Kalpit Itihas se Savdhan

Author(s): Bhuvansundarvijay, Jaysundarvijay, Kapurchand Jain
Publisher: Divya Darshan Trust
Catalog link: https://jainqq.org/explore/032834/1

Page #1
eM namaH yathArthavAdine paramAtmane / zrI prAtmAnaMda-kamala-dAna-prema-rAmacandra-bhuvanabhAnusUri-sadgurubhyo namaH OM kalpita itihAsa sAvadhAna mImAMsaka : nyAya vizArada prAcArya zrImad vijaya bhuvana bhAnu sUrIzvarajI mahArAja sAhaba ke ziSya muni zrI bhuvanasundara vijayajI saMzodhaka evaM mArgadarzaka / navya nyAya ke prakhara vidvAn munirAja zrI jayasundara vijayajI mahArAja sampAdaka: kapUracanda jaina bhAyalApurA, aspatAla ke pIche hinDauna siTI, ( ji0 savAI mAdhopura ) rAjasthAna

Page #2
prakAzaka : divya darzana TrasTa bambaI-4 prathama saMskaraNa : 1000 1983 mUlya : 10) ru. pustaka prApti sthAna : (1) kapUracanda jaina bhAyalApurA, aspatAla ke pIche hinDauna siTI ( savAI mAdhopura ) rAja0 (2) maMtrI zrI saMbhavanAtha zve. jaina mandira prosavAla mohallA madanagaMja-kizanagar3ha (ji. ajamera ) rAja. mudraka : pAMcUlAlajI jaina kamala prinTarsa madanagaMja-kizanagar3ha (rAja.) phona : 83

Page #3
::. . . . nxx ww . viSaya sUcI sampAdakIya kapUracanda jaina [prathama ] mImAMsakIya muni bhuvanasundara vijayajI [ dvitIya ] purovacana muni jayasundara vijayajI [ tRtIya ] do zabda muni guNasundara vijayajI [caturtha ] prAkkathana tIrthaGkaroM kA janma mahotsava zAsana rakSaka deva-deviyA tIrthaGkaroM kI mAtA ke garbha meM bhI pUjanIyatA tIrthaGkara ke bAraha guNa zrI RSabhadeva kA nirvANa pora pAvana dAr3hA zrI aSTApada giri para jina mandira pUrvAcAryoM kA mahAna upakAra ArdrakumAra aura jina pratimA jarAsaMdha aura kRSNa ke bIca yuddha vaizAlI meM zrI munisuvrata svAmI kA stUpa prArya zrI zayyaM bhavasUri aura jina pratimA paramAtmA zrI neminAtha va saMhAra zrI pArzvanAthajI ko vairAgya pratimA se vairAgya kA upadeza arihaMta para prabhakti evaM pUrvAcAryoM para abahumAna aMbaDa sanyAsI aura samyagdarzana 18 dazapUrvadhara zrI vajrasvAmI ke viSaya meM pakSapAta jaina dharma aura ADambara namo baMbhIe livIe caitya yAnI jinamandira yA jinapratimA 20

Page #4
22 23 97 b4. 102 106 113 128 eka hAsyAspada kalpanA labdhinidhAna zrI gautama svAmI syAdvAda siddhAnta meM hiMsI evaM ahiMsA zrI bhadrabAhu svAmI aura uvasaggaharaM stotra jaina dharma meM samyak zraddhAkI vyApakatA anucita khuzAmada rAjA samprati ke sAtha anyAya avaMti sukumAla aura jinamandira pUjya zrI devaddhigaNi kSamAzramaNa mathurA ke kaMkAlI Tole kI khudAI bhaktAmara aura kalyANa maMdira stotra jaina dharma meM mUrtipUjA aura prAcIna zilAlekha sthAnakapaMthI samAja meM itihAsa kI kamI / pariziSTa-mUrtipUjA meM zAstroM kI sammati .... 135 138 0 142 0 147 33 152 157

Page #5
3888888888888888888888608 80030038 888560380868500 0 206800521005000000000000000 0200500033900000 86580003 yugAdideva zrI AdIzvara bhagavAna delavAr3A [ mAunTa AbU ]

Page #6
_

Page #7
K00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000QQQQQQOQQQQQ SORRE 0000000000 205838003000000000000530 0000000000MMAWA000 0mintwwwwxwwwwww 8000000000000000000000000000000000000 800300333333 & 0000 &00000000000000 3888830888 388888888 OM ninto Anon 200880500058883 82833 &0000000 .... . 300000000000 88888888888888888000 10030 038888880 8 SENA 2285530582800103003888888888889336 2012 S33000 h wa0000000000000000000000 608600000000000000000000 8888888888888888888888888338 800000000000000000000000000 20000000000000000000000 13800000000000 0 63068000000000000000 330 203930008880030038888888888888822880 800000 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 &0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 8 1000000000000000 8800388856000003383 3600000588803853 8300000000000005888888836333333390030038866 3003009380030038 889390208 0060 88888888 8880330003 &00000000000000 Pc0523000000000222880500020558550508888888888888888860 33 330000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 386 & 000000 pravacana prabhAvaka vardhamAna taponidhi pUjyapAda prAcAryadeva zrImad vijaya bhuvana bhAnusUrIzvarajI mahArAja

Page #8
_

Page #9
sampAdakIya kAca ke ghara meM rahane vAlA jaba anya ke phaulAdI mahala para patthara uThAtA hai, taba vaha svayaM ko surakSita samajhane kI bar3I bhUla karatA hai / ThIka isI prakAra mUrtipUjA jaise zAzvata jaina prAcAra ke sAmane patthara pheMkane kI anucita ceSTA sthAnakavAsI sampradAya ke prabaraNI AcArya zrI hastImalajI mahArAja ne kI hai| . prAcArya zrI ne "jaina dharma kA maulika itihAsa khaMDa 1 aura 2" likhakara Agama zAstroM, pAgametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya, purAtattva sAmagrI, vidyamAna hajAroM jaina tIrthoM aura lAkhoM jina mUrtiyoM ko jhUThA karane kA dussAhasa kiyA hai / jisase jaina samAja ko bahuta pAzA aura apekSA hai aise vidvAn DA0 narendra bhAnAvata bhI aisI nimna kakSA kI pustaka chapavAne meM sAtha-sahakAra dete haiM taba kheda hotA hai| 108 se bhI adhika ziSyoM ke guru evaM 108 vardhamAna tapa mAyaMbIla kI aolI ke ArAdhaka nyAya vizArad pUjya prAcAryazrI vijaya bhuvana bhAnusUrijI mahArAja sAhaba ke ziSyaratna munirAjazrI bhuvana sundara vijayajI mahArAja sAhaba ne bhAcArya zrI hastImalajI mahArAja dvArA likhita "jaina dharma kA maulika itihAsa" jo satya tathya se rahita hone ke kAraNa sarvathA amaulika aura kalpita hai, para sundara momAMsATIkA racakara prabuddha jaina samAja ke sAmane reDa lAITa dikhAyI hai, jo

Page #10
atyanta stutya hai| "mUrtipUjA Agamika hai" aisA pariziSTa jor3akara munizrI ne mImAMsA ko prAmANita bhI kiyA hai| prAcIna sAkSya upalabdha hote hue bhI mUrtipUjA jaise viSaya ko vivAdAspada banAye rakhanA azobhanIya kRtya hai / prAcArya zrI dvArA racita itihAsa purAtattva aura zodha ke vidyArthiyoM ko mArga darzana dene meM bilkula asamartha hai| isako jaina dharma kA itihAsa kase kahA jA sakatA hai ? ... jaina zAstroM meM mUrtipUjA ke viSaya meM hajAroM-lAkhoM ullekha maujUda haiM / "prazna vyAkaraNa" nAmaka prAgama sUtra meM caitya yAnI jina mandira kI vaiyAvacca-bhakti karma nirjarA kA kAraNa hai aisA kahAM hai| vaSA Xxx atyanta bAla dubbala, gilANa vuDDha sarvaka / ... . kulagaNa saMgha ceiya? ca NijjaraTThI // 408 bhAvArtha-prati bAla, durbala, glAna, vRddha, tapasvI, kula-gaNa (sAdhu samudAya ). caturvidha saMgha aura caitya yAnI jina mandira-jina pratimA kI vaiyAvacca ( sevA-bhakti ) nirjarA ( karmakSaya ) kAraka hotI hai| vyavahAra sUtra meM yAvat jinapratimA ke samakSa bhI pApa kI mAlocanA karane ko kahA hai, yathA 80xjatyeva sammamaciyAi ceiyAI paannijjaa| kappa sesassa saMtie Aloittae vaa||80 bhAvArthaH-prAcArya prAdi bahuzruta gIlArtha kA saMyoga na mile / to "cejhyA" yAnI jina pratimA ke samakSa jAkara mAlocanA ( pApa ko pragaTa ) karanI caahie|

Page #11
- 10 pUrvadhara maharSi tattvArtha sUtra racayitA bhagavAna zrI umAsvAti mahArAja "tattvArtha sUtra kArikA" meM likhate haiM kixxx abhyarcanAdarhatAM manaH prasAdastataH samAdhizca / / tasmAdapi niHzreyasamato hi tatpUjanaM nyAyyam // xx arthAt-zrI arihaMta paramAtmA kI abhyarcanA karane se mana kI prasannatA, mana ke prasAda se samAdhi aura samAdhi se niHzreyasa mokSa prApta hotA hai| isaliye sabhI mumukSu AtmAoM ko arihaMta kI pUjA avazya karanI cAhie, yaha nyAya saMgata evaM ucita hai| - zAstroM meM itanI spaSTa bAta hote hue bhI prAcArya zrI ne svayaM ko ajJAna hI rakhanA cAhA hai| unake dvArA racita itihAsa ko sabase nirbala kar3I yaha rahI hai ki unhoMne sAre itihAsa meM kahIM bhI " caitya" ( yAnI jinamandira yA jina pratimA ) zabda kA zAstra yA koSa-vyAkaraNa se artha hI nahIM kiyA hai| phira bhI unhoMne "caityavAsa" prAdi kI carcA calAyI hai, jo sarvathA nirarthaka hI hai| . mUrtipUjA meM mAnambara evaM hiMsA kahane vAle ye 'loma svayaM bhArI prADambara racate aura apane gurutroM ke pagaliyA evaM smRti mandira prAdi banavAne kI hiMsA bhI karate haiN| apanI tasvIra chapavAkara paura baTavAkara ye gRhasthoM ke ghara meM bhI apanA sthAna surakSita rakhane lage haiN| tIrthaGkara bhagavAna ke janma kalyANaka prAdi mahotsavoM ko ThATha se manavAne meM prADambara mAnane vAle ye munigaNa svayaM kI janma jayaMti dila aura dimAga pUrvaka bar3e ADambara ke sAtha manavAte haiM, svayaM kI tasvIra yukta bar3I bar3I patrikAe~ chapavAte haiM, guruke janma dina para hajAroM loga ikaTTha hote haiM, sarasa mAla milatA hai aura mauja majA ur3Ate haiN| mUrtipUjA virodhI ye loga svayaM ke guru kI tasvIra vAle lokeTa aura cAMdI ke siSake prAdi bhI bAMTate haiM, nija guru ko nimrantha paramparA ke viruddha

Page #12
hajAroM rupayoM kI thailI arpaNa kI jAtI hai| guru ke nAma para hajAroM bhaktoM ke liye sarasa bhojana prAdi ke prArambha-samArambha rUpa mahA hiMsA, ve bhakta niyama baddha na hone se rAtri bhojana kA pApa evaM ThATha-prADambara saba kucha hotA hai, sirpha bhagavAna mahAvIra kA nAma, bhagavAna mahAvIra kI prAjJA aura bhagavAna mahAvIra kI pratimA-tasvIra hI kahIM nahIM dikhAI detI ! anya ke prAgama kathita zAstrIya dharma anuSThAnoM ko ADambara aura hiMsA kahane vAloM ke liye yaha saba atyaMta lajjAspada hai| prAcArya zrI se yahI prArthanA hai ki prAge zAyada ve "jainadharma kA maulika itihAsa-khaMDa-3" likheMge, taba satya likheM jisase sAmpradAyika dveSa mAdi bar3he nahIM aura samaya evaM sampatti kA durupayoga na hove| "kalpita itihAsa se sAvadhAna" nAmaka isa mImAMsA ke liye navyanyAya ke prakhara vidvAn munirAja zrI jayasundaraM vijayajI mahArAja ne "purovacana" evaM vidvAn munirAja zrI guNasundara vijayajI mahArAja ne " do zabda" likha diye haiM, jinakA yogadAna kabhI bhI bhulAyA nahIM jA sktaa| - pUjya prAcArya zrImad vijaya vikramasUrijI mahArAja sAhaba aura pUjya prAcArya zrImad vijaya bhuvanabhAnusUrijI mahArAja sAhaba kA mere para vizeSa upakAra aura kRpAdRSTi rahI hai, jisake kAraNa hI merI tabiyata ThIka na hote hue bhI prastuta grantha kA sampAdana kArya maiM kara sakA huuN| / - zvetAmbara mUrtipUjaka jaina saMghako vinatI hai ki pUjya prAcArya zrI vijayAnandasUrijI (mAtmArAmajI mahArAja ) likhita "samyaktva zalyoddhAra", pUjya bhAcArya zrI labdhisUrIzvarajI mahArAja racita

Page #13
"mUrtimaMDana", itihAsajJa munirAja zrI jJAnasundara vijayajI mahArAja racita "mUrtipUjA kA prAcIna itihAsa", pUjya panyAsa pravara zrI bhadraMkara : vijayajI gaNi mahArAja racita "pratimA pUjana" prAdi pustakoM kA pracAra prasAra karanA-karavAnA atyanta prAvazyaka hai| munirAja zrI bhuvanasundara vijayajI mahArAja dvArA likhita isa mImAMsA pustaka dvArA bhavikajana mUrtipUjA viSayaka satya mArgadarzana pAveMge yahI prAzA hai| isa pustaka ke mudraNa meM divya darzana TrasTa evaM zvetAmbara jaina mUrtipUjaka saMgha [ madanagaMja ] kA sarAhanIya dravya-yogadAna rahA hai, jisakA maiM atyaMta AbhArI huuN| pustaka meM rahI truTiyoM kI saba jimmedArI merI hai| . pAThakagaNa isako sAdara svIkAra kareMge aura satya ke najadIka pAyeMge yaha prAzA karatA hUM / pAThakoM se nivedana hai ki isa pustaka para jo bhI mApakI rAya ho vaha nimnalikhita pate para bhejane kI kRpA kreN| patA :bhAyalApurA aspatAla ke pIche hinDauna siTI [ji0 savAImAdhopura] ( rAja0 ) kapUracanda jaina di0 11-10-1983 . prAsoja sudI paMcamI

Page #14
mImAMsakIya . lohAmaMDI prAgarA se chapI svAdhyAya kI kitAba "maMgalavANI" jisakA saMkalana sthAnakamArgI akhileza muni ne kiyA hai, isa kitAba ke gyAraha saMskaraNa dvArA mAja taka jisakI 60 hajAra se bhI jyAdA pratiyAM mudrita ho cukI hai / isa kitAba meM "bRhad zAMti" nAmaka stotra ko saMkSipta karake chapavAyA gayA hai| yAnI mUrtipUjA samarthaka pAThoM ko mAge pIche se haTAkara "bRhad zAMti" ko saMkSipta kara diyA hai| sthAnakamArgI amolaka RSi ne unake mAne hue 32 AgamoM kA hindI anuvAda kiyA hai / zrI rAjapraznIya sUtra meM devatA dvArA jina pratimA pUjana kA varNana pAyA hai, vahAM dhUpa dene ke viSaya meM mUlapATha yaha hai ki.......... "dhUvaM dAuNaM jiNavarANaM" TIkA-dhUpaM datvA jinavarebhyaH / pArzvacandra sUrikRta TabbA-dhUpa dIdhu jinarAja ne / lokAgacchiyoM kI mAnyatA-dhUpa diyA jina bhagavAna ko| kintu sthAnakapaMthI amolaka RSi ne zrI rAjapraznIya sUtra kathita pATha ko parivartana karake likha diyA hai ki "dhUvaM dAuNaM paDimANaM" . paura artha kiyA-"dhUpa diyA pratimA ko|" phira pratimA kA artha jinapratimA na karake kAmadeva kI pratimA kara diyA hai| mUla

Page #15
zAstroM meM aura unake bhASAntara meM ina mahAzaya ne aneka sthalapara unakI mAnyatA ke anukUla parivartana kiye haiM tathA jI cAhA manamAnA artha kiyA hai, phira bhI pUrvAcAryoM ko jhUThA karate hue ve "zAstroddhAra mImAMsA" mAmaka pustaka meM likhate haiM ki xxxzrI jaina dharma pracArArtha zrI mahAvIra svAmIjI ke nirvANa ke 1242 varSa meM zailAMgAcArya ne AcArAMga aura sUyagaDAMga kI TIkA banAI, 1590 varSa pIche abhayadevasUri ne sthAnAMga se vipAka paryanta 9 aMga kI TokA banAI, isake bAda malayagiri AcArya ne rAjapraznIya, jIvAbhigama, panavaNA, candraprajJapti, sUryaprajJapti, vyavahAra aura naMdIjI ina 7 sUtra ko TIkA banAI, candrasUrijI ne nirayAvalI kA paMcaka kI TIkA banAI, aise hI abhayavevasUri ke ziSya malladhArI hemacandrAcArya ne anuyonadvAra kI TIkA banAI, kSemakIrtijI ne bRhatkalpa ko TIkA ko, zAMtisUrijI ne zrI uttarAdhyayanajI kI. vRtti-TIkA-bhASya-cUNikA-niyukti vagairaha sahita savistAra bnaayaa| ina TIkAkAroM ne aneka sthAna mUla sUtra kI apekSA rahita va vartamAna meM svataH kI pravRtti ko puSTa karane jaise manaH kalpita artha bhara diye|xxx .. . sthAnakavAsI mahA paNDita zrImAn ratanalAla jI DozI ( zailAnA vAle ) ne "jainAgama viruddha mUrtipUjA-khaMDa-1" nAmaka pustaka meM cAraNa muniyoM kA nandIzvara prAdi dvIpa meM tIrthayAtrA hetu jAne ko saira-sapATA batAyA hai| yathA xxx hamAre vicAra se [ cAraNamunikA ] vahAM jAne kA mukhya kAraNa naMdana vana kI saira karane kA hI ho sakatA hai, kyoMki yaha bhI eka chamasthatA kI palaTatI huI cambala vicAra dhArA kA pariNAma hai|xxx ....... prAcIna prAcAryoM ke prati prazraddhA vyakta karate hue sthAnakavAsI samAja ke karmadhAra prAcArya hastImala jI "jainadharma kA maulika itihAsa" meM likhate haiM ki

Page #16
xxx isa prakAra bahuta-sI camatkArika rUpa se citrita ghaTanAoM ko bhI isa graMtha meM samAviSTa nahIM kiyA gayA hai| madhyayugIna aneka vidvAna granthakAroM ne siddhasena prabhRti katipaya prabhAvaka AcAryoM ke jIvana caritra ko Alekhana karate hue unake jIvana kI kucha aisI camatkAra pUrNa ghaTanAoM kA ullekha kiyA hai, jina para Aja ke yuga ke adhikAMza cintaka kisI bhI dazA meM vizvAsa karane ko udyata nahIM hote| Xxx yahI prAcArya apanI "siddhAnta praznottarI" kitAba ke pR0 16 para likhate haiM ki xxx kucha loga kahate haiM ki-bharatajI ne marIci ko hone vAlA tIrthakara jAnakara vandana kiyA, aisA TIkA meM AtA hai| ThIka hai, yaha bAta kathA meM hai para zAstra meM nahIM hone se pramANa koTi meM nahIM mAnI jaatii| sthAnakapaMthI mata pravartaka lokAzAha ke viSaya meM sthAnakavAsI paNDita zrImAn vADIlAla motIlAla zAha-apanI "aitihAsika noMdha" meM likhate haiM ki maiM isa bAta ko aMgIkAra karatA hUM ki mujhe milI huI loMkAzAha viSayaka hakIkatoM para mujhe vizvAsa nahIM hai / tathA xxx [ lokAzAha ke cAritra ke viSaya meM hama abhI aMdhere meM hI haiM ] lokAzAha kauna the? kaba hue ? kahAM kahAM phire ? ityAdi bAteM Aja hama pakkI taraha se nahIM kaha sakate haiN| jo kucha bAteM unake bAre meM sunane meM AtI haiM, unameM se mere dhyAna meM mAnane yogya ye jAna par3atI haiN| aitihAsika noMdha pR0 56 xxx mAge ve lokAzAha ke viSaya meM likhate haiM ki xxx para isa taraha kA ullekha unake nirguNe bhaktoM ne kahIM nahIM kiyA ki lokAzAha kisa sthAna meM janme ? kaba unakA dehAnta huA ? unakA ghara saMsAra kaise calatA thA ? ve kisa sUrata ke the ? unake pAsa kauna-kauna

Page #17
zAstra the ? ityAdi ityAdi hama kucha nahIM jAnate haiN| . aitihAsika noMdha pR0 87] 888 sthAnaka mata ke prAdya pravartaka lokAzAha ke viSaya meM isa prakAra kA aMdhakAra hote hue bhI yadi koI vyakti apane mAnya puruSa ke prati prazaMsAoM kA pahAr3a khar3A kara de yA upamAoM kA sAgara sukhA de to hameM kucha bhI prApatti nahIM hai, kintu jaba ve hamAre prApta, mAnya, mahAna upakArI, mahAna jJAnI pUrvAcAryoM ko zithilAcArI kaheM, pApadharma ke pravartaka kaheM taba aise jaghanya kRtya kAraka ke sAmane zAMta kaise baiThA jA sakatA hai ? sthAnakavAsI sampradAya ke jAne mAne prAcArya hastImalajI ne 'paTTAvalI prabandha saMgraha" meM likhA hai ki xxx vIra nirvANa (pazcAt ) 628 meM aura vikrama saMvat 412 ke vaizAkha zuklA 3 ke dina pratimA kI sthApanA huI / 36 varSa taka arthAt 448 kI sAla taka kAgaja para bhagavAna kI tasvIra banAkara pUjana karate aura usa para kezara ke chIMTe ddaalte| isase tasvIra kA AkAra chipane lgaa| taba liMgadhArI ratana guru ne vicAra kara kASTa kI pratimA kraaii| saMvat 448 ke mAgha zuklA 7 se kASTha ko pratimA pUjI jAne lgii| 49 varSa taka yaha prathA calatI rhii| phira guruoM ne vicAra kiyA ki kASTha kI pratimA nitya pakSAla karane se gIlI rahatI hai, usameM phUlana A jAtI hai, isalie yaha ThIka nahIM hai|xxx [AcArya hastImalajI kA jhUTha dekho ki ve kAgaja para bhagavAna kI tasvIra banAkara pUjane kI bAta likhate haiM jabaki bhAratavarSa meM usa samaya kAgaja kA pracalana hI nahIM thaa| prAge ve kalpita evaM hAsyAspada bAteM likhate haiM ki-] xxx taba ( liMgadhArI guru ne) saMvata 497 (cAra sau satAnave ) kI sAla caitra zuklA 10 ko maMdira meM pASANa kI pratimA sthApita kii|

Page #18
10 dhAtu kI mUrtiyAM banane lgii| logoM ko AkarSaNa bar3hAne ko prabhAvanA, nATaka aura svAmI vAtsalya Adi cAlU kie / isa prakAra saM0 882 meM hiMsA dharma prakaTa huA, usakA jora bddh'aa|xxx xxx zithilAcArI sAdhuoM ne zAstroM ko bhaMDAroM meM rakhakara nayI racanA cAlU kI / ve kAvya, zloka, stuti aura bhASA kI racanA manapasanda saMskRta va prAkRta bhASA meM karane lge| caupAI, kavitta, dohA, gAthA, chanda, gIta Adi aneka prakAra kI jor3e kara logoM ko sunAte, jinendra deva kI AjJA kA lopa kara hiMsA dharma kI puSTi karate aura rAta meM jAgaraNa karavAte tathA pustakoM kI pUjA karavAte, bAjA bajavAte, gIta gavAte aura pUjya kahAte hue pAMva maMDavAkara sarasa mAla khAte the|xxx . 444 jinendra pUjA ke nimitta nahAnA, dhonA aura chale ( dulhe kI taraha ) bane rahanA tathA pUjA ke liye phala, phUla, vanaspati Adi tor3ane kI vyavasthA dekara hRdaya ke dayA-bhAva ko ghaTA diyaa|xxx xxx vIra saM0 882 meM bAraha varSIya dukAla pdd'aa| usa samaya zrI pAlitAcArya zuddha saMyamI hue| Apa dUra dezoM meM saMyama guNa sahita vicarane lge| pIche se kaI mahApuruSoM ne saMthArA kara liyaa| koI eka bhavatArI hue| jo kAyara the ve zithilAcArI hue| bhikhAriyoM se pRthvI bhara gii| khAne ko pUrA anna nahIM miltaa| taba zrAvaka loga kivAr3a jur3e hue rakhate the| taba zrAvakoM aura zithilAcAriyoM ne yaha niyama bAMdhA ki dvAra para Akara dharmalAbha kahanA / isa saMketa se kivAr3a kholakara AhAra vaharA deMge / astu / aisA hI hone lgaa| bhikhArI loga ina sAdhuoM se rAste meM AhAra pAnI chIna lete the| sAdhuoM ne socA muhapattI apanI pahacAna hai so ise utArakara hAtha meM le lo| bolate samaya muha ko lagAkara boleNge| isa rIti se unheM kucha dina ArAma milaa| bhikhArI inakI cAla ko samajhakara phira, AhAra lUTane lge| taba inhoMne bhI

Page #19
hAtha meM DaNDA pakar3A / uNDe ko dekhakara bhikhArI Darane lge| isa bhAMti inhoMne dharma ko kalaMkita kara galA xxx zrI pAlItAcArya bhI deza meM padhAre / taba sAdhuoM kA patita AcAra dekhakara unheM smjhaayaa| parantu mithyAtva ke udaya na samajhe / Xxx xxx inhoMne (zithilAcAriyoM ne ) apanI pUjA ke liye coMtarA, caitya, pagalyA, maMdira, deharA baMdhavAye / alaga-alaga gaccha baMdhI krii| dharma ke DoMgI bane / xxx xxx AcArya, RSi, muni, Adi zabdoM ko tor3akara vijaya, sUri, panyAsa, yati Adi zabdoM ko jor3ane lge| 888 sthAnakapaMthI prAcArya hastImalajI ne ukta duHssAhasa pUrNa mAkSepa zvetAmbara mUrtipUjaka jainAcAryoM Adi para kiyA hai / isake viSaya meM zvetAmbara mUrtipUjaka samAja ko jo bhI ucita ho karanA cAhie evaM jaina samAja kI ekatA ke premI ( ! ) "jaina itihAsa samiti" [lAla bhavana, caur3A rAstA, jayapura-3 ] para virodha sUcaka patra bhI likhamA cAhie / inhIM prAcArya dvArA racita dUsarI pustaka "jainadharma kA maulika itihAsa khaMDa-1 aura 2" hai, jisameM bhI aisI hI sAmpradAyika kaTutA ubhArane vAlI aura zAstra nirapekSa managhaDaMta bAteM bharI par3I haiN| inake itihAsa kI kalpita aura jhUTha kucha bAteM prastuta haiM / . sagara cakravartI ke 60 hajAra putroM kI praSTApadajI tIrtharakSA meM mauta huI thI, isa para ve likhate haiM ki xxx saMbhava hai, purANoM meM zatAzvamedhI kI kAmanA karane bAle sagara ke yajJAzva ko indra dvArA pAtAla loka meM kapilamuni ke pAza bAMdhane jora

Page #20
12 sagara putroM ke vahAM pahuMcakara kolAhala karane se kapilaRSi dvArA bhasmasAt karane kI ghaTanA se prabhAvita ho jainAcAryoM ne aisI kathA prastuta ko ho|xxx janazAsanonnati kAraka mahAna rAjA zrI saMprati ke viSaya meM ve likhate haiM ki 444 zvetapASANa kI kohanI ke samIpa gAMTha ke AkAra ke cinhavAlI pratimAeM jaina samAja meM prasiddha rahI hai aura una sabhI kA sambandha rAjA saMprati se sthApita kiyA jAtA hai| aisI pratimAoM ke aneka sthAnoM para pratiSThApita hone kA ullekha bhI kiyA gayA hai| merI vinamra sammati ke anusAra ye zvetapASANa kI pratimAeM samprati athavA mauryakAla kI to kyA taduttaravartI kAla kI bhI nahIM kahI jA sktii|xxx xxxjahA~ taka jaina mUrti-vidhAna evaM upalabdha purAtana avazeSoM kA prazna hai, yaha binA kisI saMkoca ke kahA jA sakatA hai ki rAjA saMprati dvArA nirmita maMdira yA mUrtiyA~ bhAratavarSa ke kisI bhI bhAga meM Aja taka upalabdha nahIM ho pAI haiN| 8xx ArdrakumAra ke viSaya meM ve likhate haiM ki xxx abhayakumAra ne anAryadezastha apane pitA ke mitra anArya nareza ke rAjakumAra (Ardra kumAra ) ko dharmapremI banAne ke liye dharmopagaraNa (?) kI bheMTa bhejii|xxx karIba 2 hajAra pRSTha ke "jainadharma kA maulika itihAsa khaMDa1, khaMDa-2" meM aisI aThapUrNa evaM kalpita aneka bAteM prAcArya hastImalajI ne likhI haiM / aise managhaDaMta itihAsa ko "maulika" kaise kahA jA sakatA hai ? evaM isako "jainadharma kA itihAsa" kahanA bhI asatya aura anyAya pUrNa hI hai|

Page #21
- 13 prAcArya dvArA racita kalpita itihAsa ke uttara meM maiMne yaha mImAMsA dvArA yatkiMcit prayatna kiyA hai| prabuddha aura vijJajanoM ko isa viSaya meM vizeSa prayatna karane kI atyanta AvazyakatA hai| zvetAmbara mUrtipUjaka jaina samAja meM vidyamAna saiMkar3oM suvihita mahAsaMyamI paMcAcAra pAlaka-prasAraka prAcArya bhagavaMtoM ke pavitra kara kamaloM meM merI yaha tuccha racanA samarpaNa karatA hUM evaM una pUjya prAcArya bhagavaMtoM se karabaddha savinaya nivedana karatA hUM ki sthAnakapaMthiyoM kI kupravRttiyoM ke prati Apa kucha soceN| siddhAnta mahodadhi sva0 prAcArya deva zrImad vijaya premasUrIzvarajI mahArAja sAhaba ke vidvAn ziSyaratna, 108 vardhamAna tapaprAyaMbIla kI aolI ke prArAdhaka, 108 se bhI adhika ziSya-praziSyoM ke saMyamamArgadarzaka aura pravartaka, nyAyavizArada mere pUjya gurudeva zrImad vijaya bhuvanabhAnusUrIzvarajI mahArAja sAhaba kI isa mImAMsA-pustaka kI racanA meM niHsIma kRpA rahI hai, jinakI amidRSTi se hI yaha mImAMsA pustaka prastuta hai| prAgamajJa, gItArtha mUrdhanya, pUjya panyAsa zrI jayoghoSa vijayajI gaNi mahArAja sAhaba ke ziSya ratna navyanyAya ke prakhara vidvAna munirAja zrI jayasundara mahArAja sAhaba kI jJAnadAna dvArA mujha para apAra kRpA rahI hai, jinhoMne prastuta mImAMsA pustaka kI pAMDulipi ko jA~cakara aneka pratyaMtopayogI sUcana karake apUrva mArgadarzana diyA hai, sAtha hI sAtha ina saMyamI mahApuruSa ne 'purovacana' svarUpa prastAvanA likhakara pratyanta upakAra bhI kiyA hai| vidvAn munirAja zrI guNasundara vijayajI mahArAja sAhaba ne bhI "do zabda" likhane dvArA mere prati apAra vAtsalya pragaTa karake bahuta upakAra kiyA hai|

Page #22
- prastuta grantha kA vidvattApUrNa sampAdana karane vAle suzrAvaka zrI kapUracandajI jaina (riTAyarDa tahasIladAra) kA sarAhanIya sahayoga rahA the dhanyavAda ke pAtra haiM / zrI jaina zvetAmbara mUrtipUjaka saMgha-madanagaMja evaM divya darzana TrasTa ne Arthika sahayoga dekara sukRta lAbhArjana kiyA hai, vaha anumodanIya hai| mudraka sajjana zrI pAMcUlAlajI jaina ko sahRdayatA bhI dhanyavAda ke pAtra haiN| prastuta pustaka ke dvArA mAtmArthI sAdhaka mUrtipUjA sambandhita tathya satya ko jAne-mAne aura prAtmazreya sAdhe aisI zubhASA hai / 2-10-13 prosavAlI mohallA zrI zve.jaina maMdira.madanagaMja (ji.-ajamera) rAjasthAna bhuvana sundara vijaya

Page #23
purovacana kadAcit koI pUcha le ki "gagana meM sUrya-candra camakate haiM"isameM kyA pramANa ? zAstra meM kahAM likhA hai ? anAdikAla se to vaha nahIM thA aba yakAyaka kahAM se pA gayA ? kaunase prAptapuruSoM ne sUryacandra kA pracAra kiyA ? sUrya-candra kI mAnyatA adhikatara kitanI prAcIna hogI? una mAnyatA meM pIche se kyA-kyA parivartana humA ? maadi-praadi| . .. aho! ye prazna kitane gahare haiM, kitane kaThina haiM ? koI sAmAnya puruSa kI guMjAIza hai kyA aise praznoM ke uttara dene kI ? aise tAttvika (!)prazna karane vAloM ko to hAtha jor3akara yahI kahanA par3egA, bhAI ! tumhAre prazna bahuta gahana haiM, koI sarvajJa hI unakA samAdhAna kara sakatA hai| ThIka isI prakAra 16vIM zatAbdI meM jaina zAsana meM mUrtipUjA ke gahana viSaya meM bhI aise hI praznoM kI paramparA bana gyii| bahuta se dhuraMdhara paNDitoM ne una praznoM ke uttara dene kA sAhasa kiyA, lekina praznakartA varga ko saMtoSa ho aisA una tAttvika (!) aura prati gahana (!) praznoM kA samAdhAna kauna kare ? Akhira una logoM ne mAna liyA-matipUjA galata hai, azAstrIya hai, Adhunika hai, usameM kisI prAptapuruSoM kI sammati nahIM hai| / basa ! eka nayA sampradAya bana gayA, kucha nAma rakha liyA, kucha veSa banA liyA, jhukane vAle mila gaye jo jhukAne vAloM kI tarakIba

Page #24
16 yA zarama se chUTa na paae| kucha zAstra mAna bhI lie, to kucha unakI managaDhaMta mAnyatAoM ke pratikUla the unako chor3a diyA, naye bhI zAstra kucha banA lie| ho gayA, bhagavAna mahAvIra kI mUrti ko hI chor3a diyA, nAma lene ke adhikAra ko to bar3e cAva se surakSita rkhaa| itihAsa ke panne mata ulaTAmo, usameM to jahAM kahIM mUrtipUjA kA hI samarthana milegaa| itihAsa bhI una logoM ne nayA hI banA liyA, jisameM se mUrtipUjA ko nikAla diyaa| are ! mUrtipUjA ! tUne kyA aisA aparAdha kiyA thA una logoM kA, jisase tere nAma se ve loga kAMpa uThate haiM, etarAjI rakhate haiN| hAM ! vikrama kI sAtavIM zatAbdI taka kisI anArya ne bhI tere khilApha eka laphja bhI nahIM nikAlA thaa| 1300-1400 varSa pUrva sabase pahile araba deza meM mohammada paigambara ne terA bahiSkAra kara diyA, hAM usake pAsa samaseroM kI bar3I tAkata thii| vi0 saM0 1544 ke nikaTavartI upAdhyAya zrI kamalasaMyamajI likhate haiM ki usa paiyagambara kA anuyAyI phirojakhAna bAdazAha dillI ke takhta para mArUr3ha hokara mandira mUrtiyoM ko tor3ane lgaa| idhara usI kAla meM lokAzAha nAmaka eka jaina gRhastha prapa. mAnita hokara saiyada se jA milA aura una mlecchoM ke kusaMga se mUrtipUjA kA jora zora se virodha karane lgaa| jaina zAsana meM mUrtipUjA ke khilApha vidroha karane vAlA yaha prathama hI thaa| musalamAnoM kI ora se usako martipUjA ke khilApha pracAra karane meM bahata sahAyatA mila gyii| eka sampradAya bana gayA loMkAgaccha ke nAma se, kintu unake anuyAyiyoM ne satya samajhakara phira se mUrti ko apanA liyA aura loMkAgaccha meM puna: mUrtipUjA pUrvavat prArambha ho gyii| kAla ke prabhAva se dharmasiMha aura

Page #25
17 lavajI RSi ne usa sampradAya se alaga hokara phira se. lokAzAha kI bhakti ke nAma para mUrtipUjA ke khilApha bagAvata kara dii| unakA bhI sampradAya cala par3A, loga unako DhUDhakamata ke nAma se pahicAnane lage jo nahIM jaMcA to Akhira sthAnakavAsI yA sAdhumArgI aisA sunaharA nAma banA liyaa| mUrtipUjA ke khilApha aneka prazna upasthita kiye gye| mUrtipUjaka sampradAya kI ora se una sabhI praznoM kA akATya tarkoM se aura unake mAnya zAstra pAThoM se samAdhAna kiyA gayA, mUrtipUjA meM cAra cAMda laga gye| meghajI RSi, AtmArAmajI mahArAja ityAdi aneka bhavabhIru pApabhIru mahApuruSoM ne usa bebuniyAda sampradAya ko chor3a diyA aura mUrtipUjaka sampradAya ke pakke upAsaka bana gaye / 16 vIM, 17 vI, 18 vIM zatAbdiyoM meM ho gaye agaNita prAcArya-muniyoM ne martipUjA meM agaNita pramANa dete hue aneka nibandhoM kI racanA kii| mUrtipUjA ke khilApha jitane bhI prazna ho sakate haiM una sabhI kA zAstrAnusArI sarkabhita samAdhAna karane ke lie Aja to pracura mAtrA meM sAhitya, purAtattva, zAstrapATha aura prAcIna sAkSya upalabdha haiN| taTastha buddhi se paryAlocana karane vAloM ko zuddha tattva nirNaya karane ke lie pracura sAmagrI upalabdha hai| itanA hote hue bhI mUrtipUjA ke vidveSa se usake khilApha likhane vAle lekhakoM kI prAja kamI nahIM hai, yadyapi aitihAsika tathyoM ko tor3a-mor3a kiye binA yaha sambhava hI nahIM hai| muni zrI bhuvanasundara vijayajI ne aisI tor3a-mor3a karane vAle lekhakoM kI kuceSTA kA pardA phAza karane kA isa pustaka meM eka sarAhanIya kauzalapUrNa vidvadgamya prayAsa kiyA hai isameM sandeha nahIM hai / isase taTastha itihAsa ke jijJAsutroM ko satya-tathya kI upalabdhi hogI, bhavabhIruvarga

Page #26
18 ko dizA parivartana kI preraNA bhI milegI, utpathagAmiyoM ko satyamArga kA prakAza milegaa| mUrtipUjA zAstrokta aura prAtmonnati ke lie Avazyaka evaM anivArya hai. isa tathya kI siddhi meM hajAroM pramANa maujUda haiN| mUrtipUjA ko pramANita karane vAle prAcAryoM meM upAdhyAya zrI yazovijayajI mahArAja kA nAma prAtaH smaraNIya hai| sthAnakavAsI sampradAya meM bhI prAja inake jaina-tarka bhASA Adi granthoM ko bar3I pratiSThA hai| pratimAzataka, pratimA sthApana nyAya, kUpa dRSTAnta vizadI karaNa, upadeza rahasya, SoDaSaka TIkA ityAdi granthoM meM jina akATya pramANoM kA nirdeza kiyA hai, unake sAmane sabhI sthAnakavAsiyoM kA muMha Aja taka banda hI rahA hai| kisI ne bhI usake khilApha kucha bhI likhane kA prAja taka sAhasa nahIM kiyA hai| / mUrtipUjA ke samarthaka aura bhI kaI grantha haiM jinameM ye pramukha haiM-vAcaka zekhara zrI umAsvAti prAcArya mahArAja kRta pUjA prakaraNa, 14 pUrvI pUjya bhadrabAhusvAmI mahArAja kRta Avazyaka niyukti prAdi, prAcArya zrI haribhadrasUri mahArAja kRta pUjA paMcAzaka prakaraNa, Sor3azaka prakaraNa aura zrAvaka prajJapti TIkA evaM lalitavistarA grantha, prAcArya zrI zAMtisUrijI mahArAja kRta caityavaMdana bRhadbhASya, avadhijJAnI zrI dharmadAsagaNi mahArAjakRta upadezamAlA, kalikAla sarvajJa zrI hemacandrAcArya mahArAja kRta yoga zAstra Adi grantha nidhi, navAMgI TIkAkAra prAcArya zrI mabhayadevasUri mahArAja kRta paMcAzaka vRtti / / taduparAnta zrI jJAtA sUtra, ThANAMga sUtra, rAyapaseNI sUtra, jIvAbhIgama sUtra, mahA pratyAkhyAna sUtra, mahAkalpasUtra, mahAnizItha sUtra ityAdi mUla aMga-upAMga sUtroM meM bhI mUrtipUjA ke aneka ullekha bhare

Page #27
19. mahA kalpasUtra meM gautama svAmI ke praznottara meM zrI mahAvIra bhagavAna ne kahA-"jo zramaNa jina maMdira ko na jAya use belA yo pAMca upavAsa kA prAyazcita pAtA hai| usI taraha zrAvaka ko bhii|" tathA isI sUtra meM kahA hai-jo zrAvaka jina pUjA nahIM mAnate ve mithyAdRSTi haiN| tathA samyagdRSTi zrAvaka ko jinamandira meM jAkara candanapuSpAdi se pUjA karanI cAhie / zrI bhagavatI sUtra meM tugIyA nagarI ke zrAvakoM ne snAna karake devapUjana kiyA yaha ullekha hai___"hAyA kayabalikammA" / zrI uvAI sUtra meM campA nagarI ke varNana meM "bahulAI arihaMta ceiyAI" bahuta se arihanta caityoM yAnI jina maMdira kA ullekha hai| zrI bhagavatI sUtra meM camarendra ke adhikAra meM tIna sarakha dikhAye haiM-"arihaMte vA arihaMta ceiyAriNa vA bhAvimappaNo aNagArassa vaa|" yahAM arihanta ceiyANi kA artha arihaMta kI pratimA aisA hotA hai| zrI upAsakadazAMga Agama sUtra meM prAnanda zrAvaka ke adhikAra meM jina pratimA vaMdana kA ullekha hai ___"no khalu me bhaMte ! kappai......"annautthiya pariggahiyANi arihaMta ceiyANi vA vaMdittae vA namaMsittae vaa|" yahAM anya tIthikoM se parigRhIta jimapratimAoM ko vaMdama naM karane ke niyama se anya tIthikoM se aparigRhIta jina pratimAnoM ko vandana kI siddhi hotI hai|

Page #28
20 zrI kalpasUtra meM bhI siddhArtha rAjA ne hajAroM kI saMkhyA meM jina pratimA pUjana karavAne kA "yAga" zabda se ullekha hai| zrI vyavahAra sUtra meM jina pratimA ke sanmukha pAlocanA ( prAyazcita ) karane kA ullekha hai| zrI prazna vyAkaraNa sUtra meM nirjarArthI ko caityahetuka vaiyAvacca karane kA Adeza hai-"ceiya? ....." ityAdi" arthAt pratimA kI hilanA, avarNavAda aura anya prAzAtanAoM kA upadeza ke mAdhyama se nivAraNa karane kA sAdhu ko kahA hai| zrI dvIpa sAgara pannati sUtra meM kahA hai ki svayaMbhUramaNa samudra meM jina pratimA ke prAkAra vAle matsya hote haiM, jinako dekhakara jAti smaraNa hone se tiryaMca jalacaroM ko samyaktva prApti hotI hai| __ zrI bhagavatI sUtra ke prArambha meM hI brAhmI lipi ko bhI namaskAra kiyA hai| - isa prakAra aneka zAstra-pAgama sUtroM se mUrtipUjA siddha hotI hai| mUrtipUjA se lAbha hotA hai yA nahIM-yaha to karanevAlA hI jAna sakatA hai, na karanevAle ko kyA patA? hAM! koI ikSurasa kI madhuratA kA cAhe kitanA bhI apalApa kare kintu usakA prAsvAda karane vAlA to usake madhura rasa kA sAkSAt hI anubhava karatA hai| sthAnakavAsI aura terApaMthI bandhu aura sAdhu-saMtoM se yaha anurodha hai ki ve saba samudAya meM yA akele eka mAsa svayaM jinamUrti kI upAsanA karake anubhava karaleM ki usameM lAbha hotA hai yA nahIM ? hasta kaMkaNa ko kabhI darpaNa kI jarUrata nahIM hotii| ..

