Jain Siddhant Pravesh Ratnamala 02

Author(s): Digambar Jain Mumukshu Mandal Dehradun
Publisher: Digambar Jain Mumukshu Mandal
Catalog link: https://jainqq.org/explore/010117/1

Page #1
THE FREE INDOLOGICAL COLLECTION WWW.SANSKRITDOCUMENTS.ORG/TFIC FAIR USE DECLARATION This book is sourced from another online repository and provided to you at this site under the TFIC collection. It is provided under commonly held Fair Use guidelines for individual educational or research use. We believe that the book is in the public domain and public dissemination was the intent of the original repository. We applaud and support their work wholeheartedly and only provide this version of this book at this site to make it available to even more readers. We believe that cataloging plays a big part in finding valuable books and try to facilitate that, through our TFIC group efforts. In some cases, the original sources are no longer online or are very hard to access, or marked up in or provided in Indian languages, rather than the more widely used English language. TFIC tries to address these needs too. Our intent is to aid all these repositories and digitization projects and is in no way to undercut them. For more information about our mission and our fair use guidelines, please visit our website. Note that we provide this book and others because, to the best of our knowledge, they are in the public domain, in our jurisdiction. However, before downloading and using it, you must verify that it is legal for you, in your jurisdiction, to access and use this copy of the book. Please do not download this book in error. We may not be held responsible for any copyright or other legal violations. Placing this notice in the front of every book, serves to both alert you, and to relieve us of any responsibility. If you are the intellectual property owner of this or any other book in our collection, please email us, if you have any objections to how we present or provide this book here, or to our providing this book at all. We shall work with you immediately. -The TFIC Team.

Page #2

Page #3
bhI digambara jaina mumukSu maNDala, deharAdUna kA puSpa naM0 2 jaina siddhAnta praveza ratnamAlA dvitIya bhAga. (caturtha saskaraNa prakAzaka zrI digambara jaina mumukSu maDala, deharAdUna ___winta Fir-mahAna deza np pustaka prApti sthAna nemacandra jaina, jaina baMdhu palaTana bAjAra, deharAdUna-248001 (yU0 pI0) mUlya : cAra rupayA

Page #4
prakAzakIya nighedana , jagata ke saba jIva sukha cAhate hai arthAt dukha se bhayabhIta hai / sukha pAne ke lie yaha jIva sarva padArthoM ko apane bhAvo ke anusAra palaTanA cAhatA hai| parantu anya padArthoM ko badalane kA bhAva mithyA hai kyoki padArtha to svayameva palaTate hai aura isa jIva kA kArya mAtra jJAtA-dRSTA hai| sukhI hone ke lie jina vacano ko samajhanA atyanta Avazyaka hai| vartamAna me jina dharma ke rahasya ko batalAne vAle adhyAtma puruSa zrI kAna jI svAmI the| aise satapurupa ke caraNo kI zaraNa me rahakara hamane jo kucha sikhA paDhA hai usake anusAra pa0 kailAza candra jI jaina dvArA guthita jaina siddhAnta praveza ratnamAlA ke sAto bhAga jina-dharma ke rahasya ko atyanta spaSTa karane vAle hone se cauthI bAra prakAzita ho rahe hai| isa prakAzana kArya me hama loga apane maDala ke vivekI aura sacce, deva-gurU-zAstra ko pahacAnane vAle svargIya zrI rUpa candra jI, mAz2arA : vAlo ko smaraNa karate haiM jinakI zubha preraNA se ina grantho kA prakAzana kArya prArambha huA thaa| hama baDe bhakti bhAva se aura vinaya pUrvaka aisI bhAvanA karate haiM ki sacce sukha ke arthI jIva jina vacano ko samajhakara samyagdarzana prApta kre| aisI bhAvanA se ina pustako kA cauthA prakAzana Apake hAtha me hai| isa dUsare bhAga me chahakAraka, upAdana-upAdeya, yogyatA, nimittanaimittika Adi viSayo kA spaSTIkaraNa karake sauvA gAthA ke cAra bIlo ko samajhAyA gayA hai tAki bhavya jIva ina sabako samajhakara dharma kI prApti kara mke| vinIta zrI digambara jaina mumukSu maDala deharAdUna

Page #5
jaina siddhAnta praveza ratnamAlA dUsare bhAga kI viSaya sUcI pAThakrama viSaya kitane praznottara hai lekhaka ko bhUmikA 40 praznottara hai pahalA pATha chaha kAraka adhikAra kAraka kise kahate hai aura unake prakAra chaha kAraka me nizcaya-vyavahAra kaise kartA kAraka kA spaSTIkaraNa 26- 31 karmakAraka kA spaSTIkaraNa 32-42 karaNa kAraka kA spapTIkaraNa 42-46 sampradAna kAraka kA spaSTIkaraNa 46-- 48 apAdAna kAraka kA spaSTIkaraNa 48- 52 adhikaraNa kAraka kA spaSTIkaraNa 52-- 56 kArako ke viSaya me praznottara dUsarA pATha upAdAna-upAdeya adhikAra upAdAna upAdeya kI paribhApA 71-62 kumhAra ne dhaDA banAyA-isa para praznottara 63 bAkI dUsare prazno para upAdAna upAdeya 94-123 tIsarA pATha yogyatA kA svarUpa 124-130 cauthA pATha nimittakaraNa kA spaSTIkaraNa / 130-145 pAcavA pATha nimitta naimittika kA spaSTIkaraNa 145-161 chaThavA pATha vyApya-vyApaka kA spaSTIkaraNa / 161-166 sAtavA pATha samayasAra gAthA sau ke cAra bolo kA kArya 166-174 AThavA pATha maine muha se zabda bolA isa para sau praznottaro ke dvArA spaSTIkaraNa 174-211 navamA pATha svatantratA kI ghoSaNA kalaza 211 212-233 dasavA pATha upAdAna-nimitta kA 47 doho me samvAra 233-247 bhAratIya sti-darzana ke

Page #6
bhAga 2 prArambha se pahale azuddhiyoM ko zuddha kIjiye pRSTha saMkhyA paMkti 22 16 25 1 26 25 15 8 mm 33 36 38 -65 76 62 63 64 100 103 110 xx 17 3 w 16 7 5 8 15 w 12 azuddhi marga trikAlo jA aura zAnti mane vyakarma kSakSiNa jaoNra ThAka trikAlA nazvara upapadAna uhAdAna kAraNa upAdAnakAra zuddha mArga trikAlI jo ora zanti mAne dravyakarma kSaNika aura ThIka trikAtI nambara upAdAna upAdAna kAraNa upAdAna kAraNa

Page #7
jinendra kathita vizva vyavasthA "jova ananta, pudgala anantAnanta, dharma-adharma-AkAza eka-eka aura kAla loka pramANa asaMkhyAta hai| pratyeka dravya meM ananta-ananta gaNa haiM / pratyeka guNa meM eka hI samaya meM eka paryAya kA utpAda, eka paryAya kA vyaya aura guNa nauvya rahatA hai| isa prakAra pratyeka dravya ke guNa meM ho cukA hai, ho rahA hai aura hotA rhegaa|" [jainadarzana kA sAra] sva-(1) amUrtika pradezo kA puja (2) prasiddha jJAnAdi guNo kA dhArI (3) anAdinidhana (4) vastu Apa hai| para-(1) mUrtika pudgala dravyo kA piNDa (2) prasiddha jJAnAdi guNo se rahita (3) navIna jisakA sayoga huA hai (4) aise zarIrAdi pudgala para haiM / [mokSamArgaprakAzaka] -

Page #8
sampUrNa duHkhoM kA abhAva hokara sampUrNa sukha kI prApti kA upAya anAdinidhana vastue~ bhinna-bhinna apanI-apanI maryAdA sahita pariNamita hotI hai / koI kisI ke AdhIna nahIM haiN| koI kisI ke pariNamita karAne se pariNamita nahIM hotI / para ko pariNamita karAne kA bhAva mithyAdarzana hai| [ mokSamArgaprakAzaka] apane-apane sattva kUM, sarva aise citava jova taba, parata vastu visasAya | mamata na thAya // sat dravya lakSaNam / utpAda vyaya dhaumya yuktaM sat / [ mokSazAstra ] "Permanancy with a Change" [ badalane ke sAtha sthAyitva ] NO SUBSTANCE IS EVER DESTROYED IT CHANGES ITS FORM ONLY [ koI vastu naSTa nahIM hotI, pratyeka vastu apanI avasthA badalatI hai / ] ce f {"

Page #9
lekhaka kI bhUmikA anAdikAla se paramaguru sarvajJadeva, aparaguru gaNadharAdi ne jisa vastusvarUpa kA varNana kiyA hai, vahI vastusvarUpa pUjya zrI kAnajI svAmI batalA rahe the| usI vastusvarUpa kA jJAna jo mere jJAna me AyA, use maiM sadaiva praznottaro ke rUpa me lekhabaddha karatA rahA thaa| dhIre-dhIre sarala praznottaro ke rUpa me samasta jaina-zAsana kA sAra lekhabaddha ho gyaa| mere vicAra me satya bAta samajha me na Ane kA mukhya kAraNa jinendradeva kI AjJA kA patA na honA aura jinAgama kA rahasya dRSTi me na Ane se apanI mithyA mAnyatAo ke anusAra zAstro kA abhyAsa karanA hai| jisake phalasvarUpa ajJAnI jIva svaya kI mithyAvuddhi se sasAra mArga kA zraddhAna-jJAna-AcaraNa karate haiN| vastuta kisI bhI anuyoga ke jaina zAstra kA svAdhyAya karane se pUrva yadi nimna praznottaro kA manana kara liyA jAya to zAstro kA sahI artha samajhane me suvidhA rahegI tathA sasAra mArga se bacane kA avakAza rhegaa| prazna 1-pratyeka vAkya me se cAra bAteM kauna-kaunasI nikAlane se rahasya spaSTa samajha me pA sakatA hai ? uttara-(1) jina, jinavara aura jinavaravRSabha kyA kahate hai ? (2) jina-jinavara aura jinavaravRSabho ke kathana ko sunakara jJAnI kyA jAnate haiM aura kyA karate hai ? (3) jina-jinavara aura jinavaravRSabho ke kathana ko sunakara samyaktva ke sanmukha mithyAdRSTi pAtra bhavya jIva kyA jAnate haiM aura kyA karate haiM ? (4) jina-jinavara aura

Page #10
(8) jinavaravRpabho ke kathana ko sunakara dIrgha sasArI mithyAdRSTi kyA jAnate haiM aura kyA karate haiM ? prazna 2 - jina-jinavara aura jinavaravRSabho ne padArtha kA svarUpa kaisA aura kyA batAyA hai ? jisake zraddhAna se sarva duHkha dUra ho jAtA hai ? uttara- " anAdinidhana vastue~ bhinna-bhinna apanI- apanI maryAdA sahita pariNamita hotI hai, koI kisI ke AdhIna nahI hai, koI kisI ke pariNamita karAne se pariNamita nahI hotii|" jina-jinavara aura jinavaravRSabho ne batAyA hai ki padArthoM kA aisA zraddhAna karane se sarvadukha dUra ho jAtA hai / prazna 3 - jina-jinavara aura jinavaravRSabho ke aise kathana ko sunakara jJAnI kyA jAnate haiM aura kyA karate haiM ? uttara - kevalI ke samAna padArthoM ke svarUpa kA jJAna ho gayA hai, mAtra pratyakSa aura parokSa kA antara rahatA hai / jJAnI apane trikAlI jJAyaka svabhAva me vizeSa sthiratA karake zreNI mAMDakara siddhadazA kI prApti kara lete hai / prazna 4 - jina-jinavara praura jinavaravRSabho ke kathana ko sunakara samyaktva ke sanmukha mithyAdRSTi pAtra bhavya jIva kyA jAnate haiM aura kyA karate haiM ? uttara - aho - aho ! jina-jinavara aura jinavaravRSabho kA kathana mahAna upakArI hai tathA pratyeka padArtha kI svatantratA dhyAna me A jAtI hai / apane trikAlI jJAyaka svabhAva kA Azraya lekara jJAnI vanakara jJAnI kI taraha nija- svabhAva me vizeSa ekAgratA karake zreNI mAMDara siddhadazA kI prApti kara lete hai / prazna 5 - jina-jinavara aura jinavaravRSabho ke kathana ko sunakara dIrgha saMsArI mithyAdRSTi kyA jAnate haiM aura kyA karate haiM ? uttara - jina-jinavara aura jinavaravRSabho ke kathana kA virodha - C

Page #11
(5) karate haiM tathA mithyAtva kI puSTi karake cAro gatiyo me ghUmate hue nigoda cale jAte haiN| prazna 6-prathama kina-kina pAca bAto kA nirNaya karake zAstrAbhyAsa kare to kalyANa kA avakAza hai ? uttara-(1) vyApya-vyApaka sambandha eka dravya kA usakI paryAya me hI hotA hai, do dravyo me vyApya-vyApaka sambandha kabhI bhI nahIM hotA haiN| (2) ajJAnI kA vyApya-vyApaka sambandha zubhAzubha vikArIbhAvo ke sAtha kaho to kaho, parantu para dravyo ke sAtha tathA dravyakarmoM ke sAtha to vyApya-vyApaka sambandha kisI bhI apekSA nahIM hai| (3) jJAnI kA zuddha bhAvo ke sAtha vyApya-vyApaka sambandha hai| (4) maiM AtmA vyApaka aura zuddhabhAva merA vyApya hai| aise vikalpo me bhI rahegA to dharma kI prApti nahI hogii| (5) maiM anAdiananta jJAyaka ekarUpa bhagavAna hU~ aura merI paryAya me merI mUrkhatA ke kAraNa eka-eka samaya kA bahirAtmapanA calA A rahA hai aisA jAne-mAne to turanta bahirAtmapane kA abhAva hokara antarAtmA bana jAtA hai| ina pA~ca bAto kA nirNaya karake zAstrAbhyAsa kare to kalyANa kA avakAza hai / prazna 7-Agama ke pratyeka vAkya kA marma jAnane ke lie kyAkyA jAnakara svAdhyAya kareM? uttara-cAro anuyogo ke pratyeka vAkya me (1) zabdArtha, (2) nayArtha, (3 matArtha, (4) AgamArtha aura (5) bhAvArtha nikAlakara svAdhyAya karane se jainadharma ke rahasya kA marmI bana jAtA hai / prazna 8-zabdArtha kyA hai ? uttara-prakaraNa anusAra vAkya yA zabda kA yogya artha samajhanA zabdArtha hai| prazna 6-nayArtha kyA hai ? uttara-kisa nayakA vAkya hai ? usame bheda-nimittAdi kA upacAra batAne vAle vyavahAranaya kA kathana hai yA vastusvarUpa batalAne vAle

Page #12
( 6 ) nizcayanaya kA kathana hai-usakA nirNaya karake artha karanA vaha nayArtha hai / prazna 10 - matArtha kyA hai ? uttara - vastusvarUpa se viparIta aise kisa mata kA ( sAkhyabauddhAdika) kA khaNDana karatA hai / aura syAdvAda mata kA maNDana karatA hai - isa prakAra zAstra kA kathana samajhanA vaha matArtha hai / prazna 11 - AgamArtha kyA hai ? uttara - siddhAnta anusAra jo artha prasiddha ho tadanusAra artha karanA vaha AgamArtha hai / prazna 12- bhAvArtha kyA hai ? uttara-- zAstra kathana kA tAtparya - sArAza, heya upAdeyarUpa prayojana kyA hai ? use jo batalAye vaha bhAvArtha hai / jaise- nirajana jJAnamayI nija paramAtma dravya hI upAdeya hai, isake sivAya nimitta athavA kisI bhI prakAra kA rAga upAdeya nahI hai / yaha kathana kA bhAvArtha hai / prazna 13 - padArthoM kA svarUpa sIde-sAde zabdoM meM kyA hai, jinake zraddhAna- jJAna se sampUrNa duHkha kA prabhAva ho jAtA hai ? uttara- " jIva ananta, pudgala anantAnanta, dharma-adharma - AkAza eka-eka aura loka pramANa asa~khyAta kAla dravya haiM / pratyeka dravya me ananta - ananta guNa haiM / pratyeka dravya ke pratyeka guNa me eka hI samaya me eka paryAya kA vyaya, eka paryAya kA utpAda aura guNa ghrovya rahatA hai / aisA pratyeka dravya ke pratyeka guNa me ho cukA hai, ho rahA hai aura hotA rahegA / " isake zraddhAna- jJAna se sampUrNa dukha kA abhAva jinAgama me batAyA hai / prazna 14 -- kisake samAgama me rahakara tattva kA abhyAsa karanA Tarfe aura kisake samAgama meM rahakara tattva kA abhyAsa kabhI nahIM karanA cAhie ? 2

Page #13
(7) uttara-jJAniyo ke samAgama me rahakara hI tattva abhyAsa karanA ' cAhie aura ajJAniyo ke samAgama me rahakara tattva abhyAsa kabhI bhI ___ nahI karanA caahie| 'prazna 15-mokSa mArga prakAzaka meM 'jJAniyo ke samAgama me tatva abhyAsa karanA aura prajJAniyo ke samAgama me rahakara tattva abhyAsa nahIM karanA" aisA kahIM likhA hai ? uttara-prathama adhyAya pRSTha 17 me likhA hai ki "vizeSa guNo ke dhArI vaktA kA sayoga mile to bahuta bhalA hai hI aura na mile to zraddhAnAdika guNo ke dhArI vaktAo ke mukha se hI zAstra sunanA / isa prakAra ke guNo ke dhAraka muni athavA zrAvaka samyagdRSTi unake mukha se to zAstra sunanA yogya hai aura paddhati buddhi se athavA zAstra sunane ke lobha se zraddhAnAdi guNa rahita pApI puruSo ke mukha se zAstra sunanA ucita nahI hai|" prazna 16-pAhuDa dohA meM "kisakA sahavAsa nahIM karanA cAhie" aisA kahA likhA hai ? . uttara-pAhuDa dohA bIsa me likhA hai ki "viSa bhalA, viSadhara 'sarpa bhalA, agni yA banavAsa kA sevana bhI bhalA, parantu jinadharma se vimukha aise mithyAtviyo kA sahavAsa bhalA nhii|" prazna 17-apanA bhalA cAhane vAle ko kauna-kauna sI sAta bAto kA nirNaya karanA cAhiye ? uttara-(2) samyagdarzana se hI dharma kA prArambha hotA hai / (2) samyagdarzana prApta kie binA kisI bhI jIva ko sacce vrata, sAmAyika pratikramaNa, tapa, pratyAkhyAnAdi nahI hote, kyoki vaha kriyA prathama pAcave guNasthAna me zubhabhAvarUpa se hotI hai| (3) zubhabhAva jJAnI aura ajJAnI dono ko hote haiN| kintu ajJAnI usase dharma hogA, hita hogA aisA mAnatA hai| jJAnI kI dRSTi me heya hone se vaha usase kadApi hitarUpa dharma kA honA nahIM mAnatA hai| (4) aisA nahI

Page #14
(8) samajhanA ki dharmI ko zubhabhAva hotA hI nahI, kintu vaha zubhabhAva ko dharma athavA usase kramaza dharma hogA-aisA nahI mAnatA, kyoki ananta vItarAga devo ne use bandha kA kAraNa kahA hai| (5) eka dravya / dUsare dravya kA kucha kara nahI sakatA, use pariNamita nahIM kara sakatA, preraNA nahI kara sakatA, lAbha-hAni nahI kara sakatA, usa para prabhAva nahI DAla sakatA, usakI sahAyatA yA upakAra nahI kara sakatA, use / mAra-jilA nahI sakatA, aisI pratyeka dravya-guNa-paryAya kI sampUrNa svatantratA ananta jJAniyo ne pukAra-pukAra kara kahI hai| (6) jinamata me to aisA paripATI hai ki prathama samyaktva aura phira vratAdi hote / hai / vaha samyaktva sva-parakA zraddhAna hone para hotA hai tathA vaha zraddhAna dravyAnuyoga kA abhyAsa karane se hotA hai / isalie prathama dravyAnuyoga ' ke anusAra zraddhAna karake samyagdRSTi bananA caahie| (7) pahale guNasthAna me jijJAsu jIvo ko zAstrAbhyAsa, adhyayana-manana, jJAnI puruSo kA dharmopadeza-zravaNa, nirantara unakA samAgama, devadarzana, pUjA, bhaktidAna Adi zubhabhAva hote haiM / kintu pahale guNasthAna me sacce vrata, tapa Adi nahI hote hai| prazna 18-ubhayAbhAsI ke donoM nayo kA grahaNa bhI mithyAbatalA diyA to vaha kyA kare ? (dono nayo ko kisa prakAra samajhe ?) uttara-nizcayanaya se jo nirupaNa kiyA ho use to satyArtha mAnakara usakA zraddhAna agIkAra karanA aura vyavahAranaya se jo nirupaNa kiyA ho use asatyArtha mAnakara usakA zraddhAna choddnaa| prazna 16-vyavahAranaya kA tyAga karake nizcayanaya ko agIkAra karane kA Adeza kahIM bhagavAna amRtacandrAcArya ne diyA hai ? uttara-hA, diyA hai / samayasAra kalaza 173 me Adeza diyA hai ki "sarva hI hiMsAdi va ahiMsAdi me adhyavasAya hai so samasta hI choDanA-aisA jinadevo ne kahA hai / amRtacandrAcArya kahate haiM ki-" isaliye maiM aisA mAnatA hai ki jo parAzrita vyavahAra hai so sarva hI

Page #15
( 6 ) chuDAyA hai to phira santapuruSa eka parama trikAlI jJAyaka nizcaya hI ko agIkAra karake zuddhajJAnaghanarUpa nija mahimA meM sthiti kyo nahI karate ? aisA kahakara AcArya bhagavAna ne kheda prakaTa kiyA hai / prazna 20 -- nizcayanaya ko agokAra karane aura vyavahAranaya ke tyAga ke viSaya me bhagavAna kundakunda zrAcArya ne mokSaprAbhuta gAthA 31 me kyA kahA hai ? uttara--jo vyavahAra kI zraddhA chor3atA hai vaha yogI apane Atma kArya me jAgatA hai tathA jo vyavahAra me jAgatA hai vaha apane kArya me sotA hai / isalie vyavahAranaya kA zraddhAna choDakara nizcayanaya kA zraddhAna karanA yogya hai / yahI bAta samAghitantra gAthA 78 me bhagavAna pUjyapAda AcArya ne batAI hai| prazna 21 - vyavahAranaya kA zraddhAna choDakara nizcayanaya kA zraddhAna karanA kyo yogya hai ? uttara ---vyavahAranaya ( 1 ) svadravya, paradravya ko (2) tathA unake bhAvo ko (3) tathA kAraNa-kAryAdi ko, kisI ko kisI me milA kara nirUpaNa karatA hai / so aise hI zraddhAna se mithyAtva hotA hai isalie usakA tyAga karanA cAhie aura nizcayanaya unhI kA yathAvata nirUpaNa karatA hai / tathA kisI ko kisI me nahI milAtA aura aise hI zraddhAna se samyaktva hotA hai / isaliye usakA zraddhAna karanA cAhie / prazna 22 -- Apa kahate ho ki vyavahAranaya ke zraddhAna se mithyAtva hotA hai isalie usakA tyAga karanA aura nizcayanaya ke zraddhAna se samyaktva hotA hai isalie usakA zraddhAna karanA / parantu jinamArga me nayoM kA grahaNa karanA kahA hai| usakA kyA kAraNa hai ? uttara - jinamArga me kahI to nizcayanaya kI mukhyatA liye vyAkhyAna hai, use to satyArtha aise hI hai - aisA jAnanA tathA kahI An

Page #16
(10) vyavahAranaya kI mukhyatA liye vyAkhyAna hai| use "aise hai nahI, nimittAdi kI apekSA upacAra kiyA hai"-aisA jAnanA / isa prakAra jAnane kA nAma hI dono nayo kA grahaNa hai| prazna 23-kucha manISI aisA kahate haiM ki "aise bhI hai aura aise bhI hai" isa prakAra dono nayo kA grahaNa karanA cAhiye; kyA una mahAnubhAvo kA kahanA galata hai ? uttara-hA, vilkula galata hai, kyoki unhe jinendra bhagavAna kI AjJA kA patA nahI hai tathA dono nayo ke vyAkhyAna ko samAna satyArtha jAnakara "aise bhI hai aura aise bhI hai" isa prakAra bhramarUpa pravartana se to dono nayo kA grahaNa karanA nahI kahA hai / prazna 24-vyavahAranaya asatyArtha hai| to usakA upadeza jinamArga me kisaliye diyA ? eka mAtra nizcayanaya hI kA nirUpaNa karanA thaa| uttara-aisA hI tarka samayasAra me kiyA hai| vahA~ yaha uttara diyA hai-jisa prakAra mleccha ko mleccha bhASA binA artha grahaNa karAne meM koI samartha nahIM hai; usI prakAra vyavahAra ke binA (sasAra me sasArI bhASA vinA) paramArtha kA upadeza azakya hai / isa liye vyavahAra kA upadeza hai| isa prakAra nizcaya kA jJAna karAne ke liye vyavahAra dvArA upadeza dete haiN| vyavahAranaya hai, usakA viSaya bhI hai, parantu vaha agIkAra karane yogya nahIM hai| prazna 25-vyavahAra binA nizcaya kA upadeza kaise nahIM hotA hai| isake pahale prakAra ko samajhAie? uttara-nizcaya se AtmA para dravyo se bhinna svabhAvo se abhinna svayasiddha vastu hai| use jo nahI pahacAnate unase isI prakAra kahate rahe taba to ve samajha nahI pAye / isaliye unako vyavahAranaya se zarIrAdika para dravyo kI sApekSatA dvArA nara-nAraka

Page #17
( 11 ) pRthvIkAyAdikarUpa jIva ke vizeSa kiye, taba manuSya jIva hai, nArako jIva hai / ityAdi prakAra sahita unhe jIva kI pahacAna huI / isa prakAra vyavahAra vinA (zarIra ke sayoga vinA) nizcaya ke (AtmA ke) upadeza kA na honA jAnanA / prazna 26-prazna 25 meM vyavahAranaya se zarIrAdika sahita jIva kI pahacAna karAI taba aise vyavahAranaya ko kaise agIkAra nahIM karanA cAhie? so smjhaaie| uttara-vyavahAranaya se nara-nAraka Adi paryAya hI ko jIva kahA so paryAya hI ko jIva nahI mAna lenA / vartamAna paryAya to jIvapudagala ke sayogarUpa hai / vahA nizcaya se jIva dravya bhinna hai-usa hI ko jIva mAnanA / jIva ke sayoga se zarIrAdika ko bhI upacAra se jIva kahA so kathanamAtra hI hai / paramArtha se zarIrAdika jIva hote nahI, aisA hI zraddhAna krnaa| isa prakAra vyavahAranaya (zarIrAdi vAlA jIva) agIkAra karane yogya nahIM hai| prazna 27-vyavahAra binA (bheda binA) nizcaya kA (abheda AtmA kA) upadeza kaise nahIM hotA? isa dUsare prakAra ko smjhaaiye| uttara-nizcaya se AtmA abheda vastu hai| use jo nahI pahacAnate unase isI prakAra kahate rahe to ve samajha nahI paaye| taba unako abheda vastu me bheda utpanna karake jJAna-darzanAdi guNa-paryAyarUpa jIva ke vizeSa kiye| tava jAnane vAlA jIva hai, dekhane vAlA jIva hai| ityAdi prakAra sahita jIva kI pahacAna huI / isa prakAra bheda vinA abheda ke upadeza kA na honA jAnanA / prazna 28-prazna 27 me vyavahAranaya se jJAna-darzana bheda dvArA jIva ko pahacAna kraaii| taba aise bhedarUpa vyavahAranaya ko kaise aMgIkAra nahIM karanA cAhiye ? so smjhaaiye| uttara-abheda AtmA me jJAna-darzanAdi bheda kiye so unheM bheda /

Page #18
( 12 ) rUpa hI nahI mAna lenA kyoki bheda to samajhAne ke artha kiye hai / nizcaya se AtmA abheda hI hai / usa hI ko jIvavastu mAnanA / sajJAsaMkhyA - lakSaNa Adi se bheda kahe so kathana mAtra hI hai / paramArtha se dravyaguNa bhinna-bhinna nahI hai, aisA hI zraddhAna karanA / isa prakAra bhedarUpa vyavahAranaya agIkAra karane yogya nahI hai / prazna 26 - vyavahAra binA nizcaya kA upadeza kaise nahI hotA ? isake tIsare prakAra ko samajhAiye | uttara - nizcaya se vItarAga bhAva mokSamArga hai / use jo nahI pahacAnate unako aise hI kahate rahe to ve samajha nahI pAye / taba unako tattva zraddhAna jJAnapUrvaka, paradravya ke nimitta miTane kI sApekSatA dvArA vyavahAranaya se vrata - zIla-sayamAdi at aai bhAva ke vizeSa batalAye taba unhe vItarAgabhAva kI pahacAna huI / isa prakAra vyavahAra binA nizcaya mokSa mArga ke upadeza kA na honA jAnanA / prazna 30 - prazna 26 me vyavahAranaya se mokSa mArga kI pahacAna karAI / taba aise vyavahAranaya ko kaise agIkAra nahIM karanA cAhiye ? so samajhAie / uttara -- paradravya kA nimitta milane kI apekSA se vrata-zIlasayamAdika ko mokSamArga kahA / so inhI ko mokSamArga nahI mAna lenA, kyoki ( 1 ) paradravya kA grahaNa - tyAga AtmA ke ho to AtmA paradravya kA kartA hartA ho jAve / parantu koI dravya kisI dravya ke AdhIna nahI hai / ( 2 ) isalie AtmA apane bhAva jo rAgAdika hai, unhe choDakara vItarAgI hotA hai / ( 3 ) isalie nizcaya se vItarAga bhAva hI mokSamArga hai / ( 4 ) vItarAga bhAvo ke aura vratAdika ke kadAcita kArya-kAraNapanA ( nimitta na mittikapanA) hai, isalie, vratAdi ko mokSamArga kahe so kathanamAtra hI hai / paramArtha se bAhyakriyA

Page #19
( 13 ) mokSamArga nahI hai - aisA hI zraddhAna krnaa| isa prakAra vyavahAranaya agIkAra karane yogya nahI hai, aisA jAnanA / prazna 31 - jo jIva vyavahAranaya ke kathana ko hI saccA mAna letA hai use jinavANI me kina-kina nAmo se sambodhana kiyA hai ? uttara- (1) puruSArtha siddhayupAya gAthA 6 me kahA hai ki "tasya dezanA nAsti" / (2) samayasAra kalaza 55 me kahA hai ki "ajJAnamoha andhakAra hai usakA sulaTanA durnivAra hai" / (3) pravacanasAra gAthA 55 me kahA hai ki "vaha pada-pada para dhokhA khAtA hai" / ( 4 ) AtmAvalokana meM kahA hai ki "yaha usakA harAmajAdIpanA hai" / ityAdi saba zAstro meM mUrkha Adi nAmo se sambodhana kiyA hai / prazna 32 -- paramAgama ke amUlya 11 siddhAnta kyA-kyA haiM, jo mokSArthI ko sadA smaraNa rakhanA cAhie aura ve jinavANI se kahA~kahA~ batalAye haiM ? uttara - ( 1 ) eka dravya dUsare dravya ko sparza nahI karatA hai / [ samayasAra gAthA 3 ] ( 2 ) pratyeka dravya kI pratyeka paryAya kramabaddha hI hotI hai / [ samayasAra gAthA 308 se 311 taka ] (3) utpAda, utpAda se hai vyaya yA dhruva se nahI hai / [ pravacanasAra gAthA 101 ] ( 4 ) pratyeka paryAya apane janmakSaNa me hI hotI hai / [ pravacanasAra gAthA 102] (5) utpAda apane paTakAraka ke pariNamana se hI hotA hai [ pacAstikAya gAthA 62 ] (6) paryAya aura dhruva ke pradeza bhinna-bhinna haiM [ samayasAra gAthA 181 se 183 taka ] (7) bhAva zakti ke kAraNa paryAya hotI hI hai, karanI paDatI nahI / [ samayasAra 33vI zakti ] (8) nija bhUtArtha svabhAva ke Azraya se hI samyagdarzana hotA hai / [ samayasAra gAthA 11 ] ( 2 ) cAro anuyogo kA tAtparya mAtra vItarAgatA hai / [ paMcAstikAya gAthA 172 ] ( 10) svadravya me bhI dravya guNa- paryAya kA bheda vicAranA vaha anyavazapaNA hai / [

Page #20
( 14 ) 145] (11) dhruva kA Alambana hai vedana nahI hai aura paryAya kA vedana hai, parantu Alambana nahI hai / prazna 33 - paryAya kA saccA kAraNa kauna hai aura kauna nahIM hai ? uttara - paryAya kA kAraNa usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA hai / vAstava me paryAya kI eka samaya kI sattA hI paryAya kA saccA kAraNa hai / [ a ] paryAya kA kAraNa para to ho hI nahI sakatA hai, kyoki parakA to dravya kSetra - kAla-bhAva pRthaka-pRthaka haiM / [A] paryAya kA kAraNa trikAlI dravya bhI nahI ho sakatA hai kyoki paryAya eka samaya kI hai yadi trikAlI kAraNa ho to paryAya bhI trikAla honI cAhie so hai nahI / [i] paryAya kA kAraNa anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya bhI nahI ho sakatI hai kyoki abhAva me se bhAva kI utpatti nahI ho sakatI hai| isalie yaha siddha hotA hai ki paryAya kA saccA kAraNa usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA hI hai / - prazna 34 - mujha nija AtmA kA svadravya-paradravya kyA - kyA hai, jisake jAnane-mAnane se cAro gatiyo kA abhAva ho jAve ? uttara- (1) svadravya arthAta nirvikalpa mAtra vastu paradravya arthAta savikalpa bheda kalpanA, (2) svakSetra arthAta AdhAra mAtra vastu kA pradeza, para kSetra arthAta pradezo me bheda par3anA (3) svakAla arthAta vastumAtra kI mUla avasthA, parakAla arthAta eka samaya kI paryAya, (4) svabhAva arthAta vastu ke mUla kI sahaja zakti, parabhAva arthAta guNabheda karanA / [ samayasAra kalaza 252] prazna 35 - kisa kAraNa se samyaktva kA adhikArI bana sakatA hai aura kisa kAraNa se samyaktva kA adhikArI nahIM bana sakatA ? uttara - dekho | tattva vicAra kI mahimA tattva vicAra rahita devAdika kI pratIti kare, bahuta zAstro kA abhyAsa kare, vratAdi pAle, tatpazcaraNAdi kare, usako to samyaktva hone kA adhikAra nahI aura 1

Page #21
( 15 ) tattva vicAra vAlA inake binA bhI samyaktva kA adhikArI hotA hai / [ mokSamArga prakAzaka pRSTha 260 ] prazna 36 - jIva kA kartavya kyA hai ? uttara - jIva kA kartavya to tattva nirNaya kA abhyAsa hI hai isI se darzana moha kA upazama to svameva hotA hai usame ( darzanamoha ke upazama me) jIva kA karttavya kucha nahI hai / [ mokSamArga prakAzaka pRSTha 314] prazna 37 - jinadharma kI paripATI kyA hai ? uttara - jinamata me to aisI paripATI hai ki prathama samyaktva hotA hai phira vratAdi hote haiM / samyaktva to sva-para kA zraddhAna hone para hotA hai, tathA vaha zraddhAna dravyAnuyoga kA abhyAsa karane se hotA hai / isalie prathama dravya-guNa paryAya kA abhyAsa karake samyagdRSTi bananA pratyeka bhavya jIva kA parama kartavya hai / [ mokSamArga prakAzaka pRSTha 293 ] prazna 38 - kina-kina granthoM kA abhyAsa kare to eka bhUtArtha svabhAva kA Azraya bana sake ? uttara - mokSamArga prakAzaka va jaina siddhAnta praveza ratnamAlA ke sAta bhAgo kA sUkSmarIti se abhyAsa kare to bhUtArtha svabhAva kA aa art at | prazna 36 - mokSa mArga prakAzaka va jaina siddhAMta praveza ratnamAlA me kyA-kyA viSaya batAyA hai ? uttara- chaha dravya, sAta tattva, chaha sAmAnya guNa, cAra abhAva, chaha kAraka, dravya-guNa paryAya kI svatantratA, upAdAna - upAdeya, nimitta naimittika yogyatA, nimitta samayasAra sauvI gAthA ke cAra bola, apazamakAdi pAca bhAva, tyAgane yogya mithyAdarzanAdi kA svarUpa tathA pragaTa karane yogya samyagdarzanAdi kA svarUpa tathA eka nija ke Azraya se hI dharma kI prApti ho sakatI hai, Adi viSayo kA

Page #22
( 16) rIti se varNana kiyA hai tAki jIva nija svabhAva kA Azraya lekara mokSa kA pathika bne| prazna 40-kyA jaina siddhAnta praveza ratnamAlA ke sAtabhAga Apane banAye hai ? uttara-jana siddhAnta praveza ratnamAlA ke sAta bhAga to AhAra vargaNA kA kArya hai| vyavahAranaya se nirUpaNa kiyA jAtA hai ki maiMne banAye hai| are bhaaii| cAro anuyogo ke grantho me se paramAgama kA mUla nikAlakara thoDe me saMgraha kara diyA hai| tAki pAtra bhavya jIva sugamatA se dharma kI prApti ke yogya ho sake / ina sAta bhAgo kA eka mAtra uddezya mithyAtvAdi kA abhAva karake samyagdarzanAdi kI prApti kara kramaza mokSa kA pathika bananA hI hai| bhavadIya kailAza candra jaina bandha aura mokSa ke kAraNa paradravya kA cintana hI bandha kA kAraNa hai aura kevala vizuddha svadravya kA cintana hI mokSa kA kAraNa hai| [tatvajJAnatara giNI 15-16] | - - samyaktvI sarvatra sukhI samyagdarzana sahita jIva kA narakavAsa bhI zreSTha hai, parantu samyagdarzana rahita jIva kA svarga me rahanA bhI zobhA nahIM detA; kyoMki AtmajJAna binA svarga meM bhI vaha duHkhI hai|| jahA~ AtmajJAna hai vahIM saccA sukha hai| [sArasamuccaya-39]

Page #23
// zrI vItarAgAya namaH // jaina siddhAnta praveza ratnamAlA dvitIya bhAga Namo arahatANaM, Namo siddhANa, Namo AyariyANaM / Namo uvajjhAyANaM, Namo loe savvasAhUNa // 1 // maMgalaM bhagavAna vIro maMgalaM gautamo gaNI / maMgalaM kundakundAyeM jaina dharmo'stu maMgalam // 2 // AtmA jJAnaM svayaM jJAnaM jJAnAdanyatkaroti kim / parabhAvasya kartAtmA, moho'yaM vyavahAriNAm // 3 // ajJAna timirAndhAnAM jJAnAJjana zalAkayA / cakSurunmIlitaM yena tasmai zrI gurave namaH // 4 // upAdAna nija zakti hai jiya ko mUla svabhAva / hai nimitta para yoga teM vanyo anAdi banAva // 5 // upAdAna aru nimitta ye saba jIvana pai vIra / jo nija zakti sambhAla hI so pahuMce bhavatIra // 6 // deva gurU dono khar3e kisake balihArI gurudeva kI bhagavAna diyo karuNAnidhi gurudeva zrI diyA jJAnI mAne parakha kara, kare mUDha lAgU pAMva | batAya // 7 // satya upadeza / saMkleza // 8 //

Page #24
chaha kAraka pahalA adhikAra prazna 1-chaha kAraka adhikAra me "adhikAra" zabda kyA batAtA uttara-apane trikAlI svabhAva para adhikAra mAne to samyagdarzana kI prApti hokara krama se mokSa kI prApti hotI hai| para vastuo me yA vikArI bhAvo me apanA adhikAra mAne to nigoda kI prApti hotI hai jo jIva paravastuo me yA vikArI bhAvo me apanA adhikAra mAnatA hai use hajAra vAra dhikkAra yaha "adhikAra" zabda batAtA hai / prazna 2-kAraka kise kahate haiM ? uttara-jo kriyA kA janaka ho arthAta kriyA ko utpanna karane vAlA ho use kAraka kahate haiN| prazna 3-kAraka kauna kahalA sakatA hai ? uttara-jo kisI-na-kisI rUpa me kriyA,vyApAra ke prati prayojaka hotA hai, kAraka vahI ho sakatA hai anya nhii| prazna 4-kriyA zabda ke paryAyavAcI nAma kyA-kyA haiM ? uttara-kriyA ko karma, avasthA, paryAya, hAlata, dazA, pariNAma, pariNati bhI kahate haiN| prazna 5-sasAra me kyA dekhA jAtA hai ? uttara-kArya dekhA jAtA hai / prazna 6-kArya para se kitane prazna uThate haiM ? uttara-chaha hI prazna uThate haiM kama jyAdA nahI uThate hai| prazna -kArya para se chaha prazna kauna-kauna se uThate haiM ? uttara-(1) kisane kiyA ? kartA / (2) kyA kiyA ? karma (3) kisa sadhina dvArA kiyA ? karaNa / (4) kisake lie kiyA ? sampradAna / (5) kisame se kiyA ? apaadaan| (6) kisake AdhAra se kiyA ? adhikaraNa / isa prakAra kArya para se chaha hI prazna uThate hai|

Page #25
( 16 ) prazna 8-kAraka kitane haiM aura kauna-kauna se haiM ? uttara-chaha haiM-(1) kartA (2) karma (3) karaNa (4) sampradAna (5) apAdAna aura (6) adhikaraNa / prazna :-vibhakti kitanI haiM ? uttara-sambodhana sahita ATha haiN| prazna 10-kArako me se kauna-kauna sI vibhakti nikAla dI ? uttara-chaThI sambandha vibhakti aura sambodhana ko nikAla diyaa| prazna 11-chaThI sambandha vibhakti aura sambodhana ko kyo nikAla diyA? uttara-(1) chaThI vibhakti sambandha ko batAtI hai jaise -merA makAna, merA bhagavAna / kAraka kI paribhASA me, "jo kriyA kA janaka ho use kAska kahate hai" / chaThI vibhakti me kAryapanA nahI pAyA jAtA aura jJAnI kisI ke sAtha sambandha nahI mAnate, isalie chaThI vibhakti ko nikAla diyaa| (2) sambodhana me-he rAma, he lakSmaNapanA pAyA jAtA hai, kriyApanA nahIM pAyA jAtA aura jJAnI kisI ko sambodhate nahI, kyoki pratyeka AtmA jJAna kA kanda hai isalie sambodhana ko bhI nikAla diyaa| prazna 12-vibhakti ke kitane artha haiM ? uttara-do haiM (1) vi=vizeSa rUpa se| bhakti-lInatA karanA arthAt AtmA me vizeSa prakAra lInatA karanA yaha nizcaya bhakti arthAt vibhakti kA pahalA artha hai| (2) vi arthAt vizeSa prakAra se, bhakta arthAt pRthak honA, yaha vibhakti kA dUsarA artha, hai / prazna 13-dUsarA vibhakti kA artha jo "vizeSa prakAra se pRthak honA" kiyA hai yaha kisa-phisa se pRthak honA hai ? uttara-(1) atyanta bhinna parapadArthoM se pRthak honA (2) A~kha nAka-kAna rUpa audArika zarIra se pRthak honA (3) taijasa kArmANazarIra se pRthak honA (4) zabda aura mana se pRthakA honA

Page #26
( 20 ) (5) zubhAzubha vikArI bhAvo se pRthaka honA (6) apUrNa pUrNa zuddha paryAyo ke pakSa se pRthaka honA (7) bhedanaya ke pakSa se pRthaka honA (8) abhedanaya ke pakSa se pRthaka honA ( 9 ) bhedAbhedanaya ke pakSa se pRthak honA / prazna 14- prathama vibhakti kA artha hai " AtmA me vizeSa prakAra se lInatA" usakI prApti kaise ho ? uttara- nau prakAra ke pakSo se merI AtmA kA koI sambandha nahI hai aisA jAnakara apanI AtmA jo ananta guNo kA abheda piNDa hai usakI ora dRSTi kare to " AtmA me vizeSa prakAra se lInatA kI prApti hove" / prazna 15 - apane me vizeSa prakAra se bhakti karane se kyA kyA hotA hai ? uttara - anAdikAla se nau prakAra ke pakSo me jo kartA-karmAdi kI buddhi hai usakA abhAva ho jAtA hai aura apane bhagavAna kA patA cala jAtA hai / krama se vRddhi karate-karate, pUrNa paramAtmApanA paryAya me pragaTa ho jAtA hai / prazna 16 - chaha kArako ke jJAna se kyA honA ? uttara - anAdikAla se yaha jIva apane ko bhUla kara para me, vikAra me yA kisI pakSa me paDakara pAgala ho rahA hai / yadi yaha chaha kArako kA jJAna karale, to pAgalapane kA abhAba ho jAve / prazna 17 - yaha kArakoM kA jJAna karake hama jJAnI mAne jAveM aura loga hamArA Adara kareM, hameM rupayo-paiso kI prApti ho, aisA mAnakara jo chaha kArako kA jJAna kare to kyA hotA hai ? uttara - aisA jIva ananta sasAra kA pAtra hotA hai kyoki chaha kArako ke jJAna se to anantakAla kI para me kartA-bhoktA kI khoTI buddhi kA abhAva hotA hai, usake badale usane sAsArika prayojana sAdhe jo paramparA se nigoda kA kAraNa hai / , C

Page #27
( 21 ) prazna 18 - kAraka kA nirUpaNa kitane prakAra se hai ? uttara - do prakAra se hai - nizcayakAraka, vyavahArakAraka / prazna 16 - jo vyavahAra kAraka hai unhIM ko sarvathA saccA mAne to use zAstro meM kyA-kyA kahA hai ? uttara - ( 1 ) puruSArtha siddhipAya me 'tasya dezanA nAsti' kahA hai / ( 2 ) samayasAra kalaza 55 me 'yaha ahakArarUpa moha ajJAna andhakAra hai, usakA sulaTanA durnivAra hai' aisA kahA hai / (3) pravacanasAra me 'pada pada para dhokhA khAtA hai' aisA kahA hai / ( 4 ) AtmAvalokana me 'harAmajAdopanA' kahA hai / (5) samayasAra me 'mithyAdRSTi tathA usakA phala sasAra hai' aisA kahA hai / (6) mokSamArgaprakAzaka me 'usake saba dharma ke aga mithyAtva bhAva ko prApta hote haiM tathA 'mithyAdarzana' va akAryakArI tathA 'anIti' Adi zabdo se samvodhana kiyA hai / isalie jo vyavahAra ke kathana ko saccA mAnatA hai usase mithyAtva hotA hai aura use kabhI bhI dharma kI prApti nahI hotI hai / prazna 20 - vyavahArakAraka ke viSaya me kyA samajhanA aura kyA yAda rakhanA cAhie ? uttara- "paramArthata koI dravya kisI kA kartA hartA nahI ho / sakatA", isalie yaha vyavahArakAraka asatya hai / ve mAtra upacarita asadabhUta vyavahArarnaya se kahe jAte haiM / nizcaya se kisI dravya ke sAtha kArakapane kA sambandha hai hI nahI / prazna 21 - jahA~ zAstro me vyavahArakAraka aura nizcayakAraka kA kathana kiyA ho, vahA~ kyA jAnanA cAhie ? uttara - jahA~ vyavahArakAraka kA nirupaNa kiyA ho use asatyArtha mAnakara usakA zraddhAna choDanA aura jahA~ nizcayakAraka kA nirupaNa kiyA ho use satyArtha mAnakara usakA zraddhAna agIkAra karanA, kyoki 'samayasAra kalaza 173 me kahA hai ki vyavahArakAraka me jo adhyavasAya hai so samasta hI choDanA - aisA jinadevo ne kahA hai / isalie sama

Page #28
( 22 ) vyavahArakAraka kA zraddhAna choDakara nizcayakAraka ko jAnakara apane jJAnadhana rUpa me pravartanA yukta hai / prazna 22 - nizcayakAraka aura vyavahArakAraka ke viSaya me kundakunda bhagavAna ne mokSapAhuDa gAthA 31 me kyA kahA hai ? uttara - jo vyavahArakAraka kI zraddhA chor3atA hai vaha yogI apane jAtA hai tathA jo vyavahArakArako se lAbha mAnatA hai - vaha apane Atma kAryaM me sotA hai / isalie vyavahArakAraka kA zraddhAna choDakara nizcayakAraka kA zraddhAna karanA yogya hai / { prazna 23 - vyavahArakAraka kA zraddhAna chor3akara nizcaya kAraka kA zraddhAna kyo karanA yogya hai ? uttara - vyavahAranaya = nizcayakAraka aura vyavahArakAraka ko kisI ko kisI me milAkara nirupaNa karatA hai so aise hI zraddhAna se mithyAtva hai isaliye usakA tyAga karanA / tathA nizcayanaya = nizcayakAraka aura vyavahArakAraka ko yathAvat nirUpaNa karatA hai kisI ko kisI me nahI milAtA hai, so aise hI zraddhAna se samyaktva hotA hai isalie usakA zraddhAna karanA / Z3 prazna 24 - Apa kahate ho - vyavahArakAraka ke zraddhAna se mithyAtva' hotA hai isaliye usakA zraddhAna choDo aura nizcayakAraka ke zraddhAna se samyaktva hotA hai isaliye usakA zraddhAna karo, parantu jina marga me dono kArako kA grahaNa karanA kahA hai so kaise hai ? uttara - jinamArga me jahA~ nizcayakAraka kI mukhyatA liye vyAkhyAna hai, use to "satyArtha aise hI hai" - aisA jAnanA / tathA jahA~ vyavahArakAraka kI mukhyatA liye vyAkhyAna hai, use "aise hai nahI, ' nimittAdi kI apekSA upacAra kiyA hai aisA jAnanA " - isa prakAra jAnane kA nAma hI nizcayakAraka aura vyavahArakAraka kA grahaNa hai / prazna 25 - koI-koI vidvAna dono kArako ke vyAkhyAna ko

Page #29
( 23 ) samAna satyArtha jAnakara "aise bhI haiM, aise bhI haiM" - isa prakAra kahate haiM kyA unakA kahanA galata hai ? uttara - galata hai, kyoki nizcayakAraka vyayahArakAraka donokArako ke vyAkhyAna ko samAna satyArtha jAnakara "aise bhI haiM, aise bhI haiM" - isa prakAra bhramarUpa pravartana se to dono kArako kA grahaNa karanA hI kahA hai / prazna 26 -- yadi vyavahArakAraka asatyArtha hai to usakA upadeza jina mArga meM kisaliye diyA ? eka nizcaya kAraka kA hI nirupaNa karanA thaa| uttara - vyavahArakAraka ke vinA nizcayakAraka kA upadeza azakya hai, isalie vyavahAra kAraka kA upadeza hai / nizcayakAraka kA jJAna karAne ke liye vyavahArakAraka dvArA upadeza dete haiM / vyavahArakAraka hai, vyavahArakAraka kA viSaya hai, jAnane yogya hai, parantu agIkAra karane yogya nahI hai | prazna 27 - kArya ke kAraka kitane kahe jAte haiM ? uttara - cAra kahe jAte hai - ( 1 ) usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA, anantarapUrva kSaNavarttIparyAya, (3) trikAlI, (4) nimitta, isa prakAra kArya ke kAraNa cAra kahe jAte hai / prazna 28 - zAstro me kahIM kArya kA kAraNa usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA ko; kahIM anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya ko; kahIM trikAlI ko aura kahIM nimitta ko kyo kahA hai| ? uttara --- (1) jahA~ zAstro me kArya kA kAraka usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA ko kahA ho, vahA~ yaha hI saccA kAraka hai aura anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kA kArya saccA kAraka nahI hai - aisA jAnanA / (2) jahA~ kahI kArya kA kAraka anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya ko kahA ho, vahA~ bhUta-bhaviSya kI paryAyo se pRthaka karAne kI apekSA kahA hai - aisA jAnanA / (3) jahA~ kahI kArya kA kAraka trikAlI ko kahA ho, vahA~ nimittakAraka kI dRSTi chuDAne ke lie kahA hai - aisA jAnanA / 7

Page #30
( 24 ) prazna 26 - svAzrito nizcayakAraka aura parAdhito vyavahArakAraka kI apekSA kisa-kisa prakAra haiM ? uttara- (1) kArya kA kAraka usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA svAzrita nizcayakAraka kahA ho, usakI apekSA anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya ko parAzrita vyavahArakAraka kahA jAtA hai / (2) kArya kA kAraka anantara pUrvakSaNavartI paryAya ko svAzrita nizcayakAraka kahA ho, usakI apekSA trikAlI ko parAzrita vyavahAra kAraka kahA jAtA hai / (3) kArya kA kAraka trikAlI ko svAzrita nizcayakAraka kahA ho, usakI apekSA nimitta ko parAzrita vyavahArakAraka kahA jAtA hai / prazna 30 - jina-jinavara aura jinavaravRSabho ne cAra kArako ke viSaya meM kyA batalAyA hai ? uttara - kArya kA kAraka usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA hI hai / parantu jaba-jaba kArya hotA hai vAkI ke tIna kAraka bhI hote haiM kyoki 'jisane pUrva avasthA prApta kI hai aisA dravya bhI jo ki ucita vahiraga sAdhano ke sAnnidhya ke sadabhAva me aneka prakAra kI bahuta sI avasthAyeM karatA hai" - aisA jAnanA / [ pravacanasAra gAthA 65 kI TIkA se ] prazna 31 - koI mAtra kArya kA kAraka usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA ko hI mAne, bAkI kArako kA sarvayA niSedha kare to kyA vaha ThIka hai ? ----- uttara- ThIka nahI hai kyoki jaba kArya hotA hai bAkI ke tIna kAraka hote hai aisA vastu svabhAva hai / usako na mAnane ke kAraNa vaha jhUThA hai / prazna 32 - ina cAra kArya ke kArako me kyA rahasya hai ? uttara- (1) koI akele usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kArya ke kAraka ko mAne kintu anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kAraka ko, trikAlI kAraka ko aura nimitta kAraka ko na mAne vaha jhUThA hai / (2) koI

Page #31
( 25 ) akele anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kAraka ko hI mAne kintu trikAlo kAraka, nimitta kAraka aura usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kAraka ko na mAne vaha jhUThA hai| (3) koI mAtra trikAlI kAraka ko hI mAne kintu usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kAraka ko, anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kAraka koaura nimitta kAraka ko na mAne vaha jhUThA hai| (4) koI akele kArya kA kAraka nimitta ko hI mAne kintu trikAlI kAraka, anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kAraka aura usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA rUpa kAraka ko na mAne vaha bhI jhUThA hai, kyoki jaba-java kArya hotA hai vahA~ cAro kAraka eka sAtha hote hai| prazna 33-chaha kAraka dravya haiM, guNa haiM, yA paryAya hai ? uttara-chaha kAraka guNa hai| prazna 34-chaha kAraka guNa haiM to sAmAnya haiM yA vizeSa haiM ? uttara-chaha kAraka pratyeka dravya me pAye jAne vAle sAmAnya aura anujIvI guNa hai| prazna 35-chaha kAraka guNa haiM yaha jinavANI me kahA~ AyA hai ? uttara-zrI samayasAra kI 47 zaktiyo me AyA hai| prazna 36-chaha kArako kA jJAna vidyA baDhAne ke lie, logo ko batAne ke lie, ki hama vidvAna haiM yA aura kisI kArya ke lie hai ? uttara-(1) jo jIva chaha kArako kA jJAna mAna-baDappana ke lie karatA hai vaha ananta sasAra kA kAraNa hai (2) vAstava me chaha kArako ke jJAna se para me karUM-karU~ kI aura bhoktA-bhogya kI buddhi kA abhAva ho jAtA hai aura samyagdarzana kI prApti hokara kramaza nirvANa kI ora gamana ho jAtA hai (3) pA~ca sasAra ke kAraNo kA abhAva / (4) paca parAvartana kA abhAva (5) cAra gati ke abhAvarUpa pacamagati kI prApti (6) pacama pAriNAmika bhAva kA mahatva A jAtA hai (7) paca parameSTiyo me usakI ginatI hone lagatI hai| prazna 37-paryAya (kArya) para se kisakA mApa nikAlanA cAhie? uttara-paryAya para se sacce kAraka kA mApa nikAlanA caahie|

Page #32
( 26 ) prazna 38 - paryAya para se sacce kAraka kA mApa kyo nikAlanA - cAhie ? uttara - kArya huA- isame to saba eka mata haiM / parantu karane vAlA kauna hai ? isame bhUla hai / kAraka kA sahI jJAna nA hone se sasAra kA pAtra banA huA hai / kAraka kA sahI jJAna ho jAye to sasAra kA abhAva ho jAve, isalie paryAya para se sacce kAraka kA mApa nikAlanA cAhie | kartAkAraka kA spaSTIkaraNa prazna 36 - kartA kise kahate hai ? uttara - jo svatantratA se ( svAdhInatA pUrvaka ) apane pariNAma ko kare vaha kartA hai / prazna 40 - pratyeka dravya kisakA kartA hai ? uttara- pratyeka dravya apane me svatantra vyApaka hone se apane hI pariNAma kA svatantratA se kartA hai | prazna 41 - pratyeka dravya apane hI pariNAma kA kartA hai dUsare kA nahIM, yaha jinavANI me kahA~-kahA~ AyA hai ? uttara- ( 1 ) anAdinidhana vastue~ bhinna-bhinna apanI-apanI maryAdA lie pariNAma hai, koI kisI kA pariNamAyA pariNamatA nAhI aura kisI ko pariNamAne kA bhAva ananta sasAra kA kAraNa mithyAtva hai / [ mokSamArga prakAzaka pRSTha 52] (2) saba padArtha apane - apane dravya me antarmagna rahane vAle apane ananta dharmoM ke cakra ko (samUha ko ) cumbana karate haiM sparza karate haiM tathApi ve ( saba dravya) paraspara eka dUsare ko sparza nahI karate / [ samayasAra gA0 3 kI TIkA se ] (3) jo kucha kriyA hai vaha saba hI dravya se bhinna nahI hai / isase viruddha mAnane vAlA mithyAdRSTipane ke kAraNa sarvajJa mata se bAhara hai / [ samayasAra gA0 85 kI TIkA se ]

Page #33
( 27 ) (4) sarva dravyo kI pratyeka paryAya me chaha kAraka eka sAtha vartate haiM / isalie AtmA aura pudagala zuddha dazA me yA azuddha dazA me svaya chaho kAraka spa pariNamana karate hai aura dUsare kArako kI (nimittakAraNo kI) apekSA nahIM rkhte| [pacAstikAya gA0 62 se] (5) nizcaya se para ke sAtha AtmA kA kArakapane kA sababa nahI hai ki jisase suddhAtma svabhAva kI prApti ke lie sAmagrI (vAhya sAdhana) khojane kI vyagratA ne jIva (vyartha hI) paratantra hote hai| [pravacanasAra gA0 16 kI TIkA se] (6) dekho, samayasAra gA0 103, 372, 406 / / (7) samayasAra kalaga 51, 52, 53, 54 tathA kalaza 200 / / prazna 42-pratyeka dravya apane hI pariNAma kA kartA-bhoktA haiM dUsare kA nahIM hai / parantu jo loga isa bAta ko nahIM mAnate aura kahate haiM ki hama zarIra-strI-putrAdi ke kartA haiM usakA kyA phala hogA? uttara-(1) jaise-sItA ko rAvaNa curAkara le gayA aura rAvaNa ne bahuta prayatna kiyA ki jaise-sItA rAma ko pyAra karatI hai vaisA mujhe pyAra kre| usakA phala use tIsare naraka jAnA par3A, usI prakAra jo sasAra ke padArthoM ko apane anumAra pariNamAnA cAhatA hai usakA phala use naraka me jAnA pddegaa| (2) eka bAra bambaI me hagAmA ho gyaa| logo ne pukArA "bambaI hamArA, bambaI hamArA" to sarakAra taga A gaI / tava vaDe janarala ko choTe janarala ne TelIphona kiyA, ki isakA eka mAtra upAya yaha hai subaha samAcAra patra me de do, jo apane ghara se bAhara nikalegA, use golI mAra dI jaavegii| aisA hI subaha samAcAra patra me A gayA / jaba koI apane ghara se bAhara nikalA use taranta golI mAra dI gaI, jo nahI nikalA vaha ThIka rahA, usI prakAra jo apane dravya-guNa-paryAya se bAhara nikalatA hai use cAro gati rUpa golI mAra dI jAtI hai| isalie jo apanI maryAdA se bAhara nikalatA hai vaha dukhI hotA hai| jo apanI maryAdA me rahatA hai vaha ramyagdarzanAdi

Page #34
( 28 ) ko prApti kara kramaza mokSarUpI lakSmI kA nAtha bana jAtA hai / prazna 43 - kartA kI paribhASA me se "svatantratA pUrvaka " zabda 'nikAla deM, to kyA doSa AvegA ? uttara - 'svatantratA pUrvaka' zabda nikAlane se dUsare ko bhI kartApane kA prasaMga upasthita hovegA yaha doSa AvegA / (1) jaise- roTI ATe se banI aura vAI se bhI banane kA prasaMga upasthita hovegA / (2) ghaDA miTTI se bane aura kumhAra se bhI bane, aisA prasaMga upasthita hovegA / ( 3 ) zabda bhASA vargaNA kare aura jIva bhI kare aisA prasaga upasthita hovegA, isalie 'svatantratApUrvaka' zabda nahI nikAlA jA sakatA / prazna 44 - kartA kitane kahalAte hai ? uttara - cAra kahalAte haiM, usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kartA, anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kartA, trikAlI kartA aura nimitta kartA / prazna 45 - ina cAro kartA me se kArya kA saccA kartA kauna hai ? uttara - vAstava me " usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA hI " kArya kA saccA kartA hai | prazna 46 - anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya, trikAlI kartA aura nimitta sacce kArya ke kartA kyo nahIM haiM ? uttara- ( 1 ) abhAva me se bhAva kI utpatti nahI hotI isalie anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kArya kA saccA kartA nahI hai / ( 2 ) trikAlI kartA to sadaiva ekasA rahatA hai yadi trikAlI kArya kA saccA - kartA ho to kArya trikAla rahanA cAhie / parantu kArya eka samaya kA hai / vicAro kArya eka samaya kA ho aura usakA kartA trikAlI sadaiva rahane vAlA bane aisA nahI hai / (3) kArya kA kartA nimitta to hone kA prazna hI nahI, kyoki usakA kArya se dravya-kSetra kAla-bhAva | pRthaka hai / -

Page #35
( 26 ) prazna 47-jahAM Agama me kArya kA eka kartA kI bAta ho, vahA~ pAtrajIva kyA jAnate haiM ? uttara-vaha cAro kA grahaNa kara letA hai| jo cAro kA grahaNa nahI karatA hai vaha jhUThA hai / yahA~ para grahaNa kA artha jJAna hai| prazna 48-kumhAra ne ghaDA banAyA-isameM kartA kAraka ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA? uttara-miTTI svatantratA se ghaDe ko prApta huI to kartA kAraka ko mAnA aura kumhAra ghaDe ko prApta huA to kartAkAraka ko nahI maanaa| prazna 46-miTTI svatantratA se ghar3e rUpa pariNamI, isame se 'svatantratA' zabda ko nikAla deM to kyA nuksAna hogA? uttara-miTTI se ghaDA bane aura kumhAra se bhI ghaDA banane kA prasaga upasthita hovegA / isalie svatantratA zabda ko nahI nikAlA jA sakatA hai| prazna 50-miTTI svatantratA se ghar3e rUpa pariNamI, aise kartA kAraka ko jAnane se kisa-kisa se dRSTi haTa gaI ? uttara-mumhAra, cAka, kIlI, DaDA, dharma, adharma, AkAza aura kAla dravyo se dRSTi haTa gii| prazna 51-miTTI svatantratA se ghar3e rUpa pariNamI to katakiAraka ko mAnA isako jAnane se kyA lAbha rahA? uttara-jaise-miTTI svatantratA se ghaDe rUpa pariNamI; usI prakAra vizva ke pratyeka dravya aura guNa me svatantratA se pariNamana ho cukA hai, ho rahA hai aura bhaviSya me aisA hI hotA rahegA-aisA usako jJAna ho jAtA hai, para me kartApane kI khoTI buddhi samApta hokara jJAtA buddhi pragaTa ho jAtI hai / vaha kevalI ke samAna jJAtA-dRSTA bana jAtA hai / mAtra pratyakSa-parokSa kA hI antara rahatA hai| prazna 52~-darzanamohanIya ke abhAva se kSAyika samyaktva huA, isame phartAkAraka ko kana mAnA aura kaba nahI mAnA?

