meM likhate haiM ki - ___ "zrI jinezvara bhagavAn nI pUjA vigere nuM phala cAritra dharma ArAdhananA lAkhamAM aMze paNa nathI AvatuM ane te thI tevA pUjA Adi ne choDIne paNa bhAva dharmarUpa cAritra aGgikAra karavA mAM Ave che|" (13) "adhyAtma prakaraNa' antargata "tattvasAroddhAra'' nAmaka grantha meM mUrti pUjaka vidvAn zrI hukmamunijI pR0 410 se likhate haiM ki ___ "tIratha jAtrA vrata niyama kare te paNa punya to thAya te bAta paNa mithyAta che zAmATe ke sthAvara tIratha nI jAtrAeM javu Avaq te / kAMi dharamamAM nathI kemake tene koi guNaThANAnI apekSA lAge nhii|" ziSya - svAmI cothA guNaThANAnI ekaraNI che, ane tamopaNa samyaktadvAra grantha mAM tathA mandira svAmInI DhAlo pramukha ghaNA zAstromAM lAvelA cho ne tame ihAM nA kema kaho cho|| guru - he mAnubhAva ameje samyaktadvAra pramukha ne viSe lAvyA chiye tenuM kAraNa sAMbhala eka to kalapa vehevAra, akAlanA ghaNA lokonuM mAnetuM mATe, tathA vIjuM kAraNa ke DhUMDIyA lokoM bIlakula pratimA uThAvIne beThA che, te ApaNA pakSane mAna dekhAr3avAM vAste, tathA trIjuM kAraNa e ke sAsana sAru dIse eTalAmATe ame lAvelA chiie|" arthAt - mUrti pUjA, yAtrA karanA Adi dharmakArya nahIM hai| na puNya kArya hI hai| isameM kisI guNasthAna kI apekSA bhI nahIM hai aura hamane jo anya sthAnoM para mUrti pUjAdi kRtyoM ko cauthe guNasthAna kA kArya batAyA usakA kAraNa yaha hai ki prathama to kalpa vyavahAra

Page #341
266 mUrti pUjA ke viruddha pramANa saMgraha **Ban ******************************************* arthAt isa samaya ke bahuta logoM kA mAnA huA, dUsarA DhUMDhiyesAdhumArgI pratimA ko sarvathA nahIM mAnate isaliye apane pakSa ko ucca batAne vAste tathA tIsarA kAraNa yaha hai ki isase zAsana acchA dikhatA hai isIliye hamane anya sthaloM para cauthe guNasthAna meM mUrtipUjAdi kriyA ko batalAyA hai| (14) "anubhavamAlA' urpha "svAnubhava-darpaNa' mUlakartA zrI "yogendradevajI'' vivecanakAra mUrtipUjaka samAja ke prasiddha vidvAn paM0 "lAlana' mudraNa samaya vi0 saM0 1962 ke kucha dohe nimna prakAra se haiN| "tIrtho ne deharA viSe, nizcaya deva na jaann| jinavANI guru ima kahe, dehamAM deva pramANa|| 41 // " __ (pR0 43) bhAvArtha - e khAtarI pUrvaka che, ema jinezvara bhagavAn ane guru mahArAja kahe che, eTale ke tIrthamA ane deharA mAM deva nathI, parantu deva to deharUpI mandiramAMja ch| "tana mandira mAM jIva jina, mandira mUrti na dev| rAjA bhikSArthe bhame, evI janane ttev|| 42 // " (pR0 47) nathI deva deharA viSe, che mUrti citraam| jJAnI jANe devane, mUkha bhame bhutthaam|| 43|| (pR05) kharo deva che dehamAM, jJAnI jANe teh| tIrtha devAlaya deva nahI, pratimA nizcaya eh||44||

Page #342
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 267 artha sugama hai| (15) mahAmahopAdhyAya zrImad yazovijayajI hamAre samAja kA khaMDana karate hue "pratimA zataka'' meM likhate haiM ki - sAvadhaM vyavahAra topi bhagavan sAkSAkilA naadisht| balyAdi pratimArcanAdi guNakRta maunena sNmnyte|| __ arthAt - balidAna aura pratimA pUjana Adi kriyA vyavahAra se sAvadya (niMdanIya) hone ke kAraNa bhagavAn apane mu~ha se isakA upadeza nahIM krte| kintu guNakArI hone se mauna se isakA samarthana karate haiM / (16) mUrti pUjaka samAja ke pratibhA sampanna vidvAn paM0 becaradAsajI dosI apane "jaina sAhitya meM vikAra thavAthI thayelI hAnI'' nAmaka nibaMdha ke pR0 125 meM likhate haiM ki - "mUrtivAda caityavAda pachIno che eTale ene caityavAda jeTalo prAcIna mAnavAne ApaNI pAse eka paNa evaM majabUta pramANa nathI ke je zAstrIya (sUtra vidhi niSpanna) hoya, vA aitihAsika hoy| Amato ApaNe ane ApaNA kulAcAryoM suddhAM mUrtivAda ne anAdi no TharAvavAnI tathA vardhamAna bhASita jaNAvavAnI vaNagA phukavA jevI vAtoM karyA karIe chIe, paNa jyAre te vAto ne siddha karavA mATe koI aitihAsika pramANa vA aMga sUtra nuM vidhivAkya mAMgavAmAM Ave che tyAre ApaNI pravAhavAhI paraMparAnI DhAlane Agala dharIe chIe, ane bacAva mATe ApaNA vaDilone Agala karIe chIe, meM dhaNI kozIza karI to paNa paraMparA ane "bAbA vAkyaM pramANaM' sivAya mUrtivAda ne sthApita * yahI to upAdhyAya jI kI mUrti pUjakatA hai| zAyada bhagavAn ke mana ke bhAva upAdhyAya jI ne jAna liye hoN|

