Page #1
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ hetvAbhAsa hetvAbhAsa sAmAnya ke vibhAga meM tArkikoM kI vipratipatti hai| ajhapAda' pA~ca hetvAbhAsoM ko mAnate va varNana karate haiN| kaNAda ke sUtra meM spaSTatayA tIna hetvAbhAsoM kA nirdeza hai, tathApi prazastapAda usa sUtra kA zrAzaya batalAte hue cAra hetvAbhAsoM kA varNana karate haiN| prasiddha, viruddha aura anaikAntika yaha tIna to akSapAdakathita pA~ca hetvAbhAsoM meM bhI Ate hI haiN| prazastapAda ne anadhyavasita nAmaka cauthA hetvAbhAsa batalAyA hai jo nyAyasUtra meM nahIM hai / akSapAda aura kaNAda ubhaya ke anugAmI bhAsarvajJa ne chaH hetvAbhAsa varmita kiye haiM jo nyAya aura vaizeSika donoM prAcIna paramparAoM kA kula jor3a mAtra hai| diGnAga kattaka mAne jAnevAle nyAyapraveza meM5 zrasiddha, viruddha aura anekAntika ina tInoM kA hI saMgraha hai| uttaravartI dharmakIrti Adi sabhI bauddha tArkikoM ne bhI nyAyapraveza kI hI mAnyatA ko doharAyA aura spaSTa kiyA hai| parAne sAMkhyAcArya mAThara ne bhI ukta tIna hI hetvAbhAsoM kA sUcana va saMgraha kiyA hai| jAna par3atA hai mUla meM sAMkhya aura kaNAda kI hetvAbhAsasaMkhyA viSayaka paramparA eka hI rahI hai| jaina paramparA vastutaH kaNAda, sAMkhya aura bauddha paramparA ke anusAra tIna hI hetvAbhAsoM ko mAnatI hai| siddhasena aura vAdideva ne (pramANana0 6.47) 1 nyAyasU0 1. 2.4 / 2 'aprasiddho'napadezo'san sNdigdhshcaanpdeshH|-vai0 sU0 3.1. 15 / 3 'etenAsiddhaviruddhasandigghAdhyavasitavacanAnAm anapadezatvamukkaM bhavati / -praza0 pR0 238 / 4 'asiddhviruddhaankaantikaandhyvsitkaalaatyyaapdissttprkrnnsmaaH|' nyAyasAra pR07|| 5 'asiddhAnakAntikaviruddhA hetvaabhaasaaH| nyAyapra0 pR03| 6 'anye hetvAbhAsAH caturdaza asiddhAnakAntikaviruddhAdayaH |'-maatthr 5 // 7 'asiddhastvapratIto yo yo'nyathaivopapadyate / viruddho yo'nyathApyatra yuktounaikAntikaH sa tu ||'nyaayaa0 kA0 23 !
