Page #1
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ nasahazaM pavitrA mhaavidyt| R na hi jJAnena SUNISHITTOSXITHDRA maannikcnd-digmbr-jaingrnthmaalaa| prmaannnirnnyH| BY
Page #2
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ mANikacaMdra-digambarajaina-granthamAlA, dazama puSpa .. zrImadvArAjasUriviracitaH prmaannnirnnyH| jayapuranivAsipaNDitaindralAlasAhityazAstriNA / veranIgrAma nivAsipaNDitakhUbacandazAstriNA ca sampAditaH saMzodhitazca / prakAzikAmANikacanda-digambara-jaina-granthamAlA samitiH / adhika bhAdrapada, vIra nirvANa saM0 2443 / vikramAnda 1974 /
Page #3
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ prakAzaka-- nAthUrAmapremI, maMtrI, mANikacandra granthamAlA, hIrAbAga po0 giragAMva bambaI mudrakaciMtAmaNa sakhArAma devaLe, muMbaIvaibhava presa, saheMTs oNpha iMDiyA hosAyaTIja bilDiMga, giragAMva-bambaI.
Page #4
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ nivedn| neter isa granthake kartA prasiddha tArkika zrIvAdirAjasUri haiM jinakA vistRta paricaya isa granthamAlAke cauthe grantha pArzvanAthacaritakI bhUmikAmeM diyA jA cukA hai / yaha grantha abhItaka aprApya thaa| isakA sampAdana aura saMzodhana eka hI pratiparase kiyA gayA hai jo jayapurake eka jaina-mandirake pustaka-bhaNDArase prApta huI thI aura prAyaH zuddha thii| isake lie ukta bhaNDArake adhikAriyoMko zatazaH dhanyavAda / -~-mNtrii|
Page #5
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 033333333333030033333330 mANikacanda - digambara jaina - granthamAlAsamiti / ( prabandhakAriNIsabhAke samya / ) > 1 rAyabahAdura seTa svarUpacanda hukumacandajI | tilokacanda kalyANamalajI / oMkArajI kastUracandajI | 27 "" "" " dr 4 seTha gurumukharAya sukhAnandajI | 5 hIrAcanda nemIcandajI A0 majisTreTa / 0000:00 "" 6 ThAkuradAsa bhagavAnadAsajI jauharI / 7 mi0 lallUbhAI premAnandajI ela. sI. I. / 8 brahmacArI zItalaprasAdajI | paM0 dhannAlAlajI kAzalIvAla / 10 paM0 khUbacandajI zAstrI / 11 maMtrI - nAthUrAma premI / (c)EUREUREUR33:33333;30330:0333 33 =333333333333333333333336
Page #6
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ & zrIsarasvatyai namo namaH / zrImadvAdirAjasUriviracitaH pramANanirNayaH / maGgalAcaraNam / zrIvarddhamAnamAnamya jinadevaM jagatprabhum / saGkSepeNa pramANasya nirNayo varNyate mayA // 1 // pramANalakSaNanirNayaH / samyagjJAnaM pramANaM pramANatvA'nyathA'nupapatteH / idameva hi pramANasya pramANatvaM yatpramitikriyAM prati sAdhakatamatvena karaNatvaM / tacca tasya samyagjJAnatve satyeva bhavati nA'cetanatve nA'pyasamyagjJAnatve / naMnu ca tat kriyAyAmastyevAcetanasyApIndriyaliGgAdeH karaNatvaM cakSuSA pramIyate dhUmAdinA pramIyata iti / taMtrA'pi pra " 1 " nanu ca " zabdo'tra viruddhoktau / naiyAyikamatamidam / 2 iMdriyaliMgAdAvapi /
Page #7
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pramANanirNaye mitikriyAkaraNatvasya prasiddheriti cet / nanu ca pramitirnAmAvyutpattyAdivyavacchittireva / satyAmeva tasyAM cetanasyetarasya vA pramitatvopapatteH / na ca tatrA'cetanasya karaNatvamavirodhAt / virodhino hi kutazcitkasyacid vyavacchittiH, prakAzAdivAndhakArasya / nAcetanasyApyavyutpattyAdinA kazcidapi virodho yatastato'pi tavyavacchittiH parikalpyeta, samyagjJAnAttu tavyavacchittirupapannava tasya vyavasAyAtmakatvAt / vyavasAyasya cA'vyutpattyAdinA virodhprsiddhH| na hi vyavasitameva kizcidavyutpannamArekitaM viparyastaM vA bhavati / tadabhAva eva tadbhAvasyopapatteH / ataH samyagjJAnasyaiva tatra karaNatvam / acetanasya tvindriyaliGgAdestatra karaNatvaM gavAkSAderivopacArAdeva / upacArazca tadvyavacchittau samyagjJAnasyendriyAdisahAyatayA prvRtteH| tannA'cetanasya tatra karaNatvaM mukhyavRttyA sambhavati, nA'pyasamyagjJAnasya / na hi tavyApAraparAmRSTasyA'vyutpattyAdivikalatayA bhAvasya pramitatvamupapannaM, tadasamyaktvasyaiva tathAsatyabhAvApatteH / avyutyattyAdipratyanIkasya svabhAvasyaiva samyagarthatvAt / tasya vA samyagjJAne'pi bhAve vAcanikameva tasyAsamyagjJAnatvaM bhavenna vAstavam / tataH samyagjJAnAdeva vyavasAyAtmanastavyavacchittiH / yadyeSA na vyavasAyarUpI na pramANasya samyagjJAnAtmanaH phalaM bhavet, vyavasAyarUpatve satyeva tadupapatteH / ata evoktaM " pramANasya sAkSAtphalasiddhiH svArtha 1 " praznAvadhAraNAnujJA'nunayAmaMtraNe nanu" itymrH| 2 andhyvsaayH| 3 anadhyavasitam / 4 zaGkitam / 5padArthasya / 6 vADyAtrameva / 7 satyaM / 8 " tahIti" shissttaaNshH| 9 ajJAnanivRttihInopAdAnopekSAvuddhayaH phlN| 10 jaine. neti shessH| 11 jJaptiH /
Page #8
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pramANalakSaNanirNayaH / vinizcaya" iti| vyavasAyarUpA cettarhi vyavasAyAttadvyavacchi. ttiriti tadvyavacchittereva tadvyavacchittirityuktaM bhavati, taccAnupapannameva / bhedA'bhAve kriyAkArakabhAvasyAnupapattoti cenna bhedasyA'pi bhAvAt / dvirUpaM hi vyavasAyasvabhAvasaMvedanaM, pravRttirUpaM nivRttirUpaM ceti / nahIdamavyutpattyAdi nivRttirUpameva, nIrUpatvApatteH / nA'pi pravRttirUpameva, svarUpAdinevA'vyutpattyAdirUpeNA'pi tadrUpatvApatteH / na caivamekAntato nivRttirUpatayA pravRttirUpatayA ca tasyA'pravedanAt / ata evobhayasvabhAve tasmin pravRttirUpatayA sAdhakatamasyAvyutpattyAdinivRttirUpatayA kriyAbhAvasya bhAvAnna kriyAkArakabhAvasyA'nupapattiH / kathamevamapi pramitikriyAyAM tatsahabhAvinaH saMvedanasya sAdhakatamatvamiticenna / prAgapi bhAvAta, tata eva saMvedanAtprAgapi viSayAntare pramitikriyAniSpatteH / anyadeva tatsaMvedanaM viSayabhede tadbhedasyA'vazyaMbhAvAditi cet / na / yugapadapyevaM prasaGgAva, tathAca kathaM senAvanAdipratipattiH / na hi karituragAderdhavakhadirAdezcaikasaMvedanaviSayatvAbhAve tatpratipattiH saMbhavati / yugapadviSayabhede'pi ekameva saMvedanaM, tathA tasyAnubhavAditi cenna / krameNApi tathA tadanubhavasyAvizeSAt / parAparasamayavyAteranubhavagamyatve kuto na tasyA''janmamaraNAvadhirapyanubhava iti cenna / yAvacchaktikamevAnubhavasya tatra vyApArAt / anyathA vartamAne'pi vastuni sarvatrA'pi 1 Atma / 2 tathAstviti cet / 3 anizcayAt / 4 pramiteH prAgapi saMvedanasya bhAvAt / 5 yatpUrva viSayAMtare pramitikriyAmupajanayati / 6 yugapaditi viSayabhedAtsaMvedanabhede sati / 7 janaH / 8 anyaH / 9 viSayabhede'pyekatvaprakAreNa /
Page #9
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pramANanirNaye tasya vyApAropanipAtAt / kathamevamapyanvitajJAnAviSvagbhAve tattatsamayabhAvinyo'rthapramitayo vyatibhidyante iti cet, yugapagAvinyaH kathaM ? tadAnImekaiva karituragAdiviSayA pramitirapIti cenna, tasyAsturagonmukhasvabhAvatve tadviSayatayA naravAraNAderapi turagarUpatvApatteH / atatsvabhAvatve tayA turagasyA'vyavasthApanaprasaGgAt / naravAraNAderApi tattadunmukhasvabhAvayaiva tayA viSayIkaraNaM na turagonmukhasvabhAvayaiva yadayaM prasaGga iti cet, siddhaM tarhi yugapatpamiternAnAtvaM, aunmukhyanAnAtve tadrUpatayA tatrApi nAnAtvasyopapatteH / ato yugapadiva krameNA'pi anvitajJAnAviSvagbhAve'pi vyatibhedopapatteH / tatra tatra pramitau tasyaivAnvayinaH saMvedanasya sAdhakatamatvaM, nAcetanasyendriyaliGgAdeH, nApyasamyagjJAnasyAdhyavasAyAderiti sthitam / tasya saMvedanasya svarUpamarthazceti dvividho viSayaH / tatrobhayatrApi tata eva pramiteH / kaH punarartho nAma yatra tataH pramitiriti cat, saMvedanabahi vinIlAdireva; yadyasau prakAzate na kathamasti ? byomakusumAdivat prakAzate cet, na saMvedanabahirbhAvastasya prakAzasyaiva saMvedanatvena prasiddhe'pi saMvedane pratipatteH / saMvedanaM prakAzarUpameva, nIlAdistu kadAcidaprakAzo'pi, tatastasyArthatvaM prakAzabahirbhAvAt iti cet / aprakAzAvasthasya yadi na tasya pratipattiH kathamastitvamatiprasaGgAt / pratipattizcenna prakAzavaikalyaM, prakAzavattvAdeva pratipannatopapatteH / tato nIlAdeH prakAzavahirbhAvena nArthatvamiti-kathaM tasya saMvedanAdanyataH 1 parasparaM bhidyate / 2 pramitAnAM / 3 puurvottrsmye| 4 jJAnAdvaitavAdI saugato vakti / pramiterbhinnaH kaH punarathoM nAmeti praznasyAzayaH / 5 jainaH / 6 bhaktIti shessH|
Page #10
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ prmaannlkssnnnirnnyH| pratipattiH? svata eva tadupapatteriti cet / satyamasti prakAzo vIlAdeH sa yadi svata eva bhavati tasya bodharUpatvaM / na caivaM, parata eva tadbhAvAt / tato'pi bhavatastasya bodhatvameva rUpamiti cenna, bodhyatvasyaiva tedUpatvAt / kiM punaridaM bodhyatvamarthasya, kiM punanisyApi bodhakatvaM ? paranirapekSamaparokSatvamiti cet / arthasyApi parApekSaM tadeva bodhyatvaM kiM na syAt / parasyaivArthapratItivelAyAmaprativedanAditi cenna / nIlaiM vedmi pItaM vedmIti nIlAderanyasyaiva tadvedanasyavAnubhavanAt / ananyatve hi nIlamityeva vejhItyeva vA sthAnobhayamasti cobhayaM tato'nubhavaprasiddhatvAnIlAdestatsaMvedanAnyatvasya kathamapratItivikalpa evAyaM kazcinnIlaM vejhIti nAnubhavo na ca tataH kvacidanyatvanizcayo vAsanAmAtranibandhanatvena tasya viplavatvAt, anyathA kezAderapi tadvedanasya tatastatprasaGgAt / kezAdikaM vedmIti taimirikasya tatrApi vikalpaprAdurbhAvAt bhavatu, iti cenna / kezAdevahirabhAvAt ! bahirasata eva tatastadvedanasyAnyatvamiti cenna / tadapratibhAse tata iti tadvedanasyetyapyanupapatteH / na cAsataHpratibhAsa iti cenna / vibhramasAmarthyAt asato'pi tadupapatteH anyathA vikalpe nIlatadvedanAnyatvasyApyapratibhAsotpatteH, asattvAvizeSAt / satyam / vikalpasyA'pi na tapratibhAsitvaM svasaMvinmAtraparyavasitatvAt, vikalpAntarameva tu tatra tatpratibhAsitvamavakalpayatIti cenna / tenA'pyasatastasyAna 1 parato bhavatprakAzarUpatvAt / 2arthaadbhinnsyaiv|3 jaino vkti|4 vybhicaaraat| 5 vikalpAt kvacidanyatvanizcaye / 6 anyatvaprasaMgo bhavatu / 7 asattvAt / 8 asato 'pratibhAso bA pratibhAsa iti vikalpayannAha / 9 dvitIyavikalpo ghaTate saugatabizeSe / 10 krtRtaapnnN| 11 svasminnavidyamAnasya / ___
Page #11
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pramANanirNaye vakalpanAt / punarvikalpAntarAttasya tadavakalpakatve cAnavasthApattyA nIlatadvedanavivekavikalpa eva na bhavet / na caivaM, tasya tasya pratItestato na saGgantamidaM, vikalpo grAhya grAhakollekhenotpattimAn, so'pi svarUpe grAhyagrAhakarUparahita eva apareNa tathA vyavasthApyata iti| tato na kezAderapi tadvedanasyAnarthAntaratvaM yatastannidarzanena nIlAderapi tadvedanasya tattvamavakalpyeta / tato bahireva tadvedanAnnIlAdibahirarthaH / tata idamapyanupapannam / saMvedanena bAhyatvameto'rthasya na siddhyati / ___ saMvedanAdvahirbhAve sa eva tu na siddhayati // iti saMvedanenaiva nIlAdestadvahirbhAvasyoktayA nItyA vyavasthApanAt / yadi saMvedanAdbahireva nIlAdiH kathaM tasya vastusattvaM ? taimirikakezAdivaditi cet, tatkezAderApi na saMvedanabahirbhAvenAvastusattvamapi tu bAdhakatvAt / na cedaM prasiddhe nIlavastrAdAvastIti / vastu sannevA'yaM kartavyazcaivamabhyupagamaH / anyathA nIlAdebahIrUpatveneva saMvedanasyApi pratibhAsamAnatvena taimirikakezAdinA sAdhAdavastusattvApatteH |atH saMvedanabahirbhAvAdabAdhakatvena vastusattvAccArtha eva nIlAdiravagantavyaH / yatpunaretanmataM / yathaiva hi grAhakAkAraH svarUpeNAparokSo na grAhakAntarabhAvAt / tathA tena samAnakAlo'pi nIlAdika iti / tatra bhaMvato yadi tAdRzo nIlAdirapratipattiviSayaH kathaM yathaivetyAdivacanaM pratipAdhavat / pratipattiviSayazcettahi kathaM svarUpeNA'parokSatvaM, tasya bhavatpratipattiviSayatayA parata eva tadupapatteH / yadapyetadaparaM yathA 1tadanyatvavikalpAbhAvo na ca / 2anyavikalpena vikalpAMtareNeti yAvat / 3anytvN| 4 hetunaa| 5 nyaayaat| 6 taimirikakezAdivat / 7 paramArthasat / 8 jJAyata iti shessH|9 tv| 10 pratipAdyArtho'syAstIti pratipAdyavat / 11 tvjjnyaanvissytyaa| ___
Page #12
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pramANalakSaNanirNayaH / 2 cakSurAdikAt grAhakAkAra:, tathA tatsamAnakAlo grAhyAkAropIti tatrA'pi sabhAsamavAyinIM cakSurAderbahutvAt tajjanmano vikasitakuvalayadalanIlacchAyAnuvarttino narttakIrUpasyApi bahutvena bhavitavyam / nacaivaM tadpaikatve sarveSAM teSAmekavAkyatApratipatteH / vyAmohAdeva kutazcittatra teSAmekavAkyatvaM; vastuto nAnaiva tadrUpamiticet / kozapAnAdetatpratyetavyaM na pramANataH / kutazcidapi tadabhAvAt kutazcedamavagataM grAhyAkAro'pi cakSurAderiti grAhakAkAravat / tatrApi tadanvayavyatirekAnuvidhAnasya bhAvAditi cet, kutaH punastadbhAvasyAvagatiH ? na pratyakSAt, " na hi pratyakSasaMvittiranvayavyatirekayoriti " svayamevAbhidhAnAt / nApyanumAnAtpratyakSAbhAve tatpUrvakatvena tasyApyasaMbhavAt / tadvAsanAmAtrajanmano vikalpAttadavagatau vA avAstava eva tadbhAva iti na tato nIlAderaparokSatayA cakSurAderutpAdaH zakyavyavasthApanaH / tato nIlAdivyatiriktavedanaviSayatayaivA parokSabhAvamanubhavannartha evetyupapannaM tadviSayatayA samyagjJAnasyArthaviSayatvam / bhavatu tadviSayatvameva tasya na svaviSayatvaM svAtmani kriyAvirodhAt chidikriyAvattathAhi / - viruddhA jJAnasya svAtmani pramitiH kriyAtvAt khaDgAtmani chidikriyAvat; na hi khaDgaH svAtmAnaM chindannupalabhyata iti cet, na kriyAtvamAtrAcchideH khaGgAtmanA virodho'pi tu tadAtmano bhAvarUpatvAt; chidezca pradhvaMsavizeSatvena abhAva svabhAvatvAt / bhAvAbhAvayozca parasparaparihAropapatteH / nacaivaM jJAnAtmatatpramityorbhAvetara svarUpatvaM yena tayoranyonyaparihAreNAvasthAnAdvirodhaparikalpanamato na virodhAdasvapratipattikatvaM jJAnasya zakyavyavasthaM kathaM cAsvapramitirUpatve 1 jJAne jJAyate / 2 puruSANAmiti zeSaH / 3 naiyAyiko vadati /
Page #13
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pramANanirNaye tasya niyata evArtho gocaro na sarvo'pIti, niyatasyaiva tasya prati. bhAsanAditi cetkuta idamavagantavyam / na tAvattata eva svprtipttivaiklyaat| na hi svapratipattivikalAdeva jJAnAttatra niyatArthapratibhAsanamanyadvA zakyAvabodhaM mA bhUttatastadavabodhastadviSayAttu jJAnAntarAdbhavatyeveti cenna, tasyApi svapratipattivaikalye tatrApi tadviSayasya jJAnasya niyatArthagocaratvameva pratibhAti na niravazeSavastugocaratvamiti-tata evAvagantumazakyatvAt / tasyApi niyataviSayatvamanyatastadviSayAdeva jJAnAdavagamyata iti cenna, anavasthAprasaMgAt / satyevamaparAparajJAnaparikalpanasyAvazyaMbhAvAt / tataH sudUramapi gatvA kvaciniyataviSayatvamadhyavasAtukAmena tadviSayasya jJAnasya svapratipattirUpatvamabhyupagantavyam / anyathA tatastadviSayavijJAnaniyatArthagocaratvapratipatterdurupapAdakatvAt / tathA ca siddhamarthajJAnasyApi tadvatsvapratipattirUpatvamAvizeSAt / __ yatpunaridamanumAnaM, "nAtmaviSayamarthajJAnaM vedyatvAtkalazAdivaditi' tatra na tAvadvedyatvaM nAma sAmAnyaM tasya nityatvena sarvadA bhAveSu prasaMgAta sAmAnyAdiSu tadabhAvApattezca / na hi sAmAnyAdiSu sAmAnyaM dravyAditraya eva tadabhyupagamAtsAmAnyAdiSu tadabhAvApattezca / asti ca tatrApi vedyatvaM, anyathA vyomakusumAdivattadabhAvApatteH, atona tatsAmAnyaM / bhavatu sAdharmyameva tadvedanaviSayatvasya vedyatvasya cAbhidhAnAt / tasya sarvapadArthasAdhAraNatayA dravyaguNakamasviva sAmAnyavizeSasamavAyevaSyavirodhAt / na tadabhAvApattiriticet kiM punastadvedanaM yadviSayatvaM vedyatvamarthajJAnasyocyeta, tade. 1 svasminniti zeSaH / 2 jnyaane|3 sarvArthapratibhAsanaM / / prthmjnyaane| 5dvitIyasya 6 durghtttvaat| 7 svapratipattirUpatve sati / 8 prathamajJAnasya / 9 padArtheSu /
Page #14
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ prmaannlkssnnnirnnyH| vArthajJAnamiti cenna / anAtmaviSayatve tasya tadvedanatvAnupapatteH, AtmaviSayatve ca hetupratijJayorvirodhAt / tasmAdanyadeva tadekArthasamavetamanantaraM tadvedanamiti cena, tasyAdyApyasiddhatvAt / arthajJAnaM jJAnAntaravedyaM vedyatvAt kalazAdivadityata evAnumAnAttatsiddhiArati cenna, parasparAzrayApatteH, tatsiddhAvanumAnamanumAnAcca tasiddhiriti / anyatastatsiddhirita cemn| anumAnasya vaiyrthyprsNgaat|kiNvaa tadanyat ? pratyakSamiti cenna, tasyApyavyatiriktasyAnabhyupagamAt / vyatiriktamiti cet, kimayaM niyamaH, sati viSaye tavedanamavazya. miti / tathA cennArthajJAnavedanavattavedane'pyanyattadvedanaM tatrA'pyanyadityAsaMsAraM tadvedanaprabaMdhasyaiva pravRtterna viSayAntarasaMcAro vedanasya bhavediti kathamanumAnam / dharmijJAnatajjJAnaprabaMdhasyA parame hetudRSTAntayoranupapattermAbhUdayaM niyama iti cenna tarhi dharmiNyapi vedananiyama iti kathaM tasya tadvadyatvasya hetorvA siddhirityasaMbhava evAnumAnasya bhavet / ___ atha vaidyatvamarthajJAnasya na viziSTamupAdIyate, teMdatatkRtatvena avaziSTasyaiva tasya hetutvAditi cet, kathaM tasyAnAtmaviSayatve sAdhye hetutvaM ? tenaiva kalazAdau tasya vyAptidarzanAditi cet, na, vyAptijJAne AtmaviSayatvenApi tasya taddarzanAt, na hi prAdezikI vyaaptiH| sAdhyapratipattenimittaM tatputratvAdAvapi 1 viruddhatvAditi bhAvaH / 2 arthajJAnAt / 3 tena sahaikasminnarthe samavetaM / 4pazcAdutpanna / 5 tRtIyajJAnAt / 6 dvitIyajJAnAvyatiriktasya / 7 kutaH svapratipattiprasaMgAt / 8 prabhavati na veti zeSaH / 9 prathamajJAnalakSaNe / 10 anvsthaane| 11 anyajJAnakRtatvena / 12 sAdhyasya / 13 pradeze bhavA prAdezikI / ___
Page #15
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pramANanirNaye tadbhAvAt zyomatvAdestato'pisiddhiprasaMgAt / api tu saaklyen| tatra yadU yadU vedyaM tattatsarvamanAtmaviSayamiti kiMcidvijJAnamutpadyamAnamAtmaviSayamapi bhavitumarhati / anyathA tadvadyatvasyAnAtmaviSayatayA vyAptastata evApratipattiprasaMgAta, tathAca vyabhicAri vedyatvaM vyAptijJAnena tatrAtmani viSayatvasyAbhAve'pi tasya bhAvAt / evamIzvarajJAnenApi / na hi tasyApyanAtmaviSayatvaM, asarvaviSayatvaprasaMgAt / tathA ca kathaM tasya tajjJAnena sarvajJatvaM ? tena tadaparasya sakalasya tasya ca tadanyena grahaNAditi cet, kathaM tadanyenApyasvaviSayeNa svaviSayatayA parasparaparijJAnamityapratipattireva / tena tasyAsakalapratipatteranabhyupagamAdityato'sti tasyA''tmaviSayatvaM / tathA cetkimaparAddhaM tadviSayeNa jJAnena ryattasyaivAtmaviSayatvaM neSyate iti siddham tenApi vyabhicAritvaM vedyatvasya / tatrAnAtmaviSayatvAbhAve'pi tasya bhAvAditi-nAnumAnAdapyanAtmaviSayatvamarthajJAnasyAtmaviSayatvaM tu tasyAnubhavaprasiddhamataH kiM tatrAnumAnena, yadi nirbandhastaducyata eva / arthajJAnamAtmaviSayamaviSayatvAt, yatpunarnAtmaviSayaM tadarthaviSayamApa na bhavati yathA ghaTAdi / arthaviSayaM vivAdApalaM jJAnaM tasmAdAtmaviSayamiti kevalavyatirekI hetuH, tasya parairapi gamakatvAbhyanujJAnAt / tannArthaviSatvameva jJAnasyetyupapannaM naiyAyikasya, svaviSayatvasyApi tatra bhAvAt / mImAMsakastvAha / parokSameva sakalamapi jJAnaM svaprakAzavaikalyAt, pratyakSaM tu bahirarthasya tena tasyaiva prakAzanAt iti / 1 sAdhyasya / 2 vyAptijJAnaM / 3 vyAptijJAnasyAtmaviSayatvena / 4 dvitIyajJAnenetyarthaH / 5 bastunaH / 6 dvitIyajJAnasyAtmaviSayatvena / 7 dvitiiyjnyaanvissyenn| 8 yasmAt hetoH /
Page #16
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ prmaannlkssnnnirnnyH| taMtra prakAzakatve sati kutastato'rthasyaiva prakAzona svarUpasya? zaktivaikalyAt / tathAhi, yadyatrIzaktaM na tattasyaprakAzakaM, yathA cakSU rasAderazaktaM ca sakalamapi saMvedanaM svaprakAze iti tadvaikalyamiti cet / asyAnumAnasyApi yadi tadvaikalyaM, anumAnAntarAttasyApi tadantarAttadvaikalyaM pratipattavyamiti kathamanavasthitirnabhavet ? abhirucyabhAvAt, yAvadabhirucistAvadeva bhavatyanumAnasya prabaMdhastadabhAve tvavasthitirevati cenna, tarhi kutazcidapi sakalasya saMvedanasya prakAzavaikalyapratipattiriti-kathaM tatra parokSatvavacanaM? tataH sakalasyApi saMvedanasya svaprakAzavaikalyamanumAnAdevajigamiSatA svaprakAzakameva tadabhyupagantavyam / tadvadarthajJAnamapi / tasyApyanumAnavadantorUpatayA parisphuTasyAvalokanAt / tacchaktarApi tata evAdhyavasAyAt / satyapi parokSatve kutastasya pratipattiH anyathA tadabhyanujJAnAnupapatteH / arthaprakAzAdevaM tasya tadanyathAnupapannatayA nirNayAditi cennatatprakAzasya jJAnadharmatve jJAnavatparokSasyaiva bhAvAta, tatra ca tadanyathAnupattenirNayaH parijJAta eva tadupapatteH / parijJAta evAyaM svata iti cet, na tarhi parokSatvaM jJAnasya / taddharmasyArthaprakAzasya svaprakAzatve tadavyatirekiNo jJAnasyApi tadupapatteH / anyatastasya parijJAnamiti cet kiM punaratra tadanyat pratyakSamiti cenna tasyendriyasaMprayogAdutpatteH jJAnadharme cArthaprakAze tadabhAvAt kathaM 1 jainaH pRcchati / 2 mImAMsako vadati / 3 jJAnaM na svaprakAzakaM tatra tasyAzaktatvAt / 4 AkAMkSAbhAvAt / 5 jaina Aha / 6 anumAnAt / 7 jJAtumicchatA mImAMsakena / 8 aMtarmukharUpatayA / 9 tatpratipattiriti zeSaH / 1. jaina Aha / 11 nizcite vastuni / 12 svataH parato vA iti zaMkAyAM svata iti cet / 13 jana Aha /
Page #17
