Tristutik Mat Mimansa

Author(s): Kalyanvijay Gani
Publisher: Lakshmichandra Amichandra Porwal Gudabalotara
Catalog link: https://jainqq.org/explore/003120/1

Page #1
PHUOKOK KORK aham / k-mt-miimaaNsaa| [ prathama bhAga] lekhaka muni klyaannvijy| prakAzakael. e. poravAla. mu. guDAbAlotarA (mAravAr3a.) BRUAAPAR ISAD SERIODE

Page #2
arham / tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / [ prathama-bhAga ] lekhaka muni kalyANavijaya | zA. lakSmIcanda amIcanda - poravAla. mu. guDAbAlotarA. ( mAravAr3a. ) prakAzaka isa ko ema. ema. gupta ne AryasudhAraka presa - bar3aude meM prakAzaka ke lie chApA / tA. 1-6-1917 prathamAvRtti, kaoNpI 500 vIra saMvat 2443 vikrama saM. 1974 ] [ san 1917

Page #3
patA:yaha pustaka nIce likhe do patoM para prakAzaka kI tarpha se bheMTa milegI. el. e. poravAla eNDa kaMpanI __ cIka peTha, beMgalora-siTI. zrIkezaravijaya jaina lAyabrerI, jAlora ( mAravAr3a ). -

Page #4
* prastAvanA. * jisa vakta cAroM ora se saMpa ke upadeza kA dhvani sunAI de rahA ho, sudhAraka samAja ke pukAra logoM ke kAna bahire kara rahe hoM, aura sAmAjika patra apane samAja nAyakoM ko TaTola TaTola ke sAvadhAna kara rahe hoM, usa sudhAre ke samaya meM khaMDana-maMDana kI pustakoM kA prasiddha honA logoM kI aruci kA kAraNa hove yaha eka sAdhAraNa bAta hai| dUsare hI kyoM, maiM khuda bhI isa bAta ko pasaMda nahIM karatA ki logoM ko vikSobha pahuMcAne vAle lekha yA pustakoM kA pracAra ho| isa hAlata meM pAThaka mahAzaya yaha prazna avazya kareMge ki jaba tumhArI bhI yahI mAnyatA hai to phira isa carcAvAlI pustaka ko prakAzita karane kI kyA jarUrata thii| mere priyapAThakoM ke isa prazna ko maiM mAna ke sAtha svIkAra kara ke uttara dUMgA ki Apa kA kahanA vAjavI hai, para "prayojanamanuddizya na mando'pi pravartate / " -yaha vRddha puruSoM kI kahAvata to Apane bhI sunI hI hogI ki vinA prayojana to maMda puruSa bhI pravRtti nahIM krtaa| merI yaha pravRtti-carcAtmaka pustaka ko prakAza meM lAne kI utsukatA-kina kAraNoM se huI yaha bAta mujhe isa jagaha para avazya hI kahanI par3egI, aura Apa kI zaMkA kA samAdhAna karanA pdd'egaa|

Page #5
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / pAThakamahAzayoM ko yaha hakIkata vidita hogI ki tA. 1612 san 1914 ke "jainazAsana" patra meM jainabhikSu' nAma ke kisI mahAzaya ne koraTAtIrtha ke bAre meM eka lekha diyA thA jisa meM tristutika mata ke pravartaka zrIrAjendramUrijI ke anucita kAryoM kA bhI digdarzana karAyA thA / pUrvokta lekha ko chape karIba 8 ATha mahIne bIta gaye taba taka to isa viSaya ke kucha bhI vizvasta samAcAra nahIM mile ki tIna thuI vAle isa ke liye kyA upAya le rahe haiN| bAda meM tArIkha 5-9-1915 ke roja kI DAka meM bukaposTa se ' tIrthakoTarAjI ke anucita lekha kA samucita uttara dAna patra' isa nAma kI do pustakeM mujhe ekA eka miliiN| pustaka dekhane se mAlUma huA ki pUrvokta-koraTAtIrtha viSayaka jainabhikSu ke lekha kA khaMDana hI isa pustaka kA khAsa sAdhyabiMdu hai, kyoM ki ukta pustaka kA laMbA caur3A nAma hI isa bAta ko kaha rahA hai| pustaka paDhane se bar3A hI Azcarya huA ki lekhakoM ne prathama se hI bhUlacakkara meM par3a ke ulaTe rAste gamana karanA zuru kiyA hai| jainabhikSu kauna vyakti hai isa bAta kA to lekhakoM ne bilakula hI patA nahIM lagAyA, aura mujhI ko koraTA lekha kA lekhaka 'jainabhikSu' mAna ke sArI pustaka mujha hI para jhUThe AkSepa kara ke bhara dii| lekhakoM kI isa mugdhatA para mujhe bar3A hI Azcarya aura hAsya prApta huaa| sAtha meM yaha bhI vicAra utpanna huA ki yadyapi

Page #6
prstaavnaa| . rAjendramarijI ke parivAra vAloM se Aja taka maine lekhoM dvArA carcA nahIM kI, aura na una kI gaMbhIra bhUloM aura anucita kAryoM kA prakAza kiyA, tathApi ve loga mere Upara vinA hI kAraNa isa prakAra krUratA jAhira karate haiM, to aba mujhe bhI ina kI tarpha naz2ara karanI hI caahiye| yadyapi mere isa vicAra ko kaI vidvAn logoM kI tarpha se anumodana mila gayA thA, tathApi maiMne socA ki zAyada lekhakoM kI bedarakArI se hI yaha bhUla ho gaI ho, aura aba bhI ve ise sudhAra leve to unheM prathama sUcanA kara denI cAhiye, kyoM ki itane se hI agara isa carcA kA aMta A jAya to acchI bAta hai| pAThakamahAzaya samajha sakate haiM ki yaha merA vicAra sirpha virodha ko dabAne ke liye thA na ki dUsare kisI matalaba ke lie| jaba uparyukta merA vicAra saba ko vizeSa rucikara ho gayA to maine ukta pustaka ke lekhaka munizrI harSavijayajI aura tIrthavijayajI ko nIce mujiba noTIsa dI, jAlora. tA. 8-9-1915. munizrI harSavijayajI tathA tIrthavijayajI. bamukAma-kAnadara. __ isa noTIsa se mAlUma ho ki 'tirtha koraTAjI ke anucita lekha kA-samucita uttara dAna patra' nAmaka Apa kI banAI huI kitAba mere dekhane meM AI hai jisa kI bhASA sarvathA asabhyatA pUrNa hai, usa ke aMdara jainabhikSu' nAmaka lekhaka ke lekha kA uttara dene kI ceSTA kI gaI hai / astu / bamakA

Page #7
tristutika mata-mImAMsA / aphasosa kA viSaya to yaha hai ki 'jainabhikSu ' asalI vyakti kauna hai isakA to Apane nirNaya kiyA hI nahIM aura jhUThI bhramaNA meM par3a ke mujha hI ko koraTA ke lekha kA lekhaka 'jainabhikSu' mAna liyA aura mere para hI pUrvokta pustaka meM asabhyatA va gAliyoM kI dRSTi kara dii| __ maiM vedhar3aka kahatA hUM ki jainabhikSu ' nAmA lekhaka maiM nahIM hU~; tathApi yadi Apane apanI ajJatA se gera kAyade se mere para jhUThe AkSepa kiye haiM una kA maiM badalA lenA cAhatA hU~ aura avazya hI luuNgaa| isa liye tumheM isa noTIsa se vAkipha karatA hUM ki isa asatya bhrama se likhI huI pustaka kA jaldI yogya sudhAra kara leveM aura mujhe ittalA deveM, varanA maiM isa kitAba kI yogyatAnusAra uttara likhane kI koziza kruuNgaa| mahAzayo ! 'jainabhikSu' ne rAjendramUrijI ke jo anucita kArya likhe haiM ve to kisa ginatI meM haiM, maiM to una ko pAva AnIbhara bhI nahIM mAnatA, una ke saMpUrNa anucita kAryoM kA khajAnA to mere pAsa hai, Aja taka maiM ina ko pragaTa karane se paraheja karatA thA, isa vicAra se ki kisI ke bhI durguNa prakaTa kara. usakI hataka karane se kyA phAyadA, paraMtu aba pUrvokta merA vicAra sthira nahIM raha skegaa| basa Apa kI tarpha se jo khulAsA ho jalda peza kareM, phira aisA na kaheM ki hameM pahale ittalA nahIM dI / phakta / li. muni kalyANavijaya.

Page #8
prstaavnaa| isa merI noTIsa kA javAba mujhe tA. 27-9-1915 ko milA jo baDA hI vicitra aura AzcaryakArI hai| usa ko yahAM para akSarazaH likha detA huuN| pAThaka mahodaya dekheM ki lekhakoM ne apane avyavasthita citta kA kaisA darzana karAyA hai / // zrIH // kANadara. tA. 20--9-1915. munizrIkalyANavijayajI jAlora ApakI noTIsa AI vAMca kara mAlUma huvA ki Apa kA aphasosa viSaya sApha jhUThA hI hai ki jo asalI " jainabhikSu" vyakti kA hama ko nirNaya ho jAtA taba to usI ke prakaTa nAma se hI hama samucita uttara dAnapatra prakAza karate parantu nirNaya kA vyavahAra karane se bhI vyakti kA nAma prakaTa na hone se ajJAnAMdha guru aura ajJAnAMdha zraddhAvAn jainabhikSu kA nAma se hI patra prasiddha kiyA gayA hai to Apa jhUThI bhramaNA meM paDa ke esA kyoM likhate ho ki mujha hI ko koraTA ke lekhakA lekha ka " jainabhikSu mAna liyA aura mere para hI pUrvokta pustaka meM asabhyatA va gAliyoM kI dRSTi kara dI" vAha jI vAha hamane jo Apa ko koraTA ke lekhakA lekhaka niHsaMdehamAna liyA hotA to Apa kA nAma likhate hama ko kyA zarma AtI thI ApakA nAma hama kucha nahIM jAnate the jo ApakA nAma ke sthAna meM jahAM tahAM " jainabhikSujI" hI dhAraNa kiyA aura jo jainabhikSujI kalyANavijayajI aisA pUrvekta pustaka meM likhA hotA taba to asabhyatA va gAliyoM kI dRSTi kara dI yaha lekha Apa kA satya hotA nahIM to hRdaya meM hoya so hoMThameM Ave

Page #9
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / isa lokokti nyAya se Apa kA bhrama Apa ko hI khAtA hai hamane to jainabhikSujI ko bhI jaisA usane asabhyatAkA lekha likhA hai taisA hI usI ko vaisA hI taurase javAba likhA hai parantu kucha gAli pradAnAdi nahIM diyA hai to Apa ko. to Apa kA likhanA hI asatya ThaharAtA hai ki "maiM bedhaDaka kahatA hU~ ki jainabhikSunAmA lekhaka maiM nahIM hUM"jo Apa jainabhikSu nAmA lekhaka nahIM ho to lekhaka cimanalAla takhatagaDha vAlA kA nAma se mahAzaya tArAcaMdajI kA lekhape aMdhazraddhA kA namUnA lekha kyA viSNu, isalAmI IzAI, bhikSune chapavAyA hai isa ukta lekha kA Azaya Apa hI pukAra rahA hai ki lekhaka cimanalAla kA to nAma hai aura likhane chapavAne vAle to Apa hI jainabhikSu ho taise hI koraTAtIrtha kA asabhya lekha bhI Apa chapavAne vAle kadAcit nahIM hoge to bhI ApakI sAmilAta vinA likhane chapavAne kA asaMbhAvita hai kyoM ki zrI jAlora kA killA kA maMdira kI tathA kAMkariyA vAsakA maMdira kI jhUThI azuddhiyAM aura prAcIna AcAryoM kA jIrNa lekha musalamAna zilAvaTa ke pAsa ghisavA DAlanA ityAdi lekha likhane chapavAne vAlA dUsarA koI bhI dikhatA nahIM Apa hI jainabhikSa ho tathApi Apa apanI ajJatAse prathama hI gerakAyadA karake aba bekAyadAse noTIsa dete ho yaha hI Apa kI ajJatAkI pUrNa nizAnI hai Apa ke Upara hamane jhUThe AkSepa nahIM kiye hai hamane to aMdhaguru aMdhazraddhAvAle jainabhikSu para sacce AkSepa kiye haiM Apa unakA badalA lenA cAhate hoto avazya hI le lenA usa kitAba kI yogyatAnusAra uttara likhane kI kozIsa karanA parantu yAda rakhanA ki prathama jainabhikSu ke bAremeM jaise jhUTha ke UMTa doDAye hai neme ToDAke jainadharmakI aura ApakI niMdA karAne kI kozIsa

Page #10
prstaavnaa| nahIM karanA Apa kI noTIsa hI Apa ko asabhya jainabhikSu siddha karatI hai ki Apa likhate ho " jainabhikSune rAjendramurijI ke jo anucita kArya likhe haiM ve to kisa ginatI meM haiM maiM to una ko pAva AnI bhara bhI nahIM mAnatA, una ke saMpUrNa anucita kAryoM kA khajAnA to mere pAsa hai jo khuda rAjendrasUrijI ke hastAkSaroM se siddha hotA hai " jainabhikSujI Apa pAva AnI bhara to likha cuke ho aba Apa ke ginatI Ave jaisA saMpUrNa khajAnA kholiye rAjendramurijI ke hastAkSaroM meM kucha likhane paDhane meM chadmasthapaNA kA yoga se vA vArtAlApa meM bhUla Ave vaha kucha anucita kArya nahIM kahA jAtA hai yAne bhUla kahI jAtI hai anucita kArya to corI jArI kA hai so Apa sAbUtI ke sAtha prakaTa kariye isa liye hama pratinoTIsa dete haiM ki basa Apa kI tarapha se sAbUtI ke sAtha jo khulAsA ho so jaldI peza kareM jo usakI jaldI khabara lI jAve iti zubham / / li. mayArAma DUMgaradAsa. pAThakavarga ! dekhiye eka noTIsa ke javAba meM lekhakoMne kitane raMga dhAraNa kiye haiN| isa lekha ke akSara to Ahora ke zrImAlI brAhmaNa pUnamacaMda ke haiM, Akhira meM 'li. mayArAma DUMgaradAza 'isa prakAra kA nAma kisI dUsare kA hI, aura bhejane vAlA koI ora hI, jina ke nAma se maine noTIsa dI thI una kA isa meM nAma hI nahIM !, kyA yaha saba lekhakoM kI jAlasAjI nahIM hai| isa uTapaTAMga aura uddhatAI se bhare hue javAba ko par3ha ke mujhe to kyA saba kisI ko kahanA par3egA ki aba to isa pustaka

Page #11
tristutika-mata - mImAsA / ke viSaya meM yogya upAya lenA hI cAhiye / basa mujhe nirupAya ho kara yaha vicAra nizcita karanA par3A ki aba to isa pustaka kA yogya uttara denA hI nyAya kI bAta hai| ukta vicArAnusAra maine jAlora meM hI usa pustaka ke uttara meM isa 64 tristutika mata - mImAMsA " pustaka ko likhanA zurU kiyA, aura karIba Der3ha mahIne ke aMdara lagabhaga pUrA kara diyA / bAda saMvat 1972 ke mAgha kRSNa trayodazI ke dina hama jAlora se vihAra kara ke tIsare dina yAnI amAvAsyA ke dina gAMva vAghare pahuMce, usa vakta pratiSThA kA maukA hone se dhanavijayajI, mohanavijayajI, harSa - tIrtha vijayajI vigairaha bahuta se tIna thuI ke sAdhu vahAM para Aye hue the, hama una ke pAsa jAkara mile, aura kucha samaya taka mAmUlI bAteM cIteM kIM, bAda tIrthavijayajI ekAeka bola uThe ki ' jhagaDA nahIM karanA cAhiye ' maine kahA- acchI bAta hai, jhagaDA kabhI nahIM karanA cAhiye, para sirpha yaha kahane se hI phAyadA nahIM hotA ki ' jhagaDA nahIM karanA cAhiye,' isa para amala bhI honA cAhiye, vastutaH mukha se koI bhI bAta kahanI kaThina nahIM hai, para usa mujaba vartana rakhanA bar3A kaThina hai / tIrthavijayajI - hamane to bahuta dina taka isa mujaba vartana kiyA para kyA kareM ? loga jaba hamAre pIche hI par3a gaye taba to hama bhI kitanA sahana kareM ? caMdana svabhAva se zItala hai para patthara ke sAtha ghisAne se usa meM bhI agni paidA ho jAtA hai / yaha bAta nahIM hai - maiM yaha nahIM kahatA ki loga tumhAre viSaya meM cAhe jyoM likhA kareM aura tuma .10 maiM

Page #12
prstaavnaa| 1 sunA karo, bezaka uttara to denA hI cAhiye, para isa bAta kI bhI khoja honI cAhiye ki hamAre viSaya meM likhane vAlA kauna hai aura hama kisa ke Upara likha rahe haiM / tIrthavi0- hamane to bahuta hI khoja kI, lekina likhane vAle kA nAma kisIne nahIM batAyA, isI liye gupta nAma se hI uttaradAna patra likhA hai, usa meM tumhArA nAma kahIM bhI nahIM hai / nAma se kyA karanA hai ? jaba sArI pustaka hI hamArI niMdA se bhara dI hai taba nAma likhane meM kyA kasara rhii| tIrthavi0- ( haMsa kara) aisA hI hai to jaise hamane kaI daphe sahana kiyA vaise tuma bhI eka bAra sahana kara lete ! / mujhe isa vakta cAra gAliyAM dedo ! maiM sahana kara lUMgA, para vinA hI kAraNa hamAre pUjya puruSoM kI koI niMdA kare aura hama suna ke mukha baMda kara paDe raheM-yaha bAta hama se nahIM hotI, aura na hogii| tIrthavi0- yadi tuma se yaha bAta nahIM hotI to dUsaroM ne kyA cUr3iyAM pahina lI haiM / yadi pahina lI hoMgI to bhI isa meM to kucha bhI aDacaNa nahIM hai, kyoM ki Ajakala to cUDiyAM vAlI bhI pagar3I vAloM kA sAmanA karane lagI haiN| maiM

Page #13
tristutika mata-mImAMsA / tIrthavi0- (kucha Thahara ke ) nahIM, aisA nahIM karanA cAhiye, hama aura tuma kaunase jude haiM, rAjendramarijI ke ziSya kIrticandrajI, aura una ke paziSya tuma, agara socA jAya to hama tuma saba eka hI haiN| yadi yaha kathana hRdaya kA hotA to isa takarAra kA vakta hI nahIM aataa| itanI bAtacIta hone ke bAda maiM apane sthAna para AyA / bAda isa ke dhanavijayajI ke bhakta 'lalla valyama' ahamadAbAda vAle aura zrAvaka vajIMgajI vAgharAvAle ne hamAre pAsa Akara bahuta kahA ki aba Apa jAne dIjiye, kyoM ki isa meM kucha bhI sAra nahIM hai, Apa una kI buriyAM likheMge, aura ve Apa kI, isa kA natIjA acchA nahIM aavegaa| maine kahA-tuma mujhI ko kahate ho yA una ko bhI ? / vajIMgajI bole-una ko kyA kahanA hai ? agara Apa aba kucha bhI na chapAveMge to jhagaDA miTa hI gayA ! / maine kahA-acchA, tuma una se yaha likhA doki " samucita uttara dAnapatra meM jo jhUThe AkSepa tumhAre Upara kiye haiM ve galata haiM, "-phira maiM nahIM chpaauuNgaa| vajIMgajI bole-yaha to kaise ho sake, kyoM ki aisA to ve kabhI nahIM likheNge| ___maine kahA-agara ve na likheM to hama ko kyA garaja hai jo ucita bAta ko choDa ke satya kA galA ghoMTeM / / pAThakamahodaya dekhI ina kI kAravAI ? ye to girakara ke bhI apanI TaMgaDI to uMcI hI rakhanA cAhate haiM aura dUsaroM ko kahate haiM ki 'jhagaDA mata karo!' kyA isa se Apa yaha kaha

Page #14
sakate haiM ki ye loga zAnti ko cAhane vAle haiM ? yaha to isa vAlI bAta huI ki ' cora koTavAla ko DAMTe / ' ina kI isa kAravAI ko dekha ke maine yahI nizcaya kara . liyA ki ye loga sulaha ko cAhate hI nahIM hai / khaira / ina kI marjI ! / zAyada yahAM para mujhe koI prazna karegA ki unhoMne na mAnA to tumhI savara kara lete ! kyoM ki sahana kare so hI baDA, to mujhe kahanA paDegA ki yaha ApakA upadeza isa viSaya meM ucita nahIM jAna paDatA, bhalA yaha bhI kabhI ho sakatA hai ki guru aura dharma jaise sarvottama tatva para hote hue jhUThe AkSepoM ko suna ke bhI koI upekSA kara ke par3A rahe ?, merI samajha meM to aisA karanA mAnoM satya ke gale churI calAnA hai| hAM, yaha bAta sahI hai ki lekhaka ko asatya se hamezA dara rahanA cAhiye, yahAM taka ki bana sake vahAM taka apanA lekha pramANa ke sAtha hI likhanA cAhiye / sirpha vitaMDAvAda karake apanI ThA~ga Upara rakhane kI koziza karanA mAno apane mukhase apanA parAjaya kabUla karanA hai / / __maine isa mImAMsA meM apane isa upadeza para kahAM taka pAbaMdI rakkhI hai isa kA nirNaya pAThaka mahAzaya khuda kara leMge, kyoM ki merA isa viSaya meM adhika likhanA AtmazvAghA kA kAraNa ho jAtA hai / tathApi itanI sUcanA karUMgA to kucha bhI anucita nahIM hogA ki jahAM taka bana paDA hai maine isa lekha ko pramANa pUrvaka hI likhA hai| kIrticaMdrajI kI dIkSA kI hakIkata, ratnavijayajI zrIpUjya

Page #15
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / ( rAjendrasari ) jI bane isakA vRttAnta aura brAhmaNoM ke dvArA grantha banavAnA ityAdi jo jo aitihAsika bAteM likhI haiM ve bhI kalpita yA sunI sunAI nahIM, kiMtu khuda rAjendramUrijI ke hAthoM se likhe hue-patra pustaka tathA una ke sAdhuoM ke aura zrAvakoM ke likhe hue khata patra aura DAyarI Adi ke AdhAra se likhI haiM / jo ki vistAra ke bhaya se una saba pramANoM ko isa pustaka meM jyoM ke tyoM nahIM likhA, tathApi jo hakIkata likhI hai vaha saba unhIM ke anusAra hai, balake una se kama hai para jyAdA nhiiN| jina pramANoM ke AdhAra para yaha pustaka likhI gaI hai una meM kA sirpha eka patra yahAM namUne ke taura para udhRta kara detA hUM jo rAjendramUrijI kI AjJAse una ke bhInamAla ke zrAvakoM ne ratalAma ke zrAvakoM ko likhA thA / pAThakamahAzaya dekheMge ki maine jo kucha likhA hai vaha asatya nahIM hai| // zrI // " siddha zrI namI zaMtine likhu patra suvicAra / maMgalamAlavamaMDale saMghasakalasiradAra ratnapuri nagare sire svAmibaMdhava heta / dharmarAgasuM nagarano guNagaNa gaNIne leta // 2 // lajAdika guNagaNanidhI sAdhI siradAra / guNa ikavIse gAjatA iDhivaMta dAtAra sAmAyaka posA pramukha pUjA vividha prakAra / tapa japa me nita prata vase samakita sahasaMbhAra // 4 // ityAdika guNa dIpatA ketA karUM vakhANa / samakitanA guNagaNataNo pAra na leha sujANa // 5 //

Page #16
15 samastaguNa jogya seTha poravADa jasujI caturabhujajI aura samasta samakiti zrAvakAM jogya zrIbhInamAlasuM samastasaMgha sAdhama likhAvatAM paraNAma paMcAvasI ihAM zrIgurudevapratApathI sukhasAtA varte che Apa kA sukhasAtA kA patra Ayo zrIjAlora ne dhanarAjajI mutA upare so hamAre yahAM bhejyo vAMcI baDA khusI huvA Apa sarikhA zrAvaka dhanya he so munIrAjarI khabara letA rahe me to ajAchA mAre to yahAM pahalI isyA mAragane samajhatAi nahIM piNa zrIjIrA ziSya kIrticaMdrajI mAne dharma mAraga vatAyo jada mAluma paDI hame mArA bhAgya udesuM zrI pUjya AcArya mahArAja zrI 1008 zrIrAjendrasUrIsarajI piNa comAse aThe virAje he ThANu 8 suM ora sAdhavIyAMjI ThANu tIna suM virAje he so ghaNA bhavI prANI samakita pAmyA he ghaNA pAmasI khetra suddha hosI mahAlAbha le rahyA he bhAijI isyA AcArya mahArAja vinA dharma kuNa batAve AparA guNa suNane mAne piNa draDhatA hove he ora aThe zrIsavikAlikajI TIkA sahIta to vacyo ne hame upAsaka dasAgajI bace he upara pratikramaNa sUtra TIkA vaMcIje he zrAvaka zrAvakaNyAM tithIye tIna se cyAra se suNe he hame dina 2 adhika vakhANa me badhe he ora paMcaraMgI tapa doya to huvA phera husI paDikamaNAdika kiriyA suddha hove he sarva vAta kA AnaMda varate he amaMca pAThasAlA adhyApaka pannAlAlajI kIyo tarajamo mAgha kA sarga tIna ko ora kirAta saraga 2 doya ko jamale sarga 5 ko tarajamo zloka 5510 Asare Aya pugo ne zloka 21501 Asare Age iNArA Aya pugA he jamale zloka 27011 satAvIsa hajArare Asare Aya pugo ne komadIrA uttarArddharA tarajamArA patra 4 Aya pUgA he so jANasI ora komadIro tarajamo turata bhejAvasI aThe leyA khoTI hoya he so prastAvanA /

Page #17
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / turata bhejAvasI ne pannAlAlajIne tanakhA nahI dIvI ve to lekho kara graMtha lene sarva cukatI kara desI hame eka vAra komudI ko tarajamo pelI melAvasI mahArAjaro phuramAvaNo he ke dujA tonyArA 2 likhIja jAve piNa kaumudi ko tarjamo ekaTho likhIja jAve to ThIka so Apa tAkIda karAya likhAya melasIjI ne panAlAlajIne kesI ke tarajamo karo kaumudi ko so isa mujaba karo nakala bhejI he ora panAlAlajI ne keNo laghukomadIko tarajamo tIrA dApa dirija gayA ne hAla Ayo nahI so magAya melAvasI" isa patra ko dekhate yaha mAlUma hotA hai ki rAjendramUrijI brAhmaNoM dvArA kaI granthoM kA tarjumA bhI karAte the| isa eka hI patra se itanA to spaSTa hotA hai ki ratalAma kI pAThazAlA ke adhyApaka paMDita pannAlAlajI se rAjendramUrijI ne mAgha, kirAtArjunIya, laghukaumudI aura siddhAntakaumudI kA tarjumA rupayA dilA kara ke karAyA thaa| isa se bhI bar3hakara kaI pramANa mere pAsa haiM, lekina vistAra ke bhaya se unheM choDa detA hUM, yadi jarUrata par3egI to una ko bhI prakAza meM lAne kA prayatna kruuNgaa|| jahAM taka bana sakA hai| maiM isa pustaka kI bhASAviSayaka sabhyatA tarapha bhI lakSya rakhanA bhUlA nahIM hUM tathApi isa pustaka meM yadi kahIM sakhta vacana likha gayA ho to pAThaka mahodaya kSamA kareMge, kyoM ki yaha bAta mere vaza kI nahIM hai, isakA kAraNa lekhaka mahAzayoM kA hI vaha uttaradAna patra mAnanA cAhiye jo vinA hI soce samajhe uddhatAI se asabhya bhASA meM likhA gayA hai / kyoM ki yaha eka svAbhAvika niyama hai ki

Page #18
prastAvanA | sAhacaryayoga se bhI bahudhA vastu meM guNa doSa kI sRSTi ho jAtI hai / anubhavasiddha bAta hai ki atizItala vastu bhI prabala ani ke saMbandha se prAyaH apane sahaja svabhAva ko choDa ke uSNatA ko dhAraNa kara hI letI hai| 17 isa pustaka meM 'uttaradAnapatra ' kI bhASAsaMbaMdhI azuddhiyoM kI tarapha lakSya na karake sirpha viSaya kI azuddhiyoM kI hI mImAMsA kI gaI hai, kyoM ki lekhakoM kI bhASA to esI azuddha hai ki agara isa ke sambandha meM kucha likhane baiTheM to dUsarI kaI pustakeM bana jAyeM, para aisA karane kI kucha jarUrata nahIM hai / } tathA prakRta pustaka meM udhdhRta kiye hue ' uttaradAna patra ke phikaroM meM jo azuddhiyAM haiM una kA uttaradAtA maiM nahIM hUM, kyoM ki maine to usa patra meM se phikare le kara jyoM ke tyoM isa meM dAkhila kiye haiM, isa liye inake uttara dAtA ukta patra ke lekhaka hI haiM: maiM nahIM / vizeSatA - yadyapi isa tIna ke mata ke khaMDana meM Ajataka aneka pustakeM chapa cukI haiM, tathApi pAThakamahAzaya isa pustaka meM kucha vizeSatA avazya paayeNge| kAraNa ki amuka viSaya kI sAmagrI jitanI mujhe milI hai utanI pahale ke lekhakoM ko zAyada hI milI ho / ataeva maiM yaha kahane ko samartha hUM ki isa meM likhI huI sabhI bAtoM ko pramANa puraHsara siddha karane ko taiyAra hUM, jisa ko pUchanA ho vaha khuzI ke sAtha pUcha leve / vilamba kA kAraNa jo ki yaha pustaka kabhI kI taiyAra ho gaI thI, aura ise

Page #19
tristutika- mata-mImAMsA | jaldI chapavA dene ke liye jAlora, Ahora, gur3A, harajI, takhataAdi aneka zahara gAMvoM ke saMgha aura zAsanapremI sajjanoM kI prArthanA bhI kaI dinoM se ho rahI thI, tathApi vihAra, zarIra kI asvasthatA ityAdi kAraNoM se chapane meM bahuta vilaMba ho gayA hai / isa ke lie pUrvokta saMgha aura sajjanoM se kSamA cAhatA hUM / nivedana 18 yaha eka sAmAnya niyama haiM ki prANImAtra apanI anukUlatA aura pratikUlatA ko dekha ke vastu kA grahaNa aura tyAga karate haiM / isI niyamAnusAra isa pustaka kA Adara aura anAdara hogA / jina ko yaha anukUla hogI ve bar3e cAva se par3heMge, aura jina ke liye yaha pratikUla hai ve ise dekha ke bhI cir3heMge - isa kI satyatA aura upayogitA meM zaMkA kreNge| paraMtu donoM prakAra ke pAThakoM ko merA to yahI nivedana hai ki Apa ko khuzI aura nArAja hone kI kucha jarUrata nahIM hai| Apa ko to pakSapAta ko chor3a ke sirpha usI kI tarapha lakSya denA cAhiye jo isa meM satyatattva rahA huA hai | tathAstu | / tA. 13-5-17 bar3audA. mani kalyANavijaya.

Page #20
ahaM / tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / [ prathama-bhAga] paramAtmA zrI mahAvIra deva kI trikAlaviSayaka pavitra vANI kI satyatA saMsAra bhara meM sUrya kI taraha prakAzamAna hai, " paMcamAraka meM merA zAsana cAlanI prAya ho jAyagA " isa bhaviSyad bhASiNI Apa kI vANI kI kaI mata pakSoMne satyatA kara dikhAI hai aura vartamAna meM kara rahe haiN| traistutika mata bhI isI prakAra kA eka Adhunika mata hai, isa matane pavitra jaina dharma ke anuyAyI manuSyoM ko pracaNDa pradveSAnala meM homa kara una kI kaisI durdazA kI hai yaha bAta aba gupta nahIM hai, isa mata ke pracAlakoM kI pola pratyakSa karAkara bhadra puruSoM ko isa gaDDhe meM par3ate bacAnA sajana puruSoM kA kAma hai, isI vicAra se "jaina-bhikSu" nAma ke kisI zAsana premI lekhaka ne " koraTA tIrtha " zIrSaka lekha meM isa mata ke pravartaka rAjendra-mUrijI ke katipaya anucita kAryoM kA digdarzana karAyA thA, isa hitopadeza kA asara aisA huA; jaisA sugRhI ke upadeza se mUrkha

Page #21
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / vAnara ke prati huA thA, eka laMbe cauDe lekhadvArA gAliyoM kI vRSTi kara ke apanI kopa jvAlAeM zAnta karane kA udyoga kiyA, isa meM bhI Azcarya kI bAta to yaha hai ki "koraTA tIrtha" lekha kA lekhaka jaina bhikSu koI ora hI thA; aura ina kA jvAlAmukhI kisI ora hI ke Upara phaTA !, patthara kisI ne pheMkA aura kuttA kisI kI tarafa jhapaTTA / taba kyA yaha ucita nahIM ki isa bhayaMkara bhUla se ina becAroM ko bacA lenA cAhiye, basa isI irAde se yaha lekhaka ina ke usa lekha kI khabara lene ko tatpara huA hai aura bhUla ke gaMbhIra kUpa se uddhAra karane ke vAste hastAvalaMbana bhI de rahA hai / .. Apa ne apane lekhakA nAma rakkhA hai " tirthakoraTA jI ke anucita lekha kA samucita uttara dAna patra " alavattA yaha nAma jyAdA nahIM to hanumAn kI pUMcha jitanA to laMbA avazya hai, athavA yahI cAhiye thA; kyoM ki yaha kudaratI niyama hai ki jisameM sAra nahIM hotA vaha bAhyADaMbara se hI apanA TaTTa calAtA hai, hiMdI meM kahAvata hai " thothe caNe vAje ghane " prakRta patra ke lekhakoM ne isI kathana ko caritArtha kiyA hai, kyoM ki pustaka meM eka bhI sarAhanIya bAta nahIM AI taba laMbe nAma se hI saMtoSa maanaa| lekhakoM ne zuruAta meM hI apanI yogyatAnusAra maMgalAcaraNa yoM kiyA hai..." aMdhaguru-aMdha zraddhA vAlA jainabhikSu ne zrIvijayarAjendra sUrijI ke ucita kArya kA anucita lekha likhA jisa kA ucita lekha"

Page #22
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / 3 - vAha re bahAdura lekhako ! maMgalAcaraNa to acchA kiyA, kyoM ki yaha jo prAraMbhika aMdha zabda hai vaha ' aMdhe ho kara isa uttara dAna patra ko likheMge' isa Azaya ko sUcita karatA hai aura Apane isa kA nirvAha bhI acchI taraha kara liyA phira ise anucita kyoM kaheM ? / ___Age lekhaka mahodaya 'jainabhikSu' ke lekha ke paMnyAsapada viSayaka hisse kA khaMDana karane ke liye prastAvanA kara ke lekha ke phikare likhakara kahate haiM ki " boyA gAma ke kAusagiye ke UparakA lekha dekhate pannyAsa padavI ( 1251 ) meM bhI thI, aba isa se Age bhI kahAM taka thI isa bAta kA pattA lagAnA zeSa rahatA hai / ityAdi AzaMkA kA lekha itihAsa meM upayogI nahIM ho zaktA hai, itihAsopayogI lekha to taba bana zaktA hai ki jaba panyAsa padavI kA pUrA pattA lagA ke likhe so to likhA nhiiN!|" mAlUma hotA hai aitihAsika anveSaNa kA to lekhakoM ne tanika bhI abhyAsa nahIM kiyA, yadi kiyA hotA to yaha likhane kA kabhI duHsAhasa nahIM karate ki " ityAdi AzaMkA kA lekha itihAsa meM upayogI nahIM ho zaktA hai" mathurA ke zilA lekha jo rAjA kaniSka ke saMvatsara ke haiM, unheM Aja karIba 1800 aThAraha sau varSa ho cuke haiM, yadyapi una se isa bAta kA patA nahIM calatA ki mahAvIra kA zAsana (jaina dharma ) kaba se calA, tathApi una se yaha siddha ho cukA hai ki mahAvIra-zAsana prAcIna hai, aura usI kAraNa pAzcimAtya logoM ne una lekhoM kA baDA Adara kara ke una ke AdhAra bar3e 2 lekha, nibandha aura grantha likha

Page #23
wwwwww.in tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / wwwmum diye, to kyA ve saba nikamme baiThe the jo pUrA patA lagAye vinA hI ukta lekhoM ko itihAsa meM upayogI mAna liyA ?, vAstava yaha hai ki seMkaDoM to kyA paccIsa-paccAsa varSa pahale gujarI bAta ko batAne vAle lekha bhI itihAsa meM upayogI ho sakate haiM, para yaha bAta jarUra hai ki pakSapAtI loga use dekha bhAla nahIM sakate, to maMgala hI meM andhapana ko yAda karane vAle Apa-kese navIna lekhaka bhI isa ko na dekha sakeM to isa meM kucha Azcarya nahIM / phira mahAzaya harSa-tIrtha kahate haiM ki " prAcIna tIrtha ke viSaya meM (30-31 ) paMktiyAM taka paMnyAsapadavI kA asaMbaddha lekha likhanA- dholA pe kAlA hI karanA hai ! kyoM ki pramANika jaina zAstroM meM AcArya, (1) upAdhyAya, (2) pravartaka, (3) sthavira, ( 4 ) ratnAdhika, (5) ye pAMca padaviyAM likhI hai, paraMtu paMnyAsa padavI kA lekha kisI jaina zAstra meM khullA dekhane meM prAyaH janoM ko nahIM AtA hai jisa se kAM to isa bAre meM koI pramANika jaina zAstra kA khullA pATha batalAnA thA, nahIM to upara likhita padavIyAM meM amuka padavI meM paMnyAsa padavI aMtarbhUta hai aisA spaSTa lekha likhate to bhI ThIka thA paNa tIrtha kA lekha vinA eka hI boyA gAmakA lekha se paMnyAsa padavI siddha karanA AkAza kusumavat hai|" lekhaka mahAzayoM ko isa bAta kA khayAla hai ki " koraTA tIrtha " zIrSaka jaina bhikSu kA lekha kisa viSaya meM thA ? usakA mukhya sAdhya kyA thA ? usakA viSaya thA itihAsa, aura vahI usakA sAdhya thA, " boyA gAma kA zilA lekha khAsa aiti

