Sambodhi 2007 Vol 31

Author(s): J B Shah
Publisher: L D Indology Ahmedabad

Page 58

ACHYUTANANDA DASH
SAMBODHI
33. In my opinion if all the arguments and points raised and discussed by the commentators
on the first sentence on W are brought together then it would be a monograph of at least
150-200 pages. 34. See W-S 1.1.1. 35. W-S II.I. 36. See an article by Pt.R.P.Tripathi in Nyayasatram, Pub. Sanskrit Parishad, Sagar. His
argument includes the following three points: (i) sasthi-samāsād upapada-samaso vipratisedhena (ii) vibhāsā sasthisamāsah
(iii) gatikārakopapadānām krdbhyah samāsavacanam viprati-sedhena 37. W-D 1.1.1. 38. pada-padartha-sambandha-jnanam vyutpattih, Sabda-sakti-graha ity arthah. See also NK.
P. 850. 39. prakrti-pratyayayoḥ bheda-jñānam vyutpattiḥ. 40. The author of Dīpika: Śivadatta Miśra says:
ननु ग्रन्थनामनिर्देशन व्युत्पत्तिवादो मया निरूपयते इति प्रतिज्ञा लभ्यते, व्युत्पत्तिवादपदार्थश्चोक्तव्यापारः, तादृशव्यापारश्च "अभेदश्च प्रातिपदिकार्थे ..." इत्यादिग्रन्थेनैव तदुपयोगितैव "स च क्वचिदभेदः क्वचिच्च तदतिरिक्त एव" इत्यादि
ग्रन्थसन्दर्भेण संबन्धद्वैविध्यमपि वक्तुमुचितम् । परन्तु शाब्दवोधे चेत्यादिग्रन्थस्तु अर्थान्तरग्रस्त एव, अप्रतिज्ञातत्वात् । 41. This is according to the sūtra of Gotamajātyākrtivyaktayaḥ padārthaḥ (NS. 2.2.68).
000