Page #343
268 mUrti pUjA ke viruddha-pramANa saMgraha ***************************Xue Xue ********* karavA mATe mane eka paNa pramANa vA vidhAna malI zakyu nathI, vartamAna kAlamAM mUrtipUjA nA samarthanamA keTalIka kathAo ne (cAraNa muninI, dropadInI kathA, sUryAbha nI kathA, vijayadevanI kathA) paNa Agala karavAmAM Ave che kintu vAcakoe A bAbata khAsa lakSyamA levAnI che ke vidhi granthoM mAM darzAvAto vidhi, AcAra granthoM mAM darzAvAtuM AcAra vidhAna khAsa zabdomAMja darzAvavA mAM Ave che paNa koinI kathAoM mAMthI ke koinA oThAM laine amuka amuka vidhAna vA AcAra upajAvI zakAto nathI, eka kathAmAM tenA nAyake je amuka jAtaAcaraNa karyu hoya te badhAne mATe vidheya ke siddhAMtarUpa hoi zakatuM nathI,........mAruM to ema mAnavu che ke jyAre AcAranA granthoM judAja racavA mAM AvyA che-Ave che, ane temAM pratyeka nAnA moTA AcAroM nuM vidhAna karavAmAM AvyuM che-Ave che, te chatAM temAM je vidhAna no gaMdhapaNa na jaNAto hoya te vidhAna nA samarthana mATe ApaNe kathAo nA oThAM laie ke koinA udAharaNo ApIe te bAbatane huM "tamastaraNa" sivAya bIjA zabdathI kahI zakato nathI, huM "himmata pUrvaka" kahI zakuM chauM ke meM sAdhuoM tema zrAvakoM mATe deva darzana ke deva pUjana nuM vidhAna koI aGga sUtromAM joyu nathI, vAcyu nathI, eTaluMja nahiM paNa bhagavatI vagere sUtro mAM keTalAka zrAvako nI kathAo Ave che temA teonI caryAnI paNa noMdha che, parantu temAM eka paNa zabda evo jaNAto nathI te je uparathI ApaNe ApaNI ubhI karelI devapUjana nI ane tadAzrita deva dravyanI mAnyatAne TakAvI shkiie| ___ huM ApaNA samAjanA dhuraMdharo ne namratA pUrvaka vinaMti karuM chu ke teo mane te viSernu eka paNa pramANa vA prAcIna vidhAna-vidhi vAkya batAvaveze to huM teono ghaNoja RNi thish|" ___ ww

Page #344
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 266 ********************************************* Age calakara pR0 138 para likhate haiM ki - "hUM dRr3hatA pUrvaka eTaluM jaNAvI zakuM chaM ane Agala jaNAvI cukyo chu ke je mUrtivAda - vidhAna ane devadravyano gaMdha sUtra (aMga) graMthoM mAM malato nathI teno samarthana pUrvaka ullekha haribhadrasUri kare che tenuM mUla zuM hovU joie?" ___isake pUrva pR0 131 meM isa prakAra likhA hai - "hu~ to tyAM sudhI mArnu chu ke zramaNa granthakAro jeo pAMca mahAvrata nA pAlaka che sarvathA hiMsAne karatA nathI, karAvatA nathI ane temAM sammati paNa ApatA nathI, jeo mATe koi jAta no dravyastava vidheya rUpe hoi zakato nathI teo hiMsA mUlaka AmUrtivAda nA vidhAna no ane tadavalambI deva dravyanA vidhAnano ullekha zIrIte kare? (17) digambara samAja ke "pAtra kezarI' stotra ke 37 teM zloka meM likhA hai ki - vimokSasukha caityadAna pari puujnaadhaatmikaaH| kriyA bahuvidhAsubhRnmaraNa pIDanA hetvH|| tvayAjvalita kevalena nahi dezitA kiMtutAstvayi prasRta bhaktibhiH svaya manuSTitA: zrAvakaiH // 37 // ___arthAt - mokSa sukha se rahita karane vAlI "caitya vaMdanA, dAna, pUjA" Adi svarUpa meM sabhI kriyAeM nAnA prakAra se prANiyoM ke maraNa aura pIr3A karane kI kAraNa hai, he jinendra! jvAjalyamAna kevalajJAna se yukta hokara Apane una dAna pUjAdi kriyAoM kA upadeza nahIM diyA hai| kevala tumhArI bhakti karane vAle zrAvakoM ne una kriyAoM ko svayameva kara liyA hai|" (pannAlAlajI bAkalIvAla dvArA pra0 pR0 36)

Page #345
300 mUrti pUjA ke viruddha pramANa saMgraha *************Ban *********************** pAThako! itane pramANa mUrtipUjaka samAja ke vidvAnoM-granthakAroM ke Apake sAmane peza kiye gaye, aba thor3e se ajaina vidvAnoM ke bhI vicAra dekhiye - ajaina vidAn aura mUrti-pUjA jainetara samAja meM bhI bahuta se vidvAn jo ki mUrtipUjaka vAtAvaraNa meM janme, pale aura bar3e hue ve bhI paripakva abhyAsa aura dIrgha manana ke pazcAt yaha svIkAra kara cuke haiM ki mUrti-pUjA AtmA ke utthAna meM Avazyaka nahIM, kintu vyartha hai| kucha pramANa bhI dekhiye (1) kAkA kAlelakara sAhaba loka jIvana meM likhate haiM ki - "caitanya nI bhUkha mUrti thI zIrIte bhaage| jIvaMta mUrti uddhAra kare che, ane niSprANa mUrti to galAmA patthara banIne DubADe che" (2) AcArya paMDita caturasenajI zAstrI likhate haiM ki - "pAkhaNDa meM saba se pahilA nambara mUrti pUjA kA hai| do hajAra varSa se bhI adhika kAla se isa pAkhaNDa ne manuSya jAti ko bevakUpha banAyA hai| Aja saMsAra bhara kI sabhya jAtiyoM ne mUrti-pUjA ko naSTa kara diyA hai| vaha yA to kucha jaMgalI jAtiyoM meM jo tAtAra ke ujAr3a pradeza meM hai, athavA aphrikA ke asabhya logoM meM yA phira apane ko saba se zreSTha samajhane vAle hinduoM meM pracalita haiN| yahA~ hama saMkSepa meM mUrti pUjA kA itihAsa diye dete haiN| ___ sabase prathama maiM dRr3hatA pUrvaka Apako yaha batA denA cAhatA hU~ ki prAcIna kAla ke hinduoM kA koI mandira na thA aura ve mUrti kI pUjA nahIM karate the| veda meM mUrti pUjA kA koI vidhAna nahIM hai| veda meM ___