Page #24
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / anawwarawmmmmm.wwwmarva hAsika hone se lekhaka ne use apane lekha meM dAkhila kiyaa| yaha eka sarva mAnya niyama hai ki kisI bhI aitihAsika padArtha ko nirUpaNa karate samaya lekhaka ko ucita hai ki vaha usake sahAyaka, dhvaMsaka sAmagrI kA varNana bhI saMkSepa meM kara leveM tA ki pUlaviSaya kI parisphuTatA ho jAya, ' isI niyamake anurodhase jaina bhikSune apane lekhameM rAjendramUrijI ke anucita kAryoM kA digdarzana karAyA so asthAna nahIM balake lekha kI spaSTatA ke lie hai| lekhaka mahAnubhAva ArcAyAdi 5 pAMca padaviyoM ko hI zAstrIya mAnate haiM to savAla yaha hai ki "paMDita padavI" ko Apa kisa meM ginoge ? kyoM ki usa ko to Apane pahale hI zAstrIya mAna liyA hai aura aba pAMca ko hI zAstrIya kahate haiN| athavA ThIka hai, Apa logoM kI guru zikSA bhI yahI hai ki pahale mana mAnA likha denA aura Age jAkara kucha aura hI likha mAranA, basa aise hI apanA dhoMsA bajAyA karanA, para yAda rahe ki jaise Apa aMdhapana ko mAna de kara likha dete haiM vaise pAThaka loga kadApi nahIM kareMge, ve bAhya abhyantara donoM prakAra ke apane nirmala netroM ke prakAza ko hI mAna dekara par3heMge aura ApakI ina karatUtoM ko acchI taraha jAna leNge| yadi lekhakoM kI mAnyatA ho ki " paMDita padavI" to pUrvokta pAMca padaviyoM meM antarbhUta ho jAtI hai to phira paMnyAsa padavI ke lie likhakara kyoM duHkha uThAyA ? kyA paMDita aura paMnyAsa padavI meM bhaida hai ? / agara kahA jAya ki aisA spaSTa likha denA thA ki "amuka padavI meM paMnyAsa padavI antarbhUta hai to yaha bhI galata hai, ati spaSTa vArtA ko aitihAsika eka lekha meM spaSTa karanA piSTa peSaNa tulya hai, spaSTatA usa viSaya kI honI cAhiye jo durbodha-jaTila ho /

Page #25
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / -rrrrrrrrrrr. phira lekhakajI mahArAja apanI kudarata zAlA meM se do cAra DiMgeM bAhara lAte haiM ki "zrI koraTAjI tIrtha meM gAma se bAhara AdhA mIla ke karIba bAhara kA maMdira bahuta purANA hai jisa meM vidyAdhara kula ke zrImAn ratnaprabha sUrIzvarajI ne jisa lagna meM zrI mahAvIra svAmIjI kI pratimA kI sthApanA ( kI ) thI vaha mUrti bahUta varSoM ke kisI kAraNa yoga se pavvAsaNa se vilupta ho gii|" maiM lekhakoM ko pUchatA hUM ki yaha vicitra itihAsa Apane lAyA kahAM se ? ratnaprabha mUri vidyAdhara kula ke the aisA kisI zAstra meM likhA hai yA Apa ke gAla purANa kI yaha eka gappa hai ? zAyada gappa hI hai, kyoM ki zAstroM meM to ratna prabhamUrijI upakeza gaccha ke likhe haiM aura Apa vidyAdhara kula ke the aisA likhate haiM so yaha gappa nahIM to aura kyA hai| phira bhI dekhiye, ratna prabhamUrijI ne satyapura ( sAcora ) aura oziyAjI meM mahAvIra svAmI kI pratimA sthApita kI aisA to aitihAsika pramANoM se siddha hotA hai para " koraNTaka " meM unhoM ne pratimA sthApana kI aisA itihAsa to zAyada lekhakoM ne pAyA ho to mAlUma nahIM, agara pAyA ho to prakAza meM lAiye anyathA yaha bhI dUsarI gappa to hai hii| lekhaka kahate haiM ki " kAraNa vaza vaha mUrti padmAsana se vilupta ho gaI thI so saM. 1728 meM phira padmAsana para biThAI gaI " so to ThIka hI kiyA haiM, kyoM ki ve purAne loga rAjendrasUrijI sarIkhe yazobhilASI nahIM the jo purAnI pratimA ko khaMDita

Page #26
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / kA miSa karake dUra kara deM aura apanI pratiSThita pratimA ko laMbe cauDe lekhoM ke sAtha viThavA deN| phira lekhaka apanI jUThI karatUta calAte haiM ki "jo pratimA zrImAn ratnaprabhasUrIzvarajI ne aMjanazalAkAsaha pratiSThita sthApanA kI thI usa pratimA kA pabbAsaNa meM mUla nAyaka kA abhAva dekha ke zrI vijayaprabha muri jI ke bAre meM kisa mahAn gItArtha kA upadeza se mUlanAyaka jI kA sthAna meM dUsarI prAcIna akhaMDita atizayavaMta AcArya mahArAja kA hAtha kI pratiSThita zrI mahAvIra svAmI jI kI pratimA sthApita kI gaI thI" bilakula jhUTha hai kisI bhI gItArtha ke upadeza se dUsarI purAnI pratimA sthApita nahIM huI kiMtu vahI sthApita huI jo pahale thI, matalaba yaha ki mahAvIra svAmI kI purAnI pratimA-jisa kI pratiSThA vikrama saMvata 125 meM huI thIkisI kAraNa vaza vaha padmAsana para se uThA dI yA uTha gaI thI, paraMtu jaba vaha kAraNa nivRtta ho gayA to saM0 1728 meM phira use sthAna para biThA diyA, yadyapi pratimA jI ke kucha upAMga (avayava ) ghisa gaye the tathApi zAstra ke jAna bhava bhIru baiThAne vAloM ne usa ko khaMDita kaha kara dUra biThAnA aura nayI pratimA kA sthApana-jo eka baDI bhArI AzAtanA hai-pasaMda nahIM kiyA, aphasosa ! usI nirdoSa aura bhavya pratimA ko mAna priya rAjendramUrijI ne sthAna se uThavA DAlA aura isa kSaNika kIrti ke AzA--pAza meM phaMsa kara bhayaMkara AzAtanA ke bhAgI bana baiThe ! / phira lekhaka bayAna karate haiM ki " jaise zrIjAlora gaDha ke

Page #27
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / Upara kumArapAla bhUpAla kI karAI huI atizayavanta zrI hemacandrAcArya jI kI aMjana zalAkA saha pratiSThita sthApita kI huI prAcIna pratimA kI nAsikA hAtha kI aMgulI paga kI aMgulI, aura aMguSTha khaMDita hone se bha0 zrI vijayadeva sUrIzvarajI kA Adezase, paM0 jayasAgara gaNI ne mUla prAcIna pratimA ko gaddIpara se uThavAkara raMga maMDapa meM patharAI aura saMvat (1681 ) kI nUtana pratiSThita pratimA zrI mahAvIra jI kI gaddIpara prAcIna mUla nAyaka jI ke sthAna meM sthApita karAI vaha pratimA zrIjAlora kA killApara zrIkumArapAla vihAra caitya meM Aja taka pUjI jAtI hai " yaha bhI likhanA lekhakoM kI ajJatA ko siddha karatA hai, kyoM ki na to purAnI pratimA khaMDita mAnakara gaddIpara se uThavAI aura na usa kAraNa usake sthAna meM navI pratimA sthApita kI gaI kiMtu bAta yaha hai ki jaba julmI rAjAoMne jAlora para caDhAI kara use phataha kara liyA taba zrI saMghane kile para ke tInoM maMdiroM kI pratimAeM jaisA maukA dekhA bhinna bhinna sthAno meM bhaMDAra kara dI, kAraNa yaha thA ki aisA karane se ve julmI bAdazAhoM kI anIti se baca jAya~ / bAda jaba ki rASTra meM zAnti chA gaI to sahaja sAgara gaNi ke ziSya jayasAgara gaNi ne apane AcArya zrI vijayadeva sUrijI kI AjJA se una mUrti rahita maMdiroM kI unati kI nIMva DAlI aura saMvat 1681 meM saba se pahale zrImahAvIra svAmI ke maMdira meM nayI pratimA biThAI, kramazaH saMvat 1683-1684 meM bhI zrIvijayadevamUri jI ne kaI pratimAoM kI pratiSThA kI aura bAkI ke donoM maMdiroM kI bhI marammata karavAI, bAda kitaneka arse ke vaha mahAvIra svAmI kI purAnI prati

Page #28
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / mA bhI kisI sthAna se khaMDita dazA meM hAtha laga gaI taba maMdira meM eka sthAna para padharA dI gaI, isa prakAra jAlora ke kile kI phira unnata dazA huI jo Aja taka Tika rahI hai, jaba jAloragaha ke maMdiroM kI yaha hakIkata hai to phira lekhaka kaise kaha sakate haiM ki usa purAnI pratimA ko uThavA ke nayI sthApita kii| phira lekhaka mahodaya apanA saiddhAntikatva prakAzita karane ke liye likhate haiM ki " yahAM kisI ko prazna utpanna hogA ki pratimA aMgopAMga khaMDita hone ke bAda to bhaMDAranI cAhiye ? paNa pUjanIya na cAhiye tisa kA samAdhAna yaha hai ki zrIjainazAstra meM kahA hai ki (100 ) varSa ke bhItara kI pratimA aMgopAMga se khaMDita ho gaI hoya to bhaMDAranI, paraMtu so varSa uparAMta kI pratimA kA uttamAMga khaMDita na huA hoya aura upAMga khaMDita huA hoya to bhaMDAranI nahIM, apUjanIya kabhI karanI nahIM, lekhakoMne aisA kisa jaina zAstra meM dekhA ki 100 varSa Upara kI pratimA ko apUjanIya to nahIM karanA lekina mUlanAyaka ke sthAna se uThA denA ? / merI samajha meM to yaha bhI lekhakoM kI nirI DiMga hI hai, kyoM ki jainazAstra to yoM kahatA hai " varisasayAo uTheM, jaM biMba uttame hiM saMThaviyaM / viyalaMgu vi pUijjai, taM vivaM niSphalaM na jao" // 1 // ( artha ) uttama puruSoM kA sthApita sau varSa Upara kA biMba vikalAMga ho to bhI pUjA jAtA hai, kyoM ki usa kI pUjA niSphala nahIM jaatii| lekhaka jI isa bAta kA khulAsA kareM ki purAnI vikalAMga

Page #29
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / pratimA ko mUlanAyaka ke sthAna meM kyoM nahIM pUjanA ? kyoM ki na to aisA kisI zAstra meM likhA hai aura na isa prakAra kI maryAdA hai, hAM, tInathuivAloM ne to apanI pUjA. mAnyatA ke nimitta yaha paraMparA jarUra khar3I kI hai| phira lekhaka apanI zAnti kA paricaya dete hue svayaM javAba savAla karate haiM "yahAM jainabhikSu jaisA koI anAcAra savAla karegA ki gaddIpara rahI huI prAcIna pratimA kA sudhArane vAle kA yoga nahIM milane se aMgopAMga khaMDita pratimA hI vahAM kI vahA~ gaddIpara pUjI jAtI to kyA harja hotA ? isa savAla kA javAba yaha hai ki jo pratimA uttamAMga nAsikA pramukha svalpAMga khaMDita hoya aura atizayavanta hoya, arthAt devAdhiSThita svamAdi prayoga pAlI kA bhI svalpAMga sudhArane ke bAda gaddI para rahI jAya to harja nahIM." vAha re lekhako ! jaina bhikSu jaisA-jo AzAtanA karane vAloM ko hitazikSA kare vaha to Apa ke mata se anAcAra hai to kRpayA yaha batA dIjiye ki Apa sadAcAra kise mAnate haiM ? kyA purAnI pratimAoM ko sthAna se uThavAkara nIce rakhavA de vaha ApakA sadAcAra hai, yA pratiSThita pratimAoM ke lekha musalamAna ke pAsa ghisavA de vaha Apa kA mAnya sadAcAra hai ? aphasosa ! lekhaka maMdira mArgI ho kara ke bhI pratimAdveSiyoM kA AcAra kahAM se sIkha baiThe ? / khaira / Apa apane savAla kA javAba kyA dete haiM use dekhiye, ve kahate haiM alpa khaMDita pratimA mUlanAyaka ke sthAna meM pUjI jA sakatI hai, para, vaha atizayavaMta arthAta

Page #30
tristutika-mata--mImAMsA / rrrrrrrnama svamAdi prayoga vAlI honI cAhiye, apane isa mata kI puSTi meM ve siddhAcala jI ke mUlanAyaka kI misAla dete haiM, maiM pUMchatA hUM, ora to ThIka, para, " vaha svapnAdi prayoga vAlI honI cAhiye" yaha Apa kA kathana kisI zAstra ke anusAra hai yA mAtra gappa purANa kA adhyAya likha diyA hai ? mujhe to gappa purANa hI mAlUma hotA hai, kyoM ki kaI jagaha purAne maMdira aura pratimAoM kI anArya loga AzAtanA kara dete haiM, yahAM taka ki unheM toDa bhI DAlate haiM. paraMtu svapnaprayogAdi aihika atizaya kucha bhI nahIM hotA, to kyA ve pratimA devAdhiSThita nahIM haiM aisA mAnoge ? nahIM, yaha bAta kadApi nahIM ho sakatI, zAstra kA lekha hai ki " jo lakSaNopeta padArtha hotA hai vaha devatAdhiSThita hotA hai" to jinendra pratimA-jo saMpUrNa lakSaNa yukta hotI hai-devatAdhiSThita na hove aisA ina nirbhIka lekhakoM ke vinA dUsarA to kahane ko samartha nahIM ho sakatA / phira lekhaka apanA mantavya siddha karane kI vRthA ceSTA karate haiM ki "jaise laukika meM rAjA cakSvAdi hIna uttamAMga hIna na hoya taba to rAjagaddI para sevana yogya prAyaH rahatA hai aura cakSvAdi uttameMdriya hIna hone bAda-ekAnta gaddI sevane yogya hotA hai vaise hI lokottara meM bhI AcAryAdika cakSvAdi iMdriya hIna hone bAda ekAnta sevane yogya hote haiM, taise hI lokottara deva pratimA bhI gaddI para sevane yogya rakhane se upavRhaNAtmaka samyaktva kA nAza karake prANI tIrthAdika kI mahA AzAtanA kA bhAgI ho jAtA hai aisA puruta ( dRDha ) vicAra

Page #31
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / aura atizaya svapnAdi kAraNa na hone se zrI vijaya rAjendra sUrijI ne to zrI prAcIna tIrtha kI AzAtanA TAlanekA ucita ( yogya ) kArya kiyA hai" vAha ! asatkalpanA kA bhI kucha pAra hai, lekhaka jI ! kucha soca vicAra ke likhiye maharavAna ! prathama to ApakA kalpita rAjA kA dRSTAnta hI asiddha hai / khyAla karo ! kyA brahmadatta cakravartI netrahIna hone ke bAda rAjagaddI se utAra diyA gayA thA ? yadi kahA jAya yaha bAta to nahIM huI to phira ApakA laukika dRSTAnta asiddha ThaharA yA nahIM ? / phira lekhakoM ne lokottara viSayaka AcArya kA udAharaNa diyA para vaha bhI yahAM para ghaTamAna nahIM ho sakatA, kyoMki vaha pratimA to cakSu sahita hai isa lie cakSuhIna AcArya ke dRSTAnta se kadApi utthApya yA gopya nahIM ho sakatI, isa vAste rAjendra mUrijIne vaha kArya pukhta vicAra se nahIM kiyA, kiMtu kSudra vicAra se hI kiyA hai, aura vaha AzAtanA miTAnekA nahIM; pUrNa AzAtanA karane kA / hRdaya meM tanika bhI sauco yaha merA kahanA asatya nahIM hai| lekhaka kahate haiM" rAjendrasUrijIne leza mAtra bhI mAnAbhilASipaNA nahIM kiyA" lekhaka jI! 'bhI' zabda nikAla do phira ApakA kahanA ThIka mAnUMgA, kyoM ki yaha bAta satya hai ki unhoM ne leza mAtra mAnAmilApa nahIM kiyA, arthAt bahuta kiyA thA, aura yahI kAraNa hai ki unhoM ne bAhyavRttyA dravyaparigraha Adi kA tyAga kara ke bhI kisI bhI tyAgI guru ke pAsa upasaMpada dhAraNa nahIM kI, lekhaka mahAzaya khayAla kareM ki mahAnizItha, hIraprazna vigairaha

Page #32
tristutika mata-mImAMsA / aneka zAstroM ke pramANa milane para bhI rAjendrasUrijI ne kiyoddhAraka guru nahIM kiye isa kA savava kyA hai ? kyA unako anveSaNa karane para bhI koI tyAgI guru nahIM mile ?, nahIM, yaha bAta hargija nahIM kaha sakate, bhagavAna zrI mahAvIra deva kA dharma - zAsana ikkIsa hajAra varSa taka avicchinna paraMparA se calegA, aura jaba taka vaha zAsana jArI rahegA taba taka zAstrAnusAra calane vAle sAdhuoM kA viccheda nahIM hogA yaha jainasiddhAnta kA sarva mAnya niyama hai, asalI bAta to yaha hai ki unhoMne abhimAna ke mAre kisI ke Age zira jhukAnA munAsiba nahIM samajhA, isa liye kisI ke bhI pAsa kriyoddhAra karake upasaMpad nahIM lI, lekhaka jI ! yaha Apa ke rAjendrasUrijI kA leza mAtra to nahIM kiMtu bahuta mAnAbhilASipana hai yA nahIM ? | phira lekhaka jhUThI karatUta Age karate haiM ki " prAcIna pratimA kA bahUta avayava khaMDita dekhake sudhArane vAle kA avasara para yoga nahIM milane se gaddI para se uThavA kara usakA sudhArA karane ke liye pUrvAcAryoM kA anukaraNa se anya sthAna meM sthApita karavAnA, ityAdi tIrtha kA sudhArA apane bhakta logoM ko upadeza karake karanA karAvanA yaha kucha AzAtanA kA kAraNa tathA mAnAbhilASIpaNA jaina zAstroM ke nyAya se pratIta nahIM hotA hai " 13 yaha lekhakoM kI sarAsara jAla sAjI hai, nayI pratimAoM kA yoga to mila gayA aura purAnI ko sudhArane vAle kA yoga nahIM milA yaha kathana to lekhakoM ke aMdhazraddhAlu bhaktoM ke sivA aura koI bhI nahIM mAnegA, kyoM ki ' avasara' zabda se hI Apa kI kapaTI vRtti prakaTa ho rahI hai. seMkaDoM balke hajAroM jaina-prati

Page #33
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / mAoM ko to sudhArane vAloM kA yoga jaba cAhe mila jAtA hai, aura koraTA kI eka pratimA ko sudhArane vAloM kA yoga nahIM milA yaha Apa kA bacAva sarvathA nirmAlya aura jhUThA hai, sudhArane vAle kA yoga bhI mila sakatA aura yaha acchI taraha sudhara bhI sakatI thI para aisA karanA hI nahIM thA phira kaise ho sake ! / phira lekhaka mahAnubhAva likhate haiM... "bezaka sAvadya ( pApa ) sahita kAma kA bolanA to zrIvijaya rAjendrasUrijI kA kama thA paNa malamalIna vastra to ve nahIM rakhate the, ve to (pAMDura pAuraNa ) arthAt sapeta mAnopeta jIrNaprAya vastra rakhate the" bilakula hI jhUTha hai, kauna kahatA hai rAjendramUrijI sAvadha kama bolate the? kabhI kabhI to ve isa prakAra jhUThI bAteM uDA dete the ki gRhastha loga bhI unase napharata karane lagajAte the, kyA yaha sAvadya nahIM hai ? yA kama hai ? / vastra ke viSaya meM bhI lekhakoM kA jhUThA bacAva hai ki ve malamalIna vastra nahIM rakhate the jinhoMne rAjendramUrijI yA una ke sAdhuo kI zakla dekhI hai ve yahI kahate haiM ki yaha bhI eka DhuMDhakamata kA bhAI bAhyADaMbarI mata hai jo malIna vastroM se hI logoM ko phasA detA hai / lekhakoM kA kathana kive sapheda-mAnopeta-jIrNaprAya vastra rakhate the-sarAsara jhUThA hai, rAjendramUrijI jIrNaprAya vastra nahIM rakhate the kiMtu sApha nayA rakhate the aura aba bhI una ke anuyAyI Apa logoM kI vahI dazA hai, jIrNaprAya to vaha kahA jAtA hai jo gRhasthoM ke liye anupayogI yA kama upayogI ho gayA ho, nayA vastra lekara dazapaMdrA roja bhItara vAparane se vaha jIrNaprAya nahIM hotA, yaha to sirpha Apa logoM kI kapaTa-paTutA kA namUnA hai|

Page #34
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / phira lekhaka jI apanI sAdhutA kA cinha dikhAne ke liye bhASA-samiti kA sadupayoga karate haiM ki " paraMtu jaina bhikSu kA dAdA para dAdA hI malamalIna vastra rakhate the tisako choDake jaina bhikSu kA gurune pIta vastra (phakIroM kA veSa ) dhAraNa kara kitaneka aMgasthAna meM zveta vastra aura kitaneka aMga sthAnameM pIta vastra apanI pUjA mAnatA peTa bharane ke khAtira bhAMDa ceSTA bheSa viDaMbaka ho kara jainabhikSu paNA kA pada choDa-jaina bhikhArI paNA kiyA ! ! taise rAjendrasUrijI nahIM karate the." lekhakoM ne kyA yahI brata dhAraNa kara liyA hai ki muMha AyA aMDa baMDa likha mAranA ? kyoM ki na to jaina bhikSu ke dAdA para dAdA malamalIna vastra rakhate the aura na una ko jaina bhikSune choDA hai, kAraNa vizeSa meM naye vastra kA varNa palaTanA phakIroM kA veza nahIM hai yaha jaina zAstra saMmata muniyoM kA veza hai, apane hI mukha se apanI yogyatA kA patA dene vAle lekhaka ! namaskAra ! bAra bAra namaskAra ! isa madhura likhAna ke liye Apa ko kyA pAritoSika dUM, mujhe kucha nahIM sUjhatA, sirpha yahI kaha kara saMtoSa mAnatA hUM ki aise priyabhASI lekha Apa hI ko mubArika ho / lekhaka ! priyabhASI lekhaka ! bhalA Apa apanI to batA dIjiye ki Apa aura Apa ke gurvAdi saba loga naye vasra gRhasthoM ke ghara se lA kara vAparate haiM so yaha ! kisa jaina zAstra kI TAMga toDate haiM ? kyoM ki zAstra meM to sAdhuoM ke vastravidhAna meM prathama to zvetamAno peta-jIrNaprAya vastra grAhya kahe haiM, aura dezakAlAdi vizeSa meM naye vastra ko katthe cUne Adi se varNa badala kara ke bhI rakhanA kahA hai| yaha dvitIya prakAra nimna likhita nizItha ke pATha kI cUrNi se prakAzita hotA hai, vaha pATha yaha hai

Page #35
mmmmmmmmmmmar - 11 .1 1 . . - . . .. -. .- . - 4 tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / mmm.mmmmmmar "je bhikkhU vA Navae me paDiggahe laddhe tti kaTTa loddheNa vA kakkeNa vA ehANa (vaNNeNa) vA cuNeNa vA ulloleja vA uvadejA vA ullolaMta yA uvadvaMtaM vA sAijai" yaha pATha nizItha sUtra ke caudahave uddeze meM pAtravarNanAdhikAra meM pATaNa ke bhaMDAra kI bahuta hI purAnI prata ke patra 390 meM hai, isa meM navIna pAtra raMgane kA vidhAna hai, vastravarNana meM 18 aThAra veM uddeze meM isI caudave uddeze kA atideza kiyA hai, vaha pATha usI prata ke patra 47 ve meM isa mujiba hai " je evaM caudasame uddese paDiggahe jo gamo bhaNio so ceva iha vattheNa Neyavyo" artha isa kA yaha hai ki je bhikkhU' ityAdi caudave uddeze meM pAtra saMbaMdhI jo pATha kahA hai vahI yahAM para vastra ke nAma se jAnanA; pUrvokta pAThoM se cUrNikAra ne yaha tAtparya nikAlA hai ki vastra-pAtra ko nUtanatAdi kAraNa meM tIna pasalI se jyAdA varNaka padArthoM se raMge to prAyazcitta hai arthAt ukta kAraNa meM tIna pasalI taka se raMgane meM prAyazcitta nahIM hai, aura jaba pAyazcitta nahIM to usa meM doSa bhI nahIM hai, kyoM ki doSa hotA to prAyazcitta jarUra hotaa| isI artha ko kahatA huA bRhatkalpa ke tRtIya khaMDa kI TIkA kA pATha bhI paDha lIjiye, " yadi vibhUSArtha vastrAdi rajjati tadA prAyazcittam " ____ yAnI jo sobhA ke liye vastra Adi raMge to prAyazcitta AtA hai, isa se bhI yahI siddhAnta pramANita hotA hai ki sobhA ke sivA dasare kAraNa prasaMga se vastra pAtrAdika raMge to doSa aura prAyazcitta

Page #36
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA | nahIM hai, ityAdi aneka zAstroM ke pramANoM se madhyastha pAThaka mahodaya bakhUbI samaja sakate haiM ki sApha naye vastra kA varNa parAvartana karanA zAstra viruddha nahIM balke zAstra pratipAdita mArga hai, zAstra viruddha kArya to yaha hai jo jIrNaprAya vastra bhI nahIM lenA aura nayA lekara usakA varNa badala bhI nahIM karanA, jaise lekhakoM kA gurvAdi parivAra kara rahA hai / lekhaka mahAzayo ! jarA akheM khola ke sUtroM ke pATha dekho aura sauco ki naye vastra kA katthAdi padArthoMse varNa badalanA siddha hotA hai yA nahIM ? agara lekhakoM kI mAnyatA ho ki yaha to kAraNika bAta hai, to kahanA cAhiye ki vaha kAraNa kyA hai ? zAyada lekhaka kaheMge ki vaha kAraNa madirAdi durgaMdha hai (yAnI madirAdi durgaMdha miTAne ke liye vastra katthAdi padArthoM se raMganA cAhiye ) to yaha bhI gappa hai, kyoM ki sUtra ke ' Navae me vatthe (yA) paDiga laddhe tti kaTTu ' isa vAkya meM to navIna vastra kI prApti hI kAraNa batAyA hai to tumhArA abhimata ' madirAdi durgaMdha' ko kAraNa kisa prakAra isa viSaya meM mAnA jAya ? yadi lekhaka kaheMge ki nizItha sUtra ke mUla pATha se navIna vastra kI prApti raMgane kA kAraNa kaise nikala sakatA hai ? to uttara yaha hai ki pATha meM rahe hue " iti kaTTu " zabda se yaha artha nikalatA hai, kyoM ki uparyukta zabda kA saMskRta meM " itikRtvA " yaha svarUpa banatA hai, aura " itikRtvA " kA saMskRta paryAya " iti heto: " hai, isa kA artha " isa hetuse " aisA hotA hai, yaha artha kalpita nahIM kiMtu zAstra pratipAdita hai, pAkSika mUtra TIkA meM yazobhadrasUrijIne iti kaTTu " zabda kA yahI artha kiyA hai, pATha yaha (( 17

Page #37
tristutika-mata--mImAMsA / hai " iti kaTTa-itikRtvA iti hetoH ", isa kA artha pahale likha diyA hai, isa kathana meM kisI ko zaka ho to pUrvokta grantha dekha leve / isa saba vivecana kA tAtparyArtha yaha milA ki yadi navInatAdi kAraNa se vastra kI zobhA haTAne ke liye usa kA varNa badala kiyA jAya to doSa nahIM kiMtu guNa hai, yaha mAtra yukti hI na samajhiye yaha eka nyAya prasiddha siddhAnta hai, jainoM ke mAnya nyAya ke grantha 'ratnAkarAvatArikA' meM kyA likhA hai lekhakoM ne dekhA hai ? usa meM isa prakAra likhA hai__ " vizeSapratiSedhasya sAmAnyavidhinAntarIyakatvAt " yAne viziSTa vastu kA pratiSedha sAmAnya kA vidhipratipAdaka hotA hai, jaise, " guThviNI vAlavacchA ya pavAveuM na kappai " arthAt garbhiNI aura bAla bacce vAlI strI ko dIkSA denI na kalpe, isa se yaha siddhAnta nikalA ki ina ke sivA dUsarI striyoM ko dIkSA kalpe, isI prakAra yahAM para bhI vibhUSA ( zobhA ) ke sivA dUsare kAraNoM se vastroMkA varNa badala karanA yaha eka sIdhA nyAya mArga hai, yadi lekhaka mahAzaya uttarAdhyayana-TIkA ko muMdI AMkhoM se dekha ke yaha kaheM ki varNa parAvartita vastra bhAMDoM kA veza hai to maiM dilagirI ke sAtha kahUMgA ki Apa jarA AMkhoM ko takalIpha de kara ke dekheM ki kisa jagaha bhAMDoM kA veza kahA hai, yaha bAta ora hai, yadi Apa ke gappa purANa meM likhA ho to maiM nahIM kaha sakatA, bAkI usa meM to yaha kahA hai ki pArzvanAtha ke ziSyoM ke liye raktAdi varNa vAle vastroM kI anujJA hai aura varddhamAna

Page #38
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / ke ziSyoM ko zveta vastra kI anujJA hai, so yaha utsargamArga vipayaka-pratipAdana jaina bhikSu ko to kyA saba ko pramANa hai, kyoM ki zveta mAnopeta-jIrNaprAya ina tIna vizeSaNoM se yukta sAdhu ke yogya vastra yadi mila jAya to hameM usako raMgane kI kucha jarUrata nahIM / isI prakAra ora jagaha bhI jo zveta vastroM kA vidhAna hai vaha utsarga ( kAraNa vinAkA) mArga hai. lekhaka mahodaya ! kucha soca vicAra ke likhA kareM, kyoM ki dUsaroM ko bhAMDa banAne kI ceSTA karate Apa khuda hI bhAMDa na bana jAya yaha khyAla rkhnaa| yaha bAta bhI lekhakoM ko vidita honI cAhiye ki varNaparAvatita vastroM ko jaina muni pUjA mAnyatA ke liye nahIM rakhate kiMtu zAstrAnusAra saMyama kI rakSA aura Atma-rakSA ke liye rakhate haiM, kyoM ki vivarNavastroM se pUjA mAnyatA nahIM hotI, pUjA mAnyatA hotI hai bAhyADaMbara se, jaise Apa tIna thuI vAloM ke pUjya guru karA rahe haiM / ___ aba lekhaka jaina bhikSu kI batAI huI rAjendramUrijI kI azuddhioM kA jhUThA samAdhAna karanekI zurUAta karate hue apanI sajanatA ko pragaTa karate haiM ki, " ye saba zrIvijayarAjendra sUrijI ke saMskRta jJAna khajAne kA to namUne nahI hai lekina aMdha gurUkI aMdha zraddhA ke bheSa viDaMbaka jainabhikSujIne kAlI kAzI meM saMskRta paDha ke apane ajJAna khajAne se pragaTa kiye hai "!! kyoMki (1) "viMbaM likhakarake phira kArApitA likhanA" yaha azuddhi ( bhUla ) lekhaka kI athavA khodanevAlekI aura jaina bhikSujI kI ajJAnatA kI hai " lekhaka jI ! Apa bhI apane gurvAdikI mavAphika bhAMga

Page #39
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / vigairaha kA nazA lete mAlUma hote haiM, kyoM ki bAra bAra jainabhikSu ke gurU ko aMdha batAte ho isa liye tumhArA saba kArabhAra naze meM hI hotA hai aisA jAnA jAtA hai, athavA to tumhArI buddhi hI phira gaI hai inake sivA tIsarA kucha bhI kAraNa nahIM jAna paDatA / lekhaka ! isa Apa ke likhAna se to Apa hI khuda ajJAna ke aMdhera se ghere hue mAlUma dete haiM kyoMki jainabhikSu ke to gurU kyA Aja taka koI bhI aMdha nahI huA aura hogA bhI nahIM, jainabhikSu kI paraMparA hI aisI nahIM ki camAra, meNA, nAI, kumAra, vigairaha aspRzya aura juMgitoM ko muMDa ke dekhate bhI aMdhe bana jAya, yaha rIti tumhAre aise ziSyoM ke lobhI sAdhuoM ke Age hI saphala hogI, jainabhikSu kI pavitra paraMparA meM nhiiN| lekhaka apane rAjendrasUrijI kI azuddhiyoM ko lekhaka yA khodane vAle ke zira mahate haiM para isa jAla-sAjI ko buddhimAna loga kaise satya mAneM ge ? kyoM ki eka do yA cAra azuddhiyAM hoM taba to lekhakAdi ke zira bhI caDha sakatI hai para ekeka zloka kI ATha 2 daza 2 azuddhiyAM lekhaka yA khodane vAle kI nahIM ho sakatI kyA rAjendrasUrijI dekha suna nahIM sakate the jo khAsa apane lekhoM kI bhI azuddhiyAM dekhI sunI nahIM ? / asala bAta to yaha hai ki ve paDhe likhe hI itane hI the isa liye jyoM tyoM gaDabaDa likha mArate aura apanA TaTTa calA lete the, yaha merA kathana Age jAte achI taraha siddha ho jAyagA / (2-3) " sUrizvara" tathA " mahArAja koraTA nagara " ina do azuddhiyoM kA samAdhAna bhI isI prakAra kA nirjIva hai| (4)" rASTra vaMzIya yaha donoM zabda to sarvavAcI hai usa ke

Page #40
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / sthAna meM rASTra kUTa yaha donoM zabda dezavAcI likhanA ye bhUla to jaina bhikSujI ke ajJAna khajAne kI hI hai" vAha jI vAha ! nyAya kI TAMga toDanI to ThIka sIkhe ho jarA dimAga sthira rakkho aura buddhi ko kAma meM lAo! / muMhase to kaha rahe ho ki 'rASTra vaMzIya' ye donoM zabda sarva vAcI haiM to phira ApakI buddhi kahAM calI gaI hai ki dezavAcI zabda ke viSaya meM sarva vAcI zabda prayoga ko zuddha kahate ho ? / becAre rAjendramarijI ne to ve samajha se isa mujaba likha diyA paraMtu tuma to jAna bujha ke isa azuddha prayoga ko zuddha ThaharAne kI koziza karate ho, yahI Azcarya aura khedajanaka viSaya hai ! / kyoM ki 'rASTra' yaha kisI vaMza vizeSa kA nAma nahIM hai kiMtu 'rASTrakUTa' yaha vaMza vizeSa kA nAma hai jise bhASA meM ' rAThoDa' bolate haiM isa vAste yahAM para 'rAThauDa' kI prakRti ' rASTrakUTa' hI likhanA samucita hai, 'rASTravaMzIya' likhanA aura use zuddha kahanA rAjendramUrijI aura lekhakoM kI vaDI bhArI bhUla hai / (5) isa azuddhikA nirAkaraNa lekhaka mahodaya apanI donoM AMkheM muMda ke isa prakAra karate haiM " saMvacchate trayatrizannandaikavikramAda vare 'vikramAt vikrama se trayastriMzannandaike zate aMkasya vAmA gatiH isa nyAya se (1933 ) vare ( zreSTha ) saMvat meM isa Azaya se saMvacchate trayastriMzannandaike vikramAdvare aisA vizuddha lekha zrI vijayarAjendra sUrijIne likhavAye the" lekhaka jI! jarA AMkhe khola kara dekho mUla lekha meM " nandaike vikramAd " aisA nahIM hai, kiMtu " nandakavikramAt " aisA hai to kyA yaha Apa kI cAla bAjI nahIM hai ki " nandaikavikramAt "

Page #41
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / ina samasta padoMko vyasta mAna ke AMkhoM ADe kAna karanA cAhate ho? yAda rahe ki isa prakAra kI ApakI cAlAkiyAM yahAM para nahIM caleMgI, yadi Apa kI nirvalatA ke khAtira yaha mAna bhI leM ki rAjendra mUrijI kA Azaya " nandaike vikramAt " isa para thA to bhI Apa kI vakAlata saphala nahIM hogI kyoM ki aisA mAnane para bhI vaha prayoga nirdoSa nahIM ho sakatA " aGkAnAM vAmato gatiH " isa siddhAnta ko jainabhikSu aura hama acchI taraha jAnate haiM, para " trayastriMzanandaike zate " isa vAkya meM rahe hue " trayastriMzat " isa pada kA to varSoM ke aura " nandaike " isakA 'zate ' isa ke sAtha anvaya karAne vAlA nyAya siddhAnta to traistutika mata ke sAtha janamA ho to mAlUma nahIM, lekhaka jI! kyA aisA siddhAnta Apa batA sakate haiM ? yadi kahA jAya ki yaha bAta to nahIM hai to phira " trayastriMzannandaike zate " isa viSama vAkya se (1933) esA artha kahAM se pAoge ? kyoM ki ina samasta zabdoM se to 'vikrama se ( 3300 ) tetIsa vI zatAbdI meM ' aisA hI sIdhA artha nikalatA hai dUsarA nhiiN| (6-7) ina do azuddhiyoM kA samAdhAna lekhakajI isa rIti se karate haiM, " tejasA ke sthAna meM tejena likhanA " (7) svaripUn cAhiye usa ke sthAna meM so ripUna likhanA yaha dono khoTa ( bhUla ) jainabhikSujI ke saMskRta kI ajJAnatA vA zabdajJAna kI anabhijJatA kA bahUta acchA phoTo dikhAI detA hai ! ! kyoM ki -tejas zabda sakArAnta hai, tathApi pratyAntara ( yAne ) tin nizAne dhAtu se ac pratyaya karane se akArAnta bhI ho sakatA hai saripUna ke sthAna meM svaripUn likhane se