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 12 pramANanirNaye tatra pratyakSatvaM satyapi tasmiMstatprakAzavattaddharmiNo jJAnasyApi tata eva pratipattervyarthamanumAnaM bhavet / tana jnyaandhrmstprkaashH| bhavatvarthasyaiva sadharma iti cet, na, tasyApi svataH pratipattirarthasyAcetanatvena tdnupptteH| cetanatve tu vijJAnasyaivAvasthiteH / na bahirartho nAmeti tannibandhanaH kazcidapi kriyAvidhiH syAt / parataH pratipattAvapi tasmAdAtmajJAnasyaiva kuto'numAnaM, na parajJAnasya tato'pi tatprakAzasaMbhavAt / tasyApratyakSatvena tatkRtasya tatprakAzasyAzakyapratipattikatvAditi cenna, AtmajJAnasyApyapratyakSatvAvizeSAt / tannArthadharmasyApi tasya kutazcitsiddhiH, nacAsiddhasyAnyathAnupapattinirNayo yatastadanumAnamarthajJAnasya,taduktam / "anyathAnupapannatvamasiddhasya na siddhayatIti' tato'rthasya pratyakSatvamanvicchatA pratyakSametajjJAnamabhyupagantavyam / anubhavasyApi tathaiva bhAvAt / nacaivaM svaparaviSayatayA marIcikAtoyAdivedanasyApi prAmANyaprasaGgaH / samIcaM eva tadupagamAt / na ca tadvedanasya samyaktvaM bAdhavattvAt / na samAnaviSayeNa bAdhastataH saMvAdena smyktvsyaivopptteH| nA'pi visadRzaviSayeNa nIlajJAnena pItajJAnena pItajJAnasya ttprsNgaat| bAdho'pi na svarUpApahAra utpattisamaye tadbhAve tasyAnutpattiprasaMgAt / anyadA ca svayameva nAzAt / nApi viSayApahArastasya narAdhipadharmatvena jJAneSvasaMbhavAt / naca phalApahAraH phalasyApi viSayaparicchedapravRttyAda 1pravartata iti zeSaH / 2 prtyksse| 3 arthaprakAzadharmiNaH / 4 mayi jJAnamasti arthaprakAzAdyanyathAnupapatteH / 5 kriyAvidheH / 6 svakIyasya / 7 parakIyasya / .8 ukkaprakAreNa jJAnasya svaprakAzakatve sati / 9 tA-SaSThI-satyasyetyarthaH / 1. prabhAkara Aha / 11 utpattisamaye'nyadA ghaa| 12 bAdhamaMtareNa prathamajJAnasya / ___
Page #18
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ prmaannlkssnnnirnnyH| stato darzanAt / na cAparobAdhaprakAra iti cenna, tadviSayAsattvajJApanasyaiva vAdhakatvAta, tasya ca marIcikApratyaye sati nedaM toyaM kiMtu marIcikA ityAkArasyAvalokanAt / kartavyazcaivamabhyupagamo 'nyathAbAMdhAsattvasyApi avabodhanAnupapatteH, na samAnaviSayeNetyAdivicArasya vaiyopnipaataat| tanna viparyayasya prAmANyamasamyaktvAt, evamavyutpanasaMzayayorapi tatrApi yathAtattvanirNayasya samyaktvasyAbhAvAt / tatastoyAdAveva tatpratyayasya tadbhAvaHtasya cAbhyAsadazAyAM svata evAvagamo'nyathA tu padmagandhodakAharaNAdeliGgavizeSAt / na caivaM liGgapratyayasamyaktvasyApyanyato liGgAdavagame 'navasthAnaM dUrAnusaraNe'pi kasyacidabhyastaviSayasya tatpratyayasya saMbhavAt / tataH suparijJAnatvAt jJAneSu samyaktvasyaivopapanaM, idaM samyagjJAnameva pramANaM anyathA tadanupapatteriti / devasya matamudvIkSya vicArajJAninAM prabhoH / mayA'bhyadhAyi saMkSipya pramANasyeha lakSaNam // 1 // iti zrImadvAdirAjasUripraNIte pramANanirNaye prmaannlkssnnnirnnyH|| 1 nivedanasya / 2 pratiyogibhUtabAdhajJAnAbhAve tadabhAvajJAmAnupapatteH / 3 anadhyavasAyaH / 4 na tu marIcikAdau tatpratyayasya tadbhAvaH / 5 anabhyAsadazAyAM /
Page #19
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pramANanirNaye MAnanor.. prtykssnirnnyH| tacca pramANaM dvividhaM, pratyakSaM parokSaMcati / tatra yatspaSTAvabhAsaM tatpratyakSam / kiM punaridaM spASTayaM nAma ? vizeSAvabodha iti cenna, sAmastyena saMsArijJAne kvacidapi tadabhAvAt, asAmastyena tadbhAvasya parokSe pratyayebhidhAnasya mAnatvAt / AlokaparikalitagrahaNaM taditi cenna, avyApteH, rUpajJAna eva tasya bhAvAt, na spAdijJAneSu / na caiteSAmapratyakSatvameva, tatpratyakSatvasya nirvivAdatvAt / avyavahitagrahaNaM tadityapi na mantavyaM, nirmalasphaTika. vyavahite'pi vastuni spaSTasyaiva tadbhAnasyAvalokanAt / vRkSo'yaM ziMzapAtvAdityAderanumAnasyApi pratyakSatvaprasaktiravyavahitagrahaNAta, tasmAdantarmalavizleSanibandhano vizuddhivizeSa eva spAmRtyamityupapannam / sAmAnyavizeSaH spASTayamiti cedabhimatamidaM vizuddhivizeSasyaiva tattatpratyakSasahazatayA tadvizeSatvAt nityaniravayava. rUpasya ca tasya pratyAkhyAnAt / kutaH punaridamavagataM spaSTameva pratyakSamiti ? dvibAhurekazirA nara ityapi kutaH ? tathaiva pratyakSeNAvekSaNAt, / pratyakSasya spaSTatve svAnubhavanena tathaivAnvIkSaNAditi samaH smaadhiH| samyagjJAnasya vyavasAyAtmakatve pratya 1 vimataM jJAnaM pratyakSaM bhavitumarhati vizeSAvabodhakatvAt / 2 bhAgAsiddha iti bhAvaH / 3 parokSapramANanirNayaprastAve vakSyamANatvA diti nirglito'rthH| 4 anekAMtikadoSo bhavediti bhaavH| 5pratipakSamanuvRttarUpaM sAmAnyaM parokSavyAvRttarUpaM tadeva vizeSaH 6 yogamataM sAmAnyavizeSo'rthAtparasAmAnyaM / 7 janaH / prAha 8 avagatamiti zeSaH / 9 bauddho vdti|
Page #20
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pratyakSanirNayaH / kSasyApi tadbhedasya tadAtmakatvena bhavitavyaM, naca tasya tadasti, tenAbhilApasaMbaddhatayA svaviSayasyAgrahaNAt / tathA tadgahaNasyaiva vyavasAyatvAditi cet, naivaM, vyavasAyasyaivAbhAvaprasaMgAt / abhilApena hi tadgatenaiva viSayasya saMbandhastatra tadabhAvAt / smaraNopanItena saMketakAlapratipanneneti cenna / smaraNasya nirvikalpakatve tadviSayasya svalakSaNatvena kvacidupanayanAnupapatteH / vyavasAyarUpatve ca tenApi svaviSayasyAbhilApasaMbaddhasyaiva smarttavyaM, tadabhilApasyApi tathAvidhattyaiva tatsmaraNenetyanavasthitiprasaMgAt / smaraNasya tadanabhisaMbaddhavastuveditvopa vyavasAyasvabhAvatve pratyakSasyApi tatki na syAt ? abhilApasaMbandhavaikalye kutastasya vyavasAya iti cet, abhilApasmaraNasyApi kutaH ? zabdasAmAnyatatsaMbandhayogyasya tena grahaNAditi cet, pratyakSe'pi tata eva so'stu, tenA'pi sAmAnyasya vastuSu sadRzapariNAmasya paricchedAt / anyathA zuktikAdau rajatAyapekSayA sAdharmyadarzanasyAbhAvAt kathaM tannibandhanastatra ruupyaadyaaropH| yata idaM sUktaM bhavet, 'zuktau vA rajatAkAro rUpyasAdharmyadarzanAditi " / na ca sAdhAdaparaM sAmAnyamapi tasya nityavyApisvabhAvasya kvacidapyaprativedanAt / tadviSayatve'pi parAmarzavaikalyAvyavasAyameva pratyakSamiti cenna / nIlamidaM patimidaM iti tatra parAmarzasya prtiptteH| pratyakSAdanya eva saH parAmarza iti cennai spaSTatvena pratibhAsanAt, 1 abhilApasaMbaddhasya svaviSayasyetyarthaH / 2 " vikalpo nAma saMzritaH " iti vacanAtsvAbhidhAnavizeSApekSA eva nizcayairnizcIyate ityabhyupagamAt / 3 abhilApasaM. baddhasvaviSayagrahaNasya vyavasAyatve / 4 ananyadezakAlAkAratvena / 5 vastusaMbaddhasAmAnyagrahaNAdeva / sadRzapariNAmasyAsAmAnyatve / 6 kalpanA iti zeSaH / 7 jainH|
Page #21
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pramANanirNaye spASTayamapi tatra pratyakSapratyAsatteraghyAropitameva na vAsta. vamiti cet, pratyakSasya caitanyamapyarthAntaracetanasaMsargAdadhyAropitameva na vAstavamiti kiM na syAt ? yataH sAMkhyamatasyAnabhyupagamaH pratyakSAdijJAnavyatirekeNa cetanasyApratipatteriti cet / n| parAmarzavyatirekeNa pratyakSasyApratItaH / vikalpapratisaMhAravelAyAM tathaiva tasya pratipattiriti cet, na / sakalacittavRttivikalacelAyAM cetanasya tathaivAnubhavAt, ata eva evoktaM " tadA draSTuH svarUpe'vasthAna" miti zrUyata eva kevalaM tAzI velA na kadAcidapyupalabhyata iti samAnamitarave lAyAmapi tato yathA pratyakSAderanyanna cetnmndhyvsiteH| tathA tata eva na parAmarzAdanyatpratyakSamapi / ata eva parAmarzAtmakatvaM spASTayameva mAnasapratyakSasya prtipaaditmlngkaare| idamityAdi yajjJAnamabhyAsAtpurataH sthite / sAkSAtkaraNatastatra pratyakSa mAnasaM matam // iti kathaM punarvyavasAyAtmakatve pratyakSasyAzvaM vikalpayato godarzanaM vyavasAyena gAM pazyatastatra tadanyAropasyAsaMbhavAt / nizcayAropamanasorbAdhyabAdhakabhAvAditi cenna / tadA derzanenAzvasAdharmyasyaiva gavi vyavasAyAttatra cAropasyAnupapattervizeSAkAre tasyAropo na ca tasya vyvsaayH| kutastarhi tatra tadAropaiti cet sAdharmyanirNa 1 cetanasaMsargAcetanA buddhirityasya 2 bauddho vadati 3 " saMhRtya sarvatazciMtAM stimitenaaNtraatmnaa| sthito'pi cakSuSA rUpamIkSate sA'kSajA mati" riti 4 sAMkhyariti zeSaH 5 yathA zabdena dRSTataH parAmRzyate 6 bhinaM 7 anizcayAt 8 bastunIti zeSaH 9 vauddho vadati 10 gavi azvo'yamityAdyAropasya 11 nizcayajJAnAropajJAnna yoH 12 goriti zeSaH 13 khaMDamuMDAkAre /
Page #22
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pratyakSanirNayaH / yAdeva tasya tadanukUlatayA pratIteH / bhavatastu duHparihara evAyaM prynuyogH| mAnasapratyakSeNa nIlAdivat kSaNakSayAderepi nirNaye kathaM tatrAkSaNikatvAdyAropo ytstvyvcchedaarthmnumaanpriklpnmiti| na ca tasya tenAnirNayo nIlAdAvapi tatprasaMgAt / asakalapratipattera bhyupagamAt / na cAsmAkaM parAmarzabhAvena prasitaM, manovyavasAyasya vinApi tenAvyutpattyAdivirodhirUpatayaivopapatteH / atadUpasya tu na prAmANyaM avisaMvAdavaikalyAt / tathAhi / yadavisaMvAdavikalaM na tatpramANaM, yathA ajJasya viSadarzanaM, tadvikalaM ca saugataparikalpitaM darzanamavisaMvAdo hi itthaM geyamitthaM citramityabhisandhikaraNamevA-"bhiprAyanivedanAdavisaMvAdana"-miti vacanAt / na ca tannivedanamavyavasAyasya, ajJaviSadarzanasyApi tatprasaMgAt / avyasAyasyApi darzanasya vyavasAyajananAttanivedanamiti cenna / avyavasAyAd vyavasAyasya gardabhAdazvasyevAnupapatteH / vyavasAyavAsanonmIlanenAvyavasAyasyApi vyavasAyahetutvaM darzanasyeti cenna / tadvadarthasyaiva taddhatutvaprasaMgena antargaDuno darzanasyAkalpanApatteH / vyavasAyahetutvena cAvisaMvAditvamaupacArikameva darzanasya syAt / mukhyataH saMnipatyAbhiprAyanivedanena vyavasAyasyaiva tadupapatteH / na ca tatastasya prAmANyaM / sannikarSAdAvapi 1 bauddhasya mAnasaM pratyakSa vyavasAyAtmakamiti saugatamatam / 2 svargaprApa. NAdi 3 sarva kSaNikaM satvAdityAdi / 4 tasmAd dRSTasya bhAvasya dRSTa evAkhilo guNaH / bhrAMtenizcIyate neti sAdhanaM saMpravartate // iti bauddharvastuno niraMzatvAmyupagamAt 5 nityaprasaktaM saMbaddhamityarthaH 6 abhiprAyakaraNameva 7 vasaH, darzanasyetyarthaH / 8 prAkaTayena / 9 nirarthakasya / 10 avyavadhAnena / 11 anyatheti zeSaH /
Page #23
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 68 pramANanirNaye tatprasaGgAt / tato yuktamavisaMvAdavaikalyAddarzanamapramANamiti / taduktam / viSadarzanavat sarvamajJasya kalpanAtmakam / darzanaM na pramANaM syAdavisaMvAdahAnitaH // 1 // iti prAmANyAbhAve ca dUrataH pratyakSatvaM, tasya tadvizeSatvena tadabhAve'nupapatterataH pratyakSAbhAsaM taditi pratipattavyaM / bhavatu tarhIndriyArthayoH sannikarSaH pratyakSaM, vastusAkSAtkaraNasya sarvatra tata eva bhAvAditi cenna / tasyAcetanatayA vastupramitau sAdhakatamatvAnupapattyA prAmANyasyaiva pratikSepAt / na ca tata eva sAkSAtkaraNaM viSayasya tadbhAvepi cakSuSA paTasya tatpratipatteH / astyeva cakSuSastadviSayeNa sannikarSaH, pratyakSasya tatrAsatve'pyanumAnatastadavagamAt / taccedamanumAnaM; cakSuH sannikRSTamarthaM prakAzayati bAhyendriyatvAttvagAdivat / iticet; atra na tAvadgolakameva cakSustaMdviSayasannikarSapratijJAnasya pratyakSeNa bAdhanAttena tatra tadabhAvasyaiva pratipatterhetozca tadvAdhitakarmanirdezAnantaraM prayuktatayA kAlAtyayApadiSTatopanipAtAt / na tanmAtraM cakSustadrazmikalApasya tattvAttasya ca razmiparItaM cakSustaijasatvAt pradIpavadityaMtastaijasatvasyApi taijasaM cakSuH rUpAdInAM madhye rUpasyaiva prakAzakatvAttadvadityanumAnato'vagamAditi cet / kiM punaratra cakSuryatra taijasatvaM sAdhyaM ? na golakameva tasya rUpaprakAzakatvAsiddheH; raoNzmaparikalpanAvaiphalyaprasaMgAt / razmiparikaritamiti cenna, tasyAdyApya 1 avyavasAyAtmakam / 2 tasya viSayeNa saha sannikarSapratijJAnasya, cakSuH nikRSTamarthaM prakAzayatIti pratijJAyA ityarthaH / 3 viSayakathanapazcAt / atoSnumAnAt / 5 tadasiddhau taijasatvAsiddhiH, tadasiddhau ca razmiparikalpitatvasyAsiddhiH / 6 cakSuH /
Page #24
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pratyakSanirNayaH / 19 siddhatvena rUpAdInAmityAde hai torAzrayAsiddhadoSAt / vyabhicArI cAyaM hetuH - svacchajalena tasya tadntargatarUpamAtra prakAzatve'pi taijasatvAbhAvAnna taijasatvAdrazmivatvaM cakSuSaH / arazmivatA kuto na tena vyavahitasyApi grahaNamaprApteravizeSAt ? razmivatApi kuto na svasannikRSTasyAMjanAderaMjanazalAkAdeH pradIpAdineva grahaNaM prApterabhedAt ? tathA svAbhAvyAt, iti samAnamanyatrApi samAdhAnam / tato golakameva kevalaM cakSurnaca tasya viSayasaMnikarSa / iti siddham vinApi tena tadviSayasya sAkSAtkaraNaM / tathA sukhAderapi / tadvedana mapi saMnikarSajameva vedanatvAt ghaTAdivedanavat / sannikarSo'pi tatra saMyuktasamavAyo manaHsaMyukte Atmani sukhAdeH samavAyAditi cenna / dRSTAntasya sAdhyavaikalyAttatra sannikarSAbhAvasya nirUpitatvAt / api ca yadi tadvedanAdanarthAntaraM sukhAdirna tarhi tena manasaH saMnikarSaH, tataH pUrvaM tasyaivAbhAvAt / vedanasamaye bhAve'pi vyarthastatsaMnikarSastasya vedanArthatvAt / tasya ca tataH prAgevotpatteH / arthAntarameva tataH sukhAdirataH prAgapi tasya bhAva iti cet, sa yadyanubhavarahitasyaiva sakalatatpUrvasamaye'pi bhAva, iti na candanadahanAdestasyotpattiH zakyAMvaklRptiH / anubhavasahitasyaiveti cenna tarhi tasmAdindriyasaMnikRSTAdutpattistadvedanasya samasamayabhAvitvAt / anubhavaviruddhaM ca sukhAdestadvedanAdarthAntaratvaM svasaMvedanarUpasyaiva tasyAnubhavAt / kathaM tarhi tadvedanasya prAmANya 1 yaugo vadati / 2 siddhAntI prAha // 3 pradIpAya kajjalarekhAdeH / 4 yathA ghaTAdau prAptistathAM'janAdAvapIti prAptyabhedaH / 5 utpAdakatvAt / 6 dvaMdvasamAsaH kAryaH, caMdanAtsukhasya dahanAt ameH duHkhasya / 7 zakyA kalpanA 8 anyaH prAha /
Page #25
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ .20 pramANanirNaye mAtmavedanamAtrasya tadanabhyupagamAt / " arthAtmavedanaM nyAyaM prAhu " rityuktatvAditi cenna / anugrahapIDAdirUpeNa tasya tadvedanAtkathaMcidarthAntarasyApi bhAvA~daikAntikasyaiva tatastadbhedasya tathA tadanubhavAbhAvena pratyAkhyAnAdityupapannamavyApakatvaM saMnikarSasya / tadabhAve ghaTAdau sukhAdau ca pratyakSasyoktayopapattyA vyavasthApanAt / yadi ca saMnikarSasya pratyakSatvaM tarhi cakSuSA rUpavadrasAderapi grahaNaprasaMgastasya tatravetaratrApi saMyuktasamavAyena saMnikarSAt , tadvizeSasyAbhAvAt / no cettasyaiva tarhi pratyakSatvaM, sati tasminviSayasaMvitteniyamAt / na saMnikarSasya viparyayAdityanupapannaM tallakSaNatvaM pratyakSasya / yatpunarmImAMsakasya mataM " indriyaviSayasaMprayogAdutpannaM jJAnaM pratyakSaM" iti, tadapi na yuktm| saMprayogasya saMnikarSArthatve naiyAyikavaddoSAt / yadi cendriyasannikarSAttadavacchinna evAtmapradeze jJAnaM; tarhi tadapekSayA parvatAdeH pratyAsannatvAttatra kimapekSya dUrAdipratipattiH / golakAdhiSThAnaM zarIramapekSyati cenna, tasyA~sanni kRSTatayA tajjJAnenAgrahaNAt / nacAgRhIte tasmistato'yamatidUra iti bhavati prtiitiH|arntrennaapi saMnikarSa tasya grahaNe parvatAderapi syAditi na yuktaM tatra tatkalpanaM / golakAdhiSThAna evAtmapradeze tatastaMjjJAnamiti cetkathamindriyAgravartinastasmAttanmUlagate tatra viSayajJAnamindriyAntareSvevamadarzanAt / tatrAdRSTasyApi cakSuSi 1 janaiH / 2 pramANam / 3 ekAMtena niyamena bhavaH tasyaikAMtikasya // 4 indriyANAmarthe vyApAraH, tatpraguNatayA'vasthAnaM,kAryA'vaseyA zaktirvA saMprayogaH 5AtmanaH sarvagatatvAt / 6 saMnikarSAbhAvena / 7 sanikarSajJAnena / 8 vinetyarthaH / 9 vissyjnyaanN| 10 arthajJAnaM / 11 anupalabdheH / 12 anupalabdhasyApi viSayajJAnasya /
Page #26
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ prtykssnirnnyH| kalpanAyAM varamaprApyakAritvameva kalpitamaprApyakAriNa eva golakasya prtiiteH| ___ na ca golakaM cakSustadrazmiprasarasya tattvAditi cet, kathaM tarhi cakSurarthasya cikitsAvidhegolake karaNamanyArthasyAnyatra tadanupapatteH / cakSurarthasya pAde kathamabhyaGgasya karaNamiti cenna, pAdAbhyaktasya snehasya tannADIrandhradvAreNa cakSuravAtasya tadupakAritvAt / na caivaM golakAbhyaktasyAMjanAdestadvahirgatarazmiprasarAvAptistadanupalaMbhAt / na ca zakyopalaMbhasyAnupalabdhiraMntareNAbhAvaM saMbhavati, tanna saMprayogasya saMnikarSArthatvam / ___ anukUlArthatvamiti cet, syaanmtN|grhnnaanukuulyenaavsthaanmev viSayaviSayiNoH saMprayoga iti tanna, viSayAnukUlyagrahaNaM pratyanupayogAt / anyathA tadrahitasya dvicaMdrAderagrahaNaprApteH / asatastadrahitasyApi grahaNaM na sata iti ca vibhAgaparikalpanasya nirbandha. natvAt / tanna saMprayogasyApi pratyakSatvaM / __ bhavatu vyavasAyasyaiva viSayAkArapariNativizeSAtmano buddhivyApArasya pratyakSatvaM, prativiSayAdhyavasAyo dRSTamitivacanAdU, dRSTa mitica pratyakSasyAbhidhAnAditi cenn| viSayAkArapariNAme buddherdapaNAdivadeva tasyAH praamaannyaanmuurtttvenaacetntvaaptteH| acetanaiva buddhiranityatvAtkalazAdivaditi cet| kathamidAnI darpaNAdivadeva tasyAHprAmANyaM yatastavyApAravizeSasya pratyakSatvaM, tasya tadvizeSatvena tadabhAve'nupapatteH / cetanasaMparkAcetanaiva buddhiriti cet / kuto na darpaNAdirapyevaM? cetanasya vyApakatvena tatsaMparkasya tatrApi bhAvAt / buddhAveva tadvizeSasya bhAvAditi cet / sa ko'paro'nyatra 1 cakSunimittasya / 2 abhAvaM vineti bhAvaH / 3 jaino vadati / 4 grahaNayo. gytyaa| 5 arthAnimittakatvAt / 6 niHkAraNatvAt /
Page #27
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 22 pramANanirNaye tatsvAbhAvyAditi cetanAtmaiva buddhiH| na caivaM tatra viSayAkArakalpanamupapannaM mUrttatvAbhAvAt, mUrteSu eva darpaNAdiSu mUrtamukhAdyAkArasyopalaMbhAditi na tadAkArasya vyavasAyatvena pratyakSatvakalpanamupapattimat / kuto vA buddharanyasya cetanasya bhAve tata eva na viSayapratipattiryato buddhestadarthAntarasya kalpanaM / buddhikaraNakAdeva tatastatpratipattikaraNakasya tatra tayApArasyAsaMbhavAttato buddhayadhyavasitaM buddhipratisaMkrAntameva cetanaH pratipadyate, tato yuktameva tatkalpanaM sAphalyAditi cenna / buddhayapratipattau tatpratisaMkrAntasya viSayasyAzakyapratipattikatvAddarpaNApratipattau ttprtisNkraantmukhprtiptterprtiptteH| tatprAtipattizca yadi buddhayantarapratisaMkramadvAreNa, bhavatyanavasthAnaM; tadantarasyApi tadaparatapratisaMkramadvAreNaiva prtiptteH| atadvArAyAMtu pratipattau viSayapratipatterapi buddhipratisaMkramanirapekSAyA evopapatteH kathaM na vyathaiva buddhiparikalpanA bhavet / buddheviSayapratipattivat svapratipattAvapi svayameva karaNatvAdupapannaM tatpratipattestadantarapratisaMkramanirapekSaNaM / na caivaM viSayapratipatteviSayasya grAhyatayA karmatvena svapratipattau karaNatvAnupapatteriti cet kathamidAnI buddharapi tatpratipattau karaNasya karmatvaM yatastadgAhyatA bhavet, karmaNaH karaNatvavat karaNasyApi karmatvAnupapatteH / buddhAvubhayadharmopapattau viSaye'pi syAdavizeSAt / viSayasya svapratipattikaraNatve sarvopi viSayaH sarvasya pratipanna eva bhavettatpratipattikaraNabhAvasya sarvatra tatra bhAvAditi cenna, buddhAvapyevaM prasaMgAt / 1 sAMkhyo vakti 2 buddhivyApArasya / 3 buddhipratibiMbitameva viSayaM / 4 jAnAti / / 5 pratItA apratItA veti vikalpadvayaM kalpayannAha / 6 karmatvakaraNatve /
Page #28
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pratyakSanirNayaH / 23 atha yA yasya buddhiH saiva tasya tatpratipattau karaNaM nAparA tadayamadoSa iti / yesyati kutaH ? kuzcitpratyAsattivizeSAditi cenna, viSaye'pi tulyatvAt / tasyApi hi yo yasya pratyAsannaH sa eva tasya tatpratipattau karaNaM nApara iti vaktuM zakyatvAt / sarvopi sarvAtmAnaM prati pratyAsanna evAtmano vyApakatvena sarvatra tatra bhAvAdityapi samAnaM buddhiSvapi / tanna viSayapratipattau viSayavabuddherapi karaNatvamiti na tadvyApArasya pratyakSatvaM, prAguktasya samyagjJAnasyaiva spaSTAvabhAsinastadupapatteH / atha pratyakSasya bhedadvayavarNanaM vidhIyate / tacca pratyakSaM dvividhaM, sAMvyavahArikaM mukhyaM cati / sAMvyavahArikamapi dvividhaM, indriyapratyakSamanindriyapratyakSaM ceti / tatredriyasya cakSurAdeH kArya yabahirnIlAdisaMvedanaM tadindriyapratyakSam / kaithaM punastasya viSayaniyamaH? kaithaM ca na syAt ! saMvedanAtmanA nIlAdivattadaparaniravazeSaviSayApekSayA'pi tasya tulyatvAditi cenna, zaktiniyamatastadupapatteH / niyatazaktikA hi saMvittayaH svahetusAmarthyAdupajAyate saMsAriNAmato niyatasyaiva viSayasya pratipattirna sarvasya / yAvanniyatazaktikatvAttatra viSayaniyamastA vanniyataviSayasArUpyAdevatiM kuto na bhavet / bhavati hi nIlasArUpye saMvedanasya nIlasyaivedaM saMvedanaM na pItAderiti tanniyama, iti cet, kiM punastasya tatsArUpyaM? na tAvatsadAdirUpaM tasyApisarvatra sAdhAraNatvena niyAmakatvAnupapatteH / nIlarUpameva taditi 1 syAdvAdI Aha / 2 buddharatatvAmyupagamAditi zeSaH // 3 saugataH pRcchati / 4 jainaH pRcchati / 5 cakSurAdikAryasaMvedanasya / 6 jJAnAvaraNavIryAtarAyakarmakSayopazamasAmarthyAt / 7 yathA / 8 tathA / 9 viSapaniyamaH / 10 sti| ...