Page #346
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 301 ****************************************** una devatAoM kA bhI koI jikra nahIM hai jinako ina pezevara gunahagAroM ne kalpita karake jhUTha aura beImAnI kI dukAna kholI hai| .. . ("dharma ke nAma para" pR0 133 kA pAkhaMDa prakaraNa) (3) "sarasvatI" mAsika patrikA julAI san 1916 meM devottara kA itihAsa pR07-20 meM eka vidvAn likhate haiM ki - "mUrti pUjA kI utpatti yA to yahIM kI basI huI jaGgalI jAtiyoM kI nakala karake huI hogI, yA usa samaya kI bAhara se dhAvA karane vAlI jAtiyoM kI dekhA dekhI sIkhI gaI hogI xx buddha ke jIvana meM zAyada unake lie koI mandira nahIM banAyA thA, parantu unakI mRtyu ke uparAMta bahuta se mandira bana gaye jina meM unakI mUrtiyAM rakkhI gaI x jaba tAMtrika bauddha mata kA pracAra bar3hA taba bahuta se mandira banAye jAne lage x tAMtrika mata ke anusAra bauddha, vaiSNava aura zaiva matoM kA mela hokara aisA dharma nikalA jisameM devatA aura devI kI pUjA sAtha sAtha hone lgii| zakti yA prakRti kI pUjA pAMcavIM yA chaTThI zatAbdi se zuru huii| tAMtrika mata hI ke bAda se mUrti pUjana ne jora pkdd'aa|" (jaina sAhitya meM vikAra thavAthI thayelI hAni pR0 241 se) (4) svAmI dayAnanda sarasvatI ne satyArtha prakAza meM likhA hai ki - prazna - mUrti pUjA kahA~ se calI? uttara - jainiyoM se| prazna - jainiyoM ne kahA~ se calAI? uttara - apanI mUrkhatA se aadi| pAThakoM ko dhyAna rakhanA cAhiye ki svAmI dayAnanda sarasvatI

Page #347
302 upasaMhAra kA saMhAra mUrti pUjA ke kaTTara virodhI the, ukta mantavya meM svAmIjI ne mUrti pUjA kA prArambha jainiyoM se batAyA, yaha zAyada unake samaya jainiyoM meM mUrti pUjA kI adhikatA yA aise hI kisI kAraNa se ho| anyathA mUrti pUjA kA prArambha pahale sAMsArika bhUta pretAdi kI mUrtiyoM se aura bAda meM bauddhamata se huA hai| aisA vidvAnoM kA abhiprAya hai| isa pramANa ko yahIM samApta karate hue hama pAThakoM se anurodha karate haiM ki ve svayaM ukta tInoM prakAra ke pramANoM para vicAra kareM, unheM spaSTa jJAta hogA ki mUrti pUjA se AtmakalyANa mAnane vAle satya se sahasroM kosa dUra haiN| (40) upasaMhAra kA saMhAra zrI jJAnasundarajI ne kalpanA taraGga meM bahate hue cauthe prakaraNa kI samApti kI hai usake upasaMhAra pR0 115 meM sarva prathama likhA hai ki - . "eka mUrti ko na mAnane se hamAre sthAnakamArgI bhAiyoM ko kitanA nukasAna huA hai usako bhI jarA par3ha liijiye| (1) mUrti na mAnane se jo loga tIrtha yAtrArtha jAte the mAsa do mAsa Arambha parigraha, vyApAra aura gRhakArya se nivRtta pAte the, brahmacarya vrata pAlana karate the, zubha kSetra meM dravya vyaya kara puNyopArjana karate the, una saba kAryoM se unheM vaMcita rahanA pdd'aa|" sundara mitra kA abhiprAya yaha hai ki mUrti aura tIrtha yAtrA karane se hI Arambha parigrahAdi kA tyAga, brahmacarya pAlana aura dAnAdi hote haiN| mUrti nahIM mAnane se ukta satkArya nahIM ho skte| kintu yaha ___

Page #348
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA **************** 303 **** bhAnyatA ThIka nahIM hai / sthAnakavAsI samAja binA mUrti ke hI sAmAyika, saMvara, dayA, pauSadha aura aneka prakAra ke tapa, dAna Adi sadkArya kara sakate haiN| hamAre pUrvaja Ananda kAmadevAdi ne bhI mUrti mandira aura yAtrA ke binA hI dharma sAdhana kara liyA thA / hameM bhI dharma sAdhana meM mUrti kI tanika bhI AvazyakatA nahIM hai, jo loga mUrti pUjA yA yAtrAdi meM Arambha, parigraha tyAga tathA nivRtti batalAte haiM ve samyag zraddhAna se dUra haiM kyoMki mUrti pUjA aura yAtrA meM pratyakSa rUpa se Arambha samArambha rahA hai| sabhI jAnate haiM ki ina logoM ke ukta kAryoM meM vyartha kA Arambha aura phijUla dravya vyaya hotA hai, isa prakAra kI kriyAoM meM saMvara, saMyama, nivRtti yA sanmArga meM artha vyaya nahIM hote / isaliye sundara mitra kA ukta ahaMkAra yukta kathana sarvathA asatya hai / Age Apa likhate haiM ki - (2) " dravya pUjA nahIM karane vAle bhI mandira meM jAkara navakAra kI mAlA, namotthuNaM yA stavana bola tIrthaMkaroM kI nirantara pratijJA pUrvaka bhaktikara zubha karmopArjana tathA karma nirjarA karate the, unase vaMcita rahe, ve ulTe nindA kara karmabandhana karane lage / " ukta kathana meM ahaMkAra kI mAtrA adhika rahI hai, maiM sundara mitra se pUchatA hU~ ki kyA sthAnakavAsI samAja ke liye navakAra japane natthUNaM Adi se stuti karane ke liye maMdiroM tathA mUrtiyoM ke sivAya koI sthAna hI nahIM hai? kyA binA mUrti ke kiyA huA jA yA stuti vyartha ho jAtI hai? yadi aisA hI hai to Apa logoM ke jApa pratikramaNa svAdhyAyAdi bhI vyartha ho jAya~ge / kyoMki Apa bhI ukta mUrti ke sAmane nahIM karake, apane Thaharane ke sthAna para bhI karate haiN| yadi Apa sthApanAcArya ke saMmukha karane kA kaheM to yaha bhI 1

Page #349
304 upasaMhAra kA saMhAra ******************************************** anucita hai| kyoMki yaha sthApanA anucita hote hue bhI tIrthaMkaroM kI nahIM hokara AcArya kI hI hai aura AcArya ke sAmane tIrthaMkara yA una kI mUrti kA caityavaMdana yA siddhAcala pahAr3a kA caityavaMdana, zAMtistotra Adi bolanA vyartha hI hai| sAkSAt meM bhI AcArya ko lakSya kara yA unake saMmukha unheM sunA kara-tIrthaMkara kI prArthanA nahIM kI jAtI, taba sthApanAcArya ke sAmane to ye caitya vaMdanAdi kaise ho sakate haiM? ataeva Apake hisAba se hI Apake ye kRtya niSphala aura vyartha Thaharate haiN| bandhuvara! stuti svAdhyAya yA jApa hama dharma sthAnoM meM kara sakate haiN| isake liye kalpita mUrti kI AvazyakatA nhiiN| hama apane kSayopazama ke anusAra puNya yA nirjarA binA mUrti ke hI kara sakate haiN| itanA hI nahIM mUrtiyoM aura mandiroM se vaMcita raha kara hamane apane ko karmoM ke bahuta se bandhanoM se bacA liyaa| jisameM jJAnAvaraNIya, darzanAvaraNIya aura mohanIya Adi kI mukhyatA hai| kyoMki mandiroM aura mUrtiyoM kI sajAvaTa AkarSakatA se sabhI indriyoM ke viSayoM kA poSaNa hotA hai, cakSuoM ko mohane vAlI sajAvaTa karNoM ko priya lagane vAlA gAna-vAdana, ghrANa-priya suvAsita puSpa, dhUpa, battI, itrAdi, rasendriya ko calita karane vAlI mevA miThAI kI bheMTe tathA sparzendriya ko jAgRta karane vAle snAna mardanAdi prAyaH sabhI karma bandhana meM jakar3ane vAle haiM, vivAha Adi utsava ke samaya sajAvaTa aura gAna vAdanAdi hotA hai, vahA~ jAkara yadi koI virAga bhAva se lauTatA ho to mandiroM se virAga bhAva prApta hone kI bAta satya kahI jA sakatI hai| yadyapi vivAha Adi ke samaya sAMsArika gIta gAye jAte haiM aura mandiroM meM bhjn| kintu vahA~ bhI sAdhAraNa janatA hAramoniyamAdi

