Tattvartha Kartutatnmat Nirnay

Author(s): Sagranandsuri
Publisher: Rushabhdev Kesarimal Jain Shwetambar Sanstha
Catalog link: https://jainqq.org/explore/004064/1

Page #1
munizrI nItivijayajI saune zA * yAne * zrIvItarAgAya namaH OM zrItattvArthakartRtanmatanirNaya zrItattvArthasUtrake karttAzvatAMvara hai yA digaMbara? vicAra saMgrAhakaparamapUjya nRpatipratibodhaka AgamoddhAraka zrImat sAgarAnandasUrIzvarajI mahArAja. _____prakAzikA-zrI ratalAma (ratnapurIya) zrIRSabhadevajI kezarImalajI nAmnI zvetAMbarasaMsthA. prathamAvRtta / paNyaM vikramasaMvat 500 / --10-0 / 1993 prAptisthAna--zrIjanAnandapu takAlaya gopIpurA sUrata. . isa pustakakA sarva haka prakAzakane svAdhIna rakhA hai. 24 priMTiMga presa, indaura meM mudrita. For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #2
2 (1) itaradarzana kAroMne jaba apane darzana meM aura dusare meM mArgazabda lagAyA taba isameM bhI mokSamArgazabda se kahA gayA. yAne mokSazabda ke sAtha mArgazabda zarIka kiyA gayA hai. (3) tatvArthazraddhAnaM samyagdarzanaM isakA bheda dikhAnekA sUtra alaga rakhakara yaha sUtra lakSaNakI torasehI alaga kiyAanyathA 'nisargAdhigamAbhyAM tatrazraddhA samyaktvaM' itanAhI kaha dete. darzanazabdabhI isameM sUcaka hI hai / (4) itaradarzanakAroM kevala saMhitAdise vyAkhyA mAnate haiM, taba tatvArthakArane nAmAdinikSepase vyAkhyA dikhAneko nAmasthApanA0 sUtra kahA / (5) jJAnazabda se zuddhajJAna rakhakara sAmAnyase bodha dikhAneke lie adhigamazabda rakha kara ' pramANanayairadhigamaH ' aisA kahA. yA bodhazabda nahIM rakhake adhigamazabda anyadarzanakI prasiddhise hogA, kabhI tIsare sUtrameM adhigamazabda se bhI upadeza liyA gayA hai usake saMbaMdha se * pramANa aura nayase yAne tanmayavAkyoMse upadeza hotA hai asA mAna le taba bhI yahI huvA ki anyadarzanakAra apanI prarUpaNA pramANase hai aisA mAnate haiM, lekina ye loga kevala nayAdise hI prarUpaNA karanevAle haiM aura jainako to pramANa aura naya donoMsehI prarUpaNA iSTa hai, isa tarahase bhI yaha darzana ke hisAba se sUtra hai / 3 For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #3
(6) tat pramANe, aura Aye parokSaM, pratyakSamanyat, ye tIna sUtra .: bhI itasdarzanoMke adhikArase hai| (7) matyAdijJAnoMkA sUtroMmeM dravya-kSetra-kAla-bhAcase viSaya dikhAyA hai, taba tatvArthakArane sirpha dravya bhAva hI dikhAyA, isakA bhI kSetra aura kAlako dravya mAna kara tarkAnusAriyoM kI anukUlatAhI tatva hai. .... (8).adhigamake kAraNoMke dikhAte jo tIna sUtra 'pramANanayai radhipamA 'nirdeza' 'satsaMkhyA' aise dikhAye haiM yaha tarkAnusAriyoMke hI anukUlatA ke liye hai| ....... zAstrAmaM pRthvI, jala, vAyu aura agniko jaDa mAne haiM, lekina idhara inako sacetana dikhAye haiM. vaijJAnikalogabhI vanaspati aura pRthvIko aba sacetana mAnate haiN| (anyamajahabakAloMne indriya aura viSayake vaiSamyase hI padArthajJAnakA vaiSamya mAnA hai, lekina bhagavAna zrIumAsvAtijIne padArtha aura indriyako vaiSamyatAna hone para bhI jJAtAkI dhAraNAke kAraNasabhI jJAnaviSamatA mAnI hai, anyamajahabakAloMne bhinna indriyakA sugamat jJAna ho jAya usako rukane ke liye jJAnakI yugapat anutpatti ke liye aNu aisA.mana mAna liyA, aura vaha aNu.aisA manamAnAke jisa indriyake sAtha saMyukta ho usakA jJAna utpanna hoke, aisA For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #4
mAna liyA hai, lekina ekahI indriyase aneka viSayoM kA jJAna honekA mokA AjAya yAne ekahI sparzanase zIta, uSNAdi jAnane kA, rasanAse tiktAdi anekarasa, cakSuse aneka rUpa aura zrotrase aneka zabda jAnane kA maukA AjAya to phira jJAtAkI dhAraNA ko Age karanIhI hogI. isI tarahase vAcakajI mahArAja pharamAte haiM ki jisakI dhAraNA AtmIyakalyANa ke dhyeyavAlI nahIM hai vaha manuSya apanA jJAna AtmakalyANa dhyeya se nahIM karake paugalikake dhyeyase hI karatA hai, usa jJAnakA prayojanabhI pauGgalikahI siddha karegA, isase usa paugalika dhyeyaSAlekA jJAna ajJAnahI hai. yAne jJAnakA samyakapaNA acchI dhAraNA se hI hotA hai, aura acchadhAraNAvAleke jJAnakA hI pramANavibhAga dikhAyA hai ! (11) anyadarzanakAroM ke anukaraNase hI isa tattvArthakI racanA honese hI to 'sadasato' isa sUtra meM anyadhAraNAvAle ko unmatta jaisA kaduzabda lagAyA hai, yAne anyadarzanakAroMkA ayogya aura asatya pracAra dekhake hI ina anukaraNakArako ghRNA Ai hogI, aura usI ghRNAse yaha kaThora kathana huA hogA / (12) jaise dIpakajyoti samAna hone para bhI kAcakre raMgake anukaraNase hI misra mizra prakAza hotA hai, isI tarahase For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #5
padArtha aura indriyAdise samAna buddhijanma hone para bhI dhAraNAke raMgakA anukaraNa hI buddhi karatI hai. isase yogya dhAraNA rahitako ajJAnahIM mAnA, yAne jaise andhe AdamI padArthako na dekhanese yathAyogya dRzyapadArthake viSayameM heyopAdeya pravRtti nahIM kara sakte haiM. usI taraha mRgatRSNAko jalasthAna mAnanevAle kI taraha bhI yA kaMcanako pitala aura pitalako kaMcana dikhanevAle AdamIbhI yathAyogya heyopAdeya phalako nahIM pA sakta haiM. isI taraha idharabhI syAdvAdamudrAkI aura mokSadhyeyakI dhAraNA nahIM rakhanevAlA .AtmaprakSase abodha yA durbodha hai, isase usake jJAnako ajJAna mAnake pramANake hisAbameM hI nahIM liyA hai. (13) itaradarzanakArIko syAdvAda maMjUra nahIM karanA hai isase inako upakramase sUtroMkI vyAkhyA karanI nahIM hai saba vastuko nAmAdicatuSkamaya. mAnanevAlAhI upakramAdikarUpase vyAkhyAna kara sake, isI sababasa bhagavAn umAsvAtijIne jAmasthApanAdikA sUtra kahakara catuSkakI vyApakatA dikhAI, usI taraha anugamanAmaka vyAkhyAnameM upayukta aise saMhitAdibheda itaradarzanakAroMne maMjUra kiyA, lekina syAdvAda maMjUra karane ke Darase hI una logoMne nayakI dRSTise vyAkhyA maMjUra nahIM kI hai. yadyapi ekanayadRSTise ke sabhI mata hai hI, lekina paraspara viruddha aise For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #6
nayoMkA samAveza karake dUsaroMko vyAkhyAna karanekA mokA hovehI nahIM, kyoMki aisA karanemeM viruddhadharmakA samAveza karanA hI par3e, isI hisAbase itaradarzana napasamUhako na to mAnate haiM aura na bhinabhinnanayase padArthokI vyAkhyA karate haiM, paraMtu jainazAsanameM to saba yA artha koI bhI nayavicAraNA sivAya kA nahIM hai, isase bhagavAna umAsvAtijIne nayakA vicAra calAyA hai| isI apekSAse hI AcArya mahArAja zrIsiddhasenadivAkara pharamAte haiM ki bhagavAna ApameM saba dRSTi hai, lekina sabaSThimeM Apa nahIM hai. dekhiye ! " udaghAvika sarvasiMghavaH, samudIrNAstvayi nAtha ! dRSTayaH / na ca tAsu bhavAn pradRzyate, pravi'bhaktAsu saritsvivodadhiH // 1 // " yAne nayavAdake hisAbase jainamajahabameM saba majahaba haiM, lekina anyamajahabameM jainamajahaba nahIM hai, nayavAdase jaba aisA hai tava atIndriyapadArthake hisAbase aisA hai ki sabhI majahaba dvAdazAMgasehI hai, aura isIse dvAdazAMga hI ratnAkara tulya hai, kevala dvAdazAMgakA hI padArtha anyamajahabavAloMne anyathArUpase liyA hai|' (14) itaradarzanakAroMne dravya aura guNAdi padArtha mitra mitra mAne haiM, isase ye loga guNAdika padArthoMko vyakta bhAvarUpase nahIM nirUpaNa kara sakate haiM, taba jainadarzana dravya aura For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #7
bhAvakA kathaMcit bhinnAbhinapaNAko mAnya karane ke kAraNa bhAvake nAsase paryAya dikhA sakte haiM, aura isIse tatrArthakAramahArAja : paryAyapadArthako bhI sAtha lekara bhAvake nAmase hI guNoMkA bhI nirUpaNa karate haiM, lekina pAThakoMko khyAla rakhanA cAhiye ki yaha zAstra mokSaprAptike uddezase hI banAyA gayA hai isase jyAdaha jIvake uddezase hI bhAvakA nirUpaNa kiyA hai| (15) anyadarzanakAroMne jIvako jJAnakA adhikaraNa mAnA hai, mAne AtmAko jJAnakA bhAjana mAnA hai, parantu jainadarzanake mantavyAnusAra na to jJAna AtmAse bhinna hai aura na jJAna AtmAmeM AdheyabhAvase rahA huvA hai, kiMtu AtmA jhanasvarUpa hI hai, isIse hI sUtrakArane 'upayogo lakSaNaM' aisA sUtra kahA hai, yadyapi anyamajahabavAloko paramezvarameM jJAna mAnanA hai aura iMdriya yA mana jo jJAnake sAdhana mAne haiM ve paramezvarako nahIM mAnanA hai, isase jJAna AraMmAkA svabhAva hai aisA jabarana mAnanA hI hogA, lekina naiyAyika aura vaizeSika kI taraha sAMkhya bhI muktoMmeM jJAna mAnate hI nahIM. phira ve loga AtmAko jJAnasvarUpa kaise mAneMge?, vAcakavRnda ! yAda rakhiye ki isIse hI una matoMmeM AtmAkI sarvajJatAkA sadbhAva mAnanA muzkila hojAtA hai, jJAnakI tanmayatAhI maMjura For Personal & Private Use Only *

Page #8
nahIM hai to phira ve loga jJAna aura rokanevAle karmoko kahAM se maMjUra kareM ? (16) anyadarzanakAroMne sthUla aura laiMgika aise zarIra mAne haiM, taba jainadarzana meM pRthvIse manuSyatakako audArika, deva, nArakako pUrvabhava ke kiye huve kAryoMse lAkhoM guNA sukha duHkha bhugatane ke liye kAbila aisA vaikriya2 mahAyogake yogya AhArakara ye tIna zarIra ke bheda sthUlake dikhAye aura garbhase lagAkara yAvajjIvana khurAkakA pAka karake rasAdi karanevAlA taijasa aura Akhira meM karmakA vikAra yA samUharUpa kArmaNa zarIra aise pAMca tarahake zarIra dikhAye haiM (17) anyamajahabavAloMne karmoMko hI pauGgalika nahIM mAne haiM, to phira AyuSyako paugalika mAne hI kaise haiM aura AyuSyako paugalika hI nahIM mAne to phira upakrama AyuSyako lagate haiM aura AyuSyakA apavarttana hotA hai vaisA kaise mAna sake ?, aura aisA na mAneM to anapavarttanIya vibhAga to mAnehI kahA~ se 1, ve loka upakrama aura apavardhana na mAne aisA kabhIbhI nahIM banegA, kyoMki koI bhI manuSya kyA ani hathIyAraAdise nahIM Dare aisA banatA hai ? haramIja nahIM, to phira mAnanA hI paDegA ki yahI upakrama aura apavartanakI siddhi hai. 2 T * 41 For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #9
(18, tIsare adhyAyameM karmabhUmike bheda dikhAte jo 'anyatra' karake devakuru uttarakurukA varjana karake karma akarma bhUmikA bayAna darja kiyA, vaha asaMkhyadvIpasamudrAdi varNanako zailIkI taraha alaukika hai| (19) pAMcaveM adhyAyameM ajIvakAyase AraMbha kara jo dharmAsti. kAyAdikA prakaraNa liyA hai vaha itaradarzanakAroMne jo AkAzakA AdhikaraNake hisAbase varNana kiyA thA usakA hI pratibiMba hai, paraMtu vastue~ alaukika haiM. (20) utpAdavyayAdikA nirUpaNa itaradarzanoMmeM svamameMbhI nahIM thA, aura ho. saktAbhI nahIM. (21) "kAlazvetyeke" yaha pAMca adhyAyakA sUtrahI anyadarzana kAroMko syAdvAda dikhAne ke sAtha isa tatvArthasUtrakA vyApitva dikhalAtA hai| ... (22) idhara tatvavibhAgase ApravAdike prakaraNa haiM, aura isIsehI kitaneka choTe aura kitaneka baDe bhI hogae haiM, yaha darzanakAroMke sUtroMkI anukaraNIyatA hI dikhAtA hai| . (23) deva nirgrantha aura siddha ke liye sthiti aura kSetrAdikA vikalpa karake jo nirUpaNa karanekA dikhAyA cahabhI nakAroMkI anukRti hai| (25) mAkhUma, hotA hai ki anyamajahabavAloMne mahAdevakI aSTamUrtika hisAbase aSTAdhyAyIkA vibhAga . rakkhA, B For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #10
A idhara usItarahase dazatarahakA zramaNadharma hI mokSakA sAdhaka aura tattvabhUta ginakara dazaadhyAya pramANa rakkhA hai, aura isIse hI kalikAlasarvajJa bhagavAn zrI hemacandrasUrIzvarajIne pramANamImAMsAmeM mahAvratadharmake hisAbase pAMca adhyAya aura dazavidhayatidharmake liye deza Ahika rakkhe haiM. isatarahase anya sababa bhI itaradarzanazAstrakI anukRtimeM de sakeM, lekina saMkSepa karake sajjanoMko, khuda hI socanekA izArA karake basa karate haiM. . . .. (25) ' samanaskAmanaskAH ' yaha saMsArI aura muktike vibhAga karane ke bAda aura basa sthAvara bheda ke peztara kahA hai| isakI matalaba yaha hogA ki itaradarzanakAra sabhI jIvako manase yukta mAnate haiM aura vaha mana bhI nitya mAnate hai, isase idhara dikhAyA ki sabhIko mana hai bhI nahIM, aura manakA viyoga karake hI mukta AtmA manarahita hote haiN| yaha sUtra sAmAnyavibhAgakA honese hI Age 'saMsAriganasaMsthAvarA' aisA aura 'saMjJinaH samanaskAH ' aisA patra kahA. anyathA isa samanaskA0 sUtrakI jarUrata nahIM thI. 'sIjhanaH samanaskAI' itanA hI basa thA aura saMsAriNakhasaMsthAvarAH' isa sthAnameM 'AdyAstrasasthAvarAH' itanA hI basa thaa| . . . .. . .. L . . .. For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #11
19 (26) 'matizrutAvadhimana paryAmakevalAni jJAnaM' aisA kaha kara jo 'tat pramANe' aisA sUtra kahA vaha bhI inakAra indriyArthasaMnikarSa Adiko pramANa mAnate haiM vA zrAmANya bhI jisa parase mAnate haiM yaha yogya nahIM hai aisA dikhAneke lie hai / (7) ' kRtsnakarmago mokSaH' yaha sUtra bhI amamaya yA jJAnAdivicchedamaya jo mokSa mAnate haiM unako satyapadArthasamajhAneke liye hai / yaha saba bayAna itaradarzanakAroMkI apekSAkA diyA hai, isakA matalaba yaha hai ki zvetAMbarAkIhI yaha mAnyatA hai ki jisa jamAne meM jIva jisatarahase bodha pAve aura bhAvItarAga ke mArga meM sthira hove vaisA prayatna karanA cAhiye, isase bhI yaha zAstra ghetAnAhI hai aisA samajhA jAya / Akhira meM saba zvetAMbara va digaMbaramAyAko satyamArgapara sthira rahanekI aura vItarAgapraNIta mArga akhatyAra karane kI saMbhAvanA karate haiM, aura lekhako samApta karate haiM / vIra saM. 2463ApakA 5 For Personal & Private Use Only AnandasAgara

Page #12
// zrI gaNadharAya namaH // tatvArthasUtra ke dearer kartA vetAMbara haiM * yA digaMbara ? zrImAn umAsvAtijIvAcakamahArAja granthakartA tavArthasUtra eka aisA apUrva grantha banA haiM utkRSTatA * ki isako dekhanevAlA ise apanAyeM binA * kadApi nahIM raha saktA / ataH isakA koI na koI khAsa kAraNa avazya honA caahiye| isaviSaya meM aura vidvAnaha ke cAhe kucha bhI vicAra ho kintu mere khyAlase to isakA yahI khAsa kAraNa mAlUma hotA hai ki yaha graMtha baDA hI saMgrAhaka hai. pAne dUsare graMtha eka eka viSayako pratipAdana kara zAstrake eka eka mahanaviSayakI sugamatA karake zAstrasamudra meM praveza karAte haiM aura itanA hone para bhI ekaviSayakA talasparzI jJAna utpanna nahIM kara sakte, kintu tavArthasUtra hI eka aisA graMtha hai ki jo sabhIviSayoMkA jJAna utpanna karake tamAma grAma avamAina yo zravaNakI yogyatA karA detA haiM, tamAmaviSayoMkA talasparzIjJAna karAnevAlA yAne sada hone For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #13
( 2 ) bahuta hI saMkSiptarUpa hokara saMgrAhaka hai| isIliye kalikAlasarvajJa zrImAn, hemacandrAcAryajIne apane zrIsiddhahaimazabdAnuzAsanameM 'utkRSTe'nUpena 2.2-39' isa kArakasUtrakI vyAkhyAmeM bataura udAharaNake dikhAyA hai ki 'upomAsvAti saMgrahI tAra' yAne zAstroMke tattvoMko saMgraha karake kahanevAle zrImAn umAsvAtijI mahArAjahI saMgrahakAraAcAryoMmeM ziromaNi haiN| yahI bAta zrImAn mevijayI upAdhyAyajI bhI apanI hemakaumudImeM pharmAte haiM / zrImAn vinayavijayajI upAdhyAya apanA prakriyAvyAkaraNameM aura zrImAn malayagirIjI mahArAja bhI apane zabdAnuzAsanameM isa viSaya para inhIM mahArAjakA udAharaNa dete haiN| matalaba yaha hai ki zabdAnuzAsanake banAnevAle aura uddhRta karanevAloMne bhI inhIM umAsvAtijImahArAja kI muktakaNTha. se prazaMsA kI aura inhoMko hI saMgrahakAroM meM ague batalAye haiN| . zvetAMbarAcAryoMne jisa prakAra umAsvAtijImahArAjakI saMgrahakAratarIke prazaMsA kI hai vaisI digaMbaroMke zabdAnuzAsanameM nahIM pAI jAtI. isake mukhya kAraNa do pratIta hote haiN| eka. to yaha hai ki zvetAMbaroMke Agama-zAstra vistRta vidyamAna haiM. jinakI apekSAse isa tattvArthasUtrako baDA hI saMgrAhaka mAna sakke haiM, kintu digaMbaramajahabakI mAnyatAke mutAbika zrIjinezvarabhagavAna evaM gaNadharamahArAjakA koI bhI bacana yA zAstra vartamAnameM hai hI nahIM / digaMbarajainiyoMkA jo kucha bhI sAhitya hai vaha unake AcAryoMkA hI banAyA huA hai,jo ki umAsvAtijI For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #14
( 3 ) mahArAja ke pIche hue haiM / to phira ye loga kina zAstroMke AdhArase saMgraha yAne sUkSmatAse sabaviSayoMkA uddhAra honA mAna sake~ ? | isI kAraNa se digaMbariyoMne ise saMgrahita nahIM maanaa| jaba graMthako hI saMgrahita nahIM mAnA to phira ve usake kartAko saMgrahakAra kaise mAneM ? | aura jaba kartA ko saMgrahakAra hI nahIM mAne to unheM saMgrahakAroM meM agragaNya kaise kaheM ?, arthAt zvetAMbaraloga jisa prakAra isa sUtrako saMgrahita aura sUtrakartAko utkRSTasaMgrahakAra maMjUra kara unakI muktakaNThase prazaMsA karate haiM usa taraha se digaMbaroMne nahIM kI, aura kara sake bhI nahIM / dUsarA kAraNa yaha bhI mAlUma hotA hai ki digaMvariyoM meM jisa vakta zabdAnuzAsana banA hogA usa vakta isa tattvArtha sUtra ko una logoMne pUrItaura se nahIM apanAyA hogA / jo kucha bhI ho,. kintu harSakI bAta hai ki vartamAnasamayameM isa sUtra ko zvetAMbara aura digaMbara donoM sampradAyane acchItarahase apanAyA hai / * * isa sUtra ko banAnevAle AcAryamahArAjako graMthakartA aaira loga zrImAn 'umAsvAtijIvAcaka kA aura digaMbara loga 'umAsvAmI' kahate haiM / nAma- zvetAMbara logoM ke hisAba se ina AcAryamahArAja kI mAtAkA nAma 'umA' aura pitAkA nAma * 'svAtI' thA. isIliye ApakA nAma 'umAsvAti nirNaya jagatameM prasiddha huA / zvetAMbara saMpradAyameM inhIM AcAryamahArAja ke For Personal & Private Use Only *

Page #15
( 4 ) 'race hue dUsare zAstra bhI mAne gaye haiM / unhIM meM se tatvArtha bhASya meM khuda AcArya mahArAjane hI 'svAtitanayena' aisA kahakara apane pitAkA nAma svAti hai, aisA sApha jAhira kara diyA hai, aura usI sthAna para apanI 'mAtAkA nAma umA' thA, aisA bhI spaSTa akSaroM meM hI sUcita kiyA hai. saMbhava bhI hai ki umA nAma strI vAcaka hone se zrImAn kI 'mAtA kA nAma 'umA' ho / matalaba yaha ki ApakA nAma Apake mAtApitA ke nAmake saMyoga se hai / prAcIna jamAne meM yaha ki mAtA yA pitA ke nAmase yA nAma rakhA jAtA thA / yaha bAta to huI va hisAba se graMthakAra ke nAmakI bAbata, kintu digaMbara loga 'umA' aura 'svAmI' zabdase kauna artha lagAte haiM vaha unake tarphase abhI taka jAhira meM nahIM AyA hai / yadi koI vidvAna isaviSayakA khulAsA karegA to hameM harSa hogA / bAta aksara hotI bhI thI donoM ke nAmase laDake kA jaba taka isakA khulAsA na ho aura nAmapara hI vicAra kiyA jAya to umAnAmakI koI vyakti ho, evaM usake svAmI yAne nAtha hove, aura isase zrImAnako umAsvAmI kahA jAya, yaha to acchA nahIM mAlUma hotA, isake sivAya koSakAroMne umAzabda jaisA pArvatIkA vAcaka ginA hai vaisA hI kIrtikI vAcaka bhI mAnA hai| isase umA yAne kIrti aura svAmI yAne nAyaka, arthAt kIrtike nAyaka ina graMthakArako mAnakara For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #16
( 5 ) umAsvAmI nAma rakhA ho taba to ThIka mAlUma hotA haiM, kintu digaMbariyoM meM prAyaH rivAja hai ki sAdhu aura AcAryako ilakAbake taura para nAma ke Age 'svAmI' zabda lagAyA jAtA hai, to phira isase asalI nAma umA honA aura vaha to strIvAcaka hona se sarvathA asaMbhavita hI hai / isase spaSTa ho jAtA hai ki umAsvAtIkA Tuka nAma umA rakhakara usake sAtha svAmI zabda lagAyA gayA yA zuru se hI umAsvAmI nAma ho, kintu vicAra karane para ina donoMkI ayogyatA haiM aura prathama pakSa hI ThIka jacatA hai / . zvetAMvaroMke hisAba se zrImAnkA umAsvAti ** vAcaka kauna ? nAma zurusa hI thA, kintu jaba Apa dIkSita hokara pUrvasUtroM yAne "dRSTivAda" nAmakA jo bAravAM aMga hai, usakA tIsarA hissA pUrvanAmaka usake pAThaka hue taba Apa 'umAsvAtivAcaka' kahalAye / zvetAMvarazAstroM meM yaha to spaSTa hI ha ki 'vAcakAH pUrvavidaH' arthAt pUrvazAstroMko paDhane vicArane evaM bAMcanevAle vAcaka gine jAte the / isIliye hI to Apane tattvArthabhASyame khudakA nAma umAsvAti hI dikhAkara apane gurumahArAjako hI vAcaka tarIke dikhAye haiM / yadyapi digaMbara loga ina umAsvAtijImahArAjako uccakoTIke tatvajJAnI mAnate haiM, kintu ve pUrvazAstroM ke vettA the aisA kahane meM saMkoca karate haiM, aura zvetAmbaraloma 'idamucairnAgaravAcana' aisA bhASyakA pATha dekhakara zrImAnkA vAcakapanAkA svIkAra karate haiM / * For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #17
- ( 6 ) * isa sUtrakI prAcInatAke viSayameM kucha bhI (granthakA matabheda nahIM hai / donoM hI sampradAyavAle ise samaya prAcIna mAnate haiM / zvetAmbaraloga mahopAdhyAya* * zrIdharmasAgarajIko paTTAvalI Adise aura khudane bhI tattvArthabhASyameM apanI zAkhA uccanAgarI dikhAI hai. isase zrImAnako uccanAgarIzAkhAke mAnate haiM / yadyapi zvetAmbaraloga prajJApanAnAmaka caturtha upAMgake racayitA zrImAn zyAmAcAryaka guru aura dazarvadhara mAnate haiM; kintu kitaneka tAmbaralomauccanAgarI-zAkhA kA prAdurbhAva zrIvajrasvAmIjIke bAda hone se zrImAnko sampUrNadazapUrvadhara mAnanemeM hicakate haiN| - pAThakoM ! zrImAn umAsvAtijImahArAja sampUrNa daza pUrvako dhAraNa karanevAle hoM yA na ho kintu pUrvako dhAraNa karanevAle avazya the, aura zrIvIramahArAjase isamI sadIke peztarake the,kyoMki zrImAnajinadAsagaNijI aura haribhadrasUrijI vagairA , zrIvIramahArAjakI dasavIM zatAbdIke AcAryabhI tattvArthAdisUtroMkI jItakalpacUrNi, AvazyakabRhavRtti, AdimeM sAkSI dete haiM, aura zrImAnkA banAyA huA kSetrasamAsa jo prAkRtabhASAmeM hai usako TIkAse alaMkRta kiyA hai / pUrvakA abhyAsa dasamIzatAbdI taka hI thA, yaha bAta to siddha hI hai, yAne isa sUtrako race karIba 1500-1700 varSa hue haiM, aura isaviSayameM kisIke tarphase koI bhI zaMkA For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #18
nahIM hai| digambaraloga bhI ina AcAryako gRddhapicchake ziSya mAnakara prAcInatama maMjUra karate haiM / isa viSayameM mhesANA zreyaskaramaMDalakI orase zvetAmbaroMne chapavAye tattvArthasUtrakI prastAvanAse aura baMbai paramazrutaprabhAvakasaMsthA tarphase chapavAye hue tatvArthasUtrasabhASya bhASAntara: kI prastAvanAse vidvAnoM ko vizeSa jAnakArI ho sakatI hai| .. ___ isa granthakI utpattike viSayameM zvetAmbaroM kI yaha mAnyatA hai ki zAstrake vistArase X utpatti / tattvajJAnameM jinalogoM kI ruci kama ho, yA * *jinalogoMko vistRta zAla jAnane yA sunanekA samaya kama milatA ho, yA baDe zAstroMmeM praveza karaneke peztara sUkSmatAse paribhASA samajhanA ho vaise jijJAsuoM evaM bAlajIvoMke lAbhArtha zrImAnne yaha zAstra banAyA hai / udhara digambaroMkA kahanA hai ki kisI zrAvakako pratidina eka sUtra banAnekA niyama thA, ataH usane pahilA sUtra "darzanajJAnacAritrANi mokSamArga" aisA banAkara use bhIMta (dIvAla ) para likhaa| usake ghara gocarIke liye Aye hue umAsvAtijImahArAjane usa sUtrako dekhA / usako dekhakara zrImAnne usa zrAvakase kahA ki isa sUtrake AdimeM samyakzabda aura lagAnA cAhiye, yAne"samyam-darzanajJAnacAritrANi mokSamArgaH," isa prakAra yaha sUtra honA cAhiye / taba zrAvakane namratA pUrvaka nivedana kiyA . For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #19
( 8 ) ki he mahArAja ! Apa samartha haiM ataH yaha grantha ApahI banAiye ?, usa zrAvakakI isa vinatiko svIkAra kara umAsvAtijImahArAjane yaha zAstra banAyA hai / isa viSaya meM kitane ko yaha jijJAsA jarUra rahatI hai ki vaha zrAvaka kisa gAMva kA aura usakA nAma kyA thA ?, evaM usa zrAvakako pratidina eka sUtra banAnekA jo niyama thA usakA kyA huA ? kintu isakA spaSTa khulAsA nahIM milatA hai, jainazAsana meM prasiddha aise samyagdarzanAdi meM se samyagdarzanAdimeM se samyakpadako usa zrAvakaneM kyoM nikAla diyA ? aura jaba yahI sUtra sAre granthake AdikA hai to phira AdibhAga meM 'mokSamArgasya netAraM' yaha zloka kisane lagA diyA ? kitaneka logoMkA to kahanA hai ki mokSamArgakA zloka tatrArtha meM zurU se hI nahIM thA, aura isIse vArttikakArane isa zlokakA sparza bhI * nahIM kiyA hai, isa zloka kI vyAkhyA sarvArthasiddhimeM bhI nahIM hai, isase mAlUma hotA hai ki yaha zloka tatvArtha ke antargata hI nahIM hai / Adya zloka zvetAmbaraloga isa zloka kI vyAkhyA na to apanI TIkAoM meM karate haiM aura na isa zlokakA tatvArtha ke antargata hI mAnate haiM | zvetAmbarAMkA kahanA hai ki yadi yaha zloka taccArtha kA hotA to peztara usameM AbhidheyAdi nirdeza hotA, For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #20
kyoMki abhidheyAdinirdezake binA akelA maMgalAcaraNa karanekA rivAja na to zvetAmbaroMke zAstroMmeM hai / aura na diMgabaroMke zAstroMmeM hai| jaisA zAstrake AdimeM maMgalAcaraNa hotA hai vaisA hI abhidheyAdhikArinirdezabhI avazya hotA hI hai| aura maMgalAcaraNa ziSTAcArase zAstrasamAsike liye hotA hai, kintu yahAM to , " vande tadguNalabdhaye " aisA akhIra kA pada dekara namaskArakA phala zrIjinaguNake labdhirUpa. dikhA diyA hai| jisase yaha zloka tattvArthazAstra ke sambandha meM hI nahIM hai esA kahanake sAtha 2 yaha bhI kahate haiM ki isa zlokameM peztara to mokSamArgakA praNetRtva liyA hai bAdameM karmaparvatoMkA bhedanA , taduparAnta vizvatattva kA jJAna liyA hai. yAne yaha krama hI ulaTA hai| karmakSayake binA kevalajJAna kaisA ? aura kevalajJAnake binA, moca mArgakA praNayana kahAM ?, ataH yaha zloka kramase bhI minna hai| isake sivAya isameM vizeSyakA nirdezya na honese yaha zloka dUsare granthake, sambandhameM hai, evaM isa zlokako kisIve idhara tatvArthaAdimeM maMgalAcaraNa yA aura kisI irAdese sthApana kiyA hai| tatvake jAnakAra zvetAmbara aura digambara donoM hI sampradAyavAle isa zlokako zrImAn umAsvAtijImahArAjakA banAyA huA nahIM mAnate haiN| . . . . . . For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #21
. (10) * ~* yaha tatvArthasUtra donoMhI. sampradAya yAne 8. zAstra / zvetAmbara aura digambarameM parama mAnya hai, aura sampradAya / isa para donoMhI sampradAyaka vidvAnoMne vistRta * * evaM saMkucita vivecana bhI kiyA hai| yadyapi kitaneka pramANapanthAko yAne nyAyasambandhIgranthoMko dono paraspara maMjUra karate haiM, evaM TIkAse bhI alaMkRta karate haiM, aura pratyakSAdi pramANoM, jIvAdi viSayoM tathA syAdvAdamaryAdAmeM donoMko aikyatA hai / isIse to unako pratipAdana karanevAle yuktipradhAna granthoMko donoM hI paraspara mAnate haiM, aura isI kAraNase siddhivinizcayakA ullekha pramANazAstratarIke zrInizIthacUrNimeM pAyA jAtA hai| aSTasahasrI para nyAyAcAryazrImAnyazovijayajIupAdhyAyajIne TIkA banAI hai| aise nyAyapradhAnagranthoM meM vyAkaraNagranthoM kI taraha vivAda na honese paraspara mAnyatA rahanI koI AzcaryakI bAta nahIM hai / isI prakAra : tattvArthake viSayameM bhI bahuta bhAga aisA hai ki donoM sampradAyapAloMko eka sarIkhA mAnya hai| kintu dUsare granthoMke kartA sambandhI aisA koI vivAda nahIM hai jaisA isa granthake kartAka viSayameM. hai / aSTasahasrI aura syAdvAdamaMjarI vagairA granthoMko donoM sampradAyavAle apane 2 upayogoM dete haiM, aura unake kartA sambandhI koI vivAda nahIM karate haiM / vinamvarakI kRtiko dimamvarakRti tarIke aura zvetAmbara - For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #22
(11) kI kRtiko zvetAmbarakataka tarIke donoM hI maMjUra karate haiM, kintu isa tatvArthaka viSayameM aisA nahIM hai / zvetAmbara loga isa zAstrako zvetAmbara mantavya pratipAdana karanevAlA aura digambaraloga isako apanA mantavya pratipAdana karanevAlA mAnate haiN| zvetAmbaraloga isake kartAko zrIumAsvAtijIvAcakake nAmase apanI sampradAyake AcArya mAnate haiM, to digambaraloga inako apanI sampradAyameM umAsvAmIAcAryake nAmase svIkAra karate haiM, aisI sthitimeM donoM sampradAya vAle jisa rIti se isa sUtrase apanA 2 mantavya siddha karanekI ceSTA karate haiM usI tarahase anyake majahabase yaha bAta virodhI hai aura isase yaha zAstra inhoM kA nahIM hai aisA siddha karanekA prayatna bhI karate haiN| * isa granthaviSayaka carcA honekA khAsa sampradAya kAraNa yaha hai ki isa zAstrakI racanA zvetAmbara bheTa / aura digambara donoM sampradAyakI bhinnatA honeke * * peztara huI hai| yadi donoM sampradAyaka vibhaktaM hone ke bAda isa granthakI racanA hotI to yaha carcA hotI hI nhiiN| donoM sampradAyakI vibhaktatAke samaya ke viSayameM to donoMhI sampradAyavAloMkI sarIkhI mAnyatA hai| zvetAmbaraloga digambarakoM utpanahonekA samaya zrIvIra saM0609 batAte haiM, taba digaMvaraloma zvetAmbarasampradAyakI utpatti vikrama sa0 136 meM batAte For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #23
(12) hai| arthAt digambaroM ke hisAbase bhI zvetAmbaroM ke hI mutAbika zrIvIrasaMvat aura vikramasaMvatkA pharka 470 honese cIrasaMvat 136+4776.06 hotA hai, to aise viSayameM jo tInavarSakA pharaka hotA hai vo koI pharaka nahIM ginA jAya, ataH donoM sampradAyake bhinnatAkA samaya donoM kI mantavyatAse sarIkhA hI hai| aba ina donoM sampradAyoMmeMse zvetAmbara kahate haiM ki hama asalase haiM, aura digambarasampradAya hamameM se nikalI hai, aura isakI puSTimeM boTikakA bayAna jo Avazyaka, vizeSAvazyaka, uttarAdhyayana AdimeM darja hai vaha dikhalAte haiN| udhara 'digambarIloga kahate haiM ki zvetAmbarasampradAya hamase nikalI hai, aura isake sabUtameM darzanasAragranthakA sabUta dete haiM, kauna kisase nikalA hai ? isa viSayameM yadi baTastha dRSTile vicAra kiyA jAya to digambaraloga hI vAmbaroMse nikale haiN| isakA vizeSa vivecana to isa viSayake svataMtralekhameM honA hI ThIka hai, kintu jo. digambara. loga zvetAmbarameMse nahIM nikale hote to ve digambara banda jo bastrakAhI praznottararUpa hai usase Apako kahalAtehI nhiiN| pAThakoM! yadi dAndezIse vicAra kiyA jAya to spaSTa mAlUma hojAyagA ki donoMke nAmaka akhIrameM ambarabAda lagA huA hai, joki vastrakA vAcaka hai / isase eka kahane haiM ki hama sakedakasavAle haiM aura dUsare kahate haiM ki For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #24
(13) hama dizArUpa vastravAle haiM, arthAt donoMne ambarazabdako to apane nAmameM rakhAhI hai| asalameM aisA mAlUma hotA hai ki jaba digambarasampradAya zvetAmbarase alaga huA taba itara logoneM unase pUchA ki tumhAre pAsa anya jainasAdhuoM jaise kapaDe kahA~. hai? to digambaroMko kahabhA paDA ki hamAre dizArUpahI vastra hai| isa prakAra kahanese hI isa sampradAyako loga jaina nahIM kahake digambara kahane lage, yAne digaMbarapanA logoMne hI lgaayaa| kabhI mAna liyA jAya ki digambarasampradAyase zvetAmbarasampradAya nikalI, to yaha bAta ucita nahIM jctii| kyoMki digambarameMse zvetAmbara nikale hote to unakA nAma sAmbara yAne vastravAle aisA hI honA cAhiye thA, kAraNa ki vastra vinAke digambaroM se yadi nikale hote to viziSTatAvAlA vanasahitapanekA sAmbara nAmahI rakhA hotaa| jisa prakAra zvetAmbaroM meM tyAgIvargameMse nikale hue yativargako parigrahavAle kahate haiM, usI prakAra idhara bhI sAMbara hI nAma hotA, na ki zvetAmbara / ataH nirNaya kiyA jAyagA ki zvetAmbaroMmeMse hI digambara nikale haiM, paraMtu zvetAmbara loga digambaroM meM se nahIM nikale haiM / @@@@ digaMbaroMke tarphase kahA jAtA hai ki madiH sUtra carcA yaha satra zvetAMbaroMkA hotA to isakA pratipAdana Disord zvetAMvarazailI se hotA, kintu isameM aisA pratipAdana hI nahIM hai.. betAMbaroMne.. jIvAdi mAtra 0220000000000000 000000000000 For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #25
( 14 ) tava mAne haiM aura isasUtrameM jIvAdi sAta tatvoMkA hI pratipAdana hai arthAt zvetAMbara loga puNya aura pApa tatra sAtha hI rakhakara jIvAdi navako tatra mAnate haiM, kintu isasUtrameM to jIvAdi sAta tatvahIkA nirUpaNa karake puNya aura pApa ko tatrakI koTi meM liyA hI nahIM hai. isI prakAra prAyazcittake viSaya meM bhI jaba zvetAMbaroM ke zAstra AlocanAse lekara pArAMcitataka ke dasa prAyazcitta dikhAte haiM. taba isI sUtra meM AlocanAse lekara anavasthApya takake nau prAyazcitta hI dikhAye haiM, ataH aisI sthitimeM yaha zAstra kisI bhI tarahase zvetAMbarIya kadApi nahIM ho saktA ! idhara isaviSayameM zvetAMbaroMkA kahanA hai ki zrIumAsvAtivAcakajIne " zubhaH puNyasya" aura "azubhaH pApasya " ina donoM sUtroMse puNya aura pApatacako dikhAkara puNya aura pApako tatva hI mAnA hai, itanA hI nahIM, kintu " samyaktva hAsyaratipuMvedazubhAyurnAmagotrANi puNyaM" aura "zeSa "pApa" aisA kahakara puNya aura pApake phala bhI svataMtra dikhAye haiM. to phira zrImAnne puNya aura pApako tatvahI nahIM mAnA, aisA kaise kahA jAya ? alabattA itanA jarUra hai ki zrImAnane jaisI jIvAdikI svataMtra tarIke tattvameM gintI kI, vaisI puSpa aura pApatatvakI nahIM kI, kintu isameM vivakSA hI mukhya hai, kyoMki zvetAMvarazAstra ThANAMga, panavaNA, anuyogadvAra AdimeM sAmAnya ? For Personal & Private Use Only * *

