Page #1
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ kanda-mUlaH bhakSyAbhakSya mImAMsA saMsAra ke pratyeka prANI ke prANoM kA, jIvana kA AdhAra AhAra hai| AhAra hai to jIvana hai, nahIM hai to nahIM hai| ataH zramaNa bhagavAn mahAvIra ne isI sandarbha meM kahA thA- 'AhAraTTiyA praannaa|' vaidika paramparA kA bhI yahI udghoSa hai- 'annaM vai prANAH / ' anya prANiyoM kI bAta alaga se chor3a dete haiN| yahA~ hama mAnava ke AhAra ke sambandha meM hI carcA kreNge| kyoMki mAnava ke AhAra ke sambandha meM vidhi-niSedhoM kI jitanI carcA atIta meM huI hai aura vartamAna meM ho rahI hai, utanI anya prANiyoM ke lie kahA~ huI hai? mAnava, kendra hai prANijagata kA, usI ke lie zAstra nirmita hue haiM, usI ke sudhAra ke lie - maMgala-kalyANa ke lie adhikAMza meM bhagavadAtmA mahAn divya puruSoM kI vANI mukharita huI hai| usI ke lie vidhi-niSedhoM ke anekAneka vrata, niyama Adi vihita hue haiM / mAnava zubhAzubha ke puNya pApa ke madhya dvAra para khar3A hai| usameM zubhatva vikasita ho, to vaha sahI artha meM mAnava, mAnava mAtra hI nahIM, deva evaM devAtideva bhI ho sakatA hai| aura, yadi durbhAgya se azubha vRddhi pA jAe, to vaha naradeha meM nara pazu, yahA~ taka ki daitya, dAnava, pizAca, rAkSasa bhI bana sakatA hai| aura Apa jAnate haiM prastuta zubha evaM azubha kA adhikAMza meM kSetra AhAra hai| jaisA AhAra hotA hai, vaisA mana hotA hai| jaisA mana hotA hai, vaisA hI karma hotA hai| aura jaisA karma hotA hai, vaisA hI jIvana hotA hai| jIvana ke zubhAzubhatva kA prabhAva vaiyaktika hI nahIM rahatA hai, vaha parivAra evaM samAja taka vistAra pAtA hai| isa prakAra vyakti vyaSTi nahIM, samaSTi hai| anya prANI jahA~ vyaSTi kI kSudra sImA taka hI avaruddha rahate haiM, vahA~ mAnava vyApaka samaSTi taka pahu~catA hai| ataH mAnava ke AhAra ke sambandha meM, jo yaNNA samidharma 11.8 jIvana-nirmANa kA pramukha hetu hai, AdikAla se hI zAstra para zAstra nirmita hote A rahe haiN| AhAra ko dharmAdharma taka kA virAT rUpa mila gayA hai| mAnava AhAra ke sambandha meM sabase pahalI carcA hai bhakSyAbhakSya kii| jo AhAra dUsare prANiyoM kI hatyA karake prApta kiyA jAtA hai, vaha krUratA evaM hiMsA se janya mAMsa, machalI, aNDA abhakSya AhAra hai| yaha bAgha, gIdha Adi jaMgalI hiMstra pazu-pakSiyoM tathA rAkSasoM kA AhAra mAnA gayA hai| prAyaH sabhI AtmadarzI dharmAcAryoM ne ukta AhAra ko garhita, ataH abhakSya batAyA hai| ahiMsA pradhAna dharmo ne mAMsa Adi ukta abhakSya AhAra kI kasakara nindA kI hai, aura use naraka gamana kA hetu kahA hai| mAnava apane danta Adi aMgoM kI dRSTi se mUlataH zAkAhArI prANI hai, mAMsAhArI nahIM / mAnava hradaya kI sahaja saMvedanazIlatA bhI aisI anukampA dravita hai ki vahA~ mAMsAhAra kathamapi upayukta nahIM haiN| anyatra hamane isa para kAphI carcA kI hai, ataH prastuta meM hama apane eka bahucarcita viSaya para hI kendrita rahanA cAhate haiN| mAMsAhAra ke niSedhAnantara zAkAhAra Adi kI carcA hai| zAkAhAra arthAt mukhyatayA vanaspati- AhAra ke sambandha meM bhI cintana ne kAphI svaccha vicAra