Page #350
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 305 *Ben Zi Chan * ***Ben Zhong Zhong Zhong Zhong Li **Ben Zhong Li * ******Ben Ben ********** vAdintroM ke surile evaM manohara rAga meM hI masta hote haiN| ataeva vAdintroM ke sAtha hone vAle bhajanoM meM rAga mastA (mohanIya) kA bandha honA sahaja hai aura sabase adhika aise karmopArjana ko bhI dharma aura dhArmika kriyA kahanA yaha ajJAna (jJAnAvaraNIya) kA asara aura aisI zraddhA ke calate duHzraddhA (darzanAvaraNIya) honA bhI vaisA hI sahaja aura sarala hai| tAtparya yaha ki jo loga mandira mUrti ke sthAna para hI dharma kriyA honA mAnate haiM ve vAstava meM pakSapoSita haiN| yadi Agama dRSTi se bhI dekhA jAya to dhArmika kriyA-japa, tapa, svAdhyAya Adi meM kahIM bhI mUrti kA ullekha nahIM kiyA, na kisI mokSAbhilASI ne mUrti ke sAmane dhArmika kriyAe~ kii| phira yaha kaise kahA jA sakatA hai ki - mUrti ke nahIM mAnane se sthAnakavAsI samAja dharma se hI vaMcita raha gayA? kyA yaha ahaMkAra kA tANDava nahIM hai? sundara mitra ko apanI sAdhu bhASA kA bhI bhAna nahIM hai ??? aisA likhate samaya sundara mitra ne itanA bhI vicAra nahIM kiyA ki mere isa lekha ko kauna mAnegA ki mUrti nahIM mAnane se sthAnakavAsI navakAra nahIM gina sakate, aura namotthuNaM nahIM de sakate, tathA bhajana stavana nahIM bola sakate? pratyakSa satya ko bhI chupAne vAle ina jhUThoM ke bAdazAha ko adhika kyA kahA jAya? vAstava meM yaha kahanA koI asatya nahIM ki sundara mitra kevala apanI dilI jalana ke kAraNa hI aMTa saMTa bAteM likha rahe haiN| Age dekhiye - (3) mUrti nahIM mAnane ke kAraNa hI ve lAkhoM karor3oM rupayoM kI lAgata ke mandira jo unake pUrvajoM ne banavAye, unake haka se bhI vaMcita rhe|

Page #351
306 .. upasaMhAra kA saMhAra ********************************************* kyA khUba pariNAma nikAlA? mahAzaya! jise hama cAhate hI nahIM, jisakI hameM AvazyakatA nahIM, bhalA usa para haka jamAkara hama kyoM apanI upAdhi bar3hAveM? pUrvajoM ke banavAne aura apanA haka jamAne se dharma kA kyA sambandha? saMsAra meM kahAvata hai ki "bApa kI talAI meM yadi pAnI nahIM ho to pyAse hI maranA, yA miTTI khAnA, samajhadAroM kA kAma nahIM, sujJa puruSa use tatkAla chor3akara sukhada sthAna DhUMDhatA hai|" isI prakAra yadi kisI ke pUrvajoM ne mUrti pUjakoM kI mAnyatAnusAra mandirAdi banAye hoM to isase hamAre Atma-kalyANa kA koI sambandha hI nahIM hai| hama inheM nirarthaka samajhate haiM, aisI nirarthaka vastuoM para apanA adhikAra jamA kara adhika parigrahI bananA zrAvaka ke lie anucita hai| kintu sundara mitra ke sundara mAnasa para hameM Azcarya hotA hai| Apa sAdhu kahalAte hue bhI haka evaM adhikAra bar3hAne kA prayatna kara, adhikAra chor3ane vAle kI TIkA TippaNI karate haiN| zAyada mUrti pUjaka samAja meM jAne para inhoMne apane liye kucha nirAle hI niyama banA liye hoM? . isake sivAya mAlavA Adi dezoM ke kitane hI gAMvoM meM mRtyu Adi ke mauke para jAti rivAja ke anusAra loga mandira jAyA karate haiN| yaha sabakA haka hai so surakSita hai hii| hama to yahA~ taka cAhate haiM ki isa rivAja para bhI hamArI samAja ko vicAra kara parivartana karanA cAhiye, kyoMki bahuta sI jagaha itane mAtra se hI aniSTa pariNAma hue haiN| sundara mitra! adhikAravAda se dharma kA koI sambandha nahIM nahIM hai| jahA~ adhikAra bAda hai vahA~ jhagar3A hai aura usake sAtha karma bandhana bhii| yadi yaha haka kA bhUta Apa para savAra nahIM hotA to Apa meM va

