Sanch Ko Aanch Nahi

Author(s): Bhushan Shah
Publisher: Chandroday Parivar
Catalog link: https://jainqq.org/explore/006136/1

Page #1
sAMca ko AMca nahIM bhUSaNa zAha

Page #2
hamAre preraNA srota paramArebApAcI upAsakA zrI prema sukha jI mahArAja maritone Thma pIIRTAINY dAna yAtra

Page #3
// jainazAsana jayakArA // "sAMca kI AMca nahIM ("jaisI de vaisI mile kue kI guMjAra' pustaka kI samIkSA) * devaloka se divya sAnnidhya * pa.pU. gurudeva jaMbUvijayajI mahArAja * mArgadarzana . DaoN. prItamabena siMghavI * lekhaka bhUSaNa zAha -* prakAzaka * candrodaya parivAra B-405/406, sumatinAtha kompalekSa, bAbAvADI mAMDavI (kaccha) 370465

Page #4
(c) prakAzaka prati: 1,00,000 mUlya: 100/ prakAzana varSa : 2016 nyAya kSetraH zrI simaMdhara svAmi samavasaraNa - mahAvideha prApti sthAna : sunila bAlaDa jamanA vihAra- bhilavADA (rAja.) Apa online bhI paDha sakate hai.- www.jaineliabrary.org

Page #5
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM" "sAMca ko AMca nahIM, vaha to aTala hai" zramaNa bhagavAna mahAvIra ne 12 1/2 sAla kI ghora sAdhanA karake kevalajJAna kI prApti kI evaM svayaM ne jisa satya kA sAkSAtkAra kiyA, usa satya ko dezanA ke dvArA bhavyajIvoM ke Age pragaTa kiyA / zrI AcArAGaga sUtra meM prabhune batAyA hai ki - 'saccami dhiiM kuvvahA, etthovarae mehAvI savvaM pAvaM kammaM jhosai / ' (a.3.u.2.sU.112) yAni satya ko pAne kI icchA se taTastha bhAva se anveSaNa karo, satya ko pahacAnakara use svIkAro aura apanA jIvana usake anurUpa jiiyoN| jo bhavyajIva Agama ke dvArA nirdiSTa satya kI rAha para calane kA madhyastha bhAva se puruSArtha karatA hai, vaha sarva karmoM kA kSaya kara mokSa ko prApta karatA hai / satya to zAzvata hai, use koI badala nahIM sakatA hai| jarUrata hai kevala use svIkArane kI ! paraMtu dRSTirAga, kadAgraha, matAgraha ke kAraNa kucha loga apanI mAnyatA ke anusAra satya ko siddha karane kI koziza karate hai evaM satya jo dainika vyavahAra, manovijJAna, anubhava, bhagavAna mahAvIra se calI A rahI suvihita paraMparA, itihAsa evaM Agama se siddha hai, usako cunautI dene kA duHsAhasa karate haiM / aisI hI kucha koziza " jaisI de vaisI mile, kueM kI guMjAra" meM lekhaka dvArA aziSTa bhASA meM kI gayI hai / yaha pustaka sajjana logoM meM anAdeya hI siddha huI hai phira bhI 'gu~jAra' meM diye hue galata AkSepoM ko bholI janatA sahI na mAna leveM, isalie unakA pratikAra kiyA gayA hai / " " sAMca ko AMca nahIM vaha to aTala hai" isa bAta kA jJAna lekhaka evaM vAcakoM ko hoveM isa hetu "sAMca ko AMca nahIM " yaha pustikA prakAzita kI hai, jisameM "jaisI de vaisI mile, kue~ kI guMjAra" ke hara vibhAga kI Avazyaka samIkSA kI gayI hai / satya ke upara lagAye hue asatya AkSepoM kA nirAkaraNa karanA hI yahAM abhipreta hai, phira bhI kisI kI bhAvanA ko TheMsa pahu~cI ho yA vItarAga kI AjJA ke viruddha kucha likhA gayA ho, to micchAmi dukkaDam / tA. ka. : " jainAgama siddha mUrtipUjA" evaM "jaisI guMjAra" dono pustakeM sAtha meM rakhakara paDhane se Age ekadama spaSTa bodha ho sakegA / 1 bhUSaNa zAha de vaisI mile kue~ kI pIche ke saMdarbhoM kA -

Page #6
4600 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (09602 "guMjAra kI prastAvanA kI samIkSA" "jaisI de vaisI mile, kue kI guMjAra" pustikA dekhnane meM AyI / pUre jora se lekhaka mahAzaya jisa pustikA kA pracAra kara rahe hai, vaha pustikA "jainAgama siddha mUrtipUjA" ke prakAzana se ubharI dveSAgni ke phala svarupa hai| 'jainAgama siddha mUrtipUjA' pustaka, ratanalAlajI DosI ke 'jainAgama viruddha mUrtipUjA' ke javAba svarupa hai / usameM die gae javAba lagabhaga ziSTa bhASA meM haiM / jaisI de.... guMjAra meM 'jainAgama siddha mUrtipUjA' pustaka ke uttara kA aMza mAtra bhI nahIM hai, paraMtu dusarI - dusarI bAteM karake pustikA pUrI kI hai / tathA pustikA ke lekhaka zrI apane svabhAva anusAra gAlI - galoca kI bhASA meM yaha pustikA nikAlI hai / lekhaka kI vidvattA to tabhI kahalAtI, jaba zAlIna bhASA meM usakA uttara dete paraMtu vaha unase asaMbhava hone se kIcaDa uchAlane kA kAma kiyA hai| _____ dainika vyavahAra, manovijJAna, itihAsa evaM jainAgama se siddha aisI mUrtipUjA kI, prazAMta mudrAvAlI evaM zAMti kA saMdeza denevAlI jina pratimA kI jI bharake niMdA, pUrva mahApuruSoM kI niMdA evaM unake upara jhUThe Aropa ke mahApApa se lekhaka ko cAritra kA tyAga kara saMsAra meM AnA paDA / paraMtu re ajJAna ! terA kaisA mAhAtmya hai ki tU viddhAna kahe jAnevAle vyakti ko bhI mithyAtva meM bhramita rakhakara dusare nimittoM meM phasAtA hai| . lekhaka zrI mukhya pRSTha para likhate hai "mUrtipUjA evaM jaina dharma tathA hAthapattI ke Agama viruddha hone kI siddhi", yaha unakI pratijJA sarAsara jhUTha haiM, kyoMki pUrI pustikA meM eka bhI Agamika pramANa lekhaka zrI nahIM batA sake haiM / korI DIMge hAkakara bholI prajA-ajJAnI logoM ko phasAne ke kAma kie hai / jo Age samAlocanA meM pragaTa hoNge| __ pRSTha naM. 2 meM Apa likhate haiM "dhUrtoM kI dhUrtAI aura saDe dimAgavAloM = 2

Page #7
G000 sAMca ko AMca nahIM" 0902 kI (sAdhuoM kI) jAnakArI paricaya pAnA ho to sirohI ke paTanIjI ke pAsa pahoMce" isameM lekhakazrI ne itanA bhI vicAra nahIM kiyA ki ye saba vizeSaNa dusare ko dene gaye paraMtu khuda ko hI lAgU ho rahe hai / cU~ki jo vyakti kaba ke cala base hai, unake pAsa vAcakoM ko pahoMcAte ho, ise dhUrtAI nahIM to kyA kahe ? ___lekhaka zrI 'jainAgama siddha mUrtipUjA' pustaka kI prastAvanA evaM hRdaya kI bAta barAbara paDhate to, zAyada aisI mithyA bakavAsavAlI pustikA chapavAne kA kaSTa nahIM lete / sira-dhaDa binA kI vivAdapUrNa 'jainAgama viruddha mUrtipUjA' kI nayI - nayI AvRttiyA~ chapavAkara pracAra karanevAloM kA buddhi kA uphAna hai yA mUrtipUjakoM kA, vicAra kreN| mUrtipUjakoM ne to virodha kA javAba hI diyA ___zaMkAe sahI samAdhAna nahIM' pustikA vAstavika yathA nAma tathA guNa hai / usake uttara dene kI nirarthaka koziza kI hai / usameM prAya: praznoM ke samAdhAna nahIM ho pAte hai / jisameM niMdA - TippaNI kI, pAlI se prakAzita usa pustaka kA nAma likhanA thA para binA paricaya usake bAre meM kyA bAta kara sakate haiM ? zAMti samanvaya ke jamAne meM vivAda karane kI bAta lekhaka zrI ko hI lAgu paDatI hai, yaha kAma to khuda ne hI kiyA haiM, gumanAmI tIra pheMkA hai aura mobAIla naM. dekara bAta karane kA manA kiyA hai| - bhUSaNa zAha 3

Page #8
600 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 purovacana __ - A. jayasuMdarasUrijI ma.sA. kadAcit koI pUcha le ki "gagana meM sarya-candra camakate hai" - isameM kyA pramANa ? zAstra meM kahAM likhA hai ? anAdikAla se to vaha nahIM the aba yakAyaka kahA~ se A gaye ? kIna se AptapuruSo ne sUryacandra kA pracAra kiyA ? sUrya-candra kI mAnyatA adhikatara kitanI prAcIna hogI ? una mAnyatA meM pIche se kyA-kyA parivartana huA ? Adi - Adi / - aho ! ye prazna kitane gahare hai, kitane kaThina hai ? kyA kisI sAmAnya puruSa kI guMjAIza hai aise praznoM ke uttara dene kI ? aise tAttvika (!) prazna karane vAloM ko to hAtha jor3akara yahI kahanA par3egA, bhAI (!) tumhAre prazna bahuta gahana haiM, koI sarvajJa hI unakA samAdhAna kara sakatA hai| ThIka isI prakAra 16 vI zatAbdI meM jaina zAsana meM mUrtipUjA ke gahana viSaya meM bhI aise hI praznoM kI paramparA banAI gayI / bahuta se dhuraMdhara paNDitone una prazno ke uttara dene kA sAhasa kiyA, lekina praznakartA varga ko saMtoSa ho aisA una tAttvika (!) ora ati gahana (!) praznoM kA samAdhAna kauna kare ? Akhira una logoM ne mAna liyA - mUrti pUjA galata hai, azAstrIya hai, Adhunika hai, usameM kisI AptapuruSoM kI sammati nahIM hai| . .. basa ! eka nayA sampradAya bana gayA, kucha nAma rakha liyA, kucha veSa banA liyA, jhukane vAle mila gaye jo jhukAne vAloM kI tarakIba yA zarama se chUTa na pAe / kucha zAstra mAna lie aura kucha unakI managhaDaMta mAnyatAoM ke pratikUla the, unheM chor3a diye, kucha naye zAstra bhI banA lie, ho gyaa| bhagavAna mahAvIra kI mUrti ko chor3a diyA, nAma lene ke adhikAra ko to bar3e cAva se surakSita rkhaa| __ itihAsa ke panne ulaTAo, usameM to hara jagaha mUrti-pUjA kA hI samarthana milegA / itihAsa bhI una logoM ne nayA hI banA liyA, jisameM se -

Page #9
4-6000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 mUrtipUjA ko nikAla diyaa| ___are ! mUrtipUjA ! tUne kyA aisA aparAdha kiyA thA una logoM kA, jisase tere nAma se ve loga kAMpa uThate hai ? ... hAM ! vikrama kI sAtavIM zatAbdI taka kisI anAryane bhI tere khilApha . eka laphja bhI nahIM nikAlA thA / 1300-1400 varSa pUrva sabase pahile araba - deza meM mohammada paigambara ne terA bahiSkAra kara diyA, hA~ usake pAsa samaseroM kI bar3I tAkata thii| . vi. saM. 1544 ke nikaTavartI upAdhyAya zrI kamalasaMyamajI likhate hai ki usa paiyagambara kA anuyAyI phirojakhAna bAdazAha dillI ke takhta para ArUr3ha hokara mandira mUrtiyoM ko tor3ane lgaa| idhara usI kAla meM lokAzAha nAmaka eka jaina gRhastha apamAnita ho, saiyada se jA milA aura una mlecchoM ke kusaMga se mUrtipUjA kA jora zora se virodha karane lagA / jaina zAsana meM mUrtipUjA ke khilApha vidroha karane vAle yaha prathama hI thA / musalamAnoM kI ora se usako mUrtipUjA ke khilApha pracAra karane meM bahuta sahAyatA milI / eka sampradAya bana gayA lokAgaccha ke nAma se, kintu unake anuyAyiyoM ne satya samajhakara phira se mUrti ko apanA liyA aura lokAgaccha meM punaH mUrtipUjA pUrvavat prArambha ho gayI / kAla ke prabhAva se dharmasiMha aura lavajI RSi ne usa sampradAya se alaga hokara phira se lokAzAha kI bhakti ke nAma para mUrtipUjA ke khilApha bagAvata kI / unakA bhI sampradAya cala par3A, loga unako DhUMDhakamata ke nAma se pahicAnane lage jo nahIM jaMcA to Akhira sthAnakavAsI yA sAdhumArgI aisA sunaharA nAma banA liyaa| mUrtipUjA ke khilApha aneka prazna upasthita kiye gaye / mUrti-pUjaka sampradAya kI ora se una sabhI praznoM kA akATya tarko se aura unake mAnya zAstra pAThoM se samAdhAna kiyA gayA, mUrtipUjA meM cAra cA~da laga gaye / meghajI RSi, AtmArAmajI mahArAja ityAdi aneka bhavabhIru pApabhIru mahApuruSoM ne 5

Page #10
-600 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (09002 usa bebuniyAda sampradAya ko chor3a diyA aura mUrti-pUjA ke pakke samarthaka bana gye| 16 vI, 17 vI, 18 vI zatAbdiyoM meM ho gaye agaNita AcArya-muniyoM ne mUrtipUjA meM agaNita pramANa dete hue aneka nibandhoM kI racanA kI / mUrtipUjA ke khilApha jitane bhI prazna ho sakate haiM una sabhI kA zAstrAnusArI tarkagarbhita samAdhAna karane ke lie Aja to pracura mAtrA meM sAhitya, purAtattva, zAstrapATha aura prAcIna sAkSya upalabdha hai / taTastha buddhi se paryAlocana karane vAloM ko zuddha tattva nirNaya karane ke lie pracura sAmagrI upalabdha hai / itanA hote hue bhI mUrtipUjA ke vidveSa se usake khilApha likhane vAle lekhakoM kI Aja kamI nahIM hai, yadyapi aitihAsika tathyoM kI tor3a-mor3a kiye binA yaha sambhava hI nahIM hai| . bhUSaNa zAha ne aisI tor3a-mor3a karane vAle lekhakoM kI kuceSTA kA pardA phAza karane kA isa pustaka meM eka sarAhanIya kauzalapUrNa vidvadgamya prayAsa kiyA hai isameM sandeha nahIM hai / isase taTastha itihAsa ke jijJAsuoM ko satya-tathya kI upalabdhi hogI, bhAvabhIruvarga ko dizA parivartana kI preraNA bhI milegI, utpathagAmiyoM ko satyamArga kA prakAza milegaa| ___ mUrtipUjA zAstrokta aura Atmonnati ke lie Avazyaka evaM anivArya hai, isa tathya kI siddhi meM hajAroM pramANa maujUda hai / mUrtipUjA ko pramANita karane vAle AcAryoM meM upAdhyAya zrI yazovijayajI mahArAja kA nAma agrasara smaraNIya hai / sthAnakavAsI sampradAya meM bhI Aja inake jaina-tarkabhASA Adi granthoM kI bar3I pratiSThA hai / pratimAzataka, pratimAsthApananyAya, kUpadRSTAnta vizadIkaraNa, upadezarahasya, Sor3azaka TIkA ityAdi granthoM meM jina akATya pramANoM kA nirdeza kiyA hai, unake sAmane sabhI sthAnakavAsiyoM kA muMha Aja taka banda hI rahA hai| kisI ne bhI unake khilApha kucha bhI likhane kI himmata Aja taka nahIM kI hai| mUrtipUjA ke samarthaka aura bhI kaI grantha hai jinameM ye pramukha haiM - vAcaka

Page #11
-6000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 zekhara zrI umAsvAti AcArya mahArAja kRta pUjA prakaraNa, 14 pUrvI pUjya bhadrabAhusvAmI mahArAja kRta Avazyaka niyukti Adi, AcArya zrI haribhadrasUri mahArAja kRta pUjA paMcAzaka prakaraNa, Sor3azaka prakaraNa aura zrAvaka prajJapti TIkA evaM lalitavistarA grantha, AcArya zrI zAMtisUrijI mahArAja kRta caityavaMdana bRhadabhASya, avadhijJAnI zrI dharmadAsagaNi mahArAjakRta upadezamAlA, kalikAla sarvajJa zrI hemacandrAcArya mahArAja kRta yoga zAstra Adi grantha, navAMgI TIkAkAra AcArya zrI abhayadevasUri mahArAja kRta paMcAzaka vRtti / taduparAnta zrI jJAtA dharmakathA sUtra, ThANaMga sUtra, rAyapaseNI sUtra, jIvAbhIgama sUtra, mahA pratyAkhyAna sUtra, mahAkalpasUtra, mahAnizItha sUtra ityAdi mUla aMga-upAMga sUtroM meM bhI mUrtipUjA ke aneka ullekha bhare par3e hai| ___mahA kalpasUtra me gautama svAmI ke praznottara meM zrI mahAvIra bhagavAna ne kahA - "jo zramaNa jina maMdira ko na jAya use belA yA pAMca upavAsa kA prAyazcita AtA hai, usI taraha zrAvaka ko bhii|" tathA isI sUtra meM kahA hai - jo zrAvaka jina pUjA nahIM mAnate ve mithyAdRSTi hai / tathA samyagdRSTi zrAvaka ko jinamandira meM jAkara candana-puSpAdi se pUjA karanI caahie| ___ zrI bhagavatI sUtra meM - tuMgIyA nagarI ke zrAvakoM ne snAna karake devapUjana kiyA yaha ullekha hai - "hAyA kayabalikammA" zrI uvavAI sUtra meM campA nagarI ke varNana meM "bahulAi arihaMta ceiyAi" bahuta se arihanta caityoM yAnI jina maMdira kA ullekha hai| ___ zrI bhagavatI sUtra meM camarendra ke adhikAra meM tIna zaraNa dikhAye hai - "arihaMte vA arihaMta ceiyANi vA bhAviappaNo aNagArassa vaa|" yahAM arihaMta ceiyANi kA artha arihaMta kI pratimA eso hotA hai| ___zrI upAsakadazAMga Agama sUtra meM Ananda zrAvaka ke adhikAra meM jina pratimA vaMdana kA ullekha hai - "no khalu meM bhaMte ! kappa............. annautthiya pariggahiyANi arihaMta 7

Page #12
G007 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 ceiyANi vA vaMdittae vA namaMsittae vA / " ___yahAM anya tIrthikoM se parigRhIta jinapratimAoM ko vaMdana na karane ke niyama se anya tIthikoM se aparigRhIta jina pratimAoM ko vandana kI siddhi hotI hai| - zrI kalpasUtra meM bhI siddhArtha rAjA ne hajAroM kI saMkhyA meM jina pratimA pUjana karavAne kA "yAga" zabda se ullekha hai / ___ zrI vyavahAra sUtra meM jina pratimA ke sanmukha AlocanA (prAyazcita) karane kA ullekha haiN| . zrI praznavyAkaraNa sUtra meM nirjarArthI ko caityahetuka vaiyAvacca karane kA Adeza hai - "ceiyaDe......... ityAdi" sAdhu ko arthAt pratimA kI hilanA, avarNavAda aura anya AzAtanAoM kA nivAraNa karane kA kahA hai| ___zrI dIpasAgarapannati sUtra meM kahA hai ki svayaMbhUramaNa samudra meM jina pratimA ke AkAra vAle matsya hote hai, jinako dekhakara jAtismaraNa hone se tiryaMca jalacaroM ko samyaktva prApti hotI hai| zrI bhagavatI sUtra ke prArambha meM hI brAhI lipi ko bhI namaskAra kiyA isa prakAra aneka zAstra - Agama sUtroM se mUrtipUjA siddha hotI hai| mUrtipUjA se lAbha hotA hai yA nahIM ? - yaha to karanevAlA hI jAna sakatA hai, nahI karanevAle ko kyA patA ? hAM ! koI ikSurasa kI madhuratA kA cAhe kitanA bhI apalApa kare kintu usakA AsvAda karane vAlA to usake madhura rasa kA sAkSAt hI anubhava karatA hai / sthAnakavAsI aura terApaMthI bandhu aura sAdhu-saMtoM se yaha anurodha hai ki ve sabhI samudAya meM yA akele eka mAsa svayaM jina-mUrti kI upAsanA karake anubhava kare ki usameM lAbha hotA hai yA nahIM ? hasta kaMkaNa ko kabhI darpaNa kI jarUrata nahIM hotii| mUrtipUjA ke samarthaka lekha aura nibandhoM se vigata kucha varSoM meM yaha 8

Page #13
G007 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (09602 lAbha avazya huA hai ki kucha kaTTara virodhI sAdhuoM.... mahAsatioM ko chor3akara adhikAMza varga ne mUrtipUjA kA virodha karanA chor3a diyA hai / aneka sthAnakavAsI sadgRhasthoM ne maMdira meM darzana karanA prArambha bhI kiyA hai, hAlAMki ve loga gAMva meM pUjA-bhakti karane meM kucha hicakAte jarUra haiM kintu tIrthoM me jAkara pUjA-bhakti kara lete haiN| mUrtipUjA meM hiMsA hai sAvadha hai ityAdi jo pahale ghoSaNA kI jAtI thI, vaha bhI manda hotI jA rahI haiM, kyoMki mUrtipUjA meM koI hiMsAdi doSa nahIM balki agaNita lAbha hI hai, isa tathya ko zAstra, tarka aura anubhava kA puSTa samarthana hai| samaya samaya para mUrtipUjA ke samarthana meM aise lekha aura nibaMdha likhe hI jA rahe hai aura usI kA yaha satprabhAva hai ki hajAroM loga punaH mUrtipUjA ko Adara se dekhane lage haiM / isa pustaka se bhI yahI lAbha sampanna hogA yaha AzA kI jAtI hai / pustaka ke lekhaka kA yaha zubha prayatna niHsandeha abhinandana ke yogya hai| (sAbhAra - kalpita ItihAsa se sAvadhAna pustaka)

Page #14
4-0 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 'vyavahAra kA jJAna kI samIkSA isa prakaraNa meM lekhaka zrI ne kI huI sabhI bAteM khuda ko hI lAgu hotI hai| dI huI gAliyA~ bhI ribAuMsa (Rebounce) hokara unheM hI lgegii| cUMki mUrtipUjakoM ko kapUta aura khuda ke paMthavAloM ko sapUta batAkara yaha prakaraNa racA hai| apane muMha apanI baDhAIyA~ karanevAloM kI duniyA meM kamI nahIM haiN| pramANo se siddha kiye binA ve bAteM svIkArya nahIM hotI haiM / aba hama satya pramANoM ke AdhAra se 'mUrtipUjaka sapUta haiM', usakA nirNaya kareMge - .. sAloM pahale sthAnakavAsI aura digaMbara kalpasUtra ko aprAmANika kahate the / usakI paTTAvalIyoM ko kAlpanika kahate theM / paraMtu mathurA ke kaMkAlI TIle kA aMgrejoM dvArA utkhanana huA / usameM aneka atiprAcIna jinapratimAeM nikalI / ve Aja bhI purAtattva saMgrahAlaya meM vidyamAna hai / jinapara prAcIna lipI meM lekha haiM, usameM bahuta sAre AcAryoM ke nAma aMkita haiM / aneka viddhAnoM dvArA nirNaya hone para patA calA ki unakI zAkhA - gaNa Adi sabhI kalpasUtra kI paTTAvalI se hI milate haiM / prAcIna kalpasUtra kI pustakoM meM jaise garbhApahAra ke citra diye haiM, vaise dRzyavAlA zilApaTTa bhI milA, yaha dekhakara digaMbara, sthAkanavAsiyoM ko cuppI karanI paDI / itanA hone para bhI lekhaka to abhI bhI kalpasUtra meM prakSepa aura jhUThI kalpanAoM kA honA mAnate hai, yaha kaisA kadAgraha ? phirabhI usa kalpasUtra ke AdhAra se khuda ko sapUta kahane jA rahai hai ! hai nA lekhaka zrI kI aklamaMdatA ! kalpasUtra ko pramANa mAne binA khuda sapUta kaise baneMge ? sthAnakavAsI samAja ke samartha viddhAna devendramunizAstrIjI bhI kalpasUtra kI prAmANikatA ko svIkArate hue kahate hai ki - - "vartamAna meM jo paryuSaNAkalpasUtra hai, vaha dazAzrutaskaMdha kA hI AThavA~ adhyayana hai| dazAzrutaskaMdha kI prAcInatama pratiyA~ (14 vI zatAbdI se pUrva kI) jo puNyavijayajI mahArAja ke asIma saujanya se mujhe dekhane ko milI haiM, unameM AThaveM adhyayana meM pUrNa kalpasUtra AyA hai jo yaha spaSTa pramANita karatA hai ki - 10 -

Page #15
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM" 00/ kalpasUtra koI svataMtra evaM managaDhanta racanA nahIM hai apitu dazAzrutaskaMdha kA hI AThavA~ adhyayana hai / prazna ho sakatA hai ki Adhunika dazAzrutaskaMdha kI pratiyoM meM kalpasUtra likhA huA kyoM nahIM milatA ? isakA uttara yahI hai ki jaba se kalpasUtra kA vAMcana pRthak rUpa se prArambha huA, taba se dazAzrutaskaMdha meM se vaha adhyayana kama kara diyA gayA hogA / yadi pahale se hI vaha usameM sammilita na hotA to niyukti aura cUrNi meM usake padoM kI vyAkhyA nahI AtI / munizrI puNyavijayajI kA abhimata hai ki dazAzrutaskaMdha kI cUrNi lagabhaga solaha sau varSa purAnI hai / sthAnakavAsI jaina paramparA dazAzrutaskaMdha ko prAmANika Agama svIkAra karatI haiM to kalpasUtra ko jo usI kA eka vibhAga haiM, apramANika mAnane kA koI kAraNa nahIM pratIta hotA / mUla kalpasUtra meM aisA kaI prasaMga yA ghaTanA nahIM hai jo sthAnakavAsI paramparA kI mAnyatA ke viparIta ho / zramaNa bhagavAna mahAvIra kI jIvana jhA~kI kA varNana bhI jambUdvIpaprajJapti se viparIta nahIM hai / anya tIrthaGkaroM kA varNana jaisA sUtrarUpa meM anya Agama sAhitya meM bikharA par3A haiM, usI prakAra kA isameM bhI haiM / sAmAcArI kA varNana bhI Agama - sammata haiM / sthavirAvalI kA nirUpaNa bhI kucha parivartana ke sAtha nandIsUtra meM AyA hI hai / ata: hamArI dRSTi se kalpasUtra ko prAmANika mAnane meM bAdhA nahIM haiM / ( jaina Agama sAhitya manana aura bhImAMsA pR. 44. 545) kalpasUtra ke pahale sUtra meM 'teNaM kAleNaM teNaM samaeNaM samaNe bhagavaM mahAvIre.... aura aMtima sUtra meM.... bhujjo bhujjo uvadaMsei' pATha hai / vahI pATha dazAzruta skanda ke AThaveM uddezaka (dazA) meM haiM / yahA~ para zeSa pATha ko 'jAva' zabda ke antargata saMkSepa kara diyA hai / vartamAna meM jo pATha upalabdha hai usameM kevala paMcakalyANa kA hI nirUpaNa hai jisakA paryuSaNA kalpa ke sAtha koI sambandha nahIM haiM / ataH spaSTa hai ki paryuSaNA kalpa isa adhyayana meM pUrNa kalpasUtra thA / kalpasUtra aura dazAzrutaskandha ina donoM ke racayitA bhadrabAhu haiM / isalie donoM eka hI racanAkAra kI racanA hone se yaha kahA jA sakatA hai I 11

Page #16
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM" ki kalpasUtra dazAzrutaskandha kA AThavA~ adhyayana hI hai / vRtti, cUrNi, pRthvIcaMda TippaNa aura anya kalpasUtra kI TIkAoM se yaha spaSTa pramANika hai / " isa prakAra jaba etihAsika haiM saMzodhana evaM lekhaka ke mAnya AcArya kalpasUtra ko pramANika kara rahe taba unakI bAta bhI nahIM mAnane vAle lekhakazrI pUrvAcAryo ke sapUta kaise bana sakeMge ? pAThaka gaNa nirNaya kareM / zrI kalpasUtra meM yaha ullekha hai ki bhagavAna mahAvIra ke nirvANa ke samaya meM unakI rAzi para bhasmagraha kA AkramaNa huA, jisase bhagavAna mahAvIra ke bAda 2000 varSoM taka 'zramaNa saMgha' kI udaya udaya pUjA na hogI / ve 2000 varSa vi. saM. 1530 meM pUre hote haiM / usake bAda saM. 1531 meM lauMkAzAha ne kriyoddhAra kiyA, yaha hakIkata 'zrI jaina dharmano prAcIna saMkSipta itihAsa ane prabhuvIra paTTAvalI' pustaka se paDhakara use ajJAnatA se satya mAnakara lekhaka zrI uchala uchalakara khuda ko sapUta batAte hai / uparokta pustaka kI apramANikatA aura usameM saM. 1636 ke jina hastapatroM se vaha hakIkata lI hai usakI kUTatA kI siddhi Age kareMge / (dekhiye 'lokAzAha kA jIvana' kI samIkSA) prAmANika itihAsa se to yaha siddha hotA hai ki vi. saM. 1508 meM lokAzAha aura vi. saM. 1524 meM kaDuAzAha ne jaina dharma meM utpAta macAyA / aura ina donoM ke anuyAyI kahate haiM ki hamAre dharma sthApakoM ne dharma kA udyota kiyA / aba sarva prathama to yaha socanA cAhie ki " bhasmagraha ke kAraNa udaya udaya pUjA kA na honA, zramaNasaMgha ke lie likhA haiM, jabakI lokAzAha aura kaDuAzAha to gRhastha the, inakA bhasmagraha ke kyA sambandha hai ki ye bhasmagraha utarane ke pUrva hI dharma kA udyota kara sakeM / parantu vAstava meM yaha udyota nahIM thA kiMtu utarate hue bhasmagraha kI antima krUratA kA prabhAva thA, jo ina gRhasthoM para vaha DAlatA gayA / jaise dIpa aMtakAla me apanA carama prakAza dikhA jAtA hai, vaise hI bhasmagraha bhI jAte-jAte eka phaTakAra dikhA gayA / I idhara to bhasmagraha kA jAnA huA aura udhara zrI saMgha kI rAzi para dhumaketu nAmaka mahA vikarAla graha kA AnA huA / ina donoM azubha kAraNoM 12

Page #17
4-6000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 se ina donoM gRhasthoM ne jainadharma meM bhayaMkara phUTa aura kusampa DAlakara jainazAsana ko chinna-bhinna kara DAlA, jisake sAtha asaMyati pUjA nAmaka accherA kAM bhI prabhAva par3A ki donoM grahasthI asaMyati hone para bhI zramaNa-zramaNIoM kI udaya udaya pUjA uDAkara svayaM ko pUjavAne kI koziza karane lge| tInoM kAla meM yaha asaMbhava hai, ki prabhu kA zAsana asayaMti se cale aura sthAnakavAsI apane ko unakI (laukAzAha kI) saMtAna mAnate haiM, tabhI to lekhaka zrI ne likhA vaise "AkAza se Tapakane" jaisI hI bAta huI nA ? koI putra apane pitAdi ko gAliyA~ deveM - unakI AjJA na mAne aura phira dharohara para haka jamAne kI koziza kareM, use sapUta kaheMge yA kapUta ? pUrvAcAryoM kI niMdA karanA, 'unhoMne zAstra meM pATha ghuseDe, TIkAkAroM ne galata artha kiye,' vagairaha mithyA Aropa unapara lagAnA aura phira kahanA hama unake sapUta hai / lekhaka zrI ! ApakI buddhimattA kI kamAla hai ! dekhie lekhaka khuda hI pR. 32 para kahate hai, "TIkA, cUrNi, niyuktiyoM meM kahAM kyA - kyA DAlA hogA, inakI karatUtoM ko bhagavAna hI jAne" / hai nA ! isa prakAra pUrvAcAryoM kI niMdA karanevAle kalikAla ke sapUta ! abhI sirohI ke paTanI ko kauna puchane jAveM, ve to hai hI nahI ! unake nAma para kucha bhI kaha sakate hai / vaha prAmANika nahIM ginA jA sktaa| ___lekhakazrIne pU. puNyavijayajI aura pU. jaMbUvijayajI jaise, vidvAnoM dvArA mAnya, mahApuruSoM para bhI kIcaDa uchAlane meM kamI nahIM rakhI / dIparatnasAgarajI ke saMpAdana meM bahuta hI galatiyA~ hai, ve binA saMzodhita chapavAte hai / ata: unake saMpAdana vizeSa upayogI na hone se pU. jaMbUvijayajI ne vaise zabda kahe ho sakate hai / pU. jaMbUvijayajI ma. kA. saMpAdana aura dIparatnasAgarajI ke saMpAdana meM jamIna- AsamAna kA pharka hai / kvaoNnTiTI kitanI bhI ho, kvaoNliTI na ho to usakI kImata vizeSa nahIM hotI hai| zramaNa saMgha ke iMdaura sammelana meM svasaMpradAya ke anukUla kucha niyama bane bhI ho to bhI unakA pAlana karanA azakyaprAya hai / aise to pUrva meM bhI niyama bane aura uDa gaye / cU~ki spApanA nikSepa anAdisatya hai / usameM jIva kI svAbhAvika pravRtti hotI hI hai| Apa, logoM ko trilokapUjya arihaMta 13

Page #18
-6000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 paramAtmA ke sthApanA nikSepa se dUra karate ho, isalie ve gurumUrti meM pravRtti karate haiM / apane pitA ke phoTo para paira rakhane kI koI nAstika bhI pravRtti nahIM kregaa| yaha vyavahArika pravRtti - nivRtti hI batA rahe hai, prabhu kA sthApanA nikSepa tathya hai - anAdisatya hai - pUjanIya hai - vaMdanIya hai| . Age lekhakazrI DIMge lagA rahe hai - "2000 sAla meM tumameM eka bhI aisA viddhAna nahIM huA, jisane 45 AgamoM para akele ne TIkA kI / sthAnakavAsI eka hI AcArya ne 32 AgamoM para TIkA kii|" isase pAThaka khuda hI vicAra kareM, lekhaka ko pUrvAcArya apane lagate haiM yA parAye ? aura sapUta banane jA rahe hai ! - satya bAta to yaha hai ki sthAnakavAsI AcArya ghAsIlAlajI ne 32 Agama para pUrva TIkAkAra zIlAMkAcArya aura abhayadevasUrijI ke AdhAra para svakalpita TIkAe~ racavAyI haiM, jisameM mandira aura mUrti saMbaMdhita satya zAstra pAThoM ko jhuThalAyA hai / isalie sthAnakavAsI saMta vijayamunijI zAstrI ke zabda hI paDhie - ___ "pU. ghAsIlAjI ma. ne aneka AgamoM ke pAThoM meM parivartana kiyA hai tathA aneka sthaloM para naye pATha banAkara joDa diye haiM / isI prakAra zrI puSpabhikSujI ma. ne apane dvArA sampAdita "suttAgame" meM aneka sthaloM se pATha nikAlakara naye pATha joDa diye haiM / bahuta pahale gaNi udayacandajI ma. paMjAbI ke ziSya ratnamunijI ne bhI dazavaikAlika Adi meM sAmpradAyika abhiniveza ke kAraNa pATha badale the / zAstrIya paraMparA ke anusAra AgamoM meM kisI bhI prakAra kA parivartana nahIM kiyA jAnA cAhiye / aura to kyA, akSara mAtrA taka badalane para bhI kaThora prAyazcita kA vidhAna hai|" (amara bhAratI disambara 1978 pRSTha 94) devendramuni zAstrIjI ne bhI unakI TIkAoM ke lie likhA hai ki "kaI viSayoM meM punarAvRttiyA~ bhI huI hai / paramparA kI mAnyatAoM ko puSTa karane kA lekhaka kA prayAsa rahA hai| (jaina Agama sAhitya manana aura mImAMsA pR. 551)" ____"Agama dvArA to maMdira - mUrti kI siddhi ho rahI hai, jisase aneka sthAnakavAsI sAdhuoM ne asatya kA tyAgakara satya mArga ko apanAyA aura Age | 14

Page #19
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM " bhI aisA calatA rahe to sthAnakavAsI mArga kA kyA hogA ?" isI uddezya se ghAsIlAlajI ne jhUThI TIkAe~ banAyI jo vartamAna meM bhI vidvadvarga meM kataI mAnya nahIM hai| dekhie itihAsavettA vidvadvarya kalyANavijayajI ma. ke. zabda - " yoM to aMtima do zatiyoM se jaina zramaNoM meM saMskRta kA paThana-pAThana bahuta kama ho gayA thA, parantu bIsavIM zatI ke uttarArdha meM saMskRta bhASA kI phira kadara hone lagI / banArasa, mahesANA Adi sthAnoM meM saMskRta pAThazAlAe~ sthApita huI aura unameM gRhastha vidyArthI paDhakara vidvAna hue, katipaya unameM se sAdhu bhI hue, taba kaI sAdhu svataMtra rUpa se paNDitoM ke pAsa paDhakara vyutpanna hue, isa naye saMskRta pracAra se amUrtipUjaka saMpradAya ko eka naI ciMtA utpanna huI, vaha yaha ki saMpradAya meM se pahale aneka paThita sAdhu cale gaye to aba na jAyeMge, isakA kyA bharosA ? isa ciMtA ke vaza hokara saMpradAya ke amUka sAdhuoM ne apane mAnya siddhAMtoM para naI saMskRta TIkAe~ banavAnA zuru kiyA / ahamadAbAda zAhapura ke sthAnaka meM rahate hue sthAnakavAsI sAdhu zrI ghAMsIlAlajI lagabhaga 7-8 sAla se yahI kAma karavA rahe haiM, saMskRtajJa brAhmaNa vidvAnoM dvArA AgamoM para apane matAnusAra saMskRta TIkAe~ taiyAra karavAte haiM, sAtha-sAtha unakA gujarAtI tathA hindI bhASA meM bhASAntara karavA kara chapavAne kA kArya bhI karavA raheM haiM; isa prakAra kI naI TIkAoM ke sAtha katipaya sUtra chapa bhI cuke haiM / " (paTTAvalI parAga pR. 475-476) isase yaha bhI siddha hotA hai ki ghAsIlAlajI ne bhADutI brAhmaNa paMDitoM se TIkA racavAyI, usameM unakI vidvattA kahA~ hai ? apanA nAma anya ke pAsa racavAyI TIkA para lagAnA yaha bhI anIti hai / yaha satya hakIkata jAnakara lekhakazrI ko jhUThI DaMphAse mAranA baMda kara denA cAhie / 15

