Jain Journal 2003 01

Author(s): Jain Bhawan Publication
Publisher: Jain Bhawan Publication

Page 16

HEMACANDRA ON THE CARVAKA: A STUDY: RAMKRISHNA BHATTACHARY
143
6. KM, Ch. 2, p. 191: dvidhā ānvikșiki pūrvottarapakşābhyām,
arhadbhadantadarśane lokāyata - ca pūrvapaksah. să-khya
nyāyavaiseșikau cottaraḥ, ta ime șaț tarkāḥ. 7. AC, 2.165 cd, p.107 : anviksiki tarkavidyā mimā-sā tu vicaranā. 8. Thomas, p. 124 n3 on AYVD, v.20. 9. Hemacandra in fact devotes two separate verses, one to Jaimini
(v.ll) and the other to Kumārila (v.12). 10. See P Pu, Srstikhanda, Ch. 13. Cf. Hariva-sa, Hariva-saparvan
(vulgate edition), Ch. 28. The passage has been omitted in the
critical edition (21.327, p.148). 11. SHVP, p. 740. 12. Hemacandra's auto-commentary (Bịhadvrtti) on SHśA, ibid., 740. 13. Whitney, Rule 233a, p.80. Cf. Tarkavācaspati, sv. cārvāka. 14. See Monier-Williams, s.v.cāru. 15. Rāyamukuța, Vol.2, p.269 (on Vanaușadhivargaḥ, 211) and n. 16. TRD, p. 300. I have quoted from the translation by Mrinal Kanti
Gangopadhyaya in C/L, p. 267. 17. See Bhattacharya (1998b) and (2000c). 18. In his auto-commentary Hemacandra writes: paramanastika ityarthah
(on YS, 2.37, f. 96b). 19. AYVD, v. 20. 20. Trans. Thomas, p. 126. 21. Ibid. 22. Ibid., pp. 126-27. As to the grammatical rule, cf. Panini, Ast, 4.4.60.
However, Manu. 2.11: nāstiko vedanindakah. Hemacandra explains the words, nāstika, āstika and daistika as follows: ete tadasyetyarthe
ikanantă nipātyante (Laghuvrtti on SHŠA, 6.4.66). 23. Quoted in TSP, p. 528 (on TS, Ch. 18, v. 1481). 24. Quoted in SVR, pp. 265-66. 25. NM, Ch.2, Part 1, p.184. 26. Ibid. 27. Ratnaprabhā on PNTA, p. 540 ; TRD, p.306 (on ȘDSam, v.83),
C/L, p.273 ; Sanghvi, ASILM, p. 4. 28. See Monier-Williams, S.V. varāka.