Page #42
tristutika-mata--mImAMsA / chaMda kA doSa aura azuddha prayoga kA doSa dUra ho jAtA hai isa liye yaha donoM bhUle zrIvijayarAjendrasUrijI kI nahIM hai kiMtu jaina bhikSujI ke avicAra kI hI hai !" lekhaka jI ! 'tejena' aura ' so ripUn ' ye donoM azuddhiyAM jaina bhikSujI ke avicAra kI nahIM haiN| Apa ke buDDhe dAde ke ajJAna kI haiM - rAjendrasUrijI ke ajJAna se janita haiM jinheM ThIka karane kI ceSTA se Apa khuda anajAna bana rahe haiM kyoM ki 'tejas' zabda kisI prakAra bhI akArAnta bana kara Apa ke sUrijI aura Apa kI paMDitAI nahIM sAdha sakatA, ' tij' dhAtu se ac pratyaya lagA kara ' teja ' zabda banAne kI yukti bhI Apa kI buddhi ko bakhAna rahI hai, kyoM ki ' ac' pratyaya to kartR- artha meM hotA hai isa liye isase bane hue ' teja ' zabda kA artha hogA ' tIkhA karane vAlA ' vidvattA kI ToMga toDane vAle lekhaka jI ! isa artha se kyA Apa kI abhISTa siddhi ho jAyagI ? guNavAcaka bhAvapratyayAnta ' tejas ' zabda kA matalaba dravyavAcaka kartrarthaka ' ac ' pratyayAnta ' teja ' zabda se kadApi nahIM nikala sakatA, lekhaka jI yadi ' tij' dhAtu se bhAva artha meM ' al ' yA ' ghaJ' pratyaya lagAte taba to apanI kalpanA sArthaka ho bhI jAtI. para aisA kare kauna, itanI buddhi aura vyAkaraNa-bodha lAveM kisa bAjAra meM se ! | lekhakarAja ! yadi Apa ko to itanA bodha nahIM hai paraMtu Apake gurujI bhI to paMDitAI kA dAvA karate haiM kyA unheM bhI isa bAta kA patA nahIM lagA ki ' tejas ' zabda kA artha ac pratyAnta ' teja ' zabda se kaise milegA ? athavA ThIka hai, jinhe apana hI priya hai una ko zuddhAzuddha ko parIkha ne kI zakti 23

Page #43
24 tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / kahAM se milegI ! , ' so ripUn ' isa ke sthAna meM lekhaka jI 'svaripUna ' aisA mAna ke zuddha ThaharAte haiM lekina rAjendramarijIne to 'so ripUn ' aisA likhavAyA hai, prathama to kila para kA lekha dekha leveM vahAM 'so' hai ki 'sva' pIche jhUThI yuktiyAM kareM / dUsarI yaha bhI bAta hai ki lekhakoM kI usa kuyukti se bhI ' khaMDayAmAsa svaripUn ' yaha zloka kA caraNa nirdoSa to ho hI nahIM sakatA, yoM bhI 'chandobhaMga' doSa to banA hI rahatA hai yaha eka sAmAnya niyama hai ki ___" zloke SaSThaM guru jJeyaM, sarvatra laghu paJcamam " yAnI zloka ke saba caraNoM meM pAMcavAM akSara laghu aura chaThA guru jAnanA, ' khaMDayAmAla svaripUn / yahAM para isa niyamase ulaTA bartAva hai laghu ke sthAna guru aura guruke sthAna meM laghu akSara hai, yaha to " ajamapanayata uSTapravezaH " isa nyAya vAlI bAta huI ki eka azuddhi ko dUra karate hue Apa ke pIche dUsarI do azuddhiyAM laga gaIM, lekhaka jI! kyoM aba to Apa ko nija buddhimAnI kI parIkSA huI yA nahIM ? / (8 ) isa azuddhikA pratIkAra lekhaka jI yoM karate haiM ... ___" vijayasiMhazca killA isa pada meM ATha akSara likhe hue mUlasthAna ke lekha meM mojUda hai isa ke badale meM vijesiMhazca kallA, aisA pada ( eka akSara nyUna sAta akSara ) likha chapavA ke jainaMbhikSu jI kapaTa kA kAlA kapaDA oDha ke chalAMdha kUpa meM DhIMga mArI hai|" .. lekhakoM ko jhUTha bolane kA bhI kucha Dara hai yA nahIM ? kyoM ki mUla lekha meM to 'vijesiMhazca kallA' aisA sAta akSara kA caraNa hai to lekhaka kisakI AMkhoM se dekha kahate haiM ki mUla lekha meM

Page #44
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / ATha akSara haiM ? / pAThakamahAzaya ! Apa isa bAtakA nirNaya kara sakate haiM ki chalAndha kUpa meM jainabhikSu par3A hai yA 'samucita uttaradAna patra' ke lekhaka mahAnubhAva / kyoM ki mUla lekha meM to sApha 2 sAta akSara hI likhe hue maujUda haiM aura lekhaka kahate haiM ATha haiM, yahI unake kapaTa kA namUnA kile para kA lekha dekhane se acchI taraha pragaTa ho skegaa| ( 9) isa bhUla kA sudhAra lekhaka isa prakAra karate haiM, " jIrNoddhAraH karApitaH " aisA pravRtti nimitta zuddha prayoga se hI chaMda doSa alaga ho gayA to jainabhikSu jI kArApitaH aisA zuddha prayoga likha ke kaunasA doSa kA parihAra karege so batAnA cAhatA thA ? isa liye yaha bhUla bhI jainabhikSu kI hI hai|" kauna kaha sakatA hai ki ' jIrNoddhAraH karApitaH ' yaha prayoga zuddha hai ? ' karApita ' yaha zabda lekhakoM kI buddhikI mAphika bi. lakula raddI hai, kyoM ki yaha saMskRta vyAkaraNa se kisI prakAra siddha nahIM ho sktaa| lekhakoM ne yaha to likha diyA ki 'karApita ' zabda pravRtti nimitta zuddha hai para zAbdabodhaprakriyA kA bhI kabhI adhyayana kiyA thA yA nahIM ?, mAlUma to nahIM hotA ki adhyayana kiyA ho, yA tadvipayaka grantha vAMcA ho / kAraNa ki kucha bhI zAbdabodha kI gaMdha lI hotI to 'karApita' zabda ko pravRttinimitta zuddha nahIM kahate / lekhakoM ko mAlUma hai ki pravRttinimitta kisa ciDiyA kA nAma hai ? / kyA azuddha zabda kA bhI koI pravRttinimitta ho sakatA hai ? / vAha re lekhakoM kI vidvattA ! aba to azuddhazabdo kA bhI dina vala gayA, kyoM ki unakA

Page #45
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / bhI pravRttinimitta mAnane vAle jagata meM paidA hone lage haiM, lekhakajI mahArAja ! kucha nyAyazAstra kA bhI abhyAsa karo, kina zabdoM ke kauna pravRttinimitta hote haiM isa viSaya kA jJAna prApta karo aura zaktivAdAdi granthoM kA bhI matalaba hAsila kara lo, aisA kara ke phira kisI bhI viSaya kA khaMDana maMDana karane ko tayyAra hovo, tAki Apa kI buddhi janasamAja meM hAsya kA kAraNa na hove / (10) isa azuddhi ko bhI lekhakajI likhane khodane vAloM ke zira svAra karate haiM, para lekhakajI ko socanA cAhiye ki DhuMDhaka vigairaha-jo loga pratimA ko nahIM mAnane vAle haiM-yaha kaheMge ki sUtroM meM mUrti-pUjA kA adhikAra sUtralekhakoM ne bhUla se likha diyA hai, yA ' mUrti mAnanA nahIM' aisA adhikAra sUtroM meM thA so likhane vAloM ke dRSTidoSa se raha gayA, to kyA yaha pralApayuktizUnya kathana kisI bhI buddhimAn ko mAnya ho sakegA? nahIM, aisA hargija nahIM ho sakatA, vidvAn loga yuktizUnya bAta meM aura mUrkha kI bAta meM kucha bhI pharka nahIM samajhate, ho taba to " likhane vAle aura khodane vAle kI ye bhUleM hai" yaha Apa kA kathana saMgata bhI ho sakatA yadi rAjendramUrijI ko saMskRta kA jJAna hotA aura sthAna sthAna para una kI azuddhiyAM dRSTigocara nahIM hotI, so to hai hI nahIM, baDA grantha to baDI cIja hai, para, una kA banAyA huA choTe se choTA caityavandana stuti yA prazasti lekhAdi bhI dekhate haiM to usa meM itane azuddhiyoM ke kIDe kilabilAte haiM ki bAMcane vAle kA jI ghabar3A

Page #46
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA | jAtA hai, aura tatkAla usa pustaka ko hAtha se choDa dene kI icchA ho jAtI hai, hAM una logoM ke lie isa meM apavAda samajhanA cAhiye ki jo khuda azuddhiyoM ke hI sthAna bane hue aura usI meM saMtoSa mAnane vAle haiM, kyoM ki ve to usI meM sAra mAneMge jaise viSThA ke kIDe viSThA meM / pAThaka gaNa ! merI pavitra lekhanI to eka bhI kaTu zabda likhate kAMpatI hai, tathApi mujhe jI kar3A kara ke bhI una ke lAyaka kaTu to nahIM lekina kucha khaTTI davA dikhAnI par3atI hai isa liye ajJAnarogagrasta lekhakoM ke dAMta khaTTe hoM to ve mujha para kopa na kareM kyoM ki yaha merI pravRtti unhIM ke hitake liye hai una ke cirasaMgI ajJAnavyAdhi kA pratIkAra hI merA uddiSTa kArya . hai, aura yaha unhIM kA hita sAdhana hai / phira lekhaka bayAna karate haiM ki. (6 saMskRtajJAna ke bilakula nirakSara rAjendrasUri ke nAma ke pIche unake bhakta loga kyA samaja karake - kalikAlasarvajJa, kalikAlasarvajJakalpa aise 2 vizeSaNa lagAte haiM " ityAdi (9-10 ) paMktiyoM taka apanI besamajhase apanI ajJatA pragaTa karI hai, likhane khodane vAle kI tathA apanI besamajha kI bhUla se rAjendrasUrijI ko saMskRtajJAna ke nirakSara mAnoge taba to duniyAbhara meM saikaDauM hajAro se adhika pratimAryo ke lekha meM aneka likhane khodane vAle kI bhUla dekhane meM AvegI to kyA una sarva pratiSThAkAraka AcArya udAdhyayAdi pUrvAcAryoM saMskRtajJAna ke nirakSara kahe jAyageM ? nahIM 2 kadApi nahIM kahe jAyageM / " 27 jaina bhikSu kA kahanA ki rAjendrasUrijI saMskRta jJAna ke nirakSara the- yathArtha hI hai, bhalA tumhIM soco ki jina rAjendra

Page #47
28 tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / sarijI ke mAmUlI stuti-caityavaMdanAdi meM bhI azuddhiyoM ke Dhera ke Dhera dikha paDate haiM ve nirakSara nahIM to kyA sAkSara kahe jAyaMge? hAM yaha bAta to hama bhI samajhate haiM ki jaba taka manuSya chamastha hotA hai kahIM gRDha viSaya meM bhUla bhI jAtA hai para kisa prakAra ? sAre grantha meM ekAda jagaha, isa se jyAdA ho to samajha lo ki usakI vidvattA meM gvAmI jarUra hai, to jina kA viSaya to eka mAmUlI bAtacIta hai aise caityavaMdanAdi meM bhI baDI baDI azuddhiyoM kI bharamAra nirakSaratA vinA kaise ho sakatI hai ? / pAThaka maho. daya ! lekhakoM ke parama AcArya (! ) rAjendramarijI ko-jina ke lie lekhaka mahAzaya jhUThI vakAlata karate haiM-saMskRta kA bodha kitanA thA isa viSaya ko prasphuTa karane ke liye unake banAye hue kucheka saMskRta caityavaMdana-stutyAdi ke phikare yahAM para udhRta kara dikhAtA hUM, Apa unheM gaurase par3heM, dekhiye kaisA azuddhiyoM kA khajAnA hai, ___"ahaM zrI AdinAtho jargata janapati: jJAnamUrti cidAtmA devendrAdiprapUjyo vividhasukhakaro lokakartA ca hartA / karmANAM dharmarAjo munigaNamanasi sthairyatA prAptamAnaH, so me svAmI samIzo haratu kalimalaM kora.. TesthI jinezaH // 1 // (jinaguNamaMjUSA prathama bhAga-pRSTha 2) " dvISe tra zrI maMdharai tannamAmi yugaMdharaM bAhujinaiH subAhu~H / se dhAtakI khaMDa mitaM sujAtaM zreyaprabhaM zrI vRSabhAnanaM ca // 1 // anaMtavIrya muvizAlanAthaM sUramabhaM vajradharAbhidhAnaM / candrAnanaM naumi ca puSkarAr3e zrIcandrabAhuzca bhujaMganAtham // 2 // nemiprabhaM cezvaranAmadheyaM zrIvIrasenaM jinadevakIrtim / vande mahAbhadramajItavIrya niraMtaraM saMprati vartamAnam // 3 // "

Page #48
tristutika mata-mImAMsA / (jinaguNamaJjUSA- bhAga 1 pRSTha 7 ) 66 uttaMga caGgacitraM naravararacitaM hemasUrIsaMvAre / jainAnAM bhaktikartA dharamadhuradharo rAjakaumArapAla: / tenedaM pUjanArthaM bhavabhayadamanaM kAritaM zreSThacaityaM zrImajjAloravapre pravaraguNavare vIracaityaM ca vaMde // 1 // 99 12 ha 79 18 dRSTvA bhavyalokA nijahRdi satataM harSa atyanta sAde / niMdyA je kArakA te patati tamavaMdA mokSa yAMti / teSAM pApaM ca zIghraM bhavabhavacu - gitaM nazyati kSAra siddhau // zrI0 // 2 // bho bhavyA bhadrikeyaM samakita karaNI bhASitA zrI jinendreH dhaurya tyaktvA kadAyaM kumatibhayaharaM traizaileyaM zaimIzaM saukhyaM dA~tA samagraM bhavatu bhayaharaM sUrirAjendravadyaM // zrI0 // 3 // 25 ( jinaguNamaMjUSA - bhAga 1 pRSTha 14 ) ww zrInAbheyaM dharmAdhAraM siddhaM sphAraM santAraM jJAnAgAraM dhyAnAdhAraM kIrtikAraM bhartAraM ohI kI blI varNAvAsaM bhrAMtinAzaM sanyAsaM samyak vaMde tIrthAdhIzaM pUjyaM siddhau saMvAsaM // 1 // devAvAse jyotizcakre bhaumAvAse hemAdrau tiryagloke paizAcAdau dvIpAdau vA svanyAdrau sugrAme krIDArA me tIrthasthAne caityAni vaMde tAni jJAnAnaMdaM prApyarthe 'haM sarvANI // 2 // arha - vikre sthAna cakre saMvijJAnAM samanthe zraddhAzuddhe tatve buddhe tvArye kAyeM ni 14 34 im manthe / sUrIzAnAM rAjendrANAM nityo nityaM taM vaMde sAraM sUtraM siddhiputra gaMbhIrArthaM svAnaMde || 3 || ( jinaguNamaMjUSA - bhAga 1 pRSTha 20 ) I " jayati vIra te vAguNAmRtaM harati kilbiSaM kliSTasaMcitaM / namati patkajaM pAkazAMsanaM bhajati bhaktitaH zuklapAkSikaH // 1 // jagati te'dhikA kIrtiruttamA raeNmati sA hRdi snehinAM zubhA yazasi te vapuH suMdaraM varaM 29 (

Page #49
tristutika-mata- mImAMsA / harati tAmasaM duSTamAninAm // 2 // janaka he tavaivAhamarbhako dadatu me aMtaH jnyaansNpdaaN| zubhadRzA mukhaM vIkSa mAM vibho suduHkhinaM sadA kAtarAbalaM // 4 // " (jinaguNamaMjUSA-bhAga 1 pRSTha 17) " baMdAmi vIraM manasA saMdhIraM siddhaM samRddhaM sukhaMdaM umIraM // devAdhiMdavaM surarAjavaMdyaM bhavAbdhiyAnaM zivadaM aniMdyaM // 1 // cauvIsa kevaladharA varatIrthanAthA AgAmi kaoNli gatakAli tathA ca siddhA vartanti viMzati videhavizAlapanthAH caityAni tIrthasama saMti namAmi tessaaN| sUtraM gacchendrasUtaM zubha arthayutaM sAdhuvagaiMgRhItaM jIvA jIvAdi tatvaiH caturataragamairdurlabhaM yasya taMtra baudhAdInAM nirIzaM zivasurasukhadaM zuddhavairAgya dIpaM bhaktyA vande dhanamuni jagameM sUtra AjJA calanti // 3 // " (jinaguNamaMjUSA-bhAga 1 pRSTha 29) / " aMgovAMgaM sucaMgaM jinavarakathitaM gaccharAjaiH suguMpha paMcAMgI raMga yuktaM sakalanayamayaM cAranikSepapuppha suddhAcAraM sugaMdhaM munihRdayadharaM IdRzaM sUtrahAraM siddhaM vaMde pramodaprasamayarucinA sarvavizvasya sAraM // 3 // " (jinaguNamaMjUSA-bhAga 1 pRSTha 35 ) pAThaka mahodaya ! rAjendramUrijI kI alaukika vidvattA ! Apa samajha sakate haiM ki jainabhikSu ne rAjendrasarijI ko saMskRta ke nirakSara likhA so jhUTha nahIM hai, Upara likhe hue saMskRta zloka vigairaha traistutikoM ke kAlakAlasarvajJa rAjendrasarijI kI kRti ke haiM, zlokoM ke Upara likhe hue aMka kyA haiM samajhe ? ve haiM azuddhiyoM ke naMbara / vAhare aMdhabhakto ! tumane eka atisAdhAraNa manuSya ko-jisa ke banAe hue Upara likhita mAtra ginatI ke

Page #50
tristutika--mata- mImAMsA / zlokoM meM 100 eka sau azuddhiyAM pratyakSa dikha rahI haiM-kalikAlasarvajJakalpa, kalikAlasiddhAntaziromaNi vigairaha aneka upAdhiyoM kI zilAoM se kyoM davA diyA ? isa bhAra se usakA hADapiMjara cUrA ho jAyagA isa bAta ko socane vAlA tumhAre meM koI bhI vidyamAna nahIM hai ? aphasosa ! isI aMdhazraddhA aura mUrkhatA ne manuSya ko unnati ke mArga se bhraSTa kara diyA hai, jaba koi tarakkI ke mArga meM paira rakhatA hai to usa ke aMdhazraddhAlu bhakta jhUThI vAha vAha se use isa prakAra bar3AI ke zikhara para car3hA dete haiM ki phira vaha tarakkI ke zikhara para pahuMcane kI jarUrata hI nahIM smjhtaa| rAjendramUrijI eka sAmAnya AdamI the unheM vyAkaraNa kA jJAna bahuta hI kama thA, sAhityaviSayaka grantha to unhoM ne bAMcA hI zAyada hI hogA, nyAya kA jJAna to una se kozoM dUra thA, jaina siddhAnta kA bhI unheM prazasta bodha nahIM thA, ina saba bAtoM kA patA una kI azuddhiyoM se bharI huI kRtiyoM se acchI taraha lagajAtA hai, maiMne Upara jo azuddhipUrNa rAjendramUrijI ke caitya vaMdana-stutyAdi likhe haiM vahI una ke paramasaMskRta graMtha haiM jo jo rAjendramUrijI ke banAye hue stotrAdi haiM basa isI namUne ke samajhiye balke isa se bhI jyAdA azuddha ! / Aja taka ina kA racA huA eka bhI stotra-caityavandana aisA nahIM dekhA ki jisa meM 8-10 azuddhiyAM na hoM, jainabhikSu ' kA-'eka sAdhAraNa lekha likhane meM jisane itanI bhUleM kI haiM ve kyA kabhI koSa banAne kI yogyatA rakha sakate haiM ' yaha likhanA akSarazaH satya hai, jina meM do cAra zloka banAne kI bhI pUrI yogyatA nahIM pAI jAtI

Page #51
32 tristutika--mata--mImAMsA / ve kisa yogyatA se koSa banA sakate haiN| yahAM para pAThakagaNa ko yaha zaMkA ho sakatI hai ki jaba rAjendrasarijI kI vidvattA kA yaha hAla hai to vaha koSa kisane banAyA jo 'abhidhAnarAjendra ' isa nAma se bolA jAtA hai ? to uttara yaha hai ki vaha koSa rAjendrasarijI ne apane nAma se brAhmaNoM ke dvArA tayyAra karavAyA hai - unhoM ne khuda ne nahIM bnaayaa| yaha bAta kalpita nahIM kI saMvat 1933 kI sAla se kopa kI racanA hone lagI thii| kArya brAhmaNoM ke hAthoM se hotA jAtA thaa| banAne vAle paMDitoM kI tanakhvAha aura pustakoM Adi kA prabandha rAjendramurijI karAyA karate the, yaha bAta unake ghara ke bheda vizvasta AdamI ke muMha kI hai / dUsarA yaha bhI prAmANika kAraNa he ki--jaba hamArA vihAra kAThiyAvADa se mAravAr3a kI tarpha huA-rAjakoTa kI tarpha se hamArA AnA vaDhavAna kempa huA; vahAM para kharataragacchIya muni zrIkRpAcandra jI se mulAkAta huI, do roja vahAM para ThaharanA bhI huA, daramiyAna mere aura mahArAja zrIkRpAcandrajI ke paraspara traistutiko ke bAre meM isa prakAra vArtAlApa huA. zrIkRpAcaMdrajI-' abhidhAna rAjendra ' kopa chapa gayA ? maiM----.' sunA gayA hai ki dvitIya bhAga chapa kara tayyAra ho gayA hai| zrIkR0---' isa meM bahuta hI kharca huA hai / mai- hAM huA to aisA hI hai, para Apa ko isa bAta kI jAMca kaise huI ?' zrIkR0-'saMvat 1958 kI sAla meM gAMva siyANe meM rAje ndramUrijI se hamArA milanA huA taba maiM ne una se

Page #52
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / pUchA ki 'koSa kahAM taka banA hai ? ' uttara milA ki 'pa-varga' calatA hai / phira pUchA ki ' banAne kA kAma kahAM calatA hai ' tava rAjendrasUrine kahA ' kAzIjI meM' meM-Apa bhI rAjendrasUrijI kI gRha bAteM to ThIka jAnate haiM jaise ki una kA koI ghara kA manuSya jAne / zrI kR0-hama se rAjendrasUri koI bhI bAta chipAte nahIM the| __ isa prakAra jaba zrIkRpAcandrajI ke mukha se sunA to mujhe isa hakIkata para pUrA vizvAsa baiTha gayA ki abhidhAnarAjendrakoSa brAhmaNoM se hI rAjendrasUrijI ne tayyAra karAyA hai| khAsa rAjendrasarijI ke bhakta zrAvakoM ke mukha se kaI daphe sunA hai ki isa koSa ke nimitta ru. 200000 ) do lAkha ke karIba kharca ho cuke haiM to aba vicAra karane yogya sthala hai ki itane rupaye gaye kahAM ? khAsa nirNayasAgarayaMtrAlaya sarIkhe chApAkhAne meM pAMca sau nakala chapavAne se ru. 1) meM 4 cAra hajAra ke lagabhaga zloka chapate haiM, isa hisAba se ru. 25000) meM 100000 zlokapramANa grantha kI 500 kApiyAM to nirNayasAgara presa meM chapa saktI haiM to dUsare sAmAnyayaMtrAlaya meM ru. 15000 ) meM usa grantha kI pAMca sau nakala chape isa meM zaMkA hI kyA hai ? ina saba saMyogoM se sApha sApha yaha siddha hai ki ye maba rupaye isa kopa ke banAne aura sudhArane vAle paNDitoM ke pagAra meM kharca hue haiM chapavAne meM to inakA chaThA yA AThavA hissA hI kAphI hai| rAjendramUrijI ke zraddhAndha bhakta loga-jina ke Age 'kAlA akSara bheMsa barAbara' hai-isa koSa ke bhAgoM kI bAhya sthUlatA ko dekha

Page #53
34 tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / kara phUle nahIM samAte aura bolane lagate haiM ki 'o ho ! rAjendaramUrijI bApajI kataro moTo garaMtha baNAyo hai ' para una becAre bhole bhAle mAravADiyoM kA isameM kyA doSa ! una ko to upadeza hI isa prakAra kA milatA hai ki ' rAjendrasUrijI ne paiMtAlIsa AgamoM kI paMcAMgI kA sAra lekara rAjendrakoSa banAyA hai' isa bAtako ve becAre ajJAnI gRhastha loga kyA jAne ki 45 AgamoM kI paMcAMgI kA to nahIM paraMtu 'vAcaspatya-vRdabhidhAna' jo kalakattA ke vaiSNava paMDita 'tArAnAtha tarkavAcaspati' kA banAyA huA hai usa kA sAra lekara isa ko brAhmaNa paMDitoM ne banAyA hai| khaira isa viSayakA prakAza aba bahuta ho gayA eka sAtha sArI pola kholane se lekhakoM ko sahya na hogI, phira Age kisI prakaraNa meM avaziSTa bhAga kI bhI carcA kI jaaygii| Age lekhakajI ne hIravijayamUrijI kA likhA huA paMnyAsapadayogyatAviSayaka paTTA likha ke yati kalyANavijayajI aura pramodavijayajI ko mUri banAne kI ceSTA kI hai, lekhakoM se merA yaha prazna hai ki Apake rAjendramUrijI ke dAdAgurujI aura gurujI ne hIravijayasUrijI ke paTTe meM likhe mujiba abhyAsa kiyA thA ? aura SaNmAsika bhagavatI kA yogodvahana karake gaNi pada prApta kiyA thA ?, yA "sacitta ( kaccA ) ami jala aMganA ( strI) aura navavidha parigraha ina ko indriya sukhAdika ke hetu AcArya apane aMgasparza na kareM apanI nezrA ( Azraya ) meM na rakhe taba to yaha sUripada bhAvAcArya kA rakSaka hai, aura pUrvokta [ 4 ] cIjoM se zithila (paribhogI) hoya, ve dravyAcArya nAmAcArya kahalAte haiM. arthAt ve ( sUrimaMtra ) sUripada ke yogya nahIM haiM "

Page #54
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / isa Apa ke hI lekha meM kahI huI 4 cIjoM ke ve tyAgI the ki bhogI ? | Apa hI ke isa kathanAnusAra ve mUripada ke yogya siddha ho sakate haiM yA nahIM isa kA pramANa ke sAtha uttara deveM / tAtparya yaha hai ki kalyANavijayajI aura pramodavijayajI sAmAnya yati the, ve na to vidyAvAn the aura na kriyAvAn , una ke vahI hAla the jo Aja kala ke dravyopAsaka yatiyoM ke haiM, hAM yaha una meM zAyada vizeSatA hogI ki rupayoM ke lie vivAhAdi sAMsArika utsavoM meM ve rote na phirate hoMge, paraMtu una meM sAdhuvRtti thI yaha to koI bhI asatyabhIru nahIM kahegA aura vicAra zIla maanegaa| sAdhuvRtti kahAM ?, sAdhuoM meM to mUla aura uttara guNoM kI sattA cAhiye, kadAcit kAraNavaza kisI uttaraguNa meM mavalanA ho jAya to bhI usa kI prAyazcittAdidvArA jaldI zuddhi kara lI jAtI hai, aura usa ke mUlaguNa to sarvadA akhaMDita hI rahate haiM / koI bhI bhavabhIru aisA nitAnta jhUTha bolane kA sAhasa nahIM karegA ki yati kalyANavijayajI aura pramodavijayajI meM isa mujaba sAdhupana ke guNa the| ve trasa thAvara ke prANAtipAta ko TAlate nahIM the, jhUTha nahIM bolane kA tanika bhI vrata ve pAla nahIM sakate the, adattAdAna kI virati se ve kozoM dUra vasate the, maithunaviramaNa kA bhI burA hAla thA, hAM, yaha bAta mAna sakate haiM ki jisa prakAra gRhasthoM kA niHzaMka vyavahAra hotA hai usa mujaba ina ke yahAM na hotA hogA, aura parigraha kI to bAta hI kyA; isa se to una ke saba kAma hI siddha hote the, isa kA tyAga to unheM prANatyAga tulya thaa|

Page #55
tristutika- mata-mImAMsA | I lekhaka jI ! yahI yatijI Apa ke rAjendrasUrijI ke dAdA guru aura guru the na ? | inhIM ko Apa AcArya banAne kI ceSTA karate haiM na 1 / acchA ! para yaha to kaho ki tristutikA mata nikAlane ke bAda Apa ke rAjendrasUrijI kA nAmoccAraNa bhI pramodavijayajI ne apane mukha se kiyA thA ? / ve to yoM kahate the ki ' merA ziSya kuziSya ho gayA ' isa mujaba kahane meM kAraNa do the, eka to yaha ki ve sAdhupana nahIM pAla sakate the to bhI sanAtanajinamArga ke pUre pakSapAtI the| dUsarA yaha ki mohanavijaya nAma kA una kA ziSya jo bacapana se hI pAla kara moTA kiyA thA use phusalA kara ratnavijayajI (rAjendrasUrijI ) ne le liyA thA / basa inhIM do kAraNoM se pramodavijayajI Apa ke rAjendrasUrijI se pUrI ghRNA karate the, yahAM taka ki una kA nAma taka apane muMha nahIM lAte the| itanA hone para bhI kyA kAraNa ki lekhaka aura ina ke anuyAyI loga pramodavijayajI ko jabaradastI se AcArya banA rahe haiM ? | 36 lekhakoM ne apane rAjendrasUrijI kI pATa paraMparA ke liye jo vistAra sahita parAla likhA hai vaha kucha bhI mahattvapUrNa nahIM haiM, usa meM lekhakoM ke buDDhe guru kI gappagItA kA hI mAtra zravaNa hai, jaise " " (paM) amukavijayajI gaNI, amukastaka yAne paM. pramodavijaya gaNI kalyANastaka aisA ( 1 ) ratnAdhika kA bolanA likhanA hotA hai " pAThaka mahodaya ! dekha lIjiye gappagItA kA namUnA 'staka' ityAdi azuddha zabda hI ina ke isa kathana ko gamagItA siddha karate haiM yA nahIM ? |

Page #56
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / phira lekhaka jI apanI jhUThI karatUta dikhAte haiM ki " ityAdi unakI ( pramodavijayajI kI ) yati ( sAdhu ) kI pravartanA hamAre vartamAnAcArya 'zrIvijayadhanacaMdra sUrijI' ne AMkhoM se dekhI huI saba zvetAmbara saMgha meM prasiddha hai. tina ke pATapara ' iga, bI, tI, guruparaMpara kusIle ' arthAt zrImahAnizIthokta siddhAnta vacana se eka do pATa paraMparA kA kuzIla ko tyAga ke kriyoddhAra rUpa ' zrI jina zAsana ke prabhAva ke karane vAle yaha prabhAvakAcArya zrIvijayarAjendrasUrijI huye " maiMne pahale hI yaha kaha diyA hai ki pramodavijayajI kI pravartanA sAdhupana kI nahIM thI kiMtu patita thI, maiM kyA tuma khuda eka do pATa paraMparA kA kuzIla ko tyAga ke' ina vacanoM se siddha karate ho ki 'yati kalyANavijayajI aura pramodavijayajI meM kuzIlapana thA isa liye usako tyAga ke rAjendramUrijI ne kriyoddhAra kiyA, ' isa prakAra jina ko lekhaka kuzIla mAnate haiM unhIM ko rAjendramUrijI ke pATa paraMparA ke AcArya mAnanA ? kuzIla ko AcArya ThaharAne vAle khuda hI kuzIla kyoM na mAne jAya~ ? / lekhaka jI ! kuzIliyoM ko AcArya mAnane vAle Apa logoM kI buddhi kisa pAtAla meM calI gaI hai ? kucha to soco ! jina ko apane mukha se kuzIladhArI kaha rahe ho unhIM ko AcArya kahate hue tuma ko asatya kA Dara to nahIM, para lajjA bhI nhiiN| aphasosa ! yahI asatyapoSaNa-yahI aMdhazraddhA jainoM ko unnati ke zikhara se girA rahI hai / pAThakagaNa ! pramodavijayajI kI kyA sthiti thI ve sAdhu

Page #57
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / tA se kitane dUra the isa bAta kA nirNaya to Apa loga aba bhI Ahora ke vRddha manuSyoM ko jo una ke samakAlaka yA unakI pravatainA ke dekhane vAle haiM pUcha ke kara sakte haiM, para lekhakajI ! Apa ke vartamAnAcArya jI kI dekhI bhAlI bAtako to koI bhI buddhimAn manuSya nahIM mAnegA, kyoM ki Apa ke vartamAnAcArya jI kI karatUtoM se saba koI vAkipha hai| merI samajha meM to aise jAlI AdamI jagata meM virale hI hoNge| lekhaka jI! ve hI Apa ke vartamAnAcArya jI hai na ? jinhoM ne rAjendramUrijI ke gurupada ko mana bacana aura kAyA se tyAga diyA thaa| priyapAThaka ! dekha lIjiye lekhakoM ke vartamAnAcArya jI kI karatUta, aba jo rAjendramUrijI aura una ke guru-yati pramodavijayajI ko AcArya siddhakarane kI koziza kara rahe haiM unhIM dhanavijayajI ne rAjendramUrijI ke sAtha kisa prakAra kA vyavahAra kiyA thaa| yaha bAta bhI jAnane yogya hai, ata eva isa viSaya ko unhIM ke pustakoM ke kucha phikaroM se vizada kiyA cAhatA hUM, AzA hai mere isa vicAra ko Apa asthAna na gineMge / "jaba taka zrIvijayarAjendrasUrijI ke aura mere jaina sUtro kI zraddhA prarUpaNA meM bheda nahI thA taba taka to mere dIkSopasaMpad ( kriyoddhAra ) guru zira ke mugaTa samAna the aura aba sUryodaya likhane likhAne vAle ke lekha dekhate zruta sthivira ( pUrvadhara ) tathA bahuzruto ke kiye jainasUtro kI utthApaka buddhi rAjendrasUrijI kI jJAta hone se jaba taka yaha utthApaka buddhi rahegI taba taka trividha mana vacana kAyA se tinkA guru pada ko vosarAtA hUM aura vidyamAna jaMgamajugapradhAna zrI vijayasUrirAjendra jI mahArAja kA guru pada ko khikAra karatA hUM" .