Page #26
( 15 ) se jIva aura ajIva ina donoMkohI tatva yA dravya tarIke dikhAye hai, to kyA sthAnAMga AdimeM hI anyatra kahe hue AzravAdiko vahAM tatva nahIM mAnA haiM ? avazya mAnA hai. isI taraha idhara bhI puNya aura pApa kI vivakSA pRthak tasma tarIke nahIM kI hai, kintu zrImAnne puNya aura pApako tattva avazya mAne haiM. ataH yaha zAstra sAta tava kAhI pratipAdana karatA hai isase zvetAMbaroMkA nahIM hai, aisA kahanA akalamaMdI kA kAma nahIM hai, paraspara vibhakta sAta hI taya hai. puNya aura pApa AzravakI bhItara hai, AzravAdi jIvAjIvake mizrita hai, svataMtra puNyAdikA taraha bhedarUpa nahIM hai. isI taraha AlocanAdi prAyazcitta bhI nau hI dikhAye yAne zvetAMbaroMne mAnA huA parAMcita nAmaka prAyazcitta isameM nahIM dikhAyA. isase yaha graMtha zvetAMbaroMkA nahIM hai aisA kahanA bhI bholApana hI hai, kyoMki chedanAmaka prAyazcittama cheda aura mUlakI ekahI prAyazcita tarIke vivakSA hosakatI hai. ataH cheda aura mUlakI vivakSA na kI. kAraNa yaha hai ki sAghapanake paryAya meM kucha aMza kATA jAya usako cheda aura saba paryAya kATA jAya usako mUlaprAyazcita kahate haiM, arthAt donoM prAyazcittoM meM cheda honese chedatarIke mAnane meM koI harajA nahIM hai. isI taraha anavasthApyaprAyazcittameM amuka samaya taka mahAvratakA Aroma nahIM karanA yaha tatva hai, aura parihArakA bhI yahI tatva hai. upasthApavAdakA artha sthiti karanA hotA hai. aise hI pArAM cikakA artha bhI prAyazcittakA dIrghakAla se pAra karake For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #27
( 16 ) upasthita honekA hai. yAne jisazAstra meM dasaprakArakA prAra zcita kahA hai usameM aura isameM pharka nahIM hotA hai, kitane AcArya upasthApanAmeM hI anavasthApya aura pArAcika ni haiM, vo una donoMmeM bhI upasthApanAkI kriyA dubArA karane paDatI hai. isa hisAba se bhI isameM kyA harja hai ? / tatrakI au prAyazcitta kI vivakSA alaga rItise karanemeM graMthabheda naha ginA jAtAH pAcikaprAyazcitta caturdazapUrvI kohI hotA hai kintu zrImAn umAsvAtija ke samaya meM codaha pUrva vidyamA nahIM the. ata: isa hisAba se bhI pArAMcika nahIM ginA ho taba bhI kyA tAjjuba ! / isItarahase kitaneka digaMbaroMkA aisA kahanA hai i tane lokAntika nau mAne haiM, kintu isa tattvArthameM je zvetAMbarsekA sUtra pATha haiM usameM sirpha AThahI meM ginAyeM hai. ata pAyA jAtA hai ki isasUtrako zvetAMbaroMne bigADa diyA hai kintu aisA kahanevAloM ko socanA cAhiye ki jaba zvetAMbaroM ke sthAnAMga, bhagavatIjI, jJAtadharmakathA AdimeM lokAntika devake naubheda spaSTatayA mAne gaye haiM to phira zvetAMbara loga idhara naubhedake sthAna meM ATha bheda kyoM kare ? / asala bAta to yaha hai ki umAsvAtijIne brahmalokake madhya meM rahanevAle, riSThavi mAnakI vivakSA nahIM karake sirpha kRSNarAjI meM aura brahmalokake sabhAmake zivAya yAneM aMta meM rahanevAloM ko hI idhara lokage 1 For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #28
meM rahanevAle esA. spaSTa zabdArya lekara AThahI meda lokAvikasandase liye haiM. yAne lokake antameM rahanevAle lokAntika bAjAya isa vyutpattise nirdeza hai, yAne AThakA rahanA brahmAdevalokake Akhira meM hai, isase unakoMhI lokAntika lise hai. zika apattiarthakI apekSAse kahA huA padArtha tattvakA ghAtaka nahIM ho sakatA / zvetAMbaroMne apane majahabake anukUla pAr3a karane kA nahIM rakhA, parantu jaisA pATha thA vaisI hI mAnyatA rasI aura vyAkhyA kI hai|) sI. isa taraha digaMbaroMke zvetAMbaroM para isa sUtrake zvetAMbarapane bilavameM jora kaTAkSa the, ve isa lekhadvArA dikhAye haiM, aura unakA mAdhAna bhI zvetAMbara jisa tarahase karate haiM vaisA kiyA gayA hai| * kitaneka digambara loga yaha bhI kaha dete haiM ki nava sUtroM satanaya mAnane para pAMca naya kyoM mAnA ? ko! Avazyaka, vizeSaAvazyaka vagairaha dekhate sA hai ki nayake bheda do bhI haiM, aura tIna bhI hai cAra ra pAMca bhI hai cha bhI haiM aura sAta mI haiM, yAne narake mevAnavA yaha bhI zvetAMbaroMke zAstrase pratikUla nahIM hai| jisa prakAra digaMbaroMne zvetAMbaroM ke prati tatvArtha rAga nahIM hai, aisA batalAne ke liye zaMkAeM kii| TodkI, varkase bhI digaMbaroM ke prati bahara nahIM hai, yaha dikhAne ke liye ko For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #29
(18) zaMkAeM kI jAtI haiM. ataH unameMse kitanIka yahAM para dara karane meM AtI haiM. ye zaMkAeM kevala mAnyatAke viSayameMhI haiM, kin pAThabhedake viSayameM to jo vicAra karanA hai vaha ina zaMkAoM koM jatAne bAda Age para kreNge| / (1) yadi isasUtrake kartA zvetAMvara nahIM hote to avadhi aura manaHparyavajJAnake bhedameM vizuddhiAdime donoM jJAnakA je phake batalAyA hai usameM avvala to liMga yAne vedase pharka batAnA cAhiye thA. kyoMki zvetAMbaroMke hisAbase jaisA apramattasAdhuko manAparyavaH jJAna hotA hai vaisA hI apramattasAdhvIko bhI manaHparyAya jJAna hotAhI hai, ataH zvetAMbaroMke hisAbase donoMhI vedavAle avadhi aura manaHparyavakI yogyatAvAle haiM. isase unake hisAbase vedakA.pharka dikhAnekI koi AvazyakatA nahIM hai, kintu digaMbaroMke hisAbase sAdhuoMko apramattatA hotI hai aura unako mana:paryavajJAna bhI hotA hai, lekina strIvedavAle jIvako sAdhupanA hI nahIM hotA hai, to phira manaHparyavajJAna to hove hI kahAM se? jaba manaHparyavajJAna. puruSavedavAlekohI hove aura strIcevAle. ko nahIM hove to isa sUtrameM puruSavedasvAmitvakA pharka, jarUra dikhAnA cAhiye thA. kyoMki avadhijJAna to striyoMko bhI hotA hai aisI donoM hI saMpradAyoMkI mAnyatA hai / . dUsarI bAta zvetAMbarI yaha bhI kahate haiM ki yadi digaMbaroMke hisAbase bAyasaMsargarahitako hI kevalajJAna hone aura mana: Vain Education International For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #30
(19) paryavajJAna bhI nigraMthatvapratipattimeM hI hove yAne bAhyasaMsargarahitapanemeM hI hove, to phira yaha avadhijJAnakA pharka kevala aura mana:paryava donoMke hI sAtha rahA, kintu svAmIpanase kevala manaHparyavake sAtha nahIM. aura yaha bAta sUtrakArane dikhAI hI nahIM hai / zvetAMbaroMke hisAbasetorajoharaNAdi bAghaliMga yA tyAgarUpa bAdhaliMga vAlAhI jIva manAparyavakA mAlika hotA hai, kintu avadhi yA kevalajJAnakA to cAhe vaha tyAga liMgakAlA ho yA binA liMga kA ho. donohI mAlika hosakate haiM. ataH idhara avadhi manaHparyAvake pharka meM svAmIzabda liyA hai, lekina Age kevalameM nahiM yAne avadhise manaHparyAyakA pharka dikhAyA lekina kevala kA na dikhAyA aura isase yaha sUtra zvetAMbarasaMpradAyakAhI hai, lekina digambarasaMpradAyakA nahIM hai| (2) cAranikAyake devoMke bheda dikhAte samaya graMthakAramahArAjane spaSTarUpase vaimAnikake bhedoMmeM kalpopannatakake 12 bheda hI ginAyeM haiM, yAne "dazASTapaMcadvAdazavikalpAH kalpopapatraparyantAH" kahakara vaimAnikake 12 hI devaloka dikhAye haiM, kintu digambaraloga kalpopapanna 16 bheda mAnate haiM. pAThakoM ! yadi graMthakAra mahArAja digambaramajahabake hote to " dazASTapaMcavoDazavikalpAH kalpopapatraparyantAH" isa prakAra sUtrakI racanA karate / kintu 16 bheda devalokake nahIM dikhAte sirpha 12 hI bheda dikhAye haiM, ataH nizcaya hotA hai ki yaha sUtra zvetAmbaraAcAryakA hI banAyA huA hai| " AN For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #31
/ 20) (3.) zrImAnne vaimAnikadevoMkI lezyA, pravIcAra aura sthiti ke liye jo jo sUtra banAyeM haiM ve digambarasaMpradAyaka mAne hue 16 devalokake hisAbase pratikUla haiM, kiMtu ke saba zvetAmbarake mAne hue| 12 devalokake hisAbase hI anukUla haiM. dekhiye ! digambaraloga. 1 saudharma 2 IzAna 3 sanatkumAra 4 mAhendra 5 brahma 6. brahmottara 7 lAMtaba 8 kApiSTa 9 zukra 10 mahAzukra.11 zatAra 12.sahasrAra 13 Anata 14 prANata15 AraNa aura 16. acyula. isa prakAra.16 devaloka mAnate haiM. arthAt brahmottara, kApiSTa, zukra aura zatAra ina cArako jyAdA mAnate hai.ana idhara zvetAMbaroke hisAbase lAMtakadevalokake devase Ageke saba devalokavAle devoMkI zuklalezyA hotI hai. pahile aura dUsare devalokake devatAoMkI pIta yAne tejasalezyA,tIsare cauthe aura pAMcaveM ye tIna devalokavAle devoMkI padmalezyA aura zeSa lAMtakAdidekoMko zuklalezyA hI hotI hai. aura isI mutAvika sUtrakArane bhI"pItapatrazuklalezyA dvitrizeSeSu" isa sUtrase khulaMkhullA batalA bhI diyA hai. aba udhara digambaraloga zuklalezyA kApiSTase mAnate haiM kintu kApiSTase peztara to pAMca devaloka nahIM haiM, kiMtu sAta hai isakA kyA hogA?,taba yahAM para inakI bolatI baMda hojAtI hai. kitaneka devalokameM jabarana lezyAkA mizrapana mAna lete haiM. isase sApha 2 siddha hogayA ki lezyAMke hisAbase bhI zvetAMbaroMke hI anukUla graMthakAramahArAjane sirpha 12 hI devaloka mAne haiM. For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #32
( 21 ) isI taraha pravicArake viSayameM bhI zvetAMbaroMke hisAbase dUsare devaloka taka to maithunakriyA kAyAse hai / bAdameM do devaloka taka sparzase, phira Age do yAne 5.6 meM zabdase 7-8 meM rUpase aura Age 9-10-11 12 ina cAradevaloMkoM meM sirpha manasa hI pravicAra hai. arthAt do do devalokameM kramasara eka eka bAta lImaI hai / aba isa sthAna para digambaroMko16 devalokake hisAbase moTAlA karanA paDatA hai.kyoMki devaloka zeSa rahe haiM14 aura viSaya rahe haiM 4 sparza, rUpa, zabda aura mana. isaliye do dokA krama bhI nahIM mAna sakate hai kAraNaki 14 meM cAra vibhAga karanA jarA muzkila hai yadi digaMbaroM kI mAnyatA mujaba aniyamita krama hotA to sUtrakArako alaga 2 sUtra karane paDate ki amuka amukapravicAra aura amuka amuka. kintu aisA nahIM karateM samAna vibhAgahonese hI sUtrakAramahArAjane alaga 2 sUtra nahIM karake sirpha ekahI sUtra kiyA aura do do devalokoMmeM eka eka bAta dikhAdI ___ yahAM para pAThakoMko itanI zaMkA jarUra hogI ki zvetAMbaseM ke kahane mutAbika 10 devalokameM,4 viSayakI sattA mAnanI hai aura dodoMmeM ekaeka viSayabhI mAnanA hai to yaha kaise hosattA hai ? yaha zaMkA bhI. bebuniyAda hai, kyoMki sUtrakAra zrIumAsvAti mahArAjane. hI Anata aura prANatakA AraNa aura abdutakA svAsa dikhAkara donoMkA nirdeza ekahI sAtha kiyA For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #33
( 22 ) hai. ataH cAroMhI devalokakI do devaloka tarIke ginatI karane meM koI Apatti nahIM ho saktI kyoMki.sparzAdi3 viSayake 6devaloka aura manake viSayameM 4 devaloka mAnakara 4 viSayameM 10 devaloka mAnanA graMthakArakehI hisAbase hogA. ". isI taraha sthiItake viSayameM bhI mAhendradevalokase Age 7 sAgasepamakI sthiti peztara no sAdhika dikhalAI, bAda tIna, sAta, nau, satarA, tega aura paMdraha sAgaropama eka eka devalokameM baDhAkara antameM AraNAcyutakI 22 sAgaropamakI sthiti lAnekA zrImAnumAsvAtivAcakajIne hI kahA hai. aba zvetAMbaroMke hisAbase 5-6-7.8 ke cAra aura 9-10-1112. ke do, yoM karake 6. bhAga barAbara hojAveMge, kyoMki khuda zAstrakAranehI Ageke sUtroM AraNAcyutAvaM' aisA kahakara AraNa aura atyutako ekahI ginanekA pharmAyA hai. dusarI bAta yaha hai ki jaisA AraNAcyutakA nirdeza devalokake krama sUtra meM ekavibhaktise hai vaisAhI ANata aura prANatakA nirdeza bhI eka hI vibhaktise hai, isase ina cAroM dodoko eka eka devaloka. sarIkhe gina sakte haiM. ataH zvetAMbaroMkI 12 devalokakI mAnyatA mutAbika vo yaha ThIka baiThatA hai, kintu digaMbaroMko 16 devaloka mAnanese hAtha paira lagAnA paDate haiM. isase kabUla karanA hI paDegA ki yaha tatvArthasUtra zvetAMbaroM kI mAnyatAvAle AcAryanehI banAyA hai. For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #34
(23) isa sUtrakA sArA hI cauthA adhyAya zvetAMbaroMkI mAnyatA mujabakA hai, aura digaMbaroM kI mAnyatAse khilApha hai. tabahI to digaMbarAcArya zrImAn amRtacaMdajIne isI tatvArthastrapasse "tattvArthasAra" nAmaka jo graMtha banAyA hai. usameM aura aura adhyAyoMpara to acchItarahase khulAsA aura vistRta bayAna diyA hai, lekina unako isa adhyAyake liye to bahuta hI saMkSepa karanA pdd'aa| .. (4) pAMcaveM adhyAyameM dravya kahaneke samaya zrImAnne "dravyANi ca jIvAzca' kahakara dharmAstikAyAdi cAra ajIva aura pAMcavAM jIva ina pAMcoMko dravya kahA hai. digaMbaroMke hisAbase kAlabhI eka niyamita dravya hai, kintu zvetAMbaroMke hisAbase kAla aniyamita dravya hai, aura yahI bAta zrImAnaumAsvAtivAcakajInebhI idhara pAMcako niyamita dravya hai aisA dikhAkara kAlako aniyamitadravya dikhAneke liye Age para "kAlazcatyeke" aisA kahA, yAne kitaneka AcArya kAlako bhI dravya mAnate haiM, aisA kahakara kAlakA aniyamitapanA spaSTa dikhAyA hai. yadi yaha graMtha digaMbaraAnAyakA hotA to idhara kAlakA spaSTarUpase niyamitadravyapanA dikhAte. digaMbaroMne "kAlazca" aisA sUtra rakhA hai, kintu yaha sApha 2 samajhameM AsakatA hai ki yadi graMthakAra kAlako niyamita dravya ginate to phira "kAlazca" aisA alaga sUtra alaga sthAnoM thIM For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #35
( 34 ) dharate ? yadi zrImAn ke hisAba se kAla yaha niyamitadravya hotA to pezvarasa hI dravya ke sAtha milA deke 'dravyANi jIvakAlau ca' aisA yA 'dravyANi jIvAH kAlazva' aisA sUtra karate aura alaga alaga sUtra karane kI jarUratahI nahIM thI. ataH mAnanAhI hogA ki isazAstra banAnevAla AcArya zvetAMbara hI the / ( 5 ) digaMbaraloga kAlake bhI aNu mAnate haiM aura usakA pramANa lokAkAzake yAne dharmAdharmAstikAya ke pradeza jitanA asaMkhyAta mAnate haiM. yadi zrImAn umAsvAtijI digaMbara saMpradAyake hote to jaisA dharmAstikAya, adharmAstikAya, jIva aura pudgala ke pradeza ginAneke liye "asaMkhyeyAH pradezA dharmAdharmayo." ityAdi sUtra banAye, vaisAhI kAlake aNuoMkI saMkhyA bhI batAne ke lie sUtra banavAte, yA 'dharmAdharma kAlAnAM ' aisA kaha dete kintu kisI bhI sthAnameM kAlake aNukI sattA yA saMkhyA nahIM dikhAI. isase bhI spaSTa jAhira hotA hai ki isa graMtha ke kartA zrI umAsvAtijI digaMbara AmnAyake nahIM, kintu tAMbaraAnAyake hI hai / * + ** (6) digaMbaroMke hisAba se bhI sAmAyika aura pauSadhamaiM sAdhakA tyAga to jarUra hI mAnanA par3egA. aura unake hisAba vastrAdikamI sAvadha haiM, to phira sAmAyika, pauSadhavAlako saistAropakramaNa yAne pramArjana pratyuprekSaNa kriyA kiyA binA saMthArA para baiThanA yaha aticAra hai so kaise hogA ? For Personal & Private Use Only *

Page #36
( 25 ) kAraNa ki peztara to pramArjana karaneke sAdhanako hI upakaraNa hI nahIM mAneMge to upakaraNa kahAMse hogA? ki jisase sAmAyika, pauSadhavAlA pramArjana kregaa| yadi kahA jAya ki zrAvakako sAvadhakA yA parigrahakA sarvathA tyAga, nahIM hai. jisase sAmAyika pauSadhavAlA pramArjanakA sAdhana rakha sakatA hai, kintu yaha kahanA bhI ucita nahIM mAnA jAtA. kyoMki zrAvakako sAmAyika, pauSadhameM anumodanakI pratijJA nahIM hai, paraMtu sAvaMdya evaM parigrahakI karaNakAraNaviSayameM kuchabhI chuTTI nahIM hai, to phira aisIsthiti sAmAyika, pauSadha karanevAle zrAvaka upakaraNahIca nagna hI hone caahiye| yadi sAmAyika, pauSadhameM aisA. nagapanA mAnA jAya to sAmAyikapauSadhakI yogyatA to digaMbaraloga puruSa aura strI donoMhIkoM. maMjUra. karatahI haiM, to kyA striyAM bhI nagna hokara sAmAyika kara sakatI haiM. yadi kahA jAya ki jisako sAmAyika, pauSadha karanA ho vaha cAhe puruSa ho yA khI, nagna honA hI cAhiye, to phira mAnanA hI paDegA ki jaba striyAM binA vanake ThaharaM sakatI haiM to unhIMko sAdhapanA Ane meM kyA harja hai ? aura jaba sAdhapane meM koI harja nahIM hai to phira unako kevalajJAna aura mokSa bhI hone meM kyA harja hai ? asala bAta to yaha hai ki graMthakAramahArAjane vetAMbarahI honese saMstArakako parigraha.na: mAnA aura isIliye majakake vividha trividha tyAgI zrAvaka zrAvikAko sAmAjika For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #37
pauSadhameM saMstAraka rakhanekA aura pramArjana ke liye upakaraNa rakhane kA nirdeza kiyA hai. ... kitaneka digaMbara loga yaha kahate haiM ki hama morapIchI rakhate haiM isase pramArjana kareMge, kintu yaha vyarthahI hai, kyoM ki peztara to gRhasthaloga sAmAyikameM pIchI rakhate hI nahIM, yadi mAna liyA jAya ki digaMbarasAdhukI taraha digaMbaragRhasthaloga bhI pachI rakheMge to yaha bhI pramArjanake liye upayogI nahIM hogA, kyoMki zarIra aura pairake corasa nApase jyAdA nApakI koI cIja hove tabahI pramArjanameM jIvadayA hosake, yAne rajoharaNAdiupakaraNa jisa prakAra zvetAMbaraloga rakhate haiM vaisA rakhanekA hI zAstrakArako sammata hai. ataH yaha zAstra zvetAMbaraAnAyakA hI hai / .5(7) pAThakoM ! digaMbaroke hisAbase jo koI sAdhu bImAra ho to usakI vaiyAvacca dUsarA sAdhu nahIM kara sakatA hai, kAraNa ki na to unake sAdhuke pAsa pAtra rahatA hai ki jisase vo glAnasAdhuko AhAra pAnI yA auSadha lAde, aura na vastra kaMbala Adi hI hote haiM ki jisase vo glAnasAdhuko saMthArA hI kara de, athavA jADekA bukhAra ho to usa bImArako oDhaneko de sake. AkhirakAra una logoMne yahAM taka mAnA hai ki gRhasthoMmeM hI poSyapoSakavyavahAra ho sake, sAdhumeM to nirgathapanA honese poSya-poSakavyavahAra hotA hI nahIM. aisI hAlatameM bImArakI hiphAjata karanekA kahAM se mAne 1. arthAt ina logoMke For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #38
( 27 ) hisAba se sAdhuko ziSya to banA dete haiM, lekina vaha jaba bImAra hotA hai to vaha gRhasthoMko sauMpa diyA jAtA hai, aura gRhasthaloma usa bImArasAdhukI hiphAjata karake use Arogya karate haiM. aisI sthitimeM digaMbaroM ke hisAba se vaiyAvacca karanA kaise bane ? asala meM vinaya aura bhakti to paraspara sAdhuoMmeM mAnanemeM haraja nahIM hai, lekina upakaraNa mAnanekI pharaja A paDe isase paraspara poSyapoSakabhAvake nAmase vaha uDA diyA, yadyapi saMyata meM poSyapoSakabhAvabhI haraja karane vAlAhI nahIM hai. aura veyAvacca to granthakAra mahArAjane tIrthakaranAmakarmake AzravameM aura abhyantaratapameM jatAyA hI hai / idhara to umAsvAtivAcakajIne tIrthakara nAmakarmakA kAraNa ginAte vaiyAvaccako tIrthakarane kA kAraNa dikhAyA hai aura tIrthakaranAmakarmakA bAMdhanA sAdhu evaM zrAvaka donoMhAko sarIkhA rakhA hai, yAne sAdhukoM tIrthakara nAmakarmabaMdhI manAI nahIM kI, to aisI sthiti meM yAne sAdhuko mAyA acche sAdhukI vaiyAvacca aura baradAsta karanese tIrthakaranAma bAMdhane kA kahane vAle graMtha-lekhaka zvetAMbara saMpradAya ke hI ho sakte haiN| vaisehI muhapatti na honese dvAdazAvarttavandana nahIM hogA aura vaha nahIM hone se Avazyaka pratikramaNa nahIM hogA / (8) digaMbaroMke hisAba se koI bhI cIja sAdhuko rakhanA manA hai to phira adattAdAnakA viramaNa kyoM hai, arthAt AdAna- grahaNamAtrase viramaNa honA cAhiye / For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #39
( 28 ) ( 9 ) digaMbaroM ke hisAba se vastrAdikakA lenA aura dhAraNa paribhoga yaha sabahI parigraha hai, arthAt grahaNa hI parigraha hai, to phira unake hisAba se to " graha" se hI viramaNa mAnanA cAhiye, yAne "pari" upasarga lagAnekI kyA jarUrata thI ? * 10 ) digaMbarokoM sivAya zarIrake dUsarA kucha mAnanAhI 'nahIM hai to phira ye loga sAdhuke eSaNA aura AdAnanikSepasamiti kaise mAnegeM ? kyoMki pAtrAdi nahIM rakhane se unake sAdhuoMkoM eka hI gRhesa AhAra kara lenA paDatA hai. jaba eka gRhameM hI bhojana kara lenekA haiM to phira ekagRhAnna choDanA aura mAdhukarI vRtti karanA yaha kaise rahA? jaba mAdhukarIvRtti hI nahIM rahegI to phira eSaNAsamiti kahAM rahegI ?. jisa taraha pautrAdika na honese eSaNAsamiti nahIM banasaktI usI taraha AdAnanikSepasamiti bhI nahIM bana saktI hai / kyoMki koI bhI vastu uThAnA yA dharanA usako pratyupekSaNa aura pramArjana 'karake uThAnA yA dharanA usakA nAma AdAnanikSepasamiti ' hai.. aba idhara socanA cAhiye ki jaba pramArjana karaneke liye 'na to rajoharaNAdi haiM aura na uThAne dharanekI koI vastu hI hai, to phira AdAnanikSepa samiti unalogoM ke majahaba se kaise banasaktI hai ? | yathAyogya upakaraNa nahIM hone para yadi rAtrimeM pezAba yA TaTTI jAnekA maukA AjAya to yatanA kisa tarahase kI jA sake ? kyoMki laMbA aura baDA rajoharaNa nahIM hone se aMdhere For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #40
(29) meM calate 2 pramArjana kare kisase ? arthAt upakaraNa nahIM mAnanese IryAsamiti bhI amuka TAima meM nahIM bana saktI / isI taraha dinameM bhI yadi kITikAdikA samUha nikale, usa samaya bhI virAdhanAse vacanA unako muzkila hojAtA hai. . bhASAsamitimeM bhI mukhavastrikA nahIM rakhanese bolate samaya saMpAtimAdikakI hiMsA nahIM ruka saktI. pAtrAdika na honesa vArizakI mausamameM bhI jalavRSTi hotI rahane para bhI pezAba, TavIke liye bAhara jAnAhI paDegA. aura yadi. sAthameM kaMbalI nahIM hogI to apakAyake jIvoMkI bhI yatanA nahIM ho skegii| matalaba yaha hai ki upakaraNa nahIM mAnanevAlaki liye iryAsamitiAdimeM se eka bhI samiti azakya hai, aura zAstrakAra to pAMco hI samitiko sAdhupanakI mAtA tarIke ginAte haiN| ... (11) digaMbaroM ke hisAbase jainamajahaba mathunake zivAya syAdvAdarUpa hone para aura bhAvaprAdhAnyavAlA hone para bhI nagnapanA nirapavAda hai yAne kisI bhI avasthAmeM sAdhu vastra nahIM rakha saktA yA vastrakA saMsargavAlA uccatarabhAvavAlA hone para bhI mokSa nahIM pA saktA ( bADe yA mhelakA saMsargakI yA vastra sivAya aurakA saMsargakI haraja nahIM hai ) kintu zvetAMbaroMke hisAbase zakti aura atizayasaMpannake liye sApha nanapanA jarUrI hai, lekina zeSa azakta aura anatizAyIke liye saMyamarakSAdikA

Page #41
sAdhana hI upakaraNa haiM ! jaise kSudhApariSahako jItanA aura AhArakI apekSA nahIM rakhanA, vaisehI pipAsApariSahako jItanA aura pAnIkI apekSA nahIM rakhanA. yadI zakti cale taba Ava: zyaka hI hai, lekina jaba anAhArapane aura nirjala ThaharanA nahIM hosake taba zuddha AhAra, pAnIko lenepara bhI kSudhA aura pipAsApariSaha sahana kiyA aisA kahA jAtA hai. usI taraha vastrAdika upakaraNake viSayameM bhI saMyamAdike liye zuddhaalpamUlyAdivatrA. dika upakaraNa rakhanA nAgnyapariSahajayakA bAdhaka nahIM hai, isI kAraNase to nAgnyakoM pariSahameM ginAyA. yadi nirapavAda hotA to isakI ginatI bhI mukhyatratoMmeM hotii| (12) pAThakoM ! digaMbaroMkI mAnyatA bhujaba zIta aura uSNa pariSahaba daMzamazaka nahIM jIta sake yAne zItasa urake dhUpameM Ave yA dhUpase Darake chAyAmeM jAve yA daMzamazakake bhayase kose bahAra nIkale to kevala itanI sI hI bAtapara sAdhapanA calA jAnA mAnanA pddegaa| kyoMki zuddhavastrAdika to unako maMjUra nahIM hai, phira agnyAdikA AraMbha yA saraka jAnA kyA maMjUra kara sakeMge?, khyAla rakhanA ke agnikA paribhoga sAdhuko mahAbatakA bAdhaka hai aura agnyAdikake AraMbhase sAdhapanAkA samUla nAza hojAtA hai| .. (13 digaMbaroMkI mAnyatAnusAra zayyAparISaha aura niSadyAparISaha kaise bana sakte haiM ?, yadi zayyAdike nirmamatvase For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #42
usaparISahakA sadbhAva mAnate haiM, saba to makAna ke sadbhAva meM jaise nirmamatvabhAva sAdhu rakha sakte haiM vaisehI tucchavastrAdimeM acchItarahase nirmamatvabhAva kyoM nahIM rahegA? aura zayyAparIpaha aura caryAparIpaha to vedanIya aura mohanIyameM gina gaye hai, anyathA mohameM gint| .. ... (14) digaMbaroMkI mAnyatAnusAra munimahArAjako kucha bhI nahIM rakhanA cAhiye aisA hai to phira vedarbhAditaNa bhI kaise rakha sakeMge?, aura jaba tRNakA rakhanA hI nahIM hai to phira usakA upayoga hI kahAMse ho sake ? ki jisase tRNasparzanAmakA parISaha digambaroMkI mAnyatAse hove / khyAla rakhanA jarUrI hai ki satuSabhI brIhi na pake aisA kahakara upakaraNakA niSedha kiyA to phira idhara tRNakA Dhera kaise bAdhaka nahIM hogA? tupa aru tRNakA sparzameM gADha AgADhakA pharaka mAneM tapato saMsargamAtra bAdhaka nahIM hai, kiMtu gADhasaMsargavizeSahI bAdhaka hai esA mAnanA hogA, yAne mUrchAhI nahIM ke saMsargamAtra bAdhaka mAnanA hogA asala meM to jainamajahabase dRSTAntamAtra sAdhaka hI nahIM hai| (15) jaba sAdhuoMko vastrAdika rakhanekA hI nahIM hai to phira vastrAdikase satkAra hone para bhI abhimAna nahIM Ane aisA satkAra-parIvaha sahana karanekI unako guMjAiza hI nahIM hai. For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #43
( 32 ) : pAThakoM ! asala matalaba yaha hai ki zItoSNa se lagAkara satkAratakake parISaha zvetAMbaroM kI mAnyatAnusAra hI yogya ho sakegeM / ( 16 ) Upara jitane bhI paoNinTa batalAye gaye haiM una saba se baDA poinTa " ekAdaza jine" isa sUtra meM hai / kyoMki isa sUtrameM sApha dikhAyA gayA hai ki zrIjinezvaramahArAja yAne kevalI mahArAjako gyAraha parISaha hote haiM, arthAt kSudhA aura pipAsApariSaha kevalImahArAjako bhI hotA hai, lekina digaM ke hisAba se kevalImahArAja AhAra pAnI lete hI nahIM haiM, to phira kSudhA aura pipAsAkA parISaha unako kaise hogA ?, yadi mAna liyA ki upacArasehI kSudhA aura pipAsA - kA parISaha kahA hai to svarUpanirUpaNake sthAna meM upacArako kauna kahegA ? aura kevalI mahArAjameM kSudhApipAsAparISahakA upacAra karanekI jarUrata bhI kyoM ? tumhAre matase hI ekaora to AhArAdikako doSarUpa ginakara kevalajJAnake bAda AhArAdikakA abhAva dikhAnA hai, aura dUsarIora upacAra se AhArAdikasaMbhavase hI honevAle kSudhAparISahAdika dikhAyA jAtA hai, yaha kyA pArasparika virodha nahIM hai? jarA ise sociye!, kevalimahArAjameM upacArase koI guNakA Aropa karake stutibhI kare, lekina digaMbaroM ke hisAba se AhArAdi jaisA mahA doSakA upacAra karanese to hAMsalameM kevalI mahArAjakI niMdA hI hogI, yAne AhArAdikako doSa mAnake kevalI mahArAja ke ye . For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #44
( 33 ) digambaraloga niMdakahI banate haiM, kitaneka aisA bhI kahate haiM ki idhara eka + a + daza: aisA samAsa karake ekase adhika aise dasa nahIM, isa prakAra artha karanA. yAne eka dasa zabda se gyAraha lenA aura bIcakA jo akAra vaha niSedha vAcaka honese aisA artha hogA ki kevaliyoM meM gyAraha parISaha nahIM hai, pAThakoM ! sAmAnyabuddhivAlA AdamI bhI yahAMpara kaha sakatA hai ki yaha artha zAstrakAra kI AtmAkA khUna karake kiyA gayA hai. kyoMki aisA kUTa artha na to zAstrakAra kahate haiM, aura na zAstrakArakI aisI zailI bhI hai. tattvArtha sUtra meM zrIgaNeza se itizrItaka kisI bhI sthAna para kisI bhI sUtrameM aisA TeDA artha nahIM kiyA gayA hai. to phira yahAM para aisA TeDA artha kyoM ? cothe adhyAya meM ekAdazazabda hai usakA kyA aisA artha karate haiM 1, kabhI nahIM, asala bAta to yaha hai ki zAstrakAraneM koI TeDA artha nahIM kiyA hai, kintu isa tatvArtha sUtra ke kartA hI zvetAMbarI AcArya haiM aura ve kevalImahArAjako AhAra mAnanevAle haiM. isaliye kevalImahArAjako kSudhA aura pipAsA parISada honA ginakara zvetAMbarAcArya zrI umAsvAtIvAcakamahArAjane sUtra meM myAraha hI parISada kahe haiM. digambara kI. utpattike peztara yaha sUtra zrIumAsvAtIvAcakaz2Ine guNaThAyeMmeM parISahakA avatAra ke prasaMgase kyoM na kiyA ho & * aba idhara digaMbaroMne peztara to upakaraNoMko upakaraNa $ For Personal & Private Use Only y