Page #2
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 166 zrasiddha zrAdi tInoM kA hI varNana kiyA hai| zrA0 hemacandra bhI usI mArga ke anugAmI haiM / zrA0 hemacandra ne nyAyasUtrokta kAlAtIta zrAdi do hetvAbhAsoM kA nirAsa kiyA hai para prazastapAda aura bhAsarvajJakathita anadhyavasita hetvAbhAsa kA nirAsa nahIM kiyA hai| jaina paramparA meM bhI isa jagaha eka matabheda hai---vaha yaha ki akalaGka aura unake anugAmI mANikyanandI zrAdi digambara tArkiMkoM ne cAra hetvAbhAsa batalAe haiN| jinameM tIna to prasiddha Adi sAdhAraNa hI haiM para cauthA akiJcitkara nAmaka hetvAbhAsa bilakula nayA hai jisakA ullekha anyatra kahIM nahIM dekhA jaataa| parantu yahA~ smaraNa rakhanA cAhie ki jayanta bhaTTa ne apanI myAyamaarI 2 meM anyathAsiddhAparaparyAya aprayojaka nAmaka eka naye hetvAbhAsa ko mAnane kA pUrvapakSa kiyA hai jo vastutaH jayanta ke pahile kabhI se calA AtA humA jAna par3atA hai| aprayojaka aura akiJcitkara ina do zabdoM meM spaSTa meda hone para bhI ApAtataH unake artha meM ekatA kA bhAsa hotA hai| parantu jayanta ne aprayojaka kA jo artha batalAyA hai aura akiJcitkara kA jo artha mANikyamandI ke anuyAyI prabhAcandra ne kiyA hai unameM bilakula antara hai, isase yaha kahanA kaThina hai ki aprayojaka aura akizcitkara kA vicAra mUla meM eka hai; phira bhI yaha prazna ho hI jAtA hai ki pUrvavartI bauddha yA jaina nyAyagranthoM meM akiJcitkara kA nAma nirdeza nahIM taba akalaka ne use sthAna kaise diyA, ataeva yaha sambhava hai ki aprayojaka yA anyathAsiddha mAnanevAle kisI pUrvavartI tArkika anya ke AdhAra para hI akalaGka ne akiJcitkara hetvAbhAsa kI apane DhaMga se naI saSTi kI ho| isa akizcitkara hetvAbhAsa kA khaNDana kevala vAdideva ke sUtra kI vyAkhyA. { syAdvAdara0 pR0 1230 ) meM dekhA jAtA hai / 1'asiddhazcAnuSatvAdiH zabdAnityatvasAdhane / anyathAsambhaSAbhAvabhedAt sa bahudhA smRtaH // viru ddhaasiddhsNdigdhairkinycitkrvistraiH| -nyAyavi0 2. 165-6 / parI0 6.21 / 2 'anye tu anyathAsiddhatvaM nAma tadbhadamudAharanti yasya hetomiNi vRttirbhavantyapi sAdhyadharmaprayuktA bhavati na, so'nyathAsiddho yathA nityA manaHparamANavo mUrttatvAd ghaTavaditi .........sa cAtra prayojyaprayojakamAvo nAstItyata evAyamanyathAsiddho'prayojaka iti kathyate / kathaM punarasyAprayojakatvamavagatam - nyAyama0 pR. 607 // 3 'siddha nirNIte pramANAntarAtsAdhye pratyakSAdivAdhite ca heturna kiJcitkaroti iti akinycitkro'nrthkH|-prmeyk0 pR0 163 AL
Page #3
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 166 Upara jo hetvAbhAsasaMkhyA viSayaka nAnA paramparAe~ dikhAI gaI haiM una saba kA matabheda mukhyatayA saMkhyAviSayaka hai, tattvaviSayaka nhiiN| aisA nahIM hai ki eka paramparA jise amuka hetvAbhAsa rUpa doSa kahatI hai agara vaha sacamuca doSa ho to use dUsarI paramparA svIkAra na karatI ho| aise sthala meM dUsarI paramparA yA to usa doSa ko apane abhipreta kisI hetvAbhAsa meM antabhAvita kara detI hai yA pakSAbhAsa zrAdi anya kisI doSa meM yA apane abhipreta hetvAbhAsa ke kisI na kisI prakAra meN| zrA0 hemacandra ne hetvAbhAsa (pra0 mI0 2. 