Page #58
tristutika--mata-mImAMsA / (dhanavi0 kRta-devavaMdananirNayapatAkA-prastAva 4 pRSTha 39) " apane manamAnI kalpanA kI samAcArI karane vAle ekAMta haThagrAhI sUrijI ko +++" " mUrijI to apanI manakalpanA kA haTha ke jora se ( sammadiTThI devA ) kA ekAMta nirvadya pATha ko ekAMta sAvadya ThaharA ke isa pATha kA utthApana kara ke ora cothI thui kA sarvathA utthApana kara pUrvadhara tathA bahuzruto kI paMcAMgI Adya le aneka granthoM kA pATha utthApana karate aneka pUrvadhara tathA pUrvabahuzruto kI AzAtanA karane meM rakta ho rahe hai " (dhanavi0 deva ni0 50 prastAva 4 pRSTha 5-6) " vaMditA sUtra kA pATha utthApana kara yaha bhava para bhava bigADa kara vRthA saMsAra vadhArane kI kyoM umeda rakhate ho ? " (dhanavi0 deva0 ni0 50 prastAva 4 pRSTa 15) pAThakavRMda ! Upara diye hue phikare lekhakoM ke vartamAnAcArya dhanavijayajI racita 'vedavaMdananirNayapatAkA' nAmavAlI kitAba ke haiM, dhanavijayajI kA apane guru rAjendramUrijI ke sAtha kaisA vartAva thA isa bAta kA patA ina phikaroM se acchI taraha laga jAtA hai, isa vakta rAjendramUrijI ke paTadhara hone kA dAvA karane vAle dhanavijayajI ne pahale rAjendramUrijI ke Upara kaise kaThora vAgbANa barasAye haiM isa gUDha bAta ko prakAzita karane ke liye uparyukta phikare dIpaka tulya haiM, vaistutikoM ke bhItara hI kitanI phATaphUTa hai isa bAta ke bhI pUrvalikhita phikare sAkSI samajhane caahiye| pAThaka ! tInathuI vAloM ke ghara meM kitanI pola hai yaha bAta aba to ApakI samajha meM A hI gaI hogI, ina logoM kI yaha

Page #59
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / sthiti to pahale kI hai para Aja kala kI dazA to isa se bhI burI hAlata meM hai, vartamAna meM rAjendramUrijI kA jo kSudraparivAra hai usa ke bhI do dala ho cuke haiM. kriyAviSayaka bhI bakheDA kama nahIM hai, gaccha bAhara karane karAne kI bhI paraspara meM taiyAriyAM ho rahI haiM, ina saba kA kAraNa aura kucha nahIM sirpha bhItarI pola hai, kitaneka dhanavijayajI kA kathana zAstrapramANayukta mAnate haiM taba dUsare rAjendramUrijI kI kriyA ko hI sarvajJabhASita samajhate haiM, isa kA natIjA yaha AyA ki akAla hI traistutikoM ke ghara meM yAdavA sthalI maca gii| isa mata vAloM kI thoDe hI kAla meM yaha dazA kyoM huI ? isa bAta ko samajhanA aba kucha kaThina nahIM hai, Apa soca sakate hai ki nApAyedAra imArata jyAdA vakta taka nahIM Tika sakatI, jisa mata kA janma hI zAstranirapekSa-rAga dveSa se huA hai, jisa ke janmadAtA rAjendramUrijI Apa hI avyavasthita citta the usa nirbala mata ko grahaNa karane vAloM kI yaha dazA hove isa meM Azcarya hI kyA hai ? / Apa nizcaya samajhiye ki durdazA to kyA thoDe hI varSoM meM isa kI parisamApti kI kathA bhI zAyada Apa suna leNge| lekhaka jI ! merA yaha kathana yadi asatya ho to mujhe kaha dIjiye, Apa ke vartamAnAcAryajI kI kapaTa-paTutA, prapaMca jAla aura asatya vAditA mere kahane se bhI do kalA adhika hai yA nahIM ? / isa kA uttara 'hAM' sivA kisI akSara se Apa nahIM de skoge| jaba Apa ke vartamAnAcArya jI kI bhI yaha dazA hai to aisA kauna hRdayazUnya hogA jo una ke kathana para vizvAsa dharegA!;

Page #60
tristutika mata-mImAMsA / aura java pramodavijayajI ko hI pATa kI prApti nahIM huI to una ke ziSya rAjendrasUrijI ko usa kI AzA hI kyoM rakhanI caahiye| phira lekhaka jI kA bayAna hai ki... " jainabhikSujI kI guru paraMparA meM to eliyAmbara, kAthiyAmbara, pItAmbara, kuliMgavastra dhAraNa karane kI AjJA na to koI AcArya ne dI hai ! aura na koI liMga (vastra ) badalAnevAlA Aja dinoM taka AcArya huye haiM ! to bhI vartamAna meM AcArya gurU ke diye binA apane 2 rAgI gRhasthoM ke pAsa AcArya ( sari ) pada ghara ghara meM dhAraNa kara rahe haiM to yaha kalpita pATa paraMparA se judI ! jaina zAstroM ke nyAya se aura kalpita pATa paraMparA kaunasI kahI jAyagI! apitu ! yaha pItAmbara ( pIlAvastra ) dhAriyoM kI hI kalpita paraMparA kahI jAyagI. " lekhakoM ne kaba dekhA ki jainabhikSujI kI guru paraMparA meM eliyAmbara yA kuliMga vastra dhAraNa kiye jAte haiM ? / yadi katthe Adi padArtho se vivarNa kiye hue vastroM ko bhI lekhaka kuliMga samajhate hoM to yaha Apa gaMbhIra bhUla karate haiM, nizIthacUrNi ke pramANa ke sAtha pahale siddha kara cukA hUM ki naye vastroM kA varNa badalanA zAstra-khilApha nahIM balke zAstrapratipAdita-vidhiviSaya hai, lekhakamahodaya usa sthala ko dhyAna ke sAtha phira eka daphe par3ha leveM / lekhakoM kA yaha kathana bhI asatya hai ki na koI liMga ( vastra ) badalAne vAlA Aja dinoM taka AcArya huye hai ' jaba mUtrakAroM ne yaha siddhAnta kara diyA ki * zvetamAnopeta-jINaprAya vastra sAdhuoM kA akAraNika veza hai tathApi isa prakAra ke vakhoM kI aprApti meM naye vastroM kA varNa baDhala ke unheM upabhoga

Page #61
42 tristutika-mata--mImAMsA / mmmmmmmmmmm.......... meM lAnA bhI dUSita nahIM, to lekhakoM kI kyA zakti jo isa ko apramANa kara deN| 'AcArya gurU ke diye vinA apane 2 rAgI gRhasthoM ke pAsa AcArya ( sUri ) pada ghara ghara meM dhAraNa kara rahe haiN|' yaha likhanA to lekhakajI ke AcAryoM ke hI zira savAra hotA hai, kyoM ki Apa ke guru aura dAdAguru isI prakAra AcArya bane the, athavA isa se bhI hInarIti se, kyoM ki 'rAjendrasarijI' tapAgaccha ke zrIpUjya zrIdharaNendrasUrijI' kI capeTA devI ke prasAda se svayaM AcArya ( zrIpUjya ) bana baiThe the, kisI bhI AcArya guru ne unheM AcAryapada nahIM diyA, aura dhanavijayajI bhI apane hI mukhase' dhanacaMdramUri' bana baiThe / kyoM ki ina ke guru ne to kabhI se inheM apane gaccha se dUra kara diyA thA to AcAryapada kI to bAta hI kahAM ? | saM. 1962 meM jaba rAjendramUrijI kA dehAMta ho gayA to 1964 kI sAla meM Apane mAlave meM jA kara apane rAgI gRhasthoM se AcAryapada dhAraNa kiyA / lekhaka jI! ' apane rAgI gRhasthoM ke pAsa AcAryapada ghara ghara meM dhAraNa kara rahe haiM ' yaha Apa kA kathana Apa ke hI gurvAdikoMne caritArtha kiyA yA nahIM ? / phira lekhaka likhate haiM ki .... "jainabhikSujI ko tathA jainabhikSujI ke pakSiyoM ko cAhiye ki apane aMdha guru kI aMdha zraddhA tathA kalpita paramparA choDa ke abhI vartamAna meM deza, kAla, anumAna pramANe saMyama ( cAritra ) ko dhAraNe vAle koi zvetAmbarAcArya bhAvAcarya jI kA guru pada dhAraNa kara pIche vaDI dIkSA yoga vahanAdi kriyA karake AcArya upAdhyAya pravartaka sthavira ratnAdhika

Page #62
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / pada viyAM dhAraNa kara zvetAmbarAcArya guru ke hukuma meM vartA taba hI jaina zAstroM ke nyAya se sAdhu Adi AcArya sUripada dhArI zrIvIraparaMparA ke kahe jAogeM nahIM to manomatikalpita pATa paraMparA ke hI kahe jAogeM isa meM zakka nahIM' yahAM para jainabhikSu lekhakoM ko yoM kahegA ki isa mujaba tuma ko hI vartanA jarUrI hai, kyoM ki jainabhikSu ke to guru aMdhe nahIM haiM aura na usa kI paraMparA kalpita hai, aMdha-bandha aura kalpita-balpita saba Apa ke hI supurda hai ina ko sthAna dene kI kIrti Apa hI ko priya ho / para merI rAya hai ki Apa ko bhI ina ko Azraya denA sabhyatAviruddha hai isa liye Apa ko cAhiye ki bhAvAndhyavyApta apane guru kI aMdha zraddhA aura kalita paraMparA ke poche jaldI jalAMjali de kara dravya kSetra kAla aura bhAva para lakSya rakha kara ke calane vAle kisI jainAcArya yA muni kI zaraNa meM jAo ! tA ki Apa kI zraddhAnaukA bhavasamudra meM DUbatI aTaka jAya aura sakuzala Apa ko pAra kara de| phira lekhaka mahAzaya apanI akla daur3Ate haiM ki " bhAvastava jo zrI mahAnizIthokta sAdhuoM ko caritrAnuSTAna aura zrAvakoM ko sAmAyika sahita pauSadha pratikramaNa meM niraMtara tIna thuI ke devavaMdana tathA (dravyastava ) jo sAdhuoM ko pratiSThA, zAMtisnAtrAdika ke avasara vAsakSapAdika aura zrAvakoM ko pratiSThA zAMtisnAtra aura niraMtara nivRttigAminI pUjA jo aSTa dravyAdika ke avasara zrI vyavahArabhASyAdi, jainapaMcAMgI sUtrokta tIna thuI kI tathA cAra thuI kI devavaMdanA zrI tIrthaMkaragaNadharAdika se Aja

Page #63
44 tristutika- mata-mImAsA / / taka calI AtI hai tisameM saMvat ( 1250 ) meM zrI saudharmasiddhAntikagaccha meM se Agamika matotpatti ke karane vAle zrI zIlabhadrAcArya huye tinhoM ne sarvathA cothI thuI utthApa ke ekAnta tIna thuI ke devavaMdana sthApana kiye to ' tIna thuI kA eka nayA hI zAstraviruddha majahaba rAjendrisUri jI ne hI nikAlA hai yaha lekha chapavA ke jenabhikSujI ne dahI ke badale kapAsa bhakSaNa kiyA hai ! kyoM ki rAjendrasUrijI to sAmAyika sahita pratikramaNa posahAdika bhAvapUjA jo bhAvastava cAritrAnuSThAna meM tIna thuI ke devavaMdana karate karAte the aura dravya pUjA jo (dravyastava davyAnuSThAna meM cAra thuI ke devavaMdana karate karAte the taise hI una ke pUrvAcArya zrI pramodasUrijI tathA zrIkalyANasUrijI pramukhoM bhI tIna thuI lathA cAra thui ke donoM devavaMdana apane 2 avasara pe karate karAte the" meM nahIM samajha sakatA ki tInathuI vAloM ko jhUTha para itanI prIti kyoM hai ? ve bAta bAta meM aisI DIMga kyoM mAra dete hai ? kyA isI meM unhoM ne dharma mAna liyA hai ? kyA ve yahI samajhate haiM ki isa prakAra asatya kA Azraya lene hI se hamArA mata calegA ? , nahIM, yaha kadApi nahIM ho sakatA, jalapoSya vRkSa kabhI agni se bhI navapallava ho sakatA hai ? jisa kA mUla hI satya hai vaha dhAmika mata asatya se kaba Tika sakatA hai ! ulaTA usa se to usakA satyAnAza ho jAyagA / lekhaka jI ne mahAnizItha kA nAma to likha diyA para isa se yaha siddha kara sakate haiM ki ' sAmAyikasahita pauSadha pratikramaNa meM niraMtara tIna thuI ke deva vaMdana karanA ? ' kyoM ki usa meM to caityavaMdana ke sUtroM ke upadhAna kA vidhi likhA hai, stuti kA nAma mAtra bhI nhiiN|

Page #64
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / lekhaka jagaha jagaha ullekha karate haiM ki sAmAyikasahita pauSadha pratikramaNa meM tIna thuI kA devavaMdana karanA' ___maiM pUchatA hU~ ki kyA sAmAyika rahita bhI pauSadha pratikramaNa hotA hai ki jisa meM devavaMdanakriyA kI jarUrata rahatI ho ? le. khakajI kisI bhI zAstra kA yaha pramANa de sakate haiM ki 'sAmAyika vinA bhI caturvidhapauSadha yA SaDAvazyakAtmaka pratikramaNa ho sakatA hai ? ' munane haiM, lekhakajI ke guru-dhanavijaya jI bhI kaI logoM ke Age isI prakAra se utsUtra prarUpaNA karate haiM ki 'sAmAyika vinA bhI pratikramaNa ho sakatA hai, ' baDA Azcarya hai ki unhoM ne yaha siddhAnta lAyA kahAM se ?, zAstra to sApha sApha kahatA hai ki sAmAyika vinA pratikramaNa ho hI nahIM sakatA. dekhiye saMdehadolAvali kI gAthA 41 vIM kI TIkA kA . " sAmAyikAvinAbhAvitvAtpratikramaNasya pratikramaNe kathite sAmAyikamAgatameva / " - yaha pATa, isa kA artha yaha hai ki 'sAmAyika vinA pratikramaNa nahIM ho sakatA, isa liye pratikramaNa ke kahane se sAmAyika A hI gayA' ___ tapAgacchaikamaMDana AcArya zrImaddevendramUrijI' kRta zrAddha pratikramaNavRtti ( vandAruvRtti ) meM bhI aise hI kahA hai, yathA " pratikramaNaM ca kRtasamAyikenaiva kartavyam" artha, sAmAyika le ke hI pratikramaNa karanA cAhiye / java zAstra isa prakAra pukAra rahe haiM ki sAmAyika vinA pra

Page #65
tristutika-mata--mImAMsA / tikramaNa nahIM ho sakatA to phira lekhakoM aura una ke guru jI kA 'sAmAyika vinA bhI pratikramaNa hotA hai / yaha kathana una ke aMdhabhaktoM ke sivA aura kauna mAnegA ? / tInathuI matAvalaMbI sAdhu aura una ke anuyAyI loga bhole logoM ko yoM samajhA dete haiM ki 'cothI thuI to pUjA pratiSThAdi viziSTa kAraNa ke liye hai, sAmAyika pratikramaNa vigairaha meM to tIna thuI karanA hI zAstroM meM kahA hai' bhole logoM ko dhokA dene vAle una traistutika mahAzayoM ko maiM pratijJA ke sAtha kahatA hUM ki 'cothI stuti pUjA pratiSThA meM hI kahane ke liye hai pratikamaNa meM nahIM.. aisA kisI bhI caturthastutipratipAdaka zAstra kA pramANa tumhAre pAsa ho to peza karo maiM usa mujaba vatane ko tayyAra hU~ agara tuma aisA pramANa nahIM batA sakate ho to isa bAta ko kabUla karo ki 'yadi maiM zAstra kA aisA pramANa batA dUM ki samAyika pratikramaNa meM bhI cothI thuI kahanI cAhiye to tumako cothI thuI karanI paDegI' yadi ina do pakSoM meM se eka bhI tuma nahIM svIkAroge to maiM aura saba pAThaka mahAzaya yahI samajheMge ki tumhAre isa navIna mata meM Dhola ke jitanI pola hai| kaI ajJAna ke upAsaka traistutika to yoM bhI DIMga mAra dete haiM ki

Page #66
tristutika mata--mImAMsA / 'cothI thuI karanA kAlakAcArya jI ne zurU kiyA' / merA una bhole bhAle logoM se yaha prazna hai ki Apa ko aisA svama AyA ki 'cothI thuI kAlakAcArya jI ne kI ? yA kisI nirakSara kI hAM meM hAM karate ho ? tumhArI akla ghara para hai yA nahIM ? jarA aMdhakAra se dUra ho ke zAstra ke panne kholo ! kAlakAcArya jI ne cotha kI saMvatsarI kI hai yA cothI thuI ? / vAha re ajJAna ! terA prabhAva bhI apUrva hai vinA hI takalIpha manuSya ko andhA banAne vAlI terI isa lIlA kI kyA tArIpha kI jAya / lekhaka kahate haiM ki 'saMvat (1250 ) meM zrIsaudharmasiddhAMtika gaccha meM se Agamikamatotpattike karane vAle zrI zIlabhadrAcArya huye tinhoMne sarvathA cothI thuI utthApake ekAMta tIna thuI ke devavaMdana sthApana kiye' sarAsara asatya hai, Agamikamatotpatti ke karane vAle AcArya kA nAma ' zIlabhadra' nahIM thA kiMtu 'zIlagaNa' thA, aura una ne saudharmasiddhAntika gaccha meM se yaha mata nahIM nikAlA, ve pahale paurNamIyaka gaccha meM the bAda usa meM se nikala kara aMcala gaccha meM Aye aura pIche Agamika mata nikAlA ( dekho pravacana parIkSA patra 306 ). ___AgamikoM ne rAjendramarijI kI taraha tIna thuI kA mata nahIM nikAlA, una kA mAtra yaha kathana thA ki zrutadevatAdi ke pAsa mokSa kI prArthanA nahIM karanI cAhiye,

Page #67
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / ve yoM nahIM kahate the ki samyagdRSTideva kI stuti karane te samyaktva malIna ho jAtA hai yA sAmAyikAdika meM caturthastuti karane se Azraya laga jAtA hai| lekhakoM kI kuyukti yaha hai ki--- " sAvajaM jogaM paJcakakhAmi-kara ke baiThane ke bAda caturtha stuti karane meM sAvadha lagane se pUrvapratipanna vrata meM doSa ( aticAra ) lagatA hai" . isa kA uttara yaha hai ki caturtha stuti meM lekhakajI kisa bAta kA doSa mAnate haiM ? kyA usa meM pApopadeza hai yA dhanaputrAdi paudagalika sukha kI prArthanA kI jAtI hai ? kahA jAya ki yaha to kucha nahIM, to phira yathAsthitaguNavarNanAtmaka stuti meM doSa kisa bAta kA samajhate haiM ? yadi kaheMge ki paMcama-SaSTha guNasthAnavarti zrAvaka sAdhu apane se hIna darje ke yAne caturtha guNasthAna vAle devatAoM kI stuti kaise kareM ? to javAba yaha hai ki guNaprakAza karane meM adhikAra nahIM dekhA jAtA, rAjA apane guNimaMtri kI guNastuti karatA hai, isa se yaha nahIM kahA jA sakatA ki rAjA kA adhikAra kama hai| guNI ke guNa kI prazaMsA-stuti karane meM bhI lekhaka jI yadi doSa mAnate hoM taba to una ke zira bar3I Apatti kI zilA giregI, isa mAnyatA se to bhagavAn zrImahAvIra deva bhI doSita rahareMge, kyoM kI guNapraMzasA to bhagavAna Apa bhI karate the, sulasA zrAvikA ke dharmAnurAga kI Apa ne kaI vakta stuti kI thI, AnaMda, kAmadevAdi dRDhadhArmi zrAvakoM kI Apa vAra vAra tArIpha

Page #68
tristutika-mata- mImAMsA / (stuti ) karate the, lekhaka mahAzaya soceM ki trayodazagugasthAnakavati tIrthakara zrImahAvIra deva ko yaha mAlUma nahIM thA ki mujha se hIna darje ke ina logoM kI maiM stuti kyoM karUM, para yaha bAta una ke jJAna meM bhAsa rahI thI, ve jAnate the ki cAhe jaisA nIce darje kA jIva ho usa ke sadguNoM kI prazaMsA karane meM kucha bhI doSa nahIM, ulaTA guNa hai, guNI ke guNoM kI prazaMsA karane se vaha apane vidyamAnaguNoM ko dRDha karegA, itanA hI nahIM, dUsare aneka guNoM ko-jo usa vakta usa meM nahIM haiM-prApta karane kI icchA prabala hogI, aura kramazaH aneka zubhaguNoM kA sthAna bana jAyagA / jo manuSya iSavaza ho kara guNI ke guNoM kI kadara nahIM karatA, usa kI tArIpha nahIM karatA use zAstrakAra ' anArya ' jaise nIca zabda se pukArate haiN| pAThakamahAzaya ! nimnalikhita jainazAstroM ke pATha bhI dekhalIjiye ki zAstra kyA rAstA batA rahA hai aura trastutikasamAja kisa kupaMtha para cala rahA hai| " guNAn guNavatAM ye na, zlAghante matsarAnnarAH / kSudrA rudrAryavatpretya, te bhavantyatiduHkhitAH // " (dAnakalpadruma-tRtIyastavaka / ) artha-IrSA ke mAre jo puruSa guNavAnoM ke guNoM kI stuti nahIM karate haiM ve rudrAcArya kI mAphika parabhava meM bahuta duHkhI hote haiN| " eSA bhagavatAmAjJA, sAmAnyasyApi sundaram / kAryaH sAdharmikasyeha, vinayo vandanAdikaH // " ( upamitibhavapracaMcA kathA-prastAva 5 pRSTha 758 / ) artha-yaha bhagavantoM kI AzA hai ki sAmAnya sAdhArmika

Page #69
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / (samAnadharmI) kA bhI vaMdanApramukha vinaya acchI taraha karanA caahiye| "sAhammiyamittassavi bhaNiyaM kira vaMdanAIyaM " (dharmaratnaprakaraNa gAthA 81 / ) artha-sAdharmimAtra kA bhI vaMdanAdi karanA kahA hai| " jinendrazAsane bhaktiM, yaH kazcit kurute janaH / AnandajalapUrNAkSastamahaM bahuzaH stuve // " (upamitibhavaprapaJcA--prastAva 3) . artha-jo koI bhI prANI jinazAsana ke viSe bhakti karatA hai usakI maiM AnaMdAzrupUrNanetra vAlA ho ke vAraMvAra stuti karatA huuN| " bhUriguNA virala cciya, ikkaguNo vihu jaNo na savvattha / nidosANa vi bhadaM pasaMsimo thovadose vi // " __ (dharmaratna-prakaraNa ) artha-bahutaguNa vAle to virale hI haiM para eka guNavAlA bhI manuSya saba jagaha para nahIM hai, isa liye doSarahitoM kA bhI kalyANa ho, thoDe doSa vAloM kI bhI hama stuti karate haiN| . " tAmevArIM stuve yasyA dharmaputro vRSAsanaH / " (samarAdityasaMkSepa pR0 7) artha-usa AryA ( sAdhvI ) kI maiM ( pradyumnasUri ) stuti karatA hUM; jisa kA dharmaputra ( haribhadramari ) dharmadhuraMdhara huA hai / priyapAThakagaNa ! ina saba zAstrIya vacanoM se Apa ko pUrI tasallI ho gaI hogI ki ucca adhikAra vAlA bhI apane se choTe

Page #70
tristutika- mata-mImAMsA / darje vAle kI stuti kara sakatA hai, agara lekhakamahodaya yaha zaMkA kareMge ki ina pAThoM meM kahIM kahIM to 'prazaMsA' aura zlAghA ' zabda haiM inakA artha ' stuti ' kyoM likhA ? to uttara yaha hai ki prazaMsA, zlAghA, stuti vigairaha saba zabda ekArthaka haiN| ' SoDazaka' - TIkA meM yazobhadrasUrijI ne prazaMsA kA artha ' stuti ' kiyA hai, yathA 6 " prazaMsanti stuvanti " vivekamaMjarI prakaraNa - TIkA meM bhI 'prazaMsA' zabda kA artha ' stuti' kiyA hai, " prazaMsA-stutiH yAnI prazaMsA nAma stuti kA hai / dr - ( vivekamaMjarI pRSTha 213 ) 51 'zlAghA' zabda kA bhI ' stuti' artha isI prakaraNa kI TIkA meM kiyA hai, jaise 44 zlAghyAH stutyA: " ( vivekamaMjarI - TIkA - pRSTha 208 ) ina saba pramANoM se sApha sApha yaha siddha hotA hai ki cAhe koI bhI kisI kI bhI stuti kara sakatA hai, karanevAlA cAhe vaDA ho yA choTA, aura jaba yaha siddha ho gayA ki sAmAyika yA pauSa kisI meM bhI caturtha stuti karane kA doSa nahIM, to lekhakoM kI yaha kuyukti kaise cala sakatI haiM ki sAvadyayoga kA pratyAkhyAna karane bAda caturtha stuti karane meM Azrava lagatA hai ? | phira lekhakoM kA kathana ki " zrI pramodavijayasUrijI tathA zrI kalyANavijayajI bhI tIna thuI tathA cAra thuI ke dono devavaMdana apane 2 avasara pe karate karAte the. "

Page #71
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / sarAsara jhUTha hai, tIna thuI kathana karane vAlA zAstra hI nahIM to tIna thuI ke devavaMdana Aye kahAM se? / stutika logoM kA kathana hai ki 'kalpabhASya ' meM tIna thuI karanA kahA hai, isa viSayameM unake pAsa pramANa nimna li. khita do gAthAeM haiM. " dubbhigaMdhamalassAvi, taNurappesa nhANayA / duhA vAovaho ceva, to ciTThati na cehaye // 1 // tiNi vA kaDhaI jAva, thuio tisilogIyA / tAva tattha aNunnAyaM, kAraNeNa pareNaMvi // 2 // ye donoM gAthAeM rAjendrasarijI ke svahastalikhita caityavandanavicAra patra-jo hamAre pAsa maujuda haiM una meM se jyoM kI tyoM yahAM para likhI haiM, isa se isa bAta kA bhI patA cala sakatA hai ki rAjedramUrijI saMskRta yA prAkRta kA zuddha likhanA bhI nahIM jAnate the, kyoM ki ina do gAthAoM meM bhI kitanI azuddhiyAM likha mArI ? 'vAoM yahAM 'vAu' cAhiye 'thuio' kI jagaha 'zuIo' cAhiye, 'silogIyA ke sthAna 'silogiyA' yA 'siloiyA' honA cAhiye, 'pareNaM vi' yahAM 'pareNa vi' aisA cAhiye, ityaadi| vAhare kalikAlasarvajJa! prAkRtavyAkaraNaviSayaka hasva, dIrgha AdikI azuddhiyAM bhI tere jJAna meM nahIM bhAsI ? / pAThakasajano ! aba inhIM mahAtmA kA likhA huA pUrvokta gAthAoM kA artha bhI akSarazaH nIce likhA jAtA hai dekha lIjiye, " durgaMdhI aura malakA jharaNahArA esA sarIra hai jo sonAMna karo to bhI upara ora nIce se vAyu vaha rahA tAte na rahe cetya meM kAraNe

Page #72
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / 52 jAya to tIna thuI karSana kare jAva thuI tIna siloka kI tahAM taka tahAM cetya meM munyo ko AjJA he koI kAraNa hoya to adhIka bhI rahe " mujhe dikhalAne kI jarUrata nahIM kI yaha artha kaisA gar3abar3a hai| ina kA asalI artha kyA hai so TIkA se samajha lIjiye, __ " zrutastavAnantaraM tisraH stutIstrizlokikAH zlokatrayapramANA yAvat kurvate tAvat tatra caityAyatane sthAnamanujJAtaM, kAraNavazAt pareNApyupasthAnamanujJAtamiti / " artha-zrutastava (pukkharavaradIvaDhe ) ke bAda tIna zloka pramANa tIna stutiyAM kahI jAyaM taba taka maMdira meM Thaharane kI AjJA hai kAraNavaza jyAdA Thaharane kI bhI AjJA hai| bhAvArtha isa kA yaha hai ki sAdhu jinamaMdira meM nahIM Thaharate athavA, pratikramaNa ke aMta meM maMgala ke nimitta ' namo'stu vardhamAnAya' yA 'vizAlalocana' kI mavAphika caityavaMdana ke aMta meM praNidhAnArtha tIna zlokAtmaka stuti kahI jAya taba taka sAdhuoM ko maMdira meM Thaharane kI AjJA hai, kAraNa vizeSa meM jayAdA bhI ThaharanA anujJAta hai niSkAraNa nhiiN| isa se sApha jAhira hai ki pUrvokta vyavahArabhASya kI gAthAoM kA artha yaha nahIM hai ki caityavaMdana meM tIna thuI karanA kiMtu 'caityavaMdana ke anta meM praNidhAnArtha tIna zloka kahe jAya~ tava taka maMdira meM ThaharanA vinA kAraNa jayAdA nahIM' yaha una gAthAoM kA tAtparyArtha hai| yahI tAtparya AcArya dharmaghoSasarijI ne 'saMghAcAra ' nAmakI caityavaMdanabhASya kI TIkA meM spaSTa rItise dikhAyA hai, vaha pATha yaha hai

Page #73
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / ___ " etayorbhAvArthaH-sAdhavazcaityagRhe na tiSThanti, athavA caityavandanAnte zakrastavAdyanantaraM tistraH stutIH zlokatrayapramANAH praNidhAnArthaM yAvatkathyante-pratikramaNAnantaramaMgalArthaM stutitrayapAThavat-tAvaJcaityagRhe(sthAnaM ) sAdhUnAmanujJAtaM niSkAraNaM na parataH // " . isa bhAvArtha se yaha bhI rAjendramUrijI kA kathana-ki 'ye donoM gAthAeM caityavaMdanavidhipratipAdaka haiM'-uDa gayA, kyoM ki caityavaMdanavidhipratipAdaka nahIM kiMtu vinA kAraNa jinamaMdira meM rahane kA niSedha karane vAlI pUrvokta gAthAeM haiM / yaha vAta vAdivetAla zrI zAntimUrijI' ne caityavaMdanamahAbhASya meM acchI taraha spaSTa kI hai, pATha yaha hai, " bhaNai gurU ta suttaM, ciyavaMdaNavihiparUvagaM na bhave / __ nikAraNajiNamaMdira,- paribhoganivAragatteNa // " artha-guru kahate haiM / tini vA' ityAdi mUtra vinAkAraNa jinamaMdira meM nahIM ThaharanA isa bAta ko kahane vAlA hone se caityavaMdanavidhi kA prarUpaka nahIM hai| traistutikoM kA dUsarA svamatapoSaka pramANa " nissakaDamanissakaDe ceie savvahiM thuI tiNNI / velaM va ceiyAI nAuM ekvekiA vAvi // " ___ yaha gAthA hai, paraMtu yaha bhI una kI pUrNa bhUla hai, yaha gAthA caityaparipATI (parivADI ) ke samaya meM caityavaMdanavidhidarzaka hai, isa kA matalaba yaha hai ki "eka jagaha pUrNa caityavaMdana kara lene ke bAda aura saba maMdiroM meM bhagavadaguNavarNaka maMgalarUpa tIna zloka kahA~ cAhiye, yadi maMdira

Page #74
tristutika mata--mImAMsA / 55 bahuta hoM aura samaya thor3A ho to eka hI zloka, gAthA, duhA kahanA para maMdira meM avazya jAnA cAhiye " isI vidhi se vartamAna meM zrIsaMgha caityaparipATI karatA hai, khuda tIna thuI ke sAdhu zrAvaka bhI isI mujaba vartate haiM, yadi aisA na ho to ve caityaparipATI karate vakta eka maMdira meM pUrNa caityavaMdana karake dUsaroM meM jA kara sirpha do tIna hI kAvya, zloka, yA dohare bola ke kyoM cale jAte haiM ? saba jagaha tIna yA eka stuti ke devavaMdana kyoM nahIM karate para kare kaise ? usa gAthA kA artha hI mere likhane mujava hai to dUsarA nikAle kahAM se ? sirpha muMha se volate haiM ki isa meM tIna thuI haiM, vAkaI yaha kahe vinA to ina kA kakA cale bhI kaise ? yadi una gAthAoM kA asalI artha apane mukha se kaha deveM taba ho ina ko yaha mana choDanA hI paDe na ?, hAM hRdaya meM jarUra kabUla karate hai ki..... tIna thuI kA mata sarAsara zAstraviruddha hai| agara aisA na hotA to surata nagara ke saMghasamakSa khuda rAjendramUrijI ne cAra thuI karane kA svIkAra kyoM kara liyA thA ? kyA usa vakta ' nissakaDa ' ityAdi gAthAoM ko rAjendrasUrijI bhUla gaye the ? saca to yaha hai ki ve usa vakta yathArtha samajha gaye the ki "hamArA mata zAstrasaMmata nahIM hai, jina zAstroM ke pAThoM se hamane yaha mata calAyA hai una pAThoM kA matalaba ora hai, hamane una kA artha karane meM bhUla kI hai, para aba to ho hI kyA sakatA hai, jisa vArDa meM aneka ajJAni bher3oM ke Tole bhara gaye haiM; una ko pIchA

Page #75
tristutika--mata--mImAMsA / kn k n n- ng n-' n n kk wanton... khAlI kaise karanA ? una ke Age apanI bhUla prakaTa bhI kisa prakAra kI jAya ? yadi mAna choDa ke kaha bhI deveM ki -- apanA yaha mata zAstraviruddha hai ' to mAne kauna ? sage bApa kA bhI nahIM mAnanevAlI vaniyoM kI jAta hamArA anyathA kathana kisa prakAra mAna legI ?" isa prakAra kA vicAra rAjendramUrijI ke hRdaya meM kaI varSoM taka calatA rahA, para manogata vicAra bhI gupta kahAM taka raha sakatA hai, yaha gupta abhiprAya bhI una ke parivAra ke sAdhuoM ke kAnoM taka pahuMca gayA, aura saba ke mana para acchA prabhAva par3A, yahAM taka ki kaI mahAnubhAva bhava bhIru sAdhuoM ke mukha se to isa prakAra vacana bhI nikalane lage-- ___"yadi isa prakAra apanA mata nimUla hI hai taba to isakA tyAga hI zreyaskara hai ?" rAjendramUrijI isa gaMbhIra prazna kA samAdhAna sirpha isI vAkya se kiyA karate the ki " avasara Ane para saba acchA hogA, hAla to calane do" pAThaka mahodaya ! rAjendrasarijI kA yaha kathana alabattA ThIka thA, Apa samajJa sakate haiM ki jo AdamI jhUThI yA sacI kisI bhI bAtako pakar3a letA hai vaha use vinA kAraNa nahIM chor3a sakatA rAjendrasarijI ke vAste bhI yahI bAta thI, bhAviyoga se tIna thuI kA mata una se nikala gayA thA, pIche se samajha bhI gaye the ki yaha kAma ThIka nahIM huA, para aba use ekadama choDanA kaThina kArya thA isa liye maukA dekha rahe the ki yaha mata kaba choDA jAya, itane meM vaha samaya bhI nikaTa AyA mAlUma hone lgaa|

Page #76
tristutika mata-mImAMsA / saMvat 1960 (gujarAtI) 1959 kA caturmAsa rAjendrasUrijI ne surata meM kiyA, surata ke saMgha meM isa nUtana mata kI khUba carcA calI, yahAM taka ki rAjendrasUrijI kI usa cirakAla kI bhAvanA kI siddhi kA samaya atisamIpa hone kA anumAna bhI logoM ne bAMdha liyA thA, para hove kyA ? jisa kArya kI bhavitavyatA hI dUra hai vaha kyoM kara ho jAya ! | 57 yadyapi rAjendrasUrijI kA pUrA vicAra thA ki isa mauke para cAra stutiyAM kara leMge, ata eva " panyAsajI caturavijayajI ne upAzraye temanI samakSa rAjendrasUrijI padhArelA hatA tathA saMgha samasta malyo hato temanI vacceno traNa ke cAra thui no jhagaDo kora mukI rAjendrasUrijI ne saMbe vinaMti karavAthI temaNe mAnya karI che ane tapagacchatI samAcArIpramANe jo varte temane sAdhu mAnava saMvat 1959 nA jeTha vada 13 ne vAra bhoma " isa lekha para unhoM ne hastAkSara ( dastakhata ) bhI kara diye the, paraMtu, " zreyAMsi bahuvighnAni bhavanti mahatAmapi " yaha kahAvata asatya nahIM thI, usa parama sulaha -zAnti ke kArya meM bhI vighnasaMtoSI loka apane bala kI parIkSA karane lage. mAravAr3a aura mAlave ke mamatvI traistutika zrAvakoM ne rAjendrasUrijI ke kAna phUMke aura pahale hI se ve apanI ijjata kA dAvA karane lage ki - << Apa to sAdhu haiM, Aja yahAM to kala kahIM DerA kareMge para hamArI nAka kaTa jAyagI isa kA javAba dAtA kauna ? jisa mata kI 4

Page #77
58 tristutik-mt-miimaaNsaa| cn rk k k k n ldn- aaal sh k n b b n b sn-2 'n- p- nng- saccAI ke liye hamane zirator3a mahanata kI, apane mAvApoM kA apamAna taka karake jisa paMtha meM praveza kiyA usI mata ko aba hama kisa mukha se amAnya kaheMge ? agara hama na choDeM to bhI hamArA sahAyaka kauna ? hamArA guru kauna ? hama kisa ke Age zira jhukAveMge ? kisa ke upadeza se hama dharma kriyA pAleMge ?" ina vacanoM se rAjendramUrijI kA vaha nizcaya Diga gayA, una ke usa cirakAlaka vicAra kA zIghra hI vilaya ho gayA, aura una mamatA ke mUla vaniyoM ke moha meM phaMsa kara ve apanI pratijJA se patita ho gye| traistutika sajjanoM ko socanA cAhiye ki yadi Apa ke mAnane ke mavAphika zAstroM meM tIna thuI kahI hotI to rAjendramUrijI surata meM cAra thuI karane ke liye udyata kyoM hue ? kyA usa vakta bhI koi pUjA pratiSThAdi kAraNa A pA thA jo cothI thuI karane ko tatpara ho gaye ? kyA hI acchA hotA yadi usa vakta ve apanI pratijJA ko pAlana karane ke lie bhI cAra stuti kara lete ! / khair| phira lekhaka apanI karatUta kA namUnA vAhara lAte haiM ki " paraMtu jainabhikSujI kI kalpita paraMparA ke dAdA paradAdAdi pUrvajoM ne to zrItIrthakara. gaNadhara pUrvadhara, bahuzruta gItArthoM ke vacana utthApa ke bhAva pUjA jo ( bhAvastava ) sAmAyika posahAdi ( bhAvapUjA ) cAritrAnuSThAna kA khaMDana Aja dinoM taka karate haiM aura svakIya tathA parakIya janma bigADate haiM ! taise zrIvijayarAjendrasUrijI kI pATa paraMparA ke pUrvAcArya nahIM karate karAte the aba aisI hI apanI 2 paraMparA kI judI judI vyavasthA hai "