Page #45
. tarIke mAnanekI manAI kI. taba eka ora to strIko cAritra nahIM hotA hai, aisA mAnanA paDA, aura sAthameM bandha, nirjarA aura mokSakA saMbaMdha jo pariNAmake sAtha thA usake sthAnameM mokSAdikakA saMbaMdha bAhyaliMgake sAthahI karanA par3A, aura isIkAraNase anyaliMga aura gRhiliMgase siddha honekA uDA kara siddhake pandraha bheda bhI uDAnA paDA. tadanaMtara tIrthakarakevalI gocarIke liye nahIM jAte haiM. aura pAtrAdikake abhAvase dUsare bhI AhAra, pAnI lAkara nahIM de sakte haiM. ataH kevalI mahArAja AhAra nahIM karate haiM aisA mAnanA paDA, aura isIliye isa sUtrakA aisA TeDA artha karanekI digambaroMko jarUrata par3I hai| - vyAkaraNake hisAbaseM 'ekenAdhikA na daza ekAdaza' aisA karanA hI ayogya hai. madhyapadakA lopa karake karmadhAraya tatpuruSa karanA hogA. nakA samAsa dazake sAtha karake adazazabdako joDanA hogA aura aisA karanese to arthaka hisAbase AcArya mahArAjako 'naikAdaza' aisA karanA hI lAjima hai, kintu aisA ayogyasamAsa aura itanA TeDA artha karane para bhI digaMbarIbhAiyoMkI arthasiddhi nahIM ho saktI hai. kyoMki parisaha 22 haiM, unamese 11kA niSedha karane para bhI zeSa11to rahate hI haiM, yAne kevalImahArAjAoMko11nahIM ho to bhI zeSa11to hoyeMge hii| kabhI aisA kahA jAya ki zvetAMbaraloga kevalI. mahArAjako 11. parisaha mAnate haiM usa pakSako khaMDana karaneke For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #46
liye yaha sUtra kahA hai to yaha kahanA bhI lAjima nahIM ho saktA, kyoMki tumhAre hI kathanase tumako maMjUra karanA par3egA ki tattvArthasUtrakI racanAke avvalase hI zvetAMbaroMkA majahaba thA, aura usako tattvArthakartAne khaMDita kiyA, kintu aisA mAnane parabhI "naikAdaza" aisA sUtra banAnA lAjima thA. anya logoM ke hisAbase bhI11 nahIM mAnane para bhI idhara prakaraNa TUTa jAtA hai, kyoMki11 nahIM hai to kitane haiM yaha to dikhAyA hI nahIM hai. eka ho, do ho, yAvat nava ho, yA dasa ho, taba bhI gyAraha nahIM haiM aisA hI kahA jAyagA. yadi daza mAne jAya to kSudhA choDanI yA pipAsA choDanI usakA niyama nahIM rahegA. dUsarI bAta yaha hai ki idhara kisameM kitane pariSaha hai yaha dikhAnekA prakaraNa calA AtA hai, kyoMki bAdarasaMparAyAdimeM sabhI pariSaha honekA hisAba dikhAyA hai to phira idhara gyAraha parivaha nahIM haiM aisA niSedha kahAMse AyagA ? Age kameM bhI pariSahakA avatAra karate zAstrakArane 'vedanIye zeSAH' aisA kahakara kSudhApariSaha aura pipAsApariSahakA avatAra vedanIyakama meM dikhAyA hai, aura Apake hisAbase. mI. jinarAjako vedanIyakarma naSTa nahIM huA hai, to phira vedanIyameM ginA huA kSudhA aura pipAsAkA pariSaha kyoM na ho ? aura jA kSudhA aura pipAsAkA pariSaha kevalImahArAjako honA maMjUra karoge to phira binA AhAra aura jalapAnake ke pariSaha For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #47
( 36 ) kahAMse hoMge ? yadi manamAne pariSaha mAnanA haiM to phira kevalI mahArAja meM bAvIsa hI pariSaha mAna lene meM kyA harja thI ? taTasthamanuSyakoM to yaha spaSTa mAlUma ho jAyagA ki AcAryamAhArAjane jinezvarako gyAraha hI pariSaha mAne haiM ataH zAstrakAra zrImAn umAsvAtivAcakajI mahArAja zvetAMbara pakSake hI AcArya the, na ki digaMbarapakSa / r (17) jisa taraha 'ekAdaza jine' yaha sUtra ina granthakAramahArAja ke zvetAMbara paneko sAbita karatA hai usI taraha mahAvratoMkI bhAvanA meM bhI 'AlokitapAnabhojanaH' arthAt anna pAnIko dekhakara lenA, yaha bhI zvetAMbaroMkI hI mAnyatAnusAra ho saktA hai, kyoMki pAtra ke binA lAnA aura dekhanA kaise ho sake? aura binA pAtrake dekhane meM to jamIna para anna pAnI girapaDatA hai ki jisase ahiMsAkI pAlanA bhI nahIM ho saktI / (18) zAstrakAra mahArAja yadi digaMbara hote to tapasyA ke adhikArameM digaMbaroMke hisAba se bhI 'viviktazayyAsana' nahIM kahate, kyoMki una digaMbaroMke hisAba se zayyA aura Asana rakhanekA kahA~ haiM ki jisake liye viviktasthAna meM ye do karanekA nAma tapa kaheM / V(19) phira bhI bAhya aura abhyaMtara upadhikA yAne upakaraNAdika aura kaSAyakA tyAga karanA abhyantaratapasyA kahI idhara yadi upakaraNAdika rakhanekA hI nahIM hai to phira For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #48
( 37 ) usakA abhyantaratapameM tyAga kyoM kahA? aura yadi upadhi yAne upakaraNa mahAvratakA ghAtakAraka hai to phira tapa kyA ? kyA parigrahaviramaNAdiko tapa mAna sakte haiM ? . (20) yaha zAstrakAra yadi zvetAMbarI nahIM hote to 'pulAkabakuzakuzIlanigranthasnAtakA nirgranthAH' aisA sUtra nahIM karate, kyoMki bakuzameM upakaraNabakuza vahI kahAjAtA hai ki jo upakaraNakA mamatva yAne dhonA raMganA kare aura AkAMkSA va lobha upakaraNameM rakkhe. jaba isako to nigrantha mAna liyA to phira digaMbara hove vahI sAdhu hove yaha bAta kahAM rahegI / .. 21) phira bhI ye sUtrakAra mahArAja sAdhuke vicArameM liMgakA vikalpa kahate haiM. aba digaMbaroM ke hisAbase to puruSa hI sAdhu hotA hai, to vedarUpaliMgake hisAbase bhI vikalpa nahIM rahatA hai. dravyaliMga bhI digaMbaroM ke hisAbase bhAvaliMgakI taraha niyata hai to phira veSarUpaliMgakI apekSAse bhI vikalpa kahAM rahegA? yAne isa granthake hisAbase vedarUpa yA veSarUpaliMgameM ekahI prakAra nahIM mAnA hai, kintu vikalpa mAnA hai, to isase spaSTa hojAtA hai ki ye granthakAra zvetAMbarI hI haiM. khyAla rakhanA ke siddhamahArAjakI taraha idhara pUrvabhAvaprajJApanA nahIM hai, kintu vartamAnabhAvakI hI prarUpaNA hai, (22) akhIrameM siddhamahArAjake viSayameM bhI zAstrakAra liMgakA vikalpa dikhAte haiM to vahAM bhI dravyaliMgakA anekA For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #49
( 38 ) ntikapaNA mAnane se graMthakArakA digaMbarapanA uDajAtA hai, aura zAstrakAra zvetAMbarI hI hai aisA sAbIta hotA hai. Upara dikhAye hue kAraNoMse isa tattvArtha sUtra ke kartA zvetAMbarAmnAyake hI haiM aisA mAnanA hogA. isa viSaya meM kisI bhI vidvAnko kucha bhI zaMkA samAdhAna karanA hove to zAntise pakSapAta choDake khuzI se kare, kyoMki donoM pakSoMkI dalIla sunane se hI satya kA nizcaya karanA sugama hotA hai. * isa tatrArthasUtrako donoM sampradAyavAle maMjUra karate haiM, lekina donoM sampradAya meM sUtrameM kitanAka bheda hai, sAre tatvArtha meM zvetAMbaroMke * hisAbasehI anukramase dazoM hI adhyAya meM 3553-18-54-44-26-34-25-50 aura 7 sUtra haiM, yAne saMpUrNa tatvArtha meM 346 sUtra haiM. taba digaMbarAmnAyake tattvArthameM krama se daza adhyAyameM 33-53-39-42-42-27-39 26-47 aura 9 sUtra haiM, yAne saba sUtra 357 haiM, arthAt digaMbaroMke hisAba se sarvasAdhAraNa meM gyAraha sUtra jyAde haiM. kauna adhyAya meM zvetAMbaroMke. AmnAyase jyAde sUtra haiM aura kauna adhyAyameM digambarAmnAyase jyAde sUtra haiM. kauna kauna sUtra kisa kisa adhyAyameM kauna kauna majahaba meM jyAdA haiM vaha nimnalikhita koSThakase mAlUma hogA. sUtrakA vizeSa. For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #50
( 39 ) .3 12 or mom 0 no 0 adhya. sU. . zve, 1 21 dvividho'vadhiH .1 35 Adyazabdau dvitribhedI . '2 19 upayogaH sparzAdiSu .. 2 52 ... zeSAlivedAH hemArjunatapanIyavaiDUryarajatahemamayA: 3 13 . maNivicitrapArthA upari mUle ca tulya vistArAH padmamahApadmatigiJchakesarimahApuNDarI kapuNDarIkA hradAsteSAmupari prathamo ye janasahasrAyAMmastadardhaviSkabho hadaH dazayojanAvagAhaH 3 17 . tanmadhye yojanaM puSkara 3 / 18 . tadviguNadviguNA hatAH puSkagaNi ca tannivAsinyo devyaH zrIhrodhRtikIrtibuddhilakSmyaH palyopamasthitayaH sAmA mAnikapariSatkAH 3 20 . gaMgAsi dhurohidrohitAMzAhariddharikA ntAsItAsItodAnArInarakAntAmuvarNarUpyakUlAraktAratoMvAdA:saritastanmadhyagA: 0 0 no no nom 0 0 For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #51
(40) 0 s 0 s 3 25 0 . s adhyA. sU. 3 210 dvayordvayoH pUrvAH pUrvagAH 3 22 zeSa stvaparagAH caturdazanadIsahasrArivRtAH gaMgAsiMvA dayo nadyaH . bharataH SaDviMzatipaMcayojanazata vistAra: SaT caikonaviMzatibhAgA yojanasya tadviguNadviguNavistArA varSadharavarSI vi. dehAntAH 260 uttarA dakSiNatulyA: .. 3 : 27 27 . bharatairAvatayovRddhihAsau SaTsamayAbhyA mutsarpiNyavasArpaNIbhyAm 3 28 tAbhyAmaparA bhUmayo'sthitAH 3, 29 . ekadvitripalyopamasthitayo haimavatakahA rivarSakadaivakuruvakAH tathottarAH videheSu saMkhyeyakAlA: bharatasya viSkambho jambUdvIpasya nava. ...tizatabhAga: 4. 7 pItAntazyA: 4 23 ucchvAsAhAravedanopapAtazca sAdhyA: . sh sh 0 0 0 0 For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #52
0 0 0 0 0 adhyA . sU. zva 4 30 sthitiH 4 31 bhavaneSu dakSiNArdhAdhipatInAM palyo- pamamadhyardha 4 32 zeSANAM pAdone 4 33 asurendrayoH sAgaropamamadhikaM ca 4 34 saudharmAdiSu yathAkrama 4 36 adhike ca 4 37 sapta sanatkumAre 4 41 sAgaropame 4 42 adhike ca 4 50 grahANAmeka 4 51 nakSatrANAmadhaM 4 52 tArakANAM caturbhAgaH : 4 54 caturbhAgaH zeSANAM 4 280 sthitirasurANAM 4 42 . . lokAntikAnAmaSTau sAgaropamANi saH . SAm 5 3 . . jIvAzca jIvasya ca . . .. . 5 29 ...... sad dravyalakSaNaM. .. 0 0 0 0 0 s For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #53
(42) 6.00 6 adhyA. sU. zve. 5 42 anAdirAdimAMzca 5 43 rUpiSvAdimAn 5 44 yogopayogI jIveSu 6 4 zubhaH puNyasya svabhAvamArdavaM ca samyaktvaM ca vAGmanoguptIryAdAnanikSepaNAsamityAlo. . kitapAnabhojanAni paMca krodhalobhabhIrutvahAsya pratyAkhyAnAnyanu. ___vIcIbhASaNaM ca paMca zUnyAgAranisevitAvAsaparopadhAkAra bhaikSyazuddhisadharmAvisaMvAdAH paMca strINAM kathAzravaNatanmanoharAMganirIkSa gapUrvaratAnusmANabadhyeSarasasvaza rIrasaMskAratyAgA: manojJAmanAjJandriyaviSayarAgadveSavarjanA ni paMca 9 28 prAmuhUrtAt 9. 38 upazAntakSINakaSAyayozca 9 40 pUrvavidaH 2 6 0 6 For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #54
( 43 ) adhyA. sU . zve. 10 3 kRtsnakarmakSayo mokSaH 10 4 anyatra kevalasamyaktvajJAnadarzanasiddhatvebhyaH 0 AviddhakulAlacakravavyapagatalepAlAbu vaderaNDabIjavadAnizisvApavaJceti 10 8 0. dharmAstikAyAbhAvAt 017 * * pAThako ! Upara dI huI sUcise Apako () Adhika mAlUma ho gayA hogA ki zvetAMbaroM aura digasUtroMkI bhI barAma kauna 2 sUtra kisa 2 adhyAyameM kisa * kisa jagaha jyAdaha yA kama haiN| aba yahAM para jarA socanekI jarUrata hai ki dara asalameM sUtrakArake banAye hue sUtra kisa sampradAyaneM to uDAye aura kisa sampradAyane apanI orase naye sUtra banAkara ghuseDa diye ? ____yadyapi yaha bAta saMpUrNatayA to jJAnI puruSa aura sUtrakAra mahArAja hI jAna sakte haiM, tobhI merI mAnyatAnusAra isa viSaya para tulanA karanekI jarUrata mAlUma hotI hai / evaM dUsare vidvAnoMko bhI isa viSayapara. apanI orase samIkSA karanekI jarUrata hai ki jisase dUsare taTasthalogoMko bhI apane abhiprAya sthira karanemeM sugamatA ho| For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #55
( 88 ) (1) pahile adhyAya meM zrutajJAnake bheda kathana kiye bAda zvetAMbara loga 21 veM sUtrameM "dvividho'vadhiH " isa sUtra - ko lete haiM, kintu digaMbaraloga isako nahIM mAnate haiM, aura 'makprasvayo" kahake sUtrako zurU karate haiM. aba isa sthAna para socanA cAhiye ki jaba zurUmeM avadhikA bheda hI nahIM dikhAyA to phira "bhavapratyaya" aisA vizeSabhedakA nirUpaNa kahAMse AsaktA hai ? uddezarUpa sAmAnyabhedako kahane ke bAdI matiAdijJAnarUpa pratyeka bheda kahe haiM, aura matijJAnameM bhI indriyAdibheda kahakarahI avagrahAdi bheda kahe haiM, evaM avagrahAdi bhedoMke anantarahI bahubahuvidhAdi bheda dikhAye haiM. aura zrutajJAna meM bhI do bheda sAmAnya se dikhAne ke bAdahI unake vizeSabheda usI sUtra meM bhI dikhAye haiM. isase spaSTa mAlUma hotA hai ki AcAryajIkI zailI to "dvividho'vadhi:" isI prakAra sUtrakI racanA karanekI hai. tisapara bhI digaMbarI loga mAnate nahIM hai yaha unakI marjI kI bAta hai, para sUtrako lopa karanA bhava - bhIrukA kArya nahIM hai. + (2) isI taraha zvetAMbara loga nayake sAmAnya pAMca bheda mAnakara Aca aura antya ke nayake bhedoM ko dikhAnevAlA "Adyazabdau dvivimedau" aisA 35 vAM sUtra mAnate haiM. tariyoMkA mantavya hai ki yadi ekahI sUtrase nayakI vyAkhyA karanI hotI to " pramANanayairadhigamaH " isa sUtra ke For Personal & Private Use Only .

Page #56
(45) sAthahI nayakI vyAkhyAkA sUtra kara dete| ataH siddha hotA hai ki ye donoM sUtra asalase hI haiM / / (3) dasare adhyAyameM bhAvandriyake bhedoMmeM upayogeMdriyanAmaka bhedakoM to donoMhI saMpradAyavAle mAnate haiM. aura jIvakA lakSaNa bhI upayoga hI hai yaha 'upayogo lakSaNaM' isa sUtrase donoM maMjUra karate haiM, aura vaha upayoga to sabahI kevalImahArAjAoMko bhI hotA hai, ataH idhara upayogakA svarUpa dikhAneka liye sparzAdikaviSayakAhI upayoga idhara lenA cAhiye, aura yaha dikhAneko sUtrakIbhI jarUrata hI hai| .. [4] dUsare adhyAyameM digaMbara loga "zeSAstrivedAH" aisA sUtra mAnate haiM, kintu zvetAMvariyoMkA kahanA aisA hai ki "gatikaSAyaliMga." ityAdi sUtra joki audAyakake ikkaisa bhedako dikhAnevAlA hai, usameM tIna veda kahe haiM. aura idhara nAraka aura saMmUrchajako napuMsakavedahI hotA he aura devatAmeM napuMsakaveda nahIM hotA. jaba aise do sUtra kaha diye gaye to apane Apa hI nirNaya hogayA ki manuSya aura tithaMca jo garbhaja hai ve vedavAle honese tInoMhI vedayAle haiM. isa tarahase arthApattise spaSTa bAta thI, usako dikhAne ke liye sUtrakI koI jarUrata nahIM hai / aura aisA nahIM mAneMge to audArikAdika autapAtika nahIM hotA hai masukako amuka yonI aura amuka janma nahIM hai, amuka sAparvatanIya AyuSyavAle haiM, esA bhI sUtrakArako dikhAnA hogaa| For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #57
[5] tIsare adhyAyameM digaMbara loga 12 ve sUtrase hemArjunatyAdi karake ikkaisa sUtra "dvirdhAtakI khaNDe" isasUtrake bIcameM naye mAnate haiM. sUtrakI zailIko dekhanevAle aura arthako socane vAle to idhara spaSTahI samajha sakte haiM ki ye saba sUtra digaMbarIne naye hI dAkhila kara diye haiM dara asala meM to yaha tatvArthasUtra saMgrahagraMtha hai, isaliye isameM vistArase kathana karanAhI anucita hai. aura yadi kucha bhI vistAra karanA hotA to jIvA dhanuHpRSTha bAhA prapAtakuMDa paridhi gaNitapeda ityAdikakA kathana karate / kintu varNanagraMthakI taraha varNana karanA aise graMthameM kadApi nahIM ho sktaa| himavadAdiparvatakA varNa kahAjAya aura usameM na to usakA AyAma mAna kahA aura na zikharakA mAna aura na zikharoM kI uccatAdi dikhAve, aura na zikharakI saMkhyAbhI dikhalAI, 12 veM sUtrameM hemA netyAdi kahakara AgaMke sUtra meM "upari mUle ca tulyavistArAH" aisA kaha denA kyA ucita hai? kyA saba varSadhara mAnameM sarIkhe haiM? kadApi nahIM. to phira kucha bhI khulAsA kiye binAhI aisA sUtra kaise kiyA?14veM sUtra meM"teSAmupari" aisA kahA gayA,kintu uparake bhAgameM yaha hada kahAM para hai? pUrva pazcima madhyameM hai yaha to jatalAnA thA, 18 veM sUtrameM "tadviguNadviguNA hRdAH puSkarANi ca" kahA to isa sUtrase doneM doneM hada aura puSkara haiM aisA kyoM nahIM hogA? yAvat AyAmAdikIhI dviguNatA lenI, aisA kahAMse hogA? yAvat avagAhameM dogunA kyoM na hogA.19 For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #58
(47) veM sUtrameM deviyAM sAmAnika va pariSadvAlI haiM aisA dikhalAyA gayA hai, to phira sAmAnika aura pAriSadyakI saMkhyA. kahAMse lenI ? itanAhI nahIM, bAlka isase to niyama ho jAyagA ki deviyoMko abhiyoga anIka AtmarakSaka AdikA abhAvahI hai. 20veM sUtra meM gaMgAAdi nadiyoMko himavadAdike madhya meM rahanevAlI yA jAnevAlI dikhAI haiM, kintu ve varSadharameM pUrvakI ora jAtI haiM yA pazcimakI ora ? uttarakI ora bahatI haiM yA dakSiNakI ora ? varSadhara 6 haiM aura nadiyAM 14 to vyavasthA kaise hogI? aura usa vyavasthAkA sUcaka ekaakSara bhI sUtrameM nahIM diyA gayA hai, yaha bAta bhI vicAraNIya hai| ikkaisaveM aura bAvIsaveM sUtra meM pUrva aura pazcima jAnA kahAgayA yaha kahAMtaka ThIka hai ? kyoMki gaMgA, siMdhu ityAdi nadiyAM bharata eravata dakSiNa uttarameM AyagI isakA kyA? aura varSadharapara bhI haraeka nadI alaga 2. dizAoMmeM kitanI 2 dUra aura kisa 2 dizAmeM pIche bahatI hai isakA to idhara kucha varNana . bhI nahIM hai / tevIsaveMsUtra meM gaMgA, siMdhukA parivAra to dikhAyA, kintu aura nadiyoMkA parivAra kitanA hai ? videhake vibhAga kisase hote haiM ? usakA pramANa kyA hai ? ityAdi bAtoMkA idhara nAma nizAnahI nahIM hai| 24 aura 25 veM sUtroM meM bharatAdikakA iSukA vistAra to dikhAyA kinna AyAma jIvA dhanuHpRSThakI bAta to dikhAIhI nahIM // 24 aura 28. sUtroMmeM 6 Arake svarUpako dikhAte AyugIra For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #59
(48) AdikA jikara nahIM karake bhUmirasAdikI vRddhi, hAni aura avasthitatA kahI gaI hai, yaha kahAM taka zobhA degI.1; isakA. vicAra to akalamaMdahI karasakte haiM / 29, 30 aura 31 veM sUtroMmeM sthiti dikhAI gaI hai. vahAM para aMtaradvIya aura bharataairavatakI sthitikA jikra taka bhI nahIM kiyA gayA hai, aura mahAvidehameM saMkhyeyakAla kahA gayA yahamI kitanA anucita hai?, kyoMki zIrSaprahelikA bhI saMkhyeyameM hai, aura mahAvidehameM pUrvakoTise jyAdA AyuSyahI nahIM hai| sUtra31 meM bharatakA viSkabha to dikhalAyA hai, ki tu na to vaitAvyakA nApa.dikhalAyA, aura na usakI zikharasaMkhyA Adi dikhAye. aura na bharatake liye dakSiNa uttara vibhAga aura mAnahI batalAye gaye. ye tamAma hAlAta dekhatehI vidvAnloga kahate haiM ki ye saba sUtra disaMbariyoMnehI AcAryamahArAjakI kRtirUpa maNi-mAlAmeM kAMca dukaDe kI taraha dAkhila kara diye haiM. aura una paMDitoMkA kavana harAko bhI maMjUra karanA par3atA hai, Age calakara paMDita loga kahate haiM ki digaMbariyoMnehI 32 vAM sUtra "dvirdhAtakI khaMDe' aisA rakhA hai, to idhara 10 veM aura 11 veM sUtra meM kahe hue bharatAdi, himavadAdi varSa aura varSadhara to dhAtakIkhaMDameM aura puSkarArdhameM dubArA haiM yaha mAna sake haiM, kintu ina dinabharipoM ke hisAbase to dhAtakIkhaMDa aura puSkarArdhameM bharatakA bhAga dviguNA lenA hogA, aura yaha bAta kisIko bhI mAnya nahIM For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #60
( 49 ) ho saktI hove kahAM se ?, kyoMki digaMbariyoMne svayaM sUtra banA kara zrImAnakI sUtramAlA meM dAkhila kara diye haiM / cauthe adhyAya meM " patintilezyAH " yaha sAtavAM sUtra digaMbariyoMkoM maMjUra nahIM hai jaba donoM saMpradAyavAle bhavanapati aura vyantaradevoM ko kRSNa, nIla, kApota aura tejo aisI cAra lezyA mAnate haiM, aura yaha bhI mAnate haiM ki jyotiSkadevako sirpha tejolezyA yAne pItalezyAhI hai, to phira idhara bhavanapati aura vyantarakI cAra lezyA dikhAnevAlA sUtra kyoM na mAnA jAya ? digaMbariyoMne bhavanapati aura vyantarako lezyA nahIM mAnI hai aisA to nahIM hai, kintu dUsarA sUtra joki "tRtIyaH pItalezyaH" arthAt jyotiSka nAmaka tIsarInikAyavAle ko tejolezyAhI hai, aisA dikhAneke liye jo sUtra thA usa sthAna para digaMbariyoMneM "AditastriSu pItAntalezyAH " arthAt AdikI tIna nikAya ke devoMkoM pItAntalezyA hotI hai, aisA sUtra banAyA hai, aba idhara spaSTahI hai ki jaba jyotiSkadevoMkoM tejolezyAke sivAya dUsarI lezyAeM hai hI nahIM, to phira AdikI tIna nikAyoMko pItAnta yAne kRSNa, nIla, kApota aura tejolezyAeM haiM, aisA kahanA kahAMse satya hogA ?, aura yadi aisA goTAlA karanAhI hai to phira aisAhI kyoM nahIM kaha dete ki "devAnAM SaD lezyAH" yAne devoMko 6 lezyAeM haiM, athavA sUtrakI bhI kyA jarUrata haiM ? / isase spaSTa hotA hai ki For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #61
( 50 ) zvetAMriyoMne jo asalasUtra 'pItAntalezyA H ' aisA thA vahI mAnya rakhA hai, aura vahI ucita hai / (7) cauthe adhyAya meM zvetAMbaroMne 'sthitiH' aisA sUtra devatAoM kI sthitikA adhikArake liye mAnA hai, to udhara digaMbaroMneM usa adhikAra ke sUtrakoM uDA diyA hai. khUbI to yaha ki pIchekA sArAhI adhyAya devatAdikIhI sthitiko pratipAdana karatA hai, aisA to donoM saMpradAyavAle mAnate haiM. visa parabhI digaMbara loga isa adhikArako maMjUra nahIM karate. vyAkaraNaAdi zAstroM meM bhI niyama hai ki jahAM para bArabAra anuvRtti lAkara artha karanA paDe vahAM para adhikArasUtra karate haiM, to phira idhara sArAhI bhAga sthitikA hone para isa adhikArasUtrakoM digaMbara loga kyoM nahIM mAnate haiM?, jisa prakAra Age ke adhyAyoMmeM adhikArasUtra hai usI prakAra idhara bhI lenA ThIka hai, 'sa AzravaH' 'sa baMdha : ' sUtroMkI taraha sthitikA adhikArasUtra mAnanA ucita hai / anyathA sAgaropame, adhike, sapta, trirAdhikAni tu0, ekaikena0, aparA0, pUrvA pUrvAnantarA, ityAdi sUtroMmeM samanvaya karanA narA muzkila hogA, yAne yaha sthitikAlahI hai, antara yA avirahAdikakA kAla nahIM hai, aisA kaise hogA ?, aura " nArakANAM 0 vyantarANAM ca jyotiSkANAM ca, lokA0 sarveSAM " ina sUtroMmeM adhyAhAra karanA bhI muzkila hogA / ataH ina kAraNoMkoM socanevAlA manuSya to "sthitiH " isa adhikArako 1 For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #62
(51) dikhAnevAle sUtrakoM maMjUra kiye binA kadApi nahIM raha sktaa| (8) jisa prakAra digambaroMne "sthitiH" isa adhikAra sUtrako maMjUra nahIM kiyA usI prakAra "saudharmAdiSu yathA. krama" yaha sUtra bhI digambaroMne ur3A diyA hai, yadyapi do sUtroMmeM saudharmezAna aura sanatakumAra mAhendrakA grahaNa kiyA hai, kintu trisaptetyAdisUtra meM kisa 2 devalokakI kitanI 2 sthiti hai yaha niyama karanA tathA "aparA palyopamamadhikaM" jarUra isa sUtrameM aura Ageke sUtroM meM bhI vyavasthA karanemeM kaThinatA hogI. jisa prakAra "vaimAnikAH' aura 'uparyupari" ye adhikArasUtra maMjUra kiye haiM, usI taraha yaha adhikArasUtra bhI maMjUra karanA sarvathA ucita hai, ki jisase saudharmezAnAdikake nAma bhI nahIM kahane paDegeM, aura dUsare sUtroM meM vyavasthApUrvaka samanvaya bhI ho skegaa| (9) zvetAmbara aura digambara donoM hI saMpradAyoMkI mAnyatAnusAra asurakumArake indroMkI aura zeSa asuroMkI sthitimeM khAsa pharka hai, to bhI digambaroMne sarvaasuroMkI sAmAnya asurazabda lekara hI sthiti batalAI hai, tathA dakSiNa uttara ke indra, zeSa kumAra aura unake indroMkI bhI sthiti kahI, kintu asala sUtroMko uDA diye haiM isI tarahase graha, nakSatra, tArAgaNakI sthiti, evaM unakI jaghanya utkRSTa sthitike sUtra bhI uDA diye haiM, isa prakAra isa cauthe adhyAyameM unhoMne saba milAkara 13 sUtra uDA diye haiN| For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #63
( 52 ) / (10) caturthaadhyAyake akhIrake bhAgameM digambaroMne "lokAntikAnAmaSTau sAgaropamANi sarveSAM" aisA sUtra mAnA hai. isa sUtrako zvetAMbara samAja maMjUra nahIM karatI hai, usakA sabaMba yaha hai ki yadi zrImAn umAsvAtijImahArAjakoM lokAntikakI sthiti dikhAnI hotI to lokAntikoMkA sthAna aura bheda batalAyA vahAMpara hI batA dete. dUsarI bAta yaha hai ki lokAntikakA prakaraNa choDakara lokAntikakI bAta anyatra uThAnA, yaha bhI sUtrakArakI zailIke anukUla nahIM hai. tIsarI vAta yaha hai ki yadi lokAntikakI sthiti hI kahanI hotI to brahmadevalokakI sthiti batalAI vahAM parahI kaha dete. cauthI bAta yaha hai ki--" lokAntikAnAM" aisA kahanese sabhI lokAntikakI sthiti A jAtI hai to phira " sarveSAM" isa padakI jarUrata hI kyA thI? ina kAraNoMse spaSTa hotA hai ki yaha sUtra zrImAn granthakAramahArAjakA banAyA huA nahIM hai. kintu kisI alpabuddhivAlene svakalpanAkA phalarUpa yaha sUtra banAkara zrImAnke sUtroMmeM ghuseDa diyA hai| / [11] caturthaadhyAyameM devatAoMke viSaya meM gati zarIra AdikI hAni uttarottaradevatAoMmeM hai aisA dikhAne kA sUtra hai jise digambaraloga bhI svIkAra karate haiM, kintu devatAmeM ucchavAsaAhArAdikI tAratamyatA dikhAne ke liye jo sUtra " uchvAsAhAravedanopapAtAnubhAvatazca sAdhyAH " [ 4-23 ] For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #64
( 53 ) zvetAmbaroMne kathaMcit mAnA hai vaha digambaroMne ur3A diyA hai / jaba devatAke sthitilezyAdike viSayameM adhikatA aura nyUnatA dikhAnevAle sUtra mAnaliye gaye to phira khuda svarUpa dikhAnekA sUtra kyoM ur3A diyA gayA ? yaha vicAraNIya hai| .. [12] pAMcaveM adhyAyameM zvetAMbaraloga " dravyANi jIvAzca" aisA ekahI sUtra mAnate haiN| kintu digambarI loga "dravyANi" aura 'jIvAzca' aise do sUtra mAnate haiN| zvetAMbariyoM kA kahanA hai ki yadi dharmAdharmAdi ajIvako svataMtra hI sUtra karake dravya tarIke ginAyA jAya to 'ajIvakAyA dharmAdharmAkAzapugalA dravyANi' aisA ikaTThA hI sUtra karanA thA, aura jIvako bhI pIche hI kahanA thA, tAki pAMcohIkI dravyasaMjJA hojAtI / yAne dharmAdi pAMcako ajIvakAya dikhAkara bAdameM unake dravyapanako dikhAte hue jIvako sAthameM lekara pAMcoM hIkA dravyapana dikhAyA hai / isase tIna sUtra karanekI koI jarUrata hI nahIM rahatI hai, aura jo do sUtra haiM ve hI ucita haiN| _____ pAThakoM ! ikaTThe mUtrako alaga 2 kara denA isameM sUtrakArakI baDImeM baDI AzAtanA karanA hai / kyoMki koI bhI vidvAn yadi use dekhe to vaha phorana kartAko hI galtIvAlA maanegaa| (13) isI adhyAyake 'asaMkhyeyAH pradezA' isa sUtrake sthAnameM digaMbaraloga 'asaMkhyeyAH pradezA dharmAdharmaikajIvAnAM' aisA ekahI sUtra mAnate haiM, kintu zvetAMvarIloga 'asaMkhyeyAH .. . For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #65
( 54 ) pradezA dharmAdharmayo:' aura 'jIvasya ca ' aise do vibhAgase do sUtra alaga 2 mAnate haiM / zvetAMvariyoMkA kahanA aisA hai ki yahA~ para dharmazabda se dharmAstikAya aura adharmazabda se adharmAstikAya lenA hai, kintu jIvazabdase jIvAstikAya nahIM lenA ataH donoMkA sUtra alaga honA hI ucita hai / 'jIvasya ' aise ekavacana se hI yadi eka cIja jIva 'pramANa' aisA sUtrake dvivacanaseM do pramANakI taraha AjAya to phira ekazabdako prayoga sUtrameM lAnA yaha sUtrakArakI khAmI dikhAnevAlA hotA hai / zvetAMbara aura digambara donoM hI asaMkhyAtakI saMkhyA ke asaMkhya bheda mAnate haiM, kintu yahAM para isameM kaunasA asaMkhyAta - kA bheda lenA isakA nirNaya nahIM hotA hai / jisase dharmAdharmakA pradezamAna AdimeM hI kathana karake bAdameMhI usIke barAbara pradeza haraekajIva bhI kahanA yogya hogA / aura dharmAdharmake asaMkhya pradezakA mAna to "lokAkAze'vagAhaH " isa sUtra se bhI nizcita hotA hai / idhara yaha bhI socane kA hai ki yadi ' jIvasya ca ' aisA sUtra alaga nahIM karanA hotA aura cakArase asaMkhyAtazabdakI anuvRtti nahIM lAnI hotI to pIche 'AkAzasya cAnantAH ' aisA sUtra karake ' saMkhyeyA api pudgalAnAM' aisA sUtra karate, yAne pudgala ke pradeza dikhAnevAle sUtra meM 'asaMkhyeyAH ' yaha pada karane kI jarUrata hI nahIM hotI. lekina yadi ' jIvasya ca ' yaha For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #66
( 55 ) sUtra alaga hokara asaMkhyeyazabda cakArase anuvRtta kiyA to phira 'cAnukuSTaM nottaratra' aisA niyamase yaha asaMkhyeyazabda Age nahIM cala saktA hai, jisase pudgala ke sUtrameM asaMkhyeyapada kahanekI jarUrata huI. zAstrakArakI zailI aisI hI hai ki cazabdase jisakI anuvRtti lAve usako Age nahIM calAve. aura isI se hI aupazamika ke do bheda jo samyaktva aura cAritra nAmake the, unako kSAyikake bhedoke vakta cazabdase liyA to phira kSAyopazamikake aTThArahabhedoM meM samyaktva aura cAritra ye bheda anuvRtti se nahIM lAye gaye, kintu spaSTazabda se hI vahAM kahe. isI tarahase idhara ' jIvasya ca' isasUtra meM cazabda kahakara asaMkhyeyakI anuvRtti kI hai isase vaha Age nahIM cala saktA. yAne pugalasUtra meM 'asaMkhyeya ' pada lagAneM se hI sAbita hotA hai ki sUtrakAraneM ' jIvasya ca ' yaha sUtra kiyA thA, aura ina digambaroMneM usa sUtrakoM uDA diyA aura dharmAdharmakI sAtha hI ' ekajIva kaha kara milA diyA. (14) phira bhI digambara logoMne 'sad dravyalakSaNaM' aisA sUtra 'bhedasaMghAtAbhyAM' sUtra ke bAda aura 'utpAdavyaya' isa sUtra ke peztara mAnA hai / kintu zvetAMbaraloga isa sUtrako nahIM mAnate haiN| zvetAMvariyoMkA kahanA aisA hai ki yadi sUrIzvarajIko dravyake lakSaNa meM sattvapanA lenA hotA to 'guNaparyAyavad For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #67
(56) dravyaM aisA jo dravyakA lakSaNa kahA usI sthAna para yA usIsUtrameM ve samAveza karake kaha dete / isake sivAya yadi vicArapUrvaka dekhA jAya to yaha sUtra hI jainamajahabakI mAnyatAse khilApha hai| isakA kAraNa yaha hai ki jinezvaramahArAjako mAnanevAle dravya guNa aura paryAya aise tInoM ko sad mAnate haiM, aura sad dravyalakSaNaM aisA sUtra karanese guNa aura paryAya donoM asat hojAte haiM, itanA hI nahIM, kintu vaimA dravyakA lakSaNa yadi iSTa hotA to "guNaparyAyavad dravyaM" yaha sUtra alaga kyoM karate ? matalaba yaha hai ki 'sad dravyalakSaNaM' sUtra na to jainamantavyatAkA hai, aura na yaha sUtra-racanA hI anukUla hai / zvetAMbarI loga to kahate haiM ki yaha sUtra yadi umAsvAtijIko iSTa hotA to 'sad dravyaM' itanA hI lakSaNasUtra basa thA / udAharaNArtha-'guNaparyAyavad dravyaM' isa sUtra meM lakSaNazabdake pravezakI jarUrata hI nahIM hai. usI prakAra yahAM para bhI lakSaNazabda kahanekI kuchabhI jarUrata nahIM hai / kyoMki uddezyavidheya. vidhise hI lakSaNakA bhI bhAna hojAtA thA / isake sivAya. dUsare darzanakAra bhI apane sUtrameM lakSaNazabdakA prayoga kabhI bhI nahIM karate haiN| to phira idhara lakSaNakA artha AjAne para bhI lakSaNazabdakA prayoga karanA sUtrakArako to lAjima nahIM hai| 'upayogo lakSaNaM' isa sUtrameM to lakSya kA nirdeza nahIM honese lakSaNa zabda kahanA lAjima hI hai. aura idhara to lakSyakI taura For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #68
( 57 ) . . . para dravyazabda kahA hI hai| ina hI pAMcaveM adhyAyameM 'tadbhAvaH pariNAmaH' isa sUtrake pIche zvetAMbaroMne 'anAdirAdimAMzca, rUpiSvAdimAna,, yogopayAmai jIveSu' ye tIna sUtra pariNAmake bhedoMko dikhAke AdinAla pariNAma rUpImeM sAkSAt dikhAke anAdipariNAmakA sadbhAva zeSameM sUcita karate haiN| inako samyaktva, jIva, upayoga AdimeM lakSaNa aura bhedo dikhalAnekI rItise yogya honepara bhI digambaraloga nayA karanekI Adatasa hI maMjUra nahIM karate haiN| ina sUtroke abhidheya ko ve loga bhI maMjUra karate haiN| pAMcaveM adhyAyake AkhIrake bhAgameM digambaraloga " tadbhAvaH pariNAmaH " isa sUtrase adhyAyako : samApti karate haiM, kintu zvetAmbaraloga " anAdirAdimAMzca" " yogopayogI jIveSu" aisA kaha kara pariNAma ke tIna sUtra mAnate haiN| zvetAmbariyoMkA aisA kahanA hai ki pariNAmavAdahI jaina: majabakI asalI jaDa hai, aura usake anAdisAdipanase anekAnta meM bhI anekAntakI vyApti siddha hotI hai aisA dikhAkara sampUrNatayA svAdvAdakA khyAla diyA gayA hai, evaM vaha pariNA rUpI arUpImeM aura jaDa cetana meM kisa prakAra hai, yaha dikhalAnA jarUrI samajha karahI AcAryazrIne usa adhikArako saMgrahameM liyA hai (15). Ame chaDDhe adhmAyameM manuSya ke AyuSyake Azrava meM 'alpAraMparigrahatvaM svabhAvamArdavArjavaM ca mAnuphsya' aisA . ... . . For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #69
. . . .' krodha, mAna, mAyA aura lobhake alpattrako dikhAnekA hai, vahAM digambarI loga alpAdikA eka sUtra aura svabhAvamArdavakA dusarA mAnakara mUtra vyartha hI alaga 2 karate haiM, aura svA. bhAvika Arjava jo tiryagyoniAyu rokake manuSyAyukA vidhAna karanemeM jAhira hai, usako choDa denekI anArjavatA dikhAte haiN| isI taraha devAyuSameM 'samyaktvaM ca' aisA bhI phajula hai, samya kvavAle saba Ayu bAMdhate hI nahIM, aura samyaktvavAn deva, aura nArakI bhI hai. ve deva nahIM hote haiN| .. chaThe adhyAyameM manuSya Ayuke bandhakA adhikArameM zvetAmbariyoMne " " alpArambhaparigrahatvaM svabhAvamArdavArjavatvaM ca mAnuSasya" aisA eka sUtra mAnA hai / taba digambariyoMne usake do hisse kara " alpArambhaparigrahatvaM mAnuSasya" aura "svabhAvamArdavaM ca" aise do sUtra banA DAle / isa sUtrakA niSprayojana vibhAga karadenA aura manuSyapanake kAraNoM se saralatArUpa kAraNako uDA denA yaha digambhariyoMko kaise ucita mAlUma huA hogaa| isa viSayameM digambaraloga yadi apanA abhiprAya jAhira kareMge to taTasthalogoMko socanekA prasaMga prApta hogaa| saralaSanase manuSyakA AyuSya baMdhatA hai yaha bAta digambariyoMkobhI svIkArya hai, to phira unalogoMne yahAM para se"Arjava" pada kyoM nikAla diyA ?, yadi koI aisA kahe ki yaha pada to .. . . . aaja . For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #70
( 59) . . zvetAmbariyoMne hI dAkhila kara diyA hai, to aisA kahanA bhrama. mAtrahI hai, kyoMki "mAyA tairyagyonasya" isa sUtrase jaba mAyAkA phalarUpa Ayu batalAyA to phira ArjavatAkA phalarUpa AyuSya batAyA jAnA Avazyaka hI hai / isake sivAya mArdavake sAtha Arjava lenA bhI ucita hI hai| 16 chaThe adhyAyameM digambariyAne "sarAgasaMyamA" ityAdi devatAke AyuSyake kAraNoMko dikhAnevAle sUtrake Age phira bhI "samyaktvaM ca" aisA kahakara eka sUtra vizeSa mAnA hai| zvetAmbarI loga isa sUtrako nahIM mAnate haiN| zvetAmbariyoMkA kahanA aisA hai ki "manuSya yA tiyaMcakA jIva samyaktvakI sthitimeM yadi AyuSya bAndhe to avazya hI devatAkA AyuSya bAMdhatA hai / " kintu "samyaktvaM ca" isa sUtrase devatAke AyuSyakA kAraNa samyaktva hai aisA dikhalAnA sarvathA anucita hai| isakA kAraNa yaha hai ki samyaktvase sirpha vaimAnikakA hI AyuSya bAMdhA jAtA hai, kintu yahAM para to sAmAnyase cAroMhI prakArake devatAkA AyuSya kaise bAMdhe ? yaha lenekA hai / yadyapi yahAM para saMyama aura saMyamAsaMyama lekara zrAvaka aura sAdhuke liye kahA hai, kintu dezavirati aura sarvavirati samyaktva pUrvaka hI lenA aisA idhara niyama nahIM hai| jaise samyaktvasahita zrAvakapanA yA sAdhupanA dhAraNa karanevAlA devalokakA AyuSya bAMdhanekA Azrava karatA hai, vaise hI samyaktvarahita For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #71
- . . . koI abhavya yA. mithyAdRSTi dezavirati yA sarvavirati dhAraNa karanevAle hote haiM, aura isase ve abhavyAdika aisI dezavirati AdikI dazAmeM cAroM prakArake devoM meM kisI bhI prakArake devake bhavasambandhI AyuSyakA Azraya karate haiM, arthAt dezavirati Adi dravya aura bhAvase banate haiM, aura inase cAroM hI prakArakA devaAyukA bandha hotA hai, kintu samyaktva to sivAya vaimAnikake dUsare devaAyudhakA kAraNa banatA hI nahIM / atA sAmAnya devaAyuke AzrayameM samyaktvako lenA sarvathA anucita hai / yadi mAnaliyA jAya ki vizeSadevoMke AyukA kAraNa ho aura use sAmAnyameM liyA jAya to koI harja nahIM hai, kintu yahAM para to deva aura nArakoMko devatAke AyuSya sambandhI bandhAzrava hai hI nahIM aura deva va nArakoMko pUrvabhavase calA AyA kSAyika kSAyopazamika hI hai aisA nahIM hai aura na ve jIva samyaktvayukta avasthAmeM bhI dUsarI jindagIke AyukA Azrava aura bandhaH kare taba bhI devalokake AyuSyakA Azraya aura bandha kara sakte haiN| sApha sApha bAta hai ki saMyama aura saMyamAsaMyama jisa jisa gatimeM jisa jisa jIvakoM hai ve jIva yadi AyukA Azraya aura baMdha kare to avazya devaAyu. kAhI Azrava aura baMdhakare aisA niyama hai, lekina aisA kabhIbhI niyama nahIM ho sakatA hai ki kisIbhI gatikA koIbhI jIva samyakvavAna hove to devakA AyuSyakA hI Azrava aura baMdha For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #72
kare, kyoMke deva aura nAraka samyaktvavAna to hote bhI hai paraMtu ve devAyukA kabhIbhI Azrava aura baMdha kara sakte hI nahIM, to phira aisI avasthAmeM 'samyaktvaM ca' yaha sUtra kaise ho ? lenAbhI ho to sarAjasUtra hI lenA hogA aura 'ca' to idhara phajulahI hai / ina kAraNoMse spaSTa hojAtA hai ki vAstava meM digambariyoMne zrImAnakI kRtimeM isa sUtrako ghuseDa diyA hai, aisA zvetAmbarI loga mAnate haiN| (17) Age adhyAyasAtaveMmeM " tatsthairyArtha bhAvanAH " aisA sUtra kaha kara mahAvatakI pAMca pAMca bhAvanA dikhAnevAlA sUtra donahI sampradAyavAle svIkAra karate haiM, kintu isake sivAya bhI digambaraloga pratyeka mahAvatakI pAMca 2 bhAvanA dikhAneke liye pAMca sUtra aura mAnate haiN| isa para zvetAmbariyoMkA kahanA aisA hai ki yadi AcAryazrIko pratyekamahAvratakI bhAvanA Age sUtra dvArA dikhalAnI hotI to-paMca paMcahI ke sAtha sUcanA kara dete / jaisA ki dUsare adhyAyameM aupazamikAdike bhedoMkI saMkhyA dikhAkara bheda dikhAnA thA to "yathAkrama" khaa| Age para bhI dezaviratike atIcAroMke vakhta "tazIleSu paMca paMca yathAkramam" hI kahA / arthAt saMkhyAse kahaneke bAda jaba anukramase dikhAnekA hotA hai to vahAMpara 'yathAkrama' zabda kahate haiM / AThaveM adhyAyameM bandhake adhikArameM jJAnAvaraNAdi. bhedoMkI pAMcanauAdi saMkhyA batalAI, aura Age unake bheda For Personal & Private Use Only "