Page #29
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 24 rexmmmmmmmm pramANanirNaye cenna / tasya bahireva darzanAna saMvedane, tasyAMntarataMdrUpasyaivopalaMbhAt / pratipAditazca tasya saMvedanavahirbhAvaH purastAt / kuto na vA nIlasaMvedanaM nIleneva pItAdinA'pi saMrUpaM ? tasyaiva tatkAraNatvAditi cet, kiM na cakSurAdinApi tasyApi taddhetutvAvizeSAt / nIlAnukaraNa eva tasya zaktiriti cet, vyarthamidAnIM tatra tatsArUpyaM, zaktita eva niyamavatyA viSayaniyamopapatteH / evaM hi pAraMparyaparizramaH parihRto bhavati, zaktiniyamAtsArUpyaniyamastato'pi viSayaniyama iti / satyapi sArUpye kiMvA tannIlaM yannIlasyetyuktaM / na saMvedanagataM, tatra bhedAbhAvena vyatirekavibhaktaranupapatteH / bahirgatamiti cet, tatrApi kutaH saMvedanaM ? tasya tadviSayatvAditi cettadapi kutaH ? sAkSAdeva tena tasya grahaNAditi cenna, bahirantArUpatayA nIladvayasyAprativedanAt / tatsarUpatvAttadviSayatvaM na sAkSAditi cenna, tathA tadapratipattau tatsarUpatvasyaiva dukha bodhatvAt / dvayorhi pratipattau bhavati tadgatasya sArUpyasya pratipatti pratipattau, " dviSThasArUpyasaMvittikarUpapravedanAt, dvayoH svarUpagrahaNe sati sArUpyavedanam" iti nyAyAt / tato yuktaM zaktiniyamAdeva viSayaniyamaH saMvedanasyati / tadAkAratvena tu tasya taniyame kezamazakAdau kutastatsaMvedanasya niyamaH / nahi tatra tadAkAratvaM, kezamazakAderasadrUpatayA tadarpakatvAnupapatteH / ataH sakalasyApyasatastadviSayatvena bhavitavyam / atadAkAratayA vivakSitavaditaraniravazeSAvidyamAnApekSayApi tasyAvizeSAt / na vA kasyacidapItyaprative 1 madhye ityarthaH / 2 anIlarUpasya / 3 samAnarUpaM / 4 shktiprtipaadnsmye||
Page #30
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pratyakSanirNayaH / 1 danamevA sadrUpasyeti na pratyakSalakSaNe tadvyavacchedArthamabhrAMtagrahaNamupapannam / svayamevAsati tadvedane vyavacchedanasya kiMzuke rAgArpaNavadanupapatteH / kathaM punarasataH kezAderAkArArpaNavadviSayatvamapI ti cet, syAdayaM prasaMgo yadi tasya svazaktito viSayatvaM / na caivaM vedanasAmarthyAdeva tadbhAvAttAdRzaM tatsAmarthyamasyAMtarAdadRSTavizepAdvAhyAdapi garalAsvAdakAmalAderiti pratipattavyamanumaMtavyaM cedamittham / anyathA kvacitkasyacidapi vyAmohasyAnupapattyA tadvyavacchedArthasya zastrasya vaiphalyopanipAtAt / asadarthaprativedanAdaM parasya ca vyAmohasyAnupapatteH / tataH sthitaM svazaktito viSayaniyamaH saMvedanasya tattvAdasadviSayaniyamavaditi / na kasyApyasataH saMvedanaM kezAderapi dezAMtarAdau sata eva kaoNmalinA prativedanAditi kecit / tanna / tadvedanasya graMthAvasthitatatkezAdiviSayatve vibhramatvAbhAvApatteH / ataddezAditvena grahaNAdvibhramatvamiti cet na, ataddezatvAdestatrAsatvAt / asatopi tasya grahaNe kezAdereva kiM na syAMta, yatastatpratipattirasatkhyAtireva na bhavet / arthaviSayaiva tadvittistadarthasya tvalaukikatvAttatra vibhramAbhimAno lokasyeti mataM yasya tasyApi kimidaM tadarthasyAlaukikatvaM ? saMmAnadezakAlairapyanyaistaddarzananimittAbhAvenIdRzyatvamiti cet, kiM punastannimittaM yadabhAvAttasyAdRzyatvaM / kAcAdireva kAraNadoSa iti cet, vyAhata " 1 prAmANyaM vyavahAreNa zAstraM mohanivarttanamiti vAkyAt / 2 saMkhyAtirasatkhyAtiH prasiddhArthakhyAtirAtmakhyAtirviparItArthakhyAtiH smRtipramoSa ityevaMrUpasyAparasyeti bhaavH| 3 bhavatIti zeSaH / 4 puMsA / 5 sAMkhyAH / 6 yathArthasthita / 7 tathA ca na kasyApyasataH saMvedanamityAdi na syAt / 8 paraH prAha / 9 puMbhiH / 10 kezAdidarzana / 11 viSayasya / 12 kezAdeH / 25
Page #31
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 26 pramANanirNaye midaM vastusadviSayavedanahetArdoSatvamiti cakSurAderapi tttvaaptteH| na cAsAvadoSa eva tacikitsAyAmanarthatvaprasaMgAt / alau kikatvaM loke tasyAvidyamAnatvaM, tadapi tatprayojanAniSpAdanAditi cet, asadviSayaiva tarhi tatpratItiriti spaSTamAbhidhAtavyaM, kimlaukikaarthkhyaatiritybhidhiiyte|smRtireveyN prAganubhUtasyaiva kezAdeH kAcAdimato'pi prativedanAnAsato'tiprasaMgAdityapi kasyacidvacanamasamIcInameva, smRtitve purovartitayA tasyAprativedanaprasaMgAt / pramoSavazAttathA tatprativedanamiti cet, kaH punarayaM pramoSo nAma ? svarUpAtpracyutiriti cenna tarhi smRtiriti kathaM tayA kezAdeH prativedanaM / svarUpAtpracyutApyasti smRtiyadi mate tava / supto na kiM prabuddho'stu jIvito'stu mRto na kiMm / / atha svaviSayasya purovartitayA grAhakatvameva kutazcittasyAH pramoSaH / tanna / purobhAvasyAsatve grahaNAnupapatteH, anyathA kezAderevAsatastatsaMbhavAdasatrakhyAtireva saMbhavenna smRtipramoSaH / tataH sthitaM yathA svahetusAmarthyAdevAsavabhAsina indriyajJAnasya viSayaniyamastathA sadavabhAsino'pi / tanna sArUpyAttatkalpanamupapatraM / iti nirUpitamiMdriyapratyakSam / 1 vastusadviSayavedanahetutvAvizeSAt / 2 guNaH / 3 tena kezAdinA prayojanasyArthakriyAlakSaNasyAniHpAdanAt 4 kimarthamityarthaH / 5 puMsA 6 suptazcetprabuddhastarhi tasya smaraNena bhavitavyaM tacca tasya nAstIti kathaM tasya tattvamiti kasyacitpraznasyApi svarUpAtpracyutA smRtirastItyuttaraM vAcyaM / evamagrasthe cturthaaNshe'pi| 7ataddezatvenAnubhUtasya / 8 grahaNameva 9 kAraNAditi zeSaH 10 purovidymaantvsy| 11 purobhAvasyAsatva'pi tadhaNAt /
Page #32
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ prtykssnirnnyH| 27 adhunA anidriyapratyakSasvarUpakathanArthamAha / kiM punaranidriyapratyakSamiti cet,sukhAdeH smaraNAdijJAnasya ca svarUpavedanamevaM tatra spaSTAvabhAsitayA pratyakSavyapadezopapatteH / anidriyaM ceha na paudgalikaM manaH pratipattavyaM, tadAyattajanmatve sukhAdismaraNAdInAM kAkAdiSvamanaskeSu tadabhAvAnuSaMgAt / na ca tatra na saMtyeva tAni, smaraNapratyabhijJAnAdinibaMdhanatayA svadehopalabdhasya pravRttyAdestatrApi pratipatterataH kSayopazamavi. zeSAliMgitaH kazcidAtmapradeza evAnidriyaM, tatprAdhAnyena sukhAdyutpatteH kAkAdiSvapyupapatterata eva gurubhiranaMtavIryadevairaipi tasyaivAnidriyatvamabhyanujJAtam / kiM punarevaM dravyamanasaH parikalpaneneti cet, dravyendriyasya cakSurAderapi kiM ? na kiMcit , ata eva tadvyApArAbhAve'pi satya svanAdAvantaraMgAdvizuddhivizeSAdeva rUpAdidarzanaM / tadidriyasya tu jAgradazAbhAvini tadarzane taddhetorvizuddhivizeSasya tadadhikaraNajIvapradezAdhiSThAnatvena nimittamAtratvAde kalpanamata eva gavAkSasthAnIyatAM tatra vyAvarNayAMta tattvavedina iti cet, taMrhi dravyamanaso'pi parikalpanaM kvacitsakaleMdriyasya sukhAdivedane tadavaSTabdhajIvapradezAzrayavizuddhivizeSanibaMdhane nimittatayaiva / na ca nimittena sarvadA tatkArye bhavitavyamiti niyamo gavAkSAdinA vyabhicArAt / kutaH punaH zaktivizeSasya kSayopazamAtmano'vagamo yatastatprabhavatvamiMdriyAdipratyakSasyeti cet, tata eva pratyakSAt / na tAvattadahetukaM kAdAcitkatvAt / nApi dravyedriya 1 aSTadalakamalAkAraM / 2 kSayopazamavizeSAliMgitAtmapradezasyAnidiyatve / 3 paMceMdriyasya / 4 jIvasyeti / 5 jIvasyeti / 6 vivakSita iti zeSaH /
Page #33
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 28 pramANanirNaye mAtrAttedabhAve'pi kvacidutpatteH, kadAcittadbhAve'pyanutpatteH / tAdRzaM ca tadAtmani kAraNAntarasya prAdhAnyamAvedayati / tacca yathoktazaktivizeSa evetyupapannamiMdriyAdipratyakSasya tatprabhavatvamiti / kutaH punastadubhayasyApi mukhyameva pratyakSatvaM na bhavatIti cet, vaizadyasAkalyasya tannibaMdhanasya tatrAbhAvAt / vyAvahArikatvaM tu tatra tasya vaizaye lezopAzrayeNa lokasya pratyakSavyavahAraprasi ddhH| tatpunarubhayamapi pratyakSaM pratyekamavagrahehA''vAyadhAraNAvika lpAccaturvidhaM / tatra viSayaviSayirsannipAtAnaMtarabhAvisattAlocanapuraHsaro manuSyatvAdyavAMtarasAmAnyAdhyavasAyipratyayo'vagrahaH / tadavagRhItavizeSasya devadattena bhavitavyamiti bhavitavyatAmullikhaMtI prtiitiriihaa| tadviSayasya devadatta evAyamityavadhAraNAvAnadhyavasAyo'vAyaHtasyaiva kAlAMtarasmaraNayogyatayA grahaNaM dhaarnnaa| tadeteSAmavagrahAdivikalpAnAM pUrvapUrvasya pramANatvamuttarottarasya ca tatphalatvaM pratipattavyam / svArthavyavasAyasyAvyutpattyAdivyava cchedAtmanastadgatasyApi kathaMcitpUrvapUrvasmAdutpatteH viSayabhedanibaMdhanazcAvagrahAdInAmasti saMkhyAvikalpaH sonyatra pratipattavya / iti vyAkhyAtaM vyavahArikamiMdriyapratyakSamanidriyapratyakSaM ca / adhunA mukhyapratyakSasvarUpapratipAdanAyAha / mukhyaM tu pratyakSamatIMdriyapratyakSaM / tad dvividhaM, sakalaM vikalaM ceti / vikalamapi dvividhamavadhirmanaHparyayazceti / tatrAvadhirnA 1 dravyedriyAmAvepi / 2 satyasvapnAdau / 3 anyvstugtcittkaale| 4 dravyeMdriyabhAvAbhAvAbhyAmutpatyanutpattivikalaM / 5 iMdriyAnidriyapratyakSabhedAt / 6 yogyadezAvasthAna / 7 darzana / 8 avAyaviSayasyaiva / /
Page #34
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pratyakSanirNayaH / mAvadhijJAnAvaraNavayitarAyakSayopazamavizeSApekSayA prAdurbhAvo rUpAdhikaraNabhAvagocaro viSadAvabhAsI pratyayavizeSaH / saca trividhaH, dezAvadhiparamAvadhisarvAvadhivikalpAt / tatra dezAvadhe - matijJAnaviSayasyAsarva paryAyadravyalakSaNasyAnaMtaikabhAgaH, tadanaMtaikabhAgaH paramAvadheH, tadnaMtaikabhAgazca sarvAvadheviSayaH pratipattavyaH / vizudvayatizaya pUrvasmAduttarotarasyeti / tathA mana:paryayo'pi saMyamai kArthasamavAyI tadAvaraNavIryAntarAyakSayopazamavizeSanibandhanaH paramanogatArthasAkSAtkArI pratyayaH / so'pi dvedhA, Rjumativipulamatizceti / tatra guNamanovAkkAyairnirvartito'rthaH pUrvasya, praguNairitarairvA manovAkkAyairnirvartito nirvartitaJcArthaH pazcimasya viSayaH / sUkSamatayA tu sarvAvadhiviSayAnaMtaikabhAge pUrvasya tadanaMtaikabhAge parasya nibaMdhaH / tathA vizu yatizayavizeSavattvAdapratipAtitvAcca pUrvasmAduttarasya vizeSo veditavya / iti vyAkhyAtaM vikalamatIMdriyapratyakSam / 29 sakalaM tu tatpratyakSaM prakSINAzeSaghAtimalasemunmIlitaM sakalavastuyAthAtmya vediniratizayavaizadyAlaMkRtaM kevalajJAnaM / tadvataH puruSasya sadbhAve kiM pramANamiti cet / idamanumAnaM--asti sarvajJo nirvAdhapratyayaviSayatvAt sukhAdinIlAdivat / na ca tatpratyaye vivAdastanniSedhavAdino'pi tadbhAvAdanyathA tanniSedhasyaiva tadviSayaparijJAnAbhAvenAsaMbhavaprasaMgAt / nirvAdhatvamapi tasya pratyakSAdInAmanyatamasyApi tadvAdhakatvAsaMbhavAt / tadbAdhakaravaM nAma tadviSayAsatvanivedanameva / tacca pratyakSeNa yadi kvacit 1 padArthaH 2 asarva paryAyaM dvavyaM lakSaNaM yasyeti samAso vidheyaH 3 sUkSmarUpatayA / 4 bhavatIti zeSaH / 5 AtmalakSaNArthe / 6 Rju / 7 pareSAM / 8 niSpannaH 9 vRtraiH / 10 pravRttiH / 11 prAdurbhUtam /
Page #35
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pramANanirNaye kadAcitkicidaniSTamabhyupagamAt / sarvatra sadApIti cenna, tasya sarvaviSayatvaprasaMgAt / anyathA tatra tena tnnivednaanupptteH| bhUtalamavalokayataiva tena tatra ghaTAdyasatvavedanasya pratIteH / pratyakSAbhAve ca tatpUrvakatvenAnumAnasyApyasaMbhavAt, na tasyApi tadvAdhakatvaM / yadapi vivAdApannaH sarvopi dezAdiH sarvajJavikalo dezAditvAt prasiddhadezAdivaditi, tadapi na sAdhu / dezAdeH sarvasyApratipattau hetorAzrayasvarUpAsiddhadoSopanipAtAta; pratipattI ca tatpratipattimataH sarvajJatvApattyA sarvajJanirAkaraNAnupapatteH / yadapIda-vivAdApannaH sarvajJo na bhavati puruSatvavatkRtvAde rathyApuruSavadityanumAnaM tadapi na tasya bAdhakaM / puruSatvAderhetvAbhAsatayA nirUpayiSyamANatvena tadudbhAvitasya tasyApyanumAnAbhAsatvenaivAvasthiteH / nApyarthApattistadutthApakasya sarvajJAbhAvamaMtareNAnupapannasya kasyacidarthasyAnadhyavasAyAt / nApyahamiva sarve puruSAH pratiniyatamarthamiMdriyaiH pazyaMtItyupapannamuMpamAnamapi, sarvapuruSANAM kutazcidviSayIkaraNe svasarvaveditvApatteraviSayIkaraNe tvasmRtiviSayatvenopameyatvAnupapatteH / smaraNaviSayatvena hi teSAM svasAdRzyaviziSTatayopameyatvaM / tasmAdyatsmaryate tatsyAtsAdRzyena vizeSitam / prameyamupamAnasya sAdRzyaM vA tadanvitam // iti vacanAt // zobda pramANaM sakaladarzinaH sattAviSayameva " hiraNyagarbha 1 puMsA / 2 ucyate iti shessH| 3 arthApattilakSmAdaH-pramANaSaTvijJAto yatrArtho nAnyathA bhavet / adRSTaM kalpayedenaM sArthApattirudAhRtA / 4 upamAnalakSaNamadaH-dRzyamAnAdyadanyatra vijnyaanmupjaayte| sAdRzyopAdhi tattvajJairupamAnamihodhyate / 5 viSayaM / 6 zAbdalakSaNaM yathA-zabdAdyaduditaM jJAnamapratyakSe'pi vastuni / zAbdaM taditi manyate pramANAMtaravAdinaH /
Page #36
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pratyakSanirNayaH / prakRtya sarvajJa ityAdestasyaiva zravaNAt / na ca pratyAkSAderebhAvaviSayatvaM bhAvapramANakalpanAvaiphalyaprasaMgAt / bhavatvabhAvAdeva pramANAtsarvajJasyAbhAvapratItiH, sa ca tadviSayapratyakSAdinivRttirUpo'nupalaMbha iti cenna, tasyAtmasaMbaMdhinaH paracetovRttivizeSairvyabhicArAt, vidyamAneSvapi teSu tasya bhAvAt / tadvidyamAnatAyAzca pazcAtkutazcitkAryavizeSato'dhyavasAyAt / sarvasaMbaMdhinazcAsiddheH sarvajJasyAbhAvAsiddhau tasya svayaM sarvajJAntareNApyupalambhasaMbhavAt / abhAvasiddhau tasya siddhyatyeva sarvasaMbaMdhI tadanupalaMbha iti cet, na / siddhAttataH tadabhAvasiddhistatazca tatsiddhiriti parasparAzrayopanipAtAt / anyavastuni vijJAnaM tarhi taditi cet, kiM tadanyadvastu ? niyato dezAdizcet, na / tatastatra tadabhAvesyaSTatvAt / sarva iti cenna tajjJAnavataH sarvajJatvaprasaMgAt / ato na kutazcidapyabhAvavedanaM sakalavedina iti siddhaM tasya nirvAdhapratyayaviSayatvaM / nApi hetorAzrayAsiddhatvamaMtaH prAgapi sakalajJapratIteH pratipAditatvAt / yadyevaM kimanenoti cennAtastatsattvavyavasthApanAt / prAktanyA tu tatpratItyA nityAnityatvavikalpasAdhAraNasya zabdasyeva sadasattvavikalpasAdhAraNasyaiva tasyopadarzanAt / na cAzrayabalAddhetorgamakatvaM yatastadrahitatvaM tasya doSaH syAdapitvanyathAnupapattisAmarthyAt / taccAnAzrayatve'pi, nivedayiSyate caitat / 1 pratyakSAderanutpattiH pramANAbhAva iSyate / sAtmano pariNAmovA vijJAnaM vA'nyavastuni // 1 // pramANapaMcakaM yatra vasturUpe na jAyate vastusattvAvabodhArtha tatrAbhAvapramANatA // 2 // 2 nAsti sarvajJo'smatpratyakSAdipramANairanupalabhyamAnatvAt 3 prAbhAkaramate sarvajJabAdhakapramANAbhAvaM pratipAdya, bhAhamatamidAnImAha / 4 pratyakSAdyanupalambhasya / 5 asmAdanumAnAt / 6 pUrvasmin jAtayA / 7 dharmasAdhanAkhyahetusvarUpanirUpaNAvasare /
Page #37
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 32 pramANanirNaye~~~~~~~ bhavatu kazcitsarvajJaH, satu bhagavAnnahanneveti kutaH ? sugatAderApi tattvena prasiddheriti cet, ucyate / bhagavAnahanneva sarvajJaH sarvajJatvAnyathAnupapatteH / tathAhi-sugatasya tAvannirvikalpaka vedanaM, na tena suSuptAdivedanavadvastupAracchittiH / satyAmapi tasyAM na sarvAviSayatvaM kAraNasyaiva viSayatvopagamAt / na ca kAraNameva sarva tasya samasamayasyottarasamayasya cAkAraNa tvAt / anyathA "prAgbhAvaH sarvahetUnA" mityasya vyApatteH / na caikasvabhAvatve tato nAnArthaparicchittirnityAdapyekasvabhAvAdeva hetordezAdibhedabhinnAnekavastuprAdurbhAvopanipAtena taniSedhAbhAvaprasaMgAt / prativyaktitadAbhimukhyAbhAve pRthagarthadezanAnupapattezca / bhavatvekamanekasvabhAvameva tadvedanaM yugapannAnAkAratayA svatastasya saMvedanAditi cenna / krameNApi tadrUpatayA tasya tata eva pratipattisaMbhavAt / tAdRzasaMvedanAtmA bhagavAnahanneva na sugatastasya tadvilakSaNatayA tadvAdibhirabhyanujJAnAt / tanna sugatasya sarvajJatvaM, nApi hariharAdInAmanyatamasya / tadvedanasyApi sakalaviSayasya pratyarthamAbhimukhyAbhAve satIdaMtayedaMtayA vastuparicchiteranupapattyA tathA taddezanAbhAvaprasaMgAt / prativyaktyabhimukhatayA tasya mecakatve ca krameNApi tAdUpyopapattyA pUrvavadarhata eva tAdRza evAtmanaH srvjnytvopptteH| nezvarAdestasya tadrUpatayA parairanabhyupagamAt / tato naikasyApyekAMtavAdinaH sarvavaditvamityupapannamarhata eva bhagavatastadveditvaM, tatraiva syAdvAdanyAyanAyake jagadudaravivaravartiniravazeSapadArthasArthasAkSAtkaraNadakSasyAvNasyAdhyakSasya tasyopapatteritaratra viparyAsAditi ! ! ! 1 nAkAraNaM viSaya iti / 2 virodhAt // 3 sugtH| 4 pratIteH / 5 kramayogapadyAbhyAmanekarUpasavedanAtmA / 6 pUrNasya /
Page #38
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ parokSapramANasya nirNayaH / 33 mukhyasaMvyavahArAbhyAM pratyakSaM yanirUpitam / devaistasyAtra saMkSepAnirNayo varNito mayA // iti zrImadvAdirAjasUripraNIte pramANanirNaye pratyakSanirNayaH / saMprati parokSasya pramANasya nirnnyH| tacca tasya parokSatvaM na sAmAnyaviSayatvaM, sAmAnyasya 'nirvizeSasya kvacidapyanavalokanAt / savizeSe tu tadviSayatvaM tu pratyakSatve'pi / nApi dhyAmalAkAratvaM pramANasya nirAkArasyaiva prtiptteH| ata eva tadAkAratayA teta utpattirapi mithyAjJAna eva ca tadA tadutpattirApa saMbhavenna pramANe / tasmAdataraMgamalavizleSavizeSodayanibaMdhanaH kazcidaspaSTatvAparanAmA svAnubhavavedyaH pratibhAsavizeSa eva tasyaM parokSatvaM / tacca dvividhamanumAnamAgamazceti / anumAnamapi dvividhaM, gauNamukhyavikalpAt / tatra gauNamanumAnaM trividhaM, smaraNaM pratyabhijJA tarkazceti / tasya cAnumAnatvaM yathApUrvamuttarottarahetutayA'numAnanibaMdhanatvAt / taMtra 'kimidaM smaraNaM nAma? tadityatItAvabhAsI pratyaya iti cet, na tarhi tasya pratyakSapUrvakatvaM tadaveMgRhItaviSayatve satyeva tdutptteH| nacAtItasya tadavagRhItatvamiti cetsatyamaita eva tasyApUrvArthatvopapAdanAt / tatpUrvakatvaM tu tasya nIladhavalAdinA tadviSayasyaiva tenApi grahaNAt / evamapi kathaM tasya prAmANyaM ? avisaMvAdanasya viSaya 1 yataH vizeSapadArthasahitasAmAnyaviSayatvaM bhavati / 2 aspssttvissyaakaartvN| 3 vissyaakaartyaa| 4 viSayAt / 5 na kevalaM prtipttirev| 6 mukhyAnumAnanibaMdhanatvAt 7 teSu smaraNAdiSu / 8 saugataH pRcchati / 9 saugato vadati / 10 jnyaatvissytve| 11 pratyakSAnavagRhItaviSayatvAdeva 12 nIladhavalAdisvarUpeNA'pi / ___