Page #29
21 mUrtipUjA ke samarthaka lekha aura nibandhoM se vigata kucha varSoM meM yaha lAbha avazya huaA hai ki kucha kaTTara virodhI sAdhuoM--mahAsatitroM ko chor3akara adhikAMza varga ne mUrtipUjA kA virodha karanA chor3a diyA hai| aneka sthAnakavAsI sadgRhasthoM ne maMdira meM darzana karanA prArambha kara diyA hai, hAlAMki ve loga gAMva meM pUjA-bhakti karane meM kucha hicakAte haiM jarUra kintu tIrthoM meM jAkara pUjA-bhakti kara lete haiM / mUrtipUjA meM sAvadha hai-hiMsA hai ityAdi jo pahile ghoSaNA kI jAtI thI, vaha bhI aba to manda hotI jA rahI hai, kyoMki mUrtipUjA meM koI hiMsAdi doSa nahIM balki agaNita lAbha hI hai, isa tathya ko zAstra, tarka aura anubhava kA puSTa samarthana hai / ___ samaya samaya para mUrtipUjA ke samarthana meM aise lekha aura nibaMdha likhe hI jA rahe haiM aura usI kA yaha satprabhAva hai ki hajAroM loga punaH mUrtipUjA ko Adara se dekhane lage haiN| isa pustaka se bhI yahI lAbha sampanna hogA yaha pAzA kI jAtI hai / pustaka ke lekhaka muni zrI kA yaha zubha prayatna niHsandeha abhinandana ke yogya hai / .. di0 2-10-83 .: navasArI (gujarAta) ... muni jayasundara vijaya

Page #30
pratimA pUjA kI yathArthatA do zabda jagata ke adhikAMza vyavahAroM meM jar3apadArtha meM caitanya kA Aropa kara unase prIti-aprIti hone kI sArvatrika svIkRti hone aura jainAgama meM jagaha jagaha para parama upAdeya zrI jinezvara bhagavAna kI pratimA (bimba) se zubha adhyavasAya kI bAta pratyakSa likhI hone para bhI "sthApanAjima" ko svIkAra na karane kI apanI viparIta dhuna meM ekAntavAda kA prAzraya lekara sthAnakapaMthI sthApanA satya kA sarvathA niSedha karate haiM unakA yaha dRSTikoNa sarvayA 'azobhanIya hai aura ekAntavAdI hone ke kAraNa mithyAtva svarUpa bhI hai| Aja se karIba 400 varSa pahile zvetAmbara jaina samAja se mUrtipUnA ke virodha ke kAraNa alaga hue ina logoM ne sarvaprathama pratimA evaM tasvIra mAtra kA hI virodha kiyA thaa| kintu bAda meM tasvIra ko upayogitA samajhakara ye loga apanI tasvIra chapavAne-ba~TavAne lage yAvat zrI mahAvIrasvAmI kI muMhapattI baMdhI huI tasvIra chapavAkara kalpita sthAnakapaMtha kA pracAra karane lge| isIprakAra dhannAjI, zAlibhadrajI, megha kumArajI prAdi muniyoM kI muMhapasI baMdhI huI tasvIra bhI ve loga chapavAne-baMTavAne lage aura apanI pratiSThA rakhane ke liye "noce par3e kI UMcI TAMga" vAlI kahAvata kI taraha tasvIra ke nIce likhavAte haiM ki"tasvIra sirpha paricaya ke liye" / paramopakArI tIrthaMkara paramAtmA kI

Page #31
23 tasvIra-pratimA-zyAkRti-citra se napharata aura nArAjagI karane vAle ve sthAnakapaMthI Aja to apanI jar3I-jar3AyI tasvIra evaM male meM laTakAne kA tasvIra yukta lokeTa taiyAra karavAkara apane bhaktoM ko dete haiN| ___ kintu vartamAna meM to ye loga apane guru ke samAdhibaMdira taka banavAte haiM / meraTha meM unake guru kA smAraka svarUpa kIrtistambha bhI banA hai, jisake cAroM ora bAga, harI dUba tathA bijalI prAdi jagamagAte haiM, unheM dekhakara aisA lagatA hai ki ina sthAnakapaMthiyoM ko vaimanasya sirpha bhamavAna zrI tIrthaMkara paramAtmA kI tasvIra-prAkRti-pratimA se hI hai, anya smRtikArakoM se nhiiN| guru ke samAdhi maMdira, mAtA-pitA kI tasvIra, sinemA ke dRzyoM, jinamandira, jinapratimA prAdi ko dekhakara manuSya ko khuzInAkhuzI kA mAnasika adhyavasAya hotA hai / ina saba bAtoM se yaha pratyakSa satya hai ki jar3a meM bhI cetana para upakAra yA apakAra karane kI bar3I zakti hai| ...... jar3a kA cetana para mahAna prabhAva par3atA hai| jaise vIra puruSoM kI tasbIra-citra-sTecyU dekhakara hamAre meM vIratA kA saMcAra hotA hai| kyA sAdhuveSa yA zAstra granthoM ko dekhakara sira zraddhA se nala-mastaka nahIM hotA hai ? sinemA ke parade para dikhAye jAne vAle dRzya jar3a hone para bhI dekhane vAloM para usakA gaharA asara par3atA hai / jar3a zarAba prAtmA ke caitanya guNa ko naSTa taka kara detI hai / jar3a karma pudgala ne hI ananta zaktizAlI hamArI prAtmA ko baMdhana meM bAMdha rakhA hai / sAdhuveSa pahinane mAtra se hI vyakti vaMdanIya bana jAtA hai / utanA hI nahIM choTI muhapattI kI jagaha lambI muhapattI bAMdhane para pratIka badala jAne se sAdhu kI pahicAna taka badala jAtI hai, yaha mUrtipUjA kA hI eka prakAra hai / koI sthAnakapaMthI sAdhu apane muMha para lagAyI muhapattI ko tor3a deM to phira

Page #32
kyA unake bhaktagaNa unako vaMdanIya mAneMge ? kyA anya sthAnakapaMthI muni usako tikhuttA ke pATha se vaMdana kareMge? rAjakIya puruSoM kI samAdhi para puSpa car3hAnA, rASTradhvaja ko vaMdana karanA-salAmI denA, dezanetAoM ke bAvale para puSpamAlA arpaNa karanA, guru ke jar3a bhAsana, pATa Adi ko paira na lagAnA, guru kI tasvIra yukta lokeTa bAMTanA yaha saba mUrtipUjA ke hI prakAra haiN| samavasaraNa meM caturmukha tIrthaMkara kA svIkAra karane vAle zeSa tIna pratimA-mUrtiyoM kA apalApa kaise kara sakate haiM ? cAroM tIrthaMkara bhagavAna ke samakSa loga vandana, pUjana satkAra, sammAna karate haiM devendra, cavara DhulAte haiM, saba jIvoM ko sva sammukha darzana-dezanAdi milatA hai| ina saba tathyoM se pratimA-prAkRti kI mahattA kA sanyAyaniSTa prAmANika sajjana kaise apalApa kara sakate haiM ? prAcIna zilAlekhoM evaM pratimA paTToM para uTTakita lekhoM se pratimA pUjA kI Thosa siddhi hotI hai / jainAgama evaM prAcIna jaina zAstra bhI pratimApUjA saMbaMdhita isa satya tathya ko jagaha jagaha para puSTi karate hI haiN| dazavaikAlika zAstra to dIvAra para citrita strI-citra ko brahmacArI ke liye khataranAka batAte hue usa sthAna meM rahane kA bhI niSedha karatA hai| yathA 888 cittamittaM na nijmAe, nArauM vA su alaMkiyaM / ___ bhakkharaM piva baThThaNaM, viTThi paDisamAhure // [zrI dazavakAlikasUtra-adhyayana 8 (gAthA 55) Xxx . zrI kalpasUtra zAstra [sUtra 103] batAtA hai ki

Page #33
4 taeNaM se siddhatthe rAyA dasAhiyAe ThiivaDiyAe vaTTamANIe saie a sAhassie a "jAe" a dAe a bhAe a dalamAraNe m|xxx yahAM prAcIna TIkAkAra maharSi ne 'jAe' yAnI yAga kA artha jinapUjA kiyA hai| zrI AcArAMga sUtra, dvitIya zrutaskandha, tRtIya cUlikA pandrahaveM adhyayana meM bhagavAna zrI mahAvIra svAmI ke mAtA-pitA trizalAdevI aura siddhArtha rAjA ko zrI pArzvanAtha bhagavAna kI paramparA ke ( saMtAnIya ) zrAvaka batAye haiN| aisI dazA meM zrI kalpasUtra zAstra kathita "jAe" yAnI yAga zabda kA artha 'jinapUjA' ke sivA anya kyA ho sakatA hai ? yAga zabda meM yaj dhAtu hai, jisakA artha devapUjA bhI hotA hai| / prazna hogA ki-"kyA patthara kI gAya dUdha dene meM samartha hai ? hAM, patthara kI gAya kevala pahicAna ke lie avazya kAma A sakatI hai|"-is prazna kA uttara yaha hai ki-"gAya-gAya" aisA nAma jApa karane se bhI kyA gAya nAma kA jApa dUdha dene meM samartha hogA? paramAtmA kI mAnI gaI caitanya hIna mUrti agara zubha dhyAna evaM zubha bhAva meM sahAyaka nahIM mAnI jAe to phira paramAtmA kA jar3a nAma zubha adhyavasAya meM sahAyaka kaise mAnA jA sakatA hai ? prastu / sthApanA nikSepa kA niSedha karane vAle koI sthAnakapaMthI agara lokottara jainadharma kA itihAsa likhegA to jaise koI nAdAna vAlaka idhara-udhara Ter3hI-mer3hI lakIreM nikAlakara usako Map of India ( bhArata kA mAnacitra ) kahe aura tuccha Ananda manAye aisI hI kucha ajIba sI bAla ceSTA prAcArya hastImalajI ne jainadharma viSayaka itihAsa ko kalpita evaM galata likhakara kI hai, jisase jaina samAja ko sAvadhAna evaM satarka rahane kI atyanta AvazyakatA hai|

Page #34
26 munirAja zrI bhuvanasundara vijayajI mahArAja ne prAcArya hastImalajI dvArA likhita "jainadharma kA maulika itihAsa" pustaka para yaha mImAMsA likhI hai| isa tarkapUrNa aura zAstrIya mImAMsA ke viSaya meM maiM kyA kaha sakatA hUM? pAThaka svayaM paThana kareM, soceM aura satya samajhane meM saphalatA prApta kareM yahI zubhAbhilASA hai| nyAyavizArada, vardhamAna taponidhi cintAmariNa jaina upAzraya prAcArya deveza madhumati vijaya bhuvanamAnusUrijI navasArI (ji. sUrata) mahArAja sAhaba * gujarAta di0 15-6-83 ziSya - muni guNasundara vijaya kA /

Page #35
kalpita itihAsa sAvadhAna

Page #36
_

Page #37
* OM namaH syAdvAdavAdine * zrI mRga namo namaH [ prakaraNa-1 ] prAkkathana rAgadveSa vijetAraM, jJAtAraM vizva vastunaH / zakra pUjyaM girAmIzaM, tIrthezaM smRtimAnaye / / jisake vaMdana, pUjana, satkAra evaM sanmAna dvArA rAga-dveSa prAdi Antarika zatru para vijaya pAyI jAtI hai, aise sugRhItanAmadheya, sadaiva smaraNIya, indrapUjya, syAdvAdavAdI tIrthaMkara paramAtmAnoM ke nAma smaraNa pUrvaka dravya-bhAva maMgala karake, vardhamAnataponidhi, nyAyavizArada paramapUjya gurudeva zrImad, vijayabhuvanabhAnusUrIzvarajI mahArAja sAhaba kA ziSya maiM [ muni bhuvana sundara vijaya ] sthAnakamArgI prAcAryazrI hastImalajI mahArAja dvArA likhita "jaina-dharmakA maulika itihAsa khaMDa-1 tathA khaMDa-2" para mImAMsA karanA cAhatA huuN| zvetAmbara jainamata meM karIba 400 sAla pahile aisA mUrtibhaMjaka huA jisane mUrtipUjana ke viSaya meM caityavAsI yatioM kI galato dekhakara aura musalamAna saiyada ke vacanoM meM Akara mUrtipUjA aura mUtimAtra kA virodha bola diyA aura aisA udAharaNa prastuta kiyA ki sira duHkhatA ho to usako kATa DAlanA / isI paramparA ke eka mahAzaya prAcArya hastImalajI haiM ataH sajjanoM se prArthanA hai ki jainadharma kI rakSA ke sambandha meM merI isa bAta para Apa sAvadhAna hokara dhyAna dIjie / prAcArya hastImalajI likhita 'jainadharmakA maulika itihAsa khaMDa-1, nayA saMskaraNa jo 1982 meM prakAzita huA hai / khaNDa 1, nayA saMskaraNa ke mukha pRSTha aura antima pRSTha para caubIsa tIrthaMkaroM ke lAMchana cihnoM kI tasvIra chapI

Page #38
[ 2 ] huI hai| taTastha itihAsa likhane kA dAvA karane vAle prAcArya ne pustaka meM tIrthaMkara paramAtmA kI prAkRti (tasvIra) kahIM bhI nahIM chapavAyI hai / tIrthaMkaroM kI bhinna-bhinna pahicAna karAne vAle lAMchana citra dekara praura tIrthaMkaroM kI tasvIra na dekara prAcArya ne bahuta anucita kArya kiyA hai / kintu isa pustaka ke andara dAnadAtA gRhastha kI tasvIra avazya chapavAyI hai / itihAsa lekhaka ne jJAnadAtA tIrthaMkara paramAtmA kI tasvIra na chapavAkara aura dravyadAtA gRhastha kI tasvIra chapavAkara pustaka ke prArambha meM hI ulTI gaMgA bahAyI hai| kyA utkRSTa jJAnadAtA tIrthaMkara paramAtmA se bhI bar3hakara dravyadAtA gRhastha upakArI hai ? jo ki jJAnadAtA kI tasvIra itihAsa meM nahIM chapavAyI aura dravyadAtA gRhastha kI tasvIra chapavAyI gyii| ____ yadyapi itihAsa meM namaskAra mahAmaMtra aura logassa sUtra kA lipimaya prAkRti dvArA prAcArya ne dravya maMgala kiyA hai| kintu tIrthaMkara kI citramaya prAkRti se dravya maMgala nahIM mAnA aisA pharka kyoM ? prAcArya ko yaha bhUlanA nahIM cAhie ki tIrthaMkara bhagavAna ke nAma, sthApanA, dravya aura bhAva cAroM hI nikSepa maMgala rUpa haiM evaM jagata ke upakAraka bhI haiN| "nAmAkRtidravya bhAvaH, punatastrijagajjanam / kSetre kAle ca sarvasminnarhataH, samupAsmahe / / " yaha trikAla abAdhita satya hote hue bhI prAcArya ne isakI upekSA kI hai| ye do khaMDa karIba do hajAra pRSThoM meM prakAzita haiN| prathama tIrthaMkara zrI RSabhadeva bhagavAna se lekara carama tIrthaMkara zrI mahAvIra bhagavAna taka [ eka kor3A kor3I sAgaropamakAla ] kA itihAsa prathama khaMDa meM tathA dUsare khaMDa meM zrI mahAvIra bhagavAna ke prathama gaNadhara zrI

Page #39
gautamasvAmI tathA prathama paTTadhara zrI sudharmAsvAmI se lekara pUjya devaddhi gaNi kSamAzramaNa taka kA eka hajAra varSa kA itihAsa diyA gayA hai / jisameM prAcArya ne jainadharma ke itihAsa ko apramANika evaM jhUThA likhakara anyAya hI kiyA hai / eka taTastha itihAsakAra ke kathana meM jo satyatA, vicAra meM jo niSpakSatA, satya kathana kahane meM jo niDaratA honI cAhie unakA prAcArya meM sarvathA abhAva hI pAyA jAtA hai / jaina dharma ke prAcArya, jainadharma viSayaka itihAsa meM tor3a-maror3a kareM, jhUTha likheM, aprAmANika vacana prastuta kareM, anyAya pUrNa vacana kaheM, satya tathya ko chipAne kA jaghanya prayAsa kareM yA satya ko ardhasatya ke rUpa meM batAyeM isase bar3A kheda kA viSaya anya kyA ho sakatA hai ? yaha bAta kahate hue hamako apAra duHkha hai ki prAcArya hastImalajI ne apane "jainadharma kA maulika itihAsa" grantha meM kaI aisI bAteM likhI haiM jo asaMgata haiN| ve unako kahA~ se lAye inakA kucha AdhAra-pramANa bhI unhoMne nahIM diyA hai / isIliye yaha itihAsa nitAMta kalpita evaM anyAya pUrNa hI hai aura khoja-saMzodhana karane vAle ko kucha bho preraNA aura mArgadarzana dene meM asamartha hai| jinapratimAdi viSayaka tathyoM ko chipAkara prAcArya ne kevala sampradAyavAda aura ekAntavAda kA hI prAzraya liyA hai, jo itihAsa-lekhaka ke nAte sarvathA anucita hai| prAcArya yaha bAta sarvathA bhUla gaye haiM ki svotprekSita tarka aura anumAna ke prAdhAra para prAmANika itihAsa kabhI bhI nahIM likhA jAtA hai| aura yadi koI aisA itihAsa likhe to aise itihAsa ko kauna ucita mAnegA ? itihAsa satya para AdhArita hotA hai, jabaki prAcArya dvArA likhita itihAsa ko samiti dvArA svamAnyatAnusAra nirmANa karavAyA gayA hai / jo sthAnakapaMtha ko chor3akara anya jaina samAja isase sahamata nahIM ho sakatA, aura na isako jaina dharma kA maulika itihAsa kahA jA sakatA hai|

Page #40
[ 4 ] isa itihAsa meM prAcArya hastImalajI ne jagaha-jagaha asatya likhakara jainadharmake viSayameM bhrama phailAyA hai| kathAnakoM ke tathyoMko galata likhakara aitihAsika vAstavikatA kI ora se prAMkheM banda karalI haiM / isako jainadharma kA itihAsa kahanA majAka mAtra hai| prAcArya dvArA itihAsa meM jinamaMdira, jinapratimA tathA jinapratimA pUjA ke viSaya meM satya tathya chipAne aura jainadharma kI garimA ko ghaTAne kA nikRSTa prayAsa kiyA gayA hai, jo sarvathA prastutya hai / sthAnaka paMtha vyAmoha meM phaisakara, svapaMtha ke tuccha svArthavaza pratimA prAdi aneka viSayoM meM jAnabUjhakara parivartana kara evaM satya bAta se dUra rahakara prAcArya ne apanA ullU sIdhA karanA cAhA hai| jainAgamoM evaM prAgametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya tathA prAcIna mUrtiyA~, zilAlekha Adi tathyoM se jinapratimApUjA satya siddha hote hue bhI aprAmANika bAteM likhakara prAcArya ne sarvathA jhUTha kA sahArA liyA hai| sthAnakamArgI sampradAya ke jAnemAne vidvAna prAcArya hastImalajI mahArAja ne taTasthatA, niSpakSatA evaM satya likhane kI pratijJA karane ke bAvajUda bhI satya patha se viparIta calakara jainadharma ko bhArI kSati pahuMcAyI hai| sthAnakamArgI samartha AcArya itanI bar3I aprAmANikatA kara sakate haiM yaha bhI eka sakheda pAzcarya hai| eka prAmANika itihAsakAra ko cAhie ki vaha cAhe koI bhI paMtha yA prAmnAya meM vizvAsa karate hoM kintu ve jisa paMtha yA prAmnAya ke viSaya meM likheM, vaha satya honA caahie| kintu prAcArya ne jainadharma viSayaka itihAsa ko asatya likhakara jaina samAja meM viSailA bhrama phailAyA hai| hamArA yaha spaSTa mata hai ki koI bhI sthAnakapaMthI kabhI bhI jainadharma viSayaka itihAsa ko satya aura prAmANika likha hI nahIM

Page #41
[ 5 ] sakatA kyoMki jainadharma ke mUla meM pratimA pUjA kI mAnyatA hai, jisameM sthAnakapaMthI kadApi vizvAsa nahIM karate haiM / agara prAcAryako jainadharmaviSayaka itihAsa galata evaM kalpita ho likhanA thA to itihAsa likhane kI jarUrata hI kyA thI ? prAmANika itihAsa likhane kI pratijJA karanA aura satya chipAnA donoM eka sAtha nahIM ho sakatA yaha bAta prAcArya ko bhUlanI nahIM cAhie thii| satyapriya jaina samAja ko sAvadhAna evaM satarka hokara aprAmANika evaM svotprekSita tarka ke AdhAra para likhe gaye isa itihAsa kA anAdara evaM bahiSkAra karanA caahie| bhaviSya meM koI bhI lekhaka aise kiMvadantI svarUpa itihAsa prAdi pustaka ko mudrita kara jainadharma ko prAghAta pahucAne kI evaM sAmpradAyika viSa phailAne kI ceSTA na kareM, yahI zubha uddezya lekara pUjya gurudeva zrI kI anumati evaM kRpA pUrvaka isa itihAsa kI mImAMsA karanA hamane ucita samajhA hai| saMbhava hai ki ukta prAcArya hastImalajI Age bhI jainadharma viSayaka itihAsa ke anya khaMDa prakAzita karavAyeMge, hama unase pAzA karate haiM ki ve bhaviSya meM satya kA prAzraya avazya leNge| prAcArya ne eka anucita kArya yaha bhI kiyA hai ki unhoMne sthAnakapaMthI mAnyatAyukta isa grantha kA nAma-"jainadharma kA maulika itihAsa" rakhA hai / jo ki sarvathA amaulika hone ke sAtha-sAtha bholejanoM ko bhrama meM DAlane vAlA hai| tattvapriya evaM satyapriya samAja ko aise amaulika itihAsa ko bhartsanA karanI caahie| maiM pAThakoM ke samakSa prAcArya dvArA racita itihAsa meM se galata evaM aprAmANika aMzoM kA uddharaNa kruuNgaa|

Page #42
prAzA vyakta karatA hU~ ki sabhI sajjana merI isa kRti ko svIkAra kareMge tathA aisI kRtiyoM kA adhika se adhika pracAra prasAra kara nAmadhArI prAcAryAdi dvArA hote viSaile pracAra ko rokane kA bharasaka prayatna kreNge| rAyapaseNI jIvAbhigame, bhagavatI sUtre bhAkhI jii| jaMbUdvIpa pannatI ThANAMge, vivarIne ghaNu dAkhIjI // valI azAzvati jJAtA kalpamAM, vyavahAra pramukhe aakhiijii| te jina pratimA lopai pApI, jihAM bahusUtra cha sAkhI jii|| nyAyavizArada pU0 yazovijayajI mahArAja ke laghubhrAtA -zrI padmavijayajI mahArAja

Page #43
[prakaraNa-2] tIrthaMkaroM kA janma mahotsava jaba bhI puNyAtmA tIrthaMkara paramAtmA kA janma hotA hai, taba chappana dikkumArikAeM AtI haiM, mAtA evaM putra kA sucikarma karatI haiN| indroM kA siMhAsana kaMpAyamAna hotA hai / saudharma indra bhagavAna ko meruparvata para le jAtA hai, vahA~ 64 indra ikaTThe hokara apAra bhaktipUrvaka janmAbhiSeka mahotsava sAnanda manAte haiM / bAda meM ve deva-devendra naMdIzvaradvIpa meM jAkara, vahAM sthita zAzvata jinamaMdiroM meM pATha dina kA bhakti mahotsava manAte haiN| "jainadharma kA maulika itihAsa", khaMDa-1, pR0 15 para prAcArya hastImalajI likhate haiM ki Xxx mahAna puNyAtmA ( tIrthakara paramAtmA ) jaba janma grahaNa karate haiM, usa samaya 56 vikakumAriyoM aura 64 devendroM ke Asana prakampita hote haiM / avadhijJAna ke upayoga ke dvArA jaba unheM vidita hotA hai ki tIrthakara kA janma ho gayA hai, to ve saba anAdikAlase "paraMparAgata" dikakumAriyoM aura devendroM ke "jItAcAra" ke anusAra apanI adbhuta divyadeva Rddhi ke sAtha apanI apanI maryAdA ke anusAra tIrthaMkara ke janmagRha tathA, meruparvata aura nandIzvara dvIpa meM upasthita ho, bar3e hI harSollAsa pUrvaka janmAbhiSeka Adi ke rUpa meM tIrthaMkara kA janma mahotsava manAte haiM / yaha saMsAra kA eka anAdi ananta zAzvata niyama hai|

Page #44
- mImAMsA-prAcArya ne apanI kalpita kalpanA paramparAgata, jItAcAra, apanI apanI maryAdA aura zAzvata niyama ina cAra zabdoM se kI hai| khaMDa-1 pR 15 se 16 meM tIrthaMkaroM kA janmAbhiSeka mahotsava meruparvata para deva-devendra kaise manAte haiM Adi kA varNana kiyA hai| kintu satya tathya ko viparIta karake yaha to 'jItAcAra' hai yA 'paraMparAgata' hai aisA likhanA nitAnta asatya evaM ekapakSI hone ke kAraNa sarvathA galata bhI hai / jaMbUdvIpa prajJapti zAstra ke tIsare adhikAra meM likhA hai ki janmAbhiSeka mahotsava meM AnevAle deva koI svataH apAra bhaktivaza, koI priyatamA devI kI preraNA se, koI mitra ke vacana se, koI kautuka se, koI indra kI prAjJA se, to koI apanA prAcAra kartavya samajhakara prabhujanma mahotsava meM zAmila hote haiN| 808 zrI jaMbUdvIpa prajJapti kathita zAstrapATha isa prakAra hai, yathAH-appegaiyA baMdaNavattiyaM evaM pUyaNavattiyaM sakkAra sammANa daMsaNa kouhalla appe sakkassa bayanuyasamANA appe aNNamaNu yattamANA appejIyameyaM evamAdi / xxx ataH mAtra zAzvata AcAra se yA paramparAgata rIti se deva-devendra meruparvata para janmAbhiSeka mahotsava manAte haiM, aisA likhane meM prAcArya kA anekAnta dRSTi evaM prAcIna jainAgamoM ke prati kRtajJatA tathA paramAtmA ke prati bhakti bhAva kA sarvathA abhAva hI vyakta hotA hai| paramparA se Ane kA artha to yahI huA ki deva-devendra becAre lAcArI se, majabUrI se, anicchA se yA udAsInatA se pAte haiN| kintu prAcArya kA aisA likhanA una devoM kI bhakti kI mahimA para lAMchana lagAnA hai| deva-devendra nandIzvara dvIpa meM jAkara "bar3e harSollAsa ke sAtha" lagAtAra ATha dina taka prabhubhakti mahotsava manAte haiN| isa viSaya meM khaMDa-1, pR0 555 para prAcArya likhate haiM ki

Page #45
[6] xxx isa prakAra ghoSaNA karavAne ke pazcAt zakra aura sabhI devendroM ne nandIzvara dvIpa meM jAkara tIrthakara bhagavAna kA aSTAnhika janma-mahotsava manAyA / "bar3e harSollAsa" ke sAtha aSTAnhika mahotsava manAne ke pazcAt sabhI deva aura devendra Adi apane apane sthAna lauTa gye|444 ___ mImAMsA - "baDe harSollAsa" zabda se yaha spaSTa hotA hai ki devoM dvArA janmAbhiSekAdi mahotsava manAnA paramparAgata yA rUDhi mAtra hI nahIM hai| kyoMki paramparAgata aura rUDhi kI kriyA meM to prAyaH harSollAsa kA abhAva hI pAyA jAtA hai / ata: prAcArya hastImalajI kA paramparAgata, zAzvata niyama, jitAcAra prAdi zabdoM kA prayoga karanA nitAnta bhrAntipUrNa hI hai / agara deva phArmoliTI pUrI karate yAnI rItarazma nibhAne hetu hI mahotsava manAte to "bar3A harSollAsa" nahIM aataa| sirpha khAnA pati hI karanI hotI to naMdIzvara dvIpa meM jAkara lagAtAra pATha dina kA mahotsava manAnA aura vaha bhI "bar3e harSollAsa se" yaha paramparA se saMbhava nahIM ho sakatA jaisA ki unakA kahanA hai / deva aura devendroM ke dila meM apane tAraka devAdhideva paramAtmA ke prati itanI apAra bhakti hai ki bhagavAna kA janma-mahotsava meruparvata para bhagavAna ko le jAkara karane para bhI saMtuSTa na hue, to bAda meM bhagavAna ko lAkara, mAtA ko sauMpakara saba devoM ne nandozvara dvIpa meM jAkara, vahA~ sthita zAzvata jinamandiroM meM lagAtAra ATha dina kA apAra bhaktivaza aSTAhnika mahotsava mnaayaa| kevala jitAcAra, paramparAgata aise tuccha zabdoM kA prayoga karake aura nandIzvara dvIpa sthita zAzvata jina mandiroM kA ullekha na karake prAcArya ne ina deva-devendroM kI apAra bhakti kI mahimA ko kama karane kA evaM sat vastu "nandIzvaradvIpa sthita zAzvata jina mandiroM kA" virodha karane kA nirlajja prayAsa kiyA hai, jo sarvathA anucita hai|

Page #46
[ 10 ] prabhubhakti kI mahimA devoM ke dila meM kaisI basI hai isa viSaya meM "zrI paMca pratikramaNa sUtra" meM pUrvAcArya likhate haiM ki yeSAmabhiSeka karmakRtvA, mattA harSa bharAt sukhaM surendrAH / tRNamapi gaNayanti naiva nAkaM, prAtaH santu zivAya te jinendrAH / / arthAta-jina tIrthaMkara paramAtmAnoM kA abhiSeka kArya karake harSavaza masta surendra svarga sukha ko tRNamAtra bhI nahIM ginate, ve jinendra bhagavAna prAtaH kAla meM zivasukha [nirupadravatA kalyANa ] ke liye hoN| deva-devendroM meM bhagavAna ke prati apAra bhakti kaisI hai ki ve devaloka ke sukhoM ko prabhubhakti ke Age tRNa barAbara bhI nahIM ginate haiN| deva-devendroM kI apAra bhakti ke dRSTAnta se to prAcArya ko paramAtmA para apAra bhakti karanA sIkhanA cAhie, yaha bhakti tIrthaMkara mAmakarma kA baMdha karAtI hai| kintu prAcArya kI haThadharmitA dekho ki deva-devendroM jaisI bhagavad bhakti sIkhanA to dUra rahA, kintu paramparAgata jaise halke zabdoM ko likhakara una deva-devendroM kI bhakti kI mahimA ghaTA rahe haiM aura nandIzvara dvIpa sthita zAzvata jina mandira ke tathya ko chipAne kA azobhanIya prayAsa kara rahe haiN| jisake dila meM tIrthaMkara paramAtmA kI bhakti kA aMza mAtra bhI na ho, kyA vaha devoM kI apAra, bhakti kA mUlya kara sakatA hai ? tathA jainAgamoM para saccI zraddhA kA prabhAva vAlA vyakti kyA nandIzvara dvIpa sthita zAzvata jina mandiroM ke satya ko svIkAra kara sakatA hai ? saca hI kahA hai jAke dila meM jhUTha basata hai, tAko satya na bhAve / bhakta ke mana meM mukti se bhI prabhubhakti kA mUlya adhika hotA hai / -nyAyavizArada pU0 yazovijayajI upAdhyAyajI

Page #47
[prakaraNa 3] zAsana rakSaka deva-deviyAM jainadharma meM zAsana rakSaka deva-deviyoM kI mAnyatA mUrtipUjA jitanI hI prAcIna hai / caubIsa bhagavAna ke zAsanarakSaka deva yakSayakSiNI hote haiM, jo samaya-samaya para pAkara janazAsana kI rakSA evaM jainazAsanonnati ke kAryoM ko karate haiM / unakI aisI anumodanIya pravRtti kI anumodanA hetu pratikramaNa meM bhavanadevI zrutadevI Adi kA prazaMsA sUcaka kAussagga bhI kiyA jAtA hai| ina deva-deviyoM ke viSaya meM AcArya hastImalajI khaMDa-1, pR0 18 'apanI bAta' meM likhate haiM ki xxx pratyeka tIrthakara ke zAsana-rakSaka yakSa-yakSiNI hote haiM, jo samaya samaya para zAsana kI saMkaTa se rakSA aura tIrthaMkaroM ke bhaktoM kI icchA pUrNa karate rahate haiN| 8xx mImAMsA-yadyapi prAgamika tathya hote hue bhI sthAnakapaMthI evaM prAcArya hastImalajI ina deva-deviyoM meM vizvAsa nahIM karate haiN| phira bhI ukta tathya likhanA bhole janoM ko dhokhA denA mAtra hI hai| khaMDa-1, pR0 788 para prAcArya dvArA "tIrthaMkara paricaya patra" bahuta lambA-caur3A diyA gayA hai| isakI prazaMsA kucha vidvAnoM ne kI hai| isa paricaya-patra meM tIrthaMkara bhagavAna ke dIkSA ke sAthI, prathama tapa, prathama pAraNA dAtA, chadmastha kAla Adi anekavidha mAhiti saMdRbdha kI gayI hai / kintu isa vizAla paricayapatra meM caubIsa tIrthaMkaroM ke yakSa

Page #48
[ 12 ] yakSiNI kA paricaya evaM citra dvArA mArgadarzana to dUra nAma taka nahIM diyA hai / isake kAraNa hI yaha paricaya-patra prAcArya ke pakSapAtitva kA paricAyaka mAtra hai| varanA prasaMgopAt vahAM yakSa-yakSiNI kA nAma evaM paricaya denA atyanta Avazyaka thA / itihAsakAra ko satya hakIkata likha denA cAhie kintu abhiniveza vaza AcArya ne caubIsa tIrthaMkaroM ke zAsana rakSaka deva-deviyoM ke sAtha pakSapAta kara "tIrthaMkara paricaya patra" ko bhI apUrNa hI rakhA hai| deva-deviyoM ke viSaya meM prAcArya duraMgI nIti rIti apanA rahe haiM / isa viSaya meM inake itihAsa meM svIkAra aura inkAra donoM sAtha sAtha calate haiM, jo anucita tarIkA hai| eka anya pustaka "siddhAnta praznottarI" jo sarvathA zAstra nirapekSa hone ke kAraNa kalpita hai, isameM prAcArya likhate haiM ki- "deva deviyAM kucha dete nahIM haiN|" kintu prAgamika tathya isase bilakula viparIta hI hai| kyoMki prAcArya hI likhate haiM ki kRSNa kI mAtA devakI ko kRSNa dvArA tele (aTThama) ke tapa pUrvaka hariNagameSI deva ko prArAdhanA karane se gajasukumAla nAmaka putra milA thaa| khaMDa-1, pR0 364 para yathA xxx devakI ke manoratha kI pUrti hetu kRSNa ne tIna dina kA nirAhAra tapa kara deva kA smaraNa kiyA / ekAnamana dvArA kiyA gayA cintana indra-mahendra kA bhI hRdaya hara letA hai, phalasvarUpa hariNegameSI kA Asana DolAyamAna huaa| vaha aayaa|xxx xxx ( hariNegameSI ) deva ne kahA--deva loka se nikalakara eka jIva tumhAre sahodara bhAI ke rUpa meM utpanna hogaa|xxx mImAMsA-prAcArya dvArA kathita ukta tathya se yaha siddha hotA hai ki deva-deviyAM kucha dete haiM / agara deva kI sahAyatA se putra prApti

Page #49
[ 13 ] rUpa kArya nahIM hotA to tIna dina kA nirAhAra tapa karake unako bulAnA vyartha hI thA / aisI dazA meM "siddhAnta praznottarI" kitAba meM deva-deviyAM kucha dete nahIM haiM aisA prAcArya kA likhanA sarvathA jhUTha hI rhaa| aparaM ca vairoTyA devI ke viSaya meM khaMDa-2 pR0 550 para prAcArya likhate haiM ki xxx bhagavAna pArzvanAtha ke caraNoM meM bhakti rakhane vAle bhaktoM ke kaSToM kA nivAraNa karane meM vaha ( vairoTyAdevI dharaNendra kI mahiSI ) samaya samaya para unakI sahAyatA karane lgii|xxx mImAMsA-ina tathyoM se isa bAta kI siddhi hotI hai ki sthAnakapaMthI loga jo deva-deviyoM ke viSaya meM bhramapUrNa bAta likhate mAnate haiM, unakA yaha bhrama dUra huA hogaa| khaMDa-1, pR0 524 para prAcArya likhate haiM ki 800 zraddhAlu bhaktoM ko yaha nizcita dhAraNA hai ki ina ( padmAvatI, kAlI, mahAkAlI Adi ) deviyoM (dharaNendra Adi ) devoM aura devendroM ne samaya samaya para zAsana ko prabhAvanA kI hai| isakA pramANa yaha hai ki dharaNendra aura padmAvatI ke stotra Aja bhI pracalita haiN|444 mImAMsA-"zraddhAlu bhaktoM kI yaha dhAraNA hai" aisA likhane kA artha to yahI ho sakatA hai ki prazraddhAlu hone ke kAraNa prAcArya kI aisI dhAraNA nahIM hai| yAnI sthAnakapaMthI prAcArya hastImalajI zAsana rakSaka deva-deviyoM meM avizvAsa karate haiM, kintu yaha jainAgama aura prAgametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya kA hI avizvAsa evaM anAdara karane ke barAbara hai / khaMDa-2, pR0 550 para AcArya likhate haiM ki

Page #50
[ 14 ] xxxkahA jAtA hai ki AcArya nandila ne vairoTyA ke stuti paraka "namiUNa jiNaM pAsaM" isa maMtra gabhita stotra kI racanAkara vairATyA kI smRti ko cirasthAyI bnaayaa|xxx mImAMsA-deva-deviyoM kI bAta spaSTa rUpa se prAgama zAstroM meM kathita hai| phira bhI ' kahA jAtA hai" aisA prAcArya kA likhanA anyAya hI hai| zrI bhagavatI sUtra meM sUtrakAra maharSi ne bhI yakSa-yakSiNiyoM kA lipibaddha maMgala kiyA hai / dvAdazAMgI ke pAMcaveM aMga bhagavatI sUtra ke viSaya meM prAcArya hastImalajI khaNDa-2 pR0 170 para likhate haiM ki 88 dvAdazAMgI ke pAMcaveM aMga "vyAkhyA prajJapti" [ aparanAma zrI bhagavatI sUtra ] kI Adi meM "paMcaparameSThI namaskAra maMtra", "Namo baMbhIe livIe" aura Namo suyassa pada se maMgala kiyA hai aura anta meM saMgha stuti ke pazcAt gautamAdi gaNadharoM, bhagavatI vyAkhyA prajJapti, dvAdazAMgI rUpa gaNipiTaka, zrutadevatA, pravacanadevI, kubhadhara yakSa, brahmazAMti, vairoTyAdevI, vidyAdevI aura aMtahuDI ko namaskAra kiyA gayA hai|xxx ___ mImAMsA-yahAM svayaM sUtrakAra maharSi ne antima maMgala ke rUpa meM kumbhadhara yakSa, vairoTyAdevI prAdi ko namaskAra kiyA hai / itanA Thosa Agama vacana hote hue bhI prAcArya kA pakSapAta dekho ki deva-deviyoM ke viSaya meM "aisA mAnA jAtA hai", "aisA kahA jAtA hai" aise ghaTiyA zabdoM kA prayoga karake apramANikatA kara rahe haiN| mahAna jainAcArya zrI nandila ke viSaya meM prAgamika tathya satya hote hue bhI "kahA jAtA hai" aisA prAcArya likhate haiM, jo prAcArya ke anizcita citta kA paricAyaka hai| kintu aisI anizcitatA aura apramANika bAteM to isa kalpita itihAsa meM jagaha jagaha likhI milatI haiM / khaMDa-2, pR0 646 para prAcArya likhate haiM ki

Page #51
[ 15 ] xxx bhayahara stotra bhI AcArya mAnatuMga kI racanA mAnI jAtI hai| 000 mImAMsA--'mAnI jAtI hai' aisA saMdigdha likhakara prAcArya apane itihAsa ko kaur3I kI kImata kA kara rahe haiM kyoMki itihAsa ke lekhana meM satya kathanoM ko aise saMdigdha rUpa meM likhanA doSapUrNa hotA hai| zAsana rakSaka deva-deviyAM avasara para prAkara tIrthaMkara ke bhaktoM ke saMkaTa nivAraNa karate haiM, isa viSaya meM zrI sthUlibhadra mahAmuni kI bahina sAdhvI yakSA kI bAta Agama prasiddha hai, jo zAsana rakSaka devI kI sahAyatA se zrI sImaMdhara bhagavAna ke pAsa gayI thii| isa viSaya meM khaMDa-2, pR0 776 para prAcArya likhate haiM ki x0X yadi koI kahade ki ( bhAI sAdhu zrIyaka kI mauta ke viSaya meM ) yakSA nirdoSa hai, tabhI maiM ( yakSA ) anna-jala grahaNa karUMgI anyathA nahIM / xxx 300 antatogatvA zAsanAdhiSThAtrI devI kI saMgha ne ArAdhanA kI aura devI sahAyatA se AryA yakSA mahAvideha kSetra meM zrImaMdarasvAmI ke samavasaraNa meM phuNcii|xxx xxx devI sahAyatA se AryA punaH lauTa aayo|xxx mImAMsA-ukta bAta se yaha spaSTa hai ki deva-deviyAM jainazAsana kI sahAyatA karate haiM / bar3e bar3e prAcAryoM ne bhI unakI bhakti kI anumodanArtha stotra race haiN| unake zAsana sevA kI anumodanA nimitta pratikramaNa meM kAyotsarga bhI kiyA jAtA hai| jina pratimA kI taraha deva-deviyoM kI prAcIna mUrtiyAM bhI jamIna meM se nikalatI haiM, isa dhvaMsAvazeSa pratimA kI caukiyoM para uTTa kita lekha se yaha bhI nirNaya hotA hai ki pUrvAcAryoM ne hI ina zAsana rakSaka deva-deviyoM kI mUrti kI

Page #52
[ 16 ] pratiSThA karavAyI thii| zrI bhagavatI sUtra Adi pAgama zAstroM meM bhI deva-deviyoM kI bAta AtI hai / Adi aneka tathya hote hue bhI AcArya hastImalajI yakSa-yakSiNI ke viSaya meM prakAza meM prAnA pasanda nahIM karate haiM, yaha unakA gaharA pakSapAta hI hai| prAgarA lohAmaMDI se chapI 'maMgalavANI' kitAba, saMkalanakartA sthAnakapaMthI akhilezamuni ne pR0 354 ( gyArahavA~ saMskaraNa ) para "ghaMTAkarNa mahAvIra kA maMtra" diyA hai, aura isako 21 bAra ginane para bhUta-pretAdi pIDA nAza hotI hai aisA likhA hai / jaba sthAnakapaMthiyoM ko "ghaMTAkarNa mahAvIra" ke viSaya meM pUchate haiM taba ve isa viSaya meM kucha nahIM batAte haiM / kintu isa "ghaMTAkarNa mahAvIra maMtra" se bhI sthAnakamArgI dvArA deva-deviyoM ke tathya ko puSTi to avazya hotI hI hai / phira satyatathya ko svIkArane meM inkAra kyoM ? anekAnta kA samucita bodha rahita samyagdarzana dravya samyagdarzana hai / -pU0 yazovijayajI upAdhyAya mahArAja

Page #53
. OM686660888 on atyanta prAcIna bhavya jina pratimA jo jaramanI ke saMgrahAlaya meM hai|

Page #54
_

Page #55
[prakaraNa-4] tIrthaMkaroM kI mAtA ke garbha meM bhI pUjanIyatA jaba jagatvaMdya tIrthaMkara paramAtmA mAtAkI kukSi meM Ate haiM taba bhI pUjanIya hote haiN| vaise mAtA kI kukSi meM Aye hue tIthaMkara dravya tIrthaMkara haiM, phira bhI ve devendroM ke bhI pUjanIya banate haiN| to phira "devA vi taM namasaMti" isa AgamavacanAnusAra jana sAmAnya ke bhI pUjanIya baneM isameM Azcarya hI kyA ? tIrthakara paramAtmA mAtA kI kukSi meM pAte haiM taba devendra siMhAsana para se nIce utara jAtA hai, uttarAsaMga karake apane siMhAsana se sAta-pATha kadama Age calakara bhagavAna jisa dizA meM hoM usI dizA meM praNAma karake bhagavAna kI stuti svarUpa "zakrastava" [namutthuNaM] sUtra bolatA hai / ukta bAta zrI kalpasUtra zAstra meM 14 pUrvadhara zrI bhadrabAhusvAmI ne bhI kahI hai| prAcArya hastImalajI khaMDa 1, pR0 15 para likhate haiM ki xxx sarva prathama unhoMne ( causaTha indroM ne ) siMhAsana se uTha prabhu jisa dizA meM virAjamAna the usa dizA meM uttarAsaMga kiye, sAta-ATha kadama Age jA prabhu ko praNAma kiyaa|xxx mImAMsA-zrI kalpasUtra zAstra meM kahA hai ki zakra 'namuttharaNaM' sUtra kA pATha bolatA hai| phira bhI manamAnI karake prAcArya ne zakrastava ke kathana ko chipA hI liyA hai, kyoMki mAtA kI kukSi meM Aye hae tIrthaMkara dravya tIrthaMkara haiM, unako bhI prAdikara, tIrthaMkara prAdi 33

Page #56
[ 18 ] vizeSaNoM se zrI kalpasUtrazAstrakAra dvArA samAdara kiyA gayA hai, yaha bAta prAcArya ko svamAnyatA virodhaka hone se kAMTe kI taraha cubhanevAlI hai, ataH unhoMne apramANikatA pUrvaka zrI kalpasUtra zAstra kathita 'namutthuNaM' kA pATha chipAyA hai| kinhIM jovoM ko mithyAtva kA udaya hI itanA abhiniveza pUrNa hotA hai ki vaha satya ko satya rUpa meM likhane * taka nahIM detaa| pUjya tIrthaMkara pratyeka avasthA meM pUjanIya-vaMdanIya haiM, isa viSaya meM bhAvi tIrthaMkara zrI mahAvIra bhagavAna ke pUrva bhavadhArI marIci ko prathama cakravartI bharata dvArA praNAma karanA zAstra prasiddha dRSTAnta hai / bharata cakravartI ke uttara meM zrI RSabhadeva bhagavAna ne kahA ki-"he bharata ! terA putra marIci bhAvi 24 vA tIrthakara hogA / taba jAkara bharata ne tridaNDI tApasa veza dhAraka marIci ko praNAma kiyaa| ukta bAta ko khaMDa 1, pR0 116 para prAcArya bhI vyakta karate haiM, yathA xxx marIci ke pAsa jAkara usakA abhivAdana karate hue (bharata) bole-"marIci ! tuma tIrthakara banoge isaliye tumhArA abhivAdana karatA huuN| marIci ! terI isa pravajyA ko evaM vartamAna janma ko vaMdana nahIM karatA hU~, kintu tuma jo bhAvI tIrthaMkara banoge isaliye maiM vaMdana karatA huuN|"Xxx mImAMsA-bhAvi tIrthaMkara ko bhI samyagdRSTi bharata vaMdana karate haiM, isa tathya se yaha satya siddha hotA hai ki kohinUra hIrA bhale cAhe khAna meM par3A ho, kohinUra hI hai / vaise hI tIrthaMkara paramAtmA bhI sadaiva vaMdanIya evaM pUjanIya haiM / - zAstrIya kathana hote hue bhI dravya tIrthaMkara ko pUjanIyatA meM mavizvAsa karane vAle prAcArya apanI nArAjagI pragaTa karate hue kahate haiM ki

Page #57
[ 16 ] xxxbharata dvArA bhAvi tIrthakara marIci ko praNAma karanA mUla jainAgamoM meM dRSTigocara nahIM hotA hai, kintu kathAgranthoM meM aisI bAta likhI hai|xxx kintu aisI apramANika bAta likhane vAle prAcArya hastImalajI ko yaha batAnA cAhie ki zrI mahAvIra svAmI ke jIva ne kisa jagaha, kisa samaya kauna se kAraNa nIca gotra kA baMdha kiyA thA, jisake prabhAva se zrI mahAvIra svAmI ke bhava meM unako brAhmaNI kI kukSi meM paidA honA par3A thaa| subhUma cakravartI, brahmadatta cakravartI, candragupta cANakya kA kathAnaka, sagara cakravartI ko vairAgya, zrI mahAvIra svAmI ke sattAIsa bhava, naMdavaMza kI sthApanA prAdi aneka bAteM pAgama granthoM meM nahIM hote hue bhI prAcArya ne kathA granthoM ke sahAre hI likhI haiM / phira isa bAta meM saMdeha kyoM? prAryA caMdanabAlA ke viSaya meM khaMDa 1, (purAnI prAvRtti) pR0 345 para prAcArya likhate haiM ki xxx candanA ne jaba kucha samaya bAda yauvana meM padArpaNa kiyA to usakA anupama sauMdarya zataguNita ho utthaa| usako kajjala se bhI adhika kAlI kezarAzi bar3hakara usakI piNDaliyoM se aThakheliyAM karane lgii|xxx mImAMsA-prAryA caMdanabAlA ke viSaya meM ukta bAta itihAsakAra ne. kauna se mUlAgama ke prAdhAra para likhI hai, yaha prAmANikatA pUrvaka kahanA cAhie evaM naMdavaMza kI sthApanA ke avasara para khaMDa 2, pR0 268 para prAcArya likhate haiM ki

Page #58
[ 20 ] 444 udAyI kA rAja chatra bhI svataH hI nanda ke mastaka para tana gayA aura nanda ke donoM ora mantrAdhiSThita ve donoM cAmara svataH hI adRzya zakti se prerita ho, vyajita hone lge|xxx mImAMsA-ukta bAta bhI itihAsakAra prAcArya ne kauna se mUlAgama meM se likhI hai ? itanA hI nahIM prAcArya ke mAne hue 32 mUlAgama yA ekAdaza aMga ke mUlapATha meM kahIM bhI sAmAyika kI vidhi, pratikramaNa kI vidhi, posaha kI vidhi kA ullekha nahIM hai| to phira sAmAyika, pratikramaNa aura pauSadha prAdi kI vidhi ve kauna se prAdhAra para kara rahe haiM ? saca to yaha hai ki Agametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya bhI hamAre liye utanA hI vizvasanIya hai jitanA AgamazAstra / kyoMki prAgametara jaina sAhitya ke racayitA ve jainapUrvAcArya haiM jo paMcamahAvrata dhAraka evaM utsUtrabhASaNa ke vajrapApa se Darane vAle bhavabhIru the| kalikAla sarvajJa pUjyapAd zrI hemacandrAcArya mahArAja racita "triSaSThi zalAkA puruSa caritra" meM bharata ne bhAvi tIrthaMkara marIci ko praNAma kiyA thA aisI bAta AtI hai aura "triSaSThi zalAkA puruSa caritra" vizvasanIya hai isa bAta ko prAcArya svayaM hI khaMDa 2, pR0 56 para kahate haiM 888 yaha hai AcArya zrI hemacandrasUri dvArA viracita triSaSThi zalAkA puruSa caritra kA ullekha jo pichalI ATha zatAbdiyoM se bhI adhika samaya se lokapriya rahA hai / Xxx mImAMsA- bahuta sI aisI bAteM haiM jisako pramANita karane ke liye prAgametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya kA hI ekamAtra pramANika sahArA aura saccA AdhAra hai| phira bhI marIci ko bharata dvArA kiye gaye praNAma ke viSaya meM prAcArya kA likhanA ki-"aisI koI bAta AgamoM

Page #59
[ 21 ] meM nahIM hai" bilkula anucita evaM kRtaghnatA kA sUcaka hai| yaha kaisA gUDhAcAra hai ki itihAsa kI puSTi meM sahArA lenA triSaSThi zalAkA puruSa Adi caritroM kA aura sthAnakapaMthI svamAnyatA se virodha prAye vahA~ bola uThanA ki mUlAgamoM meM aisI koI bAta pAyI nahIM hai ! kaisI hAsyAspada bAta prAcArya kara rahe haiM, gur3a khAnA aura gulaguloM se paraheja ! jainAgama evaM prAgametara jaina granthoM meM nAma evaM sthApanA kI taraha dravya tIrthaMkara bhI vaMdanIya mAne gaye haiM / yaha satya tathya eka prAmANika itihAsakAra ko svIkAra karanA caahie| abhavi evaM durbhavi ko jainAgama evaM Agametara jaina sAhitya kathita bAta nahIM suhAtI hai, jaise ullU ko prakAza /

Page #60
[prakaraNa-5 ] tIrthakara ke bAraha guNa rAga-dveSa vijetA tIrthaMkara zrI arihaMta paramAtmA ke bAraha guNoM meM kucha kapaTa kA sahArA lekara bhAcArya hastImalajI khaMDa 1, pR061 para isa prakAra likhate haiM ki Xxx (1) anantajJAna (2) anaMtadarzana (3) anaMta cAritra yAnI vItarAga bhAva (4) anaMtabala-vIrya (5) azokavRkSa (6) devakRta puSpavRSTi (7) divyadhvani (8) cAmara (9) sphaTika siMhAsana (10) chatratraya (11) AkAza meM devadundubhi aura (12) bhAmanDala / pAMca se bAraha taka ke mATha guNoM ko prAtihArya kahA gayA hai / bhaktibaza devoM dvArA yaha mahimA kI jAtI hai|xxx mImAMsA-pAMca se bAraha taka ke ATha guNoM ko devakRta kahane para bhI cha8 guNa meM "devakRta puSpavRSTi" aisA likhanA prAcArya kI apramANikatA hI hai / "devakRta puSpavRSTi" likhane para to devakRta azoka vRkSa, devakRta divya dhvani aisA bhI likhanA cAhie / phira "pAMca , se bAraha taka ke pATha guNoM ko prAtihArya kahA gayA hai, bhaktivaza devoM dvArA yaha mahimA kI jAtI hai / " aisA likhane kI AvazyakatA nahIM thI, phira bhI kyoM likhA?

