Page #1
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ sAdhvIratna puSpavatI abhinandana grantha Thitttttilittliffittiiiii 'tatvamasi' vAkya TITHHHHHHHHHH [jaina-darzana aura zAMkara-darzana ke pariprekSya meM __ -DA. dAmodara zAstrI | pratyeka darzana paramatattva ke sAkSAtkAra karane kA mArga prazasta karatA hai| jaise vividha nadiyA~ vividha mArgoM se bahatI huI bhI eka samudra meM hI jAkara giratI haiM, vaise hI sabhI darzanoM kA gantavya sthala eka hI hai, mArga yA prasthAna kA krama bhale hI pRthak-pRthak ho / pratyeka darzana kI apanI tattva mImAMsA hotI hai, jisake AdhAra para vaha satya kI vyAkhyA karatA hai| jainadarzana ko bhI eka sudRr3ha dArzanika paramparA bhArata meM prAcInakAla se vikasita hotI rahI hai| jaina dharma va darzana ke prathama (vartamAna kalpa ke) vyAkhyAtA RSabhadeva mAne gae haiM / ye RSabhadeva ve hI haiM jinheM bhAgavata purANa meM mahAn yogI, tathA bhagavAn kA eka avatAra mAnA gayA hai| yahI kAraNa hai ki jaina dharma kI zikSA meM tathA bhAgavata purANa ke RSabha kI zikSA meM paryApta samAnatA dRSTigocara hotI hai| dUsarI ora, vedAnta darzana bhI veda, upaniSad, gItA Adi ke mAdhyama se prAcInatama vicAradhArA ke rUpa meM pallavita hokara paravartIkAla meM vividha zAkhAoM vAle eka sudRr3ha vizAla vRkSa ke rUpa meM phalatA-phalatA rahA hai| donoM darzanoM ke sambandha meM sAmAnyataH yahI dhAraNA hai ki vedAntadarzana Astika hai aura jaina darzana nAstika / AstikatA va nAstikatA kI paribhASA ke pacar3e meM par3anA yahAM prAsaMgika na hogaa| hamArA to yahI mata hai ki jo bhI dharma yA darzana AtmA, purnajanma, paraloka, karma-bandha, karma-mokSa Adi tattvoM ko mAnatA ho, vaha Astika hI hai| AcArya pANini tathA mahAbhASyakAra pataJjali bhI ukta mata kA pratipAdana karate haiN| isa dRSTi se donoM darzana Astika hI haiN| . donoM darzanoM meM kucha sAmya hai, vaiSamya bhI hai / viSamatA para vicAra karanA paraspara dUrI paidA karatA hai / phalasvarUpa ajJAnatA bar3hatI hai, bhrAntiyA~ panapatI haiM / prAyaH janatA meM viSamatA ko hI ujAgara kiyA jAtA rahA hai jisase sampradAyavAda tathA paraspara kaTutA bar3hatI rahI hai / yahA~ donoM kI samAnatA ke tathyoM meM se eka tathyavizeSa para prakAza DAlanA prastuta nibandha kA uddezya hai| 1. (ka) raghuvaMza 10/26, gItA-11/28, muNDakopa. 3/2/8, bhAgavata pu. 10/87/31, bRhadA. upa. 2/4/11, praznopa. 6/5, mahAbhArata-zAMti parva-2/9/42-431 (kha) jJAnasArASTaka (yazovijaya)-16/6, siddhasena-dvAtrizikA-5/15 / 2. bhAgavata pu. 5/3-6 adhyAya / 3. aSTAdhyAyI (pANini) sU. 4/4/60, tathA mahAbhASya (ptnyjli)| 'tattvamasi' vAkya : DaoN0 dAmodara zAstrI | 76
Page #2
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ sAdhvIratnapuSpavatI abhinandana grantha vedAnta darzana meM 'tattvamasi' mahAvAkya atyanta prasiddha hai / isa mahAvAkya ke mAdhyama se mumukSu AtmA ko parabrahma se ekatA hRdayaMgama karAI gaI hai| ukta mahAvAkya (zAMkara) vedAnta tathA jainadarzana, donoM meM samAna rUpa se upayogitA rakhatA hai| kintu donoM darzanoM meM usakI upayogitA ke pratipAdana kI rIti bhinna-bhinna hai| jaina-darzana meM isa mahAvAkya kI upayogitA kisa prakAra pratipAdita svIkRta sanajho se pUrva yaha samajhanA ucita hogA ki jainadarzana kA vedAnta vicAradhArA ke prati kyA dRSTikoNa hai, usakI tattva/satya ko parakhane-samajhane kI paddhati kyA hai, tathA paramAtma-tattva va Atmatattva ke svarUpa ko kisa rUpa meM svIkAra gayA hai / jaina-darzana kI maulika tattvamImAMsA yA satya-garIkSaNa kI paddhati kA paricaya nimna prakAra hai tatva-darzana kI jaina-paddhati jainadRSTi se tatva anirvacanIya hai| kintu usa anirvavataM yatA ko pratiSThApanA jisa vicAra-paddhati dvArA kI gaI hai, vaha vizeSa mananIya hai / hamArA, sAmAnya jana kA, jJAna sopAdhika (vibhAvajJAna) hotA hai| sarvajJa kevalI, tIrthaMkara Adi isake apavAda haiN| indriyoM kI durbalatA yA vikRti hone para to hameM vastu kA sahI jJAna ho hI nahIM pAtA, kintu yadi indriyA~ avikRta va sakSama hoM to bhI saMsAra kI sabhI vastuoM ko hama nahIM dekha sakate / kisI eka vastu ko bhI deza va kAla kI upAdhi ke sAtha hI jAna pAte haiM, arthAt kisI vastu kI atIta va anAgata sthiti ko nahIM jAna pAte, isI taraha atyanta dUrI yA kisI AvaraNa va vyavadhAna ke hone para bhI kisI vastu ko nahIM dekha pAte / jo vastu dikhAI bhI par3atI hai, usakA bhI bAhya