Jagatkartutva Mimansa

Author(s): Balchandra Maharaj
Publisher: Moolchand Vadilal Akola
Catalog link: https://jainqq.org/explore/022403/1

Page #1
arham lekhaka khAmagrAma - nivAsI zrImAn-yativarya zrIbAlacandrajI mahArAja // jagatkartRtva-mImAMsA // prakAzaka vaDanagara nivAsI zrAvaka mUlacanda, vADIlAla AkolA (varADa) Printed by Gauri Shanker Lal at Chandraprabha Press, Benares. Published by Shrawak Moolchand, Wari Lal of Akola, vIra saM. 2435 ] mUlya ATha AnA [ prathama vAra 1000 Ase

Page #2

Page #3
dikh lekhaka khAmagrAma-nivAsI 1) zrImAn-yativarya-zrIbAlacandrajI mahArAja 2428.3 . // jgtkrtRtv-miimaaNsaa|| . prakAzaka ....... vaDanagara-nivAsI zrAvaka mUlacanda, vADIlAla AkolA (varADa) U Printed by Gauri Shanker Lal at Chandraprabha Press, Benarez. Published by Shrawak Moolchand, Wadi Lal of Akola. ( vIra saM. 2435] mUlya ATha AnA [prathama vAra 1000

Page #4

Page #5
_ sAkSaravarya zrImAn kevalacaMdrajo gaNi-mahArAja. ( surANA-pemarAjajI vardhAvAlekI tapaseM bheTa.) citrazALA presa, puNe.

Page #6

Page #7
pUjyavarya gaNijI zrImAn kevalacandrajI mahArAja kA saMkSipta jIvana caritra | ropakArI, udAra carita mahAna puruSoMkI jIvanI par3hane se manuSya ko jaisA manuSya karttavyakA jJAna prApta hotA hai, vaisA jJAna anya kisI bhI sAdhana dvArA nahIM ho sktaa| jaisA jaisA manuSya uttama puruSoMke caritra par3hate calA jAtA hai taisA taisA usake manameM ucca zreNI ke vicAra ba~dhate cale jAte haiM / aura anta meM aisI kartRtva zakti prApta hojAtA hai ki jisakI prazaMsA sujJa loka kiye vinA nahIM raha sakate / jIvanI likhane kA zauka bhArata meM hajAra paMdharAsau varSoM ke prathama bahutathA aisA prabaMdha ciMtAmaNi Adi aitihAsika graMthoM para se mAlUma hotA hai kintu jabase mugaloM kI rAjya sattA bhArata meM huI tabase isa bAta kA zauka naSTa prAyasA hogayA. bhAratake prAcIna itihAsameM jo jo truTiyAM vidita ho rahI haiM. isakA kAraNa bhI mugaloMkI rAjya sattA hI ko mAnanA cAhiye / jabase pAzcimAtya zikSAkA prabhAva bhArata meM par3A tabase yaha zauka phira bar3hane lagA / prastuta yahAM taka bar3hA huA hai ki aneka dainika, sAptAhika, mAsika vartamAna patroM dvArA aura pustakoM dvArA aneka sajja - noke jIvana caritra prakAzita hote cale jArahe haiM yaha pAzcimAtya logoM ke sahavAsa kA hI phala mAnanA cAhiye / pa OGORS Aja maiM mere paramopakArI pUjyapAda guruvarya zrImanmahArAja zrIkevalacandrajI gaNijIkA saMkSipta meM hI jIvana caritra likhanekA vicAra kiyA hai, isa liye yahAM para kevala AvazyakIya bAtoM kA hI ullekha kiyA jAyagA. yadi samaya milA to dUsarI vAra vistAra pUrvaka likhane kI ceSTA karUMgA. gaNizrI kevalacandrajI mahArAja kA janma vikrama saMvat 1885 ke bhAdrapada kRSNa 10 dazamI guruvAra ke roja zahara gvAliyara meM gauDa vaMzIya brAhmaNa kula meM huA. ApakI mAtu zrI kA nAma suzIlA aura

Page #8
( 2 ) eka 1 pitAjI kA nAma zivAnaMdajI thA / gaNijI ke pitA gvAliyara meM zrImAna megharAjajI surANe ke yahAM nokarI karate the / hamAre caritra nAyaka jaba nava varSa umara ke huve usa samaya zvetAMbara jainAcArya zrImada tArAcaMndra sUrijI mahArAja yatigaNa ke sAtha aneka dezoM meM vicarate huve saM0 1893 meM gvAliyara padhAre usa samaya vahAMke zrAvakoMne nagara pravezakA bar3A bhArI utsava kiyA thA. unake vyAkhyAna hamezA hote the. dina megharAjajI surANene AcAryajI se bInatI kI, ki mere varako ApakI padhArAmaNI karane kI merI icchA hai so Apa avazya padhAra kara merA ghara pAvana kIjiye / zrI jI ne yaha bAta svIkAra kara dUsare hI dina surANejI ke gharako padhAre. surANejI ne AcArya zrI jI kI nava aMga kI kesarAdise pUjana kI aura kaI prakAra se bhakti kI, usa samaya hamAre caritra nAyaka zrI jI ke samIpa jAkara baiThagaye. Apa ke mAtA pitA prabhRtine inako vahAM se uThAne kA bahuta kucha prayatna kiyA kintu AcArya zrI se dUra honA Apane bilakula nahIM svIkAra kiyA. yaha Azcarya janaka dRzya dekhakara Apake mAtA pitAne aura megharAjajI surANe ne AcAryajI se yaha bInatI kI ki, isa bAlakakI bhakti prIti Apa para adhika mAlUma ho rahI hai isase hama logoM kA anta:karaNa yahI kaha rahA hai ki isa bAlakako ApakI sevA meM arpaNa kara denA isa para se zrI jI ne uttama jIva samajha kara hamAre caritra nAyakako apane sAtha upAzrayako le Aye. vi0 saM0 1903 meM AcAryajI ke samIpase Apane dIkSA grahaNa kI. dIkSA kA nAma AjAryajI ne ApakA ' kevalacandra ' muni rakkhA . * noTa -- ina dinoM meM kharatara gacchIya zrI pUjyAcArya zrI jina saubhAgya surijI gvAliyarako padhAre huve the donohI AcArya saharSa paraspara mila aura AnaMdapUrvaka dArzanika viSaya para parAmarza kiyA gayA. bahudhA kharatara aura tapagacchake zrIpUjya " hamabar3e " isa abhimAnake vaza anya gacchIya AcAya se rUbarU meM nahi milApa kiyA karate the kintu yaha bAta zrI saubhAgyarUrIjI meM nahI thI. vaha isa bAtako khUba jAnate the ki eka pada dhArI AcAyoM ke sAtha napharata karanA sarvathA anucita haiM aura eka mekakA paraspara gaurava karanA yaha ziSTAcAra kA paripAlana hai. prastutake AcArya aura yati abhimAna aura kuAcaraNake vaza jo purAnI pratiSTA kho baiThe haiM unako ucita haiM ki, AcArya dvayakA anukaraNa kare, yadi abhI bhI isa ora lakSa nahI diyA jAyagA to rahI sahI pratiSThA bhI gamA baiTeMge. AcArya aura yatiyoMko ucita haiM ki 36 aura 27 guNoMkI tarpha dhyAna de /

Page #9
( 3 ) isa samaya ApakI koI aThAraha varSakI vaya thI, kintu itanI choTI vaya meM bhI Apane jainadarzanake mukhya 2 siddhAMtoMkA uttama prakArase jJAna saMpAdana kara liyA thA. isake sivAya vyAkaraNa, kAvya, koza, nyAya Adi zAstroMkA adhyayana karate the. jyotiSa. vaidyaka, chanda zAstra zAstrIjIke samIpase dekhA karate the. AcArya zrIjIke sAtha grAmAnugrAma vicarane se yadyapi zAstrAdhyayanameM kSati pahuMcatI thI tathApi zAstrI sAtha meM rahanese vizeSa hAnI pahucanekA saMbhava nahIM thA. AcAryajIne koI gyArA varSa paryanta Apako vidyAdhyayana karavAyA aura tadanaMtara pradhAnapadapara niyatakara diye gaye. AcArya jI kA vicAra Apa ko bahuta kucha abhyAsa karavAne kA thA parantu gacchakA bhAra calAneko suyogya pradhAna hAtha nIce na hone ke kAraNa yaha kArya Apake suparata karanA par3A. aura jahAMtaka AcArya zrI vidyamAna rahe tahAMtaka pradhAnapada para ApahI rahe / vi. saM. 1915 mAgha zukla aSTamIke roja AcAryajIkA dehAnta pohokaraNa grAmameM huA usa samaya AcAryajI mahArAjake cAroM ziSya (1 sUryamalajI. 2 mulatAnacandrajI. 3 kevalacandrajI. aura 4 kapUracandrajI.) samIpa the. sUryamalajI mahArAja bhole bhAle aura baDehI sarala manake the va AcAryajI kI sevA inhoMne bhakti pUrvaka khUba kI thI isase AcAryajIne anta samaya aisA pharamAyA ki " merA baDA ziSya sUryamala sarala aura gurU bhakta hai. isase mere pIche isako kisI bhI bAtakI takalIpha naho isa liye merA vidvAna-ziSya-kevalacaMdako Aja maiM isake nAmapara kara detA hUM" Apane bhI gurU bhaktike vaza aura jabase Apa AcAryajIke ziSya huve the tabase saba prakArakA lAlana pAlana, vagairA sUryamala nahIM kiyA isase Apane bhI isa bAtakA svIkAra kara liyA. kintu vAstavameM Apa ziSya AcArya zrIkehI kahalA sakate haiM aura yaha bAta yuktiyukta bhI hai. AcArya zrIkA svargArohaNa kriyA saba jaina zAstrAnusArahI huI. AcArya zrIke paraloka gamanake thor3ehI dina pIche Apane prathama padakA tyAga kara diyA. vi. saM. 1916 vaizAkha zukla akSayatRtiyAko bIkAnerake catuvidha saMghane milakara zrI tArAcandra sUrijIke paTTapara laghu ziSya kapUracaM

Page #10
drajIko sthApita kara diye. aura kesarIsiMhasUri aisA AcArya pada. vIkA nAma de diyA. usa samaya Apane inako AcArya karanemeM apanI sammati bilakulahI nahI dI kintu niSedha kiyA thA kyoMki AcArya honeke lAyaka Apake bar3e gurU bhAI zrI mulatAnacandrajI the yadi mulatAnacandrajIkoM AcArya kara dete to gacchakI zocanIya dazA nahIM hotI. parantu kaI kuTila, vighnasaMtoSI yatizrAvakoMne svArtha sAdhanake liye anucita kArya karaneko nahI Dare, aura prastuta bhI hamAre gacchameM yati nAmako kalaMka lAne vAle kaI adhama yati aise beThe huye haiM ki unake baiThe gacchakI unnatikI AzA rakhanA AkAza puSpavata hai, astu. ayogya kArya banA dekha ApakA vicAra paradeza gamana karanekA huA kintu zrI kesarIsiMha ne Apako jAne nahIM diyA, ina dinoMmeM Apake upadezase eka kArya aisA huA ki jisakI prazaMsA kiye binA sAre jaina samAjase nahIM rahA jA sakA, aura vaha yaha huA ki zrIyut dharmacandajI surANekI dharma panine zatrujayAdi tIrthokI yAtrA karane ko saMgha nikAlanekA nizcaya kiyA. saM. 1917 ke mArgazIrSa badImeM bIkAnerase saMgha ravAnA huA isa saMghame gAr3I 500, UMTha 400, ghor3e 100 aura manuSya saMkhyA karIba 5000 kI thI yati sAdhu sAdhavI keriba so ThANA zrIke sAthameM the, saMgha rakSArtha bIkAnera mahArAjakI orase kaI ghor3esavAra bhI diye gaye the. darzana pUjanake liye eka derAsara sAtha calatA thA. derAsarakI rekha dekha ApahI karate the. saMgha nAgora phalodhI ( pArzvanAtha ) kAparaDA, pAlI, varakANA, nADola, nADolAI, rANapura, mucchAlA mahAvIra, ityAdi paMcatIthI, sirohI, AbUrAja, pAlaNapura, saMkhezvara, rAdhanapura, vaDanagara, basinagara, pATaNa, ( hemacandrA. . cArya ) siddhapura, Adi aneka tIrthoMkI yAtrA karatA huA saMgha zatrujayakI tarATI zahara pAlitANemeM pahuMcA aura saharSa siddhagiri kI yAtrA kI aMdAja eka mAsa paryaMta saMgha pAlitANemeM rahA. tadanaMtara zatrujaya nikaTakI paMcatIrthI-aura gogA-navakhaNDA pArzvanAthajI kI yAtrA karake giranAra parvatakI tarATI zahara junAgar3ha ko saMgha pahuMcAaura revatAcala ( giranAra ) parvata upara car3hakara zrI ariSThanemI bhaga.

Page #11
( 5 ) vAnakI yAtrA kI, vahAMse ahamadAbAda hokara saMgha bIkAnerako lauTa AyA. isa yAtrAmeM lage the. aisA mAsa sumAra ATha gauravazAlI saMgha bIkAnera se Aja paryanta kabhI kisIne nahIM nikAlA. yaha zrImAna kevalacandrajI mahArAjake hI upadezakA phala mAnanA cAhiye. saM0 0 1918 kA cAturmAsa ApakA bIkAnera meM hI huA. tadanaMtara vihAra karake zahara indora padhAre, aura saM0 1919 kA caumAsA indorahImeM huA. indora mahArAja zrImAn holakara sarakAra zrI takujIrAva bar3ehI guNajJa aura sAdhu saMtake premI the, isa se prema pUrvaka hamAre caritra nAyaka se kaIvAra mile. indora sarakArane Apase kaIvAra kahA gAMva jahAMgira athavA dravyAdi jisa bAtakI Apako icchA ho vaha Apake liye taiyAra hai kintu ApakI orase uttara yahI milatA rahA ki badaulata deva guru dharma ke pratApase saba kucha hai. manuSya meM yaha guNa (nilabhatA ) AnA sahaja nahI hai. indorase ravAnA hokara Apa banhAnapura padhAre usasamaya pIracaMdajI koThArIne jJAna dhyAna ke liye ThaharanekI bInati kI isa se Apa eka mahIne taka banhAnapura Thahare vahAMse ravAnA hokara malakApura, khAmagAMva, bAlApura hote huve zirapura antarikSa pArzvanAthajI kI yA trA kara muMbaI purIko padhAre saM0 1920 kA caumAsA ApakA baMbaI me huA. gaNesadAsa kRSNAjIke dukAna ke munIma zrAvaka zrI kevalacaMdrajI surANene bahuta bhakti kI. cAturmAsa samApta hone para Apa punA padhAre aura saM0 1921 kA cAturmAsa ApakA puneme huA. punese Apa khAmagAMva padhAre yahAMkA mAlUma honese jalavAyU acchA cAturmAsa Apane khAmagAMva mehI kiye. yaha sthAna nirupadrava aura ekAMta honeke kAraNa ina dinoM meM Apane varddhamAna Adi jaina vidyAoMkA ArAdhana kiyA. Apake satyazIlAdiguNose barAr3a prAMta ke svaparadharmI saba koI darzanoMke abhilASI the. aura prastuta bhI ApakA nAma prasiddha haiM. saM0 1930 meM Apako AcArya zrI kesarI siMhasUrijI kA poSTa dvArA eka patra milA usame yaha samAcAra the ki "Apa sarIkhe nava

Page #12
vidvAna bhrAtA mereko chor3a dUra rahanese mai bar3AhI duHkhI hUM" ityAdi karuNA janaka samAcAra par3ha Apane zahara bIkAnera jAnA nizcaya kiyA. relave dvArA khaNDavA, jabalapura, prayAga dillI aura khuzakI rAstA bhIyANI, visAu, rAmagar3ha, cUla Adi zaharomeM hote huve bIkAnera padhAre. unhI dinoMmeM AcArya gacchIya upAzrayameM zrI hemacaMdra sUrijIke sabhApatitva bAcaphara meM eka sabhA bharIthI. Apane isa sabhAmeM apane maMtavyakA pUrNa samarthana kiyA, yaha apUrva zakti dekha sabhAsada aura paMDita cakita hogaye. ApakA isa sabhAmeM pUrNa vijaya huA. saM0 1931 se 1948taka aTharA caumAse Apake bIkAneramahI huve. saM 1936 meM lekhakakI mAtuzrIne apane putrako Apa gaNijI mahArAjake arpaNa kara diyA. kintu laghu vaya honese lAlana pAlana karaneke liye mAtozrIne apane samIpa rakkhA aura samvat 1940 meM pIchA soMpa diyA. saM0 1948 ke pauSameM zrAvaka dhUlacaMda gaMbhIramalajIne pAcorA ( banoTI ) se relve kharca ke liye rU0 1 0 0 kA mAniArDara bhejakara vInatIkI ki Apa yahAMpara padhArakara merA ghara pAvana kareM, Apane bInatI mAnya kI aura relve dvArA ziSyoM sahita ravAnA hokara vahAM padhAre. kaI dina taka vahAM Thaharakara khAnadeza barADameM vicarate hue khAmagAMva Aye. bahuta vA~se pIchA khAmagAma AnA huA isase saba logone saMvat 1949 kA cAturmAsa kA utsava bar3I dhUmadhAmase kiyA. saM0 1950 ke ASADha zukla dazamIko Apake hAthase lekhakakI dIkSA huI pacAsa aura ekAvana kA cAturmAsa ApakA khAmagAma mehI huA aura bAvanakA cAturmAsa AkolemeM huA isI varSame Apa ziSyaparivAra sahita zatrujaya giranAra Adi gujarAtake jaina tIrtha karaneko padhAre aura yAtrA karake pIche hI khAmagAMvako loTa Aye tataH pazcAt (trepana se lekara chAchaTa taka 14 cAturmAsa) Ajataka khAmagAMva meMhI huve haiM yadyapi zeSakAlameM Apa vicArate bhI the kintu cAturmAsake dinoMme pIche loTakara khAmagAMva AjAnA ho jAtA hai. chapana kI sAlame kesarIyAnAthajI aura makasIjIkI yAtrA kI 59kI sAla meM do mahInoke liye bIkAnera padhArethe.60kI sAlame sammeda zikharAdi pUrvakI

Page #13
yAtrAkI. Apake upadezase jabalapura ke zrAvakoMne zvetAMbarajaina pAThazAlA sthApita kI aura eka mahIne taka Apako rakkhA. saM0 1963 meM Apane apane laghu ziSyako zahara dhuliyAmeM dakSiA dI. dIkSA mahotsava kA kula kharca zrImAna zrAvaga yogIlAlajI gulAbacaMdajI khivaimarAne kiyA. ina dinoM meM vi. nyA. zrImAn zAMti vijayajI muni mahArAja bhI zahara ghuliyeme the dIkSA kI kula vidhI muni zrI ke AjJAnusArahI kI gaI. pAThaka ? munizrI lekhaka ke vidyAguru hai isa liye Apane anugraha kara dakSiA mahotsava meM sammilita huve. dAkSAkA utsava prazaMsanIya haA zahara dhuliyeke kula zrAvaka-isa utsava meM sAmilathe. ukta utsava ke thoDeDI dinoM ke pazcAta-vedanIya karmodaya se caritranAyaka upAzrayakI siDhIyoMse utarate huve paga cuka jAnese gira par3e, isase Apake DAve pagako bahuta lagI jisase haDDIne sthAna chor3a denese paga suja gayA aura bahuta takalIpha hone lagI. calanA phiranA baMdha ho gayA. aneka DAkTaroM aura vaidyoMke ilAja karanepara vedanA bezaka ArAma ho gaI kintu haDDI phira pichI sthAnapara nahIM AsakI. calanA phiranA jo baMdha ho gayA thA vaha durasta na ho sakA. "vRddhavayake kAraNa lohU kama jora ho jAnese paga zakti nahIM pakar3atA isase* yaha aisIhI haDDI rahegI" bar3e bar3e vidvAna DAkTarokA yaha abhiprAya honase upAya karanA baMdha kara diyA. tIna mAsa ke pazcAt dhUliye se relvedvArA Apako khAmagAMva le Aye. tatapazcAt calanA-phiranA baMdha ho jAneke kAraNa zeSa kAlameM vicaranA baMdhakara diyA. gata varSake cAtumAsameM arthAt saM0 1965 me apane ziSya ke samIpa Akole padhAre Apake prabhAvase Akole meM kaI bAteM acchI huI. isI varSa meM Akoleke zrAvakoMne eka jaina pAThazAlA sthApitakI. thoDedina pazcAt Apa pIche khAmagAMva padhAra gaye prastuta ApakA vicAra khAmagAMvame hI rahanekA hai isa samaya ApakI 1 varSa kI vaya hai. netroMkA teja jaisA kA vaisA banA huvA hai. dAMta saba kAyama haiM. Apako zAstra likhanekA prathamasahI bahuta zauka hai. AjabhI karIba tanisau zloka eka dina meM likha sakate haiM. akSara Apake motiyoMke dAnoMke samAna sundara

Page #14
(8) hai. likhane kA itanA zauka hote bhI Apane Ajataka eka akSara bhI mUlya nahI becA guru rya zrI kevalacaMdrajI gaNi mahArAjake karakamalake likhe huve aneka graMtha hamAre pAsa maujUda haiM. Apako kevala zAstra likhanekAhI nahIM kintu zAstrAvalokana karanekA bhI bar3A zauka hai. Apa janma sehI satya vaktA, dayAvAna, zAMta aura yoga niSTa haiM. yUM to Apane prAyaH sabhI saMskRta graMtha dekhehaiM paraMtu yoga zAstroMko dekhanekA athavA yogAbhyAsa kA bahuta zauka honese Atma dhyAnameM hamezAhI tallIna rahate haiM jina 2 . mahAzayoMne Apake darzana kiye hai ve isa bAtako nisandeha satya samajha sakate hai pAThaka! yaha lekha vicArase adhika bar3ha gayA hai isase yahAM para zrI manmahArAja zrIkevalacaMdrajI gaNijIkI janmakunDalI dekara isako pUrNa karatA huuN| vikrama saMvat 1885 bhAdrapada kRSNada zamI gurau AmA'nakSatraghaTI 56 pala 43 uparAMta punarvasu. iSTaghaTI 58 pala 43 siMha lagna vahamAne janma. rAzI mithuna. gaNizrI kevalacaMdrajIkI janma kuNDalI. 6 rA. zu.za XsU. 5 bu.) .. --------------- aNDalI. caM. 3 9 maM. * yaha janma kuNDalI jyotirmArtaNDa rA0 kRSNa sadAziva bApaTa zAstrIne naSTa jAtakase kI hai| guru bhAkta parAyaNa. mumukSu-bAlacaMdra yati. AkolA (barADa) jaina zvetAMbara maMdira.

Page #15
bhuumikaa| pyAre pAThaka-vRnda ! isa apAra saMsAra ke saMbandha meM kaI manuSyoM kA yaha mantavya hai ki-isa saMsAra kA kartA Izvara avazya hai aura kaI isa bAta ko nahIM mAnate / sRSTi IzvarakRta hai yA anAdi ? isa prazna ke khaNDana maNDana meM kaI saMskRta graMtha bhare par3e haiN| idhara IzvaravAdI apanI ora se yaha haTha pakar3akara baiThe haiM ki vinA kiye koI padArtha hI nahIM banatA, ataeva sRSTi kA kartA Izvara avazya hai aura idhara jaina darzana saMsAra ko anAdi aura akartRjanya spaSTarUpa se siddha kara ke batalA rahA hai / yaha paraspara viruddha koTI hai / aba ina donoM meM se kisakA kahanA satya hai isa ora pakSapAtarahita hokara vicAra kiyA jAya to avazyahI yaha kahanA hogA ki AItadarzana kA kahanA satya hai / kyoM ki jagat ko Izvararacita mAnane se aneka doSApatti AtI hai aura anAdi akartRjanya mAnane se eka bhI doSa nahIM AtA, aura yaha bAta isa grantha meM bhalI bhA~ti dikhAI gaI hai| sRSTi ke utpatti ke saMbaMdha meM koI IzvaravAdI kahatA hai kiH-jagat kA nimitta aura upAdAna kAraNa kevala brahma hI hai, to dUsarA kahatA ki Izvara nimitta kAraNa hai kintu upAdAna kAraNa prakRti hai, to tIsarA kahatA hai ki dRzyAdRzya sabhI padArtha Izvararacita hai, to anya kahatA hai ki Izvara, jova aura prakRti yaha tIna anAdi aura akartRjanya haiN| kaI to jIva ko sAdi sAnta mAnate haiM, aura kaI sAdi ananta pakar3a kara baiThe haiM, isI taraha kaI anAdi sAnta, to kaI anAdi ananta, ityAdi IzvaravAdiyoM meM jagatkartRtva ke viSaya meM paraspara bahuta sA matabheda hai| kintu Izvara, jIva aura prakRti padArtha ko anAdi aura akartRjanya mAnane se saMsAra svataH anAdi aura akartRjanya siddha hocukaa|sNsaar ko anAdi mAnakara phira usakA kartA mAnanA aura kartA mAnakara phira saMsAra ko anAdi kahanA yaha pratyakSa hI meM viruddha dikhAI detA

Page #16
( 2 ) hai| jaina darzana kA kahanA yukti aura pramANa se yukta hone se satya ThaharatA hai aura IzvaravAdiyoM ko bhI idhara udhara ghUma ghumAkara arthAt jagatkA karttA Izvara ko mAnakara bhI anta meM to yaha kahanA hI par3atA hai ki sRSTi anAdi hai|paatthk ! vicAra kareM, IzvaravAdiyoM ko jaina darzana kA kahanA svIkAra karanA par3AyA nahIM? aura jo IzvaravAdiyoM kA yaha kahanA hai ki-"binA kiye koI padArtha nahIM banatA isaliye saMsAra kA racayitA mAnanA avazya hai, kintu isake uttara meM jaba yaha pUchA jAtA hai ki-taba to Izvara kA bhI kartA koI hogA ? to phira kucha bhI yogya uttara nahIM de sakate, tAtparya yukti aura pramANoM se jagat kA karttA Izvara siddha nahIM ho sakatA tathApi hamAre IzvaravAdI mitra pakSapAta ke vaza jo isa bAta kA haTha aura kadAgraha nahIM chor3ate yaha bar3ehI zoka kI bAta hai| IzvaravAdI mahAzayoM kA yaha bhI kahanA hai ki "saba padArthoM kA banAnevAlA maiM IzvarahU~" aisA hamAredharmagranthoM meM Izvara ne kahA hai aura hamAre dharmagrantha IzvarapraNIta hone se zraddhA karane yogya haiM, aisA sabhI IzvaravAdiyoM kA mata hai| jaise ki isAI mahAzaya IzU khiSTa mArga ko hI saccA batalA rahe haiM aura kaha rahe haiM ki bAibala IzvarIya pavitra grantha hai, isase isameM kahI huI hI bAte satya hai aura saba jhUTha hai, hamAre bAibala meM likhA hai ki sabako banAnevAlA eka Izvara hai / idhara musalmAna (yavana) mitra kaha rahe hai ki allAha tAlA ne kurAna zarIpha meM jo faramAyA hai vahI saccA hai aura saba zaitAnI mAmalA hai yAne jhuTha hai hamArA kurAna zarIpha AsmAnI kitAba hai yAne allAha tAlA ne nabI-mahammada sAhaba ke liye AsmAna se bhejI hai aura usameM allAha tAlA ne pharamAyA hai ki 'Ama duniyA ko paidA karane vAlA maiM haiM' mere majahaba kI kitAba ke sAmane insAnoM kI banAI huI dUsarI kitAye usa gharajeM ko nahIM pahu~ca sakatI / isI taraha hamAre AryadezIya baidika mitra bhI kaha rahe haiM ki veda IzvarapraNIta hai| Izvara vaidika RSiyoM dvArA vedoM kA saMsAra meM prakAza karatA hai isase vedavAkya IzvaravAkya hai aura vedaviruddha jitane dharma haiM ve saba anIzvara-praNIta haiM / idhara zAkta arthAt vAmamArgI kaha rahe haiM ki yaha saba zakti kI mAyA hai arthAt saba saMsAra zakti

Page #17
kA racA huA hai isase zakti kA nAma jagajananI hai aura vaha zAkta janmakAle jananI, bhogakAle mAryA aura antakAle kAlikA hai ityAdi IzvaravAdiyoM meM aneka matamatAntara hote bhI 'jagat kA kartA koI bhI hai' isa viSaya meM sabhI kI eka rAya hai| kaI IzvaravAdI to manuSyotpatti saMbandha meM yahAMtaka asaMbhava bAta mAnakara baiThe haiM ki sRSTi ke Adi meM dhAtA amaithunI sRSTi racatA hai, arthAt payArya se bicAra kiyA jAya to isakA artha yaha hotA hai ki Izvara AkAza meM se khar3e khar3e yuvaka manuSya, mRtyu loka meM utAra detA hai ! dekhiye ! yaha unakI buddhi kA vaibhava / kintu isa vAre meM satyAsatya kA vicArakaranA vicArazIla aura satyagrAhI sajana manuSyo kA kAma hai, pakSapAtI jana isakA anta nahIM lA sakate ! kyoM ki prathama to ve anya darzanoM ke dharma graMtha dekhate hI nahIM, yadi daiva yoga se dekhane kA maukA mila bhI jAya to avicAra buddhi se nAstika grantha kahakara apanI TAMga U~cI rakha lete haiM kintu vAstava meM nAstika vahI hai ki jo ekapakSIya dharmagraMtha dekhakara dUsaroM ko nAstika kahane kA sAhasa karatA ho| hamArI samajha se to aneka zAstroM kA avalokana karanevAlA, satyAsatya kA vicAra karanevAlA, aura tattvajJa manuSya prAyaH Astika hI ho sakatA hai / ekapakSIya dharma graMtha dekhakara jinako 'sarvavid' kA abhimAna A jAtA hai unako ucita hai ki:-"anekazAstrANi vilokitAni" isa vAkya kA adhyana kareM / aneka darzanoM ke aura aneka viSayoM ke granthoM kA avalokana karane hI se manuSya yogyatA ko prApta kara sakatA hai aura usIko vidvAnoM kI zreNi meM sthAna mila sakatA hai, isaliye pakSAbhimAna ko tyAgakara aneka graMthoM kA avalokana karanAhI buddhimAnoM kA karttavya hai| kintu jinake vicAra cirakAla se arthAt pIr3hiyoM se sthira ho rahe haiM aura saMskAra bhI nirantara vaisehI mila rahe haiM; ki bahunA, ve apane mantavya ke viruddha eka varNa ( akSara) bhI zravaNa karanA pApa samajha rahe hai| aise avicArI, anya darzanoM ke granthoM ko kaise par3ha sakate haiM ? to vicArakaranA to dUrahIrahA kintu aise haThI loga avicAra buddhi se dekhe bhAle vinAhI nAstika grantha kaha diyA karate haiM, parantu isa bAta meM ve loka bar3I bhArI bhUla

Page #18
karate haiM / hA! yadi kisI bhI grantha ko acchI taraha samagra par3hakara pazcAt niSpakSapAta buddhi se samAlocanA kI jAya, to bhI zreya hai parantu vinA par3he athavA vinA vicAra kiye kisI bhI viSayapara apanA abhiprAya dedenA yaha buddhimAnoM kA kAma nahIM hai| par3ha aura bicArakara ke jo kisI grantha kI samAlocanA kI jAya aura usameM koI vidvAn bhUla bhI batalAve to koI harja kI bAta nahIM hai, kyoMki " gacchataH skhalanaM na doSAya " isa nyAya se nirdoSIhI kahA jA sakatA hai| parantu itanI bAta hama avazya kaha sakate haiM ki-cAhe kisI bhI graMtha ko par3hakara aura usa sambandha meM vicAra karane ke bAda AlocanA kI jAya to vizeSatayA bhUla hone kA saMbhava nahIM raha sktaa| isa nibaMdha meM veda aura brAhmaNoM kI RcAoM (maMtro) ke dvArA bhI yaha batalA diyA gayA hai ki sRSTi kA kartA Izvara siddha nahIM ho sktaa| parantu sAtha meM yaha kaha denA bhI anAvazyaka na hogA ki una mantroM ke arthabadalane meM athavA aprAmANika ThaharAne meM haThI aura durAgrahI kamI nahIM kareMge ! kintu cAhe haThI durAgrahI na mAne tathApi vicArazIla manuSya isa grantha se kucha lAbha uThAvege aisA merA vizvAsa hai| prastuta bhArata varSa meM Arya (hindU) logoM meM se veda vedAGga (zruti-smRti, brAhmaNa upaniSad purANa ityAdi ) zAstroM ko pramANa mAnane vAloM kI prAyaH gaNanA vaidika dharma meM hI ho sakatI hai aura veda ke netA vaidika brAhmaNa haiM / yadyapi kaI vaidika vidvAna satyagrAhI aura niSpakSapAtI bhI haiM aura unhoMne jainadarzana ke saMbaMdha meM apane vicAra prakaTa bhI kiye haiM kintu bahudhA vaidika, haThI pakSapAtI aura jaina darzana ke virodhI huA karate haiM, yadi koI satyagrAhI vaidika sAkSara anya darzanoM ke dharmagraMtha dekhakara kucha prazaMsA kare athavA vedoM ke saMbaMdha meM apane kucha svatantra vicAra dikhAve to usapara anya vaidika kaTAkSa kiye vinA kabhI nahIM raha skte|itnaahii nahIM, kintu 1 isa nibandha meM jahAM para vaidika aisA likhA ho vahAM para sarvatra ukta graMthoM ko mAnane vAloM ke saMbaMdha meM samajha lenA cAhiye / kyoMki vedoM kA Azraya lekara calane vAle jitane mata haiM unako vaidika kahanA koI gaira nahIM haiN|

