Sadhvi Vyakhyan Nirnay

Author(s): Manisagarsuri
Publisher: Hindi Jainagam Prakashak Sumati Karyalay
Catalog link: https://jainqq.org/explore/034600/1

Page #1
NIRSARYANEERINBENIM' ECENSECONSENSEKSears SMOTO * OM * * zrI jinAya namaH sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH lekhaka zrImAn mahopAdhyAya zrI sumatisAgarajI mahArAja ke laghu ziSya zrI maNisAgara sUrijI mahArAja MA sAdhviyoM ko sUcita kiyA jAtA hai ki sAdhuoM kI taraha sAdhviyoM ko bhI zrAvaka-zrAvikAoM kI sabhA meM dharmadezanA dene kA adhikAra hai jisake zAstrIya pramANa isa grantha meM saMgrahita haiM tathA zaMkAoM kA samAdhAna bhI kiyA gayA hai / koI vyakti isakA niSedha karane kA Agraha kare to use na mAno aura dila kholakara jJAnavRddhi karo aura dharmopadeza diyA karo / prakAzaka tu zrI hindI jainAgama prakAzaka sumati kAryAlaya, jaina presa, koTA dravya sahAyakaPA zrImatI-pravartinI pratApazrIjI-campAzrIjI-vallabhazrIjI-pramodazrIjI ke upadeza se hama zrAvikA saMgha phalaudI ( mAravAr3a) Pass vIra saM0 2472 ] san 1646 I0 [vikrama saM0 2003 BOY prathamAvRtti ] jaina priMTiMga presa, koTA meM mudrit| [mUlya satya grahaNa SOURNAMASTERNMaswwwBER MEMBERSNEPALBEANS

Page #2
bIkAnera meM upadhAna tapa aura AcArya pada (zrImAn sukhasAgarajI mahArAja ke siMghAr3e meM dUsare AcArya ) kharatara gacchIya mahAmahopAdhyAya zrI sumatisAgarajI mahArAja ke ziSyaratna pUjyavara upAdhyAya zrI maNisAgarajI mahArAja ziSya vinayasAgarajI saha virAjane se yahAM bahuta sI dhArmika jAgRtieM huii| upadhAna tapa una saba meM pradhAna hai| kArtika kRSNa 6 ko upadhAna tapa prAraMbha huA, aura isameM : zrAvaka 85 zrAvikAoM ne tapa vahana kara mahAn lAbha uThAyA / isakA sArA Ayojana seTha saMpatalAlajI daphtarI kI tarapha se huA thaa| tapa kI nirvighna samApti ke upalakSya meM mAlAropaNa kA mahotsava pauSa kRSNa pratipadA 1 kA nizcita hone para cUrU meM cAturmAsa kara nAgaura padhAre huve paramapUjya jainAcArya zrI jinariddhisUrijI ma0 ko vizeSa Agraha ke sAtha yahAM padhArane kI vinatI kI gaI / saMgha ke Agraha se prAcArya ma0 bhI zIghratA se vihAra kara mArgazIrSa zukla pUrNimA 15 ko bIkAnera padhAre / sUri jI ke svAgatArtha bIkAnera kA vizAla saMgha bar3I saMkhyA meM sAmane gayA, usI dina dopahara meM mAlA kA varaghor3A niklaa| miti pauSa kRSNa pratipadA 1 ko lagabhaga do DhAI hajAra janatA kI upasthiti meM mAlA ropaNa mahotsava seTha dAnamalajI nAhaTA kI koTaDI-nAhaToM kI gavAr3a meM saMpanna huA, isa suavasara para upAdhyAya zrI maNisAgarajI ma. ko zrI saMgha kI ora se mahopAdhyAya pada dene kA vicAra ho rahA thA para prAcArya zrI jina riddhisUrijI ma. ne ApakI yogyatA evaM viziSTa sevAoM ko dhyAna meM lAkara saMgha se zrAcArya pada dene kA prastAva rakkhA, isa para zrImAn seTha bhairUdAnajI koThArI ne saMgha kI sammati dvArA sUrijI ke prastAvita zrAdeza kA samarthana kiyA, va gambhIra jayadhvani ke sAtha unheM prAcArya pada se suzobhita kiyA gyaa| isake pazcAt saMghapatijI kI sevAoM kA zrI tAjamalajI botharA ne digdarzana karAyA aura zrI bhairUMdAnajI koThArI ke kara kamaloM se upadhAna saMghavI zrI sampatalAlajI daphtarI ko cAMdI ke kAskeTa meM sanmAna patra diyA gyaa| zrI caMpAlAlajI baksI ne do mAsa taka apane sAre vyApAra evaM gRhakArya ko chor3a kara dina rAta bar3e parizrama se upadhAna kI vyavasthA saMpanna kI isake liye unheM bhI svarNa raupya padaka dene kI ghoSaNA kI gaI tatpazcAt tapasviyoM ko mAlA pahanAI jAkara vibhinna vyaktiyoM dvArA rAvatamalajI botharA ke cAMdI ke pyAle, aATha vyaktiyoM ke nagada rupaye, pustakeM, nAriyala, khopare Adi kI karIba 71 prabhAvanAeM huI / upadhAna tapa ke upalakSa meM miti kArtika zuklA 6 ko sthAnIya zrI cintAmaNijI ke maMdira ke bhaNDArastha 1110 prAcIna pratimAeM evaM zrI mahAvIrajI ke bhaNDArastha 75 pratimAeM ko bAhara nikAla kara zrI saMpatalAlajI daphtarI ne usake darzana evaM pUjana kA mahAna lAbha utthaayaa| unakI ora se 6 aTThAI mahotsava aura anya 6-7 aTThAI mahotsava huve| giti kArtika zuklA 15 ko zrI cintAmaNijI ke maMdira se bar3e dhUmadhAma ke sAtha bhagavAna kI savArI nikAlI jAkara gauDI pArzvanAthajI ke maMdira hokara vApisa pdhaarii| mitI mArgazIrSa kRSNA 6 ko zAMti snAtra evaM visarjana kriyA vidhi ke sAtha zrI ciMtAmaNijI kI bhaNDArastha mUrtiyAM punaH bhaMDAra meM virAjamAna kI gii| zrI mahAvIra svAmI ke maMdira kI pratimAeM pauSa kRSNA pratipadA 1 ko bhaNDArastha kI gaI / mAlAropaNa utsava meM anekoM zrAvaka zrAvikAoM ne mahIne, 15 dina brahmacarya Adi ke pratyAkhyAna kiye evaMzrI rAvatamalajI va pUnamacaMdajI botharA ne jor3e se caturtha vrata evaM jatanamalajI nAhaTA (Ayu 23 varSa) ne Ajanma brahmacarya vrata svIkAra kiyA / kaI zrAvaka 12 vratAdi lene kA vicAra kara rahe haiN| jaina dhvaja varSa 8 aMka 31 tArIkha 23-12-44 ke aMka se uddhata / bhaMvaralAla nAhaTA

Page #3
upodghAta ' sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNaya : ' pustaka ke lekhaka pUjya jainAcArya zrI maNisAgarasUrijI jaina jagat meM suprasiddha vidvAn haiN| Apa zrI bRhatparyuSaNA nirNaya:, zragamAnusAra muhapatti nirNayaH, devadravya nirNAyaH evaM kalpasUtra anuvAda yadi kRtiyoM ke dvArA sAhitya sevA karake janatA kA acchA hitasAdhana kiyA hai evaM jainAgamoM ko rASTra bhASA hindI meM anudita kara janasAdhAraNa taka pahuMcAne kI ApakI yojanA avazya hI zlAghanIya hai / isa pustaka kA viSaya nAma se hI spaSTa hai / Azcarya to isa bAta kA hai ki jisa jaina dharma ne vyakti svAtantrya ke carama vikAza kA bIr3A uThAyA / jAti varNa aura liMga bheda ke mahatva ko nirmUla kara "guNA-pUjA sthAnaM guNISu na ca liMgaM na ca vayaH " kA Adarza upasthita kara mokSa kA dvAra prANI mAtra ke lie khulA kara diyA usa pavitra dharmameM Aja sAdhviyoM ke vyAkhyAna dene ke niSedha kA prazna upasthita kiyA jAtA hai| jinakA jIvana hI sva-para kalyANa ke lie, jJAna dhyAna upadeza ke lie hai ve yadi vyAkhyAna jJAna dAnAdi na kareM ? to kyA kareM? vidvAn zrAcArya zrI ne prastuta prazna para zAstrIya pramANa va yuktiyoM ke sAtha isa grantha meM yathocita prakAza DAlA hai ataH maiM usakA piSTapeSaNa na kara kucha apane vicAra pAThakoM ke samakSa upasthita karatA hU~ / jaina dharma meM strI jAti ko dhArmika dRSTi se puruSa ke samAna adhikAra diyA gayA hai / use mAnava ke ati uccatama vikAza kevalajJAna aura mokSa taka kI adhikAriNI mAnA gayA hai / caturvidha saMgha meM puruSoM ke samAna hI sAdhviyoM aura zrAvikAoM kA sthAna hai,zvetAmbara jainAgamoM meM saikar3oM sAdhviyoM [ dIkSita striyAM ] ke mokSa jAne kA ullekha hai / unnIsaveM tIrthaMkara zrImallinAtha bhagavAn bhI strI jAti ke prati the / bhagavAn RSabhadeva svAmI ne apanI brAhmI sundarI putriyoM ko 64 kalAeM sikhAI thIM aura ve bAhubalike kevala jJAnopArjana meM nimitta kAraNa ho kara anta meM mokSa gaI / saccaritratA ke lie 16 satiyoM ke nAma Aja bhI nitya prAtaH kAla smaraNa kiye jAte haiM / pratyeka tIrthaGkara ke saMgha meM sAdhu zrAvakoM se sAdhvI zrAvikA kI saMkhyA adhika thI / uttarAdhyayana sUtra meM kAmavAsanA ke dvArA saMyama mArga se vicalita hote hue rahanemi ko satI rAjImatI ne bodha dekara saMyama meM sthira karane kA ullekha hai / jJAtA sUtra meM mallikuvari [ 16 veM tIrthakara ] dvArA 6 mitra rAjAoM ke pratibodha ebaM satI draupadI kA jIvana caritra hai, arthAt strI jAti ke prati bhI samAna Adara vyakta kiyA gayA hai / Aja kala ke samaya meM strI vyakti ke paricaya dene kI koI AvazyakatA pratIta nahIM hotii| jagata ke bar3e se bar3e va kaThina se kaThina kArya striyAM kara sakatI haiM yaha pAzcAtya deza ke vikazita strI samAja va bhAratIya mahilAbhoM meM paM0 vijaya lakSmI, sarojinI nAyaDU, kaipTana lakSmIbAI Adi ne bhalI bhAMti siddha kara dikhAyA. hai / yadi unake vikAza meM kamI hai to usakA uttaradAyI-puruSa samAja hI hai jisane cirakAla se strI jAti ko hIna samajhane aura dabAye rakhane kI nIti dhAraNa kara rakhI hai| vAstava meM strI aura puruSa meM liGga bheda ke zArIrika bheda ke sivA aura koi AtmavikAza ke kAraNoM meM bheda nahIM hai / vahI tejapuMjamayI AtmA donoM ke andara birAjamAna hai kaI bAtoM meM to puruSoM se bhI bar3hakara strI jAti kA mahatva hai I

Page #4
jaina dharma meM dravya, kSetra, kAla, bhAva ke anusAra pravRtti karane kA Adeza hai, apavAda mArga isI kA pratIka hai / jisa kArya se vartamAna kAla meM adhika lAbha ho vahI karanA zreyaskara hai / vartamAna kAla meM sAdhviyoM ke vyArUyAma dene kI bar3I hI upayogitA hai kyoMki sAdhu loga alpa saMkhyaka hai aura unakA vihAra bhI avyavasthita hone ke kAra bahuta se sthAnoM ke zrAvaka dhArmika jJAna se vaMcita raha jAte haiM, yahI kAraNa hai ki lAkhoM kI saMkhyA meM zrAvaka loga anya matAvalambI hogaye haiM / isa dRSTi se bhI sAdhviyoM ke vyAkhyAna kI bar3I upAdeyatA hai isakA phala pratyakSa hai; kharatara gaccha kI viduSI sAdhviyoM dvArA jo dharma pracAra huA evaM ho rahA hai yaha sarva vidita hai ataH pratyakSa pariNAma dekhate hue isakI upayogitA meM koI saMdeha nahIM kiyA jA sakatA / samarthana hI karate haiM aura sAdhviyoM ke vyAkhyAna kA niSedha karane vAle bhI unake jJAna saMpAdana karane kA to jJAna kA vikAza jJAna dAna ke dvArA hotA hai, isake dvArA vRddhi prApta hotI hai anyathA vismRta jAtA hai ataH sAdhviyoM ke jJAna saMpAdana kA lAbha bhI janatA ko milanA cAhie / vyAkhyAna denA isake lie sundara sAdhana hai aura ise niSedha karanA koI bhI vicArazIla ucita nahIM samajhegA kyoMki kisI bhI kArya kA ucita aura anaucitya usake bhAlAbha para nirbhara hai| prAcIna kAla meM bhI jainadharma meM aneko viduSI sAdhviyAM huI hai jinameM se ' guNa samRddhi mahattarA ' racita "aMjanA caritra" upalabdha hai / vyAkhyAnAdi na dene se jJAna kA upayoga nahIM hone ke kAraNa hI vartamAna kAla meM sAdhviyAM paThana pAThana meM adhika saceSTa nahIM hotIM yadi veM vyAkhyAna denA Avazyaka samajheMgI to unakA utsAha va abhyAsa bar3hegA aura jJAna kA vikAza hone ke sAtha sAtha zrAvaka zrAvikAoM meM bhI dhArmika jJAna kI vRddhi hogI aura anya matAvalambI hone se ruka kara ubhaya samAja kA lAbha evaM utkarSa hogA / agaracaMda nAhaTA sAdhvI saMghanI upayogitA lekhaka - pArzvacandra gacchIya sAdhvIjI zrI khAMti zrIjI tA0 28,10,45 nA aMka 41 pAnA 557 para 'samAjamAM sAdhvioMnu karttavya' e mathAlA bhAI varajIvanadAsa vADI lAle eka lekha Apyoche; sAdhvIzro samAja ne upayogI bane ane ucca sthAne Ave evo emano Azaya che, parantu e lekhanI aMdara je vastusthiti jaNAvI ke te keTalIka bhayabharelI bhane ayogya che / sAdhu karatAM sAdhvIzro samAja ne ochI upayogI che te e bhAI kaI zrAMkhe joI zakatA haze ? kAraNa ke kharatara gacchIya, pArzvacandragachIya, aMcalagacchIya, sudharmagacchIya bhane sthAnakavAsI saMpradAyanI aneka sAdhvIzro judA judA dezoMmAM vicarI, vyAkhyAno ApI, pote melavela jJAnano upayoga samAjamA chUTathI karI rahela che temaja dhArmika kAryo karAvI prabhAva pADe che mane dIkSita thaye 28 varasa thavA AvyAM, te daramyAna kaccha kAThiyAbAr3ha, gujarAta, mAravAr3a (bIkAnera) sudhInA paribhramaNamAM meM te anubhavyuM che, nAnA moThA

Page #5
( 5 ) hareka gAmomAM jyAM jyA~ sAdhvIjIo birAjela hoya che, tyAM tyAM nAnI bAlAo thI kaI moTI bahina sudhI ne dhArmika abhyAsa karAvatA hoya che, temane navakAra thI mAMDI karma grantha sudhInuM jJAna sAdhvI jI monA pratApeja malyuM hoya che, sAdhvIjIo pAse strI varga hamezA abhyAsa karato anubhavAye che sAdhvI jI onA pratApa jaina strI samAja saMyamI, tapasvI, kriyA kAMDI maryAdAzIla ane dhArmika abhyAsamAM jeTalo Agala vaghelo dekhAya che, tenA ijAramA aMze paNa sAdhu samAja thI puruSa varga dhArmika bAbatoM mAM agala vadhelo dekhAya che, ? padavI dharona kharacAne pahoMcI balavA asamartha evA nAnA gAmaDAMo mAM dhArmika zraddhA TakAvanAra tathA sadupadeza ApanAra sAdhvIjIo e ja che, pUjya AcAryo tathA muni puMgavo, pAMca daza thI laI cAlIsa pacAsa ThANA ekaja sthaLe moThA moThA saheromAM sAtha rahe che, teo mA~ vyAkhyAnakArato ekaja hoya che, te sivAyanA munirAjo zAM samAjopayogI kAryo kareche? puruSoM ne bAlakoM ne bhagAtravAnI keTalI takalIpha le che taduparAMta eka bIjA ne bhaNAvI zake tevA munivaryo hAvAchatAM sAthenA munione kema bhaNAvatA nathI ane moThA pagAre paMDito ne zA mATe roke che ? varajIvanadAsa bhAI ne sAdhuo jeTale aMze samAjane upayogI jaNAyA che te dhI aneka gaNo badalo te aneka rItiye samAja pAse thI le che jema ke sAdhuo padhAre tyAre moTuM moTuM sAmaiyuM karAvanuM, padavI pradAna bakhate hajAroM nANA kharacAvavAM, nAma kAyama karavA lAkhonI rakama uDAvarAvatrI, vagere, A vicAratAM jaNAze ke sAdhvIzro no AvA prakArano bojho samAja upara nathIja, tema chatAM tenI upayogitA ane sevA samAja ne ghaNI jagAya che, prabhAvika sAdhuo nee bhAI tathA bIjAo jAge che paNa prabhAvika sAdhvIjI hoya tenuM jANatA nathI, prabhAvika sAdhu kone kaddevAya e samajha joiye, mAtra vAgachaTAthI, vidvattA thI ke amuka be pAMca kAryo karavAthI nathI thaha javatuM dAlanA prabhAvika mahAtmAoMnA anya prabhAvI paNa sarvanI jANa bahAra nathI, jevAM ke potAnI mAnyatA sAcI karAvavAnI khAtara arasaparasparamAM zirasphoTana karAvayAM, anAcArIzro ne paDale ubhA raddI hasate mukhar3e zrAMkha ADA kAtakarI nabhAvye rAkhavA, ayogya varttaNUka chatAM suzIlatAno Dola rAkhavo, Aje dhAmadhUma thI sAdhu vezamAM ne kAle gRhastha veza mAM, A UparathI samajAze ke jaina zAsana nI helanA karavAmAM sAdhuo ochA bhAgIdAra na thI te mukAbale sAdhvIo ghaNIja pavitra zrane prabhAvika gaNAya, sAdhvIomAM anAcAra ke veza palaTo kacita ja banela huze, sAdhuonI jema keTalIka sAdhvImo dIkSA Ape che, vratocAraNa vidhi pUrvaka karAve che ane dhArmika kArya paNa ghaNAMja karAve che, cAlu lAlamAM kaccha prAntamAM dazeka gAmamAM sAdhuonA comAsAM hatAM, bAkInA ghaNA gAmomAM sAdhvIjIo nA hatA jyAM teo vyAkhyAna ApatAM ane bhaNAvatAM paNa sAdhvIjI bho

Page #6
( 6 ) nA upadeze thayelA sundara kAryoM chApA sudhI pahoMcI prakAzanamAM AvI zakatA nathI, kadAca koI mokalAve to patrakAro prAyaH chApatA nathI kacita chApe che to bahuta TraMkANamAM, Ama hovAthI sAdhvIjIonI pravatti thI ghaNAo ajJAta rahe e dekhItuM che, sAdhvIjIo vyAkhyAna nathI bAMcatA e bAta to tapa gacchanA sAdhvIjIo ne lakSamAM rAkhIneja varajIvanadAsa bhAI o lakhyu haze e bAta mahadaMze sAcI che, jItavijayajI nA saMghAr3A ne bAda karatAM, tapagacchanA anya sAdhvIjIo vyAkhyAna nathI ApatAM, tenuM kAraNa e ke sAdhvI zrI sUtra na baMcAya, vyAkhyAna na apAya ne puruSoM thI sAMbhalavA paNa na javAya, eTaluja nahIM puruSavarga sAdhvI o pAse thI paJcabArA paNa na le, pavI munipuMgavonI AjJA hoya che, tapagacchamAM AvI praNAlikA cAle che, tethI prabhAvazAlI sAdhvIo dovAkRtAM bahAra AvI zakatI na thI, gAmaDAomAM cAturmAsa rahI vyAkhyAna dvArA je lAbha samAja ne malavo joiye, zAsananI sevA karavI joiye te thaha zakatI nathI, phara jiyAta sAdhuo sAthe cAturmAsa karavA, par3e che, juhA caumAsA karavA ane sUtra ke vyAkhyAna na paMcAya to cAra mAsamAM karezuM / paTale jyAM sAdhu hoya tyAMcomAsuM kare, to sUtra ne vyAkhyAna sAMbhatavAnu thAya ne sAdhuomA pAtrA raMgavAnuM, oghA banAvavAnu ane kAMbalIo tathA pAThA vagere guru bhakti karyAno lahAvo levAya, mahesANA mAM 10 ThANA sAdhuo hatA, ne 40 ThANAsAdhvIo hatA, jyAre mahesANAnI mAju bAjU nA gAmomAM koI nu comAsu nahotuM, jyAM 15-20 gharonI rastI hoya be traNa ThANA sAoinA comAsuM hoya to samAja para kevalo upakAra thaI sake / mahezAlA jevA gAMmamAM jyAM bhaNAvanAra mAstarone-paMDito hoya tyAM ATalA badhA ThANAnI zI jarUra itI ? to eka mahesANAnI vAta thaI, paNa bIjA zaheromAM e thI ye vadhu che pAsenA gAmaDAo sAdhu sAdhvIo mATe talasatA hoya paNa pelA baMdhana ne kAraNe gAMmaDA vAlAoM lAbha na laI zake ne sAdhvIbho vyAkhyAna ApI na zake have e praNAlikA ne pheravavAnI jarUra che, / varajIvana bhAI sAdhvIzronA jJAnano lAbha samAja ne apAvavo hoya, dharmano pracAra karavo hoya to pahelAM ApaNA gurudevo ne vinavavA par3aze / tebho zrInI zrAjJA chUTaze to sAdhvIo saharSa zirasAvaMdya karI sarasarIte kArya karaze paNa gurUdevonI AjJA vinA potA nI maile kAMI karaze nahIM, kAraNa ema karavAM jatAM 'AjJA bahAra' nA pharamAno chUTe ne te thI vicaravAnuM paNa muzkela thaI par3e, pUjya AcAryo ke zrI saMgha nIce pramANe kare to samAja ne jarUra vadhu paDato lAbha male 1 - jyAM sAdhu comasuM rahe tyAM sAdhvIjI e na rahe vuM / 2 -- eka gAmamA 10 ThANA baghu ThANA comAsu na rahI zake, ahamadAbAda ke muMbaI jevA zahera mAM 25 ThANA zrI

Page #7
vadhu na rahI zake / 3-jyA 1.5thI25 ghara hoyatyAMbe thI traNaThANAnuM comAsu avazya karAvaM 4- ekala vihAra taddana baMda thevo joiya 5- sAdhvIjIo bratocAraNa vidhi pUrvaka karAvI zake, ApramANenI vyavasthA thAya to ghaNA gAmo mAM ghaNA bhAiyo ne lAbha mali. zake,haribhadra surie jene yAkinI maSThattarA kahI mAna jAlavela che eja sAdhvI samAja ne Aje vaMdana karatAM, emanuM vyAkhyAna sAMbhalatAM, zrIvaka samudAyatuM puruSa pradhAna pada dhavAya che ? ( jaina sAptAhika bhAvanagara se prakAzita tA. 16-12-45 aMka 47 pR0 632-3se uddhata) vizeSa pramANa saMkSepa samarAditya ke vali caritam , cAndragacchIya zrI pradyamnasUri viracita (prakAzaka AtmAnanda jaina sabhA ambAlA) saptama bhave pRSTha 91-95 anyA puryaparyanto, jaze jayajayAravaH / suravidyAdha zcake, puSpavRSTi nabhastalAt // 16 // bhUnetrA preSito vetrI, matvA bhUpaM vyajijJapat / devA'bhUtkevalajJAnaM sAdhvyAstanmuditA purI // 17 // niravadyAmimAM vidyAdharA dharaNigocarAH / surAzca stuvate deva ! sevakA devatAmiva // 18 // zrutveti mudito nantuM, prAcAlI dclaaptiH| dharmanyastamanAstasyAH, sametazca pratizrayam // 19 // yaH svacchasphaTikacchAyaH, svarNavarNavitardikaM / sphuTasaudAminIdAmazaradambudharaprabhaH // 20 // tatra somAkRtiH somA, nAma dRSTA pravartinI / yatinIbhiyutA taaraanukaaraabhistporucaa||21|| prAvRtAGgI paTenoccaiH, zubhreNazaradabhravat / manasaH sarvataH zukladhyAneneva prasarpatA // 22 // natvA bhagavatImetAM, puSpavRSTi vidhAya ca / dhUpamutkSipya cidapastato bhUpaH padornataH // 23 // niviSTo bhUtale dharmakathA ca prastutA tayA / dAnazIlatapobhAva medarUpaprakAzikA // 24 // atrAntare 'tra sastrIko, samAyAtau sasaMmadau / sArthavAha tau bandhudevasAgara nAmako // 25 // natvA bhagavatIM prAha, sAgaro nRpatiprati / kAryaH khedaH kathAccheda prabhavo deva ! na tvayA // 26 // atyadbhutamasaMbhAvyaM, dRSTaM vastu mayA vibho , vismino'jJAtatattattvaH, sthAtuM tatpArayAmina // 27 // rAzA tiditi prokte, sa prAhA''karNaya prabho, madIyapatnI hArastha, pranaSTasya vytiiyivaan||28|| bahukAlastataH saiSa, manasopi hi vismRtaH / adya bhuktottaraM yAvacitrazAlAM gto'syhm|| tAvaJcitragata kekyucchavasyonnamya ca kandharAm / vidhUya pakSau vistArya banavatatAra sH||30|| kausumbhavasanacchanna, paTalyAM ca vimucya tm| hAraMyayaunijasthAna, tathArUpaH punHsthitH||31|| vimisto'hamiha zrutvAM, jAtaM jayajayAravam / matvA kevala mutpannaM,bhagavatyA samAgataH // 32 // atyadbhutamasaMbhAvyaM satyena bhagavatyadaH / kimiti kSamApatiprokte, babhASe bhagavatyatha // 33 // saumyanAtyadbhutaM naivA'sambhAvyaM cAsti krmnnH| azubhe'tra jalavalizcandrodhvAntaM nyo'nyH||

