Swami Dayanand aur Jain Dharm

Author(s): Hansraj Shastri
Publisher: Hansraj Shastri
Catalog link: https://jainqq.org/explore/010550/1

Page #1
THE FREE INDOLOGICAL COLLECTION WWW.SANSKRITDOCUMENTS.ORG/TFIC FAIR USE DECLARATION This book is sourced from another online repository and provided to you at this site under the TFIC collection. It is provided under commonly held Fair Use guidelines for individual educational or research use. We believe that the book is in the public domain and public dissemination was the intent of the original repository. We applaud and support their work wholeheartedly and only provide this version of this book at this site to make it available to even more readers. We believe that cataloging plays a big part in finding valuable books and try to facilitate that, through our TFIC group efforts. In some cases, the original sources are no longer online or are very hard to access, or marked up in or provided in Indian languages, rather than the more widely used English language. TFIC tries to address these needs too. Our intent is to aid all these repositories and digitization projects and is in no way to undercut them. For more information about our mission and our fair use guidelines, please visit our website. Note that we provide this book and others because, to the best of our knowledge, they are in the public domain, in our jurisdiction. However, before downloading and using it, you must verify that it is legal for you, in your jurisdiction, to access and use this copy of the book. Please do not download this book in error. We may not be held responsible for any copyright or other legal violations. Placing this notice in the front of every book, serves to both alert you, and to relieve us of any responsibility. If you are the intellectual property owner of this or any other book in our collection, please email us, if you have any objections to how we present or provide this book here, or to our providing this book at all. We shall work with you immediately. -The TFIC Team.

Page #2

Page #3
madhyasthavAda-granthamAlAyAH prathamaM puSpamUha nyAyataMtrazatapatrabhAnave lokalocanasudhAjanatviSe // pApazailazatakoTimUrtaye sajjAnAya satataM namonamaH // svAmI dayAnanda the aura ay= jaindhrm| SKRISESSEYe. .. racayitApaNDita-haMsarAja zAstrI-paJcanadIyaH 10 vikrama saMvata 1972 I. san 1915 ra 00 mUlya ATha AnA.

Page #4
Obfer Printed by Matoobhai Bhaidas at K. A's. the Surat "Jain Printing Press" Khapatia Chakla, Surat. Published by 'andit Hunsraj ( son of Pandit Prabhudayal ) Shastri of Jamadar Bazar Amritsar (Punjab.) from Gopipura Surat. :

Page #5
66. 'Amukham ->>(r)(c)(c)& AgrahI bata ninISati yukti tatra yatra matirasyaM niviSTA // (pakSapAtarahitasya tu yuktiryatra tatra matireti nivezam // 35 sArameM jitane mata yA sampradAya dekhane meM Ate haiM unameM kitanIka bAteM to aisI haiM, jinakA sabase avirodha hai aura kitaneka niyama aise bhI haiM, jo ki eka dUsarese viruddha haiM / evaM kitaneka siddhAntoM ko sarvasammata honepara bhI unakI mAnyatA pratyeka matameM bhinna bhinna prakArakI dekhI jAtI hai / vicArapUrvaka parAmarza karanese yaha niyama kucha svAbhAvika aura Avazyaka bhI pratIta hotA hai, koI mahAna puruSa jisa vakta kisI mata yA sampradAya kI sthApanA karatA hai usa vaktavaha usake lie kitaneka asAdhAraNa niyama bhI avazya banAtA 'hai, jisase anyamatoM kI apekSA usameM bhinnatA pratIta ho / svIkRta. niyamoM kI rakSA tathA unakA gaurava bar3hAneke lie anyamatoMke katipaya siddhAntoM (jo ki usake niyamoMse pratikUla mAlUma N hote hoM ) kA vaha prativAda bhI karatA hai / kisI dRSTise yaha ' bAta usake lie ucita bhI hai, anyathA usakA saMsAra para kucha prabhAva bhI nahIM par3atA; paraMtu usakI bhI koI maryAdA honI cAhie / maryAdAkA ullaMghana karake jo prativAda kiyA jAtA hai vaha nissandeha sabhyatAse girA huA aura lAbhakebadale pratyuta hAnikAraka ho jAtA hai / vRSTi sasyavRddhi meM jitanI, upayogI hai, usase adhika hAni ativRSTise hotI hai / * "

Page #6
* vizvabhara meM jitane bhI mata matAntara hai unameM satya kauna hai aura mithyA kauna hai isakA nirNaya karanA koI gur3iyoM kA khela nahIM hai| isake lie jitane vizAla pAMDitya aura parAmarzakI AvazyakatA hai usase adhika asaMkIrNa vizada aura niSpakSa vicArapriya hRdayakI jarUrata hai. isa lie kisI bhI dharma yA sampradAyakI AlocanA karanemeM pravRta honevAle manuSyako apane cAroM tarpha nirIkSaNa avazya kara lenA caahie| paraMtu vartamAna samayakA pravAha isase kucha viparIta hI dRSTigocara ho rahA hai / Aja eka sAdhAraNase sAdhAraNa buddhi rakhanevAlA manuSya bhI bar3e bar3e vidvAnoM, maharSiyoM tathA AcAyoMke vicAroM ko bhadde aura mUrkhatA bhare kahane ke lie sAhasa karane laga jAtA hai ! mAmUlI bhASA mI cAhe likhanekA zahara na ho parantu darzanoM ke mImAMsaka to avazya bana jAya~ge ! saca pUcho to aise hI manuSya saMsAra meM dveSAmike mUla utpAdaka haiM / aura aise hI puruSoMke kAraNa bhagavatI bhArata vasuMdharA aneka yAtanAoM ko sahana karatI hai / yadyapi paraspara eka dUsare ke khaMDana maMDanakI zailI arvAcIna nahIM kintu darzanoM ke prAdurbhAva se bhI prathamakI hai darzanoM ke samaya meM to vaha adhika unnatiko prApta huI para usake rUpameM vikRti nahIM huI / sabhyatA ke siMhAsana parase use nahIM girAyA gayA / usa samayakI tIvra se tIvra AlocanAmeM bhI gauravazUnya zabdoM kA vinyAsa nahIM pAyA jAtA / satya kahA jAya to vartamAna samaya meM bhAratIya pUrva maharSiyoMkI AlocanA zailIkA jIvita udAharaNa adhikAMza pAzcAtya vidvAnoM ke hI lekha haiM / Ajakala ke mithyA dharmAbhimAnI paMDitaMmanyoM ko una se bahuta kucha zikSA grahaNa karanI cAhie.

Page #7
. sajjano ! hama Upara likha cuke haiM ki khaMDana maMDanakI paddhati kuMcha navIna nahIM kintu prAcIna hai svAmI zaMkarAcAryajI tathA anya kitaneka vidvAnoM ke samaya taka vaha adhikAMza prazasta hI rahIM magara vartamAna samayameM use no adhika bhayAnaka rUpa prApta huA hai isakA kAraNa hamAre vartamAna samayake maharSi svAmI dayAnanda sarasvatIjI haiM ! yaha bAta prastuta puSpake par3hanese sphuTa ho jAyagI ! svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatIjIne anya matoMke khaMDanameM bahuta asaMkIrNatAse kAma kiyA hai, usapara bhI jainadharmake viSaya mato usakI mAtrA aura bhI adhika bar3ha gaI hai| svAmIjIke ukta vicAra kahAMtaka satya aura AdaraNIya haiM isI vicArako prastuta "madhyastha bAda graMthamAlA" ke "svAmI dayAnanda aura nainadharma" nAmake isa prathama puppameM darzAyA gayA hai| svAmIjIke saMbaMghameM jainadharmake siddhAntAnusAra hamane jina bAtoMkA ullekha kiyA hai unake ucitAnucitapanekI mImAMsA karanI pAThakoMkA kAma hai. hame isameM hastakSepa karanekA adhikAra nahIM / hamane to * bhapane vicAroMko sabhya saMsArake samakSa upasthita karadiyA hai| isake sivA ukta granthamAlAke aura bhI kitaneka puSpa likhane kA hamArA vicAra hai / unameM adhikAMza dArzanika viSayake hI lekha raheMge isa lie prastuta puSpa meM hamane jahAM kahIM " isa viSaya para hama kahIM anyatra vicAra kareMge, isakA vistAra pUrvaka sapramANa varNana kahIM anyatra kiyA jAyagA" aisA likhA huA ho usase pAThaka yahI samajheM ki usakA ullekha ukta graMthamAlAke kisI anya puppameM kiyA nAyagA. pAThakoM ko itanA avazya smaraNa rahe ki anya puSpomeM bhI jo dArzanika viSayoM kA ullekha kiyA jAyagAvaha haThavAdako sarvathA alaga rakhakara hI kiyA jaaygaa|

Page #8
'sajjano prastuta puSpameM jo kucha likhA gayA hai vaha kisI 'para AkSepa karane yA kisIkA dila dukhAne ke uddezyase nahI likhA gayA aura nAhIM hamArA yaha sarvathA vicAra hai / isapara ' bhI yadi kisI ke hRdayako duHkha pahuMce to hama vivaza hai vaha -kRpayA hame kSamA pradAna kareM / : aba hama isa lekhako yahAMpara hI samApta karate hue apane cirasmaraNIya pitRkalpa zrIyuta paMDita hIrAlAlajI zarmA aura 'paramamitra zrIyuta lAlA cUnI lAlajIko sahasrazaH dhanyavAda / dete haiM ki jinakI kRpAse hameM isa prakAra ke graMthoM ke likhanekA - saubhAgya tathA sAhasa prApta huA hai / aMtameM vidvAnoMse hamArI namra prArthanA hai ki prastuta 'puSpameM yadi koI mUla yA truTI raha gaI ho to usake lie ve kRpayA hameM sUcanA deM tAki AgAmI saMskaraNameM vaha dUra kI jAya / vijayadazamI - vikrama 1971 vimala sahacara "haMsa" bambaI. 1 " 1915

Page #9
'nmH|| ||AUMshriivii // madhyasthavAdagraMthamAlAyAH prathamaM puSpam // svAmIdayAnanda aura jainadharma" - satyaM jJAnamanantaM ya-nimaye'gAyata thutI / AtmAnandaM gatahandaM, vizrutaM taM zrayAmahe / / 1 / / manarasAdhu vAtsAdhu, taryasya mahAtmanaH zAntaye sarvabhUtAnAM,taM priyaM bhaktito numaH // 2 // -- - taimAna AryasamAjake netA " svAmI dayAnanda sarasvatIjI " bar3e nAmAMkita purupa ho gaye haiM! MAKA inakA jIvana vaidika dharmakI unnatimeM hI samApta huA hai ! saMsArage aise manuSya bahuta thor3e nikaleMge, jinhoMne svAmIjI kI taraha vaidika dharma meM asIma prema batalAyA ho : vaidika dharma para Ate hue AkSepoM ke nirAkaraNa meM svAmIjIne apanI zakti se bhI adhika parizrama kara dikhalAyA hai ! yaha bAta unake race hue pustakoM se vidita hotI hai ! svAmIjI jaise sAhasI puruSa saMsAra, bahuta kama haiM ! isIliye vartamAna janasamAjameM unheM kucha saphalatA bhI prApta huI ! ___ svAmIjIke satyArthaprakAza Adi graMtho ke dekhanekA hame bahuta zauka thA, aura aba bhI hai ! inapara vicAra karane ke liye pathAzakti parizrama bhI kiyA. hai ! svAmIjI ke anya graMthoM kI 'apekSA satyArthaprakAza kucha adhika prasiddha hai ! yaha graMtha caturdaza (14) samullAsoMmeM vibhakta hai, jisameM se isasamaya, vAraveM mullAsake saMbaMdha hame kucha kahanA hai.hamArA Azaya svAmIjI / 1

Page #10
ke graMthoMkA khaMDana, yA unakI bhUle nikAlanekA nahIM hai 1 kiMtu hamArA abhiprAya svAmI " dayAnanda " aura " jainadharma" ke saMbaMdhameM apane niSpakSa vicAroM ko madhyastha janasamAjake samakSa prakaTa karanekA hai, isaliye hama apane pAThakoMse savinaye nivedana karate haiM ki, ve hamAre madhyastha vicAroM ko madhyastha dRSTise hI avalokana kareM. sajjano ! svAmI " dayAnanda sarasvatIjI " bar3e satyavaktA aura nirbhaya puruSathe ! vaidika dharmameM inakI asIma zraddhA abhItaka logoMko mugdha kara rahI hai ! Aja bhArata varSake kone konemeM vaidika dharmakA nAda sunAI denA svAmIjI ke hI udyoga kA phala hai ! svAmIjIkA jIvana nissaMdeha satyatA aura paropakAratAke saMcemeM DhalA huA thA ! vartamAna AryajanatAmeM inake adhika sanmAna kA yaha bhI eka mukhya kAraNa hai | svAmIjI hamArI zraddhAke mukhya bhAjana haiM ! hamase jitanI inakI prazaMsA ho sake thor3A hai ! paraMtu vicAra zUnya atyaMta zraddhAlupanA bhI guNake badale doSa rUpa ho jAtA hai ! dRSTirAgako chor3akara guNAnurAga hI unnati kA majabUta pAyA hai ! ataH "zatrorapi guNA vAcyA dopA vAcyA gurorapi" isa nyAya ke anusAra niSpakSabhAvase apane vicAroMko janasamAjameM prakAzita karanA manuSyakA prathama kartavya hai, isaliye svAmIjI jaise pavitrAmA prazasta lekhoMkI mImAMsAke liye kartavya parAyaNa apanI lekhinIko zrama denA aho bhAgya samajhate hue hama prastuta viSayapara vicAra karate haiM. hama likha cuke haiM ki, svAmI " dayAnanda " sarasvatIjIkI vaidika dharma priyatA, satya parAyaNatA, aura niSpakSatAkA nAda bhArata varSake atirikta anya dezoMmeM bhI khUba banA aura baI rahA hai| vAstavikameM aise mahAtmAke jIvanameM isa bAtaya /

Page #11
3 honA Avazyaka hI hai / kyoM ki niSpakSatA aura satya parAya - NatA mahAtmA ke jIvanakA eka anUThA bhUSaNa hai ! paraMtu svAmIjI mahArAjake graMthoMkA jaba hama anveSaNa karate haiM taba hamArI yaha AzA nirAzA ke rUpameM pariNata ho jAtI hai ! svAmIjI ke graMthoM meM bahutasI bAteM aisI bhI dRSTigocara hotI haiM, jo inake prazasta jIvanako dhabbA lagA rahI haiM ! inake niSpakSa aura satyamaya zubhra jIvanameM kAlimA rUpa ho rahI haiM ! inake svarNamaya jIvanako sIsekI taraha kalaMkita kara rahI haiM ! udAharaNArtha thoDese vacana nIce likhate haiM. "svAmIjIkI madhura bhASAkA namUnAM" (1) " jo jIva brahmakI ekatA jagat mithyA zaMkarAcAryakA nija mata thA to vaha acchA mata nahIM aura z2o jainiyoMke khaMDana ke liye usa matakA svIkAra kiyA ho to kucha acchA hai " [pRSTha 287] (2) " AMkhake aMdhe gAMThake pUre una durbuddhi pApI svAthIM " [ pRSTha 31 ] (3) " kyoM bhUsatA hai " [ pRSTha 121 ] (4) " vAhare jhUThe vedAMtiyo " [ pRSTha 235 ] ( 5 ) " gaDariye ke samAna jhUThe guru " [ pRSTha 280] (6) " jisake hRdaya kI AMkhe phuTa gaI hoM [pRSTha 292] (7) "una nirlajjoMko tanika bhI lajjA nahIM AI " [ pRSTha 298 ] (8) " munivAhana bhaMgI kulotpanna yAvanAcArya yavanaM kulotpanna zaThakopanAmaka kaMjara " [ pRSTha 299 ] (9) " aMdhe dhUrtta " [ pRSTha 305 ]

Page #12
(10) "bhaThiyAreke TaTTa kuMbhArake gadhe" (pRSTha 312) (11) " aise guru aura celoMke mukhapara dhUla aura rAkha paDe " (pR. 326) (12) " bhAgavatake banAnevAle lAla bujakaha kyA kahanA hai tujhako aisI aisI mithyA bAteM likhane meM tanika bhI lajjA aura zarama na AI nipaTa aMdhA hI vana gayA ! bhalA ina jhUTha bAtoMko ve aMdhe popa aura bAhira bhItarakI phUTI AkhoMvAle unake cale bhI sunate aura mAnate haiM! ina bhAgavatAdike vanAne hAre janmate hI kyoM nahIM garbha hI meM naSTa ho gaye vA janmate samaya mara kyoM na gaye.?" [pRSTa 330] (13) " tuma bhATa aura khuzAmaMdI cAraNoMse bhI baDhakara gappI ho" [pR. 331] (14)." bhauDa dhUrta nizAcara vat mahIdharAdi TIkA kAra hue haiM " (pRSTha 402) (15) " sabase vaira virodha niMdA IrpA Adi duSTa karma rUpa sAgarameM DuvAnavAlA jaina mArga hai jaise jainI loga sabake niMdaka haiM vaisA koI bhI dUsare matavAlA mahAniMdaka aura adharmI na hogA!" [ pRSTha 431] (16) " pAkhaMDoMkA mUla hI jaina mata hai " [pRSTha 440 ] ityAdi-( satyArtha prakAza san 1884) __pyAre pAThako ! svAmIjI mahArAjakI isa manohara vAkya racanAke viSayameM yadi hama kaheM to kyA kaheM : "vidyA hi vinayAvAsyai, sA cedavinayA vahA! kiM kurmaH? kutra vA yAmaH?, salilAdagnirutthitaH // 1 // "

Page #13
bhavatI huI agni ko zAMta karaneke liye jalakA upayoga kiyA jAtA hai, yadi jalase hI agni nikalane lage to phira upAyAMtara kyA ? duHkha kevala itanI bAtakA hai ki yaha lalita lekhamAlA una mahAtmAkI hai jinakA prazasta jIvana unnati ke abhilASiyoM ko anukaraNIya samajhA jAtA hai ! astu! aba hama pAThakoM kA svAmIjI mahArAjakI lekhamAlAse uddhRta kiye hue vAkyoM meM se sabase prathama vAkyapara thor3AsA dhyAna khacate hue apane prastuta viSayakA prAraMbha karate haiM / sajjanI ! satya eka aisI vastu hai ki, jisakA sAdRzya saMsArabharake kisI padArtha meM bhI nahIM hai ! satyakI manuSya ke liye itanI AvazyakatA hai jitanI ki prakAzaka liye sUryakI ! isI liye hamAre zraddheya svAmIjI mahArAjane " satya ke grahaNa aura asatyake tyAgameM sadaiva udyata rahanA cAhiye " isa dvitIya niyama rUpa sadupadeza se manuSya samudAyako bahuta hI anugRhIta kiyA hai ! aise sadupadeSTA mahAtmAkA hama jitanA AbhAra mAne utanA thor3A hai ! paraMtu jaba hama svAmIjIke "jo jIva brahmakI ekatA jagat mithyA zaMkarAcAryakA nijamata thA to vaha acchA mata nahIM aura jo jainiyoMke khaMDana ke liye usa matakA svIkAra kiyA ho to kucha acchA hai" isa upadezako zravaNa karate haiM to hameM vivaza hokara kahanA par3atA hai ki, svAmIjI mahArAjakI satyatA aura niSpakSatA gharakI cAra dIvArI (koThaDI) mAtrameM hI paryApta hai| yadi dUsareko parAsta karane ke liye asatya pakSakA avalaMbana bhI zreyaskara hai, tabato ( kSamA kIjiye !) auraMgajebI talavArako doSI ThaharAnA nirarthaka hai ! svAmIjI ke isa upadeza se satyAsatya, dharmAdharma, sadAcAra durAcAra, prakAza aura aMdhakAra AdikI mImAMsA 1

Page #14
karanI kaThina hI nahIM, balAka asaMbhava hai ! svAmIjI jaise samAjanetA aisA upadeza kareM, isase bar3hakara aura kyA duHkhakI bAta ho sakatI hai? satya hai ! jahAM prakAza hai vahAM usakI tahameM aMdhakAra bhI apanA Asana jamAye baiThA hai ! udyAna meM jahAM modajanaka Amodase bharapUra vikasita puppa samudAya darzakoMko AnaMda detA hai, vahAMpara unake sAtha cipake hue marmavedhI tIkSNa kAMTebhI hAtha phailAye apanI ghAtameM baiThe rahate haiM:! astu ! aba hama prakRta viSayakI tarpha apane pAThakoMke dhyAnako AkarSita krtehaiN| "satyArtha prakAza" ke vAraveM samullAsameM "svAmIjI ne cAracAka (nAstika) bauddha aura jainamatakA khaMDana likhA hai ! usameM bhI cAravAka aura bauddhamatakA bahuta saMkSepase khaMDana karake avaziSTa bhAgameM jainamatakI hI samIkSA kI hai ! hama bhI yahAMpara " svAmIjI " ke lekha kramake anusAra hI apane vicAroMko prastuta karate haiM. satyArthaprakAza san 1884. vaidikayaMtrAlayaprayoga' [ka] svA080sa0-cAravAka, AmANaka, vauddha aura jainabhI jagatkI utpatti svabhAvase mAnate haiM. ( pRSTha 400) [kha]. bhAMDadhUrta nizAcaravat mahIdharAdi TIkAkAra hue haiM unakI dhUrtatA hai vedoMkI nahIM. paraMtu zoka hai cAravAka AmANaka bauddha aura jainiyoMpara ki inhoMne mUla cAra vedoMkI saMhitA ko bhI na sunA aura na dekhA aura na kisI vidvAnse par3hA . . isIliye naSTa bhraSTa buddhi hokara UTapaTAMga vedoMkI niMdA karane

Page #15
lage duSTa vAmamArgioMkI pramANa zUnya kapola kalpita bhraSTa TIkAoM ko dekhakara vedoMse virodhi ho kara avidyArUpI agAdha samudra meM jA gire. (pRSTha 402 ) [ga] saca to yaha hai ki, jinhoMne vedoMse virodha kiyA aura karate haiM aura kareMge ve avazya avidyArUpI aMdhakAra meM par3ake sukhake badale dAruNa duHkha jitanA pAveM utanA hI nyUna hai. ( pRSTha 402 ) jo veda aura vedAnukUla Apta puruSoM ke kiye zAstroMkA apamAna karatA hai usa veda niMdaka nAstikako jAtipaMkti aura dezase vAhya kara denA cAhiye. (pRSTha 13 ) [ gha ] ye cAravAkAdi bahutasI bAtoMmeM eka haiM paraMtu cAravAka dehakI utpatti aura usake nAzake sAtha hI jIvakA bhI nAza mAnatA hai punarjanma aura paralokako nahIM mAnatA eka pratyakSa pramANake vinA anumAnAdi pramANako bhI nahIM mAnatA. bauddha aura jaina pratyakSAdi cAroM pramANa anAdi jIva aura punarjanma paraloka aura muktiko bhI mAnate haiM itanA hI cAravAkase bauddha aura jainiyoMkA bheda hai. paraMtu nAstikatA veda IzvarakI niMdA paramata dvepa aura 6 yatanA jagatakA koI karttA nahIM, ityAdi bAtoMmeM saba eka hI haiM. yaha cAravAkakA mata saMkSepase darzA diyA. ( pRSTha 403 ) samAlocaka - - sajjano ! anya matoMke prativAda meM hamAre pUjanIya svAmIjI mahArAjane jina madhura zabdoM kA vyavahAraH kiyA hai, una zabdoM meM se kucha to Apa Upara suna hI cuke haiM 1

Page #16
aura avaziSTa Ageko sunoMge ! inake viSayameM hamArA vAraMvAra likhanA " svAmIjI "kA eka prakArakA apamAna karanA hai ! isaliye " svAmIjI ke saMbaMdhameM inake citAnucita panekI mImAMsAko hama Apa para hI chor3ate hue ukta . (ka)(kha ) Adi vargoM ke kramaseM hI hama " svAmIjI ke prazasta lekhoMpara madhyastha bhAvase dRSTiyAta karate haiM / hama apane pAThakoMko itanA smaraNa phira bhI karavAye dete haiM ki, svAmIjIke lekhakA prativAda karanekA hamArA abhiprAya nahIM hai, hamArA uddeza unake lekhako yathArtha samIkSaNa karake madhyastha saMsArake samakSa upasthita karanekA hai. astu ! aba prakRtakA anusaraNa karate haiN| [ka] svabhAvase jagatkI utpatti mAnanA jaina zAstrake maMtavyase vAhira hai ! jaina zAstroMkA parizIlana karanevAle isa vAtase bakhUbI paricita haiM ki, svabhAvavAdakA jainazAstroMmeM yukti pUrNa itanA prativAda-khaMDana kiyA hai ki, " svAmIjI" ke graMthoM meM usakA zatAMzato kyA ? sahasrAMza bhI upalabdha nahIM hotA ! phira mAlUma nahIM ki " aura jaina bhI jagatakI utpatti svabhAvase mAnate haiM " yaha vyartha nirvala apavAda jainoM para lagAne aura usakA prativAda karanekA " svAmIjI" kA kyA Azaya thA ? kyA hI acchA hotA ! yadi jaina dharma ke mAnya graMthoM ke do cAra pramANa bhI likha dete ! jisase jainoMkImAnI huI svabhAvase saMsArotpattike viSayameM kisIko saMdeha hI na rahatA! kyA koI samAjI vidvAna isa bAtako sapramANa batalAnekI kRpA kareMge?

Page #17
" bhAMDa dhUrca nizAcara vatuM mahIdharAdi TIkAkAra hue haiM unakI dhUrtatA hai vedoMkI nahIM " svAmIjI mahArAjakA yaha lekha dhyAna se par3hane lAyaka hai ! mahIdharAdi TIkAkAroMko bhAMDa dhUrta aura nizAcara batalAnekA " svAmIjI " ne hetu diyA hai ki, mahIdharAdi TIkAkAroMne mAMsa madirA tathA anya kaieka vIbhatsa kAryoMkA Tallekha karake mithyA hI vedoMpara kalaMka lagAyA hai, vedoM meM ina bAtoMkA arthAt mAMsamadirA ke khAnapAna tathA anya vIbhatsa vyavahAroMkA vidhAna sarvathA nahIM ! isaliye vedapara jhUThA kalaMka lagAnevAle mahIdharAdi TIkAkAroM ko avazya bhAMDa dhUrta aura nizAcara kahanA cAhiye ! pyAre sabhya pAThako | vedoMmeM mAMsa madirA AdikA vidhAna haiM yA ki nahIM ? yaha viSaya bahuta hI vivAda grasta hai ! isakI mImAMsA karanI asaMbhava nahIM to kaThina to avazya hI hai ! astu ! isa viSayapara yukti pUrNa vistArapUrvaka vicAra hama kahIM anyatra kareMge, isa samaya to mahIdharAdi AcAryoM ke viSayameM jo "svAmIjI" kA lekha hai, usako dekhakara hamAre manameM jo zaMkAyeM utpanna hotI haiM unako likhate haiM / " svAmIjI " mahArAjakA " vedoMmeM mAMsa khAnA kahIM nahIM likhA " yaha lekha isa bAtako spaSTa batalA rahA hai kiM, vedoM meM mAMsAdikA ullekha batalAnevAle sabhI ke sabhI bhAMDa dhUrca aura nizAcara haiM | mAlUma hotA hai ki, isI liye unhoMne " mahIdharAdi" isameM Adi zabda likhA hai ! kadApi - hama "svAmInI" kI yaha bAta svIkAra kareM to hame AMzA nahIM ki, vedoMse saMbaMdha rakhanevAle jitane bhI prAcIna graMtha haiM unake racayitA - AcArya - RSioMmeMse koI bhI aisA nikale ki,

Page #18
jisake pAsa " svAmIjI " mahArAjakA pradAna kiyA huA "bhAMDa dhUrta aura nizAcara rUpa svarNapadaka-cAMda-" na nikle| kyoMki, aitareyase lekara yAvat brAhmaNa graMtha, kAtyAyana zrautase lekara yAvat zrauta sUtra graMtha, evaM AzvalAyanagRhyase lekare yAvat gRhya sUtra graMtha, manusmRtise leke yAvat smRti graMtha, mahAbhAratase lekara yAvat itihAsa graMthomase, aisA eka bhI graMtha nahIM, jisameM mAMsakI carcA na pAI jAve ! Aja taka vedoMke jitane prAcIna bhASya upalabdha hote haiM, unameM hiMsAkA ullekha spaSTa dekhane meM AtA hai / yajurvedake bhASyakartA mahIdharAcArya para mAMsa saMbaMdhI ullekhakA tathA anya bIbhatsa vyavahAroMke ullekhakA doSa lagAnA vRthA hai; kyoMki, mahIdharAcAryake bhASyakA akSara akSara kAtyAyana zrauta sUtrake AdhAra para likhA gayA hai! brAhmaNoMse leke purANetihAsa paryaMta jitane bhI graMtha upalabdha hote haiM, una sabameM vedoMpara hiMsAkA kalaMka lagAyA dekhA jAtA hai ! isa liye " svAmIjI" kI AjJAnusAra hame vivaza hokara unake racayitA-maharSi vyAsa, vasiSTa, yAjJacalkya, jaimini, vAlmIka, kAtyAyana, mahIdAsa, kumArilabhaTTa, zaMkarAcArya, sAyaNa, mAdhava, rAmAnujasvAmI, madhvAcArya, vAcaspati mizra, udayanAcArya, nIlakaMTha, zrIdhara, madhusUdana svAmI, AnaMdagiri prabhRti sabhako hI bhAMDadhUtta aura nizAcara kahanA par3egA ! magara kSamA kIjiye hamameM itanA sAhasa nahIM ki, ukta mahAtmAoMkA hama ina zabdoMse smaraNa kara sakeM ! hAM! " svAmIjI " bhale hI isake liye samartha hoM!! . . " svAmIjI " mahArAja cArvAka, mAmANaka, bauddha aura jainoMpara zoka prakaTa karate haiM ki, " inhoMne mUla cAra vedoMkI saMhitAoMko na,sunA ! aura na dekhA! aura na kisI

Page #19
11 vidvAna se par3hA ! isaliye naSTa bhraSTa buddhi hokara UTapaTAMga vedoMkI niMdA karane lage" ityAdi - yadyapi svAmIjI mahArAjakA yaha kathana (inameM vedoMke jAnanevAlA koI vidvAna nahIM hai ityAdi) saMbhava nahIM ki, ucita ho ! paraMtu svAmIjIke kathanako eka daphA cupacApa suna lenA hamAre liye jarUrI hai ! svAmI " dayAnaMdajI " kahate haiM " duSTa vAma mArgiyoMkI pramANa zUnya kapola kalpita bhraSTa TIkAoM ko dekhakara vedoMse virodhI hokara (cArvAkAdi) avidyArUpI agAdha samudra meM jA gire" isakA tAtparya yaha hai ki, vedoMke jina bhASyoMko dekhakara cArvAkAdi vedoMkI niMdA karate haiM, ve bhASya vAma mArgiyoM ke banAe hue haiM ! vAma mArgiyoMne apane svArtha vazase vedoMpara madya mAMsa tathA vyabhicArakA kalaMka lagAyA hai ! paraMtu vedoM meM kahIM mAMsakA khAnA nahIM likhA ! | hamArA isameM itanA hI kathana hai ki, kadApi svAmIjI ke pratipakSI, svAmIjIke viSayameM bhI yahI kaheM ki, svAmI " dayAnaMda " sarasvatIjI vedoMke vAstavika rahasyako nahIM samajheM ! unhoMne vRthA hI pramANa zUnya kapola kalpita artha karake vedoMkI satyatAko naSTa bhraSTa kara diyA hai ! yadi svAmIjI tanika bhI apanI buddhise kAma lete to aisA kadApi na kahate ki, vedoMke bhASya vAma mArgiyoM ke banAe hue haiM ! svAmIjI dUsaroMko avidyArUpI agAdha samudra meM girAte hue svayaM hI avidyAke gaMbhIra samudrameM gote lagA rahe haiM ! jaise ki, brAhmaNa sarvasvake sampAdaka iTAvA nivAsI paMDita bhImasena zarmAjI likhate haiM ki, " jisa yajJAdika karmameM jisaprakAra jisa pazukA balidAna veda meM karttavya kahA hai vahAM vaha karma hiMsA nahIM adharma nahIM kiMtu vedokta dharma hai " [brA. bhA. 4 aM. 1 pR. 12]

Page #20
" vedAdI zAstrameM vihita madyamAMsa aura maithunameM doSa nahIM hai kyoMki jisakA vidhAna kiyA gayA vaha dharma koTImeM A gayA / vAjapeya yajJameM surAke grahoMkA vidhAna hai| sautrAmaNi yajJameM surA nAma madyakA vidhAna hai / amiSTomAdi yajJaoNma amiSomIya Adi pazukA vidhAna aura vahAM zeSa mAMsabhakSaNakA mI vizeSa vidhAna spaSTa rUpase vistArake sAtha kiyA gayA hai." trA0 bhA0 4 aM. 5 pR. 194] " hamArI to rAya yaha hai ki, jina logoMkA mata yaha hai ki, vedameM madyamAMsAdi sarvathA nahIM vA hai to prakSipta hai athavA usakA artha hI kucha aura hai aisA mAnanevAle sabhI AryasamAjioMke bar3e bhAI veda virodhI hai ki jo vedake pratyakSa siddhAMtako lauTanA cAhate haiM " [trA0 mA0 4 aM. 5 pR. 195] tathA saMskRtaratnAkara ke sampAdaka-nyAyazAstrI-vyAkaraNAcArya paMDita giridhara zarmA caturvedIjI "smRtivirodhaparihAra" nAmakI pustakameM likhate haiM ki--"yaha kauna pratijJA kara sakatA hai ki yajJoMmeM pazu hiMsA nahIM hai / yadi aisA hI hotA to jaina bauddha Adi saMpradAya sanAtana Aryadharmase pRthaka kyoM hote ? hAM Aja kahIM ke navyasamAjI vA koI koI vaiSNava bhI kisIcI dekhA dekhI vinA apane dharma samajhe cAhe yaha kahanekA sAhasa kara ki vedoMmeM pazu hiMsA nahIM hai, paraMtu vaiSNavoM ke Adi AcArya bhagavAn zrI rAmAnujasvAmI " azuddhamiti cenna zabdAt " 3-1-25 sUtrake bhApyameM spaSTa vedameM pazu hiMsA vidhiko svIkAra karate haiM " [prakAzaka adhyakSa-zrI sarasvatI bhaMDArakAzI pRSTa. 67] evaM jisa prakAra " svAmIjI" mahIdharAdike bhApyoMkA anAdara kara rahe haiM, isIprakAra Ajakalake bahutase

Page #21
2.pn 13 pratiSThita vidvAn bhI svAmIjI ke bhApyako pramANazUnya manaHkalpita samajhate hue anAdarakI dRSTise dekhate haiM! svAmI dayAnaMda: aura Ajakala ke vidvAnoMmeM se niSpakSa aura, satyavaktA. kauna hai ? isakA patA lagAnA itanA hI kaThina hai- jitanA ki... gAr3ha aMdhakAra meM par3I huI, sUkSma vastukA / paraMtu isa prakAra ina.. kA paraspara daMgala - karAnese kucha pariNAma nikale aisI abhI.. AzA nahIM | isa liye isa vipayapara sapramANa apane vicAroMkoM vizeSarUpase hama kahIM anyatra pradarzita kareMge / [ga] vedoMke na mAnanevAloM ke bAremeM " saca to yaha hai " ityAdi lekhane svAmIjI mahArAjane jo udAratA dikhalAI hai vaha, madhyastha vargako avazya smaraNa rakhane yogya haiM ! vedoMpara zraddhA ne rakhanevAleko " svAmIjI " eka to yaha AzIrvAda dete haiM ki, " vaha sukhake badale dAruNa jitanA duHkha pAve utanA nyUna hai " dUsarI AjJA usake liye yaha hai ki " usako jAti paMkti se nikAlakara jilA vatana ( dezapAra ) kara diyA jAve " yadyapi svAmIjI mahArAjakI isa nyAya priyatA ke saMbaMdha meM vizeSa kahate hue hame saMkoca hotA hai, paraMtu itanA to kahe binA nahIM rahA jAtA ki, yadi svAmI " dayAnaMda sarasvatI ke hAthameM koI sattA hotI to bicAre vedoMke na mAnanevAloMko vahI saubhAgya prApta hotA jo ki svAmI zaMkarAcAryajI ke samaya meM sudhanvA rAjAke dvArA bauddhoM ko prApta huA thA ! " svAmI jI" kI zikSAnusAra mahamUda gajanavI ne yadi bhagavAna somanAtha maMdirako toDA to kyA burAI kI ? yavana rAja auraMgajebane talavAra ke jorase yadi hiMduoM ko mUsalamAna banAyA to kyA burA kiyA ? kyoMki, ve (hiMdu ) yavanadharma, " 2

Page #22
14 aura yavana dharmapustaka kurAnako mAnanevAle nahIM the! isameM kucha saMdeha nahIM ki yadi koI praur3ha zAsana " svAmIjI ke hAthameM hotA to vedoMpara zraddhA na rakhanevAle jaina aura bauddha Adike sAhityase bhI vahI kAma liyA jAtA jo ki yavanoMke zAsanameM hamAma garama karaneke liye . amUlya hiMdu sAhityase liyA gayA thA ! pAThaka mahodaya ! kSamA kIniye hamako vivaza hokara yeha zabda likhane par3e haiM !!! . [pa] "svAmIjI mahArAna cArvAkake sAtha bauddha aura jainoMkA punarjanma paraloka aura mukti Adike mAnanese kitane hI aMzoMmeM bheda dikhalAte hue bhI unhe eka batalA rahe haiM ! isI taraha yadi koI svAmIjIke saMbaMdha kahe ki, "Izvara, veda aura punarjanmako chor3akara, svarga-naraka-devapUjA aura pitRzrAddha Adike na mAnanemeM "svAmIjI" bhI cArvAka (nAstika )ke .samAna hI haiM" to kyA kucha anucita hogA ? hamAre khyAlameM isa prakArakA kSudra lekha mahAtmAkI prazasta lokhanIkA viSaya nahIM honA cAhiye ! bauddha aura jainoMko jo "svAmIjI ne nAstika batalAyA hai, isake bAremeM hama adhika kucha na likhate hue apane pAThakoMse itanI hI prArthanA karate haiM ki, ve hamArI banAI huI "jainAstikatva mImAMsA" nAmakI pustakako dekheM. "jaina bauddhakI ekatA aura svAmI dayAnaMda" svAmI da0 sa0 - "jinako bauddha tIrthakara mAnate haiM unhIMko jaina bhI mAnate haiM" (pRSTa 105)

Page #23
15 samAlocaka- svAmIjI mahArAjakA yaha lekha aisA hai, jaise koI kahe ki, jisa kurAnazarIphako hamAre mahamadI bhAI khudAkA ilhAma kahate haiM, usIko svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatIjI IzvarIya jJAna (veda) mAnate haiM. isIliye ye donoM eka haiN|| "svAmIjI ne jaina aura bauddhako eka batalAnemeM kisI bhI yukti yA pramANase kAma nahIM liyA !! " satyArtha prakAza ke (pRSTha 407)meM jo itihAsa timira nAzakakA pATha " svAmIjI ne jaina bauddhakI ekatAmeM pramANa rUpase uddhRta kiyA hai vaha unakI AzAko saphala hone nahIM detA ! yadyapi jaina aura bauddhakI ekatAmeM koI dRDhatara yukti aura pramANake upalabdha na honepara bhI ( pratyuta isake viruddhameM zatazaH pramANa upalabdha hote haiM ! ) kevala itihAsa timira nAzaka (jisakA lekha sarvathA yukti saha nahIM) graMthake AdhAra para hI inako eka mAnanA aura batalAnA " svAmIjI" jaise niSpakSa vidvAnoMke liye ucita nahIM! tathApi " svAmIjI" jaise bhadra puruSake lekhako apramANika kahanA, apane liye ayogya samajhate hue hama itihAsa timira nAzaka graMthake kartA, bAbU"zivaprasAda" sitAre hiMdake usa patrako yahAM para uddhRta karate haiM, jo ki unhoMne gujarAMvAlA-paMjAbake jaina samAja para likhA thaa| isake dekhanese yaha bAta bakhUbI mAlama ho jAyagI ki, "svAmIjI" kA ullekha madhyastha vargako kisa sImA taka AdaraNIya hai !! [bAbU-"zivaprasAda sitAre hiMdakA patra.] zrI 5 sakala jaina paMcAyata gujarAMvAlAko zivaprasAda kA praNAma pahuMce kRpApatra patroMsahita pahuMcA.