prastuta kie haiN| lazuna, pyAja Adi kucha aisI vanaspatiyA~ haiM, jo kucha uttejaka haiM, mAnasika vRttiyoM ko zurU kara dene vAlI haiM, ataH tamoguNI hone se unakA bhI zAstrakAroM ne amuka aMza meM niSedha kiyA hai| rogAdi kAraNavizeSa me lazuna Adi bhI vihita haiM, kintu svastha sthiti meM utsargarUpeNa varjita haiN| khAsakara jaina aura deva paraMparAe~ inake niSedha para kAphI bala detI haiN| tamoguNa janya mAdakatA kA aura mana donoM para hI prabhAva par3atA hai, ataH tamoguNa AhAra kisI bhI rUpa me ho usase bacanA hI caahie| sAdhaka ke lie to vizeSa rUpa se varjita hai| yahI kAraNa hai ki prAcIna jaina- paramparA meM dUdha, dahI, makkhana, ghI Adi kI bhI vikRtiyoM meM parigaNanA hai, phalataH unakA bhI mukta bhAva se atisevana niSiddha hai| 'dAda dahI vigaio AhArei abhikkhaNaM...pAvasamaNetti vuccaI / " vanaspati- zAkAhAra ke sambandha meM AhAra kI carcA ne jaina paramparA meM Age calakara eka aura moDa liyaa| vaha hai vanaspatigata jIvoM kI saMkhyA kA jaina ma meM vanaspati ke jIvoM kI saMkhyA se tIna bheda haiM- saMkhyAta asaMkhyAta aura ananta pratyeka vanaspati Amra evaM jAmuna Adi vRkSa tathA ghIyA toraI aura kucha saMkhyAta kI gaNanA meM Ate haiM aura kucha asaMkhyAta kI gaNanA meM pa hone vAle zakarakanda, gAjara mUlI Adi kandamUla ananta jIvoM se vanaspati hai| kandamUla bhakSyAbhakSya mImAMsA
Page #2
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ apekSita hai, vanaspati sambandhI bhakSyAbhakSya vicAra ke lie| jaina-dharma kA ahiMsA evaM hiMsA sambandhI cintana prANigata cetanA ke AdhAra para hai| vikasita cetanA vAle sthUla prANI kI hiMsA meM jo tIvratA hai, vaha alpa cetanA vAle prANI kI hiMsA meM nahIM hai| jIvoM kI saMkhyA kI nyUnAdhikatA para hiMsA kI tIvratA mandatA AdhArita nahIM hai, jaisA ki samajhA jA rahA hai| vaha to jIvoM kI nyUnAdhika cetanA aura unakI hiMsA karanevAle vyakti ke bhAvoM kI ugratA mandatA Adi para AdhArita hai| isIlie AcArya somadeva Adi ne kahA hai ki kRSaka kheta Adi meM hiMsA karatA huA bhI hiMsA-janya pApa kA utanA pAtra nahIM hai, jitanA ki matsya bandhaka dhIvara bAhara meM hiMsA nahIM karatA huA bhI pApa kA bhAgI hai| aisA hI bhAva AcArya amRtacandra ne anya udAharaNoM ke AdhAra para, puruSArtha siddhyupAya meM darzAyA ataH pratyeka vanaspati to bhakSya kI gaNanA meM hai, aura anantakAya kanda mUla abhakSya kI gaNanA meN| parantu jIvoM kI nyUnAdhika saMkhyA kA yaha bhakSyAbhakSya-sambandhI vicAra prAcIna AgamakAla kA na hokara uttarakAla kA hai| jaina-dharma nivRtti para bala detA hai| ataH vaha sAdhaka ko icchA-nirodha ke lie prerita karatA hai| bhogApabhoga kI jitanI kama icchA evaM apekSA hogI, utane hI usake tatsambandhita rAga-dveSa ke vikalpa kama hoNge| phalataH Azrava evaM bandha kA dAyarA kama hogA, aura saMvaraM evaM nirjarA kA dAyarA bddh'egaa| Azrava evaM bandha adharma haiN| usake viparIta saMvara evaM nirjarA dharma haiM, mokSa kA mArga hai| yahA~ taka to ThIka hai| sAdhaka ko apanI AhArecchA para, jitanA bhI ho sake, niyantraNa karanA hI caahie| parantu