Page #352
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 307 ******************************************* digambaroM meM jo adhikAravAda kA jhagar3A hai aura usase lAkhoM karor3oM rupayoM kA apavyaya huA hai, ho rahA hai aura bhaviSya meM hone vAlA hai, yaha saba nahIM hotA, kintu jahA~ sundara mitra jaise guru hoM aura adhikAravAda kA jora zora ho, vahA~ hamAre kathana para kauna vicAra kara sakatA hai? phira bhI hama to yahI cAhate haiM ki mUrtipUjaka yA sthAnakavAsI yA aura koI bhI hoM dhArmika mAmaloM meM adhikAravAda ko uttejana dekara kleza nahIM bar3he to acchA hai| ___Age sundara mitra ne cauthI bAta yaha batAyI ki "mUrti nahIM mAnane ke kAraNa 32 sUtra ke sivAya anya sUtra va hajAroM granthoM se dUra bhaTakane lage, yadi koI par3hatA hai to carcA ke samaya use apramANika batAkara karma bAMdhatA hai" aadi| . yaha bAta bhI viveka se zUnya hai, isake viSaya meM hama pahale khUba likha Aye haiM, yahA~ saMkSepa meM itanA hI kaheMge ki sUtroM aura vItarAga vacanoM ko dUSaNa lagAne vAle tathA matamoha meM sane hue jitane bhI sUtra yA grantha Adi haiM ve avazya prAmANika nahIM ho skte| par3hanA dUsarI bAta hai aura prAmANika mAnanA bhinna bAta hai, jaise maiMne ApakA "mUrti pUjA kA prAcIna itihAsa'' (jisake uttara meM maiM yaha grantha likha rahA hU~) par3hA hai, to kyA par3hane mAtra se hI yaha mananIya yA prAmANika bana gayA? kitanA bhaddA tarka hai? ___ pAMcaveM aura chaThe sArAMza meM Apane likhA ki - : "mUrti nahIM mAnane ke kAraNa TIkA, niyukti bhASya, cUrNi, vRtti tathA granthAdi kA apamAna kara vajra pApa kA bhAgI bananA pdd'aa| naI kapola kalpita TIkAyeM banAnI pdd'ii| granthoM ke aneka cAritroM se mUrti viSayaka pATha nikAlakara kalpita pATha banAne par3e, jaise jaina

Page #353
308 upasaMhAra kA saMhAra rAmAyaNa, upAsaka dazAMga TIkA, zrIpAla rAsAdi inameM anya granthoM se corI bhI karanI pdd'ii|" Adi aadi| TIkA niryuktyAdi aura granthoM ke viSaya meM hama pahale do prakaraNoM meM bahuta kucha likha cuke haiN| yahA~ kevala itanA hI likhanA paryApta hai ki hama TIkA Adi ko mAnate haiM, kintu vartamAna kAla kI TIkA Adi ko pUrNa rUpeNa mAnya nahIM karate, kyoMki kitane hI sthAnoM para mUla ke binA hI tathA mUla viruddha vyAkhyA kI gaI hai| tathA TIkAvyAkhyA koI bhI sUtroM kA vizeSa anubhavI vidvAn banA sakatA hai tathA TIkAkAra kA nija kA maMtavya bhI usameM rahatA hai| aisI dazA meM apUrNatA ke kAraNa truTiyAM raha jAnA svAbhAvika hai| svayaM zrI abhayadevAcArya ne sthAnAMga sUtra kI TIkA samApta karate hue yaha bAta svIkAra kI hai taba A~kheM banda karake sabhI ko yathAtathya mAna lenA buddhimattA nahIM hai| yahI hAla granthoM ke bhI haiN| granthoM meM bhI kitanI hI viruddha bAteM likhI haiN| yahA~ sirpha eka pramANa diyA jAtA hai| "loka prakAza" ke tIsare bhAga meM lekhaka ne azanAdi cAroM AhAra kI vyAkhyA karate hue pAna zabda meM madirA-zarAba-ginA diyA hai? batAiye, isa viparIta vyAkhyA ko kaise mAneM? isake sivAya caritra granthoM kA to kahanA hI kyA hai? ve to kadAcit "aitihAsika upanyAsa' hI kahane ke yogya haiN| yahA~ unakI TIkA TippaNI karanA anAvazyaka haiN| samaya Ane para isake liye eka samAlocanA kA grantha hI prastuta kiyA jaaygaa| mujhe likhate hue atyanta kheda hotA hai ki hamAre sAdhumArgI samAja ke kucha vidvAnoM ne mUrti pUjaka caritra granthoM meM se kucha caritroM ko lekara una para se manamAnI rAga rAgiNI meM DhAleM banA kara unakA

Page #354
306 jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA Bi Xue Xue Ben Zhong ***Li ****Li Duo Xue Xue Shi Xue Li ******Duo Duo Duo Duo Duo Duo ****** pracAra kiyA hai| una para vyAkhyAna calate haiN| yadyapi yaha pravRtti sAdhAraNa manuSyoM ko lubhAne ke lie hI hai, tathApi yaha anucita avazya hai! yadi vyAkhyAtA ko aisI kahAniyeM hI sunAnA hai, to kRpA kara ve ina para satyatA kI chApa to na lagAyA kareM aura svataMtra buddhibala se caritra racanA kareM, vaha bhI janopakArI ho sake vaisI, kintu hAnikara tathA nirarthaka sAmagrI se bharI huI nahIM honI caahiye| mUrti pUjaka caritra granthoM se kathAnaka lekara usameM se nyUnAdhika karake use apanI mAnyatAnusAra gar3ha lenA yaha bhI ThIka nahIM hai| yadyapi mUrti pUjaka mahAtmAoM ne bhI "mahAbhArata" "rAmAyaNa' Adi anya darzaniyoM se lekara kucha parivartana ke sAtha naye rUpa meM upasthita kiyA hai aura prAcIna kAla kI hone se jaina samAja meM abhI mAnanIya samajhI jAtI hai, kintu vAstava meM mUla vastu jainetara samAja kI hai, aisA merA anumAna hai, phira bhI yahA~ maiM apane hI samAja ke vidvAnoM se nivedana karU~gA ki - kRpA kara isa pravRtti ko chor3eM to ThIka haiN| sAtaveM sArAMza meM Apane likhA hai ki - "mUrti nahIM mAnane ke kAraNa hI saMgha meM nyAti jAti meM kusaMpa paidA huaa|" Adi yaha bhI dveSa buddhi kA hI pariNAma hai| hama yahA~ lekhaka zrI se pUchate haiM ki pahale Apa yaha to batAiye ki mUrtipUjakoM meM pArasparika kalaha jo jora zora se calatA hai kyA vaha bhI mUrti nahIM mAnane kA kAraNa hai? cAra varSa pUrva mUrti pUjaka samAja meM paryuSaNa parva ke dinoM meM sAmvatsarika (eka dina Age pIche ke) jhagar3e ko lekara eka sabhA meM yuddha prArambha huA thA aura saiMkar3oM manuSya ghAyala ho gaye the, kyA yaha bhI mUrti nahIM mAnane kA phala hai? do varSa pahale udayapura (mevAr3a) meM