Page #36
i ( 30 ) uttara - AtmA kA zraddhA guNa svatantratA se kSAyika samyaktva rUpa pariNamA to kartA kAraka ko mAnA aura darzana mohanIya ke abhAva se kSAyika samyaktva huA to kartA kAraka ko nahI mAnA / prazna 53 - zraddhAguNa svantratA se kSAyika samyaktva rUpa pariNamA / isameM se svatantratA zabda ko nikAla deM, to kyA nuksAna hogA ? uttara- zraddhA guNa se kSAyika samyaktva hove aura darzana mohanIya th abhAva me se bhI kSAyikasamyaktva hone kA prasaMga upasthita hovegA / isaliye 'svatantratA' zabda nahI nikAlA jA sakatA hai| prazna 54 - AtmA kA zraddhA guNa kSAyika samyaktva rUpa pariNamA / aise kartA kAraka ko jAnane se kisa-kisa se dRSTi haTa gaI ? uttara - darzanamohanIya ke abhAva se, sacce deva-guru-zAstra se, sAta tatvo kI bheda rUpa zraddhA se aura AtmA ke zraddhA guNa ko choDakara bAkI guNo se dRSTi haTa gaI / prazna 55 - AtmA kA zraddhA guNa svatantratA se kSAyika samyaktva rUpa pariNamA, to kartA kAraka ko mAnA, isako jAnane se kyA lAbha rahA ? uttara - jaise- zraddhA guNa me svatantratA se kSAyika samyaktva huA, usI prakAra vizva ke pratyeka dravya aura guNa me svatantratA se pariNamana ho cukA hai, ho rahA hai aura bhaviSya me aisA hI hotA rahegA to para me kartApane kI buddhi samApta hokara jJAtA vRddhi pragaTa honA yaha kartA kAraka ko jAnane kA lAbha hai / prazna 56 -- kSAyika samyaktva huA isame cAro prakAra ke kArako -ke nAma batAo ? uttara - ( 1 ) kSAyikasamyaktva huA usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA saccA kAraka, (2) kSAyopazamika samyaktva kA abhAva anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya abhAvarUpa kAraka, (3) zraddhA guNa trikAlIkAraka, (4) darzanamohanIya kA abhAva nimittakAraka |

Page #37
( 31 ) prazna 57-kevalajJAnAvaraNIya ke kSaya se kevalajJAna huA-isameM kartA kAraka lagAkara batAo? uttara-(prazna 52 se 56 taka ke anusAra uttara do)| prazna 58-gurU se jJAna huA--isame kartAkAraka ko lagAo? uttara-(prazna 52 se 56 taka ke anusAra uttara do)| prazna 56-bAI ne roTI banAI-isame kartAkAraka ko lagAo? uttara-(prazna 52 se 56 taka ke anusAra uttara do)| prazna 60-kevaladarzana hone se darzanAvaraNIya kA kSaya huAisameM kartAkAraka lagAkara batAo? uttara-(prazna 52 se 56 taka ke anusAra uttara do)| prazna 61-maiMne bistarA bichAyA-isame kartAkAraka lagAo? uttara-(prazna 52 se 56 taka ke anusAra uttara do)| prazna 62-mahAvIrabhagavAna kI divyadhvani hai-isame kartAkAraka ko lagAo? uttara-(prazna 52 se 56 taka ke anusAra uttara do)| prazna 63-baDhaI ne alamArI banAI-isame kartAkAraka ko lagAo? uttara-(prazna 52 se 56 taka ke anusAra uttara do)| prazna 64-bailo ne gADI ko calAyA-isame kartAkAraka lagAo? uttara-(prazna 52 se 56 taka ke anusAra uttara do) / prazna 65-icchA kI to mai AyA-isame kartAkAraka ko batAo? uttara-(prazna 52 se 56 taka ke anusAra uttara do)| prazna 66-mai jora se bolatA hUM-isame kartAkAraka lagAo ? uttara-(prazna 52 se 56 taka ke anusAra uttara do) / prazna 67-kunda kunda bhagavAna ne samayasAra banAyA- isame kartAkAraka batAo? uttara-(prazna 52 se 56 taka ke anusAra uttara do)|

Page #38
( 32 ) karmakAraka kA spaSTIkaraNa prazna 68-makAraka kise kahate haiM ? uttara-kartA jisa pariNAma ko prApta karatA hai vaha pariNAma usakA karma hai| kartA kA iNTa vaha karma hai| prazna 66-8rma ke paryAyavAcI zabda kyA-kyA hai ? uttara-kArya, avasthA, paryAya, pariNAma, pariNati Adi karma ke paryAvAcI zabda hai| prazna 70-kArya ke kartA kitane kahalAte haiM ? uttara-cAra kahalAte haiM, usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kartA; anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kartA, trikAlI kartA aura nimitta krtaa| prazna 71-kArya kA saccA kartA kauna hai aura kauna nahIM hai ? uttara--usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA hI pratyeka kArya kA saccA kartA hai / anantara pUrva kSaNavartIya paryAya, trikAlI aura nimitta, kArya ke sacce kartA nahIM hai| prazna 72-kArya ke anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya, trikAlI aura nimitta, sacce kartA kyo nahIM hai ? uttara-(1) paryAya me se paryAya nahI AtI isalie anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kArya kA saccA kartA nahI hai (2) kArya eka samaya kA ho usakA kartA anAdiananta rahane vAlA ho yaha bhI ThIka nahI (3) nimitta ko kartA kahane kA prazna hI nahIM uThatA kyoki dono kA svacatuSTya bhinna-bhinna hai| prazna 73-kArya kA kartA trikAlI ko aura kahIM anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya ko kyo kahA jAtA hai ? uttara-(1) para dravyo se bhinna karane ke lie kArya kA kartA trikAlI ko kahA jAtA hai| (2) pUrva kI paryAya kA jJAna karAne ke liye anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya ko kArya kA kartA kahA jAtA hai (3) isalie trikAlI kartA se aura bhUta-bhaviSya kI paryAyo se aura

Page #39
( 33 ) nimitta se dRSTi uThAkara mAtra usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA hI kArya kA saccA kartA hai, yaha patA cale, to kalyANa ho| prazna 74 - karma kAraka ko samajhane ke lie kyA-kyA yAda rakhanA cAhie' (1) vAstava meM pAnI kA hI hai, anyata rahatI nahIM, yaha utara-(1) vAstava me pariNAma hI nizcaya se karma hai, (2) pariNAma apane AzrayabhUta pariNAmI kA hI hai, anya kA nahIM (3) karma kartA vinA hotA nahIM (4) vastu kI ekarUpa sthiti rahatI nahI, yaha yaha cAra vola karmakAraka samajhane ke lie paryApta hai [isake lie isI zAstra kA novA adhikAra dekhiyegA] [samayasAra kalaza 211] prazna 75 karmakAraka ko samajhane se kyA lAbha hai ? uttara-jo-jo kArya hotA hai vaha saba apanI-apanI paryAya kI yogyatA se hI hotA hai| jaba kArya apanI-apanI paryAya kI yogyatA se hotA hai to mai usa kArya ko karUM yA karAU~, aisI buddhi kA abhAva hokara dRSTi apane trikAlI bhagavAna para AnA aurazAnti kA anubhava honA yahI karmakAraka ko jAnane kA lAbha hai| prazna 76-kArya se "usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA hI kAraNa hai" yaha zAstra me kahIM AyA hai ? uttara-vAstava me koI bhI kArya hone me yA vigaDane me usakI yogyatA hI sAdhaka hotI hai| [iSTopadeza gAthA 35 kI TIkA bambaI se prakAgita] prazna 77~-(1)dUdha gira gayA (2) baccA bhAgatA-bhAgatA gira gayA (3) mara gayA (4) zarIra me bImArI huI (5) roTI jala gaI (6) mAla corI ho gayA (7) calate-calate gira gayA (8) bhASA bolI (9) hAtha U~cA uThAyA (10) pustaka uThAI (11) akSara likhe (12) makAna banA, ika sava me karma kAraka ko kavanAnA aura kA nahIM mAnA?

Page #40
( 34 ) uttara- (1) dUdha gira gayAnvayo giga ? karma kAraka ko nahI mAnA aura dUdha apanI paryAya kI yogyatA meM girA, to karmakAraka ko mAnA / (2) baccA bhAgatA - bhAgatA gira gayA, kyo girA ? karmakAraka ko nahI mAnA aura baccA apanI paryAya ko yogyatA se girA, to karmakAraka ko mAnA / ( 3 ) mara gayA, kyo marA ? karmakAraka ko nahIM mAnA aura apanI paryAya kI yogyatA se maga, to karmakAraka ko mAnA / (4) zarIra me bImArI huI, kyoM huI ? karmakAraka ko nahI mAnA aura bImArI apanI kI yogyatA se huI to karmakAraka ko mAnA / (5) roTI jala gajala gaI ? karma kAraka ko nahIM mAnA aura apanI paryAya ko gogyatA se jala gaI, to karma kAraka ko mAnA / (6) mAla corI ho gayA, kyoM huA? to karmavAra ko nahI mAnA aura corI apanI paryAya kI yogyatA meM huI, to karmakAraka ko mAnA / (7) calate-calate gira gayA, kyoM girA ? to karmakAraka ko nahI mAnA aura apanI paryAya kI yogyatA se girA, to karmakAraka ko mAnA / (8) bhASA jIva se nikalI karmakAraka ko nahIM mAnA aura bhASA apanI paryAya kI yogyatA se bhApAvargaNA me se nikalI to karmakAraka ko mAnA ( 2 ) hAtha U~cA jIva ne uThAyA to karmakAraka ko nahI mAnA aura hAtha apanI paryAya kI yogyatA se U~cA huA to karmakAraka ko mAnA / (10) pustaka maiMne uThAI to karmakAraka ko nahI mAnA aura pustaka apanI paryAya kI yogyatA se uThI to karmakAraka ko mAnA / ( 11 ) akSara maine likhe to karmakAraka ko nahI mAnA aura akSara apanI paryAya kI yogyatA se likhe gaye to karmakAraka ko mAnA / (12) makAna maiMne banAyA to karmakAraka ko nahI mAnA aura apanI paryAya kI yogyatA se banA to karmakAraka ko mAnA / prazna 78 - kArya apanI-apanI usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA se hI hotA hai to jIva kyo pAgala hotA hai uttara - karma kAraka kA rahasya patA na hone se pAgala hotA hai / ?

Page #41
( 35 ) ? prazna 76 -- karmakAraka kA jJAna kyo karAyA jAtA hai uttara - ( 1 ) zAnti prApta karAne ke lie aura zAnti prApta karane ke liye / (2) vastusvarUpa samajhAne ke liye aura samajhane ke liye / (3) anAdikAla kI khoTI mAnyatA naSTa karane ke liye aura karAne ke liye karmakAraka kA jJAna karAyA jAtA hai / prazna 80- - karma kAraka ko kisa-kisa mAnyatA vAle ne nahIM mAnA aura usakA phala kyA huA ? uttara- jaise - roTI banI, usame ( roTI banane me ) (1) vAI, cakalA, velana karttA hai (2) ATA kartA hai / (3) loI usakA karttA hai Adi mAnyatA vAlo ne karmakAraka ko nahI mAnA aura usakA phala mithyAdarzanAdi kI puSTi hokara nigoda kI prApti hotI hai / ? prazna 81 - karma kAraka kisane mAnA aura usakA phala kyA huA uttara - kArya "usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA se hI " hotA hai, hotA rahegA ora hotA rahA hai| isase kramabaddha paryAya kI siddhi ho gaI aura samyagdarzanAdi kI prApti hokara kramaza nirvANa kI ora gamana honA isakA phala hai | 2 prazna 82 - karma kitane prakAra kA hotA hai| uttara- (1) dravyakarma, (2) nokarsa, (3) bhAkakarma, (4) karma arthAt kArya aura ( 5 ) karma nAma kA kAraka / prazna 83- ina pA~ca prakAra ke karmoM me se siddha bhagavAna me kaunakaunasA karma hai ? uttara - cauthe aura pA~cave nambara kA karma hai | prazna 84 - karma arthAt kArya hotA hai usameM kitane kAraNa kahalAte haiM aura saccA kAraNa kauna hai ? uttara - cAra kahalAte hai - ( 1 ) nimitta kAraNa, (2) trikAlI kAraNa, (3) anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa, (4) usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa / ina cAro

Page #42
( 36 ) kAraNo me se karma kA saccA kAraNa usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA hI hai | ? prazna 85 - Asava tatva kA karttA kauna hai uttara - usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hai / prazna 86 - karma ke kAraNa Asrava mAne to kyA doSa AvegA ? uttara- ajIva tatva aura Asrava tatva ko eka mAnA karmakAraka ko nahI mAnA / prazna 87 - jIva ke kAraNa Alava mAne to kyA doSa AvegA ? uttara - jIva aura Asrava tatva ko eka mAnA karmakAraka ko nahI mAnA / prazna 8 - olava tatva sambandhI bhUla kaise miTe ? uttara - Asrava kA karttA usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI hai dravyakarma aura jIva nahI / dekho, yaha karmakAraka ko mAnane se Asrava tatva samvandhI bhUla dUra ho gaI / prazna 8 - baMdha tatva kA karttA kona hai uttara - usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hai| prazna 60 - baMdha tatva kA karttA dravyakarma ko mAne to kyA doSa AvegA ? uttara- ajIva aura vadha tatva ko eka mAnA- karma kAraka ko nahI mAnA / prazna 61 - jIva ke kAraNa baMdha ko mAne to kyA doSa AvegA ? uttara - jIva aura vadha tatva ko eka mAnA- karma kAraka ko nahI mAnA / ' prazna 62 - baMdha tatva sambandhI bhUla kaise miTe ? uttara - bhAva vadha "usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se hI " hai karma aura jIva se nahI hai / dekho karma kAraka ko - mAnane se vadha tatva sambandhI bhUla dUra ho gaI /

Page #43
( 37 ) ? prazna 63 - saMvara tatva kA karttA kauna hai uttara - usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hai / prazna 64 - saMvara tatva kA karttA koI dravyakarma ke rukane ko mAne to kyA doSa AvegA ? uttara - usane savara tatva aura ajIva tatva ko eka mAnA- karmakAraka ko nahI mAnA / prazna 65 -- zubha bhAva se saMvara mAne to kyA doSa AvegA ? uttara - usane Asrava, badha aura savara ko eka mAnA- karmakAraka ko nahI mAnA / prazna 66 - zubhabhAva karane se savara kI prApti mAne to kyA doSa AvegA ? uttara - usane Asrava, vandha aura savara ko eka mAnA- karmakAraka ko nahI mAnA / prazna 67 -- deva- guru- zAstra se samyakdarzana mAne to kyA doSa AvegA ? uttara - usane jIva, ajIvatatva aura savara ko eka mAnA -- karma kAraka ko nahI mAnA / prazna 68 - aNuvratAdi bAharI kriyA se zrAvakapanA mAne to kyA doSa AvegA ? uttara - usane ajIva aura savara ko eka mAnA -- karma kAraka ko nahI mAnA / prazna 66- zubha bhAvarUpa aNuvratAdi se saMvara mAne to kyA doSa AvegA ? uttara - usane Asrava, bandha tatva aura savara ko eka mAnA- karma kAraka ko nahI mAnA / prazna 100 - 28 mUlaguNa bAharI kriyA se sunipanA mAne to kyA doSa AvegA ? t

Page #44
( 38 ) uttara -- usane ajIva aura savara ko eka mAnA - karmakAraka ko nahI mAnA / prazna 101 - 28 sUlaguNa pAlane se munipanA mAne to kyA doSa AvegA ? uttara - usane Asrava, bandha aura savara ko eka mAnA - karmakAraka ko nahI mAnA / prazna 102 --savara tatva samvandhI bhUla kaise miTe ? uttara - karma kAraka kA rahasya jAnane se / prazna 103 - savara tatva sambandhI bhUla karmakAraka ko mAnane se kaise dUra ho ? uttara-savara tatva " usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se" hai / vaha jIva se, ajIva se, Asrava, badha se nahI hai / dekho, karmakAraka ko mAnane se savara tatva samvandhI bhUla dUra ho gaI / prazna 104 - bhAva nirjarA tatva kA karttA kauna hai ? uttara - usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa bhAva nirjarA tatva kA saccA kartA hai / prazna 105 - dravyakarma se bhAvanirjarA mAne to kyA doSa AtA hai ? - uttara - ajIva aura nirjarA tatva ko eka mAnA -- karmakAraka ko nahI mAnA / ? prazna 106 - jIva se nirjarA mAne to kyA doSa AtA hai uttara - jIvatatva aura nirjarAtatva ko eka mAnA - karmakAraka ko nahI mAnA / ? prazna - 107 - puNya se nirjarA mAne to kyA doSa AvegA uttara--Asrava tatva aura nirjarA tatva ko eka mAnA - karmakAraka ko nahI mAnA /

Page #45
- ( 36 ) prazna 108-bhAvabaMdha se bhAvanirjarA mAne to kyA doSa AvegA? uttara-vadha aura nirjarA tatva ko eka mAnA-karma kAraka ko nahI maanaa| prazna 106-bhAva savara se bhAva nirjarA mAne to kyA doSa AvegA? uttara-savara, nirjarA tatva ko eka mAnA-karma kAraka ko nahIM maanaa| prazna 110-roTI na khAne se nirjarA na mAne to kyA doSa AvegA? uttara-ajIva tatva aura nirjarA tatva ko eka mAnA-karmakAraka ko nahI maanaa| prazna 111-bAharI tapa aura zubha bhAvarUpa 12 prakAra ke vyavahAra tapa se nirjarA mAne to kyA doSa AvegA ? uttara-ajIva, Asrava, badha aura nirjarA ko eka mAnA-karmakAraka ko nahIM maanaa| prazna 112-bhAva nirjarA tatva sambandho bhUla kase miTe ? uttara-karma kAraka ko mAnane se bhAva nirjarA tatva sambandhI bhUla miTe / prazna 113-bhAva nirjarA tatva sambandhI bhUla karma kAraka ko mAnane se kaise dUra huI ? uttara-bhAva nirjarA tatva "usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se" hai vaha jIva se, ajIva se, Asrava se, bandha se, nahI hai| dekho karma kAraka ko mAnane se nirjarA tatva sambandhI bhUla miTa gii| prazna 114-bhAva mokSa kA kartA kauna hai ? uttara-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hai|

Page #46
/ ( 40 ) prazna 115-bhAva mokSa kA kartA dravyakarma ke abhAva ko mAne to kyA doSa AvegA? uttara-bhAva mokSa aura ajIva ko eka mAnA-karmakAraka ko nahI maanaa| prazna 116--bhAva mokSa kA kartA vanavapamanArAca sahanana ko mAne, to kyA doSa AvegA? uttara-usane ajIva ora mokSa ko eka mAnA-karmakAraka ko nahI maanaa| prazna 117-jIva se mokSa mAne to kyA doSa AvegA? uttara-usane jIvatatva aura mokSa tatva ko eka mAnA-karma kAraka ko nahIM maanaa| prazna 118-Asrava se mokSa mAne to kyA doSa AvegA ? uttara-usane Asrava ora mokSa ko eka mAnA-karma kAraka ko nahI maanaa| prazna 116-badha se mokSa mAne to kyA doSa AvegA? uttara-usane badha aura mokSa ko eka mAnA-karma kAraka ko nahIM maanaa| prazna 120--lavara se mokSa mAne to kyA dASa AvegA? uttara-savara aura mokSa ko eka mAnA-karma kAraka ko nahI maanaa| prazna 121-nirjarA se mokSa mAne to kyA doSa AnegA ? uttara-nirjarA aura mokSa ko eka mAnA-karmakAraka ko nahI maanaa| prazna 122-143 guNasthAna se mokSa mAne, to kyA doSa AvegA? uttara-Asrava, savara, nirjarA aura mokSa ko eka mAnA-karmakAraka ko nahIM maanaa| prazna 123-mokSa tatva samvandhI bhUla kaise dUra ho ?

Page #47
( 41 ) uttara-karma kAraka ko mAne to mokSa tatva savadhI bhUla miTe / prazna 124-karma kAraka ko mAnane se mokSa tatva sabaMdhI bhUla kaise miTe ? uttara-bhAva mokSa kA kartA "usa mamaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa" hai| jIva, ajIva, Asrava, vadha, savara, nirjarA usakA kartA nahIM hai / dekho, karma kAraka ko mAnane se bhAva mokSa tatva samvandhI bhUla dUra ho gii| prazna 125-vaha hamArI tArIpha karate the, Aja nindA kyoM ? isa vAkya me karma kAraka ko kaba nahIM sAnA ? aura kaba mAnA? uttara-vaha hamArI tArIpha karate the, Aja nindA kyo ? aisI mAnyatA vAle ne karmakAraka ko nahIM mAnA aura nindA usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa le huI to karmakAraka ko maanaa| prazna 126-vaha pahile lakhapati thA, Aja bhikArI kaise ho gayA? karmakAraka ko kaba nahIM mAnA aura kaba mAnA ? uttara-prazna 125 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 127-vaha Aja subaha ThIka thA, aba kaise mara gayA ? karma kAraka ko kaba nahIM mAnA aura kaba mAnA? uttara-125 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 128-usakA svAsthya abhI ThIka thA aba ekadama kaise vigaDa gayA / karma lAraka ko kaba nahIM mAnA aura kava mAnA ? uttara--prazna 125 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 126-hama dinarAta tattva kA abhyAsa karate haiM samyagdarzana kyo nahIM hotA hai ? karma kAraka ko kaba nahIM mAnA aura kaba mAnA ? uttara-prazna 125 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 130-aMjanacora mahApApI umI bhava se mokSa kaise calA gayA? pharma kAraka ko kaba nahIM mAnA aura kaba mAnA ?

Page #48
( 42 ) uttara - prazna 125 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 131 - gRhIta mithyAdRSTi gautama ko eka hI sAtha samyagdarzana, muni, gaNadharapanA cAra jJAna kA ughAr3a kaise ho gayA ? karma kAraka ko kaba nahIM mAnA aura katra mAnA ? uttara - prazna 125 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 132 - nityanigoda se nikalakara ATha varSa ko avasthA meM dharma kI prApti kaise ho gayI ? karma kAraka ko kaba nahIM mAnA aura kava mAnA ? uttara - prazna 125 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 133 - pratyeka samaya pratyeka dravya me kArya hotA hI rahatA hai yaha kabhI rukatA hI nahIM yaha kyA siddha karatA hai ? uttara - kArya (karma) ko siddha karatA hai aura kramavaddha paryAya ko siddha karatA hai / prazna 134 - karma kAraka ko kaba mAnA ? uttara - dRSTi apane trikAlI bhagavAna para AI to karmakAraka ko mAnA / karaNa kAraka kA spaSTIkaraNa prazna 135 -- karaNa kAraka kise kahate haiM ? uttara - usa pariNAma ke ( kArya kA ) sAdhakatama arthAta utkRSTa sAdhana ko karaNa kahate haiM / ? prazna 136 - karaNa kAraka me " sAdhakatama " dayA batAtA hai| uttara--"sAdhakatama" yaha batAtA hai ki utkRSTa sAdhana kartA se bAhara nahI hai / prazna 137 - kArya kA utkRSTa sAdhana kyA batAtA hai ? uttara - kArya kA madhyama sAdhana, jaghanya sAdhana nahI hai, mAtra kArya kA utkRSTa sAdhana hI kAraNa hai anya nahI hai / prazna 138 - kArya ke sAdhana kitane kahe jAte haiM ?

Page #49
( 43 ) uttara-cAra kahe jAte hai-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA sAdhana, anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya sAdhana, trikAlI sAdhana aura nimitta sAdhana / prazna 136-kArya kA saccA sAdhana kauna hai aura kauna nahIM hai ? uttara-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA hI kArya kA utkRSTa sAdhana hai / anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya sAdhana, trikAlI sAdhana aura nimitta sAdhana kArya ke sacce sAdhana nahI haiM / prazna 140-anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya, trikAlI aura nimitta kArya ke sacce sAdhana kyo nahIM hai ? uttara--abhAva me se bhAva kI utpatti nahIM hotI isalie anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kArya kA sAdhana nahIM hai / kArya eka samaya kA ho usakA sAdhana dhruva ho yaha bhI nahI banatA hai| nimitta ko sAdhana kahane kA prazna hI nahI hai kyoki dono kA svacatuSTaya pRthakapRthaka hai| - prazna 141- kevalajJAna kA utkRSTa sAdhana kauna hai aura kauna nahIM hai ? uttara-kevalajJAna kA utkRSTa sAdhana usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA hI hai / anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya, trikAlI jJAnaguNa aura jJAnAvaraNIya kA abhAva utkRSTa sAdhana nahI hai| prazna 142-anantara pUrva kSagavartI paryAya bhAvabhratajJAna, AtmA kA jJAnaguNa aura jJAnAvaraNIya kA abhAva kaise sAdhana kahe jAte haiM ? uttara-anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya bhAvazrutajJAna abhAvarUpa sAdhana, AtmA kA jJAnaguNa trikAlI sAdhana aura jJAnAvaraNIya kA abhAva nimitta sAdhana kahe jAte haiN| prazna 143-kyA kevalajJAna kA utkRSTa sAdhana vajravRSabhanArAca sahanana hai ? isame karaNa kAraka ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM maanaa| uttara-kevalajJAna kA utkRSTa sAdhana usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA

Page #50
( 44 ) kevalajJAna hai taba to karaNa kAraka mAnA aura kevalajJAna kA sAdhana vajravRpabhanArAca sahnana kahe to karaNa kAraka ko nahIM mAnA prazna 144 - kevalajJAna kA utkRSTa sAdhana usa samaya paryAya koM yogyatA kevala jJAna hI hai, anya nahIM haiM, to anya sAdhano me kyA-kyA AyA? uttara- vajravRpabhanArAca sahanana, cauthA kAla, kevalajJAnAvaraNIya kA kSaya, AtmA, AtmA ke ananta guNa, anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya bhAva zrutajJAna, Adi anya sAdhanoM meM Ate hai / prazna 145 - kevalajJAna kA utkRSTa sAdhana usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kevalajJAna hI hai taba karaNa kAraka ko mAnA- isako jAnane se dayA lAbha hai ? uttara -- jaise kevalajJAna kA utkRSTa sAdhana usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA hI hai, usI prakAra vizva me ananta dravya hai / pratyeka dravya me ananta ananta guNa hai / pratyeka guNa me jo-jo kArya ho cukA hai, ho rahA hai, bhaviSya meM hogA una saba kA sAdhana mAtra usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI hai| aisA mAnate hI cAro gatiyo ke abhAvarUpa dharma kI prApti honA - yaha karaNa kAraka ko jAnane kA lAbha hai / prazna 146 - kNa roTI kA utkRSTa sAdhana cakalA belana haiM ? isase karaNa kAraka ko kara mAnA aura kaba nahI mAnA / uttara - roTI kA utkRSTa sAdhana usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa roTI hai to karaNa kAraka ko mAnA aura roTI kA utkRSTa sAdhana cakalA - velana Adi hai to karaNa kAraka ko nahI mAnA / prazna 147 - roTI kA utkRSTa sAdhana usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA hai taba dUsare sAdhano ko kisa kisa nAma ne uttara - anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya loI ko ? kahA jAtA hai abhAva rUpa sAdhana

Page #51
( 45 ) kahA jAtA hai / ATe ko trikAlI sAdhana kahA jAtA hai| vAI ke rAga ko, cakalA, velana, tavA, Aga, dharma, adharma - AkAza aura kAla ko nimitta sAdhana kahA jAtA hai / prazna 148 - roTI kA utkRSTa sAdhana usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA hI hai aisA mAnane se kisa-kisa sAghana se dRSTi haTa gaI ? uttara - vArDa kA rAga - cakalA, belana, tavA, dharma, adharma, AkAza kAla Adi nimitta se, trikAlI ATe se anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya loI se dRSTi haTa jAtI hai / , prazna 146 -- roTI kA utkRSTa sAdhana usa samaya paryAya ko yogyatA hI hai taba karaNa kAraka ko mAnA to isako jAnane se pAtra jIvoM ko kyA lAbha honA cAhie ? uttara -- jaise- roTI kA utkRSTa sAdhana usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA roTI hI hai, usI prakAra vizva me jitane bhI kArya haiM una saba kAryo kA utkRSTa sAdhana usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA hI hai-aisA jAnatemAnate hI cAro gatiyo ke abhAvarUpa dharma kI prApti honA yaha isako jAnane kA lAbha hai / prazna 150 -- kyA samyagdarzana kA utkRSTa sAdhana deva-guru haiMisame karaNa kAraka ko lagAo ? uttara - prazna 146 se 146 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 151 - kyA mokSa kA sAdhana zarIra hai isame karaNakAraka lagAo ? uttara - prazna 146 se 146 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 152 -- kyA caritra kA sAdhana paca mahAvrata hai ? isameM karaNa kAraka ko lagAo / uttara - prazna 146 se 146 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 153 -- kyA ghar3e kA utkRSTa sAdhana kumhAra hai ? karaNa kAraka ko lagAo / isameM

Page #52
( 46 ) uttara-prazna 146 se 146 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 154-kyA sone ke hAra kA utkRSTa sAdhana sunAra hai ? isameM karaNa kAraka ko lgaao| uttara-prazna 146 se 146 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 155-kyA mandira banane kA utkRSTa sAdhana kArIgara hai ? isame karaNa kAraka lagAkara btaao| uttara-prazna 146 se 146 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 156-kyA sugandha kA utkRSTa sAdhana jJAna hai ? isame karaNa kAraka ko lgaao| uttara-prazna 146 se 146 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 157-kyA darzanamohanIya ke kSaya kA utkRSTa sAdhana kSAyika samyaktva hai ? isame karaNa kAraka lgaao| uttara-prazna 146 se 146 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 158-jJAnAvaraNIya karma ke kSaya kA utkRSTa sAdhana kevalajJAna hai ? isame karaNakAraka lgaao| uttara--prazna 146 se 146 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 156-cyA jJAna baDhAne kA utkRSTa sAdhana zAstra hai ? isame karaNakAraka lgaao| uttara-prazna 146 se 146 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 160-kyA rupayA milA usakA utkRSTa sAdhana jIva haiM ? inameM karaNa kAraka ko lgaao| uttara-prazna 146 se 146 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 161-karaNa kitane arthoM meM prayukta hotA hai ? uttara-tIna arthoM meM prayukta hotA hai-(1) karaNa = indriya, (2) karaNa= pariNAma, (3) karaNa = sAdhana-karaNa kAraka / sampradAna kAraka kA spaSTIkaraNa prazna 162-sampradAna kAraka kise kahate haiM ?

Page #53
( 47 ) uttara-karma (pariNAma, kArya) jise diyA athavA jisake liye karma kiyA jAya use sampradAna kahate haiN| prazna 163-- "sampradAna" zabda kA kyA artha hai ? uttara-sam = samyak prakAra se / pra=prakRSTa rUpa se vizeSa rUpa se / dAna = zuddhatA kA dAna diyA jaave| arthAt samyaka prakAra se vizepa karake jo dAna apane ko diyA jAve yaha sampradAna kA artha hai| prazna 164-sampradAna kA artha spaSTa samajhAiye? uttara-(1) jaise-lobha kA tyAga jo zuddhi pragaTI vaha sampradAna hai| (2) mithyAtva kA abhAva samyagdarzana pragaTA, vaha sampradAna hai| (3) pA~caveM guNasthAna me jo zuddhi pragaTo vaha sampradAna hai| (4) chaThe guNasthAna me jo zuddhi pragaTI vaha sampradAna hai| prazna 165-sampradAna kAraka ko kaba mAnA ? uttara-apanA dAna apane ko deve tava sampradAna kAraka ko mAnA jisakA kArya hai, vaha usI ko diyA jAve athavA usI ke lie kiyA jAya to sampradAna kAraka ko mAnA / prazna 166-kyA ghaDA pAnI pIne vAloM ke lie banA hai ? isa vAkya meM sampradAna kAraka ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA ? uttara-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA ke lie ghaDA banA to sampradAna kAraka ko mAnA aura pAnI pIne vAlo ke lie banA to sampradAna kAraka ko nahI maanaa| prazna 167-sampradAna kAraka ko jAnane se kyA lAbha rahA? uttara-vizva me jitane bhI kArya hote hai vaha saba usakI usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA ke lie hI hote haiM dUsaro ke lie nahI hote hai aisA mAne to dharma ko prApti ho| prazna 168-kyA roTI khAne vAlo ke lie banI hai ? isa vAkya me sampradAna kAraka ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA ? uttara-prazna 166 va 167 ke anusAra uttara do

Page #54
( 48 ) prazna 166-kyA sone kA hAra pahanane ke lie banA hai ? isameM sampradAna kAraka ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahI mAnA ? uttara--prazna 166 va 167 ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 170~-kyA samyagdarzana padArthoM ke zaTAna ke lie hai ? isame sampradAnakAraka ko kava mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA? uttara--prazna 166 va 167 ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 171-kyA kevalajJAna pAdartho ke jAnane ke lie hai ? isa vAkya me sampradAna kAraka ko kana mAnA aura kaba nahI mAnA? uttara-prazna 166 va 167 ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 172-kyA kamarA logo ke rahane ke lie hai ? isa vAkya me sampradAnakAraka ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahI mAnA? uttara-prazna 166 va 167 ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 173-kyA alamArI kitAbeM rakhane ke lie hai ? isa vAkya me sampradAnakAraka ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahI mAnA ? uttara--prazna 166 va 167 ke anusAra uttara do| apAdAnakAraka kA spaSTIkaraNa prazna 174~-apAdAna kAraka kise kahate haiM ? uttara-jisame se karma (kriyA) kiyA jAya usa dhruva vastu ko apAdAna kAraka kahate haiN| prazna 175-apAdAna kAraka kyA batAtA hai ? uttara-- jo utpAda huA vaha anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna ke abhAva ko aura dhruva ko batAtA hai / prazna 176--apAdAna kAraka meM kitane upAdAna kAraNa Ate haiM ? uttara-tIno upAdAna kAraNa A jAte hai| prazna 177-'kevalajJAna' huA-isame tIno upAdAna kAraka kisa prakAra Aye ?

Page #55
( 46 ) uttara-kevalajJAna kA utpAda usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatArUpa kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa, bhAvazrutajJAna kA vyaya anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa, AtmA kA jJAna guNa trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa, isa prakAra tIno upAdAna kAraNa A jAte haiM / prazna 178--(1) kSAyika samyaktva, (2) kSayopazama samyaktva, (3) roTI banI (4) kevaladarzana (5) bistarA bichA (6) alamArI banI, iname tIno upAdAna kAraNa kisa prakAra Ate haiM ? ___uttara-(1) kSAyika samyaktva kA utpAda usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa, (2) kSayopazama samyaktva kA vyaya anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa, (3) AtmA kA zraddhAguNa trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa, isa prakAra tIno upAdAna kAraNa A jAte haiN| isI prakAra bAkI ke 5 vAkyo me lgaao| prazna 179-kevalajJAnAvaraNIya ke abhAva meM se kevalajJAna huA kyA apAdAna kAraka ko mAnA ? uttara-nahI mAnA, kyoki kevalajJAna anantarapUrva kSaNavartI - paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa bhAva zrutajJAna kA abhAva karake AtmA ke jJAna guNa me se AyA, kevalajJAnAvaraNIya karma ke abhAva meM se nahI AyA-aisA samajhe to apAdAna kAraka ko maanaa| prazna 180--koI catura aisA kahe kevalajJAnAvaraNIya ke abhAva me se hI kevalajJAna AyA--to kyA doSa AvegA? uttara-apAdAna kAraka ko ur3A diyaa| anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa zrutajJAna ke abhAva ko aura AtmA ke jJAna guNa ko bhI uDA diyaa| prazna 181-kevalajJAna meM se kevalajJAnAvaraNIya karma kA abhAva ' AyA, kyA apAdAna kAraka ko mAnA? uttara-nahI mAnA, kyoki jJAnAvaraNIya kA abhAva anantarapUrva

Page #56
( 50 ) kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa jAnAvaraNIya ke kSayopazama kA abhAva karake kAmINa vargaNA meM se AyA, kevalajJAna me se nahIM AyA-aisA samajhe to apAdAna kAraka ko maanaa| prazna 152-koI catura aisA kahe kevalajJAna me se hI kevalajJAnAvaraNIya karma kA abhAva AyA-to kyA doSa AvegA / uttara-~-apAdAna kAraka ko ur3A diyaa| anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa jJAnAvaraNIya kSayopazama ke abhAva ko aura kArmANa vargaNA ko bhI ur3A diyaa| prazna 183-tIno upAdAna kAraNo meM kitanA samaya lagatA hai| uttara-tIno kA eka hI samaya hai| prazna 184-vAI ne roTI banAI-isa vAkya meM apAdAna kAraka ko kava mAnA aura kava nahIM mAnA? uttara-roTI anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya loI kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA abhAva karake trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa ATe me se vanI apAdAna kAraka ko mAnA aura vAI se roTI banI to apAdAna kAraka ko nahIM maanaa| prazna 185-kumhAra ne ghar3A banAyA-isa vAkya me apAdAna kAraka ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA ? uttara---prazna 184 ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 186-maine vistarA bichAyA apAdAna kAraka ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA ? uttara-prazna 184 ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 187-sunAra ne jevara banAyA-apAdAna kAraka ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA? uttara-prazna 184 ke anusAra uttara do| prazna-185-maiMne baksA uThAyA-apAdAna kAraka ko kaba mAnA ~ aura kaba nahIM mAnA?

Page #57
( 51 ) uttara - prazna 184 ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 186 - guru se jJAna huA -- apAdAna kAraka ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA ? uttara -- prazna 184 ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 160 - deva - guru se samyaktva huA -- apAdAna kAraka ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA ? uttara - prazna 184 ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 161 - jJAnAvaraNIya dravyakarma ke kSaya me se kevalajJAna huA -- apAdAna kAraka ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA uttara - prazna 184 ke anusAra uttara do / ? prazna 162 - bAI ne roTI banAI, kyA apAdAna kAraka ko ? mAnA uttara- nahI mAnA, kyoki roTI anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa loI kA abhAva karake dhruva ATe me se AI bAI me se nahI, taba apAdAna kAraka ko mAnA / prazna 163 - koI catura kahe, bAI meM se hI roTI AI, aisA mAne to kyA doSa AtA hai ? uttara--apAdAna kAraka ko uDA diyA / anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa loI ke abhAva ko aura provya ATe ko bhI ur3A diyA / prazna 164 -- anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA to abhAva ho jAtA hai, usameM se utpAda kaise ho sakatA hai uttara -- vAstava me anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa ke abhAva me se utpAda nahI hotA hai vaha to usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA me se hotA hai, yaha to abhAvarUpa upAdAna kAraNa kI apekSA jJAna karAyA hai /

Page #58
( 52 ) prazna 165 - trikAlI dhruva to anAdiananta hai aura kArya eka samaya kA hai usameM se kArya kaise ? huA uttara - nimitta, para dravyoM se alaga karane kI apekSA trikAlI upAdAna ko kArya kA kartA kahA hai / vAstava me utpAda usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA se hI hotA hai / prazna 166 - kevalajJAna usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA se huA, aisA mAnane se kisa-kisa se dRSTi haTa gaI ? uttara- vajravRpabhanArAcasahanana se (2) cothe kAla se ( 3 ) jJAnAvaraNIya karma ke abhAva se ( 4 ) AtmA se (5) jJAna guNa se (6) zruta jJAna se dRSTi haTa jAtI hai / prazna 167 - kSAyika samyaktva usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA se hotA hai, aisA mAnane se kisa-kisa se dRSTi haTa gaI ? uttara --- (1) deva - guru se (2) darzana mohanIya ke upazamAdi se (3) AtmA se (4) zraddhA guNa se (5) kSayopazama samyaktva se dRSTi haTa gaI / prazna 168 - kyA usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA se hI kArya hotA hai ? uttara - hA~, usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA se hI kArya hotA hai, aisA nirNaya hote hI dRSTi apane trikAlI svabhAva para Ave, nirNaya saccA hai, anyathA jhUThA hai / * adhikaraNa kAraka kA spaSTIkaraNa prazna 166 -- adhikaraNa kAraka kise kahate haiM ? uttara - jisame athavA jisake AdhAra se karma (kArya) kiyA jAve use adhikaraNa kAraka kahate hai / prazna 200 - anAdi se ajJAnI ne kArya ke lie kisakA AdhAra mAnA hai aura usakA phala kyA rahA

Page #59
( 53 ) uttara-anAdi se ajJAnI jIva ne kArya ke lie para kA AdhAra mAnA hai| usakA phala cAro gatiyo me ghUmakara nigoda rhaa| prazna 201-dharma ke lie ajJAnI ne kisa-kisa kA AdhAra mAnA hai? uttara-(1) apanI AtmA ko choDakara tIrthaMkaro kA, muniyo kA, atyanta bhinna para padArthoM kA, AdhAra mAnA, (2) zarIra-indriyA~ ThIka rahe to dharma ho usakA AdhAra mAnA hai, (3) karma ke kSaya Adi hoM to dharma ho usakA AdhAra mAnA hai, (4) zubha bhAva ho to dharma ho usakA AdhAra mAnA hai, (5) bhedanaya ke pakSa kA AdhAra mAnA hai, (6) abhedanaya ke pakSa kA AdhAra mAnA hai, (7) bhedAbheda naya ke pakSa kA AdhAra mAnA hai aura usakA phala ananta sasAra hai| prazna 202-kyA eka vastu ko dUsarI vastu kA AdhAra nahIM hai ? uttara-bilkula nahI, kyoki pratyeka vastu apanA-apanA kArya apane-apane AdhAra se karatI hai, para kI apekSA nahI rakhatI hai| prazna 203-kyA zarIra ko roTI kA AdhAra hai ? uttara-bilkula nahIM, kyoki zarIra kA AdhAra AhAravargaNA hai, roTI aura jIva nhii| prazna 204-~-zarIra ko roTI kA AdhAra hai, isame adhikaraNakAraka ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA? uttara-zarIra ko AhAravargaNA kA AdhAra hai roTI kA nahI aba adhikaraNakAraka ko mAnA / aura roTI hI zarIra kA AdhAra hai aisA mAneM to usane adhikaraNakAraka ko nahI maanaa| prazna 205-~-kyA mokSa kA AdhAra karma kA abhAva hai / / uttara-bilkula nahI, kyoki mokSa kA AdhAra AtmA hai, karma kA abhAva nahI hai tava adhikaraNa kAraka ko maanaa| prazna 206-mokSa kA AdhAra karma kA abhAva hI hai aisA kaheM to kyA doSa AtA hai?

Page #60
uttara-usane adhikaraNakAraka nahI maanaa| prazna 207-mokSa kA AdhAra karma kA abhAva kaba mAnA jA sakatA hai ? uttara-javaki dravyakarma jIva ho jAve to mokSa kA AdhAra dravya karma kA abhAva mAnA jA sakatA hai| lekina aisA ho hI nahI sktaa| prazna 208--mokSa kA AdhAra kauna rahA ? uttara-mokSa kA AdhAra trikAlI AtmA hai aura vAstava me mokSa kA AdhAra usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA hI hai| prazna 206-adhikaraNa kAraka ko kaba mAnA kahA jA sakatA hai? uttara-pratyeka dravya-guNa-paryAya kA AdhAra kathancit nirapekSa hai aisA mAne taba adhikaraNa kAraka ko mAnA kahA jA sakatA hai| prazna 210-kyA guru ko ziSya kA AdhAra hai? uttara-vilkula nahI, kyoki guru ko apanA hI AdhAra hai, ziSya kA nahI / taba adhikaraNa kAraka ko maanaa| prazna 211-kyA guru ko ziSya kA AdhAra hai ? isameM adhikaraNa kAraka ko kaba nahI mAnA? uttara-guru ko ziSya kA AdhAra hai aisA mAne to adhikaraNa kAraka ko nahIM maanaa| prazna 212-guru ko ziSya kA AdhAra kaba kahA jA sakatA hai ? uttara-guru ko apanI AtmA kA AdhAra hai isake badale ziSya kI AtmA guru kI AtmA bana jAve to guru ko ziSya kA AdhAra kahA jA sakatA hai lekina aisA ho sakatA nhiiN| prazna 213-kyA guru ko ziSya kA AdhAra hai ? isame saccA AdhAra kauna rahA? uttara-guru ko apanI AtmA kA AdhAra hai aura vAstava me guru ko "usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kA AdhAra" hai| prazna 214-kyA AtmA ko karma kA AdhAra hai ?

Page #61
( 55 ) uttara - prazna 210 se 213 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 215 - kyA AtmA ko zarIra kA AdhAra hai ? uttara - prazna 210 se 213 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 216 - kyA laDakI ko mA~-bApa kA AdhAra hai ? uttara - prazna 210 213 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 217 - kyA strI ko pati kA AdhAra hai ? uttara - prazna 210 se 213 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 218 - kyA kSAyika samyagdarzana ko darzanamohanIya ke kSayakA AdhAra hai ? uttara - prazna 210 se 293 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 216 - kyA muniyo ko 28 mUlaguNo kA AdhAra hai ? uttara - prazna 210 se 213 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 220 - kyA zrAvako ko 12 aNuvrato kA AdhAra hai ? uttara - prazna 210 se 213 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 221 -kyA kevalajJAna ko kevalajJAnAvaraNIya karma ke kSaya kA AdhAra hai ? uttara - prazna 210 se 213 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 222 - kyA sukha ke lie laDakA AdhAra hai ? uttara - prazna 210 se 213 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 223 - kyA jJAna ke lie zAstra kA AdhAra hai ? uttara - prazna 210 se 213 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 224 - kyA cAritra ko zarIra kI triyA AdhAra hai ? uttara - prazna 210 se 213 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 225 - kyA guru ko ziSya kA bhAdhAra hai ? uttara - prazna 210 se 213 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 226 - anAdi se laDakI ne kisa-kisa kA AdhAra mAnA aura usakA kyA phala rahA ?

Page #62
( 56 ) uttara-(1) ghara me laDakI utpanna huI prathama mA~-bApa ko AdhAra mAnA (2) phira pati ko AdhAra maanaa| (3) pati ke bAda lar3ake ko AdhAra mAnA / (4) laDake ne bhI javAba de diyA to rupaye paiso kA AdhAra mAnA / (5) rupayA-paisA na rahA to divAla ko AdhAra mAnA, isakA phala cAro gatiyo me ghUmakara nigoda rhaa| prazna 227-laDakI kisakA AdhAra le to zAnti Ave? uttara--eka mAtra apanI AtmA kA AdhAra mAne to kalyANa ho / phira paramparA mokSa kI prApti ho / prazna 228-paryAya kA AdhAra kauna hai ? uttara-vAstava me 'usa samaya paryAya ko yogyatA hI" paryAya kA , AdhAra hai| prazna 226-jaba pratyeka dravya kI paryAya kA AdhAra vaha paryAya hI hai dUsarA nahI hai| taba dRSTi meM merA AdhAra mai hI hU~ aisA mAnanejAnane se kyA lAbha hotA hai ? uttara-(1) anAdikAla se para me apane AdhAra kI kalpanA kA abhAva ho jAtA hai, (2) 'svayabhU' kahalAtA hai, (3) cAro gatiyo kA abhAva hokara pacamagati kA mAlika bana jAtA hai, (4) . pacaparameSTiyo me usakI ginatI hone lagatI hai (5) mithyAtva, avirati, pramAda, kapAya aura yoga kA abhAva ho jAtA hai, (6) paca parAvartana kA abhAva ho jAtA hai, (7) pacama pAriNAmika bhAva kA mahatva A jAtA hai, (8) ATha karmoM kA abhAva ho jAtA hai, (6) guNasthAnamArgaNA jIvasthAna se dRSTi haTa jAtI hai| prazna 230-dravya karma kitane haiM ? uttara-ATha hai-jJAnAvaraNIya, darzanAvaraNIya, vedanIya, mohanIya, Ayu, nAma, gotra aura antarAya / prazna 231-karma ATha hI hai kama-jyAdA kyo nahIM, zAstro ke "

Page #63
( 57 ) alAvA aura koI AdhAra hai; jisa para se ATha karma haiM yaha siddha ho sake ? uttara - karma ATha haiM zAstro me to hai hI parantu dekho kArya ke Upara se kAraNa kA anumAna lagAyA jAtA hai / vedanIya karma - ( 1 ) eka jIva rogI hai, eka nirogI hai| (2) eka eka ke pAsa lAkho karor3o rupayA hai, eka ke pAsa phUTI koDI bhI nahI, isase vedanIya karma kI siddhi hotI hai / nAmakarma - ( 1 ) eka to jahA~ jAtA hai mAna milatA hai, eka jahA~ jAtA hai apamAna milatA hai| (2) eka rUpavAna hai, eka kurUpavAna hai / isase nAmakarma kI siddhi hotI hai / Ayu karma - ( 1 ) eka kI sau varSa kI umra hai, eka kI pacAsa varSa kI umra hai / (1) koI garbha me mara jAtA hai, eka tIna varSa me hI cala detA hai isa se Ayu karma kI siddhi hotI hai / eka ko Ucepane se isase gotra karma kI banatA hai yadi aura gotra karma - ( 1 ) eka jaina hai, eka zUdra hai| (2) dekhA jAtA hai, eka ko nIcepane dekhA jAtA hai| siddhi hotI hai / dekho, sayoga cAra prakAra kA hI koI sayoga dekhane me AtA hai to btaao| isalie cAra prakAra ke sayoga ke alAvA aura banatA hI nahIM, isase cAra adhAti karmoM kI siddhi hotI hai / jJAnAvaraNIya karma - ( 1 ) eka ke jJAna kA ughADa aisA hai eka hI vAra me saba bAte yAda ho jAtI haiM, (2) eka ke jJAna kA ughADa aisA hai 50 vAra sunane para bhI yAda nahI hotA / isase jJAnAvaraNIya karma kI siddhi hotI hai / darzanAvaraNIya karma - jahA~ vizeSa jJAna hotA hai vahA~ para sAmAnya darzana hotA hI hai isame darzanAvaraNIya karma kI siddhi hotI hai / mohanIya karma -- ( 1 ) eka ko vizeSa rAga dikhAI detA hai, eka ko

Page #64
( 58 ) kama rAga dikhAI detA hai (2) eka mithyAtvI hai, eka samyaktvI hai isase mohanIya karma kI siddhi hotI hai / ___antarAya karma-(1) koI tIvra puruSArtha karatA hai aura koI manda puruSArtha karatA hai isase antarAya karma kI siddhi hotI hai| isa prakAra dhAti karma cAra haiM yaha saba pApa rUpa haiN| aghAni me puNya-pApa kA antara paDatA hai, isa prakAra tarka se 8 karma kI siddhi hotI hai aura jinavANI me bhI ATha karma batalAye haiN| prazna 232-karma kI kitano dazA haiM ? uttara-cAra hai-(1) udaya (2) kSaya (3) kSayopazama (4) upshm| prazna 233-ATha karmoM meM se udaya kitane karmoM meM hotA hai ? uttara-ATha karmoM me udaya hotA hai| prazna 234-ATho karmoM meM se kSaya kitane karmoM me hotA hai ? uttara-ATho karmoM meM kSaya hotA hai| prazna 235-ATho karmo me se kSayopazama kitane karmoM meM hotA uttara-cAra ghAtiyA karmo me kSayopazama hotA hai| prazna 236-ATha karmoM me se upazama kitane karmoM me hotA hai ? uttara-eka mAtra mohanIya karma me hI upazama hotA hai| prazna 237-ATha karmoM meM udaya Adi kula kitane bheda hue ? uttara-(1) udaya ke ATha bheda, (2) kSaya ke ATha bheda, (3) kSayopazama ke cAra bheda, (4) upazama kA eka bheda, isa prakAra kula 21 bheda hue| prazna 238-jJAnAvaraNIya karma meM kitanI dazA hotI hai ? uttara-tIna hotI hai-udaya, kSaya, kSayopazama / prazna 236-darzanAvaraNIya karma me kitanI vazA hotI haiM ? uttara-tIna hotI hai-udaya, kSaya, kSayopazama /

Page #65
prazna 240-antarAya karma meM kitanI dazA hotI haiM ? uttara-tIna hotI haiM-udaya, kSaya, kSayopazama / / prazna 241-mohanIya karma me kitanI dazA hotI haiM ? uttara-cAra hotI haiM-udaya, kSaya, kSayopazama, upazama / prazna 242-aghAti karmoM meM kitanI dazA hotI haiM ? uttara-do hotI haiM-udaya aura kSaya / / prazna 243-isa prakAra udaya Adi kitane bheda hue? uttara-(1) jJAnAvaraNIya ke tIna bheda, (2) darzanAvaraNIya ke tIna bheda, (3) antarAya karma ke tIna bheda, (4) mohanIya karma ke cAra bheda; (5) Ayu ke do bheda, (6) nAma ke do bheda, (7) gotra ke do bheda, (8) vedanIya ke do bheda, isa prakAra kula 21 bheda hue| prazna 244--ATha karmoM meM udaya Adi ke 21 bhedoM se kyA lAbha rahA? uttara---yaha 21 bheda haiM, yaha kArya hai aura pratyeka kArya me chaha kAraka eka sAtha vartate haiN| isa prakAra 2146=126 bheda hue| prazna 245-jJAnAvaraNIya karma ke udaya-para chaha kAraka kaise lagate haiM? uttara-jJAnAvaraNIya karma kA udaya yaha kArya hai| kArya para se chaha prazna uThate hai / (1) jJAnAvaraNIya karma kA udaya kisane kiyA? kArmANavargaNA ne kiyA / ata kANivargaNA kartA huI, (2) kArmANavargaNA ne kyA kiyA ? jJAnAvaraNIya karma kA udaya / ata jJAnAvaraNIya karma kA udaya karma huA, (3) jJAnAvaraNIya karma kA udaya kisa sAdhana ke dvArA huA ? kANivargaNA ke sAdhana dvArA / ata kArmANavargaNA karaNa huI, (4) jJAnAvaraNIya karma kA udaya kisa ke lie kiyA ? kArmANavargaNA ke lie kiyaa| ata kArmANavargaNA sampradAna huI / (5) jJAnAvaraNIya karma kA udaya kisa me se kiyA ? pahalI paryAya kA abhAva karale kANivargaNA me se kiyaa| ata.