Page #39
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pramANanirNaye prAptilakSaNasya tatrAbhAvAt, so'pi prAptikAle tasyAsaMnipAtAditi cet, pratyakSasyApi kathaM ? tadviSayasyApi tatkAle saMnipA'tAbhAvAt / bhAve smaraNaviSayasyApi syAt / nikSepAdestadviSayasyApi praaptiprtiiteH| tato yuktamavisaMvAdAttasya prAmANyam / tathA pratyabhijJAnasya, tasyApi pUrvAparapratyayApratItAMbhedasAdRzyAdiviSayatvenApUrvArthatvAdavisaMvAdAcca / pratyabhijJAnameva nAsti, so'yamityayamiva sa ityAdau sa ityayamityanayoH smaraNapratyakSAkAratayAbhinnapratibhAsatvena parasparato'rthAtaratvAdanyasya ca tadAkA-. rasyAprativedanAt kathaM tatra prAmANyapariciMtanam, iti cenna tarhi 'sa iti smaraNamapi, sakArAnuviddhAdakArAnuviddhasya saMvedanasyAnyatvAt / anyathA tadubhayAnuviddhatayA prtibhaasbhedsyaabhaavprsNgaadkssnniktvaaNptteshc| evamayamityatrA'pi pratipattavyaM / tathA ca kuto vastupratipattirayamiti pratyakSasyAvyavasthitau tatpUrvakatvenAnumAnasyApyasaMbhavAt / athA'yamityakArAdivarNabhede'pi tadanuviddhamekameva saMvedanaM tathaiva tasya nirbAdhamanubhavAt, tarhi siddhaH sa evA'yamityAdirapi pratyaya eka eva tathA tasyApi nirvAdhAvabodhagocaratvAt / anyathA samAropasyApi tadrUpasyAbhAvAnna tavyavacchedArthamanumAnamAtmadarzanasya tallakSaNasyAbhAvAnna tannibaMdhanaH saMsAro'pIti na tatprahANAya mumukSUNAM ceSTitamupapadyate / bhavatu sa evAyamiti jJAnaM pratyabhijJAnamayamiva sa ityasmAdvisadRzaH sa iti tu jJAnaM na pratyabhijJAnaM tasyopamAnatvAditi cet, tarhi 1 ekatvapratyabhijJAnasya / 2 sAdRzyapratyabhijJAnasya / 3 bauddho vadati / so'yamityAkAravedanasya / 5 kramoccAritAnekavarNAnuviddhatayA bhinnapratibhAsAtmano jJAnasyaikatvAbhyupagame tsyaiksyaanekaakssrvyaapitvsyaavshyNbhaavaadkssnniktvaapttirityrthH| 6 pratyakSe'pi / 7 mImAMsakaH prAha /
Page #40
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ parokSapramANasya nirNayaH / tadasmAdunnatamavanataM sthUlamalpaM hrasvaM dIrghamityAdijJAnAnAmupamAnatvasyAbhAvAt kathaM na pramANAMtaratvaM ? pratipannasyaivApekSopanItenonnatatvAdinA parivRttya parijJAnena pratyabhijJAnatvasyaiva tatropapattiriti cet, siddhamupamAnasyApi pratyabhijJAnatvaM, tenA'pi tathA tasya tAdRzenaiva sAdRzyAdinA parijJAnAt / bhavatu tarhi gaurava gavaya ityAgamAhitasaMskArasya punargavayadarzane so'yaM gavayazabdasyArtha iti zabdatadarthasaMbaMdhaparijJAnamupamAnamiti cet na, tatrA'pi sAmAnyataH prAgAgamA vagatasyaiva punaH sannihitavizeSa viziSTatayA parijJAnataH pratyabhijJAnatvasyaivopapatteH / anyathA SaTTiH caraNaizcaMcarIkaH, kSIranIravivecanacaturacaMcurvihaMgamo haMsaH, ekaviSANo mRgaH khaDgItivacanopajanitavAsanasya punastaddarzane so'yaM naMcarIkAdizabdasyArtha iti vAcyavAcaka saMbaMdhaparijJAnasyApyupamAnavadpratyabhijJAnatve pramANAMtarasya pramANacatuSTayaniyamavyAghAtavidhAyinaH prasaMgAt / tanna pratyabhijJAnAdanyadupamAnamityupapannaM pratyabhijJAnatayaiva tasyApi prAmANyam // tarkazcetthameva saMbhavati nAnityamiti vyAptiparijJAnAtmA, pramANaM, vinA tena liMgasAdhyAvinAbhAvasya duravabodhatvAt / na hi pratyakSatastasyAvabodhastena saMnihitaviSayavalabhAvinA dezakAlAnavacchedenaM tasyAnavagamAt / tadvacchedenAvagatAttu tato nAnu . 35 1 prijnyaatvstunH| 2 naiyAyiko vadati / 3 puMsa iti zeSaH / * vastunaH / 5 pratyakSAnumAnopamAnAgamabhedAt / 6 sAdRzyAbhAvenopamAne'pyaMtarbhAvAbhAvAt, prasiddhasA dharmyAtsAdhyasAdhanamupamAnamiti svayamevAbhidhAnAt / 7 avalaMbanasAmarthyAva saMbaddhaM vartamAnaM ca cakSurAdinA gRhyata iti vacanAt / 8 aniyamena /
Page #41
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pramANanirNaye mAnamanyatrA'nyadA tadabhAve'pi tdbhaavshNknsyaanivRtteH| pratyakSapRSThabhAvino vikalpAt tarhi tathA tsyaavgmH| pratyakSaM paunaHpunyena sAdhanasya sAdhyAnvayavyatirekAnuvidhAnamanvIkSamANaM sarvatra sarvadApyetadetena vinA na bhavatItivikalpakaM jJAnamupajanayati iti cenna; tenApyapramANena tdvgmaanupptteH| pramANatvamapi na tasya pratyakSatvena vicArakatvAttadvataH sarvadarzitvApattezca / nApyanumAnatvenAnavasthApatteH / tadanumAnaliMgAvinAbhAvasyApyanyasmAdanumAnAdavagama ityaparAparasyAnumAnasyApekSaNAt / tasmApratyakSAnumAnAbhyAmanyatayaivAyaM vikalpaH pramANayitavya, ityupapannaM tasyApi tarkAbhidhAnasya prAmANyam, anyathA liMgasAdhyAvinAbhAvaniyamasya tato'navagamaprasaMgAt / tato yuktaM smRtyAderaupacArikasyAnumAnasya prAmANyam / evaM mukhyasyApi / kiM taditi cet, sAdhanAtsAdhye vijJAnameva / sAdhanaM sAdhyAvinAbhAvaniyamalakSaNaM tasmAnnizcayapathaprAptAtsAdhyasya sAdhayituM zakyasyAprasiddhasya yadvijJAnaM tdnumaanN| "kiM tena? pratyakSata eva pRthivyAditattvasya pratipatteriti cenna, tto'pynishcitpraamaannyaattdnupptteH| naca pratItimAtrAttannizcayo mithyApratibhAseSvapi tadbhAvAt / avisaMvAdAttannizcayastasyAbhyastaviSayavedaneSu prAmANyavyAptatayA pratipatteriti cet, AgatamanumAnaM; nizcitavyAptikAdAdarthAtaraprApterevAnumAnatvAt / anumAnamabhyanujJAyata eva paraprasiddhayati cet, kuto na svaprasiddhayA ? vastu 1 saugtH|2 viklpjnyaanen|3 svayaM / 4 puruSasya / 5 trailokyatrakAlyavartyasmadAdipratyakSAgocare sakalasAdhyasAdhanavyakti sAkSAtkaraNavadazeSAtIMdriyArthasAkSAtkaraNopapatte. riti bhaavH| 6 tarkatvena prAmANyAbhAve / 7 prAmANya miti zeSaH / 8 abAdhitasyeti bhaavH|9 prativAdinaM prati asiddharaya / 10 cArvAko vadati / 11kuta iti zeSaH /
Page #42
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ parokSapramANasya nirnnyH| 37 tastasyAprAmANyAditi cet, na tarhi tataH pratyakSaprAmANyanirNayo'pramANAttadanupapatteH / anyathA pRthivyAderapi tata eva pratipattyA pratyakSaprAmANyakalpanasyApi vaiphalyopanipAtAt / kuto vA tasyAprAmANyaM ? saMbhavavyabhicAritvAliMgasya, vyabhicarati hi liMgaM bhUyaH kvaciniyamavatvenopalabdhasyopyanyatrA'nyadA ca tadvaiparItyena pratipatteriti * cet, kutaH punarvyabhicAravatve'pi tasyAprAANyaM ?- tasya tAntarIyakatayA pratipatteriti cet , AgataM punarapyanumAnam / ato nAnumAnamaMtareNa kSaNamapi jIvanaM cArvAkasya / kuto vA parasya prtipttirytsttprsiddhmnumaansy| pratyakSata iti cenna, tenA'pi zarIrasyaiva paricchedAnna bodhAtmanaH parasya / tasya tadanItaratvAt sa eva tasyApi pariccheda iti cenna, zarIrapratyakSatve'pi buddhivikalpe saMzayAt / na hi zarIraM pazyataH paMDito'yaM mUl vA sAdhurayamasAdhurveti nizcayo bhavati parIkSAnirapekSaM tatsaMbhAvanApamAnayoH prasaMgAt / mAbhUtparasya pratipattistatprasiddhamapyanumAnamiti cetkathamanumAnAbhAve zAstraM? tasyAnumAne prasiddhabhUtopAdAnacaitanyAdiviSayatvena tadabhAve nirvissytvenaanupptteH| kimartha vA tat ? na tAvadAtmArthamAtmanaH prAgevAvagatatadarthatvAdanyathA tatpraNayanAnupapatteH / tAzasyApi krIr3anArtha taditi cenna, vicAropanyAsAt / na hi vicAraH krIr3anAMgaM, kaeNrkazatvena cittaparitApahetutvAt / nA'pi 1 vRkssaadisvbhaavtyaa|2 zizapAtvAdeH / 3 latAdisvabhAvatvena! 4 anumAnasya / 5 vyabhicAravato liMgasya / 6 avinAbhAvarUpatayA / 7 " anumAnamapramANaM saMbhava vyabhicAraliMgatvAt prasiddhAnikAMtikaliMgavat / " 8 itaravAdinaH / 9 satkArAvajJayoH / 10 mA bhUditi zeSaH / 11 zAstraM / 12 avagatazAstrArthasyA'pi puNsH| 13 tat shaastrprnnynN| 14 zAstre iti zeSaH / 15 vicArasyeti /
Page #43
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pramANanirNaye parArtha parasyApratipatteH / astyeva tatpratipattiApArAdeliMgAttasya buddhipUrvakatvena svazarIre pratipattiriti cedAgataM punarapya-- numAnam, avadhRtavyAptikAdAdItarapratipattereva tattvAt / ne caivaM pratyakSAdanumAnavadanumAnAdarthApattirapyanyanyadeva pramANaM, tadavizeSAt / kathamavizeSo bahitiranumAnasyAMtAptezcArthApatterbhAvAditi cenna / apyanumAne'pyatAptereva gamakAMgatvena 'nivedayiSyamANatvAt / tataH parvato'yamagnimAn dhUmavattvAditi vA'gnirayaM dAhazaktiyukto dAhadarzanAdityapyanumAnameva nAparaM pramANam / abhAvastahi pramANAMtaraM pratyakSAdAvanaMtarbhAvAt iti cet na, tasyAjJAnatvena prAmANyasyaivAsaMbhavAt / jJAnamevAsau, bhUtale tajjJAnAdeva ghaTAbhAvasyAvagamAditi cet, naMnu tasyAbhAvo nAma bhUtalasya kaivalyameva nAparo'prativedanAta ca tajjJAnaM pratyakSameva / na tatkaivalyamAtrasya jJAnamabhAvajJAnamApa tu ghaTo nAstyapretyAkAramiti cenna, tasyApyanusmaryamANaghaTAviziSTatayopalamyamAnatatkaivalyaparAmarzinaH pratyabhijJAnatvena tadaMtaratvAnupapatteH; nA'styatra ghaTo'nupalabdhergaganakusumavadityAkAratve'pi tasyAnumAna evAMtarbhAvAditi na prAmANAMtaratvamabhAvasyApi / liMgAt / 2 prabhAkaramatamAzaMkya nirAkaroti / 3 arthApatteH 4 sarvamanekAtAsmakaM satvAdityAdisapakSavikalodAharaNAdiSvabhidhAsyamAnatvAt / 5 bhAdR Aha / 6 abhAvapramANaM jJAnamajJAnaM veti vikalpadvayaM manasi nidhAya prAha jainaH / 7 ajJAnasya prAmANyAsaMbhavaH prAgeba samarthitaH / 8 vijJAnaM vA'nyavastuni / 9 jaino vadati / 10 ghaTAbhAvasya bhatalakaivalye sati // 11 " gRhItvA vastusadbhAvaM smRtvA ca pratiyoginaM / mAnasaM nAstitAjJAnaM jaaytekssaanpekssyaa"| 12 upalabhyamAnabhUtalakaivalyaM pazcAtsmaryamANaghaTAviziSTatayA parivRtya jAnIta. ityrthH| ___
Page #44
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ parokSapramANasya nirNayaH / kiMlakSaNaM tattarhi sAdhanaM yato'numAnamiti cet, pakSadharmatvaM sapakSa eva sattvaM vipakSe vA'sattvamevota trilakSaNamiti kecit / tadasat / evaM satyudeSyati zakaTaM kRttikodayAdityasya pakSadharmatvAbhAvenAgamakatvopapattestadabhAvazca zakaTe dharmiNyudeSyatve sAdhye kRttikodasya hetorabhAvAt / nAyaM doSaH, kAlasya dharmitvAttatra ca tadbhAvAta; tathA ca prayogo muhUrtaparimANaH kAlaH zakaTodayavAn bhavati kRttikodayatvAt pravRttatatkAlavaditi cenna, evamapya. yaskArakuTIradhUmena parvatapAvakasyAnumAnApattestadubhayagarbhasya vistAriNaH pRthivItalasya dharmitvena hetoH pakSadharmatvopapatteH / nAyaM doSastasya tadavinAbhAvaniyamAbhAvAditi cet, na tArha kAlAdidharmikalpanayA'nyatrApi pakSadharmatvopapAdanena kiM. citsato'pi tasya gamakatvaM pratyanaMgatvAt / nA'pi sapakSe satvena, vinA'pi tene kevalavyatirekiNo gamakatvanivedanAt / nA'pi vipakSAsatvenAsadvipakSasyApi sarvamanekAMtAtmakaM satvA. dityAdeH svasAdhyapratyAyanasAmarthyasyAgre nirUpaNAt / nA'pi pakSadharmatvAditrayeNa, satyapi tasmin saH zyAmastatputratvAditara tatputravaditya tatvasyAgamakatvAt / asti patra tatritayaM dharmiNi sapakSe ca zyAme tatputratvasya bhAvAdazyAmAdanyaputrArdapavRttezca !!! syAnmataM na pakSadharmatvAdikaM sAkSAlakSaNaM liMgasyAvinA bhAvasyaiva tathA tatvAttasya tu tatraiva bhAvAt / tadapi tallakSaNa 1 bauddhAH / 2 muhUrtaparimANakAle dharmiNyapi / 3 tadubhayagarbha vistAri bhUtalaM parvatAgnimat ayaskArakuTIradhamavatvAditi / 4 udeSyati zakaTaM kRttikodayAdi. tyatrA'pi / 5 sarva jIvaccharIraM sAtmakaM prANAdimatvAt vyatireke bhasmavadityasyA sarve kSaNika satvAt tatra kharAviSANavadityasya / jJApana / 7 anumAne / 8 vyaavRtteH| 9 tasminsatyeva /
Page #45
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 40 pramANanirNaye tvenoktaM, tato'vinAbhAvavirahe'pi tadbhAvo na doSAya tadvAdina iti, tanna / pratyekaM pakSadharmatvAdyabhAve'pyavinAbhAvasya nirUpitatvAttatsamudAyena tadabhAve'pi saMti pramANAnISTasAdhanAdityAdau tadbhAvAttanna trairUpyaM sAdhanalakSaNam / nA'pi pAMcarUSyaM tatrA'pyavinAbhAvasyAniyamAt / pakSadharmatve satyanvayavyatirekAvabAdhitaviSayatvamasatpratipakSatvaM ca pAMcarUpyaM / na ceha tanniyamaH, prakRte hetau tadabhAve'pi tadbhAvAta, tatputrAdau tadbhAve tadabhAvAdasti hi tatputratvasya pakSadharmatvamanvayavyatirekAvabAdhitaviSayatvamapi saH zyAma iti pakSasya pratyakSAdinA bAdhAnupalabdherasatpratipakSatvamapi zyAmatvaviparyayasAdha' nasya prtynumaansyaaprtiptteH| tanna trairUpyAdikaM lakSaNaM liMgasya sAdhyAvinAbhAvaniyamasyaiva tatvopapatteH / sati tannirNaye trairUpyAdibhAvavattadabhAve'pi sAdhyapratipatterAvazyakAt / evamApi svabhAvakAryAnupalabdhibhedena trividhameva liMgaM / avinAbhAvasya tatraiva niyamAditi cet, n|rsaade rUpAdAvatatsvabhAvAderapi gamakatvapratipatteH / na hi rasAde rUpAdisvabhAvatvaM bhedena pratipatteH / nA'pi tatkAryatvaM samasamayatvAt / tatkAraNakAryatvAdastyeva tasya tatkAryatvaM pAraMparyeNeti cenna, indhanavikArasyApi pAvakajanmana evaM dhUmakAryatvena taliMgatvApatteH / na caivaM dhUmAdibhAvena tatsaM . 1" tasya tu tatraiva bhAvA" dityanenAvinAbhAvasya vyApyatvaM pakSadharmatvAdikasya vyApakatvaM cAbhihitaM yataH / 2 saugatasya / 3 sapakSe satvaM vipakSAd vyAvRttiHzca / 4 trairupyAdibhAve sati yathA sAdhyapratipattiH / 5 bauddhaH pratyavatiSThate, avinAbhAva niyamasya. liMgalakSaNatve'pi / 6 uttararUpalakSaNakAraNabhataprAktanarUpalakSaNakAryavAt / 7 bhasmAderiti bhAvaH /
Page #46
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ parokSapramANasya nirNayaH / 41 bhavenaM vyabhicArAt, raMsAderapi tatkAraNasya pratipattereva rUpAderapi pratiprattistasya tajjananadharmatayA tato'numAnAttataH kAryatayaiva tatra tasyaiva liMgatvamiti cenna, dhUmaziMzapAderapyagnivRkSAdikAryasvabhAvatayA pratipatterevAgnivRkSAdipratipattitvApattyA liMgavyavahArasyaivAbhAvopanipAtAt / rasAdikAraNAttarhi rUpAderavagama iti cenna kAraNasya liMgatvAnabhyupagamAt / svabhAvaliMgameva tattatra sAdhyasya rUpAdestanmAtreNaiva bhAvAt, svasattAmAtrAnubaMdhisAdhyaviSayasya liMgasya svabhAvaliMgatvopagamAditi cet; na / tata eva dhUmAderapi talliMgatvaprasaMgena kAryaliMgasyAbhAvAnuSaMgAnna rasAdeH kAryasvabhAvayoraMtarbhAvo nA'pyanupalabhe vidhisAdhanatvAditi kAryAdibhedenAtraividhyaM liMgasya / " nA'pyanvayAdibhedena saMti pramANAnISTasAdhanAdityasyAgamakatvaprasaMgAt / nahyasAvanvayI vyatirekI vA sAdhamryodAharaNAderabhAvAdata eva nAnvayavyatirekyapi / na cAsAvagamaka eveSTasAdhanasya pramANasadbhAvAvinAbhAvitayA nirNayAt / pramANanirapekSe hi tatsAdhane bhavatyatiprasaMgaH svAbhimatasya tatvopaplavasaMvidadvaitAde riva tadviparyayasyApi tathA tatprasaMgAt / nApi saMyogyAdibhedena cAturvidhyaM tasyaM kRttikodayasya zakaTodayAdAvaliMgatvApatteH / nahi tatra tasya saMyogo dhUmasyevAnau / nApya'sau tasya samavAyI goriva viSaNAdiH / na ca tena sahaikArthasamavAyI rUpAdineva rasAdiH / na ca tadvirodhI tadvidhiliMgatvAt / tanna liMge traividhyA " 1 ityatra tRtIyA hetvarthe natu sahArthe / 2 anubhUyamAnAt / 3 pUrvarUpAdeH 4 anubhUyamAnarasalakSaNasamAnakAlInasya / 5 pUrvarUpakSaNa uttararUpakSaNajanakaH pUrvarUpakSaNatvAt saMpratipannavat / 6 aMtabhAvaH / 7 tatvasadbhAvapuruSadvaitAdeH / 8 saMyogisamavAyiekArthasamavAyitadvirodhi bhedena / 9 liMgasya / 10 kRttikodayaH /
Page #47
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 42 pramANanirNaye diniyamakalpanamupapannam / atenniyatasyApi sAdhyAvinAbhAvaniyamaviSayasyAnekasyAbhAvAt / saMkSepeNa tu tadbhidyamAnaM dvidhA bhavati, vidhisAdhanaM pratiSedhasAdhanaM ceti / vidhisAdhanamapi dvedhA, dharmiNastadvizeSasya ceti / dharmiNo yathA; saMti bahirarthAH sAdhanadUSaNaprayogAditi / kaithaM punarato bhAvadharmiNo bahirarthasya sAdhanaM ? kaithaM ca na syAt ? asya tadbhAvadharmatve tadvadasiddhatvApattestadabhAvadharmatve cAtastadabhAvasyaiva siddherviruddhatvopanipAtAt tadubhayadharmatve ca vyabhicAraprasaMgAditi cenna, pratyeko bhayadharmavikalpavikalasyaivAsyAbhyanujJAnAt / kathamevaM tasya bahirarthabhAvaM pratyeva liMgatvaM na tadbhAvaM pratyapIti cenna, tatraiva tasyAvinAbhAvaniyamAddharmidharmasyApi kRtakatvAderanityatvAdau tata eva gamakatvopapatterna dhamidharmatvamAtreNaikazAkhAprabhavatvAdAvapi tadupanipAtenAtiprasaMgApatteH / taMtra sAdhanaM nIlAdeH saMvedanatvasamarthanaM dUSaNaM bahirarthatvaniSedhanaM tayoH prayogaH prakAzanaM" nIlAdi: saMvedanAt vyatiriktastadvedyatvAt tatsarUpavadityAdiH, na jar3o nIlAdiH pratibhAsamAnatvAt sukhAdivadityAdizca kathaM punarasya bahirarthAbhAve'nupapattiriti cet, asya bahirarthavizedeva / na hi tadabhAve tadvizeSasya saMbhavaH vRkSAbhAve ziMzapAbhA 1 na vidyate traividhyAdi niyataM yatra / 2 sAdhanaM / 3 paraH prAha / 4 jaina, Aha / 5 " asiddho bhAvadharmatve vyabhicAbhayAzritAH / viruddho dharmo bhAvasya sA. sattA sAdhyate kathaM " iti kArikAM manasi dhRtvA paraH prAha / 6 bhAva, abhAva / 7 bhAvAbhAvazca / 8 dharmitvAbhAve / 9 anyathA, sarvaphalAni pakvAni dharmANi ekazAkhAprabhavatvAt / 10 bhAvaM pratyavinAbhAvAbhAvaM samarthayate paraH / 11. unnAraNaM / 12 prayogasya bahirarthavizeSatvaM zabdarUpatvAtpratipattavyaM / ,,