Page #8
( 8 ) artho'rthaH suhRdvairI, paviH patati ca kSaNAt / zubhe tvatra punaH sarva, viparItamidaM bhavet // 35 zazoce kasya jIvasya, karmedRk pariNAmakRt / tathA proce mamaivedaM, karma khedaM dadau bahum // 36 // provAcA'maraseno'tha rasenodbhinna kaNTakaH / kathaM vA ? kiMnimittaM vA? tatkarmetyatha sA jagau // 37 // saMvignA ca sabhA rAjabandhudevo vratodyatau / Ucaturbhagavatyasti, jighRkSA nau jinavate // 144 // pratibandhaM kRSAthAMmA, tayetyuktA vimaumudA / dApayitvA mahAdAnAnyarcayitvA jinAvalIH // 145 // sammAnya praNayi vrAtamabhinandyapurIjanam datvA ca hariSeNasya, rAjya nijayaviyasaH // 146 // nRpati bandhu devena, pradhAnazca nijaiH saha / puruSendragaNaiH pArzve, pravrajyAM pratipannavAn // 147 // zrI samarAditya kevalI rAsa, zrI padma vijayajI kRta prakAzaka bhImasI mANeka bambaI. pRSTha298-9, 308 eka dina jaya jaya rava thayo, kusuma vRSTi suvizAla re // 11 // iMNi. / / surasiddha vidyAdhara thakI, vyApI ra AkAza re || rAya pUche nijapuruSaneM, kahopa kizo prakAza re // iMNi / 12 // khabara karI pratihAra te, bhAMkhe tAsa nidAna re / iMNa nayarImAM pAmIyAM, sAdhavI kevala jJAna re || iMNi | 13 || jANe lokA lokanA, traNa kAlanA bhAva re // sura vidyAdhara bahu dhUroM, sAMbhalI narapati tAvare // iMNi // 14 // harakhI cAlyo vAMdavA, Avyo upAzraya dvAra re| toraNa thaMbhane pUtalI, jyUM vidyut jAtakAra re || iMNi. / 15 / / kihAMyaka sphATika vidumakI hAM, kihAMyaka cAmara zveta re // dhvaja zira upara pharakato, kanaka kiMkiNI samaveta re // iMgi | 16 | bahu sAhuNiye parivarayAM, tima zrAvikA samudAya re / zrIsama rUpeM zobhatAM, guruNI tihAM dekhAya re // iMNi | 17 || bhavasAgara tariyAM jike, guNa maNi rayaNa bhaMDAra re / zazisama vayaNa zobhA malI, nAzita tama aMdhakAra re || iMNi / 18 // zvetAMbaradhI sAhUNI, stavatA bhUpati tAma re / kusuma barasI kare dhUpane, kare paMcAMga praNAma re // iMNi / 16 // beTho dharma zravaNa bhaNi, dharma kathA kahe jAma re / avyA doya tiro same, sAratha vAha suta tAma re || iMNi / 20 // baMdhudeva sAgara nAmeM leI nija nija nAra re| paramaguru praNamI karI, sAhuNI praName sAra re | iNnni| 21 // sAta me khaMDe DhALa e, pahelI pApanivAra re| padma vijaya kahe sAMbhalo, suNatAM jaya jayakAra re // iMNi / 22 // dohA - Shree Sudharmaswami Gyanbhandar-Umara, Surat G sAgara kahe nRpa sAMbhalo, mata kara jo mana kheda / adbhuta eka dIThu ameM, sAMbhata jo tasa bheda // 1 // sAMbhalatAM vismaya thaze, rahi na zakuM huM rAjya, vismaya prerayo vIsamI, artha na jANu zrAja // 2 // pUcheM e bhagavatI pratyeM, ThAvo nRpa kahe ThIka; / asaMbhAvya adbhuta kizu, te bhAMkho tahakIka // 3 // sAgara kahe mujha sahacarI, hAtha khoyo hAra / atIta kAla koi upareM www.umaragyanbhandar.com

Page #9
(&) vIo iMsa vAra // 4 // zrAja bhojana karI Aviyo, citrazAlI citrakAra / eka thayuM acarija ihAM bhAMkhuM te adhikAra // 5 // // DhAla bIjI // || araja araja suNoMneM ruDA rAjIyA hojI // edezI // have have mora eka citramAM hojI, leve uMco re zvAsa / kSaNamAM kSaNamAM koTa halA vato hojI, kIdho picchA vilAsa // eha // 1 // pAMkha pAMkha khakherI utarayo hojI, rAtA vastra mahAra | mUka mUki gayo nija sthAnakeM hojI, huno citra prakAra // raha. / 2 // dekhI dekhI vismaya upano hojI, kaho ezuM kahevAya / ehave pahave jaya jaya rava thayo hojI, kusuma vRSThi thAya // 0 // 3 // suravara suravara vidyAdhara milyA hojI, sAMbhalI lokanI vANi / pAmyAM pAyAM kevala sAhuNI hojI, Agyo hu~ iNa ThAMNa // eka0|4 || bole bole narapati sAMbhalo hojI, sAMdhu avarija eha / ehavuM ehavuM saMbhavIyeM nahIM hojI, pUche bhagavatI neha // e60 | 5|| bhAMkhe bhAMkhe tava teha sAdhavI hojI, pahamAM acarija kAMya / kara meM kara meM zuM navi saMbhave hojI niyamA saphalAM te thAya // eha0 | 6 // jehavAM jehavAM zubhAzubha bAMdhizrA hojI, tehaveM udaye re thAya / azubha azubha jala agani hoye hojI, nyAya te thAya anyAya | eha* // 7 // caMda caMda timira hetu hoya hojI, gharamAM thI marI jAya / artha artha anartha mitra verIo hojI, nabhathI agani varasAya // e6 // 8 // zubhathI zubhathI viSa amRta hoya hojI, durjana sajana hoya apajaza apajaza te jaza nIpajeM hojI, na haNe yuddhamAM koya // eha0 // 6 // Name pAme zracitI saMpadA hojI, suNI bole nara nAha kohanA kohanA karmanI pariNatI hojI, bole sAhuNI eha // eha. // 10 // mAharA mAharA karmanI pariNatI hojI, bole tAma bhUpAla | kimate kimate zuM nimitta kaho hojI, sAhuNI bhAMkhe rasAla // 60 // 11 // || DhAla pAMcamI // mukha mIThA virasA parche re lo, dharma thakI / sahu agha garchu re lo| bUjhI sabhA taba bhUpati re lo; baMdhudeva kahe zubhamatI re lo // 23 // dharama ameM aMgIkarUM re lo, tuma ANA ameM ziradharuM relo / jima sukha devANupriyA re lo, vilaMba na kIjeM e kriyA re lo // 24 // ThAI mahotsava kare re lo, dAna deIneM uddhare re lo / harisena ne rAjyeM Thabi re lo, dIkSA lIye jyU suragavI re lo // 25 // puruSa candra sUrine karne re lo, / sArthe pradhAna ne parijaneM re lo pAMcI DhAla padme kahIM re lo, sAta me khaMDe pa sahI re lo // 26 // upara ke donoM pAThoM meM sarvAMgasundarI nAmA sAdhvIjI ko kevalajJAna utpanna huA taba AkAza se puSpoM kI varSA huI, devatA, vidyAdhara Adi kevalI sAdhvI kI sevA meM Aye, rAjA bhI bandanA karane ko AyA, sarvo ne unakI stuti kI, upAzraya ko deva vimAna jaisA

Page #10
suzomita kiyA, sabane paMcAMga namaskAra kiyA, aura dharmadezanA sunane ko baiThe, taba kevalI sAdhvIne 'svarNavarNa vitardikaH' arthAt-kanaka ke varNa jaisI dedIpyamAna vedikA ke Upara uJcAsana para baiTha kara dAna zIla tapa bhAva rUpa cAra prakAra ke dharma kA svarUpa vAlI vistAra se dharmadezanA dI, tathA apane hI pUrvakRta karmoM kI vicitratA batalAyI. zubhAzubha karmoM kA phala aura saMsAra kI bhasAratA dikhalAyI, jisako sunakara rAjA Adi sabhA ko pratibodha huA, usake bAda rAjA ne apane rAja kumAra ko rAjyAsana para baiThAkara aThAI mahotsava pUrvaka maMtrI Adi ke sAtha zrAcArya mahArAja ke pAsa meM dIkSA grahaNa kI / ___ zrI haribhadra sUrijI mahArAja kA banAyA huA 'prAkRta samarAditya kevalI caritra' jo ki "samarAica kahA" nAma se prasiddha hai| prAcIna aura sarva mAnya hai usameM uparokta adhikAra AyA hai, isake anusAra saMkSipta samarAditya caritra"tathA"rAsa" banAyA hai usameM sAdhvI ko kevala jJAna utpanna hone para devatAoM ne mahotsava kiyA, deva vidyAdhara rAjA Adi manuSyoM kI parSadA milI, sAdhvo ko saba ne paMcAMga namaskAra kiyA, dezanA suna kara rAjAdi ne pratibodha pAkara dIkSA lene kA khulAsA likhA hai| isI prakAra anya sAmAnya sAdhviyoM ke viSaya meM bhI puruSoM kI sabhA meM dharmopadeza dene kA adhikAra jaina zAstra rUpI samudra meM pAThakoM ko aneka jagaha dekhane ko mila skegaa| yaha grantha pUrA par3hane kA prayatna kreN| ___ jaba sAdhvI ke pAsa dharma dezanA sunane ko devatA aura rAjAdi bar3e puruSa Ate haiM taya vinaya dharma kI maryAdA rakhane ke liye aura zrotAoM ko acchI taraha pratibodha hone ke liye sAdhvI ko baiThane kA uccAsana honA Avazyaka hojAtA hai| ataH sAdhvI ko pATa para baiTha kara dezanA dene meM zaMkA lAne vAloM ko yaha bAta dIrgha dRSTile gaMbhIratA pUrvaka vicAra karane yogya hai| aura devatAoM ke sAtha devI, vidyAdharoM ke sAtha vidyAdharI, rAjA Adi manuSyoM ke sAtha rANI prAdi striyoM dhArmika dezanA ke avasara meM guru vaMdanArtha svabhAvika sAtha meM jAtI haiM, yaha prasiddha bAta hai| tathA dezanA kI sabhA meM laukika vyavahAra aura dhArmika maryAdA kA pUrA viveka rakhA jAtA hai, ataH sabhA meM puruSoM ko Age baiThanA aura striyoM ko pIche baiThanA svabhAvika hI siddha hai| uparokta zAstrIya pramANa bhI yahI bAta siddha karate haiN| kaI mahAzaya sAdhvI ke vyAkhyAna meM striyoM ko Age aura puruSoM ko pIche baiThAne kI bAta karate haiM unhoMkA samAdhAna Upara ke lekha se svayaM ho jAtA hai| nivedakaH sUri ziSya muni-vinaya sAgara

Page #11
( 11 ) * prastAvanA * bhAratIya saMskRta ke nirmANa aura vikAsa meM jaina zramaNa zramaNiyoM kA sahayoga amUlya hai / bhArata ke prAcIna sAMskRtika itihAsa para dRSTipAta karane se spaSTa vidita hotA hai ki isa varga ne Atma kalyANa ke sAtha sAMskRtika sAhitya nirmANa karane kI bahumUlya sahAyatA pradAna kara bhArata ko gauravanvita kiyA hai / isa prakAra kA sAMskRtika sAhitya prAcIna saMskRti kA poSaka hI nahIM apitu navIna saMskRti kA patha pradarzaka bhI hai| saca kahA jAya to pratyeka deza ke rASTra nimmA se aise tyAgiyoM kI hI paramAvazyakatA hai| jahAM para tyAga aura vidvattA kA samanvaya ho vahAM para to pUchanA hI kyA ? jaina samAja ke kucha samajhadAra muniyoM ne AvAja uThAI hai ki jaina sAdhviyoM ko sabhA meM vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA adhikAra nahIM hai, kyoMki isameM muniyoM kA anAdara hotA hai / merI alpa buddhi ke anusAra maiM kaha sakUMgA ki ve loga prAcIna sAhitya ke talasparzI adhyayana aura vartamAna zikSA pravAlikA ke saubhAgya se saMbhavataH vaMcita haiM / prAcIna jainAgamoM meM etadviSayaka jo mahatva pUrNa ullekha Aye haiM una sabhI ullekhoM kA prastuta grantha ke lekhaka ne baDhI yogyatA va saphalatA ke sAtha varNana kiyA hai, jo lekhaka ke prakAMDa Agamika jJAna kA dyotaka hai, isake atirikta yaha bAta vyavahArika jJAna se bhI jAnI jA sakatI haiM ki prAcIna kAla meM aisI aneka sAdhviyAM huI haiM jinameM se bahutoM ne bar3e bar3e muniyoM ko saMyama se vicalita hote bacAyA hai, saMyama meM punaH sthira kiye, jaina dharma ke caubIsa tIrtha karoM meM strI tIrthakara bhI thIM / unhoMne jo upadeza rAjakumAroM ko pratibodhArtha diyA thA vaha kitanA mahatvapUrNa hai ( jJAtA dharma kathA ) isakA kitanA sundara asara huA / bAhubala jI jaise abhimAnI ko unakI bahana brAhmI sundarI jaisI sAdhvI ne pighalA diyA aura garva chur3A diyA / rAjImati jinakA zubhAbhidhAna prAtaH uThate hI gaurava ke sAtha liyA jAtA hai, unhoMne ratha nemiko saMyama se vicalita hote rokA thA, jaisA ki uttarAdhyanAdi sUtroM se phalita hotA hai| atirikta aneka aise udAharaNa diye jA sakate haiM jinase mAlUma hotA ki muni jIvana kI rakSA ke ina sAdhviyoM ne AtmoM upadezoM se kitanA abhUtapUrva kArya kiyA / madhya kAlIna prAcIna hasta likhita sAhitya dekhane kA saubhAgya prApta huA hai usameM maiM dAve ke sAtha kaha sakatA hUM ki aneka aise grantha mile haiM jinakI lekhikA sAdhviyAM thiiN| sau se Upara prazastiyeM maine ekatrita kI haiN| Aja kA yuga pragatikA hai, khoja kA hai, pratyeka dharma rASTra samAja apane apane utthAna ke liye zata prayatna karate haiN| para aisI sthiti meM jaina samAja ke eka mahatva pUrNa aMga kI apekSA kaise kI jA sakatI hai, muni loga to dharma pracAra karate hI haiM para jahAM unakA pahuMcanA nahIM hotA aura bahAM para yadi sAdhvIaiM Atma vANI se mumukSuoM ko upadeza dekara unakI jaina dharma viSayamika tRSNA kI tRpti kareM to kyA burA hai ? apitu eka mahatva ke kArya kI pUrtI hotI hai, yadi ina sAdhviyoM kI zikSA kI aura yadi samAja vizeSa

Page #12
(12) dhyAna de to nissandeha jaina dharma bahuta jaldI pleTaphArma para A sakatA hai, para sAdhviyoM ko jaina muni kyA samajhate haiM yaha to prastutaH grantha kA pariziSTa hI btaayegaa| Aja ke samaya meM aise kSudra vitaMDAvAda meM samaya vyatIta na kara kucha Thosa kArya karane kI AvazyakatA hai| ___ pUjya guru mahArAja zrI upAdhyAya 1008 zrI sukhasAgarajI mahArAja ke sAtha madhya prAMta barAra khAna deza meM vicaraNa karane ko avasara milA hai| vahAM para aise nagaroM kI kamI nahIM jahAM para vizAla jainoM kA nivAsa hote haye bhI unhoMne jaina muni ke darzana nahIM kiye haiN| bhArata meM aise aneka nagara aura prAntoM meM bhI mila sakate haiM / itanA vizAla muni samudAya ke rahate hue yadi ve loga jaina dharma kA jJAna prApta nahIM kara rahe haiM to yaha doSa maniyoM kA hI hai| aise sthAnoM meM sAdhvIaiM calI jAya to unako pratibodhanArtha vyAkhyAnAdi kI AvazyakatA rahatI hai , vahAM para yadi aisA na kareM to jaina dharma kI prabhAvanA kaise hogI aura ve loga jaina dharma ko kaise jaanegeN| Aja jaina samAja meM 2500 se bhI adhika sAdhvI samudAya hai jisameM kaI ucca zreNi kI viduSI vyakhyAna dAtR bhI avazya haiM / yadi inake liye aura bhI zikSA kA samucita prabaMdha kiyA jAya to nissandeha ve jaina dharma ke pracAra ke liye bahuta kucha kara sakatI haiM aura eka bar3e abhAva kI pUrti bhI kara sakatI haiN| sAmAjika sudhAra meM mahilAoM ke sahayoga kI AvazyakatA hai, aura yaha kArya sAdhvIaiM saphalatA pUrvaka kara sakatI haiN| Aja ke parivartana zIla yuga meM sAdhvI kI zakti ko dabAnA anucita hogaa| isameM jaina dharma kA hI nukasAna hai| jaina sAhitya meM kaI grantha aise haiM jo sAdhvioM kI preNaNA se nirmANa kiye gaye haiN| prAcIna samaya meM sAvitraoM kI zikSA kA jo prabandha thA, Aja kucha bhI nahIM hai / zrAja taka yaha prazna banA huA thA hI ki sAdhvI jAhira sabhA meM vyAkhyAna bAMce yA nahIM ? para AcArya mahArAja ne isa prazna ko jaina sAhitya ke mUla bhUta Agama aura prakIrNaka sAhitya granthoM kI sAkSI se bahuta acchI prakAra nyAya diyA hai yadyapi lekhana zailI kI apekSA se samarthana zaili atyanta upayukta hai| prAnte meM jaina samAja ke karNadhAra muniyoM se prArthanA karUMgA ki ki ve isa pustaka ko avazya par3heM aura apanA matabheda yadi ho to ( yadyapi aise pavitra kArya ke liye honA to nahIM cAhiye ) sabhya bhASA meM vyakta kareM sAtha hI sAtha aise praznoM ko chor3a kara jaina dharmonati ke liye sAdhviyoM ko ucita zikSA deN| yaha grantha apane DhaMga se atyanta mahatvapUrNa hai, spaSTa kahA jAya to prAcArya mahArAja ne eka bar3e abhAva kI pUrti kIhai jisakI jaina samAja pratIkSA karatA thaa| lekhakamuni-kAMtisAgara tAH 26-10.1845- rAyapura

Page #13
* zrI vItarAgAya namaH * sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNaya 1-jaina zAsana meM jisa taraha se tIrthakara bhagavAna ko aura anya sAmAnya sAdhuoM ko dharmopadeza dene kA adhikAra hai, usahI prakAra strI tIrthakarI aura anya sAmAnya sAdhviyoM ko bhI bhavya jIvoM ke hita ke liye dharmopadeza dene kA samAna adhikAra hai| isaliye pratyeka buddhoM se pratizedha pAye huye jitane siddha hote haiM usase kahIM adhika sAdhviyoM se pratibodha pAye huye puruSa saMkhyAta guNe adhika siddha hote haiM, isa viSaya kA vivaraNa nandIsUtra kI TIkAdi sarva mAnya prAcIna zAstroM meM hai| kharataragaccha tapagaccha zrAdi sarva gacchoM ke pUrvAcAryoM ko bhI yaha bAta mAnya hai, kintu vartamAna kAlameM jJAnasundarajI ( ghevara munijI) Adi kaI mahAnubhAva sAdhviyoM ko strI-puruSoM kI sabhA meM dharmopadeza dene kA niSedha karate haiM, parantu prAcIna kisI bhI zAstra kA pramANa nahIM batalAte haiN| kevala apanI mAna pratiSThA bar3hAne ke lie aura sAdhvI samAja ko apane nIce dabAye rakhane ke lie puruSa pradhAna dharma kA bahAnA lekara vyAkhyAna bAMcane vAlI sAdhvI aura sunane vAle zrAvaka samudAya para aneka prakAra ke AkSepa karate haiM aura vyartha kuyuktiyoM se aprAsaMgika bAta banAkara jaina samAja meM mithyA bhrama phailAte haiM isa liye Aja hama zAstrIya pramANAnusAra apane niSpakSa dRSTi se vicAra pragaTa karate haiM, jise pAThaka gaNa guNAnugagI hokara ise saMpUrNa par3hakara satya kA grahaNa kreN| 2-jaina zvetAmbara samAja meM abhI prAyaH sAta sau sAdhu aura do hajAra lagabhaga sAdhviyoM kA samudAya hogaa| kintu sAdhu samudAya meM prabhAva zAlI vyAkhyAna bAMcane yogya sau sAdhu nikalane bhI kaThina pratIta hote haiM aura mAravAr3a dakSiNa mAlavA Adi prAntoM meM vyAkhyAna yogya prabhAvika sAdhuoM kA vihAra mI kama hotA hai| jisase prati dina zvetAmbara jaina samAja kA dhArmika hrAsa ho rahA hai| aisI dazA meM viduSI sAdhviyAM grAma nagaroM meM vihAra karatI huI aura varSA kAla meM (caumAsA meM ) ThaharatI huI, zrAvakazrAvikAoM ke samudAya meM dharmopadeza dvArA aneka bhavya jIvo ko dharma mArga meM pravRti karAtI huI tathA vrata paJcakkhANAdi dharma kAryoM se samAja kA hita karatI huI zAsana kI sevA kareM to kitanA bar3A mahAn lAbha ho sakatA hai, isa prakAra ke dhArmika kAryoM meM bAdhA pahu~cA kara samAja aura dharma ko hAnI pahu~cAne ke liye sAdhviyoM ko vyAkhyAna vAMcane kA niSedha karanA ucita nahIM haiN|

Page #14
sAvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH 3-jaina zAsana meM anAdi kAla se jinamUrti ko zAkSAta hI jinezvara bhagavAna ke tulya mAna kara vaMdana pUjana karane kA akhaMDa pravAha calA AtA hai, vartamAna samaya meM jaina zvetAmbara samAja ke sabhI gacchoM meM tathA digambara samAja meM bhI yahI mAnyatA calI A rahI hai| tisapara mI abhI kucha kAla se sthAnakavAsI sAdhuoM ne jinamUrti kA vaMdana pUjana karane kA niSedha karake prapaMca phailA diyA hai tathA sthAnakavAsI sAdhviyAM gAMva gAMva phira kara zrAvaka-zrAvikAoM kI samudAya meM vyAkhyAna bAMcakara aneka prakAra kI kuyuktiyoM dvArA bhole jIvoM ko bhrAnti meM DAlakara hajAro manuSyoM ko muMha bAMdhane vAle apane bhakta banAliye haiM tathA bhagavAna kI bhakti ke virodha meM khaDe kara diye haiN| jisase jaina zvetAmbara samAja ko bar3I hAnI pahuMcI hai, aisI avasthA meM apanA sAdhvI samudAya zAsana hita kI buddhi se gAMva gAMva meM vihAra karake vahAM ke logoM ko dharmopadeza dvArA unake mithyAtva kA nivAraNa karake sanmArga meM lAtI raheM aura, bhagavAna kI pUjA bhakti ke anurAgI banAtI raheM isa prakAra mAravAr3a, mAlavA Adi pradezoM meM par3hI likhI viduSI sAdhviyoM ke vyAkhyAna se bar3e bar3e lAbha hue hai| vaise lAbha sAmAnya sAdhuoM ke vyAkhyAna se hone kaThina hai| aise pratyakSa lAbha ke kAraNa kA vicAra kiye binA apane haThAgraha kI bAta pakar3a kara strI-puruSoM ke samudAya meM sAdhvI ko vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA niSedha karane vAle mahAzaya jaina samudAya ko bar3I hAni pahu~cAne kA kArya karate haiM aura aneka bhavyajIvoM ke dharma kArya meM antarAya DAlate haiN| aba hama yahAM para zAstroM ke pramANa batalAte haiN| 4-bhAvanagara AtmAnanda jaina sabhA kI / (pha se niyukti laghu bhASyavRtti sahita chapA huA-"bRhat kalpasUtra" ke caturtha bhAga meM pRSTha 1233 meM aisA pATha hai no kappati niggaMthANa vA niggaMdhINa vA aMtaragihaMsi jAva caugAhaM vA paMcagAhaM vA Aikkhittae vA vibhAvittae vA kihittae vA paveittae vA na'nnattha egaNAeNa vA ega vAgaraNeNa vA ega gAhAe vA ega siloeNa vA seviya ThiccA no cevaNaM AThicA / / 20 // asya sambandhamAhaaippasatto khalu esa attho, jaM rogimAdIka NatA aNuNNA // aNNo vi mA bhikkhagato karijA, gAhovadesAdi atotu muttaM // 4566 //

Page #15
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH atiprasaktaH khalveSo'rthaH yadanantarasUtre rogiprabhRtInAmantaragRhe sthAnAdInAmanujJA kRtA / evaM hi tatra sthAnAdipadAni kurvan / kazcid dharmakathAmapi kurvIta, tatazcAtiprasaGgo bhavati / ato'nyo'pi bhaikSagato mA gAyopadezAdikaM kArSIditIdaM sUtramArabhyate // 4566 // anena sambandhenAyAtasyAsya vyAkhyA-no kalpate nirgranthAnAM vA nirganthInAM vA antaragRhe yAvat caturgAthaM vA paJcagAthaM vA AkhyAtuM vA vibhAvayituM vA kIrtayituM vA pravedayituM vAM / etadevApavadannAha-"na'nnatha" ityAdi "na kalpate" iti yo'yaM niSedhaH sa ekajJAtAdvA ekavyAkaraNAdvA ekagAthAyA vA ekazlokAdvA anyatra mantavyaH sUtre ca paMcamyAH sthAne tRtIyAnirdezaH prAkRtatvAt / tadapi ca ekajJAtAdi vyAkhyAnaM sthitvA karttavyam / naiva 'asthitvA' bhikSAM paryaTatopaviSTena vA iti suutraarthH|| Upara ke pATha kA bhAvArtha isa prakAra hai-vihAra karake Aye hue sAdhu-sAdhvI dUsare upAzraya ke abhAva meM athavA rogAdi kAraNa se kisI antaragRha meM, yAnI-gRhasthoM ke gharoM ke bIca meM Thahare hoM athavA gocarI Adi ke nimitta gaye hoN| taba una se koI gRhastha dharma kA svarUpa pUche tathA anya kisI kAraNa vaza vahAM para unheM dharma kathA kahanI paDe vA dharmopadeza denA paDe to sAdhuoM ko athavA sAdhviyoM ko yAvat cAra pAMca gAthAoM kA artha karake AkhyAna karanA, vibhAvana karanA, kIrtana karanA aura pravedana karanA nahIM kalpatA hai| kintu choTAsA eka dRSTAnta dekara, eka prazna kA uttara dekara eka gAthA kA vA eka zloka kA artha kaha kara saMkSepa meM dharmopadeza kahanA kalpatA hai| vaha bhI khaDe khaDe kahanA kalpatA hai| jisa para mI gRhasthoM ke gharoM meM baiTha kara vistAra se dharmopadeza dene vAle ko aneka doSoM kA prasaMga batAyA hai / isa viSaya meM laghu bhASya kA gAthAoM kA vivaraNa karate huye TIkAkAra mahArAja ne bahuta khulAsA likhA hai| chapA huA bRhatkalpa sUtra bhAga cauthA pRSTha 1234 se 1239 taka 5 ThakagaNa dekha sakate haiN| 5-aura bhI chape huye pRSTha 1239 meM isa viSaya kA dUsarA pATha isa prakAra hai| no kappati miggaMthANa vA niggaMthINa vA aMtaragihaMsi imAI paMca mahavvayAI sabhAvaNAI Aikkhittae vA vibhAvittae vA kihittae vA

