________________
NOVEMBER, 19268]
Keith, A. B. Shamasastry, R.
Ghoshal .. Nag, Kalidas Law, N... Mookerjee, R. K. Stein, Otto
Winternitz
Ray, H. Č.
ن :::
:
:
Bannerjee, N. C. Rapson.
:::::.
WADDELL ON PHOENICIAN ORIGINS
206
The Authenticity of the Kautiliya, JRAS., 1916. Introduction to the 1st and 2nd editions of his Text and English translation of the Arthasdstra of Kautilya.
Chanakya's Land Revenue Policy (fourth century B.C.), Ind. Ant.,
1905. Political
Theories of the Hindus.
Les Théories Diplomatiques De L'Inde Ancienne et L'Arthasastra. Studies in Ancient Hindu Polity.
.. Introduction to the above. Megasthenes
und Kautilya, Academie der Wissenschaften in Wien, Philosophisch-historischeklasse, Sitzungsberichte, 191, Band
Wien 1921.
Readership Lecture at the Calcutta University on the date of the
Arthasâstra of Kautilya (not yet published).
Was State-Socialism known in Ancient India? Sir Asutosh Mookerjee Silver Jubilee Volumes, Vol. III, Part I-Orientalia. Position of the Brahmana in Kautilya.
Proceedings and Transactions of the Second Oriental Conference, Calcutta, 1922.
.. Religion and Belief in the Arthasâstra. Ibid.
.. Political and Social Organisation of the Maurya Empire.
The Cambridge History of India, Vol. I; also pp. 679-80 for bibliography.
V. Smith
.. Early History of India, 3rd edition, pp. 136, 144.
Oxford History of India, pp. 76-93.
Raychowdhury, H. C... Political History of Ancient India, University of Calcutta, 1923, pp. 145 ff.
Aiyangar, K. V. Ranga- Ancient Indian Polity.
swami.
WADDELL ON PHOENICIAN ORIGINS. BY SIR RICHARD C. TEMPLE, BT. (Continued from page 197.)
8.
Cup-Markings on Stone and Circles on Coins.
On this abstruse subject Waddell is even more original and startling than he has been hitherto in this book. The long title of this Chapter thereon is sufficient proof :-" Prehistoric cup-markings on circles, rocks, etc., in Britain; and circles on ancient Briton coins and monuments, as invocations to the Sun-god in Sumerian cipher script by early Phoenicians: disclosing decipherment and translation by identical cup-marks on Hitto-Sumerian seals and Trojan amulets with explanatory Sumerian script: and Hitto-Sumerian origin of godnames; Jahoveh or Jove, Indra, Indri, Thor of the Goths, St. Andrew; Earth-goddess Mais or May, the Three Fates, and English names of the numerals." Material enough here, one would think, for a whole book. 3
Starting with eight figures of cup-marked stones in Britain, Waddell gives eleven of cup-marks on Hitto-Sumerian amulet whorls from Troy, which he compares with ten figures on archaic Sumerian seals and amulets associated with a Sumerian seal dated B.c. 3000, showing "circles as diagnostic circle marks of Sumerian and Chaldee deities in the Trial of Adam, the Son of God Ia (Iahoveh or Jove or Indara)."