Page #24
(1) jaina aura bauddha eka nahIM hai.sanAtanase bhinna bhinna cale Aye haiM. jarmanadezake eka bar3e vidvAnne isake pramANameM eka graMtha chApA hai. . (2) cArvAka auraMjainase kucha saMbaMdha nahIM. jainako cAvAka kahanA aisAhai jaisA svAmI dayAnaMdanI mahArAjako musalamAna kahanA! (3) itihAsa timira nAzakakA Azaya svAmInIkI samajhameM nahIM AyA. usakI bhUmikAkI eka nakala isake sAtha dI jAtI hai usase vidita hogA ki, yaha saMgraha hai. bahuta bAta khaMDanake liye likhI gayI. mere nizcayake anusAra usameM kucha bhI nahIM hai. (4) jo svAmIjI jainako itihAsa timira nAzakake anusAra mAnate haiM to vedoMko bhI usake anusAra' kyoM nahIM "mAnate ? vanArasa-1 janavarI ApakA dAsa- IsvIsan 1879 zivaprasAda. ' . ( ajJAna timira bhAskara prathama khar3ase uddhata.) -sajjano! Agrahagrasta manuSyako satya prAptise vaise hI hAtha dhone par3ate haiM jaise rAjayakSmAke rogIko jIvanase ! Agrahako chor3akara satyAsatyakA vicAra karanA hI vidvAnoMke prazasta jIvanakA uddezya hai / jaina aura bauddhakI vibhinnatAmeM zatazaH pramANa-upalabdha ho rahe haiM / saMsAra bharake niSpakSa vidvAna isa vAtako mukta kaMThase svIkAra kara rahe haiN| isa vAtakA udAharaNArtha thoDAsA nAma pUrvaka varNana kiyA jAtA hai. (1) sarva darzana saMgrahake racayitA mAdhavAcAryane jaina aura bauddha darzanakA svataMtra bhinna bhinna ullekha kiyA hai. hai (2) advaita siddhike kartA mahAtmA sadAnaMdane, bauddha

Page #25
17 mata sautrAMtika, vaibhApika, yogAcAra aura mAdhyamika ina cAra avAMtara bhedoM kA varNana karate hue jaina dharmako inake aMtarniviSTha nahIM kiyA. (3) maharSi veda vyAsajIne brahmasUtrameM jaina aura bauddha matakA paraspara kucha bhI saMbaMdha nahIM batalAyA. (4) svAmI zaMkarAcArya se lekara jitane bhI prasiddha vidvAnoMne brahmasUtra para bhASya race haiM, unameMse aisA eka bhI nahIM jisane eka dUsarese sarvathA saMbaMdha na rakhanevAle bauddha aura jaina matakA pratipAdana aura khaMDana na kiyA ho ! svAmI zaMkarAcArya spaSTa likhate haiM "nirastaH sugatasamayaH vivasanasamayaidAnIM nirasyate" 2-2-31. (5) bauddhoM kA kSaNikavAda aura jainoMkA spAdvAda ina donoMkA Apasa meM sadaivase 36kA saMbaMdha hai. (6) hanumannATaka graMthameM bhI jaina aura bauddhako bhinna bhinna mAnA hai. zloka. 2. (7) bauddha graMthoMmeM jaina matakA bahutasA prativAda dekhane meM AtA hai, evaM jaina graMthoMmeM bhI bauddha svIkRta kSaNika vAdake khaMDana kI kamI nahIM ! | 1 (8) prAcIna graMthoM meM syAdvAdI aura kSaNikavAdI ina do zabdoMkA artha kramazaH jaina aura bauddha kiyA huA dekhA jAtA hai. . (9) pAzcAtya vidvAn mi. . harmana jekobIne AcArAMga, uttarAdhyayana aura sUtrakRtAMga jaina sUtroMke iMgaliza bhASAMtarakI : prastAvanAmai isa aMdhakAra ko bar3e hI sabala pramANoMse dUra kiyA hai ! paraMtu svAmI " dayAnaMda " sarasvatIjIne jaina aura . - . * - eka likha mArA isakA uttara hamArI.. : bauddhako kisa Azaya se buddhise bAhira hai !

Page #26
"saptabhaMgI aura svAmI dayAnanda sarasvatI" [ka] svAmI da0 sa0--" aba jo vauddha aura jainI loga saptabhaMgI aura syAdvAda mAnate haiM so yaha hai. " san ghaTaH " isako prathama bhaMga kahate haiM kyoMki ghaTa apane vartamAnatAse yukta arthAt ghar3A hai isane abhAvakA virodha kiyA hai / dUsarA bhaMga " asan ghaTaH " ghar3A nahIM hai prathama ghaTake bhAvase yaha ghar3eke asadbhAvase dUsarA bhaMga hai / tIsarA bhaMga yaha hai ki " sannasan ghaTaH " arthAt yaha ghaDA to hai paraMtu paTa nahIM kyoMki una donoMseM pRthak ho gyaa| cauthA bhaMga " ghaTo'ghaTaH" jaise " aghaTaH paTaH " dUsare paTake abhAvakI apekSA apanemeM honese ghaTa aghaTa kahAtA hai yugapat usakI do saMjJA arthAt ghaTa aura aghaTa bhI hai / pAMcavAM bhaMga yaha hai ki ghaTako paTa kahanA ayogya arthAt usameM ghaTapana vaktavya hai aura paTapana avaktavya hai| chaThA bhaMga yaha hai ki jo ghaTa nahIM hai vaha kahane yogya bhI nahIM aura jo hai vaha hai aura kahane yogya bhI hai / aura sAtavAM bhaMga yaha hai ki jo kahaneko iSTa hai paraMtu vaha nahIM hai aura kahaneke yogya bhI ghaTa nahIM yaha saptamabhaMga kahAtA hai" ityaadi| [ pRSTa 410 ] " yaha kathana eka anyonyAbhAvameM sAdharmya aura vaidhaya'me caritArtha ho sakatA hai| isa sarala prakaraNako chor3akara . kaThina jAla racanA kevala ajJAniyoMke phasAne ke liye hotA hai| dekho jIvakA ajIvameM aura ajIvakA jIvameM abhAva rahatA hI hai jaise jIva aura jar3ake vartamAna honese sAdharmya aura cetana . tathA jar3a honese vaidharmya arthAt jIvameM cetanatva (asti) hai

Page #27
/ deg / aura jar3atva ( nAsti ) nahIM hai / isI prakAra jar3ameM jar3atva hai aura cetanatva nahIM hai isase guNa karma svabhAvake samAna dharma aura viruddha dharmake vicArase saba inakA saptabhaMgI aura syAdvAda sahajatAse samajhameM AtA hai phira itanA prapaMca bar3hAnA. : kisa kAmakA hai / isameM vauddha aura jainoMkA eka mata hai"| [ pRSTa 411] [ka] samAlocaka-" svAmIjI ne apane samasta jIvanameM jaina aura bauddha dharmakA eka bhI graMtha pddh'| athavA dekhA ho aisA unake lekhase vidita nahIM hotA ! anyathA ve " aba jo bauddha aura jainI loga saptabhaMgI aura syAdvAda mAnate haiM " aisA kadApi na likhate ! jaina aura bauddha dharmakA manamAnA, nirbala, . khaMDana karaneke liye svAmIjIne mAtra jisa sarvadarzanasaMgraha graMtha ke AdhAra para unake matakA yathA kathaMcit nirUpaNa kiyA hai, yadi usako bhI acchI tarahase dekha lete to bhI unheM mAlUma ho jAtA ki, vauddha matameM saptabhaMgIkA sarvathA aMgIkAra nahIM hai! saptabhaMgI nayake mAnanevAlA kevala jainadharma hai ! bauddhoMkA siddhAMta kSaNikavAda hai, syAdvAda nhiiN| aura jainoMkA siddhAMta syAdvAda hai, kSaNikavAda nahIM / arthAt jaina aura bauddha dharmakI vibhinnatAkA mukhya kAraNa hI syAdvAda [saptabhaMgI] aura kSaNikavAda hai / yaha bAta itanI nirdhAnta hai jitanA ki madhyAhnakA sUrya / phira " svAmIjI" mahArAjane aisA kyoM likhA ? isakA uttara sivA unake koI dUsarA de sake aisI hame AzA nahIM ! / hAM ! kadApi-"pra. mUrtipUjA kahAMse calI ? u. jainiyoMse. pra. jainiyoMne kahAMse calAI ? u. apanI mUrkhatAse " [ satyArtha prakAza pRSTha 305 ] apane isa kathanake anusAra svAmIjIne

Page #28
yaha likhamArA ho to hama kaha nahIM sakate ! kyoMki ve. svataMtra puruSa the! ___ "svAmIjI" ne jo "san ghaTaH" isako prathama, bhaMga kahate haiM, ityAdi lekhase jaina matakI saptabhaMgIkA varNana kiyA hai, vaha jaina dharmake siddhAMtameM inakI mAtra mugdhatAko hI prakaTa nahIM karatA ! kiMtu " inhoMne mUla cAra vedoMkI saMhitAoMko na sunA na dekhA aura na kisI vidvAnse par3hA isI liye naSTa bhraSTa buddhi hokara-ityAdi-tathA-kyA kareM vicAre inameM itanI vidyA hI nahIM jo satyAsatyakA vicAra kara-ityAdi [pRSTha 402]" " svAmIjI " ke isa lekhako bhI inake hI liye astra rUpa banA rahA hai| . sajjano ! kisI bhI matakA pratipAdana vA khaMDana karanevAle manuSya ke liye yaha parama Avazyaka hai ki, prathama vaha usa matakA acchI tarahase abhyAsa kara leve / haraeka matake graMthoM meM kitanIka aisI sAMketika bAteM hotI haiM ki, unakA vinA abhyAsa aura sahavAsase paricayameM AnA kaThina hai ! paraMtu Aja kala kitaneka aise bhI kSudra mAzayake manuSya dekhanemeM Ate haiM ki, jo vinA hI kisI dharmake rahasya ko samajhe, usake khaMDanameM pravRtta ho jAte haiM ! aise puruSoM ke viSayoM maharSi yAskakA " nAyaM sthANoraparAdhaH yadenamandho na pazyati" yaha vAkya hI zaraNa hai| yadyapi " svAmI jI " mahArAjake prakhara pAMDitya para hamako pUrNa abhimAna hai, aura hama cAhate haiM ki, ukta kalaMkase.. " svAmIjI." sadA mukta raheM! paraMtu zoka ! ki, unakI pUrvameM / pratipAdana kI huI 'saptabhaMgI rUpa bAlakrIDA ! hamArI isa zubha.. AzAko saphala hone nahIM detI ! " svAmIjI " kI nirUpa

Page #29
* 21 Na kI huI saptabhaMgIko dekhakara hame vicAra hotA hai ki, unhoMne saptabhaMgIkI yaha anokhI racanA jaina matake kisa graMthaparase kI hogI ! kyoMki jaina dharmake Aja kala jitane graMtha ( mudrita athavA likhita ) upalabdha hote haiM, unameM isa -prakArakI saptabhaMgIkI racanA kahIM bhI dekhane meM nahIM AtI ! saMbhava hai ! hama " svAmIjI" kA Azaya hI na samajhe hoN| kadApi yena kena prakAreNa paramatakI niMdAmeM hI unakA abhiprAya ho to usako bhI kauna roka sakatA hai ? paraMtu "svAmIjI" to saMsArase cala base, aba pUche to kisase pUche ! svAmIjIke pRSTapoSakoMmeMse inakI varNana kI huI savabhaMgI ko jaina dharmake mAnanIya graMthoMke dvArA koI samAhita kara dikhAve aisI hameM AzA nahIM ! [kha] . ___ anyonAbhAva aura sAdharmya vaidhaya'meM saptamaMgIkA aMtarbhAva batalAnA to "svAmIjI "kA unakI varNana kI huI saptabhaMgAse bhI do kadama Age bar3hA huA hai ! isa viSayameM aba hamArA kathana kevala araNya rodana ke hI samAna hai / isameM saMdeha nahIM ki, yadi " svAmIjI " saptabhaMgI ke vAstavika rahasyase paricita hote to unako " anyonyA bhAvameM" ityAdi nirbala AkSepa karaneke liye apanI lekhanIko zrama denA na par3atA! hAM ! AgraharUpa rogI auSadhi to vidhAtAke pAsa bhI zAyada hI nikale ! ___" svAmIjI " mahArAja jainoMke saptabhaMgI nayako bar3A vikaTa mArga batalAte haiM ! paraMtu vicArase dekhA jAya to yaha mArga . bar3A hI sarala aura spaSTa hai ! isake Azrayase hama kaThinase bhI kaThina praznoMkI mImAMsA bar3I hI sugamatAse kara sakate haiM!

Page #30
22 paraMtu zAka itanA hI hai ki, jainoMke isa vyApaka siddhAMtako . yathAvat samajhanevAle isa saMsArameM bahuta thor3e manuSya haiM ! aise. manuSya prAyaH adhika saMkhyA meM dekhe jAte haiM jo ki jainadharmake siddhAMtako samajhe soce vinA hI usakI peTabhara niMdA karane meM apane janmako saphala samajhate haiM ! hamAre khyAlameM aise puruSoMke viSayameM "bhadraM kRtaM kRtaM maunaM, kokilairdurAgame ! dardurA yatra vaktAra-statra maunaM hi zobhate // 1 // " isa kavi vAkyako smaraNa karate hue jainoMko mauna rahanA hI acchA hai. ___ hama apane pAThakoM se nivedana kara cuke haiM ki, jaina , siddhAMtoMse asAdhAraNa paricaya rakhanevAle bahuta thor3e manuSya haiM! vicAra kiyA jAya to jainamatake kitaneka aise gUDha vicAra haiM ki, jinako samajhaneke liye jaina graMthoMke jAnakAra kisI yogya vidvAnkA saMga aura kucha parizramakI AvazyakatA hai. / aba hama jainoMkA maMtavya kyA hai? jaina prAsAdakA AdhArabhUta saptabhaMgI naya kisako kahate haiM ? usakA prayojana kyA hai ? usase hama padArthoMkI paristhitiko sugamatAse kisa . prakAra samajha sakate haiM ? ityAdi viSayako saMkSepase varNana karate haiN| jisase hamAre pAThaka jainasiddhAMtoMse kathamapi paricita hote hue apane madhyastha vicAroMko vizAla karaneke liye sugamatA * prApta kara sakeM. . jaina dharmakA yathArtha nAma anekAMtavAda athavA syAdvAda hai / yadi isako madhyasthavAdake nAmase pukAreM to bahuta :: ucita hogaa| jaina dharmameM vastu mAtrakI vyavasthA eka / dUsarekI apekSAse kI * gaI hai, isIliye isakA dUsarA . nAma apekSAvAda bhI hai. jaina * matameM vastumAtra * hI utpatti sthiti aura nAza ina tIna avasthAoMse yukta hai|

Page #31
-- -... - jisameM ye tIno dharma nahIM vaha vastuhI zazazRMga ke samAna hai| * vastuke sthira rahane parabhI usameM utpatti aura nAza huA karatA hai. padArthameM jo sthirAMza hai usako dravya aura asthirAMzako / jaina matameM paryAya kahate haiM. jaina siddhAMtameM padArtha mAtrako dravya aura paryAyarUpa-nityAnitya-mAnA hai. arthAt dravyarUpase jIvA-. jIvAdi saba padArtha nitya haiM / aura paryAya rUpase anitya haiN| paraMtu dravya aura paryAya bhI ApasameM sarvathA bhinna nahIM, kiMtu eka dUsarekI apekSAse kahanemeM Ate haiM. arthAt dravyakI apekSAse paryAya, aura paryAyakI apekSA sedravya, kahAjAtA hai. .kyoMki, vastumAtra paraspara sApekSya hai. kisI vyaktimeM puruSa, zabdakA nirdeza kiyA jAtA hai to strI zabdakI apekSAse hI kiyA jAtA hai, evaM kisI vyaktimeM strI zabdakA vyavahAra bhI. puruSa zabdakI apekSAke vinA nahIM ho sakatA, dina kahA to rAtrikI apekSA huI / paMr3ita kahA to mUrkhakI apekSA huI / isI taraha ghaTa, aghaTakI apekSAse; satya, asatyakI apekSAse; pitA, putrakI apekSAse; bahina, bhAIkI apekSAse; tathA prakAza, aMdhakArakI apekSAse; baMdha, mokSakI apekSAse; ityAdi sarva vyavahAra apekSAse hI kiyA jA sakatA hai| saMsArameM apekSAke vinA vastukA nirdeza vaMdhyAputra ke samAna hai, aisA jainazAstrakA siddhAMta hai| jainoMke isa apekSAvAda-syAdvAda-siddhAMtakA svIkAra pratyeka darzanakArane kisI na kisI. rItise avazya kiyA hai ! jo ki, kahIM anyatra pradarzita kiyA jaaygaa| . pAzcAtya vidvAn-mi. 'sara viliyama' aura 'hemilTana, ' ne madhyastha vicAroMke vizAla maMdirakA. AdhAra jainoMke isa . 'apekSAvAdako hI mAnA hai / jainamatameM apekSAvAdakA hI dusarA

Page #32
24 nAma nayavAda hai / padArthameM rahe hue aneka dharmoM se kisI eka dharmako kisI eka dRSTise pratipAdana karanekI paddhatiko naya kahate haiM / jaise putrakI apekSAse kisI vyaktiko pitA khnaa| sarva prakArake nayoM kA samAveza mukhyatayA dravyAdhika aura paryAyAthika ina do nayoM meM kiyA gayA hai / . dravya arthAt vastu, paryAya arthAt usakI vikRti pheraphAra (jaise suvarNa dravya-aura kaTaka kuMDalAdi paryAya ) ke bodhaka jo naya unako dravyArthika aura paryAyArthika naya kahate haiN| dravyArthika nayako naigama, saMgraha aura vyavahAra ina tIna varnAmeM vibhakta kiyA hai. tathA paryAyArthika nayako RjumUtra, zabda, samabhiruDa aura evaMbhUna, ina cAra vImeM vibhakta kiyA hai. (inakA svarUpa anyatra vistArase likhA jAyagA.) zarIrake hasta pAdAdi avayavoMkI taraha eka dUsarese sahAnubhUti rakhanevAle ina sAta nayoMke samudAyase padArthakI yathAvat vyavasthAko samyakatA aura isake viparIta arthAt ina sAtoM se apekSA rahita kisI eka hI nayase padArthakI vyavasthA ko jaina matameM mithyAtva kahA hai. jainadarzanakA anya darzanoM ke sAtha itane aMzameM hI vivAda hai ki, jainadarzana sarva nayoM (apekSA) se padArthakI vyavasthA karatA hai, aura anyadarzanakAra kisI eka hI nayase padArthakI vyavasthAko svIkAra kara rahe haiM. jaise bauddhadarzana AtmAko sarvathA kSaNika ( anitya ) aura vedAMtadarzana sarvathA nitya mAnatA hai ! paraMtu jainadarzanakA kathana hai ki, sarvathA kSaNika mAnanAbhI ThIka nahIM, aura sarvathA nitya mAnanA bhI ThIka nahIM, kiMtu kathaMcit nityAnitya ubhaya prakArase hI mAnanA ucita hai. arthAt dravyArthika nayakI apekSAse. yaha AtmA nitya, evaM ajara aura amara hai. tathA paryAyArthika

Page #33
25 nayakI apekSAse yaha AtmA Anitya, evaM pratikSaNa parivartanazIla hai| isI prakAra saMsArako bhI jainamatemeM dravya aura paryAyakI apekSAse anAdi anaMta aura sAdisAMta mAnA hai| vastumAtra jainamatameM dravya aura paryAya-sat asat-nityA nitya svarUpa hai| arthAt apane apane deza, kAla, svabhAvAdikI apekSAse sat aura anyake deza, kAla, svabhAvAdikI apekSAse asat hai / yathA-ghaTa, apane ghaTarUpase to sat hai, aura anya paTa rUpase asat hai| isI prakAra sadasat bhI hai / evaM pRthivI paramANu rUpakI apekSAse, nitya hai, ghaTa paTAdikI apekSAse anitya hai| isa prakAra padArthoM kI jo vyavasthA usako batalAne ke liye jainamatameM syAt zabda kA prayoga kiyA h| syAt yaha anekAMta kA dyotaka avyaya hai| isakA artha yathA kathaMcit-jisa kisI prakArase-athavA apekSAse aisA hotA hai| kadApi prazna kiyA jAve ki, amuka padArtha sat hai? to uttara milegA ki, syAt-kisI apekSAse isIkA nAma syAdvAda athavA anekAMtavAda hai| vastu sat hI hai, athavA asaMta hI hai, isa prakArake nizcaya athavA AgrahakA nAma ekAMta hai, isase viparIta arthAt padArtha kisI apekSAse sat aura kisI apekSAse asat bhI hai, isaprakArake kathanakA nAma anekAMtavAda hai. syAdvAdakI paddhatike anusAra padArthake svarUpako batalAnevAle mAtra sAta prakAra haiM. inameMse pratyeka prakArako bhaMga kahate haiM. ina sAtoMke samudAyako hI jainamatameM saptabhaMgI kahA hai.. . __ yathA-syAdasti, syAnnAsti, syAdasti nAsti, syAdavaktavyam, syAdasti cAvaktavyam, syAnnAsti .cAvaktavyam, syAdastinAsti caavktvym|| .

Page #34
26 arthAt - kisI apekSAse hai, kisI apekSAse nahIM kisI apekSAse hai aura nahIM, kisI apekSAse kahA nahIM * jA sakatA, kisI apekSAse hai para kathana karanA asaMbhava hai, kisI apekSAse nahIM para kahA nahIM jAtA, kisI apekSAse hai aura nahIM para kahA nahIM jA sakatA / sAdhAraNa rItise to jainoMkA yaha mata bar3A hI nIrasa, avyavasthita aura paraspara viruddha pratIta hotA hai ! paraMtu isapara kucha samaya vicAra karanese isakI sarasatA, suvyavasthA, evaM avirodhatAkA mahatva bar3I hI saralatAse samajha meM A jAtA hai / jaina darzanako isa viSaya meM pUrNa abhimAna hai ki, pariNAmameM duHkhakA hetu jo mithyA jJAna usase mukta honeke liye syAdvAda jaisA uttama sAdhana dUsarA koI nahIM ! aba hama isa siddhAMta ko thor3AsA spaSTa karake pAThakoMko dikhAte haiM / bahuta se logoM kA mata hai ki, jainoMkA "syAdasti-syAnAsti " ityAdi saptabhaMgI naya paraspara viruddha padArthoM kA eka sthAnameM samAveza kara rahA hai / ataH prakAza aura aMdhakArako eka sthAna meM samAviSTa karanevAlA yaha siddhAMta kevala unmatta pralApa mAtra hI hai ! isaliye aise siddhAMta ko apane hRdayameM sthAna denA sivA mUrkhatA ke aura kucha artha nahIM rakhatA ! paraMtu hamAre vicArameM unakA yaha kathana kevala bhrAMti mUlaka hai / kyoMki jainadarzanakA yaha siddhAMta hI nahIM hai / jaina darzanakA maMtavya hai ki, jo siddhAMta kisI eka prakAra ( apekSA ) se satya pratIta hotA hai usakA virodhI siddhAMta bhI kisI anya prakAra ( apekSA ) se satya ThaharatA . hai / jaise kisI vyaktimeM usake putrakI apekSAse pitA vyavahAra kiyA, paraMtu usakA virodhI usake pitAkI apekSAse usameM

Page #35
27 putra vyavahAra bhI ho sakatA hai| isa liye nirapekSa ( apekSAse rahita ) eka vyaktimeM paraspara viruddha pitA aura putrakA vyavahAra karanA jaina dharmake maMtavyase sarvathA bAhya hai| kiMtu kisI apekSAse eka vyaktimeM bhI paraspara viruddha pitA aura putra vyavahAra ho sakatA hai| eka hI devadattameM apane pitA aura putrako apekSAse putra aura pitAke vyavahArakA honA Upara vatalA diyA gayA hai / isI bAtako spaSTa rUpase batalAneke liye jaina darzanameM " asti nAsti" Adi pratyeka bhaMgameM syAt ( kathaMcit-kisI prakAra kisI-apekSA ) zabdakA prayoga kiyA hai / aura yaha siddhAMta sarvamAnya hai / jainazAstroMmeM isI hetuse isako *sAvaMtAMtrika (sarvadarzanomeM honevAlA) siddhAMta batalAyA hai| syAdasti ghaTA-kisI eka prakArase dhaTa hai, syAnAsti ghaTa:-kisI eka prakArase ghaTa nahIM hai / ina donoMkA hamako yahI artha karanA hogA ki, ghaTa apane ghaTa svarUpase hai, aura paTa svarUpase nahIM hai / yadi paTa svarUpase bhI ghaTakA astitva mAnA jAya taba to ghaTa aura paTa donoM eka ho jAveMge, aura bheda vyavahArakA uccheda hI ho jaavegaa| jaba ki hama, kisI apekSAse pratyeka padArthameM astitva aura nAstitvakA pratipAdana kara sakate haiM, to isase arthAt siddha huA ki, kisI apekSAse padArtha asti nAsti ubhaya rUpa bhI hai / isI bAtako sphuTa karaneke liye syAdasti nAsti ghaTaH kisI prakArase ghaTa hai aura nahIM / yaha tIsarA prakAra kathana kiyA gayA hai| * truvANA bhinnabhinnArthAnnayabhedavyapekSayA / pratikSipeyunoM vedAH, : syAdvAdaM sArvatAMtrikam // . . [yazovijayopAdhyAyAH] : .

Page #36
vizvake yAvat padArtha, dravya aura paryAyakI apekSAse asti aura nAsti zabdase vyavahRta kiye jA sakate haiM, paraMtu asti aura nAsti rUpa virodhI svabhAvoMkA yugapat eka hI samayameM kathana karanA asaMbhava hai, isa rahasyako samajhAneke liye syAdavaktavyam (kisI eka prakArase kahA nahIM jA sakatA) isa caturtha bhaMgakA ullekha kiyA / evaM avaziSTa tIna maMga bhI kisI apekSAko lekara asti nAsti aura avaktavya ina tIna padoMke saMyogase banAye gaye haiN| inakA savistara sapramANa varNana hama kahIM anyatra kreNge| . "svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatIjI". jo saptabhaMgakio anyonyAbhAva ke aMtarniviSTa karanA, batalAte haiM isake viSaya meM hama pUchate haiM ki, pRthivItvakI apekSAse ghaTa paTa kI ekatA aura ghaTatva tathA paTatvakI apekSAse unakI minnatAko jisa prakAra sthAvAda apanI paddhatise vatalA rahA hai, kyA isa prakA- . rase ghaTa aura paTake paraspara sarvathA bhedakA vyavasthApaka anyonyAbhAva, bhedAbhedakA samarthana kara sakatA hai ? hAM! yadi "svAmIjI" kA anyonyAbhAva hI kisI dUsare prakArakA ho, tabato hama kucha kaha nahIM skte| . jIva aura jaDake vartamAna honese "sAdharmya" (ekatA) aura cetanaM tathA jaDa honese " vaidharmya" ( bhinnatA )" ityAdi lekhase jaDa cetanake paraspara bheda aura abhedako sAdharmya vaidharmya nAmase kahate hue to " svAmI jI " syAdvAdakI spaSTatA aura saralatAko bar3e hI abhimAnase svIkAra kara rahe haiM / / hAM ! syAdvAdakA nAma lenese yadi ve kalaMkita hote hoM to hama vivaza haiM ! eka tarpha to padArthako kuTila batalAnA aura dUsarI tarpha usakI: saralatAko spaSTa svIkAra bhI .

Page #37
karanA ! pAThako ! kSamA kIjiye yaha unmattapanA nahIM to aura kyA hai ? ___" svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatI aura jagat ?' 'satyArtha prakAza pRSTha 4 15 se 418 takameM "dayAnaMda sarasvatIjI " ne jagatkA kA Izvara hai isa viSayakA bahutasA rAga AlApana kiyA hai ! yadi " svAmIjI mahArAja " jainoMke mAnanIya siddhAMta 'graMthoMke. vAkyoMko uddhRta karake unakI samIkSA karate to kyA hI acchA hotA ! paraMtu "svAmIjI" ke graMthameM to prakaraNa ratnAkara, ratnasAra, vivekasAra Adi tIna cAra bhASAke graMthoMkA hI nAma dekhane meM AtA hai ! ye graMtha jainoMke koI sarvamAnya siddhAMta graMtha nahIM haiM. inameMbhI " svAmIjI ne kitanI bhUleM khAI haiM, yaha pAThakoMko Age vidita hogaa| yadi "svAmIjI" jainoMke--sammatitarka, syAdvAdamaMjarI, syAdvAdaratnAkarAvatArikA---pramANanayatattvAlokAlaMkAra vRtti, syAdvAdakalpalatA---zAstravA samuccayavRtti, anekAMtajayapatAkA, khaMDanakhaMDakhAdya-mahAvIrastotra, SaDdarzanasamuccaya prabhRti graMthoMke pUrvapakSoMko uddhata karake jainadharmake siddhAMtakI samAlocanA karate to avazya hI hama unake pAMDitya para phUle na samAte ! paraMtu "svAmIjI ne to sAdhAraNa bhASAke saMgraha graMthoMmeM hI apane pAMDityakI gar3haDIko. kholakara janasAdhAraNako usakA paricaya de diyA hai! . ... sajjano ! Izvara jagatkA kartA hai yA ki, nahIM ?. isa viSayameM prAcIna samayase hI vivAda calA AtA hai ! saba darzanoMkA isameM ekamata nahIM | sAMkhya aura mImAMsA darzana, Izvara gha- mahAsamuccayavanikAlakAra ra

Page #38
kartatvake sivA Izvarake astitvakA bhI virodhI hai ! mImAMsA darzanameM phirase jiMdagI DAlanevAle "kumArila bhaTTa" ne to isa prakArase IzvarakartRtvakAHprativAda kiyA hai ki, "udayanAcArya" prabhRti usakA lezamAtra bhI khaMDana nahIM kara ske| patyurasAmaMjasyAt isa vyAsasUtra ke bhAgyameM "svAmI zaMkarAcArya" kA bhI IzvarakartRtva (nimittakAraNa ) ke prativAdakA lekha dekhane yogya hai ! kyA hI acchA hotA jo "svAmI dayAnaMdasarasvatIjI" vRthA hI jainadharmake viSayameM apane pAMDityakI DugaDugI na pITakara, prathama Izvara kartRtvake viSayameM diye hue kumArila aura zaMkarasvAmIke doSoMkA uddhAra kara batAte ! svArthI tathA kadAgrahI logoMne bhadrajana samAjakA " jagatkA Izvara:-apauruSeyA vedAH" ina do bAtoMmeM itanA aMdha vizvAsa bar3hA rakkhA hai ki, inake samakSa inapara vicAra to kyA, koI cUM taka nahIM kara sakatA ! kadApi koI bhUla kara inake viSayameM kucha likha baiThatA hai to usake lekhapara kucha bhI vicAra kiye binA hI usako pApI, durAtmA aura nAstika kahakara cillAne lagate haiN!| bicAre kyA kareM ? briTiza sarakArakA rAjya hai ! nahIM to " svAmI dayAnandajI" ke kathanAnusAra inakI kRpAse usako kAlApAnI avazya hI dekhanA par3e ! Izvara jagatkA kA hai ki nahIM ? yaha viSaya bar3A hI vistRta aura gaMbhIra hai ! isa para svataMtra lekhadvArA hama kahIM anyatra avazya vicAra kareMge ! yadi isa sthAnameM hI isa viSayako carcA jAve to isa puSpakA AkAra bahuta bar3ha jaavegaa| kyoMki svAmIjIke lekhake sivA anya bhI isa viSayase saMbaMdha rakhane vAlI bahutasI bAteM haiM jina para vicAra karanA bahuta Avazyaka hai ! yahAM para hama sirpha itanA hI pAThakoMse nivedana

Page #39
karate haiM ki, jagatkA kA Izvara hai isa bAtako kalpanA mAtra jaina, bauddha, tathA sAMkhya aura mImAMsA darzanameM hI nahIM batalAyA ! kiMtu"ko dadarza prathamaM jAyamAnamanvasthaM yadanasthA bibhAti / sumyA asurasRgAtmAkvasitko vidvAMsamupAgAtpaSTumetat // [1-164-1] . yaha RgvedakA maMtra bhI sRSTikI utpatti kathAko kalpanA prasUta hI batalA rahA hai ! / astu / isa viSayako anyatra likhaneke liye hama pratijJA baddha hote hue "svAmIjI" ke Ageke lekha para pAThakoMkA dhyAna baiMcate hai. [ka] __ svA0 da0-aba jaina loga jagatko jaisA mAnate haiM vaisA inake sUtroMke anusAra dikhalAte haiM. mUla--*sAmi aNAI aNante canugaI saMsAra ghora kAntare / mohAi kamma guru Thii vivAgavasanu bhamaI jIvaro // prakaraNa ratnAkara bhAga dUsarA.2 SaSThI zataka 60 suutr2|| yaha ratnasAra bhAga nAmaka graMthake samyakatva prakAza prakaraNameM gautama aura mahAvIrakA sambAda hai // [pRSTha 419] (kha) isakA saMkSepase upayogI yaha artha hai ki yaha saMsAra anAdi anaMta hai na kabhI isakI utpatti huI na kabhI vinAza hotA hai arthAt kisIkA banAyA jagat nahIM so hI Astika nAstikake saMvAdameM he mUr3ha ! jagatkA kartA koI nahIM na kabhI * yaha prAkRta zloka adhikAMza azuddha hai. isakA zuddha pATha Age likhA jAvegA.

Page #40
32 banA aura na kabhI nAza hotA / ( samIkSaka ) jo saMyogase utpanna hotA hai vaha anAdi aura anaMta kabhI nahIM ho sakatA / aura utpatti tathA vinAza hue binA karma nahIM rahatA jagat meM jitane padArtha utpanna hote haiM ve saba saMyogaja utpatti vinAza vAle punaH jagatutpanna aura vinAza vAlA kyoM nahIM ? isa liye tumhAre tIrthaMkaroMko samyag bodha nahIM thA jo unako samyag jJAna hotA to aisI asaMbhava bAteM kyoM likhate ? ityAdi ( pRSTha 419 ) [ ka ] dekhe jAte haiM samAlocakka---"svAmIjI" pratijJA to yaha karate haiM ki, "inake sUtroM ke anusAra dikhalAte haiM" aura nAma lete haiM "prakaraNa ratnAkareM" aura "ratnasAra" AdikA ! phira Uparake prAkRta padyako likhA to hai " SaSThIzataka" kA aura batalAte haiM "ratnasAra" (joki bhASA ke vAkyoMkA saMgraha hai) ke "samyaktva prakAza" kA ! phira dekhanekA yaha hai ki, "prakaraNaratnAkara" ( jo ki bahutase stotra Adi graMthoMse prakAzakakA saMgRhIta hai. ) aura " ratnasAra " ina donoM graMthoMmeM " samyaktvaprakAza " nAmakA koI prakaraNa hI nahIM ! " svAmIjI " ne " paSThIzatakako " sUtra ( Agama ) graMtha batalAyA paraMtu jainoMke kisI bhI sUtra ( Agama ) graMthameM isakA ullekha nahIM ! aura sAthahI AnaMdakI bAta yaha hai ki, SaSThIzatakameM ukta prAkRta zlokakI gaMdhamAtra taka nahIM hai ! samyaktvaprakAza prakaraNameM gautama aura mahAvIra svAmIkA saMvAda hai " svAmIjI " " svAmIjI " kA yaha lekha to niHsaMdeha unakI 'jainadharma saMbaMdhI vijJatApara pratikSaNa AMsU vahA rahA hai ! hama nahIM kaha sakate ki, "svAmI dayAnaMdajI " kisa Azaya se jaina matake khaMDanameM pravRtta hue haiM !!