sthUla rUpa hI hameM dRSTigocara ho pAtA hai| vastu kA bAharI rUpa pratikSaNa nirantara parivartanazIla hai / bIja se vRkSa paidA huaa| vRkSa ko kATA to lakar3I banI / lakar3I jalI aura koyalA bana gii| -koyalA jalA to rAkha bana gayA / vRkSa aura rAkha-ina donoM sthitiyoM ke madhya hameM vividha avasthAe~ to dikhAI par3atI haiM, kintu ina vividha avasthAoM meM bhI eka AdhArabhUta tattva, jo utpatti va nAza kI prakriyA se sarvathA asampRkta hai, dRSTigocara nahIM ho paataa| vastutaH tattva kA samagra rUpa to sRjana, dhvaMsa aura sthiti (dhra vatA) kI vilakSaNatA meM nihita hai / hamArI dRSTi yA to saMzleSaNAtmaka hotI hai to kabhI vizleSaNAtmaka / saMzleSaNAtmaka dRSTi kevala dhra va tattva para kendrita rahatI hai, aura vizleSaNAtmaka dRSTi sRjana-dhvaMsAtmaka parivartana para / eka udAharaNa leM-gAya dUdha detI hai, dUdha se dahI banatA hai, dahI se lassI banatI hai| ina paraspara padArthoM meM hamArA bhI bhedaparaka hotA hai to kabhI abhedprk| jaise, koI davAI dUdha se lI jAtI hai, to koI davAI dahI se / dUdha se lene vAlI davAI kabhI dahI se nahIM lI jAtI, aura dahI se lI jAne vAlI davA kabhI dUdha se nahIM lI jaatii| yahAM davA lene vAle vyakti kI dRSTi bhedaparaka/vizeSaparaka hai / kintu kisI vyakti ko DAkTara ne gorasa-sevana kA parAmarza diyA ho, yA kisI vyakti ne gorasa-tyAga kA vrata liyA ho, usakI 4. tatvaM vAgativati (padmanandi paMcaviMzatikA-11/10, 23/20) / 5. niyamasAra-11 (A. kundkund)| 6. pravacanasAra (kundakunda)--100-101, tattvArtha sUtra (umAsvAti)-5/29, paMcAdhyAyI (paM. rAjamala)---1/90. 92,861 7. sarvanayasamUhasAdhyo hi loka-saMvyavahAraH (sarvArthasiddhi-1/33) / 80 | caturtha khaNDa : jaina darzana, itihAsa aura sAhitya www.jainelture
Page #3
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ sAdhvAratnapuSpavatA Abhanandana grantha dRSTi meM dUdha aura dahI donoM hI samAna haiN| isase yaha bhI siddha hotA hai ki dUdha, dahI, lassI ina saba meM eka 'gorasa' tattva samAna rUpa se anusyUta hai, jo dhra va hai| isI prakAra sone ke vividha AbhUSaNoM meM parasparabhinnatA bhI hai, suvarNatva kI dRSTi se abheda bhI hai| suvarNa kA abhyarthI kisI bhI AbhUSaNa ko samAna rUpa se dekhegaa| kintu suvarNakalazArthI tathA suvarNamukuTArthI ina donoM meM, pahale vyakti ko duHkha aura dUsare ko sukha usa samaya hogA jaba suvarNakalaza ko tor3akara suvarNamukuTa banAyA jAtA hogA, jabaki suvarNa ke abhyarthI ko na duHkha hogA aura na sukha / astu, saMzleSaNAtmaka dRSTi meM vastu nitya, avinazvara, sat, eka, sAmAnya, va abhedAtmaka hai, jabaki vizleSaNAtmaka dRSTi meM vaha anitya, kSaNika, asata, aneka, vizeSa va bhedarUpa hai| vasta bhedAbhedAtmaka, sadasadAtmaka, ekAnekAtmaka, sAmAnya-vizeSAtmaka, nityAnityAtmaka hai| isa taraha pratyeka vastU paraspara-viruddha aneka ananta dharmoM kA adhiSThAna hai|10 vicAra-abhivyakti ke kSetra meM pratyeka vastu kI sattA sApekSa hotI hai-~-arthAt vaha apekSAbheda se sadrUpa va asadrUpa-donoM hotI hai| vastutaH nityatva dharma anityatva dharma kA avinAbhAvI hai / / jaina dRSTi se bhAva kI taraha abhAva bhI vastudharma hai / " ghar3A hai-isa kathana meM 'hai' yaha pada ghar3e kI ApekSika sattA ko hI vyakta karatA hai, na ki nirapekSa sattA ko / vaha niyata sthAna, kSetra, rUpa, AkAra, guNa vizeSa kI sattA ko hI dyotita karatA hai / dArzanika bhASA meM ghar3A 'ghar3A' rUpa meM hI hai, arthAt vaha anya dravyarUpa (paTa Adi) meM bahuta kucha 'nahIM' bhI hai, vaha pArthiva hai, bhautika hai, acetana hai; kintu vaha jalAtmaka, abhautika yA cetana Adi nahIM bhI hai / apane niyata avayavoM se, apane hI niyatakAla se, apane niyata guNAdi se sambaddhatA kI apekSA se hI usakA astitva hai| saMkSepa meM, pratyeka dravya anantAnanta svatantra ikAiyoM meM vibhakta hai, pratyeka ikAI bhI ananta-ananta traikAlika avasthAoM meM vibhakta hai / pUrNa satya vahI kahA jAegA-jo dravya kI samaSTi ko apane andara sameTane kI kSamatA rakhatA ho| kahanA na hogA ki sImita jJAna-zakti vAle sAMsArika prANI samagra vastu kA sAkSAtkAra kabhI nahIM kara pAte. aura kacha jAna bhI pAte haiM to dharmoM kI parasparaviruddhatA ko vANI se kaha bhI nahIM paate| cUMki bhASA kI zakti sImita hai, isalie vastu ke paraspara-viruddha dharmoM kA, yA usake ananta dharmoM kA, athavA usakI bhedAbhedAtmakatA, nityAnityAtmakatA Adi kA, eka sAtha kathana sambhava