Page #19
yahAMtaka Andolana macA dete haiM ki 'yaha paNDita nAstika bana gayA ityAdi saba kucha kahate haiM / hamako smaraNa hai ki kAzIpurI ke prasiddha vaidika vidvAn zrIrAmamizrazAstrI jI ne jisa samaya apanI vaktRtA meM jaina darzana ke saMbaMdha meM apane ucca vicAra prakaTa kiye the (usa vyAkhyAna kA sArAMza isa nibaMdha meM de bhI diyA hai ) usa samaya kAzI ke kaI vaidika, zAstrI jI para nArAja hue the aura kaiyoM ne zAstrI jI se yaha bhI kahA thA ki Apa sarIkhe vidvAn ne jaina darzana ko ucca zreNI kA darzana kahA, yadi yaha bAta satya bhI ho to Apa ko prazaMsA nahIM karanI cAhiye parantu zAstrI jI satya vaktA hone se una ko yaha uttara diyA ki jo mujhe satya mAlUma huA vahI maiMne kahA hai| kheda ke sAtha likhanA par3atA hai ki zAstrI jI ke paraloka vAsa se jaina samAja ko bar3I hAni uThAnI par3I hai| jisa samaya lo. tilaka mahodaya ne jaina darzana ke saMbaMdha meM apane ucca vicAra prakaTa kiye the (usakA sArAMza isa graMtha meM de bhI diyA hai) usa samaya mahArASTradezIya eka do brAhmaNa tilaka para bhI kaTAkSa kiye vinA nahIM raha sake / hAla meM thor3e hI dinoM kI bAta hai ki ilAhAbAda (prayAga) kI sarasvatI nAma kI mAsika patrikA meM veda vikhyAta jI kI ora se 'veda' zIrSaka, eka lekha nikalA thA, usameM Apane vedoM ke saMbandha meM taTastharItyA apane vicAra prakaTa kiye the ( ukta lekha kA bahuta kucha sArAMza isa nibaMdha meM de bhI diyA hai) kintu ukta lekha prakAzita hote hI kaI vaidika mahAzaya vedavikhyAta jI para TUTa par3e, aura vartamAna samAcAra patroM dvArA manamAne zabdoM meM TIkA karane laga gaye / pAThakagaNa ! IzvaravAdI kaise pakSapAtI hote haiM yaha Apa uparyukta udAharaNoM se spaSTa samajha sakate haiN| ___yaha nibaMdha maiMne kisI ke bhI manaH kaluSita karane ko athavA kisI kI nindA karane ko nahIM likhA hai kintu jagat kisI kA racA huA hai yA anAdi ? aura isa vAre meM jaina darzana kA kyA abhiprAya hai yaha saMskRta ko na jAnanevAle hindI bhASA ke premiyoM ko dikhAne ke hetu se likhA hai aura AzA bhI hai ki hindI par3hanevAle avazya isase kucha lAbha utthaavege| prastuta meM kaI jainI kahalAkara bhI anya dharmiyoM ke gADha saha

Page #20
vAsa se yahAM taka nahIM jAnate haiM ki jaina darzana kA kyA siddhAnta hai? kevala itanA jAnate haiM ki hama jainI haiM aura kaI yaha bhI jAnate haiM ki hama tIrthakara vItarAga ke upAsaka hai| isake sivA jaina dharma ke tattvoM ko athavA vaijJAnika jaina sAhitya ko jAnane vAle bahuta hI kama haiN| isase pracalita bhASAoM meM jainadharma ke zuddha tattvoM ko batalAnevAle graMtha jitane adhika vidvAn dvArA likhe jAya~ aura chapakara prakAzita ho utanA adhika zreya hai aura isI hetu se maiMne bhI yaha graMtha likhA hai| ___ isa graMtha meM veda, brAhmaNa, smRti, upaniSad aura purANa Adi graMthoM ke aura aura bhI aneka graMthoM ke pramANa prasaMgAnusAra diye gaye haiM aura zrI zaMkarAcArya svAmI ke brahmAdvaita ke vAre meM bhI parAmarza kiyA gayA hai isaliye isa graMtha ko niSpakSapAta buddhi se par3hanevAle anya darzanI bhI lAbha uThA sakate haiM / . isa viSaya para eka nibandha likhane kA merA vicAra bahuta dinoM se thA parantu zArIraka aura mAnasika ApattiyoM ke kAraNa kaI dina taka yaha kArya nahIM kara sakA / kintu gata varSa meM saba prakAra kI zAMti milane se yaha kArya banane kA maukA milA yadyapi jaisA cAhiye vaisA to nahIM banA hai kyoMki yaha pAramArzika viSaya hai aura dUsarA kAraNa yaha bhI hai ki kisI eka viSaya para jaba taka aneka vidvAnoM kI lekhanI na cale taba taka vaha viSaya pUrNAMga rUpa se spaSTa nahIM ho sakatA yaha svAbhAvika niyama hai aura isa viSaya para jaisI cAhiye vaisI lekhanI vidvAnoM ne nahIM calAI aisA mAlUma hotA hai isase saMskRta graMthoM ke pUrNa vicAra pracalita bhASA meM nahIM Aye isase isameM kitanI bAto kI truTiyAM raha gaI bhI hogI kintu aba bhI koI jaina vidvAn , yati, muni isa viSayapara eka uttama graMtha likhe to bahuta hI acchI bAta hai| kisI vidvAn ko merI bhUla cUka huI mAlUma ho to mujhe avazya sUcanA karai yadi vaha sUcanA satya mAlUma hogI to upakAra mAnA jAyagA aura dvitIyAvRtti meM avazya sudhAra diyA. jaaygaa| kAzI kI yazovijayajI jaina pAThazAlA aura granthamAlA ke utpAdaka, zAstravizArada jainAcArya zrImAn vijayadharmasUrI jI mahArAja ke mukhya ziSya munimahArAja zrImAn indravijayajI ne isa

Page #21
( 7 ) grantha meM mujhe aneka prakAra kI sahAyatA dI hai isase maiM Apa kA RNI hU~, Apa ArSa jainagranthoM ke saMzodhana meM satata prayatna kara rahe haiM aura ApakI kRpA se yazovijaya jI jaina granthamAlA ke daza bAraha grantha pAThazAlA kI orase chapakara prakAzita bhI ho cuke haiM aura kaI granthoM kA kArya zurU hai isase Apa samagra jaina samAja ke koTizaH dhanyavAda ke pAtra haiM ! pAThaka mahAzaya ! aba yaha lekha bar3ha gayA hai isase mere upakArI zAnadAtA guruvarya zrImAn kevalacaMdra jI gaNI mahArAja ke smaraNa pUrvaka yaha lekha yahAM hI pUrNa karatA hU~ / granthakarttA

Page #22

Page #23
vande vIram / - jagatkartRtvamImAMsA - kartA'sti kazcijjagataH sa caikaH sa sarvagaH sa svavazaH sa nityaH // imAH kuhevAkaviDambanAH syusteSAM na yeSAmanuzAsakastvam // 1 // ( zrImAn hemacandrAcAryaH ) isa saMsAra meM pracalita aneka mata matAntara hamAre dRSTigata hote haiM aura sabahI dharmAvalambI prAyaH yahI siddha karane meM tatpara hote haiM ki "prAcIna dharma hamArA hI hai aura hamArA hI dharma sanAtana se calA AtA hai tathA hamAre dharma ke atirikta anya matamatAntaroM ke tattva yuktivikala haiM arthAt anya matoM kI sthApanA hama se bahuta hI pIche huI hai ataeva hamAre dharma kI spardhA anya koI bhI dharma nahIM kara saktA" aisA abhimAna aneka vidvAnoM ke hRdaya meM bharA huA dikhAI detA hai yadi ve niSpakSapAta buddhi se apane mana meM vicAra kareMge to pUrvokta vyartha haTha unake hRdaya meM nahIM Thahara sakegA / 1 jisa manuSya ne pUrvapakSa dekhA ho aura uttarapakSa na dekhA ho athavA uttarapakSa dekhA ho aura pUrvapakSa na dekhA ho to vaha manuSya sarvapakSasampanna nahIM kahA jA saktA aura sacchAstravettAoM kI sabhA meM AdaraNIya nahIM ho saktA ; isa samaya prAyaH durvidagdha manuSya vizeSa dikhalAI par3ate haiM aura ve apanI durvidagdhatA dikhAte hue haThAt 1 jagat kA kartA koI hai, vaha eka, sarvavyApI, svatantra, nitya hai aisI durAgraharUpI viDambanAe~ unhIM ko hotI haiM jinakA prabhu ! tU anuzAsaka nahIM hai|

Page #24
navIna mata athavA kapolakalpitamatoM ko prakaTa karake aneka mugdhajanoM ko apane mAyAjAla meM phasAkara rasAtala ke bhAgI banA dete haiM phira ukta mugdhoM ko unake jAla se mukta honA atyanta kaThina ho jAtA hai| hamako anyamatAvalambiyoM se bAdAnuvAdaM (dharmacarcA) karane para yahI pratIta huA ki apane haTha kA tyAga karanA kisI ko acchA mAlUma nahIM hotaa| bar3e hI kheda kI bAta hai ki jaba vidvAnagaNa satya kA parityAgakara kevala haThapUrvaka apane mantavya hI ko siddha karanA cAhate haiM to ukta vidvAnoM kI gaNanA kisa varga meM ho saktI hai yaha pAThaka svayaM vicAra leN| __ satya grahaNa va asatya kA parityAga karo ! isa prakAra saba hI dharmAvalambI kahate haiM aura sabhA samAjoM meM apane lambe 2 vyAkhyAnoM ko sunAkara apane mana kI Aha (jvAlA) nikAlate haiM kintu satya kisa cir3iyA kA nAma hai isakA nirNaya kie vinA hI nirarthaka pralApa karanA ThIka nahIM, jaba taka manuSya pakSapAta kA cazmA dUra nahIM karegA taba taka vaha samyakdraSTA nahIM kahA jA sktaa| vANI aura artha kA sambandha atyanta mahatva kA hai bahudhA vidvAn loga bhI apane vicAroM ko asaMbaddhatA aura aspaSTatA karake zabdADaMbara dvArA AcchAdana karane kA prayatna kiyA karate haiM aura jaisI kalpanA mana meM utpanna huI mukhadvArA va lekhinIdvArA prakAzita hue zabda bhI vaise hI nikalate haiM cAhe saMdigdha hoM athavA asaMdigdha / sAmAnya niyama aisA hai ki jo vicAra manogata hote haiM vahI zabdoM meM bhI A jAte haiM apane manogata vicAra va mukhadvArA nirgata honevAle udgAra ina donoM ke bIca meM nitya sambandha ho yA anitya ho parantu yaha bAta satya hai ki jo vicAra Adhe yA aspaSTa hote haiM unake dyotaka zabda bhI vaise hI hote haiM isake atirikta yaha bhI satya anumAna hai ki jisake bhASaNa meM arthAt vAgvilAsa meM saMdigdhatA hotI hai usake vicAroM meM bhI avazya saMdigdhatA hotI hai aneka vAra aisA banAva banatA hai ki eka vA do zabda yA vAkya kisI ne eka sthala para par3he kiMvA prasaMga

Page #25
vaza sune, ve kisI kAraNa usake zIghra hI mana meM bhara jAte haiM kintu unake tAtparyArtha ke pUrNa jJAna na hone se una zabdoM kA rUr3ha artha kisa viSaya para hai aura AnuSaGgika artha kisa para hai arthAt kaunasA artha kisa sthAna para ucita hai yaha na samajhakara kevala AnuSaGgika artha para dhyAna dene se usakI buddhi meM avazya hI bhrama ho jAtA hai aura bhrama ke hone se vicAroM meM bhI doSa Ane kA saMbhava hai aura ukta doSa ke kAraNa na to vicAroM kI saMdigdhatA dUra hotI hai aura na ve zuddha vicAroM ko prakaTa kara sakte haiN| jo mahAzaya svataH pUrNatayA nahIM samajha sakte to ve dUsaroM ko kisa prakAra samajhA sakte haiM, kadApi nahIM, kadApi nahIM ! katipaya mahAzaya bhasmAvacchana vaktRtA (vyAkhyAna) dekara yA lekha likhakara apanI vAkcAturI se alpajJa logoM ke sAmane vidvAn banane kA dAvA karate haiM parantu pUrNa satyazodhaka vidvAnoM ke sAmane unakI vAkcAturI nahIM cala saktI kyoMki jo vidvAn hote haiM ve jAna jAte haiM ki yaha kaise vyAkhyAtA vA lekhaka haiM; kisI zAstrakAra kA kathana hai ki "nAstiko'pi varaM zatrurbhasmAchanno na jaiminiH" tAtparya yaha ki jo loga asaMdigdha va spaSTa bhASaNAdi kara sakte haiM ve samyakrItyA samajhA sakte haiM kintu jinake samajhane meM hI bhUla ho ve bolane meM athavA likhane meM bhUla kareM to isameM Azcarya hI kyA hai| jagata kA kartA Izvara hai arthAt sRSTi Izvara kI racI huI hai isa bAta ko svIkAra karane vAle vedamatAnuyAyI, naiyAyika, vaizeSika, zAkta, zaiva, vaiSNava, musalamAna va IsAI Adi matavAloM kI vAkviDaMbanA bar3I hI Azcarya-janaka hai ukta matavAloM ne saMdigdha zabdoM meM jaganiyantA Izvara ke siddha karane kA pUrNatayA sAhasa kiyA hai kintu unake vicAra yuktisaMgata kadApi nahIM ho sakte / dekhie unake vedoM meM bhI sRSTiracanA ke lie eka mata nahIM hai nimna likhitaM maitroM se Apa ko vidita ho jAyagA ki inake zAstroM meM kitanA pUrvApara virodha hai|

Page #26
devAnAM nu vayaM jAnA pra vocAma vipnyyaa| uktheSu zasyamAneSu yaH pazyAduttare yuge // 1 // brahmaNaspatiretAsaM kAra ibAdhamat / devAnAM pUrve yuge'sataH sadajAyata // 2 // devAnAM yuge prathame'sataH sadajAyata // tadAzA anvajAyanta taduttAmapadaspari // 3 // bhUrjajJa uttAnapado bhuva AzA ajAyanta // aditerdakSo ajAyata dakSAdvaditiH pari // 4 // aditijiniSTa dakSa yA duhitA tava // tAM devA anvajAyanta bhadrA amRtavandhavaH // 5 // RgvedasaMhitA maM0 10 / sU0 72 bhAvArtha-brahmaNaspati kAra ke anusAra devatAoM ke janma ko karatA huA, devatAoM ke pUrva yuga meM asat se sat huA aura sat se dizA aura tadanantara uttAnapada huA aura usase pRthvI, punaH usa pRthvI se dizA (AzA) huI aura aditi se dakSa huA aura dakSa se aditi huI hai| he dakSa ! terI duhitA aditi kA janma huA tadanaMtara stutya (stuti karane ke yogya) va amara aise devoM kA janma huA dekhie Age ke maMtroM meM kaisA varNana hai:RtaM ca satyaM cAbhIdvAttapaso'dhyajAyata / tatorAtryajAyata tataH samudro arNavaH // 1 // samudrAdarNavAdadhi saMvatsaro ajAyata / ..ahorAtrANi vidadhadvizvasya miSatovazI // 2 // 1 isa artha ko hamane apanI ora se na karake sAyaNabhASyAnusAra hI kiyA hai|

Page #27
( 5 ) sUryAcandramasau dhAtA yathApUrvamakalpayat / divaM ca pRthivIM cAntarikSamatho svaH // 3 // RgvedasaMhitA 10 | 191 bhAvArtha- tapa se satya aura satya se anantara rAtri huI tadanantara samudra va pazcAt usake saMvatsara, ahorAtra yathAkrama utpanna hote bhae ; dhAtA ne sUrya caMdramA ko yathApUrva kalpanA kie aura AkAza, pRthvI, aMtarikSa Adi kI kalpanA kI; arthAt race / pUvokta maMtra Rgveda ke atirikta anya vedoM meM bhI haiN| aba taittirIya brAhmaNa meM kisa prakAra kA lekha hai so dekhie:Apo vA idamaMgre salilamAsIt / tena prajApatirazrAmyat / kathamidaM syAditi // so'pazyatpuSkaraparNe tiSThat / so'manyata / asti vaitat / yasminnidamadhitiSThatIti // sa barAha rUpaM kRtvApanyamajjat / sa pRthivImadha Arcchat / tasyA upahatyodamajjat // tatpuSkaraparNe'prathayat / yadaprathayat / tatpRthivyai pRthivitvam // 1 // taittirIyabrAhmaNa aSTa0 1 / a0 1 / a0 3 bhAvArtha - prathama jala thA usake Upara pRthvI utpanna huI ityAdi varNana hai ukta varNana ke anusAra (kintu kucha antara vAlA) varNana taittirIyasaMhitA meM hai: dekhie - Apo vA idamane salilamAsIt / tasminprajApativayurbhUtvA'caratsa imAmapazyattAM varAho bhUtvA'haratAM

Page #28
vizvakarmA bhUtvA vyamAI sA'prathata sA pRthivyabhavat tatpRthivyai pRthivitvam / / __ taittirIyasaMhitA aSTa0 7 / 1 / 5 ukta maMtra meM jala ke pIche vAyu aura tadanantara pRthvI kA utpanna honA ityAdi krama bheda likhA hai aba upaniSadoM meM sRSTikrama jo diyA hai usakA bhI thor3A sA avalokana kara lIjie tasmAdvA etasmAdAtmana AkAzaH sNbhuutH|aakaashaadvaayuH / vAyoragniH / agnerApaH / ayaH pRthivI / pRthivyA ossdhyH| oSadhIbhyo'nnam / annaatpurussH| . taittirIyopaniSad vallI 2 anu0 1 bhAvArtha-usa AtmA se AkAza aura usase vAyu, tadanantara agni, jala, pRthvI, oSadhI, anna, puruSa isa krama se eka se eka utpanna hue aise hI anya bahuta se graMthoM meM sRSTikrama aneka rIti se likhA hai parantu ukta sarva matoM ke viruddha va unase vicitra varNana taittirIyabrAjhaNa meM eka sthala para likhA hai usako bhI dekha lIjienAsadAsIno sadAsIttadAnIm / nAsIdrajo no vyomA paro yat / kimA varIvaH kuhakasya zarman / ambhaH kimAsIdgahanaM gbhiirm| na mRtyuramRtaM tarhi n|raatriyaa ahna aasiitprketH| AnIdavAtaM svadhayA tadekaM / tasmAddhAnyaM na paraH kiMcanAsa |tm AsIttamasA gUDhamagre prketN| salilaM sarvamA idN| tucchenAbhvapihitaM yadAsIta / tamasastanmahinA jAyataikaM / kAmastadane samavarttatAdhi / manaso retaH prathamaM yadAsIt /

Page #29
( 7 ) sato bandhumasati niravindan / hRdi pratISyA kavayo manISA / tirazcIno vitato razmireSAM / adhasvidAsI3 dupari svidAsI3t / retodhA Asan mahimAna Asan / svadhA avastAtprayatiH parastAt // 1 taittirIya brAhmaNa kA0 2 / pra0 8 / a0 9 ukta vAkyoM meM pUrva sRSTi kA pralaya hokara uttara sRSTi utpanna hone ke prathama sat, asat, AkAza, jala, mRtyu, amRta, rAtri, dina, sUrya, candra ityAdi kucha bhI nahIM the kevala brahma mAtra hI thA usakI sRSTi utpanna karane kI icchA huI aura phira saba jagata utpanna huA ityAdi. varNana kara ke punaH Age nimna likhita varNana hai | ko addhA veda ka iha pravocat / kuta AjAtA kuta iyaM visRSTiH / arvAgdevA asya visarjanAya / athA ko veda yata A babhUva / iyaM visRSTiryata A babhUva / 1 yadi vA dadhe yadi vA na / yo asyAdhyakSaH parame vyoman / so aGga veda yadi vA na veda / kiMsvidvanaM ka u sa vRkSa AsIt / yato dyAvApRthivI niSTatakSuH // taittirIya brAhmaNa kA 0 2 / pra0 8 / a0 9 ukta maMtra vAjasaneyasaMhitA ke adhyAya 17 kA 32vAM hai evaM RgvedasaMhitA ke a0 10 / 129vAM hai / bhAvArtha isa maMtra kA yaha hai ki yaha vividha sRSTi kisa se va kisalie utpanna huI yaha vAstava meM kauna jAnatA hai ? vA kauna kahane ko samartha hai ? devatA bhI pIche se hue phira jisase yaha sRSTi utpanna huI isa bAta ko kauna jAnatA hai ? jisase dyAvA, pRthvI huI vaha vRkSa kauna sA va vaha kisa bana meM thA yaha kauna jAnatA hai ? ina sabhoM kA adhyakSa paramAkAza meM hai vahI

Page #30
( 8 ) jAnatA hai kiMvA vaha bhI nahIM jAnatA yaha kise mAlUma ! jagadutpatti kA kAraNa jAnane vAlA koI bhI nahIM, aura utpatti krama bhI pratyakSa kisI ko mAlUma nahIM, aisA abhiprAya pUrvokta maMtra meM hai| Rgveda meM eka jagaha para jo maMtra likhA hai usa kA bhI avalokana karalIjie:- tisro dyAvaH saviturdA upasthA~ ekA yamasya bhuvane - virASAT / aur-rthymmRtaadhitsthuH|| RgvedasaMhitA 1-35-6 bhAvArtha-"dyuloka tIna, tinameM se do savityA ke udarameM aura eka yama ke bhuvana meM hai / caMdra tArAdi-amara usake Upara baiThe hue haiM" aisA kaha kara Age usI RcA meM RSi kaha rahA hai ki . iha bravItu ya u tacciketat / - bhAvArtha-yaha sava jisane jAna liyA ho aisA koI ho to use yahAM para Ake kahane do, sArAMza yaha ki pratyakSa jAnanevAlA (jagadutpatti kA) koI bhI nahIM hai aisA isa RcA meM RSi kA mata hai Apa loga ina veda maMtroM se bhalI bhA~ti jAna liye hoMge ki vedoM meM sRSTikrama meM pUrvApara kitanA virodha hai aura kaI RSiyoM kA mata to aisA bhI dikhAI de rahA hai ki sRSTi kisI kI bhI racI huI nahIM hai phira vedamatAnuyAyI kisa sAhasa para sRSTi IzvarakRta mAnate haiM yaha mAlUma nahIM hotA, jo loga vedoM ko anAdi va apauruSeya mAnate haiM unhIM vedoM meM aisA pUrvApara virodha bharA huA hai phira batalAiye ? kauna vedoM kI bAta para vizvAsa rakkhegA ? eka sthAna para to kahadiyA ki asat se sat huA aura sata se dizA huI ityAdi va dUsare sthala para kahadiyA ki tapa se satya ityAdi phira eka jagaha para kaha diyA ki prathama jala thA usa ke Upara pRthvI huI aura phira anya sthala para likha diyA ki jala ke pIche vAyu va tadanaMtara pRthvI phira eka jagaha aisA bhI likha diyA ki usa AtmA se AkAza va usa se vAyu tadanaMtara agni, jala,

Page #31
( 9 ) pRthvI ityAdi, aura phira dUsaroM kI tarkatApa se bacane ke lie aisA bhI likha diyA ki pratyakSa meM sRSTi kI utpatti jAnanevAlA va kahanevAlA koI bhI nahIM hai. aura sRSTi kisakI racI huI hai yaha bhI kise mAlUma ? dekhie jinako saMzaya zatru ne paga paga para gherA hai unake vicAroM ko kauna svIkAra karegA ! sRSTi ke kartA ko mAnane vAloM kA kahanA hai ki-carAcara jagat kA nirmANa aura saMhAra arthAt utpatti aura vinAza, Izvara svataH apanI acintya zakti ke mAhAtmya se karatA hai, yadi kevala sRSTi racAhI kare to asaMkhya prANigaNa tribhuvana meM bhI na Thahara sakeM arthAt kahIM sthAnahI na mile isaliye sAtha hI sAtha saMhAra bhI karanA par3atA hai / pRthvI, parvata, sudhAkara, dinakara, mahAsAgarAdi jo jo vastu haiM ve saMpUrNa kisI buddhimAna kI racita avazya haiN| jaise ghaTa, paTa; kumbhakAra, sUtrakAra ke race hue haiM vaise pRthvI parvatAdika ke liye bhI racayitA honA Avazyaka hai| aisA vibhu, nitya, eka, sarvajJa, sarvavyApI, paramezvara ke vinA anya dUsarA koI bhI nahIM hai, isa saMsAra meM prANimAtra jo calanAdi vyavasAya karate haiM vaha sarvazaktimAna Izvara kI acintya zakti ke prabhAva se karate haiM, aisA, sRSTi IzvarakRta mAnane vAloM kA kahanA hai, isa bAta ko jainadharma asvIkAra karatA hai, aura bauddha va prAcIna sAMkhya jo isa bAta ko asvIkAra karate haiM to prAyaH inhoMne jainadharma kA anukaraNa kiyA ho aisA hamArA mata hai kyoMki jainadharma bahuta prAcIna hai aura isa dharma ke tattva vizvAsa karane yogya haiM, yaha kahanA hamArA pakSapAta yA haTha se nahIM, kintu satyatApUrvaka hai aura satyadarzI janoM ko bhI svIkAra karanA hI hogA ki prAcIna se prAcIna jo saMsAra meM dharma hai to jainadharma hI hai jisakI Adya vyavasthA kisI bhI itihAsakAra ne yuktiyukta varNana nahIM kI yadi eka Adhe ne dveSabuddhi se kahIM likha bhI diyA ho to isase prAcInatA naSTa nahIM ho saktI / kaI vidvAnoM kI aisI bhI samajha hai ki bauddha va vaidika mata bahuta prAcIna hai| paraMtu jainadharma inase bhI prAcIna dharma hai kyoMki bauddhazAstroM meM aura vaidikazAstroM meM jainadharma viSayaka khaNDana-maNDanAdi

Page #32
rASTigata hote haiM dekhie bauddha pIThikA meM likhA hai ki "niggandhanAtha puSa aura amgI vaizAyana gotra kA sudharmA apane pake zatru haiM" ipara vedavyAsa jI ke racita dhyAsa sUtra meM "naikasimasaMbhavAt" (padA0 sU0 2 / 2 / 33) isa sUtra para zaGkarAcArya kA racita bhASya hai, usameM unhoMne jainoM kI syAdvAda-saptamajI kA khaNDana karane kA sAhasa kiyA hai / ityAdi pramANoM se kaha sakte haiM ki bauda se aura vaidika dharma se jainadharma prAcIna hai yadi usa samaya jaina dharma nahIM hotA to bauddhoM ke zAstroM meM aura vaidika zAstroM meM khaNDana maNDana kahAM se ho saktA? ataH isa viSaya meM pUrvokta pramANa paryApta hai aura jainoM kA jo yaha kahanA hai ki sRSTi kisI kI bhI racita nahIM hai yahI bAta bahuta ThIka mAlUma hotI hai. ! ___ sRSTi ko Izvaracita mAnane se aneka doSa Ate haiM aura anAdi mAnane se eka bhI doSa nahIM AtA isa bAta ko isa prantha meM acche prakAra se dikhAyA jAyagA, pAThaka dhyAna pUrvaka pddh'eN| jagatkartA mAnanevAloM kA kathana hai ki "sRSTi Izvara ne nirmANa kI hai vaha videha Izvara sarvazaktimAna hai aura veda usI paramAtmA ke race hue haiM" isake pratyuttara meM vidita ho ki videha Izvara deha ke vinA svRSTi kaise raca sakA? arthAt kAraNa vinA kArya nahIM hotA, phira batalAnA hogA ki usa videha Izvara ko sRSTi racane se kyA prayojana thA? videha Izvara ke liye jagat ke racanA karane meM pravRtti anucita va asaMbhava hai, yadi kahA jAya ki aizvarIya mAyA se jagata utpanna huA hai to vaha mAyA Izvara se bhinna hai yA abhinna ? aura vaha jaganniyantA prabhu bhI khatantra hai yAparatantra? yadi svatantra kahoge to jagatmAyA se utpanna huA hai yaha kahanA jhUThA hogA, aura paratantra kahoge to vibhu sarvazaktimAnpanA kahAM rahA, vaha to paratantra ThaharA ? yadi yaha kahoge ki Izvara ne kautuka meM Ake khela kiyA hai to isa se ApakA sarvazaktimAna Izvara rAjakumArabat rAgavAn siddha hotA hai aura jahAM rAga hai

Page #33
vahAM dveSa bhI hai isase ApakA Izvara; rAgI, dveSI kahA jAyagA aura rAga, dveSa honA Izvara ke lie dUSaNa hai ataeva usa Izvara ko koI bhI buddhimAna nahIM kaha saktA, yadi kahoge ki kRpA se sRSTi nirmANa kI hai to saMpUrNa jIva jantuoM ko sukhI banAnA thA ? saMsAra meM duHkha, durgati, daridratA; sUkara, mArjArAdika duSTa yoni, janma, maraNa, jarA, kleza ityAdi aneka prakAra ke duHkhoM se pIr3ita asaMkhyAta prANigaNa dikhAI dete haiM batalAiye ! Apa ke kRpAlu Izvara ne jIvoM ko duHkhI kyoM racA ? isase Apa ke jagatkartA Izvara ko kRpAlu kahanA nitAnta asatya hai yadi Apa aisA kahoge ki jisa jIva ke jaise zubhAzubha karma the tadanusAra verace gaye to isa kathana se Apa ke jaganniyantA kI svatantratA naSTa ho cukI kyoMki jaise hama tuma karmAdhIna kArya karate haiM taise Izvara bhI karmavasa huaa| to aba kahiye Izvara ne karma vinA svataH kyA racA? yadi jaisA karma jisakA thA taisA usane raca diyA kahoge to Apa logoM kA jo yaha kahanA hai ki "saMpUrNa kArya IzvarAdhIna hI hote haiM" isa jagaha para karmAdhIna hote haiM yaha kahanA hogA / tAtparya yaha hai ki IzvarAdhIna kucha bhI nahIM hai aura Izvara ko bhI karmAdhInahI mAnanA pdd'egaa| aura sukha duHkhAdi tathA jagat kI vicitratA karmajanya hai to phira Apa ke vizvakarmA zikhaMDI ne kyA vizva kI racanA kI ! yadi Apa kahoge ki usakI racanA samajha meM nahIM AsaktI hai to kyA Apane vinAhI samajhe vizvakA mAna liyA ? aura jo Apa ke zAstroM meM sRSTi nirmANa ke liye jitanA likhA gayA hai vaha vinA samajhe hI likhA gayA hai ? vedoM me sRSTiracanA kA krama jo hai vaha hama prathama likha hI cuke haiM aura una maMtroM se siddha hotA hai ki veda IyaramaNIta nahIM haiM aura na vedoM meM sRSTi ke liye eka mata hai, dhanya hai Apa kI mAnyatA ko! ____ yadi thor3I dera ke liye aisA mAna liyA jAya ki jagat kAkartA Izvara hai to prathama yaha prazna utpanna hotA hai ki Izvara dehayArI hai yA adeha dhArI ? yadi kahA jAya ki dehadhArI hai, to dehavArI ke puNya pApa bhI honA saMbhava hai kyoMki puNya pApa vinA zarIra (pudgala) nahIM banatA, yadi

Page #34
( 12 ) kahA jAya ki Izvara deharahita hai to zArIraka avayava (hAtha-pAva-mukhanAsikA-karaNa-netrAdi) vinA kisI prakAra kI bhI racanA bana nahIM sktii| jo loga kahate haiM ki "jaise kumbhakAra ne ghaTa banAyA tadvat Izvara ne bhI sRSTi kI racanA kI hai| yaha udAharaNa Izvara kI adehitva naSTa karane vAlA hai kyoMki kumbhakAra to apane hasta pAdAdi avayava dvArA kumbhAdika pAtra kI racanA karatA hai aura Izvara to hasta pAdAdi avayavoM se rahita hai ataeva Apa ke Izvara ne kinaH avayavoM ke dvArA sRSTi nirmANa kI hai| kumbhakAra kA dRSTAnta to ApakA yahAM nirarthaka hai kyoMki dehadhArI kA dRSTAnta adehadhArI para nahIM laga saktA, yadi Apa kahoge ki Izvara deha dhAraNa bhI kara saktA hai to nirAkAra-nitya-niraMjana-nirlepAdi upamA denA ayukta hai aura dehadhArI hone se Izvara tujhAre hamAre sadRza manuSya honA cAhie aura saba ko netroM se dikhAI denA caahie| jina IzvaravAdI janoM ke hRdaya meM aisI dRr3ha zraddhA ho ki jagatkartA Izvara hI hai unase hama prazna karate haiM ki yadi sRSTi kA nirmANakartA Izvara hai to upAdAna kAraNa kauna rahA ? yadi kaheMge ki aizvarIya zakti hai to vaha zakti Izvara se bhinna hai athavA abhinna ? yadi abhinna hai to batalAnA ucita hai ki jar3a hai yA cetana ? yadi jar3a hai to batalAiye vaha nitya hai yA anitya ? yadi bhinna aura nitya hai to saba se prathama, eka nitya padArtha Izvara hI hai, yaha kathana nitAnta asatya huA, yadi kahoge ki vaha zakti anitya hai to usakA upAdAna kAraNa kauna hai ? aura yaha niyama hai ki nitya se anitya vastu kA utpanna honA sarvathA asaMbhava hai, yadi zakti Izvara se abhinna hai to Izvara aura zakti yaha pRthak pRthak nAma se mAnanA hI vRthA ThaharA aura saMpUrNa padArtha Izvara rUpa hI hai UMca-nIca-rAjA-raMka-naraka-svarga-adharma-dharma saba ko Izvara hI kahanA koI doSa nahIM aura isase to Apa ke Izvara ne sRSTi kyA racI kintu apanA svarUpa hI bigAr3a liyA, dhanya haiM mahAzaya! Apa kA Izvara ho to aisA hI ho ! bar3A Azcarya hai ki sRSTi ko IzvararazcitasvIkAra karanevAle apane hRdaya meM yaha nahIM vicAra karate ki jaba Izvara ne sRSTi racI usa samaya upAdAna