1. 16) zabda ke prayoga kA anaucitya batalAte hue bhI sAdhanAbhAsa artha meM usa zabda ke prayoga kA samarthana karane meM eka tIra se do pakSI kA vedha kiyA hai.-pUrvAcAryoM kI paramparA ke anusaraNa kA viveka bhI batalAyA aura unakI galatI bhI drshaaii| isI taraha kA viveka mANikyanandI ne bhI darzAyA hai| unhoMne apane pUjya akalaGkakathita akiJcitkara hetvAbhAsa kA varNana to kiyA; para unheM jaba usa hetvAbhAsa ke alaga svIkAra kA aucitya na dikhAI diyA taba unhoMne eka sUtra meM isa hA se usakA samarthana kiyA ki samarthana bhI ho aura usake alaga svIkAra kA anaucitya bhI vyakta ho-'lakSaNa evAsau doSo vyutpannaprayogasya pakSadoSeNaiva duSTatvAt'-(parI0 6. 36) / prasiddha hetvAbhAsa nyAyasUtra (1.2.8) meM prasiddha kA nAma sAdhyasama hai| kevala nAma ke hI viSaya meM nyAyasUtra kA anya granthoM se vailakSaNya nahIM hai kintu anya viSaya meM bhii| vaha anya viSaya yaha hai ki jaba anya sabhI grantha asiddha ke kama yA adhika prakAroM kA lakSaNa udAharaNa sahita varNana karate haiM taba nyAyasUtra aura usakA bhAdhya aisA kucha bhI na karake kevala prasiddha kA sAmAnya svarUpa batalAte haiM / prazastapAda aura nyAyapraveza meM prasiddha ke cAra prakAroM kA spaSTa aura samAnaprAya' varNana hai| mAThara (kA0 5) bhI usake cAra bhedoM kA nirdeza karate haiM jo sambhavataH unakI dRSTi meM ve hI rahe hoNge| nyAyabindu meM dharmakIrti 1 'ubhayAsiddho'nyatarAsiddhaH tadbhAvAsiddho'numeyAsiddhazceti |-prshst. pR0 238 / 'ubhayAsiddho'nyatarA siddhaH saMdigdhAsiddhaH zrAzrayAsiddhazceti / ' -nyAyapra0 pR0 3 /
Page #4
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 200 ne prazastapAdAdikathita cAra prakAroM kA to varNana kiyA hI hai para unhoMne prazastapAda tathA nyAyapraveza kI taraha zrAzrayAsiddha kA eka udAharaNa na dekara usake do udAharaNa diye haiM aura isa taraha asiddha ke cauthe prakAra zrAzrayAsiddha ke bhI prabheda kara diye haiM / dharmakIrti kA varNana vastutaH prazastapAda aura nyAyapravezagata prastuta varNana kA thor3A sA saMzodhana mAtra hai (nyAyavi0 3 58-67) / / I nyAyasAra ( pR08) meM asiddha ke caudaha prakAra sodAharaNa batalAe gae haiN| nyAyamaJjarI ( pR0 606 ) meM bhI usI DhaMga para aneka medoM kI sRSTi kA varNana hai / mANikyanandI zabda-racanA badalate haiM ( parI0 6. 22-28 ) para vastutaH ve siddha ke varNana meM dharmakIrtti ke hI anugAmI haiM prabhAcandra ne parIkSAmukha kI TIkA mArtaNDa meM ( pR0 161 A ) mUla sUtra meM na pAe jAnevAle asiddha ke aneka bhedoM ke nAma tathA udAharaNa diye haiM jo nyAyasAragata hI haiM / A0 hemacandra ke prasiddhaviSayaka sUtroM kI sRSTi nyAyabindu aura parIkSAmukha kA anusaraNa karanevAlI hai| unakI udAharaNamAlA meM bhI zabdazaH nyAyasAra kA anusaraNa hai / dharmakIrtti aura mANikyanandI kA akSarazaH anusaraNa na karane ke kAraNa vAdideva ke prasiddhaviSayaka sAmAnya lakSaNa (pramANana0 6. 