Page #41
33 [ kha ] " svAmIjI " ne jo Upara likhe prAkRta zlokakA upayogI artha batalAyA hai vaha " svAmIjI " ke lie to upayogI ThIka ho sakatA hai ! anyathA unake manamAne nirbala AkSepakI dAla nahIM gala sakatI ! | " jo saMyogase utpanna hotA hai vaha anAdi anaMta kabhI nahIM ho sakatA " isapara hama pUchate haiM ki, yaha jagat kisake saMyoga se utpanna huA ? yadi paramANuoMke saMyoga se isakI utpatti kahoge to, prathama paramANu vibhakta dazAmeM ( jude jude ) the, yaha avazya svIkAra karanA hogA ! saMyogake nAzaka ( nAza karanevAle ) guNakA nAma vibhAga hai / isa liye vibhAgase prathama bhI paramANuoM kA saMyoga thA, yaha avazya mAnanA par3egA ! isI taraha saMyoga se pUrva vibhAga, aura vibhAga se pUrva saMyoga / isa saMyoga vibhAgakI paraMparAko anAdi mAne vinA chuTakArA honA asaMbhava hai / evaM saMyoga aura vibhAga paraMparAkI kahIM sarvathA samApti ho jAya yaha bhI asaMbhava haiM / isaliye anAdikI taraha isako anaMta ( aMtarahita ) bhI svIkAra karanA hI par3egA / isI liye bhagavAn zrI kRSNacaMdra kahate haiM ki- "nAMto na cAdirna ca sampratiSThA " [gItA. a. 15. zlo. 2. 19. lo. 2. ] arthAt isa saMsArakA na koI Adi hai, na aMta hai / tathA" ko addhA veda ka iha prAvocat kuta AyAtA iyaM visRSTiH / arvAg devA asya visarjane nAthA ko veda yataH AbabhUva // " [maM0 10 sU 129] yaha RgvedakI zruti bhI saMsArakI anAdi anaMtatA ko spaSTa batalA rahI hai / evaM " na karmavibhAgAditi cennAnAditvAt / upapadyate cApyupalabhyate ca " [vedAMtadarzana. a. 2. pA. 1

Page #42
1. sU. 35-36.] ina do sUtroM dvArA "maharSi vedavyAsajI" . bhI saMsArako anAdi kaha rahe haiN| dUsare sUtrake bhApyameM "svAmI zaMkarAcAryajI" likhate haiM ki-"upalabhyate ca saMsArasyAnAditvaM zrutismRtyo" arthAt zruti aura smRtimeM saMsArako anAdi batAyA gayA hai| "svAmI dayAnaMdajI" RgavedAdibhASya bhUmikAke pRSTha 23 meM-isa saMsArako utpanna hue (1960852976) itane varSe batalAte haiM / hama pUchate haiM ki, isase prathama yaha duniyA nahIM thI, isakA "svAmIdayAnaMdajI ke pAsa kyA pramANa haiM ? itane varSoM ke pahile yadi kucha nahIM thA to phira yaha AyA kahAMse ? yadi kaho ki, yaha jagat usavakta isa rUpameM (jaisA ki isa vakta dekhA jAtA hai) nahIM thA, kiMtu sUkSma (kAraNa) rUpameM thaa| hama pUchate haiM ki, prathama yaha sUkSma rUpa kyoM banA ? kyA isako sthUla rUpa burA lagatA thA ? yadi sthUlase sUkSma aura sUkSmase sthUla honA padArthakA dharma hI hai, to phira IzvarakA isameM kyA saMbaMdha hai ? yadi kaho ki, Izvara karatA hai, to hama pUchate haiM ki, kyoM karatA hai? kyA Izvarase yaha kAma kiye binA rahA nahIM jAtA ? yadi kaho ki, sRSTiko uptanna karanA aura nAza karanA usakA svabhAva hI hai, to, isapara hama kahate haiM ki, isa prakArakA IzvarakA svabhAva hai isameM bhI kyA pramANa ? yadi koI kahe ki, sRSTikI utpatti aura nAzake bakher3e se sadaiva mukta rahanA hI IzvarakA svabhAva hai, taba u sameM kyA kahA jA sakatA hai| "utpatti tathA vinAza hue vinA karma nahIM rahatA" ityAdi lekhase na mAlUma " svAmIjI " jainoMpara kyA AkSepa karanA cAhate haiM ? kyA jaina karma (kriyA)ko anitya nahIM mAnate ? jaina matameM to dravya aura paryAyakI apekSAse

Page #43
35 sabhI padArtha nityAnitya arthAt utpatti vinAza aura sthiti vAle mAne haiM / sajjano ! vicArase dekhA jAya to "svAmI dayAnaMdajI" isameM adhika dopake bhAgI nahIM | kyoM ki, jaina siddhAMta se ve paricita nahIM the ! jaina darzanakA unako itanA hI jJAna thA jitanA ki saMskRta sAhityakA bhAravAhika eka grAmINako hotA hai ! zoka kevala itanA hI hai ki, " svAmIjI " jaina dharma rahasya ko samajhe vinA hI usake khaMDanameM pravRtta ho gaye ! aisA karane se niHsaMdeha manuSya madhyastha jana samAjameM upahAsakA pAtra hotA hai ! isI hetuse yadi koI svAmIjI ke liye "vicchUkA maMtra AtA nahIM aura sAMpa pakar3ane dor3ate haiM" isa lokoktikA. kathana kare to, sacamuca hI hama uttara dene meM asamartha haiM ! , saMsAra ke liye jaina dharmakA maMtavya hai ki aisA koI bhI samaya nahIM thA, jaba ki sarvathA isakA abhAva huA ho; aura nAhI aisA koI samaya AvegA, jaba ki isakA sarvathA astitva na rahe / kiMtu yaha pravAha rUpase sadA hI aisA calA AtA hai aura aisA hI calA jAyegA. isIliye isako anAdi ( Adi rahita ) anaMta ( aMta rahita ) kahane meM AtA hai. saMsArake pratyekaM padArthameM parivartana ( pheraphAra ) dekhane meM AtA hai, isaliye yaha utpatti vinAzavAlA bhI hai; isI hetuse isako sAdi sAMta bhI kahA jAtA hai. aba hama usI prAkRta zlokako yahAM para phirase zuddha likhakara usakA artha karake pAThakoM ko batalAte haiM, jisakA artha karate hue "svAmIjI " ko jainoM kA jagatkA anAdi mAnanA acchA nahIM lagA ! " sAmi aNAi anaMte, cau gai saMsAra ghora kaMtAre | mohAi kampraguruThii - vivAgatrasao bhamai jIvo // "

Page #44
36 sajjano ! yaha samyaktvasAra nAmake choTese prAkRta graMthakA dUsarA zloka hai, paramArtha - tatvakA vicAra karanevAle jIvameM vairAgya garbhita prathama kisa prakArakI bhAvanA hotI hai graMthakArane paramAtmAkI stutidvArA isa bAtakA varNana isa lokadvArA kiyA hai. isakA artha yaha hai ki, he svAmin ! cAra prakArakI (deva, manuSya, naraka aura tiryak ) gatirUpa anAdi anaMta ghora jaMgakake samAna isa saMsAra meM mohanIya Adi karmoMkI utkRSTa sthitike vipAka ( phala ) ke vazase yaha jIva bhramaNa kara rahA hai ! arthAt karmoM ke pariNAma vazase yaha jIva manuSya, pazu Adi aneka janmoMko dhAraNa karatA huA isa saMsArameM bhramaNa kara rahA ! | aba hama apane pAThakoMse nivedana karate haiM ki, isa loka meM kyA burAI hai ? jo isapara "svAmInI" ne itanA hallA macAyA ! ! kyA saMsAra meM aisA koI Astika puruSa ( cAhe vo kisI dharmako mAnanevAlA ho ! ) hai ? jo isa kathanakA virodhI ho ! hAM ! yadi " svAmIjI "ko jainoMke nAmase hI cir3ha hai to unakA (jaina graMthoMkA) kyA doSa ? kyoMki netroMke honepara hI sUryakA prakAza kAma meM AsakatA hai ! kathana hai ki, jisakI Adi nahIM aura nAhI kabhI aMta honevAlA hai aise Adi aura aMtase zUnya isa saMsAra samudra meM zubhAzubha karmoM ke prabhAvase bhramaNa karate hue isa jIvako anaMta pudgalaparAvartta kAla vyatIta ho cukA hai, aura hogA, jabataka ki yaha jIva; jJAna darzana aura cAritrarUpa tatrayakI ArAdhanA se samasta karma kA kSayaH karake mokSako prApta nahIM hotA ! pyAre sabhya pAThako ! jainoMkA AAD 'jaina graMthoM meM pudgalaparAvartta kAlakA- parimANaM isa prakArase batalAyA hai / nitAMta sUkSmakAlakA nAma samayaM haiM, asaMkhya . .

Page #45
37 samayoMkI eka AvalI hotI hai, 16777216 AvalIkA eka muhUrtta hotA hai, aise tIsa muhattau kA eka dina, paMdraha dina kA eka pakSa, do pakSakA eka mAsa, evaM bAraha mAsakA eka 1 varSa hotI hai / caurAsI lAkha varSakA eka pUrvAMga aura itane - hI pUrvAMgoM ke milanese eka pUrva kahAtA hai / asaMkhya pUrvakA eka palyopama, aura daza koTAkoTI palyopamakA eka sAgaropama, evaM daza koTAkoTI sAgaropamakI eka avasarpiNI, tathA daza koTAkoTI sAgaropamakI eka utsarpiNI, ina donoM ke milane se arthAt vasi koTAkoTI sAgaropamakA eka kAlacakra hotA hai / aise anaMta kAlacakra kA eka pudgalaparAvarta hotA hai| * isa viSaya meM jainoMkI dillagI ur3Ate hue hamAre . " svAmI mahodaya " likhate haiM-" suno bhAI ! gaNita vidyAvAle logoM 1 jainiyoMke graMthoM kI kAla saMkhyA kara sakoge vA nahIM ? aura tuma inako saca bhI mAna saMkoge vA nahIM ? dekho inake tIrthakaroMne aisI gaNita vidyA par3hI thii| aise2 to inake matameM guru aura ziSya haiM jinakI avidyAkA kucha pArAvAra nahIM / " [satyArtha prakAza pRSTha 420 ] " [samAlocaka ] "svAmIjI" ke kathanAnusAra thor3I derake lie hama yahI mAna lete haiM ki, jainoM ko kAla saMkhyAkA jJAna nahIM thA ! inhoMne gaNita vidyA nahIM par3hI thI / inake guru buddhimAna nahIM the! paraMtu 'svAmIjI' to sarva vidyAmeM nipuNa aura gaNita vidyAke * lokaprakAza nAmake jaina graMthake ' kAlaloka prakAza ' nAmake tRtIya prakaraNameM isa viSayakA sapramANa bar3e hI vistArase nirUpaNa kiyA hai, vizeSa jijJAsu vahAMpara dekhanekI avazya kRpA kareM / 'isake dekhanese pAThakoMko yaha bhI bAta acchI taraha mAlUma ho jAyaMgI ki, " svAmI dayAnaMdajI "" kA isa saMbaMdha meM kiyA huA jaina tIrthaMkaroMkA upahAsya kahAM taka satya hai 1 . * 4

Page #46
38 pAragAmI haiM ! astu ! hama inakI hI sevAmeM kAlakI saMkhyAkA parimANa samajhane ke lie prArthanA karate haiM ! kRpayA hamako " svAmIjI " hI samajhA deveM ki, kAlakI yahAM taka hI iti hai ! isake Age bar3hane ke lie "svAmIjI " kI AjJA nahIM ! paraMtu "svAmIjI mahArAja" to mara gaye ! vahAMse Akara hamako- kAlakI saMkhyAkA parimANa batAveM itanI to AzA nahIM ! unakI banAI huI pothiyoM ko ulaTA pulaTA kara dekhate haiM to vo bhI bicArI vidhavA striyoMkI taraha unhIkA nAma cillA 2 kara le rahI haiM ! unako vidhAtAse bhI eka phUTa UMcA mAnanevAle samAjI mahAzaya kadApi unako patra likheM to saMbhava hai ki, unapara ve uttara likhanekI kRpA kareM ! ki, (1960852976) varSapara kAlakI saMkhyAkA kIlA gAr3a denA ! yadi koI kahe ki, isase prathama bhI kAlato thA, to usako kaha denA tUM mUrkha hai ! tereko kucha bhI khabara nahIM ! yaha dekha " svAmIjI mahArAja" ke hAthakA likhA huA patra ! jo ki unhoMne abhI hI bhejA hai ! 1 sajjano ! dinake bAda rAtri, aura rAtrike bAda dina, yaha cakra anAdikAla se calA AtA hai, aura isI taraha calA AvegA / saMsAra meM pratidina asaMkhya prANI marate haiM, aura masaMkhya hI utpanna hote haiM / isa janma maraNakI paraMparAkA patA lagAnA itanA hI asaMbhava hai, jitanI ki oMkI gaNanA karanI ! samaya pravAhase isakI saMkhyA na kisIne kI, aura na jo kucha bhI isake parimANake viSayameM voha kevala jijJAsuko vastutattvake bodha gayA hai / isI taraha ekase lekara parArddha samudrake jala biMduanAdi anaMta hai, koI kara sakegA / zAstrakAroMne likhA hai, karavAne ke lie likhA paryaMta jo gaNita '

Page #47
39 zAstrameM saMkhyAkI sImA bAMdhI hai usakA bhI tAtparya yahI hai ki, yahAM taka kI saMkhyAko ima kathamapi vyavahArameM lA sakate haiM / isase adhika saMkhyA nahIM, yaha kadApi nahIM kaha sakate / kUpakA meMDaka yadi samudra jalakI agAdhatAko na svIkAra kare to samudra jalakI agAdhatA kabhI naSTa hone nahIM lgii| itanA kahakara hama " svAmIjI " ko hRdaya se dhanyavAda dete haiM, jo ki samasta dharmAcAryoM ko mUrkha batAnevAle Apa bhAratameM akele hI anUThe vidvAn paidA hue ! jainamata meM samasta jIvoM ko saMsArI aura mukta ina do vargImeM vibhakta kiyA hai. saMsArI jIva sthAvara aura tasa bhedase -do prakAra ke haiM. ina domeMse pRthivI, jala, teja, vAyu, aura vanaspati, ye pAMca sthAvara kahalAte haiM. inase bhinnakI trasa saMjJA : haiM. pRthivyAdi pAMca aura tasa ina hai ko hI jainamata meM paTakAya kahA hai. pRthivI jina jIvoMkA zarIra hai usako pRthivIkAya kahate haiM. aise hI jalAdi cArameM bhI samajha lenA. yahAM para itanA smaraNa avazya rakhanA cAhiye ki, vaizeSika darzana ke praNetA maharSi kaNAdane vanaspati (kaMda, mUla, vRkSa, puSpa latA, gulmAdi) ko pRthivI ke aMtargata mAnakara - pRthivI, jala, vAyu, agni, ina cAroMmese vanaspatiko chor3a bAkI kisI ko bhI sajIva nahIM mAnA ! anya darzanakA kA bhI bahudhA yahI mata hai | paraMtu jainadarzanakA siddhAMta isase pratikUla hai / jaina matameM to vanaspatiko pRthivI se bhinna, tathA ina pRthivI Adi pAMcoMko sajIva mAnA hai / arthAt jIvoMne paramANuoM ko grahaNa kara karmoM ke nimittase asaMkhya zarIroMkA jo piMDa racA hai vahI 'pRthivyAdi pAMca kAya kar3e jAte haiM. inako sajIva siddha karane ke liye jainagraMthoM meM bahutase pramANoMkA ullekha kiyA huA hai.

Page #48
40 unakA yahAMpara ullekha karanA kucha Avazyaka nahIM hai / samaya Anepara kahIM anyatra kiyA jAvegA unapara vicAra karake satyAsatyakA nirNaya karanA madhyasthavargakA karttavya hai. asako jIvamAnana meM to kisIko bhI vivAda nahIM / pRthivyAdi pAMca kAyake jIva ekeMdriya kahe jAte haiM. arthAt sparza Adi pAMca iMdriyoMmeMse inameM eka sparza iMdriya hI hotI hai ! inake zarIra pramANa aura AyumAnakA jaina graMthoM meM isaprakAra varNana kiyA hai| U pRthivyAdi cAra kAyake zarIrakA pramANa aMgulakA asaMkhya bhAga arthAt bahuta sUkSma hai. pRthiva kAyake jIvakA Ayu nyUnase nyUna aMtarmuhUrta ( do ghar3Ise kucha thor3A kAla ) aura adhikase adhika 22 sahasra varSakA ho sakatA hai / evaM z2alakAyake jIvakA AyumAna nyUnase nyUna aMtarmuhUrtta aura adhika se adhika sAta hajAra varSakA ho sakatA hai / tathA abhi kAyake jIvakA Ayu nyUnase nyUna jala jitanA aura adhikase adhika tIna dinakA / vAyukAyake jIvakA Ayu pramANa bhI kamase kama aMtarmuhUrttakA aura adhikase adhika tIna hajAra varSakA ho sakatA hai / vanaspatike sAdhAraNa aura pratyeka ye do bheda haiM, . sAdhAraNa meM kaMdamUlAdikI gaNanA hai aura pratyekase vRkSAdi grahaNa kiye jAte haiM / sAdhAraNa vanaspatikA zarIramAna pRthivyAdike samAna hai aura AyukA pramANa aMtarmuhUrta mAtra hai / pratyeka vanaspatikA zarIrapramANa thoDese. thor3A pRthivyAdi jitanA aura adhika se adhika eka sahasra yojana takakA ho sakatA hai| Ayu isakA nyUnase nyUna aMtarmuhUrta aura adhikase adhika daza.. sahasra varSakA ho sakatA hai / madhyakAlakA kucha niyama nahIM, cAhe eka dinakA cAhe daza varSakA ho. sakAyake dvIMdriya, trIMdriya, caturiMdriya aura paMceMdriya ye cAra bheda haiM. jinake sparza aura rasanA ye do iMdriya hoveM ve dvIMdriya kahAte *

Page #49
haiM. jaise-jalaukA, pUre, kASTa kITa, viSTAke kITa, gaMDoye aura samudrameM utpanna honevAle zaMkha, kaur3I, zukti Adi. inakA Ayu nyUnase nyUna aMtarmuhUrta aura adhikase adhika dvAdaza varSa takakA ho sakatA hai / zarIramAna nyUnase nyUna pRthivIke jIva jitanA aura adhikase adhika dvAdaza yojana / trIdriya usako kahate haiM, jisake-sparza, rasanA aura ghrANa ye tIna iMdriya hoM / inameM aneka prakArakI pipIlikA (kIr3I) yUkA, likSA, mAkar3a, iMdrakITa ( vIrabahuTI) AdikI gaNanA kI jAtI hai| inake AyukA pramANa nyUnase nyUna aMtarmuhUrtakA aura adhikase adhika 49 dinakA hosakatA hai / madhya AyukI sthitikA kucha niyama nahIM / inakA zarIra pramANa kamase kama pRthivyAdike jIva jitanA aura adhikase adhika tIna kosakA ho sakatA hai| madhyama pramANakI sthiti nahIM / evaM sparza, rasanA, prANaM aura cakSu ina cAra iMdriyoMse jo yukta ho usako caturidriya kahA hai / makkhI, macchara, bhramara, pataMga, bicchu Adi jIva caturidriyameM gine jAte haiM / inakA AyumAna bhI nyUnase nyUna aMtarmahUrtakA hai aura adhikase adhika cha mAsakA hosakatA hai| evaM inakA zarIra nyUnase nyUna aMgulIkA asaMkhya bhAga aura adhikase adhika eka yojanakA hosakatA hai / madhyama zarIrake parimANakA kucha niyama nahIM, cAhe kitanA ho / jinake pAMcavIM zrotra iMdriya hove ve paMceMdriya jIva kahe jAte haiM / inameM manuSya, pazu, pakSI AdikI gaNanA kI jAtI hai / inakA AyumAna tathA zarIramAna evaM avAMtara bheda jainazAstrameM judA judA likhA huA hai / yahAMpara yadi una sabakA ullekha kiyA jAya to bahuta vistAra ho jAya / yahAM para to utanA hI likhanA Avazyaka samajhA hai ki, jitaneko 'svAmIdayAnaMdajI'..

Page #50
42 ne ratnasAra graMthakA nAma lekara apanI icchA ke anukUla uddhRta karake jaina dharma ke netAoMko mUrkha banAyA hai ! sajjano ! hamane jainoMkA jo maMtavya Upara dikhAyA hai, vaha bhinna bhinna vAkyoM dvArA ratnasAra graMtha meM bhI likhA huA hai / usIko kucha pecIdAsA likhakara " svAmI dayAnaMdajI " kahate haiM ki " ar3atAlIsa kosakI sthala jUM jainiyoM ke zarI paDatI hogI aura unhoMne dekhI bhI hogI aurakA bhAgya kahAM jo itanI bar3I jUMMko dekheM !!! aura dekho unakA aMdhAdhuMdha vIchU bagAI kasArI aura makkhI eka yojanake zarIravAle hote haiM inakA AyumAna adhika se adhika chaH mahaneikA hai / dekho bhAI ! cAra2 koMsakA vIchU anya kisIne dekhA na hogA jo ATha mIla takakA zarIravAlA vIhUM aura makkhI bhI jainiyoMke matameM hotI haiM / aise vIchU aura makkhI unhoke gharameM rahate hoMge aura unhoMne dekhe hoMge anya ki sIne saMsAra meM nahIM dekhe hoMge kabhI aise vIlU kisI jainiko kATate hoMge to kyA hotA hogA ?" ityAdi [ satyArthaprakAza pRSTha 421 ] Age pRSTha 422 meM " kyA yaha mahA jhUTha bAta nahIM ki jisakA ho sake ! ||" ityAdi. kadApi saMbhava na -- * samAlocaka - "svAmI jI" kA - "aDatAlIsa kosakI sthUla jUM jainiyoM ke zarIra meM par3atI hogI" likhanA sabhyatA aura satyatAkI sImAko sarvathA ullaMghana kara rahA hai ! jainathoMmeM aDatAlIsa kosakI jU~kA ullekha kahIM dekhane meM nahIM AtA ! hama pAThakoM ko Upara bata lA cuke haiM ki, tIna iMdriyavAle jo jIva haiM una kA zarIra nyUnase lAMke asaMkhya bhAga jitanA aura adhika se adhika kA mAnA hai / arthAt tIna iMdriyavAlA jIva choTese choTA to jaina mata meM nyUna aMgutIna kosa

Page #51
aMgulI ke asaMkhya bhAga (anumAna naiyAyikoMke mAne hue vyaNuka) jitanA aura yadi bar3e se bar3A hoto tIna kosake vistAra jitanA ho sakatA hai, usake madhya parimANakA kucha niyama nhiiN| cAhe eka tila jitanA ho, cAhe caNe jitanA ho, cAhe aMgula parimANakA ho, cAhe hAtha bharakA ho| tIna iMdriyavAle jIva kitane haiM isakI saMkhyA to na koi kara sakA aura na kara sakegA | kyA "svAmIjI" inakI iyattA batalA sakeMge ? tIna iMdriyavAle jIva kaunase haiM ? isameM cyUTI, jUM, khaTamala AdikA nidarzana mAtra jaina darzanameM batalA diyA gayA hai, tIna iMdriyavAle yAvat jIva haiM unameMse yadi koi bar3ese bar3A ho to itane pramANa takakA ho sakatA hai, isa kathanakA Azaya na mAlUma "svAmIjI ne yaha kaise nikAla liyA ki, aDatAlIsa kosakI jUM jainiyoM ke zarIrameM par3atI hogI ! isI taraha cAra kosakA vachUi ityAdi lekha bhI "svAmIjI" ne kucha samajha kara likhA ho aisA pratIta nahIM hotA! kyoMka, cAra kosakA vichU hotA hai aisAullekha jaina graMthoM meM dekhane meM nahIM AtA ! jaina graMthoMmeM to kevala itanA ullekha pAyA jAtA hai ki, cAra iMdriyavAle jIvoMmese yadi koI bar3ese bar3A jaMtu ho to itanA ho sakatA hai. eka hI jAtike jIvoMme nyUnAdhikya pratyakSa dekhanemeM AtA hai ! bakarI aura hastIke zarIrameM kitanA aMtara hai ? yaha sabhake pratyakSa hai, paraMtu pAMca iMdriyavAle jIvoMme ina donoMkI hI samAna gaNanA hai ! evaM billI aura siMha, tathA cir3I aura bAja ityAdi aneka jIvoMmeM pratyakSa mahAn aMtara dekhane para bhI inakA grahaNa paMceMdriyameM kiyA jAtA hai. yadi koI kahe ki-cUhA, billI, cir3I, kabUtara, bakarI Adi pAMca iMdriyavAle jIva haiM, inakA zarIra do iMca, aura adhikase adhika

Page #52
44 . . paMdraha phUTakI hotA hai to kyA " svAmIjI " ke kathanAnusAra isakA yaha artha karanA cAhiye ki, likhanevAlA paMdraha phUTakI / cir3I athavA billI yA kabUtara batalAtA hai ? nahIM ! kadApi nahIM / likhanevAlA spaSTa batalA rahA hai ki, paMceMdriya jIvoM meM aise bhI kitaneka jIva haiM jo ki do iMcake ho aura aise bhI / haiM ki jinakA paMdraha phUTakA zarIra hotA hai, jaise hastI aadi| jAnavara. isI prakAra jaina graMthoMke ullekhakA Azaya samajhanAM cAhiye / arthAt caturidriya jIva yadi koI bar3ese bar3A hoM to vo eka yojana takakA ho sakatA hai, paraMtu vaha bhI makkhI yA macchara athavA vichU hI ho yaha niyama nahIM. kalpanA karo ki, kisIne kahA ki manuSyAdi prANI nyUnase nyUna eka saiphaMDa aura adhikase adhika so varSa takakA Ayu bhoga sakate haiM, to kyA isakA yaha bhI artha ho sakatA hai ? ki koI cAra dina yA daza dinakA Ayu bhoga kara nahIM maratA ! nahIM ! sarvathA nahIM ! athavA koI kahe ki, manuSya nyUnase nyUna tIna hAthakA aura adhikase adhika sAta hAthakA UMcA hotA hai, to kyA isa kathanase cAra athavA pAMca hAthake manuSyakA abhAva hI samajhanA cAhie ? hama nahIM samajhate ki, phira " svAmIjI " ne ukta viSayako mahAjhUTha kahate hue kyoM nahIM saMkoca kiyA ? [ga] svAmI dayAnaMda sa0--aba sunie bhUmike parimANako (ratnasAra bhA. pR. 152) isa tirache lokameM asaMkhyAta dvIpa aura asaMkhyAta samudra haiM ina asaMkhyAtakA pramANa arthAt jo aDhAI sAgaropama kAlameM jitanA samaya ho utane dvIpa tathA samudra jAnanA aba isa pRthivImeM eka "jaMbUdvIpa". prathama : -

Page #53
45 sabha dvIpoM ke bIca meM hai isa kA pramANa eka lAkha yojana arthAt cAra lAkha kozakA hai aura isake cAroM ora lavaNa samudra hai usakA pramANa do lAkha yojanakA hai arthAt ATha lAkha kozakA | isa jaMbUdvIpa ke cAroM ora jo " dhAtakI khaMDa " nAma dvIpa hai usakA cAra lAkha yojana arthAt solaha lAkha kozakA pramANa hai aura usake pIche "kAlodadhi" samudra hai usakA ATha lAkha arthAt batrIsa lAkha kozakA pramANa hai usake pIche "puSkarAvarta" dvIpa hai usakA pramANa 'solaha kozakA hai / usa dvIpake bhItarakI koreM haiM usa dvIpake AdhemeM manuSya vasate haiM aura usake uparAMta asaMkhya dvIpa samudra hai unameM tiryak yonike jIva rahate haiM / ( ratnasAra bhA. pR. 153) jaMbUdvIpameM eka himavaMta, eka airaNyavaMta, eka harivarSa, eka ramyaka, eka devakuru, eka uttarakuru ye chaH kSetra haiM / ( samIkSaka) suno bhAI ! bhUgola vidyA ke jAnanevAle logo ! bhUgolake parimANa karanemeM tuma bhUle yA jaina ? jo jaina bhUla gaye hoM to tuma unako samajhAo aura jo tuma bhUle hoM to unase samajha lebho / thoDAsA vicAra karake dekho to yahI nizcaya hotA hai ki jainiyoMke AcArya aura ziyAne bhUgola khagola aura gaNita vidyA kucha bhI nahIM par3hI thI jo par3he hote to mahA asaMbhava gapor3A kyoM mArate ? bhalA aise avidvAn puruSa jagat ko akartRka aura Izvarako na mAne isameM kyA Azcarya hai ? [ satyArtha prakAza pRSTha 422 ] (1) yahAMpara svAmIjI bhUla gaye haiM unako solaha kosake sthAna meM solaha lAkha yojana likhanA cAhie thA ! // (2) yaha svAmIjIkI bhASA, vAkyaracanA tathA usake paraspara saMbaMdhakA namUnA hai ! na mAlUma kyA samajha kara svAmIjIne : isako likha mArA ? // 1

Page #54
46 [gha] isa liye jainI loga apane pustakoMkoM kinhI vidvAn anya matasyoMko nahIM dete kyoMki jinako ye loga prAmANika tIrthaMkaroM ke banAye hue siddhAMta graMtha mAnate haiM unameM isI prakArakI avidyAyukta bAteM bharI par3I haiM isa liye nahIM dekhane deteM jo deve to pola khula jAya inake vinA jo koI manuSya kucha bhI buddhi rakhatA hogA vaha kadApi isa gapoDAdhyAyako satya nahIM mAna sakegA / [ satyArtha prakAza pRSTha 422 ] " [ca] 4 yaha sabha prapaMca jainiyoMne jagat ko anAdi mAnane ke liye khar3A kiyA hai paraMtu yaha nirAjhUTa hai hAM jagatkA kAraNa anAdi hai. kyoMki paramANu Adi tatva svarUpa akartRka haiM. paraMtu unameM niyamapUrvaka banane vA bigaDene kA sAmarthya kucha bhI nahIM kyoMki jaba eka paramANu dravya. kisIkA nAma hai aura svabhAvase pRthak rUpa aura jar3a haiM ve apane Apa yathAyogya nahIM bana sakate isaliye inakA banAnevAlA cetana avazya hai vaha banAnevAlA jJAnasvarUpa hai dekho pRthivI sUryAdi sabha lokoM ko niyamameM rakhanA anaMta anAdi cetana paramAtmAkA kAma hai jisameM saMyoga racanA vizeSa dIkhatA hai vaha sthUla jagat anAdi kabhI nahIM ho sakatA ityAdi [ satyArtha pra. pR. 423 ] [ cha ] ina jaina logoM ko sthUla bAtakA bhI yathAvat jJAna nahIM to paramaH sUkSma sRSTi vidyAkA bodha kaise ho sakatA hai ? [ sa. pra. 423: ] [ga]. samAlocaka- hamAre khyAlameM na to jaina bhUle aura na - anya loga, kiMtu svAmI mahodaya hI bhUla rahe haiM ! astu !

Page #55
47 svAmIjIke nizcayake anusAra hama thor3e samaya ke liye yahI mAna lete haiM ki, jainAcAryoMko bhUgola khagola vidyAkA jJAna nahIM thA ! ve bicAre kucha bhI par3he likhe nahIM the ! isIliye unhone asaMbhava gapaur3e likha mAre ! paraMtu " svAmIjI " ina -saba dUSaNoMse mukta the ! ataH hama unhIkI likhI huI pusta - koMse bhUgola khagolake samajhanekI jijJAsA karate haiM ! paraMtu zoka hai ki, unake rela tAravAle vedoMke pothoM ko bhI kaI daphA ulaTA pulaTA kara dekhA, magara bhUgola khagolake viSaya meM to kucha bhI likhA na pAyA ! jaina graMthoMmeM varNana kiye huye bhUgola khagolako paur3A batalAnevAle svAmIjI mahArAja, yadi apane sacce mAne hue bhUgola khagolake ullekhase apane kiye Rg athavA yajurveda bhASyake pAMca sAta pRSThoMko raMga jAte to logoM ko bhI bahuta lAbha hotA ! aura hamako bhI svAmIjI aura jainoMke bhUgola khagolake viSayameM vicAra karake satyAsatya ke nirNaya karanekA samaya milatA ! paraMtu kheda hai ki, svAmI mahodaya ne svayaM isa viSaya meM kucha nirNaya na karake kevala jainake AcAryoMko mUrkha kahane meM hI apanI buddhimattAko caritArtha kiyA 1 pAThaka mahodaya 1 kSamA kIjie ! hama svAmajiki una aMgha bhaktomeMse nahIM haiM, joki unakI nirmala kIrtiko kalaMkita karane ke lie maharSi padako hAthameM lie unake pIche bhAga rahe haiN| sajjano ! sRSTike parimANa kI iyattA manuSya buddhise bAhira hai | manuSya apane parimita buddhi vaibhavase jisa siddhAMtako Aja sthira karatA hai, kala usIke viruddha zatazaH pramANoM ke upalabdha hone se usIko vaha asthira evaM asaMgata mAnane lagatA hai / jisa navIna sAyansa ke hama loga bhakta bana rahe haiM vaha, Aja jisa siddhAMta ko sthira karatA hai kala usIko khaMDana :

Page #56
48 karatA najara AtA hai| jo loga, Ajase anumAna tIsa varSa prathama, uttaradhruva pradezameM manuSyoM kI vasatI ke ghora virodhI the, vahI Aja kaha rahe haiM ki, uttaradhruva pradeza kisI samaya manuSya vasatI ke yogya thA, arthAt vahAM manuSya nivAsa karate the| hamAre vicArameM to jina logoMkA yaha mata hai ki, pRthivI etAvanmAtra hI hai, nissaMdeha ve loga bhramameM haiM ! samaya AvegAki, unhe balAtkArase apanI isa nirbala mAnyatA ko pIche kheMcanA par3egA ! "bhalA aise avidvAn puruSa jagat ko akartRka aura Izvarako na mAne to kyA Azcarya hai" svAmIjIkA yaha lekha kucha adhika vicAra se saMbaMdha rakhatA ho aisA nahIM ! isa lie isapara vizeSa kucha na kahakara pAThakoM se itanA hI nivedana karate haiM ki, Izvarako to jaina mAnate haiM, paraMtu svAmIjI ke mAne hue Izvarase usakA aMtara bahuta hai ! isakA rahasya kahIM anyatraM pradarzita kiyA jAvegA. [gha svAmIjI ke "isI lie jainI loga apane pustakoMko" ityAdi lekhase vidita hotA hai ki, unhoMne saMsAra para bahuta upakAra kiyA ! AzA nahIM ki, unake isa RNase sabhya saMsAra sadyaHmukta ho sake ! kyoMki apanI pola khula jAne ke bhayase jainI loga jina apane pustakoMko anyamatake vidvAnoMse chipAte the, unako dekhane ke lie dene se inakAra karate the, svAmIjIne kisI na kisI taraha una sabako dekhakara jainoMkI pola khola hI dI.! vizeSa harSakI bAta to yaha hai ki, "svA-. * mInI" kumArila bhaTTase bhI prathama naMbara meM nikale ! kyoMki, kumArila bhaTTa to, apane jIvanakA AdhA bhAga bauddhagraMthoM ke abhyAsameM lagAkara unake khaMDanameM pravRtta hue the! svAmI dayA--

Page #57
49 naMdajI to, kukkuTamizrakI taraha jainagraMthoMkI sugaMdhi mAtra se hI kRtakRtya hokara unake khaMDana ke lie kUda par3e haiM ! paraMtu "lene gaI pUta aura kho - AI khasama " vAlI kahAvata se nainoM kI pola kholate kholate svAmIjI, apanI hI pola khulAM baiThe ! ! svAmI mahodayakA nirUpaNa kiyA huA saptabhaMgIvAda isa bAtakA-pola khulanekA bar3A hI prauDha sAkSI hai ! ' sajjano ! mayUrakA 'nRtya dekhane meM logoMkI jitanI abhiruci hotI hai, usase dviguNa aruci usake pichale bhAgako avalokana karanese utpanna hotI hai ! hama svAmIjIke vAkyapara vizvAsa kara sakate haiM, yadi vartamAna samaya hamArA galA na dabAve ! vartamAna samaya meM jainamatake sahasroM graMtha pracArameM Ae hue dekhe jAte haiM, aura jaina samAja ke agresara inako aura bhI pracAra meM lAne ke lie yathAzakti prayatna kara rahe haiM / kumArila bhaTTase lekara prAcIna jitane AcAyoMke graMtha upalabdha hote haiM una sabameM jaina siddhAMta kA ullekha aura prativAda pAyA jAtA hai ! yadi svAmIjI ke lekhAnusAra, jaina loga apane graMthoM ko chipA rakhate the to, unameM nainamatakA ullekha kisa taraha kiyA gayA ? jaina graMthoMko gapauDAdhyAya batalAnA svAmIjIke lie koI naI bAta nahIM ! parapurupake sAtha avAcya vyavahArameM yadi saMkoca hogA to, patitratAko hogA ! anyakA to vaha .. kartavya hI hai !! * [ ca N ] svAmIjI jagatako anAdi svIkAra karanA, nirA: jhUTha: batalAte haiM ! paraMtu isapara yUM kahanA ki; jagatko sarvathA sAdi mAnanA hI nirA jhUTha hai, hamAre khyAlameM kucha adhika ucita pratIta hotA hai.| kyoMki jo loga sRSTiko 'Izvara kI kRti... : 1

Page #58
50 - mAnate haiM unako bhI sRSTi ke bAda pralaya, aura pralayake anaMtara. sRSTi, isa paraMparAko anAMdi hI svIkAra karanA hogA / anyathA sRSTike saMbaMdhameM musalamAna aura IsAi matase kucha bhI vizeSa nahIM / "svAmIjI " svayaM likhate haiM ki, " ghAtA paramAtmAne jisa prakArake sUrya caMdra dyau bhUmi aMtarikSa aura tatrastha manuSya. vizeSa padArtha pUrva kalpameM race the vaise hI isa kalpameM arthAt isa sRSTimeM race haiM " [ satyA0 pR0 231] svAmIjIke ukta lekhase spaSTa mAlUma hotA hai ki, sRSTi pravAhase anAdi hai / yadi svAmIjIkA dUsarA lekha dekhA jAya taba to, isa bAta meM rahA sahA saMdeha bhI dUra ho jAtA hai / tathA hi - ( satyArtha prakAza pRSTha 223 ) " ( prazna ) kabhI sRSTikA prAraMbha hai vA nahIM ? ( uttara ) nahIM jaise dina ke pUrvaM rAta aura rAtake pUrva dina tathA dinake pIche rAta aura rAtake pIche dina barAvara calA AtA hai isI prakAra sRSTike pUrva pralaya aura pralayake pUrva sRSTi tathA sRSTike pIche pralaya aura pralaya ke Age sRSTi anAdi kAlase cakra calA AtA hai isakI Adi vA aMta nahIM. " 2 sajjano ! svAmIjI ke isa lekhako bar3I sAvadhAnIse paDhanA ! svAmIjI apane Apa sRSTiko pravAhase anAdi mAnate hue bhI sRSTiko anAdi kahanA nirA jhUTha batalAte haiM ! eka sthAnameM to sRSTiko anAdi batalAnA, aura dUsarI jagaha usako nirA jhUTha kahanA! na mAlUma svAmIjIkI yaha ucchRMkhalatA, kyA tAtparya rakhatI hai ? astu ! svabhAvo duratikramaH !! svAmIjI jagatko to anAdi nahIM mAnate, paraMtu usake kAraNa paramANuoMko anAdi svIkAra karate haiM, unameM niyama pUrvaka banane aura bigar3ane kA sAmarthya nahIM hai / kyoM ki, ve svabhAvase pRthak svarUpa haiM, isalie inake banAne aura bigAr3anekA kAma Izvarako sapurda kiyA gayA

Page #59
hai!| isa viSayameM hama anyatra likhaneke lie pAThakoMse pratijJAbaddha ho cuke haiM kyoM ki, yaha viSaya bar3A vistRta aura gaMbhIra hai ! yahAM para to hama " paramANu svabhAvase pRthak aura jaharUpa haiM " svAmIjIke itane lekha parahI vicAra karate haiN| -~ (1) paramANu yadi svabhAvase hI pRthak svarUpa haiM to, unako samilita karanekA Izvarako kyA adhikAra hai ? yadi unake pRthak svabhAvako bhI saMmilita karanemeM Izvara samartha hai to, paramANuoMke jar3a svabhAvako badalakara unheM cetana kyoM nahIM banA detA? (2) paramANuoMkA pRthak svabhAva, nitya hai ? athavA anitya hai ? yadi nitya mAnA jAya taba to svAmIjIko sRSTisehI hAtha dhone pdd'eNge| kyoM ki, vinA paramANuoM ke melase sRSTi, ho nahIM sakatI! aura mela huA to, unakA pRthak svabhAva gayA ! isalie nitya pakSako tyAgakara yadi anitya pakSako hI svIkAra kiyA jAve. to, hama pUchate haiM ki, usako kisane banAyA ? kaba aura kyoM banAyA ? isakA uttara khAmIjIke kisI pustaka ratnase mile aisI to AzA pAThakoMko svapnameM bhI na karanI cAhiye / hAM yadi unake bhASA saMgrahako hI samajhanekI hamameM yogyatA nahIM, taba to una graMthoMkA hI durbhAgya samajhanA cAhiye !! sajjano ! svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatIjI jaina siddhAMtase kucha bhI paricaya nahIM rakhate the ! hamArA yaha kathana, kisI pakSapAtako lekara nahIM hai, kiMtu svAmIjIkA ukta lekha hI madhyastha samAjake samakSa mUMha phAr3a 'phAr3akara unakI anabhijJatAkI sAkSI de rahA hai / yadi svAmIjI jaina matakA thor3AsA bhI jJAna rakhate hote to, unako isa prakArake iMdrajAlakI racanA karanI na par3atI ! sRSTIke viSayameM / jaina siddhAMta bar3AhI sarala aura spaSTa hai|

Page #60
jaina siddhAMtameM vastukA sarvathA uccheda svIkAra nahIM kiyA / g2ayA, kiMtu utpatti aura vinAza rUpa paryAyake honepara bhI dravya rUpase padArtha sthira rahatA hai| isaliye padArtha mAtra, utpatti-sthitivinAza ina tIna avasthAoMse yukta hai| sRSTiko dravyakI apekSAse anAdi anaMta aura paryAyakI apekSA sAdi sAMta . kathana karanA jainoMkA bahuta ucita pratIta hotA hai| kyoMki, - yadi hama vizva samudAyako leveM tava to, yaha anAdi anaMta hai vaha samasta padArthoMkA samudAya hai, yaha samudAya hara samaya . vaisekA vaisA hI banA rahatA hai / isalie samudAya rUpase yaha vizva anAdi aura anaMta hai| yadi usameMse kisI eka bhAgakI tarpha dRSTi kareM-to usameM hara :samaya pheraphAra hotA dekhanemeM AtA hai, isalie isa- apekSAse hama saMsArako sAdi sAMta bhI kaha sakate haiN| [cha] svAmIjI kahate haiM ki, " jaina logoMko sthUla vAtakA bhI jJAna nahIM to parama sUkSma sRSTi vidyAkA bodha kaise ho sakatA hai ? " isase hamAre pAThaka yaha to samajha gaye hoMge ki, sthUla sUkSma saba prakArake jJAna bhaMDArakI tAlI vidhAtAne svAmIjIke hI sapurda kI huI thI! isa lie jaina evaM anya matake vidvAn jo jJAnase zUnya raha gaye vaha, svAmIjIkI hI kRpaNatAkA. phala hai ! yadi svAmIjI, thoDIsI bhI udAra vRtti dhAraNa karate to, unako samasta dharmake AcAryoMko mUrkha kahaneke * lie bahutase zvetapRSTha vRthA kAle karane na par3ate ! astu ! jainoMkA pIchA chor3akara hama, svAmIjIse hI sRSTi ke parama sUkSma tattvako samajhanekI prArthanA karate haiM ! paraMtu svAmIjIkA nAma lenepara bhI unake graMthoM taka hI pahuMcanA hogA ! isaliye, calo

Page #61
53 pahale svAminirmita RgvadAdi bhASya bhUmikAse hI mulAkAta karate haiM ! saMbhava hai vahAMse hI hamArA manoratha siddha ho jAye !! pyAre sabhya pAThako ! RgvedAdi bhApya bhUmikA ke sRSTi vidyA viSayase sRSTi saMbaMdhi jisa sUkSma tattvakI hame prApti -huI hai, usase Apa loga, kadApi vaMcita na raha jAyeM isalie hama usako yahAMpara uddhRta kara dete haiM / AzA hai ki, Apa loga usako dhyAna se par3heMge ! "jaba yaha kArya sRSTi utpanna nahIM huI thI taba taka eka sarva zaktimAn paramezvara aura dUsarA jagatkA kAraNa arthAt jagat vanAkI sAmagrI virAjamAna thI usa samaya zUnya nAma AkAza arthAt jo netroMse dekhane meM nahIM AtA so bhI nahIM thA usa samaya satoguNa rajoguNa aura tamoguNa milAke jo pradhAna kahAtA hai vaha bhI nahIM thA usa samaya paramANu bhI nahIM the " ityAdi - [ RgavedAdi bhApya bhUmikA pRSTa 117 ] isake Age phira pRSTa 124 meM " usI puruSakI sAmarthya se ghoDe aura vijulI Adi padArtha utpanna hue haiM / jinake mukhameM dono aura dAMta hote haiM una pazuoMko ubhayadata kahate haiM ve UMTa gadhA Adi usIse utpanna hue haiM usI se gAya pRthivI kiraNa aura iMdriya utpanna huI haiM isI prakAra cherI aura bher3eM bhI usI se utpanna huI haiM " ityAdi - * ' hamAre pAThaka, svAmIjIke batalAe hue sRSTi saMbaMdhi sUkSma tattvase aba to acchI taraha paricita ho gae hoMge !! pAThaka mahodaya ! dekhanA ! sRSTi N vidyAke aise sUkSma tatvako hAthase jAne mata denA ! saMbhava hai ki, isa prakAra sRSTi vidyA saMbaMdhi sUkSma rahasyoM kA samajhAnevAlA, svAmIjI jaisA upakArapriya manuSya, phira isa saMsAra meM paidA na ho 1 * * : * - " 1 .

