________________
INTRODUCTION.
derations establish the thesis of this paragraph, that the Sha was an existing collection of historical documents before Confucius.
3. From the above paragraph it follows that Confucius did not compile the collection of documents that form the
Shů. The earliest assertion that he did so we Confucius did
not compile have from Khung An-kwo, his descendant in the Sha. The the eleventh generation, in the second century,
mamber of documents in B.C. Recounting the labours of his ancestor, it in his time. The Preface An-kwo says, in the Preface to his edition of ascribed to the Sha, that he examined and arranged the him.
old literary monuments and records, deciding to commence with Yảo and Shun, and to come down to the times of Kâu. Of those deserving to be handed down to other ages and to supply permanent lessons, he made in all one hundred books, consisting of canons, counsels, instructions, announcements, speeches, and charges. The same thing is stated by Sze-mà Khien in his Historical Records, completed about B.C. 100, but Khien's information was derived from An-kwo. Such a compilation would have been in harmony with the character which Confucius gave of himself, as 'a transmitter and not a maker, believing and loving the ancients' and with what his grandson says of him in the Doctrine of the Mean, that he handed down the lessons of) Yâo and Shun, as if they had been his ancestors, and elegantly displayed those of Wăn and Wa, whom he took for his model?!
We have seen, however, that the collection existed in his time and before it. Did it then, as An-kwo says, consist of a hundred books ? His authority for saying so was a Preface, which was found along with the old tablets of the Shồ that were discovered in his time and deciphered by him, as will be related farther on. He does not say, however, that it was the work of Confucius, though Khien does. It still exists,-a list of eighty-one documents in a hundred books. The prevailing opinion of scholars in China is now, that it was not written by the sage. I entirely
Analects, VII, i.
* The Doctrine of the Mean, XXX, 1.. B 2
Digitized by Google