46 ) meM A0 hemacandra ke sAmAnya lakSaNa kI apekSA vizeSa pariSkRtatA jAna par3atI hai / vAdideva ke prastuta sUtroM kI vyAkhyA ratnAkarAvatArikA meM jo siddha ke bhedoM kI udAharaNamAlA hai vaha nyAyasAra aura nyAyamaJjarI ke udAharaNoM kA akSarazaH saGkalana mAtra hai / itanA antara avazya hai ki kucha udAharaNoM meM vastuvinyAsa vAdI devasUri kA apanA hai / viruddha hetvAbhAsa jaisA prazastapAda meM viruddha ke sAmAnya svarUpa kA varNana hai vizeSa bhedoM kA nahIM, vaise hI nyAyasUtra aura usake bhASya meM bhI viruddha kA sAmAnya rUpa se varNana hai, vizeSa rUpa se nahIM / itanA sAmya hote hue bhI sabhASyanyAyasUtra aura prazastapAda meM udAharaNa evaM pratipAdana kA bheda' spaSTa hai / 3 1 'siddhAntamabhyupetya tadvirodhI viruddhaH / - nyAyasU0 1.2.6 / 'yathA so'yaM vikAro vyakterapaiti nityatvapratiSedhAt zrapeto'pyasti vinAzapratiSedhAt, na nityo vikAra upapadyate ityevaM hetuH - 'vyakterapetopi vikArosti' ityanena svasiddhAntena virudhyate / yadasti na tadAtmalAbhAt pracyavate, astitvaM cAtmalAbhAt
Page #5
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 201 jAna par3atA hai nyAyasUtra kI aura prazastapAda kI viruddha viSayaka vicAraparamparA eka nahIM hai| nyAyapraveza (pR05) meM viruddha ke cAra bheda sodAharaNa batalAe haiN| sambhavataH mAThara (kA0 5) ko bhI ve hI abhipreta haiM / nyAyabindu (3.83-88) meM viruddha ke prakAra do hI udAharaNoM meM samApta kiye gae haiM aura tIsare 'iSTavidhAtakRt' nAmaka adhika bheda hone kI AzaGkA (3.86-64 ) karake usakA samAveza abhipreta do bhedoM meM hI kara diyA gayA hai| iSTavighAtakRt nAma nyAyapraveza meM nahIM hai para usa nAma se jo udAharaNa nyAyabindu ( 3.60) meM diyA gayA hai vaha nyAyapraveza ( pR05) meM vartamAna hai / jAna par3atA hai nyAyapraveza meM jo 'parArthAH cakSurAdayaH' yaha dharma vizeSaviruddha kA udAharaNa hai usI ko koI iSTavighAtakRt nAma se vyavahata karate hoMge jisakA nirdeza karake dharmakIrti ne antarbhAva kiyA hai| jayanta ne (nyAyama0 pR0 600-601) gautamasUtra kI hI vyAkhyA karate hue dharmavizeSaviruddha aura dhammivizeSaviruddha ina do tIrthAntarIya viruddha bhedoM kA spaSTa khaNDana kiyA hai jo nyAyapravezavAlI paramparA kA hI khaNDana jAna par3atA hai| nyAyasAra (pR06) meM viruddha ke medoM kA varNana sabase adhika aura jaTila bhI hai| usameM sapakSa ke astitvavAle cAra, nAstitvavAle cAra aise viruddha ke pATha bheda jina udAharaNoM ke sAtha haiM, una udAharaNoM ke sAtha vahI zrATha bheda pramANanayatatvAloka kI vyAkhyA meM bhI haiM (pramANana0 652-53) / yadyapi parIkSAmukha kI vyAkhyA mArtaNDa meM (pR0 162 A ) nyAyasAravAle ve hI ATha bheda haiM tathApi kisI-kisI udAharaNa meM thor3A sA parivartana ho gayA hai| zrA0 hemacandra ne to pramANanayatattvAloka kI vyAkhyA kI taraha apanI vRtti meM zabdaza: nyAyasAra ke pATha bheda sodAharaNa batalAkara unameM se cAra viruddhoM ko prasiddha evaM viruddha donoM nAma se vyavahRta karane kI nyAyamaJjarI aura nyAyasAra kI dalIloM ko apanA liyA hai| prabyutiriti viruddhAvetau dhauM na saha sambhavata iti / so'yaM heturya siddhAntamAzritya pravartate tameva vyAhanti iti |'-nyybhaa0 1. 2. 6 / 'yo hyanumeye'vidyamAno'pi tatsamAnajAtIye sarvasminnAsti tadviparIte cAsti sa viparItasAdhanAdviruddhaH yathA yasmAdviSANI tasmAdazva iti |-prshst0 pR0 238 /