Page #78
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / 59 lekhaka mahAzayoM ko isa bAta kA khayAla hai ki kalpita paraMparA kise kahate haiM ? jo paraMparA avicchinnadhArA se calI AtI ho, jisa meM kriyA prarUpaNA kA vibheda na ho usa paraMparA ko bhI kalpita kahane kA duHsAhasa vinA ulla ke ora koi kara sakatA hai ? / kalpita paraMparA hai vaha jisa ke pUrva puruSa sarvathA AraMbha parigrahAsakta the, jisa ke uttara puruSoM ne apane guruoM ko tyAga ke viruddha prarUpaNA dvArA tIna thuI kA mata nikAlA, aura jaba logoM meM 'nagurue ' kahalAne lage to lajjA ke mAre phira una tyAge hue asaMyata puruSoM ko apane pUrvAcArya sthApana kara ke Apa una kI paraMparA ke AcArya, sAdhu kahalAne lage, lekhaka jI ! saca kahiye yahI Apa kI paraMparA hai ki nahIM / jainabhikSujI ke to dAdA paradAdA hI kyoM mahAvIra svAmI se le kara Aja taka ke paraMparAgata sabhI AcArya sAdhu guru zrItIrthakara, gaNadhara, bahuzruta gItArthoM ke vacanAnusAra pratikramaNa pauSadhAdi dhArmika kAryoM meM cAra stuti karate karAte Aye haiM jisa ko lekhaka to kyA inake pUrvaja bhI nahIM choDA sakate ! / bhAvapUjA kA khaMDana ve loga karate haiM jo zAstrapramANoM kA anAdara karake apanI tuccha buddhi se nayA mata calAte haiM kyoM ki bhAvapUjA usI kA nAma hai jo vItarAgakI AjJAnusAra anuSThAna kiyA jAya, vinA AjJA devastuti to kyA apane zarIra taka kA tyAga karane vAlA bhI bhAvapUjA kA kartA nahIM ho sakatA, bhAvapUjA vahI karatA he jo jinAjJAnusAra bhalA kAma karatA hai| jinastuti bhAvapUjA nahIM, devatAstuti dravyapUjA nahIM, jinA

Page #79
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA | jJA meM saba kucha hai, jisa meM jinAjJA hai vahI bhAvapUjA aura jinAjJAzUnya dravyapUjA hai / lekhakoM kI mAnyatA hai ki ' sAmAyika pauSadhAdi meM devakI stuti nahIM karanI cAhiye, kyoM ki yaha bhAvapUjA hai, aura devatAstuti dravyapUjA hai, bhAva ke bIca meM dravya kA praveza ucita nahIM ' << merA kahanA yaha hai ki stuti bhI sAmAyika pratikramaNa kI taraha bhAvapUjA hI mAnI gaI hai, dekhiye caityavaMdanabhASya vRttiatha tRtIyA bhAvapUjA, sA ca stutibhirlokottarasadbhUtatIrthaM kara guNagaNavarNanaparAbhirvApaddhatibhirbhavati, Aha ca--tayA u bhAvapUA ThAuM ciyavaMdaNocie dete / jahasatti cittathuthutta mAiNo devacaMdraNayaM ti // " artha - aba tIsarI bhAva pUjA hai, so vaha tIrthaMkaroM ke sata lokottara guNoM kA varNana karane vAlI vacanaracanArUpa stuti yoM se hotI hai, anya granthakAra bhI kahate haiM- caityavaMdana karane yogya sthAnameM Thahara ke aneka prakAra ke stutistotroM se devavaMdana karanA isakA nAma bhAva pUjA hai, ' yaha pUjA kA tIsarA bheda hai, isa se yaha siddha huA ki sAmAyika, pratikramaNa, pauSadha ho yA mata ho kevala devavaMdana bhI bhAvapUjA hai, isa liye lekhaka aura una ke vartamAna guru kA yaha kathana ki " sAmAyika pauSava rahita zrAvaka deva vaMdana kare usa meM cauthI thuI kahane kA doSa nahIM "

Page #80
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / kevala unmatta pralApa hai, kyoM ki mukha se to kahate haiM ki bhAvapUjA meM caturtha stuti kahane se bhAvapUjA khaMDita ho jAtI hai aura sAmAyika vinA maMdirAdi meM devavaMdanarUpa stutipUjA meM caturtha stuti kA upadeza karate haiM, baDA hI Azcarya hai ! kyA stuti pUjA bhAvapUjA nahIM hai ? yadi hai to caturthastuti se usa kA khaMDana ho jAyagA ki nahIM ? / pAThakagaNa ! Apa samajhe ? yaha kula lekakoM aura ina ke guru kI cAlabAjI hai, ye loga isI prakAra logoM ko jAla meM phaMsAte haiM, para Apa jAnate haiM ki aba vaha jamAnA nahIM hai, aba logoM kA ajJAnatimira kucha dUra haTane lagA hai ataeva ve isa prapaMcajAla ko dekhane lage haiM, aura ina prapaMcAvatAra traistutikoM se napharata kara rahe haiM ki ' jAlI traistutikoM se hama bacate rheN| lekhaka jI ! jarA AMkheM kholakara dekhiye, cAritrAnuSThAna kA khaMDana jainabhikSu jI karate haiM ki Apa sarIkhe navIna matAvalambI loga ? sanAtana dharma se logoM kI zraddhA bhraSTa karane vAle, unheM mamatvadeva ke upAsaka banAne vAle traistuti loga svapara kA janma vigAr3a rahe haiM ki anya koI ? isa bAta kI to pUrI taura se talAza kara liijiye| phira lekhaka jI apane dAde kI vakAlata karate hue kahate " jAlora ke kAMkariyA vAsa meM zrIpArzvanAthajI kA maMdira hai, isa ke mUlanAyakajI ke Upara prAcIna AcArya kA nAma kA eka jIrNa lekha thA usa lekha ko eka musalamAna zilAvaTa ke pAsa ghisavA DAlA

Page #81
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / aura usake Upara rAjendrasUrijI ne apane nAma kA ' saMvat ( 1948 ) va0 vaizAkha sudi (6) zrIpArzvabiMba pratiSThitaM bha0 rAjendrasUriNA jAlora nagare kAMkariyA vAsa madhye ' yaha upara kA lekha jainabhikSujI ne atyaMta hI asatya ( jhUThA ) chapavAyA hai kyoM ki koI sthAna para nahIM to rAjendrasUrijI ne akhaMDita prAcIna mUrtiyoM ko uThavAkara nayI sthApita karavAI hai ! na to kAMkariyAvAsa ke mUlanAyakajI ke upara prAcIna AcArya ke nAma kA lekha thA ! aura na rAjendramUrijIne musalamAna zilAvaTa ke pAsa ghisavAyA !" kauna kahatA hai jainabhikSujI kA yaha lekha jhUThA hai ? jainabhikSujI kA yaha kathana satya hai ki rAjendramUrijI ne kaI jagaha para prAcIna mUrtiyAM uThavAI aura jahAM taka apanI calI una mUrtiyoM ke lekha bhI ghisavAye haiM, jisa kA tAjA dRSTAnta yaha hai ki saMvat 1955 kI sAla meM rAjendramUrijI ne Ahora meM pratiSThA tathA aMjanazalAkA kI thI, yaha bAta usa tarpha ke loga prAyaH jAnate hI hoMge, usI mauke para gAMva 'guDA-bAlotarA' se eka prAcIna jina mUrti-jisa para saMvat 1213 kA lekha bhI maujUda hai-rAjendramUrijI ne phira usa kI pratiSThA, aMjanazalAkA karane ke liye apane rAgI zrAvakoM ko bharamA ke use Ahora maMgavAne kA udyoga kiyA, vaha kucha saphala bhI hone kI tayyArI meM A gayA, bAta yoM banI ki rAjendrasarijI kI zikSA ke anusAra una ke zrAvakoM ne usa prAcIna mUrti ko baila gADImeM biThA kara rAtorAta Ahora kI tarpha khAnA kara dI, para aisA anyAya gupta bhI kahAM taka rahatA hai ? jaldI hI isa prapaMca kA patA gAMva ke mahAjana ko laga gayA unhoMne una prapaMcI traistutikoM kA pIchA kiyA aura 'Ahora' ke daravAje ke

Page #82
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / pAsa usa pratimA ko Age le jAne se rokA, bahuta prapaMca huA aura AkhirakAra pratimA jyoM kI tyoM pIchI -- guDe meM ' lAI gaI jo Aja taka vahAM mUlanAyaka ke sthAna para pUjI jAtI hai / agara isa meM kisI ko zaMkA ho-ki pUrvokta hakIkata banI banAI hai yA kalpita hai-vaha guDA ke zrI saMgha se daryAphata kara ke samAdhAna kara leve, aura yaha zaMkA ho ki usa para zilA lekha hai ki nahIM use vahAM jA kara usa pUrti kA darzana kara ke samAdhAna kara lenA cAhiye, kyoM ki vaha lekha abhI taka maujUda hai jisa ko ghisavAne kA prapaMca rAjendramUrijI ne kiyA thaa| lekhaka jI ! Apa hI kahiye jaina bhikSu kA likhanA galata hai yA Apa kA ? isa hakIkata meM rattibhara bhI jUTha ho to dikhA dIjiye / isI prakAra gAMva 'koraTe' meM jo prAcIna pratimAyeM nikalI haiM una para bhI rAjendrasUrijI ne pratiSThA ke samaya apane nAma kA lekha likhanA cAhA thA paraMtu Asa pAsa ke gAvoM ke saMghane yaha vAMcA liyA ki 'yadi rAjendrasUrijI ne ina pratimAoM para nayA lekha khudavAyA to hama pratiSThA meM ThahareMge nahIM' taba unhoMne sabara kipA, anyathA koraTA meM bhI prAcIna le voM ko visamAkara nayA lekha khudavA hI lete ! / lekhakajI mahArAja ! hama Apa ke mUrijI kI kitanI krtuu| likheM ! unhoMne apanI lagabhaga sArI jIMdagI isI prakAra ke kAmoM meM barabAda ko hai jo phAyade ke badale nukasAnakAraka the / lekhakoM kI yaha dalIla ki-kAMkariyAvAsa ke mUlanAyaka jI ke Upara zilAlekha thA hI nahIM to rAjendramUrijI ghisavAve

Page #83
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / Pr- rrrrrn. kisa ko ?-sarAsara jhUTha hai, kauna kaha sakatA hai mUla nAyaka jI ke Upara lekha nahIM thA ? barAbara thA, sArA jAlora kA jainasaMgha jAnatA aura kabUla karatA hai ki isapara purANA lekha thA aura rAjendramUrijI ne ' jamAla khAM' nAmaka musalamAna zilAvaTa ke pAsa ghisvaayaa| itanA hI nahIM, usa zilAvaTa kA beTA-jisakA nAma 'karima khAM' hai, aura jo Aja kala gAMva ' agavarI ke jaina maMdira meM kAma karatA hai-vaha bhI kabUla karatA hai ki 'mere pitAjI ne kAMkariyAvAsa ke pArzvanAtha jI kA purAnA lekha ghisA aura nayA khodA thA, kyoM le vaka jI ! jainabhikSu jI kA kathana jhUThA ThaharA ki ApakA ? / phira lekhaka teharIra karate haiM ki " isa pratimA kA utthAna zrIjAlora gaDhakA rahIsa rANAvatajI ke yodhapura vigaire ke kAma ke karane vAlA kAmetI ( kAmadAra ) Upara koTA kAnugA navalamalajI ne-makarANA jayapura yA sAdarI se lAI huIpratimA tIna cAra varSa to khuda apane ghara meM bhUharA meM rakkhI pIche upAzraya ke Ale meM lAke dharI thI, aMjana zalAkA vinA kI navIna pratimA ke upara prAcIna ( jUnI ) arvAcIna ( navIna ) olakhAna ke liye 'pUrvAcAryoM kI paraMparA gata nAma khudavAte Aye haiM jisa anurodha ( mizAla ) se rAjendra rijI ne saMvat mAsAdi nAma khudavAyA; paraMtu na kevala apanA nAma rakhane kI abhilASA se nAma khudavAyA hai:isa kI sAbutI kA lekha prathama to kAnugA navalamalajI kA lekha Upara likha cUke haiM " lekhako kA yaha kathana ki 'usa pratimA kI aMjana

Page #84
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / zalAkA nahIM huI thI ' kevala asatya hai, kauna kahatA hai vaha pratimA aMjanazalAkArahita thI ? usa para kA lekha dekhane . vAle jAlora meM abhI taka mojUda haiM usa para ke lekha kA matalaba aisA thA ki " tIrtha varakANA meM isa biMba kI pratiSThA aMjanazalAkA huI" isa se lekhakoM kA yaha kathana bhI jhUThA siddha huA ki vaha pratimA ' makarANA jayapura yA sAdarI se AI thii| pahale cAhe kahIM se bhI AI ho para navalamalajI to usa pratiSThita pratimA ko varakANA se hI lAye the aisA una ke khatapatroM se siddha hotA hai, yadi isa bAta meM lekhakoM ko zaMkA ho to jAlora A kara nirNaya kara leveM / lekhaka jI ! kahiye Apa ke rAjendramUrijI ne jisa pratimA kA lekha ghisavAyA vaha pratiSThita thI ki apratiSThita ? / phira lekhaka jhUTha kI jAla bichAte haiM ki " kAkariyA vAsa ke maMdira kA asala mUla nAyakajI ( 100 ) varSa uparAMta ke to prAcIna ( june ) the paraMtu nIce pramANe khaMDita ho gaye thai" jainabhikSu ne aisA kaba kahA ki pahale ke mUlanAyaka jI jo kucha kahIM 2 khaMDita haiM una para kA lekha ghisavA DAlA ? jainabhikSu kA yaha kathana-- " isa ke mUla nAyaka jI ke Upara prAcIna AcArya ke nAmakA eka jIrNa lekha thA, usa lekha ko eka musalamAna zilAvaTa ke pAsa ghisavA DAlA" ----satya hai, navalamala jI ne jo pratimA varakANA se lAI thI

Page #85
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / .-..--- vaha pratiSThita thI usa ke Upara pratiSThA karAnevAle AcArya ke nAma kA zilA lekha bhI thA, use rAjendramUrijI ne 'jamAla khAM' zilAvaTa ke pAsa rAta ke samaya ghisavAyA aura apane nAma kA nayA khudavAyA, jaba isa kI khabara maMdira ke goThiyoM ko milI to ve bahuta hI nArAja hue, yahAM taka ki usa zilAvaTa ko pratiSThA ke nimitta inAma ( pAritoSika ) bhI nahIM milA, yaha bAta jAlora meM mazahUra hai| phira lakhaka jI apanI yukti dikhAte haiM ki "jekara mUlanAyaka jI ke Upara prAcIna AcArya ke nAma kA jIrNa lekha musalamAna zilAvaTa ke pAsa ghisa ke sApha karavAkara apanA nAma kA lekha rAjendrasUrijI ne khudavAyA hotA taba to abhI vartamAna mUlanAyaka haiM tina kI mUrti jUnI honI cAhiye so to hai nahIM ! isa maMdira jI ke jUne asalI mUlanAyaka jI to hAla nIce pazvAsaNa pe virAjamAna ho ke pahile pIche kI donoM sAbutI de rahe haiM ki na to prAcIna AcArya kA nAma musalamAna zilAvaTa ke pAsa ghisavAyA ! na apanA nAma rakhane kI abhilASA se nayA nAma zilAvaTa ke pAsa khudavAyA " yaha bhI likhanA sarvathA nirbala hai, vinA nizAna Adi ke ekadama yaha patA nahIM calatA ki yaha prAcIna hai yA arvAcIna jo atyaMta prAcIna hotI hai usI kA patA calatA hai ki yaha pra. timA prAcIna hai, bAkI 200-300 sau varSa kI purAnI kI prAcInatA sahasA nahIM pahicAnI jAtI, jAlora zahara ke bAhara R. Sabhadeva jI ke maMdira meM jo pratimAeM haiM unheM dekha ke koI bhI yaha nahIM kaha sakatA ki ye 750 barasa kI purAnI hoMgI, sirpha una para ke saMvata 1221 Adi ke purAne lekhoM se jAnA jAtA

Page #86
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / hai ki pratimAeM purAnI haiM, yahI dazA kAMkariyAvAsa ke mUlanAyaka jI kI hai, unheM dekhate hI yaha nahIM kahA jA sakatA ki ye kitane purAne hoMge sirpha una kI prAcInatA kA sAkSI lekha thA so vaha to rAjendramUri jI ne pahale se hI ghisavADAlA, aba to isa bAta kA-ki vaha pratimA pratiSThita thI ki nahIM? usa para lekha thA ki nahIM, ? aura use ghisavA ke rAjendramari jI ne apane nAma kA nayA lekha khudavAyA ki nahIM ? ' nirNaya jAlora vAloM ke khata-patroM se aura una ke mukhase-jo saMvat 1948 kI sAla meM usa pratiSThA meM zarIka the-ho sakatA hai, isa liye lekhakoM ko dAvA ke sAtha maiM yaha kahatA hUM ki yadi Apa apane pUrvokta lekhako satya kiyA cAhate hoM to pramANa ke sAtha peza Aiye ! anyathA ApakI sArI dalIleM jhUThI aura jAlI haiM yaha kahane meM kucha bhI saMkoca nahIM rhegaa| lekhaka vAravAra usa khaMDita mUrti ko mUlanAyaka batA kara logoM ko bhUlAnA cAhate haiM para yAda rahe ki aba ApakI ye karatUteM koi bhI saccI nahIM mAnegA, kyoM ki aba jisa pratimA para rAjendramUrijI ke nAma kA lekha hai usI para pahale kA lekha thA yaha bAta prAyaH jAlora vAsI jAnate hI haiM aura maiM bhI kaI daphe kaha cukA huuN| phira lekhaka mahAzaya apanI kapaTapaTutA jAhira karate haiM ki vaha maMdira zrI saMgha kA hai, aura pratiSThA karAne vAlA bhI zrI saMgha hI thA vaha vartamAna meM aba bhI jayavanta varta rahA hai ! aura daMDa caDhAne vAlA ( 17 ) varSa ke bAda aura dhvajA caDhAne vAlA (15)

Page #87
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / varSa ke bAda aura zilAvaTa (5) varSa ke bAda apanA apanA AyupUrNa karake sukha sAmAdhi se paraloka gaye haiM " pAThakavarga ! dekha lIjiye lekhakoM kI asatyatA kI nizAnI, ve kahate haiM ki pratiSThA karane vAlA zrI saMgha thA, kauna kahegA ki pratiSThA zrI saMghane karAI ? pratiSThA karAI hai ' loDhA dalIcaMdajI' ne, lekhaka jI! jarA AMkheM khola ke dekho ki Apa ke rAjendramUrijI kA lekha kyA kahatA hai, yadi use Apane nahIM dekhA ho to dekha lIjiye yahAM para likha diyA jAtA hai, ___" saMvat 1948 varSe vaizAkhavadi 6 dine zrIjAloranagare kAMkariyAvAsamadhye zrIpArzvajinaprAsAdapratiSThA kRtA / bha / rAjendrasUriNA pratiSThA kArako vRddhazAkhAyAM loDhA uttamacaMdra __ suta dalIcaMda " ( ityAdi ) kyoM lekhaka jI ! aba to dekhA ki nahIM ? pratiSThA karAne vAlA zrI saMgha hai ki dalIcaMdajI ? inhIM dalIcaMdajI ke prANa saMvat 1949 ke zrAvaNa vadi 14 ke dina dUkAna para baiThe baiThe nikala gaye the| isI maMdira kA kalazAropaNa zA0 jItAjI ne kiyA aura saMvat 1949 ke caitra suda 13 ko ve bhI paraloka vAsI ho gye| dhvajAdaMDa caDhAne vAle zA0 javAnamalajI the, una ke bhI ekAeka putra kA duHkhadAyaka maraNa ho gyaa| vaha zilAvaTa bhI pratiSThA ke bAda thoDe hI arase meM bImAra paDA aura do varSa taka kaThina vyAdhi kA kaSTa bhugata ke Akhira isa duniyA se bidA huaa| kyA yaha saba hAlAta usa pratimA kI bhayaMkara AzAtanA kA

Page #88
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / phala nahIM samajhanA ?, lekhakajI yoM hI bekhavara gappa lagA dete haiM ki ve 17 aura 15 varSoM ke bAda paraloka gaye para lekhakoM ko talAza karane se mAlUma hogA ki 17-15 varSa to dUra raho itane mahIne bhI unane nahIM nikAle / phira lekhaka jI jainabhikSu ke parabhava kI ciMtA karate hue kahate haiM ki___"jainabhikSu jI ! Apa to svamata paramata ke mUrkha lokoM meM pavitra zrIjainadharma kI hAMsI mazkarI nindA karavA ke jahAM kardama nahIM tahAM pAnI batAnA ! aise 2 jhUTha ke ghoDe daDavaDA ke jJAnI jAne ! para loka meM kauna kugati ke sukha bhogane kI Apa kI icchA bhaI hai ? so to Apa hI apane hRdaya meM zoca vicAra ke para loka kA kArya sudhAroge to sudharegA ! nahIM to Apa kI icchA " pAThakanda ! dekhiye ina lekhakoM kA 'paropadezapANDitya,' jainabhikSu kA kathana to-jo yathArtha hai-lekhakoM ko jainadharma kI hAMsI maskharI karAne vAlA lagA aura ve khuda tathA unake guru kaI prakAra se mithyA bhASaNa kara ke apanI aura jaina dharma kI hAMsI karA rahe haiM usa kI kucha bhI ginatI hI nahIM ? lekhakoM ke gurujI kaisI hAsyajanaka bAteM banAte haiM jisa kA eka tAjA hI dRSTAnta liijiye| gatacaturmAsa ke utAra gAMva 'bAgharA' ke mahAjanoM ne gAMva . siyANe jAkara lekhaka jI ke guru (dhanavijaya jI) ko pratiSThA kA muhUrta dene ke liye prArthanA kii| dhanavijaya jI ne uttara yaha diyA 'tuma saba zrAvaka aura rAjendramUrijI ke zeSa sAdhu hamArI AjJA ke mutAvika kriyA

Page #89
70 tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / karanA kabUla karo to maiM muhUrta dUM aura pratiSThA karane ko aauuN|' gAMva vAloM ne socA ki yaha sAdhu baDA jAlI aura haThI hai pahale hI se hamako jAlameM phaMsAnA cAhatA hai, para yaha bAta hone kI nahIM, hama pratiSThA dusare sAdhuoM se hI karAveM ge| basa pratiSThA kA muhUrta-tIna thuI ke munizrI mohanavijaya jI kI salAha se jAlora ke zrImAlI paM0 ravidattajI ke pAsa nikalavA liyA aura dhanavijaya jI dekhate hI rhe| ___aba kyA thA itane hI se dhanavijaya jI ke to baMdha DhIle ho gaye, unhoM ne ThANa liyA ki mere vinA bhI pratiSThA ho jAyagI, ava karanA kyA ? dUsaroM se pratiSThA hone denI ? dUsare pratiSThA kI dhUmadhAma meM dAva kheleM aura dhanavijaya dekhatA hI rahe kyA yaha vAta ucita hai ? nahIM aisA na hogA, cAhe mAna ghaTe yA baDhe, duniyA acchA kahe yA burA jo kucha ho, para pratiSThA kA DeDhapaMca to dhanavijaya hI hogA, pratiSThA ke prapaMca ke prAsAda para to dhanavijaya kI hI dhvajA uDegI, para aba karanA kyA ? karanA kyA hai ? prathama kI prArthanA nahIM mAnI to khaira, aba vinA hI prArthanA vinatI ke vahAM jAnA aura bAjI hAtha kara ke phira dAva khelanA basa yahI dhanavijaya ke jIvana mAlikA kA meru aura mahimA kA kIrti staMbha hai| lobhI manuSya kA sarvavinAza hotA hai yaha bAta sarvAza satya hai, para nirlobhatA rakhanI bhI manuSya kA kaSTa sAdhya kArya hai, dhanavijaya jI kI bhI isa lobhane kyA avasthA kI yaha bAta isa hakIkata se spaSTa hotI hai, ve pratiSThAdi kArya meM apanA matalaba ThIka ThIka nikAla lete haiM cIja meM se cIja, auSadhiyoM meM se

Page #90
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / 71 - sn-n 41 , 1 - , g n, n b g g g n 4 -- , - - - - auSadhI, graha Adi kI sthApanA kI cAMdI, pratiSThA kI paidAiza kA cothA hissA yA jitanA mile utanA rupayA yaha saba to una kA khAnagI lAbha, sivA isa ke kaI logoM ko seMkaDoM rupayA dilavA ke apanI vAha vAha uDavAnI-jaino ke jhoMpaDe khAlI karA ke mithyAtvI logoM ke gharoM ko bharavAnA aura apanI kSaNikakIrti kI durAzA pUrNa karanI yaha unakA sarvadRzya ( bAhya ) lAbha ! / aise 2 lAbha lobha kI jAla meM jakaDe hue ve kisa prakAra pratiSThA jaise kArya se alaga raha sakeM ? mAna ko bhI choDA, apa kIrti kI caddara bhI oDhI, mUrkhatA bhI svIkArI para lobha deva ke upAsakoM ne apane upAsyadeva kI bhakti na choDI / apane pUjya paramezvara kI bhakti kA yogya samaya dekha kara suvarNa yajJa se usa kI tRpti karane ko gAMva bAghare A hI gaye ! / / " prAyaH samAsannavipattikAle dhiyo'pi puMsAM malinIbhavanti" yaha kavivacana asatya nahIM,-vipatti ke samaya puruSoM kI buddhi malIna ho jAtI hai yaha bAta jhUThI nahIM, suvarNa kA mRga dekhane se rAmacaMdra kI buddhi malIna huI-ve usa ke lobha meM phaMse yaha bAta aitihAsika hai, yadyapi satya hai para bhUtakAlIna hai, kisI kI okhoM dekhI nahIM, isa liye isa samaya rAmacaMdrajI kI apekSA dhanacaMdrajI kA dRSTAnta pUrvokta vacana kA vizeSa samarthana karatA hai yaha merI hI nahIM hajAroM manuSyoM kI mAnyatA satya hai / rAmacaMdrajI kI usa lobha dazA kA phala sirpha eka sItA ke viyoga meM pariNata huA taba dhanacaMdrajI kI lobhiSTha vRtti ne unheM apane sarvasva se hAtha dhulAye / zAMti-sItA kA viyoga hI nahIM, sarvavinAza kiyA. dhairya-pitA kA zatamakha vinipAta kiyA, kSamA-jananI koM

Page #91
72 tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / prANa mukta kiyA, manonigraha-bhrAtA ke gale pAza kiyA satya-putra ko nAma zeSa kiyA, dayA-bhaginI kI durgati kI aura viveka mitra kA ghora virodha karA ke avicAradaMDakAraNya meM bhaTakAyA / priyapAThaka ! abhI taka Apa kI jijJAsA pUrI nahIM huI hogI, Apa isa vicAra meM hoMge, jaise rAmacaMdra ko kucha samaya Apatti dekhane ke bAda phira saMpatti kA samudra hastagata huA vaise ina ke viSaya meM huA yA hogA ki nahIM ? isa prazna kA uttara denA hAla duSvAra hai, maiM aisA sAtizayajJAnI nahIM ki apanA vacana kevalIbhASita hone kA dAvA karUM ! tathApi ina kI vRtti, lokamAnyatA aura merA hRdaya ye saba merI lekhanI ko yaha preraNA karate haiM ki Apa kI isa pRcchA kA uttara 'na kAra meM ' hai / dara asala bAta bhI yahI hai, rAmacaMdra kI sI sAmagrI hI ina ke pAsa kahAM ? jo apane vinaSTa kuTumba kI vAhara kareM / samudra ullaMghana karanA, rAkSasoM ke sAtha ghorayuddha meM bhIDanA aura duzmana ke vaza par3I huI apanI prANapriyA ko chuDavAnA yaha saba eka mAtra rAmacaMdra ke hI bhAgyaphalaka meM likhA huA thA, dhanacandra ! puNyahIna dhanacandra ! kyA tuma bhI yaha manoratha karate ho ki hamArI zAnti priyA pIchI mila jAyagI ? nahIM ! tumhArI vaha priyA gaI, tumhArA vaha kuTuMba kathAzeSa huA, phira milane kI AzA nahIM / tumhArA bhAgyapaTTaka sar3a gayA hai aba isa meM sirpha ye akSara avaziSTa haiM ki priyakuTumbaghAtI nirdayamAnava ! tumhArA bhAgyasUrya asta huA aba durbhAgya kI rAtrI meM paDe paDe mRtakuTuMba ke pIche AMsu vahAo aura apane pApa kA prAyazcitta karo!'

Page #92
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / pAThakagaNa ! mApha kIjiye yaha rUpaka anAyAsa kucha baha gayA hai, Apa kA jyAdA samaya nahIM letA huA prakRta itihAsa para AtA hUM jarA dhyAna diijiiye| Apa par3ha cuke haiM ki vinatI na hone para bhI dhanavijayajI pIche se vAghare A gaye, isa banAva se ina kA tiraskAra huA sahI para ve ise ginate kaba the / / ___" miyAM gire to bhI TaMgar3I UMcI " . isa kahAvata ko ve caritArtha karanA ThIka jAnate the, vAghare Akara ke bhI isa kathana ko ve saphala karane kI ceSTA karane lge| apanI saMmati vinA nikAle gaye muhUrta ko unhoM ne duSita ThaharAyA, eka pUMcha choDa ke dUsarI pakaDI, apanI kriyA manAne kA kadAgraha choDa ke muhUrta ko sadoSa ThaharAne kA durAgraha pakar3A, para phAyadA kyA huA ? pratiSThA karane karAne tathA usa meM sAmila hone vAloM ko maraNa kA bhaya batAyA, upadrava kA bhaya batAyA aura jitanA ho sakA logo ke hRdaya meM vahama ke aMkure utpanna kiye| idhara muhUrta dene vAlA zrImAlI joSI bhI dhanavijayajI se par3e vaisA nahIM thA, jyoM jyoM ve upadrava aura maraNa kA bhaya batAte tyoM tyoM vaha zartoM ke sAtha ina kA abhAva batAne lagA, bahuta dhAMdhala macA, Akhira jAlora, Ahora vigairaha gAMvoM se jyotiSI paMDita bulAye gaye, una ke pAsa satyAsatya kA nirNaya karAyA gayA to unhoM ne bhI saM0 1972 ke mAgha zudi 13 kA muhUrta nirdoSa ThaharAyA aura dhanavijayajI kA kahanA jhUThA siddha kiyA / aba kyA kahanA rahA ? isa banAva se to una kI garmI hada

Page #93
74 tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / mmaarwwwmaininewwwwwwwwwwwwwne w ww....1,1.1.10.00 1.1.5.5.. bAhara ho gaI, mana vaza nahIM raha sakA, brAhmaNa paMDitoM ko gAliyoM kA sirapAva, mohanavijayajI ko gAliyoM kI anuvaMdanA aura vAgharA ke zrAvakoM ko durAziSoM kA dharmalAbha pradAna kara ke vahAM se raphU cakkara hue, gAMva vAloM ne bahuta namratA ke sAtha roke para saba nikammA ! cale so cale hI gAMva 'sAMthu' jAke paga ttekaa| itanA hone para bhI isa mUrti ko zAnti kahAM ? vAgharA choDA para krodha mAnAdi durguNa to nahIM choDe !, sAMthu gaye to bhI pratiSThAviSayaka bakavAda dhanavijayajI ke mukha meM dina dunA rAta caugunA hone lgaa| " pratiSThA karane vAlA sAdhu 'mohanIyA' mara jAyagA, kalaza caDhAne ghAlA zikhara se gira paDegA, dhvajA daMDa car3hAne vAlA bhI mara jAyagA, jImana karane vAlA aura khAne vAle saba mara jAyaMge". __ityAdi unmatta pralApa ina ke mukha se yatheccha nikalate aura sunane vAloM ke hRdaya meM apUrva hAsya rasa ko puSTa karate the| Upara mujaba ke pralApa bhI jaba niSphala jAne lage, pratiSThA kI tayyArI jhapATAbaMdha hone lagI taba buDhe ne jAnA ki aba to bAjI jAtI hai to ve khUba vyAkula hue, naukA ke DUbate samaya jI vanArthI manuSya cAroM ora vyAkulaSTi se jisa prakAra AlaMbana khojate haiM isI prakAra dhanavijaya jI isa Apatti ke samudra ko terane kA upAya aharniza khojane lage aura " jino rakSatu me yazaH" isa maMtra kA jApa japane lge| Akhira jaradahRdaya meM yaha nagnA vicAra utpanna huA, unhoM

Page #94
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / 75 ne yaha soca ke ki-'aba to gAMva ke ThAkura ko ulaTA bhIDAye vinA merA nistAra nahIM hai- apane tAvedAra 'ziremala' nAmake gAMva sAyalA ke gRhastha yati ko jodhapura 'dAsapA ' ThAkura ke pAsa bhejA aura usa ke dvArA una ko apane rodana sunAye, maraNa kA bhaya sunAyA, upadrava kA bhaya batAyA, para jo pRthvI ko pAlanA jAnatA hai, dharmAdharma kA phala mAnane vAlA hai aisA eka dAnA kSatriyaputra isa prakAra ke kaMgale vacanoM se kyA Dara jAyagA ? ' agara aisA ho to usakI jAti ko kalaMkita hI samajhanA cAhiye / vaha kSatriya vIra isa klIbocita vacanoM se tanika bhI nahIM Dara ke apanI acala pratijJA-pahale diye hue pratiSThA meM roka Toka nahIM karane ke vacana ko pAlane meM tatpara rhaa| ___ sAtha hI -- ito vyAghrastatastaTI' isa prakAra ke saMkaTa meM sapaDAye hue isa buDhDhe kI bhI usa dayAlu rAjapUta ko dayA AI, taba apane vAghare gAMva ke havAladAra ko likha diyA ki 'dhanavijayajI ko bhI vAgharA ke mahAjana pratiSThA meM sAmila rakkhe to ThIka hI hai,' yaha ThAkura sAhaba kA likhanA hukamarUpa nahIM para salAha mAtra thA, aura isa mujaba karane ko to vAgharA vAle pahale hI se tayyAra the / ataeva vAgharAse 10-15 zrAvaka sAMthu gaye, dhanavijayajI kI zaratoM ko mAnane ke badale ulaTI apanI tarpha se kitanIka zarateM unheM kabUla karAke le Aye / pratiSThA bhI kI, apanA matalaba bhI kiyA aura AkhirakAra zrAvakoM kI tarpha se gAliyoM kA zirapAva pA kara vAgharA se bidA hue| lekhaka jI! kyA yaha sArI kI sArI hakIkata jaina dharma kI

Page #95
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / hAMsI-masvarI karAne vAlI nahIM hai ?, yaha Apa kA 'paropadezapAMDitya ' nahIM ki Apake guru to mana AyA bake to bhI vaha hAMsI maskharI karane vAle nahIM aura dUsarA koI yogya bAta kahe to bhI use hAMsI-masvarI karAne vAlA kahanA ? vAha jI vAha ! pakSapAta ke kAle cazme to ThIka pahine haiN| lekhaka jI : jainabhikSajI hamezA sacca ke ghoDe daur3Ate haiM aura ve AsAnI se sugati ke sukha ko bhogeMge, kAraNa ki satyavaktA sadA hI sugati kA bhAgI hotA hai yaha eka sarvamAnya siddhAnta hai| hAM jo gappavAdI haiM, apanI sArI jIMdagI hI prapaMcI kAmo meM bItAte haiM unakA to DerA avazya ratnaprabhA Adi vizAlabhUmiyoM meM hI hogA, jainabhikSu sarIkhe saralahRdayI manuSyoM kA aisA karma kahAM jo ve ukta sthAnoM kI saphara kreN| phira lekhaka apanI sAdhutA kA paricaya dete haiM ki " rAjendrasUrijI ke ine gine 10 - 15 sAdhu haiM to jainabhikSujI ke aMdhaguru aMdha zraddhA ke eka do hI ine gine hoyaMge ! ! je kara kahogeM ki aMdhaguru ke ziSya ne to pIta ( pIlA ) vastra dhAraNa kiyA jisa se ina ke pakSI sAdhu aneka haiM ! ine gine nahIM haiM ! to zrIrAje. ndrasUrijI ke bhI zvetAmbara ( sapetavastra ) ke dhAraNe vAle sAdhu aneka haiM jisa liye ine gine nahIM kahe jAveMge ! " lekhaka jI! grAmazArdUloM kI taraha apane niyata gaDDoM meM hI na bharA kara jarA talAza kIjiye ki jainabhikSu jI ke guru aMdha haiM ki dekhate ? ve aMdhazraddhAlu vyakti haiM ki sAragrAhI ? aura una ke sAdhu ine gine eka do hI haiM ki eka do vIsI ? aura

Page #96
tristutika-mata - mImAMsA / isa bAta kI bhI khoja kareM ki kaI pIDhiyAM varNaparAvartita vastra dhAraNa karatI AI haiM yA Aja kala kA hI yaha bartAva hai ? na mAlUma aisA uTapaTAMga likhamAranA lekhakoM ne kisa guru se sIkha liyA hogA ? | lekhaka kahate haiM ki " zvetavastra vAle saba sAdhu rAjendrasUrijI ke hI haiM " maiM nahIM samajha sakatA ki sarva zvetAmbara sAdhuoM ko lekhaka rAjendrasUrijI ke kisa nyAya se kahate haiM ? prathama to vartamAna meM aaaa dhArI kahalAne vAle sAdhu hI ve haiM jo prANAtipAtAdi pAMca prakAra ke Azravo meM lage rahate haiM aura mAre lobha ke gAMva 2 bhaTakate phirate haiM kyA unheM bhI lekhaka rAjendrasUrijI ke sAdhu mAnate haiM ? | zAyada mAna bhI leM para yaha bhI hove kaise ? | rAjendrasUrijI se to ye loga bhI isa kadara napharata karate haiM jaise ullU se kau ! | 77 yadi pAyacaMda yA aMcalagaccha ke sAdhuoM ko lekhaka rAjendrasUrijI ke mAnate hoM to yaha bhI anyAya hai, unakA mata dUsarA unakI kriyA judI to ullU ke sivA dUsarA kauna unako apanA kaha sakatA hai ? | yadi ve se hI lekhakoM ko unakA moha lagA ho to unake sAtha AhAra- pAnI, vaMdanAdi vyavahAra kyoM nahIM karate ? kyoM lekhakajI ! aba to Apa ke sUrijI ke ine gine 10 - 15 sAdhu hai yaha siddha huA ki nahIM ? | phira lekhakajI bayAna karate haiM ki