Page #61
[ 23 ] ukta bAraha guNoM ke viSaya meM "devakRta azokavRkSa" na likhakara aura "devakRta puSpavRSTi" aisA likhane ke pIche prAcArya kA abhiprAya yaha rahA hogA ki devoM dvArA bhagavAna ke samavasaraNa meM pracita (nirjIva ) puSpoM kI vRSTi hotI hai| jabaki pUrvAcAryoM ne sacita puSpavRSTi kA bhI honA zAstroM meM likhA hai| "tuSyatu durjana nyAyena" yaha mAna bhI liyA jAe ki ahiMsA dharma ke pravartaka tIrthaMkara paramAtmA kI upasthiti meM sacita puSpoM kI vRSTi (varSA) na karake devagaNa pracita puSpoM kI vRSTi karate the, jo ki ahiMsaka haiM, phira bhI puSpavarSA se vAyukAya kI hiMsA to avazya hotI hI hogI? isakA jabAba prAcArya kyA deMge? ___ aura caMvara DhulAne Adi meM vAyukAya ke jIvoM kI hiMsA bhI vicAraNIya hai| prAcArya ne bAraha guNoM kA varNana apane itihAsa meM nahIM kiyA hai / ratha musala yuddha caMdragupta cANakya kA kathAnaka, brahmadatta aura subhUma Adi ke viSaya meM phAlatU lambI caur3I bAteM likhane vAle prAcArya ne atyanta upAdeya tIrthaMkara paramAtmA ke guNoM kA varNana nahIM kiyA hai yaha sakheda Azcarya kI bAta hai / isake sAtha eka bAta aura bhI hai ki guNa-guNI meM rahate haiM, jaise ki tIrthakara paramAtmA meM jJAna, darzana, cAritrAdi guNa rahate haiM / kintu siMhAsana, chatra, caMvara, azokavRkSa jo guNI meM nahIM rahate haiM phira bhI inako tIrthaMkara paramAtmA (guNI) ke guNa kyoM kahA hai ? isa prakAra ke spaSTIkaraNa ko atyanta AvazyakatA thii| jisako apUrNatA hI apane itihAsa meM prAcArya ne rakhI hai jo unakI anabhijJatA kI bhI sUcaka mAnI jaaegii| svata: siddha tathyoM jaise ki mahAvIra bhagavAna kA garbhApahAra, bharatacakrI kI SaT khaMDa sAdhanA, RSabhadeva bhagavAna kA 400 dina kA

Page #62
[ 24 ] vrata, paMcamI kI cautha prAdi viSayoM meM anAvazyaka piSTapeSaNa karake "jaina dharma kA maulika itihAsa" nAmaka graMtha meM thothe kA kada bar3hAne vAle prAcArya ne tIrthaMkara ke parama upAdeya bAraha guNoM kA varNana nahIM kiyA hai, yaha bAta unako tIrthakara paramAtmA ke prati nyUnabhakti kA paricaya karAtI hai| anya bAta yaha bhI hai ki devoM kI caivara DhulAne evaM puSpavRSTi mAdi pravRtti kA prApta bhagavAna ne kAma-bhoga kI taraha niSedha bhI nahIM kiyA hai / aura aisI ADambara yukta pravRtti meM lagane kI bajAya devatA zAMtacitta se dharmadezanA hI kyoM nahIM sunate ? aise praznoM kA spaSTIkaraNa bhI Avazyaka thaa| isakI bhI apUrNatA isa itihAsa meM pAyI gayI hai| isase isa tathya kI puSTi hotI hai ki AcArya ko anya bAtoM meM jitanI ruci hai itanI ruci arihaMta paramAtmA ke guNagAna meM nahIM hai / Age hama likha cuke haiM ki prAryA candanabAlA ke viSaya meM prAcArya likhate haiM ki 44.4 caMdanA ne jaba kucha samaya bAda yauvana meM padArpaNa kiyA to usakA anupama sauMdarya zataguNita ho utthaa| usakI kajjala se bhI adhika kAlI kaizarAzi bar3hakara unakI piNDaliyoM se aThakheliyAM karane lgii| 88x mImAMsA-aisI anAvazyaka bAtoM kI ruci kama hone para hI tIrthaMkara paramAtmA ke bAraha guNoM kA guNagAna ho sakatA hai| avasara prApta atyanta upAdeya tIrthaMkara ke bAraha guNoM kA guNagAna na karanA, guNa-guNI meM rahate haiM phira aSTaprAtihArya bAhara rahate hue bhI arihaMta ke guNa kaise ? bhagavAna ne unakI upasthiti meM hotI divyadhvani, puSpavRSTi prAdi kA niSedha kyoM nahIM kiyA hai ? aise aneka praznoM ko aspaSTa

Page #63
[ 25 ] rakhakara prAcArya ne jainadharma ke tIrthaMkaroM ke itihAsa ke viSaya meM apanI anabhijJatA evaM ajJatA sUcita kI hai| tathya to yaha hai ki vaitanika paMDitoM ke bala bUte para itihAsa kI racanA karavA lenA AsAna hai kintu binA gurugama aise praznoM kA rahasya pAnA AsAna nahIM hai| AzravoM ko heya-tyAjya kahakara chur3avAne vAle prApta tIrthaMkaroM ne devoM dvArA kI gayI divyadhvani, puSpavRSTi, caeNvara DhulAnA Adi pravRtti ko tyAjya nahIM kahA hai, anyathA kAma bhoga kI taraha unakA bhI prApta bhagavAna avazya niSedha krte| -nyAyavizArada pUjya yazovijayajI upAdhyAya

Page #64
[prakaraNa-6 ] zrI RSabhadeva kA nirvANa praura pAvana dAr3hA tIrthaMkara paramAtmA kA nirvANa hotA hai taba deva-devendra pAte haiM, bhagavAna ke pAvana deha ko snAna karAkara candanAdi kA vilepana karate haiM / bhagavAna ke deha ko candana kI citA para jalAyA jAtA hai / bAda meM bhagavAna kI pAvanadAr3hA deva devaloka meM le jAte haiM / deva bhagavAna ke zarIra ke avazeSoM kA Adara evaM pUjya bhAva se sevA-paryupAsanA karate haiN| praSTApadagiri para prathama tIrthaMkara zrI RSabhadeva bhagavAna kA nirvANa humA / isa viSaya meM prAcArya hastImalajI khaMDa 1, pR0 131 para likhate haiM ki 808 bhagavAna RSabhadeva kA nirvANa hote hI saudharmendra zaka Adi 64 devendroM ke Asana calAyamAna hue| ve saba indra apane apane vizAla deva parivAra aura adbhut divya Rddhi ke sAtha aSTApada parvata ke zikhara para amye / devarAja zaka kI AjJA se devoM ne tIna citAoM aura tIna zivikAoM kA nirmANa kiyaa| zaka ne kSIrodaka se prabhu ke pArthiva zarIra ko aura dUsare devoM ne maNadharoM tathA prabhu ke zeSa antevAsiyoM ke zarIroM ko kSIrodaka se snAna krvaayaa| una para gozIrSa caMdanakA vilepana kiyaa|444 xxx zaka kI AjJA se agnikumAroM ne kramazaH tInoM citAoM meM agni kI vikurvaNA kI aura vAyukumAra devoM ne agni ko prajvalita kiyaa|444

Page #65
27 ] xxx sabhI devendroM ne apanI apanI maryAdA ke anusAra prabhu kI dAdoM aura dAMtoM ko tathA zeSa kSetroM ke prabhu kI asthiyoM ko pahA kiyaa| mImAMsA-ukta kathana meM prAcArya ne "maryAdA ke anusAra" aisA likhakara kapaTa karanA cAhA hai kyoMki sirpha "maryAdA ke anusAra" likhanA ekAntavAda hone se anucita hai / sthAnakamArgI amolaka RSi kRta jaMbUdvIpa prajJapti ke pR0 100 para likhA hai ki Xxx kitaneka deva tIrthaMkaroM kI bhakti ke vaza se, kitaneka apanA jItAcAra samajha ke aura kitaneka ne dharma jAnakara ( dAr3hoM ko ) grahaNa kiyaa|xxx zAstra pATha yathA xxx "keI jiNe bhattie keI jIyamayaMtikaTu keI dhammottikaTTu gihati"777 mImAMsA-'jaMbUdvIpa prajJapti' prAgamAnusAra deva tIrthaMkara kI bhaktivaza aura dharma samajhakara bhI dAr3hoM ko grahaNa karate haiN| isaprakAra kA Agamika tathya hote hue bhI sirpha "maryAdAnusAra" likhane meM prAcArya kI ekAntavAdI haThadharmitA hI mAnanI caahie| prAcArya ko yaha bhUlanA nahIM cAhie ki yaha laukika dharmakaraNI nahIM hai, kintu lokottara dharma karaNI hai| tathA itihAsakAra prAcArya ne cAlAkI pUrvaka tIrthaMkara paramAtmA kI dAr3hoM vaMdanIya evaM paryupAsanIya haiM aura asthiyA~ bhI pUjanIya haiM isa satya tathya ko bhI gupta rakhA hai / sthAnakapaMthI amolakaRSi kRta zrI rAjapraznIya sUtra kA hindI anuvAda pR0 160 para likhA hai ki

Page #66
[ 28 ] XXXuna vajramaya gola DabboM meM bahuta jinakI dAr3hoM sthApa rakhI haiM, ve dAr3hoM sUriyAma deva ke, aura bhI bahuta se deva-deviyoM ke arcana yA vandana-paryupAsanIya haiN| 8xx mImAMsA-itihAsakAra prAcArya ne ukta tathya ko nahIM likhane meM hI apanA zreya samajhA hai, jo anucita hai| tIrthaMkara bhagavAna kI dAr3hoM vaMdanIya evaM paryupAsanIya hai aura asthiyAM bhI pUjanIya haiN| deva bhagavAna ke zarIra kA yat kiMcit avayava hAtha lagatA hai, unako bhI ve pUjyadRSTi se pUjakara apanA kalyANa samajhate haiN| zrI rAjapraznIya sUtra likhita tathya ko chipA karake prAcArya ne apramANikatA kI hai| tIrthaMkara paramAtmA kI parama pAvana AtmA isa pAvana dAr3hA meM bhI rahI thI isake kAraNa yaha zAntarasa se aisI bhAvita ho gayI hai ki do deva ke bIca lar3AI ho jAne para isa pavitra dAr3hA ke abhiSeka jala ko una para chir3akane se ve donoM deva zAnta ho jAte haiM / anya deva bhI bhagavAna kI haDDiyoM evaM anya ardhajalita aMgoM ko le jAte haiM, unakA bhI abhiSeka prAdi karate haiM / tIrthaMkara paramAtmA kI bhakti kA yaha bhI eka prakAra hai aisA zAstrIya ullekha hote hue bhI dAr3hoM ke viSaya meM paryupAsanA tathA vaMdana kI bAta prAcArya ne apane itihAsa meM kozoM dUra chor3a dI hai jo sarvathA anucita hI hai / ___durlabha manuSya janma prApta karane ke bAda tattvadarzIko sUtroktanIti ke anusAra vItarAga bhASita dharma kI ArAdhanA karanI caahie| manamAnI kalpanA para kiye hue dharma kI phUTI kaur3I kI bhI kImata nahIM hai / -1444 grantha racayitA pUjya haribhadrasUrijI mahArAja

Page #67
[ prakaraNa-7] zrI aSTApada giri para jina maMdira prathama tIrthaMkara zrI RSabhadeva bhagavAna kA aSTApada parvata para nirvANa huaA, vahA~ unake putra bharata cakravartI ne sone ke maMdira banavAkara caubIsoM bhagavAna ke zarIra kI U~cAI ke pramANa ratna kI pratimA cAra, pATha, dasa aura do ke krama se cAroM dizAoM meM virAjamAna kI thiiN| zrI RSabhadeva bhagavAna kI nirvANa bhUmi aSTApada parvata ke viSaya meM prAcArya likhate haiM ki xxx una cAra prakAra ke devoM ne kramazaH prabhu ko citA para, gaNadharoM kI citA para aura aNagAroM kI citA para tIna caityastUpa kA nirmANa kiyaa|xxx so . mImAMsA-prathama tIrthaMkara zrI RSabhadeva bhagavAna ke nirvANa sthala para devoM ne caityastUpa kA nirmANa kiyA kintu zrI ajitanAtha, zrI sambhavanAtha Adi tIrthaMkaroM kI nirvANa bhUmi para devoM ne caityastUpa kA nirmANa kiyA ki nahIM ? isa bAta ko prAcArya ne aspaSTa hI rakhI hai / prAcArya zrI malayagirijI ke kathanAnusAra bharata ne caityastUpa kA nirmANa karavAyA thaa| khaMDa 1, pR0 131 para prAcArya hastImalajI pUjyapAda zrI malayagiri mahArAja ke uddharaNa pUrvaka likhate haiM ki

Page #68
[ 30 ] xxx tathA bhagavaddehAdidagdhasthAneSu bharatena stUpAH kRtA, tato lokepi tataH Arabhya mRtakadAhasthAneSu stUpAH pravartante / [ Avazyaka malayagiri ] xxx arthAt-bhagavAna ke zarIra kA jahA~ dAha huA thA, usI sthAna para bharata ne stupa banavAyA, taba se loka meM bhI mRtaka dAha sthAna para stUpa banavAne kI pravRtti zuru huii| mImAMsA-jina caitya kaho yA jinastUpa kaho yA jina maMdira kaho eka hI bAta hai| apane pUjya upakArI zrI tIrthaMkara paramAtmA kI pratikRti, pratimA yA pAdukA maMdira Adi. meM virAjamAna karake unakI anupasthiti meM unakI caraNapAdukA, pratimA Adi kA vaMdana, pUjana, satkAra evaM sammAna karake samyagdarzanavanta bhavyajana prabhubhakti karate haiN| Agama zAstra meM bhI bharata dvArA jina maMdira banavAne kA ullekha hai / yathA zrI Avazyaka sUtrAntargata jagacintAmaNi caityavaMdana meM "aTThAvaya saMThaviya rUva, kamma? viNAsaNa" / tathA siddhastava meM "cattAri aTTha dasa doya, vaMdiyA jiNavarA cauvisaM" ityaadi| isa tathya se yaha siddha hotA hai ki caturtha pAre kI zuruAta se hI jinapratimA, jinapAdukA aura jinamaMdira the aura jina pratimA pUjA bhI thI yaha prAgamika satya hai / isa tathya ko prAmANika aura taTastha vyakti inkAra nahIM kara sktaa| AcArya pratimA pUjA aura jinamandira ke satya tathya ko svIkAra nahIM karate haiM, yaha unakI bhayaMkara bhUla hai| mUrtipUjA jaise satya viSaya ko vivAdAspada banAnA aura usake aitihAsika tathyoM se inkAra karanA sUrya ke sAmane dhUli pheMkane kI bAliza ceSTA mAtra hI hai| zrI Avazyaka sUtra meM bharata cakravartI ke banavAye jinamaMdira kA adhikAra hai|

Page #69
[ 31 ] yathA thubhasaya bhAugANaM cauvisaM ceva jiNagharekAsi / savva jiNANe paDimA, vaNNa pamANehiM niyaehi / / arthAt-eka sau bhAIyoM ke eka sau stUpa aura caubIsa tIrthaMkara ke jinamandira banavAkara usameM sarva tIrthaMkara kI pratimA apane varNa tathA zarIra ke pramANa sahita ( zrI aSTApada parvata Upara bharata cakravartI ne ) bnvaayii| aSTApadajI parvata para bharatacakravartI ne maMdira banavAye the isa viSaSa meM do prAcIna itihAsa bhI sAkSI dete haiN| eka "triSaSThi zalAkA puruSa caritra" nAmakA itihAsa jo mahAdhuraMdhara vidvAna kalikAla sarvajJa pUjya zrI hemacandrAcArya mahArAja ne racA hai aura dUsarA "cauvana mahApurisa cariyam" jo mahAna jainAcArya zrImad zIlAMkAcArya dvArA racita hai| uparokta donoM mahAn granthoM meM bhI aSTApadagiri para bharatacakravartI dvArA jinamaMdira banavAne kA ullekha hai| yaha donoM mahAn grantha aisA bhI kahate haiM ki dUsare tIrthaMkara zrI ajitanAtha bhagavAna ke cAcA sagaracakravartI ke 60 hajAra putroM ne isa aSTApada tIrtha kI rakSA meM prANa maMvAye the / isa bAta kA ullekha prAcArya hastImalajI ne "jaina dharma kA maulika itihAsa" pustaka meM khaMDa 1 pR0 165 para kiyA hai| yathA 044 sahasrAMzu Adi sagara ke 60 hajAra putra cakravartI sagara kI AjJA prApta kara senApati ratna, daNDa ratna Adi ratnoM aura eka bar3I senA ke sAtha bharata kSetra ke bhramaNa ke liye prasthita hue / aneka sthAnoM meM bhramaNa karate hue jaba ve aSTApada parvata ke pAsa Aye taba unhoMne aSTApada para jina maMdiroM ko dekhA aura unakI surakSA ke liye parvata ke cAroM ora eka khAI khodanekA vicAra

Page #70
[ 32 ] kiyA / ina donoM AcAryoM ke upari uddhata granthoM meM ullekha hai ki jaha~nu Adi una 60 hajAra sagara putroM ne bhavanapatiyoM ke bhavana taka khAI khoda DAlI / janu kumAra ne daNDa ratna ke prahAra se gaMgAnadI ke eka taTa ko khodakara gaMgA ke pravAha ko usa khAI meM pravAhita kara diyA aura khAI ko bhara diyaa| khAI kA pAnI bhavanapatiyoM ke bhavanoM meM pahuMcane se ve ruSTa hue aura nAgakumAroM ke roSa vaza una 60 hajAra sagara putroM ko dRSTiviSa se bhasmasAt kara DAlA / mImAMsA-prAcArya ne yahAM kapaTa karake aSTApada parvata para jinamaMdira thA isa tathya ko prAcArya zrI hemacandrasUrijI aura prAcArya zrI zIlAMgAcAryajI ke nAma se likhakara svayaM ko maMdira ke viSaya meM alipta rakhakara anyAya pUrNa kRtya kiyA hai / satya svIkArane kA avasara prAyA vahA~ cAlAkI pUrvaka anya ke nAma likha denA beImAnI hI mAnI jaayegii| Azcarya to yaha hai ki anya aitihAsika prasaMga inhIM granthoM meM se lekara vahAM prAcArya hastImalajI ne aisA vyakta nahIM kiyA hai ki pUrvAcAryoM ne aisA likhA hai, kintu vahAM to unhoMne svayaM apane nAma se hI likha diyA hai| phira jina maMdira aura jina pratimA kI bAta mAyI vahA~ aisA anyAya kyoM ? pUjya hemacandrAcArya mahArAja aura pUjya zologAcAryAdi aneka suvihita pUrvAcAryoM ke nAmollekha karake prAcArya hastImalajI khaMDa-1 (purAnI prAvRtti ) apanI bAta pR0 6 para likhate haiM ki xxxuparokta paryAloca ke bAda yaha kahanA kiMcit mAtra bhI atizayoktipUrNa nahIM hogA ki hamArA jaina itihAsa bahuta gaharI sudRr3ha nIMva para . khar3A hai| yaha idhara udhara ko kiMvadantI yA kalpanA ke AdhAra se nahIM para prAmANika pUrvAcAryoM kI avirala paramparA se prApta hai / ataH isakI vizvasanIyatA meM lezamAtra bhI zaMkA ko gujAiza nahIM rhtii|xxx

Page #71
[ 33 ] mImAMsA-uparokta satya tathya likhane vAle prAcArya hastImalajI kI kUTanIti dekho ki ve svayaM zrI praSTApada giri para jinamandira kI rakSA hetu jAna gaMvAne vAle sagara cakravartI ke jahna prAdi 60 hajAra putroM ke viSaya meM pUjya zIlAMgAcArya mahArAja aura pUjya hemacandrAcArya mahArAja Adi kathita sarva sudRr3ha zAstrIya pramANoM ko chor3akara paurANika kiMvadantI ko pramANita karate haiM, jo bAta unake mana kI asthiratA evaM pakSapAtapUrNatA kA sUcana karatI hai| __ prAcArya kaisI duraMgI nIti rIti apanAte haiM ki eka bhora to svIkAra karate haiM ki pUjya hemacandrAcArya mahArAja racita "triSaSThi zalAkA puruSa caritra" grantha prAmANika hai aura dUsarI ora isa grantha meM jinamandira, jina pratimA kI bAta pAyo vahA~ inkAra pUrvaka likha dete haiM ki aisI koI bAta mUla prAgama meM nahIM pAyI hai / 'triSaSThi zalAkA puruSa caritra' kI prAmANikatA ke viSaya meM khaMDa 1, pR0 56 para ve likhate haiM ki xxx yaha hai AcArya zrI hemacandrasUri dvArA viracita triSaSThi zalAkA puruSa caritra kA ullekha jo pichalI ATha zatAbdiyoM se bhI adhika samaya se lokapriya rahA hai| xx mImAMsA-bahuta sI aisI bAteM haiM jinako pramANita karane ke liye prAcArya "triSaSThi zalAkA puruSa caritra" kA sahArA lete haiM, kintu jina mandira aura jina pratimA viSayaka bAta mAnepara satyamArga se viparIta calakara turanta hI jhUTha kA sahArA le lete haiM / aSTApadajI tIrtha kI rakSA meM jahna, prAdi 60 hajAra sagara putroM ne vIragati pAyI thI aisA ullekha triSaSThi zalAkA puruSa caritra aura cauvana mahApurisa cariyama meM hote hue bhI maMdira ke virodha ke kAraNa prAcArya likha dete

Page #72
.. [ 34 ] haiM ki- "aisA koI ullekha mUlAgamoM meM dRSTigocara nahIM hotA hai|" kintu prAcArya ko duraMgI noti dekho ki 60 hajAra putroM kI mauta ke bAda sagara cakravartI kA viraha vilApa aura saMsAra vairAgya prAdi kA varNana zrI zIlAMgAcArya mahArAja racita "cauvana mahApurisa cariyaM" nAmaka grantha ke sahAre hI likhate haiN| prAzcarya to yaha hai ki yahA~ prAcArya hastImalajI ne aisA kyoM nahIM likhA ki "aisA koI ullekha mUlAgamoM meM dRSTigocara nahIM hotA hai|" zrI Avazyaka sUtra, zrI siddhastava Adi aneka prAcIna graMthoM evaM pUjya hemacandrAcArya mahArAja aura pUjya zolAMgAcArya mahArAja jaise satyavatI prAcIna granthakAroM ne likhA hai ki praSTApada parvata sthita jinamaMdiroM kI rakSA hetu khAI khodane aura usameM gaMgA kA pAnI pravAhita karane para nAga devatA ke kopa meM jahna Adi 60 hajAra sagaraputroM ne jAna gaMvAyI thI / pUrvAcAryoM ke isa satya kathana ko asatya kahakara prAcArya hastImalajI ne kiMvadantI svarUpa paurANika gapor3e kA pakSa karake jina mandira evaM jinapratimA viSayaka apanI dveSa parAyaNatA kA paricaya khaMDa 1, pR0 165 para diyA hai / yathA xxx saMbhava hai, purANoM meM zatAzvameghI kI kAmanA karane vAle mahArAja sagara ke yajJAzva ko indra dvArA pAtAla loka meM kapilamuni ke pAza bAMdhane aura sagaraputroM ke vahAM pahuMcakara kolAhala karane se kapilaRSi dvArA bhasmasAt karane kI ghaTanA se prabhAvita hoM jainAcAryoM ne aisI kathA prastuta kI ho|xxx mImAMsA-aisA anartha karane vAle prAcArya ke aitihAsika jJAna para hameM tarasa AtA hai / dRSTirAga evaM jinamandira viSayaka dveSa ke kAraNa hI isa apramANika paurANika gapor3e ko prAcArya ne Age

Page #73
[ 35 ] kiyA hai| phira khaMDa 1 (purAnI prAvRtti ) apanI bAta pR0 26 para likhanA ki-"sAmpradAyika abhinivezavaza koI bhI apramANika bAta nahIM Ave isa bAta kA dhyAna rakhA gayA hai" yaha nitAMta galata evaM bhrAntipUrNa hI sAbita hotA hai / kyoMki pUrvAcAryoM ke kathana ko jhUThA karake anya ke asatya kathana ko Age karanA kyA apramANikatA nahIM hai ? "triSaSThi zalAkA puruSa caritra" aura 'cauvana mahApurisa cariyA" ina doM mahAna graMthoM meM likhita yuktiyukta prAmANika bAta na mAnake aura "saMbhava hai" aisA likhakara purANoM kI kiMvadantI ko mAna karake prAcArya ne vizvAsaghAta kiyA hai| pUrvAcAryoM ke granthoM ke sahAre itihAsa likhanA aura jinamandira evaM jina pratimA kI bAta pAye vahA~ kRtaghnatApUrvaka yaha kaha denA ki-"pUrvAcAryoM ne purANoM kI kathA se prabhAvita hokara aisI kahAnI prastuta karadI hai, jo nitAMta galata hai / " phira to bahuta sI bAteM purANoM kI kathA se prabhAvita hokara prAcIna jainAcAryoM ne kahI hai, aisI mUrkhatApUrNa bAta kahane kI evaM mAnane ko Apatti bhI AsakatI hai| kalpanA kI uDAna meM bhaTakate hue prAcArya apanI dhuna meM yaha bhI tulanA karanA bhUla gaye haiM ki vaha purANa kI ukti prAcIna hai yA apane AcAryoM kI ukti prAcIna hai ? agara yaha tulanA kI jAtI to ve aisA likhane kA mahAn sAhasa nahIM kara pAte / jaina pUrvAcAryoM ke kathanoM ko jhUThA kahane vAle yaha kyoM bhUla jAte haiM ki phira unake kathana para kauna vizvAsa karegA ? . -nyAya vizArada pUjya prAcArya zrI bhuvanabhAnusUrIzvarajI mahArAja - -

Page #74
[ prakaraNa-8] pUrvAcAryoM kA mahAna upakAra pUjya devaddhigaNi kSamAzramaNa, navAMgI TIkAkAra zrI abhayadeva sUri mahArAja, vAdivetAla zrI zAMtasUri mahArAja, zrI malayagiri mahArAja, zrI zIlAMgAcAryajI, pUjya zrI haribhadrasUrijI, kalikAla sarvajJa zrI hemacandrAcArya mahArAja, pUjya zrI malladhArI hemacandrAcArya mahArAja Adi anekAneka prAtaHsmaraNIya sugRhItanAmadheya pUrvAcAryoM ne mAgama evaM prAgametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya ko jIvaMta rakhakara mahAna upakAra kiyA hai jisakA badalA hama cukA nahIM sakate haiN| ina mahAna pUrva puruSoM ne hI jinapratimA aura jinamandira dvArA tathA prAgamazAstroM para sarala arthapUrNa vRtti, cUNi, bhASya evaM TIkAdi racakara jaina saMskRti ko Aja taka jIvaMta rakhA hai| yadyapi prAcArya hastImalajI evaM unakA sthAnakapaMthI samudAya jinapratimA tathA jinamaMdira aura vRtti, cUrNi, bhASya evaM TIkAdi para avizvAsa evaM anAdara karate haiM, kintu Azcarya to isa bAta kA hai ki ina vRtti, cUNi, bhASya, TIkAdi ke sahAre binA ve loga AgamagranthoM kA hindI yA gujarAtI bhAdi bhASA meM sahI sahI anuvAda bhI nahIM karapAte haiM / phira bhI ina pUrvAcAryoM kI burAI karane meM sthAnakapaMthI bAja nahIM pAte haiM / sthAnakapaMthI amolaka RSi "zAstroddhAra mImAMsA" pR0 53 para likhate haiM ki

Page #75
[ 37 ] 888 zrI jainadharma pracArArtha zrI mahAvIrasvAmIjI ke nirvANa ke 1242 varSa meM zailAMgAcArya ne AcArAMga aura sUyagaDAMga kI TIkA banAI, 1590 varSa pIche abhayadevasUri ne sthAnAMga se vipAka paryanta 9 aMga kI TIkA banAI, isake bAda malayagiri AcArya ne rAjapraznIya, jIvAbhigama, pannavaNA candra prajJapti, sUrya prajJapti, vyavahAra aura naMdIjI ina 7 sUtroM kI TokA banAI, candrasUrijI ne nirayAvalI kA paMcaka ko TIkA banAI, aise hI abhayadeva sUri ke ziSya malladhArI hemacandrAcArya ne anuyoga dvAra kI TokA banAI, kSemakIrtijI ne bRhatkalpa kI TIkA kI, zAMtisUrijI ne zrI uttarAdhyayanajI kI vRtti-TIkA. cUNikA-niyukti vagairaha sahita savistAra banAyA ina TIkAkAroM ne aneka sthAna mUlasUtra kI apekSA rahIta va vartamAna meM svataH kI pravRtti ko puSTa karane jaise manaHkalpita artha bhara diye / 88x mImAMsA-sthAnakamArgI amolaka RSi meM ina TIkAkAra mahApuruSoM kI apekSA jJAna kA aMza mAtra bhI honA asambhava hai, phira bhI isa mahAzaya ne pUrvAcAryoM ko jhUThA karane meM koI korakasara nahIM chor3I hai yaha atyanta kheda kI bAta hai / yadyapi amolakaRSi dvArA unake mAne hue 32 prAgamoM kA hindI bhASA meM anuvAda ina pUrvAcAryoM kI TIkAdi ke sahAre hI kiyA gayA hai, aisA svIkAra usane apane "zAstroddhAra mImAMsA" nAmaka pustaka meM kiyA hai aura jinapratimA evaM jinamaMdira para virodha ke kAraNa sUtroM ke atha ko to amolakaRSi ne hI palaTA hai, phira bhI ulTA cora kotavAla ko DAMTe vAlI bAta siddha karate haiM / utsUtra bhASaNa ko vajrapApa samajhane vAle bhavabhIru mahopakArI pUrvAcAryoM ko "mana:kalpita artha karane vAle" kahanA mahAkRtaghnatA ke sivAya aura kyA hai ? "jJAnalava duvidagdhaM brahmApi naraM na raMjayati" isa sUkti ko amolakaRSi caritArtha kara gaye haiM / kintu pUrvAcAryoM ko jhUThA karane meM sAdhvAbhAsa amolakajI yaha bAta sarvathA bhUla hI gaye haiM ki phira unake kathana ko satya kauna mAnegA ?

Page #76
[ 38 ] sthAnakapaMthI prAcArya, sAdhu Adi chalakapaTa dvArA sUtroM evaM arthoM meM parivartana karate haiM, isakA nUtana udAharaNa yaha hai ki sthAnakapaMthI akhimeza muni dvArA saMkalita, sammati jJAnapITha AgarA dvArA mudrita "maMgalavANI" nAmaka kitAba ke navasmaraNa meM se "bar3I zAMti" nAmaka nauveM smaraNa [10 267-saMskaraNa gyArahavA ] ko manamAnI karake saMkSipta kara diyA gayA hai / "bRhat zAMti" stotra meM se mUrtipUjA samarthaka pAThoM ko Age-pIche se nikAla denA eka prakAra kI taskaravRtti hI hai / phira ye loga eka dina sAhUkAra bhI bana sakate haiM ki zvetAmbaroM ne bRhat zAMti stotra meM kucha pATha 'prakSepa kara diyA hai|" sthAnaka paMthiyoM kI isa prakAra kI kupravRttiyoM para zvetAmbara jaina samAja ko gaMbhIratA se vicAra karanA caahie| prAcArya hastImalajI pUrvAcAryoM ke nAma dekara unake prati kRtajJabhAva pUrvaka khaMDa-1 ( purAnI prAvRtti ) pR0 6 para apanI bAta meM likhate haiM ki xxx uparokta paryAlocana ke bAda yaha kahanA kiMcitmAna bhI atizayoktipUrNa nahIM hogA ki hamArA jaina itihAsa bahuta gaharI sudRr3ha nIMva para khar3A hai / yaha idhara udhara kI kiMbadantI yA kalpanA ke AdhAra se nahIM para prAmANika pUrvAcAryoM kI avirala paramparA se prApta hai / ataH isakI vizvasanIyatA meM lezamAtra bhI zaMkA kI guMjAiza nahIM rhtii| ___ mImAMsA-kintu ukta bAta likhanA kapaTapUrNa evaM bhole janoM ko bhrama meM DAlane hetu hI hai| kyoMki vRtti, cUrNi, bhASya aura TIkAdi zAstroM meM prAcArya hastImalajI svayaM vizvAsa nahIM karate haiM / sAtha hI sAtha pUrvAcAryoM ke kathana ko apramANika kahakara paurANika kiMvadantI svarUpa kalpanA ke samarthaka bhI yahI prAcArya haiN| .

Page #77
[ 36 ] sagara cakravartI ke 60 hajAra putroM ne aSTApadajI tIrtha kI rakSA hetu jAna gaMvAyI thI aisA pUrvAcAryoM kA AgamAnusArI kathana hote hue bhI prAcArya khaMDa-1, pR0 165 para paurANika kiMvadantI likhate haiM ki 88 saMbhava hai, purANoM meM zatAzvameghI kI kAmanA karanevAle mahArAja sagara ke yajJAzva ko indra dvArA pAtAla loka meM kapilamuni ke pAza bAMdhane aura sagaraputroM ke vahA~ kolAhala karane se kapilaRSi dvArA bhasmasAt karane kI ghaTanA se prabhAvita hoM jainAcAryoM ne aisI kathA prastute ko ho| mImAMsA-dekhiye, prAcArya hastImalajI jisa DAla para baiThe haiM usIke Upara kuThArAghAta kara rahe haiM / sunI-sunAI kalpita bAta likhane ke pIche prAcArya kA jaina tIrthoM ke prati bahuta bar3A pakSapAta hI siddha hotA hai / ukta bAta se yaha spaSTa hotA hai ki prAgametara prAcIna sAhitya ke racayitA pUrvAcAryoM para prAcArya hastImalajI ko avizvAsa hai| lekina dUsarI ora ve "ina pUrvAcAryoM ne pravacana ko surakSita rakhA" aiso prAtmavaMcaka prazaMsA bhI karate haiN| kintu ye pUrvApara virodhI bAteM unake asthira citta kI paricAyaka mAtra haiN| khaMDa-2 pR0 13 "apanI bAta' meM prAcArya likhate haiM ki 80 prathamAnuyoga aura gaNDikAnuyoga ke vilupta ho jAne ke bAda jaina itihAsa ko surakSita rakhane kA zreya eka mAtra pUrvAcAryoM kI zrutasevA ko hai / isa viSaya meM unhoMne jo yogadAna diyA hai, vaha kabhI bhulAyA nahIM jA sakatA / AgamAzrita niyukti, cUNi, bhASya aura TokAdi granthoM ke mAdhyama se unhoMne jo upakAra kiyA hai, vaha Aja ke itihAsa gaveSakoM ke liye bar3A hI sahAyaka siddha ho rahA hai|xxx

Page #78
[ 40 ] mImAMsA-itihAsa gaveSakoM ke liye pUrvAcAryoM dvArA racita mAgamAzrita niyukti, cUrNi, bhASya aura TIkA prAdi zAstra sahAyaka siddha ho rahe haiM, isa sahAyatA se satya kI gaveSaNA karake prAcArya satyatathya AtmasAt kareM, tabhI unakI kathanI aura karanI eka ho sakatI hai / . Azcarya to isa bAta kA hai ki prAcArya ne svamAnyatA poSaka evaM jinamandira virodhaka itihAsa eka nAmadhArI samiti dvArA banavAyA hai, kintu pUrvAcAryoM ke kathana evaM aitihAsika tathyoM para nahIM / aisI dazA meM jainAgama aura Agametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya vRtti, cUrNi, bhASya, TIkAdi zAstra evaM maMdira, mUrtiyAM Adi purAtana avazeSoM ko ve indrajAla hI siddha kara rahe haiM / isa para bhI ina sabako sahAyaka likhanA AtmavaMcanA mAtra pratIta hotA hai / jaba taka AcArya hastImalajI jaina itihAsa ke mUlastambha jainAgama, pUrvAcAryoM dvArA racita pAgametara jaina sAhitya vRtti, cUNi, bhASya evaM TIkAdi zAstroM kA satya mAdhAra evaM maMdira aura jinapratimA ke viSaya meM aitihAsika prAcIna avazeSoM kA tathya hote hue bhI mUrtipUjA jaise vAstavika satya viSaya ko vivAdAspada banAyeMge yA unake viSaya meM haThadharmitA rakheMge taba taka ve itihAsa likhane para bhI aMdhere meM hI haiM aura rheNge| jainAgama aura Agametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya vRtti, cUriNa, bhASya aura TIkAdi zAstra jisake dila meM haiM, vAstava meM usake dila meM sAkSAt vItarAga hI baiThe haiN| -1444 granthakartA pUjya haribhadrasUrijI mahArAja

Page #79
[prakaraNa-] mAkumAra aura jina pratimA pUrvabhava meM cAritra kI ArAdhanA zabala ( sadoSa ) rUpa se karane para anArya deza meM janme hue rAjaputra prArdrakumAra ne magadha samrATa zreNika ke putra abhayakumAra ke guNagAna sunakara unako upahAra bhejA aura unase maitrI cAhI / bhavya jIva jAnakara buddhinidhAna abhayakumAra ne ArdrakumAra ko dharma premI banAne hetu prathama tIrthaMkara zrI RSabhadeva bhagavAna kI ratna kI pratimA bheTa bhejI aura ArdrakumAra ko kahalAyA ki isa upahAra ko ekAnta meM kholnaa| parama vItarAga zrI RSabhadeva bhagavAna kI mUrti-pratimA ko dhyAna se dekhate dekhate prArdrakumAra ko pUrvajanma kA smRti jJAna ho gayA aura jinapratimA ke darzana se unheM samakipta lAbha huaa| pUrvajanma kA sAdhupana yAda Ane ke kAraNa tathA sAdhu banane kI tIvra bhAvanA se usane anArya deza se bhAgakara magadhadeza meM prAkara cAritra grahaNa kiyaa| jina pratimA dekhakara prArdrakumAra ko pUrvajanma kA jAtismaraNa jJAna evaM bodhi lAbha huaA thA, isa viSaya meM zrI sUryagaDAMga sUtra, dUsarA zrutaskandha, chaTThA adhyayana meM kahA hai kixxxpItIya doNha dUo, pucchaNamabhayassa patthaveso u| teNAvi sammadiditti, hojja paDimArahaMmigayA // baTuM sambuddho rakkhio ya / Xxx

Page #80
[ 42 ] vyAkhyA-[ yadukta zrI sUtrakRtAMge dvitIya zrutaskandhe SaSThAdhyayane ] anyadA kapitrA janahastena rAjagRhe zreNikarAjJaH prAbhRtaM preSitam / Adra kakumAreNa zreNikasutAyAbhayakumArAya snehakaraNArtha prAbhRtaM tasyeva hastena preSitam / jano rAjagRhe gatvA zreNikarAjJaH prAbhRtAni niveditavAn sammAnitazca rAjJA Aka prahitAni prAbhRtAni cAbhayakumArAya dattavAn, kathitAni snehotpAda. kAni vacanAni / abhayenAciti nUnamasau bhavyaH syAdAsannasiddhiko, yo mayA sAddha prItimicchatIti / tato'bhayena prathamajinapratimA bahuprAbhRtayutA''dbhakakumArAya prahitA, idaM prAbhUtamekAnte nirUpaNIyamityukta janasya / sopyA kapuraM gatvA yathokta kathayitvA prAbhRtamArpayat / pratimAM nirUpayataH kumArasya jAtismaraNamutpanna, dharme pratibaddha manaH abhayaM smaran vairAgyAtkAmabhogeSvanAsaktastiSThati / pitrAjJAtaM mAkvacidasau yAyAditi paMcazata subhaTanityaM rakSyate ityAdi / arthAt-eka dina prArdrakumAra ke pitA ne dUta ke sAtha rAjagRha nagarI meM zreNika rAjA ko upahAra bhejA / pArdrakumAra ne zreNika rAjA ke putra abhayakumAra ke sAtha maitrI karane hetu usI dUta ke hAtha upahAra bhejA / dUtane rAjagRha meM jAkara zreNika rAjA ko upahAra diye / zreNika rAjA ne bhI dUta kA yathAyogya sanmAna kiyA aura ArdrakumAra dvArA bheje gaye upahAra ko abhayakumAra ko diyA tathA snehavacana kahe / abhayakumAra ne socA ki nizcaya yaha bhavya hai aura nikaTa mokSagAmI hai, jo mere sAtha prIti cAhatA hai / taba abhayakumAra ne bahuta prAbhUta sahita prathama tIrthaMkara zrI RSabhadeva bhagavAna kI pratimA-mUrti ArdrakumAra ko bheMTa bhejI aura dUta ko saMdeza diyA ki yaha bheMTa prArdrakumAra ko ekAnta meM dikhaanaa| dUtane bhI Ardrakapura meM jAkara yathokta saMdeza kahakara bheMTa de dI / jinapratimA ko dekhate dekhate ArdrakumAra ko jAtismaraNa jJAna utpanna ho gayA evaM usakA mana dharma meM pratibodhita huA / abhayakumAra ko yAda karatA huA, vairAgya se kAma-bhogoM meM pAsakta nahIM hotA huA ArdrakumAra vahA~ rahA hai| prArdrakumAra ke pitA

Page #81
[ 43 ] ne putra prArdra ko vairAgI jAnakara, yaha kahIM calA nahIM jAe isa vAste 500 subhaToM ke bIca meM usako rakhA, ityAdi / zrI sUyagaDAMga sUtra meM yaha bhI ullekha kiyA hai ki jaba taka ArdrakumAra ne cAritra-dIkSA grahaNa nahIM kI taba taka vaha abhayakumAra se prApta jina pratimA kI pratidina pUjA karatA rahA thaa| ArdrakumAra ke ukta kathAnaka ke viSaya meM jinapratimA kI bAta Ane ke kAraNa tathya ko tor3a-maror3a kara prAcArya hastImalajI "apanI bAta" khaNDa 1, pR0 30 para likhate haiM ki xxx abhayakumAra ne anArya dezastha apane pitA ke mitra anArya nareza ke rAjakumAra ( Ardra) ko dharma premI banAne ke liye "dharmopagaraNa (?)" kI bheMTa bhejii| xx __mImAMsA-ukta kathana prAcArya ne kauna se prAcIna zAstra ke AdhAra para kiyA hai yaha unheM prAmANikatA pUrvaka kahanA cAhiye / zrI sUyagaDAMga sUtra, bharatezvaravRtti, zrI pArdrakumAra caritra prAdi prAcIna graMthoM meM abhayakumAra ne prArdrakumAra ko ( zrI RSabhadeva bhagavAna kI ) jinapratimA bhejI aisA spaSTa kathana hote hue bhI jinapratimA viSayaka svamatavirodha ke kAraNa prAcArya ne sunI-sunAI svamati kalpita bAta likha dI hai, jisameM satya kA sarvathA abhAva hI hai| yadyapi katipaya sthAnakapaMthI lekhaka apanI pustakoM meM aisA likhate haiM ki abhayakumAra ne ArdrakumAra ko "muMhapattI kA Tukar3A" bhejA thaa| koI "aodhA ( rajoharaNa)" bhejane kA bhI likhate haiM, joM zAstra nirapekSa hone ke kAraNa nitAMta asatya hai| jaina dharma ke viSaya meM svotprekSita tarka evaM kalpanA zakti ke AdhAra para itihAsa likhane vAle AcArya hastImalajI ne yahA~

Page #82
[ 44 ] "dharmopagaraNa" aisA likhakara sArA mAmalA golamola hI rakhA hai| yAnI abhayakumAra ne prArdrakumAra ko "dharmopagaraNa" ke rUpa meM kyA jinapratimA bhejI thI? kyA muMhapattI kA Tukar3A bhejA thA? kyA sAmAyika karane kA prAsana bhejA thA ? kyA podhA ( rajoharaNa ) bhejA thA? kyA pUjanI bhejI thI ? prazna to yaha hotA hai ki prAcArya mAne jAne vAle hastImalajI "jina pratimA" ke viSaya meM jhUTha kA sahArA lekara beImAnI kyoM kara rahe haiM ? woman TIkA cUNi bhASya uvakhyA, uvekhI niyukti / pratimA dveSe sUtra uvekhyA, dUra rahI tujha mukti / -nyAyavizArada pUjya yazovijayajI upAdhyAyajI

Page #83
[prakaraNa-10] jarAsaMdha aura kRSNa ke bIca yuddha ___ vAsudeva kRSNa aura prativAsudeva jarAsaMdha ke bIca yuddha huA / jarAsaMdha ne jarA nAma kI vidyA se kRSNa ke sainikoM ko hataprabha kara diyaa| jarA kI bImArI ke kAraNa yAdava sainya ko lar3AI lar3ane meM asamartha dekhakara, jarA nivAraNa hetu vanamAlI ne aTThama ( tIna upavAsa ) tapa kiyaa| tapa ke prabhAva se tuSTa hokara dharaNendra kI agramahiSI padmAvatI devI ne mahimAvantI zrI pArzvanAtha bhagavAna kI pratimA dii| jisake abhiSeka jala chir3akane se saba hI sainikoM kI mUrchA dUra huI / usa samaya neminAthajI ne vijaya sUcaka zaMkhanAda kiyaa| zaMkhapUrane ke kAraNa vahAM zaMkhezvara nAma kA gA~va basAyA, isa zaMkhezvara gAMva meM pArzvanAthajI kI pratimA virAjamAna kI gayI aura taba se pArzvanAthajI kA eka nAma " zaMkhezvara pArzvanAtha" pdd'aa| Aja bhI gujarAta ke mehasANA jile meM 'zaMkhezvarajI tIrtha" maujUda hai / zrI kalpasUtra kI TIkA meM bhI isakA ullekha hai| ukta viSaya meM zrI zubhavIra vijaya mahArAja sAhaba kA banAyA stavana jaina samAja meM pratyanta prasiddha hai / yathA zaMkhapurI sabako jagAve, zaMkhezvara gAma basAve / maMdira meM prabhu padharAve, zaMkhezvara nAma dharAve re / /

Page #84
[ 46 ] nAmaka pustaka, jisakA saMkalana sthAnaka mArgI akhileza muni ne kiyA hai| jisake pR0 271 ( gyArahavAM saMskaraNa ) para pArzvanAtha bhagavAna kA stotra diyA hai| jisameM zrI pArzvanAthajI kA eka vizeSaNa "zrI zaMkhezvara maMDana pArzvajina" likhA hai| arthAt-zaMkhezvara gAMva ke siratAja zrI pArzvanAtha bhagavAna / isase bhI zaMkhezvara pArzvanAtha nAma ke tIrtha kI puSTi hotI hai / zaMkhezvara pArzvanAtha bhagavAna kI pratimA ke viSaya meM zrI pArzvanAtha caritra aura harivaMza caritra meM isa prakAra kA ullekha pAtA hai ki gata caubIsI ke dAmodara nAma ke tIrthaMkara bhagavAna ko prASAr3hI nAma ke zrAvaka ne pUchA ki-he bhagavan ! saMsAra se merA nistAra kaba hogA? taba dAmodara bhagavAna ne usako batAyA ki mAgAmI caubIsI ke tevIsaveM tIrthaMkara zrI pArzvanAtha bhagavAna ke tuma gaNadhara banoge taba tumhArA mokSa hogaa| aisA sunakara prabhu pArzvanAtha kI pratimA usane banavAyI thii| zrI zubhavIra vijayajI mahArAja kRta "zaMkhezvara pArzvanAtha stavana" meM bhI ukta bAta kA jikra AtA hai| yathA saMvege tajI ghara vAso, prabhu pArzva ke gaNadhara thaasho| taba muktipurI meM jAzo, guNIloka meM vayaNe gavAzo re / / zaMkhezvara sAhiba saaco| ima dAmodara jina vANI, prASAr3hI zrAvake jaannii| jina vaMdI nija ghara pAve, prabhu pArzvakI pratimA bharAve re // - zaMkhezvara sAhiba saaco|

Page #85
[ 47 ] khaMDa-1, pR0 352 se 362 taka meM jarAsaMdha aura kRSNa kI lar3AI kA laMbA caur3A varNana triSaSThi zalAkA puruSa caritra, cauvana mahApuriSa cariyaM, vasudeva hinDI Adi prAgametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya se karane vAle prAcArya hastImalajI ne "zrI neminAtha ne zaMkha dhvani kI" isa bAta kA jikra kiyA hai, kintu padmAvatI devI pradatta pArzvanAtha kI pratimA ke abhiSeka jala se yAdava sainya kI jarA kI bImArI naSTa huI bhAdi bahuta se tathyoM para pardA DAla diyA hai, yaha kitanA prAzcarya hai ! itihAsa likhane baiThe haiM aura aitihAsika tathya ko chipA rahe haiM, aise itihAsa ko kauna satya mAnegA? viSama kAle jinabiMba jinAgama bhavijana ko aadhaaraa|