Page #20
-60 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 "mUrtipUjakoM ke dharma kI vicAraNA" kI samIkSA isameM mUrtipUjA kI arvAcInatA siddha karane ke lie lekhaka ne eka kutarka diyA hai / "mAtA-pitA jIvita ho, paraspara bahuta prema ho to bhI putra pitA kI mUrti banAkara pUjA nahIM karatA hai|" lekhaka zrI ko samajhanA cAhiye ki sAmAnya se vyavahAra meM viziSTa puruSoM kI mUrtiyoM kI hI pracalanA hai, vaha bhI bahulatayA maraNottara avasthA meM unake cirasmaraNa ke liye / bAkI phoTo bhI mUrti kA hI pratirUpa hai, vaha to unakI vidyamAnatA meM bhI hote hI hai / usa phoTo ko mAtApitAdi ke acirakAlIna athavA cirakAlIna anupasthiti meM darzana-pUjana ke liye upayogI mAnate hI hai / mUrtivirodhiyoM ke bhI phoTo to aneka jagaha para dikhate hI hai| isalie upara ke kutarka se jo yaha siddha karanA cAhA hai ki "bhagavAna kI upasthiti meM to unakA maMdira aura pUjA nahIM thI, amUrtipUjaka dharma hI thA / " vaha siddha nahIM ho sakatA haiM / bhagavAna ke samavasaraNa meM bhI bhagavAna khuda pUrvAbhimukha hI hote hai, anya 3 dizA meM unakI pratikRti hI hotI hai / 'mUrtipUjA kA prAcIna itihAsa' ke pR. 117 se pR. 193 taka meM mUrtipUjA kI atiprAcInatA ke anekAneka udAharaNa diye hai, jijJAsu vahA~ se dekha sakate hai / kucha isa prakAra hai :__1. prabhAsa pATaNa (gujarAta) meM somapurA-brAhmaNa ke pAsa se tAmrapatra milA, jo durgamya bhASA meM likhA huA thA / khuba mahenata se prakhara bhASA zAstrI prANanAthajI ne usa lekha ko spaSTa samajhA / usa lena meM nebucaMdra nejharane vikrama pUrva 600 yAni bhagavAna mahAvIra ke janma se pUrva giranAra meM neminAtha bhagavAna kI pratimA va maMdira banavAyA aisA ullekha hai ( jainapatra tA. 3-1-1937) 2. mohanajodArA khodakAma meM dhyAna mudrAvAlI pratimAe~ nikalI, jinheM purAtattva vibhAga ne saMzodhana karake 5000 varSa pUrva kI batAI hai| . 3. bArasI tAkalI - AkolA jile meM khodakAma meM 26 pratimAeM milI, jinheM purAtattvavidoM ne I.pU.600-700 varSa kI nizcita kI hai / (san 1936 samAcAra patra) 16

Page #21
4-60 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 ___4. bauddha graMtha mahAvagga 1-22-23 meM, mahAtmA buddha sabase pahale rAjagRha meM gaye / vahAM suppatittha - supArzvanAthajI ke maMdira meM utare the| . 5. purAtattva ke ananya abhyAsI DaoN. prANanAthajI kA mata hai - I. san ke pUrva pAMcavI-chaThI zatAbdI meM jainiyoM ke aMdara mUrti kA mAnanA, aitihAsika pramANoM se siddha hai / aise aneka udAharaNoM se bhagavAna mahAvIra ke pUrva meM bhI mUrtipUjA thii| Age lekhakazrI koNika ke varNana meM, eka bhI maMdira kA vaNarna nahIM honA, upAsakadazAMga meM daza-zrAvakoM ke maMdira vagairaha bAta nahIM honA, vagairaha bAteM batA rahe hai, vaha ajJatA yA kadAgraha hai| AgamakAra azAzvata caityoM kA varNana kitanA kareM ? ve kAlakrama se naSTa hote haiM, anya ApattioM se bhI naSTa hote rahate haiM, isalie unakA vistRta varNana nahIM kiyA hai| zAzvata caityoM kA Agama meM aneka sthaloM meM varNana milatA hI hai, vistRta varNana bhI AtA hI hai / sAmAnya se caitya zabda se jinamaMdira to AgamoM meM bhI aneka sthAnoM para batAye hI hai / koNika kI caMpAnagarI ke varNana meM bhI mUlasUtra meM 'arihaMta ceiya jaNavaya visaNNiviTTha pAThAMtara spaSTa hai, jo 1000 sAla pUrva bhI vidyamAna thA usa para TIkAkAra ne TIkA bhI kI hai / isase spaSTa siddha hotA hai, ki koNika kI caMpAnagarI meM aneka jinamaMdira the / isakI vizeSa jAnakArI ke liye dekhiye 'jainAgama siddha mUrtipUjA' meM 'caMpAnagarI aura arihaMta caitya' kI smiikssaa| ___samavAyAMga sUtra meM viSaya nirdeza meM upAsakadazA meM AnaMdAdi zrAvakoM ke jinamaMdirAdi batAye haiN| vartamAna meM sUtra saMkSepAdi kAraNoM se ve upAsakadazAMga meM dikhAyI nahIM dete / isakI vistRta siddhi 'jainAgama siddha mUrtipUjA' pR. 115 se jAna leN| isa prakAra aupapAtika Adi AgamoM meM jinamaMdira ke spaSTa pATha hote hue bhI usake aMTa-saMTa 'TAuna hola' vagairaha artha karanA aura phira zora macAnA, Agama meM kahI bhI jinamaMdira ke pATha nahIM hai, yaha inakI kunIti rahI hai| jahAM para pATha kA artha palaTanA zakya hI nahIM, aise aMbaDa parivrAjaka vagairaha adhikAroM meM prakSepa-prakSepa kA bakavAsa karanA / are ye ! mUrtipUjA ke dveSa meM ( 17

Page #22
-6000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (10960 bhAna bhula jAte hai / eka vyakti eka sthAnapara galata artha karatA hai to dusare usI sthAna meM prakSepa kI kukalpanA karate hai / dekhiye guMjAra pustaka pa. 9 lekhaka draupadI adhikAra meM kAmadeva artha karate hai aura inake puSphabhikkhu ne suttAgame meM draupadI pUjA adhikAra kA sArA pATha prakSipta kahakara haTA diyA hai / vaise hI lekhaka pR. 16 para devaloka jinAlaya meM 'jina' zabda ke aneka artha kI kukalpanA karake artha badalate hai, vahIM para puSphabhikkhU pATha uDA dete hai| koI bhI taTastha vyakti inakI isa ceSTA para madhyasthatA se vicAra kare to isameM use spaSTa hI AgamoM kA prema nahIM apitu sAmpradAyika abhiniveza - kadAgraha hI najara aaegaa| draupadI ko mithyAtvI mAnanA aura kAmadeva kI pUjA kI, yaha mAnanA kadAgraha hI hai / 'jaina kathAmAlA' pR. 59 meM inhIM ke upA. zrI madhukara munijI ne aura 'tIrthaMkara caritra' bhAga 2 pR. 29 para ratanalAla DosIjI ne spaSTa zabdoM meM niyANA karake Aye rAvaNa ko digvijaya ke pUrva hI samyaktvadhArI mAnA hai| ataH zAdI se pUrva draupadI ko bhI samyaktva mAnane meM koI Apatti nahIM hai| yaha niyama hai hI nahIM ki niyANAvAle jIva niyANA pUrNa na ho taba taka samyaktva se vaMcita rahate hai / yaha to sthAnakavAsiyoM kA apane pakSa kI siddhi ke liye kalpanA se banAyA niyama hai, inhIM ke graMthoM se yaha siddha hotA hai aura vaha samyaktvI huI to arihaMta paramAtmA kI hI pUjA karegI, kAmadeva kI kadApi nahIM / isake vistRta samAdhAna ke liye 'jainAgama siddha mUrtipUjA' pR. 124 se pR. 127 dekhiye| . .. ... Age lekhakazrI AgamakAroM ne batAyI zAzvatI jinapratimAoM kA azAzvata banAne kI paMDitAI kara rahe hai / unakA kahanA hai "tIrthaMkara zAzvata nahIM isaliye ve mUrtiyA~ unakI nahIM hai, isalie unakA jaina dharma se saMbaMdha nahIM aura namutthuNaM pATha karanA nirarthaka hai / " paraMtu ye mahApaMDita yaha bAta to gupta hI rakhate hai ki ve mUrtiyA~ kinakI hai ? aura anya kisI deva kI mAno to kauna aisA deva hai jo zAzvata hai ? carAcara sRSTi meM siddha paramAtmA ke sivAya koI jIva zAzvata paryAyavAlA nahIM hai / ve siddha paramAtmA bhI sAdi-anaMta bhAMge se hI zAzvata hai, jabaki ve mUrtiyA~ to zAstrakAroM ke hisAba se anAdi (18

Page #23
G000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 - anaMta hai / taba ye kisakI ho sakatI hai ? anAdi siddha zAzvata Izvara AgamakAroM ko tanika bhI mAnya nahIM hai| ata: kisI zAzvata vyakti kI ye pratimAe~ nahIM haiM, phira bhI Agamo meM RSabha-vardhamAna caMdrAnana-vAriSeNa ye cAra nAma diye hai / ata: AgamakAroM ko yaha batAnA hai ki tIrthaMkaro ke ye nAma pravAha se zAzvata hai / jaise dvAdazAMgI artha se zAzvata hai aura sUtra se azAzvata hai vaise| ata: lekhaka kadAgraha ko chor3akara mArgastha buddhi se vicAra kareM to hI Agama pATha kA saMgamana ho pAegA / isa caubIsI meM bharatakSetra meM prathama aura carama RSabha aura vardhamAna hai / airAvata kSetra meM prathama aura carama caMdrAnana aura vAriSeNa hai / nAma sAmyatA spaSTa tIrthaMkaroM se hI hai / aura namutthuNaM pATha, pUjanAdi sabhI tIrthaMkaroM kI pratimA mAnane para hI saMgata hote haiM / tIrthaMkara to azAzvata hai, pratimA unakI zAzvata kaise ? isakA mArgastha buddhi se uttara spaSTa hai ki zAzvata nAma batAye hai matalaba bharata-airAvata-mahAvideha meM milakara ina cAra nAma ke tIrthaMkara kisI bhI kAla meM hote hI hai / namutthuNaM kA pATha bhI jinapratimA ke saMbaMdha meM hI diyA hai aura ve pratimAeM arcanIya - pUjanIya - paryupAsanIya hai, aisA spaSTa ullekha hai, jisase spaSTa siddha hotA hai ki ve pratimAe~ tIrthaMkaroM kI hI hai|| ___devoM dvArA divAloM, daravAjoM, vAvar3iyoM kA saMkSepa se pUjana hai, tathA namutthuNaM se stavanA bhI nahIM hai| isalie vaha pUjana loka vyavahAra se samajhanA cAhiye / isake vizeSa vivecana ke liye dekhiye 'mUrtipUjA kA prAcIna itihAsa' pR. 15 se pR. 67 evaM 'jainAgama siddha mUrtipUjA' pR. 72 se pa. 86 / . ___Age lekhakazrI, mUrtipUjA, jaina siddhAMto ke viparIta hai kyoMki usameM phUla-dIpa vagaraiha evaM nAcanA - bajAnA vagairaha se jIvahiMsA hotI hai ityAdi bAteM karate haiM / unako samajhanA cAhiye, mUrtipUjaka sAdhuoM ke cAturmAsa se baDhakara, karor3oM rupaye ke AraMbha - samAraMbha sthAnakavAsI - terApaMthI sAdhuoM ke cAturmAsa meM hote hai / cAturmAsa meM bhayaMkara virAdhanA karake basa vagairaha se vaMdana ke liye jAnA, ve kartavya samajhate haiM / usake alAvA maryAdA mahotsava - saMgha sammelana - caddara mahotsava vagairaha bhAta-bhAta ke mahotsava meM hajAroM kI medanI - 19

Page #24
-G006 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (D 9602 - unake utarane kI - bhojana kI vyavasthA, kyA binA AraMbha - samAraMbha ho sakatI hai ? sthAnakavAsI sAdhu bhI inake preraka hote hI hai aura apane bhaktoM ko niSedha nahIM karate isalie anumodaka bhI hote hI hai / khuda ke nimitta se bhayaMkara AraMbha-samAraMbha meM inako hiMsA nahIM dikhatI / paramAtmA ke nimitta se hotI nAmamAtra kI hiMsA meM hiMsAhiMsA kA zora macAte haiM / yaha to guDa khAnA aura gulaguloM se paraheja rakhane jaisI bAta hai| - yaha to khuba huA, lekhaka bhagavAna mahAvIra ke samavasaraNa meM vidyamAna nahIM the, yadi hote to hArTa eTeka A jAtA aura zAyada jIvita rahate to gozAle kI taraha virodhameM cillAye binA nahIM rahate ki, are ! tyAgI, vItarAga puruSoM ko itane AraMbha aura ADaMbara kI AvazyakatA kyoM ? yadi upadeza-vyAkhyAna denA hI iSTa hai to mahAraMbha pUrvaka samavasaraNa kI kyA AvazyakatA hai| hAya re hAya ! itanA pAnI chir3akAnA, are itane gADoM ke gADe bhare hue jala thala meM utpanna hue phUloM kA bichavAnA yaha kyoM kiyA jAtA hai / isake atirikta eka yojana U~ce se puSpa barasAne se aneka vAyukAya ke jIvoM kI virAdhanA hotI hai / are ! prabho ! agnikAya kA Arambha ye dhUpa battie~ vyAkhyAna meM kyoM ? hAya ! pApa, hAya ! hiMsA, are ! bhagavAn ! ye Apake bhakta indrAdi deva tIna jJAna saMyukta samyag dRSTi alpa-parimita saMsArI mahAvivekI, dharma ke nAma para Apake sAmane ghora hiMsA karate haiM, aura Apa beThe 2 dekhate ho, para inako kucha kahate nahIM ho ? itanA hI nahIM para Apa to inake race hue samavasaraNa meM jAkara virAjamAna ho gaye ho ? ataH Apa svayaM isa Arambha kI anumodanA karate ho / tathA dharma ke nAma para itanI bhISaNa hiMsA karane vAloM kA, Apa svayaM hoMsalA bar3hAte ho / prabho ! kyA Apa yaha bhUla gaye haiM ki bhaviSya meM kaliyugI loga isI kA anukaraNa kara, ApakA udAharaNa de bicAre hama jaise kevala dayAdharmiyoM (DhoMgiyoM) ko bolane nahIM deNge| are ! dayAsindho ! Apake pratyakSa meM ye indrAdi deva bhakti meM besudha hokara cAroM aura ca~varoM ke phaTakAra lagA rahe hai, jinase asaMkhya vAyukAya ke 20

Page #25
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM" jIvoM kI virAdhanA hotI hai, phira bhI Apa inheM kucha nahIM kahate haiM, yaha baDe Azcarya kI bAta hai / hAya ! yaha kaunasA dharma ? yaha kaisI bhakti ? ki jisameM jIvoM kI aparimita hiMsA ho / he prabho ! Apako ina logoM ne merU para le jAkara kacce pAnI se snAna karAyA, para use to hama Apake janma- gRhasthAvasthA se saMbodhita kara apanA bacAva kara sakate haiN| para ApakI kaivalyAvasthA para aura nirvANa dazA meM bhI ye loga bhakti aura dharma kA nAma le lekara itanI hiMsA karate haiM, use Apa bhale hI saha leM, para hama se to yaha atyAcAra dekhA nahIM jAtA / yadyapi ye loga cAhe avratI apaccakukhAnI ho, para Apa to sAkSAt ahiMsA dharma ke avatAra ho, ApakI maujUdagI meM yaha itanA anyAya kyoM ? ye loga Apake liye hI vAjA gAjA (duMdubhI bajAte haiN| Apale AvAja ke sAtha meM bhI zahenAI ke sura dete haiM phira bhI Apa bar3IzAna se mAlakoza vageraha rAgarAganioM ko lalakArate rahate haiM isameM vAyukAya ke jIvoM kI hiMsA hotI hai usakA doSa kisake zira para hai ? kyA Apa unheM manA nahIM kara sakate ? / tathA Apa svayaM bhI, ghaMTe taka khule mu~ha vyAkhyAna de rahe haiM, to isameM kyA vAyukAya ke jIva marate nahIM hoMge ? jabaki eka bAra khule mu~ha bolane meM bhI asaMkhya jIva marate haiM to phira ghaMTe taka meM to kahanA hI kyA ? yadi Apa khuda hI khule mu~ha boloMge to paMcama Are ke pAmara prANI to niHzaMkatayA khule mu~ha hI boleMge / aura koI kahegA to ApakA udAharaNa dekara apanA bacAva kara leMge, phira dayAdharmiyoM kI to sunegA hI kauna ? | yadi Apake pAsa vastra kA abhAva ho to lIjie maiM sevA meM vastra lAdUM para Apa khule mu~ha to kRpayA vyAkhyAna mata do / yadi Apa itanA kucha kahane sunane para bhI mu~hapattI nahIM bAndhoge to acche Apa tIrthaGkara ho para maiM to ApakA vyAkhyAna kabhI nahIM sunUMgA / kAraNa merI yahi pratijJA hai ki jahA~ eka zabda bhI khule mu~ha bolA jAye vahA~ ThaharanA bhI acchA nahIM / Apako apanI pratimA banavAnA bhI pasaMda hai ataH eva samavasaraNa meM dakSiNa, pazcima aura uttara ke siMhAsana para ApakI hI 3 pratimA banavA kara baiThAI jAtI hai / Apa vahA~ manA taka nahIM karate haiM isake viparIta Apa una mUrtiyoM kI sevA pUjA aura darzana karane meM bhI dharma batAte haiM / kyA 21

Page #26
-600 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (09602 Apako apanI pratimAe~ iSTa haiM ? uph ! vItarAga hone para bhI Apa mUrtipUjakoM ke pakSa meM jA baiThe ? aba hamArI dayA kI pukAra kauna sune? ityAdi aneka kalpanA lekhakake dila meM hotI, para khuzI isa bAta kI hai ki lekhaka mahAvIra prabhu ke samaya paidA hI nahIM hue| 'eka maMdira banAnevAlA yA eka maMdira kI nIva meM IMTa DAlanevAlA eka bhava meM mokSa meM jAtA haiM' aisI prarUpaNA koI karatA hI nahIM hai / isa prakAra uTapaTAMga jhUThe Aropa ghaDane se lekhaka kI yogyatA prakaTa hotI hai| Age lekhaka AcArAMga prathama adhyayana meM jo loga dharma-mokSa ke lie cha:kAya kI hiMsA karate hai, vaha ahitakAraka - bodhidurlabhatA kA kAraNa hotI hai, vagairaha likhate hai / usakA saMbaMdha mUrtipUjA se joDanA cAhate haiM, vaha ayogya hai / AcArAMga sUtra kI TIkA meM spaSTa artha kiyA hai, ki kArtikeya ko vaMdanAdi, bagrahANAdi ko dharmabuddhi se dAna, kumArga upadeza se hiMsA meM pravRtti, durgAdi ke sAmane balI, paMcAgni tapa vagairaha kriyA meM pravRtta honA ahitakara, abodhi kA kAraNa hai / matalaba vahA~ saba mithyAtva kI kriyAeM hI batAyI hai / agara yaha nahIM mAno to, sAdhu ko vaMdana karane jAnA, kabutara ko cuggA - gAya ko ghAsa vagairaha aneka kriyAoM meM hiMsA hotI hai, jinheM sthAnakavAsI loga bhI dharmabuddhi se hI karate hai, unheM bhI abodhi kA kAraNa mAnanA paDegA / isalie spaSTa hotA hai ki zrAvakoM ke lie vihita aisI jinapUjA meM yaha bAta lAgu nahIM hotI hai / lekhaka khuda sAdhuoM kI yatanApUrvaka kI gamanAgamana kriyA meM hiMsA hote hue bhI pApakarma baMdha nahIM honA kahate hai, jabaki jinapUjA meM bhI aneka prakAra kI yatanAe~ hote hue bhI usake samakakSa maMdira mUrti ko joDanA svIkAra nahIM karate haiM, yaha kevala matAgraha hai / pUrvadhara umAsvAtijI vagairaha mahApuruSoM ne usI prakAra zramaNopAsaka ke liye dravyastava batAyA hai, use ye DeDha hoziyAra buddhi kA divAlA kahate hai / pU. umAsvAtijI ma. zrAvakaprajJapti gAthA naM. 346 meM evaM pU. haribhadrasUrijI ma. caturtha paMcAzaka mahAgraMtha meM kahate haiM - "zarIrAdi sAMsArika aura dusare dhArmika kAryoM me aneka prakAra se jIvahiMsA karate hue bhI kalyANakArI jinapUjA meM hiMsA kA bahAnA nikAlakara pravartana nahIM karanA vaha mUrkhatA hai / aba pAThaka vicAreM kisakI 22 -

Page #27
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM" buddhi kA divAlA hai / Agamokta zrAvakoM kI pauSadhazAlA unake bar3e-bar3e makAnoM kA hI eka vibhAga thA, jo Avazyaka thA / abhI to sthAnakAdi alaga se banate hai aura dharmahetu hI banate hai, to lekhaka use AcAraMga sUtra ke hisAba se ahitakAraka - abodhijanaka mAneMge ? agara nahIM to vItarAga paramAtmA ke maMdira meM hI Apako vaha kyoM najara AtA hai ? kaisI pApabuddhi ? agara sthAnakoM ko abodhijanaka mAnate hai to, usameM Apake sAdhuoM kI DAyarekTa yA inaDAyarekTa pravRtti - upadeza anumodanA kaise ? dAna denevAloM kI bhAgyazAlI, puNyopArjana karanevAle vagairaha vizeSaNoM se takhtiyA~ kaise ? yaha to hAthI ke dAMta dikhAne ke alaga aura khAne ke alaga vAlI bAta huI / AraMbha - samAraMbha se chapanevAlI dhArmika pustakoM meM jJAnagaccha jaise kaTTarapaMthI bhI dAnavIra kI prazaMsA, unakI nAmAvalI unako dhanyavAda vagairaha karate hai, to sabhI, AcArAMga sUtra ke hisAba se ina pravRttiyo se bhavabhramaNa kareMge, yaha lekhaka mAnate hai kyA ? agara nahIM to arihaMta paramAtmA se hI itanA dveSa kyoM ? Age lekhaka "anaginata maMdira mUrtiyA~ joDa dI gaI hai| kaI khoTe zilAlekha banAne ke pApa bhI karane paDe aura unheM jamInameM gADha - gADhakara kahI se khudAI meM nikAlanA batAkara apane mana ko jhUThe itihAsoM se hI saMtuSTa karane lage / " aisI uTapaTAMga bAte likhate hai, jo vidvatsabhA meM hAsyAspada ho jAtI hai | sthAnavAsI paMtha ko 350 sAla aura lauMkAzAha ko karIba 550 sAla hue, usake pahale mUrtipUjA kA virodha jainadharma meM thA hI nahIM, usake pahale kI seMkaDoM pratimAe~, zilAlekha nikala rahe hai| jinheM prAmANika aise aMgreja aura anya dharmI vidvAnoM ne bhI pramANita kiye hai| isa vaijJAnika yugameM aneka parIkSaNoM se jA~cakara vidvAna jAhira karate hai| unake parIkSaNoM se jAhira kI gaI aneka atiprAcIna mUrtiyA~, zilAlekhoM ko kAlpanika kahanA satya ko kalaMkita karanA hai / anekabAra aise lekha - zilAlekhoM kA prAcIna itihAsakAroM ke itihAsa se saMvAda milatA hai, jisase itihAsa kI nayI kaDiyA~ khulatI hai / aneka bAra 23 -

Page #28
G000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 hiMdu bauddha Adi graMthoM ke itihAsa se bhI unakI saccAI kI siddhi hotI hai / aise sabhI lekha-zilAlekhoM ko jAlI kahanA, sUrya ke sAmane dhUla uDAne jaisI mUrkhatA hai| aise hI eka udayagiri - khaMDagiri kA zilAlekha jisakI lipI - bhASA kI anabhijJatA ke kAraNa videzI aura bhAratIya purAtattvajJoM ne 100 sAla taka pUrNa parizrama karake 100 sAla ke bAda sarvamAnya nirNaya karake niSkarSa nikAlA ki kaliMga para AkramaNa karake, magadheza zreNika mahArAjA dvArA suvarNamaya AdinAtha bhagavAna kI pratimA sthApita kI jise kAlAMtara meM naMdavaMzI rAjA magadha le gayA, mahArAjA khAravela ne magadha para caDhAI karake vahA~ ke puSyamitra rAjA ko harAkara vaha pratimA vApasa laayii|" vistRta jAnakArI ke lie dekhiye - 'mUrtipUjA kA prAcIna itihAsa' pR. 123 se pR. 129 aise mahAvidvAnoM ne mehanata karake prakaTa kiye satya kA inkAra karane se vastu kI satyatA miTatI nahIM hai| __ mUrtivirodhI - mUrtibhaMjaka mUgalAdi AkramaNoM se bacAne ke liye hajAroM mUrtiyA~ jamIna meM gADhI gaI thI, jo atiprasiddha hai / isalie khudAI meM nikala rahI hai / gADhane aura nikAlane kI kapola kalpita kalpanA tabhI ho sakatI hai, jaba eka hI vyakti donoM kriyAe~ karatA ho / aisI umravAlA koI vyakti dikhAI nahIM detA hai aura na to koI vizvabhara meM ghuma-ghuma kara aneka ajJAtasthaloM meM mUrti Adi gADha sakatA hai| Age lekhaka kalpasUtra - mahAnizItha sUtroM ko uTapaTAMga kahakara unake hI AdhAra para apane kumata kI siddhi karane kI ceSTA kara rahe haiM / yaha to jisa DAlapara baiThe usI ko kATane kI ceSTA hai, aisA mUrkha ke sivAya aura kauna kara sakatA hai ? . kalpasUtra kA khulAsA isI pustikA meM anyatra A gayA hai / mahAnizItha ke pATha kA lekhaka ne sarAsara jhUThA artha kiyA hai| pUrva ke 'saMdarbha ko choDakara lekhaka ne jAna-bujhakara bhole - anapaDha logoM ko phasAne hetu mAyAcAritA se 'jinamaMdira sAvadya hai / ' aisA artha kiyA haiM / mahAnizItha ke pATha kI saMkSipta bhUmikA isa prakAra hai - anaMta covIsI ke pUrva dharmasIrI 24

Page #29
*6000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (09602 tIrthaMkara ke nirvANa bAda asaMyati pUjA nAmaka accherA huA / usameM sAdhu - zithilAcArI - asaMyati jaise bane unakA jora nuba baDhA / maMdira meM pUjA-arcA (jo zrAvakoM kA kArya hai) khuda karane lage maMdira meM rahane lage, devadravya kA bhakSaNa vagairaha anAcAra meM pravRta hone se caityavAsI kahalAe / usa jamAne meM kuvalayaprabha nAmake suvihita AcArya caityavAsiyoM ke vahAM Aye, unakA upadezAdi kA prabhAva dekhakara caityavAsiyoM ne Apa yahIM para cAturmAsa kareMge, to Apake upadeza se caitya bana sakeMge" yaha vinaMti kI / taba unhoMne spaSTa javAba diyA, 'jahavi jiNAlaye, tahA vi sAvajjamiNaM NAhaM vAyAmitteNa evaM AyarejjA' matalaba 'jinAlaya' kA kArya hone para bhI (isameM vAstavika doSa na hone para bhI) Apake isa sthAna meM jinAlaya kA upadeza sAvadya hai kyoMki yahAM para jinAlaya banane se ApakA zithilAcAra kA pracAra baDhegA / isalie vANI se bhI maiM yaha AcaraNa nahIM karU~gA aise spaSTa javAba se tIrthaMkara nAmakarma kA baMdha karake saMsAra ko eka bhava pramANa kiyA / Age pIche ke prakaraNa se upara ke pATha kA yaha spaSTa artha hote hue bhI isa prakAra beImAnI karanA sajjanatA nahIM hai| Age kI gayI mahAnizItha kI 1250 varSa bItane para kuguru kI bAta usa kAla meM hue zithilAcArI - caityavAsI sAdhuoM ko hI lAgu hotI hai| dUsare maMdiramArgI saMvigna sAdhu bhI usa vakta bahuta the / ataH usa vakta ke sabhI sAdhu kuguru koTI meM nahIM Ate hai / aura isI pustikA meM lekhaka ke batAye anusAra inakA paMtha nayA utpanna huA hai ata: bhagavatI sUtra ke kathana se vaha bhagavAna kA mArga nahIM ho sakatA hai cUMki bhagavatIjI meM prabhu ke zAsana kA 21000 varSa avicchinna calanA likhA hai / ata: mahAnizItha ke pATha se upasAyI inakI kukalpanAe~ dhUla meM mila jAtI hai| Age lekhakazrI jainAgamoM se siddha, aneka jaina-jainetara zabdakozoM se siddha, vyAkaraNa se siddha, 'caitya' zabda kA 'jinapratimA - maMdira' artha jhuThalAne ke lie caitya zabda kI carcA karate hai| unakA kahanA hai ki eka zabda ke aneka artha hote haiM, vaise caitya ke bhI aneka artha hote hai / yaha bAta ThIka hai, paraMtu zabda ke jo artha vyAkaraNa-koza (25)

Page #30
4-6000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 ruDhI se siddha hote hai, ve hI prAmANika gine jAte haiM, kAlpanika artha nahIM / aneka artha meM bhI prakaraNa ke anurupa artha hI grahaNa kiye jAte hai / bhojana karate samaya saiMdhava mAMge to ghoDA lAveM, yuddha meM saiMghava mAMge vahA~ namaka le Ave, vaha nahIM calatA hai / vaise hI jainAgamoM meM caitya ke artha jinapratimA - maMdira abhipreta haiM, vahAM uTapaTAMga jJAna-sAdhu Adi artha karanA, ayogyatA - matAgraha ko sUcita karatA hai| AgamazailI meM jJAna ke liye 'NANa', nANI - annANI prayoga seMkaDoM sthaloM meM Aye haiM / eka bhI sthala meM kevala jJAna, avadhijJAna Adi ke liye kevala-ceiya, avadhi-ceiya vagairaha prayoga dikhAyI nahIM detA hai / yahI sUcita karatA hai ki zAstrakAroM ko 'ceiya' kA 'jJAna' artha abhimata nahIM hai| kevala bhagavatI sUtra meM eka sau se adhika sthala meM isake prayoga kI sUcI ke liye dekhiye - 'jainAgama siddha mUrtipUjA' pR. 281 se pR. 215 aura usImeM pR. 169 se pR. 172 'caitya zabda kI carcA' / yahA~ para jyAdA vistAra nahIM karate hai| _ aneka jagaha para caitya zabda saMbaMdhI vistRta carcAe~ bhUtakAla meM ho cukI haiM / jijJAsu dekheM mUrtipUjA kA prAcIna itihAsa pR. 68 se pR. 123 paTTAvalI parAga pR. 455 'mUla jaina dharma ane hAlanA saMpradAyo' pR. 112 (lekhaka sthAnakavAsI paMDita nagInadAsa zeTha / caitya zabda prakSepa ke mithyA Aropa ke liye dekheM isI pustikA meM 'NamotthuNaM pATha prakSepa kI samIkSA' prakaraNa / - rAyapaseNI sUtra meM batAyI huI zAzvatI pratimA kI carcA pIche kara gaye, abhI piSTapeSaNa nahIM karate hai / zAstroM ke managaDhaMta, kAlpanika artha karake saMsAra vRddhi karanA inakI paraMparA se calA A rahA hai / vaise hI jina kA 'aneka jAti ke deva' artha kara rahe hai / lekhaka ko arihaMta paramAtmA se kitanA dveSa hai ? jahAM AgamakAroM ko 'jina' se arihaMta iSTa hai, vahAM anya jAti ke deva artha kara rahe haiM / tIrthaMkara zAzvata nahIM to kyA anya jAti ke deva zAzvata hai ? AgamakAra anya jAti ke devoM kA itanA caDhAkara varNana kyoM kareM ? anyoM 26

Page #31
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM" ko mithyAtva ke liye prerita kyoM kareM ? jarA zAMti se vicAra kIjiyegA ! Age ye likhate hai - "zAzvata sthAnoM meM mUrti yA siddhAyatana kA honA hI asaMbhava hai " matalaba hama sthAnakavAsI mUrti maMdira nahIM mAnate, isalie ve zAzvata sthAnoM meM saMbhava nahIM hai ! kitanI hAsyAspada bAta hai ! Apake nahIM mAnane se kyA zAzvata vastusthiti badala jAegI ? Age phira lekhaka Agama meM siddhAyatana, zAzvata jina vagairaha aneka pAThoM ke prakSepa kI kukalpanA karate hai / yaha to bAla nikAlane kI jagaha mastaka ko hI kATa liyA ! Apa kaunase atizAyI jJAna se una pAThoM ko. prakSipta batA rahe haiM / kevala apanI kukalpanA se aneka pAThoM ko prakSipta kahane jAoge to digaMbaro ke pakSa meM hI baiTha jAoge / ve isI prakAra kI kukalpanAoM se Agamaviccheda mAnate haiM / * hajAra sAla kI aneka prAcIna hastapratiyA~, caityAdike pAThoM kI prAmANikatA siddha kara rahI haiM / 1000 sAla pUrva ke TIkAkAroM ke sAmane evaM usase bhI prAcInakAlIna niryukti Adi sabake sAmane ye hI pATha the, tabhI to una para vivecana zakya hai / ataH prakSepa kI bAta kevala bakavAsa mAtra hai / dusarI bAta Apa bhI pupphabhikkhU ke hI bhAI ho, jinhoMne Apake jaisI kalpanA karake apane kumatako pracAra meM vighnabhUta sabhI pATha uDAkara Agama chapavAye / paraMtu usa vakta sthAnakavAsI zramaNasaMgha samiti ne sarvAnumati se TharAva pAsa kara use apramANika ghoSita kiyA / ye saba bAteM isI pustikA meM 'NamotthuNaM pATha prakSepa kI samIkSA prakaraNa meM dekhe / ataH prakSepa kI bAteM saba AkAzakusuma samAna nirarthaka hai / " dekhiye ! niSpakSa itihAsavettA paM. kalyANavijayajI ma., pATha prakSepa ke liye kyA kaha rahe haiM / "AgamoM meM banAvaTI pATha ghuseDa dene kI bAta kahI hai, vaha bhI unake hRdaya kI bhAvanA ko vyakta karatI hai / yoM to hara eka AdamI kaha sakatA hai ki amuka grantha meM amuka pATha prakSipta hai, parantu prakSipta kahane mAtra se vaha prakSipta nahIM ho sakatA, kintu puSTa pramANoM se usa kathana kA samarthana karane se hI, vidvAna loga usa kathana ko satya mAnate haiM / saMpAdaka (pupphabhikkhU) ne 27

Page #32
-G006 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" 009602 banAvaTI pATha ghuseDane kI bAta to kaha dI, para isa kathana para kisI pramANa kA upanyAsa nahIM kiyA / ata: yaha kathana bhI araNyarodana se adhika mahatva nahIM rakhatA, AgamoM meM banAvaTI pATha ghuseDane aura usameM se sacce pAThoM ko nikAlanA yaha to bhikSutritaya ke ghara kI rIti paramparA se calI A rahI hai|" (paTTAvalI parAga pR. 464) "mukhavastrikA vArtA" kI samIkSA isa prakaraNa meM koI sAra nahIM hai / pAThaka, muhapatti kI aneka pramANoM se vistRta siddhi ke liye maNisAgarajI ma.sA. kA. koTA se prakAzita "AgamAnusAra muhapatti kA nirNaya" graMtha dekha leM / lekhaka kahate haiM 8000 sAdhu-sAdhvI meM eka bhI udAharaNa nahIM ki jisane pUre dIkSAkAla meM kabhI bhI khule muMha nahIM bolA ho" aura usase ye nirNaya dete haiM ki mu~hapara bAMdhane kA siddhAMta sahI hai / unako apane nirNaya ko badalanA hogA, kyoMki aise bhI apramatta sAdhu hai jo saMpUrNa dIkSAkAla meM kabhI bhI khule mu~ha nahIM bole / ataH muMhapara bAMdhane se hote pramAda kA poSaNa aura anyaliMga ke doSa (muMhapara hamezA muhapatti bAMdhanA muniliMga nahIM hai) se bacanA cAhiye / isameM lekhaka ne aneka galata pramANa diye hai| unakA samAdhAna yaha hai (1) haribhadrasUri Avazyaka TIkA ke nAma se lekhaka ne gappa lagAyI hai|' ____ Avazyaka TIkA meM cihna ke liye rajoharaNa, muhapattI, colapaTTaka mRttaka ke pAsa rakhane kI bAta hai / cihna nahIM kareM to, koI rAjA sAdhu kA mRtaka dekhakara kisI ne sAdhu ko mArA aisI zaMkA se grAmaghAta kara sakatA hai / athavA sAdhu marakara vyaMtarAdi yoni meM jAne para anya liMgavAle muniliMga rahita apane mRtaka ko dekhakara mithyAtva dazA prApta kara sakatA hai / cihna ko pAsa meM dekhakara rAjA ko kuzaMkA nahIM hove aura deva ko bhI 'maiM jaina sAdhu thA' aisA khayAla Ave, isalie cihna svarupa muhapattI, rajoharaNa pAsa meM rakhane kI vidhi batAyI hai / isase to muhapattI pAsa meM rakhanA yahI liMga siddha hotA hai| pATha isa prakAra hai : 28

Page #33
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM" "ciNhaTTA uvagaraNa dosA u bhave aciMdhakaraNammi / micchatta so va rAyA va kuNaha gAmANa vahakaraNa || 53 || " TIkA : paridvavijjaMte ahAjAyamuvagaraNaM ThaveyavvaM muhapottiyA, rayaharaNaM colapaTTo ya / - isI TIkA meM mRtaka ko rAta meM rakhanA paDe to muhapattI bAMdhane kA kahA hai, vaha mu~ha meM jIva-jaMtu praveza na kareM, durgaMdha Adi se rakSA vagairaha ke lie samajhanA / Avazyaka niyukti aura TIkA meM kAussagga me muhapattI dAhine hAtha meM aura rajoharaNa bAyeM hAtha meM rakhane kA spaSTa ullekha hai, usase siddha hotA hai ki jaba bolane kI AvazyakatA nahIM taba muhapattI mukha ke Age rakhanI nahIM hai apitu hAtha meM rakhanI hai - pATha isa prakAra hai - cauraMgula muhapattI ujjUe Dabbahattha rayaharaNaM / vosaTTacattadeho kAussaggaM kahijjAhi / / 1545 TIkA muhapatti ujjue 'tti' dAhiNa hattheNa muhapottiyA ghettavvA, Dabbahatthe rayaharaNaM kAyavvaM / yogazAstra ke pATha meM muhapattI se jIva rakSA kI hI bAta hai / usase muMhapara bA~dhe rakhanA, siddha nahIM hotA hai, balki usameM hAthameM muMhapatti rakhane ke kaI pATha hai / jaiseki yogazAstra ke tRtIya prakAza, vaMdana adhikAra meM isa taraha batAyA hai : " taMtra prasavakAle racitakarasaMpuTo jAyate pravrajyAkAle ca gRhItarajoharaNamukhavAstrika iti yathA jAtamasya sa yathAjAtaH tathAbhUta eva vandate iti vandanamapi yathAjAtam / " isameM dIkSA ke samaya donoM hAthoM se rajoharaNa evaM mukhavastrikA ko grahaNa karane kA batAyA hai evaM usI taraha vaMdana ke samaya bhI donoM hAthoM meM rajoharaNa evaM mukhavastrikA ko grahaNa karake rakhanA vaha vaMdana ke aMtargata "yathAjAtam" Avazyaka kahalAtA hai / 29