Page #16
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH paveyattae vA, na'nnattha eganAeNa vA jAva siloeNa vA, se viya ThiccA no ceva NaM aThiccA // 21 // ___ asya vyAkhyA prAksUtravad drssttvyaa| na varaM "imAni" svayamanubhUyamAnAni paJcamahAvratAni "sabhAvanAni " prativrataM bhAvanApaJcakayuktAnyAkhyAtuM vA vibhAvAyatuM vA kIrtayituM vA pravedayituM vA na kalpante / AkhyAna nAma sAdhUnAM paJcamahAvratAni paJcaviMzatibhAvanAyuktAni SaTkAyarakSaNasArANi bhavanti / vibhAvanaM tu-prANAtipAtAd viramaNaM yAvat parigrahAd viramaNamiti / bhAvanAstu-"iriyAsapie sayAjae " (Ava0 prati0 saMgra0 patra 658-2 ityAdi) gAthoktasvarUpAH / SaTakAyAstu pRthivyAdayaH / kIrtanaM nAma-yA prathamatratarUpA ahiMsA sA bhagavatI sadevamanujA'surasya lokasya pUjyA dvIpaH trANaM zaraNaM gatiH pratiSThetyAdi, evaM sarveSAmapi praznavyAkaraNaGgoktAn- (saMvarAdhyayanAni 5 taH 10) guNAn kIrtayati / pravedanaM tu mahAvratAnupAlanAt svargo'pavargo vA prApyata iti sUtrArthaH // artha-isakA artha bhI isa hI prakAra hai ki-sAdhu sAdhviyoM ko gRhAntara meM paccIsa bhAvanA sahita pAMca vratoMkA vistAra pUrvaka varNana karanA-pAkhyAna-vibhAvana kIrtana aura pravedana karanA nahIM kalpatA hai| parantu pahile ke pATha meM spaSTa rUpa se batAyA hai ki eka dRSTAnta yAvat eka zloka kA artha khar3e khar3e saMkSepa meM kddn| kalpatA hai| kintu baiTha kara nahIM kalpatA hai / 1-sAdhu ke pAMca mahAvratoM kI paccIsa bhAvanAoM kA svarUpa, chaH kAya jIvoM kI rakSA kA svarUpa varNana karanA so AkhyAna kahA jAtA hai 2-prANAtipAta se viramaNa yAvata parigraha se viramaNa tyAga karane kA, iriyAsamiti Adi kA yatna karane kA aura pRthvIkAya Adi trasa sthAvara kI rakSA karane kA upadeza denA vibhAvana kahA jAtA hai| prathama mahAvrata ahiMsA bhagavatI deva, manuSya, asura Adi tamAma loka kI pUjyanIyA hai| tathA dvIpa samAna zaraNa dene vAlI rakSaNa karane vAlI hai| aura uttama gati dene vAlI hai| ahiMsA meM hI sarva dharma pratiSThita haiM sarva dharmoM meM ahiMsA hI mUla rUpa se vyApaka hai| evaM prazna vyAkaraNa sUtra ke pAMca se daza adhyayana taka saMghara adhyayana Adi se guNa varNana karanA ahiMsA kI mahimA batalAnA ye kIrtana kahalAtA hai|

Page #17
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH 4-mahAvatoM ke zuddha pAlana karane se devaloka athavA mukti kI prApti hotI hai ityAdi varNana karanA pravedana kahalAtA hai| isameM AkhyAna 1, vibhAvana 2, kIrtana 3, pravedana 4 ina cAroM kA bhAvArtha ekasA hI hai| 5-isa prakAra Upara ke donoM pAThoM meM sAdhu sAdhviyoM ko gRhasthoM ke gharoM meM vistAra se dharmopadeza dene kI AjJA dI nahIM apitu niSedha hai / parantu kAraNavaza saMkSepa meM dharmopadeza dene kI AzA bhI dI hai| isase apane Thaharane ke upAzraya, dharmazAlA Adi meM vistAra se dharmopadeza dene kI AjJA ho hI cukI hai| ___isa sUtra pATha meM dharmopadeza dene ke liye sAdhu aura sAdhvI donoM ko samAna rUpa se adhikArI batalAyA hai| isaliye sAdhuoM kI taraha sAdhvI bhI dharmodeza kara sakatI haiM / jisa prakAra gRhasthoM ke gharo meM strI-puruSa donoM sAtha meM dharmadezanA suna sakate haiN| usahI prakAra upAzraya, dharmazAlA Adi meM bhI dono eka sAtha baiTha kara dharmopadeza suna sakate haiN|s meM koI prakAra kA doSa nahIM praasktaa| 6-Upara ke donoM pAThoM kA vivecana ghevaramunijI (jJAnasundarajI) apane banAye zIghrabodha nAmaka pustaka bhAga 19 vA~ ratnaprabhAkarajJAnapuSpamAlA phalodI se prakAzita (bAraha-sUtroM kA bhASAntara) meM bRhatkalpa sUtra kA sAra likhakara chape huye pRSTha 30 meM isa prakAra likhA hai| __"(22) sAdhu sAdhviyoM ko gRhastha ke ghara meM jAkara cAra pAMca gAtha (gAthA) vistAra sahita kahanA nahIM kalpe / agara kAraNa ho to saMkSepa se eka gAthA, eka prazna kA uttara, eka vAgaraNA (saMkSepArtha) kahenA, sobhI UbhA rahake kahenA parantu gRhasthoM ke ghara para baiTha ke nahIM kahanA / kAraNa munIdharma hai so niHspRhI hai| agara eka ke ghara pai dharma sunAyA jAye to dUsare ke vahAM jAnA par3egA, nahIM jAve to rAga dveSakI vRddhi hogii| vAste apane sthAna para Aye huve ko yathA samaya dharma dezanA denI hI klpai"| (23) "evaM pAMca mahAvrata paJcIsa bhAvanA saMyukta vistAra se nahIM kahanA agara kAraNa ho to pUrvavata eka gAthA vA eka vAgaraNa kahanA sobhI khar3e khdd'e|' Upara ke lekha meM sAdhu sAdhviyoM ko gRhasthoM ke gharoM meM vistAra ke sAtha dharmopadeza denA nahIM kalpatA hai, parantu kAraNa vaza saMkSepa meM upadeza denA kalpatA hai aura apane sthAna para upAzraya meM Aye huye bhavya jIvoM ko dharma upadeza denA kalpatA hai, isameM sAdhu sAdhviyoM ko dharmadezanA dene kA samAna adhikAra jJAnasundarajI khuda likhate haiN| jisa para bhI aba sAdhviyoM ko dharma dezanA dene kA niSedha karate haiM yaha unakA pratyakSa mithyA haThAgraha hai| 7-jayapura ke jaina zvetAMbara saMgha kI jaina dharmazAlA ke jJAna bhaNDAra meM samvat 1619 Asoja vadI 7 dine likhI huI evaM tapagacchIya zrI deveMdrasUrijI mahArAja viracita

Page #18
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH siddha paMcAzikAvacUrNi grantha meM prathama peja para aisA pATha hai| "buddhadvAre pratyekabuddhAnAM dazakaM ekasamayena sidhyanti / buddhayodhitAnAM puruSANAmaSTazataM / buddhabodhitAnAM strINAM viMzatiH / napuMsakAnAM dazakaM / buddhibhirkodhitAnAM strINAM viMzatiH eka samayena sidhyanti / buddhibhirbodhitAnAmeva sAmAnyataH puruSAdInAM viMzatipRthaktvaM / buddhI ca mallisvAmI prabhRtikA tIrthakarI sAmAnyasALyAdikA cA" / ___artha-buddhadvAra meM pratyeka bukha muniyoM se pratibodha pAe hue dasa jIva eka samaya meM siddha hote haiM / buddhabodhita sAdhuoM se pratibodha pAye hue 108 puruSa eka samaya meM siddha hote haiM / buddhabodhitoM se pratibodha pAI huI 20 striyAM eka samaya meM siddha hotI haiN| isI prakAra dasa napuMsaka bhI siddha pada pAte haiM / buddhibhiH-arthAt-sAdhviyoM se pratibodha pAI huI bIsa striyAM eka samaya meM siddha hotI haiM tathA sAdhviyoM se pratibodha pAye hue bIsa se adhika puruSa eka samaya meM siddha hote haiM / yahAM buddhi zabda meM malli Adi strI tIrthakarI aura anya sAmAnya sAdhviyoM se pratibodha pAye hue jIva siddha hote haiN| "zrI nandIsUtra kI TIkA jo ki Agamodaya samiti se prakAzita huI hai pRSTha 119 meM aisA pATha hai: ___ "buddhadvAre pratyekabuddhAnAM dazakaM, buddhapodhitAnAM puruSANAmaSTazataM, buddhabodhitAnAM strINAM viMzatiH, napuMsakAnAM dazakaM, buddhIbhirbodhitAnAM strINAM viMzatiH, buddhIbhirbodhitAnAmeva sAmAnyataH puruSAdInAM viMzatipRthaktvaM / uktaM ca siddhaprAmRta TIkAyAM "buddhIhi ceva SohiyANAM purisAINaM sAmaneNa bIsapuhuttaM sijjhai ti|" buddhI ca mallisvAminIprabhRtikA tIrthakarI sAmAnyasAdhvyAdikA vA veditavyA / yataH siddhaprAbhRtaTIkAyAmevAktabuddhIovi mallipamuhAo annAo ya sAmannasAhuNIpamuhAo bohNtitti|" ___ artha-nandIsUtra ke isa pATha se siddha hotA hai ki pratyeka buddhoM ke upadeza se pratibodha pAye hae eka samaya meM dasa jIva siddha hote haiM / buddhabodhitoM se upadeza pAye hue eka so ATha puruSa, bIsa triyAM aura dasa napuMsaka siddha hote haiM usa hI prakAra sAdhviyoM se pratibodha pAI huI bIsa triyAM siddha hotI hai tathA puruSa Adi bIsa se adhika siddha hote haiM / buddhi arthAt-sAdhviyoM meM zrI mallInAtha svAmI Adi strI tIrthakarI tathA anya sAmAnya sAdhviyoM kA grahaNa kiyA gayA hai| 9-siddha prAbhRta graMtha meM jo ki samvat 1977 meM AtmAnanda sabhA bhAvanagara se

Page #19
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH prakAzita huA hai pRSTha 9-10 meM aisA pATha hai " patteya sayaMbuddhA buddhe, ya bohiyA muNeyavvA / eya sayaMsaMbuddhA, buddhIhiya bohiyA doNi // 35 // dAraM "patteya" gAhA-patteyabudhdhA ekke 1 'sayaM(budhdhA) buddhehiM bohiyA, svayamAtmanA svataH parato vA buddhA | svayaMbuddhabudhdhAstairbodhitA dvitIo viyappo || 2 || evaM sayaMbudhdhA tatio // 3 // budhdhIhi viyapiyA doNNi vigappA - budhdhIhiM itthIhiM bohiyAo massitthao || 4 || budhdhIhi ya bohiyA maNussA kevalA missA vA // 5 // evaM paJcabhedA iti gAthArthaH / / 35 / / I arthaH- isa pATha meM pratyeka buddha tathA buddhabodhita aura svayaMbuddha ina tInoM kA eka eka meda batalAyA hai / aura buddhi arthAt sAdhviyoM ke upadeza se pratibodha pAye hue siddhoM ke do bheda batalAye haiM / sAdhviyoM se pratibodha pAI huI kevala manuSya striyAM aura strI-puruSa donoM sAmila mile hue mizra / isa prakAra sAdhviyoM se vizeSataH pratibodha pAye hue strI puruSa donoM prakAra ke siddha hote haiM / 10- phira bhI siddha prAbhRta kI pRSTha 13 pahalI puThI para aisA pATha hai "buddhIhiM ya bohiyA doNNi vigappA" tadAha- buddhIhiM bohiyANaM bIsA puNa hoI ekasamaeNaM / buddhIhiM bohiyANaM bIsapuhuttaM tu siddhANaM // 54 // dAraM // " buddhIhiM bohiyANaM " gAhA - buddhIhiM bohiyANaM bIsA | tathA buddhIhiM ceva bohiyANaM purisAINaM sAmaNNeNaM vIsa puhuttaM sijjhati / jao buddhIo sayaMbuddhIo mallipamuhAo aNNAo ya sAmaNNasAhuNIpamuhAo borhiti o jahavi cirantaNa TIkAkAreNa savvattha eyaM Na lihiyaM / tathA'pyavagamyata iti gAthArthaH / / 54 / / artha - buddhi arthAt sAdhviyoM ke pratibodha diye hue eka samaya meM bIsa puruSa siddha hote haiM / tathA sAdhviyoM ke pratibodha diye huye puruSa Adi zabda se puruSa aura strI donoM kA grahaNa karanA cAhiye / yaha sAmAnya se bIsa prathaktva siddha hote haiM, isa prakAra svayaM buddhi zrImallinAtha svAmI Adi strI tIrthaMkarI aura anya sAmAnya sAdhviyoM se pratibodha pAye hue siddha hote haiM / dekhiye - tapagacchIya zrI kSemakIrtisUrijI viracita " 'bRhatkalpa vRtti" tathA pUrvaghara AcArya kA banAyA huA "siddhaprAbhRta" tathA tapa gaccha ke zrI devendrasurijI mahArAja

Page #20
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH kI banAI huI "siddhapaMcAzikAvacUrNi" evaM zrImalaya girijI racita "nandI sUtra kI TIkA" Adi ke prAcIna pATha jo ki Upara likha diye gaye haiM unase spaSTa prakaTa hai ki sAdhuoM ke upadeza se pratibodha pAye hue jIva jisa prakAra siddha hote haiM, usa hI prakAra buddhi arthAtsAdhviyoM ke upadeza se pratibodha pAye puruSAdi bhI siddha hote haiM, isase sAdhviyoM ko bhI sAdhuoM kI taraha zrotAoM ke sAmane dharma dezanA dene kA adhikAra siddha hai| 11-yahAM para kaI mahAzaya aisI bhI zaMkA kara baiTheMge ki "siddha prAbhRta" Adi uparyukta pramANoM ke anusAra sAdhviyoM ko dharmopadeza denA kahA gayA hai| isase sAmAnyatayA puruSoM ke Age vyaktigata rUpa se dharmopadeza dene kA siddha ho sakatA hai| parantu strI-puruSoM kI sabhA meM vyAkhyAna rUpa meM dharmadezanA dene kA siddha nahIM ho sakatA / aisA kathana bhI anasamajha kA hI pratIta hotA hai| kyoMki dekhiye "buddhio sayaMbuddhio mallipamuhAo aNNAo ya sAmaNNa sAhuNIpamuhAo bohiMti // " siddhaprAbhUta ke isa pATha meM jaise zrI mallI tIrthakarI ke lie upadeza denA likhA hai vaise hI anya sAmAnya sAdhviyoM ke lie bhI upadeza dene kA likhA hai| isalie jisa taraha strI puruSa Adi kI pariSadA meM (sabhA meM) strI tIrthakarI mallI Adi ke lie vyAkhyAna rUpa dharmadezanA denA ThaharatA hai, isahI prakAra sAmAnya sAdhviyoM ke lie bhI strI-puruSoM Adi kI sabhA meM vyAkhyAna rUpa meM dharmadezanA dene kA siddha hotA hai| isalie sAmAnya dharmopadeza kaha kara strI-puruSoM Adi kI sabhA meM vyAkhyAna dene kA niSedha nahIM kara sakate / mallInAtha svAmI Adi strI tIrthakarI ke samAna hI sAmAnya sAdhviyoM ke lie dharmopadeza dene kA samAna adhikAra batalAyA hai isa bAta ko samajhane vAle sAmAnya dezanA ke bahAne sAdhviyoM ke lie sabhA meM vyAkhyAna dene kA kabhI niSedha nahIM kara skte| aba sAdhviyoM ke vyAkhyAna ke lie aura bhI pramANa prastuta karate haiN| 12-isa hI taraha "zrI senaprazna" grantha jo ki zrI devacandra lAlabhAI jaina pustakoddhAra saMsthA kI tarapha se prakAzita huA hai usake pRSTha 74 kI pahilI puTThI meM aisA pATha hai| - " tathA- nandIvRttau 53 patre 'khittogAhANa' gAthAvicAre buddhadvAre sarvastokAH svayambuddhamiddhAstebhyo'pi pratyekabuddhasiddhAH saMkhyeyaguNAstebhyo'pi buddhibodhitasiddhAH saMkhyeyaguNAstatkathaM ? yato buddhibodhitAnAM kevala zrAddhasabhAgre vyAkhyAnasya dazavaikAlikavurayAdau nissedhdrshnaaditi|

Page #21
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH praznottaraM - buddhizabdena tIrthakaryaH sAmAnya sAdhvyaJcocyante, tatra tIrthakarINAmupadeze vicAra eva nAsti, sAmAnya sAdhvInAM tu yadyapi kevalazrAddhAnAM purastAdupadezaniSedhaH tathApi zrAddhamizritAnAM kAraNe kevalAnAM ca purastAdupadezaH sambhavatyapIti na kAvyanupapattiriti // isa pATha kA bhAvArtha aisA hai ki-buddhadvAra meM saba se kama svayambudha ( tIrthakara ) siddha hote haiN| unase pratyekabuddha nami Adi saMkhyAta guNe adhika siddha hote haiM, unase bhI buddhabodha ( guru ke upadeza se ) saMkhyAta guNe adhika siddha hote haiM / unhoMse bhI buddhi bodhita arthAt - sAdhviyoM ke upadeza se prati pAye hue saMkhyAtaguNe adhika siddha hote haiN| aba yahA~ para yaha zaMkA paidA hotI hai ki-sAdhviyoM ke upadeza se pratibodha pAye hue puruSa Adi adhika siddha hote haiM / taba sAdhviyoM ko to akele puruSoM kI sabhA meM dharmopadezakA vyAkhyAna dene kA " dazavaikAlika TIkA" meM niSedha kiyA hai / isa zaMkA kA samAdhAna zrI vijaya senasUrijI mahArAja isa prakAra karate haiM- buddhi zabda se strI tIrthakarI tathA sAmAnya sAdhvI donoM kA grahaNa hotA hai / strItIrthakarI ke upadeza kI bAbata to koI zaMkA kI bAta hI nahIM hai / parantu sAmAnya sAdhviyoM ke lie yadyapi kevala zrAvakoM kI sabhA ke sAmane upadeza denA manA hai parantu zrAvaka-zrAvikAoM kI mizra sabhA meM upadeza desakatI haiM aura kAraNa vaza akele puruSoM kI sabhA meM bhI upadeza dene kA saMbhava zabda se svIkAra kiyA hai isameM koI bhI bAdhA nahIM hai / 13- dekhiye - Upara ke pATha meM sAdhviyoM ke upadeza se adhika siddha hone kA kahA hai / sAdhviyA~ strI-puruSa donoM ko yA kAraNa vaza akele puruSoM ko bhI upadeza desakatI haiM, anAdi kAla se siddha hote Aye haiM / mahAvideha kSetroM meM vartamAna meM siddha hote haiM aura Age bhI siddha hote rahegeM / isase sAdhviyoM bhI anAdi kAla se bhavya jIvoM ko strI-puruSa Adi ko dharmopadeza detI AI haiM tathA vartamAna meM bhI dharmopadeza detI haiM aura Age bhI dharmopadeza detI raheMgI, Upara ke pATha se yaha niyama anAdi siddha hotA hai / Upara ke pATha meM sAdhviyoM ke lie sabhA meM vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA spaSTa ullekha hai isa lie vyaktigata sAmAnya upadeza dene kA kahakara sabhA meM vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA niSedha nahIM kara sakate / parantu akele zrAvakoM kI sabhA meM vyAkhyAna karanA niSedha kiyA, aura zrAvakazrAvikAoM kI sabhA meM vyAkhyAna dene kA batalAyA hai / isalie vartamAnika jo mahAzaya sAdhviyoM ko vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA niSedha karate haiM unhoMko apanI bhUla sudhArakara sAdhviyoM ke prati vyAkhyAna bAMcane kI satya bAta svIkAra karanI cAhiye / 14 - zrI kIrtivijayagaNi saMgrahIta zrI hIravijayasUrijI mahArAja kA "hIra praznottarANi" nAmaka grantha - jo ki zA0 caMdulAla jamanAdAsa chANI (gujarAta ) se prakAzita

Page #22
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH huA hai, usake pRSTha 33 meM terahavAM prazna isa prakAra hai: praznaH-sAdhvIzrAddhAnAmagre vyAkhyAnaM na karotItyakSarANi kutra granthe santIti // 13 // uttaram:--atra dazavaikAlikavRttipramukhagranthamadhye yatiH kevarazrAddhIsabhA'gre vyAkhyAnaM na karoti, rAgahetutvAdityuktamasti / etadanusAreNa sAdhvyapi kevalazrAddhasabhA'gre vyAkhyAnaM na karoti rAgahetutvAditi jJAyate / dekhiye-Upara ke pATha meM zrIhIravijayasUrijI mahArAja ko paMDita belarSigaNi ne prazna pUchA ki sAdhvI zrAvakoM kI sabhA meM vyAkhyAna na bA~ce aisA pATha kauna zAstra meM hai ? isake uttara meM sUrijI mahArAja zrAvakoM kI sabhA meM sAdhvI vyAkhyAna na vA~ce, aisA niSedhAtmaka pramANa kisI bhI grantha kA na batalA sake aura vyAkhyAna ke niSedha kI koI yukti bhI na batalAI tathA sAdhvI ke vyAkhyAna bA~cane meM koI doSa bhI na batalAyA / isa taraha kisI bhI prakAra se yukti aura zAstra pramANa se sAdhvI ke vyAkhyAna bA~cane kA niSedha nahIM kiyaa| isase "aniSiddhaM anumataM" ke nyAyAnusAra jisa viSaya kI carcA cale usa bAta kA niSedha na karane para vaha bAta mAnya hojAtI hai| isa prakAra jaba ukta sUrijI mahArAja se prazna pUchA gayA taba sUrijI mahArAja ne sAdhvI vyAkhyAna kA niSedha nahIM kiyA / isase sAbita hotA hai ki sUrijI mahArAja ko sAdhvI ke vyAkhyAna bA~cane kA siddhAnta mAnya thaa| ___ aba yahAM vicAra karanA cAhiye ki- jo mahAzaya una mahArAja ko apane gaccha ke prabhAvaka gItArtha pUjyanIya puruSa mAnate haiM, aura unakI mAnI huI bAta ko niSedha karate haiM, yaha kaisA nyAya hai| jaba aise prasiddha puruSa ne bhI sAdhvI ke vyAkhyAna kA kisI bhI grantha ke pramANAnusAra niSedha nahIM kiyA taba Adhunika mahAzaya binA kisI zAstra kA pramANa batalAye hue sirpha apanI apanI mati se niSedha karate haiM so kabhI mAnya nahIM hosktaa| aura bhI dekhiye-upara ke pATha meM sAdhu ko rAga kA hetu hone se akelI striyoM kI sabhA meM dazavaikAlika vRtti ke pramANa se vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA niSedha kiyA, isI taraha rAga kA hetu hone se sAdhvI ko bhI akele puruSoM kI sabhA meM vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA niSedha kiyaa| isase zrAvaka-zrAvikAoM kI sammilita sabhA meM sAdhu evaM sAdhvI ko vyAkhyAna bAMcane kI AjJA ho hI cukI / phira bhI jo mahAzaya sAdhvI ko zrAvaka-zrAvikAoM kI sabhA meM vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA niSedha karate haiM, unheM apanI bhUla ko sudhAranA caahie| 15-zrI hIravijayasUrijI ke saMtAnIya zrI vijayavimalagaNIjI kI banAI huI "gacchAcAra payannA kI" baDI TIkA meM jo ki- dayAvimalajI granthamAlA kI tarapha se ahamadAbAda se prakAzita huI hai usake pRSTha 138-139 para aisA pATha haiH-gAthAH --

Page #23
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH buDDANaM taruNANaM ratti ajA kahei jo dhammaM / sA gaNiNI guNasAyara! paDiNIA hoi gacchassa // 116 // vyAkhyA-" buDDANaM "-vRddhAnAM sthavirANAM-taruNAnAM-yUnAM-puruSANAM kevalAnAmakevalAnAM vA " rattiM " ti " saptamyA dvitIyA " (8-3-137) iti prAkRtasUtraNa saptamIsthAne dvitIyAvidhAnAt rAtrI yA AryA gaNinI "dhamma" ti dharmakathAM kathayati, upalakSaNatvAdivase'pi yA kavalapuruSANAM dharmakathAM kathayati, guNasAgara ! he indrabhUte ! sA gaNinA gacchasya pratyanIkA bhavatti, atra ca gaNinI grahaNena zeSamAdhvInAmapi tathA vidhAne pratyanIkatvamavaseyamiti / nanu kathaM sAdhvyaH kevala puruSANAmagre dharmakathAM na kathayanti ? ucyate-yathA sAdhavaH kevalAnAM strINAM dharmakathAM na kathayanti, tathA sAdhvyo'pi kevalAnAM puruSANAmagre dharmakathAM na kathayanti, yata uktaM zrI uttarAdhyayane: "no itthiNaM kahaM kahittA havai sa niggaMthe / taM kahamiti ? AyariyAhaniggaMthassa khalu itthANaM kahaM kahemANassa baMbhayArissa baMbhacere saMkA vA kaMkhA vA vitigicchAvA samuppajjejjA, bhedaM vA labhejjA, ummAyaM vA pAuNijjA, dIhakAliyaM vA rogAyaMkaM bhavejjA, kevAlapannatAo vA dhammAo bhaMsijjA, tamhA khalu nigaMthe no itthINaM kahaM kahejja" tti no " itthINaM" ti-no strINAM ekAkinInAM kathAM kathAyitA bhavati / yathadaM dazabrahmacaryasamAdhisthAnamadhye dvitIyaM brahmacaryasamAdhisthAnaM sAdhunAmuktam, tathA sAdhvInAmapyetat yujyate, tacca sAdhvInAM puruSANAmeva kevalAnAM kathAyA akathane bhavatIti tathA "sthAnAGge'pi" "no itthINaM kahaM kahettA havaha idaM nava brahmacaryaguptInAM madhye dvitIyaguptisUtraM, asya vRtti:-"no strINAM kevalAnAmiti gamyata / dharmadazanAdilakSaNavAkyapratibaMdharUpAmityAdi yathA ca dvitIyoM guptiM sAdhavaH pAlayanti, tathA sAdhvyo'pi pAlayanti sA ca ravInAM puruSANAmeva kavalAnAmagre kathAyA akathane bhavatItyataH procyate,