Page #66
( 60 ) kArmANavargaNA apAdAna huI / (6) jJAnAvaraNIya karma kA udaya kisake AdhAra se huA ? kArmANavargaNA ke AdhAra se huA / ata. kArmANavargaNA adhikaraNa huI / prazna 246 - Apane jaise prazna 245 meM jJAnAvaraNIya karma ke udaya para chaha kAraka lagAye haiM kyA usI prakAra bAkI 20 bhevoM para bhI lageMge ? " uttara - hA~, jJAnAvaraNIya karma ke udaya ke samAna chaho kAraka 20 bhedo para bhI lageMge / prazna 247-21x6= 126 bhevo se kyA siddhi huI ? uttara - ( 1 ) pratyeka kArya kI svatantratA kI siddhi huI ( 2 ) jIva ke kAraNa dravyakarma me udaya, kSaya Adi avasthA hotI haiM aura dravyakarma ke kAraNa jIva me aupazamika, kSAyika, kSayopazama Adi bhAva hote hai / aisI khoTI mAnyatA kA abhAva ho gayA / prazna 248 - Apane karmoM kI svatantratA kI siddhi kI aura samajha meM bhI AyA ki karma ke udaya Adi kA kartA kArmANavargaNA kA kArya jIva kA nahIM / parantu 'gaumaTTasAra' Adi zAstrI meM likhA hai ki (1) karma cakkara kaTAtA hai / (2) jJAnAvaraNIya ke abhAva se kevalajJAta hotA hai / (3) kSAyika samyaktva darzanamohanIya ke kSaya se hotA hai; Adi kathana zAstro meM kiyA hai| kyA vaha jhUTha likhA hai ? uttara- (1) are bhAI, vaha saba vyavahAra kathana hai aura vyavahAra kathana kA artha "aisA hai nahI, nimittAdi kI apekSA kathana kiyA hai", aisA jAnanA cAhie / ( 2 ) jo vyavahAra ke kathana ko saccA hI mAnatA hai vaha jinavANI sunane ke ayogya hai aura vyavahAra ke kathana ko saccA mAnane se mithyAtva kI puSTi hotI hai / ? prazna 246 - jIva meM audayika bhAva, kSayopazama bhAva, kSAyika bhAva, aupazamika bhAva bhI kyA karma kI apekSA binA hote haiM uttara - hA~, jIva me bhI audayikAdi bhAvarUpa se pariNamita hone *

Page #67
( 61 ) kI kriyA me vAstava me jIva svaya hI chaha kAraka rUpa se vartatA hai / isalie use anya kArako kI apekSA nahI hai / prazna 250- ( 1 ) zarIra, mana, vANI ke kArya, (2) dravyakarma; (3) jIva ke vikArI bhAva, (4) avikArI bhAva; kyA nirapekSa hote haiM, isake lie koI zAstrAdhAra hai ? uttara- (1) dekho, pacAstikAya gA0 62 TIkA sahita me likhA hai ki "sarva dravyo kI pratyeka paryAya se yaha chaha kAraka eka sAtha vartate haiM, isalie AtmA aura pudgala zuddha dazA me yA azuddha dazA me svaya chaho kAraka rUpa pariNamana karate haiM aura dUsare kArako kI apekSA nahI rakhate / " (2) jayaghavala na0 7 pRSTha 177 me likhA hai ki "vajjha kAraNa nirapekkho vathyu pariNAmoM" vastu kA pariNAma bAhya kAraNo se nirapekSa hotA hai / (3) samayasAra kalaza na0 51, 52, 53, 54, 61 me tathA kalaza 200 me 'nAsti sarvo'pi samvandha " aisA kahA hai / (4) AptamImAsA me kahA hai "dharmI dharma ko nirapekSa mAno" / prazna 251 - kyA eka dravya dUsare dravya kA kucha bhI nahIM kara sakatA hai ? uttara - kucha bhI nahI kara sakatA hai / vicAriye kevalI bhagavAna ko ananta catuSTya kI prApti arahatadazA me huI hai / vaha usI samaya odArika zarIra kA aura cAra aghAti karmoM kA abhAva nahI kara sakate aura chadmastha ko jarA sA jJAna kA ughADa huA aura vaha kahe, maiM para kA kara sakatA hU~, Azcarya hai / prazna 252 - saMsAra meM kitane prakAra kI dRSTi hai ? uttara - do haiM / (1) dravyadRSTi (2) paryAya dRSTi / prazna 253 - ina donoM dRSTiyoM kA kyA phala hai ? uttara- dravyadRSTi kA phala - mokSa hai aura paryAyadRSTi kA phala - nigoda hai /

Page #68
( 62 ) prazna 254 - " bAI ne roTI banAI "- isa para vyavahAra kAraka kisa prakAra ghaTita hote haiM ? uttara - dekho, 'roTI banI' yaha kArya hai aura kArya para se chaha prazna uThate haiM / (1) roTI kisane banAI ? bAI ne / ata vAI kartA huI (2) bAI ne kyA kiyA ? roTI banAI / ata roTI karma huA (3) roTI kisa sAdhana ke dvArA banI ? cakalA belana ke dvArA vanI / ata' cakalA belana karaNa huA / (4) roTI kisake lie banI ? khAne vAle ke lie banI / ata 'khAne vAlA sampradAna huA / (5) roTI kisame se banI / ? thAlI me se banI / ata 'thAlI apAdAna huA / (6) roTI kisake AdhAra se banI ? cUlhA, tave ke AdhAra se banI / cUlhA, tavA adhikaraNa huA / ata dekho, isame bAI kartA, roTI karma, cakalA - belana karaNa, khAne vAle sampradAna, thAlI apAdAna aura cUlhA tavA adhikaraNa- isame sabhI kAraka bhinna-bhinna haiM / yaha vyavahAra kAraka asatya haiM / yaha mAtra upacarita asadabhUta vyavahAranaya se kahe jA sakate haiM / ? prazna 255 -- vyavahAra kAraka ko hI satya mAne to kyA hogA uttara - yaha mahA ahakArarUpa ajJAna adhakAra hai usakA sulaTanA durnivAra hai aura use kabhI dharma kI prApti nahI hogI / prazna 256 - "bAI ne roTI banAI" isame trikAlI ko apekSA nizcaya kAraka ko lagAo ? chaha uttara - roTI banI - yaha kArya hai / kArya para se chaha prazna uThate hai / (1) roTI kisane banAI ? ATe ne banAI / ata ATA kartA huA, (2) ATe ne kyA kiyA ? roTI banAI / ata. roTI karma huA, (3) roTI kisa sAdhana se banI ? ATe ke sAdhana dvArA / ata ATA karaNa huA, (4) roTI kisake lie banI ? ATe ke lie / ata ATA sampradAna huA; (5) roTI kisa me se banI ? anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa loI kA abhAva karake ATe me se banI / ata ATA 1

Page #69
apAdAna huA, (6) roTI kisake AdhAra se bnii| ATe ke AdhAra se banI / ata ATA adhikaraNa huaa| prazna 257-roTI kA kartA Apane ATe ko khaa| parantu ATA to kanastara meM par3A hai, ava roTI kyo nahIM banatI ? to kahanA par3egA bAI, cakalA, belana Ave to roTI bane, kyA yaha bAta ThIka nahIM hai ? uttara-nahI bhAI, hamane ATe ko kartA kahA, vaha to mAtra para dravyo se dRSTi haTAne ke lie khaa| roTI kA kartA to usakI anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya loI kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hai| prazna 258-roTI kA kartA anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya loI kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura roTI karma, to isako jAnane se kyA lAbha rahA? uttara--(1) bhUta-bhaviSya kI paryAyo se dRSTi haTa gaI (2) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kI apekSA ATA vyavahAra kAraNa ho gyaa| (3) ava roTI ke liye anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa loI kI ora dekhanA rhaa| prazna 256-roTI banI-anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa loI ko apekSA chaha kAraka lagAkara dikhaao| uttara-roTI banI-yaha kArya hai, kArya para se chaha prazna uThate haiN| (1) roTI kisane banAI ? anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa loI ne / ata loI kartA huI, (2) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdana kAraNa loI ne kyA kiyA ? roTI banAI / ata roTI karma huI, (3) roTI kisa sAdhana dvArA banI ? anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa loI ke sAdhana dvArA / ata loI karaNa huI (4) kisake lie roTI banAI ? anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa loI ke lie| ata loI sampradAna huI, (5) roTI kisame se banAI ? anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna loI me se| ata loI apAdAna huI, (6) roTI kisake

Page #70
( 64 ) vanI ? anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa lorDa ke AdhAra se / ata loI adhikaraNa huI / prazna 260 - koI catura prazna karatA hai ki jaina zAstro meM AtA hai ki paryAya me se paryAya nahIM AtI hai, abhAva meM se bhAva kI utpatti nahIM hotI hai / tava phira anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa loI kartA aura roTI karma yaha kaise ho sakatA hai / uttara - are bhAI / tumhArI vAta ThIka hai / paryAya me se paryAya nahI AtI, abhAva me se bhAva kI utpatti nahI hotI hai / parantu hamane to, roTI banane se pUrva kaunasI paryAya kA abhAva karake hotI hai, usakI apekSA anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa loI ko kartA kahA / parantu yaha bhI roTI kA saccA kartA nahI hai / prazna 261 - yadi loI bhI roTI kA saccA karttA nahIM hai to phira roTI kA saccA karttA kauna hai / uttara - usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI roTI kA saccA kartA hai aura roTI banI vaha karma hai, kyoki jaisA kAraNa hotA hai vaisA hI kArya hotA hai / prazna 262 -- usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdana kAraNa roTI kartA aura roTI banI yaha karma, isa para chaha kAraka kisa prakAra lageMge ? uttara- 'roTI banI' yaha karma hai, kArya para se chaha prazna uThate hai / (1) roTI kisane banAI ? usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa roTI ne / ata roTI kartA huI, (2) usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa roTI ne kyA kiyA ? roTI banAI / ata roTI karma huI / ( 3 ) roTI kisa sAdhana ke dvArA banAI ? usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa roTI ke sAdhana dvArA / ata roTI karaNa huI, (4) roTI kisake lie banAI ? usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa roTI ke lie / ata roTI

Page #71
( 65 ) sampradAna huI, (5) roTI kisame se banI ? usa samaya paryAya kI upAdAna kAraNa roTI me se bnii| ata roTI apAdAna huI, (6) roTI kisake AdhAra se banI ? usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSakSiNa upAdAna kAraNa roTI ke AdhAra se| ata roTI adhikaraNa huii| dekho roTI kA vAstavika maccAkAraNa-kArya usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA hI hai / prazna 263-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA se hI roTI banI aura se nahIM, isako jAnane se kyA lAbha rahA / uttara-sasAra me jo-jo kArya hotA hai| vaha apanI-apanI usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA se huA hai, ho rahA hai aura hotA rhegaa| aisA nirNaya hote hI dRSTi apane svabhAva para A jAtI hai| tava vAstava me usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA ko maanaa| prazna 264-kevala jJAnAvaraNIya karma ke abhAva se kevalajJAna kI prApti huI isame (1) trikAlo upAdAna kAraNa (2) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa (3) usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa (4) nimitta kAraNa-cAro prakAra ke chaha kAraka lagAkara batAo? uttara-svaya prazna uttara 254 se 263 taka ke anusAra do| prazna 265-baDhaI ne ratha banAyA; isame cAro prakAra ke chaha kAraka lagAo? uttara-svaya prazna uttara 254 se 263 taka ke anusAra do| ' prazna 266-maine dahI me se ghI nikAlA; cAro prakAra ke chaha kAraka lagAo? uttara-svaya prazna uttara 254 se 263 taka ke anusAra ho| prazna 267-kyA aupazamika samyaktva hone se darzana paahtii| upazama huA? uttara-svaya prazna uttara 254 se 263 cakra ke anusArako .. sITI

Page #72
( 66 ) prazna 268 -- kyA jJAna kA kSayopazama hone se jJAnAvaraNIya karma kA kSayopazama huA ? uttara - svaya prazna uttara 254 se 263 taka ke anusAra do / prazna 26 -- kyA maiMne kapar3e bichAye ? uttara - prazna 254 se 263 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 270 --- kyA mai jora se bolatA hU~ ? uttara - prazna 254 se 263 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 271 - kyA nimitta se upAdAna meM kArya hotA hai ? uttara - prazna 254 se 263 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 272 ~ - kyA maine rupayA kamAyA ? uttara - prazna 254 se 263 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 273 - kyA kundakunda bhagavAna ne samayasAra banAyA ? uttara - prazna 254 se 263 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 274 - jaba "kArya usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA" se hotA hai taba ( 1 ) nimitta kI apekSA; (2) trikAlI upAdAna kI apekSA; (3) anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kI apekSA; kyo kathana kiyA hai ? uttara- (1) dravya ucita vahiraMga sAdhano kI sanidhi ke sadbhAva ratA hai / (pravacanasAra gA0 65 'vya trisvabhAva sparzI ( utpAda1) hotA hai aura kArya ke utpAda upasthiti hotI hai| (pravacanayaha siddha hotA hai ki utpAda, samaya eka ho hotA hai, aisA utpatti ke samaya ucita nimitta hai vahA~ pUrva paryAya kA abhAva, yogyatA se nimitta bhI svaya kathana hai /

Page #73
( 67 ) prazna 275 - jaba-jaba kArya hotA hai taba anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA abhAva karake hI trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa meM se hotA hai, taba nimitta hotA hI hai| aisA Apa kahanA cAhate haiM ? uttara - hA~, bhAI bAta to aisI hI hai / parantu yaha dhyAna rakhanA cAhie / (1) koI mAtra utpAda ko mAne, vyaya ko na mAne, trikAlI ko na mAne aura nimitta ko na mAne to jhUThA hai / (2) koI mAtra vyaya ko mAne bAkI ko na mAne to jhUThA hai / (3) koI mAtra trikAlI ko mAne, bAkI ko na mAne to jhUThA hai / (4) mAtra nimitta ko mAne bAkI ko na mAne to jhUThA hai (5) cAro kI sattA hai, lekina apanIapanI hai| eka dUsare me se nahI hote / (6) parantu jahA~ utpAda hogA, vahA~ vyaya kA abhAva aura trikAlI hogA aura nimitta bhI hogA (7) jahA~ vyaya hogA vahA~ utpAda aura trikAlI bhI hogA / (8) cAro kA eka hI samaya hai / utpAda, vyaya, dhrauvya eka hI me hotA hai nimitta para hotA hai; kyoki kahA hai-upAdAna nijaguNa jahA~ tahA~ nimitta para hoya / bhedajJAna paramANa vidhi biralA vRjhe koya | prazna 276 - kyA vikArI bhAvoM meM bhI chaha kAraka ghaTate haiM ? uttara - hA~ ghaTate haiM, kyoki vikArI bhAva bhI nirapekSa haiM / prazna 277 - vikArI bhAvo ko zAstro meM nirapekSa kyoM kahA hai ? uttara- ( 1 ) vikArI bhAva eka samaya kI paryAya hai yaha apane aparAdha se hI hai / yaha apane SaT kAraka se svaya hotA hai ( 2 ) vikArI bhAvo ke samaya karma kA nimitta hotA hai, parantu vikAra karma ne nahI karAyA / vikAra karma ke udaya kI apekSA ke binA hotA hai ( 3 ) apanA eka samaya kA doSa jAnakara, svabhAva trikAla doSa rahita hai usakA Azraya lekara abhAva kare / isalie zAstro me vikArI bhAvo ko nirapekSa kahA hai / prazna 278 - vikArI bhAvoM ko zAstroM meM (1) azuddha nizcayanaya

Page #74
( 68 ) se jIva kA kahA hai (2) vyavahAra se jIva kA kahA hai| (3) paryAyArthikanaya se jIva kA kahA hai / ( 4 ) azuddha pAriNAmika bhAva kahA hai| (5) audayikabhAva kahA hai; vahA~ aisA kahane kA tAtparya kyA-kyA hai ? uttara - ( 1 ) vikArI bhAva jIva kI paryAya me hote hai isa apekSA nizcaya kahA aura azuddha hai isalie azuddha kahA / azuddha nizcayanaya se vikArIbhAva jIva ke kahe, tAki jIva zuddha nizcayanaya kA Azraya lekara vikArI bhAvo kA abhAva kare (2) vikArI bhAva parAzrita hone se vyavahAra kahA, nizcaya svAzrita hotA hai isalie nizcaya kA Azraya lekara vikArI bhAva jo parAzrita hai unakA abhAva kare (3) vikArI bhAva paryAya me hai dravya-guNa me nahI hai / dravya-guNa abheda kA Azraya lekara paryAya me se vikAra kA abhAva kare (4) dhavala me vikArI bhAvo ko azuddha pAriNAmikabhAva kahA hai tAki pAtrajIva zuddha pAriNAmika bhAva kA Azraya lekara vikArI bhAvo kA abhAva kare (5) vikArI bhAvo ko audayika bhAva kahA hai tAki pAtra jIva pAriNAmika bhAva kA Azraya lekara audayika bhAva kA abhAva kare / yaha nyArI-nyArI apekSA kahane kA tAtparya hai / prazna 276- 'AtmA-prajJA dvArA bhedajJAna karatA hai'| isa vAkya para se kitane kAraka siddha hote haiM ? uttara -- tIna- AtmA-kartA, prajJA dvArA-karaNa, bheda jJAna karatA hai-karma | prazna 280 -- 'AtmA ne jJAna diyaa| isameM kitane kAraka siddha hote hai ? uttara- do / AtmA - kartA, jJAna diyA -karma | prazna 281 - AtmA ne, jJAna dvArA, jJAna diyA / isame kitane kAraka siddha hote haiM ? uttara--AtmA ne-kartA, jJAna dvAra , jJAna diyA karma /

Page #75
( 66 ) prazna 282 - 'AtmA ne, jJAna dvArA, jJAna ke lie, jJAna diyA / isame kitane kAraka siddha hote haiM ? uttara - AtmA ne kartA, jJAna dvArA - karaNa, jJAna ke lie sampradAna; jJAna diyA-karma | prazna 283 - " ahaMta bhagavAna ne kevalajJAna pragaTa kiyA / " kitane kAraka siddha hote haiM ? uttara - arhata bhagavAna - kartA, kevalajJAna-karma / prazna 284 - AtmA ne, jJAna dvArA, jJAna ke lie, jJAna meM se, jJAna diyA / isameM kitane kAraka siddha hote haiM ? uttara - AtmA-kartA, jJAna dvArA-karaNa, jJAna ke lie sampradAna; jJAna me se - apAdAna, jJAna diyA karma / prazna 285 - AtmA meM se, zuddhatA AtI hai / isame kitane kAraka siddha hote haiM ? uttara--AtmA me se- apAdAna, zuddhatA - karma | prazna 286 - nizcaya ratnatraya kA kAraNa zuddha AtmA hai / isameM kitane kAraka siddha hote haiM ? uttara - nizcaya ratnatraya - karma, kAraNa-karaNa, zuddha AtmA - kartA / prazna 287 meM, apane hita ke lie, abhyAsa karatA hU~ / isameM kitane kAraka siddha hote haiM ? uttara - maiM - kartA, apane hitake lie sampradAna, abhyAsa karatA hU~-karma / prazna 288 - U~ce nimitto dvArA, jIva U~cA car3hatA hai| isameM kitane kArako me bhUla haiM / uttara--karaNa, kartA, karma, tIna kArako kI bhUla hai / prazna 286 - mahApuruSa apane meM se dUsaro ko dete haiN| isame kitane kArako kI bhUla sAbita hotI ?

Page #76
1 ( ( 70 ) uttara - kartA, apAdAna, karma, tIna kArako kI bhUla sAbita hotI hai / prazna 260 - chaha kArakoM kI svatantratA se kyA siddha hotA hai ? uttara - jIva ananta, pudgala anantAnanta, dharma-adharma-AkAza ekaeka aura loka pramANa asakhyAta kAla dravya haiM / pratyeka dravya meM anantaananta guNa hai / pratyeka guNa me eka hI samaya me eka paryAya kA vyaya, dUsarI kA utpAda aura guNa dhrauvya rahatA hai / aisA pratyeka dravya ke guNa me ho cukA hai, ho rahA hai aura bhaviSya me hotA rahegA / prazna 261- prazna 260 ke anusAra jAnane vAle ko kyA-kyA lAbha hotA hai ? uttara- (1) kevalI ke samAna jJAtA-dRSTA buddhi pragaTa ho jAtI hai / ( 2 ) pratyeka vastu kaisI hai aura kyA karatI hai aisA saccA jJAna ho jAtA hai / (3) anAdi nidhana mantra kA rahasya apanA anubhava hue binA samajha me nahI A sakatA hai / jJAnI isa mantra kA rahasya jAnate haiM aura sadaiva sukhI rahate haiM / ( 4 ) ajJAnI anAdi se vyavahAra SaTakAraka ke avalambana me pAgala thA / vaha miTakara zuddhAtma anubhUti pragaTa ho jAtI hai / (5) jJAnI jAnatA hai merI AtmA anAdiananta kisI me gayI nahI, milI nahI hai, usI prakAra pratyeka dravya kisI me gayA nahI, kabhI jAvegA nahI / ( 6 ) yaha mantra sAre Agama kA sAra hai yaha vItarAga vijJAnatA kA bhedajJAna hai / vastu vicArata dhyAyataM, mana pAvai vizrAma / rasa svAvata sukha upajai, anubhava yAko nAma // jaya mahAvIra - jaya mahAvIra

Page #77
( 71 ) upAdAna-upAdeya dUsarA adhikAra prazna 1-kAraNa kise kahate haiM ? uttara-kArya kI utpAdaka sAmagrI ko kAraNa kahate hai| prazna 2-utpAdaka sAmagrI ke kitane bheda haiM ? uttara-do bheda haiM-upAdAna aura nimitta / prazna 3-upAdAna ke sAmane kyA hai ? uttara-upAdAna ke sAmane nimitta hai| prazna 4-nija zakti ke sAmane kyA hai ? uttara-nijazakti ke sAmane parayoga hai| prazna 5-nizcaya ke sAmane kyA hai? uttara-nizcaya ke sAmane vyavahAra hai| prazna 6-upAdAna kAraNa kitane prakAra ke haiM ? uttara- tIna prakAra ke haiM / (1) trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa, (2) anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa, (3) usa samaya paryAya ko yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kaarnn| prazna 7-trikAlo upAdAna kAraNa kise kahate haiM ? uttara-jo dravya svaya kArya rUpa pariNamita ho use upAdAna kAraNa kahate haiN| jaise ki-ghaDe kI utpatti me miTTI usakA trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa hai| prazna 8-anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kise kahate haiM ? uttara-anAdikAla se dravya me jo paryAyo kA pravAha calA A rahA hai usame anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura anantara uttara kSaNavartI paryAya kArya hai| jaise-miTTI kA ghaDA hone me miTTI kA piNDa vaha ghaDe kI anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika

Page #78
( 72 ) upAdAna kAraNa aura ghaDA rUpa kArya vaha piNDa kI anantara uttara kSaNavartI paryAya hai / (yaha paryAyAthika naya se hai) prazna :-(1) 'anantara pUrva' zabda kyA batAtA hai (2) aura anantara zabda nA lagAve to nukasAna hai ? uttara-(1) jo kArya huaa| usase tatkAla pahile kI paryAya ko batAtA hai| jaise dasa nambara para ghaDA banA to nau nambara kI paryAya ko batAtA hai (2) aura yadi anantara gabda nA lagAyA jAve to jo kArya huA-usase pahile kI saba paryAyo kA grahaNa ho jaavegaa| jo ThIka nahIM hai| prazna 10-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kise kahate haiM ? uttara-jo kArya huA-- vaha usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura vahI paryAya kArya hai| yahI saccA kAraNa hai / prazna 11-upAdAna kA zAbdika artha kyA hai ? uttara---upa samIpa / A=maryAdA pUrvaka / dAna-dAna denA / dravya ke samIpa me se kauna-sI, jaisI paryAya kI yogyatA hai / usa paryAya ko prApta honA / yaha upAdAna kA zAbdika artha hai / prazna 12-ina tIno upAdAna kAraNo me se kArya kA saccA kauna hai aura kauna nahIM hai / / uttara-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI vAstava me kArya kA saccA kAraNa hai| trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa, anantarapUrva kSaNavartIparyAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura nimitta kAraNa saccA kAraNa nahI hai| / prazna 13-~-kArya kA trikAlI utpAdana kAraNa saccA kAraNa kyoM nahIM hai ? uttara-kArya eka samaya kA hai usakA (kAya kA) kAraNa yadi anAdi ananta trikAlI ho to kArya bhI anAdiananta honA cAhie /

Page #79
( 73 ) isaliye kArya kA saccAkAraNa usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI hai trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa nahI hai / prazna 14 - kArya kA anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa saccA kAraNa kyo nahIM hai ? uttara -- kArya svaya eka samaya kA sat hai / vaha anantara pUrva paryAya me se Ave aisA nahI hai, kyoki abhAva me se bhAva kI utpatti nahI hotI hai aura paryAya me se paryAya nahI AtI / isalie kArya kA saccA kAraNa usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika uhAdAna kAraNa hI hai / anantarapUrva kSaNavartIparyAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa saccA kAraNa nahI hai| yAda rahe anantarapUrva kSaNavartIparyAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa ko kArya kA abhAvarUpa kAraNa kahA jAtA hai / ? prazna 15 - kArya ko upAdAna kAraNa kI apekSA kyo kahate haiM uttara - upAdeya kahate haiM / ? prazna 16 -- upAdAna - upAdeya sambandha kisameM hotA hai uttara---upAdAna- upAdeya sambandha eka hI padArtha me lAgU hotA hai / prazna 17 - 'upAdeya' zabda kahA~-kahA~ prayoga hotA hai ? uttara -- (1) kArya hone me upAdAna ke kArya ko upAdeya kahate haiM / (2) trikAlI svabhAva jo anAdiananta hai use Azraya karane yogya upAdeya kahate haiM / ( 3 ) mokSamArga ko ekadeza prakaTa karane yogya upAdeya kahate haiM / (4) mokSa ko pUrNa prakaTa karane yogya upAdeya kahate haiM / upAdAna - upAdeya prakaraNa me jo kArya hotA hai use yahA~ upAdeya kahanA hai / isalie yahA~ para kArya ko upAdeya kahege / yAda rakhanAvyavahAranaya ko upAdeya kahA so upAdeya kA artha 'jAnanA' samajhanA / "kumhAra ne cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi se ghaDA banAyA / " isa vAkya meM 'ghaDA' kArya para upAdAna - upAdeya kA 25 praznottaro dvArA spaSTIkaraNa

Page #80
( 74 ) prazna 18-kumhAra cAka, kolI, raMDA, hAtha Adi upAdAnakArama aura ghar3A upAdeya / kyA yaha upAdAna-upAdeya kA jJAna ThIka hai? uttara-bilkula ThIka nahIM hai, kyoki yahAM para miTTI trikAlI upAdAnakAraNa aura ghar3A upAdeya hai| prazna 16-yadi koI catura kumhAra, cAka, kolI, raDA, hAya Adi upAdAna kAraNa aura ghar3A upAdeya-aisA hI mAne to kyA doSa AtA hai? usara-kumhAra, cAka, kIlI, DaDA hAtha Adi naSTa hokara miTTI bana jAve to aisA mAnA jA sakatA hai ki kumhAra, cAka, kIlI, DaDA hAtha Adi upAdAnakAraNa aura ghar3A upAdeya / lekina aisA nahIM ho sakatA, kyoki upAdana-upAdeya tatsvarupa me hI (abhinna sattA vAle padArthoM me hI) hotA hai, jinakI sattA-sattva bhinna-bhinna haiM aise do padArthoM me upAdAna-upAdeya nahA hotA hai| prazna 20-~-jo kumhAra, cAka, kIlo, DA, hAtha Adi nimitta kAraNo ko hI ghar3e kA (kArya kA) saccA kAraNa mAnate haiN| unheM jinavANI me kina-kina nAmo se sambodhana kiyA hai| uttara-(1) jo nimitta kAraNo se hI kArya kI utpatti mAnate hai, unhe samayasArakalaza 55 me kahA hai ki "unakA sulaTanA durnivAra hai aura yaha unakA ajJAna moha adhakAra hai|" (2) jo nimittakAraNo se hI kArya kI utpatti mAnate hai, unhe pravacanasAra gAthA 55 me kahA hai ki "vaha pada-pada para dhokhA khAtA hai|" (3) jo nimittakAraNo se hI kArya kI utpatti mAnate hai, unhe puruSArtha siddhayupAya gAthA 6 me kahA hai ki "tasya dezanA nAsti arthAt vaha bhagavAna kI vANI sunane lAyaka nahI hai|" (4) jo nimittakAraNo se hI kArya kI utpatti mAnate haiN| unhe AtmAvalokana me kahA hai ki "yaha unakA harAmajAdIpanA hai|"

Page #81
( 75 ) prazna 21 - miTTI trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa aura ghar3A upAveya / isako samajhane se kyA lAbha huA ? uttara - (1) kumhAra, cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi nimitta kAraNo se ghar3A banA - aisI khoTI mAnyatA kA abhAva ho jAtA hai / (2) AhAravargaNA ke svadha miTTI ko chor3akara dUsarI vargaNAo se dRSTi haTa jAtI hai / ( 3 ) aba yahA~ para ghaDA banane ke lie mAtra trikAlI upAdAnakAraNa miTTI kI tarapha dekhanA rahA / itanA lAbha huA / prazna 22 - koI catura prazna karatA hai ki yadi kumhAra, cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi nimittakAraNa ho to ghar3A bane / zrApa kahate ho ghar3e kA (kArya kA ) nimittakAraNo se koI sambandha nahIM hai / to miTTI upAdAna kAraNa aura ghar3A upAdeya / yaha ApakI bAta jhUThI sAvita hotI hai ? uttara - are bhAI- hamane miTTI ko ghaDe kA upAdAnakAraNa kahA hai / vaha to kumhAra, cAka, kIlA DaDA, hAtha Adi nimitta kAraNo se pRthak karane kI apekSA se kahA hai / vAstava me miTTI bhI ghaDe kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahI hai / prazna 23 - miTTI bhI ghar3e kA saccA upAdAnakAraNa nahIM hai / to yahA~ para ghar3e kA saccA upAdAnakAraNa kauna hai ? uttara - miTTI me anAdikAla se paryAyoM kA pravAha calA A rahA hai / mAno dasa nambara para ghaDA banA, to usame anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya piNDa kSaNika upAdAna kAraka ghaDe kA yahA~ para saccA uAdAna kAraNa hai / prazna 24 - miTTI me anAdikAla se praryAyo kA pravAha kyoM calA A rahA hai / uttara - pratyeka dravya-guNa anAdiananta dhrauvya rahatA huA eka paryAya kA vyaya aura dUsarI paryAya kA utpAda eka hI samaya meM svaya

Page #82
svata apane pariNamana svabhAva ke kAraNa karatA rahA hai, karatA hai aura bhaviSya me karatA rhegaa| aisA vastusvarUpa hai| isI kAraNa anAdi kAla se miTTI me paryAyo kA pravAha calA A rahA hai| prazna 25--anantarapUrva kSaNavartIparyAya piNDa kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura ghaDA upAdeya / isako mAnane se kyA lAbha huA? uttara--(1) bhUta-bhaviSyat kI paryAyo se dRSTi haTa gii| (2) miTTI trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa thA, vaha bhI vyavahAra kAraNa ho gyaa| (3) ava yahAM para ghaDA banane ke lie mAtra anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya piNDa kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kI tarapha dekhanA rhaa| prazna 26-koI catura phira prazna karatA hai ki abhAva meM se bhAva kI utpatti nahIM hotI hai aura paryAya meM se paryAya nahIM AtI hai| aisA jinavANI meM kahA hai| phira yaha mAnanA ki anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya piNDa kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura ghar3A upAdeya hai| yaha ApakI bAta jhUThI sAvita hotI hai ? uttara-are bhAI-abhAva me se bhAva kI utpatti nahI hotI hai aura paryAya me se paryAya nahI AtI hai| yaha bAta jinavANI kI bilkula ThIka hai / parantu hamane to kArya se pahile kaunasI paryAya hotI hai| usakI apekSA anantarapUrva kSaNavartIparyAya piNDa ko ghaDe kA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kahA hai / parantu anantarapUrva kSaNavartIparyAya piNDa bhI dhaDe kA saccA kAraNa nahI hai| prazna 27---anantarapUrva kSaNavartIparyAya piNDa ghar3e kA saccA upAdAnakAraNa nahIM hai / to kaisA kAraNa hai aura kaisA kAraNa se bhAva yaha bAta maryAya hoto uttara-anantarapUrva kSaNavartIparyAya piNDa ghaDe kA abhAvarUpa kAraNa hai vaha kAla sUcaka hai| parantu kArya kA janaka nahI hai| prazna 28-anantarapUrva kSaNavartIparyAya piNDa kSaNika upAdAna

Page #83
( 77 ) kAraNa bhI ghar3e kA saccA upAdAnakAraNa nahIM hai / to vAstava meM ghar3e kA saccA upAdAnakAraNa kauna hai ? uttara - vAstava me usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI ghaDe kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa hai | prazna 26 - vAstava meM usa samaya paryAya ko yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa hI ghar3e kA saccA upAdAnakAraNa hai / aisA mAnane se kyA lAbha huA ? uttara- ( 1 ) anantarapUrva kSaNavartIparyAya piNDa kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kI tarapha ghaDe ke lie dekhanA nahI rahA / (2) aba ekamAtra ghaDe ke lie usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa kI tarapha hI dekhanA rahA / yaha lAbha huA / prazna 30 - ( 1 ) miTTI trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa aura ghar3A upAdeya / (2) anantarapUrva kSaNavartIparyAya piNDa kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa aura ghar3A upaadey| (3) usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA ghar3A kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa aura ghar3A upAdeya / aisA zAstro me batAyA | parantu itanA lambA-lambA jhagar3A karane se kyA lAbha yA ? kaha dete ki kArya usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se hIM hotA hai / uttara- ( 1 ) nimitta kAraNo se pRthaka karane kI apekSA se miTaTI trikAlI upAdana kAraNa ko batAnA Avazyaka thA / (2) bhUta oya bhaviSyat paryAyo se pRthak karane kI apekSA se aura abhAvarUpa kAraNa kA jJAna karAne ke lie piNDa anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa ko batAnA Avazyaka thA / (3) anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya piNDa kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se pRthak karane kI apekSA se ora kArya ke saccA kAraNa kA jJAna karAne ke lie usa samaya paryAya yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa ko batAnA Avazyaka thI /

Page #84
{ ( 78 ) tInoM kAraNo kA saccA jJAna karAne ke lie zAstro me itanA lambAlambA karake samajhAyA hai / prazna 31 - ghar3A usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se banA hai| isako mAnane se kyA lAbha huA ? uttara - jaise -- ghaDA usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se banA hai / vaise hI vizva me jitane bhI kArya haiM ve saba usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se ho cuke haiM, ho rahe haiM aura bhaviSya meM hote raheMge / aisA kevalI ke samAna saccAjJAna ho jAtA hai / prazna 32 - vizva me jitane bhI kArya haiN| ve saba usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se ho cuke haiM, ho rahe haiM aura bhaviSya me hote rheNge| aisA kevalI ke samAna saccAjJAna hote ho kyA-kyA apUrva kArya dekhane meM AtA hai ? uttara- ( 1 ) anAdikAla kI para me karU~-gharU kI khoTI mAnyatA kA abhAva honA / (2) dRSTi apane jJAyaka svabhAva para AnA / (3) samyagdarzanAdi kI prApti hokara krama se vRddhi hokara mokSa lakSmI kA nAtha honA / (4) mithyAtvAdi sasAra ke pAca kAraNoM kA abhAva honA / (5) dravya kSetra kAla - bhava- bhAvarUpa paca parAvartana kA abhAva hokara paMca parameSTiyo me ginatI honA / prazna 33 - vizva meM pratyeka kArya usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA chaNika upAdAnakAraNa se hI hotA hai| taba kauna-kauna sI cAra bAteM eka sAtha eka hI samaya meM niyama se hotI haiM / uttara- (1) usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa ( utpAda) (2) anantarapUrva kSaNavartIparyAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa (vyaya) (3) trikAlI upAdAnakAraNa ( dhrauvya ) (4) nimittakAraNa | ye cAra bAte pratyeka kArya me eka hI sAtha eka hI kAla me niyama se hotI hai / ( pravacanasAra gAthA 95 )

Page #85
( 76 ) prazna 34 -- usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA chaNika upAdAna kAraNa se hIM kArya kI utpatti hotI hai| kyA yaha nirapekSa hai| uttara - hA~ kArya svaya para kI apekSA nahI rakhatA hai isalie nirapekSa hai, aura apanI apekSA rakhatA hai isalie sApekSa hai / pAtra bhavya jIvo ko prathama nirapekSa siddhi karanI caahie| phira jo kArya huA, usakA abhAvarUpa kAraNa kauna hai, trikAlIkAraka kauna hai aura nimittakAraNa kona hai| ina bAto kA jJAna karanA cAhie, kyoki kArya ke samaya cAro bAte niyama se hotI hai / prazna 35 - ghar3A ( kArya ) usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se huA hai / aisA mAnane se kisa-kisa kAraNa para vRSTi nahIM jAtI hai ? uttara -- (1) kumhAra, cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha / (2) miTaTI (3) anantara pUrNa kSaNavartI paryAya piNDa kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa Adi para dRSTi nahI jAtI hai / prazna 36- dayA kumhAra kAraNa aura ghar3A kArya / kAraNAnu vidhAyIti kAryANi ko kaba mAnA jaura kaba nahIM mAnA / uttara -- AhAravargaNA ke skadha miTTI me se anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya piNDa kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se ghaDA banA hai / kumhAra se nahI banA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko mAnA / aura kumhAra se ghaDA banA hai aisI mAnyatA vAle ne kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahI mAnA / prazna 37 - cAka kAraNa aura ghar3A kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kava mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA ? uttara -- prazna 36 ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 38 - kIlI kAraNa aura ghar3A kArya kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA ?

Page #86
2 - .. kAryANi ko kamiTIkAraNa aura uttara dii| ( 80 ) uttara-prazna 36 ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 36-DaMDA kAraNa aura ghar3A kArya kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA? uttara-prazna 36 ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 40-hAtha kAraNa aura ghar3A kaary| kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahI mAnA? uttara-prazna 36 ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 41-miTTIMkAraNa aura ghar3A kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA? uttara-anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya piNDa kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se ghaDA (kArya) huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko mAnA / aura miTTI se ghar3A banA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahIM maanaa| prazna 42-anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya piNDa kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura ghar3A kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahI maanaa| uttara-ghaDA-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se banA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko maanaa| aura anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya piNDa kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se banA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahIM maanaa| prazna 43-bAI ne cakalA, velana, tavA, hAtha Adi se roTI banAI-isa vAkya me se roTI para upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara-prazna 18 se 42 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 44-mai muMha se bolA / isa vAkya me "bolA" para upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye ? utara-prazna 18 se 42 taka ke anusAra uttara do|

Page #87
( 81 ) prazna 45-palaMga para soyaa| isa vAkya me se "soyA" para upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye? uttara-prazna 18 se 42 taka ke sanusAra uttara do| prazna 46-maiMne meja para se kitAba utthaaii| isa vAkya meM se "kitAba uThAI" para upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye? uttara-prazna 18 se 42 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 47-maiMne cAbI dvArA dukAna kholI / isa vAkya meM se "dukAna kholI" para upAdAna-upAdeya samajAiye ? uttara-prazna 18 se 42 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 48-maiMne cArapAI para bistarA vichaayaa| isa vAkya meM se "bistarA bichAyA" para upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye? uttara-prazna 18 se 42 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 46-maine zarIra para se kapar3e utaare| isa vAkya meM se "kapar3e utAre" para upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye? uttara-prazna 18 se 42 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 50-maine hAtho kI mehanata se rupayA kmaayaa| isa vAkya meM se "rupayA kamAyA" para upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAIye ? uttara-prazna 18 se 42 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 51-maiMne AMkha dvArA jJAna kiyaa| isa vAkya meM se "jJAna kiyA" para upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye? uttara-prazna 18 se 42 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 52-mujhe divyadhvani se jJAna huA hai| isa vAkya meM se "jJAna huA" para upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara-prazna 18 se 42 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 53-maine mugadara ke dvArA kasarata kii| isa vAkya me se "kasarata kI" para upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye? uttara-prazna 18 se 42 taka ke anusAra uttara do|

Page #88
( 82 ) prazna 54 - mere hAtha meM lakavA ho gayA hai| isa vAkya meM se "hAtha me lakavA ho gayA" para upAdAna upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara - prazna 18 se 42 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 55 - maiMne aujAro se simenTa dvArA makAna bnaayaa| isa vAkya me se " makAna banAyA" para upAdAna - upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara - prazna 18 se 42 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 56 - maine hAtho se jhADU lgaaii| lagAI" para upAdAna - upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara - prazna 18 se 42 taka ke anusAra uttara do / isa vAkya me se "jhADU prazna 57 - maiMne mu~ha dvArA gAlI dI / isa vAkya meM se "gAlI dI" para upAdAna - upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara - prazna 18 se 42 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 58 - maiMne mu~ha ke dvArA miThAI khaaii| isa vAkya meM se "miThAI khAI" para upAdAna- upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara -- prazna 18 se 42 taka ke anusAra uttara do / "kumhAra ne cAka, kolI, DaMDA, hAtha Adi se ghar3A banAyAisa vAkya me se 'cAka, kolI, ThaDA, hAtha Adi kArya para upAdAna kA 22 praznottaroM ke dvArA spaSTIkaraNa" prazna 56 - kumhAra, ghaDA upAdAnakAraNa aura cAka, kIlI, DaMDA hAtha Adi kArya upAdeya / kyA yaha upAdAna- upAdeya kA jJAna ThIka hai ? 1 uttara - bilkula ThIka nahI hai / kyoki yahA~ para cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi AhAravargaNA ke skadha trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa aura cAka kIlI, iDA, hAtha Adi kArya upAdeya hai / 1 prazna 60 - yadi koI catura kumhAra, ghar3A upAdAnakAraNa aura cAka, kilI, DaMDA, hAtha Adi kArya upAdeya / aisA hI mAne to kyA doSa AtA hai ?

Page #89
uttara-kumhAra, ghar3A naSTa hokara cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi AhAravargaNA ke skAdha vana jAve to aisA mAnA jA sakatA hai ki kumhAra, ghaDA upAdAna kAraNa aura cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi kArya upAdeya / lekina aisA nahIM ho sakatA hai kyoki upAdAna-upAdeya tatsvarUpa me hI (abhinna sattA vAle padArthoM me hI) hotA hai| jinakI sattA-sattva bhinna-bhinna hai| aise do padArtho me upAdAna-upAdeya nahIM hotA hai| prazna 61-jo kumhAra, ghaDA Adi nimittakAraNo ko hI cAka, kolI, uDA, hAtha Adi kArya kA saccA kAraNa mAnate haiM / unhe jinavANI me kina-kina nAmo se sambodhana kiyA hai ? uttara-(1) jo nimittakAraNo se hI kArya kI utpatti mAnate haiM unhe samayasArakalaza 55 me kahA hai ki "unakA sulaTanA dunivAra hai aura yaha unakA ajJAnamoha adhakAra hai|" (2) jo nimitta kAraNoM se hI kArya kI utpatti mAnate haiM unhe pravacanasAra gAthA 55 me kahA hai ki "vaha pada-pada para dhokhA khAtA hai|" (3) jo nimittakAraNo se hI kArya kI utpatti mAnate haiM unhe purupArtha siddhayupAya gAthA 6 me kahA hai ki "tasya dezanA nAsti arthAt vaha bhagavAna kI vANI sunane lAyaka nahI hai|" (4) jo nimitta kAraNo se hI kArya kI utpatti mAnate hai unhe AtmAvalokana me kahA hai ki "yaha unakA harAmajAdIpanA hai|" prazna 62-cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi AhAravargaNA ke skaMdha trikAlI upAdAnakAraNa aura cAka, kolI, DaDA, hAtha Adi kArya upaadey| isako samajhane se kyA lAbha huA ? uttara-(1) kumhAra, ghaDA Adi nimittakAraNo se cAka, kIlI DaDA, hAtha Adi kArya huA-aisI khoTI mAnyatA kA abhAva ho jAtA hai| (2) cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAya Adi AhAravargaNA ke skadha ko choDakara dUsarI vargaNAo se dRSTi haTa jAtI hai| (3) aba yahA~ para cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi kArya ke lie mAtra trikAlI upAdAna

Page #90
( 84 ) kAraNa cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi AhAravargaNA ke skadho kI tarapha dekhanA rahA / itanA lAbha huaa| prazna 63--koI catura prazna karatA hai ki kumhAra, ghaDA Adi nimittakAraNa ho to cAka, kolI, DaMDA, hAtha Adi kArya bne| Apa kahate ho cAka kIlI, DaMDA, hAtha Adi kArya kA nimitta kAraNo se koI sambandha nahIM hai to cAka, kolI, uMDA, hAya Adi AhAra vargaNA ke skaMdha upAdAnakAraNa aura cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha, Adi kArya upaadey| yaha ApakI bAta jhUThI sAbita hotI hai ? uttara-are bhAI, hamane cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi AhAravargaNA ke skadha ko cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi kArya kA upAdAnakAraNa kahA hai| vaha to kumhAra, ghaDA Adi nimitta kAraNo se pRthak karane kI apekSA se kahA hai| vAstava me cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi AhAravargaNA ke skadha bhI cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahI hai| prazna 64-cApha, kolI, DaDA, hAtha Adi AhAravargaNA ke skagha bhI cAka, kIlI, DaMDA hAtha Adi kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahIM hai| to yahA~ para cAka, kolI, DaMDA, hAtha Adi kArya kA saccA upAdAnakAraNa kauna hai ? uttara-cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi AhAravargaNA ke svAdho me anAdikAla se paryAyo kA pravAha calA A rahA hai / mAno dasa nambara para cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi kArya huaa| to usame anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi kArya kA yahAM para saccA upAdAna kAraNa hai| prazna 65-cAka, kolI, DaMDA, hAtha Adi AhAravargaNA ke skaMdho meM anAdikAla se paryAyo kA prabhAva kyo calA A rahA hai ? uttara-pratyeka dravya-guNa anAdiananta dhrauvya rahatA huA, eka paryAya kA vyaya aura dUsarI paryAya kA utpAda eka hI samaya me svaya

Page #91
( 85 ) svata apane pariNamana svabhAva ke kAraNa karatA rahA hai, karatA hai aura bhaviSya me karatA rahegA / aisA vastu svarUpa hai / isI kAraNa anAdi kAla se cAka, kolI, DhaDA hAtha Adi AhAravargaNA ke svadho me paryAyo kA pravAha calA A rahA hai / prazna 66 - anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura cAka, kolI, DaDA, hAtha Adi kArya upaadey| isako mAnane se kyA lAbha huA ? uttara - (1) bhUta-bhaviSyat kI paryAyoM se dRSTi haTa gaI / (2) cAka, kIlI, DhaDA, hAtha Adi AhAravargaNA ke skadha jo pahale trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa thA, vaha bhI aba vyavahAra kAraNa ho gayA / (3) cAka kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi kArya ke lie aba yahA~ para mAtra anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa kI tarapha dekhanA rahA / yaha lAbha huA / prazna 67 - koI catura phira prazna karatA hai ki - abhAva me se bhAva kI utpatti nahIM hotI hai aura paryAya me se paryAya nahIM AtI - aisA jinavANI meM kahA hai| phira yaha mAnanA ki anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa aura cAka, phIlI DaMDA, hAtha Adi kArya upAdeya / yaha Apako bAta jhUThI sAbita hotI hai ? uttara -- are bhAI - abhAva me se bhAva kI utpatti nahI hotI hai aura paryAya me se paryAya nahI AtI hai / yaha bAta jina vANI me vilkula ThIka hai / parantu hamane to kArya se pahile kauna sI paryAya hotI hai usa kI apekSA anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara ko cAka, kolI, 'DA, hAtha Adi kArya kA upAdAna kAraNa kahA / parantu anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara bhI cAka, kIlI, DaDA hAtha Adi kArya kA saccA kAraNa nahI hai | prazna 68- anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara cAka, kolI,

Page #92
( 86 ) DaDA, hAtha Adi kArya kA saccA upAdAnakAraNa nahIM hai to kasA 'kAraNa hai aura kaisA kAraNa nahIM hai ? uttara--anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi kArya kA abhAva rUpa kAraNa hai va kAlasUcaka hai parantu kArya kA janaka nahI hai| prazna 66~-anantarapUrva kSaNavartIparyAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa bhI cAka, kIlI, DaMDA, hAtha Adi kArya kA saccA upAdAnakAraNa nahIM hai to vAstava me cAka, kolI, DaDA, hAtha Adi kArya kA saccA upAdAnakAraNa kauna hai ? - uttara-vAstava me usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa hai| prazna 70-vAstava meM usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa hI cAka, kIlI, DaMDA, hAtha Adi kArya saccA upAdAnakAraNa hai| aisA mAnane se kyA lAbha huA ? uttara-(1) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nI nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kI tarapha cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi kArya ke lie dekhanA nahIM rahA / (2) eka mAtra cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi kArya ke lie usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa kI tarapha dekhanA rahA / yaha lAbha huaa| prazna 71-(1) vAka, kolI, uDA, hAtha Adi AhAravargaNA ke ska trikAlI upAdAnakAraNa aura cAka, kIlI, DaMDA, hAtha Adi kArya upaadey| (2) antatarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa aura cAka, kolI, DaDA, hAtha Adi kArya upaadey| (3) usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA cAka kolI DaMDA, hAtha Adi kArya kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa aura cAka, kIlI, DaDA hAtha Adi kArya -upAdeya / aisA zAstro me btaayaa| parantu itanA lambA-lambA jhagaDA

Page #93
raNo se pRthak karakA trikAlI paryAyoM se ( 87 ) karane se kyA lAbha thA ? kaha dete ki kArya usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatAkSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se hI hotA hai| uttara-(1) nimitta kAraNo se pRthaka karane kI apekSA se cAka, kIlI, DaeNDA, hAtha Adi AhAravargaNA ke skagha trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa ko batAnA Avazyaka thaa| (2) bhUta-bhaviSyat kI paryAyo se pRthaka karane kI apekSA se aura abhAva rUpa kAraNa kA jJAna karAne ke lie nau nambara anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa ko vatAnA Avazyaka thaa| (3) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se pRthak karane kI apekSA se aura kArya ke saccA kAraNa kA jJAna karAne ke lie usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa ko batAnA Avazyaka thaa| isalie tIno kAraNo kA saccA jJAna karAne ke liye zAstro me itanA lambA-lambA karake samajhAyA hai| prazna 72-cAka, kolI, DaDA, hAtha Adi kArya-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se huA hai| isako mAnane se kyA lAbha huA? uttara-jaise-cAka, kIlI, DaDA hAtha Adi kArya-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se huA hai| vaise hI vizva me jitane bhI kArya haiM ve saba usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se ho cuke haiM ho rahe hai aura bhaviSya me hote rhege| aisA kevalI ke samAna saccA jJAna ho jAtA hai| prazna 73--vizva me jitane bhI kArya haiN| ve saba usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se hI ho cuke haiM, ho rahe haiM aura bhaviSya meM hote rhege| aisA kevalI ke samAna saccA jJAna hote hI kyA-kyA apUrva kArya dekhane meM AtA hai ? uttara-(1) anAdikAla kI para me karUM kaheM kI khoTI mAnyatA kA abhAva honA (2) dRSTi apane jJAyaka svabhAva para aanaa| (~

Page #94
f 3 (55) samyagdarzanAdi kI prApti hokara krama se vRddhi hokara mokSa lakSmI kA nAtha honA / ( 4 ) mithyAtvAdi sasAra ke pA~ca kAraNoM kA abhAva honA / (5) dravya-kSetra kAla-bhava bhAvarUpI pacaparAvartana kA abhAva hokara pacaparameSTiyo me unakI ginatI honA / prazna 74 - vizva me pratyeka kArya usa samaya paryAya ko yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se ho hotA hai| taba kauna-kauna sI cAra bAteM eka sAtha eka hI samaya me niyama se hotI haiM ? uttara- (1) usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa ( utpAda ) (2) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa (vyaya) (3) trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa (dhIvya ) (4) nimittakAraNa | ye cAra bAte pratyeka kArya me eka sAtha eka hI kAla me niyama se hotI hai / [ pravacanasAra gAthA 65 ] prazna 75 -- usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se hI kArya kI utpatti huii| kyA yaha nirapekSa hai ? uttara - hA~, kArya svaya parakI apekSA nahI rakhatA isalie nirapekSa hai aura apanI apekSA rakhatA hai isalie sApekSa hai / pAtra bhavya jIvo ko prathama nirapekSa siddhi karanI cAhie / phira jo kArya huA usakA abhAvarUpa kAraNa kauna hai, trikAlIkAraNa kauna hai aura nimitta kAraNa kauna hai / ina vAto kA jJAna karanA cAhie kyoki kArya ke samaya cAro vAte niyama se hotI haiM / prazna 76 - cAka, kolI, DaDA, hAtha Adi kArya usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakaraNa se huA hai / aisA mAnane ke kisakisa kAraNa para dRSTi nahI jAtI hai ? uttara --- (1) kumhAra, ghaDA / (2) cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi AhAravargaNA ke skadha / ( 3 ) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa Adi para dRSTi nahI jAtI hai / prazna 77 - kyA kumhAra kAraNa aura cAka, kolI, DaMDA hAtha

Page #95
( 86 ) Adi kaary| kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM maanaa| uttara-cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi AhAravargaNA ke skagha me se anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi kArya huA hai kumhAra se nahIM banA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko maanaa| aura kumhAra se huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahI maanaa| prazna-78-ghar3A kAraNa aura cApha, kolI, DaMDA, hAtha Adi kaary| kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA? 3 uttara-(prazna 77 ke anusAra uttara do) prazna 76-cAka, kolI, DaDA, hAtha Adi AhAravargaNA ke skaMSa kAraNa aura cAka, kolI, DaDA, hAtha Adi aary| kAraNAnuviSAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA? uttara-anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi kArya huA hai cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi AhAravargaNA ke skayo se nahI huA hai to kAraNAtuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko mAnA / aura cAka, kIlI, DaDA hAtha Adi AhAravargaNA ke skayo se huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni 'kAryANi ko nahIM maanaa| prazna 80-anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura cAka, kolI, uMDA, hAtha Adi kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA ? uttara-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se cAka, kolI, DaDA hAtha Adi kArya huA hai anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya

Page #96
( 60 ) nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se nahI huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko maanaa| aura anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se cAka, kolI, DaDA, hAtha Adi kArya huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahI maanaa| prazna 81-cAI ne cakalA, velana, tavA, hAtha Adi se roTI banAI isa vAkya meM se cakalA velana, tavA, hAtha Adi kArya para upAdAnaupAdeya samajhAiye? uttara prazna 56 se 80 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 82-maiM muMha se bolaa| isa vAkya me se 'muMha' kArya para upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara-prazna 56 se 80 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 83--maiM palaga para soyaa| isa vAkya me se 'palaga' kArya para upAdAna upAdeya samajhAiye? uttara- prazna 56 se 80 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 84-~maiMne meja para se kitAba utthaaii| isa vAkya me se 'meja' kArya para upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye? uttara-prazna 56 se 80 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 85-maiMne cAbI dvArA dukAna kholii| isa vAkya me se 'cAbI dvArA kArya para upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye? uttara-prazna 56 se 80 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 86-maiMne cArapAI para bistarA bichaayaa| isa vAkya me se 'cArapAI' kArya para upAdana-upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara-prazna 56 se 80 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 87-mene zarIra para se kapar3e utaare| isa vAkya me se 'zarIra' kArya para upAdana-upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara-prazna 56 se 80 taka ke anusAra uttara do|

Page #97
( 1 ) prazna 8 maiMne hAtho kI mehanata se rupayA kamAyA / isa vAkya meM se 'hAtho kI mehanata ' kArya para upAdAna - upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara - prazna 56 se 80 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 86 - maine prA~kha dvArA jJAna kiyA hai / isa vAkya me se 'A~kha ' kArya para upAdAna- upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara - prazna 56 se 80 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 60 - mujhe divyadhvani se jJAna kiyA hai isa vAkya meM se 'divyadhvani' kArya para upAdAna- upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara - prazna 51 se 80 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 61- maiMne mugadara ke dvArA kasarata ko / isa vAkya me se 'mugadara' ke kArya para upAdAna - upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara - prazna 56 se 80 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 62 - mere hAtha meM lakavA ho gayA hai / isa vAkya me se 'hAtha' kArya para upAdAna- upAdeya samajhAiye | uttara - prazna 56 se 80 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 63 - maine aujAro se sinenTa dvArA makAna bnaayaa| isa vAkya me se 'aujAro va simenTa' kArya para upAdAna - upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara - ( prazna 56 se 80 taka ke anusAra uttara do) prazna 64 - maine hAtho se jhADU lgaaii| isa vAkya me se 'hAyo" kArya para upAdAna - upAdeya samajhAIye ' uttara- ( prazna 56 se 80 taka ke anusAra uttara do) prazna 65 - maine mu~ha dvArA gAlI dI / isa vAkya me se 'mu~ha dvArA' kArya para upAdA upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara -- ( prazna 56 se 80 taka ke anusAra uttara do) prazna 66 - maine mu~ha ke dvArA miThAI khAI / isa vAkya me se 'ma~ha ke dvArA' kArya para upAdAna- upAdeya samajhAiye ?