Page #62
54 . svAmIjIke isa mahAn upakArakA badalA denemeM yadyapi hama samartha nahIM haiM ! tathApi svAmI ke likhe hue isa navIna sRSTi vidyArUpa sUkSma tattvake viSayameM eka madhyastha purupake hRdayameM jitane saMdeha utpanna hote haiM unameMse do cArakA bhI saMtopa janaka samAdhAna kahIse mila sake aisI AzA nahIM !! svAmIjIne sRSTikI utpattise pUrva eka Izvara, aura dUsarI jagatke banAnekI sAmagrI, yaha do padArtha batalAe haiM; paraMtu vaha sAmagrI kaunasI samajhanI ? isakA unhoMne kucha bhI patA nahIM diyA ! kadApi prakRti athavA paramANu yaha sAmagrI samajheM, kyoMki satyArtha prakAzameM unhoMne prakRti aura paramANuoMko anAdi nitya batalAyA hai! jaise-"pra0 kyA prakRti paramezvarane utpanna nahIM kI ? u0 nahIM vaha anAdi hai " [pRSTha 208] " hAM jagatkA kAraNa anAdi hai kyoMki vaha paramANu Adi tatva svarUpa akaka haiM " [ pRSTha 423 paraMtu svAmIjI to yahAMpara usa vakata unake astitvako bhI javAba de rahe haiM ! yadi sRSTikI utpattise prathama AkAza bhI nahIM thA aura prakRti bhI nahIM paramANu bhI nahIM the to, inake atirikta vaha kaunasI sAmagrI thI ? ki jisase svAmIjI mahArAjake Izvarane bher3a, bakarI, gadhA, ghoDA, UMTa, hAthI aura gAya Adike zarIrake DhAMce banAye ! eka sthAnameM to prakRti aura paramANuko anAdi kahanA, aura dUsarI jagaha sRSTike pUrva unakA abhAva batalAnA ! hama nahIM kaha sakate ki, isa prakArake unmata pralApako madhyastha samAja kisa kakSAmeM sthAna degA! phira-Izvarase bher3a, bakarI, gadhe, ghoDe utpanna hue, isakA kyA artha ! kyA Izvarako inakA prasUta huA ? athavA Izvarake

Page #63
55. pAsa koI gadhe, ghor3e, bakarI, bher3a Adi paidA karanevAlI mazIna hai ? samajhameM nahIM AtA ki, svAmIjI hamako kyA sUkSma tatva samajhA rahe haiM ? astu ! aba hama, satyArtha prakAzake sRSTi saMbaMdhi sUkSma tatvako sunate haiM, saMbhava hai usIse hamako kucha lAbha ho ! " pra0 sRSTike AdimeM eka vA aneka puruSa utpanna hue the vA kyA ! u0 aneka kyoMki jina jIvoM ke karma aizvarI sRSTimeM utpanna honeke the unakA janma sRSTike Adime Izvara detA hai kyoMki "manuSyA Rpayazca ye ! tato manuSyA ajAyaMta" yaha yajurveda meM likhA hai isa pramANase yahI nizcaya hai ki AdimeM aneka arthAt saikar3oM sahasroM manuSya utpanna hue / pra0 Adi sRSTi manuSya AdikI vAlyA yuvA vA vRddhAvasthA meM sRSTi huI thI athavA tInome ? u0 yuvAvasthAme kyoMki jo bAlaka utpanna karatA to unake pAlana ke lie dUsare manuSya Avazyaka hote aura jo vRddhAvasthAme banAtA to maithunI sRSTi na hotI isalie yuvAvasthA me sRSTi kI hai " [pR. 223] [ samAlocaka ] - hamAre pAThaka una paMktiyoM ko dhyAnase par3he jo ki moTe TAipameM haiN| yahAM para hamArI sRSTikramake siddhAMtakI DagaDagI pITanevAle navIna Arya mahAzayoM se prArthanA hai ki, binA hI mAM bApake hajAroM javAna AdamiyoMkA paidA honA sRSTi niyama ke anukUla hai vA pratikUla ? yadi sRSTi niyamake anukUla hai to, vinA mAM bApake koI manuSya paidA huA batalAo | yadi svAmIjIke ukta kathanako sRSTikramake viruddha samajhate haiM ! taba to unako, svAmIjI se pUchanA cAhiye * yaha vAkya yajurveda kahIM nahIM ! svAmIjIne vRthA hI yajurvedakA nAma liyA hai !

Page #64
N 56. ki unhoMne isa prakArakI asaMbhava gappa kyoM mArI? Izvarake pAsa yadi vinA mAtA pitAke sahasroM javAna manupya paidA karanekA koI lAyasansa hai to, vo aba kisane khosa liyA ? aba yadi eka AdhA hI paidA kara deve to, vicAre svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatIke sirapara to karakha raha jAveM ! yadi kahA jAve ki, Izvara prathama to utpanna karatA hai aba nahIM ! to isake uttarameM kaha sakate haiM ki, prathama karatA hai isameM hI kyA pramANa ? astu ! svAmIjI, hamAre zraddheya haiM ! ve bar3e yogirAja the ! unako IzvarIya jJAna thA ! Izvarane anya RpiyoM kI taraha unake nirmala hRdayameM satya vidyAke bhaMDAra vedoMkA prakAza kiyA thA ! isalie unakI gappako bhI hameM nirdhAnta hI mAnanA cAhiye ! paraMtu zoka ki, hama itanA svIkAra karane meM bhI vivaza haiM ! kyoMki, svAmIjI mahArAja kahate haiM / " aisI aisI (sRSTikramase viruddha) vAtoMko AMkhake aMdhe gAMTha ke pUre loga mAnakara bhramajAlameM girate haiM " dekho satyArthaprakAza ( pRSTha 490 ) meM IsAI matakA khaMDana karate hue svAmIjI pharamAte haiM---" ina bAtoMko koI vidvAn nahIM mAna sakatA ki jo pratyakSAdi pramANa aura sRSTi kramase virUddha haiM ina bAtoMkA mAnanA mUrkha manuSya jaMgaliyoMkA kAma hai sabhya vidvAnoMkA nahIM bhalA jo paramezvara. kA niyama hai usako koI tor3a sakatA hai ? jo paramezvara bhI niyamako ulaTA palaTA kare to usakI AjJAko koI na.mAne aura vaha bhI sarvajJa aura nirmama hai aise to jisa 2 kumArikA. ke garbha raha jAya tava saba koI aise kaha sakate haiM ki, isameM garbhakA rahanA IzvarakI orase aura jhUTha mUTha kahade ki paramezvara ke itane mujhako svapnameM kaha diyA ki yaha. garbha paramAtmAkI orase hai jaisA yaha asaMbhava prapaMca racA hai vaisA hI sUryase

Page #65
57 kuMtikA garbhavatI honA bhI purANoMme asaMbhava likhA hai aisI 2 cAtoMko AMkhake ye gAMThake pUre loga mAnakara bhramajAlameM girate haiN|" sajjano ! hamAre pUjya mahAtmA svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatIjI, . ukalekhase sRSTikramake viladdha pAtako likhane aura mAnanevAloM ko jaMgalI mUrva AMkhake aMdhe aura gAMThake pUre bhramajAlameM gire hue batalAte haiM, paraMtu Izvarane mAM bApake vinAhI hajAroM javAna sI manuSya paidA kara diye ! evaM bher3a, bakarI aura gadhe Adi pazubhI paidA kara diye ! isa prakAra kA sarvathA sRSTikrama virUddha kathana karanevAle, sarasvatI mahodaya ko kisa zreNImeM samajhanA cAhiye ! yaha hamArA pAThakoMse vinayapUrvaka prazna hai! hamameM itanA sAhasa nahIM ki pratyakSAdi pramANoMse virUddha vAtoMke kathana karanevAle svAmIjIko unake svabhAvake anusAra unako jaMgalI khakA aMdhA athavA gAMThakA pUrA ityAdi kaha sakeM ! paraMtu zoka to itanA hI hai ki, svAmIjI ne svayaM to sRSTikramase viruddha bAtoM ko likhane meM saMkoca nahIM kiyA ! aura IsAI gatake kathanako jaMgaliyoMkA kathana batalAyA hai !! astu ! svAmIjI ke batalAe hue sRSTi saMbaMdhi sUkSma tasvase to hamAre pAThaka paricita ho gae haiM ! svAmIjI ke * mRSTi prakaraNake viSayameM hameM bahuta kucha kahanA hai ! paraMtu kahI anyatra kheNge| " dravya paryAya aura svAmI dayAnaMda " svA. da.-"jo jainI loga sRSTiko anAdi anaMta mAnate aura dravya paryAyoMko bhI anAdi anaMta mAnate haiM aura pratiguNa pratidezameM paryAyoM aura prativastumeM bhI anaMta paryAyako

Page #66
58 mAnate haiM yaha prakaraNa ratnAkarake prathama bhAgameM likhA hai| yaha bhI bAta kabhI nahIM ghaTa sakatI kyoMki jinakA aMta arthAta maryAdA hotI hai unake saba saMbaMdhi aMtavAle hI hote haiM yadi anaMtako asaMkhya kahate to bhI nahIM ghaTa sakatA kiMtu jIvApekSA yaha bAta ghaTa sakatI haiM paramezvara ke sAmane nahIM / kyoMki eka 2 dravyameM apane 2 ekara kArya karaNa sAmarthyako avibhAga paryAyoMse anaMta sAmarthya mAnanA kevala avidyAkI bAta hai jaba eka paramANu dravyakI sImA hai to usameM anaMta vibhAga rUpa paryAya kaise raha sakate haiM ? aise hI eka eka dravyameM anaMta guNa aura eka guNa pradezameM avibhAga rUpa paryAyoM ko bhI anaMta mAnanA kevala bAlakapanakI bAta hai kyoMki jisake madhikaraNakA aMta hai to usameM rahanevAloMkA aMta kyoM nahIM ? aisI hI laMbI cor3I mithyA vAteM likhI haiM / " [ satyArtha prakAza pRSTha 423 ] samAlocaka - jaina dharma ke siddhAMta se svAmIjI aNumAtrabhI paricita nahIM the, yaha bAta nirvivAda hai ! kyoMki jisa jisa sthala meM pUrvapakSa dvArA unhoMne jaina matakA ullekha kiyA hai unameM itanI bhUleM haiM ki, yadi una sabako dikhalAne ke lie thor3A thor3A bhI likhA jAya to saMbhava hai ki, satyArtha prakAza jitanA eka anya pustaka bana jAya ! udAharaNa ke lie bArahavAM samullAsa saMpUrNa prastuta hai !! jaina siddhAMta dravya aura paryAyakA kyA lakSaNa vatalAyA hai ? evaM guNa aura paryAyameM kitanA aMtara hai ? tathA prativastumeM anaMta paryAyakA honA jaina kisa paddhatise mAnate haiM aura anaMta zabdakA unake matameM sAMketika artha kyA hai ? ityAdi bAtoMko yadi svAmIjI kisI yogya jaina vidvAn se acchI taraha

Page #67
* samajha lete to saMbhava thA ki, unakI jo vRthA hI anya matoMpara nirbala apavAda lagAnekI Adata thI ! vaha isa viSayako likhakara usapara AkSepa karatI huI kucha zaramAtI ! pratidastumeM anaMta paryAya svIkAra karaneko svAmIjI avidyA aura bAlaka panakI bAta batalAte haiM ! usameM Apa yukti dete haiM ki, jo vastu aMta arthAt maryAdAvAlI hotI hai usake saMbaMdhi bhI aMtavAle hI hote haiM ! :paraMtu svAmIjIkA yaha kathana unakI jainamata saMbaMdhi mugdhatAkA pUrNa sUcaka hai ! jisa prakArase jaina maMtavyako dikhA kara svAmIjI usakA khaMDana karate haiM, jaina isa prakArase mAnate hI nahIM ! jainoMkA kathana hai ki, paryAyakI apekSAse vastu pratikSaNa parivarjanazIla hai, aisA koI samaya nahIM hai ki, jisa samaya vastumeM pheraphAra na hotA ho, anyathA jo vastu Ajase daza varSa pUrva dekhI hai Aja. usameM aMtara kyoM dekhA jAtA hai ? yadi paramANuoMmeM parivartana na hotA ho to usake samudAyameM kahAMse AyA ? isalie hara samaya vastumeM pheraphAra hotA rahatA hai / yadi aisA na ho to, vastu, sadA eka rUpameM hI rahanI cAhiye ! Ajase eka hajAra varSa pUrvakI banI huI kisI eka vastumeM Aja taka kitanA pheraphAra ho cukA hai isakI saMkhyA kyA svAmIjI athavA anya koI kara sakatA hai ? yadi nahIM to, na mAlUma jainoMkA vastumeM anaMta paryAya mAnanA svAmIjIko kyoM duHkhA? "aMtavAlI vastuke saMbaMdhi bhI aMtavAle hote haiM" isa kathanase na mAlUma, svAmIjI, jainoMke kisa siddhAMtakA khaMDana karate haiM ? kyA jaina, paryAyako nitya mAnate haiM ? jainoMne to paryAyakI apekSAse hI padArthako anitya (prinnaamshiil)btlaayaahai|'

Page #68
phira Age anaMta zabdakA asaMkhya artha karate hue bhI svAmIjI bhUlate haiM ! kyoMki jaina matameM asaMkhya aura anaMta saMkhyAmeM paraspara bahuta aMtara hai. jIvakI apekSAse to svAmIjI ukta jaina siddhAMtako svIkAra karate haiM, (voha bhI.vinA hI samajhe ! ) IzvarakI apekSAse nahIM ! paraMtu unako * yaha smaraNarakhanA cAhiye thA ki, eka IzvaravAdako jaina darzanameM sthAna nahIM diyA gayA ! asalI bAta to yaha hai ki, svAmIjI anaMta zabdake sAMketika arthako hI na . samajhe usakA nitya artha mAnakara hI ve vyartha aMdherA Dhote rahe ! isa dazAmeM jaina siddhAMtako mithyA batalAnA unakA kahAM taka ThIka hai ? yaha madhyastha varga svayaM vicAra leve. "karma aura svAmI dayAnaMda" [ka] svA. da.-" jainI loga jagat, jIva, jIvake karma aura baMdha anAdi mAnate haiM yahAM bhI jauniyoMke tIrthaMkara bhUla gaye haiM kyoMki saMyukta jagatakA kArya kAraNa, pravAhase kArya aura jIvake karma baMdha bhI anAdi nahIM ho sakatA jatra aisA mAnate ho to karma aura baMdhakA chuTanA kyoM mAnate ho kyoMki jo anAdi padArtha hai vaha kabhI nahIM chUTa sakatA jo anAdikA bhI nAza mAnoge to tumhAre sarva anAdi padArthoke nAzakA prasaMga hogA aura jaba anAdiko nitya mAnoge to karma aura vaMdha bhI nitya hogA" ityAdi-[ satyArtha prakAza pRSTha 424 ] [kha] __ ".aura jaba saba karmoke chUTanese mukti mAnate ho to saba. kamaukA chUTanA rUpa muktikA nimitta huA taba naimittikI --

Page #69
mukti hogI to sadA nahIM raha sakegI aura karma kartAkA nitya saMbaMdha honese karma bhI kabhI na chUTeMge " [sa0pra0pR0424 ] ...' (pra0) jaise dhAnyakA chilakA utArane vA amike saMyoga honese vaha bIja punaH nahIM ugatA isI prakAra muktime gayA huA jIva punaH janma maraNa rUpa saMsArame phira nahIM AtA / (u0) jIva aura karmakA saMbaMdha chilake aura bIjake samAna nahIM hai kiMtu inakA samavAya saMbaMdha hai isase anAdi kAlase jIva aura usameM karma aura kartRtva zaktikA saMbaMdha hai" ityAdi [saM0 pra0 pR0 424 ] samAlocaka-sajjano ! jina akSaroMke nIce hamane lakIra baiMcI hai unakA artha svAmI mahodayakI buddhike sivA aura kucha nahIM ho sakatA ! svAmIjI likhate haiM ki-" yahAM bhI jainiyoMke tIrthaMkara bhUla gaye " paraMtu-"jainI loga jagata jIva jIvake karma aura baMdha anAdi mAnate haiM." svAmIjIke isa lekhako jaina dharmakA koI vijJapuruSa yadi dekhe to sacamuca hI vaha svAmIjIko maharSi padase bhI eka hAtha UMce siMhAsanapara baiThAe vinAM na rahe ! svAmIjIkI yogavibhUtiko hama zatazaH dhanyavAda dete haiM ki, jisakI mahimAse vedArtha jJAnake sivA jaina tattvoMkA jJAna bhI unako nirAkArako tarphase hI prApta huA! svAmIjIke isa prakArake bahudhA asamaMjasa lekhoMko dekha kara paralokavAsI bhaTTa maeNkSamUlarakA kathana adhikAMza saccA mAlama detA hai. kisI samaya devasamAjake netA agni hotrIjIke sAtha bhaTTa maeNkSamUlarakA patravyavahAra huA thA vaha " svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatIkA veda bhASya aura adhyApaka maeNkSamUlara" zIrSaka

Page #70
dvArA hindIkI prasiddha sarasvatI nAmA mAsikapatrikAmeM chapA hai,. patra yadyapi iMgaliza bhASAmeM the paraMtu sampAdaka mahodayane sarva sAdhAraNake jJAnake lie unakA hindI bhASAmeM anuvAda karake chApanekI kRpA kI hai, unameMse eka patrako hama yahAMpara uddhata karate haiM.. . . : . 7- naoNra hema gArDensa oNksapharDa 24 pharavarI, 1891. zrImAn mahAzayajI! Apane jo kAgaja patra bheje unake liye maiM ApakoM hRdayase dhanyavAda detA huuN| dayAnaMda sarasvatIke viSayakA lekha par3hakara mere ve saMdeha puSTa ho gaye jo mere cittameM unake saMbaMdha the / mai abhI taka samajhatA thA ki dhArmika viSayoMme ve bar3e hI kaTTara yA usase bhI kucha adhika the| ata eva ve apane Rgveda bhASyake uttara dAtA nhiiN| paraMtu mujhe yaha jAna kara bar3A hI duHkha huA ki ve apane dhArmika nozakI ADameM koI cAla bhI calate the / tathApi mai yaha mAne vinA nahIM raha sakatA ki unameM kucha acchI bAteM bhI thIM aura anya sudhArakoM kI taraha ve bhI apane anuyAyiyoM aura khuzAmadiyoM dvArA gumarAha kara diye gaye the| bar3e hI duHkhakI bAta hai ki unake kiye gaye Rgveda aura yajurvedake bhASyoMpara itanA adhika dhana vyaya kiyA gayA / ye donoM bhASya unakI vahakI huI. buddhikI nipuNatAke namUne aura saugAta haiN| mujhe isa bAtapara Azcarya nahIM jo kezavacaMdrasena dayAnaMda sarasvatIse sahamata. nahIM ho ske| . ... .. ... ApakA maeNkSamUlara ... [ sarasvatI bhAga 13 saMkhyA 10 pRSTha 95.4 ]

Page #71
63 sajjano ! svAmIjIkA jainadarzana se aparicita honA koI Azcarya janaka nahIM hai ! kyoMki, unhoMne jaina darzanakA. - kisI vidvAn se adhyayana nahIM kiyA thA, vinA par3he jaina darzanakA jJAna honA nitAMta kaThina hai; vinAhI samajhe kisI --mata prativAda meM pravRtta honA, manuSyako nissaMdeha satyatA aura niSpakSatAse girA detA hai ! svAmIjIne jaina siddhAMtakA pUrva * pakSa meM ullekha karate hue likhA hai ki, " jainI loga jagat jIva jIvake karma aura baMdha anAdi mAnate haiM " paraMtu jIvake karma aura baMdha isa prakArakI paddhatikA ullekha jaina graMthoM meM kahIM nahIM !. jainoMkA to kathana hai ki, " jIvake sAtha karmoM kA saMyoga pravAhase -anAdi hai, paraMtu tattva jJAnakI prApti honese usakA nAza ho jAtA hai. jaise bIjameM aMkura denekI zakti anAdi kAlase vidyamAna hai, paraMtu yadi usako mUMja diyA jAya to vaha naSTa ho jAtI hai; isIprakAra nIvake sAtha karmoM kA saMbaMdha anAdi - kAlase calA mAtA hai paraMtu tatvajJAnakI prApti hone se vaha naSTa ho jAtA hai " / isake saMbaMdhameM svAmIjIkA kathana hai ki, anAdi, 'padArthakA nAza nahIM ho sakatA / isI lie ve jainose prazva karate haiM ki -" jo anAdikA bhI nAza mAnoMge to tumhAre saba anAdi padArthoMke nAzakA prasaMga hogA aura jaba anAdiko nitya mAnoMge to karma aura baMdha bhI nitya hogA " iti / svAmIjIke ukta lekhase mAlUma hotA hai ki, Apa * anAdikA artha hI nitya samajha rahe haiM / paraMtu vicAra kiyA jAya - to yaha samajha pramANa zUnya hai / saMsArameM kitaneka aise padArtha haiM | ki, jinakI Adi nahIM aura aMta dekhane meM AtA hai / kalpanA karo ki, svAmI dayAnaMdajI ke pitA, unake pitA, unake pitA,

Page #72
64 " evaM unake pitA, aura unake pitA AdikI paraMparAko anAdi svIkAra kiye vinA kisI prakAra bhI chuTakA nahIM paraMtu isa anAdi paraMparAko svAmIjIse samApti ho gaI ! kyoM ki, svAmIjI brahmacArI the / unhoMne isa paraMparA ko Age laijAnA svIkAra nahIM kiyA ! isI prakAra dhAnyake sAtha chilakekA saMbaMdha bhI anAdikAla se calA AtA hai, jaba vAnyaparase chilakA utara jAtA hai taba vaha saMbaMdha TUTa jAtA hai / ( 1 ) kitaneka padArtha aise haiM ki, jinake mAdi aura aMta donoMhI nahIM dekhe jAte, ataH ve anAdi anaMta mAne gae haiM / (2) kitaneka aise bhI haiM ki, jinakI Adi to nahIM paraMtu aMta dekhA jAtA hai; unhI ko anAdi sAMta kahA gayA hai / ( 3 ) evaM kitaneka aise bhI haiM ki, jinakI Adi to hai magara aMta nahIM vehI sAdi anaMta kahe gae haiM / ( 4 ) isI prakAra aise padArthoM se bhI yaha saMsAra bharapUra haiM ki, jinakI Adi aura aMta donoM hI dRSTigocara ho rahe haiM, isIlie unako sAdisAMta svIkAra kiyA gayA hai. inakA sodAharaNa varNana jaina graMthoMmeM vizeSa rUpase kiyA gayA hai / yaha siddhAMta itanA avAdhya aura upayogI hai ki, pratyeka darzanakArane apane darzana meM isako sthAna diyA hai / svAmIjIke matameM to anAdisAMta koI bhI padArtha nahIM haiM ! kyoMki, anAdi padArthako voha nitya hI mAnate haiM ! paraMtu prAgabhAva ke viSayameM unhoMne apanA kyA siddhAMta sthira kiyA yaha unake graMthoMse mAlUma nahIM hotA ! prAgabhAvako mAnanevAle. to usako anAdi sAMtahI mAnate haiM. / vastutaH yathArtha bhI yahI hai. kyoM ki, ghaTAdi vastuke utpanna honese prathama jo vidyamAna ho, aura utpanna honeke bAda jisakA nAza ho jAya

Page #73
usakA nAma mAgabhAva hai| isalie isako anAdi sAMtahI mAnanA hogA / anyathA hama pUchate haiM ki, ghaTAdi padArthoMkI utpattise pahale unake kAraNoM meM nivAsa karate hue prAgabhAvake samayake hisAbakA kyA svAmIjIkI DAyarImeM koI noTa hai ? hama nahIM kaha sakate ki, svAmIjI prAgabhAvako mAnakara bhI anAdi padArthako nitya hI kyoM mAna rahe haiM ? [kha] ___ sajjano ! AtmA ke sAtha koMke AtyaMtika viyogako jaina darzanameM mokSa batalAyA hai. jaise dhAnyakA bIja, chilakese pRthak huAra phira nahIM utpanna hotA, isI prakAra karmarUpa chilakese sarvathA judA huAra yaha AtmA bhI janma maraNa rUpa saMsAra paraMparAko kabhI prApta nahIM hotA. jisa prakAra dagdha huA vIja phira paidA nahIM hotA, isI taraha mokSAtmA kA bhI saMsArameM phira janma nahIM hotA. yathA-haribhadrasUriH dagdhe vIje yathAtyantaM, prAdurbhava karmavIne tathA dagdhe, nArohati bhavAGkaraH // 1 // " mokSake nitya honemeM jainadarzana ke sivA, anya darzanakAroMkA bhI eka hI mata hai. isa viSayameM jainoMpara svAmIjIne jo AkSepa kiyA hai vaha aisA vidvattApUrNa hai ki, usakI prazaMsA koI svAmIjI jaisA hI bhAgyazAlI janme to cAhe kara sake ! hama to karanemeM sarvathA asamartha haiM. svAmIjI kahate haiM ki, " koMke chUTaneko yadi mukti kahoge to kaukA chUTanA muktikA nimitta hogA taba to mukti saMdA na rahegI." isakA tAtparya yaha hai ki, AtmAke sAtha jo karmakA saMyoga hai usake AtyaMtika vinAzako yadi mukti

Page #74
mAnA jAya taba to saMyogake vinAza arthAt abhAvako muktikA kAraNa avazya svIkAra karanA hogA, jisa vastukA koI kAraNa hai vaha avazya hI anitya hotI hai. mAlUma hotA hai ki, isI kAraNase svAmIjIne mokSako anitya svIkAra kiyA hai ! dezaka ! svAmIjIke matase to isa prakAra mAnanA TIka hai! kyoMki, ve mokSako karmajanya mAnate haiM ! nagara zoka : ki, unhoMne isa navIna ucchaMkhala maMtavyameM eka bhI sthira pramANanA ullekha nahIM kiyA !! svAmIjIne jaina matapara AkSepa karate hue muktinI anityatAmeM jisa pramANakA upanyAsa kiyA hai, usapara yadi svAmIjI thoDAsA bhI vicAra kara lete to " lene gaI pUta aura kho AI khasama " vAlI misAla unako bahuta hI zIghra yAda Ae vinA na rahatI ! aura saMbhava thA ki, ve khapAda kuThArake tIna AghAtase kadApi baca jAte! kyoMki bAnIjIne jIva, prakRti aura Izvara ina tIna padArthotro nitya svIkAra kiyA hai. inake nitya honemeM hetu, mAtra unake kAraNakA abhAva hI kaha sakate haiM; paraMtu jisa prakAra kauke saMyoga vinAzako mokSakA kAraNa mAnanepara svAmIjI usako anitya vatalAte haiM, isI prakAra Izvara, jIva aura prakRtike nityasameM bhI unake kAraNakA abhAva rUpa kAraNa honese ina vicAroMkI nityatA bhI svAmIjIkI satise mokSakI taraha thoDe hI dinake lie Thahara sakegI ! evaM pratibaMdhakake abhAvako nimita kAraNa mAnakara vastumeM anityatva vyavasthApana karanevAle svAmIjI 'mahArAnako nyAyazAstrakA kitanA adhika paricaya hogA yaha bhI vicAraNIya hai!

Page #75
67 sajjano ! 'AtyaMtiko viyogastu, kamaNAM mokSa ucyate / aise avAdhya siddhAMtako bhI manamAnI kalpanA se khaMDana karanemeM svAmIjIne tanika bhI saMkoca nahIM kiyA, isalie unako jitanA dhanyavAda diyA jAve utanA hI nyUna hai !!! [ga] svAmIjI kahate haiM ki, jIva aura karmakA saMbaMdha chilake aura bIja ke samAna nahIM haiM / paraMtu svAmIjIne isake vipayameM kisI pramANakA ullekha nahIM kiyA ! phira svAmIjI, jIvake sAtha karmakA samavAya saMbaMdha batalAte haiM; isase mAlUma hotA hai / ki, svAmIjI kriyA vizeSako hI karma samajha rahe haiM ! kyoMki kriyA aura kriyAvAlekA samavAya saMbaMdha hotA hai / yadi hama svAmIja ki ukta kathanako thoDe samaya ke lie mAna bhI leveM taba to svAmIjIkA " isase anAdi kAlase jIva aura usame karma . aura kartRtva zaktikA saMbaMdha hai " yaha kathana bahuta hI asaMgata hogA ! kyoMki, dravyotpatti ke uttara dUsare kSaNa meM guNa maura karmakI utpatti hotI hai / ( yaha usI darzanakA siddhAMta hai, jisake AdhArapara svAmI mahodaya jIva aura karma ina donoMkA samavAya saMbaMdha batalA rahe haiM / ) yadi aisA na mAnA jAya taba to inakA Apasa meM kArya kAraNa bhAva nahIM bana sakatA ! isalie jisa samaya jIvameM karma utpanna huA hogA usake eka kSaNa athavA adhika kAlataka jIvako niSkarma ( karmarahita ). avazya svIkAra karanA hogA / aisA mAnanemeM eka to yaha doSa hai ki, jaba AtmA prathama karma rahita thA to usameM pIchese karma kahAMse Ae ? dUsarA doSa yaha hai ki, jaba ukta siddhAMtase karma anitya hue taba unakA nAza bhI avazya hogA ! nAza huI vastukI utpatti vaMdhyA putrake samAna hai ! arthAt jaba kamaukA X

Page #76
. 68 eka daphA AtyaMtika vinAza ho cukA to phira unakI utpatti kisa prakArase ho sakatI hai ? yadi nahIM, taba to jIvameM karma kartRtvake saMbaMdhako nitya mAnanevAle svAmI mahodayako apane kalpita maMdirameM praveza karaneke lie koI navIna hI mArga daMDanA. cAhiye thA ! hama nahIM samajhate ki, karma nityatvake siddhAMtako svAmIjIne kisa pAThazAlAmeM baiTha kara adhyayana kiyA hogA ? karmako nitya kahanA sacamuca vyabhicArIko brahmacArI kahane ke samAna hai ! isapara buddhi ke pIche lAThI lie phiranevAle bahutase samAjI mahAzaya kaha uTheMge ki, svAmIjIna karmAko nitya nahIM kahA, kiMtu jIvameM karma aura kartRtva zaktike saMghako nitya kahA hai / isalie karma aura kartRtva zakti nitya nahIM, kiMtu. inakA saMbaMdha nitya hai ! isapara hama pUchate haiM ki, yadi kartRtva. zakti aura karma nitya nahIM, to phira inakA vinAza kyoM nahIM ? yadi vinAza hotA hai to phira kartRta zakti, kahAMse AvegI ? jo ki, muktAtmAko phira duHkhamaya saMsArakA mUM dikhalAve ! ! astu ! nippAmANikaSu pramANaparataMtrANAmasmAkaM maunameva shreyH|| yahAMpara hama pAThakoMko itanA avazya batalA dete haiM ki, jaina zAstroMmeM jisa prakAra karmakA lakSaNa, evaM svarUpa, batalAyA hai; svAmIjIkA kathana usase kosoM dUra hai ! jainamatameM karmako dravya mAnA hai, arthAt eka prakArake jaI paramANuoMme hI jainamatameM karma vyavahAra kiyA jAtA hai. jainoMkA kathana hai ki, zubha-evaM-azubha adhyavasAyase jIvake sAthe karma paramANu saMbaMdhita hokara usakI jJAna darzanAdi svAbhAvika anaMta zakti-. yoMko tirohita kara dete haiM. yaha kathana yadyapi UparaseM kucha 'zuSka aura alaMkArikasA pratIta hotA hai, paraMtu vicArase

Page #77
69 dekhA jAya to bar3A hI sarasa auraM akSarazaH satya hai. isakA vicAra hama kahIM anyatra kareMgeM. isake Age svAmIjIne kucha Izvara aura karma, tathA unake phala deneke saMbaMdha meM likhA hai; usake viSaya meM hama kahIM anyatra vicAra karaneke lie pratijJA caddha hote hue yahAM para pAThakoMse itanA hI nivedana karate haiM ki, ukta viSaya ke saMbaMdha meM svAmIjI mahArAjane jo kucha bhI likhA hai, vaha kevala araNya rodanake samAna hai ! saca pUcho to svAmIjI do pahara meM hI bhUle phirate mAlUma dete haiM ! jitane bhI pUrva aura uttara pakSoMdvArA unhoMne jaina matakA pratipAdana aura prativAda kiyA hai, vaha sabakA saba sacamuca hI tela ke zirapara kolhUkI misAlaseM upamita karane yogya hai !! " "paSTa zataka aura svAmI dayAnaMda" SaSThI zataka jainamatakA eka arvAcIna graMtha hai, jainoMke kisI aMga yA upAMgameM isakI gaNanA nahIM hai, isaliye yaha utane hI aMzameM pramANa karane yogya hai, jitanA ki 'jainamatake sarvamAnya siddhAMta graMthoM ke anukUla ho. yaha graMtha prAkRta bhASA meM hai, isakI 160 gAthA haiM, isake nirmAtA nemicaMdra nAmake - koI jaina gRhastha haiM / yaha prAyaH saMgraha graMtha hai / isakI kita-nIka gAthAeM uddhRta karake svAmI dayAnaMdajIne unakI samIkSA kI hai / uddhRta gAthAoM kA pATha bahudhA azuddha hai ! unakA artha karanemeM to svAmIjIne prAkRta bhASAke jJAnameM apanI kIrtiko khUba hI bar3hAyA hai !! unapara jo samIkSA kI gaI hai - vaha, bar3I hI nirbala aura binA sira pairakI hai ! ! ! gAthArtha ke sAtha usakA aNumAtra bhI saMbaMdha nahIM hai / udAharaNake lie- uname se kucha gAthAeM yahAM para uddhRta kI jAtI haiM /

Page #78
70 [ka] mUla-jaina kuNasi tavacaraNaM napaDhasi naguNesi desi no daannm| 'tA ittiyana sak kisija devA ikke arihaMtoSaSThI. sU. 2 // he jIva jo tUM tapacaritra nahIM kara sakatA, na sUtra par3ha sakatA, na prakaraNAdikA vicAra kara sakatA aura supAtrAdiko dAna nahIM de sakatA to bhI tUM devatA eka arihaMtahI hamAre ArAdhanAke yogya muguru mudharma jainamatameM zraddhA rakhanA sarvottama 'ghAta aura uddhArakA kAraNa hai // 2 // (samIkSaka) yadyapi 'dayA aura kSamA acchI vastu hai tathApi pakSapAtameM phasanese dayA adayA aura kSamA akSamA hojAtI hai isakA prayojana yaha hai ki kisI jIvako duHkha na denA yaha vAta saMbhava nahIM ho sakatI kyoMki duSToMko daMDa denA bhI dayAmeM gaNanIya hai, jo eka duSTako daMDa na diyA jAya to sahasoM manuSyoMko duHkha prApta ho isaliye vaha dayA adayA aura kSamA akSamA honAya / saba prANiyoMke duHkhakA nAza aura sukhakI prAptikA upAya karanA dayA kahAtI hai| kevala jala chAnake pInA kSudra jaMtuoMko bacAnAhI dayA nahIM kahAtI kiMtu isa prakArakI dayA jainiyoMke kathana mAtra hI hai kyoMki vaisA vartate nhiiN| . [kha] kyA manuSyAdipara cAhe kisI matame kyoM na ho dayA karake usakA annapAnAdise satkAra karanA aura dUsare matake vidvAnoMko mAnya aura sevA karanA dayA nahIM hai ? jo inakI saccI dayA hotI to " vivekasAra" ke pRSTha 221 meM dekho kyA likhA hai " eka paramatIkI stuti" arthAt una kA guNakIrtana kabhI na karanA / dUsarA " unako namaskAra " arthAt

Page #79
71 vaMdanA bhI na karanI / tIsarA "Alapana" arthAt anyamata vAloM ke sAtha thor3A bolanA / cauthA " saMlapana" arthAt unase vAra 2 na bolanA / pAMcavAM "unako anna vastrAdi dAna " arthAt unako khAne pInekI vastu bhI na denI / chaThA "gaMdhapuSpAdidAna ". anyamatakI pratimA pUjanake liye gaMdha puSpAdi bhI na denA / ye chaH yatanA arthAt ina cha: prakArake karmoMko jaina loga kabhI na kareM" (samIkSaka) aba, buddhimAnoMkoM vicAranA cAhiye ki ina jaina logoMkI anya matavAle manuSyopara kitanI adayA, kudRSTi aura dveSa hai| jaba anya matastha manuSyoMpara itanI adayA hai to phira jainiyoMko dayAhIna kahanA saMbhava hai kyoM ki apane gharavAloMkI hI sevA karanA vizeSa dharma nahIM kahAtA unake matake manuSya unake gharake samAna haiM isaliye unakI sevA karate anya mata-- thoMkI nahIM phira unako dayAvAn kauna buddhimAn kaha sakatA hai?| [ga] svA0 da-viveka.108meM likhA hai ki "mathurAke rAjAke namucI nAmaka dIvAnako jainamatiyoMne apanA virodhI samajha kara 'mAraDAlA aura AloyaNA karake zuddha ho gayA / kyA yaha bhI dayA aura kSamAkA nAzaka karma nahIM hai ? jaba anya matavAloM para prANa lene paryaMta vaira buddhi rakhate haiM taba inako dayAke sthAnapara hiMsaka kahanA hI sArthaka hai / [sa0 pra0 pR0 427-28]. . samAlocaka-jina akSaroMke nIce hamane laMbI lakIra baiMcI hai unakA Upara likhI prAkRta gAthAke sAtha. kucha bhI. saMbaMdha nahIM hai, gAthAmeM aisA koI bhI pada nahIM, jisakA svAmIjIkA likhA huA " suguru sudharma " ityAdi artha ho.