Page #73
(62) ginAneke liye sUtra karanekA thA to vahAM parabhI yathAkramaM aisAhI kahA gayA hai / navameM adhyAyameM prAyazcittAdike bhedoMkI saMkhyA dikhAneke liye " navacaturdazapaMcadvibhedA yathAkramam" aisA sUtra karate samaya bhI Age bhedoMkA spaSTanirdeza karanekA honese 'yathAkrama' kahA hai / isase yaha bAta nizcita hotI hai ki jahAMpara saMkhyAse bheda dikhAkara vivecanapUrvaka bheda dikhAnA hotA hai vahAMpara zrImAn AcAryamahArAja 'yathAkrama' zabda rakhate haiN| kintu yahAMpara bhAvanAke liye paMca paMca' kahakara 'yathAkrama' nahIM kahA gayA, isase spaSTa hotA hai ki mahAvratoMkI bhAvanAoMke sUtra AcAryazrIke banAye hue nahIM haiN| AcAryazrIkI zailI to aisI hai ki jahAMpara sirpha bheda hI kI saMkhyA dikhAnI ho aura bhedakA vivecana nahIM karanA ho vahAM para 'yathAkrama' nahIM kahate haiM / jaisA ki dUsare adhyAyameM kSAyikAdibhedoM meM dAnAdilabdhi gatikaSAyaliMgalezyAdikakI saMkhyA dikhAI, kintu Age vivecana nahIM karanA thA to vahAM para 'yathAkrama' nahIM khaa| vaisehI chaTe adhyAyameM bhI Azravake bayAnameM 'indriyakapAyAvratakriyAH paMcacatuHpaMcapaMcaviMzatisaMkhyAH pUrvasya bhedA:' isa sUtrameM indriyAdikake bhedakI saMkhyA to viSayameM dikhAI, kintu unakA vivecana nahIM thA to vahAM para 'yathAkrama' pada nahIM kahA / ina saba hetuoMko dekhate nizcita hotA hai ki Ageke bhAvanAviSayaka sUtra AcAryazrIjIke banAye hue nahIM MAP For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #74
( 63 ) kintu digaMbariyoMne hI ghuseDa diye haiM / yadi bhAvanAoMke 9 sUtra digambariyoMke ghuseDe hue nahIM hote to ina sUtroMmeM haraeka jagaha 'paMca paMca' zabda kahAMse ghusa jAtA 1, kyoMki AcAryazrIjIneto dezavirArta ke aticArake sUtroM meM pAMca pAMca aticAra ginAye haiM, kintu kisI bhI sUtra meM 'paMca, paMca' aisA nahIM kahA hai / jaba 'paMca paMca' aisA vIpsA vacana kahakara vyApti dikhA do to phira pratyeka sthAna meM sUtra sUtra para 'paMca paMca' kahate rahanA yaha bAta eka mAmUlI vidvAnmI ucita nahIM smjhtaa| to phira AcAryazrIjI jaise advitIyavidvAn aura saMgrahakArako aisA karanA kaise lAjima ho sakatA hai / isameM bhI sUtrakArane 'nikSepa' zabda samiti ke adhikAra meM liyA hai, aura idhara 'nikSepaNa'. aisA gurutAyukta zabda ghara diyA vaha saMgrahakAra ke liye kaise lAjima hogA ? isI prakAra 'AlokitAnnapAnAni ' aisA laghu nirdeza zakya hone para bhI AlokitapAnabhojanAni ' aisA gaurava karanA bhI lAjima nahIM thA / isake sivAya dUsare mahAvratakI bhAvanAoM meM bhI 'bhaya' zabda rakhakara 'krodha lobha bhayahAsya' aisA laghunirdeza sugama aura prasidhdhivAlA ho sake usako choDakara ' krodha lobha bhIrutvahAsya ' aisA gurutAyukta TeDhA nirdeza kauna akalamaMda karegA, sAtha hI sAtha 'pratyAkhyAnAnuvIcI bhASaNAni aisA laghu nirdeza hone para bhI 'pratyAkhyAnAnyanuvIcI bhASaNaM ca aisA murutAyukta aura nirarthakavAkya bhedayukta kahanA saMgrahakArako For Personal & Private Use Only :

Page #75
(64) kalaMkita hI karanA hai| tIsare mahAvratakI bhAvanAmeM to digambariyoMne kucha aura hI raMga jamAyA hai| tIsarA mahAvrata adanAdAnaviramaNa yAne binA dI huI cIja nahIM lenekA hai, aura bhAvanA bhI isa vratakI vaisIhI honA cAhiye ki jisase usamamAvatakI skSA ho sake / kintu inalogoMne to 'zUnyAgAravimocitAvAsa: paroparodhAkaraNabhakSyazuddhisadharmAvisaMvAdA:paMca' aisAsUtra kahakara adattAdAnaviramaNakI bhAvanA dikhAnekI vAMchA rakkhI hai ? paraMtu akalamaMda AdamI isa sUtrako dekhakara ni:saMdeha kaha sakatA hai ki yaha racanA na to tacArthakAramahArAjakI hI hai aura na adattAdAnaviramaNakI bhAvanAko dikhAnekAlI bhI hai| idhara gurulaghukA viSayato dUra rahA, kintu zUnyAgArameM rahanA yaha akhacaryake rakSaNa athavA parigrahavirati ke liye hai ki AdacAdvAnakI viratike liye hai ? kyA AgArazUnya honepara mAlikakI AjJA binA ThaharanA adattAdAnase virativAleko lAjima hogA?, yadi yaha kahA jAya ki nahIM, to phira zUnyAgArarUpabhAvanA adattAdAnaviratise bacAnevAlI kaise hogI ?, isI tarahase dUsarI 'vimocitAvAsa' nAmakI jo bhAvanA kahI gaI hai vaha parigrahaviramaNakI bhAvanA hogI yA adattAdAnaviramaNakI ? aura apanAyA aurakA AvAsa choDa de yaha ahattAdAnaviramaNase sambandha rakhatA hai kyA ?. ... 1400 ( 18) saptama adhyAyameM mahAvratoMkI sthiratAke liye For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #76
( 65 ) bhagavAn zrIumAsvAtijIne 'tatsthairyArtha bhAvanAH paMca paMca aisA spaSTa sUcana karadiyA hai| bAda inhIM digambaroMne 4, 5, 6, 7 aura 8 veM sUtroMko kalpita banAye haiN| sUrijIne to isa bhAvanAke sAtha hI hiMsAdimeM apAyAvadyadarzana, maitrI Adi, aura jagatke kAya aura svabhAvakA cintana ye sabhI isahI sthairya ke liye Ageke sUtroMse dikhAye haiM, to bIca meM mahAvratoM: kI bhAvanAkA vistAra ayogya hI dikhAI par3atA hai| jaise audAyikake ikkIsa bheda sAkArAnAkAra upayogake aSTa aura cAra bheda lokAntikake bheda Azravake bheda vagairaha saMkhyAmAtra se nirdeza kara avikRta hI rakkhA hai, isI taraha idhara bhedoMkA nirdeza ThIka hI thaa| ( 19 ) mahAvratoMkI bhAvanAke vistArake satrameM bhI logoMne eSaNAsamitiko ahiMsAkI bhAvanAmeMse ur3A dI hai| vAstavikameM inalogoMko zaucake nAmase kamaMDala to rakhanA hai, loken mAdhukarIvRttimeM aura bAla, glAna, vRddha, AcAryakI vaiyAvRtyameM jarUrI aisA pAtra nahIM mAnanA haiM / isasehI yaha jarUrI huA ki usake sthAnameM unhoMne amatyAvazyaka aisI vAgyapti DAla dI hai / aise hI 'paseparodhAkAraNa' nAmakI bhAvanAse dUsareko uparodhakA kAraNa nahIM bananA, yaha ahiMsAitakIhI bhAvanA hai, adattAdAnaviramaNase usakA bAlka kisI bhI tarahase nahIM hai| cauthIbhAvamA milyabuddhi rakhane For Personal & Private Use Only ..

Page #77
(66 ) kA digambaroMne mAnA hai. yadyapi bhaityazuddhi karanA jainamajahabake hisAbase pUrNataH jarUrI hai. aura isIse to mAdhukarIvRtti jainoMne mAnI hai, parantu digambaroMko pAtrAdi na rakhaneke kAraNa ekahI gRhameM bhojana kara lenA par3atA hai. aura mAdhukarIvRttiko jalAMjalI denI paDatI hai. lekina bhaikSyazuddhi prANAtipAtaviramaNake bacAvake liye hai. usako adattAdAnaviramaNase sambaMdha hI nahIM hai. aisI nirarthaka bAteM zrImAnumAsvAtivAcakajIne to nahIM kahI haiM, yaha to sirpha digambaroMhIkA gappa. molA hai. Age pAMcavIM bhAvanAmeM sadharmAvisaMvAda nAmaka bhAvanA batAI hai, lekina yaha bhI samyaktva yA prathamavratakI bhAvanA hai. adattAdAnaviramaNase isakA koI sambaMdha nahIM hai. asalameM to isa mahAvratakI bhAvanA yaha thI: mAlocyAvarahayAJcAkSiNAvayAcanam / etAvanmAtrabhityetadityavagrahadhAraNam // 1 // samAnadhArmikebhyazca, tathA'vaprahayAcanam / anujJApitapAnAmAzanamasteyabhAvanAH // 2 // arthAt jisa makAnameM ThaharanekI mAlikase AjJA mAMganA ho usIvakta hI kahAM 2 kyA 2 karanA hai yaha spaSTa karake mAlika se AjJA mAMganA, bAdameM sthANDila prazravaNa Adi paraThane ke sthAnameM bhI mAlikako aprIti na ho aisA khayAla karane ke liye phira bhI usa vakhta mAlikakA avagraha mAMganA. phira bhI jahAM kahIM sAdhuko For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #78
(67) ThaharanA ho vahAM bhI Apane kitanI jagaha mAlikase Thaharaneke liye lI hai, isakA pUrA nizcaya rakhanA cAhiye. aisA na ho ki Apane jisa sthAnakI yAcanA nahIM kI hai usa sthAnakA upabhoga hojAya, aura adattAdAnaviramaNameM doSa lage. ye bhAvanA to makAnake mAlika jo gRhastha yA kSetra devatA hove usakI apekSAse huI, lekina jisa makAnameM Age dUsare sAdhumahAtmA Thahare haiM aura usameM kisI naye sAdhuko ThaharanA hai to usa naye sAdhuko cAhiye ki pahile Thahare hue sAdhumahAtmAkI maMjUrI leve. isIkA nAma hI sAdharmikAvagrahakI yAcanA karanA hai. ye cAra bhAvanAeMto makAnake viSaya meM adattAdAna bacAneke liye huI, lekina dUsarI tarahase bhI adattAdAnase bacAneke liye hI kahA hai ki mAlika aura AcAryane jisa annapAnakA hukma diyA hove vahI upayogameM lenA cAhiye. isIke liye 'anujJApitapAnAnAzana' nAmakI pAMcavIM bhAvanA hai. vAcakagaNa ! idhara gaura kareM ki digambaroMkI kahI huI 'zUnyAgAra0' Adi pAMca bhAvanAeM adattAdAnase bacAveMgI ki zvetAMbaroMkI kahI huI 'AlocyAvagrahayAMcA' Adi pAMca bhAvanAeM adattAdAnaviramaNase bacAveMgI ?, yadi ye digambaroMkI kahI huI bhAvanAeM adattAdAnaviramaNase sambandhavAlI hI nahIM hai to phira aisI kalpitabhAvanAeM asaMbaddhapanase banAkara AcAryamahArAjake nAma para Thoka denA kitanA anyAyAspada For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #79
( 68 ) hogA ?, asala meM ina digambaroMkoM avagrahAdi mAMganA aura bhikSA lAkara AcAryAdikako dikhAnA yaha bAta pAtrAdika nahIM rakhaneke Agrahase iSTa nahIM hai. isI sababa se inhoMne ina bhAvanAoMkA goTAlA kara diyA hai. ( 21 ) Age AThaveM adhyAya meM zvetAMbara loga 'sa bandhaH' yaha sUtra alaga mAnate haiM, va digambaraloga 'sakaSAyatvAjjIvaH karmaNo yogyAn pudgalAnAdatte sa bandhaH' aisA kaha karake ekahI sUtra mAnate haiM. zvetAmbaroMkA kahanA hai ki yadi ekahI sUtra hotA to phira zabda se uddeza kiye binA tatzabda se nirdeza kaise hove ? asala meM tatzabda pUrvakAlameM kahI huI bAta ke parAmarza ke liye hotA hai, aura jaba yaha ekahI sUtra hai to phira tatzabdakI kyA jarUrata thI ?, itanAhI nahIM, lokan ekahI sUtra hotA to 'sakaSAya jIvana karma pudgalAdAnaM bandhaH' aisA hI sUtra karate. isameM kitanA lAghava hojAtA hai yaha bAta akalamandoMsa chipI nahIM hai. aisA laghusUtra nahIM kiyA isase sApha jAhira hotA hai ki zrIumAsvAtivAcakajIne to idhara do sUtra banAye the, lokana kisI paMDitaMmanyadigambarane isa zvetAmbara ke sUtrakoM apanA karane ke lie ulaTa pulaTa kara diyA jagatameM bhI prasiddha hai ki kisIkI cIjako uDAke le jAnevAlA usa cIjako yathAvasthitasvarUpameM nahIM rakhatA hai. zrImAn AcArya mahArAjakI to yaha zailI haiM ki peztara padArthakA svarUpa dikhAkara pIche usake For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #80
saMketake liye saMjJA karate haiM. jaise ki zrImAnne AzravakA nirUpaNa karanevAle chaTe adhyAyameM peztara 'manovAkAyakarma yogaH' esA kahakara yogakA svarUpa dikhAyA. bAdahI dUsare sUtrameM 'sa AzravaH' kahakara usa yogakI Azrava saMjJA kI. usI tarahase idhara bhI zrImAn AcAryamahArAjane pahile bandhakA svarUpa yA rAti batAkara pIche usakI 'sa bandhaH' kahakara bandhasaMjJA kI. pestarake sUtra meM bandhakA svarUpa kahanese dUsare sUtra meM tatzabdase nirdeza karake hI baMdhasaMjJA karanI lAjima hogA. isase sApha hotA hai ki zvetAmbaroMkA mAnanA hI yathArtha hai, aura asala tattvArthakA sUtra zvetAmbaroMhI ke pAsa hai. digambaroMne isa sUtrako apanA hai aisA dikhAneke lie ulaTapulaTa kara diyA hai. zvetAmbaroMkA kathana hai ki itanA hone para bhI zrImAn umAsvAtivAcakajIkA bhAgya bar3A teja hogA ki jisase ina digambaroMne gaNadharamahArAjake banAye hue asalI sUtroMko nAmaMjUra karake uDA diye, isa tarahase tattvArthasUtra meM ulaTapulaTa kiyA, lekina ur3AyA nahIM. kyoMki digambaroMkA yaha to mantavya hai hI ki zrImAnaumAsvAtimahArAjake vakta bhagavAnake Agama hAjira the aura pIche sarvathA naSTa hogaye. jaba bhagavAnake zAstroMko vyuccheda kara denemeM digambaroMko harja nahIM hui, to phira umAsvAtivAcakajIke tatvArthakA vyuccheda kaha denemeM ina digambaroMko kyA harja hotI ?, digambaraloga bhagavAnake vacanoM For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #81
( 70 ) se bhI zrI umAsvAti kA vacana jyAdaha mAnya karate hoMge, anyathA digambaroMke bujhagauneM tattvArthaAdikA rakSaNa kiyA aura bhagavAna ke vacanakA eka Tukar3A bhI kyoM nahIM rakkhAH, isa sthAna meM digambaroMko socanA cAhiye ki tumhAre pUrva puruSoMne jo purANa Adi banAye ve bhagavAnake vacana se banAye ki apanI kalpanAse banAye ? yadi kahA jAya ki bhagavAna ke vacanako dekhakara usake anusArahI banAye, to phira una AcArya ke banAye hue to purANAdike lAkhoM zloka abhI taka hAjira rahe aura bhagavAnakA zAstra sarvathA vyuccheda hI hogayA yaha bAta kaise huI ? dUsarI yaha bhI bAta socane kAbila hai ki kyA digaM baroMke pUrvapuruSa aise hue ki purANAdika ke jo kathAnakAdimaya haiM una granthoMkA to rakSaNa kiyA aura bhagavAn ke amUlya vacanarUpa sUtroMko vyuccheda hone diyA ? yaha bAta bhI socane lAyaka hai ki kyA digambaroMke pUrvapuruSa aise hue hoMge ki pAMca sAta hajAra zloka bhI yAda nahIM rakha sake ? yadi yAda rakha sakte hote to bhagavAna ke vacanake lAkhoM zloka na bhI raha sake, parantu hajAroM zloka to jarUra rahate, aura aisA hotA to digambaroMkoM " badamAza denadArako bahiyAM hI nahIM haiM" isa lokokti anusAra "bhagavAna ke sUtra sarvathA vyuccheda hogaye, aba bhagavAnake vacana hai hI nahIM" aisA kahanekA maukA hI kahAMse AtA ? For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #82
( 71 ) asalI magadhadezakI hakIkata, saMjJA, varttAva, saMketa AdikI vidyamAnatA sUtroM meM dekhakara koI bhI AdamI zvetAmbaroM ke sUtroM ko asalI sUtra hai aise kahe binA nahIM raha sakatA hai. gadyapadyakA yA sugama kaThinatAkA viSaya lekara jo kucha akalamaMdako agrAhya aisA anumAna kitaneka logoMkI tarapha se kiyA jAya to vaha bhI jhUTha hai, kyoMki jo AdamI pravAhamaya saMskRta bhASAmeM dinoM taka vAda karatA hai vahI AdamI apane gRhameM aurata laDakoAdike sAtha grAmyabhASA meM bhI bAta karatA hI hai. zrImAn haribhadrasUrijIne ati kaThina anekAntajayapatAkAdi jaise nyAyagraMtha banAye aura unhoMne hI zrIsamarAdityakathA jaisA kathAnakamaya prasannagraMtha bhI banAyA, aura jina zrImAn hemacandrasUrijIne zabdAnuzAsana aura pramANamImAMsA sarIkhe vyAkaraNa aura nyAyake prauDhagraMtha banAye unhoMne hI triSaSTizalAkA puruSacaritra aura pariziSTaparva sarIkhe kathAnakamaya sarala graMtha bhI banAye. jina somaprabhAcAryajIne haraeka kAvya ke sau artha baneM aisA kAvya racA. unhIM somaprabhAcAryajIneM sindUraprakaraNa jaisA prasannakAvya banAyA, isI taraha sUtrakI pUrvApara bhASAdimeM bhI honA asaMbhAvita nahIM hai, to phira zvetAmbaroMke asalI sUtrako digambara nahIM mAnate usameM unakA haThakadAgrahake atirikta dUsarA koI bhI saca nahIM mAluma hotA hai ( 21 ) AThaveM adhyAya ke antama For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #83
( 72 ) ' sadvaidya samyaktva hAsya ra ti puruSaveda zubhAyurnAmagotrANi puNyaM aisA sUtra mAnA hai, taba digambaroMne "sadvedya zubhAyurnAmagotrANi puN" aisA sUtra mAnA hai. bAdameM digambaroMne 'ato'nyat pApa' aisA AkhirakA sUtra mAnA hai yAne zvetAmbaroMne akele puNyakI prakRtiyoM ko dikhAnevAlA sUtra spaSTa mAnA hai aura pApaprakRtiko arthApatti se gamya mAnI hai, jaba digambaroMne donoM tarahakI prakRtiko dikhAnevAle sUtra alaga alaga mAne haiM. asala meM zvetAmbaroMko yaha socanA cAhiye ki samyaktva hAsya rati aura puruSaveda ye saba prakRtiyAM mohake bheda haiM, to mohakA bhedarUpa honevAlI prakRtiyAM puNyarUpa kaise ho sakatI haiM ? lekina zvetAmbara aura digambara donoM ko yaha to maMjUra hI hai ki asala meM AtmAko bandha to mithyAtvamohanIyakA hI hotA hai. bAda meM jaba AtmA zuddhapariNAmameM Akara una mithyAsvake pugaloMko zuddha kara DAle tabhI unapudgaloMko samyaktvamohanI ke pudgala kaha sakate haiM, aura unhIM samyaktvake pudgaloM ko vedatA huA jIva samyaktvavAn hai aura rahatA hai samyagjJAnAdikako bhI pAtA hai, to phira aise pudgaloMkA puNyarUpa nahIM mAnanA vaha kaise hogA ! asala meM to jainazAstra ke hisAba se sabhI karmapudgala pAparUpa hI hai. lekina jisake udayameM AtmA Ananda pAve vaise pugalako puNya mAnate haiM aura jina pugalako vedate AtmA takalIpha bhogatA hai usako pApa mAnate haiM. yadi For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #84
yaha bAta donoMko maMjUra hai to usa apekSAse samyaktvapudgalakA vedana karanA puNya kyoM nahIM hogA ? samyaktva pAnese. apUrva Ananda kA anubhava hotA hai aisA to donoMko hI maMjUra hai. aba Age hAsya rati puruSaveda kahe haiM, ve bhI AlhAdase jaMba anuH bhUta hote haiM to phira vaha puNyatarIke kyoM na mAnA jAya ? itanAhI nahIM, lekina donoMko yaha bhI maMjUra hai ki hAsya ratiH aura puruSavedakA karma acchA kArya karanese hI baMdhatA hai. bure. kAryakI pravRttiyoMmeM to zoka, arati aura strIvedakA hI badha hotA hai, to phira zubhayogase honevAlA Azrava 'zubhaH puNyasya aisA jo sUtra pUrvameM kahA hai usa mujaba kyoM zubha nahIM ginanA ? aura Azrabake vakta puNya gine to phira udayake vakta una prakRtiyoM ko puNya nahIM kahanA aura pApa kahanA yaha kaise hogaa| vizeSa AzcaryakI bAta to yaha hai ki digambaraloga sIne mahApApakA udaya mAnakara strIko kevalajJAna aura mokSa nahIM hotA hai aimA mAnate haiM. to idhara to unake hisAbase strIvedakA. udaya bhI jaisA pAparUpa hai vaisAhI puruSavedakA udaya bhI pApa sahIM hai. to phira strIko puruSakI taraha kevalajJAna aura mokSa kyoM nahIM mAnate haiM ? yaha to eka sAmAnyarUpase vicAraNA hI hai. asalameM to Age chaThe adhyAyameM donoMne suma se hone vaha puNyakA aura azubhaMyoga hone so pApa sApara hove aisA maMjUra kara liyA hai, to phira para - 4 . For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #85
(74 ) prakRti ginAkara pApakI prakRti apane Apa samajhameM AnevAlI honese kahanekI jarUrata hI nahIM thI. itanA hone para bhI sUtrakI samajhanevAlA AdamI spaSTa jAna sakatA hai ki yaha sUtra zrImAnaumAsvAtivAcakajIkA vA kisI bhI akalamaMdakA banAyA huA nahIM hai akalamaMda nayA banAnevAlA hotA taba bhI aisA sUtra nahIM banAtA. kyoMki 'anyat pApa' itanAhI kahanA jarUrI thA, kyoMki peztarake sUtra meM puNyaprakRti spaSTataH dikhAI hai. to phira 'ato' isa padakI jarUratahI kyA thI ? apane Apa 'anyat' zabda kahanese hI usase yAne puNyaprakRtise bhinna prakRtiyoMko pApa kahanA yaha A jAtA. jaise digambaroMke hisAbase "zeSAkhivedAH' isa sUtrameM 'ita:' vA 'ata:' kahanekI jarUrata nahIM rahI aura zvetAmbarake hisAbase 'zubhaH puNyasya' sUtrake bAda kitaneka sthAnake hisAbase 'zeSaM pApaM' isameM 'itaH' vA "ata:' kI jarUrata nahIM hai, aura donoMke mantavyase 'pratyakSamanyat' aisA jo sUtra hai usameM 'ataH' vA 'ita:' kucha bhI nahIM hai, aura isI tarahase dUsare bhI darzanakAroMne zeSakI jagaha para 'ataH' vA 'itaH' nahIM lagAyA hai. sababa mAlUma hotA hai ki yaha sUtra digambaroMne kalpita banAkara ghuseDa diyA hai. __- (22) digambaroMne adhyAya cha?meM sUtra aisA mAnA hai ki zubhaH puNyasyAzubha: pApasya' yAne zubhayoga puNyakA Azrava hai aura azubhayoga pApakA Azrava hai zvetAmbara loga isa Cain Education International For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #86
( 75 ) jagaha para 'zubhaH puNyasya' aura 'azubhaH pApasya' aisA karake donoM sUtra alaga alaga mAnate haiM. aba isa sthAnameM zvetAmbaroMkA kahanA hai ki yadi ye sUtra donoM alaga nahIM hote to prathama to idhara samuccaya karanevAlA zabda cAhiye thA. itanA hI nahIM, lekina aisA sUtra puNyApuNyakA ekatra karanA hotA tabato 'zubhAzubhau puNyapApayoH' yahI kahanA lAjima thA. sUtrakAra jahAM kahIM samuccaya kahate haiM vahAM para bahutvaizva 1.9 'aupazamikakSAyiko bhAvau mizrazca' (2-1) 'audayikapAriNAmiko ca ( 2-1) 'samyaktvacAritrasaMyamAsaMyamAzca' (2.5) 'vigrahavatI ca.' (2-28 ) 'mizrAzcaikaza:'( 2.32 ) 'mavyAghAti cAhArakaM' (2-49) 'tArakAca' (4.12). sarvArthasiddhau ca' (4.19, 4-32) 'paratvAparatve ca.' (5.22), 'aNakA skandhAzca' (5-25) 'pAriNAmiko ca' ( 537 ) visaMvAdanaM ca0 ( 6-22 ) 'dbhAvane ca0 (6-25): 'cottarasvara (6-26 ) 'styAnagRddhayazca' (7.7:) 'bikalpAzcaikaza: (7.9) 'tIrthakaratvaM ca' (7-19 ) '0mantarAyasya ca' (7-14) 'kSayAcca kevalaM': 10-1 ) 'pariNAmAcca' (10-6) zikhAbacca' (10-7) ye sUtra spaSTa tarahase udAharaNa haiM ke samuccaya dikhAne ke liye cazabda lagAyA jAtA hai. . ina sabhI sUtroMmeM mukhyatve sirpha unhIM satroMmeM kahA huA samuccaya hai aura usa samuccayako dikhalAne ke liye sUtrakArane spaSTa For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #87
( 76 ) samuccayavAcaka aise 'ca' kA prayoga kiyA hai. aura ye cakAravAle sabhIsUtra prAyaH digambaroMkI maMjUra bhI hai, jaba AcArya mahArAjakI digambaroMke hisAba se hI Upara diye hue sUtroMse zailI siddha hotI hai to phira idhara samuccAyaka aise 'ca' zabdakA prayoga na kareM aura donoM ekatra rakkheM yaha kaise bane ? isase nirNIta hotA hai ki hamAre mAne anusAra puNya aura pApake lie zrImAnmAsvAtivAcakajIne sUtra alaga alaga hIM kiye the aura ina digambaroMneM ghoTAlA kara diyA hai / ( 23 ) navameM adhyAyameM dhyAnake lakSaNa ke sUtra meM digaMbaraloga 'uttamasaMhananasyaikAgracintAnirodho dhyAnamAmuhUrttAta' aisA akhaMDa mAnate haiM. jaba zvetAmbara loga 'uttama' ityAdikako eka 'sUtra mAnake 'AmuhUrtAt' yaha sUtra alaga lete haiM, aba isa sthAna meM yA to digambaroMneM do sUtroMkA eka sUtra banA diyA yA zvetAmbarAne ekasUtrake do sUtra kara diye haiM, yaha socanekA hai. asala meM isameM eka sUtra ho yA do sUtra hoM isase bhAvArthakA pharka nahIM hai. tathApi ekakA do karanA yA do sUtrakA eka saMtra kara denA yaha bhavabhaya rahitapanakA to jarUra sUcaka idhara apane usa bAta se matalaba nahIM hai, lekina sUtra do the aura eka huA yA ekahI thA usake do kara diye. yadyapi isa bAsakA nirNaya karanA muzkila hai, tathApi azakya to nahIM hai. kyoMki sUtrakAra mahArAjane aneka sthAnoM para aneka padArthoM For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #88
( 77 ) kI sthiti dikhAI hai. jaise tIsare adhyAyameM nArakoMkI sthiti dikhAI hai, vaisehI manuSya aura tiryacakI bhI sthiti dikhAI hai, aise hI jJAnAvaraNIyAdikaukI bhI sthiti Ame dikhAI hai, lekina kisI bhI sthAnameM svarUpa yA bheda dikhAneke sAtha sthiti nahIM dikhAI hai, to idhara sUtrakAra apanI zailI palaTAve isakA koI bhI vizeSa sababa na hokara yahI mAnanA vAstavika hogA ki zrImAnaumAsvAtijImahArAjane svarUpadarzaka aura sthitidarzaka sUtra alaga hI kiye the, aura kisI paMDitamanya digambarane apanI kalpanA calAkara ikaTThA karake ekahI sUtra kara diyA hai| --- ( 24 ) isI navameM adhyAyameM digambaroMne 'AjJApAyavipAkasaMsthAnavicayAya dharmya' 'zukle cAye pUrvavidaH' aura 'pare kevalinaH' aise tIna sUtra mAne haiM, aura zvetAmbaroMne 'AjJApAyavipAkasaMsthAnavicayAya dharmamapramattasaMyatasya' 'upazAnta - kSINakaSAyayozca' 'zukle cAye' 'pUrvavidaH' 'pare kevalinaH' Isa tarahase pAMca sUtra mAne haiM. aba idhara yahI socanekA hai ki kyA zvetAmbaroMne sUtra baDhA diye haiM yA digambaroMne kama kara di haiM ? asala meM to isakA khulAsA sUtrakAra mahArAja kI sakate haiM ki amukane merI kRtimase sUtra kama kara amukane merI kRtimeM sUtra baDhAye haiM. lekina aba apanI akkalase bhI isakA kucha nizcaya karA For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #89
( 78 ) to yaha bAta donoMne dikhAI hai ki ArttadhyAna nAmaka dhyAna avirata dezavirata aura pramattasaMyatako hotA hai aura raudradhyAnanAmaka dhyAna dezAvirata aura aviratako hotA hai. aura yaha bAta donoMhI phirakevAle apane apane tattvArthasUtra meM darja karate haiM, to phira dharmadhyAna kisa guNasthAnavAlekoM hotA hai isakA nirdeza kyoM nahIM karanA ? sababa sApha hojAtA hai ki asala meM dharmadhyAna ke viSaya meM apramattasaMyatakA nirdeza sUtrakArane kiyA thA, jisako digambaroMne uDA diyA hai. 2 . yaha bAta to dharmadhyAnake lakSaNavAle sUtrake vibhAgake viSaya meM huI, Age ke liye yaha socanekA hai ki avirataAdiko to dhyAna dikhAye, lekina usase Age baDhe hue upazAnta-kaSAya, kSINakaSAyakA kauna dhyAna hove ? usakA to jikra idhara hai nahIM isI sababa se mAnanA hogA ki sUtrakArane 'upazAntakSINakaSAyayozca' yaha sUtra jarUra banAyA hai. eka bAta aura bhI gaura karane ke kAbila hai ki vAcakajImahArAjane Arttaraudra ke svAmI dikhAneke vakta aviratAdiko dikhAke guNasthAnake hisAba se svAmI dikhAyA to phira apramatta mAtrako dharmadhyAnake adhikArI dikhAve aura zeSaupazAntAdikako na dikhAve yaha kaise ho ? L sUtrakArane yaha sUtra idhara jarUra banAyA hai isakA eka aura bhI pUrNataH sabUta hai. vaha yaha hai ki yadi idhara yaha 'upazAnta : For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #90
( 79 ) . . . kSINakaSAyayozca sUtra nahIM hotA to 'zukle cA0' isa sUtrameM cakAra dharanekI kyA jarUrata thI? itanAhI nahIM, lekina haraeka dhyAnake adhikArameM peztara usakA bheda dikhAkara bAdahI usa dhyAnake mAlika dikhAye jAte haiM. jaisA khuda idharahI AtadhyAna, raudradhyAnameM bheda dikhAkara bAda meM dhyAtA dikhAyA. aisA donoM phirakekA sUtrapATha kaha rahA hai, to phira idhara zukladhyAnake bhedoMko dikhAye binA hI kauna kauna kisa kisa bhedake dhyAnevAle haiM yaha dikhAne kI kyA jarUrata thI ? isase vivaza hokara mAnanA paDegA ki dharmadhyAnako dhyAnevAlI koI vyaktikA idhara peztarake sUtra meM nirdeza thA. aura ve vyaktiyAM dUsare dhyAnako bhI dhyAnevAlI hai, ve dUsarI koI nahIM, kintu upazAntamoha aura kSINamoha ye donoM haiM. yAne matalaba yaha huA ki kitaneka upazAntakSINamohavAle dharmadhyAnavAle hote haiM aura kitaneka zukladhyAnavAle bhI hote haiM. aura isI bAtakA dikhAneke liye 'zukle cAye' isa sUtra meM sUtrakArane samuccayavAcaka 'ca' kA prayoga kiyA hai. idhara cakArakA prayoga to donoM bhI maMjUra karate haiM. kabhI digambaroMkI taraphase aisA kahA~ jAya ki idhara samuccayavAcaka cakAra hai lekina isase upazAntakSINamohakA samuccaya nahIM karanA hai, kintu peztaraM kahA huAM dharmadhyAna aura Age dikhAeMge aise. zukladhyAnake bhedadvaya ye saba pUrvake jAnakArako hote haiM. isa arthako dikhAneke lie For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #91
( 80 ) kArakA prayoga hai. aisA artha karanese na to cakAra bekAma hogA aura na bheda kahane ke peztara dhyAtA dikhAyA usakI harja hogA. isa tarahase digambaroMkA kathana hove to yaha kathana sampha galata hai. sababa ki unhoMke kathanAnusAra artha kareM to apramattase lagAkara kSINamoha taka ke jIvoMko kauna dhyAna hogA? isakA to khulAsA raha gayA / yaha bAta to digambaroM ko bhI maMjUra hI hai ki saba koI apramattase lagAkara upazAntakSINamohavAle jIva pUrvasambandhI zrutakA jJAna pAnevAle hote haiM, aisA niyama nahIM hai. itanAhI nahIM, lekina digambaraloga varttamAnakAla meM bhagavAnakA kahA huA koI bhI sUtra nahIM hai aisA mAnate haiM, to kyA sUtracyuccheda mAnA tabase lagAkara lagAtAra pAMcaveM ArekI samApti taka ke tyAgI muniyoMko bhI ye digambara loga ataraudra dhyAnavAle mAneMge ? merA khayAla hai ki ye loga kabhI yaha bAta maMjUra nahIM kareMge, taba jabarana mAnanA hogA ki digaM vane 'upazAntakSINakaSAyayova' yaha sUtra ur3A diyA hai. aba yaha socanekA hai ki 'zukle cAdye' aura 'pUrvavidraH' ye donoM alaga alaga sUtra hoMge ki eka hI sUtra hogA isa viSaya meM asala nirNaya to sUtrakAra mahArAja hI kaha sakte haiM, yaha bAta haiM, lekina asala hakIkatako socanese apane bhI nirNaya kara sakate haiM. avvala to yaha socanA cAhiye ki do sUtra alama karanese kyA artha hotA hai ? aura kyA artha '. : + For Personal & Private Use Only k