Page #98
( 2 ) uttara- ( prazna 56 se 80 taka ke anusAra uttara do) kumhAra ne cAka, kIlo, uDA, hAtha Adi se ghar3A banAyA / "isa vAkya me se "ajJAnI kumhAra" para upAdAna - upAdeya ke 25 praznottaro ke dvArA spaSTIkaraNa prazna 67-ghaDA, cAka, kolI, DaMDA, hAtha Adi upAdAnakAraNa aura rAga upAdeya | kyA yaha upAdAna- upAdeya kA jJAna ThIka hai? uttara - bilkula ThIka nahI hai / kyoki yahA~ para cAritra guNa 'trikAlI upAdAnakAraNa aura rAga upAdeya hai / prazna 68- yadi koI catura ghaDA, cAka, kolI, DaDA, hAtha Adi upadAna kAraNa aura rAga upAdeya, aisA ho mAne to kyA doSa AtA hai ? uttara- ghaDA, cAka, kIlI, uDA, hAtha Adi naSTa hokara cAritra guNa bana jAve to aisA mAnA jA sakatA hai ki ghaDA, cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi upAdAna kAraNa aura rAga upAdeya / lekina aisA nahI ho sakatA / kyoki upAdAna- upAdeya tatsvarUpa me hI ( abhinna sattA vAle padArtho me hI) hotA hai| jinakI sattA-satva bhinna-bhinna haiM aise do padArthoM meM upAdAna - upAdeya nahI hotA hai / prazna 66-- jo ghaDA, cAka, kolI, DaDA, hAtha Adi nimitta kAraNo ko hI rAya kA saccA kAraNa mAnate hai / unhe jinavANI meM kina-kina nAmo se sambodhana kiyA hai ? uttara- ( 1 ) jo nimitta kAraNo se hI kArya kI utpatti mAnate haiM unheM samayasAra kalaza 55 me kahA hai ki "unakA sulaTanA durnivAra hai aura yaha unakA ajJAna moha andhakAra hai / " (2) jo nimittakAraNo se hI kArya kI utpatti mAnate hai unhe pravacanasAra gAthA 55 me kahA hai ki "vaha pada-pada para dhokhA khAtA hai / " ( 3 ) jo nimitta kAraNo se hI kArya kI utpatti mAnate hai / unhe puruSArtha siddhayupAya gAthA 6 me

Page #99
( 63 ) kahA hai ki "tasya dezanA nAsti arthAt vaha bhagavAna kI vANI sunane lAyaka nahIM hai|" (4) jo nimitta kAraNo se hI kArya kI utpatti mAnate haiM unhe AtmAvalokana me kahA hai ki "yaha unakA harAmajAdIpanA prazna 100-cAritraguNa trikAlA upAdAnakAraNa aura rAga upAdeya / isakA samajhane se kyA lAbha hamA? uttara-(1) ghaDA, cAka, kolI, DaDA, hAtha Adi nimitta kAraNo se rAga huA aisI khoTI mAnyatA kA abhAva ho jAtA hai| (2) AtmA meM ananta guNa hai| uname se cAritraguNa ko choDakara dUsare guNo se dRSTi haTa jAtI hai| (3) aba yahA~ para rAga ke lie mAtra trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa cAritra guNa kI tarapha dekhanA rahA / itanA lAbha humaa| prazna 101-koI catura prazna karatA hai ki cAritraguNa rAga kA kAraNa ho to siddho ko bhI rAga honA caahiye| ghar3A, cAka, kolI, DaMDA, hAya Adi nimittakAraNa ho to rAga ho| Apa kahate ho rAga kA (kArya kA) nimittakAraNoM se koI sambandha nahIM hai, to cAritraguNa upAdAnakAraNa aura rAga upaadey| yaha ApakI bAta jhUThI sAbita hotI hai ? uttara-are bhAI hamane cAritra guNa ko rAga kA upAdAna kAraNa kahA hai| vaha to ghaDA, cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi nimitta kAraNo se pRthak karane kI apekSA se kahA hai| vAstava me cAritra guNa bhI rAga kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahI hai|| prazna 102-cAritraguNa bhI rAga kA saccA upAdAnakAraNa nahIM hai to rAga kA saccA upAdAnakAraNa kauna hai ? uttara-cAritraguNa me anAdikAla se paryAyo kA pravAha calA A rahA hai| mAno dasa nambara para rAga huA to usame anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa rAga kA yahA~ para saccA upAdAna kAraNa hai| . .

Page #100
( 94 ) prazna 103 - cAritraguNa meM anAdikAla se paryAyo kA pravAha kyoM calA A rahA hai ? uttara- pratyeka dravya va guNa anAdiananta dhauvya rahatA huA eka paryAya kA vyaya, dUsarI paryAya kA utpAda eka hI samaya me svaya svata apane pariNamana svabhAva ke kAraNa karatA rahA hai, kara rahA hai aura bhaviSya meM karatA rahegA - aisA vastusvarUpa hai / isI kAraNa anAdikAla se cAritra guNa me paryAyoM kA pravAha calA A rahA hai| prazna 104 - anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nazvara kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa aura rAga upAdeya / isako mAnane se kyA lAbha huA ? uttara- ( 1 ) bhUta-bhaviSyat kI paryAyoM se dRSTi haTa gii| (2) cAritra guNa trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa thA, vaha bhI aba vyavahAra kAraNa ho gayA / (3) aba yahA~ para rAga ke lie mAtra anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kI tarapha dekhanA rahA / yaha -lAbha huA / prazna 105 - koI catura phira prazna karatA hai ki abhAva meM se bhAva kI utpatti nahIM hotI hai aura paryAya meM se paryAya nahIM AtI hai / aisA jinavANI meM kahA hai| phira yaha mAnanA ki anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura rAga upAdeya hai yaha ApakI bAta jhUThI sAbita hotI hai ? uttara - are bhAI---abhAva me se bhAva kI utpatti nahI hotI hai aura paryAya me se paryAya nahI AtI hai yaha bAta jinavANI ko bilkula ThIka hai / parantu hamane to kArya se pahile kaunasI paryAya hotI hai / usakI apekSA rAga kA anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara ko kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kahA hai parantu anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya no nambara bhI rAga kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahI hai / prazna 106 - anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara rAga kA

Page #101
J ( 65 ) saccA upAdAnakAraNa nahIM hai to kaisA kAraNa hai aura kaisA pA nahIM hai / uttara - anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nI nambara rAga kA abhAva 'kAraNa hai va kAla sUcaka hai / kintu kArya kA janaka nahI hai / prazna 107 - anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa bhI rAga kA saccA upAdAnakAraNa nahIM hai to vAstava me rAga kA saccA upAdAnakAraNa kauna hai ? uttara - vAstava me usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI rAga kA saccA upAdAna karaNa hai / 108 - vAstava me usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa hI rAga kA saccA upAdAnakAraNa hai / aisA mAnane se kyA lAbha huA ? uttara - ( 1 ) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kI tarapha bhI dekhanA nahI rahA / (2) ava eka mAtra rAga ke lie usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kI tarapha hI dekhanA rahA / yaha lAbha huA / prazna 106-- ( 1 ) cAritraguNa trikAlI upAdAnakAraNa aura rAga upAdeya / (2) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa aura rAga upAdeya / (6) upa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA rAga kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa aura rAga upAdeya / aimA zAstroM meM batAyA / parantu itanA lambA-lambA jhagaDA karane se kyA lAbha thA ? kaha dete ki kArya usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se hI hotA hai| ? uttara- ( 1 ) nimitta kAraNo se pRthaka karane kI apekSA se cAritra guNa trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa ko batAnA Avazyaka thA / ( 2 ) bhaviSyat kI paryAyo se pRthak karane kI apekSA se aura abhAva kAraNa kA jJAna karAne ke lie anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya no

Page #102
kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa ko batAnA Avazyaka thaa| (3) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nI nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se pRthaka karane kI [apekSA se aura kArya ke saccA kAraNa kA jJAna karAne ke lie usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa ko batAnA Avazyaka thA / isalie tIno kAraNo kA saccA jJAna karAne ke lie zAstro me itanA lamvA-lambA karake samajhAyA hai| prazna 110-~-rAga- usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna karaNa se huA hai isako mAnane se kyA lAbha huA ? uttara-jaise-rAga-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upA. dAna kAraNa se huA hai| vaise hI vizva me jitane bhI kArya haiM ve saba usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se hI ho cuke hai, ho rahe haiM aura bhaviSya me hote rahege / aisA kevalI ke samAna saccA jJAna ho jAtA hai| prazna 111-vizva me jitane bhI kArya haiM ve saba usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se hI ho cuke haiM, ho rahe haiM aura bhaviSya meM hote rhege| aisA kevalI ke samAna saccAjJAna hote hI kyA-kyA apUrva kArya dekhane me AtA hai ? uttara--(1) anAdikAla kI para me karUM-dharUM kI khoTI buddhi kA abhAva honaa| (2) dRSTi apane jJAyaka svabhAva para aanaa| (3) samyagdarzanAdi kI prApti hokara krama se vRddhi karake mokSa lakSmI kA nAtha honaa| (4) mithyAtvAdi sasAra ke pA~ca kAraNo kA abhAva honaa| (5) dravya-kSetra-kAla-bhava-bhAvarUpa pacaparAvartana kA abhAva hokara paca parameSTiyo me unakI ginatI honaa| prazna 112-vizva meM pratyeka kArya usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se hI hotA hai| tana kauna-kauna sI cAra bAteM eka sAtha eka hI samaya meM niyama se hotI hai ? uttara-(1) usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa

Page #103
( 67 ) ( utpAda) (2) anantarapUrvaM kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa (vyaya) (3) trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa ( dhauvya ) ( 4 ) nimitta kAraNa / yaha cAra bAteM pratyeka kArya me eka hI sAtha eka hI kAla me niyama se hotI haiM / [ pravacanasAra gAthA 65 ] prazna 113 - usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se hI kArya ko utpatti hotI hai| kyA yaha nirapekSa hai ? uttara - haoN, kArya svaya para kI apekSA nahI rakhatA hai isalie nirapekSa hai aura apanI apekSA rakhatA hai isalie sApekSa hai / pAtra bhavya jIvo ko prathama nirapekSa siddhi karanI cAhie / phira jo kArya huA -- usakA abhAva rUpa kAraNa kauna hai / trikAlI kAraNa kona hai / aura nimitta kAraNa kauna hai| ina bAto kA jJAna karanA cAhie kyoki kArya ke samaya cAro vAte niyama se hotI haiM / prazna 114 - rAga -- usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se huA hai| aisA mAnane se kisa-kisa kAraNa para dRSTi nahIM jAtIM hai ? uttara- (1) ghaDA, cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi / (2) cAritra guNa / (3) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa Adi para dRSTi nahI jAtI hai / prazna 115 - kyA ghaDA kAraNa aura rAga kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyI kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA / uttara - AtmA ke cAritra guNa me se anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se rAga huA hai ghaDe ke kAraNa nahI to kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko mAnA / aura ghar3e ke kAraNa rAga huA hai to - kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahI mAnA / prazna 116 - cAka kAraNa aura rAga kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA ?

Page #104
( 18 ) uttara-prazna 115 ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 117-kolI kAraNa aura rAga kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kava nahIM mAnA ? uttara-prazna 115 ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 118-DaDA kAraNa aura rAga kaary| kAraNAnuvidhiAyIni kAryANi ko kava mAnA aura kaba nahI mAnA? uttara-prazna 115 ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 116-hAtha kAraNa aura rAga kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA ? uttara-prazna 115 ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 120-cAritraguNa kAraNa aura rAga kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM kAnA? / uttara-anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa nau nambara kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se rAga huA hai| cAritraguNa ke kAraNa nahI to kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko maanaa| aura cAritraguNa ke kAraNa rAga huA to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahI maanaa|| prazna 121-~-anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa aura rAga kaary| kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kava mAnA aura kaba nahIM maanaa|| uttara-rAga usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se huA hai anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se nahI to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko mAnA aura anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara ke kAraNa rAga huA to karaNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahI maanaa| prazna 122- bAI ne cakalA, belana se roTI banAI-isa vAkya meM se 'bAI ke rAga' para upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye ?

Page #105
( 66 ) uttara-prazna 17 se 121 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 123-maiM muMha se bolA / isa vAkya me se 'maiM ke rAga para' upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye? uttara-prazna 67 se 121 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 124-mai palaga para soyaa| isa vAkya me se 'maiM ke rAga para' upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara-prazna 67 se 121 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 125-maine meja para se kitAba utthaaii| isa vAkya meM se mere rAga para upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara-prazna 67 se 121 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 126-maiMne aujAro se alamArI bnaaii| isa vAkya se mere rAga para upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara-prazna 67 se 121 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 127-maiMne cAbI dvArA dukAna kholii| isa vAkya me se mere rAga para upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara-prazna 67 se 121 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 128-maiM ne cArapAI para bistarA bichaayaa| isa vAkya me se mere rAga para upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara-prazna 67 se 121 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 126-maiMne zarIra para kapar3e phine| isa vAkya me se mere rAga para upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara-prazna 67 se 121 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 130-maiMne hAtho se rupayA kmaayaa| isa vAkya me se mere rAga para apAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye? uttara-prazna 67 se 121 taka ke anusAra uttara do|| prazna 131-mujhe A~kha dvArA jJAna huaa| isa vAkya me se mere rAga para upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye ?

Page #106
( 100 ) uttara-prazna 67 se 121 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 132-mujhe divyadhyAna se jJAna huaa| isa vAkya me se 'mere rAga para' upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye? uttara--prazna 67 se 121 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 133-maiMne mugadara ke dvArA kasarata kii| isa vAkya meM se mere rAga para upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye? uttara-prazna 67 se 121 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 134-mujhe lakavA ho gayA hai isa vAkya meM se mere rAga para upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye? uttara-prazna 97 se 121 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 135-maine aujAro se simenTa dvArA makAna bnaayaa| isa vAkya me se "mere rAga para" upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara-prazna 67 se 121 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 136-maiMne hAtho se jhADU lgaaii| isa vAkya me se 'mere rAga para' upapadAna-uAdeya samajhAiye? / uttara-prazna 67 se 121 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 137-maiMne muMha dvArA gAlI dii| isa vAkya meM se 'mere rAga para' upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara-prazna 67 se 121 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 138-maiMne muMha ke dvArA miThAI khaaii| isa vAkya me se 'mere rAga para' upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara-prazna 67 se 121 taka ke anusAra uttara do| kumhAra ne cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha Adi se car3A banAyA-isa vAkya meM se jJAnI kumhAra ke jJAna para upAdAna-upAdeya kA 25 praznottaro ke dvArA spaSTIkaraNa prazna 136-ghar3A, cAka, kIlI, DaMDA hAtha, rAga upAdAnakAraNa aura jJAna upaadey| kyA yaha upAdAna-upAdeya kA jJAna ThIka hai ?

Page #107
( 101 ) uttara - bilkula ThIka nahI hai kyoki yahA~ para AtmA kA jJAna trikAlI upAdAnakAraNa aura jJAna upAdeya hai / guNa prazna 140 -- yadi koI catura ghaDA, cAka, kIlo, DaMDA, hAtha, rAga upAdAnakAraNa aura jJAna upaadey| aisA hI mAne to kyA doSa AtA hai ? uttara- ghaDA, cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha, rAga naSTa hokara AtmA kA jJAnaguNa vana jAve to aisA mAnA jA sakatA hai ki ghaDA, cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha, rAga upAdAnakAraNa aura jJAna upAdeya / lekina aisA nahI ho sakatA / kyoki upAdAna - upAdeya tatsvarUpa me hI ( abhinna sattA vAle padArtha me hI ) hotA hai / jinakI sattA sattva bhinna-bhinna haiM aise do padArthoM me upAdAna - upAdeya nahI hotA hai / prazna 141 - ghar3A, cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAya, rAga Adi nimitta kAraNo ko hI jJAna kA saccA kAraNa mAnate haiM unhe jinavANI meM kina-kina nAmo se sambodhana kiyA hai ? uttara - ( 1 ) jo nimittakAraNo se hI kArya kI utpatti mAnate haiM unheM samayasAra kalaza 55 me kahA hai ki "unakA sulaTanA durnivAra hai aura yaha unakA ajJAna moha andhakAra hai / " (2) jo nimitta kAraNo se hI kArya kI utpatti mAnate haiM unhe pravacanasAra gAthA 55 me kahA hai ki "vaha pada-pada para ghokhA khAtA hai / " (3) jo nimitta kAraNo se hI kArya kI utpatti mAnate haiM unhe puruSArtha siddhayupAya gAthA 6 me kahA hai ki " tasya dezanA nAsti arthAta vaha bhagavAna kI vANI sunane lAyaka nahI hai / " ( 4 ) jo nimittakAraNo se hI kArya kI utpatti mAnate haiM unhe AtmAvalokana me kahA hai ki "yaha unakA harAmajAdIpanA hai / " 2 prazna 142 - AtmA kA jJAnaguNa trikAlI upAdAnakAraNa aura jJAna upAdeya isako samajhane se kyA lAbha huA uttara- (1) ghaDA, cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha, rAga Adi nimitta

Page #108
( 102 ) kAraNo se jJAna huA, aisI khoTI mAnyatA kA abhAva ho jAtA hai| (2) AtmA me anantaguNa hai / so jJAna guNa ko choDakara bAkI guNo se dRSTi haTa jAtI hai / (3) aba yahA~ para jJAna ke lie mAtra trikAlI upAdAnakAraNa jJAna guNa kI tarapha dekhanA rhaa| itanA lAbha huaa| prazna 143-koI catura prazna karatA hai ki-ghar3A, cAka, kIlI, DaMDA, hAtha, rAga Adi nimittakAraNa hoM to isa sambandhI jJAna hove| Apa kahate ho jJAna kA nimitta kAraNoM se koI bhI sambandha nahIM hai| to AtmA kA jJAnaguNa trikAlI upAdAnakAraNa aura jJAna upAdeya / yaha ApakI vAta jhUThI sAbita hotI hai ? uttara-are bhAI, hamane AtmA ke jJAnaguNa ko jJAna kA upAdAna kAraNa kahA hai| vaha to ghaDA, cAka, kIlI, DaDA, hAtha, rAga Adi nimittakAraNo se pRthak karane kI apekSA se kahA hai| vAstava me AtmA kA jJAna guNa bhI jJAna kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahIM hai| prazna 144-AtmA kA jJAna guNa bhI jJAna kA saccA apAdAna kAraNa nahIM hai tozAna kA saccA upAdAnakaraNa kauna hai ? uttara-AtyA ke jJAna guNa me anAdikAla se paryAyo kA pravAha calA A rahA hai| mAno dasa nambara para isa sambandhI jJAna huA to usame anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa yahA~ para jJAna kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa hai| prazna 145-- jJAnaguNa meM anAdikAla se paryAyoM kA prabhAva kyoM calA A rahA hai ? uttara-pratyeka dravya va guNa anAdiananta dhrauvya rahatA huA, eka paryAya kA vyaya aura dUsarI paryAya kA utpAda eka hI samaya me svaya svata apane pariNamana svabhAva ke kAraNa karatA rahA hai, karatA hai aura bhaviSya me karatA rhegaa| aisA vastu svarUpa hai| isI kAraNa anAdikAla se jJAna guNa me paryAyo kA pravAha calA A rahA hai / prazna 146-anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika

Page #109
1 ( 103 ) upAdAnakaraNa aura jJAna upAdeya / isako mAnane se kyA lAbha huA ? uttara- ( 1 ) bhUta-bhaviSyat kI paryAyo kI dRSTi haTa gaI / (2) jJAna guNa jo trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa thA, vaha bhI aba vyavahAra kAraNa ho gayA / (3) aba yahA~ para jJAna ke lie mAtra anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kI tarapha dekhanA rahA / prazna 147 - koI catura phira prazna karatA hai ki abhAva meM se bhAva kI utpatti nahIM hotI haiM aura paryAya me se paryAya nahIM AtI hai aisA jinavANI meM kahA hai / phira yaha mAnanA kI anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya tau nambara kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa aura jJAna upAdeya hai, yaha ApakI bAta jhUThI sAbita hai ? uttara - are bhAI abhAva me se bhAva kI utpatti nahI hotI hai aura paryAya me se paryAya nahI AtI hai yaha bAta jinavANI kI bilkula ThIka hai / parantu hamane to kAryaM se pahile kauna sI paryAya hotI hai usakI apekSA se anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara ko jJAna kA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kahA hai / parantu anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara bhI jJAna kA saccA kAraNa nahI hai / prazna 148 -- anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara jJAna hone kA saccA uhAdAnakAraNa nahIM hai to kaisA kAraNa hai aura kaisA kAraNa nahIM hai ? uttara - anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara jJAna kA abhAva - rUpa kAraNa hai va kAla sUcaka hai parantu kArya kA janaka nahI hai / prazna 146 - anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa bhI jJAna kA saccA kAraNa nahI hai to vAstava me jJAna kA saccA upAdAnakAraNa kauna hai ? uttara - vAstava me usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI jJAna kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa hai /

Page #110
( 104 ) prazna 150-vAstava meM usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa kAraNa hI jJAna kA saccA upAdAnakAraNa hai| aisA mAnane se kyA lAbha huA? uttara-(1) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kI tarapha jJAna ke lie dekhanA nahI rahA / (2) aba ekamAtra jJAna ke lie usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kI tarapha hI dekhanA rahA / yaha lAbha huaa| prazna 151--(1) AtmA kA jJAnaguNa trikAlI upAdAnakAraNa aura jJAna upaadey| (2) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa aura jJAna upaadey| (3) usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA jJAna kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa aura jJAna upAdeya / aisA zAstroM me vtaayaa| parantu itanA lambA-lambA jhagaDA karane se kyA lAbha thA? kaha dete ki kArya usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se hI hotA hai ? uttara-(1) nimitta kAraNoM se pRthaka karane kI apekSA se trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa jJAna guNa ko batAnA Avazyaka thaa| (2) bhUta-bhaviSyat paryAyo se pRthaka karane kI apekSA se aura abhAva rUpa kAraNa kA jJAna karAne ke lie anantarapUrvakSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa nau nambara ko batAnA Avazyaka thaa| (3) anantarapUrva kSaNavatI paryAya kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se pRthaka karane kI apekSA se kArya ke sacce kAraNa kA jJAna karAne ke lie usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa jJAna ko batAnA Avazyaka thaa| isalie tIno kAraNo kA saccA jJAna karAne ke lie zAstro me itanA lambAlambA karake samajhAyA hai| prazna 152-jJAna usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upA. dAnakAraNa se huA hai| isako mAnane se kyA lAbha huA? , uttara-jaise-jJAna-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna

Page #111
( 105 ) kAraNa se huA hai| vaise hI vizva me jitane bhI kArya haiM ve saba usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se hI ho cuke hai, ho rahe haiM aura bhaviSya me hote rahege / aisA kevalI ke samAna saccA jJAna ho jAtA bhaviSya me hoNaka upAdAnamA prazna 153--vizva meM jitane bhI kArya haiM ve saba usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se ho cuke haiM, ho rahe haiM aura bhaviSya me hote rhege| aisA kevalI ke samAna saccA jJAna hote hI kyA-kyA apUrva kArya dekhane meM AtA hai ? uttara-(1) anAdikAla kI para me karUM-dharU' kI khoTI mAnyatA kA abhAva honA / (2) dRSTi apane jJAyaka svabhAva para aanaa| (3) samyagdarzanAdi kI prApti hokara krama se vRddhi hokara mokSa lakSmI kA nAtha honaa| (4) mithyAtvAdi sasAra ke pAca kAraNo kA abhAva honA / (5) dravya kSetra-kAla-bhava-bhAvarUpa pacaparAvartana kA abhAva hokara pacaparameSTiyo me unakI ginatI honaa| 154--vizva me pratyeka kArya usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se hI hotA hai| taba kauna-kaunasI cAra bAteM eka sAtha eka hI samaya meM niyama se hotI haiM ? uttara-(1) usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa (utpAda) (2) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa (vyaya) (3) trikAlI upAdAnakAraNa (dhrauvya) (4) nimittkaarnn| ye cAra bAteM pratyeka kArya meM eka hI sAtha eka hI kAla me niyama se hotI haiM / (pravacanasAra gAthA 65) prazna 155-usa samaya paryAya ko yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se hI kArya kI utpatti hotI hai| kyA yaha nirapekSa hai ? uttara-hA~ kArya svaya para kI apekSA nahIM rakhatA hai isalie nirapekSa hai, aura apanI apekSA rakhatA hai isalie sApekSa hai / pAtra bhavya jIvo ko prathama nirapekSa siddhi karanI caahie| phira jo kArya huA,

Page #112
( 106 ) usakA abhAvarUpa kAraNa kauna hai, trikAlIkAraNa kauna hai aura nimitta kAraNa kauna hai| ina bAto kA jJAna karanA cAhie, kyoki kArya ke samaya cAro bAteM niyama se hotI hai| prazna 156-jJAna-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se huA hai aisA mAnane se kisa-kisa kAraNa para dRSTi nahIM jAtI hai ? uttara--(1) ghaDA, cAka, kolI, DaDA, hAtha, raag| (2) jJAna gunn| (3) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa nau nambara Adi kAraNo para dRSTi nahI jAtI hai| prazna 157-ghaDA kAraNa aura jJAna kaary| kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA? uttara--AtmA ke jJAnaguNa me se anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa nau nambara kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA se jJAna huA hai ghaDe ke kAraNa nahI to kAraNAnuvidhAyInI kAryANi ko mAnA aura jJAna ghaDe ke kAraNa huA to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahI maanaa| prazna 158-cAka kAraNa aura jJAna kaary| kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA? uttara-prazna 157 ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 156-kIlI kAraNa aura jJAna kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA? uttara-prazna 157 ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 160-DaMDA kAraNa aura jJAna kaary| kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA? uttara-prazna 157 ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 161-rAga kAraNa aura jJAna kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kava mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA ?

Page #113
( 107 ) uttara-prazna 157 ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 162-jJAnaguNa kAraNa aura jJAna kaary| kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA? uttara-anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa nau nambara kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se jJAna huA hai jJAna guNa ke kAraNa nahI to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko mAnA aura jJAnaguNa se jJAna huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahI maanaa| prazna 163-anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa aura jAnakArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kava mAnA aura kana nahIM mAnA ? uttara-jJAna-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se huA hai anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa nau nambara se nahI to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko maanaa| aura anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa nau nambara se jJAna huA to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahI maanaa| prazna 164-bAI ne cakale belana se roTI bnaaii| isa vAkya me se 'bAI ke jJAna para' upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye? uttara-prazna 136 se 163 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 165--maine muha se bolA / isa vAkya me se 'jJAna para' upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye? uttara-prazna 136 se 163 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 166-maiM palaga para soyA isa vAkya me se 'jJAna para' upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara-prazna 136 se 163 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 167-maiMne meja para se kitAba utthaaii| isa vAkya meM se 'jJAna para' upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye?

Page #114
( 108 ) uttara-prazna 136 se 163 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 168-maiMne aujAro se alamArI bnaaii| isa vAkya meM se 'jJAna para' upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye ? uttara-prazna 136 se 163 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 166-~mene cAbI dvArA dukAna kholii| isa vAkya me se "jJAna para' upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye ? / uttara-prazna 136 se 163 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 170-maiMne cArapAI para bistarA bichaayaa| isa vAkya me se "jJAna para' upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye? uttara-prazna 136 se 163 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 171-maiMne zarIra para kapar3e phre| isa vAkya meM se 'jJAna 'para' upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye? uttara-prazna 136 se 163 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 172~-maiMne hAtho se rupayA maayaa| isa vAkya meM se 'jJAna 'para' upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye? uttara-prazna 136 se 163 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 173-maine mugadara ke dvArA kasarata kii| isa vAkya me se 'jJAna para' upAdAna-upAdeya samajhAiye? uttara-prazna 136 se 163 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 174-kArya kisa prakAra hotA hai? uttara--kAraNa kA anusaraNa karake hI kArya hotA hai| prazna 175-~kAraNa kA anusaraNa karake hI kArya hotA hai, aisA kahA~ kahA hai ? uttara-(1) "kAraNAnuvidhAyitvAdeva kAryANA" arthAta kAraNa kA anusaraNa karake hI kArya hotA hai| (2) kAraNa-anuvidhAyitvAt kAryANA arthAt kAraNa jaise kArya hote haiN| [samayasAra gA0 130131 kI TIkA me] (3) "kAraNAnuvidhAyIni karyANi" kAraNa jaisA

Page #115
( 106 ) hI kArya hotA hai| [samayasAra gA068 kI TIkA me] (4) "tehi puNo pajjAyA" dravya aura guNo se paryAye hotI haiN| [pravacanasAra gA063] (5) guNo ke vizeSa kArya (pariNamana) ko paryAya kahate haiN| prazna 176-kArya ke paryAyavAcI zabda kyA-kyA haiM ? uttara-kArya ko karma, avasthA, paryAya, hAlata, dazA, pariNAma, pariNati, vyApya, upAdeya, naimittika Adi kahA jAtA hai| prazna 177-kAraNa kA anusaraNa karake hI kArya hotA hai| isameM anekAnta kisa prakAra ghaTita hotA hai ? uttara-kAraNa kA anusaraNa karake hI kArya hotA hai para se nahI yaha anekAnta hai| prazna 178-kAraNa kA anusaraNa karake hI kArya hotA hai para se nahIM, isame kauna se kAraNa kI bAta hai ? uttara-vAstava me "usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa" kI bAta hai| prazna 176-"kAraNa kA anusaraNa karake hI kArya hotA hai para se nahIM", "para me" kauna-kauna se kAraNa Ate haiM ? uttara-(1) nimittakAraNa, (2) trikAlI upAdAnakAraNa, (3) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa / yaha saba para me Ate haiN| (guru se jJAna huA-isa vAkya para-(1) jJAna (2) paDhAnA, (3) rAga, (4) guru ke jJAna para 18-18 prazna upAdAna-upAdeya ke lagAkara vahA~ se zurU karo) prazna 180-kyA guru kAraNa aura jJAna kArya, kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko mAnA? uttara-bilkula nahI mAnA, kyoki AtmA ke jJAna guNa me se anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA abhAva karake

Page #116
( 110 ) usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se jJAna huA hai guru se nahI, tava "kAraNAnuvidhAyinI kAryANi" ko maanaa| prazna 181-kyA jJAna kArya aura indriyA~ kAraNa, kAraNAna vidhAyoni kAryANi ko mAnA ? uttara-nahIM mAnA, kyoki AtnA ke jJAna guNa me se anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se jJAna huA hai indriyo se nahI, taba kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko maanaa| prazna 182-kyA jJAnAvaraNIya karma kA kSayopazama kAraNa aura jJAna kArya, kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko mAnA ? uttara-nahI mAnA, kyoki AtmA ke jJAna guNa me se anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAnakAra kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se jJAna huA hai jJAnAvaraNIya karma ke kSayopazama ke kAraNa nahI, taba kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko maanaa| prazna 183-kyA zubhabhAva kAraNa aura jJAna kArya, kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko mAnA ? uttara-nahI mAnA, kyoki AtmA ke jJAna guNa me se anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se jJAna huA zubhabhAva ke kAraNa nahIkAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko mAnA / prazna 184-kyA zraddhA guNa kAraNa aura jJAna kArya, kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko mAnA ? uttara-nahI mAnA, kyoki AtmA ke jJAna guNa me se anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se jJAna huA zraddhA guNa ke kAraNa nahIM-taba kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko mAnA /

Page #117
* ( 111 ) prazna 185 - kyA AtmA kAraNa aura jJAna kArya, kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko mAnA ? uttara- nahI mAnA, kyoki AtmA me to ananta guNa haiM isalie jJAna me se anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se jJAna huA AtmA se nahI - tava kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko mAnA / prazna 186 - kyA jJAna guNa kAraNa aura jJAna kArya, kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko mAnA ? uttara- nahI mAnA, kyoki jJAna guNa to trikAla hai - jJAnarUpa kArya eka samaya kA hai / isalie anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se jJAna huA trikAla jJAna guNa ke kAraNa nahI - tava kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko mAnA / prazna 187 - kyA anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura jJAna kArya, kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko mAnA ? uttara- nahI mAnA, kyoki kabhI abhAva me se bhAva kI utpatti nahI hotI hai / isalie usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA jJAna kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura jJAna kArya, taba kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko mAnA / prazna 188 - jJAna usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se huA, aisA mAnane se kisa-kisa se dRSTi haTa gaI ? uttara - (1) atyanta bhinna deva, guru, zAstra se, (2) A~kha nAka Adi indriyo se, (3) jJAnAvaraNIya karma ke kSayopazamAdi se, (4) zubha bhAvo se (5) zraddhA cAritra - Ananda Adi ananta guNo se, (6) abheda dravya se, (7) jJAna guNa se, (8) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se, Adi sabase dRSTi haTa gaI / prazna 186 - aba vartamAna jJAna ke lie kahA~ dekhanA rahA ?

Page #118
( 112 ) uttara-vAstava meM usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI jJAna hone kA saccA kAraNa hai usakI ora dekhanA rahA / (darzana mohanIya ke kSayopazama se kSayopazama samyaktva huA-isa vAkya meM se (1) kSayopazamasamyaktva (2) darzanamohanIya ke kSayopazama para 18-18 prazna upAvAna-upAdeya ke lagAkara yahAM se zurU karo) prazna 190-kSayopazamika samyaktva huA, usakA saccA kAraNa kauna hai ? uttara-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa hI kSayopazamika samyaktva kA saccA kAraNa hai| prazna 161-kSayopazamika samyaktva kA saccA kAraNa usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI hai| aisA jAnane se phisa-kisa se dRSTi haTa gaI tathA pratyeka para kAraNAna vidhAyoni kAryANi ko kava mAnA aura kaba nahIM maanaa| lagAkara samajhAiye? uttara-(1) atyanta bhinna deva, guru, zAstra se, (2) darzana mohanIya ke kSayopazamAdi se, (3) AtmA se (4) jJAna-cAritra Adi anata guNo se, (5) zubhabhAvo se, (6) zraddhAguNa jo trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa hai usase, (7) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aupazamika samyaktva se, dRSTi haTa gii| prazna 162-kSayopazamika samyaktva kA dravya, guNa aura abhAvarUpa paryAya kA nAma batAo? uttara-(1) AtmA dravya hai, (2) zraddhA guNa hai, (3) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa aupazamika samyaktva abhAva rUpa paryAya hai| (kevalajJAnAvaraNI ke abhAva se kevalajJAna huA-isa vAkya me se (1) phevalajJAna (2) kevalajJAnAvaraNI ke abhAva para 18-18 prazna upAdAna-upAdeya ke lagAkara yahA~ se zurU karo)

Page #119
( 113 ) prazna 163 - kevalajJAna kA saccA kAraNa kauna hai? uttara - usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI kevalajJAna kA saccA kAraNa hai / prazna 194 - usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI kevalajJAna kA saccA kAraNa hai to kevalajJAna kA saccA kAraNa kauna-kauna nahIM hai / tathA pratyeka para ' kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi' ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA -lagAkara samajhAiye ? uttara - (1) cauthA kAla (2) kevalajJAnAvaraNI karma kA abhAva (3) vajravRSabhanArAca sahanana ( 4 ) AtmA ( 5 ) jJAna guNa ko choDakara vAkI ananta guNa (6) jJAna guNa (7) zuklalezyA Adi manda kaSAya kA zubhabhAva ( 8 ) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa bhAva zrutajJAna yaha saba kevalajJAna ke sacce kAraNa nahI haiM / prazna 165 - kevalajJAna kA trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa, abhAvarUpa upAdAna kAraNa kauna hai ? uttara - AtmA kA jJAnaguNa trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa hai aura anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa bhAvazrutajJAna abhAvarUpa kAraNa hai aura kevalajJAna kArya hai / ( kumhAra ne ghaDA banAyA - isa vAkya me se (1) ghaDA (2) kumhAra kA rAga para 18-18 prazna upAdAna - upAdeya ke lagAkara yahA se zurU karo ) prazna 166 - kumhAra ne ghaDA banAyA- isame kumhAra kAraNa aura ghaDA banA kArya, 'kAraNAna vidhAyIni kAryANi' ko kaba mAnA ? uttara-- nahI mAnA, kyoki AhAravargaNA rUpa miTTI me se anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa piNDa kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se ghaDA vanA, kumhAra Adi se nahI tava kAraNAnuvidhAyInI kAryANi ko mAnA / prazna 167 - ghar3A usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upA

Page #120
( 114 ) dAna kAraNa hai aura jo ghar3A banA vaha kArya hai| vaha 166veM prazna ke uttara me batAyA 'kumhAra Adi se nahIM / kumhAra Adi' me kaunakauna haiM / jinase ghaDA nahIM banA tathA pratyeka para 'kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA / lagAkara samajhAiye? uttara-(1) kumhAra kA rAga, (2) hAtha-kIlI-cAka-inDA, (3) ahAravargaNA ko choDakara vAkI vargaNAo, (4) miTTI (5) piNDa yaha sava kumhAra Adi me Ate haiM inase baDA naho vnaa| ekamAtra usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se ghaDA bnaa| (ATho karmo ke abhAva se mokSa huA-isa vAkya me se (1) mokSa (2) ATho karmoM ke abhAva para 18-18prazna upAdAna upAdeya ke lagAkara yahAM se zurU karo) prazna 168-'jJAna kriyAbhyAm mokSa.' isame aisA lagatA hai ki AtmA kA jJAna aura zarIra kI kriyA upAdAna kAraNa aura mokSa kArya, 'kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi' ko mAnA? uttara-"kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi" ko vilkula nahIM mAnA kyoki usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA mokSa kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura mokSa kArya hai| prazna 196-mokSa kA trikAlIutpAdana kAraNa aura abhAva rUpa upAdAna kAraNa kauna hai ? uttara-AtmA trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa hai aura anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdA kAraNa 14vA~ guNasthAna abhAvarUpa kAraNa hai| prazna 200-mokSa kA kAraNa kauna-kauna nahIM hai tathA pratyeka para 'kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM maanaa| lagAkara samajhAiye ? uttara-(1) audaarikshriir| (2) dravyakarma kA abhAva / (3) vajavRSabhanArAca mahanana / (4) cauthA kAla / (5) aatmaa| (6) anantara

Page #121
( 115 ) pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa 14vA~ guNasthAna / ( 7 ) AtmA kA jJAna aura zarIra kI kriyA iname koI bhI mokSa kA kAraNa nahI hai / eka mAtra usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA mokSa kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura mokSa huA yaha kArya / prazna 201 - to 'jJAna kriyAbhyAm mokSaH' aisA kyoM kahA jAtA hai ? uttara - yahA~ para jJAna arthAt samyagjJAna aura kriyA arthAta samyaka cAritra dono milakara mokSa jAno / zarIra Azrita upadeza, upavAsAdika kriyA aura zubharAgarUpa vyavahAra ko mokSamArga nA jAno yaha bAta batAI / aura jo "jJAna kriyAbhyAm mokSa " kA artha jJAna aura zarIra kI kriyA mokSa hai aisA artha karate hai vaha artha jhUThA hai| prazna 202 - AtmA kA jJAna aura zarIra kI kriyA upAdAna kAraNa aura mokSa kArya, yaha isa sUtra kA artha galata kyo hai ? uttara - 'jJAna kriyAbhyAm mokSa' kA jo artha zarIra kI kriyA aura AtmA kA jJAna / aisA karate haiM unheM vyAkaraNa kA bhI jJAna nahI hai, kyoki jJAna eka aura zarIra kI kriyA yaha ananta pudgala paramA o kI kriyA haiM / "kriyAbhyAm dvivacana hai, yadi yahA~ para 'bhyAm ' ke badale me tIsarI vahuvacana zabda hotA to ThIka hotA, parantu yahA~ para 'bhyAm ' hai yaha do ko batAtA hai / isalie jo jJAna aura zarIra kI kriyA yaha mokSa hai aisA artha karate hai vaha jhUThe hai / isalie pAtra jIvo ko yahA~ para jJAna kA artha samyagjJAna aura kriyA kA artha samyak cAritra hai tathA ina dono ko milAkara mokSa jAno aura zarIra kI kriyA ko mokSamArga nA jAno, aisA jJAniyo kA Adeza hai / ( darzanamohanIya ke abhAva se kSAyika samyaktva huA isa vAkya me se ( 1 ) kSAyika samyaktva (2) darzanamohanIya ke abhAva

Page #122
( 116 ) para 18-18 prazna upAdAna- upAdeya ke lagAkara phira yahA~ se zurU karo 1 ) prazna - 203 - 'darzana mohanIya karma kA abhAva kAraNa aura kSAyika samyaktva kArya' kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko mAnA ? uttara- nahI mAnA, kyoki trikAlI upAdAnakAraNa zraddhA guNa hai aura kSAyika samyaktva kArya hai / prazna 204 - koI catura darzana mohanIya karma kA abhAva kAraNa aura kSAyika samyaktva kArya aisA kahe to kyA doSa AtA hai ? uttara - darzana mohanIya ke abhAva ko jIva kA zraddhA guNa vanane kA prasaMga upasthita hovegA, yaha dopa AtA hai / prazna 205 - kSAyika samyaktva kA saccA kAraNa kauna kauna nahIM rahA ? uttara - usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI saccA kAraNa hai, kyoki para to kAraNa hai hI nahI / zraddhA guNa aura anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa kSayopazama samyaktva bhI saccA kAraNa nahI hai / rahA aura prazna 206 - kSAyika samyaktva kA saccA kAraNa 'usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI hai aisA jAnane se kina-kina kAraNoM se vRSTi haTa gaI tathA pratyeka para 'kAraNAtuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA / lagAkara samajhAiye ? uttara- (1) deva-guru / (2) darzana mohanIya kA abhAva / (3) zraddhA guNa, (4) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kSayopazama samyaktva, ina saba se dRSTi haTa gaI / prazna 207 - kyA guru kAraNa aura jJAna kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko mAnA ? uttara -- prazna 203 se 206 taka ke anusAra uttara do /

Page #123
( 117 ) prazna 208 - kyA bAI kAraNa aura roTI kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko mAnA ? uttara - prazna 203 se 206 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 206 -- kyA paisA kAraNa aura sukha kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko mAnA ? uttara - prazna 203 se 206 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 210 - kyA karmoM kA abhAva kAraNa aura mokSa kAryaM / kAraNAtuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko mAnA ? uttara - prazna 203 se 206 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 211 - kyA gAlI kAraNa aura krodha kArya / kAraNAnuvighAyoni kAryANi ko mAnAM ? uttara - prazna 203 se 206 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 212 -- kyA kevaladarzana kAraNa aura kevala darzanAvaraNI karma kA abhAva kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko mAnA ? uttara - prazna 203 se 206 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 213 - kyA paisA nA honA kAraNa aura duHkha kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko mAnA ? uttara - prazna 203 se 206 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 214- kyA karma kA udaya kAraNa aura vikAra kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko mAnA ? uttara -- prazna 203 se 206 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 215 - kyA jJeya vastu kAraNa aura jJAna kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko mAnA ? uttara - prazna 203 se 206 taka ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 216 -- kyA vikArI bhAva kAraNa aura karma baMdhana kArya 'kAraNAnuvidhAyI ni kAryANi ko mAnA ? uttara - prazna 203 se 206 taka ke anusAra uttara do /

Page #124
( 118 ) prazna 217-yayA zarIra rIpha rahe kAraNa aura dharma kaary| kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko mAnA? uttara--prazna 203 ne 206 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 218-bhUtArtha kAraNa aura samyagdarzana kArya, isame bhUtArtha phona hai ? uttara-ekamAtra anAdiananta amUrta nAyaka svabhAva hI bhUtArtha prazna 216-samyagdarzana kArya ke lie amRtArtha kauna-kauna hai tapA pratyeka para kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi pho phada mAnA aura keva nahIM mAnA, lagAtAra samajhAiye? uttara--(1) deva, guru, zAstra abhUtArtha haiM, (2) darzana monIya kA upazamAdi abhUtArtha hai, (3) zarIra, indriyAM, nokarma abhUtArtha haiM, (3) zubha bhAva abhUtArtha, (5) eka samaya kI apUrNa-pUrNa zuddha paryAya abhUtArtha hai| prazna 220 mokSa kArya ke lie bhUtArtha kauna hai ? uttara-ekamAtra trikAlI jJAyaka svabhAva hI bhUtArtha hai| prazna 221-mokSa kArya ke lie abhUtArtha kAraNa kyA-kyA hai tathA pratyeka para kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kara mAnA aura kaba nahIM maanaa| lagAkara samajhAiye ? uttara-(1) vajravRpabha nArAca sahanana abhUtArtha hai| (2) kamo kA abhAva abhUtArtha hai| (3) zubha bhAva abhUtArtha hai| (4) cauthA kAla abhUtArtha hai| prazna 222-kArya hone meM kAraNa se kyA tAtparya hai ? uttara-vAstava me kArya hone me upAdAna kAraNa se tAtparya hai, nimitta kAraNa se tAtparya nahI hai| prazna 223-zAstro meM phira nimitta kAraNo kI bAta kyo kI hai jaba ki kA kArya saccA kAraNa upAdAnakAraNa hI hai ?

Page #125
( 116 ) uttara--jaba-jaba upAdAna me kArya hotA hai usa samaya nimitta hotA hI hai, aisI vastu sthiti hai / isalie kArya ke samaya kauna nimitta kAraNa hai usakA jJAna karAne ke lie zAstro me nimitta kI 'vAta' samabhAI hai / prazna 224 -- jaba-jaba kArya hotA hai taba-tava nimitta hotA hI hai - aisA zAstro me kahA~ likhA hai ? 7 uttara- ( 1 ) " upAdAna nija guNa jahA~ tahA~ nimitta para hoya / bheda jJAna paramAna vidhi, viralA vRjhe koya // " [banArasI vilAsa ] (2) prati samaya ke utpAda ( kArya ) ke samaya ucita bahiraMga sAdhano kI (nimitto kI ) sanidhi ( upasthiti) hotI hI hai "jo ucita vahiga sAdhano kI sanidhi ke sadabhAva me aneka prakAra kI aneka avasthAe karatA hai / " [ pravacanasAra gA0 65 kI TIkA se ] (3) usa vastu me vidyamAna pariNamanarUpa jo yogyatA vaha antaraga nimitta ( upAdAna kAraNa ) hai aura usa pariNamana kA nizcaya kAla (kAla dravya) vAhya nimitta hai, aisA tatvadarziyoM ne nizcaya kiyA hai / [gaumaTTasAra jIvakANDa gA0 580 kI TIkA tathA zloka ] prazna 225- tInoM kAraNo me se kaunasA kAraNa ho, taba kArya kI utpatti niyama se hotI hai ? uttara- vAstava me kArya kI utpatti usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa ke samaya niyama se hotI hai / vahA~ para vAkI ke dono upAdAna kAraNa aura nimittakAraNa hote hI hai kisI ko kisI kI intajAra nahI karanI paDatI hai / prazna 226 - pahale kAraNa hai yA kArya hai ? uttara - kAraNa aura kArya kA eka hI samaya hai, phira yaha prazna pahale kAraNa yA kArya jhUThA hai| prazna 227 - jaba saba kArya " usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA

Page #126
( 120 ) kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa" se hI hote haiM to loga dUsare kAraNoM kI carcA kyoM karate haiM ? uttara - jaise -- kimI kA mAla corI karane se DaDhe paDate hai, jela jAnA paDatA hai, vaise hI jo kArya me dUsare kAraNo kI bAta meM pAgala ho rahe hai unhe cAro gatiyo me ghUma kara nigoda meM jAnA acchA lagatA hai / isalie dUsare kAraNo kI carcA karate hai / prazna 228 - jo vyavahAra kAraNo ko saccAkAraNa mAnate haiM una jIvo ko bhagavAna ne kina-kina nAmo se zAstrI me samvodhana kiyA hai ? uttara - ( 1 ) jo vyavahAra kAraNo ko saccA kAraNa mAnate haiM "unakA sulaTanA dunivAra he ora yaha unakA moha-ajJAna- adhakAra hai| [ samayasAra kalA 55 ] ( 2 ) vaha pada-pada para dhokhA khAtA hai| [ pravacanasAra gA0 55 ] ( 3 ) vaha bhagavAna kI vANI sunane lAyaka nahI hai / [ puruSArtha siddhaupAya gA0 6 ] ( 4 ) vaha mithyAdRSTi hai / [samayasAra 324 se 327 ke heDiMga me ] ( 5 ) usakA phala sasAra hai [ samayasAra gA0 11 ke bhAvArtha me ] (6) eka naya kA avalambana lene vAlA upadeza ke yogya nahI / [ niyamasAra gA0 16 kI TIkA se ] (7) usake saba dharma ke aga mithyAtva bhAva ko prApta hote haiM aura akAryakArI arthAt anarthakArI kahA hai / [ mokSamArga prakAzaka pRSTha 213] (8) harAmajAdIpanA kahA hai [ Atmavalokana pRSTa 143 ] prazna 226 - usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna se kArya kI utpatti hotI hai kyA yaha nirapekSa hai ? uttara - haoN, vastu svaya para kI apekSA nahI rakhatI isalie nirapekSa hai aura apanI apekSA rakhatI hai isalie sApekSa hai| isalie sabase prathama pAtra jIvo ko nirapekSa siddhi karanI caahiye| kI bAta AtI hai / phira sApekSatA

Page #127
( 121 ) prazna 230 - kyA nirapekSatA siddha kiye binA sApekSatA nahIM hotI hai ? uttara- nahI hotI hai, kyoki - (1) nirapekSatA ke binA sApekSatA kA yathArtha jJAna nahI hotA hai, (2) abheda ke binA bheda kA yathArtha jJAna nahA hotA hai, (3) nizcaya ke binA vyavahAra kA yathArtha jJAna nahI hotA hai, (4) upAdAna ke binA nimitta kA yathArtha jJAna nahI hotA hai, (5) bhUtArtha ke vinA abhUtArtha kA yathArtha jJAna nahI hotA hai, (6) yathArtha ke binA upacAra kA yathArtha jJAna nahI hotA hai, (7) sva ke binA para kA yathArtha jJAna nahI hotA hai, (8) svAzrita ke vinA parAzrita kA yathArtha jJAna nahI hotA hai, (6) mukhya ke vinA gauNa kA yathArtha jJAna nahI hotA hai, (10) dravyArthika ke binA paryAyArthika kA yathArtha jJAna nahI hotA hai, (11) ahetuka ke binA sahetuka kA yathArtha jJAna nahI hotA hai, (12) nitya ke binA anitya kA yathArtha jJAna nahI hotA hai, (13) tat ke binA atat kA yathArtha jJAna nahI hotA hai, (14) asti ke vinA nAsti kA yathArtha jJAna nahI hotA hai, (15) eka ke binA aneka kA yathArtha jJAna nahI hotA hai / (16) svadravya-kSa etra kAla-bhAva ke vinA paradravya-kSetra kAla-bhAva kA yathArtha jJAna nahI hotA hai / prazna 231 - kSAyika samyagdarzana huA tIno prakAra ke upAdAnaupAdeya batAo ? uttara - ( 1 ) jIva kA zraddhA guNa trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa, kSAyika samyaktva huA upAdeya, (2) kSAyopazamika samyaktva anantarapUkSaNavatI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa, kSAyika samyaktva upAdeya, (3) kSAyika samyaktva usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa, kSAyika samyaktva upAdeya / prazna 232 - kevaladarzana huA, tInoM prakAra ke upAdAna - upAdeya batAo ?