Page #48
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ parokSapramANasya nirnnyH| 43 vasyaiva prtiptteH| nAsautadvizeSa AropitaropirUpatvAditi cet, na, tataH srvshktiviklaadnissttvdissttsyaapysiddheH| apyanAropito'pyayaM bodha eva na bahirartha iti cetna; pratipAdyasya tadabhAvAt / pratipAdakasyeti cet, kathaM tataH pratipAdyasya prakRtArthapratipattiranyabodhAdanyasya tadanupapatteranyathA pratyAtmabuddhibhedakalpanAvaiphalyopanipAtAt / tasmAdarthavizeSa evA'yamityupapannamevA to bahirarthavyavasthApanaM tadabhAve svympybhaavaaptteH| __tathedamaparaM dharmisAdhanaM saMti pramANAnISTasAdhanAditi / na hi pramANanirapekSamiSTasya vibhramaikAMtAdeH sAdhanamupapannaM, tadviparyayasyApi tathaiva tatprAtyA tdekaaNtaabhaavprsNgaat| tadviparyayasyopAyAbhAvopadarzanena pratikSepe tadekAMta eva pArizeSyAdavatiSThata iti cedasti tarhi pramANamupAyAbhAvopadarzanasyaiva tatvAdanyathA tatastadekAMtaviparyayapratikSepAnupapatteH / pArizeSyaM ca yadi na pramANaM na tabalAttadekAMtasya tadviparyayavyavasthApanam / tasmAtpramANameva tattetraMtyupapannameveSTasAdhanAnyathAnupapattyA pramANAstitvavyavasthApanam / evamanyadapi misAdhanamabhyUhitavyam / dharmivizeSasAdhanamapi dvedhA, dharmiNo'narthAntaramarthAntaraM ceti / anarthAntaramApa dvividhaM, sapakSeNa vikalamavikalaM ceti / tatrAcaM sarvamanekAntAtmakaM stvaaditi|stvN khalu sAmarthena vyAptamasamarthAI vyomakusumAdestasya vyAvRtteH / sAmarthyasya caikatve na tataH pradIpAdisaMbaMdhinaH kajjalamocanatailazoSAdikAryam , anekatve ca - 1 sAdhana dUSaNaprayogaH bahirarthavizeSa ityAropitarUpatvAt / 2 pratipAdakabodhAt / 3 prakRtArthapratipattyanupapatteH / / prasaktasya pratiSedhe anyatra prasaMgAt ziSyamANe saMpratyayaH parizeSastasya bhAvaH pArizeyaM / 5 vibhrmkaaNtaadivyvsthaapne| 6 kriyAkArakAt / 7 Adizabdena vartikAdAhorddhajvalanasvaparaprakAzanatamazchedanasphoTAdikaraNAnuvRttavyAvRttapratyayotpAdanaprANivizeSaMdyaSTiprativaMdhanamanuSyAdidRSTayapratidhanaprANivizeSamAraNapradIpAMtarakAraNAdi grAhyaM /
Page #49
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 44 pramANanirNaye kathaM na bhovasyAnekAMtAtmakatvaM / bhAvatastasyavyaktirekAditi cet na, samarthoM bhAva iti bhAvasAmAnAdhikaraNyena sAmarthyasyApratipattiprasaMgAt / tathA tatpratipatteravyatireka eva dravyatvaM sAmAnya saMvedanaM pramANamityAdau dRSTatvAt / kathaM punarekasyAnekatvaM virodhAditi cet na, tadabhAve tatpratipatterevAnupapattevirodhasya hi virodhino'vagame satyeva pratipattiH / avagamazca naikasvabhAvayA buddhyA tayorekatvApatteH / anekasvabhAvAyAzcAnekAMtamanicchatAmasaMbhavAt / evaM vaiyadhikaraNyAdipratipattAvapi vaktavyam / ___ saMzayastu svayameva nirNayAnirNayarUpatayA'nekAMtarUpatAmupajIvanna tatpratikSepAya saMpadyate / bhAvasyAnekarUpatvaM yadyakasvabhAvAttaptaH kAryamapyanekaM kiM na syAt ? anekasvabhAvAccedanavasthA, punastasyApyanyatastato bhAvAt / ityapi na yuktaM; svahetoreva tathAvidhAttasya tadrUpatayotpattehetutathAvidhatvasyApi taddhetutathAvidhatvAdeva bhAvAt / na caivamanavasthAnaM doSo'nAditvAttatprabaM. dhasya / tato yuktaM satvaM sarvasyAnekAtmakatvaM tadanyathAnupapattiniyamavattayAsAdhayatsapakSavikalasyodAharaNam / sapakSAvikalamapi dvidhA, sapakSasya vyApakamavyApakaM ceti / vyApakaM yathA, anityaH zabdaH kRtakatvAt ghaTavaditi / sapakSe 1 padArthasya / 2 padArthataH / 3 bhedAt / 4 bhedAbhedayorvidhiniSedhayorekatrAbhinne vastunyasaMbhavaH zItoSNayoriveti virodhaH, bhedasyAnyadadhikaraNamabhedasya cAnyaditi vaiyadhikaraNyaM, yamAtmAnaM purodhAya bhedoyaM ca samAzrityAbhedastAvAtmAnau bhinnau cAbhinnau ca tatrA'pi tathA parikalpanAdanavasthA, yena rUpeNa bhedastena bheda. zcAbhedazceti saMkaraH, yena bhedastenAbhedo yenAbhedastena bheda iti vyatikaraH, bhedAbhedAtmakatve ca vastuno sAdhAraNAkAreNa nizcetumazakteH saMzayaH, tatazcApratipattiH, tato'bhAva ityAnekAMte'STadUSaNAni / 5 buddheH / 6 gacchan / 7 " mUlakSayakarImAhuranavasthAM hi dUSaNaM / vastvAnaMtye'pyazaktau ca nAnavasthA nivAryate " / 8 ape. kSitaparavyApAro hi bhAvaH kRtaka ucyate /
Page #50
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ parokSapramANasya nirnnyH| vyApakatvaM cA'sya ghaTavadanitye sarvatra vidyudvanakusumAdAvapi bhAvAt / tadavyApakatvaM tu tatraiva sAdhye prayatnaMtarIyakatvaM, tasya va tatvaM ghaTavadanitye'pyanyatra jaladharadhvAnAdAvabhAvAt / dharmiNo bhinnemApa liMgamanekadhA, kAryakAraNamakAryakAraNaM veti / kArya dhUmaH parvatAdau hi pAvakasya, vyAhArAdi zarIre jIvasya kAraNaM, meghonnativizeSo vRSTaH, abhyvhaarvishessstRptH| kAraNasya kathaM liMgatvaM ? pratibaMdhavaikalyAbhyAM tasya kAryatvAniyamAditi cet , satyam ; yadi kAraNamAtrasya liMgatvaM, na caivam, anyathA'nupapattiniyamanirNayavata eva tasya tattvopagamAttathAvidhatvaM ca prasiddhameva meghonnativizeSAdau vyavahAriNAmiti niravayaM tasya liMgatvam / / __ akAryakAraNaM punadhA,sAdhyena samasamayaM vibhinnasamayaM ceti| samasamayaM rasAdi rUpAdeH, zarIrAkAravizeSo jIvasyApratipadyate hi gADhamUrchAdyavasthAyAM tadvizeSadarzanAjjIvatyayamiti pratipattAraH / kathamanyathA tadavasthApanodAya teSAM cikitsAvidhAvupatrakama iti / vibhinnasamayaM punaradya bhAskarodayaH uttaredhustadudayasya / nA'vazyaMbhAvastadudayasya kadAcitpativratayA tatpratibaMdhasya zravaNAditi cenna, janazrutimAtravizvAsena vyabhicArakalpanasyAyogAt; anyathA putrasya pitRprabhavatvAnumAnamapi na bhavet, droNavadapitRkasyApi tadbhAvasya saMbhavAt / asti hi tatrApi janazrutiH " droNaH kalazAdutpanna" iti / kathamevamapyuttarodayaM pratyakAryatvamasyeti cet, tataH prAgeva bhAvAt / tathA'pyuttarasya 1 arthaatrN| 2 saugtH|3 sAmarthyapratibaMdhakAraNAMtaravaikalyAbhyAM / 4 nirAkaraNAya / 5 jJAtvAraMbha upakramaH / 6 uttareyuH bhAskara udeSyati adya bhAskarodayAt / 7 zAMDilyA / 8 ayaM pitRprabhavaH putratvAt //
Page #51
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pramANanirNaye kAraNatve 'prArabhAva sarvahetUnAmityasya vyaapttiH|tN pratyakAraNatvamapi cirvyvhittven,ttkaalpraaptybhaavaat|anythaa tAdRzAdevAvidyAtRSNAdermuktiMgatasyApi saMsArotpatterna muktirAtyaMtikI bhavet / kathaM punaH punaratatsvabhAvasyAtatkAryasya ca tadudayasya tatrAvinAbhAvo gavAdestAdRzasya zvAdau tadanavalokanAditi cet, tatsvabhAvAderapi kathaM? cUtatvasya tatsvabhAvatve'pi vRkSatve, bhasmanastatkAryatve'pi pAvake tadanavalokanAt / kathamanyathA cUtatvaM latAyAM 'nirdahanamapi bhasma bhavet / viziSTasyaiva tasya vRkSatvAdau niyamo na tanmAtrasya tathApratIteriti cet, siddhamidAnImasvabhAvAderapyadyatanatapanodayasya zvastanatadudayaM pratyavinAbhAvitvaM, tathA pratIteH, na gavAdevAdikaM prati viparyayAt / tato yuktamavinAbhAvasaMbhavAdasvabhAvAderapi liMgatvam / evamanyadapi vidhisAdhanaM pratipattavyam // pratiSedhasAdhanamapi dvidhA, vidhirUpaM pratiSedharUpaM ceti| vidhirUpamapyanekadhA, viruddhaM tatkAryamakAryakAraNaM ceti / tatra viruddhaM yathA, nA'sti tatra zItasparzo vaDheriti / vahniH khalUSNasparzAtmA rUMpavizeSAdavagamyamAnastatpratyanIkasya sparzasyA'bhAvaM gamayati / viruddhakAryamatraiva sAdhye dhUmAditi / dhUmo hi vahniM tatkAryatvenAvagamayaMstadvirodhinaH sparzasyAbhAvamavabodhayati / / kAraNaviruddhakAryamasyaiva prabhedaH / tadyathA-nA'sya himajanito romaharSAdivizeSo ghUmAditi / dhUmaH khalu himasya tatpratyanIkadaha 1 saugataH / 2 sAdhye / 3 catatvasya taruNA saha bhasmanazca saha pAvakenAvinAbhAvo'stIti cet / 4 agninA sahitaM 5 niyamasya / 6 liMgatvaM / 7 avinA bhAvitvaM nAstItyarthaH / 8 piMgAMgabhAsurAkArat //
Page #52
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ parokSapramANasya nirnnyH| . nopanayanadvAreNAbhAvamAvirbhAvayaMstatkAryasya tadvizeSasyAbhAvama. vabodhayati / viruddhakAraNa; nAyaM muniH parapIDAkaraH kRpAlutvAditi |kRpaalutvN hi prhitnibNdhntyaa'nugrhmupsthaapyttedvtsttpiiddaakrtvmpaakroti| kAraNaviruddhakAraNamasyaiva prabhedaH / tadyathA-nA'sya munarmithyAvAvastatvazAstrAbhiyogAditi / tadabhiyogo hi rAgAdirahitasya tatkAraNatayA tatvajJAnasadbhAvamupanipAtayaMstatpratyanIkamithyAjJAnanivRttinivedanadvAreNa tannibaMdhanamithyAvAdasya virahaM nirpvaadmuppaadyti| akAryakAraNamapyanekadhA, viruddhavyAptAdivikalpAt / virudvavyAptaM yathA, nAsti bhAveSu sarvathaikAMtaH satvAditi / satvaM khalvanekAMtena vyAptamanyathA tdnupptteH| tathAhi-tadarthakriyAkAriNa evaM vyomAraviMdAdAvatatkAriNi tadabhAvAt / tatkArI ca yokasvabhAvaH, ata ekameva kArya bhavenna dezAdibhinnamanekam / anyathA sakalasyApi jagata ekahatukatvApatteH / sahakAribhedAdekasvabhAvAdapi tadanekamupapannameveti cet, tadbhedasyaiva tarhi tatra hetutvaM, tadanu tayaiva tsyotpttenneksvbhaavsy viparyayAt / tasyApi tadA bhAvAddhetutve'tiprasaMgastatkAlabhAvinaH sarvasyApi tatra tatvApatteH / naikasvabhAvasya nA'pi sahakAribhedasya tatra hetutvaM, tatsamudAyasyaiva tatvAditi cet, tasyaiva tarhi satvaM sthAna pratyeka samudAyinAM na ca tatra tadabhAve samudAyasyApi tattadvyatireki 1 muneH / 2 tatvajJAnakAraNatayA / 3 nirduSTaM / * ghaTata 5 artha kriyAkArI bhAvaH 6 Adizabdena kAlAkArayorgrahaNaM / 7 anekakAryotpattibelAyo / ww
Page #53
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pramANanirNaye NastasyAprativedanAdityanekasvabhAvasyaivAnekakAryakAritvamabhyanujJAtavyam / anekasvabhAvatvaM ca tasya svakAraNAttathAvidhAttasyA'pi tatvaM tathAvidhAttaddhetoriti nAnavasthAnamatra doSastatprabaMdhasyAnAditvAdityupapannamanekAMtavyAptatayA satvasya tadvirodhiH sarvathaikAMtapratyAkhyAnaM prati sAdhanatvam / viruddhasahacaraM yathA-nAsya munemithyAjJAnaM sagyagdarzanAditi / samyagdarzanaM tatsAhacaryaniyamena samyagjJAnamupasarpayattatpratyanIkamithyAjJAnapratyavAyamupapAdayatItyupapannaM tatra tasya liM. gatvaM / viruddhasahacarasya kAraNamatraiva sAdhye tatvAdhigamAditi, kArya cAnukaMpA''stikyAdiriti / tatvAdhigamo hi samyagdarzanasya kAraNamanukaMpAdi ca kAryamavinAbhAvanirNayAt samyagjJAnasahabhAvinastasya bhAvamavabodhayanmithyAjJAnavyudAsAdhyavasAyamAsAdayati / evamanyadapi vidhirUpaM pratiSedhaliMgaM pratipattavyam / pratiSedharUpamapi tliNgmnekdhaa| tatra svabhAvAnupalaMbho yathAnAsti bodhatmani' rUpAdimatvamanupalaMbhAt kharamastake viSANavaditi / na cedamatra maMtavyaM, paramANvAdeH sato'pi kvacidanupalaMbhAdU vyabhicAra iti; tataH prakRtAnupalaMbhasya' gopAlakalazadhUmAdeH parvatadhUmAderiva vilakSaNatvena taddoSopanipAtAbhAvAt / tarhi dRzyaviSayatvameva tatastasya vailakSaNyamiti dRzyAnupalaMbhasyaiva hetutvamiti cet na, adRzyAnupalaMbhasyApyAtmani pizAcarUpatvAbhAve gamakatvAt anyathA pizAco nAhamasmIti vyavahA 1 vastunaH / 2 samyagjJAnaM / 3 upanayat / 4 abhAnaM / 5 tatvArthopadezagrahaNAdibhAvaH tatvArthAnAM zraddhAnapUrvakamavadhAraNaM hi grahaNamatreSTamanyathA'sya grahaNAbhAsatvAta / 6 cetasi / 7 paramAvAdyanupalabhAt / 8 rUpAdimatvAnupalabhasya /
Page #54
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ parokSapramANasya nirNayaH / rAnupapatteH / na ca pizAcasyAdRzyatve tavyatirekiNastadrUpa tvasya dRzyatvam / Atmano'dRzyatvena tadabhinnatayA'dRzyatvamapi tasyeti cet, nedAnImekAMtatastadanupalaMbhasyAbhAvaM prati gamakatvaM, dRzyAdRzyaviSayatayA saMzayanibaMdhanatvAt / tanna dRzyaviSayatayaiva gamakatvamanupalaMbhasyAvinAbhAvaniyamanirNaye tadaparasyApi tadu. pptteH| kAraNAnupalaMbho yathA-na tatra gRhe pAkasaMbhavaH pAvakAnupalabdheriti / kAryasyAnupalaMbhastu nA'tra zarIre buddhiApArAdivizeSAnupalabdheriti / kAryavikalasyApi kAraNasya saMbhavAna tadvaikalyAttadabhAvapratipattiriti cet, kathamidAnI kvacinmaraNasyAvagamo yatastatra dAhAdikamAcaret, prakArAMtareNa tatpratipatterabhAvAt / tataH satyavinAbhAvanirNaye kAryavaikalyAdupapannaiva kAraNasyAbhAvapratipattiH / na tatra ziMzapA vRkSAnupalabdherita vyaapkaanuplbdhiH|asyaashc taM prati prayogo yasya kvacidvRkSavikale'pi tatsadRzAkAradarzanena ziMzapAbuddhiH / kathaM punaH ziMzapAvyApakatvaM vRkSasya ? latAziMzapAyA api latAcUtavatsaMbhAvanAditi cet, kathamevaM kAraNatvamapi dhUmAdau vahneH ? avahnikasyApi tasya gopAlakalazAdau darzanAt / anya eva sa dhUmAdirvahnihetukAttata iti cet na, vRkSavyAptAyAstato latAziMzapAyA api saMbhave 'nyatvAvizeSAt / nAstyasya ta~tvajJAnaM samyagdarzanAbhAvAditi sahacarAnupalabdhiH / vyabhicArI heturasamyagdRzo'piM rUpAdau tatvajJAnasya bhAvAditi cet na, tena rUpAderitthaMbhAvanirNayAbhAvAt / 1 pizAcatvamiti yAvat / 2 anyaH kazcidvakti / 3 prANini / 4 mRte 5 vyApArAdibizeSAnupalabdhiM vihAyA'nyena / 6 latAziMzapA nAstyeva yadisaMbhava'pi / 7 samyagjJAnamiti yAvat / 8 pusa iti shessH|
Page #55
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pramANanirNaye nAnupakAMta nirNayaM tatvajJAnaM nAma bAlonmattAdijJAnavat / tanna vyabhicArakalpanamatra / na bhaviSyati muhUrtAnte zakaTodayaH kRttikodayAnupalabdheriti pUrvacarAnupalabdhiH / muhUrttAt prAk nodagAddharaNiH kRttikodayAnupalabdheriti utaracarAnupalabdhiH / evamanyAnyapi vividhipratiSedhaliMgAni pratipattavyAni / 50 yadi tatprabhavamanumAnaM, pramANameva tarhi, kasyacitkathaM tasya tadAbhAsatvamapIti cet, svArthavyavasAyavaikalyAt pratyakSavat / yate hi pratyakSasya tadvaikalyaM kvacidavyutpatyA''tmanaH, kvacitsaMzayAtmanaH, kvacidviparyAsAtmanaJca, tasya tatra pratIteH / tadpyaMtaraMgAvaraNodayAdvahiraMgAdiMdriyadopAdAzubhramaNAderapi / tadvadanumAne'pi / tatrApyuktasyAMtaraMgasya bahiraMgasya ca hetvAbhAsAde - staddhetorbhAvAt / " tatra trividho hetvAbhAsaH, asiddhAnaikAMtikaviruddha vikalpAt / asiddho'pi trividha eva svarUpAjJAtasaMdigdhAsiddhavikalpAt / tatra svarUpAsiddho yathA - nityaH zabdacAkSuSatvAditi / na hi zabdasya cAkSuSatvaM zrAvaNatvasyaiva tatra bhAvataH pratipatteH / ajJAtAsiddhastu zabdAnityatve sarvo'pi kRtakatvAdiH / na hi tasya kutazcitparijJAnaM pratyakSasya svalakSaNaviSayatayA sAmAnyAtmani tasminvikalpasya ca svAkAraparyavasAyitvenApravRtteH / vikalpAkAra eva so'pIti cet, kathamidAnIM tasya pakSadharmatvaM zabde dharmiNyabhAvAt / tatra tasyAropAditi cet na, tatra tasyeti pratyakSavikalpayoranyatareNApyazakyaparijJAnatvAt / anyatarA 1 akRtatannirNayaM / 2 tacchabdena liMgagrahaNaM / 3 anadhyavasAyAtmanaH / 4 Adizabdena pakSAbhAsAdikaM grAhyaM / 5 svarUpataH / 6 anugatAkAre / 7 svasaMvinmAtraparyavasitatvena / 8 svalakSaNe / 9 vikalpAkArakRtakatvAdeH /
Page #56
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ parokSapramANasya nirNayaH / wwwwwwwww siddha evAyaM kasmAnna bhavati mImAMsakasya zabde tadabhivyaktivAdinaH kRtakatvAderabhAvAditi cet na, zakyasamarthanatve tasya taM pratyapi siddhatvAt , azakyasamarthanatve ca svarUpAsidhda evAMtarbhAvAt tannAnyatarAsido nAma / __ saMdigdhAsidhdaH puna--mo'yaM bASpAdirvA iti saMzayyamAno bhUtasaMghAMtaH / na hyasau pAvakapratipattau dhUMmatayopadiSTo gamako bhavati nizcitasyaiva tatvopapatteH, saMdigdhasya cAnizcitatvAt / pratijJArthaMkadezAsidhdastarhi vaktavyaH, tadyathA-anityaH zabdaH zabdatvAditi / zabdasya hi sAdhyadharmadhamisamudAyarUpapratijJArthaMkadezatayA sAdhyadharmavadasidhdatvAna hetutvamiti cet, tahi dharmitvamapi na bhavediti kathaM zabdAnityatve kRtakatvAderapi hetutvamAzrayAsidhdeH / samudAyarUpatayaiva zabdasya sAdhyatvaM na pRthagapi prasiddhatvAt tato dharmitvamiti cet, hetutvamapi syAdavizeSAt / dharmitvaM pratyupakSINasya tasya kathaM hetutvamiti cet na, dharmabhedAnahi yenaiva tasya dharmitvaM sAdhyadharma pratyadhikaraNabhAvena tenaiva tasya hetutvmpitvvinaabhaavniymen| kathaM punarvipakSavyAvRttiryadanityatve tasya tanniyama iti cet, kRtakatvAderiva stvvishessaadev| na caivaM satvAdevaM sAdhyasidhdoviphalatvaM zabdatvasya kRtakatvAdAvapi tatprasaMgAt / kathaM vA zabdasya prati 1 vAdiprativAdinormadhya ekasyAsiddhaH / 2 mshkaadismuuhH| 3 bhUtasaM. ghAtaM dRSTA dhUmo'yaM bASpAdi veti saMdahe samutpanne bahniratra dhUmAditi / 4 bauddhasya mataM, pratijJA eva dharmadharmisamudAya evArthaH pratijJArthastasyaikadezaH san hetura siddha ityarthaH / 5 paravAdI / 6 jainaH / 7 kharUpeNa / 8 kRtakatvAderyathA stvvishesstvaadvipkssvyaavRttiH| 9 satIti zeSaH / 1. sAdhanAdeva / 11 saadhnsy|
Page #57