Page #92
( 81 ) . hotA hai ? socane se mAlUma ho jAyagA ki yadi idhara eka hI sUtra rakhA jAya to aisA artha hogA ki upazAntamoha aura kSINamohako dharmadhyAna hotA hai aura yadi ve upazAntamoha aura kSINamoha pUrvazrutako dhAraNa karanevAle hoveM to unhoMko zukladhyAnake Adike do dhyAna hote haiM, yAne upazAntakaSAya aura kSINakaSAya jIva bhI pUrvake zrutake dhAraNa karanevAle na hoM to unako na zukladhyAna hove. idhara yaha bAta to donoM phirakevAloMko mAnya hI hai ki zukladhyAnake peztara do bhedakA dhyAna hone bAda hI kevalajJAna hotA hai. yAne dhyAnAntarikAmeM hI kevalajJAna honA donoM maMjUra karate haiM. yaha bhI bAta donoM maMjUra hI karate haiM ki sAmAnyase aSTapravacanamAtAko jAnanevAle tyAgI bhI kevalajJAnako pA sakte haiM. aba ina bAtoMko samajhanevAle faurana nizcaya kara sakeMge ki ye sUtra alaga hI hone cAhiye. yAne donoM sUtra alaga karanese aisA artha hogA ki upazAntamoha aura kSINa mohako dharmadhyAna bhI hotA hai aura antimabhAgameM zukladhyAnake bhI Adike do bheda hote haiM, aura yadi pUrvazrutake dhAraNa karanevAle aura bhI yAne upazAntamoha aura kSINamohake sivAya ke apramattasaMyatAdi hoveM unako bhI zukladhyAnake Adi ke do bheda ho sakate haiM. aba isa tarahase artha hone meM kisI bhI tarahakA mantavya kA virodha na hogA. isa sabase mAnanA cAhiye ki ina donoM sUtroMko zrImAnumA For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #93
(82) svAtivAcakajIne alagahI banAye haiM, aura jaba aisA nizcaya hogA to jarUra mAnanA hogA ki-digambageMne hI ghoTAlA karake ina donoM sUtroMkoM ikaTThA karake ekahI sUtra banA diyA hai: bhAgya hai jagajjIvoMkA ki ina digambaroMne bhagavAnake bhASita sUtra maMjUra nahIM rakhe haiM. anyathA eka dosau zlokake tatvArthasUtra meM itanA ghoTAlA digambaroMne kara diyA hai to phira ve loga sUtrako maMjUra karate taba to baDe baDe sUtroMmeM kyA kyA ghoTAlA nahIM kara dete ? __(25) dasaveM adhyAyameM zvetAmbaraloga 'mohakSayA jJAnadarzanAvaraNAMtarAyakSayAcca kevalaM' 'bandhahetvabhAvanirjarAbhyAM' aura 'kRtsnakarmakSayo mokSaH' isa tarahase tIna sUtra mAnate haiM. tava digambaraloga 'mohakSayAj jJAnadarzanAvaraNAntarAyakSayAca kaivalaM' 'bandhahetvabhAvanirjarAbhyAM kRtsnakarmavipramokSo mokSaH' isa tarahase do sUtra mAnate haiM. aba vAstavameM idhara tIna sUtra haiM ki do sUtra haiM isakA nirNaya karanA jarUrI hai. yadyapi idhara do sUtra mAne yA tIna sUtra mAne, lekina eka bhI bAtakA ina donoM phirakoM meM pharka nahIM hai jitanI bAbata zvetAmbara mAnate haiM utanI hI digambara mAnate haiM, lekina zvetAmbaroMke hisAbase yaha rivAja hai ki sUtrabheda kare, yA sUtra aura akSara bheda nahIM karate bhI arthako bheda kare to prAyazcittApatti kama nahIM hai. astu. lekina idhara bheda kisakI taraphase huA ? tIna sUtra For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #94
( 83 ) karanevAlekI taraphase yaha bheda huA hai ki do sUtra karanevAle digambaroM kI taraphase yaha bheda huA hai|, digambaroMke hisAbase soceM taba to samagra karmakA vinAza hove usImeM bandhahetukA abhAva aura nirjarA ye donoM kAraNa hote haiM. yAne moha jJAnAvaraNa darzanAvaraNa aura aMtarAyake kSayake kAraNameM bandhahetukA abhAva aura nirjarA samAviSTa nahIM kiye haiM, kyoMki digambaroMne 'bandhahetvabhAvanirjarAbhyAM' isa vAkyako na to svatantra sUtrake rUpameM rakhA hai aura na 'mohakSayAta.' ityAdisUtra meM lagAyA hai. yAne samagrakarmake kSayarUpa mokSako pratipAdana karanevAle sUtrameM milA diyA hai. yadi aisI zaMkA hogI ki jaise digabaroMke hisAbase baMdhahetuke abhAvAdi kAraNa mokSake sAtha lageMge aura mohakSayAdike sAtha nahIM lageMge, vaisehI zvetAmbaroMke hisAbase bhI bandhuhetuke abhAvAdi kAraNa kevala mohakSayAdike sAtha hI lageMge, lekina mokSake sAtha nahIM lageMgeM. parantu yaha zaMkA karanA lAjima nahIM hai. kAraNa ki asala meM to donoM hI -phirakevAle yaha maMjUra karate hI haiM ki saMsArakI asalI jaDa cAraghAtikarma aura usameM bhI asala meM mohanIyakarma hI hai, aura mohanIyAdikake kSayameM bandhahetukA abhAva aura nirjarArUpa kAraNa dikhAnekI jarUrata hai, dUsarI bAta yaha bhI hai ki kisI bhI karmakI sthiti bAMdhanA hove to usameM mohanIyakI hI jarUrata hai, aura mohanIyakA abhAva hojAnese kisI bhI For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #95
( 84 ) karmakA sthitibandha hotA hI nahIM hai. isase mohAdikakA kSaya hone bAda vedanIyAdi aghAti ke kSayameM kucha vaise hetukI jarUrata nahIM rahegI. itanA hone para bhI zvetAmbaroM kI mAnyatA ke anusAra to mohAdikSayameM aura kRtsnakarmake kSayameM donoMmeM bhI bandhahetukA abhAva aura nirjarA yaha hetu ho sakegA. sabaMba ki' bandhahetvabhAvao' "yaha alaga sUtra bIca meM rakkhA hai. aura alaga bIca meM sUtra honese dehalI dIpaka Adi nyAyase donoM ora lagegA yAne mohAdikSaya se kevalajJAna hotA hai, lekina mohAdikA kSaya to bandhake hetuoMkA abhAva honese aura nirjarA honese hI hotA hai, yaha bhI artha hogA. . donoM phirakevAloMko yaha bAta to maMjura hI hai ki kevalajJAna pAnevAleko dazaveM guNaThANese peztara hI mohakA bandha nAza pAtA hai aura dazaveM guNaThANameM sattA meM rahA huA bhI mohanIya karma nAza pA jAtA hai, isI tarahase dazameM guNasthAnakI Akhira hote jJAnAvaraNAdike bandhakI dazAkA bhI aMta hotA hai, aura bArahaveM guNasthAna meM zeSa sattA meM rahe hue jJAnAvaraNAdighAtikarma kI sattA bhI nirmUla hotI hai. isase mohAdikSaya meM hI yaha lagAnA lAjima hai. samagrakarmakSayarUpa mokSa ke liye to kevalajJAna hone bAda sAtavedanIyase zeSa aghAtiyA ghAtikarma ke bandhakA koI sababahI nahIM hai, aura vedanIya Ayu nAma aura gotrakI nirjarA huI hai. lokaM isase ghAti aghAti donoMke sAtha bandha * For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #96
(85) hetukA abhAva aura nirjarArUpa hetuko lagA sakeMge lakina kaivalyahonemeM jitane pratibandhaka haiM una sabakA bandhahetukA abhAva aura una kamoMkA nirjaraNa kevalajJAnake pUrva anantara kAlameM rahatA hai. samaprakarmakA abhAvarUpa mokSa honemeM samagrakarmake bandhahetukA abhAva to aura aura guNasthAnake kAla meM hai aura samaprakarmakA nirjaraNa bhI aura aura guNasthAnakoMmeM haiM. yAne mokSa honeke anaMntara pazcAtkAlameM na to samagrakarmake bandhahetu the, aura na samagrakIkI nirjarA bhI anantara pazcAtkAlameM hotI hai. isIse zvetAmbara loga isa 'bandhahetvabhAva.' sUtrako donoM meM yAne kevalajJAnake kAraNa mohAdikake kSayameM aura sakalakarma mokSameM laga sakane para bhI lagAte nahIM haiM sirpha peztara sUtra meM kahe hue kevala. jJAna ke kAraNarUpa mohAdikake kSayameM hI hetupanase lagAte haiM. aura yahI yuktiyukta honese mokSake sUtrameM usako zAmila karanA yaha digambaroMkA bhavabhayanirapekSatAse bharA huA anyAya hai| ... (26 ) dazaveM adhyAya meM mokSake lakSaNake bAda digambaroM ne sUtra aise mAne haiM ki 'aupazamikAdibhavyatvAnAM ca' 'anyatra kevalasamyaktvajJAnadarzanasiddhatvebhyaH' yAne ina donoM bhAgake do sUtra mAne haiM. vetAmbaroMne isa sthAnameM 'aupazAmakAdibhavyatvAbhAvAccAnyatra kevalasamyaktvajJAnadarzanasiddhatvebhyaH' aisA ekahI sUtra mAnA hai. isa sthAnameM bhI yahI socanekA hai ki digambaroMne asalake ekasUtrake do satra kine yA For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #97
( 86 ) zvetAmbaroMne do sUtra alaga alaga the unako milAkara eka karaM diyA ?, akalamaMda AdamI samajha sakatA hai ki idhara asala alaga alaga sUtra hogA hI nahIM. aura yaha socanA jarUrI hai ki sUtrakAra 'anyatra' zabda karake jo apavAda batAte haiM vaha ekasUtra hotA hai tabhI hotA hai alaga 2 sUtra hote taba to eka nakArase hI apavAda dikhA sakate the. sUtrakArakI zailI - bhI yahI hai. dekhiye ( 337 ) 'bharatairAvatavidehAH karmabhUmayoanyatra devakurUttarakurubhyaH' isa tIsare adhyAya ke sUtrameM bharatAdikakSetroMkA karmabhUmipanakA vidhAna karate devakuru AdimI mahAvidehAMtargata honese karmabhUmi ho jAte the, isase idhara 'anyatra ' aisA kahakara devakuruAdiko varjita kiyA hai. isI taraha se idhara bhI sApha samajhane kA haiM, yAne aupazamikAdikabhAvakA sarvathA abhAva kaha dene meM kevalasamyaktvajJAnAdikakA abhAva bhI hojAtA thA isase sUtrakAramahArAjane 'anyatra kevala' ityAdi kahakara una samyaktvAdikakA jo abhAva hotA thA vaha roka diyA yaha rivAja idhara tattvArthakAra mahArAjane hI rakkhA hai, aisA nahIM hai, kintu vaiyAkaraNAcAryoMne bhI yahI rivAja rakhA hai. aura isIse hI una vaiyAkaraNAcAryoMne 'saMpradAnAccAnyatraNAdayaH' ityAdi sUtra ikaTThe hI kiye haiM, yAne ina donoM bhAgoM ko alaga alaga karake do sUtra banAnA yaha ucita hI nahIM hai: kitaneka to itanA taka kahanevAle mileMge ki jaba For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #98
pezarake sUtrase aupazamikAdika sarvabhAvakA niSedha hogayA to pIche dUsare sUtra meM 'anyatra' Adi kahanese kyA hogA ? yAne devadattakA maraNa hojAne bAda usake mAranevAleko mAra deM to kyA devadatta jindA ho jAyagA ? devadattake jindA rahate ho. mAranevAlA mArA jAya to devadatta baca saktA hai. isI tarahase idhara bhI AdyasUtrase aupazamikAdikabhAvoMkA niSedha kara diyA to phira dUsare 'anyatra.' isa sUtrase kyA hogA ? yAMne na to aise sthAna meM do sUtra karanekA ina AcAryabhagavAnakA niyama hai, aura anyaAcArya bhI aise alaga sUtra nahIM karate haiM. aura niSedha karake phira dUsare sUtrase anyatra kahakara rukanekI yogyatA bhI nahIM hai. isase idhara do sUtra alaga karanA lAjima hI nahIM thA aba ye sUtra alaga karane yogya nahIM the itanAhI nahIM, lokina alaga karane meM digambaroMko kitanA haraja hotA hai vaha dekhiye. digambaroMne 'aupazamikAdibhavyatvAnAM ca aisA sUtra banAyA hai isa sUtrameM SaSThIkA anvaya kahAM karanA usakA patA hI nahIM hai. yadi kahA jAya ki isake peztarake 'kRtsnakarmavipramokSo mokSa: isa sUtra meM vipramokSa zabda hai usa kI anuvRtti kareMge aura usase yaha artha hogA ki aupazami kAdika bhAvoMkA bhI vipramokSa hojAnA usakA nAma mokSa hai. lekina yaha kahanA niyamase viruddha hai, kyoMki vipramokSa zabda jo he vaha kRtsnakarmake sAtha samAsase lagA huA hai, aura For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #99
(88 ) samastapadakI anuvRtti nahIM ho sakatI hai. kyoMki 'saniyogaH ziSTAnAM sahaiva pravRttiH sahaiva nivRttiH' yAne ekapadase kahe hue padArthakI sAthahI pravRtti hotI hai. aura sAthahI nivRtti hotI hai, to idhara akele vipramokSapadakA anuvartana kaise hogA ? eka bAta aura bhI socane kI hai ki karmakA nAza karane ke liye prayatna kiyA gayA thA aura usase sakalakarmakA vipramokSa huA, isa tarahase kyA aupazamikAdikabhAvoMke nAzake liye prayatna karanekA hai ?; kahanA hogA ki aupazamikAdika jo bhAva haiM vaha karmoMkI taraha heya aura prayatna karake kSaya karane yogya nahIM hai. to phira idhara vipramokSazabdakI anuvRtti kaise hogI ?.. ... dasarA yaha bhI hai ki jaba bhavyazabdake Age svarUpakoM sacita karanevAlA tvapratyaya tumane lagAyA to phira bahuvacana kaise lagAyA ? yAne 'bhavyatva' hI kahanA lAjima thA. sAthameM yaha bhI socanekA hai ki aupazamikAdibhAvoMkA sarvathA viccheda lenA hove tabhI 'anyatra' kahakara apavAdakI jarUrata hai. kitaneka bhAvoMkA vyuccheda kahanA hove to 'anyatra' karake apavAda dikhAnekI jarUrata hI nahIM hai yAne matalaba yaha hai ki jaba taka saMsArasamudrame pAra na pAye aura mokSa na huA taba taka aupazamikAdika pAMca bhAva jo dUsare adhyAyameM kahe haiM unhoMkA yathAyogyatAse sadbhAva hotA hai. lekina mokSa honeke vakta una pAMcoMmeMse sirpha kevalasamyaktvAdika hI bhAva raha For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #100
kara aura bhAva saba nivRtta hojAte haiM. isa bAtako samajhanevAle manuSya acchI tarahase samajha sakeMge ki zvetAmbaseMne jo 'aupazAmikAdibhavyatvAbhAvAccAnyatraH' ityAdi eka hI bana rakha hai yahI lAjima hai, aura zrIumAsvAtimahArAjakA kiyA huA bhI aisA hI sUtra honA cAhiye. isa sUtra meM paMcamI vibhakisa nirdeza hai aura vahI yukta hai. sababa ki aupazamikAdibhavyatva ke abhAvase mokSa hotA hai, to usako hetu mAnanA aura usase mokSa honA yogya hogA. lokana yadi 'bhavyatvAnAM ca aisA karake SaSThIvibhakti mAne aura unake vipramokSako mokSa mAne ko auSazamikAdikabhAva mokSake samakAlIna bana jAyamA. aura vaha to kisI bhI tarahase iSTa nahIM hogA. isa sthAnameM zaMkA jarUra hogI ki aupazamikAdike aura bhavyatvake abhAvakI kyA jarUrata hai , kyoMki jJAnAvaraNAdika to bAnamAlikoM rokanevAle honese unakA abhAva honA jarUrI hai. lekina aupazAmikAdika aura bhanyatva kisako sekanevAle haiM ki jisaH se unakA abhAva mokSakA sAdhana mAnA jAya?, isake samAdhAna meM samajhanekA yaha hai ki aupazamikAdibhAva karmake upazamakSayopazamAdise hote haiM, aura mokSa honeke vakta bo jIva-sarvana pratibaMdhakase mukta haiM, isase muktajIvoMko se vAdhika hI mAra hotA hai. aura unameM bhI dAnAdikakI jo ki ko sAbale bhI hone vAle hai kI-mAti nahIM hotI For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #101
/ 90 ) isase kevalasamyaktvAdikake sivAya saba aupamikAdikakA abhAva honA vaha mokSakA sababa dikhAyA. idhara bhavyatvakA abhAva dikhAyA usakA sababa yaha hai ki bhavyatva jo hai vaha kAraNadazA yAne mokSapAnekI yogyatAkA nAma hai, aura mokSarUpa kArya jaba hogayA to aba kAraNadazA na rahI isase usa bhavyatvakAbhAva kahanA hI hogA jagatmeM bhI vRkSa yA skandhake vakta aMkuradazA nahIM rahatI hai. usI tarahase idhara bhI mokSake vakta bhanyatva na rahe yaha svAbhAvika hai. aura isIse hI idhara bhavyatvapanakA abhAva bhI mokSakA hetu mAnA hai. jIvapaNarUpa pAriNAmikamAva ThaharanekA honese bhavyatvakA abhAva spaSTazabdase dikhAyA, yaha to svAbhAvika hI hai| ... (27) dazaveM adhyAyameM hI pUrvaprayogAdasaMgatvA.' ityAdi sUtrake Age digambaroMne 'AviddhakulAlacakravad vyapagatalepAlAbuvaderaNDabIjavadagnizikhAvacca' aisA sUtra mAnA hai. zvetAmbara loga isa sUtrako maMjUra nahIM karate haiM. zvetAmbaroMkA kathana aisA hai ki AcAryamahArAja sarIkhe saMgrahakAra apane banAye hue sUtra meM dRSTAntakA sUtra banAveM yaha asaMbhakti hI hai. yadi dRSTAnta denA aura dRSTAntase padArthakI siddhi karanI iSTa hotI to peztara pramANake adhikArameM hetudRSTAntAdi kahate, upamAna aura AgamapramANakA bhI svarUpa kahakara dRSTAntake sAtha nirUpaNa karate. kucha nahIM to dharmAstikAyAdikake nirUpaNa For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #102
( 91) meM to dRSTAntAdi jarUra dikhAte. lokan kisI bhI sthAnameM dRSTAnta dikhAyA nahIM hai. to idhara atyantasugamasthAnameM dRSTAnta dikhAnA yaha sUtrakAramahArAjako kaisa ucita hove ? idhara akSapAdAdi sUtrakAra bhI apane kiye hue sUtroMmeM isa tarahase dRSTAnta nahIM dikhAte haiM to phira idhara saMgrahakAra hokara dRSTAnta dikhAne ke lie sUtra kaheM yaha kaise saMbhavita ho sakatA hai ? yadyapi dUsare sUtrakAra dRSTAntabalase yAne bahiyAptise padArthakI siddhiko mAnanevAle honese dRSTAntakA sUtra kahabhI sakta haiM, tathApi ve loga sUtraracanAke vakta dRSTAntako mukhya pada nahIM dete haiM, to phira jainAcArya jo antayAptise hI yAne anyathA'nupapattise hI sAdhyakI siddhi mAnane vAle hokara aise laghugranthameM dRSTAntAdikako DAleM yaha kaise saMbhavita ho sakatA hai ?, mAna liyA jAya ki mokSakI sthiti atyanta upAdeya honese usakI siddhike liye dRSTAntAdi jarUra jatAnA cAhiye to phira 'pUrvaprayogA' ityAdisUtra meM hI dRSTAnta kaha denA lAjima hove, yAne 'kulAlavakravatpUrvaprayogAdalAbuvadasaMgatvAderaNDavIjavadandhacchedAdagnizikhAMvattathAgatipariNAmAcca tadgatiH' aisA hI kahanA lAjima thA. kyoMki dRSTAntakA sUtra alaga karanese sabhI hetu arthAntarase dubArA kahanA par3A hai. saMgrahake hisAbase bAra bAra vatpratyaya aura bAra bAra paMcamIkA kathana karake hetukA prayoga dikhAnekA bhI For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #103
. . nahIM thA, kintu 'pUrvaprayogAsaMmatvabaMdhacchedatathAgatipariNAzvakAlAbveraNDAgnizikhAvad' itanA hI kahanA lAjima thA. 'kyoMki yathAsaMkhyapanase hetudRSTAntokA samanvaya aura sopaskAra hI sUtra honeke niyamase yathArtha vyAkhyA ho jAtI. - isa sthAnameM zvetAmbaroMke hisAbase 'pUrvaprayogAdityAdi maiM haraeka pada para paMcamIkA prayoga kyoM kiyA gayA hai ? yaha 'bhI socanekA hI hai. ve zvetAmbaraloga usa sUtra meM AkhirameM "tagatiH aisA pada mAnate haiM. aura usakI hayAtI honekI 'jarUrata yoM mAnate haiM ki Ageke yAne caturthasUtrameM 'gacchatyAlokAntAt' isa sthAnameM gatikA adhikAra AgayA hai aura para bhI gati hI pUrvaprayogAdikase siddha karanI hai to phira 'tanatiH' yaha pada lenekI kucha jarUrata nahIM thI. lekina idhara jI tahatiH' pada sUtrakArane liyA hai isakA mAyanA yaha hai ki siddhamahArAjakI karmakSaya honese acintyapanase gati hotI hai, aura usa gatike saghavako apana nahIM jAna sakate haiM tathApi yaha samAdhAna zraddhAnusAri sajjanoMke liye hI upayogI hogA, lekina tarkAnusAriyoM ke liye sababa dikhAnekI jarUrata hai aisA mAnakara yaha sUtra banAyA hai. aura idhara tAnusArIke liye hetu dikhAneko sabhI hetu alaga alaga dikhAye haiM. kyoMki koI kisa hetuse samajhe aura koI kisa hetuse samajhe, isIse hI to ekahatuke prayoga para dUsare Adi hetu karane para bhI dUSaNa For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #104
( 93 ) . nahIM hotA hai, anyathA ekahetuse sAdhyakI siddhi hone para anyahetuoMkA prayoga karanA nyAyazAstra se viruddha hai, asala meM to yaha gati acintyasvabhAvakI sthitise hI hai, anyathA adholaukikagrAmoMse siddhi pAnevAle meM aura UrdhvalokameM siddhi pAnebAle meM pUrva prayogAdikA tAratamya mAnanA hogA, jo ki kisI tarahase iSTa nahIM hai. isI kAraNa se to peztara ke sUtra meM 'gacchati' aisA prayoga rakkhA hai, aura idhara 'tadgatiH yaha alaga pada rakkhA hai itanAhI nahIM, balki peztarake sUtra meM 'AlokAntAt, aisA pada lagAkara sUtrakArane siddhamahArAjakI gatikA viSaya zAstrakI apekSAse vahAM hI khatama kiyA hai, anyathA cauthA - sUtra alaga nahIM karate. donoM sUtra ekatra karake 'tadanantaramAko kAntAdUrdhvaM pUrvaprayogAdimyo gatiH' itanA hI kahanA basa hotA, aura dAkhalA bhI denA hotA to 'cakrAdivat, itanA jyAdA lagA dete. lekina sUtrakAramahArAjane adhikAribheda se alaga alaga sUtra kiye haiM. isI tarahase prathamAdhyAyameM bhI sUtrakAramahArAjane 'nirdezasvAmitva 0 ' sUtra aura 'satsaMkhyA ' 0 ye sUtra alaga 2 kiye aura zraddhAnusAri va tarkAnusAriko aisA karake hI samajhAye haiM, yAne idhara tarkAnusArike liye alaga sUtra kiyA aura gatikI siddhi kI, isase 'taGgatiH' pada dharanekI jarUrata hai. aisA bhI nahIM kahanA ki jaba tarkAnusAriyoMke liye siddhamahArAjakI gatikI siddhi ke liye hetukI jarUrata zrI to For Personal & Private Use Only "

Page #105
(94) hetu dikhA diye, lokana 'tadgatiH' isa padase kyA phAyadA hai ? isakA samAdhAna yaha hai ki pahile 'gacchati' aisA pada dharA hai vaha to yathAvasthitasvarUpa vyAkhyAnake liye hai aura siddhoMkI gati sunane bAda zaMkA hoveke una siddhamahArAjako na to koI siddhakSetrameM lejAnevAlA hai, aura na koI karmakA udaya hai, na idharase pheMkanevAlA yA bhejanevAlA hai, to phira unakI gati kisa sababase hotI hai ? aisI zaMkAke samAdhAna ke liye ina hetuoMkA kathana karanA aura 'tadgatiH' yaha pada kahanA lAjima hI hai. aisI bhI zaMkA nahIM karanA ki jaba tarkAnusAriyoMke liye hetuoMkA kahanA aura 'tadgati' pada dharanA lAjima hai to phira unake liye hI dRSTAnta kahanA kyoM jarUrI na hogA ? kyoMki 'sakaSAyatvAt ' sUtra meM jaise hetu kahane para bhI dRSTAnta . nahIM liyA isI taraha idhara bhI dRSTAnta nahIM liyA hai. - (28) dazaveM hI adhyAyameM digambaraloga 'AviddhakulAlacakravadityAdi' sUtrake bAda 'dharmAstikAyAbhAvAt' aisA sUtra mAnate haiM. yaha sUtra digambaroMne kisa rItise DAla diyA isakA patA nahIM hai sababa ki peztarake 'pUrvaprayogA0' aura 'AviddhakulAlacakra0' ityAdi ina do sUtroMse siddhamahArAja kI lokAnta taka Urdhvagati honekA hetu aura dRSTAnta dikhAyAhai. aura usa gatimeM yadi hetu liyA jAya taba to yahI kahanA hove ki 'tAvaddharmAstikAyAt' yAne lokAnta taka hI dharmA For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #106
( 95 ) stikAya hai. isase siddhamahArAjakI gati lokAnta taka hI Urdhvama hove. lekina idhara to digambaroMne sUtra ulaTA dhara diyA hai yAne hetumeM kahA ki dharmAstikAyakA abhAva hai. to kyA dharmAstikAyake abhAvase siddhoMkI UrdhvameM lokAnta taka 'gati hotI hai aisA mAnate haiM ? kabhI aisA mAnanA nahIM hogA. Age hI pAMcaveM adhyAyameM sApha 2 kahA hai ki 'gatisthityupagraho dharmAdharmayorupakAraH' yAne jIva aura pudgaloMkI gatimeM dharmAstikAya hI sahArA detA hai aura una donoMkI sthitimeM adharmAstikAya sahArA detA hai. jaba yaha bAta nizcita hai to phira dharmAstikAyake abhAvase siddhoMkI gati hai aisA kaise kaha sakeMge? kabhI mAna liyA jAya ki saMsArIjIvoMkI gatimeM dharmAstikAya kAraNa hai. parantu siddhamahArAjakI gatike liye dharmAstikAyako hetu mAnanekI jarUrata nahIM hai. lekina aisA koI bhI phirakevAlA mAnatA nahIM hai. yadi aisA mAna liyA jAya aura isIse hI siddhamahArAjakI gatimeM dharmAstikAyake abhAvako hetu mAna liyA jAya to peztara to. khuda sarakArane kahI huI lokAntatakakI Urdhva gati hI nahIM rahegI. sababa vaha hai ki lokAnta takake sarva sthAnameM dharmAstikAya vyApta hI hai. sUtrakAramahArAjaneM bhI 'lokAkAzevagAha' 'dharmAdharmayoH kRtsne' .yaha kahakara samagralokameM dharmAstikAyakA honA maMjUra kiyA hai. to phira lokAnta taka bhI muktoMkI gati kaise hogI? For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #107
isa saba jhaMjhaTase chUTane ke liye eka hI rAstA hai aura vaha yahe hai ki dharmAstikAyakA abhAvarUpa hetu siddhamahArAjakI gatimeM nahIM rakhanA. kyoMki dharmAstikAyakA amAva to sarvaalokameM hai aura dharmAstikAyake abhAvase siddhamahArAjakI gati mAneM to unhoMkI gati maba alokameM hove, aura alokAkAMzakA anta hI nahIM hai. jisase siddhamahArAjakI haradama gati hotI hI rahe. isa hetuse siddhamahArAjakI gatimeM dharmAstikAyake abhAvako kAraNa nahIM mAnanAhI lAjima hai, kintu lokAntase Age dharmAstikAyakA abhAva honese lokAntase Age siddhamahArAjoMkI gati nahIM hai, aisA dikhAneke liye yaha sUtra hai. yAne dharmAstikAyakA abhAva honese siddhakI Age gati nahIM hotI hai. yadyapi isa tarahase digambaroMkA mAnanA lAjima ho jAve, lekina sUtra isa bAtako anukUla nahIM ginatA hai, kyoMki isasUtrameM siddhamahArAjakI gatikA adhikAra hai kintu alokameM siddhagatike abhAvako sUcita karanevAlA zabda bhI nahIM hai. kamI zvetAmbaroMne 'tadgatiH' aisA pada 'pUrvaprayogA' sUtra meM rakkhA hai aura udhara 'sad' zabda jaisA sarvanAma hai aura mina minna vibhaktise hI aura 2 arthako detA hai. usI tarahase 'tad' zabda avyaya bhI hai aura avyayase Age AI huI saba vibhaktiyAM uDa jAtI haiM, lekina ve uDI huI vibhaktiyAM apane arthako dikhAtI haiM isase artha karane meM 'tad' zabdako avyaya le leM to. siddhoMkA adhikAra to A For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #108
( 97 ) jAyagA. lekina gati honekI hI bAta rahegI yani gati nahIM honekI to bAta kisI bhI tarahase raha sake aisI nahIM hai. isa sababase sApha sabUta hotA hai ki kisI digambarane apanI akalakI nyUnatAse pUrNatayA soce binA hI yaha sUtra idhara baDhA diyA hai, zvetAmbaraloga to isa sUtrako maMjUra nahIM karate haiM. uparyukta 28 muddoMko socanevAle manuSyoM ko sApha sApha mAlUma ho jAyagA ki digambaroMne apanI badadyAnatase yA akalakI nyUnatAse eka choTese hI tatvArthasUtra meM kamabezIpanA karake svacchandatAkA rAjya jamAyA hai. jisa tarahase ina digambaroMne asalI sUtroMko uDAkara tathA naye sUtroMko DAlakara sUtramaya granthameM ghoTAlA, kiyA hai usI tarahase ina digambaroMne zrImAnumAsvAtikAcakajImahArAjake banAye hue isa tattvArthagraMthake sUtroMko bhI sthAna: sthAna para nyUnAdhika karake pUrA ghoTAlA kara diyA hai. yaha bAta vAcakoMko Ageke lekhase sApha mAlUma ho jaavegii| isa tattvArtha sarIkhe eka do sau zlokake granthameM digambaroMne sUtroMkA sarvathA baDhAnA aura ghaTAnA kitanA jabaradasta kara diyA hai| yaha bAta uparyukta bhAgase sAbita kara dI hai. aba inhIM digambaroMne isI tattvArthameM kauna 2 sUtroMke pAThameM nyUnAna dhikatA kI hai, yaha dikhalAyA jAtA hai, yadyapi inhoMne ke sthAnameM 'va' aura 'ta' ke sthAnameM 'da' apAyake sthAnameM bavAla For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #109
( 98 ) aura aupapAtikake sthAna meM aupapAdika Adi kI mAphika karake palaTA kiyA hai, lekina usa bAtako vyaMjanabheda karanA yaha jainamajahaba ke hisAba se baDA doSa hone para bhI gauNa karake idhara to jidhara vyaMjanabheda aura arthabheda donoM hove vaisA hI sthAna dikhAkara samAlocanA kI jAyagI / kA 1 prathama adhyAya meM ina logoMne 'dvividho'sUtrapAThIM vadhiH,' aisA sUtra nahIM mAnA, isI hI kAraNase viparyAsa unhoMne 'bhavapratyayo nArakadevAnAM', aise sUtrake * sthAna meM 'bhavapratyayosvadhirdevanArakANAM', aisA mAnA hai. yAne peztara avadhi ke bhedako dikhAnevAlA sUtra na mAnakara idhara avadhijJAnakA adhikAra na honese avadhikA adhikAra dikhAneko avadhizabda dAkhila kiyA. yadyapi avadhi ke adhikArako dikhAnekA sUtra na karake idhara avadhi - zabda kahane se avadhikA adhikAra AjAyagA. lekina Ageke sUtrameM avadhi adhikArako sUcita karaneke lie avadhizabda kahAMse AyegA ? do bhedako dikhAnevAlA sUtra mAna liyA taba to eka bheda bhavapratyayakA dikhAyA, bAdameM dUsarA sare satra se dikhAnA honese avadhizabdakI jarUrata dUsare meM hogI. lekina adhikArase hI avadhizabda A jAyagA. yadyarSi avadhipradakI anuSRtti idhara sUtrameM A For Personal & Private Use Only :

Page #110
( 99 ) sakatI hai, lekina sUtrakAra mahArAjakI zailI aisI hai ki anu. vRtti karane ke liye prayatna karanA. jaise dUsare adhyAyameM aupazamikake bhedakI saMkhyAmeM sabhyatva aura cAritra kahe aura pIche unako kSAyikake bhedameM bhI lenA thA to vahAM para anuvRttidikhAneke liye cazabdako dAkhila kiyA. idhara peztarake adhyAyameM hI 'matiH smRtiH0, isa sUtra meM matikA nirUpaNa karane para bhI Age matijJAna lenA thA to 'tadindriyAnindriyanimittaM' aisA sUtra kahakara tatzabdako dAkhila kiyA. isI. tarahase sAre tattvArthameM adhikAra aura anuvRtti ke liye cazabda yA tatazabda dAkhila kiye haiM to phira idhara isa sUtrameM dAkhala kiyA huA avadhizabda Age 'yathokta0' sUtra meM kisa taraha jAyagA? yaha to avadhi zabda idhara ghuseDanekA vicAra huA, lekina inhoMne 'nArakadevAnAM', aisA jo pATha isa satra meM thA vo bhI palaTA diyA aura 'devanArakANAM' aisA pATha kara diyA. sUtrakAramahArAjane adholoka, tiryagloka aura Uloka vaisA krama rakkhA hai. aura isIse hI sthAna nirUpaNameM peztara nAskI, pIche manuSya tiryaca aura pIche devakA nirUpaNa kiyA hai. aura Ayuke kAraNameM bhI nArakAdika anukrama rakkhA hai. AbukI prakRtiyoMkoM dikhAne meM bhI peztaraH nArakakI hI AyuprakRti dikhAI hai, to idhara 'nArakadevAnAM' aisA pada rakhanA yahI sUtrakArako abhimata honA cAhiye. For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #111
(100) (2) isI sUtrake Ageke sUtrameM zvetAmbara 'yathAkta nimittaH aisA pATha mAnate haiM. taba digambara loga 'kSayopazama. nimittaH' aisA mAnate haiM. ___ zvetAmbaroMkA kahanA hai ki Age dUsare adhyAyameM kSAyo pazamikake bhedoMmeM avadhijJAnako ginAyeMge isase idhara 'yathokta. nimitta' hI zanda kahanA ThIka hai. kyoMki yahAM para to apane apane karmake kSayopazamase matijJAnAdikakI utpatti isa prakaraNa meM nizcita hotI hai. kintu idhara kSayopazamazabda kahane se kisakA kSayopazama lenA yaha nizcita nahIM hogA. kyoMki matijJAnAdijJAna aura cakSudarzanAdi darzana aura dUsare bhI ajJAnAdika kSAyopazamika bhAvake haiM. aura ve bhI apane apane AvArakakarmake kSayopazmase hote haiM, to phira idhara kisakA kSayopazama lenA ?, yaha saMdigdhahI hogA. yAne kSayopazamakI sAtha itanA jarUra. kahanA hogA ki 'svAvArakakSayopazamanimittaH' aisA avadhimanuSya tiyaMcako hotA hai, iMdhara aisI zaMkA jarUra hogI ki karmakI prakRttike kSayopazamakA adhikAra abhI taka kahA hI nahIM hai, to phira idhara 'yathoktanimittaH' aisA kaise kaha sake ? lekina aisI zaMkA nahIM karanI cAhiye. isakA sababa yaha hai ki avvala to zAstrakAramahArAjane. jainazAstrake AdhArase hI grantha kiyA hai, isase zAstrakA adhikAra lekara 'yathoktanimittaH' aisA kaha sakate haiM.. vyAkaraNazAstrAdikakI taraha svatantra For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #112
( 101 ) saMjJAdi vidhAna karake zAstra nahIM banAyA hai, kintu jainazAstrakA eka bhAga saMgRhIta kiyA hai. isIse hI to jJAnAdi karmAdi lokAdi aupazamikAdi aneka padArthoMke idhara svarUpa nahIM kahe haiM. digambaroMkA yadi aisA kahanA hove ki zAstra meM kahe hue bayAnako khayAlameM rakhakara hI zAstrakArane 'kSayopazamanimittaH ' aisA kahA hai. lekina jaba zAstrakI apekSAse idhara kahanA taba to 'yathoktanimittaH' yahI kahanA ThIka hogA. kyoMki lAghava bhI isameM hai aura kSayopazamazabda ApekSika hone se avadhijJAnAvaraNako kahe binA kaise kSayopazamakI vyAkhyA hogI ?. ( 3 ) isI hI adhyAyameM matizrutajJAnake viSayakA jo sUtra matizrutayornibandhaH sarvadravyeSva sarva paryAyeSu' aisA thA. usameMse digambaroMne AdikA sarvazabda nikAla diyA aura 'matizrutayornibandho dravyeSvasarva paryAyeSu' aisA pATha kiyA. isa sthAna meM asala mattizrutajJAna se sabhI dravya jAne jAte haiM. yaha bAta to donoM ko bhI maMjUra hai, to phira sarvazabda nikAlane kI kyA jarUrata thI ?, digambaroMkA kabhI aisA kathana hove ki 'dravyeSu' itanA kahane se hI sarvadravya AjAyeMge isase 'dravyeSu' yA 'sarvadravyeSu' donoM meM se kucha bhI kahe usameM harja nahIM hai. lokana yadi aisA hI hove to phira kevalajJAnake viSayako For Personal & Private Use Only 1

