Two Siddhasenas And Authorship Of Nyayavatara And Sammati Tarka Pprakarana

Author(s): Piotr Balcerowicz
Publisher: Piotr Balcerowicz

Page 14

PIOTR BALCEROWICZ 210 SAN TWO SIDDHASENAS AND THE AUTHORSHIP 377. ! 8). 57 STP.2.27-29: mai-suya-nana-nimitto chaumatthe hoi attha-uvalambho / egayarammi vi tesim na damsanam damsanam kutto? Il jam paccakkha-gahanam na inti suya-nana-sammiya attha / tamha dansana-saddo na hoi sayale vi suya-nane | jam aputtha bhava ohi-nnanassa homti paccakkha / tamha ohi-nnano dainsana-saddo vi uvayutto II 58 See STP.2.6, 23, 27, 32. 59 See STP.2.21 and 2.23-24. 60 See $ 6.2.2 above and n. 47 as well as $ 4.3 and SS 5 of BALCEROWICZ (forthcoming). 61 See & 4.1 of BALCEROWICZ (forthcoming). The model is found in the Agamas, e.g. in Bhagavai 8.2.22-23 (p. 336): ...pamcavihe nane pannatte, tam jaha - abhinibohiyanane suya-nane ohi-nane manapajjava-nane kevala-nane. ... abhinibohiya-nane catuv. vihe pannatte, tam jaha - uggaho iha avao dharana; Bhagavai 2.10.9[2] (p.115): ...jive nam anamtanam abhinibohiya-nana-pajjavanam evam suta-nana-pajjavanam ohinana-pajjavanam manapajjava-nana-pajjavanam kevala-nana-pajjavanam mati-annanapajjavanam suta-anhana-pajjavanam vibhanga-nana-pajjavanam cakkhu-dam sanapajjavanam acakkhu-dam sana-pajjavanamohi-damsana-pajjavanam kevala-damsanapajjavanam uvaogam gacchari, upayoga-lakkane nam jive...; and in Nandi 6[28-29) and 8 (pp. 6, 9): ...nana-damsana-gunanam... nana pamcaviham pannattan. tam jaha - abhinibohiya-nanam suya-nanam ohi-nanam manapajjava-nanam kevalananam. 62 For details see $ 4.2 and 5 of BALCEROWICZ (forthcoming). 6! See JACOBI (1926: iii, n. 1), VAIDYA (1928: xviii-xx), BALCEROWICZ (1999: "Introduction, vii ff.) and BALCEROWICZ (2000: 20 ff.). G1 NA 12: pratyaksa-pratipannartha-pratipadi ca yad vacah / pratyaksam pratibhasasya nimittatvat tad ucyate II 65 Meanings / things that can be verbally conveyed to other people, or 'communicable entities' (prajnapaniya bhavah), are said in STP.2.16ab to be directly related to the verbal knowledge (sruta-jnana): pannavanijja bhava samatta-suya-nana-damsanavisao 1. 66 Cf. SS 6.2 in BALCEROWICZ (2000). 67 For details see $$ 3.1-3.2 of BALCEROWICZ (forthcoming). For details see $ 3.3 of BALCEROWICZ (forthcoming). 69 For details see SS 7 of BALCEROWICZ (forthcoming). 10 On the date of the Nyayavatara see BALCEROWICZ (2000: 49). 7 On the name of the author of NA see: BALCEROWICZ (1999: xxxiv-xxxvi) and n. 5 above. the International Conference on Sanskrit and Related Studies to Commemorate the Centenary of the Birth of Stanislaw Schayer (1899-1941). Poland: Warsaw University. October 7-10, 1999. Studia Indologiczne (Warsaw] 7 (2000), 17-57. Balcerowicz, Piotr (forthcoming) (2000). 'On the Relationship of the Nyayavatara and the Sammati-tarka-prakarana'. Presented at the Xlth World Sanskrit Conference, Turin, April 3rd-8th. Forthcoming (to be published in the Proceedings). Bhagavai. Viyaha-pannatti-suttam (Bhagavai] (Vyakhya-prajnaptih (Bhagavati]). Edited with the Bechardas J. Doshi assited by Maritlal Mohanlal Bhojak. Jaina-Agama Series No.4 Part VII. Bombay: Shri Mahavira Jaina Vidyalaya, 1974/1978. Dhaky, M. A. (1995). "The Date and Authorship of Nyayavatara', in M. A. Dhaky, Jitendra Shah, Ahmedabad (eds.), Nirgrantha 1, pp. 39-49. Frauwallner, Erich (1933). "Zu den Fragmenten buddhistischer Logiker im Nyayavarttikam, Wiener Zeitschrift