Page #1
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ jaina-darzana kA hRdaya hai-'syAdvAda' paramaviduSI zrI kusumavatIjI ma. kI suziSyA / viduSI sAdhvI cAritra prabhA jI ma. sA, 0000000000000000000 'syAdvAda' janadarzana kA hRdaya hai, aura bhAratIya kAntavAda" aura "syAdvAda' kA pRthak-pRthak artha darzanoM ko paraspara jor3ane vAlA eka mAtra sUtra hai| mAna sakate haiM / aise vyaktiyoM ko yaha dhyAna rakhanA isalie jaina dArzanika cintana meM "syAdvAda" ko paDegA ki "anekAnta" kA artha hotA nekAnta" kA artha hotA hai-"aneka // eka viziSTa sthAna prApta hai| yadyapi isake bIja, dharma" | ina dharmoM kI jaba vivecanA kI jAyegI to bindurUpa meM, sahasrAbdiyoM pUrva se hI, jaina-AgamoM meM vaha sAre dharmoM ko yugapad vivecita karane meM samartha "utpAda-vyaya-dhrauvya rUpa meM, "asti-nAsti-ava- nahIM bana paatii| jaba bhI vivecana hogA, kramazaH ktavya'-rUpa" meM, "dravya-guNa-paryAya"-rUpa meM tathA eka-eka dharma ko lakSya karake hI kiyA jA sAta nayoM ke rUpa meM yatra-tatra prakIrNa, upalabdha rahe skegaa| phalataH yaha vivecanA, eka RmikatA, | haiM, kintu inhIM sabako vyavasthita kara "saptabhaMgI" "anekAnta" meM nahIM hai, varan usake "kathana" meM, || ke rUpa meM, ise eka spaSTa saMjJA pradAna karane meM yAnI "vAda" meM hai| isalie anekAntoM kA jo | samantabhadra aura siddhasena jaise AcAryoM ke yogadAna jo svarUpa hotA hai, vaha "vAda" meM surakSita nahIM / ko vismRta nahIM kiyA jA sakatA / bAda ke anekoM raha paataa| yaha "vAda" kI yAnI "kathana", AcAryoM ne ise lakSya banAkara vizAla vAGamaya kI "bhASA" kI vivazatA hai / isa vivazatAvaza prayukta racanA kI / vigata 500 varSoM se dArzanika jagata ke RmikatA ko "yogapadya" kA hI rUpa mAnanA par3atA eka-eka sajIva pakSa ke rUpa meM ise gaurava milA hai| hai| anyathA "avaktavya" kahakara hama "anekAnta" Aiye, paryAlocana kareM, ki "syAdvAda" Akhira hai kI vivecanA nahIM kara pAyeMge / niSkarSa yaha hai ki kyA ? aura mAnava jIvana vyApAra meM isakI upa- "anekAnta" vastugata svarUpa hai, jo tamAma apeyogitA kyA ho sakatI hai| kSAoM se saMvalita hai| ataH usakA kathana bhI, ___"syAdvAda" zabda "syAt" aura "vAda" ina do "anekAntavAda" svarUpa vAlA mAnanA hogaa| zabdoM ko milAkara banatA hai| prathama "syAt" kA anyathA "anekAnta" svarUpa aura "anekAntavAda" artha hotA hai-apekSA yAnI "dRsstti"| 'vAda" kA do alaga-alaga saMjJAe~ bana jAne para eka vilakSaNa artha hai-"siddhAnta" yAnI mantavya / ataH donoM samasyA uTha khar3I ho jAtI hai| ataeva "anezabdoM ko milAne para inakA sammilita artha kAnta" aura "syAdvAda" ko samAnArthavAcI mAnA! hogA-"sApekSa siddhAnta" arthAt vaha siddhAnta, jAtA hai| isa samAnArthakatA se jo zAbdika antr| jisakA AdhAra apekSA ho / "anekAntavAda" - paidA hotA hai, use dRSTigata karate hue, hama moTe "apekSAvAda" "kathaMcitvAda" "syAdvAda" Adi taura para yaha mAna sakate haiM ki-"anekAnta" aneka nAma isake ho sakate haiN| kucha vyakti "ane- aneka dharmAtmaka padArtha svarUpa "vAcya" hai, aur| 548 kusuma abhinandana grantha : pariziSTa 06 sAdhvIratna kusumavatI abhinandana grantha AB3 For Puvate & Personal Use Only