Page #24
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH na kevala puruSANAM mAdhvyo dharmakathA kathayantIti / gAyAchandaH / / 116 // arthaH-vRddha ho yA javAna ho kevala puruSoM ke sAmane dina meM athavA rAtri meM gaNinI arthAt- vRddha sAdhvI dharma kathA kahe- dharma upadeza deve to vaha sAdhvI gaccha kI pratyanIka (virodhaka) hotI haiN| yahA~ para gaNinI kahane se anya sAmAnya sAdhviyoM kA grahaNa kara lenA cAhiye / arthAt-koI bhI sAdhvI kevala akele puruSoM kI sabhA meM dharmakathA arthAt-vyAkhyAna nahIM bA~ca sakatI, parantu strI-puruSa donoM kI sabhA meM vyAkhyAna bA~ca sakatA hai| jisa prakAra sAdhu ko kevala striyoM ke sAmane dharmakathA kahane kA niSedha hai usI prakAra kevala puruSoM kI sabhA meM sAdhviyoM ko bhI dharmakathA kahane kA niSedha hai| zrI " uttarAdhyayana" sUtra ke brahmacarya samAdhisthAna adhyayana ke evaM sthAnAGga sUtra ke pATha ke pramANa se bhI yahI bAta siddha kI gaI hai ki- jo sAdhu hotA hai vaha striyoM meM dharmakathA na kare agara kare to usake brahmacarya kI hAni hotI hai| usI prakAra sAdhvI bhI puruSoM kI sabhA meM dharmakathA na kare, yadi kare to usake bhI brahmacarya kI hAni hove / saMyama dharma meM brahmacarya kI rakSA sAdhu-sAdhvI donoM ko samAna rUpa se karanA Avazyaka hai| isalie sAdhu kevala striyoM kA aura sAdhvI kevala puruSoM kA paricaya na kareM / parantu dharma-dezanA strI-puruSa donoM kI sabhA meM donoM hI de sakate haiN| 16-zrI vijayasenasUrijI kA senapraznaH- zrI hIravijayasUrijI mahArAja kA "hIraprazna" evaM vijayavimalagaNijI kI banAI huI "gacchAcAra payannA" kI TIkA ke pramANAnusAra sAdhu akelI striyoM kI sabhA meM vyAkhyAna nahIM bA~ca sakatA, usI prakAra sAdhvI bhI akele puruSoM kI sabhA meM vyAkhyAna nahIM bA~ca sakatI, parantu jisa taraha strI-puruSa donoM kI sammilita sabhA meM sAdhu vyAkhyAna bAMca sakatA hai, usI taraha se sAdhvI bhI strI-puruSa donoM kI sammilita sabhA meM vyAkhyAna bAMca sakatI hai| isase sAdhuoM kI taraha sAdhvI bhI vyAkhyAna bAMcane kI adhikAriNI hai| itane spaSTa zAstrIya pramANa milane para bhI jo mahAzaya sAdhvI vyAkhyAna kA niSedha karate haiM, ve zAstroM kI upekSA karake apanA Agraha jamAne vAle Thaharate haiN| 17 - zrI lakSmIvallabhagaNijI kRta mUla-TIkA sahita jAmanagara se prakAzita "uttarAdhyayana" sUtra ke navameM adhyayana meM "namirAja" caritra ke varNana meM sAdhvI ko vyAsyAna bAMcane kA adhikAra AyA haiM - dekhiyeH- pAThaH-- "mithilAsthA suvratA janodatena tadvigrahaM zrutvA janakSayavAraNAya tayorupazamAya ca mahattarAmanujJApya sAdhvIyutA, sudarzanapure nami sainye gatvA namimavaMdApayat / namirapi tasyA AsanaM datvA bhRmdhupaviSTaH / sAdhvyAddharma uktaH,upadezAnte coktaH-asArA raajyshriiH| du:khaM viSayasukhaM / pApakA

Page #25
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH uktaH, upadezAnte coktaM-asArA rAjyazrIH / duHkhaM viSayasukhaM / pApakA ryAnniyamAnnarakagatiH / - isa pATha kA bhAvArtha yaha hai ki-namirAjA yuddha karane ke liye gayA thaa| jaba mithilA nagarI meM ThaharI huI suvratA sAdhvI ne logoM ke mukha se yaha bAta sunI / taba vicAra kiyA ki mAna ke vaza yuddha meM aneka prANiyoM kA nAza hogaa| isalie maiM usake pAsa jAkara una logoM ko upadeza dekara yuddha kI hiMsA ke pApa se bacAU~ aura upazAMta bhAva prApta karAU~ aisA vicAra kara sAdhvI ne apanI bar3I guruNI kI AjJA lekara anya sAdhviyoM ke sAtha meM sudarzanapura meM namirAjA kI phauja meM gaI, namirAjA ne sAdhvI ko vaMdanA kI, tathA baiThane ke liye Asana diyA, namirAjA bhUmi para sAmane baiTha gyaa| taba sAdhvI ne arhanta bhagavAn ke dharma kA upadeza diyA aura upadeza ke anta meM phira kahA ki- isa saMsAra meM rAjya lakSmI asAra hai, viSayasukha duHkharUpa haiM / pApa karma karane se niyama pUrvaka naraka gati meM jIva jAtA hai, ityAdi upadeza dekara yuddha baMda karAyA aura aneka jIvoM kI rakSA kii| . 18-mahopAdhyAya zrIbhAvavijayajI gaNita uttarAdhyayana sUtra kI, vRtti meM bhI chape hue pRSTa 218 meM aisA pATha hai " tacca zrutvA janazrutyA, suvadIyA vyacintayat / / imau janakSayaM kRtvA, mAsma yo hAmogatim // 199 // tadenau bodhayAmIti, dhyAtvA''hanana / sAdhvIbhiH saMyutA sAgAtsamIpe namibhUbhujaH / / 200 // tAM praNamyAsanaM datvA, namirbhuvi niviSThavAn / AryApi dharmamAkhyAya, tamevamavadatsudhIH // 201 // rAjannasArA rAjyazrI bhogaashcaaytidaarunnaaH / gatiH pApakRtAM ca syAnnarake duHkhasaMkule // 202 // . isa pATha meM bhI yahI bAta batalAI gaI hai ki-anya sAdhyioM ke sAtha meM suvratA sAdhvI namirAjA ke pAsa meM gaI / rAjA ne vaMdanA kI aura sAdhvI ko baiThane ke liye Asana diyA, Apa bhUmi para sAmane baiTha gayA, sAdhvI ne bhI dharma kA vyAkhyAna kiyA aura yuddha na karane ke liye rAjA ko upadeza diyaa| - 19-zrI kamalasaMyamopAdhyAya viracita "sarvArthasiddhi" TIkA-sUtravRtti sahita chape hue pRSTa 194 para aisA pATha hai

Page #26
14 sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH " praNamya tAM namiddhAJjalirdattAsano'vizat / tatpuro bhuvi sApyuccaistenaM kuzaladezanAm // 126 // isa pATha meM bhI sAdhvI ke sAmane rAjA hAtha joDakara baiThA taba sAdhvI ne kuzala dezanA dI arthAt-acchI dezanA dI dharma kA vyAkhyAna diyaa| yahAM yaha bAta khulAsA hai ki Upara ke pATha meM rAjA ke Age dezanA dene kA kahA hai, parantu vahAM rAjA akelA nahIM thaa| aneka jana the| saba ke sAmane sAdhvI ne dharma dezanA kA vyAkhyAna sunAyA aura dezanA ke anta meM rAjA ko yuddha baMda kara dene kA upadeza diyA hai / 20 - isI taraha se saMvat 1929 meM vRhadgacchIya zrI nemicandra sUrijI kI banAI huI "sukhabodhA" nAmA TIkA jo ki AtmavallabhasmArakagranthamAlA se prakAzita huI hai| pRSTa 140-141 meM aisA pATha hai "logapAraMparao nisuyaM suvvyjjaae| ciMtiyaM ca mA jaNavayakvayaM kAUNa aharagaIM vaccaMtu, tA do vi gaMtRRNa uvasamAvemi / gaNiNIe aNunnAyA sAhuNisahiyA gayA sudaMsaNapuraM / diTTho ya ajAe namirAyA / dinnaM paramamAsaNaM / vaMdiUNa namI ubaviTTho dharaNIe / sAhio ajAe asesasahakArao jiniMdaNIo dhammo / dhammakahAvasANe bhaNiyaM - mahArAya ! asArA rajjasirI, vivAgadAruNaM visayasuhaM, adukkhapauresu viruddhapAvayArINaM niyameNa naraesu nivAso hava / " sabase prAcIna isa TIkA meM bhI yahI bAta batalAI gaI haiM ki- sAdhvI ne rAjA ke Age sampUrNa sukha denevAlA zrI jinendra praNIta dharma kahA arthAt dharmadezanA dI tathA dezanA ke anta meM phira rAjA ko yuddha na karane kA upadeza diyA ! isa prakAra bRhadgacchIya, kharataragacchIya, tapagacchIya Adi saba TIkAoM meM sAdhvI ke vyAkhyAna dene kA aura phira rAjA ko yuddha na karane kA alaga-alaga khulAsA batalAyA hai| 21 - agara kahA jAya ki- namirAjA suvratAsAdhvI ke saMsArI putra thA aura vaha bar3e bhAI ke sAtha yuddha karane ko gayA thA, isalie sAdhvI unako yuddha na karane ke lie samajhAne ko gaI thI, isa pramANa se hareka sAdhvI ko vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA adhikAra sAbita nahIM ho sakatA / yaha kathana bhI ucita nahIM hai kyoMki dekho - bRhatkalpa, siddhapaMcAsikAvacUrNI, nandIsUtra kI TIkA, siddhaprAbhRta Adi aneka prAcIna zAstrAnusAra aura zrI hIravijaya sUrijI Adi ke granthAnusAra sAdhvI ko vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA adhikAra siddha kara Aye haiM aura yaha eka prakAra kA prasiddha ziSTAcAra bhI hai| kisI uddezya ke lie

Page #27
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH kisI baDe sthAna meM baDe puruSoM ke pAsa jAnA hotA hai taba pahile ziSTAcAra kI acchI acchI bAteM kiye bAda meM phira jisa uddezya se gaye hoM usa viSaya kI bAteM nikAlI jAtI haiN| isahI taraha se subratA sAdhvI bhI namirAjA kI phauja meM gaI jaba rAjA ne sAcI ko bandanA karake baiThane ke lie Asana diyA aura Apa hAtha jor3a kara sAmane bhUmi para baiTha gyaa| taba sAdhvI ne pahile dharmadezanA dI aura dezanA ke anta meM yuddha na karane kA upadeza diyA isahI lie zAstrakAroM ne "upadezAnte coktaM", "AryApidharmamAkhyAya","kuzalakezanAm" aura "dhammakahAvasANe bhaNiyaM" ityAdi vAkyoM meM dharmadezanA dene kA adhikAra pahile batalAyA hai isase pragaTatayA hara eka sAdhvI ko vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA adhikAra upara meM batalAye hue zAstroM ke pramANa se siddha hai| 22-dUsarI bAta yaha hai ki- "buddhIhi ya bohiyA maNussA kevalA missA vA" "siddhaprAbhRta" kA yaha pATha Upara batalA cuke haiM, isa pATha meM sAdhviyA~ kevala akele puruSoM ko athavA strI-puruSa donoM ko dharmopadeza de sakatI haiM, tathA "zrAddhI mizritAnAM kAraNe kevalAnAm ca purassAdupadezaH" yaha "sena prazna" kA pATha bhI Upara batalA cuke haiN| isameM bhI yahI batalAyA hai ki-sAdhviyA~ strI-puruSoM kI sammilita sabhA meM aura kAraNa vasa kevala puruSoM kI sabhA meM bhI dharmadezanA de sakatI hai, yaha niyama zAstrAnusAra hai aura subatA sAdhvI ne bhI khAsa yuddha kA kAraNa upasthita hone para namirAjA ke samakSa meM puruSoM kI sabhA meM dezanA dI hai| isalie uttarAdhyayana sUtra kI TIkAoM ke pAThoM ke anusAra jo ki upara likha cuke haiM usa muAphika subratA sAdhvI kI taraha saba sAdhviyoM ko dharma dezanA dene kA adhikAra siddha hotA hai, aura isahI ke anusAra saba sAdhviyeM bhI dharmadezanA de sakatI haiM tathA "kuzaladezanAm" "AryApidharmamAkhyAya" "upadezAnte coktaM" "dhammakahAvasANe bhaNiyaM" Adi uparyukta vizeSaNa hI sAdhviyoM ke lie dharmadezanA kA adhikAra siddha karate haiM / yahA~ dezanA kahane se sabhA meM dharmopadeza kA vyAkhyAna samajhanA caahiye| 23-jisa taraha subratA sAdhvI ne apane gRhasthAvasthA ke putra ke upara anukaMpA karake yuddha kI hiMsA ke pApa se usako bacAyA aura aneka jIvoM kA upakAra kiyA, isI taraha se paMca mahAvrata dhArI saMyamI sAdhvIyoM ke bhI dharma pakSa meM zrAvaka-zrAvikAyeM putraputriyoM ke tulya haiM / unhoM ke upara sAdhviyoM upakAra buddhi se anukampA lAkara unhoM ko Azrava-kaSAya Adi ke pApa se bacAne ke lie aura dharma mArga meM vrata niyama karane kI pravRti karAne ke lie avazya hI vyAkhyAna vAMca kara sadbodha kA dharmopadeza de sakatI hai| isameM kisI prakAra aMtarAya denA yoga nahIM hai / dekhiye- zAstroM meM kahA hai ki bhagavAna kI vANI ke sadbodha kA eka bhI vacana dhAraNa karane vAle bhavya jIvoM ko mahAn lAbha hotA hai| aura sAdhviyoM vyAkhyAna vAMca kara gA~voM gA~voM meM prati varSa lAkhoM jIvoM ko bhagavAn kI

Page #28
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH vANI ke sadbodha ke vacana sunAtI hai isameM aneka jIvoM kA kalyANa hai, aise lAbha ke kAma ko samajhe pinA pakSapAta ke vaza hokara abhinivezika mithyAtva ke haThAgraha se sAdhviyoM ko vyAkhyAna vAMcane kA niSedha karane vAle baDI bhArI dharma kI aMtarAya bAMdhate haiN| - 24-zrIharibhadra sUrijI mahArAja ke banAye hue "saMbodha prakaraNa" jo ki vi0 saM0 1902. evaM san 1916 I0 meM "jaina grantha prakAzaka sabhA" ahamadAbAda se prakAzita huA hai| isake pRSTha 15 meM aisI gAthA hai- "kevala thINaM puruo vakkhANaM purisaaggao anjA / kuvaMti jatthamerA naDapeDagasaMnihA jANa // 1 // " - isa gAthA meM sApha likha diyA hai ki-sAdhu akelI striyoM kI sabhA meM aura sAdhvI kevala puruSoM kI sabhA meM vyAkhyAna bAMce to una sAdhu-sAdhviyoM kI naTa peTaka jaisI kuceSTA jAnanA cAhiye / isa gAthA meM jaba sAdhu ko akelI striyoM kI sabhA meM vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA niSedha kiyA hai taba strI-puruSa donoM kI sabhA meM vyAkhyAna bAMcane kI spaSTa AzA siddha isahI taraha se sAdhviyoM ko bhI jaba akele puruSoM kI sabhA meM vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA niroga kiyA taba strI-puruSa donoM kI sabhAmeM vyAkhyAna bAMcane kI AzA siddha ho hI cukii| zrI sAgarAnanda sUrijI (aAnanda sAgarajI) ne "subodhikA TIkA" chapavAte samaya usake prathama pRSTha meM paMkti 10-11 meM "kevalathINaM purao" Upara kI gAthA ke prathama caraNa ke ye ATha akSara chor3a kara isa prakAra pATha diyA hai-"bakkhANaM purisa purio ajA, kuvvaMti jattha merA naDapeDagasaMnihA jANa / " aisI adhUrI gAthA chapavA kara sAdhviyoM ke vyAkhyAna bAMcane mAtra kA niSedha karane ke lie artha kA anartha kara DAlA hai| yaha kArya prAtmArthiyoM kA nahIM haiN| kyoMki pUrvAcArya praNIta granthoM kA mUla pATha ur3A kara artha kA anartha kara DAlanA sabhyatA ke khilApha hai| sUtra granthoM kA eka bhI akSara yA bindu vA mAtrA ur3A denA yA badala denA ananta saMsAra kA kAraNa mAnA jAtA hai| apanI haTha kI puSTi ke lie. aisA kArya karanA ucita nahIM hai latyAnveSiyoM ko paryuSaNA parva jaise dhArmika parva ke vyAkhyAna meM aisI unmArga kI prarUpaNA kadApi nahIM karanI caahiye| ... 25-zrI haribhadracUrijI mahArAja viracita- prAgamodaya samiti kI tarapha se chapI huI "dazavakAlika" sUtra kI naDI TIkA ke pRSTha 237 meM AThaveM adhyayana kI tepana kI gAthA meM dharma kathA vidhi saMbaMdhI aisA pATha hai "nArINAM, strINAM na kathayetkathAM, zaGkAdidoSaprasaGgAt, aucityaM vijJAya puruSANAM tu kathayet, aviviktAyAM nArINAmapIti / "

Page #29
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH | isa pATha kA bhAvArtha aisA hai ki sAdhu ko triyoM kI sabhA meM dharmakathA nahIM karanI cAhiye, kevala striyoM kI sabhA meM dharmakathA karane para logoM ko zaGkA kA sthAna hotA hai aura brahmacarya hAni Adi aneka doSoM kA prasaGga prApta hotA hai, isaliye sAdhu striyoM kI sabhA meM dharmakathA na kahe parantu puruSoM kI pariSadA sAtha meM ho to dharmakathA kaha sakatA hai. yahAM para dharmakathA kahane se dharmadezanA samajhanA cAhiye, isI pATha kA Azaya lekara "hIra praznottarANi" meM zrI hIravijayasUrijI mahArAja ne khulAsA kara diyA hai kisAdhu akelI striyoM kI pariSadA meM vyAkhyAna nahIM bAMce, isI taraha sAdhvI bhI kevala puruSoM kI pariSadA meM vyAkhyAna nahIM bAMce, isakA Azaya yahI nikalA ki-sAdhu ho athavA sAdhvI strI, puruSa donoM kI sammilita sabhA meM vyakhyAna bAMca sakate hai " hIrapraznosarANi" kA pATha upara likha cuke haiN| 26-jo mahAzaya puruSa pradhAna dharma samajha kara sAdhviyoM ko vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA niSedha karate haiM, unhoM kI bhUla hai / kyoMki sAdhvI vyAkhyAna bAMcakara dharmopadeza se aneka bhavya jIvoM kA uddhAra kare, usameM puruSa pradhAna dharma ko koI hAni nahIM ho sakatI / bahuta varSoM kI dIkSA lI huI aura paDhI likhI viduSI sAdhvI bhI abhI ke dIkSA lie hue sAdhu ko vaMdanA karatI hai unakA bahumAna aura vinaya vyavahAra karatI hai| yaha vandanA vyavahArAdi kA viSaya alaga hai, aura bhavya jIvoM ko dharmopadeza dekara sanmArga meM lAnA alaga viSaya hai / ataH puruSa pradhAna dharma mAnya hone para bhI sAdhvI dvArA vyAkhyAna bAMcakara dharma mArga meM pravRti karAnA upakAra karanA kisI bhI prakAra se usameM bAdhA kAraka nahIM hai / isalie niSprayojana bahAnA batalAkara sAdhvI ko vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA niSedha karanA ucita nahIM hai| ____27-AcArAGga, dazavaikAlika, kalpasUtra, nizIthasUtra, aura bRhatkalpasUtra Adi aneka AgamoM meM "bhikkha vA bhikkhuNi vA" athavA "nigaMthaM vA nigaMthiNaM vA" ityAdi pAThoM meM sAdhu ke samAna hI sAdhviyoM ke lie bhI paMca mahAvrata lekara satraha prakAra kA saMyama pAlana karate hue tathA bAraha prakAra kA tapa sevana karake yAvat sarva karmoM kA kSaya karake mokSa prApti kA samAna adhikAra batalAyA hai, kevala puruSa pradhAna dharma hone se sAdhu kA nAma prathama grahaNa kiyA hai pazcAt sAdhvI kA nAma grahaNa kiyA hai / dekhiye-Agamodaya samiti kI tarapha se prakAzita baDI TIkA sahita "dazavaikAlika" sUtra cauthA adhyayana ke chape hue pRSTha 151, 152 meM "se bhikkhU vA bhikkhuNi bA" ityAdi pATha kI vyAkhyA karate hue zrI haribhadrasUrijI mahArAja ne isa prakAra likhA hai"sa yo'sau mahAvratayukto, bhikSuSoM bhikSukI vA prArambhaparityAgAddharmakAyapAlamAya bhikSaNazIlo bhikSuH, evaM bhikSukyapi, puruSottamo dharma

Page #30
.. sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH iti bhikSurvizeSyate, tadvizeSaNAni ca bhikSukyA api draSTavyAnIti," __ isa pATha meM mahAvata sahita sAdhu athavA sAdhvI Arambha ke tyAgI apane dharma kAya rUpI zarIra kA mikSA vRtti se pAlana karane vAle sAdhu hote haiM, vaise hI sAdhvI bhI hotI hai| puruSa pradhAna dharma hone se prathama sAdhu kA nAma grahaNa karake jo vizeSaNa kartavya sAdhu ke lie batalAye gaye haiM, ve hI vizeSaNa kartavya sAdhvI ke liye bhI samajha lene caahiye| yahA~ para TIkAkAra ne khulAsA kathana kara diyA hai ki-puruSa pradhAna dharma hone se prathama sAdhu kA nAma lekara pIche sAdhvI kA nAma liyA hai parantu saMyama pAlana kA kartavya saba samAna rUpa se isa sUtra meM kathana kiyA hai| isalie puruSa pradhAna dharma kahane para bhI sAdhu kI taraha sAdhvI bhI dharmadezanA de sakatI hai| sAdhvI kI dharmadezanA se puruSa pradhAna dharma meM koI hAni nahIM ho sktii| isI prakAra "sUyagaDAMga" sUtra cauthA adhyayana Agamodaya samiti kA prakAzita pRSTha 105 pahilI puThI kI prathama paMkti meM bhI Upara mujaba hI isI Azaya kA pATha hai| 28-dekhiye phira bhI isI sUtra ke prathama adhyayana meM bAraha prakAra ke tapa ke adhikAra meM abhyantara tarpa kI vyAkhyA karate hue svAdhyAya ke vAcanA, pRcchanA, parAvartanA, anuprekSA aura dharmakathA aise pAMca prakAra ke bheda batalAe haiM, jisameM dharmakathA kA lakSaNa saMbaMdhI chapI prati ke pRSTa 32 meM isa prakAra pATha hai "dhammakahANAma-jo ahiMsAi lakkhaNaM savaNNUpaNIaM dhamma aNuyogaM vA kareI esA dhammakahA" isakA bhAvArtha aisA hai ki-bhavya jIvoM ke Age sarvajJa bhagavAn kI kathana kI huI ahiMsAdi lakSaNa vAlI dharmakathA karanA athavA ahiMsAdi lakSaNa sarvajJa bhagavAn kI kathana kI huI vANI kI vyAkhyA karanA yaha dharmakathA nAmaka svAdhyAya kA pAMcavAM meda kahA jAtA hai| bhAva sahita bAraha prakAra ke tapa karane vAle sAdhu sAdhvI ArAdhaka hote haiM, 11 aMga Adi sUtroM kI svAdhyAya sAdhu sAdhviyoM ko hamezA karane kI AzA hai / svAdhyAya kA pAMcavAM meda dharmakathA hai, dharmakathA sAdhu-sAdhvI donoM ko karane kI kahI hai, bhavya jIvoM ko sUtroM kA artha sunAnA dharmadezanA denA yahI dharmakathA kahI jAtI hai, isa nyAya se sAdhuoM kI taraha uparokta zAla pramANAnusAra sAdhvI bhI zrAvaka zrAvikAoM ko dharmakathA sunA sakatI hai, ye bAta jinAjJAnusAra hai| isalie sAdhviyoM ko zrAvaka-zrAvikAoM ke

Page #31
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH Age dharmakathA kA niSedha karane vAle jinAmA kA utthApana karane vAle Thaharate haiN| . ___29-"dazavakAlika" sUtra kA pA~cavAM adhyayana, baDI TIkA sahita chape hue pRSTha 184 meM dUsare uddeze kI AThavIM gAthA kI TIkA kA pATha isa prakAra hai kiM ca "goara gga"tti sUtraM, gocarAgrapraviSTastu bhikSArthaM praviSTa ityarthaH 'na niSIdet nopavizet kvacid gRhadevakulAdau saMyamopaghAtAdiprasaGgAt "kathAM ca" dharmakathAdirUpAM na prabadhnIyAt prabandhena na kuryAt, anenaikavyAkaraNaika-jJAtAnujJAmAha, ata evAha-sthitvA kAlaparigraheNa saMyata iti, aneSaNAdveSAdidoSaprasaMgAditi sUtrArthaH // 8 // isa pATha kA bhAvArtha aisA hai ki-gaucarI gae hue sAdhu-sAdhvI ko gRhasthoM ke gharoM meM devakulAdi meM baiThanA nahIM kalpatA hai, vahA~ para logoM kA ati paricaya hone se saMyama meM bAdhA pahu~catI hai, aura vahA~ para logoM ko sunAne ke lie vyavasthAsara dharmakathA dharma dezanA na kreN| kadAcit khAsa kAraNa ho to eka prazna kA uttara yA eka gAthA kA artha saMkSepa se kahadeM, parantu baiThakara vistAra se na kaheM / jisa prakAra "bRhat kalpa" sUtrakA pATha Upara meM batalAyA jAcukA hai usameM sAdhu-sAdhviyoM ko dharmakathA karane kA samAna adhikAra hai usI hI abhiprAyAnusAra zrI haribhadrasUrijI mahArAja ne bhI Upara kI TIkA ke pATha meM sAdhu-sAdhviyoM ko dharmadezanA kA samAna adhikAra hI batalAyA hai| dazavaikAlika sUtra kA pahilA adhyayana, cauthA adhyayana, pA~cavA~ adhyayana aura AThavA~ adhyayana kI TIkA ke cAroM pAThoM ke anusAra aura "saMbodhaprakaraNa" kI gAthA jo Upara meM batalA cuke haiM, isa prakAra zrI haribhadrasUrijI mahArAja ne uparokta pAMco pramANoM ke anusAra, sAdhu-sAdhviyoM ko dharmadezanA (vyAkhyAna bAMcane) kA samAna adhikAra batalAyA hai| dazavaikAlika sUtrAnusAra sAdhu-sAdhvI donoM ko apane saMyama kI ArAdhanA karane kI hai saMyama ke sAtha bAraha prakAra kA tapa bhI sevana kiyA jAtA hai| tapa meM svAdhyAya kIjAtI hai aura svAdhyAya rUpa tapa meM hI dharmadezanA dI jAtI haiN| ye anAdi siddha niyama hai| isa niyamAnusAra sAdhuoM kI taraha sAdhviye bhI dharmadezanA dene kI adhikAriNI siddha haiN| isalie sAdhviyoM ko dharmadezanA dene kA koI bhI niSedha nahIM kara sktaa| ... 30-phira bhI dekhiye sAdhu-sAdhviyoM ko pAMca samitiyoM kA pAlana karane kI bhagavAn kI AzA hai| usameM dUsarI bhASA samiti arthAt-upayoga pUrvaka apanI AtmA ko aura dUsare prANiyoM ko hitakArI madhura vacana bolane vAle sAdhu-sAdhvI bhagavAn kI AzA