Page #113
(102) dikhAnevAle sUtrameM 'sarvadravyaparyAyeSu' kyoM kahanA ? jaba udhara sarvadravya aura sarvaparyAyakA viSaya dikhAneke liye vahAM para sarvazabdako lenekI jarUrata hai to phira idhara sarvazabdako kyoM choDa denA ?, kabhI matizrutakA viSaya saba dravya hai. aisA nahIM mAneMge to idhara sarvazabdakI jarUrata nahIM rahatI hai to yaha mAnanA bhI vyartha hai. sababa ki aisA mAnane meM chabasthako mRSAvAdakI aura parigrahakI virati saMpUrNa nahIM hogI. kyoMki mRSAvAda aura parigraha saba dravya viSaya hai, isase idhara sarvazabda jarUra rahanA cAhiye. (4) dUsare adhyAyameM kSAyopazamika aTThAraha bheda dikhAte zvetAmbara 'jJAnAjJAnadarzanadAnAdilabdhayaH0' aisA pATha mAnate haiM. taba digambara loga 'jJAnAjJAnadarzanalabdhayaH0' aisA pATha mAnate haiM. aba idhara itanI bAta to sApha hai ki donoM phirakevAle AmauSadhiAdi aneka labdhiyAM mAnate haiM. yAne akelI dAnAdi pAMca hI labdhiyAM nahIM hai. jaba aisA hai to phira sirpha labdhizabda kahanese dAnAdikakI hI labdhi lenA yaha niyama kaise hogA ? sAre tatvArthasUtra meM kisI bhI sthAnameM ina dAnAdikako labdhi tarIke nahIM dikhAye haiM to phira idhara labdhi kahanese dAnAdika pAMca hI lenA yaha nizcaya kaise hogA? aura jaba aisA nizcaya hI nahIM hogA to phira labdhi zabdake sAtha paMcazabda kaise lagAyA jAyagA ? yaha zaMkA idhara For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #114
jarUra hogI ki peztarake sUtrameM kSAyikake navabheda dikhAte dAnAdika pAMca spaSTa dikhAye haiM. to idhara "dAnAdi' itanA hI nahIM kahate 'dAnAdilabdhayaH aisA zvetAmbaroMne kyoM kahA, lekina aisI zaMkA nahIM karanA. sababa ki kSAyopazamikabhAvaka dAnAdika pAMca pravRtti meM Ate haiM aura jagatameM vyavahAra meM bhI Ate haiM, isase usakA labdhi tarIke vyavahAra hotA hai aura kSAyikabhAvase honevAle dAnAdika pravRttirUpa hI hove vaisA nahIM hai, isI sababase paztara dAnAdikake sAtha labdhizabda nahIM lagAyA aura idhara kSAyopazamikabhedameM hI dAnAdikake sAtha labdhizabda lagAyA hai yaha samajha leveM. .... . (5) dUsare adhyAyameM hI audayikake ikkIsabhedoM meM zvetAmbaroMne 'mithyAdarzanAjJAnAsaMyatAsiddhatva'. aisA pATha mAnA hai. taba digambaroMne 'midhyAdarzanAjJAnAsaMyatAsiddha.' aisA pATha mAnA hai. yAne zvetAmbaroMne 'tva' pratyaya mAnakara asaMyatatva aura asiddhatva mAnA hai. digambaroMne tyapratyaya nahIM liyA hai, isase asaMyata aura asiddhako audayika mAnanA hogA, lekina vaha lAjima nahIM hogA, kyoMki asaMyata aura Asiddha aise to jIva AyeMge, aura jIva to audayikabhAvase nahIM hai. yadi bhAvapradhAna nirdeza mAnake idhara asaMyatatva aura asiddhatvako lenA hai to pIche 'tva' pratyaya hI kahanA kyA purA thA , aura tvapratyaya thA usako kyoM ur3A diyA zAstra For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #115
(104) kArane isI hI adhyAya meM bhavyatva0' meM tvapratyaya liyA hai aura daza adhyAyameM bhI 'bhavyatva' kahA hI hai, yAne zAsa. kAra tvapratyayako spaSTapaNese kahate hI haiM to pIche idhara kyoM na kaheMve ? dUsare adhyAyake pAriNAmikabhAvako dikhAnevAle sUtra meM zvetAmbaroM 'jIvabhavyAbhavyatvAdIni ca aisA sUtra mAnake Adizabdase asaMkhyAtAdipradezAdi lete haiM jaba digabaraloga 'jIvabhavyAbhavyatvAni ca' aisA mAnate haiM, yadyapi digaMbaraloga bhI bhavyatvAdikakI taraha asaMkhyapradezatvAdi mI pAriNAmiga hai aisA to mAnate haiM, lokana idhara AdizabdakA honA nahIM maMjUra karate haiM, idhara kabhI aisI zaMkA hove ke yadi ighara Adizabdase aura bheda lene haiM to pIche ve spaSTa hI kyoM nahIM kahe ? sUtrakArane uddezakI vakta bhI kyoM nahIM kiye, kahate samaya pAriNAmikake tIna hI bheda kyoM lie? lekina yaha zaMkA nahIM karanI, zaMkA nahIM karanekA sababa yaha hai ke asaMkhyapradezAdikabhAva pAriNAmika hone para bhI asAdhAraNa nahIM hai, isase spaSTazabdase nahIM dikhAye, aura bhedakI ginatImeM bhI nahIM liye. lokana unake liye idhara sUcanA bhI nahIM karanA yaha kaise ThIka hogA ? aMtameM se jIvake liye jIvatva anAdipAriNAmika hai usI tarahase ajIvakA az2Ivatva bhI pAriNAmika bhAva anAdi hai, usako bhI dikhAne ke liye AdizabdakI jarUrata thI.. . (6) isI dUsare adhyAyameM zvetAmbara 'pRthivyavanaspatayaH For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #116
sthAvarAH' aura 'tejovAyU dvIndriyAdagrazca trasA: isa tarahale asa aura sthAvarakA vibhAga karake pRthvIkAya, apakAyA aura vanaspatikAya ina tInako sthAvara aura teukAya, vAyukAya aura peiMdriyaAdiko sa mAnate haiM aura isIse hI Age indriyake sUtra meM 'vAyvantAnAmeka aisA sUtra mAnate haiN| yAne pRthvI kAyase lagAkara vAyukAya takake jIvoMko eka hI sparzanendriya hai, aisA zvetAmbaroMkA mantavya hai, jaba digambara loga 'pRthivyaptejovAyuvanaspatayaH sthAvarA" . 'dvIndrityAdayasamA aura 'vanaspatyantAnAmekaM aise kramase tIna sUtra usake sthAnameM mAnate haiM. asala meM ina donoM meM indriyake viSayameM to mantavya bheda nahIM hai, lekina trasasaMjJA kitanI kAyako hove aura sthAvarasaMjJA kitanI kAyako hove isameM donoMkA matabheda ho jAyagA. vyAkaraNake hisAbase socanese sApha mAlama hotA hai ki 'sthAnazIlAH sthAvarAH' yAne sthira hI rahe usakA nAma sthAvara aba pRthivIkAya apakAya aura vanaspatikAya sthira rahanevAle haiM, isase ina tInako hI sthAvara kahanA anucita na hogA. inameM yabapi nadIAdike pravAhAdi dikhanese yaha mAlama hogA ki apakAyako sthAvara. kaise kahA jAya aisIzaMkA hogI. lekina sthala ke nIcepanase jalakA.gamana hai, kintu svabhAvase gamana nahIM hai. aura dUsare kAraNoM se gamana hoke isa sthAvarapara nahIM miTatA hai. lekina anikAya aura vAyukAyakA ko For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #117
(106 ) apane svabhAva hI se calamarUpa gamana hotA hai. isase unako krsa kahane meM kyA harja hai? aisA nahIM kahanA ki sukhaduHkhakI icchAse hI hIlacAla kare usIkA hI nAma trasa kahA jAya. kyoMki aisA kahane se to trasareNuzabda se kyA lenA ? trasareNu to usI hI jaDa padArthakA nAma hai jo bArIka hokara pUrvApara vAyu Adi ke kAraNa se pazcima pUrva kI ora dhase. yaha saba kahanekA matalaba yaha hai ki anikAya aura vAyukAyako trasameM le 'sakte haiM. alavataH inako gatike kAraNa se trasa kaheMge, paraMtu sukhaduHkhake kAraNa se halacala nahIM honese labdhise sthAvara kahanA hogA. yAne jaise beindriyAdika labdhise trasa haiM aise ye labdhise trasa nahIM haiM, aura isI kAraNase to trasakAyake sUtra meM 'tasvArthakAra mahArAjane 'tejovAyU' yoM samAsa alaga karake ina donoMkA alaga svarUpa dikhAyA hai. kyoMki aisA kucha abhiprAya na hotA to 'tejovAyudvIndriyAdayastrasAH' aisA sUtra karate, jisase alaga vibhakti bhI nahIM rakhanI hotI aura cakArako bhI bar3hAnA nahIM paDatA. aisA nahIM kahanA ki zvetAmbaroMke kisI zAstrameM tejo aura vAyuko trasa tarIke nahIM gine haiM. kintu sthAnAMga bhagavatIjI paNNavaNAdizAstroMmeM pRthvyAdika pAMcoMko hI sthAvara gine haiM. aisA nahIM kahane kA yaha sababa hai ki jIvAbhigama aura AcArAMgaAdimeM teja aura vAyuko sthAvarameM nahIM ginate trasameM gine bhI haiM. tacvase to tejaHkAya For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #118
aura vAyukAya gatise trasa haiM aura labdhise sthAvara haiM. isase ina donoMko trasa aura sthAvarameM gine haiM. lekina idhara tarkAnusAriyoMke tarkakA khayAla karake donoM bAta dikhAnA zAstrakArake hisAbase lAjima hai.. . (7) sUtra 20meM digambaralogoMne sparzarasagandhavarNazabdAstadarthAH' aisA sUtra mAnA hai. aura zvetAmbaroMne sparzassagandharUpazabdAsteSAmarthaH' aisA mAnA hai, isameM tIna bAtakA pharaka hai. 1 varNa lenA ki rUpa lenA 2 tad lenA ki teSAM lenA aura 3 artha lenA ki arthAH lenA. yadyapi inameMse kisI bhI tarahase lene para tAtvika mantavyakA pharka nahIM hogA. lekina asala kyA honA cAhiye yaha socanekA hai. khayAla karanekA hai ki pAMcaveM adhyAyameM 'nityAvasthitAnyarUpINi' aura 'rUpizaH pudgalA:' lenA hai, paraMtu varNa nahIM lenA hai, ina sUtroMko donoM maMjUra karate haiM. aura vahAM rUpazabdase dRzyamAnatA hI lenI hai, to phira idhara rUpazabdako palaTAnekI kyA jarUrata hai ?, vahAM bhI rUpazabdase hI upalakSaNase sparzAdika bhI lekara dharmAstikAsAdikameM rUparasagaMdhasparza aura zabdameMse kucha bhI nahIM hai yahI kahanekA hai. yadi rUpazabda idhara na leveM to gandhAdikakA abhAva upasaNase kaise leMge ? rUpazandase vahAM para pAMcaveM adhyAyameM mUvitA lenA hove aura idhara varNazabdase zuGgAdi lenA ho to yaha bAta alaga hai. parantu iyara indriyoM kA viSaya kahanA hai For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #119
( 108 ) aura sabahI majahaba vAle vakSukA viSaya varNa nahIM mAnate haiM, kiMtu rUpahI mAnate haiM, to phira idhara viSayake sthAmeM rUpahI kahanA munAsiba hai. aura pudgalake sthAna meM hI varNa zabda lAjima hai, lokina 'tadarthA:' pada jo kiyA hai vaha ThIka nahIM hai. isakA asala to yaha kAraNa hai ki idhara arthazabdako samAsa kara lenese Age ke 'sUtrameM 'bhutamanindriyasya' ke sthAna meM arthazabdakI anuvRtti nahIM hogI aura idhara 'arthA' pada rakkhA to vahAM 'artha:' aisA ekavacanAntaM pada lagAnA kaise hogA ? dUsarI bAta yaha bhI hai ki pestarake sUtra meM 'zrotrANi' aisA bahuvacanAnta sUtra hai. usakA sambandha 'teSAM' aise bahuvacana binA kaise lagAnA 1 yadi sambandha hI nahIM lagAnA hai to phira tadzabdakA prayojana hI kyA hai ? tIsarI bAta yaha hai ki 'arthA' aisA bahuvacana rakhane se haraeka indriyameM haraeka viSayakI prApti ho jAyagI.. isase ekavacana karane se eka 2 indriyakA eka eka hI viSaya sambaddha hogA. isase sApha hogA ki 'teSAmarthaH' aisA hI pada rakhanA lAjima hogA. , (8) sUtra 29 meM digambaroMne 'ekasamayA'vigrahA' aisA -sUtra mAnA hai, aura zvetAmbaroMne 'ekasamayo'vigrahaH' aisA sUtra mAnA hai. digambaroMke hisAba se yaha sUtra avigrahAnAmakI gatikA svarUpa dikhAne ke liye hai. avigrahA nAmakI gati jo sUtra 21 meM kahI gaI hai usakA idhara svarUpa hai yAne vahAM sUtra For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #120
( 109 ) ? meM 'avigrahA jIvasya' aisA hI sirpha kahA thA. yAne avigrahA kA vakta nahIM dikhAyA thA, vaha vakta idhara dikhAyA. lokana zvetAmbarAke hisAba se yaha sUtra avigrahAgatikA vakta dikhAne vAlA hone ke sAtha vigrahagatimeM bhI Adya samayakI gatiko avigrahApana dikhAneke liye hai, aura isIse hI gatimeM jitane samaya lage unameMse ekasamayako kama karake bAkI ke samaya vigraha tarIke gina sakte haiM. niyama bhI yahIM hai ki cAhe jitane hI samayakI vakragati ho, lekina Adyasamaya meM to Rjugati hI hogI. isa sthAna meM akalamanda AdamI samajha sakate haiM ki yadi zAstrakArako avigrahAMkA vakta hI kahanA thA taba to 'avigrahA jIvasyaikasamayA,' aisA 'ekasamayA'vigrahA jIvasya' aisA yA 'jIvasyaikasamayA'vigrahA, aisA yA 'avigrahA jIvasyai saikasamayA' aisA pATha karate. lekina 'vigrahavatI ca saMsAriNaH prAkU caturbhyaH,' aisA vigrahagatikA adhikAra zurU karake bIcameM avigrahakA adhikAra nahIM lete. itanA hI nahIM, kintu 'eka hau trInvADanAhArakaH' aisA vigrahake anAhArakapanakA TAima dikhAnevAle sUtra ke bIca meM kabhI bhI nahIM DAlate isase sApha hai ki kisI digambarane apanI akala lagAkara gatike sAtha lagAne ke liye isa sUtra meM 'ekasamayA'vigrahA' aisA kara diyA hai / " i (10) sUtra 30 meM digambaroMke satase 'ekaM dvau trInvA' nAhArakaH' aisA pATha hai. taba zvetAmbaroM ke matase 'eka dvau vA For Personal & Private Use Only 1 3.

Page #121
(110) nAhArakaH' aisA pATha hai idhara socanekA yaha hai ki jaba peztarake sUtrameM 'prAk caturvyaH' kahakara tIna hI samaya taka vigrahakA honA mAnA hai, aura usameM ekasamayako vigraha tarIke mAnanekA hI nahIM hai, to phira tIna samaya anAhArake kahAMsa hoMge ? aura tInasamayakI gatimeM tInoM hI samaya anAhArake mAnoMge taba to ekasamayakA avigraha kahAM rahegA? aura RjugatimeM bhI anAhArakapanA mAnanA hogA. isase 'eka dvA vA'nAhArakaH' aisA kahanA hI lAjima hogA. aisI zaMkA nahIM karanA ki vigrahagati pAMca samaya taka kI hotI hai. kyoMki jo adholokake koNameMse Urdhvalokake koNa meM utpanna hogA usako pAMca hI samaya hoMge. AdyasamayameM vidizAse dizAmeM AvegA. dUsare samayameM sanADau~ma AvegA. tIsare samayameM UrdhvalokameM jAyagA aura cauthe samayameM dizA meM jAkara pAMcaveM samayameM vidizAmeM jAyagA. jaba isa tarahase pAMcasamayakI gati hokara cAra vakra hote haiM, to phira idhara tIna vakra hI kyoM kahe ? aisI zaMkA nahIM karanekA sababa yaha hai ki aisA saMbhava hone para bahutAyatase 'aisI gati nahIM hotI hai. aura isIsababase bhagavatIsUtrameM bhI cAra samayakI gatikA hI adhikAra liyA hai: cArasamayakI gatimeM AdyAntasamayoMmeM anAhAraka na honese do hI samaya 'anAhArapanA rahatA hai, aura isIse hI idhara eka yA do samaya hI anAhArakapanakA liyA hai. TIkAkArasiddhasenasarijImahA For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #122
( 111 ) rAja yahAM para vAzabda kI vyAkhyA meM upalakSaNase pAMcasamayakI gati aura tInasamayakA anAhArapanA dikhAte haiM. lokana tInasamayakI yA cArasamayakI gati lenA aura tanisamayakA anAhArakapanA lenA yaha to sApha hI ayogya haiM, sUtrakAra zrIumAsvAtirjAne bhI 'prAk caturbhyaH' aisA kahakara tInoM hI vigraha idhara liye haiM aura vigraha jitane hoveM utane hI anAhArapana lenA hotA taba to 'anAhAravigrahavatI 0 ' yA ' vigrahavadanAdvArA0' aisA eka hI sUtra kara dete. alaga alaga vigraha aura anAhArakA sUtra karanekI kucha bhI jarUra nahIM thI, parantu antakA vigraha anAhAra meM nahIM lenA hai jisase sUtra alaga karanA hI jarUrI thA / ( 11 ) sUtra 31 meM digambaraloga saMmUrcchanagarbhepapAdAjjanma' aisA sUtra mAnate haiM. peztara to digambaroMneM upapAdazabda upapAtake sthAna meM dharA hai. idhara hI nahIM, lekina Age bhI jahAM jahAM para aupapAtika yA upapAtazabda AtA hai vahAM vahAM para bhI inhoMne 'ta' ke sthAna meM 'da' kara diyA hai lekina yaha unakA rivAja apanI paribhASAko dikhAneke liye hI hai unake rivAja se to gatizabda ke sthAna meM bhI 'gadi' zabda kara deveM to tAjjuba nahIM, astu lekina idhara 'upapAdAt' karake paMcamIkA ekavacana kaise lagAyA ? idhara garbha, saMmUcchima aura upapAta ina tIna taraha se janma dikhAnekA hai to pIche ekavacana She For Personal & Private Use Only +

Page #123
- ( 112 ) kaise rakhA ? sUtrakAra mahArAja to sthAna sthAna para ekasthAna meM ekavacana doke sthAnameM dvivacana aura bahutake sthAna meM bahuvacana spaSTapanese kahate hI haiM. idhara ekavacanakA prayoga sirpha digI kalpanAkA hI phala hai. aisA nahIM kahanA ki 'upapAtA' aisA bahuvacana rakhanese 'janma' ke sthAna meM bhI bahuvacana rakhanA hogA. aisA nahIM kahanekA sababa yaha hai ki uddezyasthAna meM bahuvacana hone para bhI vidheyake sthAna meM to 'tattva' 'nyAsaH' 'jJAnaM' AdisthAnoMmeM donoMke pAThoMmeM aise ekavacana sApha hI hai / ( 12 ) sUtra 33 meM digambaroM ke matase 'jarAyujANDajapotAnAM garbhaH' aisA pATha hai, taba zvetAmbaroMke mata se 'jarAkhaNDapoTajAnA garmaH aisA kaTa hai, ambala to idhara vyAkaraNake niyama ke anta yA AdimeM lagA huA pada sabako laga sakatA hai, to pIche jarAyu aura aNDakI sAtha janidhAtukA banA huA 'ja' legAnekI kyA jarUrata thI ? yAne Ageke 'ja' se donoMkA sambandha ho jAyagA. aisA nahIM kahanekA hogA ki idhara to kRdanta hai. kyoMki donoM pada peztara raheM taba bhI AgekA janidhAtuse pratyaya Akara ja bananemeM harja nahIM hogA. Azcarya kI bAta to yaha hai ki jarAyu aura aNDake Age tI janadhAtu se banA huA 'ja' lagAyA, aura potake Age tI vaha bhI nahIM lagAyA. potazabdakA artha potaja ho jAyamA For Personal & Private Use Only *

Page #124
( 113 ) aisA nahIM hai potajakA artha yaha hai ki vakhakI taraha sAphapa nase janma pAve. na to jisake cAroM ora jarAyu hove, aura na jo aNDa se janma pAve, vaise hAthI ke bacce AdikI taraha janma pAne: vAleko potaja kahA jAtA hai. potazabdakA artha baccA kahA jAya to kyA jarAyuse honevAle aura aNDase honevAle choTe hoveM ve bacce nahIM kahe jAyeMgeM ? jaba ve bhI pota yAne bacce kahe jAya~ to phira potazabda kahanA hI vyartha hai, aura tIsarI tarahakA janma to raha hI jAyagA, isase lAghava ke hisAba se aura yathAsthitapadArtha ke nirUpaNa meM 'jarAkhaNDapotajAnAM aisA hI pATha kahanA lAjima hai / 1 ( 13 ) sUtra 34 meM digambara 'devanArakANAmupapAdaH aisA sUtra mAnate haiM, aura zvetAmbara 'nArakadevAnAmupaprAtaH' aisA sUtra mAnate haiM. isameM nArakoMko prathama kahanekA kAraNa prathamaH adhyAya ke 'bhavapratyayo 0? isa sUtra kI taraha aura upavAda va upapAta ke liye isI hI adhyAya ke 31 veM saMmUrcchanagarbhopapAdA sUtra kI tarahase samajhanA / ( 14 ) sUtra 37 meM digambara loga 'paraM paraM sUkSmaM' aisA sUtra mAnate haiM, aura zvetAmbara 'teSAM paraM paraM sUkSmaM' aisA sUtra mAnate haiM. donoMke bhI mata se isa sUtra ke peztara 'audArikaH zarIrANi'' yaha sUtra hai, aba idhara donoMke hI hisAba se nirdhAraNa:ko dikhAne ke liSe vibhakti to cAhiyegI / zAkhakAra mahArAja * For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #125
( 114 ) to jahAM bhI SaSThI saptamI vibhaktivAlA pada karane kI jarUra dekhate haiM vahAM para spaSTa vaha kaha dete haiM, jaise "tadvizeSaH ' 'tadyonayaH' isa taraha idhara bhI nirdhAraNa ke liye 'teSAM' pada lenA hI hogA, aura 'teSAM' aisA pada leMge tabhI to una audArikAdizarIroM meM Age AgekA zarIra bArIka yAne alpasthAna meM rahanevAlA aisA artha hogA. anyathA peztarake sUtrameM rahA huA 'zarIrANi' padakA idhara laganA kaise hogA ? (15) sUtra 42 meM digambaroMne 'tadAdIni bhAjyAni yugapadekasminnAcaturbhyaH' aisA pATha mAnA hai, aura zvetAmbarAMna 'tadAdIni bhAjyAni yugapadekasyA caturbhyaH' aisA pATha mAnA hai. yadyapi prathamAdhyAyameM aisA jJAnake vikalpoM ko dikhAnevAlA saptamIvAlA sUtra haiM, lekina vahAM to donoMke sUtrapATha samAna hai, yAne donoM saptamyanta hI mAnate haiM. idhara donoMmeM paraspara pAThabheda hai idhara socanekA yaha hai ki vahAM para to jJAna guNa thA aura guNI AtmA thA. guNa hove vaha guNImeM rahe, aura zAstrakAra ne bhI 'dravyAzrayA nirguNAH guNAH' aisA spaSTa kahA bhI hai. isase vahAM para prathamAdhyAyameM to saptamI se nirdeza karanA lAjimI hai, lekina jisa jagaha zarIra aura zarIrikA sambandha dikhAnA hai vahAM para saptamI dharanA kaise munAsiba hogA ? dUsarA yaha bhI socanekA hai ki zarIrameM jIva hai ki jIvameM zarIra hai ? yadi kahA jAya ki zarIra akelAbhI pIche ThaharatA hai aura dekhane For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #126
( 115 ) Adike vyavahAra meM bhI zarIra hI AtA hai, isase zarIra meM jIvakA rahanA yogya ginA jAya, to phira ekajIva meM cAra taka zarIra ho sakatA hai, yaha kahanA kaise banegA 1, isase sApha hai ki svasvAmibhAvako dikhAnevAlI SaSThI vibhakti hI idhara cAhiye / * : ( 16 ) isI adhyAya ke sUtra 46 meM digambara 'aupapAdikaM vaikriyaM' aisA pATha mAnate haiM. aura zvetAmbara 'vaikriyamopapAtikaM ' aisA pATha mAnate haiM. idhara digambaroMkA kahanA hai ki aupapA dika aura aupapAtikake liye to ThIka hI hai ki hamane ta ke sthAna meM da kara diyA, lekina 'vaikriya' zabdakA sthAna to tumaneM hI palaTAyA hai. hamArA yaha kahanA isase lAjima hogA ki sUtrakAramahArAjane audArikazarIra ke viSaya meM 'garbhasaMmUrcchanaz2amAdyaM' kahakara zarIrakA Akhira meM kathana kiyA, Age AhArakake adhikAra meM bhI 'zubhaM vizuddhamavyAghAti cAhArakaM' jo sUtra. hai vahAM para bhI AhArakakA nAma pIche hI kahA hai. isase sApha mAlUma hotA hai ki idhara bhI sUtrakAramahArAjane to 'aupapAdikaM vaikriyaM' aisA hI kahA thA, lekina zvetAmbaroMne inako palaTa kara 'vaikiyamopapAtikaM' aisA banA diyA. isa sthAna meM zvetAmbaroMkA kathana yaha hai ki sUtrakAramahArAjane 'vaikriyamIpapAtikaM' aisA hI sUtra banAyA hai. hamane kucha bhI palaTAyA nahIM hai, aura yuktiyukta bhI yahI pAThakrama hai. isakA sababa yaha hai ki audArika aura AhArakazarIrake sUtra svataMtra haiM, For Personal & Private Use Only -

Page #127
(116) kAne unameMse kisIkI anuvRtti Ageke sUtra meM karanekI nahIM hai, lekina idhara to vaikriyazabdakI anuvRtti Ageke 'labdhipratparya ca' isa -sUtrameM karamekI hai, aura sUtrakArakI zailI aisI hai ki vidhayakI anuvRtti vidheya zabdako AkhirameM kahanA aura Age tatazabdase parAmarza karanA. jaise 'vanisargAdadhigamAdvA' / tatpramANe 'sa AzravaH / sa bandhaH' ina saba sUtroMmeM jaba peztarake sUtroMkA samyagdarzana jJAna yoga aura karma svIkAra rUpa vidheyakI anuvRtti karanI thI to usako Akhira meM kathana karake pIche ke sUtrameM tatzabda liyA, isI tarahase idhara bhI 'vaikriya' ko vidheyameM rakkheM to 'labdhipratyayaM caM' vahAM para anuvRtti lAneke liye aMtyameM uccAraNarUpa prayatna karanA par3e. isase idhara vaikriyakA uddezyapanA aMtyocAraNase rakha diyA. jisase Age anuvRtti calI Ave, aisA nahIM kare to 'labdhipratyayaM ca' aura 'taijasamapi' ina donoM hI sUtroMmeM viparyAsa karanA hove. ... (17) sUtra 49 meM digambara AhArakazarIrake adhikArameM pramattasaMyatasyaiva' aisA mAnate haiM. taba zvetAmbara 6 catudezapUrvadharasyaiva' aisA pATha mAnate haiM, donoM majahabavAle yaha bAta to maMjUra kaste hI haiM ki yaha AhArakazarIra caudahapUrvako dhAraNa karanevAle hI karate haiM, aura AhAraka karate vakta AhAraphAra karanevAle pramatta hI saMyata hote haiM. jaba aisA For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #128
donoMkA bhI mantavya hai to phira yaha ulaTapalaTa kyoM huI ? digambara aura zvetAmbara saba hI aisA mAnate hI haiM ki satra pramattasaMyata AhArakazarIrako nahIM karate haiM. jaba saba pramatta, sAdhu AhAraka na kara sake to pIche 'pramattasaMyatasyaiva' aisA kahanA phijUla hI hai. digambaroMkI orase kabhI aisA kahA jAya ki 'pramattasaMyatasyaiva' yaha kahanekI matalaba yaha hai ki apramattasaMyata hove ve AhArakavAle na hove, aisA kabhI digambaroMkA kahanA hove to vaha bhI phijUla hai. sababa ki apramattaH guNaThANA AhArakazarIravAleko bhI hotA hai. yadi kahA jAya ki AhArakazarIra jisa vakta banAve usa vakta apramattapanA nahIM hotA hai, kiMtu AhArakazarIra banajAne ke bAda apramattapanA ho sakatA hai, to idhara yaha bAta jarUra socanekI hai ki kyA apramasapanA huA usa vakta usake AhArakazarIrako AhArakazarIra nahIM ginA hai?, ginA hai to phira 'pramattasaMyatasyaiva' yAne pramattasaMyatakohI AhArakazarIra hotA hai yaha kahanA kaise lAjima hogA? yAne na to saba pramattako AhAraka hotA hai aura na saba AhArakazarIravAle pramattahI hote haiM. lekina pUrvadharapane meM to niyama hI hai ki jo caturdazapUrvako dhAraNakaranevAlA ho vahI AhAraka karatA hai. aba sApha hogayA ki zvetAmbaroM kA mAnA huA 'caturdazapUrvadharasyaiva' yahI pATha satya hai, aura 'pramattasaMpatasyaiva' aisA digambaroMkA kahA huA pATha asatya aura kalpita hai| For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #129
( 115 ) (18) tIsare adhyAya meM prathamasUtra meM digambara loga 'ratnazarkarAvA lukAyaMkadhUmatamoma hAtamaH prabhA bhUmayo ghanAmbuvAtA - kAzapratiSThAH saptAgho'dhaH' itanAhI pATha mAnate haiM, aura tara loga isake Age ' pRthutarAH' itanA jyAdA mAnate haiM. donoMke matase eka eka pRthvIse Age AgekI pRthvI cauDI hai to pIche idhara ' pRthutarA: ' pada nahIM mAnanA yaha digambaroMko lAjima nahIM hai, aura yadi 'pRthutarA: ' nahIM leve to ' adho'dhaH ' kI jarUratahI kyA thI ?, kabhI aisA kahA jAya ki pRthvIkA anukrama dikhAneke liye ' adho'dhaH ' kahane kI jarUrata hai to yaha kahanA bhI phijUlahI hai. kyoMki ghanAmbuvatAkAzapratiSThAH ' kahane se hI ' adho'dhaH ' kA bhAvArtha AjAtA hai, to isase spaSTa hai ki sUtrakArane 'adho'dhaH ' ye pada kahe the, aura usase nIcekI pRthvI jyAdA jyAdA vistAravAlI yaha siddha karane kI jarUra hogI, isase pRthutarAH pada sUtrakArane kahAhI haiM. " ( ( 19 ) tIsare adhyAyake dUsare sUtrameM digambara ' tAsu triMzat paMcaviMzatipaMcadazadazatripaM cone kanara kazatasahasrANi paMca caiva yathAkramaM ' aisA sUtra mAnate haiM. taba zvetAMbara tAsu narakA: ' itanAhI sUtra mAnate haiM. akalamaMda AdamI isa sUtrako dekhatehI kaha sakeMgA ki yaha sUtrakI kRtihI zrIumAsvAtivAcakajIkI nahIM hai, kintu digambaroMne hI ghuseDa 2 kara mUtra For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #130
( 119 ) bigAr3a diyA hai. kyoMki abbala to saMgrahakArakake vacanameM itanA vistAra hI asaMgata hai. aura yadi sUtrakAramahArAjakI hI kRti hotI to Upara aura nIca hajAra yojana jo haraeka pRthvI meM varjanekA hai vaha bAta kyoM nahIM kahate ? dUsarA yaha bhI hai ki lakSazabdako choDakara zatasahasra jaisA baDA zabda kyoM DAleM ? yadi nArakake liye narakAvAsakI saMkhyA kaheM to phira saudharmAdikadevaloka meM vimAnoMkI saMkhyA aura bhavanapatiAdike bhavanakI saMkhyA sUryacandrakA pramANa Adi kyoM na kaheM ? taccArthakAra jaise akkalamaMda AcArya kyA aisA nahIM kaha sakte haiM ke jisase vidheyapada mukhya hove aura paMcakI saMkhyAko bhI alaga na karanA paDe, aisA nahIM kahanA ke aisA ho sakatA hI nahIM dekhiye isa taraha se hove ke " tAsu triMza: spaMcaviMzatipaMcadazadazatripaMco ne kalakSa paMcanarakA: ? ? akalamaMda soca sakte haiM ke yaha caivazabda hI kaha rahA hai ke yaha digaMbaroM kA kartuta hai, aura yathAkramaM ' yaha zabda bhI bina jarUrI hai, yadi samAnasaMkhyA honepara bhI yathAkramaM zabdakI jarUrata hove to teSveke ' tyAdi jo narakakI sthitivAlA sUtra hai vahAM 'yathAkramaM ' zabda kyoM nahIM ?, sUtrakAra mahArAjakI ( 2-1 ) sUtra jo bhAvoMkA uddezarUpa hai vahA~ yA ' paMcanava0 ' aisA karma ke bhedoM kA uddezarUpa sUtra hai vahAMhI yathAkrama zabda lagAte hai aura, idhara vaisA uddeza aura nirdeza alaga hai hI nahIM, aisI avasthA meM 6 For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #131
( 120 ) , yathAkramaM zabda lagAdenA yaha bhavabhayakI rahitatA dikhAnekI sAtha ghuseDane vAle kI bAlizatAhI dikhAtA hai. isase sApha hogayA ke yaha digaMbaroMkA kalpitahI sUtra hai. dimaMtraroMne yaha kalpitaH banAyA hai aura zvetAMbaroMne mAnA huvA sUtra vyAjabI hai, isakI spaSTa sabuta mojUda hai, vo yaha hai ke donuM majahabavAle AgekA sUtra 6 TThA isa tarahase mAnate haiM 'teSvekatrisaptadaza saptadazadvAviMzatitrayastriMzatsAgaropamA sattvAnAM parA sthitiH ' isa tarahakA sUtra: jaba donuke matase maMjUra hai to pIche ubhara ' teSu ' zabda se kisakI anuvRtti kareMge. zvetAMbaroMne to 'tAsu nArakAH' aisA sUtra mAna liyA hai, isase unako to sAtohI bhUmimeM rahe huke sAtahI taraha kI narako anukramase AyuSya A jAyagA, lekina digaMbaroMne to lakkho narakAvAsa liye isase sAta sthitioMkA saMbaMdha kahAM dikhAeMge, itanA hI nahIM, kintu cha narakake narakA-: vAsa to ekasamAsa se kahe hai aura saptamIkA narakAvA sabhI alama kahA hai, isase bhI sAta sthitioMkA sambandha kaise lagAyA jAyagA 1, idhara itanA socanA jarUrI hai ki sUtrakArakI zailI hai ki samAsake alamapanese sthitikA sambandha alaga rakhate haiM. aura isItarahase devatAoMke adhikArameM AnatANata, Araacyuta aura vijayAdikako ekasamAsa meM kahe aura sthiti meM navame dazaveMmeM aura gyArahaveM bArahaveM meM do do sAgaropama baDhAye: haiM. aura vijayAdimeM ekahI baDhAyA, isa rIti se idhara bhI samajha For Personal & Private Use Only .