Page #80
sake ! ukta gAthAkA sarala aura spaSTa itanA hI artha hai ki-*" he jIva ! yadi tUM tapa, zAstrAbhyAsa aura supA dAna AdimeM se kucha bhI karanemeM samartha nahIM to, kyA tUM itanA bhI nahIM kara sakatA ? arthAt samajha sakatA ki, eka arihaMta' deva arthAt sarva doSa rahita Izvara hI upAsanA karane yogya / hai." hama nahIM samajhate ki, ukta upadezameM svAmIjIne kyA burAI samajha kara itanI uchala kUda kI ? isake anaMtara samIkSakase lekara jo likhA gayA hai vaha vinA sira pairakA hai! kyoMki ukta gAthAke arthake sAtha usakA kucha bhI saMbaMdha nahIM!! isapara vicAra karanA bhI samayako vyartha khonA hai! yadyapise lekara-dayA kahAtI hai-takake lekhameM svAmIjI jainoMko kyA samajhA rahe haiM ? yaha kucha samajhameM nahIM AtA ! kyA duSTa puruSako daMDa denA jaina anucita samajhate haiM ? jainoMkAM. to kathana hai ki, niraparAdha prANIko kadApi satAnA na cAhiye, aura prANimAtra para dayA rakhanA manuSyakA sabase uttama kartavya hai. hAM! apanese choTe tathA niraparAdha prANiyoMko ahaMkArameM Akara pAMvake tale kucala DAlane, tathA svAmIjIkI taraha "he Izvara ! AryoMke zatruoMkA nAza kara! unako khuzaka. lakar3IkI taraha jalA DAla ! " isa prakArake niMdanIya updeN| zoMko jainoMne apane zAstroM meM sthAna nahIM diyA ! * SaSThI zatakakA zuddhapATha tathA usakI vyAkhyA-" jaI na kuNa si tava caraNaM, na paDhasi na guNesi desi no dANaM / tA ittiaM na'sakkasi, jaM devo ikku arihaMto // 2 // " vyAkhyA-yadi na karoSi tapazcaraNaM, na paThasi, na guNasi, na dadAsiM dAnaM, tat etAvanmAtraM kartuM na zakropi ? yaddeva eko'hanneva pUjyo dhyeyazceti gAthArthaH // 2 // .

Page #81
73 svAmIjI kahate haiM ki - " jala chAnake pInA kSudrajaMtu - oMko bacAnA hI dayA nahIM kahAtI " hama pUchate haiM ki, jaina matake kisa graMtha meM likhA hai ki, jala chAnakara pInA aura kSudra jaMtuoM ko bacAnA mAtra hI dayA hai / svAmIjIne yadi jaina graMthoMkA avalokana kiyA hotA to unako mAlUma hotA kipaMceMdriya se lekara ekeMdriya jIvakI rakSA aura unapara dayA bhAva rakhane ke sadupadezakA keMdra eka jainadharma hai ! - 1 isake Age svAmIjI kahate haiM ki-" isa prakArakI dayA jainiyoMkA kathana mAtra hI hai kyoMki vaisA varttate nahIM " hama kahate haiM ki, kadApi jaina loga apane zAstroMke sAtvika dayAmaya upadezakA pAlana na kareM to, usameM zAstrakA kyA aparAdha haiM ? ( cahutase samAjI mahAzaya svAmIjI ke bhakta hone para bhI unake upadezakA pAlana nahIM karate to, kyA isameM svAmIjIko doSI ThaharAnA cAhiye ? udAharaNa ke lie dekho, svAmIjIne eka strIko 11 pati banAne takakI AjJA dI hai ! paraMtu zoka ki, unake do tIna lAkha bhaktoMge se Ajataka eka bhI aisA dRSTigocara nahIM huA, jisane ukta AjJAko pAla kara dikhAyA ho ! aura pAlakara dikhAve aisI AzA bhI nahIM!! phira svAmIjI ke calAe niyoga jaise pavitra mArgapara bhI unake bahuta se bhaktaM pAMva rakhate hicakate hai ! svAmIjIne to, saMnyAsI hokara bhI vidhavAoM para bar3I dayA kI thI ! paraMtu inake bhaktAM hRdaya to itane kaThora ho raheM hai ki, bicArI gharameM honevAlI anAtha vidhavAoMkI hona dazA aura uSNa zvAsa evaM karuNAmaya dIna svara se bhI unapara kucha asara nahIM hotA !!!) * svAmIjI jaina zAstroM ke samIkSaka bane haiM yA jainoMke ? yadi kisI zithilAcArI jaina vyaktipara unakA AMkSepa hai to, 7

Page #82
74 / hamArA usameM kucha vivAda nahIM; hamArA to vicAra kevala jaina zAstroM ke saMbaMdha hai. dharmakI mImAMsA, kisI vyaktigata AcaraNapara nirbhara nahIM ho sakatI ! anyathA kisI mahAzayakA. vezyA premI honA bhI svAmIjIke vaidika dharmako avazya hI lAMchita kara DAlegA !! [kha] * "kyA manuSyAdi para cAhe kisI matameM kyoM na ho dayA karake usako anna pAnAdise saMskAra karanA aura dUsare matake vidvAnoMkA mAnya aura sevA karanA dayA nahIM ? svAmI jIkA yaha lekha baDA hI parAmarza karane yogya hai ! dayAkA rahasya batalAte hue svAmIjI mahArAja ukta lekhase. madhyastha saMsArako do vAtoMkA upadeza kara rahe haiN| (1) manuSya mAtrakA (cAhe vaha kisI dharmameM vizvAsa rakhanevAlA ho) annapAnAdise satkAra karanA. arthAt naMgeko vastra, bhUkheko anna, pyAseko pAnI denA. (2) anyamatake. vidvAnokA mAna aura sevAkA karanA. ___svAmIjIke yaha dono hI upadeza niHsaMdeha mAnane yogya haiN| isa prakArake sadupadeSTAoMkA kauna aisA kutsita puruSa hai jo hRdayase dhanyavAda na kare ? jisa vakta isa prakArake sadupadezoMkI nirmala dhArA bhAratameM vahatI thI usa vakta zAMtikA samrATa bhArata hI thA! paraMtu hama apane pAThakoMko prathama itanA batalAnA cAhate haiM ki, anyamatake vidvAnoMkA mAna aura sevA karanI isa dUsare upadezapara svAmIjIne svayaM kitanA amala kiyA hai| kyoMki unake lekhAnusAra kadApi jaina matameM to anya matake vidvAnoM kA mAna aura sevA karanI na bhI ho, paraMtu svAmIjI

Page #83
75 to svayaM isakA upadeza kara rahe haiM isalie unhoMne to anyamatake vidvAnoMkA avazya hI mAna kiyA hogaa| . svAmIjIne anyamatake AcAryoM aura vidvAnoM evaM unake upAsya devoMkA sanmAna jinaM prazaMsanIya zabdoMmeM kiyA hai unamese thoDese zabda namUneke taurapara hama yahAMpara likhate haiN| [1] " sanAtanadhI vidvAnoM ke mAnanIya bhAgavatAdi purANoM ke nirmAtAkA sanmAna.!" . . vAhare vAha ! bhAgavatake banAnevAle lALa bujakkaDa ! kyA kahanA tujhakoM aisI 2 mithyA bAteM likhane meM tanika bhI lajjA aura zarama na AI nipaTa aMdhA hI vanaM gyaa| bhalA ina mahA jhUTha bAtoMko ve aMdhe popa aura vahira bhItarakI phUTI AMkhovAle unake cele bhI sunate aura mAnate haiM bar3e AzcaryakI bAta hai ki ye manuSya haiM yA anya koI !!! ina bhAgavaMtAdi purANoM ke banAne hAre janmate hI kyoM nahIM garbha jhI naSTa ho gaye ? vA janAte samaya mara kyoM na gaye ? . [ sa0 pra0 pRSTha 330] [2]"mUrtipUjaka devapUjA karanevAle vidvAnoMkA sanmAna!" gaura Apa parAdhIna bhaThayAre ke TaTTa aura kumhAra ke gadheke samAna zatruoM ke vazame hokara aneka vidhi duHkha pAte haiM...... jaba koI kisIko kahe ki hama tere baiThane ke Asana vA nAmapara patthara dhare to jaise vaha usapara kroSita hokara mAratA vA gAlI pradAna karatA hai vaise hI jo paramezvarake upAsanAke sthAna hRdaya aura nAmapara pApANAdi mUrtiyAM dharate haiM una duSTa buddhivAloMkA satyAnAza paramezvara kyoM na kre| [satyA0 pR0 312]

Page #84
76 jo pASANAdi mUrti pUjate haiM ve atIva veda virodhI haiM. [ satyA0 pR0 314 ] [3] "mUrtipUjAkA sanmAna 1" nahIM 2 mUrti pUjA sIr3hI nahIM kiMtu eka bar3I khAI hai jisameM girakara cakanAcUra ho jAtA hai punaH usa khAIse nikala nahIM sakatA kiMtu usImeM mara jAtA hai [ satyA0 pR0 311 ] [4]" maMdirameM deva pUjA karanevAle brAhmaNoMkA sammAna " ! pASANAdikI mUrti banA usake Age naivedya ghara ghaMTAnAda TaMTaM pUMpUM aura zaMkha bajA kolAhala kara aMgUThA dikhalA arthAt " tvamaMguSTaM gRhANa bhojanaM padArthaM vA ahaM grahISyAmi " jaise koI kisIko chale vA cir3Ave ki tUM ghaMTA le aura aMgUThA dikhalAve usake Agese saba padArtha le Apa bhoge vaise hI lIlA ina pUjAriyoM pUjA nAma satkarmake zatruoMkI hai| mUDhoM ko caTaka maTaka calaka jhalaka mUrtiyoMko banA ThanA Apa ThagoMke tulya banaThanake bicAre nirbuddhi anAthoMkA mAla mArake mauja karate haiM / jo koI dharmirAjA hotA to ina pASANa priyoM ( pattharake pyArayoM) ko patthara tor3ane banAne aura ghara canane Adi kAmoM meM lagAke khAne pIneko detA [ satyA * pR0 315] 1 [5] " brAhmaNakA sanmAna !," ( brAhmaNoMkI tarphase svayaM praznakarttA banakara unake viSayameM isa prakAra likhate haiM . ) prazna -- to hama kauna haiM ? uttara - tuma popa ho / prazna - popa kisako kahate haiM ?

Page #85
77 uttara --- usakI sUcanA rUmana bhASAmeM to bar3A aura pitAkA nAma popa haiM paraMtu aba chalakapaTase dUsareko Thaga kara apanA prayojana sAdhanevAleko popa kahate haiM. ityAdi ( satyAM0 pR0 278 ). 45 [6] " zaiva dharmakA sanmAna ! pazcAt ina vAmamArga aura zaivoMne sammati karake bhaga lagakA sthApana kiyA jisako jalAdhArI ( jalaharI ) aura liMga kahate haiM aura usakI pUjA karane lage una nirlajjoMko tanika bhI lajjA na AI ! ki yaha pAmarapanakA kAma hama kyoM karate haiM ? ( satyA * pR 297 ) [7] " tulasI rudrAkSa aura caMdana AdikI mAlA paharane vAloMkA sanmAna ! " jitanA rudrAkSa, bhasma, tulasI, kamalAkSa, ghAsa, caMdana Adiko kaMThameM dhAraNa karanA hai vaha saba jaMgalI pazuvat manudhyakA kAma hai ! aise vAmamArgI aura zaiva bahuta mithyAcArI virodhI aura kartavya karmake tyAgI hote haiM / [ satyA0 pra0 300 ] [8] " vaiSNava dharmakA sanmAna ! " prazna - vAmamArgI aura zaiva to acche nahIM paraMtu vaiSNava to acche haiM ? uttara - yaha bhI veda virodhI honese unase bhI adhika bure haiM / [ satyA0 pra0 pR0 301 ] cakrAMkita koga apaneko bar3e vaiSNava mAnate haiM paraMtu apanI paraMparA aura kukarmakI ora dhyAna nahIM dete ki prathama inakA mUla puruSa " zaThakopa " huA ki jo cakrAMkitoM hI ke graMthoM

Page #86
78 aura bhaktamAla graMtha jo nAbhA DUmane banAyA hai uname likhA hai-" vikrIya sUrpa vicacAra yogI" ityAdi vacana.cakrAMkitoMke graMthoMmeM likhe haiM zaThakopa yogI sUpako banA vecakara vicaratA * thA arthAt kaMjara jAtima utpanna huA thA usane brAhmaNoMse par3hanA vA sunanA cAhA hogA taba brAhmaNoM ne tiraskAra kiyA hogA usane brAhmaNoM ke viruddha saMpradAya tilaka cakrAMkita Adi zAstraviruddha manamAnI bAteM calAI hoMgI usakA celA munivAhana jo caMDAla varNameM. utpanna huA thA usakA celA " yAvanAcArya" jo ki yavana kulotpanna thA jisakA nAma badalake koI2 yAmunAcArya bhI kahate haiM unake pazcAt rAmAnuna brAhmaNa kulameM utpanna hokara cakrAMkita. huA / ityAdi [satyA0 pra0 pR0 304] [9]" zaiva matavAloMkI prazaMsA !" prazna-zaiva matavAle to acche hote haiM ? uttara-acche kahAMse hote haiM ? " jaisA pretanAtha vasau bhUtanAtha " jaise vAmamArgI maMtropadezAdise unakA dhana harate vaise zaiva bhI " OM namaH zivAya ". ityAdi paMcAkSarAdi maMtroMkA upadeza karate rudrAkSa. bhasma dhAraNa karate maTTIke aura pASANAdike liMga. banAkara pUjate haiM aura hara2 baM baM aura vakarake zabda samAna bar3e 3 mukhase zabda karate haiM | ityAdi [ satyA0 pra0 pR. 350 ] [10] " vaiSNavoMkI prazaMsA!" prazna-vaiSNava to acche haiM ?

Page #87
79 uttara -- kyA dhUr3a acche haiM ? jaise ve vaise ye haiM dekha lo vaiSNavoMkI lIlA - ityAdi [satyA0 pra0 pR0 350 ] . [11] " kavIrake matakA sanmAna prazna- cIra paMthI to acche haiM ? - uttara -- nahIM ! ityAdi (adhika dekho ) [ satyA0 pR0 454 ] [12] " sikhamata ke pravarttaka guru nAnaka sAhavakA sanmAna !" prazna - paMjAba dezameM nAnakajIne eka mArga calAyA hai kyoM ki ve bhI mUrttikA khaMDana karate the musalamAna honesa bacAye ve sAdhu bhI nahIM hue kiMtu gRhastha bane rahe dekho unhoMne yaha maMtra upadeza kiyA hai isIse cidita hotA hai ki unakA Azaya acchA thA - oM satya nAma kartA ityAdi / . uttara-- nAnakajIkA Azaya to acchA thA para vidyA kucha bhI nahIM thI, hAM bhASA usa dezakI jo ki graMthoMkI hai use jAnate the, vedAdizAstra aura saMskRta kucha bhI nahIM jAnate the, jo jAnate hote to " nirbhaya ! zabdako " nirbhI " kyoM likhate ! aura isakA dRSTAMta unakA banAyA saMskRtIstotra hai cAhate the ki bhai saMskRtameM bhI paga " aDAUM" paraMtu binA par3he saMskRta kaise AsakatA hai ? ityAdi [ satyA0 pR0 356 ] " " [ 13 ] 'mahAtmA dAdUjIkA sammAna ! prazna- dAdUpaMthIkA mArga to acchA hai ? 2 uttara---acchA to vedamArga hai jo pakar3A jAya to pakar3o nahIM to sadA gote khAte rahoge inake mata meM dAdUjI - kA janma gujarAta meM huA thA punaH 'jayapura ke pAsa

Page #88
80 Amerame rahate the telIkA kAma karate the Izvarako sRSTikI vicitra lIlA hai ki dAdUjI bhI pujAne. laga gaye ! ityAdi [ satyA0 pR0 358 ] [14] " rAmasnehI matakA sanmAna !" "thor3e dina hue ki eka rAmasnehI mata zAhApurAse calA hai unhoMne saba vedokta dharma chor3ake rAma 2 pukAranA acchA. mAnA hai usImeM jJAna dhyAna mukti mAnate haiM paraMtu jaba bhUkha lagatI hai taba " rAmanAma " me se roTI zAka nahIM nikalatA kyoM ki khAna Adi to gRhasthoMke gharahImeM milate haiM vebhI mUrti pUjAko ghi kArate hai paraMtu Apa svayaM mUrti bana rahe haiN| striyoM ke saMgameM bahuta rahate haiM kyoMki rAmajIko "rAmakI" ke vinA AnaMda nahIM mila sktaa| [satyA.pR.358-59-60 meM dekho] / [15]" gokuliye gusAiyoMkA sanmAna !" prazna-gokuliye gusAiyoMkA mata to bahuta acchA hai dekho kaisA aizvarya bhogate haiM kyA yaha aizvarya lIlAke vinA. aisA ho sakatA hai ? uttara-yaha aizvarya gRhastha logoMkA hai gusAiyoMkA kucha nhiiN| prazna-vAha ! 2 gusAiyoMke pratApase hai| uttara-dUsare bhI isI prakArakA chala prapaMca raceM to aizvarya milaneme kyA saMdeha hai ? aura jo inase adhika dhUrtatA karate to adhika bhI .aizcarya ho sktaa| [sa0 pR. 362] (kha) ye gosAMI loga apane saMpradAyako " puSTimArga" kahate haiM arthAt khAne pIne puSTa hone aura saba striyoMke saMga yatheSTa bhoga vilAsa karaneko puSTi mArga kahate haiM ! paraMtu inase

Page #89
'pUchanA cAhiye ki jaba bar3e duHkha dAI bhaMgadarAdi rogagrasta hokara aise jhIka 2 kara marate haiM ki jisako yehI jAnate hoMge saca pUcho to puSTi mArga nahIM kiMtu kuSTimArga hai jaise kuSTike zarIrakI saba dhAtu pighala 2 ke nikala jAtI haiM aura vilApa - karatA huA zarIra choDatA hai aisI hI lIlA inakI bhI dekhanemeM AtI hai isaliye narakamArga bhI isIko kahanA saMghaTita ho sakatA hai. [sa0 pR0 366] - (ga) go loka svargakI apekSA narakavat ho gayA hogA athavA jaise vahuta strIgAmI puruSa bhagaMdarAdi rogoMse pIDita rahate haiM vaisA hI golokameM bhI hogA ! chi chi !! cha !!! (ityAdi satyArtha prakAza pRSTha 367 se 369 takakA lekha avazya dekhane yogya hai) [16] " svAmI nArAyaNa matakA sanmAna !" (prazna ) svAmInArAyaNakA mata kaisA hai ? (uttara) "yAzI zItalAdevI tAdRzaH kharavAhanaH" jaisI gusAMijIkI dhana.haraNa AdimeM vicitra lIlA hai vaisI hI svAmInArANayakI bhI hai ! [ sa0 pR0 369] . . ( isa matake saMbaMdhameM pRSTha 370 meM svAmIjIne eka nAkakaToMkI kathA likhI hai ! vistArake bhayase use yahAM uddhRta nahIM kiyA gayA pAThaka mahodaya vahAMse hI dekha leveM.) [17] "mA dhva aura liMgAMkita saMpradAyakA sanmAna " (prazna ) mAdhva mata to acchA hai ! ( uttara ) jaise anya matAvalaMbI haiM vaise hImAdhva bhI haiM ... kyoMki ye bhI cakrAMkita hote haiM [ityAdi-sa0 pR0 373 ] . . (prazna ) liMgAMkitakA mata kaisA hai ? (prabhA . ( uttara ) jaisA cakrAMkitakA [ityAdi-sa0 pR0 374 ]

Page #90
[18] "'brahma samAja aura prArthanA samAjakA sammAna !" .. (prazna ) brahmasamAja aura prArthanA samAja to acchA hai cAM nahIM ! ( uttara ) kucha 2 bAteM acchI haiM aura bahutasI burI haiM | ityAdi-sa0 0 374 se 380] [19] "jaina dharmakA sanmAna !" ( ka ) sabase vairaM virodha niMdA IrSA Adi duSTa karmarUpa sAgarameM DuvAnevAlA jaina mArga hai jaise jainI loga sabake * niMdaka hai vaisA koI bhI dusarA matavAlA mahA niMdaka aura adharmI na hogA. [ sa0. pR0 431] (kha) saba pAkhaMDoMkA mUla bhI jaina mata hai. [ satyArtha prakAza pR0 440 ] ___ (20) " DhUMDhaka matavAloMkA sanmAna !" . (ka) zvetAMbaroMmeMse DhUMDhiyA aura DhUMDhiyoMmeMse terApaMthI Adi DhoMgI nikale haiM. . . . (kha) jaise aMtyajoMkI durgaMdhaka sahavAsase pRthaM rahanevAle bahuta acche haiM jaise aMtyajoMkI durgaMdhake sahavAsase nirmalabuddhi nahIM hotI vaise tuma aura tumhAre saMgiyoMkI bhI bUddhi nahIM 'bar3hetI jaise rogakI adhikatA aura bUddhike svalpa honese dharmAnuSThAnakI bAdhA hotI hai vaise hI durgaMdhayukta tumhArA aura tumhAre saMgiyoMkA bhI vartamAna hotA hogA (sa0pR0 449) . (21)" IsAI matakA sanmAna !" (ka) isa liye asaMbhava bAta kahanA IsAkI ajJAnatAkA prakAza karatA hai bhalA jo kucha bhI IsAmeM vidyA hotI * * " svAmIjI to sabako tAranevAle haiM ! isIlie unhone kisI matakI bhI prazaMsA karanemeM truTi nahIM rakhI !!" (lekhaka)

Page #91
to aisI . aTADhUTa, jaMgalIpanakI bAteM kyoM kaha detA ? ( satyArtha prakAza pR0 496) (kha) saca to yahI hai ki yaha pustaka IsAIyoMkA aura * IsA IzvarakA veTA jinhoMne banAye ve zaitAna hoM to ho. ityAdi-sa0 pR0 505) (ga) yohana Adi saba jaMgalI manuSya the. ( ityAdi sa0pra0 pra0 sakAmI matakA salamAna lA . (22) ":isakAmI matakA sanmAna !" (ka) yaha kurAna kurAnakA khudA aura musalamAna loga kevala pakSapAta avidyAke bhare hue haiM isIliye musalamAna loga aMdheremeM haiM ( sa0 pra0 538) (kha) aMba dekhiye kitane mahApakSapAtakI bAta hai ki jo musalamAna na ho usako jahAM pAo mAraDAlo aura musalamAnoMko na mAranA bhUlase musalamAnoM ke mAranameM prAyazcita aura anyako mAranemeM bahizta milegA aise upadezako kueMge DAlanA , cAhiye aise aise pustaka aise2 paigaMbara aise 2 khudA aura aisera matase sivAya hAnise lAbha kucha nahIM aisAMkA na honA acchA hai.* ( sa0 pR0 541) * kurAnake aMdara yadi ukta zikSAkA upadeza ho to usapara svAmIjIkA isa prakArase likhanA TIka mAlama paDanA hai, kyoMki musalamAnase anyako (cAhe usane kucha bhI aparAdha na karA ho) mAra DAlanA, aura musalamAna (cAhe vaha aparAdhI bhI ho) ko . bhUla kara bhI nahIM mAranA-yaha upadeza nyAyako siimaa| . nissaMdeha bAhara hai ! paraMtu hame vivaza hokara kahanA paDanA. hai ki, svAmI mahodayake yajurvedAdi bhApyomeM bhI isa prakArakI suzikSAkI kamI nahIM!. udAharaNArtha yajurveda bhASyaM adhyAya 12 maMtra 13 " he rAja puruSa.!.

Page #92
84 (23) " saba matoMke vidvAnoMkA sanmAna !" svAmIjIne satyArtha prakAzake pRSTha 380 se 382 takameM eka kalpita kathA likhI hai usameM jijJAsuke praznottara rUpase saba matoM aura unake vidvAnoMkI prazaMsA karate hue ve likhate haiM ki, " phira Age calA to saba matavAloMne apanera ko saccA kahA koI hamArA kavIra saccA koI nAnaka koI dAdU koI vallabha koI sahajAnaMda koI mAdhava Adiko avatAra batalAte sunA sahasroseM pUcha unake paraspara eka dusarekA virodha dekha vizeSa nizcaya kiyA ki inameM koI guru karane yogya nahIM kyoMki eka ekake jhUThameM 999 gvAha ho gaye jaise jhUThe dukAnadAra vA vezyA aura bhaDuA Adi apanIra vastukI baDAI. dUsarekI burAI karate haiM vaise hI ye haiM !" ityAdi / . samAlocaka-AzA hai ki anyamatoM tathA matAMtarIya vidvAnoMkA svAmIjIne kitanA satkAra kiyA hai isase aba hamAre pAThaka aparicita na rahe hoMge ! matAMtarIya vidvAnoMkA Apa dharmake virodhI duzmanoMko AgameM jalA deveM ! ! ai teja,dhArI puruSa ! jo hamAre duzmanoMko utsAha ( hausalA ) detA hai usako Apa ulaTA laTakA kara sUkhI lakar3IkI taraha jalA deveM.!!! evaM. yaju. a. 15 maMtra 17 " hama loga jisase zatrutA ( duzmanI) kareM aura jo hamase zatrutA ( duzmanI ) kareM usako hama 'vyAghra Adike. hameM DAleM aura rAjA bhI usako vyAghra Adike muMhameM DAla de " tathA-yaju. a. 6 maMtra. 22 " he paramezvara ! ApakI kRpAse jala aura auSadhiyeM (anAja vagairaha ) hamAre liye sukhakAraka (sukhake denevAlI ) hoM ! aura jo hama logoMse dveSa ( duzmanI karatA hai aura jisase hama loga dveSa karate haiM usake liye ye ( anna aura jalAdi vastu ) duHkha denevAle hoM !" ityAdi adhika dekhanevAle vahAM para hI dekha leveM !

Page #93
85 svAmIjIne jina madhura zabdoMse satkAra kiyA hai unakI prazaMsAke lie hama lAcAra haiM ki, hamAre pAsa koI bhI zabda nahIM ! zoka kevala itanA hI hai ki, hamAre durbhAgya se svAmIjI zIghra hI saMsAra cala base ! anyathA bhAratIya dhArmika samAja meM "unakI kRpAse utpanna huI zAMtikI jvAlA niHsaMdeha pracaMDa dAvAnala ke svarUpako dhAraNa kiye vinA na rahatI ! paraMtu kyA kiyA jAve " devo hi duratikramaH " ! kadApi koI svAmIjIke ukta lekhakA ( jo ki unhoMne anyamatoM aura vidvAnoM ke bAremeM satyArtha prakAzameM prakAzita kiyA hai. ) yaha Azaya batalAve ki " anyamatake vidvAnoMkA mAna karanA " isakA itanA hI artha hai ki, yadi koI anya matakA vidvAna apane pAsa Ave to usako apane pAsa biThalAnA aura usase AnaMda pUrvaka vAtacIta karanI, graMthoM meM usakI athavA usake dharmakI peTa bharakara niMdA karaneme kucha burAI nahIM ! isakA tAtparya to yaha ho sakatA hai ki, kisI matake vidvAnako mUMhase gAlI denI acchI nahIM hai, likhakarake to cAhe jitanI dI jAveM utanI thor3I haiM ! astu ! isa prakArakA ! sammAna karanevAle mahAzayoMse to hamArA mauna hI uttarameM nivedana hai ! sajjano ! " kyA manuSyAdipara dayA karake usakA annapAnAdise satkAra karanA aura dUsare matake vidvAnokA mAna karanAM dayA nahIM hai ?" isa kathanase svAmIjI jainoMpara kyA AkSepa karanA cAhate haiM ? yaha samajhameM nahIM AtA ! kyA jaina ukta karmako dayA nahIM samajhate ? athavA unake zAstroM meM kyA isa karmako dayA nahIM batalAyA ? aisA to nahIM. kyoMki, jainazAtroM meM varNana kiye hue- supAtra, abhaya, anukaMpA, kIrtti aura 8

Page #94
ucita ina pAMca prakArake donoM se anukaMpA dAnakA yahI vAtparya hai ki, anAtha-dIna-duHkhI manuSyAdi prANiyoMko (cAhe vaha kisI jAti athavA kisI matake hoM) dayA bhAvase anna vastrAdi denA aura unakI yogya sevA karanI / "dharmavidu" meM jainAcArya zrI haribhadrasUri likhate. haiM ki,-" tathA duHkhiteSvanukampA yathAzakti dravpato. bhAvatazva " adhyAya 3 sUtra 61 / arthAt duHkhI prANiyoMpara yathAzakti dravyase aura bhAvase dayA karanI / evaM ukta graMthake TIkAkAra "prAyaH saddharmavIjAni " dharmavindu a0 2 sUka. 1 ityAdi sUtrameM likhate haiM ki, "saddharmasya samyak jJAnadarzanacAritrarUpasya bIjAni kAraNAni tAnicAmUni--duHkhiteSu. dayAtyantamadveSaH guNavatsu ca / aucityAsevanazcaitra, sarvataivAvizeSataH // 1 // arthAt duHkhI prANiyoMpara ati dayA karanI (1) guNI vidvAnoMse adveSa arthAt prema rakhanA / (2) sarvatra. samabhAvase ucitta vyavahArakA AcaraNa karanA / (3) yaha tInoMhI jJAna darzana aura caritra rUpa dharmake mukhya vIja arthAt, kAraNa haiM / isalie jainoMke viSayameM svAmIjIkA ukta AkSepa sarvathA anucita pratIta hotA hai| isake anaMtara jo svAmIjIne kucha vivekasArakA pATha uddhRta kiyA hai usake viSayameM hama kevala itanAhI kahanA ucita samajhate haiM ki, vivekasArakI jaina dharmake kisI bhI. mAnanIya graMthameM gaNanA nahIM hai ! yaha eka bilakula sAdhAraNa. bhASAkA choTAsA saMgraha graMtha hai ! jabataka isake ukta lekhakA AdhAra jaina matake kisI mAnya graMthameM na mile tabataka isapara vicAra karanA kevala pAnI viloneke samAna niSphala hai ! paraMtu, vivekasArake pAThako uddhRta karake usapara samIkSA karate hue

Page #95
87 jo svAmIjI jainoMko anya matake dveSI batalAte haiM yaha unakA apUrva sAhasa hai ! saMsArabharake dharmokI jI kholakara niMdA karate hue bhI svAmIjI svayaM to anya matoMse sahAnubhUti rakhanevAle caneM, aura jainoMko anya matake virodhI batalAveM ! pAThaka mahodaya ! kSamA kIjie, yaha unakI niraMkuzatA nahIM to kyA hai ? hama nahIM samajhate ki, svAmIjIke anokhe jIvanako AMkhe mIcakara nyAyake saMcemeM DhalA huA batalAnevAle kitaneka samAjI mahAzaya anyAyakA keMdra kisa jaMgalakI cir3iyAko samajha rahe haiM / sajjano ! jainoM tathA jaina graMthoMpara lagAye hue svAmIjIke asabhya apavAda kahAMtaka satya haiM isake saMbaMdhameM hama apanI tarphase kucha bhI na kahakara kevala jainatattvAdarza nAmake graMthakA kucha pATha uddhRta karate haiM. AzA hai ki, isako (ukta pustakase uddhRta kiye hue pAThako) dhyAna pUrvaka par3hanese satyAsatyakI chAnavIna karanekA Apako bahuta hI zIghra samaya milegA! ukta graMthake nirmAtA paralokavAsI jainAcArya zrImad vijayAnaMda sUri urpha* AtmArAmajI haiM. jaina zAstroMdvArA gRhastha dharmakA varNana karate hue Apane likhA hai ki-- "aba paratIrtha-anyamatavAloMse (jaina gRhasthakA) ." ucita vyavahAra likhate haiM. yadi bhanyadharmake (arthAt bhikSu) "bhikSAke vAste (jaina gRhastha ke ) gharameM Ave to unakA " ucita satkAra karanA, tathA rAjAkA evaM anya mAnanIya " (puruSoM) kA yogya satkAra karanA, yathAyogya dAna denA, " yadi una sAdhuoMpara bhaktibhAva na bhI ho to bhI gharameM isa vIsavIM sadImeM jaina samAjameM Apa eka nAmAMkita vidvAn aura prAmANika purupa hogae haiN| dar

Page #96
88 mAMgane AyoM ko denA cAhiye; kyoMki dAna denA yaha gRhasthakA < "dharma hI hai. tathA anya koI mahAn puruSa gharameM Ave to 41 " ( jaina gRhastha, ) usako Asana denA, sanmukha jAnA, uThakara " khar3e honA Adise ucita satkAra kare. tathA anyadharmavAlA " 46 88 " kisI meM paDA hove to usakA uddhAra kare / duHkhI " jIvoMpara dayA kare. ( gharameM Anepara ) anya matavAloMse kAma kAja pUche, jaise ki ApakA AnA kisa prayojanake vAste huA hai ? pIche vaha jo kAma batAve usako yogya " samajhe to pUrA kare. tathA duHkhI, anAtha, aMdhA, vaharA, rogI Adi dIna logoMkI dInatAko apanI zaktike anusAra dUra kare. " ityAdi : [ jainatattvAdarza pRSTha 454 ] 88 isake Age supAtra prabhRti dAnoMke avAMtara bhedoM kA varNana karate hue Apa likhate haiM ki - ( jaina gRhastha ) " apanI zaktike anusAra bhojana ke samaya ( gharameM ) Aye hue " sAdharmIyoMkoM apane sAtha bhojana karAve, kyoMki ve bhI pAtra haiM. 66 tathA aMdhe Adi mAMganevAloM ko bhI yathAzakti deve, paraMtu kisIko nirAza na jAne deve. dharmakI niMdA na karAve, " kaThina hRdayavAlA na bane, bhojana ke samaya dayAvAn ( jaina 66 "1 gRhasthako ) kapATa lagAne na cAhiye, usameM bhI dhanavAnko " to avazya hI kapATa nahIM lagAne, Agama ( jainagraMthoM ) "" meM kahA hai ki- " neva dAraM pihAveI, bhuMjamANo susAvao / " aNukaMpA jiNidehiM, saDhANaM na nivAriyA // 1 // 46 dahUNa pANinivaha, bhIme bhavasAyaraMmi dukkhattaM / " aviseMsa aNukaMpa, duhAvi sAmatthao kuNaI ||2||

Page #97
89 arthAt bhojana ke samaya meM ( jaina. gRhastha ) gharakA << " daravAjA baMdha na kare, kyoMki jinezvara bhagavAnne zrAvakaM " ( jaina gRhastha ) ke liye anukaMpA dAnakA kahIM niSedha nahIM " kiyA (1) bhayAnaka saMsArameM duHkhoMse pIDita prANi samudAyapara dravyaM aura bhAvase samAna dayAbhAva rakhe (2) zrI paMcamAMgAdikameM " jahAM zrAvakakA varNana kiyA hai vahAM "avaguMThia duvArA " " aisA pATha likhA hai, arthAt bhikSu Adike pravezake vAste zrAva " kako hara samaya daravAjA khulA rakhanA cAhiye / dInoMkA uddhAra " to saMvatsarI dAnameM tIrthaMkaroMne bhI kiyA hai / kadApi kAla duSkAla par3a jAve tatra to zrAvaka vizeSa karake dAnAdise dInoMkA uddhAra kre| Age vikrama saMvat 1325 meM bhadresara " grAma nivAsI zrImAla jAtike jaina gRhastha zAha jhagar3ane 112 " dAnazAlAyeM dAna deneke liye kholI thIM / " ityAdi [ jainatattvAdarza pRSTha. 457-58 ] 88 hame AzA hai ki, jainatattvAdarza ke sapramANa ukta lekhako dhyAna pUrvaka par3hane se hamAre pAThaka avazya hI kisI natIje para pahuMca jAya~ge / svAmIjIkA jainoMke viSayameM paramata dveSI aura nirdayI Adi likhanA sabhyatA aura satyatAko sImAkA kitanA pAlana kara rahA hai isakI mImAMsA ve aba bahuta hI sugamatA se kara sakeMge ! hama apane pAThakoMse itanAM nivedana aura bhI karate haiM ki, janasAdhAraNakI sevAkA zaMkha phUkanevAle svAmIjI mahArAjake nIce likhe hue dayAmaya eka upadezako ve avazya par3heM / 66 "" satyArtha prakAza pRSTha 278 meM svAmIjI likhate haiM ki - " paraMtu jo brAhmaNa nahIM hoM unakA na brAhmaNa nAma aura na unakI sevA karane yogya hai " //

Page #98
[ga] vivekasAra pRSTha 108kA havAlA dete hue svAmIjIne namuci nAmake dIvAnakI kathA likhakara jo jainoMko hiMsaka taka kaha mArA hai ! usake bAremeM pAThakoMse hamArA itanA hI nivedana hai ki, ukta graMthake pRSTha 108meM isa prakArakI kathAkA ullekha nahIM hai / astu ! " tupyatu durjanaH" isa nyAyase hama svAmIjIko ukta kathAko thoDe samayake lie satya mAna kara hI usapara vicAra karate haiN| jainoMne yadi mathurAke rAjAke namuci nAmA dIvAnako apanA virodhI samajhakara mAra DAlA to isase svAmIjIko kyA kSati pahuMcI thI jo unhoMne jainoMkI niMdA karanemeM jI tor3a mehanata kI ? / hamAre khyAlameM to svAmIjIko bahuta prasanna honA cAhie thA ! kyoMki unake siddhAMtase yaha kathA kitaneka aMzameM milatI julatI hai ! jaise-" zatruke nagaroMko ujAr3ane, vaidika dharmake virodhiyoMko AgameM jalAne, vyAghra Adi hiMsaka prANiyoMke muMhame dene aura tar3aphA tar3aphA kara mArane " AdikA sadupadeza svAmIjI svayaM hI bhArata saMtAnako kara gae haiM !-dekho unakA yajurveda bhASya / zoka hai ki, namuci nAmA dIvAnako jainoMne kyoM mArA ? usane jainoMkA kyA aparAdha kiyA thA ? athavA vinA hI aparAdhake usako mAra DAlA ? ityAdi bAtoMkA kucha bhI kisI jaina graMthake AdhArase svAmIjIne varNana nahIM kiyA ! yadi ukta maMtrIne jainoMkA koI vizeSa aparAdha kiyA hogA to usako prANAMta daMDa denA koI , anucita kAma nahIM; kyoMki, svAmIjI svayaM likhate hai ki "duSToMko daMDa denA bhI dayAmeM gaNanIya hai" kadApi nirapa'rAdhako hI jainoMne mArA ho ! yaha svAmIjI bhale kaheM ! itihAsaH

Page #99
91 to isa bAtakA ghora virodhI hai ! jaina rAjAoMke samaya meM bhI jainoMne kisI prakArakA anya matoMse balAtkAra yA atyAcAra nahIM kiyA, aisA itihAsase jAna paDatA hai ! isalie anyamata sahiSNutA ke saMbaMdha meM jainoM ko yadi hama prathama zreNImeM mAne to koI atyukti nahIM hai !! svAmIjIne jo jainoMko vRthA hI nirdayI aura hiMsaka kahakara apanI sarasvatIko pavitrata kiyA hai isake viSaya meM hama unako dhanyavAda hI dete haiM ! ! ! [ gha ] svA0 da0 sa0--" samyaka zraddhAna samyaka darzana jJAna aura cAritra ye cAra mokSamArga ke sAdhana haiM ! inakI vyAkhyA yogadevane kI hai ityAdi [ satyA0 pR0 428 ] sarvathA'navadyayogAnAM tyAgazcArita mucyate / kIrttitaM tadahiMsAdi vrata bhedena paMcadhA // saba prakArase nindanIya anya mata saMbaMdha kA tyAga cAritra kahAtA hai aura ahiMsAdi bhedase pAMca prakArakA vrata hai / ( satyA0 pR0 429 ) [gha] samAlocaka- svAmIjIne jaina graMthoMkA kahAM baiThakara adhyayana kiyA hogA ? isakA patA lagAte hue hama isI pariNAmapara pahuMce haiM ki, vaha sthAna aisA honA cAhie ki, jahAM para sivA aMdhakAra ke anya vastukA astitva hI na ho ! jaina ke kisI bhI graMtha meM mokSake ukta cAra sAdhana nahIM batalAe. yadi kisI graMtha svAmajikei kathanAnusAra likhA hoto samajha lo ki vaha jaina matakA graMtha hI nahIM ! astu ! bandhyAyA: bhogyAM vidhAtuM svAmina eva samarthAH ! !