yaha niyantraNa icchA evaM Asakti ke AdhAra para honA cAhie, na ki niSedha ke ati utsAha meM bhakSyAbhakSya jaise zabdoM ke AdhAra pr| mAMsa Adi ke lie to abhakSya zabda kA prayoga upayukta hai, kintu jIvoM kI gaNanA ke AdhAra para vanaspati-AhAra ke lie ukta zabda kA prayoga upayukta nahIM hai| bAta yaha hai ki jo abhakSya hai, vaha abhakSya hI hai, kasturI muktApiSTi Adi ke rUpa meM kucha amuka ApavAdika sthitiyoM ko choddkr| haldI, sauMTha, adaraka Adi spaSTa hI ananta kAya kandamUla haiN| prazna hai, kandamUla ko ekAnta abhakSya kahane vAle aura upayoga na karane vAle haldI Adi kA upayoga mukta rUpa se kaise karate haiM? gRhastha hI nahIM. sAdhu-sAdhvI bhI karate haiN| samAdhAna diyA jAtA hai ki ve zuSka arthAt sUkha jAte haiM, taba acitta hone se upayoga meM lie jAte haiN| maiM pUchatA hai, kyA pakka hone aura sUkha jAne para abhakSya, bhakSya ho jAtA hai| bAta kaDavI hai, para satya kI spaSTatA ke lie kahanA hI hogA ki taba to mAMsa Adi abhakSya bhI paka jAne yA sUkha jAne para bhakSya ho jaaeNge| kintu aisA hai nhiiN| ataH spaSTa hai ki anantakAya kandamUla nataspatiyA~, apana jIvAtmaka hone ke nAte abhakSya nahIM haiN| abhakSya kI mAnyatA gale ananta kAya haldI, adaraka Adi kandamUla ko, gIle yA sUkhe kisI bhI rUpa nahIM khA sakate hai| __ aparadA aura ananta kI gaNanA meM kyA antara hai? asaMkhya meM yadi eka saMkhyA bhI bana jAe, to vaha Aya se ananta kI paridhi meM A jAtA hai| isalie anya darzana asaMkhya aura 21 ta meM koI bheda nahIM karate haiN| prazna hai, asaMkhya taka to bhakSya hai, aura mAtra eka jIva kI vRddhi hote hI vaha abhakSya kaise ho gyaa| Agraha nahIM, cintana jIvoM kI nyUnAdhika saMkhyA ke AdhAra para hiMsA-ahiMsA kI mAnyatAvAle jaina nahIM hastitApasa the, jinakA varNana jainAgamoM meM bhI milatA hai| ye tApasa kahate the ki vanaspati evaM atra Adi khAte haiM, to bahata adhika jIvoM kI hiMsA ho jAtI hai, ataH hAthI tathA hAthI jaisA eka vizAlakAya prANI mAra leM to kama hiMsA hogii| eka prANI kaI vyaktiyoM kI, kitane hI dinoM taka kI bhakha nivAraNa meM kAma AtA rhegaa| ukta mata kA jena-darzana ne pracaNDatA se khaNDana kiyA hai| ataH kandamUla ko vanaspati jIvoM ko adhika saMkhyA ke AdhAra para ekAnta abhakSya batAne vAle mahAnubhAvoM ko uparyukta cintana para vicAra karanA cAhie ki kahIM ve bhramavaza hastitApasoM ke vicAra pakSa meM to nahIM jA rahA hai? maiMne pUrva meM kahA hai ki prAcIna Agama yuga meM vanaspati-AhAra ke sambandha meM jIvoM kI nyUnAdhika saMkhyA ke AdhAra para bhakSyA'bhakSya kI carcA nahIM hai| kandamUla kI acitta pariNati hone para pUrvakAla meM use muni bhI grahaNa karate the, AgamasAhitya meM anekazaH ullekha milate haiM, isa sambandha meN| dazavakAlika sUtra AcAra-zAstra kA mUrdhanya zAstra hai| AcArAMga se pUrva bhikSu-AcAra ke paribodha ke lie, dazavaikAlikasUtra ke adhyayana kA hI vyApaka pracalana hai| ataH yahA~ sAkSI ke rUpa meM anyatra dUra na jAkara dazavaikAlika kA hI sAkSya prastuta kiyA jA rahA hai| mere samakSa TIkA, dIpikA, avacUri tathA gajarAthI TabbA ke sAtha dazavaikAlika sUtra kA bahuta purAtana mudrita saMskaraNa hai| yaha saMskaraNa, zvetAmbara mUrtipUjaka paraMparA kandamUla bhakSyAbhakSya mImAMsA paNNA samikkhae dhamma