Page #32
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH ke ArAdhaka hote haiN| yaha bAta zAstrAnusAra sarvamAnya pratyakSa satya hai| isa hI ke anusAra sAdhvI bhI bhavyajIvoM ke Age unake hitakArI upakAra karane vAlI zuddha bhASA samiti sahita sUtrArtha kA vyAkhyAna sunAveM to vaha sAdhvI bhagavAn kI AjJA kI ArAdhaka ThaharatI hai| jisapara bhI jo mahAzaya sAdhvI ko dharmopadeza dene kI manAI karate haiM, ve loga pratyakSa hI zAstroM kI bAtoM kA utthApana karane vAle Thaharate haiN| 31-sAdhviyoM ko kevalajJAna prApta karake mokSa meM jAne vAlI mAnate haiM taba kyA sAdhvI kA vyAkhyAna mokSa se bhI adhika mahatva kA hai ? ki-jisakA niSedha karate haiN| yahA niSedha karane vAloM kI buddhi para hameM dayA AtI hai ki ve sAdhviyoM ko ananta jJAnI aura mokSa prApti karane vAlI mAnakara bhI unako bhavyajIvoM ke Age upadeza dene kA niSedha karate haiM / puruSa pradhAna dharma mAnakara bhI sAdhviyoM kA vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA anAdi siddha adhikAra hai / usako niSedha karanA kisI prakAra bhI ucita nahIM hai| 32-jaina zAsana meM puruSa pradhAna dharma hone se zAstroM meM jagaha jagaha para sAdhu ke nAma se jo jo kriyA kI bAteM batAI haiM usake anusAra sAdhviyoM ke lie bhI yathAyogya vehI kriyA kI bAteM samajha lenI cAhiye / jaise-zramaNasUtra meM "cauhiM vikahAhiM itthikahAe, bhattakahAe, desakahAe, rAyakahAe" isa pATha meM sAdhu ke lie strIkathA kA niSedha kiyA hai aura yehI pAThasAdhviyA~ bhI bolatIM haiM taba "ithi kahAe" ke sthAna meM puruSakathA na karane kA artha liyA jAtA hai, isI prakAra zrAvaka ke "vandittA" sUtra meM bhI "cautthe aNuvvayaMmi niccaM paradAragamaNaviraIo" isa pATha meM zrAvaka ke cauthe anuvrata meM hamezA parastrI kA tyAga batAyA hai, aura yehI pATha zrAvikAyeM bhI bolatI haiM, unake lie cauthe anuvrata meM hamezA para puruSa ke tyAga karane kA artha samajha liyA jAtA hai, isahI prakAra jahA~ jahA~ sAdhu zrAvaka ke lie jo jo adhikAra Aye hoM vahA~ vahA~ sAdhvI tathA zrAvikA ke lie bhI yathA yogya samajha liye jAte haiM, isa nyAyAnusAra jisa zAstra meM sAdhu ke lie dharmadezanA dene kA vidhAna AyA ho usake anulAra hI sAdhvI ke lie bhI dharmadezanA dene ke lie unhIM pramANoM ko usI adhikAra kA samajha lenA caahie| ___33-phira bhI dekhiye-anya darzanIya logoM ne jaba kaI taraha ke niyama banAkara veda par3hane Adi ke striyoM ke svAbhAvika adhikAra chIna lie the aura unhoM ko apane nIce dabA rakkhA thA. kaI bAtoM meM sarvathA paravaza banA diyA thA taba usa paravazatA kA nAza karake zrI mahAvIra bhagavAn ne striyoM ko paMca mahAvrata-saMyama lenA, agyAraha aMga Adi mUla AgamoM ko par3hanA, svAdhyAya karanA aura apanA saMyama pAlana karate hue yAvat mokSa pahu~ca ne taka ko puruSoM ke samAna adhikAra batalAyA hai| aise udAra aura nyAya saMpanna sarvaza

Page #33
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH vItarAga ke jaina zAsana meM sAdhvI samAja ko dharmopadeza dekara dUsaroM ke kalyANa karane kA sAdhuoM ke samAna hI adhikAra hai, jisa para bhIabhI kaI anasamajha logoM ko yaha bAta samajha meM nahIM AI hai, unhoMko Upara meM jo jo zAstroM ke pramANa hamane batalAye haiM, unhoM para dIrgha dRSTi se vicAra karake apanI bhUla sudhAranA aura satya bAta grahaNa karanA ucita hai| gyAraha aMga mUla sUtroM kA par3hanA, usakA artha sIkhanA, usa mujaba apanA AtmakalyANa karanA yaha to lAbha kA hetu kahanA aura unhIM sUtrArtha ko dUsare bhavyajIva-zrAvaka Adi ko sunA kara unhoMko apanI AtmA ke kalyANa kA mArga batalAnA, isameM alAbha pApa doSa batalAnA yaha kaisA bhArI anyAya hai isakA vicAra sajana pAThaka apane ApahI kara leve / / 34-jo mahAzaya aisA kahate haiM ki "yAkinI mahattarA" sAdhvI ne haribhadra bhaTTa ko " cakkIdaggaM" ityAdi eka gAthA kA artha na batalAyA to phira sAdhvI sabhA meM vyAkhyAna karake sUtroM kA artha kaise batalA sakatI hai| aisI zaMkA bhI anucita hai| kyoMki vaha sAdhvI akelI thI aura zAma kA samaya thaa| haribhadra bhaTTa ne rAste calate yaha pUchA thA, vaha bhI akelA thA aura anya matAvalambI thA aura aparicita bhI thA usake sAtha akelI sAdhvI ko zAstrIya vArtAlApa karanA ucita nahIM thA, ataH isa sAdhvI ne haribhadra bhaTTa ko eka gAthA kA artha na batalAyA, parantu guru mahArAja ke pAsa meM jAkara samajha lene kA kahA, kintu abhI sAdhvI vyAkhyAna bAMcegI vaha to samudAya meM bAMcegI, isalie aprAsaMgika akele va anya matavAle haribhadra bhaTTa kA dRSTAnta batalAkara hajAroM zrAvakazrAvikAoM ke dharma zravaNa meM antarAya DAlanA ucita nahIM hai| jisa jagaha AcArya, upAdhyAya aura apane guru Adi bar3e puruSa virAjamAna hoM aura vahAM para sAmAnya sAdhu gaucarI Adi ke lie gayA ho vahAM use koI zrAvaka-zrAvikAdi prazna pUche to apane baDe puruSoM ke pAsa jAkara samAdhAna karane ke liye kaha deve, kintu Apa vahAM apanI paMDitAI batalAne ke lie prazna kA uttara na deve, isa prakAra baDe puruSoM kI vinaya bhakti bahumAna kI maryAdA hai isI prakAra se yAkinI sAdhvI ne haribhadra bhaTTa ko eka gAthA kA artha na batalAkara apane AcArya mahArAja ke pAsa jAkara samajhane kA kaha diyA, yaha usakI apane pUjya puruSoM ke prati vinaya bhakti aura bahumAna kI maryAdA va buddhimattA thii| isa bAtakA bhAvArtha na samajha kara sAdhviyoM ko zrAvaka-zrAvikAoM kI sabhAmeM vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA niSedha samajha rakkhA hai, yaha unakI baDI bhUla hai| __ haribhadrabhaTTa hI dIkSA lekara zrIharibhadrasUrijI mahArAja hue haiM unhoMne apane banAye " saMbodha prakaraNa" meM tathA "dazavaikAlika" sUtra kI baDI TIkA meM sAdhu ke samAna

Page #34
22 sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH sAdhviyoM ko bhI vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA samAna adhikAra batalAyA hai, unhoMke pAMca pramANa Upara meM batalA diye gaye haiN| isalie zrIharibhadrasUrijI kA aura yAkinI mahattarA kA nAma lekara sAdhvI ko vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA niSedha karane vAle bar3I bhUla karate haiN| .... 35-zrI jayatilakasUrijI mahArAja kA banAyA huA zrI " mahAbala malayasuMdarI - caritra" jo ki jAmanagara se prakAzita huA hai| usake pRSTha 192-193 meM aisA pATha hai itazcAmalacAritrA sAdhvI mlysNdrii| ekAdazAMgatatvajJA pratibodhaparAyaNA // 84 // tapyamAnA tapastIvaM karma-marma dvidodyatA / / kramotpannAvadhijJAnA guruNiH zrImahattarA // 85 / / satsaMdeha samAMsIha jaghAnA prabhevasA / - vitrastakunayolUkA bhavyAMbhoja prayodhikA / / 86 // mahAbala munetviA nirvANaM tanayaM nijaM / prabodhayitumAyAtA pure tatra mahattarA / / 87 // vasatAvucitAyoM mA sthitA sAdhvI smnvitaa| rAjJAzatayalenaitya mahAbhaktyA ca vaMditA // 88 // AlApito mahArAjaH prasannatanayA tyaa| girA madhurayA, zrota zravaNAmRta tulyayA / / 89 // pitA taca narAdhIza mahAsattva ziromaNiH / upasargAsriyAstasyA-prapede zivasaMpadaM // 9 // sarva putra kalatrAdi tyajyate yasya hetve|. .... satya ca mahAduHkhaM tapolocakriyAdikaM // 91 // durlabhaM yadi tatprAptaM sthAnaM zAzvatamuttamaM / / tyaktoM bhavazva pitrAte zoko'dyapi tataHkathaM // 12 // mahAnidhAnamApnoti yadyabhISTo jano nijaH / vijRmbhate mahAzoko vadaM kiMvA mahotsavaH // 93 //

Page #35
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH sudussahAmi pIDApi na cinlyA ca pitustvayA prahArAtra sahate kiM jayazrI laMpaTA bhaMTAH // 94 // sAdhayanto'thavA vidyAM narA duHkhaM sahati vai / siddhiratyadbhutApena binA kaSTa na jAyate // 95 // tAtapAdAnatAnaiva kartavyeti ca nA'dhRtiH / janakArAthanAsakto yatvaM prAgadhunApi ca // 96 // tAdvamuMca pituH zokaM paribhAvaya saMmRti / paritrANaM na zokena kiMcidbhava te dehinAM // 97 // bhavaM duHkhAlayaM vRddhi saMgamaM svapna sannirbha / lakSmIM vidyullatAlAla jIvitaM budabudopamaM // 98 // yadi yuSmAdazIpyeva guruzikSAvicakSaNaH / zokaM kurvanti tadvai vivekro'pi ka yAsyati // 99 // evaM dharmopadezaiH sa narendro bodhitastayA / * saMvibhogatazokazva lagnodharme vizeSataH // 1 // nityaM mahattarApAdAn vandatesma narezvaraH / upadezAna zRNotisma zAsanodaya kAriNaH // 2 // 23 PDR k 66 36-isa upara ke pATha kA bhAvArtha zrI kAntivijayajI kA banAyA huA zrI mahAbala malayasuMdarIrAsa " jo ki zrAvaka bhImasIha mANeka dvArA prakAzita huA hai| usakI mudrita pustaka ke pRSTha 313-314 meM aisA pATha hai || DhAla // saDatIsamI || hU~ dAsI rAma tumhArI e dezI // ehave nirmala carita pavittA, satya zIla saMtoSa vicittA / pAtI vrata ekacittA, sAdhvI malavA tapa, jutA // horAja // 1 // mahAsatI dhura sohe, zrutadharme bhavi paDivohe // horAja || ma0 // ekAdaza aMganI jANa, pAmI zubha avadhinANa bhAvaMtI thira pANa, saMyama tatra yoga vihANa | dorAja // 2 //

Page #36
24 sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH saMdeha bhavikanA TAle, kumatAdikanA mdgaale| eka avasara avadhe bhAle, mahAbala nirvANa nihAle / horAja // 3 // nija naMdana pratibodhavA, bhavatApa duraMta hrevaa| AvI tiNa purI tatakhevA, hove sAdhu ne dharmanI devA / / horAja // 4 // sAdhuyogya vasatIne ThAmeM, pazu paMDaga rahita sudhaameN| sAdhvI ne ThANa abhirAme, biTI rahI AI sukAme // horAja // 5 // zatabala bhUpata ati bhakte, vAMde zrAvakanI yukt| samajAvA sAdhvI yugate, jiNa dhI pAme valI mukte| horAja // 6 // rAjendra pitA tuja zUro, upazama saMvege pUro / satya sAhasa zauca sanUro, pAmyo zivasukha maha bhuuro||horaaj // 7 // upasaryo kanakavatIye, na karayuM mana kaluSa vrtiiye| bhavasAgara taratAM tIye, avalaMbana dIbUM mIye ||horaaj // 8 // dhana putra kalatra gRhabhAra, jasa kAraNa tajiye sNsaar| tapa loca kriyA vyavahAra, sAdhIje vividha prakAra // horAja // 9 // seve je giri vana ghAMTA, sahiye vacana kaTukanA kaaNttaa| upasarga uraganI AMTA, khamIye taI dhIrajanA sAMTA / / horAja // 10 // durlabha te pada tAteM lAMdhU, nIgamIyUM bhava bhaya bAMdhU / have kA mana zoke vAMbUM, kare kAI vayuSa e AMdhU / horAja / / 11 / / kRtakRtya huo munirAya, tiNe harSa taNA e upAya / te mATe aho mahArAya, kAI zoka kare eNe ThAya ||horaaj / / 12 // potAno vAlho koI, nidhipAme sahasA soii| tihA zoka ke harSaja hoI, kahe hiyaDe vicArI joI ||horaaj // 13 // ' vizvAnara pIDA tAteM, sAMsahI hoze eha yAMteM / ciMtA ma kare tilamAte, jaya arathi khiti sahe gAte / horAja // 14 // sAdhakanara vidyAsAdhe, pahelu tihA budhava, sahe bodho| nija kAraja siddhiM ArAdhe, nava AyanaH phalamukhalAdho // 15 //

Page #37
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH paheluM duHkha saghale dIse, pAche sukha saMbhava hIse / ima jANIne vizvA vI.se, mana nAkhe zoka mAM kIse // 16 / / bheTyA nahi caraNa pitAnA, mata kara iMmapari ciMtAnA / pahelI para havaNA dAnA, tuja bhaktinA guNa nahi chAnA // 17 // zoka mUkIne have bhUpa, saMsArano bhAvI sarUpa / dRr3hadhArI viveka anUpa. taja dUre sahu bhavakUpa // 18 // dukhasAgara e saMsAra, saMgama supanA anukAra / lakhamI jima bIja saMcAra, jIvi buda-bude aNuhAra // 19 // tuja sarikhA je ima karize, zokAkule hiya9 bharaze / bApaDalo kiMhA saMcaraze, dhIraja dhAnaka viNa phiraze // 20 // ima dharmataNo upadeza, nisuNI pratibudhyo nareza / chaMDe savizoka kalezA, saMvega layo suvizeSa // 21 // praName nitya-nitya bhUpAla, mahattarikA caraNa trikAla / sar3atrIsabhI e kahI DhAla, cothe khaMDe "kAnti" rasAla // 22 // dohA:- . pahattarikAnA mukhathakI suNe dharma upadeza / kare mahonnati dharmanI, dharma dhurINa nareza // dekhiye Upara diye hue caritra ke pATha se vidita hotA hai ki-malayasuMdarI sAdhvI nirmala cAritra pAlana karatI huI, gyAraha aMgoM kI par3hane vAlI tatvakSA, pratibodha dene meM parAyaNa, bahuta kaThina tapa karake karmakSaya karane meM sAvadhAna hone se avadhizAna pAyA thaa| jisase logoM ke saMzaya rUpI aMdhakAra ko nAza karane meM sUrya samAna prabhAvavAlI huI thii| aura anya mithyAtviyoM kA mAna utAranevAlI tathA bhavya jIva rUpI kamaloM ko pratibodha karanevAlI thii| usa sAdhvI ne rAjA ko bahuta vistAra se dharmopadeza dekara pratibodha diyA thaa| isase rAjA hamezA usa sAdhvI ke caraNa kamaloM ko vandanA karatA thA aura jaina zAsana kI unnati karane vAlA dharmopadeza hamezA sunatA thaa| isakA vizeSa vivaraNa rAsa banAnevAle zrIkAntivijayajI mahArAja ne bhASAbaddha racanA meM khulAsArUpa se likha diyA hai jisase yahAM para phira adhikarUpa se likhane kI AvazyakatA nahIM samajhI gaI hai|

Page #38
26 sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH 37-Upara caritra ke pATha meM "tatvajJA" "pratibodha parAyaNA" "satsandehatamAsIha jaghAnyarkaprameva sA" "vitrasta kunayolUkA bhavyAmbhojaprabodhikA" ityAdi tathA rAsa ke pATha meM zrutadharme paDibohe horAja // 1 // "sandeha bhavikanA TAle" kumatAdikanA mada gaale| ityAdi vAkyoM se caritrakArane evaM rAsa racayitA ne malayasuMdarI sAdhvI ko anya bhavyajIvoM ko bhI dharmadezanA denevAlI ThaharAI hai| 38-isa prakAra prasaMgavaza pratyeka avasara para sAdhviyoM ne puruSoM ko aura striyoM ko anekavAra dharmopadeza diyA hai| jisakA "zAtAjI" "utarAdhyayana" "nirayAvalI" Adi aneka sUtra tathA caritra prakaraNa Adi meM bahuta zAstrIya pramANa sthAna sthAna para milate haiN| jisa para bhI jJAnasuMdarajI Adi kaI mahAzaya kahA karate haiM ki-sAdhvI ke vyAkhyAna bA~cane kI kuprathA karIba pacAsa-sATha varSoM se navIna pracalita huI hai| kisI bhI zAstra meM sAdhvI ko vyAkhyAna bA~cane kI AjJA nahIM hai sAdhvI agara vyAkhyAna bA~ce to tIrthakara gaNadhara pUrvAcArya va zAstroM kI maryAdA bhaMga karane kI aparAdhinI ThaharatI hai aura unakA vyAkhyAna sunanevAle zrAvaka bhI doSI Thaharate haiN| ityAdi aneka taraha kI mithyA bAteM banAkara bhole jIvoM ko unmArga meM DAlate haiN| hama Upara vRhatkalpa siddha prAbhRta va nandIsUtraTIkA Adi ke zAstrIya pramANa batalA cuke haiN| una saba pramANoM se sAdhviyoM ko vyAkhyAna bA~cane kI AjJA anAdisiddha sAbita hai| ___39--kaI mahAzaya sAdhvI ko vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA niSedha karane ke lie "jIvAnuzAsana" grantha kA yaha pramANa batalAte haiM ki muddha jaNachettasuhaSohasaMssaviddavaNadakkhasamaNIo IIo viyakAo vi aDaMtidhammaM kahaM tiio|| 181 / / vyAkhyA-mugdhajanAH svalpabuddhilokAH ta eva kSetrANi vIja vapanabhUmayasteSu zubhayodhaH pradhAnAzayaH sa eva sasyaM dhAnyaM tasya vidravaNaM vinAza karaNaM tatra dakSA: paTavyaH prAkRtatvAcAtra vibhaktilopaH zramaNyaH AryikA Itaya iva tiDDAdyA kAzcana na sarvA aTanti grAmAdiSu caranti dharma dAnAdikaM kathayantyo bruvANA iti gAthArthaH / etadapi nirAkartumAha egateNaM vi ya taM na suMdaraM jeNa tANapi paDisehI / siddhaM tadesaNAe kappaSTiya eva gAhAe // 182 / / vyAkhyA-ekAnte naiva * sarvathA taddharmakathanaM na naiva sundaraMbhavyam,

Page #39
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH yenatAsAM sAdhvInAM pratiSedho nirAkaraNaM siddhAnta dezanAyA Agama kathanasya / kathA pratiSedhaH ? kalpasthitayaiva gAthayetyarthaH kalpagAthA mevAha kusamaya suINa mahaNo vivohao bhaviya puMDarIyANaM / __ dhammo jiNapannato pakappajaiNA kaheyavvo // 18 // vyAkhyA-kusamaya zrutInAM kusiddhAntamatInAM mathano vinAzakaH, vibodhako vikAzako bhavyapuNDarIkANAM muktiyogyaprANizataM petrANAM dharmoM dAnAdiko jinaprajJapto munIndragaditaH kalpayatinA nizIthajJa sAdhunA kathayitavyo na punaH sAdhvyetihRDhayamiti gAthArthaH nanu yadi tAsAM sadIyate, tatonindyaMtaddharma kathanamityAha saMpai puNo na dijaha pakappagaMdhassa tANa suttattho / ... jaiyA viya dijaMto taiyA viya esa paDiseho // 184 // vyAkhyA-sAmpratamadhunA puna: naiva dIyate vitIryate prakalpa granthasya nizIthasyatAsAM AryikANAM sUtrArthaH sUtreNa paddhatyA sAhito'rtho'bhidheyaH sUtrArtha ubhayamiti hRdayam yadApi vA dIyate vitIryatesma, tadApi ca tasminnapikAle eSa vyAkhyAna karaNa lakSaNaH pratiSedho nivAraNamitigAthArthaH amumevA) dRSTAntapUrvakaM darzayannAha haribhaddadhamma jaNaNIe kiMca jAiNi pavattiNIe vi| ego vi gAhatyo no siThTho muNiya tattAe // 18 // vyAkhyA-sUcanAtsUtrasya haribhadrasUridharmajananyApi dharmadAtrItvena pratipannamAtrA kiJcAbhyucaye yAkinI pravartinyA etannAmamahattarayA na kevalamanyAbhirityapi zabdArthaH eko'pi ca gAthArtho'bhidheya AstAM prabhUta ityaperoM no naiva ziSTaH kathito muNitatatvayA jJAtaparamArthayA tathA ca "cakkIdugaM haripaNagaM" ityAdi gAthAyAH svArtha pRSTA haribhadra bhaTTena, na ca tayA kathitaH, itisupratIto'yamarthaH / iti gAthArthaH evaM jJAte jIvopadezamAha 7 //

Page #40
28 sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH bahu mannasu mA cariyaM amuNiyatattANa tANa tA jIva / jai saM nivAriyAo tA bArasu mahurabakkeNa // / 186 | vyAkhyA - bahu manyasva bhavyAmidamitimaMsthAH, mA iti niSedhe, caritaM dharmakathana lakSaNam, amuNita tattvAnAm avidita paramArthAnAm tAsAM AryikANAm tasmAjjIva / Atman ! yadi vikalpArthaH, tiSThanti saM nivAritAH niSiddhAH tato vAraya niSedhaya, madhura vAkyena - komala vaca seti gAthArthaH / isakA bhAvArtha aisA hai ki alpabuddhivAle bhole jIva rUpI kSetroM meM zubha bodha rUpI zreSTha dhAnya ko nAza karane vAlI TiDDAdi Iti samAna kaI eka sAdhviyA~ parantu yahA~ para sarva sAdhviyoM kA grahaNa nahIM karanA, ve sAdhviyeM grAmAdi meM vicaratI haiM aura dAnAdi dharma kathA kahatI phiratI haiM / sAdhviyoM ko dharma dezanA kA kathana karanA ekAnta se sarvathA acchA nahIM hai / AgamoM kA sundara kathana karanA arthAt zAstroM kI dezanA denA ( tAsAM ) arthAt una caitya vAsinI sAdhviyoM ke lie niSedha kiyA hai / kuzAstroM kI mati ko vinAza karanevAlA tathA muktijAne yogya bhavya jIva rUpa puNDarIkamaloM ko vikAza karanevAlA jinendra kathita dAnAdi dharma nizItha sUtrako jAnane vAle sAdhu ko hI kahanA yogya hai, kintu sAdhviyoM ko nahIM vartamAna kAla meM una sAdhviyoM ko prakalpa grantha kA arthAt nizItha sUtra aura usakA artha nahIM diyA jAtA, . pahale ke kAla meM diyA jAtA thA taba bhI usakA vyAkhyAna karane kA niSedha thA, isahI viSaya meM dRSTAnta kahate haiM haribhadrasUrijI ko unakI mAtA yAkinI mahattarAsAdhvI ne cakkIduggaM haripaNagaM" ityAdi eka gAthA kA artha nahIM batAyA to phira adhika batAne kI bAta hI kyA hai / 66 isI prakAra tatva ko nahIM jAnane vAlI jo sAdhviyA~ dharmakathA kI dezanA detI haiM unako madhura vANI se niSedha karanA yaha jIvAnuzAsana ke pATha kA sArAMza hai / aba yahA~ para upara ke pATha kI samIkSA karate haiM / jIvAnuzAsana meM sAdhviyoM ko grAmAdi meM vihAra karanA tathA dAnAdi kA dharmopadeza denA ye donoM bAteM bhavyajIvoM ko nukasAna karanevAlI hone se inakA niSedha kiyA hai| isakA bhAvArtha samajhe binA sarva sAdhviyoM ko dharmopadeza dene kA niSedha karane vAloM kI bar3I bhUla hai, kyoMki yaha adhikAra usa samaya kI caityavAsinI bhraSTAcArI sAdhviyoM ke lie granthakAra ne kahA hai isa grantha meM

Page #41
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH usa gAthA kI TIkA meM khulAsA kathana kara diyA hai, ki abhI una sAdhviyoM ko nizIthasUtra artha sahita nahIM paDhAyA jAtA kintu pahale paDhAyA jAtA thA aura usa samaya gujarAta Adi dezoM meM prAyaH caityavAsinI vezadhAriNI sAdhviyA~ thI aura unhIM kA adhikatara saMyama dharma girA huA thA aisI dazA meM usa samaya kI una sAdhviyoM ko nizIthasUtra Adi paDhane kI manAI kI gaI tathA grAmAnugrAma vihAra karane kI aura dharmadezanA dene kI manAI kI gaI jo unhoM ke kartavyoM ke anusAra ucita hI thaa| isa bAta kA bhAvArtha samajhe binA zuddha saMyamI sAdhviyoM ko nizIthasUtra par3hane kI tathA grAmAdi meM vihAra karane kA aura dharmadezanA dene kA niSedha karanA sarvathA anucita hai| 45-jo mahAzaya "ekAnte naiva sarvathA taddharma kathanaM na naiva sundaraM bhavyam" isa vAkya se zAstroM kI dezanA dharma kathA karane kA sAdhviyoM ko sarvathA ekAnta rUpa se niSedha karate haiM yaha bhI anucita hai "siddha prAbhRta" "nandIsUtra kI TIkA" aura "siddhapaMcAzikA vacUrNi" Adi sarva mAnya prAcIna zAstroM meM mallIsvAmI Adi strI tIrthakarI tathA anya sAmAnya sAdhviyoM ko dharmopadeza dene kA khulAsA ullekha hai, isake pATha bhI Upara batA suke haiM / isaliye jIvAnuzAsana kA uparokta vAkya sarva sAdhviyoM ke lie ThaharAne vAle abhinivezika mithyAtva se unmArga kI prarUpaNA karanevAle banate haiN| 46-eka gAthA kA artha na batalAne sambandhI yAkinI mahasarA sAdhvI bAbata haribhadrasUrijI kA kathana batalAkara sarva sAdhviyoM ko vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA niSedha karanevAle mithyA haThAgrahI ThaharAte haiM, isa viSaya meM adhika khulAsA Upara meM likha cuke haiN| . 47- jisa samaya apane mithyApakSa ko sthApana karane ke lie aura dUsaroM ke satyapakSa ko niSedha karane ke lie jisa manuSya ko haThAgraha ho jAtA hai vaha apane haThAgraha kI dhuna meM purvApara kA vicAra kiye binA aTasaMTa likha mAratA hai / vahI dazA isa sthAna para sAdhvI kA vyAkhyAna niSedha karanevAle zAnasundarajI Adi mahAzayoM kI huI hai / dekho-yahA~ para to jIvAnuzAsana kA uparokta pramANa batalAkara "sAdhvInAM pratiSedhonirAkaraNaM siddhAntadezanAyA zrAgama kathanasya" isa vAkya se sAdhviyoM ko vyAkhyAna SAMcane kA sarvathA niSedha karate haiM aura "kyA puruSoM kI pariSada meM jaina sAdhvI vyAkhyAna de sakatI hai" isa TrekTa ke pRSTha 5 ke 13 vI paMkti se 20 paMkti taka isa prakAra likhA hai : "yadi sAdhviyoM dvArA jana kalyANahI karavAnA hai to Aja strI samAja kA kSetra kama nahIM hai ve sAdhviyA~ mahilAoM ko upadeza dekara unakA uddhAra kareM aura yaha kArya koI sAdhAraNa bhI nahIM hai eka mahilA samAja kA sudhAra ho jAya to akhila saMsAra kA kalyANa ho sakatA hai| zAtAsUtra meM AryA gopAlikA tathA niriyAvalikA sUtra meM sAdhvI suvatA