Page #97
. 78 tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / "pahile rAjendrasUrijI ko guru mAna ke una kI samAcArI kA vartAba meM varta ke tinakI hitazikSA kI tarjanA ke mAre una kA guru pada choDa aura ko guru karanA ! vA mukha se to kahanA hamAre rAjendrasUrijI guru haiM aura tina kI likhita samAcArI [ kalamoM ] ke mujaba nahIM vartanA apane manamAnI samAcArI karanA vaise sAdhuoM kA gharakI yaha samakita dene kI vidhi jainabhikSujI ne chapavAI hai paraMtu khAsa rAjendrasUrijI ke sAdhuoM kI yaha samakita dAna ( dene ) kI vidhi nahIM hai kiMtu gacchabahAra ke sAdhuoM kI hai ! " lekhaka jI ! pahale mere isa prazna kA uttara dIjiye ki aMgAramardakAcArya ko usa ke pAMca sau ziSyoM ne kyoM choDa diyA ? jamAlI ko usake parivAra ke sAdhuoM ne kisa liye tyAga diyA ? / kahoge ki ve to kramazaH abhavya aura ninhava the ! to yahAM bhI jAnalo ki jaba taka kisI ko yaha mAlUma na huA ki 'rAjendramUrijI zAstraviruddha calate haiM ' saba una ke kahane meM calate rahe, para jaba yaha bAta samajha meM A gaI ki rAjendramUrijI kA mata zAstrasaMmata nahIM hai taba to una ke mata kA aura gurupada kA tyAga avazya karanA hI cAhiye ! kyA bhavabhIru jIvoM ko yaha ucita hai ki 'gadhe kI pUMcha pakaDI so pakaDI, cAhe dAMta bhI gira jAya~ para use choDanA nahIM ?,' nahIM 2 yaha vAta acchI nahIM hai, saMsAra meM vaha manuSya mUrkha kahalAtA hai; jo apanI tuccha buddhi se asatya vastu ko satya mAna letA hai, aura usakA bhI ziromaNi vaha hai, jo asatya ko asatya jAnake bhI usa ko satya kaha kara pakaDe rahatA hai|

Page #98
tristutika--mata-mImAMsA / maiM kyA sArA saMsAra una mahAnubhAva puruSoM kI stuti karatA hai; jo jhUThI mAnyatA ko jalAMjali dekara satyavastu kA svIkAra karate haiM, lekhaka bhI yadi satyagrAhI hone kA dAvA karate hoM to cAhiye ki ve bhI rAjendramUrijI kA guru pada choDa ke kisI mahApuruSa ko guru kara leM yadyapi lekhakoM ke guru dhanavijayajI ne to unakA gurupada kabhI kA choDa diyA huA hai; tathApi kheda kI bAta hai ki abhItaka unhoM ne apanA abhimAna choDa ke kisI bhI dUsare munirAja kA gurutva nahIM svIkArA ! / maiM bAravAra dhanavijaya jI se prArthanA karatA hUM ki ve kisI mahAtmA ke pAsa upasaMpada dhAraNa kara ke vItarAmadeva ke vacanoM ke ArAdhaka baneM, na jAne yaha kSaNavinazvara deha kisa vakta miTTI meM mila jAyagA, isa kA kSaNamAtra vizvAsa na kara ke jinAjJArAdhaka honA hI buddhimAnI kA lakSaNa hai| pAThakadvaMda ! dekhiye aura sociye ki 'mukhase to kahanA hamAre rAjendramurijI guru haiM aura tina kI likhita samAcArI ( kalamoM ) ke mujaba nahIM vartanA' yaha lekhakoM kA lekha kina ke liye hai ? isa prakAra ye loga kisa vAste AMsu girAte haiM Apa samajhe ? agara nahIM samajhe hoM to suniye-yaha azrupAta hai una ke nijadhara ke pIche ! una ke ghara meM hI bar3I phUTaphATa ho rahI hai, ina ke parivAra ke hI sAdhu lekhakoM ke vartamAnAcArya kA hukma nahIM mAnate, basa isI duHkha kA yaha rudana hai, aura yahI kAraNa hai ki samakita dAnavidhi kA doSAropaNa lekhakoM ne una ke Upara maMDhA hai, bAkI vAstava meM to lekhakoM ke ghara meM bhI samakita dAna vidhi vahI hai jo jainabhikSu ne likhA hai|

Page #99
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / phira lekhaka jI apanI ajJatA jAhira meM lAte haiM ki " vyavahAra samakita ke liye vinA pitAmbarI sAdhu jo vrata paJcakkhANa dezaviratIpaNA sarvaviratIpaNA lete dete haiM ve saba paramAtmA ke zAsana ko naSTa karane vAle haiM " lekhakoM ne kisa pItAmbarI sAdhu ko dekhA ki samyaktva vinA dezasarvaviratyAdi kisI ko diyA ? eka do nAma to likha dene the / lekhaka jI! abhI taka tuma gRhazUra ho, isa bAta kI tumheM khabara nahIM ki una kA-jina kI Apa ' pItAmbarI' kaha kara ghRNA karate haiM-kaisA suMdara vyavahAra hai, ve kisa rIti se logoM ko dharma grahaNa karAte haiM, agara Apane kisI bhI paraMparAgata sAdhu kI sevA kA lAbha prApta kiyA hotA to yaha kahane kA kabhI maukA na AtA ki ve saba paramAtmA ke zAsana ko naSTa karane vAle haiN| ve paramAtmA ke sAzana ko naSTa karane vAle nahIM haiM, naSTa karane vAle ve haiM; jo manuSya kI lyAkata dakhe vinA use pratijJA karA dete haiM ki ' amuka kArya nahIM karanA, ' para yaha nahIM socate ki isa kA natIjA kyA hogA? kaI traistutikazrAvakoM kI yaha dazA AMkhoM dekhI jAtI hai ki pahale to samyaktva vigairaha lekara isa kadara siddhAI batAte haiM ki mAnoM AnaMda zrAvaka kahe so to yahI hai, para jaba koI nirjIva bhI kAraNa upasthita hotA hai to mAmA, mAtA, kSetrapAla Adi mithyAtvI devoM ke Age bhI zira jhukAte haiM, aura unheM balidAnAdi karate rote phirate haiM / lekhaka mahAzaya khayAla kareM ki Apa kI karAI huI pratijJA kI kyA dazA huI ? usa kA samUla nAza huA ki kasara rhii|

Page #100
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / yadi kahA jAya ki yaha to usane una devoM kI pUjA mA. nyatA sAMsArika kArya ke nimitta kI hai| to javAba yaha hai ki dUsarA kauna mokSa ke nimitta unheM pUjatA hai ? jisane Apa kA samyaktva nahIM liyA vaha bhI agara kisI nimitta para unheM yAda karegA to sAMsArika dRSTi se hI, yaha to vaha kahatA hI nahIM ki 'mokSa prApti ke artha maiM ina mithyAtvI devoM kI pUjA karatA hUM' aura yaha bhI to koI kahatA nahIM ki sAMsArika kAryoM ke lie bhI mithyAtvI devoM kI pUjA nirdoSa hai ! / kahane kA matalaba yaha hai ki vinA soce samajhe 10-12 varSa ke bAlakoM ko aura ajJAnI logoM ko pUrvokta pratijJA karavAnA bhUla hai, kyoM ki ve use pAla nahIM sakate / AkhirameM usa niyama ko khaMDita karake Apa hI ke mata se mahApApI banate haiM, kyoM ki tumhAre hI mata vAle kahate haiM ki 'vrata nahIM lenevAlA pApI, aura lekara khaMDita karane vAlA mahApApI, ' phira becAre una ajJAniyoM ko jAnabUjha ke mahA pApI kyoM banAte ho| ___yaha dazA to huI dezavirati kI, aba sarvavirati ke bhI kucha hAlAta suna lIjiye, sAdhupana ( sarvavirati) bhI ye loga jisa tisa pAmara manuSya ko bhI de dete haiM natIjA yaha AtA hai ki jaba mulka meM sukAla ho jAtA haiM peTa bharane kA upAya sulabha hotA hai taba ve dukAliye peTa ke pUjArI amUlyacintAmaNitulya cAritra ke upakaraNa-rajoharaNa, muhapattI vigairaha ko kahIM kuMe Adi meM pheMka ke apanA rastA lete haiM-bhAga jAte haiM / isa prakAra kA banAva varSa bhara meM do cAra vakta to bana hI jAtA hai, aura jainadharmakI baDI nindA hotI hai, jaba koI zAsanarAgI una ko 11

Page #101
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / kahatA hai ki 'isa prakAra dharma kI hAni karane vAlA kArya Apa ko nahIM karanA cAhiye to ve uttara dete haiM ki 'tuma isa bAta meM kyA samajho ! sAdhuoM kA to yahI dharma hai, jyoM tyoM karake bhI saMsArI ko saMsAra choDAnA cAhiye, yogyA'yogyatva kI parIkSA dekhane ko jAveM taba to kAma pAra hI kaise jAve ! jo ho so ho, use muMDa to lenA hI cAhiye, pIche vaha agara calA bhI jAyagA to isa meM hAni kyA hai ? jitanA samaya cAritra pAlegA vaha to kahIM jAne kA nahIM ? kumhAra nivAha pakAtA hai to yaha to hotA hI nahIM ki sabhI bartana akhaMDa paka jAya~, kitane phUThate haiM, kitane kacce rahate haiM, aura kitane pakate haiM / isI prakAra yahAM para bhI samajhalo!, koI bhagegA koI mUrkha rahegA aura koI acchA bhI niklegaa|' priyapAThakagaNa ! dekha lI rAjendrasarijI kI mAnyatA ? hai 'tIna loka se mathurA nyArI' ki nahIM ? , bhalA, itanA hI nahIM-ye loga vinA AjJA jisa tisa ko muMDa lete haiM yahI bAta nahIM, Aja kala ke AraMbhI yatiyoM kI mavAphika seMkaDoM rupayA de kara laDakoM aura AdamiyoM ko kharIdavAnA bhI nahIM bhUlate ! isa viSaya meM aneka daphe satya hakIkata sunI gaI hai| misAla rAjendra mUrijI ke eka bhakta zrAvaka kA likhA huA khata mujhe milA hai, usa kA saMkSipta sAra yaha hai ki "mahArAja rAjendrasUrijI kI AjJA se ru. 200) do sau mere pAsa ke jJAna khAte ke aura 150) sA. suratIMgajI manAjI gAMva harajI vAloM kI tarpha se tathA, 50) vaDanagara-mAlavA vAle bAlajI ke,

Page #102
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / 83 evaM ru. 400) cAra sau nAI 'mAnA' ke ghara vAloM ko de ke mAnA ko saMvat 1941 ke dvitIya jeTha sudi 3 tIja ke dina gAMva zivagaMja meM rAjendrasUrijI kA ziSya banavAyA" agara kisI ko isa bAta meM zaMkA ho to ve mere pAsa rahe hue asalI khata ko dekha leveM, usa meM sAla, tithI, nAMva vigairaha sabhI bAteM khulAse vAra likhI haiM / dUsarA yaha ki jisako ye loga dIkSA dete haiM usa ke saMbaMdhiyoM kI AjJA kI bhI paravA nahIM karate, AjJA mila gaI to ThIka nahIM to cupa cApa rIti se bhI use muMDa hI lete haiM jisa kA natIjA yaha AtA hai ki usa ke saMbaMdhiyoM ko khabara pahuMcate hI ve Akara oghA, muhapatti dUra pheMkate haiM aura cAritrI ko phira gRhastha veza pahinA ke ghara pai le jAte haiM, isa viSaya ke bhI aneka dRSTAnta haiM, Ahora kasbe ke traistutika zrAvaka javAnamalajI bUTA ke putra ' motIcaMda ' ko rAjendramUrijI ne gAMva bhaMsavADe' meM isI prakAra se gupta dIkSA dI thI aura dIkSita kA bar3A bhAI 'kezaramala bUTA ' oghA muhapatti pheMka ke use vApisa ghara le gayA jo abhI taka saMsAra meM baiThA hai| abhI thoDe hI mahInoM kI bAta hai, usI javAnamalajI ke paute 'jasarAja' ne rAjendrasUrijI ke sAdhuoM ke pAsa gupta rIti se dIkSA le lI aura usa kA kAkA motIcaMda-jisane pahale dIkSA lI thI use pIchA ghara le gyaa| baDe hI aphasosa kI bAta hai, isa prakAra burA natIjA dekha ke bhI ye apanI burI rItiyoM kA parityAga nahIM krte| pAThaka mahodaya ! jina ke ghara meM itanI pola hai, cAritra jaise

Page #103
tristutika mata-mImAMsA / amUlya ratna ko bhI kupAtra meM nAMkhate jina ko tanika mAtra vicAra nahIM ve samyakatva ko vinA bicAre jahAM tahAM becate phireM isameM to Azcarya hI kyA hai ? / / lekhakajI ! jarA dila meM khyAla karo ki paramAtmA ke zAsana ko naSTa karane vAle pItAMvarI haiM ki rAjendramUrijI ke parivAra ke malinAmbarI / phira lekhaka apanI ajJatA kI nizAnI dikhAte haiM ki " vyavahAra samakita dene lene kI maryAdA to jainabhikSu pItAmbarI sAdhuoM ke guruparaMparA meM hI nahIM hai ?" lekhakoM ne kisa bhava meM jainabhikSu kI guru paraMparA ko dekhA ki usa meM samyaktva dene lene kI maryAdA hI nahIM ? hAM vaisI aMdhAdhuMdhI to nahIM hai jaisI Apa ke mata meM hai, bAkI dezavirati, sarvaviratyAdi dene ke samaya vaha AlApaka bhI avazya hI paDhA jAtA hai| jise tuma loga samyaktva kA pATha kahate ho, nyAya se dekhA jAya to honA hI isI mujaba cAhiye, samakita uccarAne ke bAre meM jina jina zAstroM ke nAma tristuti vAle pukArate haiM una saba se yahI siddha hotA hai ki pahale bhI prAyaH dezavirati vA sarvavirati dene ke samaya meM hI vaha pATha bolA jAtA thA na ki yogyatA vinA hI traistutikoM kI mavAphika use par3ha ke samakita de diyA jAtA thaa| agara aisA na hotA to kisI na kisI devatA ke adhikAra meM vaha pATha AnA cAhiye thA ki 'amuka devatAne amuka tIrthakara gaNadhara, kevalI yA muni ke pAsa samyaktva uccarA' kyoM ki devatA loga dezaviratI sarvaviratIrUpa cAritra ko nahIM pAla sakate; para

Page #104
tristutika- mata-mImAMsA | epa samyaktva to ve bhI pAla sakate haiM ? phira samakitI devoM ke a dhikAra meM una ke samyaktva uccara ne kA pATha kyoM nahIM ? Apa ke mata mujaba to avazya AnA hI cAhiye thA ! paraMtu aisA to kahIM bhI nahIM dikhatA, sirpha vahIM usa pAThakA ullekha hai jahAM sAdhu zrAvakadharma (sarvavirati dezavirati ) grahaNa karane kA adhikAra hai, isa liye lekhakoM ko kabUla karanA hogA ki vinA vrata ke kevala samakita uccarAne kA pATha zAstra meM nahIM dikhatA / kyoM lekhaka jI ! aba to samajhe na ? basa isI liye jainabhikSu jI kI paramparA kevala pATha sunA ke logoM ko samakitI nahIM banAtI !, yadi Apa ke pAsa isa se viruddha yAnI vrata vinA bhI kevala samyaktva ucarAne kA pramANa ho to peza kIjiye usa kI samAlocanA karane ko hama tatpara haiM / lekhakoM ko yAda rahe ki jainabhikSu aura usake sAthiyoM kI aisI to zAstrasaMmata pravRttiyAM haiM ki Apa to kyA Apa jaise sahasroM vyaktiyAM kaTibaddha ho jAya~ to bhI unheM nahIM tor3a sakatIM ! | aba lekhaka logoM ko upadeza karate haiM << aho bhavyo ! Apa loga apane 2 kalyANa kara nA cAhate ho to aise jainazAsana kI hilanA ( nindA ) ke karAne vAle jaina bhikSu kA prasaMga mata karo " merA bhI yahI kathana hai-' jo manuSya apanA bhalA cAhe vaha jinamArgabAhya nihnava jainabhikSuoM kA paricaya kadApi na kare ' / aise pItavastradhArI jaina bhikSu " ityAdi le ke " tisa kI sthApanA karane ko prarUpaNA meM kaTibaddha huye haiM " yahAM taka lekhakoM ne "C

Page #105
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / sirpha piSTapeSaNa kiyA hai, kyoM ki yahI bAta inhoM ne pahale bhI likha dI thI, isa liye isa kA uttara bhI pahale hI dediyA gayA hai, lekhakoM kI taraha yahAM phira piSTapeSaNa karanA mujhe rucikara nhiiN| lekhaka vAra bAra yaha pukArate haiM ki 'caturtha stuti kisI bhI jainazAstra meM nahIM kahI' isa lie caturthastuti ko siddha karane vAle kucha zAstroM ke pramANa bhI yahAM likha detA huuN| (1) "vaiyAvRttyakarANAM pravacanArthaM vyApRtabhAvAnAM yakSAmrakUSmANDyAdInAM, zAntikarANAM kSudropadraveSu, samyagdRSTInAM sAmAnyenA'nyeSAM samAdhikarANAM, sva-parayosteSAmeva, svarUpametadevaiSAmiti vRddhasaMpradAyaH, eteSAM saMbandhinaM-saptamyarthe SaSThI-etadviSayam etAnAzritya karomi kAyotsargam / kAyotsargavistaraH pUrvavat / stutizca navarameSAM vaiyAvRttyakarANAM, tathA tadbhAvavRddharityuktaprAyam // ( hAribhadrIya lalitavistarA vRtti ) (2) " paJcabhirdaNDakaiH, stuticatuSkeNa, zakrastavapaJcakena, praNidhAnena ___cotkRSTA caityavandaneti " (zrIdevamUrIya yatidinacaryA) (3) " tathA paJcadaNDakaiH -zakrastava, (1) caityastava (2) nAmastava (3) zrutastava (4) siddhastavAkhyaiH, (5) stuticatuSTayena, stavanena, jaya vIyarAyetyAdi praNidhAnena ca utkRSTA / " (mAnavijayopAdhyAyakRta dharmasaMgraha ) (4) tahA sakkatthayAidaMDagapaMcaga-thuIcaukka-paNihANakaraNato saMpuNNA, esA ukkosA / " ( vandanakacUrNi) (5) " evaM ca zakrastavapaJcakaM bhavati, utkRSTacaityavandanayA vanditukAmaH

Page #106
tristutik-mt-miimaaNsaa| sAdhuH zrAvako vA caityagRhAdau gatvA yathocitapratilakhitapramArjitasthaNDilastrailokyagurau vinivezitanayanamAnasaH saMvegavairAgyabharojjambhamANaromAJcakaJcukitagAtraH prAptaprakarSaharSavazavisarpadvASpapUrapUrNanayananalinaH sudurlabhaM bhagavaccaraNAravindavandanamiti bahumanyamAnaH susaMvRtAGgopAGgo yogamudrayA jinasaMmukhaM zakastavamaskhalitAdiguNopetaM paThati, tadanu airyApathikIpratikramaNaM karoti, tataH paJcaviMzatyucchAsamAnaM kAyotsarga kRtvA pArayitvA 'logassujjo agare ' tyAdi paripUrNa bhaNitvA jAnunI ca bhUmau nivezya mArjitakarakuzezayastathAvidhasukavikRtajinamaskArabhaNanapUrva zakrastavAdibhiH paJcabhirdaNDakairjinamabhivandate, caturthastutiparyante punaH zakrastavamabhidhAya dvitIyavelaM tenaiva krameNa vandate, tadanu caturthazakrastavabhaNanAnantaraM stotraM pavitraM bhaNitvA * jayavIyarAya ' ityAdikaM ca praNidhAnaM kRtvA punaH zakrastavamabhidhatte, ityeSotkRSTA caityavandanA airyApathikIpratikramaNapUrvikaiva bhavati, jaghanya-madhyame tu caityavandane airyApathikIpratikramaNamantareNApi bhavatIti ( bhavata iti )" (pravacanasAroddhAravRtti / ) (6) " iri 1 namukkAra 2 namutthuNaM, 3 / 'rihaMtathuI 4 loga 5 saba 6 thuI 7 pukkha 8 / thui 9 siddhA 10 veyA 11 thuI 12, namo tyu jAvaMti thaya jayavI // 62 // savvovAhivisuddhaM, evaM jo vaMdae sayA deve / debiMdaviMdamahiaM, paramapayaM pAvai lahu so // 63 // (devavandanalaghubhASya ) (7) " tataH * siddhatti '--siddhANamityAdi bhaNitvA -- veyatti '

Page #107
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / veyAvaJcagarANamityAdinA kAyotsargaH kAryaH, tataH 'thuI tti ' vaiyA vRttyakarAdiviSayaiva caturthI stutidIyate / " ( bhASyavRtti ) ina uparyukta zAstra pAThoM kA artha kramavAra nIce mujaba hai--- (1) yAvacca karane vAle yAnI jinazAsana ke viSe vyApAra ( pravRtti ) vAle, tathA kSudropadravoM ke viSa samakita dRSTiyoM aura dUsaroM ke zAnti ke karane vAle, tathA samakitadRSTiyoM ke aura svapara ke samAdhi karane vAle, kyoM ki ina kA svarUpa ( svabhAva ) hI yaha hai aisA vRddha puruSoM kA saMpradAya hai-yakSa Amra kuSmANDAdi ke saMbandhI ( saptamI ke artha meM paSThI ho ne se yaha bhAva ki ) ina ko Azrita-adhikRtakara ke kAyotsarga karatA hUM, kAyotsarga kA vistAra pUrva kI mavAphika jAnanA / itanA vizeSa ki yahAM stuti vaiyAvacca karane vAle pUrvokta devatAoM kI kahanI, kyoM ki isI prakAra una ke bhAva kI vRddhi hotI hai| (2) pAMca daMDakoM se cArathuiyoM se, pAMca zakrastavoM se aura praNi dhAna pATha se utkRSTacaityavandanA hotI hai / (3) tathA, zakastava 1 caityastava 2 nAmastava 3 zrutastava 4 siddhastava 5 nAmaka pAMca daMDakoM se, cAra stutiyoM se, stavana aura praNidhAna pATha-'jaya vIyarAya ' ityAdi se utkRSTa caityavandanA hotI hai| (4) tathA zakastavAdi pAMca daMDakoM cAra stutiyoM aura praNidhAna ke karane se saMpUrNa caityavandanA hotI hai, yahI utkRSTA kahI jAtI hai|

Page #108
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / (5) pAMca zakrastava isa prakAra se hote haiM-utkRSTacaityavandanA se devavandana karane kI icchA vAlA sAdhu vA zrAvaka jinamaMdira Adi meM jAkara yathA yogya pratilekhita aura pramArjita kiyA hai sthAna jisane, tathA nayana aura mana jisane trilokIguru ( tIrthakara ) ke viSe lagAyA hai, saMvega aura vairAgya ke samUha se khaDe hue romAJcoM se jisakA zarIra chA gayA hai, prApta hue atiharSa ke vaza nikalate hue azrujala se jisa ke nayanakamala bhara gaye haiM 'bhagavaJcaraNakamala kA vandana bahuta durlabha hai' isa prakAra bahumAna karatA huA, aMgopAMgoM ko acchI taraha jisane saMvarA hai (aisA sAdhu vA zrAvaka) yoga. mudrA se bhagavatke Age zakrastava ko askhalitAdi guNoM sahita paDhe, pIche IryAvahI paDikkama ke paccIsa zvAsocchAsa pramANa kAyotsarga kare, pAra ke 'logassujoagare' ityAdi saMpUrNa kahe, bAda donoM jAnu jamIna para rakha kara kara-kamala jor3a ke acche kaviyoM ke race hue apUrva namaskAra-stotra pAThapUrvaka zakastavAdi pAMca daMDakoM se jinavaMdana kare, cauthI thuI ke aMta meM phira zakastava kaha kara dUsarI bAra bhI isI krama se vAMde, bAda isa ke cauthI bAra zaka stava kahane ke anaMtara pavitra stotra paDha kara jayavIyarAya' ityAdi praNidhAna pATha kaha ke phira zakrastava kahe, isa prakAra yaha utkRSTa caityavandanA IryAvahIpratikramaNapUrvaka hI hotI hai, paraMtu jaghanya aura madhyama caityavaMdanA ryAvahI vinA bhI hotI haiN| (6) IyaryAvahI, namaskAra, namutthuNaM, arihaMtaceiyANaM, stuti, loga ssa, sabaloe, stuti, pukkharavaradI, stuti, siddhANaM buddhANaM,

Page #109
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / vaiyAvaccagarANa, stuti, namutthuNaM, jAvaMti, stavana, jayavIyarAya // 62 // isa vidhi se sarvopAdhivizuddha jo nitya devavaMdana karatA hai vaha jaldI devendrapUjita parama pada ko pAtA hai| (7) pIche 'siddhANa buddhANaM' par3ha kara * veyAvacagarANaM' ityAdi se kAyotsarga karanA bAda 'thuI ' yAnI veyAvaccakarane vAle devoM kI caturtha stuti denI ( kahanI ) / pAThakamahodaya ! Apa dekha sakate haiM ki uparyukta zAstrapAThoM meM kaisA sApha sApha cAra stutiyoM se devavaMdana karanA kahA hai, phira jainabhikSu cAra stuti kI prarUpaNA karane ko kaTibaddha kyoM na hove ? / ina pAThoM se lekhaka yaha siddha kara sakate haiM ki yaha vidhi pUjA pratiSThAdi kAraNa vizeSoM meM karane kA hai ?, nahIM, yaha bAta hI nahIM, ina meM to ulaTA yoM kahA ki ' isa vidhi se jo niraMtara devavaMdana karatA hai| vaha jaldI mukti pada ko pAtA hai|" (dekho pramANa 6 ThA) yadi lekhakoM kI kalpanA mujaba yaha vidhi kAraNika hotA to isa meM 'sadA' zabda kyoM AtA? kyA viziSTa kAraNa sadaiva bane rahate haiM / dasarA yaha ki uparyukta cAra stuti ke devavaMdana ko mukti kA kAraNa kahA hai, khayAla karo ! agara yaha vidhi pUjA-pratiSThAdi viSaya kA mAneM to mukti kA kAraNa kaise kahA jAya ? kyoM ki pUjA-pratiSThAdi kArya to lekhakoM kI mAnyatA mujiba dravyastava hai aura dravyastava kA utkRSTa phala bAravAM devaloka

Page #110
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / kI prApti hai mokSa kI nhiiN| vAstava to yaha hai ki pUrvokta devavaMdana saMbandhI sarva vidhividhAna sAdhu zrAvakoM ke yathAzakti nitya karane ke haiM, ata eva una meM eka jagaha ' sAdhuH zrAvako vA ' isa prakAra sAdhu zrAvaka donoM kA grahaNa kiyA hai| phira lekhaka jI kahate haiM ki " aba isa jhUThA lekha kA aMta meM jhUThI sUcanA pUrvaka lekhako jainabhikSujIne samApta kiyA hai ! tisa kA satya ( saccA ) pratyuttara dAna pUrvaka * satyottaradAna lekha ko' hama bhI samApta karate haiM " lekhaka jI ! kyA hI acchA hotA yadi jainabhikSujI ke lekha kI satyatA para dRSTi rakha kara usa kA ucita uttara dete !, na mAlUma Apa logoM kI aisI Adata kyoM par3a gaI hai jo sarAsara jhUThA hotA hai use to saccA kahanA aura sacce ko jhUThA ? / khaira, jaisI tumhArI mrjii| para yAda rahe ki ApakI ina jhUThI karatUtoM ko sahana kara lene kA jamAnA hAla kA nahIM hai, jyoM jyoM Apa kI asatya karatUtoM kI viSavRSTi hogI tyoM hI tyoM usa ke Upara satyadalIloM kI amRtamaya vRSTi bhI hotI rhegii| phira lekhaka apanI akala kA namUnA dikhAte haiM " aba jaina bhikSu jI saba hiMdusthAna ke jahAM 2 ' zabdopalakSita ' sthAnoM kI sAbutiyAM de ke apanA lekha saccA kareM ! taba to ina ke AtmAkA uddhAra hoya nahIM to apanI jhUThI jIbhaDalI apanA hAtha se uddhAra kareM jaba uddhAra hoya" | jainabhikSu jI kA kathana yathArtha hai, jaba rAjendramUrijI ne

Page #111
92 tristuttika-maMta-mImAMsA / jAlora meM pratimA Upara kA lekha ghisavAyA, gAMma koraTe aura gur3e meM ghisavAne kA udyoga kiyA to yaha zaMkA ho sakatI hai ki unane ora jagaha bhI isa prakAra anucita vyavahAra kiyA hogA vastutaH kiyA hI hogA paraMtu una ke aMdhabhakta apane guru kI apakIrti hone ke Dara se usa bAta ko bAhara nahIM lAte / lekhaka jainabhikSu jI kI jIbha kA uddhAra karAyA cAhate haiM, merI rAya hai ki yaha kAma Apa ke liye hI lAbhakAraka hai, kyoM ki uddhAra usI cIja kA hotA hai jo TUTa-phUTa gaI ho yA kisI prakAra apavitra ho gaI ho, jainabhikSu ke satya lekha ko asatya kaha kara Apa kI jIbha ne jo apavitratA uThAI hai| mere khayAla se usa apavitratA se isa kA uddhAra honA hI cAhiye, para bAta kucha vicAraNIya hai, dAMtoM ke uddhAra kA upAya buddhimAnoM ne nikAla diyA, AMkhoM kA uddhAra bhI dekhA gayA hai, lekina jIbha kA uddhAra kisa prakAra karanA isa viSaya meM abhI taka kisI kI buddhine kAma nahIM kiyA, to lekhakoM kI isa apavitra jihA kA uddhAra hogA kaise ?, zAsanadeva kare isa kA bhI upAya kahIM nikala jAya ! / yahAM taka lekhakoM ne jainabhikSu ke 'koraTA tIrtha' zIrSaka lekha ke pIche TaoNya TA~ya kiyA jisa kA maine mAkUla javAba de diyaa| ___aba lekhaka jI 'aMdhazraddhA kA namUnA' isa lekha kI samAlocanA karate hue apanI buddhi kA pariziSTa khajAnA kholate haiM / maiM bhI ina ke jauharoM kI kImata karane ke liye tayyAra hU~ / pahile isa bAta kA itihAsa jAnanA jarUrI hai ki 'aMdha

Page #112
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / zraddhA kA namUnA' isa lekha kA janma kaise huA?, Apa kI isa jijJAsA kI tRpti ke lie kucha likha detA hU~, Apa gaura se pddh'eN| ___ koraTA tIrtha' zIrSaka lekha ne traistutika samAja meM eka uccATana maMtra kI garaja sArI, isa kA pATha yA zravaNa karate hI ve loga mAre jalana ke cillAne lage, krodha se vyAkula hone lage aura bAvare ho kara idhara udhara daur3ane lage, para niSphala! isa kA pratIkAra karane vAlA koI ustAda nahIM milA aura na ina ko zAnti milI, taba 'bAlI' nivAsI 'tArAcaMdra' nAmaka eka vyakti ko apane samAja kI dayA AI, vaha jAnanA kucha bhI nahIM lekina " nirastapAdape deze eraNDo'pi drumAyate " isa kahAvata ko yAda karake pratimaMtra calAne ko pravRtta huaa| para usane yaha to jAna liyA thA ki jainabhikSu ke lekha kA khaMDana karanA mAnoM loha ke caNe cAbaNe haiM-isa kA uttara denA hamArI zakti ke bAhara hai-taba kyA upAya kiyA ki usa lekha ke poiMToM (viSayoM) ko choDa kara mAtra rAjendramUrijI kI tArIpha ke do phikare likha diye-chapavA diye-aura yaha mAna ke rAjI ho gaye ki 'jainabhikSu' ke lekha kA khaMDana ho gyaa| isa rAjendramUrijI kI stuti se-'ajJAna aMdaghora mAravAr3a' zIrSaka lekha se-una kI azakti dekha ke jaina-bhikSu ne bhI una azakta-garIboM-para lekha dvArA bhI vizeSa AkramaNa karanA ucita na samajha kara DhAMka pichoDA kisa kA nAma' isa heDiMga ke eka choTe se lekha meM una kA DhAMka pichoDA khulA kara ke virAma le liyaa| yadyapi jainabhikSu ne dayA kI khAtira lekha meM ina kA adhika marmavedha nahIM kiyA-ina kA pIchA choDa diyA, para kaI zAsana

Page #113
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / premI sajjanoM ko yaha dayA asthAna mAlUma huI, cAhe jaise garIba to bhI AkhirakAra to durjana ! ina kI dayA karanA kisa ke ghara kA nyAya ? isI vakta takhatagar3ha nivAsI zrAvaka cimanalAla jI perAjajI ne 'aMdhazraddhA kA namUnA' zIrSaka eka vistRta lekha de kara usa rAjendrastuti ( ajJAna aMdaghora mAravADa ) lekha ke eka eka poiMTa kA yukti aura pramANoM dvArA pratyuttara diyA jo tA. 21 pharavarI san 1915 ke jaina ' patra meM Apa ne dekhA hogaa| basa usI lekha ke khaMDana meM navIna lekhaka jI pravRtta hue haiN| Apa dekheM ki zera ke zikAra meM lage hue gIdar3a kI kyA dazA hotI hai / aTakalapaccU lekhaka jI likhate haiM ki " isa ' DhAMka paccheDA ' lekha se itanA pattA lagA ki koraTA tIrtha kA jhUThA lekha likhane chapAne vAlA yaha jainabhikSu hai ! paraMtu pUrA pattA to tA. 21 phebruvArI san 1915 kA jaina aMka meM aMdhazraddhA kA namUnA ' heibila meM mahAzaya tArAcaMdajI kA lekha kI jhUThI samAlocanA kara lekhaka cimanalAla takhatagaDha vAlA kA nAma se chapavAyA, tisI se mAlUma bhayA ki aMdhaguru kA upAsaka ziSya kA ziSya ne yaha lekha chapavAyA hai taba hI ' aMdhazraddhA kA namUnA ' samAlocanA kA sthAna para-viSamAlocanA prakaTa kI hai" yaha lekhakoM kI mAnyatA sarAsara jhUThI hai ki 'koraTA tIrtha 'DhAMka pichoDA kisa kA nAma ' aura ' aMdhazraddhA kA namUnA' ye tInoM hI lekha eka vyakti ke likhe hue haiM, yaha to baccA bhI samajha sakatA hai ki 'DhAMka pichoDA' aura 'aMdhazraddhA kA namUnA'

Page #114
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / ina donoM kA lekhaka agara eka hotA to use do lekha dene kI jarUrata hI kyA thI ? ' aMdhazraddhA kA namUnA ' isa kA viSaya 'DhAMka pichoDA' isI lekha meM kyoM nahIM de diyA ? eka lekha meM kucha bhI na likha kara vahI lekhaka usI viSaya meM dUsarA lekha deve yaha to kamaakla ke sivA koI bhI nahIM mAna sakatA ! / lekhaka jI ! jarA AMkhoM ke par3ade aura hRhaya kA kabATa khola ke dekho aura talAza karo ki 'aMdhazraddhA kA namUnA' lekha kisane chapavAyA hai ? vinA hI tapAsa kiye kisI kA bahema dharanA adhama aura bevakUpha AdamiyoM kA kAma hai| 'aMdhazraddhA kA namUnA' lekha ke lekhaka ne 'tArAcaMdra' ke lekha kI aisI to yuktipUrNa samAlocanA kI hai ki tuma sAre traistutika ikaTThe ho kara talapa paDo to bhI usakA nirAkaraNa nahIM ho sakatA / tuma cAhe use viSamAlocanA hI kaho, kyoM ki jo viSaya jisake liye atikaThina hotA hai vaha usa ke Age viSama hI hai, yaha samAlocanA bhI tumhAre lie usI prakAra kI hai ataH tuma ise viSamAlocanA hI khiye| phira lekhaka apanI buddhi kA prakAza karate haiM ki-- "pUrvAcArya navAMgavRttikAraka-zrImadabhaya-devasUrijI mahArAja paMcAzaka sUtravRtti meM ' caturtha stutiH kilArvAcInA' isa vAkya meM (kila) avyaya kA jitanA artha vyAkaraNa, koza, yA jaina zAstroM meM kiyA haitina sarva artha se cothI thuI arvAcIna ( navIna ) hI siddha hotI hai" zrImad abhayadevamUrijI ne caturtha stuti ko arvAcIna kahA hai' yaha kahane vAle jhUTha ke pUtale haiM, abhayadevamUrijI ne ___