Page #355
310 upasaMhAra kA saMhAra ******************************************* do mUrti pUjaka sAdhuoM ke Apasa meM DaMDemAra cala gaI thI jisase eka sAdhu ko jyAdA coTa laga jAne se rakta baha nikalA thA, kyA yaha bhI mUrti nahIM mAnane kA phala thA? vAstava meM mUrti pUjA karane va na karane kA itanA jhagar3A nahIM hai jitanA svArtha, abhimAna yA pakSa moha kA jhagar3A hai| sundara mitra ne to kalpanA taraMga meM hI kalama calAI hai, kintu hama to sapramANa spaSTa kahate haiM ki jaina samAja meM kalaha kI adhikatA meM mandiroM aura mUrtiyoM kA bhI pradhAna kAraNa hai| karor3oM rupaye inake lie korToM meM aura vakIla bairisTaroM ke khajAnoM meM pahu~ca gye| kezariyA tIrtha meM mAnava saMhAra huaa| makasI tIrtha meM mUrti kI hAlata do patnI vAle pati jaisI huI aura hamezA ho rahI hai| AgamoddhArakajI ko khUna se mandira dhone kA phatavA jAhira karanA par3A Adi aneka taraha se ina mandiroM aura mUrtiyoM ne jaina samAja meM phUTa phailaaii| dhana nAza kraayaa| eka ko dUsare kA duzmana bnaayaa| isa taraha mUrtiyoM aura mandiroM se jaina samAja kI apAra hAni huI hai? isa hAni ko chupAkara ulTI hamAre zira lAdanA, yaha sundara jI kI sundara buddhi kA camatkAra hai| ___sundara mitra mUrti nahIM mAnane ke kAraNa hI saMgha meM jhagar3A honA batAte haiN| yaha vAstava meM inakI kaluSita bhAvanA kA hI phala hai| maiM yahA~ sirpha yahI kahatA hU~ ki sundara mitra! pahale itihAsa par3heM, phira itihAsajJa bneN| Apake hI itihAsakAra jaina samAja meM kalaha kA Arambha vi0 saM0 236 se batalAte haiM, jaba digambara aura zvetAmbara aise do pakSa hue the| phira caityavAda aura caityavAsa ne kalaha kA poSaNa kiyaa| isa prakAra yaha dinoM dina phailatA hI gyaa| kintu sundara mitra ko itihAsa se kyA tAtparya? inheM to sirpha vaira vasUla karanA hai|

Page #356
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 311 *********************Li *Sheng Duo Zi Duo Ci *********** Apa antima mantavya meM likhate haiM ki - 'mUrti nahIM mAnane ke kAraNa mUrti nahIM mAnane vAloM ke utpAda se zuddhi kA kArya banda ho gyaa|" yaha bhI pUrvavat viparIta hI hai| kyoMki zuddhi ke viSaya meM mUrti mAnane nahIM mAnane kI koI bAdhA hI nahIM hai| na sthAnakavAsI samAja zuddhi kA virodhI hai| phira yaha anargala kathana kyA artha rakhatA hai? / jaisI pustaka vaisA hI usakA upsNhaar| satya ke pIche to sundara mitra burI taraha se laTTha lekara par3e aura kalpanA taraMga meM hI gote lagAte gaye, vaha bhI pakSa moha meM masta hokara, phira vahA~ satya ke lie avakAza hI kahA~ rahatA hai ? yadi satya aura dharmatattva ko hRdaya meM rakhakara vicAra kiyA jAya to sundarajI ke upasaMhAra kA saMhAra hI nizcita hai| pAThaka svayaM isakA anubhava kara leN| (41) niSkarSa zrI jJAnasundarajI ke 'mUrti pUjA kA prAcIna itihAsa' nAmaka grantha ke uttara meM yaha prathama bhAga hama pAThakoM kI sevA meM rakha rahe haiN| hamAre sujJa pAThaka samajha gaye hoMge ki sundara mitra kA pakSa kitanA nirbala hai| yahA~ saMkSepa meM isa grantha kA niSkarSa (pariNAma) de dete haiM 1. mUrti pUjA pravRtti mArga kA poSaka hai, indriyoM ke viSayoM ke poSaNa kA sarala sAdhana hai, Atma-kalyANa se isakA sambandha tanika bhI nahIM hai| 2. rUpI dravya (pudgala) anAdi hone se mUrti pUjA anAdi tathA AcaraNIya nahIM ho sktii| kyoMki isa yukti se to caNDI, kAlI Adi kI mUrtiyeM bhI pUjanIya ho sakeMgI tathA pudgala tyAga rUpa .

Page #357
312 niSkarSa ***Zai Sha Te Er Zhong Li Li Li Zi Bu Xing Li Kong Zhong Xue Xue Zi Di Zhong Li Dong Xue Zhong Xue Sheng Zai Zhong Li *** nivRtti mArga, pudgala saMgraha, pudgalAsakta rUpa prabRtimArga hokara Atma-kalyANa se vaMcita rahatA hai| 3. mUrti pUjA kA siddhAMta vizvavyApaka nhiiN| na kisI vastu ke vizva vyApaka hone se vo dhArmika bana sakatI hai yA upAdeya ho jAtI hai, jaise mithyAtva, vyabhicAra, pAkhaNDa aadi| .... 4. mUrti sadAcAra Adi kA mUla kAraNa nahIM, phara prAyaH durAcAra kI pravartikA hai| pratyakSa meM jaina samAja ke karor3oM rupayoM kA jhagar3e meM nAza, Apasa meM kleza, yahA~ taka ki nRzaMsa hAlyA kA bhI kAraNa mUrtiyeM hI banI haiM, pAkhaNDa aura andhavizvAsa kI prabala pracArikA bhI yahI haiN| 5. hRdaya meM sAkSAt kA dhyAna karanA yA guNa ciMtana karanA mUrti pUjA nahIM hai| 6. mUrti pUjakoM ne saMsAra kA jitanA ahita kiyA hai utanA kadAcit hI aura taraha se huA ho? yadi mUrtipUjaka apanA dhana mandiroM aura mUrtiyoM meM nahIM lagAte to deza kI itanI garIbI hAlata nahIM hotii| 7. dharma prabhu AjJA ke pAlana karane meM hai aura prabhu AjJA meM sAdhuoM ke paMca mahAvrata Adi tathA zrAvakoM ke dvAdazavata Adi hai, mUrti pUjA nAma mAtra ko bhI nahIM hai| 8. sUryAbha deva ne apane paramparA ke rivAja ke anusAra pratimA pUjI thI, kintu dharma nimitta nhiiN| na ve mUrtiyeM tIrthaMkaroM kI siddha ho sakatI haiN| kyoMki ve zAzvatI haiM tathA sUryAbha kI pUjA sAMsArika hai| 6. "niyaMseI" zabda kA vastra car3hAnA artha karanA ekadama mithyA hai| ___