Page #42
sAdhvI zyAkhyAna nirNayaH ne mahilA samAja ko upadeza diyA thA ataH sAdhvI strI samAja ko upadeza dekara unakA kalyANa kare usameM saba saMsAra kA bhalA hai|" isa lekha meM niriyAvalakA sUtra aura zAtAsUtra ke pramANa se sAdhviyoM ko zrAvikAoM ke sammukha dharmadezanA dene kI AzA svIkAra karate haiM, isa pramANa se jIvAnuzAsana grantha ke uparokta pramANa se sarvathA ekAntarUpa se sAdhviyoM ko dharmadezanA dene kA niSedha mithyA ThaharatA hai, jisa pramANa ko Apa baDI zUravIratA se peza karate haiM, usI bAta ko Apa apane lekha se apramANita sAbita karate haiM, jaba sAdhviyoM ke lie striyoM kI sabhA meM dharmadezanA denA maMjUra karate haiM, taba dharmadezanA kA sarvathA niSedha karanA vyartha ThaharatA hai / tathA striyoM ko dharmadezanA sunAnA aura puruSoM ko nahIM sunAnA yA puruSoM ko nahIM sunane denA aisA kisI bhI zAstra kA pramANa nahIM haiM, parantu-strI puruSa donoM eka sAtha milakara sAdhvI kI dharmadezanA suna sakate haiM / isa viSaya meM hama Upara aneka pramANa batalA cuke haiM / isalie sAdhvI ko dharmadezanA dene kA niSedha karanevAle baDI bhUla karate haiN| 48-jaina zAsana meM sAdhu, sAdhvI, zrAvaka aura zrAvikA isa prakAra caturvidha saMgha kI sthApanA tIrthakara bhagavAn karate haiM, saMgha kA mukhya kartavya tapa-saMyama svAdhyAya dvArA prAtmakalyANa karanA, AtmakalyANa ke sAtha 2 dUsare bhavya jIvoM ko dharmopadeza se dharma pravRtti karAkara paropakAra karanA / dharmadezanA svAdhyAya meM samajhI jAtI hai, svAdhyAya karanA cAroM prakAra ke saMgha kA khAsa kartavya hai| isa bAta kA bhAvArtha samajhanevAle aura jo zAstra pramANa hama Upara meM batalA Aye haiM, unhoM ko samajhanevAle koI bhI sajjana sAdhvI ko dharmadezanA dene kA niSedha nahIM kara sakate, jisapara bhI jJAnasundarajI Adi jo mahAzaya sAdhvI kI dezanA kA niSedha karane ke lie baDA Agraha kara rahe haiM, una logoMkA sAdhviyoMke prati dveSa mAlUma hotA hai, kyoMki khuda vyAkaraNa paDhe nahIM, sUtroM kI TIkA kA vyAkhyAna sabhA meM nahIM kara sakate aura kaI acchI paDhI likhI sAdhviyA~ sUtroM kI TIkA kA sabhA meM vyAkhyAna bAMcatI haiM, unakA prabhAva bhI samAja meM acchA paDatA hai, yaha bAta sAdhvI samAja ke dveSiyoM se sahana ho nahIM sakatI isalie sAdhvI samAja kI nindA buddhi meM unako nIcA dikhAne ke lie aura apanA mithyA ghamaNDa rakhane ke lie sAdhvI ke dharmadezanA kA niSedha karate haiM aura bhadra jIvoM ko unmArga meM DAlane ke lie kaI prakAra kI kuyuktiyA~ karate haiN| una kuyuktiyoM kA samAdhAna yahA~ para likhate haiN| 49-agara kahA jAya ki-sAdhvI adhika paDhegI, vyAkhyAna bAMcegI to usako abhimAna pAjAvegA aura sAdhu kA anAdara kareMgI, isalie sAdhvI ko adhika paDhanA, vyAkhyAna bAMcanA yogya nahIM / aisA kahanA bhI anucita hai| kyoMki dekho-agara sAdhvI adhika paDhegI, jJAna vRddhi hogI to usase sadviveka zrAvegA jisase sAdhuoM kI bahumAna pUrvaka

Page #43
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH caityavAsiyoM kI zAstra viruddha bahutasI bAtoM kI AcaraNAoM kA niSedha kiyA hai| usake sAtha sAtha una caityavAsinI sAdhviyoM ko grAmAdi meM vihAra karanA tathA upadeza denA donoM hI bAtoM kA niSedha kiyA hai, usake sAtha yaha bhI batalAyA hai ki "aDaMtidhammaMkahaMtipro" tathA "AryikA Itaya iva tiDDAdyAH kAzcana na sarvA" yaha vAkya Upara ke mUla pATha meM tathA TIkA ke pATha meM khulAsA likhA huA hai, isase granthakAra ne yaha viSaya una vezadhAriNIyoM ke lie kahA hai, parantu sarva saMyamI sAdhviyoM ke lie nahIM jisa para bhI granthakAra ke amiprAya viruddha hokara ke yaha viSaya sarva sAdhviyoM ke lie ThaharAnevAle mAyAcAra se abhinivezika mithyAtva kA sevana karate haiN| 40-aura bhI dekhiye-jisa taraha kisI grAma-nagara yA prAnta meM bhraSTAcArI sAdhusAdhviyoM kA samudAya rahatA ho aura unake loka viruddha dharma viruddha vyavahAra ke dekhane se jaina zAsana kI avahilanA hotI ho, taba usakA sudhAra karane ke lie yadi koI sudhAraka kahe ki-sAdhu-sAdhviyoM kA ahAra-pAnI denA, vandanA karanA, aura unhoM kA vyAkhyAna sunanA ityAdi kArya pApa vRddhi kA hetu hai, isalie aisA nahIM karanA caahie| aisA kahane vAloM kA Azaya una sAdhu-sAdhviyoM kA bhraSTAcAra rokane kA hotA hai, parantu ve vAkya zuddha saMyamI sarva sAdhviyoM ke lie nahIM mAne jA sakate / isahI taraha se jIvAnuzAsana granthakartA ne bhI caityavAsinI sAdhviyoM kA vihAra aura upadeza donoM niSedha kiyA hai, jisa para bhI isa pramANa ko Age karake sarva zuddha saMyamI sAdhviyoM ko vihAra karane kA tathA upadeza dene kA niSedha karanevAloM kI baDI ajJAnatA hai| 41-phira bhI dekhiye-Upara ke pramANa se yadi sarva sAdhviyoM ko vyAkhyAna vAMcane kA niSedha kiyA jAve to yaha bAta jinezvara bhagavAna kI AjJA ke sarvathA viruddha ThaharatI hai, kyoMki "uttarAdhyayana, nandI, sUyagaDAMga, jJAtAjI, nirayAvalI" Adi AgamoM kI TIkA tathA prakaraNa aura caritrAdi aneka zAstroM ke pATha Upara meM batalAkara hama sAdhvI ko vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA adhikAra sAbita kara Aye haiM, yaha niyama anAdikAla se hai, isahI se to sAdhviyoM se pratibodha pAye hue puruSa cAritra lekara yAvat siddha hote haiM, isalie jIvAnuzAsana ke nAma se sarva sAdhviyoM ko vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA niSedha karanevAle jinAzA ke virAdhaka banakara utsUtra prarUpaka Thaharate haiN| 42-agara nizIthasUtrakojAnanevAlekohI vyAkhyAna bAMcanekA adhikArI mAnakara aura sAdhviyoMko vyAkhyAna bAMcanekA sarvathA niSedha kiyAjAvetoyaha bhI bahuta anucita hai, kyoMki dekho-jainazAsana syAdvAda anekAnta hai, usameM ekAnta haThahI nahIM ho sakatA, dekhiye-gaucarI jAnA, vyAkhyAna denA, ityAdi aneka bAtoM ko mukhya vRttise gItArthoM ke lie AzA hai, parantu isase inabAtoMkA anya sarva sAdhuoMke lie niSedha nahIM bana sakatA abhIye bAteM sAmAnya sAdhu

Page #44
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH bhI karate haiM, aura jisa prakAra sAdhuoM ke lie yogavahana karake sUtra vAMcanekA tathA upadhAna vahana karake zrAvakoMko navakAra maMtra Adi sUtra paDhanekA mukhyavRttise kahA gayA hai to bhI abhI bahuta sAdhu yoga vahana kiye binAhI sUtra paDhate haiM / aura upadhA na kiye binA aneka zrAvakazrAvikArye navakAra maMtra par3hatI haiM, aura kalpasUtra bhI rAtri ke samaya vArSika pratikramaNa kiye bAda 'kAusagga' dhyAna meM sarva sAdhuoM ko sunane kI mukhya vidhi thI, eka sAdhu saba ko sunAtA thA, parantu Ajakala (abhI ) lAbha ke kAraNa dezakAla ke anusAra pratyeka gA~va meM sarva saMgha samakSa " kalpasUtra " bAMcA jAtA hai / isI taraha se yadyapi nizIthasUtra ko jAnane vAle gItArtha sAdhu ko vyAkhyAna vAMcane kA mukhyavRtti se kahA gayA hai parantu dezakAla ke anusAra lAbha ke lie isa samaya sAmAnya sAdhu-sAdhviyoM bhI vyAkhyAna bAMca sakatI haiM, isameM koI doSa nahIM hai, isalie isameM ekAnta haTha karanA ucita nahIM hai / 30 43 - jo mahAzaya kahate haiM ki-jIvAnuzAsana kI vRtti zrIjinadattasUrijI ne saMzodhana kI hai, usameM sAdhvI ko vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA niSedha kiyA hai, ye jinadattasUrijI kharataragacchavAloM ke dAdAjI hote haiM, unakA vacana kharataragacchavAloM ko pramANa karanA cAhiye, aisA kahanevAle pratyakSa mithyAvAdI haiM, kyoMki yaha vRtti 1962 meM banI hai aura kharataragaccha ke dAdAjI ko 1966 meM " sUripada " milA hai| isalie ye donoM jinadattasUrijI bhinna bhinna haiM aura vRtti saMzodhana karanevAle jinadattasUri ke lie "saptagRha nivAsI " aisA vizeSaNa TIkAkAra ne likhA hai, isalie yaha jinadattasUrijI dUsare haiM aura ve jinadattasUrijI dUsare haiM, jinadattasUrijI nAma ke aneka zrAcArya huye haiN| isalie vRttikA pATha dekhe binA yA dUsaroM ke kahane mAtra se aMdha paraMparA se dAdAjI kA nAma lekara bhole jIvoM ko bhrama meM DAlanA ucita nahIM hai aura granthakAra vRttikAra ne tathA vRtti saMzodhana karanevAloM ne zuddha saMyamI sAdhvI ke vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA niSedha kiyA hI nahIM hai| isakA vizeSa khulAsA Upara likha cuke haiM / 44 - jo mahAzaya sAdhviyoM ko nizIthasUtra paDhane kA niSedha samajhe baiThe haiM ve bhI bhUla karate haiM, sAdhviyoM ko nizIthasUtra paDhane kA niSedha kisI bhI zAstra meM dekhane meM nahIM AyA, isalie sAdhviyA~ nizIthasUtra ko paDha sakatI haiM, kisa kisa kArya karane se saMyama dharma meM kyA kyA doSa lagate haiM, tathA pranAdavaza ajJAnatA se koI doSa laga jAve usakA kitanA kitanA aura kyA kyA prAyazcita AtA hai ityAdi bAtoM kI jAnakArI "nizIthasUtra " paDhe binA nahIM ho sakatI, aura una donoM kA bacAvapUrvaka zuddha saMyama bhI tabhI pAlA jA sakegA, java ki - " nizIthasUtra " paDha liyA jAvegA / isalie buddhimatI jJAnI saMyamI sAdhviyoM ko guru se apanI yogyatA anusAra " nizIthasUtra " avazya paDhanA caahiye| isI jIvAnuzAsana kI 184 nambara kI gAthA jo Upara batalAI gaI hai, usakA bhAvArtha vicArakara samajhane vAle koI bhI mahAzaya sAdhviyoM ko nizIthasUtra paDhane kA niSedha nahIM kara skte| kyoMki

Page #45
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH 33 binaya bhakti karegI / sAdhviyoM meM vizeSa paDhAI na hone se ajJAnatA ke kAraNa abhimAna hotA hai aura usase ucita vinaya, viveka buddhi bhI nahIM hotI, jisase hI anapaDha sAdhviyoM meM vizeSa karake vinaya bhakti kA vyavahAra kama dikhAI detA hai ataH sAdhvI samudAya meM vizeSa paDhAI karane kI adhika AvazyakatA hai / zAna vRddhi hone para sad-viveka AvegA, jisase apanA aura dUsaroM kA upakAra acchI taraha se ho sakegA / jisa samudAya meM sAdhviyoM meM vizeSa paDhAI karane kA pracAra adhika hotA hai / usa samudAya kA saMpa bhI acchA rahatA hai, vyAkhyAna Adi bhI hajAroM logoMke samudAya meM bAMca sakatI haiM dharmopadeza dvArA aneka jIvoM ko dharma kAryoM meM pravRti karAtI haiN| jisa samudAya meM paDhAI kA pracAra adhika hogA usa samudAya meM vinaya viveka, laghutA Adi pratyeka guNoM kI vRddhi hogI, jisa samudAya meM paDhAI kA pracAra adhika nahIM hogA, usaM samudAya kI sAdhviyA~ nindA vikathA pramAda Adi karma bandhana ke kAryoM meM apanA aura dUsaroM kA samaya barabAda kareMgI jisase na to apanA AtmakalyANa hogA aura na dUsaroM kI AtmA kA paropakAra bhI ho sakegA jo loga sAdhviyoM ko adhika paDhane kA virodha karake zAna kI antarAya karate haiM unhoMko jhAnAvarNIya karmoM kA baMdha hogA isalie sAdhviyoM ko par3hane se rokanA ucita nahIM hai| 50-agara kahA jAya ki sAdhiyA~ vyAkhyAna yAMcane laga jAveMgI to sAdhuoM kI avajJA hogI, yaha ma kevala bhrama hai, kyoMki dekho-kabhI koI gurU sAdhAraNa buddhivAlA hotA hai aura unakA ziSya adhika buddhivAlA zAstroM kA jJAtA-gItArtha banatA hai, yogyatA prApta hone se gurU aura saMgha milakara unako AcArya banAte haiM, vehI AcArya hajAroM logoM ko dharmopa. deza dvArA pratibodha dete haiM, jisase unakI aura unake dIkSAguru kI zobhA hotI hai parantu guru kI avajJA kamI nahIM ho sakatI isahI taraha se yadi par3hI likhI viduSI sAdhvI vyAkhyAna bAMcakara gA~va gA~va meM logoM ko pratibodha dekara dharma kI prabhAvanA kareMgI to usase sAdhu kI avakSA kamI nahIM hogI kintu yaDI zobhA hogI ; loga kaheMge amuka samudAya meM sAdhviyeM kaisI buddhivAlI acchI par3hI likhI haiM aura kaisA acchA vyAkhyAna bAMcatI haiM, kaisA 2 upakAra karatI haiM, dhanya hai usa samudAya ko ki jisameM aisI 2 sAdhviyA~ bhI maujUda hai isa prakAra vyAkhyAna yAMcane meM sAdhuoM kI pravakSA nahIM aura na kisI prakAra dharma kI hAni hI hai ! kintu mahAna zobhA aura lAbha kA kArya hai| ___ itanI bAta avazya hai ki jisa gA~va meM zuddha AcArapAlA sAdhu maujUda ho vahA~ para sAdhvayoM ko vyAkhyAna bAMcanA ucita nahIM, parantu baDe zaharoM meM vizAla jaina samudAya meM sAdhu sAdhviyoM ke aneka upAzraya ho vahA~ para sAdhu hone para bhI yadi zrotAoM kI bhAvanA hoto vahA~ para sAdhviyA~ vyAkhyAna bAMce to koI hAni nahIM aura gA~voM meM bhI agara koI sAdhu bhraSTAcArI hone para sAdhvI vyAkhyAna yAMce to bAMca sakatI haiM, isase puruSa pradhAna dharma meM koI hAni nahIM haiN|

Page #46
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH 51-agara koI kahe ki chaH cheda aura caudaha pUrva paDhane kI sAdo ko manAI hai, to phira sAdhvI vyAkhyAna kaise bAMca sakatI hai / yaha kahanA bhI anucita hai kyoMki-cha cheda aura caudaha pUrva Adi paDhane kI to sAmAnya sAdhu ko bhI ganAI hai, unakA paDhanA yogyatAnasAra hotA hai para vyAkhyAna to sAmAnya sAdha bhI bAMca sakatA hai, usa prakAra sAdhvI bhI vyAkhyAna bAMca sakatI hai| kahIM kahI aisA bhI dekhA jAtA hai ki koI bahuta vidvAna hone para bhI bhaprAvazAlI upadeza nahIM de sakate haiM aura kaI alpa paDhe hue bhI acchA prabhAvazAlI' upadeza de sakate haiM. isalie paDhane kI bAta batalAkara upadeza dene kI manAI karanA ucita nahIM haiM, sAdhviyA~ kevala jJAna prAptakara asanta jIvoM kA uddhAra karake mokSa meM jAtI haiN| usa bAta ko samajhanevAle koI bhI buddhimAna vyAkhyAna bAMcane kI manAI kabhI nahIM kara sakate / 52-agara koI kahe ki-sAdhvI ko saMskRta paDhane kI manAI hai, aura sUtroM kI TIkA saMskRta meM hai| isalie saMskRta paDhe binA TIkA samajha meM nahIM AsakatI, to phira vyAkhyAna kaise bAMca sakatI hai| yaha kathana bhI ucita nahIM, sAdhvI ko saMskRta paDhane kI manAI kisI bhI zAstra meM nahIM hai, yaha to anasamajha logoM ne haThAgraha ke vaza meM pratyakSa mithyA bAta kA prapaMca phailAyA hai, abhI vartamAna meM tapagaccha kI hI sAdhviyA~, laghuzAMti, vRhadazAMti,bhaktAmara, snAtasyA aura sakalA'hat Adi aneka stotra stuti paDhatI haiM tathA abhI kucha varSa pahileM AgamoM kI bAMcanA ke samaya meM sAdhuoM ke sAtha sAtha hI sAdhviyoM ko bhI, khAsa AnandasAgarajI (sAgarAnanda sUrijI) ne sUtroM kI TIkA baMcAI hai| aura jaba ki gyAraha aMgo ko paDhane kI sAdhviyoM ko prAkSA hai, to phira usakI vyAkhyA paDhane kA niSedha kaise ho sakatA hai|? kabhI nahIM ? gyAraha aMgoM kI taraha unakI vyAkhyA rUpa artha bhI paDhane kI sAdhvI ko bhagavAna kI AzA hai / ataeva sUtroM kI saMskRta TIkA tathA sUtroM ko sAdhvI vyAkhyAna meM bAMca sakatI hai| ___53-kaI mahAzaya-caudahapUrvo ko saMskRta bhASA meM jAnakara sAdhviyoM ko pUrva paDhane kI manAI samajhate haiM, yaha bhI unakI bhUla hai, kyoMki saMskRta bhASA ke stotra caritra aura sUtroM kI TIkA Adi sAdhviyA~ paDhatI haiM, yaha bAta sarva gacchoM meM saba sAdhuoM ko bhI mAnya haiM isalie saMskRta bhASA meM pUrva hone se sAdhviyA~, pUrvo kI paDhAI nahIM kara sakatIM, yaha bAta nahIM hai kintu pUrSoM meM maMtra taMtra yaMtra aura vanaspati Adi kI apUrva zakti aura aneka prabhAva zAlI divya vastuoM kA saMgraha tathA anya bhI aneka gambhIra viSayoM kA pratipAdana hone se sAmAnya sAdhu sAdhviyoM ko paDhane kI manAI ho sakatI hai| aura pratikramaNa meM " namo'stu varddhamAnAya" nahIM paDhatI jisakA kAraNa bhI saMskRta bhASA kA nahIM kintu usakA uccAraNa "bAla vRddha maMdabuddhivAlI striyA~ (sAdhviyA~) spaSTa rUpa se nahIM kara sakatIM aura "saMsAra dAvA" saba ke sukha se uccAraNahosake isalie "saMsAra dAvA" bolatI hai| aura bhI dekhiye

Page #47
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH 35 chacheda grantha prAkRta bhASAmeM hone parabhI unameM utsarga apavAda vidhivAda aura caritAnuvAda mAdi aneka gambhIra viSayoM kA saMgraha hone se aura kaI bAtoM kA bhAvArtha, guru gamya hone se sAmAnya buddhivAle sAdhu sAdhviyoM ko paDhane kI manAI kI gaI hai| parantu nizItha satra zrAdi cheda-sUba mahattarA ko (baDI sAdhvI ko) paDhane kI AzA bhI hai, isalie saMskRtabhASA sAdhviyA~ mA paDha sakatI aisA kahanA anucita hai, aura "saMsAra dAvA" sama saMsthata prAkRta hai isalie kevala prAkRta kAhanA ajJAnatA hai, caudaha pUrva aura cheda prAza paDhane kA bahAnA lekara dharmopadeza kA niSedha karanA ucita nahIM hai . ___54-agara kahA jAya ki sAdhvI zrAphaka zrAvikAoM kI sabhA meM vyAkhyAna bAMdhegI, taba zrAvakoM ke sAmane dekhAnAgA , sAmane dekhane se brahmacarya kI bATa kA bhaMga hogA aura mohabhAva utpanna hokara bhaviSya rahmacarya kI hAni hone kI saMbhAvanA hogI isalie sAdhvI ko sabhA meM vyAkhyAna bAMcanA yogya nhiiN| aisA kahanevAle jaina siddhAntoM kI syAhAda-anekAnta zailI ko samajhanevAle nahIM mAluma hote haiN| kyoMki mohabhAva se sAdhvI ko puruSoM ke sAmane dekhane kI manAI hai| parantu upakAra buddhi se saMsAra kI, zarIra kI, kuTumba kI, dhanasampadA kI aura AyaSya Adi kI anityatA azAradA batalAte hae. dharmopadeza dete sama sAmAnyatayA karuNA buddhi se yadi pRruSoM ke sAmane dekhA bhI jAve lo koI doSa nahIM aasktaa| dekhiye-dazavaikAlika sUtra ke AThaveM adhyayana kI 81vIM gAthA meM likhA hai jisa taraha sUrya ke Upara dRSTi paDane para tatkAla pIchI khIMca lete haiM usahI taraha se sAdhu kI yadi strI ke Upara dRSTi paDa jAve to zIghra pIchI khIMca lenI cAhie, jisapara bhI sAdhu ko striyoM ke vrata pazcakkhANa Adi karavAte samaya strI ke sAmane dekhanA paDatA hai| to bhI mohabhAva na hone se kisI prakAra kA nukasAna nahIM ho sakatA, parantu rAgabhAva se sApo dekhane kA niSedha hai| phira bhI dekhiye-abhI paDhI likhI cidupI sAdhvI ke pAsa meM kucha zrAvaka milakara kitI prakAra kA prazna pUchane ke lie yA dharma kI carcA karane ke lie jAte haiM aura sAdhviyA~ mI unheM apanI buddhi ke anusAra samAdhAna bhI karatI haiM-dharmopadeza detI haiN| isahI taraha se sAdhviyoM ke pAsa meM zrAvaka zrAvikAyeM vyAkhyAna sunane ko jAsakate haiM, isameM koI doSa nahIM hai| 55-dUsarI bAta yaha hai ki, karmagrantha meM puruSa veda kA udaya ghAsa kI agni ke samAna tathA strI veda kA udaya chAnoM kI agni (bhobhara) ke samAna aura napuMsaka veda kA udaya nagara dAha kI agni ke samAna kahA hai, aba yahA~ para vicAra karane kA avasara hai ki zAstra ke anuH sAra veda ke udaya mUjaba vikAra bhAva paidA hone meM striyoM se bhI puruSoM meM dhairyatA kama sAvita hotI hai, isase jaba sAdhu vyAkhyAna bAMcatA ho usa samaya striyA~ vastra AbhUSaNAdi zraMgAra sajakara jevara kA jhanakAra karatI huI aura vinaya bhAva kA laTakA karatI huI vyAkhyAna meM AtI haiM usako dekhate hI sAdhu kA bhI citta calAyamAna ho AvegA, taba to Apake kathanA.

