Vedsamya Vaishmya

Author(s): Sukhlal Sanghavi
Publisher: Z_Darshan_aur_Chintan_Part_1_2_002661.pdf
Catalog link: https://jainqq.org/explore/229082/1

Page #1
'vedasAmya-vaiSamya' zrImAn pro0 hIrAlAlajI kI sevA meM--- . sapraNAma nivedana ! Aja maiMne 'siddhAnta-samIkSA' pUrI kara lii| abhI jitanA saMbhava thA utanI hI ekAgratA se sunatA rahA / yatra tatra prazna vicAra aura samAlocaka bhAva uThatA thA ataH cihna bhI karatA gayA; para una uThe hue praznoM, vicAroM aura samAlocaka bhAvoM ko punaH saMkalita karake likhane mere lie saMbhava nahIM / usameM jo samaya aura zakti Avazyaka hai vaha yadi mila bhI jAya tathApi usakA upayoga karane kA abhI to koI utsAha nahIM hai / aura khAsa bAta to yaha hai ki merA mana mukhyatayA aba mAnavatA ke utkarSa kA hI yicAra karatA hai| to bhI samIkSA ke bAre meM mere mana para par3I huI chApa ko saMkSepa meM likha denA isalie jarUrI hai ki maiM Apake Agraha ko mAna cukA huuN| sAmAnyatayAH Apa aura paM0 phUlacandajI donoM aise samakakSa vicAraka jAna par3hate haiM jinakA carcAyoga birala aura puNyalabhya kahA jA sakatA hai| jitanI gaharI, marmasparzI aura parizramasAdhya carcA zrApa donoM ne kI hai vaha eka khAsA zAstra hI bana gayA hai / isa carcA meM eka ora paMDita mAnasa dUsarI ora prophesara mAnasa-ye donoM paraspara viruddha kakSA vAle hone para bhI prAyaH samatva, ziSTatA, aura AdhunikatA kI bhUmikA ke Upara kAma karate hue dekhe jAte haiM / jaisA ki bahuta kama anyatra saMbhava hai / isalie vaha carcA zAstrapada ko prApta huI hai| Age jaba kabhI koI vicAra karegA taba ise anivArya rUpa se dekhanA hI par3hegA / itanA isa carcA kA tAtvika aura aitihAsika mahatva mujhako spaSTa mAlUma hotA hai / yadyapi maiM saba paNDitoM ko nahIM jAnatA tathApi jitanoM ko jAnatA hU~ unakI apekSA se kahA jA sakatA hai ki isa viSaya meM paM0 phUlacandajI kA sthAna anyoM se U~cA hai| dUsare graMthapAThI hoMge para itane adhika artha sparzI zAyada hI ho / kitanA acchA hotA yadi aise paNDita ko koI acchA pada, acchA sthAna dekara kAma liyA jAtA / yadi aise paNDita ko pUrNa svatantratA ke sAtha pUrA arthasAdhana diyA jAya to bahuta kucha zAstrIya pragati ho sakatI hai| abhI to arthapradhAna paNDita aura gRhastha aise suyogya paNDitoM ko ayogya rUpa se nicor3ate haiN| merA vaza cale to maiM aisoM kA sthAna bahuta svAdhIna kara dU~ / astu yaha to prAsaGgika bAta huii|