Page #132
(121) leMge to digaMbaroMkI cAlAkI samajha sakeMge. isase yaha ch| kA samAsa karanA aura sAtavIMkA narakAbAsa alaga rakhanA, yaha Age kahane meM AyagI usa sthitike sambandha se viruddha hI hai| sabase jyAdA to yaha hai ki 'narakAH' yo paramAnAmA aisA koI bhI pada idhara svataMtra nahIM hai ki jisakA sambanlA teSu isa padake sAtha kiyA jAya. zvetAmbara to 'tAsu naraMkAra aisA sUtra mAnate haiM, isase 'teSu' ke sthAna meM svataMtra narakamabda lagA kara sAtakA sambandha kara sakeMge.... . . . : ... . (20) isI adhyAyake tIsare sUtra meM zvetAmbaroMkI mAnyaH tAse 'nityAzubhataralezyApariNAmadehavedanAvikriyA aisA sUtrapATha hai. jaba digambaroM ke matase. 'nArakA nityAzubhatara0 pATha mAnA hai. aba isa sthAnameM socie ki pherakhara dUsare patroM narakAnAsakA sUtra banAyA hai to idhara nArakaisa pada sambandha kaise lamAyA ?-yAne dinambaroM ke hisAbale bhI "tepura yA tatra' aisA koI pada honA jarUrI kAH isase mAlUma hota hai ki zvetAmbaroMkA jo dUsarA sUtra tAsu narakAH' aisA thaa| usameM kisIne TippaNakI tarahase narakAbAsakI saMkhyA likhI huI hogI, vaha ina digambarAne mUlasUtrama milA dI aura narakAvAsakI saMkhyAko milAdemese naskA:' kaha pada kalA phAjala huA usako idhara tIsare satra meM milAyA aisA na kahanA ki- isameM kyA harja hai / kyoMki asala po For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #133
(122) idhara 'narakAH' pada zvetAmbaroM ke hisAbase dUsare sUtrameM 'tAsu' padakI sAtha lagA huA thA, aura idhara narakAvAsakI saMkhyA bIcameM DAlakara jo ' nArakAH ' pada DAlA hai vaha asamaddha ho gayA hai. isake liye 'teSu' yA 'tatra' pada lagAnekI jarUrata hai. isake Ageke sUtra meM bhI teSveka0' ityAdi sUtrakI jagaha para bhI 'teSu' yaha pada sAmAnyabhUmibhedase nArakoMkoM nahIM laga sakegA. kyoMki bIca meM narakAvAsakA sUtra Akara aba 'narakAH' sAmAnyanArakoMkA vAcaka ho jAyagA. bAdameM 'teSu' kahakara bhUmibhedase nArakoMkI sthiti batAnA asaMbaddha hogA. isase sApha mAlUma hotA hai ki digambaroMne apanI kalpanAse hI narakAvAsakA bhAra idhara DAladiyA aura 'nArakAH' zabda sambandha lagAye binAhI idhara tIsare sUtrameM DAla diyA hai. ". (21) isI tIsare adhyAyameM sUtradazavemeM digambara loga bharatahamavataharividaharamyakaharaNyavatairAvatavarSAH kSetrANi' aisA sUtrapATha mAnate haiM. taba zvetAmbara loga 'tatra bharatahema. vata' ityAdi sUtra pATha mAnate haiM. aba isa jagaha para digambaroMne 'tatra' zabda ur3A diyA, lekina ye bharatAdikSetroMkA sthAna kahA~ mAnege, kyoMki tiryaglokameM saba dvIpasamudrako dikhAkara unakA AkAra Adi dikhAye, bAdameM 9 veM sUtra meM "tat' zabdase saba dvIpasamudrakA parAmarza karake bIcameM jandvIpa dikhAyA hai, aba isa jambUdvIpameM ina bharatAdikako For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #134
(123) dikhAneke liye parAmarza karanevAle padakI jarUrata thI. lekina ina digambaroMne vaha parAmarza karanevAlA pada ur3A diyA. kabhI aisA kahA jAya ki peztara jaMbUdvIpakA adhikAra honese usakI anuvRtti ho jAyagI, aura anvaya lagAneke liye saptamI lagAkara tatra aisA le leMge. yaha kahanA vyarthahI hai, kyoMki avvala to sUtrakArakI yaha zailI hI nahIM hai, aura aisA hI mAna leM to idhara to saptamyantakA koI bhI sUcaka pada nahIM hai, lekina Ageke sUtrameM 'tadvibhAjinaH' isa sUtra meM parAmarza karanekI koI jarUrata nahIM thI. isase sApha hai ki idhara 'tatra' pada honA hI cAhiye. digambaroMkI orase kabhI aisA kahA jAya ki ye bharatAdika kSetra akele jambUdvIpameMhI nahIM lene haiM. kintu dhAtakIkhaMDa aura puSkarArdhameM bhI yehI bharatAdika. kSetra lene haiM, isase idhara 'tatra' zabda lenekI jarUrata nahIM hai. lekina yaha kahanAbhI vyartha hai. isakA sababa yaha hai ki Age 'dvirdhAtakIkhaMDe' 'puSkarArdhe ca' aisA kahakara vahAM para to bharatAdikakA dviguNapanA lenA hai, isase yaha sUtra to jambUdvIpake liye hI rahegA, aura idhara 'tatra' aisA pada z2arUra cAhiyegA. digambaroMke hisAbasebhI to yaha sUtra jaMbUdvIpAdi tInasthAnake liye raha sakatA hI nahIM hai. sababa ki ina logoMne jo maMtra baDhAye haiM usameM saba adhikAra jambUdvIpakA hI liyA hai. yAvata. bharatako 190 meM bhAgameM liyA hai, vaha jambUdvIpake sivAya nahIM For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #135
( 124 ) hai. isase idhara tatra zabda jarUra hI lenA paDegA. ( 22 ) isI adhyAyake sUtra 36 meM digambaraloga 'AryA mlecchAzca' aisA pATha mAnate haiM, jaba zvetAmbara 'AryA klizaca' aisA pATha mAnate haiM. digambaroMne idhara spaSTatA ke liyehI 'slizatha' ke sthAna meM 'mlecchAtha' aisA kara diyA hai. lekina idhara avvala yaha zocanekA hai ke mleccha aura Arya zabda paraspara viparIta hai, lekina Aryazabda niruktise huvA hai aura mlecchazabda mlecchadhAtusehI banA hai, isase dhAtuse banA huvA zabdako pradhAna pada diyA jAya yahI yathArtha hai aura jaba dhAtuseddI hone vAlA mlecchazabda leMge to karttA meM kipU pratyaya lagAke gliza aisAhI zabda banAnA hogA, aura isakI yaha matalaba hogA ki avyakta bhASA bolane vAle gliza hote hai, aura jo vaise nahIM hai ve Arya hai, isase yaha bhI sApha hogA ki idhara brAhmIlivi aura ardhamAgadhI bhASAkA jahAM jahAM pracAra nahIM ve gliza kahe jAya, aura jihAM unokA pracAra hogayA ve Arya hai. isa hetuse idhara glizazabdahI kahanA lAjima ginA gayA hai. 4. ( 23 ) sUtra 38 meM 'parApare' aisA utkRSTa aura jaghanya aisI manuSya va tiryacakI sthiti dikhAnekA sUtra thA. vahAM ina digambaraune 'parAvare' aisA kara diyA hai, kyoMki zAkhakAra to jahAM para bhI jaghanyasthitikA adhikAra lete haiM vahAM : For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #136
(125) jaghanyasthitiko aparA sthiti kahate haiM. dekhie cauthe adhyAyameM devatAoMkI jaghanyasthiti meM aparA palyopama' (33) 'tadaSTabhAgo'parA' aise hI 'adhyAyaAThaveMmeM bhI 'aparA dvAdazamuhUrtA' (18 ) ina sUtroM ko dekhanese mAlUma hotA hai ki sUtrakAra jaghanyasthitiko aparA hI kahate haiM. dUsarI yaha bhI bAta sApha hai ki jahAM para utkRSTasthiti dikhAnekI hotI hai vahAM 'parA' zabdase hI vyavahAra karate haiM. jaisA isI tIsare. adhyAyameM manuSyatiryacakI utkRSTasthitimeM utkRSTasthiti dikhAne meM isI sUtrameM 'parA' kA vyavahAra kiyA hai. isI tarahase nArakoMkI utkRSTasthitikA sUtra jo naM. 6 kA hai, usameM parAzabdase hI utkRSTasthiti kahI hai. adhyAyacauthemeM 'parA palyopamamadhikaM ca' ( 39) digambaroM ke hisAbase bhI utkRSTasthitimeM parApadakA hI prayoga mAnya hai, to phira utkRSTa se pratipakSa aisI jaghanyasthiti dikhAnemeM 'aparA' aisAhI padakA prayoga hove. lekina digambaroMne apanI Adata mujaba kucha bhI pharka DAlanA cAhiye aisA soca kara idharaM 'pa' ke sthAnameM 'va' karake 'parAvare' aisA kara DAlA hai.. ( 24 ) sUtra naM. 39 meM zvetAmbaraloga "tiryagyonInA ca' aisA pATha mAnate hai. isa sthAnameM 'tiryagyonInA' ke pAThakI jagaha para digambaroMne 'tiryagyaunijAnAM ca aisA TeMdA pATha kyoM kiyA ?, kyA tiryagyonizabdase tirthacoMkA bodha 71 - For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #137
( 126 ) : nahIM hotA thA ?, yadi digambaroM kA yaha mAnanA ho to vaha nihAyata anucita hai, kyoMki tiryagyonizabda se tiryaMca nahIM leMge to pIche ' tiryagyonija ' zabda hI tiyaMcoMke liye kaise hogA ? asalama sUtrakArane to 'tiryagyoni' aisA hI zabda rakhA hai, dekhie adhyAyacauthekA sUtra 27 'aupapAdikamanuSyebhyaH zeSAstiryagyonayaH' idhara tiryaMcoMkA lakSaNa yA saMjJA karate bhI ' tiryagyoni' yahI zabda kahA hai. idhara sUtrakArane ' tiryagyonijAH' aisA digambaroM kA phirAyA huA pATha na to sUtra meM diyA hai aura na digambaroMne aisA mAnA hai. isI taraha se 'mAyA tairyagyonasya' isa sUtra meM tiryagyonija zabda tiryaMcake liye nahI mAnA hai, idharato Ayu dikhAne meM 'tairyagyona' zabda taddhitAMta hai sUtrakAra mahArAjane to tiryagyonizabdasehI tiryaca liye hai, aura kevala apanI Adata se anyathA kaha kara tiryacoMkA AyuSya dikhAyA hai isase sApha hotA hai ki digambaroMne hI yaha pATha bigADA hai. (25) adhyAya cauthe meM digambara 'AditastriSu pItatilezyA: ' aisA sUtra mAnate haiM. taba zvetAmbara 'tRtIyaH pItalezyaH' aisA sUtra mAnate haiM, isa viSayakI samAlocanA sUtrakI adhikatA ke viSaya meM hogaI hai. sababa yaha bAta vahAM hI se samajha lenA ucita hai. dUsarA yaha hai ki yadi sUtrakArakA kiyA huA aisA sUtra hotA to aisA astovyasta sUtra kabhI For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #138
(127) bhI nahIM hotA. kyoMki tIna nikAyake devoMkI lezyA kahanI hotI to 'pItAntalezyA' itanAhI sUtra karate, aura vaimAnikakI lezyAkA to Age hI apavAda hai. dUsarA yaha bhI hai ki pItAntalezyAH' aisA bahuba hikI chAyAvAlA pada hI nahIM rakhate. kintu pItAntA lezyAH' aisA sApha kahate, tIsarA yaha bhI hai ki 'AditaH' aise tampratyayAMtakI kyA jarUrata hai. 'Aditrike' itanA kahate, yA 'triSu' itanA hI kahata aisA nahIM kahanA ki Age karmasthitike adhikArameM sUtrakAramahArAjane hI 'AditastisRNAM aisA sUtra karake kahA hai,jisase idhara aaditH| kahanA kyA burA hai ?, aisA na kahanekA sababa yaha hai ki vahAM peztarakA sUtra antarAyakarmakI dAnAdi uttara prakRtiko kahatA hai. aura vahAM para 'AditaH' pada na lagAyA hotA to dAnAditInaprakRtikI sthiti ho jAtI. lekina jJAnAvaraNIyAdi tIna mUlaprakRtikA to prasaMga hI nahIM thA, sababa vahAM para AditAH aisA pada dene kI jarUrata thI. acala to AdizabdakI hI idhara jarUrata nahIM thI. kyoMki Age vaimAnikake apavAda zivAya bhI prathamopasthita tInahI bheda A sakate the. ....... . (26) cautha adhyAyake 4the sUtrameM digambara loga 'trAyaviMzat aisA pATha trAyastriMzadevatAke. liye . mAnate. haiM aura jabaraloga 'trAyaviMza' aisA pATha mAnate haiM, taiMtIsa devatA visa hote haiM vaiseko 'bAyastriMza' nAmake deva kahate haiN| For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #139
( 128 ) vaisI jagaha yaha nAma honese u pratyaya Ane kI jarUrata hai yaha bAta vyAkaraNa ke jAnakAroMse chipI huI nahIM hai. # (27) isI tarahase ina digambaroMne pAriSadya nAmako tAoMke liye 'pariSad' aisA pada kahA hai, yaha bhI zocanIya haiM. ( 28 ) isa cauthe adhyAya ke 19 ve sUtra meM to digamba bar3A hI julma kara diyA hai, zvetAmbaraloga isa sUtra kA pATha 'dharmezAna sanatkumAra mAhendrabrahmalokalAntakamahA zukra mahA vAntANatarAraSTrA cyUtrayornavasu deveyakeSu vijayantasantAparAjiteSu sarvArthasiddhe ca' isa tarahase mAnate haiM. digambara loga isa sUtra brahmake jAge brahmottara lAntada(ka) ke Age kApiSTa aura zukra phira mahAzukra ke Age zatAra, isa tarahase cAra devaloka jyAdaha mAnate haiM asala meM yaha sUtra vetAmbarAcAryakA kiyA huA thA, isase idhara kalpopapana bAraha hI devaloka ginAye the. lekina digambaroMne apanI mAnyatA jaba solaha kalpApapatra devaloka banA diye, ye devaloka asala AcAryaka pAThana nahIM the isakA sabUta isI adhyAgameM digambaroMkI mAnyatA mujaba bhI sApha sApha hai. dekhie, peztara to de oke bheda dikhAye haiM, jisameM hI 'dazASTapaMcadvAdavikalpAH upanayantAH' isa sUtra se kalpopapAke nAra aura baiMka vimAnase paikarake tI 'progU viyayaH lvA For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #140
(129) . . . 23 vAM sUtra digambaroMne bhI mAnA hai, isase spaSTa hai, to phira khuda sUtrakArane hI bAraha bhedakA uddeza kiyA to pIche nirdezameM solahabheda kahAMse kahA jAya ?, dUsarA yaha bhI hai ki I loka takake devatA to kAyase maithunasevAke pravicAravAle haiM aura Age sparza rUpa zabda aura manase pravicAra karane vAle haiN| yadyapi idhara zvetAmbaraloga to do domeM spAdikakA pravicAra mAnate haiM. aura sUtrakArane bhI 'dvayordvayoH' aisA kahakara 3-4 meM sparza5-6 meM rUpa7 8 meM zabda9-10-11-12 meM mana, isa tarahase pravicArake liye sthiti mAnIhI haiM. yahAM digambarake hisAkse peztara sparzake viSaya meM to do devaloka raheMge, bAda rUpa zabda aura mana ina tInoM meM bhI cAra cAra devaloka lene hoMge. sUtrakArako yaha kaise iSTa hove ?, kyoM ki ekameM do aura tInameM cAra cAra devaloka lenA hove aura kucha bhI saMkhyAkA nirdeza na kare,digambaroMke hisAbase to sUtrakArako 'dvicatuzcaturdvikeSu' aisA kahanA z2arUrI thA. aisI zaMkA nahIM karanA cAhiye ki Akhirake manaHprabicArameM to vaisA cAra devaloka to zvetAMbaroMko. lenAhI hai to manake viSayakI taraha. idhara tInameM bhI cAra cAra devaloka mAnanA kyA burA hai? vaha zaMkA nahIM karanekA sababa yaha hai ki sUtrakAramahArAjane hI ANataprANata' ko aura 'AraNa acyuta ko ikaDe gine haiM. aura isIse hI khuda sUtrakAranehI 'ANataprANatayoH' aura 'AraNAcyutayoM, aisA alaga alaga aura ekatra samAsa kara dikhAyA hai. itanAhI For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #141
(130) nahIM, kintu AraNAcyutAx0' isa 32 veM sUtrameM khuda AcAryamahArAjane hI AraNAcyutakA ikaTThApanA dikhAyA hai isase Anata aura prANatako AraNa aura acyutako to do ginanA sUtrakArake vacanase hai. lekina rUpa aura zabdake viSaya meM cAra 2 devaloka lenA yaha to sUtrakArake dvayordvayoH vacanoMse khilApha hI hai. Age para aura socanekA jarUrI hai ki digambaroMke hisAbase mAhendradevalokakI sthitike sUtra ke bAda 'trisaptanavaikAdazatrayodazapaMcadazabhiradhikAni tu' isa sthitike sUtrameM 7-3=10, 7-7=14, 7-9=16, 7-11-18, 7-13-20, 7-15=22 isa tarahase cha hI devalokakI sthiti dikhAI hai, aura Ageke sUtrameM aveyakAdikI sthiti dikhAI hai. idhara zvetAmbaroMke hisAbase sUtrake AdimeM 'vizeSa' zabda mAhendra kI sthiti ke liye hai.. bAda 5-6-7-8 ye cAra devaloka svataMtra aura 9-10 kA eka bAda 11-12 kA eka, isa tarahase chaH sthAna ho jAte haiM, lekina digambaroMke hisAbase to idhara sthitike kramako devalokakI saMkhyAke sAtha milAnakA rAstA hI nahIM hai. ina saba sababoMseM sApha ho jAtA hai ki digambaroMne apanI manta. vyatA ghuseDakara isa sUtrako sApha bigADa diyA hai. - (29) sUtra 28 veM digambaroMne sthitirasuranAgasuva. varNadvIpazeSANAM sAgaropamatripalyopamArdhahInamitAH' aisA sUtra mAnA hai. akalamanda AdamI isa sUtrako dekhatehI kaha sakate For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #142
( 131 ) , haiM ki yaha sUtra sApha jhUThA hai. kyoMki asala to idhara zvetAmbaroMke hisAba se to Agese sthitikA aura bhavanabAsikA adhikAra calA AtA hai. lekina digambaroMne ye ' sthitiH ' aura 'bhavaneSu' vAle sUtra nahIM mAne haiM to idhara zeSazabdase kisako lenA usakA hI patA nahIM hai. dakSiNa aura uttarake indroMkA vaimAnika meM to AyuSyabheda sUtrase dikhAyA aura idhara nahIM dikhAyA. idhara pAMcakA uddezya hai aura vidheyameM sirpha tIna hI haiM. aura mAna liyA jAya ki doke zivAyako ardhaardhahIna kahanA to isake liye avvala to ardhazabdako do bAra kahanA cAhiye, lekina yaha to kahA hI nahIM. itanA hI nahIM, lekina idhara ' mitA: ' zabdasthitikI sAtha lagAnA yaha bhI ayogya hai. aura 'mitAH ' kA vizeSya hI koI nahIM kahA hai. akkalamanda prakSepa bhI karatA to 'ardhavihIna panyopamA ' aisA sIdhA sUtra banAtA, asala meM vo 'mitAH' zabda hI phijUla hai. kyoMki idhara kisI bhI sthiti ke sUtra meM 'mitA : ' zabda na to lagAyA hai aura na lagAnekI AvazyakatA hai. dakSiNa aura uttarake nAgakumArAdikakI sthiti meM bhI idhara pharka nahIM dikhAyA hai. ina sabavoMse sApha ho jAtA hai ki. digambaroMne idhara bhI sUtroMkA pUrA ghoTAlA kara diyA hai / (30) isI cauthe adhyAya ke sUtra 29 meM digambara loka 'saudharmezAnayoH sAgaropame adhike' aisA pATha mAnate haiM. yaha For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #143
( 132 ) " pATha bhI sUtrakArakI zailase viruddha hai, avvala to yaha sociye ki donoM devaloka meM sthiti alaga 2 dikhAte haiM yA eka hI sthiti dikhAte haiM ? yadi mAna liyA ke alaga alaga sthiti dikhAne kI hai yAne saudharma devalokakI alaga aura IzAnadevalokakI bhI alaga dikhAnI hai. to donuMkA samuccaya karaneke lie 'cakAra' dAkhala karanA hI cAhiye, sUtrakAra hareka sthAna para samuccaya ke sthAna meM cakAra lagAte hI hai. yadi kahA jAyake donoM devalokakI sthiti sAthahI kahanI hai to pIche ' adhike ' aisA kaha nahIM sakte haiM, kintu ' sAdhike aisA hI kahanA hogA, dusarI bAta yaha bhI hai ke AgehI " sthitiprabhAva0' isa sUtra meM sApha sApha kahA hai ke hareka devaloka pesvara pestaske devalokakI apekSA se jyAdA sthiti lenI, to idhara prathama aura dusare devaloka meM sthiti sarakhI kaise hove / isI taraha se Age sUtra 33 meM bhI digambaroMne 'aparA palyopamamadhikaM aisA cakAra lagAye binA hI pATha mAnA hai, to usase aparA yAne jaghanyasthitimeM bhI donuM devaloka meM pharaka nahIM rahegA. aura pharaka nahIM rahane se 'sthiti0' Adi sUtra jhUThI ho jAyagA, yadi vahAM jaghanyasthiti meM prathama devaloka meM eka pralyopama aura dUsare devaloka meM palyopama adhika sthiti mAnanI ho, to vahAM mI cakAra lagAnA hI cAhiye, area aa svara "saudharmAdiSu yathAkramaM ' aisA adhikAra kSetra mAnA hai, , For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #144
(133) aura 'sAgaropame' 'adhike ca' aise alaga alaga sUtra mAne hai. jisase na to unako adhika sthiti lene meM haraja hai, aura na 'saudharmezAnayoH' aisA mAnanekI jarura hai, isI tarahase 'sthitiH' aisA adhikArasUtra sthitivAcaka mAnA hai, aura Age bhavanapatimeM dakSiNa aura uttaraindroM kI sthitike lie aura zeSa vahAMke devokI sthitike lie sthitikA alaga alaga sUtra dikhAyA hai isase sApha ho jAyagA ke zvetAmbarokA hI pATha saccA hai, __(31) isI adhyAyameM sUtra 30 meM digambaraloka 'sAnatkumAramAhendrayoH sapta' aisA pATha mAnate hai. aba isa sthAnameM avala to adhikAra sUtra mAnA hotA to 'sAnatkumAramAhendrayoH' aisA nahIM kahanA paDatA, aura kahane parabhI donoM devalokakI sthiti sarakhI ho jAtI hai. aura isIse hI 'sthitiprabhAva.' yaha sUtra viruddha ho jAtA hai. idhara dusarA bhI virodha AyagA. vo virodha yaha hai ke saudharma aura IzAnadevalokakI jaghanya sthiti dikhA karake zAstrakAra mahArAja pharamAge ke 'parataH parataH pUrvI pUrvA'nantarA' yAne dusare devalokase Age pestara pestara devalokakI utkRSTa sthiti hove vo Age Age devalokameM jaghanyasthiti samajanI. aba idhara tisarA aura cauthA devalokakI eka sarakhI mAna lI to pIche cauthAdevalokameM jaghanyasthiti kahAM se lAyeMge ?, tisarA aura cauthA devalokakI sthiti sarakhI honese idhara hI tIsare devaloka meM For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #145
( 134 ) nizcaya nahIM hogA. sababa ke prathama dUsare devaleokakI sthiti eka sarakhI batAI hai. dusare devaloka kI koI alaga utkRSTa sthiti dikhAI nahIM hai ke jisako idhara tIsare devalAka meM jaghanyasthiti ke rUpa meM mAne. yadi mAna liyA jAya ki idhara utkRSTasthiti ke sUtra meM 'saudharmezAnayoH sAgaropame adhike' aisA kahA hai, lekina jaghanyasthitike sUtra meM 'saudharmezAnayo:' aisA pada dekara jaghanyasthiti nahIM kahI hai. isase vahAM para jaghanyasthiti ' aparA palyopamamadhikaM ' isa sUtra se sirpha saudharmadevalokakI jaghanyasthiti mAneMge. avvala to idhara saudharma IzAna do devaloka lenA isakA Apako nizcaya honA hI kaThina haiM. sababa ki Apane 'saudharmAdiSu yathAkramaM ' yaha adhikAra sUtra to nahIM mAnA hai. dUsarA idhara eka yA do devaloka lenA usake liye koI pada nahIM haiM itanA hone para bhI yaha virodha ho jAyagA ki IzAnadevaloka meM Apako jaghanyasthiti kauna mAnanI yaha muzkila ho jAyagA sababa ki saudharmadevalokakI utkRSTa sthiti do yA sAdhika do sAgaropama hai, aura vahIM izAna meM jaghanyasthiti mAnanI hogI. isakA matalaba yaha ho jAyagA ki IzAna meM jaghanyasthiti do sAgaropama yA sAdhika do sAgaropama mAnanI hogI. isase yaha baDA harja hogA ki yadi idhara hI dUsare devalokase peztarakI utkRSTasthitikA jaghanyasthitipaNA dikhAnA hotA to Age narakake * For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #146
(135) sUtrameM 'dvitIyAdiSu' aisA pada kahA hai, vahI pada idhara kahanekI jarUrata hotI. yAne aisA sUtra kahanA hotA ki 'dvitIyAdiSu parataH parataH pUrvA pUrvA'nantarA' 'nArakANAM ca' lekina aisA sUtra nahIM kahA, yahI spaSTa dikhA rahA hai ki sUtrakAra: mahArAjako yaha jaghanyasthitikA sUtra devalokameM dUsare Adise lagAnA nahIM haiM. isase sApha ho gayA ki digambaroMkA mAnA huA pATha asala AcAryajIkA banAyA huA nahIM hai. isase yaha bhI sApha hogayA ki Age bhI 'sAgaropame' 'adhike ca' yaha sUtra tIsare cauthe devalokakI jaghanyasthitike the. va bhI digambaroMne ur3A die haiM. isa sthAnameM yaha zaMkA jarUra hogI ki yadi 'saudharmAdiSu yathAkrama' aisA adhikAra sUtra hI zvetAmbaroMne mAnA hai to phira 'sapta sanatkumAre aisA sUtra banAnekI kyA jarUrata thI ?, kyoMki peztara do devalokakI sthiti AgaI hai, isase yaha tIsarI sthiti tIsarA devalokakI hai, yaha spaSTa mAluma hojAtA hai. lekina yaha zaMkA yogya nahIM hai. sababa yaha hai ki Ageke sUtrameM 'vizeSa' adhikasthiti cauthe mAhendradevalokameM dikhAnI hai to vahAM para cauthA devaH loka aura adhika sAtamAgaropamakI sthiti ye donoM bAteM spaSTa mAlUma hojAya, isIse idhara yaha sUtra jarUrI hai, dUsarA yaha bhI kAraNa hai ki tIsarA cauthA devaloka eka balayameM hone se koI manuSya donoM devaloka meM sAdhikasAgaropamakI sthiti For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #147
(136) mAna le, isase bhI sanatkumArakI sthiti alaga dikhAne kI jarUrata hai. isItarahase Age bhI 'AraNAcyutAvaM' isa sUtroM bhI devalokakA nAma lene kI yaha jarUrata hai, kAraNa ki AraNAcyutako eka sAtha ginanA aura isI tarahase AnataprANatako bhI samasamAsavAle honese eka sAtha ginanA yaha bAta spaSTa ho jAya. isI tarahase prativeyakameM ekeka sAgaropama baDhAne ke liye natra aveyaka aisA kahA aura sAre vijayAdicArameM ekahI baDhAne ke liye 'vijayAdiSu' aisA kahA hai, aura sarvArthasiddhi meM ajaghanyAnuskRSTa taitIsa sAgaropama sthiti hai yaha dikhAne ke liye usakA bhI nAma spaSTa kahA hai, antameM yaha saba vyavasthA adhikArasUtra kahanese hI huI hai, aura cauthe Adi devalokoMke nAma bhI adhikAra sUtrakI sattAse hI kahane nahIM paDe hai. (32) Age bhI idhara cauthe adhyAya meM vyantara aura jyotiSkoMke viSaya meM jaghanya aura utkRSTasthitimeM sUtrake pATha bhinna bhinna haiM, lekina usa viSayameM sUtrakAra mahArAjakA svataMtra aisA koI vacana nahIM haiM ki jisase ghuseDane vAle yA uDAdenevAleko pakaDa sakeM. yadyapi isI hI sUtrakA bhASya svopajJa honese aura inhIM AcAvejIke banAye hue aura aura granthaka AdhArase viparyAsa karanevAlekA nirNaya kara sakate haiM, lekina usameM abhI anya granthase utaranA ThIka nahIM ginakara isa sthAna meM saMkoca hI ThIka hai.. For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #148
(137 ) ( 33 ) adhyAye pAMcaveMmeM digambara lona 'gatisthityupaH graho dharmAdharma yorupakAraH ? aisA 17 veM sUtrameM pATha mAnate taba zvetAmbara loga " 0 tyupagraho 0 ' aisA pATha mAnate haiM. idhara samajhanA itanA hI hai ki haraekakA upakAra alaga - 2 hai hara ekake do upakAra na honese 'upagrahau' aisA dvivacana karanA munAsibahI nahIM hai. aura yadi donoM ke liye dvivacana rakhanA hove to 'dharmAdharmayoH kRtsne' vahAM para bhI ekavacanAMtahI avamA hakI anuvRttike liye kaThinatA hogI vahAM para bhI 'avagAhoM' : aisA hI karanA hogA. ( 34 isI adhyAya meM 28 veM sUtrameM zvetAmbara loga 'bhedasaMghAtAbhyAM cAkSuSAH aisA pATha mAnate haiM, taba digambara loga 'bhedasaMvAtAbhyAM cAkSuSaH? aisA mAnate haiM aba isa sthAnameM yadi presa yA zodhakakI galatI na hove to kahanA cAhiye ki zvetAmbaroM kA mAnA huA DI pATha yogya haiM, aura digambarokA pATha ayogya hI hai. sababa ki pezvara sUtrakArane 'agavaH skanAtha' aisA sUtra karake bahuvacanAnta hIM skandhazabda rakhA hai, aura digambaroMne bhI ' saMghAtabhedebhyaH utpadyante'aisA sUtra: 26 kA pATha mAnA hai. isase skandhazabda vahAM bhI bahuvacanAntahI mAnA hai, to phira idhara ekavacanAnta skandha zabdakI anuvRtti kahA~se AyegI ? aura ekavacanAntale kyA phAyadA hai ? aisA nahIM kahanA cAhiye ki jaise 'medAvajuH For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #149
( 134 ) isa sUtra meM aNuzabda ekavacanAnta kara diyA hai. isa taraha se idhara skandhazabda bhI ekavacanAMta hI honA ucita hai aisA nahIM kahanekA avvala kAraNa to yaha hai ki vahAM para aNuzabda anuvRttise lAnekA nahIM hai. aura idhara to skandhazabdakI anuSRtti lAnI hai, aura skandhazabda peztara hI bahuvacanAnta hai. dUsarA yaha bhI sababa hai ki aNukA sthAna eka hI hai, aura skandhake sthAnabhI to anantAnanta haiM, isase bhI skandhazabda ekavacanAnta honA ThIka nahIM hai, dUsarA vahAM aNuzabdakA zAstrakArane spaSTa uccAra ekavacanameM kiyA hai ina saba sababako socanese spaSTa ho jAyagA ki 'cAkSuSAH' aise zvetAMbaroMkA mAnAhuA asalazabdako ina digaMbaroneM palaTAyA hai. jaise ina sUtroMpara digambaroMkA tatvArthasUtra jo nirNayasAgara - presakI orase chapAhuA jainanityapATha saMgraha meM hai usake pAThakI apekSA se samIkSA kI haiM, isI tarahase dUsare bhI sUtroMkA vicAra usI hI kitAbase kiyA hai, yadi digambara bhAiyoM kI mAnyatA aura tarahakI hove to sUcita kareM ki jisase hama asatyAkSepa se baca jAyeM. * (35) isI hI pAMcaveM adhyAyake 37 veM sUtrakA pATha digambara loga aisA mAnate haiM ki 'baMdhe'dhiko pAriNAmikau cayAne pudgaloMkA paraspara bandha honemeM jo adhikaguNa hotA hai vaha pAriNAmika yAne dUsare ko palaTA detA hai. For Personal & Private Use Only :

Page #150
( 139 ) isa sthAna para zvetAmbara loga 'bandhe samAdhikau pAriNAmikau' aisA pATha mAnate haiM, isakA artha yaha haiM ki pudgaloMkA paraspara baMdha hone para samaguNase bhI samaguNakA palaTA ho jAtA hai. yAne dazaguNa kRSNapudgala ke sAtha dazaguNazvetakA baMdha hove yA dazaguNarakta ke sAtha dazaguNasaphedapudgalakA baMdha hove to kramase kApota aura gulAbI pariNAma ho jAtA hai. yaha bAta pratyakSa se bhI gamya hai, to phira aisI bAtako diga mbaroMne kisa akalamandIse palaTA dI hai, nyUnaguNakI bAbata meM zvetAmbara aura digambara donoMmeMse ekane bhI vidhAna nahIM kahA isakA sababa yaha hai ki dUsarA jo kamaguNa hotA hai to vaha vo bandha pAnevAlA dUsarA skandha ApoApa jyAdahaguNavAlA hai. aura adhikaguNavAlekA pariNAma ho jAya yaha to sUtra meM sApha kahA hI hai. ( 36 ) sUtra 39 meM digambara loga 'kAla' aisA sUtra mAnate haiM. taba zvatAmbara loga 'kAlazcetyeke' aisA sUtrapATha mAnate haiM. zvetAmbaroMkA kathana aisA hai ki yadi kAladravya svAbhAvika hI AcArya zrIko mAnya hotA to 'dravyANi jIvAzca' isa sthAna meM hI kaha dete, Akhira meM kAlake upakArakA ' varttanA pariNAma: 0 ' ityAdi sUtra kahA vahAM para bhI kahate. aura dUsarA yaha bhI hai ki yadi idhara ekIyamata se kAlako dravyanahIM batAnA hotA aura digambaroMkI mantavyatAnusAra hI For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #151
samayaH sAtaMtrarIta kA kara to ghara cakAskI vasta aisA choTA thI, aura na 'so'nantasamarthaH ' aisA pRthaka kSetra karake anuvRttike liye satzabdakI jarUrata thI. isase sApha hotA hai ki kAlako AcArya mahArAjane vikalpase dravyatarIke mAnA hai, aura aisA hone para 'kAlaya' aisA zvetAMbaroMke kathanAnusAra hI pATha honA jarUrI hai. digambaroMke hisAbase to sAre loka ke AkAza meM kAlAkI vidyamAnatA hai. isase unake mata se kSe jaisA 'dharmAdharmayoH kRtsne yaha sUtra zrIumAsvAtivAcakajIne kiyA hai, usI tarahase isa kAladravyake liye bhI avagAha aura pradezamAna samagralokameM dikhAnA jarUrI thA, yAne ' loke tadAkAzamitAH (bA) lokamitA kAlANavaH ' aisA yA anyakisI tarahase kahane kI jarUrata thI. lekina na to sUtrakAramahArAja svataMtra kAlako dravya mAnate haiM, athavA na to lokAkAsameM vyApti mAnate haiM, aura na samagralokAkAza ke pradeza jitane hai itane kAlake aNu mAnate haiM.. isase sApha hotA hai ki na to sUtrakAra digavara AmnAyake the, aura na unhone digambarakI mAnyatA saccI mAnI hai. yaha sUtra kAlametyeke kisI bhI tarahase mAne, paraMtu yaha sUtra pUrNataH zvetAmbarAkI mAnyatA kAhI hai, isase sApha hotA hai ki isake AcArya zrakAmAroMkI mAnyatA vAle the aura graha tathArthamaMtra bhI una vetAmbaroMkAhI hai.. For Personal & Private Use Only mAnanA hotA meM *

Page #152
( 141 ) 7 (37) Age Ayanako pratipAdana karanevAle chaDe adhyA bameM digambara ' tIvramandAtAjJAtamAtrA kiranapIyavizeSaH aisA chaDDA sUtra mAnate haiM. aura vetAmbara loga 'nandA tAjJAta bhAvavIyadhikaraNebhyasvadvizeSaH ' aisA sUtra mAnate hai. tAmbakA kahanA hai ki jaise tIvramandAdi abhyantara tarahase vIryamI abhyantara vastu hai aura adhikaraNa yaha bA vastu hai aura usa adhikaraNake bhedabhI Age dikhAneke haiM to adhikaraNako Akhira meMhI rakhanA yogya hai. tRtIyA leke karaNa lenA yA paMcamI se hetu lenA aura vizeSazabdakI idhara jarurata hai yA nahIM yaha zocane ke kAbila hone parabhI kartAkI carcA meM itanA upayukta nahIM hai. isa sthAnameM sabase jyAdA dhyAna denekA to yaha hai ki idhara adhikaraNa padaM samAsameM AgayA hai isase gauNakA parAmarza honA nahIM mAnake Age sUtra meM 'adhikaraNaM jIvAjIvAH' aisA kahakara adhikaraNazabda spaSTa lenakI jarUrata huI, isI tarahase dUsaresthAnoM meM samastapadokI anuvRtti karanA sUtrakArako iSTa nahIM yaha bAta nizcita hojAtI hai / J' ( 38 ) isI adhyAyameM sUtra 13 meM digambaro kaSAyodayAcI pariNAmacAritramohasya' aisA sUtra haiM. taba zvetAmbara loga 'kaSAyodayA cItrAtmapariNAnavArivanodaya' aisA pATha mAnate haiM zvetAmbarAMkA kahanA aisA hai ki ivara For Personal & Private Use Only *