Page #48
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH nusAra sAdhu ko bhI vyAkhyAna nahIM yAMcanA cAhiye / parantu aisI mithyAtva ko baDhAnevAlI, mithyA bhrama janaka kalpanA sarthaza bhagavAna kI prAzA pAlana karanevAloM ke mana se kabhI nahIM uTha sakatI para karuNA buddhi se saMsAra dAvAnala meM jalate hue aura roga, zoka viyoga Adi dukhoM se ArtadhyAna karate hue prANiyoM ko uddhAra karane kI bhAvanA se zAnta rasa maya vairAgya utpanna karanevAlA sarvaza bhASita dharmopadeza kA vyAkhyAna calatA ho, usa samaya cAhe sAdhu ho yA sAdhvI ho apane putra putrI ke tulya bhAvaka zrAvikAyeM bhagavAna kI vANI sunane ko sAmane baiThe hoM unhoM ke sAmane sAmanyatayA udAsInabhAva se dekhane meM Ave to usa samaya vikArabhAva kA prasaMga nahIM hai| aise avasara para vikArabhAva nahIM ho sakatA hai, isalie vikArabhASa hone kA bahAnA lekara sAdhvImAtra ko hI vyAkhyAna yAMcane kA hI niSedha karane rUpa bhrama phailAnevAle bar3e ajJAnI Thaharate haiN| 56-phira bhI dekhiye- agara sabhA meM sAmAnyatayA sAmane dekhane se hI vikArabhAva paidA hotA ho taba to khAsa bhagavAna ke sAmane samavasaraNa meM hI gautamasvAmI Adi sAdhu sAdhviyoM ko dikhAne ke lie hI indrAdi deva vairAgyamaya aneka taraha kA nATaka karate haiM yahA~ para divya manohara aneka strI puruSoM ke rUpa sAdhu sAdhviyoM ke dekhane meM Ate haiM, to mI sabako vikArabhAva hone kA kabhI nahIM kaha sakate / isI taraha se sAdhvI mI vyAkhyAna samaya sAmAnyatayA puruSoM ke sAmane nirvikArabhAva se dekha leveM to usameM vikArabhAva utpanna hone kA saba ko kabhI nahIM kaha sakate haiN| 57-agara kahA jAya ki-amuka gA~va meM eka amuka sAdhvI vyAkhyAna bAMcatI thI, eka bhASaka ke sAtha usakA ati paricaya hogayA vaha zrAvaka bhI usa sAdhvI ke pAsa bArapAra akelA jAne lagA Apasa meM mohabhAva se bigADa hokara dharma kI bahuta hAni huI isalie sAdhvI ko vyAkhyAna bAMcalA ucita nahIM hai, aisA kahakara saba sAdhviyoM ko vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA niSeSa karanA bar3I bhUla hai| sAdhvI ne zrAvaka ke sAtha vAle paricaya kiyA jisase isa prakAra nukasAna huA / parantu samudAya meM vyAkhyAna bAMca se kisI prakAra kA nukasAna nahIM ho sakatA dekhiye-kisI sAdhu ke pAsa meM koI bhAvikA vandanA karane ko AtI ho aura sAdhu usa bhAvikA ke ghara meM zrahAra pAnI aAde ke lie bArambAra jAtA ho aisI dazA meM kamI prati paricaya hokara modabhAva se brahmacarya kI hAni ho jAya athavA sarvathA dharmabhraSTha hojAve, to usake karma kI gati parantu usa eka kA dRSTAnta batalAkara saba zrAvikAoM ko guru mahArAja ke pAsa meM vandanA karane ko Ane kA aura saba sAdhuoM ko zrAvikAoM ke paroM meM pAhAra pAnI Adi ke lie jAne kA niSedha kabhI nahIM ho sakatA isalie akelI sAdhvI kA iSTAnsa batalAkara ke samudAya meM saba sAdhviyoM ke vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA niSedha karanA sarvathA anucita hai

Page #49
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH 58-phira bhI dekhiye-jisake mana meM jaisA bhAva bharA rahatA hai vaha hara bahAne hareka prasaMga para usakI ceSTA karake apane manogata bhAva ko prakAzita kara detA hai, usako buddhimAna marmajJa loga usakI ceSTA se usake manogata bhAvanA ko samajha lete haiM / isahI taraha sAdhvI vyAkhyAna bAMcegI to logoM ke sAmane dekhane para vikAra bhAva paidA hogaa| aisA bAraMbAra kahanevAloM ko hI vikArI bhAvavAle samajhane caahiye| kyoMki jisane apanI AtmA ke kalyANa ke lie saMsArI mAyA choDakara paMca mahAvrata liye haiM tathA dUsaroM kA uddhAra karane kI jisake mana meM hamezA vairAgya bhAvanA lagI rahatI hai vaha sAdhvI vyAkhyAna samaya sAmAnyatayA nirvikAra bhAva se upakAra buddhi se hita zikSA detI huI puruSoM ke sAmane dekha bhI le to bhI kisI prakAra kA vikAra bhAva paidA nahIM ho sakatA hai, parantu jisake mana meM vikAra bhAva bharA rahatA hai vaha saba meM apane jaisA vikAra bhAva dekhatA hai, usake karma kI gati unake kahane likhane yA bArambAra bakavAda karane para bhI kucha nahIM ho sakatA hai, parantu aisA karake sAdhvI samAja para mithyA Aropa lagAne se durlabha bodhi-anaMta saMsAra vRddhi ke karma avazya hI bAMdhege / kyoMki siddhaprAbhRta, nandI sUtra kI TIkA Adi aneka zAstroM ke pramANa hama Upara batA cuke haiM, unhoM meM jJAnI pUrvAcAryoM ne zrAvaka zrAvikAoM ke sAmane sAdhviyoM ko dharmopadeza dene kI AjJA dI hai, isalie aisI kuyuktiyA~ karanevAle ajJAnI Thaharate haiM, kisI eka vyaktigata kA dRSTAnta saba ke Upara lAgU nahIM ho sakatA hai| 56-agara kahA jAya ki-kisI sAdhvI ko kevala jJAna prApta ho jAya to usako chadamastha sAdhu vandanA nahIM karate haiM, to phira sAdhvI vyAkhyAna kaise bAMca sakatI hai ? aisA kahakara jo mahAzaya sAdhviyoM ko vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA niSedha karate haiM unakA bar3A hI anucita haThAgraha hai kyoMki-vaMdanA karanA alaga viSaya hai aura vyAkhyAna bAMcanA alaga viSaya hai, dekhiye-jaina zAstroM meM muNoM kI pUjA hai parantu vyakti kI nahIM / "muNAH sarvatra pUjyante, na ca jAti na ca vayaH" isa prakAra saba jagaha guNoM kI pUjA hotI hai| isalie agara sAdhvI ko kevala jJAna aura kevala darzana prApta ho jAve to vaha saba ke bhAva se vandanIya pUjanIya avazya hai / aura unase apanA saMdeha bhI pUcha sakate haiM parantu sirpha ajJAnI logoM ke (vyavahAra viruddha) saMzaya kA kAraNa na hone ke lie dravya se paMcAMga namAkara vandanA karane kA vyavahAra sAdhu kA nahIM hai, parantu kevala jJAnI sAdhvI yA anya chamastha sAdhvI dezanA detI ho to usako vidyAdhara devatA aura zrAvaka zrAvikA Adi sunakara lAbha uThA sakate haiM / isameM kisI prakAra kA doSa nahIM hai isalie sAdhu ke dravya se vyavahArika vandanA karane kI bAta batalAkara dharmadezanA dene kA niSedha karanA sarvathA anucita hai| phira bhI dekhiye-yahA~ para Apako pratyakSa pramANa batalAtA hUM ki-jisa taraha apana loga "namo loe savva sAhaNaM,, kahakara paMca mahA bratadhArI darzana jJAna cAritra se mukti kA sAdhana karanevAle saba sAdhuoM ko hamezA

Page #50
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH hI anekavAra vandanA karate haiN| isameM paMca mahAvratadhArI apane se dIkSA meM choTe saba sAdhuoM ko bhAva se vandanA hotI hai| paMca mahAvratadhArI saba sAdhu vandanIya pUjyanIya avazya hI haiM, parantu apane se dIkSA meM choTe hoM unhoMko vyavahAra se paMcAGga namAkara dravya vandanA karane kA vyavahAra nahIM hai / isahI taraha se mahAvratadhArI saMyamI chadmastha sAdhvI ho yA kevala jJAnI sAdhvI ho guNoM kI dRSTi se vaMdanIya pUjyanIya avazya hI hai| isalie sAdhuoM ke vandanA kI vyavahArika bAta ko Age karake zrAvaka zrAvikAoM kI sabhA meM sAdhvI ko vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA niSedha karanA bhUla hai / 38 60 -- agara kahA jAya ki - sAdhvI ko AhAraka labdhi nahIM hotI to phira sAdhvI vyAkhyAna kaise baca sakatI hai| aisA kahanevAloM ko sAdhviyoM ke vyAkhyAna bAMcane ke Upara bar3A hI dveSa mAlUma hotA hai| kyoMki sAdhvI agara virAdhaka hokara aneka prakAra ke duSTa karma kare to bhI AyuH pUrNa karake sAtavIM naraka meM nahIM jA sakatI aura zuddha saMyama pAlana karatI huI utkRSTa zuddha adhyavazAya se guNaThANoM meM caDhakara zukla dhyAna se ghanaghAtI karma kSaya karake kevala jJAna prApta karake mukti meM jAsakatI haiN| isalie AhAraka labdhi na ho to bhI vyAkhyAna bAMcakara paropakAra karane meM kisI prakAra kI bAdhA nahIM sakatI / aisI 2 kuyuktiyeM karane para bhI sAdhvI ko vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA niSedha nahIM ho sakatA / parantu jina manuSyoM ko apane svArthavaza dUsaroM se dveSa ho jAtA hai taba satyAasatya kA vicAra kiye binA hI dUsaroM ke avaguNa kahane laga jAte haiN| isahI prakAra kaI sAdhu logoM ke aura una sAdhu logoM ke dRSTi rAgI pakSapAtI zrAvakoM ke bhI sAdhviyoM ke vyAkhyAna para antara kA pUrNa dveSa hogayA hai, jisase saMyamI sAdhvI ke jJAna guNoMkoM aura unake vyAkhyAna Adi se honevAle zAsanahita, paropakAra, jIvadayA, vrata pazJcakkhANa, samyaktva prApti Adi aneka dharmakAryoM ke lAbha ko na dekhate hue kevala vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA niSedha karane kI hI durbuddhi huI hai| isalie AhAraka labdhi Adi binA prasaGga kI bAteM batalAkara viSayAMtara karake bholejIvoMko bhrama meM DAlate haiM / 61-agara kahA jAya ki "bRhatkalpa" sUtra meM likhA hai ki- jisa makAna meM sAdhvI ThaharI ho yadi usa makAna kA daravAjA khulA ho to usake Age eka paDadA daravAje ke phATaka para bAMdha denA cAhie, jisase dUsare puruSoM kI dRSTi sAdhvI para na paDa ske| jaba sAdhviyoM ke lie isa prakAra kA niyama hai to phira sAdhviyA~ zrAvaka zrAvikAoM ke samudAya meM vyAkhyAna kaise bAMca sakatI haiM ? isa prakAra zaMkA karanevAle jaina zAstroM ke ati gaMbhIra bhAvArtha ko nahIM jAnane vAle mAlUma hote haiM kyoMki dekhiye - sAdhviyA~ AhAra karatI ho athavA paDilehana Adi karatI ho usa samaya kisI prakAra kA kucha aMga khulA ho aisI dazA meM anya puruSa kI dRSTi paDanA anucita hai / athavA anya matavAloM kI dRSTi bacAne ke lie aura apane svAdhyAya dhyAna Adi dhArmika kAryoM meM kisI prakAra kI bAdhA na hone ke hetu khule daravAje

Page #51
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH ke Upara kapaDA bAMdhane kI AzA hai| kintu jaba sAdhviyA~ vyAkhyAna bAMcatI hai taba to upayoga pUrvaka apanA zarIra vastra se Dhake rahatI haiM, aura sunanevAle bhI aneka manuSya hote haiN| isalie khule daravAje para kapaDA bAMdhane kI bAta batalAkara vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA niSedha karanA sarvathA anucita hai| apane Thaharane ke sthAnoM meM to cAhe jaise phaTe purAne maile tathA choTe vastra pahanakara bhI sAdhviyA~ baiTha sakatI haiM / kintu AhAra-pAnI, vihAra, vyAkhyAna, mandira aura sthaMDila Adi ke lie pUrA vastra oDhakara zarIra ko sarvAGga Dhakakara hI bAhara jAnA par3atA hai isase kisI prakAra kI beadabI nahIM ho sakatI / isalie upayoga pUrvaka vyAkhyAna vAMcane meM kisI bhI prakAra kA doSa nahIM A sakatA hai| 62-agara kahA jAya ki-kisI kAraNavaza sAdhu yA zrAvaka ko sAdhviyoM ke upAzraya meM jAne kA kArya ho to bAhara daravAje se hI khuMkhAra Adi AvAja dekara ke upAzraya meM jAnA kalpatA hai / jaba sAdhdhiyoM ke upAzraya meM jAne ke lie puruSoM kI aisI maryAdA hai to phira sAdhviyoM ke upAzraya meM jAkara zrAvaka kaise vyAkhyAna suna sakate haiM,? yaha kathana bhI ucita nahIM, sAdhviyoM ke upAzraya meM puruSoM ko khuMkhAra AvAja karane kI isalie maryAdA hai ki sAdhviyA~ apane kArya meM khule aMga Adi hoM to khuMkhAra yA AvAja sunakara vastra oDha leM, apanA aMga khulA huA Dhakale, apanI maryAdA pUrvaka sAvadhAna hokara baiTheM jisase kisI prakAra kI amaryAdA yA lajA bhaMga na hone pAveM, parantu vyAkhyAna sunane ke liye to niyata samaya para zrAvaka zrAvikA aneka jana sAtha meM Ate haiM, jisase sAdhviyA~ pahile se hI sAvadhAna rahatI haiM isalie zrAvakoM ko vyAkhyAna sunane ke lie sAdhviyoM ke upAzraya meM Ane meM koI hAni nahIM hai| 63-yadi kahA jAya ki sAdhviyA~ kalpasUtra kA yoga vahana nahIM karatI isalie paryuSaNA ke vyAkhyAna meM sAdhviyoM ko kalpasUtra kA vyAkhyAna nahIM bAMcanA caahiye| aisA kaha kara sAdhviyoM ko paryuSaNA meM kalpasUtra bAMcane kA niSedha karanevAloM ke hI gaccha meM, samudAya meM, AcArya, upAdhyAya Adi saiMkar3oM sAdhu yoga kiye binAhI kalpasUtra bAMcate haiM, unhoM ko to manAI karate nahIM tathA khuda Apa bhI yoga kiye binA hI pratyeka varSa meM kalpasUtra bAMcate haiM / aura sAdhviyoM ke liye yoga bahana karane kA bahAnA lekara bAMcane kA niSedha karanA yaha kitanA bar3A bhArI anyAya hai, jo mahAzaya apane nijakA aura AcArya, upAdhyAya, pravartaka Adi muniyoM ko paryuSaNa parva meM kalpasUtra bAMcane kA niSedhakara sakate nahIM aura kaI jagaha para paMcAzrava sevana karanevAle yati zrI pUjyoM ko bhI kalpasUtra bAMcane kA niSedhakara sakate nahIM, tathA apane gaccha ke zrAvaka zrAvikAoM ko yati zrI pUjyoM ke vyAkhyAna meM kalpasUtra sunane kA niSedha karate nahIM, aura antaradveSa ke mAre sAdhviyoM ko kalpasUtra bAMcane kA unakA niSedha karate haiM yaha kabhI nyAya nahIM kahA jA sktaa|

Page #52
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH 64-phira bhI dekhiye-zrI mahAnizIthasUtra Adi aneka zAstroM meM upadhAna vahana kiye binA zrAvaka-zrAvikoM ko navakAra maMtra paDhanA guNanA nahIM kalpatA aisI vidhi pratipAdita hai, parantu dravya, kSetra, kAla, bhAvAnusAra abhI vinA upadhAna vahana kiye lAkhoM zrAvaka-zrAvikAoM ko navakAra maMtra sAdhu sAdhvI sikhAyA karate haiM, yaha bAta prasiddha hI hai| isahI prakAra kalpasUtra bhI pahile to paryuSaNA kI rAtri meM saMvatsarI pratikramaNa kiye bAda sarva sAdhu kAussaga dhyAna meM sunate aura eka sAdhU saba ko sunAtA thA yaha vidhi thii| parantu Aja pratyeka gA~voM meM nagaroM meM prati varSa saya ke sAmane kalpasUtra bAMcane kI pravRti zurU hai| jisa nagara meM sAdhuoM kA caumAsA ho prAcArya upAdhyAya zrAdi padavIdhara maujUda hoM to bhI bar3e bar3e zaharoM meM bahuta jagaha yati zrI pUja Adi se bhI kalpasUtra baMcAte haiN| aisI dazA meM mahAvratadhArI par3hI likhI viduSI sAdhvI paryuSaNA ke vyAkhyAna meM kalpasUtra bAMcakara sunAve to isameM koI hAni nahIM / jisa para bhI jo mahAzaya zrAvaka-zrAvikoM ke sAmane sAdhvI ko vyAkhyAna bAMcane kA aura paryuSaNoM meM kalpasUtra bAMcane kA niSedha karate haiM vaha mahAzaya mithyA haThAgraha karate haiN| 65-agara kahA jAya ki jisa taraha se sAdhuoM ko jaba kevalajJAna hotA hai to devatA Akara utsava karate haiM aura svarNa kamala racate haiM usa para baiThakara kevalajJAnI dezanA dete haiM / isahI taraha se sAdhvI ko bhI kevalajJAna hove taba sAdhuoM kI taraha kevalajJAna kA mahotsava karane kA tathA svarNa kamala kI racanA karane kA aura usa svarNa kamala para kevalajJAnI sAdhvI baiThakara dharma dezanA dene kA kisI bhI zAstra meM dekhane meM nahIM aataa| to phira abhI sAdhviyA~ vyAkhyAna kaise bAMca sakatI haiM ? yaha kathana bhI anucita hai| kyoMki dekhiyejisa prakAra puruSa ke dIkSA lene ke samaya mahotsava hotA hai, usahI taraha strI ke bhI dIkSA lene ke samaya meM mahotsava hotA hai, yaha bAta "bhagavatI" "jJAtAjI," "antagaDa dazA" Adi aneka zAstroM ke pramANAnusAra jaina samAja meM prasiddha hai, jaba dIkSA lene ke samaya puruSa aura strI donoM ke lie apane 2 punyAnusAra mahotsava hone kA adhikAra hai candanavAlA Adi ke dIkSA samaya mahotsava hone kA kalpasUtra kI TIkAoM Adi zAstroM meM ullekha AtA hai taba dIkSA lie bAda utkRSTa tapa saMyama kI ArAdhanA karake kSapaka zreNI caDhakara zukla dhyAna se ghanaghAtI karmoM kA kSaya karake ananta jJAna, ananta darzana kI prApti kara leveM aisI mahAn zuddha nirmala pAtmA ke lie kevalajJAna kA mahotsava tathA dharma dezanA dene kA niSedha karanA koI bhI buddhimAna nahIM mAna sakatA aura sAdhu ho athavA sAdhvI ho unake liye kisI bAta kA mahotsava honA, devatA yA manuSyoM kA AnA, vaMdana-pUjana-mAna-satkAra kA honA ye bAteM apanI 2 puNya prakRti ke anusAra hotI haiM / aura kisI 2 muniyoM ke prANAMta upasarga ke samaya bhI koI devatA yA manuSya nahIM Ate, aura prANAnta hone para Ayu pUrNa karake devaloka

Page #53
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH . meM cale jAte haiM athavA koI kevalajJAna pAkara nirvANa prApta kara lete haiM / isalie sAdhuoM kI taraha sAdhviyoM ke kevalajJAna mahotsava hone kA yA dezanA dene kA niSedha kisI prakAra nahIM ho sktaa| jisa sAdhvI ke chadmastha avasthA meM athavA kevalI avasthA meM jitane 2 dezanA dene ke lie paropakArI bhASAvargaNA ke pudgaloM kA jitanA 2 baMdha paDA hogA unako bhogane ke lie (kSaya karane ke lie ) dezanA dekara paropakAra avazya kara sakatI haiM / yaha karma ke anusAra anAdi siddha niyama hai, isako koI bhI anyathA nahIM kara sktaa| 66-phira bhI dekhiye-gRhastha loga hara samaya, chaH kAya ke jIvoM kI virAdhanA karate hue 17, 18, pApasthAnoM kA sevana karake kuTumba, zarIra Adi kI moha mAyA se, krodhAdi kaSAyoM se aneka prakAra ke karma baMdhana karate rahate haiN| aisI dazA meM sAdhvIgaNa grAma nagara Adi meM vihAra karatI huI zrAvaka-zrAvikAoM ke samudAya meM jaba taka vyAkhyAna bAMcatI rahegI, taba taka bhavya jIvoM ke pUrvokta karma baMdhanoM ke kAraNoM se chuTakArA rahegA, aura bhagavAn kI vANI sunakara ve loga paramAnanda prApta kareMge, zubha dhyAna se aneka bhavoM ke azubha karmoM kA nAza hogA tathA sAdhvIgaNa kI dezanA se sAmAyika, pratikramaNa, pauSadha, dAna; zIla, tapa, bhAva, Adi zubha kAryoM se aneka prakAra kA lAbha prApta hogA aura kaI bhavya jIva vairAgya prAptakara gRhasthAzrama choDakara saMyama lekara apanA Atma kalyANa kareMge, isIliye siddha prAbhata Adi meM sAdhvI ke upadeza me paruSoM kA siddha honA likhA hai| isa prakAra sAdhvIgaNa ke vyAkhyAna se ananta lAbha hue haiM, hote haiM, aura Age bhI hote raheMge, aise saba jIvoM ke abhayadAna ke hetu Adi aneka lAbhoM kA vicAra kiye vinA anI tuccha buddhi ajJAnatAvaza sAdhvIgaNa kA vyAkhyAna niSedha karake uparokta pApa pravRti kA kAraNa aura dharma kAryoM kI antarAya karate haiM yaha sarvathA anucita hai| 67-kaI mahAzaya kahate haiM ki bhagavAna mahAvIra svAmI ke sAmane dIkSA dI huI, 36000 sAdhviyAM thI, unameM 1400 sAdhviyoM ko to kevalazAma hogayA thaa| ora anya sAdhviyAM bhI 11 aMga Adi Agama paDhI huI thI' parantu unameM se kisI ne bhI zrAvaka zrAvikAoM ke sAmane dezanA dI ho vyAkhyAna bAMcakara kisI ko pratibodha diyA ho, aisA kisI bhI zAstra meM likhA huvA dekhane meM nahIM AtA, to phira abhI kI sAdhviye vyAkhyAna kaise bAMca sakatI haiN| yaha kathana bhI anasamajhavAloM kA hI hai, kyoMki dekhiye-bhagavAna ke sAmane 36000 sAdhviye maujUda thI, aura lAkhoM zrAvaka vratadhArI maujUda the parantu kisI sAdhvI ko kisI bhI zrAvaka ne dAna diyA ho yA vastra pAtra kambalAdi vahorAye hoM aisA kisI bhI zAstra meM vyaktigata nAma lekara likhA huvA dekhane meM nahIM Ane para agara koI kutarka karegA ki-kisI zrAvaka ne kisI sAdhvI ko dAna nahIM diyA, aisA kahanevAle ko ajJAnI samajhA jAtA hai, kyoMki sAdhviyoM ko AhAra Adi denA, vastra pAtra kambalAdi vahorAnA zrAvakoM kA khAsa kartavya hai| agara bhagavAna ke sAmane kisI sAdhvI ko kisI dhAvaka ne AhArAdi

Page #54
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH dAna dene kA kisI vyaktigata nAma kA ullekha kisI zAstra meM na hone para bhI dAna dene kA mAnA jAtA hai isI prakAra paDhI likhI chadmastha sAdhvI ho yA kevalajJAnI sAdhvI ho unake paropakAra ke liye bhASAvargaNA ke pudgala baMdhe huve hoMge to vaha sAdhvI zrAvaka zrAvikAoM bhavya jIvoM ke sAmane avazya hI dezanA dekara paropakAra kara sakatI hai| kyoMki khAsa kevalazAnI tIrthakara bhagavAn ke hI jaba taka bhASAvargaNA ke pudgaloM kA baMdha rahatA hai taba taka hI dezanA dekara paropakAra kara sakate haiM, aura bhASAvargaNA ke pudgaloM kA kSaya hone para dezAnA baMdhakara dete haiM athavA anazana kara lete haiM / isI taraha se chamastha sAdhvI ho yA kevalI sAdhvI ho athavA sAdhu ho vA koI bhI saMsArI prANI ho jaba taka jisake bhASAvargaNA ke pudgaloM kA baMdha rahegA taba taka hI vaha bola sakatA hai, aura nikaTavAle hara koI prANI suna sakate haiM, isa bAta ko bhagavAn kI vANI para zraddhA rakhanevAlA koI bhI jainI niSedha nahIM kara sakatA, isI taraha se saMyamI par3hI likhI sAdhvI apane bhASAvargaNA ke pudgaloM ko kSaya karane ke liye dharmadezanA de sakatI hai aura koI bhI bhavyajIva unakI dezanA sunakara lAbha uThA sakate haiN| aba merA yahI kahanA hai ki bhagavAn ke zAsana meM kisI bhI sAdhvI ne vyAkhyAna nahIM bAMcA ! aisA kahane vAle pratyakSa mithyAvAdI haiM isa viSaya meM aneka zAstroM ke pramANa Upara vatalA cuke haiN| jaba ki-sAdhviyoM ko bAraha 12 prakAra kA tapAdhikAra meM 5 prakAra ke svAdhyAya karane kA gyAraha 11 aGga paDhane kA tathA Atma kalyANa ke sAtha bhavya jIvoM kA paropakAra karane kA pUrNatayA (saba taraha se) adhikAra hai usameM dezanA dene kA bhI adhikAra AjAtA hai, aura zrAvasyakAdi aneka zAstroM meM cattAri maMgalaM, arihaMtA maMgalaM, siddhA maMgalaM, sAhu maMgalaM, kevaliparaNatto dhammo maMgalaM cattAriloguttamA, arihaMtAloguttamA, siddhA loguttamA, sAhu loguttamA, kevalipaeNatto dhammo loguttamA / cattAri saraNaM pavajjAmi, arihaMte saraNaM pavajjAmi, siddhe zaraNaM pavajjAmi, sAhu saraNaM pavajjAmi, kevaliparaNataM dhamma saraNaM pavajjAmi // ye tIna gAthAnoM ke kathanAnusAra dharma kA hI AdhAra bhavya jIvoM ko hai, kevalI praNIta dharma maMgala rUpa hai, uttama hai, aura zaraNa aMgIkAra karane yogya haiM, aba vicAra karanA cAhiye ki- kevalI zabda meM sAdhu sAdhvI kA samAveza hotA hai, aura hareka tIrthakara ke zAsana meM sAdhuoM se prAyaH duguni sAdhviyAM kevalazAnI hotI hai / isaliye jisa kevalI sAdhvI ko maMgala rUpa, uttama aura usakA prarUpita dharma zaraNa karane yogya mAnA jAya jisase bhavya jIvoM kA saMsAra se uttIrNa honA mAnate haiM, isa vAste unakI dezanA bhI sunane yogya hai yaha bAta anAdi siddha hai / iti zubham / OM zAntiH zAntiH zAntiH zrI maNisAgarasUrijI ma0 AjJA se muni-vinayasAgara