Page #100
[ca] sajano ! svAmIjIkI prAkRta saMbaMdhi vijJatAko chor3a kara unake saMskRta pAMDitya parabhI yadi kucha dRSTi DAlI jAve to vahAMbhI sivA AMsU bahAneke aura kucha nahIM ho sakatA ! jo loga unako maharSi aura bhagavAnke bailUnapara para car3hA rahe, haiM ! una vicAroM kI bhI zAstrIya yogyatA aura saMskRta jJAna hadase pAra hI honA cAhie ! Upara likhe hue jaina graMthake saMskRta zlokake jisa Adhe bhAgake nIce laMbIsI lakIra baiMcI hai usakA artha yadi Apa eka laghukaumudI par3hanevAle vidyArthIse bhI pUchoge to voha bhI yaha spaSTa batalA sakegA ki, ukta zlokakA yaha AdhA bhAga azuddha hai! aura svAmIjIne jo usa (azuddha) kA bhI artha kiyA hai usakA ukta zlokake sAtha itanA bhI saMbaMdha nahIM, jitanA ki eka sanyAsI mahAtmAkA vezyAke sAtha bhI hotA hai! hama hairAna haiM ki, "sarvathAnavadyayogAnAM tyAgazcAritramucyate" ina akSaroMkA "saba prakArake niMdanIya anya mata saMbaMdhakA. tyAga" yaha artha svAmIjIne kisa vyAkaraNa athavA paddhatike anusAra kiyA hai ? yadyapi svAmIjI isa samayameM nahIM haiM paraMtu, unako bhagavAnkI melaTrenameM savAra karAnevAle abhI lAkhoMkI saMkhyA vidyamAna haiM ! unameM paMDitamanyoMkI bhI kucha nyUna saMkhyA nahIM ! kyA ve svAmIjI mahArAjakI ukta artha saMbaMdhita mugdhatAmeM kucha sahAnubhUti prakaTa kareMge ? yadi koI samAjI mahAzaya satyArtha prakAzameM uddhRta kiye hue ukta zlokake jyUke yUM pAThako jaina graMthoMmeMse batalAne aura vyAkaraNa athavA anya kisI mAnanIya paddhatike anusAra usake svAmIjI dvArA kiye gaye arthako satya pramANita karanekI kRpA kareM to hama . unakA

Page #101
bar3A. hI AbhAra mAneMge ! paraMtu yaha bhAzA yadi niSphala nahIM to saphala honI bhI asaMbhava hai.! . . hama apane vidvAn pAThaka samudAyase bhI prArthanA karate haiM ki, ve svAmI mahodayake kiye hue arthapara avazya lakSa deM! ukta zlokako artha karate samaya svAmIjIne akelI mugdhatAse hI kAma liyA ho aisA nahIM, kiMtu usake sahodara durAgrahako * bhI apane pAsa biThA rakhA thA ! anyathA "anyamata saMbaMdhakA tyAga" yaha kina akSaroMkA artha kiyA gayA ? yaha svAmIjIne anyamatoMkA jainadharma para dveSa bar3hAneke lie hI likhA hai ! aisA spaSTa mAlama par3atA hai| svAmIjIne sikha dharmake AcArya guru nAnaka devajIkI khillI ur3Ate hue likhA hai ki-" ve cAhate the ki maiM bhI saMskRtameM paga ar3AUM paraMtu vinA paDhe saMskRta kaise AsakatI hai?" [sa.pR0 366] hamAre khyAlameM kadApi guru nAnaka devajI, svAmIjIke isa upAlaMbhake uttara dAtA nabhI ho sakeM ! kyoMki unhoMne sAdhAraNa logoMke bodhake lie kevala sarala paMjAbI bhASAmeM hI apane sAragarmita upadezoMkA saMgraha kiyA hai ! aura ve saMskRta jAnanekA abhimAna karate hoM aisA unake lekhase vidita nahIM hotA ! isalie unake viSayameM isa prakArakA AkSepa karanA sivA ISAMke aura kucha tAtparya nahIM rakhatA! hAM! svAmIjIke saMbaMdhameM yaha bAta acchI taraha saM gaThita ho sakatI hai ! kyoMki unapara isa bAtakI jokhamadArI sabase adhika hai ! ve maharSi the ! ve vedoMke evaM zAstroMke AcArya the ! unake vizAla pAMDityakI vijaya patAkA abhI taka bhI phar3a phar3A rahI hai ! isalie unake kiye hue ukta zlokake " kIrtitaM tadahiMsAdivatabhedena paMcadhA" isa avaziSTa arddha. bhAgake

Page #102
aura ahiMsAdi bhedase pAMca prakArakA vrata hai" isa arthako dekhakara hama vinA saMkoca yaha kahanekA sAhasa kara sakate haiM ki, svAmIjI jaina graMthoMko par3he sune to kucha bhI nahIM the! paraMtu cAhate the ki, maiM bhI unameM paga aDAUM ! paraMtu vinA kisI yogya jaina vidvAnkI sevA kiye jainagraMthoMkA marma kahAM samajhameM A sakatA hai ? kadApi hama svAmaniki hI ukta arthakI pUMcha pakar3akara caleM ! to bhI kisI pariNAmapara pahuMca sakeM aisI hame AzA nahIM ! kyoMki Age calakara jo unhoMne ukta zloka ke saMbaM'dharma samIkSA kI hai vaha sacamuca hI svAmIjI ke pUrva kathana ke virodhameM eka nirdaya rAkSasa senAM jaisA kAma kara rahI hai ! svAmIjI, jainoMkI tarphase pUrvapakSameM "saba prakArake niMdanIya anyamata saMbaMdhakA tyAga cArita kahAtA hai" likhate hue isakI samIkSA meM pharamAte haiM ki "kyA yaha choTI niMdA hai ki jinake graMtha dekhanese hI " pUrNa vidyA aura dhArmikatA pAijAtI hai unako burA kahanA! " aura apane mahA asaMbhava jaisAki pUrva likha Aye haiM vaisI " bAtoM ke kahanevAle tIrthakaroMkI stuti karanA ! kevala haThakI " bAteM haiM bhalA jo jainI kucha cAritra na kara sake, na par3ha sake, " na dAna denekA sAmarthya ho to bhI jainamata saccA hai kyA " itanA kahane hIse vaha uttama ho jAye aura anyamatavAle zreSTa " bhI azreSTa ho jAyeM ? aise kathana karanevAle manuSyoM ko prAMta " aura bAlabuddhi na kahAjAya to kyA kaheM ? isameM yahI vidita " hotA hai ki inake AcArya svArthI the pUrNa vidvAna nahIM the|" - svAmIjIkI samIkSA ukta zlokArtha se kitanA saMbaMdha rakhatI hai. isakA inasApha hama pAThakoMpara hI choDate haiM !

Page #103
95 kyoMki aisI mahatvapUrNa samIkSApara vicAra karane kI hamameM yo-gyatA nahIM hai / saca pUcho to svAmIjIkI samIkSA aura paMjAbI kI "vaNa vica phuliyAM kikarAM, lagge seU vera / jhar3a jhar3a paiNa parAtaDe, dekha dAladA svAda !" yaha kahAvata, dono sagI bahane haiM ! | sabhyavRMdo ! "saba prakArake niMdanIya anyamata saMbaMdhakA tyAga" isa kalita zlokArtha parabhI svAmIjI yadi kucha rozanI DAla jAte to bhI ve kisI aMzameM stutya samajhe jAne lAyaka the ! astu aba hama ukta zloka aura usakA ThIka ThIka artha karake pAThakoM ke una saMdehoM ko dUra karate haiM, jinakA svAmIjI ke lekhako dekhakara honA eka svAbhAvika hai !!. "sarvasAvadyayogAnAM tyAgazcAritramucyate / kIrtitaM tadahiMsAdi - vratabhedena paJcadhA // artha - sarva prakAra ke pApayukta vyApArake parityAgakA nAma cAritra hai, vaha (cAritraM) ahiMsAdi (ahiMsA 1 satya 2 asteya 3 brahmacarya 4 aparigraha 5 ) vrata bhedase pAMca prakArakA haiM. isakA sphuTa bhAva yaha hai ki, saba taraha ke bure kAmoMko chor3ane kA nAma cAritra hai. vaha, kisI jivako mAranA nahIM ?, satya bolanA 2, corI nahIM karanA 3, brahmacarya rakhanA 4, kisI vastu mamatva nahIM rakhanA 9, ina bhedoMse pAMca tarahakA hai / jinako pAtaMjala darzana aura manusmRti meM yamake nAmase pukArA hai, unhI kI jaina zAstroM meM vrata saMjJA hai. inakA niraMtara pAlanakaranA svAmIjI bhI batalAte haiM ! dekho [ satyA0 pR0 47 ] . sajjano ! ukta zloka meM kyA hI suMdara evaM zAMtimaya / upadezakA sarala aura spaSTa zabdoM meM varNana kiyA hai ! ekasAdhAraNa paDhA likhA huA bhI bar3e anAyAsa se samajha sakatA.

Page #104
hai! paraMtu svAmIjI jaise prakhara vidvAn aise sAra garmita upadezake viSayameM vinA hI samajhe kSudratAkA paricaya deveM yaha kitane duHkhakI bAta hai ! ! satya hai " ghUmA kokila vRMda bIca sukhase Ajanma tU kAka re, chor3A kiMtu kaTUktiko na phira bhI hA haMta tUne are // kiMvA hai lavaleza doSa isameM terA nahIM durmate, yA yasya prakRtiH svabhAva janitA kenApi na tyajyate // 1 // [cha ] svA0 da0 sa0-- mUla--jiNavara ANAbhaMga, umagA usmuttlesdesnno| ANA bhaMge pAvaM, tA jiNamaya dukkaraM dhammaM // SaSTI za.sU.11.. "unmArga utsUtrake leza dikhAnese jo jinavara arthAt bItarAga tIrthaMkaroMkI AjJAkA bhaMga hotA hai vaha duHkhakA hetu pApa hai. jinezvarake kahe samyaktvAdi dharmakA grahaNa karanA baDA kaThina hai isaliye jisa prakAra jina AjJAkA bhaMga na ho vaisA karanA cAhiye // 1 // (samIkSaka ): jo apane hI mukhase apanI prazaMsA aura apane hI dharmako bar3A kahanA aura dusarekI niMdA karanI hai vaha mUrkhatAkI vAta hai kyoMki prazaMsA usIkI ThIka hai jisakI dUsare vidvAn kareM apane mukhase apanI prazaMsA to caura bhI karate haiM to kyA ve prazaMsanIya ho sakate haiM ? isI prakArakI inakI bAteM haiM" [ satyArtha pra0 pR0 429-30 ] [cha ] samAlocaka-svAmIjI kahate haiM ki-" apane mukhase apanI bar3Ai karanI mUrkhatAkA kAma hai| unakA yaha kathana saMcamucahI suvarNAkSaroMmeM mudrita karane lAyaka hai ! apane muMhase

Page #105
97 apanI bar3AI karanI mUrkhatA hI nahIM ! pratyuta pAmaraMtA bhI hai| paraMtu isa kaMthanako Upara kahI gaI prAkRta gAthAke sAtha kyA saMbaMdha hai, isakA uttara yadi kisI nippakSa 'bidvAnse pUchA * jAveto. AzA nahIM ki vaha svAmIjIkI svairiNI icchAke sivA * kucha aurabhI kahanekA sAhasa kara sake ! kyA Upara likhe hue prAkRta lokameM apane mukhase apanI bar3AI aura anyakI niMdA karanekA upadeza hai ? yadi nahIM to hameM balAt kahanA par3egA ki, svAmIjI jainamatake saMbaMdha avazya IkiluSita the ! sajano ! kisI eka AdamIko sirameM dhotI aura kamarameM kamIja bAMdhate dekha kara pAsameM baiThe hue eka bhadrapuruSane kahA ki, mitra ! aisA mata karo ! dhotIko kamarameM bAMdho aura kamInako galemeM DAlo ! yaha suna vaha bolA ki, basa karo sAhiba rahane do ! kala Apane bhI to lar3ake kI zAdI karI thI jisameM hamako bulAyA taka bhI nahIM ! sacamuca hI svAmIjIkI samIkSAkI bhI yahI dazA hai ! ukta zlokameM kathana to yaha hai ki, " utsUtratA aura unmArgatAse tIrthaMkaroMkI AjJAkA bhaMga hotA hai vaha pApa hai isalie unakI AjJAkA ullaMghana karanA ucita nahIM" paraMtu svAmIjI samIkSA karate haiM ki-" apane mukhase apanI bar3AI aura dUsarekI niMdA karanI mUrkhatAkI bAta hai" pAThaka mahodaya ! kahie ! svAmIjIke graMthoMse atirikta bhI kahIM isa prakArakI samIkSA dekhanemeM AI ? dekho bhI kahAM ! svAmIjI jaisA dUsarA samIkSaka Aja taka koI paidA huA hI nahIM ! hAM ! bhaviSyatmeM koI ho jAya to hama kaha nahIM sakate ! hamAre vartamAna Arya mahAzayoMko yaha jAna kara bar3A hI prasanna honA cAhiye ki, bhagavAna svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatI 2

Page #106
28 mahArAja, veda bhASyoMke amUlya ratna bhaMDArako unake sapurda kara jAneke atirikta apanI agAdha buddhikA yaha (jainamatako / samIkSA ) namUnA bhI inake pAsa chor3a gae haiN| jisase unakI vidvattAkA paricaya prApta karavAneke lie inako kisI prakArakA parizrama bhI na uThAnA par3e ! hamAre khyAlameM to svAmIjIke svarNamaya prazasta jIvanakI parIkSAke lie yaha samIkSA hI bar3I majabUta kasauTI hai ! astu ! aba hama prakArAMtarase isa bAta para vicAra karate haiM. sajjano! paThizatakake racayitAke kathanakA itanA hI sarala aura spaSTa sAra hai ki, " bhagavAn vItarAgake upadezase viruddha kathana karanA aura AcaraNa karanA ucita nahIM hai" isakA tAtparya yadi svAmIjIne " apane mukhase apanI var3AI " karanAhI samajhake jainoMke pUjanIya tIrthakaroM aura AcAryoMko mUrkha vatalAkara unakA dila duHkhAyA ho ! tara to pAThaka, kSamA kareM! hama vivaza haiM ! svAmIjIkI [" acchA to vedamArga hai jo pakar3A jAya to pakar3o nahIM to sadA gote khAte rahoge "-"jo pApANAdi mUrti pUjate haiM ve atIva vedavirodhI haiM "-"jo veda aura vedAnukUla Apta puruSoMke kiye zAstroMkA apamAna karatA (nahIM mAnatA) hai usa vedaniMdaka nAstikako jAti paMkti aura dezase vAhya kara denA cAhiye"-"saca to yaha hai ki jinhoMne vedoMse virodha kiyA aura karate haiM aura kareMge ve avazya avidyA rUpI aMdhakArameM par3ake sukhake badale dAruNa jitanA *duHkha pAveM utanAhInyUna hai". * yaha lalita lekhamAlA. unako mUkhauMkA bhI saradAra banA rahI __* svAmIjIne ye bhayaMkara zabda mAnuSI dazAmeM likhe hoMge yA anya kisI meM ? yaha vicAra karane yogya hai !!! -

Page #107
99 hai ! itanA hI nahIM isane unake jIvana ke pratyeka vibhAgakA phoTo rauMcakara bhI madhyastha samAjake sAmane rakha diyA hai !1 sajjano ! apane mukhase apanI bar3AI karanI kisakA - nAma hai, yaha bAta hama svAmInI ke hI lekhase Apako batalAteM - haiM | satyArtha prakAzake pRSTha 179 meM hamAre mAnanIya svAmIMjI - mahArAja likhate haiM-- [ " Izvara sabako upadeza karatA hai "ki, he manuSyo ! maiM Izvara sabake pUrva vidyamAna saba jagat kA "pati hUM, maiM sanAtana jagatkA kAraNa aura saba dhanoMkA vijaya ." karanevAlA aura dAtA hUM, mujhahIko saba jIva jaise pitAko ."" saMtAna pukArate haiM vaise pukAreM, maiM sabako sukha denehAre jagat " ke liye nAnA prakArake bhojanoMkA vibhAga pAlanake liye * 4 *" karatA hUM // 3 // maiM paramaizvavAryan sUrya ke sadRza saba jagatkA "" prakAzaka hUM, kabhI parAjayako prApta nahIM hotA aura na kabhI mRtyuko prApta hotA hUM, maiM hI jagatrUpa dhanakA nirmAtA hUM "" saba jagat kI utpatti karanevAle mujhakohI jAno, he jIvo ! "" aizvarya prAptike yatna karate hue tuma loga vijJAnAdi dhanako mujhase mAMgo aura tuma loga merI mitratAse alaga mata hooo / " he manuSyo ! maiM satya bhASaNa rUpa stuti karanevAle manuSyako sanAtana jJAnAdi dhana detA hUM, maiM brahma arthAt '"" vedakA prakAza karane hArA aura mujhako vaha veda yathAvat 46 41 kahatA usase sabake jJAnako maiM bar3hAtA, maiM satpuruSakA preraka *" yajJa karane hArekoM phaLa pradAtA aura isa vizva meM jo kucha // *" hai usa saba kAryakA banAne aura dhAraNa karanevAlA hUM isalie tuma loga mujhako chor3a kisI dUsareko mere sthAnameM mata * pUjo mata mAno aura mata jAno " ] 66

Page #108
100 pyAre sabhya pAThako / saMsArameM vastu tattvako samajhanevAle yadi nyUna saMkhyAmeM haiM to usake yathArya svarUpako pratipAdana karanevAle bhI svAmIjI jaise thor3e hI mahApuruSa nikalate haiM ! isIlie saMsAra unako adhika sanmAnakI 'dRSTise avalokana karatA hai ! apane mukhase apanI bar3AI karanevAlekA citra ukta lekhameM yathAvat jaisA svAmIjIne ba~cA hai aisA dusarA koI baiMca sake yaha bAta yadi asaMbhava nahIM to sahaja bhI nahIM ! 'paraMtu svAmIjIke ukta lekhapara vicAra karanese eka nijJAsu manupyake hRdayameM jitane saMdeha utpanna hote haiM una sabako yadi 'ekatrita karake likhA jAve to eka acchAsA graMtha vana jAnemeM bhI kucha saMdeha nahIM ! yadyapi anyAnya zaMkAoM ke saMbaMdhameM isa samaya hamako kucha vaktavya nahIM hai paraMtu eka vAtapara hama avazya kucha vicAra karanA cAhate haiM. svAmIjIkA ukta (Izvara sabako upadeza karatA hai ityAdi) lekha yadi satya hai taba to unake kathanAnusAra Izvarako mUlkA bhI guru samajhanA cAhie ! kyoMki usane apane mUMhase apanI itanI bar3AI kI hai ki usakA sahasrAMza bhI dUsarA karasake aisI saMbhAvanA nahIM! apane mukhase apanI bar3AI karanevAleko mUrkha to svAmIjI spaSTa hI batalA rahe haiM ! yadi svAmIjI jhUTha likha rahe haiM to unakA anyAnya kathana bhI aisA hI kyoM na mAnA jAya ? isalie svAmIjIkI lakIrake phakIra mahAzayoMse hamArI prArthanA hai ki, ve itanA batalAnekI avazya kRpA.kareM ki, svAmIjIke lekhAnusAra Izvarako mUrkha kahanA, yA maharSi svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatIjIko jhUThA ThaharAnA, ina donoMmeMse unako kyA abhISTa hai?

Page #109
[ja svA0 da0 saM0-- mUla. *bahuguNa vijAnilao. ussuttabhAsI tahAvi muttavyo / ..saha varamaNijuttoviha, viggha. karo visaharo loeH / / paSThi za0 sU0 18 // jaise viSadhara sarpameM maNi tyAgane yogya hai vaise jo jainamatameM nahIM vaha cAhe kitanA bar3A dhArmika paMDita ho usako tyAga denA hI jainiyoMko ucita hai / ( samIkSaka ) dekhiye kitanI bhUlakI bAta hai jo inake cele aura AcArya vidvAn hote to vidvAnoMse prema karate jaba inake tIrthakara sahita avidvAna haiM to vidvAnoMkA mAnya (mAna) kyoMkara kareM ? kyA murvaNako mala vA Dama paDeko koI tyAgatA hai ? isase yaha siddha huA ki vinA jainiyoMke vaise dUsare kauna pakSapAtI haThI. durAgrahI vidyA hIna hoMge ? / [ja] samAlocaka-sajjano ! svAmIjI eka acche vidvAn manuSya the, yaha bAta bahudhA satya hai ! hama unako usI dRSTise dekhate haiM jaise ki eka mahA purupako dekhanA cAhie ! paraMtu unake jIvanakI dIvArako pakSapAtake kIr3oMne itanA khokhalA banA diyA ki kisI dina usake astitvameM bhI AzaMkA hai ! svAmIjIne jainamatakI samIkSA kI, yaha burI bAtaH nahIM! kyoM ki samIkSA manupya jIvanako ucca banAnekA eka sarala sAdhanaH hai, paraMtu vaha yadi nyAyapUrNa ho ! manuSyajIvanako svaccha *bahuguNavidyAnAM nilayopi gururutsUtrabhApI tathApi moktavyaH yathA zreSTa maNiyuktopi nizcaye mRtyukaraH viSadharaH sarpaH jaMgati |ityvcuurikaar //

Page #110
102 aura nirmala banAneke lie jitanA nyAyamArga upayogI hai usase kaI guNA adhika manuSya jIvanako barabAda karanevAlA anyAya mArga hai ! anyAya aura pakSapAta inameM kevala nAma mAtrakA aMtara hai ! pakSapAtameM yaha bar3A bhArI guNa hai ki, vaha satyako apane najadIka phaTakane nahIM detA ! satyake na rahanese dharmakI vahAM dAla gale yaha to asaMbhava hI hai ! jahAMse dharmane apanA daMDa kamaMDalU uThA liyA vahAM to phira allAuddInakA hI. nyAya zAsana calAvegA! hamArA yaha saba likhanekA prayojanamAtra itanAhI hai ki, svAmAjIne mahAtmAke jIvanakA jo vAstavika uddeza honA cAhie usase sarvathA viparIta hI samajhA mAlUma detA hai ! unake javinake kisI bhI vibhAgako pholakara dekho vahAMse bahudhA anyAyakI hI sugaMdhi AvegI ! jo kucha vahAM nyAyake paramANu dekhanemeM Ate haiM unakI bhI bar3I malina dazA hai / aisA jIvana dhArmika saMtAnako kitanA hitakara ho sakatA hai yaha pAThakasvayaM vicAra sakate haiM ! svAmIjIne jo Upara likhI prAkRta gAthAkA artha kiyA hai vaha pakSapAtase. hI sarvathA ota prota hai ! isIlie hamane usake nIce lakIra baiMca dI hai. vidvAn vargase. hamArA savinaya nivedana hai ki, vaha ukta gAthA aura usake. (svAmIjI racita ) arthakA bar3e madhyastha bhAvase avalokana karake svAmIjIkI nippakSatAse avazya paricaya prApta kareM! ukta gAthAkA artha bar3A hI sarala aura subodha hai| bANikya nItimeM jo "durjanaH pariharttavyo, vidyayAlaGkatopi san / maNinA bhUSitaH sarpaH, kimasau na bhayaGkaraH ? // "

Page #111
. likhA haiM. arthAt durjana manuSya yadi vidyAse bhI yuktaho to bhI usako tyAga denA cAhie ! kyA maNise yukta sarpa. bhayake denevAlA nahIM hotA ? isakA sphuTa bhAva yaha hai ki, jaise maNiyukta bhI sarpa bhayaprada honese tyAgane yogya hai / aise durjana, yadi vidvAn bhI ho to bhI usako tyAga denA! basa ! Upara likhI paSThizatakakI gAthAkA bhI aisA hI. artha hai. arthAt maNise yukta bhI viSadhara-sarpa vighnakAraka honese. jaise tyAgane yogya hai isIprakAra zAstrase viruddha kathana aura AcaraNa karanevAlA yadi vidvAn bhI ho to bhI vaha tyAga dene lAyaka hai ! arthAt usakI saMgata karanI acchI nahIM ! isake ilAvA svAmIjIne ( jo jaina matameM nahIM haiityAdi ) jo artha kiyA hai, vaha kevala unakI nijakI kalpanA hai / ukta gAthAmeM aisA koI pada nahIM jisakA yaha artha ho sake! sajjano ! yaha upadeza itanA suMdara aura sAra garbhita hai ki, saMsAra bharakA koI bhI nippakSa vidvAn isakI prazaMsA kie vinA na rahegA ! paraMtu svAmIjIne jaina AcAryoM aura tIrthaMkaroMko vRthA hI mUrkha batalAkara saMsArabharakI kAlimAse. apane mukhako ujjvala kyoM kiyA? isakA javAba denemeM hama. asamartha haiM / evaM svAmIjI ukta upadezako dRpita ThaharAnekelie yukti dete haiM ki, " kyA suvarNako mala vA dhUr3ame par3eko koI tyAga detA hai" paraMtu svAmIjIkA yaha kathana ukta upadezake. prativAdameM kitanA asaMgata aura bhaddA hai, isako vRddhase lekara bAlaka bhI anAyAsase samajha sakate haiM ! isalie svAmIjIkI aisI prasiddha mugdhatApara vizeSa likhanA unakA apamAna karanA hai|

Page #112
isake anaMtara ukta. upadezakA svAmIjI hamako sAra catalAte haiM ki, isase yaha siddha huA ki vinI jainiyoM ke vaise dUsare kauna pakSapAtI iMTI durAgrahI aura vidyAhIna hoMge." sajjano! yaha svAmIjIkI madhura bhApAkA namUnA haiM ! jo ki unake pavitra mukhase nikalA huA hai !acchA svAmIjI ! jaina to pakSapAtI haThI durAgrahI aura vidyAhIna haiM ! paraMtu Apa to ukta dopoMse sarvathA mukta the ! isI lieM Apane jainoMko ina zabdoMse yAda kiyA ! ata: hama usa gujarAta-kAThiyAvAr3a bhUmiko hRdayase dhanyavAda dete haiM jahAM para Apa jaise pakSapAta Adi dopoMse rahita mahAnubhAvoMkA avatAra huA : vai jananI bhI sahasrazaH dhanyavAda ke yogya hai jisakI kukSIse Apa jaise amUlya ratna paidA hue ! svA majiki ina pUrvokta manohara vacanoM ke saMbaMdha unake bhaktoM ko hama vadhAI dete haiM aura smaraNa. karAte haiM ki," tUM bhalA hai to burA ho nahIM sakatA ai jAka! hai burA vahI ki jo tujhako burA jAnatA hai ! " [] svA0 da0 sa0mU.-*aisayapAviyapAvA, dhammiapavvesu eva pAvarayA / na calaMti suddha dhammA, dhannA kevi pAvanemu / / [paSThiza0 29] * satyArtha prakAzameM yaha gAthA bahuta hI asta vyasta likhI huI hai ! jo ki svAmIjIke prAkRta jJAnakA eka namUnA hai.! prAyaH sarvatra hI gAthAoMko tor3a phor3a usakI saMkalanA aura vAkya racanAkA svAmI ne nAza kara diyA hai ! yahI svAmIjIkI prAkRta azatAkA pUrNa dRSTAMta hai !!

Page #113
1.5 anyadarzanI kuliMgI arthAt jainamata virodhI unakA darzana bhI jaina loga na kareM // 29 // ( samakSika) buddhimAna loga vicAra leMge ki yaha kitanI pAmarapanakI bAta hai - ityAdi [ satyArtha prakAza pRSTha 430 ] [ jha ] samAlocaka- svAmIjI kI isa niSpakSa samIkSA ke viSayameM hama apanI sammati pragaTa kareM, isase pUrva saMskRta prAkRtake jAnanevAle pAThaka mahodayoMse hamArA sAgraha nivedana hai ki, ve kRpA karake svAmIjIke kie hue ukta prAkRta zlokake arthapara 'jisake nIce laMbI lakIra khaiMcI hai prathama avazya vicAra kareM !! hame AzA hai ki, unake vicAra karanese svAmIjIke kalpita satya aura madhyastha vicAroMke agAdha samudra meM derase DUbI huI kitanI bhadra AryaprajAko sadyaH hI nikalanekA saubhAgya prApta hogA ! svAmIjIkA jainoMke saMbaMdha meM isa prakAra ke ahetuka sarvathA dveSa bhare udgAroMke nikAlanekA kyA hetu hogA ? yaha samajhane ke lie hama bahuta asamartha haiM / hameM bar3e duHkhase kahanA par3atA hai ki, Upara likhe prAkRta zloka meM aisA eka bhI akSara nahIM ki, jisakA " jo jainamatakA virodhI ho usakA darzana bhI jaina loga na kareM " yaha artha ho sake ! ukta zlokakA sIdhA sAdA nirvivAda akSarArtha yaha hai ki, " atizaya pAparakta puruSa, dhArmika parvoM meM bhI pApa karanese nahIM cUkate / evaM kitaneka puNyazAlI dharmAtmA puruSa adhArmika meM bhI dharma kAryoMke karanese cyuta nahIM hote " st atizaya pApino dharmaparvasvapi pAparatA eva bhavanti / evaM kepi dhanyAH zUddhadharmAtpApaparvasvapi na calanti " ityavacUrikAra H |

Page #114
106 sajjano ! saMsArake pracalita dharmoM se haraeka dharmane apane 2 sAMpradAyika kRtyoMke anuSThAnake lie varSabhara meM kitaneka dina nizcita kara rakhe haiM. jaise ki, hiMdu sanAtana dharmiyoMmeM durgAnavamI, vijayAdazamI, dIvAlI, holI, paMcabhISma, nAgapaMcamI Adi / jainoMmeM paryuSaNA (pajosaNa ) Adi / musalamAnoMmeM Ida aura roje vagairaha / pArasiyoMmeM patetI veimanajazana aadi| IsAiyoMmeM bar3e dina aprela phula Adi / ye prAyaH parvake nAmase hI prasiddha haiM, jinakA dUsarA nAma tyohAra bhI kahanemeM AtA hai. SaSTi zatakake racayitAne kisI apekSAse inako dhArmika aura adhArmika ina do bhAgoMmeM vibhakta kiyA hai. usakA kathana hai ki, jinameM kisI bhI niraparAdha prANikI hiMsA karanemeM na Ave, aura sAtvika zraddhAmaya dharmakA pracAra karanemeM Ave; ve "dhArmika parva haiM. aura jinameM dhArmika pravRttiyoM ke badale kevala niraparAdha prANiyoMkA galA kATakara khuzI manAI jAve ! unakI adhArmika paryoM meM hI gaNanA karanI ucita hai ! hamAre pAThaka isa vAtase aparicita na hoMge ki, 'hiMduo, musalamAno, aura IsAiyoMmeM kitaneka aise tyohAra parva pAye jAte haiM ki, jinameM dharmake nAmase saiMkar3oM anAtha 'prANiyoMke komala galoM para bar3I nirdayatAse churI pherI jAtI hai ! isa prakArake parvo aura unake upadezoMkA jainoMne isa hetuse prativAda kiyA hai ki, ina dinoM meM isa tarahake adhArmika kRtya hote haiM, yadi ina dinoMmeM bhI dharma saMbaMdhI hI kArya kiye jAve taba to inako dhArmika parva kahane aura unake 'upadeSTAoMko dharmAtmA svIkAra karanemeM jainoMko kisI prakAra kA bhI Agraha nahIM. vastutaH honA bhI aisA hI cAhie. ukta graMthake racayitAkA kathana kevala azuddha pravRttiko lekara hai,

Page #115
107 na ki, vastu sthitikI dRSTise / aisA ukta graMthake pATha karanese mAlUma hotA hai. . . . . . . , sajjano! hamane sarala rItise Apako ukta zlokakA artha-bhAva batalA diyA hai, aba svAmIjIkA kiyA huA artha aura usakI samIkSAke sAtha isakI tulanA karanI ApakA pharja hai / svAmIjI apane zrImukhase jainoMko pAmara ( nIca) kahate haiM ! paraMtu hama jainoMse nivedana karate haiM ki, isake uttarameM ve svAmIjIko uttamapuruSa kaha kara hI yAda kiyA kareM! kyoMki "jo tujhako kAMTe boye, usako vo tUM phUla / ve kAMTe usake lie, tujhe phUlake phUla // " [Ta] . svA0 da0 sa0- . *nAmapi tassa asuha, jeNa nirdiThAI micchpvaaii| josa aNusaMgAo, dhammANavi hoI pAvamaI ||ssssttishtk 27 // jo jainadharmase viruddha dharma haiM ve saba manuSyoMko pApI karanevAle haiM isaliye kisIke anya dharmako na mAna kara jaina dharmako hI mAnanA zreSTha hai // 27 // ( samIkSaka ) isase yaha siddha hotA hai ki sabase vaira virodha niMdA IrSA Adi duSTa karma rUpa sAgara, DuvAnevAlA jaina mArga hai jaise jainI loga savakai niMdaka hai vaisA koI bhI dUsarAmatavAlA mahA niMdaka aura adharmI na hogA-ityAdi [sa. pra.pR. 431] [ ] samAlocaka-sajjano! "jo jaina"-se lekara-"zreSTha hai", takakA lekha svAmIjIkA nijakA hai, ukta zlokake sAtha usakA asatyArtha prakAzameM yaha gAthA asta vyasta aura azuddha likhI huI hai !

Page #116
108 aNumAtra bhI saMbaMdha nahIM ! svAmIjI jisa saccAIse jaina siddhAMtoMkA khaMDana karate haiM usakI yaha canagI hai ! paraMtu vaha jamAnA aba bahuta dUra nahIM hai jisameM svAmIjIkI saccAIkI DugaDugI saMsAra bhara pITane lagegA ! astu ! prathama hama pAThakoMko ukta zlokakA artha batalA dete haiM. isa zlokakA sIdhA akSarArtha yaha hai ki,-"usakA nAma bhI acchA nahIM jisane mithyApA jhUThe tyohAroMkA upadeza kiyA hai ! kyoMki inake prasaMgase dharmAtmA manuSyoMkI bhI buddhi pApameM saMlagna ho jAtI hai !" * jisa zloka para hama pIche vicAra kara Ae haiM vaha zloka isase do zloka AgekA hai, arthAt vaha 29 kA hai aura yaha 27 kA hai / hamAre khyAlameM to ukta zlokameM koI anucita upadeza pratIta nahIM hotA. kyoMki, niMdanIya vyavahAroM kurItiyoMkA upadezaka manuSya kavIbhI sabhya saMsArameM gauravako prApta nahIM hotA!jo sabhya samudAyakI dRSTise tiraskRta hai,vaha sacamucahI nAma lenelAyaka nahIM! jina sajjanoMko saMskRta mAkRtakA jJAna bahuta thor3A hai unase bhI hamArA nivedana hai ki, ve bhI kisI yogya vidvAnse milakara svAmIjIke likhe hue ukta zlokake arthakIsatyatAkA avazya nizcaya kareM ! svAmIjI paSTizatakake uktaH prAkRta zlokakI samIkSA bar3I hI sabhyatApUrvaka karate haiM ! Apa kahate haiM ki,-"isase yaha siddha hotA hai ki sabase vaira virodha niMdA IpI Adi duSTa karmarUpa sAgarameM DuvAnevAlA jaina mArga hai" hamako svAmIjIke ina zabdoMko par3hakara yaha vicAra ho rahA hai ki, svAmIjIne yaha samIkSA likhate samaya manuSyatvako kahAMpara rakha chor3A hogA ? sajjano svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatIjI *nAmApi tasyAzubhaM yenopardizitAni rajaHparvAdIni mithyAtvaparvANi 'yeSAmanuSaMgAtsaM yogAt dharmavatAM satAmapi paapmtirbhvti"ityvcrikaarH||

Page #117
109 jaise hI mahApuruSa manuSyatA aura saMbhyatAkA khUna karane laga jAveM yaha kitane duHkhakI bAta hai ? [3] svA0 da0 sa0 - *-hAhA! gurua akajaM, sAmI nahu atthiA kassa pukrimoN| kaMha jiNavayaNaM kaha suguru, saviyoM kahai akj| pN..36|| sarvajJa bhApita jina vacana jainake suguru aura jaina dharma kahAM aura unase viruddha kuMguruM anya mArgike upadeza kahAM arthAt hamAre suguru sudeva sudharma anyake kudeva kuguru kudharma haiM // 35 // (samIkSaka ) yaha vAta bera vecane hArI kuMjaDIke samAna hai jaise vaha apane khaTTe veroMko mIThA aura dUsarIke mIThoMko khaTTA aura nikamme batalAtI hai isI prakArakI jainiyoMkI bAte haiM [ satyArtha prakAza pRSTha 431 ] [ ] . samAlocaka-sajjano ! svAmIjIkI samIkSApara aba hama kucha vizeSa vicAra nahIM kareMge ! svAmIjIkI samIkSApara samA' locanA karanekA vizeSa adhikAra vahI manuSya rakha sakatA hai . jo ki, anya dharmoM aura unake AcAryoM ko svAmIjIkI taraha bar3e khulle zabdoMmeM UMcA nIcA kahaneke lie samartha ho! isalie-" javAve jAhalAM vAzuda khAmozI kI misAlaseM * satyArtha prakAzameM svAmIjI mahArAjane jitanI SaSTi zatakakI gAthAe~ uddhRta kI haiM prAyaH sabakI saba azuddha aura astavyasta lIkhI haiM jinase svAmIjI mahArAjakA prAkRta jJAna khUba hI jhalaka rahA hai ! pAThakavRMda hamArI, likhI huI aura satyArtha prakAzameM likhI huI gArthI oMkA milAna karake dekha leveM: . kyoMki .punaH punaH likhaneke badale prathamase hI gAthAko zuddha karake yahAM hamane uddhRta kiyA hai| : . . ...