Page #2
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ syAdvAda usakA vAcaka hai| vastutaH "anekAnta- unhoMne "saptabhaMgI" nAma diyA hai| aura isakI mAra vAda" aura "syAdvAda" meM, yaha sUkSma antara banatA paribhASA, eka rAya hokara isa prakAra kI haihI nahIM hai| yaha antara tabhI bana pAtA hai, jaba hama "praznavazAdekatra vastUnyavirodhena vidhi pratiSedha "anekAnta" ke sAtha "vAda" zabda na joDe / kalpanA "sptbhNgii"| saptAnAM 'bhaMgAnA' samA hAraH sptbhNgii| -itivaa| "pravacanasAra" kI manyatA ke anusAra "syA- hAra dvAda" vaha siddhAnta hai. jisameM paraspara viruddha dharmoM jaina dArzanika mAnate haiM ki kisI bhI eka vasta kA samanvaya vibhinna apekSAoM ke sAtha mukhyatA meM, sAta prakAra ke hI saMzaya, prazna utpanna hote haiM / ma aura gauNatA ke AdhAra para kiyA jAtA hai| jaise kyoMki, vastu meM sAta dharmoM kI hI, pramANoM ke anu- Ike eka nyAyAdhIza, apanI sUkSma vivekitA ke sAra siddhi hotI hai / ataH ina dharmoM se sambandhita AdhAra para niSpakSa nirNaya dene kA mahatvapUrNa kArya praznoM, jijJAsAoM ke utpanna hone para ina praznoM e mA sampanna karatA hai, usI taraha vibhinna vicAroM meM ke samAdhAna hetu sAta prakAra ke hI uttara apekSita | samanvaya sAdhane ke lie, nyAyAdhIza jaisA hI kArya hote haiM / ina sAta uttara vAkyoM ko hI 'saptabhaMgI' "syAdvAda" nibhAtA hai| isI AdhAra para syAvAda ke zabda ke dvArA kahA gayA hai| kinta ina sAtoM vizeSajJa vidvAna isa zabda kI paribhASA isa prakAra vAkyoM meM arthAt pratyeka vAkya meM 'eva'-hI zabda karate haiM-"apane aura dasaroM ke vicAroM meM, matoM kA prayoga karanA Avazyaka ho jAtA hai| aura, meM, aura kAryoM meM unakI mUla-bhAvanAoM kA sama- pratyeka vacana, kathana meM, eka-'apekSA' vizeSa nvaya karanA "syAdvAda" hai| isa paribhASA ko nihita hone ke kAraNa, usake sUcaka 'syAt' zabda spaSTa karate hue AcArya amRtacandra ne sundara zabda kA prayoga bhI pratyeka vAkya meM anivAryataH karanA citra prastuta kiyA hai hogA / anyathA 'ghaTa' kA vivecaka vAkya, 'paTa' kA vivecaka bhI ho sakatA hai, yaha khatarA paidA ho IKS ekanAkarSantI zlathayantI vastutatva mitareNa / / jaayegaa| ina sAta uttara vAkyoM arthAt sAta antena jayati jainI nItirmanthAnanetramiva gopii| bhaMgoM ke prakAra nimnalikhita hote haiMisa paribhASA ko aSTasahasrIkAra ne ina 1. syAdastyeva ghaTaH, zabdoM meM vyakta kiyA hai-pratyakSAdi pramANA 2. syAnnAstyeva ghaTaH, vikaddhAnekAtmaka vastu pratipAdakaH zrutaskandhAtmako 3. syAdasti-nAstyeva ghaTaH