________________ vyatirekavyapadeso hi yathakathancid vasanabalad api bhavann upalabhyata iti prak pratipaditam/ ji ltar sngon po myong ba zhes brjod pa de kho na ltar 'di myong ba sngon po'i rang bzhin yin no zhes rigs so // tha dad par bsnyad pa tsam gyis ni tha dad pa ma yin te / tha dad pa'i tha snyad ni rnam pa 'ga' zhig (D22b5) Itar bag chags kyi stobs las kyang dmigs pa yin no zhes sngar bstan zin to // [PVA 353.13-22] nanu nilam katham atmarupam prakasayati/na hi prakasya ghatadayah pradipadina svaprakasakah / svatmani83 ca 84 kriya virudhyate / na hi saivasidhara tayaiva vicchidyates / atra pariharah / ji ltar sngon po'i rang gi ngo bo gsal bar byed / sgron ma la sogs pas gsal bar bya ba bum pa la sogs pa dag ni rang nyid gsal bar byed pa ma yin no // bdag nyid la ni byed par 'gal ba yang yin (D22b6) te / ral gri'i so de nyid kyis gcod pa ni med do zhe na / 'di la lan / prakasamanas tadatmyat svarupasya prakasakah / yatha prakaso 'bhimatas tatha dhiratmavedini /(PV III 329) ji Itar de yi bdag nyid phyir // gsal byed rab tu gsal ba na // rang gi ngo bo gsal byed 'dod // de Itar blo bdag rig can yin // (PV III 329) svatmani kriyavirodha iti kutah pramanad avagatam / na hi dnstantamatrad * arthasya prasiddhih samihitasya viparyaye 'pi drstantasya pradipasya sambhavat /yadi ghatah pradipena bahyatmana prakasyate / pradipo 'pi tathabhutenapareneti na paryanuyogah /na ca ghato 'pi pradipena prakasyate / api tu tathabhutasyaiva tata utpattih 887 bdag nyid la byed pa 'gal ba zhes tshad ma gang las nges / dpe tsam gyis ni 'dod pa'i don (D2267) mi 'grub ste / bzlog pa la (P; las D) yang sgron ma dper yod pa'i phyir ro // gal te bum pa phyi rol gyi bdag nyid du gyur pa'i sgron mas gsal bar bya ba yin na / sgron ma yang de lta bu gzhan gyis gsal bar bya ba yin no zhes brgal zhing brtag pa ni ma yin no // bum pa yang sgron mas gsal bar (D23al) ni byas pa ma yin te /'on kyang de las de ltar skyes pa yin no // [PVA 353.22-27) atha pradipo 'py88 aparena caksuradina prakasyate / na / 82M's scribe seems to amend after inserting double danda. See M(178b2). 83svatmani M(17863); atmani S. 84ca M(17863), ... yang... T; om. S. 8Svicchidyate M(178b3); cchidyate S. SMT; ins. avedyavedakakara (PV III 330c) S. 87This sentence is quoted in Nyayabhusana (NBhu) of Bhasarvajna. See NBhu 138.9-10: yat punar uktam --- "na ca ghato 'pi pradipena prakasyate, api tu tathabhutasyaiva tata [M(B); om. tata NBhu] utpattir" iti. See Yamakami [1999: 228.8-11; 284,nn. 262-3] (in Japanese). 88'py S, yang T; om. M(17865). Hisayasu Kobayashi_15
