Disclaimer: This translation does not guarantee complete accuracy, please confirm with the original page text.
## Pindianuyukti: An Observation
**115. In the last two Chaturbhangis out of the 115 Chaturbhangis, the first three alternatives are prohibited and the fourth alternative is to be worshipped. In the first Chaturbhangi, all four alternatives are prohibited for begging.**
**Like the Sanhrita Dvara, here also, one should understand the saamyogik bhang of Prithvikaaya etc. and the four alternatives of shushk and aadr should be known like the Sanharan dosha.**
**While explaining the difference between Unmisra and Sanhrita dosha, the author says that giving alms by mixing both kalpya and akalpya types of objects is Unmisra dosha, and collecting the non-deserving object from the bhajanastha and putting the kalpya object in it and giving alms is Sanhrita dosha.**
**8. Aparinat Dosha**
**To take an object which is not completely a-chitta or which the giver does not want to give is Aparinat dosha. In the Dashavaikalik Sutra, the word 'anivvud' is used for Aparinat.**
**According to the Digambar tradition, tilodak, tandulodak, ushnajal, chane ka dhovan, tushodak, if they are not completely a-chitta or other objects which are aparinat, taking them is Aparinat dosha. This is of two types - dravya aparinat and bhav aparinat.**
**From the perspective of the giver and the receiver, there are two types of each:**
**Dravya Vishayak Aparinat - This is of six types due to its relation with the Shatkayas. For example, conscious earth is aparinat as long as it is alive, and after becoming lifeless, it is called parinat. Similarly, one should know about Apkay etc.**
**Bhav Vishayak Aparinat - When an object is related to two or more people, one person wants to give it to the sadhu and the other person or others do not want to give it, then it is bhavatah aparinat from the giver's perspective. Similarly, if two munis go for alms and one muni considers the object to be eshaniya and the other does not consider it to be eshaniya, then it is bhavatah aparinat from the receiver's perspective, hence it is akalpya.**
**_The commentator Malayagiri has explained the difference between anisrusht and datribhav from aparinat. According to him, in anisrusht, the giver is generally indirect, but in datribhav from aparinat, the giver is present. Both of them disagree to give alms._**
**9. Lipta Dosha**
**Taking lepkrud substances increases the desire for taste, hence taking lepkrud substances like milk, curd etc. is Lipta dosha.**
**1. Pini 291/1. 2. Pini 291, Mavri P. 165. 3. Pimpr 90. 4. Das 3/71. 5. Mula 473. 6. Pini 293. 7. Pini 294, 295, Jiba 1590-92. 8. Mavri P. 166.**