Page #34
-600000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0960__tathA isI yogazAstra meM vaMdana viSayaka pUrvAcAryoM kI gAthAe~ uddhRta kI gayI hai, jinameM se muMhapatti hAthameM rakhane kA spaSTa rUpa vidhAna hai / ve gAthAe~ isa taraha haiM : vAmaMgulimuhapottIkarajuyatalatalatthajuttayaharaNo / avaNiya jahottadosaM gurusamuhaM bhaNai payaDamiNaM // 4 // vAmakaragahiapottIegade seNa vAmakannAo / ArabhiUNaM NaDAlaM pamajja jA dAhiNo kaNNo // 8 // abbocchinnaM vAmayajANuM nasiUNa tattha muhapottiM / rayaharaNamajjhade sammi ThAvae pujjapAyajuga // 9 // tathA isameM muMhapatti se bAyeM kAna se lekara lalATa ko pUMjate hue dAyeM kAna taka pUMjakara muMhapatti ko bAyeM ghuTane para rakhanA batAyA hai| muMhapatti hAtha meM rakhane se hI kAna lalATAdika kI pramArjanA karake jIvadayA pAla sakate haiM, paraMtu hamezA muMhapatti baMdhI huI hove to muhaMpatti se pramArjanA nahIM ho sakatI usase jIvadayA bhI nahIM pala sakatI / isalie muMhapatti bAMdhanA sarvathA zAstra viruddha hai| jaina AcAroM se anabhijJa aMgreja kA kahanA koI mahatva nahIM rakhatAhai / TIkAkAra - pUrvAcAryoM ke vacana prAmANika gine jAte haiN| . Agama ke mUlasUtra se bhI muhapattI bA~dhate nahIM the, yaha siddha hotA hai / vipAkasUtra meM mRgAvatIne gautama svAmIjI ko muMha bA~dhane kA kahA hai, agara baMdhA huA hI hotA to kyoM bAMdhane kA kahatI ? isa prakAra mUla Agama se muhapattI muMha para nahIM bAMdhanI siddha hai / to bhI "mukhavastrikA hAtha meM rakhanA yA mu~ha para bAMdhanA aisA eka bhI spaSTa pATha Agama meM nahIM hai" aise jhUThe gappe lagAte hai| 4. devasUri sAmAcArI prakaraNa graMtha meM rajoharaNa pratilekhana karate vakta mu~ha para muhapattI bAMdhane kA likhA hai, aisA lekhaka kahate hai, usase to spaSTa siddha hotA hai, usI vakta muMha bAMdhanA, usake alAvA nahIM bAMdhanA / - 30

Page #35
6000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 5. senasUrijI ne hitazikSA pATha meM kahA hai, vaha barAbara hI hai usase bhI muha bAMdhane kI siddhi nahIM hotI hai / unhoMne spaSTa sthAnakavAsI sAdhu kI vezabhUSA batAkara mukha bAMdhe te mukhapattI na Ave puNya ke kAma' yAni muhapattI bAMdhane se puNya nahI hotA hai aisA kahakara bAMdhane kA niSedha hI kiyA hai| 6. haribalamacchI rAsa pR. 73 ke pATha meM bhI vyAkhyAna ke samaya muhapattI bAMdhanI aura sAdhu vidhi prakAza meM pratilekhanA karate samaya muhapattI bAMdhanI kahA hai| usase spaSTa hotA hai ki usake alAvA na bAMdhe, agara aisA na ho aura baMdhI huI ho to usa samaya bAMdhane kI kyoM likhate ? 8. yatidinacaryA meM zaucAdi samaya muhapattI bAMdhanI, durgaMdha se nAsikA meM arzAdi rogoM se bacane Adi ke lie batAyI hai use unakI sAmAcArI samajhanA / vahI para bAMdhanI, matalaba usake alAvA hamezA nahIM bAMdhanA siddha hotA hai| 9. yogazAstra vRtti meM paDhane - prazna puchate vakta pustakAdi hAtha meM hone se muhapattI kA upayoga rakhane meM duvidhA hone se muhapattI bAMdhanA likhA hai vaha bhI yogya hai usake alAvA nahIM bAMdhanA svata: siddha hotA hai| ___ 10. zatapadI meM upadeza dete samaya muhapattI bAMdhanA kahA hai, vaha bhI barAbara hai pahale pravacana zAstra ke AdhAra se hI dete the, hAtha meM zAstra ho to muhapattI ke upayoga meM duvidhA Ane se bAMdhanA kahA hai / usake alAvA nahIM bAMdhanA siddha hotA hai / vartamAna meM nAjuka kAgajavAlI tADapattiyAM, hastaprata zAstra hAtho meM rakhate nahIM hai, ata: bAMdhane kI jarurata nahIM, paraMtu kevala bolate samaya muhapattikA upayoga rakhane kI jarurata rahatI hai| 11. AcAra dinakara meM vasati pramArjana aura vAcanA meM muhapattI bAMdhanA likhA hai / vasati pramArjana meM dhula Adi nAsikA meM na jAveM ityAdi surakSA ke liye / vAcanA kA kAraNa upara kI taraha / usake alAvA nahIM bAMdhanA siddha hotA hai|| 12. bRhatkalpa bhASya kA pATha gaNadhara vyAkhyAna vAMcate muhapattI bAMdhanA likhA hai, vaha korI gappa hai / pATha denA cAhiye / asatkalpanA se mAna bhI le, - 31

Page #36
G006 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" 0960 to bhI usake alAvA nahIM bAMdhanA siddha hotA hai| 13. nizItha cUrNi - vArtAlApa meM mu~ha bAMdhane kI bAta bhI korI gappa hai / pATha denA caahiye| 14. eka bhI pratikramaNa graMtha meM pratikramaNa samaya muhapattI bAMdhane kI bAta nahIM hai / muhapattI paDilehaNa kI bAta AtI hai| 15. pravacana sAroddhAra meM saMpAtima jIvoM kI rakSA ke liye muhapattI bAMdhanI nahIM likhI hai, balki bolate samaya jIvarakSA ke liye muhapattI kA upayoga karanA, yaha bhAva hai| ____16. buddhi vijayajI ko vRddha saMta ne uttara diyA, vaha vyAkhyAna ke samaya muhapattI bAMdhane kI bAta hai / hamezA ke liye nahIM / ___ 17. zivapurANa pATha kA dhAraNa karane kA artha bAMdhanA nahIM apitu bolate vakta use mu~ha para dhAraNa karanA hai / jo zivapurANa ke dusare pATha se hI spaSTa hai| .. - vastrayuktaM tathA hastaM, kSipyamANaM mukhe sadA / dharmeti vyAharaMntaM, namaskRtya sthitaM hre||||shivpuraann, jJAnasaMhitA, 29 vA adhyAya, zloka naM. 311 // isa zivapurANa ke zloka meM spaSTa vastrayukta (muhapattIvAle) hAtha ko (bolate samaya) mukhapara rakhate aura dharmalAbha bolate, aise jaina sAdhu kA varNana kiyA hai / isa prakAra jainetara graMtho se bhI muhapattI hAtha meM rakhane kI hI siddhi hotI hai| __isa prakAra sabhI pramANoM ke parIkSaNa se spaSTa hotA haiM ki lekhakane jo pramANa muhapattI bAMdhane ke diye hai ve sabhI sAre dina muhapattI nahIM bAMdhane kI siddhi kara rahe hai / ata: "prAcIna paddhati mu~ha para bAMdhane kI hI thI, yaha prAcIna pramANoM siddha hotA hai" yaha lekhaka kA kathana sarAsara mithyA siddha hotA hai / Dore se muMhapattI bAMdhanA to zAstroM meM kahIM para bhI nahIM batAyA hai| . 2000 varSa prAcIna kaMkAlI TIlA (kRSNarSi kI mUrti), osiyAjI, kuMbhAriyAjI, Abu, rANakapura, pAlItANA, sAMDerAva, sevADI Adi aneka sthaloM meM 500-700-1000 varSa prAcIna sabhI gurumUrtiyAM hAtha meM muMhapattIvAlI - milatI haiM / eka bhI prAcIna mUrti mu~ha baMdhI nahIM milatI hai / isase bhI - 32

Page #37
-6000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 muhapattI hAtha meM rakhanA hI siddha hotA hai / AvazyakatAnusAra bolate vakta usakA upayoga rakhane se apramattatA bhI rahatI hai / aura sAdhu kA liMga bhI vahIM hai / hamezA bAMdhI rakhanA kuliMga hai| vidvAna saMta saMtabAlajI nIDaratApUrvaka kahate hai - "mukhabaMdhana zrI lokAzAha nA samayathI zaru thayela nathI paraMtu tyAra bAda thayelA svAmI lavajI nA samaya thI zaru thayela che ane e jarurI paNa nathI" (jaina jyoti tA. 18-51936 pR. 72 rAjapAla maganalAla boharA kA lekha)) terApaMtha ke AcArya mahAprajJajI ne bhI spaSTa khulAsA diyA hai ki "jaina paramparA meM mukhavastrikA bAMdhane kA itihAsa purAnA nahIM hai| yaha sthAnakavAsI paraMparA se zuru huI hai / muni jIvejI Adi ke samaya se zuru huA hai| kiMtu eka paraMparA ke calane kA artha yaha nahIM ki hama purAne arthoM ko . ThIka se na samajheM / hameM purAne arthoM ko bhI ThIka se samajhanA haiM / hastaka se zarIra kA pramArjana kareM / hastaka kA artha hai mukhavastrikA / mukhavastrikA muMha para bAMdhane kA artha nahIM hai / mukhavastra yAnI rumAla, jaba muni pratilekhana kareM to usa rumAla yA kapaDe se pahale pUre zarIra kA pramArjana kreN| mukhavastrikA se kaise zarIra kA pramArjana kareMgA ? yahI socane kI bAta hai / 'hatthagaM saMpamajjitA' pratilekhana kI vidhi hai ki usase pahale pUre zarIra kA, sira se paira taka hastaka se pramArjana kareM / aba kaise karegA ? hama jo sahI artha hai, use samajha nahIM pAte, isalie ruDhiyAM panapatI hai / mukhavastrikA kA artha muMha para bAMdhane kI paTTI nahIM / Agama meM kahI bhI bAMdhane kA ullekha nahIM hai|" (tattvabodha se sAbhAra uddhRta tA. 01/03/04 sitaMbara 2007) lekhaka ne batAye 3 guNa to hAtha meM rakhane se bhI zakya hai hI, cauthA apramattatA guNa bhI baDhatA hai| muMhapattI viSayaka kaI bAra zAstrArtha bhI hue, para sthAnakavAsI bhAI parAjaya ho jAne para bhI anya sthAna para jAkara kaha dete haiM ki "zAstrArtha meM kyA dharA hai ? hama karate haiM, vaha zAstranusAra hI karate haiM / " para jahA~ aise viSaya 33

Page #38
60 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0960-7 meM sattAdhArI nareza yA paMDita madhyastha na hoM, vahAM jaya parAjaya kA sampUrNa nirNaya nahIM ho sakatA hai / para eka samaya aisA avasara mila gayA ki nyAyazIla nAbhA (paMjAba) nareza kI rAjadhAnI nAbhA meM idhara jainAcArya zrI vijayavallabha sUrijI (usa samaya ke muni zrI vallabha vijayajI mahArAja) udhara sthAnakavAsI pUjya sohanalAlajI ma0 apane viddhAna ziSya muni zrI udayacandajI ke sAtha nAbhA meM padhAra gaye / ina donoM mahAtmAoM ke ApasI praznottara kA kArya nAbhA nareza kI rAja sabhA ke paNDitoM para rakha diyA gayA jisameM jaya parAjaya kA nirNaya nAbhAnareza ke mAdhyama se unakI sabhA ke vidvAna paNDita kareM / basa ! unhoMne jo phaisalA diyA usako akSaraza: yahAM uddhRta kara diyA jAtA hai| phaisalA zAstrArtha nAbhA OM zrIgaNAdhipataye namaH zrImAnmunivara vallabhavijayajI ! . paMDita zreNi sarakAra nAbhA isa lekha dvArA Apako vidita karate haiM / gata saMvatsara meM Apane hamAre yahAM zrI 108 manmahArAjAdhirAja nAbhAnarezajI ke hajUra meM 6 (cha:) prazna nivedana karake kahA thA ki yadyapi jaina mata aura jaina zAstra bhI sarvathA eka hai paraMtu kAlAntara se hamAre aura DhuMDhiyoM meM paraspara vivAda calA AtA hai balki kaI eka jagaha para zAstrArtha bhI huA parantu yaha bAta nizcaya nahIM huI ki amuka pakSa sAdhu hai / zrImahArAja kI nyAyazIlatA aura dayAlutA dezAMtaroM meM vikhyAta hai isase hameM AzA hai ki hamAre bhI paraspara vivAda kA mUla Apake nyAya prabhAva se dUra ho jAyegA, bhagavadicchA se ina donoM meM DhUMDhiyoM ke mahaMta sohanalAlajI yahAM Aye hue haiM, unake sanmukha hI hameM ina 6 (cha:) praznoM kA uttara jaina mata ke zAstrAnusAra unase dilAyA jAve / Apake kathanAnusAra ukta mahaMtajI ko isa viSaya kI ittalA dI gaI, Apane ittalA pAkara sAdhu udayacandajI ko apane sthAnApanna kA adhikAra dekara unake hAni lAbha ko apanA svIkAra karake zAstrArtha karanA mAna liyA thaa| tadanaMtara zrI 108 zrImanmahArAjAdhirAjajI kI AjJAnusAra hama logoM 34

Page #39
-G902 sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 ko zAstrArtha ke madhyastha niyata kiyA gayA / tisa pIche kaI dina taka hamAre sAmane ApakA aura udacaMdajI kA zAstrArtha hotA rahA / zAstrArtha ke samaya para jo pariNAma Apane dikhalAye so zAstravihita the / Apa kI ukti aura yuktiyeM bhI niHzaMkanIya aura prAmANika thI / prAyaH karake zlAghanIya haiM / ukta zAstrArtha ke samaya para aura isa DeDha varSa ke aMtara meM bhI jo isa viSaya ko vicArA hai usase yaha bAta siddha nahIM huI ki jaina mata ke sAdhuoM ko vArtAlApa ke sivAya ahorAtra akhaMDa mukha baMdhana aura sarvakAla mukha potikA ke mukha para rakhane kI vidhi hai / kevala bhrAMti hai / kevala vArtAlApa ke samaya hI mukha vastra ke mukha para rakhane kI AvazyakatA hai hamAre buddhi bala kI dRSTi dvArA yaha bAta prakAzita hotI hai ki ApakA pakSa DhUMDhiyoM se balavAna hai / yadyapi ApakA aura DhUMDhiyoM kA mata eka hai aura zAstra bhI eka haiM isameM bhI sandeha nahIM, sAdhu udayacaMdajI mahAtmA aura zAntimAna hai paraMtu Apane jaina mata ke zAstroM meM atIva parizrama kiyA hai aura Apa unake parama rahasya aura gUDhArtha ko prApta hue haiM / satya vohI hotA hai jo zAstrAnusAra ho aura jisameM usake kAyadoM se svamata aura paramatAnuyAyioM kI zaMkA na ho / zAstra ke viruddha aMdhaparaMparA kA svIkAra karanA kevala haTha dharma hai / pUrva vicArAnusAra jaba Apa kA zAstra aura dharma eka hai usake kartA AcArya bhI eka haiM phira Azcarya kI bAta hai ki kahA jAtA hai ki hamAre AcAryoM kA yaha mata nahIM hai aura nA vo ina granthoM ke kartA hai / Apa dekhate haiM ki hamAre bhagavAn kalakI avatAra kI bAbata jahAM Apa dekhoge eka hI vRtta pAvegA, aise hI Apa ke bhI jarUrI hai| Apa ke prativAdIke haThake kAraNa aura unake kathAnAnusAra hameM zivapurANa ke avalokana kI icchA huI / basa isa viSaya meM usake dekhane kI koI AvazyakatA nahIM thii| IzvarecchA se usake lekha se bhI yahI bAta pragaTa huI ki vastra vAle hAtha ko sadA mukha para phaikatA hai isa se bhI pratIta hotA hai ki sarva kAla mukha vastra ke mukha para bAMdhe rakhane kI AvazyakatA nahIM hai kintu vArtAlApa ke samaya para vastra kA mukha para honA jarurI hai / Apa ke zAstrArtha - 35 -

Page #40
-G900 sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (09602 se eka hameM bar3A bhArI lAbha huvA hai ki hameM mAlUma ho gayA ki jaina mata meM bhI sUtaka pAtaka grahaNa kiyA hai aura jainI sAdhuoM ko una ke gharoM ke AhArAdi ke lene kI vidhi nahIM hai| ___vyatIta saMvatsara ke jeSTha sudI paJcamI saM. 1961 ko jo zAstrArtha madhya meM chor3A gayA jisakA yaha Azaya thA ki DhUMDhiyoM kI ora se sadA mukha bandhana kI vidhi kA koI pramANa mile so Aja dina taka koI uttara unakI tarapha se pragaTa nahIM huA, ata: una kI mUkatA Apa ke zAstrArtha ke vijaya kI sUcikA hai / basa isa viSaya meM hamArI saMmati hai aura hama vyavasthA yAne phaisalA dete haiM ki Apa kA pakSa una kI apekSA balavAn hai, Apa kI vidyA kI sphUrti aura zuddha dharmAcAra kI niSTA atIva zreSThatara hai / prAyaH karake jaina zAstra vihita pratIta hotA hai aura hai| ityalam 18 pauha saM. 1962 mu. riyAsata nAbhA / 1. paNDita bhairavadatta. 2. paNDita zrIdhara rAjya paNDita nAbhA. 3. paNDita durgAdatta. 4. paNDita vAsudeva. 5. paNDita vanamAlidatta jyotiSI. ukta phaisale ke Ane para zrImuni vallabhavijayajI ne zrImAn nAbhA nareza ko eka patra likhA, usa kI nakala Age dete haiN| ___ zrImAn mahArAjA sAhiba nAbhApatijI jayavante raheM, aura rAya-koTa se sAdhuvallabhavijaya kI tarapha se dharma lAbha vAMcanA / devaguru ke pratApa se yahAM sukha zAnti hai, aura Apa kI hamezA cAhate haiM / samAcAra yaha hai ki Apa ke paMDitoM kA bhejA huA phaisalA pahu~cA, paDha kara dila ko bahuta Ananda huA, nyAyI aura dharmAtmA mahArAjoM kA yahI dharma hai, ki satya aura jhUTha kA nirNaya kareM jaisA ki Apane kiyA hai, kitane hI samaya se bahuta logoM ke udAsa hue dila ko Apa ne khuza kara diyA, isa bAre meM Apa ko bAra bAra dhanyavAda hai| aba isa phaisale ke chapavAne kA irAdA hai, so riyAsata nAbhA meM chapavAyA jAve 36

Page #41
-60 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 yA aura jagaha bhI chapavAyA jA sakatA hai / AzA hai ki isakA javAba bahuta jalda mile / tA. 18-1-1906, da0 vallabhavijaya jaina sAdhu / / pUrvokta patra ke uttara meM nAbhA nareza ne paNDitoM ke nAma patra likhA, usakI nakala nIce mujaba hai : brahAmUrta paNDita sAhibAna kameTI salAmata nambara 1193. indula gujAriza pezagAha khAsa se irazAda sAyara pAyA ki bAbA jI ko ittalA dI jAve ki jahAM unakI manazA ho vahAM isako tabaa karAve, yaha una ko akhatiyAra hai, jo kucha paMDatAna ne batalAyA vaha bhejA gayA hai, lihAjA mutakallipha khidamata hU~ ki Apa bamanazA hukma tAmIla pharmAvaM, 10 mAgha saMvat 1962 Apa sarizataha DyoDhI pannAlAla, srishthdaar| isa patra ke uttara meM kameTI paMDitAna ne zrImuni vallabhavijayajI ke nAma patra likhA, usakI nakala yaha hai - "brahA svarUpa bAbA sAhibajI zrImahAtmAvallabhavijayajI sAhiba sAdhu salAmata. naM. 776" . sarakAra bAlA dAma hazmatahU se ciTThI ApakI peza hokara badIM javAba batavassula DyoDhI mubArika va havAlaha hukma khAsa badI irazAda sadUra huA ki bAbAjI ko italA dI jAve ki jahA~ unakA manazA ho tabaa karAveM, bakhidamada mahAtmAjI namaskAra dasta bastaha hokara iltimAsa kiyA jAtA hai ki jahA~ ApakA manazA ho chapavAyA jAve, aura jo phaisalA tanAjaa bAhamI sAdhuAn mahAtmA kA jo jainamata ke anusAra paNDitAna ne kiyA thA, Apake pAsa pahu~ca cukA hai mutalaa ho cukA hai, taharIra 11 mAgha saMvat 1962 da0 saMpUrNasiMha aja sarizahata kameTI paNDitAna // jisa prakAra nAbhA kA phaisalA huA aura isameM sthAnakavAsiyoM kA parAjaya huA thA isI prakAra paTiyAlA ilAkA ke samAnA zahara meM bhI zAstrArtha huA usa meM bhI sthAnakavAsiyoM kA hI parAjaya huA thA aura bAta bhI ThIka hai ki jina logoM ne jaina-zAstra viruddha AcaraNa kI hai una logoM kA parAjaya hotA hI hai kyoMki DorADAla dinabhara mu~hapattI bAMdhane meM na to jainazAstra sahamata hai na paradharma ke zAstra / aura na aitihAsika sAdhanoM ke pramANa 37

Page #42
2006 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 hI sammata haiM itanA hI kyoM para yaha prathA loka viruddha bhI hai isa kuliMga kI sthAna sthAna niMdA aura avahelanA hotI hai jaina dharma kI niMdA aura ha~sI karavAI hai to aise kuliMga dhAriyoM ne hI karavAI hai ina logoM ke liye hameM dayA AtI hai zAsana deva inako sadbuddhi pradAna kare inake alAvA aura kyA kiyA jaay| - isa nAbhAnareza va paNDitoM ke phaisale se pAThakavarga aura vizeSakara hamAre sthAnakavAsI bhAI ThIka taura para samajha gaye hoMge ki jainazAstroM va anyadharma ke granthoM ke AdhAra para diyA huA phaisalA sApha-sApha pukAra rahA hai ki jaina muniyoM ke mukhavastrikA kA sanAtana se hAtha meM aura bolate samaya mu~ha Age rakhanA hI vidhAna hai| hArA juArI dugunAkhele ese phaisaloM se aura etihAsika sAdhanoM se ina kalpitamata (sthAnakavAsI) kI cAroM aura pola khulane lagI aura samajhadAra bhava bhIrU sthAnakavAsI sAdhu eka ke pIche eka mu~hapatI kA mithyA DorA tor3a kara mUrtipUjA ke upAsaka banane lge| isa hAlata meM sthAnakavAsiyoM ke pAsa dUsarA koI upAya na rahA jisa se rahe hue abodha logoM ko kucha bhI AzvAsana dekara una ke calacitako sthira kara sake / phira bhI yaha karanA ina logoM ke lie jarUrI thA ataeva hAla meM hI ina logoMne 'pItAMbara parAjaya' nAmaka eka choTA sA TrekTa chapavAyA, jisa meM bilakula kalpita aura asabhya zabdoM meM Apa apanI jaya aura jaina muniyoM kA parAjaya hone kA mithyA prayatna kiyA hai / para aba janatA evaM vizese sthAnakavAsI samAja itanA ajJAnandhakAra meM nahIM hai ki nAbhA-nareza kI sabhA ke paNDitoM ke hastAkSara se diyA huA phaisalA aura khAsa nAbhAnareza ke sAtha patra vyavahAra dvArA mahArAja nAbhAnareza ne apanI sabhA ke paNDitoM dvArA diyA huA nyAyapUrvaka phaisalA chapAne kI ijAjata deM / usa phaisalA ko asatya samajhe aura sthAnakavAsI kaI matAgrahI logoM kI kalpita evaM bilakula jhUThI bAtoM ko satya samajha le ? yadi sthAnakavAsI bhAI jainamuniyoM kI parAjaya aura apanI jaya honA ghoSita karate haiM to unako 38

Page #43
-G006 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 kahanA cAhiye ki nAbhAnareza kI sabhA ke kisI paNDita kA diyA huA phaisalA ki eka lAina taka bhI janatA ke sAmane rakhe / yadi ApakA yaha kahanA ho ki madhyastha paNDitoM ke andara se saba ke saba nahIM kintu kucha paNDitoM ne phaisalA diyA hai parantu Apa una madhyastha paNDitoM se kisI eka kA . to isa phaisalA ke viSaya meM virodha ho to unake hastAkSara le jAhira kareM varanA aba thothI bAtoM aura mithyA lekhoM se janatA ko bhrama meM DAla dene kA jamAnA nahIM hai ki nAbhA nareza kI sabhA ke niyata kiye hue madhyastha paNDita ubhaya tarapha kI dalIleM suna nirpakSa bhAvoM se phaisalA deM aura usa phaisalA ko chapavAne kI khAsa nAbhA nareza apanI anumati deM usako to janatA asatya samajha le aura pramANa zUnya manaH kalpita bilakula jhUThI bAteM para sahasA duniyA vizvAsa karale ? isase to aisI raddI pustakeM prakAzita karavAne vAloM kI ulTI ha~sI hotI hai phira bhI "hArA juArI dUganA khele" isI yukti ko hamAre sthAnakavAsI kaI matAgrAhI loga ThIka caritArtha kara rahe haiM tathApi isa satyatA ke yuga meM sadaiva satya kI hI jaya ho rahI hai| // mUrtipUjA kA prAcIna itihAsa // (pR. 412 se pR. 412) "maMdira-mUrti saMbaMdhI pramANa" kI samIkSA lekhaka zrI ko isa prakaraNa meM vAstavika rIti se maMdira - mUrti ke virodhI Agama pramANa dene cAhiye the, paraMtu Agama meM kahIM para bhI eka zabda * bhI maMdira - mUrti virodhI nahIM milane para hiMsA-hiMsA kA zora macAte hai| ahiMsA saMbaMdhi aneka Agama pATha diye usakA to kauna niSedha karatA hai ? paraMtu kyA pUre sthAnakavAsI samAja meM eka bhI sAdhu aisA hai, jisake sAdhu-jIvana meM aMza mAtra bhI hiMsA nahIM huI ho ? yaha zakya hI nahIM hai| gamanAgamana - nadI utaranA Adi kriyA hone para bhI, unameM hiMsA hone para bhI una kriyAoM ko Avazyaka mAnakara unase pApabaMdha nahIM hotA, aisA lekhaka khuda hI pR. 12 para likha rahe hai / isalie hiMsA-ahiMsA ko sUkSma dRSTi se samajhanI Avazyaka hai / unake svarupa-hetu anubaMdha ye tIna bheda hai / - 390

Page #44
60 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 1. svarupa hiMsA - jIva mare yA jIvoM ko duHkha hove / svarUpa ahiMsA - jIvana na mare yA unako duHkha na hoveM / 2. hetu hiMsA - hiMsA kA mukhyakAraNa ayatanA - jIva na mare usakA dhyAna na rakhanA, upayoga na rakhanA, yaha hetu hiMsA / hetu ahiMsA - yatanA rakhanI - jIva na mare usakA dhyAna rakhanA . 3. anubaMdha hiMsA - jisa pravRtti se pariNAma meM hiMsA ho, jisakA phala hiMsA ho| _ anubaMdha ahiMsA - jisa pravRtti se pariNAma meM ahiMsA ho, jisakA phala ahiMsA ho| anubaMdha hiMsA - ahiMsA meM dhyeya kI mukhyatA hai / ahiMsA kA pAlana kisa Azaya se kara rahA hai yA hiMsA kisa Azaya se kara rahA hai, usase usakA nirNaya hotA hai / abhavya kA jIva sUkSma cAritra pAlana kareM, sUkSma ahiMsA kA pAlana kareM to bhI dhyeya zuddhi na hone se use anubaMdha hiMsA hotI hai / susAdhu -- nadI utaratA hai to bhI use anubaMdha ahiMsA hotI hai| tabhI to araNikAputra AcArya ko nadI utarate khuda ke zarIra ke khUna se apkAya ke jIvoM kI hiMsA hote hue bhI kevalajJAna kI prApti aura mokSagamana ho sakA / (isake vistRta vivecana ke liye dekhie - 'jainAgama siddha mUrtipUjA' pR. 212 se pR. 223) ___ maMdira nirmANa - jinapUjAdi meM yatanA aura dhyeya kI zuddhi hone para,. vahA~ bhI pAramArthika anubaMdha ahiMsA hai / dekhiye pUrvAcAryoM ke vacana - satAmasya kasyAcid yatanA bhaktizAlinAm / anubandho hyahiMsAyA jinapUjAdikarmaNi // khAsa bAta to yaha hai ki - maMdira nirmANa - jinapUjAdi ke adhikArI / sAdhu nahIM paraMtu zrAvaka hai / sAdhu sAvadya yogoM se mana-vacana-kAyA se nivRtta / hai| zrAvaka to saMsAra meM baiThA hai, hiMsA rojAnA jIvana meM cAlu hI hai / dusarI aneka prakAra kI hiMsAe~ karate hue bhI hiMsA-hiMsA kA zora macAkara jo jinapUjAdi nahIM karate hai, vaha unakI mUrkhatA hai| dekhiye - pUrvadhara umAsvAtIjI ma. ke vacana - .40

Page #45
G000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0960--2 dehAdi NimittaM pi hu je, kAyavahammi taha payasa'ti / jiNapUAkAyavahammi, tesimapavattaNaM moho / (zrAvakaprajJapti gAthA naM. 349) . bhAvArtha : zarIra, vyApAra khetI Adi sAMsArika kAryo meM tathA saMtasatiyoM kI janma-jayantiyA~, zmazAna yAtrA, kitAbeM chapavAnA, maryAdA mahotsava, dIkSA mahotsava, cAturmAsa meM vAhana dvArA saMta-satiyoM ke darzanArtha jAnA, baDe-baDe sthAnaka, sabhA-bhavana, samatA bhavana banavAnA Adi dhArmika kAryoM meM hiMsA karate hI haiM, lekina jIvahiMsA kA bahAnA banAkara jo loga samakita aura mokSa denevAlI jinapUjA nahIM karate hai / yaha unakA mithyAtva hai ! moha hai !! mUrkhatA hai !!!! pUrvAcAryoM kI vANI ko mAnane vAle sapUta yA avahelanA kareM vaha sapUta ? nirNaya svayaM kre| .. isI bAta ko ekAvatArI 1444 graMthoM ke praNetA, videza ke aneka mahAviddhAnoM dvArA pramANita kiye gaye, aise haribhadrasUrijI ma.sA. ne apane paMcAzaka mahAgraMtha ke caturtha paMcAzaka meM bhI kahIM hai| digaMbaroM meM bhI unake pUrvAcAryoM ne bhI isa vastu ko svIkArA hai| dekhiye : "thoDA AraMbha hote hue usakI bhAvanA AraMbha karane kI nahIM hai / lekina AraMbha ke binA koI bhI gRhastha kArya nahIM hotA / dravya se pUjA karanevAloM ko thoDA AraMbha hotA hI hai, usake badale meM mahAn puNya bhI hotA hai, aisA svayaMbhU stotra meM likhA hai|" ("eka hI rAstA" pR.44 lekhaka dhavalasAgarajI) zvetAMbara - digaMbaroM meM sabhI pUrvAcArya ekamata se isa vastu ko svIkArate haiM / kevala lekhaka mahAzaya jaise hI isameM doSa batAte hai / lekhaka mahAzayane Age - pIche apazabdoM kI laMbI prastAvanA karake saMskRta-prAkRta ke anabhijJa pAThakoM ko ullu banAne ke lie pR. 13 aura pR. 24 para sAdhu saMbAMdhi mahAnizItha sUtra ke pATha diye haiM / sAdhu ke liye upara kahe mutAbika maMdira, jinapUjA Adi sAvadya hone se varjita hai / pR. 13, pR. 24 pAThoM meM sAdhu usameM pravRtti kareM usase spaSTa hI unake liye vaha doSa kA 41

Page #46
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM " kAraNa, saMsAra bhramaNa kA kAraNa batAyA hai / gRhastha ke liye vahI hitakArI hotA hai / jisase mahAnizItha ke pATha se mUrtipUjA kA virodha hotA hI nahIM hai / dekhiye mahAnizItha sUtra tRtIya adhyayana meM spaSTa pATha hai : 'tesiya tiloyamahiyANa dhammatitthagarANa jagaguruNaM bhAvaccaNa davvaccaNa bheeNa duhaccaNaM bhaNiyaM bhAvaccaNaM caritANaTThANa - kaThuggaghoratavacaraNa, davvaccaNaM, virayAvirayasIla pUyA sakkaradANAI / to goyamA esatthe paramatthe / taM jahAbhAkccaNa-maggavihArayAya davyaccaNaM tu jina pUyA / paDhamA jaINa donnivi gihINa / isa prakAra spaSTa pUjA ke do bheda batAkara muni ko bhAva pUjA hI hai, zrAvaka ko dravya-bhAva yaha donoM pUjA hai / isa paramArtha satya ko mahAnizItha sUtra meM batAyA gayA hai / Age lekhaka zrI "praznavyAkaraNa - AcArAMgAdi sUtroM meM bhagavAna ne dharmopadeza meM jIvoM kI rakSA - dayA - vairAgyAdi kA upadeza dene kA batAyA hai, maMdira mUrti Adi kA upadeza dene kA kahIM bhI nahIM kahA " aisA batA rahe hai / unhoMne yaha vicAra nahIM kiyA ki paramAtmA ne upadeza meM gAyoM ko ghAsa, kabutara kA cuggA (jinameM ekendriya kI hiMsA hotI hai), sthAnakAdi banavAnA, sAdharmika kI bhakti karanA vagairaha bhI nahIM batAyA, to kyA ve saba varjita hai ? ina saba meM hiMsAto hotI hI hai / Age lekhaka ne vyavahAra cUlikA kA caMdragupta ke 16 svapna meM cauthe pAMcave svapna ke phala kA pATha dekara niSkarSa nikAlA ki usa samaya jinapratimA - maMdira nahIM the, tabhI svapna ke kuprabhAva se yaha honA likhA / paraMtu unakI yaha kalpanA galata hai / zrAvaka maMdira - mUrti banavAne - pUjana ke adhikArI hai / sAdhu kevala bhAvapUjA ke adhikArI hai, paraMtu kAla ke prabhAva se kitaneka sAdhu vezadhArI patita hokara nahIM karane ke kAma kareMge / isalie vahA~ spaSTa 'lobha se kareMge' likhA hai / ataH lekhaka kI kukalpanA vyartha hai / vaise to paM. kalyANavijayajI ne nibaMdha nicaya meM usa vyavahAra cUlikA ko kRtrima kahA hai, isalie vastuta: yaha pramANabhUta nahIM hai / 42

Page #47
-G006 sAMca ko AMca nahIM" 09602 - pIche lekhakazrI jhUThe zilAlekha likhakara gADane kI kukalpanA karate haiM vicAra kareM - prAmANika itihAsa se jJAta hotA hai ki lauMkAzAha ke pUrva mUrtipUjA kA virodha thA hI nahIM to bhalA kauna aura kyo hajAroM kI saMkhyA meM lekha-mUrtiyAM gADane kI ceSTA karegA lekhakakI kalpanA ke hisAba se to vaisA koI sarvazaktimAna vyakti mAnanA paDegA jo jagaha-jagaha para, videza meM - anArya kSetroM meM - dariye meM bhI hajAroM kI saMkhyA meM lekha-mUrtiyA~ Adi gADane kA yA DAlane kA kAma karatA hogA / yA to aise hajAroM vyakti mAnane paDeMge, jinako kUTalekhoM kA kAma sopA ho / kaisI bhaddI kalpanA hai. mahAzaya kI ! videza ke aura bhArata ke mahAn itihAsajJa - mahAn viddhAna jina lekhoM ko sacce mAnate haiM, jina lekhoM ke AdhAra para itihAsa kI gupta kar3iyA~ sulajhatI hai aura itihAsakAra AnaMdita hote hai, una lekhoM ko mahAzaya kalpita mAnane kI ceSTA karate hai / aura saMmUchima jaisI jisakI utpatti hai, jisakI prAcInatA kA eka bhI pramANa nahIM hai, sabhI vidvAnoM ne jise arvAcIna mAnA hai, aise sthAnakavAsI paMthako prAcIna siddha karane kI kukalpanAe~ karate haiM / hai nA lekhaka kI buddhizAlItA ? aneka pUrvAcAryoM dvArA pramANita zaMkhezvara pArzvanAtha kI mUrti kI prAcInatA, niyukti cUrNi - TIkAdi se bhI siddha jIvita svAmI kI pratimA ko DhoMga - tuta kahane kI kubuddhi sujhatI hai / re mithyAtva ! terA kaisA prabhAva ? baDe-baDe viddhAnoM ko kadAgraha se bhAna bhulA detA hai| - pakaDI gaI beImAnI !!! Age lekhaka kI beImAnI dekhiye - kalikAlasarvajJa A. zrI hemacaMdrasUrijI ma. ke. yogazAstra pR. 287 kA pATha apanI kubuddhi se zabda joDakara galata artha karate hai / yogazAstra meM mUrtipUjA kA eka zabda meM bhI niSedha nahIM hai, apitu jinapUjA kI vistRta vidhi batAyI hai / graMthakAra to alaga hI kaha rahe hai / sAvadya Arambha meM zAstrakAra vacana se bhI anumodanA na ho usa bAta kA dhyAna rakhate hai / "snAna vilepanAdi svataH siddhavastu kA upadeza nahIM hotA hai paraMtu jo pUjA vagairaha aprApta vastu ho usI ko zAstra -43

Page #48
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM " batAte haiM / " yaha bAta kahakara graMthakAra Age devagRha gamana kI vidhi - sarva RddhipUrvaka jAnA vagairaha vistRta vidhi batAte hai| isase pAThaka lekhaka kI beImAnI samajha sakate hai / Age lekhaka mahAzaya maMdira mArgiyoM ko kahate hai- "zarmahIna hokara kahate jA rahe hai ki jainadharma meM mUrtipUjA anAdi se hai" hama zarmahIna hokara nahI kahate hai, paraMtu aneka AgamoM ke Thosa pramANoM se siddha hone se garva se mUrtipUjA ko anAdi batA rahe haiN| jabaki lekhaka svayaM saMmUrchima jaise Tapake hue pramANahIna paMtha ko zarmahIna hokara bhagavAna mahAvIra se joDane kI kuceSTA kara rahe hai / AgamoM meM jagaha- jagaha para zAzvata (anAdi) jinapratimAoM kI bAta hai, accaNijja pUNijja kahakara Agama hIM unhe, pUjanIya batA rahe hai to mUrtipUjA anAdi svayaMsiddha ho hI jAtI hai| kevala isake lie lekhaka zrI ko abhiniveza kA kAlA cazmA utArakara samyagadarzana ke pavitra cazme se AgamoM kA avalokana karane kI AvazyakatA hai / Age lekhaka ne samyaktva zalyoddhAra kI bAta ko lekara pUrI beImAnI kI hai, samyaktva zalyoddhAra pR. 4 para pU. AtmArAmajI ma. praznavyAkaraNa sUtra ke pAMcaveM saMvara dvAra kA pATha dekara Age isa prakAra likhate hai " bhAvArtha - pAtra 1 pAtrabaMdhana 2 pAtrakesarikA 3 pAtra sthApana 4 paDale tIna 5 rajastrANa 6 gocchA 7 tIna pracchAdaka 10 rajoharaNa 11 colapaTTA 12 mukhavastrikA 13 vagairaha upakaraNa saMjama kI vRddhi ke vAste jAnane // upara likhe upakaraNoM meM unake kitane, sUta ke kitane, laMbAI vagairaha kA pramANa kitanA, kisa-kisa prayojana vAste aura kisa rIti se vartane vagairaha koI bhI DhuMDhaka jAnatA nahIM hai, aura na yaha sarva upakaraNa ina ke pAsa hai / " lekhaka ne jo isa graMtha meM "jisa sAdhu ke pAsa ye upakaraNa nahIM ho aura anya koI bhI upakaraNa ho vaha jaina sAdhu nahI hai " aisA honA likhA hai yaha vAkya nahIM to uparokta pATha meM hai nahIM Age pIche bhI graMtha meM hai / hogA bhI kaise upara mUlasUtra meM ' muhaNaMtagamAiyaM' tathA usake anuvAdameM batAye vagairaha zabda se anya saMyamopayogI upakaraNa grahaNa kiye hai to pU. AtmArAmajI jaise mahAvidvAna aisA kaise likheMge / 44