Page #35
kAraNa rUpa padArtha kyA thA ? arthAt sAmagrI kahAM se lAe ki jisa se sRSTi nirmANa kI jaise kumbhakAra (kuMbhAra) ghaTa kI racanA mRttikA, jala, cakrAdi padArtha kI sahAyatA vinA nahIM kara saktA, tadvat jaganiyantA Izvara ko sRSTinirmANa karate samaya sAmagrI avazya cAhiye; yadi koI kahe ki sAmagrI to anAdi se hai to yaha siddha ho cukA ki sAmagrI Izvara racita nahIM hai to mahAzaya ! Apake Izvara ne kyA racanA kI ? aura yaha kathana bhI nitAnta asatya ho cukA ki "saba se prathama Izvara hI thA, aura Izvara ne hI saMpUrNa padArthoM kI racanA kI hai" kyoMki sAmagrI IzvarakRta na hone se saMpUrNa padArtha Izvara ke race siddha nahIM ho sakte, phira Izvara ne kyA racanA kii| ___ kitane kahate haiM ki Izvara nirAkAra hokara bhI sRSTi racanA karane kI sAmarthya na rakkhe to vaha sarvazaktimAn kisa rIti se ho saktA hai ? isake pratyuttara meM yaha kahanA cAhiye ki sarvazaktimAn vaha kadApi nahIM kahA jA saktA, kyoMki vaha svataH apanA svarUpa vigAr3a carAcara meM vidyamAna hokara sarvazaktimAna bananA cAhe to nahIM bana saktA / sRSTi racanA karane se Izvara meM rAgadveSa rUpa doSa prApta hote haiM aura jisameM rAga dveSa rUpa doSa hai usako sarvazaktimAna Izvara kahanA sarvathA ayukta hai| ____ arUpI Izvara se rUpI padArthoM kI utpatti mAnanA pramANa se bAdhita hai, kyoMki Apa kA arUpI sarvazaktimAna Izvara saMsAra kI racanA karate samaya sAmagrI kahAM se aura kina hAthoM se lAyA ? yadi kSaNa bhara jIva kA kartA Izvara ko mAna bhI leM to yaha virodha AtA hai ki kArya apane upAdAna kAraNa se bhinna nahIM ho saktA, yadi jIvoM kA upAdAna kAraNa Izvara hI hai to batalAnA hogA ki jIva-Izvara kI aikyatA meM aMtara kyoM mAnate ho? aura aizvarIya icchA se jIva pratikUla kyoM dikhalAI par3ate haiM arthAt Izvara ne jo jo AjJAeM dI haiM una AjJAoM se viparIta kyoM calate haiM ? aneka manuSya prasaMgavasa aisA udgAra nikAlA karate haiM ki "amuka manuSya ko durbuddhi utpanna hone kA

Page #36
( 14 ) kAraNa kevala IzvarIya icchAhI hai| hama pUchate haiM ki IzvarIya icchA Izvara kI AjJA se pratikUla bhI ho jAtI hai ? arthAt Izvara jIvoM ko durvRddhi bhI detA hai ? isase to Izvara ne jIvoM ko durbuddhi de ke jAna bUjha kara naraka ko mejane kA prayatna kiyA, dhanya hai Apa ke sRSTi kartA dayAlu Izvara ko ! dayAlu ho to aisA hI ho / ___eka manuSya kA dUsare manuSya se badha karAnA va usa ghAtakI manuSya ko rAjyadvArA prANanAzaka kaThora daMDa dilAnA yaha kArya Izvara ke lie kitanI bahAdurI kA hai ! dhanya hai Apa ke Izvara ko va IzvarIya icchA ko! yadi kahA jAya ki eka kArya to Izvara ne kiyA aura dUsarA kArya jIva ne kiyA yaha ThIka nahIM hai kyoMki jIva IzvarIya icchA ke sivAya kucha karahI nahIM saktA to phira jIva ne kaise kiyA aura yaha dikhAnA anucita nahIM hogA ki sarvazaktimAn jagamiyantA Izvara ko kisa yukti se mAnate haiM ! eka sthala para to sarvazaktimAna Izvara kI icchA se karma kiyA aura dUsare sthala para jIva ne svakarmAnusAra kiyA yaha bhI khUba pUrvApara viruddha vacana hai ! eka sthAna para likhA hai ki paramezvara ne apane Apa meM vicAra kiyA ki maiM sakala saMpUrNa padArthoM ko utpanna karUM; isa vicAra ke pUrNa karane ko tapasyA kI, tadanantara sakala padArthoM ke mUla kAraNa ko utpanna kiyA aura unako apanA AtmA diyA isa prakAra se saMpUrNa padArtha utpanna hue| aba yaha parAmarza karane kA sthAna hai ki nirAkAra Izvara ne kisa zarIra se tapasyA kI aura apanA AtmA kaise diyA ? sakala padArthoM ke mUla kAraNa ko kisa sAmagrI se banAyA! tapasyA kisake prItyartha kI? kyoMki tapasyA kA phala koI denevAlA hogA, tabhI to Izvara ko tapasyA karanI par3I hogI!jaise hama tuma kisI bhI devatA ke ArAdhana ke liye tapasyA karate haiM to vaha devatA usa tapasyA kA phala detA hai tadvat Izvarane tapasyA kI tousakA phala denevAlA bhI koI honA hI caahie| aura yahA~ para yaha bhI zaGkA utpanna hotI hai ki prathama akelA nirAkAra Izvara hI thA aura sakala padArtha to Izvara ne pIche se race phira Izvara ne kisa sthAna

Page #37
para baiTha ke tapasyA kI hogI aura usakA phala kisa dvArA prApta huA hogA ? jo loga Izvara ko sarvazaktimAn jagat kA kartA hartA mAnakara bhI korTa kacehariyoM meM pulisa kAnaSTebaloM ke hAthoM ke dhake khAte phirate haiM usa samaya unakA sarvazaktimAna Izvara apane race jIvoM kI rakSA karane meM kyA asamartha hai ? kyA usa samaya Izvara kA sarvazaktimAnpanA naSTa ho jAtA hai ? utpanna karane kI zakti rakhanA va pAlana karane meM azakta ho jAnA kyA yaha bAta sarvazaktimAn jaganniyantA Izvara ko ucita hai / satyapAhI jana to taba ApakA sarvazaktimAn Izvara svIkAra kareMge ki jaba IzvaravAdiyoM ke lie pratyakSa meM sarva jIvoM ke sanmukha (jo nahIM mAnate unake bhI sAmane ) Akara kahe ki he mere utpanna kie hue prANigaNoM ! maiM tuhmAre lie upasthita hUM, aura jo mere ko sarvazaktimAn jagat kartA Izvara nahIM mAnate unake lie maiM upasthita nahIM huuN| paraMtu aisA to dRSTigata nahIM hotA jo loga jaganniyantA Izvara svIkAra karate athavA nahIM karate haiM una donoM ke lie sAMsArika saMpUrNa bAteM eka samAna dRSTigata hotI haiM phira Apake jagatkartA Izvara ko sarvazaktimAna hama kisanyAya se khaiN| kitane kahate haiM ki Izvara akhaNDa brahmANDa meM vyApaka hai| "jale viSNuH sthale viSNurAkAze vissnnumaalinii| viSNumAlAkule loke nAsti kiMcidavaiSNavam" // _ bhAvArtha-jala meM viSNu,sthala meM viSNu, AkAza meM viSNu, jo kucha hai vaha viSNu hI kI pati mAlA arthAt sarva loka viSNu hI kI mAlA (pati) karake bharA huA hai ataeva aisI koI bhI vastusaMsAra meM nahIM hai ki jo viSNu kA rUpa nahIM hai| Izvara ko aisA saMpUrNa ghaTa paTAdi padArthoM meM vyApaka svIkAra karane se Izvara kI akhaNDatA naSTa ho jAyagI aura Izvara khaMDa khaMDa ho jAyagA va Izvara ko sarvavyApI mAnane se aneka doSa Ate haiM jIvoM meM vyApaka hone se nirlepatA naSTa hokara karmarUpI maile Izvara ko laganA

Page #38
( 16 ) ucita hai va janma, jarA, mRtyu Adi duHkha kA bhI mAgI honA hogA, nirAvaraNatA naSTa hokara sAvaraNatAprApta hogI ityAdi aneka doSa prApta hone kA saMbhava hai, aisA kauna mUda hai ki jo uttama pada ko tyAga adhama pada prApta karane kI icchA karegA! Izvara saMpUrNa sukhamaya hokara usako saMsAra ke duHkhoM meM Akara phasane kI kyA buddhi huI! kyoMki jIva svataH parama 'pada arthAt IzvarapadAbhilASI hokara jAna bhakti Adi karatA rahatA hai aura sAMsArika bandhana se mukta honA cAhatA hai, paraMtu Apake bacana to baDe hI Azcaryajanaka haiM, dhanya hai ! Apa ke kartA hartA Izvara ko ki jo svataH sAMsArika duHkho meM bhAga lene ko vibhakta hotA hai ! kitaneka kahate haiM ki yaha saMsAra IzvarIya vibhUti hai arthAt jIva Izvara kA aMza hai isa vAkya se yaha dhvanita hotA hai ki jIva aura Izvara meM aMzAMzI bhAva saMbandha hai / yadi kSaNa bhara ke lie kadAcit aisA hI mAna liyA jAya to jIva Izvara ke sadRza honA cAhie ! kyoMki azAMzI meM bheda nahIM ho saktA |saaraaNsh yaha ki Izvara ke tulya jIva ko bhI nirmala honA cAhie ? yadi jIvoM ko nirmala svIkAra kareMge to karma rUpa mala lagAne kA kyA prayojana huA ? Izvara jIva ko apanA aMza jAnate bhI karma rUpa mala lagAtA hai yaha kitanA Azcarya hai aura jIva Izvara kA aMza hone se narakagAmI Izvara bhI huA / sukhI ho vaha bhI Izvara aura duHkhI ho vaha bhI Izvara, saMsAra paribhramaNa karai vaha bhI Izvara, isase to sivAya Izvara ke koI bhI sthala zUnya nahIM ThaharA / yadi aisA hai to vaira, virodha, kalaha, mukha, duHkha, dIna, daridrI, pApI, hatyArA ityAdi sava IzvarahI ThaharA, kartA bhI vahI aura bhoktA bhI vhii| brAhmaNa, kSatriya, vaizya, zUdra, atizUdrAdi meM Izvara vyApaka hai tau phira brAhmaNa ko uttama aura cANDAlAdika ko nIca mAnane se kyA prayojana ? kyoMki Izvara to sarva jIvoM meM vyApaka hai| Azcarya hai ki apane aMza ko ghAta karanevAlA Izvara ApahI hai ! yaha vicArane kA sthAna hai ki svataH apane aMzo ko ghAta karane se ghAtakI ThaharA, aura ghAtaka rUpa kalaMka yukta svataH hI hai to dUsaroM ke kalaMka dUra karane kI sAmarthya

Page #39
( 17 ) kahAM se AI, svataH daridrI hokara anya ko dhanADhya kisa prakAra kara saktA hai ? kabhI nahIM kara saktA / tadvat ApakA Izvara bhI anya kA kalaGka dUra nahIM kara saktA / aise kalaGkI aura anyAyiyoM ko Izvara kahanAbhI ayukta hai| avinAzI ko vinAzI, nirAkAra ko sAkAra,nirdoSI ko doSI ityAdi saMpUrNa doSa jagatkartA Izvara ke mAnane meM prApta hote haiN| ___kitane logoM kI yaha samajha hai ki sRSTi kA kartA koI honA hI cAhie kyoMki saMsAra kI adbhuta racanA dikhalAI par3atI hai isakA svAbhAvika honA asambhava hai aura karmAdi jar3a padArthoM se jagadutpatti honA saMbhava nahIM hai ataeva jagat IzvarakRta kRtya honA saMbhAvita hai| isake pratyuttara meM yaha kahanA cAhiye ki yadi Apake kathana se kSaNa bhara aisA mAna bhI leveM to Izvara prANiyoM kA kAraNa huA aura saba padArtha Izvara ke kArya hue ataeva Izvara pitA aura saba padArtha putrarUpa mAnanA par3eMge yadi Izvara ko pitA mAneM to saba padArthoM para IzvararUpa pitA kA prema honA ucita hai aura saba saMsAra ke prANiyoM ko sukhI rakhanA pitA kA dharma hai parantu saMsAra meM to aneka duHkhI bhI dikhAI par3ate haiM, kitanehI pApI, kitanehI puNyavAn , kitanehI dharmI adharmI, manuSya haiM yaha kisa prakAra ho sakatA hai ? kyA yaha bAta pitA ke yogya hai ki putroM ko duHkha de ? yahAM para yadi koI yaha kahe ki lAyaka putroM ko sukha detA hai aura nAlAyakoM ko duHkhI karatA hai to isake pratyuttara meM kahanA cAhiye ki lAyaka nAlAyaka hone kI buddhi kA dAtA bhI to Apa Izvara ko hI mAnate haiM phira eka ko lAyaka buddhi denA aura dUsare ko nAlAyaka buddhi denA yaha Izvara ke lie kitanA anucita hai ? Izvara pravataka hokara kaI jIvoM ko kubuddhi dekara naraka kA bhAgI banA detA hai aura kaI jIvoM ko subuddhi dekara svarga kA bhAgI banA detA hai isameM durgati meM jAnevAle jIvoM ne Izvara kI kyA hAni kI thI aura sugati meM jAnevAloM se Izvara ko kyA lAbha huA ? yadi isakA uttara dene ko asamartha hote bhI apanA haTha nahIM tyAga sakte to dhanyavAda hai Apako Apake Izvara hoM to aisehI hoN|

Page #40
sRSTikartA Izvara ke svIkAra karanevAle sajana yaha nahIM parAmarza karate ki Izvara ko saMsAra kI racanA karate samaya aisI kyoM durbuddhi utpanna huI ki saMsAra kI racanA ke karane ke sAtha hI aneka mata matAntara bhI raca die, kyA usane yaha nahIM jAnA thA ki aneka mata matAntara racane se mujhe koI acchA kahegA aura koI buraa| aneka manuSya ziva-viSNu kI pUjA arcA karate haiM aura aneka yavanAdi manuSya unhIM ziva-viSNu kI nindA karate haiN| saMsAra meM aneka zAkta aura aneka zeva tathA aneka laukika mata dhArI haiM, koI gANapata aura koI vaidika haiM isa prakAra aneka mata matAntara racakara saMsAra meM nirarthaka paraspara kalaha, kadAgraha bar3hAkara Izvara ne kyA lAbha uThAyA ? kyA sRSTi racayitA isa bAta se ajJa thA ? ki aneka mata matAntara racane se koI mere ko dhikkAra deMge aura koI acchA bhI kheNge| ataH siddha huA ki jagava Izvara kA racA huA nahIM hai kintu anAdi hai| ____sRSTikartA Izvara svIkAra karanevAle yaha bhI kahate haiM ki buddhi Izvaradatta hai isa para hama pUchate haiM ki eka gau kI pUjA karatA aura dUsarA arthAt yavanAAdaka gAya kA vadha karatA hai yaha donoM ko buddhi Izvara ne dI yA dUsare ne? batalAie jaba buddhi kA preraka Izvara hai to eka ko subudi denA aura dUsare ko naSTabuddhi denA kyA Izvara ke lie nyAya hai ? isaliye uparyukta ApakA kahanA bhI ayukta hai| __ jo loga yaha svIkAra karate haiM ki sRSTi kA adhipati Izvara hI hai aura jagat usakA aizvarya hai isIse Izvara ko aizvarya prApta huA hai, jo aizvaryavAna ho vahI Izvara kahA jA saktA hai, isake pratyuttara meM vidita hoki jagat kA Adhipatya lene se Izvara ko kyA prayojana thA ? jagatarUpa aizvarya Izvara ko kisa lie cAhie thA? kyA jagadutpattirUpa aizvarya ko jaganniyantA Izvara ne bhUtapUrva kabhI prApta nahIM kiyA thA ? jagadutpatti ke prathama Izvara ke samIpa aizvarya nahIM thA ?

Page #41
( 19 ) prApta hone ke prathama anIzvara thA ? kyA sRSTi racane se hI aizvarya prApta huA hai ? jo Izvara ko aizvarya prApta huA hai vaha kisI kA diyA huA hai yA svataH utpanna ho gayA ? yadi aizvarya kisI kA bhI diyA huA mAna liyA jAya to denevAlA kauna ? yadi svataH utpanna honA mAnoMge to kisa rItyanusAra aura kisa sthAna para prApta huA ? yadi jaganniyantA svIkAra karanevAle aisA kaheM ki dravya se manuSya dhanADhya kahalAtA hai aura prajA se rAjA kahalAtA hai tadvat jagatarUpa aizvarya se Izvara kahalAtA hai isake uttara meM Apa svataH vicAra kareM ki jaba jagat ke aizvarya se Izvara kahalAtA hai to sRSTi ke pralaya ho jAne para aizvarya naSTa bhI hojAnA cAhie ? jaise dhanADhya kA dhana cale jAne se dhanADhyatA naSTa ho jAtI hai arthAt phira vaha dhanAvya ke sthAna para dIna daridrI kahalAtA hai tadvat Izvara ko bhI anIzvara svIkAra karanA hogA ? aura sAtha hI sAtha yaha bhI kahanA hogA ki kabhI Izvara hai aura kabhI anIzvara hai, ataH siddha huA ki jaganniyantA Izvara jagat kA adhipati nahIM hai| kitane logoM kA kahanA hai ki sRSTi kI utpatti ke prathama Izvara ne aisA saGkalpa kiyA ki maiM apanI sAmarthya prakaTa karU~ ___ "eko'haM bahu syAma" bhAvArtha-maiM eka se aneka banUM / Izvara ko sRSTi racanA karane kA yahI prayojana thA isaliye sRSTi nirmANa kI, yadi aisA hai to smaraNa rahai jahA~ saMkalpa hai tahA~ vikalpa bhI hai, ataH ApakA Izvara saMkalpa vikalpa sahita ThaharA ? saMkalpa vikalpamaya siddha hone se usako sarvathA Izvara nahIM kaha sakte / jo Izvara ne apanI sAmarthya prakaTa kI vaha kisako batalAne ko kI ? aura "maiM apanI sAmarthya prakaTa karUM, aisI icchA jIvabuddhi ko honA ucita hai ataH ApakA Izvara jIvabuddhi ThaharA, aura jIvabuddhi hone se usako sarvajJa kahanA ayukta hai, kyoMki Izvara hokara sAmarthya prakaTa karanA na karanA ityAdi kArya to dehadhArI

Page #42
( 20 ) ko honA cAhie ! kintu Apa to adehadhArI mAnate haiN| jisako saMzaya zatru ne gherA hai aura saMkalpa vikalpa karatA hai usako jo manuSya sarvajJa kahatA hai vaha kevala haThabAda ke sivAya kucha nahIM karatA ! Izvara ko sAmarthya dikhAkara kisI ke pAsa se inAma prApta karanA thA ! yadi kahoge ki nahIM; to vRthAhI Apake paramezvara ne itanA parizrama kyoM kiyA ? ephase aneka rUpa hone meM Izvara ko kyA lAbha huA ? kyA sAMsArika jIvoM se prazaMsApatra (Certificate) prApta karanA thA ? aura jo yaha kahanA hai ki sAmarthya prakaTa karane ke liye jagadutpati kI hai to yaha kathana bhI nitAnta asatya hai kyoMki kisako batalAne ke liye sAmarthya prakaTa kiyA aura kisako batalAne ko sRSTi utpanna kI! kyA usa samaya koI dUsarA Izvara kA mitrAdi vidyamAna thA ! jisako batalAne ke vAste itanA bhArI kheda uThAnA par3A, ApalogoM kA mantavya to yaha hai ki saMpUrNa padArtha Izvara ke race hue haiM, phira sAmarthya batalAne ke lie sRSTi nirmANa kI yaha kathana Apa kA pUrvApara virodha se bharA hai yA nahIM ? Izvara ko sAmarthya batalAne kI icchA kabhI nahIM honA cAhie ataeva yaha bhI Apa kA hetu ThIka nahIM hai| kaI mahAzayoM kA yaha bhI abhiprAya hai ki Izvara kA jagat rUpa zrRMgAra hai, yaha usane apanA rUpa vistAra kiyA hai, saMsAra rUpa apanA mukha dekha apane hI mana meM Apa AnaMdita hotA hai| isakA pratyuttara yaha hai ki isa kathana se to IzvaravAdI jI ! Apa ke Izvara ne apanA svayaM hI svarUpa vigAr3a liyA, kyoMki mArjAra, barAha, aja, mahiSAdi, nAnA prakAra ke rUpa jitane haiM sabhI usIke rUpa jAnane cAhie ? kitane kahate haiM ki"eka eva hi bhUtAtmA bhUte bhUte vyavasthitaH / ekadhA bahudhA caiva dRzyate jalacandravat" // 1 // . bhAvArtha-eka hI bhUtAtmA arthAt Izvara, prANImAtra meM pRthaka pRthavyavasthita hotA hai, jaise jalabhare pAtroM meM caMdra ke pratiSimba

Page #43
( 21 ) pRthak pRthak dikhalAI par3ate haiM tadvat Izvara bhI ghaTa ghaTa vyApI hai| tAtparya-Izvara bimba hai aura jIva pratibimba hai / paraMtu yaha kahanA bhI ajJatA se bharA hai kyoMki bimba ke sadRza pratibimba hotA hai, jaise dvitIyA kA caMdramA dhanuSAkAra choTA hotA hai to jala meM bhI usakA vaisAhI dhanupAkAra choTA hI pratibimba dIkhatA hai aura pUrNimA kA caMdra sthAlI ke AkAra gola hotA hai to jala meM bhI pratibimba vaisAhI gola dRSTi gata hotA hai, athavA kAMca ke bhavana (Adarza bhavana) meM jo koI manuSya praveza kare usakA jaisA bimba hogA vaisAhI prativimba cAro ora najara AvegA tadvat Izvara kA pratibimba saMsAra ko svIkAra karane se spaSTa virodha AtA hai, kyoMki koI sukhI koI duHkhI, aura koI pApI koI dharmI ityAdi nAnA prakAra kI vicitratA saMsAra meM dikhalAI par3atI hai, ataeva saMsAra ko Izvara kA pratibimba kisa hetu se mAnA jAya kyoMki yaha svAbhAvika niyama hai ki bimba kI sAdRzya pratibimba meM honA hI cAhie jaise Izvara ko avinAzI mAnate ho tadvat saMsAra ko bhI avinAzI svIkAra karanA yogya hogaa| jaisA Izvara karmarahita hai taise jIvoM ko bhI karmarahita honA cAhie ? to aisA to dikhAI nahIM detA isase siddha huA ki Izvara kA pratibimba jagat nahIM hai / Izvara sukhamaya hai aura saMsAra duHkhamaya hai, dekhiye ? yaha pratyakSa virodha AtA hai isa se ApakA kahanA asatya huaa| kaI mahAzayoM kA yaha abhiprAya hai ki carAcara meM AtmA (Izvara) ekahI hai aura pudgala bhinna bhinna haiN| "sarvataH pANipAdaM tat sarvato'kSi ziromukham / sarvataH zrutimalloke sarvamAvRtya tiSThati // 1 // bhAvArtha-jisake saba jagaha para hAtha, paga, AMkha, zira, aura mukha hai aura saba sthAna para jisake kAna haiM saba aura saMpUrNa padArthoM meM vyApaka ho ke rahatA hai saba aura saMpUrNa vRttiyoM (vyavahAroM) kA sthAna hoke ThaharA huA hai| tAtparya-garuDa se Adi lekara kITikA paryanta saba aura saMpUrNa padArthoM meM

Page #44
( 22 ) AtmA ekahI hai / yadi aisA ho to eka vyakti ke pApa karanepara sAre saMsAra ko laganA cAhie? aura eka jIva mukta ho jAne se saMpUrNa saMsAra kA mokSa ho jAnA cAhie ! eka prANi ke baMdhanayukta hone se sAre saMsAra ko baMdhayukta honA cAhie ? bhinna bhinna, jIvoM kA anuSThAna (kriyA) bhI niSphala honA cAhie | paraMtu yaha bAta to dikhAI nahIM detI aura pApI dharmI, deva, naraka, U~ca, nIca, cANDAla, brAhmaNa, rAjA, prajA, cora, . sAhUkAra, pitA, putra, mAtA, strI, puruSa, bhAI, bahina ityAdi bhinna bhinna kaise dikhAI par3ate haiM ataH siddha huA ki saba saMsAra meM AtmA eka nahIM kintu aneka hai / kitane kahate haiM ki jitane kAryAkArya hote haiM ve saba IzvarIya icchA se hote haiM "mamecchA kApi nAsti IzvarecchA pravarttate " IzvarIya icchA se hI kAryAkArya kA honA mAna liyA jAya to viSa khAne se mRtyu, aura dhAnya bhakSaNa karane se kSudhA kI zAnti, jala tRSA kI nivRtti, agni se zItaharaNa, tApa se khedotpatti, varSA se dhAnyotpatti, dveSa se vairotpatti, namratA se snehotpatti, corI se tADana, pApa se naraka, puNya se svarga ityAdi kAraNa aura kArya nirarthaka ho jAya~ge, aura jitane padArtha haiM vaha saba apane guNa doSoM se rahita mAnanA hogA, kyoMki aizvarIya icchA se hI saMpUrNa kAryAkArya mAna lie jAya~ to rAga karanevAlA snehI aura dveSa karanevAlA zatru yaha kahanA anucita hogA, kyoMki rAga dveSa bhI IzvarIya icchA se hI utpanna hote haiM / saMpUrNa kArya karane kA mUla kAraNa eka IzvarIya icchA hone se pApa puNya kA karanevAlA, aura bhoganevAlA Izvara hI ThaharA ? yadi aisA hai to kisI ko pApI, kisI ko dharmI kahane se kyA prayojana hai ? aura ApakA zuddha, jaganniyantA Izvara kArya ke sAtha meM akArya bhI jaba kara - tA hai to DAkU luTere Adi kI upamA usako denA bhI anucita na hogA, aura usake utpanna kie hue jIva akArya karane meM pravRtta hoM to usa meM

Page #45
( 23 ) Azcarya hI kyA ! dhanya hai Apake Izvara ko aura Apako ! paraMtu yAda rakhiye Izvara kabhI akArya sukArya nahIM karatA vaha nirantara nirdoSa hai ataeva siddha huA ki kAryAkArya hote haiM ve Izvara kI icchA se nahIM kintu zubhAzubha karmoM se hote haiM / kitane sajjanaM yaha siddha karanA cAhate haiM ki sRSTi ke Adi meM jIva ke zarIra aura sAMce ko banAnA IzvarAdhIna hai pazcAta putrAdi santati utpatti karanA jIva kA kartavya hai dekhie ! kyA jagatkartA svIkAra karanevAle sajjana ! itane meM hI thaka gae !! aura phira aisA bhI kahate haiM ki nAnA prakAra ke karma jIva kiyA karate haiM una karmoM kA karAnevAlA IzvarahI hai ataH Izvara kI preraNA vinA jIvoM se karma nahIM ho sakte / dekhie ! yaha kathana kitanA pUrvApara virodha se bharA huA hai eka sthAna para kahanA ki sRSTi ke Adi meM jIva ke zarIrakA sA~cA banAnA IzvarAdhIna hai aura dUsare sthala para kahanA ki nAnA prakAra kA jIva karma karatA hai una karmoM kA karAnevAlA IzvarahI hai aura dUsare ke tarka - hai-tApa se bacane ke liye kisI sthala para yaha bhI kaha dete haiM ki jIva jaisA karatA hai vaisA pAtA hai dekhie ! Izvara ko jagatkartI mAnanevAloM ke Apta vAkya meM kaisA nyAya bharA hai ? yadi nAnA prakAra ke jIva karma karate haiM una karmoM kA karAnevAlA IzvarahI hai to karmoM kA kartA bhI IzvarahI ThaharegA kyoMki kriyA kA preraka hI kartA ho saktA hai aura jo kartA ho vahI bhoktA honA cAhie, kartA ke sivAya bhoktA anya nahIM Thahara saktA, aura kartA bhoktA Izvara ko mAnane se pApa puNya bhI Izvara hI ko laganA ucita hai, jaise kisI eka manuSya ne yaSTikA ( lakar3I ) se kisI eka puruSa ko mArA, usakA pApa lakar3I ko kabhI nahIM laga saktA, balki mAranevAle ko hI lagA yaha kahanA hogA; tadvat jIva ke kie hue pApa puNya kA preraka Izvara hone se pApa puNya kA bhAgI Izvara ko hI mAnanA hogA, kyoMki karma kA kartA jIva to yaSTikA ke tulya hai "kartA bhoktA mahezvaraH " isa bAta se siddha huA ki jIva kucha karatA bhI nahIM aura bhoktA bhI nahIM jaba kartA bhoktA jIva nahIM hai

Page #46
( 24 ) to svakha dharmAnusAra jo jo manuSya snAna, sandhyA, madya mAMsa parityAga, tapa, japa, niyama, dhyAna, dAna ityAdi aneka prakAra ke anuSThAna, pApa nivAraNa ke lie karane kA kaSTa kyoM uThAte haiM aura prAyazcittAdi bhI lenA vRthA hI hogA ? aura sajjana durjana bhI kisI ko kahane kI AvazyakatA nahIM hai ? aura kartA bhoktA Izvara ko kahane se harSa, zoka bhI jIva ko nahIM kintu Izvara hI ko hotA samajhanA cAhie ! aura jo yaha kahAvata hai ki "jaisA karegA vaisA pAvegA" yaha satya nahIM hai kyoMki jaba kartA bhoktA Izvara hai to jIva kyoMkara pAvegA kyoMki kriyA kA preraka Izvara hai| aneka manuSyoM ke vRnda hAtha jor3a ke bhaktipUrvaka Izvara kI prArthanA karate haiM ki "he prabhu ! hamAre pApa Apa nivAraNa karo!" aisI prArthanA ke sthAna para aisI prArthanA kyoM nahIM karate ki "he paramezvara tuma hI kartA aura tumahI bhoktA ho tumhAre kie pApa tumahI bhogo aura tumahI apane dUra karalo" aura kartA bhoktA Izvara ke hone se prANigaNa ko prArthanA karane kI bhI AvazyakatA nahIM hai| jagat kAkartA svIkAra karane vAloM ke Apta pranthoM meM kahA hai ki pApa dUra karane ke liye Izvara kI prArthanA karanA cAhiye aura kartA bhoktA Izvara ko kahakara eka prakAra se manuSyoM ko bhramajAla meM phasAne kA sAhasa karanA hai, ataeva siddha huA ki kartA bhoktA Izvara nahIM kintu jIvahI hai| jagat kartA Izvara svIkAra karane vAloM kA kahanA hai ki "sarvajJa Izvara" vedAdi zAstroM meM jagatkartA Izvara ko sarvajJa mAnA hai, yadi sRSTikartA Izvara sarvajJa hai to apane pratipakSI rAvaNa, vakradanta, zizupAlAdi rAkSasoM ko kyoM utpanna kiyA, yadi kahA jAya ki rAkSasayoni Izvara kI ajJatA meM utpanna huI hai to isa vAkya se Apa kA jaganniyantA Izvara sarvajJa siddha nahIM hotA kintu asarvajJa huA, jo saMpUrNa padArthoM ko nirantara aura saMpUrNa rItyA jAnatAhI rahe usI ko sarvajJa kahanA ucita hai paraMtu Apake Izvara ne to rAkSasayoni ajJatA meM utpanna kI isase Apa