Page #6
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 202 kAntika hetvAbhAsa naikAntika hetvAbhAsa ke nAma ke viSaya meM mukhya do paramparAe~ prAcIna haiN| pahalI gautama kI aura dUsarI karaNAda kii| gautama apane nyAyasUtra meM jise samyabhicAra ( 1. 2. 5. ) kahate haiM usI ko kaNAda apane sUtroM (3.1.15 ) meM sandigdha kahate haiM / isa nAmabheda kI paramparA bhI kucha zrartha rakhatI hai aura vaha artha agale satra vyAkhyAgranthoM se spaSTa ho jAtA hai / vaha artha yaha hai ki eka paramparA zranaikAntikatA ko arthAt sAdhya aura usake abhAva ke sAtha hetu ke sAhacarya ko, samyabhicAra hetvAbhAsa kA niyAmaka rUpa mAnatI hai saMzayajanakatva ko nahIM jaba dUsarI paramparA saMzayajanakatva ko to zranaikAntika hetvAbhAsatA kA niyAmaka rUpa mAnatI hai sAdhya tadabhAvasAhacarya ko nhiiN| pahalI paramparA ke anusAra jo hetu sAdhya - tadabhAvasahacarita hai cAhe vaha saMzayajanaka ho yA nahIM-vahI savyabhicAra yA zranaikAntika kahalAtA hai / dUsarI paramparA ke anusAra jo hetu saMzayajanaka hai - cAhe vaha sAdhya - tadabhAvasahacarita ho yA nahIM-vahI zranaikAntika yA savyabhicAra kahalAtA hai / anaikAntikatA ke isa niyAmakabhedavAlI do ukta paramparAoM ke anusAra udAharaNoM meM bhI antara par3a jAtA hai / zrataeva gautama kI paramparA meM asAdhAraNa yA viruddhAvyabhicArI kA zranaikAntika hetvAbhAsa meM sthAna sambhava hI nahIM kyoMki ve donoM sAdhyAbhAvasahacarita nahIM / ukta sArthakanAmabheda vAlI donoM paramparAoM ke paraspara bhinna aise do dRSTikoNa Age bhI cAlU rahe para uttaravartI sabhI tarkazAstroM meM- cAhe ve vaidika hoM, bauddha hoM, yA jaina-nAma to kevala gautamIya paramparA kA zranaikAntika hI jArI rahA / kaNAdIya paramparA kA sandigdha nAma vyavahAra meM nahIM rahA / prazastapAda aura nyAyapraveza ina donoM kA paurvAparya abhI sunizcita nahIM zrataeva yaha nizcita rUpa se kahanA kaThina hai ki amuka eka kA prabhAva dUsare para hai tathApi nyAyapraveza aura prazastapAda ina donoM kI vicArasaraNI kA bhinnatva aura pArasparika mahattva kA bheda khAsa dhyAna dene yogya hai| nyAyapraveza meM yadyapi nAma to zranaikAntika hai sandigdha nahIM, phira bhI usameM naikAntikatA kA niyAmaka rUpa prazastapAda kI taraha saMzayajanakatva ko hI mAnA hai / zrataeva nyAyapravezakAra ne anaikAntika ke chaH bheda catalAte hue unake sabhI udAharaNoM meM saMzayajanakatva spaSTa batalAyA hai / prazastapAda nyAyapraveza kI taraha saMzaya * 1 ' tatra sAdhAraNaH - zabdaH prameyatvAnnitya iti / taddhi nityAnityapakSayoH
Page #7
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 203 janakatva ko to naikAntikatA kA niyAmaka rUpa mAnate haiM sahI, para ve nyAyapraveza meM anaikAntika rUpa se udAhRta kiye gae asAdhAraNa aura viruddhAvyabhicArI ina do bhedoM ko zranaikAntika yA sandigdha hetvAbhAsa meM nahIM ginate balki nyAyapravezasammata ukta donoM hetvAbhAsoM kI sandigdhatA kA yaha kaha kara ke khaNDana karate haiM ki asAdhAraNa aura viruddhAvyabhicArI saMzayajanaka hI nahIM ? | prazastapAda ke khaNDanIya bhAgavAlA koI pUrvavartI vaizeSika grantha yA nyAyapravezabhinna bauddhagrantha na mile taba taka yaha kahA jA sakatA hai ki zAyada prazastapAda ne nyAyapraveza kA hI khaNDana kiyA hai| jo kucha ho, yaha to nizcita hI hai ki prazastapAda ne asAdhAraNa aura viruddhAvyabhicArI ko sandigdha yA anaikAntika mAnane se inkAra kiyA hai / prazastapAda ne isa prazna kA, ki kyA taba asAdhAraNa aura viruddhAvyabhicArI koI hetvAbhAsa hI nahIM ?, jabAba bhI bar3I buddhimAnI se diyA hai / prazastapAda kahate haiM ki asAdhAraNa hetvAbhAsa hai sahI para vaha saMzayajanaka na hone se anaikAntika nahIM, kintu use zranadhyavasita kahanA cAhie / isI taraha ve viruddhAvyabhicArI ko saMzayajanaka na mAnakara yA to zrasAdhAturUpa zranadhyavasita meM ginate haiM yA use viruddhavizeSa hI kahate ( zrayaM tu viruddhabheda eva praza0 pR0 236 ) haiM / kucha bhI ho para ve kisI taraha asAdhAraNa aura viruddhAvyabhicArI ko nyAyapraveza kI taraha saMzayajanaka mAnane ko taiyAra nahIM haiM phira bhI ve una donoM ko kisI na kisI hetvAbhAsa meM sanniviSTa karate hI haiM / isa carcA ke sambandha meM prazastapAda kI aura bhI do bAteM khAsa dhyAna dene yogya haiN| pahalI to yaha hai ki zranadhyavasita nAmaka sAdhAraNatvAdanaikAntikam / kim baTavat prameyatvAdanityaH zabdaH zrAhosvidAkAzavatprameyatvAnitya iti / - ityAdi-nyAyapra0 pR0 3 / 1 'asAdhAraNaH - zrAvaNatvAnnitya iti / taddhi nityAnityapakSAbhyAM vyAvRttatvAnnityAnityavinirmuktasya cAnyasyAsambhavAt saMzayahetuH kimbhUtasyAsya zrAvaNatvamiti / ..... viruddhAvyabhicArI yathA anityaH zabdaH kRtakatvAt ghaTavat; nityazabdaH zrAvaNatvAt zabdatvavaditi / ubhayoH saMzayahetutvAt dvAvapyetovekokAntikaH samuditAveva / nyAyapra0 pR0 3,4 / 'ekasmiMzca dvayorheoryathoktalakSaNayorviruddhayoH sannipAte sati saMzayadarzanAdayamanyaH sandigdha iti kecit yathA mUrtatvAmUrtatvaM prati manasaH kriyAvattvAsparzavattvayoriti / nanvayamasAdhAraNa evAcAkSuSatva pratyakSatvavat saMhatayoranyatarapakSAsambhavAt tatazcAnadhyavasita iti vakSyAmaH / '- prazastra0 pR0 238, 236 //
Page #8