syaadvaadH"| 4. syAdavaktavya eva ghaTaH ye paribhASAe~ spaSTa karato haiM ki "anekAnta- 5. syAdastyavaktavya eva ghaTaH vAda" aura "syAdvAda ke zAbdika arthoM kA bheda, 6. syAnnAstyavaktavya eva ghaTaH koI artha nahIM rakhatA / yahI tathya isa bAta se bhI 7. syAdastinAstyavaktavya eva ghaTa: spaSTa ho jAtA hai ki jaina dArzanikoM ne ina donoM inameM se prathama vAkya meM 'ghaTa' apane dravya-kSetrazabdoM se abhivyakta padArtha ke svarUpa vivecana ke kAla-bhAva kI apekSA se ghaTa hI hai| na ki 'paTa' lie jo eka zailI/paddhati sunizcitta kI hai, use Adi anya kuch| dUsare vAkya meM, 'ghaTa' para-dravya 1 pravacanasAra 2/7 2 AptamImAMsA 104 3 puruSArtha siddha yupAya / 546 // kusuma abhinandana grantha : pariziSTa 0640 sAdhvIratna kusumavatI abhinandana grantha Jan Education International or Private & Personal Use Only v.jainsusary.org
Page #3
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ 000000000000000000000000000 kSetra-kAla-bhAva kI apekSA se (para-rUpa) nahIM hI tatva meM aneka dharma haiN| ye dharma hara samaya, vastu meM hai| jabaki tIsare vAkya meM 'ghaTa' apane dravya-kSetra- vidyamAna rahate haiM / jaba, kisI eka apekSA se vastu kAla-bhAva kI aura para-dravya-kSetra-kAla-bhAva tatva ke bodha kI AvazyakatA hotI hai, taba bhI kI bhI kramika apekSAoM se, kramazaH 'ghaTarUpa hI hai| usameM anya sAre dharma vidyamAna rahate haiM / ina dUsare paTa Adi anya rUpa nahIM hai|' kintu yahI donoM dharmoM kI apekSAe~ vAMchita apekSA ke sAtha sambaddha apekSAe~ yugapat eka sAtha utpanna ho jAyeM, taba hokara apane uttara na mA~gane laga jAyeM, yaha bacAne unakA samAdhAna bhASA ke vaza ke bAhara ho jAtA meM hI 'syAta' zabda ke anivArya prayoga kI sArthakatA hai| isIlie use 'avaktavya'-'akathanIya' hI hai, nihita hai / yaha kahA jAtA hai| caturtha vacana kA yahI Azaya bhAratIya dArzanikoM ne syAdvAda kI sApekSatA 5 hai| yahIM se yaha spaSTa hotA hai ki maulika rUpa se ko sahaja hI svIkAra kara liyA hai, kintu pazcimI to prathama tIna hI bhaMgoM kI sArthakatA hai / zeSa bhaMgoM vidvAnoM ne bhI isakI upAdeyatA ko kama mahatva kI utpatti; inhIM tInoM se sambaddha apekSAoM ke nahIM die + nahIM diyaa| sammizraNa se hotI hai| ____ isIlie pazcimI aura bhAratIya kaI ukta sAta kathana-vAkyoM meM 'eva' zabda kA vidvAnoM ne isa siddhAnta kI spaSTatA, sahajatA aura prayoga isalie kiyA gayA hai ki vAkya kA artha kaThinatA ko bhI siddha karane ke lie apanI-apanI 'ghaTa' kA hI bodha karAye, paTa Adi kA nahIM / yadi lekhaniyA~ uThAI haiN| hAlAMki isa siddhAnta kI EARST isa 'eva' zabda kA prayoga na kiyA jAye to, jisa AlocanA zaMkarAcArya jI ne paryApta kI thii| para, taraha apane dravya-kSetra-kAla-bhAva kI apekSA se 'ghaTa' unakI isa AlocanA ke aucitya para prayAga vizva ke astitva kA bodha hotA hai, usI