fur die Kunde Morgenlandes 40: 300_304. (reprint: Frauwallner (1982: 479-483)). Frauwaliner, Erich (1957). "Vasubandhu's Vadaviddhi', Wiener Zeitschrift fur die Kunde Sud- und Ostasiens: 104_146. (reprint: FRAUWALLNER (1982: 716-758)]. Frauwallner, Erich (1982). Kleine Schriften. Hrsg. von Gerhard Oberhammer und Ernst Steinkellner, Glassenapp-Stiftung 22. Wiesbaden: Franz Steiner Verlag. Granoff, Phyllis (1989-1990). "The Bibliographies of Siddhasena - A Study in the Texture of Allusion and the Weaving of a Group Image', Part I: Journal of Indian Philosophy 17 (1989): 329-384. Part II: JIP 18 (1990): 261-304. Jacobi, Hermann (1926). 'Introduction and Contents', Haribhadra: Samaraicca-kaha A Jaina Prakrta Work; Volume I: Text and Introduction, BI, Calcutta: pp. i-cxxx. Malvania, Dalsukhbhai (1979). 'Parisista 1. Nyayavatara ki Tulana. NA. Siddhasena Divakara: Nyavavatara. (1) See BALCEROWICZ (1999). (2) Edited With Siddharsigani's Vivrti and Devabhadra's Tippana by Bhagavandas Harakhchand. Patan: Ahmedabad, 1917. (3) Edited with Siddharsigani's Vivrti and Devabhadra's Tippana by P. L. Vaidya, Shri Jain Shwetamber Conference. Bombay, 1928. (reprinted in Vaishali Institute Research Bulletin 1, Vaishali 1971: 1-95). Nandi-suttam and Anuoga-ddaraim (Nandi-sutra and Anvoga-dvarani) (1968). Editors. Muni Punyavijaya, Dalsukh Malvania, Amrital Mohanlal Bhojak. Jaina-Agama Series, No. 1. Bombay: Shri Mahavira Jaina Vidyalaya. NAT. Devabhadra: Nyayavatara-tippana. See: NA. NAV. Siddharsgani: Nyayavatara-vivrti. See: NA. NB (1971). Dharmakirti: Nyaya-bindu, in Pt. Dalsukhbhai Malvania (ed.), Pandita Durveka Misra's Dharmottara-pradipa [being a subcommentary on Dharmottara's Nyaya-bindu-tika a commentary on Dharmakirti's Nyaya-bindu), Patna: Kashi Prasad Jayaswal, Research Institute. NBh. Vatsyayana Paksilasvamin. Nyaya-bhasva. See: NS. NS (1986). Mahamuni Vatsvavan's Nvaya-bhasya on Gautama-Nvava-sutras With Prasannapada Commentary of Pt. Sudarsanacarya Shastri. Dvarikadas sastri, SS 10. Varanasi: Sudhi Prakasanam. PALV. Ananta Virya. Pariksamukha-lagu-yrtti. See: PA. Pannavanasuttam (1969-1971). Editors. Muni Punyavijaya, Pt. Dalsukh Malvania, Pt. Amritlal Mohanlal Bhojak. Jaina-Agama-Series, No. 9, Parts 1-2. Bombay: Shri Mahavira Jaina Vidyalaya. PBh (1994). Bronkhorst, Johannes and Ramseier, Yves (eds.), Word inder to the Prasastapadabhasya: a complete word inder to the printed editions of the Prasastapadabhasya. Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass. Pischel, Richard (1990). A Grammar of the Prakrit Languages. Translated from German by Subhadra Jha. Second Revised Edition. Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass. (Grammatik der Prakrit-Sprachen. Band 1. Heft 8. Grundriss der Indo-Arischen Philologie und Altertumskunde. Strassburg 1990.). REFERENCES Anuoga. See: Nandi. Balcerowicz, Piotr (1999). Jaina Epistemology in Historical and Comparative Perspective. Critical Edition and English Translation of Logical-Epistemological Treatises: Nyavavatara, Nyavavatara-vivrti and Nyayavatara-tippana with Intro. duction and Notes. Doctoral Dissertation: University of Hamburg. Forthcoming to be published in Alt- und Neu-Indische Studien Band 53, 1+2, Franz Steiner Verlag 2001. Balcerowicz, Piotr (2000). "On the Date of the Nycravatara', in Piotr Balcerowicz and Marek Mejor (ed.). On the Understanding of Other Cultures. Proceedings of