Page #47
( 25 ) ke Izvara meM ajJatA kA dUSaNa AyAyA nahIM ? yadi aisA kaheMge ki Izvarane rAvaNAdi rAkSasoM ko jAna bUjha kara utpanna kiyA thA to isa para isa praznakA udbhava hotA hai ki rAkSasayoni ke utpanna karate samaya kyA Izvarane yaha nahIM jAnA thA ki jo rAkSasaloga utpanna hoMge ve mere pyAre devatAoM ko duHkhI kareMge, aura phira devatAloga merA smaraNa kareMge aura mujhe unakI bhakti ke baza hokara rAkSasoM ko saMgrAma [ yuddha ] karake mAranA par3egA tathA devatAoM kI rakSA karanI hogI ? aba vicAriye ki Izvara ko rAkSasayoni utpanna karane se lAbha ke sthAna para hAni bhoganI par3I yA nahIM ? isase to rAkSasayoni ko nahIM utpanna karate to zreya thA, kyoMki . Izvara ko avatAra dhAraNa karane kA aura yuddha meM atula bala dekhAne kA parizrama nahIM karanA par3atA / dUsarI bAta yaha hai ki prathama utpanna kiyA aura phira unase yuddha karake unheM mAra DAlA isase Izvara ko kyA lAbha huA ? __mahadAzcarya hai ki vicArA jagatkartA Izvara utpanna karane kA aura mAraDAlane kA nirarthaka parizrama rAta dina karatAhI rahatA hai| uparyukta bAtoM ko vicAra karane se vidita hotA hai ki jaganniyantA Izvara sarvajJa nahIM hai kintu asarvajJa hai| "ye ye hatAzcakradhareNa daityA strailokyanAthena janArdanena // te te gatA viSNupurIM narendrAH! krodho'pi devasya vareNa tulyaH" // zlo. 23 pANDavagItA. bhAvArtha- cakradhArI trailokyanAtha janArdana ne jina jina daityoM ko mArA ve saba viSNupurI [mokSapurI] ko gae ataeva Izvara kA krodha bhI bara ke tulya hai| . dekhie ! Izvara ne jitanoM ko mArA utane saba mukta hogae ! to apane pyAre devatAoM aura bhaktajanoM se bhI zIghra rAkSasoM ko viSNupurI detA hai| jagatkartA kaisA nyAyazIla hai isa bAta kA yaha eka namUnA hai ki

Page #48
( 26 ) jopratipakSI hokara Izvara se yuddha karate haiM ve zIghra muktipada ko cale jAte haiM aura jo jIva Izvara kI bhakti karanevAle haiM, arthAt bhaktajana haiM unako mokSa dene meM Izvara vilamba karatA hai ataH isa mantavya ko svIkAra karane vAle sajjanoM ko ucita hai ki Izvara se bhakti ke badale zatrutA kareM ki jisase zIghra mukti ho jAya aura jo jo isa mantavya ko svIkAra karanevAle mitra bhakti karate hoMge ve bar3IhI bhUla karate haiM, yadi zIghra mokSa prApta karanA ho to Izvara se pratipakSI hone kA prayatna kareM, kadAcit isIlie rAkSasoM ne yaha sarala mArga svIkAra kiyA hogA? aura jo kahate haiM ki hamAre Izvara ne hamako AjJA dI hai ki "merI. bhakti kro| isapara yaha kahA jA sakatA hai ki sAyata tumako Izvara ne vaJcita karake zIghra mukta na hone kA upAya batalAyA ho! yadi buddhimAna ho to apane Izvara kA kathana kadApi svIkAra nahIM karanA jisase tuma zIghra mukta hojAo / dekhie ! sRSTikartA svIkAra karanevAloM ne mokSaprApti kA kaisA uttama upAya zocA hai| jagatkartA svIkAra karanevAloM kA kahanA hai ki Izvara jaba saMhAra karatA hai usa samaya (Izvara) svataH pahile prAgvaTa vRkSa ke patte para jAke so jAtA hai aura jaba sRSTi racane kA vicAra hotA hai taba jAgatA hai / hama pUchate haiM ki jaba sRSTi kA pralaya huA usa samaya prAgvaTa kisa sthAna para jA ThaharA thA ? prAgvaTa sRSTi meM hai ki bAhara! yadi sRSTi ke bAhara prAgvaTa mAnoge to yaha siddha huA ki sRSTi ke bAhara bhI kaI padArtha haiM, yadi sRSTihI meM mAnate ho to sRSTipralaya ke sAtha prAgvaTa kA pralaya kyoM nahIM huA aura pralaya ke samaya kisa sthAna para jA ThaharatA hai ? aura Apa logoM kA yaha jo pharamAnA hai ki pRthvI jalamayI ho jAtI hai phira usake Upara kevala prAgvaTa hI dRSTigata hotA hai yadi aisA hai to yaha svIkAra karanA hogA ki pRthvI, jala, vaTa, mahApralaya ke anantara bhI rahate haiM, yadi aisA Apa maMjUra kareMge to prazna utpanna hogA ki Izvara ne saMhAra kina 2 padArthoM kA kiyA? aura mahApralaya kisa nyAya se huaa|

Page #49
( 27 ) ataH siddha huA ki saMpUrNa padArtha zAzvata haiM, kyoMki sRSTi utpanna karane ke prathama pRthvI, jala, prAgvaTa jIva aura paramANu kAyama the to phira Apake Izvara ne kyA sRSTi rcii| jagatkartA to jaba siddha ho ki binA kisI padArthoM kI sattA se svataH Izvara kA saba padArtha utpanna karanA saddhetudvArA siddha kara diyA jAya / parantu asatya bAta kahAM taka satya ho / aura jo yaha kahanA hai ki mahApralaya meM so jAtA hai to kyA Izvara ko nidrA bhI AyA karatI hai ? kyA Izvara sotA jAgatA bhI hai ? jAgrat , svapna, suSupti, AhAra, vihArAdi dazA dehadhAriyoM ko hotI hai, aura Apaloga to Izvara ko adehI mAnate haiM isase ApakA mantavya nirarthaka huA kyoMka adehI kA jAganA aura sonA nahIM bana saktA aura binA zarIra ke prAgvaTa para jAnA AnA sonA bhI nahIM ho saktA, isalie adehI Izvara ke lie yaha eka dUSaNa hai aura isase Izvara sRSTi kA kartA, hartA hai yaha kahanA bhI asatya huaa| kitaneka loga kahate haiM ki brahmA, viSNu, aura ziva yaha trimUrti sarvajJa hai aura saMsAra meM jo kucha padArtha hai so yahI hai, paraMtu hamArI samajha se to vesarvajJa nahIM haiM kyoMki ziva ne ajJAna se pArvatIputra gaNeza kA ziracchedana kiyaa| yadi sarvajJa hote to kyA yaha nahIM jAna sakate the ki yaha merI prANaballabhA pArvatI se utpanna huA merA putra hai ? ityAdi aneka dRSTAnta zaiva mata ke zAstroM meM milate haiM unake dekhane se hama ziva ko sarvajJa nahIM kaha skte| ___idhara jaba rAvaNa ne sItA kA haraNa kiyA usa samaya rAmacandrajI viSNu ke avatAra aura sAkSAt paramezvara sarvajJa hokara bhI vana ke vRkSoM se pUchate phire ki"bho vRkSAH parvatAgre bahakusumayutA vAyunA dhUyamAnAH, sA sItA kena nItA mama hRdayapriyA komalA kApi dRSTA,, ___ merI sItA, kisIne dekhI ? merI sItA, kisIne dekhI ? aisA jaba pUMchate phirate the usa samaya unakI sarvajJatA kahA~ jAtI rahI thI ? ki ve vRkSAdikoM se pUchane lge|

Page #50
- aura brahmAjI kI ora dekhA jAya to vidita hotA hai ki jisa samaya brahmA ke samIpa se rAkSasa bedoM ko corA le gae usa samaya brahmA kI sarvajJatA kahA~ gaI thI. ? yadi brahmA sarvajJa hote to vedoM kI corI kaise hone dete ? ukta bAtoM kI ora nirIkSaNa karane se yahI pratIta hotA. hai ki brahmA-viSNu-ziva sarvajJa nahIM ho sakate kintu unheM asarvajJa hI kahanA hogaa| ___kitane mahAzaya yaha pharamAte haiM ki "Izvara ne jala meM apanA vIrya chor3A" usakA aMDA huA, usa aMDe ke phira do vibhAga hue, eka vibhAga kA nAma pRthivI aura dUsare kA nAma svargapar3A" dekhiye! jagatkartA mAnanevAloM kI lIlA, ki jaba Izvara ke vIrya se pRthivI Adi padArtha utpanna hue taba to Izvara ke zarIra bhI honA ucita hai kyoMki vinA zarIra ke vIrya nahIM ho saktA aura jo Izvara kA zarIra siddha ho jAya to Izvara ko adeha nirAkAra kahanA jhUThA huA yaha kitanA pUrvApara viruddha hai / jagatkartA Izvara mAnane vAloM meM bhI eka mata nahIM hai, koI IzvaravAdI kahatA hai ki hamArA Izvara avatAra dhAraNa karatA hai aura anya kahatA hai ki Izvara avatAra dhAraNa nahIM karatA kintu vinA zarIra hI sava kArya kara sakatA hai / ina bAtoM ko kahA~ taka likheM yadi IzvaravAdiyoM ke mantavya kA paraspara virodha likhane baiThe to eka bar3A grantha ho jAya isIlie unakI tarkoM kA hI kiMcit parAmarza karanA yukta samajhA gayA hai| ___ koI IzvaravAdI kahate haiM ki Izvara hI jagat meM vyApta hokara krIDA kara rahA hai / aura kitaneka kahate haiM ki manuSyoM ko jaba uddhAra hone kA mArga nahIM milA isaliye ve rodana karane lage taba karuNAnidhAna vizvapitA unakA rodana sunakara eka RSi ke hRdaya meM prakaTa hue aura vaha RSi IzvarIya zakti meM balavAn hokara khar3A huA aura vizvavAsiyoM ko kahane lagA, he vizvavAsIjanoM ! zravaNa karo ! maiMne usa anAdi purAtana paramapuruSa ko jAnA hai| Aditya ke samAna to usakA varNa hai, aura ajJAnI loga usakA sparza nahIM kara sakte / usake jAnane se tuma

Page #51
( 29 ) loga mRtyu ke hAtha se chUTa jAoge, isake sivAya aura koI mArga nahIM hai| dhanya hai IzvaravAdiyoM kI tarkoM ko! koI 2 IzvaravAdiyoM ne aisA vicAra kiyA ki yadi hama kaheMge ki hamAre zAstra Izvara ke race hue haiM to loga isa bAta ko tor3a deMge ki "adeha Izvara ne kisa mukha se zAstra race ?" isa liye yaha kahanA cAhiye ki Izvara ne RSiyoM ke AtmA meM vedoM kA prakAza kiyaa| IzvaravAdI yaha khUba uttama pATha par3he haiM ? Izvara RSiyoM ke AtmA meM prakAza kare arthAt bhUta preta kI taraha prakAza kare kiMvA bole yaha IzvaravAdiyoM ke ghara kA hI nyAya hai isa bAta ko pAThaka ! soceM / kitane loga brahmA, viSNu, aura ziva ko IzvarIya avatAra mAnate haiM, aura yaha bhI kahA karate haiM ki yahI sAkSAt Izvara haiM kyoMki brahmA jIvoM kI utpatti karatA hai, biSNu pAlana-poSaNa karatA hai aura ziva saMhAra karatA hai isaliye saMsAra triguNAtmaka [triguNa-maya] hai / aba prathama to ina devatAoM ke vAre meM inake hI mata ke parama vidvAn mahArSa bhartRhari kyA pharamA rahe haiM use suniye:"zaMbhuvayaMbhuharayo hariNekSaNAnAM, yenAkriyanta satataM gRhakarmadAsAH / vAcAmagocaracaritravicitritAya, tasmai namo bhagavate! kusumaayudhaay"||1|| bhAvArtha-jisa kAmadeva ne zaMbhu, viSNu, brahmA ko striyoM kA dAsa banA diyA hai aise agocara caritra vAle kAmadeva ko namaskAra hoM arthAt maiM (bhartRhari) namaskAra karatA huuN| 1 AgnivAyuravibhyastu trayaM brahma sanAtanam / dudoha yajJasiddhayarthamRgyaju:sAmalakSaNam // manu0 isa zloka kA kitaneka yaha artha karate haiM ki paramAtmA ne sRSTi ke Adi meM manuSyoM ko utpanna karake agni, vAyu, sUrya, agirA, ina cAra RSiyoM ke bhAtmA meM prakAza kiyA aura ukta RSiyoM ke dvArA veda brahmA ko prApta karAye / parantu yaha artha isa zloka meM se nahIM nikltaa| -

Page #52
mahAzaya ! Apa ke jagatkartA hartA triguNAtmaka avatAroM ke saMbandha meM bhartRhari jI kA abhiprAya to Apa ko uktazloka se vidita . huA hogaa| Azcarya hai ki jagat ke kartA hartA hokara bhI jaba kAmadeva ke vazIbhUta hogae, to jo kAmI krodhI hogA vaha doSarahita kaise ho sakatA hai ? . daityoM kI chAtI para paga rakha kara raudra rUpa se sazastra khar3e haiM aise devoM ko zAnta, dAnta, samAdhistha kauna kaha sakatA hai ! yadi taTastha hokara dekhA jAya to ukta deva sarvajJa kiMvA rAga dveSa rahita nahIM kahe jAsakate / aura sRSTi ke kartA hartA bhI unakA mAnanA sarvathA anucita hogA / pakSapAtI jana cAhe bezaka ! mAna leM kyoMki mAnanA apane 2 mana para nirbhara hai| paraMtu nyAyazIla manuSya to nyAyayuktahI bAta ko svIkAra kregaa| prastuta bhAratavarSa meM aneka dharma dikhAI dete haiN| koI logoM kI yaha samajha hai ki, vaidika dharma aura bauddha dharma prAcIna hai aura dUsare saba dharma ina donoM se pIche sthApita hue haiM aura jaina dharma bauddhoM kI zAkhA kiMvA bauddhoM ke samAna hone se bauddha ke samakAlIna mAnA jAya to kucha harja nhiiN| isa bAta meM hamArI samajha se aise jJAna rakhanevAloM kI pUrI bhUla hai kyoMki jainadharma ina donoM (vaidika bauddha ) dharmoM se bhI bahuta prAcIna hai yaha bAta hama sapramANa prathama likha Aye haiM isaliye yahA~ likhane kI koI AvazyakatA nahIM hai / jainadharma ko bauddhoM kI zAkhA kiMvA bauddhauM ke samAna samakAlIna mAnanA ajJatA kA sUcaka hai| hA~, zaiva, vaiSNava, zAkta, gANapatya Adi dvaitavAdI, vedAntI, sAMkhya,' pAtaMjala, jaiminIya, kANAda, gautamIya, rAmAnuja, ballabha, mAdhva, guru nAnaka, kabIraM, AryasamAja, brahmasamAja, khAmInArAyaNa ityAdi matoM kI gaNanA vizeSa karake vaidika mata meM hI ho sakatI hai aura ukta paMtho ko vedoM kI zAkhArUpa kiMvA vaidika dharma ke pIche ke kahane se koI harja nhiiN| yadyapi ukta paMthoM kA mantavya vedoM se kucha kucha nahIM bhI milatA aura graMtha bhI pratyeka paMtha vAloM ne 1 prAcIna sAMkhya Adi koI 2 darzana vAle Izvara ko nahIM bhI mAnate haiM

Page #53
apane apane alaga 2 banA liye haiM, tathApi aMta meM veda, upaniSada, zruti, smRti ityAdi graMthoM ke hI zaraNa jAte haiM isaliye ukta paMthoM ko vedAnuyAyI dharma kahA jAya to kucha kSati nahIM hai| kyoMki vaidikoM ne sRSTi kA kartA Izvara ko mAnA hai aura ukta paMtha vAloM ne bhI sRSTi kA kartA Izvara kohI mAnA hai paraMtu sRSTi racanA ke saMbaMdha meM thor3A bahuta paraspara mata bheda sabhI meM hai / vedoM meM hI jaba sRSTi racanA kA eka mata nahIM hai ( aura yaha bAta hama prathama sapramANa likha bhI Aye haiM ) to vedoM ke anuyAyI matoM meM sRSTi nirmANa kA paraspara mata bheda ho isameM Azcarya hI kyA hai ? ukta paMthoM meM paraspara kitanI hI bAtoM kA jo mata bheda hai, usa ora hama isa samaya vicAra karanA nahIM cAhate, balki hama isa jagaha isa bAta kI vizeSa jarUrata hI nahIM samajhate kyoMki yahAM para to hama kevala jagatkartA ke saMbandha meM, athavA jagat kartA mAnane vAle darzanoM ke saMbandha meM ucita zabdoM se hI vicAra karanA yogya samajhate haiN| dUsaroM para jhUThA AkSepa karanA apanI lekhanI ko kalaGkita karanA hai, apazabda likhane se lekhaka kabhI bahAdura nahIM kahA jAsakatA, aura na hama yaha paddhati pasaMda karate haiM / paraMtu jaba jisa bAta kI samAlocanA kI jAtI hai to usa bAta meM ( arthAt pratipakSI zAstroM meM ) jo jo zabda athavA vAkya AyeM ve yadi kAraNa vaza hame lene par3eM to isa bAta meM hama sarvathA doSI nahIM ThaharAye jAsakate, kyoMki hama apanI ora se likheM to doSI bneN| yadi pratipakSiyoM ke vAkya na leveM to AlocanA meM truTi mAlUma ho isalie yadi aisI samhAla karane para bhI pAThakoM ko kahIM anucita mAlUma ho to kSamA kreN| jinako sRSTi Izvara racita mAnane kA haTha hai unake liye sarvazaktimAna Izvara ke saMbandha meM, aura IzvarIya avatAroM ke saMbandha meM, thor3A likhanA ucita samajhA gayA hai:"vedaiH purANaiH smRtibhizca yeSAM, manAMsi nityaM parigarvitAni / pRcchAmi saMdehapadAni teSAM,

Page #54
( 32 ) samIpataH zAstravirodhabhAJji" // 1 // bhAvArtha-veda, purANa, aura smRtiyoM ke kathanoM se jinakA mana garvita huA ho unase aise prazna pUche jAte haiM ki jo vicAra karane ke yogya haiN| "brahmA'pi putrImavasamvadAtmA, vRddho'pi kiM khAM cakame na mohAt, pInastanIbhiH saha gopikAbhiH lakSmIpatiH so'pi ciraM cikhela" // 2 // bhAvArtha-dekhie ! "brahmAjI ne vikAravaza hokara apanI putrI kI ora kudRSTi se dekhA" yahAM bicAra karane kA sthAna hai ki brahmAjI aise sRSTikartA mahArSa ko athavA IzvarIya avatAra ko aisA ayogya kartavya karanA kyA ucita thA ? kitane loga isa bAta ko chipAne ke liye aisA bhI kahate haiM ki prajApati nAma sUrya aura sUrya kI putrI uSA hai| vedoM meM jisa jisa sthAna para aisA likhA hai usa sthAna para aisA samajhanA cAhie ki sUrya uSA ke pIche calatA hai / hamArI ora se ve cAhe jaisA artha kyoM na kareM isameM hamArI yatkiMcit bhI kSati nahIM hai parantu ukta zloka se kyA bhAvArtha dhvanita hotA hai yaha pAThaka samajha leM ! idhara viSNu athavA viSNuavatAra phoDazakalAparipUrNa zrIkRSNajI kI lIlAoM kI ora dekhA jAya to gItagovindAdi kAvyoM meM aura bhAgavatAdi purANa granthoM meM spaSTa likhA hai ki gokula grAma kI gopiyoM ke adharAmRta se aura unake utuGga stanakalazoM ko AliGgana karane kI krIDA se kRSNajI kA mana hArSata hotA thaa| idhara zivajI ke vRttAnta kI ora avalokana karate haiM to spaSTa vidita hotA hai ki: "sa nIlakaNThastripurasya dAhaM, kopAdvitene gaganasthitasya,

Page #55
E pUSA'ndhakAdIca mRdhe jayAma, muktipradaH syAt katamaratvamISu" HAR bhAvArtha-nIlakaNTha [zivajI ne krodha meM Akara, jo rAkSasoM ke AkAza meM tIna nagara (tripura) the unheM jalA diyA ( bhasma kara diyA) aura pUSAndhakAdi daityoM ko yuddha meM mAra DAlA / batalAie ! uparyukta guNavAle Apake trimUrti brahmA, viSNu, ziva, mukti pada ko kaise de sakate hU~ ? nahIM de sakate aura jagatkartA bhI nahIM kahe jA sakate / isaliye Apaloga Izvara ko jagatkartA mAnakara bar3I bhUla meM par3e haiN| kyoMki jo kAma,krodha, lobha aura moha se yukta ho vaha kisa nyAya se Izvara kahAjAsakatA hai ? kabhI nhiiN| dekhie Apake mata ke mahArSa bhatahari ne bhI karma ko pradhAna mAna kara samasta devatAoM ko usake vazIbhUta mAnA hai:"namasyAmo devAnanu hatAviropi bazamA . vidhirvandyaH so'pi pratiniyatakamaikaphaladaH / phalaM karmAyattaM kimamaragaNaiH kiMca vidhinA, ... namastatkarmabhyo vidhirapi na yebhyaH prbhvti"||95|| ... bhAvArtha-hama indrAdika devatAoM ko namaskAra karate haiM parantu devatA vidhi ke vaza haiM isase vidhi ko namaskAra karanA ucita hai kintu vidhAtA bhI pUrva kRta karma ke anusArahI phala detA hai / yadi vidhi svatantra nahIM hai Ara phala karma ke AdhIna hai to devatA aura vidhi se hameM kyA prAyojana hai, isase maiM karma ko hI namaskAra kyoM na karU~ kyoM ki vidhAtA kA bhI karma para sAmarthya nahIM hai / "brahmA yena kulAlavanniyamito brahmANDabhANDodare, _ viSNuryena dazAvatAramahane kSipto mahmasaGkaTe / rudro yena kapAlapANiSuTake bhikSATanaM kAstiH,

Page #56
( 34 ) sUryo bhrAmyati misvameva gagane tasmai namaH karmaNe" 963 // bhAvArtha - jila karma ne jhA ko brahmANDa racane meM kumbhakAra kI taraha lagAyA, aura viSNu ko dazAvatAra grahaNa rUpa bar3e saMkaTa meM DAlA aura ziva ko kapAla hAtha meM leke bhikSA mA~gane meM rakkhA, aura sUrya ko nitya AkAza meM bhramAyA, aise karma ko merA namaskAra hai // uparyukta doloM meM bhartRhari kyA kaha rahe haiM khyAla kIjie ! karmoM kA phala denevAlA jise Apa mAnate haiM usako bhI karma ke Age bhartRhari ne nirarthaka btlaayaa| Azcarya hai ki aise paratantra ko sarvazaktimAn IzvarIyAvatAra kahane meM loga kucha vicAra nahIM karate ! phira bhI thor3A hAla suna lIjie ! : " tapakhizApAnna kathaM vinaSTA, pUrNArikA yAdavamaNDitA'pi / haribhraman kAnanamadhyadeze, bANaprahArAnna kathaM vinaSTaH " // 1 // bhAvArtha- bar3e hI Acarya kI bAta yaha hai ki kRSNAvatAra vidya mAna rahate bhI dvArakA purI tapasvI ke zApa se naSTa ho gaI arthAt ani se jala kara bhasma ho gii| jo auroM kI Apatti dUra karane ko to avatAra dhAraNa kare parantu apanI Apatti dUra na kara sake vaha kaisA Izvara hai / anta meM dvArakA se nikala kara kRSNa jI vana meM gaye, aura vahA~ para bhI eka vadhika ke bANa ke lagane se duHkhI hokara jala ke pyAse hI unheM dehatyAga karanA par3A aise alpazaktimAn manuSyoM ko sarvazaktimAn IzvarAvatAra kahanA bar3I kheda kI bAta hai ! aura bhI thor3A avatAroM kA hAla suna lIjie ! :"cakarta zIrSa svakareNa mAtuH, niHkSatriyAM yaH pRthivIM cakAra /

Page #57
svAti sma teSAM rudhiraitrikAlaM, ... so'pyucyate'nyairmadhusUdanAMzaH" // 1 // bhAvArtha-parazurAma ne apanI mAtAjI (reNukA) kA mastaka apane hAtha se chedana kiyA, aura kSatriyoM ko mArakara pRthivI niHkSatriyA kI, aura unake rudhira se dina meM tIna tIna bAra snAna kiyaa| aise ghRNAkAraka kRtya karanevAloM ko sarvazaktimAna IzvarIyAvatAra kahanA bar3ehI duHkha kI bAta hai kyA yaha nirdayatA nahIM hai ? parantu yaha bAta vaidikoM ke svabhAva hI meM dAkhila ho gaI hai kyoMki ye loga hiMsAko uttama mAnate haiM isIlie yAgAdi meM ye bar3I bhArI hiMsA karate haiN| kaI vaidika yAgAdi meM jo isa samaya hiMsA nahIM karate haiM, yaha jainadharma kA hI prabhAva samajhanA cAhiye aura isa bAta ko vaidika vidvAn kabUla bhI aba thor3A vaidika RSiyoM kA bhI hAla suna lIjie :- . "parAzaraH kAmavazAnna kanyA, divA niSeve ymunaajlsthH| .. vyAsastu bandhordayitAdvayasya, vaidhavyavidhvaMsakaro na jajJe" // 1 // bhAvArtha-parAzara RSi, yamunA nadI meM dhIvara kI kumArI kanyA meM Asakta ho gaye / kyA parAzara sarIkhe nAmI RSi ko yaha kArya karanA ucita thA ! kyA RSiyoM ko aisA kAma karanA anucita nahIM hai ? aura unake putra vyAsa jI ne apane bhrAtAoM (citrAGgada, citravIrya ) kI striyoM kA vaidhavya vidhvaMsa kiyA, aba jarA isa ora khyAla kIjie! kyA ina kAmoM ko Apaloga ayogya nahIM kaheMge? . vidvAna loga to aise kAma karanevAloM ko bezaka burA hI kaheMge ! aisehI Izvara ko jagatkartA-mAnanevAle vaidikalogoM ke aura bhI RSiyoM kI kathAoM ko tarapha khyAla kIjiye / isa samaya bhI kitaneka

Page #58
( 36 ) vaidika jo punarlana (niyoga) ke pakSapAtI haiM, vaha veda vyAsabhI kI hI kRpA kA phala mAnanA caahie| aura jo jo vaidika mitroM ne punarlagna kA niSedha kiyA hai unako zatazaH dhanyavAda denA cAhie kyoM ki ve loka kucha satyapAhI bane haiN| ..::.. .... pAThaka ! Apa loga sarvazaktimAna jagaskartA Izvara ko mAnanevAle mahAzayoM ke netAoM kI AkhyAyikAoM kI ora vicAra kreN| hAM, itanA hama avazya kaha sakate haiM ki zrI kRSNacandrajI,rAmacandrajI aura lakSmaNajI atyanta prabhAvazAlI rAjA hue aura nItimAn , zraddhAvAn tathA Astika the, paraMtu inako sarva zaktimAna IzvarIyAvatAra kahanA unake bhaktoM kI icchA para nirbhara hai, brahmA, viSNu, ziva ko sRSTi ke kartA, hartA mAnanA unake anuyAyI janoM kI zraddhAmAtra hai, vaidika RSiyoM ko dayAvAn athavA ahiMsA ke pakSapAtI mAnanA unake premiyoM ke mana kI bAta hai, parantu yukti tathA pramANa aura AcaraNoM se pratIta hotA hai ki uparyukta bAteM unameM nahIM thIM ? IzAmasIha kA yahUda deza meM utpanna honA, aura zUlI para car3hAkara zatruoM dvArA unakA prANa lenA yaha aitihAsika bAta hai; paraMtu Izvara kA putra kahanA aura saMsAra kA trANakAraka mAnanA arthAt maMsAra kI bhalAI ke liye zUlI para car3hanA yaha IzAI logoM ke nizcaya kI bAta hai, parantu anya matAvalambI mahAzaya isa bAta ko vinA pramANa satya nahIM mAna sakate / isI taraha musalmAnalogoM ke paigambara (nabI) mahammada sAheba kA make meM utpanna honA aura madIne meM paraloka (mRtyu) honA yaha bhI eka aitihAsika bAta hai, parantu allAha ke dvArA inake liye AsamAna se kurAna zarIfa kI kitAba kA bhejanA aura usa kitAba meM likhI bAtoM para vizvAsa lAnA yaha musalmAnoM ke aitakAda kI bAta hai, paraMtu satyavAhI buddhimAna manuSya satyAsatya kA vicAra kara sakate haiN| IzAI aura musalmAnI kitAboM ke bAre meM maiM isa jagaha vizeSa likhanA isalie ThIka nahIM samajhatA ki isI prantha ke dUsareM yA tIsare bhAga meM ina matoM kI avazya samIkSA karanA hai, aura yaha anya kisI pakadharma ko acchA aura dUsare ko burA kahane

Page #59
( 37 ) ke liye nahIM likhA gayA hai, aura na kisI ko acchA burA kahane kI hamArI icchA hai kintu sRSTi kisI kI banAI huI hai yA anAdi hai ? isI bAta ke bAre meM yahAM likhA jA rahA hai / isa prathama bhAga meM vizeSa karake hamAre bhArata ke Arya (hindU) dharmoM meM se jitane jagat kartA Izvara ko mAnate haiM unhIM ke mantavyoM para vicAra kiyA gayA hai aura dUsare yA tIsare vibhAga meM hindustAna ke bAhara ke dharmoM ke bAre meM vicAra kiyA jAyagA / jisa deva kI mUrti hI zAnta vastugatyA dikhalAI nahIM detI vaha kisa yukti se sarvazaktimAna kahA jA sakatA hai ! kisaneka loga mUrti ko nahIM bhI mAnate aura Izvara ko nirAkAra kahakara bhI usako saMsAra kI racanA karane kA doSa dete haiM yaha yuktiyukta nahIM hai, kyoMki nirAkAra se sAkAra padArthoM kA utpanna honA kisI rIti se bhI siddha nahIM ho sakatA ! 1 koI yaha bhI kahate haiM ki yaha zarIra aura isa ke bhItara jo bola rahA hai yaha saba pAMca tattvoM kA khela hai| arthAt pRthivI se haDDI, jala se rudhira, agni se jaTharAgni, vAyu se zvAsa aura AkAza se zUnyatA (polApana) huA hai| evaM ukta pAMca tatvoM se hI saba saMsAra hai arthAt paJcatatvamaya hI saMsAra hai / hama pUchate haiM ki caitanya utpanna karane kI zakti kisa tatva meM hai ? kyo ki taba to pAcoM hI jaDa haiM phira jaDa se caitanya kI utpatti kisa rIti se ho saktI hai / aura yaha kahanA ki paJcabhUtoM ke paraspara sammelana se jIva kI utpatti hai to yaha nitAnta asatya hai kyoMki jaise zuSka vRkSa meM patra, puSpa, phala lagane kA saMbhava nahIM hai tadvat paJcabhUtoM meM caitanya utpanna karane kI zakti nahIM haiM / ataeba yaha mantavya vRthA hai | kitanoM kA yaha bhI kathana hai ki paMcabhUtoM se vizva utpanna huA karatA hai aura jaba mahApralaya hone kA kAla (samaya) AtA hai taba usa samaya sRSTi paJcabhUtoM meM lIna ho jAyA karatI hai aura paMcabhUta Izvara meM lIna ho jAte haiM / isa mantavya ko svIkAra karane vAle yaha nahIM vicAra karate ki paJcabhUta kA Izvara meM lIna honA

Page #60
( 38 ) mAnane se Apa logoM kA Izvara aDapizrita honA siddha hotA hai aura jaDamizrita hone se samala aura nirmala donoM avasthA prApta honI hI caahie| dUsarI bAta yaha hai ki jaDamizrita Izvara hone se ApakA Izvara jyotiHsvarUpa nirAkAra nahIM ho saktA / aura pAMca bhUtoM se jagadutpatti mAniyegA to pAMca bhUta anAdi zAzvata pahile siddhaho cuke haiM, aura anAdi siddha hone se pRthvI, jala, teja, vAyu aura AkAza, ina pAMco bhUtoM ko apane apane dharmAnusAra svAbhAvika kArya karate hI rahanA cAhie phira batalAiye pralaya kaise huA!aura kisa padArtha kA pralaya honA ApamAnate haiM ? yadi isa para koI yaha kahe ki paJcabhUta jagat nirmANa kI kriyA nahIM kara sakate, to dravyarUpa hI nahIM haiM balki kathanamAtra ke hI ThahareMge ? kyoMki padArtha apanA guNa (dharma) nahIM tyAga kara sakatA, yaha svAbhAvika dRDha niyama hai / aura jo yaha mAna liyA jAyagA ki pAMca bhUta anAdi aura anaMta kAla se cale Aye haiM inakA racayitA koI nahIM hai to phira saMsAra bhI anAdi aura ananta kAla kA siddha ho cukaa| aura jaba vizva anAdi ananta kAla kA siddha ho cukA to phira usakI utpattikaranevAlA athavA nAzakaranevAlA kisI ko mAnanA bhrama meM par3anA hai / kaI loga Izvara, jIva, prakRti (svabhAva-kAla-dizA) ityAdi ko anAdi kahakara phira bhI jagat kA kartA Izvara (niraJjana-nirAkAra-sarvajJanitya upamAvAle) ko kahate haiM, kyA yaha pUrvApara virodha se bharA vAkya nahIM hai ? jaba Izvara, jIva, prakRti anAdi siddha haiM to racanA Izvara ne kina padArthoM kI kI ? yadi isake uttara meM yaha kaheMge ki sUkSma rUpa meM se sthUla rUpa kiyA, isaliye hama Izvara ko jagat kA kartA mAnate haiM, to sarva zaktimAn kahA~ rahA ? kyoMki sarva zaktimAna to jaba mAnA jAya ki jaba vaha navIna bhI koI padArtha utpanna kara ske| navIna padArtha to utpanna karane kI usameM zaktihI nahIM hai to vaha eka prakAra kI zakti se rahita hai isse| usakA sarva zaktimattva dharma naSTa ho cukA / jagatkartA mAnane meM kaI doSa Ate haiM tathApi haThI aura kadAprahI isa bAta ko nahIM tyAgate / astu! unake pUrvakRta karmoM kI bAta hai,