Page #86
[ prakaraNa-11] vaizAlI meM zrI munisuvrata svAmI kA stUpa zreNika mahArAjA ke putra kUriNaka ne vizAlA nagarI para car3hAI kii| usI nagarI meM bIsaveM tIrthaMkara zrI munisuvrata svAmI kI pAdukA sthApita thI, jisase nagarI para kUNika vijaya nahIM pA sake the| isakA varNana zrI nandIsUtra meM pR0 61 para hai / yathA 444 vizAlAyAM puryA kUlavAlakena vizAlA bhaGgAya yanmunisuvrata pAdukA stUpotkhAta sA tasya pAriNAmikI buddhiH|xxx bhAvArtha-vizAlA nagarI kA nAza karane ke liye zrI munisuvrata svAmI ke pAdukA sahita stUpa ko ukhAr3ane se nagarI kA bhaMga ho skegaa| aisA kathana kUlavAlaka muni ne kiyA yaha pAriNAmika buddhi se| vaizAlI ke vinAza ke viSaya meM prAcArya hastImalajI ne khaMDa1, pR0 746 se 754 taka lambA varNana kiyA hai, kintu isa stUpa ke viSaya meM aitihAsika vivaraNa nahIM diyA hai / vaizAlI ke vinAza kA saMkSipta itihAsa isaprakAra hai| rAjA zreNika ke putra kUNika aura vaizAlI ke rAjA ceTaka ke bIca bhayaMkara yuddha huA / kUNika kA bahuta dinoM taka vaizAlI para gherA par3A rahA / lAkhoM sainikoM ke saMhAra hone para bhI kUNika se vaizAlI

Page #87
[ 46 ] nagarI jItI nahIM jA sakI / daivI zakti dvArA kUNika ko jJAta huA ki vaizAlI nagarI meM zrI munisuvratasvAmI kA prAcIna stUpa hai, jisake prabhAva se vaizAlI avijita rahI hai| avijita vaizAlI nagarI para vijaya pAne ke liye bhagavAna ke stUpa ko tor3anA Avazyaka thaa| ataH kUlavAlaka nAma ke muni ko mAgadhikA nAma kI vezyA dvArA caritrabhraSTa karavAkara naimittika ke rUpa meM gupta rIti se vaizAlI meM praveza karavAyA gayA / varSoM ke yuddha se parezAna janatA ne naimittika kUlavAlaka ko yuddha mukti kA upAya pUchA / kUlavAlaka ne zrI munisuvrata svAmI kA stUpa tor3a dene para yuddha samApti batAyI / kAphI pracAra ke bAda logoM ne kUlavAlaka kI bAta para vizvAsa kara stUpa ko tor3a diyaa| pUrva saMketa ke anusAra kUNika ne pahile sainikoM ko vaizAlI se dUra haTA liyA, kintu bAda meM vaizAlI para AkramaNa karake isako jIta liyaa| khaNDa 1, pR0 753 para prAcArya likhate haiM ki 44 duzmana ke ghere se Ube hue nAgarikoM ne phUlavAlaka ko naimittika samajhakara bar3I utsukatA se pUchA-vidvan ! zatru kA yaha gherA kaba taka haTegA? kUlavAlaka ne upayukta avasara dekhakara kahA-"yaha stUpa bar3e azubha muhUrta meM banA hai| isI ke kAraNa nagara ke cAroM ora gherA par3A huA hai| yadi ise tor3a diyA jAya to zatru kA gherA haTa jaaygaa| kucha logoM ne stUpa ko tor3anA prArambha kiyaa| phUlavAlaka ne kUNika ko saMkata se sUcita kiyA / kUNika ne apane sainikoM ko gherA samApti kA Adeza diyaa| stUpa ke ISat bhaMga kA tatkAla camatkAra dekhakara nAgarika bar3I saMkhyA meM stUpa kA nAmonizAM taka miTA dene ke liye TUTa pdd'e| kucha hI kSaNoM meM stUpa kA cinha taka nahIM rhaa|

Page #88
[ 50 ] phUlabAlaka se iSTasiddhi kA saMketa pAkara kUNika ne vaizAlI para prabala AkramaNa kiyaa| use isa bAra vaizAlI kA prAkAra bhaMga karane meM saphalatA prApta ho gii|xxx mImAMsA-ina saba bAtoM se isa tathya kI Thosa puSTi hotI hai ki usa samaya meM bhI yAnI prAja se karIba 2500 varSa pahile bhI vaizAlI nagarI meM zrI munisuvrata svAmI kA prabhAvazAlI stUpa thA arthAt jima maMdira thA, jisake kAraNa hI vaizAlI avijita rahI thii| jinastUpa ke aise avarNanIya prabhAva ko evaM jinamandira viSayaka tathya kA sthAnakapaMthI prAcArya ne yahAM prasaMga prApta vizada varNana nahIM kiyA hai jo anucita hai / prAcArya ne apane itihAsa meM yaha bhI nahIM likhA hai ki yaha stUpa kaba banA thA ? zrI mahAvIra svAmI ke samaya meM bhI isakI mahimA thI, Adi tathyoM ko bhI prAcArya ne chipAyA hai| phira bhI Aja se 2500 sAla pahile bhI vaizAlI meM jinastUpa yAnI jinamandira thA, isase mUrtipUjA viSayaka Thosa tathya ko itihAsakAra prAcArya kyA svIkAra kareMge ? kyA prAcArya satya ko satya rUpa meM pasaMda kareMge? sUtramapAsya jar3A bhASante, kecana matamutsUtram re / kiM kurmaste parihRta payaso, yadi piyante mUtram re / arthAt-sUtra nIti ko chor3akara mUrkha-jar3a utsUtra bolatA hai| jo svAdiSTa dUdha ko chor3akara pizAba pItA hai, unake liye hama kyA kara sakate haiM ? -pU0 vinaya vijayajI upAdhyAya

Page #89
[ prakaraNa-12] mArya zrI zayyaMbhava sUri maura jina pratimA jisaprakAra zrI munisuvrata svAmI ke stUpa ke kAraNa vaizAlI nagarI kA vinAza saMbhava na ho sakA thA, ThIka usIprakAra yajJastambha (yUpa) ke nIce rahI bhagavAna zrI zAMtinAthajI kI prabhAvazAlI pratimA ke kAraNa zayyaMbhava brAhmaNa kA yajJAdi phalaphUla rahA thA aura bAda meM ve pratimA darzana ke kAraNa hI jainadIkSA meM pratibuddha hue the| zrI mahAvIra svAmI kI pATa paramparA meM zrI sudharmA svAmI ke bAda cauthe zrI zayyaM bhava sUrijI paaye| Apane zrI dazavakAlika sUtra kI racanA kI thI / Arya zrI zayyaMbhava sUri ke viSaya meM zrI dazavaikAlika niyukti zAstra tathA triSaSThi zalAkA puruSa caritra itihAsa kazrita kathAnaka isa prakAra hai| prArya zrI prabhavasvAmI ko apane samudAya meM caturvidha zrI saMgha saMcAlaka tejasvI sAdhu nahIM milA / rAjagRha nagara nivAsI, yajJAnuSThAna nirata zayyaM bhava brAhmaNa ko jJAnavala se suyogya jAnakara Apa rAjagRhI meM padhAre aura do sAdhutroM ko saMketa pUrvaka zayyaMbhava ke yajJamaMDapa para gocarI ke liye bhejA / zayyaMbhava brAhmaNa ne yajJamaMDapa ( sthala ) apavitra hone ke Dara se unako rokaa| taba sAdhu bole ki-"tuma tattva nahIM jAnate" / zayyaMbhava ne yajJagorapurohita ko tattva pUchA / pradhAna purohita ne yajJayAga aura veda ko hI tattva btaayaa| isa para bhI zayyaMbhava kI jijJAsA zAMta na huI aura kruddha

Page #90
[ 52 ] hokara usane talavAra nikAlI, taba jAna khatare meM jAnakara purohita ne batAyA ki-"sukha caina se yajJa ho rahA hai aura tuma phUla phala rahe ho, isakA kAraNa yajJa stambha ke nIce rahI zrI zAMtinAtha bhagavAna kI prabhAvazAlI pratimA hai|" zayyaMbhava ne yUpa ( yajJa stambha ) ko tatkAla ukhAr3akara prazAMtamudrAyukta zrI zAMtinAtha bhagavAna kI pratimA nikaalii| ___ bAda meM prArya zrI prabhavasvAmI ke pAsa jAkara bAhyAtmA, aMtarAtmA aura paramAtmA kA tattva pAkara apanI sagarbhA strI ko chor3akara usane cAritra liyaa| ukta yathArtha kathAnaka ke tathyoM ko tor3a-maror3a kara khaMDa 2, pR0 314 para prAcArya hastImalajI likhate haiM ki 446 upAdhyAya ne kAla ke samAna karavAla liye apane yajamAna ( zayyaMbhava brAhmaNa ) ko sammukha dekhakara socA ki aba saccI bAta batAye binA prANarakSA asaMbhava hai| yaha vicAra kara usane kahA-"arhata bhagavAna dvArA prarUpita dharma hI vAstavika tattva aura sahI dharma hai ( ! ? )" isakA sahI upadeza yahA~ virAjita AcArya prabhava se tumheM prApta karanA caahie|xxx mImAMsA-zrI dazavakAlika sUtra ke kartA zrI zayyaMbhavasUri zrI zAMtinAthajI kI pratimA ko dekhakara pratibodhita hue the, aisA zrI dazavakAlika niyukti zAstra meM bhI likhA hai, yathA xxx "sijjaMbhavaM gaNaharaM jiNapaDimA daMsaraNeNa paDibuddha // shlok-14||XXX yajJagora ne zayyaMbhava brAhmaNa ko yajJastambha ke nIce rahI zrI zAMtinAtha bhagavAna ko pratimA ko tattva batAyA thA, aisA dazavakAlika

Page #91
[ 53 ] niyukti prAgama evaM pUjya hemacandrAcArya dvArA racita prAcIna itihAsa ke pariziSTa parva meM bhI pratimA kA satya batAyA gayA hai, phira bhI pratimA viSayaka satya ko chipAnA prAcArya kA anucita kArya hI hai / itihAsa lekhana meM sthAnakapaMthI prAcArya ko yadi pratimA virodhI mAnyatA kA hI samarthana evaM nirUpaNa karanA thA, to itihAsa likhane kI AvazyakatA hI kyA thI ? aura unhoMne apane sthAnakapaMthI itihAsa kA nAma "jainadharma kA maulika itihAsa" aisA rakhakara asatya kA sahArA kyoM liyA ? paMDikkamaNe muMnidAna vihAre, hiMsA doSa vizeSa / lAbhAlAbha vicArI jotA, pretimA mAM zo dveSa ? -yAyavizArada pUjya yazovijayajI upAdhyAyajI

Page #92
[ prakaraNa-13] paramAtmA zrI neminAtha va saMhAra kRSNa aura jarAsaMdha ke yuddha meM mAtali sArathI kI bAta meM pAkara zrI neminAtha ne saMhAraka lIlA dikhAyI aura kucha kSaNoM meM hI eka lAkha zatruoM ko mAra giraayaa| mAno zrI neminAtha paramAtmA meM dayA kA aMza hI na ho aisI kalpita bAta paramArtha na jAnane kI anabhijJatA ke kAraNa prAcArya ne bor3a dI hai| khaMDa 1, pR0 356 para mAcArya likhate haiM ki xxx yaha dekhakara mAtali ( bhagavAna neminAtha ke sArathI ) ne hAtha jor3akara ariSTanemi se nivedana kiyA-"trilokanAtha ! yaha jarAsandha Apake sAmane eka tuccha kITa ke samAna hai| ApakI upekSA ke kAraNa yaha pRthvI ko yAdava vihIna kara rahA hai| prabho ! yadyapi Apa janma se hI sAvadha (pApapUrNa) kAryoM se parAGgamukha haiM, tathApi zatru dvArA jo Apake kula kA vinAza kiyA jA rahA hai, isa samaya Apako usakI upekSA nahIM karanI caahie| nAtha ! apanI thor3I sI "lIlA" dikhaaiye|xxx mImAMsA-"apanI thor3I sI lIlA dikhAiye" isa kathana ko prAcArya hastImalajI ne kauna se prAgama zAstra se liyA hai, vaha inhoMne sUcita nahIM kiyA hai / kintu doSa rahita paramAtmA ko lIlA aura vaha bhI 'saMhAraka lIlA' ke sAtha jor3akara prAcArya ne akSamya aparAdha hI kiyA hai|

Page #93
[ 55 ] jinamaMdira meM jinapUjA ke avasara, sthAvarakAya jIvoM kI svarUpamAtra virAdhanA ke viSaya meM hiMsA hiMsA kA zora macAne vAle aura dayAdharma kI bAMga pukArane vAle prAcArya hastImalajI ne paramakRpAlu, jJAnabhita vairAgyavanta, janma se tIna jJAna dhAraka zrI neminAtha paramAtmA ko saMhAraka hiMsaka lIlA karane vAlA batAyA hai, yaha kahAM taka sahI ho sakatA hai, pAThaka svayaM nirNaya kara sakate haiN| mAtali sArathI ke 'lIlA dikhAiye' sirpha itanA kahane para hI janma se pApa kAryoM se parAMgamukha zrI neminAtha bhagavAna ko mAno pAnI car3ha gayA aura saMhAraka lIlA dikhAyI aisA khaNDa 1, pR0 358 para prAcArya likhate haiM / yathA xxx isa taraha prabhu ( ariSTaneminAthajI ) ne bahuta ho svalpa samaya meM eka lAkha zatru-yoddhAoM ko naSTa kara ddaalaa|xxx mImAMsA-dayArdra zrI nemikumAra ne pazu saMhAra ke bAre meM socakara aura pazu pukAra ko sunakara zAdI taka nahIM kI thI aura saMsAra tyAgapUrvaka cAritra liyA thaa| aise paramakRpAlu paramAtmA neminAtha ne lAkha sainikoM ko mAra girAyA aisA bhAcArya hastImalajI kA likhanA vicAra zUnya aura sUtra ke rahasyoM evaM paramArtha nahIM jAnane kI kSamatA ko hI sUcita karatA hai / yadyapi isa viSaya meM binA gurugama aura anabhijJatAvaza prAcArya hastImalajI ne paramAtmA zrI ariSTa neminAthajI kI 'narasaMhAraka lIlA' vaha bhI mAtali sArathI ke "lIlA dikhAiye" sirpha itane zabdoM para, ko triSaSThi zalAkA puruSa caritra ke sAtha jor3anA cAhA hai jo anucita hai| lakIra ke phakIra banakara anya ko sUtra ke paramArtha rahasya ko jAnoM aisA korA upadeza [ zrI RSabhadeva bhagavAna ke 400 dina ke upavAsa ke viSaya meM] dene vAle ahiMsaka dharma ke ThekedAra prAcArya ne yahA~ sUtrArtha ko jAnane kI koziza nahIM kI hai, isa kAraNa hI sirpha mAtali

Page #94
[ 56 ] sArathI ke vacana para hI janma se pApakAryoM se parAGgamukha zrI neminAtha bhagavAna ko saMhAraka lIlA ke sAtha jor3ane kA sAhasa kara sake haiN| prAcArya yahA~ yaha kyoM bhUla jAte haiM ki tIrthaMkara paramAtmA kA cAritra tadbhava meM sarvathA nirdoSa hI hotA hai / aisI bhrAmaka bAta likhane vAloM se jaina samAja ko sAvadhAna rahanA cAhie aura vizeSakara dayAdharmI samAja ko, kyoMki tIthaMkara zrI neminAtha bhagavAna ke ujjvala caritra ko kalaMkita karane kI prAcArya hastImalajI kI yaha gahaNiya ceSTA hai| yadyapi caubIsa tIrthaMkaroM meM solahaveM zAMtinAthajI, satrahaveM kuMthunAthajI, evaM aThAraveM bharanAthajI SaTkhaMDa pRthvI ke sAdhaka cakravartI rAjA hue haiM / kintu ina puNyAtmAoM ko binA zastra uThAye hI SakhaMDa bhUmi prApta ho jAtI hai, kyoMki tIrthakara puNyalakSmI unake caraNa cUmatI hai| aisA hI puNya prAgmAra zrI pAvakumAra kA thaa| unake yuddhabhUmi meM jAne ke sAtha hI usa mAtali sArathI sahita devoMdvArA pUje gaye pAzvaMkumAra ko dekhakara yavanarAjA prabhu ke caraNoM meM A gayA thaa| aisA hI puNya prakarNa zrI neminAthajI kA thA, aisA prAcArya ko svIkAra karanA caahie| jisake hRdaya meM sUtrAbhyAsa dvArA sadbodhaka prArdubhAva huA hai, usake hRdaya meM hI AgamasUtra kI tAttvika sparzanA hotI hai| -gyAyadizArada pUjya yazovijayajI upAdhyAya

Page #95
[prakaraNa-14] zrI pArzvanAthajI ko vairAgya eka bAra pArzvakumAra kumArAvasthA meM bagIce meM apanI patnI prabhAvatI ke sAtha gye| vahA~ mahala kI dIvAra para zrI neminAthajI ne rAjImati ko chor3akara kisa prakAra cAritra liyA inake viSaya meM citra dekhe| yaha nimitta pAkara pArzvakumAra cAritra lene ke liye udyata hue| isa viSaya meM pUrvamuni racita zrI pArzvanAthajI kI stuti bhI jaina samAja meM prasiddha hai yathA "nemirAjI citra virAjI, vilokita vrata liye" / arthAt- neminAthajI aura rAjImati ko (bArAta ke) citra meM virAjamAna dekhakara pArzvakumAra ne cAritra liyaa| __zrI pArzvakumAra ko cAritra lene meM citra nimitta bane haiM aisA pUrvAcArya kahate haiM, phira bhI yaha bAta prAcArya hastImalajI ko prakharatI hai, jo sarvathA anucita hai| citra darzana se jJAna prApti ke isa satya tathya ko anya pUrvAcAryoM ke nAma likhakara prAcArya ne svayaM ko alipta rakhane kI ceSTA kI hai aura itihAsakAra ke nAte satya meM aruci pragaTa kI hai, jo ucita nahIM hai|

Page #96
[ 58 ] zrI pArzvakumAra ko tasvIra se [ citra darzana se ] vairAgya huA hai, isa tathya ko majabUra hokara khaMDa 1, pR0 486 para prAcArya hastImalajI ko anya pUrvAcAryoM ke nAma likhane par3e haiM ki xxx jaise 'cauvana mahApurisa cariyaM' ke kartA AcArya zIlAMka, "siripAsa nAha cariyaM" ke racayitA devabhadrasUri aura 'pArzvanAtha caritra' ke lekhaka bhAvadeva tathA hemavijayagaNi ne bhitticitroM ko dekhane se ( pArzvakumAra ko ) vairAgya honA batAyA hai| Xxx. mImAMsA-itane sAre prAcInAcAryoM kA kathana hone para to prAcArya ko tasvIra viSayaka tathya ko avazya svIkAranA hI cAhie aura isa viSaya meM apanI nArAjagI dUra karanI hI caahie| sthAnakapaMtha ke pAdya praNetA eka vRddha jaina bhAI loMkAzAha ne cAritra liyA thA, aisA kahIM se sirpha saMketa mAtra mila jAne para bar3hA car3hAkara lambI vAkya . racanA kara dene meM kuzala prAcArya ko pArzvakumAra ke vairAgya meM prAcIna pUrvAcAryoM ke granthoM kA sahArA milane para bhI satya ko svIkAra karane meM kaunasA siddhAnta bAdhya karatA hai ? apanI tasvIra banavAkara ba~TavAne vAle, gRhastha kI tasvIra ko apane itihAsa meM chapavAne vAle, tIrthaMkara paramAtmA ke lAMchana citroM ko mAnyatA denevAle AcArya jaba tIrthakara paramAtmA kI tasvIra mAtra se hI napharata karate haiM taba sakheda pAzcarya hotA hai| yadyapi janma se hI tIna jJAnadhAraka tIrthaMkara paramAtmA svayaM buddha hote haiM, ve kisI se bodha pAkara cAritrI nahIM banate, phira bhI jaise ariSTanemikumAra kA zAdI na karake cAritra lene meM pazuoM kA karuNa kraMdana nimitta huA hai, vaise hI pArzvakumAra ko neminAtha aura rAjImati kA citra darzana cAritra kA nimitta banA aisA pUrvAcAryoM ne kahA hai, jo

Page #97
[ 56 ] sarvathA ucita hI hai / evaM jJAnabhita vairAgyavanta hote hue bhI tIrthaMkara paramAtmA niyata samaya para hI cAritra lete haiM, usI taraha svayaMbuddha hone para bhI agara ve koI bAhya nimitta se cAritra grahaNa karate haiM, to usameM zAstra siddhAnta sahamata hai / zrI zAntinAtha bhagavAna ke caritra meM khaMDa 1, pR0 240 para prAcArya svayaM likhate haiM ki xxx lokAntika devoM se prerita hokara prabhu ne varSabhara yAcakoM ko icchAnusAra dAna diyA.......... ( yAvat ) siddha kI sAkSI se sampUrNa pApoM kA parityAga kara dIkSA grahaNa kii|xxx __ mImAMsA-ukta prakAra hI pUrvAcAryoM kA prAcIna granthoM meM aisA kahanA hai ki zrI pArzvakumAra ko cAritra kA nimitta zrI neminAtha tathA rAjImati ke bArAta ke citra hue the| isa satya tathya ko prAmANikatA pUrvaka prAcArya ko svIkAra karanA cAhie / pApa nahIM koI utsUtra bhASaNa jisyo, dharma nahIM koI jaga sUtra sarikho // -adhyAtmamUrti mahAna vidvAn zrI prAnandaghanajI mahArAja

Page #98
[prakaraNa-15] pratimA se vairAgya kA upadeza kumbharAjA kI putrI mallikumArI kA sauMdarya alaukika thaa| lokottara sauMdarya kI prazaMsA sunakara pUrvabhava ke chaha mitroM ne mallikumArI ke sAtha zAdI karanI cAhI / rAjA kumbha Dara gaye ki eka rAjakumAra ko mallikumArI dene para unheM anya ke sAtha lar3AI mola lenI pdd'egii| bAda meM mallikumArI ne apanI pratikRti-pratimA banavAkara zarIra kI azucitA usa pratimA-mUrti dvArA dikhAkara una chahoM rAjakumAroM ko pratibodhita kiyA thaa| zrI jJAtAsUtra evaM ThANAMgasUtra meM bhI likhA hai ki mallikumArI ne apanI pratikRti-pratimA dvArA rAjakumAroM ko pratibodhita kiyA thaa| isa viSaya meM khaMDa 1, pR0 278 para prAcArya hastImalajI likhate haiM ki xxx sUryodaya hote hI mohana ghara ke garbhagRhoM ke vAtAyanoM meM se jitazatru Adi una chahoM rAjAoM ne bhagavatI malli dvArA nirmita sAkSAt malli kI pratikRti-pratimA ko maNipITha para dekhA / xxx mImAMsA-tasvIra meM bahuta kucha rahasya bharA huA hai, tabhI to sthAnakapaMthI saMta bhI apanI tasvIreM Aja bhI bar3e cAva se chapavAtebaMTavAte najara Ate haiN| pichale prakaraNa meM hama dekha pAye haiM ki zrI neminAtha aura rAjImati ke citroM ke darzana, zrI pArzvakumAra ko cAritra

Page #99
[ 61 ] dIkSA meM nimitta hue the aura prastuta meM bhagavatI mallikumArI apanI pratikRti-pratimA dvArA chahoM rAjAoM ko pratibodhita karatI haiN| ina saba tathyoM se pratimA viSayaka satya kI puSTi hotI hai, jise prAmANikatA aura himmatapUrvaka prAcArya ko svIkAra karanA cAhie evaM tasvIra sirpha "paricaya" ke liye hI nahIM hai, kintu jJAna vaMdanAdi ke liye bhI hai aisA anekAntavAda kA mAzraya lenA caahie| hamAre pAsa sthAnakamArgI prAcArya cauthamalajI sahita 43 muniyoM kI sAmUhika tasvIra-phoTo hai, jisake vikraya hetu samAcAra patroM meM bhI pracAra karavAyA gayA thaa| yadyapi "tasvIra sirpha paricaya ke liye hai" aisA tasvIra ke nIce likhakara sthAnakapaMthI bAhara se thothA virodha karate haiM kintu nija kI tasvIreM cAva se chapavAne aura ba~TavAne vAle ve loga apane andara jhAMkakara dekheM to unheM tasvIra kA mukhya prayojana apane Apa mAluma ho jAegA / jar3a nAma ke smaraNa ke pIche jo prAzaya sadhatA hai, isase aneka guNA prAzaya jar3a tasvIra yA pratimA ke darzana pUrvaka ke nAma smaraNa se sadhatA hai, yaha unako samajhanA caahie| apanI tasvIreM bar3e cAva se chapavAne-baTavAne vAle sthAnakapaMthI saMtoM ne kyA kabhI tIrthaMkara bhagavAna kI tasvIra bhI chapavAyIbaMTavAyI hai ? are ! aura to kyA kaheM ? ekAnte zaraNya, jJAnadAtA zrI tIrthaMkara kI tasvIra se napharata karanevAle prAcArya hastImalajI svayaM ne hI apane itihAsa meM dAnadAtA gRhastha kI tasvIra chapavAI hai| tIrthaMkara bhagavAna kI tasvIra ke prati hI aisA pakSapAta aura ghRNA karanA prAcArya kA anucita evaM kRtaghnatApUrNa kRtya hai / viSama kAle jina bimba jinAgama __ bhavijana ko aadhaaraa|

Page #100
[prakaraNa-16 ] arihaMta para prabhakti evaM pUrvAcAryoM para prabahumAna "jainadharma kA maulika itihAsa-khaMDa 1" para caubIsoM bhagavAna ke paricAyaka bhinna bhinna lAMchana citroM kI tasvIra evaM bhItara meM dAnadAtA gRhastha kI tasvIra chapAne vAle prAcArya hastImalajI ne jJAnadAtA tIrthakara paramAtmA kI tasvIra apane itihAsa meM na chapavAkara arihaMta paramAtmA para apanI prabhakti kA paricaya diyA hai| yAnI AcArya ko gRhastha kI tasvIra se koI pakSapAta nahIM hai aura tIrthaMkaroM kI lAMchana tasvIra se bhI unheM koI virodha nahIM hai, pakSapAta aura virodha hai to kevala jJAnadAtA jinezvara zrI tIrthaMkara bhagavAna kI tasvIra se hai, jo sarvathA anucita hI hai / bhinna-bhinna tIrthaMkaroM kI mUrtiyoM kI pahacAna karAnevAle lAMchanoM ko mAnanA aura una mUrtiyoM ke prati prAMkheM mUda lenA yaha kaunasA roga hogA ? jJAnI jAne ! kintu isake mUla meM prAcArya kI tIrthaMkaroM ke prati bhakti evaM bahumAna kA prabhAva hI pragaTa hotA hai| . isI taraha prAcArya meM mahA dhuraMdhara pUrvAcAryoM para bhI prabhakti. evaM prabahumAna pratIta hotA hai kyoMki mUrti aura maMdira kI bAta mAne para prAcArya hastImalajI vRtti, cUrNi, bhASya, TIkAdi ke racayitA pUrvAcAryoM ko jhUThA karane meM tanika bhI lajjA nahIM karate haiM / Azcarya

Page #101
[ 63 ] to isa bAta kA hai ki pUrvAcAryoM dvArA racita TIkAdi granthoM ke sahAre binA eka bhI sthAnakapaMthI vidvAn ( ! ) apanA lekha sampUrNa evaM prAmANika likha hI nahIM pAte haiM, phira bhI pUrvAcAryoM ko jhUThA ThaharAne meM ve apanI kRtaghnatA nahIM samajhate / yaha kaisI viDaMbanA hai ki gur3a khAnA aura gulaguloM se paraheja ! khaMDa 1, pR0 884 para dI gayI, saMdarbha grantha kI sUcI isa bAta kI sAkSI hai ki prAcArya hastImalajI ko prAcIna jainAcAryoM para zraddhA, bhakti, bahumAna aura Adara nahIM hai / usI sUcI meM sthAnakapaMthI saMta kA nAma sanmAna evaM bahumAna sUcaka vizeSaNoM se likhA hai| prAcArya hastImalajI ne apane itihAsa kI saMdarbha sUcI meM jinase jJAna liyA hai una mahAn upakArI pUrvAcAryoM ke nAma prA0 hemacandra, malayagiri, abhayadevasUri, rAjendrasUri aise abahumAna sUcaka zabda likhakara aura bahumAna sUcaka vizeSaNoM kA prayoga na kara unake upakAra kA badalA kRtaghnatA se cukAyA hai| anyathA mahAupakArI pUrvAcAryoM ke nAma likhane kA avasara prApta ho, vahA~ prAtaHsmaraNIya, mahopakArI, mahAjJAnI, pUjya, pUjyapAda, paramapUjya aise vinaya, zraddhA, bhakti, sammAna, bahumAna, Adara aura ahobhAva sUcaka zabdoM ke prayoga dvArA prAcArya kI lekhanI pUlakita honI cAhie thii| lekhanI ko pUrvAcAryoM ke pavitra vizeSaNoM se pulakita karane ke bajAya anya viSayoM meM phAlatU piSTa peSaNa karane vAle prAcArya ne upakArI ke upakAra kA badalA cukAne kA avasara prAne para apanI lekhanI kA sahI sadupayoga nahIM kiyA hai, jo unakA AghAta janaka vartana hai, kyoMki pUrvAcAryoM meM jo jJAna hai usakA aMza bhI prAcArya meM honA saMbhava nahIM hai| kucha zatAbdiyoM se paMDita manya Adhunika ciMtakoM kI aisI kupravRtti calI hai, ki ve jinase jJAna lete haiM una mahAna pUrvAcAryAdi ke

Page #102
[ 64 ] nAma hemacandra, haribhadra, yazovijaya, zIlAMga, malayagiri, aise prabahumAna, anAdara, avinaya mora prabhakti pUrNa zabda prayoga karake unake prati apanA abhimAna, manamratA aura prazraddhA sUcita karate haiN| mahAjJAnI pUrvAcAryAdi ke pavitra nAma ke Age pIche vizeSaNa na dekara karanA cAhie utanA sammAna nahIM karane vAloM meM aura isa pravinaya pUrNa pravRtti ko bar3hAvA dene meM sthAnakavAsI sampradAya meM prAcArya hastImalajI bhI eka haiM jisakA hameM sakheda Azcarya hai| upakArI ke upakAra kA badalA apakAra se cukAne kI aisI kRtaghnatA pUrNa nIti-rIti ko prAcArya bhaviSya meM avazya sudhAreMge, hamArI yahI mAzA hai| abhyarcanAvahatAM manaH prasAdastataH samAdhizca / tasmAdapi niHzreyasamato hi tatpUjanaM nyAgyam / zrI arihaMta paramAtmA kI abhyarcanA se mana kI prasannatA, mana kI prasannatA se niHzreyasa-mokSa prApta hotA hai| isaliye sabhI mumukSu AtmAoM ko arihaMta prabhu kI pUjA avazya karanA cAhie / yaha nyAya saMgata evaM ucita hai| -10 pUrvadhara pUjya umAsvAti mahArAja

Page #103
[ prakaraNa-17 ] aMbaDa sanyAsI aura samyagdarzana prAgama zAstroM meM jahAM bhI zrAvaka ke bAraha vratoM kA varNana pAyA hai vahAM sarvaprathama samyagdarzana kA varNana pAyA hai| samyagdarzana prahaNa ke binA bAraha vrata kI prArAdhanA niSphala mAnI gaI hai / prataH zrI bhagavatI Adi sUtroM meM Ananda, kAmadeva Adi zrAvakoM ke bAraha vrata svIkArane kI bAta pAyI hai, vahAM bAraha vrata ke pUrva samyagdarzana ke svIkAra kI bAta AtI hai| kyoMki samakita binA navapUrvI ko bhI prajJAnI mAnA gayA hai| zraddhA bhraSTa ko jainAgama ne bhraSTa kahA hai| zraddhAbhraSTa jamAli mAdi ke cAritra kI kImata phUTI kaur3I bhI nahIM mAnI gaI hai| sudeva-suguru-sudharma para hI zraddhA-vizvAsa karanA arthAt kudeva, kuguru aura kudharma ko tyAganA yaha samyagdarzana hai| yAnI arihaMta deva aura arihaMta deva kI pratimA ko hI mAnanA pUjanA, anya mithyAdRSTi deva-deviyoM meM vizvAsa nahIM karanA / paMca mahAvrata dhArI zuddha jinAgama prarUpaka sAdhunoM ko hI guru mAnanA, kuveSa-kuliMga dhArI, utsUtra prarUpaka, pAlU prAdi anaMtakAya aura bAsI, dvidala prAdi abhakSya ko bhakSaNa karane vAle ko guru nahIM mAnanA tathA vItarAga zrI arihaMta deva prarUpita sattvoM para hI zraddhA-vizvAsa karanA yaha samyagdarzana hai|

Page #104
[ 66 ] aMbaDa nAma kA eka sanyAsI zrI mahAvIra bhagavAna kA bhakta banA thaa| khaMDa 1, pR0 661-662 para prAcArya hastImalajI ne aMbaDa sanyAsI kA adhikAra likhA hai, kintu aMbaDa ne zrI mahAvIra svAmI ke pAsa samyagdarzana ko svIkAra kiyA thA, isa viSaya meM prAcArya ne eka zabda bhI nahIM likhA hai, jo itihAsa lekhaka kI apUrNatA kA sUcaka hai| . aMbaDa sanyAsI jaba samyagdarzana ko svIkAra karatA hai taba bhagavAna zrI mahAvIra svAmI ke sAmane pratijJA karatA hai ki. xxxNaNNattha arihaMte vA arihaMta ceiyANi vA vaMditA vA namasaMti vaa| [ zrI uvavAI sUtra ] 888 . arthAt-[ aMbaDa kahatA hai, he bhagavan ! prAja se mujhe ) arihaMta aura arihaMta kI pratimA kI vaMdana karanA kalpe, anya hari harAdi aura unakI sthApanA-pratimA ko nahIM / - ukta sUtra kA samadarzI lauMkAgacchIya prAcArya zrI amRtacandra sUri ne nimnalikhita artha kiyA hai| yathA - xxx arihaMta aura arihaMta kI pratimA kI sthApanA te vaMdana karavA kalpe (anya nhiiN)| [ zrI uvavAI sUtra pR0 297 ] 88 kalpita evaM UTapaTAMga artha karate haiM ki

Page #105
[ 67 ] 4 4 phakta arihaMta aura arihaMta ke [ caitya yAnI ] sAdhu ko ( ? ) hI vandana karanA-namaskAra karanA yAvat sevA bhakti karanA kalpatA hai / [ uvavAI sUtra pR0 163 ] xxx mImAMsA-yahAM amolaka RSi ne "arihaMta gheiyANi" sUtra pATha kA kalpita evaM jhUThA artha "arihaMta ke sAdhu" aisA kiyA hai, jo unake zrI amRtacandra Adi lauMkAgacchIya prAcArya ne kiye artha se bhI viparIta evaM viruddha hai tathA koSa aura vyAkaraNa nirapekSa bhI hai| loMkAgaccha ke prAcAryoM ne bhI mandira meM jina pratimA ko pratiSThita karavAyI hai, aisI dazA meM jo svayaM ke prAcAryoM ke viruddha calate haiM ve agara unase bhI prAcIna prAcAryoM evaM zAstroM ko mAnya na kareM aura unase viparIta yA viruddha caleM, to isameM Azcarya kI bAta hI kyA hai ? aMbaDa sanyAsI ke adhikAra meM samyagdarzana kI bAta hI prAcArya hastImalajI ne apane itihAsa meM chipAI hai aura unake pUrvavarti amolaka RSi ne manamAnA kalpita artha kiyA hai, unake Adi puruSa lauMkAzAha se isa sthAnakapaMtha paramparA kI yahI vizeSatA rahI hai| __sthAnakapaMthiyoM meM koI "bRhat zAMti stotra" ko mUrtipUjA samarthaka pAThoM kI kAMTa-chAMTa karake saMkSipta kara rahA hai, to koI vidyAvanta cAraNamuniyoM kA naMdozvara prAdi dvIpa meM saira-saphara hetu jAne kA likha rahA hai, to koI pAgama sUtroM kA manacAhA aMTa-zaMTa artha kara rahA hai, to koI paramArtha nahIM jAnate hue bhI "ghaMTAkarNa mahAvIra"

Page #106
[ 68 ] nAma ke yakSa kA maMtra-jaMtra chapavA rahA hai, to koI pAlU, bAsI, makkhana mAdi abhakSya kA bhakSaNa karane para bhI dayA dharma kI bAMga pukAra rahA hai, to koI zrI mahAvIra svAmI prAdi kI muhapattI baMdhI huI tasvIraphoTo chapavAkara baMTavA rahA hai, to koI nija kI tasvIra yukta lokeTa apane bhaktoM ko de rahA hai, yaha kitanA asAmaMjasya ? tapa saMyama kiriyA karo, mana rAkho ThAma / samakita bina niSphala hue, jima vyoma citrAma / / -pUjyapAd jJAnavimalamUrijI mahArAja sAhaba

Page #107
[prakaraNa-18] vazapUrvadhara zrI vajasvAmI ke viSaya meM pakSapAta dhanagiri ne apanI sagarbhA patnI ko chor3akara pUjya prArya zrI siMhagirijI se dIkSA lI thii| janma ke bAda apane pitA kI dIkSA kI bAta sunakara bAlaka ko jAti smaraNa jJAna ho gayA aura mAtA se chuTakArA pAne ke liye usane dina rAta ronA zurU kiyaa| parezAna mAtA ne apane putra ko dhanagiri ko sauMpa diyaa| guru prArya zrI siMhagirijI ne bhArI vajana hone ke kAraNa bAlaka kA nAma vajra rkhaa| bAlaka vajra ne sAdhvIjI ke upAzraya meM rahate rahate sAdhviyoM dvArA raTAte hue zAstra pAThoM ko suna sunakara gyAraha aMga kaMThastha kara liye| bAlaka vaz2a ko bAda meM Arya zrI dhanagiri ne dIkSA dii| prApane krama se zrI bhadraguptAcArya ke pAsa 10 pUrva kA adhyayana kiyA aura Arya zrI dhanagirijI ne Apako apanA paTTadhara bnaayaa| pApako prAkAzagAminI labdhi thI, jisake prayoga se Apa samasta zrI jainasaMgha ko paTTa para baiThAkara dubhikSa kSetra se subhikSa ke kSetra meM lAye the| usa subhikSa kSetra kA rAjA baudhadharmI thA, jo jainadharmAvalambiyoM se dveSa rakhatA thaa| pavitra paryuSaNA parva meM tIrthaMkara paramAtmA ke pUjana hetu puSpa cAhie the, jinako dene ke liye bauddha rAjA ne manA kara diyA thaa| taba prArya zrI vajrasvAmI vidyA dvArA prAkAza mArga se himavaMta parvata para gaye aura zrI devI ke

Page #108
[ 70 ] pAsa se kamala tathA pitRmitra deva ke pAsa se bIsa lAkha puSpa lAkara pratispaddhi bauddhoM ke sAmane jaina dharma kI prabhAvanA karate hue zAsanonnati kA mahAna kArya kiyA thaa| isa zAsana prabhAvanA se prabhAvita hokara bauddharAjA evaM anya prajA bhI jainadharmI bana gaye the| dazapUrvadhara zAsana prabhAvaka mahAna jainAcArya zrI vajrasvAmI ke viSaya meM khaMDa 2, pR. 578 para prAcArya hastImalajI likhate haiM ki RXXApane AkAzagAminI vidyA kA prayoga karake saMgha ko subhikSa meM pahuMcAyA thaa| vahA~ kA rAnA bauddhadharmAnuyAyI hone ke kAraNa jaina upAsakoM ke sAtha virodha rakhatA thA, para Aryavana ke prabhAva se vaha bhI zrAvaka banA aura isase dharma kI bar3I prabhAvanA huii|888 . mImAMsA-dekhiye ! yahA~ kaisA gola-mola evaM apramANika likhA gayA hai / bauddharAjA para Arya zrI vajrasvAmI kA kauna sA prabhAva par3A thA, jisake kAraNa bauddhadharma ko chor3akara vaha jainadharmI bana gyaa| isa tathya ko saMdigdha rakhakara prAcArya ne apanI purAnI khAsiyata ke mutAbika jinamUrtipUjAdi ke viSaya meM satya se hI anAdara kiyA hai / kyoMki bauddha rAjA ke jainadharmI banane ke pIche prArya zrI vajrasvAmI kA AgAzagAminI vidyA dvArA AkAzamArga se jAkara zrIdevI ke pAsa se padma evaM pitRmitra deva ke pAsa se 20 lAkha puSpa lAnA Adi kAraNa hai yaha satya hai| jina maMdira aura jinapratimApUjA ke viSaya meM matibhrama aura sammoha ke kAraNa sthAnakapaMthI kabhI bhI satya nahIM likha sakate haiN| phira bhI bhArya zrI vajrasvAmI AkAzagAminI vidyA se AkAza mArga se bhagavAna kI puSpapUjA hetu puSpa lAye the aura jainamatAvalambiyoM ke manorathoM kI pUrti kI thii| isa tathya kA

Page #109
[ 71 ] svIkAra prAcArya dvArA digambara aura zvetAmbara paramparA kI sAmyatA dikhAne ke avasara para anAyAsa hI ho gayA hai| khaMDa 2, pR0 585 para prAcArya likhate haiM ki xxx Arya vajra ke gagana vihArI hone, jainoM ke sAtha bauddhoM dvArA kI gayI dhArmika utsava viSayaka pratispardhA meM Aryavana dvArA jainadharmAva. lambiyoM ke manorathoM kI pUrti ke sAtha jinazAsana kI mahimA bar3hAne Adi Aryavana ke jIvana kI ghaTanAoM evaM sampUrNa kathAvastu kI mUla AtmA meM donoM paramparAoM ko paryApta sAmyatA hai / Xxx mImAMsA-prArya zrI vajrasvAmI gagana vihArI kyoM hue ? jaina aura bauddhoM meM kaunase dhArmika viSaya meM pratispardhA huI ? prArya zrI vajrasvAmI ne jainadharmAvalambiyoM ke kauna se manorathoM kI pUrti kI tho? donoM paramparA meM digambara aura zvetAmbara Ate haiM jo mUrtipUjA meM vizvAsa rakhate haiM, phira sthAnakapaMthiyoM kA sthAna kahAM hai ? prAdi aneka praznoM ko prAcArya ne aspaSTa hI rakhA hai, jo anucita hI hai / __yahAM prAcArya ne dhArmika utsava viSayaka pratispardhA kA ullekha kiyA hai, kintu himmata aura satyatA pUrvaka yaha nahIM likhA ki bauddharAjA ne jainiyoM ko paryuSaNA parva meM jinapratimA kI pUjA hetu puSpa dene kI manA karadI thii| taba prArya zrI vajrasvAmI ne jainadharmAvalambiyoM ke manoratha kI pUrti AkAzagAminI vidyA dvArA puSpa lAkara kI thii| isase prabhAvita hokara bauddhadharmI rAjA evaM prajA jainadharmI bane the, isa satya tathya ko prAcArya ne chipAyA hai| eka bAta aura bhI hai ki zvetAmbara aura digambara donoM jaina paramparA mUrtipUjA meM vizvAsa karatI hai, ataH zrI vajrasvAmI ke kathAnaka meM donoM paramparAmoM kI sAmyatA honA svAbhAvika hI hai| kintu ina donoM paramparA kI zraddhA se viparIta zraddhA sthAnakapaMthI kI haiM, ataH ve apane Apa hI jainAbhAsa

Page #110
[ 72 ] siddha ho jAte haiM, aisI dazA meM ve loga jainadharma ke mUla se sambandhita jinamUrti aura jinamUrtipUjA kI prAcInatA evaM satyatA kA samarthana kyoM kareMge? yahA~ vahI purAnI lakIra ke phakIra banakara prAcArya hastImalajI ne mahAna jainAcArya 10 pUrvadhara prArya zrI vajrasvAmI ke caritra ko mUrtipUjA se saMbaMdhita hone ke kAraNa apramANika likhA hai aura satya ko tor3a-maror3a karake prastuta kiyA hai| isase jaina itihAsa lekhana ke sambandha meM kI huI unakI taTasthatA aura satyatA kI pratijJA kA sarvathA bhaMga hI huA hai, jo atyanta khedajanaka hai| jisako jainAgama hRdayaMgama nahIM hue haiM, vaha cAhe prAcArya padAdhirUr3ha kyoM na hoM, jaina siddhAnta kA duzmana hI hai, kyoMki jainAgama ke viSaya meM vaha diGa mUr3ha hai| -bhAgametara sabase prAcIna zAstra zrI upadezamAlA

Page #111
ati prAcIna bhavya jina pratimA

Page #112
_

Page #113
[ prakaraNa-16] jainadharma maura mADambara cAturmAsa meM darzanArthiyoM ke lie caukA lagavAne kI preraNA karanA, nija kI pratiSThA evaM pradarzana hetu kosoM kI dUrI se bhaktajanoM ko darzana ke bahAne bulAnA, nija kI tasvIreM chapavAnA-ba~TavAnA, patrikA evaM sAptAhika patra prAdi nikAlanA, zrAvakoM kA sammelana karavAnA, upAzraya-sthAnaka banavAnA, goTha-prItibhoja karavAnA, nAriyala Adi kI prabhAvanA ba~TavAnA, apane guru kA janmadina manavAnA tathA isa hetu patrikA chapavAnA Adi aneka bAhya kriyAkAMDa aura bAhya ADambara karane meM hiMsA aura pApa nahIM mAnane vAle dayAdharma ke ThekedAra ( ! ) sthAnakapaMthiyoM jinamandira nirmANa, jina pratimA pratiSThA, jina pratimA pUjA, siddhacakra prAdi pUjana, snAtra pUjA, svAmI vAtsalya, tIrthayAtrA, yAtrAsaMgha, jalayAtrA kA jalUsa Adi jainadharma sambandhita prAcIna aura jainazAsanonnatikArI jaina zAstra kathita pavitra kriyAnoM ko manabhara ke kosate haiM aura bAhya prADambara kahakara unakA anAdara evaM apalApa karate haiM, yaha atyanta galata kRtya hai| vaise dekhA jAe to jisa kriyAdi ko prAcArya hastImalajI apanI "siddhAnta praznottarI" nAmaka kitAba meM bAhya prADambara aura bAhya kriyAkAMDa kahate haiM, vaha jainadharma kI kaunasI pravRtti meM nahIM hai ! tIrthaMkara paramAtmA kA samavasaraNa meM ratna ke siMhAsana para baiThanA, nava

Page #114
[ 74 ] kamala para calanA Adi kriyAeM kyA bAhya prADambara nahIM hai ? devoM dvArA hotI puSpavRSTi, caMvara DhulAnA tathA sUryAbhadeva aura jINakumAriyoM kA nATaka prAdi bhagavAna zrI tIrthaMkara kI maujUdagI meM bhI hotA thA, ina pravRttiyoM ko prApta bhagavAna ne bAhya prADambara kahakara heya yA tyAjya nahIM kahA hai| prAcArya zrI mAnatuga sUri mahArAja ne bhI "bhaktAmara stotra" zloka-33 meM tIrthaMkaroM ke bAhyADambara-ThATha-zobhA-vibhUti kA varNana kiyA hai, yathA xxx itthaM yathA tava vibhUtirabhUjinendra / dharmopadezanavidhau na tathA parasya // xxx mahAna tattva jJAniyoM ne isa bAhyADambara ko bhI anya jainetara bhadraka bhavya jIvoM ko jainadharma ke prati AkarSaNa karane aura jainadharma premI banAne ke liye prabala hetu mAnA hai| magadha samrATa zreNika, kUNika, darzANabhadra Adi bar3e bar3e rAjA mahArAjA bhI bhagavAna ke darzana hetu bar3e ThATa bATa ke sAtha gaye haiN| aura yaha pUrNa satya hai ki prApta bhagavAna ne kabhI bhI inako ADambara kI saMjJA nahIM dI hai| khaMDa 1, pR0 617 para prAcArya likhate haiM ki 444 rAjA zreNika ko bhagavAna padhArane kI sUcanA milI to ve rAjasI zobhA meM apane adhikAriyoM, anucaroM aura putroM Adi ke sAtha bhagavAna kI vandanA karane ko nikale aura vidhipUrvaka baMdana kara sevA karane lge|xx

Page #115
[ 75 ] mImAMsA-zreNika kA rAjasI vaibhava se jAne meM mArgagamana janya hiMsA to huI hI hogI, phira prApta bhagavAna ne kyoM nahIM kaha diyA ki-"yaha dayAdharma ke siddhAnta ke viruddha hai|" yadi bhagavAna eka bAra zreNika jaise vinayavanta bhakta ko niSedha kara dete to anya rAjA kabhI vaMbana hetu aise prADambara sahita nahIM jaate| rAjA darzANabhadra ne sarvazreSTha zobhA ke sAtha bhagavAna kI vandanA ke liye jAne kI socI aura indra ne unakI sarvazreSTha zobhA kA garva cUra kara diyA, bAda meM usane cAritra-dIkSA lii| khaMDa 1, pR0 658 para prAcArya likhate haiM ki xxx usame ( darzANabhadra ne ) bar3I dhAmadhUma se prabhu vandana kI taiyArI ko aura caturaMga senA va rAja parivAra sahita sajadhaja kara vandana ko niklaa| 888 mImAMsA-dhUmadhAma aura sajadhaja kara yAnI bAhyADambara se jAne kI pravRtti ko jaina zAstroM meM kahIM bhI anucita nahIM ThaharAyA hai, dayAdharmiyoM ko yaha vicArane kI bAta hai| khaMDa 1, pR0 745 para prAcArya hastImalajI likhate haiM ki 444 tadanantara kUNika ne apane nagara meM ghoSaNA karavAkara nAgarikoM:ko prabhu ke zubhAgamana ke susaMvAda se avagata karAyA aura apane samasta antaHpura, parijana, purajana, adhikArI varga evaM caturaMgiNI senA ke sAtha prabhudarzana ke liye prasthAna kiyaa|xxx mImAMsA-prApta bhagavAna ne evaM prAcIna zAstrakAroM ne jainadharma ke pracAra, prasAra evaM unnatikAraka aisI pravRttiyoM ko kabhI bhI