taraha para dravya- vidyAlaya ke tatkAlIna kUlapati DA0 gaMgAnAtha jhA kSetra-kAla-bhAva ko apekSA kI bhI avasara mila dvArA kI gaI TippaNI vizeSa ullekhanIya mAnI jA C) jAne se ghaTa, astitvavAn rahate hue bhI 'paTa' ke sakatI hai| ve likhate haiM-jaba maiMne zaMkarAcArya jI astitva kA bodha bhI hone laga jAyegA / yaha avya- dvArA kie gae jaina siddhAnta kA khaNDana par3hA, tabhI vasthA, tatva bodha meM na hone pAye; isIlie vAkya- mujhe yaha vizvAsa ho gayA thA ki isa siddhAnta meM Sil bhaMga meM 'eva' zabda kA prayoga kiyA jAnA anivArya bahata kucha (sAra) honA cAhie, jise vedAnta ke Milf mAnA gayA hai| jJAtA AcArya ne ThIka se nahIM smjhaa| maiMne aba isI prakAra pratyeka vAkya meM 'syAt' zabda kA taka jaina-darzana kA jo bhI, jitanA adhyayana kiyA ERIAL prayoga karanA bhI Avazyaka ho jAtA hai| kyoMki hai, usake AdhAra para maiM yaha dRr3ha vizvAsapUrvaka kahara yaha 'syAt' zabda eka apekSA vizeSa kA jJAna sakatA hU~ ki yadi zaMkarAcArya mahodaya ne jaina darzana / karAtA hai| ke maulika granthoM ko dekhane kA kaSTa kiyA hotA, jisase, yaha jJAna bhI hotA hai ki vastu-tatva to unheM syAdvAda siddhAnta kA virodha karane kA / meM aura bhI apekSAe~ haiN| ina aneka apekSAoM avasara na miltaa| kA ahasAsa karAne ke lie hI 'syAt' zabda kI DA. jhA kI ukta TippaNI se yaha spaSTa jJAta anivArya prayogatA rakhI gaI hai| cUki vastu- hotA hai ki zaMkarAcArya mahodaya ne syAdvAda ke usa FRN 1 tatvArtharAjavArtika 1/16/5 2 janadarzana (sAptAhika) 16/6/34 550 kusuma abhinandana grantha : pariziSTa sAdhvIratna kusumavatI abhinandana grantha FOP Private & Personal Use Only
Page #4
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ kaThinatama pakSa ko hI dekhA, jisake lie yaha siddhAnta vizva meM prasiddha hai / eka hI vastu meM utpatti, vinAza aura dhrauvya jaise paraspara virodhI dharmoM kI sattA kaise ho sakatI hai / yaha hai isa siddhAnta kI jaTilatA / isI jaTilatA ko lakSya kara, bahuta se vidvAnoM ne isa siddhAnta kI jamakara AlocanAe~ kI haiM / kintu yahI tathya, jaba paraspara virodhI dharmoM kI upasthiti, eka hI padArtha meM mAnane jaisI bAta, sAmAnya vyaktiyoM kI samajha meM nahIM A sakatI, taba, unhoMne isI siddhAnta kI vivecanA, itane sarala zabdoM meM kara DAlI ki choTe se choTA bAlaka taka binA kisI zrama ke AsAnI se samajha le / jaise, eka svarNakAra sone ke ghar3e ko tor3akara, sone kA mukuTa banA rahA hai / isI samaya usake pAsa tIna grAhaka A jAte haiN| inameM se eka grAhaka sone kA ghar3A kharIdanA cAhatA thA, to dUsarA sone kA mukuTa kharIdane kI icchA lekara AyA thA, jaba ki tIsare ko svarNa kI AvazyakatA thI / usa svarNakAra kI kriyA pravRtti ko dekhakara pahale grAhaka ko kaSTa kA anubhava huA, to dUsare ko prasannatA bhI huI, jabaki tIsare grAhaka ke mana meM kaSTa aura prasannatA