Page #49
-G000 sAMca ko AMca nahIM" 09602 lekhaka kUTanIti se galata pATha peza kara rahe hai / pAThaka svayaM upara ke pATha se nirNaya kreN| praznavyAkaraNa ke pATha se to ulTI khuda kI jAMgha hI khulI huI / inhoMne jo pR. 37 para, sthAnakavAsiyoM kA AgamAnusAra upakaraNa rakhane kI bAta likhI hai, vaha uDa jAtI hai / ina ke pAsa zAstra meM batAye paTala, rajastrANa, gocchaga upakaraNoM kA nAmonizAna nahIM hai / yaha mata gRhastha se nikalA hone se, saMmUrchima hai / jisase paramAtmA kI vizuddha paraMparA na hone se zAstra meM likhkhe upakaraNa, pratilekhana vidhi vagairaha ke jJAna se rahita hai / ataH kalpita upakaraNa evaM vidhiyA~ calAyI hai / DaMDA rakhanA AcArAMga - dazavaikAlikAdi se siddha hai / bhagavatI zataka 8 uddeza 6 meM spaSTa pATha hai - "evaM gocchaga rayaharaNaM colapaTTaga kaMbala laTThI saMthAraga padRgA bhANiyabA // " ata: "ina upakaraNoM ko manamate rakhane kI paraMparA calAkara bhI apane ko jaina sAdhu kahate hai aura phira bhI likhate samaya inako bhAna nahIM rahatA ki khuda kI jaMghA para kulhADI calAne rupa hama yaha kyA pAgalapana kara rahe hai ? yahI ajJAnadazA aura bhavitavyatA hai|" ye lekhaka ke zabda kisa ko lAgU hote haiM, usakA nirNaya pAThaka hI kareM! ___ Age bhadrabAhu ke 8ve svapna kA phala-jina-jina sthAnoM para prabhu ke kalyANaka hue, una-una sthAnoM para dharma kI hAni hogI - yaha jo hai usakA lekhaka ulTA artha kara rahe hai / una-una sthAnoM para maMdira bane isaliye dharmahAni batA rahe hai / lekhaka kI kubuddhi dekhiye - maMdira se aMtara meM kitanA dveSa bharA hai| agara sthAnaka banate to inake hisAba se dharmavRddhi hotI ! vAstavikatA to yaha hai ki una sthAnoM meM jainoM kI vasati nahIM rahegI - ujjaDa baneMge - isalie dharma kI hAni hogI / jo Aja bhI pratyakSa haiN| ___ Age lekhaka zrI 'pUjAkoTisamaM stotraM' yaha jainatattvAdarza kA pATha dekara sArI jiMdagI pUjA kare to bhI eka stotrapATha ke phala barAbara nahIM hotA, yaha hisAba lagAkara mUrtipUjakoM ko mUrkha - mahAmUrkha kaha rahe hai / vastuta: ye padavIyAM unako khuda ko hI lagatI haiM, cUMki mUrtipUjaka to stotrapATha, maMdira 45

Page #50
-G006 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (D9601 meM bhI karate hai, sAmAyika meM bhI karate haiM aura pUjA kA phala bhI unako ekasTrA meM milatA hai, jabaki sthAnakavAsI to kevala sAmAyikAdi meM hI stotra-pATha kareMge / pUjA meM to pApa mAnane se usa phala se bhI vaMcita hai, to hisAba meM lAbha kisakA baDhegA ? vAstavameM stotrAdi bhI svabhUmikA ke anusAra pUrvapUrva se yukta hokara hI viziSTa phaladAyI hote hai / aMka binA ke zUnyoM kI koI kImata nahIM hotI haiM / isalie kevala mahimAparaka vAkyoM ko lekara dusare yogoM kI anupayogitA siddhi nahIM hotI hai / aba vicAra kareM kauna mUrkha - mahAmUrkha hai ? ajJAna timira bhAskara kA pUrNa avalokana kiyA, inhoMne likhI bAta kA usameM nAmo nizAna bhI nahIM hai / AtmArAmajI jaise dhuraMdhara viddhAna ke graMtha ke nAma se 'kapolakalpita' bAteM likhakara pAThakoM ko ullU banAnA khuda kI kamajorI, khuda ke mata kI ni:sAratA ko prakaTa karatA hai / lekhaka kI yogyatA bhI isase dikhAyI detI hai| ..... Age lekhaka zrI AdhAkarmI Adi doSa lagAke mUrtipUjaka sAdhuoM kI niMdA kara rahe hai / mUrtipUjaka aneka zuddha saMyamI sAdhu Aja bhI AdhAkarmI Adi doSoM kA sUkSmatA se varjana karate dikhAyI dete hai / jabaki aneka sthAnakavAsI saMta-satiyA~ bhI AdhAkarmI Adi kA sevana karate dikhAyI dete hai / ajJAnatA se nityapiMDa ke laghudoSa se chuTane meM AdhAkarmI Adi baDe doSa meM lipaTe hue aneka sthAnakamArgI dikhate haiM / 'hamArA dhovaNa pAnI nirdoSa hotA hai' aisA manase mAnane se pAnI nirdoSa nahIM banatA hai / kevala mAyA cAritA hai / isa kAla meM saMpUrNa zuddha dhovaNa milanA atidurlabha hai / saMto kI preraNA pAkara prAya unhIM ke lie dhovaNa pAnI banAkara rakhA jAtA hai / isalie dveSa se aisA kIcaDa uchAlanA barAbara nahIM hai| 46 -

Page #51
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM" 66 " mUrtipUjA: pAzcAtya vidvAna" kI samIkSA isa prakaraNa meM lekhaka ne misTara lesana sAhiba kA mantavya diyA hai ki bauddha aura jaina dharma meM mUrtipUjA anya dharma ke prabhAva se cAlU huI, yaha kevala unakI kalpanAmAtra hai / bAki dayAnaMda sarasvatI kahate hai- anyadharmoM meM jainoM ke dekhAdekhI - mUrtipUjA cAlu huI hai / ataH kisI ke bhI abhiprAya mAtra se tattvanirNaya nahIM hotA hai| Agama zAstra se hI jaina dharma meM anAdikAla se mUrtipUjA siddha hotI hai / jo isI pustikAmeM Age-pIche aneka pAThoM se siddha kiyA gayA hai| "rAtri meM pAnI rakhanA " kI samIkSA jinazAsana anekAMtamaya hai, utsarga - apavAda se calatA hai / utsarga ke sthAna meM utsarga kA evaM apavAda ke sthAna meM apavAda kA sevana karanA Avazyaka hotA hai / kucha paristhitiyoM meM apavAda ke sthAna para utsarga kA sevana karane para bhI ArAdhaka hotA hai, paraMtu kucha paristhitiyoM meM apavAda ke sthAna para utsarga kI pakar3a rakhane para virAdhaka hotA hai / utsarga - apavAda kI sahI jAnakArI ke lie gurugama se chedagraMthoM ke talasparzI adhyayana kI AvazyakatA rahatI hai / pariNatAdi aneka guNoM se yukta sAdhu hI usakA adhikArI hotA hai, sabhI sAdhu bhI usake adhikArI nahIM hai, aisA zAstra kahate haiM / are chedasUtra to kyA dusare AgamoM ke liye zrI vyavahArasUtra 10 ve uddezeM meM spaSTa rIti se batAyA hai, amuka Agama amuka varSa paryAyavAlA sAdhu hI paDha sakatA hai / itanA spaSTa pATha hone para bhI ye mahAzaya pR. 26 para mUrtipUjakoM para "bhaktajanoM ko zAstra paDhane aura dekhane se mahAna bhaya batAkara kosoM dUra rakha diyA hai / " aisA galata Aropa lagAkara apanI ajJAnatA - abhiniveza prakaTa karate hai / 47

Page #52
6-6000 sAMca ko AMca nahIM" 0960 yaha to atiprasiddha bAta hai ki laukika meM bhI RSimuni Adi bhI apane ziSyoM ko yogyatA dekhakara hI viziSTa zruta - maMtra-vidyAdi dete the, to lokottara jinazAsana meM sarAsara yogyatA kA vicAra kiye binA Agama jaise ativiziSTa gaNadharapraNIta, anya zrutadhara praNIta - Agama zruta, jaise - taise gRhasthAdi ko diye jAyeMge kyA ? itanI sIdhI sI bAta bhI kadAgrahIoM ke gale nahIM utaratI hai / aura ayogyoM ko dekara avidhi karake saMsAra bhramaNa baDhAte rahate haiM / Apa se hI nIkale terApaMthI AcArya jitamalajI Agama pATha kA sahI artha karake bhramavidhvaMsana pR. 361 para spaSTa batA rahe hai - "ketalA eka kahe - gRhastha sUtra bhaNe tehanI jina AjJA che, te sUtranA ajANa che / ane bhagavantanI AjJA to sAdhu ne ija hai / piNa sUtra bhaNavArI gRhastha ne AjJA dIdhI nathI / " .. abhI apanI mUla bAta - jaina sAdhu - sAdhvI ke rAtri meM pAnI rakhanA yA AhAra rakhanA niSiddha hai, yaha bAta barAbara hai| paraMtu jinazAsana kevala utsargamaya nahIM hai / dravya-kSetra-kAla-bhAva kI apekSA se usameM bhI apavAda hai hii| vartamAna me atizuddhivAda ke kAla meM jainadharma kI niMdA na ho, aisI kisI apekSA se mahApuruSoM se AvazyakatA mahasUsa hove to rAta ko pAnI rakhane kI paraMparA cAlu huI hai / yaha eka jItAcAra hai| auSadhI rUpa se koI mUtrAdi kA upayoga kare isaliye vaha ekAnta azuci nahIM hai, kahanA ajJAnatA hai / auSadhI rupa meM upayoga kAraNika hotA hai usameM zuci-azuci; bhakSya - abhakSya gauNa banatA hai / jahara kA bhI auSadhIrupa meM upayoga hotA hai, isalie vaha jahara nahIM hai, aisA nahIM kahA jAtA haiN| NisAkappa vagairaha bhI ApavAdika vidhiyA~ haiM, unheM autsargika banA denA, vaha to virAdhakatA hai / isa avidhi se hI to khuda loka meM niMdApAtra banate haiM evaM jinadharma ko lajAte haiM, aura dusaroM ke upara usakA doSAropaNa karanA, khuda ke doSoM ko chipAnesvarupa mAyAcAritA hai mUtrAdito loka meM bhI azuci ke rupa - 48

Page #53
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM" me prasiddha hai / isaliye paraThane kA viveka na rakhane ke kAraNa zaharoM meM sAdhusAdhvI ke liye vasati durlabha banatI jA rahI hai / vyavahAra sUtra meM mokapratimAdi kI bAteM viziSTa jJAnI - pratimAdhArI ke liye hai / ve viziSTa jJAna ke AdhAra se kalpya - akalpya, sajIva - nirjIva kA viveka kara sakate the / vahAM para mUtra meM kRmi Adi kI saMbhAvanA bhI batAyI hai / ApavAdika ko ekAMta se kalpya mAnakara upayoga karane meM kahIM aise jIvAkula mUtra ke upayoga meM prathama mahAvrata meM bhI, saMyama me bhI doSa saMbhava hai 1. isaliye usako azuci na mAnakara usakA sArvatrika upayoga karanA sacamuca jainadharma kI niMdA karavAkara durlabha bodhitA ko prApta karanA hI hai / " zAstrapATha meM coriyA~" kI samIkSA isa prakaraNa meM lekhaka ne 'cora koTavAla ko DaMDe' kI bAjI khelI hai / mAyAcAritA se aMgreja vidvAna kA nAma de dekara ajJa pAThakoM ko unmArga kA rAstA batAte ye lekhaka sacamuca dayApAtra hai / bhavabhramaNa ko kitanA baDhA rahe - hai / san 1888 meM chapI upAsakadazA pustaka ke anuvAda noTa meM hAranala sAhaba ne 1. aNNautthiya pariggahiyANi 2. aNNautthi pariggahiyANi cehayAI 3. aNNautthiya pariggahiyANi arihaMta ceDyAiM / ye tIna pATha dekara 2-3 naMbara ke pATha ko prakSipta mAnA hai| tIna naMbara ke pATha ko hAranala sAhaba ne prakSipta mAnA, aisA ajJa logoM ko batAkara prakSepa prakSepa kA zora macAte ho / jabaki do naMbara ke pATha ko bhI unhoMne prakSipta mAnA hai, use khuda bhI svIkArate ho, kyoMki isako svIkAre binA arthaghaTana saMbhava nahIM hai| ajJa pAThakoM ko yaha jAnakArI nahIM hone se aMgreja ke nAma se apanI khIcaDI pakA sakate ho / bAki vidvAna to ApakI beImAnI pakar3a hI leNge| dusarI bAta Apane likhI saMvat 1621/1745/1824 kI pratiyoM se bhI 49

Page #54
- G902 sAMca ko AMca nahIM" 09602 prAcIna pratiyoM meM arihaMta ceiyAI' vAlA pATha TIkAkAra ke sAmane thA tabhI to unhoMne usa pATha ko lekara TIkA kI hai| itanI spaSTa bAta hote hue bhI jaise ullU ko spaSTa sUryaprakAza meM bhI aMdherA dikhatA hai, vaisI lekhaka kI sthiti hai / uparokta pATha kI vistRta samIkSA ke liye dekhiye "jainAgama siddha mUrtipUjA" pR. 109 se pR. 116 / Age isameM jo coriyA~ karanA - raMge hAtha pakaDe jAnA - eka jhUTha ke lie aneka jhUTha karanA vagairaha laMbI apazabdoM kI prastAvanA racI hai, vaha inakI corI pakaDI jAne se inako hI lAgU paDatI hai| inakI jagajAhira coriyoM ke lie isI pustikA meM dekhiye / "namutthuNaM pATha prakSepaH" kI smiikssaa| "bAvIsa abhakSya kI samajha" kI samIkSA .. 22 abhakSya kA spaSTa pATha Agama meM na hone mAtra se usako Agama viruddha kaheMge to sthAnakavAsI paMtha meM anekAneka bAteM Agama meM nahIM hai, ve mAnate haiM to ve kyA Agamaviruddha hai ? 22 abhakSya kA tyAga ahiMsA meM upaSTaMbhaka hai| Agama meM aneka bAteM nahIM hone para bhI pUrvAcAryoM se paraMparA rupa me calI AtI hai , ve Agama bAdhita nahIM ginI jAtI hai / 12vA~ aMga dRSTivAda viccheda hai, 14 pUrva viccheda hai unameM aneka bAteM thI, jo pUrvAcAryoM kI paraMparA se calI AtI hai / saMsakta niyukti pUrva meM se uddhRta hai, usa meM bhI kacce gorasa meM dvidala ke mizraNa se jIvotpatti batAyI hai, usI prakAra kacce gorasa meM kusuMbasAga ke mizraNa se bhI jIvotpatti batAyI hai / bRhatkalpabhASya meM bhI - pAlaMkalaTTasAgA muggakayaM cAmagorasummIsaM / saMsajjai a acirA taM pi niyamA dudosAya // 60 // pUrvAcAryoM kI paraMparA se dvidala - dahI saMyoga se jIvotpatti mAnI jAtI hai / yoni prAbhRta graMtha hAla meM viccheda hai, jisameM dravyoM ke mizraNa se 50

Page #55
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM" tatkAla jIvotpatti ke aneka prayoga the / isalie isameM sajIvatA siddhi me koI bAdha nahIM hai, laukAzAha kI prAcIna sAmAcArI se bhI yaha varjya siddha hotA hai / isameM bhI dvidala meM doSa batAyA hai, vaha isa prakAra - dekhie suzIlakumArajI likhita " jaina dharma kA itihAsa" meM pR. 299-300 para laukAzA kI samAcArI - meM kalama (17) 'jisa dina gorasa liyA jAya usa dina dvidala kA prayoga nahIM honA cAhiye / ' lekhaka ke pUrvaja zrI amolaka RSijI mahArAja apanI pustaka 'jaina tattva prakAza' pR. 497 para 22 abhakSya kA vistRta varNana karake use tyAjya batAte hai / usameM (naM. 18) meM "ghola baDe kacce dahI ko pAnI meM gholakara usameM bar3e (pakauDe) DAle jAte haiM / ve kucha samaya bAda khadabadA jAte haiM / ve bhI abhakSya hai / " isa prakAra dvidala ko tyAjya mAnate hai / khuda ke mAnya pUrvajoM kA bhI virodha karate lekhaka svacchaMdamati hai yA nahIM ? pAThaka svayaM vicAre / Aja ke vijJAnayuga meM sUkSmadarzaka yaMtroM se pratyakSa jIva dikhAI dene para bhI aisI bAteM karanevAle ajJAniyoM ke ajJAna para ha~sI AtI hai| pratyeka kI apekSAse anaMtakAya meM prAyazcita adhika hai, isakA bhI anaMtakAya varjya hai / lekhaka zrI pUrvAcAryoM ko alpajJa aura khuda ko mahAjJAnI mAnakara sabhI 'vastu ke jIvotpatti kA kAla batAne jA rahe hai / " vastu ke aMdara varNa meM, gaMdha meM, rasa meM, sparza meM azubha vikRti hone para jIvotpatti hone kA svabhAva ho sakatA hai" paraMtu vastuoM ke svabhAva ke anusAra amuka kAla meM pakanA, amuka kAla meM bigaDanA nizcita hai / jaise phala-phUla meM yaha pratyakSa hai, vaise hI sabhI vastuoM meM hai / to jahA~-jahA~ para saMbhava hai pUrvAcAryoM ne vaha batAyA hai, bAkI vastuoM ke liye upara kA sAmAnya niyama batAyA hai / cAra mahAvigaI batAyI usameM mAMsa-maMdirA ke samakakSa zahada - makkhana hai, aisA kahIM para bhI nahIM kahA gayA hai, usameM taratamatA avazya hai hI / paraMtu 51

Page #56
-G000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 cAroM mahAvigaiyA~ hI kahalAegI evaM cAroM abhakSya bhI hai / prAcIna graMthoM meM bhI inheM abhakSya mAnA hai / karIba 1100 sAla pUrva vikrama kI dasavIM sadI meM hue viddhAna digaMbarAcArya amRtacandrajI ne 'puruSArthasiddhayupAya' graMtha meM jIvotpatti ke kAraNa inheM abhakSya mAnI hai| ... madhu madyaM navanItaM pizitaM ca mahAvikRtayastAH / ... . ... valbhyante na vratinA tadarNA jantavastatra // 6 // "madhu-arthAt zahada bhI abhakSya hai / madhu-makkhiyAM aneka vanaspatiyoM ke phUloM ke rasa ko ikaTThA karake usa para baiThatI haiM / bhIla, kola Adi asaMskArI jAti ke loga Aga lagAkara, dhuA~ karake makkhiyoM ko uDAte haiM aura makkhiyoM dvArA baDI musIbata se taiyAra kiye hue chate ko toDakara, kapaDe meM bAMdhakara nicoDa lete haiM / nicoDate samaya makkhiyoM ke aNDoM kA rasa bhI usameM mila jAtA hai / isa prakAra ghRNAspada aura pApa se paidA honevAlA madhu khAne yogya nahIM hai / " (jaina tattva prakAza-pR. 497) . "sthAnakavAsI dharma kA jJAna" kI samIkSA isa prakaraNa aura Age ke prakaraNa meM lekhakazrI ne kalpasUtra meM nirdiSTa bhasmagraha kI bAta ke AdhArapara khuda ke saMpradAya meM calatI parApUrva se pITI piTAyI kAlpanika - tathyavihIna bAteM likhI hai / jinake uttara, pUrva meM aneka bAra diye gaye haiM, phira bhI inake pAsa dusare koI bhI prAmANika aitihAsika pramANa nahIM hone se kareM bhI kyA ? ve kI ve bAteM raTe jAte hai / isa prakaraNa meM bhasmagraha ke kAraNa zAsana avanati - asaMyati pUjA - hiMsA-ADaMbara - parigrahadhArI - zithilAcArI sAdhu.... lauMkAzAha ne dharma ko punarjIvita kiyA vagairaha - vagairaha... aneka bAteM kI hai, jisake javAba ke liye dekheM madhyakAla ke ghoTAle kI samIkSA' prakaraNa meM paTTAvalI parAga kA pATha / "zrImAn lokAzAha" meM jJAnasuMdarajI ma. usa samaya kI paristhiti kA varNana isa prakAra karate hai : - 52

Page #57
-600 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 -- "Aja yaha bAta kaha denA baccoM kA khela sA ho gayA hai ki pUrva samayameM jaina sAdhuone zithilAcArI ho jaina zAzana ko bar3I hAni pahu~cAI thii| para yadi thor3AsA parizrama kara tatkAlIna itihAsa ko dekhA jAya to, yaha kahe binA kadApi nahI rahA jAyegA ki usa vikaTa samaya meM cAhe unameM se koI AcArya apavAdasevI bhale hI rahe hoM, para usa samaya unhoMne hajAroM ApattiyA uThA kara bhI jo kAma kiyA hai, vaha unake bAda sahastrAMza bhI kisI ne kiyA ho aisA eka bhI udAharaNa dRSTigocara nahIM hotA hai / yadi yaha kahA jAya ki usa vikaTa samayameM una AcAryoM ne jaina dharma kA jIvana surakSita rakkhA, to bhI koI atizayokti nahIM hai| bhagavAna mahAvIra svAmI se 1000 varSa taka pUrva-zruta jJAna kA prabhAvazAlI yuga hai, usake bAda vIrAt gyAravI zatAbdI se solahavIM zatAbdI kA kAla caityavAsa kA samaya hai / ina pAMca sau varSoM meM jainAcAryoMne jitane rAjAoM ko jaina banAyA, tathA jitane ajainoM ko jaina banAyA, jitane tAtvika viSayoM ke graMtha banAe, aura jitane zAstrArtha kara vijaya vaijayantI phaharAI utane pIche ke itihAsa meM nahIM milate hai / aura yaha bhI nahIM hai ki usa samaya saba zithilAcArI evaM caityavAsI hI the, kyoMki usa samayabhI kaI sAre kriyApAtra evaM kriyA uddhAraka hue haiM / aura usa samaya jo kevala caityavAsI, evaM zithilAcArI hI the, unakI nasoM meM bhI jaina dharma kA gaurava akSuNNa rakhane ko vaha joza bharA huA thA, jo pIche ke sAdhuoM meM AMzika rUpa se hI vidyamAna rahA / parantu Aja hama AlIzAna upAzraya, sthAnaka aura gRhasthoM ke baMgaloM meM ArAma karate hue bhI kucha nahIM karate haiM, kevala gRhasthoM para dama lagA rahe hai, vastutaH zithilAcAra aura caityAdimaThavAsa to yahI hai| kintu apanI galatI na dekha una pUrvaja mahApuruSoM ko zithilAcArI Adi se saMyojita kara unakI niMdA karanA yaha bhISaNa kRtaghnatA hI hai aura saMbhava hai Aja isI vajra pApa se yaha samAja rasAtala meM jA rahA hai| = 53

Page #58
-G006 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 - jyoM jyoM kriyAvAdI, bastIvAsI, aura ugra vihAriyoM kA jora bar3hatA gayA tyo tyoM caityavAsiyoM kI sattA haTatI gaI, vikrama kI terahavIM zatAbdI meM to caityavAsiyoM kI sattA bilakula hI asta ho gaI, kAraNa usa samaya kalikAla sarvajJa bhagavAna hemacandrasUri, rAjaguru kavasUri, malladhArI abhayadevasUri; vAdIdevasUri, jayasiMhasUri, zatArthI somaprabhasUri, jinajandrasUri Adi suvihitAcAryoM kA prabhAva cAroM ora phaila gayA thA, aura mahArAja kumArapAla jaise jaina narezoM kI sahAyatA se jaina dharma kA khUba pracAra ho rahA thA, isI se caityavAsiyoM kA usa samaya prAya: aMta ho gayA thA / arthAt usa samaya koI bhI sAdhu caitya (maMdira) meM nahIM ThaharatA thA / kiMtu sarvatra vastIvAsiyoM kA vijaya DA baja rahA thA / vaha samaya jainadharma kI unnati kA thA, isa samaya meM jaina janatA kI saMkhyA 12 karor3a taka pahu~ca gaI thI / pahile jo pukAra bAra bAra kI jA rahI thI, ki caityavAsa ko dUra karo yaha pukAra caityavAsa dUra hone se svata: naSTa ho gaI thii|" .. zrImAn lokAzAha (pR. 75-72-73) __ isa prakAra aitihAsika anveSaNa se spaSTa hai ki lokAzAha ke samaya meM punaruddhAra kI AvazyakatA thii| - Age lekhakazrI ne sthAnakavAsI ke mukhya uddezya kyA - kyA hai ? usameM Agama viparIta koI bhI prarupaNA nahIM, Agama viparIta koI bhI upakaraNa rivAja rupa meM nahIM rakhanA vagairaha - likhA hai jo kevala bakavAsamAtra hai - muhapattI muMha para 24 ghaMTe bAMdha kara phiranA, laMbA joharaNa vagairaha aneka bAteM Agama viparIta hai dekhiye -paTTAvalI parAga pR. 471 - "lokA ke anuyAyiyoM meM pracalita seMkaDoM aisI bAteM haiM jo 32 AgamoM meM nahIM hai aura unheM ve saccI mAnate hai, taba kaI bAteM unameM aisI bhI dekhI jAtI haiM jo mAnya AgamoM se bhI viruddha hai, isakA kAraNa mAtra isa samAja meM vAstavika talasparzI jJAna kA abhAva hai / (itihAsavettA viddhadarya paM. zrI kalyANavijayajI ma.sA.) 54

Page #59
" sAMca ko AMca nahIM " 00: "mahAtmA laukAzAha kA jIvana kI samIkSA ne isa prakaraNa meM aura pIche ke prakaraNa meM lekhaka likhate hai ki 'lokAzAha punaruddhAra kiyA', to prazna hotA hai ki usake pUrva meM kyA satya dharma nahIM thA ? usakA viccheda huA thA ? bhagavatI sUtra 20 zataka 8 uddeza meM paramAtmA kahate hai - "hai gautama isa jaMbudvIpa bharatakhaMDa meM avasarpiNI kAla meM merA zAsana 21000 varSa paryaMta calegA / " isa sUtra pATha meM viccheda kA athavA punaruddhAra kA nAmanizAna bhI nahIM hai| kintu niraMtara calane kA hI artha nikalatA hai / kalpasUtra meM bhI 2000 varSa taka sAdhu-sAdhvI kI udaya - udaya pUjA hogI ora bhasmagraha ke bAda sAdhu-sAdhvIkI udaya - udaya pUjA hogI aisA kahA hai, grahayoga se jinakI pUjA nahIM hotI thI, unhIM kI vizeSa prakAra se hogI, gRhastha kI pUjA kA usase kyA lenA-denA ? vAstavameM kalpasUtra ke mutAbika zrI AnaMdavimalasUri, zrI hemavilamasUri, zrI dAnasUri, zrI hIrasUrijI zrI jinacaMdrasUrijI vagairaha AcAryoM ne kriyoddhAra kiyA, taba se tyAgI - zuddha - susAdhu kI mAnyatA - pUjyatA loka meM dina-dina phailane lagI- baDhane lagI jo pratyakSa hai / kalpasUtra meM aisA to kahA hI nahIM hai ki bhasmagraha ke kAraNa do hajAra varSa taka dayAmaya dharma kA lopa hogA, loga hiMsAdharma ke kumArga para car3heMge aura graha ke utarane ke bAda koI gRhastha punaruddhAra karegA - usase usakI udayaudaya pUjA hogI / jisa strIne garbhadhAraNa kiyA haiM, vahI putrako janma degI / jo rogI hai, roga dUra hone para vahI nirogI banegA, usI prakAra jinakI pUjA baMda huI hai, unhIM kI pUjA cAlu hogI, yaha spaSTa artha hote hue bhI toDa-moDakara sUtra kA jAnabujhakara ulTA artha karanA asatyapriyatA ko sUcita karatA hai / jaba vi.saM. 1530 meM bhasmagraha utarA to usI samaya saMgha kI rAzi para 55

Page #60
*-G006 sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (20902 dhUmaketu nAma kA vigraha utpAdaka graha A baiThA, jisake prabhAva se hI lokAzAha jaise nihava paidA hue / usane jaina dharma ke aMdara kusaMpa aura azAMti paidAkara sarvanAza karane kA duHsAhasa kiyA / vi. saM. 1525 taka to ajainoM ko jaina banAye jA rahe the, bAda lokAzAha ke kadAgraha ke kAraNa gAmo-gAma phUTakusaMpa aura dhaDAbandhI ke kAraNa ve zaktiyA~ chinna-bhinna ho gaI / lokAzAha ke samaya me jainoM kI saMkhyA 7 karoDa thI jo phUTa-kusaMpa ke kAraNa 12-13 lAkha hI rahI / aba vicAra kIjiye lokAzAha ne kaisA punaruddhAra kiyA ? lokAzAha ke pUre paricaya kA AdhAra lekhakazrI ke pAsa kevala saMvat 1991 meM prakAzita huI 'zrI jaina dharmano prAcIna saMkSipta itihAsa ane prabhuvIra paTTAvalI' pustaka hai / usa pustaka kA AdhAra saMvat 1636 kI likhI hastapustaka 1636 yAni lagabhaga 100 varSa pUrva kI hastapustaka huI, paraMtu usakI bhASA para se use vartamAna meM kisI vyakti kI banAvaTI kRti nizcitarUpa se kaha sakate hai cUMki 400 sAla purAnI bhASA aura abhI kI bhASA meM bahuta aMtara hai / uparokta caritra vartamAnakAlIna bhASA meM haiM, usameM 400 varSa prAcIna bhASA hai hI nhiiN| aitihAsika dRSTikoNa se bhI vaha asatya hai, lokAzAha saM. 1500 meM ahamadAbAda Aye, sAhukArI byAja kA dhaMdhA cAlu kiyA, usake bAda muhammada bAdazAha se mulAkAta kara khajAMcI bane / ye bAte 1636 kI kRti meM batAyI - paraMtu itihAsa ke hisAba se yaha saba hakIkata asatya ThaharatI hai, kyoMki itihAsakAra kahate haiM ki muhammada bAdazAha kA saM. 1497 meM ahamadAbAda meM maraNa huA / aba vicAra kareM - lokAzAha kI saM. 1501 meM bAdazAha se mulAkAta kaise ho sakatI hai ? isaliye ve do hastapratte nakalI hai / isaliye lekhakazrI kA diyA huA lokAzAha kA caritra saMpUrNa kAlpanika banAvaTI siddha hotA hai| 56

Page #61
-G900 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" 0960-3 dusarI bAta munizrI maNIlAlajI kI 'jaina itihAsa aura prabhuvIra paTTAvalI' jo sthAnakavAsI jaina kAryAlaya ahamadAbAda se prakAzita huI hai, use sthAnakavAsI jaina konpharansane tA. 10-5-1936 kI janarala vArSika baiThakameM amAnya ghoSita kiyA thA / cUMki pustaka meM itihAsa asatya - avizvasanIya thA / isase bhI lekhakazrI ne diyA huA caritra apramANika siddha hotA hai| satyapriya sthAnakavAsI viddhAna nagInadAsa giradharalAla zeTha apane 'mUla jaina dharma ane hAlanA saMpradAyo' pustaka meM lokAzAha ke viSaya meM isaprakAra abhiprAya dete hai - 'kharI vAta e che ke lokAzAha saMbaMdhI paNa ghaNI vigato upalabdha che, paraMtu te badhI vAtoM sthAnakavAsIonI hAlanI manathI mAnelI mAnyatAthI viruddha jAya cha / tethI sthAnakavAsIoM te vAto jovA ke tapAsavAnI tamA paNa karatA nathI ane bacAvamAM kahe che ke virodhiyoM to lokAzAha mATe game tema kahe che te vAta sthAnakavAsIoM mAnavA taiyAra nthii| ___sthAnakavAsIone pote satyanA anuyAyI hovAno daMbha karavo che paNa satya jANavA - tapAsavAnI darakAra karavI nathI ! je aneka vizvasanIya pramANoMthI asatya Tharatu hoya tene paNa asatya tarIke na svIkAra temAM ajJAna nathI paNa daMbha ane durAgraha cha / ane daMbha tathA durAgraha te mithyAtvanA aMzo gaNAya cha / ' 343, 344 . 'aMdhazraddhAthI munizrI sadAnaMdIne tathA sthAnakavAsIone sAcA pramANoM na mAnavA hoya ane sarvadharmakriyAno niSedha karanAra lokAzAha ne khoTI rIte 'dharmaprANa' kahI asatya mAnyatAnuM pApa vahora hoya to te jainadharmI kahevaDAvanAra mATe dUSaNa cha / ' pR. 340 lokAzAha ke samakAlIna athavA unake najadIka ke kAla meM racanAyeM huI, unase hI lokAzAha kA vAstavika caritra mila sakatA hai / sAta lekhakoM kI prAcIna kRtiyoM se kucha satyatA prApta ho sakatI hai| usameM se pA~ca kRtiyoM ko nagInadAsa zeTha isa prakAra batAte hai - ___- 1. vi. saM. 1543 siddhAMta copAI' lekhaka paM. munizrI lAvaNyasamaya 2. vi. saM. 1544, 'siddhAMta sAroddhAra lekhaka kharataragacchIya jinaharSasUri 57

Page #62
6000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 ziSya upAdhyAya kamalasaMyama / _3. vi. saM. 1544, munizrI vIkAkRta 'utsUtra nirAkaraNa batrIsI' / 4. vi. saM. 1578 'dayAdharma copAi' lekhaka - lokAgacchIya yati bhAnacaMdra ... 5. 'lokAzAha kA silokA' lekhaka-lokAgacchIya yati kezavajI RSi - 17 vI sadI - 'A sarva aTale pAMceya lekhako lokAzAha nA avarNavAda bolavA mATe nathI lakhyu paNa te vakhatanI paristhiti jaNAvavA mATe lakhyuM che / ane pahelA traNa lenakoo lokAzAha nI mAnyatA jaina dharma ane jaina siddhAMta viruddha che te batAvavA mATe sUtronI sAkho TAMkIne lakhelu che aTale zaMkAne sthAna rahetuM nathI / tethI sthAnakavAsIo matAgrahI, haThAgrahI banavA ke rahevA mAMgatA na hoya, to temaNe satya jANavU joio, satya kabula karavU joise ane khoTI mAnyatA choDavI joio / ' pR. 347 _ 'lokAzAha eje dhArmika kriyAoM vagereno bahiSkAra athavA niSedha . karelo te bAbata lokAgacchanA yatioo, mUrtipUjaka yatioo, digaMbara lekhakoo tathA tapagAcchanA virodhI kaDuAzAha vagereo, badhAo akasarakhI rIte akasaranI ja vAta karI cha / to zuM o badhAja lokAzAha nA virodhI hatA ? nahI ja, athI paNa pUravAra thAya che ke lokAzAha saMbaMdhI prAcIna lekhakoo je lakhyuM che te sAcuM ja lakhyuM che / chatA te sAhityane sAcu nahi mAnanArane durAgrahI, kadAgrahI ane haThAgrahI ja kahI zakAya ane e Agraho mithyAtvanA ja aMzo gaNI zakAya / ' pR. 350 - ___isake alAvA 6. 'taraNa tAraNa zrAvakAcAra' digaMbara tAraNa svAmI 16 vI sadI aura 7. 'bhadrabAhu caritra' digaMbara ratnanaMdI 16 vIM sadI, ye do kRtiyA~ bhI milatI hai, unameM bhI uparokta pAMca kRtiyoM meM batAyI bAteM haiN| uparokta sabhI kRtiyoM meM bhinna-bhinna ullekha milane para bhI lokAzAha kA jaina sAdhuo dvArA apamAna huA, isa viSaya meM ekamata hai| - 58 D

Page #63
-"sAMca ko AMca nahIM" 09602 . saMkSepa meM upara kI kRtiyoM se sArarupaH yaha hakIkata prApta hotI hai ki lokAzAha ne mUrti, mUrtipUjA siddhAMta se viruddha hai, isaliye usakA virodha nahIM kiyA, paraMtu yatiyoM ke sAtha evaM saMgha ke sAtha jhagaDe ke kAraNa krodhAveza meM yati aura saMgha kA virodha kiyaa| ... yati sUtra kI bAta kareM isaliye sUtra kA virodha kiyA / yati sAmAyika vagairaha dhArmika kriyA kA kahe isaliye dhArmika kriyA kA virodha kiyA / yati mUrtipUjA kA kahe isalie mUrtipUjA kA virodha kiyaa| saMgha ke sAtha jhagaDA . hone se dAna, svAmivAtsalya vagairaha kA virodha kiyA / lokAzAha -::... ... 1. sUtroM ko nahIM mAnate the| 2. sAmAyika, pratikramaNa, pauSadha, pratyAkhyAna nahIM mAnate the| ... 1. 3. dAna, maMdira, mUrti - mUrtipUjA nahIM mAnate the| ___yaha hakIkata unake samakAlIna - nikaTakAlIna sAhitya se prApta hotI hai / lokAzAha ko dhArmika kriyAoM kA virodha hone se usakA mata nahIM cala sake aisA thA, isalie unake anuyAyiyoM ne lokAzAha ke bAda badala karake dhArmika kriyAoM kA svIkAra kiyA, battIsa Agama mAnya kiye, mUrti-mUrtipUjA mAnya kI, jo loMkAgaccha meM cAlu thii| . . . . . ___sthAnakavAsI jo abhI mUrtipUjA kA virodha karate haiM, usakA prAraMbha muni dharmasiMhajI aura lavajI RSine kiyA / saM. 1685 meM zivajI guru se alaMga paDakara dharmasiMhajI ne dariyApurI saMpradAya sthApana kiyA / saM. 1692 meM bajaraMgajI guru se alaga paDakara svayaM veza pahanakara lavajI ne khaMbhAta saMpradAya kI zaruAta kI / usake bAda meM saM. 1916 meM dharmadAsajI ne dIkSA lI / ye tIsare kriyoddhAraka bane / ye dharmasiMhajI tathA lavajI meM se eka ko bhI nahIM mAnate the / dharmasiMhajI ne AThakoTI mata claayaa| lavajI ne saM. 1708 se 24 ghaMTe muhapattI kA Agraha calAyA / usako inake dusare kriyoddhArakoM ne bhI apanAyA / tInoMne mUrti-mUrtipUjA kA virodha vApisa cAlu kiyA / dharmasiMhajI aura lavajI surata meM mile the| ye donoM eka dusare se sahamata nahIM hue, itanA hI nahIM, ve eka dusare ko jinAjJAbhaMjaka aura mithyAtvI taka kahate the| 59