Page #3
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ ke custa zrAvaka zrI bhImasiMha mANakajI (bambaI) dvArA vikrama saMvat 1957 tathA san 1900 meM prakAzita hai| kandamUla ke sambandha meM ekAnta abhakSya kI mAnyatA kA Agraha, zvetAmbara mUrtipUjaka paraMparA ko hI prAyaH sarvAdhika hai| ataH anya prakAzanoM ko chor3akara hama yahA~ isI paraMparA ke purAtana prakAzana ko upasthita kara rahe haiN| mUla-sUtra hai, sAtavIM-AThavIM zatI ke suprasiddha zrutadhara AcArya zrI haribhadrajI kI TIkA hai, aura prAcIna gujarAthI bAlAvabodha (TabbA) hai| vistAra bhaya se dIpikA aura avacUri kA pATha chor3a diyA hai| ye donoM AcArya haribhadrIya TIkA kA hI anusaraNa karate haiM, ataH alaga se inakI yahA~ upAdeyatA bhI nahIM hai| kaMde mUle ya sacitte phale bIe ya Amae ||3 | 7 1 kanda, mUla, phala aura bIje kacce sacita sAdhu na le letA hai to anAcIrNa hai, doSa hai| kando vajra kandAdi, mUlaM ca saTTAmUlAdi sacittamanAcaritam / tathA phalaM trapuSyAdi, bIjaM ca tilAdi AmakaM sacittamanAcaritamiti sUtrArthaH / - AcArya harabhadrajI kI TIkA 'kandaH ' eTale vajrAdi kanda, tathA 'mUlam' eTale mUla, e be vastu sacitta vAparAvI, te anAcarita / ....... ...Amam eTale lIlUM kAMcaM, evAM phalaM, te karkaTI Adika phala, ane tilAdika bIja, ebe lIlAM kAMcA vAparAvAM, te krameM karI ADatrIzamaM tathA ogaNa cAlIzamaM anAcarita jANavuM / -gujarAthI vAlAvabodha uparyukta mUla, TIkA aura bAlAvabodha para se spaSTa hai ki sAdhu ke lie kanda, mUla, phala, bIja Adi sacitta kacce anAcIrNa haiM, acita pake hue nahIM: kaMdaM mUlaM palaMbaM vA, AmaM chinnaM ca sanniraM / bAgaM siMgaberaM ca, AmagaM parivajjae || 5 | 1 | 70 // - kanda, mUla, phala, patrazAka, tumbAka-dUdhI dhIyA, adaraka Adi- yadi kacce sacita hoM to sAdhu grahaNa na kare, tyAga de / ****** . kandaM sUraNAdi lkssnnm| mUlaM vidArikAdi rUpam pralaMbaM vA tAlaphalAdi / AmaM chinnaM vA sanniram / sanniramiti patrazAkaM tumbAkaM tvagmajjAntarvarti / ArdrA vA tulasImityanye / zrRGgaberaM cArdrakam / AmaM puNA samiva dhammaM 162 parivarjayediti sUtrArthaH / AcArya haribhadrajI kI TIkA sUraNa bigere kanda, vidArikAdi mUla, athavA pralaMbaM eTale tAlAdikanA phala / ane AmaM kAMcaM athavA chinnaM chedhuM evaM sanniraM patrazAka tathA bAgaM tUMbaDUM dUdhiyuM, te ne tathA zRMgaberaM eTale ArdU eTalA vAnAM AmakaM eTale kAcAM sacitta hoya to tene parivarjayet tyAga kare / ... -gujarAthI bAlAvabodha uparyukta ullekhoM ke sivA dazavaikAlika ke paMcama adhyayana (dvitIya uddezaka, gA0 27-28) meM zAlUka Adi kandoM ke nAmollekhapUrvaka punaH kandamUla kI carcA hai. aura anta meM 'AmagaM parivajAe unhIM pUrvokta zabdoM meM kacce, sacita kandamUla khAne kA niSedha kiyA hai| pakka evaM acitta ke khAne kA Agama meM kahIM para bhI niSedha nahIM hai| upara meM dazavekAlika sUtra ke AdhAra para jo kanda-mUla Adi