Page #61
parantu eka bAra satyamArga ko dikhAdenA hamArA kartavya hai / ___ jagatkartA-mAnanevAloM kA kahanA hai ki vinA Izvara ke saMsAra meM saba padArtha zUnya hai, arthAt Izvara sarva vyApaka hai aura Izvara ke vinA dUsarA padArtha hI nahIM hai, yadi aisAhI hai to dAna-puNya karanevAlA bhI Izvara huA aura lenevAlA bhI Izvara hI huA? ataeva lene dene meM kucha antarahI nahIM rahA ? Izvara ne apanA dAna ApahI le liyA ! phira amuka vyakti ne diyA aura amuka ne liyA, aura denevAle ko bahuta puNya huA ityAdi kahanAhI asatya ThaharegA ? isase to dAna puNya karanAhI vRthA huaa| aisehI mAranevAlA bhI Izvara hai aura maranevAlA bhI Izvara hai ata: Izvara ne Izvara ko mArA ! isameM kisI kA koI bhI zatru mitra na rahA kyoMki donoM meM vyApaka Izvara hai / evaM dravya kA svAmI bhI Izvara hai aura usa dravya kA corAnevAlA bhI Izvara hai isase to apanA dravya ApanehI corAyA ! dUsare ko cora kahane se kyA garaja ? kyoM ki jo Izvara dravyavAle puruSa meM vyApaka hai vahI cora meM bhI to vyApaka hai| tathA varga meM bhI Izvara hai aura naraka meM bhI Izvara hai isase svarga ke sukhoM kA bhI Ananda Izvara ko honA aura naraka ke raurava duHkha kI ghedanA bhI usakohI honA mAnanA cAhie ! puNyavAn svarga jAtA hai aura pApI naraka jAtA hai yaha kahanA bhI jhUThA hogA / parantu smaraNa rahai ki ApakA mantavya uparyukta dRSTAntoM se asatya ho cukaa| ghaTa ghaTa meM (pudgala pudgala meM-zarIra-zarIra meM) jIva alaga alaga hai aura unake karma bhI pRthak pRthak haiM / jo loga sAre saMsAra meM Izvara ko vyApaka kahate haiM unakI pUrI bhUla hai / itane para bhI jinako isa bAta kI haTha ho unase hama pUchate haiM ki yadi eka Izvara sarva vyApaka hai to caMDAla, rAjA, AdikoM ko ucca, nIca kahane se kyA garaja ? eka puNya kare to usakA phala sAre saMsAra ko kyoM nahIM milatA ? eka ke naraka bhAgI hone se sArA saMsAra hI naraka kA bhAgI kyoM nahIM hotA? eka zrImAn hone se sArI sRSTi zrImAna kyoM nahIM hotI ? aura eka bhikSuka hone se sArI sRSTi bhikSuka kyoM nahIM ho jAtI kintu ukta bAteM to nahIM hotI, phira saba padArthoM meM ekahI paramAtmA vyApaka hama

Page #62
( 40 ) kisa nyAyA se mAne ? isase siddha huA ki eka mAtmA sarvavyApaka mahIM hai| jo jo sRSTi kA kartA Izvara ko kahate haiM unako smaraNa rahe ki yadi sRSdhi Izvara kI racI huI hai to jitane jaganniyantA Izvara kI bhakti karate haiM una saba ko aura jo no Izvara ko jagatkartA svIkAra karate haiM unako bhI sukhI rakhanA jaganiyantA ko ucita hai ! parantu jaganniyantA ko mAnanevAle bahuta se loga mahAn duHkhI bhI dikhalAI par3ate hai / jaganniyantA Izvara ko ucita thA ki o jo loga jagatkartA ko nahIM mAnate haiM unake saMmukha Akara spaSTa kahate ki sRSTi kA phartA hartA maiM hU~ ! tuma sRSTikartA ko nahIM mAnate isa lie maiM tumAre samIpa AyA hU~ ! aisA kyoM nahIM kiyA ? kyA isa kAma ko karane kI usameM zakti nahIM thI? kyA sarva zaktimAna meM hama logoM ko samajhAne kI sAmarthya nahIM hai? kyA pRthA hI sarvazaktimAna kahalAne kA dAvA rakhatA hai ? kyA sRSTi utpanna karate samaya yaha nahIM socA thA ki ye mere ko jagatkartA nahIM mAnanevAle merA khaNDana kareMge isalie inako na banAU~ ? jaba saMsAra kA kartA koI haihI nahIM so uparyukta bAteM kahA~ se hoN| Izvara ko jagatkartA mAnanA hI bhrama hai| isa samaya bhI sRSTi ko akartajanya anAdi ananta mAnane vAloM kI saMkhyA kucha kama nahIM hai| jaina, bauddha, aura prAcIna sAMkhyakAra ityAdi sRSTi ke kartA ko nahIM mAnate, to ina dharmAvalambiyoM ko Apake Izvara ne kyoM racA ? isakA uttara dIjiye / jagat kA kartA mAnanevAle jaba apanA pakSa nirbala dekhate haiM taba yaha bhI kahane ko taiyAra ho jAte haiM ki hama Izvara se nirmANa kiye gaye haiM parantu jaisA hamArA zubhAzubha karma hogA vaisAhI hamako phala Izvara dvArA prApta hogA / dekhie pAThaka ! prathama to eka Izvara kohI pakar3a kara baiThe the parantu phira dUsare kI tarkatApa se bacane ke liye karma kI ora jhuke, karmoM kA phala IzvaradvArA prApta honA mAnane meM na mAlUma IzvaravAdiyoM ko kyA lAbha hotA hai ? jaba Izvara apanI ora se kucha nahIM de sakatA to phira kartA hartA vaha kisa nyAya se siddha ho saktA hai| yadi kevala aisAhI mAna liyA jAya ki sukha, duHkha vavakarmAnusAra prApta

Page #63
( 41 ) hote haiM aura karmA bhoktA Izvara nahIM hai kintu svataH jIva hI hai aura isameM Izvara se kucha sambandha nahIM hai to vivAda karane kA kAraNahI nahIM rhtaa| vyartha Izvara ko kartA, hartA, sarvavyApaka Adi kahakara saMsArI duHkhoM meM vibhakta hone kA kalaGka denA buddhimAnoM kA kAma nahIM hai / kyoMki Izvara anAdi ananta sukhoM ko chor3akara sAMsArika duHkhoM meM vibhakta kyoM hogA ? ___ kaI logoM kA yaha mantavya hai ki sRSTi Izvara kI racita hone se saba padArthoM meM IzvarIya kalA hai / yadi yaha bAta satya ho to vidvAn aura mUrkha meM bheda kyoM mAnA jAtA hai ? kyA vidvAnoM meM hI IzvarIya kalA hai aura mUoM meM nahIM hai ? aisA ho nahIM sktaa| jaba sabhI meM IzvarIya kalA hai to nAnA prakAra kI vicitra racanA saMsAra meM kyoM hai ? manuSya, ghaTa paTAdi padArtha ko banA saktA hai aura zvAna, rAsabha, zUkara, mArjAra, vyAghrAdi pazu prANI, ghaTa paTAdi padArtha nahIM banA sakate, yaha bAta saba koI jAnate haiM / kyA pazuoM meM IzvarIya kalA nahIM hai ? Apa ina pazuoM ko kalAhIna kaheMge, yA kalA sahita ? ApakA to yaha mantavya hai ki saba padArthoM meM IzvarIya kalA hai phira pazu mUrkhAdi aneka kArya karane meM aura vicArazakti meM hIna kyoM haiM ? yadi yaha kahA jAya ki saba meM samAna kalA nahIM hai kintu nyUnAdhika hai to ApakA Izvara anyAyI ThaharA ! eka ko vizeSa kalA denA aura dUsare ko nyUna denA yaha pakSapAta huA yA nahIM ? kyA Izvara kA bhI koI zatru mitra hai ? yA usako kisI kI ora se lAbha yA hAni hone kA saMbhava hai ? ki jisase kisIko nyUna aura kisIko adhika kalAe~ denI par3IM ! yadi usake zatru mitra nahIM haiM to yaha anyAya huA yA nahIM ? hamArI samajha se to padArthoM meM aizvarIya kalAe~ mAnanA anucita hai| kitaneka kahate haiM ki jaganniyantA prabhu bhaktavatsala hai aura khecchA se avatAra (janma) dhAraNa karatA hai / yadi Izvara bhaktavatsala hai to bhaktajana jvara tApa, AdhI vyAdhI, janma jarA mRtyu vagairaha aneka prakAra ke duHkhoM se duHkhI kyoM dIkhate haiM ? yadi bhaktavatsale ho to apane bhaktoM ko bar3e bar3e kaSTa kyoM pAne detA hai. ? asaMkhyAta .

Page #64
bhakta sajjana; saMbandhI kuTumba parivAra ko duHkhI tyAgakara paraloka cale jAte haiN| yadi ApakA prabhu bhaktavatsala hotA to bhaktoM ko aura bhaktoM ke parivAra ko kyoM duHkhI hone detA? kyA bhaktoM kI Ayu adhika kara dene kI zakti sarvazaktimAn-bhaktavatsala Izvara meM nahIM hai ? yadi hai to duHkhI kyoM ? isase yahI pratIta hotA hai ki ApakA Izvara bhakta vatsala nahIM hai / jaba jagat kA kartAhI Izvara siddha nahIM hosaktA to phira dUsarI bAteM kahA~ se siddha ho skeNgii| Izvara ko jagat kA kartA mAnanevAloM kI yaha bhI samajha hai ki saba padArthoM kA adhiSThAna Izvara hai, aura IzvarIya icchA se saba kRtyAkRtya hote haiM to ghaTa paTa kyoM nahIM hojAtA ! jaise ghaTa kA kAraNa mRttikApiMDa hai isaliye mRttikApiMDa se ghaTotpatti hotI hai paraMtu mRttikApiMDa se paTAdika kArya nahIM hosakate / vaise hI paTa kA kAraNa tantu hai isase paTotpatti hotI hai paraMtu tantu se ghaTAdi padArtha kabhI nahIM bana sakate / yadi Apa isabAta ko svIkAra nahIM kareMge to kAraNa se kAryotpatti honA mithyA kaha denA cAhie ! yadi Apako jaganniyantA Izvara para itanA pakSapAta hai to ApakA adhiSThAna Izvara, ghaTa ko paTa aura paTa ko ghaTa kyoM nahIM karadiyA karatA ? jo loga Izvara ko jagat kA kAraNa adhiSThAna batalAte haiM vaha unakI bhUla hai / jagat kA kAraNa Izvara kisI yukti yA pramANa se siddha nahIM hosaktA / ataeva siddha huA ki Izvara adhiSThAna nahIM hai aura IzvarIya icchA se kRtyAkRtya mAnanA yukti yA pramANa se nahIM siddha hotA / ___ sRSTi ko Izvararacita mAnanevAle yaha bhI mAnate haiM ki brahmA ke mukha se brAhmaNa, bhujAoM se kSatriya, jaMghAo se vaizya aura pAvoM se zuddha utpanna hue / mukha bhujA jaMghAoM se utpanna hone ke kAraNa ina tInoM kI dvija saMjJA hai aura zUdra pAvoM se utpanna huA isa se dvija nahIM hai| arthAt zUdra nIcI jAti kI saMjJA hai / dekhie ! mahAzaya ! yaha kaisA pUrvApara viruddha hai ! eka jagaha kahanA ki Izvara ne sabhI padArtha kI racanA kI hai aura dUsarI jagaha kahanA ki brahmAjI ne brAhmaNa-kSatriya-vaizya

Page #65
aura zUdra ko racA / yadi tarkatApa se bacane ke lie aisA kaheM ki brahmA kahane se Izvara hI ko yahA~ lenA cAhiye; hama Izvara ko brahmA bhI kahate haiM to kyA nirAkAra Izvara ke bhI hAtha pA~va mukha Adika hote haiM ? yadi hote haiM to usako nirAkAra kahanA mithyA hai| nirAkAra kA artha AkArarahita hotA hai kintu hAtha pA~vavAlA kabhI nirAkAra nahIM kahA jAsakatA / brahmAjI ne brAhmaNa kSatriya vaizya aura zUdra ko-mukha-bhujAjaMghA aura pAvoM se utpanna kiyA isa kAraNa ye uttama-madhyama-jaghanya jAti kahI jAtI haiM aisA vaidika mAnate haiM aura isIse vaidika loga brAhmaNoM ko sarvocca mAnate haiM / kSatriya usase kama aura vaizya usase kama aura zUdra ko sabase nIce kI paMkti meM ginA hai yahAM vicAra karane kA sthAna hai ki kartA ne brAhmaNAdi vargoM ke zarIra ke cinha (avayava) hI alaga alaga kyoM nahIM karadiye ? kiM jisase guNa-karma-svabhAva kI parIkSA karane kA bhI koI kAraNa nahIM rhtaa| kyA sRSTikartA ko varNAzramoM meM zArIraka cinha karadene kI kaThanAI par3atI thI? aura dUsarI bAta yaha hai ki guNa-karma-svabhAva-se varNAzramoM kI vyavasthA lagAne se bahuta kucha vivAda upasthita hone kA sthAna hai / jaisA ki eka manuSya brAhmaNa kula meM utpanna huA aura usake guNa-karmakhabhAva zUdra ke haiM aura dUsarA zUdrakula meM utpanna huA aura guNa karma svabhAva brAhmaNa ke haiM, phira batalAiye kisako brAhmaNa kahanA aura kisako zUdra / kyoMki brAhmaNakula meM utpanna hue manuSya ko zUdra kaheMge to usakA vivAhAdi saba vyavahAra zUdrajAti meM hI honA cAhie ? aura zUdrajAti meM utpanna hue manuSya ko guNa-karmasvabhAva se brAhmaNa kaheMge to usakA vivAha Adi saba vyavahAra brAhmaNajAti meM hI honA cAhie ? aura yadi aisA honA saba mAna leM to varNavyavasthA kadApi ThIka nahIM raha saktI / isa bAta ko kitaneka vaidika mAnate haiM aura kitaneka niSedha bhI karate haiN| jo loga brahmAjI ke mukha-bhujA-jaMghA aura pAMvoM se cAro varNoM kI utpatti mAnate haiM unhIko vicAra karanA cAhie ki brahmAjI ke mukha se utpanna honevAle

Page #66
( 44 ) brAhmaNa mAtAdvArA janma lete haiM yaha kyoM ? unakeliye brahmAjI ko avazya aisA prabaMdha karadenA thA ki ve guhyasthAnadvArA janma na lete ! yadi mukhadvArA janma dhAraNa karate to avazya hama mAnate ki brAhmaNoM kI utpatti brahmA ke mukha se hai paraMtu yaha bAta to hai nahIM sabhI varNa mAtA ke udara meM se hI janma dhAraNa karate haiM isase yaha spaSTa hai ki cAro varNoM kI utpatti brahmA ke mukhAdi sthAnoM se mAnanA bhrama hai| 3. kaI aisA bhI kahate haiM ki Izvara pRthvI kA bhAra utArane ke liye avatAra lekara asura pApI janoM kA saMhAra karatA hai aura devoM kI rakSA karatA hai| hama pUchate haiM ki Izvara ne asura-pApI janoM ko utpannahI kisa liye kiyA ! prathama utpanna hI nahIM karatA to pRthvI ke Upara bhAra hone kA koI kAraNahI nahIM thA aura avatAra dhAraNakara mRtyuloka meM Ane kA parizrama bhI nahIM uThAnA par3atA / tathA matsyakaccha-vArAha-nRsiMha Adi tiryak yonI meM bhI janma nahIM dhAraNa karanA pdd'taa|aashcry hai ki ApakA Izvara sukha ko chor3a svataH duHkha meM Ane kA upAya karatA hai arthAt pazuoM kA bhI rUpadhAraNa karatA hai| dUsarI bAta yaha hai ki devatAoM kI rakSA karanA aura asura yAne rAkSasoM kA saMhAra karanA isase Apake Izvara meM rAga dveSa kA honA siddha hotA hai aura rAgadveSI ko Izvara kahanA sarvathA ayukta hai / kyoMki rAga-dveSa Izvara ke lie dUSaNa hai aura Izvara ko hamezA nirdUSaNa honA cAhie / dUsarI bAta yaha hai ki Apaloga to yaha mAnate haiM ki IzvarIya vibhUti vinA saMsAra meM koI padArthahI nahIM hai isase to deva tathA dAnava donoM meM bhI IzvarIyavibhUti honIhI cAhie / tathA rAkSasoM meM IzvarIyavibhUti yadi Apa mAneMge to Izvara ne svataH apanI vibhUti kA nAza (saMhAra) kiyA aura yadi aisA nahIM mAneMge to "IzvarIyavibhUti vinA saMsAra meM koI padArtha nahIM hai" yaha kahanA asatya huA ! dhanya hai IzvaravAdI jI Apake takoM ko| koI yaha bhI kahate haiM ki Izvara ne putalA racakara strI ke udara meM rkhdiyaa| parantu hamArI samajhase yaha bAta to nitAnta asatya hai kyoMki

Page #67
saba jIvoM ke zarIra kI racanA apane 2 pUrvakarmAnubandha ke anusAra hI hotI hai| isa bAta ko jo na mAne usase hama pUchate haiM ki eka zrImAn , aura dUsarA dIna, eka rAjA, aura dUsarA raMka, eka rUpavAn, aura dUsarA kurUpa, eka jJAnI aura dUsarA ajJAnI, eka paMDita aura dUsarA mUrkha, aisI vicitra racanA jagat kI kyoM dIkha rahI hai ? kyA kisI ne Izvara kA bhalA burA kiyA thA ? / isase siddha huA ki jaisA 2 jIvoM kA pUrvakRta karmoM kA bandha hotA hai vaisA 2 rUpa-raMga-AkRti-mukhaduHkha-jJAna-ajJAna prApta huA karatA hai / jagatkartA mAnane vAle nirdUSaNa-nirAkAra paramAtmA ko rAgI-dveSI banAkara kumbhakAra ke samAna saMsArI jIvoM ke zarIroM (pudgala ) ko rAtadina arthAt barAbara racane kA kalaMka (doSa) nirarthaka dete haiN| IzvaravAdI rAgAdi ke baza se haTha nahIM tyAga karate, to unako ucita hai ki isa bAta ko jarA zoceM ki Izvara ne jaba jIvoM ko racA usa samaya nirmala racA yA malIna ? yadi nirmala racA kahiyegA to dharmazAstra (zruti-smRti-kurAna. bAibila vagairaha jagat kartA mAnane vAloM ke Aptagrantha) kisako pavitra (nirmala) karane ko race gaye? kyoMki pavitra zAstra to malIna ko pavitra karatA hai| jaba jIvoM ko Adi se hI nirmala racA phira malIna hone kA kyA kAraNa huA ? / evaM buddhi Izvaradatta mAnane se jIvoM ne malInatA svataH lI yaha bhI nahIM kaha sakate aura IzvaranedI yaha bhI kahanA ayukta hai kyoMki Izvara kyA jIvoM ko malIna hone kI durbuddhi detA hai ? yadi kahA jAya ki paramezvara ne jIvoM ko malIna hI racA thA to kyA jIvoM ke pApa kiye vinA hI pAparUpa malInatA lagA dI ? yadi kahoge hAM, to aise anyAyI ko kauna buddhimAn Izvara kaha saktA hai| yadi kahAjAya, ki Izvara svecchA se saba jIvoM ko sukha duHkha detA hai to maiM pUchatA hU~ ki icchA Izvara se bhinna hai yA abhinna ? yadi bhinna hai to Izvara kI icchA hI nahIM kaha sakate, kyoMki bhinna hone se Izvara se kucha saMbandha nahIM hai / yadi kahA jAya abhinna hai arthAt Izvara meM hai to kSaNa bhara meM utpanna honA aura kSaNa bhara meM vinAza honA, yaha

Page #68
nitya paramezvara meM vyApaka icchA kA virodha AtA hai / isase kaha sakte haiM ki uparyukta bAta yuktiyukta nahIM mAlUma hotii| . kaI aisA bhI mAnate haiM ki- Izvara vAyu calAtA hai, megha varSAtA hai, aura jo kucha hotA jAtA hai, vaha saba Izvara hI karatA hai usakI zakti agAdha hai, isake uttara meM hama pUchate haiM ki Izvara ko aise kArya karane meM kyA kucha lAbha hai ? ki jo itanA agAdha parizrama karatA rahatA hai| yadi kahoge ki lAbha hai; to kyA abhItaka asalI svarUpa meM kucha nyUnatA rahagaI hai ! ki jo parizrama karake milAnA cAhatA hai ? / yadi kahoge ki Izvara ko kucha milAnA nahIM hai to vicAra karane kA sthAna hai ki phira usake samAna dUsarA ajJAnI hI kauna hai ki jo vinAhI kucha lAbha ke itanA nirarthaka zrama karatA rahatA hai| kaI kahate haiM ki Izvara ne sRSTi isa vAste racI hai ki isa vicitra racanA ko dekha jIva mere para vizvAsa laaveN| dekhie-mahAzaya ! yaha kaisI tarka hai! / saMsArI jIvoM ko vizvAsa karAne kI abhilASA Izvara ko kyoM huI? kyA saMsArI jIvoM se kisI prakAra kA Izvara ko vyApAra (rojagAra) karanA thA ? ki jisase prathamahI yaha bandobasta karaliyA ki merA vizvAsa hogA to merI huMDI patrI saMsAra meM clegii| kyA ApakA jaganiyantA prabhu itanA lAlacI hai? jo saMsArI jIva Apake Izvarapara vizvAsa na rakkheM to kyA isameM Izvara kI kucha hAni hai ? yadi kahoge ki na to lAbha hai aura na hAni hai to phira sRSTi ko vizvAsa lAne ke liye saMsAra racanA karane kA parizrama uThAne kA kyA prayojana huA ! ataeva jagat IzvarakRta siddha nahIM hotA / Azcarya hai ki IzvaravAdI aisI aisI kamajora tarka karate hue kucha vicAra hI nahI karate haiM ! jagat kA kartA Izvara ko mAnanevAle jaisA mantavya jagatkartRtva ke saMbandha meM rakhate haiM vaisAhI Azcaryajanaka mantavya mukti ke bhI saMbandha meM rakhate haiM / saMsArI jIvoM ke lie antima sAdhya mukti hai| jitanI kriyAjIva dhArmika buddhi se karatA hai vaha saMsAra se mukta hokara AdhyAtmika

Page #69
sukha kI prApti ke lie karatA hai / isase isa sthAnapara mukti ke vAre meM bhI thor3A likhanA aprAsaMgika aura arocaka na hogaa| sRSTi kA kartA mAnanevAle kaI sajjana to jaisA Izvara ko sarvavyApaka mAnate haiM vaisA mukti kA bhI sthAna kisI bhI eka jagaha nizcita nahIM mAnate / unakA kahanA hai ki muktAtmA saMkalpamaya zarIra hokara brahma meM vicarA karate haiN| kyA mAlUma isa mantavya ko svIkAra karanevAloM ke brahma kA kaunasA sthAna hai ! hamArI samajha se to mukti kA sthAna Aniyata mAnane se mukta AtmA kA pavitra ora apavitra sthAnoM meM bhI vicaranA ina logoM ko mAnanA cAhie ! kyoMki sthAnahI jaba niyata nahIM hai to apavitra sthAna meM muktAtmA jAve isa meM AzcaryahI kyA hai ? aisI mukti unakA Izvara unhIM ko de| muktajIva sthUla zarIra tyAgakara saMkalpamaya zarIra se AkAza dvArA paramezvara meM vicarate haiM aura brahma meM Ananda, niyata samaya taka bhogate haiM ki punaH mahAkalpa ke pazcAt saMsAra meM Ate haiM arthAt 'parAMta kAla taka mukti meM rahate haiM phira mukta AtmA pIche saMsAra meM lauTa Ate haiM / vAha ! IzvaravAdIjI ! ! ApakI mukti bhI khUba hai ! mukta AtmA ko pIche saMsAra meM lauTa Ane kA kAraNa kyA hai ? kyA muktAtmA jIva mukti se nArAja hokara svataH cale Ate haiM yA ApakA sarvazaktimAna Izvara unako mukti meM se dhakkA dekara girA detA hai ? yadi svataH saMsAra meM AnA kahoge to yaha batalAnA hogA ki AdhyAtmika sukha ko chor3a sAMsArika duHkhoM meM kyoM Ate haiM ? yadi kahoge ki paramezvara unako AjJA detA hai to pharamAiye unako sukha se duHkha meM lAne kA kyA kAraNa huA ? dekhiye yaha kaisI vicitra mukti hai ! jaise kisI strI kA zvazuragRha aura mAtRgRha / mana kI icchA huI jaba strI sAsara calI jAtI hai aura mana kI icchA hotI hai jaba pIhara calI AyA karatI hai aisI Apa logoM kI mukti hai| . 1 taiMtAlisa lAkha, bIsa hajAra varSoM kI eka caturyugI, do hajjAra caturyugI kA eka ahorAtra, aise tIsa ahorAtra kA eka mahInA, aise bAraha mahIne kA eka varSa aise sau varSoM kA parAnta kAla hotA hai / aisA satyArthaprakAza ke navama samullAsa meM likhA hai / kahIM aisA bhI mAnA gayA hai ki ikatIsa nikharva, daza kharba, cAlIsa arvavarSoM kA eka parAnta kAla hotA hai|

Page #70
(48 ) kaIloga muktipAMca prakAra kI mAnate haiM-1sAlokya-2-sAmIpya3-sAyujya-4saoNrTi-5ekatva / kintu yahabhI ThIka nahIM hai; aba hama mukti kA saccA svarUpa likhate haiM, paDhie !: (sragdharAvRttam) nAtyantAbhAvarUpA, naca jaDimamayI, vyomavavyApinI no, na vyAvRttiM dadhAnA viSayasukhaghanA nekSyate srvvidbhiH| sadrUpA''tmaprasAdA dRgavagamaguNaughA na saMsArasArA, niHsImA'tyakSasaukhyodayavasatiraniSpAtinI muktiruktA 1 bhAvArtha- bauddhoM kI mAnI huI atyantAbhAva svarUpavAlI mukti nahIM hai, naiyAyika aura vaizeSikoM kI mAnI huI jaDasvarUpavAlI bhI mukti nahIM hai, AjIvaka aura AryasamAjiyoM kI mAnI huI AkAza kI taraha vyApaka aura anya se vyAvartana svabhAva ko dhAraNa karane vAlI bhI mukti nahIM hai, yavanoM kI mAnI huI viSaya sukha se vyApta bhI mukti nahIM hai, kintu sarvajJoM ne isase viparIta arthAt bhAvasvarUpa vAlI AtmA kI prasannatAvAlI jJAna darzanAdi anekaguNa samUha vAlI sAMsArika sukhoM se rahita aura niHsIma atIndriya sukhavAlI udaya kA sthAna aura phira jisase patana nahIM (nitya) hai aisI mukti hai| mukta hue bAda lokAgra bhAga meM azarIrI hokara "jalatumbikA nyAyena" sthira rahanA mAnA hai, AtmA kA muktahue bAda punaH saMsAra meM lauTa AnA mAnanA ayukta hai / lokAgra bhAga meM AdhyAtmika sukho meM magna rahanA mAnanA yukta hai| pAThakavarga! vicAra kareM, ki mukti kA svarUpa kauna sA yukta hai aura kauna sA ayukta ? mukti ke saMbandha meM 1 viSNuloka meM jAke rhnaa| 2 Izvara ke najadIka jAke baiThanA / 3 Izvara meM yukta hojAnA athavA Izvara se paraspara milajAnA / 4 Izvara ke samAna aizvaryavAna hojaanaa| 5 Izvara ke rUpa meM milajAnA athavA eka hojaanaa|''

Page #71
( 49 ) yahA~ para isase vizeSa likhane kI AvazyakatA nahIM mAlUma hotI, avasara milA to phira kisI sthAnapara isa viSaya kI mImAMsA kI jAyagI / Izvara ko jagatkartA mAnanevAloM ne sRSTi kI taraha, mukti ke vAre meM jo 2 kalpanAe~ kI haiM usakA yaha namUnA hai: kaI loka yaha dalIla karate haiM ki:-"zaMkarAcArya aise vidvAnoM kA yaha mata hai ki saba saMsAra brahmarUpa hai aura nAnA prakAra kA jo prapaJca dikhAI detA hai vaha saba mAyAjanya hai| isIlie dvaita mAnanA ThIka nahIM, arthAt advaita hai| jagat kA nimitta aura upAdAna kAraNa brahmahI hai / jagat satya apaneko bhAsa hotA hai isakA kAraNa mAyA hai. aura mAyA kA svarUpa anirvAcya hai / mAyA ko "sat " yAne, 'hai' bhI nahIM kaha sakate, athavA " asata', yAne 'nahIM' bhI nahIM. kaha sakate haiM / hai aisA kaheM. to mAyA. paramArtha dRSTi se bhramAtmaka hai, nahIM aisA kaheM to vyavahAra dRSTi se mAyA satya hai / zaMkarasvAmI ke mata se jIva aura paramAtmA do nahIM haiM arthAt ekahI hai" isa para zrImAn hemacandrAcAryajI mahArAja kA jo kathana hai vaha sunie : "mAyA satI cet iyatattvasiddhirathAsatI hanta kutaH prapaJcaH / mAyaiva cedarthasahA ca tat kim, mAtA ca vandhyA ca bhavet pareSAm // 1 // bhAvArtha-yadi mAyA sat rUpa hai to do tattva kI siddhi huI-eka brahma aura dvitIyA mAyA (isase to brahmAdvaitavAda ke mUlameMhI kuThAra mAranA huA) yadi asat rUpa hai to AkAzapuSpavat avastu rUpahoneH se nAnA prakAra ke prapaJca ko mAyAjanita kahanA kisa rIti se saMbhava ho sakatA hai arthAt asaMbhava hai| jisako mAtA kahanA aura usIko bandhyA 1 avidyA. 7

Page #72
bhI kahanA, yaha kisa yukti se siddha hosaktA hai ! yadi mAtAhI hai to bandhyA kaise ho sakatI hai aura yadi bandhyAhI hai to mAtA kahanA ayukta hai / brahmAdvaitavAdI jI ! Apake vacanoM meM yaha pratyakSa virodha AyA yA nahIM ? aura jaba Apake mata se jagat kA nimitta aura upAdAna kAraNa brahmahI hai to phira mAyA ko vyavahAradRSTi se sat aura pAramArthika dRSTi se asat kahanA yaha dUsaroM kI tarkatApa se bacane kA upAya hai yA nahIM ? kintu isa vAgjAla ko, samajhanevAle turanta samajha sakate haiN| jaba jIva aura Izvara do nahIM haiM to avidyA (mAyA) ke bhrama meM jIva kyoM phasate haiN| kyA jIva Izvara hokara bhI mAyA se vaMcita nahIM rahatA ? zaMkarasvAmI maMDanamizra kI strI se kAmacarcA meM hAra gaye the isase to ve svataH mAyA ke phAMsa meM phase siddha hote haiN| Apaloga jisa zaMkarAcArya ko sarvajJa mAnate haiM jaba vehI mAyA ke phAMsa meM phase to unake race zAstra amAyika kaise ho sakate haiM ? nahIM ho sakate / ata eva vedAntiyoM kA brahmAdvaitavAda yukti vikalahI ThaharA / jaba jIva aura paramAtmA meM bheda nahIM hai to phira vyavahAra dRSTi se mAyA sat aura paramArtha dRSTi se asat kahanA ayukta hai / bhalA kahIM brahma arthAt paramAtmAsvarUpa jIva ke bhI do dRSTi hotI haiM ? dhanya hai ApakI pratibhA ko! __ nyAyasiddhAntamuktAvalI kI bhUmikA meM likhA hai ki"darzanakAroM ke paraspara virodha ke mUlabhUta bhagavAn bhASyakAra bhagavatpAda zrI 108 zaMkarAcAryahI haiN| inase prathama, sAMkhya yogAdi uttama siddhAntoM ke nirAkaraNa karane meM kisI Astika vidvAn kA sAhasa na huA thA kintu sAMkhyasiddhAntoM ke sahita usake kartA ko aprAmANika ThaharAne meM tathA gautama, kaNAda ko vainAzikatulya batalAkara unake siddhAntoM ko dhUlI meM milAne meM evaM dharmamImAMsA ke mUlocchedana meM yaha prathama 2 bhagavatI bhagavatpAdahI kI lekhanI pravRtta huI hai " Age phira likhA hai ki 1 baMbaI meM kSemarAja zrIkRSNadAsajI ke veMkaTezvara sTIma presa meM chapI hai|