nahIM hai, isalie vastU 'avaktavya' hai| vAstava meM hamArA sArA zAbdika vyavahAra, abhiprAya-vizeSavaza vastu ke anantadharmoM tathA parasparaviruddha aneka dharmayugaloM meM kisI eka hI dharma-vizeSa para kendrita rahatA hai| ukta dharmavizeSAzrita kathana pUrNa 'asatya' nahIM; to pUrNa satya bhI nahIM kahA jA sktaa| jainadRSTi se yaha 'satya kA aMza' kahA jAtA hai| 8. AptamImAMsA (samantabhadra)-69, 59, adhyAtmopaniSad (yazovijaya) 1/44, tulanA-pAtaMjala mahAbhASya 1/1/1, yogasUtrabhASya-4/13, pravacanasAra--2/101-102 / 9. padmanandi paMcaviMzatikA-4/591 10. anantadharmaNastattvam (samayasAra-kalaza-A0 amRtcndr-2)| 11. sammatitarka (siddhasena)-3/1-4, pravacanasAra-2/100-101 / 12. yuktyanuzAsana (samantabhadra)-59, nyAyAvatAra (siddhasena)-16, sarvArthasiddhi (puujypaad)-9/2| 13. tattvArthazlokavAttika (vidyAnandi)-1/6 sUtra para zloka saM. 6, jaina tarkabhASA (yazovijaya)-naya vivaraNa / 'tattvamasi vAkya' : DaoN0 dAmodara zAstrI | 81 www.jait
Page #4
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ TUD ...... .................... sAdhvIratna puSpavatI abhinandana grantha / / yaha to huI sAmAnyajanoM kI baat| sarvajJa kevalI tIrthaMkara bhI, jinheM sampUrNa loka ke ananta padArthoM kA, tathA unakI ananta ikAiyoM-ananta traikAlika sUkSma-sthUla avasthAoM ko spaSTa dekhane kI zakti prApta hai,14 bhASA kI sImita zakti ke kAraNa vastu ko samagra rUpa se eka sAtha kaha nahIM pAte, yadi ve kramazaH bhI kaheM to ananta kAla laga jaaegaa| sarvajJa tIrthaMkara ne apane upadeza meM yaha prayAsa kiyA hai ki vastu ke vividha satyAMzoM ko kramazaH ujAgara kiyA jaay| kintu viDambanA yaha bhI hai ki jo kucha bhI unhoMne kahA, usameM se kucha (anantavA~) bhAga hI lipibaddha kiyA jA sakA;15 aura jo lipibaddha bhI huA usameM se bahuta kucha lupta ho cukA hai| anekAntavAda-syAdvAda paddhati jaina darzana ne 'parama satya' ko samajhane/samajhAne/nirUpita karane ke lie anekAntavAda va syAdvAda siddhAnta ko prastuta kiyA hai / anekAntavAda vastu meM paraspara-viruddha dharmoM kI avirodhapUrNa sthiti kA tathA usakI anantadharmAtmakatA kA nirUpaNa karatA hai| syAdvAda sImitajJAnadharI prANiyoM ke lie ukta anekAntAtmakatA ko vyakta karane kI aisI-paddhati nirdhArita karatA hai jisase asatyatA yA ekAMgitA yA durAgraha Adi doSoM se bacA jA sake / (1) 'yaha vastu ghar3A hI hai', (2) 'yaha ghar3A hai' (3) 'merI apanI dRSTi se, yA kisI dRSTi se (syAt) yaha ghar3A hai'-ye tIna prakAra ke kathana haiN| inameM uttarottara satyatA adhika ujAgara hotI gaI hai| antima kathana parama satya ko vyakta karane vAlI vividha dRSTiyoM tathA una para AdhArita kathanoM ke astitva ko saMketita karatA haA parama satya se svayaM kI sambaddhatA ko bhI vyakta karatA hai| isalie vaha svayaM meM ekAMgI (ekadharmasparzI) hote hue bhI asatyatA va pUrNa ekAMgitA kI koTi se Upara uTha jAtA hai| jaise, aMjuli meM gRhIta gaMgAjala meM samasta gaMgA kI pavitratA va pAvanatA nihita hai, usI taraha ukta kathana meM satyatA nihita hai| vAstava meM apane kathana kI vAstavika sthiti (sApekSatA kA saMketa) batAne se satyatA hI udbhAsita ho jAtI hai| jaise, koI mUrkha vyakti yaha kahe ki "maiM paMDita hU~, kintu maiM jhUTha bola rahA hU~" to vaha asatya bolane kA doSI nahIM kahA jA sakatA, kyoMki usane apane kathana kI vAstavikatA ko bhI ujAgara kara diyA hai| ThIka vahI sthiti 'syAt ghaTa hai' isa kathana kI hai| yahA~ 'syAt' pada se kathana kI ekadharmasparzitA vyakta kI jA rahI hai, sAtha hI anya virodhI dRSTi se jur3e viruddhadharma kI sattA se bhI apanA avirodha vyakta karatA hai, jisase ukta kathana 'satya' kI koTi meM pratiSThita ho jAtA hai / yahI jaina-darzana ke syAdvAda siddhAnta kA hArda hai / vividha prasthAnoM meM vedAnta darzana: jaina dRSTi se jaina darzana kI daSTi meM sabhI vicAra-bhedoM meM vaiyaktika STibheda kAraNa hai| vAstava meM unameM virodha hai hI nhiiN| virodha to hamArI dRSTiyoM meM panapatA hai| vastu to sabhI virodhoM se Upara hai / eka hI vyakti kisI kA pitA hai, kisI kA beTA hai, kisI kA bhAI hai to kisI kA pati / usa vyakti kA pratyeka sambandhI-jana dRSTivizeSa se jur3A huA hai| vastutaH vyakti pitRtva, putratva Adi vividha dharmoM kA . 14. tattvArthasUtra-1/29, pravacanasAra-6/37-42, 47-52 / 15. sanmatitarka-2/16, rAjavAttika-1/26/4, vizeSAvazyakabhASya-1094-95, 140-142, Avazya kaniyukti 89-90, dvAdazAra nayacakra (caturtha ArA)-pR. 5, padmapurANa-105/107, ugrAditvakRta kalyANakAraka-1/49, pR. 16, paTkhaNDAgama-dhavalA-pustaka-12, pR 171 / 16. tiloya paNNani (yativRSabha)- 4/757, 1471, 1583, 2032, 2366,2753, 2889 Adi-Adi / 82 | caturtha khaNDa : jaina darzana, itihAsa aura sAhitya
