Page #1
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ Views on Ahimsa, Compassion, and Samyaktva in Jainism KRISTI L. WILEY University of California at Berkeley Ahimsa appears to be the central theme of Mahavira's teachings. As Padmanabh S. Jaini has observed, there is a "preoccupation with ahimsa" within Jainism, for no other religious tradition "has carried it [ahimsa] to the extreme of the Jainas. For them it is not simply the first among virtues but the virtue..." Although in most other religious traditions violence is usually associated with causing harm to other living beings, Jaini has noted that "for Jainas, however, it (himsa] refers primarily to injuring oneselfto behavior which inhibits the soul's ability to attain moksa." This focus on one's own spiritual progress as an important motivating factor for observing ahimsa has been mentioned by other authors as well. For example, Ronald Huntington, the late professor of religion and and the co-director of Albert Schweitzer Institute at Chapman University, has written that Jainism "expands Albert Schweitzer's famous concept of reverence for 'Padmanabh S. Jaini, The Jaina l'ath of Purification (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1979), p. 167. ? The reasoning is that intentional harm to other living beings is motivated by passions (kasayas), which cause the binding of unwholesome varicties (papa prakrtis) of karmic matter to one's own soul. These karmas cause rebirth in undesirable states of existence that are characterized by a preponderance of suffering and prolong the soul's journey in samsara. Jaini, op. cit., p. 167, For Private & Persold Use Only
Page #2
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ Kristi Wiley, "Ahimsa, Compassion and Samyaktva" life into reverence for the entire universe" and that it "has affinities with Gandhi's non-violent campaigns of satyagraha (truth-force)" and with the writings of St. Francis of Assisi. He concludes that "it would be entirely wrong, however, to see ahimsa in any sentimental light. The Jain doctrine of non-injury is based on rational consciousness, not emotional compassion; on individual responsibility, not on a social fellow-feeling. ... The motive in Jainism is self-centered and entirely for the purpose of individual kaivalya. And yet, though the emphasis is on personal liberation, the Jain ethic makes that goal attainable only through consideration for others." In other writings however, a different view of ahimsa and compassion in Jainism has been expressed. For instance, in an essay entitled "Environmental Wisdom in Ancient India" L. M. Singhvi describes the "ecological philosophy of Jainism" as being "virtually synonymous with the principle of ahimsa." He states: Compassion and reverence for life are the sheet-anchor of the Jain quest for peace, harmony, and rectitude, based on spiritual and physical symbiosis and a sense of responsibility and restraint. The term ahimsa is stated in the negative (a = non, himsa = violence), but it is rooted in a host of positive aims and actions which have great relevance to contemporary environmental concerns. It is a principle of compassion and responsibility, ... Compassion and non-violence are the basis of the ancient Jain scriptural aphorism Parasparopagraha Jivandm (all life is bound together by the mutual support of interdependence.)' R. Huntington, Jainism and Ethics," www.chapman.edu/schweitzer/huntington.html (December 15, 2001). The essay was intended to be a chapter in a textbook of world religions that he was preparing at the time of his death. It appears on The Albert Schweitzer Institute's website via a link called "Readings on Reverence for Life." * Singhvi at http://www.ccomall.com/greenshopping/castgreen.htm.
Page #3
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ Lessons of Ahimsa and Anekania for Contemporary Life A similar view of ahimsa and compassion is found on a web page of Jain pilgrimages: "Jainism has become synonymous with ahimsa. Ahimsa (non-violence) occupies the supreme place in Jainism. ... Compassion (daya) is the guiding force of nonviolence. It is the positive way of life. It has been assigned an equally high place in Jainism- 'Daya dharma ka mala' (Compassion is the basis of religion)."S These writings are reflective of different views regarding compassion in Jainism. In writing about Jain views of ecology in the West, Anne Vallely has observed that "in the diaspora community . . . asceticism is being de-emphasized so that teachings of compassion and non-violence are no longer anchored to a renunciatory worldview. Jain teachings are being redefined according to a different ethical charter altogether one in which active engagement in the world is encouraged."6 Is this diversity of opinion indicative of a shift in thought regarding compassion itself? In this regard, it would be instructive to examine views regarding compassion that are found in some classical Jain texts that emphasize renunciation and asceticism. First, let us examine statements in the Tattvarthasutra (TS), a text accepted by both Svetambaras and Digambaras. In T$ 6.12, compassion (unukampa) is listed as one of the causes of the influx of