Page #358
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 313 *********Quan Zhong Li ************Xue Xue *************** 10. rAyapaseNaiya kA bhArI pATha bheda honA tathA TIkAkAra ke kathana se vahA~ kA pATha kadAcit TIkAkAra kA hI banAyA huA ho, yaha sandeha suspaSTa hai| 11, sUryAbha kI pUjA meM zAstrakAroM kI sammati batAnA sapheda jhUTha hai| 12. prabhuvandana, sAdhu sevA, saMyama pAlana ke phala se mUrti pUjA kA phala samAna dikhAnA dina dahAr3e A~khoM meM dhUla DAlanA hai| 13. sUryAbha no "nammutthuNaH" se mUrti ko nahIM para bhAva siddhoM ko namaskAra kiyaa| 14. "pUyaNAbattiyaM" se phUloM se pUjana kA artha karanA pakSa vyAmohatA hai| 15. loMkAmacchIya yati jo mUrti pUjaka haiM ve zrImAn lokAzAha ke vaMzaja kahe jAne yogya nahIM, kyoMki ve usa puNya puruSa kI mAnyatA ke viruddha mUrtipUjaka haiN| unakA pramANa kucha bhI prabhAvajanaka nahIM ho sktaa| 16. camarendra ne mUrti kA zaraNa liyA hI nhiiN| na mUrti zaraNa dene yogya hI ho sakatI hai| 17. "devANaM AsAyaNAeM" kA artha mUrtiyoM kI AzAtanA mAnane vAle alpajJa haiN| 18. Ananda zramaNopAsaka ko mUrti pUjaka kahanA sarAsara mithyA hai| 16. aMbar3a zrAvaka mUrti pUjaka nahIM thA, uvavAI ke pATha meM gar3abar3a pAI jAtI hai| 20. tuMgiyA ke zramaNopAsakoM ko mUrti pUjaka batAne vAle

Page #359
314 niSkarSa ****************************************** matamoha meM masta hI kahe jA sakate haiN| bahuta se mUrti pUjaka vidvAn bhI unheM tIrthaMkara kI mUrti ke pUjaka nahIM mAnate haiN| 21. cAraNa muniyoM ne mUrti kI stuti yA vaMdanA nahIM kii| .. 22. draupadI ne mithyAtva dazA meM jo pratimA pUjI, vaha kAmadeva kI pAI jAtI hai| kyoMki vaha nidAna prabhAva se viSayAbhilASiNI thI, sAtha hI samyaktva rahita bhii| zrI guNasAgarasUri jI Aja se 300-350 varSa pUrva hue haiM ve bhI isa bAta ko svIkAra kara cuke haiN| 23. jJAtA kA "NamutthuNaM' prakSipta pATha hai| prAcIna pratiyoM meM aisA pATha nahIM hai| zrImAn harSacandrajI mahArAja tathA zrI majyeSThamallajI mahArAja ke nAma kA ullekha kevala janatA ko bhrama meM DAlane ke lie hI kiyA gayA hai| 24. "caitya' zabda kA kevala jina mandira aura jinamUrti artha karane vAle zabda zAstra tathA AgamoM ke virAdhaka haiN| caitya zabda anekArthavAcI hai| 25. dharma ke kahe jAne vAle mukhya aMga aise mUrti pUjA ke lie AjJA rUpa vaidhAnika pramANa nahIM dekara kathAoM ke pramANa, ve bhI manaH kalpita DhaMga se dene vAle satya se sarvathA dUra haiN| caritAnuvAda kA kathana vidhivAda meM grAhya nahIM hotaa| phira caritAnuvAda ke zabdoM aura bhAvoM ko bigAr3a kara apanA matalaba sAdhane kA prayatna karanA to anucita hai hii| 26. sthApanAcArya rakhane kA vidhAna kisI bhI sUtra meM nahIM hai, na isakI AvazyakatA hI hai| 27. pUjya ke siddhAnta viruddha siddhAntoM kA bhaMgakara ulTI kriyA karanA, pUjya kI pUjA nahIM para apamAna hai| mUrti pUjA meM prabhu

Page #360
jainAgama viruddha mUrtti pUjA ******** *************** kI pUjA nahIM hotI, kintu jIvoM kI hiMsA tathA pUjya kA apamAna anAdara tathA virAdhanA hotI hai| 28. DaoN. haramana jekobI kA mUrti pUjA ke viruddha abhiprAya aTala hai| jodhapura kA abhiprAya mahatvapUrNa nahIM hai / 315 26. bharata cakravartI ne mandira mUrttiyeM banAI, aisA kahane vAle dUsare pApa ke bhAgI haiN| 30. zreNika ko mUrti pUjaka gapaur3a zAstra hI batAte haiM / sarvamAnya Agama nahIM / 31. svarNa gulikA ke sAtha mUrti kA sambandha paurANika gapaur3A hai| 32. caMpAnagarI meM arihaMtoM ke mandira the, aisA kathana prAmANika nahIM hai / 33. jina mUrti ke sAmane AlocanA karane kA kahane vAle utsUtra bhASI haiN| 34. dAr3hA pUjana dhArmika kriyA nahIM hai| 35. sthApanA satya kA tAtparya mUrti pUjA nahIM, para sthApanA ko sthApanA, citra ko citra mAnane se haiN| na 36. mUrtiyoM kI prAcInatA se dharma kA koI sambandha nahIM, mUrtiyoM ke sabhI lekha sacce haiN| mUrti ko lekara kaI prakAra ke SaDyaMtra race gaye aura svArtha sAdhA gyaa| usI prakAra saMvat likhane meM bhI honA svAbhAvika hai| sarvamAnya AgamoM ke sAmane isakA koI mUlya nahIM / 37. stUpa nirmANa kA kAraNa smAraka tathA dAha Adi sthAnoM ko apavitrAdi nahIM hone dene kA hai| pUjA ke liye nahIM /

Page #361
316 niSkarSa ******Xue *********************************** 38. muni zrI maNilAlajI mahArAja ne apane itihAsa meM mUrti pUjA kA samarthana nahIM kiyA, kintu virodha to avazya kiyA hai| 39. mUrti pUjA viSayaka grantha, AgamoM ke viruddha aura vItarAga vacanoM ke bAdhaka hone se pUrNa rUpeNa mAnya nahIM ho skte| 40. TIkA, niyukti Adi mUla kI taraha mAnya nahIM ho sakatI, kyoMki inameM skhalanA bhI ho gaI hai| 41. sAdhumArgI jaina ko, mUrti pUjaka kahane vAle matamoha meM matavAle ho rahe haiN| 42. battIsa sUtroM meM mUrti pUjA kA vidhAna hone kA kahanA vaMdhyA ke putra hone kA kahane ke barAbara hai| 43. sAdhAraNa logoM dvArA phailI huI vikRti se mUla siddhAnta kA koI sambandha nahIM hai| muslima tathA krizciyana Adi samAjoM meM mUrti pUjA vikRta rUpa se ghusI hai, ina samAjoM ke mUla siddhAntoM meM mUrti pUjA kA khaNDana kiyA gayA hai| 44. mUrti pUjaka samAja ke granthoM meM mUrti pUjA ke viruddha ullekha maujUda hai| 45. mUrti pUjA viSayaka upadeza denA jaina sAdhu kA kartavya nahIM hai| isa mUrti aura mandira ke cakkara meM par3a kara mUrti pUjaka muniyoM ne cAritra dharma kI upekSA kara dI hai| 46. sundara mitra kA upasaMhAra bhI ahaMkAra pUrNa aura asatya hai| 47. mUrti pUjA se na kisI kA Atma-kalyANa huA, na kisI sAdhu yA zrAvaka ne ise apanAyA, Apta kathita AgamoM meM anekoM Atma-kalyANakartAoM kA caritra vidyamAna hai, kintu kisI eka bhI caritra meM aisA ullekha nahIM hai| ___

