SearchBrowseAboutContactDonate
Page Preview
Page 239
Loading...
Download File
Download File
Page Text
________________ 220 JAINA THEORIES OF REALITY AND KNOWLEDGE maintains, require the necessity of the relata in it and, consequently, should exist in its own right. An analysis of its requirements, however, exhibits the serious lack of dependence upon its relata for its existence. It cannot therefore exist, Dharmakirti affirms, as a full-fledged and independent real (tan na parāpekṣā nāma yadrāpaḥ sambandhah siddhyet'). When the truth of Dharmakīrti's contention in the above argument is recognised, the falsity of the converse of the argument could also be easily perceived : a non-existent relation cannot, as it has been just observed, exhibit any 'expectancy' for the necessity of the relata inasmuch as the relata will not, then, have any basis for their subsistence (apeksādharmāśraya-virodhāt”). Lastly, Dharmakirti scathingly brings out a major inconsistency which, from the Idealist point of view, is destructive of the opponent's strength in upholding the reality of relation. Relation is acknowledged, as it has been repeatedly pointed out, by the Naiyāyika to be a distinct entity besides the relata in a relational situation. This provokes the Buddhist dialectician to the presentation of a new dilemma inherent in the relationship between the consti 1. PKM, p. 505. 2. Ibid. 3. The purport of this argument is contained in the following kā. of Dharmakirti : parāpekşā hi sambandhah so'san katham apeksatel sams ca sarvanirāśamso bhavaḥ katham apekṣate// PKM, spd., p. 505, kā. 3. See also NKC, Vol. I, p. 306, SRK, p. 813, and TSV, p. 148. Jain Education International For Private & Personal Use Only www.jainelibrary.org
SR No.001608
Book TitleJaina Theories of Reality and Knowledge
Original Sutra AuthorN/A
AuthorY J Padmarajiah
PublisherJain Sahitya Vikas Mandal
Publication Year1963
Total Pages444
LanguageEnglish
ClassificationBook_English, Philosophy, Epistemology, & Anekantvad
File Size23 MB
Copyright © Jain Education International. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy