Indian Culture and Jainism

Author(s): Kamalchand Sogani
Publisher: Jain Vidya Samsthan
Catalog link: https://jainqq.org/explore/006927/1

Page #1
INDIAN CULTURE AND JAINISM By Prof. KAMAL CHAND SOGANI bana vidhAkAta zrImahAvIrajI Published by JAINA VIDYA SANSTHANA Digambara Jaina Atisaya Ksetra Sri Mahaviraja (Rajasthan) For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #2
INDIAN CULTURE AND JAINISM Lecture to be delivered in the International Conference on Indian Philosophy, Science and Culture to be held from 29th March to 1st April 2003 at The India Habitat Centre, Lodhi Road, New Delhi By Prof. KAMAL CHAND SOGANI Former Professor of Philosophy M.L. Sukhadia University Udaipur (Rajasthan) Published by JAINA VIDYA SANSTHANA Digambara Jaina Atisaya Ksetra Sri Mahaviraji (Rajasthan) For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #3
Publisher Jaina Vidya Samsthana Digambara Jaina Atisaya Ksetra Sri Mahaviraji Sri Mahaviraji-322 220 (Rajasthan) Branch Office Jaina Vidya Samsthana Digambara Jaina Nasiyam Bhattarakaji Savai Rama Simgha Road, Jaipur 302004 Shri N.K. Sethi President Shri Narendra Patni Secretary Managing Committee Digambara Jaina Atisaya Ksetra Sri Mahaviraji * Price Rs. 10 per copy 1 $ Lecture on Indian Culture and Jainism to be delivered at a plenary Open Session on 29th March, 2003 at Hotel Ashok, New Delhi Theme : Indian Culture and Religions Chairperson : Professor D.P. Chattopadhyaya Printed by Jaipur Printers Pvt. Ltd. M.I. Road, Jaipur-302001 For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #4
INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE on INDIAN PHILOSOPHY, SCIENCE AND CULTURE (MARCH 29, 2003 TO APRIL 1, 2003) Chairman, Advisory Committee Professor D.P. Chattopadhyaya (Chairman, Centre for Studies in Civilizations) New Delhi Chairman, Organising Committee Professor Kireet Joshi (Chairman, Indian Council of Philosophical Research) New Delhi Co-Director, Organising Committee Professor Bhuvan Chandel Member-Secretary, CSC Co-Director, Organising Committee Professor R.C. Pradhan Member-Secretary, ICPR Member-Convenor, Organising Committee Dr. Mercy Helen Director-in-Charge, ICPR For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #5
Chairman Permanent Invitee Member ADVISORY COMMITTEE 1. Professor D.P. Chattopadhyaya, Chairman, CSC 2. Professor Kireet Joshi, Chairman, ICPR 3. Professor G.C. Pande, Chairman, IIAS, Shimla 4. Professor R. Balasubramanian, President Afro-Asian Philosophy Association 5. Professor K. Chadha, Vice-Chancellor, JNU 6. Professor Jaakko Hinitikka, President, IIP 7. Shri Siraj Hussain, Vice-Chancellor, Jamia Hamdard 8. Professor Ioanna Kucuradi, President, FISP 9. Professor R.A. Mashelkar, Director-General, CSIR 10. Professor M.G.K. Menon, Former Union Minister 11. Professor M.G.S. Narayanan, Chairman, ICHR 12. Professor Deepak Nayyar, Vice-Chancellor, Delhi University 13. Professor V.R. Panchamukhi, Chairman, ICSSR 14. Dr. Raja Ramanna, President Emeritus, NIAS 15. Professor Vachaspati Upadhyaya, Vice-Chancellor, Sri Lal Bahadur Shastri Kendriya Sanskrit Vidyapeetha 16. Professor M. Valiathan, President, INSA 17. Professor Bhuvan Chandel, Member-Secretary, CSC 18. Professor R.C. Pradhan, Member-Secretary, ICPR Member Member * Member . Member Member Member Member Member Member Member Member Member Member Permanent Invitee Permanent Invitee ORGANISING COMMITTEE 1. Professor Kireet Joshi, Chairman, ICPR Chairman 2. Professor D.P. Chattopadhyaya, Chairman, CSC Permanent Invitee 3. Professor Bhuvan Chandel, Member-Secretary, CSC Co-Director 4. Professor R.C. Pradhan, Member-Secretary, ICPR Co-Director 5. Professor S.R. Bhatt, Delhi University Member 6. Dr. R.C. Agarwal, Member-Secretary, ICHR Member 7. Shri Bhaskar Chatterjee, Member-Secretary, ICSSR Member 8. Professor I.N. Choudhury, Former Secretary, Sahitya Akademi Member 9. Dr. Bharat Gupta, Founder Member and Trustee, IFIH Member 10. Dr. Mercy Helen, Director-in-Charge, ICPR Member-Convenor 11. Professor Kapil Kapoor, JNU Member 12. Dr. Shashi Prabha Kumar, JNU Member 13. Professor Pratap Bhanu Mehta, JNU Member 14. Professor Ranjit Nair, Centre for Philosohy and Foundations of Science Member 15. Professor G.L. Pandit, Delhi University Member 16. Dr. Kavita Sharma, Principal, Hindu College Member 17. Dr. R.P. Singh, JNU Member 18. Professor V.C. Srivastava, Director, IIAS, Shimla Member 19. Dr. B.V. Subbarayappa, NIAS Member For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #6
INDIAN CULTURE AND JAINISM For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #7
a a L. 180 C T t t t p P y SALA z (anusvAra) 3. A INFO a e kh kh 108 109. F ch ch th th th ph ph r DIACRITICAL MARKS s S Mr. P i i ai g j d d ta b 1 S Yur im 0 I 5009 dh bh to > ho ha h : (visarga) H For Personal & Private Use Only u = la u au n Ja n Na IT S n FE m kS ks Ja tr X jJ jn 1612 U u

Page #8
INDIAN CULTURE AND JAINISM Dr. Kamal Chand Sogani Former Professor of Philosophy It is an acknowledged fact that Indian culture is the result of an interaction between two streams, Vedic and non-Vedic, Brahmana and Sramana. The relationship of the Harappan to the Vedic civilization has remained a puzzle, nevertheless, recent records tend to favour their close relationship, though there exists a difference of opinion on the exact nature of this relationship. "How exactly Vedic and non-Vedic cultures were related is not clearly known, but there is no doubt that the two gradually fused in the post-Vedic age to form the classical culture of India'." It requires to be accepted that the dominant note of Indian culture is the dissemination of the everlasting ethico-spiritual values without any diversion. This has been practised by the great personalities of India "from the Vedic seers and the Sramanic sages to the medieval saints and modern savants2." Thus it is the ethico-spiritual truth which has been tenaciously held in Indian culture through all its vicissitudes as the essential and consistent tradition. Rsabhanatha as non-Vedic and the founder of Jainism: In consonance with the ethico-spiritual adherence of the Indian saints and sages, nonVedic, Sramanic and Ksatriya Jaina tradition of twenty-four Tirtharikaras headed by Rsabhanatha or Adinatha, the first Jaina Tirthankara has been responsible for the rise and development of Jainism in the history of Indian culture. The symbol of Rsabhanatha is 'bull'. This reminds us of the Mohenjodaro seals wherein the bull has played a prominent part in the cult of the Indus people. "A large number of seals have been found bearing the figure of a bull and it is an undeniable fact that such seals are far greater in number than those bearing the figures of other animals3." Along with the bull, the figure of the deity has been represented as nacked and he has adopted Kayotsarga (standing) meditative posture. The presence of bull in the large number of seals, the adoption of nudity and the Kayotsarga meditative posture-all these seem to be sufficient to identify the figure on the seals as Rsabhanatha, the first Tirthankara of the Jainas. "Since in the seals from the Indus Valley we have the earliest Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #9
evidence of a yogic posture and since Yoga as a system of self-realisation is foreign to the earlier Vedic texts, are we to conclude that the Vedic people learnt about meditation and its technique from the Indus Valley people4." On the basis of the Rsabhanatha cult it may be said that Jainism represents the continuation of Sramanic culture which is as old as the Vedas so far as the literary evidence goes, though the archaeological evidence takes Sramanism far back to Harappan civilization, which is predominantly a yoga-based non-Vedic culture. According to Dr. G.C. Pandes "the anti-ritualistic tendency, within the Vedic fold, is itself due to the impact of an asceticism which antedates the Vedas. It is recognised that "some of the relics, recovered from the excavations at Mohen-jodaro and Harappa, are related to Sramana or Jaina tradition. "The nude images in Kayotsraga, i.e., the standing posture lost in meditation, closely resemble the Jaina images of the Kusana period. Kayotsarga is generally supposed to belong to the Jaina tradition. There are some idols even in Padmasana pose." "Even after the destruction of the Indus civilization, the straggling culture of the Sramanas, most probably going back to pre-Vedic times, continued even during the Vedic period as is indicated by some such terms as Vatarasana, Muni, Yati, Sramana, Kesi, Vratya, Arhan and Sisnadeva". "There can hardly be any doubt that the Muni was to the Rgvedic culture an alien figure". "In the Rgveda', Arhan has been used for a sramana leader." "The mention of Sisnadevas (naked gods) in the Rgveda is also noteworthy?." All this speaks of Jainism as a pre-Vedic religion and Rsabhanatha as its founder. According to tradition, Rsabhanatha founded the social order and family system, taught to mankind the cultivation of land, different arts and crafts, writing etc., improving the lot of his people. That is why the Indian tradition preserves the memory of Rsabha and has been called in the Brahmanical texts as an incarnation of god Visnu and Bharata, a Mahayogi. Owing to the importance of Rsabha in the history of Indian culture, he is called Prajapati, Mahadeva, Pasupatinatha, Brahma etc. It will not be out of place to point out that the ancient Indian Script Brahmi has been styled 'Brahmi Script' after the name of his daughter, Brahmi. Bharata after Rsabhanatha's son Bharata : "All the main Puranas like the Visnu, Agni, Markandeya, Brahmanda, Skanda, Linga Purana, etc. Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #10