Page #73
"bicAre kapila ko lather3anA Arambha kiyA aura yahAMtaka lather3A ki zrutismRtipratipAdya sarvajJa kapiladeva vAsudevAMza rUpa meM jo avatIrNa hue theveaura hI haiM aura yaha dvaitavAdI sAMkhya zAstra kA kartA koI avaidika kapila hai ityAdi sabhI kucha khaa|" Age phira likhA hai ki"kapila, kaNAda, gautama, pataJjali, tathA jaimini ye pAMco darzanakAra to nAnAtmavAdI hone se avaidikahI haiN| zeSa rahe vyAsadeva so inakA bhI yogasUtroM ke bhASya meM to nAnA cidAtmavAdahI siddhAnta hai ina ko bhI cAhe Apa vaidika mAne yA avaidika " / Age phira likhA hai ki- "aba hamako yahAM sandeha utpanna hotA hai ki kapilAdi Sad maharSi avaidika haiM yA eka bhagavatpAda zrI 108 zaMkarakhAmIhI a. vaidika haiM ? paraspara viruddha lekha hai isaliye donoM meM eka koTI avazya nirbala honI cAhiye / 'kauna honI cAhiye ?' isako vidvAna loga svayaM soceN| phira Age likhA hai ki-"gautama aura kaNAda ke siddhAnta para jo Apane mithyA AkSepa kiyA hai vaha hamako sarvathA asahya hai|" usake Age likhA hai ki-"zaMkara svAmI ne sAMkhyAdi sarva darzanoM se viruddha eka apanI DhAIpAva judAhI pAI hai " / ityAdi bahuta kucha parAmarza kiyA hai / jisako dekhanA ho vaha nyAya siddhAnta muktAvalI kI bhUmikA dekhale / kaIloka kahate haiM ki 'zaMkara svAmI ne jaina mata kA mUla ukhAr3A aura vaidika dharma kI punaH sthApanA kI, isa para hamArA yaha uttara paryApta hai ki uparyukta bhUmikA ke lekhaka ne zaMkara svAmI ko 'avaidika the' aisA spaSTa likhA hai phira unhIMko vaidika hama kisa AdhAra se kaha sakate haiM, aura jaba apane pUrvaja kapilAdi maharSiyoM kI nindA karate jinako vicAra na huA taba ve dUsaroM ko yadi bhalA burA kaheM to isameM AzcaryahI kyA ? parantu aise kahane se kyA hosakatA hai| zaMkara svAmI kI kyA zakti thI ki ve jaina dharma ko mUla se ukhAr3a sake hoN| jainadarzana avicchinna rUpase Ajataka calA AyA hai aura AjabhI jaina darzana ke aneka zAstra vidyamAna haiM isase aisA kahanevAle pratyakSa hI jhUThe Thaharate haiN| ghara meM baiThakara apane se apanI racita

Page #74
pustakoM meM koI cAhe jaisA kyoM na likhe kyoMki lekhanI apane hAtha kI hotI hai| vedavyAsa jI ke aura zaMkara svAmI ke lekhoMpara cAhe unake matAnuyAyI vizvAsa rakkheM, kintu anya nahIM rakha skte| vicArane kA sthAna hai ki kaI vaidikoM ne bhI Apako avaidika batalAyA hai aura advaitavAda para kaTAkSa kiyA hai| yaha bAta pAThaka uparyukta lekha se bhalI bhA~ti samajha sakate haiM / AnandAgiri kRta zaMkaradigvijaya aura mAdhavakRta zaMkaradigvijaya meM jainamata ke khaNDana meM jo jaina sAdhuoM ke upakaraNa aura jaina sAdhuoM se vAdAnuvAda likhe haiM vaha nitAnta jhUTha aura kalpita haiM kyoMki jainazAstroM meM jo bAteM nahIM haiM vaisI kalpita bAteM praznottara rUpa meM likhakara jainadharma ko khaNDana karanA samajhaliyA hai parantu aisA karane se kyA hosakatA hai ? jisako isa bAta ke saMbandha meM satyAsatya kA nirNaya karanA ho vaha jainazAstra aura zaMkara digvijaya yaha donoM ko milAkara dekhe to mAlUma hojaaygaa| vyAsajI se aura zaMkara svAmI se syAhAda nyAya kA khaMDana na hosakA, kyoMki do cAra zabda yA vAkya apane race pustako meM likha denese khaMDana nahIM kahA jA sakatA, khaMDana usakA nAma hai ki jisa yukti aura pramANa se dUsare kI dalIleM tor3I jAveM? basa isIse kaha sakate haiM ki syAdvAda nyAya kA khaMDana unase na ho sakA / khaMDana to dUrahI rahA paraMtu ve syAdvAda nyAya ko pUrA pUrA samajhabhI nahIM sake aura kitanI bAtoM meM jo zaMkara svAmI ne syAdvAda nyAya kA gupta sahArA liyA hai vaha spaSTa dikhAI detA hai dekhie ? / advaita'mImAMsA meM likhA hai ki: aupaniSad siddhAntoM ke vyAkhyAtA ne viSaya bheda se cAravarga banAye haiM (1) brahma (2) jagadutpatti (3) AtmA aura (4) mukti (jagadutpatti ke ora nirIkSaNa karane se spaSTa vidita hotA hai ki zaMkarAcArya ne kucha jaina siddhAntoM kA AdhAra liyA hai aura kucha vedAdi apara siddhAntoM 'kA) 'jagadutpatti ke saMbandha meM para aura apara vidyA ke nAma se do vibhAga 1-yaha pustaka mahAdeva rAjArAma bohamra em. e. ne kesarI patra ke eka lekha ke AdhAra se likhI hai aura bhAryabhUSaNa presa pUnA meM 1893 I. meM chapI hai| .

Page #75
zaMkara ne mAne haiM / avidyAmUlaka saMsAra apara vidyA kA viSaya hai / sarva bAhya sRSTi ke sthAna para kevala vyAvahArika satyatva hone se vaha mAyA ke yoga se brahma para AbhAsa rUpa se bhAsamAna hotA hai tathApi saMsAra ko bIjAGkura nyAya se anAdihI mAnanA cAhiye / isake sivAya Izvara ne sRSTi nirmANa kyoM kI ? isa prazna kA yogya uttara logoM ko kabhI bhI denA AtAhI nhiiN| jagat utpanna karane meM kartA kA kucha bhI hetu honA cAhiye parantu vaisA hetu zuddha brahma ke sthAna para kadApi saMbhavita nahIM hotaa| vRkSa sUkha gayA to bhI bIja rahatA hI hai aura usase dUsarA vRkSa utpanna hotA hai usI rIti se manuSya marA to bhI usakA karma bIja punarjanma kA kAraNa hotA hai isa rItyanusAra yaha utpatti aura nAza kI anAdi paraMparA nirantara cala rahI hai|' dekhiye mahAzaya ! Apa ke zaMkara ne idhara udhara phiraphirAkara anta meM jagat ko anAdihI mAnA hai / yadyapi zaMkara svAmI ne saMsAra ko anAdi yogya rIti se jaisA cAhiye vaisA nahIM mAnA tathApi anta meM unako yaha to kahanA hI par3A ki sRSTi anAdi hai / "zaMkarAcArya va jJAnezvara" nAmaka mahArASTra bhASA ke pustaka meM likhA hai ki:-"sarva zAstrAdi aura pratyakSAdi' pramANa avidyAtmaka hai" Age phira isI pustaka meM pR. 32, paM. 19meM likhA hai ki:-"zaMkarAcArya ne jo ajJAna kA grahaNa kiyA hai isakA kAraNa aisA hai ki vedAnta, karma upAsanA ityAdi viSayaka haiM aura ina sabhoM kI vyavasthA lagAne kA kAma AcArya para Ake par3A thA 1-zaMkarAcArya jI ne sRSTi ko jo anAdi kahA hai vaha tattva upaniSadoM kA nahIM hai kintu jaina siddhAntoM kA hai isase kaha sakate haiM ki zaMkara ne jaina siddhAntoM kA Azraya liyA hai| aura jo manuSya jina siddhAntoM kA Azraya lekara calatA hai vaha manuSya una siddhAMtoM kA kyA khaNDana kara sakatA hai ? arthAt nahIM kara sktaa| 2-yaha nibaMdha, rA- rA. bAlA zAstrI huparIkara ne likhA hai aura viSNu goviMda vijApurakara, ema. e. sampAdaka graMthamAlA ne kolhApura zrI samartha prasAda chApAkhAne meM chapavAyA hai| . ...... 3-Adi zabda se vedAdi zandapramANa bhI avidyAtmakahI samajhanA cAhie /

Page #76
( 54 ) aura inake bhI pUrva kAla se ajJAna ke grahaNa karane kI rIti calI AI thii| yaha yogavAsiSTha para se aura unake granthoM para se samajha sakate haiN| isaliye pIche se calA huA ajJAna kA grahaNa karake una (zaMkarAcArya) ko bhASyoM ko likhanA par3A, aura usasehI zrutiyoM kI vyavasthA lgii| karma, upAsanA ajJAnI ko hai, jJAnI ko kucha nahIM aisA sthala 2 para AcArya kA kathana hai| aura eka ajJAna ko grahaNa karane ke liye AbhAsavAda, IzvaravAda, ityAdi vAda aura tatvamasi Adi vAkyoM kI sArthakatA hone lagI, aura zruti kA bhAra apane mastakapara lene ke kAraNa zruti ke vyavasthA ke lie unhoMne sarva pakSa lie haiN| aba kitaneka loga AcAryapara aisA AkSepa karate haiM ki, jhUThA ajJAna lekara saba vyavasthA kI sahI; paraMtu unhoMne (zaMkara ne) isa rIti se jagat ko phasAyA hai| eka dRSTi se yaha AkSepa yadyapi saccA mAlUma hotA hai tathApi vicAra karane se AcArya ne jo kiyA vaha ThIka kiyA hai aisA mAlUma hotA hai / " dekhie brahmAdvatavAdIjI ! Apake zaMkara to saba zAstroM ko aura pratyakSAdi zAbda paryanta pramANoM ko avidyAtmaka batalAte haiM aura unake anuyAyI yaha svIkAra bhI karate haiM ki zaMkarAcArya ne ajJAna kA grahaNa kiyaa| bhalA kahIM ajJAna ke grahaNa karane vAloM ko bhI koI jJAnI kaha saktA hai ! kabhI nhiiN| aura jo ajJAna kA grahaNa karake bhASya likhane par3e tabhI to jainaloga zaMkara ke kathana ko ajJAnI racita kahate haiN| aura jo ApakA yaha mAnanA hai ki zaMkarAcArya ke pUrva kAla se hI ajJAna grahaNa karane kI rIti calI AI thI to isase yaha bhI siddha ho cukA ki veda-vedAnta darzana prathamasehI ajJAna ko grahaNa karate cale Aye haiM isIse sacce jJAna ke grahaNa karanevAle jaina Apake ajJAna ke vAkya nahIM maante| bhalA kahIM ajJAna ko grahaNa karane sebhI sArthakatA ho sakatI hai ! ajJAna ko grahaNa karanA ajJAniyoM kA kAma hai, na ki zAniyoM kA / jJAnIloga ajJAna kA grahaNa karanA burA samajhate haiM isa liye ve ajJAna ko nahIM grahaNa kara skte| zaMkara ke anuyAyI isa bAta ko kabUla karate haiM ki:-"unhoMne isarIti se jagat ko phasAyA hai, eka dRSTi se yaha AkSepa saccA mAlUma hotA hai " yadi yaha AkSepa sacA

Page #77
( 55 ) hai to kyA zaMkara svAmI aisA mArga nahIM sodha sake ki jJAna mArgasehI apane pantha kI vRddhi karate ! isase yaha siddha hotA hai ki zaMkara ne ajJAna mArgasehI apane pantha ko bar3hAyA hai, aura yaha bhI kahate haiM ki ajJAnI logahI zaMkara ke ajJAna meM phase hoMge ! yadi ve pUre jJAnI hote to aisA mArga kabhI na lete ! jaba Apa saba zAstra ajJAnAtmakahI mAte haiM to zuddha brahma ke lakSaNa ajJAnAtmaka zAstroM meM kahA~se ho sakate haiM ! kahIM ajJAna se jJAna prApta hosaktA hai ! kadApi nahIM / isase yaha siddha ho cukA ki Apa ke veda vedAntAdi zAstroM se saccA brahma kA svarUpa nahIM mila saktA / aura jainoM ke zAstra pUrNa jJAnAtmaka haiM isase saccA brahma kA svarUpa inase barAbara mila sakatA hai / jainaloga zruti smRti Adi veda-vedAnta zAstroM ko na to pramANa mAnate the aura na aba mAnate haiM / kahIM ajJAna mArga se jJAna mArga kI sthApanA ho sakatI hai; kabhI nahIM / jaina logoM ke praznoM ke samAdhAna karane kI zakti zaMkara meM nahIM thI kyoM ki zaMkara svAmI jaina zAstroM kA rahasya hI nahIM jAnate the aisA unake granthoM se mAlUma hotA hai / maNDanamizra jaina nahIM the kintu dvaitavAdI the aura unakI strI ke sAtha kAmacarcA meM zaMkarasvAmI ko niruttara honA par3A thA / yadi pUrNajJAnI hote to usI samaya uttara de ke samAdhAna kara dete ! jainoM ke kisI bhI graMtha meM zaMkarAcArya kI stuti kI huI hamAre dekhane meM nahIM AI yadi koI bahAdura ho to batalAve hama svIkAra kara sakate haiM / parantu hamArI samajha se yaha kevala jhUTha hai / jaina kisI kA bhI utkarSa dekhakara nArAja nahIM hote / parantu isase yaha nahIM samajha lenA cAhiye ki jaina zaMkara ke mata ko acchA samajhe haiM, balki jaina zvetAMbarAcArya zrImAn hemacaMdrAcAryakRta brahmAdvaitavAda kA khaMDana dikhAI de rahA hai| Apa loga jagat kA kAraNa Izvara arthAt brahma ko mAnate haiM yaha bhI Apa kI nirI bhUla hai hama isI graMtha ke pRSTha 17 para siddha kara cuke haiM ki Izvara jagata kA kAraNa siddha hohI nahIM sakatA, isaliye yahAM likhane kI AvazyakatA nahIM hai / yaha grantha kisI eka ke siddhAntoM para TIkA karane ke lie nahIM likhA gayA hai kintu jagat ke anAdi aura akartRjanya siddha karane ke liye racA gayA hai / isa

Page #78
lie hama isake saMbandha meM isa jagaha adhika likhanA nahIM caahte| zaMkarAcArya jI ke saMbaMdha meM isa graMtha meM parAmarza karane kA prayojana yaha huA ki Apane bhI brahma ko sarvavyApI aura jagat kA kAraNa mAnA hai isa lie inake saMbandha meM likhanA aprAsaMgika nahIM samajhanA caahie| aura aneka bAteM prasaMgataH jo jo likhI gaI haiM vaha dekhakara viSayAntara nahIM samajhanA cAhiye / yadi samaya milA to zaMkarAcArya ke brahmAdvaitavAda ke saMbaMdha meM apane vicAra phira kisI samaya meM anya sthala para prakaTa karane kI ceSTA kruuNgaa| . veda-vedAntAdi darzana ke aneka vidvAngaNa jainadarzana ko bauddha cArvAka, nAstika kahakara athavA ukta matoM ke tulya batalAkara kevala ApahI sacce Astika banane kA dAvA karate haiM, paraMtu isa bAta ko kahanevAle apanI ajJatA pUrI pUrI jhalakAte haiM / jainadharma anAdi kAla se hI avicchinna pravAha rUpa se calA AyA hai aura Astika ziromaNi dharma hai / aura yaha bAta vedamatAnuyAyI kAzI (banArasa) nivAsI sAkSarayaM sarvataMtrasvataMtra satsampradAyAcArya svAmI 'rAmamizra zAstrI jI ne apanI vaktRtA meM siddha karadI hai pAThaka ! isa vyAkhyAna kA sArAMza gaura ke sAtha par3hiye ki vaidika vidvAna jaina dharma ke saMbandha meM kyA pharamA rahe haiM jarA dhyAna dIjie:"sajjana mahAzaya ! . Aja bar3A sudina aura mAMgalika samaya hai ki hama bhAratavarSIya, jinake yahA~ sRSTi ke Adi kAlahI se sabhyatA, AtmajJAna, parArthe AtmasamarpaNa, AtmA kI anAdyantatA jJAna calA AyA hai balki samaya ke phera se kucha purAnI pratiSThA purAnI sI par3a gayI hai, ve isa 1-khAmI rAmamizrazAstrI jI ne kAzI meM yazovijaya jI jainasaMskRta pAThazAlA ke bhavana meM jaina dharma viSaya para jo vyAkhyAna diyA thA, vaha vyAkhyAna (bhASaNa) 'sujanasammelanam' nAma se pustaka rUpa meM muMbaI nivAsI seTha-vIracaMda dIpacaMda sI. AI. I. je. pI. aura seTha gokula bhAI mUlacaMda dvArA banArasa caMdraprabhA presa meM chapa kara prakAzita huA hai / aura yaha-zAstravizArada-vijayadharma sUri jI ko kRpA kA phala hai|

Page #79
( 57 ) sthAna meM ekatra huye haiM avazya hI ise saubhAgya mAnanA aura kahanA cAhiye, kyoMki vaidika mata aura jaina mata sRSTi kI Adi se barAbara avicchinna cale Aye haiM aura ina donoM majahaboM ke siddhAnta vizeSa ghaniSTha samIpa saMbandha rakhate haiM jaisA ki pUrva meM maiM kaha cukA hU~ aura jaisA ki satkArya vAda, satkAraNa vAda, paralokAstitva, AtmA kA nivikAratva, mokSa kA honA aura usakA nityatva, janmAntara ke puNya pApa se janmAntara meM phala bhoga, vratopavAsAdi vyavasthA, prAyazcita vyavasthA, mahAjana pUjana, zabda pramANa ityAdi samAna haiM, basa to isI hetu mujhe yahA~ yaha kahate hue merA zarIra pulakita hotA hai ki Aja kA yaha hamArA jainoM ke saGga eka sthAna meM upasthita hokara saMbhASaNa vaha hai ki jo cirakAla ke bichar3e bhAI bhAI kA hotA hai / sajjanoM ! yaha bhI yAda rakhanA jahA~ bhAI bhAI kA ristA hai vahA~ kabhI kabhI lar3AI kI bhI lIlA laga jAtI hai parantu yAda rahe uskA kAraNa kevala ajJAnahI hotA hai| __ isa deza meM Ajakala aneka alpajJa jana bauddha mata aura jaina mata ko eka jAnate haiM aura yaha mahA bhrama hai / jaina aura bauddhoM ke siddhAnta ko eka jAnanA aisI bhUla hai ki jaise vaidika siddhAnta ko mAna kara yaha kahanA ki vedoM meM varNAzrama vyavasthA nahIM hai athavA jAti vyavasthA nahIM hai| ___ Age phira likhA hai ki "ajJoM kI dantakathA hai ki jaina aura bauddha eka samAna haiM; sajjano ! burA na mAno aura burA mAnane kI bAta hI kauna sI hai jaba ki khAdyakhaNDanakAra zrIharSa ne svayaM apane prantha meM bauddha ke sAtha apanI tulanA kI hai aura kahA ki hama logoM se [yAne nirvizeSAdvaita siddhAntiyoM se] aura bauddhoM se yahI bheda hai ki hama brahma kI sattA mAnate haiM aura saba mithyA kahate haiM, parantu bauddhaziromaNi mAdhyamika sarva zUnya kahatA hai taba tau jina jainoMne saba kucha mAnA unase napharata karanevAle kucha jAnatehI nahIM aura mithyA dveSa mAtra karate haiM yaha kahanA hogaa| sajjanoM ! jaina mata se aura bauddha siddhAnta se jamIna AsmAna kA antara hai| usase eka jAna . ..

Page #80
( 58 ) kara dveSa karanA yaha ajJa janoM kA kArya hai sabase adhika ve ajJa haiM ki jo jaina sampradAya siddha melo meM vighnaDAlakara pApabhAgI hote haiM " / / ... Age phira likhate haiM ki "sajano ! jJAna, vairAgya, zAnti, jhAnti, adambha, anIrSA, akrodha, amAtsarya alolupatA, zama, dama, ahiMsA, samadRSTitA ityAdi guNoM meM ekeka guNa aisA hai ki jahA~ vaha pAyA jAya vahA~ para buddhimAna pUjA karane lagate haiM taba to jahA~ ye pUrvokta saba guNa niratizayasIma hokara virAjamAna haiM unakI pUjA na karanA athavA guNapUjakoM kI pUjA meM bAdhA DAlanA kyA inasAniyata kA kArya hai ?" phira Age likhate haiM ki "sajjano ! ajJatA aisI cIja hai usake kAraNa aneka bera aneka loka binA jAne bUjhe dUsare kI nindA kara baiThate haiM / thor3ehI dina kI bAta hai ki kisI naye majahabI ne josameM Akara jainamata meM mithyA Aropa kiye aura anta meM hAni uThAI / maiM Apako kahAM taka kahU~ bar3e bar3e nAmI AcAryoM ne apane pranthoM meM jo jainamata kA khaNDana kiyA hai vaha aisA kiyA hai ki jise suna dekha kara ha~sI AtI hai| ____ maiM Apa ke sanmukha Age calakara syAdvAda kA rahasya kahU~gA taba Apa avazya jAna jA~yage ki vaha eka abhedya kilA' hai usake andara mAyAmaya gole nahIM praveza kara sakate / __Age phira likhate haiM ki "sajano! eka dina vaha thA ki jaina sampradAya ke AcAryoM ke huMkAra se dazo dizAeM gUMja uThatI thIM, eka samaya kI vArtA hai ki hamAre hI ( yAne vaidika sampradAyI vaiSNava ne) kisI sAmpradAyika ne hemacaMdrAcArya jI ko dekhakara kahA__'Agato hemagopAlo, daNDakambalamuhahan / basa to phira kyA thA unhoMne mandamusakAna ke sAtha uttara diyA ki. 1 kilA-durga-gaDha - koTa-ityAdika kahate haiN|

Page #81
( 59 ) 'SaDdarzanapazupAyAMzcArayan jainavATake' sajjano ! isa zloka ke pUrvArdha aura uttarArdha ko sunakara Apa loga khUba jAna gaye hoMge ki pUrva samaya para Apasa meM vidvAnoM ke ha~sI ThaThola bhI kaise hote the / ye mahAnubhAva hemacandrAcArya vyAkaraNa se lekara darzana zAstra paryaMta sarva viSaya meM apratima AcArya the / sajjano! jaise kAlacakra ne jainamata ke mahatva ko DhAMka diyA hai vaise hI usake mahatva ko jAnane vAle loga bhI, aba nahIM rahagaye / 'rajjaba sAce / sUra ko vairI karai bakhAna' / yaha kisI bhASAkavi ne bahuta hI ThIka kahA hai / sajjano! Apa jAnate ho maiM vaiSNavasampradAya kA AcArya hUM yahI nahIM hai maiM usa sampradAya kA sarvatobhAva se rakSaka hUM aura sAtha hI usakI tarapha kar3I najara se dekhane vAle kA dIkSaka bhI hUM to bhI bharI majalisa meM mujhe kahanA satya ke kAraNa Avazyaka huA hai ki jainoM kA prantha samudAya, sArasvata mahAsAgara hai / usakI pranthasaMkhyA itanI adhika hai ki una granthoM kA sUcIpatra bhI eka mahA nibaMdha ho jaaygaa|" phira Age likhA hai ki-"sajjano ? jaina mata kA pracAra kaba se huA isa vAre meM logoM ne nAnA prakAra kI uchala kUda kI hai aura apane mano nIta kalpanA kI hai / aura yaha bAta ThIka bhI hai jisakA jitanA jJAna hogA vaha usa vastu ko utanAhI aura vaisAhI smjhegaa"| Age likhA hai ki-"isameM kisI prakAra kA una nahIM hai ki jaina darzana vedAntAdi darzanoM se bhI pUrva kA hai taba hI to bhagavAn veda vyAsa maharSi brahma sUtroM meM kahate haiM:-'naikasminnasambhavAt' sajjanoM ! jaba veda vyAsa ke brahmasUtrapraNayana ke samaya para jaina mata thA taba to usake khaNDanArtha udyoga kiyA gayA, yadi vaha pUrva meM nahIM thA to vaha khaNDana kaisA aura kisa kA ? sajjanoM ! samaya alpa hai aura kahanA bahuta hai isase chor3a diyA jAtA hai nahIM to bAta yaha hai ki vedoM meM anekAMta bAda kA mUla milatA hai / sajjanoM ! maiM Apa ko vedAntAdi darzana zAstroM kA aura jainAdi darzanoM kA kauna mUla hai yaha kaha

Page #82
kara sunAtA hU~ / uccazreNI ke buddhimAn logoM ke mAnasa nigUDha vicAra hI darzana haiN| jaise ajAta vAda, vivarta vAda, dRSTi-sRSTi vAda, pariNAma vAda, Arambha vAda, zUnyavAda ityAdi dArzanikoM ke nigUDha vicAra hI darzana haiM / basa taba to kahanA hogA ki sRSTi kI Adi se jaina mata pracalita hai / sajjano ! anekAntavAda to eka aisI cIja hai ki use sabako mAnanA hogA, aura logoM ne mAnA bhI hai / dekhie viSNu purANa meM likhA hai: narakasvargasaMjJe vai puNyapApe dvijottama ! vastvekameva duHkhAya sukhAyerSyA jamAya ca kopAya ca yatastasmAdvastu vastvAtmakaM kutaH ? yahA~ para jo parAzara maharSi kahate haiM ki vastu vastvAtmaka nahIM hai, isakA artha yahI hai ki koI bhI vastu ekAntataH eka rUpa nahIM hai, jo vastu eka samaya sukha hetu hai vaha dUsare kSaNa meM duHkha kI kAraNa ho jAtI hai; aura jo vastu kisI kSaNa meM duHkha kI kAraNa hotI hai vaha kSaNa bhara meM sukha kI kAraNa ho jAtI hai / sajjano ! Apane jAnA hogA ki yahAM para spaSTa hI anekAntavAda kahA gayA hai / sajjanoM ! eka bAta para aura bhI dhyAna denA jo "sadasadbhyAmanirvacanIyaM jagat" kahate haiM unako bhI vicAra dRSTi se dekhA jAya to anekAntavAda mAnane meM una nahIM hai, kyoMki jaba vastu sad bhI nahIM kahI jAtI aura asad bhI nahIM kahI jAtI to kahanA hogA ki kisI prakAra se sat hokara bhI vaha kisI prakAra se asat hai, isa hetu na vaha sat kahI jA saktI hai aura na to asat kahI jA saktI hai, to aba anekAntatA mAnanA siddha ho gyaa| sajanoM ! naiyAyika tama ko tejo'bhAva svarUpa kahate haiM aura mImAMsaka aura vedAntika bar3I ArabhaTI se usakA khaMDana karake use bhAva svarUpa kahate haiM to dekhane kI bAta hai ki Aja taka isakA koI phaisalA nahIM huA ki kauna ThIka kahatA hai to aba kyA nirNaya hogA ki kauna bAta ThIka hai / taba

Page #83
( 61 ) to do kI lar3AI meM tIsare kI pau bArA hai yAne jaina siddhAnta siddha ho gayA, kyoMki ve kahate haiM ki vastu anekAnta hai use kisI prakAra se bhAvarUpa kahate haiM aura kisI rIti para abhAvarUpa bhI kaha sake haiM / kisI rIti para koI AtmA ko jJAnasvarUpa kahate haiM aura koI jJAnAdhAra svarUpa bolate haiM to basa kahanAhI kyA anekAnta bAda ne pada pAyA / kisI rIti para koI jJAna ko dravyasvarUpa mAnate haiM aura koI bAdI guNasvarUpa / isI rIti para koI jagat ko bhAva svarUpa kahate haiM aura koI zUnya svarUpa taba to anekAntavAda anAyAsa siddha ho gyaa| koI kahate haiM ki ghaTAdi dravya haiM aura unameM rUpa sparzAdi guNa haiN| paraMtu dUsarI tarapha ke vAdI kahate haiM ki dravya koI cIja nahIM hai vaha to guNasamudAya svarUpa hai / rUpa, sparza, saMkhyA, parimANa ityAdi kA samudAya hI to ghaTa hai ise chor3a kara ghaTa kauna vastu hai / koI kahate haiM AkAza nAmaka zabdajanaka eka niravayava dravya hai / paraMtu anya vAdI kahate haiM ki vaha to zUnya hai| ___sajano ! kahA~ taka kahA jAya kucha vAdiyoM kA kahanA hai ki gurutva guNa hai / parantu dUsarI tarafa vAdI logoM kA kahanA hai ki gurutva koI cIja nahIM hai pRthvI meM jo AkarSaNa zakti hai use na jAna kara logoM ne gurutva nAmaka guNa mAna liyA hai| mita hita vAkya pathya hai, usIse jJAna hotA hai vAgjAla kA koI prayojana nahIM hai isa hetu yaha viSaya yahA~ hI chor3a diyA jAtA hai aura AzA kI jAtI hai ki jaina mata ke kramika vyAkhyAna diye jaayeNge| .. zubhAni bhUyAmurvarddhapAnAni / zam khAmI rAmamizra zAstrI-agastyAzramAzrama-kAzI. mi0 pauSa zukla pratipat-budhavAra saM0 1962

Page #84
( 65 ) I Apaloga prasiddha vaidika vidvAna zrImAn rAmamizra zAstrI jI ke vyAkhyAna para se. bhalI bhA~ti jAna sakte haiM ki jainamata Astika hai yA nAstika ? aura jaina darzana kA syAdvAda nyAya kitanA pukhta hai yaha bhI Apa acchI taura se samajha sakte haiM / jaina zvetAmbara kAnapharansa ke bar3ode kA adhivezana tArIkha 30 / 12 / 1904 I0 meM huA thA usa vakhta jagatprasiddha dezabhakta mAnanIya paNDita zrIyuta bAlagaGgAdhara tilaka mahodaya ne apanI vaktRtA meM kahA thA ki " brAhmaNoM aura hindU dharma meM mAMsa bhakSaNa aura madirA pAna banda huA yaha bhI jainadharma kA hI pratApa hai " ityAdi bahuta kucha kahA thA / dekhie ! jaina darzana kI tArIpha anyamatoM ke bar3e bar3e vidvAnagaNa kara rahe haiM / saccI bar3AI vaha hai ki jisakI tArIpha dUsare loga kreN| jaina darzana kI prazaMsA aneka pUrvadezIya aura pAzcAtya vidvAnoM ne kI hai aura karate hI cale jAte haiM vizeSa likhane kI koI AvazyakatA nahIM / jaina darzana ke tattva saba darzanoM se adhika zreSTha haiM, isase vizvAsa karane yogya hai / jaina darzana jagatkA kartA Izvara ko nahIM mAnatA aura yaha bAta bahuta ThIka hai / jagat Izvara kA racA huA mAnane vAle vedAdi dharmAvalambiyoM se jaba pUchA jAtA hai ki Izvara ko jagatkA kartA Apaloga mAnate haiM isa saMbaMdha meM Apa ke pAsa kyA dRr3ha pramANa hai ? to pratyuttara meM jora dekara kahate haiM ki isa bAta kA sAkSI veda hai / aura veda Izvara ke race hue haiM isalie vizvAsa karane ke yogya haiM isase bar3ha kara kyA pramANa cAhie ? | veda pauruSeya hai yA apauruSeya, athavA manuSyanirmita ? samArgadarzaka hai yA nahIM ? aura vizvAsa karane yogya hai yA ayogya? aba hame ina ukta bAtoM para parAmarza karanA avazya hai / parantu hamAre ora se likhane kI bhI koI jarUrata nahIM mAlUma hotI / kyoMki kitaneka veda matAnuyAyI vidvAn mahAzayahI vedoM ko kyA samajha rahe 1 jaina dharma ke pratApa se brAhmaNa aura hindU dharma meM mAMsa bhakSaNa aura madirA pAna baMda huA isa upakAra ke badale meM kitaneka manuSya jainoM ko nAstika kiMvAnAstikoM kI zreNI meM kahane kA sAhasa karate haiM dhanya hai aise sAhasiyoM ko ?

Page #85
haiM aura lekhanI dvArA kyA vyakta kara rahe haiM yaha batalAnA vizeSa lAbha dAyaka hogA isa lie hama eka vaidika vidvAna mahAzaya kehI bicAra yahAM para denA ucita samajhate haiN| pAThaka ise par3ha kara isa bAta para bicAra kareM: "veda zabda "vid" dhAtu se nikalA hai| isa dhAtu se jAnane kA artha nikalatA hai / " Age likhA hai ki-"veda para sanAtana dharmAvalambI hinduoM kA aTala vizvAsa hai / veda hama logoM kA saba se zreSTha aura sabase purAnA prantha hai|" Age likhA hai ki-"kolabuka sAhaba ne bhI veda-prApti kI ceSTA kI thI, para kisI dAkSiNAtya paMDita ne vaidika chandoM meM likhI huI devI-devatAoM kI stutiyoM se pUrNa eka graMtha unheM de diyA aura kahA ki yahI veda hai / bhalA mlecchoM ko kahIM dAkSiNAtya paMDita veda de sakte haiM ? aisAhI dhokhA eka aura sAhaba ko bhI diyA gayA thA / madarAsa ke kisI zAstrI ne satrahavIM zatAbdI meM eka kRtrima yajurveda kI pustaka phAdara rAbarTa Di nobilI nAmaka pAdarI ko dekara usase bahutasA rupayA liyA / yaha grantha 1761 IsavI meM perisa ke pradhAna pustakAlaya meM pahu~cA, vahA~ pahale isakI bar3I kadara huI / para sArA bheda pIche se khula gyaa|" Age likhA hai ki-vedoM kI "trayI' saMjJA hai / trayI kahane se Rk, yaju aura sAma inhIM tIna vedoM kA jJAna hotA hai / atharva veda eka prakAra kA pariziSTa hai / Rgveda meM tIna hI vedoM kA ullekha hai| . 1 yaha lekha vinAyaka vizvanAtha veda vikhyAta jI kI sahI se ilAhAbAda (prayAga) kI sarasvatI nAma kI mAsika patrikA ke bhAga 9 veM kI saMkhyA 9 para arthAt 1908 ke saptambara kI saMkhyA meM pRSTha 389 para chapA hai| 2 kaisA zreSTha aura kaisA purAnA graMtha hai yaha isa lekha ko par3hane se mAlUma ho jaaygaa| pranthakartA ..