Page #64
-600 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 "mAsika dharma meM dharmAnuSThAna : saMvAda" kI samIkSA isa saMvAdameM sthAnakavAsI samAja kI zAstra aura lokaviruddha mAnyatA ko kutarka se siddha karane kA prayAsa lekhaka mahAzayane kiyA hai, jo nimnokta rIti se asiddha ho jAtA hai - 1. abhidhAna - rAjendra koSa bhAga 1 pR. 827 ke AdhAra para satzAstra kA adhyayana karanA svAdhyAya hai, yaha batAyA / paraMtu usa, koSa meM 'unameM sUtra ke mUla pATha kA adhyayana uccAraNa nahIM kalpatA' yaha bAta nahIM hai apane ghara kI kalpita bAta hai / asvAdhyAya kevala sUtra kA hI hai, artha kA nahIM, isakA koI Agama pATha nahIM hai / to lekhaka kI aisI Agamaviruddha bAta kaise mAnI jAegI? 2. sUtra-artha ina donoM meM arthabalavAna hai / sUtra gaNadhararacita hai to artha tIrthaMkara kathita hai / usakI anArAdhanA meM prAyAzcita bhI adhika hai / to usakI asajjhAya kyoM nahIM ? artha se yahA~ para niyukti - bhASya - cUrNi - TIkA se prApta paraMparAgata artha abhipreta hai, jo sUtra se aviruddha hai / TIkAkArAdi mahApuruSa bhI pUrva TIkAdi ke AdhAra se hI artha karate the, apanI kalpanA se nahIM, yaha TIkAdi meM aneka sthAnoM para dRSTigocara hotA hai / sthAnavAsiyoM ke svakalpita - manamAne artha sUtravirodhI hai, jinameM kAlpanikatA ke kAraNa paraspara eka vAkyatA bhI nahIM hai / ve artha nahI paraMtu anartha hai| . .... 3. vyavahArAdi sUtroM kI pATe bAMdhakara svAdhyAya vagairaha kI sabhI bAteM ApavAdika bAteM hai, jo sAdhu sAdhvI ke liye hai / usake AdhAra para sabhI jagaha gRhasthAdi sabhI ko dharmakriyAoM meM usakI chUTa denA, apavAda kA durupayoga, asthAna prayogAdi svarupa virAdhakatA hai| __ saMvAda ke bIca meM sAdhuke moka samAcArI Adi kI bAteM likhI usakA nirAkaraNa yaha hai ki - 4. jisa prakAra se gRhastha jagaha - jagaha para zauca karatA hai, vaisA sAdhu kA AcAra nahIM hai / ata: gRhastha vizeSa zuddhi ke kAraNa zaucadharmI hai / Avazyaka zauca kA to sAdhu ko bhI zAstra meM vidhAna hai hI / jahA~ para - 60 -

Page #65
GG "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (09002 AcArAMga sUtra meM moka samAcArI zabda hai, vahA~ para spaSTa zabdoM meM kAryavazAt yAni kAraNika ApavAdika lene kA sUcana hai, sArvatrika nahIM / ata: moka samAcAra sArvatrika nahIM hai, jala ke abhAva meM rAtri Adi meM use ApatkAlIna samajhanA cAhiye / nizItha sUtra kI cUrNi gAthA naM. 898 meM spaSTa rIti se kAraNika deza-uccholaNA batAyI hai| ___"jettiyamettaM tu leveNaMti asajjhAtiyamuttapurIsAdiNA jati sarIrAvayaveNa calaNAdi gAtaM levADitaM tassa tattiyamettaM dhove / " matalaba ki mUtra - purisa ke azuci se zarIra kA paira vagairaha jitanA bhAga bigaDe utanA hI pAnI se zuddha kareM / aba pAThaka khuda hI vicAreM ki lekhaka zAstraviruddha unmArga kI prarupaNA karate hai yA nahIM ? ... 5. nizItha sUtra meM rAtri meM AhAra pAnI rakhane kA prAyazcita hai, usase ApatkAla meM kvacit zarIrabAdhA meM mokasamAcAra siddha hotA hai / dina meM aura sArvatrika nhiiN| AgamazAstra meM jahA~ para yaha ApavAdika bAta batAyI hai, vahIM para rAta ko pAnI rakhane kA apavAda bhI batAyA hI hai / ataH rAta ko pAnI rakhane meM doSa aura mokasamAcArI nirdoSa kahanA zAstra kI ajJAnatA hai / donoM vastu ApavAdika hai| ___ata: vartamAnakAla meM vizeSa zuddhi, dharmaniMdA Adi ke kAraNa AvazyakatA meM rAtri meM pAnI rakhane kI, pUrvAcAryoM se ApavAdika gItArtha AcaraNA cAlu huI hai vaha bhI ucita hI hai| 6. lekhaka mahAzaya jo sAdhu - sAdhvI ko paraspara eka-dusare kA mUtra lenA vagairaha loka aura zAstra viruddha bAta likhate hai, vaha unakI ajJAnatA hai / sUtra meM to ulTA usakA spaSTa zabdoM meM niSedha aura prAyazcita batAyA hai| isalie zAstrakAra bhagavaMta pharamAte hai, aise ayogyoM ke hAtha meM zAstra jAne para vaha 'zastra' banatA hai / jinazAsana kA aura saMgha kA ghAtaka banatA hai / aisI viruddha bAteM chapavAne se spaSTa hI (lekhaka zrI ke zabdoM meM) jinadharma ko lajAkara zarmahIna banate hai aura vyartha hI loka haMsI ke pAtra banate hai| 61

Page #66
6000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" 0902 - zAstra meM analasUtra meM dIkSA ke ayogya meM rugNa - rogI hai, use dIkSA nahIM dI jAtI / paraMtu dIkSA ke bAda koI rogI bane to usakA pAlana kiyA jAtA hai / vaise hI striyoM ko mAsika dharma meM dharmAnuSThAnAdi niSiddha hone para bhI sAdhvIjI evaM pauSadha meM rahI huI strIko mAsika dharma A jAne para yatanApUrvaka anuSThAnAdi karanA vihita hai / ye niyama naye nahIM ghaDe hai, pUrvAcAryoM se calI AtI avicchinna paraMparA se siddha hai| jisase dharma ArAdhanA meM aMtarAya nahIM lagatA hai / ulTA ina niyamoM kA bhaMga bhayaMkara AzAtanA kA kAraNa banatA hai| .. Agama meM jo ApavAdika vAcanA kA vidhAna hai, vaha bhI sAdhvIjI ke lie hai, gahasthoM ke liye nahIM hai, jisase sarvajJoM ke vidhAnoM ko dUSita karane ke AkSepa yA to ajJAnatA prayukta athavA to abhiniveza prayukta hai / jo sUtraviSaya ke anadhikArI hai, unameM sUtra ko lagAnA sarvajJoM ke Agama ko dUSita karanA hai| eksIDeMTa meM khUna bahate rahane ke prasaMga meM evaM dIrghakAlIna roga Adi meM manameM namaskAra maMtrAdi kA smaraNa kara hI sakatA hai, dusare bhI use ArAdhanA karA sakate haiM / manameM namaskAra maMtra kA smaraNa kisI bhI avasthA meM niSiddha nahIM hai / jisase koI virodha nahIM hai| ___ isalie Agama aura avicchinna paraMparA se siddha vastu ko kutarkoM se asiddha karane kI ceSTA hI vAstavika mUDhatA hai / zAstra meM 'logaviruddhaccAo' yAni loka viruddha ke tyAga kI bAta AtI hai, vijJAna se bhI mAsika kA apAlana aneka doSoM kA kAraNa siddha hai / aisI pratyakSasiddha vastu kA apalApa karanA aura lokaviruddha kA AcaraNa karanA kyA jinazAsana batA sakatA hai ? kadApi nahIM ! sAmAnya phoDA phuTanA - khUna vagairaha se mAsika dharma meM bahuta hI aMtara hai / usakA pAlana nahIM karanA aneka doSoM kA kAraNa hai / jo vaijJanika pramANoM se bhI siddha hai, vaha isa prakAra - 1. DaoN. sIke ne dekhA -phUloM kA gucchA dusare dina ekadama murajhA gayA thaa| aisA kabhI hotA nahIM thA / usa Rtu meM ve phUla kaI dinoM taka tAje rahate the| usakI talAza karane para patA calA ki jisa naukarAnI ne use rakhne the vaha 62

Page #67
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM". - rajasvalA thI / usane batAyA mere pIrIyaDake dinoM meM maiM jaba-jaba tAje phUloM ko sparza karatI hUM, ve murajhA jAte haiN| DaoN. sIke ne usakI prAyogika jA~ca kI eka hI prakAra ke, eka hI samaya meM lie hue phUla usa naukarAnI aura dusarI strI ko diye / rajasvalA strI ke phUla 48 ghaMTe meM suka gaye, dusare 48 ghaMTe meM usakI paMkhuDiyAM gira gyii| jabaki dusarI strI ke phUla dusare dina bhI tAje rahe aura cauthe dina murajhAyeM / 2. amerikA meM prasiddha jona hopa kIMsa yunivarsiTI ke leboreTarI meM mArkara aura lobIna do leDI DaoNkTarone pro. sIke ke prayoga, vanaspati ke paudhopara karake siddha kiyA ki mAsika prasaMga meM strI ke zarIra meM 'mInoToksina' nAma kA jahara utpanna hotA hai / jisakA 'kemikala phormyulA' 'oksIkolesTarIna ' ke jahara se milatA hai / usa kAla meM ghara kA kArya varjya hai, yaha sacamuca satya aura sacoTa hai / - 3. vIenA yunivarsiTI ke pradhyApaka DaoN. sIkI ne meDikala rIvyu meM mAsika dharma saMbaMdhI vistRta noMdha meM batAyA ki - rajasvalA strI ke sparza kI cetana sRSTi para bahuta hI burI asara hotI hai / una dinoM meM jahara usake zvAsozvAsa meM nahIM, paraMtu pasIne meM hotA hai; jo jaharIlA pasInA raktakaNoM dvArA bAhara nikalatA hai / vaha jahara 100 DigrI se ubalate pAnI meM bhI naSTa nahIM hotA hai / garamI meM rakhane para yA pAnI meM ubalane para bhI vanaspati sRSTi para asara karane kI usakI zakti meM pharka nahIM paDatA hai / 4. prAcIna vaijJAnika plInI spaSTa zabdoM meM kahatA hai 'mAsika dharmavAlI strI kI hAjarI meM dAru kA svAda bigaDatA hai / peDa para se phala khirate hai, khile hue phala - phUla murajhAte hai / bartanoM ko jaMga lagatA hai / kA~ca vagairaha kI camaka kama hotI hai / dhAradAra hAthiyAroM kI dhAra para bhI asara hotI hai / lekina yaha saba asara dhImI gati se hone se khyAla nahIM AtA hai / 5. I.sa. 1820 meM DaoN. bIseke ne sAyanTIphika prayoga dvArA likhA hai ki strI kI camaDImeM mInoToksIna nAma kA viSa mAsika dharma meM paidA hotA 63

Page #68
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM" 000/ hai| dusare ke zarIra ke sparzamAtra se aneka rogoM ke jarmsa kA vapana karatA hai / ' 6. RtuvaMtI strI kI dRSTi se naye pApaDa-baDI kA kAlA paDanA, usakI chAyA se bhI pApaDa - vaDI meM vikRti anekoM ko anubhava siddha hai / 7. rezama aura zakkara ke kArakhAnoM meM prayoga dvArA siddha kiyA gayA hai ki nayA rezama aura zakkara RtuvaMtI strI kI hAjarI se kAlI paDate hai / 8. 'navanIta' gujarAtI DAyajasTa 1962 sapTeMbara ke aMka meM kahA hai ki - makkA meM rahA 'asavada' nAma kA patthara jo musalamAnoM meM pUjanIka hai, vaha rajasvalA strI ke sparza se kAlA paDA / Aja bhI usakI kAlimA maujUda hai / 9. IsAiyoM ke bAIbala meM bhI kahA hai ki " striyoM ko mAsika prasaMga meM sAta dina alaga baiThanA cAhiye / " 10. aphrikA - kAMgo nadI ke taTa ke loga, nyujIlaiMDa meM amuka sthaloM meM, dakSiNa amerikA oronokIno kI darI meM, sAutha AyalaiMDa, sIriyA vagairaha aneka dezoM meM alaga-alaga rIti se mAsika maryAdA kA pAlana karate haiM / custa musalamAnoM meM bhI mAsika maryAdAkA pAlana kiyA jAtA haiM / isa prakAra anubhava se, loka se, zAstra aura vijJAna se siddha mAsika maryAdA kA niSedha karanA hI vAstava meM mUDhatA hai| jina dinoM meM loka vyavahAra bhI garhita hai, doSoM ke kAraNa hai, una dinoM meM pavitra dharmAnuSThAna aura parama pavitra Agama ke arthAdi kA svAdhyAya kaise ho sakatA hai ? yaha to maMdabuddhi bhI samajha sakatA hai / AzAtanA se bacane hetu dharmAnuSThAna na kare paraMtu samaya kA sadupayoga . karate hue manameM anuprekSA karake dharmadhyAna meM lIna honA cAhiye, yaha pUrvAcAryoM ko iSTa hai / agara koI pramAda yA ajJAnatA se sAvadya kArya kareM yA Alasya kareM aura ghara meM idhara - udhara cakkara kATeM, usameM pUrvAcAryoM kA kyA doSa hai ? kisI ayogya vyakti ko dIkSA dene kI manAI karane para, usa vyakti ke saMsAra meM rahakara kiye jAnevAle pApoM kA doSa kyA guru ko lagatA hai ? nahIM / usI taraha pUrvAcAryoM dvArA banAyI maryAdAoM ke hArda ko samajhanA evaM pAlana karanA jarurI hai, anyathA saMsAra vRddhi hue binA nahIM rahatI hai / 64

Page #69
-60 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (09001 "maMdira : Agama meM prakSepa" kI samIkSA maMdira-mUrti virodha ke abhiniveza kI dhUna meM lekhakazrI bhAna hI bhUla jAte hai, aMTasaMTa likhate hai - "anya mata ke zAstroM kA bhI racanAkAla lekhana kAla ke bAda kA hI samajhanA cAhiye" / apane yahA~ AgamazAstra gurugama se maukhika paraMparA se kevala sAdhuoM ko hI milatA thA / Agametara jaina sAhitya aura ajaina sAhitya bhI devarddhigaNi ne Agama lekhana karavAyA, usake pUrva pustakArUDha thA hii| devarddhi gaNi ke pUrva me bhI vAcanAoM meM zAstralekhana huA thA, aisA bhI spaSTa ullekha hai / paramAtmA ke samavasaraNa meM 363 pAkhaMDI baiThate the, unake mata ke zAstra vagairaha nahIM the, yaha kahanA kukalpanA mAtra hai / anyamata ke zAstroM kA racanAkAla lekhanakAla ke bAda kA kahanA kitanA ucita hai ? prAmANika hastapratoM ke zuddha pAThoM se siddha kiye binA pUrvAcAryoM kI racanAoM meM bedhaDaka prakSepa kA bedhaDaka AkSepa kadAgraha prayukta hai| sAMpradAyika abhiniveza ke kAraNa tathA maMdira aura arihaMta paramAtmA kI pratimA ke prati kaTTara dveSa ke kAraNa prakSepa kI kukalpanA hotI hai / taTastha dRSTi se lekhaka vicAra kareM to samAdhAna svata ho jAte hai / jainAgamoM meM paraspara amuka sthAnoM meM virodha ho, vahAM para jaise samAdhAna kiyA jAtA hai, usI dRSTi se socane para prakSepa mahasUsa nahIM hogA, virodha bhI mahasUsa nahIM hogaa| __1. rAvaNa tIrthaMkara baneMge, 15 bhavoM ke bAda baneMge (triSaSThizalAkApuruSa caritra parva sarga 10 zloka naM. 232 se 244) isalie jo tIrthaMkara nAmakarma bA~dhA thA, vaha samyaktva kI hAjarI meM anikAcita bAMdhA thA aura anikAcita tIrthaMkara nAmakarmavAle 4 thI naraka meM jAne meM koI virodha nahIM hai| vahAM jAne para usakI udalanA bhI zakya hai nikAcita tIrthaMkara nAmakarma vAle 4 thI naraka meM nahIM jA sakate hai / jisase rAvaNa kI bAtameM virodha kA gaMdha leza bhI nahIM hai| 2. eka tIrtha para pA~va dhare to mokSa, eka maMdira banAveM to mokSa vagairaha uTapaTAMga AkSepa diye hai / aisA koI mAnatA hI nahIM hai / 'svalabdhi se aSTApada giri para jo jAtA hai vaha usI bhava me mokSa meM jAtA hai' yaha paramAtmA mahAvIra ne pharamAyA aura gautama svAmI vahA~ para gaye vagairaha kI puSTi uttarAdhyayana / 65

Page #70
.-60@n "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 sUtrake 10veM adhyayanakI niyukti se hotI hai / bhagavatI sUtra 14 zataka 7 uddezA 'cirasaMsiTThoDasi goyamA cira saMthuoDasi goyamA' sUtra kA saMbaMdha bhI ukta niyukti se hI baiThatA hai / ata: aisI bAtoM ko kalpita mAnanA AgamoM kI AzAtanA hai| __3. bhagavAna mahAvIra ke 14000 sAdhu kI saMkhyA svahastadIkSita - svaziSya kI samajhanA aisA khulAsA aneka jagaha para AtA hai / jisase gautamasvAmI ke ziSyoM se virodha nahIM hai / bhagavAna ke kevalI kI 700 kI saMkhyA svahastadIkSita, svaziSya sAdhuoM kI apekSA se lenaa| 4. kalpasUtra ke bAre meM binA pramANa ke uTapaTAMga bakavAso kI viddhasabhA meM koI kiMmata nahIM hai / ati prAcIna mathurA ke kaMkAlI TIle ke lekhoM se kalpasUtra kI sthavirAvalI pramANita hone se kalpasUtra pramANita siddha hotA hI hai / samavAyAMga mUlasUtra ke 'kappassa. samosaraNaM NeyaM' pATha se kalpasUtra kI prAcInatA siddha hotI hai / dazAzrutaskaMdha niyukti meM bhI kalpasUtra ke varNana vibhAga kA 'purima carimANa kappo maMgalaM vaddhamANa tithyammi ___ia parikahiyA jiNagaNaharAI therAvalI caritaM' ..ke dvArA atideza kiyA hai| ..dazAzrutaskaMdha kI 8 vI (udaMzA) kI cUrNi meM kalpasUtra ke pAThoM ke artha bhI kiye hue hai, jisase cUrNikAra kalpasUtra ko dazAzrutaskaMdha kA vibhAga hI mAnate the, yaha spaSTa hai / ata: malayagirI Adi AcAryoM taka nAmonizAna bhI nahIM thA,yaha kahanA lekhaka kI ajJatA ko sUcita karatA hai| . niyukti - bhASyAdi ko svataMtra graMtha kahanA ajJAnatA hai / niyukti Adi sUtra - Agama ke upara hone se usase abhinna mAne jAte hai / bhagavatI Adi sUtroM meM bhI sanijjuttie. vagairaha se usI kA dyotana hotA hai / ata: AgamoM ke nirdeza se unakA bhI nirdeza ho hI jAtA hai, zruta saMkhyA meM alaga se kyo sonAveM ? ... agara naMdI sUtra meM jisa' zAstra kA ullekha nahIM haiM, vaha pUrvadhararacita nahI ho sakatA hai" aisA mAnoMge to 10 pUrvadharaumAsvAti racita tattvArtha sUtra bhI Apake lie apramANa bana jAyegA kyoMki usakA bhI ullekha naMdI sUtra meM nahIM hai| = 664

Page #71
" sAMca ko AMca nahIM" 07700: viddhaddharya zrI puNyavijayajI ma.sA. ko atiprAcIna agastyasiMhasUrijI kI cUrNi milane para unhoneM apanI mAnyatA badalakara niyuktioM ko atiprAcIna svIkAra kiyA hai, jo bAta unhoMne bRhatkalpa ke Amukha meM spaSTa kI hai / ata: unakI purAnI bAta ko doharAnA kadAgraha hai / '72 zAstroM meM se kisI meM bhI zrAvaka athavA sAdhu ke dvArA mUrtipUjA yA maMdira nirmANa kA ullekha nahIM hai / ' isa prakAra ke aura bhI anekabAra kie gaye lekhaka ke ullekha sampradAya abhiniveza hI hai / prAcInakAla meM pratimAzataka (mahAmahopAdhyAya zrI yazovijayajI ma. sA.) Adi aneka graMtho meM, evaM vartamAna meM bhI 32 AgamoM meM mUrtipUjA, mUrtipUjA kA prAcIna itihAsa, pratimApUjana, jainAgama siddha mUrtipUjA Adi aneka graMthoM meM sapramANa sacoTa AgamoM ke mUrti aura mUrtipUjA ke pAThoM kI siddhi hone para bhI abhiniveza se unake viruddha artha karane unako prakSipta kahanA aura vApisa 'AgamoM meM mUrtipUjA nahIM hai' aisI bakavAsa karanA, mahAabhiniveza ke sivAya zakya nahIM hai / * lekhaka zrI ke 'hAthI ke dA~ta khAne ke anya, dikhAne ke anya', 'duharI cAla calanA vagairaha diye hue AkSepa ajJAnatApUrNa hai / hama AgamazAstra aura Agametera zAstra donoM ko pramANa mAnate haiM / prAmANya meM pharaka jarura paDegA / jaise Apa aMga aura upAMga donoM 32 sUtroM meM hone parabhI prAmANya meM pharaka mAnate hai / jaise kevalajJAnI avadhijJAnI donoM pramANa hone para bhI prAmANya meM taratamatA hai / usI prakAra pUrvAcAryoM ke graMtha bhI koI AgamamUlaka, koI pUrva meM se uddhRta, koI avicchinna paraMparAmUlaka hone se pramANa hI mAne jAte hai, paraMtu Agama aura Agametara pUrvAcAryo ke graMtha kI prAmANyatA meM taratamatA rahegI / ataH 45 Agama meM unako ginane kA prazna rahatA hI nahIM hai / sthAnakavAsI 32 sUtroM ke sivAya sabhI pUrvAcAryoM ke graMtha bhI apramANa ginate hai aura hajAroM bAteM pUrvAcAryoM ke graMthoM kI lete hai, Acarate hai, mAnate haiM, phirabhI ve pramANa nahIM, pramANa nahIM kA sTaNa karate hai / aba vicAra kIjiye 'hAthI ke dA~ta khAne ke anya, dikhAne ke anya ' 'duharI cAla calanA' vagairaha bAteM hamako lAgu hotI hai yA Apako ? 67

Page #72
60 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 - "NamotthUNaM pATha ke prakSepa" kI samIkSA isa prakaraNa meM, lekhakazrI 'jaina sAhitya mAM vikAra thavAthI thayelI hAni' nAmaka pustaka ke lekhaka ko mUrtipUjaka samAja ke pratiSThita viddhAna kahate hai, vaha unakI anabhijJatA hai, kyoMki ukta lekhaka to mUrtipUjaka samAja se bahiSkRta kiye hue the, unhoMne aneka zAstraviruddha bAteM likhI hai / paM. kalyANavijayajI jaise vidvAnoM ne jisakI samAlocanA bhI kI hai / aisI vyaktiyoM ko Age karake 'mUrtipUjA Agamika nahIM' 'NamotthuNaM prakSipta hai' vagairaha bAte karanA, kamajora nIMva para 100 mAla kI imArata khaDI karane kI ceSTA hai| __draupadI pratimApUjana saMbaMdhI varNana meM TIkAkAra NamotthuNaM pATha ko mahattva nahIM dete, unake sAmane donoM prakAra kI pratiyA~ upalabdha thI, vagairaha pITIpITAyI bAtoM ko lekhaka doharAte hai / jJAtAsUtra meM saMkSipta aura bRhad donoM vAcanAoM meM NamotthuNaM kA pATha hai hii| TIkAkAra ke sAmane NamotthuNaM pATha vAlI hI pratiyAM thii|' ina saba bAtoM kI aneka pramANoM se 'jainAgama siddha mUrtipUjA' pustaka meM pR. 124 se pR. 136 meM siddhi kI hai| usameM 8-10 atiprAcIna jaisalamera-khaMbhAta Adi ke hastapratiyoM ke AdhAra se NamotthuNaM pATha kI siddhi kI hai / vartamAna meM upalabdha sabhI pratiyoM meM namutthuNaM pATha hai / eka bhI prati namutthuNaM pATha binA kI nahIM mila rahI hai, to prakSepa kI kukalpanA kitanI ucita haiM ? TIkAkAra pUrvAcArya khUba hI bhavabhIru the| unake sAmane unase bhI prAcIna TIkAe~ hogI, aisA amuka TIkAoM ke ullekha se jJAta hotA hai / 'pUrvaTIkAkRtastu Ahu !' vagairaha ullekha Ate hai / ata: sUtroM meM jaisA pATha hai, usI kI TIkA paraMparA se TIkAkAra karate Aye hai / isa guMjAra ke lekhaka ne 'jainAgama siddha mUrtipUjA' pustaka taTasthApUrvaka par3hI hotI to, aneka kukalpanAoM kI bakavAsa nahIM karate / inakI guMjAra meM AtI aneka bAtoM ke niSpakSatA se satya samAdhAna usameM diye gaye haiN| 68

Page #73
-60000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (209602 vAstavikatA to yaha hai ki jahA~-jahA~ para mUrti yA mUrtipUjA kI bAta AgamoM meM AtI hai, vahA~-vahA~ para yA to uTapaTAMga artha karake yA to prakSepaprakSepa ke mithyA Aropa se usako ur3Ane kI inakI mAnasikatA se spaSTa samajhA jAtA hai ki lekhaka ko satyatA kA Agraha nahIM hai, paraMtu pakSarAga kA abhiniveza bharA par3A hai / zAMti se koI sujJa vyakti vicAra kareM to yaha saralatA se samajha jAegA kI zAstroM evaM anya TIkA - prakaraNAdi meM jagahajagaha para mUrti-mUrtipUjA ko ghusADane kA prayojana usa kAla meM thA hI nahIM kyoMki mUrti virodhI pakSa hI nahIM thA / sabhI vidvAn ekamata se svIkArate hai ki karIba 500 varSa se hI lokAzAha se yaha virodha cAlu huA hai / ataH lekhaka evaM unake pakSadhara pUrvAcAryoM para nahIM paraMtu gaNadharacita satya AgamoM para hI prakSiptatA kA jhUThA kalaMka de rahe haiN| - aneka itihAsakAra spaSTa mAnate haiM ki caityavAsiyoM meM zithilatA hone para bhI jainAgamoM meM eka akSara bhI parivartita karane se ve bhayabhIta the / prakSepa parivartana to niSThura banakara lekhaka ke pakSadhara hI kara rahe hai / corI ko chipAne ke liye dusaroM para galata AkSepa de rahe haiM / "cora koTavAla ko DaMDe" nIti apanA rahe hai / pramANa ke lie dekhiye / itihAsa vettA paM. zrI kalyANa vi.ma. ke zabda - jaina AgamoM meM kAMTachAMTa : lauMkAmata kA prAdurbhAva vikrama saM. 1508 meM huA thA aura isa mata meM se 18vIM zatI ke prArambha meM arthAt 1709 meM mukha para muhapatti bAMdhane vAlA sthAnakavAsI sampradAya nikalA, ityAdi bAtoM kA vistRta varNana laukAgaccha kI paTTAvalI meM diyA jA cukA hai / zAha lauMkA ne tathA unake anuyAyI RSiyoM ne mUrtipUjA kA virodha avazya kiyA thA, parantu jaina AgamoM meM kATachAMTa karane kA sAhasa kisIne nahIM kiyA thaa| sarvaprathama saM. 1865 meM sthAnakavAsI sAdhu zrI jeThamalajI ne "samakitasAra" nAmaka grantha likhakara mUrtipUjA ke samarthana meM jo AgamoM ke = 69

Page #74
" sAMca ko AMca nahIM" pATha diye the unakI samAlocanA karake artha- parivartana dvArA apanI mAnyatA kA bacAva karane kI ceSTA kI, parantu mUla - sUtroM meM parivartana athavA kAMTa-chAMTa karane kA kAtara prayAsa kisI ne nahIM kiyA / usake bAda sthAnakavAsI sAdhu zrI amolakaRSijI ne 32 sUtroM ko bhASAntara ke sAtha chapavAkara prakAzita karavAyA / usa samaya bhI RSijI ne kahIM-kahIM zabda parivartana ke sivAya pAThoM para kaTAra nahIM calAI thI / vikrama kI 21 vI zatI ke prathama caraNa meM unhI 32 sUtroM ko "suttAgame " isa zIrSaka se do bhAgoM meM prakAzita karavAne vAle zrI puSpakabhikkhU (zrI phUlacandajI) ne ukta pAThoM ko jo unakI dRSTi meM prakSipta the nikAlakara 32 AgamoM kA saMzodhana kiyA hai / unhoMne jina-jina sUtroM meM se jo-jo pATha nikAle haiM unakI saMkSipta tAlikA nIce dI jAtI hai - (1) zrI bhagavatI sUtra meM zataka 20 / 309 / sU. 683 - 684 bhagavatIsUtra zataka 3 / 302 meM se / - bhagavatIsUtra ke andara jaMghAcAraNa vidyAcAraNoM ke sambandha meM nandIzvara mAnuSottara parvata tathA meru parvata para jAkara caityavandana karane ke pATha mUla meM se ur3A die gae haiM / (2) jJAtAdharma - kathAMga meM draupadI ke dvArA kI gaI jinapUjA sambandhI sArA kA sArA pATha haTA diyA hai / (3) sthAnAMga sUtra meM Ane vAle nandIzvara ke caityoM kA adhikAra haTAyA gayA hai / (4) upAsaka dazAMga sUtra ke Ananda zrAvakAdhyayana meM se samyaktvoccAraNa kA AlApaka nikAla diyA hai / (5) vipAkazruta meM se mRgArAnI ke putra ko dekhane jAne ke pahale mRgAdevI ne gautama svAmI ko muMhapatti se muMha bAMdhane kI sUcanA karane vAlA pATha ur3A diyA hai / (6) aupaNAtika sUtra kA mUla pATha jisameM ambaDaparivrAjaka ke samyaktva 70

Page #75
-6000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" 09602 uccarane kA adhikAra thA, vaha haTA diyA gayA hai, kyoMki usameM "arihantacaitya" aura "anya tIrthika parigRhIta arihanta caityoM" kA prasaMga AtA thaa| (7) rAjapraznIya sUtroM meM sUryAbhadeva ke vimAna meM rahe hue siddhAyatana meM jinapratimAoM kA varNana aura sUryAbhadeva dvArA kiye hue una pratimAoM ke pUjana kA varNana sampUrNa haTA diyA hai| (8) jIvAbhigama sUtra meM kiye gae vijayadeva kI rAjadhAnI ke siddhAyatana tathA jinapratimAoM kA, nandIzvara dvIpa ke jinacaityoM kA rucaka tathA kuNDala dIpa ke jinacaityoM kA, varNana nikAla diyA gayA hai / zrI jIvAbhigama kI tIsarI pratipatti ke dvitIya uddeza meM viruddha jAne vAlA jo pATha thA usako haTA diyA hai| ... (9) isa prakAra jambUddhIpa prajJapti Adi sUtroM meM Ane vAle siddhAyatana kUToM meM se "Ayatana" zabda kI haTAkara "siddhakUTa" aisA nAma rakkhA hai| . (10) vyavahAra-sUtra ke prathama uddezaka ke 37 ve sUtra ke dvitIya bhAga meM Ane vAle "bhAvi jinaceia" zabda ko haTA diyA hai| uparyukta sabhI pATha sthAnakavAsI sAdhu dharmasiMhajI se lagAkara bIsavIM sadI ke sthAnakavAsI sAdhu zrI amolaka RSijI ne 32 sUtroM ko bhASAntara ke sAtha chapavAkara prakAzita karavAyA taba taka sUtroM meM vidyamAna the| gatavarSa saM. 2019 ke zItakAla meM jaba hamane zrI puSpakabhikkhU sampAdita "suttAgame" nAmaka jainasUtroM ke donoM aMza par3he to jJAta huA ki sUtroM ke isa navIna prakAzana meM zrI phUlacandajI (puSpaka bhikkhU) ne bahuta hI golamAla kiyA hai / sUtroM ke pATha ke pATha nikAlakara mUrtivirodhiyoM ke lie mArga niSkaNTaka banAyA hai| maiMne prastuta sUtroM ke sampAdana meM kI gaI kATachAMTa ke viSaya meM sthAnakavAsI zrI jainasaMgha sahamata hai yA nahIM, yaha jAnane ke lie eka choTA sA lekha taiyAra kara "janavANI" kAryAlaya jayapura (rAjasthAna) tathA cAMdanI cauka dehalI naM. 6 "jainaprakAza" kAryAlaya ko eka-eka nakala prakAzanArtha bhejI, parantu ukta lekha sthAnakavAsI eka bhI patrakAra ne nahIM (71

Page #76
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM" 00: chApA, taba isakI nakala bhAvanagara ke "jaina" patra ke oNphisa ko bhejI aura vaha lekha jaina ke "bhagavAn mahAvIra janma kalyANaka vizeSAGka" meM chapakara prakaTa huA, hamArA vaha saMkSipta lekha nimnalikhita thA / zrI sthAnakavAsI jainasaMgha se prazna : pichale lagabhaga arddhazatAbdI jitane jIvana meM aneka viSayoM para gujarAtI tathA hindI bhASA meM maine aneka lekha tathA nibandha likhe haiM, parantu zrI sthAnakavAsI jainasaMgha ko sambodhana karake likhane kA yaha pahalA hI prasaMga hai, isakA kAraNa hai "zrI pupphabhikkhU" dvArA saMzodhita aura sampAdita "suttAgame " nAmaka pustaka kA adhyayana / pichale kucha varSoM se prAcIna jaina sAhitya kA svAdhyAya karanA mere lie niyama sA ho gayA hai, isa niyama ke phalasvarUpa maiMne "suttAgame" ke donoM aMza paDhe, paDhane se mere jIvana meM kabhI na hone vAlA duHkha kA anubhava huA / merA jhukAva itihAsa saMzodhana kI tarapha hone se "zrI laukAgaccha " tathA "zrI bAIsa sampradAya" ke itihAsa kA bhI maiMne paryApta avalokana kiyA hai / laukAzAha ke mata - pracAra ke bAda meM likhI gaI aneka hastalikhita pustakoM se isa sampradAya kI paryApta jAnakArI bhI prApta kI, phira bhI isa viSaya meM kalama calAne kA vicAra kabhI nahIM kiyA, kyoMki saMpradAyoM ke ApasI saMgharSa kA jo pariNAma nikalatA hai use meM acchI taraha jAnatA thA / laukAzAha ke maulika mantavya kyA the, usako unake anuyAyiyoM ke dvArA 16 vI zatAbdI ke anta meM likhita eka carcA-grantha ko par3ha kara maiM isa viSaya meM acchI taraha vAkipha ho gayA thA / usa hastalikhita grantha ke bAda meM banI huI aneka isa gaccha kI paTTAvilayoM tathA anya sAhitya kA bhI mere pAsa acchA saMgraha hai| sthAnakavAsI sAdhu zrI jeThamalajI dvArA saMdRbdha "samakitasAra" aura isake uttara meM zrI vijayAnandasUri - likhita "samyaktva zalyoddhAra" tathA zrI amolakaRSijI dvArA prakAzita 32 sUtroM meM se bhI katipaya sUtra par3he the / yaha 72

Page #77
-G006 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (09002 saba hone para bhI sthAnakavAsI sampradAya ke viruddha likhane kI merI bhAvanA nahIM huii| yadyapi kaI sthAnakavAsI vidvAnoM ne apane mata ke bAdhaka hone vAle sUtrapAThoM ke kucha zabdoM ke artha jarUra badale the, parantu sUtroM meM se bAdhaka pAThoM ko kisI ne haTAyA nahIM thA / laukAgaccha kI utpatti se lagabhaga pone pAMca so varSoM ke bAda zrI puSphabhikkhU tathA inake ziSya-praziSyoM ne una bAdhaka pAThoM para sarvaprathama kaiMcI calAI hai, yaha jAnakara mana meM apAra glAni huI / maiM jAnatA thA ki sthAnakavAsI sampradAya ke sAtha merA sadbhAva hai, vaisA hI banA rahegA, parantu pupphabhikkhU ke ukta kArya se mere dila para jo AghAta pahu~cA hai, vaha sadA ke lie amiTa rhegaa| ____ bhagavatIsUtra jJAtAdharmakathAMga, upAsakadazAMga, vipAkasUtra, aupapAtika, rAjapraznIya, jIvAbhigama, jambUddhIpa-prajJapti, vyavahArasUtra Adi meM jahAM-jahAM jinapratimA-pUjana jinacaityavandana, siddhAyatana, muhapatti bAMdhane ke viruddha jo jo sUtrapATha the, unakA saphAyA karake zrI bhikkhUjI ne sthAnakavAsI sampradAya ko nirApada banAne ke lie eka aprAmANika aura kApuruSocita kArya kiyA hai, isameM koI zaMkA nahIM, parantu isa kArya ke sambandha meM maiM yaha jAnanA cAhatA hU~ ki "suttAgame" chapavAne meM sahAyatA dene vAle gRhastha aura suttAgame para acchI-acchI sammatiyAM pradAna karane vAle vidvAn munivarya mere isa prazna kA uttara dene kA kaSTa kareMge ki isa kArya meM ve svayaM sahamata haiM yA nahIM ? uparyukta merA lekha chapane ke bAda "akhila bhArata sthAnakavAsI jaina kaoNnphrensa" ke mAnanIya mantrI aura isa saMsthA ke gujarAtI sAptAhika mukhapatra "jaina-prakAza" ke sampAdaka zrIyut khImacandabhAI maganalAla boharA dvArA "jaina" patra ke sampAdaka para tArIkha 1-5-62 ko likhe gaye patra meM likhA thA ki - "suttAgameM" pustaka zrI pupphabhikkhU mahArAja kA khAnagI prakAzana hai, jisake sAtha "zrI varddhamAna sthAnakavAsI jaina zramaNasaMgha" athavA "akhila bhAratIya sthAnakavAsI jaina kaoNnphrensa" kA koI sambandha nahIM hai, so jAniegA / "isa pustaka ke prakAzana ke sambandha meM zramaNasaMgha ke adhikArI munirAjoM 73

Page #78
602 sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (09604 ne tathA kaoNnphrensa ne zrI puSphabhikkhU mahArAja ke sAtha patra vyavahAra bhI kiyA hai, isake atirikta yaha praznazramaNasaMgha ke vicAraNIya praznoM para rakhA gayA hai aura zramaNasaMgha ke adhikArI munirAja thor3e samaya meM mileMge taba isa pustaka prakAzana ke viSaya meM Avazyaka nirNaya karane kA socA hai|" kucha samaya ke bAda patra meM likhne mujaba tA. 07-06-62 ke "jaina prakAza" meM sthAnakavAsI zramaNasaMgha kI kAryavAhaka samiti ne "suttAgama" pustaka ko apramANita ThaharAne vAlA nIce likhA prastAva sarvAnumati se pAsa kiyA... ..... ..... ___"mantrI zrI phUlacandajI mahArAja ne "suttAgame" nAmaka pustaka ke prakAzana meM AgamoM meM katipaya mUla pATha nikAla die hai, vaha yogya nahIM hai| zAstra ke mUla pAThoM meM kamI karane kA kisI ko adhikAra nahIM hai, isalie "suttAgame" nAmaka sUtra ke prastuta prakAzana ko yaha kAryavAhaka samiti apramANita udghoSita karatI hai|" uparyukta sthAnakavAsI zramaNasaMgha kI samiti kA prastAva prasiddha hone ke bAda isa viSaya meM adhika likhanA ThIka nahIM samajhA aura carcA vahIM sthagita ho gii| paTTAvalI ke vivaraNa meM zrI puSphabhikkhU ke "suttAgame" nAmaka sUtroM ke prakAzana ke sambandha meM pupphabhikkhUjI dvArA kiye gaye pATha parivartana ke sambandha meM kucha likhanA Avazyaka samajha kara ara nikAle hue sUtrapAThoM kI tAlikA dI hai / puSphabhikkhUjI kA puruSArtha itanA karake hI pUrA nahIM huA hai, unhoMne sUtroM meM se caitya zabda ko to isa prakAra lupta kara diyA hai ki sArA prakAzana par3ha lene para bhI zAyada hI ekAdha jagaha caitya zabda dRSTigocara ho jaaye| .... . . . .. - bhikkhUjI kI caitya zabda para itanI akRpA kaise huI yaha samajha meM nahIM AtA, mandira athavA mUrtivAcaka "caitya" zabda ko hI kATa diyA hotA to bAta aura thI / para Apane cuna-cuna kara "guNazilakacaitya", "pUrNabhadracaitya", - 74