unanimously record that India came to be styled as Bharata after Bharata Cakravarti, a supreme ruler and a great victor, the son and successor of the mighty and enlightened paramount monarch and the first Jaina Tirthankara Adinatha or Rsabhanatha of the solar dynasty8," although certain scholars erroneously associate India's name as Bharata after Bharata, the son of Sakuntala and Dusyanta. It may be noted here that attempts are being made to change tradition into history in the modern sense of the word. The historicity of Parsva (877 B.C.) the 23rd Tirthankara has been established.' The predecessor of Parsva is Aristanemi (Neminatha) the first cousin of Lord Krsna1o. The twenty first Tirthankara Nami of Mithila in Videha seems to have given rise to the spiritualistic thought of the Upanisad." Discourses of Mahavira in Prakrta and his first sermon at the advent of a Vedic Brahmin Scholar: Mahavira (598 B.C.-527 B.C.) is the twenty-fourth Tirthankara, who attained omniscience (Kevalajnana). Mahavira remained silent and did not deliver, according to Digambara tradition, any sermon for sixty-six days. At the advent of a renowned Vedic, Brahmin scholar, named Indrabhuti Gautama in the Samavassarana (religious assembly) Mahavira delivered his first sermon at the Vipulacala mountain outside the city of Rajagrha, the capital of Magadha, on Saturday the 1st July 557 B.C.12 This day is celebrated as the Virasasana day and Indrabhuti Gautama was designated as the first Ganadhara (chief disciple) by Mahavira. Along with Indrabhuti Gautama his five hundred pupils joined the order of Mahavira. Gradually Mahavira initiated more Brahmin Vedic scholars into the ascetic order. It is of capital importance to note that Mahavira made use of Prakrta for his discourses13, as a result of which the whole canonical literature in Prakrta was prepared by the Ganadharas. Now the question is why did Mahavira deliver his first sermon only at the advent of a Vedic Brahmin scholar? My interpretation of the event is Vedic scholar is a Prakrta scholar, since the Vedas have been composed in Loka Bhasa (language of the masses) of that period. Pt. Kisoridasa Vajapaye tells us that the language of the Vedas is the first form of Prakrta, though this underwent change in form in course of time and became the second stage of Prakrta. This second stage was prevalent in a very large area and Mahavira's discourses were meant for all without Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only 3

Page #11
any distinction of cast and creed, classes and masses, so he chose Prakrta for his deliverances. I have no hesitation to say that the mother tongue ven Panini was Prakrta. Since the eleven Ganadharas including Indrabhuti Gautama were Vedic Brahmana scholars they were wellversed in Praksta language. Mahavira gave them the most important task of Agamic preparation. My contention is that just as the seeds of Laukika Samskrta are inherent in the Vedic language, similarly the seeds of Praksta constructions may be easily discerned in the Vedic language. Thus the Vedic language is the precursor of Laukika Samskrta as well as Prakrta constructions. Thus to say that Prakrta is derived from Laukika Samskrta is an improper approach to the history of language development in India. I may, therefore, conclude by saying that the study of Vedic language will constitute an all-embracing foundation of Indian culture. Unfortunately India is missing this aspect of culture and it must be remembered that the study of language is basic to the study of any culture. This will open the way to Praksta and Apabhramsa studies and the study of regional languages. By virtue of this, the origin of national language, Hindi will be understood in a right perspective. Religion of Mahavira as Sarvodaya-Tirtha : It will not be idle to point out that after attaining supreme knowledge known as Kevalajnana, Mahavira for full thirty years visited different parts of country especially the important centres in Eastern and Northern India and promulgated socio-spiritual values throughout. Owing to the magnetic personality of Mahavira and his metaphysical, ethical and spiritual teachings, number of kings, queens, princes, princesses, ministers and merchants accepted him as their teacher. Thus males and females of all casts and classes became the ardent followers of Mahavira, and a fourfold order of Sadhus (male ascetics), Sadhvis (female ascetics), Sravakas (male householders) and Sravikas (female householders) came into existence. In view of the all-embracing character of Mahavira's principles the Jaina Acarya Samantabhadra, as early as second century A.D. called the religion of Mahavira a 'Sarvodaya' Tirtha!4, which term is so commonly used nowa-days after Gandhiji. Thus 'Mahavira is one of those few towering personalities who fought for individual liberty in the context of social life. He revolted against the socio-religious exploitation and oppression of man and introduced vigorous innovations in the then existing social Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #12
law and order. He did not confine himself to individual upliftment, but he dedicated himself to the development of a new creative social order for the healthiest orientation of the individual. Though he was a man of contemplative values, yet social values got his fullest attention. Those who regard Mahavira only as an apostle of spiritual message do great injustice to him. In fact, he serves as an illustration both of spiritual realisation and social reconstruction. Mahavira attained Nirvana at Pava in Bihara at the age of 72 on Tuesday the 15th October 527 B.C. This day is being celebrated as the Dipavali festival (festival of lamps) throughout India. Besides, Mahavira's Nirvana day marks the beginning of Vira Nirvana Samvat. This Samvat is the oldest Samvat followed in India. Unprecedented contributions of Jainism to Indian Culture: I take this opportunity to enumerate and discuss in brief the unprecedented contributions which have been made by Jainism to Indian culture, by virtue of which this culture has been enriched and adorned. 1. Classification of empirical selves as the basis of socio-spiritual principle of Ahimsa and the dissemination of the doctrine of Aparigraha. 2. Inclusion of the notion of Paryaya (modification or change) in the definition of Substance and its spiritual implication. 3. Theory of Metaphysico-axiological Anekanta along with the doctrine of Naya (view-point). 4. Device of Syadvada as the key to the pointed communicability of knowledge. 5. Doctrine of Karma as an explanation of the cognitive, conative and affective differences existing in the world at large. 6. Mystical journey of the self from darkness to light, from slumberness to perfect spiritual awakening. 7. Composite Sadhana of Tri-ratna (Samyagdarsana, Samyagjnana and Samyakcaritra) leading to emancipation. (Moksa). 8. According religious freedom to women and down-trodden people. 9. Propounding the philosophy of vegetarianism and the philosophy of fighting defensive wars. Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only 5

Page #13
10. Accepting Sallekhana as the spiritual welcome to death without any fear and perturbation. 1. Classification of Jivas (empirical selves) as the basis of socio-spiritual principle of Ahimsa and the dissemination of the doctrine of Aparigraha The doctrine of Ahimsa is the be-all and end-all of the Jinist way of life and living. The oldest Jaina Agama Ayaro remarkably pronounces that none of the living beings ought to be killed, ought to be ruled, ought to be enslaved or possessed, ought to be distressed and ought to be put to disquiet. (Hoa TUTUT Hall, ut 316ildcat, ut affroat, ut ufarctical, UT 3Educat)15 The socio-political organisations and the capitalistic set up can easily derive inspiration from this ethico-social statement. Thus the Ayaro (Acaranga) conclusively pronounces that after understanding the importance of kindness to beings, the enlightened person should preach, disseminate and applaud it at all places in East-West and North-South directions. (dayaM logassa jANittA pAINaM, paDINaM, dAhiNaM udINaM Aikkhe vibhae kiTTe agat)16 The Prasnavyakarana Sutra designates social Ahimsa as kindness, (dayA) security (rakSA) salutariness (kallANa) fearlessness (abhaya) and so on.17 The Acaranga gives us certain arguments to renounce Himsa. (i) Socio-political argument against Himsa : The Acaranga condemns Himsa by saying that its operation is without any stop, cessation and discontinuance and it goes on increasing to the extent possible with the political consequence that the race of armaments becomes unarrestable and continues to grow without any check. In contradistinction to this it eulogizes Ahimsa by saying that its observance is total and not piece-meal, with the result that the armament race discontinues and comes to a stop. ( 31fer frei uur ui, ufrer gripei utot ui )18 (ii) Psychological Argument against Himsa: After comprehending and beholding the significance of peacefulness of beings, one should renounce Himsa, inasmuch as Himsa causes suffering to beings and human suffering caused by theft, hoarding, falsehood, slavery, economic exploitation, social oppression, curtailment of legitimate freedoms and the like is a great mental disturbance, is dreadful and Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #14
is associated with unbearable pain and affliction. Since life is dear to all beings, pleasures are desirable, pain is undesirable for them, beings ought not to be killed, ruled, possessed, distressed and so on (NijjhAittA paDilehittA patteyaM pariNivvANaM savvesiM pANANaM assAtaM apariNivvANaM mahavbhayaM dukkhaM ) ( savve pANA suhasAtA dukkhapaDi kuulaa| savvesiM jIvitaM piyaM)19 It will not be idle to point out that the talk of Ahimsa is not possible without a world of living beings. Social Ahimsa begins with the awareness of the 'other'. Like one's own existence, it recognises the existence of other beings. In fact, to negate the existence of other beings is tantamount to negating one's own existence. Since one's own existence can not be negated, the existence of other beings also can not be negated. Thus there exists the universe of beings in general and that of human beings in particular. ( Neva sayaM logaM abbhAikkhejjA, Neva attANaM abbhAikkhejjA / je logaM 30415 crafa )19 1 The Jaina Agama classifies living beings (Jivas) into five kinds, namely, one-sensed to five-sensed beings.21 The minimum number of Pranas possessed by the empirical self is four (one sense, one Bala, lifelimit and breathing), and the maximum number is ten (five senses, three Balas, life-limit, and breathing). The lowest in the grade of existence are the one-sensed Jivas which possess only the sense of touch and they have only the Bala of body, and besides they hold life-limit and breathing. These one-sensed Jivas admit of five-fold classification22; namely, the earth-bodied (Prthivikayika) water-bodied (Jala Kayika) fire-bodied (Agnikayika) air-bodied (Vayukayika) and lastly, vegetable-bodied (Vanaspatikayika) souls. The two-sensed Jivas posses six Pranas, i.e., in addition to the four Pranas of one-sensed souls, they have two Pranas more; namely, the sense of taste, and the Bala of speech; the three-sensed souls have the sense of smell additionally; the four-sensed souls have the sense of colour besides the above; and lastly, the five-sensed souls which are mindless are endowed with the sense of hearing in addition; and those with mind possess all the ten Pranas. Thus the number of Pranas possessed by one-sensed to five-sensed souls is four, six, seven, eight, nine and ten respectively. This classification of Jivas into five kinds is used for the measurement of the degree of Ahimsa. The more the senses the more the Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only 7