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 52 pramANanirNaye jJArthaMkadezatvaM, zabdazabdanirdiSTasya tadvizeSasyaiva tatvAnna zabdasAmAnyasya / tatkathaM tasyAsiddhatvaM? zabdazabdenA'pi sAmAnyasyaiva nirdezAditi cet, viphalamidAnIM satvAdyanumAnamapi vastunya. vasthAM pratyanaMgatvAt / vastuni hi zabdavizeSe tato nityatvavya vasthitau tasya tadaMgatvaM nAvastuni sAmAnye / nAyaM doSaH sAmAnyAnityatvena vizeSAnityatvasya lakSaNAditi cet, liMgAdeva kuto na tallakSaNaM ? vizeSANAmAnaMtyena tatra liMgapratibaMdhasya duravagamAditi cet na, sAmAnyapratibaMdhasyApi divizeSAt / tanna sAmAnyasya dharmitvaM vizeSasyaiva tatvAt / kathaM tasya pratijJArthakadezatvenAsiddhatve sAmAnyasyApi tatvaM ? 'vizeSAdanyasya sAmAnyasyaivAbhAvAditi cenna kiMcididAnI liMgaM nAma satvAderapi tathAvidhasyAbhAvAt / bhAva eva satsadityanugamapratyayasya tadviSayasya bhAvAditi cet na, zabdaH zabda iti tatpratyayasyAvizeSAt / tanna zabdAnityatve zabdatvasyAsiddhatvaM / nA'pi rUpAdyanityatve rUpAditvasya zabdatvena samAnayogakSematvAt / nA'pyanityaHzabdo'nityatvAdityasya pratijJArthaMkadezatvanAsidhdatvaM zabde'pi tadApattyA tasya dharmitvA'bhAvaprasaMgAt ; samudAyA 1 zabda iti zabdaH zabdazabdaH / 2 zabdatvasya / 3 yatsat tatkSaNikaM yathA jaladharaH saMzca zabda ityAdyanumAnaM / 4 zabdatvalakSaNe / 5 anityaH zabdaH kRtakatvAdityanumAnAt zabdasAmAnyasyAnityatvena sAdhitena tadvizeSANAmanityatvasya lakSitalakSaNatayA lakSaNAtparijJAnAtkutaH zabdasAmAnyasya zabdavizeSaH sahAvinAbhAvAt / 6 vizeSAnityatvaparijJAnaM / 7 avinaabhaavsy| 8 sAmAnyena saha sasatvasyAvinAbhAve duravagamatvAvizeSAt kutastasyApyAnaMtyAt / 9 paravAdI / 10 paro vakti tathAvidhasatvAdireva / 11 sAdhanasya / 12 AkSepasamAdhAnAt /
Page #58
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ parokSapramANasya nirNayaH / pekSayo'pi tasyApi tadavayavatvAvizeSAt / kutastarhi tasyAsiddhatvamiti cet, tarhi svarUpata evAnirNayAdbhavatu / svarU pAsidhdatvAdevAyamaheturiti cet na, zabdAvacchinnasyAnityatvasya sAdhyatvAt / na ca tasya hetutvaM anityamAtrasya tatvAt , taMtra ca mImAMsakasyApyavivAdAt, anyathA ghaTAdAvapi tadabhAvApatteH / kathaM punaH zabdAnityatvAbhAve tanmAtrasyAnupapattiryatastadanityatve tasya hetutvamiti cet na, zabdavattadabhAve'pi ghaTAdervastutvAvyAghAtAt, tadvastutvavacchabde'pyanityatvasAmAnyasyApi tadvizeSe'nyathA'nupapattimattvAdupapannameva hetutvam / evamapi na tritvamevAsiddhasyAzrayAsiddhasyApi bhAvAt / tadyathA-dravyamAkAzaM guNAzrayatvAdityAkAzAsatvavAdinaM bauddhaM pratyasyAzrayatvAsiddhatvopapattariti cet na, AzrayavatsvarUpasyAsatve svarUpAsiddha evAMtarbhAvAt , satve cAnyathAnupapattI gamakatvasyAnyathA ca vyabhicAritvasyaivopapatterbhAgAsidhdasya tarhi bhAvAna tritvamasidhdasya / tadyathA-cetanAstaravaH svApA 1 anyatheti shessH| 2 sAdhyarUpasya sAdhanasya / 3 taTastho brUte / / viziSTasya / 5 zabdasyaiva nAbhyupagamyate nityatvaM naanytr| 6 anityatvamAtravivAdavizeSAt / 7 zabdenityatvameva vastutvamicchatAM ghaTAdAvapyanityatvamaMtareNa vastutvamiSyatAM tathAcAnityamAtramavalokena siddhayati, anyathA'nupapattiH pratipAditA bhavatItyatrAvagaMtavyam / 8 zabdavaditi, yathA zabdasyAnityatvAbhAve. 'pi vastutvamupapannaM tathA ghaTAderapi, anityatvAbhAve'pi vastutvamavyAhatamiti vastu kimapyanityaM na syAt, na caivaM tataH kAraNAdvastutvasya ghaTAdAvanityatvena vyAptatvAt , vastutvavaditi vastutvasAmAnyasya vizeSAnityatvavyavasthApakatadanityatvasAmAnyasya tadvizeSe nityavizeSe'nyathAnupapattimattvAdupapannameva hetutvam / ___
Page #59
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 54 pramANanirNaye diti / na hi taruSu sarvatra svApaH patrasaMkocalakSaNasya tasya dvidaleSveva bhAvAditi cet, bhavatvevaM na tathA'pi doSaH, svAzrayeSu tena pazumanuSyAdinidarzanabalena cetanatvaM vyavasthApayatA tarvantareSvapi tavyAptahetusthApanadvAreNa tasya vyavasthApanAt / pare'pi taravazcetanAstatvAt svApavatprasiddhataruvAditi / tat nA'sya bhAgAsidhdatvaM doSAya gamakatvApratikSet / evameva zabdAnityatve prayatnAnaMtarIyakasyA'pi bhAgAsidhdasya nirdoSatvakalpanopapatteH / asti hi tasyApi bhAgAsidhdatvaM samudraghoSajaladharadhvAnAdAvabhAvAt / viparyastAsidhdastvajJAtAsidhda eva, na hi dhUmastadviparyAsena pratIyamAnaH svarUpataH parijJAto nAma, tanna tatastasya pRthagasiddhatvam / ___ anaikAMtikazca punardidhA-nizcitasaMbhAvyavyabhicAravikalpAt / nizcayazca vyabhicArasya kvacitpakSaikadeze, yathA-pakvAnyatAni phalAnyakazAkhAprabhavatvAdupabhuktaphalavaditi / asti hya tatraiva tannizcayaH pakSIkRteSveva bahulamAmeSvapi prakRtasya hetorbhAvAt / kvacidanyatra, yathA saH zyAmastatputratvAditaratatputravaditi / atra hyanyatraiva tannizcayastatraivAzyAme'pi tatputrasyAvalokanAt / saMbhAvyavyabhicAro yathA-vivAdApannaH puruSaH kiMcijjJo rAgAdimAnvA vaktRtvAde rthyaapurussvditi|sNbhaavnaa'tr vyabhicA. rasya, sarvajJAdAvapi virodhAbhAvena vaktatvAdeH saMbhavAvirodhAt / virodhe vA jJAnaprakarSatAratamye vaktRtvasyApakarSatAratamyamupala 1 ekdlessu| 2 ekdlaaH| 3 atra matvarthe pratyayaH / 4 bhUtasaMghA. tena / 5 anumaane| 6 anubhUtaphalavat / 7 anumAne / 8 apakveSvapi / 9 anumaane| 10 vipakSe / 11 vItarAge / 12 asaMbhavAditi bhAvaH /
Page #60
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ parokSapramANasya nirNayaH / 55 bhyeta / na caivaM sati tasmin tatrA'pyatizayatAratamyasyaiva pratipattestato'tizayaparyaMtagatajJAnasyApi saMbhavatyeva vaktRtvaM / na saMbhavati tasya vItarAgatvena rAgavizeSAtmano vivakSAyA abhAvAtta nibaMdhanatvAcca vaktRtvasyeti cet na, tadabhAve'pi gotraskhanAdau tasya pratipatteH / na hi tatra yadviSayaM vacanaM tadvivakSA vidyate / vivakSAntarasya sato'pi hi na taddhetutvamatiprasaMgAt / vivakSApUrvakatve ca vaktRtvasyAnabhyastasyApi zAstrArthasya kazciiktA bhavet tadvivakSAyAstatrA'pi saMbhavAnnacaivaM vyAkhyAtRsevAvaiphalyaprasaMgAt / abhyAsasAhAyye bhavatyeveti cenna, satyabhyAsapATave nirvivakSasyaiva svApAdau tadarthapratipAditvasya pratipatteH / tanna vivakSAvaikalyena vItarAgasya vaktRtvAsaMbhavakalpanamupapannam / upapannameva vaiyarthyAt, na hi vItarAgasya tena kazcidarthaiti cet na, svArthasyAbhAve'pi parArthasya bhAvAt / tAdRzasya kathaM parArthe'pi pravRttiriti cet, bhAnoH padmavikAsane karthe ? tathAsvabhAveneti cet, samAnamidamanyatrA'pi / tato yuktaM sarvajJAderapi vaktRtvaM / evaM puruSatvAdikamapi tasyApi kvacitaM sakalajJatvAdinI jaiminyAdau vedArthajJatveneva virodhAbhAvAt / sarvajJAderavidyamAnatvAnna tatra vaktRtvAdikamityapi neM yuktamanyetaistadavidyamAnatvasya pratipattAvasya vaiphalyAdanenA'pi tadabhAvasyaiva kiMcijjJatvAdyupanayanenopasthApanAdateM eva tatpratipattAvanyonyAzraya 1 nuH / 2 vaktRtvamiti zeSaH / 3 ghaTAdikAraNasya mRdAdeH paTAdikAraNatvaprasaMgAt / 4 puNsH| 5 vaktavvA saMbhavakalpanaM / 6 prayojanaM / 7 pravRttiriti zeSaH / 8 tathA svabhAvenetIdaM / 9 puNsi| 10 sAkamiti shessH| 11 paravAdI vakti / 12 jaino vadati / ataH " veti vikalpadvayaM / pramANAMtarAt vaktRtvAdikAt / 88 > 66 13 anyataH 14 Anayanena / 15 dvitIyavikalpaH // -
Page #61
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pramANanirNaye nawwamro w meaninrna NamatastadabhAvapratipattau tatra vaktRtvAderasaMbhAvanamasaMbhAvitavyabhicArAcAtastadabhAvasya pratipattiriti / tataH sthitaM sNbhaavyvybhicaartvaadvktRtvaadernaikaaNtiktvmiti| nanu evaM zabdAnityatve prameyatvamapyanaikAMtikameva bhavet tasya nitye gaganAdAvapi bhAvena vyabhicArAditi cet na, tasya kUTasthasya pramitAvanupayogAdupayoge vA kuto na sarvadA tasya prameyatvaM? sahakArisannidhisamaya eva tadbhAvAditi cet na, tadApi prAcyarUpAparityAgena tadanupapatteH, tatparityAge tu pariNAmi nityameva / tanna kUTasthaM, na ca tatra bhAvAddheto~bhicAraH, saMpakSabhAvitvena sAdhyapratipattiM pratyAnukUlyAt / sAdhyasapakSatvamapi tasya zabde'pi sAnvayasyaivAnityatvasya sA. dhanAnna niranvayasya, tadvati pramiterasaMbhavAt / na hi sA tataH samasamayAnniSpannatvena tasyAstanirAsatvAt / nA'pyatItAcciratarAtItAdiva kAryakAlamaprAptAttato'pi tadanupapatteH / na cAtatprabhavayA tayA tasya prameyatvaM " nAkAraNaM viSaya " ityasya vyaaptteH| kathaM punaH sAnvayavinAze'pyanityatve sAdhye na vyabhicAraH prameyatvasya bhAvavadabhAve'pyavastuni bhAvAt tatra ca vastudharmasyAnityatvasyAnupapatteriti cet na, tasya kutazcidapratipatteH, vyatireke ca bhAvebhyastasya kuto na teSAM sAMkaryameM / tatsaMbaMdhAditi cet na, tenA'pi svataH saMkIrNA 1 sarvajJAbhAvasiddhau vaktRtvAbhAvasiddhistatsiddhau srvjnyaabhaavsiddhiH| 2 ghaTata iti shessH| 3 ajJAtavyabhicArAt / 4 anekAMtikaM punadheityAyuktaprakAreNa / 5 nizcitavyabhicArAkhyamiti bhAvaH / 6 svapramitAvityarthaH / 7 pramANaviSayatvameva prameyatvaM / 8 aprameya / 9 gaganAdau hetau / 10 kathaMcidabhinnasyaiva / / 11 nirapekSatvAt / 12 ghaTaH paTo na bhavati paTo ghaTo na bhavatIti vyAvartakasyAbhAvasya bhAvAt /
Page #62
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ parokSapramANasya nirNayaH / 57 ~~~~~ www.mmm~~~newwwwwwwwwwwwwm nAmananyathAtvasyAkaraNAt, karaNe vA tadeva teSAmanyonyamabhAvastasya ca tebhyo'nantaratvena taddhetoreva bhAvAditi / tasya vaiyaymarthAtarasya tasya prAgabhAvAdibhedinaH kathaMcidbhAvAviSvagbhAvena tdvdevaanitytvopptteH| na tadgatatvenA'pi prameyatvasyAnaikAMtikatvaM, vyabhicArasya nizcitasyeva saMbhAvyasyApi tatrAbhAvAt / saMzayakaratvAdapyanaikAMtikaM vaktavyaM / tadyathA-zrAvaNatvaM na hi tasya zabde nityatvetaratvayoranyatra hetutvamanavagatabahiranvayasya tadarnupapatteH / na ca tene vinA tasya saMbhavaH sarvasyA'pi vastusata. stena vyaapteH| tataH zabde tadupalamyamAnaM tatra saMzayamAvahati, kiM zrAvaNatvAnnityaH zabda Ahosvidanitya iti / tasmAdanakAMtika miti cet na; satvavattasyApi tadvizeSasya zabdAnityatve hetutvsyaivopptteH| bahiranvayAnavagame kathaM taditi cet, sarvAnityatve satvasyApi kathaM ? na hi tasyApi bahistavagamaH sarvasya pakSIkRtatvena tadvahirbhUtasyAbhAvAt / nityasya saMhakamAbhyAmarthakriyAvaikalyena vyomAraviMdavat satvAnupapatteH / tato nizcitavyAvRttikasya tasya pakSa eva tabdyAteravagamAditi cet, siddhastarhi zrAvaNatvasyApi tatraiva tadavagamo vipakSAtsatvasya vyAvRttau tadvizeSasyApi tasya tato'vazyaM tayA vyAvRttenirNayAt / nirvizeSAdapi satvAttadanityatvasyA'pi siddheH kiM tadvizeSeNa 1 svarUpeNa saMzliSTAnAM padArthAnAM / 2 anityaH zabdaH zrAvaNatvAt / 3 anityatva / 4 zrAvaNatvasya bahiranvayAbhAvena zabdanityatvetaratvayoranyataratvasAdhakatvabhAve'pi zabdaH saMbhaviSyatItyAkAMkSA pratikSipannAha / 5 nitytvenaanitytven| 6 saMzayamAvahati yasmAt / 7 sarvamanityaM satvAt / 8 hetutvamiti shessH| 9 yogapadya / 10 zrAvaNAdivizeSarAhatAt /
Page #63
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pramANanirNaye zrAvaNatveneti cet naivamutpattimattvAdAvapi prasaMgAt / tataH sAmAnyavattadvizeSasyA'pi sAdhyAvinAbhAvanirNaye kadAcitkutazcitsAdhyapratipatterupapannaM tadvizeSasyA'pi zrAvaNatvasya tatra gamakatvamato na tasyAnaikAMtikatvakalpanamupapannam / sAdhyArthAbhAvanizcito viruddho hetvAbhAsaH / sa cAnekadhA, dharmatadvizeSAbhyAM dharmitadvizeSAbhyAM ca viparItasyaiva sAdhanAt / tatra dharmaviparItasAdhano yathA-nIlatajjJAnayorabhedaH sahopalaMbhaniyamAt dvicaMdravaditi / tatsAdhanatvaM cA'sya yogapadyArthe sahazabde tanniyamasyAbhedaviruddha nAnAtva eva bhAvAt / abhede'pi caMdradvitaye bhAva iti cet na, tatrA'pi yathApratibhAsaM bheda eva bhAvAt / yathAtatvamabhedepIti cet na, tadAnImabhedasyAnavabhAsanAt / na cAnavabhAsini tasmistaniyamasya tadanugamaH zakyo gaMtumavabhAsinyeva sAdhye tadanugamasya hetvaMtareSu pratipatteH / sannapi tatra tanniyamo viruddha eva dharmavizeSaviparItasAdhanatvAt / dharmavizeSo hi nIlatajjJAnayoH sisAdhayiSatAM tAtvikamekatvaM na ca tasyAyaM sAdhanaH kiM tAtvikasyaiva tasyaiva caMdradvaye svayaM mithyAjJAnaviSayatvenAtAtvike bhAvAt / nanu evaM pAkAnvitasyaivAnityatvasya ghaTe darzanAttasyaiva zabde'pi kRtakatvAtsAdhanaM taditi cet na, tatrAnyatra ca tadanvitasyApi 1 anityaH zabda utpattimatvAdityAdAvapi / 2 prayogakAle / 3 zrAvaNa tvAdivizeSAt / 4 " sAdhyArthAvinAbhAvaniyamanizcito viruddho hetvAbhAsa' ityapi kutracitpAThaH / 5 kriyaavishessnnmdH| 6 sahopalaMbhaniyamakAle / 7 dharmavizeSaviparItadarzanaM darzayati / 8 abhede| 9 dharmo bhedastasya vizeSastAtvikatvaM tasmAdviparItamatAtvikatvaM tasya sAdhanaM tasya bhAvastatvaM tasmAt / 10 pttaado|
Page #64
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ parokSapramANasya nirnnyH| tasya pratipatteH / na caivaM caMdradvayAdanyatra tAtvikasyobhayAbhedasya pratipattiryadavaSTaMbhena nIlatadvedanayorapi tanniyamastasyaiva heturbhavettato yuktaM dharmavizeSaviparItasAdhanatvenAsya viruddhatvam / dharmiviparItasAdhanasya kimudAharaNam ? idaM-na dravyaM bhAvaM ekadravyavattvAvyatvavaditi / dravyatvaM hi yathA na dravyaM tathA na bhAvo'pi / tatra yadi tadvedakadravyavatvAdbhAvo'pi na dravyaM sa bhAvo'pi na bhavediti, tanna, kRtakatvasyApyevaM tatsAdhanatvApatteH / zakyaM hi vaktuM ghaTasyAnityatvamivAzabdatvamapi / tatraM yadi tadvatkRtakatvAdanityatvaM zabdasyAzabdatvamapi bhavediti / yadi zabdasyApratipattirAzrayAsiddhiliMgasya, pratipattAvapi na tatrAzabdatvasAdhanam tatpakSasya tatpratipattyaiva pratikSepAt / tatkathaM kRtakatvasya dharmiviparIsAdhanatvamiti cet na, bhAve'pyevamabhAvarUpatvasAdhanasyAnupapatterekadravyavattvasyApi tatsAdhanatvAbhAvaprasaMgAt / kiM tarhi tatrodAharaNamiti cet, kSaNabhaMge sarvo'pi saMtvAdiH, tato hi dharmiNaH zabdAdestatkSaNa eva bhaMge tadabhAvasiddheravazyaMbhAvAdanyadA bhaMgasya ca tatkSaNabhaMgatvAnupapatteH / tatkSaNabhaMgo'pi tasya kSaNAMtarAdeva vyAvRttirna svarUpAt tannAyaM prasaMga iti cet na, tato'pi tasyAnarthAtaratve prasaMgasyaunivRtteH tathA kSaNAMtarAdapi vyAvRttiH svarUpAdapi tatprasaMgAtkathaMcida taratvasya ca syAdvAdavidvoSiNAmasaMbhavAt / saMbhave'pi viruddhaH __ 1 sahAyena / 2 paryAyaH 3 dharmiviparItasyodAharaNamuktam / 4 dharmiviparIta-- saadhntvaaptteH|5 kRtktvaanumaane|6 paro vkti| 7 sarvasminpadArthepi satvAdihetunA vinAzasvabhAvatvasAdhanasyAnupapatteH kutaH pratipattyaprattipattipakSasyAvizeSAt / 8 paravAdI vakti tatra viparItasAdhane kimudAharaNamiti / 9 utpttimtvaadiH| 10 utpa-- ttisamaye / 11 tvadbhAvasiddhayorevAvazyaMbhAvalakSaNaprasaMgasya //
Page #65
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pramANanirNaye aiva tatraM satvAdimivizeSaviparItasAdhanatvAt / dharmivizeSo hi parasyaM niSkaleH zabdastadviparItazca sa eva pravRttirUpatayA tu dvirUpastaM ca sAdhayataH spaSTameva saMtvAdestadviparItasAdhanatvaM / evaM puruSo'sti bhoktabhAvAditi / asyApi na hi puruSasya bhoga upacArAdapratipanne tatra tadanupapatteranyatazca tatpratipattAvasya vaiphalyAt / ata eva tatpratipattau pratipanne tatra bhogopacArastatazca tasya pratipattiriti parasparAzrayAttAtviko'pi ca tasmAnna vyatirekI, tena tasya gaganAderiva bhokRtvAnupapatteH, bhogyasaMnidhisavyapekSatayA kAdAcitkatve tasya tadrUpatayA puruSasya kathaMcidanityatvAt, siddhaM tasya sAdhayiSitakUTasthapuruSarUpadharmivizeSApekSayA viparItatvamityupapannaM bhoktRtvasya tatsAdhanatayA tadviparItatvasAdhanamato viruddhatvam / evaM viruddhAvyabhicAriNo. 'pi / tatkhalvidamanityaH zabdaH kRtakatvAt ghaTavaditi / tadavyabhicAritvamasya tatraiva nityatvasAdhanasya pratyabhijJAyamAnatvAderbhA vAt / viruddhatvaM niranvayavinAzaviparItasya sAnvayavinAzasyaiva sAdhanAt / tadapi kathaM nityatvahetunA pratibaMdhAditi cet na, tadviSayasyApi nityatvasya savinAzAnvayatadvinAzAdavizeSAt, kUTasthe tasminiranvayavinAzavadarthakriyAzaktivaikalyena tadvyAptasya kasyAcidapi hetorasaMbhavAt / kathamidAnIM avi 1 dharmivizeSaviparItasAdhanaM drshyti| 2 kssnnbhNgsaadhye| 3 saadhnN| 4 saugtsy|5 nirNshH| 6 svapararUpAdyapekSayA / 7 sAdhanasya / 8 upacArAtparamArthato vaa| 9 vyatirekiNA taatviken| 10 udaahrnnN| 11 sarvathA nitye / 12 viruddhatvaM nAstyanaikAMtikatvaM kutastadviparIte vartamAnatvAt , prakRtasAdhyadvayasyAvizeSapratipAdanakAle yuSmanmate'pi kathaM tayoranyonyaviruddhatvamityAzaMkate paraH, sAnvayavinAzasavinAzanityatvAbhyAmiti zeSaH //
Page #66
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ parokSapramANasya nirnnyH| ziSTe viSaye tasya tadviruddhatvamiti cet na, tatra kathaMcidvirodhasyApi bhAvAttanna tavyabhicAriNo'naikAMtikatvaM viruddhatvasyaiva bhAvAt / kathaM vA tasya tatvaM tadvalAdanityastadviruddhabalAnnityo vA zabda iti saMzayAditi cet, kevalasyApi syAttato'pi tatra tatsaMbhavAta, kRtakatvasya niranvayavinAzavat kauTasthye'pi kAlpanikasya bhAvAt, tAtvikasyAnekAMtanAMtarIyakatayobhayatrApyasaMbhavAt / tato'nekAMtanyAyavedinAM viruddha eva viruddhAvyabhicArI, tadanyeSAM tu tadvatkevalA api kRtakatvAdayaH saMzayahetava evAnekAMtarUpaprakriyAparicyutAnAM teSAM sAdhyavaditaratrApi saMbhavAt / taduktam ---" viruddhAvyabhicArI syAt viruddho viduSAM mtH| prakriyAvyatirekeNa sarve sNbhohhetvH||" ityanyapi hetvAbhAsAH prtipttvyaaH| kiM punaH sAdhyaM yadavinAbhAvo hetulakSaNamityucyate / " sAdhyaM zakyamabhipretamaprasiddhamiti" / na hi prasiddhasya sAdhyatvaM punaH punastatprasaMgenAnavasthApatteH / nApyanabhipretasya sAdhyaM pratyabhimukhacittasyeva liMgatastatpratipatteH / nApyazakyasya tatra hetorshkteH| tato'paraM sAdhyAbhAsaM / tacca prtykssaadiviruddhviklpnaadnekdhaa| tatra pratyakSaviruddhaM yathA-pratikSaNavizarAravo bhAvA iti, pratyakSatastatra kathaMcidavizaraNasyApi pratipatteH / lokopAdhyA 1 saMdigdhAnekAMtikatvAditi bhAvaH / 2 kenacidvAdinA pratyAbhijJAyamAnatvAdityetasya pratipakSasAdhanasyAprayuktatve sati kevalasyetyarthaH, vipakSasAdhakarahitasyApi / 3 abAdhitaM / 4 iSTaM / 5 prativAdyapekSayA'prasiddhaM / 6puMsaH //