Page #128
( 122 ) uttara - ( 1 ) AtmA kA darzanaguNa trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa, kevaladarzana upAdeya, (2) acakSu darzana anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa, kevaladarzana anantara uttara kSaNavartI paryAya upAdeya, (3) kevaladarzana usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa, kevaladarzana upAdeya / prazna 233 --- antarAya karma kA abhAva meM tInoM prakAra ke upAdAnaupAdeya batAo ? uttara -- (1) kArmANa vargaNA trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa, antarAya dravya karma kA abhAva upAdeya, (2) antarAya karma kA kSayopazama anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa, antarAya karma kA abhAva anantara uttara kSaNavartI paryAya upAdeya, (3) antarAya karma kA abhAva usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa, antarAya karma kA abhAva upAdeya / prazna 234 - yathAkhyAta cAritra meM tIno prakAra ke upAdAnaupAdeya lagAo ? uttara - (1) jIva kA cAritra guNa trikAlI upAdAnakAraNa, yathAkhyAta cAritra upAdeya, (2) sakala cAritra anantarapUrvaM kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa, yathAkhyAtacAritra anantara uttara kSaNavartI paryAya upAdeya, (3) yathAkhyAta cAritra usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa, yathAkhyAtacAritra upAdeya / prazna 235 - opazamika samyaktva meM tIno upAdAna- upAdeya batAo ? 1 uttara - prazna 234 ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 236 - kevalajJAna me tIno upAdAna - upAdeya batAo ? uttara - prazna 234 ke anusAra uttara do / prazna 237 -- divyadhvani meM tIno upAdAna - upAdeya batAo ? uttara - 234 ke anusAra uttara do /

Page #129
( 123 ) prazna 238-mohanIya karma ke kSaya me tIno upAdAna-upAdeya batAo? uttara-prazna 233 ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 236-jaba utpAda hotA hai, vahAM para utpAda ke alAvA tIna bAteM kauna-kauna sI hotI haiM ? uttara-(1) usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa (utpAda) (2) anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa (vyaya) (3) trikAlI uhAdAnakaraNa (dhrauvya) (4) anukUla nimitt| prazna 240-dharmadravya ne jIva ko claanaa| isame 'jIva calA' para cAra bAteM kauna-kauna sI hotI haiM ? uttara-prazna 236 ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 241-maiMne kitAba bnaaii| isameM cAra bAteM kauna-kauna sI hotI haiM ? uttara-prazna 236 ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 242-jIva ne vikAra kiyA to karmabaMdha huaa| isame cAra bAteM kauna-kauna sI hotI haiM ? | uttara-prazna 236 ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 243-kSAyika samyaktva meM cAra bAteM kauna-kauna sI hotI uttara- prazna 236 ke anusAra uttara do| jaya mahAvIra-jaya mahAvIra - 0 --

Page #130
( 124 ) yogyatA kA tIsarA adhikAra prazna 1 - yogyatA kise kahate haiM ? uttara - samartha upAdAna zakti kA nAma hI yogyatA hai / prazna 2 - yogyatA ke paryAyavAcI zabda kyA hai ? uttara - samartha upAdAna zakti kaho, bhavitavyatA kaho, yogyatA kaho, eka hI bAta hai / ? prazna 3 - bhavitavyatA arthAt yogyatA kA vyutpatti artha kyA hai uttara- " bhavitu yogya bhavitavyam tasya bhAva bhavitavyatA" jo hone yogya ho use bhavitavya kahate haiM aura usakA bhAva bhavitavyatA kahalAtI hai| jise hama yogyatA kahate hai usI kA dUsarA nAma bhavitavyatA hai / prazna 4 - yogyatA ko jAnane se kyA-kyA lAbha haiM ? - uttara- (1) pratyeka dravya me jo-jo pariNamana hotA hai / vaha " usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA" ke anusAra hI huA hai, ho rahA hai, hotA rahegA / usame kisI dUsare kA jarA bhI hastakSapa nahI hai / ( 2 ) aisA jAnane se parakA mai kucha karU yA para merA kucha kare- aisA prazna upasthita nahI hotA hai / ( 3 ) kramabaddha paryAya kI siddhi hotI hai / ( 4 ) karU karU~ kI khoTI buddhi kA abhAva hote hI samyagdarzanAdi kI prApti hokara krama se nirvANa kI prApti hotI hai / T prazna 5 - 'kArya yogyatAnusAra hI hotA hai' isake lie kucha zAstra ke pramANa dIjiye ? uttara - (1) vaibhAvika pariNamana nimitta sApekSa hokara bhI vaha apanI usa kAla me pragaTa hone vAlI yogyatAnusAra hI hai / apanI yogyatAnusAra jIva sasArI hai aura apanI yogyatAnusAra hI mukta hotA hai, (2) pariNamana kA sAdhAraNa kAraNa kAla dravya hote hue bhI dravya apane utpAda-vyaya svabhAva ke kAraNa hI pariNamana karatA hai / kAla

Page #131
( 125 } usakA kucha preraka nahI hai, (3) tatvata pratyeka apanI yogyatAnusAra hI pariNamana hotA hai / ( pacAdhyAyI gA0 61 se 70 taka pRSTha 163 pa0 phUlacandra jI) (4) vastu kI ekarUpa sthiti nahI rahatI hai, kyoki yaha paryAya kA svabhAva hai| ( samayasAra kalaza 211) (5) eka dravya me atIta (bhUta) anAgata (bhaviSya ) aura gAthA me Ae hue " api " zabda se vartamAna paryAyarUpa jitanI artha paryAya aura vyajana paryAya haiM, 'tatpramANa' vaha dravya hotA hai / ( ghavala pu0 1 pRSTha 386 ) ( 6 ) tIna kAla ke jitane samaya hai, utanI utanI pratyeka dravya ke pratyeka- pratyeka guNa me utanI hI paryAye hotI haiM / use jarA bhI idhara-udhara karane ko jinendra bhagavAna bhI samartha nahI haiM / ( 7 ) pratyeka paryAya pUrva paryAya kA abhAva karake AI isa apekSA 'vikArya' kahA hai, naI utpanna huI isa apekSA 'nirvartya' kahA hai, thI to AI isa apekSA prApya' kahA hai / ( samayasAra gA0 76 se 78 taka ) yaha yogyatA ke lie zAstra ke pramANa haiM / prazna 6 - jaba Apa logoM para koI uttara nahIM banatA hai, to Apa kaha dete ho ki yaha 'usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA se' hai to kyA 'yogyatA' kahakara Apa ghokhA nahIM dete- aisA praznakAra kA prazna hai ? uttara- (1) do paramANu hai, eka paramANu kI varNa guNa kI paryAya sau phIsadI sapheda hai aura dUsare paramANu kI hajAra guNA sapheda hai / to Apa batalAiye, usakA kyA kAraNa hai ? praznakAra cakkara me paDa gayA aura socane lagA paramANu to zuddha hai usame dUsarA kAraNa nahI kahA jA sakatA hai / taba uttara diyA ki usakA kAraNa usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA hI hai (2) Apake sAmane sava pudgala skadha haiM, kisI kI raga guNa kI paryAya kAlI hai, harI hai pIlI hai, nIlI hai / to prazna hotA hai aisA kyo hai ? to Apako kahanA paDegA "usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA" hI kAraNa hai / (3) vizva me jIva ananta haiM, sabake bhAva alaga-alaga kyo haiM ? Apako kahanA paDegA - usa samaya paryAya kI

Page #132
( 126 ) yogyatA hI kAraNa hai / (4) mAsTara 50 laDako ko paDhAtA hai sabako ekasA jJAna kyo nahI hotA hai ? to Apako kahanA paDegA, "usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA" hI kAraNa hai / (5) sAmane lokAloka hai / lokAloka kA jJAna kevalI ko hotA hai, Apako kyo nahI hotA hai ? to kahanA paDegA, "usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA" hI kAraNa hai / (6) bhagavAna kI divyadhvani khiratI hai, kyA sabako ekasA jJAna hotA hai ? Apa kahege nahI / to hama kahate haiM aisA kyo hai ? Apa kahoge "usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA" hI kAraNa hai / yAda rakkho - vAstava me koI bhI kArya hone meM yA bigaDane me "usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA hI " sAkSAt sAdhaka hai / prazna 7 -- AcAryoM ne ghavala 160 me yogyatA ke viSaya meM kyA batAyA hai ? uttara- (1) dravyArthikanaya se dravya me tIno kAla kI paryAyo rUpa apane-apane samaya meM pariNamana karane kI yogyatA hai / (2) paryAyAthikanaya se dravya me jo vartamAna paryAya hotI hai vaha usI rUpa se pari mana kI yogyatA rakhatI hai ( 3 ) isase yaha siddha huA vartamAna paryAya bhUta yA bhaviSya me pariName aisA kabhI bhI nahI hotA hai / bhUtakAla kI koI bhI paryAya me Age-pIche kAla me hone kI yogyatA nahI rakhatI hai / bhaviSya kI paryAya usase pahale ho jAve yA pIche ho jAve, aisI yogyatA nahI rakhatI hai / isalie kisI bhI dravya kI kisI bhI paryAya ko anizcita mAnanA jinamata se bAhara hai / ( 4 ) yaha jIva itanA kAla bItane para mokSa jAyegA, aisI nodha kevalajJAna me hai / (samayasAra kalaza TIkA kalajJa na0 4 pRSTha 5) (5) kevalajJAna eka hI samaya me sarva Atma pradezo se samasta dravya-kSa etra - kAla bhAva ko jAnatA hai / ( pravacanasAra gA0 47 kA rahasya ) prazna 8 - yogyatA se kyA siddha huA ? uttara - (1) bama paDanA ( 2 ) bahuta se manuSyoM kA eka sAtha

Page #133
( 127 ) maranA / (3) eka zarIra me rahane vAle nigodiyA jIvo kA savakA eka sAtha maraNa honaa| (4) havAI jahAja kA ttuuttnaa| (5) rAkeTa Upara jAnA / (6) nadI kA pravAha vadalanA / (7) bAMdha kA bnaanaa| (8) kacce phala ko jaldI pakAnA / (6) pakke phala ko lamve kAla taka kAyama rakhanA / (10) akAla maraNa / (11) karma kA sakramaNa, udIraNA, utkarSaNa, sthitikANDa, anubhAgakANDa Adi sava kAma apane-apane kArya kAla me hI hote hai, kyoki pratyeka dravya me jitane jitane guNa haiM usa-usa pratyeka guNa me tIna kAla ke jitane samaya haiM utanI-utanI paryAya hai / vaha nizcita aura kramavaddha hai| jarA bhI Age-pIche nahI ho sakatI hai aisI bAta 'yogyatA' se siddha hotI hai| prazna :-yogyatA kyA hai ? uttara-bhavitavyatA athavA niyati 'usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA hai' vaha kSaNika-upAdAna kAraNa hai| prazna 10-dravya kI yogyatA kyA hai ? uttara-pratyeka dravya apane-apane dravyarUpa hI rahatA hai, kabhI dUsare dravyarUpa nahI hotA, isaliye dravyarUpa yogyatA dravya rUpa rahatI hai| prazna 11 ---guNa ko yogyatA kyA hai ? uttara-pratyeka guNa apane-apane rUpa hI rahatA hai| jaise-jJAna guNa jJAnaguNa rUpa hI rahatA hai, zraddhA cAritra rUpa nahI hotA hai| aura pudgala me rasaguNa, rasaguNa rUpa hI rahatA hai gadha-varNa-sparzarUpa nahIM hotA hai| yaha guNarUpa yogyatA hai| prazna 12-paryAya rUpa yogyatA kyA hai ? uttara-pratyeka dravya me ananta-ananta guNa hai| eka-eka guNa me jisa samaya jisa paryAya kI yogyatA hai, vahI hogii| eka samaya bhI Age-pIche nahI ho sakatI hai| kisI bhI taraha se usa yogyatA ko TAlane ke lie deva, indra, jinendra bhagavAna bhI samartha nahI hai| paryAya kI yogyatA eka samayamAtra kI hI hotI hai|

Page #134
( 128 ) prazna 13-upAdAna-upAdeya adhikAra meM kisa yogyatA ko bAta calatI hai ? uttara-paryAyarUpa yogyatA kI vAta calatI hai| yaha yogyatArUpa paryAya jAnane yogya hai, Azraya karane yogya nahIM hai| prazna 14-yogyatA rUpa paryAya ke jAnane se kyA-kyA lAbha haiM ? uttara-(1) sava me yogyatArUpa paryAya jo honI hai vahI hogI Age-pIche nhii| (2) para me karane-karAne kI buddhi kA abhAva ho jAtA hai| (3) dRSTi apane svabhAva para A jAtI hai aura jaina darzana ke rahasya kA marmI vana jAtA hai| (4) krama se mokSa kA pathika bana jAtA hai| prazna 15-(1) paryAyarUpa yogyatA aura dravyarUpa yogyatA ke viSaya me kyA-kyA jAnanA cAhiye ? uttara-(1) paryAyarUpa yogyatA jJAyaka kA jJeya hai, jAnane yogya hai| (2) nija dravyarUpa yogyatA Azraya karane yogya hai, kyoki isake Azraya se hI dharma kI zuruAta vRddhi aura pUrNatA hotI hai| prazna 16-paryAyarUpa yogyatA ko vizeSa rUpa se samajhAo ? - uttara-(1) jaise-Ama hai, jaba usakI pakane yogya avasthA hotI hai tabhI hogI, Age-pIche nhii| kisI ne pAla me dekara pahale pakA diyA aisA nahIM hai / (2) Ama khaTTA thA mIThA ho gayA, jaba usakI mIThA hone yogya avasthA thI, tabhI huI, Age-pIche nahI aura kisI ke kAraNa se bhI nhiiN| (3) zarIra me bAlakapana, yuvAvasthA, vRddhAvasthA hone yogya hove, tabhI hotI hai| kisI bAhya sAdhana se yA kisI bhI prakAra se hera-phera nahI ho sakatA hai| (4) mahAvIra bhagavAna ko 30 varSa kI Ayu me dIkSA kA bhAva aayaa| AdinAtha bhagavAna ko 83 lAkha varSa pUrva Ayu ke bAda dIkSA kA bhAva aayaa| yaha unakI yogyatA hI aisI thii| (5) mahAvIra bhagavAna ko dIkSA ke 12 varSa bAda kevalajJAna huA aura AdinAtha bhagavAna ko dIkSA ke eka hajAra varSa bAda

Page #135
( 126 ) kevalajJAna huA / mallinAtha bhagavAna ko dIkSA lete hI kevalajJAna huA / yaha saba usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kI bAta hai, kisI kA kucha bhI hastakSepa nahI hai / ( 6 ) sava dravyo me jo-jo paryAya hotI haiM, vahavaha usa usa samaya kI yogyatA ke kAraNa hI hotI haiM / isa bAta ko svIkAra karate hI dRSTi apane bhagavAna para AtI hai tabhI vAstava me yogyatA ko mAnA aura jAnA / prazna 17 - jIva- pudgala dravyo me yogyatA kI bAta hai yA sava dravyoM ke viSaya me yogyatA kI bAta hai ? uttara- ( 1 ) jIva ananta, pudgala anantAnanta, dharma-adharma - AkAza eka-eka aura loka pramANa asakhyAta kAla dravya hai / ina saba dravyo me pratyeka pratyeka me ananta - ananta guNa hai / pratyeka guNa me paryAyo kI yogyatA jitane tIna kAla ke samaya hai utanI hI paryAyo kI yogyatA haiM / ( 2 ) vaha yogyatA kramabaddha aura kramaniyamita hai / use jarA bhI koI bhI hera-phera nahI kara sakatA hai / prazna 18 - saba dravyo kI paryAyo ko yogyatA kramabaddha aura nizcita hai, isako kauna jAnatA hai uttara - cauthe guNasthAna se lekara siddhadazA taka saba jAnate haiM / jAnane meM jarA bhI hera-phera nahI hai mAtra pratyakSa-parokSa kA bheda hai / prazna 16 - yogyatA, yogyatA kI bAteM kare aura AtmA kA Azraya nA leve, to kyA doSa AvegA ? uttara- vaha svachandatA kA sevana karane vAlA cAro gatiyo me ghUmakara nigoda calA jAvegA / kyoki yogyatA ko jAnane aura mAnane kA phala apane svabhAva kA Azraya lekara samyagdarzanAdi kI prApti karake krama se nirvANa kI prApti hai / prazna 20 - yogyatA se kyA-kyA siddha hotA hai ? uttara- (1) jisa samaya jonasI paryAya utpanna hone kI yogyatA ho, vahI niyama se hotI hai / ( 2 ) paryAya hotI hai vaha apane svakAla

Page #136
( 130 ) se hotI hai / (3) hara paryAya apane janma-kSaNa meM ho utpanna hotI hai / (4) jisa samaya jisa paryAya kA utpAda hogA usI samaya vahI hI hogI / (5) zramavaddha paryAya kI siddhi Adi bAnoM kA nirNaya yogyatA ke mAnane se hotA hai| prazna 21 - yogyatA mAnane vAle ko kyA-kyA prazna upasthita nahIM hote haiM ? uttara- (1) unane yaha huA / (2) yaha ho, yaha nA ho / ( 3 ) aisA vayaM Adi prazna upasthita nahI hote haiM / 1 jaya mahAvIra jaya mahAvIra -:0: nimittakAraNa cothA adhikAra prazna 1- nimittakAraNa kise kahate haiM ? uttara -- jo padArtha svayaM svata. kAryarUpa pariNamita nA ho parantu kArya kI utpatti me anukUla hone kA jisa para Aropa A sake usa * padArtha ko nimitta kAraNa kahate haiM / jaise-ghaDe kI utpatti me kumbhakAra, ts, cakra Adi nimitta kAraNa haiM / prazna 2 - kyA nimitta saccA kAraNa hai ? uttara - nimitta saccA kAraNa nahI hai / vaha akAraNavat-ahetuvat hai, kyoki vaha upacAra mAtra athavA vyavahAra kAraNa hai / prazna 3 - nimitta ke paryAyavAcI nAma batAo ? uttara - nimittamAtra, asara, prabhAva, valAdhAna, preraka, sahAyaka ina saba zabdo kA artha nimittamAtra hai /

Page #137
prazna 4-~Apane jo nimitta ke paryAyavAcI nAma batAye, yaha kisa zAstra me Aye haiM ? uttara-zrI tatvArthasAra tIsarA adhikaar| prazna 5-jainendra siddhAnta koSa bhAga do pRSTha 610 me nimitta ke paryAyavAcI zabda kyA-kyA batAye haiM ? uttara-kAraNa, pratyaya, hetu, sAdhana, sahakArI, upakArI, upagrAhaka, Azraya, Alambana, anugrAhaka, utpAdaka, kartA, hetukartA, preraka ; hetumata, abhivyajaka, ye saba nimitta ke paryAyavAcI zabda haiN| prazna 6-nimitta kAraNo ke kitane bheda haiM ? uttara-do bheda haiM (1) preraka nimitta (2) udAsIna nimitta / prazna 7-preraka nimitta kise kahate haiM ? uttara-(1) gamana kriyA vAle (mAtra kSetra se kSetrAntara hI lenA hai) jIva, pudgala, (2) icchAdi (krodha, mAna, mAyA, lobha) vAlA jIva preraka nimitta kahalAte hai| prazna 8-preraka kA artha kyA hai ? uttara--apane me prakRSTarUpa se iraNa aura preraNA kare vaha preraka hai| prazna :-icchA Adi vAle jIva aura gamana kriyA vAle jIvo se kyA tAtparya hai ? uttara-(1) muni hai / kisI dharma lobhI jIva ko upadeza dene kA vikalpa Ave, to vaha (muni) icchAdivAle nimitta kahalAye (2) ahaMta bhagavAna icchAdivAle nimitta nahIM hai, parantu ahaMta bhagavAna gamana kriyA vAle nimitta hai| prazna 10-siddha bhagavAna ko icchA nahIM hai aura gamana bhI nahIM hai taba siddha bhagavAna kauna se nimitta kahalAveMge? uttara-siddha bhagavAna udAsIna nimitta kahalAye jaaveNge| prazna 11-kyA preraka nimitta upAdAna me kucha karatA hai ? uttara-bilkula nahI, preraka nimitta jabarana upAdAna me kArya kara

Page #138
( 132 ) dete haiM yA prabhAva Adi DAla sakate haiM aisA nahI samajhanA, kyoki dono padArthoM kA ( upAdAna - nimitta kA) eka-dUsare me abhAva hai| preraka nimitta upAdAna ko preraNA nahI karatA / prazna 12 - udAsIna nimitta kise kahate haiM ? uttara- dharmAstikAya, adharmAstikAya, AkAza aura kAlAdi niSkriya ( gamana kriyA rahita ) yA rAga rahita dravyo ko udAsIna nimitta kahate hai / ? prazna 13 - jaba nimitta upAdAna meM kucha karatA hI nahI hai / taba preraka nimitta aura udAsIna nimitta aisA bheda kyoM DAlA hai| uttara--nimitto ke upabheda batAne ke lie kinhI nimitto ko preraka aura kinhI ko udAsIna kahA jAtA hai / kintu sarva prakAra ke nimitta upAdAna ke lie to "dharmAstikAyavata udAsIna hI haiM / " nimitta ke bhinna-bhinna prakAro kA jJAna karAne ke lie hI usake yaha do bheda kiye gaye haiM / prazna 14 - nimitta ke dUsare prakAra se kitane bheva haiM ? ? uttara - do bheda hai / sadbhAvarUpa nimitta aura abhAvarUpa nimitta / prazna 15 - cAro prakAra ke nimitto me kyA antara hai uttara - preraka aura udAsIna nimitta sadbhAvarUpa va abhAvarUpa donoM prakAra ke nimitta hote haiM / prazna 16 - sadbhAvarUpa nimitta aura abhAvarUpa nimitta se kyA tAtparya hai ? uttara - sadbhAvarUpa nimitta astirUpa hai aura abhAvarUpa nimitta nAstirUpa hai / prazna 17 - sarva prakAra ke nimitta dharmAstikAyavat hI haiM aisA fe zAstra meM kahA~ AyA hai ? uttara- " nAjJo vijJatvamAyAti, vijJo nAjJatvamRcchati / nimittamAtra manyastu gate dharmAstikAyavat" // 35 //

Page #139
( 133 ) artha :-ajJAnI vizeSa prakAra ke jJAnabhAva ko prApta nahI karatA aura vizeSa jJAnI ajJAnapane ko prApta nahIM krtaa| gati ko jisa prakAra dharmAstikAya nimitta hai, usI prakAra anya to nimittamAtra hai| [iSTopadeza zloka 35](2) caitanya svabhAva ke kAraNa jAnane aura dekhane kI kriyA kA jIva hI kartA hai| jahA~ jIva hai vahAM cAra arUpI acetana dravya bhI haiM tathApi ve jisa prakAra jAnane aura dekhane kI kriyA ke kartA nahI hai usI prakAra jIva ke sambandha me rahe hue karma, no karma rUpa pudgala bhI usa kriyA ke kartA nahI hai| [pacAstikAya gA0 122 kI TIkA se] prazna 15-'kumhAra ne ghar3A banAyA' isa para nimitta kI paribhASA lagAo? ____ uttara-kumhAra svaya svata ghaDe rUpa pariNamita nA ho| parantu ghaDe kI utpatti me anukUla hone kA jisa para (kumhAra para) Aropa A sake usa padArtha ko (kumhAra ko) nimitta kAraNa kahate haiN| prazna 16-jIva ne karma bAMdhA, isa para nimitta kI paribhASA lagAo? uttara-jIva svaya svata karma badha rUpa nA prinnme| parantu karma badha kI avasthA me anukUla hone kA jisa para (ajJAnI jIva para) Aropa A sake usa padArtha ko (ajJAnI jIva ko) nimittakAraNa ka usa padArtha hAna kA jisvaarnnme| paranta / kahate haiN| prazna 20-(1) strI ne roTI bnaaii| (2) darzanamohanIya ke kSaya se kSAyika samyaktva haA; (3) kevalajJAna se kevalajJAnAvaraNIya kA abhAva huA; (4) maine bistarA uThAyA, (5) darjI ne kapar3e banAye; (6) divyadhvani sunane se samyagjJAna kI prApti huI; (7) jJeya se jJAna hotA hai; (8) maiMne makAna banAyA; (9) dharma dravya mujhe calAtA hai, (10) mujhe AkAza jagaha detA hai| (11) maiMne kitAba uThAI; (12) kAladravya ne mujhe pariNamAyA, (13) jJAnAvaraNIya

Page #140
( 134 ) karma ke kSayopazama se jJAna kA ughAr3a hotA hai| (14) mai haMsA; (15) mai bolA, (16) mai calA, (17) maiMne kapar3e pahine; (18) maiMne palaga banAyA; (16) maiMne halavA banAyA; (20) maiM uThA, Adi vAkyo meM nimitta kI paribhASA lagAkara batAo? __uttara-(1) strI svaya svata. roTI rUpa pariNamita nA ho / parantu roTI kI utpatti me anukUla hone kA jisa para (strI para) Aropa A sake / usa padArtha ko (strI ko) nimitta kAraNa kahate hai| isI prakAra bAkI ke 16 vAkyo para prazna 18 ke anusAra lagAkara btaao| prazna 21-"guru upadeza nimitta bina, upAdAna bala hAna / jyo nara dUje paoNva bina, calave ko AdhIna // " artha-guru ke upadeza rUpa nimitta binA upAdAna (ziSyAdi) balahIna hai, (kyoki) dUsare paoNva ke vinA manuSya cala nahI sakatA hai ? [yaha mAnyatA barAvara nahI hai ? aisA ziSya kA prazna hai|] uttara--yaha mAnyatA barAbara nahI hai-aisA batalAne ke liye zrI guru dohe se uttara dete hai ki "jJAna naina kiriyA carana, doU ziva maga dhAra / upAdAna nihacai jahA~, tahA~ nimitta vyohAra // " artha-samyagdarzana-jJAnarUpa netra aura sthiratA rUpa caraNa (lInatA rUpa kriyA) yaha dono milakara mokSamArga jaano| jahA~ upAdAnarUpa nizcayakAraNa hotA hai vahA~ nimittarUpa vyavahAra kAraNa hotA hI hai| bhAvArtha-upAdAna to nizcaya arthAta saccA kAraNa hai, nimitta to mAtra vyavahAra arthAt upacAra kAraNa hai, saccA kAraNa nahIM hai, isIliye to use akAraNavata (ahetuvata) kahA hai use upacAra (Aropita) kAraNa isaliye kahA hai ki vaha upAdAna kA kucha kArya karatA-karAtA nahI hai, tathApi kArya ke samaya usa para anuka latA kA Aropa AtA hai, isa kAraNa use upacAra mAtra kahA hai| samyagjJAna aura cAritra rUpa lInatA ko mokSamArga jAno-aisA kahA, usame

Page #141
( 135 ) zarIrAzrita upadeza, upavAsAdika kriyA aura zubharAgarUpa vyavahAra ko mokSamArga na jAno yaha bAta A jAtI hai / ) "upAdAna nija guNa jahA~ tahA~ nimitta para hoya / bhedajJAna paramAna vidhi, biralA bUke koya // " artha -- jahA~ nija zakti rUpa upAdAna ho vahA~ para nimitta hotA hI hai / usake dvArA bhedajJAna pramANa kI vidhi ( vyavasthA ) haiM / yaha siddhAnta koI virale hI samajhate haiM / bhAvArtha - jahA~ upAdAna kI yogyatA ho vahA~ niyama se nimitta hotA hI hai / nimitta kI pratIkSA karanI paDe aisA nahI hotA, aura nimitta ko hama juTA sakate haiM- aisA bhI nahI hotA / nimitta kI pratIkSA karanI paDatI hai yA use maiM lA sakatA hU~ - aisI mAnyatA para padArtha me abheda buddhi arthAt ajJAna sUcaka hai / upAdAna aura nimitta dono asahAyarUpa svatantra hai yaha unakI maryAdA hai / "upAdAna bala jaha~ tahA~ naha nimitta ko dAva / eka cakra sau ratha cale, ravi ko yahi svabhAva // " artha-jahA~ dekho vahA~ upAdAna kA hI bala hai, ( nimitta hotA hai ) parantu nimitta kA (kArya karane me ) koI bhI dAva (bala) nahI hai / eka cakra se ravi kA ( sUrya kA ) ratha calatA hai vaha usakA svabhAva hai / ( usI prakAra pratyeka kArya upAdAna kI yogyatA se ( sAmarthya se ) hI hotA hai / ) prazna 22 -- " hau jAne thA eka hI upAdAna so kAja / sahAI pauna bina, pAnI mA~hi jahAja // artha -- akele upAdAna se kArya hotA ho to pavana kI sahAyatA ke binA jahAja pAnI me kyo nahI calatA ? uttara- " sarva vastu asahAya jaha~ taha~ nimitta hai kauna / jyo jahAja paravAha me, tirai sahaja vina pauna // " artha - jahA~ pratyeka vastu svatantra rUpa se apanI avasthA ko ( kArya

Page #142
( 136 ) ko prApta karatA hai vahA~ nimitta kauna hai ? jisa prakAra jahAja pravAha me sahaja hI binA pavana ke tairatA hai| __bhAvArtha-jIva aura pudgala dravya zuddha yA azuddha avasthA me svatantra rUpa se hI apane me pariNamana karate haiN| ajJAnI jIva bhI svatantra rUpa se nimittAdhIna hokara pariNamana karatA hai, koI nimitta use AdhIna nahI kara sktaa| "upAdAna vidhi nirvacana, haiM nimitta upadeza base ju jaise deza meM kara su taise bheSa // " artha-upAdAna kA kathana nirvacana hai, (arthAta eka 'yogyatA dvArA hI hotA hai) upAdAna apanI yogyatA se aneka prakAra se pariNamana karatA hai, taba upasthita nimitta para bhinna-bhinna kAraNapane kA Aropa (bheSa) AtA hai, upAdAna kI vidhi nirvacana hone se nimitta dvArA yaha kArya huA aisA vyavahAra se kahA jAtA hai| ___ bhAvArtha-upAdAna jaba jaisA kArya karatA hai taba vaise kAraNapane kA Aropa (bheSa) nimitta para AtA hai| jaise ki koI vanakAyavAna manuSya sAtaveM narakagati ke yogya malIna bhAva dhAraNa karatA hai, to vajrakAya para naraka ke kAraNapane kA Aropa AtA hai, aura yadi jIva mokSa ke yogya nirmala bhAva karatA hai to usa vajrakAya para mokSa ke kAraNapane kA Aropa AtA hai| isa prakAra upAdAna ke kArya anusAra nimitta me kAraNapane kA bhinna-bhinna Aropa kiyA jAtA hai| isase aisA siddha hotA hai ki nimitta se kArya nahI hotA parantu kathana hotA hai, isalie upAdAna saccA kAraNa hai aura nimitta Aropita kAraNa hai| vAstava me to nimitta aisA prasiddha karatA hai ki-naimittika svatantra apane kAraNa se pariNamana kara rahA hai, to upasthita dUsarI anukUla vastu ko nimitta kahA jAtA hai| prazna 23-hama nimitta milAveM yA nahIM ?

Page #143
( 137 ) uttara-koI kisI bhI dravya ko milA nahIM sakatA, kyoki saba dravya pRthak-pRthak hai / nimitta milAne kI buddhi mithyAdRSTiyo kI hai| prazna 24-hama nimitta kyo nahIM milA sakate haiM ? uttara-(1) nimitta aura upAdAna ke kArya kA eka hI samaya hai (2) nimitta-naimittika do svatantra dravyo ke eka samaya kI paryAyo me hI hotA hai| (3) chadmastha eka samaya kI paryAya pakaDa nahI sakatA hai| (4) eka dravya kI paryAya dUsare dravya kI paryAya me akiMcitkara hai| (5) kisa samaya kisa kA pariNamana nahI hotA ? sabakA hI hotA hai| isalie nimitta milAne kI buddhi ananta sasAra kA kAraNa hai| prazna 25-nimitta kA jJAna kyo karAte haiM ? uttara--(1) mithyASTiyo ne anAdi se eka-eka samaya karake nimitta kA Azraya mAnA hai| (2) nimitta para dravya hai usase terA sambandha nahI hai| aisA jJAna karAkara svabhAva kA Azraya le, to terA bhalA ho| (3) nimitta kA Azraya chuDAne ke lie nimitta kA jJAna karAyA hai| (4) jahA~ upAdAna hotA hai vahA~ nimitta hotA hI hai isalie nimitta kA jJAna karAyA hai| prazna 26-nimitta aura upAdAna ke viSaya me kyA-kyA bAteM yAda rakhanI cAhiye ? __uttara-(1) jaba yogyatAvAlA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa hotA hai vahA~ para niyama se trikAlI upAdAnakAraNa, anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura nimittakAraNa niyama se hotA hai| koI nA hove, aisA hotA hI nahI hai / (2) upAdAna kA kArya upAdAna se hI hotA hai, nimitta se nhiiN| (3) jitane bhI prakAra ke nimitta haiM, ve saba upAdAna ke lie mAtra dharma dravya ke samAna hI haiN| (4) jaba upAdAna hotA hai taba nimitta hotA hI hai aisI vastu sthiti hai| (5) nimitta kAraNa upAdAna ke prati nizcaya se (vAstava me) akiMcitkara (kucha karane vAlA) hai, isIlie use nimitta mAtra, balAdhAna mAtra,

Page #144
( 138 ) sahAya mAtra, ahetuvat Adi zabdo dvArA sambodhita kiyA jAtA hai / (6) kisI bhI samaya upAdAna me nimitta kucha bhI nahI kara sakatA hai, nimitta upAdAna me kucha karatA hai aisI buddhi nigoda kA kAraNa hai / (7) upAdAna ke anukUla hI ucita nimittakAraNa hotA hai / ( 8 ) nimitta kAraNa Aye tabhI upAdAna me kArya hotA hai aisI mAnyatA jhUThI hai / (6) upAdAna - nimitta dono eka sAtha apane-apane kAraNa se hote haiM / (10) kArya upAdAna se hI hotA hai nimitta kI apekSA kathana hotA hai aisA pAtra jIva jAnatA hai / 1 prazna 27 - ajJAnI kyA dekhate haiM ? uttara - vizeSa ko hI dekhate hai sAmAnya ko nahI dekhate haiM / prazna 28 --- mAtra vizeSa ko dekhane se sAmAnya ko nA dekhane se kyA hotA hai ? uttara - Asrava vadha karatA huA cAro gatiyo me ghUmatA huA nigoda me calA jAtA hai / prazna 26 -- jJAnI kyA dekhate haiM ? uttara - sAmAnya ko dekhate hai / prazna 30 - sAmAnya ko dekhane se kyA hotA hai ? uttara --savara - nirjarA kI prApti karake krama se mokSa kI prApti karatA hai / prazna 31 - nimitta kyA batAtA hai ? uttara - nimitta upAdAna kI prasiddhi karatA hai / jaise - pAnI kA loTA yaha batalAtA hai ki loTA to pItala kA hai pAnI kA nahI hotA; usI prakAra nimitta kahatA hai jaisA meM kahatA hU~ use jhUThA mAnanA aura upAdAna jo kahatA hai use satya mAnanA, kyoMki maiM kisI ko kisI me milAkara kathana karatA hU~ mere zraddhAna se midhyAtva hogA aura upAdAna kisI ko kisI me milAkara nispaNa nahI karatA, usake zraddhAna se samyaktva hotA hai / ora jahA~ merI apekSA ( nimitta kI

Page #145
( 136 ) usakA artha "aisA hai nahI, nimittAdi kI aisA jAnanA / aisA pAtra jIva ko nimitta apekSA) kathana kiyA ho, apekSA kathana kiyA hai" jJAna karAtA hai / prazna 32 - upAdAna kyA batAtA hai ? uttara - upAdAna kahatA hai jo maiM kahatA hU~ use satya mAnanA, nimitta kI bAta jhUTha mAnanA, kyoki mai kisI ko kisI me milAkara nirUpaNa nahI karatA, mere zraddhAna se samyaktvAdi kI prApti hokara krama se mokSa lakSmI ko prApta karegA aura nimitta kisI ko kisI me milAkara nirUpaNa karatA hai usake zraddhAna se cAro gatiyo me ghUmakara nigoda ko prApta hogA / aura jahA~ merI apekSA ( upAdAna kI apekSA ) kathana kiyA ho use " aisA hI hai" aisA zraddhAna karanA / aisA pAtra jIva ko upAdAna jJAna karAtA hai / prazna 33 - ajJAnI kahate haiM ki jJAnI nimitta ko nahIM mAnate, kyoMki vaha nimitta se upAdAna me kucha honA nahIM mAnate haiM ? uttara-- jaise--anya matAvalambI kahate haiM ki jainI Izvara ko nahI mAnate hai, kyoki vaha Izvara ko utpanna karane vAlA, rakSA karane vAlA, pApiyo ko naSTa karane vAlA nahI mAnate hai, usI prakAra vartamAna me digambaradharmI nAma gharAke kahate haiM, ki jJAnI nimitta ko nahI mAnate hai / prazna 34 -- kyA vAstava meM jJAnI nimitta ko nahIM mAnate haiM ? uttara - vAstava me jJAnI hI nimitta ko mAnate haiM, kyoki jJAnI kahate hai ki nimitta apanA kArya sau phIsadI apane me karatA hai / upAdAna sau phIsadI apanA kArya apane me karatA hai aisA svataMtra nimitta naimittika sambandha hai / parantu khoTI dRSTi se zAstra paDhane vAle ajJAnI kahate haiM ki nimitta upAdAna me kucha kare to hama tumhArA nimitta honA mAne /

Page #146
( 140 ) prazna 35-nimitta upAdAna meM kucha kre| aisA mAnA jAve to kyA doSa AtA hai ? uttara-usane nimitta ko nimitta na mAnakara upAdAna maanaa| prazna 36-yaha jIva saMsAra me kyo bhramaNa kara rahA hai / uttara-nimitta ko nimitta na mAnakara parantu nimitta ko upAdAna mAnakara sasAra me bhramaNa kara rahA hai / prazna 37--kyA nimitta nahIM hai ? uttara--(1) nimitta haiN| (2) nimitta jAnane yogya hai| (3) Azraya karane yogya nahI hai| prazna 38-nimitta kA prabhAva par3atA hai yaha mAnyatA kisakI hai ? uttara-ajJAnI mithyAdRSTiyo kI hai| prazta 36-Ajakala ke paDita nAma dharAne vAle apane ko digambara dharma ke ThekedAra mAnane vAle kahate haiM ki nimitta binA kAma nahIM hotaa| guru binA jJAna nahIM hotaa| karma kA abhAva hue binA mokSa nahIM hotA hai| zubha bhAva kare to dharma kI prApti ho| kyA yaha unakA kahanA galata hai ? uttara-bilkula galata hai, kyoki nimitta binA kAma nahI hotA Adi mAnyatA anya mato kI hai| digambara dharma kI ADa me anya mata kI puSTi karane vAle cAro gatiyo me ghUmakara nigoda ke pAtra haiN| prazna 40-upAdAna aura nimitta kisa naya kA kathana hai ? uttara-upAdAna nizcaya naya kA kathana hai aura nimitta vyavahAra naya kA kathana hai| prazna 41-yAda rakhane yogya bAteM kyA-kyA haiM ? uttara-(1) anantarapUrva paryAya kA vyaya hokara jo utpAda rUpa paryAya hotI hai, vaha dravya me hone yogya hove, vaha hI hotI hai anya nahI hotI hai| (2) jo svaya svata kArya karane meM asamartha hai usakA para

Page #147
( 141 ) kucha bhI nahI kara sakatA hai aura jo svata apanA kArya karane me samartha hai usakA bhI para kucha nahI kara sakatA hai| prazna 42-mukta dazA hone para anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA kyA nAma hai ? aura kyA vaha niyama se hotA hai ? uttara-usakA nAma ayogI kevalI caudahavA~ guNasthAna hai aura vaha niyama se hotA hai| prazna 43-koI mAtra sAmAnya aMza ko hI upAdAna kahe, to kyA doSa AtA hai ? uttara-vaha upAdAna kA svarUpa na jAnane vAlA vedAnta mata 'vAlA hai| prazna 44-koI mAtra vizeSa aza ko hI upAdAna kahe, to kyA doSa AtA hai ? . uttara-vaha upAdAna kA svarUpa na jAnane vAlA bauddhamata vAlA prazna 45--upAdAna aura nimitta kAraNa haiM yA kArya haiM ? uttara-dono kAraNa haiM kArya nahI hai| prazna 46-nimitta aura naimittika kAraNa haiM yA kArya hai ? uttara-nimitta kAraNa hai aura naimittika kArya hai| prazna 47-paryAya niyata hai yA aniyata hai ? uttara--paryAya svaya se niyata hai| prazna 45-paryAya niyata hai yaha jarA spaSTa karo ? uttara-tIna kAla ke jitane samaya haiM, utanI hI eka-eka guNa me paryAya hotI haiN| use jarA bhI Age-pIche nahI kiyA jA sakatA hai kyoki eka paryAya ko Age-pIche karanA mAne to guNa-dravya ke nAza kA prasaga upasthita hovegaa| prazna 46-pratyeka kArya kramabaddha aura nizcita hai to hama milAne kI bAta kahA~ se AI ?

Page #148
( 142 ) uttara-(1) jaba nizcaya kAraNa upAdAna ke kArya rUpa pariNamita hone kA kAla hotA hai tava nimitta kI upasthiti svayameva hotI hai aisA vastu kA svabhAva hai (2) jo jIva nimitta milAne ke prayatna me lage rahate haiM unhe dharma kI prApti nahI hogI, kyoki nimitta milAnA paDatA nahI hai, parantu hotA hai| (3) nimitta milAne kI bAta nigoda se AI hai, kyoki pratyeka kArya eka samaya jitanA hone se usakA (kArya kA) nimitta ke sAtha eka samaya kA sambandha hai| kArya hone se pahale nimitta kise kahanA aura milAnA kaise ? prazna 50-upAdAna aura nimitta ko jAnane se kyA phala AnA cAhiye ? uttara-(1) vyavahAra se moha choddnaa| (2) vyavahAranaya me avirodha rUpa se madhyastha rahanA / (3) trikAlI upAdAna ke dvArA moha kA abhAva karanA / (4) maiM para kA nahI hU~, para mere nahIM hai aisA svapara kA paraspara sva-svAmI samvandha ko tyAga denaa| (5) maiM eka AtmA hI hU~ anAtmA nahI huuN| (6) apane me apane ko ekAgra karanA / (7) dhrauvya ke lie zuddha AtmA hI upalabdha karane yogya hai| (8) adhruva zarIrAdi upalabdha karane yogya nahIM hai| [zrI pravacanasAra gA0 160 se 163 taka ke zabdo me] prazna 51-kaunasA upAdAnakAraNa ho, taba kArya kI utpatti niyama se hotI hai ? uttara-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa ho, taba niyama se kArya kI utpatti hotI hI hai| prazna 52~-pahale kAraNa yA kArya ? uttara- vAstava me sacce kAraNa-kArya kA eka hI samaya hotA hai| phira pahale kAraNa aura phira kArya-aisA prazna hI nahI hai| prazna 53-upAdAna ke kArya ke lie aura nimitta ke kArya ke lie AcAryoM ne kyA zabda batAyA hai ?

Page #149
( 143 ) uttara - upAdAna ke kArya ko "anurUpa" aura nimitta ke kArya ko "anukUla" zabda batAyA hai / prazna 54 - paryAya kA kAraNa para to hai nahIM, parantu dravya bhI kAraNa nahIM aura anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya bhI kAraNa nahIM hai / mAtra usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA hI kAraNa hai| isakI siddhi kaise ho ? ---- uttara - dekho darI, laDDU, cazmA, pustaka yaha cAro pudgala haiM / ina saba me varNa guNa hai saba kI alaga-alaga paryAya kyo hai ? varNa guNa to saba me hai / isalie mAnanA paDegA mAtra usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA hI kAraNa hai / prazna 55 -- usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa ko jAnane se kyA lAbha hai ? uttara- (1) jagata me jo-jo kArya hotA hai vaha usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa se hI hotA hai / (2) para to usakA kAraNa hai hI nahI / ( 3 ) dravya bhI usakA kAraNa nahI hai / (4) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa bhI saccA kAraNa nahI hai / (5) usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI saccA kAraNa aura kArya hai / aisA jAnane se anAdikAla se para me kartA-bhoktA kI khoTI vRddhi kA abhAva hokara dharma kI prApti hotI hai / prazna 56 - kyA nimitta upAdAna se kucha karatA hai ? uttara - bilkula nahI karatA hai, kyoki dono kA svacatuSTya pRthak-pRthak hai / prazna 57 - sonagar3ha me nizcaya kI bAta to ThIka hai, parantu vyavahAra kI bAta ThIka nahIM hai, kyA yaha bAta satya hai ? uttara - eka seTha ke eka laDakA thA / use javAnI me vezyA sevana kA vyasana paDa gayA / jaba seTha ne laDake se laDakA kahane lagA, maiM zAdI nahI karAU~gA / zAdI kI bAta kahI to parantu seTha ne socA, yaha

Page #150
( 144 ) kaise ho sakatA hai| seTha ne khAnadAna kI eka sundara laDakI se usakI sagAI kara dii| laDakA kahatA hai ki mujhe zAdI nahI karanI hai, kyoki maiM usakA muha dekhUgA, to andhA ho jaauuNgaa| taba seTha ne laDakI vAlo ko bulAkara kahA ki hamAre yahA~ laDake kI A~kha para paTTI vA~dha kara phere hote hai aisA rivAja hai| ___laDakI vAlA rAjI ho gayA aura zAdI ho gii| laDakA ghara me A~kho para paTTI bA~dhakara Ave, turanta calA jaave| laDakI hoziyAra thI use patA cala gayA, merA pati vezyA-gAmI hai tathA vezyA ne use kahA hai tU usakA muha dekhegA to andhA ho jaavegaa| eka dina laDakI ne apane pati kA hAtha pakaDakara kahA, Apako mAlUma hai ki Apa mujhe dekhe to andhe ho jaavoge| Apa mere kahe se eka A~kha para paTTI ba~dhI rahane do aura eka A~kha se mujhe dekha lo| to usane aisA hI kiyA, to dekhA A~kha to phUTI nhii| taba usane kahA aba dUsarI para paTTI bA~dha lo aura aba dUsarI A~kha se mujhe dekho tava vaha bhI nahI phUTI, taba usane kahA aba dono A~kho se mujhe dekho, to usane jaba dono paTTiyo ko uThAkara dekhA to A~khe phUTI nahI, aura taba vezyA para se dRSTi uTha gaI, usI prakAra sonagaDha kA nizcaya to Thoka hai to bhAI vahA~ jAkara dekha, kasA vyavahAra sonagaDha me hai lAkho rupayo kA dAna hotA hai, nAma koI likhAtA nahIM / do vAra pravacana, pUjA bhakti hotI hai vaha dekha / kandamUla koI khAtA nahI, rAtri ko pAnI pIte nahI / jyAdAtara pati-patni brahmacarya se rahate hai| 60 ke karIba bahine Ajanma brahmacarya se rahatI hai| isalie he bhAI / nizcaya to sonagaDha se sIkhanA paDegA, parantu vyavahAra bhI sonagaDha se sIkhanA paDegA / jahA~ para vyavahAra ko heya kahA jAtA hai / dekho, vahA~ kA vyavahAra kaisA hai| isalie sonagaDha kI nizcaya kI bAta ThIka hai aura vyavahAra kI bAta ThIka nahI hai yaha bAta bilkula jhUTha hai / prazna'58-nimitta kartA se kyA tAtparya hai ?

Page #151
( 145 ) uttara-isane aisA kiyA to aisA huaa| aisI mAnyatA honA yaha nimittakartA se tAtparya hai| prazna 56-nimitta kartA ke prazna uThAkara samajhAiye? uttara-(1) maiMne zubhabhAva kiyA to jIva vaca gyaa| (2) maiMne azubhabhAva kiyA to jIva mara gyaa| (3) maiMne gAlI do to use krodha aayaa| (4) jIva ne vikAra kiyA to karma vadha haa| maine bhAva kiye to aise-aise kArya hue Adi nimittakartA ke udAharaNa haiN| prazna 60-nimittakartA mAnane kA kyA phala hai ? uttara-cAro gatiyo me ghUmakara nigoda nimittakartA mAnane kA phala hai| jaya mahAvIra-jaya mahAvIra nimitta-namittika pAMcavaoN adhikAra prazna 1-nimitta-naimittika sambandha kise kahate haiM ? uttara-jaba upAdAna svaya svata kAryarUpa pariNamina hotA hai| taba bhAvarUpa (astirUpa) yA abhAvarUpa (nAsti rUpa) kisa ucita (yogya) nimittakAraNa kA usake sAtha sambandha hai| yaha batalAne ke lie usa kArya ko naimittika kahate haiN| isa prakAra bhinna-bhinna padArthoM ke svatantra sambandha ko nimitta-naimittika sambandha kahate hai| prazna 2-nimitta-naimittika saMbaMdha kisameM hotA hai ? uttara-nimitta-naimittika sambandha do svatantra paryAyo ke bIca meM hotA hai|

Page #152
( 146 ) prazna 3 - kyA nimitta naimittika saMbaMdha parataMtratA kA sUcaka hai ? uttara - bilkula nahI, kyoki nimitta - naimittika savadha paraspara svatantratA kA sUcaka hai / paratantratA kA sUcaka nahI hai / parantu naimittika ke sAtha kauna nimitta rUpa padArtha hai usakA vaha jJAna karAtA hai / prazna 4 - kArya ko nimitta kI apekSA kyA kahate haiM ? uttara - naimittika kahate hai / prazna 5 - kArya ko upAdAna kI apekSA kyA kahate haiM ? uttara - upAdeya kahate hai / prazna 6 - nimitta naimittika kA dravya, kSetra, kAla bhAva eka hI hai yA pRthaka-pRthaka hai ? uttara - nimittanaimittika kA dravya, kSetra, kAla bhAva bhinna-bhinna hai / -- prazna 7 - kyA nimittanaimittika sambandha eka dravya me usako paryAya ke sAtha hotA hai ? } uttara - bilkula nahI, nimitta naimittika sabadha do pRthak-pRthak svatantra paryAyo ke bIca me hotA hai / eka dravya me usakI paryAya ke sAtha nahI hotA hai / prazna 8- -aneka nimitta kAraNo me kauna-kauna se bheda paDate haiM ? uttara - aneka nimitta kAraNo me jo mukhya nimitta ho use antaraga ( nimitta ) kAraNa kahA jAtA hai / aura gauNa nimitta ho use vahiraga nimitta kAraNa kahA jAtA hai / prazna -jIva ne vikAra kiyA to karmabadha huA / isane nimittanaimittika batAo ? uttara - karmavadha huA naimittika aura jIva kA vikAra nimitta / prazna 10 - 'karmabadha huA' isameM karma ko kitane prakAra kI dazA hotI hai ?

Page #153
( 147 ) uttara - prakRti- pradeza- sthiti aura anubhAga cAra prakAra kI hotI hai / prazna 11- prakRti, pradeza huA isame nimitta naimittika kauna hai ? uttara - prakRti - pradeza naimittika, ora yoga guNa kI vikArI paryAya nimitta / prazna 12 - sthiti, anubhAga huA isame nimitta - naimittika kauna hai ? uttara --- sthiti anubhAga huA naimittika aura kapAyabhAva nimitta / prazna 13 - karmavandha huA, isame pRthaka-pRthaka nimittanaimittika kisa prakAra hue jarA spaSTa samajhAiye uttara- (1) prakRti- pradeza kA vadha huA naimittika aura yoga guNa kI vikArI paryAya nimitta, (2) sthiti - anubhAga huA naimittika aura kaSAyabhAva nimitta / karmavadhana ke lie AtmA ke yogaguNa ke vikArI pariNamana ko bahiraga nimitta kAraNa kahA aura karmabaMdhana ke lie jIva ke kaSAyabhAva ko antaraMga nimitta kAraNa kahA / parantu karmabaMdhana ke lie dono nimitta dharma dravya ke samAna hai / parantu nimitto kI pahicAna ke lie spaSTa kiyA hai / prazna 14 - karmabandha me yoga kI vikArI paryAya aura kaSAyabhAva kaise nimitta haiM ? uttara - vAstava me dono vahiraMga nimitta hai / prazna 15 - karmabandhana ke lie Apane yoga ke vikArI pariNamana ko bahiraga nimitta aura kaSAya ko antaraga nimitta kyo kahA hai ? uttara - (1) kapAya kI mukhyatA batAne ke lie kapAya ko ataraga nimitta kAraNa kahA hai aura yogaguNa ke vikArI pariNamana kI goNatA batAne ke lie vahiraMga nimitta kAraNa kahA hai| prazna 16 - karmabandhana ke lie antaraga aura bahiraMga nimitta kAraNa batAne ke pIche kyA rahasya hai

Page #154
( 148 ) uttara-(1) prakRti-pradeza kA naimittikapanA apane upAdAna se huA, yoga guNa ke vikArI pariNamana ke kAraNa nhii| yoga guNa me vikArI pariNamana ke kAraNa prakRti-pradeza kA kArya huA aisI zraddhA choDanI hai / (2) sthiti-anubhAga kA naimittakapanA apane upAdAna se huA, kapAya ke kAraNa nhii| kaSAya kA pariNamana hone ke kAraNa, kArmANavargaNA me sthiti anubhAga huA, aisI zraddhA choDanI / prazna 17-darzana mohanIya ke upazama se aupazamika samyaktva kI prApti huI, isame nimitta-naimittika sambandha batAo? uttara-aupazamika samyaktva kI prApti naimittika aura darzana mohanIya kA upazama nimitta / prazna 18-aupazamika samyaktva me darzana mohanIya karma kA upazama nimitta batAyA hai| isake alAvA dUsarA koI nimitta hai ? uttara-saccA guru dUsarA nimitta hai| prazna 16-darzanamohanIya kA upazama aura guru, yaha do aupazamika samyaktva meM nimitta hue, ina dono nimittoM ko kyA kahA jAtA hai ? uttara-darzana mohanIya kA upazama ataraga nimitta aura guru bAhya nimitt| prazna 20-guru jo nimitta hai usameM bhI koI bheda hai ? uttara-hA~ hai, jJAnI guru kA abhiprAya antaraga nimitta aura vANI bahiraga nimitt| prazna 21-antaraMga nimitta, bahiraMga nimitta yaha nimitto ke bheda kyo kiye ? uttara-(1) nimitto ke upabheda batAne ke lie bheda kie hai| (2) samyagdarzana apane zraddhA guNa ke pariNamana ke kAraNa huA hai, nimitto ke kAraNa nahI, (3) jitane bhI nimitta haiN| cAhe antaraga ho yA bahiraga ho vaha saba nimitta dharma dravya ke samAna hI haiN|

Page #155
( 146 ) prazna 22-bAI ne roTI banAI, isameM nimitta-naimittika kyA hai? uttara-roTI banI naimittika aura bAI kA rAga nimitta / prazna 23-karma ke kAraNa rAga huA, isame nimitta naimittika batAo? uttara-rAga huA naimittika aura cAritra mohanIya karma kA udaya nimitt| prazna 24-dhobI ne kapaDA dhoyA, isame nimitta-naimittika batAo? uttara-kapaDA dhoyA naimittika aura dhobI kA rAga nimitta / prazna 25-dharma dravya jIva ko calAtA hai isame nimitta-naimittika kyA hai ? uttara-jIva calA naimittika aura dharma dravya nimitta / prazna 26-(1) bar3haI ratha banAtA hai| (2) maiM roTI khAtA huuN| (3) karmoM ke abhAva se jIva mokSa jAtA hai| (4) deha se sukha hotA hai| (5) maiMne vistarA bichaayaa| (6) jJAnAvaraNIya ke kSayopazama se jJAna kA ughADa hotA hai| (7) kevalajJAna lokAloka ko jAnatA hai| (8) darzanamohanIya ke kSaya se kSAyika samyaktva hotA hai| (8) maiMne kitAva bnaaii| (10) maiMne meja utthaaii| ina saba me nimitta-naimittika sambandha lagAo? uttara-(1) ratha banA naimittika aura baDhaI kA rAga nimitta / isI prakAra vAkI ke ha vAkyo ke uttara do| prazna 27-sakala cAritra ko prApti haI, isame nimitta-namittika kyA hai ? uttara-sakala cAritra naimittika aura anantAnubandhI Adi tIna caukaDI rUpa dravya karma kA abhAva nimitta /

Page #156
( 150 ) prazna 28-aupAmika samyaktva kI prApti huI, isame nimitta namittika kyA hai? uttara-aupagamika samyaktva naimittika aura darzana mohanIya kA upanama aura anantAnuvandhI krodha, mAna, mAyA, lobha dravyakarma kA kSayopagamAdi nimitta / prazna 26-mithyAtva dazA huI isameM nimitta-namittika kyA hai ? uttara-mithyAtva dadyA nemittika aura darzana mohanIya karma kA udaya nimitt| prazna 30-bArahaveM guNasthAna meM alpajJa dazA hai isame nimittanaimittika kyA hai ? uttara-12ve guNasthAna me kSayopagama dagA naimittika aura jJAnAvaraNIya, darganAvaraNIya, antarAya karma kA kSayopagama nimitta / prazna 31-kevalajJAna me nimitta-naimittika kauna hai ? uttara-kevalajJAna namittika Ara kevalajAnAvaraNIya karma kA abhAva nimitta / prazna 32-arhata dazA meM siddhapada nahIM hai, isame nimitta-namittika kauna hai ? uttara-arhata ko siddha pada nahIM naimittika aura cAra aghAti karma kA udaya nimitta he| prazna 33-sacce zrAvakapate me nimitta-naimittika kyA hai ? uttara-saccA zrAvakapanA naimittika aura darganamohanIya sahita anantAnubandhI aura apratyAkhyAna cAritra mohanIya karma kA abhAva nimitt| prazna 34-jIva kI vibhAvavyaMjana paryAya me, nimitta naimittika kauna hai ? uttara-jIva kI vibhAvavyajana paryAya naimittika, zarIra aura nAma karma kA sadbhAva nimitta /

Page #157
( 151 ) prazna 35-jIva ko svabhAvavyaMjana paryAya meM nimitta-naimittika kyA hai ? uttara-jIva kI svabhAvavyajana paryAya naimittika, zarIra aura nAma karma kA abhAva nimitta / prazna 36-zuklalezyA meM nimitta-naimittika kyA hai ? uttara-zuklalezyA kA bhAva naimittika aura cAritra mohanIya karma kA mada udaya nimitta / prazna 37-no kaSAya me nimitta-naimittika kyA hai ? / uttara-no kaSAya kA bhAva naimittika aura cAritra mohanIya karma kA udaya nimitta / prazna 38-akaSAya bhAva me nimitta-naimittika kyA hai ? uttara-akaSAya bhAva naimittika aura guNasthAna pramANa cAritra mohanIya karma kA abhAva nimitta / prazna 36-zukladhyAna me nimitta-naimittika kyA hai ? uttara-zukladhyAna naimittika aura sajvalana cAritra mohanIya karma kA guNasthAna anusAra abhAva nimitta / prazna 40-avyAbAdha pratijIvI guNa zuddha huA, isame nimittanaimittika kyA hai ? uttara-avyAvAdha pratijIvI guNa kI zuddha paryAya naimittika aura vedanIya karma kA abhAva nimitta / prazna 41-avagAhana pratijIvI guNa zuddha huA, isame nimittanaimittikapanA kyA hai? uttara-avagAhana pratijIvI guNa kI zuddha paryAya naimittika aura Ayukarma kA abhAva nimitta / / prazna 42-agurulaghutva pratijIvI guNa zuddha pragaTA, to naimittika kyA hai ?

Page #158
( 152 ) uttara-agurulaghutva pratijIvI guNa kI zuddha paryAya naimittika aura gotrakarma kA abhAva nimitta / / prazna 43-sUkSmatva pratijIvI guNa kI zuddha paryAya pragaTI, to nimitta-naimittika kauna hai ? uttara--sUkSmatva pratijIvI guNa kI zuddha paryAya naimittika aura nAma karma kA abhAva nimitt| prazna 44---parama jJAyaka svabhAva me nimitta-naimittika kyA hai ? uttara-parama jJAyaka svabhAva nirapekSa svabhAva hai| isame nimittanaimittika nahI hotA hai| kyoki nimitta-naimittika do svatantra paryAyo ke boca me hotA hai| prazna 45--kyA dravya karma hai, isaliye doSa hai ? uttara-bilkula nahI, kyoki dono dravyo ke dravya, kSetra, kAla, bhAva, pRthak-pRthak hai| isalie dravya karma hai to jIva me doSa huA-- aisA nahIM hai| prazna 46-kyA doSa hai isaliye dravya karma hai ? uttara--vilkula nahI, kyoki dono pRthak-pRthak padArtha haiM / prazna 47-aisA kaunasA dravya hai jisakI paryAya meM nimitta-naimittikapanA na ho? uttara-aisI koI bhI dravya kI paryAya nahIM hai| kyoki paryAya me nimitta-naimittikapane kA svabhAva hai aura svabhAva kA kabhI abhAva hotA nahI hai| prazna 4jIva kI azuddha dazA me nimitta-naimittika sambandha kyA hai ? uttara---jIva kI azuddha dazA naimittika aura dravyakarma kA udaya nimitta / prazna 46-jIva pudgala gati kare to nimitta-naimittika kyA hai ?