Page #15
evolved consciousness. As for example, two-sensed Jivas are more evolved than the one-sensed beings, five sensed beings are more evolved than the one, two, three and four-sensed beings. Thus Ahimsa will be directly proportionate to the Ahimsa of the beings (Jivas) classified. Spiritual Perspective of Ahimsa : We have dwelt upon Ahimsa as a social value. This view regards Ahimsa as 'other' oriented and is concerned with the progress and development of the 'other'. The Purusarthasiddhupaya moves in a different direction when it unambigously expresses that non-emergence of attachment, aversion etc. on the surface of self is Ahimsa ( 349g ufa: U TUGTi haruft afat).23 This pronouncement has a deep inward reference and regards Ahir a spiritual value. This method of dealing with Ahimsa obliges us to peep into one's own inner life, so that attachment and aversion along with their ramifications like anger, pride, deceit and greed are completely got rid of. The Prasnavyakarana Sutra designates Ahimsa as Nirvana (nivvANa), Samadhi (samAhI) Supreme tranquillity. (saMtI), happiness (pamoa), super satisfaction (farit) and purity (Ufall) and so on24. In other words, we may say that even the slightest fall from complete self-realisation is to be regarded as Himsa. Thus Himsa commences with the appearance of passions on the ground of self. The Acarnga gives us spiritual argument to renounce Himsa. Spiritual Argument against Himsa : Since all the selves are transcendentally alike, killing the other is killing one's own self, ruling the other is ruling one's own self, enslaving the other is enslaving one's own self, distressing the other is distressing one's own self, and disquieting the other is disquieting one's own self. By reason of this Himsa of all the living beings has been abandoned by those desirous of self-realisation ( qe fa una eta i inloci fa huulfa, TH FH una pista Ji ajjAvetavvaM ti maNNasi, tumaM si NAma taM ceva jaM paritAvetavvaM ti maNNasi, tumaM si NAma taM caMva jaM parighetavvaM ti maNNasi, evaM taM ceva jaM uddavetavvaM ti mnnnnsi|).25 Dissemination of the doctrine of Aparigraha 26 : Mahavira was well aware of the fact that economic inequality and the hoarding of essential commodities very much disturb social life and living. These acts lead to the exploitation and enslavement of man. Owing to this, life in society is endangered. Consequently, Mahavira pronounced that the remedy for Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #16
the ill of economic inequality is Aparigraha. The method of Aparigraha tells us that one should keep with one self that which is necessary for one's living and the rest should be returned to society for its well-being. Limit of wealth and essential commodities are indispensable for the development of healthy social life. In a way wealth is the basis of our social structure and if its flow is obstructed because of its accumulation in few hands, large segments of society will remain undeveloped. The hoarding of essential commodities creates a situation of social scarcity which perils social life. In order to resist such inhuman tendency, Mahavira incessantly endeavoured to establish the social value of Aparigraha. 2. Inclusion of the notion of Paryaya (modification or change) in the definition of Substance and its spiritual implication Definition of Substance (Dravya): In consonance with the perspective adopted by the Jainas in their metaphysical speculation, substance is that which exists or that which is characterised by simultaneous origination, destruction and persistence, or that which is the substratum of attributes (Guna) and modes (Paryaya)27. Permanence signifies persistence of substance along with attributes, and change refers to fluctuating modes along with the emergence of the new modes and the disappearance of the old ones at one and the same time. To illustrate, gold as a substance exists with its modifications and qualities. Now after making an ornament, gold as a substance is existent along with its attributes and what changes is the mode. Thus existence which is inseparably bound up with substance (gold) accompanied by its attributes and modes necessitates the production of a new form, the cessation of the old one, and continuation of gold as such simultaneously28. In other words, the denial of the different aspects of the Jaina view of substance will lead us either to the Buddhist philosophy of universal change which disregards the underlying permanent being, or to the Vedantic monism which declares the accompanying change as appearance or illusory. Substance (Dravya) and modification (Paryaya): The notion of Paryaya is peculiarly Jaina29. In conformity with the nature of substance as permanence in change, Paryaya alludes to the changing aspect of a thing. Every quality changes its state every moment; and this mode of being is called Paryaya which is incessantly transforming itself into the Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only 9

Page #17
next, though the quality as such is never abrogated. It is on this account alleged that substance is in a state of perpetual flux. However incessant and infinite the transformations may be, the underlying substantiality and permanency can never part with existence. Substance and Paryaya are not to be distinugished like two different things, for it is substance through qualities which because of its flowing nature attains the qualification of Paryayi. Substance and modes are neither exclusively identical nor exclusively different, but the relation is one of identity-indifference. Thus origination and destruction are applicable to Paryayas, and persistence to qualities along with substance. Thus there is no substance (Dravya) without modification, and modification is inconceivable without substance30. Hence permanence is not the denial of change, but includes it as its necessary aspect. Spiritual implication of Paryaya: Svabhava Paryaya and Vibhava Paryaya Kundakunda, the great philosopher of the 1st Century A.D. discusses the spiritual implication of Paryayas (modifications) of self. According to him, the self, as an ontologically underived fact, is one of the six substances subsisting independently of anything else. Consciousness is the essential quality of the self. It manifests itself at the mundane stage of existence in auspicious and inauspicious psychical modifications. Whenever the auspicious mode of kindness originates, inauspicious mode of cruelty ceases and the quality of consciousness continues simultaneously. Thus self as a substance exists with its modifications and qualities. Kundakunda speaks of essential modifications (Svabhava Paryayas) and non-essential modifications (Vibhava Paryayas) and accepts that the empirical self has been associated with the non-essential modifications (Vibhava Paryayas) and accepts that the empirical self has been associated with the non-essential modifications (Vibhava Paryayas) since an indeterminable past, thereby it has identified itself with attachment and aversion"!. We may point out in passing that the transcendental self occupies itself with essential modifications (Svabhava Paryayas) and goes beyond the quality of attachment and aversion and is the doer of detached actions and the enjoyer of pure knowledge and bliss. The empirical self is potentially transcendental, though this transcendental state of existence is not actualised at present; hence the distinction is 10 Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #18
incontrovertible. The wordly human beings have identified themselves with the non-essential modifications (Vibhava Paryayas) from beginningless past. Kundakunda, therefore, draws our attention to the essential modifications (Svabhava Paryayas) of self. He advises us to relinquish the working of Vibhava Paryayas after turning to Svabhava Paryayas of self. No doubt we are in the empirical form of existence from beginningless past, but his theory of Svabhava Paryaya reminds us of our spiritual magnificence and glory. The doctrine of Svabhava Paryaya does not assert that the self is at present perfect but simply affirms that the self ought to attain the height illumined by it. It has the force of 'ought' and not of 'is', but the force is valid for empirical selves having Vibhava-Paryayas. Kundakunda regards the attainment of Svabhava Parvava as the attainment of knowledge-consciousness (Inana Cetana) which is the full-fledged and legitmate manifestation of consciousness32. The Arhat or Siddha state is the state of knowledge-consciousness, the state of omniscience and bliss". 3. Theory of Metaphysico-axiological Anekanta along with the Doctrine of Naya - (view-point) Metaphysical Anekanta : It is incontrovertible that metaphysics deals with the problem of reality or substance. For Jaina thinkers, reality is constituted of apparent contradictions. So its one dimensional exposition is not possible. It is an inalienable complex of permanence and change, existence and non-existence, oneness and manyness, universality and particularity etc. Because of this complexity, reality or substance is styled 'Anekantic'. It is thus multi-dimensional possessing antagonistic dimensions of permanence and change, one and many etc. These antagonistic dimensions are infinite in number, of which we know only a few of them. Thus the Jaina philosopher differs from all absolutists in their approach to the unfoldment of the inner nature of reality. The Jaina advocates change to be as much ontologically real as permanance. Being implies becoming and vice versa. It may be said "if the Upanisadic thinkers found the immutable reality behind the world of phenomena and plurality, and the Buddha denounced everything as fleeting, Mahavira found no contradiction between permanence and change, and was free from all absolutism." While discussing the nature of substance we have Indian Culture and Jainism 11 For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #19