Page #79
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM" +3 aura cobIsa tIrthaGkaroM ke " caityavRkSa" Adi jo koI bhI caityAnta zabda sUtroM meM AyA, usako nestanAbUda kara diyA / inake purogAmI RSi jeThamalajI Adi "caitya" zabda ko " vyantara kA mandira" mAnakara isako nibhAte the, unake bAda ke bhI bIsavI zatI taka ke sthAnakavAsI lekhaka " caityazabda" kA kahI 'jJAna', kahIM 'sAdhu', kahIM 'vyantara deva kA mandira' mAnakara sUtroM meM ina zabdoM ko nibhA rahe the, parantu "zrI puppha bhikkhUjI" ko mAlUma huA ki ina zabdoM ke artha badalakara caityAdi zabda rahane denA yaha eka prakAra kI lIpApotI hai / "caityazabda" jaba taka sUtroM meM banA rahegA taba taka mUrtipUjA ke virodha meM lar3anA jhagaDanA bekAra hai, yaha socakara hI Apane "caitya" "Ayatana " "jinaghara", " caityavRkSa" Adi zabdoM ko nikAlakara apanA mArga niSkaMTaka banAyA hai / ThIka hai, inakI samajha se to yaha eka puruSArtha kiyA hai, parantu isa karatUta se inake sUtroM meM jo navInatA praviSTa huI hai, usakA pariNAma bhaviSya meM jJAta hogA / pupphabhikkhUjI ne pUjA-viSayaka sUtra- pAThoM, mandiroM aura mUrtiviSayaka zabdoM ko nikAlakara yaha siddha kiyA hai, ki inake pUrvavartI zAha laukA, dharmasiMha, RSi jeThamalajI aura zrI amolaka RSijI Adi zabdoM kA artha badalakara mUrtipUjA kA khaNDana karate the, vaha galata thA / ( paTTAvalI parAga pR. 447 se. pR. 455 ) isa satya ghaTanAko paDhakara pAThaka samajha sakate hai, "aise prakSepayukta AgamoM ke prati aMdhazraddhA buddhi na rakhakara, viveka baddhi rakhanA hI upayukta hai" ye vacana lekhakazrI ke ghara ke AgamoM ke lie hI lAgu paDeMge / tathA " prakSepayukta Agama" lekhaka ke ina zabdoM se Agama evaM pUrvAcAryoM ke prati unakI bhAvanA spaSTa pragaTa hotI hai / Agamo ke pAThoM kI prAmANikatA ko devendramunizAstrI ne bhI svIkArI hai / dekhe unhIM ke zabda - 75

Page #80
500 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (O9001 ... "aMga sAhitya meM bhagavAna mahAvIra kI vANI apane bahuta kucha aMzoM meM jyoM kI tyoM aba bhI prApta hotI hai / isa vANI ke toDA-maroDA nahIM gayA hai / yaha jaina paramparA kI vizeSatA rahI ki aMgoM ko lipibaddha karane vAle zramaNoM ne mUla zabdoM meM kucha bhI herA -pherI nahIM kI, jaisA ki anya paramparAoM meM huA hai / aMga evaM Agama sAhitya para TIkAoM, cUrNiyoM Adi kI racanA huI kintu Agama kA mUla rUpa jyoM kA tyoM rahA / sAtha hI devardhigaNI kSamAzramaNa kI yaha udAratA rahI ki jahA~ unheM pAThAntara mile vahA~ donoM vicAroM ko hI taTasthatApUrvaka lipibaddha kiyA / " (jaina Agama sAhitya manana aura mImAMsA pR. 44) "madhyakAla ke ghoTAle" kI samIkSA isameM paM. zrI kalyANavijayajI ke prabaMdha pArijAta ke AdhAra para pATha diyA hai evaM Age bhI isakI vizeSa jAnakArI hetu prabaMdha pArijAta ke adhyayana kI bhalAmaNa kI hai| paraMtu sAre prabaMdha parijAta meM na to inakA diyA pATha hai na inhoMne likhI aisI koI bAta hai / ajJa pAThakoM ko gumarAha karane ke lie aisI managhaDaMta bAteM likhate hai / satyAnveSI pAThaka to jA~cakara hI vastu ko svIkAreMge / bAkI ajJa pAThaka to avazya gumarAha ho jAte hai, jisakA pApa lekhaka ke sira para rhegaa| lekhaka kI cAlabAjI dekhiye - paM. zrI kalyANavijayajI kA mithyA sahArA lekara apanI khicaDI pakAyI hai, managhaDaMta bAteM likhI hai / pAThaka madhyakAlAdi ke viSaya meM paM. zrI kalyANavijayajI kI mAnyatA ko jAnane ke liye unakA hI pATha dekheM aura lekhaka kI prAmANikatA kA nirNaya kreN| "vikrama kI cauthI zatI se gyArahavI zatI taka zithilAcArI sAdhuoM kA prAbalya ho cukA thA / phira bhI vaha unakA yuga nahIM thA / hama use unakI bahulatA vAlA yuga kaha sakate haiM, kyoMki usa samaya bhI udyatavihArI sAdhuoM 76. -

Page #81
-600 sAMca ko AMca nahIM" 900, kI bhI saMkhyA paryApta pramANa meM thI / zithilAcArI saMkhyA meM adhika hote hue bhI udyatavihArI saMgha meM agragAmI the / snAtramahotsava, prathamasamavasaraNa Adi prasaMgo para hone vAle zramaNa-sammelanoM meM pramukhatA udyatavihAriyoM kI rahatI thI / kaI prasaMgo para udyatavihArI zramaNoM dvArA pArzvasthAdi zithilAcArI phaTakAre bhI jAte the, adhikAMza zithilatAe tathApi unameM kA nimnasataha taka pahuMca gayA thA aura dhIre-dhIre unakI saMkhyA kama hotI jAtI thii| vikrama kI gyArahavIM zatI ke uttarArdha taka zithilAcArI dhIre-dhIre niyatavAsI ho cuke the aura samAja ke upara se unakA prabhAva paryApta rUpa se haTa cukA thA / bhale hI ve jAtigata guruoM ke rUpa meM amuka jAtiyoM aura kuloM se apanA sambandha banAe hue hoM, parantu saMgha para se unakA prabhAva paryApta mAtrA meM miTa cukA thA, isI ke pariNAma svarUpa 12 vI zatI ke madhyabhAga taka jainasaMgha meM aneka naye gaccha utpanna hone lage the / paurNamika, AMcalika, kharatara, sAdhupIrNamika aura Agamika gaccha ye sabhI 12vIM aura 13 vIM zatI meM utpanna hue the aura isakA kAraNa zithilAcArI caityavAsI kahalAne vAle sAdhuoM kI kamajorI thI / yadyapi usa samaya meM bhI varddhamAnasUri, jinezvarasUri, jinavallabhagaNi, municandrasUri, dhanezvarasUri, jagacandrasUri Adi aneka udyatavihArI AcArya aura unake ziSya parivAra apratibaddha vihAra se vicarate the, tathApi eka ke bAda eka naye sudhAraka gacchoM kI sRSTi se jainasaMgha meM jo pUrvakAlIna saMghaTana calA A rahA thA vaha vizRMkhala ho gayA / - isI ke pariNAma-svarUpa zAha laukA, zAha kaDuA Adi gRhasthoM ko apane pantha sthApita karane kA avasara milA thA, na ki unake khuda ke puruSArtha se / uparyukta jainasaMgha kI paristhiti kA varNana par3hakara vicAraka samajha sakeMge ki zramaNasamudAya meM se adhikAMza zithilAcAra ke kAraNa nirbala ho jAne se sudhArakoM ko naye gaccha aura gRhasthoM ko zramaNagaNa ke viruddha apanI mAnyatAoM ko vyApaka banAne kA suavasara milA thA, kisI bhI saMsthA yA samAja ko banAne meM kaThina se kaThina puruSArtha aura parizrama kI AvazyakatA par3atI hai, na - 77

Page #82
600 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" 09/02 ki naSTa karane meM / samAja kI kamajorI kA lAbha uThAkara kriyoddhAra ke nAma se nava gacchasarjakoM ne to apane bAr3e majabUta kiye hI, para isa avyavasthita sthiti ko dekhakara katipaya zramaNasaMsthA ke virodhI gRhasthoM ne bhI apaneapane akhAr3e khar3e kiye aura Apasa ke virodhoM aura zithilAcAroM se balahIna banI huI zramaNasaMsthA kA dhvaMsa karane kA kArya zuru kiyaa| ___ lauMkA tathA usake anuyAyI mandira tathA mUrtiyoM kI pUjA kI atipravRttiyoM kA udAharaNa de dekara gRhasthavarga ko sAdhuoM se viruddha banA rahe the / kaDuvA jaise gRhastha mUrtipUjA ke pakSapAtI hote hue bhI sAdhuoM ke zithilAcara kI bAtoM ko mahattva de dekara unase asahakAra karane lage, cIja banAne meM jo zakti vyaya karanI par3atI hai vaha bigAr3ane meM nahIM / lauMkAzAha tathA unake vezadhArI cele hiMsA ke virodha meM aura dayA ke pakSa meM banAI gaI copAIyoM ke pulinde khola kholakara logoM ko sunAte aura kahate "dekho . bhagavAn ne dayA meM dharma batAyA hai, taba AjakAla ke yati svayaM to apanA AcAra pAlate nahIM aura dUsaroM ko mandira mUrtipUjA Adi kA upadeza karake pRthvI, pAnI, vanaspati Adi ke jIvoM kI hiMsA karavAte haiM, bolo dharma dayA, meM ki hiMsA meM ? uttara milatA dayA meM," taba lauMkA ke cele kahate "jaba dharma dayA meM hai to hiMsA ko chor3oM aura dayA pAlo" anapar3ha loga, lauMkA ke anapar3ha anuyAyiyoM kI isa prakAra kI bAtoM se bhramita hokara pUjA, darzana Adi jo zramasAdhya kArya the, unheM chor3a chor3akara lauMkA ke anuyAyI bana gye| - isameM lauMkA aura inake anuyAyiyoM kI bahAdurI nahIM, vidhvaMsaka paddhati kA hI yaha prabhAva hai, manuSya ko uThAkara uMce le jAnA puruSArtha kA kAma hai, para khar3e puruSa ko dhakkA dekara nIce girAnA puruSArtha nahIM kAyaratA hai, jainoM meM se hI pUjA AdikI zraddhA haTAkara zAha laukA, lavajI, rUpajI, dharmasiMha Adi ne apanA bADA baDhAyA, yaha vastu prazaMsanIya nahIM kahI jA sakatI, inakI prazaMsA to hama taba karate jaba ki ye apane tyAga aura puruSArtha se AkRSTa karake jainetaroM ko jainadharma kI tarapha khIcate aura zithilAcAra meM 78

Page #83
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM " DUbane vAle, tatkAlIna yatiyoM ko apane Adarza aura preraNA se zithilAcAra se UMcA uThAne ko bAdhya karate / " ( paTTAvalI parAga pR. 467 se pR. 469) 66 " dravyapUjA - bhAvapUjA" kI samIkSA isa prakaraNa meM lekhaka kI cauryavRttikI hada huI hai / unhoMne pAThoM ko toDa-maroDa kara aisA upasAyA hai, mAno niryuktikAra ne sabake lie dravyapUjA ko gauNa kiyA hai / paraMtu lekhaka ne dI huI 193 naM. kI niyukti gAthA meM spaSTa hai ki saMpUrNa saMyama pradhAna mahAvratadhArI muni ke lie hI dravyastava viruddha hai / kyoMki usameM hiMsA hotI hai, jabaki muniko cha: kAya jIvoM kI hiMsA kA tyAga hai / 'asAratA khyApanAya Aha-aniuNamaI vayaNamiNaM ityAdi / zloka naM. 192 kI TIkA ke isa pATha ke sAtha, zloka naM. 194 meM se "yaH prakRtyaiva asuMdara sa kathaM zrAvakANAmapi yuktaH" isa pUrvapakSa ke pATha ko joDakara artha kA anartha kiyA hai / isakA artha yaha nikalatA hai (dravyapUjA kI) asAratA batAne ke lie anipuNamati vAle kA ( dravyastava bhI aneka apekSAoM se bahuta gaNakArI hai) yaha vacana hai / jo prakRti se asuMdara hai, vaha zrAvakoM kI bhI kaise yogya hai ? yaha artha niryuktikAra bhagavaMta ke kathana se bilkula viruddha hai / niryuktikAra ne 193 naM. ke zloka meM spaSTa zabdoM meM sAdhu ke liye hI dravyastava niSiddha batAyA hai| jisameM se uThAkara TIkA kA vAkya inhoMne joDA vaha 194 naM. kI gAthA evaM usakI TIkA isa prakAra - Aha-yadyevaM kimayaM dravyastava ekAntata eva heyo vartate ? AhosvidupAdeyo'pi ? ucyate, sAdhUnAM heya eva, zrAvakANAmupAdeyo'pi, tathA cAha bhASyakAra 79

Page #84
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM" akasiNapavattagANaM virayAvirayANa esa khalu jutto / saMsArapayaNukaraNo davvathae kUvadiTTaMto // 194 // (bhA0 ) vyAkhyA :- akRtsnaM pravartayatIti saMyamamiti sAmarthyAdramyate akRtsnapravartakAsteSAM, 'viratAviratAnAm' iti zrAvakANAm 'eSa khalu yukta:' eSa dravyastavaH khaluzabdasyAvadhAraNArthatvAt yukta eva, kimbhUto'yamityAha 'saMsArapratanukaraNaH' saMsArakSayakAraka ityarthaH, dravyastava:, Aha-yaH prakRtyaivAsundaraH sa kathaM zrAvakANAmapi yukta ityatra kRpadRSTAnta iti, jahA NavANayarAisannivese kei pabhUyajalAbhAvao taNhAiparigayA tadapanodArthaM kUpaM khaNaMti, tesiM ca javi tahAdiyA va Mti maTTikAkaddamAIhi ya maliNijjanti tahAvi tadubbhaveNaM ceva pANieNaM tesiM te taNhAiyA so ya malo puvvao ya phiTTai, sesakAlaM ca te tadaNNe ya logA suhabhAgiNo havaMti / evaM davvathae jaivi asaMjamo tahAvi tao ceva sA pariNAmasuddhI havar3a jAe asaMjamovajjiyaM aNNaM ca NiravasesaM khavetti / tamhA virayAviraehiM esa davvatthao kAyavvo, subhANubaMdhI bhUyataraNijjarAphalo yatti kAuNamiti gAthArtha: // 194 // - isakA bhAvArtha - saMyama meM asaMpUrNa pravartaka aise zrAvakoM ko yaha dravyapUjA saMsAra kA kSaya karanevAlI hai / zaMkA karate hai jo prakRti se hI asuMdara hai vaha zrAvakoM ko bhI yukta kaise ? usake samAdhAna meM kUpa dRSTAMta samajhanA / vaha isa prakAra - naye base grAmAdi meM pAnI kI kamI hone se pyAsa ko bujhAne hetu kitaneka loga kuA~ khodate haiM / unakI tRSNAdi baDhatI hai / ve kIcaDAdi se malina hote hai, to bhI kue~ se nikale pAnI se unakI pyAsa bujhatI hai / sadA I ke vakta lagA mala aura pUrva kA bhI mala dUra hotA hai / hamezA ke lie ve aura dusare bhI loga sukhI hote haiM / isI prakAra dravyastava meM asaMyama hone para bhI usIse vaha pariNAma zuddhi hotI hai, jisase asaMyama se upArjita aura usake alAvA dusarA bhI karma nikhazeSa nAza hotA hai / isalie zrAvakoM ko yaha dravyastava (dravyapUjA) karanA cAhiye / 80

Page #85
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM " abhI pAThaka svayaM vicAreM aMDaralAina kiye gaye TIkA ke pATha kA artha kyA hai, aura lekhaka ne kaisA ghoTAlA kiyA hai ! TIkA ke adhure pUrvapakSa ke pATha ko uThAkara dusare sthAna meM joDakara kaisA anartha kiyA hai ? Age phira 1101 naM. kI gAthA kI TIkA kA pATha uThA lAye aura aisA AbhAsa karAnA cAhate hai ki dravyapUjA meM virAdhanA hone se vaha tyAjya hai aura sAmAyikAdi pravRtti hI upAdeya hai / paraMtu usa gAthA kI TIkA se bhI spaSTa artha nikalatA hai ki, "jo tapasaMyama meM udyata hai vaha caityAdi ( maMdira - mUrti, kula, gaNa, saMgha, AcArya, pravacana - zruta) saMbaMdhI kRtya kA bhI virAdhaka nahIM hai (ArAdhaka hai) / arthAta maMdira - mUrtibhI ArAdhya haiN| Age lekhaka bhI isI kA jo bhAvArtha batAte hai " ataH saMvara sAmAyikAdi pravRttiyoM ko choDakara jo kevala pUjA karake, dharma kara liyA aise saMtuSTa amare bane rahate hai, ve vAstava meM ukta pramANa anusAra anipuNamati arthAt mUDha buddhi hai|" ina lekhaka ke zabdoM se bhI pUjA Adi meM dharma hai yaha spaSTa hotA hai / usake sAtha sAmAyikAdi bhI Avazyaka hai / kevala dravyapUjA se kRtakRtya na bane, bhAvapUjA. bhI Avazyaka hai / upara batAyeM TIkA pATha ke pherabadala se inakI pustikA ke pR. 32 para likheM - " ataH kisI bhI prAcIna Agama yA grantha yA vyAkhyAoM ko paDhane meM samajhane meM ukta aMgreja ke samAna viveka kI AMkhe to khola kara hI rakhanI cAhiye / aMdhe bane rahane meM to dhUrto kI dhUrtAI hI palle paDanevAlI hai / kyoMki jinakA jaisA paDyA svabhAva jAsI jIva sU~ / sA~ca ko kahIM AMca nahIM hai / koI na koI mArga upAya mila hI jAtA aura jhuThe ko eka jhUTha ke liye aneka (sau) jhUTha karane paDate haiM / phira bhI durbhAgya se burI taraha phasakara kabhI pakaDA bhI jAtA hai" ye zabda lekhaka ko barAbara lAgu ho jAte hai yA nahIM pAThaka svayaM nirNaya kareM / 81

Page #86
*60 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 "makkhana aura dvidala" kI samIkSA isa prakaraNa kI zuruAta lekhakazrIne haribhadrasUri TIkA kA nAma lekara kI hai, paraMtu diye pATha meM se prathama gAthA hI usa TIkAmeM hai, Age kA pATha usa TIkA meM hai nahIM / isa prakAra aMTasaMTa pATha dene para aise vyakti vizvasta kaise bana sakate haiM ? TIkA meM uddhRta niyukti pATha meM spaSTa hai ki "saMsakta aura asaMsakta pAtra eka vyakti sAtha meM nahIM rakheM, anyathA saMsakta ke gaMdha se asaMsakta bhI bigar3a jAegA / aura usako sAtha meM rakhakara bhikSAbhramaNa na kareM, virAdhanA hogii|" rasaja saMsakta viSayaka isa bAta se spaSTa hai ki zAstra meM pAnI-dahI navanItAdi meM trasa jIva saMsakta kI hI bAta nahIM, apitu rasaja saMsakta kI, bAta bhI AtI hai / jaba ki lekhaka trasasaMsakta ke aneka pATha dekara rasaja saMsakta kI bAta ko DhAMkane kI koziza karate hai| . rasaja jIva, dahI Adi meM batAyA huA kAla purA hone se, vAtAvaraNa se yA dvidalAdi mizraNa se bhI ho sakate hai / usakA vahAM para spaSTIkaraNa kiyA nahIM hai / graMthakAra usa viSaya ko chue nahIM hai vaha unakI marajI / vicitrA sUtrANAM gtiH| rasaja saMsakta dahI Adi batAne se, dvidala se saMsakta dahI kA grahaNa bhI ho hI jAtA hai / tathA bRhatkalpabhASya meM bhI - 'pAlaMkalaTTasAgA muggakayaM cAmagorasummIsaM / saMsajjai a acirA taM pi niyamA dudosAya // 60 // ' isa pATha ke dvArA kacce gorasa (dahI Adi) meM rasaja saMsakti hI batAI hai / tathA 'rasajai saMsaktaM tu kAMjikAdi sapAtraM tyAjyam / ' lekhakane diye hue isa pAThameM 'Adi' zabda se dahI Adi kA bhI grahaNa ho jAtA hai| isalie lekhaka ne 'Adi' zabda kA artha hI nahIM kiyA hai| saMsakta niyukti evaM bRhatvakalpabhASya meM dahI ke rasaja saMsakta hone kI 82 -

Page #87
G000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" 09602 bAta batAyI hone se, yahAM para 'Adi' zabda se dahI Adi kA grahaNa karanA ucita hI pratIta hotA hai| lekhakane sArArtha (6) evaM niSkarSa (2) meM 'rasaja jIvotpati yukta AhAra' kI bAta likha kara, kahIM para bhI dvidala saMbaMdhI kathana kA nahIM honA likhA hai, vaha vadatovyAghAta hai, cUMki khudane batAye rasaja jIvotpati yukta AhAra meM dvidala se saMsakta dahI kA bhI grahaNa ho jAtA hai / kyoMki dahI bhI AhAra ginA jAtA hai| pUrvAcAryoM kI paraMparA se dvidala - dahIM saMyoga meM jIvotpatti mAnI hai| yoniprAbhRta graMtha hAla meM viccheda hai, jisameM dravyoM ke mizraNa se tatkAla jIvotpatti ke aneka prayoga the / isalie isameM sajIvatA kI siddhi koI bAdha nahIM hai / lokAzAha kI prAcIna sAmAcArI se bhI yaha varNya siddha hotA hai| usameM bhI dvidala meM doSa batAyA hai, vaha isa prakAra - dekhie suzIlakumArajI likhita "jaina dharma kA itihAsa" meM pR. 299-300 para lokAzAha kI sAmAcArI meM kalama (17) 'jisa dina gorasa liyA jAya usa dina dvidala kA prayoga nahIM honA cAhiye / ' lekhaka ke pUrvaja zrI amolakha RSijI mahArAja bhI dahIdvidala mizraNa meM jIvotpatri mAnakara use abhakSya mAnate haiM / jisakA pATha 22 abhakSya-samIkSA meM pAThaka dekheN| ___ rasaja saMsakta dahIM A jAye to usako paraThane kA viveka bhI pAtra sahita vagairaha, niyukti meM batAyI huI vidhi ke anusAra samajhanA cAhiye / spaSTIkaraNa : (I) trasasaMsakta meM trasa jIva do prakAra ke - (1) taduttha : mUla dravya meM paidA hue, jaise gehu~, ATe vagairaha meM dhAnya kITaka vgairh| . (2) AgaMtuka : bAhara se AyI cITI vagairaha / ye donoM prakAra ke trasa jIva mUla dravya se vidhipUrvaka alaga kiye jA sakate hai| 83

Page #88
4-60 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 __ (II) rasaja saMsakta meM rasaja yAni pravAhI dravya meM utpanna hue atisUkSma jIva jo pRthak nahIM kie jA sakate haiM, ata: yahA~ pAtrasahita mUladravya ko paraThanA batAyA hai| ___ zvetAMbara meM hemacaMdrasUrijI vagairaha aneka pUrvAcAryoM ne makkhana ko abhakSya mAnA hai| digaMbara bhI ise abhakSya mAnate hai / digaMbarAcArya amRtacandrajI racita 'puruSArtha siddhayupAya graMtha (karIba 1100 varSa prAcIna) meM bhI makkhana meM jIvotpatti mAnakara use abhakSya ginA hai|' - navanItaM ca tyAjyaM yonisthAnaM prabhUtajIvAnAm / .. yadApi piNDazuddhau viruddhamabhidhIyate kiJcit // 193 // sthAnakavAsI ke mahAna AcArya zrI amolaka RSijI bhI makkhana ko abhakSya batAte haiM / dekheM unhIM ke zabda - "chAcha se alaga hone ke bAda thoDe hI samaya meM makkhana meM kRmi Adi jIvoM kI utpatti ho jAtI hai / usameM lIlana - phUlana bhI A jAtI hai / isake atirikta makkhana kAma vikAra utpanna karane vAlA hone se bhI abhakSya hai|" (jaina tattva prakAza - pR. 497) isa prakAra pUrvAcAryoM kI prAcIna paraMparA se usameM jIvotpatti mAnI jAtI hai / ata: makkhana kA nirNaya atIndriyajJAnIgamya hai| TeDhe praznoMkesIdhe - sacoTa uttara AgamAdi ke viSayameM pUche gaye praznoM ke uttara pAne ke pahale itanA samajhanA Avazyaka hai ki - pUrvakAla meM Agama kaMThastha the evaM ziSyoM ko AcArya sUtra kaMThastha karAne ke sAtha-sAtha artha kI vAcanA dete the, ve usameM se kucha ko dhAraNa karate the, kucha ko kaMThastha karate the, kucha padArtha AcArya zrI saMgrahaNI gAthAoM ke dvArA saMkalita karake dete the evaM arthavizleSaNa apanI zailI se karate the| __ kaMThastha karane kI paraMparA meM sUtra, niyukti, saMgrahaNI Adi sabhI ko pRthak-pRthak rupa se avadhAraNa karake rakhA jAtA thaa| NE 84

Page #89
+G000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" 009602 dhIre-dhIre medhA zakti, dhAraNA zakti kama hone lagI, kAla viSama hone lagA, duSkAla vagairaha paDe, zramaNoM kI saMghayaNa -sahanazIlatA kama hone lagI, rAjakIya paristhitiyAM viSama hone lagI, aMtara - bAhya yuddha vagairaha kI vikaTa paristhitiyAM bhI hone lagI / aisI paristhitioM ke kAraNa zramaNoM ko saMyamanirvAha hetu magadha Adi kSetra ko choDakara sukAla vAle dUra-dUra ke kSetroM meM vicaraNa karanA paDA / durlabha bhikSA, vihArAdi ke kAraNa svAdhyAya hAni hone se zruta kA bahuta bhAga vismRta prAya: ho gayA, use puna: samaya - samaya para saMkalita kiyA gayA / taba kaI paraMparAgata pAThAntara Adi bhI upasthita hue, jinheM bhI ucita rIti se saMkalita kiyA gayA / prathama vAcanA - pATalIputra meM bhadrabAhusvAmI ke samaya meM huii| dusarI vAcanA - mathurA meM skaMdilAcArya kI nizrA meM / tIsarI vAcanA - vallabhIpura meM nAgArjunAcArya kI nizrA meM / cauthI vAcanA - vallabhIpura meM devardhigaNijI kI nizrA meM / mAthurI evaM nAgArjunIya donoM vAcanA kI paraMparA ko eka karane ke prayAsa pUrvaka AgamoM ko pustakAruDha kiyA gyaa| isake alAvA khAravela rAjA ke samaya bhI zruta uddhAra hone kA ullekha milatA hai| AgamakI mAnyatA ke anusAra eka-eka akSara likhane para prAyazcita AtA hai, paraMtu lAbhAlAbha ko dekhakara devardhigaNijI ke samaya se yaha Agama lekhana zuru huA / paraMtu usa samaya kAgaja durlabha the, ata: ekadama nikaTanikaTa likhne jAte the / niyukti, bhASya, saMgrahaNI Adi ko pRthak-pRthak nirdeza karanekA prayAsa nahIM kiyA jAtA thA / vartamAna kI saMpAdana zailI meM sukhabodha ke lie kiye jAnevAle alpavirAma pUrNavirAma Adi bhI prAyaH nahIM rakhe jAte the / isa kAraNa kucha bhASya-gAthAe~ niyukti meM mizrita ho gayI, saMgrahaNI, niyukti gAthAe~ Adi mUlasUtra meM mizrita ho gyii| yaha bAta * dazavakAlika kI agastyasiMhajI kI cUrNi ke dvArA patA calatI hai / jise 85.

Page #90
+-60 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 cUrNikAra niyukti gAthA kahate hai, vaha Aja mUlasUtra meM pAyI jAtI hai, kucha jagaha para 'keti suttaM, keti vittivayaNamimaM bhaNaMti' ke dvArA cUrNikAra usakAla meM mUlasUtra evaM vyAkhyA sAhitya kA saMmizraNa honA sUcita karate hai / agastyasiMhajasUrijI kI cUrNi meM pradarzita niyukti gAthAoM se kaI adhika gAthAe~ hAribhadrI TIkA meM milatI hai / jisakA spaSTIkaraNa lADanu se prakAzita "dasaveyAliyaM" kI prastAvanA meM bhI diyA hai / arthAt sUtroM meM kucha vRddhi yA arvAcIna bAta dekhI jAveM to vaha usake abhinna aMga samAna vyAkhyA sAhitya ke kucha aMza ke jur3ane se huI hai, ata: AgamoM meM manasvI, prakSepa kI zaMkA ucita nahIM hai| dusarI bAta mUla sUtroM meM vacit paraspara visaMvAda dikhane para, apekSA bheda yA matAMtara kahakara usakA samAdhAna kiyA jAtA hai tathA sthAnAMga sUtra aupapAtika sUtra, Adi mUlasUtroM meM godAsa Adi nau gaNa tathA nihava Adi paravartI ghaTanAoM ke ullekhoM ke milane mAtra se AgamoM kI prAmANikatA meM saMdeha bhI nahIM kiyA jAtA hai / vahA~ para samasta zvetAMbara paraMparA ko AgamoM ko pustakAruDha karane vAle AcAryoM kI prAmANikatA, bhavabhIrutA para vizvAsa ke bala se lekhana kAla taka huI ghaTanAoM ke ullekha kiye jAne para bhI AgamoM meM saMdeha nahIM hotA hai, kyoMki jagaha-jagaha para TIkAkAroM ne isa viSaya meM prazna uThAkara sUtroMkA trikAla gocara honA vagairaha samAdhAna bhI kiye hai tathA abhI batAyI rIti se vyAkhyA sAhitya ke kucha aMzo kA sUtra se saMmizraNa yA saMkalanakAra dvArA ucita jAnakara tatkAla taka huI ghaTanAoM kA azaTha rupa se ullekha karanA vagairaha samAdhAna bhI kiye jA sakate hai|| devendramuni zAstrIjI ne bhI kahA hai - "uttara meM nivedana hai; jaina dRSTi se bhagavAna mahAvIra sarvajJa the, ata: ve pazcAt hone vAlI ghaTanAoM kI sUcanA kareM isameM koI Azcarya nahIM hai / jaise - navam sthAnameM AgAmI - utsarpiNI kAla ke bhAvI tIrthaMkara mahApadma kA caritra diyA gayA hai / aura bhI aneka sthaloM para bhaviSya meM honevAlI ghaTanAoM kA ullekha hai / 86

Page #91
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM" dUsarI bAta yaha hai ki pahale Agama zruti paramparA se cale A rahe the, una pAThoM kA saMkalana aura Akalana AcArya skandila aura devardhigaNI kSamAzramaNa ke samaya lipibaddha kiyA gayA thA / usa samaya ve ghaTanAe~, jinakA ullekha prastuta Agama meM hai, ve bhaviSya meM honevAlI ghaTanAe~ bhUtakAla meM ho cukI thI / ata: jana-mana meM bhrAnti utpanna na ho jAya isa dRSTi se AcAryoM ne bhaviSyakAla ke sthAna para bhUtakAla kI kriyA dI ho yA una AcAryoM ne usa samaya taka kI ghaTita ghaTanAe~ isameM saMkalita kara dI hoN| isa prakAra kI do - cAra ghaTanAe~ bhUtakAla kI kriyA meM likha dene mAtra se prastuta Agama gaNadharakRta nahIM hai, aisA kathana ucita pratIta nahIM hotA / " - ( jaina Agama sAhitya manana aura mImAMsA, pR. 98) ataH ogamoM meM sabakA vizvAsa ekadama ucita hI hai / ThIka usI taraha ukta lekhaka ko paryuSaNA kalpa, niryukti Adi sAhitya ke viSaya meM bhI svataH samAdhAna mila sakate hai, jarurata hai kevala pUrvagrahoM se mukta taTastha satyAnveSaNa kI bhAvanA kI / puche gaye praznoM ke uttara prazna 1-kA uttara :- pajjosavaNA kalpasUtra kA alaga astitva kaba huA ? yaha prazna hI sUcita karatA hai ki Apa bhI kalpasUtra ko dazAzrutaskandha kI AThavIM dazA ke rupa meM svIkAra karate hai, ApakA vivAda kevala usake pRthak astitva ko lekara hai, jo koI vizeSa mahattva nahIM rakhatA hai / ApazrIne jo usake alaga astitva pratipAdaka pramANa viSaya meM puchA thA, usakA samAdhAna yaha hai ( 1 ) samavAyAMga mUla - sUtra svayaM " kapparasa samosaraNaM neyaM" ke dvArA kalpasUtra kA sUcana karatA hai evaM TIkA meM isakA spaSTIkaraNa bhI kiyA gayA hai / (2) dusarI bAta yaha ki jina granthoM meM paryuSaNa kalpa kA ullekha hai, usakA sUcana Apake prazna naM. 9 se hI mila jAtA hai, ve sUcita grantha isa prakAra hai : 87

Page #92
" sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (a) nizItha sUtra dazama uddezaka (ba) nizItha bhASya 3218 aura (ka) usakI cUrNi jisameM 'pajjosavaNAkappa' kA spaSTa pATha hai / (3) tathA samasta zvetAMbara paMtha meM mAnya dazAzrutaskandha ke mUlapAThoM meM bhI 8veM adhyayana kI zaruAta 'teNaM samaeNaM samaNe bhagavaM mahAvIre paMcahatthuttare hotthA...' se karake 'jAva bhujjo bhujjo uvadaMser3a tti bemi' ke dvArA 'atha se iti hI pure AThaveM adhyayana ke sUtroM kA atideza kiyA hai, anyatra prasiddha vastu kAhI atideza kiyA jAtA hai / ata: 'jAva' zabda ke dvArA AThaveM adhyayana ke sUtroM ke lie kiyA gayA atideza hI batAtA hai ki devardhigaNi ke pahale hI yaha AThavAM adhyayana hI paryuSaNA kalpasUtra ke rupa se alaga astitva evaM prasiddhi ko dhAraNa karatA thA, jisake sUtroM kA yahAM nirdeza kiyA gayA hai, anyathA Apa 'jAva' zabda se kauna se sU ko grahaNa kareMge ? prazna- 2 kA uttara :- pratiSThita itihAsa vizeSajJa, Agama prabhAkara munizrI puNyavijayajI ma.sA. (bRhatkalpa ke Amukha meM), dalasukha mAlavaNiyAM (nizItha kI prastAvanA) evaM DaoN. sAgaramala jaina (dazAzrutaskandha eka adhyayana) vagairaha taTastha, prakAMDa itihAsavettAoM ne eka AvAja se kahA hai ki niryuktiyA~ Agama ke pustakAruDha hone ke bahuta pUrva racI jA cukI thI / kahIM-kahIM sthaloM para bhASya Adi kI gAthAe~, niryukti meM mizrita ho gayI hai, jinheM svayaM TIkAkArAdi bhI pRthak karane meM saMdigdha the / aisI paristhitioM meM agara niryukti meM naMdIsUtra kA ullekha A gayA ho, utane mAtra se pUrA niyukti sAhitya pU. devardhigaNijI (naMdIsUtra ) ke bAda racA gayA, yaha kahanA anucita hai| sthAnakavAsI samAja ke supratiSThita manISI zrI devendramuni zAstrIjI ne bhI kahA hai ki - " yaha satya hai ki vIra nirvANa kI AThavIM nauMvI sadI ke pUrva inakI racanA ho cukI thI / (jaina Agama sAhitya : manana aura mImAMsA peja 436) niryuktiyoM kI racanA karake bhadrabAhu ne jaina sAhitya kI jo sevA kI vaha sadA amara rahegI / ( vahI pR. 455) 88

Page #93
G006 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (29602 jaise 12-12 varSIya bhISma duSkAloM ke bAda zruta saMkalanA ke lie huI vAcanAoM meM jitanA zrutajJAna tatkAlIna AcAryoM ke pAsa thA, use saMkalita karake AgamoM ko surupa pradAna kiyA gayA thA, usameM tatkAla taka hui ghaTanAoM ko bhI zAyada saMkalita kiyA gayA ho, isalie zrI sthAnAMga sUtra, zrI aupapAtika sUtra Adi mUlasUtroM meM 7 nivanavoM Adi kA ullekha pAyA jAtA hai| itane mAtra se 'pure sthAnAMga sUtra Adi AgamoM ko arvAcIna mAnanA' kyA zvetAMbara paraMparA ke kisI bhI paMtha ko mAnya hai ? kadApi nahIM, ata: jaise vahA~ para samAdhAna kiyA jAtA hai, vaise prabhu vIra se calI A rahI AcArya paraMparA ke sapUtoM (?) ko pUrvAMcAryoM kI paraMparA se calI A rahI niyukti ke zrutakevalI bhadrabAhusvAmIkRta hone kI mAnyatA ke viSaya meM samAdhAna avazya prApta ho sakatA hai| prazna-3 kA uttara :- kalpasUtra ke Adi meM namaskAra maMtra ke viSaya meM pATha bhedavAlI prateM vyAkhyAkAroM ke sAmane hogI, ata: vyAkhyAbheda prApta hote hai / evaM 'navakAra maMtra' lipikartA dvArA kiyA huA maMgala bhI ho sakatA ho, jo mUlasUtra ke sAtha, kAlakrama se anAbhogAdi ke kAraNa jur3a gayA hogA, itane mAtra se use 'prakSepa' kahanA ucita nahIM, kyoMki prakSepa meM mUlagrantha meM kucha baDhAne kI icchA hotI hai| prazna-4 kA uttara :- Apane puchA ki kalpasUtra meM usa sUtra va usa adhyayana ke nAma kA mukhya viSaya sabase aMta meM hai, prAraMbha meM karIba 1000 zloka pramANa varNana anya hai, jabaki niyukti meM prAraMbha se hI mukhya viSaya kI vyAkhyA hai aura 1000 zloka jitane mUla pATha ke liye kevala eka 62 vI gAthA meM saMketa mAtra hai, aisA kyoM ? isa meM bhI kucha rahasya ho sakatA hai kyA? aba yahA~ vicAra karanA hai ki, niyukti ke prAraMbha meM mukhya viSaya kI bAta batAyI hai aura 1000 zloka ke varNana vibhAga ko eka 62 vI gAthA se sUcita kiyA hai yaha kahA~ taka satya hai kyoMki 8veM adhyayana kI niyukti meM pahale pajjosavaNA zabda ke ekArthika zabda batAkara unameM se 'ThavaNA' zabda ke 89 -