jaisA kucha bhI 'anubhava nahIM huaa| vaha usa svarNakAra ko taTastha bhAva se dekhatA rahA / aisA kyoM huA ? isakA kAraNa yaha hai ki prathama grAhaka svarNaghaTa kharIdanA cAhatA thA, parantu svarNakAra ko sone kA ghar3A tor3ate hue dekhakara use kaSTa kA anubhava honA sahaja hI hai / dUsarA grAhaka usI svarNakAra ko apanI manacAhI vastu - svarNamukuTa banAte hue dekhakara prasannatA anubhava kare, yaha bhI ekadama sahaja hI hai / tIsarA grAhaka, sonA hI cAhatA thA ataH 1 AptamImAMsA 56 / 60 svarNaM ghaTa ko tor3ane se yA svarNa mukuTa banAne se, use apanI icchita vastu pAne meM koI pharka nahIM par3atA thA / isalie usakI taTasthatA bhI sahaja mAnI AnegI / isa udAharaNa kA abhiprAya yaha hai- eka hI padArtha - " svarNa" meM, eka hI samaya meM, eka vyakti "vinAza" ko hotA huA dekha rahA hai, to dUsarA "utpatti" ko, aura tIsarA "dhrauvya" ko / tInoM hI dazAe~; paraspara virodhI haiM, phira bhI eka hI samaya meM, eka hI padArtha meM yaha bhI pAyI jAtI haiM / isI taraha, vizva kI pratyeka vastu meM, eka hI samaya meM, eka sAtha tInoM sthitiyA~ rahatI haiM / isI tathya ko jainadArzanikoM ne vastu mAtra kI " triguNAtmakatA" kahA hai, aura yaha triguNAtmakatA vastumAtra kA sahaja-svabhAva hai / isI taraha vastu mAtra meM bhinna apekSAoM se anekoM paraspara virodhI dharma, eka samaya meM eka sAtha bane rahate haiM / ukta udAharaNa syAdvAda kI sahajatA, saralatA kA dyotaka hai / vAstavikatA yaha hai ki " syAdvAda" ukta udAharaNa se bhI adhika sarala hai / itanA sarala ki- rAstA calate samaya koI bAlaka Apa se syAdvAda ke bAre meM prazna pUcha le to bhI Apa ArAma se samajhA skeN| saMyogavaza, eka jainAcArya mahodaya ke sAtha aisI hI sthiti, A bhI gaI / vihAra-yAtrA meM sar3aka mArga se jAte hue, unheM kisI bAlaka ne pUchA - "bhagavan ! ApakA syAdvAda kyA hai ?" AcArya ne apane eka hAtha kI 'kaniSThA' aura "anAmikA" / uMgaliyoM ko Upara uThAkara, usa bAlaka se pUchA - " batalAo vatsa ! ina u~galiyoM meM kauna uMgalI bar3I hai ?" kusuma abhinandana grantha : pariziSTa sAdhvIratna kusumavatI abhinandana grantha 551
Page #5
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ bAlaka ne uttara diyA - "anAmikA" | aba AcArya ne kaniSThA ke sthAna para 'madhyamA' ko "anAmikA" ke sAtha Upara uThAyA, aura bAlaka se punaH pUchA - "aba batalAo, ina donoM uMgaliyoM meM kauna u~galI choTI hai ?" bAlaka ne uttara diyA- 'anAmikA" / yaha uttara sunakara AcArya ne use samajhAyA jisa taraha tumane eka hI u~galI ko "bar3A" ora "choTA" kahA, usI taraha yaha " syAdvAda" bhI eka hI padArtha meM sthita, paraspara virodhI dharmoM kI bAta batalAtA hai / " AcArya kI bAta sunakara bAlaka ha~satA huA calA gayA / yahI hai isa siddhAnta kI sahajatA / saralatA, jo kisI bhI vidvAna kA dhyAna apanI aura varavaza AkRSTa kara letI hai / "syAdAda" siddhAnta meM nayoM kI bahumukhI vivakSA hamezA hI rahatI hai| kyoMki jisa kisI bhI padArtha kA, jo arthasvarUpa, syAdvAda dvArA alaga karake vivakSita kiyA jAtA hai, usI artha / svarUpa kI abhivyanjanA karane vAle "naya" hote haiM / " nIyate - sAdhyate gamyate mAno'rthaH yena" - isa vyutpatti se "naya" kA uttama ukta svarUpa hI spaSTa hotA hai / ye " naya" sAta haiM / inhIM para "syAdvAda" kA yA saptabhaMgoM kA AdhAra sthita hai| ye sAta naya hai : - naigama, saMgraha, vyavahAra, RjusUtra, zabda, samabhirUr3ha aura evambhUta / ukta sAtoM nayoM ko mUlataH do vibhAgoM meM vibhAjita kiyA gayA hai-' dravyArthika" aura "paryAyArthika" / kucha AcAryoM ne " naigama" aura "saMgraha" ko dravyAthika ke antargata mAnA hai jabaki kucha AcArya mAtra " naigama" ko hI " dravyArthika" ke antargata mAnate haiM / dravyArthika naya, mAtra 1 AptaparIkSA 108 2 dravyAnuyogatarkaNA 552 kusuma abhinandana grantha : pariziSTa "sAmAnya" kA hI guNa grahaNa karatA hai, isalie isake antargata vastutaH kevala naigama kA hI samAveza mAnanA ucita hogA / paryAyArthika naya, bheda vivakSAoM ko, aura "vizeSa" ko bhI grahaNa karatA hai / ataH zeSa chaH hI nayoM ko, isake antarbhUta mAnA jAtA hai / ina sAta nayoM ke anya upabheda bahuta haiM / unakA sAmAnya vivecana bhI yahA~ vistAra kA kAraNa bana sakatA hai / kintu inhIM sAtoM nayoM ko eka dUsarI apekSA se "nizcayanaya" aura "vyavahAranaya" ke bhedoM, upabhedoM ke rUpa meM vibhAjita aura vyavahRta kiyA jAtA hai / isalie inake sambandha meM bhI, kucha kahanA ucita hI hogA / " syAdvAda" siddhAnta kA vyAvahArika upayoga karate samaya, vastutaH nayoM ke "nizcaya" aura "vyavahAra" bhedoM kI hI vizeSa apekSA pratIta hotI hai ! kyoMki, saptabhaMgI ke sandarbha meM jo bhI prAsaMgika viziSTa apekSAe~ jAgRta hotI haiM, una kA mukhya sambandha "nizcaya" va vyavahAra se hI jur3atA hai / kyoMki, pratyeka dravya vyavahAra meM hameM jaisA dikhalAI par3atA hai, vastutaH vaha vaisA hotA nahIM / usake aura bhI anekoM rUpa hote haiM, ho sakate haiM, yaha batalAne vAlA naya hai- "nizcayanaya" / isI tathya ko AcAryoM ne isa paMkti meM vyakta kiyA hai"tatvArtha nizcayo vakti vyavahArazca janoditam 12 isa kathana ko nimnalikhitaH udAharaNa se spaSTa samajhA jA sakatA hai / eka bAra bhagavAn mahAvIra se pUcha gayA"bhagavan ! phANita pravAhI gur3a meM kitane varNarasagandha hote haiM ? bhagavAna ne uttara diyA- 'vyavahAra meM to mAtra 'madhura' rasa hI usameM meM hai, yaha kahA sAdhvIratna kusumavatI abhinandana grantha
Page #6