Page #67
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pramANanirNaye rUDhatvAnmithyaiva tatpratipattiriti cet nAnyathApratipatteranadhyavasAyAdvicAratastadadhyavasAyasya cAnyatra virodhAt / anumAnaviruddhaM yathA-na saMti bahirA iti sAdhanadUSaNa. prayogAdinA tatsadbhAvasyAvasthApanAt / AgamaviruddhaM yathA-nAsti sarvajJa iti mImAMsakasya / tatra "hiraNyagarbha prakRtya sarvajJa" ityAdau tatsadbhAvasya zravaNAt / na tasya tatsadbhAvAvedane tAtparyamarthavAdatvenaM hiraNyagarbhasya sarvajJatayA stutividhAvevaM tadbhAvAt / anyathA''dimadarthatvena tasyAnityatvApatteriti cet, kathaM tatrAsatA tena stutiH ? adhyAropitena teneti cet na, AropaNasya mithyAjJAnatvena vedAdasaMbhavAdanyathAvidhiparo'pi tasmin anAzvAsApatteH / tatastadAvedana eva tAtparya tasya / nacAnityatve tasya doSo nityatva eva tasya vakSyamANatvAt / svavacanavirudhdaM yathA-na vAco vastuviSayA ityasya vastuviSayatvasya pratijJAnasyaM virodhAt, avastuviSayatve cAnarthakavacanatayA nigrhsthaantvaaptteH| lokaviruddhaM yathA-mithyaiva sarve pratyayA iti lokasya bahulaM jAgratpratyayeSvamithyAtve eva viSayabhAvalakSaNe'bhinivezAt / vAsanAdAyAdevAyaM na vAstavAdamithyAtvAditi cet na, taddAyasyApya tatpratItisamyaktAbhinivezopanItatvenAvastutvApattI 1 dharmaviparItasAdhanodAharaNanirUpaNAvasare / 2 yuNavAdatvena, " viruddha guNavAdaH syAdanuvAdAvadhArita" iti vacanAt , 3 stutirUpatvena / karmastutiH, yajeta ityajJAtajJApanarUpe'jJAtajJApako vidhiriti vacanAt / 4 AdimAn sarvajJAdyarthoM yasya sa tthaa| 5 kalpitana / 6 AropaNasaMbhavaprakAreNa / kAra. NAt / 8 vacanasyeti shessH| 9 prakRta iti shessH| 10 ttprtiitismykaabhineveshH| ___
Page #68
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ parokSapramANasya nirnnyH| vyomakusumAdivattatasteSu tatkalpanAnupapattestato viSayabhAvAdeva tatpratItivadanyatrApi tadabhiniveza iti kathaM na sarvapratyayamithyAtvaM lokaviruddhaM / hetusAdhyayoriva dRSTAMtasyApyAbhAso nirUpayitavyaH, anyathAtadvilakSaNatayA tasya nirUpaNAnupapatteriti cet na, dRSTAMtasyaiva tadabhAve'pyanumAnasya bahulamupalaMbhena taM pratyanaMgatvAt, tamamyupagamya tu brUmaH / sAdhyasAdhanadharmayoH saMbaMdho yatra nitiH sa dRssttaaNtH| sa ca dvedhA, sAdhamryeNa vaidhamryeNa ca / tatra zabdasya kRtakatvAderanityatve sAdhamryeNa ghaTaH vaidhayeNAkAzaM taMtra tayoranvayamukhena vyatirekadvAreNa ca saMbaMdhaparijJAnAt / tadAbhAsAH punaH sAdhyavikalAdayaH-tatra nityaH zabdo'mUtatvAdityatra karmavaditi sAdhyavikalaM nidarzanamanityatvAt karmaNaH, paramANuvaditi sAdhanavikalaM mUrttatvAtparamANoH, ghaTavadityubhayavikalaM anityatvAnmUrttatvAcca ghaTasya / rAgAdimAna sugato vaktRtvAdityatra rathyApuruSavaditi saMdigdhasAdhyaM rathyApuruSe sAdhyasya pratyakSeNAnizcayAt, vacanasya ca tatra dRSTasya tadabhAve'pIcchayA saMbhavAt / ata eva maraNadharmA'yaM rAgAdityatra asarvajJo'yaM rAgAdityatra ca saMdigdhasAdhanaM saMdigdhobhayaM ca rAgAdivadasarvajJatvasyApi tatra nizcetumazakyatvAt / rAgAdimAnaM vaktRtvAdityatra ananvayaM, tatrai rAgAderasiddhau tdnvysyaasiddheH| anityaH zabdaH kRtakatvAt ghaTavadityatrApradarzitAnvayaM, yadyaskRtakaM tattadanityamityanvayapradarzanasyAtrAbhAvAt , yadanityaM 1 prayoga / 2 ghaTAkAzayoH / 3 saadhysaadhnyoH| 4 mImAMsakAbhyupagatAdRSTavat / 5 sugata itynuvrtte| 6 na vidyate sAdhyasAdhanayoranvayo yatra / 7 rathyApuruSavadityatra /
Page #69
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 64 tatkRtakamiti viparItAnvayam 1 evaM nava sAdhamryeNa dRSTAMtAbhAsAH | pramANanirNaye evaM vaidharmyeNA'pi tadyathA - nityaH zabdo'mUrttatvAt yanna nityaM na tadamUrttaM paramANuvaditi sAdhyAvyAvRttaM paramANornityatvAt / karmavaditi sAdhanAvyAvRttaM amUrttatvAtkarmaNaH / AkAzavadityubhayAvyAvRttamubhayorapi tatra bhAvAt / sugataH sarvajJa anupadezAliMgAnanvayavyatirekapramANopapannatatvavacanatvAt, yastu na sarvajJo nAsau tadvacano yathA vIthIpuruSa iti saMdigdhasAdhyavyatirekaM tatra sarvajJatvAbhAvasya duravabodhatvAt / anityaH zabdaH satvAt yanna tathA na tatsat yathA gaganamiti saMdigdhasAdhanavyatirekaM gaganasatvasyAdRzyatvenAnupalaM bhAdabhAvAsiddheH / saMsArI hariharAdiravidyAdimatvAt yastu naivaM nAsau tathA yathA buddha iti saMdigdhobhayavyatirekaM, buddhAtsaMsAritvAdivyAvRtteH pramANAbhAvenAnavadhAraNAt / nityaH zabdo'mUrttatvAt yanna nityaM na tadamUrtta yathA ghaTa ityavyatirekaM ghaTe sato'pi sAdhyavyatirekasya hetunirvarttanaM pratyaprayojakatvAdanyathA karmaNyapi tasya tatvopapatteH / anityaH zabdaH zabdatvAt vaidharmyeNAkAzavaditya pradarzitavyatirekaM / tatraiva yatra sanna tadanityamapi yathA nabha iti vyatirekaM sAdhyanivRttyA sAdhananivRtteranupadarzanAt / ta ime nava pUrve cASTAdaza dRSTAMtAbhAsAH pratipattavyAH ! ! ! kutaH punardRSTAMtatadAbhAsayoH sAdhanadUSaNabhAvasyAbhAve'bhyupagamenApi nirUpaNamiti cet na, taitvavAda eva tayostadabhA " 1 saMdigdhaH sAdhyavyatireko yatra / 2 adRzyArthAbhAvasya duravabodhatvena bauddhai. svayamanabhimatatvAditi bhAvaH // 3 vItarAgakathAyAM /
Page #70
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ AgamanirNaya: / vAt / prativAdAdau tu sa vidyata eva tadvAdasyApi ciraMtanairabhyanujJAnAdityupapannameva tannirUpaNaM phalavatvAditi / ( padyam ) smRtyAderanuMmAdhiyo'pi ca mayA hetvAdibhiH setairaiH / nIte nirNayapaddhatiM sphuTatayA devasya dRSTvA matam // zreyo vaH kurutAnmanomalaharaM sphArAdaraM zrAviNAM / mithyAvAdatamo vyapohyaM nipuNaM vyAvarNito nirnnyH|| iti zrImadvAdirAjasUri-praNIte pramANanirNayanAmni nyAyagraMthe anumAnanirNayaH // AgamanirNayaH // 65 punaH athedAnImAgamaH / sa cAptopadezaH, tasya ca prAmANyaM tatastadviSayapratipatteraupacArikaM, mukhyatastasyA eva tadbhAvAt / kathaM zabdAdarthapratipattistasyArthAbhAve'pi bhAvAditi cet, kathamidAnIM jJAnAdapi kutazcittatpratipattistadabhAve tasyA'pi bhAvAcaMdradvayAdivat / puruSecchAnuvidhAyitvAnnArthavattvaM zabdasyetyapi na yuktaM jJAne'pi samAnatvAt / asti hi tasyApi tadanuvidhAyitvaM brahmapradhAnAdiSu tadvAdimatAnuvidhAyitayaiva tasya pravRtteH, na vastutathAbhAvAdanyathoM svayaM tatpratikSepasyAnu 1 vijigISukathAyAM / 2 upacArAnumAnasya / 3 AdizabdenA'tra sAdhyadRSTAMtau grAhyau / 4 hetvAbhAsAdibhiH / 5 nizcayamArga / 6 zIghraM zrotRRNAM / 7 dUrIkRtya / 8 aMgulya hastiyUthazatamAsta ityAdivaditi zeSaH / 9 vastuyathArthatvAt / 10 saugatairiti zeSaH //
Page #71
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pramANanirNaye papattiprasaMgAt / kAraNadoSopanItamithyAvabhAsanasvabhAvasyaiva tayA'pi tatra tasya pravRtti parasya, tasya vastubhAvAnurodhitayaiva pravRttariti cet, anukUlamidamasmAkamevaM zabdasyA'pi vastubhA. nurodhinaH zakyavyavasthApanAt / sAmAnyameva zabdasya viSayastatraiva saMketasya saMbhavAt tasya cAvastutvAttadvAcinaH kathamarthavatvamiti cet na, tasya nityavyApirUpasyAbhAve'pi viSayatapratyakSayoriva sadRzapariNAmarUpasya tatvata eva bhAvAdanyathA pratyakSe'pi tasyAtAtvikena tato viSayavyavasthApanasyAbhAvaprasaMgAt / kathaM vA tasyAvastutve kvacittannibaMdhana ekatvasamAropoM yatastavyavacchedArthamanumAnaparikalpanaM / so'pyaMtaraMgAdeva kutazcidupaplavAna tata iti cet na, sadRzAparAparotpattivipralaMbhAnnAvadhArayatItyasya virodhAt / tanna sadRzapariNAmasyAtAtvikatvaM, anubhavaprasidhdatvAcca / anyathA visadRzapariNAmasyApyevaM tannivaMdhanatvena svalakSaNasyApi kaalpniktvopnipaataat| ceSTamevedam, " bhAvA yena nirUpyate tadrUpaM nAsti tatvata" iti vacanAditi cet na, kutaH punarnirUpyamANatvAvizeSe bhAvarUpasyeva tannairAtmyasyApi tAtvikatvam ? apariskhalitanirUpaNatvAcet, AgataM tarhi sadRzapariNAmasyApi tattvaM tadavizeSAdityupapannameva tadviSayatayA zabdasya vastuviSayatvaM / tacca na tanmAtratvAdatiprasaM 1 janita 2 samyagjJAnasya 3 samyagjJAnasya 4 saugato vadati 5 " arthana ghaTayatyenAM nahi muktArtharUpatAM / tasmAtprameyAdhigateH pramANaM meyarUpateti svayaM saugatairuktaprakAreNa viSayatatpratyakSayostAtvikaH sadRzapariNAmo'sti tathA 6 sa mA bhUdityAzaMkAyAmAha 7 sarva kSaNikaM satvAditi 8 visaMvAdAt 9 anubhavaprasiddhatvAvizeSeNa tAtvikatvApatyA 10 svenAsAdhAraNasvarUpeNa lakSyata iti svalaNakSaM na tathA sati visadRzapariNAmAbhAve tasya tathA lakSayitumazakyatvAtkAlpanikatvopanipAtaH 11 tatvopaplavavAdI prAha //
Page #72
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ AgamanirNayaH / gAt / api cAtopajJatvena guNavatvAdAtizca vakturvAcyavastuyAthAtmya veditve satyavipralaMbhakatvam / Aptazca dvedhA, vikalAvikalajJAnavikalpAt / vikalajJAnasyAtatve tadvacanasyAvisaMvAdakatayA bahulaM vyavahArAdhirUDhatvAt / avikalajJAnazca dvedhA - parokSapratyakSajJAnavikalpAt / parokSajJAno gaNadhara devAdistasya pravacanopanItasakalavastuviSayAvizadajJA natayA parokSajJAnatvAt / pratyakSajJAnastu tIrthaGkaraH paramadevastadaparo spi kevalI tasya niravazeSanirdhUtakaSAyadoSaghAtimalopalepatayA paramavairAgyAtizayopapannasya sakaladravyaparyAyaparisphuTAvadyotakAriNaH : pratyakSajJAnasya bhAvAt / prasAdhitaJcAyaM / tato yuktaM taduktatvAtpravacanasya guNavatvaM, anyathAM tadvacanasyAsaMbhavAt / saMbhava eva vItarAgasyApi sarAgavacceSTAsaMbhavAditi cet na, prayojanAbhAvAt / krIr3anasya ca rAgAtirekaimalImasamAnasadhamatayA paramavItarAge bhagavatyanupapatteH / vairAgyAtizayazca tatra ' rAgAdiH kacidatyantahAnimAn prakRSyamANahAnikatvAt heni kAlikAdivadityanumAnato'dhyavasAyAt / vyabhicArI hetuH sakalazAstravidaH prabhRti prakRSyamANahAnikatve'pi jJAnasya kvacidatyaM - tahAnyabhAvAditi cet na, tasyApi bhasmAdau niravazeSasyaiva prANasya pratipatteH / Atmanyeva rAgAdivatkuto na tasya taditi cet na, tasyaivAtmatvena tatraiva tathA tadabhAvasya virodhAt / rAgAdestu tadananyatve'pi yuktastatrAbhAvaH satyapi tasmin bodhasvabhAvasya tasyAparikSayAt / tatsvabhAvaJcAtmA " tathaivAhaM jAnAmi " iti pratyakSeNa prativedanAt / anumAnasya ca tadvilakSaNe 88 67 1 sarvajJaH 2 aguNavataH 3 AdhikyaM 4 niravazeSeNa 5 ekeMdriyAdau 6 hetvarthe tRtIyA vibhaktiH 7 //
Page #73
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 68 tasmin pratyakSaviruddhapakSatayAnupapatteH / tanna paramavItarAgatayA nirvyabhicAra hetubalAvadhArite bhagavati vacanapralaMbhaH saMbhavati / kathamevaM tAdRzasya vacanamapi svArthAbhAvAditi cet na, parArthatayaiva tadbhAvAt / tayApi tanna parAnugrahAbhisaMdhestatra tadbhAvAt, api tu sukRtavizeSopanipAtAt, svabhAvavizeSAdeva, bhAnumatonalinavikAsavat, udanvadaMbhovivarddhanavacca tuhinadyuteH // pramANanirNaye kathaM tarhi pratyarthaniyatatvaM tadvacanasya sakaladarzanopajanite tatra sakalArthatAyA evopapatterniyataviSayAbhisaMdhezca nayarUpatayA tatrAsaMbhavAditi cet na, praznaviSayaM eva pratyarthaniyatAnekasvabhA vAdhikaraNAdapi taddarzanAttadupapateH / praznasya ca sakalaviSayasya yugapatpraznakAriNyasaMbhavAt saMbhave ca bhavatyeva tadvacanAt kutazcidapyaMtaraMgamala vizleSa vijRMbhitaprajJApATavasya gaNadharadevAdeH sakalaviSayapratipattiH / adyApi kasyacidbodhAtizayavizeSavataH sUtrAdeva tadvRttirvAttikAdivivaraNIya tadartha vistAraparijJAnasyopalaMbhAt / kaH punaH pravacanasyAptopajJatvena guNo yataH prAmANyamiti cet, pramANAMtarAvirodhalakSaNo'visaMvAda evaM na hyasau tatra zabdasyaiva sAmarthyena svatastasyopAdhyAya sevAvaiphalyaprasaMgenA pratyAyakatvAvaM, nA'pi puruSamAtrasya vacanamAtre'pi tatprasaMgAt / asti pravacane tatastadarthasya kathaMcitpratyakSeNAparasyAnumAnenAtyaMtaparokSasya ca tadekadezairaviruddhatayaivaM pratipatteH / ke punaste'rthA ye tathA te pratipattavyA iti cet / bhAveSvanekAMtaH pariNAmo 1 / 1 hetvarthe tRtIyA 2 satIti zeSaH 3 svasya prayojanAbhAvAt 4 mohAt 5 caMdrAt 6 arthe iti zeSaH 7 vyAkriyamANa 8 avAdhasvarUpaH 9 anizcAyakatvAt 10 kasya tadarthasya pratyakSeNAviruddhatayA tataH pratipattiriti saMbaMdhaH evamanumAnAdAvaSi yojyaM 11 pUrvAparAviruddhatayA tathaivoktaM zrImadAzAdharadevai " dRSTo'rtho'dhyakSato vAkyamanumeye'numAnataH / pUrvAparAbirodhena parokSe ca pramANate " //
Page #74
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ AgamanirNayaH / mArgastadviSayazca / tatrAnekAMto nAma teSAM yugapadanekarUpatvaM / pariNAmazca krameNAsti hi tayorguNapayaryavadravyamityAderAgamAdiva pratyakSAderapi pratipattizcetane svaparavedanavikalpAvikalpavibhramAvibhramAdibhiH svabhAvairacetane parisAmAnyavizeSaguNaguNyAdirbhistadekAMtabhedAbhedayorapratipattyA pratikSepeNa yugapadanekarUpasAdhyakSataH zaktibhedaizca kAryabhedapratipattihetukAdanumAnato'pi nirNayapathaprApaNAt / evaM pariNAmasya, tasyApi smaraNapratyabhijJAnAdyanupAtinazcisvabhAvasyAcitsvabhAvasyApi kuMDalaprasAraNAdyanuSaMgibhujaMgAyA tmanaH svAnubhavAdaidriyAdapyadhyakSato'nvIkSaNAt / evamanumAnato. 'pi / taccedaM-kramAdapyanekAMtAtmA bhAvo yugapadapyanyathA tdnupptteH| nityAnityAtmakasya tatra saMzayAderdoSAdabhAve saMkRnnAnakarUpatvamapi na syAt tadavizeSAt |maabhuuditi cet, na tarhi saMzayAdirapi, tadvikalpasyApi nAnAparAmarzarUpatvenAnekAMtAtmaka. tvAsaMbhave'nupapatteH / bhavatu saMkRdanekAMtaH, kathaM tAvatA krameNApi ? virodhAbhAvAditi cet na, niranvayavinAze tasya cirAtikrAMtaMvatkAryatatkAlamaprAptasyAnupayogenAvastutvApatteH, sAnvayavinAze tu sa eva parAparasamayeSvapi tasya svabhAva iti tadAtmanaH kramAnekAMtasya tataH sAdhanamavinAbhAvasya tatraivAdhyavasAyAt / kastarhi mArga iti cet , niHzreyasaprAptyupAya eva / sa ca trirUpaH "samyagdarzanajJAnacAritrANi mokSamArga" ityAgamAt / 1 sahabhAvino guNAH; kramabhAvinaH paryAyAH 2 " sarvathA savikalpatve tasya syAcchabdarUpatA / sarvathA nirvikalpatve svArthavyavasitiH kutaH" 3 svabhAvasyeti zeSaH 4 yugapaditi bhAvaH 5 jJAnasya 6 yugapat 7 agnyabhAve dhUmasadbhAvavirodhavat; kramAnekAMtAbhAve yugapadanekAMtasadbhAvasya virodhAbhAvAt 8 cetanAdeH 9 atItavat 10 Agamasya pramANAMtarAvirodhalakSaNaM darzayati //
Page #75
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pramANanirNaye anumAnAJca / taccedaM-trirUpo'pavargamArgaH apavargamArgatvAnyathAnupapatteH / na cA'tra hetorAzrAyAsiddhirapavargavAdinAM sarveSAmapi tasya prasiddhatvAt / nApyanyathopapattiH jJAnAdeH pratyekaM tanmArgatvAbhAvAt / tathA hi-na jJAnAdevApavargaH pratyutpannatatvajJAnasyApyanapavRktasyAvasthiteranyathopadeSTurabhAvenApavargArthinAM tatvajJAnasyAbhAvaprasaMgAt / nApi darzanAdevAyamabhirucirUpAt tadviSayAparikSAne tasyaivAsaMbhavAt / nApi tatastatparijJAnasahAyAdanuSThAnakalpanAvaiphalyopanipAtAt / nA'pi anuSThAnamAtrAt, tadviSayavedanA''darayorabhAve tasyaivAbhAvAt / tato yuktaM trairUpyameva tanmArgasya / __ kathaM punarbadhena tasyAvirodhe tatparikSayarUpastasmAdapavarga iticet na, sAkSAdavirodhe'pi tannidAnavirodhitayA'pi tatastadutpatteH / tathA hi-yadyannidAnavirodhi tatastatparikSayaH, yathA vyAdhinidAnavAtAdivirodhino bhaiSajyAt vyAdheH, baMdhanidAnavirodhI cokto mArga iti| baMdhasya ca nidAnaM rAgAdirAstravastadvirodhitvaM ca mArgastha, tasya bheSajasyevAtizayatAratamye rAgAdervAtAderivApakarSatAratamyasya pratipatteH / __ bhavatu nAma tadatyaMtAtizayadazAyAM tannidAnaparikSayAdhasyAnAgatasyAnutpatterabhAvaH prAgavasthasya tu kathamiti cet na, tasyApyAzravarUpasnehavazAvasthAyinastatsnehApakramAdevAbhAvAt / tatvAbhinivezarUpatvAnmArgasya tato mithyAbhinivezasyaivApavarttanaM kathaM rAgAderiti cet na, tasyApi tadvizeSatvAt / kutaH punastasya baMdhanibaMdhanatvamiti cet / ucyate / rAgAdirjIvasya zarI1 amuktasya / 2 Adizabdane zleSmapittayorgrahaNaM / 3 atra hetvarthe paMcamI // ___
Page #76
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ AgamanirNayaH / rAdivyatiriktapudgalavizeSa saMbaMdhahetu statvAnmadirAdyarthinastadrAgAdivat / yathAvasthitasvaparajJAnasvabhAvasyAtmanaH kuto rAgAdirapi doSo yatastasya tatsaMbaMdhanibaMdhanatvamiti cet na, tasyApi tAzotprAcyAdeva satsaMbaMdhato bhAvAt / tathA hi-tAdRzasyAtmano rAgAdistasaMbaMdha pUrvakastatvAnmadirApItasya rAgAdivat so'pi tatsaMbaMdhastataH prAcyAdrAgAdereva / na caivamanavasthitirdoSo hetuphalarUpatayA rAgAditatsaMbaMdhaprabaMdhasyAnAditvAt / taduktamjIvasya saMvido rAgAdiheturmadirAdivat / tatkarmAgaMtukaM tasya prabaMdho'nAdiriSyate // iti / viSayastu mArgasya saptadhA tatvaM jIvAjIvAzravabaMdhasaMvaranirjarAmokSAstatvam " iti sUtrAt / tadviSayatvaM ca tasya tannirNayAdeva pravRtteH / 66 na hi jIvasyAnirNaye tatpravRttiranirNItasyApavargArthitvAsaMbhavAt / nApyajIvasya tardA tatsaMbaMdhasya saMbaMdhasyAnavagamena tadviyogakAMkSAnutpatteH / nApyAzravasya baMdhasya ca tannidAnenivarttanadvAreNa zakyanivarttanatvAnavagamena kasyacittannivarttanAyodyamAnupapatteH / nApi saMvarasya nirjarAmokSayorvA tadApi tasya tannidAnapratyanIkatvaryaM tayorbaMdhavizleSasvabhAvatvasya cAnavagamena tadanupapatteH / kutastarhi jIvAdernizcaya iti cet na, jJAnasyaiva svaparasaMvedana svabhAvasyAnvayino jIvatvAttasya ca kramAnirUpaNe na nirNayAt, tadvilakSaNasyAjIvasya baMdhatadAsravayozca mArgAttadAstravanirodhasyAMtadvAreNa vaMdhanirharaNasyApyekaM deza sakalavikalpasyo - nirNayatvAt / 1 rAgAdihetukAt / 2 saMvitsvabhAvasya / 3 puMsa iti zeSaH / 4 anavagamasamaye / 5 nidAnaM kAraNaM 6 / tasya nidAnaM tasya pratyanIkasya bhAvastatvaM / 7 saMvarasya // * ekadezena nirjarI, sakaladezena mAkSaH / 71