Page #159
( 153 ) uttara-jIva-yudgala kA gamana honA naimittika aura dharma dravya nimitta / prazna 50-jIva-pudgala sthiti kare to nimitta-naimittika kyA" uttara-jIva-pudgala kI sthiti honA naimittika aura adharma dravya nimitt| prazna 51-chaho dravyo ko avakAza dene me nimitta-naimittika kyA hai ? uttara-chaho dravya kA apane-apane sthAna (kSetra) me rahanA naimittika aura AkAza dravya nimitta / prazna 52-chaho dravyo ke pariNamana me nimitta-naimittika kyA" uttara-chaho dravyo kA pariNamana naimittika aura kAla dravya nimitta / prazna 53-kSAyika samyagdarzana kI prApti me nimitta-naimittika kyA hai ? uttara kSAyika samyagdarzana naimittika aura sAto karma prakRtiyo kA abhAva antaraga nimitta / prazna 54-rAgAdi kA honA, isame nimitta-naimittika kauna hai ? uttara-rAgAdi kA honA naimittika aura cAritra mohanIya kA udaya aura nokarma nimitta / prazna 55-chaThe guNasthAna me nimitta-naimittikapanA kyA hai ? uttara-(a) zuddha pariNati naimittika aura tIna cokaDI karma kA abhAva nimina tathA (A) zubha bhAva naimittika aura sajvalana krodhAdi. kA tIvra udaya nimitta / / prazna 56-sAtaveM guNasthAna meM nimitta-naimittika kyA hai ? uttara-(a) rAga kA avyakta rUpa se sadabhAva naimittika aura

Page #160
( 154 ) sajvalana-krodhAdi kA mada udaya nimitta tathA (A) zuddhopayoga dazA naimittika aura tIna caukaDI tathA sajvalana ke tIna udaya kA abhAva nimitta / prazna 57-jIva kA svabhAva dravya karma ke abhAvarUpa kaba hotA uttara-jIba ke svabhAva me dravyakarma ke abhAva kA aura sadbhAva kA koI sambandha nahI hai kyoki svabhAva trikAla eka rUpa rahatA hai| prazna 58-mokSamArga meM prakAza kisakA hai ? uttara--savara-nirjarArUpa nizcaya ratnatrayarUpa janadharma kA prakAza prazna 59-kyA upAmazreNI aura kSapakazreNI kA kAraNa dravya'karma hai ? uttara-bilkula nahIM, kyoki zreNI kA kAraNa usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hai / prazna 60-eka jIva ananta kAla pahale mokSa gayA aura eka aba jA rahA hai aura anya Age jAveMge / usakA kyA kAraNa hai ? uttara-'usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa' prazna 61-kyA jIva ko azuddhatA me upAdAna kAraNa dravya karma uttara-vilkula nahI, kyoki usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA 'kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa saccA upAdAna kAraNa hai, dravyakarma kAraNa 'nahI hai| prazna 62-nimitta-naimittika jAnane se kauna sI khoTI mAnyatA dUra ho jAnI cAhiye ? uttara-eka-dUsare me karane-karAne kI aura bhoktA-bhogya kI buddhi naSTa ho jAnI caahie|

Page #161
( 155 ) prazna 63-kyA kevalajJAniyo ko hI pAramArthika sukha hai ? uttara-hA~, kevalajJAniyo ko hI pAramArthika sukha hai aisA jJAnI jAnate hai| prazna 64-phevalajJAniyoM ko hI pAramAthika sukha hai, aisA kahIM pravacanasAra me AyA hai ? uttara-gAthA 62 me AyA hai ki --- sUNI ghAtikarma vihIna ko sukha, vaha sukha utkRSTa hai| zraddhe na vaha abhavya hai aru bhavya vaha sammata kare // artha-jinake ghAtikarma naSTa ho gaye hai| unakA mukha (sarva) sukho me utkRSTa hai| yaha sunakara jo zraddhA nahI karate, ve abhavya haiN| aura bhavya use svIkAra karate haiM-usakI zraddhA karate haiM / prazna 65-pAramArthika sukha kI zuruAta kauna se guNasthAna se hotI hai ? uttara-cauthe guNasthAna se pAramArthika sukha kI zuruAta hotI hai jinako pAramArthika sukha kI zuruAta hotI hai| vaha alpakAla me hI mokSa ko prApta karate hai| prazna 66-jJAniyo ko sukha hai aura jJAna bhI hai| aisA kauna kahate haiM ? ___ uttara-jina-jinavara aura jinavaravRSabha kahate hai| prazna 67-jJA niyo ko pAramArthika sukha hai aura jJAna bhI hai| aisA jAnakara jJAno kyA karate haiM ? uttara---apane jAyaka svabhAva me vizepa sthiratA karake alpakAla me hI mokSa ko prApta karate hai| prazna 68-jJAniyoM ko pAramArthika sukha hai aura jJAna bhI hai| ajJAniyo ko nA mukha hai aura nA hI jJAna hai| aisA samyaktva ke sanmukha pAtra ajJAnI sunakara kyA karatA hai ?

Page #162
( 156 ) uttara-samyaktva ke sanmukha pAtra ajJAnI apane zAyaka svabhAva kI zraddhA karake krama se jJAniyo kI taraha mokSa ko prApta karate hai| prazna 66-jJAniyo ko hI pAramArthika sukha hai aura jJAna bhI hai ajJAniyo ko nA sukha hai aura nA hI jJAna hai| aisA apAtra ajJAnI sunakara kyA karatA hai ? uttara-bhagavAna kI vANI kA virodha karake cAro gatiyo me ghUmatA huA nigoda calA jAtA hai| prazna 70-jJAniyo ko pAramArthika sukha aura jJAna kyo hai ? uttara-jJAniyo ko apanA zraddhAna jJAna-AcaraNa hone se tathA vastusvarUpa kA jJAna hone se pAramArthika sukha aura jJAna dono vartate hai| prazna 71--ajJAniyo ko pAramArthika sukha aura jJAna kyo nahIM uttara-ajJAniyo ko apanA zraddhAna-jAna-AcaraNa nA hone se tathA vastusvarUpa kA jJAna nA hone se pAramArthika sukha aura jJAna nahI hai| prazna 72-vastusvarUpa kaisA hai ? uttara-"anAdinidhana vastue~ bhinna-bhinna apanI-apanI maryAdA sahita pariNamita hotI haiM, koI kisI ke AdhIna nahI hai, koI kisI ke pariNamita karAne se pariNamita nahI hotI'' aisA vastusvarUpa hai| prazna 73-"maiM subaha uThakara yahA~ AyA" isa vAkya me vastusvarUpa (nimitta-naimittika) kisa prakAra hai ? uttara-(a) maiM AtmA anAdiananta jJAyaka svarUpa ananta guNoM kA dhArI amUrtika pradezo kA puMja huuN| mujha AtmA kA apanI kriyAvatI zakti ke kAraNa gamanarUpa pariNamana huA-phira sthirarUpa pariNamana huaa| gamanarUpa pariNamana me dharma dravya nimitta hai aura sthirarUpa pariNamana me adharma dravya nimitta hai| mujha AtmA apane asakhyAta

Page #163
( 157 ) pradezo me rahA / isame nimitta AkAza dravya hai| mujha AtmA ke ananta guNo me nirantara pariNamana usakI yogyatA se hotA hai / usame nimitta kAladravya hai| (A) audArikagarIra, taijasazarIra, kArmANazarIra, bhASA aura mana kA mujha AtmA ke sAtha mAtra eka kSetrAvagAhI sambandha hai tathA vyavahAranaya se jJeya-jJAyaka sambandha hai| vAstava me to jJAna paryAya jJeya aura mujha AtmA jJAyaka hai| parantu yaha bhI bheda hai aura bheda ke lakSya se rAgI jIva ko rAga kI utpatti hotI hai| ata mujha AtmA jJAyaka so jJAyaka hI hai| isa prakAra abheda ke lakSya se jIva kA kalyANa hotA hai| ata mujha Atma jJAyaka-jJAyaka / (i) audArika zarIra, tejasazarIra, kArmANazarIra, bhASA aura mana me ananta pudagala paramANu haiN| pratyeka paramANu apanI-apanI kriyAvatI zakti ke kAraNa gamana karatA hai jisame dharmadravya nimitta hai aura gamana karake sthira hotA hai usame adharmadravya nimitta hai aura audArikazarIra Adi me ananta pudgala paramANu apane-apane pradeza me avagAhana karate haiN| usame nimitta AkAzadravya hai| audArikazarIra Adi me ananta pudgala paramANu hai aura pratyeka paramANu me ananna-ananta guNa haiN| ve saba apanI-apanI yogyatA se pariNamana karate haiM usame kAladravya nimitta hai| yaha saba mUrtika dravyo kA piNDa, prasiddha jJAnAdi guNo se rahita, jinakA navIna sayoga huA hai aisA audArika Adi zarIra (pudgala) para haiM / aisI vastusthiti hai| aisA vastusvarUpa (nimitta-naimittika) jAnane-mAnane se pAtra jIvo kI para me se kartRtvabuddhi chUTa jAtI hai| ve una sabakA jJAtA-dRSTA hI rahate hai / ata sukha aura jJAna bhI hara samaya rahatA hai aura krama mokSarUpI lakSmI ke nAtha bana jAte haiN| prazna 74-prazna 73 ke anusAra vastusvarUpa kA jJAna arthAt nimitta-naimittika sambandha kA saccA jJAna aura zraddhAna kA phala bhagavAna ne kyA batAyA hai ? uttara-"bhava bandhana taD-tar3a TUTa paDe, khila jAve antara kI

Page #164
( 158 ) kaliyaoN" arthAt anAdi kA bhava bandhana samApta hokara Rma se mokSa kI prApti isakA phala batAyA hai| prazna 75---'mai subaha uThakara yahA~ AyA' ajJAnI isame kaisA nimitta-naimittika sambandha mAnatA hai ? uttara--ajJAnI kI mAnyatA me mai AtmA thA to zarIra uThakara AyA" yA zarIra thA to maiM AtmA aayaa|" isa prakAra ananta para dravyo me apanepane kI-mamakArapane kI, para ko apane rUpa karane kI apane ko pararUpa karane kI khoTI vRddhi pAI jAtI hai jisakA phala nigoda hai arthAta ulTA nimitta-naimittika sambandha mAnane kA phala nigoda hai| prazna 76-ajJAnI kA ajJAna dUra karane kA upAya bhagavAna ne kyA batAyA hai ? uttara-jisa prakAra koI mohita hokara muda ko jIvita mAne yA jilAnA cAhe to Apa hI dukhI hotA hai tathA use murdA mAnanA aura yaha jilAne se jiyegA nhiiN| aisA mAnanA so hI dukha dUra hone kA hai upAya / usI prakAra mithyAdRSTi padArthoM ko anyathA mAne anyathA pariNamita karAnA cAhe to Apa hI dukhI hotA hai tathA unhe yathArtha mAnanA aura yaha pariNamita karAne se anyathA pariNamita nahIM hoge| aisA mAnanA so hI usa dukha ke dUra hone kA upAya hai| bhrama janita dukha kA upAya bhrama dUra karanA hI hai| so bhrama dUra hone se samyak zraddhAna hotA hai / yahI satya upAya bhagavAna ne batAyA hai| prazna 77-kyA ajJAnI subaha se zAma taka pudgala ke dikhane vAle kAryoM kA nimittakartA bhI nahIM hai ? uttara-vAstava me subaha se zAma taka jitane rUpI padArthoM ke kArya hote haiM unakA kartA pudgala hI haiN| ajJAnI jIva me bhI pudgala ke kAryoM kA nimittakartA nahI hai| parantu ajJAnI ajJAnavaza yaha mAnatA hai ki maiMne roTI banAI, maiMne vyApAra kiyA, maiM hasA, maiM soyA Adi

Page #165
( 159 ) viparIta mAnyatAo me pAgala banA rahatA hai| jisakA phala paramparA nigoda hai| prazna 78-ajJAnI duHkhI kyo hai ? uttara-jaDa kI kriyA apanI mAnane ke kAraNa hI dukhI hai| prazna 76-jJAnI sukhI kyo hai ? uttara-jaDa kI kriyA apanI na mAnane ke kAraNa hI sukhI hai| apanI jAna kiyA hai aisI zraddhA-jJAna hone se hI jJAnI sukhI hai| prazna 80-jitanA jaDa kA kArya hai| kyA usakA kartA-karma aura bhoktA-bhogya sarvathA jaDa hI hai ? uttara-hA~, bhAI jaDa kA katA-karma, bhoktA-bhogya sarvathA jaDa hI haiM jIva nahI hai| prazna 81-kyA ajJAnI jaDa ke kArya meM nimitta bhI nahIM hai ? uttara-ajJAnI jaDa ke kArya me nimitta bhI nahI hai| parantu jaDa ke kArya meM karatA hU~ aisI mAnyatA hone se dukhI hai| prazna 82-kyA jaDa ke kArya me jJAnI kA nimitta-naimittikapanA nahIM hai ? uttara-nahI hai| kintu mAtra neya-jJAyakapanA vyavahAra se hai| arthAt jJAna kI paryAya naimittika aura jaDa padArtha kI paryAya nimitta hai| prazna 83-'mai bakse ko uThAkara lAyA' isa vAkya me uttara- prazna 73 se 82 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 84-'maiM kapaDe pahanatA hU~ isa vAkya me uttara-prazna 73 se 82 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna =5-'maiMne kapaDA kharIdA' isa vAkya me uttara--prazna 73 se 82 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 86-mokSamArga prakAzaka ke tIsare adhikAra meM nimittanaimittika sambandha ke viSaya me kyA batAyA hai ?

Page #166
( 160 ) uttara-moha ke Aveza se una indriyo ke dvArA viSaya grahaNa karane kI icchA hotI hai| aura una viSayo kA grahaNa hone para, usa icchA ke miTane se, nirAkula hotA hai taba Ananda mAnatA hai| jaise--kuttA haDDI cabAtA hai usase apanA lohU nikale, usakA svAda lekara aisA mAnatA hai ki yaha haDiDayo kA svAda hai| usI prakAra yaha jIva viSayo ko jAnatA hai usase apanA jJAna pravartatA hai, usakA svAda lekara aisA mAnatA hai ki yaha viSaya kA svAda hai| so viSaya me to svAda hai nhii| svaya hI icchA kI thI, use svaya hI jAnakara, svaya hI Ananda mAna "liyA, parantu maiM anAdi-ananta jJAnasvarUpa AtmA hU~-aisA ni kevalajJAna kA (para se bhinna apanI AtmA kA) to anubhavana hai nahI / prazna 87-~~'maiM subaha uThA' isa vAkya ko prazna 86 ke uttara anusAra samajhAiye? prazna 88-'maiM bolA' isa vAkya ko prazna 86 ke uttara anusAra samajhAiye? prazna 86-'maiMne roTI khAI isa vAkya ko prazna 86 ke uttara anusAra samajhAiye ? prazna 60-'maiMne rupayA kamAyA' isa vAkya ko prazna 86 ke uttara anusAra samajhAiye? prazna 61-'maine jIvo kI rakSA kI' isa vAkya ko prazna 86 ke uttara anusAra samajhAiye ? prazna 62-'mai bImAra hU~' isa vAkya ko prazna 86 ke uttara anusAra samajhAiye ? prazna 63--'maiM zAstra pravacana karatA hU~' isa vAkya ko prazna 86 ke uttara anusAra samajhAiye ? prazna 94-'maiM kapar3e ghotA hU~' isa vAkya ko prazna 86 ke uttara anusAra samajhAiye?

Page #167
( 161 ) prazna 65-'maine sinemA dekhA' isa vAkya ko prazna 86 ke uttara anusAra samajhAiye? jaya mahAvIra-jaya mahAvIra vyApyavyApaka chaThA adhikAra prazna 1-vyApyavyApaka kise kahate haiM ? uttara-(1) jo sarva avasthAo me rahe vaha vyApaka hai aura eka avasthA vizeSa (usa vyApaka kA) vyApya hai| prazna 2-vyApyavyApaka ke paryAyavAcI zabda kyA-kyA haiM ? uttara-vyApaka-vyApya kaho, kartA-karma kaho, pariNAmI pariNAma kaho, trikAlI upAdAna-upAdeya kaho eka hI bAta hai| prazna 3-dravya-guNa-paryAya meM vyApya-vyApaka kisameM hai ? uttara-dravya aura guNa vyApaka hai aura paryAya vyApya hai| prazna 4-kyA vyApya-vyApakapanA bhinna-bhinna padArthoM meM hotA uttara-bilkula nahI, kyoki vyApya-vyApakapanA tatsvarUpa me hI (abhinna sattAvAna padArtho me hI) hotA hai| atasvarUpa me (jinakI sattA bhinna-bhinna hai aise padArthoM me) nahI hI hotA hai| prazna 5-vyApya-vyApaka jAnane se kyA lAbha haiM ? uttara-sAmAnya me se vizepa AtA hai arthAt vyApaka me se vyApya AtA hai, para se nhiiN| aisA jAnane se jJAnI ho jAtA hai aura anAdi

Page #168
( 162 ) se para padArtho me jo kartA-karma mAnA thA usakA abhAva ho jAtA hai| jagata kA jJAtA dRSTA sAkSIbhUta vana jAtA hai| prazna 6-samyagdarzana kA vyApya-vyApaka kauna hai aura kauna nahIM uttara-AtmA kA zraddhA guNa vyApaka aura samyagdarzana vyApya hai| aura deva-guru-zAstra, darzana mohanIya ke upazamAdi vyApaka nahIM hai| prazna 7-kevalajJAna huA isameM vyApya-vyApaka kauna hai aura kauna nahIM hai ? uttara-AtmA kA jJAna guNa vyApaka hai aura kevalajJAna vyApya hai aura vajravRSabhanArAca sahanana, jJAnAvaraNIya kA abhAva, cauthA kAla aura zubhabhAva vyApaka nahI hai| prazna 8-kyA roTI vyApya aura bAI vyApaka ThIka hai? uttara-bilkula nahI, kyoki ATA vyApaka aura roTI vyApya hai| prazna :-yadi bAI ko vyApaka kahe to kyA hogA? uttara-bAI ke nAza hone kA prasaga upasthita hovegA aura bAI ATA bana jAve to aisA kahA jA sakatA hai| lekina vyApya-vyApaka sambandha eka hI dravya kA usakI paryAya me hotA hai do dravyo meM nahA hotA hai| prazna 10-kyA jIva ke vikArI pariNAma vyApaka aura pudgala ke vikArI pariNAma vyApya, ThIka hai ? uttara-bilkula nahI, kyoki pudagala ke vikArI pariNAma vyApya aura kArmANa vargaNA vyApaka hai| prazna 11-koI kahe, hama to jIva ke vikArI pariNAma vyApaka, aura pudgala kama vyApya aisA hI mAneMge, to kyA doSa AvegA' uttara-jIva ke nAza kA prasaga upasthita hovegA aura jApa hokara kANivargaNA bana jAve to aisA kahA jA sakatA hai|

Page #169
( 163 ) vyApya vyApaka savadha eka dravya kA usakI paryAya me hI hotA hai bhinnabhinna padArthoM me nahI hotA hai / prazna 12-kyA dravyakarma kA udaya vyApaka aura sasAra avasthA vyApya ThIka hai ? uttara-bilkula nahIM, kyoki sasAra avasthA vyApya aura jIva vyApaka hai| prazna 13-koI kahe, hama to karma ke udaya ko vyApaka aura saMsAra avasthA vyApya, aisA hI mAneMge to kyA doSa AvegA ? uttara-jIva ke nAza kA prasaga upasthita hovegA aura karma ke udaya ko jIva bana jAne kA prasaga upasthita hovegaa| lekina vyApyavyApaka samvandha eka hI dravya kA usakI paryAya me hotA hai bhinna-bhinna dravyo me nahI hotA hai| prazna 14-kyA dravya karma kA abhAva vyApaka aura saMsAra kA abhAva vyApya, ThIka hai? uttara-bilakula nahIM, kyoki sasAra kA abhAva vyApya aura jIva vyApaka hai| prazna 15--koI kahe pharma kA abhAva vyApaka aura saMsAra kA abhAva vyApya aisA hI mAne to kyA doSa AvegA? uttara-jIva ke abhAva kA prasaga upasthita hovegA aura karma ke jIva bana jAne kA prasaga upasthita hovegaa| lekina vyApya-vyApaka sambandha eka dravya kA usakI paryAya me hI hotA hai alaga-alaga dravyo me nahI hotA hai| prazna 16-kyA vAyu kA calanA vyApaka aura samudra meM lahara uThI vyApya, ThIka hai? uttara-bilkula nahI, kyoki samudra me lahara uThI vyApya aura samudra vyApaka hai|

Page #170
( 164 ) prazna 17-koI kahe, vAyu kA calanA vyApaka aura samudra me lahara uThI vyApya, to kyA doSa AvegA? uttara-samudra ke naSTa hone kA prasaga upasthita hovegA aura vAyu kA calanA naSTa hokara samudra bana jAne kA prasaga upasthita hovegaa| kyoki vyApya-vyApaka sambandha eka dravya kA usakI paryAya me hotA hai bhinna-bhinna dravyo kI paryAyo me nahI hotA hai / prazna 15-kyA vAyu kA na calanA vyApaka aura taraMga na uThI vyApya, ThIka hai? uttara-bilkula nahI, kyoki samudra me lahara na uThI vyApya aura samudra vyApaka hai| prazna 16-koI kahe, havA nA calI vyApaka aura taraMga nA uThI vyApya, to kyA doSa AvegA? uttara--samudra ke naSTa hone kA prasaga upasthita hovegA aura vAyu kA nAza hokara samudra bana jAne kA prasaga upasthita hovegA, lekina vyApya-vyApaka sambandha eka dravya kA usakI paryAya me hotA hai bhinnabhinna dravyo kI paryAyo me nahI hotA hai / prazna 20-vikArI bhAva ahetuka hai yA sahetuka hai ? uttara-vAstava me vikArI bhAva ahetuka hai, kyoki pratyeka dravya kA pariNamana svatatra hai / aura vikArI paryAya ke samaya nimitta hotA hai isa apekSA sahetuka hai| prazna 21-vikArI bhAva ahetuka hai yA sahetuka, isameM koI dUsarI aura bhI apekSA hai ? uttara-(1) vikArI bhAva AtmA svatantra rUpa se karatA hai vaha apanA hetu hai isa apekSA sahetuka hai| aura karma saccA hetu nahI hai isa apekSA ahetuka hai| prazna 22-tuma vikArI bhAva ko AtmA kA svabhAva kahate ho

Page #171
aura svabhAva kA kabhI abhAva hotA nhiiN| isaliye vikAra ko karmakRta mAnanA caahie| kyA yaha ThIka hai? uttara-(1) vikArI bhAva vyApya aura dravyakarma vyApaka, aisA mAne to vyApya-vyApaka sambandha nahI banegA, kyoki vyApya-vyApaka sambandha eka dravya kA usakI paryAya me hI hotA hai bhinna-bhinna dravyo meM nahI hotA hai / isalie AtmA vyApaka aura vikArI bhAva vyApya aisA mAnane yogya hai| (2) hama vikAra ko eka samaya kA vikArI svabhAva kahate hai trikAlI svabhAva nahI kahate haiN| (3) yadi jIva vikAra ko eka samaya kA svaya kA aparAdha mAne, to trikAlI svabhAva ke Azraya se vikAra kA abhAva kara sakatA hai| (4) yadi vikAra ko karmakRta mAnA jAve to jIva kabhI nigoda se bhI nahIM nikale, jahA~ jo paDA ho vahI par3A rhegaa| prazna 23-zuddhanaya kI dRSTi se rAgAdika kA vyApya-vyApaka kauna hai ? uttara-rAgAdibhAva vyApya aura pudgala vyApaka hai| prazna 24-azuddha nizcayanaya se rAgAdika kA vyApya-vyApaka kauna hai ? uttara--rAgAdi bhAva vyApya aura ajJAnI jIva kA cAritra guNa vyApaka hai| prazna 25-dravya-guNa aura paryAya meM vyApya-vyApaka kauna hai ? uttara-dravya-guNa vyApaka hai aura paryAya vyApya hai| prazna 26-vyApya-vyApaka ke paryAyavAcI zabda kyA-kyA haiM ? uttara-vyApya-vyApaka kaho, kartA-karma bhAva kaho eka hI bAta hai| kyoki vyApya-vyApaka bhAva ke binA kartA-karma kI sthiti nahI ho sakatI hai| prazna 27-kundakunda bhagavAna ne samayasAra banAyA-isame vyApya vyApaka batAo?

Page #172
( 166 ) uttara-javAnI uttara do| prazna 28-maiM ha~sA-isameM vyApya-vyApaka kyA hai ? uttara-jabAnI uttara do| prazna 26-mai bolA-isameM vyApya-vyApaka kyA hai ? uttara-jabAnI uttara do| prazna 30-mai uThA-isameM vyApya-vyApaka kyA hai ? uttara-maukhika uttara do| prazna 31-maiMne kitAba uThAI-isame vyApya-vyApaka kyA hai ? uttara-maukhika uttara do| prazna 32-~-maiMne dukAna banAI-isame vyApya-vyApaka kyA hai ? uttara--maukhika uttara do| jaya mahAvIra jaya mahAvIra sAtavA~ adhikAra samayasAra gAthA sau ke cAra bolo kA spaSTIkaraNa prazna 1-pUrvaka kA kyA artha hai dRSTAnta dekara samajhAiye ? uttara--'pUrvaka' kA artha abhAva hai ? jaise --(1) sasArapUrva (abhAva karake) mokSa hotA hai| (2) zrutajJAna matijJAna pUrvaka (abhA karake) hotA hai / (3) zubhabhAva pUrvaka (abhAva karake) zuddhabhAva ho

Page #173
( 167 ) hai| (4) mithyAtvapUrvaka (abhAva karake) samyagdarzana hotA hai| (5) zrutajJAnapUrvaka (abhAva karake) kevalajJAna hotA hai| prazna 2-zrI samayasAra gAthA 100 ke cAra bola kyA-kyA haiM ? uttara-(1) yadi AtmA vyApya-vyApaka bhAva se para dravya kA kartA bane, to tanmayapane kA prasaga upasthita hovegA arthAt abhiprAya me AtmA ke nAza kA prasaga upasthita hovegA, (pararUpapanA)(2) yadi AtmA nimitta-naimittika bhAva se para dravya kA kartA bane, to nitya katRtva kA prasaga upasthita hovegA arthAta usakA sasAra tIno kAla kAyama rhegaa| (trikAla sasArapanA) (3) ajJAnI kA yoga aura upayoga para dravya kI paryAya kA nimitta-naimittika bhAva se kartA banatA hai, (ajJAnIpanA) (4) jJAnI kA yoga aura upayoga para dravya ko paryAya kA nimitta-naimittika bhAva se kartA nahI, mAtra jJAtA hai| (jJAnIpanA) prazna 3-kumhAra ne ghaDA bnaayaa| kyA kumhAra vyApaka aura ghar3A vyApya ThIka hai? uttara-bilkula ThIka nahI, kyoki miTTI vyApaka aura ghaDA vyApya hai| prazna 4-koI catura kahe, kumhAra dhyApaka aura ghar3A vyApya, to kyA hogA? uttara-kumhAra naSTa hokara yadi miTTI bana jAve to aisA kahA jA sakatA hai| parantu vyApya-vyApaka sambandha tatsvarUpa meM hI hotA hai atatsvarUpa me nahI hotA hai| prazna 5-vyApya-vyApaka sambandha to eka dravya kA usakI paryAya meM hotA hai yaha bAta Apako ThIka hai| lekina ghar3A banA naimittika aura kumhAra nimitta to hai nA? uttara-(1) kumhAra nimitta nahIM hai| yadi kumhAra ghaDe kA nimitta-naimittika bhAva se kartA vane, to kumhAra ko nitya kartRtvapane

Page #174
kA prasaga upasthita hovegA arthAt usakA sasAra tIno kAla kAyama rahegA, (2) nimitta-naimittika do dravyo kI svatantra paryAyo ke bIca me hotA hai| dravya-guNa ke bIca me nimitta-naimittika sambandha nahI hotA hai| dUsarA vola dravya kI apekSA se hai| isalie kumhAra nimitta nahI prazna 6-hama dravya-guNa meM nimitta-naimittika sambandha nahIM mAnate haiN| isaliye Apako vAta ThIka hai| parantu ghar3A banA naimittika aura kumhAra kA usa samaya rAga nimitta to hai nA ? uttara--(1) nimitta to hai, parantu ajJAnI nimitta katA mAnatA hai / nimitta kartA mAnane se jaba-java ghaDA bane to kumhAra ko upasthita rahanA pddegaa| vaha kabhI apane bAla-bacco ko bhI nA khilA sakegA, svarga-mokSa me bhI nA jA skegaa| usakA sasAra tIno kAla kAyama rhegaa| (2) jaise gAya kA mA~sa nikalA ho to kauvvA vahI para baiThatA hai, usI prakAra ajJAnI kI dRSTi nimittakartA para hI rahatI hai, (3) vAstava me ajJAnI paryAya me nimitta-naimittika sambandha zAstra ke AdhAra se kahatA hai usakI buddhi me kartA-karma vaiThA hai| isalie kahatA hai ki eka samaya kA nimitta to hai naa| prazna 7-hamArI dRSTi me kucha baiThA ho hama to yaha pUchate haiM ki ghar3A banA naimittika aura kumhAra kA usa samaya kA rAga nimitta hai nA? uttara-jaise-ghaDA banA 10 nambara para, kumhAra kA rAga bhI 10 nambara para, hAtha Adi kriyA bhI 10 nambara para, yaha tIno alagaalaga dravyo kI svatantra kriyAye hai| ajJAnI ko inakI svatatratA kA patA nahIM haiN| (1) yahA~ para kumhAra ke jJAna kA kaSAyo ke sAtha juDanA -~-use upayoga kahA / (2) aura hAtha Adi kI kriyA kA mana-vacanakAya ke nimitta se Atma pradezo kA calana-vaha yoga hai| (3) ghaDA /

Page #175
( 166 ) vanA--yaha para dravya kI kriyA hai| ajJAnI kA yoga aura upayoga para dravya kI paryAya kA nimitta-naimittika bhAva se kartA banatA hai| hai nhii| cArTa ko dekho trikAlI upAdAna kumhAra kA | AhAravargaNA | miTTI cAritra guNa | ke skadha - our Mur 9 16 mPage #176
( 170 ) bhAva se kartA banatA hai| to kyA jJAnI kumhAra ho vaha svataMtra paryAyo kA nimitta-naimittika bhAva se phartA nahIM hai ? uttara - vAstava me jAnI to na010 asthiratA ke rAga kaa| 10 nambara hAtha Adi kriyA kaa| 10 nambara para ghaDA vnaa| una saba kA cArTa ko dhyAna se dekho trikAlI upAdAna kamhAra kAkAhAra kA hAya mAdi / jJAna guNa cAritra guNa AhAravargaNA miTTI ke skandha ow KWU.. January mprr rmro 595 91 G - 3D anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa / 0 usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa / asthiratA ! hAtha Adi / ghaDA (kArya) upAdeya jJAna huA | kA rAga | kI kriyA | banA mAtra vyayahAra se jJAtA hai| kyoki jJAnI jAnatA hai saba dravya apane

Page #177
( 171 ) apane svarUpa se pariNamate haiM koI kisI kA pariNamAyA pariNamatA naahii| prazna :-kyA jJAnI kumhAra kA ghaDA banane me nimitta-naimittikapanA nahIM hai ? uttara-jJAtApanA hai, jJeya-jJAyaka sambandha bhI vyavahAra se hai, kyoki jJAnI kumhAra to yoga hAtha Adi kriyA kA, asthiratA ke rAga kA, ghaDA banane kI kriyA kA, nimitta-naimittika bhAva se kartA nahI hai mAtra jJAtA hai| prazna 10-kyA jJAno kumhAra jJAyaka aura asthiratA kA rAga, hAtha Adi kI kriyA; ghar3A banA, yaha saba jJeya hai ? uttara-hA~, yaha sava vyavahAra se jJAna kA jeya hai| vAstava me jJAnI ne apanI jJAna paryAya kA jJAna kiyA hai| prazna 11-kyA AtmA jJAyaka aura jJAna kI paryAya jJeya / yaha to ThIka hai? uttara-yaha bhI vyavahAra kathana hai vasa jJAyaka to jJAyaka hI hai| prazna 12-samayasAra kI 100vIM gAthA ke cAra bolo se kyA tAtparya hai ? uttara-(1) dravyadRSTi se to koI dravya anya kisI dravya kA kartA nahI hai| (2) parantu paryAyadRSTi se kisI dravya kI paryAya kisI samaya kisI anya dravya kI paryAya ko nimitta hotI hai| isalie isa apekSA se eka dravya ke pariNAma anya ke pariNAma ke nimitta kartA kahalAte haiM / (3) paramArthata pratyeka dravya apane hI pariNAmo kA kartA hai, anya ke pariNAmo kA anya dravya kartA nahIM hai| prazna 13-100vI gAthA ke cAra bola samajhane se kyA-kyA lAbha haiM ? uttara-(1) para me kartA-bhoktA vuddhi kA abhAva hokara dharma kI prApti honA / (2) paca parAvartana kA abhAva honaa| (3) mithyA HALA

Page #178
( 172 ) tvAdi sasAra ke pA~ca kAraNo kA abhAva honaa| (4) pacama pAriNAmika bhAva kA mahatva aanaa| (5) paca parameSTiyo me ginatI hone lagatI hai| prazna 14-maiM muMha se volatA hU~-isa vAkya me sauvIM gAthA ke cAra bola lagAkara batAo? uttara-prazna 3 se 13 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 15-baDhaI ne aujAro se alamArI banAI-isa vAkya meM sauvI gAthA ke cAra bola lagAkara batAo? uttara-prazna 3 se 13 taka ke anusAra uttara do|| prazna 16-maiMne hAthoM se pustaka banAI- isa vAkya me sauvIM gAyA ke cAra bola lagAkara batAo? uttara prazna 3 se 13 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 17-maiMne jhADU se pharza sApha kiyA-isa vAkya meM sauvIM gAthA ke cAra bola lagAkara batAo? uttara-prazna 3 se 13 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 18-maiMne aujAro se makAna banAyA-isa vAkya me sauvoM gAyA ke cAra bola lagAkara batAo? uttara prazna 3 se 13 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 16-maiM muMha se bolA-isa vAkya meM sauvoM gAthA ke cAra bola lagAkara batAo? uttara-pragna 3 se 13 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 20-maiM dharmadravya ke dvArA TAMgo se calA-isa vAkya meM sovoM gAthA ke cAra bola utArakara batAo? uttara-prazna 3 se 13 taka ke anusAra uttara do| prazna 21-mai bistare se prAta kAla uThatA hU~-isa vAkya meM sauvIM gAthA ke cAra bola utArakara batAo? uttara-pragna 3 se 13 taka ke anusAra uttara do|

Page #179
maiMne muMha se zabda bolA kA cArTa dhyAna se dekho maharUpa bhASAvargaNA trikAlI upAdAna jJAna guNa cAritra guNa AhAravargaNA kAraNa skadha | marm mr m>>3095 | warm surya 079 anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa 10 / (kArya) upAdeya naimittika jAna huA | rAga huA muha hilA | zabda huA - - - pratyakSa parokSa kA hI bheda hai itanA vizeSa jAnanA cAhie ki kevalajJAnI to sAkSAt zuddhAtma svarUpa hI hai aura zru tajJAnI bhI zuddhanaya ke avalambana se AtmA ko | aisA hI anubhava karate haiM / pratyakSa aura parokSa kA hI bheda hai| [ samayasAra (gAthA 320 ke bhAvArtha se) ] -

Page #180
( 174 ) pradezo kA calana, (2) upayoga arthAt jJAna kA kapAyo ke sAtha upayukta honaa-juddnaa| prazna 31-yoga aura upayoga to ghaTAdika va dravya karma kA nimittakartA kahA jAtA hai kintu AtmA ko unakA kartA kyoM nahIM kahA jAtA hai ? uttara--(1) trikAlI AtmA usakA kartA nahI hai / (2) jisako svabhAva kI dRSTi huI hai vaha jJAnI AtmA yoga-upayoga aura ghaTAdika, dravyakarma kA nimitta-naimittika bhAva se bhI kartA nahI hai, mAtra jJAtA hai| isalie AtmA ko unakA kartA nahIM kahA jAtA hai| (3) mAtmA ko sasAra dagA me ajJAna se mAtra yoga upayoga kA kartA kahA jA sakatA hai| parantu kisI bhI AtmA ko ghaTAdika aura dravyakarma kA kartA to kisI bhI apekSA se nahIM kahA jA sakatA hai| prazna 32-maine pairo se sAikila calAI, isa vAkya meM sauvIM gAthA ke cAra bola samajhAiye? uttara-prazna se 13 taka ke anusAra uttara do| jaya mahAvIra jaya mahAvIra sau praznottaro kA AThavaoN adhikAra A. prazna-maiM muMha se bolaa| B. prazna-mujha AtmA aura bolane se muMha khulaa| C. prazna-bolane aura muMha khulane se rAga huaa| . D. prazna-rAga, bolanA aura muMha khulane se jJAna huaa|

Page #181
maiMne muMha se zabda bolA kA cArTa dhyAna se dekho maharUpa bhASAvargaNA trikAlI upAdAna | jJAna guNa cAritra guNoAhAravargaNA kAraNa | skadha | omar msur 9 Porrmusur 9 ] anormy owaisi w anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika 10 upAdAna kAraNa 10 / 10 / (kArya) upAdeya naimittika jJAna huA | rAga huA | muha hilA zabda huA pratyakSa parokSa kA hI bheda hai itanA vizeSa jAnanA cAhie ki kevalajJAnI to sAkSAt zuddhAtma svarUpa hI hai aura zrutajJAnI bhI zuddhanaya ke avalambana se AtmA ko aisA hI anubhava karate haiM / pratyakSa aura parokSa kA hI bheda hai| [ samayasAra (gAthA 320 ke bhAvArtha se) ]

Page #182
( 176 ) - namittika, kArya upAdeya nimitta kAraNa (1) java bolane ko naimittika kahege | tava jJAna-rAga muMha nimitta kAraNa (2) , muMha hilana, " jJAna-rAga bolanA / / (3) rAga kAya, , , jJAna-bolanA muha , , (4) , jJAna kAya, , , , rAgavAlanA muha , , noTa-mujha AtmA yA meM bolane me Ave taba vahA para jJAna-rAga yaha do kAryoM ko ginnaa| - A. prazna-meM muMha se bolA-isa vAkya para nimitta kI paribhASA lagAkara vatAmo? uttara-AtmA kA jJAna, rAga, maha svaya svata volane rUpa pariNamita nA ho, parantu bolane kI utpatti me anukUla hone kA jisa para Aropa mA sake / usa AtmA kA jJAna, rAga aura muMha ko nimitta kAraNa kahate hai| B prazna 1-AtmA kA jJAna, rAga aura bolane ke kAraNa muMha khalA-isa vAkya para nimitta kI paribhASA lagAkara batAo? uttara-AtmA kA jJAna, rAga aura bolanA svaya svata muMha khulane rUpa pariNamita nA ho, parantu muMha khulane kI utpatti me anukUla hone kA jisa para Aropa A sake / usa AtmA kA jJAna, rAga aura bolane ko nimitta kAraNa kahate hai| C. prazna 1-jJAna, bolane aura muMha khulane ke kAraNa rAga huAisa vAkya para nimitta kI paribhASA lagAkara batAo? uttara-jJAna, bolanA aura muMha khulanA svaya svata rAga rUpa parigamita na ho, parantu rAga kI utpatti me anukUla hone kA jisa para

Page #183
( 177 ) Aropa A sake / usa jJAna, bolane aura muMha khulane ko nimitta kAraNa kahate haiN| D. prazna 1-rAga, bolanA, muMha khulane ke kAraNa jJAna huA-isa vAkya para nimitta kI paribhASA lagAkara batAo? __ uttara-rAga, bolanA, muMha khulanA svaya svata jJAnarUpa pariNamita nA ho, parantu jJAna kI utpatti me anukUla hone kA jisa para Aropa A sake / usa rAga, bolanA, muMha khulane ko nimitta kAraNa kahate haiN| A. prazna 2-maiM muMha se bolA-isa vAkya para nimitta-naimittika sambandha kI paribhASA lagAkara batAo? uttara-jaba bhASA vargaNA svaya svata bolane rUpa pariNamita hotA hai taba jAna, rAga aura muMha bhAvarUpa kisa ucita nimitta kAraNa kA bolane ke sAtha sambandha hai| yaha batalAne ke lie bolane ke kArya ko naimittika kahate haiM / isa prakAra jJAna, rAga, muMha aura bolane ke bhinnabhinna padArthoM ke svatantra sambandha ko nimitta-naimittika sambandha kahate haiN| ____B. prazna 2-jJAna, rAga aura bolane ke kAraNa muMha khulA-isa vAkya para nimitta-naimittika sambandha kI paribhASA lagAkara batAo? uttara-jaba muMharUpa AhAra vargaNA svaya svata muMha khulane rUpa pariNamita hotA hai| tava jJAna, rAga aura bolane ke bhAvarUpa kisa ucita nimitta kAraNa kA muha khulane ke sAtha sambandha hai / yaha batalAne ke lie muha khulane rUpa, kArya ko naimittika kahate hai| isa prakAra jJAna, rAga, bolanA, muha khulanA rUpa bhinna-bhinna padArthoM ke svatantra sambandha ko nimitta-naimittika sambandha kahate haiN| C. prazna 2-~-jJAna, bolane aura muMha khulane ke kAraNa rAma humA

Page #184
( 178 ) isa vAkya para nimitta-naimittika sambandha kI paribhASA lagAkara batAo? uttara- java AtmA kA cAritra guNa svayaM svata rAgarUpa pariNamita hotA hai taba jJAna, bolanA, maha salane bhAvarUpa kisa ucita nimitta cAraNA kA rAga ke sAtha sambandha hai| yaha batalAne ke lie rAgaspa kArya ko naimittika kahate haiN| isa prakAra jJAna, bolanA, muha khulanA aura rAga ke bhinna-bhinna padArthoM ke svatatra sambandha ko nimitta namittika rAgbandha kahate haiN| D. prazna 2-rAga, bolanA, muMha khulane ke kAraNa jJAna huAisa vAkya para nimitta-naimittika sambandha kI paribhASA lagAkara samajhAo? uttara-java AtmA kA jJAna, guNa svaya svata jJAnarUpa pariNamita hotA hai tava rAga bolanA, maha khulane bhAvarUpa kisa ucita nimitta kAraNa'kA jJAna ke sAtha sambandha hai| yaha batalAne ke liye jJAnaspa kArya' ko naimittika kahate haiN| isa prakAra rAga, bolanA, muha khulanA mora jJAnarUpa kArya ke bhinna-bhinna padArthoM ke svatanya sambandha ko nimitta-naimittika sambandha kahate haiN| . prazna 3--mujha AtmA aura muMharUpa AhAra vargaNA upAdAna kAraNa aura bolanA upAdeya-kyA yaha upAdAna-upAdeya kA jJAna ThIka hai? * uttara-bilkula ThIka nahIM hai, kyoki yahA~ para bhASA vargaNA trikAlI upAdAnaM kAraNa aura volanA kArya upAdeya hai| prazna 3-mujha AtmA aura bolane rUpa bhASA vargaNA upAdAna kAraNa aura muMha khulA upaadey| kyA yaha upAdAna-upAdeya kA jAna ThIka hai?

Page #185
( 176 ) uttara-bilkula ThIka nahIM hai, kyoki yahA~ para muharUpa AhAravargaNA trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa aura muha khulA upAdeya hai| C. prazna 3-bolane rUpa bhASA vargaNA aura muMha rUpa AhAravargaNA upAdAna kAraNa aura rAga upAdeya / kyA yaha upAdAna-upAdeya kA jJAna ThIka hai? uttara-bilkula ThIka nahIM hai, kyoki yahA~ para AtmA kA cAritra guNa trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa aura rAga upAdeya hai| ____D. prazna 3-~-rAgarUpa cAritra guNa, bolane rUpa bhASA vargaNA, muMharUpa AhAra vargaNA upAdAna kAraNa aura jJAna upaadey| kyA yaha upAdAna-upAdeya kA jJAna ThIka hai? uttara-bilkula ThIka nahIM haiM, kyoki yahA~ para AtmA kA jJAna guNa trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa aura jJAna upAdeya hai| A. prazna 4-yadi koI catura mujha AtmA, muMharUpa AhAra vargaNA upAdAna kAraNa aura bolane rUpa kArya upaadey| aisA hI mAne to kyA doSa mAtA hai ? uttara-mujha AtmA, muMharUpa AhAra vargaNA naSTa hokara bhASA vargaNA bana jAve to aisA mAnA jA sakatA hai ki mujha AtmA, muMharUpa AhAravargaNA upAdAna kAraNa aura bolane rUpa kArya upAdeya / lekina aisA nahI ho sakatA hai, kyoki upAdAna-upAdeya abhinna sattA vAle padArtho me hI hotA hai / AtmA, muMha-bolanA jinakI sattA-sattva bhinnabhinna hai, aise padArthoM me upAdAna-upAdeya nahI hotA hai| ____B. prazna 4--yadi koI catura mujha AtmA, bolane rUpa bhASA vargaNA upAdAna kAraNa aura muMha khulA upaadey| aisA hI mAne to kyA doSa AtA hai? uttara-mujha AtmA, bolane rUpa bhASA vargaNA naSTa hokara muMharUpa

Page #186
( 180 ) AhAravargaNA bana jAye to aisA mAnA jA sakatA hai ki mujha AtmA, bolane rUpa bhASAvargaNA, upAdAna kAraNa aura muMha khulA upAdeya / lekina aisA nahIM ho sakatA hai kyoki upAdAna-upAdeya abhinna sattA vAle padArthoM meM hI hotA hai| AtmA, bolanA, muMha khulA jinakI sattA-sattva bhinna-bhinna hai, aise padArthoM me upAdAna-upAdeya nahI hotA hai| _____C. prazna 4-yadi koI catura bolane rUpa bhASA vargaNA, muMha khulane rUpa AhAravargaNA upAdAna kAraNa aura rAga upaadey| aisA hI mAne kyA doSa AtA hai ? uttara-bolane rUpa bhASAvargaNA, muMharUpa AhAravargaNA naSTa hokara AtmA kA cAritra guNa vana jAye to aisA mAnA jA sakatA hai ki bolane rUpa bhASAvargaNA, muMharUpa AhAravargaNA upAdAna kAraNa aura rAga upAdeya / lekina aisA nahIM ho sakatA hai, kyoki upAdAna-upAdeya abhinna sattA vAle padArthoM me hI hotA hai| bolanA, muMha khulanA rAga jinakI sattA-sattva bhinna-bhinna hai| aise padArthoM me upAdAna-upAdeya nahI hotA hai| ___D prazna 4 yadi koI catura rAgalpa cAritraguNa, bolane rUpa bhASAvargaNA, muMharUpa AhAra vargaNA upAdAna kAraNa aura jJAna upaadey| aisA hI mAne to kyA doSa AtA hai ? uttara-rAgarUpa cAritra guNa, bolane rUpa bhASAvargaNA, muMha rUpa AhAravargaNA naSTa hokara AtmA kA jJAna guNa bana jAve to aisA mAnA jA sakatA hai ki rAgarUpa cAritraguNa, bolane rUpa bhASAvargaNA, maharUpa AhAra vargaNA upAdAna kAraNa aura jJAna upaadey| lekina aisA nahI ho sakatA hai, kyoki upAdAna-upAdeya abhinna sattA vAle padArtho me hI hotA hai| rAga, bolanA, muMha khulA, jJAna jinakI sattAsattva bhinna-bhinna hai| aise padArtho me upAdAna-upAdeya nahA hotA haiN|

Page #187
( 181 ) ___4 prazna 5-jo AtmA, muha Adi nimitta kAraNo se hI bolane Adi kI utpatti mAnate haiN| jinheM jinavANI me kina-kina nAmoM se sambodhana kiyA hai| uttara-jo AtmA, muMha Adi nimitta kAraNo se hI bolane ko utpatti mAnate hai| (1) unhe samayasAra kalaza 55 me kahA hai ki unakA sulaTanA dunivAra hai aura yaha unakA ajJAna moha andhakAra hai| (2) unhe pravacanasAra gAthA 55 me kahA hai ki vaha pada-pada para dhokhA khAtA hai| (3) unhe puruSArtha siddhiyupAya gAthA 6 me kahA hai ki "tasya dezanA nAsti / " (4) unhe AtmAvalokana me kahA hai ki yaha unakA 'harAmajAdIpanA' hai| __B prazna 5-jo AtmA bolane Adi nimitta kAraNoM se hI muMha khulane rUpa kArya ko utpatti mAnate haiN| unheM jinavANo me kina-kina nAma se sambodhana kiyA hai ? uttara-jo AtmA, bolanA Adi nimita kAraNo se hI muMha khule rUpa kArya kI utpatti mAnate haiN| (1) unhe samayasAra kalaza 55 me kahA hai ki unakA sulaTanA dunivAra hai aura yaha unakA ajJAna moha andhakAra hai / (2) unhe pravacanasAra gAthA 55 me kahA hai ki vaha padapada para dhokhA khAtA hai| (3) unhe puruSArtha siddhiyupAya gAthA 6 me kahA hai ki "tasya dezanA nAsti / " (4) unhe AtmAvalokana me kahA hai ki "yaha unakA harAmajAdIpanA hai|" ___C. prazna 5-jo bolanA, maha khulanA Adi nimitta kAraNoM se hI "rAga kI utpatti mAnate haiN| unheM jinavANI meM kina-kina nAmoM se sambodhana kiyA hai| uttara-jo bolanA, muMha khulA Adi nimitta kAraNo se hI rAga

Page #188
( 182 ) kI utpatti mAnate hai / (1) unhe samayasAra kalaza 55 me kahA hai ki unakA sulaTanA dunivAra hai aura yaha unakA ajJAna moha andhakAra hai| (2) unhe pravacanasAra gAthA 55 me kahA hai ki vaha pada-pada para dhokhA khAtA hai| (3) unhe puruSArtha siddhiyupAya gAthA 6 me kahA ki "tasya dezanA naasti|" (4) unhe AtmAvalokana me kahA hai ki "yaha unakA harAmajAdIpanA hai|" ____D. prazna 5-jo rAga, bolanA, muMha khulanA Adi nimitta kAraNoM se hI jAna kI utpatti mAnate haiM unhe jinavANI meM kina-kina nAmoM se sambodhana kiyA hai ? uttara~jo rAga, bolanA, muha khulanA Adi nimitta kAraNo se hI jJAna kI utpatti mAnate hai| (1) unhe samayasAra kalaza 55 me kahA hai ki unakA sulaTanA dunivAra hai aura yaha unakA ajJAna moha andhakAra hai| (2) unhe pravacanasAra gAthA 55 me kahA hai ki vaha padapada para dhokhA khAtA hai / (3) unhe puruSArtha siddhiyupAya gAthA 6 me kahA hai ki "tasya dezanA naasti|" (4) unhe AtmAvalokana me kahA hai ki yaha unakA harAmajAdIpanA hai| A. prazna 6-bhASA vargaNA trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa aura bolane rUpa kArya upAdeya / isako samabhane se kyA-kyA lAbha huA ? .. uttara-AtmA, muMha Adi nimitta kAraNo se bolane rUpa kArya huA-aisI khoTI mAnyatA kA abhAva ho jAtA hai / (2) bolane rUpa bhASA vargaNA ko choDakara dUsarI vargaNAo se dRSTi haTa jAtI hai / (3) aba yahAM para bolane rUpa kArya ke lie eka mAtra bolane rUpa bhASA vargaNA kI tarapha dekhanA rhaa| B. prazna 6-muMha rUpa AhAra vargaNA trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa aura muMha khulA upAdeya / isako samajhane se kyA-kyA lAbha huA?

Page #189
( 183 ) uttara-(1) AtmA, volanA Adi nimitta kAraNo se muMha khulA -aisI khoTI mAnyatA kA abhAva ho jAtA hai| (2) muMha khulane rUpa AhAra vargaNA ko choDakara dUsarI vargaNAo se dRSTi haTa jAtI hai| (3) aba yahA~ para muMha khulane rUpa kArya ke lie eka mAtra muha khunane rUpa AhAra vargaNA kI tarapha hI dekhanA rhaa| C prazna 6 -AtmA kA cAritra guNa trikAlI upAdAna phArama aura rAga upAdeya / isako samajhane se kyA-kyA lAbha huA? uttara-(1) bolanA, muMha khulanA Adi nimitta kAraNo se rAga huA-aisI khoTI mAnyatA kA abhAva ho jAtA hai| (2) AtmA me ananta guNa haiN| uname se cAritra guNa ko choDakara bAkI guNo se dRSTi haTa jAtI hai| (3) aba yahA~ para rAga ke lie eka mAtra AtmA ke cAritra guNa kI tarapha hI dekhanA rhaa| D. prazna 6-AtmA kA jJAna guNa trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa aura jJAna upaadey| isako samajhane se kyA-kyA lAbha huA? uttara-(1) rAga, bolanA, muMha khulA Adi nimitta kAraNo se jJAna huaa| aisI khoTI mAnyatA kA abhAva ho jAtA hai / (2) AtmA me ananta guNa hai| uname se eka jJAna guNa ko choDakara bAkI dUsare guNo se dRSTi haTa jAtI hai| (3) aba yahA~ para jJAna ke lie ekamAtra AtmA ke jJAna guNa kI tarapha hI dekhanA rhaa| 7 A. prazna 7-koI catura phira prazna karatA hai ki Apa kahate ho bolane rUpa kArya kA AtmA, muMha khulA Adi nimitta kAraNo se sarvathA sambandha nahIM hai to vizva me bhASAvargaNA to bharI par3I hai, aba bolane rUpa kArya kyo nahIM hotA hai ? ata ApakA aisA kahanA ki bhASA vargaNA upAdAna kAraNa aura bolane rUpa kArya upAdeya-yaha bAta jhUThI sAbita hotI hai|

Page #190
( 184 ) uttara-are bhAI hamane bhASA vargaNA ko bolane rUpa kArya kA upAdAna kAraNa kahA hai| vaha to AtmA, muMha khulA Adi nimitta kAraNo se pRthaka karane kI apekSA se kahA hai| vAstava me bhASA vargaNA bhI bolane rUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahI hai| ___B. prazna 7-koI catura phira prazna karatA hai ki Apa kahate ho muMha khulane rUpa kArya kA, AtmA, bolane Adi nimitta kAraNo se sarvathA sambandha nahIM hai to vizva me AhAra vargaNA to pahale se hI bharI par3I hai| taba una saba me muMha khulane rUpa kArya kyoM nahIM hotA hai ? ataH ApakA aisA kahanA ki muMha rUpa AhAra vargaNA upAdAna kAraNa ora muMha khulA upAdeya-yaha ApakI bAta jhUThI sAvita hotI hai| uttara--are bhAI hamane muha rUpa AhAra vargaNA ko muMha khulane rUpa kArya kA upAdAna kAraNa kahA hai| vaha to AtmA, volanA Adi nimitta kAraNo se pRthaka karane kI apekSA se kahA hai| vAstava me muMha rUpa AhAra vargaNA bhI muMha khulane rUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahIM hai| ____C. prazna 7-koI catura phira prazna karatA hai ki Apa kahate ho rAga-rUpa kArya kA, bolanA, muMha khulA Adi nimitta kAraNo se sarvathA sambandha nahIM hai to cAritra guNa to siddha bhagavAna, ahaMta bhagavAna Adi me bhI hai / uname rAga utpanna kyo nahIM hotA hai ? ata. Apako aisA kahanA ki AtmA kA cAritra guNa upAdAna kAraNa aura rAgalpa kArya upAdeya-yaha ApakI bAta jhUThI sAbita hotI hai ? uttara-are bhAI hamane AtmA ke cAritra guNa ko rAga rUpa kArya kA upAdAna kAraNa kahA hai, vaha to bolanA muMha khulA Adi nimitta kAraNo se pRthaka karane kI apekSA se kahA hai| vAstava me cAritra guNa bhI rAgarUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahIM hai| D prazna 7-koI catura phira prazna karatA hai ki Apa kahate ho

Page #191
( 185) jJAnarUpa kAyaM kA rAga, bolanA, muMha khulA Adi nimitta kAraNo se sarvayA sambandha nahIM hai| jJAnaguNa to saba AtmAoM ke pAsa hai| to una sabako, rAga, bolanA, muha khulA sambandhI Adi kA jJAna kyoM nahIM hotA hai| ataH ApakA aisA kahanA ki jJAnaguNa upAdAna kAraNa aura rAga, bolanA, muMha khulAdi sambandhI kA jJAna upAdeya-yaha ApakI bAta jhUThI sAbita hotI hai ? uttara-are bhAI hamane AtmA ke jJAnaguNa ko rAga, bolanA, muMha khulA Adi sambandhI jJAnarUpa kArya kA upAdAna kAraNa kahA hai| vaha to rAga, bolanA, muMha khulA Adi nimittakAraNo se pRthak karane kI apekSA se kahA hai| vAstava meM AtmA kA jJAnaguNa bhI rAga, bolanA,'muha khulA Adi sambandhI jJAnarUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahIM hai| A. prazna 8-bhASA vargaNA bhI bolane rUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahIM hai| to yahAM para bolane rUpa kArya kA saccA upAvAna kAraNa kauna hai ? . ..uttara-bhASA vargaNA me anAdikAla se paryAyo kA pravAha calA A rahA hai| mAno dasa nambara para bolane rUpa kArya banA to usame anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa bolane / rUpa kArya kA yahA~ para saccA upAdAna kAraNa hai| B. prazna 5-muha rUpa AhAra vargaNA bhI muha khulane rUpa kArya kA . saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahIM hai| to yahAM para muha khulane rUpa kArya kA ... saccA upAdAna kAraNa kauna hai ? . . uttara-muMha rUpa AhAra vargaNA meM anAdikAla paryAyo kA pravAha . / calA A rahA hai| mAno dasa nambara para muMha khulane rUpa kArya huaa|

Page #192
( 186 ) to usame anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa muMha khulane rUpa kArya kA yahAM para saccA upAdAna kAraNa hai| C. prazna -AtmA kA cAritraguNa bhI rAgarUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahIM hai| to yahA~ para rAgalpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa kauna hai ? uttara-AtmA ke cAritraguNa me anAdikAla se paryAyo kA pravAha calA A rahA hai| mAno dasa nambara para rAgarUpa kArya huA, to usame anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa rAgarUpa kArya kA yahA~ para saccA upAdAna kAraNa hai| D. prazna 8-AtmA kA jJAnaguNa bhI jJAnarUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahIM hai| to yahAM para jJAnarUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa kauna hai ? uttara-AtmA ke jJAna guNa me anAdikAla se paryAyo kA pravAha calA A rahA hai| mAno dasa nambara para jJAnarUpa kArya huA to usame anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya no nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa jJAnarUpa kArya kA yahA~ para saccA upAdAna kAraNa hai| ___A prazna 6-bhASA vargaNA me anAdikAla se paryAyo kA pravAha kyo calA A rahA hai ? uttara pratyeka dravya-guNa anAdi ananta dhrauvya rahatA huA eka paryAya kA vyaya aura dUsarI paryAya kA utpAda eka hI samaya me svaya svata apane pariNamana svabhAva ke kAraNa karatA rahA hai, karatA hai aura bhaviSya me karatA rahegA-aisA vastu svarUpa hai| isI kAraNa anAdikAla se bhASA vargaNA me paryAyo kA pravAha calA A rahA hai| B prazna :-muharUpa AhAra vargaNA meM paryAyo kA pravAha kyoM calA A rahA hai?