Page #116
[ 76 ] bAhyADambara nahIM kahA hai / basa evaM rela meM baiThakara saiMkar3oM mIloM kI dUrI se vaMdanArtha pAne vAle bhaktoM ko prAcArya hastImalajI ne kyA kabhI rokA hai ? ki-"vAhana Adi se Ane meM mahApApa yAnI hiMsA hotI hai, prataH sacce mana se yA bhAva se merI vandanA vahAM ghara para baiThe hue hI karalo, itane saiMkar3oM mIloM kI dUrI se prAnA hiMsA, adharma, pApa aura bAhyADambara hai|" sampradAya ke moha bandhana meM phaMsakara yA apanI manakalpita hiMsA kA zora-zarAbA karake jainadharma ke pracAra prasAra kI zubha pravRttiyoM ko bhI bAhyADambara yA bAhya kriyAkAnDa kahakara nindA karane vAle dayAdharmiyoM ( ! ) ko nija kI karaNI aura kathanI jAMcanI caahie| aura agara isameM bAhyADambara aura hiMsA prAdi hove to ImAnadArI pUrvaka unako tyAganA caahie| khaMDa 1 ( purAnI prAvRtti ) pR0 70 para prAcArya likhate haiM ki Xxx kheda hai ki hama apanI dRSTi se kisI bhI viSaya ke antastala taka nahIM pahuMcate aura purAnI lakIra ke hI phakIra bane hue mImAMsA-hamArA bhI yahI kathana hai ki purAnI lakIra ke phakIra bane rahane ke liye unheM kauna bAdhya karatA hai ? jinamandira, snAtrapUjA aura tIrthayAtrAdi pravRttiyoM ko hiMsA evaM bAhyADambara kahakara virodha karane vAloM aura "prArambhe natthi dayA" yAnI "hiMsA rUpa prArambha meM dayA nahIM hai" aisA mAge pIche kA saMdarbha rahita aikAntika vacana bolane vAloM kI kitAba chapavAnA, kabUtaroM ko cuggA DAlanA, apanI tasvIra chapavAnA, bhaktajanoM ko mIloM kI dUrI se darzanArtha

Page #117
[ 77 ] bulavAnA, unake nimitta caukA-calAne kI preraNA denA, nAriyala nAdi kI prabhAvanA bAMTanA, goTha-prItibhoja karavAnA Adi pravRttiyAM dayAmaya dharma se prerita hai yA hiMsAmaya dharma se ? isameM bAhyADambara hai ki jaina'zAsanonnati hai ? pAzrava-pApa hai yA dharma-saMvara? ina praznoM kA prAcArya svayaM ko prAmANika evaM zAstrIya uttara denA caahie| MM - bhagavAna kI AjJA ke Adara se mokSa . paura anAdara se saMsAra hotA hai| .. -kalikAla sarvajJa pUjya hemacandrAcArya ma0

Page #118
[prakaraNa-20 ] namo baMbhIe livIe yadyapi zAstra svayaM maMgala svarUpa haiM, phira bhI vighnoM kI zAnti hetu pUrvAcAryoM ne zAstra ke Adi, madhya evaM anta meM lipi meM likhakara bhI dravya aura bhAva maMgala kI prazasta pravRtti kI hai| zrI bhagavatI sUtra meM svayaM zAstrakartA maharSi ne "namo baMbhIe livIe"-yAnI bAhmI lipi ko namaskAra-aisA likhakara dravya-bhAva maMgala kiyA hai / kintu sthApanA nikSepa ko dravya-bhAva maMgala svarUpa na mAnane vAle sthAnakapaMthI prAcArya hastImalajI zAstrakartA ke isa kathana para svamAnyatA virodha ke kAraNa bahuta ruSTa haiM / pUjya zAstrakAra maharSi ke ukta kathana ko jhUThA karane hetu prAcArya ne bahuta sI prAcIna pratiyAM bhI DhUDha DAlI haiM, aisA unhoMne khaMDa 2, pR0 170-171 para svIkAra bhI kiyA hai, kintu unheM kahIM para koI virodha kA aMza nahIM milA / agara kahIM eka prati meM bhI virodha kA alpasA AdhAra mila jAtA to kyA thA ? prAcArya ho-hA kA zora karane meM hI apanA zreya samajhate, kintu unakA yaha prayAsa bhI masaphala hI rhaa| aMtato gattvA asatya kA sahArA lekara khaMDa 2, pR0 170 para prAcArya vyartha kI kalpita kalpanAe~ karate haiM ki xxxho sakatA hai zAstra lipibaddha hue hoMge taba pIche se "bamo bebhIe jibIe" pAsa sAmba meM ghusA diyA homaa| *

Page #119
[ 76 ] mImAMsA-prAcArya kA yaha kaisA bhaddA tarka hai ki-"pUrvAcAryoM ne beImAnI karake "namo baMbhIe livIe" isa pATha ko zrI bhagavatI sUtra meM ghusA diyA hogA," kintu prAcArya kA aisA likhanA alpajJatA kA hI sUcaka hai / pUrvAcAryoM ke kathana para "siddhasya gaticiMtanIyAH" isa ukti ko prAcArya hastImalajI kyoM mAnya nahIM karate haiM ? zrI bhagavatI sUtra kathita Adi evaM antima maMgala ke viSaya meM prAcArya khaMDa 2, pR0 170 para isa prakAra likhate haiM ki 44 dvAdazAMgI ke pAMcaveM aMga "vyAkhyA prajJapti ( aparanAma zrImatI bhagavatI sUtra ) kI Adi meM "paMca parameSThI namaskAra maMtra" 'Namo baMbhIe livIe' aura "Namo suyassa" pada se maMgala kiyA hai aura anta meM saMgha stuti ke pazcAt gautamAdi gaNadharoM, bhagavatI vyAkhyA prajJapti, dvAdazAMgI rUpa gaNipiTaka, zruta devatA, pravacana devI, kumbhadhara yakSa, brahmazAMti, vairATayA devI, vidyAdevI aura aMtahuDI ko namaskAra kiyA gayA hai|xxx mImAMsA-paramapUjya sUtrakAra maharSi ne "namo baMbhIe livIe" aisA likhakara dravya-bhAva maMgala-svarUpa mAnakara lipi ko bhI namaskAra kiyA hai / isa sUtra kI vyAkhyA-TIkA likhane vAle dhuraMdharavidvAna navAMgI TIkAkAra pUjyapAda abhayadevasUrijI mahArAja ne bhI sUtrakAra maharSi dvArA kiye gaye maMgala ke anurUpa hI TIkA racI hai, ki"namo baMbhIe livIe" aisA zAstrakAra dvArA maMgala kiyA gayA hai aura prAcIna pratiyoM meM bhI isI prakAra kA pATha milatA hai / ina saba bAtoM se spaSTa siddha hai ki sthApanA nikSepa rUpa brAhmI lipi ko bhI zAstrakAra maharSi ne dravya bhAvaM maMgalaM svarUpa mAnA hai| phira bhI isa niHsandeha satya tathya para bhI prAcArya ne khaMDa 2, pR0 170 se 172 taka meM lambIcaur3I managhaDaMta kalpanA calAyI hai, aura pUrvAcAryoM ko jhUThA karane kA dussAhasa kiyA hai ki

Page #120
[ .] xxxho sakatA hai zAstra lipibaddha hue hoMge taba pIche se "namo baMbhIe livIe" pATha zAstra meM ghusA diyA hogaa|8xx mImAMsA-bAta to yaha hai ki 'ho sakatA hai' aisA likhanA itihAsa ke lekhana meM sarvathA aprAmANika evaM nirarthaka hI hai, yaha bAta itihAsajJAbhAsa bhUleM isameM Azcarya hI kyA hai ? "tasvIra sirpha paricaya ke liye" yAnI tasvIra ko vaMdanAdi karoge to mithyAtva kA pApa lagegA aisA kahane vAloM ko zrI bhagavatI sUtrakartA evaM TIkAkartA pUrva maharSi kA kathana "namo baMbhIe livIe" para vicAra karake sthApanA viSayaka satya ke mArga ko prAmANikatApUrvaka svIkAra karanA caahie| TIkA cUNi bhASya uvekhyA, uvekhI niyukti / pratimA kAraNa sUtra uvekhyA, dUra rahI tujha mukti / / -nyAyavizArada pUjya yazovijayajI upAdhyAya

Page #121
alaukika zrI pAzrvanAtha bhagavAna hasAmapurA, ujjaina [ ma.pra.] [ vikrama kI 10 vIM sadI pUrva ]

Page #122
_

Page #123
[prakaraNa-21 ] caitya yAnI jinamaMdira yA jinapratimA caitya zabda kA artha jinamandira athavA jinapratimA aisA hotA hai / sthAnakapaMthI loga guruvaMdana ke 'tikkhuttA" nAmaka pATha meM "devayaM ceiyaM pajjuvAsAmi" aisA bolate haiM / kintu "ceDayaM" zabda kA artha ve galata karate haiM / 'ceiyaM' yAnI "caitya" zabda kA artha sthAnakapaMthI santoM dvArA vividha pustakoM meM vividha kiyA gayA hai| ' ce iyaM pajjuvAsAmi" kA zAstrIya artha "jinapratimA kI taraha maiM ( guru kI) upAsanA karatA hUM," aisA hotA hai / eka itihAsakAra ke nAte prAcArya hastImalajI ko AgamazAstroM, pAgametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya, vRtti, caNi, bhASya tathA TIkAdi aura zabdakoSa-vyAkaraNa ke sahAre se svamAnyatA ko dUra rakhakara taTasthatA evaM prAmANikatA se 'ce iyaM' yAnI 'caitya' zabda kA artha karanA atyanta Avazyaka thA kintu isa viSaya meM prAcArya ne aMdhere meM hI rahanA ucita samajhA hai aura aisA karake unhoMne apane itihAsa ko bhI apUrNa rakhA hai / phira bhI khaMDa 2, pR0 623 se 628 taka prAcArya ne "caityavAsa" ke viSaya meM caitya kA artha nahIM karake hI lambI caur3I nirarthaka carcA calAyI hai| kintu caitya' kA artha "jinamaMdira" hotA hai isa tathya ko puSTi unase mAnoM yA na mAnoM ho hI gayI hai| jainAgamoM meM jahA~ bhI caitya zabda prAtA hai, vahA~ sthAnakapaMthI saMta Adi caitya zabda kA jina pratimA aura jinamaMdira aisA prakaraNa

Page #124
[ 2 ] sulabha artha ko chor3akara, ekAntamArga kA Azraya karake caitya kA artha kahIM jJAna, kahIM sAdhu, kahIM kAmadeva kI pratimA Adi kara dete haiM, jo apramANika hai / jJAna ke liye zAstra meM kahIM bhI caitya zabda nahIM likhA hai, ki maticaitya, zrutacaitya ityAdi / evaM zabdakoSa aura vyAkaraNa meM sAdhu ke liye nirgrantha, zramaNa, muni Adi zabda prasiddha hai na ki caitya / pUjya hemacandrAcArya mahArAja ne koSa meM 'caitya' zabda kA artha jinapratimA evaM jinamaMdira kiyA hai, yathA "caityaM jina bimbaM tadaukaH / " "arihaMta ceiyANaM" zabda kA artha zrI Avazyaka sUtra ke pA~caveM kAyotsarga nAmaka adhyayana meM 'jina pratimA' aisA kiyA hai, yathA "arhantaH tIrthaMkarAH, teSAM caityAni prtimaalkssnnaani"| navAMgI TIkAkAra pUjya zrI abhayadevasUrijI mahArAja ne 'caitya' zabda kA artha "iSTa deva kI pratimA" aisA kiyA hai| yathA "caityam iSTadeva pratimA" [ bhagavatI sUtra, zataka 2, uddeza 1] pravacana sAroddhAra kI vRtti meM tathA sUrya prajJapti meM caitya kA artha jinapratimA tathA upacAra se jinamaMdira aisA kiyA hai| _AcArya hastImalajI ne caitya zabda kA zAstra kathita artha DhUDhA hotA to svayaM ko aura anya ko bhrama meM rakhane kA pardA phAza ho sakatA thaa|

Page #125
[ 83 ] sthAnakapaMtho saMta evaM paMDita caitya zabda kA artha karane meM kaisI dagAbAjI karate haiM yaha dekhiye / zrI uvavAI sUtra meM aMbaDa zrAvaka kA adhikAra prAtA hai, jo pahile sanyAsI thaa| jaba zrI mahavIra svAmI ke samakSa bAraha vrata dhAraNa kiye taba usane bAraha vrata rUpa mahala kI nIMva ke samAna 'samyagdarzana vrata' sarvaprathama svIkAra kiyA thaa| vaha zrI mahAvIra bhagavAna ke sAmane yaha pratijJA karatA hai ki 444 NaNNattha arihaMte vA arihaMta ceiyANi vA vaMditA vA namasaMti vaa| [ zrI uvavAI sUtra ] xxx arthAt-vItarAga zrI arihaMta tathA arihaMta kA (caitya yAnI ) jina pratimA vAMdavA kalpe anya nhiiN| ukta sUtra kA sthAnakapaMthI saMta amolaka RSi apramANika evaM vyAkaraNa aura zabda koSa nirapekSa artha karate haiM ki 80 phakta arihaMta aura arihaMta ke [caitya yAnI] sAdhu ko hI vandana karanA, namaskAra karanA yAvat sevAbhakti karanA kalpatA hai| [uvavAI sUtra, hindI anuvAda, pR0 163] xxx mImAMsA-yahAM caitya kA kalpita artha sAdhu kiyA hai, jo svamatikalpita evaM zAstra nirapekSa hai| kyoMki zrI bhagavatI sUtra meM asurakumAra devatA saudharma devaloka meM jAte haiM, taba eka arihaMta dUsarA caitya arthAt jinapratimA aura tIsarA anagAra yAnI sAdhu ( muni ) ina tonoM kA zaraNa karate haiM aisA kahA hai, yata. xxx nannastha arihaMte vA arihaMta ceiyANi vA bhAvI appaNo aNagArassa vANissAva uDDhe uppayaMti jAva sohammo kppo|xxx

Page #126
[ 84 ] isa pATha meM (1) arihaMta (2) caitya aura (3) anagAra, yaha tIna kA zaraNa kahA hai / yadi caitya zabda kA artha sAdhu hotA to 'anagAra' zabda pRthak kyoM kahA ? ataH caitya kA artha sAdhu ( muni ) karane vAle sthAnakapaMthI jhUThe sAbita hote haiM / caitya zabda kA dUsarA kalpita artha amolaka RSi 'jJAna' karate haiM, yaha bhI dekhiye / zrI bhagavatI sUtra meM gaNadhara zrI gautamasvAmI tIrthaMkara mahAvIra svAmI ko cAraNamuni ke utpAta [vidyAbala se chalAMga lagAne kI zakti) ke viSaya meM pUchate haiM ki - 444 "vijjAcAraNassa bhaMte ! uDDhe kevaie gai visae paNNatte ? goyamA ! se NaM itto egeNaM uppAeNaM NaMdaNavaraNe samosaraNaM karaI, karitA tAhi ceiyAiM vaMdai, vaMdaittA bitieNaM uppAeNaM paMDagavaNe samosaraNaM karaI, karittA tahiM ceiyAiM vaMdaI, vaMdaittA tao paDiNiyattaI, paDiNiyaittA, ihamAgacchaI, ihamAgacchittA iha ceiyAI vaMdaI / vijjAcAraNassa gaM goyamA ! uDDhe evaie gaI visae paNNatta / " [ bhagavatI sUtra-zataka 20, uddeza 9 ]688 ukta sUtra kA zAstrokta artha - "he bhagavan ! vidyAcAraNa labdhivAle muniyoM kA Urdhva meM gamana kA kitanA viSaya kahA hai ? [ bhagavAna zrI mahAvIra svAmI uttara dete haiM ki-] he gautama ! vidyAcAraNa muni yahAM se eka utpAta meM naMdanavana meM vizrAma leve, vahAM ke caitya yAnI jinabiMba [pratimA] ko vAnde, vahA~ ke jinacaitya ( jinabimba ) ko vandana karake (paryupAsanA karake ) paMDakavana meM jAe, vahAM caitya yAnI jinabiMba ko vandana karake (paryupAsanA karake ) phira svasthAna lauTe aura svasthAna ke ( madhyaloka ke azAzvata ) jinabimba

Page #127
[ 85 ] [pratimA ko vAnde / he gautama ! vidyAcAraNa ke viSaya meM Urdhvagamana kA itanA viSaya hai|" ukta sUtra kA sthAnakapaMthI saMta amolaka RSi pAgamanirapekSa evaM svamati kalpita artha isa prakAra karate haiM 80xgautama kA prazna-he bhagavan ! vidyAcAraNa kA Urdhva gamana kA kitanA viSaya kahA hai ? aho gautama ! vidyAcAraNa muni eka utpAta meM yahA~ se ur3akara meruparvata ke nandana vana meM vizrAma leve / vahAM ( caitya yAnI ) "jJAnI ke jJAna" kA guNAnuvAda kare (?) vahAM se dUsare utpAta meM paMDakavana meM samavasaraNa kare (vizrAma leve) vahAM para bhI jJAnI ke jJAna kA guNAnuvAda kare (?) aura vahA~ se bhI pIcchA apane sthAna para Ave / aho gautama ! vidyAcAraNa muni kA Urdhvagamana kA itanA viSaya hai| XXX mImAMsA-sthAnakapaMthI saMta amolaka RSi ne ukta prAkRta sUtra kA "iha ceiyAiM vaMdaI" [yAnI yahA~ Akara azAzvata jinamandira ko vAnde 1 itane zabdoM kA hindI anuvAda karanA hI chor3a diyA hai jisase unakI beImAnI jAhira hotI hai / ___ amolaka munijI jJAniyoM ke prarUpI jJAna ke vandana hetu cAraNamuniyoM ko paMDakavana aura nandanavana meM bheja rahe haiM, mAnoM paMDakavana aura naMdanavana meM jJAnI ke jJAna ke Dhera par3e hoMge / paMDakavana aura naMdanavana meM zAzvata jina mandira hai, isa tathya kI siddhi na hone pAe, isa kAraNa amolaka RSijI asatya kA sahArA lekara caitya kA artha jJAna karate haiM jo sarvathA apramANika hai / sthAnakapaMthI amolaka RSi kI sAhasikatA dekhiye ki jJAnI ke prarUpI jJAna ke vandana hetu paMDakavana aura nandanavana meM

Page #128
[ 86 ] bhejakara mahAjJAnI cAraNamuniyoM ko bhI ve ullU banA rahe haiN| kyA cAraNamuni itane mUrkha haiM ki arUpI jJAna kA yahAM baiThe baiThe vaMdana na karake labdhi kA prayoga karake vahA~ jAe ? aura naMdanavana evaM paMDakavana meM jAne hetu labdhi kA prayoga karane para bhI kyA vahA~ jJAnI ke jJAna ke bhaMDAra bhare par3e haiM ki guNAnuvAda karane hetu itane yojanoM kI lambI yAtrA kreN| ___paMDakavana aura naMdIzvara dvIpa sthita zAzvata jina mandiroM meM cAraNa muni jAte haiM aura vahAM caityavaMdana karate haiM isa zAstrIya tathya ko satya hotA dekhakara nitAMta asatya kA sahArA lekara sthAnakapaMthI mahA vidvAna ratanalAlajI DozI (zailAvA vAle ) "jainAgama viruddha mUrtipUjA bhAga-1" pR0 166 para mahA sAhasa pUrvaka likhate haiM ki 888 hamAre vicAra se [ cAraNamuni kA ] vahAM jAne kA mukhya kAraNa naMdanavana ko "sara" karane kA hI ho sakatA hai, kyoMki yaha bhI eka chadmasthatA kI palaTatI huI caJcala vicAra dhArA kA pariNAma hai|xxx mImAMsA-sthAnakapaMthI mahApaMDita ratanalAlajI kI chadmasthatA kI palaTatI huI caMcala vicAradhArA kA pariNAma dekhiye ki ve paMDitajI cha? aura sAtaveM guNasthAnaka meM sthita, mahAsaMyamI-jJAnI cAraNa muniyoM ko paMDakavana aura naMdIzvara dvIpa meM saira-saphara ke liye bhejane kI mUrkhatA kara rahe haiM aura cAraNamuniyoM ko naMdIzvara dvIpAdi meM jAne kI pravRtti ko chadmasthatA kI caMcaladhArA kA pariNAma kahane para to, tIrthaMkaroM aura kevalajJAniyoM ko chor3akara anya saba jJAniyoM kI pravRttiyA~ galata kahane kI ajJAnatA bhI ve paMDitajI kara rahe haiM / vAstava meM cAhe amolaka RSijI hoM, cAhe prAcArya hastImalajI hoM yA paMDita ratanalAlajI DozI hoM, sabhI sthAnakapaMthI hI

Page #129
[ 87 ] dRSTirAga ke pUrvagraha se grasita evaM mithyAtva ke raMga se aise raMge hue haiM ki ve siddhAyatana, jinacaitya, jinamaMdira Adi kI bAta mAne para satya kA pakSa chor3akara jaldI se jhUTha kA hI sahArA lene para utArU ho jAte haiM / __ zrI mahAvIra svAmI ke zAsana meM vIra saMvat 882 se aisA samaya pAyA ki kitaneka jaina muni zithilAcArI bana gaye, maMdira saMbaMdhita dravya yAnI "devadravya" kA bhakSaNa karane lage, unakI vihAra Adi kI caryA zithila ho gaI ! ve jinamandira meM hI rahane lage isa kAraNa ve "caityavAsI" khlaaye| prAcArya hastImalajI ne jainadharma kA maulika itihAsa, khaMDa 2, pR0 623 se 628 taka caityavAsa ke viSaya meM lambI-caur3I vArtA kI hai, kintu 'caitya' kA artha unhoMne aspaSTa aura saMdigdha hI rakhA hai / pR0 624 para ve likhate haiM ki 444 isakA ( caityavAsa kA ) prArambha vIra saMvat 882 meM ho gyaa| yadyapi usa samaya vana ke badale muni loga vasati ke caitya aura upAzraya meM utarate the, kintu vahAM ve sthAnapati hokara nahIM rahate the / caityavasati meM utarane para bhI ve satata vihArI hone ke kAraNa viharUka kahalAte the| 88 mImAMsA-itihAsakAra prAcArya ne yahA~ kaisA uTapaTAMga aura aspaSTa likhA hai ? evaM "caitya" tathA "caityavasati" zabda kA artha karanA to prAcArya ne TAla hI diyA hai / jina maMdira ke zatru caitya zabda kA artha 'jina maMdira' kyoM kareMge? parama satyapriya, 1444 granthoM ke racayitA pUjyapAda haribhadrasUrijI mahArAja ke kathana kA uddharaNa karake khaMDa 2 pR0 626 para prAcArya hastImalajI likhate haiM ki

Page #130
[ 88 ] 888 ye sAdhu caityoM aura maThoM meM rahate haiM / pUjA karane kA Arambha evaM devadravya kA upabhoga karate haiN| Xxx mImAMsA-maTha zabda se prAcArya kA kyA tAtparya hai ? aura caitya zabda kA artha yahAM bhI unhoMne nahIM kiyA hai| kintu itanA to spaSTa hai ki usa samaya bhI jinapratimA, jinamandira aura jinapUjana prathA thii| aura devadravya bhI thA isa satya tathya kI ora aAMkheM mUMda lenA anucita hI hogaa| aura yaha bhUlanA nahIM cAhie ki usa samaya bhI pUjya haribhadrasUrijI, pUjya abhayadevasUrijI Adi sUvihita muni vidyamAna the, jinhoMne caityavAsa sambandhita zithilatA kA virodha karate hue bhI jinamandira aura jinapratimA Adi zAstra kathita pravRttiyoM kI prarUpaNA evaM puSTi kI thI aura preraNA bhI dI thii| khaMDa 2, pR0 628 para prAcArya likhate haiM ki 888 upalabdha sAhitya ke avalokana se aisA pratIta hotA hai ki vikrama saMvat 1285 se "caityavAsa" sarvathA banda ho gayA aura muniyoM ne upAzraya meM utaranA prArambha kara diyaa| XXX mImAMsA-hamArA to itanA hI kahanA hai ki jina suvihita, prAgamajJa muniyoM ne caityavAsa sambandhI zithilatA ko sAmane Takkara lekara caityavAsa ko samApta kiyA thA, unhoMne hI jinamandira, devadravya, rakSaNa Adi ke viSaya meM preraNA kI thii| yAnI jo siradarda thA use auSadhi se miTAyA thA, kintu sira ko kATane kI mUrkhatA ina suvihita muniyoM ne nahIM kI thI, isa satya tathya se prAcArya hastImalajo aparicita nahIM hoNge| sAdhavaH zAstra cakSuSaH sAdhunoM jJAna A~kha se dekhate haiM /

Page #131
[prakaraNa-22 ] eka hAsyAspada kalpanA aAdhunika yuga ke ucchRkhala cintaka jo prAcIna jainAcAryoM kathita camatkArapUrNa ghaTanAoM meM vizvAsa nahIM karate haiM, unake tuSTikaraNa hetu prAcArya hastImalajI ne pUrvAcAryoM para avizvAsa karane vAlI sAhasikatA kA avalambana kara khaMDa 2 prAkkathana pR0 38 para likhA hai ki xxx isI prakAra bahuta sI camatkArika rUpa se citrita ghaTanAoM ko bhI isa grantha meM samAviSTa nahIM kiyA gayA hai| madhyayugIna aneka vidvAna graMthakAroM ne sikhasena prabhRti katipaya prabhAvaka AcAryoM ke jIvana caritra kA Alekhana karate hue unake jIvana kI kucha aisI camatkArapUrNa ghaTanAoM kA ullekha kiyA hai, jina para Aja ke yuga ke adhikAMza cintaka kisI bhI dazA meM vizvAsa karane ko udyata nahIM hote| 888 mImAMsA-pUjyapAda siddhasena divAkara sUrijI ke "kalyANamandira" nAmaka stotra ke prabhAva se zivaliMga phaTA thA aura usameM se zrI pArzvanAtha bhagavAna kI pratimA nikalI thii| jinapratimA kI mAnyatA kA virodha karane ke kAraNa hI mAcArya hastImalajI ne pUjyapAda siddhasenasUrijI Adi ke viSaya meM aisA likhA hai ki camatkArika ghaTanA isa grantha meM nahIM likhI gayI hai / "camatkArika ghaTanAmoM ko isa grantha meM samAviSTa nahIM kiyA hai," aisA prAcArya hastImalajI kA kathana sarvathA jhUThA

Page #132
[ 60 ] hI hai / hA~ ! "jinapratimA" viSayaka camatkAra se svamatahAni ke kAraNa hI prAcArya ne prastuta meM asatya evaM apramANikatA kA sahArA liyA hai / anyathA svayaM prAcArya ne hI zrI pArzvanAtha bhagavAna ke caritra meM jIrNakumArI, candragupta-cANakya kA kathAnaka, zrImAnatugasUrijI kA ber3I TUTanA, subhUma aura brahmadatta cakravartI kI Azcarya evaM camatkArapUrNa ghaTanA kA apane itihAsa meM samAveza kiyA hai / itanA hI nahIM sagara cakravartI ke 60 hajAra putroM kI mauta para paurANika kiMvadantI svarUpa gapor3e ko bhI yahI prAcArya mahAzaya ne prastuta kiyA hai / api ca naMdavaMza kI utpatti ke avasara para prAcArya ne hI pratijJA bhaMga karake camatkArika ghaTanA khaMDa 2, pR0 268 para prastuta kI hai, yathA Xxx udAyI kA rAjachatra bhI svataH hI nanda ke mastaka para tana gayA aura nanda ke donoM ora mantrAdhiSThita ve donoM cAmara svataH hI adRzya zakti se prerita ho vyajita hone lge|xxx evaM zrI mAnatugasUrijI ke viSaya meM khaMDa-2, pR0 646 para prAcArya likhate haiM ki xxx kamaroM ke dvAra svataH hI khula gaye, AcArya mAnatuga ke sabhI baMdhana kaTa gye| 80x mImAMsA-prAcArya hastImalajI dvArA prastuta uparokta ghaTanAeM kyA camatkArika nahIM haiM ? kyA ina para prAcArya ke mAne hue aAdhunika ciMtaka vizvAsa kareMge? kyA uparokta bAtoM se unakI camatkArika ghaTanA prastuta nahIM karane kI pratijJA kA bhaMga nahIM hotA hai ? jaba camatkArapUrNa ghaTanAe~ prAcArya ne apane itihAsa meM likhI hI haiM, to pUjya siddhasenasUrijI sambandhita zivaliMga phaTane kI ghaTanA, zrI gautamasvAmI kA yAtrA hetu aSTApada giri para jAnA, zrI vanasvAmI kA

Page #133
[ 1] jinapUjA nimitta AkAzagAminI vidyA dvArA puSpa lAnA Adi bAtoM se hI unako kyoM nArAjagI hai ? jinapratimA pUjA, jinamandira aura jainatIrthoM ne prAcArya kA kyA bigAr3A hai, ki unake sAtha sambandhita ghaTanAmoM ko ve camatkArika kahakara napharata karate haiM ? ___ eka prazna yaha bhI hai ki prAcArya hastImalajI ciMtaka kisako kahate haiM ? aAdhunika jo ciMtaka nAstika haiM, azraddhAvAna haiM aura mithyAtvavAsita haiM, unako to kitanI bhI satya hone para dharma saMbaMdhI koI bhI bAta suhAyegI hI nahIM / aise bahuta se Adhunika ciMtaka itane nAstika haiM ki ve dharma ko "nazA" kI saMjJA dete haiN| aise citakoM kI tuSTi ke liye asatya kA sahArA lekara, pUrvAcAryoM ke kathanoM ko dhRSTatA pUrvaka anyathA kahakara prAcArya hastImalajI sabhI jaina zAstroM ko jI cAhe vaise palaTa DAle, phira bhI prAcIna jaina zAstroM kI bAta para unake mAne hue Adhunika ciMtakoM ko vizvAsa hogA yA nahIM yaha prazna jyoM kA tyoM khar3A hI rahegA / phira to "lene gaI pUta aura kho pAyI khasama" vAlI kahAvata prAcArya dvArA caritArtha ho jaaygii| jaina dharma meM bhI aise bahuta se vyakti haiM jo Agama aura prAgametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya vRtti, cUrNi, bhASya aura TIkAdi kathita prAmANika satya hone para aura aitihAsika prAcIna zilAlekhoM evaM dhvaMsAvazeSoM kI sAmagrI maujUda hote hue bhI jinamaMdira tathA jina pratimA Adi ke viSaya meM zraddhA nahIM karate haiM, phira kyA unake lie prAcIna Agama zAstroM ko badala diyA jAya ? athavA prAcIna jaina pratimA aura maMdira Adi ko indrajAla hI samajhA jAya ? jisake dila meM prAcIna jainAcAryoM para zraddhA, bhakti aura bahumAna hai, vaha kabhI bhI avizvAsa pUrNa vacana nahIM bolegA ki "pUrvAcAryoM ne aisI camatkArika ghaTanA kA ullekha kara diyA hai, jisa

Page #134
[ 2 ] ko mAnane ke liye adhikAMza aAdhunika ciMtaka kisI bhI dazA meM vizvAsa nahIM kara sakate / " kintu prAcArya hastImalajI kA ukta pratipAdana nitAMta galata aura svamati kalpita hai kyoMki akhabAroM meM prasiddha hone vAlI bahuta sI camatkArika ghaTanAoM ko Aja ke ciMtaka satya tathya svIkAra karate haiN| hamArA to yahI mAnanA hai ki Aja ke yuga ke adhikAMza citakoM" meM AcArya bhI eka haiM, jinhoMne pUrvAcAryoM ke prAmANika kathanoM para aprAmANika AkSepa karake bagAvata kI hai| prAcArya ke pAsa aisA kaunasA yaMtra hai jisase ve jAna sakeM ki camatkArapUrNa ghaTanA para Aja ke yuga ke citaka vizvAsa nahIM karate haiM ? prAcArya nija ke viSaya meM to aisA kaha sakate haiM, kintu adhikAMza ciMtakoM ke viSaya meM aisI kalpanA unake adhikAra ke bAhara hai / hamArA to yaha kahanA hai ki pUrvAcAryoM ke viSaya meM prAcArya aisI saMkucita mAnyatA kyoM rakhate haiM ki pUrvAcAryoM ne prAgametara jaina sAhitya galata racA hai| Aja ke vijJAna ke yuga meM jainAgamoM kI bahuta sI bAteM jo pahile videzI zikSitoM meM avizvasanIya evaM kAlpanika mAnI jAtI thIM, Aja ve prAmANika siddha huI haiM / jaise ki pUrva bhava kA honA, vanaspati ekendriya jIva hai, pAnI meM asaMkhya jIva kA honA, AvAja kA paudgalika honA, eka bhASA meM bolA gayA zabda apanI apanI bhASA meM sunanA Adi aneka jainAgama kathita bAteM vijJAna dvArA siddha ho cukI haiN| camatkArapUrNa ghaTanAeM prAdhunika ciMtakoM ko avizvasanIya lagatI haiM isake kAraNa unako apane itihAsa meM likhanA prAcArya ne anucita samajhA hai| phira to jaina dharma kA tyAga-tapa-saMyamAdi kI bAteM adhikAMza prAdhunika ciMtakoM ko prarucipUrNa aura avizvasanIya lagatI haiM, to kyA prAcArya jaina dharma ko avizvasanIya mAnakara tyAga deMge?

Page #135
[ 63 ] astu / pUjya siddhasenasUrijI Adi kI ghaTanA camatkAra pUrNa hone ke kAraNa aAdhunika ciMtakoM ko avizvasanIya lage ataH prAcArya ne unako nahIM likhanA ucita samajhA hai, to kyA nimnalikhita Agama kathita bAteM Adhunika ciMtakoM ko avizvasanIya aura prazraddhanIya nahIM lageMgI ? phira kyA prAcArya prAgama zAstroM ko bhI Adhunika ciMtakoM kI saMtuSTi ke liye palaTeMge ? yathA (1) tIrthaMkaroM kA khUna sapheda honaa| (2) tIrthaMkara paramAtmA ke janmAdi kalyANakoM ke avasara para devendroM kA Agamana Adi / (3) indrabhUti Adi 4400 brAhmaNoM kI eka hI dina meM bhagavAna zrI mahAvIra svAmI ke pAsa dIkSA lenA aura indra dvArA sAdhu veSa denaa| (4) zrI RSabhadeva bhagavAna kA 400 dina kA nirjala upavAsa / (5) vaizyA ke ghara rahe hue naMdoSeNa dvArA hara dina 10 ko pratibodhita karake dIkSA dilvaanaa| (6) ceTaka aura kUNika ke bIca rathamUsala yuddha meM eka hI dina meM 66 lAkha sainikoM kA saMhAra honA / (7) sadyojAta bAlaka mahAvIra ke caraNa-sparza mAtra se meru parvata kA kaMpAyamAna honA / (8) madhyaloka meM asaMkhya dvIpa aura samudra kA honaa| (9) mahAvideha kSetra meM zrI sImaMdhara svAmI prAdi bIsa tIrthaMkaroM kA honaa|

Page #136
[ 94 ] (10) sUrya, candra, maMgala Adi jyotiSa devoM ke vimAnoM kA astitva, jahA~ rokeTa Adi dvArA manuSya aba bhI nahIM pahuMca pAyA hai| (11) janu Adi 60 hajAra sagaraputroM kI tIrtharakSA meM eka sAtha mRtyu / (12) ekendriya se paMcendriya taka ke sammUcchima ( mAtApitA ke saMyoga ke binA janme hue ) jIva / (13) isa avasarpiNI kAla ke daza Azcarya / (14) dharmAstikAya aura adharmAstikAya kA astitva / (15) svarga aura naraka Adi kA honA / (16) aosa ke jIvoM kI rakSA hetu kAlavelA meM suvihita muniyoM dvArA kambala kA upayoga krnaa| (17) rajasvalA strI kI apavitratA aura usake liye svAdhyAya niSedha / (18) saMgama kA kAlacakra Adi devakRta bhayaMkara upasarga hone para bhI bhagavAna mahAvIra kI mRtyu kA na honaa| (16) vidyut-bijalI Adi agnikAya ekendriya jIva hai| (20) vAyu ekendriya jIva hai| (21) AlU, mUlI, gAjara Adi jamIkandoM meM ananta jIva kA honA aura dayAdharmI ko ve nahIM khAnA cAhie aisI zraddhA aura vizvAsa saMpAdana krnaa|

Page #137
[ 65 ] (22) bAsI aura dvidala bhakSaNa meM trasakAya jIvoM kI mahA hiMsA kA honaa| (23) thUka Adi meM sammacchima jIvoM kI utpatti honaa| (24) rAtri bhojana naraka kA dvAra hai / (25) jIva, saMsAra aura karma anAdi haiN| (26) namaka, patthara, sonA, cAMdI Adi pRthvIkAya ekendriya narata haiN| aisI to saiMkaDoM bAteM haiM, jinakI prAmANikatA aura satyatA ko siddha karane ke liye hamAre pAsa AgamoM aura prAgametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya ko chor3akara AdhAra hI kyA hai ? prAptapuruSa tIrthaMkaroM evaM pUrvAcAryoM ke vacanoM para zraddhA aura vizvAsa ke prabhAva meM prAptapuruSa kathita ina bAtoM para prazraddhA aura avizvAsa banA rahe to isameM kyA gurugama aura samucita abhyAsa ke abhAva meM jyotiSa Adi zAstra ajJAnI ko vyartha yA jhUTha lage, aise hI gurugama aura samucita syAdvAda pariNatamati ke abhAva meM AcArya hastImalajI ko paMcamahAvratI pUrvAcAryoM kathita bAteM camatkArika evaM kalpita lage to koI prAzcarya kI bAta nahIM hai| Aja ke yuga ke kathita katipaya nAstika ciMtakoM kI saMtuSTi hetu prAcArya ne jaina sAhitya ko badalane aura chipAne kI jo sudhAravAdI pravRtti kI hai, isase jaina samAja ko sAvadhAna evaM satarka rahane kI pratyaMta svayaM sudhAravAdI vRttivAle prAcArya dUsaroM ko prAtmavaMcaka hitazikSA khaMDa-2, pRSTha 26 para dete haiM ki

Page #138
[ 96 ] xxxyadi pratyeka jinazAsanAnuyAyI meM isa prakAra kI jAgarUkatA utpanna ho jAe to Aja jainAgamoM ke sambandha meM tathAkathita sudhAravAdiyoM dvArA jo viSailA pracAra kiyA jA rahA hai, usake kuprabhAva aura kupravAha ko rokA jA sakatA hai|xxx mImAMsA-hamArA bhI yahI kahanA hai ki prAcArya hastImalajI ke prAcIna jaina sAhitya viSayaka sudhAravAdI viSale dRSTikoNa se jaina samAja ko jAgarUka rahanA caahie| OTHA NA turns. | jaina zAstra meM samyagdarzana se bhraSTa ko bhraSTa kahA hai| zAstra meM sthAna pakSa /

Page #139
[prakaraNa-23 ] lagdhinidhAna zrI gautamasvAmI prAtaHsmaraNIya, vinayavanta, labdhinidhAna prathama gaNadhara zrI gautama svAmI mahArAja 14 vidyA ke pAraMgata the / bhagavAna zrI mahAvIra deva ke tIna hI pada [upane IvA, vigameIvA, dhUveIvA ] pAkara jinake hRdaya meM dvAdazAMgI kA prakAza huA thaa| ve itane vinayavanta the ki dIkSA dina se hI ahaM kA tyAga kara bhagavAna ke sAmane aMjalibaddha baiThakara bhagavAna kI vANI ko nidhAna se bhI adhika mUlyavAlI samajhate hue sunate the| unakI saralatA itanI thI ki bhUla mAlUma hone para caudahapUrvadhArI unhoMne prAnanda zrAvaka se kSamAyAcanA kI thii| aise pavitra cAritraghara zrI gautamasvAmI zrI mahAvIra svAmI ke vacana para apanI carama bhavitA ke nirNaya tathA yAtrA hetu svalabdhi bala se sUrya kI kiraNoM kA sahArA lekara zrI aSTApadajI tIrtha para gaye the, jahAM zrI RSabhadeva bhagavAna kI nirvANa bhUmi para prathama cakravartI bharata rAjA ne maMdira banavAyA thaa| tIrthayAtrA kAla meM hI unhoMne zrI vajrasvAmI jo pUrvabhava meM tiryag bhaga deva thA, unako pratibodha kiyA thA aura aSTApada tIrtha kI yAtrA hetu labdhi prApti ke liye tapa karate hue 1500 tApasasanyAsiyoM ko cAritra-dIkSA dekara, akSINa mahAnasa labdhi ke bala se aMgUThe meM se amRta tulya khIra bahAkara pAraNA karavAyA thA, prataHmAja bhI loga zrI gautamasvAmI ke viSaya meM kahate haiM ki aMgUThe amRta base / ve

Page #140
[ 68 ] 1500 tApasa guru zrI gautama svAmI kI kRpA se kevalajJAnI bane the| zrI gautama svAmI ne jinako bhI dIkSA dI hai, unhoMne kevalajJAna prApta kiyA hai, ataH aAja bhI "gautama sarikhA guru nahIM" aisA jaina jana jana ke dila meM gUjatA hai| khaMDa 2, pR0 32 se 36 taka meM pUjya zrI gautamasvAmI ke viSaya meM prAcArya hastImalajI ne bahuta kucha likhA hai, kintu zrI gautamasvAmI kA svalabdhi bala se zrI aSTApada giri para tIrthayAtrA hetu jAnA, aSTApadagiri ke sopAna para labdhiprApti hetu tapa karate hue 1500 tApasoM ko khIra kA pAraNA karavAnA Adi tathyoM ko chipA ke unhoMne prathama gaNadhara zrI gautamasvAmI ke caritra ke sAtha. sarAsara anyAya kiyA hai / pR0 36 para prAcArya likhate haiM ki 800 ve sarvAkSara sannipAta jaisI vividha labdhiyoM ke dhAraka the| 808 pR0 36 para likhate haiM ki 444 pratidina lAkhoM jana Aja bhI prabhAta kI maMgala velA meM bhakti pUrvaka bhAva vibhora ho bolate haiM, aMgUThe amRta base, labdhi taNAM bhaMDAra / zrI guru gautama samariye, vAMchita phala dAtAra // xx mImAMsA-zrI gautamasvAmI ne aMgUThe meM se amRta kahA~ aura kyoM bahAyA ? labdhi kA upayoga kahAM aura kyoM kiyA? ve vAMchita phala ke dAtAra kisa kAraNa kahe jAte haiM ? ina tathyoM ko prAcArya ne apane itihAsa meM kyoM chipAyA hai ? kyA eka itihAsakAra ko aisI vaMcanA zobhanIya hai ?

