Nakamura On Bhartrhari

Author(s): Ashok Aklujkar
Publisher: Ashok Aklujkar

Page 14

174
ASHOK AKLUJKAR
unitary, subtle form which is not different from the language-principle, śabda-tattva-brahman.39 It again appears as a diversity with main and subsidiary divisions after the creation of the universe. The Mimāņsakas, on the other hand, hold that even the divisions of the Veda are eternal, that it remains with divisions even in the event of the dissolution of the universe. See TK 1.5cd, V. pp. 24.2-26.5; V 1.6 p. 27.8-10; V 1.136 pp. 223.6-224.3; V 1.137 pp. 226.1-227.7.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Khw.ca) Tripädi, Idge, Mass. (Unbaris Trikāndi”.
Aklujkar, Ashok, 1969. "Two Textual Studies of Bhartphari", Journal of the American
Oriental Society (New Haven), 89.547-563. - 1970. “The Philosophy of Bhartshari's Trikāņdi". Ph. D. dissertation, Harvard
University. Cambridge, Mass. [Unpublished.] Bhartphari. (a) Tripädi. See fn. 6 above. Mahābhāşya-dipikā of Bhartshari, Part I. (Eds.)
K. V. Abhyankar and V. P. Limaye) (= Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute. Postgraduate and Research Department Series, No. 8) (Poona, 1967). I have received the forms of the second part. The particulars of publication are the same. (b) Trikāndi. See fn. 1 above. (i) kānda 1. (Ed.) K. A. Subramania Iyer, Vākyapadiya of Bhartshari with the Vrtti, and the Paddhati of Vrşabhadeva (= Deccan College Monograph Series, No. 32) (Poona, 1966). (ii) kāņda 2. (Ed.) Gangādhara Šāstri Mänavalli, Väkyapadiyam ... Sri-Bharthari- ... viracitam Sri-Punyarāja-krtaprakāšakhya-ţikäyutam (=Benares Sanskrit Series, Nos. 11, 19 and 24) (Benares, 1887). The numbering of the Vāk yapadiya verses in this edition is quite often incorrect. My references to the second kāņda assume a correction of those inaccuracies. Unfortunately the Vrtti of the second kāņda is yet to be published in its entirety. I have, therefore, been forced to refer to my hand-written copy of that Vrtti. See Aklujkar, 1969: 555-561. (iii) kända 3. With Helārāja's commentary Prakirņaka-prakāśa. Samuddeśas 1-7: (Ed.) K. A. Subramania Iyer (= Deccan College Monograph Series, No. 21) (Poona, 1963). Samuddeśas 8-13: (Ed.) K. Sāmbaśiva Šāstri (=Trivandrum Sanskrit Series, No. CXVI) (Trivandrum, 1935). Samuddeśa 14: (Ed.) L. A. Ravi Varmā (= University of Travancore Sanskrit Series,
No. CXLVIII) (Trivandrum, 1942). BSS. See Bhartshari (b) (ii) above. Charudeva Shastri, 1930. "Bharthari: a Critical Study with Special Reference to the
Vākyapadiya and its Commentaries”, Proceedings and Transactions of the Fifth
Indian Oriental Conference, Vol. I (Lahore), pp. 630-665. - 1934. (Ed.) Vāk yapadiyam Prathamam Kāņdam (Lahore, Ramlal Kapoor Trust). Helārāja. See Bharthari (b) (iii) above. Kunhan Raja, C., 1936. "I-tsing and Bhartphari's Vākyapadiya”, S. Krishnaswami
Aiyangar Comm. Volume (Madras), pp. 285-298. Punyarāja. See fn. 2b and Bhartphari (b) (ii) above.
89 V1.5 p. 24.2-4 (cp. V 1.134 p. 216.1-2, p. 219.6-7), p. 25.2, p. 26.5; V 1.6 p. 27.8-10; TK 1.9 V p. 37.3-8; TK 1.10a V pp. 38.3-39.8; TK 1.11a V p. 40.1; TK 1.112 V p. 184.2; chandah-śabdena param vāk-tattvam āha. (Vrşabha, p. 183.21-22); TK 1.137ab V p. 227.3-4.