Page #2
jaina dharma aura darzana maiM Apako likhatA hU~ aura Apake bAre meM kucha likhU to koI zAyada cATu vAkya samajhe; para maiM to kabhI cATukAra nahIM aura badaprakRti bhI nhiiN| isalie jaisA samajhatA hU~ likha detA huuN| jainetara vidvAnoM meM to karmazAstra vipayaka gahare jJAna kI apekSA hI nahIM rakhI jA sakatI; para jaina aura unameM bhI prophesara meM aise gahare jJAna ko DhU~DhanA nirAza honA hai jitanA Apake lekhoM meM vyakta hotA hai| niHsaMdeha aApane karmatattva kA prAkaNTha pAna hI nahIM manana bhI kiyA jAna par3atA hai| anyathA paM0 phUlacaMdajI ke zAstrIya aura sopapacika lekhoM kA javAba denA aura so bhI atyanta gaharAI aura pRthakkaraNa ke sAtha saMbhava nhiiN| sthiti aisI jAna par3atI hai ki karmazAstra viSayaka jitanA pANDitya paNDita meM ho utanA hI vizada pANDitya eka prophesara ke lekha vyakta karate haiM / donoM kI vicAra saraNiyA~ aura dalIleM dekhatA hU~ to yaha nizcayapUrvaka antimarUpa se kahanA to abhI kaThina hai ki kauna eka vizeSa grAhya hai ? khAsa karake jaba yaha carcA eka yA dUsare rUpa se sAmpradAyikatA ke sAtha jur3a jAtI hai taba mauna hI acchA jAna par3atA hai| to bhI taTasthabhAva se dekhane para mujhe apane vicAra meM parivartana karanA par3A hai jo maiMne karma grantha ke eka pariziSTa meM likhe hai / mujhako jAna par3atA hai ki Apako vicAra saraNI vastugAminI hai cAhe jitane zAbdika pramANa virodhI kyoM na hoN| maiM kisI zAstravAkya kA vaisA kAyala nahIM jaisA vastutattva kaa| hajAroM ke dvArA sarvathA pramANa bhUta mAne jAne vAle vAkyoM aura zAstroM ko maiM kSaNabhara meM chor3a sakatA hU~ yadi unase merI buddhi aura tarka ko saMtoSa na ho / para Apane to tarka aura buddhi svAtantrya ke alAvA zAstrIya pramANa bhI diye haiM jo bahuta mahatva ke haiN| isa dRSTi se mere para ApakI vicArasaraNI kA asara hI mukhya par3A hai| jo maiMne alpa svalpa karmazAstra viSayaka ciMtana manana kiyA hai, jo mujha meM dUsarI sahAyaka alpa svalpa dArzanika zaktiyA~ haiM, una sabako yadi maiM ekAgra kaleM aura usameM apanA asAmpradAyika saMskAra milA kara Apa donoM kI pratyeka dalIla kI gaharI chAnabIna karU~ to saMbhava hai maiM pUrA nyAya karake ekatara nirNaya bA~dha sakU~ / para saMbhava ho taba bhI aba isa ora merI ruci nahIM hai| eka to yaha viSaya itanA adhika sampradAyagata ho gayA hai ki use koI jainapakSa taTasthabhAva se kabhI nahIM dekhegA / dUsare yaha viSaya jIvanasparzI bhI nahIM / na to kisI puruSa yA strI kA mokSa honA hai aura na vaisA mokSa iSTa bhI hai| hama jisa nivRttipradhAna jaina paramparA ko sarvAGgINa aura sadA ke lie abhrAnta samajhate haiM usa paramparA ke mUla meM eka yA dUsare kAraNa se dUsarI paramparAoM kI taraha truTiyA~ bhrAntiyA~