Page #141
[ 6] tathya yaha hai ki akSINa mahAnasa labdhi se zrI aSTApadagiri ke sopAna para tapa karate 1500 tApasoM ko khIra ke pAtra meM aMgUThA rakhakara cAhe jitanI khIra bahAkara zrI gautama svAmI ne pAraNA karavAyA thA, isaliye unake viSaya meM kahA jAtA hai ki "aMgUThe pramRta base / " tathA sva vidyA-labdhi bala se sUrya kI kiraNoM ko pakar3akara ve praSTApadajI tIrtha para yAtrA karane gaye the, prataH unheM "labdhi taNAM bhaNDAra" kahate haiM aura unhoMne jinako bhI dIkSA dI thI, unako kevalajJAna rUpa akSayalakSmI kI prApti huI hai. ataH unako vAMchita phala dAtAra kahate haiN| inhIM kAraNoM se bAja bhI zrI gautama svAmI kA nAma jaina jana-jana ke hRdayoM meM aMkita hai| prAcArya hastImalajI ne zrI gautamasvAmI ko vividha labdhiyoM kA dhAraka batAyA hai, kintu zrI gautama svAmI ne labdhiyoM kA upayoga kaba aura kahA~ kiyA thA ? pratidina lAkhoM jana unako labdhi kA nidhAna kahakara kyoM yAda karate haiM ? ve aMgUThe se amRta bahAne vAle kyoM kahe jAte haiM ? prAdi aneka praznoM ko maMdira aura mUrti virodhI svamAnyatA ke kAraNa prAcArya ne jo chipAne kI kuceSTA kI hai. vaha vicAraNIya hai / prAcArya pada dhAraka hote hue eka vyakti jinapratimA, jinamaMdira evaM tIrthoM Adi ke viSaya meM tathyoM ko chipAye yA pakSapAtapUrNa vartana kare, yaha kyA nyAyapUrNa hai ? aisI dazA meM 'saMpAdakIya noMdha" pR0 30 ( purAnI prAvRtti ) para mukhya saMpAdaka zrI gajasiMhajI rAThaur3a (nyAyatIrtha) kA likhanA sarAsara jhUTha aura asaMgata evaM prAtmavaMcaka hai ki 444 itihAsa-lekhana jaise kArya ke liye gahana adhyayana, kSIra nIra vivekamayI tIvra buddhi, utkaTa koTi ko smaraNa zakti, utkaTa sAhasa,

Page #142
[ 100 ] athAha jJAna, aDiga adhyavasAya, "pUrNa niSpakSatA" ( ? ) ghora parizrama Adi atyucyakoTi ke guNoM ko AvazyakatA rahatI hai| ve sabhI guNa AcAryazrI ( hastImalajI ) meM vidyamAna haiN|xxx mImAMsA-zrI gajasiMhajI ko prazaMsA evaM khuzAmada nitAMta prasatya ThaharatI hai, kyoMki AcArya meM niSpakSatA prAdi kA sarvathA abhAva hI pAyA jAtA hai, jo bAta hama pUrva meM dikhA cuke haiN| itihAsa viSayaka tathya satya ko chipAne ke bAvajUda bhI prAcArya padArUr3ha aura satyavrata ke dhAraka kahe jAne vAle prAcArya kA chalakapaTa dekho ki ve khaMDa 2, pR0 36 para 'prAka kathana' meM likhate haiM ki xxx hamArI ceSTA pakSapAta vihIna evaM kevala yaha rahI hai ki vastu sthiti prakAza meM lAyI jAya / 888 mImAMsA-"vastusthiti prakAza meM lAyI jAya"-aisA pratijJApUrvaka kahane vAle prAcArya ko unakI kathanI aura karanI bIca kitanA bar3A antara hai yaha vicAranA cAhie / itihAsakAra ko taTastha aura prAmANika honA cAhie jisakA sthAnakapaMthI prAcArya hastImalajI meM nitAMta prabhAva hI pAyA gayA hai, jo atyanta kheda kI bAta hai| saccA itihAsakAra tathya ko kabhI bhI nahIM chipAtA hai, cAhe vaha svayaM use mAne yA na mAneM yaha eka

Page #143
[ 101 ] alaga bAta hai kintu itihAsakAra ke jariye jo kucha aitihAsika sAmagrI jisake bhI viSaya meM upalabdha ho una sabako prastuta kara denA usakA pavitra kartavya hai| -: lokottara cAra mahApApa : (1) sAdhu mahArAja kA khUna karanA ( 2) sAdhvIjI ke zIla kA khaMDana karanA (3) devadravya kA bhakSaNa karanA [ bolI bolakara paisA na denA ] (4) jinamaMdira aura maMdira kI pratimA ko tor3anA [bhadrika jIvoM kI maMdira viSayaka bhAvanA ko tor3anA yA maMdira meM nahIM jAnA aisI pratijJA denA ]

Page #144
[prakaraNa-24 ] syAhAda siddhAMta meM hiMsA evaM ahiMsA __ vaise dekhA jAe to sAmAyika, pratikramaNa, pravacana denA, gocarI hetu jAnA Adi sabhI zubha dharma kriyAoM meM sthAvarakAya kI sUkSma hiMsA hotI hI nahIM hai aisA dRr3hatA pUrvaka kahanA muzkila hai| zrAvaka sammelana karavAnA, pradarzana hetu bhaktajanoM ko saikar3oM mIla kI dUrI se vaMdana ke bahAne bulAnA, unake bhojanAdi kI suvidhA ke liye anya bhaktoM ko prerita karanA, kabUtaroM ko cuggA DAlane kI preraNA karanA, sthAnaka banavAne kI preraNA denA, kitAba chapavAnA, goThaprItibhoja karavAnA, itihAsAdi mudrita karavAne hetu vaitanika paMDita ko sAvadya prAdeza pUrvaka idhara-udhara bhejanA, nija kI tasvIra chapavAne-ba~TavAne meM bhaktagaNoM ko mUka sammati denA, nAriyala Adi kI prabhAvanA karavAnA, dayA palavAne para kaccA pAnI pInA-pilAnA, thoDIsI rAkha DalavA ke pAnI ko acitta (! ) banavAnA Adi aneka sAvadha yAnI pApapUrNa kAryoM ko ahiMsA dharma ke premI mAne jAne vAle aura "prazna vyAkaraNa" nAmaka pAgama zAstra ke nAma se dUsaroM ko ahiMsA viSayaka korA upadeza dene vAle prAcArya hastImalajI ukta sAvadha kArya kyoM karate evaM karavAte haiM ? yaha prAzcaryapUrNa hai / "prAraMbhe natthi dayA" arthAt "hiMsA rUpa prArambha meM dayA nahIM hai", aisA ekAnta se kahane vAle

Page #145
[ 103 ] prAcArya ko apanI karanI aura kathanI jAMcanI cAhie aura agara unakI ukta karanI hiMsAmUlaka hai to unheM inakA tyAga karanA caahie| hiMsA aura ahiMsA ke viSaya meM jaina siddhAnta syAdvAda ke samucita jJAna ke abhAva ke kAraNa hI prAcArya ne khaMDa 2, pR0 156 para likhA hai ki xxxjo loga caitya, maMdira, maTha aura yajJa-yAgAdi dharmakAryoM meM hone vAlI hiMsA ko nahIM mAnate unheM prazna vyAkaraNa ke isa adhyayana ko dekhanA caahie| isameM artha aura kAma nimitta kI jAne vAlI hiMsA kI taraha dharmahetu kI jAne vAlI hiMsA ko bhI adharma batAyA hai| Xxx mImAMsA-'prazna vyAkaraNa' pAgama ke nAma se maMdira aura maTha ke sAtha yajJa-yAgAdi kI hiMsA ko jor3anA prAcArya kA apramANika kRtya hai| prAcArya ne agara jainAgamoM aura prAgametara jaina sAhitya vRtti, cUNi, bhASya, TIkAdi ko acchI taraha dekhA hotA to maMdira ke sAtha yajJa-yAgAdi kI hiMsA ko jor3ane kA dussAhasa nahIM krte| saMpUrNa jaina sAhitya meM kahIM bhI yajJa-yAgAdi kriyA ko sarAhA nahIM hai| itanA hI nahIM zAstroM meM unako sarvathA anucita mAnate hue unakI kar3I AlocanA evaM bhartsanA kI gayI hai| "caitya' zabda ke artha ko prAcArya hastImalajI ne aspaSTa rakhA hai / yAnI 'caitya' zabda se unakA matalaba kyA sAdhu se, yA jJAna se, yA kAmadeva kI pratimA se, yA anya kisI artha se hai ? "maTha" zabda se prAcArya kA tAtparya agara sthAnaka yA upAzraya se hai, taba to ghaTakuTyAM nyAya' caritArtha ho gyaa| ve svayaM

Page #146
__ [ 104 ] maTha-sthAnaka-upAzrayAdi banavAne kI preraNA karate haiM aura sthAnaka banavAne vAloM kI prazaMsA-sarAhanA anumodanA bhI karate haiN| prataH "prazna vyAkaraNa" kathita ahiMsA viSayaka bodha pAkara svayaM prAcArya ko aisA pratipAdana karanA cAhie ki maTha-sthAnaka-upAzraya baMdhavAnA adharma hai yAnI pApa hai, tAki unake bhakta sthAnaka banavAne kI hiMsAmaya pApa pravRtti se baca skeN| jinamandira tathA jinapUjA meM hiMsA hone se pUjAdi ko pApa rUpa kahane vAle prAcArya ko sAmika bhakti, prItibhoja, zrAvaka sammelana, jIvAnukampA, pustaka chapavAnA, bhaktoM ko mIloM kI dUrI se bulavAnA, sthAnaka banavAnA Adi kArya bhI pApa rUpa hone ke kAraNa, inheM tyAganA cAhie / "prazna vyAkaraNa" ke upadeza se svayaM prAcArya hI kyoM viparita cala rahe haiM ? Age pIche ke saMdarbha evaM tAtparya ko chor3akara aikAntika rIta se "prazna vyAkaraNa Agama" ke nAma se maMdira evaM jina pratimAdi satkAryoM ko kosane kI prAcArya kI pravRtti unameM syAdvAda pariNata mati kA abhAva hI pragaTa karatI hai| ekAnte zaraNya, vizvavaMdya tIrthaMkara paramAtmAoM kI upasthiti meM bhI puSpavRSTi, caMvara DhulAnA, sugaMdhita jala kA chir3akanA, devadudubhi bajanA Adi hotA thA, ahiMsA miyoM ko yaha bhUlanA nahIM cAhie ki isameM vAyukAyAdi kI hiMsA hotI hogI phira bhI ina pravRttiyoM kA kAma-bhoga kI taraha bhagavAna ne niSedha nahIM kiyA hai, evaM zreNika Adi rAjA mahArAjAoM kA caturaMgI senA aura sarva Rddhi-ThATha se prabhuvaMdanA ke liye jAne meM bhI hiMsA to hotI hI hai, phira bhI Rddhi-ThATha pUrvaka vandana hetu Ane ko bhagavAna ne niSedha nahIM kiyA hai|

Page #147
[ 105 ] syAdvAda pUta dRSTivAle ko jAnanA cAhie ki yahAM bhagavAna ko dravyastava janita zubhabhAva hI anumodanIya hai, na ki tadviSayaka hiMsA / jaise sArmika bhakti ke pIche evaM dayA palavAne ke pIche sAdhu ko sArmika bhakti yA jIvadayA abhipreta-anumodanIya hai, na ki caukA viSayaka hiMsA tathA jaise upAzraya baMdhavAne kI preraNA ke pIche sAdhu ko dharma kI ArAdhanA abhipreta hai, na ki tadviSayaka hiMsA, vaise hI gRhasthoM dvArA hotI puSpa prAdi se bhagavAna kI pUjA meM sAdhu ko dravyapUjA dvArA zubha bhAvavRddhi anumodanIya hai, na ki puSpAdi viSayaka hiMsA, yaha bhUlanA nahIM cAhie / isI prakAra dravyastava kI anumodanA ke pIche bho gabhita rIti se prApta bhagavAna ko dravyapUjA se janita zubhabhAva kI anumodanA hI abhipreta hai, na ki prArambha kI anumodanA / aise hI bhagavAna ko dravyastava anumodanIya aura abhipreta hai, kyoMki samavasaraNa meM rAjA evaM amAtyoM dvArA hotA baliupahAra evaM bharata cakravartI Adi dvArA nirmita jinamaMdira aura mUrtipUjA ke viSaya meM bhagavAna ne kabhI bhI niSedha nahIM kiyA hai aura na anucita bhI kahA hai / isa viSaya ko laghuharibhadra nyAyavizArada pUjya yazovijayajI upAdhyAya mahArAja apane "upadeza rahasya" nAmaka graMtha meM anumAna pramANa se bhI isa prakAra siddha karate haiM / yathA 444 dravyastavo bhagavadanumativiSayaH yogyaprajJApye bhagavadanivAritatvAt, yannavaM tannaivaM yathA kAmAdayaH, yadi ca bhagavAnenaM nAnvamodayiSyatadA nirAkariSyat, anyathA yogye niSedhyam aniSedhyopadezAntaradAne tadanumatiprasaMgAt / 808 arthAt-dravyapUjA bhI bhagavAna ko abhipreta [ mAnya-iSTaanumati kA viSaya ] hai / agara bhagavAna ko dravyapUjA ( dravyastava ) aniSTa-asahamata hotA to ve kAma-bhoga kI taraha isakA bhI indrAdi.

Page #148
[ 106 ] devoM aura zreNikAdi bhaktoM ko niSedha avazya karate / yadyapi bhagavAna jamAli jaise ayogya aura aprajJApanIya [ jar3abuddhivAlA ] ko niSedhya kA niSadha nahIM karate, kintu indrAdi devoM aura abhayakumAra, zreNikAdi jaise yogya aura prajJApanIya [ sukhabodhya ] ke sAmane niSedhya kA niSedha nahIM karake anya viSaya meM upadeza dene lagate, to bhagavAna kI niSedhya meM bhI anumati hai aisA siddha ho jaataa| bhagavAna prApta haiM yAnI ve yogya aura sukha bodhya ko ahita se nivartana aura hita meM pravartana karavAte haiN| bhagavAna ne devoM dvArA hotI puSpavRSTi, caMvara DhulAnA aura bali upahAra prAdi kA niSedha nahIM kiyA hai, isase dravyapUjA ke viSaya meM bhagavAna kI anumati spaSTa siddha hoto hai / aisA hI zreNika Adi kA caturaMgI senA ke sAtha jAnA evaM sUryAbhadeva tathA jIrNakumArioM ke mATaka ke viSaya meM bhI jAnanA cAhiye / Agama zAstroM evaM prAgametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya vRtti, cUNi, bhASya, TIkAdi kathita aura pUrvAcAryoM vihita (nirUpita) tathA hajAroM sAloM ke prAcIna zilAlekha, jinamUrtiyoM para likhe lekhoM se mUrti aura mUrti kI mAnyatA siddha hote hue bhI jinamUrtipUjA meM hiMsA hiMsA kI pukAra karane vAloM kI dayAdharmitA pAlU, mUlI, gAjara Adi anantakAya bhakSaNa karate vakta evaM bAsI tathA dvidala khAte samaya kahA~ calI jAtI hai, yaha samajha meM nahIM paataa| vihAra ke samaya nadI utaranA, bartana kholakara atiuSNa peya cAya Adi grahaNa karanA, varSA barasate samaya bhI pravacana rakhanA, nAriyala kI prabhAvanA karanA, ityAdi hiMsA ko dayAdharmI prAcArya kyoM mAnyatA dete haiM ? ina saba sthAnoM para prazna vyAkaraNa ke upadeza"dharmahetu kI jAne vAlI hiMsA bhI adharma hai" ko prAcArya kyoM bhUla jAle

Page #149
[ 107 ] haiM ? meraTha meM sthAnakapaMthI sAdhu ke smAraka svarUpa eka korti stambha banA hai, usake cAroM tarapha bAga, bagIce, nIce hari dUba tathA bijalI prAdi jagamagAte haiM ? maMdira kI AlocanA karane vAle aura maMdira meM nahIM jAne kI pratijJA karAne vAle prAcArya ne ukta kAryoM kA kyA kabhI virodha kiyA hai ? yA usa sthAna para darzanArtha nahIM jAne kI pratijJA apane bhaktoM ko dI hai ? syAdvAdadRSTi se hama to itanA hI kaheMge ki bhagavAna kI prAjJA meM hI dharma hai| pUjya kAlikAcArya ne lar3AI taka lar3avAI hai, isa para bhI ve mahAna ahiMsaka kahe jAte haiM / mUr3ha loga bhale dayA palavAI usako ahiMsA mAne, kintu pAnI meM thor3I sI rAkha DAlakara kaccA pAnI pilAne ke kAraNa bAharI kalpita ahiMsA bhI bhItara se mahAhiMsA hai, itanA hI nahIM kintu aisI kupravRtti mithyAtva ko bar3hAvA bhI detI hai| prAgametara jaina zAstroM meM sabase prAcIna, zrI mahAvIra svAmI ke dvArA dIkSita pUjya dharmadAsa gaNi mahArAja dvArA viracita "upadezamAlA" zAstra meM kahA hai ki xxx tamhA savvaNunnA, savvaniseho ya pavayaNe natthi / AyaM vayaM tulijjA, lAhAkaMkhivva vANio ||shlok 392 // bhAvArtha-jinAjJA utsarga aura apavAda rUpa meM hai| jainAgamoM meM tyAjya rUpa se jisakA niSedha kiyA gayA hai, usakA bhI apavAda mArga se vidhAna batAyA gayA hai / yAnI jaina pravacana meM sarvaniSedha kahIM bhI nahIM hai / ataH lAbhAkAMkSI baniye kI taraha lAbhAlAbha vicAra karake hI pravRtti karanI cAhie /

Page #150
[ 108 ] jinamaMdira, jinapratimAdi ke viSaya meM prAcArya ko anekAntavAda kA Azraya lenA cAhie, kyoMki zAstroM meM syAdvAdaparikarmita zuddha zraddhA aura pariNati ke binA vyakti ko dravyacAritrI hI kahA hai| sthAvara hiMsA jinapUjA meM, yaha dekha tU dhra je / to pApI vaha dUra deza se, jo tujhe prAkara pUje / / -nyAyavizArada pUjya yazovijayajI upAdhyAya mahArAja -

Page #151
[ prakaraNa-24] zrI bhadrabAhusvAmI praura uvasaggaharaM stotra bhagavAna zrI mahAvIra svAmI kI pATa paramparA meM prArya zrI prabhava svAmI ke pazcAt pUjya yazobhadrasUrijI pAye / Apake ziSya pArya zrI bhadrabAhu svAmI 14 pUrvadhara the| ApakA jIvana vRttAnta isa prakAra hai| prArya zrI yazobhadrasUrijI ke pAsa brAhmaNa jJAtIya bhadrabAhu aura varAhamihira nAma ke do bhAIyoM ne dIkSA lii| zrI bhadrabAhusvAmI vinayavanta aura tejasvI the, gurukRpA se Apa caudahapUrva ke dhAraka baneM aura pApako yogya jAnakara guru ne prAcArya padArUr3ha kiyaa| prAcAryapadecchu varAhamihira ko ayogya jAnakara guru ne prAcArya pada nahIM diyA / ataH vaha phira se brAhmaNa veza dhAraNakara naimittika bana gyaa| eka bAra rAjA ke ghara putra kA janma huA, taba varAhamihira ne bAlaka kI mAyu 100 sAla batAI, kintu Arya zrI bhadrabAhusvAmI ne batAyA ki usakI sAtaveM dina biDAla se mauta hogI / bAlaka kI surakSA ke nimitta rAjA ne saba biDAla billI ko nagara ke bAhara nikAla diyaa| phira bhI sAtaveM dina bAlaka kI mRtyu kapATa kI argalA para utkIrNa biDAla kI prAkRti vAlI argalA se ho gyii| rAjA ko jJAta huA ki pUjya bhadrabAhusvAmI kA jJAna satya se paripUrNa hai| logoM meM varAhamihira kI bar3I hA~sI huI, vaha ajJAnakaSTa se marakara deva huA

Page #152
[ 110 ] aura logoM para upasarga karane lgaa| isase bacane hetu pUjya bhadrabAhusvAmI ne "uvasaggaharaM stotra" kI racanA kI, jisake jApa-dhyAna se saMgha upadrava rahita huaa| prAcArya hastImalajI khaMDa 2, pR0 331 para likhate haiM ki 388 dhAtrI se bAlaka kI mRtyu kA kAraNa pUchA gayA to usane rote hue usa argalA ko uThAkara mahArAja ke sammukha prastuta kara diyaa| argalA ke mukha para utkIrNa kI huI biDAla kI AkRti ko dekhakara rAjA ne AzcaryAbhibhUta hokara bArambAra AcArya bhadrabAhu kI mahimA ko 108 mImAMsA-yahA~ prazna yaha hai ki bAlaka kI mRtyu biDAla se huI yA lohe kI argalA se ? yadyapi bAlaka kI mRtyu lohe kI argalA se huI hai, phira bhI agAdha jJAnI 14 pUrvadhara maharSi zrI bhadrabAhusvAmI ne bAlaka kI mRtyu kA kAraNa biDAla kyoM batAyA ? itane jJAnI ko to yaha kahanA cAhie ki bAlaka kI mRtyu- "lohe kI nargalA girane se hogii"| kyoMki bir3Ala kI nirjIva prAkRti se kisI kI mauta nahIM ho sakatI / yahA~ 14 pUrvadhara ko biDAla kI mUrti meM bhI mUrtimAna abhipreta hai, kintu isaprakAra kI sUkSma bAta kI samajha binA gurugama ke kAraNa sthAnakapaMthI ko kabhI nahIM AyegI, ki-"14 pUrvadhara ne bhI bAlaka kI mauta kA kAraNa biDAla se kahA thA, joki lohe ke kapATa para utkIrNa nirjIva biDAla kI prAkRti mAtra thii|" spaSTa tathya yaha hai ki kevalajJAnI tulya dezanA dene vAle caudaha pUrvadhara zrImad bhadrabAhu svAmI ne biDAla kI prAkRti ko bhI biDAla kahA hai / isI dRSTAMta se prAcArya ko bhI jAnanA cAhie ki jinezvara deva kI pratimA bhI jinezvara deva ke samAna kahI jAtI hai /

Page #153
[ 111 ] yadyapi zvetAmbara aura digambara donoM jaina samAja kI yaha zraddhA hai ki "jina pratimA jina sArikho" / yAnI jinezvara deva kI pratimA jinezvara deva ke samAna hI hai| bahudhA sthAnakapaMthI loga zvetAmbaroM ko patthara pUjaka kahate haiM yA bhagavAna kI mUrti ko patthara kahate haiM to yaha unakI alpajJatA hI hai, kyoMki mUrti kI pUjA isalie nahIM kI jAtI hai ki vaha sone, cAMdI yA saMgamaramara kI hai, kintu vaha tIrthaMkara paramAtmA kI hai isalie pUjA kI jAtI hai| vAstavikatA yaha hai ki jisakA bhAvanikSepa vaMdanIya-pUjanIya hai, usakA nAma, sthApanA aura dravya ye tInoM nikSepa bhI vaMdanIya-pUjanIya haiM / mUrti mUrtimAna kA smAraka hai / mati dvArA mUrtimAna kI pUjA kI jAtI hai| sirpha nAma smaraNa karane vAle bhI agara nAma smaraNa kI gaharAI meM utareM to jar3a nAma ke smaraNa ke pIche bhI yahI Azaya samAyA huA hai / yadyapi tIrthaMkara paramAtmA ke sirpha nAma smaraNa ke pakSadhara evaM himAyatI sthAnakapaMthI muni Adi apanI tasvIra bar3e cAva se khicavAte, ba~TavAte dekhe gaye haiM, yahA~ bhI mUrti ke pIche mUrtimAna ke smaraNa kA bhAva hI hogA yA anya ? isakA javAba prAcArya svayaM kyA deMge ? jase pitA vandanIya hai, to unakA citra-pratimA bhI vaMdanIyapUjanIya hai / isI taraha namaskAra mahAmaMtra vaMdanIya hai, vaise unakI tasvIra bhI vaMdanIya hI hai / kyA sthAnakamArgI namaskAra mahAmaMtra kI tasvIra ko thUka athavA paira lagAkara AzAtanA kareMge? nyAyavizArada mahAjJAnI pUjya yazovijayajI upAdhyAya mahArAja prabhu ke stavana meM likhate haiM ki ye jina pratimA jinavara sarikhI, pUMjo trividhe tume prANI / jina pratimA meM saMdeha na rakkho, vAcaka yaza kI vANI / /

Page #154
[ 112 ] yadi sthAnakapaMthI prAcAryAdi ko kupaMtha tyAga kara satyamArga para pAnA ho, to unheM caudaha pUrvadhara maharSi zrI bhadrabAhu svAmI mahArAja kA eka hI kathana-"biDAla kI prAkRti yAnI biDAla" ke tathya ko acchI taraha samajhanA caahie| jinapravacana aura jinamaMdira ke avarNavAda aura apalApa karane vAle jinazAsana ke ahitakArI tattvoM kA jitanI ho sake utanI tAkata se sAmanA karanA cAhie / -"zrI upadezamAlA zAstra"

Page #155
[ prakaraNa-26 ] jaina dharma meM samyak zraddhA kI vyApakatA vIra nirvANa ke karIba 980 sAla bAda AgamoM kI vAcanA karavAke pUrvAcAryoM ne jainAgamoM evaM prAgametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya ko pustakArUr3ha kara mahAna upakAra kiyA hai / utsUtra ko vajrapApa samajhane vAle, bhavabhIru una pUrvAcAryoM kI prAmANikatA aisI rahI ki jahA~ bhI sUtra-artha viSayaka matabheda Aye vahA~ grantha meM unhoMne donoM matabheda likha diye aura aise tattvoM ko vivAdAspada na banAte hue likha diyA ki-"yadatra tattvaM tattu kevalino vindanti" yAnI yahA~ paramArtha kyA hai yaha tattvajJAnI-kevalI hI jAneM / mahAjJAnI pUrvAcAryoM kI svacchamati dekho ki unhoMne tattva viparIta ho jAne ke Dara se Agama sUtroM para apanI svatantra rAya pragaTa nahIM kI hai| unako prAmANikatA aura vizvasanIyatA ke kAraNa hI hamAre liye pAgama aura Agametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya satya, mAnya aura zraddhanIya haiN| kyoMki "puruSa vizvAsa se vacana vizvAsa" yaha pAgama vacana hai| AcArya hastImalajI ko prAmANika pUrvAcAryoM ke kathana para zraddhA aura vizvAsa pratIta nahIM hotA hai / ataH ve sagaracakravartI ke 60 hajAra putroM kI mauta para prAcIna graMthoM kA sahArA chor3akara paurANika gapor3oM para vizvAsa kara rahe haiM evaM zrI siddhasenasUrijI ke viSaya meM

Page #156
[ 114 ] prAdhunika ciMtakoM ke bahAne pUrvAcAryoM ke kathana ko jhUThA karane ko tule hue haiM / kintu yahI isa kalpita paramparA kI zurU se pAdata rahI hai| jainAgamoM meM samyak zraddhA ko cAritra, tapa, zIla prAdi saba dharmoM se prathama batAyA hai / paMcasUtrakartA prAcInAcArya ne samyak zraddhA ke binA jamAli Adi kI cAritra kI sundara kriyA ko bhI "kulaTA nArI kI kriyA" kahI hai, jisakA phala saMsAra bhramaNa hai| prAcArya hastImalajI jainAgama kathita samyak zraddhA ko acchI taraha jAnate, to jaina sAhitya ko palaTane kI sudhAravAdI pravRtti nahIM apanAte / Adhunika ucchRkhala isa prakAra kA bhAba prAcArya ne khaMDa 2, pR0 38/36 para prAkkathana meM pragaTa kiyA hai / yathA 444 isI prakAra bahuta sI camatkArika rUpa se citrita ghaTanAoM ko bhI isa grantha meM samAviSTa nahIM kiyA gayA hai| madhyayugIna aneka vidvAna granthakAroM ne siddhasena prabhRti katipaya prabhAvaka AcAryoM ke jIvana caritra kA Alekhana karate hue unake jIvana kI kucha aisI camatkArapUrNa ghaTanAoM kA ullekha kiyA hai, jina para Aja ke yuga ke adhikAMza cintaka kisI bhI dazA meM vizvAsa karane ko udyata nahIM hote| 800 mImAMsA-paMcamahAvrata dhAraka prAcInAcAryoM ko jhUThA karake pAgama evaM prAgametara prAcIna sAhitya meM manamAnA aura jIcAhA parivartana karane para bhI ucchRkhala Adhunika vicArakoM ko prAcIna jaina sAhitya viSayaka bAta mAnya banegI yA nahIM yaha to vicAraNIya hI hai / kintu prAcIna jaina sAhitya ke viSaya meM apane unmArga preraka sudhAravAdI vicAra prAcArya ne Aja ke yuga ke adhikAMza cintakoM ke bahAne prastuta kara diyA hai, jo jainadharma viSayaka prAcIna sAhitya para prazraddhA evaM avizvAsa kA sUcaka hai / syAdvAda parikarmita mati ke prabhAva ke kAraNa

Page #157
[ 115 ] hI jamAli prAvi zAsana bAhya ho gaye the, prAcArya isa bAta ko sUkSmatA se jAnate hI hoNge| kyoMki khaMDa 1, pR0 718 para ve likhate haiM ki bahuta kucha samajhAne para bhI jamAli kI bhagavAna ke vacanoM para zraddhA pratIta nahIM huI aura vaha bhagavAna ke pAsa se calA gyaa| mithyAtva ke abhiniveza ( durAgraha, bhUThI jidda ) se usane svapara ko unmArgagAmI banAyA aura binA AlocanA ke maraNa prApta kara kilbiSI deva huaa| ___ mImAMsA-utsUtra bhASaNa ke vajrapApa ke kAraNa hI jamAli zAsana bAhya ho gayA aura usane deva durgati pAyI / aisA ninhavoM ke prakaraNoM ko jAnane vAle sthAnakapaMthI prAcArya hastImalajI pAgama aura Agametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya kathita aura pUrvAcAryoM dvArA vihita evaM prarUpita jinapratimA, jinamaMdira, tIrthoM Adi kA virodha karake mithyAtvI jamAli Adi ninhavoM kI koTi meM kyoM praveza karate haiM ? kyoMki jainadharma meM sthAnakapaMthI mata pravartaka lokAzAha ke pahile jinamUrtipUjA aura jinamaMdira kA virodha kisI jainAcAryAdi ne kiyA ho to prAcArya ko prAmANikatA se prastuta karanA caahie| ___ rAya bahAdura paMDita zrI gaurIzaMkara aojhA apane "rAjapUtAnA kA itihAsa" pR0 1418 para likhate haiM ki 80 sthAnakavAsI zvetAmbara samudAya se pRthak hue jo mandiroM aura mUrtiyoM ko nahIM mAnate haiN| usa zAkhA ke bhI do bheda haiM, jo bArahapanthI aura terahapaMthI kahalAte hai / DhUDhiyoM ( sthAnakapaMthI ) kA samudAya bahuta prAcIna nahIM hai, lagabhaga 300 varSa se yaha pracalita huA hai|xxx mImAMsA-mUrti aura maMdira kA virodha karane vAle zrImAn lokAzAha ke gacchavAle prAcArya jo "loMkAgacchIyAcArya" ke nAma se

Page #158
[ 116 ] pukAre jAte the, unhoMne hI maMdira banavAkara jinamUrtiyoM kI pratiSThA karavAyI thii| eka tathya aora bhI hai jisase vidyamAna prAcIna sAhitya aura karIba karIba sabhI sthAnakapaMthI vidvAna sahamata haiM ki loMkAzAha ne svamati kalpanA se kevala jinamaMdira aura jinapratimA kA hI virodha kiyA thA, kintu bAda meM "lavajI" nAmaka sthAnakapaMthI sAdhu ne sUrata (gujarAta) meM vi0 saM0 1706 ( I0 saM0 1652 ) meM muMha para muMhapattI bA~dhakara isa mata kA pravartana kiyA thA, na ki loMkAzAha ne| yAnI prAjake sthAnakapaMthI loMkAzAha ke nahIM kintu lavajIRSi kI paramparA (saMtAnIya) ke haiM / sthAnakapaMthI paMDita likha rahe haiM ki Xxx mukha bandhana zrI lokAzAha ke samaya se zuru nahIM huA hai, kintu usake bAda hue svAmI lavajI ke samaya se zuru huA hai aura vaha [ mukha para muhapattI bAMdhanA ] Avazyaka bhI nahIM hai| [ jaina jyoti, dinAMka 18-7-36, pR0 172, lekhakarAjapAla maganalAla boharA, gujarAtI para se hindI ] zvetAmbara jaina zrAvaka zrI raNajItasiMhajI bhaNDArI [jayapura ] "satyasaMdeza" kitAba pR0 (kha) para likhate haiM ki 808 muhapattI rAta dina muha para bAMdhane se bAra bAra thUka kI cipacipI, caturasparzI jIvoM kA tAr3ana pratAr3ana, bolane meM asuvidhA tathA cehare ke sahI bhAva vyakta karane kI suvidhA se vaMcita honA Adi / kyA yaha vaijJAnika kasauTI para kharI utara sakegI? 888 mImAMsA-eka maMdira aura mUrti ke pIche sthAnakavAsiyoM ko jainAgamoM aura prAcIna jaina sAhitya ko bhI jhUThA kahane kI evaM palaTane kI naubata AtI hai aura kuveSa racakara ve hAsyAspada bhI banate haiN|

Page #159
[ 117 ] janma se sthAnakamArgI paMDita sukhalAlajI apane paryuSaNA ke vyAkhyAna meM likhate haiM ki xxx hindustAna meM mUrti ke virodha kI vicAraNA muhammada paigambara ke pIche unake anuyAyI araboM aura dUsaroM dvArA dhIre dhIre praviSTa huii| jaina paramparA meM mUrti virodha ko pUrI pAMca zatAbdI bhI nahIM bItI hai [mUrtipUjA kA prAcIna itihAsa meM se] xxx mImAMsA-vAstavikatA to yaha hai ki mUrti virodha karane vAloM ke pAsa bhI jainadharma kI prAcInatA siddha karane ke liye maMdira aura mUrti ko chor3akara anya pramANa hI kyA hai ? svayaM prAcArya hastImalajI ne hI naMdIsUtra evaM kalpasUtra kI paTTAvaliyoM ko prAcIna jinapratimA kI caukiyoM para uTTa kita lekha evaM prAcIna zilAlekhoM kA sahArA lekara hI prAcIna evaM prAmANika nirNata kiyA hai / vidvAna lekhaka muni zrI jJAnasundarajI mahArAja apanI "mUrtipUjA kA prAcIna itihAsa" nAmaka kitAba ke pR07 para likhate haiM ki xxx sthAnakavAsI mata pravartaka lokAzAha [ sthAnakapaMthI paramparA ke AdyapraNetA eka vRddha jaina bhAI] para muslima saMskRti kA burA prabhAva thA aura mUrtivirodhI unakI mAnyatA ko musalamAnoM ne sahAyatA ko thii|xxx mImAMsA-jainadharma meM maMdira aura mUrtivirodhI mAnyatA kA prAdyapraNetA lokAzAha ko mAnA jAtA hai, jo ki ekavRddha jainabhAI thA aura zAstroM ko likhakara apanI prAjIvikA calAne vAlA likhArI mAtra thA / aura usase cale hue loMkAgacchIya prAcAryoM ne hI mUrtipUjA

Page #160
[ 118 ] kA samarthana kiyA hai / sthAnakapaMthiyoM meM ghara ke AMgana meM hI loMkAzAha ke viSaya meM kAphI matabheda haiM evaM isakI dIkSA ke viSaya meM bhI itane hI matabheda haiN| hamArA to itanA hI kahanA hai ki sthAnaka paMthI agara pUrvAcAryoM para zraddhA rakhate haiM to unake mArga ko unheM apanAnA cAhie / anyathA zraddhAbhraSTa ke viSaya meM prAcArya svayaM khaMDa 2, pR0 57 para likhate haiM ki 888 saNa bhaTTho bhaTTho, daMsaNa bhaTThassa natthi nivvANaM / sijhaMti caraNa rahiyA, daMsaNa rahiyA na sijhaMti // arthAt-darzanabhraSTa ( zraddhA se patita ) bhraSTa hai, aise zraddhAbhraSTa kA nirvANa ( mokSa ) nahIM hotA, ( dravya ) cAritra binA bhI mokSa hai, kintu zraddhA rahita kA mokSa nahIM hai|444 mImAMsA- zrI ThANAMga sUtra, jambUdvIpa prajJapti Adi aneka Agama sUtroM meM jagaha jagaha zAzvata-prazAzvata jinapratimA aura jina mandira prAdi kI bAta AtI hai / prAgametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya vRtti, cUNi, bhASya, TIkAdi meM bhI jinamandira, stUpa Adi kI bAta likhI hai| prAcIna aitihAsika avazeSa bhI mUrtipUjA kI Thosa siddhi karate haiM evaM pUrvAcAryoM ne hI sammedazikhara, zatrujaya, giranArajI, pAvApurI, caMpApurI Adi aneka tIrthoM evaM tIrthaMkaroM kI kalyANaka bhUmiyoM para jinamandira nirmANa karavAye haiM aura unameM jinapratimA kI pratiSThA bhI karavAyI hai / aisI dazA meM kama se kama zraddhAvanta koI bhI jaina jinapratimA aura maMdira ke tathya ko svIkAra kiye binA nahIM raha sakatA aura isameM hI anekAnta dRSTi sannihita hai /

Page #161
[ 116 ] anekAnta dRSTi ke kAraNa hI aneka sthAnakapaMthI muniyoM ne muhapatti kA DorA tor3akara zuddha saMvegI sAdhu mArga apanAyA thaa| "satyasaMdeza" saMpAdaka-pArasamala kttaariyaa| lekhaka-saubhAgyacanda loDhApR0 23 para likhate haiM ki 80. unhoMne DhUDhakamata ko tyAgakara zuddha saMvegI mata svIkAra kiyaa|xxx mImAMsA-gaNivara zrI muktivijayajI ( mUlacandajI ), gaNivara zrI buddhivijayajI (bUTerAyajI), mahopAdhyAya zrI raNadhIra vijayajI, mahAna jainAcArya pUjya zrI vijayAnandasUrijI (AtmArAma jI), muni zrI jJAnasundarajI Adi aneka vidvAnoM ne kalpita jAnakara sthAnaka paMtha kA tyAga kiyA thA aura zuddha saMvegI sAdhu mArga meM dIkSA lI thI aura sAhitya lekhana dvArA sthAnakamata viSayaka bhramajAla kA pardA kholane kA sarAhanIya prayAsa kiyA thaa| bAta to yaha hai ki bholI janatA ko aMdhere meM taba taka hI bhaTakAyA jA sakatA hai jaba taka unameM saMskRtaprAkRta bhASA dvArA jJAna kA prakAza na ho| Azcarya to isa bAta kA hai ki sthAnakapaMthI apane prAdyapravartaka lokAzAha ke batAye rAste se bhI viparIta calate haiM, ve agara unase bhI prAcIna zAstroM ko mAnya nahIM kareM to Azcarya hI kyA hai ? khaMDa 1, pR0 666 para prAcArya likhate haiM ki xxx14 pUrva ke raciyatA gautamasvAmI Ananda ko micchAmidukkaDaM dete haiN| 888

Page #162
[ 120 ] mImAMsA-yaha to anajAna se bhUla huI usakI mAphI zrI gautama svAmI mAMgate haiM, kintu jAnabUjhakara aura mAyAvRtti ke sAtha kI gayI bhUloM ke liye gahare prAyazcitta kI AvazyakatA hai| ataH itihAsa ke anta meM micchAmi dukkaDam' aisA prAcArya likha deM, to usase duSkRtagardA nahIM ho sktii| jA jisakA mana samakita meM nizcala / koI nahIM tasa tole re // -pU0 yazovijayajI mahArAja

Page #163
[ prakaraNa-27] pranucita khuzAmada AcArya hastImalajI ne "jainadharma kA maulika itihAsa" nAmaka pustaka likhakara sAmpradAyika kaTutA ubhArane kA prastutya prayatna kiyA hai / inhIM mahAzaya ne hI isake pahile "paTTAvalI prabadha saMgraha" nAmaka eka kitAba jisakA DA0 narendra bhANAvata ( jayapura ) ne saMpAdana kiyA hai, chapavAkara jinamUrti pUjA viSayaka "isa prakAra saM0 882 meM hiMsAdharma pragaTa huprA" tathA prAcIna saMyamI jainAcAryoM para 've zithilAcArI the" Adi likhakara anargala AkSepa kiye haiN| "satya saMdeza' kitAba dvArA jaina zvetAmbara tapAgaccha saMgha aisI sAmpradAyika kaTutA ubhArane vAlI pustaka kA vyApaka virodha honA cAhie thA, vaha nahIM huA hai| isake kAraNa hI Aja bhI prAcArya hastImalajI dvArA dUSita sAhitya nirmANa kara viSailA pracAra cAlU ho rahA hai| ekatA aura zAnti hameM pasanda hai, kintu sthAnakapaMtha ke karNadhAra prAcArya satya ko tor3a-maror3a kara usakA kupracAra kareM, vaha asahya hai| sthAnakapaMthI samAja ke karNadhAra dvArA aisI anucita aura galata pravRtti kaba se prArambha ho cukI hai, jisane bar3A vivAda jagAyA hai, jisakA jaina samAja dvArA vyApaka pratihAra honA atyanta Avazyaka hai|

Page #164
[ 122 ] ukta 'paTTAvalI prabandha saMgraha' nAmaka grantha jo prAcArya hastImalajI ne likhA hai isa viSaya meM taTastha sAhityakAra, purAtattvajJa vidvAn zrI agaracandajI nAhaTA "satya saMdeza" pustaka meM pR0 ( ka ) para-"eka atyAvazyaka spaSTIkaraNa" likhate haiM ki 444 mUrtipUjA ke sambandha meM bhI isa grantha meM prakAzita kaI bAteM sarvathA galata aura sAmpradAyika kaTutA ko ubhArane vAlI haiN| [satya saMdeza, saMpAdaka-pArasamalajI kaTAriyA, jayapura] 444 mImAMsA-zrI agaracandajI nAhaTA kA ukta kathana sarvathA satya hai / mUrtivirodhI galata mAnyatA vAle prAcArya ke sAhitya kI taTastha evaM prAmANika koI bhI vidvAn prazaMsA nahIM kara sktaa| DA0 narendra bhANAvatajI jaise vidvAn bhI jaba sAmpradAyika kaTutA ubhArane vAle SaDyaMtra meM aise mahAzaya ko sAtha-sahakAra-protsAhana dete haiM taba hameM sakheda Azcarya hotA hai| "jaina dharma kA maulika itihAsa" pustaka ke eka mukhya saMpAdaka nyAya-vyAkaraNa tIrtha zrI gajasiMhajI rAThaur3a ne khaMDa 1 ( purAnI prAvRtti ) meM "saMpAdakIya noMdha" ke pR0 33 se 42 taka AcArya hastImalajI kI lambI-caur3I prAtmavaMcaka khuzAmada kI hai| pR0 30 para ve likhate haiM ki xxx itihAsa-lekhana jaise kArya ke liye gahana adhyayana, kSIra nora vivekamayI tIvra buddhi, utkRSTa koTi kI smaraNa zakti, utkaTa sAhasa, athAha jJAna, aDiga adhyavasAya, pUrNa niSpakSatA, ghora parizrama Adi atyuccakoTi ke guNoM ko AvazyakatA rahatI hai / ve sabhI guNa AcArya zrI ( hastImalajI ) meM vidyamAna haiN|xxx

Page #165
[ 123 ] mImAMsA-aisA lagatA hai ki sthAnakapaMthiyoM meM apanI prazaMsA karavAne kA vizeSa pralobhana hotA hai / unake mAne hue 32 prAgamoM para kucha vRtti-cUNi-bhASya-TIkAdi ke sahAre se, kucha idharaudhara se lekara aura vaha bhI bhUloM evaM jhUThoM se bharA huA sirpha "hindI anuvAda" karane vAle amolaka RSi nAmaka sthAnakapaMthI sAdhu ne apanI hindI anuvAdita pustakoM ke panne-panne para apanA nAma likhavAyA aura chapavAyA hai| aisA to saMskRta aura prAkRta bhASA meM jainAgamoM para svataMtra pracura sAhitya racane vAle pUjya haribhadrasUrijI, pUjya abhayadevasUrijI, pUjya hemacandrAcArya mahArAja evaM pUjya yazovijayajI upAdhyAya mahArAja Adi mahAn vidvAnoM ne bhI nahIM kiyA hai / ukta amolaka RSi kI paramparA ke prAcArya hastImalajI bhI eka mahAzaya haiM, jinhoMne manakalpita evaM jIcAhA jainadharma sambandhita itihAsa prAdi sAhitya nAmadhArI eka samiti dvArA racavAyA hai aura usameM apanI jIbhara prazaMsA karavAyI hai| zrI gajasiMhajI dvArA prazaMsA karavAne vAle prAcArya hastImalajI svayaM prAcIna jainAcAryoM ko jhUThA karane hetu khaMDa-1, pR0 123 para likhate haiM ki 688 chadmastha sAhityakAroM dvArA caritra-citraNa meM atizayokti honA asaMbhava nhiiN|xxx mImAMsA-prAcArya ke uparokta kathana se gajasiMhajI rAThaur3a kA bhrama naSTa ho gayA hogaa| yAnI chadmastha gajasiMhajI rAThaur3a dvArA kiyA gayA "prAcArya hastImalajI" kA caritra-citraNa atizayoktipUrNa honA sarvathA saMbhava hai / kyoMki mukhya saMpAdaka gajasiMhajI chadmastha hone ke sAtha sAtha vaitanika bhI haiM, isake kAraNa ve "aho rUpaM, aho dhvani" vAlA prasaMga yadi prastuta kareM to usameM unakA svArtha unako bAdhya kara sakatA hai tathA gRhastha hone ke kAraNa zAyada zrI gajA

Page #166
[ 124 ] ve satya bolane kI pratijJA vAle bhI nahIM hoMge, ataH prAcArya hastImalajI ke viSaya meM unakA kathana atizayokti se bharapUra ho to usameM Azcarya hI kyA ? rahI bAta pUrvAcAryoM kI, so ve to bhavabhIru aura paMcamahAvratoM ke dhAraka satyapratijJa the, jhUTha aura atizayoktipUrNa likhane kA jinako koI prayojana hI nahIM thA / aise satyapriya jaina pUrvAcArya kathAgrantha ke caritracitraNa meM atizayokti kyoM kareMge ? tathA chadmastha hone ke kAraNa pUrvAcAryoM ke kathana ko atizayoktipUrNa kahane para to tIrthaMkara aura kevalajJAniyoM ko chor3akara anya saba jhUThe hI ThahareMge, phira to svayaM chadmastha prAcArya hastImalajI kA sAhitya sarvathA jhUThA aura apramANika siddha ho jAtA hai / khaira ! prAcArya dvArA racita isa itihAsa meM aisI to aneka galatiyAM bharI par3I haiM, jo gajasiMhajI rAThaur3a dvArA kathita unakI kSIra-nIra vivekamayI tIvra buddhi para bar3A praznArthacihna lagAne vAlI hai| prAcArya hastImalajI ke viSaya meM aisI hI atizayokti pUrNa bAta paMDita zrI dalasukhajI mAlavaNiyA ne bhI likhI hai| khaMDa-1, pR0 6 para "prakAzakIya noMdha" meM paMDita dalasukhajI mAlavaNiyA ke prazaMsA sUcaka vacana ko AkarSaka rUpa meM pragaTa kiyA gayA hai / ve prAcArya ke itihAsa ke viSaya meM anucita khuzAmada karate haiM ki 880 bahuta kAla taka ApakA yaha itihAsa graMtha prAmANika itihAsa ke rUpa meM kAyama rhegaa| naye tathyoM kI saMbhAvanA aba kama mImAMsA-aisA lagatA hai zrI mAlavaNiyAjI ko saMpUrNa itihAsa dhyAna se par3hane kA samaya hI na milA ho, saMbhava hai sirpha UparaUpara se dekhakara hI jarUrata se jyAdA AtmavizvAsa aura sAhasa ke

Page #167
[ 125 ] sAtha ukta nirNaya unhoMne de diyA ho, kyoMki itihAsa meM jagaha jagaha para "yaha vicAraNIya hai", "isa para vizeSa prakAza itihAsajJa DAleMge," isa prakAra likhakara aneka praznoM ko itihAsakAra prAcArya hastImalajI ne apUrNa evaM anirNita hI chor3a diyA hai / yathA khaMDa-1 (purAnI AvRtti ) 'apanI bAta' meM pR0 17 para bhagavAna zrI mahAvIra svAmI kA rAtri vihAra evaM brAhmaNa ko ardhavastradAna Adi bAtoM ke viSaya meM prAcArya likhate haiM ki 444 ina saba kI saMgati kyA ho sakatI hai ? isa para gItArtha gaMbhIratA se vicAra kreN|xxx __ mImAMsA-mukhya sampAdaka gajasiMhajI prAcArya hastImalajI ko athAhajJAnI, ghora parizramI Adi atyuccakoTi ke guNoM ke mAlika kahate haiM, kathita guNoM se yukta prAcArya ne ukta viSayoM ko anya ke bharose kyoM chor3A ? "athAhajJAnI" (! ) prAcArya svayaM ne isa para gaMbhIratA se vicAra kyoM nahIM kiyA ? aisI dazA meM gajasiMhajI dvArA kI gayI prAcArya kI khuzAmada kyA AtmavaMcaka nahIM ThaharatI ? aura isa bAta se mAlavariNayAjI kA bhI bhrama naSTa ho gayA hogaa| jisako bauddhadharma sambandhita batAyA jAtA hai, aise "bauddha dharmacakra" aura caturmukha siMhAkRti vAlA sAranAtha ke staMbha ke viSaya meM prAcArya khaMDa-2, pR0 451 para likhate haiM ki xxxsiMha kA saMbaMdha buddha ke sAtha utanA saMgata nahIM baiThatA jitanA ki bhagavAna mahAvIra ke sAtha / bhagavAna mahAvIra kA cinha ( lAMchana ) siMha thA aura kevalajJAna kI utpatti ke pazcAt bhagavAna mahAvIra ke sAtha-sAtha siMha kA cinha bhI caturmukhI dRSTigocara hone lagA thaa| siMha catuSTaya para dharmacakra isa bAta kA pratIka hai ki jisa samaya tIrthaMkara vihAra karate haiM, usa samaya

Page #168
[ 126 ] dharmacakra nabhamaNDala meM unake Age Age calatA hai / isa prakAra ke aneka gahana tathya haiM, jinake sambandha meM gahana zodha kI AvazyakatA hai| mImAMsA-"kevalajJAna ke bAda bhagavAna zrI mahAvIra svAmI catumukhI dRSTigocara hone lage the"- isa tathya meM pratimA kA siddhAnta samAyA huaA hai, kyA prAcArya isa satya ko svIkAra kareMge ? aura prastuta meM prAcArya svayaM kaha rahe haiM ki-"isa prakAra ke aneka gahana tathya haiM, jinake sambandha meM gahana zodha kI AvazyakatA hai," svayaM AcArya dvArA likhita isa bAta para se mAlavaNiyAjI kA kathana "naye tathyoM kI saMbhAvanA aba kama hI hai" sarvathA apramANika aura jhUTha hI siddha hotA hai / sAtha hI sAtha mukhya saMpAdaka zrI gajasiMhajI dvArA kathita "ghora parizramI" prAcArya svayaM kyoM ukta viSayoM meM gahana zodha nahIM karate haiM ? prAcArya hastImalajI ne "saMbhava hai" aisA likhakara prAcIna jainAcAryoM ke kathana ko apramANika karate hue paurANika gapaur3oM ko bhI mAnyatA dI hai evaM jinamandira aura jinapratimA Adi ke viSaya meM aitihAsika zilAlekhoM Adi avazeSa vizeSoM ke satya hote hue bhI prAcArya ne apane itihAsa meM galata evaM kalpita jo bAteM likhI haiM, ina bAtoM kA mAlavaNiyAjI ko agara thor3A sA bhI patA hotA to prAcArya dvArA likhita apramANika itihAsa kI prazaMsA karane kA sAhasa ve nahIM karate / isa tathya ko mAlavaNiyAjI sarvathA bhUla hI gaye haiM ki koI bhI sthAnakapaMthI cAhe vaha AcArya padArUr3ha kyoM na ho, jaina dharma viSayaka satya aura prAmANika itihAsa likha hI nahIM sakatA, kyoMki jainadharma ke itihAsa ke mUla meM jinamaMdira aura jinapratimA kA eka anUThA hI sthAna hai, jina se sthAnaka paMthiyoM ko duzmanI hai / ___ aMgreja vidvAna DA0 harmana jaikobI ke viSaya meM prAcArya hastImalajI nimna bAta likhate haiM, isase * naye tathyoM kI saMbhAvanA aba

Page #169
[ 127 ] kama hI hai"-aisA.mAlavaNiyAjI kA likhanA kitanA prAtmavaMcaka evaM bhrAmaka hai, isa bAta kI puSTi apane pApa ho jAtI hai| aMgreja vidvAna DA. harmana jaikobI ke jainadharma viSayaka kathanoM ke viSaya meM khaMDa 1, pR0 768 para prAcArya likhate haiM ki Xxx DA0 jaikobI kI dhAraNA ke bAda 31 varSa ke sudIrgha kAla meM itihAsa ne bahuta kucha naI upalibdhayAM kI haiM, isalie bhI DA0 jaikobI ke kathana ko antima rUpa se mAna lenA yathArtha nahIM hai|xxx __ mImAMsA-isI prakAra hamArA bhI yahI kahanA hai ki "naye tathyoM kI saMbhAvanA aba kama hI rahI hai"-aisA paMDita zrI mAlavaNiyAjI kA likhanA anucita evaM tathyahIna hone ke kAraNa avizvasanIya hI hai / jinapUjanasatkArayoH karaNalAlasaH khalvAdyo dezavirati pariNAmaH / arthAt-dezavirati ( zrAvaka ) dharma kA Adya pariNAma zrI jinezvara bhagavAna kI pUjA aura satkAra karane kI lAlasA hai| yAnI jise zrI jinezvara bhagavAna kI pUjA aura satkAra karane kI lAlasA nahIM hai, use paMcama guNasthAnaka svarUpa dezavirati-zrAvakapana kA prAdya pariNAma bhI prApta nahIM hai| -1444 graMtha ke racayitA zrI haribhadrasUrijI mahArAja