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ KO jAyegA kintu nizcayanaya kI apekSA se usameM kI sampUrNatA kA jJAna nahIM karAtA, na hI usakA pAMcoM varNa, donoM gaMdha, pA~coM rasa, aura AThoM sparza kevala 'dIrghatva' usake sampUrNa svarUpa kA paricAyaka hote haiN| bana pAtA hai / balki, ina donoM svarUpoM kA sammiisa uttara kA Azaya yaha hai ki vasta kA jo lita rUpa hI Amraphala ke samagra-svarUpa kA dyotakA svarUpa indriyagrAhya hotA hai, vaha jisa taraha kA bAdhaka banatA hai| hotA hai, usase bhinna prakAra kA usakA vAstavika isalie sva-dravya, kSetra, kAla-bhAva kI / svarUpa hotA hai| apekSA se aura para-dravya, kSetra kAla bhAva kI hama saba usI bAhya svarUpa ko dekha pAte apekSA se bhI vastu kA jo svarUpa nizcita hotA 1 haiM, jo indriyagrAhya hotA hai| sarvajJa to nizcaya hai vahI svarUpa, vastu mAtra kA vAstavika svarUpa rUpa meM, usake 'bAhya' aura 'Abhyantara' donoM hotA hai| ho svarUpoM ko dekhate jAnate haiM / sApekSavAda isI vAstavika svarUpa ko vyAkhyA karane ke adhiSThAtA DA0 alabarTa AiMsTIna ne bhI apanA ke lie dArzanika jagata kA eka mAtra siddhAnta / Azaya isI taraha kA vyakta kiyA hai / ve kahate haiM- 'syAdvAda' hI hai| yaha na kevala loka vyavahAra ko 'hama to kevala ApekSika satya ko hI jAnate haiN| varan padArtha mAtra ko apanA viSaya banAtA hai| / sampUrNa satya ko to sarvajJa hI jAnate haiN| cU ki, 'syAdvAda' zabda meM 'syAta' zabda ko rASTrabhASA sarvajJa kA jJAna, 'kevalajJAna' hotA hai, isalie vaha hindI ke 'zAyada' zabda kA paryAyavAcI mAnakara 'pUrNajJAna' bhI hotA hai| isI kAraNa vaha dravya kucha vidvAnoM ne ise 'saMzayavAda' kI saMjJA do hai, kI samasta vivakSAoM ko bhalI-bhA~ti jAnate haiN| to kucha vidvAnoM ne ise saptabhaMgI vAkyoM meM Aye ___vastu/padArtha kI sApekSatA ko svIkAra karane ke asti-nAsti' zabdoM kA artha hI sahI sandarbha meM na lie hI syAdvAda siddhAnta ke antargata saptabhaMgoM samajhakara ise 'anizcitatAvAda' kI saMjJA pradAna kA pratipAdana kiyA gayA hai| isake binA kisI kI hai| bhI padArtha ke svarUpa ko pUrNatA prApta nahIM ho isa taraha kI zaMkAyeM, unhIM vyaktiyoM dvArA sktii| jaise, Ama kA eka phala apane se bar3e uThAI jAtI haiM, jo Alocya siddhAnta ke marma ko AkAra vAle phala kI apekSA se 'choTA hotA hai, samajha binA hI, sva-icchita rUpa se, kucha bhI kaha aura apane se choTe phala kI apekSA se 'bar3A' bhI dete haiM / vastutaH ina donoM hI zaMkAoM ko pUrvahotA hai| likhita vizleSaNoM ke anusAra, sira uThAne kA donoM apekSAoM ko dRSTi se Ama ke phala avasara hI nahIM miltaa| vaise bhI jina jainetara meM 'laghutva' aura 'dIrghatva' donoM hI rUpoM ko vidvAnoM ne isake marma ko AtmasAt kiyA hai, ve jaba svIkAra kiyA jAyegA tabhI Ama kA svarUpa dRDhatA ke sAtha, yaha kahane meM bhI saMkoca nahIM karate pUrA mAnA jAegA kyoMki, kevala laghutva Ama phala ki 'syAdvAda' hI jainadarzana kA hRdaya hai| 1 kosmolojI olDa eNDa nyU / 553 2. kusuma abhinandana grantha : pariziSTa sAdhvIratna kusumavatI abhinandana grantha Jan Education Internatione Por Private & Personal Use Only v.jainenery.org