Minority Benefits

SR No.: 034376
Original Sutra Author: N/A
Author: Babita Jain
Publisher: Shrut Samvardhan Samsthan
Publication Year: 2017
Total Pages: 250
Language: English
Classification: Book_English
File Size: 13 MB

Page 50

(i) that the educational institution was established by a member/members of the
religious minority community; (ii) that the educational institution was established for the benefit of the minority
community; and (iii) that the educational institution is being administered by the minority
community. The aforesaid facts may be proved either by direct or circumstantial evidence. There must be some positive index to enable the educational institution to be identified with religious minorities. There should be nexus between the means employed and the ends desired. If the minority educational institution concerned is being run by a trust or a registered society, then majority of the trustees of the trust or members of the society, as the case may be, must be from the minority community and the trust deed/ Articles of Association or any other document duly executed in this regard must reflect the objective of sub-serving the interest of the minority community. In the absence of any documentary evidence some clear or cogent evidence must be produced to prove the aforesaid facts. There is no bar to the members of other communities to extend their help to the member of a minority community to establish an educational institution of its choice. (See S.K. Patro vs. State of Bihar AIR 1970 SC 259).
As has been held by the Madras High Court in T.K.V.T.S.S. Medical Educational & Charitable Trust vs. State of Tamil Nadu AIR 2002 Madras 42 that a minority status can not be conferred on a minority educational institution for particular period to be renewed periodically like a driving license. It is not open for the State Government to review its earlier order conferring minority status on a minority educational institution unless it is shown that the institution concerned has suppressed any material fact while passing the order of conferral of minority status or there is fundamental change of circumstances warranting cancellation of the earlier order. Reference may, in this connection, be made to the following observations of their lordships:
"...............In conclusion, we hold that if any entity is once declared as minority entitling to the rights envisaged under Article 30(1) of the Constitution of India, unless there is fundamental change of circumstances or suppression of facts the Government has no power to take away that cherished constitutional right which is a fundamental right and that too, by an ordinary letter without being preceded by a fair hearing in conformity with the principles of natural justice."
(emphasis supplied) It is now well settled that any administrative order involving civil consequences has to be passed strictly in conformity with the principles of natural justice (Sec AIR 1978 S.C. 851). If any order relating to cancellation of minority status granted to a minority educational institution has been passed without affording an opportunity of being heard to such educational institution, it gets vitiated.
y Benefits