already said that permanence signifies persistence of substance along with attributes, and change refers to fluctuating modes along with the emergence of the new modes and the disappearance of the old ones at one and the same time. (i) Metaphysical Anekanta and the Classification of Substance : (Plurality, Duality and Unity) Jainism resolves the whole of the universe of being into two everlasting, un-created, co-existing, but independent categories of Jiva and Ajiva. The Ajiva is further classified into Pudgala (matter), Dharma (principle of motion), Adharma (principle of rest), Akasa (space) and Kala (time). Hence reality is dualistic as well as pluralistic. But, according to the Jaina, plurality, considered from the point of view of one existence, entails unity also. According to Kundakunda, in spite of the unique characteristics possessed by the different substances, existence has been regarded as an allcomprising characteristic of reality which ends all distinctions34. Samantabhadra also endorses this view by affirming that in view of the conception of one universal existence all are one, but from the point of view of substances distinctions arise. 35 In his Saptabhangitarangini Vimaladasa concludes that both the postulation of existential identity and the articulation of differences from the stand-point of different substances are logically necessary and justifiable36. Thus Jainism gives credence to the recognition of existential oneness but not exclusively, since it is always bound up with plurality. This is quite consistent with the Anekantatmaka view of reality propounded by the Jaina philosopher. Hence unity, duality, and plurality-all are inseparably and inevitably involved in the structure of reality. This is the Anekantic view of reality. (ii) Knowledge of Anekantic reality (Pramana and Naya) According to Jainism reality or substance is cognized by Pramana and Naya??. Pramana refers to the grasping of reality in its wholeness, while Naya points to an aspect of infinitely-phased reality illumined by Pramana, thus the latter takes into consideration only a fragment of the totality38. A substance embellishes itself with apparent antagonisms. The emphasis on the one and the cancellation of the other would irresistibly lead us to the biased 12. Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #20
estimation and Ekantic view of reality. Pramana assimilates all the characteristics at once without any contradiction and animosity between one characteristic and the other, for instance, between one and many, existent and non-existent, etc. Of the unfathomable characteristics, Naya chooses one at one moment, but keeps in view the other characteristics also. "Though the Jaina thinker has made critical estimation of the philosophical assumptions of other schools of thought, they paid proper respect to them and accept their truth-value on the basis of different Nayas39." We can thus say that both Pramana and Naya are essential for the proper understanding of the nature of reality. Reality being the respository of infinite attributes, the apprehension of it from a particular angle of vision, i.e., Naya, which is objectively given and not subjectively contemplated, does not exhaust the whole of the multiphased reality. We may point out here that corresponding to the infinite antagonistic charcteristics, there are infinite Nayas. But summarily speaking, all the Nayas from the metaphysical point of view can be summed up into two kinds, namely, Dravyarthika Naya and Paryayarthika Naya. These two Nayas can very well expound the nature of reality, or substance. Dravyarthika Naya refers to the permanent aspect of a substance and Paryayarthika Naya refers to the changing aspect of a substance. (iii) Axiological Anekanta For the proper intelligibility of the Anekantic reality, Jaina Acaryas have given us two Nayas, namely Dravyarthika Naya and Paryayarthika Naya corresponding to the permanent and changing aspects of reality. This type of comprehension yields intellectual satisfaction, yet it does not show us the way to spiritual growth, satisfaction and self-realisation. Axiological consciousness is very much different from descriptive consciousnes produced by metaphysical curiosity of the human mind. So the Jaina Acaryas have propounded two axiological Nayas, namely Niscaya and Vyavahara for properly evaluating the manifested and unmanifested Paryayas of self. Thus we have axiological Anekanta and the metaphysical Anekanta. Indian Culture and Jainism 12 For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #21
(iv) Meaning of two axiological Nayas40 : The Niscaya Naya grasps the soul in its undefiled state of existence in contradistinction to the Vyavahara Naya which describes the self as bound, impure and the like. No doubt, we are in the defiled form of existence from beginningless past, but the Niscaya Naya reminds us of our spiritual magnificence and glory. It prompts the sullied self to behold its spiritual heritage. It endeavours to infuse and instill into our minds the imperativeness of Suddha Bhavas after abundantly showing us the empirical and evanescent character of Subha and Asubha Bhavas that bind the soul to mundane existence. It does not assert that the soul is at present perfect but simply affirms that the self ought to attain the height illuminated by it. It has the force of 'ought' and not of 'is', but this force is valid for empirical selves. Niscaya Naya points to the potentiality of the empirical self to become pure and enjoy its unalloyed status.... Briefly, we may say that to make Anekantic reality. intelligible from the metaphysical perspective, Dravyarthika and Paryayarthika Nayas are necessary and to make an axiological assessment of Anekantic reality from the spiritual perspective, Niscaya and Vyavahara Nayas can not be dispensed with. S ' 4. Device of Syavada as the key to the pointed communicability of knowledge The significant fact about knowledge is its communicability. When the knowledge is for one's own self, the question of communicability can be dispensed with; but when it is for the other, the question needs serious consideration. Communicability is accomplished through properly worded propositions and formulation of propositions is dependent on the content of knowledge. If there is discordance between the content of knowledge and formulation of propositions, serious misunderstandings are bound to arise. Syadvada is the linguistic device to represent without any omission and distortion the content of knowledge. Thus in a way Syadvada and knowledge become the obverse and the converse of the same coin. The Jaina thinkers propound that the object has infinite antagonistic characteristics - some known, some in the process of being discovered 14 Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #22
and many as yet unknown. This is known as the doctrine of Anekantavada. Syadvada is the method of communicating the manifold characteristics of a thing to the other. Thus Syadvada is the expression of Anekantavada in language. If Anekantavada is the mode of cognition, Syadvada is the mode of expression. The significant point to be comprehended in regard to Anekantavada is that every characteristic of a multiphased thing is maintaining its identity through the existence of its opposite as its aspect". In fact, a thing can not be the same thing without the negation of other things in it. For example, a colour can not remain a colour without the negation of other characteristics like taste, smell etc. in it. Thus non-exister as much an essential aspect of the real as existence is. Negative propositions can not be asserted without accepting non-existence a element in the constitution of the real. Similarly, the characteristics of one and many, permanence and change, generality and particularity are reconciled in a thing without any incongruity. Thus when the Jinist is faced with the problem of expressing the complex content of knowledge in language in a way which can communicate to the other the knowledge as such, he had to devise the method of Syadvada. The word 'Syat' when added to a proposition is indicative of the presence of multiple characteristics in a thing in addition to the characteristic referred to in the proposition under consideration. In the propostion 'Syat Ghata is colourful', the word 'Syat' implies that the subject Ghata is a manifold of attributes, of which the attribute of being colourful referred to in the posposition is there in the Ghata as a matter of fact. This should not be understood, as it is generally done, to mean that the existence of colour in the Ghata is doubtful. In other words, certainty of colour along with the manifoldness of characteristics is indicated by the word 'Syat.' Thus Syadvada is the custodian of clarity, certainty and unambiguity in the field of philosophy. It is by no means the doctrine of doubt and uncertainty Saptabhangivada (Doctrine of seven-fold propositions)^2 Although an existent is possessed of infinite attributes, yet the knowing of it is not a simple affair. The question is : what is it to know a thing ? and how many propositions are requisite to express the content of knowledge ? The conviction of the Jaina is that the seven distinct Indian Culture and Jainism 15 For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #23