Page #362
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA ******* 48. sundara mitra ne prAyaH asatya pakSapAta tathA niMdakapana se hI kAma liyA hai| taTasthatA se nahIM / maiM apanI jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA nAmaka pustaka ke pUrvArddha ko pUrNa karate hue pAThakoM se anurodha karatA hU~ ki ve niSpakSa dRSTi se vicAra kreN| pustaka ke pramANoM ko dekheM, yuktiyoM ko prkheN| yadi pAThakoM ne mere nivedana para dhyAna diyA to yaha spaSTa jJAna hogA ki sundara mitra ke grantha kI asatyatA tathA mUrti pUjA ke siddhAnta kI anupAdeyatA sahaja hI buddhi gamya hai / sundara mitra ke mUrti pUjA viSayaka praznottara nAmaka prakaraNa kA sacoTa uttara isa pustaka ke uttarArddha meM dene kA prayatna karU~gA / yadi pAThakoM kA sahayoga huA aura sAdhanoM kI anukUlatA huI to zIghra hI dvitIya bhAga bhI pAThakoM ke karakamaloM meM lagabhaga isI AkAra meM samarpita karane kA prayatna kruuNgaa| jisase pAThaka jAna sakeMge ki sundara mitra ke tarka kitane bhadde aura chala kapaTa pUrNa haiM | // samApta // 317

Page #363
318 pariziSTa pariziSTa anusaMdhAna pR0 226 paM0 aMtima ke baad| ' (2) bhAvanagara se prakAzita mUrtipUjaka "jaina" patra tA0 16-5-42 ke aMka pR0 416 meM "prAcInatA nuM khUna' zIrSaka lekha se likhA hai ki - "zrI sametazikhara jI nI yAtrArthe madhuvana gayA tyAM sarva maMdira nA darzanakarI bAhara AvatAM madhuvana taleTI nAM mandiranI DAbI bAjunA holamAM nAnI moTI sapheta kAlA ArasanI pratimA jI nA darzana karavA jatAM eka dRzya dekhAyuM, pratimAjI prAcIna dekhAtI par3atI jyAre tenI nIcenA lekha vAcatAM te lekho miTAvI nAMkhelA tathA koimAM zrAvaka nuM nAma saMvat vigere prAcIna hatuM ane pratiSThA karAvanAra AcArya mahArAjanuM nAma navu khodela joyuM munIma ne puchatAM evo javAba malyo ke eka tapA gacchIya mahArAje junA lekhoM je kharatara gacchI mahArAjA nA nAmanA hatAM teno nAzakarI potAnA tapA gaccha nA AcAryoM nA nAmano lekha khodAvavo zaru karyo temaja zikharajI nI uparanI Tuko nA caraNo je kharatara gacchIya AcAryonA haste pratiSThita thaola che tene paNa rAtanA kArIgaro mokalI miTAvI dIdhA ch|" (ukta lekha kA prativAda tA0 23-6-42 ke jaina patra pR0 5 meM kiyA gayA hai kintu pratimA ke lekhoM ko miTAne kI bAta usameM bhI mAnI gaI hai|)

Page #364
jainAgama viruddha mUrti pUjA 316 ******************************************* (3) ukta patra varSa 41 aMka 22 tA0 7-6-42 pR0 360 meM "jaina samAja kI do zAkhAeM " zIrSaka lekha meM likhA hai ki - "jaitAraNa aura murzidAbA ke jaina mandiroM meM bIsavIM zatAbdI kI nUtana mUrtiyoM para kharataroM ne bArahavIM zatAbdI ke nAma ke zilAlekha khudavA diye haiN|" dekha liye mUrtiyoM ke lekhoM kI saccAI ke namUne ? * * * * upayogI padya thAvara tIratha saMsAra meM, Adhunika najara Ate haiN||aNtr|| jisakara tIre tIrtha hai soii| dekho zabda arthako joii|| so to zakti na dose koI, saritA aura pahAra meN| pina ku guru bharamAte haiN||1|| jaMgama tIratha ko nahIM dhyAveM, kalpita jar3a tIrthoM para jaave| dhAma kAma taja pApa kamAveM, vo bhava dadhi kI dhaar| gahire gote khAte haiN||2|| vikrama saMvatasara suna bhAI, eka sahiMsa paitAliza maaNii| zatruJjaya para nIMva lagAI, maMdira bahu vistAra meN| banavAyA batalAte haiN||3|| dekho jina bhASita Agama ko, tajado mithyAjAla bhrmko| dhAro hirade dayA dharama ko, par3o matI jaMjAra meN| hita dharakara samujhAte haiN||4||

Page #365
320 pariziSTa bArahaso chyAsaTha hAyana meM, vikaTa pahAr3a dekha kAnana meN| banavAye pagalyA pAhana meM, taba se gar3ha giranAra meN| tIratha karane jAte haiN||5|| bAraha saya piccAstrI vatsara, banavAyA maMdira AbU pr| tejapAla aru vastupAla nara, hiMsA dharma pracAra meN| dou bar3hiyA kahivAte haiM // 6 // vikramArka saulaha zata jAno, upara barasa paccIsa bkhaano| tabase zikhara tIrtha prakaTAno, dekho zikhara majhAra meN| yaha zilA lekha pAte haiN||7|| kara anumAna zikhara girajAI, behada aTavI ko kttvaaii| bIsa ToMka jaga seTha banAI, mUr3ha adharma duvAra meN| dhana vyaya kara haraSAte haiN||8|| acaraja vijJa baneM jar3a seveM, jar3a kI bhakti mukti kima deveN| yaha to bAlaka hU lakhi leveM, lAo buddhi bicAra meN| ima sata guru cetAte haiN||6|| (daMDI daMbha darpaNa)

Page #366
emajA bhAravara bAICO vyAvararAja)