sata-vedaniya karma (the karma that causes pleasant bodily feelings), along with giving (dana), asceticism with attachment (saraga-samyama), concentration (voga), equanimity (ksanti), and purity or freedom from greed (sauca). Here, and in other 5 http://www.jainpilgrimages.com/general/mahavir.htm (December 15, 2001). * Anne Vallely, "From Liberation to Ecology: Ethical Discourses among Orthodox and Diaspora Jains," in Christopher Key Chapple (ed.), Jainism and Ecolog: (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2002), pp. 193-216. ? Muni Shri Mishrimal Maharaj (trans.), Karmagrantha of Devendrasuri, 6 vols. (Beawar, Rajasthan: Shri Marudharakesari Sahitya Prakashana Samiti, 1974-1976): 1.55. Here compassion is associated with the binding of suta-vedaniya karma. For Private & Perso1 2. Use Only
Page #4
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ Kristi Wiley, "Ahimsa, Compassion and Samyaktva" passages related to compassion, the commentators gloss anukampa as "daya" or "ghrna," "compassion, pity, sympathy, or tenderness towards others." Compassion is "maitri," or "friendliness towards others." A compassionate person is one whose heart is full of the feeling of kindness for the afflictions (pida) of others, as if this suffering were one's own. Another interpretation of compassion, that of giving to others, is offered by the Svetambara commentator Siddhasenagani. "When one gives food, water, clothing, utensils, shelter, and so forth to the afflicted, the poor, and beggars who have not renounced the household life, and to mendicants as well, there are fruits in the form of disassociation of various types of karmic matter. This brings about knowledge, faith, and conduct. Or, giving is showing compassion. It is viewing the suffering of others as if it were one's own. Dana is giving away with the intent or wish of showing kindness or giving assistance to others." Compassion is discussed by the commentators in association with TS 1.2, where samyak-darsana is defined as "belief in substances as they really are." Here, four indicative signs of samyak-darsana are listed as prasama (calmness), samvega (uneasiness with worldly existence), anukampa (compassion), and astikya (belief in the existents such as the soul, non-soul, and so forth). Since compassion is associated with a proper view of reality (samyaktva), it is not surprising that karunya is listed among the contemplations (bhavanas) that strengthen all five vows (TS 7.6 SS 7.11). This sutra reads: "Friendliness (maitri) towards all living beings, delight (pramoda) in the distinction and honor of others, compassion (karunya) for the afflicted (klisyamana), and equanimity (madhystha) towards the ill-mannered [should be contemplated]." = 8 Umasvati, Tattvartha Sura with Svopajna-bhasya and commentary by Siddhasenagani, 2 vols., (Devachanda Lalbhai Jain Pustakoddhar Fund, Series nos. 67 and 76, 1926-30): 6.13.
Page #5
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ Lessons of Ahimsa and Anekanta for Contemporary Life Here, in the Sarvarthasiddhi (SS) the Digambara commentator Pujyapada defines karunya as "a disposition (bhava) to render assistance (anugraha) to the afflicted or those who suffer pain or anguish due to the rise of asata-vedaniya karma. He concludes that "He who conducts himself in this manner is able to practice non-violence and other vows to perfection." 19 Thus, according to the commentators on the Tattvarthasutra, compassion may be expressed either passively or actively: by viewing the suffering of others as if it were one's own or by rendering assistance to those who are afflicted. The definitions for compassion in these commentaries are similar to those in the Oxford English Dictionary: (1) Compassion is suffering together with another, participation in suffering, fellowfeeling, sympathy. It is (2) the feeling or emotion, when a person is moved by the suffering or distress of another and by the desire to relieve it; pity that inclines to spare or to succour. 10 Compassion is discussed in a variety of texts in the context of appropriate mendicant and lay conduct. Regarding mendicant conduct, Acaranga-sutra 11.6.5.2 states "A saint, with right intuition (samyak-darsana) who cherishes compassion for the world, in the east, west, south, and north, should preach, spread, and praise (the faith), knowing the sacred lore." Uttaradhyayana-sutra 21.13 says that "A monk should have compassion (dayanukampa) on all beings, should be of a forbearing character, should be restrained and chaste, and abstaining from everything sinful; he should live with his senses 11 9 See S. A. Jain (trans.), Pujyapada's Sarvarthasiddhi (Madras: Jwalamalini Trust, 1960, Reprint 1992). p. 195. 10 Oxford English Dictionary, (Clarendon Press, second edition, 1989). [] Ilerman Jacobi (trans.), Jaina Sutras, part 1: Translation of the Acaranga-sutra and Kalpa Sutra (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1884; reprint Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass, 1989), p. 60. For Private & Persol Use Only
Page #6