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 204 hetvAbhAsa kI kalpanA aura dUsarI yaha ki nyAyapravezagata viruddhAvyabhicArI ke udAharaNa se vibhinna udAharaNa ko lekara viruddhAvyabhicArI ko saMzayajanaka mAnane na mAnane kA zAstrArtha / yaha kahA nahIM jA sakatA ki kaNAdasUtra meM avidyamAna anadhyavasita pada pahile pahala prazastapAda ne hI prayukta kiyA yA usake pahile bhI isakA prayoga alaga hetvAbhAsa artha meM rahA / nyAyapraveza meM viruddhAvyabhicArI kA udAharaNa-nityaH zabdaH zrAvaNatvAt zabdatvavat, anityaH zabdaH kRtakatvAt ghaTavat' yaha hai, jaba ki prazastapAda meM udAharaNa'manaH mUrtam kriyAvatvAta; manaH amUrtam aspazavattvAt'-yaha hai| prazastapAda kA udAharaNa to vaizeSika prakriyA anusAra hai hI, para Azcarya kI bAta yaha hai ki bauddha nyAyapraveza kA udAharaNa khuda bauddha prakriyA ke anusAra na hokara eka taraha se vaidika prakriyA ke anusAra hI hai kyoMki jaise vaizeSika zrAdi vaidika tArkika zabdatva ko jAtirUpa mAnate haiM vaise bauddha tArkika jAti ko nitya nahIM mAnate / astu, yaha vivAda Age bhI claa| tArkikapravara dharmakIrti ne hetvAbhAsa kI prarUpaNA bauddhasammata hetutrarUpya ke' AdhAra para kI, jo unake pUrvavartI bauddha granthoM meM abhI taka dekhane meM nahIM aaii| jAna par3atA hai prazastapAda kA anaikAntika hetvAbhAsa viSaya bauddha mantavya kA khaNDana barAbara dharmakIrci ke dhyAna meM rhaa| unhoMne prazastapAda ko javAba dekara nyAyapraveza kA bacAva kiyA / dharmakIrci ne vyabhicAra ko aneMkAstikatA kA niyAmakarUpa nyAyasUtra kI taraha mAnA phira bhI unhoMne nyAyapraveza aura prazastapAda kI taraha saMzayajanakatva ko bhI usakA niyAmaka rUpa mAna liyaa| prazastapAda ne nyAyapravezasammata asAdhAraNa ko anaikAntika mAnane kA yaha kahakara ke khaNDana kiyA thA ki vaha saMzayajanaka nahIM haiN| isakA javAba dharmakIrti ne asAdhAraNa kA nyAyapraveza kI apekSA judA udAharaNa racakara aura usakI saMzayajanakatA dikhAkara, diyA aura batalAyA ki asAdhAraNa anekAntika hetvAbhAsa hI hai / itanA karake hI dharmakIni santuSTa na rahe para apane mAnya 1 'tatra trayANAM rUpANAmekasyApi rUpasyAnuttau sAdhanAbhAsaH / uktAvapya. siddhau sandehe vA pratipAdyapratipAdakayoH / ekasya rUpasya'.. .. ityAdi -nyAbi0 3.57 se| 2 'anayoreva dayo rUpayoH saMdehe'naikAntikaH / yathA sAtmakaM jIpaccharIraM prANAdimattvAditi |......at evAnvayavyatirekayo: saMdehAdanakAntikaH / sAdhyetarayorato nizcayAbhAvAt |'-nyaaybi0 3. 68-110 /
Page #9
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 205 AcArya diGnAga kI paramparA ko pratiSThita banAe rakhane kA aura bhI prayatna kiyA / prazastapAda ne viruddhAvyabhicArI ke khaNDana meM jo dalIla dI thI usako svIkAra karake bhI prazastapAda ke khaNDana ke viruddha unhoMne viruddhAvyabhicArI kA samarthana kiyA aura vaha bhI isa DhaMga se ki diGnAga kI pratiSThA bhI banI rahe aura prazastapAda kA javAba bhI ho| aisA karate samaya dharmakIrtti ne viruddhAvyabhicArI kA jo udAharaNa diyA hai vaha nyAyapraveza aura prazastapAda ke udAharaNa se judA hai phira bhI vaha udAharaNa vaizeSika prakriyA ke anusAra hone se prazastapAda ko grAhya nahIM ho sakatA / isa taraha bauddha aura vaidika tArkikoM kI isa viSaya meM yahA~ taka carcA AI jisakA anta nyAyamaJjarI meM huA jAna par3atA hai / jayanta phira