Disclaimer: This translation does not guarantee complete accuracy, please confirm with the original page text.
## 296
**Description of the Nine Substances and the Path to Liberation**
[**Water-dwelling, Land-dwelling, and Sky-dwelling**] Those who are water-dwelling, land-dwelling, and sky-dwelling [**Strong**] such strong [**Beings**] beings [**Color, Taste, Touch, Smell, and Sound**] are able to perceive color, taste, touch, smell, and sound [**Five Senses, Senses**].
**Special Meaning:** The commentator has explained this meaning as follows: Among the lower animals, some have very strong senses, such as the crocodile among water-dwelling creatures, the octopus among land-dwelling creatures, and the vulture among sky-dwelling creatures. Those beings with external souls who are attached to the pleasures of the senses, which are opposite to the unchanging bliss of pure consciousness that arises from meditation on the flawless Supreme Soul, bind the karma of the five senses, known as the "five-sense category." Upon its arising, they acquire the karma of "vigor-hindrance" and the karma of covering the senses of touch, taste, smell, sight, and hearing. Due to the destruction and pacification of these covering karmas, they gain the benefit of the five senses. Some beings, upon the arising of the karma that covers knowledge through the mind, become devoid of the five senses and the mind. They are then incapable of learning, conversing, or receiving teachings. Some beings, due to the destruction and pacification of the karma that covers the nine senses, become five-sensed beings with a mind. Among these five-sensed beings, hell-beings, humans, and gods are all "with a mind." The five-sensed lower animals are of two types: "with a mind" and "without a mind." Those with one to four senses are all "without a mind."
Someone might question: "Do beings without a mind also have knowledge of destruction and pacification? And isn't the mind the thought that arises from destruction and pacification? If this thought exists in beings without a mind, why are they called 'without a mind'?" The commentator answers: "Beings without a mind do not have the knowledge of the pervasiveness of cause and effect. They cannot contemplate beforehand, in every situation, that doing this will lead to this benefit and that doing that will lead to this harm. Beings without a mind act according to their nature, without considering benefit or harm. For example, the ant's cleverness in relation to smell and food, etc., is due to its natural disposition. It cannot contemplate or understand other matters. The mind has the power to indirectly know the Supreme Soul and other principles through the knowledge of pervasiveness, which is the knowledge of the three worlds and three times. Therefore, it is similar to pure knowledge."
**117**
... This is a conclusion regarding the relationship of the four paths of existence with the beings described according to their differences in senses.
**118**
... Gods have four bodies, humans are the earth of karma and enjoyment, and lower animals are numerous and diverse, dwelling on the earth.