propositions, neither more nor less are needed to express the content of knowledge in regard to an existent. Let us now illustrate the doctrine of seven-fold proposition by taking an example of the attribute 'existence' in respect of pen. 1. The first proposition is : Syat pen exists. This means that the existence of pen is contextual, the context being its own Dravya (substance), Ksetra (space), Kala (time) and Bhava (state)... 2. The second proposition is : Syat pen does not exist. It states the non-existence of pen in respect of other Dravya, Ksetra, Kala and Bhava. Thus it strengthens the first proposition rather than cancel it. The pen is pen only because it is not not-pen. Thus both existence and non-existence are co-present in the pen without any contradiction. According to the Jaina, non-existence is as much constitutive of the nature of thing as existence. 3. The third proposition is : Syat pen exists and does not exist. 4. The fourth proposition is : Syat pen is inexpressible. In this proposition the two attributes of existence and non-existence instead of being asserted successively as in the third proposition, are asserted simultaneously. Since words are incapable of expressing this apprehension of pen, the pen is inexpressible.. 5. Syat pen exists and is inexpressible. 6. Syat pen does not exist and is inexpressible. 7. Syat pen exists, and does not exist and is inexpressible. All these propositions, according to the Jaina, represent a new aspect of the real 5. Doctrine of Karma as an explanation of the cognitive, conative and affective differences existing in the world at large. The empirical selves differ from one another in respect of cognition, conation and affection etc. What is the cause of this differene ? How to account for these perceptible distinctions among empirical selves ? The answer of the Jaina is that it is the beginningless material subtle principle known as Karma that is responsible for the cause of differences in the empirical selves. This Karma has been exercising its limiting and 16 Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #24
crippling influence on the empirical conscious principles from the beginningless past. This material subtle principle is known as Dravyakarma, and its psychical counterpart in terms of Raga and Dvesa is called Bhava-Karma. Karmas are of varied nature, but the fundamental kinds of Karma are eight in number13-namely. (1) Knowledge-obscuring, (Jnanavaraniya-Karma) (2) Intuition-obscuring, (Darsanavaraniya-Karma) (3) Feeling-producing (Vedaniya-Karma) (4) Delusion-producing, (Mohaniya-Karma) (5) Longevity-determining, (Ayu-Karma) (6) Body-making (Nama-Karma) (7) Status-determining (Gotra-Karma) (8) Obstruction-generating (Antaraya-Karma) (1) Just as the curtain obstructs the knowledge of things inside the room, so also the knowledge-obscuring Karma obstructs the expression of knowledge. (2) Just as a door keeper does not allow persons to meet the king etc. so also the intuition-obscuring Karma does not allow apprehension of things. (3) Just as on licking honey from the sharp edge of a sword, the person enjoys honey as well as suffers pain, so also the feeling-producing Karma produces pleasure and pain in man. (4) Just as wine stupefies a person, so also the delusion-producing Karma perverts the person. (5) Just as wooden fetters stop the movement of a person, so also the longevity-determining Karma obliges the soul to stay in a particular body. (6) Just as the painter produces different pictures, so also the body-making Karma makes different bodies. (7) Just as a potter makes earthen pots of different sizes, so also the status-determining Karma determines status in society. (8) Just as a treasurer generates obstructions in giving money etc. to others, so also the obstructiongenerating Karma causes handicaps in charity, in gains and in selfpower. It is no doubt true that Karmas bind the self to mundane existence. Now the question that arises is this: How the self is bound by Karmas ? What are the causes that create Karmic bondage in the self? The answer Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only 17

Page #25
of the Jaina is that it is actions (mental, bodily and vocal) polluted by passions that cause empirical bondage to the self44. The passion-free actions do not bring about any mundane bondage whatsoever. When there are no passions, there is no bondage (Bandha). It is passions that mar the spiritual career of an aspirant. 6. Mystical journey of the self from darkness to light, from slumberness to perfect spiritual awakening The equivalent expressions in Jainism for the word 'mysticism' are : Suddhopayoga", Arhat and Siddha46 state, Pandita-Pandita Marana47 Paramatmanhood48, Atmasamahita state49, Samatva", Paradrstis, Ahimsa53 etc. All these expressions convey indentical meaning of realising the transcendental self. The traditional definition of Jaina mysticism may be stated thus : Mysticism consists.in the attainment of Arhathood or Siddha-hood through the medium of Samiyagdarsana (spirital awakening) Samyagjnana (value knowledge), and Samyakcaritra (ethico-spritual conduct) after dispelling Mithyadarsana (spiritual perversion), Mithyajnana (perverted Value knowledge), and Mithyacaritra (perverted conduct)54. Kundakunda (1st cent A.D.) records departure from this terminology when he says : Mysticism consists in realising the Paramatman (transcendental self), through the Antaratman (internal self) after renouncing the Bahiratman (external self)55. Thus we may say that the Paramatman is the true goal of the mystic quest. The whole mystic journey may be put as follows: (1) Awakening of the self, (2) Purgation, (3) Illumination, (4) Dark-night of the soul, and (5) Transcendental life. The Jaina tradition deals with the mystic journey under the fourteen stages of spiritual evolution, technically known as Gunasthanas. However, these stages may be subsumed under the above heads in the following way :56. 1. Dark-period of the self prior to its awakening : Mithyatva Gunasthana (First) In this Gunsthana the empirical souls remain in a perpetual state of spiritual ignorance. The soul staying in this Gunasthana identifies itself with bodily colour, physical frame, sex, cast, creed, family, friends and wealth. The consequence is that it is constantly obsessed with the fear of self-annihilation on the annihilation on the body and the like and is tormented even by the thought of death. 18 Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #26
1. Awakening of the self-Aviratasamyagdrsti Gunasthana (Fourth) Fall from awakening : (a) Sasadana Gunasthana (Second) (b) Misra Gunasthana (Third) The soul in this Gunasthana considers his own self as his genuine abode regarding the outward physical dwelling places as artificial. He renounes all identification with the animate and inanimate objects of the world and properly weighs them in the balance of his discriminative knowledge. He is the only person who has acquired the right of Moksa. Fall from awakening : If the spiritual awakening is due to the total annihilation of spiritual ignorance the self has thrown over all the chances of its fall to the lower stages. But if the spiritual awakening is consequent upon the suppression of spiritual ignorance, the self either falls to the lower stages or remains in the same stage with the emergence of certain defects ordinarily incognisable. 3. Purgation : (a) Viratavirata Gunasthana (Fifth) - (b) Pramattavirata Gunasthana (Sixth) After dispelling the dense and intense darkness caused by spiritual ignorance, the passionate and ardent longing of the awakened self is to purge the defects of conduct which now stands between it and the transcendental self. In the fifth Gunasthana, the aspirant who is a householder is incapable of making himself free from all Himsa root and branch. In consequence, he adopts the five partial vows (Anuvratas) along with the seven Silavratas in order to sustain the central virtue of Ahimsa as for as possible. This shows that the householder's life is a mixture of virtue and vice, which obstructs the purgative way pursued by the mystic. Hence the aspirant, being motivated by certain incentives to spiritual life, (Anupreksas) gradually renounces the householder's type of living, becomes a saint in order to negate Himsa to the last degree. In consequence, the saint observes five Mahavratas, and practises internal and external austerities with special attention to meditation, devotion, and Svadhyaya. This stage may be regarded as the terminus of purgative way.. 4. Illumination : (a) Apramattavirata Gunasthana (Seventh) (b) Apurvakarana Gunasthana (Eighth) (c) Anivsttikarana Gunasthana (Ninth) Indian Culture and Jainism 19 For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #27
(d) Suksmasamparaya Gunasthana (Tenth) (e) Upasantakasaya Gunasthana (Eleventh) (f) Ksinakasaya Gunasthana (Twelfth) These Gunasthanas from the seventh to the twelth are the meditational stages or the stages of illumination and ecstasy. By the time the aspirant aches the seventh Gunasthana, he has developed a power of spiritual attention, of self-merging and of gazing into the ground of the soul. It is through the aid of deep meditation that the mystic now pursues the higher path. In consequence, he arrives at the eighth and the ninth stages. In the tenth Gunasthana there is only subtle greed that can disturb the soul. The soul suppresses even this subtle greed in the eleventh Gunasthana. If the self follows the process of annihilation instead of suppression it rises directly from the tenth to the twelth Gunasthana. 5. Dark-night of the soul post-illumination : Fall to the first or the fourth Gunasthana. Owing to the suppressed passions gaining strength, the illuminated consciousness of the eleventh Gunasthana falls to the lowest stage or to the fourth stage. The consequence is that the ecstatic awareness of the transcendental self gets negated and an overwhelming sense of darkness envelops the mystic. 6. Transcendental life : (a) Sayogakevali Gunasthana (Thirteenth) (b) Ayogakevali Gunasthana (Fourteenth) The slumbering and the unawakened soul, after passing through the stages of spiritual awakening, moral and intellectual preparation, now arrives at the sublime destination by dint of ascending the rungs of meditational ladder. In the thirteenth stage the soul possesses dispassionate activities and develops omniscience. It is a state of JivanaMukta, a supermental state of existence and an example of divine life upon earth. In the fourteenth stage the soul annuls all activities, but preserves omniscience and other characteristics. After this, disembodied liberation results (Videha Mukti). The self in these two Gunasthanas bears the title of 'Arhat' and after this, the title of 'Siddha.' This state of Siddha is beyond all Gunasthanas. It may be noted here that the self in these two Gunasthanas is called Paramatman. This perfected mystic is established in truth in all directions. 20 Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #28