apane pUrvAcAryoM kA pakSa lekara nyAyapraveza aura dharmakIrtti ke nyAyabindu kA sAmanA karate haiN| ve asAdhAraNa aura viruddhAvyabhicArI ko naikAntika na mAnane kA prazastapAdagata mata kA bar3e vistAra se samarthana karate haiM para sAtha hI ve saMzayajanakatva ko anaikAntikatA kA niyAmaka rUpa mAnane se bhI inkAra karate haiM / bhAsarvajJa ne bauddha, vaidika tArkikoM ke prastuta vivAda kA sparza na kara anaikAntika hetvAbhAsa ke ATha udAharaNa diye haiM ( nyAyasAra pR0 10 ), aura kahIM saMzayajanakatA kA ullekha nahIM kiyA hai / jAna par3atA hai vaha gautamIya paramparA kA anugAmI hai / 1 'viruddhAJyabhicAryapi saMzayaheturuktaH / sa iha kasmAnnoktaH / ...... zratrodAharaNaM yatsarvadezAvasthitaiH svasambandhibhiryugapadabhisambadhyate tatsarvagataM yathA'kAzam, abhisambadhyate sarvadezAvasthitaiH svasambandhibhiryugapat sAmAnyamiti / ...... dvitIyo'pi prayogo yadupalabdhilakSaNaprAsaM sannopalabhyate na tat tatrAsti / tadyathA rafavidyamAna ghaTaH / nopalabhyate copalabdhilakSaNaprAptaM sAmAnyaM vyaktyantarAleSviti / zrayamanupalambhaprayogaH svabhAvazca parasparaviruddhArthasAdhanAdekatra saMzayaM janayataH / - nyAyaci0 3. 112-121 / 2 sAdhAraNavirudvAvyabhicAriNau tu na saMsta eva hetvAbhAsAviti na vyAkhyAyete |.......................api ca saMzayajananamanaikAntikalakSaNamucyate cet kAmamasAdhAraNasya viruddhAvyabhicAriNo vA yathA tathA saMzayahetutAmadhiropya kathyatAmanaikAntikatA na tu saMzayajanakatvaM tallakSaNam.... api tu pakSadvayavRttitvamanaikAntika.....' - bhyAyama0 pR0 568-566 / lakSaNam
Page #10
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 206 jaina paramparA meM anekAntika aura sandigdha yaha donoM hI nAma milate haiN| akalaGka (nyAyavi0 2. 166 ) sandigdha zabda kA prayoga karate haiM jaba ki siddhasena (nyAyA0 23) Adi anya jaina tArkika anaikAntika pada kA prayoga karate haiM / mANikyanandI kI anaikAntika nirUpaNa viSayaka sUtraracanA zrA0 hemacanda kI sUtraracanA kI taraha ho vastutaH nyAyabindu kI sUtraracanA kI saMkSisa praticchAyA hai / isa viSaya meM vAdideva kI sUtraracanA vaisI parimArjita nahIM jaisI mANikyanandI aura hemacandra kI hai, kyoMki vAdideva ne anaikAntika ke sAmAnya lakSaNa meM hI jo 'sandihyate' kA prayoga kiyA hai vaha jarUrI nahIM jAna par3atA / jo kucha ho para isa bAre meM prabhAcandra, vAdideva aura hemacandra ina tInoM kA eka hI mArga hai ki ve sabhI apane-apane granthoM meM bhAsarvajJa ke pATha prakAra ke anaikAntika ko lekara apane-apane lakSaNa meM samAviSTa karate haiN| prabhAcandra ke (prameyaka0 pR0 162) sivAya auroM ke granthoM meM to pATha udAharaNa bhI ve hI haiM jo nyAyasAra meM haiN| prabhAcandra ne kucha udAharaNa badale haiN| yahA~ yaha smaraNa rahe ki kisI jainAcArya ne sAdhyasaMdehajanakatva ko yA sAdhyavyabhicAra ko anaikAntikatA kA niyAmaka rUpa mAnane na mAnane kI bauddhavaizeSikagranthagata carcA ko nahIM liyA hai| I0 1636 ] [pramANa mImAMsA