Page #193
( 187 ) uttara-pratyeka dravya-guNa anAdi ananta dhrauvya rahatA huA eka paryAya kA vyaya aura dUsarI paryAya kA utpAda eka hI samaya me svaya svataH apane pariNamana svabhAva ke kAraNa karatA rahA hai, karatA hai aura bhaviSya me karatA rahenA-aisA vastu svarUpa hai| isI kAraNa anAdikAla se muMha rUpa AhAra vargaNA me paryAyo.kA pravAha calA A rahA ____C. prazna -AtmA ke cAritraguNa meM anAdikAla se paryAyo kA pravAha kyo calA A rahA hai ? uttara-pratyeka dravya-guNa anAdi ananta dhauvya rahatA huA eka paryAya kA vyaya aura dUsarI paryAya kA utpAda eka hI samaya me svaya svata apane pariNamana svabhAva ke kAraNa karatA rahA hai, karatA hai aura bhaviSya me karatA rahegA-aisA vastu svarUpa hai| isI kAraNa anAdikAla se AtmA ke cAritra guNa me paryAyo kA pravAha calA A rahA hai| D. prazna -AtmA ke jJAnaguNa me anAdikAla se paryAyoM kA pravAha kyo calA A rahA hai ? uttara-pratyeka dravya-guNa anAdi ananta dhauvya rahatA huA eka paryAya kA vyaya aura dUsarI paryAya kA utpAda eka hI samaya me svaya svata apane pariNamana svabhAva ke kAraNa karatA rahA hai, karatA hai aura bhaviSya me karatA rahegA-aisA vastu svarUpa hai| isI kAraNa anAdikAla se AtmA ke jJAnaguNa me paryAyo kA pravAha calA A rahA hai| 10 A. prazna 10-anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura polA upAdeya-isako jAnane-mAnane se kyA-kyA lAbha huA? uttara-(1) bhUta-bhaviSya kI paryAyo se dRSTi haTa jAtI hai| (2) bhASAvargaNA jo trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa thA, vaha bhI vyavahAra

Page #194
( 188 ) kAraNa ho gyaa| (3) aba yahA~ para bolane rUpa kArya ke lie mAtra anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kI tarapha dekhanA rhaa| B. prazna 10-anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura muha.khulA upaadey| isako jAnane-mAnane se kyA kyA lAbha huA? uttara-(1) bhUta-bhaviSya ko paryAyo se dRSTi haTa jAtI hai| (2) muMharUpa a hAra vargaNA jo trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa thA, vaha bhI vyavahAra kAraNa ho gyaa| (3) ava yahA~ para muMha khulArUpa kArya ke lie mAtra anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa kI tarapha dekhanA rhaa| C. prazna 10-anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura rAga upaadey| isako jAnane mAnane se kyA-kyA lAbha huA? uttara-(1) bhUta-bhaviSya kI paryAyo se dRSTi haTa jAtI hai| (2) AtmA kA cAritraguNa jo trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa thA, vaha bhI vyavahAra kAraNa ho gyaa| (3) aba yahA para rAga ke lie mAtra anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kI tarapha dekhanA rhaa| _D. prazna 10-anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika uzadAna kAraNa aura jJAna upaadey| isako jAnane-mAnane se kyA-kyA lAbha huA? uttara-(1) bhUta-bhaviSya ko paryAyo se dRSTi haTa jAtI hai| (2) AtmA kA jJAnaguNa jo trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa thA, vaha bhI vyavahAra kAraNa ho gyaa| (3) aba yahA~ para jJAnarUpa kArya ke lie mAtra anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kI tarapha dekhanA rhaa|

Page #195
( 186) 11 A. prazna 11-koI catura phira prazna karatA hai ki abhAva meM se bhAva kI utpatti nahIM hotI hai aura paryAya meM se paryAya nahIM AtI haiaisA jinavANI meM kahA hai| phira yaha mAnanA ki-anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura bolane rUpa kArya upAdeya / yaha Apako bAta jhUThI sAbita hotI hai| uttara-are bhAI ! abhAva me se bhAva kI utpatti nahI hotI hai aura paryAya me se paryAya nahI AtI hai-yaha bAta jinavANI kI vilkula ThIka hai| parantu hamane to kArya se pahile kaunasI paryAya hotI hai| usakI apekSA anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya no nambara ko bolane rUpa kArya kA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kahA hai| parantu anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara bhI bolane rUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahI hai| ____B. prazna 11-koI catura phira prazna karatA hai ki abhAva meM se bhAva kI utpatti nahIM hotI hai aura paryAya meM se paryAya nahIM AtI hai| aisA jinavANoM meM kahA hai / phira yaha mAnanA ki anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura muMha khulA upAdeya / yaha ApanI bAta jhUThI sAbita hotI hai ? uttara-are bhAI / abhAva me se bhAva kI utpatti nahI hotI hai aura paryAya me se paryAya nahI AtI hai-yaha bAta jinavANI kI vilkula ThIka hai| parantu hamane to kArya me pahile kaunasI paryAya hotI hai| usakI apekSA anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara ko muMha khulane rUpa kArya kA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kahA hai| parantu anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara bhI muMha khulane rUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahIM hai|

Page #196
ThIka hai| paranta paryAya nahIM gAva me se bhAva ka ( 190 ) C. prazna 11-koI catura phira prazna karatA hai ki abhAva meM se bhAva kI utpatti nahIM hotI hai aura paryAya me se paryAya nahIM AtI hai| aisA jinavANI meM kahA hai| phira yaha mAnanA ki anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura rAgarUpa kArya upaadey| yaha ApakI bAta jhUThI sAbita hotI hai ? uttara-are bhAI | abhAva me se bhAva kI utpatti nahI hotI hai aura paryAya meM se paryAya nahI AtI hai yaha bAta jinavANI kI bilkula Thoka hai| parantu mane to kArya se pahile kaunasI paryAya hotI hai| usakI apekSA anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara ko rAgarUpa kArya kA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kahA hai / parantu anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara bhI rAgarUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahIM hai| ____D prazna 11-koI catura phira prazna karatA hai ki abhAva meM se bhAva kI utpatti nahIM hotI hai aura paryAya meM se paryAya nahIM AtI hai-aisA jinavANI me kahA hai| phira yaha mAnanA ki anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura jJAnarUpa kArya upAdeya / yaha ApakI bAta jhUThI sAbita hotI hai ? uttara-are bhAI / abhAva me se bhAva kI utpatti nahI hotI hai aura paryAya me se paryAya nahI AtI hai-yaha bAta jinavANI kI bilkula ThIka hai| parantu hamane to kArya se pahile kaunasI paryAya hotI hai| usakI apekSA anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara ko jJAnarUpa kArya kA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kahA hai / parantu anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara bhI jJAnarUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahI hai| 12 A. prazna 12-anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara bhI bolane

Page #197
( 191 ) rUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahIM hai| to kaisA kAraNa hai aura kaisA kAraNa nahIM hai ? uttara-anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara bolane rUpa kArya kA abhAvarUpa kAraNa hai| kAlasUcaka hai parantu kArya kA janaka nahI hai| ___B. prazna 12-anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara bhI muMha khulane rUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahIM hai| to kaisA kAraNa hai aura kaisA kAraNa nahIM hai ? uttara-anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara muMha khulane rUpa kArya kA abhAvarUpa kAraNa hai| kAlasUcaka hai parantu kArya kA janaka nahI hai| ___C. prazna 12--anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara bhI rAgarUpa kArya kA saccA upAvAna kAraNa nahIM hai to kaisA kAraNa hai aura kaisA kAraNa nahIM hai ? uttara--anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau namvara rAgarUpa kArya kA abhAvarUpa kAraNa hai| kAla sUcaka hai parantu kArya kA janaka nahI hai| D. prazna 12--anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara bhI jJAnarUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahIM hai to kaisA kAraNa hai aura kaisA kAraNa nahIM hai ? uttara-anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nI nambara jJAna rUpa kArya kA abhAvarUpa kAraNa hai / kAla sUcaka hai parantu kArya kA janaka nahI 13 A. prazna 13-anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa bhI bolane rUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahIM

Page #198
( 192 ) hai to vAstava meM bolane rUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa kauna hai ? uttara-vAstava me usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI bolane rUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa hai| ___B. prazna 13-anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa bhI muMha khulane rUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahIM hai| to vAstava meM muMha khulane rUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa kauna hai ? uttara-vAstava me usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI muMha khulane rUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa hai / C. prazna 13-anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa bhI rAgarUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahIM hai| to vAstava meM rAgarUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa kauna hai ? uttara-vAstava me usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI rAgarUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa hai| D. prazna 13--anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa bhI jJAnarUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa nahIM hai| to vAstava meM jJAnarUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa kauna hai ? uttara-vAstava meM usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI jJAnarUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa hai| 14 A. prazna 14-vAstava meM usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI bolane rUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa hai| aisA jAnane-mAnane se kyA-kyA lAbha humA ? uttara-(1) bolane spa kArya ke lie anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nI nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kI tarapha dekhanA nahI rahA /

Page #199
( 163 ) (2) ava ekamAtra bolane rUpa kArya ke lie usa samaya paryAya ko yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa ko tarapha dekhanA rhaa| B. prazna 14-vAstava meM usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI muMha khulane rUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa hai| aisA jAnane-mAnane se kyA-kyA lAbha huA? uttara-(1) muMha khulane rUpa kArya ke lie anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau namvara kI tarapha dekhanA nahI rahA / (2) aba eka mAtra muMha khulane rUpa kArya ke lie usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kI tarapha hI dekhanA rahA / C. prazna 14-vAstava me usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI rAgarUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa hai| aisA jAnane-mAnane se kyA-kyA lAbha huA? uttara-(1) rAgarUpa kArya ke lie anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kI tarapha dekhanA nahI rahA / (2) aba ekamAtra rAgarUpa kArya ke lie usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kI tarapha hI dekhanA rhaa| D. prazna 14-vAstava meM usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI jJAnarUpa kArya kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa hai| aisA jAnane-mAnane se kyA-kyA lAbha huA ? uttara-(1) jJAna rUpa kArya ke lie anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kI tarapha dekhanA nahI rahA / (2) ava ekamAtra jJAna rUpa kArya ke lie usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kI tarapha hI dekhanA rhaa| 15 A. prazna 15--(1) bhASA vargaNAtrikAlI upAdAna kAraNa aura bolA upaadey| (2) anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika

Page #200
-- ( 194 ) upAdAna kAraNa aura bolA upaadey| (3) bolA-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura bolA upAdeya-aisA jinavANI me AyA hai| parantu itanA lambA-lambA jhagaDA karane se kyA lAbha thaa| kaha dete ki-bolA kArya usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se hI hotA hai ? / uttara-(1) nimitta kAraNo se pRthaka karane kI apekSA se bhASAvargaNA trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa ko batAnA Avazyaka thA / (2) bhUtabhaviSya kI paryAyo se pRthaka karane kI apekSA se aura abhAva rUpa kAraNa kA jJAna karAne ke lie nau nambara anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa ko vatAnA Avazyaka thaa| (3) nI nambara anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa sa pRthak karane kI apekSA se aura sacce kAraNa-kArya kA jJAna karAne ke lie bolAusa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA jJAna karAnA Avazyaka thaa| isaliye tIno kAraNo kA saccA jJAna karAne ke liye jinavANI me itanA lamvA-lamvA karake samajhAyA hai| ___B. prazna 15-muMharUpa AhAra vargaNA trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa aura muMha khulA upAdeya / (2) anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura maha khulA upAdeya / (3) muMha khulA usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura muMha khulA upaadey| aisA jinavANI meM AyA hai| parantu itanA lambA-lambA jhagaDA karane se kyA-kyA lAbha yaa| kaha dete ki muMha khulA kArya usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se hI hotA hai ? uttara-(1) nimitta kAraNo se pRthak karane kI apekSA se muha rUpa AhAra vargaNA trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa ko batAnA Avazyaka thaa| (2) bhUta-bhaviSya kI paryAyo se pRthaka karane kI apekSA se aura abhAva rUpa kAraNa kA jAna karAne ke lie nau nambara anantarapUrva kSaNavartI 'paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa ko batAnA Avazyaka thaa| (3) anantara

Page #201
( 195 ) pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se pRthaka karane kI apekSA se aura sacce kAraNa-kArya kA jJAna karAne ke liye muha khulA usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA batAnA Avazyaka thaa| isaliye tIno kAraNo kA saccA jJAna karAne ke liye jinavANI me itanA lambA-lambA karake samajhAyA hai| C. prazna 15-(1) AtmA kA cAritra guNa trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa aura rAga upaadey| (2) anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura rAga upaadey| (3) rAga usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura rAga upAdeya-- aisA jinavANI meM AyA hai| parantu itanA lambA-lambA jhagaDA karane se kyA lAbha thA? kaha dete ki rAga kArya usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se hI hotA hai ? uttara-(1) nimitta kAraNo se pRthaka karane kI apekSA se AtmA kA cAritra guNa trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa ko batAnA Avazyaka thaa| (2) bhUta-bhaviSya kI paryAyo se pRthaka karane kI apekSA se aura abhAva rUpa kAraNa kA jJAna karAne ke lie nau nambara anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA batAnA Avazyaka thaa| (3) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se pRthak karane kI apekSA se aura sacce kAraNa-kArya kA jJAna karAne ke lie rAga usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa ko vatAnA Avazyaka thaa| isalie tIno kAraNo kA saccA jJAna karAne ke lie jinavANI me itanA lambA-lambA karake samajhAyA hai| D. prazna 15-(1) AtmA kA jJAna guNa trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa aura jJAna upaadey| (2) anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura jJAna upaadey| (3) jJAna usa samaya paryAya ko yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura jJAna upAdeyaaisA jinavANo me AyA hai| parantu itanA lambA-lasvA jhagar3A karane 44

Page #202
( 196 ) se kyA lAbha thA ? kaha dete ki jJAna kArya-usa samaya paryAya ko yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se hI hotA hai ? uttara-(1) nimitta kAraNo se pRthaka karane kI apekSA se AtmA kA jJAna guNa trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa ko vatAnA Avazyaka thaa| (2) bhUta-bhaviSya kI paryAyo se pRthaka karane kI apekSA se aura abhAva rUpa kAraNa kA jJAna karAne ke lie nau nambara anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa ko batAnA Avazyaka thaa| (3) anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nI nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se pRthaka karane kI apekSA se aura sacce kAraNa-kArya kA jJAna karAne ke lie jJAnausa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa ko batAnA Avazyaka thaa| isalie tIno kAraNo kA saccA jJAna karAne ke lie jinavANI me itanA lambA-lamvA karake samajhAyA hai| 16 A. prazna 16-bolane rUpa kArya-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se huA hai-isako jAnane-mAnane se kyA lAbha huA? uttara-jaise-bolane rUpa kArya-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se huA hai, vaise hI vizva me jitane bhI kArya hai| ve saba usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se ho cuke hai, ho rahe hai aura bhaviSya me hote rhege| aisA kevalI ke samAna saccA jJAna ho jAtA hai| ___B. prazna 16-muha khulA-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se huA hai-isako jAnane-mAnane se kyA lAbha huA? uttara- jaise muha khulA-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se huA hai, vaise hI vizva me jitane bhI kArya haiM / ve saba usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se ho cuke kSaNika usa samaya aura bhavi

Page #203
( 197 ) haiM ho rahe haiM aura bhaviSya me hote rhege| aisA kevalI ke samAna saccA jJAna ho jAtA hai| C. prazna 16-rAga-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se huA hai-isako jAnane-mAnane se kyA lAbha huA? uttara-jaise rAga-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se huA hai, vaise hI vizva me jitane bhI kArya hai / ve saba usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se ho cuke haiM, ho rahe haiM aura bhaviSya me hote rhege| aisA kevalI ke samAna saccA jJAna ho jAtA hai| ____D. prazna 16-jAna rUpa kArya-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se huA hai-isako jAnane-mAnane se kyA lAbha huA ? uttara-jaise jJAnarUpa kArya-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se huA hai, vaise hI vizva meM jitane bhI kArya haiN| ve saba usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se ho cuke haiM, ho rahe hai aura bhaviSya me hote rhege| aisA kevalI ke samAna saccA jJAna ho jAtA hai| 17 ___A prazna 17-bolane rUpa kArya ke samAna vizva me jitane bhI kArya haiM ve saba usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se ho cuke haiM, ho rahe haiM aura bhaviSya me hote rahege-aisA kevalI ke samAna saccA jJAna hote hI kyA-kyA apUrva kArya dekhane meM AtA hai ? uttara-bolane rUpa kArya ke samAna saba kArya apanI-apanI yogyatA se hI hote hai-aisA mAnate hI (1) anAdikAla kI para me karUM-dharUM ko khoTI mAnyatA kA abhAva honA / (2) dRSTi apane jJAyaka svabhAva para AnA / (3) samyagdarzanAdi kI prApti hokara krama se vRddhi hokara

Page #204
( 168 ) mokSa lakSmI kA nAtha bnnaa| (4) mithyAtvAdi sasAra ke pA~ca kAraNo kA abhAva honaa| (5) dravya-kSetra-kAla-bhava-bhAvarUpa paca parAvartana kA abhAva honA / (6) paca parameSTiyo me ginatI honaa| ___B. prazna 17-muMha khulane rUpa kArya ke samAna vizva me jitane bhI kArya haiN| ve saba usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se ho cuke haiM, ho rahe haiM aura bhaviSya meM hote rahege-aisA kevalI ke samAna saccA jJAna hote hI kyA-kyA apUrva kArya dekhane meM AtA hai ? uttara-muMha khulane rUpa kArya ke samAna vizva ke sarva kArya apanIapanI yogyatA se hI hote haiM-~-aisA mAnate ho (1) anAdikAla kI para me karU~-dharU~ kI khoTI mAnyatA kA abhAva honA / (2) dRSTi apane jJAyaka svabhAva para aanaa| (3) samyagdarzanAdi kI prApti hokara krama se vRddhi hokara mokSa lakSmI kA nAtha honaa| (4) mithyAtvAdi sasAra ke pA~ca kAraNo kA abhAva honaa| (5) dravya-kSetra-kAla bhava-bhAvarUpa pacaparAvartana kA abhAva honaa| (6) paca parameSTiyo me ginatI honaa| ___C. prazna 17-rAgarUpa kArya ke samAna vizva meM jitane bhI kArya hai| ve saba usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se ho cuke haiM, ho rahe haiM aura bhaviSya meM hote rahege-aisA kevalI ke samAna saccA jJAna hote hI kyA-kyA apUrva kArya dekhane meM AtA hai ? uttara-rAgarUpa kArya ke samAna vizva ke sarva kArya apanI-apanI yogyatA se hI hote hai| aisA mAnate hI (1) anAdikAla kI para me karU~-dharU~ kI khoTI mAnyatA kA abhAva honA / (2) dRSTi apane jJAyaka svabhAva para AnA / (3) samyagdarzanAdi kI prApti hokara krama se vRddhi hokara mokSa lakSmI kA nAtha honaa| (4) mithyAtvAdi sasAra ke pA~ca kAraNo kA abhAva honaa| (5) dravya-kSetra-kAla-bhava-bhAvarUpa paca parAvartana kA abhAva honA / (6)paca parameSTiyo me ginatI honaa|

Page #205
( 166 ) D. prazna 17-jJAna rUpa kArya ke samAna vizva me jitane bhI kArya haiN| ve saba usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se ho cuke haiM, ho rahe haiM aura bhaviSya meM hote rahege-aisA kevalI ke samAna saccA jJAna hote ho kyA-kyA kArya dekhane meM AtA hai ? uttara-jJAnarUpa kArya ke samAna vizva ke sarva kArya apanI-apanI yogyatA se hI hote haiM--aisA mAnate hI-(1) anAdikAla kI para me karUM-karU~ kI khoTI mAnyatA kA abhAva honaa| (2) dRSTi apane jJAyaka svabhAva para AnA / (3) samyagdarzanAdi kI prApti hokara krama se vRddhi hokara mokSa lakSmI kA nAtha honaa| (4) mithyAtvAdi samAra ke pA~ca kAraNo kA abhAva honaa| (5) dravya-kSetra-kAla-bhava-bhAvarUpa paca parAvartana kA abhAva honaa| (6) paca parameSTiyo me ginatI honaa| 18 A prazna 18-bolane rUpa kArya ke samAna vizva me pratyeka kArya usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se hI hotA hai| taba kauna-kauna sI cAra bAteM eka hI sAtha eka hI samaya me niyama se hotI haiM ? uttara-(1) usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa bolane rUpa kArya (utpAda) (2) anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa bolane rUpa kArya se anantara pUrva paryAya (vyaya) (3) trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa bhASA vargaNA (dhrauvya) (4) jJAna, rAga, muMha (nimitta kaarnn)| jaise bolane rUpa kAya me cAra vAte eka sAtha eka hI samaya me hotI haiM usI prakAra ya cAra vAte-pratyeka kArya me eka hI sAtha eka hI kAla me niyama se hotI hai| [pravacanasAra gAthA TIkA 65) B. prazna 18-muha khulane kArya ke samAna vizva me pratyeka

Page #206
( 200 ) usamaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se hI hotA hai| taba kauna-kauna sI cAra vAteM eka hI sAtha eka hI samaya me niyama se hotI haiM? uttara-(1) usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa muMha khulanempa kArya (utpAda) (2) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa muMha khulanespa kArya se anantarapUrva paryAya (vyaya) (3) trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa muMharUpa AhAra vargaNA (dhrauvya) (4) jAna, rAga-bolanA (nimittkaarnn)| jaise muMha khulanerUpa kArya me cAra vAte eka sAtha eka hI samaya meM hotI haiM, usI prakAra ye cAra bAte pratyeka kArya meM eka hI sAya, eka hI kAla meM niyama se hotI hai| [pravacanasAra gAthA TIkA 65] C. prazna 18~rAgaspa kArya ke samAna vizva meM pratyeka kArya usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatAkSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se hI hotA hai / taba kauna-kauna sI cAra bAteM eka hI sAtha eka hI samaya meM niyama se hotI haiM? uttara-(1) usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa rAgarUpa kArya (utpAda) (2) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa rAgarUpa kArya se anantarapUrva paryAya (vyaya) (3) trikAlI upAdAnakAraNa AtmA kA cAritra guNa / (dhrauvya) (4) bolanA, muMha khulA, jJAna, nimittakAraNa / jaise rAgarUpa kArya me cAra bAte eka sAtha eka hI kAla me hotI hai, usI prakAra ye cAro vAte pratyeka kArya me eka hI sAtha eka hI kAla me niyama se hotI haiN| [pravacanasAra gAthA TIkA 65] D prazna 18-jJAna rUpa kArya ke samAna vizva meM pratyeka kArya usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se hI hotA hai| taba kauna-kauna sI cAra bAteM eka hI sAtha eka hI samaya meM niyama se hotI hai ?

Page #207
( 201 ) uttara-(1) usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAnakAraNa jJAnarUpa kArya (utpAda) (2) anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa rAgarUpa kArya se anantarapUrva paryAya kA (vyaya) (3) trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa AtmA kA jJAna guNa (dhrauvya) (4) rAga-muMha-bolanA (nimittkaarnn)| jaise jJAnarUpa kArya me cAra vAte eka hI sAtha eka hI samaya me hotI haiM, usI prakAra ye cAro vAteM pratyeka kArya me eka hI sAtha eka hI kAla me niyama se hotI haiN| [pravacanasAra gAthA TIkA 65] 19 A. prazna 16-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se hI bolane rUpa kArya kI utpatti hotI hai| kyA yaha nirapekSa hai ? uttara-hA~, bolane rUpa kArya svaya para kI apekSA nahI rakhatA hai isaliye nirapekSa hai| aura apanI apekSA rakhatA hai isaliye sApekSa hai| pAtra bhavya jIvo ko prathama nirapekSa siddhi karanI caahie| phira jo kArya huA-usakA abhAvarUpa kAraNa kauna hai, trikAlI kAraNa kauna hai aura nimittakAraNa kauna hai| ina bAto kA jJAna karanA caahie| kyoki pratyeka kArya ke samaya cAro bAteM niyama se hotI hai| B. prazna 16-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se hI muMha kholane rUpa kArya kI utpatti hotI hai| kyA yaha nirapekSa hai ? uttara-hA~, muMharUpa kArya svaya para kI apekSA nahI rakhatA hai isaliye nirapekSa hai aura apanI apekSA rakhatA hai isaliye sApekSa hai| pAtra bhavya jIvo ko prathama nirapekSa siddhi karanI caahie| phira jo kArya huA-usakA abhAvarUpa kAraNa kauna hai, trikAlI kAraNa kauna / aura nimitta kAraNa kauna hai| ina bAto kA jJAna karanA caahie| kyoki pratyeka kArya ke samaya cAro bAte niyama se hotI hai|

Page #208
( 202 ) C. prazna 16-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se hI rAgaspa kArya kI utpatti hotI hai| kyA yaha nirapekSa hai ? uttara-hA~, rAgatpa kArya svaya para kI apekSA nahIM rakhatA hai isalie nirapekSa hai aura apanI apekSA rakhatA hai isalie sApekSa hai| pAtra bhavya jIvo ko prathama nirapekSa middhi karanI cAhie phira jo kArya huA-usakA abhAvaspa kAraNa kauna hai, trikAlI kAraNa kauna hai aura nimitta kAraNa kIna hai| ina bAto kA jJAna karanA cAhie kyoki pratyeka kArya ke samaya cAro vAte niyama meM hotI hai| D prazna 16-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se hI jJAnarupa kArya ko utpatti hotI hai| kyA yaha nirapekSa hai| uttara- hA~, jJAnampa kArya svaya para kI apekSA nahI rakhatA hai isaliye nirapekSa hai aura apanI apekSA rakhatA hai isaliye sApekSa hai| pAtra bhavya jIvo ko prathama nirapekSa siddhi karanI caahie| phira jo kArya huA-usakA abhAvarUpa kAraNa kIna hai, trikAlI kAraNa kauna hai aura nimitta kAraNa kona hai| ina vAto kA jJAna karanA cAhie, kyoki pratyeka kArya ke samaya cAro vAte niyama se hotI hai| 20 A. prazna 20-bolanerUpa kArya-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se hI huA hai| aisA jAnane-mAnane se bolane rUpa kArya ke lie kisa-kisa kAraNa para dRSTi nahIM jAtI hai ? uttara-(1) AtmA kA jJAna, rAga, muNhkhulaa| (2) bhASA vargaNA / (3) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nI nambara kSaNika upAdAna kaarnn| ___B prazna 20-muMha khulane rUpa kArya-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se hI huA hai| aisA jAnane-mAnane se muha / khulanerUpa kArya ke lie kisa-kisa kAraNa para dRSTi nahIM jAtI hai ?

Page #209
( 203 ) uttara-(1) AtmA kA jJAna, rAga, bolnaa| (2) muMharUpa ra vargaNA / (3) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika dAna kaarnn| C. prazna 20-rAgarUpa kArya-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA Nika upAdAna kAraNa se hI huA hai| aisA jAnane-mAnane se rAgarUpa kArya ke lie kisa kisa kAraNa para dRSTi nahIM jAtI hai ? uttara-(1) AtmA kA jJAna, bolanA, muMha khulaa| (2) AtmA kA cAritra guNa / (3) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kaarnn| D. prazna 20-jJAnarUpa kArya-usa samaya paryAya ko yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se hI huA hai| aisA jAnane-mAnane se jJAnarUpa kArya ke lie kisa-kisa kAraNa para dRSTi nahIM jAtI hai ? uttara-(1) rAga, muha khulanA, bolnaa| (2) AtmA kA jnyaangunn| (3) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kaarnn| PAP 21 FP " A. prazna 21-AtmA kA jJAna kAraNa aura bolanA kArya / "kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA ? mA uttara-bhASA vargaNA me se anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se bolanerUpa kArya haA hai AtmA ke jJAna se 26 nahA huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko maanaa| aura bolanerUpa kArya AtmA ke jJAna se huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahI maanaa| B..prazna 21-AtmA kA jJAna kAraNa aura muha khulA kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA ?

Page #210
( 204 ) uttara-muhaspa AhAra vargaNA me se anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nA nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se muMha khulA hai AtmA ke jJAna se nahI khulA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko mAnA / aura AtmA ke jJAna ke kAraNa muMha khulA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko nahIM maanaa| _____C. prazna 21-AtmA kA jJAna kAraNa aura rAga kArya / kAraNAnu'vidhAyoni kAryANi ko kava mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA ? uttara-AtmA ke cAritraguNa me se anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se rAga huA hai, AtmA ke jJAna ke kAraNa rAga nahI huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko mAnA / aura AtmA ke jJAna ke kAraNa rAga huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahI maanaa| D. prazna 21-rAga kAraNa aura jJAna kArya kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA? uttara-AtmA ke jJAnaguNa me se anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kA yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se jJAna hA hai rAga ke kAraNa jJAna nahI huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyinI kAryANi ko maanaa| aura rAga ke kAraNa jJAna huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahIM maanaa| 22 A. prazna 22-rAga kAraNa aura bolanA kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA? uttara-bhApA vargaNA me se anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nI nambara

Page #211
( 205 ) kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa ko abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se volane rUpa kArya huA hai rAga ke kAraNa nahI huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko mAnA aura rAga ke kAraNa bolanerUpa kArya huA aisI mAnyatA vAle kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahI maanaa| B. prazna 22-rAga kAraNa aura muha khulA kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA ? uttara-muMharUpa AhAravargaNA me se anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se muMha khulane rUpa kArya huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko mAnA / aura rAga ke kAraNa muha khulA hai to aisI mAnyatA vAle ne kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahI maanaa| C. prazna 22-bolanA kAraNa aura rAga kaary| kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA ? uttara-AtmA ke cAritra guNa me se anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya ko yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se rAgarUpa kArya huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko mAnA / aura bolane ke kAraNa rAgarUpa kArya huA hai aisI mAnyatA vAle ne kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahI maanaa| D prazna 22-muMha khulA kAraNa aura jJAna kaary| kAraNAtuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahI mAnA ? uttara-AtmA ke jJAna guNa me se anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se jJAna rUpa kArya huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko maanaa| aura muMha khulane ke kAraNa jJAna huA hai-aisI mAnyatA vAle ne kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANiko nahI maanaa|

Page #212
( 206 ) 23 A. prazna 23-muha khulA kAraNa aura bolanA kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko kava mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA? uttara-bhApA vargaNA me se anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se bolane rUpa kArya huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko maanaa| aura muMha khulane ke kAraNa bolanerUpa kArya huA hai-aisI mAnyatA vAle ne kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko nahI maanaa| ____B prazna 23--bolanA kAraNa aura muMha khulA kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA? uttara--muMharUpa AhAra vargaNA me se anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se muMha khulane rUpa kArya huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko maanaa| aura bolane rUpa kArya ke kAraNa muha khulA hai to aisI mAnyatA vAle ne kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahIM maanaa| prazna 23-muha khulA kAraNa aura rAga kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kava mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA? uttara-AtmA ke cAritra guNa me se anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se rAgarUpa kArya huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko mAnA hai| aura muMha khulane ke kAraNa rAgarUpa kArya huA hai aisI mAnyatA vAle ne kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahIM mAnA hai| D prazna 23-bolanA kAraNa aura jJAna kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA ?

Page #213
( 207 ) uttara-AtmA ke jJAna guNa me se anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se jJAna huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko maanaa| aura bolane rUpa kArya ke kAraNa jJAna rUpa kArya huA hai aisI mAnyatA vAle ne kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahI mAnA hai| 24 A prazna 24-bhASA vargaNA kAraNa aura bolanA kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA ? uttara-anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se volane rUpa kArya huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko maanaa| aura bhASA vargaNA ke kAraNa bolane rUpa kArya huA haiaisI mAnyatA vAle ne kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko nahIM maanaa| ___B. prazna 24---muharUpa AhAra vargaNA kAraNa aura muha khulA kaary| kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA? uttara-anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kANa kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se muMha khulane rUpa kArya huA hai muMha rUpa AhAra vargaNA se nahIM huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko mAnA hai / aura muha rUpa AhAra vargaNA ke kAraNa muha khulane rUpa kArya huA hai-aisI mAnyatA vAle ne kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahI maanaa| C prazna 24--AtmA kA cAritra guNa kAraNa aura rAga kaary| kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA ? uttara-anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna

Page #214
( 208 ) kAraNa kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se rAga rUpa kArya huA hai AtmA ke cAritra guNa ke kAraNa nahI huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko maanaa| aura AtmA ke cAritra guNa ke kAraNa rAga rUpa kArya huA hai-aisI mAnyatA vAle ne kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahI maanaa| ___D. prazna 24-AtmA kA jJAna guNa kAraNa aura jJAna kaary| kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA ? uttara-anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa kA abhAva karake usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se jJAna rUpa kArya huA hai AtmA ke jJAna guNa ke kAraNa nahIM huA to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko mAnA / aura AtmA ke jJAna guNa ke kAraNa jJAna rUpa kArya huA hai-aisI mAnyatA vAle ne kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi kA nahI maanaa| 25 A. prazna 25-anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kAraNa aura bolanA kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA? uttara-bolanA rUpa kArya usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se huA hai, anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se nahI huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko maanaa| aura anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara se bolane rupa kArya huA aisI mAnyatA vAle ne kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahIM maanaa| ___B. prazna 25-anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kAraNa aura muha khulA kaary| kAraNAnuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA?

Page #215
( 206 ) uttara--muha khulA kArya-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se huA hai anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se nahI huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko mAnA / aura anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se muMha khulane rUpa kArya huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahI maanaa| ____C. prazna 25--anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kAraNa aura rAga kArya / kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko kava mAnA aura kaba nahIM mAnA? uttara-rAgarUpa kArya-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se huA hai anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se nahI huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko maanaa| aura anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se rAgarUpa kArya huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahI maanaa| ___D. prazna 25-anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya no nambara kAraNa aura jJAna kArya / kAraNAtuvidhAyoni kAryANi ko kaba mAnA aura phava nahIM mAnA? uttara-jJAna rUpa kArya-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se huA hai anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara ke kAraNa nahI huA hai to kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko mAnA / aura anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya nau nambara kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se jJAna rUpa kArya huA hai to aisI mAnyatA vAle ne kAraNAnuvidhAyIni kAryANi ko nahI maanaa| prazna 26-maiMne A~kha se nRtya dekhaa| isa vAkya me jJAna-rAga A~kha-nRtya, cAro kAryoM para praznottara 1 se 25 taka ke anusAra uttara do?

Page #216
( 210 ) prazna 27---maine hAtha se pustaka utthaaii| isa vAkya meM jJAna-rAga hAya-pustaka, ina cAro kAryoM para praznottara 1 se 25 taka ke anusAra uttara do? prazna 28-maine muMha se per3A khaayaa| isa vAkya meM jJAna-rAga-muMhaper3A, ina cAra kAryoM para praznottara 1 se 25 taka ke anusAra uttara do? prazna 26-maiMne nAka se phUla sNghaa| isa vAkya meM jJAna-rAga-nAkaphUla, ina cAra kAryoM para praznottara 1 se 25 taka ke anusAra uttara do? prazna 30~maiMne kAna se reDiyo sunaa| isa vAkya me jJAna-rAgakAna-reDiyo, ina cAra kAryoM para praznottara 1 se 25 taka ke anusAra uttara do? prazna 31-maiM kursI se uThA-isa vAkya me jJAna-rAga-kursI-uThanA, ina cAra kAryoM para praznottara 1 se 25 taka ke anusAra uttara do? prazna 32-~maiM lakar3I ke sahAre calA-isa vAkya me jJAna rAgalakaDI-calA, ina cAra kAryoM para praznottara 1 se 25 taka ke anusAra uttara do? prazna 33-karma ke udaya se mujhe bukhAra ho gayA isa vAkya me jJAna-rAga-karma kA udaya-bukhAra, ina cAra kAryoM para praznottara 1 se 25 taka ke anusAra uttara do? prazna 34-ThaDI havA calane ke kAraNa mujhe bukhAra ho gayA isa vAkya meM jJAna-rAga-ThaDI havA-bukhAra, ina cAra kAryoM para praznottara 1 se 25 taka ke anusAra uttara do? prazna 35--mere gale me khAMsI ho gaI isa vAkya meM jJAna-rAgagalA-khAMsI, ina cAra kAryoM para praznottara 1 se 25 taka ke anusAra uttara do?

Page #217
( 211 ) prazna 36-cakkU se merI UMgalI kaTa gaI isa vAkya meM jJAnarAga-cAkU-UgalI kaTanA, ina cAra kAryoM para praznottara 1 se 25 taka ke anusAra uttara do? prazna 37-maiMne cakalA-belana Adi se roTI banAI isa vAkya meM jJAna-rAga-cakalA-belana-roTI, ina pA~ca kAryoM para praznottara 1 se 25 taka ke anusAra uttara do? prazna 38-maiMne maMjana se dAMta sApha kiye-ima vAkya me jJAnarAga-manana-dAMta sApha, ina cAra kAryoM para praznottara 1 se 25 taka ke anusAra uttara do? / prazna 36-maiM pAuDara lagAne se gorA ho gayA-isa vAkya meM jJAnarAga-pAuDara-gorA, ina cAra kAryoM para praznottara 1 se 25 taka ke anusAra uttara do? prazna 40-maiMne hAtha kalama se pustaka banAI isa vAkya me jJAnarAga-kalama-hAtha-pustaka, ina pA~ca kAryoM para praznottara 1 se 25 taka ke anusAra uttara do? zrAvaka kA AcaraNa rAtri bhojana me trasa hiMsA hotI hai, isalie zrAvaka ko usakA tyAga hotA hI hai| isI prakAra anachane pAnI me bhI trasa jIva hote hai / zuddha aura moTe kapaDe se chAnane ke pazcAt hI zrAvaka pAnI pItA hai / rAtri ko to pAnI piye hI nahI aura dina me chAna kara piyeN| rAtri ko basa jIvo kA sacAra bahuta hotA hai| | isalie rAtri me khAna-pAna se basa jIvo kI hiMsA hotI hai| jisame trasa hiMsA hotI hai / aise kArya zrAvaka ke nahIM ho sakate / pUjya zrIkAnajI svAmI zrAvaka dharma prakAza 53-54 .

Page #218
( 212 ) navamA adhikAra svatantratA kI ghoSaNA (cAra bolo se svatantratA kI ghoSaNA karatA huA vizeSa pravacana) pUjya zrI kAnajI svAmI kA pravacana samayasAra-kalaga 211 bhagavAna sarvajJadeva kA dekhA huA vastu svabhAva kaisA hai, usameM kartA-karmapanA kisa prakAra hai, vaha aneka prakAra se dRSTAMta aura yuktipUrvaka puna punaH samajhAte huye, usa svabhAva ke nirNaya meM mokSamArga kisa prakAra AtA hai vaha pUjya gurudeva ne ina pravacanoM me batalAyA hai| inameM punaH punaH bhedajJAna karAyA hai aura vItarAga-mArga ke rahasyabhUta svatantratA kI ghoSaNA karate hue kahA hai ki sarvajJadeva dvArA kahe hue isa parama satya vItarAga-vijJAna ko jo samajhegA usakA apUrva kalyANa hogaa| kartA-karma sambandhI bhedajJAna karAte hue AcAryadeva kahate hai ki nanu pariNAma eva phila karma vinizcayataH sa bhavati nAparasya pariNAmina eva bhavet / na bhavati kartRzUnyamiha karma na caikalyA sthitiriha vastuno bhavatu kartR tadeva tata // 21 // vastu svayaM apane pariNAma kI kartA hai, aura anya ke sAtha usakA

Page #219
( 213 ) kartA-karma kA sambandha nahI hai-isa siddhAMta ko AcAryadeva ne cAya volo se spaSTa samajhAyA hai - (1) pariNAma arthAta paryAya ho karma hai-kArya hai| (2) pariNAma apane AzrayabhUta pariNAmI ke hI hote haiM, anya ke nahI hote / kyoki pariNAma apane-apane AzrayabhUta pariNAma (dravya) ke Azraya se hote hai / anya ke pariNAma anya ke Azraya se nahI hote| (3) karma kartA ke binA nahIM hotA, arthAt pariNAma vastu ke binA nahIM hote| (4) vastu ko nirantara eka samAna sthiti nahI rahato, kyoMki vastu dravya-paryAya svarUpa hai| isa prakAra AtmA aura jaDa sabhI vastuye svaya hI apane pariNAmarUpa kama kI kartA hai-aisA vastu svarUpa kA mahAna siddhAta AcArya deva ne samajhAyA hai aura usI kA yaha pravacana hai| isa pravacana me aneka prakAra me spaSTIkaraNa karate hue gurudeva ne bhedajJAna ko puna: puna samajhAyA hai| dekho, isame vastu svarUpa ko cAra volo dvArA samajhAyA hai| isa jagata me chaha vastuye hai AtmA ananta hai, pudgala paramANu anantAnanta haiM tathA dharma, adhama, AkAza aura kAla-aisI chaho prakAra kI vastuye aura unake svarUpa kA vAstavika niyama kyA hai ? siddhAnta kyA hai ? use yahA cAra bolo me samajhAyA jA rahA hai - (1) pariNAma ho karma hai| prathama to 'nanu pariNAma eva kila karma vinizcayata' arthAt pariNAmI vastu ke jo pariNAma hai vahI nizcaya se usakA karma hai / karma arthAt kArya, pariNAma arthAt avasthA; padArtha kI avasthA hI vAstava me usakA karma-kArya hai| pariNAmI arthAta akhaNDa vastu; vaha jisa

Page #220
( 214 ) bhAva se pariNamana kare usako pariNAma kahate haiM / pariNAma kaho kArya kaho, paryAya kaho yA karma kaho-vaha vastu ke pariNAma hI haiN| jaise ki-AtmA jJAnaguNasvarUpa hai; usakA pariNamana hone se jAnane kI paryAya huI vaha usakA karma hai, vaha usakA vartamAna kArya hai| rAga yA zarIra vaha koI jJAna kA kArya nahI, parantu 'yaha rAga hai, yaha zarIra hai, aisA unhe jAnane vAlA jo jJAna hai vaha AtmA kA kArya hai| AtmA ke pariNAma vaha AtmA kA kArya hai aura jaDa ke pariNAma arthAta jaDa kI avasthA vaha jaDa kA kArya hai| isa prakAra eka vola pUrNa huaa| (2) pariNAma vastukA hI hotA hai, dUsare kA nhiiN| aba, isa dUsare bola me kahate haiM ki-jo pariNAma hotA hai vaha pariNAmI padArtha kA hI hotA hai, pariNAma kisI anya ke Azraya se nahI hotaa| jisa prakAra zravaNa ke samaya jo jJAna hotA hai vaha kArya hai-karma hai / vaha kisakA kArya hai ? vaha kahI zabdo kA kArya nahIM hai, parantu pariNAmI vastu jo AtmA hai usI kA vaha kArya hai| pariNAmI ke binA pariNAma nahIM hotaa| AtmA pariNAmI hai-usake vinA jJAna pariNAma nahI hotA-yaha siddhAta hai| parantu vANI ke binA jJAna nahIM hotA-yaha bAta saca nahI hai| zabdo ke binA jJAna nahI hotA-aisA nahI, parantu AtmA ke binA jJAna nahI hotaa| isa prakAra pariNAmI ke Azraya se hI jJAnAdi pariNAma hai| dekho, yaha mahA siddhAMta hai, vastusvarUpa kA yaha abAdhita niyama pariNAmI ke Azraya' se hI usake pariNAma hote haiM jAnanevAlA mAtmA vaha pariNAmI hai, usake Azrita hI jJAna hotA hai, ve jJAnapariNAma AtmA ke haiM, vANI ke nhiiN| vANI ke rajakaNo ke Azrita jJAna nahI hote, parantu jJAnasvabhAvI AtmAvastu ke Azraya sa

Page #221
( 215 ) ve pariNamana hote haiM / AtmA trikAla sthita rahane vAlA pariNAmI hai, vaha svaya rUpAtara hokara navIna-navIna avasthAo ko dhAraNa karatA hai| usake jJAna-Ananda ityAdi jo vartamAna bhAva haiM ve usake pariNAma haiN| _ 'pariNAma' pariNAmI ke hI haiM anya ke nahI-isame jagata ke sabhI padArthoM kA niyama A jAtA hai| pariNAma pariNAmI ke hI Azrita hote haiM, anya ke Azrita nahI hote haiN| jJAna pariNAma AtmA ke Azrita haiM, bhASA Adi anya ke Azrita jJAna ke pariNAma nahI hai| isaliye isame para kI ora dekhanA nahI rahatA, parantu apanI vastu ke sAmane dekhakara svasanmukha pariNamana karanA rahatA hai usame mokSa mArga A jAtA hai| __ vANI to ananta jaDa paramANuo kI avasthA hai, vaha apane paramANuo ke Azrita hai| bolane kIjo icchA huI usake Azrita bhApA ke pariNAma tIna kAla me nahI haiM / jaba icchA huI aura bhASA nikalI usa samaya usakA jo jJAna huA vaha jJAna AtmA ke Azraya se hI huA hai / bhASA ke Azraya se tathA icchA ke Azraya se jJAna nahI huA hai| pariNAma apane AzrayabhUta pariNAmI ke hI hote hai, anya ke Azraya se nahI hote-~-isa prakAra asti-nAsti se anekAnta dvArA vastusvarUpa samajhAyA hai / satya ke siddhAMta kI arthAt vastu satasvarUpa yaha bAta hai, usako pahicAne vinA mRDhatApUrvaka ajJAnatA me hI jIvana pUrNa kara DAlatA hai / parantu bhAI / AtmA kyA ? jaDa kyA ? usakI bhinnatA samajhakara vastusvarUpa ke vAstavika sat ko samajhe binA jJAna me satapanA nahI AtA, arthAt samyagjJAna nahI hotA, vastusvarUpa ke satyajJAna ke binA ruci aura zraddhA mI nahI hotI, aura saccI zraddhA ke binA vastu me sthiratA rUpa cAritra pragaTa nahI hotA, zAnti nahI hotI samAdhAna aura sukha nahI hotaa| isaliye vastusvarUpa kyA hai use prathama

Page #222
( 216 ) samajhanA cAhiye / vastusvarUpa ko samajhane se mere pariNAma para se aura para ke pariNAma mujhase-aisI parAzrita buddhi nahIM rahatI arthAt svAzrita-svasanmukha pariNAma pragaTa hotA hai, yahI dharma hai| __ AtmA ko jo jJAna hotA hai usako jAnane ke pariNAma AtmA ke Azrita hai, ve pariNAma vANI ke Azraya se nahIM hue hai, kAna ke Azraya se nahIM hue hai, tathA usa samaya kI icchA ke Azraya se bhI nahI hue haiN| yadyapi icchA bhI AtmA ke pariNAma haiM, parantu una pariNAmo ke Azrita jJAna pariNAma nahIM hai, jJAna pariNAma Atmavastu ke Azrita haiM -isaliye vastu sanmukha dRSTi kr| bolane kI icchA ho, hoTha hile, bhApA nikale ora usa samaya usa prakAra kA jJAna ho--aisI cAro kriyAye eka sAtha hote hue bhI koI kriyA kisI ke Azrita nahI, sabhI apane-apane pariNAmI ke hI Azrita hai / icchA baha AtmA ke cAritraguNa ke pariNAma haiM, hoTha hile vaha hoTha ke rajakaNo kI avasthA hai, vaha avasthA icchA ke AdhAra se nahIM huii| bhASA pragaTa ho vaha bhApAvargaNA ke rajakaNo kI avasthA hai vaha avasthA icchA ke Azrita yA hoTha ke Azrita nahIM huI, parantu pariNAmI aine rajakaNo ke Azraya se vaha bhApA utpanna huI hai aura usa samaya kA jJAna Atmavastu ke Azrita hai, icchA athavA bhASA ke Azrita nahIM hai, aisA vastusvarUpa hai / bhAI, tIna kAla tIna loka me sarvajJa bhagavAna kA dekhA huA yaha vastusvabhAva hai, use jAne binA aura samajhane kI paravAha binA andhe kI bhAti calA jAtA hai, parantu vastusvarUpa ke sacce jJAna ke binA kisI prakAra kahI bhI kalyANa nahI ho sktaa| isa vastusvarUpa ko bArambAra lakSa me lekara pariNAmo me bhedajJAna karane ke lie yaha bAta hai| eka vastu ke pariNAma anya vastu ke Azrita to hai nahI, parantu usa vastu me bhI usake eka pariNAma ke Azrita dUsare pariNAma nahI

Page #223
( 217 ) hai| pariNAmI vastu ke Azrita hI pariNAma hai| yaha mahAna siddhAta pratikSaNa icchA, bhASA aura jJAna yaha tIno eka sAtha hote hue bhI icchA aura jJAna jIva ke Azrita hai aura bhApA vaha jaDa ke Azrita haiM, icchA ke kAraNa bhApA huI aura bhASA ke kAraNa jJAna huA-aisA nahI, usI prakAra icchA ke Azrita jJAna bhI nhii| icchA aura jJAna yaha dono hai to AtmA ke pariNAma tathApi eka ke Azrita dUsare ke pariNAma nahIM hai| jJAna pariNAma aura icchA pariNAma dono bhinnabhinna hai / jAna vaha icchA kA kArya nahI hai aura icchA vaha jJAna kA kArya nahIM hai| jahA jJAna kA kArya icchA bhI nahI vahA jaDa bhASA Adi to usakA kArya kahA se ho sakatA hai ? vaha to jaDa kA kArya hai| ___ jagata me jo bhI kArya hote haiM vaha sat kI avasthA hotI hai, kisI vastu ke pariNAma hote hai, parantu vastu ke vinA adhara se pariNAma nahI hote| pariNAmI kA pariNAma hotA hai, nitya sthita vastu ke Azrita pariNAma hote hai, para ke Azrita nahIM hote| paramANu me hoTho kA hilanA aura bhApA kA pariNamana-yaha dono bhI bhinna vastu hai| AtmA me icchA aura jJAna-yaha dono pariNAma bhI bhinna-bhinna hai| hoTha hilane ke Azrita bhApA kI paryAya nahI hai / hoTha kA hilanA vaha hoTha ke pudagalo ke Azrita hai, bhASA kA pariNamana vaha bhApA ke pudgalo ke Azrita hai| hoTha aura bhApA, icchA aura jJAna-ina cAro kA kAla eka hone para bhI cAro pariNAma alaga haiN| usame bhI icchA aura jJAna-yaha dono pariNAma AtmAzrita hone para bhI icchA pariNAma ke Azrita jJAna pariNAma nahI hai| jJAna vaha AtmA kA pariNAma hai, icchA kA nahIM, isI prakAra icchA vaha AtmA kA pariNAma hai, jJAna kA nhii| icchA ko jAnane vAlA jJAna vaha

Page #224
( 218 ) 'icchA kA kArya nahIM hai, usI prakAra vaha jJAna icchA ko utpanna nahIM karatA, icchA-pariNAma AtmA kA kArya avazya hai parantu jJAna kA kArya nahIM / bhinna-bhinna guNa ke pariNAma bhinna-bhinna haiM, eka hI dravya me hone para bhI eka guNa ke Azrita dUsare guNa ke pariNAma nahI kitanI svatantratA / / aura isame para ke Azraya kI to bAta hI kahA rahI ? - AtmA meM cArinaguNa ityAdi ananta guNa hai, uname cAritra ke 'vikRta pariNAma so icchA hai, vaha cAritraguNa ke Azrita hai, aura usa samaya icchA kA jJAna huA vaha jJAnaguNa rUpa pariNAmI ke pariNAma haiM, vaha kahI icchA ke pariNAma ke Azrita nahIM hai| isa prakAra icchA pariNAma aura jJAna pariNAma dono kA bhinna pariNamana hai, eka-dUsare ke Azrita nahIM hai| sat jaisA hai usI prakAra usakA jJAna kare to sat jJAna ho aura sat kA jJAna kare to usakA vahumAna eva yathArtha kA Adara pragaTa ho, ruci ho, zraddhA dRDha ho aura usame sthiratA ho, use dharma kahA jAtA hai / sat se viparIta jJAna kare use dharma nahIM hotA / sva me sthiratA hI mUladharma hai, parantu vastusvarUpa ke sacce jJAna vinA sthiratA kahA~ karegA? AtmA aura zarIrAdi rajakaNa bhinna-bhinna tatva haiM; zarIra kI avasthA, halana-calana-bolanA, vaha usake pariNAmI pudgalokA pariNAma hai, una pudgalo ke Azrita vaha pariNAma utpanna huye haiM, icchA ke Azrita nahI; usI prakAra icchA ke Azrita jJAna bhI nahIM hai / pudgala ke pariNAma AtmA ke Azrita mAnanA, aura AtmA ke pariNAma pudgalAzrita mAnanA, usame to viparIta mAnyatA rUpa mUDhatA hai / jagata me bhI jo vastu jaisI ho usase viparIta batalAne vAle ko loga mUrkha kahate haiM, to phira sarvajJa kathita yaha lokottara vastu svabhAva

Page #225
( 216 ) jaisA hai vaisA na mAnakara viruddha mAne to lokottara mUrkha aura avivekI hai, vivekI aura vilakSaNa kaba kahA jAya ? kisI vastu ke jo pariNAma huye use kArya mAnakara, use pariNAmI-vastu ke Azrita samajhe aura dUsare ke Azrita na mAne, taba sva-para kA bheda jJAna hotA hai aura tabhI vivekI hai aisA kahane me AtA hai| AtmA ke pariNAma para ke Azraya nahI hote / vikArI aura avikArI jo bhI pariNAma jisa vastu ke haiM vaha usI vastu ke Azrita hai, anya ke Azrita nhii| padArtha ke pariNAma vahI usakA kArya hai-yaha eka bAta, dUsarI vAta yaha ki vaha pariNAma usI vastu ke Azraya me hote haiM, anya ke Azraya se nahIM hote| --yaha niyama jagata ke samasta padArtho me lAgU hote haiN| dekho bhAI / yaha bheda jJAna ke lie vastu svabhAva ke niyama batalAye gaye haiN| dhIre-dhIre dRSTAta se yukti se vastu svarUpa siddha kiyA jAtA kisI ko aise bhAva utpanna huye ki sau rupaye dAna me daM, usake vaha pariNAma Atma vastu ke bAzrita huye haiM, vahA~ rupaye jAne kI jo kriyA hotI hai vaha rupaye ke rajakaNo ke Azrita haiM, jova kI icchA ke Azrita nahI / aba usa samaya una rupayo kI kriyA kA jJAna, athavA icchA ke bhAva kA jJAna hotA hai vaha jJAna pariNAma AtmAzrita huA hai-isa prakAra pariNAmo kA vibhAjana karake vastu svarUpa kA jJAna karanA caahiye| ___ bhAI, terA jJAna aura terI icchA, yaha dono pariNAma AtmA me hote huye bhI ve eka dUsare ke Azrita nahIM hai, to phira para ke Azraya kI to bAta hI kahA~ rahI ? dAna kI icchA huI aura rupaye diye gaye, vahA rupaye jAne kI kriyA bhI hAtha ke Azrita nahI, hAtha kA hilanA icchA ke Azrita nahI, aura icchA kA pariNamana vaha jJAna ke Azrita nahI hai sabhI apane-apane AzrayabhUta vastu ke AdhAra se hai|