kA varNana kiyA gayA hai, usa para se eka aura bAta para bhI dhyAna dene jaisA hai| kanda ke sAtha anya phala, zAka, bIja, tathA ibhukhaNDa Adi kA bhI ullekha hai| sUtrakAra tathA TIkAkAra Adi ne kandamUla tathA phala Adi kA bhakSya tathA abhakSya ke rUpa meM vargIkaraNa nahIM kiyA hai| sAmAnyarUpa meM vanaspati kA varNana hai| ataH spaSTa hai ki sUtrakAra Adi kI sAmAnya rUpa se mAtra sacina vanaspati kA niSedha hI abhISTa hai, kandamUla ko avazya karanA aura unheM sacina tathA ati donoM hI rUpoM meM niSiddha karanA, abhISTa nahIM hai| jana saMgha meM zvatAmbara paraMparA ke samAna hI eka mahattvapUrNa digambara paraMparA bhI hai| digambara muni ugra AcAra evaM kaThora kriyAkANDa kA vizeSa pakSadhara hai| ataH prastuta meM hama kandamUla ke bhakSyAbhakSya ke sambandha meM ukta paramparA ke vicAra bhI jijJAsuoM ke lie upasthita kara rahe haiN| AcArya vaTTakera svAmI digambara-paramparA ke prAcIna mahAn zrutadhara AcArya haiN| munidharma ke varNana meM unakA prAkRta bhASAnibaddha 'mUlAcAra' grantha AcArazAstra kA pratinidhi zAstra hai| zvetAmbara - paramparA ke AcArAMga sUtra ke samAna hI digambara- paramparA meM mUlAcAra kA bahumAna puraHsara prAmANya hai| mUlAsAra ke aneka ullekha uttarAdhyayana sUtra evaM zrI bhadrabAhu svAmI kI Avazyaka niyukti ke ullekhoM mUla bhakSyAbhakSya mImAMsA 163
Page #4
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ ke sAtha zabdazaH evaM arthazaH milate haiM, jo unakI prAcInatA evaM prAmANikatA ke spaSTataH udghoSaka haiN| mUlAcAra kA, san 1919 meM muni anantakIrti digambara grantha mAlA dvArA prakAzita saMskaraNa, mere samakSa hai| paM0 zrI manoharalAlajI zAstrI kA sampAdana hai, hindI TIkA hai| navama anagAra bhAvanAdhikAra meM muni ke AhAra kI carcA hai| AcArya vaTTakera, muni ke lie kanda, mUla, phala Adi apakva-kaccA khAne kA niSedha karate haiM, pakva kA nhiiN| "phala-kanda-mUla bIyaM, aNaggipaka ta AmayaM kiNci| NaccA aNesaNIyaM, Navi ya paDicchanti te dhIrA // 825 // " -agni para nahIM pake, aise phala, kanda, mUla, bIja tathA anya bhI jo kaccA padArtha, usako abhakSya jAna kara ve dhIra-vIra muni khAne kI icchA nahIM krte| jaM havadi aNivvIyaM, NivaTTiyaM phAsuyaM kapaM ceva / NAUNa esaNIyaM, taM bhikkhaM muNI paDicchaMti // 826 // -jo nirbIja ho aura prAsuka kiyA gayA ho, aise AhAra ko khAne yogya samajha kara munirAja usake lene kI icchA karate haiN| ukta gAthAoM para se spaSTa hai ki muni kanda, mUla Adi prAsuka hoM, to unheM azanIya (khAne yogya) samajha kara AhAra meM le sakatA hai| anazanIyatA ke rUpa meM kandamUla kA niSedha apakkatA se sambandhita hai, pakatA se nhiiN| kyA AlU sacamuca meM kanda hai? AlU ke sambandha meM alaga se carcA kara rahA huuN| bAta yaha hai ki prAntabheda se jaina-samAja meM AlU khAyA jAtA hai, kahIM nahIM bhI khAyA jaataa| khAsa kara gujarAtha meM nahIM khAyA jaataa| khAnA aura na khAnA eka alaga bAta hai| parantu AlU ko ananta kAya kanda mAna kara use abhakSya kahanA aura khAne vAloM ko ghRNA kI dRSTi se dekhA, yaha yukta nahIM hai| AlU