Page #55
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH pariziSTa naM. 1 jo jo sAdhuoM ne apane Azrita sAdhviyoM ko vyAkhyAna bAMcanA niSedha karake jJAna vRddhi kI aMtarAya kI, unakI sAdhviyoM kI kaisI durdazA huI usakA digdarzana karAne vAlA 1 lekha jaina patra pu0 37 aMka 40 kA 16 // 10 // 38 kA vikram 1664 pAso vadi 8 ravivAra ko bhAvanagara se prakAzita huA vaha lekha nIce urddhata kiyA jAtA haisAdhvI saMsthA Aje samAja mATe koyar3A rUpe kema banI ? [ lekhikA-sAdhvI khAntizrIjI ] aAje keTalAye samaya thayA puruSa varge "strI" nI zakti, bala ane buddhi kevI rIte dabAvI dIdhI cha ? keTalI hade tene nIce utArI pAr3I che? temo jo ullekha karavA mAM Ave to moTuM eka pustaka thAya; parantu atyAre e vivecanaM nahIM karatA sAdhvI saMsthA tarapha lakSa khecAya ch| Aje sAdhviyo mAM ajJAna, kusaMpa, jhagar3A ane kuthalIao kema vadhI ? tenuM jarA nirIkSaNa karIe / __pahelA to gharanI aMdara striyo nai koI paNa prakAranI kelavaNI apAtI nathI / tenA mAM ucca saMskAra rer3AtA nathI / tethI gharanI aMdara kema vartavu ? te tenI samajha mAM hotuM nthii| kelavaNI nahIM pAmelI strio mAtA putrI, sAsU bahU, derANI jeThANI ane naNaMda bhojAI Apasa Apasa mAM lar3aQ kAma mATe huzA tuzI karavI eka bIjA para hukumo calAvavA-zrAvo vartAva cAlI rahyo hoya che| valI puruSoM nI bIka thI koI divasa sArUM pustaka vAcavU ke sadgurU no saMga karavo zreto ene hoya ja nhiiN| ene to gharanI cAra dIvAloM bacce rAta divasa purAI rahevAnu / jagatanI aMdara suM su cAlI rahyaM che ? duniyA kaI dizAe gamana karI rahI che ? ene bhAnaja na hoya, kema ke gharanA kAma mAthI e UMcI ja na Ave / zrAvI rIte tenI buddhi ane zakti ber3aphAi jAya che ane potArnu parAkrama phoravI zakatI nthii| . . kama bhAgye e bicArI vidhavA bane ane be barasa khuNo pAlavAnuM hoy| pachI vidhavA banelI te kahaMka dharma no Azraya le che| eTale ke gharanA kAma thI paravArI derAsare dazana karavA, gurU mahArAja nA darzana karavA ane pratikramaNa karavA vigere kriyA mA joDAya / tyAM ene sAdhvIjIo nA saMga thAya ane samajhAvavA mAM Ave ke bena ! tArA eka peTa mATe zA sArU pAkhA gharanoM dhaMdhoM kuTe che ? have tAre gharamA zuM rahya che nAhaka eTalA karma zA mATe bAMdhavA jopae ? 'cAla tUM mArI celI thA, tane kAma nahIM karavU par3e ane thArA AtmA no uddhAra kara , prA upadeza ra ajJAna bAInA hRdaya mAM vasI jAya / enA mana mA ema thAya che ke have mAre kAma nahIM kara par3e ne A ghara mAMthI chuttiish|

Page #56
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH 1 Ama amuka apavAda ne bAda karatA duHkha garbhita ke moha vairAgya thAyaH e e mArge javAM taiyAra thAya / ghara nA mAyalo samajhe ThIka thayuM / roTalA ApavA maTyA kAraNa Aje vidhavA ghara mAM pharatI hoya e sone mana kAlI nAgaNI bhAse che vidhavA Upara sitamo gujarAya che se atyAre lakhavA icchatI nathI / zrapaNe sAdhvI jIvana ja vicAravAnuM che / e bAI lAla kapar3A dUra karI dholA veza mAM AvI jAya che, arthAt parama pavitra bhAgavatI dIkSA ne grahaNa kare che / 4 pachI to ApaNe joie chIe ke sarva kAma no bojho ziSyAo Upara ja mUkAya che ane vaDIlo tarapha thI hukamo nI hAra mAlA to cAlU ja hoya / jema gRhasthAzrama mAM sAsU, sAsU pazu bhajave tema dIkSA mAM gurU, gurUpaNuM bhajave che / A zuM temanI ochI bhUla kahevAya ? alavata, gurU no vinaya karavo, temanI AjJA mAM khar3A page UbhA rahevuM, parantu te viSe temanI kadara hovI joie paNa Aje e badhuM visarAi gayuM che / pote to cAra pAMca bAionA gherA mAM besI gharo gharI paMcAta kUThe ane vikathAo mAM utarI potA nA samaya ne barabAda kare che / ziSyAo ne bhaNAvavAnI paNa jarUrata nahIM bheTale abhyAsa mAM paNa pachAta / paMca pratikramaNa karyA ne cAra ATha coDhAliyA, thor3A ka stavana sajjhAyo karyA paTale ber3A pAra / paNa hAM, kyA thI vadhe ? gurujIzro bhaNelI hoya tyAre ne ? ajJAnamaya jIvana prathama thI ja hatUM nai pAchala thI paNa tema thavA myuM / kalaha, IrSA - adekhAi, carasA carasI vigere dUSaNo jIvana mAM jar3a ghAlI rahela pahele thI ja hatA / tene dUra karavA, jIvana sundara banAvavA, tyAgI banAvanAra tyAgIo tarapha thI jarAye sUcanA ke samajhAvavA mAM Ayu nahIM / samayanI kaThinatA, AtmA kema ujvala bane ? jIvana su yazazvI ma thAya ? tenuM ene bhAnaja na karAvayuM / kAraNa ene to gharanA kAmamA thI mukta karavI hatI ane celInI lAlasA hatI te kAma to nahIMyAM paNa kara par3e che ! kaho, have enA mAM thI ajJAna, kalaha ane IrSA Adi doSo kaI rItie dUra thAya ? luMja nahIM paNa pU0 munirAjo nI upAdhi kaMda sAdhvI saMsthA mATe ochI nathI / teo prathama thI ja ' strIvarga ' ne dAsI tarIke gaNanA mAM devAi garalA dovA thI ane zAstra mAM thI ekAda dAkhalo ( jevo ke sau varSa nI dIkSita sAdhvI Aja nA dIkSita sAdhu ne vAMde) Agala dharI, sAdhvI saMsthA ne tucchagaNI potAnI tAbedArI mAM raheSA hakumata calAvavA himmata kare che / guru no vinaya karavAnA bAnA thI sAdhvIjIo pAse zrI, gRhastho nI jema munirAjo potAnA kapar3A dhovA, zroghA vaNavA pAThA bharavA, kAmalIo nI koro cItaracI, kapar3A sIbavA bhane pAtra raMgavAnA kAryo karAve che / jANe nokarar3Io rAkhI hoya tema eka pachI eka kAma te tarapha thI taiyAra ja hoya /

Page #57
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNaya: 45 monA svArthI hRdaya nI ajANa bicArI sarala sAdhvizra rakhene guruno avinaya thaI jAya, guru nArAja thaijAya zrema bItI mane ke kamane eo zrI nA kAryoM kare che / evA kAryoM sAvi nA pAse thI karAvayA pazuM sAdhuo ne ghaTita che ? AgalanA sAdhu sAdhvizra pAse dhI suM pa kAryo karAvatA hatA ? Agala baMdhI e tAraka gaNAtA guruno, sAdhvizro pratye AzA chor3e che ke - sAdhvizro zrI sUtra na paMcAya, vyAkhyAna na apAya / zrAvI rIta nI aTakAyata zrI sAdhvijIzro saMskRta mAgadhI abhyAsa karatAM aTakI jAya che / kAraNa jyAre sUtro na vAMcavA hoya ne vyAkhyAna na ApavuM hoya to evaM ucca jJAna melavI zuM kare ? Ama nirutsAha banI abhyAsa mAM jJAna mAM Agala vadhI zakatI nathI / valke saMyama nuM rahasya samajhavuM dUra rahI jAya che| meM ghaNI sAdhvIjIo nA mukha zrI sAMbhalyuM che ke - amone vyAkhyAna ane sUtro bAMcavAnI guru tarapha jJA nathI jethI vyAkhyAna sAMbhalavA gurunI sAthai ja caumAsA karIe chIe / jyAre pUchavA mAM Ave ke dara roja vyAkhyAna mAM jatA tyAre dukhI hRdaye javAba ApI kahe ke kAma na hoya to jahae | AdhI sAMbhalanAra ne Azcarya thayA binA nahIM rhe| zuM munIrAjo potAnA kAryoM karAvavA sAdhvina ne sAthe comAsuM karAtA haze ? zrAvA kAraNoM ne laI krame paricaya vadhato jAya che ane chevaTe ati paricaya nA yoge jaina zAsana ne lajavanArI gaMdI bAto bahAra Atreche / haju paNa pUjya muni mahArAjo samajhe ane sAdhvio upara thI potAnA kAryo no bojo utAre temaja vyAkhyAna bhane sUtra bAMdhavAnI chUTa Ape, abhyAsa vadhAravA khAza bhalAmaNa kare to Aja nuM vAtAvaraNa ( ajJAna, kusaMpa, kalaha kuthala vigere ) pharIjatAM vAra lAgaze nhiiN| pachI samAja joI zakaze ke sAdhvI saMsthA keTalaM kArya karI zake che ane samAja ne kevI upayogI thAya che AgalanI mahAsatI ziromaNi sAdhvIjIzro jJAna meM vadhelI hovA thI caritra dhI bhraSTa yatA moTA RSizro ne paNa sadbodha thI mArga Upara lAvI zakyA che evA aneka dAkhalAo maujUda che / te Aje koI nA thI ajArAyuM nathI / te zakti Aja paNa nAza pAmI nthii| jo tene puratI sagavar3o karI devA mAM Ave to nisteja banelI zakti sateja bane mAM kAMI Azcarya nathI / Aja zrAvako paNa sAdhutro nA bharamAnyA thI jema ke puruSa pada pradhAna che meM strI nIcI ve tethI sAdhviyo pratye bahUja zrochI lAgaNI dharAve che / temanA vyAkhyAna zravaNa thI paNa zrAvako abhar3AI jAya che| kha pUcho to to sAdhvI jI pratye bhAgyeja koI pUjya bhAva dharAvatA haze / sAdhuo ne bhaNAvavA mAThe sau sau rupayA nA pagAradAra paMDito tyAre sAdhvibho mATe pAMcano e nahIM / prAzuM ochI saMkucita dRSTi kaddevAya / hajU pa zrAvako cete ane sAdhviyo ne bahumAna nI dRSTi thI jue / sAdhvIjIzro mA caumAlA alaga karAve ane temane abhyAsa mATe puratI kre| jo sAdhvI saMsthA sudharaze to jarUra strI

Page #58
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH / varga sudharavAno saMbhava rahe / tenI prajA paNa bA hoza banaze jo Ama thAya to kharekhara bhaviSya mAM jaina samAja sArI pAyarIe AvI zakaze avI AzA rAkhavI asthAne nthiij| mahAsatI pUjya sAdhvI jI mahAra jo, have ApaNe samajavU ghaTe che ke gRhasthAzrama tyAgI sAdhvI jIvana prAtma kalyANArtha grahaNa karyu che to khAlI jaganI jaMjAla, Apasa mAM kusampa vadhArI jIvana ne barabAda karavU yogya nathI, ghara karI baiThela pramAda ne tilAMjalI ApI Atma sanmukha dRSTi rAkhI, potArnu ane paranu jIvana ujvala banAvaqe ApaNI pharaja che |jo ApaNe ApaNA paga Upara rahI zu to je samAja ne Aje bhAre par3atA gaNAiye chIra te bhAra samAja upara thI ocho karI zakIzuM / a paNA jagera varttavAnI samAjanI karar3I dRSTi thai che te ApaNA zuddha parivartana thI mIThI dRSTi thatA vAra nahIM laage| Alekha dveSa buddhi thI nathI lakhyo chatAM koI ne aghaTita lAge to kSamA yA ch| . pariziSTa naM. 2 hamane jayapura se jJAnasundarajI ke sAtha patra vyavahAra kiyA pahale patra kA javAba to zAnasundarajI ne diyA, dUsare-tIsare patra kA javAba nahIM de sake-patroM kI nakala nIce likhe mujiba hai| jJAnasundarajI meM kamajorI va anyAya jJAna sundarajI ko sUcanA / ___ jaba maiM phalaudI se vihAra karatA huvA kAparar3AjI tIrtha meM Apase milA thA taba maiMne Apase kahA thA ki-kharatara gaccha ke viruddha hamAre sAdhu sAdhvige viruddha TrekTa aura lekha jitane chapavAte haiM vo dUsaroM ko bhejate haiM parantu hamako tathA hamAre gaccha ke sAdhu aura zrAvakoM ko nahIM bhejate hai yaha ucita nahIM hai saba TrekTa mere ko do maiM unakA ucita javAba dUMgA, usa para Apane batalAyA ki-abhI mere pAsa nahIM hai caumAsA meM sA TrekTa avazya meja dUMgA aura sAdhvI vyAkhyAna saMbaMdhI carcA kA lekha bhI bheja dene kA maMjUra kiyA thA vo Aja taka nahIM bhejA, aura ajamera kI dAdAbAr3I vAle lekha kA samAdhAna karane bAbata Apane mere ko kahA thA taba usa para maiMne Apale vAyadA kiyA thAki-maiM ajamera jAkara dekha kara likhavAne vAle kI tathA usakI preraNA se karane vAloM kI salAha lekara Apako khulAsA likhUgA, ina tIna bAtoM kA mere aura Apake bIca meM vAyadA huvA thA usake anusAra maiMne jayapura se Apako, phalaudI patra likhA thA, jisakI nakala isa prakAra hai maNisAgara vinayasAgara jayapura /

Page #59
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH 47 zrImAn zAnasundarajI ma0 Adi yogya anuvaMdanA vaMdanA sukhasAtA baMcanA, aura hama ajamera tIna dina Thahara kara jayapura Agaye the, yahAM para Aye bAda tabiyata kI gar3abar3I rahI isa vAste patra meM vilaMba huA, hamane ajamera meM Apake kahe anusAra zrAvakoM se vArtAlApa kiyA aura jodhapura se bhI salAha maMgAI saba kA sAra yaha hai ki-jamAnA zAnti aura saMpa kA hai, donoM tarapha se virodha na bar3hanA cAhiye, isaliye nyAya kI aura hita kI dRSTi se ve loga bhI isa lekha ko sudhArale / aura Apane jo jo isa gaccha ke samudAya ke viruddha lekha nikAle haiM unako Apa bhI vApisa le leM, aisI bahuta logoM kI icchA hai isI meM hI samAja kA bhalA hai| aura sAdhvI vyAkhyAna bAvata ApakA aura merA vyaktigata vivAda hai, isaliye Apane kAparar3AjI meM lekha bhejane kA maMjUra kiyA thA, usa mujaba Apa lekha bheja denA, usa para maiM bhI merA lekha bheja dUgA, aura 12 TrekTa bhejane kA kahA thA so saba kI 2-2 kApI bheja denA / daH vinysaagr|| 1- aba Apase merA yahI kahanA hai ki-sAdhvI vyAkhyAna kA viSaya Apake aura mere bIca meM vyaktigata hai jaba Apane mere upara lekha chapavAyA vo usI samaya Apako mere pAsa bheja denA thA yahI nyAya kI bAta hai, parantu jisa para bhI maiMne bhaMgavAyA to bhI Apane Aja taka nahIM bhejaa| jisake upara lekha chapavAnAusako na bhejanA, yaha Apa apanI kamajorI sAbita karatA hai, isaliye yaha jAhira sUcanA karatA hUki-binA vilaMba vo lekha bheja deM, usakA pratyuttara dene ko taiyAra huuN| 2-Apane apane nAma se yA Apake anuyAyI bhaktoM ke nAma se kharatara gaccha ke viruddha jitane TrekTa Apake dvArA nikAle gaye haiM vo saba bhejane meM derI na kareM. maiM Apako kAparar3AjI meM sApha kara cukA hUM ki-jo jo vyaktigata nindanIya ghraNita aura AkSepa vAle Apake lekhoM kA javAba maiM nahIM duuNgaa| aura Apake upara vaise AkSepa bhI na karUMgA sirpha zAstrIya pramANAnusAra yukti pUrvaka uttara dUMgA TrekTa bhejeN| 3-isa patra ke pahuMcane para pandraha dina ke andara Apa lekha va TrekTa bhejane meM bilaMba na kareM upara lekha vijJApana ke rUpa meM va jAhira patroM meM chapavAne kA vicAra kiyA thA, para ApakI mitratA ke kAraNa na chapavA ke pahale Apako bhejA hai| ___ 4-vizeSa sUcanA yaha bhI Apako kaha denA ucita samajhatA hUM ki-Age se kisI anya vyakti ke nAma se koI bhI lekha isa viSaya kA prakAzita na karAveM, aisAna karane para sabhya samAja meM kleza phailAne se ApakI mAyAcArI va kamajorI sAbita hotI hai, yaha maiMne hita buddhi se Apako itanI sUcanA kI hai| zubham 26-4-42 pra. paM0 muni maNisAgara va kalama vinayasAgara

Page #60
ka lAvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH tIrtha zrI kAparar3AjI tAH 6 / 542 zrImAna upAdhyAyajI zrI maNisAgara jI mahArAja- mu0 jayapura sAdara vaMdanA pazcAt vidita ho ki ApakA patra tArIkha 26-4-42 kA likhA huA tA. 5-5-42 ko rajisTara dvArA milaa| patra par3hane se saba hAla mAlUma huaa| para yaha samajha meM nahIM AyA ki eka ora to Apane mitratA pUrvaka patra likhA hai aura dUsarI ora pandraha dinoM kI dhamakI dI hai| khaira maiMne Apake patra kA javAba mitratA ke nAte diyA na ki dhamakI ke Dara se / zrAge TrekTa bhejane ke viSaya meM Apane likhA ki hama aura hamAre sAdhu yA zrAvakoM ko nahIM dete ho ityAdi / para aisI bAta nahIM hai TrekTa nikalA to sabase pahale phalaudI evaM ajamera vAloM ko hI bhejA thaa| ki jinhoM ke kAraNa likhA gayA thA bAda bIkAnera jodhapurAdi anya sthAnoM meM bhejA gayA thaa| yadi Apako na milA ho to bAta dUsarI hai| khaira Aja maiM merA likhA TrekTa DAka dvArA bheja rahA huuN| zeSa ke liye koziza karUMgA / Age sAdhvI ke vyAkhyAna ke viSaya meM Apane bhI vAyadA kAparaGAjI meM kiyA thA ki maiM mere zeSa lekha Apako bheja duuNgaa| vo Aja paryanta nahIM mile haiN| yadi Apa apane lekha meja dikhAyeM to maiM una lekhoM kA uttara likha kara mere lekha meM zAmila kara Apa ko bhijavAne kA prayatna karUMgA / ajamera kI dAdAvAr3I ke viSaya meM maiMne zrApako kAparar3AjI meM kahA thA ki lekha dekhane ke bAda maiMne karIbana dasa mAsa taka samAdhAna kI kauziza kii| para usameM saphalatA nahIM milii| itanAhI kyoM para phalaudI se Apake sAdhuoM dvArA aisA javAba milA ki - jisase lAcAra ho mujhe TrekTa likhanA par3A jo Aja kI DAka se Apako bhejavAyA jA rahA hai / bAda kAparar3AjI meM ApakA milApa evaM vArtAlApa huaa| tathA jaba maiM phalaudI gayA to eka sajjana ne vizvAsa dilAyA ki maiM samAdhAna kI koziza karU~gA basa isa vizvAsa para philahAla likhA par3hI baMda karadI hai / Age Apane yaha bhI likhA hai ki lekha vijJApana ke rUpa meM va jAhira patroM chupAne kA vicAra kiyA thaa| para ApakI mitratA ke kAraNa na chapavA kara Apako mejA hai / yaha ApakI maherabAnI hai / maiM bhI zAnti kA icchuka hUM / phira bhI vijJApana Adi chapA nevAlA tathA usakA javAba dene vAle svataMtra haiM Shree Sudharmaswami Gyanbhandar-Umara, Surat bhavadIyajJAnasundara www.umaragyanbhandar.com

Page #61
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH // shrii|| maNimAgara vinayasAgara-jayapura jyeSTha su04 saMvat 1999 zrImAn-zAnasundarajI Adi yogya anuvaMdanA vaMdanA sukhasAtA ke sAtha vidita ho ki-ApakA patra milA samAcAra jAne, Apane Aja taka kharatarotpatti bhAga 1-2-3-4 Adi 15-20 TrekTa nikAle sune jAte haiM unhIM TrekToM ko maiMne Apase kAparaDAjI tIrtha meM mAMge the, Apane una saba TrekToM ko bhejanA maMjUra kiyA thA magara aphasosa hai ki-Apane abhI taka una saba TrekToM ko nahIM meje aura aba bhI bhejane meM TAla TUla karate haiM isase ApakI kamajorI sAbita hotI hai aura ApakA yaha sarvathA anyAya hai| 1-agara Apa satya likhate hoto kharatarotpatti bhAga 1-2-3-4 Adi anya dekTa jodhapura bIkAnera phalaudI meM kaunara se kharatara gaccha ke sAdhu tathA zrAvakoM ko bheje unhoM kA nAma batAo, anyathA Apa apanA mithyA lekha vApisa lo| 2-ajamera kI dAdAbAr3I ke lekha ke sambandha meM maiMne Apako phalaudI patra diyA thA tathA pahale patra ke sAtha nakala bhI bheja cukA hUM, usa nyAya ke mArga ko Apa aMgIkAra karate nahIM haiM yaha bhI ucita nahIM hai| 3-sAdhvI vyAkhyAna bAbata merA lekha "jaina dhvaja" meM prakAzita ho cukA hai| usakA javAba Apane karIbana bAraha mahIne pahile chapA diyA tA bhI abhI taka Apane mere pAsa nahIM mejA ApakI kitanI bhArI kamajorI hai, jaba maiM kAparaDAjI tIrtha meM mere aura Apake yaha bAta taya ho cukI thI, Apane maMjUra kiyA ki-jo lekha merA chapane ko gayA hai. usako nahIM chapavAUMgA, presa meM se do prUpha maMgA kara eka Apako dUMgA, usa para maiMne bhI Apase vAyadA kiyA thA ki maiM bhI merA lekha kitAba rUpa meM na chapA kara saba pUrA lekha Apake pAsa meja duuNgaa| aura apane Apasa meM patra vyavahAra se samAdhAna kiye bAda kitAba chapavAI jAyagI isa niyama ko Apa bhaMga kara ke Apane pahale kitAba chapavAdI aba bhI Apa mere pAsa bheja. dIjiye, usa para maiM bhI merA lekha mejane ko taiyAra huuN| 4-aba Apase merA Agraha pUrvaka yahI kahanA hai ki yadi Apako nyAya mArga priya ho satya aMgIkAra karanA cAho to "vitaMDAvAda" "zuSka vivAda' kIbAtoM meM vyartha samaya na gamA kara nyAya mArga se dharmavAda karane kI icchA ho aura samAja meM satya pracAra kI bhAvanA hoto apane vAyade ke anusAra sAdhvI vyAkhyAna kA TrekTa tathA kharatarotpatti bhAga 1-2.3-4 tathA anya saba TrekTa jaldI se bhejado, maiM mere vAyade ke anusAra lekha mejane ko taiyAra huuN| 5-kAparar3AjI meM jo TrekTa Apane diyAthA, vahahI vyartha bukaposTa se mejA dUsarA mejte| zubham muni maNisAgara vinayasAgara

Page #62
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH // zrI // maNisAgara vinayasAgara jayapura dvi0 jye. su. 5 vA. gurU saMvat 1999 zrImAn jJAnasundarajI Adi yogya anuvaMdanA vaMdanA sukhasAtA baMcanA / 1- hamane yahAM se jyeSTha sudi 4 ko Apake nAma kA rajisTara patra diyA thA so milA hogA, bahuta roja huye usa rajisTara patra kA abhI taka javAba nahIM, tathA TrekTa bhI Apane abhI taka bheje nahIM, isa taraha TrekTa chapavAkara samAja meM mithyA bhrama phailAnA nindanIya lekha likha kara logoM ke karma baMdhana karavAnA yaha Apako ucita nahIM hai / 50 2- - vAdavivAda vAle carcA ke lekha jisake Upara chapAyA jAya usako pahile bhejane kA niyama hai, jisa para Apane mere Upara lekha chapavA kara mere ko nahIM bhejA samAja meM pracAra kiyA yaha ApakI bar3I mAyAcArI kI kamajorI sAbita hotI hai, yadi Apane satyatA kI tAkata hotI to mere pAsa lekha bhejane meM derI nahIM karate, maiMne Apako kAparar3AjI tIrtha meM khulAsA kaha diyA thA ki- ApakA lekha Ane para maiM jIvAnuzAsana ke pATha kA khulAsA likha bhejUMgA yaha bAta Apane maMjUra kI thI, jisa para bhI Apane mere ko lekha nahIM bhejA, adhUrA lekha chapavA kara samAja meM utsUtra prarUpaNA karake mAyA jAla phailAyA, aba Apa apanA lekha bhejane meM Darate ho isase hI Apa kA lekha mithyA sAbita hai / 3- tapagaccha ke sAdhujI ke pAsa se kharatarotpattibhAga 1-2-3-4 eka zrAvaka ko milI usane par3hI mere ko kahatA thA ki jJAnasundarajI ne kharatarotpatti bhAga 1-2-3-4 meM bahuta nindanIya halake tuccha zabda likhe haiM kharatara gaccha ke pUrvAcAryoM kI bahuta nindA kI hai, binA zira paira kI banAvaTI bAteM likhI hai usameM prathama karemibhante cha kalyANaka Adi bahuta bAtoM kA ullekha kiyA hai isa kitAba ke par3hane para mAlUma hotA hai ki jJAnasundarajI ke tIvra kaSAya kA udaya hai tathA kharatara gaccha ke sAtha pUrA dveSa bhAva hai, isa jamAne meM nindanIya bhASA meM likhane vAle kI jaina samAja kucha bhI kImata nahIM karatI, jisako madhyastha dRSTi se satya bAta nirNaya karanA ho to sabhyatA ke sAtha lekha likhe, parantu jisake andara dveSa bhAva bharA huA hotA hai vo nindanIya gAliyoM se kAma letA hai, yahI dazA jJAnasundarajI ne apanI kItAva meM karI hai ityAdi kaI bAteM kahI hai isa para merA Apa se yaha kahanA hai ki agara ApakI yahI dazA hoto saba kitAbeM jala zaraNa kara dIjiye, anyathA aba mere ko kitAba bhejane meM vilaMba na kIjiye yahI merA Agraha hai / 4- mere ko yaha bhI eka ApakI mAyAcArI kA prapaJca mAlUma hotA hai ki zrApa apanI

Page #63
sAdhvI vyAkhyAna nirNayaH manamAnI kharatara gaccha kI nindA kI vAteM likha kara TrekTa chapavA dete haiM unako dUsarI jagaha apane paricaya vAloM meM tathA apane bhaktoM meM pracAra karate haiM aura kharatara gaccha ke sAdhusAdhvI tathA AgevAna zrAvakoM ke pAsa na pahuMcane pAve isakI bhI khUba sAvadhAnI rakhate haiM aura phira Apa mithyA ghamaMDa kI bAteM banAte haiM ki-kharatara gaccha vAle javAba nahIM dete haiM yaha kUTa nIti kI mAyAcArI hai aisI jAlasAdI se Apa apanI AtmA ko bhArI kyoM karate haiM / ApakA khAsa kartavya hai ki-kharatara gaccha ke mukhya 2 sAdhu-sAdhvI tathA prAgevAna zrAvakoM ke pAsa kamase kama 25 jagaha saba TrekTa bheja denA caahiye| isa javAbI rajisTara patra kA uttara 15 yA 20 dina ke andara nahIM AyA to hama chapavAnA zurU kreNge| 22.6-42 / zubham vinayasAgara ____ sajjana ! pAThakagaNa ! Upara ke patra vyavahAra se Apa samajha gaye hoMge ki-zAnasundara jI meM dharma nyAya kA zAsanahita kA kitanA viveka hai| zrI jinamaNisAgarasUrijI ma. kI AjJA se muni-vinayasAgara

Page #64