Page #226
( 220 ) devo, yaha sarvana ke vijJAna pATha hai, aisA vastu svatpa kA jJAna saccA padArtha vijJAna hai / jagata ke padAryoM kA svabhAva hI aisA hai ki ve sadA eka rUpa nahIM rahate, parantu pariNamana karake navIna navIna avasthA rUpa nArya kiyA karate hai, ---yaha vAta cauthe vola meM kahI jaayegii| jagana ke padAyoM kA svabhAva aisA hai ki vaha nitya sthAyI rahe aura usame pratikSaNa navIna-navIna avasthA rUpa kArya usake apane Azrita huA kare / vastu svabhAva kA aisA jAna hI samyagjJAna hai| jIva ko ucchA huI isaliye hAtha hilA aura sI rupaye diye gayeaisA nahIM hai| (1) icchA kA AdhAra AtmA hai, hAtha aura rupayo kA AdhAra paramANu hai / (2) rupaye jAne the isaliye icchA huI aisA bhI nahIM hai| (3) hAtha kA halana-calana vaha hAtha ke paramANuo ke AdhAra se hai| (4) spayo kA AnA-jAnA vaha rupayA ke paramANuo ke gavAra se hai| inchA kA honA vaha AtmA ke cAritra gaNa ke AdhAra se hai| __yaha to bhinna-bhinna dravya ke pariNAma kI bhinnatA kI vAta huI, yahA to usase bhI Age andara kI bAta lenA hai| eka hI dravya ke aneka pariNAma bhI eka-dUsare ke Azrita nahI hai-sA vatalAnA hai rAga aura jJAna dono ke kArya bhinna hai, eka-dUsare ke Azrita nahIM hai| kisI ne gAlI dI aura jIva ko dvapa ke pApa-pariNAma huye, vahA ve pApa ke pariNAma pratikUlatA ke kAraNa nahI huye, Ara gAlI dene vAle ke Azrita bhI nahI huye, parantu cAritraguNa ke Azrita huye hai, cAritraguNa ne usa samaya usa pariNAma ke anusAra pariNamana kiyA hai| anya to nimittamAtra haiN| . aba Sa ke samaya usakA jJAna huA ki 'mujhe yaha dveSa huA'yaha jJAna pariNAma jJAnaguNa ke Azrita hai, krodha ke Azrita nahIM hai| jJAnasvabhAvI dravya ke Azrita jJAna pariNAma hote hai, anya ke Azrita nahI hote| isI prakAra samyagdarzana pariNAma, samyagjJAna pariNAma,

Page #227
( 221 ) Ananda pariNAma ityAdi me bhI aisA hI samajhanA / yaha jJAnAdi pariNAma dravya ke Azrita haiM, anya ke Azrita nahI tathA paraspara eka-dUsare ke Azrita bhI nahIM hai| gAlI ke zabda athavA dveSa ke samaya usakA bhAna huA, vaha jJAna zabdo ke Azrita nahIM hai aura krodha ke Azrita bhI nahI hai, usa kA AdhAra to jJAnasvabhAvI vastu hai-isalie unake Upara dRSTi lagA to terI paryAya me mokSamArga pragaTa ho, isa mokSamArgarUpI kArya kA kartA bhI tU hI hai, anya koI nhii| ___aho, yaha to sugama aura spaSTa bAta hai| laukika paDhAI adhika na kI ho, tathApi yaha samajha me A jAye aisA hai| jarA andara me utara kara lakSa me lenA cAhiye ki AtmA asti rUpa hai, usame ananta guNa haiM, jJAna hai, Ananda hai, zraddhA hai, astitva hai isa prakAra ananta guNa hai| isa ananta guNo ke bhinna-bhinna ananta pariNAma prati samaya hote hai, una sabhI kA AdhAra pariNAmI aisA Atmadravya hai, anya vastu to usakA AdhAra nahI hai, parantu apane me dUsare guNo ke pariNAma bhI usakA AdhAra nahI hai, -jaise ki zraddhA pariNAma kA AdhAra jJAna pariNAma nahI hai aura jJAna pariNAma kA AdhAra zraddhA nahI hai, dono pariNAmo kA AdhAra AtmA hI hai| usI prakAra sarva gUNo ke pariNAmo ke liye samajhanA / isa prakAra pariNAma pariNAmI kA hI hai, anya kA nhii| isa 211ve kalaza me AcAryadeva dvArA kahe gaye vastusvarUpa ke cAra bolo me se abhI dUsare bola kA vivecana cala rahA hai| prathama to kahA ki 'pariNAma eva kila karma' aura phira kahA ki 'sa bhavati pariNAmina eva, na aparasya bhavet' pariNAma hI karma hai, aura yaha pariNAmI kA hI hotA hai, anya kA nahI, --aisA nirNaya karake sva-dravya sanmukha lakSa jAne se samyagdarzana aura samyagjJAna pragaTa hotA hai| samyagjJAna pariNAma huye vaha AtmA kA karma hai, vaha AtmArUpa

Page #228
( 222 ) pariNAmI ke AdhAra se hue hai| pUrva ke mandarAga ke Azraya se athavA vartamAna me zubharAga ke Azraya se ve samyagdazana pariNAma nahIM hue| yadyapi rAga bhI hai to AtmA kA pariNAma, parantu zraddhA-pariNAma se rAga pariNAma anya hai, ve zraddhA ke pariNAma rAga ke Azrita nahIM haiN| kyoki pariNAma pariNAmI ke hI Azraya se hote hai, anya ke Azraya se nahIM hote| usI prakAra cAritra pariNAma me-AtmasvarUpa me sthiratA vaha cAritra kA kArya hai, vaha kArya zraddhA pariNAma ke Azrita nahI, jJAna ke Azrita nahI, parantu cAritraguNa dhAraNa karane vAle AtmA ke hI Azrita hai / zarIrAdi ke Azraya se cAritra nahIM hai / (1) zraddhA ke pariNAma Atmadravya ke Azrita haiM; (2) jJAna ke pariNAma Atmadravya ke Azrita haiM; (3) sthiratA ke pariNAma Atmadravya ke Azrita hai| (4) Ananda ke pariNAma Atmadravya ke Azrita haiN| basa, mokSa mArga ke sabhI pariNAma sva dravyAzrita hai, anya ke Azrita nahIM haiM, usa samaya anya (rAgAdi) pariNAma hote haiM unake Azrita bhI yaha pariNAma nahIM hai| eka samaya me zraddhA-jJAna-cAritrA ityAdi ananta guNo ke pariNAma vaha dharma, unakA AdhAra dharmI arthAta pariNamita hone vAlI vastu hai, usa samaya anya jo aneka pariNAma hote hai unake AdhAra se zraddhA ityAdi ke pariNAma nahI haiN| nimitAdi ke AdhAra se to nahI hai, parantu apane dUsare pariNAma ke AdhAra se bho koI pariNAma nahIM hai| eka hI dravya me eka sAtha hone vAle pariNAma me bhI eka pariNAma dUsare pariNAma ke Azrita nahI, dravya ke hI Azrita sabhI pariNAma haiM, sabhI pariNAmo rUpa se pariNamana karane vAlA dravya hI hai-arthAt dravya sanmukha lakSa jAte hI samyak paryAye pragaTa hone lagatI haiN|

Page #229
( 223 ) vAha / dekho, AcAryadeva kI zailI thoDe me bahuta samA dene kI hai| cAra bolo ke isa mahAna siddhAta me vastusvarUpa ke bahuta se niyamo kA samAveza ho jAtA hai| yaha trikAla satya sarvajJa dvArA nizcita kiyA huA siddhAta hai| aho, yaha pariNAmI ke pariNAma kI svAdhInatA, sarvajJadeva dvArA kahA huA vastusvarUpa kA tattva, santo ne isakA vistAra karake AzcaryakArI kArya kiyA hai, padArtha kA pRthakkaraNa karake bhedajJAna karAyA hai| andara me isakA manthana karake dekha to mAlUma ho ki ananta sarvajJo tathA santo ne aisA hI vastu svarUpa kahA hai aura aisA hI vastu kA svarUpa hai| ___ sarvajJa bhagavanta divyadhvani dvArA aisA tattva kahate Aye haiM--aisA vyavahAra se kahA jAtA hai, divyadhvani to paramANuo ke Azrita hai| ___ koI kahe ki are, divyadhvani bhI paramANu-Azrita hai ? hA~, divyadhvani vaha pudgala kA pariNAma hai, aura pudgala pariNAma kA AdhAra to pudgala dravya hI hotA hai, jova usakA AdhAra nahIM ho sktaa| bhagavAna kA AtmA to apane kevala jJAnAdi kA AdhAra hai| bhagavAna AtmA to kevalajJAna-darzana-sukha ityAdi nija pariNAmarUpa pariNamana karatA hai, parantu kahI deha aura vANIrUpa avasthA dhAraNa karake bhagavAna kA AtmA pariNamita nahIM hotA, usa rUpa to pudgala hI pariNamita hotA hai| pariNAma pariNAmI ke hI hote haiM, anya ke nhiiN| bhagavAna kI sarvajJatA ke AdhAra se divyadhvani ke pariNAma hueaisA vastusvarUpa nahI hai| bhASA pariNAma ananta pudgalAzrita hai, aura sarvajJatA Adi pariNAma jIvAzrita hai, isa prakAra dono kI bhinnatA hai| koI kisI kA kartA yA AdhAra nahI hai| dekho, yaha bhagavAna AtmA kI apanI bAta hai / samajha me nahI AyegI, aisA nahI mAnanA; andara lakSa kare to samajha me Aye-aisI sarala hai| dekho, lakSa me lo ki andara koI vastu hai yA nahI ? aura yaha jo jAnane ke yA rAgAdi ke bhAva hote haiM ina bhAvoM kA kartA kauna

Page #230
( 224 ) hai ? AtmA svaya unakA kartA hai| isa prakAra AtmA ko lakSa me lene ke lie dUsarI paDhAI kI kahA AvazyakatA hai ? duniyA kI vegAra karake dukhI hotA hai usake vadale vastusvabhAva ko samajhe to kalyANa ho jAye / are jIva / aise sundara nyAya dvArA santo ne vastusvarUpa samajhAyA hai une tU samajha / vastusvatya ke do vola hue| ava tIsarA bola - (3) kartA ke binA karma nahIM hotA kartA arthAt pariNamita hone vAlI vastu aura karma arthAta usakI avasthA rUpa kArya; kartA ke binA karma nahIM hotA, arthAt vastu ke vinA paryAya nahIM hotI, sarvathA gUnya me me koI kArya utpanna ho jAye aisA nahIM hotaa| dekho, yaha vastu vijJAna ke mahAna siddhAMta hai, isa 21zve kalaza me cAra volo dvArA nAge pakSo se svatantratA siddha kI hai| videzo me ajAna kI paDhAI ke pIche hairAna hote hai, usakI apekSA sarvajadeva kathita isa parama satya vItarAgI vijJAna ko samajhe to apUrva kalyANa ho / (1) pariNAma so karma , yaha eka vaat| (2) vaha pariNAma kisakA ?-ki pariNAmI vastu kA pariNAma hai, dUsare kA nhiiN| yaha dUsarA bola isakA bahuta vistAra kiyA hai| ___ aba isa tIsare vola me kahate hai ki-pariNAmI ke vinA pariNAma 'nahI hotaa| pariNAmI vastu se bhinna anyatra kahI pariNAma ho aisA nahI hotaa| pariNAmI vastu me hI usake pariNAma hote haiM, isalie pAraNAmI vastu vaha kartA hai, usake vinA kArya nahIM hotaa| dekho, isame nimitta ke vinA nahI hotA-aisA nahIM khaa| nimitta nimitta me rahatA hai, vaha, kahI isa kArya me nahI A jAtA, isalie nimitta ke vinA kArya hai parantu pariNAmI ke vinA kArya nahIM hotaa| nimitta bhale

Page #231
( 225 ) ho, parantu usakA astitva to nimitta me hai, isame usakA astitva nahI hai| pariNAmI vastu ko sattA me hI usakA kArya hotA hai / AtmA ke binA samyaktvAdi pariNAma nahI hote / apane samasta pariNAmo kA kartA AtmA hai, usake vinA karma nahIM hotaa| "karma kRta zUnya na bhavati"-pratyeka padArtha kI avasthA usa-usa padArtha ke vinA nahI hotii| sonA nahI hai aura gahane bana gaye, vastu nahI hai aura avasthA ho gaI-aisA nahI ho sktaa| avasthA hai vaha traikAlika vastu ko pragaTa karatI hai-prasiddha karatI hai ki yaha avasthA isa vastu kI hai| ___ jaise ki-jaDa karmarUpa pudgala hote haiM, ve karma pariNAma kartA ke vinA nahI hote / aba unakA kartA ?-to kahate hai ki-usa pudgala karmarUpa pariNamita hone vAle rajakaNa hI kartA hai, AtmA unakA kartA nahI hai / (a) AtmA kartA hokara jaDa karma kA bandha kare-aisA vastusvarUpa me nahI hai| (A) jaDakarma AtmA ko vikAra karAye-aisA vastusvarUpa meM nahIM hai| (i) manda kaSAyake pariNAma samyaktva kA AdhAra ho-aisA vastusvarUpa me nahI hai| (I) zubha rAga se kSAyika samyaktva ho--aisA vasturUpa me nahI hai| __ tathApi ajJAnI aisA mAnatA hai yaha saba to viparIta hai-anyAya hai| bhAI tere yaha anyAya vastusvarUpa me sahana nahI hoge| vastusvarUpa ko viparIta mAnane se tere AtmA ko bahuta dukha hogA,-aisI karuNA santo ko AtI hai / santa nahI cAhate ki koI jIva dukhI ho| jagata ke sAre jIva satya svarUpa ko samajhe aura dukha se chUTakara sukha prApta kare-aisI unakI bhAvanA hai| bhAI / tere samyagdarzana kA AdhAra terA Atmadravya hai| zubharAga kahI usakA AdhAra nahI hai / mandarAga vaha kartA aura samyagdarzana usakA kArya aisA trikAla me nahI hai / vastu kA jo svarUpa hai vaha tIna kAla me Age pIche nahI ho sktaa| koI jIva ajJAna se use viparIta

Page #232
( 226 ) mAne usase kahI satya vadala nahIM jaataa| koI samajhe yA na samajhe, satya to sadA satyarUpa hI rahegA, vaha kabhI vadalegA nahA / jo use yathAvat samajhege ve apanA kalyANa kara leMge aura jo nahI samajhege unakI to vAta hI kyA ? ve to sasAra meM bhaTaka hI rahe hai|| dekho, vANI sunI isalie jJAna hotA hai na / parantu sonagaDha vAle inkAra karate hai ki 'vANI ke AdhAra se jJAna nahIM hotA',-aisA kaha kara kucha loga kaTAkSa karate hai, lekina bhAI / yaha to vastusvarUpa hai, trilokInAtha sarvajJa paramAtmA bhI divyadhvani meM yahI kahate hai kijJAna AtmA ke Azraya se hotA hai, jJAna vaha AtmA kA kArya hai, divyadhvani ke paramANu kA vaha kArya nahIM hai / jJAna kArya kA kartA AtmA hai, na ki vANI ke rajakaNa ? jisa padAtha ke jisa guNa kA jo vartamAna ho vaha anya padArtha ke yA anya guNa ke Azraya se nahIM hotaa| usakA kartA kauna ? -ki vastu svaya / kartA aura usakA kArya dono eka hI vastu me hone kA niyama hai, ve bhinna vastu me nahIM hote| yaha lakaDI Upara uThI so kArya hai, yaha kisakA kArya hai ? -ki kartA kA kArya, kartA ke binA kArya nahIM hotaa| kartA kauna hai ? - ki lakaDI ke rajakaNa hI lakaDI kI isa avasthA ke kartA haiM, yaha hAtha, agulI yA icchA usake kartA nahIM hai| ___ aba antara kA sUkSma dRSTAta le-kisI AtmA me icchA aura samyagjJAna dono pariNAma vartate haiM, vahA icchA ke AdhAra se samyagjJAna nahIM hai / icchA samyagjJAna kI kartA nahIM hai| AtmA hI kartA hokara usa kArya ko karatA hai| kartA ke vinA karma nahIM hai aura dUsarA koI kartA nahI hai, isaliye jIva kartA dvArA jJAna kArya hotA hai| isa prakAra samasta padArthoM ke sarva kAryoM me usa padArtha kA kartApanA hai-aisA samajhanA caahie| dekho bhAI, yaha to sarvajJa bhagavAna ke ghara kI bAta hai, use sunakara santuSTa honA cAhie / ahA / santo ne vastu svarUpa samajhA kara mArga

Page #233
( 227 ) spaSTa kara diyA hai, santo ne sArA mArga sarala aura sugama banA diyA hai, usame vIca me kahI aTakanA paDe aisA nahI hai / para se bhinna aisI spaSTa vastusvarUpa samajhe to mokSa ho jaaye| bAhara se tathA andara se aisA bhedajJAna samajhane para mokSa hathelI me A jAtA hai| maiM to para se pRthaka hU~ aura mujha me eka guNa kA kArya dUsare guNa se nahI hai-yaha mahAna siddhAta samajhane para svAzraya bhAva se apUrva kalyANa pragaTa hotA ___karma apane kartA ke vinA nahI hotA-yaha vAta tIsare vola me kahI, aura cauthe pola me kartA kI (-vastu kI) sthiti ekarUpa arthAt sadA eka samAna nahI hotI, parantu vaha naye-naye pariNAmo rUpa se badalatI rahatI hai yaha bAta khege| hara vAra pravacana me isa cIthe bola kA vizeSa vistAra hotA hai, isa bAra dUsare vola kA vizepa vistAra AyA hai| kartA ke binA kArya nahI hotA yaha siddhAta hai, vahA koI kahe ki yaha jagata so kArya hai aura Izvara usakA kartA hai, to yaha bAta vastusvarUpa kI nahI hai| pratyeka vastu svaya hI apanI paryAya kA Izvara hai aura vahI kartA hai, usase bhinna dUsarA koI Izvara yA anya koI padArtha kartA nahIM hai| paryAya so kArya aura padArtha usakA krtaa| ___ kartA ke binA kArya nahIM aura dUsarA koI kartA nhiiN| koI bhI avasthA ho-zuddha avasthA, vikArI avasthA yA jaDa avasthA, usakA kartA na ho aisA nahI hotA tathA dUsarA koI kartA ho-aisA bhI nahI, hotA / to kyA bhagavAna usake kartA hai ? hAM, bhagavAna kartA avazya hai, parantu kauna bhagavAna ? anya koI bhagavAna nahIM parantu yaha AtmA svaya apanA bhagavAna hai vaha kartA hokara apane zuddha-azuddha pariNAmo ko karatA hai| jaDa ke pariNAma ko jaDa padArtha karatA hai, vaha apanA bhagavAna hai| pratyeka vastu apanI-apanI

Page #234
( 228 ) avasthA kI racayitA Izvara hai| sva kA svAmI hai para kA svAmI mAnanA mithyAtva hai| sayoga ke binA avasthA nahI hotI-aisA nahI hai, parantu vastu pariNamita hue binA avasthA nahI hotI-aisA siddhAta hai / paryAya ke kartRtva kA adhikAra vastu kA apanA hai usame para kA adhikAra nahI hai / icchArUpI kArya huA usakA kartA Atmadravya hai / usa samaya usakA jJAna huA, usa jJAna kA kartA Atmadravya hai / pUrva paryAya me tIna rAga thA isaliye vartamAna me rAga huA, isa prakAra pUrva paryAya me isa paryAya kA kartApanA nahI hai| vartamAna me AtmA vaise bhAvarUpa pariNAmita hokara svaya kartA huA hai| isI prakAra jJAnapariNAma, zraddhApariNAma, AnandapariNAma una saba kA kartA AtmA hai para kartA nhii| pUrva ke pariNAma bhI kartA nahI tathA vartamAna me usake sAtha vartate hue anya pariNAma bhI kartA nahI haiAtmadravya svaya kartA hai| zAstra me pUrva paryAya ko kabhI-kabhI upAdAna kahate haiM, vaha to pUrva-pazcAt ko sadhi batalAne ke lie kahA hai, parantu paryAya kA kartA to usa samaya vartatA huA dravya hai, vahI pariNAmI hokara kAryarUpa pariNamita huA hai| jisa samaya samyagdarzana paryAya huI usa samaya usakA kartA AtmA hI hai / pUrva kI icchA, vItarAga kI vANI yA zAstra-ve koI vAstava meM isa samyagdarzana ke kartA nahI haiN| usI prakAra jJAnakArya kA kartA bhI AtmA hI hai / icchA kA jJAna huA, vahA vaha jJAna kahI icchA kA kArya nahI hai aura vaha jJAna kA kArya nahI hai| dono pariNAma eka hI vastu ke hone para bhI unako kartA-karmapanA nahI hai, kartA to pariNAmI vastu hai| pudagala me khaTTI-khArI avasthA thI aura jJAna ne tadanusAra jAnA, vahA~ khaTTe-khAre to pudgala ke pariNAma haiM aura pudgala unakA kartA hai; tatsambandhI jo jJAna huA usakA kartA AtmA hai; usa jJAna kA

Page #235
( 226 ) kartA vaha khaTTI-khArI avasthA nahIM hai| kitanI svatantratA || usI prakAra zarIra me rogAdi jo kArya ho usake kartA ve pudgala haiM, AtmA nahIM aura usa zarIra kI avasthA kA jo jJAna huA usakA kartA AtmA hai| AtmA kartA hokara jJAna pariNAma ko karatA hai parantu zarIra kI avasthA ko vaha nahIM krtaa| yaha to paramezvara hone ke lie paramezvara ke ghara kI vAta hai| paramezvara sarvajJadeva kathita yaha vastusvarUpa hai| jagata me cetana yA jaDa ananta padArtha anantarUpa se nitya rahakara apane vartamAna kArya ko karate haiN| pratyeka paramANu me sparza-raga Adi ananta guNa, sparza kI cikanI Adi avasthA; raga kI kAlI Adi avasthA, usa usa avasthA kA kartA paramANudravya hai| cikanI avasthA vaha kAlI avasthA kI kartA nahIM hai| isa prakAra AtmA me-pratyeka AtmA me ananta guNa haiM; jJAna me kevalajJAna paryAyarUpa kArya humA, Ananda me pUrNa Ananda pragaTa huA usakA kartA AtmA svaya hai| manuSya-zarIra athavA svastha zarIra ke kAraNa vaha kArya huA aisA nahIM hai,pUrva kI mokSamArga paryAya ke AdhAra se vaha kArya huA aisA bhI nahI hai; jJAna aura Ananda ke pariNAma bhI eka-dUsare ke Azrita nahIM haiM, dravya hI pariNamita hokara usa kArya kA kartA humA hai| bhagavAna AtmA svaya hI apane kevalajJAnAdi kArya kA kartA hai, anya koI nahI / -yaha tIsarA bola huaa| (4) vastu ko sthiti sadA eka rUpa [-phUTastha] nahIM rahatI sarvajJadeva dvArA dekhA huA vastu kA svarUpa aisA hai ki vaha nitya avasthita rahakara pratikSaNa navIna avasthA rUpa pariNamita hotA rahatA hai| paryAya badale vinA jyo kA tyo kUTastha ho rahe-aisA vastu kA svarUpa nahI hai| vastu dravya-paryAya svarUpa hai, isalie usameM sarvathA akelAnityapanA nahIM hai, paryAya se parivartanapanA bhI hai| vastu svaya hI apanI paryAya rUpa se palaTatI hai koI dUsarA use parivartita kare-aisA

Page #236
( 230 ) nahI hai| nayI-nayI paryAyarUpa honA vaha vastu kA apanA svabhAva hai, to koI usakA kyA karegA? ina sayogo ke kAraNa yaha paryAya huI, -isa prakAra sayoga ke kAraNa jo paryAya mAnatA hai usane vastu ke pariNAmanasvabhAva ko nahI jAnA hai, do dravyo ko eka mAnA hai / bhAI, tU sayoga se na dekha, vastusvabhAva ko dekha / vastusvabhAva hI aisA hai vaha nitya ekarUpa na rahe / dravyarUpa se ekarUpa rahe parantu paryAyalpa se ekarUpa na rahe, palaTatA hI rahe-aisA vastusvarUpa hai| ina cAra volo se aisA samajhAyA hai ki vastu svaya hI apane pariNAma rUpa kArya ko kartA hai-yaha nizcita siddhAta hai| isa pustaka kA pRSTha pahale aimA thA aura phira palaTa gayA, vahA~ hAtha lagane se palaTA ho aisA nahIM hai, parantu una pRSTho ke rajakaNo me hI aisA svabhAva hai ki sadA ekarUpa unakI sthiti na rahe, unakI avasthA badalatI rahatI hai, isaliye ve svaya pahalI avasthA choDakara dUsarI avasthA rUpa huye hai, dUsare ke kAraNa nahI / vastu me bhinna-bhinna avasthA hotI hI rahatI hai, vahA~ sayoga ke kAraNa vaha bhinna avasthA huI-aisA ajJAno kA bhrama hai, kyoki vaha sayoga ko ho dekhatA hai parantu vastasvabhAva ko nahI dekhtaa| vastu svaya pariNamanasvabhAvI hai, isalie vaha eka hI paryAyarUpa nahIM rahatI,-aise svabhAva ko jAne to kisI sayoga se apane me yA apane se para me parivartana hone kI buddhi chUTa jAye aura svadravya kI ora dekhanA rahe, isalie mokSamArga pragaTa ho| pAnI pahale ThaDA thA aura cUlhe para Ane ke bAda garma huA, vahA~ una rajakaNo kA hI aisA svabhAva hai ki unakI sadA eka avasthA rUpa sthiti na rahe, isaliye ve apane svabhAva se hI ThaNDI avasthA ko choDakara garma avasthA rUpa pariNamita huye haiN| isa prakAra svabhAva ko na dekhakara ajJAnI sayoga ko dekhatA hai ki agni ke Ane se pAnI garma huaa| AcAryadeva ne cAra bolo se svatantra vastusvarUpa samajhAyA

Page #237
( 231 ) hai, use samajha le to kahI bhrama na rhe| eka samaya me tIna kAla-tIna loka ko jAnane vAle sarvajJa paramAtmA vItarAga tIrthakaradeva kI divyadhvani me AyA huA yaha tatva hai aura manto ne ise pragaTa kiyA hai| varpha ke sayoga se pAnI ThaDA huA aura agni ke sayoga se gama huA aisA ajJAnI dekhatA hai, parantu pAnI ke rajakaNo me hI ThaDAgarma avasthA rUpa pariNamita hone kA svabhAva hai use ajJAnI nahIM dekhatA / bhAI / vastu kA svarUpa aisA hI hai ki avasthA kI sthiti ekarUpa na rhe| vastu kUTastha nahIM hai parantu bahate huye pAnI bhAti dravita hotI hai-paryAya ko pravAhita karatI hai, usa paryAya kA pravAha vastu me se AtA hai, sayoga me se nahIM aataa| bhinna prakAra ke sayoga ke kAraNa avasthA kI bhinnatA huI, athavA sayoga vadale isaliye avasthA badala gaI-aisA bhrama ajJAnI ko hotA hai, parantu vastusvarUpa aisA nahIM hai| yahA~ cAra bolo dvArA vastu kA svarUpa ekadama spaSTa kiyA hai| (1) pariNAma hI karma hai| (2) pariNAmI vastu ke hI pariNAma hai, anya ke nhii| (3) vaha pariNAma rUpI karma kartA ke binA nahIM hotaa| (4) vastu kI sthiti ekarUpa nahI rhtii| -isaliye vastu svaya hI apane pariNAma rUpa karma ko kartA hai-yaha siddhAMta hai| ina cAro bolo me to bahuta rahasya bhara diyA hai| usakA nirNaya karane se bhedajJAna tathA dravya sanmukha dRSTi se mokSamArga pragaTa hogaa| prazna-saMyoga Aye tadanusAra avasthA badalatI dikhAI detI hai na? uttara-yaha barAbara nahIM hai, vastu svabhAva ko dekhane se aisA dikhAI nahIM detA, avasthA badalane kA svabhAva vastu kA apanA hai aisA dikhAI detA hai| karma kA mada udaya ho isaliye mada rAga aura tIvra udaya ho isaliye tIvra rAga-aisA nahIM hai, avasthA ekarUpa nahI rahatI, parantu apanI yogyatA se mada-tIvrarUpa se badalatI hai-aimA svabhAva vastu kA apanA hai, vaha kahI para ke kAraNa nahIM hai|

Page #238
( 232 ) bhagavAna ke nikaTa jAkara pUjA kare yA zAstra zravaNa kare usa samaya alaga pariNAma hote hai, aura ghara pahucane para alaga pariNAma ho jAte he to kyA sayoga ke kAraNa ve pariNAma badale ? nahI, vastu ekarUpa na rahakara usake pariNAma badalate rahe-aisA hI usakA svabhAva hai, una pariNAmo kA badalanA vastu ke Azraya se hI hotA hai, sayoga ke Azraya se nhii| isa prakAra vastu svayaM apane pariNAma kI kartA hai-yaha nizcita siddhAta hai| ina cAra volo ke siddhAMtAnusAra vastu svarUpa ko samajhe to mithyAtva kI jaDe ukhaDa jAyeM aura parAzritavuddhi chUTa jaaye| aise svabhAva kI pratIti hone se akhaNDa svavastu para lakSa jAtA hai aura samyagjJAna pragaTa hotA hai / samyagjJAna pariNAma kA kartA AtmA svaya hai| pahale ajJAna pariNAma bhI vastu ke hI Azraya se the aura aba jJAna pariNAma huye ve bhI vastu ke hI Azraya se haiM / merI paryAya kA kartA dUsarA koI nahIM hai, merA dravya pariNamata hokara merI paryAya kA kartA hotA hai-aisA nizcaya karane se svadravya para lakSa jAtA hai aura bhedajJAna tathA samyagjJAna hotA hai| aba, usa kAla kucha cAritradopa se rAgAdi pariNAma rahe vaha bhI azuddha nizcayanaya se AtmA kA pariNamana hone se AtmA kA kArya hai-aisA dharmI jIva jAnatA hai, use jAnane kI apekSA se vyavahAra ko usa kAla me jAnA huA prayojanavAna kahA hai| dharmI ko dravya kA zuddha svabhAva lakSa meM A gayA hai isalie samyaktvAdi nirmala kArya hote haiM aura jo rAga zepa rahA hai use bhI ve apanA pariNamana jAnate haiM parantu aba usakI mukhyatA nahI hai, mukhyatA to svabhAva kI ho gaI hai| pahale ajJAnadazA me mithyAtvAdi pariNAma the ve bhI svadravya ke azuddha upAdAna ke Azraya se hI the, parantu jaba nizcita kiyA ki mere pariNAma apane dravya ke hI Azraya se hote haiM taba usa jIva ko mithyAtva pariNAma nahI rahate, use to samyaktvAdi rUpa pariNAma hI hote haiN| aba jo rAga pariNamana sAdhaka paryAya me zeSa rahA hai usame yadyapi use ekatvabuddhi nahIM hai

Page #239
( 233 ) tathApi vaha pariNamana apanA hai-aisA vaha jAnatA hai| aisA vyavahAra kA jJAna usa kAla kA prayojanavAna hai / samyagjJAna hotA hai taba nizcaya" vyavahAra kA svarUpa yathArtha jJAta hotA hai taba dravya paryAya kA svarUpa jJAta hotA hai, taba kartA-karma kA svarUpa jJAta hotA hai aura svadravya ke lakSa se mokSamArga rUpa kArya pragaTa hotA hai, usakA kartA AtmA svaya hai| isa prakAra isa 211veM kalaza me AcArya deva ne cAra bolo dvArA spaSTa rUpa se alaukika vastusvarUpa samajhAyA hai, usakA vivecana pUrNa huaa| jaya mahAvIra-jaya mahAvIra -'.-- dasavA~ adhikAra bhaiyA bhagavatIdAsa jI viracita || upAdAna-nimitta dohA || dohA-pAda praNami jinadeva ke, eka ukti upajAya / __upAdAna arU nimitta ko, kahU~ saMvAda banAya // 1 artha-jinendradeva ke caraNo me praNAma karake eka apUrva kathana taiyAra karatA huuN| upAdAna aura nimitta kA savAda banAkara ise kahatA huuN| prazna-pUchata hai koU tahAM, upAdAna kiha nAma / kaho nimitta kahiye kahA, kaba ke hai iha ThAma // 2

Page #240
( 234 ) artha-yahA~ koI pUchatA hai ki upAdAna kisakA nAma hai ? nimitta "kise kahate haiM ? aura unakA savadha kaba se hai ? so kaho / uttara-upAdAna nija zakti hai jiyako mUla svabhAva / hai nimitta parayoga teM, banyo anAdi banAya // 3 artha-upAdAna apanI nijakI zakti hai vaha jIva kA mUla svabhAva hai aura para sayoga nimitta hai unakA sambandha anAdikAla se banA huA nimitta-nimitta kahai moko sabai, jAnata hai jaga loya / terA nAva na jAna hI, upAdAna ko hoya // 4 artha-nimitta kahatA hai ki jagat ke sabhI loga mujhe jAnate haiM aura upAdAna kauna hai, usakA nAma taka nahI jaante|| "upAdAna-upAdAna kaheM re nimitta, tU kahA kara gumaan| moko jAneM jIva ve jo haiM samyak vAna // 5 artha-upAdAna kahatA hai ki he nimitta / tU abhimAna kisaliye karatA hai / jo jIva samyaka jJAnI haiM ve mujhe jAnate haiN| nimitta-kahaiM jIva saba jagata ke, jo nimitta soI hoy| upAdAna kI bAta ko, pUche nAhIM koya // 6 artha-jagata ke saba jIva kahate hai ki jaisA nimitta hotA hai vaisA hI kArya hotA hai / upAdAna kI vAta ko to koI pUchatA hI nahI hai| upAdAna-upAdAna bina nimitta tU, kara na sake eka kAja / kahA bhayo jaga nA lakhai, jAnata hai jinarAja // 7 artha-upAdAna kahatA hai ki are nimitta eka bhI kArya binA upAdAna ke nahIM ho sakatA, ise jagata nahIM jAnatA to kyA huA ? jinarAja to use jAnate hai| 'nimitta-deva jinezvara guru yatI, aru nija Agama sAra / iha nimitta se jIva saba, pAvata haiM bhavapAra // artha-nimitta kahatA hai ki jinezvaradeva, nigraMthaguru aura vIta

Page #241
( 235 ) rAga kA Agama utkRSTa hai, ina nimito dvArA sabhI jIva bhava se pAra hote haiN| upAdAna--yaha nimitta iha jIva ke milyo anaMtIvAra / upAdAna palaTyo nahIM to bhaTakyo saMsAra // artha-upAdAna kahatA hai ki yaha nimitta isa jIva ko anatabAra mile, kintu upAdAna-jIva straya nahI badalA, isaliye vaha sasAra meM bhaTakatA rhaa| nimitta-ke kevali ke sAdhu ke, nikaTa bhavya jo hoya / sokSAyaka samyaka lahai, yaha nimitta bala joya // 10 artha-nimitta kahatA hai ki yadi kevalI bhagavAna athavA zrutakevalI muni ke pAsa bhavya jIva ho to kSAyika samyaktva pragaTa hotA hai-yaha nimitta kA bala dekho| upAdAna-kevali aru munirAja ke, pAsa rahe bahu loy| paMjAko sulaTiyo dhanI kSAyika tAko hoya // 11 artha-upAdAna kahatA hai ki kevalI aura zru nakavalI bhagavAna ke pAsa bahuta se loga rahate haiM, kintu jisakA dhanI [AtmA] anukUla hotA hai, usI ko kSAyika samyaktva hotA hai| nimitta-hiMsAdika pApana kiye, jIva naraka meM jAhi / jo nimittanahiM kAma ko to ima kAhe kahAhi // 12 / artha-nimitta kahatA hai ki yadi nimitta kAryakArI na ho, to phira yaha kyo kahA jAtA hai-hiMsAdika pApa karane se jIva naraka meM jAtA hai ? upAdAna-hiMsA meM upayoga jahAM, rahe brahma ke rAca / ____ teI naraka me jAta haiM, muni nahiM jAhiM kadAca // 13 __ artha-hiMsAdika me jisakA upayoga (caitanya pariNAma) ho aura jo AtmA usame racA-pacA rahe vahI naraka me jAtA hai| bhAvamuni kadApi naraka me nahI jaate|

Page #242
( 236 ) nimitta dayA dAna pUjA kiye, jIva sukhI jaga hoya / jo nimitta jhUThI kaho yaha kyo mAne loya // 14 arya-nimitta kahatA hai ki dayA-dAna-pUjA karane se jIva jagata me sukhI hotA hai| yadi Apake kathanAnusAra nimitta jhUThA ho, to loga use kyo maanege| upAdAna-dayA dAna pUjA bhalI, jagata mAhi sukhakAra / ___ jahaM anubhava ko AcaraNa, tahaM yaha baMdha vicAra // 15 artha-upAdAna kahatA hai-dayA-dAna-pUjA ityAdi bhale hI jagata me bAhya sahuliyata de, ki jahA~ anubhava ke AcaraNa para vicAra karate haiM, vahA~ yaha saba (zubha bhAva) vadha hai [dharma nahI] / nimitta-yaha to bAta prasiddha hai, soca dekha ura maahiN| nara dehi ke nimitta vina, jiya kyo mukti na jAhiM // 16 artha-nimitta kahatA hai ki yaha bAta to prasiddha hai ki nara deha ke nimitta vinA jIva mukti ko prApta nahIM hotA, isalie he upAdAna ! tU isa sambandha me apane antaraga me vicAra kara dekha / upAdAna-deha pIjarA jIva ko, roka zivapura jAta / upAdAna kI zakti so, mukti hota re bhrAta // 17 artha-upAdAna nimitta se kahatA hai ki bhAI / deharUpI piMjarA to jIva ko zivapura (mokSa) jAne se rokatA hai, kintu upAdAna kI zakti se mokSa hotA hai| noTa-(deharUpI piMjarA jIva ko mokSa jAne se rokatA hai yaha vyavahAra kathana hai / jIva zarIra para lakSya karake apanepana kI pakaDa se svaya vikAra me ruka jAtA hai, taba zarIra kA piMjarA jIva ko rokatA hai, yaha upacAra se kathana hai|) nimitta upAvAna saba jIva pe, rokana hAro kona / jAte kyoM nahiM mukti meM, bina nimitta ke hona // 18 artha-nimitta kahatA hai ki upAdAna to saba jIvo ke haiM taba unheM

Page #243
ho rahA haina kahatA hai siddha loka kA ( 237 ) rokane vAlA kona hai ? ve mokSa me kyo nahI cale jAte ? spaSTa hai ki nimitta ke na hone se aisA nahIM hotaa| upAdAna-upAdAna su anAdikA, ulaTa rahyo jaga maahi| sulaTata hI sUghe caleM siddha loka ko jAMhi // 16 artha-upAdAna kahatA hai ki jagata me anAdikAla se upAdAna ulTA ho rahA hai, usake sulTe hote saccA-jJAna aura saccA cAritra pragaTa hotA hai aura usase vaha siddha loka ko jAtA hai-mokSa pAtA hai| nimitta-kahuM anAdi bina nimittahI ulaTa rahyau upyog| _aisI bAta na saMbhavai upAdAna tuma joga / / 20 ____artha-nimitta kahatA hai ki kyA anAdi se vinA nimitta ke hI upayoga (jJAna kA vyApAra) ulTA ho rahA hai / he upAdAna / tumhAre lie aisI bAta to sabhava nahI hai| upAdAna-upAdAna kahe re nimitta hama pe kahIM na jAya / aise hI jina kevalo, dekhe tribhuvana rAya // 21 artha-upAdAna kahatA hai ki he nimitta / mujha se nahIM kahA jA sakatA / jinendra kevalIbhagavAna tribhuvana rAya ne aisA hI dekhA hai| noTa-(yahAM kahA hai ki upAdAna me kArya hotA hai taba nimitta svaya upasthita hone para bhI upAdAna ko vaha kucha kara sakatA nahI-aisA ananta jJAniyo ne apane jJAna me dekhA hai) 'nimitta~jo dekhyo bhagavAna ne so hI sA~co aahi| hama tuma saMgha anAdi ke valI kahoge kAhi // 22 artha-nimitta kahatA hai bhagavAna ne jo dekhA hai vahI saca hai| merA aura terA anAdikAlIna sambandha hai| isalie do me se balavAna kise kahA jAya ? arthAt kama-se-kama yaha to kaho, hama dono samAna haiN| samakakSa haiN| upAdAna-upAdAna kahe vaha valI, jAko nAza na hoya / jo upajata vinazata rahe, balI kahA te soya // 23

Page #244
( 238 ) __ artha-upAdAna kahatA hai-jisakA nAma nahI hotA vaha valavAna hai / jo utpanna hotA hai aura jisakA vinAza hotA hai vaha valavAna kaise ho sakatA hai ? noTa-(upAdAna trikAlI akhaDa ekarUpa vastu svaya hai isalie usakA nAza nhiiN| nimitta to sayogarUpa hai--AtA aura jAtA hai isalie nAzarUpa hai / ata upAdAna hI valavAna hai)| nimitta-upAdAna tuma jora ho to kyo leta ahaar| __ para nimitta ke yoga so jIvata saba saMsAra // 24 artha-nimitta kahatA hai ki he upAdAna | yadi terA vala ho to tU AhAra kyo letA hai / sasAra ke sabhI jIva para nimitta ke yoga se jIte hai| upAdAna-jo ahAra ke joga so, jIvita hai jgmaahi| to vAsI sasAra ke, marate koU nAMhi // 25 artha-upAdAna kahatA hai ki yadi AhAra ke yoga se jagata ke jIva jIte ho, to sasAravAsI koI bhI jIva nahI mrtaa| nimitta-sUra soma maNi agni ke, nimitta lakheM ye naina / andhakAra me kita gayo, upAdAna dUga daina // 26 artha-nimitta kahatA hai--sUrya, candramA, maNi athavA agni kA nimitta ho to A~kha dekha sakatI haiN| yadi upAdAna dekhane kA kAma kara sakatA ho to adhakAra meM usakI dekhane kI zakti kahA~ calI jAtI hai (andhakAra me A~kha se kyo nahI dikhAI detaa)| upAdAna-sUra, soma, maNi, agni jo kare aneka prakAza / nana zakti bina nA lakhe, andhakAra sama bhAsa // 27 artha-upAdAna kahatA hai ki sUrya, candramA, maNi aura dIpaka aneka' prakAra kA prakAza karate haiN| tathApi dekhane kI zakti ke binA kucha bhI nahI dikhAI detA, saba andhakAra sA bhAsita hotA hai /

Page #245
( 239 ) nimitta-kahai nimitta ve jIva ko mo vina jaga ke mAMhi / sabai hamAre vaza pare, hama bina mukti na jAhiM // 28 artha-nimitta kahatA hai ki mere vinA jagata me mAtra jIva kyA kara sakatA hai ? sabhI mere vaza me hai, mere vinA jIva mokSa bhI nahI jA sktaa| upAdAna-upAdAna kahai re nimitta! aise bola na bol| toko taja nija bhajata haiM, te hI kareM kilola // 26 artha-upAdAna kahatA hai ki he nimitta / aisI bAta mata kara terI Upara kI dRSTi ko choDakara jo jIva apanA bhajana karatA hai vahI Ananda karatA hai| nimitta-kaha nimitta hamako taja, kaise ziva jAta / paMcamahAvata pragaTa haiM aura hu kriyA vikhyAta // 30 artha-nimitta kahatA hai ki mujhe choDakara koI mokSa kaise jA sakatA hai ? paca mahAvrata to pragaTa haiM hI aura dUsarI kriyAye bhI prasiddha hai| jinhe loga mokSa kA kAraNa mAnate hai| upAdAna-paMca mahAvata joga traya aura sakala vyvhaar| para ko nimitta khapAya ke taba pahuMce bhavapAra // 31 arya-upAdAna kahatA hai paca mahAvrata, tIna yoga kI ora kA lakSya aura samasta vyavahAra tathA nimitta kA lakSya dUra karake hI jIva bhava se pAra hotA hai| nimitta-kaha nimitta jaga maiM baDyo, mote bar3o na koya / tIna loka ke nAtha saba, mo prasAda teM hoya // 32 ___ artha-nimitta kahatA hai ki jagata me maiM baDA hU~, mujhase vaDA koI nahI hai, tIna loka kA nAtha bhI merI kRpA se hotA hai| ___ noTa-(samyagdarzana kI bhUmikA me jJAnI jIva ke zubha vikalpa karane para tIrthakara nAma karma kA vandha hotA hai, isa dRSTAnta ko upasthita karake nimitta apanI balavattA ko pragaTa karanA cAhatA hai|)

Page #246
( 240 ) upAdAna-upAdAna kahaiM tU baDA, cahu~ gati meM le jaay| to prasAda te jIva saba duHkhI ho hi re bhAya // 33 artha-upAdAna kahatA hai are nimitta / tU kauna ? tU to jIva ko 'cAro gatiyo me le jAtA hai| bhAI, terI kRpA se sabhI jIva duHkhI hI hote haiN| noTa-(nimittAdhIna dRSTi kA phala cAro gati sasAra hai, nimitta ke kAraNa jIva cAra gati me jAtA hai-aisA nahI hai|) 'nimitta, kaha~ nimitta jo duHkha sahai, so tuma hamahi lgaay| sukhI kauna teM hota hai, tAko dehu batAya // 34 artha-nimitta kahatA hai-jIva to dukha sahana karatA hai usakA doSa tU hamAre Upara lagAtA hai, kintu yaha bhI batAo ki jIva sukho kisase hotA hai ? upAdAna-jo sukha ko tUM sukha kahai so sukha to sukha naahiN| ye sukha dukha ke mUla haiM, sukha avinAzi mAhi // 35 artha-upAdAna kahatA hai ki tU jisa sukha ko sukha kahatA hai vaha sukha hI nahIM hai, vaha sukha to dukha kA mUla hai| AtmA ke antaraga me avinAzI sukha hai| nimitta-avinAzI ghaTa ghaTa base, sukha kyoM vilasata naahiN| zubha nimitta ke yoga bina pare pare bila lAhi // 36 artha-nimitta kahatA hai ki avinAzI sukha to ghaTa-ghaTa me pratyeka jIva me vidyamAna hai| taba phira jIvo ke sukha kA vilAsa-sukha kA bhoga kyo nahI hotaa| zubha nimitta ke yoga ke vinA jIva kSaNa-kSaNa me dukhI ho rahA hai| upAdAna-zubha nimitta iha jIva ko milyo kaI bhvsaar| paiika samyaka darza bina, bhaTakata phiryogvaar||37 artha-upAdAna kahatA hai-~-zubha nimitta isa jIva ko kaI bhavo me

Page #247
( 241 ) mile, parantu eka samyagdarzana ke binA yaha mUrkha jIva (ajJAna bhAva se) bhaTaka rahA hai| nimitta-samyakadarza bhaye kahA tvarita mukti meM jaahiN| Age dhyAna nimitta hai te ziva ko pahacAhiM // 38 artha-samyagdarzana hone se kyA jIva tatkAla mokSa me calA jAtA hai ? nhii| Age bhI dhyAna nimitta hai| jo mokSa me pahucatA hai| yaha nimitta kA tarka hai| upAdAna-chora dhyAna kI dhAraNA mora yoga kI rIta / tori karma ke jAla ko jori laI ziva prIta // 36 artha-upAdAna kahatA hai ki dhyAna kI dhAraNA ko choDakara, yoga kI rIti ko sameTa kara, karma jAla ko toDakara jIva apane puruSArtha ke dvArA zivAnanda kI prApti karate haiN| nimitta taba nimitta hAryo tahAM aba nahiM jori basAya / upAdAna ziva loka meM pahacyo karma khapAya // 40 artha-taba nimitta hAra gyaa| aba kucha jora nahIM karatA aura upAdAna karma kA kSaya karake ziva loka me pahuca gyaa| upAdAna-upAdAna jItyo tahA~, nija balakara parakAza / sukha ananta dhruva bhogave aMta na varanyo tAsa // 41 artha-isa prakAra nija bala kA prakAza kara upAdAna jItA (vaha upAdAna aba) usa ananta dhra va sukha ko bhogatA hai jisakA anta nahI hai| tatva svarUpa-upAdAna aru nimitta ye, saba jIvana paM viir| jo nija zakti saMbhAla ho so pahu~ce bhavatIra // 42 artha-upAdAna aura nimitta sabhI jovo ke hai kintu jo vIra apanI upAdAna zakti kI sambhAla karate hai ve bhava ke pAra ko prApta hote haiN|

Page #248
( 242 ) AtmA ko mahimA bhaiyA mahimA brahma kI, kaise varanI jAya / vacana agocara vastu hai kahivo vacana batAya // 43 artha-bhagavatIdAsa jI Atma svabhAva kI mahimA kA varNana karate hue kahate haiM ki bhAI / brahma kI (Atma-svabhAva kI mahimA kA varNana kaise kiyA jA sakatA hai| vaha vastu vacana agocara hai use kina vacanoM ke dvArA batAyA jA sakatA hai| sarasa saMvAda upAdAna aru nimitta ko, sarasa banyo saMvAda / samadRSTi ko sarala hai, mUrakha ko bakavAda // 44 artha-upAdAna aura nimitta kA yaha sundara samvAda vanA hai yaha samyagdRSTi ke lie sarala hai aura mithyAdRSTi ke lie vakavAda mAlUma hogii| jo AtmA ke guNo ko pahicAnatA hai vaha isa svarUpa ko jANe jo jAne guNa brahma ke, so jAne yaha bheda / sAkha jinAgama so mile, to mata kIjyo kheda // 45 artha-AtmA ke guNo ko jo jAnatA hai, vaha isakA marma jAnatA hai| isa svarUpa kI sAkSI jinAgama se milatI hai isalie isame zakA nahI karanA caahie| AgarA meM saMvAda banAyA nagara AgarA ana hai, jainI jana ko vAsa / tihathAnaka racanA karo, 'bhaiyA' svamati prakAza // 46 artha-AgarA me jainiyo kA vAsa jyAdA hai| vahA~ para bhaIyA bhagavatI dAsa ne apane jJAna ke anusAra yaha racanA kI hai athavA apane jJAna ke prakAza ke lie yaha racanA kI hai| racanA kAla-saMvat vikrama bhUpa ko sattaraha se pacAsa / phAlguna pahale pakSa meM dazo vizA parakAza // 47

Page #249
( 243 ) artha-vikrama savat 1750 ke phAlguna mAsa ke prathama pakSa me isa savAda kI racanA kI gaI hai| jaya mahAvIra-jaya mahAvIra maukhika praznAvalI prazna 1-kevalajJAna meM lokAloka ke saba padArtha jAnane meM Ate haiN| isame nimitta-namittika kyA hai ? prazna 2-kevalajJAna ko naimittika kahe, to nimitta kauna hai ? prazna 3-lokAloka ko naimittika kahe, to nimitta kauna hai ? prazna 4-kevalajJAna ko nimitta kI apekSA kyA kahate haiM ? prazna 5-kevalajJAna kA trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa kyA hai ? prazna 6-'upAdeya' zabda kitane arthoM meM prayukta hotA hai ? prazna 7-kevalajJAna ko upAdeya kyo kahA hai ? prazna 8-kArya ko nimitta kI apekSA kyA kahate haiM ? prazna :-kArya ko upAdAna kI apekSA kyA kahate haiM ? prazna 10--maiM jora-zora se bolatA hU~ isameM 100vIM gAthA ke cAra bola lagAmo? prazna 11-kyA nimitta-naimittika eka dravya me hotA hai ? prazna 12-kyA upAdAna-upAdeya do dravyo ke hotA hai ? prazna 13-cAI upAdAna kAraNa aura roTI upaadey| kyA upApAna-upAdeya kA jJAna ThIka hai ?

Page #250
( 244 ) - prazna 14-koI catura vAI ko upAdAna kAraNa aura roTI ko upAdeya / aisA hI mAne to kyA doSa AtA hai ? prazna 15-nimitta kAraNo se ho kArya kI utpatti mAne use jinavANI me phina-kina nAmo se sambodhana kiyA hai ? prazna 16-ATA trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa aura roTI upaadey| aisA mAnane se kyA lAbha huA? prazna 17-koI catura prazna karatA hai ki tavA, cakalA, belana, bAI Adi nimitta kAraNa ho to roTI bane Apa kahate ho nimittakAraNo se kArya kA sambandha nahIM hai| to ATA upAdAnakAraNa aura roTI upAdeya / yaha ApakI bAta jhUThI sAbita hotI hai ? ' prazna 18-ATe bhI roTI kA saccA kAraNa nahIM hai to roTI kA saccA upAdAna kAraNa kauna hai ? prazna 16-ATA me anAdi kAla se paryAyo kA pravAha kyo calA A rahA hai ? prazna 20-anantara pUrva kSaNavartI paryAya loI kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura roTI upAdeya / isako mAnane se kyA lAbha huA ? prazna 21-koI catura phira prazna karatA hai ki abhAva me se bhAva kI utpatti nahIM hotI haiM aura paryAya meM se paryAya nahIM AtI hai / aisA jinavANI meM batAyA hai| to phira yaha mAnanA anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya loI kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura roTI upAdeya / yaha ApakI bAta jhUThI sAbita hotI hai ? prazna 22-anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya loI roTI kA saccA kAraNa nahIM hai| to kaisA kAraNa hai aura kaisA kAraNa nahIM hai ? prazna 23-anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya loI bhI roTo kA saccA kAraNa nahIM hai| to vAstava meM roTI kA saccA kAraNa kauna hai ? prazna 24-vAstava meM usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA roTI kSaNika

Page #251
( 245 ) upAdAna kAraNa hI roTI kA saccA kAraNa hai| isako jAnane se kyA lAbha hamA? prazna 25-(1) ATA trikAlI upAdAna kAraNa aura roTI upaadey| (2) anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya loI kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura roTI upAdeya (3) usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA roTI kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa aura roTI upAdeya / aisA zAstro meM btaayaa| parantu itanA lambA-lambA jhagar3A karane se kyA lAbha thaa| kaha dete ki kArya usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA se hI hotA hai ? prazna 26-roTI usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se banI hai| isako jAnane se kyA lAbha huA? prazna 27-kevalI ke samAna saccA jJAna hone se kyA-kyA apUrva kArya dekhane meM AtA hai ? prazna 28-vizva meM pratyeka kArya usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA se hotA hai| tava kauna-kauna sI cAra bAteM eka sAtha eka hI samaya meM niyama se hotI haiM ? prazna 26-kArya usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa se hI hotA hai, kyA yaha nirapekSa hai ? prazna 30-bAI ne roTI banAI-isa para kitane prazna uThate haiM ? prazna 31-bAI ne roTI banAI-isa para chaha kAraka lagAkara batAo? prazna 32-nimitta ko jAnane kA kyA lAbha hai ? prazna 33-trikAlI kartA ko jAnane kA kyA lAbha hai ? prazna 34-trikAlI kartA ATe para chaha kAraka lagAkara batAo? prazna 35-anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya loI ko jAnane kA kyA lAbha hai ? prazna 36-anantarapUrva kSaNavartI paryAya loI kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa para chaha kAraka lagAkara batAo?

Page #252
( 246 ) prazna 37-kyA abhAva meM se bhAva kI utpatti nahIM hotI hai ? prazna 35-kyA usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa hI kArya kA saccA kAraNa hai ? prazna 36-usa samaya paryAya kI yogyatA roTI kSaNika upAdAna kAraNa para chaha kAraka lagAkara batAo? prazna 40-yogyatA se kyA siddha hotA hai ? prazna 41-cAI ne roTI banAI-isa vAkya para nimitta kI paribhASA lagAkara batAo? prazna 42-bAI ne roTI banAI-isa para nimitta-naimittika sambandha lagAkara samajhAo? prazna 43-vAI ne roTI banAI-isa para vyApya-vyApaka kisa prakAra hai ? prazna 44-bAI ne roTI banAI-isa para sauvIM gAthA ke cAra bola lagAkara batAo? prazna 45-cAro gattiyo kA abhAva vAlA maMtra kyA hai? prazna 46-saupI gAthA meM yoga kise kahA hai aura upayoga kise kahA hai ? prazna 47-sauvIM gAthA ke cAra bolo ke nAma batAo? prazna 48vyApya-vyApaka kise kahate haiM ? prazna 46-nimitta-naimittika sambandha kI paribhASA kyA hai ? prazna 50-nimitta kAraNo ke kitane bheva haiM ? prazna 51--prApya-vikArya-nirvayaM kA artha samajhAo? prazna 52-samyagdarzana para tInoM upAdAna-upAdeya smjhaao| prazna 53-'upAdeya' zabda kahAM-kahAM para prayoga hotA hai ? prazna 54-rAga ko kisa-kisa apekSA kyA-kyA kahate haiM aura kyoM kahate haiM ?

Page #253
( 247 ) prazna 55-pharma kI dazA kitane prakAra kI hotI haiM ? prazna 56-mohanIya karma meM kitanI dazAyeM hotI haiM ? prazna 57-kAraka kise kahate haiM ? prazna 58-nimitta-upAdAna kA bar3A bhArI jhagaDA lagatA hai ? uttara-nimitta upAdAna kA saccA jJAna ho to jhagaDe ko samApta kara detA hai parantu eka ko dUsare kA kartA mAnanA yaha jhagaDA hai| prazna 56-nimitta-upAdAna kA jhagar3A kyoM nahIM miTatA hai ? uttara-upAdAna-nimitta kA saccA jJAna nA hone se apane kAryoM kA kartA nimitta para lagAkara svaya nirdoSa banA rahanA cAhatA hai isalie 'nimitta-upAdAna kA jhagaDA nahI miTatA hai| prazna 60-aba kyA kareM to nimitta-upAdAna kA jhagaDA samApta ho jAve ? uttara-jaisA nimitta-upAdAna kA svarUpa isa zAstra me samajhAyA hai usI prakAra samajhakara apanI ora dRSTi kare to nimitta-upAdAna kA jhagaDA samApta hokara dharma kI prApti kara krama se mokSa rUpI lakSmI kA nAtha bana jaave| // dvitIya bhAga sampUrNa // jaya mahAvIra-jaya mahAvIra