________________
LXIY
INTRODUCTION
Bhasya on TS (V, 29) when it widely differs from that of his? Haribhadra, too, seems to be ignorant about Gandhahastin's com. None of these two Sūris has referred to each other.
In Haribhadra's com. (p. 119) we come across two pathäs from some Pāhuda- the gâthas which are not found in any work so far known:
“परिगप्पिद-संपुड-तत्तिगा य तह तत्तिग त्ति चउभेआ ।
धम्मा भावाण जए विष्णेआ बुद्धिमंतेहिं ॥ पायरेहिं सुहसाणाई जगमुत्तिभायणं चेव ।
समयाहिएसु अ तहा पता य एते जहासंखं ॥" Some of the quotations are common to both the cammentaries on TS-one by Haribhadra and the other by Gandhahastin, whom I am somehow inclined to assign a date earlier than Haribhadra.
There are certain topics to be found in both AJP and this com. But, even then there are no cross-references.
(40) Nyāyāvatāravrtti As the name suggests, this is a com. on Siddhasena Divākara's Nyāyāvatārd. In the Brhattippan:ki, a list of the 15th century we have: "19127TH Moti nautiful Jaina Granthāvali etc. mention on this basis that Haribhadra Sūri has commented upon Nyāyāvatära. But Dr. P. L. Vaidya opines that “this seems to be a mistake” as no Ms. of such a com. is found. But this does not necessarily prove that the statement in Brhattippanikā is wrong; for, this com. is so noted eten in Caturvimsatiprabantha (p. 52).
(44) Pañcasūtrakavyākhyā* This is a Saṁskṛta com. on Pancasuttga, a work in Pāîya 1 See "Notes". 2 Vide his intro. (2.21 ) to his edition of Vyüyāvatūra. 3 This com, along with the text has been published by Jain&
Ātmānanda Sabhā, Bhavnagar in 1923 A.D. Tho toxt together with intro., and notes by Prof, A. N. Upadhye was published by Dr. P. L. Vaidya in 1932 A. D. The text along with intro, translation and notes and glossary has been edited and published by Prof. A. N. Upadhye in 1931 A. D. In the notes he has quoted excerpts from this com. Prof. V. M. Shah has also edited this work with Saraskrta rendering and intro., notes and translation in English, and it has been published by Shambhulal Jagashi in 1934 A, D,