Nirgrantha-3

SR No.: 522703
Original Sutra Author: N/A
Author: M A Dhaky, Jitendra B Shah
Publisher: Shardaben Chimanbhai Educational Research Centre
Publication Year: 2002
Total Pages: 396
Language: English, Hindi, Gujarati
Classification: Magazine, India_Nirgrantha, & India
File Size: 11 MB

Page 82

Vol. III, 1997-2002
The << True Vaisnava >>.....
63
3. The formula Pida paräi jāne is also found in the Barvai n.79 of the poem 'Barvai' in Early
Hindi of Rahim (1536-1627): Pira paräi jänai "who can perceive another's pain", cf. R. Snell, " 'Barvai' Metre in Tulsidās and Rahim," Studies in South Asian Devotional Literature Eds. A. W. Entwiste and F. Mallison, New Delhi-Paris 1994, 394. kacha : M. A. Mehendale (Saṁskrti, 26-7, Ahmedabad 1972, 219-220) proposes to understand kācha as "act, deed" and not as "body" or "sex" as it is often translated, duplicating the meaning of the following stanza. He proposes the etymology: Skt. krtya > Pkt. kacca >
Guj. kāca or kārya > kāja > kāca. 5. Ekotera : according to H. Bhayani in "Sabdaprayogoni pagadandī," Forbes Gujarati Sabhā
Traimāsika, 54-2, Bombay 1989, 93 : “bādotera so, bilamtara so," ekotera is to be read as ekotara so (i.e. as a Sanskrit copy of ekottara sata) and to be translated into Gujarati as so upara eka 'one plus one hundred' or 'one hundred and one and not as ekotera, usually
translated as 'seventy one'. 6. Ch. Vaudeville, L'Invocation, le Haripath de Dñandev, Paris 1969, 62-65. 7. Ch. Vaudeville, Kabir, Oxford 1974, 99. 8. The Svāmi-nārāyaṇi sect is a Krishnaite movement which was founded at the beginning
of the 19th century and which subsequently developed Guru worship in a separate
branch. It always showed a strong reformist and puritanical tendency. 9. K. K. Shastri, Narasimha Maheto, eka adhyayana, Ahmedabad 1971, 263. 10. Vaisnavajana was even compared with the Bible's Ten Commandments by M. H. Bhatt in
"Vaisnavajana to tene kahiye,” Narasimha Mahetā āsvāda ane svādhyāya, Ed. R. Chaudhari,
Bombay 1988, 296. 11. See below Conclusion. 12. Shastri, Narasimha Maheto, 264 and S. Jesalpura, "Vaisnavajananun pada Narasimhanun
che, e više śamkā nathī,” Forbes Gujarati Sabhā Traimāsika, 49-1, Bombay 1984, 78f. 13. M. B. Vyas, Vimalaprabandha, Surat 1913, Introduction, 44. 14. See M. Lath, "Bhajan as Song : Towards an Oral Stemma of Namdev's padas", Bhakti in
Current Research, 1979-1982, Ed. M. Thiel-Horstmann, Berlin 1983, 231-233. 15. Shastri, Narasimha Maheto, 263. 16. Ed. I. S. Desai, Brhat Kävyadohana, IV, Bombay 1890, 247-288. 17. K. K. Shastri, Kavicaritra (bhāga 1-2), Ahmedabad 1952, 318-323; R. Sh. Desai, Prācīna
kavio ane temani krtio, Baroda repr. 1977, 414. 18. A third one is actually mentioned by K. M. Munshi, Narasiṁhayuganā kavio, Bombay
1962, 111. 19. Ed. Desai, Brhat Kävyadohana, IV, 199-246. 20. Shastri, Kavicaritra, 356-361; Desai, Prācīna kavio.,300. It was not possible to consult the
manuscript published by M. B. Vyas, but it would be interesting to check whether Vacho was not misread (or eventually miscopied) instead of Narachaio, one of the possible