Page #5
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ sAdhvIratna puSpavatI abhinandana grantha puja bhI hai / 17 yahI sthiti paramasatya ke viSaya meM hai| sabhI darzana apanI-apanI dRSTi se usakA nirUpaNa karate haiM, kintu una sabhI jJAta-ajJAta dRSTiyoM kA samanvita rUpa hI parama satya hai| samasta dRSTiyoM ko sAta vargoM meM jaina AcAryoM ne vibhAjita kiyA hai aura inheM 'naya' nAma se abhihita kiyA hai| nayoM kI saMkhyA sAta hai-naigama, saMgraha, vyavahAra, RjusUtra, zabda, samabhirUr3ha aura evambhUta / inameM se koI naya (vyavahAra) bhedagrAhI hai, koI (saMgraha) naya abhedanAhI hai| koI (naigama) naya saMkalpa meM sthita bhAvI yA bhUta padArtha ko viSaya karatA hai to koI (RjusUtra) naya sAmAnyajanocita vyavahArAnurUpa sAmAnya-vizeSa Adi aneka dharmoM ko viSaya karatA hai, yA kAryakAraNa, AdhAra-Adheya kI dRSTi se vastu kA aupacArika kathana ke AzrayaNa ko svIkRti pradAna karatA hai / koI (RjusUtra) naya atIta anAgata rUpoM ko ojhala kara mAtra vartamAna pratyutpannakSaNavartI sthiti ko grahaNa karatA hai to koI (zabda) naya kAla, liMga, kAraka Adi bheda para AdhArita vAcya padArtha ke bheda para, aura koI (samabhirUr3ha) naya paryAya-bheda se vAcya padArtha-gata bheda para bala detA hai-arthAt padArthagata sthiti ke anurUpa hI paryAyavizeSa ke zAbdika prayoga ko ucita ThaharAtA hai| koI naya (evambhUta) atIta va anAgata padArthagata rUpoM ke sthAna para vartamAna avasthA ke anurUpa hI usa padArtha ke lie vAcaka zabda kA prayoga ucita ThaharAtA hai / vyavahAra meM hama sabhI kisI na kisI dRSTi (naya) kA Azraya lete haiM / __ukta sabhI nayoM ko do dRSTiyoM meM bhI bA~TA gayA hai| ve haiM-dravyAstika (abhedagrAhI) va paryAyAstika (bhedagrAhI) / satyAnveSI ke lie donoM dRSTiyAM samAna rUpa se AdaraNIya mAnI gaI haiM, ve voM ke samAna kahI gaI haiN|20 jisa prakAra mathAnI ke cAroM aura lipaTI rassI ke do choroM ko donoM hAthoM meM lekara makkhana nikAlA jAtA hai, usa samaya eka chora ko apanI ora khIMcate hue dUsare chora ko DhIlA kiyA jAtA hai, phira dUsare chora ko khIMcate hue pahale chora ko DhIlA kiyA jAtA hai / usI prakAra satyAnveSI ko cAhie ki vaha ubhaya naya ko krama-krama se pradhAnatA-gauNatA pradAna karate hae tAttvika jJAna prApta kare, aura jJAna prApta karane ke bAda prasaMgAnurUpa kisI dRSTi ko heya yA upAdeya kare / 22 pratyeka naya apane dUsare nayoM ke sAtha saMgati/samanvaya/avirodha rakhe to vaha anAdi avidyA (mithyAtva) ko dUra karane tathA mokSopayogI jJAna ko utpanna karane meM sahAyaka ho sakatA hai, anyathA nahIM / 29 vAstava meM pratyeka naya apane Apa meM apanI apanI maryAdA meM-satyatA lie hue hai, parantu anya nayoM kA nirAkaraNa va virodha pradarzita karane se hI vaha 'asatya' bana jAtA hai / 24 17. sanmatitarka-3/17-18 18. adhyAtmasAra-18/88 19. draSTavya - tattvArthasUtra--1/33, tathA usa para rAjavAttika, sarvArthasiddhi tathA zlokavAttika Adi / syAdvAda maMjarI-kA. 28, AlApa paddhati-5, bRhad nayacakra-185, harivaMza puraann-58/41| 20. samayasAra-113-115 para taatpryvRtti| 21. puruSArthasiddha yupAya-225 22. kSatracUDAmaNi-2/44, AdipurANa-20/156-157, uttarapUrANa-74/549, 56/73-74, niyamasAra 52, tathA tAtparyavRtti gAthA-43 (niyamasAra) pr| 23. sarvArthasiddhi-1/33, rAjavAttika-1/33/12, sanmatitarka-3/46, 1/21-27, svayambhUstotra-1, AptamImAMsA--108, gommaTasAra-karma0 895, kaSAyaprAbhRta-1/13-14, nayacakra-zrata0 11, kArtikeyAna prekSA--266, dhavalA-9/4,1,45, adhyatmopaniSad (yshovijy)-1/36| 24. sanmatitarka-1/28, jJAnasArASTaka (yazovijaya)-32/2 / 'tattvamasi vAkya' : DaoN0 dAmodara zAstrI | 83 PrithADDA Nilmani www.jal
Page #6