Page #94
" sAMca ko AMca nahIM " nikSepa kiye / phira gAthA 3 se 61 taka usakI vizada vivecanA kI jisameM prasaMgopAta paryuSaNA kI bAteM bhI A gayI, paraMtu mUlasUtra kI vivecanA ina 61 zlokoM meM nahIM kI gayI hai / isa prakAra 8vIM dazA kI bhUmikA meM 61 zloka ho jAne ke bAda 62 ve zloka meM varNana vibhAga kA sUcana kiyA evaM Age 5 gAthA meM mUla paryuSaNAkalpa ke mukhya viSaya ke kucha aMzoM kI vivecanA kI hai / niryukti meM mukhya viSaya kI vivecanA pahale kI gayI hai aura varNana vibhAga kI vivecanA bAda meM kI hai, ataH vaha prakSipta hai ityAdi prakSepa kI kalpanA kI bAteM, uparokta rIti se sUkSma avalokana karane para asatya siddha ho jAtI hai / tathA 1000 zloka pramANa varNana vibhAga kA eka zloka se saMketa karane ke pIche rahasya yaha hai ki varNana vibhAga sugama hone se usakA vistAra nahIM kiyA gayA hai / isI taraha niryukti meM hara jagaha lAghava dikhAI detA hai, TIkAkAra usakA yathocita vizleSaNa karate hai / isIlie bhUmikA ke 61 zloka meM prAsaMgika rupa se paryuSaNA viSayaka vizada vivecana ho jAne se niyukti meM kevala 5 zloka meM hI varNana kiyA hai / prazna-5, 6, 7, kA uttara - tInoM praznoM meM kalpasUtra meM bhadrabAhusvAmI ke bAda ke AcAryoM ko namaskAra 980 va 983 ke ullekhoMko lekara prakSipta kara baDhAne vagairaha kI hI bAteM likhI hai / eka viSayaka hone se una sabakA javAba sAtha meM hI diyA jAtA hai / nizItha bhASya evaM cUrNi se spaSTa hotA hai ki pUrvakAla meM, pAMca rAtri meM, paryuSaNa kalpa kA vAMcana cAturmAsakI sthApanA pahale kiyA jAtA thA, jisameM varSAkAla saMbaMdhI utsarga - apavAdoM kA sAmAnya se nirUpaNa kiyA jAtA thA / ina AcAroM ke varNana ke pUrva cAturmAsa meM viziSTa ArAdhanA kI preraNA hetu tathA apanI gauravavaMtI guruparaMparA ke itihAsa ko jIvaMta rakhane hetu 24 tIrthaMkara, unake parivAra, gaNadhara bhagavaMta tathA sthaviroM ke caritra paDhe jAte the / 90

Page #95
*6000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (D 9602 'purimacarimANa kappo maMgalaM vaddhamANatitthammi ia parikahiyA jiNa gaNaharAi therAvalI carittaM / ' (nizItha bhASya evaM dazAzrutaskandha niyukti) saMbhava hai ki jaba bhadrabAhusvAmI ne dazAzrutaskandha kI racanA kI, taba 8veM adhyayana ke rupa meM paryuSaNA kalpa kI racanA kI evaM usameM cAturmAsika kalpa kI maryAdAnusAra sthavirAvalI ke varNana vibhAga meM apane samaya taka ke AcAryoM kA varNana kiyA, bAda meM yaha grantha maukhika paraMparA se Age calatA rahA evaM pratyeka vAcanA ke samaya meM sthavirAvalI ko kramazaH Age baDhAkara suvyavasthita kiyA jAtA rahA / devardhigaNi ke samaya meM yaha grantha pustakAruDha kara diyA gayA tathA sthavirAvalI ko tatkAla taka saMkalita kiyA gayA evaM usake bAda meM sthavirAvalI vibhAga vahA~ taka hI paDhA jAne lagA / maukhika paraMparA meM sthavirAvalI Age Age baDhatI thI, pustakAruDha hone ke bAda vaha vahA~ para hI sthAgita ho gayI / pustakAruDha karate samaya mAthurI anuyAyI evaM nAgArjunIya anuyAyioM meM vIra nirvANa saMvat meM matabheda thA / ataH donoM matoM ko 980 aura 993 ke rupa meM likha diyA gayA / (vizeSa vistAra ke lie dekhie paM. kalyANavijayajI kI paTTAvalI parAga pustk)| ina sabhI bAtoM meM kahI para mUlagrantha meM prakSepa kI gaMdha nahIM AtI hai| paraMtu 'ia parikahiA jiNa gaNaharAi therAvalI caritaM' ke dvArA niyuktikAra ne jo sthavirAvalI varNana karane ke lie sUcana kiyA hai, usakA pAlana karanA hI samajhA jAtA hai, jo granthakAra ke Azaya ke anukUla hI hai aura uktta ke vistAra rupa cUlikA ke rupa meM bhI ina saMvardhanoM ko ginA jA sakatA hai| __ jaise anya sthavira kRta adhyayana bhI dvitIya zrutaskandhaM meM cUlA rUpa se, AcArAMga sUtra se abhinna rupa se svIkRta kiye gaye hai, usI taraha pUrA kalpasUtra akhaNDa mAnA jAtA hai| prazna-8 kA uttara :- "etat na svabuddhayA procyate kintu bhagavadupadezapAratantryeNa ityAha....' (kalpa subodhikA TIkA) . -91

Page #96
" sAMca ko AMca nahIM " kiM svecchayA bhaNati netyucyate taM niddeso kIrati puNo / ' (dazAzrutaskandha 8ve adhyayanakI cUrNi ) isake dvArA vyAkhyAkAroM ne spaSTa nirdeza kiyA hai ki yaha kalpasUtra, granthakAra bhadrabAhusvAmI apane mana se nahIM batA rahe paraMtu ise bhagavAna ne bhI artha 'pajjosavaNAkappotti varisastamajjhAtA' yAni cAturmAsika maryAdA ke niyama vAle isa adhyayana ko artha se batAyA thA / jarurI nahIM hai ki zabdazaH vartamAna kA sUtra bhagavAna ke mukha se vaise hI nikalA ho, paraMtu artha ke upadezaka tIrthaMkara hai / ataH arthase yaha sUtra A jAtA hai evaM sthavirAvalI bhI 'ia parikahiyA' ke nirdezAnusAra Age bar3hane se yaha grantha lagabhaga 1200 sUtra kA banA isameM koI anupapatti nahIM dikhatI hai / prazna-9 kA uttara :- kalpasUtra meM kevala tIrthaMkaroM ke caritra hI nahIM paraMtu sAdhubhagavaMto ke ApavAdika AcAroM kA bhI nirupaNa hai, ata: usameM gopanIya bA bhI Ane se tathA mUlataH kalpasUtra, dazAzrutaskandha rupa chedagrantha kA vibhAga rupa hone se gRhasthoM ko sunAne meM prAyacchita batAyA hai / prazna-10 kA uttara :- kalpasUtra ko mUrtipUjaka samAja kAlikasUtra meM hI mAnatA haiM aura kAlika sUtroM ke lie nirdiSTa vidhi ke anusAra vartamAna meM bhI kAlagrahaNa pUrvaka usake yogodahana bhI kiye jAte hai, ata: kAlikasUtra ko utkAlika sUtra kara dene kA AkSepa dene meM praznakAra kI anabhijJatA aura jaldabAjI prakaTa hotI hai / vartamAna meM gRhasthoM ke Age, dinameM kalpasUtra ko, nizIthI bhASya gAthA 3220 evaM usakI cUrNi ke dvArA nirdiSTa apavAda mArga se paDhA jAtA hai / 'jIvita makkhI jAnakara nigala jAnA' ye zabda to lekhaka kI mAnasikatA ko sUcita karate hai / vyavahAra sUtra meM AgamoM ko niyata paryAya vAleM zramaNoM ko hI paDhAne kI spaSTa AjJA hone para bhI unheM sAnuvAda chApakara gRhasthoM ko par3hAne kI pravRtti karane para kyA yezabda lekhaka ko hI lAgu nahIM par3ate ? prazna- 11 kA uttara :- nizItha sUtra meM aparyuSaNA meM paryuSaNA kA jo 92

Page #97
G006 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 niSedha hai, vaha aparva meM (5, 10 punama, amAvasyA sivAya meM) paryuSaNA karane kA niSedha hai, aisA usakI cUrNi se spaSTa hotA hai tathA kalpasUtra meM bhAdaravA suda 5 ke bAda paryuSaNA kA niSedha tathA usake pahale ke paryoM meM anujJA dI hai, jo nizItha sUtra se aviruddha hI hai| jo loga zAstra meM paryuSaNA (saMvatsarI) ko bhAdaravA suda 5 kI niyata honA mAnate hai, unake lie yaha samAdhAna hai ki - pahalI bAta to kalpasUtra ke kartA bhadrabAhusvAmI hai, jabaki nizIthasUtra ke kartA nizItha grantha kI prazasti ke anusAra 'vizAkhAcArya' hai, ata: donoM granthoM ke kartA bhinna hai / ata: lekhaka ke dvArA eka hI vyakti dvArA pUrvApara viruddha bAtoM kA nirupaNa karane kI AzaMkA uThAnI ucita nahIM hai| dusarI bAta utsarga - apavAdamaya jinAzAsanameM kisI grantha meM koI bAta utsarga se kahI gayI ho, usI bAta kA ApavAdika vidhAna anya graMtha meM ho sakatA hai ! yogyatA evaM gurugama ke binA sUtroM ke rahasya nahIM mila sakate hai ! koI utsarga sUtra hotA hai, koI apavAda sUtra hotA hai| isalie nizItha sUtra evaM kalpasUtra meM koI virodha nahIM hai| prazna-12 kA uttara :- kalpasUtra meM granthakAra dvArA 'vayaM' zabda kA prayoga honA vyAkaraNa se siddha hai / ata: usameM kuzaMkAoM kI guMjAIza nahIM rahatI hai / niyuktikAra sUtra ke hara zabda kI vyAkhyA kare, aisA Agraha rakhanA bhI anucita hai, ata: Thosa pramANa ke binA, sUtroM meM prakSepa - prakSepa kI bAte karanA kevala araNyarudana jaisA hotA hai ! viddhaddharga use pramANita nahIM karatA hai / isakA vizeSa khulAsA pIche "namutthuNaM pATha ke prakSepa" kI samIkSA prakaraNa meM diyA jA cukA hai| prazna-13 kA uttara :- lekhaka mahAzaya ! Apane naMdI sUtra nirdiSTa 72 AgamoM meM se 45 AgamoM ko hI mAnane kA kAraNa puchA, usake javAba ke pahale to bar3A prazna yaha uThatA hai ki Apa 32 Agama hI kyoM mAnate ho aura 20 prakIrNaka meM se eka bhI prakIrNaka kyoM nahIM mAnate ho ? . 93 .

Page #98
6000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (29602 astu, hamArA javAba to spaSTa hai ki 45 Agama kI saMkhyA kI dhAraNA pUrvAcAryoM kI vivakSA vizeSa hai / hama 45 Agama sivAya ke AgamoM kI bhI vaisI hI pramANikatA svIkArate hai / prazna to ApakI 32 Agama kI dhAraNA para hotA hai kyoMki Apa anya AgamoM kI prAmANikatA hI nahIM svIkArate hai| prazna-14 kA uttara :- haribhadrasUriAdi pUrvAcAryoM kI AgamAdi kI TIkA vagairaha to Agama rupa hI mAnI jAtI hai, unakI anya svataMtra kRtiyAM bhI unake sapUta - maMdiramArgI samAja meM pramANa rupa meM atyaMta pratiSThA ko dhAraNa karatI hai / grantha kA pramANa rupa honA alaga bAta hai aura Agama koTi meM mAnA jAnA alaga bAta hai| jaise Apake guruoM kI dhAraNAoM ko Apa pramANa rupa meM mAnate ho, paraMtu unake granthoM ko Apa Agama nahIM mAnate ho / prazna-15 kA uttara :- sUryaprajJapti meM mAMsaviSayaka pATha prakSipta hai, aisA binA AdhAra se bedhaDaka prarupita karanA kyA 'jaM alu tu na jANejjA evaM eaMti no vae / ' isa dazavaikAlika sUtra kI AjJA kA bhaMga karanA nahIM kahalAtA hai ? tathA kisI bhI paMtha meM aisA koI prayojana bhI isase siddha nahIM hotA hai, jisake lie yahA~ prakSepa kI AzaMkA bhI uThAI jA sake / ata: mAMsa viSayaka sUtra meM bhI vastusthiti kA pratipAdana hI abhipreta lagatA hai / dusarI bAta 'mAnava bhojya mImAMsA' meM prakAMDa itihAsavettA paM. kalyANavijayajI ne AgamoM meM Ate mAMsa viSayaka sUtroM kA vanaspati vAcaka honA nighaSTu Adi zAstroM ke AdhAra se siddha kiyA hai / ata: una sUtroM ko prakSipta kahanA anucita hI hai| prazna-16 kA uttara :- AcArAMga ko Agama kyoM mAnA jAtA hai ? aise prazna to 32 AgamoM meM ina AgamoM kI ginatI karane vAle sthAnakavAsI samAja ko bhI lagatA hai / isI taraha ke prazna karake lekhaka apane Apako pracchanna digaMbara yA svacchanda mativAle, itihAsajJa (ajJa ?) ke rupa meM siddha kara rahe hai ? -

Page #99
-G900 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" 09602 ___astu yaha to prAsaMgika kathana mAtra thA / AcArAMga kA 8vAM adhyayana nahIM milane para use apramANa mAnane kI koI bAta nahIM AtI hai / kisI vyakti kA koI aMga kaTa jAtA hai, to kyA vaha AdamI apanA vyaktitva kho baiThatA hai ? gaNadhararacita sUtroM ke kaI aMza vicchinna hone para kyA upalabdha 11 aMga apramANa bana jAyeMge ? prazna-17 kA uttara :- praznavyAkaraNa ko Agama kyoM mAnA jAtA hai ? usakA javAba yaha hai ki kAla kI viSamatA evaM jIvoM kI ayogyatA ko dekhate hue, kisI samartha AcArya ne prazna vyAkaraNa meM se praznavidyA adi gaMbhIra viSayoM kA saMharaNa karake kAla ke anurUpa anya aviruddha bAtoM ko hI batAyA naMdIsUtra meM usake viSaya nirdeza ke antameM 'aisA praznavyAkaraNa kI TIkA meM abhayadevasUrijIne khulAsA kiyA hai / 'caraNa karaNa paruvaNA Aghavijjai' ke dvArA, vartamAna meM upalabdha, Azrava-saMvara varNana kA sUcana bhI milatA hI hai| isa prakAra prAcIna parapaMrA se cale A rahe isa 'prazna vyAkaraNa' Agama ke lie samasta zvetAMbara paraMparA ekamata hI hai| prazna-18 kA uttara :- 45 AgamoM ke racanAkAra evaM unakI racanA ke samaya ke itihAsa saMzodhana karane nikale hamAre lekhaka ko kyA 32 AgamoM kA itihAsa upalabdha hai ? (1) agara nahIM hai, to Apa unheM kyoM mAnate hai ? ___ (2) aura agara Apa 32 AgamoM ko bhI nahIM mAnate ho, (16, 17 veM prazna se aisA spaSTa samajha meM AtA hai) to Apa svayaM hI sthAnakavAsI samAja ke bhI gaddAra rupa meM siddha ho gaye ho / prazna-19 kA uttara :- bRhatsaMgrahaNI kI Agama paribhASA vAlI gAthA hameM mAnya hai / aisA hote hue bhI 45 Agama ko mAnane meM hameM koI Apatti nahIM hai kyoMki - (1) 11 aMga to gaNadhara racita hone se sarvamAnya hai| ____(2) 12 upAMga bhI sthavira (14 pUrvadhara Adi viziSTa jJAnI) dvArA racita hone se Agama me sammilita hai / 95

Page #100
4-0 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" ( 00900-2 ___ (3) 10 prakIrNaka bhI naMdIsUtra nirdiSTa pratyeka buddha Adi racita prakIrNaka hone se mAne jAte hai| ___(4) naMdIsUtra devavAcaka (devardhigaNi) ke dvArA racita hone para bhI sarvamAnya hai / anuyogaddhAra AyarakSitasUrijI racita hai, jo sADhe nau pUrvadhara hone para bhI sarvatra mAnya hai| (5) dazavaikAlika sUtra - 14 pUrvI zayyaMbhavasUrijI racita hai, uttarAdhyayana sUtra tIrthaMkara, pratyeka buddha Adi kI vANI hai / ___oghaniyukti, piMDaniyukti athavA Avazyaka niyuktiyA~ 14 pUrvadhara bhadrabAhu svAmI kI hone se mAnya hai| (6) nizitha sUtra 14 pUrvadhara kAlIna viziSTa zrutadhara vizAkhAcArya kRta hai| __- dazA-kalpa-vyavahAra sUtra bhadrabAhusvAmIjI kRta hai| _____ mahAnizItha sUtra yugapradhAna haribhadrasUrijI dvArA prAcIna pratIM meM se uddhRta kiyA gayA thA evaM usakA naMdIsUtra Adi meM nirdeza bhI milatA hai tathA jinazAsana ke jyotirdhara yugapradhAna madhyastha ziromaNi haribhadrasUrijI ne upadhAna paMcAzaka meM mahAnizItha sUtra kI prAmANikatA bhI siddha kI hai| __jItakalpa : saMghayaNa Adi kSINa hone para dravya kSetra kAla bhAva ke anusAra saMyama maryAdA kA sucAru rupa se pAlana hoveM evaM ucita AlocanA - prAyazcita ke dvArA zuddhi ho sake, isa hetu nizItha Adi ke AdhAra se parama gItArtha aise bRhatsaMgrahaNIkAra (jisakI gAthA ke AdhAra para Agama kI nirdhAraNA Apane kI hai) jinabhadragaNi kSamAzramaNa ke dvArA yaha jItakalpa racA gayA hai| ata AlocanA - prAyazcita Adi pratipAdaka isa grantha ko Agama mAnane meM koI harja mahasUsa nahIM hotA hai| isa taraha bhavabhIru saMvigna gItArtha guru - bhagavatoM kI suvizuddha paraMparA se AyI huI 45 Agama kI isa mAnyatA meM kisI kuzaMkA ko avakAza nahIM rahatA hai| 96

Page #101
G006 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 prazna-20 kA uttara :- prazna (17) aura (20) donoM eka hI prazna hai| prazna-21 kA uttara :- prazna (16) aura (21 donoM eka hI prazna haiM, paraMtu dhUrtatA se praznoM kI saMkhyA baDhAne kI ceSTA lekhaka ne kI hai, aisA lagatA hai| prazna-22 kA uttara :- isakA javAba prazna 5,6,7 ke diye hue javAba evaM pIche prakaraNoM meM kalpasUtra kI prAmANikatA kI siddhi ke prastAva meM A jAtA hai, vahA~ se samajha lenA cAhie / eka hI prazna bAra-bAra, ghumA phirAkara puMchanA, lekhaka kI nirbalatA ko sUcita karatA hai| ___ prazna-23 kA uttara :- isa prazna kA khulAsA prazna (14) evaM (19) ke mahAnizItha sUtra kI siddhi ke prastAva meM diyA jA cukA hai / isI prazna meM lekhaka jinheM zuddha prarUpaka mAna rahe hai aise bhavabhIru, ekAvatArI sUripuraMdara haribhadrasUrijI ne hI mahAnizItha sUtra kI siddhi upadhAna paMcAzaka meM kI hai| prazna-24 kA uttara :- lipikAla meM bhUla huI hai, aisA Thosa pramANoM se siddha kiye binA, yaha pATha sahI hai, yaha galata hai, aisA mAnanA apanI phuTapaTTI jaisI buddhi se samudra ke vistAra ko nApane jaisA hai| lekhaka kI taraha hI, svacchandamati dhAraka sthAnakavAsI saMta maMtrI zrI phulacaMdajI (pupphabhikkhu) ne manasvI rIti se 'suttAgame' meM AgamoM ke pAThoM ko pherabadala karane kI ceSTA kI thI, jise sthAnakavAsI zramaNasaMgha kI kAryavAhaka samiti ne bhI apramANita ghoSita kiyA thA / sthAnakavAsI samAja dvArA apramANita ghoSita kI huI usI ceSTA ko punaH prAmANikatA kI chApa lagAne kI mAnasikatA ko dhAraNa karate hue lekhaka kyA bhagavAna ke zAsana evaM zAstroM ke sAtha-sAtha sthAnakavAsI samAja ke bhI gaddAra to nahIM bana gaye dusarI bAta kAla ke kAraNa naSTa ho rahe zruta ko yathAvat saMrakSita rakhane kA AcAryoM kI paraMparA ne athAga prayAsa kiyA hai, ata: jagaha-jagaha para pAThAntaroM ke nirdeza, pUrva kI prAcIna TIkA Adi ke ullekha vagairaha prAmANika rUpa se kiye gaye bhI hai / svayaM mahAviddhAna TIkAkAra bhI mUlapATha kA lekhaka = 97 -

Page #102
500 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (09002 kI taraha niDara rUpa se apanI buddhi se nirNaya nahIM dete haiM kyoMki khuda kI chadmasthatA kA unheM spaSTa khyAla thaa| aMta me ve 'tattvaM kevalIgamyaM' kaha dete the, paraMtu lekhaka kI taraha binA pramANa se pATha ko badala karane kA dussAhasa nahI karate the / isake aneka udAharaNa Agama kI TIkAoM meM milate haiM, kevala grantha gaurava ke bhaya se nahIM diye jAte hai / prazna-25 kA uttara :- bhagavatI sUtra ke aMtameM maMgala prazasti lipikartA kI hai isalie abhayadevasUrijI ne vyAkhyA nahIM kI, aisA nahIM hai, paraMtu vaha prazasti spaSTArtha hai isalie vyAkhyA nahIM kI hai / unhoMne kahA hai ki - __ 'Namo goyamAiNaM gaNaharANamityAdayaH pustakalekhakakRtA namaskArAH prakaTArthAzceti na vyAkhyAtAH // ' yAni ki - Namo goyamAiNaM vagairaha namaskAra pustaka ke lekhaka dvArA kiye gaye hai aura ve spaSTa artha vAle hai, ata: unakI vyAkhyA nahIM kI gayI hai|" maMdiramArgI samAja dvArA prAya: AgoM kA saTIka hI saMpAdana kiyA jAtA hai, ata: ve gAthAe~ TIkA kI spaSTIkaraNa vAle pATha ke sAtha hI chApI jAtI hai / ata: mUla ke pATha ke sAtha unheM joDane kI bAta nahIM AtI hai| kevala mUlasUtra vAle AgamoM kA saMpAdana, to mukhyarupa se sthAnakavAsI evaM terApaMthIsamAja kI ora se prakAzita hotA hai, ata: lekhaka ke dvArA yaha AkSepa ghuma-phira kara sthAnakavAsI samAja para hI hai, jo vAstava meM ucita bhI nahIM hai / isameM na to sthAnakavAsI samAja yA terApaMtha samAja kI galatI hai, kyoMki ve to mUlasUtra kI upalabdha pratImeM jaisA pATha hai, use chApa rahe hai ? upalabdha pratIM ke pAThoM kI kAMTa-chAMTa karanA prAmANika saMpAdana ke lie ucita nahIM hai, ata: donoM samAja bhI agara una pAThoM ko chApate haiM, to vaha vaphAdArI hI hai, phira bhI agara lekhaka aise saMpAdaka ko galata kahate hai to ise lekhaka kI svacchandamati kA vilAsa hI kahanA cAhie, jo apane saMpradAya para bhI kIcaDa uchAlane se nahIM aTakate haiM / prazna-26 kA uttara :- "ceiyarukkhe tti baddhapIThA vRkSA yeSAmadhaH kevalAnyutpannAni" samavAyAMga sUtra 157 TIkA (prakIrNaka samavAya) - . 98 - .

Page #103
4-0 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" 09602 'caityavRkSA maNipIThikAnAmuparivartinaH sarva ratnamayA uparicchatradhvajAdibhiralaGkRtAH sudharmAdisabhAnAmagrato ye zrUyante te eva iti sambhAvyata' - sthAnAMga sUtra adhyayana 8 sUtra 654 TIkA azvatthAdayazcaityavRkSA ye siddhAyatanAdi dvAreSu zrUyanta iti / - sthAnAMga 10 sthAn, sUtra 736 / adhobaddhapIThike upari cocchritapatAke vRkSe' - uttarAdhyayanasUtra - adhyayana9 zloka 10 kI zAMtisUri-TIkA citiriheSTakAdicayaH tatra sAdhuH - yogyazcityaH prAgvat, sa eva caityastasmin, kimuktaM bhavati ? . ina saba TIkA grantha Adi se "caityavRkSa" kA bAMdhI huI pIThikAvAle vRkSa arthAt jina vRkSoM ke Asa-pAsa iTeM yA maNi Adi se bAMdha kAma kiyA gayA ho, aisA artha hotA hai| tathA prakANDa vidvAna paM. kalyANavijayajI ke mata meM 'caitya' zabda kA artha isa prakAra hai - "uparyukta saMkSipta vivaraNa se pAThakagaNa samajha sakeMge ki caityazabda "sAdhuvAcaka" athavA "jJAnavAcaka" na kabhI thA na Aja bhI hai / kyoMki "caitya" zabda kI utpatti pUjanIya agnicayana vAcaka "cityA" zabda se huI hai na ki 'citA' zabda se athavA 'citi saMjJAne' isa dhAtu se / ina prakRtiyoM se "caita", "citta", "caitas" zabda bana sakate hai, 'caitya' zabda nahIM / zrI pupphabhikkhU kI samajha meM yaha bAta A gaI ki zabdoM kA artha badalane se koI matalaba hala nahIM ho sakatA / pUjanIya padArtha - vAcaka "caitya" zabda ko sUtroM meM se haTAne se hI amUrtipUjakoM kA mArga niSkaNTaka ho skegaa|" . . (paTTAvalI parAga pR. 456) . "kozakAroM ne 'caitya' kA artha - 'jinaukaratabimbaM, caityo jinasabhAtaruH kiyA hai / " (uparokta pustaka ke pR. 455) prazna-27 kA uttara :- dvIpasAgara prajJapti ko Agama mAnate hI hai, 45 Agama meM usakI ginatI nahIM karane meM pUrvAcAryoM kI 45 AgamoM kI saMkhyA - 99 -

Page #104
4600 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" 1960-- kI vivakSA hI kAraNa hai / jisakI spaSTatA prazna 13 ke javAba meM bhI kara cuke hai| prazna-28 kA uttara :- AgamoM kI prAmANikatA ke liye mUrtipUjaka samAja meM matabheda nahIM haiM, kevala saMkhyA kI dhAraNA meM hI bheda hai jo pUrvAcAryoM kI vivakSA ke AdhIna hai tathA ina saMgrahakAroM kA anya saMkhyA ke 'saMgraha ke lie virodha bhI nahIM hai / prazna-29 kA uttara :- 10 prakIrNaka ke sivAya ko Agama nahIM mAnane ke AkSepa hI galata hai, jisakA khulAsA isI bAta ko lekara puche prazna 13 ke uttara meM diyA hai / racayitA ke nAma nahIM milane para bhI Apa bhI upAMgoM ko mAnate hI hai to atiprAcIna suvihita paraMparA se prApta ina payannAoM meM kyA harja hai, jinake nAma evaM atideza naMdIsUtra meM bhI hai| prazna-30, 31, kA uttara :- prazna ke javAba prazna 14 ke uttara meM A jAte hai| eka hI prakAra kA prazna bAra-bAra puchakara kevala grantha ke kalevara ko baDhAnA kitanA ucita hai ? pAThakagaNa svayaM nirNaya kareM! dusarI bAta isa prazna meM Apane haribhadrasUrijI ko prakAMDa vidvAna, jJAnI, prabhAvaka saMtaziromaNi, yugapradhAna AcArya ina birudoM se navAjA hai, to inhI yugapradhAna AcArya dvArA racita paMcavastuka grantha meM pUrvazruta meM se uddhRta 'stavaparijJA' prakaraNa diyA hai, vaha to Apako bhI mAnya hI hogA usameM jina-pratimA kI pUjA ko vistAra se nirdoSa sAbita kiyA hai| tathA inhI AcArya dvArA racita paMcAzaka graMtha kA isI pustikA meM diyA huA zloka mananIya hai 'dehAdiNimittaMpi hu je, kAyavahammi taha payasa'ti jiNapUAkAyavahammi, tesimapavattaNaM moho // 45 // zrAvaka prajJapti (zloka 349) agara nahIM mAnate ho, to yugapradhAna pUrvAcAryoM ke sapUta kaise kahalAoge ?' 10 pUrvadhara pU. umAsvAtijI racita tattvArtha sUtra to cAroM phirakoM meM mAnya haiM, usameM to mUrtipUjA vagairaha kI bAteM bhI nahIM hai, to bhI Apa use 32 - 100

Page #105
-60 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 Agama me kyoM nahIM mAnate haiM ? - prazna-32 kA uttara :- isakA javAba prazna 19 ke javAba meM A gayA hai| prazna-33 kA uttara :- zrAvaka ke kartavya yA kisI dharmAnuSThAna kA phala nirUpaNa karane ke svarupa mArga prarUpaNA karanA sAvadya bhASA meM nahIM AtA hai, vaha prajJApanI bhASA kahalAtI haiM / usameM maMdira, pUjA, sAmAyika, pauSadha, tapa, dIkSA, svAdhyAya Adi saba Ate hai / kyA sthAnakavAsI saMta dhovana pAnI pIne kI, guru-vaMdana, jIvadayA Adi kI preraNA nahIM karate hai ? ina preraNAoM ko lekara agara koI dhovana pAnI kA upayoga cAlu kareM, yA cAturmAsAdi meM guruvaMdana Adi karane jAveM, gAya Adiko ghAsa evaM kabutara Adi ko cuggA DAleMge, usameM jo apakAya, vanaspatikAya vagairaha kI virAdhanA hotI hai, to kyA usameM unake guruoM ko pApa lagegA ? hA~ usameM agara koI bhI sAdhu bhagavaMta kisI bhI sAvadha kriyA kI Direct preraNA kareMge, to usameM AjJApanI bhASA kA doSa to lagatA hI hai / paraMtu mArga prarUpaNA yA kartavya-nirupaNa meM doSa nahIM lagatA hai| prazna-34 kA uttara :- devaloka meM zAzvata pratimAe~ evaM unake nAma viSayaka zaMkAoM ke uttara "zAstra pATha se coriyA~" kI samIkSA prakaraNa tathA "mUrtipUjakoM ke dharma kI vicAraNA" kI samIkSA prakaraNa meM diye jA cuke haiN| prazna-35 kA uttara :- muhapatti Adi nAma hote hue bhI hAtha meM rakhane ke viSayaka prazna kA 'mukhavastrikA vArtA kI samIkSA' prakaraNa meM vistAra se uttara de cuke haiM, phira bhI Apake saMtoSa hetu yahA~ para bhI uttara diyA jAtA hai - rajoharaNa kA artha 'raja ko haraNa karane vAlA' hotA hai / Apake hisAba se to rajoharaNa pure dina dhula ko haTAne meM kAma liyA jAtA rahe, to hI vaha rajoharaNa kahalAyegA, paraMtu Apa to rajoharaNa ko bahulatayA kaMdhe para hI dhAraNa kiye hue rahate ho / to vaha rajoharaNa kaise kahalAyegA ? . tIrthaMkara kA artha 'tIrtha kI sthApanA karanevAlA' to kyA bhagavAna mahAvIra tIrtha kI sthApanA ke bAda 30 sAla pRthvItala para vicareM taba ve tIrthaMkara (101 -

Page #106
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM" nahIM the ? vyavahAra meM bhI kvacit hone vAle kisI mukhya kArya ko lekara hI vastu kA nAma pravRtta hotA hai, 24 ghaMTe usa kArya kA honA Avazyaka nahIM hai / jaise ki koI Doctor, Driver, Teacher, Toothbrush cAya kI keTalI vagairaha aise to kaI prayoga hai| jaise vahA~ una nAmoM kI sArthakatA, prayojana ke Ane para hI kvacit hotI hai, usI taraha 'bolate Adi samaya para mukha ke Age dhAraNa karanA', yaha prayojana hai jisakA vaha ' mukhavastrikA ' kahalAtI hai / hAtha yA keDa meM rakhane para bhI use pUrvokta vastuoM kI taraha vyavahAra naya se 'mukhavastrikA' hI kahA jAtA hai / . hA~, evaMbhUta naya (nizcaya naya) se to prayojana vaza jaba usakA upayoga hotA ho, tabhI vaha mukhavastrikA kahalAtI hai / isa naya se, binA prayojana mukha para dhAraNa kI jAnevAlI ApakI mukhavastrikA (1) mukhavastrikA nahIM kahI jA sakatI hai / tathA Dore meM paroyI huI mukhavastrikA, zAstra nirdiSTa nahIM hone se vaha vyavahAra naya se bhI mukhavastrikA nahIM kahalAtI hai / ataH hamArI, prayojana paDane para upayoga meM lI jAnevAlI muhaMpatti donoM nayoM se mukhavastrikA ke rupa meM siddha hotI hai, jabaki ApakI to donoM hI nayoM se asiddha hotI hai / lekhaka mahAzaya ko jarurata hai ki laukika vyavahAra evaM lokottara aise jinazAsana ke naya-nikSepoM kA gurugama pUrvaka jJAna prApta kareM / prazna- 36 kA uttara :- mukhavastrikA kA upayoga nahIM karanA, pramAda kahalAtA hai, utane mAtra se 'vaha sAdhu nahIM hai' aisA nahIM kaha sakate hai / jaise Apa ke kaI sAdhu bhI nIce dekhe binA calate hai, binA puMje - pramArje baiThate hai, ityAdi pramAda ko lekara unheM Apa kyA jinAjJA bAhya, asAdhu mAnate ho ? prazna- 37 kA uttara :- yaha prazna, prazna na hokara kevala AkSepabAjI karane svarupa hai / lekhaka ne lagAye hue AkSepa ke lie pramANa dete hue likhA ki 'prazna pramANa ke lie dekhe, zaMkAeM sahI samAdhAna nahIM - prathamAvRtti' / lekhaka kI 102

Page #107
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM" sUcanA ke anusAra 'zaMkAe~ sahI samAdhAna nahIM' isa pustikA ke pure nirIkSaNa karane para kahIM para bhI kisI para kaThora, AkSepa bhare vAkya vagairaha dekhane meM nahIM Aye haiM / vaha sthAnakavAsI bhAIyoM ke dvArA hI chapAyI gayI thii| maMdiramArgI saMtoM kI bAteM sunakara jo zaMkAe~ utpanna huI ve puchI gayI thI, paraMtu samAdhAna nahIM milane para ve zaMkAe~ hI prakAzita kI gayI hai, aisA usake prAstAvika kathana se spaSTa samajha meM AtA hai / pustikA meM kisI samAja para AkSepa nahI kiye gaye haiM, paraMtu kevala saumya bhASA meM prazna puche gaye haiM / phira usameM lekhaka ko itanA Akroza karane kI jarurata kyA huI ? uttara nahIM AtA ho to gussA karanA kyA samajhadArI kahalAtI hai ? 'apane ko cora, dhUrta - ziromaNi, Darapoka aura mahAkapaTI, prapaMcI, durmativAlA kahA jAne ke kartavya kara rahA hai' lekhaka ke ye zabda kinako lAgu paDate hai, yaha pAThaka vicAra kareM, kyoMki unhoMne hI tuccha bhASA meM tathA AkSepabharI yaha gumanAma pustikA nikAlI hai, jisameM vItarAga deva kI mUrti kI niMdA, AgamoM kI avalehanA, pUrvAcAryoM para AkSepa, sthAnakavAsI, maMdiramArgI evaM terApaMthI AcAryAdi ko gaddAra vagairaha kahane kI kuceSTA kI hai| aura aise avivekI kArya karake nAma chupAkara baiThe hai / prazna- 38 kA uttara :- * digabaMroM ke khuda ke itihAsa meM dvitIya bhadrabAhu kI bAta AtI hai, jinakA vikrama kI chuTTI zatAbdI meM astitva thA / ho sakatA hai, varAha mihira unake bhAI rahe ho aura yahAM kiMvadaMtI kAlakrama se niryuktikAra prathama bhadrabAhusvAmI se juDa gayI ho / niryuktiyoM meM bhASya kI gAthAeM mizrita ho gayI hone se, isameM milanevAlI paravartI ghaTanAoM ke ullekhoM se Adhunika itihAsakAroM ne parApUrva se suvihita paraMparA se calI A rahI niyuktikAra ke zrutakevalI hone kI mAnyatA ko uDAkara niyuktikAra ko nimittavettA dvitIya bhadrabAhusvAmI mAnane kI bAteM likhI hai / vAstava meM niryuktikAra prathama bhadrabAhusvAmI the, jabaki varAhamihira kI vArtA dvitIya bhadrabAhusvAmI saMbaMdhI lagatI hai / isa bAta kI puSTi bRhatkalpabhASya 103

Page #108
4000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 ke Amukha meM puNyavijayajI ma. ne bhI kI hai| evaM itihAsa ke isa prazna ke samAdhAna ko pAne ke lie DaoN. sAgaramala jaina ne bhI 'dazAzrutaskandha eka adhyayana' meM prayAsa kiyA hai aura niyuktikAra ko apane hisAba se AryarakSita sUrijI ke nikaTavartI (vikrama kI dusarI zatAbdI, vIra ni. 584) honA saMbhavita kiyA hai| unake kathana se bhI niyuktikAra varAhamihira se lagabhaga 400 sAla pahale hone siddha hote hai| prazna-39 kA uttara :- varAhamihira kI varAhisaMhitA ke pIche aMta meM likhA huA saMvat lekhaka svayaM nikAlakara dekha leveM / usakA koI mahattva nahIM hai / prAyaH vi.saM 562 hai| prazna-40 kA uttara :- dhanyavAda ! dhanyavAda ! itanI to Apako sadbuddhi ho gayI ki aMta meM Apane svIkAra kara liyA kI mUlasUtroM meM avirata zrAvaka evaM devoM dvArA mUrtipUjA karane kI bAta AtI hai / kyoMki Apane prazna meM 12 vratadhArI zrAvaka dvArA mUrtipUjA ke ullekha ke bAre meM puchA hai| ___ Apane 45 yA 72 Agama meM zrAvaka dvArA mUrtipUjA ke lie pATha mAMge hai, ata: Apake saMtoSa hetu sarvaprathama ubhayamAnya 32 Agama ke saMkSepa se kucha pATha diye hai, bAda meM zeSa AgamoM ke kucha pATha diye hai| lekhaka mahAzaya taTasthatApUrvaka diye jAnevAle pramANoM para vicAreM / (i) bhagavatIsUtra zataka 22, uddezA 11, meM rAnI padmAvatI aura balarAjA ne mahAbala (sudarzana zreSThI ke pUrva bhava) ke janma samaya meM mahotsava kiyA, usake varNana meM 'sae sahassIe, sayasAhassIe jAe dAe bhAe....' ityAdi likhA hai / yahA~ para 'jAe' kA artha yajJa nahIM kara sakate hai, paraMtu 'jinabhakti mahotsava' artha karanA paDatA hai, kyoMki rAnI ke lie 'devagurujaNasaMbaddhAhi kahAhiM jAgaramANI...' aisA likhA hai, ata: usake samyag dRSTi hone se 'jAe' se jinapUjA hI abhipreta siddha hotI hai / - 104