Page #86
( 64 ) yathA: "ahe budhniya mantraM me gopAya trayamRSayastrayI vedA viduH Rco yajUMSi sAmAni" manusmRti meM bhI manu ne -" dudoha yajJasiddhyarthamRgyajuH sAma lakSaNam" kahakara tIna hI vedoM kA nAma liyA hai| paraMtu pIche se cAra veda mAne jAne lge| zrImadbhAgavata aura viSNupurANa Adi purANoM meM to sarvatra hI cAra vedoM kA ullekha hai-likhA hai ki brahmA ke eka eka mu~ha se eka eka veda nikalA hai / " sanAtana dharmAvalambiyoM kA pakkA vizvAsa hai ki veda nitya hai aura ve IzvarapraNIta haiN| kapila ne sAMkhya darzana meM Izvara kI sthiti meM to sandeha kiyA hai " pramANAbhAvAnna tatsiddhiH " para vedoM ke IzvarapraNIta hone meM kisIne sandeha nahIM kiyA / yathA:-na pauruSeyatvaM tatkartuH puruSasyAsambhavAt " / nyAya darzana ke karttA gautama ko chor3akara saba darzanakAroM kI yahI rAya hai / saba vedoM ko IzvarakRta mAnate haiN| akele gautama hI ne unheM pauruSeya arthAt puruSakRta likhA hai| aba nahIM kaha sakate ki isa "pauruSeya" se unakA kyA matalaba thA / ve vedoM ko sAdhAraNa hama tuma sadRza puruSa ke race hue mAnate the, yA puruSa prakRtivAle "puruSa" (Izvara) se unakA matalaba thA / yadi unheM pichalI bAta abhISTa thI to yaha kahanA cAhiye ki sabhI darzanakAroM kI isa viSaya meM ekatA hai / kisI kisI muni kI to yahA~ taka rAya hai ki veda nitya hai aura unhIM ke anusAra Izvara sRSTi kI racanA karatA hai ? so veda Izvara ke bhI patha' pradarzaka hue ! veda nitya hai, isase kalpAnta meM ve hiraNyagarbha * 1 vedoM ko Izvara ke pathadarzaka mAnane se veda Izvara ke raca siddha nahIM hote aura anAdi bhI siddha nahIM ho sakate isase yahI mAlUma hotA hai ki vaidika RSiyoM ne veda race haiM / aura dUsarI bAta yaha bhI hai ki vedoM ko Izvara ke pathadarzaka mAnane se Izvara se bhI vedo kI yogyatA vizeSa huI isase Izvara nyUnaguNa huA aura veda pUrNa - guNa hue, dekhie yaha kaisA bhAzcarya hai ! /

Page #87
(brahmA) ko Apa hI Apa A jAte haiM / sRSTi kI Adi meM hiraNyagarbha hI pahale pahala paidA hote haiM / veda unake pUrvAbhyasta rahate haiM / isase smaraNa karate haiM. unheM ve Apa hI Apa yAda ho jAte haiM / so kara jagane para kyA pUrvAbhyasta bAteM kisIko bhUla bhI jAtI haiM ? phira hiraNyagarbha ko veda kaise bhUla sakate haiM ? isa taraha ke zAstrArtha se kitane hI prAcIna grantha bhare par3e haiN"| _"isa samaya Arya-samAja meM vaidika bAtoM para bahudhA bicAra huA karatA hai / isa samAja ke koI koI anuyAyI veda kA yathArtha artha jAnane kI ceSTA bhI karate haiM / "triveda nirNaya" nAmaka pustaka isakA pramANa hai / para ve bhI vedoM ko Izvarokta mAnate haiM ? paraMtu vedoM ko vicAra pUrvaka par3hane se yaha bAta nahIM pAyI jAtI / isIse isa samaya ke acche acche vidvAn vedoM ke kartRtvaviSaya meM vAda vivAda nahIM karate / ve isakI jarUrata hI nahIM samajhate / ve jAnate haiM ki veda manuSyanirmita haiM / paraMtu sarva sAdhAraNa aisA nahIM maante| isase jo koI vedoM ke IzvarapraNIta hone meM zaGkA karatA hai use ve ghora pApI aura ghora adharmI samajhate haiM / ise hama bakhUbI jAnate haiM / tisa para bhI jo hama sarva sAdhAraNa ke vizvAsa ke viruddha likha rahe haiM usa kA kAraNa yaha hai:- "satye nAsti bhayaM kacit" .. ___"vedAdhyayana nahIM, veda pATha se hI yaha mAlUma hotA hai ki vaidika RSihI veda praNetA haiM / vaidika sUktoMhI meM praNetA RSiyoM ke nAma vidyamAna haiM / inhIM RSiyoM ne aneka prakAra ke chandoM meM stotra Adi banAkara devatAoM kI stuti aura prArthanA kI hai| yaha saba unhoMne apane apane abhISTa sAdhane ke lie kiyA thaa| likhA bhI hai : 1 ina vacanoM se bhI spaSTa mAlUma hotA hai ki na veda pauruSeya hai aura na apauruSeya kintu manuSyanirmita hai / hAM yadi pauruSeya kahane vAle hamAre tumhAre samAna sAdhAraNa manuSyoM ke arthAt RSiyoM ke race mAnate hoM to ThIka hai| "pranthakartA" 2 apane 2 abhISTa sAdhana ke lie kiye hue maMtra sarva sAdhAraNa ko mAnya kisa nyAya se ho sakate haiM ? aura mukti bhI kaise de sakate haiM ! nahIM, isase hI vedoM ko aneka vidvAn amAnanIya kahate haiN|

Page #88
( 66 ) " artha pazyantu RSayo devatAzchandobhirabhyadhAvan / jaise pIche ke saMskRta-kaviyoM ne gaNeza, durgA, ziva, viSNu, sUrya Adi kI stutiyoM se pUrNa stotra banAye haiM vaisehI agni, soma, varuNa, savitA indra Adi kI stutiyoM se paripUrNa stotra vaidika RSiyoM ke banAye hue haiN| yahAM para koI yaha kaha sakatA hai ki vaidika RSi mantradraSTA the| unhoMne yogabala se Izvara se pratyAdeza kI taraha vaidika mantra prApta kiye haiN| yadi yaha bAta hai to ina sUktoM meM ina RSiyoM kI nija kI dazA kA varNana kaise AyA ? ye maMtra inakI avasthA ke jJApaka kaise hue ? Rgveda kA koI RSi ku~e meM girajAne para usIke bhItara par3e par3e varga aura pRthivI Adi kI stuti kara rahA hai| koI indra se kaha rahA hai ki Apa hamAre zatruoM kA saMhAra kiijiye| koI savitA se prArthanA kara rahA hai ki hamArI buddhi ko bar3hAie / koI bahuta sI gAeM mAMga rahA hai, koI bahuta se putra / koI per3a, sarpa, araNyAnI, hala aura dundubhI para mantra racanA kara rahA hai / koI nadiyoM ko bhalAburA kaharahA hai ki ye hameM Age bar3hane meM bAdhA DAlatI haiM / kahIM mAMsa kA ullekha hai, kahIM surA kA hai, kahIM chUta __ 1 yaha bAta mahammadI kurAna ke liye aura isAI apanI bAIbala ke liye bhI kahate haiM kisakA kahanA satya hai aura kisakA jhUTha hai aura isa bAre meM tInoMhI ke samIpa kyA pramANa hai ? 2 jina vedoM meM athavA vedAGga meM dArU pIne kA, mAMsa kAma meM lene kA, cUta ko uttejana dene kA, dillagI ' karane kA, bhalA burA kahane kA, devatAoM se svArtha ke liye prArthanA karane kA, mAraNa mohana uccATana vazIkaraNa strIvazIkaraNa dyUta meM jIta hone ityAdi kukAryoM ke karane kA maMtra tathA varNana hai aura aisA anIti kA jina vedoM meM upadeza hai una ghRNita zAstroM ko kauna buddhimAn apauruSeya athavA vizvAsa karane yogya aura sadmArgadarzaka kaha sakatA hai ? kaI logoM kI yaha rAya hai ki khAsa vedoM meM aisI anucita bAteM nahIM haiM kintu mAMsa madirAdi ke sevana karane vAloM ne brAhmaNAdi vedAGga zAstroM meM pIche se milAdI haiM, astu / kintu veda athavA vedAGga zAstroM meM yaha bAteM dekhane meM AtI haiM tabhI to kaI vidvAn aisA likhate haiN| 'granthakartA

Page #89
kA hai| Rgveda ke sAtaveM maMDala meM to eka jagaha eka RSi ne bar3I dillagI kI hai| somapAna karane ke anantara veda-pATha-rata brAhmaNoM kI veda-dhvani kI upamA Apane barasAtI meMDakoM se dIhai / ye saba bAteM veda ke IzvarapraNIta na hone kI sUcaka haiM / Izvara ke lie gAya, bhaiMsa, putra, kalatra, dUdha, dahI mAMgane kI koI jarUrata nhiiN| yaha Rgveda kI bAta huI / yajurveda kA bhI prAyaH yahI hAla hai / sAmaveda ke mantra meM to kucha aMza ko chor3akara zeSa saba Rgveda hI se cune gaye haiN| rahA atharvaveda, so vaha to mAraNa, mohana, uccATana aura vazIkaraNa Adi mantroM se paripUrNa hai / striyoM ko vaza karane aura juve meM jItane taka ke mantra atharvaveda meM haiN| ataeva isa viSaya meM vizeSa vaktavya kI jarUrata nahIM / na Izvara jUvA khelatA hai aura na vaha straiNahI hai / na vaha aisI bAteM karane ke liye auroM ko preraNAhI karatA hai / ye saba manuSyoM hI ke kAma haiM; jinhoMne vedoM kI racanA kI hai|" ___'parantu Izvara-praNIta na hone se vedoM kA mahattva kucha kama nahIM hosakatA / cAhe aitihAsika dRSTi se dekhie, cAhe dhArmika dRSTi se dekhie, cAhe vidyA viSayaka dRSTi se dekhie, vedoM kI barAbarI aura kisI deza kA koI grantha nahIM kara sakatA / prAcIna samaya kI vidyA, sabhyatA aura dharma kA jaisA uttama citra vedoM meM pAyA jAtA hai, anyatra kahIM nahIM mila sktaa| vaidika samaya meM bhAratavAsiyoM kI sAmAjika avasthA kaisI thI, ve kisa taraha apanA jIvana nirvAha karate the, kahA~ rahate the, kyA kiyA karate the-ina saba bAtoM kA patA yadi kahIM mila sakatA hai to vedoMhI meM mila sakatA hai / ataeva vedAdhyayana karanA hama logoM kA bahuta bar3A kartavya hai|" 1 nahIM kaha sakate ki jina granthoM ke viSaya meM yUta, straiNAdi ghRNAkAraka vicAra veda vikhyAta jI' kara Aye haiM phira unhIM ke saMbandha meM unheM aisA likhane kA kyA kAraNa huA ! parantu anumAna hotA hai ki zAyada anya vaidika loMgo ke bhaya se athavA jaina sAhitya ke avalokana ke abhAva se, balAt AdaraNIya likhanA par3A ho !

Page #90
( 68 ) " jisa' rUpa meM Aja kala veda grantha dekhe jAte haiM vaha unakA Adima rUpa nahIM hai / unakA vartamAna rUpa veda vyAsajI kI kRpA kA phala hai / vyAsajI ke pahale vaidika stotrasamUha eka jagaha ekatra na thA / vaha kitanehI bhinna bhinna aMzoM meM prApya thaa| kyoMki sAre stotrasamUha kI racanA ekahI samaya meM nahIM huI / kucha aMza kabhI banA hai, kucha kabhI / kisI kI racanA kisI RSi ne kI hai, kisI kI kisI ne / una saba bikhare hue mantroM ko kRSNa dvaipAyana ne eka praNAlI meM baddha karadiyA / tabhI se vedoM ke nAma ke Age "saMhitA " zabda prayukta hone lagA / usakA artha hai - " samUha ' 77 66 jamAva, " " ekatrIkaraNa " / vartamAna rUpa meM vedapracAra karanehI ke kAraNa bAdarAyaNa kA nAma vedavyAsa par3A / unhoMne samagra veda apane cAra ziSyoM ko par3hAye / bahUvRca nAmaka Rgveda saMhitA paila ko, nigada nAmaka yajurveda saMhitA vaizampAyana ko, chandoga nAmaka sAmaveda saMhitA jaimini ko, aura aGgirasI nAmaka atharva-saMhitA sumantu ko / ina cAra ziSyoM ne apane apane ziSyoM ko naI praNAlI ke anusAra vedAdhyayana karAyA / isa prakAra veda- pAThiyoM kI saMkhyA bar3hate bar3hate vedoM kI aneka zAkhAyeM hogaI, mantroM meM kahIM pATha bheda hogyaa| kisI RSi ke par3hAye ziSya eka taraha kA pATha par3hane lage, kisI ke aura taraha kA / yaha pATha-bheda yahAMtaka bar3hagayA ki sAmaveda kI sau taka zAkhAyeM hogaI ! parantu aba ye saba zAkhA pATha nahIM milate / kuchahI milate haiM / "" 1 veda, vyAsajI ke pahale veda grantha ke rUpa meM hI nahIM the / grantha kA rUpa vyAjInehI vedoM ko diyA aura vedoM kA mahatvabhI taba se vizeSa bar3hA isase kaha sakate haiM ki vedoM para jitanA aba vaidikoM kA vizvAsa hai utanA vyAsajI ke pahale nahIM thA / IzvarapraNIta zAstroM kA rUpa sarva kAla eka samAna cAhie / "anthakartA " 1 2 isase yaha bhI pratIta hotA hai ki vyAsajI ke pahale veda jAnanevAle kama the ? jabhI to zAkhAoM kA abhAva ho gayA ? 3 IzvarapraNIta zAstroM me vikhyAtajI kI rAya hai ki veda ThIka mAlUma hotI haiM / bhI kahIM pATha bheda hosakatA hai ? isaliye jo veda IzvarapraNIta nahIM haiM kintu manuSyanirmita haiM yaha

Page #91
"vedoM ke vyAkhyAna arthAt TIkA kA nAma "brAhmaNa'' hai| bahuta loga saMhitA aura brAhmaNa donoM kI "veda" saMjJA mAnate haiM / ve kAtyAyana ke " mantrabrAhmaNayorvedanAmadheyam " isa vAkya kA pramANa dete haiM / parantu yaha bAta vicAraNIya hai / brAhmaNa-granthoM meM vaidika mantroM kA matalaba samajhAyA gayA hai / aura bhI kitanIhI bAteM haiM / ataeva unakI racanA vedoM ke sAthahI huI nahIM mAnI jA sktii| vaidika mantroM ke Azaya samajhane meM jaba kaThinAI par3ane lagI hogI taba "brAhmaNa" banAye gaye hoMge, pahale nhiiN| Rgveda ke brAhmaNoM meM vizeSa karake hotA ke kAmoM kA vidhAna hai aura yajurveda ke brAhmaNoM meM ardhvayu ke aura sAmaveda ke brAhmaNoM meM udgAtA ke kAmoM kA vidhAna hai / yajJasaMbandhI bAtoM ko khUba samajhAne aura yajJa kArya kA sambandha vaidika mantroM se acchI taraha batalAnehI ke liye brAhmaNoM kI sRSTi huI hai| saMhitA padya meM hai, brAhmaNa gadya meN| gadya ke bIca meM kahIM kahIM "gAthA" nAmaka padyamI brAhmaNoM meM hai|" "brAhmaNa-pranthoM ke anta meM "AraNyaka" haiM / jo ghara chor3a kara bana cale gaye haiM, ataeva jinhoMne yajJa karanA banda karadiyA hai, ye "AraNyaka" grantha unhIMke lie haiN| unhIM ke kAma kI bAteM inameM haiN| "AraNyaka" se utarakara upaniSad haiM / ve saba jJAnakANDa ke antargata haiN|" "yajJa sambandhI kriyAkalApa arthAt karmakANDa kA viSaya jaba bahuta pecIdA hogayA aura sAdhAraNa AdamI brAhmaNa granthoM kA ThIka ThIka matalaba samajhane athavA tadanusAra kriyA nirvAha karane meM asamartha hone lage taba zrauta, gRhya aura dharma sUtroM kI utpatti huii| ina granthoM meM saba bAteM thor3e meM samajhAI gaI haiM / zrauta-sUtroM meM zruti-(yahAM 'brAhmaNoM' se matalaba haiM ) meM ullikhita bar3e bar3e yajJoM ke vidhAna Adi haiM; gRhya-sUtroM meM janana, maraNa, vivAha Adi saMskAroM kI vidhi haiM; aura dharma-sUtroM meM dharma-sambandhI, arthAt dharmazAstra yA smRtiyoM kI bAteM haiM" "inake sivA " anukramaNI" nAmaka granthoM kI ginatI bhI vaidikasAhitya meM kI jAtI hai / ina granthoM meM vedoM ke pATha Adi kA krama

Page #92
likhA hai / yaha isaliye kiyA gayA hai jisameM vedoM ko koI aMza khoM na jAya, athavA usameM pAThAntara na ho jAya / eka anukramaNI meM to Rgveda ke sUktoM kI, maMtroM kI, zabdoM kI, yahAM taka ki akSaroM taka kI ginatI bhI dI hai ?" ___"prAtizAkhya, pariziSTa, bRhadevatA, nirukta Adi bhI vaidika sAhitya ke aGga haiN|" ___"Rgveda saba vedoM se purAnA hai / vahI sabase adhika mahattva kA bhI hai / maMDala nAmaka 10 adhyAyoM meM vaha vibhakta hai / koI 15 prakAra ke vaidika chandoM meM usakI racanA huI hai / Rgveda kA koI caturthAza gAyatrI-nAmaka chanda meM hai / aise tIna hI chanda haiM jinakA prayoga adhikatA ke sAtha kiyA gayA hai aura chandoM kA kama prayoga huA hai / Rgveda kI RcAoM kI racanA bhinna bhinna RSiyoM ke dvArA bhinna bhinna samaya meM huI hai / isa veda ke RSi pratibhAzAlI kavi the-kavi nahIM, zreSTha kavi the / isake adhikAMza mantroM kI racanA vaidika devatAoM kA uddeza karake kI gaI hai / unameM unake bala, vIrya, zakti, prabhutA, audArya Adi kI prazaMsA hai / ina maMtroM ke racayitA RSiyoM ne devatAoM kI stuti aura prazaMsA ke dvArA unase laukika sukha-prApti ke lie prArthanA kI hai / bahuta se pazu, bahuta se putra pautra, bahuta sA aizvarya, dIrghAyu aura zatruoM para vijaya prApti ke lie unhoM ne devatAoM kI stuti kI hai / laukika sukha-prApti kI tarapha unakA 1 surA mAMsa dyUta straiNa Adi kI behUdI bAteM karate the Apa unako zreSTha samajhate haiM ? dhanya hai aise zreSTha kaviyoM ko| 2 jina vaidika RSiyoM ko laukika sukha kI tarapha dhyAna adhika thA phira una RSiyoM ko tattvavettA kauna kaha sakatA hai ! aura jina vedoM meM pAralaukika arthAt makti sukha prApta karane kI bAteM kama aura laukika sukha kI bAteM vizeSa haiM una granthoM ko kauna buddhimAna samArgadarzaka zAstra kaha sakatA hai ? vAmamArgI Adi nAstika logoM kA bhI laukika sukha kI tarapha hI khyAla rahatA hai aura jaba vaidika RSiyoM kA yaha hAla thA to phira vaidika RSiyoM meM aura vAmamArgiyoM meM antarahI kyA rahA !

Page #93
( 71 ) dhyAna adhika thA, pAralaukika kI tarapha kama / yajJoM ke saMbandha meM agni aura soma Adi devatAoM ke lambe lambe stotroM se Rgveda bharA huA hai / bIca bIca meM yAjJika viSayoM ke A jAne se stotra-janita rasAnubhava meM yadyapi kucha vighAta hotA hai, tathApi jisa sAdagI aura jisa bhakti bhAva se purAtana RSiyoM ne apane vicAra pragaTa kiye haiM vaha avazya 'prazaMsanIya haiM / indra, varuNa, agni, mAtarizvana, savitA, pUSaNa, USA Adi jitane devatAoM kI stuti kI gaI hai prAyaH una saba se matalaba kisI na kisI prAkRtika padArtha se hai / arthAt prAkRtika vastuoM aura prAkRtika dRzyoM hI ko devatA mAnakara, yA una para devatva kA Aropa karake, unakA stavana kiyA gayA hai / eka RSi Azcarya pUrvaka kahatA hai, yaha sUrya AkAza se gira kyoM nahIM par3atA ? dUsarA kahatA hai ye tAre dina meM kahAM cale jAte haiM ? tIsare 1 kyoM na prazaMsanIya ho ! jinhoMne apane matalaba ko (aihika) hI dharma mAna rakkhA hai unake lie bezaka prazaMsanIya hai ? paraMtu na mAlUma vedavikhyAta jI (ki jo vedoM ke saMvandha meM ghRNita aura Azcarya janaka bAteM likha kara bhI) phira kisa kAraNa se vaidika RSiyoM ke vicAra prazaMsanIya samajha rahe haiM ? / . 2 prAkRtika padArthoM ko devatA samajha athavA prAkRtika vastuoM para devatva kA Aropakara stavana kiye haiM isase bhI vaidika RSiyoM kI ajJatA spaSTa jhalaka rahI hai phira aise RSiyoM ke race grantha kaise sarva mAnya ho sakate haiM ! 3 jina vaidika RSiyoM ko vaijJAnika bAtoM kA itanA bhI jJAna nahIM thA una ke race grantha tattvadraSTA kaise ho sakate haiM ? dekhie ! yaha vedoM kI yogyatA / mAkAza meM sUrya rahatA hai isa bAta ko bhI ve acchI taura se nahIM samajha sakate the tabhI to unakI sUrya ke saMbandha meM aisI kalpanA huI hogI yadi vaidika RSi tatvavettA hote to isa bAta ko kyoM nahIM samajha skte| 'pranthakartA' / 4 kyA vaidika RSiyoM ko itanA bhI mAlUma nahIM thA ki 'sUrya ke prakAza ke prabhAva se tAre nahIM dIkhate' jo itanA ajJatAbharA prazna kA gaMbhIra vicAra karane lage / aise ajJAnI athavA alpajJAniyoM ke race vedoM para kauna buddhimAn vizvAsa rakha sakatA hai|

Page #94
( 72 ) ko yaha vismaya ho rahA hai ki bar3I bar3I aneka 'nAdayoM ke girane para bhI kyoM samudra apanI hada se bAhara nahIM jAtA ? isI taraha A ora kautuka ke vazIbhUta hokara prAcIna RSiyoM ne prAkRtika padArthoM ko devatA mAnanA AraMbha kara diyA / isa AraMbha kA anta kahA~ jAkara pahu~cA, ise kauna nahIM jAnatA ? Rgveda ke 33 devatA bar3hate bar3hate 33 karor3a ho gaye / " " mImAMsA darzana ke kartA jaimini kA mata hai ki "devatA" nAmakoI sajIva padArtha nahIM hai / "indra" kahane se isa zabda ko devatA mAna lenA caahie| apane darzana ke chaThe adhyAya meM:"phalArthatvAtkarmaNaH zAstra sarvAdhikAraM syAt " " isa sUtra se Arambha karake Apane devatAviSayaka bahuta sI bAteM likhI haiM | Apa ke kathana kA sArAMza yaha hai ki vaidika devatAoM ke na jIva hai aura na zarIra / yadi ye devatA zarIrI hote to yajJa ke samaya Akara jarUra upasthita hote / so to hotA nahIM / yadi yaha kaheM ki ve Ate to haiM para apanI mahImA ke bala se hama logoM kI A~khoM se adRzya rahate haiM to bhI ThIka nahIM / kyoMki, isa dazA meM, yadi dasa jagaha bhinna bhinna yajJa hoMge to eka zarIra ko lekara ve kahA~ kahA~ jAya~ge ? ataeva maMtra hI ko devatA mAna lenA cAhie / paraMtu isa viSaya meM aura adhika na likhanA hI acchA hai / 1 yaha phira bhI vaidika RSiyoM kI ajJatA alpajJatA kA namUnA dekha lIjie ki jinako saMsAra kI paristhitikA kA kucha bhI mAlUma na thA / 2 jina vedoM kI racanA Azcarya aura kautuka ke vazIbhUta hue vaidika RSiyoM ne kI hai tina vedoM meM pAramArthika bAteM kahA~ se ho sakatI haiN| pakSapAta ko tyAga ke dekhA jAya to veda samyakpathadraSTA mAlUma nahIM hote / 3 prAkRtika padArthoM ko devatA mAnA hai isakA kAraNa prAyaH yaha honA cAhiye kiM vaidika RSi surApAna ke vazIbhUta hokara unmattatA se cAhe una padArthoM para kalpanA karane laga gaye hoMge / kyoMki surA kA pAna karane vAloM ke hRdaya meM zuddha vicAra kI jagaha nahIM rahatI aura uddvAra vicArAnusAra hotA hai isaliye una kI bAtoM para buddhimAn manuSya vizvAsa nahIM kara sakate /

Page #95
( 73 ) vaidika samaya meM pazuhiMsA bahuta hotI thI / yajJoM meM pazu bahuta mAre jAte the aura unakA mAMsa bhI khAyA jAtA thA / usa samaya kaI eka pazuoM kA mAMsa khAdya samajhA jAtA thA, unake nAmanirdeza karane kI yahA~ AvazyakatA nahIM hai / isa viSaya ke ullekha jo vedoM meM pAe jAte haiM unheM jAne dIjie kintu mahAbhArata meM carmaNvatI nadI aura rantideva rAjA kA jo vRttAnta hai usehI par3hane se purAne jamAne kI khAdyAkhAdya cIjoM kA patA laga jAtA hai / soma rasa kA pAna to usa samaya itanA hotA thA ki jisakA ThikAnA nahIM para logoM ko soma pAna kI apekSA 'hiMsA adhika pyArI lagatI thI / isI vaidikI hiMsA ko dUra karane ke lie gautama buddha ko "ahiMsA paramo dharmaH " kA upadeza denA par3A " / I "sAmaveda ke mantra prAyaH Rgveda se hI liye gaye haiM, sirpha unake svaroM meM bheda hai / ve gAne ke nimitta alaga kara diye gaye haiM / soma yajJa meM udgatAoM ke dvArA gAne ke liye hI sAmaveda ko pRthak karanA par3A hai / sAmaveda bhI yajJa se saMbandha rakhatA hai aura yajurveda bhI / sAmaveda kA kAma kevala soma yajJa meM par3atA hai, yajurveda meM sabhI yajJoM ke vidhAna Adi haiM / sAma kI taraha yajurveda bhI Rgveda se 1 jina veda zAstroM meM hiMsA kA pracura upadeza hai, itanAhI nahIM kintu surApAna yAne dArU kA bhI pInA kucha kama nahIM likhA hai / aise garla aura nIca pathapara manuSyoM ko le jAnevAle zAstroM ko hama sarvathA heya samajhate haiM / hamahI kyA koI mI buddhimAn isa bAta ko svIkAra na karegA / Azcarya hai ki aise vedoM ko mAnanevAloM ke dila meM kucha vicAra bhI nahIM AtA ! 2 yaha siddhAMta bauddhoM kA nahIM kintu jainoM kA mukhya siddhAMta hai| jaina tIrthakara- gaNadhara anaMta kAla se isa sUtra kA upadeza karate cale Aye, aura bhaviSya meM ( hone vAle) tIrthakara bhI kareMge / aisA jainoM kA mAnanA hai| gautama buddha ne isa siddhAnta kA kucha aMza liyA paraMtu pUrA nahIM isIse bauddhamatAnuyAyI gautama buddha ke samaya meM bhI mAMsa khAte the aura Aja bhI khAte haiM / jaina aura bauddha dharma ko jo loga ekahI batalAte haiM athavA eka ko eka kI sAkhA kahate haiM unakI bhUla hai kintu donoM dharma alaga alaga haiN| tIrthakara mahAbIra jI kA ziSya gaNadhara gautama aura bauddha dharmotpAdaka gautama buddha ke nAma eka hone se donoM eka nahIM ho sake / 10

Page #96
( 74 ) uddhRta kiyA gayA hai; para hAM sAma kI taraha prAyaH bilakulahI Rgveda se nakala nahIM kiyA gayA / yajurveda ( vAjasaneya-saMhitA ) kA koI eka caturthAza mantrabhAga Rgveda se liyA gayA hai; zeSa yajurvedahI ke RSiyoM kI racanA hai / yajurveda meM gadya bhI hai, sAmaveda meM nahIM, kyoMki vaha gAne kI cIja hai / yajurveda ke samaya meM Rgveda ke samaya kI aisI manohAraNI vAkyaracanA kama hogaI thI / usa samaya stuti prArthanA kI tarapha RSiyoM kA dhyAna kama thA / yajJasaMbandhI sUkSma sUkSma niyama banAkara usIke dvArA apane saukhyasAdhana kI tarapha unakA dhyAna adhika thA / isIse jarA jarA sI bAtoM ke lie bhI unheM vidhi vidhAna banAne par3e the / laukika aura pAralaukika sukha prApti kI kuJjI yajJahI samajhA gayA thA" / " vinAyaka vizvanAtha vedavikhyAta " pAThaka ! veda vikhyAta jI ke isa lekha se vedoM ke saMbaMdha meM Apa loga acchI taura se samajha sakate haiM / veda IzvarakRta athavA apauruSeya nahIM haiM kintu manuSyanirmita haiM vedavikhyAta jI ne bhI yahI mata prakaTa kiyA hai aura aura bhI isa bAta ke aneka pramANa mila sakate haiM / veda kisake kahe hue haiM isa saMbaMdha meM vaidikoM kA bhI eka mata nahIM hai| kaI vedoM ko anAdi kahate haiM aura kaI brahmA ke mukha se prakaTa hue mAnate haiN| kaI kahate haiM ki brahmA ke mukharUpa brAhmaNa haiM aura veda brAhmaNoM ke mukha se kahe hue haiM isase brahmA ke hI kahe hue mAnanA cAhie / Rgveda ke maMtra 7 bhAga 2 para likhA hai ki veda paramezvara se Aye haiM ataeva saba prakAra se stutiyogya haiN| yajurveda meM likhA hai ki veda paramezvara' ke zvAsa se nikale haiM / manusmRti adhyAya 1 zloka 23 para likhA hai ki brahmA ne agni, vAyu, aura sUrya se Rg 1. Izvara to adeha hai phira zvAsa deha binA kahA~ se AyA ! kyoMki zvAsa dehadhArI ke hotA hai / yadi kisI dehadhArI manuSya kA nAma Izvara paramezvara ho aura usake bhI zvAsa se vedoM kI utpatti mAneM to bhI asaMbhAvya hai to phira adeha Izvara ke zvAsa se vedoM kI utpatti mAnanI nitAnta bhramAtmaka hai /

Page #97
( 75 ) yajuH aura sAma AkRSTa kiye aura yaha bhI phira usI zloka meM likhA hai ki tInoM veda asala meM sanAtana haiM / vaidika mahAzaya cAhe vedoM ko sanAtana mAne athavA IzvarakRta mAneM unakI zraddhA kI bAta hai paraMtu taTastharItyA dekhane se yaha bAta nahIM pAI jAtI hai, kyoM ki: "tAlvAdijanmA nanu varNavargo, varNAtmako veda iti sphuTaM ca / puMsazca tAlvAdirataH kathaM syAdapauruSeyo'yamiti pratItiH?" // 1 // (zrImAn-haribhadrasUriH) bhAvArtha-varNa (akSara) ke vargoM kI sRSTi tAlu Adi sthAna se aura jihvA ke prayatna se hai aura yaha bAta prakaTa hai ki veda varNAtmaka haiM aura tAlu Adi sthAnaprayatna manuSya ke hote haiM ataeva veda 'apauruSeya' hai yaha pratIta kaise ho? ! zabdarUpa vANI kA uccAraNa azarIrI se nahIM ho sakatA / nirAkAra Izvara mukha se bole yaha vicArazIla manuSya kabhI svIkAra nahIM kara skte| kyoMki jaba AkArahI nahIM hai to mukha kahA~ se AyA aura mukha ke vinA uccAraNa kahA~ se ho saktA hai kyA Izvara koI iMgrejI bAjA hai? / yadi koI yaha kahe ki Izvara ne RSiyoM ko preraNA kI to azarIrI ko preraka mAnanA yuktivikala hai| veda zabdarUpa hai aura jo jo zabdarUpa hai vaha dehadhArI kA hI kathana ho sakatA hai / satya pUcho to vedoM kI utpatti manuSyoMhI se hai| vedoM ke bAre meM isa graMtha meM jo jo vAteM likhI gaI haiM unheM dekha veda ke pakSapAtI avazya nArAz2a hoMge parantu vinA pramANa kaise kaheM ki veda apauruSeya haiM / vastutaH pUrvokta aneka pramANoM ke AdhAra para kaha sakte haiM ki vedoM kI sRSTi manuSyoM se hI hai / pAzcAtya vidvAna mokSamUlara Adi kA AbhiprAya hai ki "veda ke vacana aise haiM ki jaise ajJAniyoM ke mukha se