He experiences bliss, which is supersensuous, unique, infinite, and interminable. He has transcended the dualities of friends and foes, pleasure and pain, praise and censure, life and death, sand and gold, attachment and aversion. The supreme mystical experience is ineffable and transcends all the similies of the world. It is a movement from darkness to light and slumberness to perfect spiritual awakening. 7. Composite Sadhana of Tri-ratna (Samyagdarsana, Samyagjnana and Samyakcaritra) leading to emancipation (Moksa)S7 Jainism regards Moksa (emancipation) as the highest objective of human life and for the attainment of which it has prescribed the composite Sadhana of Tri-ratna known as Samyagdarsana (spiritual awakening), Samyagjnana (value-knowledge) and Samyakcaritra (ethico-spiritual) conduct). Jainism regards spiritual awakening (Samyagdarsana) as the beginning of the spiritual pilgrimage, and it is the foundation of the magnificent edifice of liberations. Spiritual perversion acts as a barricade to soul's true life. So spiritual awakening is to be attained, which in turn will make knowledge and conduct conducive to the attainment of Moksa59. Even performing very severe austerities, persons devoid of spiritual awakening do not attain spiritual wisdom even in thousands and crores of years. Value knowledge is acquired through spiritual awakening. The spiritually awakened self considers his own self as his genuine abode and regards the outward dwelling places as artifical. He renounces all identification with the animate and inanimate objects of the world, and properly 'weighs them in the balance of his awakened spirit. Thus he develops a unique attitude towards himself and the world around him. The person having value knowledge becomes free from wordly attachment. Knowledge becomes the cause of spiritual unfoldment only after spiritual awakening is kindled and stirred up. As regards ethico-spiritual conduct (Samyakcaritra), Jainism recognizes that the person who is devoid of all attachments and who is engrossed in the self apprehends and experiences the self in its basic nature. He should devote his energies to meditation on the self, perform devotion to Arhat and Siddha and engage himself in Svadhyaya of ethico-spiritual literature along with the performance of other spiritual exercises. Before taking up these spiritual practices, he resorts to moral Indian Culture and Jainism 1 For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #29
discipline in the form of Anuvratas and Mahavratas. It may be noted here that Mahavira gave utmost importance to the practice of Dhyana, since it is directly related to the actualization of the divine potentialities. 8. According religious freedom to women and down-trodden people Mahavira gave complete religious freedom to women. They were allowed to accept the life of asceticism like men. Mahavira himself initiated Candana into the ascetic order. In the Samgha of Mahavira 36000 Sadhvis were following religious observances. We hear of large number of women in the history of Jainas who distinguished themselves as teachers and preachers. "The followers of Jaina religion have been divided into four categories, viz., Sadhus, Sadhvis, Sravakas and Sravikas. Sadhvis are female ascetics who follow the five great vows in a very strict manner. This shows that complete freedom was given to women to enter the ascetic order. Female sex was no bar to the practice of asceticism. The Jaina Acaryas were extremely sympathetic in their attitude to women and admitted them freely into their order, no matter whether the candidates for admission were royal consorts, members of the aristocracy, and women belonging to the common run of society." Religious freedom given to women enhanced their prestige in society. They were imparted education like men." The first Tirthankara, Rsabhadeva realised the utmost importance of imparting education to females and advised his two young daughters, Brahmi and Sundari that "only when you would adorn yourself with education, your life would be fruitful, because just as a learned man is held in high esteem by educated persons, a learned lady also occupies the highest position in the female world. Both the girls were first initiated to writing by their father and later on with the help of teachers they studied all branches of knowledge to such an extent that they could be regarded as incarnations of Sarasvati, the Goddess of Learning6." The greatest name among Jaina Women in Kannada Literature was Kanti who, along with Abhinava Pampa, was one of the gems that adorned the Court of Hoyasala King Ballala (A.D. 1100-1106). She was redoubtable orator and a poet who completed the unfinished poems of Abhinava Pampa in the open court of that ruler. Similarly, a Jaina lady Avvaiyara, the Venerable Matron, was one of the most admired amongst the Tamil poets62" Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #30
In times of need women did rise to the occasion and held important positions in the political sphere from the very beginning." In the first quarter of the 10th century A.D. figures a remarkable Jaina woman administrator, Jakkiyabbe, and it is stated that she was skilled in ability for good government, and protected the Nagarakhanda 70 (a name of a place). It is recorded that a Jaina lady Saviyabbe accompanied her husband on horse-back to the battle-field and fell fighting in the battle of Bagiyur63. "It appears from Epigraphia Carnatica that the office of Nadagauda, an important rural official, was held by a Jaina woman. An incription dated A.D. 918 shows that a Jaina widow was a Nadagauda and was distinguished for the skill and ability of her management. It states that though a woman, she well protected her charge with pride in her own heroic bravery. In the 16th century A.D. when the Jaina queen Bhairavadevi, while ruling over the kingdom of Gerosoppe, was attacked by the neighbouring Saiva Saradara, she faced the enemy bravely and defeated him in the battle64. " As the full religious freedom was allowed to females, widows could devote their time for their spiritual upliftment and thus carve a respectable position for them in their family and in the minds of people in general. Mahavira based the fourfold division of society on activities and not on birth. He accorded full freedom to one and all including women and down-trodden people to perform religious practices and admitted them into the order of ascetics65. Thus "the doors of Jainism were thrown open to all and equal opportunity was given to everybody to practise religion according to his capacity. Those who followed religion as house-holders were known as Sravakas and Sravikas and those who observed it fully by leaving their houses were called as Sadhus and Sadhvis"." The Uttaradhyayana says that Harikesa who was born in a family of untouchables attained saintly character owing to the performance of austerities. Good conduct and not caste is the object of reverence. Merit is the basis of caste and the pride of caste destroys right living67. It is significant to point out that Mahavira's social mind exhorted that Ahimsa consists in recognising the dignity of man irrespective of caste, colour and creed. Man is man and should be recognised as such without any hesitation. The dignity of man is sacred and it is our duty to honour Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only 23

Page #31
this dignity. Every individulal, whether man or woman, should enjoy religious freedom without any distinction. A non-violent society can not subscribe to class exploitation and social oppression of man. Mahavira bestowed social prestige upon the down-trodden individuals. This led to the development of self-respect in them. Thus he showed that no man or woman should be deprived of availing himself of the opportunities of socio-spiritual advancement. 9. Propounding the philosophy of vegetarianism, and the philosophy of fighting defensive wars The term Himsa may be defined as the committing of injury to the Dravya-Pranas and the Bhava-Pranas through the operation of intensepassion-infected Yoga (activity of mind, body, and speech). Suicide, homicide and killing of any other life whatsoever aptly sum up the nature of Himsa, inasmuch as these villainous actions are' rendered conceivable only when the Dravya-Pranas and the Bhava-Pranas pertaining to oneself and to others are injured. The minimum number of Dravya-Pranas has been considered to be four and the maximum has been known to be ten; and the Bhava-Pranas are the very attributes of Jiva. The amount of injury will thus be commensurate with the number of Pranas injured at a particular time and occasion68 . Himsa is of two kinds, namely, intentional and non-intentional. The intentional perpetrator of Himsa engages himself in the commitment of the acts of Himsa by his own mind, speech and action; provokes others to commit them; and endorses such acts of others. Besides, Himsa which is unavoidably committed by defending oneself from one's foes is denominated as non-intentional defensive Himsa. This leads us to the philosophy of fighting defensive wars69.. Now the householder is incapable of turning away completely from Himsa; hence he should keep himself away from the deliberate commission of Himsa of the two-sensed to five-sensed beings. The commitment of Himsa in adopting defensive contrivances, can not be counteracted by him. Thus he has to commit intentional injury to onesensed Jivas, namely, the vegetable-bodied, the air-bodied, the firebodied etc; and non-intentional injury in fighting defensive wars. Even in the realm of one-sensed Jivas and in the realm of fighting defensive 24 Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #32