Page #118
110* * cupa rahanA hI unakI samIkSA kI samAlocanA hai ! paraMtu bhaI samAjako unakI isa ziSTa paddhatikA paricaya hama avazya karabAte raheMge. pAThakoMko isa bAtakA khyAla rahe ki, ukta prAkRta zlokakA artha karate samaya svAmIjIne apane pUrva svabhAvakA parivartana nahIM kiyA ! yahAM para bhI unhoMne apanI Adatake anusAra arthameM kucha pheraphAra kiyA hai | prakaraNa prApta ukta zlokakA spaSTa bhAvArtha yaha hai ki ukta graMthake racayitA apane samayameM honevAle jaina veSadhArI daMbhI sAdhuoM aura unake vaisehI bhaktoMko jainazAstroMse - viruddha AcaraNa karate dekha aMtaHkaraNameM kheda prakaTa karate hue kahate haiM ki "baDe duHkha kI bAta hai ! kisake Age pukAra kareM ? koI prabhu nahIM hai ! kahAMto jineMdra bhagavAnakA kathana aura usake anusAra zuddha cAritrake pAlanevAle suguru, arthAt guru kahAne yogya jaina sAdhu aura unakI bhakti karanevAle jaina gRhastha ! aura kahAM ye jaina veSadhArI zithilAcArI jaina zAstroMkI AjJA se viruddha AcaraNa karanevAle kuguru aura unakI sevA karanevAle ye nAma mAtrake zrAvaka - ( jaina gRhastha ! ) isalie yaha bar3A a-kArya hai ! !" * * CL hA hA khede gurucAkArye svAmI kopi nAsti yaH zikSAM datte kasyAgre pUtkriyate ? kedaM jinavacanaM niSkalaMkaM ! kva suvihitA guravaH ! kva cottamAH zrAvakA dharmarahasyArthinaH ! ityakAryamityaka cUrikAra: // "

Page #119
111 ... sabhya vRMdo ! yadi isa prakArake niSpakSa upadezameM bhI svAmIjIko kuMjar3Ike hI beroMke svama Ave to yaha unake bhAgyakI bAta hai ! hamArA isameM koI doSa nahIM ! prakRtikA niyama hI aisA hai ki, kuMjar3eko berokA aura jauharIko ratnoMkA hI svapnaM AtA hai ! yadi hama kisI apekSAse svAmIjIke arthako hI ThIka mAne taba bhI jainoMkA kathana koI anucita nahIM ! kyoMki anya dharmoMkI apekSAH apane dharmako utkRSTa mAnanA athavA batalAnA yaha pratyeka dharma kI rUr3hI hI hai| isase ucitAnucitakA vicAra kiye vinA hI kuMjar3oMkI upamA denI kevala kSudratA hai ! svAmIjI sthAna 2 meM vaidika dharmako hI saba dharmoMse zreSTha aura mokSake denevAlA batalAte haiM, to kyA unako kuMjar3A kahanA cAhie ? hama to isa prakAra kathana karanemeM sarvathA asamartha haiM / kadApi unakA kathana hI unako isa mahatI upAdhise vibhUSita kare to hama vivaza haiM ! . sajjano! jo manuSya apane pAoNkI tarpha dekhakara nahIM calatA use avazya mahake bala giranA par3atA hai ! dUsaroMke majabUta makAnoM para patthara varasAnevAleko prathama apanI phUsakI sauMpar3IkA avazya khyAla kara lenA cAhie ! dUsarekI eka AMkha kANI karaneke lie apanI dono hI AMkheM kho baiThanevAlA manuSya nissandeha socane lAyaka hai! . .... . [Da] . . . svAmI dai0 sa0. . . sappo ikaM maraNaM, kuguru aNaMtAI dei. mrnnaaii| ... tA vara sappaM gahiraM, mA kuguru sevaNaM bhadda.!.. ............... ||ss0.0.37.||

Page #120
112 / jaise prathama likha Aye ki sarpa meM maNikA bhI tyAga karanA ucita hai vaise anya mArgiyoM meM zreSTha dhArmika puruSoMkA bhI tyAga kara denA aba usase bhI vizeSa nindA anya matavAloMkI karate haiM. jaina matase viruddha saba kuguru arthAt ve sapaise bhI bure haiM unakA darzana sevA saMga kabhI na karanA cAhiye kyoMki sarpake saMgase ekavAra maraNa hotA hai aura anyamArgI kuguruoMke saMgase anekavAra maraNameM giranA par3atA hai isaliye he bhadra anyamArgiyoMke guruoMke pAsa 'mI mata khar3A raha kyoMki jo tUM anyamArgiyoMkI kucha bhI sevA karegA to duHkhameM par3egA (samIkSaka) dekhiye jainiyoMke samAna kaThora prAMta dveSI nindaka bhUlA hubhA dUsare matavAle koI bhI na hoMge inhone manase yaha vicArA hai ki hama anyakI nindA aura apanI prazaMsA na kareMge to hamArI sevA aura pratiSTA na hogI ityAdi [ satyArtha prakAza pRSTha 431] . . [] '. samAlocaka-sajjano ! "gurocAlIkanivandhaH, samAni brahmahatyayA" kisI supratiSThita dharmAtmA vyaktipara jhUThA ilajAma laMgAnA brahmahatyAke samAna bar3A bhArI pApa hai ! isa pApako dharmazAstrakAroMne sAmAnya. manuSyako mAra denese bhI kisI durje adhika batalAyA hai ! svAmIjIne barAya~ nAma jaina graMthoM ke katipaya vAkyoMko satyArtha prakAzameM uddhata karake unake manamAne artha batalA kara jainoMpara jo mithyA kalaMka lagAe haiM, unase upArjana kie hue pApase unakI AtmAko kitanI zAMti prApta huI hogI yaha hama nahIM kaha sakate ! svAmIjIne yahAM jo kucha likhA hai vaha kevala dveSa buddhise hI likhA haiM, yaha

Page #121
to Aja hama kahate haiN| paraMtu vaha dina bhI bahuta hI najadIka haiM jisameM sAre vizvake vidvAn ekamata hokara mukta kaMThase isa bAtakoM svIkAra karane lageMge ! uktaM prAkRta zlokadvArA graMthakAra bar3I hI yogya zikSA dete haiM. ve kahate haiM ki, *" sAMpa aura kuguru ( jaina. zAstrase viruddha. AcaraNa. karanevAlA jaina veSadhArI daMbhI svArthI saMsAra vaMcaka sAdhu ) meM bahuta aMtara hai ! kyoMki, sAMpa to kATanese eka hI daphA maraNa detA hai, aura kuguruke saMsargase to anekavAra janma maraNakA anubhava karanA par3atA hai ! isalie hai bhadraH! sarpako grahaNa karanA to acchA hai, paraMtu kugurukI sevA karanI acchI nahIM hai" isakA tAtparya yaha hai ki, daMbhI, svArthI, sAdhuoMke veSako kalaMkita karanevAle aura aneka prakArake apakarma karanevAle nAma mAtrake sAdhuoMkI guru buddhise sevA bhakti karanevAle puruSako lAbha ke sivA hAnikI hI saMbhAvanA hai ! isa prakArake saMsAra vaMcaka guruoMse buddhimAn purupako alaga rahanA hI zreSTha hai ! __hamane apane pAThakoMko ukta zlokakA artha aura bhAva donoM hI sarala rItise vatalA die haiM. aba svAmIjIkA ukta zlokake AdhArapara jainoMko kaThora bhrAMta dveSI niMdaka aura bhUle hue kahanA kahAM taka ucita hai ? isakA vicAra ve svayaM kara leveM. []. svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatI-- . *. " sarpaH ekavAramaraNaM bhraSTaguru: bahUni maraNAni dadAti sarpaNa gRhItaM varaM na punaH kuguru sevana' he sarala!" ityvcuuNrikaarH||

Page #122
114: * govi jANa ahio, tosa dhammAmaI je pakuvvati / - muttUNa corasaMgaM, karaMti te coriaM pAvA / / 50 za0 71 // isakA mukhya prayojana itanA hI hai ki jaise mUDha jana corake saMgase nAsikA chedAdi daMDase bhaya nahIM karate vaise jainamatase bhinna coraM dharmo meM sthita jana apane akalyANa se bhaya nahIM karate // 75 // (samIkSaka ) jo jaisA manuSya hotA hai vaha prAyaH apane hI sadRza dUsaroM ko samajhatA hai kyA yaha bAta satya ho sakatI hai ki anya saba cora mata aura jainakA sAhUkAra mata hai ! jaba taka manuSyameM ati ajJAna aura kusaMga se bhraSTa buddhi hotI hai taba taka dUsaroMke sAtha ati IrSyA dveSAdi duSTatA nahIM chor3atA jaisA jainamataM parAyA dveSI hai vaisA anyamata koI nahIM. [satyArtha prakAja pRSTha 433 ] [ Dha] .. samAlocaka- hama prathama Upara likhI prAkRta gAthAkA artha pAThakoM ko batalA dete haiM jisase svAmIjIke kiye hue arthapara vicAra karane ke lie unako kisI prakArakI kaThinatA na par3e ! SaSTi zataka ke racayitA ke vakta kitaneka aise bhI manuSya the, jo ki, daMbhI aura kapaTI guruoMkA saMsarga to nahIM karate the; paraMtu unake race hue mAyAjAla rUpa dharmakA anuSThAna ve avazya karate the ! unakI isa zocanIya dazA ko dekha kara. ukta graMthakArane ukta zlokakI racanA kI hai. isakA sIdhA bhAvArtha yaha hai ki - + " jina pAkhaMDI logoMke saMsarga se bhI * * satyArtha prakAzameM yaha zlokaM bahuta hI asta vyasta likhA huA hai, hamane yahAM ThIka ThIka likhA hai. anyatra bhI sarvatra isI taraha samajha lenA. * " yeSAM saMsargopi na kriyate teSAM punarupadiSTaM ye dharmaH kurvanti te pApinazcaurANAM saMgaM muktvA jAne svayaM caurya kurvanti" ityvcuurikaarH|| +

Page #123
115 : hAni hai unake kathana kiye hue dharma ( vastutaH adharma ) kA jo manuSya anuSThAna karate haiM ve ( viveka zUnya ) mAnoM corakA saMga karane meM burAI samajhake usako chor3akara svayaM corI karane meM pravRtta hote haiM ! " arthAt corake saMsarga meM doSa samajha kara bhI -corI meM burAI na samajhanevAlA manuSya jaise viMcAra zUnya samajhA jAtA hai, vaise hI kumArgagAmI svArthI logoM ke kutsita upadezakA anuSThAna karanevAleko bhI samajhanA cAhie ! isake sivA svAmIjIne jainamatase bhinna cora dharma ityAdi jo kucha likhA hai, vaha saba unakI nijakI kalpanA hai ! Upara likhe hue prAkRta zloka meM se kisI akSarakA bhI artha nahIM ! svAmIjIkA isa prakAra se likhanekA Azaya nissandeha anya matabAloMkA jainoMse dveSa bar3hAne kA hI pratIta hotA hai ! paraMtu isa dveSase unhe kyA lAbha hogA ? so hama nahIM kaha sakate . sajjano ! svAmIjI mahArAja kahate haiM ki, "jo jaisA manuSya hotA hai vaha apane hI sadRza dUsaroMko samajhatA hai. " paraMtu hama to isa kathanako satya mAnane ke lie taiyAra na hoMge ! kyoMki, svAmIjI jaise mahApuruSako kumhArakA TaTTU, bhaDuA, jhUThA, dukAnadAra, svArthI, mUrkha, adharmI, nirdaya, pApI, durAcArI, dveSI, mahAnindaka, pAmara vagairaha kahane meM hama sarvathA asamartha haiM ! yadi hama unakA ukta kathana satya pramANita kareM taba to unake viSaya meM ukta apazabdoM kA prayoga karane ke lie hame avazya bAdhita honA par3egA ! kyoMki, svAmIjIne anya - dharmaguruoMke saMbaMdha meM ina pUrvokta zabdoMkA vyavahAra kiyA hai ! svAmIjIke kathanAnusAra svayaM pApI hue vinA kahAM nahIM jAtA ! yA yUM kahie ki, jo svayaM pApI hai vahI dUsaroMko pApI kahatA vA jAnatA hai ! aisA mAnane se svAmIjI dUsaroMko pApI

Page #124
116 aura unakA mata saMsArako avidyAMdhakArake sAgarameM DubAnevAle siddha hote haiM / kyoMki, ve jaina matako aisA hI batalAte haiM ! isalie svAmIjIke ukta kathanako satya mAnakara unake sAre upadezako dhUlameM milAnA hama pasaMda nahIM karate ! phira jo isake Age hI svAmIjI likhate haiM ki, " jabataka manuSyakI ati ajJAna aura kusaMgase buddhi bhraSTa hotI hai tabataka dUsaroM ke sAtha ati IrSyA dvepAdi duSTatA nahIM chor3atA jaisA jaina mata parAyA dvepI hai aisA anya koI. nhiiN"| svAmIjIke isa kathanakA spaSTa Azaya yaha. hai ki, jisa manuSyakI ajJAna aura kusaMga Adi doSoM se buddhi bhraSTa ho rahI hai vahI dUsaroM ko burA kahatA hai. arthAt dUsaroMse IrSA dveSa karanA aura unako burA kahanA ityAdi doSoMkA kAraNa hI. ajJAna aura kusaMga hai ! athavA yUM samajhie. ki, dUsaroMko. vahI manuSya kurA batalAtA hai ki, jisakI buddhi ajJAna aura kusaMga prabhRti doSoMse naSTa bhraSTa ho gaI ho ! paraMtu svAmIjIke isa kathanako vahI satya mAna sakate haiM, jo ki, unako (svA0 ko) naSTa bhraSTa vuddhivAle kahane meM kucha bhI saMkoca na. rakhate hoM ! kyoMki, svAmIjIke lekhAnusAra. dUsaroMse ISo dveSa yA dUsaroMkI nindA vahI manuSya kara sakatA hai ki, jisakI- ajJAnatA aura kusaMgase: buddhi bhraSTa ho gaI ho! svAmIjI to dUsaroMkI nindAmeM graMthoMke graMtha kAle kara gae haiM! isalie ajJAnatA aura kusaMga.doSase unakI buddhi naSTa bhraSTa ho rahI thI yaha balAt svIkAra karanA par3egA! hama to na svAmIjaki ukta, kathanako satya hI mAnate haiM, aura na unako naSTa bhraSTa buddhivAle hI: kahate haiM ! paraMtuHsvAmInaki vacanako vidhAtAko rekha mAnanevAle katipaya navIna Arya mahAzayoMse hamArI.prArthanA hai

Page #125
117 ki, svAmIjIke isa kathanako satya mAnakara unako bhraSTa buddhivAle kahanA unako ThIkai jalatA hai ? yA unake isa kathanako jhUThA batalA kara unako mithyAbhASI ThaharAte hue unakA apamAna karanA ve acchA samajhate haiM ? [ ta ] svA0 da0 sa0 kiM sopi jaNaNijAo jANo jaNaNI ikaM ago viddhi / jaI micchaMra o jAo guNe suta maccharaM vahaha // Sa0 za0 sU0 81 // jo jainamata virodhI mithyAtvI arthAt mithyA dharmavAle haiM ve kyoM janme ? jo janme to vaMde kyoM ? arthAt zIghra hI naSTa ho jAte to acchA hotA // 81 // ( samIkSaka ) dekho ! inake vItarAga bhASita dayA dharma dUsare matavAloMkA jIvana bhI nahIM cAhate kevala inakA dayA dharma kathana mAtra hai ityAdi [ satyArtha prakAza pRSTha 434 ] [ ta ] samAlocaka - sajjano ! isa prakAra saMkucita aura halakI zikSAkA varNana jaina graMthoMmeM to hamAre dekhane meM nahIM AyA | hAM ! svAmIjIke graMthoM meM to hai 11 dekho [ satyArtha prakAza pRSTa 330" ina bhAgavatAdike banAne hAre janmate hI kyoM nahIM garbhahI meM naSTa ho gaye " ityAdi ] yahAM para to svAmIjIne " ulaTA cora koTavAlako DAMTe " vAlA 'hisAba kiyA hai ! kyoMki, anya matavAloMke jIvana takako bhI cAhate to svayaM nahIM, isIlie spaSTa likha rahe haiM / paraMtu isa mahA ghRNita dveSamaya upadezakA ilajAma bicAre jainoM para lagA rahe haiM | parantu smaraNa raheM " jo ki z2Alima hai vo haragiz2a phUlatA phalatA nahIM ! sabaja hote kheta bhI dekhA kahIM zamazerakA ? "

Page #126
118 . ... Upara hamana jA SaSTizatakakA zloka satyArtha prakAzase uddhRta kiyA hai usakA pATha adhikAMza * azuddha aura astaM vyastya hai ! aura usake arthameM to itanI bhI satyatA nahIM hai jitanI ki svAmIjImeM bhI thI ! isalie ukta zlokake yathArtha pATha aura arthako hama yahAMpara likhate haiM, jisase svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatI aura jainoM ke saMbaMdha ukta viSayakI chAna vInakA samaya pAThakoMko sugamatAse mila sake. . - sajjano ! saMsArameM isa prakArake manuSya bhI bahuta haiM, jo ki, apane kadAgrahase jhUThako satya aura satyako jhUTha mAnate tathA upakAra parAyaNa saccAritrI prazastajIvI dhArmika vidvAnoMse pratyakSa dveSa karate haiM ! aise manuSyoMke upalakSyameM ukta graMtha 'kAra likhate haiM ki-- "kiM sovi jaNaNi jAo, jAo jagaNIi kiM gao burchi / jai miccharao jAgo, guNemu taha macchara vahaI // 81 // " arthAt *mithyAtvameM rakta aura saccAritrI vidvAnoMse (ahetuka) dveSa karanevAlA manuSya kyA (prazasta ) mAtAse janita hai ? yadi yaha satya hai to usakI vRddhi kyoM huI ? arthAt vaha puSTa kyoM huA / isakA khulAsA matalaba yaha hai-jo manuSya * * isameM koI naI bAta nahIM hai ! yahI to svAmIjIkI prAkRtAnabhijJatAkA pramANa hai ! // ___ * adevameM devabuddhi, agurumeM gurubuddhi, aura adharmameM dharmabuddhiko jainagraMthoMmeM mithyAtva batalAyA hai. yathA-adeve devabuddhiyA~, gurudhIragurau caM yaa| ___adharme dharmabuddhizca, mithyAtvaM tadviparyayAt // [yogazAstre] . * se naro jananyA kiM jAtaH 1 jAtazcetkiM vRddhi gaMtaH ? yadi mithyAraktaH atha ca guNeSu matsaraM vahati, satyadharmavantaM dveSTi / etAvatA tasya janmavRddhayAdikaM sarva nirarthakamevetyavacUrikAraH / /

Page #127
satyAsatyake vivekase zUnya aura zreSTa puruSoMse niSkAraNa sadA virodha rakhanevAle haiM ! unake honese saMsArako kisI prakArakA lAbha nahIM hai ! yA yUM kahie ki, ve sRSTi meM eka prakArake bhAra rUpa hI hai ! paraMtu isa upadezase jainoMko svAmIjI nirdayaH kisa kAraNase batalAte haiM ? vaha hama nahIM samajha skte| . isake atirikta svAmIjIne ukta graMthake aura bhI kitaneka zloka satyArtha prakAzameM uddhRta kara unakI samIkSA kI hai. paraMtu una sabapara vicAra karanA pAsehueko pIsane samAna vyartha hai ! kyoMki, vahAMpara bhI svAmIjI sarvathA usI paddhatise kAma le rahe haiM jisake svarUpase hamAre pAThaka bakhUbI paricita ho cuke haiM, isalie ukta graMthakI samIkSAke vicArako aba yahIMpara samApta karate hue hama pAThakoMkA dhyAna anyatra baiMcate haiM. "vivekasAra aura svAmI dayAnaMda" svAmIjI mahodayane Age calakara vivekasAra nAmake kisI eka bhASA graMthake nAmase kitanIeka bAteM udbhata karake jainoMpara bahuta anucita AkSepa kie haiM ! jainoMpara AkSepa karaneke viSayameM hame koI vivAda nahIM hai. hamako to una AkSepoMkI asabhyatA aura bhramamUlakatAke viSayameM kucha vicAra karanA hai. __hama apane pAThakoMko itanA aura bhI batalA dete haiM ki, hama vivekasArakI bAtoMpara vivekasArake AdhArapara vicAra nahIM kareMge; kiMtu jaina dharma ke sarva mAnya graMthoMmeM una bAtoMkA jisa prakAra ullekha kiyA gayA hogA usake anusAra vicAra kareMge. svA0 da0 sa0- . aba ina jainiyoM ke sAdhuoM kI lIlA dekhiye|

Page #128
120 ...1) vivekasAra pR. 228" eka jaina matakA sAdhu kozI vezyAse bhoga karake: pazcAt. tyAgI hokara svarga lokako gyaa| (2) vivekasAra pRSTha 10 " arNaka muni cAritraseM cuka kara kaI varSa paryaMta datta seThake gharameM viSayaH bhoMgA karake pazcAt: deva lokako gayA " " zrI kRSNake putra DhaMDhaNa muniko syAliyA uThA le gayA pazcAta devatA huaa"|| (3) viveka. pR. 156. " jainamatakA sAdhu liMgadhArI arthAt vezadhArI mAtra ho to bhI usakA satkAra zrAvaka loga kareM cAhe sAdhu-zuddha cAritrI ho cAhe azuddha cAritrI saba pUjanIya haiM " // (4) viveka. pR. 168 " jainamatakA sAdhu cAritra hIna ho to bhI anyamatake sAdhuoMse zreSTa hai"| (5) viveka. pR. 1.71 " zrAvaka loga jaina matake sAdhu oMko cAritra rahita bhraSTAcArI dekheM to bhI unakI sevA karanA cAhiye "* (6), viveka. pR. 256 " eka corane pAMca muThI loca kara cAritra grahaNa kiyA bar3A kaSTa aura pazcAttApa kiye chaThe mahIne meM kevala jJAna pAke siddha ho gayA" (samIkSaka ) aba dekhiye inake sAdhu aura gRhasthoM kI lIlA inake maMtameM bahuta kukarma karanevAlA sAdhu bhI mokSakoM gyaa| (7) viveka. pR. 106 meM likhA hai ki kRSNa tIsare narakameM gayA (samIkSaka) bhalA koI buddhimAna puruSa yahaHpATha vivekasArameM hamAre dekhanemeM nahIM aayaa| C

Page #129
121 vicAre ki inake sAdhu gRhastha aura tIrthakara jinameM bahuta se vezyAgAmI parastrIgAmI cora Adi saba jainamatastha svarga aura mokSako gaye aura zrI kRSNAdi mahA dhArmika mahAtmA saba narakako gaye yaha kitanI bar3I burI bAta hai ! pratyuta vicArake dekheM to acche puruSako jainiyoMkA saMga karanA unako dekhanA bhI burA hai ! kyoMki jo inakA saMga kare to aisI hI jhUThI 2 bAteM usake bhI hRdayameM sthita ho jAyeMgI kyoMki ina mahA haThI durAgrahI manuSyoMke saMgase sivAya burAiyoM ke anya kucha bhI palle na par3egA / hAM jainiyoMmeM jo uttama jana haiM unase satsaMgAdi karanemeM kucha bhI doSa nahIM [ isapara svAmIjIne eka nIce noTa diyA hai ]; jo uttama jana hogA vaha isa asAra jaina matame kabhI na rahegA ] [satyArtha prakAza pRSTa 443 - 444] ( ? ) samAlocaka - svAmIjI jaina sAdhuoMkI lIlA dikhAte hue kahate haiM ki - "eka jaina matakA sAdhu kozA vezyAse bhoga karake pazcAt tyAgI hokara svarga lokakA gayA" bhalA isa kathanase jaina sAdhuoM kI unhoMne kyA lIlA dikhAI ? " pazcAt tyAgI hokara svarga lokako gayA" isameM kaunasI lIlA kI bAta hai ? yadi koI bezyAlaMpaTa manuSya vezyA gamanako buga samajha ke tyAga de, aura sarvathA nivRtti mArga avalaMbanase apane AtmAko sudhAra le to kyA yaha lIlA hai ? hAM jainazAstrAnusAra sAdhuveSa dhAraNa karaneke pazcAt no vezyA . 11

Page #130
122 gaMmanAdi kukarmoM meM pravRtta hai aise durAcArIko sAdhu athavAe svarga gayA kahIM jaina zAstroMmeM likhA ho taba to lIlA kahanA ThIka ho sakatA hai ! paraMtu aisA to hamane jainagraMthoM meM kahIM likhA huA nahIM dekhA ! jainagraMthoM meM to sthAnara meM yaha upadeza hai ki-" varamaggimmi paveso, varaM visuddheNa kammeNA maraNamA gahiyanvayabhaMgo, mAjIaMkhaliyasIlassa // " arthAt amimeM jala maranA acchA hai ! anazanAdi vratase zarIrako. tyAga denA zreSTa hai ! paraMtu grahaNa kiye hue sanyAsa-vratakA tyAga aura skhalita zIla (jisane brahmacaryarUpa amUlya ratnakA. nAza kiyA ho aise ) yatikA jInA acchA nahIM ! / / sajjano ! svAmIjI mahArAja jisako eka jainamatakA sAdhu kaha kara likhate haiM unakA nAma " sthUlibhadra" hai ! inako jainadharmameM bar3A hI uccasthAna prApta huA hai isakA kAraNa inakA AdarzarUpa jIvana hai ! inake saMbaMdhoM jainagraMthoM meM bahuta kucha varNana kiyA gayA hai ! inake caritrakA sAMgopAMga varNana pariziSTaparvameM zrI hemacaMdrAcAryane kiyA hai. ina graMthoMko chor3a kara inake saMbaMdha jo viveka sArameM likhA hai usIko yadi svAmIjI satyArtha prakAzameM uddhata kara dete to unakI vatalAI huI jainamatake sAdhaoMkI lIlAko samajhaneke lie kisIko bhI kaThinatA na par3atI ! hama apane pAThakoMko syUlibhadra munike caritrakA kucha aMza (jisakA svAmIjIke kathanake sAtha saMbaMdha hai) varNana karake sunAte haiM. yaha varNana bhI hama vivekasArasehI uddhRta karate haiM. kyoMki, jaina sAdhuoMkI lIlA dikhalAnake lie Apane isI pustakakA nAma liyA hai ! ukta pustakakI bhApA yadyapi bahuta purAne DhaMgakI hai, evaM raddIsI hai ! paraMtu hama usakA parivartana nahIM karate, kyoMki, usakA jyUMkA

Page #131
123 syUM pATha uddhRta karanese svAmInIkI satyatAkA pAThakoM ko adhika paricaya milegA ! vivekasArake pRSTha 227 meM likhA hai ki- "rAjAbhiyoga" rAjAkA hukuma arthAt rAjAkI AjJA se kisI kAmameM lagane se dharmakArya na honA, isase dharmakArya na ho sake to bhI pApa nahIM lagatA kyoMki rAjAjJA nagaradasta hai. " jaise kozA " pATalIputra nagara meM sthUlabhadra munike pAsa dikSA pAya ( jaina zAstra ke anusAra jaina gRhasthake dharmako aMgIkAra karaneke lie pratijJAbaddha hokara - lekhaka ) samyaktva mUlaka dvAdaza vrata ( jaina gRhasthocita karttavya ) pAlanevAlI kozA nAma vezyA thI / usako rAjAne kisI dhanurvidyA jAnanevAle ko de diyA, usa kozAne icchA na rahetI bhI ( rAjAkI AjJA se use ) aMgIkAra kiyA ! paraMtu usa rathIke Age ( vaha ) sarvadA sthUlabhadra munikI stuti kiyA kare ( karatI rahatI thI - le. ) ( eka dina ) vaha rathI usako rijhAne ke liye bagIcAmeM jAya baMgalekI khir3akI me usake sAtha baiThake eka bANa Amake jhumakAmeM vedhA ( Amraphala ke gucche meM mArA ) dUsarA usa vANameM vedhA tIsarA bANa usa bANameM aisA (se) vANa bANa vedhateM ( mArate ) khir3akI taka bANakI lar3a lagAya hAta ( tha ) hIse nAma dhIMca ke ( khaiMca ke ) toDake usako de diyA / kozAne bhI kahA ( aba ) hamArI kalA dekho (yaha ) kahake eka thAlImeM sarasoMkI DherI lagAya usake upara phUloM se DhakI huI sUI khar3I kara diyA ( dI ) usake Upara khUba taraha se ( usane ) nAca kiyA paraMtu sUI pairame gar3ane 1 na pAI aura sarasoMkI DherI bhI nahI vikharI / yaha dekhake vaha dhanurdhArI prasanna hoya bolA ki hama tere (rI) caturAIpara tuSTa haiM

Page #132
mAMga kyA de tujhakoM kozA volI *yaha kyA hamane duSkara karma kiyA ? jisse (jisase ) tuma itane khuza hue, yaha nAcanA duSkara nahIM hai, na vANase Ama toDanA duSkara hai, duSkara to vaha hai jo ki sthUlabhadra munine kiyA. yaha (isa ) sthUlabhadrane pahale bAraha varSa hamAre sAtha aneka bhogabhoge pIche dIkSA pAya ( sanyAsa-trata grahaNa kara ) cAritra pAlate hue hamAre ihAM caturmAsa vAsa kiyA hamane aneka kAmaceSTA kiyA (kI) to bhI unake manako kucha bhI vikAra chuya nahIM gayA (hamArI aneka prakArakI kAmaceSTAoMse bhI sthUlabhadrake manameM kiMcita vikAra utpanna nahIM huA) itanA - * sovAca kiM mayAkAri, duSkaraM yena rjitH| idamapyadhikaM nAnAt, kimabhyAsena duSkaran ! // 178 // kicAnalumbIchedoyaM, nRttaM cedaM na duSkaran / AzikSitaMtthUlabhadro, yacakre tattu duSkarala ! // 179 // abhukta dvAdazAndAni, bhogAnyatra sanaM myaa| tatraiva citrazAlAyA-matyAttokhaMDitavataH ! // 180 // dugdhaM nakulasaJcArA-diva strINAM prcaartH| yoginAM duSyate cetaH, tthUlabhadranuni vinA ! / / 181 // dinamekamapi tyAtuM, ko'laM strIsannidhau tthaa| cAturmAnI yathA'tiSThat, tyUlabhadro'kSatataH / // 182 / / AhAraH ptshcitr-shaalaavaaso'nggnaantike| apyeka vrata lopAyA-'nyatya lohatanorapi ! / / 183 // vilIyante dhAtumayAH, pArzve vaherikha triyAH / satu vanamayo manye, sthUlabhadranahAnuni ! // 184 // sthUlabhadraM mahAsattvaM, kRtaduSkaraduSkaram / / : vyAvarNayukSA nuTraiva, mukhe varNAtuM param ! // 185 // - * . [ ityAdi pariziSTapaNi ]

Page #133
125 sunate hI ( usa ) rathIko pratibodha ho gayA zIghra hI guruke pAsa jAya dIkSA le ( sanyAsa vrata dhAraNa kara ) cAritra pAlane lagA kozA bhI zrAvaka (jaina gRhastha ) kA dharma pAlatI huI sadgatiko prApta huii|" ... aba pAThaka vicAra sakate haiM ki, isameM kaunasI anucita bAta hai ? jisase svAmIjI jaina sAdhuoMkI lIlA batalAte haiM ! sajjanoM ! sthUlabhadra ke caritrameM jo kozA vezyAkA sarasoMkI DherIpara nAcanA likhA hai, isako svAmIjI bahuta gappa mAnate haiM ! Apa likhate haiM ki, " kozA vezyA cAhe usakA zarIra kitanA hI halakA ho to bhI sarasoMkI DherIpara sUI khar3I kara usake Upara nAcanA sUIkA na chidanA aura sarasoMkA na 'vikharanA atIva jhUTha nahIM to kyA hai ? " paraMtu hamAre pAThakoMmeMse jinhoMne pharI san 1912 kI sarasvatI mAsika patrikAmeM nartakAcArya paMDita giradhArIlAlajI tivArIjIkI * jIvanIko par3hA hogA unheM kahanA par3egA ki, ukta kAma * inakI (tivArIjIkI) anyAnya jIvana saMbaMdhI ghaTanAoMkA varNana karate hue nRtyakalAke saMbaMdhameM likhA hai ki-"(jayapurameM) paMDitajIne hoz2ameM bhare hue pAnIkI satahapara koI pAMca minaTa taka nRtya kiyA ! taba to una logoMke hoza ur3a gae aura paMDitajakI bar3I prazaMsA huii|......tlvaaroNpr, AroMkI dhAroMpara, pahiyepara lagI huI kIloMkI nokoMpara bhI Apa sugamatApUrvaka nAcate haiN| pharzapara aura dhAradAra cIjoMke Upara nAcate samaya ApakA paira barAbara ekasA rahatA aura giratA hai |......aap apane zarIrakA halekApana dikhAneke liye pharzapara zakarake batAze bichavAkara unapara nAcate haiN| unapara Apa khUba ghUmate haiM khUba calate haiM para kyA majAla jo eka bhI batAzA phUTa jAya / Apa thAliyoMkI uThI huI dIvAroMpara bhI nAcate haiM / thAliyoMmeM pAnI bhI usa samaya Apa bharAlete haiN|

Page #134
126 koI asaMbhava nahIM ! abhyAsa se saba kucha sAdhya ho sakatA hai ! yadi isa vakta ( ukta nartakAcAryajI ke samaya meM ) svAmInI vidyamAna hote to unheM apanI bhUla sudhAranekA avazya maukA milatA ! [ 2 ] araNaka ( arhannaka ) muni aura dRMhaNa kumArakI bAta svAmIjIne jo kucha likhA hai usameM itanA bhI satya nahIM jitanI ki ur3ada ke dAnepara saphedI hotI hai ! arhanaka guni viSayasevana karatA huA devalokako gayA aura DhaMDaNa kumArako syAliyA ( gIdar3a ) uThA le gayA isa prakArakA ullekha hamane jaina graMthoM ke atirikta svAmI mahodaya ke batAye hue viveka sArameM bhI nahIM dekhA ! isalie hame karanA par3atA hai ki, svAmIjI saMsArako dhokhemeM DAla rahe haiM ! madhyastha puruSa isa para avazya dhyAna deM !! [ 3-4-5 ] hama prathama pAThakoMkI sevAmeM nivedana kara cuke haiM ki, vivekasArameM kathana kI huI bAtoMmeMse hama usI para vicAra nAcate samaya thAliyAM sarakatI aura ghUmatI bhI haiM para na to unakA pAnI hI chalakatA hai aura na unake ghUmane meM kucha skAvaTa hI hotI hai do tIna thAliyoM para Apa khar3e ho jAte haiM ! icchA karane hIse Apa kisI bhI thAlI kI gati badala sakate haiM / yadi eka pairake nIcekI do thAliyAM eka tarphako ghUmatI haiM to dUsarekI eka dUsarI tarphako !... sarasoMmeM tArapara nAcanevAle loga chAtekI zaraNa lekara apane prayoga karate haiM para paMDitajIko chAte vAtekI AvazyakatA nahIM rahatI / Ana binA chAte yA kisI anya cIjakI sahAyatAke sugamatApUrvaka tArapara bhI nAcate haiM " ityAdi - [ sarasvatI bhAga 13 saMkhyA 2] ukta narttakA cAryajI abhI vidyamAna haiM. ' lekhaka ' //

Page #135
kareMge, jisakA ki, ullekha kisI mAnanIya jaina graMthoM ho ! jaina graMthoM meM cAritra bhraSTa zithilAcArI sAdhuko guru athavA uttama mAnakara sevA pUjA karanekA ullekha hamAre dekhanemeM nahIM AyA, isalie jaina siddhAMta ke viruddha vivekasArake kie gae ullekhake uttara dAtA jaina nahIM ho sakate ! jaise ki Aja kalake saMsAra vaMcaka viSayAnaMdI kitaneka vAvA loga apanemeM aMdha saMsArakI guru bhAvanA sthita rakhane ke lie aneka prakArake cAgajAla zAstroMke nAmase racate haiM, nissaMdeha satyArtha prakAzameM uddhRta kiyA huA vivekasArakA ukta lekha bhI isI prakArakA hai ! yaha eka svAbhAvika niyama hai ki, saMsArameM kamAnese kamInA manuSya bhI apanI pratiSThAke lie aneka prakArakI yuktieM DhUMDa nikAlatA hai aura ve kitaneka mUryopara kArAmada bhI ho jAtI haiM ! paraMtu vicAra priya manuSyoMke hRdayapara unakA aNumAtra bhI asara nahIM ho sakatA. vivekasArake aMdara bahutasI aisI bAteM pAI jAti haiM, jo ki, jaina dharmake maMtavyase sarvathA viruddha haiM! kevala svArthako siddha karane ke lie hI jaina graMthoM ke nAmase unakA ullekha kiyA gayA hai ! bhAjakala aise bahutase graMtha dekhane meM Ate haiM jinameM svArthi logoMne jaina dharmake nAmase hI apanI dukAna calAnekA prayatna kiyA hai| hAla hI meM jaina dharmake nAmase eka tivarNA . cAra nAmakA graMtha prakAzita huA hai usake saMbaMdha jaina hitaipI. mAsikameM nikalanevAlI samAlocanAko jina logoMne par3hA. hogA ve samajha sakate haiM ki usake lekhaka mahAzayane kisa kadara dhUlakI muTThIse sUryako DhAMpanekA sAhasa kiyA hai ! aisI. hI dazA vivekasArakI hai ! udAharaNake lie aMka 3-4. kA hI ukta lekha le lIjie / jaina graMthoMmeM caritra bhraSTa sAdhu

Page #136
128 ko guru vuddhise vaMdanA karane kA ullekha to nahIM parantu niSedha to kiyA hai | yathA--upadezaratnAkare--- "cAritreNa vihInaH, zrutavAnapi nopajIvyate sdbhiH| . zItalajalapari pUrNaH, kulajaizcANDAlakUpa iva // " ___ arthAt jaise zItala jalase pUrNa bhI caMDAlakA kUpa uttama puruSoM karake sevanIya nahIM; aise hI cAritrase bhraSTa sAdhu yadi vidvAn bhI ho, to bhI vaha zraSTa puruSAdvArA pUjA (satkAra) karane lAyaka nahIM hai / tAtparya ki vaha caMDAlake kUpakI taraha uttama puruSoMko tyAga karane yogya hai / tathA-AvazyakasUtraniyuktimeM bhI* "pAsasthAi vaMdamANassa, neva kittina nijarA hoi / kAyakilesaM emeva, kuNai taha kammabaMdhaM ca // " arthAt pArthasthAdi-zithilAcArI-yamaniyamAdike anu *tyAkhyA-pArzvasthAdInuktalakSaNAn vandamAnasya namaskurvataH naiva kIrti va nirjarA bhavati, tatra kIrtanaM kIrtiraho'yaM puNyabhAgityevalakSaNA sA na bhavati, apitvakAttirbhavati, nUnamayamapyevasvarUpo yenaipAM vandanaM karoti / tathA nijaraNaM nirjarA karmakSayalakSaNA sA na bhavati, tIrthakarAzAvirAdhanadvAreNa nirguNatvAttepAmiti / cIyate iti kAyaH dehaH tasya klezaH avanAmAdilakSaNaH kAyaklezastaM kAyaklezaM evameva mudhaiva karoti nirvatayati / tathA kriyate iti karma jJAnAvaraNIyAdilakSaNaM tasyabandhaH viziSTaracanayA Atmani sthApanaM, tena vA Atmano bandhaH svarUpatiraskaraNalakSaNaH karmavandhaH taM karmavandhaM ca karotItivarttate, cazabdAdAjJAdIMzca doSAnavApnute / katham ? bhagavatpratikruSTavandane AjJA maMgaH, taM dRSTvA'nyepi vandante ityanavasthA, tAn bandamAnAn daSTvA'nyeSAM mithyAtvaM, kAyaklezataH devatAbhyo vA AtmavirAdhanA, tadvandanena tatkatAsaMyamAnumodanAt saMyamavirAdhanetigAthArtha iti / pArzvasthAvasannakuzIla saMsaktayathAcchaMndAH, ete pArzvasthAdayaH (sAdhavaH) avandanIyA jinamate, iti ca [ bRhahRttau zrIharibhadrasUriH]

Page #137
129 chAnase rahita sAdhuoMko vaMdanA karanevAlekI na to saMsArameM kIrti hotI hai aura na koMkI nirjarA hotI hai| pratyuta vaha caMdanAdvArA zarIrako kaSTa detA aura karma baMdhana karatA hai| isalie gAr3I vAr3I aura lAr3I ke zAyakInoMko [cAhe vaha kitanebhI par3he likhe aura mIThe 2 vyAkhyAnodvArA logoMko mugdha karanevAle bhI kyoM na hoM| kevala veSamAtrase sAdhu tathA. guru kahane, evaM pUjya gurubuddhise unakI sevA bhakti karanekI AjJA jaina zAstra to nahIM detA / vivekasArake racayitA deM yaha unakA akhatyAra hai ! hamAre khyAlameM to isaprakArake graMtha jaina dharmameM kalaMka rUpa haiM ! isalie jainoMko isa tarpha ayazya lakSya denekI jarUrata hai! [6] corakA corIko tyAga kara tapazcaryA karake sadgatiko jAnA koI asaMbhava bAta nahIM / tapakI mahimA avarNanIya hai| isameM vAlmIka aura mAtaMga jaise maharSiyoMke itihAsa AbAlagopAla prasiddha haiN| maharSi manujI (vastutastu bhRgunI) manusmRti adhyAya dazameM likhate haiM ki-- yastaraM yadurApaM, yadurga yacca duSkaram / tatsarva tapasA sAdhyaM, tapo hi duratikramam // 239 // mahApAtakinazcaiva, zeSAzcAkAryakAriNaH / tapasaitra sutaptena, mucyante kilviSAttataH // 240 // kITAcAhipataMgAca, pazavazca vAMsi ca / sthAvarANi ca bhUtAni, divaM yAnti tapobalAt // 24 // ina zlokoMkA bhAvArtha yaha hai ki jisa hetuse dustara duSprApya aura duSkara kArya bhI tapake prabhAvase siddha ho sakate