videzoM se AyA hai| vaha kanda kI zreNi meM nahIM aataa| vaha jar3a nahIM hai apit tane meM lagane vAlA phala vizeSa hai| Ala bhUmi se Upara bhI tane meM laga sakatA hai| vaha bhUmi meM nahIM paidA hotaa| usakI surakSA evaM vikAsa ke lie miTTI alaga se Upara meM dI jAtI hai| aura usa miTTI kI taha ke nIce vaha vikAsa pAtA hai| yaha bAta sAdhAraNa vanaspati-paricaya kI pustakoM meM bhI dekhI jA sakatI hai| sthUla dRSTi se hI bhUmigata hone kI bAta kahI jAtI hai, jaise ki kAphI samaya taka mUMgaphalI (sIMgadAnA) ko bhI bhUmigata hone ke kAraNa vyartha hI kanda ke rUpa meM varjita karate rahe haiN| vastusthiti ko sAMgopAMga rUpa se spaSTatayA samajhanA Avazyaka hai| vyartha ke pUrvAgrahoM ke AdhAra para kucha-kI-kucha kalpanA kara lenA aura usa para dhArmika vigraha evaM kalaha khar3e kara denA, kathamapi ucita nahIM hai| Ala ko kanda samajha lene aura mAna lene ke sambandha meM isI prakAra kA vyartha vigraha cala rahA hai| naI daniyA, indaura kA dinAMka 9-12-83 kA aMka abhI-abhI eka dharma bandhu ne mujhe dikhAyA hai| usake eka samAcAra para se AlU kI sthiti kAphI spaSTa ho jAtI hai| likhA hai - "manIlA ke vaijJAnikoM ne TamATara aura AlU ke paudhe ko milAkara pomATo' nAmaka eka nayA paudhA taiyAra kiyA hai, jisa para Adhe TamATara aura Adhe AlU kI zakla ke phala lagate haiN|" dazavakAlika sUtra ke samAna hI yahA~ mUlAcAra meM bhI kanda, mUla kA phala aura bIja Adi ke sAtha sAmAnyatayA vanaspati ke rUpa meM ullekha hai| pratyeka vanaspati se bhinna, niSedha ke lie abhakSya rUpa meM pRthak ullekha nahIM hai| maiM samajhatA hU~, anAgraha kI yathArtha dRSTi ke jijJAsa, digambara aura zvetAmbara donoM hI, ukta Agama kAlIna prAcIna spaSTa ullekhoM para se kanda, mala kI bhakSyAbhakSya se sambandhita vicAra dhArA kA marma samajha jAeMge aura vyartha ke kadAprahoM se apane ko alaga rkheNge| pratyeka sAdhaka ko mAnyatA aura siddhAnta ke antara ko samajha lenA Avazyaka hai| aneka pracalita mAnyatAoM se satya kahIM pare hotA hai| use anAgrahI sAdhaka hI dekha sakate haiM AgrahI nahIM- 'satyameva jyte|' vaijJAnikoM kI yaha zodha, spaSTa rUpa se TamATara ke samAna hI AlU ko bhI eka phala vizeSa hI pramANita karatI hai| yadi AlU mUla meM sacamuca hI kanda hotA, to TamATara ke sAtha vaha phala ke rUpa meM kaise vikAsa prApta karatA? kandamUla bhakSyAbhakSya mImAMsA "paNNA samikkhae dhamma 164
Page #5
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ Ala Adi-kanda mUla ke khAne ke sambandha meM merA koI bhI vyaktigata Agraha nahIM hai| maiM nahIM kahatA ki khAnA hI caahie| jo sAdhaka apanI icchA kA nirAdha kara kanda-mUla yA zAka-sabjI Adi kA jo bhI tyAga karate haiM, maiM unakA anumodana karatA haiN| prastuta carcA para se maiM kevala eka hI bAta spaSTa karanA cAhatA hU~ ki jo bhI vidhi yA niSedha ho, vaha prAmANika ho, zAstrIya AdhAra para ho| apanI kalpita mAnyatA ke AdhAra para, zAstra-dvArA pramANita maulika satya kA apalApa karanA aura pArasparika nindA ke vitaNDAvAda meM ulajhanA ThIka nahIM hai| paNNA samikvAe dhamma 166