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ sAdhvIratna puSpavatI abhinandana grantha jainadRSTi se pratyeka bhAratIya darzana kisI na kisI 'naya' se sambaddha hai / eka ora mImAMsaka, advaitavAdI va sAMkhya darzana abhedavAdI dravyAstika naya ko aMgIkAra karate haiM, to dUsarI ora bauddhadarzana bhedavAdI paryAyAstika naya ko 125 cArvAkadarzana vyavahAra naya ko, bauddha RjusUtra naya ko, naiyAyikavaizeSika naigama naya ko, tathA sAMkhya va advaitavAdI saMgrahanaya ko aMgIkAra kara vastu tattva kA nirUpaNa karate haiM / 26 ina sabhI nayoM tathA unake Azrayita darzanoM ke prati jainAcAryoM kI apanI taTastha dRSTi rahI hai / itanA hI nahIM, kucha sthaloM meM unake prati pUrNa Adara bhI vyakta kiyA hai| jainAcAryoM ne spaSTa kahA hai - sabhI zAstrakAra mahAtmA tathA paramArtha (ucca) dRSTi vAle haiM, ve mithyA bAta kaise kaha sakate haiM ? vastutaH unake abhiprAyoM meM bhinnatA hai, isalie unake kathana meM paraspara bhinnatA dRSTigocara hotI hai, kyoMki jitane abhiprAya hoMge utanI dRSTiyA~ hoMgI aura tadanurUpa utane hI vacana yA vyAkhyAna ke prakAra hoMgeM / 28 saccA jainI sabhI darzanoM kI ekasUtratA ko dhyAna meM rakhatA hai / zAstrajJa vahI hai jo sabhI darzanoM ko samAna Adara se dekhatA hai / 29 saccA jainI abhimAnavaza anya dharmoM kA tiraskAra nahIM karatA / " vaha sabhI dRSTiyoM ko madhyasthatA se grahaNa karatA hai / 31 madoddhata hokara apane jJAna va mata / sampradAya kI mahattA kI prazaMsA tathA dUsare kI nindA se vaha dUra rahanA pasanda karatA hai / AcArya siddhasena ne spaSTa sujhAva prastuta kiyA ki dUsare darzanoM/ dharmo ke siddhAntoM ko jAnanA cAhie, aura jAna kara satya ko puSTa karane kA prayAsa karanA cAhie, kintu unakA khaNDana karane kA vicAra kadApi ucita nahIM / vyartha yA zuSka vAdavivAda se hamezA bacanA cAhie, kyoMki usase kisI tattva taka pahu~canA sambhava nahIM hotA / 24 jaina mata buddha tattva (paramapada / paramAtmatattva ) kI prApti madhyastha / udAra dRSTikoNa vAle ko hI hotI hai / 35 madhyastha bhAva ke sAtha kiyA gayA eka pakSa kA jJAna bhI sArthaka hai, anyathA karor3oM zAstroM ke par3hane se bhI koI lAbha nahIM 136 kaThinAI yaha hai ki darzana abhiprAya bhedoM para dhyAna na dekara paraspara vivAda meM ulajha jAte haiM / 37 jaba bhI koI darzana durAgrahavAda se grasta ho jAtA hai, apanI hI prazaMsA aura dUsaroM ko aprAmANika batAkara unakI nindA karatA hai, to jJAna va karma kI granthiyoM ko sulajhAne kI apekSA aura adhika ulajhA detA hai / 38 jaise kaI andhe vyakti kisI vizAlakAya hAthI ko sparza kara, pRthak-pRthak AMzika rUpa se to 25. syAdvAda maMjarI, kA. 14 26. jainatarkabhASA - nayapariccheda, tathA syAdvAda maMjarI, kA. 14 / 28. sanmatitarka - 3 / 47 30. ratnakaraNDa zrAvakAcAra - 26 32. prazamaratiprakaraNa ( umAsvAti ) - 91-109 27. zAstravArtAsamuccaya - 3 / 15 29. adhyAtmopaniSad - 1 /70 31. jJAnasAra ( yazovijaya ) - 32/2 33. dvAtriMzikA 8 / 19, aSTaka prakaraNa - 12/1-8 34. yazovijaya kRta dvAtriMzikA - 8 / 18, 23 / 1-17, 32, adhyAtmopaniSad - 1/74 35. jJAnasArASTaka - 15 / 6, samayasArakalaza - 341, 248-261 36. adhyAtmopa. 1/73 38. vizeSAvazyakabhASya - 62, sUtrakRtAMga - 1 / 1 / 23, padmanandi paMca. 4/5 84 | caturtha khaNDa : jaina darzana, itihAsa aura sAhitya 37. siddhasenakRta dvAtriMzikA - 20/4
Page #7
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ sAdhvIratna puSpavatI abhinandana grantha jAna lete haiM, kintu koI andhA pUrNa samagra jJAna nahIM prApta kara pAtA, kyoMki pUrNa samagra darzana khulI A~khoM se, udAra / vyApaka dRSTikoNa se dekhane para hI sambhava hai / isa prakAra, jainadRSTi se vedAntadarzana eka dRSTikoNa hai, jise grahaNa kie binA pUrNa satya kA jJAna sambhava nahIM / itanA hI nahIM, kaI viSayoM meM vedAnta va jaina darzana donoM kI vicAra-samatA dRSTigocara hotI hai / vedAntadarzana, vizeSakara zAMkara advaitadarzana, sAmAnyagrAhI hai / usakI ghoSaNA hai - ekamAtra brahma hI pAramArthika satya hai - 'brahma satyaM jagat mithyA' / jainadarzana meM bhI brahmasthAnIya 'samasta padArthavyApI' eka parama sattA kI kalpanA kI gaI hai / 40 kintu jahA~ zAMkara vedAntasammata brahma 'prajJAnaghana' hai, " vahA~ jainasammata ukta paramasattA cidacid ubhayadravyavyApI hai / dravyArthika naya se dravya kA kathana karate samaya, samasta guNa-bheda kI, tathA guNa-guNIbheda kI vAsanA miTa jAtI hai, aura eka 'akhaNDadravya' pratIti meM AtA hai / 42 isa prakAra, jainadarzana tathA vedAnta darzana (zAMkara) -- donoM hI 'eka tattva' kI kalpanA meM sahabhAgI dRSTigocara hote haiM / brahma (paramatattva ) aura jainadRSTi 44 sabhI dravyoM / padArthoM kI sArthakatA Atma dravya kI siddhi meM nihita hai, 43 aura cU~ki AtmA sabhI tattvoM meM utkRSTa hai, " ataH vahI 'paramatattva' hai / zuddhAtmA-prApti hI nirvANa hai, isalie jaina paramparA nirvANa ko bhI 'paramatattva' kahA gAyA hai / " jIvAdi saMsArI bAhya tattva heya haiM, 17 aura 'paramatattva' hI upAdeya aura ArAdhya hai / " yahA~ 'paramAtma tattva' se zuddhAtmA (saMsAra-mukta ) grAhya hai, saMsArI AtmA nahIM 149 zuddhAtmA ko hI jaina zAstra meM 'brahma', 'parabrahma' aura 'sahaja tattva'" bhI kahA gayA hai / Atma-tattva ke jJAta hone para kucha jJAtavya nahIM raha jAtA, ataH Atma-jJAna kI mahattA sarvopari hai - isa viSaya meM upaniSadoM tathA jainadarzana kA samAna mantavya hai / 39. padmanandi paMca. 