wars he is required to confine his operations in such a way as may affect the life and existence of a very limited number of Jivas. In these two provinces the point to be noted is that of alleviating the amount of injury that is apt to be caused and not that of total relinquishment which is not possible without jeopardizing the survival of man. The hard fact to be noted is that man is subject to Himsa by the very condition of his existence. Yet instead of aggravating the natural weight of Himsa by falling foul upon one another and by our cruel treatment of the animal and vegatable kingdoms, we should endeavour to alleviate this general curse, to the extent to which we are capable of doing, by conforming ourselves to the sacred injunctions enjoined by Jaina spiritual teachers70. Vegetarianism is therefore prescribed. It limits us to the unavoidable injury caused to only one-sensed-Jivas. This is the philosophy of vegetarianism propounded by Jainism. 10. Accepting Sallekhana as the spiritual welcome to death withou any. fear and perturbation" Sallekhana implies the enervation of external body and internal passions in a legitimate way by the gradual removal of the causes of their nourishment, so that one may renounce the present body with a view to having a new bodily modification. Sallekhana is performed on the occasion when the time of natural death has been known in all probability. No doubt the body which is the medium of upliftment of the soul is to be properly nourished and cared for and the diseases are to be serously met with without any retreat. But if the body refuses to respond to our earnest endeavours, we should not falter to forsake it in the interest of saving the peace of mind. Thus if one is encountered with the termination of duration of the present life one should resort to the performance of the process of Sallekhana, which is not other than the spiritual welcome to death. This is not yielding to death, but a way of meeting the challenge of death undauntedly and adequately. "Self-restraint, study, austerities, worship, and chairty - all become useless if the mind is not pure at the last hour of life, just as the training of a king who has learnt the use of weapons for twelve years, becomes useless if he faints on the battlefield." The person performing Sallekhana should observe self-control, and than fix his mind in the Atman, when the vital forces depart from the body. The process of Sallekhana must needs be distinguished from Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only 25

Page #33
suicide. Sallekhana is undertaken only when the inevitability of death is a matter of undisputed certainty, while suicide may be committed at any time in the life under the spell of emotional disturbance or passionate attitude of mind. The person performing Sallekhana should make his earnest request to the members of his family and others around him to pardon him for the vicious deeds committed by him to affect them wittingly and unwittingly. He should also forgive them from the bottom of his heart for being troubled by them on certain occasions. Nourishment is to be renounced gradually, so that mental disturbance may be avoided. The persistence of equanimous mental state is the prime necessity. For this the person should devoted himself to meditation (Dhyana) and bid farwell to his body. It will not be out of place to mention that Acarya Vinoba Bhave adopted the method of Sallekhana in order to renounce the body with equanimity of mind. It is important to note that there are other factors contributed by Jainism for the enrichment of Indian culture. 1. Jaina Art 2. Jaina Literature 1. Jaina Art : At the outset, it may be noted that Jainism does not subscribe to the philosophy of 'Art for Art's sake'. Jaina Acaryas have always exhibited their concern for the ethico-spiritual development of man. In conformity with this view, art must give ethico-spiritual message to mankind. This means that for jainism art is purposive and the purpose is to inspire people to translate into action the ideals of life and living. Thus Jaina Art has been essentially religious with ethical predominance, but this did not obstruct the manifestation of aesthetic consciousness of an artist dedicated to the Jaina values of life. Jaina art expresses itself in diverse forms, important of which are caves, temples, pillars, towers and paintings. Jainas built cave dwellings for monks, so that they may get secluded places for their Sadhana. A large number of rock-cut caves has been indentified in the Udayagiri and Khandagiri Hills in Orissa (2nd Cent. B.C.) the picturesqueness of their forms, the character of their sculptures and architectural details combined with their great antiquity, render 26 Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #34
them one of the most important groups of caves in India72." The other caves are found at Junagadha in Gujarata (2nd Cent. B.C.), Rajagiri in Bihara (1st Cent. A.D.) Udayagiri in Madhyapradesa, (4th cent. A.D.), Candragiri at Sravanabelagola in Mysore, (4th. Cent. B.C.), at Ellora and at Usmanabada in Maharastra (5th Cent. A.D.) and Sittanavasala in Tamilnadu (3rd Cent. B.C.)73. "By far the most interesting cave-temples of the Jainas, from the artistic point of view, are, however, the Indrasabha and Jagannatha-sabha groups at Ellora. According to Percy Brown, "No other temple at Ellora is so complete in its arrangements or so finished in its workmanship as the upper storey of the Indrasabha74." It is of capital importance to note that since Jaina religion regards the construction of temples as an auspicious act, Jainas have constructed a large number of temples throughout India. The two temple complexes, known as the Delavada temples at Mt. Abu and built in the 11th and 12th centuries A.D., by the minister of the kings of Gujarata are regarded as the minor wonders of the world." Henry Cousens wrote, "The amount of beautiful ornamental detail spread over these temples in the minutely carved decoration of ceilings, pillars, doorways, panels and niches, is simply marvellous76," Again the Jaina temple at Ranakapura in Mevada (1440 A.D.) is the most complicated and extensive Jaina temple in India??." Fergusson remarks that "no two pillars in the whole building are exactly alike - the grace with which they are arranged, the tasteful admixture of domes of different heights with flat ceilings, and the mode in which the light is introduced, combine to produce an excellent effect78." The other temples of such superb character are the temples of : Parsvanatha at Khajaraho in Bundelakhanda (11 cent. A.D.), the temple at Lakkundi in Karnataka (12th cent. A.D.), The Jinanathapura temple near Sravanabelagola in Mysore (12th cent. A.D.) and Hosa Basti at Mudabidri in South Kanara (14th cent. A.D.79). Besides, the grouping together of temples into what may be called "Cities of temples" is a peculiarity which the Jainas have practised to a greater extent than the followers of any other religion in India80" "Such notable temple-cities are found, among other places, at Satrunjaya or Palitana and Giranara in Gujarata, at Sammeda Sikhara in Bihara, at Sonagiri in Bundelakhanda, at Muktagiri in Maharastra, at Kunthalgiri Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #35
in the Deccan, at Sravanabelagola in Mysore and at Mudabidri in South Kanara!" Another remarkable contribution of the Jainas to the whole of Indian art, is the free standing pillars found in front of almost every Jaina temple in South India82. There are more than twenty such pillars in the district of south Kanara alone. Nothing can surpass the stately grace of these beautiful pillars. During the past one hundred years numerous such pillars have been erected in different parts of the country83. The Jainas generally call these pillars Manastambhas84. Apart from pillars, a tower known as Kirtistambha in Cittoda, Rajasthana was constructed in 12th cent. A.D. and it was dedicated to Adinatha85. It may be noted here that "the most distinctive contribution of Jainism to art was in the realm of icon-making. Innumerable, Jaina images made of stone, metal inclduing gold, silver and bronze, wood, terracotta, and even precious stones, are available86." On the basis of the Hathigumpha inscription (2nd cent. B.C.) of Kharavela, the history of Jaina iconography takes us back at least to the 4th cent. B.C.: The Mathura School of Art speaks of the development of Jaina icons from the 1st cent. B.C., to 12th cent. A.D. Statues of Tirthankara were made by Jainas in good number. In the Mathura School "Adinatha or Rsabhanatha was shown with hair falling on his shoulders and Paravanatha had a snake canopy over his head and 22nd Tirthankara Neminatha was presented flanked by Balarama and Krsna87." The Image of Sarasvati is found at Mathura (132 A.D.). This is the earliest statue of Sarasvati known to us. Gradually it assumed many forms88. This shows that Sarasvati was worshipped in Jaina tradition. Undoubtedly the most remarkable of the Jaina statues is the statue of Bahubali situated at Sravanabelagola in Mysore (constructed in 983 A.D. by Camundaraya and it is 56'/, Ft. in Height) It is the largest free standing statue in Asia89. Painting on walls, palm-leaves and paper : The earliest example of wall paintings is found in Sittanavasala cave in Tamilnadu in the 7th. cent. A.D. In the 10th. and 11th cent. A.D. the temple of Tirumalai presents beautiful wall paintings%. After 11th cent. A.D. paintings on palm-leaves began. The palm-leaves paintings are found at Mudabidri in the South and at Patana (Gujarata) in the North". In London is preserved 28 Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #36
the Kalpasutra which is the earliest example of paper painting (1427 A.D.). Paintings on cloth and wood are preserved in Jaina Sastra Bhandaras of various places. It is of capital importance to note that Jainas have carefully maintained manuscript libraries throughout India. These libraries possess not only Jaina literature but preserve also the non-Jaina literary works. In Rajasthana, Madhyapradesa, Gujarata, Karnataka and Maharastra, a large number of manuscript libraries preserving vast and varied literature, both religious and secular have been maintained. Jaina Literature: According to Jainism a Tirthankara, along with self-realisation, propagates socio-spiritual values for the benefit of mankind. His deliverances form the canonical (Agamic) literature of the Jainas. Mahavira, the twenty-fourth Tirthankara preached in the language of the masses which was known as Prakrta. Thus the Jaina Agamas (canons) are in Prakrta. These Agamas form the 'Holy Scriptures of the Jainas'. These cover a wide variety of subjects. It is of capital importance to note that the Jaina Acaryas continued to compose works in Prakrta up to 13th cent. A.D. namely, the Agamic commentaries, the metaphysicospiritual works of Kundakunda, logical works of Siddhasena and Devasena, Tiloyapannati of Yativrsabha, Trilokasara of Nemicandra, Brhatsangrahani of Candrasuri, Vicarasara Prakarana of Pradyumnasuri, Bhagavati Aradhana of Sivarya, Mulacara of Vattakera, Pravacanasaroddhara of Nemicandra, Savayapannatti, Yogasataka and Dhurtakhyana of Haribhadra, Kattigeyanuvekkha of Svamikumara Paumacariya of Vimalasuri, Caupannamahapurisa-Cariya of Silankacarya etc 93 There are numerous Caritras in Prakrta which describe the life of individual Tirthankaras such as Rsabha, Santinatha, Neminatha, Parsva and Mahavira. Jainas own abundant narrative literature in Prakrta. Vasudeva-Hindi of Samghadasagani, Samaraicca-kaha of Haribhadra, Kuvalayamala of Uddyotanasuri and many Katha-kosas have been composed by the Jainas94. All this shows that Jainas have to their credit voluminous Prakrta literature, but unfortunately the study of Prakrta language has practically disappeared from India. What will be its consequence is a matter of great concern for the custodians of Indian culture. Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only 29