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ Kristi Wiley, "Ahimsa, Compassion and Samyaktva" under control.":12 In the Digambara Armanusasana, unlimited compassion (karunapara) is listed among the fruits of practicing severe austerities." Here, one is urged to follow the path of compassion, self-control, renunciation, and equanimity.!4 "When the shore of the ocean of the cycle of existence is close by, the fortunate man has aversion to sense-gratifications, has renounced all possessions, subjugates the passions, has tranquility, vows, self-control, practice of self-contemplation, pursuit of austerities, duly ordained mental activity, devotion to the Jinas, and compassion (dayaluta).":15 And in discussing religious virtues in the Prasamaratiprakarana, Umasvati states, "Compassion is the root of sacred doctrine (dharma). A person who is devoid of patience (aksamavan) does not show compassion. Therefore, one who is devoted to patience attains the highest dharma.")6 In some of the Sravakacara texts, which detail appropriate conduct for laity, compassion is listed as one of the qualities of an observant layperson (sravaka-guna), specifically in the context of samyaktva and in observing various lay vows. For example, Samantabhadra defines abstention from eating after dark (ratribhojana) as abandoning food by night out of compassion for 12 Herman Jacobi (trans.), Jaina Sutras, part 2: Translation of the Uttaradhyana-sutra and Sutrakrtanga Sutra (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1895; reprint Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass, 1989), p. 109. 13 Jacobi (trans.), Acaranga-sutra, op.cit., p. 68. ** Jacobi (trans.). Acaranga-salra,op. cit., p. 107. "S Jacobi (trans.), Acaranga-sutra.op. cit. p. 224. 16 Yajneshwar S. Shastri (trans.), Umasvati's Prasamaratiprakarana. L.D. Scries, 107 (Ahmedabad: L. D. Institute of Indology, 1969), p. 168. "This guna ... is of the very essence of Jainism and needs no comment." See R. Williams. Jaina Yoga: A Survey of Mediaeval Sravukacaras (London: Oxford University Press, 1963), p. 269, For Private & Persosal Use Only
Page #7
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ Lessons of Ahimsa und Anekanta for Contemporary Life living beings (jiva-daya).18 The Digambara author Asadhara, in his Sagara-dharmamrta, declares that "compassion is the root of the whole sacred doctrine." It is clear from examining selected passages in classical Jain texts that compassion is associated with appropriate conduct for both mendicants and laity. Is it possible, then, for actions undertaken by those who lack samyuk-darsana, in other words, by those who hold a false view of reality (mithyadrsti), to be informed by compassion, as understood in these textual sources? This question is addressed by the Digambara author Vidyananda in his commentary on TS 1.2. He writes that the qualities of samvega and anukumpa are not possible for those who have the wrong views or mithyadrsti. Although I have been unable to locate a similar statement on this matter in the Svetambara commentaries, there is a passage in the Svetambara Dasavaikalika-sutra that reflects a similar point of view: "First knowledge, then compassion, those who observe total restraint si.e., mendicants) live thus."*20 Therefore, according to these sources, humans, heavenly beings, and five-sensed rational animals who have attained a proper view of reality can have, and do have, compassion for others, as understood in Jainism. Although the Jain doctrine of ahimsa is based on rational consciousness or a proper view of reality (samyaktva), compassion is an appropriate expression of this spiritual progress. While it is true that spiritual progress entails individual responsibility, this does not preclude a "social fellow-feeling" of compassion. And while the ultimate goal may be individual 1 Raina-karanda-sravakacaru - v.21, as cited in Williams, op. cit., p. 108. 19 Sagara-dharmamita 1.4, as cited in Williams, op. cit., p. 42. 20Kastur Chand Lalwani (trans.), Dasavai kalika-susra (Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass, 1973), p. 10. For Private & Persolal Use Only
Page #8
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
________________ Kristi Wiley, "Ahimsa, Compassion and Samyaktva" kaivalya, spiritual progress need not be attained through total isolation from other beings in the world. The objects of one's compassion, or the ways of expressing compassion, undoubtedly have changed over the centuries in accordance with social conditions of the times. But whether acts of compassion are manifested in speaking out against animal sacrifice in Vedic ritual practices of ancient times, or in persuading others to refrain from killing animals for food or sport, or in activities associated with animal welfare and the environment in modern times, this ethical value has been an aspect of ahimsa throughout the history of Jainism. One of the best expression of this sentiment is in the practice of samayika-- the attainment of equanimity-which a Jaina aspires to achieve. Friendship towards all beings, Delight in the qualities of virtuous ones, Utmost compassion for afflicted beings, Equanimity towards those who are not well-disposed towards me, May my soul have such dispositions as these forever.21 21 As translated in Jaini , op. cit., p. 224.