Page #153
(142) Atmazabda na rakkheM to kisI munimahArAjako kisI adhama. manuSyane kaSAyodayase tADana tarjana kiyA. to kyA kaSAyodayase munirAjake zarIrameM jo paryAyAntara huA vaha munirAjako cAritramohako bandhAnevAlA hogA?, mAnanA hI hogA ki rairAgyavAn munirAjako to usase nirjarA hotI hai, to pIche idhara pariNAmakI sAtha Atmazabda laMgAnA jarUrI hI hai donoM phIrake vAlene isI graMthake dusare adhyAyakA aupazamikavAle sUtra meM audayika pAriNAmikase peztara hI jIvasvatatva zabdakA kahanA mAnA hai, isase yaha bhI mAnatehI hai ki karmodayajanya pariNAma bhI jIva aura ajIva donoM meM hotA hai, isase idhara Atmazabda / honA hI cAhie. .. (39) isI tarahase sUtra 14 meM digambara 'baDvAraMbhaparigrahatvaM nArakasyAyuSaH' aimA hI sUtra mAnate haiM, taba zvetAMbara 'bahavAraMbhaparigrahatvaM ca nArakasyAyuSaH' aisA pATha mAnate haiM. zvetAMbaroMkA matalaba yaha hai ki jaise bahutaAraMbhAdise narakakA avirata aise cakravartiAdi jIva AyuSya bAMdhate haiM, usI tarahase tandulamatsya kuruTotkuruTa Adike samAna jIvo bhI kaSAyodayakI tIvratAse narakaMke AyuSyakA Azrava karate haiM, isase cakArakI jarUrata hai, aura isIse hI. deva, guru, dharmakI AzAtanA karanevAleko aura mAsAdikakA tapa karake AhAra karanevAleko bhI narakodikA AyuSya bAMdhane kA saMbhava mAnA jAyagA. For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #154
(143) (40) adhyAyasAtaveMmeM digambara loga ' hiMsAdiSvihAmutrApAyAvadyadarzanaM ' aisA pATha mAnate haiM, taba zvetAMbara loga 'hiMsAdiSvihAmutra cApAyAvadyadarzanaM / aisA pATha mAnate haiM. idhara to sApha mAlUma hojAtA hai. ki : iha' aura 'amutra'kA samuccaya karaneke liye cazabdakI jarUrata hai, aura sUtrakArane cakAra kahA bhI hogA. lekina sirpha zvetAMbaroMkA sUtra lekara kisI bhI tarahase yadvA tadvA karake ulaTa pulaTa karane kA kAryahI digaMbaroMne kiyA mAlUma hotA hai... (41) jisatarahase nabameM sUtra meM jarUrI aisA cakAra thA, lekina digambaroMne ur3A diyA, isI tarahase gyArahaveM sUtraH meM ' maitrIpramodakAruNyamAdhyasthyAni ca saMvegavairAgyArtha. ' aisA sUtra banAkara anAvazyaka cakArako zarIka kara dIyA hai.' idhara cakArakA koIbhI mUla prayojana nahIM hai. aura na to idhara cakAra lagAnese koI phAyadA hai. lekina digambaroMne idhara cakAra lagA diyA hai. (42) adhyAya sAtaveMmeM sUtra 32 meM digambaroMne 'kaMdarpa. 0paribhogAnarthakyAni ' aisA sUtra mAnA hai. aura zvetAmbaroMne 'kaMdarpa0 gAdhikatvAni' aisA sUtra mAnA hai. zvetAmbaroMkA kahanA hai ki anarthadaMDake adhikArameM anarthaka kisako ginanA? yahI samajhAnekA hotA hai. aura usI hI zabdako bhItara kesa DAleM ?, isase yaha sApha hai ki apane arthase jyAdA ho vaha For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #155
( 144 ) aticArarUpa hove, anyathA adhika hone para mI anyake bhI prayojana meM Ave usako anarthaka kaise kaha sakeM 1 yAneM anarthakapana to tabhI hove ki apane aura dUsareke bhI prayojanameM na Atre aura adhikapaNA to apane kAryase jyAdA huA usako kaha sakate haiM, aura vahI anarthadaMDakA aticAra banatA hai. ( 43 ) AThaveM adhyAyake 6 TThe sUtrameM digambara 'matizrutAvadhimanaH paryaya kevalAnA' aisA sUtra mAnate haiM. taba zvetAmbara 'matyAdInAM' itanA hI sUtra mAnate haiM, zvetAMbara loka isake saMbadha meM kahatehaiM ki mati zruta avadhi manaHparyava aura kevala ye pAMcoM jJAna prathama adhyAya meM dikhA gaye haiM. isase matyAdi itanAhI kahanA kAphI aisA nahIM kahanA ki yadi idhara mati Adiko spaSTa nahIM kahate haiM to phira 'cakSuscakSuradhikevalAnAM' aisA darzanAvaraNa ke bhedoM meM: spaSTa nirdeza kyoM mAnate haiM?. aisA nahIM kahane kA kAraNa yaha hai ki.. isa graMtha meM isake sivAya kisI bhI sthAnameM cAra darzana ginAye hI nahIM hai. kSAyika aura kSAyopazamikabhedameM kamase eka aura tIna milake cAra darzana ginAye haiM. lekina kisI bhI sthAna meM cAradarzanake nAma to ginAyehI nahIM hai. isa sabase ina cAra nAmoMko jarUra kahanA cAhiye. aura matyAdijJAnake nAma to Age Agaye haiM, sababa nahIM kahanA hI lAjima haiM. digaMbaroM kI ulaTApAlaTa karane kI vicitratA to yaha hai ki yahAM spaSTatAkI jarUrata hai aura sUtrakArane spaSTatA kI hai vaha ur3A dete haiM aura F For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #156
(145) jidhara punaruktapanase saMkoca kiyA hai vahAM svayaM saMkucitatA kara baiThate haiM.. . (44 ) AThaveM adhyAyake 13 veM sUtrameM digambaraloga 'dAnalAbhabhogopabhogabIryANAM' aisA pATha mAnate haiM. taba zvetAmbaraloga 'dAnAdInAM' itanA hI sUtra mAnate haiM. zvetAmbaroMkA kahanA hai ki zrImAnne dUsare adhyAyake cauthe sUtra meM hI kSAyikake bheda ginAte dAna lAbha bhoga upabhoga aura vIrya ye pAMco hI bheda yathAkramase ginAye haiM. aura sUtrakArakI paddhatise ekavAra kahA huA dubArA kahanA ucita bhI nahIM hai. . . . .. (45) isI adhyAyake 20veM sUtra meM digambara 'zeSANAmantarmuhUrtAH' aisA pATha mAnate haiM. taba zvetAmbara 'zeSANAmantarmuhUrta' aisA pATha mAnate haiN| zvetAmbaroMkA kahanA hai ki aMtarmuhUrta yaha zabda avyayIbhAvase banA honese napuMsakaliMgakA hai. isase aMtarmuhUrta aisAhI honA cAhiye. aura saba zeSakokI jaghanyasthiti eka eka aMtarmuhartakI honese antamuhUrtazabdase Age bahuvacana karanA viruddha hai. kabhI aisA kahane meM Ave ki ekeka karmakI antarmuhUrttakI jaghanyasthiti honese saba zeSakarmokI apekSAse bahuta antarmuhUrta honese antarmuhUrtazabdake Age bahuvacana dharanA munAsiba hai, lekina yaha kahanA vyartha hai. isakA sababa yaha hai ki bahotakarmokI apekSAse :sthiti meM bahuvacana mAne to peztara jJAnAcaraNAdicArakarmokI utkRSThaH For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #157
( 146 ) sthiti tIsa koDAkoDI sAgaropama kahI hai vahAM para 'triMzataH ' aisA kahanA hogA aura nAmagotrakI sthiti bIsa sAgaropama koTi dikhAI hai to vahAM para 'viMzatI' aisA kahanA hogA. isI tarahase devatAoM kI sthiti meM pratyeka devatA aura devalo - krakI alaga 2 sthiti hone se palyopama aura sAgaropamameM sabhI sthAna meM bahubacana rakhanA hogA. ina saba sababoM se sApha hotA hai ki 'aMtarmuhUrtta ' aisA hI pATha honA cAhiye. ( 46 ) navameM adhyAyake 30 veM sUtra meM digambara 'ArttamamanojJasya 0' aura 31 meM 'viparItaM manojJasya' aisA pATha mAnate haiM. taba zvatAmbara' ArttamamanojJAnAM0' aisA pATha mAnate haiM. zvetAmbaroMkA kahanA hai ki anekatarahake amanojJa viSaya hote haiM aura dhyAnakA vakta muhUrtta takakA honese amanojJaviSayoke viyoga meM dhyAna hotA hai. aura anekaviSayoM kA samUharUpa se bhI viyukta hone ke liye dhyAna hotA hai. isase bahuvacana rakhanA yahI munAsIba hai. ( 47 ) sUtra 33 meM digambara 'nidAnaM ca' aisA sUtra pATha mAnate haiM aura zrutAmbara nidAnaM kAmopahatacittAnAM' aisA sUtrapATha mAnate haiM. zvetAmbara aura disambara donoMhI bhavAntarameM bhagavAnakI sevAkA milanA, zubhagurukA yoga milanA, guruvacanakA zravaNa pAnA ityAdi bAteM milane kI cAhanA karate haiM. lekina unako nidAna ginakara AdhyAna nahIM ginate haiM. isase kauna nidAna ArttadhyAna ginA jAya ? yaha socanA For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #158
( 147 ) cAhiye nirNaya yahI hogA ki viSayAsaktike pariNAma vAlekA hI nidAna ArttadhyAna hogA. ( 48 ) sUtra 36 meM digambara loga dharmadhyAnake adhikArIkA nirdeza nahIM karate haiM. zvetAmbara loga 'apramata saMyatastha' aisA kahakara dharmadhyAna ke adhikArIkA nirdeza karate haiM. tA baroMkA kathana hai ki yadi Artta, raudra aura zukladhyAna ke adhikArI bhagavAn umAsvAvijIne dikhAye haiM to phira idhara dharma dhyAna meM adhikArIkA nirdeza kyoM nahIM ? uparyukta vicAroMse zvetAmbara aura digambaroMke tatvArtha sambandhI kauna 2 sUtrameM pharka hai yaha bAta socane meM A gaI, ra isa tasvArtha sUtra ke Upara eka choTA bhASya hai jisako zvetAmbara loga mAnate haiM, aura dinacara loga nahIM mAnate haiM. usa bhASyako zvetAmbara loga sirpha mAnate hI haiM aisA nahIM, kintu usa bhASyako zrImAn umAsvAtivAcakajIne hI banAyA hai aisA mAnate haiM. bhASya ke karttA kI mImAMsA 3 aba socane kA yaha hai ki vaha bhASya zrImAn umAsvAtivAcakajIkA banAyA huA hai yA nahIM ? yaha mAnya svarya zrIumAsvAtivAcakajIne hI banAyA hai, usa viSaya meM yadyapi isakI vRtti banAnevAle zrIharibhadrasUrijI aura zrIsiddha senAcAryajI to sAphahI zabdoM meM usa bhASyako svopajJa dikhAte haiN| For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #159
(148) E bhASyakA svopajJatAkA vicAra.. ... (1) bhASyakAra mahArAja khudahI isa sUtra kA svakRtapanA dikhAte haiM, dekhiye saMbaMdhakArikA 31 'nate ca mokSamArgAd hitopadezo'sti jagati kRtsne'smin / tasmAt paramidameveti mokSamArga pravakSyAmi // 31 / / ' akalamaMda AdamI soca sakate haiM ki yadi sUtrakAra aura bhASyakAra ekahI nahIM hote to pravakSyAmi / aisA asmatzandakI sAtha honevAlA kriyApada nahIM kahate. .. (2) sAre bhASyako dekhanevAlA manuSya acchItarahase dekha saktA hai ki bhASyameM ekabhI jagaha para sUtrakArake liye bahumAnakA eka vacanabhI nahIM AyA hai. yadi sUtrakAramahArAjase bhASyakAra alaga hote to kabhI bhI sUtrakArake bahumAnakI paMktiyAM yA vizeSaNa kahe binA nahIM rhte| (3) bhASyakArane kisIbhI sthAnameM avataraNake adhi. kAra Adi sUtrakArase bhinnapanA nahIM dikhAyA hai. yA vaikalpikapanabhI nahIM dikhAyA hai... (4) bhASyakArane kisIbhI sthAnameM sUtrakA duruktapana yA sUktapanakA vicAra nahIM kiyA hai. (5) bhASyakAramahArAjane kisIbhI sthAnameM sUtrakArane aisA kahA hai sUtrakAra aisA kahate haiM aisA kathana nahIM kiyA hai. aura vyAkhyAkA vikalpabhI nahIM dikhAyA hai... For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #160
(149) (6) bhASyakArane jahAM parabhI sUtrakA avataraNa diyA hai vahAM sUtrakI sAkSI dene parabhI 'uktaM bhavatA' Adi sUtrakAra aura bhASyakArakA abhedapanA dikhAnevAlAhI zabdaprayoga kiyA hai. dekhiye ve ' atra bhavatA' Adi abhedadarzaka sthAnoM, jisake dekhane se Apa vAcakoMko pUrA nirNaya ho jAyagA ki yaha bhASya sUtrakAramahArAjakAhI kiyA haika bhASya ( kalakattAkI pustaka) pRSTha 39 uktaM bhavatA' jIvAdIni tattvAni' yAne jIvAdi tacco Apane dikhAye, sUtra 4 meM jIvAdi dikhAye haiM. yadi bhASyakAramahArAja aura sUtrakAramahArAja alaga hote to idhara 'uktaM bhavatA' aisA prayoga nahIM hotA.. . kha pRSTha 45 meM 'uktaM bhavatA paMceMdriyANIti' Apane indriyAM pAMca haiM aisA kahA hai . yaha sUtra a. 2 sUtra 15 * ga pRSTha 45 meM hI uktaM bhavatA pRthivyabvanaspatitejo vAyavo dvIndriyAdayazca nava jIvanikAyAH (a2 sU.13-14) aura paMcendriyANi ( a.2 sU 15) ceti, isako socanese yaha sApha ho jAyagA ke bhASya sUtrakArane hI kiyA hai, aura pRthivyadhanaspatyAdikA kramahI sthAvara aura trasake viSayameM mAnA hai. gha pRSTha 46 'uktaM bhavatA dvividhA jIvAH samanaskA amana - skAzceti' (a. 2 sU. 11) For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #161
(150) Ga pRSTha 66 ' uktaM bhavatA nArakA iti gati pratItya yiko bhAvaH / (a 2 sU 6 gatikaSAya. ) ca pRSTha 77 ' uktaM bhavatA lokAkAzevagAhaH (5-12) 'tadanantaramUrdhva gacchatyA lokAntAditi' (105) isa sthAnameM jyAdA to khyAla yaha karanekA hai ke tIsare adhyAyameM bhASyakAra ' uktaM bhavatA' aisA kahate haiM, aura ve sUtra to bahota Age AyeMge, isa bAtako socanese nirNaya ho jAyagA ke yaha 'uktaM bhavatA' kA prayoga bhASyakI apekSAse nahIM hai, kintu pestara sUtrakI racanA apanehI kI hai usakI apekSAse hI hai. cha pRSTha 86 ' uktaM bhavatA mAnuSasya svabhAvamArdavArjavatvaM ca' ... ( alpAraMbhaparigrahatvaM svabhAvamAdevArjavaM ca mAnuSasya a. 6 sU. 18) . ja pRSTha 92 'uktaM bhavatA bhavapratyayo'vadhi rakadevAnAmiti' - (bhavapratyayo nArakadevAnAM (a 1 sU 22) tathaudayi keSa bhAveSu devagatiriti (2-6 gatikaSAyetyAdi ) kevalizrutasaMghadharmadevArNavAdo darzanamohasya ( a. 6 sU. 14) sarAgasaMyamAdayo devasya (sarAgasaMyamasaMyamAsaMyamAkAmanirjarAbAlatapAMsi ca devasya ( a. 6 sU 20 ), nArakasaMmRcchino napuMsakAni, na devAH ( a. 2 sU. 50-51) . For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #162
( 151 ) jha pRSTha 96 ' uktaM bhavatA devAzcaturnikAyAH ( 4-1 ) dazA STapaJcadvAdazavikalpAH ( 4-3 ) Ja pRSTha 111 ' uktaM bhavatA dvividhA vaimAnikA devAH, kalpopapannAH kalpAtItAzca ( a. 4 sU 18 ) Ta' pRSTha 113 uktaM bhavatA jIvasyaudayikeSu bhAveSu tiryag yonigatiriti ( a. 2 sU. 6 ) ( gatikaSAyaliMgetyAdi) tathA sthitau tiryagyonInAM ceti (3-18) AzraveSu ca mAyA tairyagyonasya ( a. 6 17 ) iti. Tha pRSTha 134 'uktaM bhavatA saMghAtabhedebhyaH skandhAH utpadyante (a. 5.26 saMghAta bhedebhya utpadyante ) Da pRSTha 135 'uktaM bhavatA jaghanyaguNavarjAnAM snigdhAnAM rUkSeNa rUkSANAM ca snigdhena saha baMdho bhavatIti' ( na jaghanyaguNAnAm 5-33 ) , , Dha pRSTha 136 ' uktaM bhavatA dravyANi jIvAzca ' (5-2 ) Na pRSTha 137 ' uktaM bhavatA guNaparyAyavad dravyam (5-37) ta pRSTha 137' uktaM bhavatA bandhe samAdhiko pAriNAmiko (5-36) tha pRSTha 143 ' uktaM bhavatA sakaSAyAkaSAyayoryogaH sAmparA keryApathayo: ' (65) ( sakaSAyAkaSAyayoH sAmparAyikeryApathayoH ) da pRSTha 149 'uktaM bhavatA sadvedyasyAzraveSu bhUtavratyanukampeti' ( 6-13 ) For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #163
(152) dha pRSTha- 154 'uktaM bhavatA hiMsAdibhyo virativrataM ' ( hiMsA nRtasteyAbrahmaparigrahebhyo virativratam 7-11) na pRSTha 183 ' uktaM bhavatA guptyAdibhirabhyupAyaiH saMvaro ___ bhavatIti ' (9.2 sa guptisamitidharmAnuprekSA0) pa pRSTha 207 'uktaM bhavatA pUrve zukle dhyAne (zukle cAye.9-39) - pare zukle dhyAne ( pare kevalinaH 9.40) pha pRSTha 208 / uktaM bhavatA parISahajayAttapaso'nubhAvatazca karmanirjarA bhavatIti' (9-3 tapasA nirjarA ca, 8-22 . vipAko'nubhAvaH, 8.24 tatazca nirjarA) ba pRSTha 3 tattvArthAthigamAkhyaM bahvartha saMgrahaM laghugraMtham / vakSyAmi ziSyahitamimamarhadvacanaikadezasya // 22 // ina vacanoMse bhI sApha hojAtA hai ke bhASyakArahI sUtrakAra hai, yadi donoM ekahI nahIM hote to ' vakSyAmi' aisA graMtha karaneke viSayameM nahIM kahate.. 'bha pRSTha 5 (taM purastAllakSaNato vidhAnatazca vistareNopade kSyAmaH' isa sthAnameMbhI : upadecyAmaH' aisA prayoga mokSamArgake lie tabahI hove ke jaba mUlakArahI bhASya kAra hove..... ma pRSTha 7 'tA~llakSaNato vidhAnatazca purastAd vistareNopade kSyAmaH / sUtrakArahI bhASyakAra nahIM hote to idhara 'vakSyanti' aisA kahate / For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #164
(153) ya pRSTha 16 bhASyakAra likhate haiM ke 'uktaM bhavatA matyAdIni jJAnAni uddizya tAni vidhAnato lakSaNatazca purastAdvistareNa vakSyAma iti taducyatAmiti / atrocyate / matiH smRtiH saMjJA cintetyAdi, ina paMktiyoMkoM socanevAle akalamaMda to jarUra maMjura kareMge ke isa vacanase sUtrakAra aura bhASyakAra ekahI vyakti hai, kyoMke aisA nahIM hotA to bhASyakAraka vacanakA dAkhalA leke zaMkA uThAnI aura pIche sUtrase samAdhAna karanA yaha donoMke kA eka na hove to kabhI bhI bane nahIM: isI tarahase pRSTha 9 'aNavaH skaMdhAzca (5.25) saMghAtabhedabhya utpadyante ( 5-26 ) iti vakSyAmaH, pRSTha 16 nayabAdAntareNa tu yathA matizruttavikalpajAni bhavanti tathA ra pRSTha 32 cAritraM navame'dhyAye vakSyAmaH, nayAna vakSyAmaH, pRSTha 48 sakaSAyatvA0 (2.2 . kAyavAGmanaHprANA0 . (5-19 nAmapratyayAH0 ( 8-24) iti vkssyaamH| pRSTha 166 bandhaM vakSyAmaH / pRSTha 172 sthitibandhaM vkssyaamH| pRSTha 180 anubhAvabandhaM vkssyaamH| For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #165
(154) pRSTha 181 pradezabandhaM vakSyAmaH / pRSTha 183 saMvaraM vakSyAmaH / pRSTha 195 parISahAn vakSyAmaH / pRSTha 200 ita UrdhvaM yadvakSyAmaH / ina saba sthAnoM meM mUlasUtrakArake viSayameM tIsare puruSake kriyApadakI jarUrata thI, lekina mUla aura bhASyake racayitA ekahI honese sarvatra 'vakSyAmaH' aisA asmatzandake kriyApadakA prayoga kiyA hai| la ina saba pramANose jyAdaha balavattara pramANa nIce dikhAte haiM. isa nIce diye hue pramANase sApha mAlUma hojAyagA ki tattvArthake mUlasUtrakAra aura bhASyakAra ekahI hai. isa pramANako jyAdaha balavattara kahanekA muddA yaha hai ki khudahI bhASyakAra mahArAja apanI spaSTa vRtti dikhAte haiM. pRSTha 232 vAcakamukhyasya0 / vAcanayA ca mahA. nyagrodhikAprasUtena0 / arhadvacanaM samyagguru0 / idamuccai - garavAcakena satvAnukampayA dRbdhaM / tattvArthAdhigamAkhyaM spaSTamumAsvAtinA ( svAtitanayena) zAstram // 5 // aisA spaSTa pramANamaya ullekha hone parabhI bhASyakArako nahIM mAnanA, yaha kaisA abhinivezakA prabhAva hogA so vAcakagaNa ApahI soceM For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #166
( 155) 00000000 0000000 sababa 0000000000 30000000 00 bhASyako uparyukta pramANoMse vAcakoMko spaSTa mAlUma hogayA nAmaMjUra hogA ki jina umAsvAtivAcakajIne tavArthakaranekA sUtra banAyA hai, unhonehI yaha bhASyabhI banAyA hai. vAcakako aba yaha zaMkA jarUra hogI ki aisA spaSTa pramANa hote digambara loga tattvArthasUtra ko maMjUra karate haiM, lekina bhASyako kyoM nahIM maMjUra karate haiM ?, parantu yaha zaMkA unhIM vAcakoM ko hogI ki jo digambaroMkI rItise paricita nahIM haiM. kyoMki una logoMko asala to tatvArtha hI mAnanA ucita nahIM hai sababa ki isameM saMgamAtrako parigraha nahIM kahA hai, kevalI mahArAjako gyAraha parISaha mAnakara kevalIko AhAra mAnA hai. bakuzako bhI nigraMtha mAnA hai, lekina ye loga ina mUlasUtroMkA artha apane majahabake anukUla Thoka ThAka kara baiThA lete haiM. lekina jaba bhASyako maMjUra kareM taba to apanA kapolakalpita artha cale nahIM, isase ina digambaroMne bhASyako nAmaMjura hI rakkhA. bhASyakAramahArAjane to vivecana meM aisA spaSTa pharmAyA hai ki jisase digambaroMko apanI maMtavyatA choDakara zvetAmbaroMkI mantavyatA maMjUra karanI hI paDe. dekhiye7 11 kA bhA. - cetanAvatsu acetaneSu ca bAhyAbhyantareSu dravyeSu mUrchA parigrahaH For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #167
9-11 kA bhA -ekAdaza pariSahAH jine vedanIyAzrayAH saMbhavanti, tadyathA kSutpipAsAzItoSNadaMzamazakacaryAzayyA vadharogatRNasparzamalaparISahAH 9-48 kA bhASya-zarIropakaraNavibhUSAnuvartina RddhiyazaskAmAH sAtagauravAzritAH aviviktaparivArA chedazaralayuktA nigraMthA bakuzAH, liMgaM dvividha-dravyaliMgaM bhAvaliMgaM ca, bhAvaliMgaM pratItya sarve paMca nigraMthA. bhAvaliMge bhavanti, dravyaliMga pratItya bhAjyA: ... liMga strIpunapuMsakAni, pratyutpannabhAvaprajJApanIyasyAvedaH sidhyati, dravyAlagaM trividhaMsvaliMgamanyaliMgaM gRhiliNgmiti,ttprtimaajy| sarvastokA napuMsakaliMgasiddhAH strIliMgasiddhAH saMkhyeyaguNAH puliMgAsiddhA saMkhyeyaguNA iti / ahecchAsanAnuSThAyinAM zrutadharANAM bAlatapasvi. zaikSyaglAnAdInAM ca saMgrahopagrahAnugrahakAritvaM prvcnvtsltvmiti| anujJApitapAnabhojanamiti / 7-33 AtmaparAnugrahArtha svasya-dravyajAtasya annapAtra bastrAdeH pAtre'tisargo dAnam / tatra bATo dvAdazakarUpasyopadheH / . For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #168
(157) 9-49kA bhASya-bakuzo dvividhaH-upakaraNa rakuzaH zarIrabakuzazca, tatropakaraNAbhiSvaktacitto vividhavicitramahAdhanopakaraNaparigrahayukto bahuvizeSopakaraNakAkSAyukto nityaM tatpratIkArasevI bhikSurupakaraNa bakuzo bhavati / uparyukta vAkyoMko dekhakara digambaroMne bhASya khuda sUtrakArane kiyA hone parabhI maMjUra kiyA nahIM hai. yadyapi digambaroMne isa bhASyako mAnya nahIM bhASyakA kiyA hai, lekina digambaroM ke AcAryoMne isI anukaraNa bhASyako dekhakara usake Uparase hI bAdameM sarvAthIsaddhiAdi TIkAe~ banAI hai. svoo.0000000004 zrImAn gaNadharamahArAjane aura AcArya kRtikI mahArAjAoMne anantagama aura nayake AvazyakatA vicArase yukta aMgoMkI racanA kI thI, aura vaha kRti zrImAnakI vakta acchI taraha vidyamAnabhI thI, to phira sUtrakAramahArAjako tatvArtha banAnekI kyA jarUrata thI? zrImAnane isa zAstrameM kahI huI bAtoM sUtroM meM spaSTa upalabdha thI aura abhI bhI upalabdha hai. dekhiye ! samyagdarzanAdi mokSamArgake lie 'nAdaMsaNissa nANaM nANeNa viNA Na hoMti caraNaguNA / 0000000000000 For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #169
(158) caraNAhiMto mokkho mokkhe sokkhaM aNAbAhaM / uttarA. adhya. isI tarahase paNNavaNAjI aura uttarAdhyayanameM nisargAdhigama samyatvakA byAna pada 1 aura uttarAdhya0 kI gAthAoM meM hai, satsaMkhyAkSetrAdike lie saMtapayaparUvaNA anuyogadvAromeM, jJAnakA sArA adhikAra nandIsUtrameM, nayakA adhikAra anuyogadvArameM, mAvokA adhikAra anuyogadvAromeM, jIvoke bheda jIvAbhigama aura paNNavaNA, zarIrakA adhikAra prajJApanAmeM aura anuyogadvArameM, narakakA adhikAra jIvAbhigama bhagavatIjIAdimeM, bharatAdikSatroMke lie jaMbUdvIpaprajJapti zeSa samastadvIpasamudroke lie bhagavatIjI aura anuyogadvAra aura jIvAbhigama, devatAoMkA adhikAra sthAnAMga samavAyAMga bhagavatI prajJApanA jIvAbhigamAdi, kAla aura sUrya caMdrAdi bhramaNaAdike lie sthAnAMga bhagavatI jaMbUdvIpaprajJapti caMdraprajJapti sUryaprajJaptiAdi, devatAoMkI sthitike liye prajJApanAkA sthitipadaAdi, dharmAstikAyAdidravyoMke lie anuyogadvArasthAnAMgabhagavatIAdi,pudgaloMke skandhavarNa zabdake lie uttarAdhyayana prajJApanA bhagavatI sthAnAMgAdi, utpAdAdi syAdvAdake lie nayApekSayukta anuyogadvAra bhagavatIAdi, dravyAMdike lakSaNoMke lie uttarAdhyayanAdi,Azravake lie sthAnAMga bhagavatIAdi, jJAnAvaraNAdihetuoMke lie zrIbhagavatIjI paMcasaMgrahAdiprakaraNa dezasarvavirati aura bhAvanAke lie sUgaDAMga AcArAMga upAsakadazAdi, aticAroMke lie upAsakadazAMgazrAddhapratikramaNAdi, For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #170
( 159 ) karmake bhedoke lie sthAnAMga prajJApanA bhagavatI karmaprakRtyAdi, karmokI sthiti ke lie sthAnAMga samavAyAMga prajJApanAdi, saMvarake lie uttarAdhdhayana dazavaikAliMka AcArAMgAdi, parISahake lie uttarAdhyayanabhagavatyAdi, tapasyA ke lie uttarAdhyayana aupapAtika sthAnAMga bhagavatyAdi, dhyAnake lie Avazyakaniryukti aupapAtika sthAnAMgAdi, nirgrathoMke svarUpake lie bhagavatI uttarAdhyayana sthAnAMgAdi, mokSa ke lie aupapAtika prajJApanAdi, ina sabakI matalaba yaha hai ki zrImAn umAsvAtivAcakajIne tattvArtha sUtra meM jo hakIkata kahI hai ve sUtroM meM anupalabdha nahIM hai, taba aisA hai to pIche aisA alaga sUtra karanekI kyA jarUrata thI ? aisA alaga sUtra banAnese to vidyArthiloga isase hI saMtuSTa ho jAyeMge aura Age sUtra dekhane kA prayatna nahIM kareMge aura aisA honeM se sUtrakAragaNadhara mahArAjakI avajJA hogI. dekhate bhI haiM ki digaMbaraloga isI tantrArthako maMjura karate haiM aura saba sUtra siddhAMtoMko uDA dete haiM. yadi vAcakajI mahArAjane yaha nahIM banAyA hotA to digaM baroMko aisA sUtrApalApakA mahApApa aMgIkAra karane kA maukA nahIM bhI AtA, pUrvoktazaMkAke samAdhAna meM peztara to yahI samajha lenA yogya hai ki jainoM meM na to 'pUrvapUrvamunInAM prAmANyaM' aisA niyama hai, aura na. 'uttarottaramunInAM prAmANyaM' aisA niyama haiM, kintu pUrvApara aviruddha syAdvAdamaya padArthako mAnanA yahI niyama haiM. isase zraddhAluoM ko to padArtha sUtrameM se mile yA dUsare graMthose mile For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #171
(160) usameM kisIbhI tarahakI haraja nahIM hai, asalameM sUtrake adhikArI hone parabhI Adyase hI saba koI sabhI sUtrake adhikArI nahIM hote haiM. isase AdyAdhikAriyoM ko phAyadA pahoMcAnA yaha isa graMthakA uddezya hai. dUsarA muddA yaha bhI hai ki Apake kathanase bhI yaha bAta to spaSTa hai ki isa tattvArthameM kahe hue viSaya zrIgaNadharapraNIta. sUtromeM hai lekina viprakIrNa hai, to aise viprakIrNapadArthako. ekatra karake kahanA yaha kamaupayogI nahIM hai. tIsarA muddA yaha bhI hai ki sUtroMmeM jahAM jahAM padArthoM kA svarUpa kahA hai vahAM baDe baDe vistArase. aura sAgapUrNatAse kahA hai. aura saba vidyArthigaNa aimA bistArayukta aura sarvAMgapUrNa tatva avadhAraNa karaneko samarthana hove, isase vaise ke lie aisA laghusaMgraha banAnekI jarUrata kama nahIM hai. cauthA muddA yahabhI hai ki zAstroMmeM jisarUpase jIvAdrika tacoMkA svarUpa kahA gayA hai usase idhara kucha aurahI rUpase jIvAditattva kahe haiM, yAne jaisA idhara sampradarzanAdikakramase jIvAdi padArtha nirUpita haiM vaisA krama kisIbhI sUtra meM nahIM hai. pAMcaveM muddemeM abhyAsiyoMko mukhapATha karane meM laghu sUtra hone se bar3I subhItA rahatI hai, khuda gaNadhara mahArAjAoMnebhI bhagavatIjIAdisUtroke zatakauddezakI AdimeM saMgraha dikhAyA hai. aura zrIsamavAyAMgajI aura nandIjImeM AcArAMgAdikasUtrakI saMgrahaNI aura zrIpAkSikasUtrameM bhI kAlika utkAlika sabhIkI saMgrahaNI kahI hai, isase sabakA saMgraha yaha For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #172
kA hAnAyagA boTIvArakA sase (161) tattvArthakA honA munAsibahI hai, ina saba kAraNoMko socate spaSTa mAlUma hojAyagA ki vAcakajImahArAjakI yaha racanA atyaMta Avazyaka hai, aisI choTI kRtise vidyArthiyoMko tattvapadArthoM kA samajhanA sahela honese sUtrakArakA kahA huvA vistRta bayAna jAnane ko taiyAra aura lAyaka ho jAyaMgeM. isase zrIvAcakajImahArAjane sUtrakAskI avajJA nahIM kI, kintu sUtrakAramahArAjakI baDIhI bhakti kI hai. AkhirameM jo Apane kahAki digaMbaraloga isI tattvArthako mAnya karake sUtroMko uDA dete haiM, to isameM aisAhI kahA jAyaki AgADhamithyAtvakA udaya hojAya aura aisA kare usameM zrIvAcakajImahArAjakA kyA doSa ?, kyA aisA tatvArtha jaisA graMtha nahIM hotA to ve digaMbara AgADhamithyAtvI nahIM hote ?, kabhI nahIM, to pIche isa AgADhamithyAtvavAlekA vicArale ke vAcakajI para doSAropa kaise kiyA jAyI, ina digaMbara logako to utthApakapana aura viparyAsakAritva galemeMhI lagA hai. usameM koI kyA karegA?, dekhiye ! ina logoMne bhagavAnakI mUrtiko bhI cakSuhIna kara dI, itanAhI nahIM, balke palyaMkaAsanase baiThane para kimIbhI AdamIkA liMgaAdi dRzya nahIM hotA hai, tababhI ina digaMbaroMne palyaMkAsanastha bhagavatpratimAko bhI hAthake Age liMga lagA diyA hai, asalameM bhagavAnakA liMga adRzya thA, usakobhI inone nahIM socA. digaMbaraloga yaha nahIM socate haiM ki jaba tattvArthasUtrako maMjUra karanA hai to pIche zrImAn For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #173
tatvArthakA honA munAsibahI hai, ina saba kAraNoMko socate spaSTa mAlUma hojAyagA ki vAcakajImahArAjakI yaha racanA atyaMta Avazyaka hai, aisI choTI kRtise vidyArthiyoM ko tattvapaH dArthoM kA samajhanA sahela honese sUtrakArakA kahA huvA vistRta bayAna jAnane ko taiyAra aura lAyaka ho jAyaMgeM. isase zrIvAcakajImahArAjane sUtrakArakI avajJA nahIM kI, kintu sUtrakAramahArAjakI baDIhI bhakti kI hai. Akhira meM jo Apane kahAki digaMbaraloga isI tatvArthako mAnya karake sUtroMko uDA dete haiM, to isameM aisAhI kahA jAyaki AgADhamithyAtvakA udaya hojAya aura aisA kare usameM zrIvAcakajImahArAjakA kyA doSa ?, kyA aisA tavArtha jaisA graMtha nahIM hotA to ve digaMbara AgADhamithyAtvI nahIM hote ?, kabhI nahIM, to pIche isa AgADhamithyAtvavAlekA vicAra le ke vAcakajI para doSAropa kaise kiyA jAya?, ina digaMbara logako to utthApakapana aura viparyAsakAritva gale hI lagA hai. usameM koI kyA karegA?, dekhiye ! ina logoMne bhagavAnakI mUrtiko bhI cakSuhIna kara dI, itanAhI nahIM, balke palyaMkaAsanase baiThane para kimIbhI AdamIkA liMgaAdi dRzya nahIM hotA hai, tavabhI ina digaMbaroMne palyaMkAsanastha bhagavatpratimAko bhI hAthake Age liMga lagA diyA hai, asalameM bhagavAnakA liMga adRzya thA, usakobhI inone nahIM socA. digaMbaraloga yaha nahIM socate haiM ki jaba tatvArthasUtrako maMjUra karanA hai to pIche zrImAn For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #174
( 163 ) racanA kyoM kI ?, yaha tIsarI zaMkA hogI, cauthI zaMkA yaha bhI hogI ki adhyayanakartAoMko mukhapATha karanemeM aura dhAraNa smaraNa meM upayogI vaisI padyabandha racanA nahIM karate gadyabandha racanA idhara kyoM kI gaI ?, ina zaMkAoMke samAdhAna isa taraha se kramasara samajane cAhie, isako sUtra kahane kA yaha sababa mAlUma hotA ki prakaraNakA kArya ekeka aMzako vyutpAdana karanekA hotA hai, aura isa sUtra meM saba viSayoMkA pratipAdana hai. asala to jaise jaimini Adine apane apane majahabake darzanasUtra banAye, isItarahase yaha zrIsvArtha bhI jainamajahabakA darzanasUtra banAyA hai, isIsI isako sUtra kahA jAtA hai. yahI samAdhAna vibhAgakA nAma adhyAya tarIke rakhane meM aura gadyabandhasUtrakI racanA karane meM bhI samajanA, kyoMki dUsare darzanazAstrabhI adhyAyavibhAgase aura gadyasUtra se hI hai, aise yaha sUtrabhI racA gayA hai, isI tarahase dUsare dazarnazAstra grantha saMskRtabhASAmeM honese hI yaha sUtra bhI saMskRtabhASA hI banAyA gayA hai. jainIloga akelI prAkRtabhASAhI mAnya karate haiM. yaha kahanA hI besamajhakA hai, kyoMki jainoMke sthAnAMga aura anuyogadvArasUtrameM ' sakayA pakayA ceva' isa vAkyase saMskRta aura prAkRta donoM bhASA ekasarIkhI mAnI hai. zrImAn tIrthakara mahArAjAdikI dezanA jisa prAkRtameM mAnI hai, vaha prAkRta abhI kahI jAtI hai vaisI saMskRtajanya prAkRta nahIM hai, kintu aDhAratarahakI dezI bhASAse mizrita ardhamAgadhI prAkRta.. * For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #175
( 164 ) isa bhASA se sabhI dezavAle zrotAoM ko dharmakA bodha acchItarahase ho sakatA hai. saMskRtabhASA meM dezanA dene se katipaya bidvAnoMkohI bodha miLa, lekina sAmAnya janatA to zrIjinezvara bhagavAna ke upadeza se vaMcita rahe, aura yadi aisA hove to pIche zrIjinezvaramahArAja jagadguru kaise baneM ?, devatAkI bhASA bhI ardhamAgadhI hI hai. isakA sababa bhI yahI hai ki AbAlagopAlako devatAke ArAdhana kI yogyatA hai. aura devatAko ArAdhakakA bhAva samajhane kI bhI jarUrata hai. itanAhI nahIM, kintu devatAkA vArtAlApa yadi saMskRtameM hI hove to AbAlagopAla ke sAtha tuSTa hokara vArtAlApa karanA yA varadAna denA asaMbhavitahI ho jAya. isase devatAoMkI bhASA bhI AbAlagopAlakI samajhameM AjAya aisI ardhamAgadhI mAnI gaI haiM, lekina saMskRta bhASA se vidvAnoMko samajhAnekI jarUra ginakehI zrImAn umAsvAtivAcakajIne yaha sUtra saMskRta meM hI banAyA hai. saMskRtetara bhASA hI pUrvakAlameM pracalita thI isase azokAdikarAjAAdike prAcIna lekha bhI saMskRtetara bhASAmeM hI hai, prAcInatama koIbhI zilAlekha saMskRtabhASAmeM nahIM haiM, saMskRtazabdadI saMskRtabhASA ke asalIpanakA inkAra karatA hai, kyoMki koI bhI asalI bhASAkA saMskAra karake taiyAra kI huI bhASAhI saMskRta ho sakatI hai, aura isIse hI prAkRtabhASAko sUgaDAMganiyuktikAra For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #176
(165) svAbhAvikabhASA gina sakate haiM. prAkRtazabdakA artha bhI bhASAkA svAbhAvikapana dikhAtA hai. itanA hone parabhI jamAneke prabhAvase jaba saMskRtabhASAkI ora laukikavidvadgaNa jhukA aura logoMkI abhiruci saMskRtakI ora baDhI, aMtameM saMskRtameM hI vidvattA kI apUrvatA ginanameM AI. taba zrImAn umA svAtivAcakajIko bhI jainamahattAke lie tattvArthastra saMskRtabhASAmeM karanA jarUrI mAlUma huaa| Pos pUrvatarakAlIna jainasUtroMkI racanA darzana jJAnAdi AtmAkA svarUpa hai aura AzravAdi vikAra haiM. jisase AzravAdise haTa jAnA / chAyA.... aura jJAnAdike liyahI kaTibaddha honA isI uddezase kI jAtI thI, aura isI sababase bhava aura mokSameM bhI Akhira udAsInatAhI rahatI thI, isI sababase to kevalI. mahArAjako saMkalpa vikalpa rahita mAnate the, lekina sAMkhya, naiyAyika, mImAMsA, vaizASaka aura bauddha vagairahane jaba apane zAstra mokSake uddezase banAye aura logoMkI abhiruci bhI vaisI huI to zrImAn umAsvAtijIko bhI usItarahase isakI racanA karanI Avazyaka mAlUga huI. isIse hI zrImAnne 'samyagdarzanajJAnacAritrANi mokSamArgaH' aisA AdimeM hI bhokSakA uddeza karake sUtra banAyA. . ...... 00000000000000 Coces0000000000 For Personal & Private Use Only .

Page #177
1. isI tarahase sUtrakArabhagavAnane nisargaadhigamAdi samyaktvake daza bheda dikhAye the, taba vAcakajIne zeSa AjJAruciAdibhedoMkA antarbhAva nisarga aura adhigamameM kiyA, aura inako bhedakI tarahase nahIM lete hetukI taurase liye. sAthameM sUtrakAroM ne samyaktvako AtmAkA svarUpa mAnA thA,aura tattvArthako zraddhAko eka AstikyarUpa-liMgapanese lI thI. lekina vAcakajIye, zraddhAko lakSaNasvarUpameM lI hai. isakA sababa bhI dArzanika siddhAnta hI hai| kyoMke tarkAnusAriyoMke liye jitanA yaha lakSaNAdikA rAstA anukUla hogA utanA vaha nahIM hogaa| 2 sUtrakAroMne jJAna AtmAkA lakSaNa hai aisA karake jJAnakA bayAna kiyA hai, taba vAcakajIne padArthake adhigamake liye pramANakI jarUrata hai, aura vaha pramANa jJAnarUpa hai, isase jJAnake bayAnakI jarUrata ginaaii| .. 3 patrakAroMne upakramake bhedameM yA jJAnake dUsare pakSase pramANakI vyAkhyA kI thI. taba vAcakajIne jJAnakA svarUpa hI pramANa lekara vyAkhyA kI hai| 4 sUtrakAroMne aMgopAMgameM smaraNAdikake liye vibhAga nahIM kiyA thA, vaha inhoMne matijJAnameM smaraNAdi samAveza karake usakA parokSameM antarbhAva spaSTa rUpase dikhaa| .. 5 sUtrakAroMne cakSu aura manake lie amAppakAritA para dabAva nahIM diyA thA, taba vAcakajIne svataMtra stra banAkara For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #178
(167) cakSu aura manakI aprApyakAritA spaSTa kara dI, yaha bhI dArzanikasiddhAntake pracArake sababase hI saMbhavita hai. kyoMki bauddhoMkA mantavya cakSu mana aura zrotrakI aprApyakAritAkA hai, aura naiyAyikAdikoMkA mantavya aisA hai ki sparzanAdikI taraha cakSu bhI prApyakArI hI hai. vAcakajIne to sApha kaha diyA ki, cakSu aura mana ye donoM hI aprApyakArI haiM, aura sparzanAdi cAra prApyakArI hI hai| 6 dUsare darzanakAroMne piTaka aura vedAdike lie prAmANikatAkA nAda calAyA thA, taba vAcakajIne zrutake adhikArameM AcArAMgAdika aMga aura tadvyatirikta AhetavacanoMkI prAmANikatA pratiSThita kii| - 7 dUsare darzanakAroMne viparyAsa aura saMzayAdikako mithyAjJAna aura ajJAnazabdase pukArA hai, taba vAcakajIne jisakI dhAraNA padArthoMke lie yathAsthita nahIM hai aura sadasatke jo ekAntavAdI haiM ina sabhIkA bodha ajJAna hI hai, aisA dikhAyA hai. yAne pavitramantavyako mAnya karanevAle manuSyake saMzaya viparyAsavAle jJAnase bhI pavitrapadArthako nahIM mAnanevAlekI akala yA zAstrIyapravINatA unmArgakAhI vardhana karAnevAlI hai, itanA hI nahIM, balki vaiseko kisI paudgalikapadArthakA atIdriya aisA vibhaMgajJAna bhI ho jAya taba bhI vaha jJAna usa mahAtmAko aura usake upAsakoMko saMsArakI ora girAne For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #179
( 168 ) vAlA hai. yaha saba vivaraNa darzanakAroM ke pracArake prabhAvase hI jyAdA huvA hai / * 8 sUtrakAroMne sUtrakI vyAkhyA karate samajhe hue padArthaka acchI taraha se samajhAne ke lie nayoMkI jarUrata mAnI thI, aura isIse nayakA adhikAra anugamake anantara rakkhA thA, aura 'natthi naehiM vihUNaM suttaM attho va jiNamae kiMcI' aisA kahake samagra jinavacanameM nayakI vyApakatA dikhAI thI, taba vAcakajI ne samagrapadArtha ke jJAna meM una nayoMkI prAraMbhasehI upayogitA dikhAke pramANakI taraha naya bhI padArthaavabodhakA mukhya hetu hai aisA dikhAyA haiM / munizrI nItivijayajI jJAna bhaDAra. For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #180
HEARNERALARIA hU~ tattvajijJAsuoMke liye apUrvagraMtha, 1 zrIAcArAMgasUtra (dvitIya zruta skaMdha ) zrIzIlAMkAcAryakRta TIkAsahita ru. 2-052 zrIbhagavatIsUtra ( AcArya dAnazekhara sUrivihita TIka sahita ) ru. 5-0-0 te 3 zrItatvArthasUtra ( AcArya haribhadra mUrikRta TIkA aura svopajJa bhAdhya ) ru. 6-0-0 4 zrItattvArthasUtra ( mUla tathA svopajJa bhASya ) ru. 1----0 haiM 5 zrIparyuSaNAdazazataka ( mahopAdhyAya zrI dharmasAgaragaNi kRta svopajJa) ru. 0-10-0 66 puSpamAlA ( upadezamAna ) (maladhArI hemacaMdrasUrikRta svapajJa) ru. 6-0-0 7 vizeSAvazyaka bhASya pUrvArdha ra (shriikott.rkii| ru. 5-0-0 ro o m: Ser ing Jin Shascht D (dharma ru. 0-3-0 : prAptisthAna 020320 jainAnaMda pustakAlaya, gopIpurA sUrata. *IRECTORS ENCY TRESEARCHROGRAAT HARA baddhisAga qyanmandir@koatirth urg For Personal & Private Use Only