Page #37
Apart from the vast Prakrta literature Jaina authors adopted various languages such as Apabhramsa, Kannada and Tamil for their compositions. "The credit of inaugurating an Augustan age in the Apabhramsa, Tamil and Kannada literature unquestionably goes to the Jainas 95." Apabhramsa which enjoyed the credit of being the national language of Northern India for a very long time has been nourished by Jaina authors. From the 6th Cent. A.D. to 15th Cent. A.D. the cultivators of Apabhramsa language were Jainas". Svayambhu (8th Cent. A.D.) Puspadanta (10th Cent. A.D.), Dhanapala (10th Cent. A.D.), Vira (11th Cent. A.D.), Nayanandi (11th Cent. A.D.), Kanakamara (11th Cent. A.D.), Hemacandra (12th Cent. A.D.), Harideva (15th Cent. A.D.), Raidhu (15th cent A.D.) etc." are the immortal literary figures of India. Joindu, Muni Ramasimgha, Devasena etc. are the prominent ethicospiritual writers who have been recognised as the precursors of Kabir, Tulasi and other mystic poet-saints of India98. It will not be amiss to point out that the national language, Hindi owes a great deal to Apabhramsa. Hindi has inherited all its literary forms from Apabhramsa. The regional languages such as Sindhi, Punjabi, Marathi, Gujarati, Rajasthani, Bihari, Udiya, Bangali, Asami and the like have grown from the soil of Apabhramsa language and literature"9. As regards Jaina literature in Tamil, "it is not a mere accident that the best literature, known as the Sangama literature, of the ancient Tamil country was the creation of the Jaina scholars. "The two great works, Kural and Naladiyar are the compositions of Jaina authors 100. Of the five major Kavyas, the three, namely, Jivaka Cintamani, Silappadikaram and Valaiyapati are by Jaina writers. Jivaka Cintamani is the greatest existing Tamil literary monument102." Besides, all the five minor Kavyas were also composed by Jaina authors 103. Tolkappiyam, the earliest Tamil grammar, Nannul, the most popular grammar in Tamil language and the works on Tamil lexicography-all these were written by Jaina authors 104. We may conclude by saying that Jainism prevalied in the South from before the Sangama period (350. BC to 20 A.D.) of Tamil literary history. Regarding the Kannada language, we may say, "The Jainas have undoubtedly been the foremost cultivators of the Kannada language 30 For Personal & Private Use Only Indian Culture and Jainism

Page #38
from the inception of its literary history which is traced back to the 4th5th century A.D. By the end of the 10th century, they had made it a well established literary language's." Professor R. Narsimhachari observes, "The earliest cultivators of the language were Jainas. The oldest works of any extent and value that have come down to us are all from the pen of the Jainas106. Jaina authors in Kannada are far numerous than in Tamil. To name only a few, we have, Pampa, Ponna, Ranna, Gunavarma Nagacandra, Nayasena, Nagavarma, Aggala, Nemicandra, Janna and Madhura, authors whose works are admired as excellent specimens of poetic composition. "Besides Kavyas written by Jaina authors we have numerous works by them dealing with subjects such as grammar, medicine, veterinary science, cookery and so forth. Altogether the number of Jaina authors in Kannada is nearly two hundred 107." In addition to the Praksta, Apabhramsa, Kannada and Tamil literature Jainas started writing in Samskrta also as early as 1st cent. A.D. The Tattvarthasutra of Umasvati is the compendium of Jainism in Samskrta. Pujyapada (5th cent A.D.) Akalanka (8th cent. A.D.) Vidyanandi (9th cent A.D.) Siddhasenagani (8th cent A.D.) wrote commentaries on it. Works on Jaina logic have been written from 2nd cent to 15th Cent. A.D. Some of the great logicians are Siddhasena, Samantabhadra, Akalanka, Vidyanandi, Haribhadra, Manikyanandi, Hemacandra, Prabhacandra, Vadidevasuri, Mallisena, Vimaladasa and Yasovijaya. Samskrta literature has also been enriched by Jaina Puranas, Mahakavyas, devotional literature, grammar, Campukavyas and large number of ethico-spiritual works. Besides, Jaina scholars wrote treatises on politics, mathematics, lexicon. poetics, medicine, astronomy, geography and astrology. Jainas recognized the genius of Kalidasa, so much so that the Jaina writer Mallinatha wrote commentaries on the works of Kalidasa and thus paid homage to this great luminary of Samsksta literature09. In conclusion we may say that in the field of socio-spiritual values, logico-metaphysical pronouncements, diverse Indian languages and meanigful artistic, scientific and secular consciousness, Jainism has enormously contributed to Indian Culture. Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #39
Jo References 1. The Dawn of Indian Civilization upto 600 B.C. edited by Dr. G.C. Pande, Page 13. (PHISPC/Centre for Studies in Civilizations, Delhi, 1999). 2. Ibid. Page, 7. 3. Ibid. Page, 388. 4. Ibid. Page, 387. 5. Studies in the Origins of Buddhism by Dr. G.C. Pande, P 317. (Allahabad 1957). 6. Lord Mahavira and His Times, by Dr. Kailash Chand Jain, P. 9 (Motilal Banarsidasa, Delhi, 1991). 7. Ibid. P. 9. 8. Bharata and Bharata by Dr. Prem Sagar Jain, foreword by Dr. Munish Chandra Joshi, page (ii) (Jaina Vidya Samsthana, Sri Mahaviraji). 9. Lord Mahavira and His Times (LMHT) by Dr. Kailash Chand Jain, P. 11, (Motilal Banarsidasa, Delhi, 1991). 10. Religion and Culture of the Jains (RCJ) by Dr. Jyoti Prasad Jain, P. 12. (Bharatiya Jnapitha, Delhi 1975). 11. Ibid. P.11. 12. LMHT, P. 57. 13. Tirthankara Vardhamana Mahavira by Pandita Padama Chandra Sastri, P. 82. (Jaina Vidya Samsthana, Sri Mahaviraji, 1997). 14. Yuktyanusasana of Samantabhadhra 61 (Vira Seva Mandira, Delhi). 15. Acaranga Sutra, 132, Edited by Muni Jambuvijayaji (Sri Mahavira Jaina Vidyalaya, Bombay, 1976). 16. Ibid. 196. 17. Prasnavyakarana Sutra, 6,1,3, Pages 683, 684, Edited by Muni Nathmal under the title Angasuttani (3) (Jaina Vishva Bharati Ladnun, 1974). 18. Acaranga Sutra, 129. 19. Ibid. 49, 78. 20. Ibid. 22. 21. Pancastikaya, 112 to 117, (Srimad Rayacandra Asrama, Agasa, 1968). 22. Pancastikaya, 110. 23. Purusarthasiddhupaya 44 (Srimad Rayacandra Asrama, Agasa, 1986). 24. Prasnavyakarana Sutra, 6.1.3. Pages 683, 684. 25. Acaranga Sutra, 170. 26. Ethical Doctrines in Jainism (EDJ) by Dr. K.C. Sogani, Pages 86,87. (Jaina Samskrti Samrakasaka, Samgha Sholapur, 1967). 27. Pancastikaya, 10. 28. EDJ, Page 16. 29. Pravacanasara Introduction, P. LXVI (edited by Dr. A.N. Upadhye, (Srimad Rayacandra Asrama, Agasa). 30. Pancastikaya, 12. 31. Niyamasara, 14,15 (P. 133 - Sri Kundakunda Kahana Digambara Jaina Tirtha Suraksa Trust, Jaipur 1933). 32. Pancastikaya, Comm. Amrtacandra, 39. 33. Ibid. 38. 32 Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #40
34. Pravacanasara, Comm. Amrtacandra, II. 5. 35. Aptamimamsa, 34. (Muni-Anantakirti Granathmala, Bombay). 36. Saptabhangitarangini, P. 78 (Srimad Rajacandra Asrama, Agasa). 37. Tattvarthasutra, I. 6. (Under the title Sarvarthasiddhi, Bharatiya Jnana Pitha, Delhi). 38. Sarvarthasiddhi, I. 6. 39. Life, Thought and Culture in India Vol II (LTCI) edited by K. Satchidananda Murty, (300 A.D. to 1000 A.D.) P. 318. (PHISPC/Centre for Studies in Civilizations, 2002). 40. EDJ, Page, 36. 41. LTCI, Page 315. 42. Ibid. Pages, 316, 317. 43. Tattvarthasutra, VIII-4. 44. EDJ, Pages, 50, 51. 45. Pravacanasara, I. 14 (Rayacandra) 46. Dravyasamgraha, 50 (Sacred books of the Jainas Vol. I); Bhagavati Aradhana, 2144 (Digambara Jaina Granthamala, Sholapur). 47. Bhagavati Aradhana, 27.: 48. Moksa Pahuda, 5, 51 (Patani Digambara Jaina Granthamala Marotha, under the title, Asta Pahuda) 49. Acaranga Sutra, I. 4. 18 (Jaina Svetambara Terapanthi Mahasabha, Calcutta). 50. Sutrakstanga, I. 2. 1, I, (Sacred books of the East Vol. XLV). 51. Jnanarnava, XXIV, 3. (Rayacandra) 52. Yogadrstisamuccaya, 178 (L.D. Institute of Indology, Ahmedabad). 53. Purusarthasiddhupaya, 44 (Rayacandra) 54. Tattvarthasutra, I. 1. 55. Moksa Pahuda, 4. 7. 56. Jaina Mysticisam and other Esays by Dr. Kamal Chand Sogani, Pages 1 to 13 .. (Prakrta Bharati Academy, Jaipur). 57. Tattvarthasutra, 1. 1. 58. Yasastilaka and Indian Culture by Handiqui, P. 248 (Jivaraja Granthamala, Sholapur). 59. EDJ, Page, 61. 60. Jaina Community - A Social Survey (CSS) by Vilas A. Sangave, Pages, 169, 170 (Popular Prakasana, Bomaby, 1980). 61. Ibid. P. 172. 62. Ibid. P. 173. 63. Ibid. P. 177. 64. Ibid. P. 177. 65. Ibid. P. 65. 66. Ibid. P. 66. 67. EDJ, P. 273. 68. Ibid. P. 76. 69. Ibid. Pages, 77, 78. 70. Ibid. P. 78. 71. Ibid. Pages, 117, 188. 72. JCSS, P. 372. 73. Ibid. P. 372.. 74. RCJ, Pages, 140, 141. 75. Ibid. P. 143. 76. Ibid. P. 143. 77. JCSS, P. 371. 78. Ibid. 79. Ibid.' 80. Ibid. P. 372. 81. Ibid. P. 372. Indian Culture and Jainism 33 For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #41
82. Ibid. P. 372. 83. RCJ, P. 146. 84. Ibid. P. 146. 85. JCSS, P. 373. 86. RCJ, P. 135. 87. Life, Though and Culture in India, Vol. I edited by Dr. G.C. Pande, P. 1164. (PHISPC/Centre for Studies in Civilizations, Delhi). 88. Ibid. Pages, 1164, 1165. 89. JCSS, Page, 374. 90. RCJ, Page, 147. 91. Bhartiya Samskrti Ko Jaina Dharma Ka Yogadana (BSJDY) by Dr. Hiralal Jain, P. 365, (Madhyapradesa Sasana Parisad, Bhopal 1962). 92. Ibid. 370. 93. BSJDY, Pages, 72 to 134. 94. Ibid. Pages, 134 to 151.95. RCJ, Page, 151. 96. Apabhramsa; Eka Paricaya, (AEP) by Dr. Kamal Chand Sogani, P. 2. (Apabhramsa Sahitya Academy, Jaipur). 97. Ibid. Pages, 8 to 21. 98. RCJ, Page, 156. 99. AEP, Page, 44. 100. Jaina Literature in Tamil by A. Chakravarti, P. 28. (Bhartiya Jnana Pitha, Delhi, 1974). 101. Ibid. Page, 48. 102. Ibid. Page, 63. 103. Ibid. Page, 83. 104. Ibid. Pages, 19, 129, 130, 131. . 105. RCJ, Page, 157. 106. Ibid. Page, 157. 107. Ibid. Page, 157. 108. Ibid. Pages, 85 to 99. 109. RCJ, Page, 165. Residence H-7, Chitranjan Marg C-Scheme Jaipur-302 001 Phone : (0141) 2376415 Office Jaina Vidya Samsthana Digambara Jaina Nasiyam Bhattarakji Savai Rama Simgha Road Jaipur-302 004 Phone : (0141) 2382847 Indian Culture and Jainism For Personal & Private Use Only

Page #42