Page #3
vedasAmya-vaiSamya 536 aura ekadezIyatA bhI raha gaI hai jo tAttvika aura aitihAsika dRSTi se dekhane para spaSTa mAlUma hotI haiN| hama janma saMskAra aura dRSTi saMkoca ke kAraNa kucha bhI kaha aura mAna nahIM sakate haiN| para sAmpradAyika mokSa kA svarUpa aura nivRtti kI kalpanA na kevala adhUrI haiM; kiMtu mAnavatA ke utkarSa meM AtmIya sadguNoM ke vyApaka vikAsa meM bahuta kucha bAdhaka bhI haiN| hamArI cirakAlIna sAmpradAyika jar3atA aura akarmaNyatA ne kevala bAhya khokhe meM aura kalpanArAzi meM jainatva bAMdha rakhA hai| aura jaina prasthAna meM jo kucha tattvataH sArabhAga hai use bhI DhAMka diyA hai| khAsa bAta to yaha hai ki hamArI nirmaryAda socane kI zakti hI sAmpra dAyika jar3atA ke kAraNa moThI ho gaI hai / aisI sthiti meM eka avyavahArya viSaya para zakti kharca karane kA utsAha kaise ho ? tathApi Apane isa viSaya para jo itanI ekAgratA se svatantra ciMtana kiyA hai usakA maiM avazya kAyala hU~ / kyoMki merA mAnasa vidyApakSapAtI to hai hI / khAsa kara jaba koI kisI viSaya meM svatantra ciMtana kareM taba merA Adara aura bhI bar3hatA hai / isalie ApakI dalIloM aura vicAroM ne merA pUrvagraha chuDAyA hai / 1 strI zarIra meM puruSa vAsanA aura puruSa zarIra meM strItvayogya vAsanA ke jo kisse aura lakSaNa dekhe sune jAte haiM unakA khulAsA dUsarI taraha se ho jAtA hai jo Apake pakSa kA poSaka hai / para isa nae vicAra ko yahA~ citrita nahIM kara sakatA / bhogabhUmi meM garbha meM strIpuruSayugala yogya upAdAna haiM aura karma bhUmi meM nahIM ityAdi vicAra nire bAlIza haiM / jo anubhava hamAre pratyakSa hoM, jinheM hama dekha sakeM, jAMca sakeM, una para yadi karmazAstra ke niyama sughaTita ho nahIM sakate aura unheM ghaTAne ke lie hameM svarga, naraka yA kalpita bhogabhUmi meM jAnA par3e to acchA hogA ki hama usa karmazAstra ko hI chor3a deM / hamAre mAnya pUrvajoM ne jisa kisI kAraNa se vaisA vicAra kiyA; para hama utane mAtra meM baddha raha nahIM skte| hama unake vicAra kI bhI parIkSA kara sakate haiM / isalie dravya aura bhAvaveda ke sAmya ke samarthana meM dI gaI yuktiyA~ mujhako AkRSTa karatI haiM aura jo eka AkRti meM vijAtIya vedodaya kI kalpanA ke poSaka vicAra aura bAhya lakSaNa dekhe jAte haiM unakA khulAsA dUsarI taraha se karane ko ve yuktiyoM bAdhita karatI haiM / koI puruSa strItva kI abhilASA kare itane mAtra se strIvedAnubhavI nahIM ho sakatA / garbhagrahaNa - dhAraNa-poSaNa kI yogyatA hI strIveda hai na ki mAtra strIyogya bhogAbhilASA / maiM yadi aisA socU~ ki kAna se dekhatA to andha na rahatA yA aisA socU~ ki sira se calatA aura daur3atA to paGgu na rahatA to kyA itane socane mAtra se cakSujJAnAvaraNIyakarma ke kSayopazama kA yA pAdakarmendriya kA

Page #4
jaina dharma aura darzana phala mujha meM prakaTa hogA ? jaise jJAnIya kSayopazama vastutaH eka haiM tathApi mithyA. darzana Adi ke sambandha se usake samyak viparyAsa Adi phala vividha hote haiM, vaise hI veda eka rahane para bhI aura usakA sAmAnya kAryapradeza ekarUpa hone para bhI anya kASAyika baloM se aura anya saMsarga se usa ceda ke viparIta lakSaNa bhI ho sakate haiM / puruSa veda ke udayavAlA puruSaliGgI bhI strItva yogya abhilASA kare to use strIveda kA lakSaNa nahIM parantu puruSaveda kA viparIta lakSaNa mAtra kahanA caahie| sapheda ko pIlA dekhane mAtra se netra kA kSayopazama badala nahIM jAtA / vastutaH kisI eka hI veda meM nAnAvidha abhilASA kI jananazakti mAnanA caahie| cAhe sAmAnya niyatarUpa usake abhilASA ko loka amuka hI kyoM na maane| vIryAdhAyakazakti, viryagrahaNa zakti the hI krama se puMveda strIveda haiM jo dravyAkAra se niyata haiN| bakarA dUdha detA hai to bhI use strIveda kA udaya mAnA nahIM jA sakatA, niyata lakSaNa kA Agantuka kAraNavaza viparyAsa mAtra hai| jaise sAmAnyataH strI ko DAr3hI mUMcha nahIM hote para kisI ko khAsa hote haiM / yaha to lambA ho gayA / sArAMza itanA hI hai ki mujhako vedasAmya vicArasaMgata jAna par3atA hai| punazca zroprezana ke dvArA eka dRzya dravyaliGga kA anya dravyaliGga meM parivartana Ajakala bahuta dekhe sune jAte haiN| ise vicArakoTi meM lenA hogaa| napuMsaka zAyada tIsarA svatantra veda hI nhiiN| jahA~ amaka niyata lakSaNa nahIM dekhe vahA~ napuMsaka svatantra veda mAna liyA para aisA kyoM na mAnA jAya ki vahA~ veda strI puruSa meM se koI eka hI hai, para lakSaNa viparIta ho rahe haiN| dravya AkAra bhI puruSa yA strI kA vividha tAratamya yukta hotA hI hai /