4/7, tulanA -- yazovijayakRta dvAtriMzikA - 16/25 40. paMcAstikAya - 8, pravacanasAra - 2 / 5, sarvArthasiddhi-1 /33, paMcAdhyAyI-1 /8, 264, tattvArthabhASya- 1/35 [tulanA - maMtrAyaNI upa. 4/6, chAndogya upa. 6 / 2 / 1] 41. bRhadA. upa. 2/4/9 (zAMkarabhASya ) | 43. adhyAtmasAra - 18/3 45. kArtikeyAnuprekSA - 204, padmanandi paMca. 4/ 44, 23/12 42. pravacanasAra TIkA - 1 /6 (tattvadIpikA) / 44. niyamasAra - 92 46. yogadRSTisamuccaya- 129, 132 48. padmanandi paMca - 4 / 44, 60, 75, 22/1-2 47. niyamasAra - 38 49. samayasAra - 38 para tAtparyavRtti TIkA 50. niyamasAra kalaza - 25, mokSaprAbhRta-2, jJAnasArASTaka 8/7, 2 / 4, 16/6, paramAtmaprakAza-171 51. niyamasAra kalaza - 176, 184, 52. upadezasAhasrI - samyagmati prakaraNa-1-7, bRhadA. upa. 2 / 4 / 13-14, 4/5/6, 4/4/12, zvetA. upa. 1/12, kenopa. 2 / 13, muMDakopa. 1 / 1 /3-6 53. kArtikeyAnuprakSA - 4 / 79, bhagavatI ArAdhanA, 1/9, padmanandi paMca. 4 / 20-21, adhyAtmasAra - 18 / 2-3, samayasAra gAthA - 15 para tAtparyavRtti 'tattvamasi vAkya' : DaoN0 dAmodara zAstrI | 85 www.2
Page #8
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ sAdhvIratna puSpavatI abhinandana grantha anekAntavAdI jaina darzana meM sAmAnya tattvoM ko dekhane-samajhane-parakhane ke lie dRSTiyoM-nayoM (dravyAstika - paryAyAstika, tathA naigama Adi sAta nayoM) kI kalpanA hai, vaise hI Atma-tattva ko adhyAtmasAdhanA ke sandarbha meM hRdayaMgama karane hetu do anya viziSTa nayoM kA nirUpaNa kiyA yA hai / ve haiM(1) vyavahAranaya, aura ( 2 ) nizcayanaya / nizcayadRSTi vastu meM abheda dekhatI hai / vyavahAradRSTi dravya, kSetra, kAla, bhAva-ina cAroM meM se kisI eka prakAra se yA aneka prakAra se bheda dekhatI hai, aura kabhI-kabhI para- dravya ke guNoM / dharmoM ko bhI kisI dravya meM aupacArika dRSTi se Aropita kara letI hai / nizcayadRSTi kI do koTiyA~ haiM / nicalI koTa (zuddha) Atma dravya ke unhIM dharmoM / guNoM ko svIkAra karatI hai jo parAnapekSa hoM, arthAt AtmA ke svabhAva-bhUta dharmoM ko hI aMgIkAra karatI hai, kintu nizcayanaya kI ucca (zuddha) koTi Atma dravya ke svabhAvabhUta guNoM/dharmo/ traikAlika bhAvoM / avasthAoM meM bhI abheda dekhatI hai, arthAt rAgAdinirmukta akhaNDa 'cinmAtra' paramatattva kA viSaya karatI hai / 54 advaita dRSTi (zuddha nizcayanaya) se AtmA ke bandha, mokSa, rAga, dva eSa, Adi kucha bhI nahIM hai / vaha sarvathA zuddha va mukta hai 155 zAMkara vedAntadarzana meM pAramArthika, vyAvahArika va prAtibhAsika - ye tIna sattAe~ mAnI gaI haiM / inameM pAramArthika va vyAvahArika sattAe~ jainasammata nizcayanaya va vyavahAranaya se sambaddha pratipAdita SATTA hai / jaina mAnyatA ke anusAra, vyavahAradRSTi se dvaita buddhi aura nizcayanaya se advaita buddhi utpanna hotI hai / dvaita buddhi saMsAra ko -bandha ko bar3hAtI hai, aura advaita buddhi mokSa kI ora paramAtmatA kI ora le jAtI hai / 7 jJAnI vyakti heyopAdeya vizeSajJa hotA hai, isalie vaha donoM dRSTiyoM ko jAna kara, AtmakalyANakArI adva aita dRSTi ( nizcayadRSTi) ko aMgIkAra karatA hai / parama zuddha, eka, akhaNDa AtmA -- 'cinmAtra' ko viSaya karane vAlI zuddha nizcayadRSTi kA avalambana karane se sAdhaka ko advaitarUpatA prApta ho jAtI hai 158 jaina darzana meM zuddha paramAtmatattva ko paramArtha' nAma se tathA ise viSaya karane vAle nizcayanaya ko 'paramArthadRSTi' nAma se abhihita kiyA gayA hai| paramArthadRSTi se abheda / akhaNDa tattva kI anubhUti 54. samayasAra, 141, samayasAra kalaza - 9-10, 120, padmanandi paMca. 4 / 5, 17, 32, 75, samayasAra gA. 56 va 272 para AtmakhyAti, AlApa paddhati 204, 216, pravacanasAra - 1 / 77 para tAtparyavRtti, adhyAtmasAra - 9 / 8, 18 / 12, 130, 173, 189, 275, 196, yazovijayakRta dvAtriMzikA 21/9. 55. samayasAra -14-15, 278-79, 141, padmanandi paMca. 11 / 17, paramAtmaprakAza 65, pravacanasAra- 172, paramAtmaprakAza - 68. 56. padmanandi paMca. 4 / 17, 57. padmanandi paMca. 4/32-33, 9 / 29, adhyAtmasAra - 18/196, 58. padmanandi paMca. 4 / 31, 11 / 18, samayasAra - 186, 206, paramAtmaprakAza-173 59. pravacanasAra-2/1 tA. vRtti, samayasAra - 151 para TIkAe~ (AtmakhyAti va tAtparyavRtti) dhalaH - pustaka - 13, pR. 280, 286 86 | caturtha khaNDa : jaina darzana, itihAsa aura sAhitya www.jainer