Page #98
( 76 ) akasmAt bole jAve hoM aura inakI racanA anumAna 3000 varSa se huI hai| anumAna hotA hai ki vaidika RSiyoM ne surA pAnakara unmattatA se kautuka ke vazIbhUta hokara jaise prAkRtika padArthoM ko devatA mAnA hai vaisehI jagatkarttA honA bhI mAnA ho ! " vinA kiye koI padArtha nahIM banatA isaliye jagat kA kartA Izvara avazya hai " aisA samAdhAna karake veda meM likha diyA ho ki " jagatkartA Izvara hai " aura unake anuyAyioM ne isa bAta ko pIche se pakar3a rakkhA ho to bhI Azcarya nahIM ! "" kitaneka mahAzayoM kA yaha mata hai ki - "Izvara, prakRti, kAla, AkAza aura jIva ke anAdi hone se isa jagata kI utpatti hotI hai| isakA uttara yaha hai ki aba yaha tIna vastu anAdi haiM to phira Izvara ne kyA jagata racA ? isase to saba padArtha anAdi siddha ho cuke aura saba padArtha anAdi hone se Izvara kA racA jagat kabhI siddha nahIM ho sakatA ? Izvara ko kartA mAnane vAloM kI bahAdurI jaba samajhI jAya ki fear kisI padArtha se Izvara ne sRSTi racI hai yaha nyAyayukta siddha karadeM / yadi Izvara ko jagatkartA mAnane vAle pUrvokta tIna vastu ko anAdi mAneMge to yaha veda vAkya: "etasmAdAtmana AkAzaH saMbhUtaH " jhUThA hogA, kyoMki ukta RcA meM usa AtmA se AkAza kI utpatti mAnI hai / eka jagaha para anAdi kahanA aura dUsarI jagaha utpattimAnanA yaha pratyakSa viruddha hai / isase yaha bhI ApakA tarka kalpita hai Izvara jagat kA kartA kisI yukti yA pramANa se siddha nahIM ho sakatA / yaha niHsandeha bAta hai / kaI mahAzaya aba saba prakAra se niruttara ho jAte haiM taba yaha bhI kaha diyA karate haiM ki - " jaisA jIva karma karatA hai vaisA pAtA hai / paraMtu zubhAzubha karmoM kA phala denevAlA Izvara hai / kyoMki karma

Page #99
( 77 ) . jaDa hai isalie svataH jIva prApta nahIM kara saktA / isase denevAlA koI honA hI cAhie / karma karanevAlA jIva hai aura phala denevAlA Izvara hai|" isakA pratyuttara yaha hai ki jaisA jIva karatA hai vaisA pAtA hai aura yadi denevAlA Izvara hai to prathama to Apase hamArA yaha prazna hai ki phira Izvara ne apanI ora se kyA diyA ? kucha bhI nahIM / aura Apa jo yaha hetu dete haiM ki karma jaDa hai isalie IzvaradvArA phala milatA hai; so yaha bhI bhrama hai / jaise viSamizrita bhojana karane se manuSya mRtyu ko prApta hotA hai paraMtu biSa jaDa padArtha hai usako yaha jJAna nahIM hai ki jo mujhe khAtA hai usakI mRtyu ho jAtI hai, tathApi usako khAnevAlA avazya mRtyu ke mukha meM giratA hai / vaise hI pauSTika padArtha mRgAGka, makaradhvaja, caMdrodaya Adi mAtrAe~ athavA ghRta, dugdha Adi bhakSaNa karane se manuSya kA zarIra puSTa hotA hai, paraMtu ukta padArthoM ko sarvathA yaha mAlUma nahIM ki hamAre sevana karane vAle kI puSTi hotI hai| athavA jaise cumbaka patthara, lohe kA AkarSaNa karatA hai to pASANa aura loha donoM hI jaDa padArtha haiM parantu cumbaka patthara meM aisA hI svAbhAvika guNa hai ki vaha loha ko AkarSaNa kiye binA nahIM raha sakatA / isameM jaise preraka kA koI kAma nahIM tadvat karma jar3a hone se kyA huA ? karma phala bhogane meM bhI Izvara kA koI kAma nahIM hai karmo meM yaha svAbhAva hai ki zubha karma ke kartA ko zubha sAmagrI aura azubha karma ke kartA ko azubha sAmagrI svataH prApta ho jAtI hai / yAda rahe dravya apanA pariNAma nahIM chor3atA / karmoM ko jaDa kahakara zubha karmoM kA phala denevAlA Izvara siddha karanA cAhe to nahIM ho sktaa| jIva zubhAzubha pariNAma ke upayoga se zubhAzubha karma AkarSaNa karake AtmA ko lolupIbhUta karatA hai yaha anAdi anaMta kAla kI sthiti hai / sava vastuoM kA sva va svarUpa meM astitva hai isameM Izvara kA koI kAma nahIM / jagata kA kartA Izvara hai isa bAta ko svIkAra karanevAle yaha kahA karate haiM ki kartA bhoktA eka Izvara hai, dUsarA koI nahIM aura jaba isa bAta meM pakSa nirbala hotA dekhate haiM to zubhAzubha kamoM kA phala Izvara detA hai aisA kahanA

Page #100
( 78 ) zurU kara dete haiM / hama pUchate haiM ki ApakA jagatkartA hI saba kucha hai to phira karmoM ko mAnane kI kyA garaz2a rahI ? - jagatkartAmAnanevAloM kA yaha haTha hai ki vinA kiye kucha bhI cIja nahIM hotI, isase jitane padArtha haiM unakA karanevAlA koI honA hI cAhiye / uttara meM jJAta ho ki phira Apake Izvara kA bhI kartA koI honA cAhie? kyoMki ApakA Izvara vinA hI kiye kaise ho gyaa| yadi kahAjAya ki Izvara kA kartA koI nahIM hai Izvara khataH siddha hai / saMsAra kA racayitA Izvara mAnanA ThIka hai paraMtu Izvara kA kartA mAnanA ThIka nahIM / hama kahate haiM ki kyoM ThIka nahIM ! Apa prathama kaha cuke ho ki vinA kiye kucha bhI padArtha nahIM banatA isase to Izvara kA bhI kartA koI honA ucita hai aura aba kaha rahe ho ki Izvara kA kartA koI nahIM / jaise Apa Izvara kA kartA koI nahIM mAnate tadvat jagat kA kartA bhI koI nahIM aisA mAna liyA jAya to kisI bhI taraha kA vAda vivAda kA kAraNa nahIM raha saktA, aura Izvara ko sRSTi kA kartA nahIM mAnane meM Izvara meM bhI kisI prakAra kA doSa nahIM AtA / parantu Izvara ko sRSTikartA mAnane meM aneka doSa Ate haiM yaha hama prathama dikhA Aye haiM isalie yahA~ para likhane kI jarUrata nhiiN| kitaneka Izvara vAdiyoM kA mAnanA hai ki jagat ke utpatti ke prathama kevala jagat kA kartA eka zuddha, buddha, saccidAnaMda paramezvara hI thA aura dUsarI kucha bhI sAmagrI nahIM thI aura sava padArtha (vastu) Izvara ke hI race huai haiM aura kitaneka IzvaravAdI jagat kI utpatti ke prathama eka Izvara aura dUsarA jagatutpannakarane kI sAmagrI (kAla-dizAprakRti) aura jIva ina tInoM ko anAdi mAnA hai ina donoM hI prakAra ke IzvaravAdiyoM ke praznoM kA uttara nyAyayukta isa graMtha meM diyA gayA hai phira koI IzvaravAdI mahAzaya tarka karegA to yathAsAdhya uttara dene meM bilamba nahIM kiyA jaaygaa| kisI mahAzaya ke mana meM isa viSaya para kucha likhane kI ummeda ho to bezaka kucha likhe, gaura kiyA jaaygaa|

Page #101
jaba IzvaravAdI sarva prakAra se niruttara ho jAte haiM to yaha kahA karate haiM ki jaba Izvara ko sRSTi kA kartA vA preraka na mAneM to Izvara ko kaisA mAne ! aura jaba Izvara kucha karatA hI nahIM hai to Izvara ko mAnane se hI kyA lAbha hogA ? / IzvaravAdI mahAzaya ! isake uttara meM sunie / Izvara ko sAMsArika bAtoM kA preraka mAnane se athavA jagat kA kartA mAnane se pUrvApara virodha AtA hai isIlie jagat kI Izvara ko mAnane vAloM ko niruttara honA hotA hai ataeva Izvara ko dhyeyarUpa mAnane se Izvara meM kisI prakAra kA bhI doSa nahIM AtA aura dhyAna kA AdhAra dhyeyarUpa mAnanA kyA yaha lAbha nahIM hai ? balki etAvanamAtra hI mahAn aura uttama lAbha hai| upsNhaar| aura ' (jaina tattvajJAna) "yadi niSpakSapAta hokara dekhA jAya to satya bAta yaha hai ki, jIva aura jaDa anAdi se mile hue haiM / inakA racayitA koI nahIM hai / yaugika aura mizra padArthoM ke sUkSma aNu-hajAra, lAkha, karoDa, saMkhyAta, asaMkhyAta aura ananta paramANuoM ke skandha kabhI pRthak 2 ho bhI sakte haiM; paraMtu mUla paramANuoM kA vizlaSa kabhI nahIM ho saktA / tAtparya eka paramANu ke do vibhAga nahIM ho sakate / ataeva siddha huA ki mizra padArtha vinAzazIla haiM paraMtu asalI padArtha vinAzazIla nahIM / jIva anAdi aura amara hai| eka zarIra se dUsarA zarIra dhAraNa karanA isakA nAma mRtyu hai| vartamAna avasthA pUrvakRta karmAnusAra aura AgAmI avasthA vartamAna meM kie hue karmoM ke anusAra hotI hai| AtmA jabataka saba karmoM se mukta na hogA taba taka janma maraNa rUpa cakra meM bhramaNa karatA rahegA / jaise manuSya madirA (surA) ke pAna karane se parAdhIna arthAt usake nazA ke AdhIna ho

Page #102
( 80 ) 1 jAtA hai tadvat AsmA sarva zaktimAna arthAt anaMta zaktimAna hone para bhI karmAdhIna hone se paribhramaNa karatA hai / jo jIva jaisA karatA hai vaisA phala bhogatA hai| karmoM kA phala denevAlA dUsarA mAnanA bhrama hai / karmoM kA bhuktabhoga pUrA ho jAne se jIva mukta' ho jAtA hai / pUrva saMcita karmoM ko dUrakara AgAmI karmoM kA baMdha par3anA roka deve tabhI jIva kI mukti hotI hai / jagat kA kartA koI nahIM svataH anAdi kAla se pravAharUpa calA AtA hai / mukta jIva phira saMsAra meM lauTa ke nahrIM Ate / jo loga mukta jIvoM kA phira saMsAra meM lauTa AnA mAnate haiM unameM vaha buddhi kA doSa hai / sarva padArtha svataH apanA apanA kArya karate rahate haiM aura kAla, svabhAva, niyati, udyama, aura karma ina pAMcoM kA samavAyasaMbaMdha, padArtho ke saMyoga meM nimitta hai / jaisA ki sUtra ke taMtu ke puMja se paTa kI utpatti hone kA samaya isako "kAla" jAnanA aura sUtra ke puMja meM paTa kI utpatti karane kI yogyatA hai isako "svabhAva" jAnanA / paDha ke banAne kA pudgala jaise rUI hai isako "niyati" sama jhanA, bhavitavyatA-prArabdha - daiva- adRSTa - jIvakRta dharmAdharma, kiMvA pudgalAdi bhI niyata kA artha hotA hai athavA jina jina padArthoM ke jaise 2 svabhAva haiM una una padArthoM kA vaisA vaisA jo pariNAma ho usakA bhI nAma niyati hai / jisa sUtra ke taMtu ke puMja se jisa paTa kI utpatti kA jo nimitta honA " vaha " pUrva karma" samajhanA cAhie / aura taMtu ke puMja se paTa kI utpatti karane kA jo udyoga karanA usako " udyama" jAnanA cAhiye / ina pAMcoM ke samavAya saMbandha ke yoga se saba kArya hote haiM isameM Izvara kA kucha kAma nahIM / jaDa, cetana padArtha svayaM anAdi siddha haiM / puruSa binA strI nahIM, aura strI binA puruSa nahIM / bIja binA vRkSa nahIM, aura bRkSa binA bIja nhiiN| pRthavI, jala, vAyu aura AkAza inake binA, manuSyoM kI athavA vRkSoM kI sthiti honA prAyaH duHsAdhya hai / jar3a aura cetana ina donoM padArthoM ke aMtargata saba padArthoM kA samA 1 zarIrAdi sarva padArthoM se AtmA kA Atyantika viyoga ho jAne kA nAma mukti hai / jo Atmika sukhoM meM mamna rahe use muktAtmA kahate haiM /

Page #103
( 1 ) veza ho sakatA hai / pratyeka padArtha meM apanA apanA guNa ThaharA huA hai / mRttikA meM yaha guNa hai ki agni meM rahane se kaThora aura raktavarNa ho jAtI hai parantu kAgaz2a meM ukta guNa nahIM hai / vaha na kaThora ho sakatA hai aura na lAla / kASTha kI lakar3I do lekara aura chIlachilAkara paraspara donoM ko phasAdo aura Thokakara custa karado jor3a laga jAyagA aura paraspara ekameM eka milakara eka samAna hojaakgii| parantu dhUlipara dhUli rakhane se jor3a nahIM lagasakatA, isI taraha saMsAra ke sarva padArthoM kI parIkSA karane se siddha hotA hai ki pratyeka vastu meM pRthak pRthak svAbhAvika guNa rahate haiM / aneka padArtha aise saMsAra meM haiM jinake milane se aura pRthak pRthak hone se aneka navIna svabhAva utpanna hote haiN| jaise zyAma aura pIta raMga milane se haritabhAva hotA hai / ghAsa kA bIja pRthivI meM bone ko koI nahIM jAtA; paraMtu barSA ke pAnI kA yoga pAkara svataH aMkura nikalakara ghAsa uga jAtA hai / tadvat saMsAra meM padArthoM kA ota prota (ulaTa-palaTa) hokara nAnA prakAra ke navIna bhAva sadA utpanna aura vinaSTa hote rahate haiN| isa prakAra kI racanA ko ajJa athavA alpajJoM ne Izvara kI racanA samajha rakkhI hai / jIva jaisA karma karatA hai tadanusAra usako phaLa svataH prApta hotA hai, Izvara ko isameM madhyastha hone kI koI AvazyakatA nahIM hai| koI aisA nyAyazIla manuSya saMsAra meM nahIM dIkhatA ki jo rAgadveSarahita Izvara ko sRSTikartA siddha kara de ! jo lorA pakSapAtarUpa kathA or3hakara baiThe hue haiM ve yukti pramANa ko kucha cIja nahIM smjhte| yadi ve kadAcit lekhanIdvArA athavA vaktRtAdvArA haThAt apane mantavya siddha karane kA prayatna bhI kareM to bhI buddhimAna aura vivekI puruSa, usa durAgraha ko zIghra samajhakara unake mantavya ko apane hRdaya meM sthAna nahIM dete ! jagat racanA kI ora lakSyapUrvaka dekhA jAya to itanI bAta avazya hai ki kAraNarUpa jagat ; arthAt jaDa, cetana padArtha anAdi se hai aura 1 isa bAta para vizeSa dekhane kI jisakI icchA ho vaha bhautika zAstra dekhe / 2 guddd'ii|

Page #104
( 82 ) kArya rUpa jagat ; arthAt nAnA prakAra ke padArtha jo kRtrima dRSTigata ho rahe haiM unake banAnevAle saba saMsArI jIva haiM / isameM Izvara kA kucha saMbaMdha nhiiN| "svayaM karma karotyAtmA, vayaM tatphalamaznute / khayaM bhramati saMsAre, svayameva vinazyati" // 1 // "yaH kartA karmabhedAnAM, bhoktA karmaphalasya ca / saMsadma parinirvAtA, sa hyAtmA nAnyalakSaNam" // 1 // AtmA ajJAna ke udaya se bure aura jJAna ke udaya se acche ApahI svataH karma karatA hai, aura svayaM hI bhogatA hai, svayaM hI saMsAra meM paribhramaNa karatA hai aura svayaM hI eka gati se dUsarI gati meM jAtA hai, jisako vyavahAra meM mara gayA kahate haiN| jaba saba kAryoM se niHspRhI hokara AtmA kA sAdhana karegA taba janma, maraNa se chUTakara sarva karmoM se vimukta ho jAyagA; phira saMsAra meM paribhramaNa karanA na hogaa| ___mAtA ke udara meM jisa samaya jIva AtA hai usa samaya pUrvabhava ke, puNya pApa ke baMdha ke anusAra acchA yA burA zarIra banAtA hai aura zarIra saMpUrNa hojAnepara janma dhAraNa karatA hai / yadi AyuH pUrNa hotA hai to adhika kAla usa zarIra meM rahatA hai / zubha karmoM se sukha aura azubha karmoM se duHkha jIva ko hotA hai yaha sarala mArga hai| jaina zAstroM meM arihanta aura siddha ko deva mAnate haiM / AcArya, upAdhyAya aura sAdhu ko guru mAnate haiM / jJAna, darzana; cAritra aura tapa ko dharma kA mUla mAnA hai| ukta zuddha deva, zuddha guru aura zuddha dharma ina . 1 antarAyadAnalAbhavIryabhogopabhogaNA: / hAso ratyaratI bhItirjugupsA zoka eva ca // 1 // kAmo mithyAtvamajJAnaM, nidrA ca viratistathA / rAgo dveSazca no doSAsteSAmaSTAdazApyamI // 2 // bhAvArtha-1 dAnAntarAya 2 lAbhAntarAya, 3 vIryAntarAya,4 bhogAntarAya, 5 upabhogAntarAya, 6 hAsya, 7 rati, 8 arati, 9 bhaya,10 jugupsA, 11 zoka, 12 kAma, 13 mithyAtva, 14 ajJAna, 15 nidrA, 16 avirati, 10 rAga, 18 dveSa / ina aThAraha doSoM se rahita arihanta hote haiN|

Page #105
( 83 ) tIna tatvoM ko jo pUrNa jAnakAra dRDha zraddhAvAn ho vahI vizuddha jainI kahA jA sakatA hai / jisa deva meM aThAraha doSa hoM athavA aThAraha meM se eka bhI doSa mile use zuddha deva nahIM jAnanA / aura jo guru kanaka kAminI kA lolupI ho vaha suguru nahIM ho sakatA aura jo dharma hiMsApracura ajJAniyoM dvArA praNIta ho vaha zuddha dharma nahIM ho sakatA / ina tIna tattvoM kA jaina zAstroM meM khUba vicAra kiyA gayA hai| jIva, ajIva, puNya, pApa, Azrava, saMvara, baMdha, nirjarA aura mokSa ye nava padArtha (tatva) mAne haiM / dharmAstikAya - adharmAstikAya AkAzAstikAya - pudgala aura jIva yaha SaT dravya haiM / astitva, vastutva dravyatva, prameyatva, aguru laghutva, pradezatva, cetanatva, acetanatva, mUrttatva, aura amUrttatva, yaha daza dravya ke sAmAnya guNa haiM / jJAna, darzana, sukha, vIrya, sparza, rasa, gandha, varNa, gatihetutva, sthitihetutva, avagAhanAhetutva, varttanAhetutva, cetanatva, acetanatva, mUrttatva aura amUrttatva yaha dravya ke solaha vizeSa guNa haiM / asti, nAsti, nitya, anitya, eka, aneka, bheda, abheda, bhavya, abhavya aura parama yaha gyAraha dravya ke sAmAnya svabhAva haiM / cetana, acetana, mUrtta, amUrtta, eka pradeza, aneka pradeza, vibhAvasvabhAva, zuddha svabhAva, azuddha svabhAva aura upacarita svabhAva yaha daza dravya ke vizeSa svabhAva haiM / vastu ke eka eka dharma para saptabhaMgI kI racanA jAnane yogya hai / syAdvAda' nyAya se jisa vastu kI parIkSA kI jAya aura vaha ThIka parikSA meM utare vaha satya hai | sabhI vastu utpatti, vyaya aura dhrauvya guNa se yukta hai / dravya kI apekSA nitya, aura paryAya kI apekSA anitya hai / vastu svarUpa karake astitva meM hai aura para rUpa karake astitva meM nahIM hai, arthAt para rUpa karake asti nahIM aura svarUpa karake nAsti nahIM / pratyakSa aura parokSa do pramANa mAne haiN| tIrthakaroM ne eka zrAvaka (gRhastha ) dharma aura dUsarA yati dharma kahA hai | zrAvakoM ke liye dazavidha dharma isa prakAra 1 jAnanAH 1 syAdasti, 2 syAnnAsti, 3 syAdasti nAsti, 4 syAdavaktavya, 5 syAdasti avaktavya, 6 syAnnAsti avaktavya, 7 syAdasti nAsti avaktavya / yaha saptabhaMgI arthAt syAdvAdanyAya kI mukhya bAteM haiM / -

Page #106
( 28 ) "dayA dAnaM damo devapUjA bhaktirgurau kSamA / satyaM zaucaM tapo'steyaM, dharmo'yaM gRhamedhinAm" // 1 // 1 sarva jIvoM para anukaMpA dayA rakhanA, 2 abhaya supAtrAdi dAna denA, 3 paMca indriyoM kA damana, 4 jineMdra deva kI dravya bhAva sahita pUMjA, 5 guru bhakti, 6 kSamA, 7 satya, 8 pavitra rahanA, 9 tapasyA karanA aura 10 corI nahIM karanA / yaha dazavidhadharma gRhasthoM kA kahA / dharma kArya meM udyamI, Astika, vinayavAn, zAstra gurumukha se zravaNa karane vAlA, paraloka sAdhana ke lie, zuddha mana, vacana, kAyA se dharmakriyA karane vAlA, sadbuddhiyukta, saMsAra ko asAra samajhakara lobha lAlaca ko ghaTAnevAlA, viSaya sukha ko kSaNika samajhakara tyAga karanevAlA aura kaSAya ko haTAkara svabhAva ko sthira rakhanevAlA ho vahI zuddha zrAvaka ho sakatA hai| " dUsarA yati dharma dazavidha isa prakAra jAnanA :-- "khaMti- ajjava - maddava - mutti-tava-saMyamo ya boddhavo / saccaM soyaM akiMcaNaM ca baMbhaM ca jaI dhammo " // 1 // 1 kSamA, 2 nirabhimAna, 3 niSkapaTa, 4 sarva sAMsArika kAryoM se mukta, 5 tapayukta, 6 satraha prakAra ke saMyama kA pAlanahAra, 7 satyagrAhI-satyavaktA, 8 bAhya Abhyantara zauca, 9 suvarNAdika dhAtu ke tyAgI, 10 brahmacaryavrata sahita yaha dazavidha yatidharma kahA / aura cha kAya ke rakSaka, zuddha upadeza ke dene vAle, SaTa dravya kI carcA ke jAnakAra paMca mahAvrata dhAraka, pAMca indriya ke 23 viSayoM ko jItane vAle, kaSAyarahita, jJAna, darzana, cAritra ke ArAdhaka, jinAgama syAdvAda vANI ke jAnakara, apramAdI dharmadhuraMdhara, mokSamArga ke darzaka, gRhasthAzrama kA tyAga, dIkSA grahaNakara tIrthakaroM ke mArga ko batalAne vAlA jo ho usI ko yatidharma kA ArAdhaka samajhanA cAhie /

Page #107
( 85 ) jo gRhavAsa tyAgakara dharmakriyA karanA cAhatA hai usakeliye tIrthakaroM ne yatidharma batalAyA aura jinase sAMsArika cIjoM kA sarvathA tyAga nahIM ho sakatA unake liye zrAvaka dharma batalAyA hai / 8 tIrthakaroM kA yaha upadeza hai ki dharma karo, susta mata baiTho, jindagI ke ghar3Ibhara kA bhI bharosA nahIM hai / isaliye satyadarzI bano, AtmA paratantratA se chUTe aisA mArga svIkArakaro aura svatantra banAo yahI saMsAra meM sAra hai / prastuta bhArata ke aneka vidvAna deza kI svatantratA prApti ke liye Andolana kara rahe haiM, athAha parizrama va kaSTa uThA rahe haiM unakA yaha vicAra hai ki deza kI unnati ho aura hamAre bhAratavarSIya janasamUha sukhI saubhAgyazAlI bane ! unase hamArA nivedana hai ki jaise Apa deza kI svatantratA prApti ke liye dattacitta bane haiM vaisehI Apa AtmA kI svatantratA arthAt svAdhInatA prApti karane kA bhI prayatna kyoM nahIM karate ! | Izvara ko jagat kA karttA hartA mAnane vAle aura IzvarIya ( saGketa) icchA se kArya kA honA na honA mAnanevAle loga hamArI samajha se hamezAhI ke lie parataMtra hai arthAt Izvara ke athavA Izva rIya icchA ke AdhIna hI haiN| deza kI svatantratA se manuSya prANioM ko paugalika ( zArIraka ) sukha prApta hone kA saMbhava hai paraMtu AtmA kI svatantratA se Atmika sukha kSaNika nahIM kintu hamezA ke liye hai / kiMbahunA AtmA ko svatantratA prApta karanA hai arthAt janma janma kI paratantratA ko naSTa karanA hai arthAt mokSa prApti karanA hai / saccI svatantratA vahI hai jo zubhAzubha karmoM ke vazIbhUta hue AtmA ko sava karma baMdhanoM se chur3Akara Atmika sukhoM meM magna karanA / jisane AtmA kI svatantratA prApta karalI hai usakeliye na koI zatru hai aura na koI mitra | aura svadezI videzI bhI samAna haiM isIliye maiM apane bhAratavarSIya saba mitroM se yahI sUcita karatA hU~ saccI svatantratA cAhiye to Izvara ko jagatkartA ki yadi Apa ko mAnanA chor3a do

Page #108
( 86 ) aura jaina darzana ke pranthoM kA dIrgha dRSTi se avalokana karo jisase Apako saccI svatantratA prApti karane kA mArga mile / anta meM dezI videzI svadharmI paradharmI saba mitroM se isa grantha ko Adi se anta taka par3hane kI prArthanA karake maiM isa graMtha ko yahA~ hI pUrNa karatA hU~ / zubhAni bhUyAsurvarddhamAnAni / zam saMvat 1965 kArtikavadI SaSThI guruvAra AkolA (barADa) jaina zvetAmbara mandira tAjanA peTha sajjana kRpAbhilASI yati bAlacandra

Page #109
isa grantha ke chapane meM jo agrima mUlya dekara grAhaka bane haiM unakI nAmAvalI. pustakasaMkhyA. nAma.. gAma. | pustakasaMkhyA. nAma. gAma. 300 sA. mUlacanda vADIlAla / 1 sA. velajI ratanasI ,. ne-svargasthabhrAtA-sA. / 1 sA. lIlAdhara rANA , mohanalAla-vADIlAla ke 1 sA. candulAla jhUThamala , smaraNArtha-sAdhu-sAdhvI- 1 sA. somacanda cunnIlAla ,, zrAvaka-zrAvikA-pATha- / 1 sA. daulAsA kasturacaMda ". zAlA Adi ko bhejadene 1 sA. maGgulAla tribhuvana , ke liye AkolA 1 sA. jagajIvana kizora , 10 muhutA-pRthivIrAjajI 2 sA. cunnIlAla puMjamala , ratanalAlajI 1 dasADIyA haragoviMda 10 sA. giradhara hakamacanda , puruSottama " 5 sA. bhANajI sojapAra , | 15 sA. trIkamaladdhA copaDA 5 sA, ThAkarasI devajI , 11 sA. DugarazI devarAja , 5 sA. hIrajI korasI , 5 sA. kAnajI jevata pAcorA 5 sA. petharAja rAyasI , 2 sA.kAnajI rUpazI cAlIzagAMva 5 sA. maGgusA hIrAcanda , 5 sA. kesavajI ratanazI zegAMva 5 sA. dolAjI kuzanAjI , 5 sA. lAlajI haMzarAja baMbaI 3 sA. devajI gelA , 5 bhaMDArIjI-sujAnamalajI 3 sA. cunnIlAla Dosalacanda,, hIMganaghATa 2 sA. cApasI tejasI , 1 jaDAvamalajI dIpacanda selu. 2 sA. pAlaNa gelA 1 metA, tilokacaMdajI dulajI 2 sA. kherAja raNasI , pratApagaDha, jilA-nImace chAvaNI. , 2 sA. phakIracanda maganalAla, , 1 matA,

Page #110
zrI - jaina esosIezana oNpha inDiyA ke lAipha membara sA. ratanazI - sAmajI kaccha - koThArA vAle kI banAI huI gahulI / [ raMgarasIyA - raMgarasabanyo manamohanajI | yaha dezI ] aho guru bAlacandrajI, bhale AvyA jI / sahu saMgha harSita hoyaho, manabhAvyA jI / anta* // 1 // kevalacandrajI guru ApanA, guNavantA jI / ziSya cho tame buddhivantaho, vidyAvantA jI // 2 // tame jinavANi satya karI, dRDha mAnI jI / tethI tyAgI duniyA zIghra ho, divAnI jI // 3 // karmagrantha vAMco acchA ati, sAruM jI / teto lAge sahune mIThaDu, atipyAruM jI // 4 // zrAvaka zrAvikA sahumalI, guNagAtre jI / zAstra sAMbhalI pulakita hoya, hAM manabhAve jI // 5 // AkolAno saMgha tamane nameM, bahubhAve jI / sAmata suta ratanasI, guNa gAve jI // 6 // // iti //

Page #111
// vijJApana // reonon . nirAkaraNa-nirNaya / isa grantha meM digambara zrAvaka tAtyA neminAtha pAMgale ke asatya AkSepoM kA uttara darja hai aura zvetAmbara jainadharma kA prAcInatva sapramANa siddha karake batalAdiyA gayA hai / yaha grantha zrIyati mahArAja zrIvAlacandrajI racita hai; DemI AThapejI pA~ca phArama kA grantha hai tathApi mUlya kevala do Ane rakkhe gae haiM / ma~gAnevAle zIghratA kreN| milane kA patApRthivIrAjajI ratanalAlajI muhatA Co. tAjanA peTha - AkolA (barAr3a)

Page #112
jaintttvdigdrshn| yaha vaktRtAsvarUpa grantha, zAstravizArada-jainAcArya zrIvijayadharmasUri jI ne kRpAkarake kaoNnvenzana oNpha inDiyana rilIjens kalakattA ke presIDenTa hAIkorTa ke bhUtapUrva jaja bAbU zAradAcaraNa mitra jI kI prArthanApara pUrvokta sabhA ke liye hindI meM likhA thA-aura 9 apraila 1909 I0 ko usa sabhA meM par3hA bhI gyaa| isa pustaka meM prAyaH samasta jainazAstra kA tattva abhiniviSTa hai / samaya ke prabhAva se itara kI kathAhI kyA ! jainadharmI bhI apane dharma ke siddhAnta ko pUrA kyA ! adhUrA bhI nahIM jAnate; unake liye aura sarva sAdhAraNa jainadharmatattvajijJAsuoM ko yaha bar3A lAbhadAyaka hai| ____ isame saMkSeparUpa se sabhI padArthoM kI uttamarIti se vivecanA kI gaI hai aura isake viSaya meM jo samAlocanAyeM huI haiM unameM se do eka kA saMkSipta bhAva yaha hai:-sarasvatI prayAga-agasta 1909 I0 'kucha dina hue kalakatte meM eka dharma-mahAsabhA huI thii| usameM saMsAra ke mukhya mukhya matoM aura dharmoM para kitanehI lekha par3he gaye the| jaina dharma para jo lekha par3hA gayA thA vaha aba pustakAkAra prakAzita huA hai| isameM jaina dharma ke mukhya mukhya siddhAntoM kA sthUlarUpa se hindI meM varNana hai| ... isa choTIsI pustaka meM jaina dharma kA tattvanirUpaNa uttamatA pUrvaka kiyA gayA hai| thor3e meM jise isa dharma kA sAra jAnanA ho use...yaha pustaka prakAzaka se ma~gAkara jarUra par3hanA caahie|... isa pustaka ke anta meM pustakakartA ne apanI zAlInatA aura namratA kA darzaka vIra-prArthanA para eka padya diyA hai ......" LUZAC'S ORIENTAL LIST & BOOK REVIEW OF MARCH --APRIL 09. Jaina-tattava-dig-darsana is the title of a monograph recently read at a Convention of Indian Religions in Calcutta by Vijayadharma Suri. The work is written in scholarly but lucid Hindi, and gives a succinct outline of Jain theology, doctrine, and religious practice, with a sufficient amount of detail. Nothing new is presented, but the essentials of Jainism are described clearly and attractively. The little work is likely to be of considerable use as a handbook of Jainism, and deserves to be welcomed. mUlya 4 AnA mAtra patA:-sA. harSacanda bhUrAbhAI. aMgrejI koThI, banArasa siTI.