Page #109
G000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (O900 (ii) AcArAMga tRtIya cUlA, 3 bhAvanA adhyayana meM mahAvIra svAmI ke mAtA-pitA pArzvanAtha bhagavAna ke anuyAyI the, aisA likhA hai, ataH kalpasUtra meM (pIche ke prakaraNoM se dazAzrutaskandha ke 8vAM adhyayana ke rupa meM siddha) prabhuvIra ke janma mahotsava meM bhI 'sae sahasse sayasahassIe jAe dAe bhAe...' ityAdi dvArA sUcita yajJa-jinamaMdiroM meM paramAtmabhakti mahotsava siddha hotA hai| (iii) bhagavatI sUtra meM tuMgIyA nagarI ke zrAvakoM ke varNana meM 'kayabalikamme' ke dvArA jina pratimA-pUjana kA sUcana milatA hai, jisakA artha navAMgI TIkAkAra abhayadevasUrijI ne bhI kiyA hai / abhayadevasUrijI kI prAmANikatA ke lie nemicaMdajI bAMThiyA ne bhI 'vidyuta bAdara tejaskAya hai' pustaka ke pR. 74 meM likhA hai - "baMdhuo ! kahA~ Agama manISI navAMgI TIkAkAra AcArya abhayadeva sUrijI kI saralatA, nirabhimAnatA evaM utsUtra prarupaNA kA bhaya jo unake ukta udgAroM se parilakSita ho rahA hai...." (iv) Avazyaka niyukti meM zloka 490 meM 'vaggura zreSThI dvArA, mallInAtha bhagavAna kI pUjA kA ullekha milatA hai| (v) bhakta parijJA - zloka 30 meM dezaviratidhara zrAvaka aMta samaya meM punaH aNuvrata lekara apane dravya ko nUtana jina maMdira, jinabiMba Adi kI pratiSThAoM tathA prazasta pustaka, acche tIrtha evaM tIrthaMkaroM kI pUjA meM vitarita karatA hai, aisA likhA hai| "niadavyamapuvajiNiMdabhavanajiNabiMbavara paiThThAsu / viarai pasattha putthaya sutitthatitthayarapUAsu // 30 // " (vi) Avazyaka niyukti gAthA 322 meM zreyAMsakumAra ne prabhu ke pAraNA sthAna para ratnamaya pITha banAkara pUjA kI thii| Avazyaka niyukti gAthA 335 meM bAhubalIjI dvArA dharmacakra tIrtha kI sthaapnaa| | 105 - - -

Page #110
-G6000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" / 09/02 (vii) gRhastha ke lie mUrtipUjA hitakArI hotI hai, dekhiye mahAnizItha sUtra kA pATha 'tesiya tiloyamahiyANa dhammatitthagarANa jagaguruNaM bhAvaccaNa dabaccaNa bheeNa duhaccaNaM bhaNiyaM bhAvaccaNaM carittANuTThANa - kaTugga ghora tava caraNa, davbaccaNaM, virayAviraya-sIla-pUyA sakkAradANAi / to goyamA esaththe paramaththe / taM jahA, bhAvaccaNamuggavihArayAya davyaccaNaM tu jina-pUyA / paDhamA jaINa donnivi gihINa // - isa prakAra spaSTa, pUjA ke do bheda batAkara "muni ko bhAva pUjA hI hai, zrAvaka ko dravya-bhAva yaha donoM pUjA hai" isa paramArtha satya ko mahAnizItha sUtra meM batAyA gayA hai| ... (viii) gaNivijjA prakaraNa meM - - 'dhaNiTThA sayabhisA sAIssavaNo a puNavvasu / eesu gurusustUMsa ceiANaM ca pUaNaM // 1 // 'jaisI de vaisI mile, kue kI guMjAra' ___ ke lekhaka kI manodazA manovatso yuktigavIM madhyasthasyAnudhAvati, tAmAkarSati pucchena tucchAgraha mana:kapi // ___madhyastha manuSya aura kadAgrahI tucchAgrahavAle manuSya meM yaha pharka hai ki jaise gAya kA baccA, gAya kA sahajatA se anusaraNa karatA hai, vaise madhyastha vyakti kA mana sadyukti kA anusaraNa karatA hai / jabaki kadAgrahI yukti ko apanI tarapha khIMcatA hai, yAni apanI mAnI huI vastu ko siddha karane meM kuyukti dauDAtA hai, jaise koI baMdara puMcha pakaDakara gAya ko apanI tarapha khIMcatA hai| yaha anubhava guMjAra meM aneka sthAnoM para hotA hai jaise ki - (1) sapUta banane ke lie "pUrvAcArya hamAre haiM" "hama unakI saMtAna haiM" - 106

Page #111
" sAMca ko AMca nahIM " aisA kahate hai, jabaki vAstavikatA yaha nahIM hai kyoMki Age khuda hI pUrvAcAryoM kI niMdA - una para AkSepa karate hai / (2) lekhaka ne khuda ke vAstavika pUrvaja ghAsIlAlajI ko mahAn pUrvAcAryoM se bhI jyAdA mahatva dene kI koziza kI hai / jabaki unakI 32 sUtra kI TIkAe~, aneka sthalo meM pUrva TIkA - pAThoM kI kopI kI huI, kahIM para pATha parivartanavAlI - kahIM para artha parivartanavAlI aura bhADutI paMDitoM dvArA banavAyI gayI haiM / (3) guMjAra ke pR. 9 para draupadI ke dvArA kAmadeva kI pUjA aura pR. 10 para zAzvata pratimA tIrthaMkara kI nahIM hai, isakI siddhi karane kI koziza kI hai aura pR. 47 pR. 49 meM una sthaloM para pATha prakSepa ke jhUThe AkSepa diye haiM / agara ve pATha jhUThe hai to kAmadeva vagairaha artha hI kyoM kiye ? Apa artha karate ho usakA matalaba pATha sacce hai, anyathA kAmadeva vagairaha artha karane kI jarurata hI nahIM paDatI / ApakI isa ceSTA se sAmAnya vyakti bhI samajha sakatA haiM ki Apako mUrti mUrtipUjA ke prati dveSa hai, zAstroM ke prati prema nahIM hai, isalie upara batAyI kuyuktiyoM ko khIMcane kI kadAgrahI kI bhUmikA nibhA rahe ho / (4) pR. 48 se 50 meM vidvaMdvarya kalyANavijayajI ke nAma se galata bAteM peza kI hai / (5) pR. 51 'dravyapUjA bhAvapUjA' meM beImAnI se pUrvapakSa kA AdhA pATha hI peza karake pAThakoM ko bhramita karane kI koziza kI hai / (6) ' mukhavastrikA vArtA' prakaraNa meM kadAgraha se dinabhara muhapattI mu~ha para bAMdhane kI kuprathA kI siddhi meM pAThakoM ko bhramita karane hetu 17 galata pramANa peza kiye haiM / (7) apanI galata mAnyatA ke kAle cazme pahane ho to, AgamoM ko bhI 107

Page #112
-6000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 apanI tarapha khIMcane kI koziza karanI par3atI hai tathA dusarA koI artha nahIM kara sakate ho taba mUlasUtroM meM prakSepa - prakSepa kA mithyA bakavAsa karanA paDatA hai / (dekhiye usI ke pR. 45 se pR. 47) aura yuktiyoM ko bhI apanI tarapha khIMcane paDatI hai| agara lekhaka abhiniveza ke kAle cazme ko utAra kara taTastha dRSTi se vicAreM, to yaha saba karane kI AvazyakatA hI nahIM rhegii| ___ "mukhavatrikA saMvAda" jijJAsu :- matthaeNa vaMdAmi / Aja Apane pravacana meM vAyu meM asaMkhyAta jIvoM kA honA batAyA, to unakI rakSA ke lie maMdiramArgI saMta muMha para muMhapatti kyoM nahIM bAMdhate hai ? sadguru : bolane Adi ke samaya hAtha ke dvArA muMhapatti ko muMha ke Age rakhane se yatanA ho jAtI hai, ata: bAMdhane kI jarurata nahIM rahatI hai| jijJAsu :- matthaeNa baMdAmi ! agara muMhapatti bAMdhakara rakheM to, muMha ke ekadama najadIka rahatI hai, ata: vAyukAya ke jIvoM kI virAdhanA nahIM hotI hai / jabaki hAtha meM rakhI muMhapatti muMha se thoDI dUra rahatI hai, ata: vAyukAya ke jIvoM kI virAdhanA hotI hai| . sadguru : pahalI bAta to yaha hai ki, hAtha meM rakhI huI, muMhapatti bhI muMha ke ekadama najadIka raha sakatI hai tathA muMhapatti bAMdhane para bhI muMha aura muMhapatti ke bIca meM rahe hue asaMkhya vAyukAya ke jIvoM kI virAdhanA to hotI hI hai, isalie bAMdhane kI jarurata nahIM haiN| . dusarI bAta, 32 yA 45 AgamoM meM kahIM bhI mukhavastrikA ke prayojanoM meM vAyukAya kI rakSA ko nahIM batAyA hai, paraMtu saMpAtima (uDanevAle sUkSma jIva) kI yatanA ko usakA prayojana batAyA gayA hai| - jijJAsu : kalikAlasarvajJa hemacaMdrAcArya dvArA racita yogazAstra meM to vAyukAya kI yatanA ko bhI prayojana rupa meM batAyA hI hai, yaha to maMdiramArgI AcArya kA hI grantha hai| 108

Page #113
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM" meM sadguru :- kyA sthAnakavAsI saMta Adi, Agama meM muMhapatti ke prayojanoM kI rakSA ko nahIM batAye jAne para bhI, use hI vAyukAya prayojana mukhya mAnane kI apanI mahatvapUrNa dhAraNA ko maMdiramArgIoM ke granthoM ke AdhAra se hI mAnate hai ? agara aisA hai to ve 'yogazAstra' meM nirdiSTa anya bAtoM ko kyoM nahIM mAnate hai ? tathA yogazAstra meM bhI vAyukAya kI rakSA hetu 24 ghaMTe muMhapatti bAMdhanA batAyA nahIM hai / astu, yaha to kevala prAsaMgika bAta batAyI hai / yogazAstra meM bhI vAyukAya ke jIvoM kI rakSA kI bAta upaSTambhaka hetu ke rupa meM hI hai / sarvaprathama to Agama nirdiSTa mukhya prayojana rupa " saMpAtima jIvoM ( uDanevAle sUkSma jIva ) kI rakSA" ko hI batAyA hai aura ye saba prayojana hAtha meM rakhI huI muMhapatti ko muMha ke Age rakhane se bhI siddha hI hai / yogazAstra kA pATha isa taraha hai : mukhavastramapi sampAtimajIvarakSaNAduSNamukhavAtavirAdhyamAna - bAhyavAyukAyajIvarakSaNAnmukhe dhUlipravezarakSaNAccopayogi / (yogazAstra tRtIya prakAza) jijJAsu :- matthaeNa vaMdAmi ! AgamoM meM muMhapatti ke prayojanoM meM 'vAyukAya kI rakSA' ko kyoM nahIM ginA hai ? sadguru :- dekho ! vAyukAya atisUkSma evaM sarvatra vyApta hai, ata: apane vihAra, paDilehaNa Adi hara saMyama yogoM se aparihArya rUpa se unakI virAdhanA to hotI hI hai, yahA~ taka ki muMhapatti ko bAMdhakara bolA jAve, taba bhI muMha aura muMhapatti ke bIca meM rahe hue asaMkhya vAyukAya ke jIvoM kI sAmAnya rupa se virAdhanA hotI hI hai / isa kAraNa se, AgamoM meM kahIM para bhI "khule muMha bolane se yA muha Dhakakara bolane se vAyukAya kI hiMsA hotI hai, " isalie "muMhapatti bAMdho yA mauna raho aisA vidhAna nahIM kiyA gayA hai| paraMtu " " na phumejjA, na vIejjA" ityAdi ke dvArA jisameM mukhyarUpa se vAyukAya kI virAdhanA hotI hai, jaise ki 109

Page #114
60 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 phUMka denA, paMkhA vIjanA, havA khAne baiThanA (AcA. a. 1. u. 7 niyukti gA. 170) vagairaha aisI ceSTAoM ke niSedha meM vAyukAya kI rakSA ko mukhya prayojana batAyA hai| se bhikkhU vA 2 ussAsamANe vA nIsAsamANe vA kAsamANe vA chIyamANe vA jaMbhAyamANe vA uDDoe vA vAyanisaggaM vA karemANe pubbAmeva AsayaM vA posayaM vA pANiNA paripehitti tao saMjayAmeva usasijjA vA jAva vAyanisaggaM vA karejjA // (AcA. zru. 2. cU. 1 adhya. 2, u. 3 sUtra 109) . isa sUtra ke dvArA mu~ha Adi kI - kriyAoM meM hotI vAyukAya kI virAdhanA meM bolane kI kriyA ko nahIM batAyA hai| - isa prakAra bolane Adi meM vAyukAya kI sAmAnyarUpa se AnuSAMgika virAdhanA hotI rahane se AgamoM meM usakI rakSA ko muMhapatti ke prayojana meM nahIM batAyA hai, jabaki yogazAstra meM bolane Adi ke samaya meM bhI vAyukAya kI zakya yatanA ko bhI prayojana meM ginA ho, aisA samAdhAna kiyA jA sakatA hai / bAki to jJAnI kaheM vahIM pramANa / kucha bhI ho, hAtha meM rahI muMhapatti se bhI ye saba prayojana siddha hote hI hai, tathA Agama nirdiSTa zarIra kI pramArjanA Adi prayojana bhI hAtha meM rakhI muMhapatti se hI siddha ho sakate hai, bAMdhane se nhiiN| - dusarI bAta agara Agama meM vAyukAya kI hI rakSA hetu muMhapatti bAMdhane ko kahA hotA aura agara usIlie sthAnakavAsI saMta Adi usako bAMdhate hai aura usakA upadeza dete hai to phira muMhapatti kevala muMha ke Age hI kyoM bAMdhI jAtI hai ? use to nAka ke upara taka bAMdhanI cAhie kyoMki nAka se zvAsa Adi dvArA satata vAyukAya kI virAdhanA hotI hai, ata: samajha sakate hai ki _* TippaNa :- (1) se puvAmeva sasIsovariyaM kAyaM pAe ya pamAjjiya... sijjAsaMthArayaM saIjjA / (AcA.zru3,cU.1, adhya.2, u.3, sUtra 108) (2) 'hathagaM saMpamajjitthA tattha bhuMjijja saMjae' (daza.sU.adhya.5,u.1,gA. ) 110

Page #115
-6000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" 109002 vAyukAya kI rakSA ko lekara 24 ghaMTe muMhapatti bAMdhanA AgamakAroM ko iSTa nahIM hai aura vartamAna meM bhI bAMdhI jAnevAlI muMhapatti se bhI vAyukAya kI rakSA kA prayojana bhI siddha nahIM hotA hai| jijJAsu :- tahatti ! ApazrI to jJAna ke sAgara ho ! ApazrIne Agama ke pATha evaM vyavahArika dRSTAMta se saTIka samAdhAna diyA hai| sadguru :- eka prazna purcha ? burA to nahIM lagelA ? jijJAsu :- puchie ! sadguru :- kyA sthAnakavAsI saMta Adi AhAra (gocarI) karate samaya muMhapatti ko muMha para bAMdhakara rakhate hai yA use kholate hai ? jijJAsu :- kholate hI hai, kyoMki usake binA AhAra kaise grahaNa kara sakeMge ? sadguru : sahI bAta hai / hamane bhI unheM muMhapatti nikAlakara AhAra karate hue dekhA hai| ___aba dusarA prazna, agara unheM AhAra karate samaya koI kArya A jAveM to ve kaise boleMge? jijJAsu : pahalI bAta to ve mauna rakhate hoMge evaM ati jarurI prayojana Ane para hAtha yA vastrAdi ko muMha ke Age rakhakara bolate hoNge| ...sadguru : are ! ve aisA kyoM karate haiM ! Apake hisAba se unheM to hAtha evaM muMha dhokara, puna: muMhapatti ko muMha para bAMdhakara, bolakara apanA kArya nipaTAkara puna: use kholakara AhAra kriyA ko Age baDhAnA caahie| jijJAsu : aisA karanA to avyavahArika hai / AhAra karate samaya to hAtha yA vastra Adi se yatanA karanA hI ucita hai| sadguru : agara AhAra karate samaya hAtha yA muMhapatti Adi ke dvArA yatanA ho sakatI hai, to pure dina meM jaba prayojana AveM (sAmAnyata: muni mauna rakhate hai), taba muMhapatti ko Age rakhakara yatanA karane meM kyA harja hai / pure dina niSkAraNa muMhapatti bAMdhe rakhanA kyA avyahArika nahIM hai ? -

Page #116
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM " jijJAsu : ApakI bAta to sahI hai, agara AhAra ke samaya jarurI kAryavaza bolane ke lie binA muMhapatti bAMdhe, kevala hAtha yA muMhapatti ko Age rakhakara yatanA kI jA sakatI hai, to pure dina meM usI taraha karanA hI ucita hai / sadguru : dusarI bAta, koI custa sthAnakavAsI zrAvaka rAste meM jA raheM ho evaM unheM sthAnakavAsI saMta-satiyA~ mila jAyeM athavA acAnaka koI sthAnaka meM gurumahArAja ko milane kA prayojana A jAyeM to usa samaya kaise vArtAlApa kareMge ? jijJAsu : vaha zrAvaka turaMta hAtha meM rumAla lekara mu~ha ke Age rakhate hue bolegA / sadguru: agara sAmAyika binA bhI zrAvaka acAnaka bolane ke prasaMga meM muMha ke Age rumAla rakhane kA upayoga rakha sakatA hai to, sAmAyika lekara pravacana Adi sunate samaya to prAyaH mauna rakhanA hotA hai, to usa samaya muMhapatti bAMdhane kI kyA jarurata hai ? vahA~ para bhI jarurata paDane para bolate samaya muMhapatti ko muMha ke Age rakhakara yatanA kI jA sakatI hai / jijJAsu : ApazrI hara bAta ko itane sacoTa tarka evaM udAharaNoM se samajhAte ho ki turaMta dila aura dimAga meM baiTha jAtI hai / sadguru : bahuta acchA ! Apake jaise madhyastha satyAnveSI jijJAsuoM kohI Agama ke gUDha rahasya saralatA se hRdaya meM uttara jAte hai / aba dusarI bAta suno ! pure dina muMhapatti bAMdhakara rakhane meM eka apekSA seto bhAvahiMsA bhI hotI hai / jijJAsu : heM !! yaha bAta to kabhI sunI nahIM hai, jarA vistAra se samajhAne kI kRpA kareM / sadguru : (1) je AsavA te parisavA, je parisavA te AsavA / (AcArAMga sUtra) isa sUtra se AgamakAroM ne sAdhaka AtmA ke upayoga - yAni bhAvoM ke AdhAra para hI karmabaMdha yA nirjarA kA honA sUcita kiyA hai / (2) tathA 'jayaM care, jayaM ciTThe, jayaM Ase, jayaM sae,' 112

Page #117
-6000 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" D 960 jayaM bhuMjato bhAsaMto, pAvaM kammaM na baMdhar3a / (daza. 4 adhyayana) ke dvArA pramAda rahita yatanA karane vAle sAdhu ko dravya se hiMsA hone para bhI pApa-karma kA baMdha nahIM hotA hai, aisA batAyA hai| ___(3) karmasAhitya bhI isI bAta ko puSTa karatA hai, vaha isa taraha : jaba tAttvika hiMsA hotI hai, taba azAtAvedanIya karma kA baMdha hotA hai, jaba ki chaThe (pramatta) guNasthAnaka ke bAda azAtAvedanIya kA baMdha viccheda batAyA hai, yAni ki 7veM aura usake upara ke guNasthAnakoM meM tAttvika hiMsA (hetu anubaMdha) nahIM hotI hai aura pramAda hai vahA~ hetu hiMsA hone se azAtA kA baMdha hai| AgamoM meM bAta AtI hai ki kevalajJAnI bhagavaMta yA apramattamuni upayoga pUrvaka calate ho aura agara unake pairoM ke nIce kAI saMpAtima jIva A jAe to bhI unheM usakI hiMsA kA pApa nahIM lagatA hai| usI taraha zAstrokta vidhi ke anusAra hAtha se muMhapatti ko muMha ke Age rakhakara bolane meM hone vAlI vAyukAya ke jIvoM kI hiMsA meM doSa nahIM lagatA hai, yaha samajha sakate haiN| . agara pramatta sAdhaka nIce dekheM binA calatA hai aura koI jIva nahIM maratA hai, to bhI use hiMsA kA doSa lagatA hai, kyoMki vahA~ pramAda rupI bhAvahiMsA (hetu hiMsA) cAlu hai / ____ ataH pramAda hai vahA~ hiMsA hotI hai, apramAda meM ahiMsA hai / aba dekho / muMhapatti bAMdhe rakhane meM pramAda evaM jIvadayA ke pariNAma ke sAtatya kA abhAva . kisa taraha hotA hai| - jijJAsu :- kaise hotA hai ? jarA udAharaNa dekara batAyeM ! yaha bahuta gahana viSaya laga rahA hai| __sadguru : jaise koI cappala pahanakara calatA hai, use kaMTaka AdikA bhaya nahIM hone se usakA upayoga nIce dekhane meM nahIM rahatA hai / agara upAzraya - sthAnaka meM dina bhara rajoharaNa se koI pramArjana karate hue calatA hai aura nIce dekhane meM dhyAna nahIM rakhatA hai to, jIva kI hiMsA nahIM hone para bhI vahA~ IryAsamiti kA upayoga nahIM rahane se jIvadayA ke bhAva nahIM kahe jAte hai aura use pramAda hI kahA jAtA hai| 113

Page #118
" sAMca ko AMca nahIM" usI taraha pure dina muMhapatti bAMdhe rakhane meM bhI pramAda evaM jIvadayA ke pariNAma kA sAtatya bhI nahIM rahatA hai aura IsIlie aisA dekhA bhI gayA hai ki kriyA meM custa aise sthAnakavAsI saMta bhI AhAra karate samaya muMhapatti nikAlakara, muktadila se khule muMha bolate hai, jabaki maMdiramArgI kaI saMta jinheM muMhapatti kA upayoga rakhane kI apramattatA hai, ve AhAra karate samaya bhI prayojana Ane para pAnI se mu~ha ko zuddha karake muMhapatti yA vastrakhaMDa ko muMha ke Age rakhakara bAta karate hai / jijJAsu : ApakA anaMta upakAra hai, Apane merI mithyA-bhrAnti miTAyI aura mujhe anekAntavAda kI divyadRSTi pradAna kI / paraMtu, mujhe eka choTA saMzaya raha gayA hai, jo puchanA cAhatA hU~ ? sadguru : ni:zaMka pucho / jijJAsu : kaI maMdiramArgI saMtoM ko bhI muMhapatti ko muMha ke Age rakhakara bolane meM bhUla hotI rahatI hai, pramAda A jAtA hai, to kyA isa doSa se bacane ke lie muMhapatti bAMdhakara rakhane kA ApavAdika AcaraNa svIkArya nahIM ho sakatA hai ? sadguru : nahIM! kyoMki deza - kAla Adi kI viSamatA ke kAraNa apavAda kA sevana karanA vihita hai paraMtu muMhapatti bAMdhe rakhane ke lie aisI koI viSama paristhitiyAM nahIM hai, ataH vaha apavAda kA sthAna nahIM hai, tathA (1) anAbhoga Adi se, pramAda se upayoga nahIM rahanA choTA doSa hai jabaki 24 ghaMTe muMha para bAMdhane meM baDe pramAda kA doSa lagatA hai ! (2) pure dina bhara zAstranirdiSTa muMhapatti ke kaI anya kArya hote haiM, jaise ki gocarI evaM saMthArA ke pahale muMha Adi kI pramArjanA tathA hAtha, muMha Adi para cIMTI Adi sUkSmajIva A jAveM, to vahA~ rajoharaNa upayogI nahIM banatA hai, vahA~ para to muMhapatti kA hI prayoga kiyA jAtA hai| aise jIvarakSA ke prayojana, muMhapatti bAMdhI huI rakhane para siddha nahIM ho sakate hai / ata: saMyama virAdhanA kA doSa bhI lagatA hai / agara isa hetu pUjanI vagairaha rakheM to adhika upakaraNa kA doSa lagatA hai / 114

Page #119
"sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (3) sAdhu ke veza meM 'Dore se muMhapatti bAMdhanA' kisI Agama yA Agametara zAstra meM nahIM AtA hai, paraMtu hAtha meM muMhapatti rakhane kI bAta hI AtI hai / (a) 'hatthagaM saMpamajjitthA ....' (dazavai. pUadhya. gA. 83 ) 'hastakaM mukhavastrikA rupam, AdAyeti vAkyazeSa:, saMpramRjya vidhinA tena kArya tatra bhuJjIta 'saMyato' rAgadveSAvapAkRtyeti sUtrArtha: / ' (hAribhadrI TIkA) muMhapatti ke liye 'hatthagaM' zabda hI batAtA hai ki muMhapatti hAtha meM rakhane kI hai aura usIse kAyA kI pramArjanA zakya hai / (ba) tateNaM sA miyAdevI taM kaTThasagaDiyaM aNukaDDhamANI aNukaDDhamANI jeNeva bhUmighare teNeva uvAgacchai, uvAgacchittA cauppuDiNaM vattheNaM muhaM baMdheti, muMha baMdhamANi bhagavaM goyamaM evaM vayAsI - tubbhe vi NaM bhaMte ! muhapottiyAe muhaM baMdha / tate NaM se bhagavaM goyame miyAdevIe evaM vRtte samANe muhapottiyAe muhaM baMdheti / (zrI vipAkasUtraM, prathama adhyayana ) isa mUla Agama meM spaSTa batAyA hai ki mRgAdevI ne pahale khudane cArapaDa ke vastra se apane muMha ko bAMdhA aura phira gautama svAmIjI ko muMhapatti se muMha bAMdhane ko kahA hai| vyavahAra meM bhI durgaMdha se bacane ke lie muMha bAMdhate usameM muMha (do hoTha ) evaM nAMka dono DhaMka jAve usa taraha bAMdhate hai akele nAka ko nahI bAMdhate hai aura nA hI muMha (do hoTha ) Dhake ho to nAka ko DhaMkane ke lie " muMha bAMdho " aisA kahate hai apitu " nAka bAMdho" aisA hI prayoga kiyA jAtA hai, isalie 'muhaM baMdhaha' se kevala nAka bAMdhane kA kathana samajhanA bhI galata hI hai / dusarI bAta jaise mRgAvatI ke lie "muhaM baMdheti" likhA vaise gautamasvAmIjI ke lie bhI " muhaM baMdheti" hI pATha hai ata: jaise mRgAvatI kA muMha pahale khulA (DhAMke binA kA ) thA aura bAda meM muMha ko bAMdhA thA vaise hI isa mUla Agama se gautama svAmI ke muMha para muMhapatti nahIM baMdhI huI thI, yaha siddha hotA hai / (sa) Avazyaka niryukti aura TIkA meM kAussagga meM muMhapatti dAhine hAtha meM, rajoharaNa bAyeM hAtha meM rakhane kA sSTa ullekha hai, usase siddha hotA hai, 115

Page #120
" sAMca ko AMca nahIM" ki jaba bolane kI AvazyakatA nahIM taba muMhapatti bAMdhanI nahIM hai, apitu hAtha meM rakhanI hai - pATha isa prakAra hai - " cauraMgula muhapattI ujjUe Dabbahattha syaharaNaM vosaTTacattadeho kAussaggaM kahijjAvahi || 1545 // " TIkA - muMhapatti ujjue 'tti' dAhiNa hattheNa muhapotti ghettatvA Dabbahatthe raharaNaM kAyavvaM / tathA (da) "ciNhaTTA uvagaraNa dosA u bhave aciMdhakaraNammi / micchatta so va rAyA va kuNaha gAmANa vaharakaraNa || 53||" TIkA: parihavijjaM ahAjAyamuvagaraNaM ThaveyavvaM muhapottiyA, rayaharaNaM colapaTTo ya / ina donoM pAThoM se 'muMhapatti ko pAsa meM rakhanA' yahI liMga siddha hotA hai / - (2) tathA yogazAstra ke vaMdana adhikAra meM Ate 'pravrajyAkAle ca gRhItarajoharaNamukhavastrika.....' 'vAmaMgulimuhapottIkarajuyalatalatthajuttarayaharaNo .....' 'vAmakaragahiaMpottIegaTTeseNa vAmakannAo....' ina pAThoM se bhI hAtha meM muMhapattirakhanA hI zAstra sammata sAdhuliMga siddha hotA hai / hAtha meM muMhapatti rakhanA muniliMga hote hue bhI, 24 ghaMTe muMhapatti bAMdhakara hI rakhane para 'liMgabheda' kA mahAn doSa lagatA hai / isalie "jue par3a jAtI hai, to sira kATane kI mUrkhatA" nahIM karanI cAhie / (4) 'jayaM bhujaMto bhAsato,' pAvakammaM na baMdhaI dazavaikAlika sUtra kI isa gAthA meM yattrA pUrvaka bhASaNa karane kA likhA hai / so hamezA muMha baMdhA huA hove to yatnA karane kI kucha bhI jarurata nahIM rahatI, kintu haMmezA muMha khullA ho tabhI mukha kI yatnA karake bolane meM AtA hai, isaliye isa pATha se bhI hamezA mukha bandhA rakhanA kabhI siddha nahIM ho sakatA aura khullA rakhanA va 116

Page #121
Ge "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (0902 bolane kA kAma paDe taba yanA karake bolanA yahI khAsa jinAjJA hai| __se bhikkhU vA 2 ussAsamANe vA nIsAsamANe vA kAsamANe vA chIyamANe vA jaMbhAyamANe vA uDDoe vA vAyanisaggaM vA karemANe puvAmeva AsayaM vA posayaM vA pANiNA paripehittA tao saMjayAmeva asasijjA vA jAva vAyanisaggaM vA karejjA 2 // (AcA. zru. 2, cU., 1. adhya 2, u. 3, sUtra 109) / upara ke donoM pAThoM se spaSTa hai ki - jaba-jaba mu~ha khulatA hai taba mu~ha ko DhaMkanA, yaha zAstra kI AjJA hai, ata: muhapatti ko 24 ghaMTe bAMdhakara rakhane meM AjJA bhaMga kA doSa bhI hai| (5) "vastrayuktaM tathA hastaM, kSipyamANaM mukhe sadA / dharmeti vyAharaMtaM, namaskRtya sthitaMhare // " zivapurANa, jJAnasaMhitA, 29 vAM adhyAya, zloka 311 // isa prakAra zivapurANa Adi jainetara zAstra, prAcIna gurumUrtiyoM se bhI muMhapatti ko hAtha meM rakhane kI suvihita paraMparA siddha hotI hai aura vaha saMvigna paraMparA Aja bhI maujuda hai, ata: muMhapatti bAMdhe rakhane meM suvihita paraMparA ke bhaMga kA doSa bhI lagatA hai| (6) binA kAraNa mu~ha bAMdhe phiranA avyavahArika - aziSTa bhI dikhatA hai, ata: loka viruddha bhI hai, ityAdi kaI doSa muMhapatti bAMdhakara rakhane meM lagate haiN| jijJAsu : tahatti, Apane sacoTa rupa se Agama evaM zAstra pAThoM se 24 ghaMTe muMhapatti ko bAMdha kara rakhane kI pravRtti ko, Agama, evaM zAstra viruddha siddha kiyA hai| agara Apake pAsa itane pramANa maujuda hai to Apa ajJAnatA meM DubI huI bholI evaM zraddhAvaMta janatA ko kyoM nahIM samajhAte hai tathA unake sAdhuoM ko samajhAkara jainazAsana meM ekatA ko kyoM nahIM karavAte haiM ? - ___ sadguru : ApakI bhAvanA suMdara hai / pahale ke jamAne meM kaI bAra vAda hue, usameM maMdiramArgI jIte hai kaI sthAnakavAsI sAdhuoM ne puna: satya mArga kA svIkAra bhI kiyA thA / nikaTa ke kAla meM nAbhA nareza kI sabhA meM maMdiramArgI muni vallabhavijayajI aura sthAnakavAsI saMta zrI udayacaMdajI kA vAda huA thA, jisame muni vallabhavijayajI kI jIta huI, aise phaisale bhI 117

Page #122
-60 "sAMca ko AMca nahIM" (209602 maujuda hai / paraMtu vartamAna meM vAda-vivAda kA jamAnA nahIM hai aura paristhitiyA~ aisI hai ki Apake jaise koI jijJAsu AveM to unheM tattva kA bodha dene kI hI bhAvanA rahatI hai| ___ aise bhI tattva rucivAle loga hI kama hote hai / unameM bhI kucha loga hI sattvazAlI hote hai, jaise ki AtmArAmajI ma.sA. (vijayAnaMdasUrijI), gayavaramuni (jJAnasuMdarajI ma.sA.) vagaraiha jinhoMne satya kA jJAna pAne para apane mata ko choDakara satya mArga para calane kA puruSArtha kiyA hai| kucha loga aise hote hai jo satya ko samajhate hai paraMtu pravRtta galata AcaraNa ko choDa nahIM sakate hai / jaiseki vidhAnasaMta saMtabAlajI ma.sA. niDaratApUrvaka kahate hai - "mukhabaMdhana zrI lokAzAha nA samayathI zaru thayela nathI paraMtu tyArabAda thayelA svAmI lavajI nA samaya thI zaru thayela che ane e jarurI paNa nathI" (jaina jyoti tA. 18-5-1936 pR. 7) __aura terApaMthI AcArya mahAprajJajI ne bhI niSpakSatApUrvaka svIkAra kiyA hai ki muMhapatti bAMdhane kI prathA nayI cAlu huI hai / muMha para bAMdhane kI paTTI yaha 'mukhavastrikA' kA artha nahIM hai / (tattva bodha se sAbhAra uddhRta) ___ paraMtu aise niSpakSatApUrvaka satya kA anveSaNa karake usakA svIkAra karane vAle bhI kama hote hai / isalie 'samajhadAra jijJAsu hogA vaha samajhegA isI uddezya se satyamArga kA upadeza denA ucita lagatA hai| jijJAsu : Apane zata-pratizata saMtoSakArI javAba dekara merI jijJAsA ko saMtoSa diyA hai aura mujhe sanmArga kA bodha karAyA hai / Aja se maiM sAmAyika meM muMhapatti ko muMha para bAMdhugA nahIM / prAya: mauna rakhaMgA evaM prayojana Ane para hAtha se muMhapatti ko muMha ke Age rakhakara boluMgA / isameM pramAda nahIM karUMgA taki vacanatrupti evaM bhASA samiti kA sahI pAlana ho sakeMge / Apane mujhe sanmArga kA jJAna dekara mithyAtva pramAda, liMgabheda, AjJAbhaMga, saMyama virAdhanA Adi aneka doSoM se bacAva mahAna upakAra kiyA haiM, usakA atyaMta RNI rhuNgaa| matthaeNa vNdaami| (118

Page #123
amAvasya 16.06.201 calo tapodhA jAlana

Page #124
. kalpita kRti se sAvadhAna abhI-abhI hAtha meM eka banAvaTI kRti AyI hai| jisakA nAma 'samutthAna sUtra hai| trilokacaMda jaina (bhUtakAlIna / cAritra tilokamani) jisake saMpAdaka hai| 'jaisI de vaisI mile ku~e kI guMjAra pustikA kA adhikAMza meTara aMta meM pariziSTa 47 . aura 5 meM liyA hai| jisase guMjAra pustikA ke gumanAmI tIra pheMkane vAle chupe rustama bhI ye hI hone cAhie. aisA anumAna hotaa| hai| asta...1 - pustaka ke sampAdakIya' ke nirIkSaNa se cora kI dAr3hI meM tinAkA' jaisA anubhava huA hai| saMpAdaka ko khuda ko isa meM| kalpita kati kA anubhava ho rahA hai| tabhI to 'apane pUrvagraha ke kAraNa ati hozyAra koI sAdhU yaha kahe ki isameM kisI kii| upaja kA asara hai. ataH hama ise Agama rUpa meM nahIM svIkAra karate haiM, to yaha vyaktigata AgrahamAtra hai| aise vicAra prakaTa he|| phira bhI pustaka meM apane pakSa (sthAnakavAsI) kI siddhi ke kisI bhI Agama meM aMzamAtra bhI dRSTigocara na hote kalpita pATha milane / se saMpAdaka' yaha satra bhI jinavANI saMmata viSayavAlA hai, isaliye avazya sammAnanIya hai| isa prakAra likhate hai-- prAyaH ye hI saMpAdaka -guMjAra' pustaka meM bhadAhusvAmI racita aneka pramANoM se siddha kalpasUtra ko prAmANika na mAnakara kalpita mAnate hai aura abhI 100 sAla pUrva kI kalpita kati ko apane pakSa kI siddhi hotI hai. isaliye ArAma koTI meM ginte| haiN| jo apane kalpita mata kI siddhi karatA hai vaha jinavANI saMmata aura jo aphane kalpita mata kI asiddhi karatA ho (cAhe vaha gaNadhara racita satya Agama bhI kyoM na ho) vaha aprAmANika yaha saMpAdaka kA nApadaMDa kevala mithyAtva prayukta Abhiniveza bharA spaSTa dikhAI de rahA hai| samutthAna sUtra' kI racanA paddhati ko khuda saMpAdaka 12vIM se 14vIM sadI kI mAna rahe haiM, to svataH siddha hotA hai yaha viziSTa / parvadharAdi jJAnioM se racita kati nahIM hai. to Agama kaise mAna rahe haiM? sampUrNa vizva meM roDI gA~ meM bhaMDAra meM hI kevala / jIrNa prt| thI. isakI dUsarI prata kahIM para bhI nahIM hai, aisI kapolakalpita bAtoM para koI bhI taTastha vyakti vizvAsa nahIM kara sktaa| vAstavikatA yaha lagatI hai-100 sAla pUrva gaNivarya udayacaMdrajI ma. ke ziSya pa. zrI ratnacaMdrajI ko yaha prata hnumaangddh'| cAturmAsa meM prApta hi| isakA matalaba udayacaMdrajI gaNi kA 110 varSa pUrva saM. 1962 meM nAbhA rAjasabhA meM munizrI vallabhavijayajI se| mahapattI bAbata vAda huA, usameM udayacaMdajI kI burI taraha hAra huI jisakA phaisalA apanI isI pustikA meM pIche diyA huA hai| isake bAda sthAnaka vAsIoM kI apakIrti haI aura unameM se aneka sAdhu saMvegI banane lge| isaliye unhoMne 'cora koTavAla ko / DaDa nIti apanAkara ulTA pracAra cAla kiyA aura pItAMbara parAjaya' nAmaka choTI buka chaapii| usI kAla meM isa banAvaTI kati / kI utpatti huI ho, yaha saMbhava hai| isakA kAraNa yaha hai 1. kRti meM pR. 24-25-26 meM kapolakalpita daura se mu~hapattI mu~ha para bA~dhanI yaha sAdhuliMga hai, vagairaha bAteM likhI hai|| 2. 30 para 'upAsaka dazA meM AtA samyaktva kA AlAvA arihaMta ceiyAI' nikala jAe isaliye, nayA managhaData / AlAvA banAyA hai| 3.4.61-63 para tikhattA ke pATha se guruvaMdana krnaa| 4.pa. 129 para AgamoM meM aMzamAtra bhI nahIM milatA jJAnArthaka ceiya zabda dekara apane pakSa kI siddhi kI koziza kI hai| 5. pR. 175 para jinakalpI bhI hamezA muMhapara mu~hapattI bA~dhate haiN| 6.pa.201 para paramAtmA ke janmanakSatra para bhasmagraha saMkrama ke bAda bahuta saare| muni muMha para se mu~hapattI nikAlakara dravya liMgadhArI bneNge| 74 202 para bhasmagraha ke uttarane para sAdha-sAdhvI aura zrAvaka-zrAvikA kI bhI udaya-udaya pUjA hogii| 8. pa. 203 para jo prakatibhadraka bhI jIva jinapratimA nirmANa karAegA athavA usakI pratiSThA karavAegA, vaha pApakama kA baMdha kregaa| bhArekarmI jIva aise katrima-banAvaTI katiyoM ko chApakara saMsAra ko bar3hAte hai| isa arAjakatA ke kAla meM kaun-kiskaa| muMha baMda kara sakatA hai? sujJa bhavabhIru aisI bhelasela se sAvadhAna raheM!!! - bhUSaNa zAha - 1..pU. 202 para