Page #115
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / .............. kisI jagaha aisA nahIM kahA ki 'caturtha stuti nayI hai' stutika loga " caturthastutiH kilArvAcInA" isa prakAra ke akSara dekha ke kUdane laga jAte haiM ki ahA ! ' abhayadevamUrijI cothI thuI ko nayI kahate haiM, ' paraMtu una bhole AdamiyoM ko yaha khayAla nahIM ki yaha vacana abhayadevamUrijI kA mAnya siddhAnta hai yA ve kisI kA mata pradarzita karane ke liye aisA likhate haiM ? / pAThakagaNa ! Apa dekha lIjiye paMcAzaka vRtti ke usa pATha ko jise tIna thuI vAle apanA matapoSaka samajhate haiM, " caturthastutiH kilArvAcInA, kimityAha utkRSyate iti utkarSA utkRSTA / idaM ca vyAkhyAnameke ----- tinnI vA kaTui jAva, thuIo tisiloiyA / / tAva tattha aNunnAyaM kAraNeNa pareNa vi // ityetAM kalpabhASyagAthAM, paNihANaM muttamuttIe iti vacanamAzritya kurvanti " bhAvArtha-caturthastuti zAyada arvAcIna hai, isa se kyA hotA hai ? aisA prazna hone para AcArya uttara dete haiM ki 'utkRSTA' yAnI pUrvokta vidhi se utkRSTa caityavaMdanA hotI hai, yaha vyAkhyAna Apa kisa zAstra ke AdhAra se karate haiM ? isa prazna kI upasthiti ke pahale hI Apa samAdhAna kara dete haiM ki yaha vyAkhyAna 'tinnI vA0' isa gAthA tathA 'paNihANaM0 ' isa vacana kA Azraya le ke koI AcArya karate haiM, arthAt hama aisA vyAkhyAna nahIM karate, anya koi eka AcArya karate haiN| isa se sApha 2 yaha siddha huA ki 'caturthastutiH kilArvAcInA' yaha vacana abhayadevamUri apanI tarapha se nahIM kahate

Page #116
tristutika -mata-mImAMsA / kiMtu dUsare kisI eka AcArya kA mata dikhAne ke lie likhate haiN| AcArya Apa isa vyAkhyA meM sahamata haiM ki nahIM isa zaMkA kA samAdhAna bhI AcArya ke hI vacana se ho jAtA hai, kyoM ki 'caturthastutiH kilAcInA ' yahAM para 'kila' zabda kA prayoga kara ke ukta vyAkhyA meM Apa apanI aruci jAhira karate haiM, kyoM ki AcArya zrImadabhayadevamUri jI zuddhaparaMparA mArga gAmI puruSa the, una ko zAstra-viruddha kalpanA pasaMda nahIM thI, ve pUrvAcArya kRta caityavaMdanabhASyAdi granthoM ko mAnane vAle the, isa viSaya meM ApakA sirpha eka hI vacana udhRta kara dikhAtA hUM, tA ki Apa samajha leMge ki ve pUrvAcAryakRta granthoM ko kaise pramANa karate the !, " tathA saMvegAdikAraNatvAdazaThasamAcaritatvAjjItalakSaNasyehApadyamAnatvAccaityavandanabhASyakArAdibhiretatkaraNasya samarthitatvAcca tadadhikataramapi tannA'yuktam / naca vAcyaM bhASyakArAdivacanAnyapramANAni, tadaprAmANye sarvathA''gamAnavabodhaprasaGgAt / " (pazcAzakaprakaraNavRtti , patra 17 ) artha- (mUtra meM caityavaMdana eka hI prakAra kA kahA hai to usa ke jaghanyamadhyamAdi bheda kyoM pAr3e gaye haiM ? isa pUrvapakSa kA upayukta pATha se Apa uttara dete haiM-)-saMvega Adi guNoM kA kAraNa hone se, azaTha puruSoM kA mAnA huA hone se jIta vyavahAra ke lakSaNa se yukta hone se aura caityavaMdanabhASyakAra Adine isa kA samarthana karane se adhikatara (jyAdA adhika) bhI caityavaMdana ayukta nahIM hai, bhASyakAra Adi ke vacana apramANa haiM yaha bhI 13

Page #117
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / nahIM kahanA, kyoM ki una ke aprAmANya meM AgamazAstroM kA bodha hI kisI prakAra nahIM ho skegaa| priya pAThaka ! isa se Apa samajha sakate haiM ki AcArya abhayadevamUrijI pUrvAcArya kI AcaraNA, una ke grantha aura vizeSa kara 'zAntimari' kRta caityavaMdanamahAbhASya ko kisa kadara se pramANa mAnate the| khayAla karane kI jagaha hai ki jisa bhASya ko abhayadevasUri sarva prakAra se pramANa bhUta ginate haiM usI bhASya meM kahI huI cAra aura ATha thuI kI caityavandanA ko choDa ke ve 'tIna thuI se utkRSTa caityavandanA hotI hai cothI thuI nayI hai' aisA kaheM yaha to ulluoM ke sivA koI bhI nahIM maanegaa| AcArya zrIabhayadevasaripramANita caityavaMdanabhASya meM kaisA spaSTa rIti se cAra aura ATha thuI se caityavandana likhA hai so dekha lIjiye" eganamokkAreNaM hoi kaniTThA jahanniA esA (1) / jahasattinamokkArA janniA bhaNNai vijeTTA ( 2 ) // sacciya sakkathayaMtA neyA jeTTA jahanniA sannA ( 3 ) / sacciya iriyAvahiA-sahiA sakkathayadaMDehiM // majjhimakaniTTigesA ( 4 ) majjhimamajjhimA u hoi sA ceva | ceiyadaMDayathuiegasaMgayA sabamajjhima yA (5) // majjhimajeTTA sacciya tinni thuIo siloyatiyajuttA (6) / ukkosakaNiTTA puNa sacciya sakkathayAijuA (7) / thuijualajualaeNaM duguNiaceiathayAidaMDA jA / sA ukosavijeTThA nihiTThA pubasUrIhiM ( 8) //

Page #118
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / thottapaNivAyadaMDagapaNihANatigeNa saMjuA esA ) / saMpuNNA vinneyA jeTThA ukkosiA nAma (9) // " (zAntimUrIya caityavandanamahAbhASya) artha-mAtra eka namaskAra karane se / jaghanyajaghanyA / caityavaMdanA hotI hai| 1 / eka se jyAdA yathAzakti namaskAra karanA ise 'jaghanyamadhyamA' caityavandanA kahate haiM / 2 / vahI zakrastavaparyanta karane se yAnI yathAzakti namaskAroM ke Upara zakrastava kahane se 'jaghanyotkRSTA' nAma kI tIsarI caityavandanA hotI hai / 3 / vahI-uparyukta caityavandanA IryAvahiyA ke sAtha zakrastavadaMDaka ke karane se 'madhyamajaghanyA' nAma kI cauthI caityavandanA hotI hai / 4 / yahI caityadaMDaka aura eka stuti ke sAtha karane se ' sarvamadhyamA' yAnI nava bhedoM ke madhyameM rahane vAlI ' madhyamamadhyamA' nAmA pAMcavIM caityavaMdanA kahI jAtI hai / 5 / ___ usI pAMcavIM eka stuti vAlI caityavaMdanA meM trizlokAtmaka tIna thuIyAM aura saMyukta kara dene se vaha cAra thuI kI ' madhyamotkRSTA' nAma kI chaThI caityavaMdanA hotI hai / 6 / / . isI chaThI caityavaMdanA meM zakrastavAdi adhika joDa dene se 'utkRSTajaghanyA' sAtavIM caityavaMdanA hotI hai / 7 / 'thuijualajuala' isakA artha hai ' ATha thuI ' kyoM ki" stutiyugalaM ca samayabhASayA stuticatuSkamucyate "

Page #119
100 tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / ityAdi zAstrIya vacanoM se-' thuijuala-stutiyugala ' isa kA artha huA stuticatuSka yAnI cAra thuI, isa kA yugala kahane se yAnI ise do daphe ginane se ' ATha stuti ' yaha artha pAyA, ataH stutiyugalayugala se ( ATha thuIyoM se ) aura yAvat caityastavAdi daMDakoM ko dugunA karane se 'utkRSTamadhyamA' nAmA AThavIM caityavaMdanA hotI hai / 8 / isI AThavIM caityavaMdanA ko stotra, praNipAtadaMDaka aura praNidhAna trika ke sAtha karane se saMpUrNA-'utkRSTotkRSTA' nAma kI navamI caityavaMdanA hotI hai / 9 / priyapAThaka ! Apa madhyasthabhAva se kahiye ki bhASyokta caityavaMdanA ke ina nava bhedoM meM eka bhI koI aisA bheda hai jisa meM tIna hI stutiyAM kI jAtI hoM ? / jaba bhASyakAra isa prakAra spaSTatayA cAra aura ATha stutiyoM se caityavaMdanA kA vidhAna pratipAdana karate haiM aura abhayadevamUri ise pramANa mAnate haiM to yaha kauna buddhimAn kahegA ki 'abhayadevamUri aisA kahate haiM ki caturtha stuti nayI hai ? ve Apa aisA nahIM kahate kiMtu ora koI aisI vyAkhyA karate haiM jise Apa likhate haiM aura zAstra-AcaraNA viruddha jAna kara usa meM Apa apanI aruci jAhira karate haiN| __kahA jAya ki-aruci jAhira karate haiM-yaha kaise jAnA ? to uttara yaha hai ki una ke mukha se nikalA huA 'kila ' zabda yaha bAta kaha rahA hai, kyoM ki prAmANika koSakAroMne jo jo 'kila ' zabda ke artha kiye haiM una saba se yahI siddha hotA hai ki lekhakoM ke priya pUrvokta vyAkhyAna meM TIkAkAra kI Apa kI saMmati nahIM hai|

Page #120
tristutika mata-mImAMsA | 101 amarakoza ke kartA ' kila ' zabda ke isa mujaba do artha likhate haiM. " kila saMbhAvya vArtayoH " ( amarakoza ) - saMbhAvanA aura vArtA ina do arthoM meM kila zabda kA prayoga hotA hai / AcArya hemacaMdra apane ' anekArtha saMgraha ' meM yoM likhate haiM" vArtA - saMbhAvyayoH kila, hetvarucyoralIke ca " ( haeNma anekArthasaMgraha ) -vArtA, saMbhAvanA, hetu, aruci aura jhUTha ina pAMca arthoM meM 'kila ' zabda kA prayoga hotA hai / lekhakajI ! kahiye 'kila nAma nizcaya kara ke, kila nAma nizcaya kara ke ' yaha Apa kA pokAra kisa prAmANika koza anusAra hai ? | / ke mAna bhI liyA ki Apa kA abhimata artha bhI kisI ne likha diyA to bhI kyA isa se yaha kaha sakate haiM ki 'abhayadeva sUri ' ne 'kila ' - zabda kA prayoga isI artha meM kiyA hai ? hargija nahIM / ve cAra stutipratipAdaka caityavaMdanamahAbhASya ko pUre taura se pramANa samajhate the isa lie cothI thuI ko navIna ThaharAne ke liye nahIM kiMtu aisI mAnyatA kA khaMDana karane ke liye unhoMne khAsa ' kila ' zabda kA prayoga kiyA hai, yaha bAta pahale hI kaha cukA hU~ | aba lekhaka jI apane zrAvaka tArAcaMdra kI vakAlata karate

Page #121
102 tristutika--mata-mImAMsA / hue 'ina jhagaDoM kA mUla kisane ropA ?' cimanalAla ke isa prazna kA uttara ghaDa kara kahate haiM ki " jisane mere lekha kI samAlocanA ko choDa, viSamAlocanA likha chapavAI tisa kA dAdAguruneM to-mUla ropA : aura tisa ke ziSya pratiziSyoM ne tathA tina ke pakSiyoM ne- jhUTha rUpa pAnI sIMca ke tIna cAra thuI saMbaMdhI jhagaDoM ke vRkSa baDhAye ! aura Aja taka aise 2 jhUTha lekha chapavA ke baDhAte hI rahe haiM ! to tuma lekhaka mahAzaya ko kyA javAba do ge ? je kara kahoM ge ki hamAre dAdAguru to -- aMdha the ! aura hamAre guru kucha paDhe gaNe nahIM the isa liye rAjendrasUrijI hI isa jhagaDA kA mUla ropA hai aura unane hI baDhAyA hai." yaha likhanA bhI lekhakoM kI ajJatA ko jAhira karatA hai kyoM ki na to tumhAre lekha ke samAlocaka ke guru ne isa kA mUla ropA na ina ke ziSyapratiziSyoM ne aura pakSiyoM ne tIna cAra stuti saMbaMdhI jhagaDoM ko baDhAyA aura na Aja kala bhI baDhA rahe haiM, yaha kAma tumhAre hI vAr3e kI bheDoM kA hai, ve hI ise acchI taraha pAra pahuMcAte haiM aura zAMta jainasamAja meM dveSa kI Aga bhaDakAte haiM, tathA samAlocaka ke guru to apaDha nahIM the, yaha padavI bhI Apa ke hI Tole meM sobhA pAyagI, aura una ke dAdAguru ko aMdha batAne vAle Apa hI aMdha jAna par3ate haiM, kyoM ki aMdhapana kA phala hI yaha hai ki sIdhe rAste se gira paDanA, yaha dazA tIna ke mata vAloM kI barAbara ho rahI hai / phira lekhaka jhUThI yukti calAte haiM ki " apane gaccha ke sAdhu sAdhviyoM kI pravartanA samAcArI (kalameM) bAMdhI, tIsa meM likhA hai ki-pUjA-pratiSThA, dIkSAdi nAMda vidhi meM cAra

Page #122
tristutik-mt-miimaaNsaa| 103 m.. ........................................ thuI karane kA nA nahIM to hAM to avazya hI huA " pAThakagaNa ! dekhiye traistutika loga mukha se to pukArate haiM 'hama tapagaccha kI samAcArI mujaba calate haiM, aura aMdara se manaHkalpita nayI samAcArI banA ke usa mujaba calate calAte haiM, yadi tapagacchIya sAmAcArI mujiba calate hote to ' nayI kalameM' bAMdhane kI hI kyA jarUrata thI? kyA tapagaccha meM prAcIna samAcArI grantha nahIM the ? isa se to yahI pAyA jAtA hai ki -- pUjA pratiSThAdi viziSTa kAryoM meM cAra; bAkI tIna thuI karanI caahiye| ityAdi kathana sarAsara asatya-pralApa hai, agara kisI bhI zAstra yA samAcArI grantha meM tIna stuti kA vidhAna hotA to isa ke liye nayI samAcArI ( kalameM ) bAMdhane kI hI kyA AvazyakatA thii| phira lekhaka apanI asatyatA kA namUnA dikhAte haiM " tumhAre dAdA guru ko rAjendrasUrijIne hita zikSA karI kigRhasthapana kA AraMbha chUTane ke liye tumane apane hAtha se bheSa dhAraNa kiyA ! taba maiMne zrAvaka kA vrata ucarA ke vAsakSepa kiyA hai kyoM ki-cakSuhIna ko zAstra meM dIkSA dene kI manA hai vAste aba tuma apane AtmA se logomeM sAdhupanA zraddhate zraddhAte ho? yaha vyavahAra acchA nahIM ! taba kadAgraha ke vaza ho ke tumhAre gurU aura dAdA gurU donoM ne tIna thuI ko choDa ke ' jAlora meM ekAnta sAmAyika sahita posaha pratikramaNAdika meM cAra thuI kA zaraNa liyA ! jaba se mAravADa meM tIna aura cAra thuI saMbaMdhI jhagaDA TaMTA kA vRkSa ATha AnA baDhA ! aba tumane to sole AnA kara diyA ! kyoM ki-prathama to tumhAre guru ko cakSuhIna kA ziSya rahane meM lajjA Ai ! taba zvetAmbara guru ko choDa ke

Page #123
104 tristutika- mata-mImAMsA / pItAmbara gurU kara zvetAmbara panA kA liMga ( veSa ) hI choDa diyA " pAThakamahodaya ! yadi Apa mahAmRSAvAda kA namUnA dekhanA cAhate hoM to lekhakoM kI isI dalIla ko dekha lIjiye merI samajha meM isa se baDha kara asatyatA kA dRSTAnta Apa ko dUsare kahIM bhI nahIM milegaa| ___ Apa ko isa bAre meM zaMkA avazya hogI ki yaha aisA asatya kisa prakAra ho sakatA hai, para maiM Apa kI isa zaMkA kA nirAkaraNa bhI sAtha hI kara diyA cAhatA hUM, AzA hai ki Age kA itihAsa paDha ke Apa apanI zaMkA kA nirAkaraNa svayaM kara leNge| tapagaccha ke zrIpUjya vijayadharaNendramUrijI kA vikrama saMvat 1923 kI sAla kA varSA caturmAsa kasbe 'ghAnerAva' meM huA, usa vakta bIkAnera' se yati ratnavijayajI bhI apane guru pramodavijayajI, guru bhAI himmatavijayajI Adi 7-8 yatiyoM se ghAnerAva caturmAsA karane ko Aye hue the / darmiyAna caturmAsa meM bhAdrapada zudi 3 ke dina zrIpUjyajI ne attara mola liyA aura ratnavijayajI ko dikhA kara kahA dekhiye yaha attara kaisA hai ? pAMca rupaye tole ke hisAba se liyA hai, ThIka hai yA nahIM ? ' / ratnavijayajI ne kahA aisA kImatI to yaha attara nahIM hai| yaha suna zrI pUjyajI ne 'ilojI ghoDoM ke pArakhU' tuma 1 yaha eka mAravADI kahAvata hai, jaba koI kisI vastukI parIkSA meM bhUla khA jAya taba usa parIkSaka kI maskharI karane ke liye isa kahAvata ko bolate haiM /

Page #124
tristutika-- mt-miimaaNsaa| 105 attara meM kyA samajho ! yaha kaha kara aMgulI bhara ke una ke kapaDe meM ragaDI taba ratnavijayajI ne apane kapaDe ke usa attara vAle bhAga ko jamIna ke sAtha ghisa ke sApha kiyA / yaha dekha zrIpUjya kruddha ho kara vole aise attara ko tuma dhUla meM milAte ho !, / ratnavijayajI bole-maiM to ise mUtra samajhatA hUM / ___yaha garviSTha vAkya zrIpUjya se sahana na huA-ve apane krodha ko nahIM roka sake, basa phira kyA thA usI samaya ratnavijaya jI ke mukha para eka thappaDa jamA diyaa| isa se ratnavijaya jI kA mijAja bigaDA, ve gusse ho kara bole ' tuma mujhe mArate ho !, maiM kaisA yati hUM! mujhe dUsare yatiyoM ke sarIkhA mata samajhanA !' vigairaha yadvA tadvA bolate hue uTha ke apane guru ke pAsa sthAna para gaye aura saba hakIkata apane guru ko kahI aura vahAMse nikala kara ' nADola ' gaye / yaha samaya paryuSaNa parva ke utAra kA thaa| isa arase meM 'Ahora' se zA0 'khUbA ' jI 'samaratha' jI maMdira ke lie patthara lene ko gAMva 'sonANe' gayA thA, usane logoM ke mukha se zrIpUjya aura ranavijaya jI kI khaTapaTa ke samAcAra sune, taba vaha ' nADola ' jA kara ranavijaya jI ko milA, saba hakIkata pUchI sunI, aura phira Ahora AyA, vahAM A kara usane logoM ko kahA ki ' apane upAdhyAya jI paraloka vAsI ho jAne se vyAkhyAnAdi kA aMtarAya par3atA hai isa liye agara saba bhAiyoM kI salAha ho aura ratnavijayajI ko yahAM para bulA leM to ThIka hai|'

Page #125
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / .. . . yaha bAta bahuta logoM ke gale utara gaI taba saba zrAvakoM ne mila kara zA0 ' ratanA nAthAjI' aura 'sAdha-motIrAma kA beTA-sahaja rAma ' tathA eka ' meNA ' ina tInoM ko uMTa bhADe karA ke ' nADola ' bheje / ' ratanA nathAjI' Asoja sudi 10 ke dina zuvaH ratnavijayajI ko le ke Ahora phuNcaa| aura ' sAdha-sahajarAma ' yati vinayavijaya ko lekara Asoja sudi 15 ke sAma ko Ahora aayaa| ratnavijayajI ne tapagaccha ke upAzraya meM sUtrakRtAMga (sUyagaDAMga ) sUtra aura samyaktvakaumudI kA vyAkhyAna zurU kiyaa| ___abhI taka pramodavijayajI ' nADola meM ' hI the / upAdhyAya sureMdrasAgarajI ke ziSya dalIcaMda bhI usa arase meM Ahora the| dhanarAja talAvata aura zeTha vAghajI navatattva kA abhyAsa karane lage / eka vakta dalIcaMda jI aura dhanarAja jI ke Apasa meM isa prakAra vAtolApa huAdalIcaMda-dhanA ! apana donoM daphtarIjI ( ratnavijayajI ) ke ziSya ho jAveM? dhanarAja-jIvavicAra sIkhate samaya jaba 'egidiyA ya savve' yaha gAthA maine sIkhI aura artha paDhA to mujhe saMsAra se baDA bhaya lagA, aura isa se chUTane kA upAya upAdhyAya jI ko pUchA to unhoMne kahA ki 'saMsAra ke bhaya se chUTa ne kA upAya to dIkSA hai paraMtu cakSuhIna ko dIkSA denA niSedha hai, aThArA prakAra ke puruSa aura vIsa prakAra kI striyAM dIkSA ke ayogya haiM, isa liye daphtarIjI mujhe to dIkSA

Page #126
tristutika mata-mImAMsA | 107 nahIM deMge aura mujhase dIkSA pala bhI nahIM sakegI / dulIcaMda - tau bhI daphtarIjI ko arja to kareM ki una kA isa bAre meM kyA abhiprAya hai / dhanarAja - hAM, isa meM koI hAni nahIM hai / isa prakAra Apasa meM bAta karate hue ve ratnavijayajI ke pAsa gaye aura apanA vicAra una ke Age prakaTa kiyA / ratnavijayajI saba suna lekara phira dhanarAja ko uddezya kara bole- 'tU khuzI se dIkSA le, aThArA prakAra ke puruSa dIkSA ke ayogya kahe haiM para vaha kathana TIkAkAroM ne pIche se likhA hai so kAraNika aura apekSA kA hai / vyavahAra meM acchA nahIM lage isa lie aisI maryAdA vAMdhI hai| sUtroM meM to aThArA prakAra ke puruSoM meM se kaI puruSoM ne dIkSA lI mAlUma hotI hai| jaise ki " juMgita ' ( nindya ) jAti ke puruSa ko TIkAkAroM ne ayogya kahA hai, aura sUtroM meM ' metArya, harikeza, citra, saMbhUta' vigairaha kaI hIna se bhI hIna jAti ke puruSa sAdhu hue the aisA dekhA jAtA hai / isa liye yaha bAta apekSA kI hai / paramArtha meM kucha bAdha nahIM / dhanarAjajI ne kahA - ' yaha Apa kA kathana to zAyada nizvayadRSTi se mAna bhI liyA jAya ki paramArtha meM bAdha nahIM, lekina vyavahAra meM loga carcA kareMge ki netrahIna ko dIkSA kyoM dI ? to Apa kyA javAba deMge ? | ratnavijayajI bole 'tU jAnatA hI hai ki isa samaya maiM parigrahadhArI hUM tathApi merA anizcita bhI irAdA hai ki isa parigraha ko kisI samaya chor3a duuNgaa| agara tU abhI dIkSA le leve to

Page #127
108 tristuttika - mata-mImAMsA / jaba hama parigraha chor3a ke nirgrantha baneMge taba tujhe bhI kriyoddhAra karA leMge / yadi koI pUchegA ki cakSuhIna ko dIkSA kyoM dI ? to hama ko uttara denA sulabha hogA ki ' hamane pahale hI isa ko dIkSA dedI thI to aba akelA kahAM rakkheM 1 | agara nirAdhAra rakha bhI chor3eM to jinazAsana kI helanA hove isa lie isa ko bhI kiyoddhAra karA ke sAtha meM rakkhA hai| yadi vaha kaheMge ki yatipana meM hI isa ko dIkSA kyoM dI? to hama kaheMge usa vakta hama ko sUtroM kA vizeSa jJAna nahIM thA isa liye yaha mAlUma nahIM huA ki netrahIna ko dIkSA denA niSedha hai / pIche se jAnA paraMtu aba kucha upAya nahIM hai / ' vAste tuma donoM dIkSA ke liye tayyAra ho jAo / ' ityAdi ratnavijayajI kI preraNA se dhanarAja aura dalIcaMdajI ne isa prakAra kA lakhata kiyA " apana donoM ko dIkSA lenI, jo inkAra kare vaha gaur3IjI ke maMdira meM 101 eka sau eka rupayA daMDa ke deve 19 Upara mujaba kA lakhata Ahora ke tapagaccha ke upAzraya meM saMvat 1923 ke kArtika sudi 5 kI rAtri ke samaya likhA aura nIce ' likhe nAma vAle ' cAra sadgRhasthoM kI sAkha bhI likhavAyI thI / sAkha likhane vAloM ke nAma ye haiM zA. rUpAjI bhagAvatazeTha TIkamajI. phUsAjI nemAjI. rughanAtha phatAvata. ina ke sivA nimna likhita nAma ke gRhastha bhI usa vakta

Page #128
tristutika - mata-mImAMsA / 109 upAzraya meM maujuda the, una ke nAma-zrImAlI ( brAhmaNa ) haThojI, mAnAjI AlujI, serA rUpAjI, tulasA sivAjI aura zeTha vAghajI vigairaha / ina saba mahAzayoM ke samakSa vaha lakhata dhanarAja aura dalIcaMda ne daphtarI- ratnavijaya jI ke sipurda kiyaa| zrIpUjyapadavI kA abhilASa / / rahate 2 jaba ratnavijayajI ke Upara Ahora vAle zraddhAvAn ho gaye taba unhoMne zrAvakoM se kahA-' nADolase mere gurujI ko bulA lAo, mujhe zrIpUjya banane ke liye mAlave kI tarpha vihAra karanA hai|' isa ke uttara meM zrAvakoM ne kahA ki 'sureMdrasAgarajI ko upAdhyAyapada deke pIche se zrIpUjya nAkabUla ho gaye haiM, isa vAste vartamAna zrIpUjya hama se bhI nArAja haiM so Apa hI ko hama zrIpUjya banA leNge|' pUrvokta ThaharAva nakkI kara ke Ahora vAloM ne ratnavijayajI ke guru-' pramodavijaya ' jI ko lene ko AdamI bhejA / usa vakta pauSa vadi 10 ke mauke para zrIpUjya 'varakANA' tIrtha para Aye hue the / pramodavijayajI bhI -- nADola' se varakANe Aye the lekina ina ke aura zrIpUjya ke Apasa meM anabanAva jaisA thaa| Akhira Ahora ke manuSya ke sAtha pramodavijayajI Ahora Aye aura gAMva ke bAhara gor3I pArzvanAtha ke maMdira ke pAsa sAmiyAnA ( taMbU ) khaDA karavA ke vahAM Thahare / bAda pauSa sudi 15 pUrNimA ke dina prAtaHkAla meM sAmujA ke phale' ho kara bAjate gAjate gAMva meM praveza kiyA aura upAzraya meM utre| eka dina ratnavijayajIne zrAvakoM ko kahA ki mere aura

Page #129
tristutika mata-mImAsA / zrIpUjyajI ke Apasa meM takarAra ho gaI hai so to tuma jAnate hI ho isa hAlata meM zrIpUjya ke kabje meM rahe hue mere sAmAna ko kaise chuDAveM / kyoM ki isa vakta mere 300) tIna sau rupayA to nakada zrIpUjyajI se lene haiM / mere eka cele kA gahanA mayapeTI ke, aura bhagavatI, pannavaNA Adi sUtroM kI pratiyoM se bharI huI eka baDI maMjUsa bhI unhIM ke pAsa paDI hai / sivA isa ke do varSa kA merA pagAra bhI una meM lenA bAkI hai / isa prakAra merI milkata ko zrIpUjyajI davA baiThe haiM, to ise maMgavAne ke liye kyA upAya kareM ? / yaha vicAra ratnavijayajI aura zrAvakoM ke Apasa meM kucha samaya taka hone ke bAda yaha nizcaya huA ki ' Ahora' ke ThAkura sAhaba ko isa ke liye arja kI jAya, Akhira para yahI huA / ____ Ahora ke ThAkura sAhaba bar3e hI bhadrapuruSa the, upAdhyAya surendrasAgarajI ke sAtha gADha paricaya hone ke kAraNa sAdhu-yatiyoM ko aura bhI adhika mAna dete the| Apane ratnavijayajI aura Ahora ke zrAvakoM kI arja svIkAra kI aura rAja-sirohI se likhA-paDhI kara ke zrIpUjyajI se ratnavijayajI kA mAla chuDavAyA / vaha mAla gAMva 'zivagaMja ' meM ratnavijayajI ko milA, jisa meM nakada rupayA, cele kA gahanA aura 3 tIna pustakeM nahIM thiiN| zrIpUjya aura ratnavijayajI ke paraspara phArakhatI huI aura jo 2 cIjeM vAkI thIM ( nahIM milI thIM ) vaha phArakhatI meM vakAta likhI gii| bAda ratnavijayajI vApisa Ahora Aye / yaha pahale hI kahA jA cukA hai ki Ahora ke tapAgacchIya sirohI rAjyase likhApar3hI karane kA kAraNa yaha hai ki usa vakta zrIpUjya sirohI gaye hue the|

Page #130
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / 111 zrAvaka ratnavijayajI ko zrIpUjya banAne ke liye vacana de cuke the / isa liye ratnavijaya jI bhI isa kArya ke liye unheM bAdhya kareM isa meM koI navAI nahIM hai, Ahora Ate hI ve zrAvakoM ko ikaTThA kara ke bole 'aba mujhe jaldI se zrIpUjya bananA hai, lavAjame-sAmagrI ke liye tumhArI tarpha se kyA bandovasta hai / ' upAzraya ke zrAvakoM ne kahA-kitanIka cIjeM to upAdhyAyajI ke bhaMDAra meM maujuda haiM aura bAkI siddhacakrajI kA sAmAna hai usa meM se Apa ko jarUrI cIjeM de dete haiM Apa zrIpUjya baniye / isa samaya nimna likhita cIjeM zrAvakoMne ratnavijayajI ko bheMTa kI---- rezamI gaddI-takiyA, naM0 1 jAjama bar3I naM01 kinakhAba kA caMdroA naM. 1 pichavAI (puThiyA) naM. 1 sone ke varakavAlI sthApanA naM0 1 sivA ima ke cAMdI kI chaDI aura cAmara bhI-jo munisuvratabhagavAn ke the-ratnavijayajI ke sipurda kiye / aba ratnaviOM yajIne ThAkura sAhaba ko arja kI ke ' Apa hameM paravAnA likha dIjiye ki-' ina ko hamane zrIpUjya banAyA hai aura chaDI cAmara bhI hamane diye haiM ' isa se Apa kA baDA yaza hogaa| kyoM ki dete to mahAjana haiM Apa ko to sirpha cAra akSara likhane kI hI takalIpha hai|' yaha bAta pahale hI kaha cuke haiM ki ThAkura sAhaba sajjana puruSa the aura-lagna-muhUrtAdika Apa ratnavijayajI se pUchA karate

Page #131
112 tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / the-yaha bhI eka dAkSiNya kA kAraga thA aura Akhira prArthanA bhI bedAma kI thI isa vAste Apane ratnavijayajI ko pUrvokta pramANa patra likha diyaa| ___ yaha saba ho jAne para ratnavijayajI ne vahAM se nikalane kA irAdA kiyA, kharcI kama hone se rupayA eka sau 100) zeTha TIkamajI ke aura eka sau 100) lakhamAjI rupAjI ke pAsa se liye yaha kaha kara ke ki vaMdAne meM mileMge taba tumheM vApisa de deMge / rupayA 58 // 7) aThAvana aura terA Ane talAvata dhanarAjajI kI mAraphata zrAvikAoM se ora bhI mile / yaha saba sAmAna le kara ratnavijayajIne Ahora se ajamera kI tarpha vihAra kiyA, usa vakta nimna likhita yati vigairaha una ke sAtha meM the 1 dhanavijayajI, 2 khUbavijayajI, 3 lAlavijayajI, 4 hamIravijayanI, 5-6 do gRhastha cele aura 7 eka brAhmaNa, ___ ajamera meM miyAnA ( pAlakhI ) kharIda kiyA aura vaMdAte 2 saMbhUgaDha ' pahuMce / vahAM para 'hemasAgara' jI yati se milanA huA aura zrIpUjya jI ke sAtha calI huI khaTapaTa kI bAta cIteM huii| usa vakta hemasAgarajI bhI usI kAraNa se zrIpUjya jI se nArAja the jisa se ki Ahora ke zrAvaka / isa liye unhoM ne bhI ratnavijayajI kI khaTapaTa meM sahAyatA dI / itanA hI nahIM, balke vahIM (zaMbhugaDha meM) utsava kara ke ratnavijayajI ko pATha viyayA aura ' rAjendramUri' jI nAma sthApana kiyA / pAThakagaNa ! dhyAna rakhiye, aba Apa kA paricita nAma

Page #132
tristutik-mt-miimaaNsaa| 113 'ratnavijaya' pardAnazIna hotA hai aura usa kI jagaha para 'rAjendrasari' yaha abhinava nAma upasthita hotA hai, aba Apa isI ke khela dekheM ge / hamArI kalama bhI aba isI naye nAma para mohita hai| nizcaya dRSTi se ve cAhe ' rAjendra' ho yA 'raGkendra' 'mari' ho yA 'ri' hameM isa bAta se prayojana nahIM hai, isa mImAMsA kA yaha sthala bhI nahIM hai, hameM prayojana hai una ke bAhya kartavyoM se, aura unhIM kI hama mImAMsA kara rahe haiN| ' nAmanikSepa ' bhI jainasiddhAnta meM svIkRta hai| hamAre liye yaha siddhAnta isa jagaha baDA kAma degA / isI siddhAnta ke AdhAra se hama ' ratnavijayajI' ko niHsaMkoca 'rAjendramUri' jI isa nAma se likheMge / isa meM hameM kisI prakAra kI Apatti nahIM hai| rAjendrasarijI ne yati-zrIpUjya Adi sarva avasthAoM meM kyA kyA khela khele haiM-yaha saba kahane kA yaha sthAna nahIM hai| una gupta aura ayogya kheloM ko isa sabhyatApriya jamAne meM prakaTa karanA hai bhI ayogya / jo bAta prakRta-viSaya meM upayogI hai sirpha usI kA yahAM para ullekha karanA sArthaka hai| saMvat 1925 ke ASADha vadi 10 ke roja rAjendrasarijI ne gAMva 'jAvare' meM vinA hI guru ke svayaM kriyoddhAra kiyaa| yahIM se mAno ina kI lIlA kA caturtha aMka prAraMbha huaa| pahale kahA jA cukA hai ki talAvata dhanarAjajI aura dalIcaMdajI ne dIkSA lene kA pUrNa vicAra kara liyA thA / jaba rAjendramUrijI ne vyavahArika parigraha tyAga diyA to dhanarAjajI

Page #133
114 tristutika-mata--mImAMsA / bhI apanI pratijJA ko pUrNa karane ke liye apane mA-cApoM se dIkSA lene kI AjJA mAMgane lge| para yaha kAma sahaja nahIM thA, cAhe jaisA bhI putra ! putra kA viyoga ! mohagrasta saMsAriyoM ke liye yaha eka asahya ghaTanA hai| isa ghaTanA ko sarva sAdhAraNa kaha kara ke dhanarAjajI ne apane mAtA-pitA ko bahuta kucha samajAyA lekina nirAzA ke sivA aura kucha phala nahIM pAyA / ___ itanA hone para bhI ve bhagnamanoratha-nirAza nahIM hue / sarva vighnoM-antarAyoM kA nAza karane vAle pavitra AyaMbila tapa ko aba ve karane lage, isI ko unhoMne apanA antima aura amogha zastra smjhaa| tapasyA sacamuca hI adbhutaprabhAva vAlI siddha kriyA hai / " tapo hi duratikramam " yaha zAstrIya hI nahIM balke anubhava siddha vacana hai-aisA kahanA cAhiye / dhanarAjajI ko isa kA anubhava acchI taraha ho cukA thaa| ve jyoM jyoM pUrvokta tapa karane lage tyoM tyoM una kI dIkSA meM aMtarAya karane vAloM ke pariNAma badalane lge| ve apanI mohabharI bhUla ko pratyakSa dekhane lage / 'dharmakArya meM vighna DAlanA dRDhadharmIpana kA lakSaNa nahIM ' yaha bodha una ke hRdaya meM prakAzamAna huaa| Akhira vicAra badalA aura dIkSA kI anumati de kara sATha AyaMbiloM kI pAraNA krvaaii| talAvata dhanarAjajI kI diikssaa| vikrama saMvat 1931 kI sAla kA varSAcaturmAsa dhanavijayajI aura rAmavijayajI ne to jAlora-mAravAr3a meM kiyA aura