Page #170
[ prakaraNa-28] rAjA sampati ke sAtha anyAya sthAnakapaMthI saMpradAya ke karNadhAra mAne jAne vAle prAcArya ne apane itihAsa meM jinamandira evaM jinapratimAdi viSayoM para tor3amaror3a kI prakriyA pracura mAtrA meM kI hai / Azcarya to isa bAta kA hai, prAcArya ne nAmadhArI samiti dvArA jIcAhA itihAsa banAyA hai, jisako jainadharma kA itihAsa kahanA jainadharma kI majAka ur3Ane ke samAna hai| prAcArya kA itihAsa bhrAmaka evaM kapota kalpita tattvoM se paripUrNa hai, vaha unakI garimA ke anurUpa nahIM hai / khaMDa-2, pR0 633 para prAcArya likhate haiM ki xxx AryavRddha deva ke pazcAt Arya pradyotanasUri gaNAcArya hue / paTAvaliyoM meM isa prakAra kA ullekha upalabdha hai ki ajamera aura svarNagiri meM Apane pratiSThA karavAyI thI / para svargIya muni kAntisAgarajI ke anusAra itihAsa ke prakAzana meM isa prakAra ke ullekhoM kI saccAI saMdigdha mAnI ___ mImAMsA-ajamera aura svarNa giri meM prAcArya zrI pradyotanasUrijI ne kisakI pratiSThA karavAyI thI? jinamUrti pratiSThA ke isa satya ko to prAcArya ne chipA hI liyA / kalpasUtra aura naMdIsUtra kI prAcIna paTaTAvaliyoM ke prAmANika ora vizvasanIya pramANa ko chor3akara itihAsakAra (! ) AcArya ne apanA ullU sIdhA karane ke liye svargIya

Page #171
HEREgam zve. jaina tIrtha zrI kSatriyakuNDa-lachavADa (bihAra) ati prAcIna zramaNa bhagavAna zrI mahAvIra svAmI kI zailezIkaraNa avasthA meM bhavya jina pratimA (pAla kAlIna)

Page #172
_

Page #173
[ 126 ] muni kAntisAgarajI ke vacanoM kA kalpita sahArA liyA hai| prAcArya hastImalajI ne yaha to likhA hI nahIM hai ki zrI kAntisAgarajI kaba hue ? aura ve kaunase prAmANika itihAsakAra the ? kaunase grantha ke kisa pRSTha para unhoMne aisA likhA hai ki-"itihAsa ke prakAzana meM isa prakAra ke ullekhoM kI saccAI saMdigdha mAnI gaI hai|" isa prakAra ke yAnI kauna se prakAra ke ? zrI kAntisAgarajI ke isa viSaya meM kaunasI nyAyasaMgata yukti dI hai ? ina saba praznoM kA satyapratijJa prAcArya ko pramANika uttara denA cAhie aura svargIya kAntisAgarajI ne kyA aisA likhA hai ki-"ajamera aura svarNagiri meM pradyotanasUri ne pratiSThA nahIM karavAyI hai ?" isakA bhI uttara prAcArya deN| bAta to yaha hai ki naMdIsUtra aura kalpasUtra kI prAmANika evaM prAcIna paTTAvaliyoM kA tathyapUrNa sahArA lenA chor3akara svargIya kAntisAgarajI ke nAma se pratAtvika, UTapaTAMga aura idhara-udhara ko kiMvadantI svarUpa tathyahIna bAta kA sahArA prAcArya ne kyoM liyA? ina saba bAtoM se prAcArya kI svecchAcAritA siddha hotI hai, ataH hamArA yahI kahanA hai ki prAcArya hastImalajI dvArA racita itihAsa saccAI se sarvathA rahita hI hai / pAzcarya to taba hotA hai ki satya tathya ko tor3a-maror3a kara viparIta rUpa se likhane vAle khaMDa-1 ( purAnI prAvRtti ) pR0 70 para itihAsajJoM ko hitazikSA dete haiM ki vastusthiti ke antaHstala taka pahu~cakara satya kA anveSaka bananA cAhie / yathA 80 kheda hai ki hama apanI dRSTi se kisI bhI viSaya ke antaHstala taka nahIM pahu~cate aura purAnI lakIra ke hI phakIra bane ____mImAMsA-pratimApUjA aura jinamandira Adi jainadharma ke viSayoM ke antaHstala taka prAcArya prAdi svayaM kyoM nahIM pahu~cate ? ve svayaM

Page #174
[ 130 ] kyoM satya kA pakSa chor3akara asatya aura jhUTha kA sahArA lekara purAnI lakIra ke hI phakIra bana baiThe haiM ? satya ke pakSadhara banane meM unako kauna bAdhA de rahA hai ? purAnI lakIra ke phakIra banakara hI prAcArya ne eka viSelA sUtra pracAra karavAyA hai, yathA guru hastI ke do pharamAna / sAmAyika svAdhyAya mahAna / / yadyapi dekhane meM yaha sUtra nirdoSa lage kintu isake pIche ekAntavAda samAyA huA hai ataH unakA yaha sUtra galata hai| kyA sAmAyika aura svAdhyAya hI mahAna haiM ? kyA tapa, tyAga, jJAna-dhyAna, brahmacarya, prabhubhakti, gurusevA, ahiMsA Adi dharmakArya mahAna nahIM haiM ? saca to yaha hai ki pharamAna karane vAle guru hastImalajI hai hI kauna ? kintu unako pUchane vAlA bhI kauna hai ? pUrvajanma ke dIkSAdAtA upakArI guru prArya zrI suhasti mahArAja ko dekhakara rAjA saMprati ko pUrvajanma kA smRtijJAna ho gayA thaa| "pUrvajanma meM guru ne dIkSA dekara upakAra kiyA thA, isake kAraNa maiMne isa janma meM rAjaRddhi pAyI hai" aisA socakara upakArI guru ke upakAra ke badale meM guru kI preraNA se rAjA saMprati ne savAlAkha jina mandira aura savA karor3a jinapratimA banavAyI thiiN| isa viSaya meM "jina pratimA maMDana" nAmaka suprasiddha stavana meM nyAyavizArada zrImad yazovijayajI upAdhyAya likhate haiM ki vIra paMchI base nevu varase, saMprati rAya sujANa / savA lAkha prasAda karAvyA, savA kor3I biMba sthApyA,

Page #175
[ 131 ] ho kumati kyoM pratimA utthApI ? ye jina vacama se sthApI / jainAgama ko pramANa karake Arya zrI suhasti mahArAja ne saMprati rAjA ko jaina saMskRti ke pracAra prasAra hetu jinamaMdira evaM jinapratimA banavAne kI preraNA dI thI, isa satya kI "tapAgaccha paTTAvalI" nAmaka prAcIna grantha bhI puSTi karatA hai / isa grantha ke AdhAra para svayaM prAcArya hastImalajI bhI khaMDa 2, pR0 456 para likhate haiM ki 444 samprati ke viSaya meM katipaya jaina granthoM meM isa prakAra kA ullekha milatA hai ki usane bhArata ke Arya evaM anArya pradezoM meM itane jaina maMdiroM kA nirmANa karavAyA thA ki ve sAre pradeza jinamandiroM se suzobhita ho gye| [ tapAgaccha paTTAvalI ] xxx mImAMsA-'katipaya' zabda se prAcArya kA kyA tAtparya hai yaha aspaSTa hI hai / sthAnakapaMtha ke pAdyapraNetA jaina gRhasthI lokAzAha ne dIkSA lI thI (?) aisA kahIM se alpavirAma sA sahArA milane para pUrNavirAma taka likhane ke kalAkAra prAcArya hastImalajI katipaya granthoM kA prAmANika sahArA hone para bhI jinapratimA jaise aitihAsika satya tathya ko kyoM nahIM mAnate haiM ? vRtti, cariNa, bhASya aura TIkAdi zAstra bhI isa tathya se sahamata haiM, phira bhI prAcArya apramANika vartana kyoM karate haiM ? kyoMki usI pRSTha para prAcArya svayaM likhate haiM ki xxx cUNi aura niyuktiyoM meM yaha bhI sUcita kiyA gayA hai ki samprati ne pracuramAtrA meM jinamUtiyoM ko maMdira evaM devazAlAoM meM sthApanA karavA kara jaina saMskRti aura sabhyatA ko sthAna-sthAna para phailAyA thaa|xxx

Page #176
[ 132 ] mImAMsA- ukta kathanAnusAra vRtti, cUNi, niyukti Adi zAstroM kA prAmANika sahArA hote hue bhI evaM prAcIna maMdira, mUrti, zilAlekha Adi kA tathya hote hue bhI prAcArya hastImalajI sampradAyavAda ke vyAmoha meM mUlapatha se vicalita hokara mRSAvAda kA prAzraya khaMDa 2, pR0 456 para isa prakAra karate haiM ki xx4 jahA~ taka jaina mUrti-vidhAna evaM upalabdha purAtana avazeSoM kA prazna hai, yaha binA kisI saMkoca ke kahA jA sakatA hai ki rAjA samprati dvArA nirmita maMdira yA mUrtiyA~ bhAratavarSa ke kisI bhI bhAga meM Ajataka upalabdha nahIM ho pAI haiN| 8xx mImAMsA-acArya padArUr3ha vyakti kA yaha eka saphade jhUTha hai / mUrti meM mUrtimAna ke dazarna karane ke jJAna se jo anabhijJa haiM evaM jo maMdira meM jAnA pApa samajhate haiM aura apane anuyAyiyoM ko mandira meM nahIM jAne kI saugandha dilAte haiM, unheM samprati rAjA dvArA banavAyI gayI pratimA dekhI hI kyA hogI ? agara prAcArya niSpakSa hokara khoja karate to jayapura, Amera, jaisalamera, pAlI Adi meM hI samprati kAlIna mUrtiyoM ke unheM darzana ho jaate| "binA saMkoca kahA jA sakatA hai ki saMprati nirmita mUrtiyA~ kahIM bhI upalabdha nahIM haiM"-binA pramANa aisA likhane kI prAcArya hastImalajI jaba dhRSTatA aura beImAnI hI karate haiM taba to unako yaha avazya khoja nikAlanA cAhie ki samprati dvArA nirmita jinapratimA ke rUpa meM jo pratimAeM hajAroM varSoM se prasiddhi pAI huI Aja vidhamAna haiM, ve pratimAeM kisake dvArA nirmita haiM ? prAcArya agara yaha kaheM ki hama aisI khoja karane ko bekAra nahIM baiThe haiM, taba to ve jhUThe itihAsakAra bana baiThe haiM, yaha siddha hotA hai|

Page #177
[ 133 ] aparaMca aitihAsika tathyoM se saMpratirAjA dvArA nirmita pratimA kA prAmANika satya siddha hote hue bhI "tuSyatu darjana nyAyena" mAna bhI liyA jAe ki rAjA samprati dvArA nirmita mUrtiyAM bhAratavarSa ke kisI bhI bhAga meM Aja taka upalabdha nahIM ho pAI haiM, phira bhI jainAgama, vRtti, niyukti prAdi zAstra kyA jhUThe ho sakate haiM ? dharmAstikAya, ardhAmastikAya Adi zAstra kathita zUkSma tatvoM ko hama dekha-samajha na pAeM isa se kyA zAstroM kI prAmANikatA naSTa ho sakatI hai ? anaMtakAya ke eka zarIra meM anaMtajIvoM kI bAta zAstra karate haiM, to kyA usake viSaya meM bhI pAgama nirapekSa zaMkA kuzaMkA karake pAlU kA bar3A, lahasuna kI caTanI, aura gAjara kA haluvA Adi anantakAya (jamIkanda] ke bhakSaNa ko kyA prAcArya evaM sthAnakapaMthI ucita samajheMge? phira to pAgama kathita eka bhI bAta zraddhA karane yogya nahIM rhegii| jinapratimA ke viSaya meM paTTAvaliyAM Adi zAstroM ke uparAMta dhvaMsAvazeSoM kA aitihAsika satya tathya hote hue bhI prAcArya aMdhere meM hI rahanA pasanda karate haiM / ve khaMDa 2, pR0 456 para likhate haiM ki xxx zveta pASANa kI kohanI ke samIpa gAMTha ke AkAra ke cinhavAlI pratimAe~ jaina samAja meM prasiddha rahI haiM aura una sabhI kA sambandha rAjA saMprati se sthApita kiyA jAtA hai| aisI pratimAoM ke aneka sthAnoM para pratiSThApita hone kA ullekha kiyA gayA hai| merI vinamra sammati ke anusAra ye zveta pASANa kI pratimAeM samprati athavA mauryakAla kI to kyA taduttaravartI kAla kI bhI nahIM kahI jA sktii|xxx ___ mImAMsA- zvetapASANa kI kohanI ke samIpa gAMTha ke prAkAra ke cinhavAlI pratimAeM "jaina samAja" meM prasiddha rahI haiM / " aisA prAcArya likhate haiM to jainasamAja se unheM yahA~ kyA abhipreta hai ? kyoMki

Page #178
[ 134 ] zvetAmbara aura digambara donoM jaina samAja pratimA aura pratimApUjA meM vizvAsa karate haiM aura sthAnakapaMthI nahIM karate haiM, aisI dazA meM prAcArya hastImalajI ke "jaina samAja" aisA kathanAnusAra kyA sthAnakapaMthI samAja svataH hI "jainAbhAsa" siddha nahIM ho jAtA hai ? "aisI pratimA aneka sthAnoM para pratiSThApita kI gayI haiM" isa prakAra kA zAstrokta kathana hote hue bhI dhRSTatA kA avalaMbana lekara likhanA ki-"merI vinamra sammati ke anusAra ye zveta pASANa kI pratimAeM samprati athavA mauryakAlina to kyA taduttaravartI kAla kI bhI nahIM kahI jA sktii|" kintu prAcArya kA aisA likhanA sarvathA kapaTapUrNa hai, kyoMki phira ye pratimAeM kaunase kAla kI haiM yaha to unako batAnA hI cAhie evaM prAcArya kI namra sammati pramANabhUta AdhAra para hai yA nirAdhAra ? zAstra sApekSa hai yA nirapekSa ? AgamAnusAra hI hai yA prAgama viparIta ? tattvAnusArI hai yA tattvavinAzaka ? ye prazna vicAraNIya haiM / jaise "vyAghrI apane bacce ko saumya aura akrUra mAnatI hai" isI prakAra prAcArya kI sammati agara kalpita mAtra hai to akiMcitkara hai / zAstra meM aisI sammati ko mithyAbhimAna kahA hai| aisI apramANika mithyA sammati itihAsa kI saccAI meM mUlyahIna mAnI gaI hai, kyoMki prAmANikatA kI kasauTI para aisI manamAnI sammati jhUThI hI ThaharatI hai| jinapratimA ke viSaya meM prAcArya hastImalajI kA dveSa kitanA hai, isa viSaya meM rAjA samprati kA eka hI dRSTAMta bahuta kucha prakAza DAlatA hai|

Page #179
[ prakaraNa-26] prati sukumAla aura jinamaMdira eka bAra pUjya Arya zrI suhasti mahArAja apane ziSya samudAya sahita azvazAlA meM Thahare / svAdhyAya ke avasara para sAdhuoM ke muMha se devaloka sthita nalinI gulma vimAna kA varNana sunakara avaMti sukumAla ko pUrvajanma kA jAti smaraNa jJAna ho gyaa| usane devaloka ke nalinI gulma vimAna se yahA~ manuSya janma liyA thA, aisA jAnakara usane prAcArya prArya suhastijI ke pAsa cAritra liyA aura rAtri meM zmazAna meM dhyAnastha rhaa| vahAM lomar3I aura isake baccoM ne upasargakara zrI avaMtisukumAla muni ko maraNAnta kaSTa diyaa| samabhAva maura samAdhi se maraNa ke bAda punaH ve usI nalinI gulma vimAna meM utpanna hue| guru mahArAja kA upadeza sunakara mAtA aura battIsa patniyoM ne apanA zoka dUra kiyA aura eka sagarbhA strI ko chor3akara sabhI ne vairAgya pUrvaka cAritra grahaNa kiyaa| samaya pAkara sagarbhA strI ko putra janma huA jisakA nAma mahAkAla thaa| jisane bar3e hokara apane sAMsArika pitA kI smRti meM avaMti sukumAla muni ke agnisaMskAra sthAna para "avaMti pArzvanAtha" kA maMdira bnvaayaa| jo bAda meM "mahAkAla maMdira" ke nAma se mahAna tIrtha ke rUpa meM prasiddha huaa| pUjya hemacandrAcArya mahArAja dvArA racita "triSaSThi zalAkA puruSa" nAmaka itihAsa meM yaha bhI sUcita kiyA hai ki

Page #180
[ 136 ] bhagavAna zrI mahAvIra svAmI ke nirvANa se 250 varSa bAda prAcArya zrI Arya suhasti mahArAja dvArA pratiSThita aura zrI avaMtisukumAla muni kI smRti meM unake putra dvArA nirmita zrI pArzvanAtha prabhu kI pratimA "zrI avaMti pArzvanAtha" ke nAma se Aja bhI ujjaina meM birAjita haiN| kAlakrama se anya dharmiyoM dvArA zivaliMga sthApita kara isa pratimA ko Dhaka diyA thA / jisako vikrama saMvat pravartaka rAjA vikramAditya ke samaya meM prabhAvaka prAcArya zrI siddhasena divAkara sUrijI ne kalyANa maMdira stotra kI racanA dvArA punaH pragaTa kiyA thaa| unake dvArA racita "kalyANa maMdira stotra" Aja bhI jaina samAja meM atyanta prasiddha hai, jisa stotra ke pIche "avaMti pArzvanAtha" kI pratimA kA rahasya chIpA huA hai| __ zrI avaMti sukumAla ke caritra meM "triSaSThi zalAkA puruSa caritra" kA ullekha pUrvaka khaMDa 2, pR0 462 para prAcArya hastImalajI likhate haiM ki xxx AcArya hemacandra dvArA pariziSTa parva meM kiye gaye ullekha ke anusAra avaMti sukumAla ke putra ne apane pitA kI smRti meM unake maraNa sthala para eka vizAla devakula kA nirmANa karavAyA jo Age calakara mahAkAla ke nAma se vikhyAta huaa| [pariziSTa parva, sarga-11] Xxx mImAMsA-prAcIna, jJAnavanta, dhuraMdhara vidvAn pUjpapAd kalikAla sarvajJa zrI hemacandrAcArya mahArAja sAhaba ko sirpha prAcArya hemacandra itanA abahumAna sUcaka zabda prayoga prAcArya ne kiyA hai jisakA hameM kheda hai| aparaMca "devakula" aisA kliSTa aura saMdigdha prayoga

Page #181
[ 137 ] prAcArya dvArA anAvazyaka kiyA gayA hai, prAmANikatA pUrvaka jinamandira aisA likha dete to kyA hotA? yahAM jina mandira ke viSaya meM "triSaSThi zalAkA puruSa caritra" ke racayitA prAcArya zrI hemacandra sUri mahArAja kA nAma dekara prAcArya ne svayaM ko mandira ke mAmale meM bhailipta rakhanA cAhA hai, cUki sthAnakapaMthI bhaktagaNa unase cauMka na utthe| kintu maMdira kI bAta pUjyapAda hemacandrAcArya mahArAja ke nAma para likhakara bhI prAcArya baca nahIM sakate, satya to svIkAranA hI cAhie, kyoMki "triSaSThi zalAkA puruSa caritra" ko svayaM unhoMne hI prAmANika graMtha batAyA hai / yathA xxx yaha hai AcArya zrI hemacandrasUri dvArA viracita triSaSThi zalAkA puruSa caritra kA ullekha jo pichalI ATha zatAbdiyoM se bhI adhika samaya se lokapriya rahA hai| [ khaMDa 2, pR0 56 ] 800 mImAMsA-ukta bAtoM se jina pratimA aura jina maMdira kI prAmANikatA siddha hote hue bhI prAcArya aMdhakAra meM rahanA kyoM pasanda karate haiM ? yaha unakI prAcArya pada kI garimA ke bilakula pratikUla hai| pichale cAra pAMca sau varSoM meM jitanA bhI mUrti kA virodha huA hai, usameM isa tathya kI ora dhyAna nahIM diyA gayA ki mUrti-mUrtimAna kA smAraka hai, na ki jisa dhAtu kI banI hai uskaa| svayaM ke phoTo bar3e cAva se khicavAne vAle yadi ve apane andara jhA~kakara eka bAra dekheM to saba kucha spaSTa ho jaaegaa| -DA0 zrI hukamacanda bhArilla

Page #182
[prakaraNa-30 ] pUjya zrI devaddhiMgaNi kSamAzramaNa bhagavAna zrI mahAvIra svAmI ke nirvANa ke pazcAta karIba 980 varSa bAda vallabhIpura meM jina mahApuruSa ne zramaNoM ko ikaTThA karake Agama vAcanA karavAyI thI aura jainAgamoM ko tAlapatroM para likhavAkara surakSita karavAyA evaM hamAre taka pahuMcAyA una mahopakArI zrI devaddhigariNa kSamAzramaNa kA jIvana kavana isa prakAra hai| devaddhigaNi pUrvajanma meM hariNagameSI deva the| prAkAzagAminI vidyAdhAraka cAraNamuni se usane aisI bAta jAnI ki-"vaha durlabha bodhi hai kintu ve bhagavAna zrI mahAvIra deva ke zAsana kI mahAsevA jainAgamoM ko pustakArUr3ha karavAkara kreNge|" apane bhAvi jIvana kA vRttAnta sunakara hariNagameSI deva ne aisI vyavasthA kI ki usakI mauta ke bAda, usake sthAna para Ane vAlA uttaravartI (anya ) hariNagameSI deva isako bodhilAbha kI prApti karAve / navotpanna hariNagameSI deva ne devaddhi ko bodhilAbha kI prApti hetu anekoM prayAsa kiye, kintu vaha asaphala rhaa| zikAra khelane kA vyasanI devaddhi eka bAra zikAra khelate samaya khaDDe meM gira gayA / deva ne ise isa pratijJA se bacAyA ki vaha cAritra le| bAda meM devaddhi ne bodhilAbha pUrvaka cAritra liyA / Apake sundara cAritra ke pAlana se prabhAvita hokara kapardiyakSa, cakrezvarI devI tathA gomukha yakSa pApako pratyakSa the aura ApakI sevA hetu sadA tatpara rahate the| Apane

Page #183
[ 136 ] vallabhIpura meM zramaNa saMgha ko ikaTThA karavAkara prAgamika vAcanA karavAyI thI aura jainAgamoM evaM prAgametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya ko cira sthAyI banAkara apAra upakAra kiyA thaa| khaMDa 2, pR0 676 para AcArya hastImalajI likhate haiM ki XXXApa pUrva janma meM hariNagameSI deva the| navotpanna hariNegameSI deva devaddhi ko sanmArga para lAne hetu vibhinna upAyoM se samajhAne kA prayAsa karane lgaa|xxx xxx usa samaya sahasA devaddhi ke kAnoM meM ye zabda par3e"aba bhI samajha jAo, anyathA terI mRtyu tere sanmukha khar3I hai|" bhaya vihvala devaddhi ne gir3agir3Akara kahA-"jaise bhI ho sake mujhe bacAo, tuma jaisA kahoge vahI maiM karane ke liye taiyAra huuN|xxx 888 deva ne tatkAla use uThAkara AcArya lohitya sUri ke pAsa pahu~cA diyA aura devaddhi bhI AcArya lohitya kA upadeza sunakara unake pAsa zramaNa dharma meM dIkSita ho gye|xxx 444bAda meM vIra nirvANa pazcAt 980 sAla bAda Apane ballabhIpura meM Agama vAcanA karake zAstra pustakArUDha karavAke varNanAtIta upakAra kiyaa| 8xx mImAMsA-yahAM taka pUjya devaddhi gariNa ke viSaya meM sahI sahI likhane vAle prAcArya ne jaise hI zAsana rakSaka deva-deviyA~ evaM yakSa Adi kI bAta AyI ki vahAM unhoMne jhUTha kA sahArA le liyaa| khaMDa 2, 10 677 para prAcArya likhate haiM ki 888 zraddhAluoM dvArA paramparA se yaha mAnyatA abhivyakta vaDA Veer in kI jA rahI hai ki Apake tapa-saMyama kI viziSTa sAdhanA evaM ArAdhanA se

Page #184
[ 140 ] kapadiyakSa, cakrezvarI devI tathA gomukha yakSa ApakI sevA meM upasthita rahate the| 888 mImAMsA-mApane dila meM rahA huA pApa prAcArya ne "zraddhAluoM dvArA paramparA se yaha mAnyatA abhivyakta kI jA rahI hai"ina zabdoM meM prakAzita kiyA hai, kyoMki yahAM zraddhAlu aura paramparA jaise ghaTiyA zabdoM kI AvazyakatA hI kyA thI ? prAcArya ne yahAM zraddhAluoM' zabda kA tAtparyArtha nahIM likhA hai kintu prAcArya kA tAtparya aise logoM se ho sakatA hai jo ki kiMvadantI yA aMdhazraddhA meM vizvAsa rakhate hoM, parantu "zraddhAluoM" aisA zabda likhanA anucita isaliye hai ki to kyA prAcArya svayaM 'prazraddhAlu' haiM ? tathA 'paramparA se' aisA likhane ke pIche prAcArya kI jaghanya bhAvanA yaha rahI hogI ki paramparA se yAnI rUr3hi se yAnI gatAnugatikatA se zraddhAlubhakta aisI bhAvanA vyakta karate haiM yAnI svayaM prAcArya kA isameM avizvAsa hai| prAgametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya meM kahA hai sAtha sAtha prAcArya ne khaMDa 2, pR0 676 para likhA hai, kintu yahAM paramparA se' evaM 'zraddhAlabhakta' ye do zabda likhanA unakA anucita hI hai| pUjya devaddhi gaNi kI sevA meM kapardiyakSa, cakrezvarI devI tathA gaumukhayakSa rahate the, to isa bAta meM prAcArya ko kyA nArAjI hai ? "devA vi taM namasaMti" isa prAgama vacanAnusAra saMyamI puruSoM ko deva namaskAra karate haiM yaha satya tathya hote hue bhI 'paramparA se" "zraddhAlu" Adi zabdoM ke likhane kI AvazyakatA hI kyA hai ? prAgamika tathya hote hue bhI deva-deviyoM ke tathya kA prAcArya apalApa kyoM karate haiM ?

Page #185
[ 141 ] itane mahAna upakAraka mAgama-saMrakSaka zrI devaddhigaNi mahArAja ke viSaya meM prAcArya hastImalajI prazaMsA ke do zabda to na likha sake kintu upakAra kA badalA 'paramparA' aura 'zraddhAlu' jaise ghaTiyA zabda likhakara apakAra se cukAyA hai, jisakA hameM kheda hai / jisake dila meM sUtrAbhyAsa dvArA sadbodha kA prAdurbhAva hotA hai, usake dila meM hI pAgama sUtra kI tAttvika sparzanA hotI hai| -nyAyavizArada pUjya yazovijayajI upAdhyAyajI

Page #186
[prakaraNa-3] mathurA ke kaMkAlI TIle kI khudAI itihAsa kI satyatA ke liye hastalikhita prAcIna graMtha kI taraha prAcIna zilAlekha, sikke, mUrtiyA~, tAmrapatra, dhvaMsAvazeSa evaM paTTe Adi ko bhI prAmANika sAmagrI mAnA gayA hai / ___jainadharma kI prAcInatA siddha karane ke liye evaM prAgama zAstroM kI saccAI ko siddha karane vAlI jamIna meM se nikAlI huI prAcIna jina pratimA aura pratimA kI caukiyoM para likhe hue lekha prAmANika purAvA (sabUda) hai / takSazilA ke pAsa 'mohana-jo-daro' meM prAcIna jina pratimA nikalI hai / ur3IsA meM udayagiri tathA khaMDagiri parvata para khudAI karane se jinamUrtiyAM Adi milI haiN| aise to saiMkar3oM udAharaNa haiM, jahA~ jamIna meM se prAcIna jina pratimA Adi milI hoN| ina sabase jina maMdira, jina pratimA evaM pratimA pUjA prAcIna kAla meM bhI thI isa tathya para vizad prakAza par3atA hai| prAgamazAstra aura prAgametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya vRtti, caNi, bhASya aura TIkAdi bhI jina maMdira, jina pratimA evaM jina pUjA ke tathyoM ke samarthaka rahe haiN| aisI dazA meM agara sthAnakapaMthI svayaM ko prAmANika karate haiM to unheM ukta satya ko svIkAra karanA hI caahie| mathurA ke kaMkAlI nAmaka eka prAcIna TIle kI khudAI bhArata sarakAra dvArA karane para saiMkar3oM prAcIna mUrtiyA~, sikke, caraNa pAdukAeM,

Page #187
[ 143 ] pabAsana evaM eka stUpa Adi mile haiM, unameM karIba 110 kI saMkhyA meM prAcIna zilAlekha aura aneka mUrtiyAM evaM zrI supArzvanAtha kA prAcIna stUpa jainoM se sambandhita haiM aisA itihAsajJoM kA nizcayAtmaka rUpa se kahanA hai / ina mUrtiyoM ke zilAlekhoM meM mauryakAla, guptakAla aura kuzAgavaMzI rAjAoM kA samaya 2000 yA 2200 varSa pUrva kA kahA jA sakatA hai / ataH ina avazeSoM ko bhI itanA hI prAcIna kahanA cAhie / hamAre jaina pUrvAcAryoM ne upakAra karake ina rAjAmoM ko jainadharma premI banAyA thA aura jaina zAsanonnati hetu inase jaina maMdira banavAkara zrI arihaMta, siddha prAdi kI pratimAeM pratiSThita karavAyI thiiN| ina saba tathyoM se itanA to avazya spaSTa hotA hI hai ki naya dRSTi kA abhyAsI eka taTastha vyakti kabhI bhI jinapratimAdi viSayoM kA virodha yA anAdara nahIM kara sakatA hai| "jaina dharma kA maulika itihAsa" khaMDa 2, TippaNI pR0 32 para prAcArya hastImalajI likhate haiM ki xxx mathurA ke kaMkAlI Tole kI khudAI kA kArya sarva prathama I0 san 1871 meM janarala kaniMghama ke tattvAvadhAna meM, dUsarI bAra san 1888 se 1891 meM DA0 phyUrara ke tattvAvadhAna meM tathA tIsarI bAra paM0 rAdhAkRSNa ke tattvAvadhAna meM karavAyA gyaa| ina tInoM khudAIyoM meM jaina itihAsa kI dRSTi se bar3I mahattvapUrNa vipula sAmagrI upalabdha huii| vaha sAmagrI Aja se 1891 se lekara 1798 varSa taka kI prAcIna evaM prAmANika hone ke kAraNa bar3I vizvasanIya hai| Xxx - mImAMsA-ye sAmagrI "itihAsa kI dRSTi se bar3I mahatvapUrNa hai" aisA prAcArya kA likhanA dhokhA mAtra hI hai / kyoMki ina khudAI meM se nikale jinapratimAdi prAcIna avazeSa sirpha itihAsa kI dRSTi se hI mahatvapUrNa nahIM hai, kintu prAtmA meM bhare par3e mithyAtva aMdhakAra ko dUra

Page #188
[ 144 ] karane aura satya kA prakAza karane kI dRSTi se bhI bar3I mahatvapUrNa hai, isa tathya ko prAcArya kyoM bhUla jAte haiM ? tathA "yaha sAmagrI prAcIna evaM prAmANika hone ke kAraNa bar3I vizvasanIya hai|" aisA likhane meM bhI ve kapaTa hI kara rahe haiM kyoMki Agama evaM prAgametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya vRtti, cUrNi, bhASya evaM TIkAdi grantha jinapratimApUjA kI puSTi karate haiM aura dhvaMsAvazeSa se isa tathya kI satyatA meM cAra cAMda laga gaye haiM, phira bhI sthAnakapaMthI aura prAcArya hastImalajI isa tathya kI ora A~kheM banda kara baiThe hue haiM satya kahA hai ki ullU ko prakAza bhI burA lagatA hai / jaina itihAsa kI satyatA kA sundaratama varNana to eka abhavya vyakti bhI kara sakatA hai kintu saccI zraddhA pUrvaka apane dila meM satya kI sthApanA nahIM karane ke kAraNa unakI aisI satya prarUpaNA kI kImata phaTI kaur3I kI bhI nahIM raha jAtI hai, kyA isa tathya se prAcArya anabhijJa nahIM haiM ? itihAsa lekhana dvArA satya gaveSaNA karake jinapratimA aura jinamaMdirAdi kA satya tathya yadi AcArya apane dila meM zraddhA aura bhakti pUrvaka sthApana nahIM kareMge to unakA itihAsa kA lekhana unake liye AtmavaMcanA hI hogA, kyoMki prazraddhA pUrvaka kI gaI saba sat ceSTAe~ bhI jainAgamoM meM saMsAra vardhaka hI mAnI gaI haiN| kaMkAlI TIle meM se nikale hue prAcIna avazeSoM se prAcArya hastImalajI ne kalpasUtra evaM nandIsUtra kI sthavirAvaliyoM ko prAmANika aura vizvasanIya siddha kiyA hai, kintu mUrtimAnyatA ke viSaya meM eka zabda bhI likhanA unheM abhiSTa nahIM hai, jisakA hameM kheda hai / eka prAcArya padArUr3ha itihAsakAra prAmANikatA aura taTasthatA kI pratijJA karane para bhI itanI dhRSTatA kare kyA yaha kheda kI bAta nahIM hai ? khaMDa 2, pR0 32 para TippaNI noMdha meM prAcArya kI kapaTa vacana racanA isa prakAra hai

Page #189
Proeante vizvavaMdya bhagavAna zrI mahAvIra svAmI kaMkAla TolA, mathurA se prApta IsA kI 1-2 zatAbdI vartamAna meM mathurA myUjiyama meM hai|

Page #190
_

Page #191
[ 145 ] xxx mathurA ke kaMkAlI Tole kI khudAI se nikale I0 san 83 se 176 taka ke Ayoga paTToM, dhvajastambhoM, toraNoM, hariNagameSI deva kI mUrti, sarasvatI kI mUrti, sarvatobhadra pratimAoM, pratimA paTToM evaM "mUrtiyoM kI caukiyoM" para ukita zilAlekhoM se isa tathya kI puSTi hotI hai ki vastutaH ye donoM sthavirAvaliyAM ati prAcIna hI nahIM, prAmANika bhI haiN| 80x mImAMsA-prAcArya kA hariNegameSI deva kI mUrti, sarasvatI ko mUrti aisA likhane ke bAda "mUrtiyoM kI caukiyoM" aisA likhanA mAyAcAra hI hai, kyoMki parizeSa nyAya se "mUrtiyoM kI caukiyoM" kA artha to 'tIrthakara bhagavAna kI mUrtiyoM kI caukiyoM" hI hotA hai, jo chalakapaTa pUrvaka na likhakara prAcArya ne pakSapAtapUrNa vartana kiyA hai| phira khaMDa 2, pR0 36 para TippaNI noMdha meM 4 hamArI ceSTA pakSapAta vihIna evaM kevala yaha rahI hai ki vastusthiti prakAza meM lAyI jAra XXX mImAMsA-aisA likhanA dhokhebAjI hI hai| kyoMki hariNaigameSI deva kI mUrti, sarasvatI kI mUrti prAdi likhanA aura tIrthaMkara kI mUrti likhane kA jahA~ avasara prAyA vahAM "tIrthaMkara bhagavAna kI mUrtiyoM kI caukiyA~" aisA na likhakara sirpha "mUrtiyoM kI caukiyA~" aisA likhanA kyA anUThA mithyAcAra nahIM hai ? / __bhagavAna kA garbhApahAra bAlaka vardhamAna dvArA sumeru kampana Adi ke viSaya meM anyoM ko satya vastusthiti samajhAne kA prayAsa prAcArya ne kiyA hai, aisA prayAsa jina pratimA ke viSaya meM kyoM nahIM kiyA ? zrI mahAvIra svAmI ke viSaya meM 'mAMsabhakSaNa' kA bhrama dUra karane hetu prAcArya ne Agama, prAgametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya vRtti, cUrNi, bhASya aura TIkAdi tathA koSa evaM vyAkaraNa dvArA spaSTIkaraNa kiyA hai / vaisA hI prayAsa AgamazAstra, prAgametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya,

Page #192
[ 146 ] prAgamoM para racita vRtti, cUNi, bhASya TokAdi sAhitya evaM vyAkaraNa paura zabdakoSa tathA prAcIna pratimA para uTTa kita zilAlekhoM Adi sAmagrI Adi kA sahArA lekara jinapratimA, jinamaMdira aura jinapUjA Adi viSayoM meM gaveSaNA aura tathya kA anveSaNa karanA atyanta pAvazyaka thA jisa para prAcArya ne pardA hI DAla diyA, isase yaha siddha hotA hai ki prAcArya ko aMdhakAra hI pasanda hai / prAcArya kA jainadharma viSayaka mUrtiyoM kI caukiyoM para ukita lekhoM se zrInandIsUtra aura zrI kalpasUtra kI sthavirAvaliyoM ko pramANita karanA aura svayaM mUrtiyoM ko pramANita nahIM karanA yaha ardhajaratIya nyAya sarvathA anucita hI mAnA jaaegaa| nikkhamaNa nANa nivvANa, jamma bhUmIu vaMdaI jiNANaM // -jisa bhUmi se tIrthakara bhagavAna ne janma liyA ho, dIkSA lI ho, kevalajJAna pAyA ho evaM nirvANa ( mokSa ) prApta kiyA ho, usa pavitra kalyANaka bhUmi kI ( jainiyoM ko ) vaMdanA-sparzanA karanI caahie| -prAgametara jaina sAhitya meM sabase prAcIna grantha zrI upadezamAlA [zloka-236]

Page #193
[prakaraNa-32 ] bhaktAmara praura kalyANamaMdira stotra pUjya siddhasena sUriz2I ne Agamika zAstroM ko prAkRta bhASA meM se vidvadbhogya saMskRta bhASA meM karane ke vicAra mAtra ko guru ke Age vANI dvArA pragaTa karane para guru ne unheM pArAMcita prAyazcita diyA thaa| kyoMki sarvajJa vacanoM para evaM sarvajJoM kI eka bhI kriyA para prazraddhA pragaTa karanA mahA aparAdha hai / sarvajJoM ne prAkRta bhASA meM jo vANI kahI hai vaha pAbAla gopAla ke hita ke liye hI kahI hai, phira bhI usa vANI ko paMDita bhogya saMskRta bhASA meM parivartana karane kA svatantra, jinAjJAnirapekSa vicAra mAtra pragaTa karane para dhuraMdhara vidvAna zrI siddhasenasUri divAkara ko pArAMcita prAyazcita guru ne diyA thaa| isa prAyazcita meM bAraha sAla taka veSa chipAkara rahanA hotA hai aura apane jJAnAdi guNoM se kisI rAjA Adi ko jainadharma meM pratibodha karane para isakI samApti hotI hai| pArAMcita prAyazcita vahana karane ke kAla meM pUjya siddhasenasUrijI ne rAjA vikrama ko pratibodhita kiyA thaa| isa viSaya meM kathAnaka isa prakAra hai| guptaveSa meM pArAMcita prAyazcita vahana karate karate sUrijI eka bAra zivamandira meM Thahare / pujArI ke niSedha karame para bhI prAcArya zrI siddhasenajI zivaliMga ke sAmane paira karake so gye| rAjA vikrama

Page #194
[ 148 ] ko bulAyA gyaa| usa samaya zrI siddhasenasUrijI zivaliMga ke sAmane paira kiye hI bhagavAna kI stuti bolane lage / ve kucha hI zloka bola pAye the ki zivaliMga phaTA aura usameM se adbhuta teja ke sAtha zrI pArzvanAtha bhagavAna kI pratimA pragaTa huI thii| jisase rAjA vikrama bhI pUjya sUrijI kI apAra vidvattA se prabhAvita hokara jainadharmI bana gayA thaa| bhagavAna kI stuti svarUpa isa stotra kA nAma "kalyANa mandira stotra" hai / jo Aja bhI jaina samAja meM suprasiddha hai| pAgama evaM prAgametara prAcIna zAstra likhita bAtoM ko AmUlacUla badalane para bhI ye bAteM aAdhunika ciMtakoM ke mana meM bhAyeMgI yA nahIM yaha vicAraNIya prazna hai, phira bhI AcArya hastImalajI jainAgamoM kI bAtoM ko badalane ke samarthaka rahe haiM, kyoMki khaMDa 2, pR0 38-36 prAkkathana meM ve likhate haiM ki 444 isa prakAra bahuta sI camatkArika rUpa se citrita ghaTanAoM ko bhI isa grantha meM samAviSTa nahIM kiyA gayA hai| madhyayugIna aneka vidvAna granthakAroM ne siddhasena prabhRti katipaya prabhAvaka AcAryoM ke jIvana caritra kA Alekhana karate hue unake jIvana kI kucha aisI camatkAra pUrNa ghaTanAoM kA ullekha kiyA hai, jina para Aja ke yuga ke adhikAMza ciMtaka kisI bhI dazA meM vizvAsa karane ko udyata nahIM hote|xxx __ mImAMsA-prAdhunika ciMtakoM ke pakSadhara banakara prAcArya hastImalajI ne pUrvAcAryoM ko jo ki paMcamahAvrata dhArI aura satya pratijJa the unako jhUThA karane kI bagAvata kI hai aura Adhunika cintakoM kI tuSTikaraNa ke liye sudhAravAdI viSelA dRSTikoNa apanAyA hai, phira bhI khaMDa 2, pR0 26 prAkkathana meM prAcArya likhate haiM ki

Page #195
[ 146 ] xxx yadi pratyeka jina zAsanAnuyAyI meM isa prakAra kI jAgarUkatA utpanna ho jAe to Aja jainAgamoM ke sambandha meM tathAkathita sudhAravAdiyoM dvArA jo viSelA pracAra kiyA jA rahA hai, usake kuprabhAva aura kupravAha ko rokA jA sakatA hai| Xxx mImAMsA hamArA bhI yahI kahanA hai ki tathA kathita sudhAravAdI prAcArya svayaM hI haiM, jinhoMne nAmadhArI samiti racakara, sthAnakapaMthI svamAnyatAnusAra "jainadharma kA maulika itihAsa" likhakara jaina dharma ke itihAsa ke nAma para kAlA kalaMka lagAyA hai aura jaina samAja meM bhrama evaM vighaTana phailAne kA asad kArya kiyA hai / usake kuprabhAva aura kupravAha ko rokane hetu hI gurukRpA se hamane yaha mImAMsA racakara jAgarUkatA dikhAne kA prayatna kiyA hai / jainAgamoM, Agametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya, pUrvAcAryoM ke kathanoM aura jainadharma biSayaka prApta prAcIna zilAlekhoM, mUrtiyoM prAdi dhvaMsAvazeSa para jinako vizvAsa ho una jina zAsanAnuyAyiyoM se hamArA nivedana hai ki ve tathAkathita sudhAravAdiyoM kI pravRtti se satarka rheN| sthAnakapaMtha ke karNadhAra prAcArya hastImalajI ne paTTAvalI prabandha saMgraha. jainadharma kA maulika itihAsa, saiddhAntika praznottarI, jaina prAcArya caritAvalI Adi kitAbeM likhakara svArthavaza yA aura bhI kisI kAraNavaza jaina samAja meM dveSa viSa phailAyA hai| hamane isa viSaya meM yat kiMcit prayAsa kiyA hai, lekina isa viSaya meM zAstramarmajJoM ko adhika prayAsa karanA cAhie / anyathA aise kalpita itihAsa Adi viSaile sAhitya kA pracAra rukanA asaMbhava hI hai| "sudhAravAdI prAdhunika ciMtakoM ko nahIM jace" isakA bahAnA bAjI kara prAcArya kaha rahe haiM ki zrI siddhasena sUrijI Adi kA caritra hamane isa itihAsa meM nahIM diyA hai, kintu yaha sarvathA galata hai, isakA

Page #196
[ 150 ] mukhya kAraNa jina pratimA viroSa hI hai anyathA zrI mAnatugasUrijI ke viSaya meM bhI zrI siddhasenasUrijI ke sadRza hI camatkArika ghaTanA ghaTI hai, jisakA varNana khaMDa 2, pR. 646 para prAcArya svayaM ne apanI ora se hI kiyA hai| yathA Xxx kamaroM ke dvAra svataH hI khula gaye, AcArya mAnatuga ke sabhI baMdhana kaTa gye|xxx maiM unake dvArA nirmita bhaktAmara stotra Aja bhI jaina samAja meM bar3I hI zraddhA-bhakti ke sAtha ghara-ghara meM gAyA jAtA hai| AcArya zrI mAnatuga sUrijI ko 44 kamaroM meM 44 ber3iyoM se jakar3a kara banda karanA aura eka eka zloka ke prabhAva se eka eka ber3I kA TUTanA aura kamare ke dvAra svataH hI khula jAnA kyA isako camatkArika ghaTanA nahIM kaha sakate ? kyA tathAkathita Adhunika ciMtaka isa para vizvAsa kareMge ? prAcArya kA chala kapaTa to dekho ki zrI AdinAtha bhagavAna ke bhaktAmara stotra ke viSaya meM zrI mAnatuMgasUrijI kI camatkAra pUrNa ghaTanA kA apanI hI ora se ullekha karate haiM, jaba ki zrI pArzvanAtha bhagavAna ke "kalyANa maMdira stotra" ke viSaya meM zrI siddhasenasUrijI kI camaskAra pUrNa ghaTanA meM-zivaliMga phaTanA aura pArzvanAtha bhagavAna kI pratimA nikalanA, yaha bAta khaMDa 2, pR0 528 para prAcArya ne katipaya kathAgranthoM ke nAma se likhakara apramANikatA kI hai / yathA 444 rAjA dvArA bArabAra Agraha kiye jAne para siddhasena ne mahAdeva ke sacce svarUpa kI stuti prArambha kii| katipaya kathAgranthoM meM batAyA gayA hai ki siddhasena, stuti ke kucha hI zloka kA uccAraNa kara pAye the ki adbhuta teja ke sAtha vahAM bhagavAna pArzvanAtha kI pratimA pragaTa ho gii|

Page #197
[ 151 ] rAjA vikramAditya acintya Atma zakti ke aneka camatkAroM ko dekhakara siddhasena ke parama bhakta bana gye|xxx mImAMsA-prAcArya eka ora likhate haiM ki acintya prAtmazakti ke camatkAra aise hote haiM, kintu pratimA dveSa ke kAraNa dUsarI ora ve likhate haiM ki Adhunika ciMtaka isa para vizvAsa nahIM karate haiM / lagatA hai mana ke anizcita evaM cala vicalita pariNAma ke kAraNa hI aisI paraspara virodha pUrNa bAteM prAcArya ne likhI haiN| saca hI kahA hai"viveka bhraSTa kA patana anekazaH hotA hai|" pApabhIru eka sAmAnya jana bhUla se bhI jhUTha bolane se kAMpatA hai, magara bhAcArya hokara bhI jAnabUjha kara jhUTha bole to unakI dIkSA nirarthaka hai| -prAgamaitara sabase prAcIna grantha upadezamAlA [ zloka-508 ]

Page #198
[ prakaraNa-33 ] jaina dharma meM mUrtipUjA aura prAcIna zilAlekha jinAgama aura jinapratimA-maMdira ye do hI zreSTha sAdhana jainadharma kI saMskRti ke pracAra prasAra ke AdhAra rahe haiN| ina donoM zreSTha mArgoM se hI pUrvAcAryoM ne jainadharma kI saMskRti ko Ajataka TikAyA hai / bhUmi kI khudAI dvArA mile prAcIna dhvaMsAvazeSa mUrtiyAM aura zilAlekhoM ne jainAgama aura pAgametara prAcIna jaina zAstroM kathita jina mandira aura pratimApUjA ke satya tathya ko cAra cAMda lagA diye haiM / niSpakSa itihAsakAra aura purAtattvavid ina aitihAsika tathyoM se pUrNataH sahamata haiM ki jinamUrtiyAM, pAdukA evaM stUpAdi bhagavAna mahAvIra se bhI bahuta pahile pUje jAte the| __ mathurA ke kaMkAlI TIle meM se mile prAcIna dhvaMsAvazeSa se yaha tathya bhalI bhAMti siddha ho cukA hai ki mahAna samrATa azoka (aparanAma samprati), bindusAra aura candragupta Adi rAjA bhI jinapratimA prAdi meM vizvAsa karate the| khaMDa 2, pR0 451 para prAcArya likhate haiM ki ..... . ................... jina zilAlekhoM ko Ajataka azoka ke zilAlekhoM ke nAma se bauddhadharma se sambandhita zilAlekha samajhA jAtA rahA thA,

Page #199
[ 153 ] unameM katipaya zilAlekha samprati, bindusAra aura candragupta ke evaM jainadharma se sambandhita bhI haiN| mImAMsA-dhvaMsAvazeSa ke rUpa meM mile prAcIna zilAlekhoM, jinamUrtiyAM aura jinamUrti para uTTa kita zilAlekhoM se isa tathya kI bhalIbhAMti puSTi hotI hai ki pUrvAcAryoM ne ina rAjA mahArAjAoM ko pratibodha karake jaina saMskRti ke pracAra prasAra hetu Agama kathita mArga se jinamandiroM kA nirmANa karavAyA thA evaM unameM tIrthaMkara paramAtmA kI mUrtiyoM kI pratiSThA karavAyI thI tathA inake dvArA jainadharma ko lokahRdaya meM Ajataka surakSita rakhA hai| jinapratimA aura jinamandira ke virodha ke kAraNa hI dhvaMsAvazeSa ke viSaya meM prAcArya apanI kalama corI-corI calA rahe haiM, unakI sAvadhAnI kA yahI kAraNa hai ki kahIM unake hAthoM pratimA kI satyatA jAhira na hone paaye| kintu eka saccA itihAsakAra sacce tathyoM para kabhI bhI abhiniveza yA durAgraha nahIM rakha sktaa| jainAgama tathA prAgametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya evaM aitihAsika zilAlekhoM Adi ke tathya hote hue bhI mUrtipUjA jaise viSaya ko vivAdAspada banAkara inake aitihAsika tathyoM se inkAra karanA sUrya ke prakAza ko hAtha se rokane sadRza bAliza prayAsa mAtra hai aura apane anugAmiyoM ko galata aura apramANika mArga para bhaTakAye rakhane kA ghRNAspada kRtya bhI hai| jinapratimA aura jinamandira ke viSaya meM pUrvagraha prasita mAnasa ke kAraNa khaMDa 2, pa0 451 para prAcArya kaisI aspaSTa, gola-mola evaM hAsyAspada bAta likhate haiM ki xxx siMha kA sambandha buddha ke sAtha utanA saMgata nahIM baiThatA jitanA ki bhagavAna mahAvIra ke sAtha / bhagavAna mahAvIra kA cinha ( lAMchana ) siMha thA aura kevalajJAna kI utpatti ke pazcAt bhagavAna mahAvIra ke sAtha-sAtha