Page #9
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ sAdhvIratnapuSpavatI abhinandana grantha kA honA vaidika00 evaM jaina donoM zAstroM meM samAna rUpa se mAnA gayA hai| A. zaMkara 'paramArtha' kA varNana karate hue ise advaita darzana meM kAraNa mAnate haiN| AcArya zaMkara kA vacana 'nizcayena brahmAhamasmi' ---'ityaparokSIkRtya'62 hameM jaina darzana ke nizcayanaya kA spaSTa dhyAna karAtA hai| _ vedAntadarzana kI taraha hI,63 jainadarzana kA bhI carama lakSya jIva-brahma kI ekatA yA zuddha caitanya svarUpa kI adhigati (prApti) meM paryavasita ho jAtA hai / jaina dRSTi se abhedadRSTi paramabrahma taka jAne kA, usase ekAtmatA-prApti kA, arthAt svasvarUpasthiti pAne kA ekamAtra sAdhana hai| vastutaH to paramatattva sabhI nayoM/dRSTiyoM se atIta hai / 15 'naya' eka pakSa hai, usakA kAma paramabrahma taka kA mArga dikhAnA mAtra hai| paramAtmatA prApti hone para sAdhaka-sAdhya, upAsaka-upAsya, heya-upAdeya-sabhI bhAva svataH samApta ho jAte haiM aura zuddha cinmAtra rUpa avaziSTa raha jAtA hai|66 A. zaMkara ke mata meM bhI brahma kI sattA akhaNDa hai, mana, vANI va indriyoM se atIta hai, deza-kAla Adi maryAdAoM se amaryAdita hai| usakA vyAkhyAna neti neti hI ho sakatA hai| brahma saccidAnanda hai,68 apane mUla rUpa se kabhI bhI vyabhicarita na hone ke kAraNa sat hai, caitanya hai-satyaM jJAnamanantaM brahma / jainadarzana bhI paramatattva ko akhaNDa, neti neti dvArA varNya svarUpa vAlA, tathA avAGa manogocara mAnatA hai| vedAntadarzana meM saMsArI jIva va paramAtmatattva 'parabrahma' meM bheda kA kAraNa/AdhAra avidyA yA ajJAna hai, vastutaH unameM koI bheda nahIM hai| isa ajJAna kA nirastIkaraNa pAramArthika jJAna se ho jAtA hai| avidyA ke nirasta ho jAne para jIva brahmarUpatA prApta kara letA hai| 60. ekatvaM pAramAthikama, mithyAjJAnaviz2ambhitaM ca nAnAtvam-(brahmasatra-2/1/14 para zAMkara bhaassy)| dra.viSNapurANa-1/2/6, 10-13, 2/14/29-31, 2/15/34-35, 2/16/24, 6/8/100, ba. sU. 1/1/4/4 (zAMkarabhASya) / bra. sU. 2/1/27 (zAMkarabhASya), bhAgavata purANa-5/12/11 61. samayasAra-8 para AtmakhyAti va tAtparyavRtti TIkA, samayasAra-kalaza-18 62. zvetA. upa. 4/11 para zAMkara bhASya 63. AtmA vA are draSTavyaH zrotavyo mantavyo nididhyAsitavyaH (bRhadA. upa. 2/4/5)| viSayo jIva-brahmakyaM, zuddha caitanyaM prameya tatraiva vedAntAnAM tAtparyAt (vedaantsaar-4)| Atmakatva-vidyA-prAptaye sarve vedAntA Arabhante (ba.sa. zAMkara bhASya, prstaavnaa)| 64. padmanandi paMca. 4/20-21, kArtikeyAnuprekSA-4/79, adhyAtmasAra-18/2, iSTopadeza-49, 65. samayasAra-142, padamanandi-11/53,42-43, samayasArakalaza-4,9, 66. pravacanasAra-2/80, jJAnasArASTaka (nirlepASTaka), jJAnasAra-26/3, 67. vedAntasAra, 1/1, taitti. upa. 2/4. kenopa. 1/3,4, muNDakopa-3/1/8, gItA-11/8, bRhadA. upa. 4/5/15, kaThopa-2/6/12, mAMDakyopa-7, upadezasAhasrI-samyagmati prakaraNa-71 68. vedAntasAra-1, yogatatvopa. 17, 69. taitti . upa. 2/1, 70. AcArAMga-5/6/123-125, samayasAra-142, padmanandi paMca. 11/2,53,42-43, paramAtmaprakAza-19-22, samaya sAra kalaza-4-9, 71. avidyAkalpitaM vedyaveditavedanAdibhedam (ba. sa. zAMkara bhaassy-1/1/4)| mithyAjJAnakRta eva jIvaparamezvarayo daH na vastukRtaH (zAMkarabhASya-ba. sU. 1/3/19) / avidyA-nivRttI svAtmanyavasthAnaM paraprAptiH (taitti. upa. zAMkarabhASya prstaavnaa)| avidyA-nivRttireva mokSaH (muNDakopa-1/5 shaaNkrbhaassy)| 72. brahmasUtra-2/1/20, zAMkarabhASya 'tattvamasi vAkya' : DaoN0 dAmodara zAstrI | 87
Page #10