Page #134
tristutika- mata- mImAMsA / 115 rAjendramUrijI, pramodarucijI aura jayavijayajI-inhoM ne Ahora meN| isI caumAse meM zrAvaNa sudi 15 pUrNimA ke dina baDI dhUma-dhAma ke sAtha, ATha daza gAMvoM ke logoM ke samakSa dhanarAjajI ko rAjendramUrijI ne khuda ne dIkSA dI aura 'dharmavijaya' nAma rakkhA / usI roja dUsare bhI do AdamiyoM ne dhanarAjajI ke sAtha dIkSA lI thI jina ke nAma ' udayavijaya ' aura 'sukhavijaya' rakkhe the| bAda saMvat 1935 ke jeTha sudi 2 aura zukravAra ke dina zahara jAlora meM rAjendramUrijI ne saMghasamakSa 'dharmavijaya' jI ko baDI dIkSA dI aura pahale ke nAma ko badala ke 'kIrticandra ' nAma diyaa| isa mauke para bhI rAjendramUrijI kA parivAra-dhanavijayajI, mohanavijayajI, RddhivijayajI, tIkamavijayajI, tathA sAdhvI lakSmIzrI vidyAzrI, amRtazrI, jJAnazrI vigairaha-vahAM maujuda thaa| ___ pAThakagaNa ! isa laMbe caur3e itihAsa ne Apa kA bahuta samaya liyA-yaha maiM kabUla karUMgA, para yaha bhI kahanA jarUrI hogA ki yaha itihAsa nirarthaka nahIM hai, isa ke itane vistAra vinA Apa yaha kaise jAna sakate the ki lekhaka mahAzaya bAra 2 apanA bhItarI dveSa kisa ke Upara nikAlate haiM ?, ve apanI sajjanatA ( ? ) ko jAhirAta meM lAte hue * aMdha-zabda' kA prayoga kisa ke liye karate haiM ? / apanI asatyatA aura mithyAvAda kA sAkSI

Page #135
116 tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / " tumhAre dAdA guru ko rAjendrasUrijI ne hita zikSA karI" -ityAdika kaTu lekha meM hamArA dAdAguru ve kisa ko likhate haiM / aba Apa isa bAta ko AsAnI se samajha sakeMge ki jisa dhanarAja ke viSaya meM Apane adbhuta vairAgya-bhAvanA kA pATha par3hA hai usI mahAnubhAva ko rAjendramUrijI ne prathama-dIkSA meM 'dharmavijaya' aura dvitIya-baDI dIkSA meM 'kIrticaMdra' jI banAyA thaa| basa isI mahAtmApara ye sajana ziromaNi lekhaka apane anantAnubandhI krodha kI jvAlAeM barasA rahe haiM, isI mahApuruSa ke liye ve likhate haiM ki rAjendramUri jI ne dIkSA nahIM dii| priyapAThaka ! Apa hI sociye ki aisA mahAmRSAvAda kA udAharaNa Apa ora kahAM pA sakate haiM yA pA sakeMge ? / duniyA meM aisA bhI manuSya Apa ko kahIM dikhAI diyA-jo madhyAhna ko madhyarAtri aura mUrya ko andhakAra kA Dhera kahatA phiratA ho ? / yadi kahoge ki nahIM, to mahAmRSA vAda kA dRSTAnta bhI dUsarI jagaha nhiiN| lekhaka jI ! Apa isa viSaya meM Aja kala ke bAla haiM, Apa purANI hakIkata se ajJAta hone se gappIdAsoM ke mukha se jo jo sunate ho usI ko satya mAnalete ho, paraMtu takalIfa uThA kara purAne itihAsa ko paho aura jijJAsu bhAva se talAza karo, pIche mAlUma hogA ki-' tumhAre dAdA guru ko rAjendramUrijI ne dIkSA nahIM dI ' yaha mAnanA kitanA satya hai ! / hamAre gurumahArAja ko mahArAja zrIkIrticaMdra jI ke ziSya rahane

Page #136
tristutika- mata --mImAMsA / ...................... ..........................wr meM kisI prakAra lajjA nahIM AI, ve una mahopakArI guru ko jIMdagI ke cheDe taka guru hI mAnate the, tathApi kriyoddhAra kara ke upasaMpara dhAraNa kI isa kA kAraNa dUsarA hai, tuma kahate ho vaha nahIM / kIrticaMdrajI bhavabhIru puruSa the / unhoM ne tIna thuI ke mata ko zAstraviruddha samajhate hI use choDa dene kA udyoga kiyA aura Akhira choddaa| merI hI kyA, sAre saMsAra kI samajha meM yaha kAma bar3A utkRSTa samajhA jAtA hai / cirakAla se pakaDI huI apanI asatya bAta ko choDa denA lar3akoM kA khela nahIM hai / saMsAra ke bhaya vinA aisA honA kaThina kArya hai / aisA kaThina kArya bhI unhoM ne kara liyA to bhI abhItaka ve apanA eka kArya bAkI samajhate the / ve acchI taraha jAnate the ki cAhe jaisI bhI utkRSTa dharmakriyA vItarAga kI AjJA mujiba karane se hI saMpUrNa phala detI hai| yadi aisA na hotA to ' jamAlI ' kadApi kilbiSiyA devoM kI yoni meM nahIM jAtA / isa liye jaise caturthastutiko zAstrasammata jAna ke maine svIkAra kI, vaise hI dezakAla ke anusAra saMyamapAlane vAle vItarAga kI AjJAnusAra mUtrapaJcAGgIsvIkRta cAra stuti ke mata ko pAlane vAle kisI saMyamI muni kA yoga mile to una ke pAsa kiyoddhAra bhI kara lUM / paraMtu bhAvi prabala hai, isa abhilASA kI siddhi hote pahale hI una mahAtmA ne isa kSaNika manuSya deha kA tyAga kara ke divya deha kA svIkAra kara liyA-ve devaloka sidhAra gye| yaha kheda kA viSaya hai ki una kI ukta dhAraNA siddha nahIM

Page #137
118 tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / huI, tathApi vaha sarvathA niSphala bhI nahIM gaI / Akhira meM usa pavitra bhAvanA kA vIja Apane apane vinItaziSya munivarya zrIkezaravijayajI ke hRdaya meM ropA jo kAlAntara meM zrImatpaMnyAsasiddhivijaya jI gaNi kI kRpA se aMkurita huaa| lekhaka jI! ava to Apa spaSTa jAna sakate haiM ki hamAre gurumahArAja ne jo kriyoddhAra kiyA hai vaha sirpha tristutika mata ke saMskAro ko ghoDAlane ke liye kiyA hai, yA yaha kahanA cAhiye ki unhoMne maryAdA hIna tristutika mata kI kalpita maryAdA ko jalAMjali dekara sanAtana maryAdA aura guruparaMparA meM praveza kiyA hai dUsarA kucha bhI nahI kiyaa| to aba tumhArA pUrvokta sArA hI lekha asatya ThaharA yA nahIM ? / phira lekhaka kahate haiM ki jaina dharma kA asalI sanAtana rAmtA dekhane vAle rAjendrasUri jI ke to jainadharma kI puSTi ke lie dalIle zAstrayukta huA karatI thI, aura una ke parivAra ke sAdhuoM kI bhI yahI dazA hai " / lekhaka jI ! tumhAre rAjendramUri jI jainamArga ke kaise anajAna the isa bAta kA to maine pahale hI vivecana kara diyA hai / unhoMne apane mata kI puSTi ke liye kaisI 2 zAstraviruddha mana:kalpita yuktiyAM calAI haiM phakta unhIM ke kucha dRSTAnta batalAnA ucita samajhatA huuN| rAjendramUrijI ke khuda ke likhe hue * caityavaMdanavicAra' ke patra mere pAsa haiM, una meM eka jagaha ve likhate haiM " lalItavistarA caityavaMdana kI TikA 962 kI sAla meM harIbhadrasUrI bhaye tino ne banAi tAmeM likhate he-' upacitapunyasabhArA'

Page #138
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / esA pATha kA paramArtha yaha he ke upacaya karI he pUjA sAmagrI jino ne ese" kyA hI asatya DiMga hai ! 962 meM haribhadramari hue aisA kisI bhI jaina zAstra yA itihAsa se siddha nahIM hotA, zAstra meM to sirpha yaha ullekha pAyA jAtA hai ki 962 kI sAla meM siddharSi ne ' upamitibhavaprapaJcA kathA' samApta kii| siddharSi ne haribhadramUrijI apane dharmaguru likhe haiM isa kAraNa se yadi '962 kI sAla meM haribhadramUri hue ' aisA mAnate ho to baDI bhUla hai, siddharSijI ke hI lekha se haribhadramUri una se bahuta purAne the aisA siddha ho cukA hai, isa liye siddharSi ke sattA-kAla ko haribhadra mUrijI kA utpattisamaya kahanA nitAnta mUrkhatA hai / upacitapuNyasabhArAH ' isa kA artha bhI rAjendramarijIne sirpha apanI manaHkalpanA se hI kiyA hai, yaha bhI una kI kukalpanAoM meM kA hI eka namUnA hai / unhIM patroM meM " kimityAha-utkRSyata ityutkarSA- utkRSTA / idaM ca byAkhyAnameke 'tiNNI vA kaTTaI jAva thuIo tisilogiA' ityetAM kalpabhASyagAthAM, paNihANaM0 " isa pATha kA ve kaisA kalpita artha karate haiM paDha lIjiye " kese jANI esA TikAkArane koi pUche to kahate he ke utkRSTa caityavaMdana kalpabhASyakAra tIna thui kA likhate he tIna thui karaNA yAvat chelI tIna zloka kI varddhamAna thui esA pATha se hama jANate he yA cothI navI he "

Page #139
120 tristutika- mata-mImAMsA / pAThaka mahodaya ! yadi Apa saMskRta ke jAna haiM to dekha leveM rAjendrasUrijI ke artha kI asatyatA / agara svayaM nahIM samajha sakate ho to kisI niSpakSapAtI vidvAn se pUcha ke nirNaya kara lo ki uparyukta pAThoM kA artha rAjendrasUrijI ne kaisA asaMgata aura asatya likhA hai ! / maiM ina saba sthaloM kI samAlocanA karanA vistAra ke bhaya se choDa detA huuN| phira unhIM patroM meM rAjendrasUrijI apanI mata kalpanA kA paricaya dikhAte haiM ki "vaMdettu meM gAthA tayAlIsa 43 theTa kI ne phera sAta gAthA koiye navI khepana karI visa kI mAluma nhiiN|" lekhaka jI ! tuma bhI sauco aura tumhAre guru ko bhI pUcha lo ki yaha bhI rAjendramUrijI kI yukti zAstra khilApha hai yA nahIM ? / kahAM taka likheM, jaise 2 rAjeMdramUrijI ke asadvicAroM ke Dhera unAr3ate haiM vaise hI vaise una meM azuddhiyoM ke kIDe kilabilAte hue najara Ate hI rahate haiM / Ajakala ke una ke kaieka sAdhuoM ke vicAroM kI dazA to isa se bhI bar3hI car3hI hai / ina kI asad gandha ke Age to hameM suba se dama lenA bhI muzkila ho gayA hai| phira lekhaka apane rAjendramUrijI kI bahAdurI kA byugala phUMkate haiM ki-- " golavADa sthala meM zrI koraTAjI tIrtha zivagaMjAdi sahara gAMvo meM jIrNoddhAra tathA navIna maMdiroM kI pratiSThA aura seMkaDoM pratimAoM kI aMjana zalAkA karavAI. phira jAlorI sthala meM jIrNoddhAra tathA aMjana zalAkA karavAI. aura sirohI rAjya vigare sthalo meM pratiSThA aMjana

Page #140
tristutika- mata-mImAMsA | zalAkA jIrNoddhAra navIna maMdira upadeza de kara zrIvijayarAjeMdrasUrijI ne karavAye " lekhakajI jina jina gAMvoM ke nAma lekara tuma rAjeMdrasUrijI int bahAdurI ke gIta gA rahe ho ve saba gAMva hamAre dekhe hue haiM, jisa ne ina gAMvoM ko dekhA hogA koI bhI aisA nahIM kahegA ki rAjendrasUrijI ne yaha kAma jinabhakti ke nimitta kiyA hai| koraTe meM karIba do hajAra varSa kI purAnI zrImahAvIra prabhu kI pratimA ko uThavA kara nIce jamIna para rakhavAI aura isa ke sthAna para apane nAma ke laMbe caur3e lekhavAlI nayI mUrti sthApita kI / kyA ise bhI koI jinabhakti kaha sakatA hai ? | 121 zivagaMja meM 4-5 purAne maMdiroM ke hone para bhI apanA nAma rakhane ke liye kIrti ke abhilASI gRhasthoM ko upadeza dekara nayA maMdira banavAyA, kyA isa kA nAma bhI bhakti hai ? / jAlora meM pratiSThita pratimA kA lekha musalamAna zilAvaTa ke pAsa sivA ke baDhI bhArI AzAtanA kI kyA isa ko bhI bhakti kahanA ! | ? sirohI rAjya ke gAMva jAvAla meM do bar3e maMdiroM ke hone para bhI apanA pakSa aura kIrti bar3hAne kI icchA se nayA maMdira karavAyA, kyA yaha bhI bhakti kA sthAna samajhanA ? | , aise hI ' Ahora, '' guDA, ' ' harajI, 'maMDavAriyA ' vigairaha kaI gAMvo meM purAne do do cAra cAra maMdira vidyamAna the to bhI rAjendrasUrijI aura una ke sAdhuoMne lAkhoM rupayA kharca karAke naye maMdiroM kI bharamAra karavA dI, aura aba bhI karavA rahe haiM, kyA isa meM bhakti ke nAma se AzAtanA nahIM hai ? | 16 ,

Page #141
122 tristutika- mata--mImAMsA / anoon.in jahAM purAne maMdira maujuda haiM, aura una kI to saMbhAla aura sevA pUjA kA bhI ThikAnA nahIM aise sthAnoM me naye maMdira khar3e karavAne kI preraNA karanA, yaha kIrti kI abhilASA nahIM to aura kyA ho sakatA hai / bar3e kheda kI bAta hai| jainadharmiyoM kI ghaTatI ke pokAra pratidina sunAI de rahe haiM, jainatIrthoM aura maMdiroM kI durdazA ke duHkhaprada samAcAroM se kAna bharAte jAte haiM, avidyA kI prabalatA jainoM ke zira svAra ho rahI hai, jainadharma ke pAlakoM ko garIbI se bhIkha mAMga ke peTa bharane kA vakta A gayA hai, sAdhu, upadezaka aura sAmayika patra vigairaha samAjahitaiSI gaNa; ina duHkha ke samAcAroM ko pukAra kara ke jainasamAja ke kAnoM meM pahuMcA rahe haiM to bhI samAja jAgatA nahIM hai, kadApi jAgRta hone kI ceSTA karatA hai to kIrti ke lobhI samaya ke anajAna sAdhu use jAgane nahIM dete-ve isa ko samaya ke anupayogI jIrNa saDe hue vicAroM kI nidrA meM par3e rakhanA hI cAhate haiN| tIrthakara gotra, svarga ke sukha aura mukti ke mahala kA lobha batA kara kIrti ke bhUkhe jainoM se binajarUrI kAryoM meM lAkhoM rupayoM kI AhutiyAM dilAte haiM, para garIba jainoM ke duHkha kI tarpha koI bhI nahIM dekhatA, ajJAnI jaina bAlaka apanA paramapavitra dharma choDa ke anyadharma kI zaraNa lete haiM-isa tarpha kisI kA khayAla taka nahIM hai ! / aphasosa ! aise upadezaka aura dharmiyoM kI AMkheM kaba khuleMgI aura apane kartavya kI tarpha lakSya deMge ? / phira lekhaka apanI ajJatA kI nizAnI batAte haiM ki" tumhAre jaise aikAntika cAra thuI ke matavAle ko pRcchA kareMge ko samaya ke a tIrthakara gotra va jainoM se

Page #142
tristutika-mata - mImAMsA / 123 ki tumhAre cAra thuI ke jo jo zAstra hai ! tina me cAra nikAya ke saba devatA atratI apaccakkhAnI haiM vAMdane pUjane yoga nahIM - aisA likhA hai ! to tuma cAra thuI vAle apanA hI zAstravacana utthApa ke cothI thuI kaha ke tina atratI devatAoM kI vaMdanA pUjanA kyoM karate ho ? aisA ve DhuMDhaka va terApaMthI, Apa ko vA Apa ke pakSiyoM ko pUcheMge ! to Apa kyA javAba doMge ? " bilakula galata bAta hai, koI bhI cAra dhuI karane vAlA cothI thuI kahake avatI devoM kI vaMdanA pUjanA nahIM karatA, tathApi lekhaka kahate haiM ' karate ho ' so yaha ina kA pUrNa ajJAna hai / kyA lekhaka bilakula ajJAnI haiM ? una ko yaha bhI mAlUma nahIM ki stuti nAma kisa kA hai ? agara kucha bhI saMskRta vidyA meM praveza kiyA hotA to yaha kahanekA sAhasa kadApi nahIM karate ki ' stuti ' zabda kA artha vaMdana pUjana hai| khaira | lekhaka ! aba bhI yAda rakhiye ki ' stuti ' zabda kA artha vaMdana pUjana nahIM kiMtu ' stuti prazaMsA, zlAghA, varNavAda kA hai, bhASA meM isa kA paryAya zabda ' tArIpha ' yA ' bakhAna hai isa viSaya meM maiMne pahale hI bahuta kucha likha diyA hai isa liye yahAM para phira vistAra karanA acchA nahIM / | lekhakoM kA yaha bhI likhanA asatya hai ki ' ina devatAoM kA pUjana cAra thuI ke zAstroM meM nahIM likhA ' barAbara likhA hai, paraMtu pakSapAta ke kAle cazme pahine hue manuSya ise nahIM dekheM to isa meM doSa kisakA ? / lekhaka mahAnubhAva pakSapAtarahita ho kara nIce likhe hue zAstrapAThoM ko dekheM ki jainazAstroM meM devatAoM kI pUjA likhI hai yA nahIM ? |

Page #143
tristutika mata-mImAMsA / " sAhammiA ya ee mahaTTiA sammadiTTiNo jeNa / eto ciya uci khalu eesi ittha pUyAI // " ( paMcAzakamakaraNa ) artha-ye brahmazAnti, ambikA vigairaha maharddhika deva sAdhArmika ( samAnadharma vAle ) haiM isa lie yahAM para ina kI pUjA aura stuti vagairaha karanA hI cAhiye / " vizvavighAyaNaheuM ceIhara rakkhaNAya nizca pi / kujjA pUyAIya- meyANaM dhammavaM, kiMca // micchayaguNajuANaM nivAiyANaM kareMti pUyAI / ihalokae, sammatta -- guNajuANaM na uNa mUDhA || ( jIvAnuzAsana ) artha-vighnoM ke nAza ke nimitta aura jinamaMdiroM kI rakSA ke lie dharmI puruSa ina brahmazAntyAdi devoM kI nitya hI pUjA tathA kAyotsarga stuti Adi kareM / ( ina kI pUjA vigairaha nahIM karane vAloM ko granthakAra upAlaMbha dete haiM ki ) mithyAtvaguNayukta rAjAdika kI to iha lokArtha pUjA karate haiM aura samyaktvaguNayukta sAdharmika devoM kI (pUjA) mUrkha nahIM karate / 124 lekhaka jI ! dekhiye cAra thuI ke zAstroM meM samyaktvI devoM kI pUjA kA niSedha kiyA hai ki una kI pUjA nahIM karane vAle gRhastha ko mUrkha - ajJAnI kahA hai ? | phira lekhaka apanI paMDitAI kA namUnA dikhAte haiM ki" sAmAyika vrata meM ragaDA DAla kara tapAgaccha ke pItAmbara saMvegI to zrI Avazyaka sUtra ko utthApa ke sAmAyika uccAra ke

Page #144
tristutika- mata-mImAMsA pahile hI iriyAvahI karate karAte haiM ! aura kharataragaccha ke pItAmbara saMvegI zrImahAnizItha sUtra ko utthApa ke sAmAyika uccAra ke bAda hI iriyAvahI karate karAte haiM ! ityAdi zvetAmbara dharma meM aneka ragaDA DAla kara jainabhikSu sarikhe hI pItAmbara saMvegIyo ne judA mata nikAlA hai ! aura jagaha 2 saMgha meM virodha jagAyA hai " lekhakoM ko AMkheM khola ke dekhanA cAhiye ki tapAgaccha ke saMvegI Avazyakamatra kA utthApana karate haiM yA tumhAre jaise asaMvegI / pAThaka mahodaya ! isa viSaya ke kucha siddhAnta suna leveM aura phira soceM ki ina meM AdaraNIya siddhAnta kaunasA hai / (1) " eAe vihIe tiviheNa sAhuNo NamiUNa pacchA sAhusakkhi karei ' karemibhaMte ' ( ityAdi ) jAvasAhU pajjuvAsAmi tti kAUNa, jai ceiAI asthi to paDhamaM vaMdai, sAhusagAsAo rayaharaNaM nisajjaM vA maggati / aha ghare to se uvaggahiarayaharaNaM asthi, tassa asati vatthaMteNaM / pacchA IriAe paDikkamati, pacchA AloettA baMdati AyariAdI / " ( AvazyakacUrNi) (2) " so a sAvao iDhipatto aNiDhipatto a / jo iDhipatto so gao sAhusamIve sAmAiyaM karei / jo puNa aNiDhipatto so gharAo ceva sAmAiyaM kAUNa paMcasamio tigutto jahA sAhU tathA (hA) gacchai, sAhusamIve patto puNo sAmAiyaM karei, IriyAvahiAe paDikkamati, jai ceiAI asthi to paDhamaM vaMdai pacchA paDhai suNai vA" ( navapadaprakaraNa vRtti)

Page #145
126 tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / __ (1) artha-' isa vidhi se sAdhuoM ko trividha namana kara ke pIche sAdhusAkSika ' karebhi bhaMte' ityAdi karake yadi caitya hoM to unheM prathama vAMda le aura sAdhuoM ke pAsase rajoharaNa-daMDAsaNa yA nipadyA mAMge, jo ghara para ho to usa ke aupagrahika rajoharaNa-caravalA hotA hai, agara na ho to vastra ke cher3e se kAma lenA, pIche IryAvahI paDikama kara AloyaNA karake AcAryAdika ko vaMdana kre|' (2) ' vaha zrAvaka do prakAra ke hote haiM-RddhiprApta ( Rddhimanta ) aura anRddhiprApta, ( sAmAnya ) / jo RddhiprApta ho vaha sAdhusamIpa jAkara sAmAyika kare aura anRddhiprApta ho vaha ghara se hI sAmAyika karake pAMcasamati pAlate hue tIna guptiyoM se gupta sAdhu kI taraha sAdhusamIpa jAve, vahAM jAkara phira sAdhu sAkSika sAmAyika kare ( uccare), bAda IyaryAvahI paDikama kara jina pratimAeM hoM to prathama vaMdana kare phira pustaka par3he yA sune / ' uparyukta pAThoM kA bhAvArtha bhAvArtha ina kA yaha hai ki sAmAyika kartA zrAvaka do prakAra ke hote haiM / pahalA, rAjA maMtrI vigairaha Rddhimanta, aura dUsarA sAdhAraNa / _Rddhimanta zrAvaka ko sAdhu ke yoga meM svayogyatAnusAra una ke pAsa jAke hI sAmAyika karanA cAhiye jisase ki jainadharma aura sAdhuoM kI unnati ho / dUsare darje ke zrAvaka ko jahAM tahAM bhI phurasata milane para sAmAyika AdaranA cAhiye, para yaha bAta jarUrI hai ki sthAna nitimaya honA cAhiye, dhaMdhArthI sAmAnya zrAvaka ko sAdhuoM kA

Page #146
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / 127 yoga hone para bhI ghara para hI sAmAyika grahaNa karake pIche sAdhu samIpa jAnA aura svayaM lie hue sAmAyika ko phira sAdhusAkSika kara lenA cAhiye, aisA karane kA prayojana yaha hai ki sAdhAraNa manuSyoM ke kArya prAya aniyamita rahate haiM / vAstava meM una kA jIvana hI pravRttimaya hotA hai / jo samaya una kI niti kA mAnA jAtA hai; bahudhA usa meM bhI ve niti nahIM pA skte| idhara se udhara gaye ki vaha bhI samaya pravRttimaya banA hI thaa| matalaba ki vaha becArA dharmasthAnaka meM jAte jAte hI kaI anivArya kAmoM se ghira jAtA hai, pariNAma yaha AtA hai ki usakI sAmAyika karane kI bhAvanA yoM hI par3I rahatI hai aura vivaza ho kara use anya kAmoM meM laga jAnA par3atA hai, isa lie isa darje ke zrAvaka ko samaya milate hI sAmAyika kara lenA cAhiye / yadyapi pahale darne ke gRhastha bhI kAmoM se mukta to nahIM haiM to bhI una ke sabhI kAma bahuta karake niyamita samaya meM hI kiye jAte haiM, yadi koI ekA eka nayA kArya upasthita ho bhI jAya to bhI use naukara cAkaroM ko sauMpa sakate haiM, yA amuka samaya ke liye choDa sakate haiM, paraMtu sAdhAraNa manuSya prAyaH aisA nahIM kara skte| saba prakAra ke sAmAyika kartAoM ke lie sAmAyika lene kA sAmAnya vidhi yaha hai ki prathama IyaryAvahI paDikama ke sAmAyika daMDaka uccare / dara asala yahI vidhi yuktiyukta aura zAstrasaMmata mAlUma hotA hai, kyoM ki mahAnizItha sUtra meM isI mujiba caityavaMdana svAdhyAyAdi dharma kAryoM kA vidhi pratipAdana kiyA hai|

Page #147
tristutika mata-mImAMsA / yuktigamya bhI yahI ho sakatA hai, jaise dravyastava - jinapUjA meM zarIrazuddhi ke nimitta dravyasnAna - jalasnAna kI prathama jarUrata hai vaise hI bhAvastava - sAmAyika meM bhI pariNAmazuddhi ke liye bhAva snAna - IryAvahIpratikramaNa kI prathama jarUrata siddha hotI haiM / aura jese prathama snAna kara lene ke bAda pUjA karate samaya phira vinAkAraNa snAna kI AvazyakatA nahIM hai, isI prakArase prathama fast kara lene ke bAda sAmAyika meM phira vinA kAraNa IrSyAvahI karane kI jarUrata nahIM rahatI / 128 isa vistRta vivaraNa se yaha siddha huA ki IryAvahI pratikramaNa pUrvaka sAmAyika lekara phira IrSyAvahI paDikamanA nirarthaka hai, aura IryAvahI pratikramaNa vinA hI sAmAyika lekara pIche vahI karanA bhI pUjA ke bAda snAna aura bhojana ke bAda dAna karane ke barAvara viparIta hai / rAjendrasUrijI ke anuyAyI loga sAmAyika daMDaka uccara ke pIche vahI paDakamate haiM, taba dhanavijayajI kA bhrAnta bhaktavarga uccAraNa ke pahale aura pIche evaM do IryAvahI karate haiM / isa prakAra ye donoM prakAra kA ayaktika vidhAna lekhakoM ke mata meM pracalita hai / "sAhusamIve patto puNo sAmAiyaM karei IriyAvahiAe paDikkamati " ityAdi pAThoM ko dekha ke lekhaka jI vigairaha kitaneka loga to yahI mAna baiThe haiM ki sAmAyika uccarane ke bAda bhI yA bAda hI vahI karanI cAhiye, paraMtu ve yaha nahIM socate ki isa IrSyA kA saMbaMdha kisa ke sAtha hai ! pATha meM sApha 2 kaha diyA hai ki jo gRhastha apane ghara se sAyAyika karake sAdhusamIpa

Page #148
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / 129 Ave vaha prathama to svayaM lie hue sAmAyika ko sAdhusAkSika kara deve aura pIche gamanAgamana kI IryAvahI paDikame | isa se sApha jAhira hai ki isa IryAvahI kA saMbandha sAmAyika ke sAtha nahIM kiMtu sAmAyika lekara kiye hue gamana ke sAtha hai| ___ aba vicAranA cAhiye ki jo sAdhusamIpa jAkara hI sAmAyika letA hai yAto jahAM letA hai vahIM pUrA karatA hai-dUsare sthAna para jAtA hI nahIM usa ko sAmAyika lene ke bAda IyaryAvahI karane kI jarUrata hI kyA hai ? / pAThaka ! isa rahasyArtha se Upara kahe hue donoM mata kaise uDa jAte haiM Apa dekha leveN|| lekhakajI ! aba saca kahiye sAmAyika vrata meM bhI ragar3A saMvegiyoMne DAlA hai yA Apa ke matavAloMne ? / phira lekhaka apanI jAnakArI kA paricaya dete haiM ki---- " cAra thuI ke gacchavAloM se pratiSThita pratimA ko hI vAMdanA ! pUjanA ! dUsare tIna thuI AdigacchavAloM kI pratiSThita pratimA ko vAMdanA pUjanA nahIM ! phira prAcIna pratimA ko hI vAMdanA pUjanA para navIna pratimA ko vAMdanA pUjanA nahIM ! ityAdi aneka ekAntika matoM ke maMDana karane vAle nindAke pAtra hoke tuma nindya se anyathA kaise ho sakate ho ? / " ___ yaha bhI lekhakoM kI jhUThI kalpanA hai ki jainabhikSu Adi aise matoM kA maMDana karate haiM, hAM yaha bAta to ve jarUra hI kahate haiM ki yadi purAnA maMdira aura pratimAeM maujuda hoM to vahAM para naye maMdira aura pratimAeM jyAdA bar3hAne kI kyA jarUrata hai| bina jarUrI maMdira pratimAoM kA baDhAnA hI mAnoM una kI AzAtanA karanA haiM / jainabhikSu kA to yaha mata nahIM hai ki purAnI

Page #149
130 tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / pratimAoM kA hI vaMdana, pUjana karanA, nayI pratimAoM kA nahIM, paraMtu yaha mata bhI una kA nahI ki purAnI pratimAoM ko uThA kara jamIna para rakha denA aura apane nAma ke zilA lekha vAlI nayI pratimAoM ko una ke sthAna para biThA denA, jaise rAjendrasUrijI vigairaha karate the| 'dUsare gacchavAloM kI pratiSThita pratimAoM ko vaMdana nahIM karanA' aisA jainabhikSu Adi to nahIM kahate paraMtu gajendramUrijI ne to aisA vartAva kaI jagaha kiyA hai so prasiddha hai / tAjA dRSTAnta lIjiye-saMvat 1955 kI sAla meM kharataragaccha ke zrIpUjyajIne Ahora meM zrIRSabhadevajI ke maMdira kI pratiSThA kI tava rAjendrasarijI usa maMdira meM darzana ke lie bhI nahIM jAte the, logoM ke kahane para ki 'Apa isa maMdira meM darzana karane ko kyoM nahIM padhArate haiM ' unhoMne uttara diyA / isa maMdira kI pratiSThA ko hama maMjUra nahIM karate isa lie abhI taka yaha pratimA vaMdanIya nahIM huI ' aisA kaha ke dUsare bhI logoM ko darzana ke liye vahAM jAne se rokA ! / lekhakajI ! talAza kIjiye ki yaha hakIkata satya hai yA nahIM, agara satya hai to Apa ke hI matavAle zAstra viruddha mata kA maMDana karane vAle Thahare yA nahIM ? / janazAsana patra ne jaba traistutikoM kI pola jAhira kI, vaha una kI aMdhazraddhA ko prakAza meM lAkara hitopadeza karane ko udyata huA, taba ve bahuta hI cir3hAye aura gabharAye, paraMtu satya bAta ke Age una kA upAya hI kyA thA ?, jaba ve samajha gaye ki satya prakAzaka 'jainazAsana' patra kisI prakAra hama se dava

Page #150
tristutik-mt-miimaaNsaa| nahIM sakatA to ve use nIce mujaba ThaMDA upadeza karane lage ki "jainazAsana patra ko aise lekha kadApi prakAza nahIM karanA cAhiye ki-jisa meM pakSapAta doSa yA jainadharma kI hAni ho / " lekhakajI ! Apa kA upadeza to yogya hai paraMtu Apa jAnate haiM ki patra prakAzaka loga bahuta pahuMce hue hote haiM, ve prathama yaha acchI taraha jAMca lete haiM ki kaunasA lekha kitanA lAbhakAraka hai, phira usa lekhako prakAzita karate haiM jo acchA phAyadA karanevAlA ho / hAM, sabhI lekha aise nahIM hote ki unheM paDha kara sabhI loga rAjI ho jAya~, aura aisA honA hai bhI muzkila, aisI davA zAyada hI koI hogI jo saba rogiyoM ke liye hitakara ho| yadi sabhI rogoM kA vijaya karane ke liye eka hI auSadha-vaha bhI mIThA-samartha ho baiThatA ho bAkI ke saba amadhura auSadhoM kA pRthivI para utpanna honA hI vyartha ho jAtA, paraMtu aisA hotA nahIM hai, saba rogoM kA auSadha eka nahIM hai, aise hI saba doSoM ko dUra karane ke vAste eka mIThe rasa kA lekha hI samartha nahIM hotA / aura lokasthiti to yahAM taka kahatI hai ki 'kaTurasa' jitanA guNakAraka hai utanA mIThA nahIM / yaha bAta sahI hai ki mIThI davA se roga miTa jAya to kaTu kI jarUrata nahIM, paraMtu akhabAra vAloM ko yaha kahane kI hI kyA jarUrata thI?, ve kaI varSoM se miSTa auSadhoM se upacAra kara hI rahe the, para saba niSphala ! kucha bhI guNaprApti nahIM huI taba unhoMne kaTu oSadhI kI tarpha dRSTi nAMkhI-kucha kaTu lekhoM se Apa ke muMha bigADe / isa se yaha kahanA ucita nahIM ki 'jainazAsana'

Page #151
132 tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / patra pakSapAtI hai, hAM yaha bAta jarUra hai ki vaha satyagrAhI avazya hai, aura yahI kAraNa hai ki satyatApUrNa lekhoM ko vaha bar3e Adara ke sAtha sthAna detA hai-chApa detA hai, Apa kA asatyapUrNa lekha 'janazAsana ' ne nahIM chApA to isa kA doSa janazAsana ke zira caDhAnA mUrkhatA hai, yaha doSa Apa kI hI asatyatA kA hai aura isI ke zira maMDhA jAya to kucha bhI anucita nahIM hogA / -upasaMhArapriyapAThakagaNa ! aba maiM harSa-tIrtha ke likhe hue nAma se to samucitauttaradAnapatra' para guNa se ' anucitauttara dAna patra' kI mImAMsA ko pUrNa karatA huuN| yadyapi aneka bAteM isa meM likhane yogya upasthita haiM tathApi isa jagaha aba jyAdA likhanA munAsiba nahIM samajhatA huuN| vAstava meM adhika likhanA hai bhI vyartha, yaha to mujhe AzA hI nahIM ki isa pustaka meM likhI huI satya bAteM bhI traistutika loga aMgIkAra kara leMge, kyoM ki ve loga-asadAgraha se pUrNa bhare hue haiM, una meM yaha viveka hI nahIM hai ki satya bAta kaunasI hai, agara kinhIM meM hai bhI to ve jAnate hue bhUlate haiM, una kI yaha to mAnyatA hI nahIM ki ' saccA so merA' / ve to sacamuca yahI mAna baiThe haiM ki 'merA so hI sccaa'| yaha merA kathana Apa atizayoktipUrNa na samajheM, ve loga mere kathana se bhI adhika aMdhazraddhA vAle haiM, isa viSaya meM Apako cAhiye jitane pramANa mila sakate haiM, merI tarpha se bhI do eka suna lIjiye--

Page #152
tristutika-mata-mImAMsA / 133 " sUrirAjendra jI mudrA choDI ___ aSTakarmamamatA ko toddii| saccidAnaMda se prema to joDI zivaramaNI gaye jaldise doDI // " (gurunirvANa lAvanI-pRSTha 9) " paMcama kAla meM sUrivijaya__ rAjendratulya nahi koi hogA / gotra tIrthakara liyA hai zivaramaNI kA sukha bhogA // " ___ (gurunirvANa lAvanI-pRSTha 13 ) pAThakagaNa ! dekha lIjiye, aMdhazraddhA meM hai kucha khAmI ? rAjendrasarijI ko tIrthakara gotra baMdhA kara yahIM se sIdhe zivarapaNI ke sukha bhugavAne vAle-mukti meM bhejane vAle traistutikoM kI aMdhazraddhA kI hadda A gaI yA nahIM ? / aise aMdhavizvAsI buddhihIna kadAgrahagrasta manuSyoM ko yaha merA nibandha phAyadA pahuMcAvegA aisI mAnyatA maiM svapna meM bhI nahIM rkhtaa| merI jo kucha AzA hai vaha tattvajijJAsu aura madhyastha dRSTi vAle sajjanoM ke prati hai, kyo ki isa mImAMsA kI satyatA ke sAkSI vahI hoMge jo satyapriya aura vicAra zIla haiM, aura unhIM kI satyagrAhitA se yaha mImAMsA phalavatI hoMgI /

Page #153

Page #154
Nong Mo Shu Shu Shu Shu Shu Ni Xu Shu Shu Shu Shu Lai Lian Jie Qin hama ko kisa bAta kI jarUrata hai ? 1. zAstrakAroM kA pharamAna hai ki deza kAla ko mAna dene vAle manuSya apanI, apane dharma kI aura apanI jAti kI unnati AsAnI se kara sakate haiN| 2. isa se ulaTA bartAva karane vAle tana, mana aura dhana kA bhoga dete hue bhI apanA iSTa kArya sAdha nahIM sakate, aura kevala hAni uThAte haiN| 3. aisA bhI koI samaya thA, jisa meM pratiSThA, aThAhiutsava, vivAha aura ausara Adi kI dhUmadhAmoM meM lAkhoM rUpayA kharca kara loga apanI dhArmika aura jAtIya unnati karate the| 4. hAla kA samaya aisA hai ki lAyabrerI, pAThazAlA, borDiMga, kaoNleja Adi vidyonati ke sAdhanoM se hI dharma aura jAti kI vizeSa unnati ho sakatI hai| 5. isa ke lie hama janabhAiyoM se-vizeSatayA mAravAr3I jainoM se prArthanA karate haiM ki ve apanI kSINa hotI huI jAti aura dharma kI tarpha eka bAra dRSTi kareM aura soceN| ki isa vakta hama ko kisa bAta kI khAsa jarUrata hai| /