Page #77
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pramANanirNaye kathamevaM " tapasA nirjarA ca " iti saMvara nirjarayostapo nimittatvamabhihitaM tapasaH kAyaparitAparUpasyAmArgAgatvAditi vet na, tapaH zabdena taMtrApi tatvajJAnaparipAkaparikalitasya bAhyetaravyApAroparamalakSaNasya cAritrasyaiva pratipAdanAdanazanAdInAM tatparibRMhaNaparatayaiva tapastvAt na mukhyataH / yadyevaM cAritrAdeva tAdRzAdAstravanirodhe kathamabhyadhAyi, " sa guptisamitidharmAnuprekSAparISahajayacAritraiH " iti gutyAderapi tanni rodha iti cet na, tasyApakRSTatadvikalparUpatayA lezatastato'pi tadupapatteH / kIdRzastArha mokSe jIvo nIrUpa eva na bhavatyeva kevalamityabhyupagamAditi cet na, tataH prAganuvRttisvabhAvatayA pratipannasya tadApi pUrvavattatsvabhAva parityAgAnupapatteH / prAgapi tasya vAstavamanuvRttimatvamadhyAropAdeva tasya bhAvAditi cet na, adhyAropasyApyaparAparakSaNeSvekatvAdhyavasAyasya tatpratipattivikalAdayogAt kSaNaparyavasAyinazca kutazcitpratyakSAdivattatpratipatteranupapatteH, aparAparasamayAnupAtitvasya tatra vAstavatve vastusata eva tadrUpatayA jIvasya vyavasthiteH / kAlpanikatve tatkalpanAkAriNyapyevaM prasaMgenAnavasthopanipAtAt / tato vAstavameva tasyAnuvRttimatvaM kalpanayA tadanupapatteriti mokSe nIrUpatvamupapannam / bhavatu tarhi jIvastadAnIM brahmavede brahmaiva bhavatItyAmnAyAt 72 "" 1 mokSamArgadeva bhavati cediti zaMkAyAM / 2 sUtre / 3 " bhavahetuprahANAya bahi ramyaMtarakriyAvinivRtteH paraM samyak cAritraM jJAnino matam " / 4 taTastho vakti, bauddhaH pratyavatiSThate, niHsvabhAvaH sarvazUnya' ityarthaH / 5 dIpo yathA nirRtimabhyupaiti naivAvaniM gacchati nAMtarikSaM // dizaM na kAMcidvidizaM na kAMcitsnehakSayAtkevalameti zAMti // " jIvastathA nirvRtimabhyupaiti naivAvaniM gacchati nAMtarikSaM / dizaM na kAMcidvidizaM na kAMcinmohakSayAtkevalamati zAMtiM 6 vidhavAdI vakti //
Page #78
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ aagmnirnnyH| brahmaNaikyamApanna iti cet na, brahmaNastadApi prAgiva tadbhedA. parityAge tadanupapatteH / tatparityAge cAtAdevasthyenAnityatvApattyA nityaM brahmati pratijJAvyApatteH / prAgapi tenaika eva jIvaH kevalamavidyAnibaMdhana eva bheda iti cet na, tadabhedinastasya tadvadeva suvizuddhajJAnasvabhAvatayA tasyApyavidyAnupapatteH / bhavatu ko doSa iti cet na, tatra nityanirmuktatayA muktyarthasyAtmadarzanazravaNamananAderAmnAyAbhirUDhasyAnarthakyApatteH ! ! ! astu tarhi jIvastadAnIM niravazeSabuddhayAdivaizeSikaguNanimukta iti cet na, tasya buddhayAdisvabhAvatvena tadabhAve satyabhAvasyaiva prasaMgAt / tadrUpatvaM ca tasyA'haM boddhA'haM draSTati buddhayAdisamAnAdhikaraNatayA pratyavabhAsanAditi cet, samAnAdhikaraNatayA pratyavabhAsanasya ca dravyatvaM sAmAnyamityAdAvabhedanibaMdhanasyaiva pratipatteH / buddhayAderAtmanastadguNatvena bhedAnmithyaiva tathA tatpratibhAsanamiti cet, kuto bhede'pi sa tasyaiva guNo nAkAzAderapi, samavAyasya tannibaMdhanasya tatrApi bhAvAt / svagatAt kutazcidvizeSAditi cet, saH ko'paro'nyatra kathaMcidabhedAt ? iti na jJAnAdivyatirekI jIvaH sNbhvtiiti| bhavatu tarhi tadA cinmAtrameva tasya tatvamiti cet, kimidaM cinmAtramiti ? dRzyopalaMbhavyAvRttaM svAvabhAsanamiti cet, tadupalaMbhasya tatsvabhAvatve kathaM tato vyAvRttiranityatvApatteratasvabhAvatve prAgapi kathaM sa. tasya ? tatsvabhAvayA prakRtyA saMsargAditi cet, na tarhi kadAcidapi tato vyAvRttiH prakRtyA 1 pUrvAvasthAyA abhAvalena / 2 yaugo vadati / 3 svarUpaM, sAMkhyasya matamadaH 4 ghaTAyupalabhavyAvRttaM 5 anyatheti zeSaH 6 mukteH prAgityartha. 7 pradhAnena //
Page #79
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 74 pramANanirNaye nityavyApikatayA tannibaMdhanasya saMsargasya sarvadA'pi bhAvAt / nA'pi rAgAdimalavilayaparizuddho niranvayaparizuddho vinazvarabodhakSaNaprabaMdha eva tadA sa iti sAMprataM niranvayavinAzitve bodhakSaNAnAmarthakriyAkAritvasya pratikSiptatvena prabaMdhAnupapatteH / tasmAnnirmUlanirmuktakarmabaMdho'tinirmalaH / vyAvRttAnugatAkAro'naMtamAnaMdadRgbalaH // 1 // niHzeSadravyaparyAyasAkSAtkaraNabhUSaNaH / jIvo muktipadaM prAptaH prapattavyo manISibhiH // 2 // bhavatu nAma nizcitalakSaNena pratyakSAdinA'saMvAdAttadviSayeNa prAmANyamAgamasyAtyaMtaparokSe tu jagatsaMnivezavizeSAdau kathaM nirNetavyamatannirNaye tatvajJAnasyAparipUrNatayA niHzreyasanivaMdhanatvAbhAvaprasaMgAditi cet na, tadviSayasyApi pravacanasya pratyakSAdisaMvAdabalAdavadhAritaprAmANyapravacanasamAnakartRkatayA tannirNayAt / na ca niHzeSanidhUtarAgAdidoSasya sarvavedinaH kacittathyA mithyA cAnyatra vacanapravRttiH saMbhavati, rAgAdimatyatatvajJa eva tathA tatpravRtterupalaMbhAt / samAnakartRkatvamapi tatra bhAgasya bhAgAMtaraNa zAsrAMtaravadavicchinnAdupadezapAraMparyAvagataH / __ padAdirUpameva pravacanaM padAdezca sphoTAtmano nikalasya nityatvenA'pauruSeyatvAt kathaM tadAtmanaH pravacanasya puruSaguNavazAtprAmANyamiti cet na, varNakramasyaiva padAditvAttadapi tada 1 nityatvAt vyAptitvAcca / * karmabhyaH vyAvRttaH, sNvidaadinaanugtH| 3 anNtsukhdrshnviiryjnyaanblH| 4 atyaMtaparokSavastupratipAdakasyAgamAMzasya prAmANyAnirNaye / 5 atyaMtaparokSArthapratipAdakAgamAMzasya / 6 pratyakSAdiprasiddhArthapratipAdakAgAzena saha / 7 bhAdra Aha / 8 Adizabdena vAkyasya grahaNaM / 9 niraMzasya /
Page #80
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ aagmnirnnyH| 75 nyasya tasyApratipatteH / varNAnAmitaretarakAlaparihArAvasthAyinAM kathamekatra vastupratipattAvupayoga iti cet / itaretaradezaparihArAvasthAyinAM kAraNAnAmapyekatra kArye kathaM ? teSAM yathAsvadezaM bhAvAditi cet na, varNAnAmapi yathA svakAlaM vidyamAnatvasyAvizeSAt / avazyaM caivamabhyupagaMtavyamanyathA tAlvAdiparispaMdasyAparAparasamayabhAvinaH ekatra padAdisphoTAbhivyaktAvapyanupayogitvenAnarthakatvaprasakteH / kathaM sphoTAdarthapratipattiH ? svAdhInAbhivyaktikAdanabhivyaktikAdvA tato'rthapratipattau sarvadA sarvasyApi ttstdaaptteH| tato varNakramanivezarUpameva padAdikaM, tasya ca pauruSeyatvAdupapannaM puruSaguNAyattaM tatra prAmANyaM / kathaM punarevamanityatve zabdasya tasmAd vyavahAro'pratipannasamayAttadanupapatteH, pratipannasamayasyApi tasya vyavahArakAlaM yAvadasthiteriti cet na, samayasyA'pyayamasyetyakaraNAt / kathaM tahIdRza IdRzasya vAcaka iti ? tatastAtkAlikasyevaM kAlAMtarabhAvino'pi tAdRzatayA samayaviSayatvAdupapadyata eva tasya vyavahAropayogitvaM / karttavyazcaivamaMgIkArastAlvAdivyApArajanmano dhvanivizeSasyApyanityasyaivameva samayaviSayatayA varNAbhivyaktAvupayogAdityalamativistareNa !!! kathaM punaranityatve zabdasya sa evAyamakAra ukAro vA yaH prAgazrAvIti pratyabhijJAnaM, satyeva nityatve tadupapatteriti cet na; tadgatAtkutazcitsAmAnyavizeSAdevaM tadavakRpteH / tasya sadRzapariNAmarUpatvAttAdRzo'yamiti bhavatu tatastavaklaptiH kathaM 1 vyApArasyati / 2 racanA / 3 zabdAdityarthaH / 4 ayaM zabdo'syArthasya vAcaka iti / 5 IdRzasyArthasyedRzaH zabdo vAcaka iti saMketakaraNaM kathaM / 6 kAraNAt / 7 zabdasya / 8 kutracitsAmAnyAt / 9 zabdasya //
Page #81
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ pramANanirNaye punaH sa evAyamiti cet na, tathA tato'pi kalamakezAdau tadupalabdheH / bhrAMtameva tatra tallUnapunarutpannatayA bhedini vastuta ekatvasyAbhAvAt iti cet na, varNAdiSvapi tadavizeSAt, vyayaprAdurbhAvayostatrApi pratyakSato'dhyavasAyAt / tadanenaM tabalAttatra vyApitvavarNanamapi pratyAkhyAtaM ghaTAdiSvavyApiSveva tatrApi tadbhAvAt / vyApinaH sAmAnyasya bhAvAdeva ghaTAdiSvapi tadbhAva iti cet na, tAdRzasya pravedanAsaMbhavAttatsaMbhave'pi varNeSvapi tata eva taditi kathaM tatastadavyaktiSu tatvapratipattiH ? kIdRzaH punarasau zabdo yasya prAdezikasyAnityasya copakalpanamiti cet, paudgalika iti bruumH| tathA hi-pudgalavivarttaH zabdaHiMdriyavedyatvAt kalazAdisaMsthAnavat / toyAdisaMsthAnena vyabhicArastasya satyapi tadvedyatve tadvivarttatvAbhAvAt / so'pi toyAdau sparzAdisvabhAvacatuSTayasyAbhAvena tallakSaNasya pudgalasyAbhAvAditi cet na, tatrApyanabhivyaktasya gaMdhAdeH sparzavatvAdeva liMgAtpRthivyAmiva pratipatteH, anubhUtasvabhAvatvAcca hemnyuSNasparzavadanupalaMbhasyApyavirodhAt / pRthivyAdirUpatayA cAturvidhyasyApi dhAraNa ivoSNeraNarUpatayA pudgalatatvAvizeSe'pyupapatteH, tannAyaM niyamaH, Apo rasarUpasparzavatyastejorUpasparzavat vAyuH sprshvaaniti| nApi sAmAnyaiH karmabhirvyabhicArasteSAM tadvato bhede tadvedhatvasyAprativedanAta; abhede tu tadvataH pudgalatayA tadvivarttatvena teSu sapakSasyaiva bhAvAt / mUrtimadiMdrayavedyatvasyaiva paudgalikatvena vyAptirna ca 1 pUrvoktanyAyena nityattvanirAkaraNena vA / 2 astviti zeSaH, tathAcAniSTa mImAMsakasya kutaH varNeSveva vyaktivattena sAmAnyAnaMgIkaraNAt / 3 ekatva 4 Adizabdena tejovAyU gRhiitvyau| 5 pRthivyAdeH pudgalatvAvizeSAt bhedaH kathamiti cet / 6 calanAtmakaiH //
Page #82
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ aagmnirnnyH| 77 ~~rrammmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmms zabdasya tadasti tadidriyasyAmUrttatvAditi cet, kathamevamanyo'pi hetudaMDAdinibaMdhanasyaiva kRtakatvasyAnityatvena vyAtina ca tacchabdasya vidyata ityapi vadato nivArayitumazakyatvAt kRtakatvamAtrasyaiva tena vyAptau prakRtenApyadriyatvamAtrasyaiva sA vktvyaa| kiM vA tadamUrtimadidriyam ? AkAzamiti cet na, tasya vyApitvenAtidUrasyApi zabdasya sarvasyakeMdriyatvenaM sarvaviSayasyaikenaikaviSayasya sarveNa zravaNaprasaMgAt / karNazaSkulivivaraparicchinnastasya pradeza iti cet na, tasya vAstavatve kAryatve ca nabhasaH kalazAdivadanityatvaprasaMgAta; kAlpanikasya ca vyomakusumAdivadidriyatvAnupapatteH / tataH kSayopazamasvabhAvazaktivizeSAdhyAsitajIvapradezAdhiSThitasya zarIrAvayavasyaiva zrotratvaM, tatsaMsparzanenaiva zabdasya zravaNamiti na tasyeMdriyAntarAtkazcidvizeSaH / kathaM punaH paudgalikatve zabdasya ghaTAdivadavyApakatvAnAnAdezasthairyugapadupalaMbhaH ? zrotrasyAprApyakAritvAditi cetna, tatra prApyakAri zrotraM pratyAsannagrAhitvAt, yannaivaM tannaivaM yathA nayanaM, tathA ca zrotramiti prApyakAritvasya vyvsthaapnaat| pratyAsannagrAhitvaM ca tasya tata eva tadvivaravartinaH kITakAdidhyAnasyApratipatteH / sAdhanavyAvRttizca nayanAttato'janAdestadgatasyAprativedanAttadaprApyakAritvasya ca pratyakSanirNaye nirUpitatvAt / kathamevamekazrotrapraviSTasya varNasya tadevAnyaiH zravaNamiti ? 1 kRtakatvAdiH / 2 zrotraikeMdriyatvena / 3 paudgIlakatvena ghaTAdevyApakatve'pi nayanasya prApyakAritvAdyupalaMbho yathA, tathA zabdasyApi kuto na syAditi prazna ityAha / 4 nRbhiH //
Page #83
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 78 pramANaniye na, varNasya nAnAdigabhimukha pravRttikasadRzAnekasvarUpatayaiva svahe - balato gaMdhavadeva prAdurbhAvAt / na hi gaMdhasyApi yugapannAnAdezasthamrANeMdriyaprAptirekasyaivAvyApino loSThavadeva tadanupapateH / tanaivaM pravacanasyApaugalikatvaparikalpanamupapannam / tataH sthitaM sakalabhAvAdhiSThAnayoranekAMtapariNAmayormArgatadviSayayozca pratipAdakaM pravacanamavisaMvAdabhAvAttadbhAvasya ca nirUpitatvAtpramANamiti / taca svaviSaye'nekAMtAdau tatpratyanIkadharmasadvitIye vartamAnaM saptabhaMgyA pravarttate / tadyathA syAdanekAtmaiva bhAvaH syAdekAtmaiva, syAdubhayAtmaiva, syAvavaktavya eva syAdanekAvaktavya eva syAdakAtmAvaktavya eva syAdubhayAtmAvaktavya eveti / anekAtmatatpratyanIkayo dvitvAttadAzrayAvubhAveva bhaMgAvupannaukathamamI sata bhaMgA iti cet na, pratipitsAtAvattvena tadupapatteH / tathA hi- anekatmanastatpratyanIkasya ca pratyekamubhayoH krameNa yugapacca pratipitsAyAM prAthamikAJcatvAro bhaMgAH, prathamabhaMgatrayasya krameNAvaktavyatvena saha bubhutsAyAmapare tryo bhaMgA iti / evaM pariNAmAdAvapi sapratyanIke bhaMgasaptakamunnetavyam / I na caivaM bhaMgAMtarasya parikalpanaM bhavati prathamAdedvitIyAdinA yoge tRtIyAdyaMtarbhAvasya bahulaM punaruktasyai copanipAtAt / tanna yuktamidaM- " saptabhaMgIprasAdena zatabhaMgyapi jAyate / " iti prakRtadharmavidhipratiSedhAbhyAmeva tadanutpatterjIvAdipadArthagatatadaparAnekadharmavidhivyavacchedabalAlaMbena tadavakalpanA 1 anyathA nAnAdigabhimukhavRttikasadRzAnekasvarUpatvAbhAve / 2 prathamabhaMgasya tRtIyabhaMgena saha yogena punaruktatvamastitvadvayAt // *
Page #84
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ AgamanirNayaH / yAmatyalpamidaM zatabhaMgItyAdi, tataH sahasrabhaMgyAderapi saMbhavAt / evakAro'tra sarvatroyogavyavacchedAya sarvamanekAtmaiva nAnyatheti, evamanyatrApiM / tasyApyanekAtmAdipadAdeva pratipattumasAmarthyaM bhavatvayaM ka syacitsAmarthye tu kimaneneti cet na, tadApyaprayoga eveti niyamAbhAvAt / kathaM tadabhAvaH pratItArthaprayogasya doSatvAditi cet, kathamidAnIM dvAvapUpau tvaM pacasItyatra dvaupadatvaMpadayoH prayogo vinA tAbhyAM tadarthapratipatteH / loke gurulAghavaM pratyanAdarAditi cet, siddhamevakAraprayogasyApi nirdoSatvaM / taJcAnekAtmatvaM bhAvasya syAtkathaMciddharmarUpeNaiva na dharmirUpeNa tasyaikasyaiva zabdAdirUpasya pratIterekAtmatvamapi dharmirUpeNaiva, na dharmarUpeNa, tasyApi tatrAnityatvakRtakaprayatnAnaMtarIyakatvAdirUpasyAnekasyaiva pratipatteH / kalpanaiva sA na vastutattvAvagAhinI buddhiriti cet na, kalpanAyA evAbhilApyAnabhilApyasvabhAvAyAH syAdvAdavidveSe satyanutpatteH / kalpanAyAM na tadvidveSa iti cedanyatrApi na syAdavizeSAt / evamubhayAtmakatvamapi svagatAbhyAmeva dharmadharmibhyAM kramavubhutsAviSayAbhyAM na bhAvAMtaragatAbhyAmavaktavyatvamapi tAbhyAM yugapadeva na krameNa nApi padAMtareNa tena yugapadapi zatRzAnayoH sacchadeneva vaktavyatvasaMbhavAt / evamuttaratrApi syAnnipAtAdatiprasaMganivRttiravagaMtavyA / 79 1 bhaMgeSu / 2 dvitIyAdibhaMgeSvapi / 3 puMsa iti zeSaH / 4 dvAviti padaM ca tvamiti padaM ca dvaupadatvaM / 5 anekaikatvaviSayA / 6 " dhIrvikalpAvikalpAtmA bahiraMtazca kiM punaH / nizcayAtmA svataH siddhayetparato'pyanavasthitiH 7 svarUpApekSayA // >>
Page #85
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 80 pramANanirNaye bhavatu nAma heyopAdeyatatvasya sopAyasya pravacanena pratipAdanaM tatparijJAnasya niHzreyasanibaMdhanatvena puruSArthahetutvAdanekAMtapariNAmayoH kimabhidhAneneti cet na, heyAditatvasya tavyApRtvajJApanArthatvAt, tasya na hyanekAtmapariNAmavikalaM tatsaMbhavati vastumAtrasyApi tavyAptasyaivopapatternirUpitatvAt / tathA cAnekAMtanyAyavidviSAM tadabhAvena tadavyAptasya heyAditatvasyApyanupapattestatpravacanAnAM tadAbhAsatvamabhihitaM bhavati / tataH sthitaM yuktizAstrAvirodhena sakalabhAvAdhikaraNAnakAMtapariNAmaniHzreyasamArgatadviSayalakSaNasya satyacatuSTayasya yathAvadabhidhAnAdanyayogavyavacchedena bhagavajinazAsanameva pramANamiti / zreyaH zrIjinazAsanaM yadamalaM buddhirmama stAda -- drIcI nityamanuttarApyadamuIcI me rucirvarddhatAm // A saMsAraparikSayAdamumuIcI bhAvanA bhAvato bhUyAnme bhvbNdhsNttimimaamucchettumicchaavtH|| iti zrImadbhagavadvAdirAjasUripraNIte pramANanirNayanAmni nyAyagraMthe aagmnirnnyH| // samAptiM paphANAyaM shriiprmaannnirnnyH|| ||shubhN bhavatu // 1 mArgaviSayabhUtasaptatatvasya / 2 amudrIcI, ado'cati prApnotItyamudrIcI, yathA vissvgdriicii| adamuIcI, amumuIcI iti prayogAvapi prAptyarthe'daHzabdAdbhavataH etaitribhiH prayogaiH " vAdirAjamanuzAbdikaloka " iti stutiH sAkSA. kRtArthA bhavati //
Page #86
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ Piyawans- msona -strunthar-ob nivedana / isa granthamAlAkI sahAyatA karanA pratyeka dharmAtmAkA kAma hai hai| yaha kevala prAcIna jainasAhityake uddhArake lie prakAzita hai hai kI jAtI hai / pratyeka granthakA mUlya ThIka lAgatake barAbara I rakkhA jAtA hai / isake pratyeka granthakI daza daza pA~ca pA~ca I pratiyA~ kharIdakara vidvAnoMko, pustakAlayoMko, jainamandiroMko I dharmArtha denA caahie| prabhAvanAke lie isase acchA kAma aura hai 1 nahIM ho sakatA / granthamAlAke kisI granthakI kamase kama / 250 pratiyA~ lenevAloMkA phoTU usa granthakI tamAma pratiyoMmeM lagavA diyA jAtA hai| ezarmannann. umrahmhmhuimerez t mas nivedaka ~-star-samsussionis nAthUrAma premI, maMtrI mANikacandajainagranthamAlA samiti, ___ hIrAbAga, bmbii| - 3-90-samso-st~-~-~~-sirsawe