Page #200
[ 154 ] siMha kA cinha bhI caturmukhI dRSTigocara hone lagA thaa| siMhacatuSTaya para dharmacakra isa bAta kA pratIka hai ki jisa samaya tIrthakara vihAra karate haiM, usa samaya dharmacakra nabhamaNDala meM unake Age Age calatA hai / isa prakAra ke aneka gahana tathya haiM, jinake sambandha meM gahana zodha kI AvazyakatA hai / 8xx mImAMsA-prAcArya hastImalajI ne ukta bAta bauddhadharmacakra paura caturmukha siMhAkRti vAle sAranAtha kA stambha ke viSaya meM kahI hai| kintuM samavasaraNa meM bhagavAna kA caturmukhI dikhanA aura tInoM prora devoM dvArA bhagavAna ke zarIra pramANa-pratikRti yAnI pratimA kI sthApanA karanA Adi viSaya meM svamAnyatA virodha ke kAraNa vizada spaSTIkaraNa ve nahIM karapAye haiM jo kheda kA viSaya hai / "isa prakAra ke aneka gahana tathya haiM, jinake sambandha meM gahana zodha kI AvazyakatA hai" prAcArya kA aisA likhanA anucita hai kyoMki ghora parizramI (!) aura vastu ke antaHstala taka pahuMcane kI prajJAdhAraka (! ) prAcArya svayaM isa prakAra ke tathyoM para gahana zodha kyoM nahIM karate haiM ? prAgamasUtroM evaM prAgametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya meM bhI jinamandira, mUrtipUjA kA varNana pAtA hai / purAtana avazeSa vizeSa bhI isa tathya kI puSTi karate haiM / AbU, rANakapura, giranArajI. zatrujaya, kadambagiri, sammetazikharajI, pAvApurI, rAjagiri, kesariyAjI, tAraMgAjI Adi tIrthoM para pUrvAcAryoM ke prAgamAnusArI kathana para hI jinezvara bhagavAna ke bhaktoM ne vizAla jina maMdira banavAye haiM aura maMdira meM jina mUrtiyoM kI una prAcAryoM dvArA pratiSThA karavA kara ve jaina zrAvakoM jina mUrti se mUrtimAna arihaMta kA vaMdana-pUjana-satkAra-sammAna kara kRtArtha ho rahe haiM / ekAntavAdI dRSTi ke kAraNa hI khaMDa 1, pR0 423 para prAcArya vizAla jina mandiroM ko mAtra kalAkRti ke hI pratIka kahate haiM, jo anyAyapUrNa hai / yathA

Page #201
[ 155 ] xxx bhagavAna pArzvanAtha kI bhakti se ota-prota aneka mahAtmAoM evaM vidvAnoM dvArA racita prabhu pArzvanAtha kI mahimA se pUrNa kaI mahAkAvya, kAvya, caritra, agaNita stotra aura deza ke vibhinna bhAgoM meM "bhavya kalAkRtiyoM ke pratIka" vizAla maMdiroM kA bAhulya, ye saba isa bAta ke puSTa pramANa haiM ki bhagavAna pArzvanAtha ke prati dharmaniSTha mAnava samAja pIr3hiyoM se kRtajJa aura zraddhAvanata hai| mImAMsA-vizAla jina mandiroM ko mAtra bhavyakalA kRtiyoM ke pratIka kahanA prAcArya kI bahuta gaharI galatI hai| ye maMdira bhagavAna ko pratidina vaMdana-pUjana-satkAra-sanmAna karake unake prati kRtajJatA evaM zraddhA kA bhAva pragaTa karane hetu haiM / mandiroM ko "bhavya kalAkRtiyoM ke pratIka" kahane kI apanI dhuna meM prAcArya yaha bhUla gaye ki phira to pUrvAcAryoM dvArA racita stotra, bhajana, stavana, caritragranthoM Adi bhavya racanAtroM ko bhI vANIvilAsa yA kAvya vinoda hetu hI pUrvAcAryoM ne racA hai, aisA anucita mAnane kI bhI prApatti aajaaygii| jinamandira aura stotra mAdi sAhitya tIrthakara paramAtmA kI bhakti, upakArI ke upakAra ke badale meM kRtajJatA vyakta karane hetu aura zraddhA tathA jJAna prApti hetu evaM jinezvara deva ko nitya vaMdana, pUjana, satkAra sammAna hetu hai, yaha bAta prAcArya ko bhUlanA nahIM caahie| prabhu pArzvanAtha kI bhakti ke viSaya meM prAcArya khaMDa 1, pR0 523 para likhate haiM ki xxxjaina sAhitya ke antargata stuti-stotra aura maMtrapadoM se bhI jJAta hotA hai ki vartamAna avasarpiNI kAla ke caubIsa tIrthaMkaroM meM se bhagavAn pArzvanAtha kI stuti ke rUpa meM jitane maMtra yA stotra upalabdha haiM, utane anya ke nahIM haiN|xxx ___mImAMsA-pArzvanAtha bhagavAna ke jitane stotra haiM, utane hI jinamandira haiM, yaha kisI ko bhUlanA nahIM caahie| zrI pArzvanAtha

Page #202
[ 156 ] bhagavAna ko kalpasUtra prAdi zAstroM meM puruSAdAnIya kahA hai| prAcIna stotroM meM Apake 108 nAma prasiddha haiM / ina nAmoM se sambandhita vizAla tIrtha Aja bhI maujUda haiM aura bhavika loga una tIrthoM kI yAtrA karake pAvana hote haiN| ciMtAmaNi pArzvanAthajI, aMtarikSa pArzvanAthajI, avaMti pArzvanAthajI, zaMkhezvara pArzvanAthajI, jirAvalA pArzvanAthajI varakANA pArzvanAthajI, navakhaMDA pArzvanAthajI, nAkoDA pArzvanAthajI, sammetazikhara para zrI zAmaliyA pArzvanAthajI, paMcAsarA pArzvanAthajI Adi aneka nAmoM se bhagavAna zrI pArzvanAthajI aneka tIrthoM meM pUje jAte haiM / ina saba tathyoM ko itihAsa lekhaka prAcArya jAneM aura mAne tathA satya ko prAtmasAt kareM, yahI hamArI zubhecchA hai / agara mUrtipUjA ko maiM bahuta prAcIna aura paramopayogI mAnatA huuN| jainadharma ko aba taka isa rUpa meM TikAye rakhane kA pramukha zreya maiM mUrtipUjA ko detA huuN| -zrI agaracandajI nAhaTA, itihAsavettA evaM purAtattvavid

Page #203
[prakaraNa-34] sthAnakapaMthI samAja meM itihAsa ko kamI Agama zAstra, prAgametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya bhASya, vRtti, cUNi, TIkAdi rUpa prAgamika sAmagrI evaM jamIna meM se nikale prAcIna avazeSa vizeSa rUpa aitihAsika tathyoM se yaha sarvathA satya siddha ho gayA hai ki jina mUrtiyAM, caraNa pAdukA evaM stUpAdi bhagavAna mahAvIra se bhI bahuta pahale pUje jAte the| jina maMdira evaM jina pratimA viSayaka isI prakAra prAcIna prAmANika AdhAra hote hue bhI prAcArya hastImalajI ne kaisA kalpita, galata evaM apramANika itihAsa likhA hai isakI mImAMsA pichale 33 prakaraNoM meM hama kara Aye haiM / eka mAne hue jainAcArya ne paMthamoha meM phaMsakara apramANikatA aura jhUTha kA sahArA lekara jainadharma ke itihAsa ko kalaMkita kiyA hai aura prAcArya pada kI garimA ko kAlimA lagAyI hai| phira bhI ulTA cora koTavAla ko DAMTe isa bhAMti khaMDa 1 ( purAnI prAvRtti) apanI bAta pR0 25 para prAcArya likhate haiM ki xxx jaina itihAsa ke isa prakAra ke prAmANika AdhAra hone para bhI Adhunika vidvAna isako binA dekhe jainadharma aura tIrthaMkaroM ke viSaya meM dhAntipUrNa lekha likha DAlate haiM, yaha Azcarya evaM kheda kI bAta hai| itihAsajJa

Page #204
[ 158 ] ko prAmANika granthoM kA adhyayana kara jisa dharma yA sampradAya ke viSaya meM likhanA ho prAmANikatA se likhanA cAhie / sAmpradAyika abhiniveza yA binA pUre adhyayana manana ke sunI sunAI bAta para likha DAlanA ucita nhiiN|444 .. mImAMsA-yahI bAta hameM prAcArya ke liye hI kahanI hai ki digambara aura zvetAmbara donoM jaina sampradAya mUrtipUjA meM vizvAsa karate haiM, phira mUrtipUjA ke viSaya meM prAcArya ne viruddha kyoM likhA ? AgamagranthoM, pAgametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya evaM aitihAsika zilAlekhoM Adi kI prAmANika sAmagrI hote hue bhI viparIta mArga para calanA aura apane anuyAyiyoM ko bhI viparIta mArga para bhaTakAye rakhanA kyA ucita hai ? agara prAcArya ko jainadharma ke viSaya meM itihAsa likhanA thA to donoM digambara evaM zvetAmbara jaina paramparA ke prAcIna sAhitya aura aitihAsika sAmagrI ke sahAre se mUrtipUjA viSayaka tathya ko satya likhanA thaa| isase viparIta agara prAcArya ko kalpanA pUrvaka managaDhaMta itihAsa kA eka samiti dvArA nirmANa karavAnA hI thA to jaina samAja ko aise kalpita itihAsa kI AvazyakatA hI kyA thI ? agara prAcArya ko sthAnakapaMthI mAnyatA pUrNa hI itihAsa likhanA thA aura jinamandira prAdi viSayoM ko aMdhere meM hI rakhanA thA to acchA yaha thA ki pApa "sthAnakapaMthI jaina itihAsa" aisA kucha nAma dekara zrImAn lokAzAha se hI usakA prArambha karate aura kisI bhI itihAsa samiti dvArA cAhe jaisA likhavAte-chapavAte isameM hameM koI Apatti nahIM hotI aura "sthAnakapaMthI jaina itihAsa" aisA kucha nAma pUrvaka unake pAdya pUrvapuruSa vRddha jaina gRhasthI lokAzAha se itihAsa prArambha karane para prAcArya ko kisI bhI jhUTha kA sahArA lene kI naubata na AtI evaM kama se kama jaina itihAsa ko kalaMkita karane ke pApa se bhI Apa baca jAte / sthAnakapaMthI mAnyatA ke anukUla itihAsa likhanA

Page #205
[ 156 ] aura usakA nAma "jainadharma kA maulika itihAsa" rakhanA yaha eka manISI prAcArya kA bhrama phailAne kA apramANika kRtya hI hai| khaMDa 1, pR0 34 para sampAdakIya noMdha meM gajasiMhajo rAThaur3a likhate haiM ki xxxjaina samAja, khAsakara zvetAmbara sthAnakavAsI samAja meM jainadharma ke prAmANika itihAsa kI kamI cirakAla se khaTaka rahI thii| 888 mImAMsA-"jaina samAja" meM itihAsa kI kamI hai hI nhiiN| vasudeva hiNDI, paumacariyaM, tiloya paNNatti, cauvana mahApurisa cariyaM, triSaSThi zalAkA puruSa caritra, harivaMza purANa Adi aneka prAmANika prAcIna itihAsa evaM pAgama tathA prAgametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya, caritra anthoM Adi meM prAcIna jainAcAryoM dvArA kathita jaina samAja kA pramANika itihAsa suvyavasthita rIta se surakSita hai aura sammetazikhara, pAvApurI, giranAra, zatrujaya, rANakapura, AbU, kesariyAjI, kumbhAriyAnI, tAraMgAjI Adi hajAroM tIrthoM evaM lagabhaga 80 hajAra se bhI adhika jina mandiroM ke rUpa meM jaina samAja kA itihAsa svayaM vyavasthita hai| ata: jaina samAja meM itihAsa kI kamI khaTakane kI sampAdaka zrI gajasiMhajI kI kathita bAta sarvathA asatya hI hai| prAcArya svayaM khaMDa-1 [purAnI prAvRtti] pR0 6 para apanI bAta meM likhate haiM ki 888 uparokta paryAlocana ke bAda yaha kahanA kiMcitmAtra bhI atizayokti pUrNa nahIM hogA ki hamArA jaina itihAsa bahuta gaharI sudRr3ha nIba para khar3A hai / yaha idhara-udhara kI kiMvadantI yA kalpanA ke AdhAra se nahIM para prAmANika pUrvAcAryoM kI avirala paramparA se prApta hai / ataH isakI vizvasanIyatA meM lezamAtra bhI zaMkA kI guMjAiza nahIM rhtii|xxx mImAMsA-prAcArya ke ukta kathana se bhI "jaina samAja meM itihAsa kI kamI" kI gajasiMhajI dvArA likhita bAta prasatya hI siddha

Page #206
[ 160 ] hotI hai| prAmANika pUrvAcAryoM kathita satya itihAsa maujUda hote hue bhI kalpita evaM kiMvadantI svarUpa, asatya evaM sthAnakapaMthI mAnyatA se pUrNa, nAmadhArI eka samiti dvArA prakAzita kiyA gayA aura nAmadhArI eka prAcArya dvArA racA gayA "jainadharma kA maulika itihAsa" nAmaka pustaka ko kauna sajjana satya mAna sakatA hai ? ataH jina mandira evaM jinamUrtipUjA meM vizvAsa karane vAle sujJoM se merA anurodha hai ki jitanI saMbhava ho sake utanI tAkata se itihAsa lekhana kI aisI kupravRttiyoM kI AlocanA karanI caahie| rahI bAta sthAnakapaMthI samAja kI so ve apane itihAsa kA nAma "sthAnakapaMthI samAja kA maulika (!) itihAsa" rakhakara, phira cAhe jaisA manamAnA apanA itihAsa raceM, to hameM koI vivAda nahIM hai / bharatacakravartI ne aSTApada para jinamaMdira banavAye isa viSaya meM kalpita paurANika kiMvadantI ko sAmane kara zrI siddhasenasUrijI kI ghaTanA ko pratimA ke kAraNa aprAmANika likhakara, zrI gautamasvAmI kA aSTApadagiri para jAne kA satya chipAkara, dazapUrvadhara zrI vanasvAmI kA vidyAbala se puSpa lAne ke satya ko viparIta kara prAcArya ne satya se vaimanasya rakhA hai aura aisI to aneka bAteM haiM, jinako prAcArya ne viparIta likhI hai, phira bhI ve khaMDa-1, pR0 31 para likhate haiM ki 444kahIM bhI sAmpradAyika abhiniveza vaza koI apramANika bAta nahIM Ane pAve, isa bAta kA vizeSa dhyAna rakhA gayA hai|xnx - mImAMsA-sthAnakapaMthI kabhI bhI jainadharma viSayaka itihAsa satya likha hI nahIM sakate haiM / sAmpradAyika vyamoha ke kAraNa prAcArya ne apane itihAsa se jinapratimA, jinamandira Adi viSayoM meM aneka aprAmANika bAteM likhI haiM, ata: unakA ukta kathana sarvathA asaMgata hI hai|

Page #207
[ 161 ] mukhya saMpAdaka zrI gajasiMhajI rAThaur3a ko hamArA itanA hI kahanA hai ki itihAsa lekhana meM Agama zAstra, prAgametara prAcIna jaina sAhitya evaM prAcIna jinamaMdira-jinamUrtiyAM evaM zilAlekha prAdi ke vidyamAna hote hue, agara Apa satya itihAsa likhate-likhavAte aura sahI mArgadarzana karate to ApakI vidvatA se vijJajanoM ko avazya saMtoSa aura Ananda hotaa| prAcArya hastImalajI se hameM AzA hI nahIM, vizvAsa bhI hai ki ve prAcArya pada kI garimA samajhate hue Age prAmANika evaM satya itihAsa likhane kA kaSTa kareMge / yahI zubhecchA hai ki prAge ke itihAsa meM prAcArya hastImalajI pUjya hemacandrAcArya mahArAja, pUjya haribhadrasUrijI, pUjya abhayadeva sUrijI, pUjya hIrasUrIzvarajI, pUjya yazovijayajI Adi aneka mahAna puruSoM ke viSaya meM jo bhI likheM vaha satya tathya para prAdhArita honA cAhie evaM kubhArapAla mahArAjA, vastupAla-tejapAla, udAyana maMtrI, AmrabhaTTa-bAhar3abhaTTa, dharaNazAha, pethar3azAha, jagaDuzAha, vimalazAha, karamAzAha Adi mahAna jaina zrAvakoM ke viSaya meM bhI likheM to satya likheM / sAtha hI sAtha zatrujaya, sammetazikharajI, pAvApurIjI, giranArajI, vaibhAragiri, rANakapura, prAMbU, tAraMgAjI, kumbhAriyAjI, kesariyAjI, nAkoDAjI, zaMkhezvarajI Adi tIrthoM ke viSaya meM likheM to sahI sahI satya likheMge aura milI haI evaM bacI haI samayAdi zaktiyoM kA sadupayoga kara jaina zAsana kI garimA ko unnata kreNge| . jaina samAja meM vidyamAna sarva prabuddha janoM se vinatI hai ki prakAza se aMdhakAra meM le jAne vAlI galata itihAsa prAdi sAhitya likhane vAloM kI bAliza kuceSTA se sAvadhAna evaM satarka rheN| ___ mere dvArA jinAjJA ke viruddha yadi kucha bhI likhA gayA ho to micchAmi dukkaDam detA huuN| sujaiH mayi upakRtya shodhym| jainaM zAsanam jytu|

Page #208
[ prakaraNa-35 ] pariziSTa mUrtipUjA meM zAstroM ko sammati prathama pramANa zrI jJAtAdharma kathA nAmaka prAgamasUtra ke chaThe adhyayana meM draupadI ne jina pUjA kI thI, aisA spaSTa kathana hai| jisase zrI neminAtha bhagavAna ke kAla meM bhI jinamUrti pUjA thI, yaha bAta siddha hotI hai / zrI jJAtAdharma kathA sUtra kathita pATha isa prakAra hai xxx taeNaM sA dovaI rAyavara kannA jeNeva majjaNaghare teNeva uvAgacchai, uvAgacchaittA majjaNagharamaNuppavisai, aNupavisaittA vhAyA kayanalikammA kayakouyamaMgalapAyacchittA suddhapAvesAI maMgalAI vatthAI pavara parihiyA majjaNagharAo paDimikkhamai, paDinikkhamittA jeNeva jiNaghare teNeva uvApacchai, uvAgacchaittA jiNagharaM aNupabisai, aNupavisaittA Aloe jiNapaDimANaM paNAma karei, paNAmaM kareittA lomahatthayaM parAmusai, evaM jahA sUriyAbho jiNapaDimAo accei taheva bhANiyavvaM jAva dhUvaM Dahai, dhUvaM DahaittA vAmaM jANu aMcei, aMceittA dAhiNaM jANudharaNItalaMsi Nivesei, NivesittA tikhutto muddhANa dharANItalaMsi, namei, namayittA isi paccuNamai karayala jAva kaTTa evaM vayAsi namotthuNaM arihaMtANaM bhagavaMtANaM jAva saMpattANaM baMdai namasai jiNagharAo paDiNikkhamai / [ sUtra 11-9 ] xxx

Page #209
[ 163 ] artha-isake bAda vaha draupadI rAjakanyA snAnaghara meM prAI, snAna ghara meM mAkara snAna kiyA, balikarma-kautuka maMgala prAyacchitta karake zuddha praveza yogya zreSTha vastroM ko pahinakara snAna ghara meM se bAhara nikalI aura jahA~ jina mandira hai vahA~ pAI, prAkara ke jina mandira meM praveza kiyA, praveza karake jinapratimA ke darzana kiye, praNAma kiyA, praNAma karake morapIMcha ( morapaMkha ) se jisa prakAra sUryAbhadeva jina pratimA ko pUjatA hai, usI prakAra ( vistAra se ) pUjA-arcanA kI, yAvat dhUpa karake bAyAM ghuTanA khar3A karake dAyAM ghuTanA ko jamIna para sthApana karatI hai, sthApana karake tIna bAra mastaka jhukAkara namaskAra karatI hai, namaskAra karake sira jhukAkara donoM hAtha jor3akara isa prakAra bolatI hai namaskAra ho arihaMta bhagavaMtoM ko yAvat jo (siddhigati ko) prApta hue haiM unako vaMdana karatI hai, namaskAra karatI hai, vaMdana aura namaskAra karake jinamandira meM se bAhara nikalatI hai| [noMdha-yaha Agamika zailI hai ki Agama zAstroM [ bhagavAna kI vANI ] ko graMthArUr3ha karate vakta grantha-vistAra ke bhaya se granthakartA maharSiyoM ne samAna varNana vAle prasaMgoM ko jahA~ vistAra se varNana milatA ho ( likhA ho ) usI pAgama sUtra kA nirdeza ( sUcana ) kara diyA hai ki-'vahA~ se isa viSayaka varNana dekha lenaa|" -- jaise zrI jJAtAdharma kathA nAmaka aMgasUtra meM zrI mallinAtha svAmI kA janma mahotsava viSayaka varNana kA nirdeza zAstrakAra maharSi pUjya devaddhigaNi kSamAzramaNa mahArAja ne "jambUdvIpa prajJapti sUtra'' meM se dekhalene kA kaha diyA hai . "jahA jambUddIba paNNattie savvaM jammaraNaM bhAriNayanvaM"

Page #210
[ 164 ] tathA jJAtAsUtra meM hI zrI mallinAtha svAmI ke dIkSA viSayaka varNana ko jamAli ke adhikAra meM se jAna lenA aisA sUtrakAra maharSi zrI devaddhigaNi mahArAja ne kahA hai| yathA 888 evaM viNiggamo jahA jamAlIssa / 288 ThIka usI prakAra rAjakumArI draupadI ne vistAra se jina pUjA kI thI, isa viSaya meM zAstrakAra maharSi "rAyapaseNI" nAmaka upAMgasUtra kA nirdeza karake kahate haiM ki- "draupadI ne vistAra se jina pUjA kI thI vaha "rAyapaseNI sUtra" meM se dekha lenaa|" zrI jJAtAdharma kathA nAmaka chaTThA aMgasUtra ke kartA 1 pUrvadhara maharSi pUjya devaddhigaNi kSamAzramaNa bhI draupadI viSayaka jinapUjA ke adhikAra ko sUryAbhadevakA adhikAra jisa "rAyapraznIya" nAmaka upAMga sUtra meM hai, usameM se dekhalene kA nirdeza [ sUcana ] karate haiM. yaha isabAta kA sUcaka hai ki 1 pUrvadhara maharSi zrI devaddhigaNi kSamAzramaNa mahArAja bhI aMgasUtra ke samAna hI upAMga sUtra kA bhI mahimA-mahatva karate haiM / yAnI upAMgasUtra bhI aMgasUtra jitanA hI mahatvapUrNa aura prAmANika hai / ] dvitIya pramANa zrI rAyapaseNIya nAmaka upAMga sUtra meM sUryAbhadeva ne jinamUrtipUjA kI thI, isa viSayaka pATha xxx taeNaM se sUriyAbhe deve cahiM sAmANiya sahassIhiM jAva annehi ya bahuhiM ya sUriyAbha jAva devehi ya devIhiM saddhi saMparivuDe savvaDhDhie jAva NA (va) niya-raveNaM jeNeva siddhAyataNe teNeva uvAgacchati, uvAgacchittA siddhAyataNaM purathimilleNaM vAreNaM aNupavisai, aNupavisittA jeraNeva devacchaMdae,

Page #211
[ 165 ] jeNeva jiNapaDimAo teNeva uvAgacchati, uvAgacchittA jiNapaDimANaM Aloe paNAmaM kareMti, karittA lomahatthaeNaM gihaMti, gihittA jiNapaDimANaM lomahatthaeNaM pamajjai, pamajjittA jiNapaDimAo surabhiNA gaMdhodaeNa vhANei, hANittA surabhigaMdhakAsAieNaM gAyAI lUheti, lUhittA jiNapaDimANaM sarasa gosIsa caMdaNeNaM gAyAiM aNulipai, aNulipaittA ahayAI devadUsa juyalAI niyaMsei, niyaMsittA pupphAruhaNaM mallAruhaNaM gaMdhAruhaNaM cuNNaruhaNaM vannAruhaNaM vatthAruhaNaM AmaraNArahaNaM karei, karittA Asatosatta viulavaTTavagdhAriya malladAmakalAvaM karei, malladAmakalAvaM karittA kayaggaha gahiya karayala panbhaTTha vippamukkeNaM dasaddhavanneNaM kusumeNaM mukka puppha-pujovayAra kaliyaM kareMti, karittA jiNapaDimANaM purato acchehi saNhehi rayayAmaehi accharasA taMdulaehiM aThTha maMgale Alihai, taM jahA-sotthiya jAva dappaNaM / tayANaMtaraM ca NaM caMdappabharayaNa vaira veruliya vimaladaMDa kaMcaNa maNirayaNa bhatticittaM kAlAguru-pavara kudarukka turukka pUva maghamaghaMta gaMdhuttamANuviddha ca dhUvaTTi viNimmuyattaveruliyamayaM kaDucchuya paggahiyapayatteNaM "pUrva dAuNaM jiNavarANaM" aThThasaya visuddha gaMthajuttehiM atyajuttehiM apuNaruttehiM mahAvittehiM saMthuNai, saMthuNaIttA sattaThTha-payAI paccosakkai, paccosakkaIttA vAmaM jANu aMcei, aMcaIttA dAhiNaM jANu dharaNItalaMsi nihaTTa, tikkhutto muddhANaM dharaNItalaMsi nivADei, nivADittA Isi paccuNNamai, paccuNNamaIttA karayala pariggahiyaM sirasAvattaM matthae aMjali kaTTa, evaM vayAsi-namotthuNaM arihaMtAgaM jAva saMpattANaM vaMdai, namasai, vaMdittA namaMsittA jeNeva devacchaMdae jeNeva siddhAyataNassa bahumajjhadesabhAe teNeva uvAgacchai / [ rAyappaseNI sUttaM ] 444 artha-usake bAda sUryAbhadeva cAra hajAra sAmAnika devoM ke sAtha yAvata anya bhI aneka sUryAbhavimAna meM nivAsa karane vAle deva tathA deviyoM ke sAtha saparivAra sarvaRddhi se sahita ( yukta ) yAvat vAjiMtranAda ke sAtha jahA~ siddhAyatana ( jina maMdira ) hai vahA~ prAtA hai, Akara pUrvadvAra se siddhAyatana meM praveza karatA hai, praveza karake jahA~ deva

Page #212
[ 166 ] chaMdaka hai aura jahA~ jinapratimAeM haiM vahAM jAtA hai, jAkara jinapratimA kA darzana karatA hai, darzana karake praNAma karatA hai, praNAma karake morapIcha ( morapaMkha ) letA hai, lekara pratimAoM kA morapIMcha se pramArjana karatA hai| pramArjana karane ke bAda jinapratimAoM ko sugandhita gaMdhodaka se snAna karAtA hai, abhiSeka karake surabhigandha yukta kASAyika vastroM se ( aMgaluhanA se ) bhagavAna ke gAtroM ko svaccha karatA ( poMchatA ) hai, svaccha karake sarasa gozIrSa caMdana se gAtroM kA vilepana karatA hai, vilepana karake akhaMDita devadUSya ( vastrayugala ) rakhatA hai, rakhakara puSpa car3hAtA hai, mAlA arpaNa karatA hai, gaMdha aura sugaMdhI arpaNa karatA hai, tathA varNaka arpaNa karatA hai, vastra arpaNa karatA hai, AbhUSaNa car3hAtA hai, AbhUSaNa caDhAkara cAroM ora lambI puSpamAlAeM laTakAtA hai, puSpamAlA laTakAkara khule hue paMcavarNa puSpa hAthameM lekara cAroM ora bikheratA hai, isa prakAra puSpoM dvArA pUjopacAra ( pUjA dvArA bhakti se ) pUrvaka siddhAyatana ( jina mandira ) ko sajAtA hai, sajAne ke bAda meM jinapratimAke sAmane apsarAeM svaccha cikanA rajatamaya akSatoM se aSTa maMgala kA prAlekhana karatI haiM, jinake nAma svastika yAvat darpaNa haiN| usake bAda candraprabha ratna, horA aura vaiDUryaratnoM yukta jisakA daMDa ujjvala hai evaM suvarNa aura maNiratnoM kI racanA se manohara, kRSNAgaru zreSTha kundurUpa turuSka dhUpa se maghamaghAyamAna uttama gaMdha se yukta dhUpabattI jaisI sugaMdhiko phailAnevAlA vaiDUryaratnamaya dhUpadhAnA ( dhUpadAnI ) ko lekara prayatna pUrvaka (sAvadhAnI se ) jinavaroM ko dhUpa karatA hai. bAda meM 108 vizuddha racanAvAlA arthayukta apunarukta ( vividha ) mahAna zlokoM se stuti karatA hai| stuti karake sAta-pATha kadama pIche haTatA hai, pIche haTakara bAyA~ ghuTanA U~cA karatA hai aura dAhinAM ghuTanA jamIna para TikAkara jamIna para tIna bAra sira jhukAtA hai, mastaka ko jamIna para lagAkara thor3A U~cA uThAtA hai, UMcA uThAkara donoM hAtha jor3akara aMjalIbaddha karasaMpuTa karake isa prakAra stuti karatA hai

Page #213
[ 167 ] "namaskAra ho arihaMta bhagavantoM ko yAvat jo siddhigati ko prApta kiye hue haiM unako" ityAdi caMdana namaskAra karatA hai, vaMdana-namaskAra karake jahA~ devachaMdaka hai, jahA~ siddhAyatana kA madhyabhAga hai vahA~ jAtA hai| [ zrI rAjapraznIya sUtra] - tRtIya pramANazrI aMgacUliyA nAmaka kAlika sUtra [ jisakA ullekha zrI naMdIsUtra kathita 73 sUtra meM hai ] meM kahA hai ki sarvasAvadya tyAga rUpa dIkSA jinamandira meM denI cAhie / yathA 888 tihi nakhasa muhUtA ravijogAiyaM pasanna divase appA vosirAmi / "jiNabhavaNAi" pahANakhita guru vaMditA bhaNai icchakAri tumhe anhaM paMca mahAvbayAI rAinoyana veramaNaM chaTThAI aarovaavnniyaa| .. [zrI aMgacUliyA sUttaM ] 80x artha-tithi, nakSatra, muhUrta, raviyoga prAdi yoga yukta prazasta zubhadina ko ( mumukSu ) apanI prAtmA ko pApa se vosirAve ( tyAge ), so jinabhavana ( jinamandira ) Adi pradhAna ( zreSTha ) kSetra meM guru ko vaMdanA karake kahe- 'prasAda karake pApa mujhako paMca mahAvrata aura chaTA rAtribhojana viramaNavrata prAropaNa karo ( devo)| caturtha pramANa zrI bhagavatIsUtra meM niyukti, TIkA Adi ko mAnane kA nirdeza kiyA hai / yathAxxx suttattho khalu paDhamo, bIo nijjutti missao bhaNio, taioya niraviseso / esa vihi hoI annuogo| -zrI bhagavatI sUtra, 25 vAM zataka, tIsarA uddezAxxx

Page #214
[ 168 ] artha-prathama (sAmAnya se) sUtra aura artha kA kathana karanA, dUsarA niyukti ke sAtha artha denA (artha karanA ) aura tIsarI bAra nivizeSa arthAt sampUrNa (pUrA pUrA ) artha denA (krnaa)| .. [ isa pAgama pATha meM tIsare prakAra kI vyAkhyA meM bhASya, cUNi, TIkA mAdi ke sahAre se sUtrArtha karanA aisA sApha likhA huprA hai| paJcama pramANa zrI mahAkalpasUtra nAmaka utkAlika sUtra meM [ jisa sUtra kA nAma kathana zrI nandIsUtra meM bhI hai ] likhA hai ki-sAdhu aura zrAvaka jina mandira meM nitya jAveM / agara nahIM jAveM to prAyacchita lagatA hai, aisA zrI mahAvIra svAmI ne gautama svAmI gaNadhara mahArAja ke prazna ke uttara meM kahA hai / yathA xxx se bhayavaM ! 'tahAevaM samaNaM vA mAhaNaM vA ceiyaghare gacchejjA ? haMtA goyamA ! diraNe diNe gcchejjaa| se bhayavaM! jattha diNe Na gacchejjA tao kiM pAyacchit havejjA ? goyamA ! pamAyaM paDucca tahAruvaM samaNaM vA mAhaNaM vA jo jiNagharaM na gacchejjA tao chaThu ahavA duvAlasamaM pAyacchittaM havejjA / se bhayavaM ! samaNovAsagassa posahasAlAe posahie posaha vaMbhayAri ki jiNagharaM gacchejjA? haMtA, goyamA ! gcchejjaa| se bhayavaM! keNagaM gacchejjA ? goyamA ! gANa daMsaNa caraNaTThAe gacchejjA / je koI posahasAlAe posaha baMbhayArI jao jighahare na gacchejjA tao ki pAyacchittaM havejjA ? goyamA ! jahA sAhU tahA bhANiyagvaM, cha8 ahavA duvAlasamaM pAyacchittaM hvejjaa| .... ...[zrI mahAkalpasUtra zAstra ] xxx

Page #215
- [ 166 ] - artha- gautama svAmI kA prazna:- ( sAdhu aura zrAvaka nitya jinamandira meM jAveM ) he bhagavaMt ! agara nahIM jAveM lo kyA prAyacchita ( daNDa ) lagatA hai ? mahAvIra svAmI:-he gautama ! yadi pramAda (pAlasya ) ke kAraNa ve jina maMdira na jAveM to do vrata yA tIna vrata ( upavAsa ) kA prAyacchita lagatA hai| gautama svAmI he bhagavaMt. ! pauSadha brahmacArI zrAvaka pauSadha meM rahA huaA kyA jina mandira jAve ? mahAvIra svAmI- hA~ gautama ! jaave| gautama svAmI-bhagavan ! maMdira meM vaha kisaliye jAve ? mahAvIra svAmI-he gautama ! jJAna-darzana-cAritra nimitta jaave| gautama svAmI-pauSadhazAlA meM rahA humA pauSadha-brahmacArI dhAvaka jinamandira meM nahIM jAve, to prAyacchita kyA hotA hai ? . mahAvIra svAmI he gautama ! sAdhu ko jitanA prAyacchita hotA hai utanA prAyacchita lagatA hai yAnI cha8 ( belA ) athavA usake samAna tapa kA prAyacchita lagatA hai| _ [ zrI mahA kalpasUtra zAstra kA hindI anuvAda ] SaSTha pramANa zrI mahA nizItha sUtra meM likhA hai ki jo puruSa jina mandira banAve, usako bArahavAM devaloka taka kI prApti hotI hai / yathA kAuMpi jiNAyayaNehi, maMDiyaM savvameyaNIvaTTa / dANAi caukkeraNaM, saDhDho gacchejja accuyaM jAvanaparaM / /

Page #216
[ 170 ] artha-jina maMdiroM se pRthvI ko maMDita ( suzobhita ) karake, dAnAdika cAroM ( dAna, zIla, tapa aura bhAvanA ) dharma karake zrAvaka yAvat bArahaveM devaloka taka jaaveN| saptama pramANa zrI pAvazyaka sUtra meM vaggura nAmaka zrAvaka ne zrI purimatAla nagara meM zrI mallinAthajI kA jinamaMdira banavAkara, sampUrNa parivAra sahita jinapUjA kI aisA adhikAra prAtA hai / yathA tattoya purimetAla, vaggura-isANa praccae paDimaM / mallijiNAyayaNa paDimA, annAevaMsivahugoThI / / aSTama pramANa mAgametara sAhitya meM sabase prAcIna jaina grantha "upadezamAlA", jo zrI mahAvIra bhagavAna ke hasta dIkSita zrI dharmadAsagaNi mahArAja viracita hai, usameM likhA hai ki Xxx nikkhamaNa - nANa - nivvANa, jammabhUmIu vaMdai jiNANaM // 236 // xxx marthaH-zrAvaka ko ( jainoM ko ) tIrthaGkara bhagavAna sambandhi janma, dIkSA, kevalajJAna paura nirvANa ( mokSa ) prAdi pavitra kalyANaka bhUmi kI vaMdanA-sparzanA karanI cAhie / isI upadezamAlA ke zloka 242 meM likhA hai kixxx sAhUrNa ceiyAga ya, paDaNIyaM taha ya avayavAyaM ca / ____ niNapavayanassa ahiyaM, savvatthAmeNa bAreI 1000

Page #217
[ 171 ] . .."zrI upamiti bhava prapaJcA kathA" ke kartA pUjya siddharSi gaNi mahArAja ukta zloka kI TIkA karate haiM ki xxx sAdhUnAM munInAM caityAnAM jinaprAsAda-pratimAnAM ca pratyanIkaM kSudropadravakAriNaM tathA avarNavAdinaM kuvacanabhASakaM jinazAsanasya ahita kAriNaM zatrubhUtaM janaM, saH zrAvakaH samasta prAraNena svakIya sarva zaktayA, prANavyayenApi vArayati / zAsanonnatikaraNasya mahodaya hetutvAt / 88x artha-sAdhu tathA jinamandira evaM jinapratimA ko tuccha upadrava karane vAle aura unakA anAdara evaM kuvacana bolakara avarNavAda karane vAle jaina zAsana ke zatrubhUta vyaktikA jaina zrAvaka sarva sAmarthyazakti se yAvat prANatyAga pUrvaka bhI sAmanA-virodha kareM, kyoMki zAsamonnati karane se mahodaya hotA hai| navama pramANa 14 pUrvadhara zrI bhadrabAhu svAmI mahArAja zrI mAvazyaka sUtra meM kahate haiM kixxx akasiNa pavattagANaM virayA virayANa esa khalu jutto| saMsAra payaNa karaNe davvatthae kuuvdittuNto||max artha:-sarvathA vrata meM pravRtta na hue viratA-virati arthAt zrAvaka ko yaha ( puSpAdi se pUjA karaNa rUpa dravyastava ) nizcaya hI yukta-ucita hai / saMsAra ko patalA karane meM arthAt ghaTAne meM-kSaya karane meM kUpa kA dRSTAnta jaannaa| 'dazama pramANa "jaMghAcAraNa tathA vidyAcAraNa muniyoM ne jina pratimA vAndI hai" isa kathana kA ullekha zrI bhagavatI sUtra zataka 20, uddeza

Page #218
[ 172 ] xxx jaMghAcAraNassa gaM bhaMte ! tiriyaM kevaie gai visae pannatA ? goyamA se gaM itto egeNaM uppAeNaM ruagavare dIve samosaraNaM karei, karaittA tahiM ceiAI vaMdai, vaMdaittA ihamAgacchai ihamAgacchaittA, iha ceiyAI vaMbai, jaMghAcAraNassa goyamA ! tiriyaM evaie gaivisae pnntaa| xx ...... artha-he bhagavan ! jaMghAcAraNa muni kA tirachI gati kA viSaya kitanA hai ? he gautama ! vaha yahA~ se eka utpAta ( chalAMga) meM rucakavara (nAmaka terahavA) dvIpa meM samavasaraNa (vizrAma) kare, karake vahA~ ke caitya arthAt jinamandira (zAzvatA jina maMdira-siddhAyatana) ko vAMde, vAMdakara vahAM se vApasa lauTate dUsare utpAta meM nandIzvaradvIpa meM samavasaraNa (vizrAma ) kare, vizrAma karake vahA~ ke ( zAzvata jina ) caitya yAnI jina mandira ko vAMde, vAMdakara yahA~ ( bharata kSetra meM ) prAve, yahAM pAkara yahA~ ke (prazAzvata ) jina caitya yAnI jinamaMdira vAMde / he gautama ! jaMghAcAraNa muni kA tirachIgati kA viSaya itanA (jAnanA) hai| vidyAcAraNa muni ke jina pratimA vandana ke viSaya meM zrI bhagavatI sUtra meM pATha hai ki 888 vijAcAraNassa Na bhante ! tiriyaM kevaie gai visae pannataM ? goyamA ! seNa itto egeNa uppAraNa mANusottare pavvae samosaraNa karei, karaittA tahiM ceiAI vandai, vandaittA vIeNaM uppAeNaM gaMdisaravara dIve samosaraNa karei karaittA tahi ceiAI vandai, vaMdaittA tao paDiniyattai ihamAgacchaha, ihamAgacchaittA iha ceiAI vNdi| vijjAcAraNassa Na goyamA tiriyaM evaie gai visae paNNatte / [bhagavatIsUtra, 20 zataka, 9 uddeza] ...... artha-he bhagavan ! vidyAcAraNa muni kA tirachI gati kA viSaya kitanA hai ? he gautama ! vaha mahA~ se eka utpAta (ur3Ana ) meM mAnuSottara parvata para samavasaraNa (vizrAma ) kare, vizrAma karake vahAM ke

Page #219
[ 173 ] caitya yAnI jinamandira ko juhAre-vaMdana kare, vAnda kara dUsare utpAta meM nandIzvara dvIpa meM samavasaraNa ( vizrAma ) kare ( ruke ) / vizrAma kara ke nandIzvara dvIpa ke caitya yAnI jinamandira ko vAnde, jinamandira ko vAnda kara yahA~ vApasa lauTe / yahA~ prAkara (madhyaloka sthita-bharata kSetra ke prazAzvata ) jina mandira ko vAnde-juhAre / he gautama ! vidyAcAraNa muni kA tirachI gati kA itanA viSaya hai| ekAdaza pramANa . zrI paMcAzaka prakaraNa meM 1444 grantha ke racayitA, parama satya priya pUjya haribhadrasUrijI mahArAja likhate haiM ki "gRhasthoM ke pAsa svayaM ke upabhoga kI jo sAmagrI hai unakA sarvazreSTha upayoga bhagavAna zrI tIrthakaroM meM viniyoga hai yathA "na ya anno uvarogo, eesi siyANaM laTThayaro" isa gAthA [zloka] kI TIkA karate hue navAMgI TIkAkAra pUjyapAda zrI abhayadevasUrijI mahArAja likhate haiM ki xxxna naiva, ca samuccaye anyo jinapatipUjAto'paraH upayogo viniyogasthAnam, eteSAM pravarasAdhanAnAM satAM vidyamAnAnAM laSTataraH pradhAnataro bhavati........ataH pravara puSpAdibhiH pUjA vidheyA iti gaathaaryH|xxx artha - vidyamAn pravara [ zreSTha ] sAdhanoM [vastra-puSpa-phalaAdi] kA jinendra bhagavAna kI pUjA se bar3hakara anya uttama upayoga nahIM hai / isaliye puSpAdi se jinezvara bhagavAna kI pUjA karanI caahie| dvAdaza pramANa ____ prAgametara jaina sAhitya meM sabase prAcIna prAmANika "upadezamAlA" nAmaka grantha, jo zrI mahAvIra bhagavAna ke hasta dIkSita ziSya

Page #220
[ 174 ] pUjya zrI dharmadAsa gaNi mahArAja dvArA racita hai, usameM jaina zrAvaka ko haradina jinamandira meM jina pratimA kI aSTaprakArI pUjA karane kA vidhAna hai| xxx vaMdai ubhao kAlaMpi, ceiyAI thaithuI prmo| jiNavara-paDimA-ghara, dhUva-puSpha-gaMdhaccaNu jjutto|| [ zloka-230 ] xxx artha-stavana, stotra, stuti prAdi se pradhAna (yukta ) hokara zrAvaka tInakAla zrI jinezvara bhagavAna ke maMdira meM jinezvara bhagavAna kI pratimA ko puSpa, dhUpa, gaMdha arcanAdi se pUjana kreN| [upadezamAlA zAstra] trayodaza pramAraNa parama satya priya, tArkika ziromaNi, 1444 graMtha ke racayitA pUjya zrI haribhadrasUrijI mahArAja jo vikrama kI AThavIM zatAbdi meM hue, Apa "paMcAzaka" zAstra meM likhate haiM ki xxx jiNabhavaNa-bibaThAvaNa-jattA-pUjAi sutto vihinnaa| bamvatyamo ti neyaM, bhAvatthaya-kAraNatteNa // zrI paMcAzaka zAstra-6-3 888 ukta gAthA kA navAMgI TIkAkAra pUjyapAda zrI abhayadeva sUrijI, jo vikrama kI bArahavIM zatAbdi meM hue, Apa partha-TIkA karate haiM [ mUla saMskRta kA hindI meM ] ki- .. zAstrokta vidhi pUrvaka kiye hue jinamandira nirmANa, jina pratimA nirmANa, jina pratimA kI jina mandira meM pratiSThA, aSTAhnika mahotsava rUpa yAtrA, puSpAdi se pUjA aura stavana-stuti Adi guNagAna

Page #221
[ 175 ] . svarUpa anuSThAna sarva virati ( cAritra dharma ) rUpa bhAvastava ke kAraNa hone se dravya stava ( dravya pUjA ) hai / [ bhAvastava kA kAraNa svarUpa yaha dravyastava ( pUjA ) kA tIrthaGkara bhagavAna ne bhI kAma-bhoga kI taraha niSedha nahIM kiyA hai, prataH dravya stava bhagavAna ko abhipreta-anumataiSTa hai ] - caturdaza pramANa caudaha pUrvadhara zrutakevalajJAnI zrI bhadrabAhu svAmI mahArAja "zrI prAvazyaka sUtra" meM likhate haiM ki-udAyana rAjA kI prabhAvatI rANI ne jina mandira banavAyA aura tIna kAla bhagavAna kI pUjA-arcanA karatI thii| yathA 888 aMteura ceiyagharaM kAriyaM pabhAvaIe hAtAti / saMjhaM accei, annayA devI gaccai rAyA vINA vAyei // 4 // bhAvArtha-prabhAvatI rANI ne apane aMtepura ( rahane ke mahala ) meM jiNaghara yAnI jinamandira bnvaayaa| prabhAvatI rANI snAna karake prabhAta-madhyAnha evaM sAyaMkAla tIna vakta ghara meM rahA jinamandira meM arcA-pUjA karatI thI, ekadA rANI prabhAvato ( bhagavAna ke sAmane ) nRtya karatI hai aura svayaM rAjA vINA bajAtA hai paMcadaza pramANa bhagavAna zrI mahAvIra svAmI ke gyAraha zramaNopAsaka [zrAvaka ne jina pratimA pUjI hai / dhAvaka pramukha zrI prAnanda zrAvaka ke viSaya meM zrI upAsaka dazAMga sUtra meM nimna pATha hai xxx no khalu me bhaMte ! kampai ajjappabhiiMcaNaM anna utthipAkA anna usthiya devayANi vA anna utthiya pariggahiyAiM "arihaMta ceiyAI" vA vittae vA namaMsittae vaa| -ubAsagadasAMga sUtaxxx

Page #222
[ 176 ] ukta sUtra kI TIkA karate hue navAMgI TIkAkAra zrImad mabhayadeva sUrijI mahArAja likhate haiM ki xxxno khalu ityAdi no khalu mama bhadaMta ! he bhagavan ! kalpate yujyate adya prabhRti itaH samyaktva-pratipatti-dinAdArabhya niraticArasamyaktva paripAlanArtha tadyatanAmAzritya annausthietti jainayUthAdyanyadya thaM saMghAntaraM tIrthAntaramityarthaH tadasti yeSAM te'nyayUthikAH carakAdi kutIthikAH tAn manyayUthika daivatAni hari-harAdIni anya yUthika parigRhitAni vA "ahaMccatyAni. ahaMtupratimA-lakSaNAni" yathA mauta parigRhitAni vIrabhava-mahAkAlAdini bancituvA abhivAdanaM kartuM namasyatu vA pragAma pUrvaka prayAstadhvanibhiH guNotkIrtanaM kartum / zrI upAsaka dazAMga sUtra, prathamAdhyayanai 444 ____ bhAvArtha-he bhagavan ! mujhe mAja meM (samyagdarzana kI prApti ke bAda) nimna kathita bAteM na kalpe, jisase maiM (Ananda prAvaka ) niraticAra samyagdarzana kA pAlana kara skuu|maaj se lekara mujhe jainasaMgha ke antargata arihaMta aura arihaMta kI pratimA ko chor3akara anya tIrthI caraka prAdi, anya tIrthI ke deva hari-harAdi aura anya tIrthI ke grahaNa kiye arihaMta ke caitya arthAt jina pratimA ko vaMdana karanA, namaskAra karanA nahIM klpe| [ zAstra pAThoM meM jinAjJA viparIta yA zAstrakartA maharSiyoM ke abhiprAya ke viparIta kucha bhI likhA gayA ho to micchA mi dukaDam / ] VATI