Page #138
' 130 haiM isalie tapa hI duratikrama hai / brahmahatyAdi pApa aura aneka prakArake akRtya karanevAle tapake sAmarthya se ukta pAvase mukta ho jAte haiM / tapake balase kITa sarpa pataMga pazu pakSI aura sthAvara prANI taka svargako cale jAte haiM / . sajjano | svAmIjI jisa saMpradAya ke saMsthApaka haiM, vaha to, ( tapakI bAta to darakinAra ) sirpha pAvabhara ghI jalAkara 'pAMca miniTameM hI aMtyajoM ko bhI zarmA varmA banA rahI hai ! hama nahIM samajhate ki, karma mAtrase varNa vyavasthA sthApita karanekA jhaMDA liye phiranevAle sarasvatIjI mahArAja uttama -karma ke anuSThAnase honevAlI corakI sadgagati se kyoM hicakate haiM ?. [ 7 ] * svAmIjI kahate haiM ki, " "aba dekhiye inake sAdhu aura gRhasthoMkI lIlA inake matameM bahutase kukarma karanevAlA sAdhu bhI mokSako gayA aura zrI kRSNa narakameM gayA / " sajjano ! svAmIjIkA ukta kathana satya se bahuta girA karanekA upadeza tathA aisA ullekha kahIMpara 1 huA hai ! jaina graMthoM meM sAdhuko kukarma kukarma karane se koI sAdhu mokSako gayA nahIM / kevala dveSabuddhise niMdanIya karmakA kisI para Aropa karanA Apa jaise sanyAsIke lie ucita nahIM thA ! jaina loga kRSNako tIsare naraka meM gayA mAnate haiM yaha bAta satya hai paraMtu pratidina pratikramaNa [saMdhyA] meM donoM vakta usako vaMdanA bhI karate haiM yaha bhI satya hai / kyoMki inake siddhAMtAnusAra kRSNane Ageko amama nAmA bAravAM tIrthaMkara honA hai / isake Age svAmIjIkA " bhalA koI buddhimAn puruSa vicAroMki inake sAdhu " gRhastha aura tIrthaMkara jinameM bahuta se vezyAgAmI parastrIgAmI " cora Adi sabha jainamatastha svarga aura mokSako gaye au

Page #139
"zrIkRSNaM Adi dhArmika mahAtmA narakako gaye yaha kitanI "bar3I burI bAta hai" likhanA madhyastha prajAmeM kevala dveSAmi bhar3akAnA hai ! svAmIjIko ucita thA ki ve prathama jainagraMthoM ko dekha lete aura phira kRSNakA nAma lekara saMsArako bhdd'kaate| sajjano ! jaina matameM jisa kRSNakA ullekha hai vaha gItA ke upadeSTA kRSNase bhinna hai| kyoMki jainamatameM mAne hue kRSNako hue Aja 86440 varSase kucha adhika samaya ho cukA hai / vaha ariSTanoma nAmake 22 veM tIrthakarake cacere bhAI the, aisA jainoMkA mAnanA hai / aura 22 veM tIrthakarakA nivarNisamaya jainoMke aMtima tIrthaMkara bhagavAn mahAvIra svAmIke nirvANase 84000 varSa pUrva hai aura mahAvIra svAmIke nirvANako Aja 2440 mA varSa hai| paraMtu mahAbhAratameM ullikhita kRSNako hue Aja lagabhaga pAMca sahasra (5000)varSa hue haiM / jaina matameM bAraha cakravartI 9 baladeva 9 vAsudeva aura 9 prativAsu devoMkA isa avasarpiNImeM honA mAnA hai, jinameM kRSNa. navamaM vAsudeva hue haiN| isalie saMsArakA adhika bhAga jisa. kRSNacaMdrako IzvarAvatAra mAna rahA hai, aura svAmI dayAnaMda aura unake bhakta jisa (avatAra) kA ghora khaMDana kara rahe haiM ! ve kRSNa aura jainoMke mAne hue kRSNa vAsudevameM rAta dinakA aMtara hai ! svAmIjIne kRSNa bhagavAnakA nAma lekara jainoMpara asabhyatA bhare zabdoMse jo AkSepa kiyA hai usakA mAtra hetu, kRSNake upAsakoM kA jainoMse dveSa bar3hAnekA hai, aisA unake lekhase sphuTa pratIta hotA hai| [svAmIjIne jainamatakI samIkSA karate hue bahudhA eka hI AMkhase kAma liyA hai| zAyada ve netra hIna guruke ziSya the isIlie! ! anyathA unako jainoMkA kRSNa,

Page #140
132 jIko pratidina vaMdanA karanA aura Ageko 12 vAM tIrthaMkara honA mAnanA bhI prakAzita kara denA ucita thA ! kadApi koI kahe ki, svAmIjI jaina graMthoMse vAkipha nahIM the isa lie unhone kRSNajI ke saMbaMdha meM itanI bar3I bhUla khAI hai ! tatra to unake ziSya samudAyako ucita hai ki vaha gurujIkI isa mahatI azuddhiko mArjana karake unako ukta kalaMka se mukta kareM ! ! !] isake atirikta svAmIjIkA jaina sAdhu aura tIrthakaroko - vezyAgAmI parastrIgAmI aura caura Adi zabdoMse smaraNa karane kA kyA hetu thA ? yaha buddhimAna svayaM vicAra leveM / evaM matAMtarIya vidvAn aura unake lekhoM kI samIkSA karate hue svAmIjIne jinaM madhura zabdoMkA vyavahAra kiyA hai unase to pAThaka prathama acchI taraha paricita ho cuke haiM / paraMtu isa prakAra ke zabdoM ke prayoga karaneke kAraNakA anveSaNa karate hue ima jisa pariNAmapara pahuMce haiM usakA digdarzana karavA denA yahAM kucha Avazyaka pratIta hotA hai / maharSi kaNAdakA kathana hai ki, " kAraNaguNapUrvakaH kAryaguNo dRSTaH " arthAt kAraNameM jaise guNa hote haiM vaise hI kAryameM Ate haiN| saMsAra meM yaha bAta AbAla prasiddha hai ki, jaisA guru vaisA ziSya arthAt guruke saMskAroMkA prabhAva ziSya para adhika par3atA hai ! ziSyako yadi guruke saMbaMdha meM grAmophona kI bhI upamA dI jAve to hamAre vicArameM kucha asaMgata na hogI ! hamAre pAThaka isa bAtase to prAyaH jJAta hI hoMge ki, svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatIjIke guru kauna the ? kadApi kisI mahAnubhAvako patA na bhI hogA, isalie hama kaha dete haiM ki, svAmI dayAnaMdajIke guru the, svAmI virajAnaMdajI daMDI aMdhe ! basa, aMdhekA ziSya yadi aMdhA nahIM to eka tarpha dekhanevAlAto avazya honA cAhie ! 1

Page #141
': saMjano ! daMDI mahodaya AMkhoMse hI aMdhe nahIM the, kiMtu vicArase bhii'| Apake pavitra caritrako yadi kisIne eka vAra bhI adhyayana kiyA hogA to usako svAmI dayAnaMdajIkA matAMtarIya vidvAnoMko gAlie~ taka denekA hetu bar3I saralatAse samajhameM AMsakegA / kyoMki guruke AcaraNoMpara hI celoMkI sabhyatA nirbhara hai ! svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatIjIke guru netra hIna svAmI virajAnaMda daMDIjIkA caritra kitanA pavitra thA isakA eka udAharaNa hama pAThakoMkI sevAmeM nivedana karate haiM. " zrI maharSi svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatIke guru zrI svAmI virajAnaMda sarasvatI daNDIjIkA jIvana caritra " nAmakI pustakake pRSTa 19-20 meM likhA hai ki-- " saMvat 1917 ke caitra mAsameM eka satyake jijJAsu " vidyArthI svAmI dayAnaMda 'nAmA / usake pAsa A gaye jisa " taraha rekhA gaNitase anabhijJa manuSya aphalAtUnakA ziSya " nahIM ho sakatA thA usI prakAra vyAkaraNakA na jAnane" vAlA virajAnaMdakA ziSya nahIM ho sakatA thaa| vyAkaraNaM " jAnaneke kAraNa hI RSi virajAnaMdane vidyArthI dayAnaMdakoM "ziSya banAyA / tatpazcAt kaumudI Adi graMtha jo unake " ( dayAnaMdake ) pAsa the, yamunA nadImeM kikavA diye / " aura jaba dayAnaMdajI yamunAmeM nizcaya graMtha vahAkara A "gaye to Rpine kahA ki apanI buddhise bhI ina graMthoM ke "vicArako pRthaka kara do, taba aTAdhyAyI phaauuNgaa| "daMDIne yaha nizcaya kara liyA thA ki bhAgavatAdi purANoM " aura siddhAMta Adi anArSa graMthoMne saMsArameM atyaMta mUrkhatA " aura svArthatatparatAkA rAjya phailA rakkhA hai| isI kAraNa " bhraSTa graMthoMke / karttAoMkIorase apane vidyArthioMko

Page #142
" atyaMta ghRNA dilAnA cAhate the| tathA ca isa kAryakI " pUrti ke liye unhoMne eka jUtA rakha chor3A thA aura siddhAMta "kaumudIke kartA bhaddojI dIkSitakI mUrtiko ve saba vidyA"rthiyoMse jUte lagavAte the| kyoMki unakA-kazana thA ki " isI nacine saMskRta vidyAkI kuMjI aSTAdhyAya ke pracArako " rokaneke liye yaha banA rakkhA hai / kabhI bhAgavata purANakI " pustakako yaha kahate hue apane pAMva lagA dete the ki ina " purANoMne hI bhramajAla phailAkara logoMko vidyA buddhi aura " puruSArthase hIna kara diyA hai|" sajjano ! ukta lekhakA eka 2 akSara dhyAnase par3hane lAyaka hai / svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatIjIne saMsArabharake dharmoM tathA AcAryoMkA ghora anAdara karanA kahAMse sIkhA! isa bAtako samajhaneke lie ukta daMDIjIkA caritra bar3A hI jIvita udAharaNa hai ! daMDIjIkA prazasta jIvana madhyastha saMsArake lie kitanA AdaraNIya honA cAhie isa viSayameM hama svayaM kucha na kahate hue,kevala "sarasvatI ke pustaka parIkSA zIrSaka saMpAdakIya lekhako hI yahAMpara avikala rUpase uddhRta kara dete haiN| "jIvana caritra-isa choTIsI, 28 pRSToMkI, pustaka svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatIke guru svAmI virajAnanda sarasvatIkA carita varNana hai / cAreta kyA svAmIjIka saMbaMdha kI kucha bAtoMkA ullekha mAtra hai / yaha ullekha kisa AdhArapara kiyA gayA hai, yaha pustakameM nahIM likhA / mUla pustaka urdU hai / vaha "dharma vIra paM0 lekharAmajI Arya pathika"kI likhI huI hai| usIkA yaha hindI rUpAntara hai| rUpAntarakAra hai-munzI. jagadambA prasAda / prakAzaka, paNDita zaGkaradatta zarmA, (zarmA maizIna priMTiGga presa, murAdAbAda)se yaha eka AnemeM milatI hai /

Page #143
mAjakarake RSi aura maharSi kaise hote haiM, yaha jAnanekI icchA jise ho use yaha pustaka avazya par3ha lenA caahie| isake kitane hI aMza par3hakara hameM kheda huA aura krodha bhI A gyaa| sunate haiM, andhe AdamI prAyaH niHzIla hote haiN| paraMtuM svAmI virajAnanda paNDita the| isase unake viSayameM kahI gaI kitanI hI bAtopara Azcarya hotA hai / Azcarya kyA, unapara vizvAsa karaneko jI nahIM caahtaa| udAharaNa (1) "manoramA, zekhara, nyAya muktAvalI, sArasvata, candrikA paJcadazI Adi navIna vanAvaTI jyotiyoMke tuccha prakAzako aSTAdhyAyI Adi Rpi-muni-kRta sUryagranthoMke sAmane (svAmI virajAnanda) bilakula vyartha samajhane lge|" [pRSTa 16] (2) " aSTAdhyAyI, mahAbhAgya, vyAkaraNake mukhya grantha haiM tathA . kaumudI, manoramA Adi grantha manuSyakRta aura azuddha haiM / tathA nyAya muktAvalI Adi aura bhAgavatAdi purANa, raghuvaMza Adi kAvya, vedAntameM paJcadazI aura navIna sampradAyI jitane graMtha haiM saba azuddha haiM " / [pRSTha 18 ] mAlUma nahIM, isa caritake lekhaka lekharAma saMskRta bhASAke kitane bar3e vidvAn aura vyAkaraNa, nyAya, vedAnta, kAvya, purANa Adike kitane bar3e jJAtA the| unake pUrvokta avataraNoMse to sUcita hotA hai ki saMskRta bhASA aura saMskRta zAstroMse unakA kucha bhI saMparka na thA aura rahA bhI hogA to bahuta kama / jo kucha navIna hai sabhI azuddha haiM, yaha kahAMkA nyAya hai| paJcadazI azuddha! nyAya muktAvalI azuddha raghuvaMza azuddha! are bhAI, kabhI par3hA bhI inako ? yadi azuddha haiM to sAdhanta sabhI azuddha haiM yA inake kucha hI aMza azuddha haiM ? jabAnameM lagAmahI nahIM! yadi kisI graMthakA azuddha honA "navIna sampradAyI" honepara

Page #144
136 . hI avalambita ho to svAmI dayAnanda sarasvatIke banAye grantha bhI azuddha haiM, kyoMki ve bhI naye haiM aura sampradAyika bhAvase khAlI nhiiN| nyAya muktAvalI aura paJcadazI Adi to vanAvaTI jyotiyA~ haiM aura ApakI Rgveda bhASya bhUmikA aura satyArtha prakAza ? ve to zAyada sRSTike ArambhameM Apa hI Apa utpanna hue jvAlAmAlI sUrya haiM ! svAmI virajAnandane isa tarahakI bAteM yadi kahI bhI hoM, to bhI lekhakako samajhabUjha kara zabda prayoga karanA thaa| pratiSThita janoM ke mukhase aisI bAteM nikalanA acchA nahIM hotaa| RSiyoM aura muniyoMko hI zuddhatAkA ThekA paramezvarake yahAMse nahIM milaa| manuSya bhI zuddhAcArI aura zuddha lekhaka ho sakate haiN| vikSiptakI taraha barrAnese RSiyoM aura maharSiyoMkA bhI Adara nahIM hotA aura vicArapUrvaka bAta kahanese manuSya bhI zraddhAbhAjana ho sakatA hai| . . eka aura avataraNa suna lIjie: "daNDI virajAnandane yaha nizcaya kara liyA thA ki bhAgavatAdi purANoM aura siddhAnta Adi anArSa granthoMne saMsArameM atyanta mUrkhatA aura svArthaparatAkA rAjya phailA rakhA hai| isI kAraNa ve ina bhraSTa granthoMke kartAoMkI orase apane vidyArthioMko atyanta ghRNA dilAnA cAhate the| tathA ca isa kAryakI pUrttike lie unhoMne eka jUtAM rakha chor3A thA aura siddhAnta kaumudIke kartA bhaTTojI dIkSitakI mUrtiko ve saba vidyArthioMse jUte lagavAte the "[pRSTa 20] chi0 chi0 ! kahAM to sanyAsa-vrata aura kahAM aisA jaghanya kAma! jisa kaumudIkI badaulata hI isa jUte bAja svAmIko aSTAdhyAyI par3hanekI akla AI usIke kartAkA itanA apamAna ! kRtaghnatA kI hada ho gaI ! vivekakI iti zrI ho gaI ! aise hI aise RSi-janocita kAryoMke upalakSyameM Arya samAjake anuyAyiyoMne isa netra hIna vaiyAkaraNako bhI RSikI padavI

Page #145
- - 137 de DAlI hai / siddhAnta kaumudIkA Adara karanevAloMko aba isa bAta para vicAra karanA cAhie ki yadi koI vaiyAkaraNa hararoja subaha uThakara virajAnandakI mUrtipara ginakara pacAsa daphe usI taraha ke sammAna puSpa car3hAve to use bhI RSikI padavI milanI cAhie yA nahIM ? AryasamAjake nAyakoMko munAsiba hai ki ve dUsaroMkA Adara karanA sIkheM aura isa rUpameM isa pustakakA pracAra rokadeM / Arya samAjiyoMke guruke gurukI isa lIlAke vijJApana se hAnike sivA lAbha nhiiN| jisa "dharma vIra" ne isa lIlAkI jhAMkI dikhAI hai usakI vIra aura dhArmika AtmAko bhagavAn sadgati de !" [sa0 bhA 15 khaM 2 saMkhyA 3 ] * * noTa-bahudhA logoMkA mata hai ki vartamAna Arya samAjake zikSita vibhAgameM vicAra saMkIrNatA aura aMdha zraddhAlutA anya sAMpradAyika puruSoM kI apekSA kucha kama hai / hama bhI isa vicArameM adhikAMza sahamata the, paraMtu vizeSa parAmarzase hamArA ukta vicAra bhramamUlaka hI nikalA / matAMdhatA aura vyaktigata rAgAMdhatAne vartamAna Aryadalake zikSita vibhAgako bhI azikSitoMkI taraha apanA dAsa banAye vinA nahIM chor3A ! kitaneka sAmayika saMyogoMse yaha bAta spaSTa jAna par3atI hai| udAharaNa ke lie ukta saMpAdakIya samAlocanA hI le liijie| hameM kheda hai ki, ukta niSpakSa samAlocanAko dekhakara bhI vartamAna Aryadalake nAyakoMke krodhakI mAtrA itanI bar3ha gaI ki, aneka samAjI palIma kolAhala macAne ke sivA kitanAMka bAla aura vRddha sabhAoNne ukta AlocanAke viSayameM kaI eka prastAva bhI pAsa kara DAle ! jinase madhyaprAMta bulanda zaharakI Arya pratinidhi sabhAke pAsa kiye hue eka prastAva ko pATakoMke avalokanArtha hama yahAM para bhI uddhRta kara dete haiN| " Arya graMthakAroMse savinaya nivedana hai ki ve apanI likhI " pUstakoMko sarasvatI saMpAdaka paMDita mahAvIraprasAdajI dvivedIke

Page #146
138 sajjano ! siddhAMta prabhRti sadagraMthoMko yamunA nadIma vahAne aura bhaTTojI dIkSita jaise asIma upakArI AcAryoMko nIca kahakara unakI pUjanIya pratimAkA jUtoMse nirAdara karanevAle aMdhe guruke cele, svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatIjI, jainAcAryoMko yadi vezyAgAmI batalAve to kucha Azcarya nahIM ! kyoMki, " Akake par3ase kabhI Ama nahI TapakA karate" !!! " pAsa samAlocanArtha kadApi na bhejA kareM / pakSapAtake vinA " nyAyapUrvaka pustakake guNa dopa varNana karanA pratyeka samAloca. "kakA pradhAna karttavya honA cAhiye / paraMtu kheda hai ki dvivedIjI " isa vAtako kabhI kabhI bilakula bhUla jAte haiN| Arya " samAjake Upara to unake krodhakI mAtrA dina pratidina " bar3hatI jAtI hai| abhI hAlameM Apane eka pustakakI " samAlocanA karate hue zrI svAmI dayAnaMdajI sarasvatIke guru " maharSi virajAnandajI prajJAcakSuke Upara gaMde zabdokI bauchAr3a " karake apanI mahAvIratAkA pracaNDa paricaya de DAlA hai| " aisI dazAmeM hamArI sammati hai ki koI AryagraMthakAra " apanI pustakoMko vahAM na bhejeN|" Arya pratinidhi sabhA saMyukta prAnta bulanda zahara / vina 6-10-14. ( madanamohana seTha '.A. L. L. B. maMtrI sabhA. sajano ! meghapaTalAcchanna sUryakI taraha vyaktigata rAgAMdhakArase; kartavya patha pradarzaka jJAnazaktike lupta ho jAnepara, manuSya kisa mArgakA avalaMbana karatA hai ? aura aMdhazraddhA, guNadoSake vicArase use kisa taraha vaMcita rakhatI hai ? ukta prastAvake par3hanese yaha bakhUbI samajhame A sakatA hai / astu ! jina mahAnubhAvoMne yaha prastAva prakAzita kiyA hai unako unakI ananya guru bhaktike upalakSameM jitanA dhanyavAda diyA jAya utanA hI kama hai !! .

Page #147
- aba hama svAmIjIke dUsare kathanapara kucha vicAra karate haiN| svAmIjI pharmAta haiM ki vicArakara dekheM to acche puruSako jainiyoMkA saMga karanA vA unako dekhanA bhI burA hai kyoMki ina mahA haThI durAgrahI manuSyoM ke saMgase sivAya burA iyoMke anya kucha bhI palle na paDegA" sajano ! svAmIjI, jainoMkA saMga to dara kinAra, darzana takameM bhI burAI basalAte haiN| isakA kAraNa unake kathanAnusAra jainoMkA haTha aura durAgraha hai ! paraMtu jainoMke darzana takameM bhI pApa kahanA yaha niSpakSa bhAvase hai yA durAgrahase ? yaha bhI vicAraNIya hai| jainoM ke saMga aura darzanase anya manupyoMke sivA svAmIjImeM kitanI burAI AI hogI isa bAtakA anubhava unhoMne hI kiyA hogA / paraMtu zoka hai ki, svAmIjI jaldI hI kUca kara gaye ! ! yadi ve kucha kAla aura jIte rahate to saMbhava thA ki, jisa prakAra unhoMne apane (mAne hue) anya kitaneka siddhAMtoMko ( unakI buddhike anusAra asaMgata honeke kAraNa) uthalA puthalA diyaa| isI prakAra unakI, jaina tathA itara dharmAcAryoMko haThI durAgrahI aura jhUThe dukAna dAra Adi, bIbhatsa zabda kahanekI burI Adata bhI badala . jAtI ! aura jisa dveSa aura durAgrahase unhoMne jainoMke darzanameM bhI pApa batalAyA hai zAyada vaha jar3a mUlase hI ukhaDa jAtA !!! kyoMki bhramayukta manuSya kitanIka asta vyasta bAteM bhI kaha DAlatA hai| bhramake dUra ho jAnepara unheM doSarUpa samajhakara vaha tyAga bhI detA hai| isI prakAra svAmI dayAnaMdajIke saMbaMdha samajhanA cAhie / paraMtu svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatIjI sarvathA nizrInta the, unameM aMdherA nAma mAtrako bhI nahIM thA, isa prakArake aMdha zraddhAluoMke viSayameM hama kucha nahIM kaha sakate !

Page #148
140 kyoMki zrAvaNa bhAdrapadake mahIne meM netra hIna huA manuSya sarvatra harA hI harA dekhatA hai ! usakA yaha doSa svabhAvakI taraha anivArya hai !! niSpakSa janatA ke hRdaya meM: isa prakAra ke saMkIrNa vicAroMko sthAna nahIM milatA yaha khuzIkI bAta hai| pAThakoM ko isa bAtakA smaraNa rahe ki hamAre isa kathana meM anyAnya vidvA. noMke atirikta kitaneka nippakSa AryasamAjI vidvAn bhI sahAnubhUti dharAte haiM / udAharaNa ke lie " maharSi svAmI dayAnanda sarasvatI aura unakA kAma " nAmI kitAba meM hamAre bhArata premI zrIyuta lAlA lAjapatarAyajI likhate haiM . " hamako bhalIbhAMti vidita hai, ki svAmI " dayAnaMda sarasvatIne apane jIvanameM kai vera - "apanI sammatiyeM palaTI / eka samaya thA ki "vaha zivamatako pratipAdana karate the, aura "rudrAkSa aura kaMThImAlA dhArate the / phira eka " samaya AyA ki usakA khaMDana karane lage / ""eka samaya thA ki vaha ( dekho cAMdApurakA "vAda ) mokSakI avadhi nahIM mAnate the / aura. "unako nizcaya thA ki mukta huI AtmA phira " deha dhAraNa nahIM karatI / phira vaha samaya " AyA ki unhoMne apanI sammati palaTa dI " Adi Adi / kisako vidita hai ki yadi " vaha jIte rahate to apane jIvanameM aura kyA.

Page #149
141 "kyA sammatiyeM palaTate / jitanI Ayu var3ha"tI thI utanI hI vidyA aura jJAna unakA "adhika hotA jAtA thA, utanA hI pratyaya "prakAza unapara DAlaMtA jAtA thaa| aisI "avasthAmeM kauna kaha sakatA hai ki svAmIjI "nirdhAnta the / jo mahAzaya unako nirdhAnta "mAnate haiM vaha kRpAkara usa samaya ko bhI "prakaTa kareM jaba ki vaha nirdhAnta hue|" [pRSTha 142 ] astu ! aba svAmIjIkI eka aura bAtapara pAThaka dhyAna deN| svAmIjI "hAM jainiyoM meM jo uttama puruSa haiM unakA saMga karanemeM kucha doSa nahIM" likhate hue jo noTameM likhate haiM ki "jo uttama puruSa hogA vaha isa asArajainamatameM kabhI na rahegA" isakI saMgati hamAre khyAlameM nahIM AtI / kyoMki svAmIjIke kathana mutAbika jainoM meM uttama purupa toraha hI nahIM . sakatA, jo rahe vaha uttama nahIM arthAt adhama hai ! to phira jainoMmeM vaha uttama puruSa AyagA kahAMse ? jisake saMga karanemeM svAbhIjI doSa nahIM batalAte : yadi noTake kathanako saccA mAnA jAya taba to unakA UparakA kathana jhUThA ThaharatA hai aura yadi UparakA kathana hI satya mAnA jAya taba noTakA ullekha mithyA siddha hotA hai ! isalie ukta donoM lekhoM se svAmIjIke kisa lekhako satya aura kisako jhUThA ThaharAnA ? isakI sapramANa mImAMsA yadi koI samAjI mahAzaya hI kara

Page #150
15.2 nekAH prayatna kareM tato madhyastha prajAko bahuta lAbha ho / paraMtu eka tarpha to " jainoMmeM jo uttama puruSa haiM " kathana karanA aura dUsarI tarpha " jo uttama puruSa haiM vaha jainoMmeM raha hI nahIM sakatA " kahanA ! isa vadato vyAghAta ke dolatese svAmIjIkI kyA dazA huI. aura varttamAna Arya samAjane - usakI kyA cikitsA kI ? yaha hama nahIM kaha sakate . / kyA. nainoM meM koI uttama puruSa nahIM ? saba adhama hI adhama haiM ? svAmIjIke dalake to saba uttama ! aura jainasamAjake - saba adhama ! kitane insAphakI bAta haiM ? jaghAnako thor3IsI -bhI lagAma kI jarUrata nahIM rakhI ! dhanya hai AryasamAja ke kaliyugI / maharSi ! aba . vicArazIla puruSoMse hamArA nivedana hai ki, svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatIjIkI taraha yadi koI jainasamAjakA netA vartamAna Aryadalako adhama batalAve to usako bhI jaina samAja kI, tarpha (vartamAna AryasamAjakI taraha ) maharSikI padavI milanI cAhie yAki nahIM ? isake atirikta bhI svAmIjIne vivekasAra-tatvavivekaratnasAra prabhRti bhASA ke kSudra kSudra graMthoMke hI kitaneka vAkya uddhRta karake jainoMpara manamAne AkSepa kie haiM, paraMtu unako ucita thA ki, ve jainadharma ke sarvamAnya siddhAnta graMthoM ke vAkyoMko uddhRta karake unakI samIkSA karate ! hame vivaza hokara kahanA par3atA hai ki, jainadharma ke khaMDana karanemeM satyArtha - prakAzakAM - lagabhaga dosau pRSTha kAlA kiyA hai paraMtu usameM ratnasAra vivekasAra Adike sivA jainadharma ke kisI bhI AgamakA vAkya taka bhI uddhRta nahIM kiyA 1 satyArtha prakAzakI bhUmikA ke aMdara svAmI jIneM jainoMke mAnanIya jitane graMthoMkA ullekha kiyA hai unameM se . ekakA bhI vAkya. bAraveM samulAsameM dekhane meM nahIM AtA ! hama 2 : 1

Page #151
143 nahIM samajhA ki, jainoMke sarvamAnya saMskRta aura prAkRtake aneka graMthAko chor3akara vivekasAra jaise raddI pustakoMke nAmase itanA araNya rodana svAmIjIne kyoM kiyA ? kadApi unhoMne vedoM se rela-tAra nikAlanekI taraha yaha lIlA. bhI apane zkoko rijhAne ke lie hI kI ho to hama kaha nahIM sakate ! isalie svAmIjIke viveka aura sArakI samIkSAko hama pAThakoMke. hI svAdhIna karate haiN| kRpayA ve hI isameMse sAra nikAlanekA prayatna kareM / svAmIjIne to saMsAra para bahuta upakAra kiyA hai ! vartamAna Aryadala unase anRNI ho sake aisI AzA nahIM ! kyoMki unhoMne cirakAla taka jaina graMthoMkA abhyAsa karake unako haThI durAgrahI aura mUkhoMke banAe hue sAbita kara dikhAyA ! isa upalakSameM kitaneka samAjI mahAzaya yadi phUle na samAyeM to kucha Azcarya nahIM / paraMtu svAmIjIke isa mayUra vATakakA madhyastha saMsAra para kitanA prabhAva par3A hai ? vaha hama nahIM kaha skte| "digaMbara-zvetAMbara aura svAmI dayAnaMda " svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatIjIne, jainadharmakI digaMbara aura zvetAMbara ina do mukhya zAkhAoMkA paraspara sthUla aMtara kitanA hai, yaha batalAne ke lie jaina muni zrI jinadatta sUri racita "viveka vilAsa " mese tIna zloka satyArtha-prakAzameM uddhRta kiye haiN| unamese tIsarA zloka aura usakI svAmIjIkRta vyAkhyAke pAThako hama pAThakoMke avalokanArtha yahAM para uddhRta karatehaiM / na bhukte kevalaM na strI, mokSameti digambaraH / prAhureSAmayaM bhedo, mahAn zvetAmbaraiH saha / 3 / / * bhA.-digabaroMkA zvetAmbaroMke sAtha itanA hI bheda hai ke, digaMvara loga strI saMsarga nahIM karate aura zvetAMbara karate

Page #152
144 haiM ityAdi vAtoMse mokSako prApta hote haiM yaha I ho| oMkA bheda hai| [ pRSTa 477 ] ': samAlocaka-hAya ! hAya ! kitanA anI meM raha aMdhera ! kahAM to jaina matake khaMDanakA abhimAna lattase usake sthUlase sthUla siddhAntoMke samajhane meM bhI itanA ajJAna sAhasakI hada ho gaI ! vijJAnakI samApti ho gaI ! pAThaka mahodaya ! svAmIjI bar3e hI prauDha vaiyAkaraNa ye kyoMki unhoMne siddhAnta kaumudI Adi graMthoMko yamunA nadImeM 'pheMkakara eka netra hIna vaiyAkaraNase aSTAdhyAyI aura mhaa| bhASya par3hA thA / isalie vuddhimAnoM ko unake prazasta vaiyAkaraNa' honemeM aNumAtra bhI saMdeha nahIM ! hamako to svAmIjI ke vyAkaraNa saMbaMdhi aprameya jJAnakA vartamAna AryasamAjase bhI adhirva abhimAna na hai ! paraMtu svAmIjIne ukta zlokakA jo artha likhA hai vaha yadi aise vidvAnke dekhane meM Ave jo ki svAmIjIke caritase anabhijJa ho to saMbhava nahIM ki vaha svAmIjIkI zabdazAstra sambandhI yogyatAkI kadara kie vinA raha sake ! vaha yadi sAthameM jaina siddhAMtakA bhI kuccha jJAtA ho taba to svAmIjIkI jainazAstrIya vijJatAkI bhI prazaMsA kina zabdoMse kare isakA nizcaya karanA hamAre lie to azakya hai| __hAM ! itanA to hama avazya kaha sakate haiM ki ukta zlokakA. artha karake sAkSara vargameM svAmIjIne jo zAstrIya pratiSTa: prApta kI hai. usake upalakSameM vartamAna AryasamAja uneM yA maharSise bhI Age bar3hA detA, evaM eka " dayAnaMda digvijaya / kI jagaha yadi.dasa vIsa pacAsa bhI digvijaya banA diye jA.''

Page #153
.! kyA hI acchA hotA jo uktaM zlokakA artha nahIM samajhaprathama kisI yogya jaina vidvAnse samajha lete / paraMtu bhanaka prathaHkaranese zAyada unakI mahatI pratiSTAko koI dhakkA itanA ara astu aba hama ukta zloka kA yathArtha pATha aura vedamise rela ThIka arthaH pAThakoMko batalAte haiM ! bha " na bhukte kevalI na strI, mokSamati digNbraaH| mAhureSAmayaM bhedo, mahAn zvetAmbaraiH saha " bhA0-(kevalI na bhukta) kevalI-tatvajJAnI bhojana nahIM karatA, aura (strI mokSaM na eti) strI mokSako prApta nahIM hotI, aise (digaMbarAH prAhuH ) digaMvara loga kahate haiM (zvetAMbaraiH saha) zvetAmbaroMke sAtha ( eSAM) inakA-digaMbaroMkA (ayaM) yaha ( mahAn bhedaH ) bar3A bheda hai. arthAt jaina dharmakI zvetAmbara aura digaMvara ina do zAkhAoMmeM bar3A bhArI aMtara itanA hI hai ki zvetAMbara loga tatvajJAnIkA bhojana karanA aura cAritra (sanyAsavrata)ke pAlanese karma kSaya dvArA strIkA mukta honA mAnate haiM, aura digaMbara loga ukta dono bAteM svIkAra nahIM karate / pAThakoMko yahAMpara itanA aura bhI smaraNa rahe ki ukta lokameM kevalI ke sthAnameM jo svAmIjIne kevalaM likha mArA hai vaha sarvathA jaina siddhAntase viruddha aura azuddha hai ! kadApi, kevaLaM pATha hI svIkAra kiyA jAve to bhI svAmIjIne " digaMbara loga strIkA saMsarga nahIM karate" " zvetAMbara karate haiM" / " ityAdi vAtoMse mokSako prApta hote haiM " yaha kina akSaroMkA artha kiyA so to svAmIjI jAne, yA gurukulake naye kaNAda, "pataMjali, yA, gautama vyAsa ! kyoMki, svAmIjIke veda bhASyoMkI zeSapUrti aba unhIpara avalaMbita hai !

Page #154
1-46 "zaMkara svAmIkI mRtyu aura svAmIdayAnanda". svAmIdayAnandasarasvatIjI mahArAjane, jainoMke viSaya meM anyAnya bAtoM kA ullekha karaneke sivA eka aura bar3I vicitra bAta likhi hai ! bAta kyA hai ? jainoMpara mithyA Aropa diyA gayA hai ! Apa likhate haiM-- [ "jaba vedamatakA sthApana ho cukA aura vidyA pracAra karanekA vicAra karate hI the itane meM do jaina Uparase kathana mAtra vedamata aura bhItarase kaTTara jaina arthAt kapaTa muni the / zaMkarAcArya unapara ati prasanna the unadonoMne avasara pAkara zaMkarAcArya ko aisI viSayukta vastu khilAI ki unakI kSudhA maMda ho gaI pazcAta phor3e phunsI hokara chaH mahIne, ke bhItara hI zarIra chUTa gayA "] [satyA. pra. pU. 278 ] samAlocaka -- svAmIjI, bhagavAn zaMkarAcAryakI mRtyukA kAraNa jainoM ko batalAte haiM / unakA kathana hai ki jainAne viSa dekara zaMkarAcAryako mAra DAlA ! magara isa kathana kI 'satyaMtA ke, kie unhoMne kisI pramANakA ullekha nahIM kiyA ! evaM svAmI zaMkarAcAryajIke jitane jIvanacarita Ajataka upalabdha hue haiM unameM bhI ukta varNana nahIM hai aura nAhI aisA koI aitihAsika graMtha hamAre dekhane meM AyA hai ki jisameM zaMkarasvAmIkI mRtyukA kAraNa jainoM ko batalAyA ho ! hame Azcarya hai ki, saMsArabharake vidvAnoMmeM Ajataka jo bAta kisIkebhI smRtigocara nahI huI svAmIjIko usakA patA kaise milA ? sajjano ! svAmIjI mahArAja paramayogI the ! yogAbhyAsake atula balase unheM matIndriya jJAnakI upalabdhi ho cukI thI ! hama jina bAtoMkA jJAna ina carmacakSubhase nahIM kara sakate svAmIjI mahArAjane apanI yogavibhUtise unako

Page #155
pratyakSa kara liyA thA ! isalie unake lekhoM meM pramANoMkA anve-- paNa kAnA hamAre lie Avazyaka nahIM hai ! kyoMki ve RSi. the ! aura hama manuSya haiM ! mastu ! hamArA sabhya saMsArase sAgraha nivedana hai ki, vaha svAmIdayAnandasarasvatIjIke ukta lekhapara avazya dhyAna de| eka samAjapara akAraNa hI itanA bhayAnaka asabhya AkSepa karanA svAmIjI ke lie kahAMtaka zobhAspada hai yaha pAThaka svayaM vicAreM / hamAre vicArameM to AryasamAjake netAbhoMko ucitta hai ki, ve satyArthaprakAzamaise ukta lekhakoto avazyahI nikaalddaaleN| isa prakAra ke AropI mithyA lekhoMse svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatIjIkI pratiSThA nahIM pratyuta usakI hAnikI hI saMbhAvanA hai ! aba prakAzakA jamAnA hai !! aMdhera sadAke lie nahIM rahatA!!! sajjano | jainadharmake saMbaMdhameM svAmI dayAnaMda sarasvatIjIne lo udgAra nikAle haiM unakA yaha namUnA mAtra ApakI sevAmeM nivedana kiyA gayA hai / isapara niSpakSa bhAvase vicAra karanA paba ApakA kartavya hai| kyoMki niSpakSa bhAva hI manuSya jIvanakA saccA uddeza hai / jaba taka manuSyake hRdayase "merA so saccA" nikalakara " saccA so merA" isa vicArakI sthiratA na ho taba taka jIvanake vAstavika lakSase vaha kosoM - dUra hai| astu ! aba hama isa lekhako madhyastha bhAvase avalokana karaneke lie sabhya pAThakoMse nivedana karate hue apanI lekhinIko virAma dete haiM / zivamaMstu sarvajagataH / Ba Ba Ba Ba Ba Ba Ba Ba Ba Ba Ba Ba Ba Ba Ba Ba Ba Gong iti madhyasthavAda granthamAlAyAH prathamaM puSpam / /

Page #156

Page #157
": vimala vinoda ... WE ..4 cAhA LikAvimalAmAkaratAhA:Ara-1, .. . .. basa nAma hose AnaMda denevAlI yaha pustaka hai / cimuca hI pahanevAleko vimala bhI karatI hai aura vinodaH / mA. detI hai| Ajakala upanyAsake zaukIna jyAdA najara / pAte haiN| basa unake hI lie yaha pustaka samAjhae / / isameM upanyAsake DhaMgase AryasamAjake netA svAmI / dI . Sal-. ' inti .... liyA ki pUrNa kiye binA caina na paregI. rozana mahallI AgArA

Page #158
14: [ Shi 8 F -- 44 fri

Page #159
_