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ sAdhvIratnapuSvatI abhinandana grantha) jainadarzana meM bhI paramatattva 'saccidAnanda' rUpa hai| 73 saMsArI jIva samyagjJAna prApta kara, AtmAnAtmaviveka ke anantara, rAgAdi karma kA kSaya kara sarvajJatA tathA saccidAnandarUpatA kramazaH prApta kara letA hai| uparyukta dRSTiyoM se A. zaMkara tathA jaina dRSTi meM paryApta samAnatA dRSTigocara hotI hai / tattvamasi vAkya vedAntadarzana meM 'tattvamasi, 76 'ahaM brahma asmi'77 'yatra nAnyatpazyati,78 na tu tad dvitIyamasti tato'nyad vibhakta yatpazyed 79 ---ityAdi upaniSad-vAkyoM ke AdhAra para paramAtmA va jIvAtmA kI ekarUpatA ko svIkArA gayA hai| ___ 'tattvamasi' mahAvAkya kA artha hai-vaha tU hai| 'vaha' se tAtparya hai-parokSa va sarvajJatva Adi guNoM se viziSTa caitanya / tat se tAtparya hai-pratyakSa va alpajJatva Adi guNoM se viziSTa caitanya / arthAt zuddha caitanya tathA ajJAnopahata caitanya-donoM ekarUpa haiN| 'tattvamasi' vAkya ke zravaNa-mananAdi se jIva ko apane svarUpa kA bhAna hotA hai aura jIva brahmarUpatA prApta kara letA hai / jainadarzana ke anusAra mukta AtmA svazuddhAtmarUpa parabrahma se vibhakta hokara nahIM rhtii| vAstava meM zuddha nizcayanaya ke viSaya paramAtmatattva kI bhAvanA va dhyAna ke sopAna para car3hate-car3hate, upAsaka hI upAsyarUpatA usI prakAra prApya kara letA hai jisa prakAra dIpaka kI battI dIpaka kI lau ke rUpa meM, tathA vRkSa kI lakar3I paraspara ragar3a khAkara agni ke rUpa meM prakaTa ho jAtI hai / jainadarzana sAdhaka ko bAra-bAra yaha parAmarza detA hai ki ajIvAdi meM tathA azuddha jIvAvasthA meM 'aham' yA 'mama' kI mati chor3akara zuddha paramAtmA ke sAtha 'so'ham' kI bhAvanA ko dRr3ha kare to mukti avazyambhAvI hai|82 ajJAna va AvaraNa ke kAraNa hI paramAtmA va jIva meM bheda daSTigocara hotA hai| zuddha nizcayanaya yA paramArthadRSTi se jIvAtmA bhI zuddha cidra pa hai| sAdhaka isa paramArtha dRSTi kA hI avalambana le aura paramAtmA ko jIva aura jIva ko paramAtmA-donoM ko eka samajhe, to isa samabhAva se zIghra nirvANa prApta kara letA hai 73. padmanandi paMca. 4/1, hema. yogazAstra-10/1, niyamasAra-40 para tA. vRtti, adhyAtmasAra-18/74 74. padmanandi paMca. 4/26, 11/42, tattvAnuzAsana-234, 236, iSTopadeza-49, samAdhizataka-35, jJAnasArASTaka. 12/1, yogasAra prAbhRta-5/40, mokSaprAbhRta-5, niyamasAra-7 75. dra. brahmasUtra-1/4 zAMkara bhASya / samayasAra 390 va 404 para AtmakhyAti TIkA, evaM samayasArakalaza-235 76. chAndogya upa. 6/8/7 77. bRhadA. upa. 1/4/10 78. chAndogya upa. 7/24/1 79. bRhadA. upa. 4/3/33 80. zrutvA tattvamasItyapAsya duritaM brahma va sampadyate (sarvadarzana-saMgraha - zAMkaradarzana, pR. 466) / 81. amitagati dvAtriMzikA-29, samAdhizataka-27-28, 97-98 82. niyamasAra-96, samayasAra 297, samayasArakalaza-185, 271, samAdhizataka-23, 28, 43 88 | caturtha khaNDa : jaina darzana, itihAsa aura sAhitya GARLIONan www.jainelib
Page #11
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ sAdhvIratnapuSpavatI abhinandana grantha HERAI jo jiNu so appA muNahu, ihu siddhaMtaha sAru / iu jANe viNa joiyaho chaMDahu mAyAcAru / / 83 jo paramappA so ji hauM jo hauM so paramappu / iu jANe viNu joiyA aNNu ma karahu viyappu // 86 ehau appasahAu muNi lahu pAvahi bhavatIru // 85 suddha saceyaNu buddha jiNu kevalaNANasahAu / so appA aNudiNu muNahu jai cAhahu siva lAhu / / upaniSad Adi meM kahA gayA hai ki brahma 'vijJAnaghana' hai,87 usI prakAra mukti meM mAtra 'jJAnaghanatA' hI avaziSTa rahatI hai-aisA jaina mata hai 188 ___ saMkSepa meM, vedAnta (zAMkara) tathA jainadarzana-donoM meM anya mata-bheda hone para bhI isa bAta meM aikamatya hai ki advaitAnubhUti hI mokSaprApti kA ekamAtra sAdhana hai, aura usa advaitAnubhUti ke lie paramArthadRSTi kA avalambana karanA Avazyaka hai| 0000000000000000000000000000 B HEREHHHHHHHHHEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEfffiliatriiiiiiii puSpa-sUkti-kaliyA~ dharma vaha hai, jo dhAraNa kre| mAnava ko, samAja ko, rASTra ko aura samasta saMsAra ko, jo apanI zakti, maryAdA va saMvidhi se dhAraNa-rakSaNa va saMpoSaNa karane meM samartha hai, vahI vAstava meM dharma hai / 9 dharma vaha hai, jise jIva mAtra dhAraNa kara sake / * vaha dharma jala kI taraha saba ke lie samAna upayogI hai, usameM kisI bhI prakAra ke bheda kI kalpanA nahIM kI jA sktii| jo bhI use dhAraNa kare, vahI sukha va zAMti kA lAbha kara sake, usI kA nAma hai dharma / 98935866080533360000 00000000000000000000000000000 H83. yogasAra (yogIndu)-21, 84. yogasAra-22 85. yogasAra-24 86. yogasAra-26 87. bRhadA. upa. 2/4/12 88. samayasAra-15 para AtmakhyAti, samayasAra kalaza-13, 244-45 'tattvamasi vAkya' : DaoN0 dAmodara zAstrI | 89 D HA www.jal mA HISTORY