On Asrayasiddha

SR No.: 269540
Original Sutra Author: N/A
Author: Toru Funayama
Publisher: Toru Funayama
Total Pages: 7
Language: English
Classification: Article
File Size: 581 KB

Page 7

darn while the fallacy itself is meant by asrnyos idehotvo. The latter was in a later period meant also by osrayasiddhi with the same connotation. 2) ubhayasiddha, prativadyas" & vodino's", sopdehdi", dharmyas" in Dharmakirti's Nyayabindu. The problem of an unreal locus was discussed with another word "anyatoras idda", because of redundancy of the fourfold classification. Jitori's tenfold classification in his letutattvopadesa is also essentially the same as Dhormakirti's. 3) For examples of the fallacy, see TBh (- Moksdkaragupta's Tarkabhasa, Mysore 1952), 51,13-14; SD (= Asoka's Samanyadusana in Asokanibandhau, ed. A. Thakur, Patna 1974), 13,1013. We con also trace Kumarila's earlier usage of "svarupatoh" to mean the concerned asiddha. See S. Yamakami, T. Tokenaka, H. Kuroda & A.Akamatsu, "Slokavarttiko, anumana sho no Kenkyu (11) - Wayaku to Kaisetsu-," Indo Shiroshi Kenkyu 3, 1985, pp. 26-31. A) This fallacy is mentioned in the TBh, 64,14--19; SI, 13,11; ibid. 19,1. It is mentioned as early as in the TSP, ed. 'S.D. Shastri, Voronasi, 1981, 142,11. 5) Kebavomibra's Torkabhoso (eds. D.R.Bhandarkar & Kisaliitya blusage, Bombay, 1937, pp.85-87), enumerates three kinds of abiddhas (i.e. osroyas ideha, svarupu", ond vyupyotvao), and says that visesapa', visesya" as well as other asiddhas should belong to svarupu' . 6) Pvt, P. Je, 471,8-180'; 11.400' a, which was followed by Karpokagomin's PVSV-Tika, 76,18-19. 7) Cf. Dhormottora's Nyayabindutika (ed. D. Molvania, Patna, 1955), 125, 1-2. 8) Pramanavarttikavstti, P. Che, 4364-5; D. 386.5.-. 9 TSP, 250, 21-22. 10) T.Tillemons, "Two Tibetan Texts on the 'Neither One Nor Many' Argument for Sunyata," Journal of Indian Philosophy 12, 1984, pp.357-388; M. Kobayashi, "Mujishdsho Ronsho to Shoefu jo (asrayasiddha) no Mondai - Kamalaslla no Chukonmyo wo Chubhin to shite," Buoka 50-3.4, 1987, pp.41-60. 11) TSP, 246,18-21. 122 Pramdpaviniscayatika, P. Ise, 16988-b'; D. 14567 ^. 13) TSP, 253, 13-16. Cf. S. Mookerjee, The Buddhist Philosophy of Universal Flux, Calcutta, 1935 (reprint: Delhi, 1975), p.406. 14) See T. Funayama, "Bubun to Zentai - Indo Bukkyo Chishikiron'ni okeru Gaiyo to Koki no Mondaiten," TOho Gakuho 62, 1990, pp.621-630. 15) Avayavinirakarapa (ed. A. Thakur, n.4), 1,8-11. 16) Ibid., 1,15-19. Jap. tr., Funayama, op.cit., pp. 627-630. 17) For the problem of his date, see Funayama op.cit., n.25. Cf. Abhayadevosuri's Tattvabodhavidhuyini, 658, 14-22. 180 Cf. Y.Ka jiyama, "Ratnakirti no Kibyu Ronsho to Naihen ju Ron no Seisei," Tsukamoto Hakase Shoju Kinen Bukkyo Shigoku Ronshu, Kyoto, 1961, pp. 265-266. <Key words) asiddha, asrayasiddha, prasanga, svatantrasadhana, asoka ** (Rescorch fellow, Kyoto University)